Click here to load reader
Upload
ariel-radovan
View
220
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
7/28/2019 ACLU Sues NSA Surv Program
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/aclu-sues-nsa-surv-program 1/3
Back to previous page
ACLU sues over NSAsurveillance program
By Ellen Nakashima and Scott Wilson, Published: June 12
The American Civil Liberties Union filed a lawsuit
Tuesday challenging the constitutionality of the U.S.
government surveillance program that collects the
telephone records of millions of Americans from
U.S. telecommunications companies.
It is the first substantive lawsuit following reports in The Washington Post and the Guardian last week
that detailed two vast surveillance programs run by the National Security Agency under laws
authorized by Congress after the attacks of Sept. 11, 2001.
The ACLU suit, filed in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York, challenges the
legality of the spy agency’s collection of customer “metadata,” including the phone numbers dialed
and the length of calls. The lawsuit asks the court to force the government to end the program and
purge any records it has collected, and to declare that the surveillance is unconstitutional.
The program, details of which were first disclosed by the Guardian, collects such information, used by
intelligence analysts to detect patterns and personal connections, on every phone call made or
received by U.S. customers of major American phone companies. The once-secret program was
acknowledged last week by Director of National Intelligence James R. Clapper Jr., who is named in
the ACLU lawsuit.
The disclosures of the NSA’s operations have generated concern across party lines, illustrated Tuesday
by sharp criticism and new requests on Capitol Hill from members of President Obama’s party.
Sen. Dianne Feinstein (D-Calif.) said Tuesday that the Senate Intelligence Committee, which she
chairs, has asked the NSA’s director to declassify some information to better explain the programs.
Senior intelligence and Justice Department officials also briefed House lawmakers late Tuesday on the
NSA’s phone-tracking program, according to lawmakers who attended.
The debate surrounding the surveillance has revived an unresolved question of post-Sept. 11
American life — how much privacy should be sacrificed to enhance security. It has also brought new
scrutiny on Obama’s promise to better strike that balance after what he has called the national security
excesses of the George W. Bush administration.
ACLU sues over NSA surveillance program - The Washington Post http://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/aclu-sues-over-nsa-
of 3 6/15/13 7:46
7/28/2019 ACLU Sues NSA Surv Program
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/aclu-sues-nsa-surv-program 2/3
Early Tuesday, Sen. Ron Wyden (D-Ore.), a member of the Intelligence Committee, accused Clapper
of failing to give a “straight answer” about the scope of the NSA’s surveillance programs during a
committee hearing in March.
During that open hearing, Wyden, a longtime critic of the administration’s surveillance policy, asked
Clapper whether the NSA collects “any type of data at all on millions or hundreds of millions of
Americans.” Clapper responded, “No, sir.”
But the recent disclosures of the NSA surveillance initiatives, which the Obama administration says
are separately authorized under the Patriot Act and the Foreign Intelligence Surveillance Act (FISA),
has focused attention on the truthfulness of Clapper’s response.
In addition to the phone-
records collection, The Post reported on a surveillance program known as PRISM, which allows the
government to collect video, photos, e-mails, documents and connection logs for the users of nine
leading Internet companies. The government obtained the data through orders approved by the secret
court established by FISA.
In an interview with NBC News over the weekend, Clapper, who complained at the start of his Marchappearance on the Hill that “an open hearing on intelligence matters is a contradiction in terms,” said
that his answer to Wyden was the “least untruthful” he could provide given the secret nature of the
program.
Asked Tuesday whether Obama believes the national intelligence director had been truthful in his
testimony, White House press secretary Jay Carney said, “He certainly believes that Director Clapper
has been straight and direct in the answers that he’s given and has actively engaged in an effort to
provide more information about the programs that have been revealed through the leak of classified
information.”
Wyden was one of eight senators, including two Republicans, who proposed legislation Tuesday thatwould force the government to declassify “significant” rulings of the Foreign Intelligence
Surveillance Court, a secret panel that rules on NSA requests.
The ACLU lawsuit will bring the phone-data collection program into federal court, setting up
a challenge for Obama, who pledged during his 2008 presidential campaign to bring more
transparency to national security policy.
According to a classified court order to Verizon Business Network Services, published by the
Guardian, the NSA directed the company to turn over “all call detail records” of customers under
Section 215 of the Patriot Act.
Clapper said last week that the NSA does not receive phone call content or a subscriber’s identity
under the program. He also said that before the data can be searched, the NSA must have a
“reasonable suspicion, based on specific facts, that the particular basis for the query is associated with
a foreign terrorist organization.”
The ACLU challenged that modest characterization, saying in its lawsuit that the program’s scope is
“akin to snatching every American’s address book — with annotations detailing whom we spoke to,
when we talked, for how long and from where.”
ACLU sues over NSA surveillance program - The Washington Post http://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/aclu-sues-over-nsa-
of 3 6/15/13 7:46
7/28/2019 ACLU Sues NSA Surv Program
http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/aclu-sues-nsa-surv-program 3/3
“It gives the government a comprehensive record of our associations and public movements, revealing
a wealth of detail about our familial, professional, religious and intimate association,” the lawsuit
states.
The ACLU asserts that it has standing to sue the government over the program because it is a Verizon
customer, overcoming a hurdle that has blocked previous attempts to challenge secret programs.
The organization also contends that the NSA’s surveillance will have a “chilling effect” onwhistleblowers who would otherwise contact the group for help.
Carney defended the administration’s treatment of whistleblowers, saying “there are established
procedures that whistleblowers can employ that also protect, or rather ensure protection of national
security interests.”
The collection program, officials said, began in 2006 under Section 215 of the Patriot Act.
Feinstein said Tuesday that she asked Gen. Keith B. Alexander, who leads the NSA and U.S. Cyber
Command, to declassify some program information “so that we can talk about them, because I think
they’re really helpful.”
Feinstein noted that she has already publicly discussed two incidents in which, she said, the NSA
programs helped stop attacks in 2009 in New York and Mumbai.
“But there are other things that are also classified that would be helpful since this has all exploded for
the American public to know,” she said. “If we can get that declassified, we can speak much more
clearly.”
Ed O’Keefe contributed to this report.
Sponsored LinksTop 3 Stocks for 2013
3 Stock Opportunities That Are Poised To Explode.
www.TheStockReport.com
Refinance Now 2.88% FIXED
No points & virtually zero costs! Free quote in minutes. (2.88%APR)
Fetcharate.com
U.S. Stock Selections
Get in on the Ground Floor of Breakthrough Technologies.
www.gfiz.com
Buy a link here
© The Washington Post Company
ACLU sues over NSA surveillance program - The Washington Post http://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/aclu-sues-over-nsa-
of 3 6/15/13 7:46