A PORTRAIT OF PROFESSIONAL EFL TEACHERS

AT SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

SKRIPSI

BY

NISAUL QOMARIYAH

NPM 21601073066

UNIVERSITY OF ISLAM MALANG

FACULTY OF TEACHER TRAINING AND EDUCATION

ENGLISH EDUCATION DEPARTMENT

2020

A PORTRAIT OF PROFESSIONAL EFL TEACHERS

AT SENIOR HIGH SCHOOL

SKRIPSI

Presented to

Faculty of Teacher Training and Education

University of Islam Malang

in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of

Sarjana in English Languange Education

BY:

NISAUL QOMARIYAH

NPM 21601073066

UNIVERSITY OF ISLAM MALANG

FACULTY OF TEACHER TRAINING AND EDUCATION

ENGLISH EDUCATION DEPARTMENT

JULY, 2020

UNIVERSITAS ISLAM MALANG

FAKULTAS KEGURUAN DAN ILMU PENDIDIKAN Jl. Mayjen Haryono 193 Malang, Telp. 0341-571950

Nama : Nisaul Qomariyah

NPM : 21601073066

Jurusan/Program Studi : Pendidikan Bahasa Inggris

Judul Skripsi : A Portrait of Professional EFL Teachers at Senior

High School

ABSTRAK

Kata kunci: Guru EFL, Kompetensi Guru, Guru Profesional

Penelitian ini menyajikan potret guru profesional Bahasa Inggris di

sekolah menengah atas. Sebagai negara di mana bahasa Inggris berdiri sebagai

bahasa asing, kebutuhan akan guru profesional Bahasa Inggris memainkan peran

penting. Oleh karena itu, peneliti kemudian melakukan penelitian dengan tujuan

untuk memberikan deskripsi rinci tentang bagaimana potret guru profesional

Bahasa Inggris dengan menggunakan dua kompetensi utama yaitu Kompetensi

Pedagogik dan Kompetensi Profesional.

Penelitian ini menggunakan pendekatan deskriptif kualitatif dengan

rancangan studi kasus. Subjek penelitian ini adalah guru bahasa Inggris di salah

satu SMA dan guru bahasa Inggris di SMA Islam di Malang. Subyek penelitian

dipilih berdasarkan pertimbangan bahwa keduanya memiliki cara tersendiri untuk

mencapai profesionalisme mereka dalam mengajar bahasa Inggris. Untuk

membuktikan serta menyelidiki profesionalisme subjek penelitian, peneliti

mengimplementasikan penelitian berbasis online, yaitu; wawancara online,

menyebarkan formulir refleksi diri, dan melakukan analisis dokumen yang

digunakan sebagai metode pengumpulan data.

Hasil temuan dari penelitian ini menunjukkan bahwa subyek adalah guru

Bahasa Inggris profesional, hal ini dilihat dari kompetensi pedagogik dan

profesional yang mereka miliki. Dari kompetensi profesional, ditemukan bahwa

subyek mendapatkan sertifikat pendidikan bidang studi mereka, mendapat

penghargaan pendidikan, bergabung dengan asosiasi profesional yang disediakan

oleh pemerintah atau sekolah, dan mereka selalu mencari peluang untuk

meningkatkan potensi mereka. Dari kompetensi pedagogik, ditemukan bahwa

subjek tahu dengan baik tentang kurikulum, bagaimana memotivasi siswa, dan

memiliki hubungan yang baik dengan kolega dan siswa.

Dapat disimpulkan bahwa subjek memenuhi kompetensi yang dibutuhkan

untuk menjadi guru profesional Bahasa Inggris. Satu hal yang menonjol dari hasil

penelitian ini bahwa apa pun kondisi dan di mana mereka mengajar, para guru

profesional memiliki satu kesamaan: mereka profesional dalam arti sebenarnya.

Peneliti menyarankan bahwa untuk guru Bahasa Inggris dan guru Bahasa Inggris

di masa depan, mata pelajaran dapat digunakan sebagai contoh ideal bagaimana

menjadi guru Bahasa Inggris profesional. Untuk peneliti masa depan yang ingin

melakukan penelitian serupa, penelitian ini juga dapat digunakan sebagai

referensi, namun peneliti berharap bahwa parameter yang digunakan akan

didasarkan pada teori terbaru dari guru Bahasa Inggris profesional.

Malang, August 3rd, 2020

The Researcher,

Nisaul Qomariyah

Advisor I,

Dr. Alfan Zuhairi, M.Pd.

NPP. 1920200011

Advisor II,

Dr. Imam Wahyudi Karimullah, S.S., MA.

NPP. 130301198632110

Acknowledged by,

On Behalf of Dean,

1st Assistance of Dean,

Dr. Sri Wahyuni,M.Pd.

NPP. 196808231993032003

UNIVERSITAS ISLAM MALANG

FAKULTAS KEGURUAN DAN ILMU PENDIDIKAN Jl. Mayjen Haryono 193 Malang, Telp. 0341-571950

Nama : Nisaul Qomariyah

NPM : 21601073066

Jurusan/Program Studi : Pendidikan Bahasa Inggris

Judul Skripsi : A Portrait of Professional EFL Teachers at Senior

High School

ABSTRACT

Keywords: EFL Teachers, Teacher’s Competencies, Professional Teachers

This research presents the portrait of professional EFL teachers at senior

high school. As a country in which English stands as foreign language, the need of

professional EFL teacher plays an important role. Therefore, the researcher then

conducted a research with the goal to give a detail description on how the portrait

of professional EFL teacher is by using two main competences that is Pedagogical

Competence and Professional Competence.

This research used a descriptive qualitative approach with a case study as

the research design. The subjects are an English teacher at one of senior high

school and an English teacher at Islamic senior high school in Malang. The

subjects are chosen based on the consideration that both of subjects had their own

way to achieve their professionalism in teaching English. To prove as well as

investigate the professionalism of the research subject, the researcher implement

the online-based research, those are; online interview, spreading the self-reflection

form, and did a document analysis were employed as the methods of collecting

data.

The findings showed that the subjects are professional EFL teacher, it is

seen by the pedagogical and professional competence they have. From the

professional competence, it was found that the subjects got their educational

certificate of field of study, got the educational award, joining the professional

association that provides by the government or the school, and they always seek

opportunities to increase their potentials. From the pedagogical competence, it

was found that the subjects knew well about the curriculum, how to motivate the

students, and having good relationship with the colleague and students.

It can be concluded that the subjects met the competencies required to be

professional EFL teacher. One thing stands out from the results of this research

that whatever the condition and where they teach, the professional teachers have

one thing in common: they are professional in the real sense of word. The

researcher suggests that for the EFL teacher and future EFL teacher, the subjects

can be used as an ideal example of how to be a professional EFL teacher. For the

future researcher who wishes to conduct similar research, this study could also be

used as a reference, yet the researcher expected that the parameters used would be

based on the latest theory of professional EFL teacher.

Malang, August 3rd, 2020

The Researcher,

Nisaul Qomariyah

Advisor I,

Dr. Alfan Zuhairi, M.Pd.

NPP. 1920200011

Advisor II,

Dr. Imam Wahyudi Karimullah, S.S., MA.

NPP. 130301198632110

Acknowledged by,

On Behalf of Dean,

1st Assistance of Dean,

Dr. Sri Wahyuni,M.Pd.

NPP. 196808231993032003

CHAPTER I

INTRODUCTION

In this chapter, the researcher presents some points related to this study.

Those include the background of the study, formulation of the research problem,

objective of the study, the significance of the study, scope and limitation of the

study, and definition of the key term.

1.1 Background of the Study

Teaching is basically an attempt to create conditions or environmental

systems that support and allow for the learning process to take place. Teaching in

principle means to guide the students during the teaching and learning process. It

implies that teaching is an attempt to organize the learning environment which

later can enable the students to absorb and gain the material being discussed. This

understanding implies that teachers are required to be able to act as organizers of

students during their learning activities and should also be able to utilize the

environment, both in the classroom and outside the classroom, which can support

the teaching and learning activities. Harmer (2007) points out:

One of the most important tasks that teachers have to perform

is organizing students to do various activities. This often

involves giving the students information, telling them how

they are going to do the activity, putting them into pairs of

groups, and finally closing things down when it is time to stop.

(p.111)

It means that, without the existence of the teacher, it is almost impossible

for the students to learn by themselves during their learning process.

An English teacher is not possible if he or she has to do the teaching

without guidance. Teachers’ readiness and ability are indeed considered

important, but without guidance, the teacher cannot teach optimally. According to

Horn (2019), there are six principles for exemplary English teaching, those are:

knowing the learners, creating conditions for language learning, designing high-

quality lessons for language development, adapting lesson delivery as needed,

monitoring and assessing student language development, engaging and

collaborating within a community of practice. The six principles are the core set

of principles for exemplary teaching and learning of English as a new language.

Thus, these six basic principles can be adapted during his or her English teaching

as the guidelines for an EFL instructor.

Besides the teachers’ guidance, teachers also have to know about four

teachers’ competencies, those are pedagogical competence, professional

competence, personality competence, and social competence. Those parameters

are clearly stated in Undang-Undang Nomor 14 Tahun 2005 tentang Guru dan

Dosen or Act on Teachers and Lecturers Number 14 Year 2005. All aspects

mentioned above are important as the main benchmark as a professional English

teacher, because teachers can fulfill their duties with the best performance in the

teaching and learning process by promoting aspects of competence.

Some experts and researchers have tried to define the meaning of being a

professional English teacher as a starting point to meet the needs of professional

English teachers. Asmaradhani (2017, p. 2) defined that a professional teacher

indeed possesses a deep interest in knowledge, especially the knowledge he or she

teaches. This deep interest keeps a teacher constantly updated on the progress in

his or her field in some way. Therefore, this kind of teacher will never feel any

doubt about incorporating the newest development of technology into the lesson

he or she teaches. In this way, the professional teacher always up-dated and

presents a high quality of the teaching-learning process.

Defining the meaning of a good English language teacher is not enough.

Some experts also try to further give characteristics of a good and professional

English teacher by synthesizing several researchers’ findings. Brown (2007, p.

430) listed the characteristics of a good language teacher after doing a synthesis of

a successful language teacher. Those characteristics of a good English teacher can

be seen from several aspects namely technical knowledge, pedagogical skills,

interpersonal skills, and personal qualities. Each from those aspects has several

points on how to be a good English foreign language teacher. Asmaradhani (2017,

p. 2) revealed that as someone who really masters the field, a professional teacher

always uses his or her time continuously in obtaining new things in the field. He

or she presents the materials enthusiastically and stimulates the eagerness to the

students. This will finally make the students learn independently.

Another opinion of how to be a professional teacher, there are some

significant levels of teaching English in the terms of professionalism, those are;

teaching English in elementary school, secondary school, and vocational high

school. Some researchers tried to give detailed information about those four

different levels. Sepyanda (2017, p. 206) to be a professional English teacher at

elementary school is easy and challenging at the same time. Even though teaching

elementary level is easy, the teacher also feel the challenge to teach the students

because teaching Bahasa Indonesia is seen more important as their first language

rather than English, but, on the contrary, teaching English in elementary school is

the right level to start introducing English as a foreign language because they are

still in the golden age, so that is why the role of teachers’ professionalism is

needed.

Teaching English at secondary school also gives a different perspective.

Students at the secondary level are they who still in the transition period from

elementary school, in which the role of the English teacher is more extra in

conveying the material. According to Behroozi and Amoozegar (2013, p. 204)

students and learners see learning English as a challenging subject that students

rely on to the teacher’s authority and a classroom is a place that used to answer

teacher’s questions and spoken during English class.

Another level of teaching English is also coming up from vocational high

schools that English is used for specific purposes suit with each offering. Mustofa

(2011, derived from Google scholar) says that “EFL teachers at vocational high

schools use various strategies to master their subject-matter relevant to the

students’ study program and keep updated on the current development of their

profession.” The basic aim in question is to use English as the lingua franca

according to the majors taught. Therefore, in this case, English used in vocational

high school is considered as a specific purpose.

Skilled English teacher words can also be linked to the successful English

language teacher. Dincer, Goksu, Takkac, and Yazici (2013, p. 3-5) in the meta-

analysis of studies in the area of foreign language education four main

characteristics of an effective English language teacher; those are socio-affective

skills, pedagogical knowledge, subject matter knowledge, and personal qualities.

From the meta-analysis, a teacher can be called an effective English language

teacher if the teacher can accomplish those four main characteristics.

A research on finding parameters of a professional teacher had been

conducted by Anugerahwati (2009) found that the subjects in three of four towns

have all the four competencies (subject matter, pedagogical, social and personal

competences), with the personal competence being the most influential in shaping

them as professional and exemplary teachers. A profile of the professional

qualifications of the exemplary English teachers at secondary schools is

developed from the findings.

It is in line with the Undang-Undang Nomor 14 Tahun 2005 tentang Guru

dan Dosen or the Teachers and Lecturers Act No. 14 Year 2005, certain criteria

exist that considered as the main benchmark as a professional English teacher,

those are; pedagogical competence, professional competence, social competence,

and personality competence. Thus, teachers can carry out their duties with the best

performance in the teaching and learning process by promoting aspects of

competency.

Those findings of characteristics of a professional EFL teacher based on

Dincer, Goksu, Takkac, and Yazici (2013), Anugerahwati (2009), and also from

the parameters of Undang-Undang Nomor 14 Tahun 2005 tentang Guru dan

Dosen are similar in each competence. In brief, Anugerahwati (2009) mentioned

that the characteristics of a professional EFL teacher consist of four main

domains, those are; subject matter, pedagogical, social, and personal competence.

It is in line with the findings from Dincer et al. (2013) and also from the

parameters that they are liaising with each other.

Based on the parameters which have been stated in Undang-Undang

Nomor 14 Tahun 2005 tentang Guru dan Dosen and also from the qualification of

professional EFL teacher proposed by Anugerahwati (2009) and Dincer et al.

(2013), one of English teachers at SMA Negeri 7 Malang, East Java, is seen as a

professional EFL teacher and an English teacher at MA Al-Ittihad Malang who

also seen as a professional EFL teacher. That is why the researcher wants to

investigate both of teachers and find the difference among the teachers. In short,

the terms of those parameters of a professional EFL teacher which is used in this

study namely teacher pedagogical competence and professional competence.

In an attempt to know how a portrait of professional English foreign

language teacher as both teachers are, the researcher interested to conduct a

research entitled “A Portrait of Professional EFL Teachers at Senior High School”

which provides detailed information specifically about pedagogical and

professional competence, meanwhile some previous studies were mentioned four

aspects of a professional EFL teacher in the Indonesian context. The differences

of this research and several previous studies also seen by the population of the

subjects, while in this study the researcher broaden the scope of the subject than

what Yulianto, 2016 had.

Another difference is seen from the number of teachers’ competencies that

all the previous studies discussed four; pedagogical, social, interpersonal, and

professional competence, yet in this research, the researcher only provides two

aspects of pedagogical and professional competence and gives its detailed

information of both aspects.

1.2 Research Problem

Based on the background of the study above, the researcher formulates the

problem as follows;

1) What competencies do the two English teachers possess?

This question can be further elaborated into:

a) What pedagogical competencies do they have?

b) What professional competencies do they have?

2) How do the two English teachers achieve those competencies?

This question can be further elaborated into:

a) How do they achieve their pedagogical competencies?

b) How do they achieve their professional competencies?

1.3 Objectives of the Study

Based on the background of the study and the research problem above, the

objective of the study can be formulated as follows:

To know the detail description of a portrait of professional EFL teacher at

SMA Negeri 7 Malang and MA Al-Ittihad Malang, such as:

1) The competencies of a professional EFL teacher in senior high schools in

Malang, which are further elaborated into the pedagogical and professional

competencies,

2) How the professional EFL teacher achieves those competencies.

1.4 The Significance of the Study

It is expected that after reading this research the reader will get detailed

information on how to be a professional EFL teacher. It is also expected that this

research can be used as a reference.

a. For EFL teacher and non-English teachers

It is expected that after reading the result of this study, a self-reflection

can be done in order to become a better and more professional English

teacher. While for teachers teaching other than English, it is expected that the

result of this study can be used as a reference on how to be a good and ideal

teacher.

b. For the theoretical contribution

With regard to theoretical contributions, it is expected that the results of

this study can provide theories of teacher competences of professional EFL

teacher portraits through pedagogical and professional competence, especially

in Indonesian context, as it is quite difficult to find clear and detailed

description of it.

1.5 Scope and Limitation of the Study

● Locative scope: the teachers are located at SMA Negeri 7 and MA Al-

Ittihad Malang.

● Human scope: the subjects of this study are the EFL teachers at SMA

Negeri 7 and MA Al-Ittihad Malang.

● Limitation of this study: due to Corona Virus (Covid-19) break, the

researcher difficult to collect the data directly in the field, which during

this long-break the researcher should conduct the research at school. The

researcher only did the online-based consultation with the supervisor and

the researcher had conducted an online-based observation by having

WhatsApp video call with the subjects in purpose of doing interview,

asking the subjects to fulfill self-assessment and angket guru from Google

Form, and asking the subject’s supporting documents. That is why the

researcher chose these options due to the unstable condition.

1.6 Definition of Key Terms

The definition of key terms is provided to avoid misunderstanding and

ambiguity. There are some terms used in this study which need to be defined.

1. EFL (English as a Foreign Language) teacher is a teacher who teaches

English to students in a country where English is not the native language.

2. Pedagogy is one of teachers’ competencies that define teachers’ ability in

managing the classroom activity and it is related to the ability of teachers to

understand the learning process.

3. Professional is an aspect which someone is able to put themselves in a certain

field. In this context, the professional being concerned is a professional in the

education that teachers are expected to be qualified in terms of teaching.

CHAPTER V

CONCLUSION AND SUGGESTION

This chapter consists of conclusion and suggestions. In conclusion, the

researcher gives brief conclusion related to the findings and discussion from the

previous chapter. Further, the researcher gives suggestions related to this study for

the future researchers.

5.1 Conclusion

Based on the findings and discussions from the previous chapter, it can be

concluded that both of subjects had already fulfilled two parameters of

professional EFL teacher. The two competences outlined by Undang-Undang

Nomor 14 Tahun 2005 Guru dan Dosen and its elaborations are appropriate to be

used as the criteria for determining the quality of teachers. Those four

competences that mentioned by Undang-Undang Nomor 14 Tahun 2005 Guru

dan Dosen, if all are fulfilled, would lead a teacher to be fully professional, yet in

this study, the researcher investigates two competences only. But, it does not

mean, by investigating the two competences are not give a contribution to lead the

teacher to be professional. In fact, from the findings, the subjects are professional

according to their respective versions.

One thing stands out from the results of this research that whatever the

condition of where they live and teach, the professional teachers have one thing in

common: they are professional in the real sense of the word. They have very good

mastery of English. They have the skills and mastery of the appropriate teaching

techniques to be used. Furthermore, they implement well-planned lessons, use

various media, and can make a classroom activity interesting for the students.

They have good relationships with their principals and colleagues and are

generally well-liked and well-respected because of their exemplary good conduct,

work ethics, commitment and their personality in general.

The professional teachers achieved their competences through their

participation in various workshops and trainings, not only in the field of English

teaching, but also in assessment, Classroom Action Research, and others.

Moreover, these professional teachers are not people who get satisfied easily; they

keep updating their knowledge and mastery of new ways of teaching, and of the

English language in general.

In short, either subject A or subject B, they are all professional according

to the standard of Undang-Undang Nomor 14 Tahun 2005 Guru dan Dosen, even

though the researcher only investigate two competences; pedagogical and

professional competence. The researcher really sure that even though the social

and personality competence are not tested, both of subject have a good social and

personality; it is proved from the findings that both of subjects have a good

relationships with the students and colleagues. It can be seen that both of subjects

also master the social and personality competence.

5.2 Suggestions

There are several suggestions related to the result of this study. The first is

for the teacher and the future researcher who had read this study, can learn the

way the subject in becoming a professional EFL teacher. The professionalism can

be started by having a good personal competence that can lead to the good social

competence and good pedagogical competence will lead to great professionalism.

This research employed several parameters of professional EFL teacher

from Undang-Undang Nomor 14 Tahun 2005 Guru dan Dosen, Anugerahwati

(2009), and Dincer et al. (2013). The researcher really suggests that the next

research on finding the portrait of professional EFL teacher will use the newest

parameters found by other researcher other than those who have mentioned above.

It is expected that the next researcher will renew their references or parameters

that used in this research, in order to there will be a difference and new update

rather than this research. The researcher also suggests that the next researcher will

not only focus on the professional parameters, but also on the characteristics of an

ideal EFL teacher as an addition in order to make the result of the next study

richer than this research.

In term of selecting the subject, the research suggests that the next

researcher will select more than two professional EFL teachers from different

region across Indonesia in order to enrich information of being a professional EFL

teacher. As this research did not conduct either observation or interview directly

on the spot, it is suggested also that the next researcher will conduct a direct

research, since the result of the direct research and online-based research are

really different. It will be easy to write the findings if the researcher can conduct

the direct research, since he or she can remember when observation takes place,

and it is more authentic rather than online-based research.

REFERENCES

Akcan, S., Aydin, B., Seferoglu, A. Cendel Karaman Golge, Korkmazgil, S., &

Selvi, Alev Ozbilgin Ali Fuad. (2016). Qualities and Qualifications of EFL

Professionals: What Do Intensive English Program Administrators Think?

TESOL Journal , 5.

Amin, M. (2014). What Makes Teachers of EFL Professional or Unprofessional.

Jurnal Pendidikan Humaniora , 295.

Anugerahwati, M. (2009). Professional Competence for Teachers of English in

Indonesia: a Profile of an Exemplary Teacher. Malang: State University

of Malang.

Anugerahwati, Mirjam & Ali Saukah. (2010). Professional Competence of

English Teachers in Indonesia: A Profile of Exemplary Teachers.

Indonesian Journal of English Language Teaching Volume 6, 107-119.

Asmaradhani, A. I. (2017). Some Criteria of Professional Teacher. Mataram:

IKIP Mataram, the Department of English Education.

Behroozi, M. & Amoozegar, A. (2014). Challenges to English Language Teachers

of Secondary Schools in Iran. Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences ,

204.

Brown, H. D. (2007). Teaching by Principles - an Interactive Approach to

Language Pedagogy. New York: San Fransisco State University.

Das, S. & Nalinilatha. (2017). A Study on Teaching Competency of Secondary

School Teachers. International Journal of Research - Granthaalayah ,

508.

Departemen Pendidikan Nasional. (2005). Undang-Undang no 14 tahun 2005

tentang Guru dan Dosen. Jakarta. Depdiknas.

Departemen Pendidikan Nasional. (2008). Peraturan Pemerintah no. 74 Tahun

2008 tentang Guru. Jakarta: Depdiknas.

Dincer, Ali., Goksu, Ali., Takkac, Aysegul., & Yazici, Mine. (2013). Common

Characteristics of an Effective English Language Teacher. The

International Journal of Educational Researchers 4(3), 3-5.

Hakim, A. (2015). Contribution of Competence Teacher (Pedagogical,

Personality, Professional Competence and Social) on the Performance of

Learning. The International Journal of Engineering and Science (IJES) ,

1.

Harmer, J. (2007). The Practice of English Language Teaching. Harlow: Pearson

Education Limited.

Hidayati, T. (2016). English Language Teaching in Islamic Education in

Indonesia: Challenges and Opportunities. Nagroe Aceh Darussalam:

STAIN Teungku Dirundeng Meulaboh.

Horn, B. (2019). Six Principles for Exemplary Teaching of English Learners.

United States of America: TESOL International Association.

Kementrian Agama. Peratutan Menteri Agama Republik Indonesia Nomor 16

Tahun 2010. Indonesia.

Khaeruniah, A. E. (2013). A Teacher Personality Competence Contribution to a

Student Study Motivation and Discipline to Fiqh Lesson. International

Journal of Scientific & Technology Research , 3.

Mustofa, M. (2011). Professional Development of EFL Teachers at Vocational

Schools. Malang: Karya Ilmiah UM.

Nabila, H. (2016). The Influence of Pedagogic Competence and Professional

Competence to Performance of Teachers Social Studies in Trowulan

District. International Conference on Ethics of Business, Economics, and

Social Science , 556.

Nessipbayeva, O. (2012). The Competencies of the Modern Teacher. Pre-Service

and In-Service Teacher Training , 149.

Sepyanda, M. (2017). The Importance of English Subject in Elementary

Curriculum. English Langauge Teaching and Research, (p. 206). Solok.

Thomas, G. (2013). How To Do Your Research Project. London: Library of

Congress Control.

Undang-Undang Republik Indonesia Nomor 20. Indonesia Republic Law Number

20. (2003)

Undang-Undang Republik Indonesia Nomor 14 Tahun 2005 tentang Guru dan

Dosen. (2005).

Yasemin Gulbahar, Filiz Kalelioglu. (2015). Competencies for e-Instructors: How

to Qualify and Guarantee Sustainability. Contemporary Educational

Technology , 141.

Yulianto, H. (2016). A Portrait of Professional EFL Teacher. Malang: University

of Brawijaya.