Across Grade Coherence and Instructional Practice in ...€¦ · • Identify and reframe deficit thinking and speaking. ACROSS GRADE COHERENCE IN GRADES 6–8 ... function represented

February2019

AcrossGradeCoherenceandInstructionalPracticeinGrades6–8

1

ACROSSGRADECOHERENCEINGRADES6–8

WelcomeBack!

2


ThankYouforYourFeedback!

+ ∆

3

• Takeresponsibilityforyourselfasalearner.

• Honortimeframes(start,end,andactivity).

• Beanactiveandhands-onlearner.

• Usetechnologytoenhancelearning.

• Striveforequityofvoice.

• Contributetoalearningenvironmentinwhichitis“safetonotknow.”

• Identifyandreframedeficitthinkingandspeaking.


NormsThatSupportOurLearning

4


ThisWeekDay Ideas

Monday FocusandWithinGradeCoherence

Tuesday Rigorandthe MathematicalPractices

Wednesday Across Grade CoherenceandInstructionalPractice

Thursday Adaptation andCurriculumStudy

Friday AdaptationandPractice

“Dothemath”

Connecttoourpractice

5

Equityforall


Today

• Morning:AcrossGradeCoherenceinGrades6–8

• Afternoon: InstructionalPracticeinGrades6–8

6


MorningObjectives• Participantswillunderstandandapplylearningprogressionstosupportstudentswhoarebelowgradelevel.

o Participantswillbeabletoidentifyasequenceofprerequisitestandardsnecessaryinmathunderstandingandlearning.

o Participantswillbeabletoidentifyonrampsforteachingmajorworktostudentswithunfinishedlearning.

o Participantswillbeabletoadaptalessonforstudentswithunfinishedlearningbyaddingjust-in-timescaffoldsbasedonlearningprogressions.

o ParticipantswillbeabletoexplainhowattendingtotheshiftofacrossgradecoherenceisanequitablepracticeinStandards-alignedmathinstruction.

7


MorningAgenda

I. AcrossGradeCoherence

II. VerticalCoherenceChallenge

III. MappingtheProgressions

IV. ToolsforUnderstandingtheProgressions

V. AdaptingLessonsforStudentswithUnfinishedLearning

8


UnpackingEquity

9

Equityexistswhenthebiasesderivedfromdominantculturalnormsandvaluesnolongerpredictorinfluencehowonefaresinsociety.

Equitysystematicallypromotesfairandimpartialaccesstorightsandopportunities.

Equitymaylooklikeaddingsupportsandscaffoldsthatresultinfairaccesstoopportunitiesorcreatingopportunitiesforallvoicestobeheard.

Educational Equityensuresthatallchildren—regardlessofcircumstances—arereceivinghigh-quality,grade-level,andstandards-alignedinstructionwithaccesstohigh-qualitymaterialsandresources.

Webecomechangeagentsforeducationalequitywhenweacknowledgethatwearepartofaneducationalsystemthatholdspoliciesandpracticesthatareinherentlyracistandthatwehaveparticipatedinthissystem.Wenowcommittoensuringthatallstudents,regardlessofhowwethinktheycometous,leaveushavinggrownagainstgrade-levelstandardsandconfidentintheirvalueandabilities.


I.AcrossGradeCoherence

10

Lenapaid$18.96for3poundsofcoffee.

Whatwouldstudentsneedtounderstandaboutproportionalrelationshipstographtherelationshipbetweenthenumberofpoundsofcoffeeandthetotalcost?

Grade6Useratioandratereasoningtosolvereal-worldandmathematicalproblems…bymakingtablesofequivalentratios,findingmissingvaluesintables,andplottingthepairsofvaluesonthecoordinateplane.

Grade8Graphproportionalrelationships,interpretingtheunitrateastheslopeofthegraph;comparedifferentproportionalrelationshipsindifferentways.

Grade7Explainwhatapoint(x,y)onthegraphofaproportionalrelationshipmeansintermsofthesituation,withspecialattentiontothepoints(0,0)and(1,r)wherer istheunitrate.


WhatIstheRightOrder?

11

“A focused, coherent progression of mathematics learning, with anemphasis on proficiency with key topics, should become the norm inelementary and middle school mathematics curricula. Any approach thatcontinually revisits topics year after year without closure is to be avoided. Bythe term focused, the Panel means that curriculum must include (and engagewith adequate depth) the most important topics underlying success in schoolalgebra. By the term coherent, the Panel means that the curriculum ismarked by effective, logical progressions from earlier, less sophisticatedtopics into later, more sophisticated ones. Improvements like thosesuggested in this report promise immediate positive results with minimaladditional cost.”

–NationalMathematicsAdvisoryPanel


CoherenceIsKey

12


TheProgressions

13

AcrossGradeCoherence:Learningiscarefullyconnectedacrossgradessothatstudentscanbuildnewunderstandingontofoundationsbuiltinpreviousyears.

• Inyourgroups,youhave13standardsonpiecesofpaper.MoststandardscomefromtheRatios&ProportionalRelationshipsdomaininGrades6–8.

• Thestandardsarenotlabeled!

• Determinewhichstandardsareprerequisitesforotherstandards.

• Note: Thereismorethanoneverticalstrand.

• Bonus: Canyoudeterminewhichstandardsbelonginwhichgrade?


II.VerticalCoherenceChallenge

15

Grades4and5

Grade6 Grade7 Grade8 HighSchool

J4.MD.2

B5.NF.3

G5.G.2

F6.RP.2

L6.RP.3a

D7.RP.1

K7.RP.2

M7.RP.3

H7.G.1

C8.F.2

A8.EE.6

I8.EE.8

EF-BF.1


APictureofCoherence

16


ProgressionsofContent

17

Howdoesunderstandingtheprogressionofcontentsupportourunderstandingofgrade-levelcontent?

Protocol:

• Identifythreeprerequisitestandards—thestandardsdonothavetobeinthreedifferentgrades.

• Identifytheaspectsofrigorforeachprerequisite.

• Discusswithapartner:1. Howdoeseachprerequisite

supportthestandard?2. Whyisitimportanttopay

attentiontotherigoroftheprerequisitestandard?


III.StandardsMapping

18

TheStandards:Grade6– 6.EE.B.7Grade7– 7.NS.A.2Grade8– 8.F.A.2

Solvereal-worldandmathematicalproblemsbywritingandsolvingequationsoftheformx +p =q andpx =q forcasesinwhichp,q,andx areallnonnegative rationalnumbers.


Grade6—6.EE.B.7

19

5.NF.B.4Applyandextendpreviousunderstandingsofmultiplicationtomultiplya fraction orwholenumber byafraction.

6.EE.B.5Understandsolvinganequationorinequalityasaprocessofansweringaquestion:whichvaluesfromaspecifiedset,ifany,maketheequationorinequalitytrue?Usesubstitutiontodeterminewhetheragivennumberinaspecifiedsetmakesanequationorinequalitytrue.

6.NS.A.1Interpretandcomputequotientsof fractions,andsolvewordproblemsinvolvingdivisionoffractionsbyfractions,e.g.,byusing visualfractionmodels andequationstorepresenttheproblem.

Applyandextendpreviousunderstandingsofmultiplicationanddivisionandoffractions tomultiplyanddivide rationalnumbers.


Grade7—7.NS.A.2

20

6.NS.A.1Interpretandcomputequotientsof fractions,andsolvewordproblemsinvolvingdivisionoffractionsbyfractions,e.g.,byusing visualfractionmodels andequationstorepresenttheproblem.

5.NF.B.3Interpreta fraction asdivisionofthenumeratorbythedenominator(a/b=a÷ b).Solvewordproblemsinvolvingdivisionof wholenumbers leadingtoanswersintheformoffractionsormixednumbers,e.g.,byusing visualfractionmodels orequationstorepresenttheproblem.

5.NF.B.4Applyandextendpreviousunderstandingsofmultiplicationtomultiplya fraction orwholenumber byafraction.

Comparepropertiesoftwofunctionseachrepresentedinadifferentway(algebraically,graphically,numericallyintables,orbyverbaldescriptions).Forexample,givenalinearfunctionrepresentedbyatableofvaluesandalinearfunctionrepresentedbyanalgebraicexpression,determinewhichfunctionhasthegreaterrateofchange.


Grade8—8.F.A.2

21

7.RP.A.2Recognizeandrepresentproportionalrelationshipsbetweenquantities.

8.F.A.1Understandthatafunctionisarulethatassignstoeachinputexactlyoneoutput.Thegraphofafunctionisthesetoforderedpairsconsistingofaninputandthecorrespondingoutput.

8.EE.B.5Graphproportionalrelationships,interpretingtheunitrateastheslopeofthegraph.Comparetwodifferentproportionalrelationshipsrepresentedindifferentways.Forexample,compareadistance-timegraphtoadistance-timeequationtodeterminewhichoftwomovingobjectshasgreaterspeed.

Break


IV.UnderstandingtheProgressions

23

TheProgressionsDocuments

WiringDiagram

ContentGuides


UnderstandingtheProgressions

24

Howdoesunderstandingtheprogressionssupportinstruction?

25

ACROSSGRADECOHERENCEINGRADESK-2

LeveragingtheProgressions

25

Howcanweleverageprogressionsofcontenttogiveall studentsaccesstograde-levelcontent?


V.AdaptingLessonsforStudentswithUnfinishedLearning

26

Protocol:• Review Lesson1andidentify thetargetedstandard.• Identify theprerequisitestandardsfrompriorgradesthatsupportthetargetedstandard.

o Whatistheaspectofrigorforeachprerequisite?• Discuss withapartner:

1. Howdoeseachprerequisitesupportthestandard?2. Howcouldyoustrategicallyusetheseprerequisitestandardsto

supportstudentswhoarenotongradelevel?o Annotate thelessonwithspecificsupports.

• Withyourtable:o Eachpairsharesoutthespecificadaptationsyouandyour

partnermade. Explainwhyyoumadetheseadaptations.


LessonAdaptations

27

Whattypesofadaptationscouldyouconsideratthelessonlevel?

• Addawarm-upactivitythatconnectstopriorlearning.

• Addasectiontothelessonportiontoaddressprerequisiteskills.

• Adjusttheexamplesand/orproblemsettofocusonprerequisiteskills.

Protocol: time• 10min:Individualworktime• 15min:Partnerwork• 10min:Tableshareout


AdaptingLessonsforStudentswithUnfinishedLearning

28

GoalsforThisActivity:I. ReviewLesson1andidentify

thetargetedstandard(s).II. Whataretheprerequisite

standardsfrompriorgradesthatsupportthisstandard(s)?

III. Whataspectsofrigorarehighlightedintheprerequisitestandards?



29

Protocol:• ReviewLesson1andidentifythetargetedstandard.• Identifytheprerequisitestandardsfrompriorgradesthatsupportthetargetedstandard.

o Whatistheaspectofrigorforeachprerequisite?• Discuss withapartner:


supportstudentswithunfinishedlearning?o Annotatethelessonwithspecificsupports.


partnermade.Explainwhyyoumadetheseadaptations.

TransitiontoPartnerTime!30



31


GoalsforThisActivity:I. Howdotheseprerequisite

standardssupportthegrade-levelstandard(s)?

II. Howcouldyoustrategicallyusetheseprerequisitestandardstosupportstudentswithunfinishedlearning?

o Annotatethelessonwithspecificsupports.



32


o Whatistheaspectofrigorforeachprerequisite?• Discusswithapartner:




partnermade. Explainwhyyoumadetheseadaptations.

TransitiontoTableShare!

33



34


GoalsforThisActivity:o Eachpairsharesoutthespecific

adaptationsmadeandexplainswhytheseadaptationsweremade.



35


o Whatistheaspectofrigorforeachprerequisite?• Discusswithapartner:




partnermade.Explainwhyyoumadetheseadaptations.



36

Whatgrade-levelstandarddoesthelessonaddress?Whatistheevidence ofalignmenttothisstandard?

What aretheprerequisitestandardsfrompriorgradesthatsupportthisstandard?

Brainstorm waysyoucouldusetheseprerequisitestosupportstudentswithunfinishedlearninginaccessingthecontentofthislesson.• Annotatethelessonwithspecific

supports.

37


Summary

• Whatistheshiftofcoherence?

• Howdoescoherencehelpussupportstudentswithunfinishedlearning?

• Howdoesrigorhelpussupportstudentswithunfinishedlearning?

• Howdoesthislearningapplytoyourspecificrole?

3838

ACROSSGRADECOHERENCEINGRADESK-2

Lunch12:00-1:00

38

Lunch12:00–1:00

INSTRUCTIONALPRACTICEINGRADES6–8

Today

• Morning:AcrossGradeCoherenceinGrades6–8

• Afternoon: InstructionalPracticeinGrades6–8

39


AfternoonObjectives• ParticipantswillbeabletousetheInstructionalPracticeGuide(IPG)asalessonplanningtoolandacoachingtool.

• Participantswillbeabletoidentifywhere,inlessonsandvideos,teachersengageinCoreActions.

• ParticipantswillbeabletoexplaintherelationshipbetweenCoreActionsandequitableinstructioninStandards-alignedmathinstruction.

40

I. IntrototheInstructionalPracticeGuide(IPG)

II. CoreActionsinAction!

III. LessonPlanningwiththeIPG

IV. ConnecttoPractice


AfternoonAgenda

41

INSTRUCTIONALPRACTICEINGRADESK-2

InstructionalPractice...effectiveteachingisthenon-negotiablecorethatensuresthatallstudentslearnmathematicsathighlevels...

–PrinciplestoActions:EnsuringMathematicalSuccessforAll(NCTM)

42


I.InstructionalPracticeGuide(IPG)

TheInstructionalPracticeGuideincludescoaching andlessonplanning toolstohelpteachersandthosewhosupportteacherstomaketheKeyShiftsininstructionalpracticerequiredbytheStateStandards.

43


CoreActions

1. EnsuretheworkoftheenactedlessonreflectstheFocus,Coherence,andRigorrequiredbycollege- andcareer-readystandardsinmathematics.

2. Employinstructionalpracticesthatallowallstudentstolearnthecontentofthelesson.

3. Provideallstudentswithopportunitiestoexhibitmathematicalpracticeswhileengagingwiththecontentofthelesson.

44


CoreAction1

IndicatorsA. Theenactedlessonfocusesonthegrade-levelcluster(s),grade-levelcontent

standard(s),orpart(s)thereof.Mathematicallearninggoal:Standard(s)addressedinthislesson:

B. Theenactedlessonappropriatelyrelatesnewcontenttomathcontentwithinoracrossgrades.

C. Theenactedlessonintentionallytargetstheaspect(s)ofRigor(conceptualunderstanding,proceduralskillandfluency,application)calledforbythestandard(s)beingaddressed.

Circletheaspect(s)ofRigortargetedinthestandard(s)addressedinthislesson:Conceptualunderstanding/Proceduralskillandfluency/ApplicationCircletheaspect(s)ofRigortargetedinthislesson:Conceptualunderstanding/Proceduralskillandfluency/Application

EnsuretheworkoftheenactedlessonreflectstheFocus,Coherence,andRigorrequiredbycollege- andcareer-readystandardsinmathematics.

45


CoreAction2Employinstructionalpracticesthatallowallstudentstolearnthecontentofthelesson.

IndicatorsA. Theteachermakesthemathematicsofthelessonexplicitthroughthe

useofexplanations,representations,tasks,and/orexamples.B. Theteacherstrengthensallstudents’understandingofthecontentby

strategicallysharingstudents’representationsand/orsolutionmethods.

C. Theteacherdeliberatelychecksforunderstandingthroughoutthelessontosurfacemisconceptionsandopportunitiesforgrowth,andadaptsthelessonaccordingtostudentunderstanding.

D. Theteacherfacilitatesthesummaryofthemathematicswithreferencestostudentworkanddiscussioninordertoreinforcethepurposeofthelesson.

46


CoreAction3

IndicatorsA. Theteacherprovidesopportunitiesforallstudentstoworkwithandpracticegrade-level

problemsandexercises.Students workwithandpracticegrade-levelproblemsandexercises.

B. Theteachercultivatesreasoningandproblemsolvingbyallowingstudentstoproductivelystruggle.Students persevereinsolvingproblemsinthefaceofdifficulty.

C. Theteacherposesquestionsandproblemsthatpromptstudentstoexplaintheirthinkingaboutthecontentofthelesson.Students sharetheirthinkingaboutthecontentofthelessonbeyondjuststatinganswers.

D. Theteachercreatestheconditionsforstudentconversationswherestudentsareencouragedtotalkabouteachother’sthinking.Students talkandaskquestionsabouteachother’sthinking,inordertoclarifyorimprovetheirownmathematicalunderstanding.

E. Theteacherconnectsanddevelopsstudents’informallanguageandmathematicalideastoprecisemathematicallanguageandideas.Students useincreasinglyprecisemathematicallanguageandideas.

Provideallstudentswithopportunitiestoexhibitmathematicalpracticeswhileengagingwiththecontentofthelesson.

47


DeeperDivewiththeIPG

48

SmallGroupProtocol

• ReadtheindicatorsoftheCoreActionforyourgroup.

• Discussthefollowingwithyoursmallgroup:1. HowdoesthisCoreAction(includingthe

indicators)supportteachersandcoachesinbuildingunderstandingofStandards-alignedinstruction?

2. Whataretheessentialteacherpracticesthatsupporttheindicators?

3. HowdoesthisCoreActionsupportequitableinstructionforall students?



49

TableDiscussionProtocol

• Turnandteach.• Discussthefollowingwithyourtablegroup:

1. HowdoesthistoolsupportteachersandcoachesinbuildingunderstandingofStandards-alignedinstruction?

2. WhatareessentialteacherpracticesthatsupporteachCoreAction?

3. WheredoeseachoftheStandardsforMathematicalPracticeshowupintheIPG?

4. HowdoesthisCoreActionsupportequitableinstructionforall students?



50

WholeGroupDiscussionProtocol

1. HowdoesthistoolsupportteachersandcoachesinbuildingunderstandingofStandards-alignedinstruction?

2. WheredoeseachoftheStandardsforMathematicalPracticeshowupintheIPG?

3. WhatconnectionsdidyoumakebetweentheCoreActionsandequitableinstructionforall students?

• Usefulinbothplanningandcoaching.

• Evidencefortheindicatorscancomefromlessonmaterials,teacheractions,studentdiscussion,andstudentwork.

• Whenusingasacoachingtool,notallindicatorsmaybeevidentinasingleclassperiod.

• Not tobeusedasanevaluationinstrument.


IPGSummary

51

WhatCoreActionsarevisible?


II.CoreActionsinAction!

52

Break


III.LessonPlanningwiththeIPG

54

HowcanweusetheCoreActionsandindicators?• Planning• Evaluating• Reflecting


LessonPlanningTheCoreActionsshouldbeevidentinplanningandobservableininstruction.

• Whatpartsofthelessonplanarevital toshowevidenceofCoreAction1?Annotatethelessontoshowthese.

• WhataresomeofthethingsyoucoulddotoensurealignmentwiththeindicatorsforCoreActions2and3?

WhattoReview:Grade6,Module1,Lesson2Grade7,Module1,Lesson2Grade8,Module5,Lesson2

55


Example:Grade7,Module1,Lesson1

56


LessonPlanning

57

Protocol: time• 15min:Individualworktime• 10min:Smallgroupcollaboration• 15min:Tableshareout

GoalsforThisActivity:1. Readthelesson.2. AnnotatethelessonforyourCore

Action.• Whatpartsofthelessonplanare

vital toshowevidenceofCoreAction1?

• WhataresomeofthethingsyoucoulddotoensurealignmentwiththeindicatorsforCoreActions2and3?

TransitiontoSmallGroupTime!58


LessonPlanning

59


GoalsforThisActivity:1. Sharehowyouannotatedthetask

withyourgroup.

TransitiontoTableShare!

60


LessonPlanning

61


Goalsforthisactivity:1. Shareyourannotationswiththe

peopleatyourtable.2. Discussandrecord:

• WhatkindsofevidencesupportedtheindicatorsforCA1?

• WhatkindsofactionsdidyouaddtosupportCA2?

• WhatkindsofactionsdidyouaddtosupportCA3?

62


IV.LessonPlanning

63

Protocol:

AnnotateyourlessonforeachCoreAction:1. WhatistheevidenceofalignmenttoCoreAction1?Howcanyou

improvealignmenttoCoreAction1?2. Whataresomeofthethingsyoucoulddotoensurealignment

withtheindicatorsforCoreAction2?3. Whataresomeofthethingsyoucoulddotoensurealignment

withtheindicatorsforCoreAction3?


Summary

64

• HowwilltheCoreActionsimpactyourworkwith creatingand/orcoachingaroundlessonplans,andensuringequitableinstructionforallstudents?

• Howhasyourthinkingchangedaboutlessonplanning?

• HowhavetheShiftsimpactedyourapproachtoinstruction?


HomeworkTopreparefortheworkwewilldotomorrowandFriday:• Read UnderstandingLanguage- PrinciplesfortheDesignofMathematicsCurricula:PromotingLanguageandContentDevelopment.– LocatedinmaterialsforThursday,ontheStandardsInstituteswebsite:standardsinstitutes.org

• Thinkaboutapossibleproblemofpracticethatyouarestrugglingwithrelatedtothecontentwehavecoveredthisweek,thatyouwouldwanttoproblemsolveonFriday.Share thisproblemofpracticewithmetodaybeforeyouleave.– TheProblemofPracticeQ&AwilltakeplaceFridayafternoon.

65

FeedbackPleasefilloutthesurveylocatedhere:www.standardsinstitutes.org.

• Click“Winter2019”onthetopofthepage.• Click“Details”onthecenterofthepage.

66

• Copyright©2019UnboundEd Learning,Inc.• ThisworkislicensedunderaCreativeCommonsAttributionNonCommercial ShareAlike 4.0InternationalLicense.• UnboundEd Learning,Inc.isthecopyrightholderoftheimagesandcontent,exceptwhereotherwiseindicatedintheslidenotes.•MoreinformationonCreativeCommons’licensescanbefoundhere: https://creativecommons.org/licenses/.

AboutThisDeck

67

HowYouCanUseThisDeckThematerialsthatwecreate,unlessotherwisecitedintheslidenotes,arelicensedunderthe CreativeCommonsAttribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0Internationallicense (CC BY-NC-SA4.0). Thismeansyoumay:• Share—copyandredistributethematerialinanymediumorformat• Adapt—remix,transform,andbuilduponthematerial

Aslongasyoufollowthelicenseterms:• ProvideAttribution—Youmustgiveappropriatecredit,providealinktothelicense,andindicateifchangesweremade.Youmaydosoinanyreasonablemanner,butnotinanywaythatsuggeststhatUnboundEd oranythirdpartycreatorendorsesyouoryouruse.

• NoCommercialUse—Youmaynotusethematerialforcommercialpurposes.• ShareAlike—Ifyouremix,transform,orbuilduponthematerial,youmustdistributeyourcontributionsunderthesamelicenseastheoriginal.

• NoAdditionalRestrictions—Youmaynotapplylegaltermsortechnologicalmeasuresthatlegallyrestrictothersfromdoinganythingthelicensepermits.

68