A Great Year for Balanced Portfolios

8/11/2019 A Great Year for Balanced Portfolios

1/6

2013 was an incredible year for the stock markets around the globe (well most markets). The S&P 500 hadone of its best years in many decades moving up some 32% when we factor in dividends. The developedinternational markets ( EFA) increased by over 21%. My home market of Canada ( EWC ) was up about 10%though U.S. investors would have taken a currency hit bringing down that Canuck return to the area of 5%.Canadian investors invested in U.S markets saw a currency premium.

Given that, investors who were "all in" with pure stock portfolios were likely treated to incredible portfoliosaving (decade saving) returns in 2013. And U.S. investors who had a home bias were "rewarded" for thatlack of diversification. Of course U.S. investors were punished in the period of 2000-2009 if they were

Seeking AlphaSeeking Alpha Portfolio App for iPadFinance(1)

Home |Portfolio |Breaking News |Investing Ideas |Dividends & Income |ETFs |Macro View |ALERTS |PROSign in / Join Now

4,146 people decided to get AGG articles by email alertWhich cover: new articles | breaking news | earnings results | dividend announcementsGet email alerts on AGG

CrankyLong-term horizon

Send Message| Follow (1,000)

A Great Year For Balanced PortfoliosJan. 28, 2014 7:22 AM ET | by: Cranky 1 comment | Includes: AGG, CVY, EFA, EWC , HYG, SPY, VYM

Disclosure: I am long SPY, EFA, DIA, EWC, . Dale Roberts aka cranky is a Streetwise Coach at ING DirectMutual Funds. The Streetwise Portfolios offer index-based complete portfolios to Canadians. Dalescommentary does not constitute investment advice. The opinions and information should only be factoredinto an investor's overall opinion forming process. (More...)

at Year For Balanced Portfolios [SPDR S&P 500 ETF Trust, iShare... http://seekingalpha.com/article/1971951-a-great-year-for-balanced-portfo...

1/28/2014 11


2/6

sticking close to home with their portfolios.

And it was a fantastic year for the Balanced Portfolios. A Balanced Portfolio will essentially give up somelong term total return in return for much lower volatility of the broader markets. There are two main reasonsto hold a Balanced Portfolio (that is a mix of stocks and bonds and perhaps cash and other asset classes). Oneof course as mentioned is to lower portfolio volatility due to the basic fact that the investor cannot handle thewild swings of the broader stock markets. Another reason is time horizon. If an investor is in the drawdown

phase (harvesting their investments for spending) they need a certain amount of price protection to lessen the

need to sell assets to fund that retirement. While markets will beat inflation over most periods we all know it'snot a straight line up. In years where the market offers a severe correction, an investor in the drawdown phasewould have to sell more assets. Protecting the overall value of your portfolio protects the drawdown factor.

With the equity markets delivered unusual returns, that translated into incredible returns for the BalancedPortfolio. A typical balanced portfolio of 60% stocks and 40% bonds would have delivered a return of 18% in2013. A very simple portfolio mix could use ( SPY) for equities and the broad based bond ETF ( AGG). Of course those are dreamy returns for an investor who is managing risk. And that comes in a year when the

bond markets (AGG in this case) delivered a negative return of -2%. As I wrote early in 2013 in this article -"Asset Allocation is Alive and Well". The balanced portfolio never goes out of style and we should never look at stocks and bonds in isolation. 2013 was a great year for the Balanced Portfolio in a year where we did see

bond prices take a sizeable hit. Yields on 20-year plus Treasuries spiked in early summer. Was that a headfake, or a warning shot? No worries on either count for the investors in balanced portfolios. Once again, theincredible dynamic between stocks and bonds did their magic. That is likely to continue.

The traditional Balanced Income portfolio that I suggested in this article , The Ultimate Income Portfolio, alsohad a great year. The Income Portfolio consists of Vanguard's High Dividend ETF ( VYM ) at 50% withGuggenheim's Multi-Asset class ETF ( CVY) at 35% and the high yield bond ETF ( HYG) at 15%. That

portfolio would offer a very generous current yield in the area of 4.3% and it delivered a total return of 22.6%in 2013.

Not only that, even the most conservative of Balanced Portfolios could have seen some very decent returns in

2013. Here are those historical returns to end of 2013.(click to enlarge)

We can see that the Balanced Income Portfolio (with 70% bonds and 10% each of U.S., International andCanadian equity markets) earned over 6% in 2013. The traditional balanced portfolio with 60% equities and40% bonds had a blowout year with a 14.7% return. And the Balanced Growth Portfolio (25% bonds)delivered over 19%.

Full disclosure, my new monies for registered retirement and tax free accounts are going into the Balanced


1/28/2014 11


3/6

Portfolio. Could I mimic the Balanced Portfolio with ETFs and keep my fees even lower? Yes. Do I have thediscipline to follow the formula and rebalance on a quarter basis without thinking? No. I will pay a little extrafor that forced discipline. Also I do get some free monies from ING Direct with a matched employer contribution retirement plan. Financial Planning 101 says we should always take the free monies.

Here are the recent historical returns for one of our RSP (registered retirement accounts). They show incomeand total return growth.

In 2013 my very conservative Balanced Portfolios delivered in the area of 9-12%. Much better than the previous year.

Those numbers are impressive considering that the bond markets had an off year, and the Canadian marketsare still underperforming the U.S. and International markets. Once again that is the magic of diversification.While major stocks markets will usually fall together in a correction, certain markets and regions canoutperform in the bull scenario. 2013 was a perfect example of when investors can profit from InternationalDiversification. I would then suggest that U.S. investors add in some international diversification by the wayof EAFE and perhaps a sprinkling of individual countries such as Canada.

In my own self-directed Balanced Portfolios I practice the Cranky Maneuver where I take all of the incomefrom various ETFs and direct that income to the rising income stream of my Canadian Dividend ETFs andVanguard's VYM. In 2013 I also made attempts to fix my Canadian home bias - I'll admit to being scared off of the U.S. markets in 2009 or earlier. Sorry, I wasn't sure that you'd make it. And I'm not even sure that youapplied the right medicine, but what choice does an investor have but to invest in the great companies in theworld's largest economy? So in 2013 I did a rebalancing of sorts to add more U.S. exposure in those self directed accounts. I was also way too defensive with overexposure to bonds that would limit potential for modest total return. Those accounts are still quite defensive with just over 50% in equities and the rest in

bond ETFs.

The rebalancing to add more equity exposure allowed me to generate some modest gains, though the additionof U.S. indexes and dividend ETFs eliminated my income growth for the year. My Canadian stock ETFs offer a much higher yield. I have created a portfolio with an incredibly low beta, but at times it can have incrediblylow returns. I learned that one can certainly be too conservative if they want to participate even modestly inthe stock market gains. I am still too conservative of course, I will gradually move my asset mix to that sweetspot of 60-40 by directing income to equities. But to tell you the truth I have been waiting for that equitymarket correction that simply has not yet arrived to make a significant rebalancing. Note to self: Never try totime the market even in modest way. If we investors have a mistake to fix, we should fix it now instead of waiting for an "opportunity".

It was a great year for the Balanced Portfolio. I can't guarantee or predict that 2014 will be just as fruitful, butwe do know that over longer periods investors in Balanced Portfolios have been rewarded with very generousinflation beating returns. That is likely to continue. The reason to hold bonds and create Balanced Portfoliosnever changes for those investors who want or need to manage risk or require portfolio price protection.

As always and perhaps more than ever - asset allocation is alive and well.


1/28/2014 11


4/6

4,146 people decided to get AGG articles by email alertGet email alerts on AGG Share this article with a colleagueTweet

More articles by Cranky

In The Recent Pullback, Long-Term Treasuries Do Their Thing Sat, Jan 25Small Caps Will Outperform If You Give 'Em Time Sun, Jan 19Skip The Dividends If You're Young And Brave Wed, Dec 18The Best Market Correction Insurance Mon, Dec 16Separating The Yield From The Chaff With Vanguard's VIG Sat, Dec 14

Comments (1)

Register or Login to rate comments

The Part-time Investor , contributor Comments (1016) Cranky,Thanks for the article.

"If an investor is in the drawdown phase (harvesting their investments for spending) they need a certainamount of price protection to lessen the need to sell assets to fund that retirement. "Or they could have a DGI portfolio and just harvest the dividends. Then they wouldn't have to worry atall about what kind of volatility there is in the market because they wouldn't need to sell any their

principle.28 Jan, 09:29 AMReplyLike1

GuestAdd Your Comment:

PublishLoading...Symbols:Authors:

About this articleEmailed to: 160,711 people who get ETFs & Portfolio Strategy daily.Author payment: $0.01 per page view. Authors of Top Ideas on small- and mid-cap stocks receive aminimum guaranteed payment of $150-500.Become a contributor Tagged: ETFs & Portfolio Strategy , Portfolio Strategy & Asset AllocationProblem with this article? Please tell us. Disagree with this article? Submit your own .


1/28/2014 11


5/6

Top Ideas

SWS Group Buyout Offers A 'Hill-A-Cious' Return by Whopper Investments1.JGWPT Holdings Has Massive Potential by Ashleigh Rogers2.Amidst Huge Unknowns, Conatus Pharmaceuticals Worth A Closer Look by Stephen Simpson, CFA3.Pro-Dex: Potential Insider Buys Suggest Dramatic Stock Rise by Valuable Insights4.

Dividends & Income

Get Skeptical About This MLP Claim by Factoids1.Dividend Growth Investing: Myths 16-20 by David Van Knapp2.How The Focus Of Dividends Impacts Returns by Larry Swedroe3.Johnson & Johnson Is A Dividend Growth Giant by Valuentum4.2014 Dividend Growth Holdings For The Retired Investor, A Core And Satellite Approach by BobJohnson

5.

ETFs & Portfolio Strategy

The Devil Is In The Details Of Solar Securitization by Troy Jensen1.Replicating Yale's Endowment Portfolio With Accessible Instruments by Alexander Valtsev2.Last Week's Selloff Isn't A Big Deal -- Yet by Vahan Janjigian3.Top Performing Asset Allocation Portfolios Based On Maximum Drawdown by VizMetrics4.

After Last Week's Sell-Off, More Volatility Ahead by Russ Koesterich5.

Macro View

International Tower Hill Mines: Not As Cheap As It Seems by Hebba Investments1.Bakken Update's 2014 Stock Picks: The Permian Operators by Michael Filloon2.An Emerging Global 'Perfect Storm?' 4 Key Trends To Watch by Jack Rasmus3.Was The Sell-Off The Start Of Something Bigger? Here's The Evidence by Cliff Wachtel4.Gold Has Found Its Bottom, Is $2000 Possible This Year? by Dave Kranzler 5.

SURVEYWhat mobile device do you use to watch your stocks?

iPhone iPad Android Blackberry None

TOP AUTHORS: The Opinion LeadersTOP USERS: StockTalkers | InstablogsFollow usFollow us


1/28/2014 11


6/6

Documents

A Great Year for Balanced Portfolios