Upload
others
View
1
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
���������� ��
���������
Department of Political Science
College of Social Sciences
National Taiwan University
Master Thesis
��� ������� �!"#$
A Study of Taiwan's Non-therapeutic
Medical Cosmetology Industrial Policy
% & '
Chun- Chen Huang
()*+:,-./�
Advisor� Ching-Peng Peng�Ph.D.
012� 1003 74
July52011
2
6 7��� �� �����������������������
�� �� ��� ����������������
�� ������� ��������������
�� ������� ���������������
�� �� �!"����������������#
�$ %&'()*+,��������������-�
��� ./)*01�� �� �������������-2
�� ./)*01 ����������������-2
�� 34�56789:;<�=�� �>?@ ��2�
��� AB56789:�;<CD�EFGH �����2�
�� AB56789:IJ�;<)D �������2�
�� KLM@56789:�;<CD ���������
�� NOPQFRSTU>VWQX�;<CDYZ[F\
]^_`aFbc?defg ����������h
��� ABKLM@56789:�3ijk ������#�
�� jk���l,�mn �����������#�
3
�� >o3ip�qrsjk������������t
�$� u� ����������������������t
�� �;C�������������������t
�� u��vp�������������������
wx./��������������������������-
y\X.zj����������������������-
{\|.zj�����������������������
} ~�������������������������-�
��rs�~���������������������-�
4
896:� � � ������ …………………………………………12
� � � ���� ……………………………………………… 14
� -�� F��6�f3i���,���………………………26
� -�- C��343i��qj�………………………………31
� -�t ����;��9:3i����………………………43
� 2�� rsfg…………………………………………………… 69
� 2�- NO�F��F�5MGH………………………………77
� 2�t ��rsq������ r�)?¡¢………………100
5
;<= >�
;<?#$@ABCD
£¤¥¦�§¨©�ª5M9:�;<�«¬®¯®°±²³´9:�µ
¶¯·©�5678%&�5M�b¸¹¬º»b%¼>?��U½WQ²56
78¾U9:q¿ZÀÁ¸ÂÃÄ�;<©�!ÅÆÇb£¤ÈÉÊË�ÌÍ�
ÎÏÐÑ�ÒÓÔÕ©fS�Ö×د٩ÚÛÈÜÝÞßÔÕ�àÅᮯ®
âãä�!Å©F�å×æçèéê��맩ìíî�o56Xï\PQ@�
ð!5ñ`�à�Uò5Mó¿©ôÛôõöë÷;<øù5M¾Uzj©Zú
»�J�5Mßû²÷F��o5ñ¿õl�øù@q5Müýþ�©�X�Z
5678XïÝ78Xï¿��G��� 1©��Çí�q�©FòÞ 5
678qò m����� (�.�©2009)2²
ZF��;<¯·©¸�.¿�©5678¾U9:¼«���©m��q
«�;<¬ô���÷�²�÷©� F�Uò��5M�©!"F�PQo#
$�� ¯·©ZAB%�¯�5M;<��©�«AB�&m�'Á;<56
78¾U9:�()²ÇbAB� 5MJ*+,\5Mò-./ê�0�q
�©1Á23PQ45�67ð829²:;³NO¾UPQ÷<©AB�mÁ
=)�¾U9:WQ�Á�>qð²
�34�«�9:;<?@X©5678AKB¼CD�9:¯;<©÷Æ
1 E�FG©HI×F 99��ÈÜ©åAJ?ÁAo\KL\MI\NO\]P\QRS 19R56Xï©TTåzlÁ5678XïÝ78Xï©�¾UD2X©�z�VWXYZ[\Ó�]�\5^bc©ú_7`\ab\�]S%&�5678Ó�]üý²2 ABÞ 5678�òcq¿Z®¯®W©�ì�òcd��o#$� Á&²£¤5M\ª�ef©ò�ghijú�©HI�3z�]ÈÜk?©AB 65lZ���mòc¬�Iòc� 10.63%©d�n (d�òc/o�òcqpjG)b 65.05%©�NOPQXq½S��©rsABtuv�m�wÀ²�÷©�X 1946�x 1965�qyz���½{�|}~�¦©tÆ�«ABwÀ¿Ûß�����mà©ÇÂ�m������©�X=�d��5678���Æ°±;<²w¢�ñ���� 9911��http://edm.itri.org.tw/enews/epaper/9911/d01.htm²
6
j���o9:;<?@X��>?��� (�¹�©2010)²��¯Ù©��3
ñ��o]�9:��3i����X©S�5M�������\ª�¾�U
9:µ¶©��á�Z·x56789:�343i��X�G> 3²
56789:© �ÆKLM@5678¾Uµ¶©�F�«�;<�¬¡
5Müý9:�!v¯¢C²³5M�=�&£¯·©56789:¤¬¥¦Î
k�5§&£©�bu¨üý:�5©ªª�9:²AB�¾U9:�9«��
%¼¬o©Z��®¯°±¯Ù©AB5Müý�°g8²ì´�NOðP3
SW³ð2²Ç©� F���´��q�©AB�mìÁ=)e�fðµ�
¶·¾þ9:©Aú»�F�¸¹)²
º��%�¯34%&�3i��X©5678¾�»¿9��R¼û¬
�½ x>1©�÷YS¾5M�b�¾¿@©m�ìÀ%&cÊ�&�Á
,3i¥Á¿Âò"�zj�"ÄÅ©f5Mñ¿l�ÆWÇê©�3i��
�¢È�ìôÉÊË©îÛ56789:�;<�©µµÇbÌW3i"�!Å
�ÍÎ÷Á¿ÏÐô«²�¾�#$� �©5678¾U9:µ¶�;<©
ÑT�Ò����"�NO�Ó�F%=Ae©Ô�ÆÕ®W³ ²ä�©A
B�%&cÊD2�3i�Á,�ÑTÖ×�J0Ø��Ù�ÚÛ©ÜîAB�
5678¾!Å��)ÝÁÞ"SF��ßÛà��=¢�©�NOc?FRá
âF�5M�cã�©AB�3i��!ÅÑT1ÆÁVä� 4²
å�¿�©��Æ"¾�#$� z;©� æçAB56789:�
3 �o]�9:èé5M��9:\��\ª9:\dPêë9:\.�ì¡9:\í�=î9:�ïðñ:Sãw¢�3ñ��o]�9: �oòó�9: ôo>Vüý:�ÈÉõ�http://www.ey.gov.tw/policy/7/index.html²�Âq�©�3ñS 2009 �¿úz��AB�ªö÷øù��!ú�ZÓ�æû��»«`�!ú�©¾�þ>V?@áÆ"ô����ü�AB56789:�;<©ý�þ´9:�=��o�©e÷ì��W��:�À©A�W���R9« ©?@���8w¢�3ñå�ÈÉõ �>o3iµ¶ ��;�8 �http://www.ey.gov.tw/ct.asp?xItem=53816&ctNode=2922&mp=1²4 2010 �]^_F�5M9« 16 �7�\aF 12 �\ � 9 �©�AB�1��ä�²º��F34"×F 97�õöe��5MüýF����?@�©�ù��qÁ 4400��©`]^_\aF34%G©ÈîÓò)���r��²w¢FR�ª5M9:ieÀ��5���q � 3 i " � c � � � A B ¸ � ú » F � 5 M 9 « �http://www.ibmi.org.tw/client/ForumDetail.php?DSCDOCTYPID=0lge2ef9mro52lmr&DSCDOCID=00blousbf1y3efq0²
7
;<AZKLM@5678¾Uµ¶bcq�©ì�"Êê�õ���>��©
}^��%&cÊD2¸����¢È3i���dV©³KLM@5678q
�b�ÊêÝõ�e����ç�©A"����Xúz%&�¢��3iv
p²
;E? #$6FBGH
�� ����
de�+�;<~�©56789:© �ÆKLM@5678¾�»©ô
�³9:;<ÝR9«÷<©�¼«�+ÌW³eFRX©áÆ34 ���
��U9:WQ²³AB5Mªª�;<¯Ù©AB�5MI鯷Á�ÅTþ
¾�©!³Æ5Mªª�"*¬xF���°±©�«ÁWR5Mñ¿(�#\
$�\%å¨\�o\&'\`(S)Í�7F JCI5ñ)*5©+oWáÍ�5
ñ)*,5M"*ieÀ�-G©ö=ç.�,�5MÓüý°±©�F�yß
Û%¼��)®²�½ÆßÚ�ùÈ%fHb�/©�Ö¯Ù©AB5M0ª¿
´®21?27FR�$jq�:�jq� 6²ä�©AB5M1Ál3³e\
4:0��5M56©ZÓüý7üSTþ¾� (89:©2009)²
56789:CbFR;<;<�ª9:¼X�>?#©fFR�J�
Rì�Á�>?@©Ç©�=Á>U!"�íe´9:WQ�;<©m�Æ�
þ«Û���p�²�÷©%HS?%FR�;<©AB�«�56789:m
5 JCIb Joint Commission International �@A©���³ÆZ7F5ñ)*�B±©¯)*7FZ��5ñ²¼�©��c?�-G�B©ÆC� JCI�-G©¯çG§D��Â"*`-G�Eå²JCI )*FG�nS 1998 �©Æ�+H�FG-G�7FF�5ñ)*FG©ZIØF�§òEå�5M��"*bîj©ÍJ)*KVáÆ7F�F�5M�84R©Z�ðrF\.LMNÓ��rs�!O©Pf5M"*Óüý¼=MQ)R©��ôjST²6 �¸UVWàXY\�1ZS5©ªª�ùÈ©AB�ßùB±1ôx7F�[jq�ã\]\\^Ý_`S5678!Å�ßùB±©ì1ôx7F��jq�²
8
�Åa �Ub$²³5MªªàÅ÷<©AB�5Mº¬;<x�,°±©�
?%FRì�cöde¼Xã³�ÈÈî¯Ù©AB�«�5MÈîº�1fg
h©�ÚÛ�3iÈîÑTv�ÛôÆij0�ã³��µk¯Ù©ABðlò
m©=nÀ9:R9«oÄú»�=)��ÁÇã³�JF�Pb#$¯Ù©
YS?%FR�3iÈî!Å�å)ÚÛ©ÇÂ�ÌWÅv�©?f�¹ÚR
9«�ú»ìôÆij8p²�S¾UÇê©AB�56789:ÑTì�;<
:�,���©q�1ÆÅa �Ub$�rs²
�¾�� q�©34¸�ØÈ�«tÁ�u�©IØAg�¼«567
89:�;<vyãw^��x&S56789:��©y;ZHbåd@\
WÅv�1�¯æç%&�9:3i©ìy;PfHb�J�3i��e�jk
��©ÇÂì�; E�zk34�þ56789:{|��² �Æ�}~
GH���Zì�R9«��KLM@5678�¾Uµ¶X©�È3i��
����ÚÛ¯b¼«;<��UÍ�e��Û©�¯%&D2²¸���3i
��Z�ú»Âþ9:q¸¹)��q�B©�b�.¿ç��c?!v²å
�¿�©�.����©��ô���©��J�b���þ�
1. v�=n����3i���B±�
æç34²´¸�PfÒþp���3i��©³²´³vn�Û����
�B±©¾Æ������²�."%&8���Â���©v�z�Û���
��3i����B±©ZCbq�jk56789:3i�������=Á
������²
2. �Z%&FR��56789:��©Cb�F�¯56789:3
i���|qvp�
��.e�����X©Á�U>V�SPf?%FR�;<�e�d
e�æç²56789:�«�ÌWFRXáÆ34�);<�9:WQq�©
Ç©de�ÓFR�;<�D©fS�F34�3i���îÈ�m�Á¿�
9
û©ìÇÂCb�F34�¯��%&56789:3i���vp 7²
3. b�F¼«56789:¿Åa�b$��z��
E�Y�.j�e��ç�©f�F56789:�;<Á������©
AVz�F�¾U;<��X¿Åa���²YS8���ý��%=u¨-=
��zH����u�©ÇÂ�.þ3i��8�¿v����B±©²ÈS5
6789:�jk�²�¥C�GH��jk©"%&FR;<��ô�Å
v¯^á�F�´WQ;<�=�²���E�úze����3ivp©À
34�%&3i����3i������©á=�Á¼ð��AB56789
:�«¿Åa�b$�rs²
�� ��
��c?ÆZ3i����� ¯æçAB56789:�;<©A+
þ�V<X�}~GH��KLM@5678¾Uµ¶²�<q©��c?¤
>�Æv��Û��3i���B±©AæçAB�«�56789:�;<�
Åa >Ub$�rs©�Y¾Û��3i���B±\Ú¨�ÓFR�Z�Z
�;<�©¯�x34�Z��ȾU3i��¯����²�<Z�q©
�.�����Iu¸��
������� ����������������������
�!"��#$%&'(�)*+
7 56789:�NOÌWFRXáB�b>V;<�9:©�XZ]^_\aF\[F�b;©ä� Æ¡e¢ö� ��XFo£²åd¾UFR�3i©�%&cÊD2WXÜ)S��5M:�êë:�¤:u¨©� �ø;<�Á¾��5MêëÛ¥��q�©�ú_ ÌW³:�À©Ë¦´FF��üý:²�XaF34�¬þ§ÎaF5ñF��5Müý°±�þ��bc?�¨�Cþ�q�²w¢�æå©�AB5Müý9:�F��Ó�<©�©ABüý:ªõ4�jk©http://www.twcsi.org.tw/columnpage/expert/e057.aspx²
10
Ç©�."3i���8���jk©ZÓq�fAB56789:;<
CD�de©w^�?%FR;<���Z�«Ú©��áÆb þ8���
ý�¢C%u ©�¬z�ÛÁ¼���B±© �E���������²
;I? #$JKB#$LM
�� ����
�.����ÆZ3i�����©æçABKLM@56789:�%
&3i©A�Z%&FR�56789:WQX�;<�©Z��AB�«�
´9:WQ¿Åa�b$�rs²�S¾��l,©ì�ZÙ©���q
®?��©³Æb�¯AB�56789:© �ÆKLM@5678¾�
»©úz�¨��3ivp©Z��¯�%&��!Åá=Á���;<²
�÷©�v��U�!P���X©E�����©c?ÆZ�Uo!
v¯v�©¾�Uo!vj�b���b�9:;<� �Nï���©��b
�=�¯O�ÚÛ�(c?æç��Vb%&D2�5J\�Ó�b�����
ÔÕ)©�� Æ¿°��;<�ÔÕ�(¡n3i9z\3iÁ,�!v�±²
�)R)²
��Uo!vè³�Uzj©�b�´9:;<�� ´¦�©n�Æ3i
¢C�#$©µè³W>��þ�Ƕ©�F�3L.�\�iW¬��}¯\
wÀ·��¨GZÓF�#$�¸¹áÁ�=��ÔÕ 8©�. ¤>SCD�
jkã�b´9:WQ;<����*©¾U�����n�Æ´9:�«¿'
Á�u�`º�b��»Á¼����*©-=Á,z��¨9:;<�3i²
8 HI Linder � Peters�dV©ÔÕ3i�����Ƕ©Á�z½Æ¿°��´¦Ç¶�©ì³Æè³3i}¯\3L.�\wÀj¾��S©áÀf3i�������ÔÕ²Âzj�dVì��E�¿úq�9:;<q� ´¦��Åv%=f�²w¢ Linder, S. & Peters, G.“Instrument of government: perceptions and con texts.” Journal of Public Policy , 9(1), pp. 35-38.
11
��Uo!v è³�Uc?zj©�b�%&cÊD2�wÀ5J��
��©¾Uµ¶j��Ucã©��b�9:;<���X©cÊD2¿���
Èî��e��Ú9©��Z8�b�FR�&¿=�©ì³ÆnÀFR�&%
f�SwÀ�Á(�qfn©¯ÂÚÈî`���B�3i�=) (ÃÄ�©
1995)ã�� b�Ó×y5J�%&FG�Å)©ÇbÆ�3i� FRcÊ
�&�Å)q�©ì��?Á×y5J�FG�Ç.©-=ßÛ�W�Èî¯<
X;<©÷9:3i�Ƹ©Æ�9:3i!�34�×y%=Ú¨©���
A�"x�,����¼ã�� Æ�Ó�b��ÔÕ�YSÔÕ9:;<�
Ƕ©� F�Ƕq�©Á¥È�ÓFR�;<e�©ìÀf�F�9:ɯ
�o�¸¹²Ç©���X©��Ó�b��¾Uzjn�c?³Æ?%T
UFR�56789:!Å�Cb©f�F�´9:�;<�ÀɯÊjÔÕ²
� ´¦����*¾�Uzj©���ËS3i���µ¶©ÇbÁ,3
i©�Ì���»Á¼�+,����*©�x%&�� ´¦©-=��z�
¼�3i!ú©ìÇ÷-=Ú9%²�3i��²:S%&cÊ�&�wÀ5J
���© GH�v��@�jk©Çb¼3i���,q�©Í��Á%Êc
Ê�&�¿=�wÀ5J�=)©-=Á¼��²��Æ�Ó�b��ÔÕ©f
SÌW9:¯Ù©�ÓFR�´9:WQ�;<e�Æ%¼>?�© �Æ��
PQy�FR©�9:;<�¸¹��Ëf0©Ç¾U�b��3iCb©³
�8pf�F�9:9�¸¹²
��Uo!v Æ¿°��;<�ÔÕ�©¾z½¦� ����jkq
�©fS3i9z\3i�����ZÓ3i!v�Á,�,ÀÁ�Î�dV�
·"²
�.ÏÆZ¾��J�3idb��©Pf�Uo!v�3i� \�
8qy�&ª@vn9:3i)R�B±©wHI¾�Uo!v���¯zkA
B�«�KLM@56789:3i��!Å���©Aý�b�¯��È�%
&3iú_vp²
12
�.������¸��©�¾U�X©�i���³å¨x���Uo
!v©ì³Æ9:;<q� ´¦�3i����*©AÚ¨3i��ô�¾*
¯æç²¾U����©��²´wå¨x�%&cÊ�&�¿=ZÓwÀ5J
�=)©A+^�F�y�Ó�b�f�F%&3i�=���¸¹©�x3i
�����@©Ð�z����@�3i²�� Æ�;<�ÔÕ�3i��
X©x�3i9z\3i!vS��u�©wå¨ç�z�7�3ivpZÓ�
¯����;<!v²
¼�©�W§�3i#$X©E�-b¾�Uo!v�!ź�Æ%=Ñn
�©��,ÒÂqyÀ9�ô����ÔÕ²ì³ÆÙ©¾�Uo!vÀ���
Ó#�¢C¯O©1?�X�Uo!vÁ¿I§Ý��©³�,Àf�Ó�U
!v��Ò���¸¹©¸¹�u��=Æ��ì�=Æô��²�»Á�¾
W§%=ÔÕ�#$X©9:3i�;<-Á�=e�z�Û��¨¼¹;<
#$�¢C¯O²
E�l,������¸��
Èܯî�E�ø��8 ���������
9:;<� �Nï���c?Æ´9:�«�AB�;<C�©ZÓ��z�c?���b$²
=�¯O�ÚÛ�c?Æ%&cÊD2�5J���©ZÓ�Ó�b��ÔÕ(ý�YGHjk\��rs¯��C��åÖ)²
;<ÔÕ�c?�Sjkq�Á&3i9z\3iÁ,�!v�±²�)R�u�ãA×�=ðHI¾U��¯�xABKLM@56789:�¯�;<!v²
13
�� �� �
�mn������q�©��³�Z³�z����e���²�
���q��Æ?PfAB�56789:© �<X�KLM@5678¾U
zj©úz�¼�3ivp²�0�¾U������X©E�-b�Z"Ì
WjÇ�ç�Åv¯æç�U9:�;<e���X���²
!³©��³de�x��«AB56789:�Ø���U>?Cg©�
=bÊjAB'Á¾já�5M�)©÷5678�Æ�ZÀAB5M�ª9:
ì���9«�WQ©�%HS?%FR�°±;<©AB�¾!Å����Ñ
TÝÁÞ"xÙ��°±²
Þ�¯©HIE�f¾U;<e��>?Cg�de©e�fðúz��
¿?&Ú���ã�<q©E�®?���ÆAB�56789:©�KLM@
5678¾Uzj©�«�;<�Åa>Ub$©fS�¯�=�;<¯Ù©A
B1=ÛÜÝ>U�À�ì³ÆÙ©?;<¾þ9:©34²´�¼ðÐ�>U
3i�
�¾q�© Æ���� �jk�!O²�8��àÅ©E����Æ
3i����� ©¾�� q¿Z=nÞ¨��´?©ÆÇb��
��Æ?"ßJ3i���¯jkAB�56789:©¿Z34�%&D2¸
�àC3i��©e÷Áz�Û���3i!ú©fS��áx���
B¯Ù©��Æ%¼ü¨�²� Îk3i���8�� q�©E�ìâì]
3i�����©¯Ú¨�J9:;<�æç©�ZÂßÛ�WÅv��ã²
� �8�àÅm,c?��� q�©��Ó�!"����©E�
ìPf��´?�� GH�¼�C"²³¾UÅv¯Ù©¾Uzj Æè³
./jk\GH�S>?�àC�þ²
�e�8�æç�%&�./jk\GH��©Pf5678¾U9:�
;<©��8²�ZßÛ�U1f0��Zg©"¾UZgäåzx©�3i�
14
��àC�©ì̳�Z"8��%&jk���Xmn����±��x�
V²
Þ�¯©E�"�%&4:òæ�rsX©æçAB�«�KLM@567
89:Á¤��%&�TU>?p�©¾Up�q¿Z>?©ÆÇbµ�&£x
ABKLM@56789:�¯�;<ã�¥ìç©=n�Y�4:òæ (èé
34�z\5M:��4R�·" )���rs©"ô��1�¯·�J;<�
b$���©e÷b�*�3i#$è�z�UGH=n°±;<��i�±©
��zÁ¼+���3ivp²
�J����éw¢���
CDde�AB'Á¾já�5M�)©÷KLM@�5678�Æ�ZÀAB5M�ª9:ì���9«�WQ©�%HS?%FR�°±;<©Z�«�;<CD¯·©AB�¾!Å����ÑTÝÁÞ"xÙ��°±²
úz���34²¸�Ð��¨KLM@56789:�3
i©Z��´9:�«¿Åa���Aíe�¯�;<�
15
������� Èܯî�E�ø��8
c?Z3i��\ì]3i��b��
"./jk\GH����¯jk9:;<CD�b$
8��¬ ÈÜjk
"_èÅ\´êÅ�#$Å�UÅv¯�x²
��z´9:WQ�¯Á¼+���3ivp
Y��rsü��KLM@56789:%&�TU>?p�
16
;N? #$OPBQR
�� ����
YS���8ë©ÁÌW«Û��c�©�¾U�c�ìí�µkÆ%
¼âî�©Ç©!Z�����¯x�©����,ZÒUÅvbü�jk
�&ïV©¸Â�¯-=f�c�ÁH���æç���©÷¾³Æ���
� �>?@²
¿°�� ©ðn��fS�fg (ñ¸3LCg)��©xòÆ"
>�à½bz;V\¤óV\�0ô©xe�de\õö\j��jk²YS¤
óV�ô�(Ó�� �ô� )©³�Á�F�q%Ú¨�)*©Cbjk�
�©AZ�X�UNï)*CbÂ�� q'÷ (�øù©1999)²
�.c?ç��µ¶<X�34%&�ßJ3i��©>V�S34¿Á,
�3i!vZÓ¢C3i�!O©÷¿°�3i©Ïb34�&b��ÒþßJ
��Ý9hÒþßØ´ê�,CbÝôCb©ZÓ¸�Cb�%&Ë� (ú,©
2003)²Ç©�.��Z3i����� ¯ü�ç�ABKLM@567
89:�;<©"_èÅ\#$Å�´êž�ô��Åv©¯ç���xA
BKLM@56789:�;<²
�÷©� 3i����� q�©�.ìâÈ =n01Gfô�./
�GH�� (comparative Historical Approach)©¾z½c?Ƥ>��F�Ó
F�;<�!Å�f��GH©C�¾�GH�©���Z;CNO�Ó
>VFR�5678¾U9:X¿�Ú�ÈîZÓ¢C�;<¯O²
56789:�ÌW³eFRXáÆnB@�9:©���Z"�F�5M
°±©·z¾UFR�5M���ýàC���)²E��¾û¿e��GH
�©c?ÆZNOTU>VFRbc©�¸]^_\aF²¾UFR�5M9
17
:�;<�q¿Z>?©ÆÇb³Ò���¯Ù©¾TUFR�F)áfá
o²�Âq�©¾TUFRìüå)Èî;<5M9:²
w"ä�UÅv¯·©�¾U9:X©¸�?Á¿;<©FR�Ú�ÈîW
ýÆ%¼>?�©¸�ÝÁFR%&zÀ�cÊ�&�Ç.©PÆ�þ×y5J
�FG�)�©ij¾U9:Æ�"�e;<�²¾ì³ÆbÊjw�ÓF�;
<�À¸Â>?©Çb¾TUFR�5M9:áà;©Ý½½��K��q
X©��ø�34®�ÀÁàW3i��ÚÛ{|©Ó��;<��ÚÛ��
�Á�wx�6�q®«©���âÈGH�� ¯��æç²
��©�3i��!Å�ç�X©E�^� Rothwell� Zegveld¿úz��ì
]3i�(Innovation Policy)��©È¯�g��c���� ¢È��ô
h²Rothwell � Zegveld(1981)þ\ª3i�9:3i��¨÷b¿°��ì]
3i�©«�ðÆ�:"©;Ë�©�� Æ�:e��"��²È
(�C�\ ��©2005)²
�«�F34þ56789:õS�ª9:¾Uoµ¶X©E�-b©�ª
9:�%&3i©ø�ìèé\ª;�zj©ZÓ9:;<�zj©Ç¸�
¾�¬�x©Rothwell� Zegveld¿ú�ì]3i)*=n�E�Y¾�
��x�x34�%&3i����¢È©ø�Á�Sf�c�Á�e�f�
Ûܲ
�� ����
�m,�ü��Åv�dVq�©�J��³��C��!"�¢È
¯e�²�!"��� �ô�qô©�S�!"n�ÆÈÜ�<�ÈÜ
ô8�!O²
�����ÆæçABKLM@56789:�;<©AZ3i��bc
?�� ¯ü�©YS�3i���GHÓF;<�!Å´?ô8o��È
18
Ü�%&����©ÇÂE�âÈ��!"©1Æ<X�*@��!"¾
Uzj©HôxÃ����!"²
E����XâÈ�c?�!"¸��
(�) ./jk"
./jk�>?�³Æî��=n��%&�WQXâî��AßÛ
�W%&���²Cooper -b./�ÂÁ��?@©Ónz\6��*Æ�
÷¯�©ÇÂfS�x��( ©ö�b��v�q©��?�L©A�Â�
��ÓWQ��fS�ø�%�Ý%Ñ���Á�;C©>U8�Be�fä
å©ZÓfSCÁ%&��Á�ôh (Cooper, 1989ã��7©1999ã���©2008)²
Ç©E��e�����X©��=ðf�«AB�56789:;<
%&�./e����w�©ä�©!F�%&��Á&S56789:�ç�
.�©¸����E���Á¿%&©E�ì��=wxA��²
�J¯Ù©E�"TUc?�o!v¯e�%&./��<©q�w��=
ð³�zÁ�û�zje�æç²!v¸��
1. !�����3i!ú?@!�
¾z½c?Æw��56789:;<%&�TU34cÊD2©�¸H�
"\Rz\�ñS©ý�"�ß�3i!ú?@Ý`Z!XßÛ�È
�Èܲ
2. ×y%&FG�5J�����
� !�¢Cq�©�9:�;<�©×y%&FG�5J¿���Èî
ì%¼>?²�¾UzjE�Á"TU>?�FGü�©�¸w5"òFR
�ª5MieÀ\#5"ò 21�$��ÀS²
3. %&�6ª�.�
ABÁÌW6%��¿©&�á9zÌW�5678¾Uc�%&��
19
.©Ç©E�ì"¾Uzj¤0©�<�Uf���Á¿�û�6ª�
.²
4. ��\õ'��Ó%&ÈÜ�
&S9:;<�zj©F��áÁÌW¤'���()%&�p�.�ã�
Âq�©õ'�ÈîìÆE��e��¥ô�ÝÖ��UÈܯî�þ©
c?ÆÇbC�ÁÌWÈÜÓ���áÆdÞ�%&�õ'�;Ýß
�©Ç¾z½ßÚ�Èî�©m�ô8�*²
(�) ��rs"
���rs�³ÆPf¾,��¿e��ÅfÅc��Kc�S%=+Í�
!O©ZßÛ r�fSÒþUúÝCg��\��Ócd·"(,.-\.
/O©1999ã�01©2007)²��c�%&�4:òæe�rs©Æ�<
�ÈÜä�U%¼Á¼�!O²HI�c�e���rs©��Æ2©C�r
s���©;C�U�ý¢C��>?Ƕ©ZÓ���&ÝÁÚ¡x�3
V²¾UǶ�3VAôÆC��Å�de�ÒÍ�r�³�ZßÛ�©��
�©������%&òæ\��Æ��ý���c�Á¿%&�4:òæ
�fs©¯�`&�U>?ǶfS�c��¡��®«b�²
Ç©�Ó¾�8Yv�©�¥ìÇb��c?ÆZAB56789:
�;<bc©ÇÂE��rsfg©"�9:;<%&�WQ¯Ð�©èéßz
4�3iê,%&�4:òæ©ZÓ5+XK�Á�&Ú56789:;<��
�4:5^²
YS¥y���E5�Çê©5��67v�E�e���rs�4:òæ
ÁZ�T2©Zßz4(34%&D2)�8z4(c?Æ5+)¯�j�
1. ßz4�4:òæ�
(1) �3ñ3ýKV9:��9:�3K�«;<F�5M4P�3i�
20
�©fSF�5M4P���\5M9:�,2Á�4:�dV²
(2) �3ñH�"5©ô8Ë=\K�56789:�;<�%&:ý`"
�Çê��H�"��iÁ¤%¼���&ª@©ÇÂ�8Ë=\K�
rs=ÀE�f3i�����ãÁ������²
2. 8z4�4:òæ�
(1) >?æûÊ8J´@©KA�B5^�A5^bAB�'��d4R©
�5678¾UWQCD¬E©fS´9:�;<�Á�Ñx�¢�²
(2) NnFo�]78<5��KGHI5^�NnFo�]<5K�w^
�JÀ���KÙ©bAB57�]ªªLI©�Çw^JKÙ5
�MP©õö�XFo£vn5M78��'�©YSK�w����
�N�57¨�©G5^�="9:;<��=@�Ç꯷�U9:
���²ìÆ×F�p�AB!Oõ�£PøY��!;5QrÓêó
�:+;<ò²
(3) X:×F785656ÀMR8©K,S!K�TU5^�Z&b78
5656ÀS!K�&½©�5^�=YkV�¨���¯·�U56
789:�;<©�fE���Á%¼o��û²
(4) ABdP5M;<À8©K�WX5^��WX5^&bdP5M
À8©K©Ü)S��5678�dP5M�u¨©fS5M789:
�;<ìÁÑx�·"²
21
;S? TUVWXYZ[
�� ���������������� !
&S¿°��5M�b�©�«�F�%&�"Y�µ�AÝÁdÞ+�m
�,�©qS5M"�5^"¿�µ��.X©Z, �U&S5M�bq�
�[(èéóM\LM\õè\]�óW!¨éS )�%&©þ²
�÷©H�"Çb53Ê8��´?©^�ì£Îð� ÌW%&�_
s©³�5M�b�` Hb�m�,�©GH�a���Ï�5M�b£bZ
LM\ctÝÙdòJe§\fg\hÖb��©¿b�óe\óWÓLMãÝ
�Sóe\óWu�©ZLMb��©¿b�ô!\È\\|ªÝô9S�b�
åzÝ�z�I÷�9²
Ç©Z�«cÊ�&q%&�i_idq©¿°��5M�b�²£nb
Zj�@q�bÝóe\óWÓLMq�b©kB-,b5M�b²cÊ�&þ
�5M�b�qµk,��¸ÂâîqÇ©ô�T£�S53Ê8ÓçlÞ
5ñóLÝüýqòq5MEåb��©÷þ�5M�b��,�©YZµl�
�µ¶¶ob�â�q5M�b�(�.�©2009)²
:S¿°��5678�©��m�,��=b�©�«�F�%&���
"�X�ìÝÁGHk��Ù"ã�÷©³��È�"�µ¶¯ç�©!m�
H�"� 83021752 n_��i¯·©�����,³H�"�n�÷<©m�
Æþ¿°��5678�ö��5M�b�X©��¿nÀ��KLM@56
78��¸Â10²ì³ÆÙ©ÀÓÔÕÝI§òJu���8�=��b©á
9 ?ÁH"5o� 107880n_\� 8251156n_\� 83031201n_\� 84032858n_\� 85038723n_\� 85042155n_ZÓ� 0910062996n_²10 H�"S×F 83� 4p 27�H"5o� 83021752n_��iX©�� 1?ÀÓÔÕÝI§òJu�Ó�8�=q�b©¸\]\\^\7q\�óZ……SkôÛY78:�bq©Ï�Y5M��bq²
22
��Y5M��bq©A+�%&"r�,©Y�Á5^ȯq5©òV¯��²
å�¿�©�F�«�"��Êê�Åv©34%&D2ÍÆüvþ�56
78��%&�bö��5M�b���µWQX©¾ì�ZÙ��F5©D2
��sn�©ì³Æ³×�=ðþÁ5M¡�ÝCÈ��bö��5M�b��
µ¶©Zt�µÊ8ã^�©¸Á´?�u©�v��w�wÀ$D`×Ø�Ë
��´?©þ�U��Z���!OxZ5�²
�<q©5678£nY5^dÞ��©ÝÆ�5^ns����78LM
�b²�Îk78ô��Æ©5678��m,�Á�8@M¼ã÷+��?¥
È©�Ze�j�@�LM0β³�F%&"��-,©�¸�Ð�yz�©
o¸�{�ó|�\�7q}Z�\�~��8�S©áÆ"Y�Á¿ÇêA��Ê
ê�5M�b(Ã��©2003)11²
�� "�#�����$"�#����� !
¿°��KLM@5678�©£nb9hUòcd�fS7�q´ê©÷
C�0ª\5�Ó\�S!O©e�I§ÝIØKÇ�)Ƕ (¸¡�©�Ýe
§)¿��qòJ�d���\][Ó7dSq5M�bã+�òJ�d���\
][Ó7dAôÀÔÕ&J�FG�tJ¢C (�.�©2009)²
Ç©³Z��,�¯·©��o��Zþ�KLM@5678�jbZ�
����
(�) j�@�56780ª�
Â��£nÇ&J�d�"9hUòc&�q´ê©÷��ÈZj�@
�56780ª¯I§Á��d©�¸\^\\]\7qS²
11 �÷©³ÒU�z��jÍÀ��Uú¿e����÷Á¿��©�¸H"5o� 8101863n_Ï�i�78^"©��\�ó�Ó�y�&�q�&ôË5M�bã�S��\�ó�Ó�&q�©�SÚb�z��]SòJ%&z2©îq��©²Ë5M�b�ãH"5o� 986000n_ �i�bòLM��\_]\\^\{�óZ\�z���gS�b©hË5M�b�²
23
(�) Kj�@0ªq�Ó5678�
Â��n�ÆK0ª!O÷�x9hUò��d�q´ê�5M�
b©¸ab7`\��\|â����\��¶S²YSÂ��q56
78���0ª�Xe�©ÇÂTT¿Á5678�5M��kÁú_
%&�üý²
÷¿°��LM@5678�n� Æ&Jdz�Ý��Ƕ¿��qFG
���� ÷ÔÕ¡ tJ¢CÝ�¢=Á¿£ Ý��òJ�d�qÖ¤©÷
��C�0ª\\�Ó�80�©þ�ctÝô8î�¥¦tJq�8¢=Ý�
d²
��¯Ù©�LM@5678�èé§]�¨¦\dz�Ý�)Ƕ¿��
q&JÒUz2�>v\©FG f�ô8ZÓÇLMe§¿bq5M�b÷�
�qª«��Ψ¦S(�.�©2009)²
å�¿�©�KLM@5678�º�ìBè³�â���5M�b�µ¶
�©��¿e����Aô�LM@©¬ÆZC�ô�!O¯I§òJ�d�
q��\][�7d��b²ä�©Þ �KLM@5678�qò©Ó���
Ö§D�ô�qô©�SÓ��&J³�8�÷<AÝÁÆ�e§\�þ¡ �
¢Cì�tJ©ÇÂAô®ÒU5M�b¾j�c¯@©³fÝÁnÏe�KL
M@5678�%&�b©ìôÀÔÕ¼©ò&J¡ �tJ¢C²
Â�©�KLM@5678��%&�b©ô8�WXôƼ©ò�e§©
ÇÂfS¼©ò¿°±�ôm,@¯Ù©%HS�Öe§�LM©²÷³���
÷<ÆGH��²ì³ÆÙ©âÚ�KLM@5678��b�¼©ò©fSø
�¿Þ �5M�bu�Æ�ZÙ��©¾U¼©ò���ìà�m©³?ç©
=9hø�cd��´ê²
24
;E= �\XY]^B@AJK
;<? �\XY]^
���e����X©³�J������÷<©./�ÂÆ%¼>?�
�z½²./�¾U��q¿Z>?©ÆÇb���c����³À�Åv
ÆKJW�+âî�ã"&�Uô���z;¯æç���./©fSE���
�%&��¥©á�ÁKJ>?�wx®«²
���c�Æç�AB56789:�;<©A+þ�V<X�KLM@
5678¾Uzj²ä�©YS�.c?ÆâÚ3i���GH�S%&��
!O©�¢E�Æþ>V¤>S3iÅv©ì³Æ�F34%&D2�3i!Å
���\àC©ZÓ¢È3i���u�²��©³Æ�x��+Á¼�3i�
�Ó3i���=Á>U²
����æç�c�%&�./q«©1Á�z½ìÆ����?³x�x
�©YS��âÈ3i����� ©ÇÂ�UÁ&3i���´./�
�©���ìÆE���?³�Â�æç�²w�©YS�5678����
Æ�UGH]��9:©��0��,��©E�ì-b��³q«�./`�
0��01©Zgj�����Ö5M�b�ô�²
Ç©HI��c��æçµk©³./��Â�0�¾z½¯Ù©��
���å¨wx�«F��fS5678%&p��ç�©;�./�cJ�b
34�zÀ�%&D2©ì�b×y5J�FG©¼�ì�ZÆUò²��¨�
Â./���X©E�;C44Z3i��\3i�����¯ç�ABKLM
@5678¾þ9:�./ÆKJ;�ãZ56789:bc�./¼�àW©
�Æü��1�WXÆâÚGHâî�� ©ì³ÆÙ©¾U./WXÆZ�J
;<bç�©Ý�Æ<X�ÒU�5678%&�ªª@àÅ�²ä�©&S5
25
6789:��µÊêàÅ©ozj%&�./ìá<X�"YàÅ©y;Z3
ibc©`�0�@�æç��²
��ÈÜ��<��µq�©��oÜ�Zþ�Â�./j�Z��Uo
�©Ó3i��8��%&./\�5678�bq,�%&./©ZÓ�56
789:q;<Åv%&�./²&SGH�z�¶���8©E���Å�ç
�X·ý`�H0��Ѹ©A·ýÙ�E��e�./�Â��X¿e���
xjk²
�� %&'()*�+,%&*-���./
(�) 3i���¡ì
��ÂÁ&3i���ì]3i���%&./q«©��Á�?³Pf
�3i���¾U)*e����+,²
�3i���ìJ���3���\�ßJ3i���34?@�SÈ�¹u
��ö©�y��¤ÍÁºe�f¼�²!³©�3i�����34?@�º
á�ȯ�3i�B��J�ê©���Aô=��Sn²34?@ÆPf�
B\Èî�FGS`¾,�²Èã÷3i�� H34?@���Ö@©�ÈS
ô��?@X(·.»©1991)²
�½©�3i���ì��ßJ3i�ì²�Á¿Pj©�ßJ3i��ìí
µk²´Hâ©b3i�B\3i��\3i��S�´�Ë��I÷²÷3i
��1Æ�X�U#ã�3i������3����)*ì²Á¿ô�©�
3��Æ34�&�z¼��3Cb�C"©Æ¸ßý½ \Ê8ê�SkË
q©�b34�&¿îÈ©C�ßL)Z��ßJ3i©���î´�&=��
0�Æýã÷3i�� Æ|ÈSB�5J����&©ç¾=fwÀ9�¼�
�0�(.°¿©1999)²
26
÷Pf3i��¾U'(¿l,�)*©�x¬ÁÌW6�ý�b��,
�©�YS&26�¿¤>�Åvô�©ZÜS�«À�Ák��Ù" (,Á©
2004)²YS)*��ôÃ%�©ÇÂE�³þF��>?6�c?úÄ�)*
¡ìC�Å?��8©Z�f´þ�� Á�������
� 2-1 F��6�f3i���,���
úÄ6� ���8
Hood 3i��b34�v�WF¨Ó�
UƦq�©�Yl,Ê8��x�
�B���(Hood, 1986)²
Elmore 3i��Æ�FLI@�0���©È
¬�¿áq�B(Elmore, 1987)²
Linder & Peters 3i��¡n34b �3i�
B©¿îÈ�ô�!"©�µk"yÞ
�!"¸ËøÇÙ\C�Ȭ©xHb
dÞq34ú_üýS!" (Linder &
Peters, 1989)²
Schneider & Ingram 3i��ÆY3il?���²Âô¿
°q3il?ÆÈô���b¯O�
�ßJ��©ÝÆßÛ3i�B
(Schneider & Ingram, 1997)²
Vedung ßJ3i��Æ�Fb34¿îÈ�
ªª©ÈZmçÇ.\��\ÝÙdw
À§É(Vedung, 1998)²
27
Salamon 3i��³ÆßJ�����©µÆY
FG��xÞ8ßJ���<J�b
(Salamon, 2002)²
Hughes 3i��Æ�Ñ��ê\ê��!
O©÷�¾�ê�©34ÆZ¨8�
!O��(Hughes, 2003)²
|=Ê 3i��Ïb3i���� Z�
3i�BÝ9�3i¼��0��*
(|=Ê©1998)²
ËÌÊ\ÍÎa 3i��b3il?�3i��qy
�¹Ù©ìÆ�þ�´k�x��
b\�þÁ�����(ËÌÊ\ÍÎ
a©2003)²
ú, 3i��134�&b��3iZ
�3i�B©�ZøY��²Èq�
ªª\!"Ý�ê�I÷©ÏÏþ3i
�Bë���J3i��¿îÈ��
�Ý�ê(ú,©2006)²
Èܯî�E�w�%&./��
e�f¯·©�F�./X©3i��JZ�policy instruments�Ý�policy
tools�¾�U'(b¦�©:SF�./©ÁU6�ÆZ34��ÝL8��S
'(n÷©�¡n34b�¾¿�3i�B©Z�kLLb��©¿â���
F3i0�©�c?CÈÆþ3i�B�J�©ZCÁ�Èîb«ú©þ3ié
Æ��©34¢È3i��dÞÝyÞÑ�×y:;<Ë�²«�j_èÅ�
´êÅ©_èÅè³#3ÇÐ(¸�Ñ\�È�ì:È�)\ò)(¸ò-ÒÓ\.
28
/S)ÓªªÇÐ(¸ªª¼¬\���ªªëÔÝÈÉüýS )ã´êÅèéì
���(¸34âÕ\Ö×;èS)ÓØÙ��(¸Z,B±\Jp¦8S)²÷3
4yÞÑ��zj© Pjb\ª;<���l| (înßJvlÓ��wÀ�
��üý{|)\ÔÙì]¡Ú�¬�ì]��ê@3iS (·/Û©2000)²
Â�©Y������Û�©3i��¹u�³Æ34�Cb��Á,�3
i�B©�<q©3i��³Æ34�|3ܼ¿îÈ�0�²Ç©Z�
�c�¯Ù©���Æ?æçAB56789:�;<©¸�^�3i���
�� ©³Æb ¼�34�´þ9:µ¶�;<WQX©�«t�àCX�3
i��Á>U©�¯�Á>U���3i���¨=¢È²
(�) ì]3i�¡ì
Rothwell � Zegveld(1981)þ\ª3i�9:3i��¨÷b¿°��ì]
3i�©«�ðÆ�:"©;Ë�©�� Æ�:e��"��²È
(�C�\ ��©2005)²
ì]3i�ï��Sì]�b³À]�ã\];��ì�\9"l?\ýÝ\
�9\�Ù\���S�´�Ë�©]�Þß�&£�=�õ¦©:����
ê�ÔÙ�"©ì]©÷34 C���9:+Ó\ª+�=�ªà©�È3i
íe���ì]©we÷ÔÕR;<(�C�©2000)²
:S\ª3i�9:3i�=´¸�Pj© ���þ\ª]�:9:Ë�
Pj��U�����\6�\²È\6�\²Èªª;<\ªª�È�\
ªª������Ë�©6�oá-b«��ËS\ª3i�µ¶©H>1��
�©¬Õ®C�ì]ªªbc©���JZ�.;�!Oßõã���ËS
9:3iWQ©H>1²È�©ZÚ¨��õ;¸¹)�"bc©���µ
µ?ç;(á⸩2007)²
���.���Úv©c?<X�34PfKLM@56789:�%&�
29
�©ÇÂc?ÆZ9:3i�Åvbç��>V²�÷©9:3i�¡ì�=b
��â��9:3i£n34Á&9:��ü3iqI` (ãä©1993)²Z�F
vÀ�n�¯·©�-b9:3iÆîn34¢È�#3\��\JpS3
i��©dÞ\yÞÑ�9:Ë�©Z¬�9:;<Óu���qk÷©¸34
Ñ�9:;<q3i�� (G!Ù�å&æS)³ÆËS�9:3i��#�(v
À©2000)²Ç©������Zþ9:3i�,�õö¸���b9:3i
���Seê¾,qR;<Ý9:;<�B©AK1���U¾,���ã�
b9:3iAô5�©ÏKç¦���ê�¢C©���>1Z���êZ��
!O¯Ñ�9:�R�;< (ú�:©1998)²
�«�F34þ56789:õS�ª9:¾Uoµ¶X©E�-b©�ª
9:�%&3i©ø�ìèé\ª;�zj©ZÓ9:;<�zjã¼�©Z
�.��c�¯Ù©ç��µ¶þ<X�34�9:3i\9:;<���%
&Ú9�©Ç©¸�¾�¬�x©Rothwell� Zegveld¿ú�ì]3i)*©
¸�Y¾���x�x34�%&3i����¢È©ø�Á�SE�f�
c�=Á�e�f�Ûܲ
3i��Æ34Ñ�9:\ª;<��J0�©�<q©3i���¢È©
f9:\ª��J;<¿É¯�ÔÕÆåÅ@�©"�Ì�;\xõ;�<¥
�ì]\õK��´ê���S©3i��áÁ�o�ÔÕ²Rothwell �
Zegveld(1981)þ3iÅv����@©j�_èÅ\´êÅZÓ#$Å�o�©
Z�bÅD)�(á⸩2007)�
1. _èÅv�3i���èé#ýÇÐ�3i�� (��\�È\}~
@È�)ãò)ÇÐ�3i��(èÓ\./)㪪ÇÐ�3i��(ß
é©:\�;<FG\ÈÉüý)²
2. ´êÅv�3i���èéì�´ê�3i�� (¨×�\âÕ)ã
ØÙ���3i��(ªªB±\Jp¦8)²
3. #$Åv�3i���èévn9:��u��3i�� (ßJü
30
ý)ãÔÙì]¡Ú�3i�� (êæuë\4�\ìí)ã¬�ì]
��ê@3i��(R�ê3i\ªªÊê3iJpÊê3i\�
ÈÊê3i)²
å¨ Rothwell� Zegveld�dV©ì]3i"_èÅ\´êÅ�#$Å�U
Åv¯æç34³¾,9:÷<¿àCq3i���0���¼©fS�FR9
:;<XBõS�ª9:;<µ¶�56789:÷<©E�-bm�ì="¾
�U¾,+�J�Åv¯de%&3i��fÂ9:;<¿���ÔÕ²
(�) 3i���ì]3i���%&./
�f3i���)*Á������©��³�Ze�f�ÂZ3i��8
�bc�%&./©E�c?�deÅvÆý�"�U´�ßJ3i./X©
ý�³�3i��%&�./e��²�÷©�x6+fSßJ3i��©
¸� Salamon¿<©c?áÆ�I¿eê�3i�B©jkU�3i!úÝ�J
3i!ú�ܼ©���y;Z3i��Cb��Nï (.°¿©1999)²�d
.ÎxGH¡%©-£ÎÁ6���3i����²
åd�3i��%&�./©�F�6�!Å©B. G. Peters(1984)-b�W
d8��`�îd8��kô�¨ÈS3i���jk�©Ç÷Óc·âÚÑS
��qy��l?8��¯jk3iãR. F. Elmore(1987)�� f��3i��
���ï,©Ó��²È�À9����ãS. H. Linder & B. G. Peters(1989)-b
3i�����©À x�i�Uò�� (perception)�ÔÕ©÷¾U���]
�©�Æ x�¹ð´¦Ç¶�ÔÕ²
A. Schneider & H. Ingram(1990)Pf$�3i��(LI�\ÈÇ�\=)�\
gñÓÇÙ�ZÓ6�� )e��ãM. Howlett(1991)Ѹ �3i���
�� ©èéÈî� \¹ÎÉ� \3il?� ©&U� k+, �UÔ
Õ3i�����&ï§ ãM. Howlett & M. Ramesh(1993)æç 3i���
31
����©úz�3i6���)*f3i�����ÔÕ©��úz 3i�
��6�¯�ãB. G. Peters & F. K. M. van Nispen (1998)© ³�3i��%&�
�þp�e� �� æçãL. M. Salamon(2002) Ææç�]L8´µ�©Á
>U���_îÈ©Af&�3i��e����ç�©õuz&þ���¼
�\¼ò\ßt@\��@�t¼@SB±��Ë@²
�F��zj©6�ó��(1998)\.°¿(1999)ZÓÍÎa(2000)©k�
ZßJ3ibc��è\!X©Pf3i���¡ì\j�\��Ó¼�C �
��Ѹ²|=Ê(1999) á�3i���¢È©fS3i��¯Ù©Æ%¼&
ï�Ƕ©Ç³3i���)*e� Ìf�æç²:Sôõæ�.!Å©Z
3i��bc�÷öA��.%�¯¬KJ;©ozj���Íþ3i��
¼C��� ©Ú¨ÒU�c�¯e����æç²
Þ�¯©&S3i��qj��./©ÌW6��¢�áô�©
Henekom(1987)þ3i��jbn"\üý�÷\ñæ�Ùü¾�ô��[ã
Schneider � Ingram(1990) þ3i��jbLI@ (authorities)\ÈÇ@
(incentives)\=)v�(capacities building)\gñ@(symbolic and hortarory)�6�
@(learning)$�ãWeimer� Vining(1999) þ�jb���ê\�Ñ�êæ\l
,� \Y��Z��êú_-Ý�ú_ç~çlãHowlett � Ramesh(1995)
�IøÚ��þ��jbøÚ@�� (voluntary instruments)\áê@��
(compulsory instruments)�ø¨@��(mixed instruments)¾�²
Â�©Salamon � Lund Æ�8 �ù�q6��·"©þ���ðe�
j�©î���=��34¿îÈ��ü3i��©�j�õö��8¸���
� 2-2 C��343i��qj�
úÄ� 3i���8
32
Mosher(1980) ��\ß�È�\�ú\�úçG\Êê\Ö×\dÞü
ý\X !FG
Bryson(1983) ßJ��\34yÖ×\4÷��\ûÈü\�Ñ\±ç\
Êê\æßÈÇ\Ö×ÝÕýüý\¾ÌL
Chelf(1981) Çz\��\þ�\�ú\",ê�\ø�Êê\0F�
�G\�æ\üýÖ×\34¿ÁL�¢C\§Î��F\
-G\��\¾ÌL²
MacRae(1980) dÞ��¨pY�Ñ\Êê\���áê\dÞ��¨pY
æß\�9�"Î�\3i§�\üýÎ�²
Salamon(1980) ��ê�\�ò�Ñ\�ú\�úçG\±ç\RÊê\
wÀÊê\æßÇz\34ß�²
Herzlinger(1979) ��\dÞÇéUò\�úèÝ��\�úçG\±ç\
`Ý��Z,Ö×\34üý²
Weaver(1980) �Ñ\�ú\�úçG\Êê\æßÈÇ\Ö×�è\F
Á:\ns?@\â��\34��²
Rivlin(1977) ò)üý�ª��\ßûj\è¾�üý�ûÈü\
wÀç~\Ê��C�¨p�ê�§¨²
Èܯî�Salamon & Lund(1989)
:SF�6��3i��j��ç��©ËÌÊ�ÍÎa(2003) ZF�6
����b��©e�f�� ô�����©èé���RÈÇ\ç~?
@\ø�Êê\ñßùÈ��æ\èÓÈÉ ��ÎÏÐJ\,���ü"��
D\��N;\Ì�Gê�\B±l,\ô�\0F\��Sã¾z½�ç�Æ
%¼0��©�Çbô�WQÁô��È�3i�[©ÇÂ34��m�=n8
��3i����¤©-=e�f������3i��¯àC²
33
� ��¾UÁ&3i����8�¢È�)*./q� ©E�-b
Rothwell� Zegveld¿úz��ì]3i�(Innovation Policy)��©ìÌ�Z�
g��c���� ¢È��ôh²
&Sì]3i�%&./Ӳȩ���(1986)-bì]3iÆ34Ñ�9
:\ª;<��J0�ã ��(2000) -bªª3i\\63i\\ª3i\
9:3i�ì]3iS$3i�Á,©�B³�S�,�¨;<qªª©�q
Z3i��¯�9:e�ªªqõ;²
w�©!"]�´6ùZ�����Ê���úzì]3i©34GHJÈ
�3i��oÜèéú_êæÈÇÝdÞ��À:�e�ì]\vn��9L�
ç�ê�\�n����ì]\lnßJ���dÞe�ì];ZÓú�ß
J;��õËSU�;ì]��G>S²Metcalfe� Georghiou(1998)�HI
¾U��úzO)©�-b����Ê��8���©�mú_ %¼��8Y
À34Ñ��íeì]�¾þp�©�Æ��"ú_�m�3i��¬�Ý\!
(prescriptions)èx3iêZ�wx²
Ediquist � Chaminade(2006)Pf�xì]´k%&./Ó�fSì]´k
�de©"ì]´k����8z �U��ò��&ïË� (Jôì]´
k)©�U��j�bì]�������\´ê²Ç¶\ì]%&FG��ê
ZÓì]:¿´�üýS²
ä�©Metcalfe� Georghiou(1998)ìþÔÕì]�b�CÓ3i���Z�
����©Pjb�ÔÕ!v���
1. Èî(resource)�YSÖ×Èî(c?ÆÈ�)÷�"<õ©�ÖÆ;�
�6ª�©Ý�Æ�H�wÀ�û�:;ã
2. ÈÇ(incentives)�\ª�iJ´Ý���ê�"ú_hn�ÈÇ©h
ZÀ´kXÁ)��b;�©�¸96¨CXfSè��»S)*ã
3. =�(capabilities)�YSFGXÖ×ÒU=)Ý=�©hZe�ÒU
ì]��¿´��b©�¸Ö×F�1�ݹuZtSþì]��
34
�<:F��Aã
4. �À(opportunities)�ú_e�ì]��ÀÓfSßJ\ª;��
;�¼û��A²
Y¾�Uo!v©34��Èô���V¯;<3i��©èéÇÐ��
�\�ì�J��È\ÈÉú_�&£�Ñ\vnõ¦&£\ßJâÕ\´k
@3i\ÊêS(.��©2006)²
�� �������0!1���./
YS�5678�ËSGH]�;<�WQ©ÇÂF��«³5678�b
�,�©���AÝÁk��)*Ù�©Ç©E���¾z½./���X©
JÀÇb5678�b��Ö5M�b���÷Á¿� ©¾z½c?ÆÇb�
��FcÊ�&(ÏH�")f�5M�b��,�©�.��c��KLM@
�5678����ÆB-,b¿°��5M�b�12©÷¾�,�-�©�
��À�"�Ó3i����ÄÅ�!�©��ào�¾¤²
���c��AB�56789:%&©ÇÂE�-bÁ�?³³�56
78�¾U'(�)*e�Hb�m�,�²ådF�%&�./©Ì"#(2006)
-b5678$¹1Æ�%÷©�C¦56�j\X©A�Ñnq�5678
\�©÷²£n�¬Z9hê5�qcd7�b¬v©�ÈC�56q��\
ªª\\�\H&S¿|��5M�b�ãá'((2006)-b¿°��78��
jb�5M@78�Ó�K5M@78�©«�Ïb��c�¿°��567
8�©ì³ÆnC�0ª\\�Ó�8S0�©ZI§òJ�zq�[\��\
7dS©Z�áòJ��7�bc?��q¨¦`w�78²
)*#(2006)-b5678£nZæûqòbfg©å¨¢È�\�\Z[\
+\^\ó\ï8Ó78�]�\S\XÁ&78zj�ªª©b��J�4412 ��H�",ô���p�ô[�HË5o�,�-��[$�n_q�i©�-,1?ÀÓÔÕÝI§òJu�Ó�8�=S�b©¸\]\\^\7q\�óZ……SkôÛY78:�bq©Ï�Y5M��bq²
35
78ªª©Z9h�ÖtJòfø&]J�07@´êq5M�bãÃ��(2003)
-b5678£nY5^dÞ��©ÝÆ�5^ns����78LM�b©
�Îk78ô��Æ©5678��m,�Á�8@�M¼©÷+��?�¥
È©�Ze�j�@�LM0Îã�.�(2009)-b¿°�5678£nb9h
ã.&J�¡ ÓFG¢=¢CtJqò©³cd�fS7�q´ê©÷C�0
ª\5�Ó\�S!O©e�I§ÝIØòJ�d���\][Ó7dSq5M
�b²
³���,�¯·©�«F�Pf5678¾Uc���©WXÍþ56
78¾U'(�)*,��UòÇbcd�fS7��´ê©÷�Y0ª\5M
¡&Ó\��!O©¯I§ÝIØòJ�d����\][�7dSÅv�5M
�b²
2� �����3405678���./
¾z½�./�ZÙÆE��e�./�Â���XHb¤>�Åv©«�
o�./��©���Æ�E������l,���X©=n³8��
¤�zjÁ¿8�©ZËÈ%&�� ��ì²�÷©³���c�¯Ù©
�56789:;<%&�./1ÆGH>?�©.þ¾�o��./jbTU
ô��½Áj�©Zõö�8ô����de�
1. 9:;<Åv
&S�9:;<Åv%&�./©HIE��01©�«�34%&3i?
@���X©WXþ56789:¾Uµ¶ö��ª9:�/�>V;<WQ¯
ç�ãì³ÆÙ©�«F�34%&D2����Ó3i!ú©y;ÁZ56
78¾�4þbc�¯e�ç��æç�²� 34D2¿ú_�ÈÜZ�©3
4z4K0�Ó��&ÝUòe�c�����©ì1�Áwx®«²ä
36
�©F�c?o6�ßJH��¿\5ýÊ8�¿S%&��´¿©fS
5678¾Uc�:¹ì� ÌW>?��C"©�ábE�����X
=n�Z�wx�>?./²
�3ñAB�ªö÷øù��!ú (2009) Ù�5678��ª5\�5M
¡&9:X¿�����©¤óS�5678%&q�¡l3\5M&ÜS9:
�ªªÅv��ì]©�¥ìx� 5M��\6ª���%&�ª5MÝ�:
�¨C;ã,23\Ë45(2010) Z5M¡&Óæû��üý���ü�©
æçAB56789:�ªª\®«6jkZÓ��9:C�©APf�B��
úz¨����ü�i�vp©ä�ì¾�PfXFo£56789:�;<e
�æç©�xAB�56789:?¸���N���X�x,2²
�¹�(2009) Z�F�ª5M9:�;<b� ©æç5678¾�þK
�?Ý7ù@�5Mªª©�Z�e;<�dV©¯)RAB56789:�í
e9:;<��e8Øæû��=@�Çêã·ë9(2008) c?ÆZAB78
564:�;<b�©¯jk4:�Ó4:y�¸`&£�i���©�¥ì�
� 56789:�;<:;ãÃ��(2003)Zßn5ñøù5Müý���¯
ü�ç�5678�%&p�©æçå×æç�IÙf�|�ÔÕf5M���
é#$��¸¹©e÷ÔÕx5M9:�;<ã<3.Sò(2010)"å��ª
9:�;<)D©��ç�x�F�«�ª9:�;<CD©�¥ì�� �F
�ª9:�;<3i�;<i�\%&3i����¼Ó;<<©²
�J÷<©�9:;<Åv%&�./©Â'��ÏÆç�5678¾þ9
:�«�;<C�ZÓ��=v©� %&�3i��q�©fSAB5678
9:�u��º�©ì%¼�Áwx®«²�¾U./X©���Z·zAB�
��³5678¾U9:�;<÷<©��ÁÌWò"ô����¯ü�©�
Èô���� ¯e����æç²56789:�b�F�ª9:µ¶X�
nB@9:©ÌW��ìôWúx¾U9:�Zì��R9«KJ�©³9
:;<¯·©¾m�ìÆ��²´&Ú��V²
37
2. "�ÊêÅv
�ç�56789:;<���X©ôÛôç��³ÆÁ&"�Êê�¾U
zj²º�³9:Åv�dV¯·©�Ä"��ÊêfS�J9:�ú»ìÌÀ
Áu�©�÷YS�5678�µ¶X©Á�Uªª��¢È��5M�b�
¤©ÇÂ34�%&D2fÂ�=³Àl,ÒUÇê²� "Y!Å©�567
8%&�c�©�J¢�³Æ5Mâ��5M�Ù�Êê©YS5678¾þ5
Müý�¾¿@©�â���Ù�JÀ�ò>?©¿Z�Êê�³��@^S
¯ÛA²Ç©�ç�56789:;<¾Uc����X©Á&"�\ÊêÅ
v�./©Í��w��x©Z�=Ûx�0����²
�.�(2008)Z"Y�dVb��©)�KLM@5678�ש"Y!Å
�&£©�"Ö×�dV©¯æçKLM@5678�b��Ö5M�b��
¤©Ae��ýB���ã�tC(2002)"56D8�dVz;©æç�Ù�
¦�5ýD8�¸E©A+"�5©"Y�(Law & Medicine)�àůæç5M
"�©A��5Mâ��5MD8�F�²
�G(2002)Y5Mâ��1�ü�©ç�â��H"çlqy�&£©�
-b�F�5Mâ�%¼IJ©�"��Êê!Å©ì²´Á��z�Ki�C
"ã �W(2005)æç 5Mñ¿¢È�:0""©�ÙÝâ�Æ!L¼©AZ
./�Â�!O©j�Pf%&5M�Ù�â�q./ÓÊê!Å��µe�æ
ç©���<oAMðP�56Xï�.§ÈÜ©³��8e�jk©ìxe
7F JCAHO5ñ)*B±Xf5M�Ù�â��D8�µ²
"���./�8¯·©���ZÛ�Z56789:bc���©Á�
z½m�¤>�"�Êê�æç©Z"YbdVz;�./ÉW©¾z½WX�
³%&"Y��8e�Ki©A��æç�ýB���ì²ä�©"56D8d
Vz;æç5M�Ù\5Mâ��./ìô;©¾ÆÇb5678¾Uc�J
38
�5M�Ù\5Mâ���8u¨��ö©Ç¾z½�./m�ìÆE��
���X��?Ú¡x�Åv²
3. GH��Åv
&SGH��Åv�%&./©³��c�¯Ù©¼«ABÍÀ�Á�
�PfNOTU>VFR�56789:e��@�GH�²HIE��d
e©�GH�¾Uzj©�«AB%&./ç��W�³Æ<X�F�5M\
dP5M¾Uzj©TTÁ,�Z��./áÆZç�F�5M\dP5Mb
cã³���;<�D¯·©NOÌWFR�«��â�¸¹�©ì³ÆF�5
M�dP5M�;<²¾ÆÇb¾�U9:µ¶³ÌW³eFR¯Ù©áÆÁ;
<()�9:©�å���ÔÕ�©!®ú»FR�=¢�©;<F�5M\d
P5M6fÆ�U%¼Á¼�i�²�÷©56789:¼�ìè³�F�5M
�;<µ¶X©ÇÂ&S�F�5M¾Uc�%&�./©fSE�¯ÙÍ�Á
%¼qwx®«²
�3ñ�æû��»«`�!ú?@!�(2009)Ù� 5M��9:¸¹)
�jk\5M��9:�;<µ¶\5M9:;<��ocã�,��%&3i
!ú©ä�ìæç Ù�¼û©�X�>?�ÆÙ� 5678�5M��üý
�dP:X���©NÙ5678üýµF���;<²�3ñ�AB5Müý
F����?@�(2010)�� �F34��5MüýF��� \Ù��Ü
¼nB�)R�±©ìPf��5MüýF���CD�Åa�Ð{e� ç
�©æç�F��5MüýF����B��Óe�uº�� SWOT jk©�
¥ìç��;<�rs�b$²
�Oþ(2009)âÈUú��!O©Z�P�¿�â�dP5M3ib>
V©Y��rs�!O©e��z@�*�jk©Aõöz�P�;<dP5
M�®«Å\��Å\Ç.Å���i�ãQ�R(2002)PfNOTU>VFR©
39
èé��\AB\[F\XF�]^_e��ª9:;<�)G©� ��¾T
UFR��ª9:�;<CD���i�q�©ìGH �F��ÓNOFR�
;<i����!O��¤�qôãSTU(2009)ZaFû×5ñ�éb�
Uú©æç �NOØ���}V�©�UNOFR�8n5ñTTôwÁ§
DP©SÆ1�ä�Ó�©�¥ìõì F�dP5M]�Å�;<��©A
+ç� TU&SAB;<F�5M\dP5M�>?��©ÏABÆ!�3;
<5Mêë�¸¹)©ZÓNO�ÓFR�¾!Å�u��¾�©Ó�fAB9
��¸¹�ÔÕ²
Y¾z½�./�Â��©���Z��x©56789:¸¹�ÌWFR
X©¬B�b;<F�5M�>V9:²�¾U./X©���Z·x�F3
4�¾�µ¶X®?cöde�Å)©��¸�©C�F�5M¯ì�5678
9:�R9«©m�ìƼ«��=n;<��Uz;V²Ç©&S%&F
R��F�5M\�ª9:�3i��©ZÓPfÒUFR�ðP34qdP5
M\êë5Me�ç���þ�©³���c�¯·©Í�Á%¼�wx®
«²
å¨Z�E�¿�8q�56789:;<qÅv%&��o�./¯
·©�x&S56789:��©WXÆZ9:;<�dV©ÝZ"�Êê�
�V¯z;©:SGH���!Å©E�¿=ÚÛ�%&./ìôƾ�W©
�01./���X©E��y;;CZ3i��� bü���¯ç��%&
./²Ç©º���<ÈÜ���XÀÁ¿b6©�ÆE�-b"3i���
��¯æç56789:�;<©m�ìÆ�01AB56789:;<�]
1�ãE�ç©=W�S�Pf´9:CDjk�����©Xvö�%&
FR�56789:WQ¿���3i©¢È3i��¾þ�� ¯01AB
¼«56789:�;<©jk�«9:¿Åa�rs�b$©Z`b�¯��
3i��*wx²
40
;E?�_B����� `aF
bC@ABcd�
�\%9:;����3456%&�<=#
HI M. E. Porter�·"©FRÆ:����¸¹u�©ÇbFR=ì�
A.Î:�¸¹�LãFRô�ÔÕ:¿`�i�©ìÆì�AäÎ�9�
ªª;<�Nï©YÂ�Z��Æ�9:3i�YZá¡[¤FR�À�©÷Æ
�34fR©ý��{©á6\ÀfÈî�Ú9ÝKÚ9�ÔÕ²�÷©Robert
Reich Æ-b©¿°�9:3i©�ç�x34 ��w�©Aô¡[¤Æ3
4�¿ôx�ØÙ©�ô�s?Z34�n¬¯¦ç���É]©÷Æ��Z«
^@�·",Á��@�3i©¯£;Èî�ô¼Ú9©;�9:�F�¸¹)
(.vF©1991ãá⸩2007)²
Y���ô��dV¯·©FR©Ý�ÆÙ34fS9:;<�==!�
��Uå�å=���©¾�V=Áº¹p©FR34ÑT�Ò���©Í�
"0åÚ¦���)�²ijfS9:;<¯Ù©FR34xò²´?¸�;�
Ç.�íe¸¹)�ÔÕ_�
&S9:;<��XFR (34)¿²´�����©��ÁàW6ùáúz
ô��·"²¼�©"¤��;<¯·©�;�Wç��Æ�:;<!Å�3
i©9:3i��¼û)R\���Ê�34Ñ�\ßJ��8�Ý3LR6
���\o`�:ç�8�\]�´6ù�%&jkS©oJáÆ"�:;<�
��X�;z¯qPfFRCb�OB�ç�²
娾U6ù�·"©oÜ�Zj��GHo�!v©�bÇ.34Ñ�
ØÙ©�b²f34Ñ�9:3i�;<©á�øY���u®@²¾Xy��
���©oܳÆ���Ê�34�Ê��VÚ9²�÷©ÏtFRÑ�9:;
41
<ìÌÀÁ�;²¼���=@©���©fSÌW9:�;<e�¯Ù©Ò
���1Æ´?FR�¼�Ñ�©-Á�=9��o��¼û²
ab.(2003)-b�eFR?ec³eFR©��?Z9:3iS��¯i
�9:;<i�©Z�Ñ�ìdAÈ�!OÒ~o`�:©e~�F:©�Ã
6�³eªª©¸Â-Á�=�¸¹�ûÔf\³e�e�g�û¶o�hD�
�fºÁ©ë�Aú»�F�GH�û©!�ZîR.Î;<©�9)ÛZe
f²�9:;<�34�Ñ�fS3i������âÈ©JÀ xÓF�Ô
Õ©�FÒÂyìÀ9�%=6��¯O©��r���³Æ{����Ri
j©JÂ��F¸%¯k¿°���é¯O²
Wade(1990)-bAB�{��;<��X©FRô1|�¢=@(functional)
�ßJ3i©�>?�Æf�U�B9: (target industries)e�%¼���ØÙ©
÷¾UØÙÆ��@�©l²¼¥���hD©ÇÂÓúz�Ê8��8��©
�XÓ�I34%fS8z4qW¬Ýe£�29 ©úz leadership �
followership qPj©�¥�W¬�DX©á)ØÙ�Ó÷qb big leadership©
Ó-b�AB;<��X©¾hDW+>?©£¤\ª;<©AB�xZX�
:bcJ�9:u�£¤�\ª9:�mò�K)Yn);<9:ë�bÈ
��ªª;<9:(.o�©2001)©�Ué][;<YÝ�:Eh:üý:©
9:;<¾�ìÇ÷¡vå���ì];<²
�.��c�ÆAB�KLM@56789:©KLM@5678¾�
»©ÆBè³�â��56789:µ¶X©Ç©¸�?"3iůç�©�
p�Ì�î�©��ÍÆ��?Pf56789:�J�;<3i¯æç²¼
�©³3i���÷<©Æ�9:�,ÆÁ(��;<�=@©34-ÁÑ�Ø
Ù�8Y²³56789:�;<÷<©Ò���© 9:m�ì��KqX©
�¥ì�¨SAB9:�;<� ²
w"��z���¯·©56789:ìfÆ��5MWQX�üý:©
KLM@�5678 �¸Â©ÇbKLM@5678£n9hUòcd�fS
42
7��´ê©÷C�ô��5M!O¯I§òJ�d����\][�7d©�
¥ôI§òJ�zjFG�tJ¢C²ìYSÀÓ�µkàâ©ÇÂfS567
89:�;<¯Ù©KLM@5678��Æà>?��»²
"K�;<���¯·©¸�þ56781bFR�J��þ9:©ijF
R(34)�¾;<��X¿������,KJ>?²º�Æ�9:�;<á´
?WÅv�Ú¨©ì³Æ� FR(34)�Ç.�©1?ÌW×y5J�:+�
J�Å)©�FR(34)Í�ÁÔÕ����>qð²�34�9:;<?@
X©56789:�G>�=ÁW�©¾jÚ�u�³�Z·z56789:�
¯�;<xòqd�!²Ç©FR(34)�3i���������©fS5
6789:��J;<¯Ù©�Áro�ÔÕ)²
�� %9>?����3456�)@
HI�ñPf�����«^å�R=�Ó34�������
�©��sAB��F�����º�ô�©�����¥�È9£ ÁÇ©�
zc� ��©�27FR#s@°¬Üec´êo£�hD�©fAB�zc
��¸¹©V�zAB�9:\Jpu���tu@ãÇ©34�m²´C�
ì]��ã¯����©Z�AB9:u��»Áë� (�æå©2010)²
OECD(2009)��nz©��XK�R�K���èéZ��Uo!
v���bC�:Rïv���¯á�ì]ã��b�ÈS�ì¡���vl13\NÙ R&D14\í��È15Óú»ò)¶*S16²
13 OECD FRzÔR�!úW w�SIØFR���vl©C�¨�\�x\ßJ¢y\��\5M��l3\6%èÓ�È\5ñ\=îEåÓC¦�� ICT��vlS²14 R&DÓì]Æ OECDFRzÔR!úX�u³��©èé;ìÙ\¾¿�WQ�{|� R&D��vl��È\zÔ8z4�;�È\X�:ÇÐ>�Ó;³:S²15 ¾z½èé�zR\=R\í�¢y\õ�Ó{|°îú_Sãä�ìèéá�]=î\EWQ©:u¨Ó��i����²16 !Ø OECD FRþèÓ\./�Zì�]��C�Àö�¦}!ú�Nï?@ãä�Áô;{| ÈS�X�:Ýá�:Rïv²
43
�NOFRX©��\[F�����¸¹�©áÁ�ø<X;<�9:©
ZIØF�R;<��D©HI~��(2009)�jk©�¯�Ff]=î\
=ªª��>1©5M��Ó¤:u¨�CgþÀ®¯®�rã�¥©ZXSß
�bc?7ù��¯õ;u*g®9"©ZÓzcW��þ�bc�²����
w¢��(~��©2009)�
� 2-3 ����;��9:3i����
AB CD,EF�GE056
AB HDIJ��KLM4�56NO�P4QR
AB SDTU�5VWX&YZ[
�\=î?@\�Ä��\�)Î�Ó=î�þ@\N=�Ó;<
�È5M\FRæû��©ý
ì]ªªú÷\��ªª\�gèÓ\�g5M\f���\ª£æ
]^õ��zÉj©õ;Ã�=\���S
;<;<dPêë\æûKiwÀ\g�5M��8üý
;ZXSß�àbc?7ù8J�]9"
_\
;<í�ªª9:©¸Ã�=��\�����ÜS
;<å�æû��©5Müý\5M�&FR-GêS
�� ´k\��Ý\�5M\��ò²ÈSã�ªªÓ�����©úz�¤�;<i�
`aÃ�P�\��� ��\��\=£z¨Í��
��c�Oêë��\5678`¡ Ô~�5MdP
��\ªãzc9"W��\"��\&着ÚÛ
Èܯî��ñ IEKXï
Y���¢©³������;<e�¯·©AB�9:u�Á�U>]�
��Åv©³Æá�5M��©:�;<©A�¤:u¨²÷����%&p�
X©��c�O�êë��\5678�¡ Ô~�5MdP©¾UáBö�X
44
K��;<��X²¾U�V��.��c�t�ô�÷¨©KLM@�56
78t�Æ%&5Müý:\5M�dP¤:u¨�>Vþ�²YÂ��©56
789:�mÆAB]�¦9:X%¼>?��#©¿Z34�Ò���©�
m²´��ðÑ�A+;�L8;<�=)©Z�=����µk�x�7�
��²
Ç©¸�D³5678¾þ9:�;<¯Ù©���ìÆ��?�å�
R;<���%=���©�¯34��²¸���©ZÇÂ#$�§¨_�³
��#$¯·©AB�«�PQR����¬>],2©ECFA�øYJp
,(FTA)���©ABìÌÁ�À��+R�A��å�ÝPQJ\ª�
45²³¾z½¯·©34��>]w�]�9:©56789:¬B�F3
4���o]�9:�;<þ�X©Çb]�9:�;<&£xÃWÅv�=�
�ÚÛ©ÇÂEzÀ\EWQ��©+,;<���u³��©^áEzÀ\
X�\ð!�Uà½�=��+Í©A+>1:+�´ê\&Úô��vWQ�
ªàS©áÆ34��?Ú¡�ð!²
ä�©³56789:© �ÆKLM@56789:¯Ù©���¬¡
vüý:���!O;<©Ç©34�¾�V�³��Ú¡x¸�þKLM@
56789:¼��üý:¯��©¡vo��\F���\ª�²5678
9:�ì]\»Á�ë�©Ò���fSAB�R;<ìÁ%¼>?�Ô
ղǩ¾þ9:¿´?���vl³§Û¾�>?©èé"�ÄÅ\7ù�
�b�Í��\%&ÈÜ��v�©34á��Zì]�dV¯��²
45
;I= ������� F
`aefBg�hi
;<?������� jkF`aXf
%�¯©FòYSR=)��Ë°±ú»©fSIØø&�Ö�]J�¡
Úìo��^©ÇÂ5678���¬�; ��¬o���²�÷©567
8�Îk56�LM���ÆÁj��©ìÇÂ����56789:¥©�
,ì?Zô����¯d·²
w�©!³��#$¯ç�©�F�æçê�ø 91� 7ö³õöÅa#ý
b$©��I�Ùfº��êæçÇz����\�`#ýb$©�Í�; Ì
W5M#$u����(� ¡©2004)²¼9:#$;�§�¥©FGu��
é!v¼�ìÀ£q맲%$\��¯5Mñ¿¢¢õöl9øù5Müýþ
�©®Æøù78üý©ÝÆ%1abcLS©���c?ìÆbê#ýgv\
��£Îé(Ã��©2002)²
Ç©æçøùþ��;<m�ìf�F�56789:�� ¤¥¦©e
÷ú» 9:�&�;<²Z[78\78�]ZÓ%�¯%¼���î�]
S©|�¾ULM�78���ó¿Á¸§�>¨Ö.n©ì��I§ �U5
678���][²
º��.��c�ÆKLM@�56789:©�t�KLM@�567
8B³é�5678��Jµ¶X©ÇÂ��Á��³³�J�56789:C
�Hb)é@�æç©Þ¤wPfKLM@5678�%&�zjþe����
��
46
�� `a����34�56AB
���AB56789:�;<CDq«©��Á�?³��AB5678
9:�;<��²!"IJ#$�¯·�u©ZRÅ÷�©YS5Mçæ`
R;<Á¤;ü�¹�&£©�Ö÷<©¼F׿ۮ�¥©ò×f5Mçæ�
´ê³À®W©Ç£¤F׿Û�^©×Øf5Mçæ�7�?êÓ7ùì³
À�¤ú»²©¸ï86R Maslow ¿úz��´êà½��V17©ò�?³9
h�8ÓEå�´ê©-Áª)eêH�à½�´ê²YSC¦×cøYFR�
R°±Ò«uSZµ©ò�Á=)eêøTÓø��C�´ê©Æ�eê�7�
��)ìø��^©�bc���()*#©2006)²AB¼�ìƸ©£¤F
׿Û�ú»©³RÅv¯·©%HSZ«©Fò�mÁ�W�ª¬=nþ0
��È���5678¾Uµ¶²
³ê�ů·©ABYS�|å×æç©îÛAB�5M�� x%¼o�
ÔÕ©�¥ÇbI�Ùfê����©�5Mñ¿rôZå���Óú�éßb
�B©÷¡vPf]���z]9" 18²�¾�� �©;<z �TDz
qË©!³³Æe�78��;<5678Ý®�5678%&�ç¯"©w
�³Æ �µøùþ��5M��e�õ;©¸æû0F\Z[78\78�]
S©�X5678¾Uµ¶YSP8+,©^�}~H�\ß�7©óM�8Y
�x��]�\©x%T�����°�[\�zƸP\Úb±²`\³´
°S©%HS�x�é¯O©5678�Ò����Ù¬I§ 5MJ´�
J�¢C!O²
17 Maslowþï8´êjb$o�©Y�÷�j�b��8�´ê\Eå�´ê\µ�¶Ë�´ê\øT�´ê`ø��C�´ê²�-b¾U´ê1ÁH�à´êB9hq�©-Á�=µ���àxe�²18 ¿°�I�ÙfÇéê��£nç~ò�5Müýú_�©³¾,µk�5Müýþ�q�zÝ�J©Ù³Z�!OZ,�¯��¥y��5MùÈI�©Zmçç~#ýßÇgvq5MùÈÙéê�²�l?�ö��ÏbêùÈÇz©�ê��|�©5M5J��J�;öAê5MùÈ�K�<Æ©ç©�Y5Mñ¿y�¨C�5+øcÊ8Ó�·ê×�ê©£;ç~òfñ¿È\�LMSüýþ���A��²
47
³wÀ.�ů·©µ7ø�Æò��@©q«YSFòï[Hb罩f
S5678�LMþ�µµ©÷�f©��27FR©×Øb eê7÷ê�S
56784R�h]%¼Ò«²�÷©£¤ABwÀ}¸�õ�©�«=nÞ
5678M��ò¬®¯®W©e÷ìf56789:���,�ÔÕ²
b ?�G�Å�Ù"©��³"F��k? I¯·©HIF�78�]
�\56À(International Society of Aesthetic Plastic Surgery, ISAPS)�k?19©å
� 57U´FG�ÀVFX©2004�Þ 5678�7ù�Iò ©5'«['
�j�b7F\¹|º\»H¼\|½¾\"FÓ¿|©AB 5'�ô$©%
HS¾UòcØW�oF©Iòc %fH;�AB©��å�5678���
�Áò©�=�x«�jq�á©YÂ�¢©F�=nÞ 5678LMþ��
òc��KJW©ì�·zF�56789:;<�°± 20²
��³\ªÅ¯æç©YS��\ª`5Mªª��]p¤©ìÇ÷É�5
678�;<©A+î5678§Û�Eå\�t�©ìHZ«�gp%ò©�
¸å¨¢È��\ª\���6\v\6`�Ç\À�SWÁ²\ªªª©
�z��Â[��¶©fV|L©Á¼��Â[���§VÓÖ¤©e÷x5
678�¢¼©¾U��\ª�;<©áÀ56789:�¥Ãe\�]p¤²
Z5Mªª�ú»e�¯·©�F56789:�¯�;<öV�¤�ep
: 1992 ��F�Äö��°�[}~©¼¥%&�\�5^õöú_Z78b
���5Müý(Å��©2009)²Þ¤�¯©2002�7F Allerganß�¿�z�
�����¶�ÆM�©õöÀ5678uv9:��;<²AB�¾ôT�y
��\ª!Å�ef©±²`\³´°\�KÇ�\÷Çab\�¿}Z\Æ
¸P\ab��SªªôWð�]�ú»©ìÇ÷É�5678uvä�U;<
19 ISAPS���¢=Æú_å�78�]5^ÀVZ�%&�É]©&S�d\ÐJ;���\�Ö@�Ê8`oØ�èÓ?@²20 È Ü ¯ î � ISAPS Statistics: comparisons 2002 -2003-2004.http://www.isaps.org/Stats2004CompRes.asp
48
��È21²
�Å����8c?Æ"56789:�IJ#$¯jk©ZRÅ\ê�
Å\wÀ.�Å�\ªÅ�;<¯U�æçã�÷©¸�"9:�&�;<��
¯·©å¨õö%&���©AB56789:�«�é¢C��;<��o
)�ZY�ÅTUÅv¯d· (ÉÊ�©2010)�
(�) î�]¬�r6�YSAB¤� 1993 �ò³¬fÆtOe�d
òF��m�wÀ(d�òc�Iòc� 7.03%)©ÙR� 2025 �
¥©ABd�òcÀ�K: 16.5%²� Irsz¯�É]ÆAB
��m��Æ�Ç�©�X5678�Æ%¼>?�µ¶²HIÌ
W4R6�Ó:+òæ�de©AB�5678��j�å�;
<���T%�Ü©ì³Æî�]�êóò Göe�Îk�]�
ò ?¯Û�W©YSî�]78�¾�ÆÝÁ�rfc\¥¦�
Ë�HÌ\®2¨8©GöÎk�]èòj�@\ôø�\ôÍü\
®2�� g©�pB�ÖòÞ ²
(�) 5Müý:¢ö��5M&£�©56789:¬¥¦Îk5§�
�ê5�&£©ë÷Züý:bJ\5©ªªbÈ�5Müý:©
Zµ�òó¿�!O¬ôw�¨C¹���´ê©²÷³À�WC
���Ê8\�3Ê8\i�Ê8©56789:�¬e�:�
éÊ8�]$+²
(�) e�������«AB785656À�ÀV(�ò ¬Õ��
Îò©Z[\56ÀÀVÁ,pWò©÷�]�\56À Á$p
'ÀVã5678\î�]%&�5Mñ¿¸�§�>¨½zC©
YSo�¸¹�(¸#5S)ì%�e���©ÇÂ56789:õ
öZÚ>�:�:Üb�B¬v©dÞÔÕx5M"*�LM¼
�©î56789:�_è���¬ÏÏðoS´ê©ì¡[e21 w¢Rzªªô9:��üý?@õ' IT ISòõ�http://www.itis.org.tw/²
49
� ¸¹Ôf�����²
(�) �"�jÐ�oÄ@Ì�5678��"(�M�ݪª)�«¿
=ã.��jÐ�á�oÄ@ÌX©�¸ô�«ab�5M¡�ì
Ì�ZLM¿Á�Z[e§©�÷�«¬�;<xPfô�§V÷
Áô�¿K�ab©W���"º�Á�S�J9:��K©�
���ì8p�SÑ®¸¹©fS56789:�é�¯Ù©�
��Åa���#$Æ@rÒÓ� 22²
�� ����WX�bc
HI%&����¬©"�Åvde�F5678����9«©µko
)�]AÔ 50 ��: 1250 ��Z�ôS(Ã��©2003©�RB©2007©�ø
��¥�©2007/12/13ãøY¥�©2007/10/01\ª¨�©2007/10/15ãR��©
2008/09/04ãÕÖt©2008ã�×Ø\ËÙÚ©2009ã�¹�©2010)²Çb�!
Ù"ô�©å¨��B�þ�ìÁUî�¤©ÇÂþ�Åvq56789:�
���¯)�¸�(�¹�©2010)�
����ú_5678üý¿´�5M�¡\ÚbP]\\"ÝÛÜSÝ�
:ÝJp:²¾z½F����9«×Á]AÔ 50��23²
����ú_5678üýq5Mçæüý:²¾z½F����9«×Z
]AÔ 100-180��24²
����Z[ç¯"�³\�Ü"qÝ�:ÝJp:²¾z½F���9«
22 w¢�ñ IEK9:jk��©ÉÊ�©�AB5678ó¿;<�����)D�©2010�11p 20�©http://edm.itri.org.tw/enews/epaper/9911/d01.htm²23 w¢·ë9©�î4\��78565^��ö�w4:��©2008©Fn�¢o6ßJH�6´ôæ�.ãÝNF��½ÁÇß�©�ÝNF��½ÁÇß�ßõÙ�!�©2009㪨¡�©�x� 8�òâ�����©2007/06/21²24 w¢øY¥�©�5678 AMKL^�{��©2007/10/01㪨�©�Þßàá 2�X7[37 ½�©2007/10/15ã�RB©2007©�ø��¥�©�ÝNâã5678oä �ÜÕ7�©2007/12/13²
50
×Á]AÔ 300��25²
�����J�Üç¯"9:²¾z½F���9«×Á 600��²
�$��«��������w^�78üý:²¾z½F���9«×
]AÔ 1250��²
� F�����¬ Iq�©^åo�#�æ�� 2010� 7p¥ì
PfAB�5678��e��F©���R?AB���5678��×Á]
AÔ 600��qç©÷�XBè�d�Æ�5678�"³éé�X� 46��©
×��JG� 8%²%&4R6�ÙR 2011�AB5678�d�Æ��¯þY
�� 46��ÃÄ�K: 168��©�X�ZêêM��ª�¥¦�¥yÌ\
¼�ø�r¤�³´°î�]M��bë4©��Kò�©�· 20%26²
å�¿�©�F�5678�UWQ%&�üý��©m�£¤ÌWǶ÷
�½�ö©ìÉ� 57�¡�57ÚbP]����K©¼�©fS�57%
&�ç¯"��÷<©ì���¶o¼X²�J÷<©Z 2006 ��k? I¯
·©F�5678���¯×�]AÔ 105��: 242��qyã�¾¼X�G
��W�³Æ57�¡�57%&�Z�ÚbP]©���9«³{ 57üý
��9«� 15%-40%©YÂ�Z��57üý:�%&579:�&ª�� (�
¹�©2010)²
����F56789:�J�;<)Dq�©��Å��ç�X©��
þPf�.��c�©ì³ÆKLM@56789:�;<CD©¯e��z
�æç©��Æb ��m���¾U9:µ¶X�%&e��CD²
25 w¢��¥�©��F�pìí��7"9"îjF������©2006/11/02ã·ë9©�î4\��78565^��ö�w4:��©2008©Fn�¢o6ßJH�6´ôæ�.²26 w¢#�¥�X�.���©�AB�ÖÀ 57��oä 600 ��©2010 � 7 p 27 �©http://upntoday.blogspot.com/2010/07/taipei-news-medical-2010-7-27-01.html²
51
;E?� ������� F`aef
�\@d+"�e8f+�g+"��56AB
�5678�Æu¨56�4:� �78�ªªüý©Zú_Eå�þ�
�¨@üý²5678��C�4:5^ÝS5^n¬��8òV©Y56ª
ª©�¸0ª\\�\5M¡�\��\ª&ÜS©���Á�j�@�(invasive)
Ý�Kj�@�(non-invasive)�5Mªª©¯IØÝI§&J�Ö\][©Z9
h7ù��78��(Ëïð©2009)²
HI«.���©ôÊÆ�j�@�Ý�Kj�@��5678ªªÝ0ª©
���áBõS�KLM@5678��â�µ¶X©�Çb¾U0ª�e�á
ôÆÇb¼©ò&JFG��Á� Ç÷ÔÕ¡ tJ¢CÝ���d�qÖ
¤÷e��©ì³Æ¬zSUòcd¡�©�Y5678�0ª¯I§ø
���֩DzõËS�KLM@5678��µ¶²
%�¯©å��56789"¾!Å¿á��³Æ�î�]��d*©ôõ
ñ�î�]57º���¼�Á�,�òÇ©ì�"0åÚ¦Îk�]�\�0
ª©�fSjó�¹�C¦ò÷<©�î�]�¬�b5678�u³��²
ì³ÆÙ©5678�;<©ì"�x�Èõñ¯xI§���©ë§�
C�ô´�ñ�î�]ªª²¢ÈÅD�Úb©³=x78�¼�²� ��
j�@��]0ª�©î�]É�5678��Kò��©+&�á�o��
KX(Ëïô©2009)²
Ç©���Z��x©KLM@�5678©�;<�����ì¬"
Îk��Áì�©=v�îì�\��ì��ི�e�5678���X©Z
�³e\ªª�ïõ�!"©��£;78�� f©£ö�÷ø�ô��©À
78�=n��öÄ\�Í��#$XÛxóL©A+=n�Ã\��\�0å
52
𥦩¾³Æ�îì�\��ì�5678¿á����27²
�� h���0ij�kl�mnopq�rst�uv��QR
!Z9:Å���¯d·©�Ùd56�Æ%T�¯%¼ë4���©�Ùd
56�Â'��³ÆZ�ÙdùSLM��d*bcã©c?èé�UoÅv©
�b�æû�íe�©�b�e§�Ùd�²ì³ÆÙ©C�¾�o!"¯Íúe
§�;�©ã.�8\ï8�7��[²
�«�ABKLM@5678�9:µ¶X©ô�Æ5+Ý:+©áüvþ
�5678���Ùd56�u¨��ö©ì³Æ¿°��Ùd5678�²�Ù
d5678�Æû�Ùd56�¼C�4:�«¬@��©�5M����¬
�©³�0ü©��wxÃÆ!Ý�Z�5678�!OÑ�©A+�ª�=
ne��´k�\�+,�4:��©îtÁ����;�òå�©ôw9��
Ñ´?LM��D²
G!Ù©¸�ZZ[�[�LMb�©LM���³À78��Z[�xæ
û�[©¸�78�1ÆôÉ9¡©Â¥w^�5678�!"ݪª¯ô8²
ì³ÆÙ©©«�Z³0F78��Z[©m,Â[CÁ�[D©�x��`Æ
�LMã¾¥Á�=ÀÇb[Dô�¨©÷��ô`Æ�j�@LM©³`Ùd
5678��8!O©¾-=ýtÙdZ[�LM�9�àW�Ó����þ
CÈ(�A²©1992ã.��©2006)²
YS�Ùd56�¦� �Um,�\ròEï�5M´k©ì³Æ�ª«
0Ø÷�J���0F©ªX5^ï�\���5ª©ZÓª�./ïõ�56
27 ¿°�îì�©Â'��ÆâÈ���0ªücq!"¯e��\LM©C�¢È��Áªª`&ÜZÓï��àC©î78��e�0ª�LM¥©ftJFG� f��=n@£x��\;�²²�ö\������ì£x��©�¥ì��å��;;V��ò©Õ��ª«ì=@x��²:S¿°���ì�©�Ö-b�ìM"ÆLM�ôÕ«;\ô´e0ª�\ô´õñ÷�=78©¸Z[�8\��LM\cüÝ��S\�LM\�8LM¾Uô´?0ª�þ�²Á¥b ÚÛ�7¼�©4:5^JÀû�ì78�îì�78ªª%u¨©¼a ôx78¼�¥©Á¥�=1��e�Hoìf�0ª²
53
���EåÁ¼�Á´k�3R¨�9"`Hè�©ÇÂE� Îk5678�
;<b$©¿ZC�ÌW5678�5Mñ¿á%���Ùd56�u¨©e÷
=nú_78��e�f�çl©�¥ìb9:�;<�Ú]�)�²
2� P4QR�wx56yz
(�) 5M�dPêë�u¨
�KLM@5678�YS½½ð=v�îì�É:Æ��ì��LM!O©
A+¬�f��Ùd56�%=Ú¨©Ç½½;<z�¤:u¨��¨C&
£²¾¼X�Ez�³ÆKLM@5678�êë9:�u¨²
�F%&D2�5Mêë%u¨q3i���X©�¤¢S 2003 ��3ñ
\ªÂ�FÁ,��ABi�@üý9:q THIS ?@�28²�çæêë(Health
Tourism)�b´?@�cãq�©ì³ÆZ�dPêëbc©5Mçæb¼�©
c?vdP�ú_j�@H��5Müý©�¸æû0F�5678S²2005
�©H�"À�¨ÍzdP�©ª¨êë`5M:�©Z��bÆÞðPõlå
F0y5Mêëó¿©¾ìÆF�!�Yßz4c¬�n�5MdP��²�
÷©´���ÇÖ×�¨�ò)ÈîÊ8J´\%&ÚÛ{|�F��Ù�K�
��©¬Üé¢ô7\�¼ôõ(,��©2006)29²
Ït���çæêë5678Xï����â��©2006 �©��3ñN
,q�2015�R;<Ú ������¸z?@Y9:;<Ûú�X©�5M
üýF����?@�ÍB�b5M9:��o;<i�q� 30²�JÀìS
28 Â?@��8è³ Telecare(�g��)\Health tourism(çæêë)\Integrated medical system(�¨@5MJ´)¾�U>oÅv²29 ´ó¿�¯�é¢�Dô¸Ù�©2007 �´ó¿B�¬ZdÙ!O�P©ABð!H��öz��\�©�� H�"dôA��&£©%&�Ú¨:��D2 (þ:����>5ñ)ìáôw�´ó¿Îײ30 �5MüýF����?@��� ¦�AB5MüýáþÓ�����F�5Müý¯O©
54
¾���nüý:�âXï©�X5MdPçæ³Æ>V�Cq�©þ¯Aw
<\wd\xe\��q�ýòæPî���F5MçæüýJ´©NÙF��
ýòæSÕA�y©�t��F5Mçæüý��©e�%&�0F�78J�²
2007 ���3ñüý:3in¬�F��CÀpÁ,��3ññÀÍ�
�©õö��´?@©����b 2007�: 2009�ã´?@YH�"K08n
5Mñ¿ÀÞ8©AZ�>o5M�\�æû0F���5678�bc?��
þ�©vâo��F7ù�ú_5Müý©ý�ZAB�¸¹u��5Müýþ
�©C�E34�&�×y5J¨C�?@@�Ù©Â�å�:òÝ?%FR`
W�Á¯AÞ 5Müý©ÝþAB�"*q5MªªyzF�©vn5Müý
F���é¯OZÓ0��®«6 (�¹�©2010)²
�×y%&5J�5Mñ¿�â�Ë�X©2008 �©AB5MdP;<
À(TMTDA)§��n©u¨ê�w:�\5Mñ¿\�?��:�\ç~:\
�vß�\EF@��(�¸]^_��ß�S5J )Sô�4:òæ©�bF�
��UtO�nq5MdP�×y��5J²�#5ñ�íF��\� ê�w
u!©�zæ05MÛ"©ä�ìèé5678�%&þ�©Au¨=rAMë
4 V�dP��²�o5ñ Çb�ª<5Æ0�<u5M\êë\��\#
$�%qS¢=�<5©fS�o5ñõ<5MdP���ûÉo©� =ú_
5M�üý(èé5678)q�©� Vl3�Ï%¼0� (��È©2008)²$
&'Î5ñì�zæûêë©ô1ú_óMüý©ìÁ4Ë��ÁæûÃqz�
5678Xï©�þ5Mñ¿���´ku¨ (.(4©2008)²
�¾U%&�?@!ú�FGu�X©���Z·z5678© �ÆKL
M@5678¾Uzj©���dPêë�� %¼�¢�¤:u!²�¾¼
X©� 34%&zÀ�cÊ�&���q�©×y:��Å)ìô8�*ãq
¿ZÀÁ¾�;<©à>?��UÇÆKLM@�5678���ZCb5
Ì�Z)*Ô~\+,0ª\ïÊ�\\ò��-\&9�ªSb!?���üýþ�©�Çb¾UáËS>o�j�@�0ª©ÀÓ5M}~Ho©+Þ q§D´?K��¦¥yݦæ©Ç÷�"�Ì¥yL.M��"©êëË�©/�;34%&zÀ�0ç²
55
MdP;<�nB>Vþ�²×yÁàW:�ìá��¢C©�¸Aè:<5
ZAè�5é78üý:��ZÓ.c¯�0�12ð8#$S�L©Þ¨
34ç©=nZ4:5M¯âÕAB5MdP9:�B±©õ;�5M784P
(3ë4©2006ã�5�©2006ã�ë7©2006)²��¿úx��o5ñ©�;
<5MdP���XìZî�]bc?�üýþ�©�!Å6¨��´ê©�!
Åì7\Çõñ��Ýñ÷Õ�5J8Õ� �Çê (��È©2008)²
(�) "5MdPxF�5M
5MdP!=E�¯���Çê©we�f;<�u©³Àú»xF�5M
�ཀྵ÷¾ìÆ34����5MüýF����?@�¥�q�;<�B²
�AB©&'5ñS 2007 �ötO�nF�5Mz©�Í�F�5ñ)*
(JCI)�©�7F�å�!�æûÊ8ß�(Global Choice Health-care)��×u!©
þ5ñÈî^Z�¨©ÁïÍ��q4V©4ò4�bF�§Dú_ 24 �¥ª
à9c©vnF�5Müý¯O©âã:Á5MdP��(,.Û©2008)²#5
"òAMXRñ}l5ñC�`]^_ ARC(NOCk�½ÁÇß� )i�ª!
�!O©c;5MdP\F�5M�}~(Ë<=©2008)31²"n�\5ñÇ?
%�\c©/�2�æ>Ó���¢�שõÞ�F�5MdP4ó�©ú_ê
P�óMüý©5ñ¾�Y�\�cL5^�n�F56©Zcó!Obæ>
êPÓV�ú_�¼ò�üý©§ØÈÜì�É�æ>�©Y?5`�Î�?�
óL(,7Þ©2007)²
ZABCÁ�5M�)¯·©ô��®¯!ÅÝ"*!Å©m�áÁW³�
ÓFR�uV²ZKLM@�5678¯Ù©AB�\^\_`\\@Sj�@
31 XR5ñq�ì�z�dP��5�©¯Aêëy���ê�5����§A��¥���¥yX©��7A�x?% FB\:|CS Vwd²
56
q56780ª¾z½©®¯ùÈáG27FR�/ÌW 32(AB8n5Mñ¿
À©2009)²³"*!Å©AB5678�5M°±¤¬RF�©�³D¤©
�XKLM@5678�ªª¸³´°\ab\ƸP\7E\7FÓó\S©
h¬F�°±©�¥'Á�F��f�GÜab\���¿ñSªª©��H
�z�IJKab�½0ª 33!Å��³ì%¼D® 34²Ç©!D³KLM@
5678¾Uµ¶¯·©m��ZCb5MdPÉ:ÆF�5M%&3i!úc
)���>Vþ�²
(�) �N¨��]Ö�
��Nõ�d�ZÓ£Îõ�£P¯A\øY�dP��NtO�" ECFA
�©�� ECFA ¥¦�q5MH�9:�;<³3 �+L�²YSAB�56
78!Å��)W³o£©ÇÂ� £Pq�©ô;A�É:Æo£�s#©á
4�¯Ae�5678M�©�bAB�<5MdP��ou�ã�Âq�©³
3i=��� ¯·©�N��½M�Àì� 2010 �tO�"��N5\H�
¨Cp�©�5\H��p>V©¾fS�N56789:�¨��;<
¯ÙìÆ�o�W35²
ABÁÌW5Mñ¿á¬·X¾U;<��©á)��5M}~H��KL
M@5678M�¯âN¾»oä²¾UKLM@�57M�èéabP�L
M\�°�[\|â�����ÆZÓ±²`�³´°�ÚbS²ä�©{�
32 � 5678�0ªq�©ABÁÌW�\0ª¿´�ùÈáq×b27FR� 1/5: 1/6²¸)Ô~0ªùÈ×b 880007�©×b7FùÈ� 29%©]^_ùÈ� 1/2ãO&9�zjùÈ×b 59007�©b7F� 17%\�F� 22%\]^_� 50%²ä�©AB�¾\0ª¸ò�¾H~\ab7`\ò�ï¾S©ùÈá1´27FR% 1/2�®¯²33 �H�zab�IJKabáÆËSP�@ab©uVÆ=C�þZ[�àQ;P�©ÃÄx��R��V`��©�ÖVÆâ0ab�ÀÁzV©18p�;S¥@�§T²34 w ¢ U � ©� A B 5 M 7 8 æ 0 V W F � �© 2011 � 6 p 7 � ©http://gb.want-daily.com/gate/gb/money.chinatimes.com/news/news -content.aspx?id=20110607000901&cid=1208²35 %&�p>V1èé��\ª\]\¨C\a ý�S©æûN"%=-Gì�©ö�p�©AB�ªX��£;YK���-G¥y©þ^Ä%&:�eZXFo£¹Ú�p��æûN"���[f²
57
óZ\\ \}ZSj�@�56780ª©ìÆÌW5Mñ¿���c)þ�²
56789:�==!�K©����F� GDP&¹�o©÷o£� GDP
�%T�¯ôW�K©f5678�´êm�Á�^�vy©�î�]����
K��Så�gh«ãÇ©��Nõ�¨�q�©56789:�ÃÄ;<©
ÑTìÆn��º²
³dP5M¾U��¯Ù©ABdP5M�7ù\8� F��ÖoØÓ�
�:]�©�o�;<()����So£dPP©o£�5�°g^³eFR
1Á��àK�g^©�õ�o£dPP¯A�©YSo£òæô�ÁABæç
&½©ôÊÆ56789:ÝÆ�Ó5Mªªþ��zj©áþ�;�o���
(·_I©2006)²
:SAB5+�·"©�34õ�£PøY��©5+ì�s�¯þZîì
78\~¾Sþ��<£P5M©ô�©5+ìvp34�¯�ZäK£PøY
�D½¯A� :�Up©�=Þ¨5678LM�¥¦�l, 36²
XFo£%�¯Rö÷©IR?©5678��&�Z 10%�Ä��K©
W³å� 6%gh«² Irs©o£� 2010����³Á 300�ò�|567
8��]0ª²Ù?ô�$q�ÏÏ$��©X9�Áþ�Kx`Î�ò©¸�
�òaù����5678�©ij5678�J�9«þÀ%¼mò 37²
o£57��¬o©AB�Á57�_s\�.�Su�©ÇÂAB³
¾þ9:÷<���3{�@��x©;<�²ªªgA©¤>;�ò-Ò
¯©-=ÀABKLM@�5678ªª�¾�~�XâÛ��²
36 w¢X�w ©�£ P øY� 57 +b} K� �© 2011 � 6 p 19 �©http://tw.news.yahoo.com/article/url/d/a/110619/5/2tl2a.html²37 w ¢ U � ©� � N 5 7 ¨ � ¨ C À c [ à d · �© 2011 � 6 p 6 � ©http://bbs.105life.com/viewthread.php?tid=38147²
58
;I? lmno�pqrsctuo0F
`aefvwx�yz{|}~�
��d����
«Å��ç�xABKLM@56789:�TU;<>V©�X5Md
P\F�5M�?@e�©áfKLM@56789:�;<Á¤%¼���Ô
Õ²�÷©�NOFRX©��ìÚ¡xÁTUFR�¾U>Vµ¶X¿�Ú�
Å)�ÈîÆ%¼¬o�ãì³ÆÇb¸Â©��Á�?³¾TUnBFRe�
5M9:;<i��æç©Z�=�AB�«�;<$De�GH©e÷"Xß
ÛIØ�ú»3i���)�!v²
Z�.³[F\]^_�aF�5MdP\F�5M!Å���©Ó�f5
6789:(ZKLM@56789:bc )¿���ÔÕC�)�@����
æç�
(�) [F
1. 5MdP�;<h]�
�5MdP�zj©[F�K��� �;<©S5Mªª!Å©¬��
oUV(e\f\g\oh\]i\�j)WQ;z]�5Mªª(AB��å¨
�¿©2006)²
ä�©c[��]9:ìb�ì�z�d��kß�¾��qlÂ�ÝÔ~
!Å©¬Õ�³eFR°±©0ªÓLMù�1Á7F�ôjq�\���$
jq�²Ç©x[FÞ LM��FòÁ®¯®�^���²[F34bå)
;<5MdP9:©¬.Î�Ò¯4:5MòV\mnòV©A+;<dP��
°±�5Ml3©ZÓ¨Í\ÝoÓdPS�©pJl3 (�qr©2006)²
59
2. F�5M�;<)D�
[F34S 2008� 10põöþF�5MZb]�K�)9: 38©HI[F
çæwÀ�ñ�ÈÜrs©2009 �¯[��FdPPW[p�'©�XZ
5Mb���êP³� ��'©[F34��BÆ� 2013 �¥Â�x�ô�
'\2015 �Â�x�ô�'\2020 �Â�x�p�'�Fò¯[Þ 5Móe
�üý²
ä�©[F34ø 2007� 3pö©³�[FdPßw� 30W^[F5M
ñ¿�n�[FF�5MüýpÀ�©Â��FdPP«µæ0\78S©Ü
)S��5Mñ¿s�§DÇê©�5M:�¨"Â��F§D�[³5©¨
Z�5MtL;�"�Z�5M�&u<�ÈÈ�©��5M�&'÷�Z�F
�Bs�,©lnå¨5ñ§ ªB±Ó 8v龿4:æ05ñS (��
'\�.w\�xy©2011)²
� 2010 �¥©[F34e�fúz�2010 �F�5Må¨3i�©c?�
��Æb ^áSæûæ0\78�]\Z[78\¾\\z!LMS$UF�
5Mµ¶��âã�5M����,\F�5M�"�.Îõ;ZÓ�����
ÙS!Åáèxo)Ç.²ä�©ì¾�þ�B��Pf�Fò�F�5M�
�©[FdPßwC�å� 27 UIVe�§Î��â (ABüýJp�hõ©
2011)²
�[F;<F�5M���X©���Z·x�34m�C��¹ð�3i
�?@© vnF�Á�5ñ\IØ5Müý\5M�GSÚÛ{|¯�);<²
[F34�bíeFR5M9:�f�¨C¨��;<©�z èéF�5M�
���Global Health Care å�æûÊ8�4ú©l9���D�s�ÇÐ44�38 2008 � 10p[F34ß Z�oWQbc� 22þ9:WQb]�K�)9:©¾�oWQb=î,#$WQ\¢y´kWQ\New ITWQ\�¨]9:WQ\��\ªWQZÓ��üýWQ²
60
CF�ãä�©�34ìêZ &Sç~ /Ùd5M¢¹S%&�"Yê�©A^
áf�§Î���Ë��ÇЩ+.ÎÒ¯F�5M4:ò-Óln�å�¸¹
)�5ñl3S²
3. f5678(è³KLM@5678)9:�ÔÕ�
HI[FF���¿;��ÈÜ©YS[F�]�\�¾@©¿ZÂ�ÌW
�Fò¯[Þ 5678�]!Å�F�5M©fS¯[êó��FD�÷<©
5678�F\!Å�LMÑTH�Â�)²%fð©¯[Þ UV0ª\ò�
&0ª��FD�©TT�ZÙÆîT�î²W ¯[Þ óM��FòáÆ
Çb¯[êë�©Þ{x[F5Mh��-xÞ óM©YS[FÔ|.��Ô
Õ©�X�Z5678¾�»�b }6 (ABüýJp�hõ©2011)²
Ç©�[F56789:�;<�©¸�=þdP�5678LM�þ�
`����ªà©fS[FF�5M�;<©ìÌ=9��o�ÔÕã÷F�5
M9:�;<©ìÀ²�¯íe56789:�ú»²
³5678¾Uµ¶¯·©[Fþ���SF�5Mµ¶�ÙÆô~ª)©
� X�34q�©ð!øL5JÏþ5678�F�5MCu¨²Z�F�â
Q�b�©�F34ç©�FðP=�b1MNF�5M�ëV©ç©=�Y5
678�ªªb��âF�5M9:�;<��©ÇÂZ�Xï�]�\�Z[
\;<�ðPbXï©þ1�FP��0ASP�bdPPQ\|�FP�bo
65ñ;<�PQ©?@e�449:��â²!³Ù�Zæû0F\�]\Z
[�Ùd56bc©�¯þ½½¶oë�>VÓÏ@§��©�â�F�F�5
M²
Y�Å���¯·©���Z��[F34�)���F�5M3i©��
�f[F�J�5678 (è³KLM@5678)9:�;<¯Ù©m�ÁKJ
o��û²ì�ZÙ©�;<F�5M���X©[F34m���ø&�5M
61
�)©A+=n���ÁûÜ\�=Â�x�Fòêó�áþ¯;<²
(�) ]^_
1. 5MdP�;<h]�
]^_YS5M�dPÈîh%fH8FFRb7©Ç©%�¯´F5M
dP9:�C��;<© �ÅD\oÄ�!tÆ�c?êê©�5MªªÓ�
<��eu�©>1§ò�8�Æ�o¾� (�<D©2006ã�qr©2006ã�
v`Sò©2008)ã�Çð�29©=nÂ� �\N¯|N�Á�ò櫵 (,
z:©2006)²
]^_34�;<5MdP���X©c?Æâß8z4¨Ce��Ù�]
^_êë�o)�â5MdP©õ'¹uF�5M©1Á«µ³5��G\Ýo
Ù�(,z:©2006)ã]^_c?�5M8 (Raffles)E5��뢴k©E5£
�7Ëe�ê�©�¥�E5¼ðdPêë²HI]^_êë��R?©2004
�]^_5M����F§D 27 �'©2005 �o��K: 40 �ò©Ù?�
2012�5MdPò þÕ� 100�ò(Yim©2005ã�<D©2006ã�v`Sò©
2008)²
2. F�5M�;<)D�
]^_F�5M9:�;<ZÅD\oÄ\!tbc?êê©>1§D�8
b�¾�©^��3F�5M-GB±�^.©ÇÂ�ß27F�êPÓNO`
W�( ²
�5Mþ�zj©HI]^_F�5Mf��Ùõ'�ÈÜrs©"���
æû0F\�8�]0ª©Z:Á²0ªM�©ZÓ�4\�8�¸ï*\\
62
�\\�9\\��\\ó\\�\�}\S©]^_�F�5Mçæüý�Ù
Æ�²Ãå39²
� �F�°±�5M"*ÓÅDt��u�q�©]^_F�5M%HS
NO�ÓFR¯Ù©GH¾��1ÁZ�¾V©ì³Æ�H�z�Ê8Ó?ê
�©�J]^_�5M9:�dã.�C���5Mçæ´k©ß�>?�ÈÜ
`k? I©èéÎG§Aê I©ZÓ�õ�ß�J¢5Müý�ghÝñù
Ȳ¸ÂC��ê�©ôqú»�J5�"*©íî5MòV=nfôWI§�
hD`zoÄ`Á¼�²²©�¥ì=�§ò`z��ò���²� F�-
Gq�©5Müý"*ì�C�ßõ;�5M*�nB�©]^_ØW5M�
�á��õ'�ßõ;��Z`F�B±%GH�0ª�¢ò©ZßÛ§D�(
Ʋ
HIk?©]^_&�îÈF�5M�ò½Z% 20%ÃÄ�K©Ù?� 2012
���J�9«� 30�7�Ó 100�ò½��¯²�F�5M�c?üý!
Å©Z��d\�]78\æû0F(æû�0)bc©ä�ìèé �ÓGH4
\�0ªLM©�¸ï*0ª\�\\ó\\F\\�����\0ªS (AB
üýJp�hõ©2011)²
ä�©1Á�VGH¾��Æ©]^_�F�5MJ´ÆàS¯ð�I5M
ñ¿��¯Óüýþ�÷Pjb5ñ<5 40\5ñ/5MXï41Ó4\5M<542
�o�©�NO�Ó��F�5M�FRX©y;·x�jÛ¸Â�a��àJ
´²
÷]^_�F�5M!Å���©"343iõö³Æ�þEzÀ�¨C©
x :²ìô��²]^_�F�5M;<ìÆ"�o���3�9:¤0�
39 w¢]^_F�5Mõ'�http://www.singaporemedicine.com/cn/index.asp²40 c?b�o5ñ<5�Fnæç<5 (National Healthcare Group)\]^_çæ5M<5(Singapore Health Services)ZÓpk5M<5(Parkway Group Healthcare)²41 GH¤'�Á��æ5ñ (Raffles Hospital)\Fno65ñ(National University Hospital, S2004�ßÛ JCI-G©b]^_��RßÛ´-G�5ñ )²42 GH¤'�Á Novena Heart Centre(ï*4\)\Asia HealPartners Pte. Ltd(56784\)\Pacific Healthcare(�¨@5Müý��)\Specialist Dental Group(F\Ó784\)S²
63
5MÓêëã�H�z\R;<�\:;<�\êë��0¨Cq�]^_
F�5M�(Singapore Medicine)¾UEWQ�gA�©ôqú_ 5MüýD2
�ÈÉ©êë�G>ì%¼ß>²÷34Ó:+³Æ·�]^_�"*�F��
#$©�©bF�5Mɯ�W^j (ABüýJp�hõ©2011)²
3. f5678(è³KLM@5678)9:�ÔÕ�
��Ó��F�5M�FR%�©]^_�F�5M\5MdP!Å¿�Ú
�Å)©m�ìÀ]^_�5Mªª��=¢�©¾¼X¼�ìèé 5678
(è³KLM@5678)9:��W²
%HSNO�ÓFR©]^_�F�5M¾Uµ¶X©c)ìÌAô��5
678¾Uþ��©Çb]^_¿o)���©Æ��à½��J5Müý©è
éåÛ�æ0\ï;��ñ0ªZÓ�4\���zLM²�ÏtƸ©]^
_$�1ÆlÁÌW44Z5678b4\LM�5Mñ¿©¾�;��5M
��!O©m�ìÀ�5678%&�ÌW�j�@�0ªLM©�b]^_F
�5M�>?þ��c?9«²
(�) aF
1. 5MdP�;<h]�
aF�5MdPZdP� (Tourism Thailand Organization)b�<D2²aF
¤� 1970 �¦³Z5MdP�'©�¯ÆÇbaF�³ÆZêë÷¤'�F
R©�¯�S��&³Æ2N���>?ë¢'ã�¥©aF�5Mªª£¤
��p�;<ì@¢��©¾���]\§@\¾F\ï*S!Åãä�©pJ
l3ìÏ�0Ø\®¯�/©gh®¯1Á27���x�X (�ë4©2006ã
64
vÀ©2006)²
aFdP5M�¤:u¨�ì%¼�¢©¸�ê�w¨Cs�5Mêë5©
0���¿Á��(�ë4©2006)ã�5MdP�É��©aFdPß�Á%¼
u¤��C(�À�©2010)²³D��j¯Ù©aF5MdPc?�D�¯ø
S��\��\]^_\AB\¿���\XFZÓ<^}(Connell, 2006)²
2. F�5M�;<)D�
aFø 2004 �ö³õö�|�þb�$��FR;<i�?@©YaFß
JæûzÉ�©?@Z5Müý\æûçæüý\aF\�9:�UP»©�â
aF�b�NOæûêëXï�©÷Z�«���¯·©´þ?@m�Æ�¢�43©Çèé34Ó:���i��¢\�\ªl3\�27SFR .��+
Á5�òVÓ%fH��5Mù\¤F}hêëÚÛ\øì��æûêë�"�
S²
aF�5MJ´jbßn�8n5ñ©8n5ñþ%$pR©×�jq�2
S��©r¢���;��5MÈî©�F�5M�µ¶X©:Á�5Mñ¿³
Ëû×5ñ(Bumrungrad International Hospital)���'�ãû×5ñþ¤u¤�
5Mªª\�/�®¯\0��üý6ZÓaFÁ''�êë V©0åþ5
MdP�F�5M%=u¨�¡ì;�x��ܲHIû×5ñõ'�ÈÜ©r
sz��å�ô�UFRáÁlnëÑ5M�Þ©ô (International Referral
Offices)©&�T%�p��³5ò½X©Á�XÆ�Fò©�X7F��W44²
aF�F�5MfÆY5MdPäå��¢��UFR©�5MdP��
��%&üý:�6ozj<XS��ðP©ZÓ�Ó>?�dP��©¸Ò
43 ¾þ?@���ÆZFR3i��)¯��;<aF�b�NOæûêëXï�\�NOæûqá�©A+Dz�aF�\æû�\�aFbNOæûXïq��i��ZÓ��¢q5Mêëi��S!P²44 w¢û×5ñõ'�http://www.bumrungrad.com/thailandhospital²
65
�\�J\�uS²�� dP V�©=þaF�vF�5M°±��Ó�
Æ©1èé0Ø�©pJÚÛl|©ZÓ��o�ÝF�-G�5M��ã¼�
5MùÈ%f³eFRt�\5Müý°±�27FR`�OTT%¼\4óS
È¥yHÌ\ú_§D�8SüýH27F^5ñ�bÑïS�z�þ�©ìÆ
aF=�3F�5M°±-G�8Y 45²
�J·¯©aF34m�þ�5MdP���F�5M�1b�þ�¨@�
�"©C�3i�Ú¨ÊËàC©ì�z�¤��r�¸¹u�©¾]][�
5M9:¢C©m�À�ÓFR©�rÓ²
3. f5678(è³KLM@5678)9:�ÔÕ�
fS�U¸Â�¢ðâ�þ5MdP�F�5M¨JJM�FR÷<©w^
���à¤�³Á�]78 (ozj<X�§@0ª)�;< î©5MdP�F
�5M�;<e�©���m�ìÀaF�5678 (è³KLM@5678)9
:�^°±²
HIk?©F�êP�aFdP���X©�JîÈ�5Müýèéæû0
F\%1ctab0ª\�]780ª\¾FóM\�\0ª�¦æS©¾ìr
saF�´S5MWQ¬Á%¼�'�©4:p F�§Dq¡,²%�¯©a
F�56789:ì;<x�îì�\��ì�¾�»©Ó�j�@�0ª©ÝÆ
Z�P]�Úb©���� �FP�}6ã^�aF�\�LM!ÅÁ¤¢E
�Ø£©u¨aOÎk5M(�¸aOm¤�8LMZÓ SPA°M)©w^��\
ª�5678ªª©¬�baFÑo�¯�57M�©&�kÂ�o�dPP
45 aF�5MùÈ!Å��¸¹u�©aF¿´�5MùÈTTÆ27FR�ôjq�ôx²�¸ï*¥¦��0ª�7FùÈ×´ 20�7�Z�©´E����X�hnè³7F:aF¯��§\0ªùÓÛ¥êë��S1¨¨Áª²�]78ùÈÏ�©�z}Z0ª�7F´?2 �7�©�aF q´? 7500 7�²¸Â¬o�5M���¤©6©rÌW27òæf«µaF5MdP�q!ª²
66
bÂ�a©ÂÏÏaF�F�5Mµ¶Xá)�â�Û¥�� 46²
�Âq�©aFdP�ì�����aFæû78Ëï�q��%&õ��
ÙË�©Ë��âèé¾FLM\abct0ª\�80ª\&ïÊ�dM�\
å&æû0FS²þ5678u¨¯�\m¤\#M\é¯ÓÎk\�¯IØò
Jd��C"©ø`=�\ÎkÓKÎk�!"©u¨¤'�aOüý\«��
ºPqËÓR�ë�®¯©¾U¤:u¨�34�o)Ç.�â©m�áÀa
F�56789:%HS?%FR÷<��ÁÂ�)�Ùü) 47²
46 w¢aFAB�Àª¨IÀ ©�aF5MdP,üý9:)D�¬ �©�Èøhttp://blog.udn.com/LindaFu/3528376 ©2009/11/24²47 w ¢ a F d P � (TAT) X . õ ' �http://www.tattpe.org.tw/TravelInfo/TravelInfo_detail.aspx?NewsID=130²
67
;N= ��� ������� F
�!��
;<?��JKF�[B��
�� {|}~D����$"�#����34��� !
�.��c�bABKLM@56789:3i��©��Vb³d
eAB56789:;<�IJ#$©e÷w"X¬æKLM@56789:�
�zÅv©Ae÷e�%&�3ijk²
YS56789:Æ�UKJâî�µ¶©�.��c�Æ3iÚv©Ç
Â��âÈY��rs�z>?3ip����!O©¯@�9:�ç�µ
¶©�¥=n�Þ%3i�*���NïãZÂ!O�¬©e÷=nPf�«A
B�KLM@56789:�;<�¿ë�3ib$©Ó�%=&ª�>?3
ip�©¯�®z�J9:3i�;<²
�e�%&p��jkq«©Á�?³+,9:B��ç�µk©-=e�
��m���²â���56789:�Æ5678��XÆþ%&9:�Í÷©
÷���Ù"¿,��ô�9:µk©�9��9«�Ù�9:¼ûìÀÁào
��¤²�Ö÷<HÝÁ���zjÆ5678üý:ZÓú_57üý¿´?
q5M�¡\ÚbP]\�³\�Ü"qÝ�:ÝJp: (�¹�©2010)²
KLM@�5678èéj�@�zj� \^\\]\�z�]Ó7qSã
ä�KLM@�5678ìè³ Kj�@�zj�¸ab7`\ab�½\|
â����\��¶S²÷¾UKLM@5678M��e�©á��Y4:�
5Mòæ¯|L²YS��e�KLM@5678q%&M�©c?ÆzS¼©
��Uò¡Ú©ÇÂì�Z+,b¼©�ÁÂI§��¡á�©÷Y5M4:ò
68
æ¯e�%&��üý�²
å�¿�©Ú¨��¿?���>?3ip�©��c?þKLM@567
89:�µk+,¸��(1)ú_KLM@5678q5Mñ¿üý: (è³5M
��)©¾z½c?<X�K�?@�øù5Mã (2)ú_KLM@5678üý
¿´5M�¡qÝ�:�Jp:©�¸�e�ab7`�ab��¥¿´?�5
M�¡ã(3)ú_KLM@5678üý¿´Z�ÚbP]qÝ�:ÝJp:©
�¸����\��¶kË��Ý]©Â��ìè³ ��ÝK��&Ü�5M
²ÈãZÓ(4)�zÓZ[�Üç¯"qÝ�:ÝJp:©KLM@5678ç
¯"9:b¾��ª9:��Ç©ËS��ªª�¾È�6"��Üç¯"��
²È©oWÆâÈÒ��ªªÝ��-¯©§÷��Á¾,¢= (ç°\d±
Ý7`S)�Z[ç¯"²
�� ���������{|��
(�) Z��rs�z>?3ip��8Y
YS�.��c�ÆZKLM@56789:3ibXï©�«F�%&
��©y;ZKLM@56789:3ibc©WXÆZ5678bXï÷�
;�%&p�ç�©�<X�3iÅv�m�ôW²Ç©�����³ÆP
f"KLM@56789:��÷z�>?3ip�©e÷jk�ç�²
�÷©YS�wx��J�AôW©ÇÂ��âÈ�!OÆ©ý��%&
ßz4`8z4�4:òæÞ�Ae���rs²Ârs���Æ®C�Åf
Å%=+Í�!O©ßÛ r�fSÒU3ip�ÝC��de�·"²ßz4
�4:òæ�3i�=��dÞ©Ó��=70Þ%&�:ýã÷8z44:
òæ�¡¢© �ZÀ�����«¾U3i��ýàC�1Á>U3V©Ý�
�ýe�XÀx>UÍ�²
69
(�) rsfg���
rsfg���ð������Órsfg�� �L÷,©j�Y34
�&%&D2�òV\5Mñ¿����¦�ZÓ%&566À�¦�©AZ�
3ip�%&����qe���rs©Z�¨æ²@��©AÁ�Sf�
�����²rsfg¸� 4-1¿s©e�¥yb 2011� 6p: 2011� 7p²
� 4-1 rsfg48
¦�µ¶ ¿÷ rs��
34%& V H�"5©ô\K(A)49 2011/6/16
�3ñ3ýKV(B)50 2011/6/24
5M:� >?æûÊ8J´@©K (A)51 2011/6/17
NnFo�]78<5��K (B)52 2011/7/12
6()À¦� X:×F7856568©K (A)53 2011/6/22
ABdP5M;<À8©K (B)54 2011/7/12
Èܯî�E�ø��8
(�) jk��!O
48 bêZ��Èrs�8�!t@©/þrsò�Z�Uµ¶¯j�©j�b34%& V\5M:��6()À¦�©Aþ&Uµ¶��2rsò�Z A � B b¦n©�Z���ÈXþZ¦n�s©��34%& V A\5M:� B²49 �3ñH�"5©ô��\8Ë=\K²50 �3ñ3ýKV9:�³�²51 AB�d57LI\>?æûÊ8J´@©KA�B5^²52 NnFo�]78<5��KGHI5^²53 X:×F785656ÀMR8©K,S!K�TU5^²54 ABdP5M;<À8©K�WX5^²
70
�rs���l,��X©E�w� %&./�©¬z TU�«�KL
M@56789:GH%&�3ip�©AHI¾Up�¯l,ú��rs�
�²:Sjk���!O©YS34Ñ�3i;<��J0�³Æ¢È%&�3
i��²�<q©3i��fS9:;<�ÔÕ©�9:�&%&q;��\
ì]\��´ê�%&ÇêSÅv©3i���àC���áÀ9��oÓåÅ
@�ÔÕ²
«.ç�"3i��8������äåz¯�Y Rothwell�Zegveld¿ú
z�ì]3i��©���-bì]3i�dV�34�9:3iÁ�o�&
¹ãZvÀ(2000)Pf9:3iq¡ì¿`�,��i¯·©�-b9:3i
Æîn34¢È�#3\��\JpS3i��©dÞ\yÞÑ�9:Ë�©
Z¬�9:;<Óu���qk÷²©��©9:3im£òb{|©���l
��� ©¢ÈÛ¼ Á�½á����=�CÈ (�v³©2006)55²
å�¿�©¸�"3i��Ú¨ì]���dV©wu¨9:3i�;<e
�©������Zþ34fSÒþ¾,9:¿���3i©"_èÅ\´êÅ
�#$ůjk²_èÅ¡Ï34dÞ��9:;<��UǶ©Ó#ýÈî\
ò)Èî\ªª�ßJüýÈîSã´êÅ¡Ï34Pf9:�;<@©Z��
�õKb¤óV©e÷f9:3i¿���ÔÕã#$Å¡Ï34yÞf9:;
<q#$^ÆÔÕ56²
ZKLM@5678¾þ9:¯·©��?æç�³Æ34fS¾þ9:�
;<�ú_� >UÈî(_èÅ)ãÆ!m�Z¶·9:�J���b�B©e
÷ì�´êÝØÙ��(´êÅ��J�Å)ãZÓ�;<#$�vê�©34f
55 %&>?�9:3i,�1èéú�:\�´µ(1986)�9:3iÆ�S�+¸¹#$\9:�&Èî`FRIJ�B�xé�,FR�¯8®�9:u�©34A�Â���¼��ê©AÁ¼�Â�BãDriscoll & Behrman(1988)�9:3i£34bzÔ¾,9:z4q�È©AYS�J3i6��Þ qR�K°±�¿´q9:u�©bêDz¿âÚq��©µ£f¾,9:z4qíe©÷K�Jq�:�ã.vF(1991)9:3iÆn¿Á�=ÀIØR_èÅ��ü{|©Æ��ZIØR�K\�9)`¸¹)�hËq²56 w¢��� p. q��²
71
´þ9:Æ!vn9:���v��õ;�¼�9:#$\ú_ßJüýZÓâ
ÈÒU�ê@�C"¯¬�ì]ÝÔÕ;< (#$Å)²
Ç©�Þ�¯���X©Pf&U>?�3ip�©þHIZ����j
k!O¯e�ç�©��=ð"¾�Uô��Åv¯jk�KLM@5678%
&�3ip�©Aý�¬æ9:�z�«¿Åv�b$���©ZÓ�¯;<�
�=@�Çê²
(�) >o3ip��«¬Ù�
��¨�KLM@56789:%&�./�9:����©��;C�
«�KLM@5678q;<GH%&�p�©oÜ�Á�ÅTU©j�¸��
(1) 5MdP�%&3i�34%�¯Pf5MdP��_èÅ�
;<�C"©c?ÆZ�¨�Ù\Zçæ78\#$¯�Óê
�X�?q5M�bb�B9"©ÏÆZ�ÁEå@�\D¬\
¦�Ìq#$¯�\æû0F\78\%1aÀÓ¾\LM
S��j�@5M9"©`b��dP��qêë�� (,p
¶©2005)²Y��dV¯·©KLM@5678m�ÁàWM
�þ�áÆËS34��5MdP�ªªµ¶²�÷©ø 2003
��F34õö"�çæ5M�¾U)*z;\e÷�%&3
i{Ó5MdP¾�P»q�©¾ôT�¯�;<��ô¸Ù
�©�àWÅv�ÍÁ«Û0ç�vy²
(2) F�5M%&3i(�sF�5M4P��� )�F�5M¾Up
�%T�¯@; xå�+>1©:SAB!Å©" 2007�H
�"�n�5MüýF��4úÊ8Xï��©³õöo)�
�F�5M�;<e�²Ò���¯Ù©F�5M��ì�
«þ�5MdPu¨��ö©�÷F�5Mè³����Æ�
72
âî�+,©%HS5MdP¯Ù©F�5MÆ�4:\�ª
ª@�¢C²¼���5MdP`F�5M8²áfR9«
Á¿·/�ÔÕ@©�XfSKLM@56789:�;<ì
��¸¹©ÇÂ��Á�?³3iů�p%&3i��ì²
(3) 5M�ì�ë�—"Ké���*x�:�\9:��YSK
LM@5678�M��Uòcd�¡áÁGHo�&ª@©
ÇÂ�9:;<���X©ì³ÀxÎk5M�5678qy
�¡ìë�²�¾Uë����X©34x���V²¤>S
�ô�34´¸���Îk5M�5678�gv�+��¾
U��áf9:�;<Á�o�ÔÕ)©ì��ðÔÕ34�
3i����Ú9²
(4) %&"�Êê�fSKLM@56789:©Ý�fS567
8Ý5M%&q�J9:�;<÷<©ìÌÊê@\�ê@�
3i��¿;��ÔÕ)Æ�b¸¹�²9:;<³Àx5M
¾4:@�ªª©34�%&D2��À"ÌWÅv¯x
�©÷K�[ðíe;<²��=²´¸��xgvV�¾U
Êê@\�ê@�3i��©fS9:;<÷<©�ØÙ��
�Æ!¨��!x�¾UÊêfS�J�9:#$�À��Ê
jÔÕ�¾U����áÀf9:;<��%¼���¸¹²
å�¿�©�.�Þ�¯���jkX©³ÆZ¾�U>?�3icãbz
;V©ý�"3i���Åv©��=ðZ_èÅ\´êÅ`#$ů�x34
|�3i�x�ZÓ�J9:�;<©AZ4:òæ¿)�;��¡¢bw�M
��>?B�©e÷�����B²
73
;E?c��!�H"����
(�) 5MdP�%&3i
AB;<5MdP�c?¸¹�Æ��NO��F©?%�aF\]^_\
�\N¯|NÓ[FS©¾UFR;<5MdPk¬1��¼²¾UFR;<
5MdP�J�VÆ34k��>?��ݼ¬���©�<q©ÏÆ34 �
�â\9:+%=Ú¨(º»¼©2009)²
�÷©Z�F�;<hD¯·©º�34�5MdP¾�µ¶���H�Ó
NOFR¯Û¡©�ø 2005 �Z¯©34ìfÆ�f;<%&�3i©Z78
çæbcã©ç©�5MdP¾�UWQÁ¿½e©�b��"cöde_ 57�
HIT2 r��¡¢©���Z·z�U3i�ôn8ä�²¾²3i�ôn
8ä�u�ì³f%&5M9:�� �ú»R9«\ì];<!Å�Í�²
ýPfT2 r��¡¢�8zTUjþ?V¸��
1. ��3i����
¿°��5MdP����³Æ?ÈABD®�5Mªª©Â��F×Ø«
¯³5©A+ZAB�dPÈîb¼�©Z�b�F§Dú_�Uõ��5§#
$©�LMqª©Í�ÌëAB�} 'ù\� AB�}¿×h²�5MdP�
¾U3i���n¡É7©�������X©�ý�ÍÀëx�UC�Å�
��©¾ìÆ�«AB��5MdP�¾Uµ¶¿Åa�b$²
57 2005 ��3ñ��çæêë��?@©ÌfZ�dPbc\çæb¼��;<!P©�?@ù���Y"n�>5ñcÞ©I'�ªß�ú_5M�¡l3© ���78çæ©üý�8èé78ab\�°�[ZÓÛ¥æ0S²¾þ?@ÆAB!�Yßz4c¬Y9\ \6�!¨C©u¨5M�dP9:�i�ª!!ú©��È��72�} ©^�AB�&�5MªªÉ���ðP5M9:�;<©�^FR�k�ß�©�ú_Á¡:ABe�dP5M�dPPä�U]���²w¢º��©2006©���çæêëq7ù�Õý���9¡�����©�3ñH�""n5ñ�>jñ²
74
��6()À¦� Be�rs���X©��s5MÀ¢�ô8��\ç~
���dP�����áÆAB�«��Áü�²ä�©34AÝÁ¾�vF�
�âݧÎAB�5MdP©¾Æà�Â�²5M:� B � r¥ �sAB
��?�x=nÂ�x�Fò�ìV©ì³Æ��?�zø��u'\��ò�
ªª©¯Â��FP©¸Â�¯-Á;<5MdP�8Y²
�,-�.(/�01)2#34!"�
�.56�78!"�����9:;<=>�.?@A��.56�
BC78D
EF�!"�GHI�J1K=L?#EFMNOP��QRST(U
V.�W�EF�BCXY�!"���Z[\]#U^_�9:D
,-`a�!"�2K,-`abXc4de�fg�hijklUR
mnop�V.D
ST,-�.)*q?rs&tuvw�Kfxyz{�hi|��0
1)2,-�.f;}�=L~01��.������b�01��
�K�����]#�����Z���[�����������]
#�01������I��.I�U;4�������� ¡�¢
£K¤{¥�#¦§¨©ªU,-�.�«��]#jZ�9:¬��
®®¯
°e01,-�.)*q?#U;H±�R=L�²J1³?´ªRS
T(µ¶�.�m�/[�·¸�·¹º»�I�opV.�«�01
¼]#lU�½¬9:®®¯��¾�q?¿À B Á¯
�Q�ÃÄ(Å���.bÆUÇÈ�ÉÊ��ËÆÌÍSTK���
.�ÎÏ�ST�ÎÏÐѪ#�Ò#Ó�ÔÕ�ÔÕÖ( ×�£Æ
ØÙÚ�Û �ÜÝÞßàl ×�f4ÔÕá?â(âÔ (……)(�.�ã B)
2. �¨Èî���
"NOTU;<5MdP%¼�¢�FR¯·©�Á�Và>?�³Æ3
4��J���`ÛKJ�©ì³ÆÙ©�ªªÈî�ò-\ò)Èî!Å©
34á=`xàÃ;��¨© Â�¯-=n�¢ðþ5M�dP¾�UJ´
75
u¨��ö²6()À¦�(B)� r��X¾�sx¾�V©��s34AÝ
ÁûF��5MJ´e��¨©÷ÆÀ¦��56Xï�øb3©¾�VKJ
i©²5M:�(B) -b !��l,�U�¨@�gA©ä�ìsxdP
���JÀ�3i!Åô�����©34ìÝÁPf5MdPÅa���
��Çê(¾z½Õºq�Á����ç� )²
;4ä�åæ�ç=#è�.é~(Sê!�J1�)*���ëì[
í=���#KG��îïðñqò�STó�ôõiö�)*�ST
��.÷ø#ùúûü�ý4��û�#J1���þ����ª�,
-�.f;}UZ������ªÖ�(U�� (�q?¿À B)D
01°el�*,-�.h��j¥�/�?�Kc��]� �0
1³lU�fg����«�²4hb��� �®®¯ ��{�
��01l���;4���;�ª��;4�S�fô��(U?m
n#����ô;�õi�ã(U�j�k�D
«�,-�����L�q?���?jË;g�,-��¾�,-Ã
��� R�(S,-���J1�!#"J�#$�,-��
ËKÁ�L�q?ó�mn%&'��(�,-�³���K�.�
��)*�+,-.�/01�2�ÃÄ�3¹�ã®®¯
2K#4¥��k567ST��.,-��89:� 2002 {á��)*�.,-�;h89:��<�j¥�56 (……)(��¾�.�ã B ÁÂ)
Y�� r��¡¢�Z·z©³5MdP¾UÅv¯·©34¿`�Å
)��Æôh�²³3i���_èů٩��?�x�Æ34f9:�;
<ú_ >UÈîã�*Åv·¯©34º�ôWð�3i?@���z]©
��ÝÁHI&U?@e�Ez4��¨©%&D2���ÈîB�Æô��
�©dP�ÁdP��x�©�JÀÁ�JÀ�-�²Ö×EzÀ�¨�
u�©��1À��AB�=��ð�Ù5MdP¾Uzj²
76
³´êů·©��?�x�Æ©Pf5MdP¾UWQ©34Á>UC
bì� ¾!Å�´ê©Ý²÷ØÙ ���¶·²Y r��¡¢©���
Z·z34�§Î��â�F5MdP�êê!ÅAÝÁ�J���©ÇÂA
ÝÁ0åxì�´ê��B²ä�©%HSNO�Ó;<5MdP�FR÷
<©¾UFR���,2��Æà�m+�a�²��¯Ù©aFbNO�ï
ùðA+Z§@0ª�'ã � çÕÎk.�á�ÄÅ\#ÆM"b¾�©
]^_ZNO�5M"*¤÷©[F�È��¦<�¢â��]�ש÷AB
5M�F����'�Aô¸1cNFR©dP��Ïô¾�Ez©ÇÂ�Z
�¬z���5MdP¾!Å���,2��Æôn�m�©ZÜS�"ì�
z�W���´ê²
"#$ů·©�«34b e�f;�dP5M�¼û©¬¤0��
F�5M4P�Ú9©¾v�4P�®"m�=b5M9:ɯ�Ç;<�
ÈP(¾z½���ç�þÕº��jþw�Î )²�b ã.Ò���g
v©34Í¢È ÒU�ê@�ÊA��©¯ÛÜ5MdP�;<©¾ìÁ�
=Æ5©D2f5MdP�¢CÍ®ç.�U�F�5M%=A��gv
V©¼�ìÁ�=Æ5©D2fSÒU��Í-�ô�©-À¸ÂÉ.ã34
%& V A �sx£PøY�3if5MdP�¼ûÁ��¥©�s Z
��dV�
0Ë�4=�'(�������¾01f;^Å(¥>?@�1A?
#;H����Ú����B\#>C���ÆD?E1�"J%�F
G@?RST(HI�f4\�#��«�C?úRJCK����m
nkLM®®¯
~'��(SU^_fg��.NO�K�.P6�QR�]#ÎSË
;g®®¯
Y���;<�8©�Û�34D2fS5MdP¿=ɯ�¼û��1
ÆÁ¿*��©�5MÊê�ìôÀb íe5MdP÷¾�õ�©¾��Æ
77
àrò�xÊï�²TTozj�9:�;<��X©á´?34o)�Ç.
-=ÁH��u�©[F\aF\]^_�5MdP¾UzjáÆ34üå)
Ç.�©ÇÂ�Zâ�ÌWtÁ�Çê©þ5MdP�¼û;<x�o²�÷©
YSAB�¾zj�;<ÆGHç½�©¿Z5MdPþ�¯=n9�Wo�
R9«©¾zjÍÁº�˲
(�) F�5M%&3i(�sF�5M4P��� )
�w^�5MüýF����?@�q�ôR5Mñ¿���ÈÜR?©
AB�F�5M9«×ÑS]AÔ 6 ��: 28.28 ��qy(�æå©2011)ã
: 2010�bú©��òæ�A³5ò × 11.5�ò©ì�9«× 1�7�58²
³F�5M¾U3ip�¯·©YS�«34tá)���F�5M4P�
�v9©ÇÂÁ�T2 r�áHIF�5M\F�5M4P¾Up�;�
Ó��¡¢©����ç�q«©��1Ƴ³F�5M4P¾U#$Å�v
���ÓFR��Ñv9`��¨@�GH²�F�«¬�,�ÌÍ Îvn
F�5M4P©NO�ÓFRìÁ�Ñ�3i!ú©w¢���
� 4-2NO�F��F�5MGH
FR ��¥y ,2 � 1998 � â�½^Ï^F�çæ�ÐQ 911²Ñ� vnÐQ��\ªXïN¯|N 1998� â�æûÍ�aF 1980 � vn1cN5MüýXï]^_ 2002� vnå�5M>Ä[F 2014 �Z«ä� RÒÓ5MçæXï\!^5Md
P¾P
58 w ¢ R � � ©� F � 5 M � � � Ù â P î �© 2011 � 6 p 21 � ©http://udn.com/NEWS/FINANCE/FIN9/6410802.shtml²
78
Èܯî�5MF��4úÞß�\R��59
Ç©Y���Z·z©�,ÒUPQv9F�5M4P©ÑTÆ�«F�
�;<��²AB�«t�¬��þF�5M4Pä[S Ω�÷HI�«
34¿���3i©34�z�%&òæZÓ×y�4:òæ©��áf¾Up
�Á�Ut,�®"©fS34�[���F�5M4P©×y�4:òæAK
IÆKJÇ.�²¼�©¸�=n��=ðÛܾU¯øô�WQ�¡¢©�Ò
���©ì̳=GHmüðÛܾUp��;<!v²ý³Z�rs��
8©"34%&òæ�n�ZÓ×y4:òæ�n�¯j�©��we��¨@
��
1. 34fF�5M\F�5M4P�n�
��=ÊjÆÔF�5MÕ©ÁòÀþF�5M®®bÔF�òæ·§Õ©
�¾�,���3ñ¿���F�5M�gô�²F�5M��o»(>V\
78\æ0)X��»h�êëÁ&©TTÆZ�j5M��b�¹�[jêë
:²¼��Þ8¾êë:ý¥©��ô��?�5ñÔc>V��Õ`fG©ì
ô=Çb!Øò`#:æ0ê멳û��î�Á��(9:�©2011/04/13©ª
¨�ס��)60²
YZ�����Û�©34fS�F�5M��,�©���Æþ�1b5
Mêë�äå²¾Ù"ì��i�«3i�ë�©û5MdP�>V5Máè
³��F�5M����X©Z�=þ5Müý:�9«;�x�o²
&S34%& VfSF�5M�4Pl9��V©34%& V A sx
q¿Zln¾U4P©��Æb v��U;<#$©�;��òNfF�5M
59 w ¢ R � � ©� F � 5 M � � � Ù â P î �© 2011 � 6 p 21 � ©http://udn.com/NEWS/FINANCE/FIN9/6410802.shtml²60 w ¢ ª ¨ � ©� 9 : � / Ý Á 4 P F � 5 M ð Ö f �© 2011/04/13 ©http://mag.udn.com/mag/life/storypage.jsp?f_ART_ID=312451²
79
¾Up���ײä�©ÓìsxF�5M¿è³�µ¶AK1òÇS567
8©F�5M¿ìí�µk��Æàâ�©Ùd56\>VLMáè³��²f
S34�âF�5M�3i¡ì©����¼�³Æç©�Fò¯AÞ LM©
ÇÂ�����U¨Ít�qô¯v�4P²ÌÍ Î� Á��'q�©�¯
ìÀÚ¨F���vno����v��²ÇÂfS�Fò¯Ù©¾Æ�U��
¨Ít�@�ðV©5Mq����E5©ì=C�ô��¨Í��¯��²
2KST�TUà�K������?VW34mnú�XY�³�0
1Zª�[\;4TU�ôú]#^_l)*®®¯
`÷(/���ab0cK��d�=>�.�f4=>�.�Ë�e
5K����f;}�01KU=>�."fëì��¨g��R��
����hLi�jkR;Hlop�V.�?ëìK�4ú�=>�
.|�®®¯
���=>�.�m�(H�����b?�"þ�;4ÉÊ�01K
�=>�.�h�noØÙ=L�Ú(RSTµ¶fH�.pE
®®¯
2K�noJ��K;4Î��qÕ��%rU=>�.�ÉÊ�2K
KS��mnst�³�Kuvwxyz{|}���.È�R@��
~n¾�������×R���F�\�¾���KL=Ú(ST
HI�h�¥�?#�I�����=L���(/��I�Ú��
b���#��mnË?ôST��I³����K��;�����
=L��I��ªÃ��jkJ��R7l�����fH���îï
K'(z{|�9:þ�?#f^?�(��)�f³��÷��9:
�ÉÊ�ÒË�È����9��f¬=�;�û�³?#jú�Ë
��fx���.¾Z�«Ñ�#�÷0 @Æ9:��¡�f\�K
¢?#£a��)* i�;4�¤ (��¾��3¹�¥ B ÁÂ)D
ä�©&SF�5M4P�l9©àWòÀþ��Îk5M���öç
�©�ØF�5M4Pé��9:;<��ã©À5ÙÚÎk5MfF×æû
���²34%& V B �sF�5M4P�Îk5Müýô´È9:;<
80
�Ké�cã¯�j©º�lnF�5M4Pm�ÀÀ5ñß��¾Up�Û
�ÜÅ©�¾�Îk5M¿;<�µkÆ0åô��©ì³ÆÙ©�vKé�\
Z��F×æûbc�Îk5M©��vé�\Z;<5M9:ßÛR¼û
bc�F�5M©�¯³�ZôÈ}���öç�²5Ù�!���©¾Æc
Ê�&��Z,�µ¯�ú�©¾Æä�Uà½���©÷ôÆlnF�4P
²´Åf���²
¦f��=>�.%�a�§�.pEË�¨��)*a©ª�Z«(v
Ê®®¯
��%��X¾¬��¹��=®�ûMN¯f4!"°�±�D²�
MNa�³Ë�´µ�#A¥����ª¶³�\Ë�·%�Ú¸�¨
%�Ë~¹�º �»1NOã¼�NO®®¯ %��=�Q'��)
*½Ö����"��³�®¾Ú¿9Àð��ÁÂàl ×�J³#
ÓlÃL&���DÄ��ÅÆKÃLU�Ç�lÈÉÃLEFMN»
®®¯
�����Ê<����KËËÌST�.©ª�±¯��§à�Í�4
Îr���ϼÐ��Ñ�ô�#^_aÆÓsª=>�.�éÒ�Æ
Ó&�ÀðasªDÒÔ�%�(&�=>�.�ËÕ¨+Eðñ��Æ
��ËËÌST2��.÷ø�;Ö�Ñ ��¾��3¹�¥ B Á¯D
YZ��dV��©�«34m�®Z�F�5M4P��v9¯�c¸"
_èÅ\´êÅ�#$Å�UoÅv©��5M9:%HSNO�ÓFR÷<;
<ÏÐ���²Pf!ÝF�5M4P�ÞÌÍ�v�©H�"¬`¨Íz�
J�©�� Î'P�'Põ;ú©��ZF�5M4PCbc?�Èþ�©�
¯P�ß�ߪ 20%��àÚæçEå±3� 61²
�J¯·©3ñfSF�5M�n�Æþ�1bé�©:©ÈF�5M:ý
61 H�"þF�5M4PsB�L¨Y������'Põ;�sB.L! ©f�ß�s�©l,ß�È��² 6��Z�©?@�È�¯:; 20��©ZßLÓëÑF�§DÓ�ádPæ0bc©!?ßFò©��bæçôèéþ�²w¢��¥�©�F�5M4Pä[ Î�©2011� 4p 19�²
81
¯ì��;��9«©4P�¢C0åâøù!O©���쬡vß���L
8¢C²H�"ÌfR?©AB×Á�n 3UF�5M4P�vy©�ÌÍ�v
�q�©�4\�P�«ì� �¹Ú62²
2. ×y4:òæ�n�
m�34�«���©F�5M4P�!úm��%& V��¿�âq�
¸ã¸äðe�X©�ÏtF�5M4P�n¡É7©�üáÆb AB�R
;<¯x�©�K34 Vq×y4:òæ�óX©34�«����Æx>
���_�Z56789:¯Ù©��F�5MÆ!³=ì��J5M9:�
9«©¹ÉìÀ5678:� ë©e÷ÀAB�56789:Á�e�f�ú
»_�
5M:� A � r¥�sÓAôÆà·�F�5M4P��¯©Çb!³
34��?�x=nÂ��Fò¯ABLM�8Y©¸�ÝÁ¾U8Y©ij=
F���ìÝÁȲ³5678!ů·©AB�«�ZåÛ��ÓFR�ÑT
1Á®¯Hb�/©�¾à8pBÚ¦©Çb©æ=å���©�òì=å��
�©�?ÀF�5M4P�¢�&ï���S���=ô=`ÛG�ò���1
Á©�[ðþç©��õ��£P5\øY��£P�©¾H�³Æ>ç�3i
Úv©�XFo£�56ªª�½6�c��©AB��Àè�Êj�x�¯1
Æ1ÁAB���é
04Ú�H�Ë�jHZ=>�.%��'(�=>�.%��Zª×�
³��=>�²=��NOã³Ë?Kf�NO�²01�تØÙ=L
�Ú(STUV.��·¸(/�=��ÙÚ¢£jZ�«�]#��
(ñ�STÚõ$Ò�$ËR�ÛL=Ú(³��·¸�fË�~=Ú�
ÜÝÞ+«�Q�ßàÚ��hàÚ»»�á�U�jZ�1A�#�ÆD
62 w ¢ � � ¥ � ©� F � 5 M 4 P ä [ Î �© 2011 � 4 p 19 � ©http://money.chinatimes.com/news/news -content.aspx?id=20110419001118&cid=1210²
82
ST����â;���K'ãä�«�f4j�åæç¿�Ûãäè�
0mÛ�è���_éjkç�áê���®®¯
ST=>�.%�ªBCôÚ]ë¶ST�����jËì+¦f�S
ÚU�\Ë?m01í���/STªØÙ=>�NOã�îï/�0�
ËHZ�®®¯
01ªØÙð(+í=Ú+ñRÚ+Ë�Æ��ú�Ú1A?(�"J�
òRË?(���â;�óo³�ú���«�f�ôõ��X¾ú�ª
öÁ÷��ø�4ù��ST]#3{�����Kfg�d�=>�.
%�(ú�0û¾ST�����b#ST����ª�Ö=>K]#�
���üýàfK�k®®¯��¾�.�ã A Á¯
Þ�¯©³¸��Å¿sx�©®¯ôÀ£�ÆÂ��Fò¯A³5�Ç
¶²5M:� Bìsx©F�5M�ê�)Á�z½Æ?Á³e�\ª�l3©
ä�1?èéu*�5Müý²Çb¼�Fò®?e�E$5M¥©àW¥ÈÓ
�x��Æ=ô= xGø�F����5MÈ�=n�t�@h\5
Mªª���FRXLM©ijÁ¥È®¯AôÆÓ�x��»�Ƕ²¿Z©
x�¯341Æ��Pf�UÇêe���©6�]^_\aFS34�F�5
M��¦@©AB-Á�=;<F�5M²
STKf;}#JC��ªÍ�=>�.(H�Ú1¾JCªR"J=
]U�.+s¼þU�.q?�LM§¡��# 40%�m�Í�ª#Í&�iÙ¬�����ªÍ&�iÙª&��f�=>�.� Ó�o
ªXY��L����.pEÕ 32%�f³�¾JCú]ªl89:U�.�J1���jËì�pEGKj�jÚ(¯�fHá�=>
,-�ª�þU�.XY��L�#[»hi��ô�m�/[·¸
ËÆ»�³�ªþU�.�ãä ÒË�oª�XY (®®)
89:��<�j¥�56�m�/JK=>,-�.Î�|��A
ðRt���ST]#;]�.û��æ�Alª��D�L#�Z�
��¬ÙÚ L��ª#Z�Úá�89:l���������0�
�J1K;q��a³��K89:���ST�Ë�ÆfgU��f
\�����!"��Qª���(H��.�#�;4���]#K
83
����ÜàÆ�)*�+(®®)
þ=ú�¾�ØÙ=>�.���K�Ã���@��;}qU�.%
��ª89:(��XJ�q���J� ��0(�XÛ·a�89
:¬í=?Kf|#c}qU=>�.%����fc4=]��!Í
��2004{²�� ×��4ú����³æfc4=]Ê��
[2KKuvwxª9:;4=>�.%��K²4q��X�ÚÀ
ð�ôj¥Ú"¶(ST³��#µ$¶R%&'�('�.ðñ�À
ðã��)*�f�89:+Ñ�fgjZ,-fHÚK��Î��9
.à�Ë?$/0�.�ðñ�f�Z��«�2K#4!"³�=>
�.%�BC?KfC12�q��J3�;�ª#45Ã����Ê
<����×fg��.��ÆËÆ�X�6���4!"�3�]#
"JNOa,-�ðñ�X¾=>�.Ë�b#ª70�Úá?(,-(��¾�.�ã B ÁÂ)
ä�©6()À¦� Aº�ë�F�5M4P�l9©�ìsx"r!Å
���©"r¸�ÝÁ¦@©ij©AB�F�5M�õ;�³1=ä�©X
î'Á�+���ò-©¸�3i!ÅÝÞ"ÚÛ©��ì�"9�Êj¼
ûãÂ�©Y4:òæ¯e��?�FGÊ8Æà>?�©�F�5M4P�
����X©ÑTìÖ�Áa �ý�FGÊ8�4:ò橾fSF�5M
4P���÷<��ì�o�ʲ
f;£���,-«�Ú]rs�K����01#]#89Ó:+f
;¦°K<{�³��ªU��f�hi�!"�0��E=ST��
�Úá>~?@;G�«f�������!" (®®)
ST�Úáj�A��X¾�@!½�Új¨����j¥�ÚBC�
«fH�D�û¾�Ej��"f]²CÇÈ��2KFa²4=>�
.%����]#JC%�ڸG�Fa�HI �fEaJKP8
�ÆÓ(��¾�q?¿À A ÁÂ)D
6()À¦� B fSF�5M4P�·"©��T�AôƲ´l�>
û©÷Æ34´¸��¨[o5MJ´�ò-�ªª²ä�©F�5M4P�
84
7ù�µìÆ�U��©Æ!1Á�Fò=7ù©Fò!®e�øù5M©Æ
!=�F�5M4PXe�LM©¾áÆ34���4P¥©��x��wÀ
��²¼�©"����1Æ�o>V©¸�"�ÝÁÚÛ©ijPÁ�UF
�5M4P©fSABõ;F�5M¾!Å©��ìÝÁÆ��*��²
0û¾ÙÚ¬Úámnoª�ÒË�/;�ª�Kuv1��|�ªB
Cl��ùú�.÷ø�Ú(=>�.þ�á�oÕ (®®)
��0�EÜ�,o�L��0��û¾Ë;�ª�KÎS�%�|
���L�#4!"�³�;�MNO�QªPQ+E�RÁÅmn¥
ÆS�.%�lµ¶V.�Ë���:+�.%�T5L=ÚNO
Þ+fg\?\²UVíW9ú��8!" (®®)
b0È���XY£=��@úM(LM�jk�ª#;ZÚR[y�
=]�[�í=�ç=lê!�¾JCJ1�=>�.?U�²C²\�
�Zª��ªBCl����#�9�]^��H�I���=>�.(®®)
K=>�.�É_�0��û¾ªÍ��Öª)*�I��`�01R
=L)*jËì��DÚáab( (��¾�q?¿À B ÁÂ)D
3. �¨ç�
Y��5M:��6()Àrs¦��¡¢©�ZÛ�º�×y�4:ò
æWX?ÛF�5M4P�l9n¡É7©�1Æf�9z¼û�x*�²�
XÁ�2(5M:� A�6À¦� B)fS4P�l9�ZÙÆ1�d©Ýô
·��[�²fSF�5M4P�l9©��ø"34õö�)��Z¯³Á
àW;Å�WízCã¾U²fWîWXÆ-b´þ��Ãàq�c©ÏîA
B¬ôSä��[©ì��ï�MQ)R¿ÁPd�L�0���©-=e
�¾þ!ú²
85
Pd�L�0��b�©�>?�³Æ©pJÆ!¬�3�Z���È
²©J!Å©AB�5Mªª�ò-¼�ôÆ��©���Ƹ�Ûx�¨©
¸�þ¿Áò)�)kw��ö©;��o�¼û©¾z½34�«1�úz
Hb�J���!ú²pJ!Å©¾joE��È´?àW:��©?vn
���]O©¸����U4P�l9©Æ!´?w�xeF��«¬�
v0�Ýt��vX�4ú© �xAB���¥�©¾UáÁº34¯�ð²
fSAB�9:;<¯Ù©�dñ�¤�U��©i³ÆAB�9:3i
���Æ�òW�N�²Rz1ÆÎkÝ�9:�cÊ�&©dP9:�c
Ê�&ƨÍz©5M9:�cÊ�&ÆH�"©ñó9:�cÊ�&ÆñK
À©èÓ9:�cÊ�&ÆèÓz©ÐJ9:�cÊ�&ÆFRÍÉÎÏKV
À©n);<9:¿´n�)�cÊ�&ÆnKÀ²�¾¼X©� Rz�
ÆýÆíe9:;<ú»Rq�©�Ó�&Îk�Æýá1ÆüýF�×
ةǸ�ë��Züý�Fò�ï[¯��9:u��ë�©¾Í�Æ�
U%¼o���²
Z56789:(è³KLM@5678)¯Ù©F�5M4P���©m
�Ò���fS9:�»ÁÁ¿�îÛAB�5678�Zwµ�Ez
�f©�ÙF�²�÷©¸�ý�?;�9«©ôÆ1ÁÅD�î�]567
8³�Z�²AB¿?Ð{�©²´Æ���\��ôÁ@�57ªª©¾
�Fò-ÁÖeAB¿ðe�LM�8Y©ì-Æ;<´9:\ì���9«
�»��¡²
&S�žU�V©5M:� B�·"ÑT�ZÈZõG�
01?mnP��¦c³�f4��'(�BCgl)*� (®®) D
Ã�é�²Ö�.,-lde�fU,-���«�01���´lP
O�¦c³�no01Kg;4hiD����� )*²;4���
Å ,-�NOaÃÄ�fc4�jË;g��;4�,-($¶ST
���� �«b�;ÕÕ�j� ³����«f4��~01(k
86
³Ë�fCKÁ�X¾ËP#]#��(S�01�EST³#fg�
NOÓ��01no�¦c³�lÓlU�¬m��lU�01ªU�
���� �!Án�lU�4,-������ôú]HRSTU�
jZ�Å ��(�ôJ1#7�#o�#��ô´(STU���
�Ú���ÅmJ1�]Ú;�(�fÖ��Ö2�h³�áê��
�ÃÄ(®®)
�Q�ÃÄ(Å���.bÆUÇÈ�ÉÊ��ËÆÌÍSTK���
.�ÎÏ(®®)
Uj� ¬ÇÈ�NO�fÖ,-�.Ë?�p�X¾�Qx,-�.
����KfCqr�st�f4��\ËÐ)*��X¾J1u÷�
ø�4ù��ª)*�ÉÊ�vs�ÙÚ�\³���k���ªw\
Ö(�J1ª(01f|³�no01Æ#J1]#�vsÙÚ�f"
fST#Z34���(®®)D
�½©?ú»56789:�;<©"_èů٩34³����%&
�ò)�ªªÈ��¨u'ò-©¸�;<���5678ªª©f9
:�»Á-Á�²
³´êů٩��?õ;�ìôD1Æþç©20S£PøY��õ�
�©¸�ÌW r�¿�s�©o£�57ªªef�Ä�¬®¯®Ã©¸
�ABÝÁÂ��ò¯�¡���ªª©i�´¸�ì��W���´ê�î
�]f�F�57ªª¯Ùô�1Æ�ö�÷©��²\�ï;�57ªª©
-Æ��=nøòÀ56789:�F�5M¾Uµ¶X;P;ì�Ƕ²
³#$Å÷<©NO�Fm�áZõ;4P¯��F�5M©��ÓFR
� pJl3�©©J!Å�Êêì£Î��©"��ù©��õ�©¾Uz
j�«AB�hDÍÁÌW´?ç��ð! (Õº���Ujþe�ç� )²
(�) 5M�ì�ë�—"Ké���*x�:�\9:�
5MdP�F�5M4P���©³�*�÷<Á�Uà>?�®«ë
87
�©i³ÆþÎk5M�Ké�dV©ë���:�9:��dV²÷¾�
®«§¨©��ìf56789:Á¤�o�ÔÕ²3ýKV9:��1�S
3ñüý¥©³ZXññæ�&½á��F�5M4P��l9Æ�?�©
Nú34��¨I5M"¯Ç²©±Æ3K�©ìõö�)���F�5M4
P��l9²
�÷©`(LUXï5ññK,G ¹Î���ÐJ��!©nzF�
?;<F�5MAô´?¨"`lnF�5M¾P©÷Ʋ´�õ5M�:�
�*©ÀF��5M=næå;<©ø�³=]�;<F�5M��L©Ae
÷É�F��5M°±63²
¾�24:òæ��V��fn©��Vz �«AB�;<5M9:�
��Uà>?�)*ûüë�©i³Æf5M���®«d�z;V�ô�²
�bþ5M¼��üý9:©� �ÂFòæûq�©ì�Zv�;<©Ç
ýá�FR�R©÷+��Ó�9:�ÀÅaF�¸¹²�Åaå��
Jp�|f¸¹�©F��æç�H�JêÑØ�"Áhn�¦@À5+xÇ
²©���!O³ÆâÚ��F�ê�64©ÀF��5M&Ú�ÂFòæû�
5Mþþ©ä�!Å õ�5M¾P©ÄÅ"r8Ì�W�øY��¢C��
�é©NÙF�5M���È©Â�F� VIP�²P�«¯³565²
ä�)*ûü -b5M�*�Sú»56�5©òV¶*©b§òÝ
×Øú_�"*�üý©çl×Ø�vû�þþ©÷ô²´ÁÆ�é��¬v
Ý��©Ý��:��x�²ÇbÁÆ�é��¬vÝ��©Ý�:��x�©
À�F�]�é��5M#$�.�©��5+�v�·�©�� 5M�&
63 w¢���� ©�é9:�ñæQ� �©,Gö© 2010 � 11 p 24 �©http://tw.nextmedia.com/applenews/article/art_id/32984228/IssueID/20101124ãXF¥�©��ÕY;< F � 5 M ? þ ý � © �© , G ö © 2010 � 11 p 25 � ©http://news.chinatimes.com/2009Cti/Channel/Life/life -article/0,5047,11051801+112010112500056,00.html²64 w¢ª¨�©�9:����F�5M ��=Ô�F�êÕ�©2009 � 4 p 20 �©http://www.cier.edu.tw/ct.asp?xItem=10534&ctNode=61&mp=1²65 w¢8��©�Á&F�5M����©http://thchou.blogspot.com/2010/11/blog-post_29.html²
88
�Â×Øæû�H�îj 66²
�÷©¾��V��¤1Ær 5M�&³ÆÁ�ô��®«Ý,
2©²·�3�¸�x,2Ó���vÆ�!q�¿�;����²
&S5MÆ!=�:�©9:�©�E�e���rs���X© r�
ì�s Ó�f¾Up��®"�dV©�Xìúx &S56789:�z
j©ý³rs�8��¸��
1. 34f5M�:�\9:��n�
&S5M�:�\9:����©34%& V A �s!Z34cÊ�
&���¯·©��ÆüvôZ�:�\9:�¯,2�²Çb34�&�q
û&���Æ×Ø�&Jæû©Æ�5Mªª�;<ìá��ZÂbêÆ�z
;V²5MfS34cÊ�&÷<©1ÆGHüvwÀEå�Åv²¼5M�
�=vé�¥©i³���mðZ�F��`�F��µ¶¯�+²F�×Ø
�æûÆæçJ´��x��©�F�5M�ZÆZ5M9:�;<¯��²
é��wÀEå�j+©�Zå�B±ÃW ©�F�µ¶6fô�=©1
À��Ê8����²�½ê�l?ìÀz��²&S5678¾Uzj©3
4%& V A ì�s ·"©-b5678�Îk5M�;<!v6fÆô
��©¼F����`�©5678�,1Á=vF��"��©-Á�ñ�
vy²
K�.�(/�01mnË?�J��²;4���mn1�¢?#£
�ÉÊ�ÒË�e'sx)*�ÉÊ�¼lb#MÉr1�%���D
�����2K�yé�Ú����û�f³À��.f;}�e'
¢?#£�ÉÊ�;�.��ª�(��h�³#;H!"�ªl7
8�m�/fÖmnË�zIV.�KÎ��{;à��ôJlu��
66 w¢8��©�Á&F�5M����©http://thchou.blogspot.com/2010/11/blog-post_29.html²
89
|��ú¯�«�Q/�.���ª�¾���h�²CKÚ÷#£
��}���R,-�.�²���l~���ªVW� (®®)
�Q/�.aª��ÉÊ�ϼ��xcã��¹�bÆ#5��ô
J?�¯�Ë4�ÆK�V�#µ���ª��ÉÊ�?�¯�˪�
�ÉÊ�¢?¯�f>~�UËR��X¾K@����ËZ���K
P8�Ë�å�K6���¡\Ë�åDmn#�Æ�³���=>�
.�(@����;����R��û�³�/#%U=>�.��û�
�ó�³���?�¯�³����MN������Ë5�U��.
pE���«�ÐÑ�=>�.¾Z�Ë�t+E.���4�û��
OhLsª(®®)
ôe(H������)*3~"J�§�.?mnù�«�¬"J=
]m�(mn>ú9+�)*�`÷(/�=�������?â(â
v�'(�Æ?��Yé¯1��¯�ÉÊ�^_MN�hL�K��
��;�?Ö2�(��¾��3¹�¥ A ÁÂ)D
Y���dV��©fS5M�==!�:�\9:�©Z34�n�¯
·©���ÆÁjà½�²!³³IJ5M�Åv÷<©5©ô�n�à6þ
�UÅv�5Måz�:�\9:�©Çb5©ô��°±�ÆFòæû
�}~²ÇÂ5©ô�n�AÝÁÞ"f¿Á�5Mþ�kâ���[�²w
�©à�rð³ÆZF�5Mbêê��V©¾z½³�Z�ÈS�:�\9
:����©1?�µÛ�©34�n�À-bâÚ�:�\9:��;<©
m�=n�eR9«²
2. ×y4:òæ�n�
&S5M9:����©×y4:òæ�n���ÆHÁ¦@�©Ç�
S¾U4:òæÆ��àC5Mªª\ÅfD��ò©ÇÂÓ�fS�ý��
�U8�©n��dVáÀ�34cÊ�&t,�®"Á¿ô�²5M:� A
90
� r¥úx©5M�ZÆ�Uà4:�9:©��¥��ÁwÀþ�@*©
¾�¾@Æ�ZA�ô �ã5M:� B ÆdÞþ5M�+��Uµ¶©
e§LM�zjËSÎk5M©¾z½´?x�xæç�<Æ©�®5678
��Óøùþ�© �Z�b¿°��æû9:�©Æ¢È�J5M��z½
x`9:�;<²6()À¦� AÆ"5Mò-��¾V¯s©��sÁ��
-b5Mò-��ÆÇbæçê�ô0Ø¿Ü©�Ó�s¾Æûæçê�¼�
��c©¸�=��õ�ò-��Í©ij,=ì�z�o�R9«ã6
()À¦� B ÆdÞþF�5M�Îk5Mjõ¯s©�PfÌW5^µ�
:5M�!v=©Ó-b¾Æo#$I§¿Ü©�341Æ��zů��²
;�Ú�,�(/�Ë��³�ï���³�����.³��.�"
ff�Ë~��X¾ýÖ���#"o�(��.;£�4����.
�;4j%���� (®®) �.\��Å(j¥��t�«��.�Å#¢?���(� (®®) ���.#J�sx(\#¢?��������fc;¦ËÆfCc�¯�L�JDË��vÊ�(®®)(�.�ã A)
¦f��.R�#c4���m�/zI�R�³�e'�§�.�f
³��ª£õ+,EF(OP�;4�� «�[�.��¬�OI�
"f�e'+,���J�¨�.;É_�ðñlU���)* (�.�ã B)D
~'��û¾�.Ëe'��Òe¢?#£�ÉÊ��¡�@û¾�§
�.ÚáG¢��X�X¾+E6�Ë�£\²�fÕ(/�0û¾ý
4Ú�#Ë��^_a�¤�I��«ªë¶����#�D¥?xÚ
����Õ�;����˪�+E6�;¡;4¦§Dëì[��þ
�¡j¥¾Ú¨�©�Kª+E¼ «ÆD«�#�ªfC¥��û¨
�Þ+¦f��Ë�ª�����Q�J1��U"Jw\Ö�ú�
sx�¬��.I��3�~T���;���¥�® (�q?¿ÀA)-
k'=>�.a�§�.(/�˯°�������=>�.;U;
4��(sª�«"f�.�����±�¢?EF�E�«�ÛH¼
91
l��§�.�2K�?��.������h����«��Q�#
��D�B?��.���÷��.���?Bà0��X¾ú]ËR
ÁlU²H²Fv�I��;£�³ÇÈU�«�¥Æ�I�(U�
f����ªl�~��«�[+E\����´ ;�Mf/¬"
J=]m©��²\��«�2KZª�TUKµ¶�ú]�´ª·]
;Õ�fH����ªÖ�(78� (�q?¿À B)D
3. �¨ç�
"Z� r��dV¯·©wÀ�Ò«*��³Æ5M9:�q�©Æ!
À5ÙÁ�Îk5M��÷©¾U��³34�n�¯·Æ�Sç½�©»
Á�F�5M¾z½�ZÈ9:�;<¯·º²:S×y4:òæ�n�©!
��þ5M9:@�:56789:¯ç�©³À;C×y4:òæ�n��
�-b5M�9:��5M�*�êê��Æô¸E�ãþq�jb�Îk5
M���56789:��U཯ç�©³�Zà�að��:�3icã
�¢C²5678�ZB¼��æû9:©¸Â�¯³f34��¾z½�
Êê©ìÁøY���)�=n×����ãÇ©Îk5M\�Â×Øæû
��*ÆôÀB�� ²¾ÆUKJ8p���ûü©ìÆ×y4:òæ�N
ú34��Ê꥿êÆ�8Y²
�÷©�x�ö� ©�5M�ô�Z9:���¾U����
ÆY34á��F�5M¾U�{¿�;�²�«�F�5M"�©��f5
MË�l, ÌWÇê©5M"ì�Z5Mñ¿ôÛZX�cÊ�&ß�ùú
qôt¼�!"¯s�§òÝs�5M:ý©A+ìf5Mâ��!Ol,Ì
W�µ²S¯¯Ù©�¾UÇê�èédPæ0Ý5MdP¾��F�5M/
��:ý©������XÆBÅ0Å[�²¸����F�5M"�©³�
Z;CH�cÊ�&��'Á%¼o���vy©fS�:��F�5M©¸
�"�!ÅÝÁÄÅ©iH�³Æ�ô�x ²
�«;<�¬F�5M4P:ý�3ýKV9:����;��.�
92
Xúx��¼«#$�©��ç�5Müý:��<ÑØ����Á��²A
BÆ�|å×æç�FR©ÇÂF��5Mþ�6oW á æçìí©Aô
8p�¾tÁ�o���äì]�²Â�©� 78�æ0S©�Ö�5M
þ�ìôÃ8p�K<�ã�=ò×?Áe§-Á5M´ê©_èÅà6Á¼
zÔ�´67²
�S¾�®"©9:�3K-bAB�5M9:!?�xzc©ý�³
1Á;<F�5M¾��©»ÁC�0å�:��]O©õ;øù5Mþ��
��©AB�5M-==z1òÇ�Îk5M�è�©��ZD®ïõ�5M
ªªì�z���9«²AB�F�5MÁ�UK<��=@©�b78æ0
Sö�üý©ä�bcV>V�5M0ª²Z¯A³5�Pî÷<©æ078
P��=¯ø�+�ð©�zj>V5M ô8ÌK�÷�ÝF�5ñÉE©
�Pî³HÁðQ@²÷¼34�Z��«�T§D�PîðQ�j��©
Þ�¯�9:i���³ÀGHÁ!v ²
¼�©F�5M�F�5MÆ�U��ô����©ÇÂ�øûÅ�.
�\Jê\"�\颾@©���á?Z�Ûô��B±¯¢C²Ç©�
n5M9:����:¾P�©��¾P�8Ì�:Úv�5M©¾ÑTÆ�
«»��Zâé�\Ké��:3i©�¥�Â5M9:��Îk5M���
� ²
5M�==!9:��?E�Îk��ãý�àb6©�©��©��4
:�5Mm��Z�ÒUÅvbFRì�zmò�R9«²9:�q�ɯ
�¼û©ôD1Æ5Mªª�&9��©1èé£q÷¯�³:�À\êë\
dPS8F9:©¾m�ÆÎk5M�"{Ó�²Ç© ���=ï��x©
¥¦Îk5M���©ÁüÎk5M��:�5M�ê��8*���¤©A
e÷���qy�È"�\ê��¢CÚÛ�UgvV©ij©5M9:�¿
�;��ÃÑT³�Z>]�� ²67 w¢9:�©���F�5M ��=Ô�F�êÕ�©ª¨�©2009� 4p 20�²
93
(�) %&"�Êê
�«AB���5M9:�%&üý�©m��S"rÇê©e÷ÔÕ3
i���(Ë��©2009)©÷¾z½�Z1b34f5M9:;<¿lÇqõ
ê@�Êê@�3i��©�«c?ÔÕ9:;<�TU"���¸� (��
�©2010)�
!³b5M"f5Mâ��Çê�5M"��ô����þ¿÷ùúqô
t¼!"©5M��ùúZ��qôt¼!"s�§ò©�¸���"\��\
Wà½ÎÙÝ�Ñ\�cÊ�&N3�øùV�zÞ8�ó\§Îuëé÷
!OS²
w�b5^"f5^�:�¿qÇê�5^"�,Ç���,5^�:²
�¿�ðcÊ�&N (�q5M��bq²
��bo£òævé¯A³5qÇê�o£ðPò×vée�ABðP�
L��Á&³5\!5�,©vé¯A³5�©Ûvé�Ú"Ý 27S�7Ë
2ò��©�?¥AÛvéo£ðP5�òV 2ò£��ܲ
��b5M�G�����AB�F���G��q�,©�«�G�
Á�©j�b��¨�G�\���G�\�8Õ�G�(8Õ�Çb 180 �
Z�)Ó�3Õ�G�(8Õ�Ç� 180�Z�)©�j��A�F�5MêP�
�5M�G�©�Fòæ!ávé¯AB³5©���,��q=�I¼©ò
úz�5ñóWG�\ëó�#_\Ù�!Ó#)G�SÈÜ©N;8Õ�Ç
6UpZ���8Õ�G�²
���F�5M�5MdP%&3i���X©�������V(o£
òæ¯A³5)���V(5M�G)�zjÀëx�Wb6©=!â��Ùì
Æ�Uo��©Çb¸�ô=øYâ��u©ij³�"�vF�²ä�³Æ
F�5MÀ¢´¸�ô8���²�«F�5MÀ¢�ô8¯Ojb�ש<
94
Æ���$©<Æ��o�©«�£n¼©òÀÓjL<Æ\Ö×<Æ©÷5
Mñ¿¼;%&&£q¹É<Æã��b:ý��<Æ©Be�<Æ�b��
òV��i\Ê8òV(H�"©2009)²�÷©F�5MÅf�áƯø�+
�ð�§D©�ô��<Ý.���¤�©F�5MÀ¢!;��=´¸�ô
8©��Æ�U%¼o���²
AB�«A�PfEF5MÀ¢ô8�"Yê,©Ì��AB���F�
5Mê륩!l�F�5MÀ¢�ô8© q�wx�«AB�ðô8�
©÷!?çlF�êP�L)© �wx��5MêëÁ�qFR�"Y©
e÷ê,ËSAB�"Y4' (º»¼©2009)²÷�«H�"�ô8!O©³
ÆPfF�5MÀ¢�ô8¯OúzÙ�©!§D¿ËFúzê(©¿�Èq
�J"Y ����ÓF���"� �e�ãÇ©F�§Dô��ABÝ
�¿ËFe�ê(© kZAB"Y¯�,%&L���ý (H�"©2009)²
&S5M9:\56789:�;<© r��¡¢��àWáÆPf"
r�µ¾Uzj©� ��úx�TU?Vq�©ä��;¹p�1ZÌW�
���¸���\�d�SÈS5678��ªª©AB�«àWá1�õ
�©¾ìÆ�; r�;zôgqW�>V²
r�Pf¾þp�¿úz�%&¡¢©èéfS56789:�¯;<
�*�©k�8��¸��
1. 34cÊ�&¿).�n�
&S"�Çê�ÔÕ©34%& V A � r¥�s©¸�"���©
ij:�qy�¸¹©�=³À���Uô¼�ÔÕ©�=Àfgxò×�æ
û©¸�0åâøY�Æ�ï[©�=À���Uô¼���©ÇÂ34�«
fS"��ÄÅÍ�Sç½ã34%& V B Æ"GHô����¯s"
��Êê©�PfF�5M4P�lnsx�U"�����©�¸�G;
95
�\ÈðÇêS©��¥ìsx �FæçJ´���©34²´ÊA�©�
�Æ7\5ñ��5M©mç�,�5M"*��:*�²
2K#ÉÊ��§�.� RÚáôI�2���01K÷6�lH�
h�fË�È;XY�\²��«�����K)*�h�J=f
?#;H¹¸aËÌ�²01HR�.��f;}�J�89"f�©
�¹º��89¹º�»Q³�?K89à��Ö2;H!"��Æ?
#µËÌÚ÷�ÉÊ(®®)
��KP8��¼~����¬"J��§zIV.�KP8����
3é]#Ë;g�˼#ÎS¼~�Ç(U;H9��¼~fH[��
.��»»��O�.I�³#mn¥;Õ�ª����/�.� 61{�9���.@½�Ë��¨þ¾ZP@¹MÇ Ëê;à�(¿À
�.0Á�fHËê;à�ëì[Áã�ÊeY»�fI9���¨
'�#��.@½�«�KP8�=f�#¼~�.��1ã�O�.
(P8�X¾J1K%Ã�����mn�å?l®¨RfHà��f
K�§zIV.���Ë�Æ)0����K�Ç�¿À���2K#
KVW~�.��¬�O�.�ÉÊU;HP8�X¾¬;��§¨�
�sªhLË4;g�2K?�Í~'�hLi(9�ª�J�àÚ�
��b0TU(®®)
��¦7���,01©��EÄ,Ëno¼�?�¯lŹNOaw\ËЪ ��,X¾J©e'�.�¾D�.�¾Æ¡RÇ��+,È EÉ,©���vÊ�P6¾Ë (��¾��3¹�¥ A ÁÂ)D
=>�.�� R(³#MGya©MGyÉÊDMGy�oª��Ì=
�)�Ûõcrs�Á¼~opIÍ;ñ�)aD��89:¼~tU
àÚ�L=IÍ���K¤Îh�)XÌ=�«ú�IÍRST(�»
Ì=³ª»�Ø(®®)
K�.%�ÉÊ�Î�b0�9�'(��.%�ËÂ��ª���q�
b�êZf�uv@�dy#úh¿����&��á?¨=]���n
o9ùÏ��)*�ø�DZª¹Ð©�b0c'(�Ñ8�ST�.Ò
��ÓÔ(®®)
f�4jÕÖ�!"�ST��.÷ø�+EÈ;EF�×��Z7�Ú
96
õ��$#ÇÈ�+E�«\X¾�Ï��4�.ø§�£Ø¢����
@6�µÙ¶�j�kD¾�Ú�ÛO�Ù½�.�¾�b0c¶�âP
â¥DK�4ú�.÷øf�4ÕÖ�Ü"�Ë�åÉst(®®)
�O��mnÈ������U�³�Ú��û¼��.�=E;��.
��a��ÝÞ(��¾��3¹�¥ B ÁÂ)D
2. ×y4:òæ¿).�n�
&S"�Çê¾Uzj©×y4:òæ�Zs�dVÃW ©ÇbÓ�Æ
e�5M�ý�¼©�©fS"�Çê¿É¯�ôt©�,Áà�+�JÀ²
5M:� A �s»Á"�ÄÅ©AB�5M-Á�=ýt=vF��ã"�
�ùr�ê 5^�ì]©¾Æà�Â��Vãþøù5M,-�©ìÆ34
rò.ô¤���C"©Çb¸Â�¯�=³Í� àWì]����²5
M:� Bsx©»Á"�ùr��©AB-Á¸¹)©ì-=;<5MdP\
íe]�[�56�²ä�©&S579:©ÓìsxAB�«Ö×�Æn
B@�5ñ©ÇÂ�"�ö�U56789:�wä²&SF�5M�5Md
P©�G\5MÀ¢�ô8\ç~�æ\ê�w7����©¾U34�«á
1ÝÁKJ0Ø�ÚÛ²
6()À¦� Asx5M¡&��9©ìÇb x"rÇê÷�";<ã
6()À¦� B sx;<dP5MÀÅa���©���X34"��Çê
µµ�bÍ�©Ç©Y34zů�¨�³§ÛKJ>?²
0û¾��ST���ª=>¯�ßͪ�³���ª]^�`(³�
ª<àáhi�01��Æ´�R�³�ú�Ú�"J=]�Ú³�
4�â�����Ø�Q�9Ë]^�òR]��¡�d�=>�.(®®)
`(³�ST���~�D�564ãä��DÆlw8ÆlU�¦c
4>��fgª��ØÙÚ]/Û1=]UËR�«�01��U�+
97
QR��]#��Û1ËÆU�0��U�Ú]á?(�Û��U�0
\��U�0mÛ�Ë�mÛZ�Ú]á?(�Ë£Û��U�0\�
�U�«�0mnä�\]#mnZ�ð?(+2KST���ÙÚ#
�;4L=ËÆU+J1�m01Í&å-«�����99�01
ËÆUf4,-=L���~'��f;}��æm01Z�STË�
,(®®)
�Ïàl,0�Üç,m��T�.0����úèéê���ë'EÄë'ã�Ëbx�O�.��ìí¯ ,P6")*��x!Í Bî,��ïðñ�òM¯» Bîóéôõ (®®)
ST��Dá�j��jö�©��#w8�ÆÓ�«÷'���¹
���4�^7�DST�#JC����mSÚ�+ÒÔ��K=
>¯;þØÙÚ](��"fËb����#+-�X¾+-mnÇÈ�
��pE¾½���f4~ST(k�#����89: �¦ÚÓÒ
��mË�01�(��¾�.�ã A ÁÂ)-
�.,-�Q�4�����b¨§ø�Ë?²\���ã\?â(â
]#����Lùú�����[�Qûüý�£?@�K¨�h�
b#ST¬þí�]��STbmþí°;ÕÕ�Òr���01
�89Ó;#KG¢�Z��D&Ë(�Z���\&Ë(��.�9
564¥�ô01�×4¥�fôSÚKú�&�h�01;à³?
æëâ�(®®)
�Q2K�����ST�?#89Ó��b�ÐÑ��× 10�15 {lu�í=� 1990 {³&Rþ=�¨�%�¡��Ñ�ú�ûü��.û�U�¡�®�í=��0Kú����;�²���§�8
9:¢£]#í=fC¥ú ¡�ë��Ã�«�>\� 2002 {³��U���Q01���]^�Ú]\?]^,-�ïðñ���í=
rs �ïðñ®¨K�É����0¨�ST��ª 5�10{á?����¢£01rs�×��«ËªôíWâ(âú�X¾£?@�
89Ë���K�6�(®®)
ST��]#;4��(��û¡¨��Ë[ç=�,õ�û�í=�BK���û�fH���@¿À(��û�ST]#!Án�ST�oÕ�Kú�û�[�Sú��`»�J1Ë?&o��� �J1
ª��·¸�·¹º»opV.���·®��XJ1üý�~�.�
�(/\Ë?ÎSl)* (®®) «�QðRËÓÊY�Ȫ;c��
98
0�UÖ(�9+�jÎ�«X¾2������]#Ú��Àðf;
}(®®)
2st��.,-��u;4!"�Ã�(l�!"�56K<�Øå
æ�j¥Ú´�«¼��K<�Ø��².K1�XÌ=!"��(
S�1�;HÚ×a��ª@×�=����f4Ì=�!"\�;4
��(®®)
`(³��×?�0��.56ÉÊ��.56�ð(��+]#Ú(
���f~ST�?\²O��ËÌ��.�©�Z,����¡�Ë
Z�]#Ú�����í=¬ú�K,-�.Éʳ#;4��É��
�³��É���(U×Ý�78� ;Ëp���ª��!"#�
W�²ð(��f4�!�ÉÊ (®®)
�Lj¥ÚîR¹'EF¬$ �!"�m�/(ST�¦�.�Jb
lÆËÆ$ 1�!çEFXY�f�����mn>%R� (®®)2K�!"�01îï�=�¼ËÆKJ1;q$ �ËƧ¾J1�
�Ö�f?&Ã�;HJ1(�ÁR�'"��vs��.O¨ (®®)
�L¼~Ã�¢(²�!"�QR�f�40L!"�[í=��³?
)ò�*�Ã�¢�ôJ1l¿À3¹Ú¥(í=ÃÄ�Fê�¦Ï�
�ÓZ¹�«�]#*t(²�ÉÊ�«��Q01��¾�)*,
-�.�X�J1;Hê��b+�bªJ1�ϼfg��Ñ&(S
TU���+-�ý)»»�îÖ=�³X,)ò�fgáÆ-òÃ�
¢(��¾�.�ã B ÁÂ)D
�.ú./÷�ÉÊy��01@ú}Ë�01ËZ�Ò�01ËU�
2KSTÚ�ËRÁUfH�X¾Ú�ä�9����56���\'
üýfH��)*�;£]��mnZ(®®)
uv�=>�.%�3���;�Àtj¥�Ó�noJ��U²\�
ªU²\�³�ªùÕ�²HË�8 �.P6���2çN0 (��¾�q?¿À A ÁÂ)D
�,-�.(/�01)2#34!"�
�.56�78!"�����9:;<=>�.?@A��.56�
BC78D
EF�!"�GHI�J1K=L?#EFMNOP��QRST(U
99
V.�W�EF�BCXY�!"���Z[\]#U^_�9:D
,-`a�!"�2K,-`abXc4de�fg�hijklUR
mnop�V.D
�Qªx,-�.;U;Ö���W�ÐÑ��3¹È�(�~��L
M�HI��01��I(-ò�4���)* (®®)
�ª���R�l9:�3�öÈ�(78öI!"�[��Ç�!
"�f�¹'�9ÉÊ�!"��.�|�9�ËÆU�Ç�×(q~
²¾��Q�=>�.�4¨5±1Ç÷þ±(U�dz���f�j
67�;;¦(®®)
�L88îR�,-`a�!"�Ъ�h�Ë���¼~opV.
�É_(�`a�hi (®®)
,-�.�É_�Ã�¢�(²!"\��ª��Ö�q~á���ª
¬�D(²Þ+«�ËXÃ�¢(\/˼l�˼ST�Ã�¢ª
(�ú��Ã�¢\ª(���f4ÉÊj�����ª��Ö�(q
~�(��¾�q?¿À B ÁÂ)D
3. �¨ç�
HI�Å����¡¢©Z�U5M9:Ý56789:�;9¯·©3
4S#$Åv¿l9��ê@\Êê@3i��©��ÆÔÕ¼«9:;<�
�oÍ�²YS#$Åv�u�zC��©ø�÷�ð³�"ú����´
ê©F�5M\5MdP\5678�LMÒ���á Ç©AB�«��
Dm��"�NO�ÓFR%GH©ÇbaFS���5MdP!Å1��¼
�FR©WÁú_5M44�G\K��GÝ\�G�üý²
�¾�D�©��5Mâ�\5^�:�¿Óo£ò×vé¯A³5S
Çê©APf5M�G\F�5MÀ¢Z,%&"r©À"r��ýu¨©v
n�Û0Ø�ÚÛ{|© Â-=�Á¼ð��F�5M�5MdP�%&3
i©ì-=À56789:Áo��½e²
¼�©YS�«�F34t��)���F�5M4P��v9©ÇÂÌ
W"���"�¥Ãe��.©�«á¬�;¨"�ç�²HI3ñ�dV©
100
F�5M4P��i�èé5M"¨"u³0� 68\�ô8sB.L69\�
�5M�G70\�F�ç~ß��s¨CZÓ�F�5Mâ�.§¾$oþ71²
&S5M9:\56789:�;<©£¤F�5M4P�v9�"��
£Î��©���m·x �ÇÈPã�÷©AB�Áu��³ÆD®�5M
ªª©¾z½ÆÌWFR©�þ��²¸�äξïõ�ªªÎk©¾z½
�mì´?34�È_èÅv�3i��©�Ú�Wò)\#)��)¯;
<©Z�À�J9:Á�7���¯²
4. rs������¨
YSE�����X�4:òæ¿e��rs©�rs������ô
�%�©ÇÂ�����þrs��e�����õö©AÅDB/ r��
·"²
� 4-3 ��rsq������ r�)?¡¢
��
r�5MdP F�5M /
F�5M4P
5M9:� %&"rÇê
68 ¨"�.�8¸��� 4 �¨tb8n5M��ÛZß��[lnF�5M��©��Æb �xF�5M��ß��"î©Z�uÈ\E:¨Cã� 90�¨tbH"ÛÇê�n,PQ�nF�5M��©AÇê§ ©ôÛîÈæç©Fò?øù5MìÁÇê©��Æb �xH�"�nF�5M4P"îã� 115�¨tb!F�5M��bß��[©Fßl��þô�ß�\÷KzÈq8n5M��©��Æ�Z� �Èfg²69 �H�"���F�5M4Pl9sB�L©véòȯ�L�b��Á��é5M����A²�F�5M��u!ã�bÌÌZ:ª!!Ow�ã�b²�5M��õ;é�²70 ��5M�Gzj©F�êP¯A¬ÄÅ©�o£f>VÓöVD�xF�5M��GÍAÊ©¾z½�¯b�NC�ÊË���²ä��5e5z��£P�"w^5M\78\æ0��©¾z½�C�øY��õ�¯��²71 w¢��¥�©�9:��Æ��0 F�5M4P ,oÁ���©2010 � 3 p 22 �©http://money.chinatimes.com/news/news -content.aspx?id=20110322000024&cid=1206²
101
34 V A
ë���5MdP©�Í��e��?�Êê²
�5MdP�·"�Ü©Ç.�ôÆ�Çõ�²
F�5M4P�â9:�¢C©�Íþ�Ö�5M,bSwÀEå÷KR;<�µ¶²
fS"r�µ��ùÍ�罩ôç©���:�xzÔ7ù�ì�ô�?q´ê²Çb5M�bÀÓxH"æûLqçl©Í²�v�;�Êêb�²
34 V B
þ5MdPèé�F�5Mµ¶X¯;<²
�)Ç.34��F�5M©4P�vnÆ�?�©ÆAB5M9:�z�²
Îk5M�F�5MAô¸E©F�5M�é�\ß��ãÎk5M�õæç\wÀEåJê²
b;<F�5M4P©�?�"�ùr´¨tÝ��²5M"�¨tb��u³©�G;�\â�Çê\o£òæ¯A³5S´�fõ�²
5M:� A
�Á�W¤¹©á���&Ú�ÍÆF���²
fF�5MZÓ4P�v9Á¿*�©ÇbêÆ8Yô�m©ABÝÁâzø��u�²
5M�ZÆ�9:©�4:��9:²5678�Îk5M�Z�j²
"�ÝÁÄÅ©AB�5M9:ô�=Á�¯²ô1Æ:ý��!Å�ÄÅ©1��ÄÅf���\�d�¿lÇ�ùr²
5M:� B ��ÁEzÀ��¨ (¸dP���JÀ�¨C)²
Ç.;<©�ÁàWÚÛ{|����0�²
5M?uv��ªª�9:�©�^}^®«²
5MdP\F�5M¿ �Çê����©6�ÓF�;<�²
6()À¦
� A
Ç.;<©�"����ù²
Ç.;<©���Áu¨a �ý�FGÊ8=)�4:òæw�²
5M�Z9:�©5678�%&ªª�,2bæû9:²
ô¨8�5MÊê"r��x�©ô=ââ�\©© "Y�µ©�¬Í�5M9:�;<²
6()À¦
� B
5MdP?;<©��þ34zÅ�¨\ú_�?�Èî�²
ç.d©[�©c·ªª�ò-1ÆGH>?©?�x¸��¨[
Îk5M�F�5Mô÷�©�Z�¥A�ã���Y34l,0
â���\�G��;���\ç~��\ê�w7���á��ÄÅã34��e��?
103
;S= ��
;<? #$`e
£¤R=)�ú»©56789:m�¬�b³eFR9:u�X%¼
>?��#©â��56789:ìí�zjKJ¬o©èé5M¡&\Z�Ú
bP]\%&�³\�Ü"S©kè³��²b @�����µk©�.�
�c� Æ<X�KLM@56789:¾Uzj©¿°��KLM@567
8�£nb9hUòcd�fS7��´ê©÷C�0ª\5��\�S!O©
e�I§ÝIØKÇ�)Ƕ (¸¡�©�Ýe§)¿��qòJ�d���\]
[Ó7dSq5M�bã÷�òJ�d���\][Ó7dAôÔÕ&J�FG
�tJ¢C²
¸�"wÀ;<�dV¯·©KLM@5678�%&M�q¿ZÀ�%�
¯�b}~©�Ç�UwÀ;<x����©ò�ÇbR=)ú»©÷FR�
J GDP ìÇqú»�©¾UPfòJ�Ö`]Je��]5M�C�7ù³À
�^©Çbò�Á�W�=)�ª¬x�xø���Ö�]J���Ö¤�©e
÷Z%&�57M�¯e��I��²Ç©56789:�;©���¦�
�F�R;<¬uv����²
&S5678��./��KJW©�q«���y;Z9:3i¾U
Åv¯e�æç©ìy;þ��V��KLM@56789:�²�.c?Æ
ZKLM@5678�9:3ibc�©�����l,�©Z3i���ì
]3i���b�� ©¼Z�%&4:òæ�fs©e÷;1z�«TU�
KLM@56789:%&�3ip�©A+C�¾���!O©ö=���
´9:µ¶�;<CD�åÖ²
³ABKLM@56789:�;<¯·©�q¿ZÀ°±�K©� R
104
�K\ghijäK¾UCb³eFR¿�3�u�q�©1Á�Uà>?�Ç
¶©³Æ5678ªª�D®²"«oRsx5678©1À®x�Ñ#$9:
�7[ SPA©?ô³ÆGHÎk��]�\©�¸\^\\]S0ª©�¾UM
��0ª��á¬�"9h�]¥¦�Ë�wÀoØ©÷��;<z�]2�
ªª�M�²G!Ù�[ªª©�¤�ÆZ�6!O¯�[©�¯IÈ�°©�
x 90�¦©¬e�xP��ªª©x 21�$©5678¬I=îPª
ª ²¾jo���½e©YABø��5M56³�0Ø|C÷ô´��F�
�)�©�ZÙAB�5678¾Uµ¶ý�Æ�Á�,��)²
�÷©AB,�'Á¾jáo�5678�)©�Æ%HSNO�ÓFR¯
Ù©���´ê���b�ÝÁ%f@�K_�¸�Á¾�ªª©�ÝÁÞ"
ßÛ£q÷¯�R9«©ij¾¼X�,�ÒU#z ��©-À¬Ü¾
�u�²����ïlð�S©KLM@56789:�;<�q¿ZÀ
xb$©²´Æ34%&�9:3i�"Êˢȿܲ
Ç©�.��� ��È�©-À��Z3i���ì]3i���¯
�x©e�fð"34�%&3i����©S_èÅ\´êÅZÓ#$ž�
oÅve� >UCb�ôCb©�; >U>?�3ip�©q�w���²
3AB�KLM@56789:3i��È�©�=Åa >Ub$²
��«���./jk�%&3ip��ç©ZÓ�ßz4`8z4�
4:òæe���rsq�©PfKLM@56789:�;<©��;C´
þ9:���TU>?�3ip�=v©¾U3ip�j�¸��
(�) 5MdP�;<�56789:Æ5MdP;<�>Vþ�q�©
YSAB�5678!Å�Á%¼D®+ïõ�ªª©ÇÂ�Z�
dP9:`u¨©ì��o�R9«²
(�) F�5M/F�5M4P�v9�F�5M�)*Æ5M9:���
Uûüë�© �Zé�bc�$�F�5M (ì³ÆÂ��FêP
�$e�5M���)�Æ��5M9:���o�¡©�¥ìÆ5
105
6789:�Z;<��ê²�¢C��êÁÌW��©èéF�
¾×4ó\êëæ0©ì賫þ�5MdP©¾Uá�Z��E
55678�M�©ÇÂF�5M/F�5M4P�;<�5678
9:9«�ú»Á¤%¼��&ª@²
(�) 5M9:��-��5678ÁÌWªªþ��³ôBè³�æ
çèé�µkX©ÇÆ5678�M�WXAôÀdÞÔÕxò
J&ïEå©Ç©��<56789:���X©¸�þÎk5
M�é�O�5Me��m�,2©AY����µû.5Ù5
MÈî��=@©³�b5M9:���X�>?���²
(�) %&"r�Çê��ú»56789:;<���X©5MdP\
F�5MáÆì�579«�>?�ê©�÷©�«�F34f5
MdP�F�5M�"�ÇêÍ�KJW©ºÁ�fõ�©�%H
SNO�ÓFR�;<©ABm�¬ôSKJä��b$²ä
�©34fS���S%&��lÇ©ì²´�;wÀ4�©�
x�0Ø�¢C��©-=nú»5678�5Mªª©e�fí
e�J9:�;<²
Ç©��-b©!34=müÛÜÝ���oÅv�3i��©Ú¨�
�#$�v�©ij56789:³Áe�f;<��=@²
;E? ��B��
��PfAB�KLM@56789:e�«¬@��©ZÃÄDzA
B�ÂWQ�9:;<ä�SNO�Ó; FR�ÃÄ�K©APf�FÃÄK
<�dP9:©ú_�5@�3ivp²YSÂ�WQ�3i�iòæb 66
106
� ©÷9:W¬�ì1ÆôS.²`·ý���©��q7érs���=
nÞ rs�fg©YS3i�8&���\9:@®«á©���%f�²b
6²�8÷ô9�ßz4`8z4�4:òæe���rsq�©��úz
Z��u�©PfABKLM@56789:�;<©úzZ�TV3i���
�J!v©Z�=nfABKLM@56789:3iq;<Á�e�f��
x²
��%9�����56����D
5MdPÆú»AB56789:;<��o�¡©AB�&�Á5Mª
ª\��\ª�u�©� �F��q�©¸�=>V;<5MdP¾Uµ¶©
8²=�Y�&�5Mu�ì�z�o�9«²&S¾Uzj©34�ZwxN
O�Ó;<5MdPà�¢�FR©�34�C"�=b�²E��w�%&.
/�©-b�F34��PfZ�¾TUjþ¯e�0ç�
(�) 5M9"¾����m\��,2���a�wxNO�ÓF
R�,2©aFÆZ§@0ª�aOm¤b:V©[F Æ�
Ù�]0ª© �Æõï0ª�ÎkM" (¸ÄÅ\#M)\]
^_c?��UVLM��Áæ0S©¾UFR�5M9"¾
���áà�m©ì¤á�F�y'Á�,���´ê²�A
B�«�¾�»©ÑTá1=ôz>V5M�µ¶©fS5M
}~H��5678M�©AB��ï�x�xÁ>UÆ�Z
vF��Ù�²
(�) vn�F�@\å�@�5ñ"�]g��«AB�5MdP
!Å1ÝÁ�UnB@�5ñ©�²dNO�ÓFR©aF�
û×5ñ\ ��»¿Ï5ñ\]^_�×;<Ò��5MX
ïS©¾UáÆ�¢âÈZ��¬vq�:�Ê8¯O�8n
107
5ñ©¾�5Mñ¿³GH�¨;<é�¬v�5MdP²
(�) =3ò-��Ó�L��u��?;<5MdP©� 5Mª
ª��)q�©�ÓPd��Lìà>?©�¸�<=)\u
õ�5M"*�Hb�/�5MùÈS²NO�ÓFR¸a
F\ �\]^_Sk�Á�+ÍÈ�< (��)�u�©¾z
½��Æ��GHìÖ�²
(�) 34��o)Ç.©âÈ�´k@��âi��NO�Ó�¢
;<5MdP�FR©µ�q¿ZÀ�¢©à>?��V³Æ
�34áþ5MdP�bFR;<�>?�Bq�©A+ZÂ
;<z�Û��@�%�?@©Ú¨¨Z%&�"�©��
G\�æS�µ!Ål,uë{|©å);<´F�5Md
P²÷�«AB�;<h]Æ1ÁÌWS¤B¨I�"r�
µ©�«Í��ç¼X©34!w¸Â>Ä«e©��ÓFR
��g�=³À®¯®o²
($) 3i�B��l,�m�¸aF��b1cN5MüýX
ï\]^_ý�â�NOPQ5MXï©÷[F�Àø��
bNO]5MdPXïS©¾Uá��Y34 ���©A+
�%&�üý9:e�¨C©-ÁÞ"C�5MdP�;<ì
�R¼û²÷AB�«� ÌÍF�5M4P���q�©
ÑT·ô¢Æ��J�%&3i©¾�VÆàÀòf9:;<
��¯�xÊï�²
��\����������h�D
108
�����������X©��¬{Ó ÌW�F�5M���%&�
3ip�©ôÊÆÚ¨4P��÷��e��"rÄÅ\â��ÙZÓ©pJl
3�v9©1Æb w�F�¸¹¿`�Å)©���&�U#á�5678
9:�;<Á¤�o�&ª@²¸�5MdP=�F�5MC�;ü�u¨©i
jAB�5678!Å�ªª�,=�5'F�©s��W�FêP«¯e�%
&�M�²
�÷©� «��¿sxq�%&3i;<��l�©���U!v\²?
õýð¯�x©34!?��F�5M©�dÞÀÅax���³Æ�����
����� ������������������ �����wHI
¾UF�×Øx��Ƕ©e�fxIØø&�5M#$©¾ì̳=�^Á
¼ð��%&3i²
w��ÓFR�;<��©��õözTþF�êP��«µ³5FR¥¿
x��Ƕ(�¶Â©2008)�
(�) Nï=)(Core-competence)�¾�V���³Æ�F�5Müý"
*Æ!uõ\5M´kÆ!Eå�@©ì¦� �UFR=��F
�5M�Nï=)²
(�) Þ�=)(Approach)�¾�V]^_`Û��©�Y]^_êë�
W��Å)©F�=¢��7²ABq¿ZA�F�5M©³ÆÇ
bNï=)ôyè�ÓFR©��dÝÁ=zx\ô�wf�§
5©ZÜ�+Aô��AB�5M=)©ÂPì�"Þ{ãÇ©
AB?�F�5M©1´?�W§ÎZ¹ÚF�=¢�²
(�) ª¦(Communication)�¼�F×Ø�ËAB©ìç©xAB³5
¥©��?ÁÌÍ�ÊË©�¸C�õ�=À�F×Ø�¼ð5
^\5M��\êëdP:�\�v:�ªà©E5©«�5MB
CZÓxAB³5¥�¨Í\No\D�RË�êë©�©1Á³
5«�0F\ÝñÓª��¦æ\eE0F\���ùÈÇéS²
109
¾UjþaF�]^_á`Ûà�¢©ìÆAB=6��fg²
(�) PÝ�(Customize)��FêPe��F5ñ�©5Müý�>�F
tOõöãôq?Áuõ�5Mªª©1?Áf¾UF�§DAØ
÷7ü�üý�#$²aF�û×5ñôqÁÍG 20 WF�<�
ÞºòV©É:1`x�§iXl9�FR�âÏ��1�˲Ç
©5ñ���F�5M¥©²´bF�¯�§Dln4<Þº�
F©ôq;<5§+Í©1?l?�Û0��Þº?@©À§D
ÁPÝ��4Ë�²
Z�¾TU?V©%HS��q«�v3i���ç�©ìÌËSGH�©�
�µ¶©�¸�=`x¾U�î�?ê©w^�3i���o!vtm©ì̳
=�F�5M�;<��ue�of²�=NO�ÓFRá¬` �E�©©
��C��®-t?õö÷¬©¿ZÆ��îqôáô=ÚZöï²
���¯·AB��«�;<CD©��ý�ÁÌW´?Áü�ð!©èé
�<l�©¾Æ=n��F§D+Í��>?��V©�AB5M%&òV��
�=)Ò«ôh²5©òV¼�GHÝ��©�Æ�3òV\0�ª^��æ�
��=)WX³Áº�Ë©¸�ÝÁF���üýòV©AB�´¸�þ5M�
vF�_�Ç©�<=)ÆÁº^á��#²
w�©�U5M#$ì��e�o�]©AB�æçê��qW�©ÇÂÌ
W5§&£ávn�%¼ôf÷��[�©�¾5§&£�=�©���¬
¯� 5��"m��§De�+Í�H�©¾�5§&£Æ�"Þö�F§
D�²¿°�F�5Müý©³ÆZ§òbXï�üý©�÷©�>�5M#$
���X©�¥ìÆf5MJ´�²�©¾6fÆ���;<F�5M���
X©%¼>?��U�I©ìÆ>vAB5MJ´�Uà>?���²
2��{������������34D
110
�5678%&9:�;<�©�¿Åa��Ub$³Æ5M�=Æ!²´
9:����²àW��-b¸�þ5M9:�©ij³�,À5ÙÚZwÀJ
�þþ\ò×æûbx��5M²�¾d*��³ÆÔÕ56789:;<�
o�Í)©5M´ô´Á�:�x©��²´Y34�;%&�4�©Àò×ø
ò��Îk5M�5M9:�j�+�©�tÁ�æ絶�Á��&Jæû
�5M©��æ絶q��5M9:©=nȯì��o�R9«²
5Mxò²ô²´9:�©ABwÀq¿ZÀ�;¾jW��é���w
ÀK��|æçê�î�² ���x·NO�Ó�5M9:�;<ÛGHÃ�
FR©�¸]^_`aF©³�Z;CÓ��wÀf5M�®«d�5MJê�
¢C`ABÆ%¼ô��²]^_á�æû�5M��ÆUò�<Æ©îÈ�é
ù�ïvB�bJK©5MfS]^_wÀ¯ÙÆ�"©ôÆ34²´°±�
<ƲaFìÆ�©aF34º�õÞæç©�5MÈî�J¯ÙAô®AB
ij_s©34�Ñ�ìÝij�²Ç©!Z.��dV¯·©ABH�L,
�æç.���à6B�M©ìÇÂàWòá�5M9:�÷�§²
��?�x�Æ©Îk5M�5M9:��Æô¸E�©ìÌF�ÁòÀ-
b34o)��5M9:q�©F�5MJ´���´¸���²�¾��Æ�
Uô�µ¶���©F�5MJ´X��U�����¸æçèéþ�NO\5
^"øèÓrò*�\5^ò)ôhS©¾U�����5M9:AÝÁ���
&ª@²��5M9:AôÀÀ¾U���P�©¼�ìô�=��F�tÁ5
MJ´X¿ÁÞß�5©��²
Ç©�56789:�;<�©!=¥¦Îk�@+©��³=·x9:
e�f»Á�ÈP©÷¾ìÆ34��xÅ)�©À�UwÀ]��J�©À
wÀoØ��Îk5M�5M9:���Zjõ¯·º©�ø��¼«Åa�b
$²
Z��Uo!v©ÆE��Ø����¿9��u�©�J÷<©³�
«34¿`��¯·©fS56789:�;<©E�Í�Æ).d©�[�©
112
���\
�y0���
1. �G©2002©5Mâ��H"çl©åFY^©2002� 11pn©S 29-31²
2. �<D©2006©ABdP5M�����"*u�©øY¥�©2006 � 10
p 17�²
3. �v³©2006©ô��jÐ�9:ì]3iq)R�©\ª;<3i�¬
SR9510©2006� 10p©S 1171-1201²
4. ��È©2008©�o5ñ©êiêë�Ù���Ð�©� 71�²
5. �æå©2009©AB5Müý9:�F��Ó�<©©ABüý:ªõ4�
jk©http://www.twcsi.org.tw/columnpage/expert/e057.aspx²
6. �æå©2010©«^å�R=�Ó34�����©R«^©� 132�²
7. �æå©2011©5MF��9«��RÓ�¡ì©å�A�üýõAB#
)�4�©http://twbusiness.nat.gov.tw/epaperArticl e.do?id=101220357²
8. �Oþ©2009©�P�;<5MdPÊ8i�q�©FnXFo6ßJ©
ýÊ8�¿ôæ�.²
9. �¹�©2010©;<Ö�Ýæû�Ê�"�e;<dV·AB�56789
:©Fn�¢o6ßJH��¿ôæ�.²
10.��'\�.w\�xy©2011©AB;<5MdPüý:¸¹u�q�©
X:Ê8)�F�6�©� 14ü� 1�©S 1-16²
11.ÍÎa©2000©ßJ3i���'©AM�T��!ß�²
12.AB��å¨�¿© 2006©[F�zUVLM\�]dP�"
�© http://www.japanresearch.org.tw/hotnews.asp?pagenum=75²
13.A B ü ý J p � h õ © 2011 © [ F F � 5 M 9 : Ñ ¸ ©
113
http://www.taiwanservices.com. tw/org2/0/news_detail/zh_TW/32411/I²
14.� 3 ñ © 2009 © � o ] � 9 : c � õ ©
http://www.ey.gov.tw/policy/3/index.html²
15.�3ñH�"©2009©æû��»«`�!ú?@!©�3ñå�ÈÉõ�>
o3iµ¶�©http://www.ey.gov.tw/ct.asp?xItem=53816&ctNode=2922&mp=1²
16.�3ñH�"©2009©AB�ªö÷øù��!ú©�3ñå�ÈÉõ�>
o3iµ¶�©http://www.ey.gov.tw/ct.asp?xItem=53817&ctNode=2922&mp=1²
17.�3ñH�"©2010©UB5MüýF����?@©�3ñRvlKV
ÀÈÉõ�3iÃVµ¶�©http://www.cepd.gov.tw/m1.aspx?sNo=0014026²
18.�A²©1992©78�� 100��07�W§©AM�ÒH.�ß�²
19.ÃÄ�©1995©;<3LR6�8���X©AM�$c!�²
20.Ã��©2003©ßn5ñøù5Müýqܼ)RYZÒ5678Xïb�©
KLo65ýÊ8�¿ôæ�.²
21.ú,©2003©ßJ3iY´©AM�$c!�²
22.ú,\·�!\�øù\ ãZ\Ìn�©2006 �©�36(�)©AM�F
nvXo6²
23.ËÌÊ\ÍÎa©2003©3i���)R©AM���z[w²
24.Ë<=©2008©dP5M�â�j©2008AB5MüýF��:¯O
Ó;<i�F�çÀ�.²
25.Ëï\©2009©7�ô1�àZ�]@îÈ5678CgÌæ©Fn�¢o
6ßJH��¿ôæ�.²
26.Ëïô©2009©AB^@78�]��ÔÕǶ��&J¡g\ò�ÔÕ
�ÐJÔÕ©�]o6wÀï86´ôæ�.²
27.���©2008©UB�½��IÉ3i��²Èq�©Fn1:o6ßJ
�3�¿ôæ�.²
28.<3.Sò©2010©2010��ª9:`Z!©Rz�:�²
114
29..vF©1991©9:3i�9:Ê8�Pf�FR;<�8��C�©A
M���.�²
30..°¿©1999©ßJ3i]�©AM�òù.�©:ÁÇß�²
31..��©2006©"ì]3iÓ#��·ì]3i�)R©\ª;<3i�¬
SR9510©2006� 10p²
32..��©2006©æçÔÕ5678ÂP�b¡�q>?ǶYZoAMðP
Z[\5Mñ¿b�©o�o6©:é¿�z[ôæ�.²
33..(4©$&'Î5ñ©êiêë�Ù���Ð�©� 68�²
34.|=Ê©1998©3i���?¶jk©x�p�©� 23 ü©� 4 �©S
6-15²
35.3ë4©2006©Aè<5)ReZ5MdP9:©��¥�©2006 � 10 p
20�²
36.Å��©2009©5M787ù\8fdP5Mq�b��¯O©NOo6
éÊ86´ôæ�.²
37.ó��\|=Ê\ Á_\G2`©1998©ßJ3i©AM�FnvXo6²
38.��7n©Harrie M. Cooper ¤©1999(1989)©�./q�Â��¨©AM�
Fn�n�²
39.�C�©2000©ì]3i)�©AM�:a.�©:ß�²
40.�C�\ ��©2005©\ª3i8���ý©AM�å:\ª�!²
41.ÕÖt©2008©ô�ñ�� �W}~�Å��� É�5678�72]�
�©�ª�5M¡&�¬©� 113�²
42.�øù©1999©�3Ê8©AM��×!�²
43.�tC©2002©"56D8dV·5Mâ�©åFY^©2002 � 11 pn©
S 24-28²
44.�5�©2006©âNdP5Moä AèI�V©XF¥�©2006� 10p 20
�²
115
45.�qr©2006©D®deçæêë �7®/Æ;<u�©D®ßa©� 265
�©S 98-101²
46.�v`\MF5\ú�P©çæêë;<CD�;<!vqæç©êëæû
6�©� 7ü� 1�©S 43-62²
47.Ì"#©2006©5M�b�È���<Æ��@æçY��5M�b��@
*j�q��@©Fn�¢o6"Y6´ôæ½ôæ�.²
48.���©1986©\ª;<�3i��©\ª;<�.<©AM�ABR
�ñ²
49.�ë4© 2006©�â5MêëABÀô.²�� ©o$�¥�©
http://www.epochtimes.com/b5/6/4/19/n1292626p.htm%EF%BC%8C%E6%B0%
91%E5%9C%8B²
50.�.�©2009©KLM@5678ש"Y&£q�©FnXto6"Y
6�¿ôæ�.²
51.�&©2009©�����5M�ª9:�5M��;<��©X:×Fì:
�È�:�:ßÀå�ÈÉõ©http://www.tvca.org.tw/²
52.�×Ø\ËÙÚ©2009©5M78¢ö ���· 800�©�ª�5M¡&�
¬©� 125�²
53.�À�©2010©aFdP:�3LRjk©AB1cN6�©� 7 ü� 1
�©S 41-74²
54.Q�R©2002©AB/XF/��/]^_/[F�ª9:o¸b�Á&i�Ó�
� ! O q G H © � ñ IEK 9 : h � õ � � � ©
http://ieknet.iek.org.tw/pubinfo -detail.screen?domain=5&pubid=36638860²
55.·/Û©2000©AB�\ª9:�;<q3i�YZ��ªª9:b�©
FnXto63L6�¿ôæ�.²
56.·¸c©2001©�!"©AX�d\�!�½ÁÇß�²
57.·_e©2006©ABdP5M9:i�)RYZ®«ì]b��©FnAB
116
o6Ê86ñ��ßJÊ8Fôæ�.²
58.·ë9©2008©î4\��78565^��ö�w4:�©Fn�¢o6
ßJH��¿ôæ�.²
59.~��©2009©AB���å���wö÷�]Ö�©�ñ IT IS9:Å�²
60.,Á©2004©ABX¬J9:3iq��3i���� ©fMo6
ßJ�36´ßJ3iôæ½ôæ�.²
61.,p¶©2005©AB;<5MdPq��@�©XF.�o6dP©:
�¿�z[ôæ�.²
62.,��©2006©5MdP9:YAB�x]��©8#Ð�©� 34�²
63.,z:©2006©ì¡§,� ¸�Îjq��ÀYNO]���\§ò\�è\
5M�êë©�¢ßa²
64.,7Þ©2007©8�5MdPP9«H�ÖdPPW 4-6 g©X�âÏ�
A²
65.,.Û©2008©VIPæ0 &'âãdP5M©XF¥�²
66.,23\Ë45©2010©56789"ì]���AB;<Ö�©Rz²
67.h:©©2000©wÀ\6)�©AM�5ò.�©:ÁÇß�²
68. v À © 2006 © Û Ü å � d P 5 M ü ý 9 : ] � � ©
http://www.cepd.gov.tw/index.js²
69.�ë7©Aè<5)ReZ5MdP9:©��¥�©2006� 10p 20�²
70.º»¼©2009©AB;<F�5Mê븹)�i�)Rq�©ý8o6
#$ëi©:6´ôæ�.²
71.ÉÊ�©2010©AB5678ó¿;<�����)D©�ñ IEKjk�
�©http://edm.itri.org.tw/enews/epaper/9911/d01.htm²
72.� ¡©2004©56ab787ù¡v¯Ov�q�G�Yu�!�Oq
²È©FnXto6:Ê8�¿�z[qôæ�.²
73. ��©2000©34È����?@ܼ)Rq�YZRz\ª4ú
117
b�©¨oéÊ8�¿ôæ�.²
74. �W©2005©5M�Ù�â�ÊêqÌæ�©KLo65ýÊ86�
¿ôæ�.²
75.ab.©2003©å����ABR©AM�jF!�²
76.á'(©2005©�]785M<Æ�À¢ô8q�©FnAMo6"Y6
´ôæ½×s"6Fôæ�.²
77.á⸩2008©AB 2�89:q�Y3i���� ©FnABo
63L6´ôæ�.²
78.STU©2009©Z 4C ���aFû×5ñ;<dP5M��¢Ç¶¯·
AB��À©Fn3Lo6éÊ8ôæ6� (EMBA)�.²
79.)*#©2006©²ÈÈÜækªªS5M�Ùq�YZ5678b�©F
n0.\ªo6ÈÉÊ86´ôæ�.²
�y����
1. Elmore, Richard F., 1987, Instruments and Strategy in Public Policy, ” Policy
Studies Review, 7(1), pp. 174-186.
2. Edquist, C. and Chaminade, C. Fro m Theory to Practice: the Use of the Systems
of Innovation Approach in Innovation Policy, in Hage, J., and Meeus, M. (eds.)
Innovation, Learning and Institutions, Oxford University Press, 2006.
3. Hood, Christopher C., 1986, The Tools of Government, Chatham, New Jersey:
Chatham House Publishers, Inc.
4. Hanekom, S. X., 1987, Public Policy, Johannesburg: Macmillan.
5. Howlett, M., 1991, Policy Instruments, Policy Styles, and Policy Implementation:
National Approaches to Theories of Instruments Choice ”, Policy Studies Journal,
118
Vol. 19, No.2., pp. 1-21.
6. Howlett M. and Ramesh, M., 1993, Patterns of Policy Instrument Choice: Policy
Styles, Policy Learning and the Privatization Experience, Policy Studies Review,
Vol. 12, No. 1, pp. 3-14.
7. Howlett M. and Ramesh, M., 1995, St udying Public Policy: Policy Cycles and
Policy Systems, New York: Oxford University Press.
8. Hughes, Owen E., 2003, Public Management & Administration: An Introduction,
New York: Houndmills.
9. Linder, S. H. and Peters, B. G., 1989, Instrument of government: pe rceptions and
contexts. Journal of Public Policy, 9(1), pp. 35 -38.
10. Metcalfe J. S. and Georghiou L., Equilibrium and Evolutionary Foundations of
Technology Policy, STI Review No. 22 Special Issue on “New Rationale and
Approaches in Technology and Innovation Policy”, OECD Paris, 1998.
11. OECD, 2009, Policy Response to the Economic crisis: Investing in Innovation for
Long-term Growth, Paris: OECD.
12. Peters, B. G., 1984, “From Social Theory to Policy Design ”, Journal of Public
Policy, Vol. 4, No.3, pp. 237-259.
13. Peters, B. G. and F. K. M. Van Nispen eds., 1998, Public Policy Instruments:
Evaluating the Tools of Public Administration, Northampton, MA: Edward Elgar.
14. Rothwell, R. and Zegveld, W., 1981, Industrial Innovation and Public Policy:
Preparing for the 1980s and 1990s, Frances Printer, London.
15. Schneider, A. L. and Ingram, H., 1990, “Behavioral Assumptions of Policy Tools”,
Journal of Publics, Vol. 52, No.2, pp. 510-529.
16. Schneider, A. L. and Ingram, H., 1993, “Social Construction of Target Populations:
Implications for Politics and Policy,” The American Political Science Review,
87(2), pp. 334-347.
119
17. Schneider, A. L. and Ingram, H., 1997, Policy Design for Democracy, Lawrence,
Kansas: University Press of Kansas.
18. Salamon, L. M. and Lund, M. S., 1989, Beyond privatiza tion: The tools of
government action, Urban Institute Press, Washington, D. C. and Lanham, MD.
19. Salamon, L. M., 2002, “The New Governance and the Tools of Public Action: An
Introduction,” in Salamon, Lester M.(ed.), The Tools of government: A Guide to
the New Governance, New York: Oxford University Press.
20. Vedung E., Bemelmans-Videc, and Rist R.C., 1998, Carrots, Sticks & Sermons:
Policy Instruments and Their Evaluation, Transaction Publishers.
21. Wade, R., 1990, Governing the Market: Economic Theory and the Rol e of
Government in East Asian Industrialization, Princeton, N. J.: Princeton University
Press.
22. Weimar, D. L. and Vining, A. R., 1999, Policy Analysis: Concepts and Practice,
New York: Prentice Hall Inc.
23. Yim, C. K., 2005, Healthcare Destinations in Asia, A sia Case Research Centre,
University of Hong Kong.
120
�7
� � � � � ��������D%9�����A� ¡D100� 6p 16�¢£D�3ñH�"¤�¥D�M¦ §¨©Tª
� � « ���`a¬®¯N�������°�±�TU²³56N���´µ�
�¶·¸¹º»¼½N:;¬¾�¿ÀNÁÂ�¬ÃÄ�Å»ÆÇÈÉ#�56ÊËÌÍ����Î��Ç34NÁÂ�`a�¬Ï34�(dÐÑBÊËÌ=Ò�Ó¢ÔÕ¬Ï34�3ÖNÁÂ�×�ØÙ�%&ÚFdÐÊ�x��J·xllmm)¤;n�§�o�xôê5©�éôzçG�©C�¬·ôx¾hD ©¾¦�¤AB�F×R©ð:S5^¯��_èá¬ú�ÌW©5Mªª�þ�ê�ìú�ÌW²¼#$efx¾���q�©ò×�����æû©É:Æe§�LMq�©-Á�=xeê78��d�IØ©Ý�ÆÙ®Ùd56\æû0F¾1��§³ú«Ùd\��©¾�sF×�wÀR#$¬x Ò�U��²
�1cN?%FRGH©®ÆaF©Á3i¾¡e~ÒUD2©u¨��\êë�F�5M�zj©��J¯Ù©Ó��IJ�5MªªÆÁä��©�ABô�©AB�57�5Mªª��Ó�Îk5Mªª�°±Æ�ôW�©%HS�ÓFR�>VpÒ©AB�5MÆåÅ�.Îú»©ZÒ«��°±���ÓFR¯GH�u©ìáGH�q²
Z5678¯Ù©F�ø��7ù³¬Á%¼�°± ©É:��UF��5678çÀ�©AB5^�ªª�ïÛj���Váôy�ÓFR²�Æ���;<�[³ÀôÃ�©Z3i¯ÙÀGHTQ�V©®ÆfS5^�¯�©��ÆGHÁ?@@�©�Æ®¾UKe§�LMÆÝÁ¾�f��Ö�5M´êûÅ©¿Z���K�¯�¾U5^�¥È©��À?ÛÙ©¼5^���?rx¾UWQx�¥È©fS�ÖÎkLMÀÁ�UÂéf��¯ÙÆ9�6�©��ç©hv;<©�Æ�ÀÂÃÙ;<ÛÃÃ�¥È©ÀôÀfS��Îk5M��¸¹©��5^ò)Èî�5Ù²
121
��ô�=®�Ó9:���Ƕ·9=©�5^_è�ÆôÃ�=`¾�ô8©©���F�¯·©����J5678Æ;<Û9Ã�©¾³À;��U��´?xô8�Cg©è³�Us��â��b�5M�"*�Å©ÆôÆ´?`�U�ïð�\�ô��ô8©¾UáÆÃÄ;<q�À;����©G¸ÙC�56ñ�:�6�©x"©Îk5M�C�òÆ®¯®; ©¾UôÆÙ7856�ö³���u�©ôÆD�Ƕ���©�ƾCg;�q�©Z�UFR�H�J´¯·©��ì��xÚ¡�¯�J�5^¯�ZÓfF×æû�Â�´?©ôÃ�=À¾U�ô8p¯��5^ÍÍs�¾,�WQ©1ÆÀÁ�UÊ8��Âò
���Û±Ü�M¦ÝXNÁÂ�`a�56�����7��ÞßàdÐÊáâËãZ[ÊC�Ázj�Îk5MÅaxò-ÌÖ�Cg©"���Jê�x·�¥È©¾ôÆD�Ƕ¿���©�Æ5678�;<�¥È©Óm�ÀÁ�U&¹�ÔÕ©i��·x5M78¾�»©Ó�¸¹��ÆKJÔf�©¸¹Ôf�u�³ÆÀ�¸¹0"�zC�U��©�=ÀdÞÔÕòJ�zj©¿Z5Müý�&��Ó�Ö�"üýú_ÀÁ�VôÃ�©³Æ1?�üý��8�"*�` ��q�©³Á�=ÔÕxòJ©�Ö�"ý:��ÎÔÕ�5M78Gö¯³GHÝijS>©¿Z��¸¹�¥È©�Ö=n`���U³Æå���©�Æå����%ft~@³Àú�©��U³ÆÝ�´ê©�Uô´?\ô²´\ô�¨õ�©�¾U¥È©¸�ÆÇbBÈ;z¯�´ê©¾ÀÀ×ØV��ô´?Åf�}~ûÅ©Îke§�¾!Å�}~%f��V©5M78�´êGHÁ�=BÈ;z¯©¸�Æ�¯³Á´ê�ò³ÝÁÊj��©Çb¸¹¿È;z¯�´ê� V��}~q�©ì�=¬ÜôÞ�º�¹p©
�«�Ê8�©Pf5678��Ó�Îke§LM©�Ê8�"r�TTÝÁô�©ô�Á¾�Pfâ�¯`�U�,©Pf¾U®Æ5M78SS�øù5Mþ�³ÁGHW�V�?ê©�¸Ù5M" 61���,©5M��Æô�ZÈX�cÊ�&ß�qôt¼0"¯s�5M�¡©¾Uôt¼0"èé®u®\j�é÷S©¾þ�,Æ�ÈS¿Á�5M��©�Æ�Ê8�m�ÆÁPf5M78Ý�øù5M¯Ê8©ÇbÓ��íÙ�!"�Å GH8pÀxîÈx¾U0"©
122
¾�Îke§LM�ÅÆô�=;��©¿Z�â�\s�!Å©C�Á�xÃf5M78�øù5M�zj`�UÊ8©Çb��ÖÎkó¿�é�[ôÃ�©C�Àu³fS���\¯^á?êÓ�0ª"*\H�#$²
2�䮯%9åæçè\���éê���N�ëìí!Íîéêï;ðñ�òóN:;\���éê���NÁ^ôdõö÷�ÊøùN���\���éê�ú��N¸û7ü¼½��q�N��ýþû�ÝX¯�N�����7�=Ð���NE�[�%&�¯� ��yÊC�AB�#$�©�3i!Å34ÀxÃTUGHo�Ƕ©³Æ��c?Æè��U#$©ÀoRÁ�×x;<²IJ¯Ù©34�H�"��¿°�F�5M©¾UF�5MAôÆòÇ�5678¾�»©���`F�5M��èé "Ùd56x5678\���\©É:x�Uc>V�LMáÀèé��Uo�F�5MûŲ��ÓFRGö¯©��ÁàW�5Mªª�å�+áÆ � ��©�¸ËJ)*Ô~0ª³Æå�+���©à;ÁFR®ABÁ¾jW5ñ©Á¾jWÁ=)�5^©¾jgh�5M°±©¾Æ��à�v�ÈZ"F�5M���¯·©56781ÀÆ�X��Uzj©����F�5M�¥ÈÆç©Â�F��ò¯xABÞ ¾U5Müý²C�Æç©Ó�Z��U¾,�ðVõö44`F�5M�zj©C��AÅ�GH�a�³Æ�ÌÍ Îw�v�x©"5MD2x�����Hbt�©y¢0��x�P�¨Íì�bt�©��Fò¯AB·§�¥È©WXÀÁD§�7A©ZF���D¯Ù©D§�òÍJ1ÆDïE�©GHôÀÀAB�D§³Æz· �{F�ö|©¿ZF��D§1´?ê�©É:Ó�Zxôx==��©¾U´ê�ú_��¯�v����XáÀÁ¾��:@�õ;©¾³Æ�J3i���zj©÷ôÆD¬�"r�,©¾�F��Öñ¿³ÀÁào�ô�©¾þÆZ5Mbc©��'Á�J�Ë�=���l?©¾ìÆ�wÀEå�9:;<qy��Ugv²
���%9çè\���éê0ëN��åæ¢�=çè����¬�þ{N��;\���éêN�����!�Ã���������T����8�� �!±"����mnN¬þ{�ë¸#$?\���éê����%&'NËÌ(:)*�+ ¯÷N,-.@��%&ìk/N¬ÃÄû:�����¯� �yzÊ0�����¬��
123
NÁdõö÷�Ê
�ôÆÃm,�¯£PøY��Zb��¾��ɯW;���©ÝÌÀÁ�UøY��ò�Z©ZµìÁ;��©�=��ýÝÆ�Ó4:¨��ÀxAB¯·§©¾UìÆÁ�©�Æ�ÀoxÊj��©�«GH6)R©�¸�ÙøY�1ÆGH�vêë���¯·�u©i�?Û571Áæ01ÆÁ�=�bÓ����XWz¯��þ²fS£P¯A`�Ѿ�5M7ù©�5MÊê���ÆÝÁ¾�ô�©IJ�¯Ù©�«�5M�3Ê8�©ìÝÁxPjÙÆ!bøùó¿©¿Z""r�¯}©o)ÝÁô�©�1ÆÀÁ�U&Ss�\â���,©�xâ���,�=À��Ù��8Æf�©�Æô��,���µk�÷ �©C�1?=G�Æf�©³�Z}²ÁU�:@�.�Ýâ�©º�ÙÛáÆf�©�JÀ+¡���~VÝÆîÈÇꩾUÆGH���ð!©
1����34�çèú��Nd�£�<=�Ã��Í���$l2��~Â3N4J���56J�ú�NÁ:î�£dã÷�ÊÁÂ�`aÃÄE7ÓÍ��Î��Ç34NÒ�Ó¢28`a^ô���ÑB+9� �3ÖN�:;[�k;�56ÊH�`5MÊ8¾�»©5^�¯�zj©à;Á�Ó�4:òVÆȾS¯?@�!Ox�,Ó�_è©5^C�&�s��ò Æ 13002©w�^]�¾��¾� 10%©��³Æ 1430 2©²´ÝÁ�Ó�6\ÀƾS¯�Aʲ�5M�¯Ù©��GHôÀûÓ,2��U9:©GH�vwÀEå�zj©÷ôÆËSR;<�zj©�x1Áßz4ÝÆ4:�5^�Zõ:©C�õ�#5"ò�õl5ñ©¾³�s5M¾�»ÆËSwÀEå�zj©¼5M=vé�@*�¥È©³Á�U��´?xô8©G¸Ù¾GHôÆe§LM©�¾,��L��ZÀÓxeê����o�©�¸�Ù5M�ZZé�b���¥È©ij�òJEå�©ÏtÆõ�xdP5M©i´¸�x�`Æ´?xÃ�²�ÆÎke§LM1Ʋ´ËSwÀEå�µ¶©ô��æç¹u�¥ÈÀà~�©æçà�rÆËSwÀEå�zj²¸�Ù5M�é��zj©C�n"þ��¦^&£©1=ÁÇ��ÀÓ�:�©ôÃ�=�"L�dÞü{©é��zj=�:�©ôé��zj=wÀ�©¾6fÆ`ôx�©Çb�+,�B±ô�å©�Ê8�ô8p©�ê��l?ìô8p²GHÁ�=�³ÆZÔF�5MÕ +,©¿Z¼Ì�"úxn"ñ©³ÆÙÁ4`F�5M�5ñ© �³Æ�Z�:�©³Æ�ZZß��'�õl©ôÇ,`�5Müý�8©�Æ��ZF�5Mbc©ôö�æçµk©�U5ñZøù�[é²
124
<�:;����34�56N=Q¯�Á>dÐ?@ÊAB>dÐCD�E*ÊÌ�¯·©5678�;<%f�ÓÎk5MÀGHé�Æ��ÓFRGö¯GH;o�¯�;<©IJ¯Ù©F�����`�À®¯®�©�¯�=À=v<5�Ý"���zj©�Ñß���[©����Æ�,ÀzC�²�Z5©ô�n� ,��Í�vç½,ôç©���:�xzÔ7ù�ì�ô�?q´ê ,ÇbÓÍËS5M�b²5M�bÀÓxH"�æûLqçl ,Ͳ�v�;�Êêb�²
125
� � � � � ��������D%9�����B� ¡D100� 6p 24�¢£D�3ñ¤�¥DFG�%nH�
� � « �����qIJ:��mnáÃ�$l2�K¯Ò��Â3N\���éê
LMN�Ã���3456�OP�k;��NQ»RS��TU���ßà0ùNÁÂ�¬�¡�4V>�=Ð%&����WXÊ
©��©F�5M4P�Îk5Müýô´È9:;<�Ké�cã¯�j²ABõö®?��F�5M�¥�ऩ¤�)�ÎÆ�3ññK���.ÆþñK¥©³õö��F�5M²i¥�®"ƪ¨5ñ©YFRz�f�â�\��ç~���©c?wxfg³Æ]^_S©]^_¤¬û5M¼C9:©AB�x¾T�ìá��F�5M©¿Zô´Ù4P-õ�AB5M9:��)*²
ABÌW5ñèé�,GñK��hô²fF�5M©ìc·øù5M®¯?G�F�©à6Ùi�¥��F�5MbKé�©1=Ùi¥���©AÝÁ{Ó5ñÆ!q=ZKé�FGñ����²ln4P©Çb¨"�&£©�mî5ñß��¾U��²�ÜŲ�nß��5øôÆ=�©ÁÌW�:á´?Ëø©ìô´�X4:òæ¢È4:ôf�©N�P�Ý7ù���7ù²³®Y^ô´�2N�ê(©F�5M?`�ÁF�})©�¯³ô´1Æ�[eê�û©1Ʋ´1§¸7©¿Z¾��yAK=�²4P�mÆ�S9:;<Zz�3i©��B³Æî8ò�^�È©û���xq�©Ó³Á�)x��e��â²ñ¸�a����`â�©x�s��ç~ß�S²
34¿´�Ú۩Ƹ��ôÔÕAB5MKé�.��Îk�©³õU�4©¸�C����!O©À�Á�×�=)éF�5M�56©=ne��È�é²÷+Z4P¯e�F�5M©ô�ÈæçÈî©�=Æ�ôÔÕABC�5MJ´��!O²
���çè�ú��NYþû�%&ÚFâËã[RÊ4n{���yZ[âËãÒ�Ê
126
F�5M����¯³ÁßJ#�KßJ#zj²ßJ#�>?�Æ�G�;�©Ô×"¬�¡Pf>V§D���;�²�¸]^_Pf�$�0ª��F§D©�Z���¥�;è�G©�o£§DxAB¯©S�G³?SX�²
�R68�X©34JÀÑ�ßJ#Ý�z@©�Æ�9:������ÏôW©÷�X�=<q�8�©³Æ�â8��²!Æ34É�© þ¤�¯u��}~j�©³=Á¼ÉWX���K�f�d^�Ð���0²AB34?É��ª9:©�&ï³�S²�5M4Pzj©� H�"�©�¯�5M4Pô¢Û´?34
¿ð©1Æt�¾½ÌÍ��}%Áo�sBú�¨e�©-ÀÈFR3i©ç©^ÃÂ�:;<�Ä�²c?&ïÍÆH�"�¯��8`AB5M°±�õ�²
2�Á:����dõö÷�ʬ:\������ÃÄd·:zÊ
F�5M�µkHo©è³>V5M�dP5Mzj²AB5MªªG]^_�aF�©� dP5M�©>V5MþÆAB���²
AB;<�ª:Á�o()©èé«Û���å×æç©'Áå��o:òÈÜ�©ZÓ�¯�©�n�56ÈÜ0�²ABæç���'©'Á -�t���ò�³5$~©�÷å�+�o�:ò56ÈÜ�²0²ªªÀò��t�©�560�)*©ì�©À564:e�f�ȲZ�E§�õ5�¯]8©AB;<�ª:���Uu�²Ónz©�x:òEb)§¿ø©�³ABW³å��)*�²YS:ò&Ju�©`�ÓòÁ¿ô�©AB�¾!Å��©�¸5&!Å©ì=ú_:ò4Ë��©H�ÓF�oX�Áu�²
���,º\�]\�^_\`��NÁ:;`a����àab�ØÙopdã÷�ÊËã�k;56�ëÔ¯Z[Ê
127
AB5+Á�ø��¯�Îk©å×æç��Þß©÷+c?ÆH�"�:ý©�ô�;��W¡¢²5M����9:ô�©�¯³ôqqÆ�U�:©�ÀÓå×�æû©Á��ý©¾ÆbÊj5ñ£�ÆÊê�:�Dz¿ZAô=¸æ���¿Ù©?ZR;<b«ú¯��©R;<ô´Æ5Måz��B²
1�ÁÂ����34�N%9�cà�WX�deËãfghiÊ
¾ÆUàÞß���©AB�5MJ´YæçD�ç~¿�í©�ôÆò×ÛZÁÅD�æç©�ìÇb¸Â©�U5M´k0å��Æ����ê©IɧÛàb6²b 7\îù©�¬5M�b©H�"§ÛۮʮW²��Uo5MJ´¾ÆUÞß�p�©ô8ps�a²
øù��GHD¬©34²´`Û³Æ7\5ñ��5M©mç�,5M"*��:*�²
<�����34Ù���mn�ÈÉ34NÁ:â34�56dã÷�Ê^j ��ÐkÊ
UòPfÂz½5678D��:��zôÉ �©ÇÂ�";�¡¢²
128
� � � � � ��2���D��4B�A� ¡D100� 6p 17�¢£D>?w×�x�d�5678Xï¤�¥Dlm�nc)�opMª qrs�t
� � « ���ÁÃ`a3u�vwé`Nx ¸åæÍvw��������UyQ
R��zN{|+9}:~8B'��EDy�mnN�Á^¥��£¯÷NÁÂ�Í��Ù��Çmn4¯ç�Nͯ�56��ËãÊ�Öò�d*¯Ù©ôÆT³Æ`©9:³Æ9:©5M³Æ5M©��¾Æôf�©Çb&1|áÁ�>�@©5M¼�ÆU9:©5MÆ�Uà4:�9:©¹�?`5M³ô=û5M¼C®ÆÄN��Ö�9:©5Mì�ZɯàW�ß�©�Æ5M�ÉÁwÀþ��@*©?��òq��©¿Z5MÁÓ�R@ìÁwÀþ��·/©¿Z¾�L©ô=¾j����)WÓ²ô²â�j"²¸�Ù5678°±;<ÀÔÕÎk5M�;<©¾��ÆUÑÆ÷K�d*©¹�ABÀÁ¾���Cg©áÆ34�<Æ©Çb34û�U5Mê�á��Ú ©Çbæçê�l?Ûô¨8©³À�� ¾�®«d*©�ÆôÆ?û5678§�9:ÆÝÁ&£�©¹�¸�õï*0ª����`57����©i�À?xõï*�¾³Ææçê�����ô�����²¿Z34§÷õ�øù5MÀ��5Ù5MÈî�5^ò)qu� ,¾0åÆæçê�l?ôõ¿���²
��:;¬�®`a�������NÁ^ôdõö÷�Ê�¼½¥7���Í����Î��ÇUy#�56 NÁÂ�����¬Ï34�56q>EdõöTUÊ5M78ìôƾj8p�©¸¹Æ%¼Ôf�©Çb?e�5678�4�Aô�©1Æ`Û�Ýô����©��³À���®¯��¸¹©¿ZæÙ5678���à�����ÆôÀ�²&S34D2úx5678ÆÇbò×BÈ;z¯�´êqÙ©¾H�³ÆJ9c���®©ç©&UòáÆ��²��¾Æò@���©ò@áÆ�eê7��©�©¹��Uòï*ô�?õñ©iƯôÛZ�©�Æ57�zjÆýtÁ´?�ò-Àx`�©¹��Uò¹ßáßô�©Ó�jÀx`57_�¿ZÀx`5678�ò�,Æc|Á��ò©³®�ZÈ LV�èè³ôÀxÈ�� 200��Z詾³Æò@²
129
34D23iÅ�²´e~�Æ56��S�5ªª9:�;< ,UB¾!Ūª���Áì@²÷57q5M¡&�¸ab�¡S�«kYF�ec©UBA�¨¯�¡©�Æ©��ab�¡�>?��ïáÆUBC�,�F5M¡&X�wvUBý�©�Êjôxe~¾U9:À���Zzcu*5M¡&��Êj?ÀUB5Mñ¿a¾jW�wxvF�ý�5678¾U9:�-b³Æ�d���©�¯?�ÁF�¸¹)�,?�¾�»â³�-=ÚÛÜùÖ�²
2�:;%9䮯åæçè�\���éêN¬Ã��QR<�"�����:������½�éêN�Á�vw���¬���çè¬ö��k�Nºq�ë�uv��¬����·���ú�NÁÂ�\���éê�ï�:`��34ÃÄd^:zÊABNÁ:%9¬¾���N�������klB��£¯÷N�Â�:34�[�56ÃÄd·�:Ê�Uò�·"ôÆà·�F�5M4P��¯©F�5M4P�c?êê³Æ=F�©iF��7ù�³ôÀ�¾F7ù©i��¹�?Â�F��ò¯AB`LM©Z�)¯Ù©F��ªªº�à�©�ÆÝÁõ��¯î©ABò×56á5ôx©æ�Fò¯³�Z�)©¾ôÆfFò�¾1���¸�ï*0ª\��0ªSS©ý�`Ûà�©ÝÌ1Á�=²AB5678»��u��S®¯©�ƾUà8pBÚ¦©æ®¯�©�Gæ��©¿ZÑTà6ÚÛýt�u�²ä�®�Y�ÝÆ]^_�5^J�F�çÀ�;�©AB�5^³à;¾j`© �\aFìÆàW©iABF�5M4P?�jÀòR�ËAB�5678àô>�©���ò`�ìôÀG���©¿ZÙAB?Â�F��7ù�©�`Ù©�Æô·��²��?Â��¯�[Fò���ò�ô�=�©o£òÝÌÀ¯©�Ó�H�ôÀ¯©¿Z»��2©³Æo£P©�ƾÆÌS�©Çbo£?6�c��Ä�Ãà ©ABÝÁT��u��Z�¾¿°�F�5M4P¯�©�-bAB�571Æ1ÁAB���©?=zF��ÝÁ343ie~���b6©��U©�Öò��.=)áô�©5^�&¼�Æ OK�©�Æ�8òV��ÓòV���ÆGô��ÓFR�©G¸Ù]^_©Ó&�UòáÁ��=)©5M#$\�<=)\¨Í#$áôÀG���©÷+Ó��34e.¾�5MÈîGAB�ÃW ©¿Z���Êj�òR¹�
130
���`a�ë���¯÷N�����/ìkÃ�Ï56����Uy��NÁÂ��¬�Uy���N>�=ºI�¢�dÐÊáâ=�ö�NE5�`a�����¬�7�ÑBÊ�-b�«AB�57?F��©!³?�³Æ"r?ÄÅ©w¯³Æ?��3Õ¥y©���«=®Ûx�³Æo£ò©�ÓFR�ò³ÆU2 ©¿Z¹�¸�"�ôÄÅ©H�ÝÞ"C¿°�F�5M²w¯³ÆAB�"rf5^�ÇêÃS¯©5^=xì]=x`�©hÃ; ©¾?¸�Â�òRÙæ�FR`ôx©�Æ���Z`�����ÆÝÁ�©æ�ô=`©��Z`©òR-À¯©æ�Z`©�ì�Z`©�Gæt�©Gæ�©òR-À¯©ô�æ�Z`©�ì�Z`©�Æ�GHv©ìÝÁGH�©�À¯�C�AB�57ªªÁ>�U�Fô=`�Ó�1G��³e�é�Æ34�"��,��ô=`¾U éF��34fS57¾�»�ÇÐG���©ABôÆ é
1�ÁËã÷@)*���34¬�7�+ �V:*� WXE���`ak;56�2zN(:¬�þ{NÁÂ�%9���%&q>EÒ�Ð��¯ 8`a�ÑBNÒ'+9� �k;3ÖÊïl"rÄÅ ©1?34=nû�����Zô "rÇêAÃÄ�ÝC�9"ÝÆ]�ªª©34ìô?Êj�F��\`����-�Z`©¾£�áÆ���ò�Å©£�áÏò�f©bÊjô`TU;�©À�Fò¯6��_�®q«X��ñ��56\6�¿¿K�_¡õæ1Böê ,º���B�¢ ,�¬fUB�5;<C >>â¹ é¸Â�x ,�Æ.£d��©UB5M�59:�oÜjfÆ"rÕÁç½ÕÁS©ô1þøù5M9:,-� ,Êê�;<©�þW³q� ,�¸���\�d�Sq�¤j⥠éAB�5^ý�àu*঩KJ�Áì]�=)©��S"r�&£©û�Uáŧ ²AB1ÁÊj1|�ZG�òá�÷+�Z�F��¼XÂ�òR¯�©��ô178©1Áæ0©Çbæ0GHÅD©ÆZüýb¬v�©¾UfAB¯}ÆÁu��©]^_q5©ò)°±ÆGô����é
131
� � � � � ������D��4B�B� ¡D100� 7p 12�¢£DNnFo�]78<5¤�¥Dh�ª ¡¢£�t
� � « ���Áô�������4�tNËÌÍ��Î��Ç34¯klNÁÂ�
`a�¬����(¤ÐÑBÊ¥^�56q�릧»Ð¨©Ê��¤�xK<dP5M¥Þ àW�Ù�À©��N1Ýõ�q«��³x` ¾�§Î©�ÆiU¥È1Ævn]g©ÀoR�ËAB� �F�°q�©1Á��5MÈî©�¼¥1ÆfÐJ;©oR³�˾UÉ]³u� ²"¹�õö©��xln �U�B©�,?vl�UgA©¾À !¯`ÀGHÁ�(�©À�Ö×y:�¯`Æàb6�²�ÆdP��n�`�JÀ�n�Ààô�©dP�Æb dPêë�ò½©x ¯AdP�ò½©Ó�Æ!Á�Ó�E5©dP�Aô�¡©�JÀ ÆGH4ÚS��@�dP©³Æ,2�5M78\¾F\æû0F\¯�ÝÆ��êë�%&:�©¿Z"¹���³õöë� ©,2³Æ����êë²��õöxu¨AB�u�©��JÀo)Ú¨©Çb�JÀ����«�n �Uüý:�âXï©þüý:1b�U9:©A�� �U�þ�¯`�<©G¸Ù.ì\ABï"Ó5MdPS©Æ�¾�!ÅGHÁ��D2²AB�¾�»ÁÊju�?³"F�5M¯·©ò�bÊj?x�ÓFR`5M��E$5MÀ�)Rk?©×Á 40%�G�rs?Á³e�\ª�l3©l3?³e©\ª?ef©¾ÆF�5Mê�)�>?Ƕ©ä�u*�5Müý� 32%©¾³ÆbÊjoR?x]^_`5M©Ó��l3àô>©üý��à�Ì�àò@�©¾U-ÆF�dPP?�E$5MǶ©ä�1Á®SÈ¥y�KÌ©G¸Ù®�)ô=S©³´?E$5M©®¯²÷ôÆ>?�Ƕ²¿Z?þ5M1b�U9:©AB��XÁTU¾V�
1. AB�ªª�Z78�]¯}©oR�=ô�Ë©&$U[F5�³ÀÁ�U¯AB6�©¿ZAB[F./zàW���5�©¿ZABÆÁà��ªª���²ä�®Æ`�¨�ªª©��ìáÁx�+�Fx`ªªyz©¾UáÆ"AB�ðÏÏ
132
�;<z¯�©¿Z�����ÆGH³e�²2. AB�\ª�å�+1Á 20A©ª� 640üï*ab©�AB³Á 3AqW©G�AB�pJ\ª��°±Æà��²
3. AB�5M( �H��%HSXF÷<©��ABfS5��(Æ�GH�²
4. AB5M�!t@�5MÈî£0�Û©Ò«@à�©Z�]5M¯Ù©àWXFòrx[F`��©��×Áô�ò½©�¯1À�Î�K©�Æ[F�ªªÆAB�IèÓ��©º�[FGHÀ�Ù©��<Æ�Uào���©Pf:òP©¾ÆAB��ou�²
��I����0������¬�þ{N�Áô��t��£¯÷N`a�����dã�S\��ÑBÊ:;\������(��)���çèNÁÂ��������UyEª«õö¾�¬ÊAB�NÁ:`a����34�[�56dã÷�Ê5M�&ÆU�ð��9:©Pò?`5M�,ÆZ!t@bc©o×1Á 3%�òÀÁ`E+5M�´ê©��`�UÅD�5M©Æô´?`xE+5M�zj©Êj¥È-´?`xE+5M_�
1. Á¿ôh��¸o£��1Zªª1��«���©¿ZÓ��./�,ôÀ�©³fÓ�Á�Uo5ñ�Á'5^©�Æ=üý�ò ²´ìKJ�;©¿Z��ìô´?±ïõ� dP5Mq�©ÀÁoO�ò¬eAB©o׳Æi 3%�ò÷¬²
2. (ï�ôh�¾ 3%À¯AB�ÇìÁ¿ô�©� �ªª��ôhq�©¸�ÓfSiU; Á'�5�ôn�Á(ï�u©¾ìÆÀe�E+5M��U��²
3. 5Mªª�ï±����þ�©ªª���Á��³Æu�©�Æ{ó|©���ªª³Æ�Îk�ô�©a�¥yGHÌ©¨¦Ã©ìÝÁª«©¿Z��þ����Z`ÛGHï�\ï±\�þ�Eå²
C�ÁÃW�b6ÇêÝAB�5MdP ©]^_" 2002 �-õö;<5MdP©¼¥]^_34�� àW�Çê©G¸ÙÓ�F�dP5M¾PûÆ8ÌÈ����©ABÝÁ�R5Mñ¿ÆBÌÌxé��²ä�Á ��l3�ªªq�©1?Á��ò-©]^_xé �\®x�5�©�Ó��¼ð���³�Z�]^_�:©ABÆô�=¾`�©¾ìáÆ3i���©¸�?Z9:¯·º5M©Á>�U9:ÆÝÁ�34�Ç.�=��;<��5MdP¸�ÆU9:©341ÈcnÆôÀ�¢�©:�ìÀ®¯®
133
ÝÁ(ï©ä��¡l3�õ�©®Æ�¯°±©å�+á�È�¥È©1ÁAB�M[1Ýõ�©AB1GM[¤�VVõ�÷¬©¿Z���¸¹)�d���©��5^eô¯©��l3ìeô¯©5M"�ÇêÃW©À��ä�ÃW©¾À�ò�o½e�¥È©����³ÀBÕ® ²XFo£b Â�F�5M©�Z����±x��²�»ð`5M4P©?]^_¯í©èÓ¿ð©£\Ó�æ©5�¯ èæ��©]^_�[FÀ�¾ûÁ�»ð`F�5M4P©¿Z¾�UFR�ÆW³ ©2004��n q�©�Uo£���³B¾�UFRj= ²¸�C�"r�ù©ABÆÀÁ¸¹)�©1Æ��"ä� 10³15 �xe©[F" 1990 �³exXF©Èvè¨C�!O`o6ñ%\5Mñ¿`¨C©îÛ[F�5��o£Äö �´}ö0¬�cµ©]^_º�ÝÁ[F¾jWo�C�è¥�Ù©��;ì" 2002 �³õö` ©¸����"rÄÅ©òRìÀÄÅ éZ�����©[F¬N ���îÈ��z78 ©�ÙüAB1´? 5³10�-Àõ�©¿Zº���¬ä� ©�ô?À�g®¯®o©Çbå�+�¸¹ôÆ34�Aê�²AB�«ÝÁ�UnB@�5ñÓó¿©ô®aF�û×5ñ©[F� BK1�5ñ©¾UáÆ:+¦�@�5ñ©ABÝÁW�¶©AB�>Vá��o5ñ©®ÆAo\MIS©Ó�ôÀÚ>57�]©Ó�?�Æ�)\�&S>VLM©¿ZXî34èÓ�e~©f5M78¯ÙìôÀ¾�x;<²�¸�È�ôn;<©Dþ��25�¿`z¯��¯áà�©�ÇbC��"r©AÝÁò�Z�Ⱦ�»²
2�Á^ôÃ�j�tN��t��£¯÷NÁÂ�Í��®Ù�Çmn4¯ØÙN{|�Æ��Uy¯+9k;3ÖN�`a��Í��Î�$l2�K�Â3�NÁÂ�¬�¡ÃÄ=kúÆZ[�4VÊABÁ^ôdõö¯x�÷�Ê
134
H�"�·"Æf�©©��5M�&Á�U9:©G¸Ùe§��&³ÆËSÎk5M©¾³Æ´?å×æûç~¯;±��U<Æã�Æ®5M78�øùþ���ÆËSæû9:©ÓÆÈ5M�z½�Èîx`9:�;<²àW5�Àë�x57©� ?^õæçò��·�q�©��ë`57ìô�,À�¢©àW®Æ¸´\ÝÆ�\�5^ë`57©��1Æë�x`�\©¾³Æ���øY�ê²w¯¾U®ë��5^��Æ��WQ�ÈîjÚ��"·/ï)©H�"�¡¢²´Æ�Zwx©�²´ìÊôݹ©Çb8Yº�àgj©�ìÝÁ"rÇêô ë�©æxdú1ô¸xÊ8©H�"ÁH�"�n�©Ó´?;±à>�wÀ<Æ©�ƾ�®"fS��`5MdP9:ìô�²
��%9ä®� �çè�\���éêNQR»<�������:������½�aGN¬Ã�°±ù\¥¯`��AÒ����²!ô~���%&NÁ:%9¬¾���dã÷�ÊÁÂ�¬ÃÄÃ��×��%&�³ÊC���5MdP9:��U��ÆêP¯x���©Çê�ô$�©ª©àWò®©���"�ô$��0�M�ÝÆÇ�G���"¯A©ÝÆ�Uª��´?ä�ºF��D©¾U�G���ìÆ�U��©¾�aF³ÆdÞvé³�Z ©�AB³��õnß.\r��SS²w¯³ÆZ�À���5MÀ¢zj©5MÀ¢Æ�¯���ÝÁò¯��©¾fABÆÀ��;Å�ÔÕ©5MÆKJcd�©ïlCÛô�©ÝÁò�Z��©[F�o£�dP5Mzj³Á�U��z©�!³��z���¯`�Î�ô8©��ôü��©?="Y� �u©i�¯��¾U"Y�zj�dP5M78Ì����Ưô ©Ì�áÆ`î�]�ÅD�7ù©�¾dP5MôÀKE©Çb¸�þdP5M9:,2�¾j»R���©¾U9:ìô�;< ©ÇbÓ�ec�Ä�Ãà ©?;<�zjÆ���ªª©ì³Æ«Å}�u�?ì�z¯©Ó�?¯��¾û³Æç©��=ÁÓ�ÝÁ���ªª©¾��ABÁ�TUu��©�Æ�qá1ÆÀ9�5MÀ¢�©¿Z34ÁÝÁ¾U�ê¯ô8©¾�ÎÆ�,?���©Iô=dÆ`ÅD�LM¹é¾H�³ô´?;<©;<?µ��=©G¸Ù+,>v©�ƾ�À¢}~³à�©��?Á�Uà��ßg�ê©ì��?Áò-�y�-�²ä�àWòúx&Sç~��æ���©G¸Ù¯AB"©5M©Ó�
135
x=ô=�æÝÆWÚç~è驾Æ789:GH;Qx�©��`78�]�f!¯}ìô=��Ó��wÀç~Ý5Mç~ûÅ©��C����Æ��ú_�G��ô=�Ó�¼ð�æ©ô=�bÓ��Çz©¾ÀûÙ �UÓ�¯�¡Ú© �Æ����5MùȲä�Pfê�w7����©���¾ÆU�[��©®[F34³À���Ñ�ê�w©ÀÓ�xs�%&òV¯[Fêë\wr©�Âvnõ�&£©�ÆÝÁÑ�7��zj©�Ƹ���34b ;<dP5M©è Ó��Utv��I©1?Ó�ÆC�¾�!Oe¯AB`57\æ0\~¾SS©úzG�³èx��©¾-=�ê�w©Çbo£5¯A©ABðÞ5ÆÝÁÊj���©Ó��þqÁ��U¿9�`¨C�ß�©9���ÁÇ©b â��©ø�³ÀÐ�GH��¯�ó¿©£Pa o�¯A`5M78�Bàà¼Ñ©`z¯�"*ìÝÁ�©AB�5M]g³vn�¾Uò0û ©¿ZAB�5M78ÀzCºÔê�õÔ��DÆ�ZÙ¢�©¿Z¾U9:ÝÁ34��µÆ`ôö¯�²®C��ÌÍ Î?���UF�5M4P©�iUð!õ�è"ò�È©ÀàWò�˯AB³�ZdÞ xè�Á�:Á5MÈî©�È��Zßû©¾Æ]^_¯O©¾à� é¾Uò�34¾,��µ�AôÀ5ÙÚ5M�ÈÆ��©�ÆC�ÁU��³ÆF�5M4P�jÀ�¾j�½�ð!©ÓÐF�,?Á��ê��9:ÚÛ©¿Z��¾�5M9:=ô=øèøhá1ÆU��©ÐFÝÁ�Ó7ù�dP�Èî©ÇbF�5MôÆ1Á?§Ú�ò-À¯ éPfAB��ÈîuS]^_���¯Ù©5M��*f ©Á¾U}^®«¼��©¸�5M��*ôf©¾UÈî^e¯ìôÀÛj©�5ñð��`7NC©fS��@�ò¯AB©Ó�Àb AB��ß³¯�)��¿Z;<���ªª\l3\��\4R©¾-ÆÂ�òR¯�Ç©�Ó�1Æ}^®«÷¬²¯`78�ôƧò©¸�?û78��Ö5Mø��ö�¥È©àW©hƳ¾ô��©�Æûµü{z¯�¥È©�8F�dPÈîu¨�u©�G�Ö5M?¯Û^j©ÇbP��´êÆô��©785M�PòÆb ��\�æû\�ÁË)\���d©Ó�¯`785M���³Æb À�Ë��©¿Z¾UdPÈî�u¨-=b785M^j©�Æ�Ö>V5M³ôÀ^j ²
1��;)*���+ N:;:*����´q�µ WXNÁdã÷�ʥ˶,-.@��%&ìk7ÓçèNÁÂ�¬Ï%&ÃÄE�I\���34�¯56�·�Ê
136
NnFoC��`�èÓ./Æ�v��N6ª��+Íx¿©¾À^áAB�fN�5678�'�©?³Ácµ©òR-À¯ý©?ÁJ�-Á��©Á��-=�Ù©�x1ÆøÙøu©ÝÁøY�P��¯�¥È©à6`���Ù©Çb�Ö5P¯�¥ÈÆà���©Çb5���Aôèé78��©¿ZÓ�ìô=ßõ©�ÆøY�q�©Ó��ZûÓ����� blog�©³õöB�¬ ©YSB�¬��8GHtv©³À9����Ù©¿ZøY�q«à����`AB�5M78©øY�q�AB�Þ{VÀWàW²��ÀGH±ï�©h³Æ¾U9:�¯Æ�jx;<�©Z��NnFo�n�¼�ÆÀ¡v��\+,\cµ\J�©��xì����}^®«©ê�5�i5MdPx}Ë�À`dP78©�Z���n�®x±;�©h³Æç©���A�UØ£©Æû78�];<��U9:©É�dP\7ù�ê멾�UÆàô��©�UÆdP¯ AB�78�]©�1Æ�VV�î�]³�Z ©�¾U9:f��¯}³ôƾj�¡©ÇbôÊÁÝÁ£P¯A©��ø�AB³Á¾�7ù) ©��ç©�©h³ÆÅ)x`©�¤34x`©��?`�Æ78�]�W�¶©x`�UdP78�9:©ÀoR·xAB`Ûà�©É�£P¯©ÀÓ�ÁÝ\Áß\Á�©À®¯AB`78�]�ò1�ZɤÓ��Rò�ö¯©¾�ÅzC�¥È³Æýt�78êë²
<�¸R·d�56VÁ·(¤�ª�k�¯÷NÁÂ�`a=Í��3456¹º»N�Y�7'�(���¼½��)>�=TUоd�ßàʸ�Zêë¯É785M1=`ÅD�zj©Aô=rAB�785M�¾�©AB�¾���?Áá÷Á)�ìV©ìVz¯q�ø�=Â�ò�Ô�©.ÎCD�xq�©¾UìV-À®¯®ì©C�1=}¤�dPò�©��³Á©³ÀoRÁJ�©-=e�fx`©Çb��C��¾z½ä��òô�©ô�=��³À�ò�ËAB�5M�=ÁÊj�©Ó�ÝÁJ��q«Æà6�i�a�©¿Z��³ÀÏÏ��ê�ò©����1Z\ó|\���SS��Æ�æ�ô��©¾Æ´?¥y�©Çb�%(¾L©hÀ�¢©¿Z�-À%(�`¾U©hÆÁ¡��©÷+��Ë����B?�j`©�ÆÁU:�ô·�ÝÆÝÁÛÜNï��¤@²³�¼�àWX�:ÔµâÒ�©[À�§©¸�þ¯ÝÁIØ©��1Æ���©àW5Mò-áÀÔx���MÃx ©¾Æ·Ûz¯�²
137
� � � � � ��1���D�(¿)û�Å�A� ¡D100� 6p 22�¢£DX:×F785656À¤�¥D�ÀÁ\������ûÂÃ)MªÄÅƪ ÇÈÉ�t
� � « ���ô��ÀÁ\������û�ÂÃ)MªV`a±Ê��û)MªN
:;`a�����56¿��!dÆÇ���ËÌNÁÂ�`a�����56¿��ãÊÃÄ(¤Í��ÑBÊ�®AB57�u�²´ì¸�[F\��É:Æ27³eFRSJ�h]©ì³ÆÙ©_ÄhNR�K©¿Z&UòáÀõöÚ>ø���Ë"*©¾Æ��UÀ¬Ü°±;<�u�ã��Uu�³ÆC�òc�^\ghijäK ©¾Æ�Ut��K�FRÝƬõ;FRÀñ����©÷��¸¹wÀ©W1� ��©ÝÆu Åô��o©É:ôuÅ©¬ÜwÀ�màd�©¯î¿:�ÆäK©wÀd�^�;���Cg©��wÀ¸¹Ôf©Àò�¿���¥)�^©�¬Ü57�°±;<©¾UÆ���ä�Uu�²ä�Æò)Èî��u�©C�Ùd56`Ûô>©�§�ò; ©��úx¿���¸¹`ghij�äK©¾ìÆ���êÀ�^�>?Ƕ²Z«¿°�Îk78�¸#$5©� SAP©x�¯���\©�ñ�\]Ç\\^¾U�©¾Æ�Uà>?�zj©�ƾU¬ô=9hwÀoØ ©SÆ9� �U��©�UÆÇb\ª�ef©G¸Ù��\�Æ�©¤�� 80 �¦ÆÈ�6�[©�¯IÈ�°�[©�¾U1ÆÝÞ"9h©x 90�¦e�P��ªª©21�$I=îPªª©¾û¿°���u�³Æ57��"Îk�78È e�x�UÀ¾UwÀoØ=nÞ ¯ô´?�ñ³�Z9h��\�Æ�´ê©"o��§�î��©����ê�]XV�©¾ì³Æ����ê!Å�u�²����ê�u�Á�Å©�UÆ5�©ä�UƼ�©÷+ô´?�ñ©�0ª²��\ª�9"�5M�¡�efZÓ�8KJÁëÉ�5^©^�Z[\5^\���\5^J�¯w�©%&�4:òæV�©^�56À1Ò.%&��8^\78^©¾FG@�üý²AB�?%FR%G©5ª²´Æ5���2�©¾ôÆÊo©[F¿Á�1|áÆ34å)�Ó�§Î©aFìÆÁFR3i�e~©A
138
B�o��E³Æô=`â�©"YÇêÃS¯é5MÆfòæû�©:©^��U&ï\ï8���©ô�Æ��1Æè&78©&Sæûò�èÓbÊjô=§Î_�×ØÁ��Lû é1Á�U>V©C�57�9"©ô�ÆÈP�1Æ����©iU�¯³Æ5M�9"©i�jÀô=§Î_�C�È�Ë�]\³´°©³Æ±²`©ÓÆ�U�8�Ë�©¿Z¾Æ��U>V©¾Ææû�9:©��ô�Z§Î�UB�5MÊê�?%NÒFRG��ÃS¯ é34K�ÝÁÌ1¤j¾�Íé
��ËÌÍ����Î��Ç34N�ä?�56¯÷N����ì�úÎ�\¥Ï¤N`a�����UyÐÑ�\�q¸ÒuÓÔÕNÁÂ�����ÃÄE�`a+9}� �k;3ÖÊfS34-b5MôËS9:÷ËwÀEå�zj©ZÓ:+-bÎk5Mò-���ÇÆÇbæçê�ô0Ø���¾V¯Ù©�-b&UòáÁô���×�6��þ�©�?�Ë�Æ©¿Á5^5�Rò�ï1Æ� �XZ�©ô?ûæçê�¼C�U�c²èé®56XïÓàW8òó¿Íá�þæç�Ë��²�ÆÁ´?¾jW�5ñó¿��©��Æô´?�©34¸�õ�Ó��Z`�Óì�z�o�R9«�5Mþ�©%(fUB�·/�,Æ�WÛÇé3iê�Æ?I©Z�9\b�©�x�9�½æçèé-��W»©�Æ?W��E5�æ©¡½\o�½1?ΰ^�©¾���H�Æ;±ôö�²C�æçèé¨Ib�9�½è��$©�Æ�Åa;��ÝÁò?��o ©¿Z¾�!ÅìÆ���ê���©`3iÆÁ&£Ý>©�Æô=0åõÏSæç�ê�©1Æ1Æ?`�¼�¨t²
2�Á^ôÃ�j�tN��t��£¯÷NÁÂ�Í��®Ù�Çmn4¯ØÙN{|�Æ��Uy¯+9k;3ÖN�`a��Í��Î�$l2�K�Â3�NÁÂ�¬�¡ÃÄ=kúÆZ[�4VÊABÁ^ôdõö¯x�÷�Ê
139
¸����56ñ�6���6³�FbÊj?�56ñ©�dxõö���¥Èw`�½�F©·Ó�Æ?x��©ÝÆ`UÊj©®��:�¥È©���6á)¤£Ð�qïÙ?x`Êj`Êj©�ÆR���ÆàC��©æ·¾U5^�ï[Æ�`Êj©æ-=ýt��Ó�"��Ú©xe�56ñ©xe�¿��®"Ƹ�©��wx��ôl©ª���5^©C��¿�ÁÝÁ?ë:©bÊj?ë:�w�[,ôl�d5^©ï[�ÆÊj�û¾Uï[jk0 -=¯s¾L©h²Z«������ÚƼï*\Ý�v�\5^©Çbi�Z5ò©¾³ÆZ«5^�ï[©�¾Æt~�©º�C�wÀ#$ô�©�ìô:Sû¾�£ÑqïèÒíÚ©¸�ÝÁÒíÚ©H�"�d·Êj����5^ò-Æ�è�©�è³ÆÁ�×x`Êj³`Êj©¿ZÝÁ¿°ëôëbüý:���²
��%9ä® �çè�\���éêNQR»<�������:������½�aGN¬Ã�°±ù\¥¯`��AÒ����Ö!ô~���%&NÁ:%9¬¾���dã÷�ÊÁÂ�¬ÃÄÃ��×��%&�³Ê¾¼�Æ�� é�ÆòR¬=�«Å ©��ÁÝÁ¸¹)_�¾L©¤�ô�«³²´?` ©¾Æ¥y���©��ZçGAB�57ò-6f�+��©�¾áÆ3i"r���²AB�ò-àu'©ÆÇb5+W¬�òàÈï©Þ àW6ªç©�¾U5^á-bø�à�©��ÝijÅD�©C�w�iUF�5M4P�ò©áÝÁÊj4:òæJ�w�©ìÖa �ý�FGÊ8�=)²
1��¼½���×Ø�NÁLM$Ù<Î)*�����¬����+ N:;:*�����µ WXNÁdã÷�ÊÁÂ�)*�+ E�`a�����56�¯Ð·�AÚÛÊ
140
ÈPÆ�,Á�©ìÝÁ¿°�¸¹©>V1Æ���ÁÝÁu�©o£�uV³ÆpJKJ�©©Jzj��JÙo£ô�©�C�Ó�oO���©÷+�màÒ«�婾ÆàÓg��L©²F�5M4P?��©���ò=)nôn©4:�ònôn©¾-Æ>V¿�©��©�dP57!Å©o£-b���«�5M4:ªª1Õ®Ó�àW©É:G[F1?�²�ÆABÁÝÁG[F��1ÆÁ�©�ôÆ&Uòá�Ëé5M¡&pJ�zjw�¸ab�¡xôÆ��ô�©÷Æ��ô`©C�ABòáôÚ¡`¾U©Çbò�v©^�"r�Çê©34ì�e~¾U9:;<©¼�ÝÞ"GH�²
<�¸R·d�56¯÷NÁ:`a�����ܯdã?@ÊËÌÍ^Î��Ïmn34NÁÂ�ÝÃÄ>dÒÓTU�Þ¡Ê�ºÆ�,Á�©&bABò1ÆÁABò�PMé�Æ©"©57�ò?¸�À¾U�¢�òû�¢�Îè´?�ò©oR�öûüý"*�4:ªªáú»©AB�579:-À`Û�²ÌÍ�F�5M4P%(34�,��àWï)©ç©Ó�Z`�¢©?`�¢©³Æ?ÃVûiUô¨8q5MÊê"r×�Ú7Ú²
141
� � � � � ��<���D�(¿)û�Å�B� ¡D100� 7p 12�¢£DABdP5M;<À¤�¥D`a����56¿û )Mª Çßà�t
� � « ���Áô�`a����56¿û)MªN:;\�����������
�0��%&�çè�8¯áâ�NËÌÍ��Î��Ç34¯klNÁÂ�`a�¬����(¤ÐÑBÊ¥^�56q�릧»Ð¨©ÊABdP5M;<À¬e���Ô©�¾þ%���¥yûÅ©��;CdP5M¾�»©F�f���5Má9¡,�©1Æ���34�,2�á1ÝÁÞ"åÛ�!v©®�«£PøY�©34AÝÁû���u�\�áþ�5Mþ�`�U§Î\�â�±3�C©º����W«Á��Ùf?`dP5M©�ÆAÝÁà�����,2²�Up«©ª©aFÁù5M5f¯Ar�©Ó��;<!v©èé®[F©34Á�Ò!Åú_Èî�©AB ÆÀ×y�ø;<©AB�5MJ´Á[oñ%©&U56ñáÁÓ��56Xï©¿Z?ûdP5M¾�»`�©²´Æ34?zů`�¨²¸�?`dP5M©ZAB¯}©¾\�GH �©®Æ~¾�z½©ABo×Æ 6³8 �©ª�®�©�Æ����=³Æ 15³20 ��®�©F�5M�u©²´ÆÙABÁ>U5Mþ�ÆGHáþ�©�¥34ì²´x§¬©À���F��=Á�U�'�©¤���dP5M;<ÀÁ`�U.§xF�©iÓ�³À®?xAB¯Þ 5M©G¸Ù®Æ�)\�&Sáþ�>VLM©�Æ���ÝÁx`§¬���©²�¯·aF©Ó�³��Û9��©34²´n��U56Xïx���F���Áu���'��5^¯�nF�5MX奄ÀGHÁvyx`¾L©²��"àWF��¯�É]Û�©¾F�5M�z½ÀÁþ% 800 W�©þ% 1000 �7��9«©¸�þF�5M¼`�U9:�u©34Æ«Ûx��¾L©�²
142
��I����0������¬�þ{N�Áô���t��£¯÷N`a������ãä�å���dã�S\��ÑBÊ:;\�������������çèNÁÂ������ãä�å������UyEª«õö¾�¬ÊAB�NÁ:`a����34�ãä�å����[�56dã÷�ʸ�Z��¾\¯Ù�u©ô�«��³õö`¾FÕ`�þ�©C�쮯®Ò«©ªªìïex¿°���ÑÖ©�½ìÁò"F�¯�Pò�ZÞ �× 5���®¯©¯ABѾ���ÑÖ©�MÃì�®¯ì�ôWÁ 8000�ò×Ô²C�®¾KLM@�ªª©�«�F�áÆYõ:5^ø�xõ;\�©�Æ¿°�F�5M©�?Û8��Æ?³�xF��áþ�Æ>F©ÆF��òÀ4�÷�¯©ô�T®��e�¾�5M©®Æ~¾©«�´�ìÁòa 40 �~�×¾©¿ZF�5MÆ?þF�u'�pJl3©Ú¨u'�5^x;<�©®aFÆZ�U��Á���!Oxé©�Æ�F�³ÀÁ�U¸E©³®ÆÁ�ò�5MJ´©?=dP5M�u©³À§�ÁUòéGH��ùÈx`LM©G¸Ù®æç©�UÆÎk�æç©�UÆF�5M©F�5Mß�ùȳÀô�©ÆÝÁ�ç~èéq��²
2�Á^ôÃ�j�tN��t��£¯÷NÁÂ�Í��®��Çmn4¯ØÙN{|�Æ��Uy¯+9k;3ÖN�`a��Í��Î�$l2�K�Â3�NÁÂ�¬�¡ÃÄ=kúÆZ[�4VÊABÁ^ôdõö¯x�÷�Ê
Z«�56D8Ëø%¼�áf©��X�b 5òÀôØØø�t~©�ÆC�ôÃ�©ôÆÙÝÁD8Ëø©÷Æ®x��o6ªx©¬Á 2³3 U¾5´Ùe «ô'©¾�sÙ5M¬�ë§ ©Z«Æ�Ü���ÍÍx�5\©�iU¥ÈÆÝÁæç�©®Æ�\\�9\áÆß�à��©�ÆC�ÁæçZ�©Î°³ô®Z«� ©ìÌ1Á 5³10©ª�pΩG¸Ù�x��Uò�&©æç5MùÈ�ôW 1�©øùùÈ�ôW 4�©¸�Æ 1�»�u©åx5^0X�ì̳1è�Tλ ²¾³Åax�U��©C�?x56ñ�6�©Ó¸�Ù?x¼�U�\5^©³ÀÁàW�5MÀ¢�}~?°±©�=õñ?'ôTU�¥©�Ææåx�ºAÝÁGH�©Çbæçèé³Æ¾j;©%f¯Ù©Ó¸�"©5M78�z½©a�¥yGH;©åx���GHW©Çb¾-ÀàW5^=v5M78¾�»²:SF�5M�Îk5M¯ÙÆô¸E�©34²´ûF�5M¼`�
143
U9:¯é©���5MÆ34²´��wÀç~�ý©�Ææ·�x�Îk5M`C���:5M²´Æ�Z�¥A��©�Ƹ�¿Á�5^áµ�:5M=©�J�5M"*ÆÀµ�Ú�©ÇboRôÚ¡x`iU}~��þ�©¼�Æ��ÅD`���W��þ�¯`©¾Æ34´?xÅf�©�Æ®æçìÆ34��§q�©d�Ù��ÓFRGfÆ9�¢�©�ÆC�c?Æ#$�I§©oRá®?öÄ�V©¾UÆ34´?zůô8�²
��%9ä® �çè�\���éêNQR»<�������:������½�aGN¬Ã�°±ù\¥¯`��AÒ����²!ô~���%&NÁ:%9¬¾���dã÷�ÊÁÂ�¬ÃÄÃ��×��%&�³Ê
�-bªª�ò-GH>?©÷ôÆÙ�,?l�ÌÍÝÆ>û©?�jx�¨[o5MJ´�ò¯F�5MXï-Æ>V²�«�Æç.�d©�[�©�1Æ-bô�,?l�¾��4PûÅ©ä�1ÁU��©³Æ�ÖdpÙ¸�?9Úæç©Ú¡aGHW�Û5M4PxÞ LMÆôÆ�Z_�5M4PqÇ�Fò7ù��¾ìÀ��Üs�g^o�ï8��²
1��IæO�¼½��×Ø�NÁLM$Ù<Î)*���+ N:;:*����´q�µ WXNÁdã÷�ʥ˶,-.@��%&ìk7ÓçèNÁÂ�¬Ï%&ÃÄE�I\���34�¯56�·�Ê��õö�¥È©�Æ).�º�ïh©�Æ�;<��N¨�q�;C©o£C���K��ÆÃÑÝ ©¤��¥ÈÓ��5^ÎÈ\l3á%¼ô�©C�Ó��5ñ�pJl3�ÅTTá¬Õ® AB©w¯³ÆÓ��ò-TTáÆ�xF�ê6©¿Zo£�����gAÝÁ®®X�o©Ó�i¥½O��KÆàÑÝ�©�pJ�ªª�áôÆ��²C�º�1ÆÁo£�ò¯AB©e�ÅD�57M�©�=�U¤�³0� ©�ƾ�¿°�F�5M¯Ù1ÆÁ���g©Z¾\¯Ù©¾\�dP5M�ÅÁào�Çê©®Æ~¾©Æô�=����0��©Æ´?�U��O�©ä�®ÆGHÅD�¾F7`�z½©o£ø��&³Á¾�ªª ©Z¾\¯Ù©õ�£Pɯ�R¼ûÁDz
144
ZdP5M¯Ù©��;CÁTU���1. 5MÀ¢�ô8���34²´���ÛF�5MÀäå�5MÀ¢´�jô8²
2. ç~����ÒUþ�Ó��F�ÀÁç~ß�;±©¸�xAB¯`LM�u©ç~´�jèé���©34�®ìÝÁ`�Ñ���²
3. dP������C�dP��1è�U��©¾�¥yà6x`xGH>V�LM²
¸�?þdP5M¼`�9:�u©���¨%&D2¯Åf©A)R>Uþ�Æ���áþ¯��U9:�;<²
<�¸R·d�56VÁ·(¤�ª�k�¯÷NÁÂ�`a=Í��3456¹º»N�Y�7'�����¼½���>�=TUоd�ßàʾ´?"34�&x��©���D2¯ô8�þ��©®Æâ����©¾Æ&S"�zj���©5M"ûÅ�,ô=`â�©�¯��b ¸�ÆF�5M©!È�.ÝÅJX.¯`â�³�Z©¾Æài©��L©²ä���úx�dP�����©�?�¥ÈÆôÆ�ZPf>VLM�z½¯õ����¥y²H�D2²´Þ<åF�5+od¯)R©É:´?Á�8òx?%�FR©®Æ[F\aFxr�©bÊjÓ��F�5MÀ`Ûij�¢©�c?1Æ?�jx§Î©1Á"��ÄÅ\>UáþÆ�¨F�5M²¸�Ù?ûF�5M¼`�9:©�Uò-bÆôÀ�Îk5MÁ¿ß{�²�Æ�æç�!ů٩¸�¿Á�þ�áBö�æçèé�u©ii�\�=³�ôW�ñô�x ©øù�þ�pW©i�\³À;<Û®�©®Æ�9\C�¿Á�þ�áö��æç©�9\5^¼�ÀëC5678²AB�æçÆb ,�§©¿Zàá 5^¾�»©C��5^�ß�¬ô®�x¾j� ²�F�5M�z½©�1Æ-b?³,2z?;<�þ�©wû��xF�;<àô>�5^ò-��¯²dP5M�z½©ê�w�7���ìÆ´?34zÅ�-�©Æ?�5^7����Æôèê�w7ìÙô�x©ô�AB�ê�w?7©o£�ê�wì?7©¿Z¾Uzjà��©Æ´?34zů��²