Abel - Violent Affect - Literature, Cinema, And Critique After Representation

7/28/2019 Abel - Violent Affect - Literature, Cinema, And Critique After Representation

1/313


2/313

Violent Affect


3/313


4/313

UniversityofNebraskaPressLincolnandLondon


5/313

C

J I N E: Aff

C V Aerin Psyho,

Aneki . (): . A &

F , ://.../j.

C D

DL I R F: L,

I, R Seein /, -

pmla . (): .

B R U

N

A M U S A

L C C--P D

A, M.

V ff : , , q

/ M A.

. .I (. ) .

isbn-: ---- (. )

isbn-: ---x (. )

. A fi H

. . V . . V

. I..

ps.va

'.

S C P B Rz.

D A J.


6/313

F M R A

I M L ()


7/313


8/313

P

A

. Te Violence of Sensation

Miers Crossin, Aff, M

. Judgment Is Not an Exit

R, Aff, Aerin Psyho

. Are We All Arnoldians?

A C G J

. Serializing Violence

P H E P V

. Becoming-Violent, Becoming-DeNiro

R V V S

. Don DeLillos In the Ruins of the Future

V, P, R S /

N

B

I


9/313


10/313

Te vioene of senstion is oosed to the vioene of the rere-

sented (the senstion, the ih). Te forer is inserbe fro

its diret tion on the nervous syste, the eves throuh whih

it sses, the doins it trverses: bein itsef Fiure, it ust

hve nothin of the nture of the reresented obet. [Vioene] is

not wht one beieves it to be, nd deends ess nd ess on wht is

reresented.G Dz, Frnis Bon

I nt he but dre bout kind of ritiis tht woud not try

to ude.

M F, T M P

A j , , -. M , ( ) fi - ( ?). D - , fi, I - - j ,


11/313

Prefe

fi. Sfi, ff , ,

SP (, ), C S (), J. D S- (), S J S (), J R. G() -, , of , , reity ( ). P ff, - fi, fi () , , ff , .

W ff ff? B Sz - ,

j , - - j ( q fi , fi -

j). I Sz ,

() . I - , j , reresent.O () fl , , ( ) - .

A , ,


12/313

Prefe

. I, , -

fi , q - fi - fi ( ) , - ( P, F S). I I fi H fi, N B T W, , H fi . T fi .C, , H j . W ? A B-

I T K fi. A C H, . N ff- fi - fi, B W q

z j : .

I , , fi ony j I . A , - fi. T, - , , .

I , Sz


13/313

Prefe

( ) (-

) . L , - ( ) . T ff - () ff, - () ff .B , ff j-. A , () fl - , - . B - , ,

ff, , , .

I, . B fi - () reresenttions - , , ,

- ud-ent. T () j , , , P . T (j) (j) j ( ) ff ff ( -). T , j j j ( ) j j ( , ),


14/313

Prefe

j . (I.., , -

- z j , , .) T j q ( ffi ) fi . R- , - . () ff () - z .

M , , - - () ,

fl . I , I q is , . M, ff - .

I ff -

ff j j . I , , q jfi how fi , , . T , , j (-). I -

j . S , , q , if -


15/313

Prefe

exerient ?

T -, j , rtie edoi fore , fi, . Sfi, -- , - - . N- - - Jq D, M F, G Dz,I, , . H, D , F

, Dz . W , D is , F- , Dz -z fore, , -. H, , - -

I , - j , T A , j.

I () fi - ( Dz F, A, M H A N) , Dz , fi, : Msohis: Codness nd Cruety Frnis Bon: TeLoi of Senstion. I , j Dz ( D-


16/313

Prefe

z F G) , -

fi j . T, fi, () Dz () I .

G , I - , exeri-ent. T , W WII A fi , . O , -, z . I , I Sj Dz

(.., ), , , (Orns without Bodies ).

O, D , ,, , , , -. H, I D - z

. J , .I , ff -- se , , Dz G , -. T , - -ff - ( ) , . E


17/313

Prefe

( D,

, , , ff) .

W ff, fi , . H, osts ff, , ff, - fi fi C B, B E E Aerin Psyho fi M H, P- H fi, R DN, D DL /. T ,

, - : , fi ff -; , fl . E fi q fi q

.T, -

, how - j before . I , I - j-, q () before j , , .


18/313

I , I fi B E EAerin Psyho. F , . A , I A, G. E

F - E . B ff , I . I I E ff

. F , fi BE E.

B ( ) I ,I I , . I . I . S, I


19/313

j . F , I - K H, Jff . N, J M,

I fi . M - j . S - !

A , I fi - : R D,E W, S S, C S, P J,D S, Jff K, J R, R Nz, M- B, C H, K DL, P G, GE, D H, Ez Mzz ff - j fi. I

D E U N, : , L fi . I W W D G A F, - . L,

L R P, fi -j unl, , J R, . F, I N S, , , , -! L R! A, , L R- U N P fi , A J . I R S T MH,

Aknowedents


20/313

, , fi ,

I .B

ff, . H G U S , I G, - M D, C Wz, J M, D- H, Uz F, , A, fi , . S B. W I , I . L, , R G , , .

I , , - -

, R M A. T ( G), I .

Aknowedents


21/313


22/313

Te Vioene of Senstion

V. M , , , - , , , . A , - - -

, , , . V tv ; - . A N J ?T ffi j other,

. B j - . C fl , , , ?O , q : fi ?

W - ? W ff ,

Millers Crossing, Affect, and Masocriticism


23/313


? T / -, ,

z . B , , z?

O , , I ( I ?), W C. T U.S. I : I j , I , z , q . T

M, L, E, Iq, fi. N / G ,S , .

I, - , different, V ff fi .1 I , - ff fi event - , -, .

B , . O


24/313


I , , -

.2 , - W z; , , q . A , j , - - -PC: B B-H. W ff- fi , , (, B) q ethi. I, z z fl. I, theseves q ,

. T , I - re-ity .

Te Violence of Sensation

, , Miers Crossin (), A - fi C B q fi . T fi z . A , I A : I .I . I , L, I I . J - fi ,


25/313


, , - . T

- . V - fi H C L C ( E G. R M LR Litte Cesr []),P E ( J C W W fi ), S ( PM H H fi). A z , fi J C (J P) :

Y I . I .B I . W I fi fi, I fi, I fi I

fi ff . B I B B, I , , I .T I . H I fi fi.

A , - C ,

. T : S, I ? C L (A F), , : A .

B L , C, -, :I fifi. N, fi, ? F . I C , , fi . W , L


26/313


(G B), , C , D (J. E. F)

. R j. T -. W , , . W B B ff , -. A . A -, L C, S ? D, C, , F .

O , fi - . V - fl fi . W fi, fi, fi/ fi : .3 I , fi

.V , -: , .

Y, ff . I --. T -

ff before , ,. I - , G Dz B F B. A Dz, B (Frnis Bon ). T , B ff ( ) ff ( ).

P


27/313


fi O SNtur Born Kiers () R- Rz Sin City ()

ff - -- fi. N - , -z () , () . R , , (Dz, Frnis Bon ). A , - j : B: ff, - (). A ff, (), - ffi []

. B P (). S-ff j: j j . W ff (ffq ), ff Dz ff z, ,

.4Dff ,

(Dz, Frnis Bon ) .A Dz , fi ().5 I C - q Miers Crossin. W - ( Dz fi), intensify fi q B F C.


28/313


I B , F fi,

() . A Dz , F fi : . . ., . . . (). T F, , : , fiurtive, iustr-tive, nrrtive F (). I C B fi, J P --, ff, C z P , , fi , , . L B, C fi , , fi F; ff, , . T ff

- fi j fi/ whoese j.

W , , C . F , , ff- (Dz, Frnis Bon ).

W , , ? S , , , , , , B

Miers Crossin C. H, q B, C, us , z ? M - , . T B


29/313


[ ] ( )

, fores of the fu-ture (, ). A , , - ff ff . B fi ff-, B in -, j .

W ? W future - . B , susendin q , - (D-z, Frnis Bon ). W , fi

. A , Dz H- : D j , , ().

A Dz, B , , - fi , (). T -

F ( , , , , ) ffi , .F M H, j z , . F Dz, , , ,[] ffi , , F G fi , Wht Is Phiosohy?(). I , , - z Dz


30/313


; Frnis Bon, F - .

E , , turin fores. F fi. P K N , (Dz, Frnis Bon , ). I, Miers Crossin. O , (fi-) , . A Dz , fi fi [, -] ; (). A , fi fi , [] j : F fi; - ( , , ), () q C B . Y,

fi, , F, ff () --, , .

S, before fi Mi-ers Crossin, F , . A , , (Dz, Frnis Bon

), . H ? H , fi, () j ? O, , de to j? C B , Dz , C , , . S . W , j, this (). I fi - C B fi:


31/313


fi, fi q j j,

this .6 A,, B, q , , , Cz .

Te Violence of Ethics

I , q - , q , , -, . Tz q j, Jff N hoosin , ffi r-

tion . [ . . . ] R, j- resonse , . T I s ifI -; , I (AterityPoitis ). T ff - , . T ff

rior z, -z ff -z , I -. W - - before ff, z- ().

A ffetive effets


32/313


. A ff fi

. , ff q, j j .7 B ff, ,I j ( ff z j), B M , -- (). Aff, , ff ; ,ff [ ] - , , ().

T, I , Miers Crossin , q

fi . T q , , - . H, , - ff . I ,

q fi Q , S P, --, , fi ( ,ff ). O, , fi Te Wid Bunh (. S P, ) Pu Fi-tion (. Q , ) within .

B Miers Crossin ff


33/313


, -, fi ff . I fi ,

() , , , .8 T C . , , . O , C - , , q ( fi ?) fi .9 I, C -

. O, L C q B, B, - . Dff , L - B C, ? A , L ; , C . O , B,

L C, L fi. C L L . F C , , L -, , : , L .

H, j Cfi -- . R, redy .T fi C-


34/313


fi - ff , .

E (), senseC () ; . T , C , , , --, C . C, , -. R z , . R, , , , .

W C , C fi Bood Sie

Fro, stye fi ff sense . C - fi ,Miers Crossin - ff C fi .10 S - . T

, , fi C ff- : j , , , C . A , - C jfi ; , we re ent to sense the vioene of ethis .

A , - --, . B --, -. B ,


35/313


C fi . R-, , Bood Sie -

Fro. L, C fi , , , - . Y C fi - , . B , - Ntur Born Kiers, - fi . W fi () ( -, ..), Miers Crossin effet [] , -

(M- ). I , fi ff .

T fi q shoud (z ffi ); ,Miers Crossinfi

-, q before . H, , -? A , - - z q j? I , - Miers Crossin: () , - ?


36/313


Te Violence of Masochism

I Frnis Bon, Dz z ffi . I , Dz fi , -, : , (). N Dz - , - . F , -, in . J , ,Dz Nz E R.I () E R, Dz Nietzshe nd Phiosohy E R fi

ff . Ony - . W , , ff , , ff. F, Dif-ferene nd Reetition, Dz , D S , Dz . U- -

, Dz B - ony . I B -, B, , q , , D .

I F B , - fi ()

, q , -, F fi (Dz, Frnis Bon), , z


37/313


. B q () .11 H

Dz , [] [] (). M - , - .

C, B , . H - knows wht he wnts to do, he does not know how to et there, (Dz, Frnis Bon ). A q : how ? T ,

() , q , event .

C B , Dz . T - , ( ), ,

, ( ). I , (Frnis Bon ). A, : fi ff ? B ffi , , . T , ffi , . T , Nz -fi sine


38/313


. T ffi - : I -

, , fi . O , - , , (Dz,Nietzshe nd Phiosohy ).W I , , Dz B ff fi ffi . T I Dz B q .12

C, , C B Fro, fi - , z, . S , Dz L S-M , -

, (Ms-ohis ). Y, : z (). z ( ), , -

.13 T , , (). T , , , , z (). W , , fi this


39/313


: , ff, , j

. T j . I , .Cq, , is , . W , -, ethi - . I , - () (). Y, Dz , , [ . . . ] z . [I -], z, [ ] ().

T Fro. I fi -

fi, , . I fi fi - z - . Sq, fi, fi.14Fro ff

- fi j , - . Y, - , q I I I I -before ( ). I , C , , C - fi -


40/313


fi . C, ,

.R Fro -

fi, , I ffi ethodooi - Dz . T - , , ; , , , fi -. S -q , ff ()

ff . O ff () j . W - j , I , ,

z stye . W , q .

I , I , , ( ?). H, - , Dz


41/313


, (Fouut ). H,

. T H j . R, , j (fi- ), -. E, , , . O, Dz , : D I . O , - (Differ-ene nd Reetition ).

C, j edoy of

vioene - . M - . M . A Dz , D - , :

z z (Msohis ). C Nz - ffi , ?

H, , q? F , , , Dz , ,


42/313


z, , - , -

q , ; - (Msohis ). T z - , , - ( ) z ( ). J - -, , Dz, W W II, z ( ) z . I, : C B, B E E, P H,

R DN, D DL, , , G Dz.O j , , ; fi - , ff, . O, , , D-z, ;

. P - , fi , , , j (Msohis ).

T , , tivey . I . D , z -fi ,


43/313


. T z

, ff : I (Dz, Cine ). T -: j. H ff ff. B , , z , - Sz (fi fi q ).15 A ffi ff, . H j . H .

B -. H , j , .

A Dz , , fi ( ) -. H

fi . T - fi (Msohis ). Az , j , ( - ). T - .


44/313


E, fi -, ,, ,

j, . T -, j, , q , fi, , ffi -, , q, z . I - ; , , , .

Masocriticism

G , - - q q

rodution. Cz , ,

j , -

, ff, - .16

C, -, ; , , , fi . I , -, . T - j,


45/313


fi . R

, ff - , -, . A q , fi .17

M , I .I P M . H, , I -: T H ( - H). M - (). V Dz ( G), I

M , . M - reutin . T - . T needs . T fi z :

j ( ), j ( ). T - -, - fi, , .

A z -: j , - fi fi j, ( - ), ,


46/313


j, ( ) ,

ff , ff, z, z . I , - , q O, --, ff ff .

Cq, Dz . A , - , fi: , - - , itsef roduesoetive utternes. [ . . . ] N ,

- . T - - , (Cine ). A -. I, , , . N q -, j

. R, -, . T . A : - , fi oetive . B ffi q , ; in


47/313


, in fi, () fi

-.M , , j

, fi . T , , ff. W , , - - ( C fi -q ).

A, , , , , ,

, . I, , , . T , , , , - z .

I, / . I -

, : I I ? T q ffi , ffi -, , . N-, ( ff , ) : ff- ( ) ffi ff.


48/313


I , , Dz

-, susension of the word ff disturbne, , [] , q - (Cine ). T - ( , j, ). B () , -, j ff - (e fl S F : ). , ,, j.T , , , , Dz , [] j

( ) ff (Cine ).T

j -. C fiAerin Psyho ; -

q j; fi P H R fi

j ; - R DN - () ; D DL / ff - .

T , I :


49/313


, I - ;

, I . O, , j I throuh . T - ff ff . M , , ff , , () . I j j (, !) , , .


50/313

Judent Is Not n Exit

Comparison, Representation, Judgment

M H fi B E E Aerin Psyho J-L G - - , , -

- Chiers du Cin - G Pierrot Le Fou Pierrot (G-, L P ). A , , , () , . C ,

fi, H , , , , - H P B W S . G E q

A - , H fi :.1

Representation, Affect, andAmerican Psycho


51/313


T zz, ff-

. T - ff, , - - .2 A , fl , . Y, I fi zz - . W .

W G , fi

, - . O , H E q ff fi . A , fi q fiq

W S fi P B-, E .I AerinPsyho j E - R, H fi - , , udent () .3

R, H fi ,


52/313


E .4 E fi , . I ,

fi . F , R Siht nd Sound fi ().H , , , , M H- G . [ . . . ] [] j (). H, , fi ? W H fi E fi ff ? T q ( ) ff fi ff .

q, I fi ff, , q B E E () . T , , fi ( ) I A P .

-

q , , fi.T . U - , I Aerin Psyho . T - fi, , , fi (


53/313


D H, RC, J M. C).

W, , ? O . J - , , (tv, , ) -. I , , .5 A D , j. I - -- - . I ff - ff , ,

, fi .A, , , ,

, , .6 A, , ff : . N -

( L-A-N-G-U-A-G-E ), P ; , P, j .7 T , ; - q .8 O, , , P, q - M-


54/313


A . H, Aerin Psyho, I

stye P - : , -, , j .

F A P, , . R, I , , fi - : ( ) ff - j. T q , -

Nz . A A P, , q , q , , .9

G , q ,

, j - . O, ff q-, (.., ny , , , j ), j?10 T . R, j ,


55/313


- j.

Deleuzes Symptomatology

W, , j? C q, K , () G Dz q- , , ff

j , , . E F Nz, B Sz, A A-, Dz H D J j : J . F - , ,

, . H, , -: to brin into existene nd not to ude. I

j, q , j (, ). I Dz q. I , Dz --

Jq D M F , . G - Nz, , G . I , ,Nz , , . I , j () , /ff .11

Dz Sz


56/313


. F Dz q j fi

ff: - ffetive ( , , ) ff ff ? H, Dz, fl , , ff j- fi, .

L , I , ff j, - ff -. S , not q

j , . F Dz [ . . . ] fi fi (B I S ), j q, . I - ffi j ,

fl. A , Dz - , - , ff , , --ff .

P , Dz . H () ( Nz , ) : ,


57/313


, . I

is, , Dz .T q , differ-enty? A P P, Dz ,, W [] , - j - . T ().

R fl , , . H, - fi (, -

, ), is, do , ff.

P ff, fi, Dz .12H fi ff . [ . . . ] A fi -

(B I S ). Dz ,, - . O , . F , Sj [ ] (P ). H , , ff Dz L L j ,


58/313


L , fi j, , . I , L-

Dz . I Dz Jq L , , ff .13

F Dz, , ff j z ff , , L L .F, ff , j ff fi - . ,, j throuh , , -

, , , ff.

I, A B , q , (). H, ( ) j

. C ffi , - M M H A N- Dz , . I [. . .] z z fl , [. . .] (). I , .


59/313


, , Bq j, I

j -, : M H E -Aeri-n Psyho. R Dz - j , I - ff , , ff E ie Sy , P B, . A , Hfi E . I ff -

fi I Dz -, fi Msohis: S- q ff ff (). B Hfi A P ,

nd I E -, , R- , G S , ().

M fi, I Aerin Psyho - ffi H


60/313


(Hb). A H fl E , fi

(, , -) - E .14 I [ ], ff , , (N ).I , I fi - E H fi , I ff, . P

q - , I ff , ff , ff ff- AerinPsyho .

Harrons Film as a Double Response

F , q E : - , Aerin Psyho , fl - . T j E .C H, , , I [ ]


61/313


, fl , j , . Aerin Psyho -

, - , Rues of Attrtion (q. L ). : I . I . I, , (). A, -, R R New York ies ff E , , , , [] j.

T ff.15 C E, , j -

ff : j j ; j .16R j, , z; . I ffi , Aerin Psyho fi

, - j . I , E - , j, .

N, - j - ; ,


62/313


q j , ff . A ff fi -

j , - EAerin Psyho M H fi. I , H -z E , -fi - .17W E , fi, H - E throuh . G q , H - E .

z, H fi -fi,I Shot Andy Wrho (), VS, scum (S C UM) A W - E : , .

O , fi j

, X . (I-, O S, - fi, .) H, I untity , , .H fi ff . Aff q ;, . F, -


63/313


S; ( Dz G, Tousnd Pteus

). T q, , ff Aerin Psyho , . C , , G - ff - E ? T , G qB ? A ? (wo orTree Tins, ) .

I , , H- fi z E rey q fi- , q .18 F - A P, ,

fi . T fi z A -, fi -. (I , fi fi . E fi .)19 Wq, fi, E j

W S A; , fi j . T , , - z .

F ffi fi fi q. F, H ff B . S -


64/313


z E, ,

.20S, H - E . T fi B fi, . T , J (CS), B ffi - . E, fi B - . M fi : . I fi (

E ), q rey . T , .21

T, H C B ff P B

A P - fi . C B, - . I , fi , B .22 I -, z z B . F, H


65/313


z

, , S . V H- fi , , , , , -, . I, H fi E. C, H - .23

S I j H fi , , H fi effet , ff fi . T

, H fi E : , ffi H j ff -. H, I j ost - - -

(-z) E. A , ?W - Aerin Psyho () ? W ffi fi ? W ff ff , ,


66/313


B j (

)?24 A, fi, Aerin Psyho, , z ?

W , , ff H- fi E ( ) : H E - ? fi , H - : B - .

Te Boredom of Violence, the Violence of Boredom

T ff H fi E j . R , , , , ,

, , q .A, (, , ) E - . (R fi - .) T , , B - B


67/313


. B, , -

q - ff ff fi , - , , () .25

H, , : , , . I ,E z, -, E E . R ff q , ,

, , , ff ff . C, , , fore - : B . W , , (E ), ff

ff .C , fi

B - q ff , - ff . H, j q B . I , q q -


68/313


, ff ff

. , - q . T q , , , , q .

Y, q q ff, fi.26 B j , , -, throuh (-) Aerin Psy-ho. Jff N q : S -

j , , : j . T ,, (Doube Redin). I

; , I , sowin down .

W , , ff ff q Aerin Psyho . I - ff , ffi ff .27 P A-


69/313


N W H . T

, N -- Az, (Doube Red-in). V, , fi. Dz ,, - B M , , - fi ff ().28

S, -, , , , ; , , , , , .I , ,

. T ff , , AerinPsyho , B fi , . A , ff

( fi) , , ? H ff, , ff z ff - - , ?

B I q . F E-Aerin Psyho ff ; ,


70/313


- (),

.29 B , , fl , ff ffi ff ( - ) ff-, , , fl - . M, H, P, , Offi ,H C, D, D C, H, D C,B M, V S, F, D, , ff . S . C-q, B

, , fi . S , ff , fl , zfi ff -

. N, I , q , , B . O, q - fi - ff , fi , - ff . R q .30

W I


71/313


- , -

ff, fi F J ff (). I , , fl - fi D C B E, , ff.O , ff ff j . I, ff fl - ff . T fi ff fi . B fi D C Frisk () Te Suts (),

B E T P L () Te Brotherhood of Mutition (), ff, - z

j ( , ff q j ) .

A P, E

, H . A, fi B ff . H : ; B ; B ; ffi ; fi; ; ; D,

j; - -


72/313


; , -

. A q .T, , B .H , - , . A , I fi q, . T - . P -, , fi .

H, q , fi if ff E . H ,

. A H , I (H, E, B). H, fi . Hrron seeds u reiseytht whih is bout sowness in the book . T ,

ff H ff -. F, H -, fi , . N j , , .

F, fi ff . F, . (B,,


73/313


U E S fi. Y,

-- ff- . P fi - .) A , fi ff ff .T j , , , , - , z . B , fi B z G, W H, H L N , fi ff :D B

? A q ? T fi B - , Aerin Psyho - ff

. (B H L H B Sq .) T H q B , , ff .

W . A ( ) B, -


74/313


. I , , , . T fi,

, q B. W fi q q () , fi , , , - j. E -fi ff ; fi .31

T fi , . I, . B ff kind E . W - - E , , , ,

ff, ffi ( j ff ). U, , j fi , , , , .H, . F

, ff q - q fi ff q .

B fi fi fi . (Aff , fi.) R, fi H


75/313


Aerin Psyho, -

. (I , , , , E .) T fi .I , fi ( ) , , -

j H , - ff . T , ff - z , . T - ( S S ), ff fi ,

, ( ) j , j .

I z E -fi , , z, - : ff -

. I , ff fi , not ff , . B , , , , , . (N Aerin Psyho . H -


76/313


ff - fi .) T ff

ff, . T , -, H E , ff .

A S N ff , - , z , , ().

H E ff - -

, ff : . L , fi - q - , , ff

j .

Nz , , , , fi ff ff- q , ,, .32 T fi , ,

jfi ff ff . I j ff, , , j ff.H fi, , -


77/313


j q . I

. C-q, fi, , E , ff, . B, Dz , H , ? I . W - , - (Differene nd Reetition ).

I . A- - ,

z .33 H, e j E , - H,Aerin Psyho , - . (A H fi ff .)

I , , , , : . R () s , , - fi ff ff, , q Dz j, : Aff , j : I I I j (Cine ).


78/313


Representation(al) Costs

S , , fi , . I, -z H E - Aerin Psyho fi () . A, ? N , - - I (, , !) , , - (- ) . I , fi

fi B EE not ( ) fi does, , Aerin Psyho z . I . R, - ,

fi A the -.34

A, , ff -

- j . W Aeri-n Psyho , , -


79/313


, , ff ff .35 C

O , , ff - E , -, , j ( - j j). B - ( ), (), j -

j . (N , , -fi L fi, , effetive. I , fi [] B ff , -

, B T . [. . .] I .) I . A, - j fi q , I , q j. I

eerene - , . J- - j - ( ) , not , I .

C fi ,, q ff,


80/313


ff , - ff

. Dz, ff, q (: q) ff fl .36 T fl, - Dz G; fl - , ff , fl ff. F, , q -: H fl? I ? A - ? H, q , I , E z H -ff ff .M

, I - . I , fi ff q - ff Aerin Psyho.37


81/313

Are We A Arnodins?

B q. I j, I M A, - fi V j , , -

j. W- C. H H W HA Hndbookto Literture A j j (), Norton An-thooy A ( A ff []), - q z , j . A

A , , -, z, . S - . I , z T F C (), , A - j [. . .] (Norton ). P , A -

A Conceptual Genealogy of Judgment


82/313

Are We A Arnodins?

(), j

. H, - , B , , [ ] , , ().

A fi- . H -, , j. A j , , (Norton ), j: , j , fi, -

, (). Y, z, q A - . A - , L S, T H H

ffi . A H [ ] () , -fi , , q . I, A j , fi q fi .


83/313

Are We A Arnodins?

A , , A? Y .C, ,

z . I , z Entertinent Weeky, New York ies, tv Ebert nd Roer t the Movies j fi , , . T . T q j , , .

C L G - (We Gott Get Out ). T , , . F , M

P P D A (mppda), ff (Sz ), - H fi mpaa , , fi , . L, tv A - H . W

, -, . L , .F , ; , jfi , .


84/313

Are We A Arnodins?

C , jfi -

. I H fi ffi . O M A . A T F - Te Conuest of Coo, . A , . A , A ffi : , fi, ff - . E , - ; , ,

. W , , j .

I H - , - fi .Cq, W W II. W

tv (.., V, JFK, L H O) , H fi z ( H- -). T H - j , fi ,


85/313

Are We A Arnodins?

, - vhs dvd. , ,

fi - ,

j , - j H fi. T j ,, , - M G Te Pssion of the Christ ().

B , - , ? I , A - A . Y, j .1 I , fl -

, P M, fl ,Aeories ofRedin, j .2 W A - M S R- q j-

fi . I, M A j - . H, M ( ) A - . A , M j q . W


86/313

Are We A Arnodins?

j , M

.

Paul de Man: Debunking Meaning

D M S R A j (N C) ().3 H q , q :

W , fi ff, . N

, : or onsiene . B , - , oriertive , , ,

, ff. (, )I , M - , , - ff . T - , , M : , / j .


87/313

Are We A Arnodins?

C, , M ,

, not j.I , / ff - . W N C, , , q q. A M , , : , (). H, N C - , , .4

T M /

q () fifl z - /, /, /-, /. D q how , M -

. I , : , M G I, - ().

F , , -fi, M A B, W B Y, M P (.., - ). W M, , . H fi


88/313

Are We A Arnodins?

,

- -. T , , fi ff, - . S q vue udents : , , , , - . (, )

M, , . T M z ( q) - , , z [. ..] (). W - , M ( ) fi , , ().

Y, Nz , M ( fi []) -() . A M , - [ ], (). T . F, ,


89/313

Are We A Arnodins?

(). N -

. S, , fi; . T, , , z M , z (). T , - [ ] ; ().

H M , fl , q . H

A. Y, - A , , M - j . F / , , Jff N , z-

(Aterity Poitis ) , . A / - j, M ffi j . A , , , j, - j . I , , M , j-


90/313

Are We A Arnodins?

( ?) . W fi

j, M j ( ; ) : is . I , M ff j, - ( ) -A- .

Lawrence Grossberg: Affecting Cultural Studies

B M

j, : , , A fi j - ? I q L G q , fi . C , j N H

N M, , , .5 R q, - , , ff .6 Y, , G , , , I , , M j j: , the eonoy of reresenttion itsef noweeres s the robe. J M ff -


91/313

Are We A Arnodins?

( - fl-

fi ), G fi .7 I G- , , , .

I T V C, G oi ( ). D fi j j - fi -, (). Sfi, -

, G , , , , -, ff (). O , G fi z ; F Nz, , z (,.., O L E-M S), - G Dz M F. Y, I q G , ff , :

N A M z - , , (.., ). T ,


92/313

Are We A Arnodins?

fi , , -

, . A , ff, , , , j, . ()

Nz q -

, , , .S, G - fi, z ff - : . I I q , Aerin Psyho q , , j . T G I inst .

T G

, , . O - (). C, G , ude (, ). T , , , j: (). R A (q. G ),G


93/313

Are We A Arnodins?

.8 T fi

-z A , , ( I ) B E E - . A , E fi Less Tn Zero() no du our -, - q E W C . P q E , Aerin Psyho : / E - , j - ; E Aerin

Psyho, , . T , , E . S, , -z j z

.9S, E () ,

j , AerinPsyho .T E . T -, , , () fi , ,, . T q , fi ,


94/313

Are We A Arnodins?

- .10 B -

, fi, j fi ; , .

I , () . S, , P H JT fi - shoud . I , , H Te ented Mr. Riey () T Kier Inside Me () ff. I , H T - E , H T, -

z // , . T A A C H. L -z, A

A R E, J B, M H, H , Pn B ().T fi

. I - , j - ( q ). C, j - H , I .

S, G -


95/313

Are We A Arnodins?

() . I

G q - () - , j ().Sfi, G , fi [ ] (). T, . A , I , F ,

ff .11

G . S, , z ff -, . C ff - , G , , , ff -K [, , j]

; - - (). W G , , ff ff - .

W B M z G ff, I G fi


96/313

Are We A Arnodins?

.12 J M

A , G M j , , : .F G , - j ; , .

G, , /- . R, - ff - , .W . O, , Sfi -

- , (). C B q : P -, [] , () ( ) () - ( - ), - [z. , ] . A

[ . . . ] (j) (). BG B ( , ), , B , [ ] ()? q, B G G Dz, , fi , .13


97/313

Are We A Arnodins?

T G Dz -z

- . T , M q j ; M q M (A ) . T q en? - . L, - , ,

( ), G . I z , () ( ) q- . I , - q , , ,

j.14T , , Dz

fl fi , N H, . Aq mla Dz , F/N H, D/D. S, j Dz ,

j .15 W


98/313

Are We A Arnodins?

? W - Dz ? W

( ffi , - , ffi - ), I , G, Dz . O, , fi Dz Dz - , -, j I .16 , Dz , T S A P -

z , - fi ().

Gilles Deleuze: Overcoming Platonism

Nz

P, Dz (S- ). I Dz - q P. A , P W- . A Jq D q , W P M H, I P fi . A , ,


99/313


100/313

Are We A Arnodins?

, , .

T , P I - j (). W Dz udent P- , . T Dz P - : .

I P, Dz, [] - , ; siu-r , , (S ). T , P ff , , ,

() I: T I . T - j (- ) I. H q (q j, ) (j). I , -

I, , (). I -, , dissiirity I: I ff,.

O Dz , JB F J .18 T Dz ff in kind ; -


101/313

Are We A Arnodins?

ff . C

, effet: [ ] ff ; [] . T fi fi ; .T , fi, fi ; (). F P, fl , (-)P C, - I (P) G (C). F , C, Dz ,, G . T, ,

. W . W - (). C- j ; ,, , -z.

Dz , , . Dz V , -

: L L, .R, - .O , , B (), the oriin nd the oy,the ode nd the rerodution (). T () onstitutive , .19 T


102/313

Are We A Arnodins?

, ff, -

, ff , , .T C R , , I .T , , (), zz, , - - : , .20

B P . R, Dz , P - , (). B

, , , K , j - , -. A , j j : ff ; , ().O, C C , fi

j , , - fi . [ . . . ]W , j, within . B j fi ().

A , , P - j j; , , fi - - . T


103/313

Are We A Arnodins?

, , .21T j, -

(Dz, S ), ff (), - (), P , W (j) , .22

A Dz, P z : - fi -, fi j, (). A , ff , , (P ). L j j

. T , , j: - j, j. O, Nz , j P ff - . A P, , , [] , , fi

(Nz, U D ). Dz P, , P. Dz Nz q.23 R, I Dz P(). P -

j - . T P ffi

j z , j ,


104/313

Are We A Arnodins?

, A

.24

I , , q . A , - ( ), j , j, . I , A .F, ( , , , .) j j , j . F j

ff j j , -- . H, Dz P P z ; fi j.25 R,

j . T j q , ff ; , E Aerin Psyho ( H Te ented Mr. Riey), j q : ff - q .

B ffi j ( , ) .26


105/313

Are We A Arnodins?

W M -

, ff () , Dz ff q . A, q W ? W - , , ? O , q , Dz , N S S.

W I , , I , H fi I . T , Dz

j, I - fi j j- ( j -, ),

j, , is - . M ,

Dz , ,vioene is there is ff ff . Y - , B -. I , .27I , , - ff. A


106/313

Are We A Arnodins?

j , . A -

. Y . I , Dz P -j- . O . W ff, :W ff ? W fi ? W fl -? I , , - ff.

N , Dz ff - ff. Aff -, ff ff. A K- ff , Dz ffi ff ,

: . Aff - ff; , /. Aff - fi, , , j throuh j .T , , j j j q . T -

, , j ( , , S S W WII fi Shinders List [] Svin Privte Ryn []).R, q : I j ( fi ) , , ? O ? I , - ? T Dz fi,


107/313


108/313

A I , fi B E E Aerin Psyho. V M H - A ,

fi z . W C D A M P H Teented Mr. Riey A ff , - fi A- A .1 A fi-, fi,

New Yorker New York ies fi H . F , New Yorker - S C M - H, ().L, New York ies H .F, N, M K, , fi R E L.2 T F R -

Patricia Highsmiths Empirical Pedagogy of Violence


109/313

Seriizin Vioene

S Mz Te ented Mr. Ri-ey -- A . F, D

T J M, A() fi , fi .

I Mfi A A Te Enish Ptient () P H,

A q , - fi E ff U S // fi.

L (, .., S D), C H () E U S (). R

H ffi fi U S,M B U S fi H [ ], - fl (). I, M fi, H . I j - Te Seeted Stories of Ptrii Hihsith () Noth-

in Tt Meets the Eye: Te Unoeted Stories of Ptrii Hihsith(), N H -- , Strners on rin (), B fi j H-, A W Beutifu Shdow (). , H Mj M Hihsith: A Rone of the s (), . T , U.S. .

M , M


110/313


111/313

Seriizin Vioene

I B E E , j

. E z q- j , - P B V W, Gor () . M Aerin Psyho fi j fi -. L j , () ,, I H fi - j. PH, I , fi -

, , ff.

A M fi , H

j.4 H, I H -.5 I, I H fi z j . I, P H q j ffH fi . I ,H F , , , q - robtiues , ,


112/313

Seriizin Vioene

(Fouut Reder ). M- F, j G Dz,

, (Differene nd Reetition).6 I , / ff F - -. H, . Y fi (Fouut Reder). A H j.T ff, , , - throuh q , , . T , -fi-- - -, fi, Pot-tin nd Writin of Susense Fition (), H

, , , , fi q j q -.7

I , H, q j , H .

T H fi q z - j , , , ff . M

j . I , j- , -, . H , , R ( ), j


113/313


114/313

Seriizin Vioene

, , fl ,

j,, , A . A j Eire - ff , H E . H - ff , fi ff : E.

T H , , , , , j-

j E . I ff , intensities , H, , , , fi. V, H , . T ,

fi z q () .

Violence, Judgment, and Writing

R P H - q ,


115/313

Seriizin Vioene

j, . I . A H,

fi : S [ ] I didnt ind. S, I , P. B I -.I didnt ind one bit (D , ). I , ff , , fi ff . I stye , H . I , , , , , .

H, q - , .

M , H- j. I j ,

. C j O , q .8 A Dz , , , q ; q j , - , , , , , z


116/313

Seriizin Vioene

( H D ). A -, H Bq I

fi, j.9

, I not H - ; q . R, I stye , , fi . H, , I ttitude H ,

z . J () j, j . H- q j

mfa U S S P, A S, RL. S I , , , I , I I - (D ). H j- O fl (- fiz), -


117/313

Seriizin Vioene

Nz ff

.10 I , I H . R, -, H . T , , , robtiue. R , , . T , , ff- .

R H - - fi, (O-

, , fl, ) - fi ff Dz . W Dz - ( ), H

, , j. B H Dz j .J H fi , Dz , , . [ . . . ] W (L L ).11 I , q , z fi .


118/313

Seriizin Vioene

T fi H fi q q j q . H fi fi: W, I -, I (H, ). W, , ,

j H ? A - , , , ff ? O, ff q j fi ff ?12

H , R, - fi H . G zH q

j ff z. C H R H , q .K, , R

R -- : [ . . . ] - .S : fl j .K G K R , j ().F, R, H -, , (). T,


119/313

Seriizin Vioene

H j H -

.I, I , R

intensifition H - . T z fi , fi fi z -. E H , - .I , , , z , -, I I . H ,

, - . I , , , j .

I , ff fi - fi . C,

- . A , H j- . A - fi , F z -z fi fi -. T robtiues H ,


120/313

Seriizin Vioene

, , - ,

.

A fi H . T Te ented

Mr. Riey . Strners on rin () (B) (G). Te Prie of St() (.., ) fl - . T

j

fi .O , , H fi . A H , Cro ( H fi ), Te Prie of St , . P ,

A , , ( ), q ().H , C M, (), j ; , - ff .

E Te Prie of St -


121/313

Seriizin Vioene

H , - , fi

. A ,H q - Te Prie of St, ff q ff (Found in the Street [] S : Suer Idy). F, Te Bunderer (), , - (W S) j (G K), , , .

I , fi - . I , fi R R, , , . W (ff -

j) ( -) , , R.H, , , z . O, , j- q (

), j .J ff Strners on rin

Te Bunderer. T H , . O , H -

j j ff .

A D C , W, Te Bund-erer, z [ ] C [


122/313


123/313

Seriizin Vioene

. I H fi

q j - , H . T fi. I , Dz , (Cine ).15 A

A , N Y, E, F, Sz, G F , H E fi A z.16 B

/j- A , - ( ). B H K H- - ; ,

, , , (Dz, Cine ). R, H q- j :, , . N , , H R I (Pottin nd Writin).


124/313

Seriizin Vioene

Becoming-Violent

Te ented Mr. Riey H R, q . I , R - , , , q P. H , R - . I , fi R Te ented Mr. Riey - j - . H M. R G, fi, I , D, U S j G . R, -

q D, . E, , , D . R - , D . T q , ff I q D , M, ,

F M, D R . B , R, , , , , .

C Te ented Mr. Riey,

M fi, H - q R . B R , fl


125/313

Seriizin Vioene

H , , , , H-

fi R .D R , , ff . L-, R . T,, ffi ffetive R - , , E H () .17M , , z R - j q ;

R . Y, ff- ff ffi R , , H H fi j. I , , I H fi j

ff - R - .18

B , G- , , () M. G I,R . H - -q fi . L G , R () q , , , fl- . R


126/313

Seriizin Vioene

. F (), .

H fl. I . Soe-thin in hi hd set it out nd et t it even before his brin (, ). T fi H , (H , ) , R , B, F, Dz, : R () , z .

C R , H fi R

. H , H R ff : - , (), - () - fi ffetive .Dz :

T . [ . . . ] D

. R, - . [ . . . ] Soethin in the word fores us to think.T j enounter. [W ] ffetive : , , ,ff. I , . (Differene nd Reetition ,fi )


127/313

Seriizin Vioene

Dz [] R

H: R . M , R re-sonds . T , -, . H (), R not - , , z .

I , , Dz G - .19 B-, A Tousnd Pteus, (), [] fi- (). - . R -

q D -D. F, , ; , - (), (), (), ff (), ff, z (). I , , z : -

, -, - z(Dz P, Dioues ). -D - , , - : S , j , , fi, - ,


128/313

Seriizin Vioene

. [ . . . ] T

. I zone of roxi-ity (Tousnd Pteus ). A H , , G , ff ff ff [ ] (Tousnd Pteus ). R .

S, , H fi n of resonse.I j G ( , D), R . I , R . H

, ff . B , Dz : W - ( - ).T q. I - , (Fouut ). T -

, , , z , . T ff, , . T . H, , H : , ff .

I - , fi- ff . T D . B, -


129/313

Seriizin Vioene

z, -D j: , ,

M D, .20 R M , D - (), iines , , exerienes ff j: T , - , M Dfi (). T , fi- (R [] M. G ), -fi . S D q M j (..,M - D ), - , D

fi (). I , ().

A ff , -D. H , , D j M (). G , ,

. I , , : T [ . . . ] ood teerent , - . T (, ). I , H stye, , , . A : ff,


130/313

Seriizin Vioene

.21 A , ,

, : tv.

-D , j, - ff . I , , - fi D. H -D --. T z D .L fi ,D , D . W D-z G , z - fl . T fl -D/-, D

- : D -D.22

W C S R, D, ff, -, fi -, , - : D . A

z , ff, , . H D. I fi . B, , , . N , , D -, ? H D (). I, - -


131/313

Seriizin Vioene

: j , j ,

, j. T j, , -, , .

A . H - -D, z : H j : D G (). B -D, H . I, how (). N - q , , . ,

. B . T -D, --.23 A : T W. B D . T ff. [ j .] SR. F. A , F E I . A -, fl . W? (). N

, . A D , , , , D , [] D, D (). N, H - j fi ff.

A , , beuse , .


132/313

Seriizin Vioene

H j is .

. M , - , ( - R []) - : H ? I , , , -, , t (). T , , intensey, intensey (, ). I , , , , ff , -

z , .H ff fi , -q , ff : - , ( fi Hq z ) - -D. T -

fi , H .E , Te ented Mr. Riey, H- - ( D , []) fi . I , ( ). B I H j , j- q


133/313

Seriizin Vioene

( ) , , .24 I , H j

is -. T H q j (Te Bunderer) q intense j.

, , q . I , fi H fi robtiue: q j, q , fi . Y j . F, ff , .

- -D, -D q -. F, - : j - . A , j D M , , (). J, ,

roeeds with too uh seedj -. I q j , .

Empirical Violence

W , H robtiue j ,


134/313

Seriizin Vioene

j . Y, R ff C, H

Teented Mr. Riey. T , , Dee Wter Te wo Fes of Jnury, , fi (Tis Sweet Sikness [] Te wo Fes of Jnury) - (Dee Wter,A Ge for the Livin[]; Te Cry of the Ow [], ). G, - . I , , j, , fi - ( ) . A,

fi D S H . R , ff . T, H ,

( ) . I , H- fi ff.25

F , Te wo Fes of Jnury, RK , CMF, ( ) ff K. D MF K, K . Q . B -


135/313

Seriizin Vioene

, K - MF, .

M MF K, z , . L, D K Tis Sweet Sik-ness , , K z . T H , . K , fi , ff .

B q fi : H ? S

zz - j fi q ?

O H , P C Te Gss Ce() S B Te Story-eer(). Te Gss

Ce ff j . I , q P : , . M - ff Te Story-eer. H, B, - , - : - fi () fi . R , Te Story-eer . I


136/313

Seriizin Vioene

, H fi , , -

, H . H, H, - Strners on rin, q , I (C-C ). H, H fi qfi , Tose Who Wk Awy() Te reor of Forery (), - ( -). , , H - , , , j. T - z

H . A H, ; - j , , .

I, , H j,

Te ented Mr. Riey. RH fi ( fi ), I ffi ff , , . A ffi fi fi .26I, H ff . A Te reor of Forery, fi -


137/313

Seriizin Vioene

- . I , H I, A ,

. A fi N Y I , fi j . O , . N , , . T : j - -?27 O ?

R - - A- -

H , , q j () , - z: G, , - , , - S U [I] , A , . A I fi

, , q j , q. M , A, A- S, (?) I . S , A I A J-C . A I () -


138/313


139/313

Seriizin Vioene

. I , H , : I

- j . T, I - , I (Pottin nd Writin). I , ff , .B, , . (I - . R, , .)T ff , - . I z,, , H

robtiue,

j . H,H hd fi ff .

I , J S, H -, j H - R : T M. R, H [],

- . V , fi , fi (, ). I , S ff H . H : H , rob-tiue, fi


140/313

Seriizin Vioene

j. A I H , , . T , ,

- ; , Te ented Mr. Riey, , ( ,R ), fi j- . T , , j- , , . I H- , , , , , , , fi, .

V ff, ff - q . P , robtiue

. T fi fl: , H -/j/ fl.

T H fi

Riey Under Ground() , , , W W II (A) , W - . M H A N E-

ire j W z R.B W W II , , , , E: I ,


141/313

Seriizin Vioene

E fi . I deentered deter-

ritoriizin , . E , fl , - . T ().

T z : E fi W z . A , , , -. E, , - , ,, Dz G , T

, (Anti-Oedius ).T q z . A H N , - ( , M). N , , , E

z ff . [B ] [ . . . ] reornize rediret . [ . . . ] T E, , (, ). A, .

H, - I z , - H N -


142/313

Seriizin Vioene

, , () -. F -

, .H N , : D z[ ff ], E -, - . W E M ().

H N - ( ) fi [ ]: ffi - this , -

(). I , , ffi j . I , q - , H N - ff. I , E -

ff ().28 H, z - . T , () ; , , , , .29

q j, , -


143/313

Seriizin Vioene

H N q . T

. D E , , - (). T , : j. H N fi z (ngo) A I M F, . A, , H N ff , , E . I,

z, - , E . q :

S ngo ff ( ) fi

E.T ngo j , , . L D J , . Trouh their nue nd their tion theyfirst define the eney s rivtion (in the hoe of reventin

serious de) nd then reonize the eney s sin. (,

)

Sj , Eire: , ,


144/313


145/313


146/313


147/313

Seriizin Vioene

-. Y,

. I, ff : . H fi, , . T - , . S z . H, fi - . V, fi, .T H . I , reeted . A , , I fi R reor ofForery.32

R, , - H fi. C I K z - (Foundtions . ),H Nz z H ,

. R, H fi ff. I , z H - q - Nz .33 I, , Dz Nz fi H . A Dz, Nz , K, , ,


148/313

Seriizin Vioene

(Differene nd Reetition ).H -

K z (); , beyond. [ . . . ] T , , - , j (, ). I , , . I fi , , , fi -. F , , () fi ( , )? A

fi j - - - ( ) fi , q , , .

B H fi fi -

, , ffi . R, H - j . H j , H fi , ff . A : j,H , ff


149/313

Seriizin Vioene

, H

() . T H , U S, , , q j , , . H H A , fi . B , , T M W W B HH, : , , - , I , whether it is ever ubishedor not (D , ).34

N -

j. I rob-tiue ( ) ( , H fi ). B - (K ),

. I . H : fi -, , j, - W W II , , , .35 I, H -


150/313

Seriizin Vioene

(A) ( fi

q , , , fi ) E R. A Dz Nz :

E I - ( ) -

. R , .T , - S .R - . R- , - ; ff, ff, ff. S , ff, -

. R , , ff. (Differ-ene nd Reetition )

A [ . . . ] , [ . . . ] - (Dz, Differene nd Reeti-

tion ), R z. F fi R j- -, , j- .

T H , , R :Riey Under Ground(), Rieys Ge, Te Boy Who FoowedRiey (), Riey Under Wter() - Te ented Mr. Riey. S, , Riey Underround, -


151/313


152/313

Seriizin Vioene

q ff .

R , , ff H - . T , , , , .J E Aerin Psyho, Eire, Dz ( G-) , H , , q : - -.

W j Hfi ---

-- - H, j . T fi - in q j - ff

. I , fi M Te ented

Mr. Riey () ( ) fi ff H q j. I , , j , , j H . R, H -z E


153/313

Seriizin Vioene

. B H

z , A fi q j (fi) fi H . H-, j , q () - .

I , , q- (.., H E R Dz Nz R ), I -, fi -

tin.37

A MS, A j ? B, , S -, , z R D-N.


154/313


155/313

Beoin-Vioent, Beoin-DeNiro

[] A beieve ,

, , , , , (). I R I I - . I , - - . T - (.., ).

I q

( ), I -fi M F G Dz is , is , , , - , [] (). F fi - robtiue ff fi (j-) ( fi). I ,,

Documents

Abel - Violent Affect - Literature, Cinema, And Critique After Representation