26
A Feature-Integration Theory of Attention A. Treisman and G. Gelade (1980) Friday, May 10, 13

A Feature-Integration Theory of Attentionmiriah/uncertainty/FeatureIntegrationTheoryOf... · bottom-up overt top-down covert focused sustained attentionalternating Friday, May 10,

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: A Feature-Integration Theory of Attentionmiriah/uncertainty/FeatureIntegrationTheoryOf... · bottom-up overt top-down covert focused sustained attentionalternating Friday, May 10,

A Feature-Integration Theory of Attention

A. Treisman and G. Gelade (1980)

Friday, May 10, 13

Page 2: A Feature-Integration Theory of Attentionmiriah/uncertainty/FeatureIntegrationTheoryOf... · bottom-up overt top-down covert focused sustained attentionalternating Friday, May 10,

selective divide

d

bottom

-up

top-downover

t

covert

focu

sed

sustained

alternating

attention

Friday, May 10, 13

Page 3: A Feature-Integration Theory of Attentionmiriah/uncertainty/FeatureIntegrationTheoryOf... · bottom-up overt top-down covert focused sustained attentionalternating Friday, May 10,

selective divide

d

bottom

-up

top-downover

t

covert

focu

sed

sustained

alternating

attention

Friday, May 10, 13

Page 4: A Feature-Integration Theory of Attentionmiriah/uncertainty/FeatureIntegrationTheoryOf... · bottom-up overt top-down covert focused sustained attentionalternating Friday, May 10,

Feature Integration Theory

objects perception

separable perception of features (e.g. color, shape,

orientation etc.)

combine / link features in

objects

pre-attentive focused attention

Friday, May 10, 13

Page 5: A Feature-Integration Theory of Attentionmiriah/uncertainty/FeatureIntegrationTheoryOf... · bottom-up overt top-down covert focused sustained attentionalternating Friday, May 10,

Feature Integration Theorysupport

9 experiments testing predictions based on the theory

Visual SearchTexture SegregationIllusory ConjunctionsIdentity and LocationInterference from Unattended Stimuli

5 Areas

Friday, May 10, 13

Page 6: A Feature-Integration Theory of Attentionmiriah/uncertainty/FeatureIntegrationTheoryOf... · bottom-up overt top-down covert focused sustained attentionalternating Friday, May 10,

Feature Integration Theory

objects perception

separable perception of features (e.g. color, shape,

orientation etc.)

combine / link features in

objects

pre-attentive focused attention

Friday, May 10, 13

Page 7: A Feature-Integration Theory of Attentionmiriah/uncertainty/FeatureIntegrationTheoryOf... · bottom-up overt top-down covert focused sustained attentionalternating Friday, May 10,

Feature Integration Theory

single features can be detected in

parallel without attention limits

conjunctions require focal attention of

each object, resulting in serial search

pre-attentive focused attention

Friday, May 10, 13

Page 8: A Feature-Integration Theory of Attentionmiriah/uncertainty/FeatureIntegrationTheoryOf... · bottom-up overt top-down covert focused sustained attentionalternating Friday, May 10,

find the S or blue

Visual Searchfeature

Friday, May 10, 13

Page 9: A Feature-Integration Theory of Attentionmiriah/uncertainty/FeatureIntegrationTheoryOf... · bottom-up overt top-down covert focused sustained attentionalternating Friday, May 10,

Visual Search

S XTT

T

T

TTT

TT

T

T

TT

XXX

X

X

XX

X

X

XX

X

X

feature

Friday, May 10, 13

Page 10: A Feature-Integration Theory of Attentionmiriah/uncertainty/FeatureIntegrationTheoryOf... · bottom-up overt top-down covert focused sustained attentionalternating Friday, May 10,

find the S or blue

Visual Searchfeature

Friday, May 10, 13

Page 11: A Feature-Integration Theory of Attentionmiriah/uncertainty/FeatureIntegrationTheoryOf... · bottom-up overt top-down covert focused sustained attentionalternating Friday, May 10,

Visual Search

TXT

TT

T

TT

T

T

T

T T

TT

X

XXX

X

XX

XX

X

XX X

feature

Friday, May 10, 13

Page 12: A Feature-Integration Theory of Attentionmiriah/uncertainty/FeatureIntegrationTheoryOf... · bottom-up overt top-down covert focused sustained attentionalternating Friday, May 10,

find the T

Visual Searchconjunction

Friday, May 10, 13

Page 13: A Feature-Integration Theory of Attentionmiriah/uncertainty/FeatureIntegrationTheoryOf... · bottom-up overt top-down covert focused sustained attentionalternating Friday, May 10,

Visual Search

T XTT

T

T

TTT

TT

T

T

TT

XXX

X

X

XX

X

X

XX

X

X

conjunction

Friday, May 10, 13

Page 14: A Feature-Integration Theory of Attentionmiriah/uncertainty/FeatureIntegrationTheoryOf... · bottom-up overt top-down covert focused sustained attentionalternating Friday, May 10,

Experiment 1

T XTT

T

T

TTT

TT

T

T

TT

XXX

X

X

XX

X

X

XX

X

X

T XTT

T

T

TTT

TT

T

T

TT

XXX

X

X

XX

X

X

XX

X

X

T STT

T

T

TTT

TT

T

T

TT

XXX

X

X

XX

X

X

X XX

XS XTT

T

T

TTT

TT

T

T

TT

XXX

X

X

XX

X

X

XX

X

X

T XTT

T

T

TTT

TT

T

T

TT

XXX

X

X

XX

X

X

XX

X

X

Feature

S

blue

Conjunction

Distractors: , TXTarget: “S or blue,” T

Friday, May 10, 13

Page 15: A Feature-Integration Theory of Attentionmiriah/uncertainty/FeatureIntegrationTheoryOf... · bottom-up overt top-down covert focused sustained attentionalternating Friday, May 10,

Visual Searchresults

Friday, May 10, 13

Page 16: A Feature-Integration Theory of Attentionmiriah/uncertainty/FeatureIntegrationTheoryOf... · bottom-up overt top-down covert focused sustained attentionalternating Friday, May 10,

Experiment 2

T  X  X  T  T  XX  T  T  X  X  TX  T  X  X  T  XT  X  T  X  T  TX  T  T  T  X  TX  X  T  T  X  X

O  N  N  O  O  NN  O  O  N  N  ON  O  N  N  O  NO  N  O  N  O  ON  O  O  O  N  ON  N  O  O  N  N

Condition: easyDistractors: , Target:

Condition: difficultDistractors: , Target:

O NO

X TT

Friday, May 10, 13

Page 17: A Feature-Integration Theory of Attentionmiriah/uncertainty/FeatureIntegrationTheoryOf... · bottom-up overt top-down covert focused sustained attentionalternating Friday, May 10,

Friday, May 10, 13

Page 18: A Feature-Integration Theory of Attentionmiriah/uncertainty/FeatureIntegrationTheoryOf... · bottom-up overt top-down covert focused sustained attentionalternating Friday, May 10,

Experiment 3

Distractors: , Target:

Distractors: , Target:

Distractors: , Target:

conjunction feature featureFriday, May 10, 13

Page 19: A Feature-Integration Theory of Attentionmiriah/uncertainty/FeatureIntegrationTheoryOf... · bottom-up overt top-down covert focused sustained attentionalternating Friday, May 10,

ZQ

Experiment 4

P+Q=P =Rillusory “R”

I+Z= =TIillusory “T”

Distractors: P , Q Target: R

Distractors: P , B Target: R

Distractors: P(Q,B) Target: R

( )

P

P PP

PP P

PP

P P

PP

PR

PP

PP P

P

PP PP

PP

P PP

BB

B B

BBBBB B

BB

BB

R

P

PP

P

PP

P P

PP P

P

PP

Q

QQ

QQ

QQ

QQ

QQ

QQ

Q

Q

Rillusory conjunction non-illusory conjunction single feature

Friday, May 10, 13

Page 20: A Feature-Integration Theory of Attentionmiriah/uncertainty/FeatureIntegrationTheoryOf... · bottom-up overt top-down covert focused sustained attentionalternating Friday, May 10,

Friday, May 10, 13

Page 21: A Feature-Integration Theory of Attentionmiriah/uncertainty/FeatureIntegrationTheoryOf... · bottom-up overt top-down covert focused sustained attentionalternating Friday, May 10,

Experiment 5

O V V O OV O O V VV O V V OO V O V OV O O O V

O O O O OO O O O OO O O O OV V V V VV V V V V

color shape

O V V O OV O O V VV O V V OO V O V OV O O O V

conjunction control

Task: sort by boundary (horizontal vs vertical)

Friday, May 10, 13

Page 22: A Feature-Integration Theory of Attentionmiriah/uncertainty/FeatureIntegrationTheoryOf... · bottom-up overt top-down covert focused sustained attentionalternating Friday, May 10,

Experiment 6

O V V O OV O O ∏ ∏V O V ∏ OO V O ∏ OV O O O ∏

disjunctive feature control

O V V O OV O O V VV O V V OO V O V OV O O O V

conjunction

Task: sort by boundary (horizontal vs vertical)

Friday, May 10, 13

Page 23: A Feature-Integration Theory of Attentionmiriah/uncertainty/FeatureIntegrationTheoryOf... · bottom-up overt top-down covert focused sustained attentionalternating Friday, May 10,

Experiment 7

O R R Q QR O O P PR O R P QO R O P QR O O Q P

boundary determined by non-intersecting pairs of [P, R, E, F, O, Q, X, K]

“single feature”:(PO/RQ), (EO/FQ)“conjunction”:(PQ/RO),(FK/EX)

interesting cases

Friday, May 10, 13

Page 24: A Feature-Integration Theory of Attentionmiriah/uncertainty/FeatureIntegrationTheoryOf... · bottom-up overt top-down covert focused sustained attentionalternating Friday, May 10,

Experiments 8/9

O X O O H XX X O X O O

Distractors: O , X Target: H (H , X , O)

O X O O X XX X O X O O

Distractors: O , X Target: X , O

disjunctive feature conjunction

Friday, May 10, 13

Page 25: A Feature-Integration Theory of Attentionmiriah/uncertainty/FeatureIntegrationTheoryOf... · bottom-up overt top-down covert focused sustained attentionalternating Friday, May 10,

Applications to Graphics

encoding variables that represent individual features (e.g. color, orientation, intensity, movement) are good for search tasks

unique combinations of features do not create pop-out effects in the same way as unique features

Friday, May 10, 13

Page 26: A Feature-Integration Theory of Attentionmiriah/uncertainty/FeatureIntegrationTheoryOf... · bottom-up overt top-down covert focused sustained attentionalternating Friday, May 10,

?Questions

Friday, May 10, 13