Upload
others
View
0
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
COMMUNITY LAWYERING
A PRO ACTIVE
STRATEGY TO
BUILD POWER IN
COMMUNITIES
S.L.A.T.
WENATCHEE, WA
OCTOBER 10, 2018
MISSION DRIVEN PRACTICE?
Public Interest lawyers have often wrestled with competing
missions. They are:
• Access to justice – focusing on resolution of problems in court.
• Law Reform – Changing structures to better accommodate clients
needs.
• Community empowerment – placing the client in a position of power
and advantage
• Community Economic Development – corporate counsel for the
poor.
DEVELOPING POWER IN THE CLIENT COMMUNITY
• The only approach that addresses power has been variously
called community lawyering, social justice lawyering,
rebellious lawyering, client centered lawyering; democratic
lawyering, opportunity lawyering, community
empowerment, collaborative lawyering. These all make up
the academic background of the practice
• Does the client leave the relationship any more powerful
than when the relationship began.
COMPETING DELIVERY SYSTEMS
CLINICAL MODEL
Who is in charge
• Lawyer determines the terms of
engagement.
• Lawyer determines the relevant
facts and narrative.
• Lawyer defines the problem and
solution
• Lawyer defines success.
• Lawyer retains power/Client
dependence
COMMUNITY LAWYERING
• The best solutions to any problem
necessarily involve those directly
affected.
• Never do for any group what they
can do for themselves.
• Use the law to place the clients in
control of their lives and
neighborhood institutions.
• Race and ethnicity become assets.
• Power and recognition transferred
to the community
You Don’t Have to Choose/The Approaches Can Be Merged
What Managers Can do:
• Require some time each week out of
the office
• Recognize and manage dual intake
systems
• Put race on the table in case selection
• Employ the Opportunity Analysis at
case selection/staff meetings.
• Promote the balance in weekly case
discussions.
STANDARDS OF PRACTICE FOR CIVIL LEGAL SERVICES
• STANDARD 7.16 ON REPRESENTATION OF
GROUPS AND ORGANIZATIONS STANDARD:
The practitioner should proficiently and zealously
represent groups and organizations to respond to
the legal needs of the communities served by the
provider.
• Representation of groups and organizations is
often a central component of strategies to
respond to needs of low income communities.
Ongoing interaction with community
organizations can also serve as an important
source of information about needs in the
community that help guide a provider’s strategic
planning efforts.
COMMUNITY LAWYERING PRACTICE
Meet clients on their own turf/Get out of
the office.
Approach the community with an open
mind rather than an agenda
Mantra: Lawyer doesn’t always know
best
Build infrastructure and capacity in the
community.
Leave something for the community to
use, e.g. maps/data
Touchstone: Is what I’m doing self-
sustaining for the community?
SCOPE OF COMMUNITY LAWYERING PRACTICE
8
• Advocacy crosses substantive silos.
• Advocate employs all legal tools to
achieve the client’s goal, including:
• Community legal education.
• Transactional work.
• Capacity building.
• Litigation.
• Legislative advocacy.
HOW COMMUNITY LAWYERS CREATE OPPORTUNITY
Ensure Ensure meaningful community participation, leadership and ownership in change efforts.
PromotePromote cases that are catalytic, coordinated, and result in a triple bottom line; (ie. Equity, Economic inclusion and Environment).
Expose and reduce
Expose and reduce local and regional disparities.
Examine and expose
Examine and expose racialized structures.
Integrate Integrate strategies that focus on people with those focused on improving places.
COMMUNITY LAWYERING OBJECTIVES
• Include client groups in strategies to couple community building and legal/administrative advocacy
• Let client groups guide the strategy using lawyers as one aspect of the strategy
• Open door for client groups to explore how race and poverty frame opportunity (this exploration and discussion must take place before any discussion of specific remedy)
• Use data to demonstrate impact of policy decisions and provide visual examples of inequity.
• Ground truth these examples.
• Create sustainable knowledge and programs so the lawyer can leave
WHAT ADVOCATES MUST DO TO PREPARE TO ENGAGE THE COMMUNITY
• Engage with humility
• Understand that relationships take time.
• Understand that you are a lawyer and may
never become a part of the community you
serve. You serve them nonetheless.
• You cannot lead, but you can offer
opportunities many of which will be rejected.
• You must bring all the tools of the law to your
client’s case. If you don’t possess them, you
must find them.
• You must have the difficult conversations about
race and identity at the beginning of the effort.
WHAT MANAGERS NEED TO DO?
• Require some time each week to be spent out of the office and in the
community.
• Realize that relationships take time.
• Value these activities in employee evaluations.
• Recognize that you are managing dual intake systems.
• Use staff meetings to report on progress so that all staff are aware of
the efforts.
• Employ an opportunity analysis in case selection.
• Prioritize community work for the most marginalized groups.
QUINN COTTAGESHOUSING DESIGNED BY HOMELESS
QUINN COTTAGESHOUSING DESIGNED BY HOMELESS
QUINN COTTAGESHOUSING DESIGNED BY HOMELESS
QUINN COTTAGES
• Won national awards for
design and resident council
program.
• Transitions 85% of residents to
permanent housing with stable
income within 18 months.
• Has moved 24 families from
homelessness to home
ownership in past 10 years.
FROM HOMELESSNESS TO HOME OWNERSHIP
HOUSING DESIGNED TO REUNITE FAMILIES WITH CHILDREN IN FOSTER CARE
SERNA VILLAGE AT MCCLELLAN PARK
• Built on the former McClellan AFB.
• McKinney claim submitted by non profit created
by loaves & fishes.
• Contentious history as county tried to deny
claim.
• Threatened litigation.
• 96 3-4 bedroom units built to suit.
• Designed to reunite homeless families with kids
in foster care.
ROOMING HOUSE WITH PROGRAM DESIGNED WITH INPUT FROM MENTAL HEALTH CONSUMERS
HOME OWNERSHIP: THE VIRTUAL DEVELOPMENT MODEL
• Low income buyers create a
development corporation for one
development.
• Pre development, engineering,
construction are contracted out.
• Organized client groups provide political
clout for the project.
THE VIRTUAL DEVELOPMENT MODEL
• The developer’s fee or “profit” is used to
reduce the price of homes.
• Corporation is disbanded after homes
are built, occupied and debts paid.
• Over 500 units built to date in Northern
California using this model.
SINGLE FAMILY HOMES IN SACRAMENTO
SINGLE FAMILY HOMES IN SACRAMENTO
FARMWORKER HOUSING IN DIXON,CA.
FARM WORKER HOUSING IN DIXON,CA
WELFARE JOBS PROGRAMS DESIGNED BY RECIPIENTS
• Placed 1200 recipients into jobs
averaging $16.50 per hour all with
benefits.
• Placed workers in jobs in the health care
industry with upward mobility.
• Targeted health care industry.
• Coordinated job training with hiring
agreements.
CHILDCARE
WHY WE ENGAGE IN COMMUNITY LAWYERING
29
“The legal aid lawyer will eventually go or
be taken away; He does not have to stay,
and the government which gave him can
take him back just as it does welfare. He
can be another hook on which poor
people depend, or he can help the poor
build something which rests upon
themselves—something which cannot be
taken away and which will not leave until
all of them leave.” Stephen Wexler, 79
Yale law journal, 1049, 1073 (1970
FINAL THOUGHT
• Highly attuned seekers and leaders have the ability
to see across categories and to recognize the
importance of bringing love into even the most
potentially mathematical equations. They also
importantly -- and here I think especially of Dr. King
-- place themselves in service to more than caring
for those in pain. They also place themselves in
service to the public face of love: justice. And they
call upon each and all of us to do the same.
• john a powell , Racing to Justice
QUESTIONS
• Are you currently engaged in community
lawyering that seeks to build power in the
communities you serve? How will the power
remain after your work is done?
• Do program structures encourage or impede
community lawyering?
• How are you accountable to the community?
• If you are engaging in community lawyering, how
are you accountable to your client
• What does it look like to be accountable to
communities most harmed by poverty and
racism?