Upload
lekien
View
212
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
A Critical Assessment of Don Marquis' Anti-Abortionist Argument
Kyoto Women's University EGUCHI Saloshi
Abstract:After briefly reviewing the philosophical controversy on abortion. I will introduce Don Marquis' "fu
ture-like-ours" argument and its various critiques. Marquis insists that (J) it is seriously immoral to kill
us because killing deprives us of our valuable futures, and (2) a human fetus has a future like ours, there
fore (3) it is seriously immoral to kill a human fetus. His argument is very simple but plausible. and not
easy to rebut. Possible objections to his argument are (J) an objection from negligence of the women's
viewpoint. (2) a rududio ad absurdum objection from contraception. (3) an objection from metaethical
analysis of "loss" and "deprivation", (4) an objection from personal identity and non-similarity of a fetus
and us, and (5) a metaethical objection from relation of value and desire. I argue that objection (5),
which relies on the desire account of value. is most powerful, if we are to account for modifications and
qualifications of "desire". such that desire should be interpreted as "dispositional desire" and desires
should be "rational and well-informed". But these objections also have a significant burden of philosophi
cal justification.
~~'*'ti'Jt::. t 0bQ;g~~rD9J1!jK.0t"'(It, IEr"'.!
L'lt, ~ A 'J '/(f) r~~'*'ti'J(f)m~j (Thomson.
1971), ~? - Y-(f) r~~tpti'Jc~~l:JI'.f&Lj
(Tooley, 1972), :!O.t 0:'./ '/ ji-(f) r~~.l1(f)1tflJlillJ
(Singer, 1979, 1993) L'(f)~~iJ;3F'ffit::.1'i~L'iI;
Q. LiJ'L, IE~L'~•• t~~(iJ·~~~tpti'J~
-S-i!-jt~.nJ1;:(~~~.n-n'Qt.:.lJ:>iJ·, ~.nJ;J.~~(f)
m~~~~(*~~~tp~~~~~QU~(f)b(f)
iJ·.-t:5H::.tIllM~.n-n't.ct'.t?t::',~,b.n7.> ". *ili'i
L'ltL~L~rQW(f).*.~~~~tpti'J~j
(Strong, 2008) c ~.nQ 7-'\>.A(f) rtJ:-tf~f~tp
ti'J1;l:.'l'iElfRjtJ:(f)iJ.j (Marquis, 1989) ~m1f L t.:.J:
L', ~.nt::.~~QJlt*II~tIlINLt.:.t'.
.t ( ~fJ~.n -C t, Q .t ? t::., ~*L'11~~tp~(f)1:'9
tmft~1'flI16alill~(f)tJ:iJ'L'~ ~., c ~.t (~~~.n,
~ L t 'i'ai«'(f)~t::. tJ:" -C t, Q '7 - 7 (f)-0L'iI; Q.
~f~r.p~t::.~~Q~~lff«(f)~il1Ii(f)~( It~*~tUii
ilt!L'iI;Q. ~.n~-A\l:t::'~(f).t?tJ:Jf~~c Q.
I. AI:JI~f&~'::c 11'l'lEL';f.,7.>.
2. IJaYi'.11Ara9L';f.,Q.
3. ~.n.p*-, IJa~I'.~f&~~f~9'~I;l:.'l'lEL'iI;Q.
.t (~J~.nt.:.r,iJlWc L -C, rJJ€l~I'.I;l:.t'0iJ·~Ardl
t.c(f)tJ.j c t'? r~iJl ~1~9J.!!jj iJ;;f.,7.>. ~ «(f)~~
• 19 •
~M~••~. M~t~~~~MKlt~.~-.~
51 < .: UJ;-C'!!<t.. ~·~t:.tJ,,:;. MYclt:l'l:fi'i~~~I~}!i:
tJ' ':; AJ~~ -e i!; ;;, t ~. ? !~IJl' ~ t ;;, 0
.: ? U-: f!?:';j:.~ f.&iMli It - JI.~ t .: .c:d)· t.. 'J fJl.j.<f
tJtJ;i!;;;,t-:lb. ~fWi<~M~~l~K.J:..,-C (i!;;;'Ht..;. 1''''';,- f
c0~tJ;i!;;h.li~·-::>-e~) r.ti&:"';h.;;' t~:~T;;' y"." <t ..... { ;..
7/L--?~tR$it~~Rlt'"i ""i t..:iE~11::~;1;\;;"HTt ..
b"";;,~,z.t.. ~·o -'t~~i~~*5.lIJT;;' t. (I) I· 1>.-;
:/~J:? K.• :i<i'l~m'fIJt'Jill'C~m'fIJU:;)fffi.T;;' ~
~t;;"~L. :i<i'l~m~~.~T;;,.:t~~~LJ:
? t T;;' ~~. (2) I- ? - Y - -? 7 ... v:/ (Warren,
197:3) ii> ~ J: ? IC rV- U ~~~~5t:lfrT;;'': tiC
J:.., -C. IJill'CItrRAll c~il\!~J'J':Jj1!l{lLIH..,n·t..
~< t H~IDE L J: ? tT;;' ~~. (3);0 11-~J: ?
P;lJ'fIJ~il'iiJ'J':Jt.. j!bffl~~U!il"I~;-:!ITICJ:;;' ~ ~ (Singer,
1993) ;;;). ~.=: :f1[ilc t.. ;;, 0
1-1>.-;:/K~."';h.;;'~i'l~m5t~~~K.T;;'
m'fIJlcii!F,z. ;;'ilff1:lil~iiil:*~iltt\';\lt. v -( 7'IC J: ;;'~f
Wi<-? m~~~7EIU)'fJ'b;;,ItEWi<~J:? t.. ffiYii6t..~l
~~~l1li. m~~,l1J'~IC)tfT ;;,m'fIJtJ;'Jill'C~~E1fI;
IC)tfT ;;, m'fU J: 'J ,'i'; IC.~T;;' t ±5~T ;;, ~ Iti!ft L
~< t. it-:. IJill'Clcltm~~,l1J'1*~m~·;;, CiHfAl
J'J':J) tffi'fUtJ;i!;;;' t ~~T;;' .: t It (c}' t.. < t ~ -1l1\~V-Uct ..,-Clt) T5tfiJ{jgIC,,;!;,,b;h.;;';: t -ei!;;;'o
m~-?IJill'C~tffi'fIJf/'c~ J: "> t.. ~ ~fNtm I]fJ t~· ">
bl1-elt t.. ~· ~t:' f)' ,:;, ';f.·ICm~~m'fI]tJ".~T Q
~t:'U)'. i!;;;'Ht. IJil~lc~m~o)%i*~iil!,,>tffi
'fUIHJ:~·~t:'t jllJjj~ L -C L i ? .: t l,tiMli}A\~J&lct..
..,-CLi ?:to-'t;h.tJ;i!;;;'o Lt.:.tJ;..,-C, J:ic~J:?
t.. ffiYii6t..~~~~~·t-:~fWi<~Mlct-:~· L -CIt I- 1>.-;
:/ ':; ~ilff1iMliltT7}i'illtJt .. ~ ~-eIH.. ~·o
-1L 7 ... v :/ {' I- ? - Y- ':; IC J: .., -CfJHll t<;h.
t~M~r.t$T;;'~iMliKJ:;h.li. M~lti~fV-t
(I' - -; :/) J -ei!;;;' t-:Ib~<I6,~~iLI:-ei!; ;;'M:~{' EI
c%!:~~~ ..,n·t.. ~·~t:'tJ'':;it:' fv-tJ -ei!;Q
t IH' ,z. f. -'t;h. t9' ,z./iltA t 15] L: J: ? t..il\!~(I'JJtIlilL
{'tffi'fIJlt ~.., -C~.;;, t IH·,z. tJ:~' t t< ;h.;;, 0 .: ~1lI!
~j',&f,~~m-( '/ I-~. 1!t~<;j:.~~~~lcML-C. fA
fal (:to J: V' -'t ~ JJill'c) ~!Jt 5.lIWh· T ;;, :U.E EI3 IH.. IC
tJ'J f!Jtlc[YJ¥J.J t ~illl~'ltRf)'J t~· "> r.~I~·~-::>!!<
-::>11;;,.:tKi!;;;'o ~M~M.~••~a4~. ~
-l.f~~:f1[i t L -C ~Aralt:'11 tJ;!JtJ)IJ tJ::ilHAHI'Jl1!l!J'L~ ~
-::> ~tJ, ~TI:IDET;;' ;: t tJ"i!ft U <. t ICi!;;;' 0 ArhliJ;
il\!~!(fJlc!JtJ)11 tdcll'D.~<16'~ t T;;' l'dlE13 tJ\ iiilcArJ]
ItAlhlt:'iJ·':;J t~·?.: t -ei!;;h.li. -'t;h.ltijU.. ;;,
11\:5)IJ {,ifaJl. t 15Jffl:~ ~ ~ -e L tJ' t.. ~.:to -'t;h. tJ;i!; ;;, 0
AltJJltAINlt:.tJ,,:;!JtJ)IJt:.. t~·.., t-:llliEl3lt. t-: t,z.
lilUl~~{,A1ill~ J: ? t..il\!f!.1J'J':JK_m:~-et..~·!Jt~~
JfI ~. -C!Jt:@~ :/ IL- - 7'~A ,< t:'I1~!JtJ)IJ1Jl. U-: 'J ilk
5)IJ U-: 'J T;;' .: t t 7<:!!< t..illlHH.. ~·o U-:tJ;.., -C.
b;h.b;h.ltiji t.. Q~~1lI!~illl~ ·t-:11-e~ t.. <. AfJj
t it!! ~!lYJ¥J.J~IHJlci!; Qil\!~J'J':JICm:~ tJ:illl~' ~ JI. ~ ·t:.
T <16'~ tJ;i!; ;;, 0 '" ~ t.. 11;h.1;! i!; ':; tJ' C-Ib AfJJJ;)J'l-~
!lYJ~~~1fI;~Alhl J: 'J ~ fiIfiif!!iJ" t.. ~· t ;tNjIM.. < fJ1)fJ~
L-CLi?4~~~mL-C:to'J. f1ll!iIk~J K:to
't:> ~ • .., -C ~. Q .: t/U.. ;;, 0 -'t L -C :to -'t ':; < !lYJ~ t A
I~~t ~*!!< < 5tI1Q:iEi~J'J':Jlc:!fI~t..illlHt. %!:~{'
~~~tJ. -'tL-C~c%!:~~c-ei!;;;,t~b;h.Qo
TQtM~~~~.~.tl5J••tJ·-'t;h.~~~.~
{',';!'.~~tJ Lf)'~'"n·t..~·~-e. Illi:At I5J L: J: ?
t..mWt ~.., n·t.. ~· t~,z. ':;;h.Qo
;:~Y-(~~.iMli~i!ft4~--::>lt.M~~~-e~
<~~y~ ~ i Ut!! ~lIiH~L. t IffJ./Jl' iJ·-'t ;h.J;),~~M:
~1il{',';!;',01&·til§JJ LtJ·~.., n·t..~.~-e. ~-?'t-t.. c~
lI~i~Ll:WHJl:T ~ t tJ;f;!r-~ "';h.;;' ~ t.. ':; Ii. -'t;h.J;),~
~~:~{'!;!!,~fjgtJ LiJ'~ t-:t"~'~~l'CHJl:T': t ~
ii'!'$ "';h. -C L i "> t ~. ? fJjllj'j-C' i!; Q ;,) 0 ~.., t llli~~
B';JlcmiJiU t.. nfJJij'jlt. b;h.b;h.lt%!:~~9<.., t-: 'J. fill
!lYJ(J"Jlcill\1;L L -C ~ ·t-: 'J L -C. M:~{' mc.~~9<..,
-C ~ ·t-: ') EI 'l}tJ;~tr«!!< ~ ~~!i'! i t.. ~.,: t tJ;i!; Q
~, -'t~~~~il\!~J'J':J~.~M.-ei!;'J-::>~I1.il\!
fl!1(rJJ1!lilL{'tffi'fIJ~9<bt"~·~IH..-l.fiJ·t~·? .: tiC
~,z. tJ: 11;h.lit.. ':; t.. ~· t ~. ? ;: t -e i!; Qo t-: t ,z.li
I-? - Y -It, fi!;QA~XIC)c:tTQm'fUtJ;i3(~",
;h. "> ;;, ~It. -'t~A¥J.JtJ', X~1iX;j( Ln· Q .i:j;J~t:' ~j
-et.. <. ~-FO)5k{*tJ;t..~;h.(i-'t~AltlJl.tEX ~iiX
;j( L n ·t-: -e i!; 6 "> t ~.,z. Q ij;l~ ~ ~tr 0 -'t~5ki~:
t l;t. (i)-'t~ A~iJ;jm1llJB':Jt..~&ij~9<..,t-=lX!~lci!;
Q. (ii)-'t~A~iJ;lJl.tE~:~~9<..,-C~.;;,. (iii)-'t~A
¥J.Jlt XO)!J.:!lo ~iiX;j(T Q J: ? ~i'l'~ 11 ':;;h.n· Q.
t~·? ~~-ei!;QJ (Tooley. 197L. p.4S) t~·..,t-:
~~~~m:@~W<Kei~. ~-l.f':~J:?~m:@
t;;!hLiJ·;h.;;, ~ fJ' ~-r5tlcitlI.~T;;' .: t Ita L c": t
~~Ib-C~'Qo ~ L. ~·ilJl.IC%!:~~~..,-Cc·t.. c·
• 20 •
O',l: {>lI\1gt vn, ,<"J-,l: b l&:K.@'W: C 'ClJ:~z- (,-:>
,t ? K.t.l: :<, 1J' iC> ill*"Ali¥JK.lli~ t.l: I<) t.: t L' ':>t.:illt IjfJ >d:'
1JII k.:<' t.l: iC> 1;1:- IIf'i 'JC. b jib' iC>fft~{> 13 C:t!.~Z- b
0,t?~~:<'I<)~b·iC>.A,l:~C,t?~.?«~~
,l: L'? 13UiUb,nrfJl§b'b Utt.l:L'.
.: ? U~Jl(I,<i:i >d:'13'.7t-t.l:b\ iC> b, ~1'*f!£f~:Jt.l:'m~-f:TVI
r.:~I<)il';I"t':C'It, ':? U~ fO',l:J ~~I<)5ttrrb'
iC>*~>d:'.e~:<'~~:<'~.fl~.~~M.>d:'~{>
Cc~k.~~*~>d:'T-~C'il';:<',l:~k.:<'.~k~
~~,l: --:> C l<)illHIIiII, t: I<),t ? ~~ C c f:fill~5JIJJ z-@
~C~ffiiC>~'JC.~b~A,l:~~l<)m~i¥J~&Z-e~
7.>~.H'\HH~ 7.> b', C'il'; 7.> ,l:~ k. iC> n 7.> •
2 ?-~A~ rpnpnc~~~*J ~
~~ijij
':?Ck~.I<)~b·C'~~·7-~~ffilOO9.
b"'J1\l!±l U~mfU)(fl, ~~*f!£fI9t.l:il6trJ!Q.\b'iC>, -Jil.~7.>
U~'ffi I~ illt~\Hf) t.(~~ * ~R:tt l<)1lNmfU z-J1\l!±l C c t:l:§ >d:'fG V't~o -t l<)~il6l;1<)11H1HI~~'ffiI~ '-" ~ 7' I~ c" il';
7.>. ijij;1!fl:~-hli~l<),t ? ~~tJ::<'.
I. f:>!:Ab\T-~C'il';7.>l<)fl, fI!i~~b'iC>bnbn
t~C~~il';7.>~*z-~?k~C'il';7.>o
2 (~'Ij~ t.() JIf'i l'Cf:l:bnbn,l: ~ CfiUi(i!iil'; 7.>:t;1
*Z-b --:>cl,'7.>.
3 -tn~k., ~'JC.>d:'.~':,l:ltbnbn>d:'.~
':,l:,l:t--:>k<~C~t:.*~T-~C'il';7.>.
.: l<)~mfUl:I:, bnbnl<)!? < l<)illffi.i¥JOOlfll!,l: ~it
ff.JC'il';:<,o iiIrh';. 7tI:l:bnbn~~,l: --:>cM,I,'bl<)C'
il';~, t1AI:l:T-~C'il';:<'. Cb,UHf-t?t.(l<)t':6
? b',l: 7-~:A f:l:F"'? 7tb"'M,c"il'; ~, .Ab"'T-~
t.( I<) 1:1:, ii' ~~ -tntM'i'fJi'j z- lj- k. 7.> b' iC> C'11tJ: 1,'. b
C-t? t.( iC> Ii. 'i!fji'i'i t.( < .~t.( iC> IH9:AIF1'.lE c"l:I:
tJ:I,·,l: 1,' ? .: ,l: I~ tJ: ~ b·b t.(1, 'b' iC> C'il'; 7.>. 7 - ~
:A11~1<),t? ~~-g?
hhhhf:l:. hhhh t3 tn::. 0L' L IDl'l,' ID t.l:" nij
jIU"c,!lillt <>.: t n'--r:i! 0 0 'thliTt.eh~, <hh
hh ~;litT': t li'FJE --r: <60) g,? jo'lIh'<60 0
&ID~••~_.IDRre'tht3.~ &~;Iit~
h 0': t ~'FJE~::'To hft--r:lit.e "0 &1,-,<t."",B',
1of.i>~*9<T o!iliJll, &Ii, ;Iit~ ht.efthli:fi1*1D
t',IDD-t!:: V(ID~Ii5~tlllJi11:L."n'1~tJ'>(,l-ht.e"
1i5!IiJJ~Hiilli~iQ<l-.l;. t.e!::" IDT'" -C ~9<., -C l- "H'.
l-k~"L, &~7th~ &ID:fi1*K~To~.~
T"'L••~h-Cl-!?.:tK~oo 0i!~ltot•
':5l-k*9<~&~1(,kGT.:t~,&~;litT.:t
~'FJEI::'TolD--r:<6oo 't5,'5hft--r:, <ft!!I::'~f.\!:
IDllli iJJ n' t.e ft h Ii. ,'n' t.e 0 Ji11:A l-1~ Are1 ~ i, ;lit T
':!::f:l:i!hlt-C'FJE--r:<6<» !:Toi,IDf:l:, 'tIDA
IDH-* ID i~9< --r: <60 .J: 5 ~::. .\!;(hh 0 0 (Marquis,
1989. pp.189-190 'iiliil!\lliJil(Xo)
7tb'M,C';J;~, ~J!:Ab'T-~C'il';7.>l<)f:l:, DC6,
-tntM?nbnb' iC> (ilij(Hlil'; 7.>i'l-*Z-~? b' iC> C'il'; 7.>.
.: nb'7 - ~:A 1<)7t I<)M,~ ~~01,' cj;jUIJ~7.> f~uq:
illtJ (deprivation account) C'il';7.> "'o 7t1<)M,~ 1':-:>
"cl:l:/I!H~~:lL(f;;Jillb\il'; l) k.7.>0 -01:1: f7tb~')/gI,'
b I<) C' il'; 7.> I<) a, -tn b"'~A I<)!t ~Mti'tt.: , ' ,l: 1,' ?
iik;J<I::'R~ 7.> b' iC> c"il'; 7.> J ,l: ~:<, fiik;J<illtJ (desire
account) C';J;~, b?-01:1: f7tb\M,I,'bl<)C'il';
7.> 1<)11, -tnb\~AI<) -tn :l' C'1<)li'£~HJr~m --:> c
C t ? b'iC> C'il'; 7.> J ,l:~ 7.> f;a;~illtJ (discontinua
tion account) C'il';:<, oil 0
7 - ~ :A f:l:, /Ui'; --:> c 1,' :<, A, -1~fJ':JI~1\):II!lH!Ui!i~~
;J; :<, A {>, -lli¥ff-Jt.(I!i;/j(Ii!\I~jl(hc rE >d:' i\ A., C'I,' 7.>
W.li!t~7.>':,l: >d:'i\A.,c"IH't.(I,'t;\ -tnC'b7t
I:I:-t? Ct~A'H':,l:--:>cM,I,'bl<)C';J;7.>,l:I,'?oC
t~b' --:> c iik;J<illtfiilltt1li¥Jc"fHJ:h -15, ;a;~illt~~
01,'cl:l:(kI<),t ? t.(.~,~~~I~IDFk. 7.>. il'; 7.>m3<\.1<)
.i!:!.:jt,-1M~·il'; ~~ilf{ U·'i!f C .7t-1~mi A., C':to l), -tn~k.
-t1<)••I<)~~I<)li'£.I:I:-tn~~*~~.~~b~
t.l: I, '. Cb' C, -t I<)I~.<ii.C'I<) rE z-il!t11nl;(,\!:!.:jt,-I:I:-t
1<).@mcc•• il';7.>!tm~~7.>':,l:ffiC'~:<'I<)C'
il';nli, {>11~ 7tI:l:!I!.(I,'bl<)C'il';7.>o U~b;.,c,
7t1<»)/g~ 1:I:~~I<)li'£.,l: 1:l:iJ<liH*If;f-fH t.:f, ;a;~
illt b illtf--'lll)C'fH.(1, '0 -t.: C'~7.>~1~q:illtb'7tI<)M,~
~~01,' c 1<)~~*f!£i¥JtJ:illtljJj t C c fin c 1,' 7.> .: t I~
t,r; 7.> 0
~iC>~, ~'ffi~~'JC.btkhnbn,l:~C,t?~
-t ? C t.: filfi(i!iil'; 7.> i'l-* z- b --:> c 1,' :<, .: ,l: 1:1:~ 1:< 13 UJj
C'il';7.>,l: 7-of-:Alt~·k.7.>0
• 21 •
<.~~~~-.~~~~~n.•-.~~n. ~
~lIHg~tMj7t~H*~filljf[(~i\19<~0 iJ'G -r:;J; 0>
~ " 5 :t\IW:. kf/(1i(,*,~~j(,ol1ln::.;ttl-llt 5 >f<jt!!~t.e
Hjl1lili~ ~ t-: G~o 1\\'!i\!!~t.e1ll1 ''1.~1'1*I::'f:l:. rP.1\
~Y;tll'l.~:j;1* ~ fOJ--c';J; o.l: 5 t.e-iili~ft!fR. ~-rii!iJ.
~.~E~~ihoo.~.~A~~.~~~~~
t.e~ f:l:t.e.g' iJ' ~i\l1!!IJ ~ 0 ~ I::. i-7)- t.el1l1 EiJ 1:1:. 1lI1,'I. r::.
~ik~-cnioo ~~k~. <.~W.~l1I1EiJ~~
fthff. 'p~f:l:illflJ(t:H::';!b~-C~~-C';J;o>~ "
5 li8~f::' t.e 0 0 (Marquis. 1989. p.192)
~/(1i(,*,el:l:.A~i~k<~~C~E~K-e~
0''''0 ~hfi'//7/J..-eil;1) t.eiJ;Gt.eiJ,t.etJ'/~ '7 7
1\.0 t.eJX!lf/(1i(,*,etOi.1l!i>Jt-e il; 0 0
7-~~tO••~li'/:-'7~~tO~~~.~<tO
:lHJrtJ"il;oo 'ttO,· < -:>t),~il;Irf-C';;"J: 5, 1iBI~. -:.tOi~.li r(A,fl,1tO) !t1'ititO*,II!M!~J tOJ: 5
t.e*r!dt-Jt.d§~1::.1Rfr:-t 0 ~ to-eI:tl" "0 il; < i-e
rbhbh~.-t ~ ~ fi~K-eil; oj ~ ,. 5*~.
(J) A!? I::'~~~ ~ h -C,' 0 ~1'7t<;yj{EI9ts:1§ ~t)' G~q; ~ t':
~ho~tO-eil;oo it-:. rmflJJ tOJ:5ts:rti'l'~'
A1.l,i¥Jjlj'{~I::.m;t 0 ~ to -e ~ t", .,ii'0liB=x. ~ tOf,il!~(.fi rfi1!i(f!liJ 1::.-:>,·-Ct01!f$i¥JK.
;l(ILHL1J1lj~if@] L n·ot':l>? 'thl::.~;to46,J,g
tJ;ts:,< ~-eil;oo bhbhtOA!t~"lH·~(J)I::.-t
o ~ tOtr,f"j-e il; 0 tJ'fi1!f$:jlj(J)IN]-e ~ ~JVM.b'J·h
0 0 t:J<~ijji,~ ~ o1!f$:jljat:J<~t.:lttJ··fi1Ii(f!li-eil;o ~
±3R L. ~fiIl.i¥J y ~ r ijji,~ ~ o1!f$:jljfiffi~~Rtj~
~~.~~.'ttO_. ~fiIl.~~hkfillj.~fr:~-to
~~iJR-tot':~ 5;"0 UJ·L':': -efi't(J)J: 5 tdil
L H,}]JI£j I::'~ ~ l.l:l-t46,J,gI:tfs:'·, ~ fiIl.EI9j;!£JI;',l-e il;
h. 1t!!tO~fiIl.i'I'~Ij]:!il1tOrvtj'[-c'il;h. ~ lUI' <. bt-:
LtO~*~bkL~.~~~-Cfi1li.~il;o,:~~~
lii!i':iE-e~tS:"J:51::.bt-:U::'lilj!!,bhoo ~L-C.
bkLtJ·G. 't5Lkfi1li.il;0~*~••~h-CL
i5':~~bkLtO~tO.~tO.J,g~.7t~•• L
-C"o': ~tJ"~l>?ots:Gli. ~ I) il;;tf'th -e7
~~tO.H;jiil::'li-H}-eil;o~ ,. 5.: ~IUs:oo
m=:I::'. j;)ljijiJ'Gjltf.IJ~h -C"o rJ!Ii'Jeli~~i¥J
ts:rH -eil;o. 'th,,!>;t. lJ'~ ~ IftJ L:ii\'i:c@i¥J11ilfIJ~
~ -:> (ii\'i:C@(~JI1!l(:!L ~ ~ -:» J ~ -t 0 r~~tt tOi.1l!~f(jJ
~tOi&H::'I'HI L-C~': 50 ~tO,9 4 7·tOi.1l!~;itili~
< tO~;iti:jlj I::' J: ~ -C 1Ii'diIi¥J1::'i!i':iE ~ h -C ,. 0 0 r J" 'J
:-'~W5J:5~~/'Y~'·fh.tO#~ ••-to
ti' G ~ ,. ~ -C. -t-eI::..tO#-eil; 0 ~ I1'·;t ts:,·o
IftJCJ:5~. ~~ffi~*.A~~o~L-C~••A
~ IftJ C11ilfIJ~ ~ -:> ~ 11'·;t ts:h il; :OU'j,o,'U -e!J"ftt
p ~ ~ -:>b· E 5 t1'li. 'tht), G. to IR¥A\l , -e!J"ftt p
~~-:>t)·E 5 tJ'I::'li1Rfr:Lts:,·tO-C·il;oo ~ 5 Lt-:
~~i1tOi.il!~I:t. ~ ~ L -C. l!liY'GtOU'jA-e'thli!t
~ 0 rmm ~ ~ -:>b·i!i'tJ·. it.:. MYeli rlJ' ~ J
-e il; 0 tJ·i!i'tJ·l::' tJ'b'b 0 f,i!!~;itit': ~ t..: t-:/lb I::'. 1:to J:
5~JX~~';;"ibhoo ~':~ffi. rbhbh~1ftJ
C1'f*J ~~-:>b'E5tJ'~'·5.~X-C'li. 1!Ii~~ 5ilJ(
ge~::.t-:'·L-C*~ts:;m;H:tIH·0 E~G~~'tG<
(7'f;:iI§ffij-e. j)J!tJ;J: Ithl:O 70ijO~~-tbhbh~
IftJ Cfi1Ii(f!liil;o~*~ ~ ~ -C,' 0 ~ ,·;too .: to J: 5
I::' 7 - ~ ~ to.~;itifi. r r' :-' (/ Y1:1: i t':.tO# -el:l:
ts:H ~,'5)x~(;U~j@It-C,'00
~gg~::., "7'-~AQ)~ii6UI'1~ f""-:J /~i1UJ O)J:
5 1::.~~~:ill:1ll.-t 0 i.1l!~tJ;..-;-:>tJ, 0 *IliI!:I*!il1~ ~ ~ll:
Wfi!it:jlj ts: E tOl~1J1lj~@]j@ Ln· 0 0 il; 0 V' CiJ;A!t
tOil;onlf ....... -e*IliI!L n·J: 5~. f,'j*,lli¥JI::.~'ti::iE-C'
il;~5~. iJtJl&l~hn·J:5~. ~L'ttOAI::'bh
bh ~ IftJ C J: 5 l::'fiJfi(i~iil; 0 1'f*b·'t.Jl~ h n· 0 b·
;totO-eil;h~ 'ttOA~~~~o':~fibhbh
~~~~otO~IftJCJ:5~~K-eil;00~L~~~
.1ll.-to.:jlj~ r*IliI!:I*!il1tO.:jlj~m"~~b~
,. (J)li. ~*~~~ ~ I) ~ E Lt-: ~ ~ to't (J).I!:.:jljtO
.*~.~ffi••~tJ·G-eil;oJ ~~;to~GIL
~~ b :p1*.*~#.!:~ ~ ~ -:> -:. ~ I::' ts: 0 tOt':tJ'G.
lftJil'lH::.j)k 5 ..-.: ~ -e il; 0 ~ ,. 5 .: ~ IUs: 0 0~~1L~. ~ tOi.1l!~li:f[!7::§:5]iJtOllfJIIJ'j~@]j@ L -C ,.
0 0 t-: ~ ;t ff*!J!iilll'iAJRtO-f,jII:l:bnbn ~ J: < jj;),
-C~I). ~tOkl>?bhbh~~~~CJ:5~fi1Ii.~
01'f*~~ ~-c'·QtJ·~ l-htJ:"o b l-'t 5 ts:Gff.
*!J!iilll'iA3ffHll:-t.: ~ fibhbh Hll:-t to ~ IftJ C <G'·~K-eil;0~'·5': ~1::.ts:otJ'~ Lhts:\,·o
1i. J'lmts:EI:t1-:LtJ·l::' r!t~-C"oJ tJ;~'tG <
,'i!'.'.~~~c~i.1tt~j:.:,·n·o ~~;tGnot-:l>? b
hbh ~ IftJ C J: 5 ts:~*~ ~ ~ -c,. oblt-C'I:tIs:'·o
Lk~~-c'thG~.-t':~fibhbh~.-t.:~
• 22 •
hl:.cl:l:'1'JE1:I;J:t.n't-:650 ;: <OJ: 5 ~c L'c7-'\'
A <OiID!~ifUli.f*:<;1'±~*<O-IlltIi'Jtdili~6D<O J: 5 ~::.:(ffi~
5J1j1i'J1:f;J:t,c: I, '0
~ G ~C, flIi <oi'.N~Ii.ID:!Jl'II1,'1~H'c ~*Wl.~.*<Oi'tfff.
~~~~.·JE~1t~~~.~h~0 ~~~L~
',W.K.~~*~~~~b~b~~~~J:5~
filJi(lfih~H*fi.~ ..,"(l"t,c:l"tl,~ L~t,c:I,'o ;:<OJ:
; t,c:~~~c-t<O.\!i.*~~!I;HC"f tHt ~ ;: ~ Ii., "f t-:~~A~~<Oh~~~~~~K"ftl~~~c'1'JE1:
Itt,c:I,'tl,~ L~t,c:I,'o ~1'1f;~cID:I,'ffili'J' fHI;Ii'JII1,'1i!l'
~~1,', ~1f<o A~~tl;~~1f;~::.:J,· t,c: I, ':ifr~~H Ji'Ji'*1:h ~ 0 ,: <0 Au::. -::> I, , -C 1i. 7 - '\'- A <o@' 1Il1 ~C Ji'l1l: L
t,c:I,'~*~~I,'t-:6 5 tl\ flIi~::'Ifi]m~~.A~:J,·t,c:<t,c:I,'t-:6 ; 0
~~:7Hc ~ tl,t,c:' ft Lh 1-\:~IY"t,(jjt,¥IJ~I,'<-::>tl,
A -C~ ~ ,: ~ ~c L J: ; 0 Wfr¥l <0 tJl.,\'i: <0 ~:lJL (2)1l!
u<or"~fIIj, (3) r1li!9<J r~IJ'l\tJ <OXt,*~cl>!J~ ~ '" fJ
••$Ii'J~W, ~r~~J rb~b~J <O~-~~
b~b~~ lJ1iW'.<O~\I;J.~~::.tl,tl'b~~,¥II,(5)(iIIi([( ~
.*<OOO.Ktl,tl~~~W~ft~li'J1:h~o.KA
-c~tcl,'o
4.1 'tl:11(l)fl.\'1:
"fT, ,:; LtC7-'\'-A<oiID!~~Uol,'-Cft,~f~
~ ~ fr~ 13 ,!ltl::' -::>1" -C"f .., tc <A!h~ G~ -C 1,' t,c:1, '.<2.~~W~~~«t~650 ~~~~~,~~7-,\,
A~~~<o••Ii'J.&Ka~L, ~~<o~~~M~
tJl.~~ -:ti1:, fr~ 13 ,!It<o:fIj'jf;~m:fIJK "f -:>1c <a
~: ~ tL. .., -C 1,' t,c: 1,'.<2. ~ ~ fll L -C 1" ~ (Cudd,
1990) 0 ;: ~It~1:IC1970:¥j-\:tl' G~f~'Ni!:~cl>!J~
~7~i:A~~~<O.~KJ:..,-C~K±.~~-C
t~ID:~~~B1:h9, 7-'\'-A<oiID!~<oA~~;:
~ <l)1:t t,c:HK.\'i:1:h~~ ,~.b~~o
Lb'L, ~~<O••Ii'J.&<o~fIIj~.~~TK,
:t('¥l<om:fIj<O~~±.~~ bltlc ~ I, 'tl,t,c:1, '0 J:1:
~ A, 'J /<o);i\i~I::'-::>\,''"(tlil1li LtcJ: 51c, IJliYc<o:fIJ
i!i'~m:flj J: 9 fr¥l <o:fIji!i'~;gtRt,c: c tl;~J't:~ 0 <0 tl'
c5tl'~"f~K~flIj1:ho<O~fr~<otJl.B~~.
ICA~-C\',t,c:\"tl'G ~ \"'" '"( 7-'\'- A <o);i\ir.6D~-1f,t
4.2 9;Hm,*,~f!!l:: ;~UI
.=<O.Ii., 7-'\'-A<O~.1:lt~:(ffi<01l!U~"f
~'1'JE1:ho;:~K~~;:~~~-t5~~~~<01:
hoo tc~~li, /-"oAIi., ~WT~m'f~, Iii;
~~~~J:5Kb~b~~~~filJi.h~H*~~..,
-C \" 0 ~ j§i ~ t,c: 1,' <0 tl' t. r"~ 5 (Norcross, 1990)0
~ L~~J:; t.dlli([(h~H*~~ ..,'"(l"o Uj~o
<0 t,c: GIi, 7 - '\'- A <Oi\!l!!Jj -C'Ii., 1l!kf ~ f&.A ~ ~ ~
;fli1!Jl'lc'1'JE1:ho;: ~ I::.t,c:oo Ltl' Lb~b~lt1l!
~fHJ!:.A t. ~ ~ J: ; 1::''1'JE'"('h~ t. Ii.~~ t,c: \, '0 L
tc7'1;.., -C 7-'\'- A <o);i\i~ltnX::J;jj L -C\',t,c:\" ~ ~ 0 0
,: <o1l!~f~ f&.A7'1"~ ~ -C' h 0 7'1' ~ \" ; 1J,~fIIj~c -::> 1,'
-C, 7-'\'-A l3,!ltltlk<OJ: 5 ~::.i1S«-c\"00
.H~fihh~.~~~. A.,~mTt. (••3
hk)-0~.T~~&~~~~~?~. ::'hG~
~~eh3~~.~~A.~9'~~0 ••~~~eh-ltlt;l'?tc<~1£Lt.t\"0-tht.'. ~'BlE~~J
hh~~.t.~~'~lt.•~~~~eh-lt~~.~t.tO)t~0? tJ" L.tJ' L. i:'~~~1l-h-ltO)~IJl:j~t~
0;?~0)~~';l'k~~~~~o.~~~±~~
1'.~t~3 t.tl,', (Marquis 1989, pp.201-202)
7-'\'-A~1l!U<O&.1:ltC<offi'ft.c<o.'f~
fa.g.~ 0 ;: ~ I::' t,c: 0 tJ'v.t:lE ~ ~ -C \,' t,c: \, 'tclib IC. "f
t-:b~b~t. ~ ~~~*It ~.., -C\',t,c:\" t.~~ ~b~
1:hoo L7'1'L, ':':1:, ,~.~~!\tl)~L-C~oo ~~
'f-OO t. *J'H-OO~;gfR L, '/ ,. - v <0 t,c:7'1'~CA~
ot,c:Gli, (-t~G7'1"~ L$1l:ffi~o ~~~Ii) $1l:*J'i
J:),lJfrK. ~1:I::' c <o!J~'f t. c <Ofi'H7'1"fii.g.~ 0 7'1'ltY<
:lE~~ -C "~;: ~ Ict,c: 0 0 L t.:.tJ;.., -C, ,: <O!J~T ~
;: <o*JH 7'1"fa.g.~ 0 ,: t. H;lji!l'~ 0 t,c: GIi, ,:~G
<O~H t. ffi'H' G;b~b~~ ~ ~H*~'l\t..,'"(l,'o
,: ~ l::.t,c:~7'1'~ L~t,c:\"o
'b L;: <o.'i!.',~~!\tl)<Ofa:!lW'JELlthfi, m~eb
~ 7'1"Y<:lE ~ ~ -C \, , t,c: \,' tclib IC iJiGflll'f t. $1l:f,'i!J~ <orHlIc
11* ~ t,c:••Ii'JJ1hfli.<Ojfi[\, '7'1;6'> 0 ~ ~07 - "" A <0
Aflilit-: 1t1:1i.-j-~1:fi. t,c:1, '0
tct-:L'l1A1:lt. ;:,: 1:7-'\'-Alt):),Jlfr7'1'G9'M
lZJc:IVF< IC J: .., '"(til! IiI '" ~ '"( 1,' 0 jl'j~f'l<ojfi[ 1,' <or.ili~
• 23 •
K.:lJH.6': ctr'-C~6iJ'{, I...-ntJ:I,', -t-C~'::;<-:l
:/ v>1970:¥fl:::fJJjiJH.:, ffli-'N~i- c :Jtf,'W~ c -Cli,
jq.*Ii'ZA~.:tJ:6i.\Y.i«\t'lv;"*~< ili!1", ':nv>lM~Al'I~J
il'fr~.:~!&~Jj-*. -(\,'6': c HifiJi*i1...- '(\,'6 (Noonan,
1970, p.56), :;< -:;I- :/~':J:nl:(. -'t{'-'t{,lM~~PI'iI
il'frli;;$:1'lB9 ~':Jm:!,!,\f'1~': v> v>b 6 ~:ljlJ'fr -C h 6, t:. IJ' G
.:-'tl~~~I~Jm:i«\tt-cA~~~~6,:cK~6
fi~c, 2 7j-~ 1 ~JlA\'i«\tt-C~tJ:~6': c ~.:tJ:6fi
~liim:~\(fJtJ:;r:IE ~ ~,¢.', -c;t ·cd.:. <"* ~ tJ:ili!I,' v>h
6, ~ilJji- c :Jtf,~!J~-Cf;J:-1't*rti:A~.: tJ: 6i.\Y.?/.WltJ""*
~<ili!51...-,:Jtffi.c~.5~~~M~~~K{,"*
~tJ:ili!I,'v>h6, ':~ili!I,'li, bnbncl'ilL::J;-l*
~ {,--:> J: 5 ~.: tJ: 6 JlA\'i«\t'l ~ili!I,' -C {, h 6, {, 1...-': 5
I...- t.:.:;< -:1- :/ ~~illilliliv>llj(b-Ch 6 c -tnl:(. / - !J
" 7- G~11'f~~I}JjJ¥j~ Jjh 't.:.m:illilili"7 - """ 7- O)~:lliti
~m:!£1-t6~':li~""n'tJ:I,'J: 5 ~':,'i!:\bn6,
4.3 i/<IJW C~;Ic
~ / -y I- 7 - A 7- I- " :/ !J'li, "7 - """ 7- ~1'.illillili-C'
ffll,'Gn6 r'lli!9i:J (loss) ~ r9i:5J (loose), r~J
~~J (deprivation) c 1,'''' t.:.iilfl/'4i-~B9-Ch6': c
~jifiJi*i I...- -c 1,' 6 (Sinnott-Armstrong, 1997), bn
bnli r'lli!;lcJ ~ r~J'!\tJ c \" 5 :m~.:;\'-n -C '" "'-T1 7'tJ:I'IH51.~:Ifi!~v>"G-CiV'), -'tnli!lf\l,< c-CiV
6c~*.v>"G-CiV6, t.:c*.I:(. AV>B~ll:t;{jj~
'!\t..,t.:~-Chnl:(. t.: I...-v'~.:-'tnli;r:IEtJ:': c-CiV
6,BffiM~~.I...--C9i:",~c-tnlf-'tnliBK
c..,-C;r:¥tJ:,:c-C'iV6, Lv'L, t.:t.*.lfA t.
Bffi~-V-7-~L-C, Affi."L~.~, -'tnli
B ~.: t. .., -C .fIJ~ I, tJ 7 1 - ~'Ili!9i: (loss) t:' t.13
*. 6 v\ A IttJ:~': iJ,;r:IE tJ:': c f;J: L t.:.b VT -ClttJ:1,',
{, I...- B v',,,. ~ :/ I! -y !J -C';r:IEtJ:'f-~:ll:~ffll,'-Cse ~
jf Iv ~j~1~ L t.:.': t. v>~Jt L t.:. t. -t 6 tJ: G If, B v>
G -" jf Iv~~J'!\t-t6': t.IHs LiSIE U< U:'iS 5,
-?;t ~ r'lli!9i:J ~ r)fIJ'ti'J ~':lii1!i~(flluj'j'[tJ:ilG;zn
(flffli* C, 3~i!I!~il'¥fiIfi~t';trim:~@.(19ffl~tJ>iV6, b
nbnli': 5 L t.:.ffl~~ili!H':fiiXF~-C iV 6,Q:,:ID!t;>h
6,
"7-",,"7-~ rIi'ZA~of&-t.: t.t;>;r:IEtJ:~li, mfiiiii
iV 6 j'i*~~J'!\t-t 6t;, Gt:'J c 1,'''' t.:.3!<:gH.: M'-C
Ii, r~J~i<J liJ1!i~@'(fJtJ:M.,*-C'ffll,'Gnn'6 J: 5
~':Ji!,*.6, L1J'L, t.:LtJ'I':iV6D-ct;q.,t. {'t.im:
f~\(:I'~tJ:t1tfIJ~ {, .., n, 6 {, ~ ~)f.IJ'W-t 6 .: t. li;r:IE
-CiV6tJ\ -'t 5 Lt':'#lm~ {,.., -n'tJ:I,'{, ~~~I~i'
~n~~9i:..,~~-t6.:t.f;J:im:~B9K~n-CiV6Ii
f-CiV6, "7-",,"7-~~illili-C~r~.~~KJ:..,-C
lJilYclibnbnt.liiJL:J: 5tJ:-1't*~'i!i!9i:-t6J ~ r'l~
9i:J lii1!if@.(j'~tJ:m'*-ClttJ:I,', t. 1,' 5 ~f;J:, Ml'CiJ',
-'t 5 Lt.:.i1!if~\B9mfIJ~ {, .., on, 6t;''i§'v'li;t t:'li..,
~ ~ Ln'tJ:I,'iJ'G-ciV6, l!Ill'Cliilli:f@'(flmflj~{,
.., -n, 6 c -t 6 .: t. liillili,?\geJliU': tJ: 6, -'tn'1> *. y
/ -y I- 7 - A 7- I- " :/ !J'li, "7 - """ 7-li;t fJJil~'Ct;,
J1!i~lI¥Jmfl]~{, .., -C 1,' 6 iJ' C 5 v,~n;UE-t 6~ ~-c
iV6t.-t6,
.: 5 I...- t.: y / -y ,- 7 - A 7- I- tJ :/ !J' ~jjt~:lHi, I1I~~;zn~6X~ffl:m c, filfiiMllltfr~;zn~6X~ffliili
c ~1K7J11 c1,' 5 -" ;; jl1ill1lt~~jLJ~'t~':Ill!g,;L t.:iJl.l"j;JJ
I) 1:J~{,"?-C1,'6, LtJ'I...-.:~m:!£1O)ii'l'infili;:fEU',
t.:. LtJ'I': "7 - """ 7- ~~~(;Uli r)fII~i<J ~ r'i!i!9i:J c 1,'
.., t.:.IT!ViiJ ~'i§'IE(i'-JI'IJZI. ~;r:~ l.:flJffll...- -C 1,' 6 J: 5 I':
,1[',bn6, I...-tJ'l...-, ;tf.:.: -C"7-",,"7-~{,c {, t.
~~illilili, rmflJj t. 1,' 511.I'tt:~':lim*. -C l"tJ:I,',:
cK~m-t6~~~iS5, rIi'ZAA~of&-t.:t.ffi;r:
IE-c iV 6 ~Ii At;, GmfiiiiiiV 6i'i*~'!\t 5 tJ> G t:'J
c 1,' 5 X iJ4~ ~.:illfA\B9 r#iffIJJ ~.: f'JF *. t.:. {, ~ -C iV
6 ~IJ> C 5 t;>liUI':IM'lllffriJ>;:fE L 1,', {, L"7 - """ 7
~f.illillilitJ\ r#iffl]J t.1,'5~Jtt:~.:f;Jf*.6,:ctJ:<fitJ:
bn-n'6~-ciVnlf, y/ -y 1-7-A7-I-":/!J'
~m:!£11i~r:T~iJ'{,I...-ntJ:I,',
;t t.:. "7 - """ 7- iJ"tHl:i I...- -C 1,' 6 ~f,(;U -Cli, im:~B9I':
m::ID!t.~*.Gn-CI,'6':cli rfJlfiiiiih6j'i*~{'..,
n'6J t. 1,' 5-,?\-C'h6, Ii'ZAt.JJil~'C~re1~-'t~
jt!!~ili!1,'Ii. ("7 - """ 7-1': J: .., -C Ii) im:~A\B9I':Jl!:ID!tJ:
,f-1:/ I- cli~*.Gn-CI,'tJ:I,', I...-t.:.t;>"?-C, y/
-y I- 7 - A 7- I- tJ :/ !J'~ J: 5 ~':liltA t.IJill'C~ iV 1,' t:.~':lim~(t~tJ:#ifflj~;m~, t;\iV 6 lift:. t. -t 61'.Nillili.:
-'tillili}!.',geJf~ ~rr tJ: .., -C 1,' 6 !f!:nv',iV 6, L t.:.tJ>"? -C ,
.: ~:N!~jjt~'11t i'I<lE(fre iV 6 ,l: 1i.13 I, 'I;>t.:. 1" J: 5 ~.:
mbn6,trL~~.li,ill~B9KJl!:ID!-CiV6,l:~
n6 ~*~{'-?J clic~J:5~.:t.tJ>~f;J:"?~
~~~6.:t.-ciV6J:5Kmbn6,
4.4 D-cO)I'iI-11 , tJntJnc~ill'CO)~IHJ;.l11
"7 - """ 7- (i, llilYclihnbn t.I"J L:i'l-*~ {, -? t.
• 24 •
~.~~b~~~. rbhbhJ ~M*~t0=t
t. /li;)'CV;M*~t0=to);5~·t':K_i:t:k~tJ:;n>;~·
V;;5~o)'1.'i:ttJ:~·v·t~·">litftf);;5~o 1f. lJil9c.
f:t ;J: t.: r v- U '1.' i:tfJ: <. 1 t.:.. TVt:lll: L- t.:. O)"b 0)
rV-u tl:tjjlJ-'1.'I:tfJ:~·t~~Jlt'I'IJv;;5~ot.:.t
;tit. 7'1"Tco-I:t. lJil)V:t;J:t':{.'I'fJf.5illb~rrtJ:'"
-C:io Gf. -thry;t V- t 0) jjlJ-i'l (personal identi
ty) 0)~f\l1~7liJt.:. L- n·tJ:~' ttliiWli L- -C~.~ (McIn
erney,1990)0 L-t.:.v;..,-C. lJil)'Cv',t ..,-C~.~ t t>
h~M*I:t. -to)/li;~~~:Ill:L-kM.~C~v-to)
M* t jjlJ C t o)-C'(.:ttJ:~' t ~~o ;J: t.:. 7" 7" :/ l:t.
rbhbhJ ~ r bt.:. L-J t i:t{,·~ t .., t':'f?tE~
(minded being) '1.';5.., -C. -to);$:'!'ti:t#f*-C-i:tfJ:
< %!:I,I,X'1.';5 I). U.:.v;.., -C rbt.:. L-J O)f:t C 1 'J i:t
rbt.:. L-J v;~· ~ 1ifj!\H*v'·%!:I,I,X~ t "bi:t CObt.:.II!t,\'i.
'1.';5~t:t.~~ (McMahan,2002)0 L-t.:.f);..,-C.
j,'tJ: < t t fJJJ!IlO)2fM<<f'ti'li:t;1l):A J: 'J IHs L- -':>~2f
I;:/!;(-C~'~o "k1;:;5Vft.:.'.//", c 7-A? C o:/f/
t. bhbho)J:">~-~O)~:Ill:~~~~L-.-~
O)%!:I,I,X••~-t~;tk~~*I:t••;5~M*~t..,
n·~ t~..,-CH'J:? I;:.'~,bh~v\ fJJWIO)IJil)'C
iiH.:IitI,l,X••~t ..,n·tJ:~·o ;J:t':-m't t ..,t.:.
= to)tJ:~·tO)~9i:? =tl:t'1.'~tJ:~·t':-':> "> t~~o
7 - '1"? 0) illllr,fi1; I;: t.:. ~.~ ~ = h G O)J.R!li!tt:ii*I:t1i$
1JrtJt':v\ rbhbhJ U:tcA,tJ:r-f~'1.';5~v't
~ • "> 'fg'jtrtJl;:~F11'; l;:rnlliE tJ: PJJlIH~.g Iv '1.' ~. ~ = t v;
'f'tR t> h ~ t.: -':> "> 0 0"," 0) rAIMJ9;1J1g:ifni~ ~ to ~
-A 0) rAIMJ;$:l1ifniJ I;:l!ll~ t"b. mf-l::-C'I:t/, - 7
~ "' r (Parfit, 1971) I;:P:r,~ge~ ~ V- t 0) Jj1J-11O)Pn911H 1;:1*1 L- -C 1:t'fg'jtrtJl;:j','j\ It tJ:.lLJtJ v',iiJilli-C';5 ..,
-C. =='1.'I:tt-51I;:m?=tl:t'1.'~tJ:~'o
L- v' L- 7 - '1"?' 0)~r,(iU"0)~!1'J!1;: 0~' -C ~. < 0 v'
:J;l:/ c L--C:io< = tl;:~Qo 1flli:'Jl!tJ:0)1:t. 7
-'1"?O)~ifni-tO)tO)f:t~fL-t rv-tJ~-tO)jjlJ
-110)1IJ'tftl;:m;tv'~-CIH·tJ:~< t'1.';5Qo 7-
'1"?O)~ifni~~'Jl!~o)i:trV-tJ~:t~<~L--':> r.
(i!iO);5Qj;r-*J -C';5Qo L-t.:.I/'",-C. tIU),< tJ:1v
GV·O)~~*v;:bh:bh t /i'iJ C J: "> t"tJ:/v G1)·0).
(i!i;5QM*~ t .., n· ~ t :t'lK-C' ~ hlt~ifnil:tllli:.lL
~Qo
;J:k. 7-'1"?O)illllifnil:t. /li;~~O)~O)rv-tJ
t jjlJ-O)~~'1.';5 Q =t t liljr~ L- -C ~. t",'o /1( 0) J:
? tJ:,~.~:'Ji!.~ L- -C;l,o. J: "> 0 ;5QAfF'j1=jllo;:J:..,-C
jjGte:~;J: .., t.:. < 9i:.., -C L- 1 ~', -t O)M.. 7" 7 /.
:/~ './ / "' r 7 - A ? r 0 :/ f/ V;:tP.~ L- -C ~. Q J: ">
~%!:~'1.'O)v-tO)jjlJ-I1~9i:..,-CL-;J:..,kt~Qo
GtJ· L- -t 0) V- t f/·-t O)U!f,.2, '1.'. Ei 51O)j;r-*O)~f.5I;:.(OCiV;;5 Q t !&.IO Q 0)'1.';5hlt. ~I:t 'J -to)~f.51;:
l:tfilliIOCif);;5QJ: ?1;:,~l:bhQ"o L-t.:.I;;..,-C. v-t
0) rjjlJ-I1J t7-'1"?0)~ifniKf:t~fL-t~.'1.'
i:tt,,~·I;'t L-ht,,~·o
=O)J:?~. rv-tJ t-tO)jjlJ-I1~IO~~illllifni
f:t 'fg'*"(J91;:i1iE U'o r;5 Q ¥.f~ 0) V- t 'J 0) V- t J '1.'
;5 ~ = t i:t cO) J: ? tJ: = t 1;' t ~. "> i1iE1~9~fii7lrJ<~ ~
<!Z•• v";5 Qo 1980if.f1:0) /, - 7 ~ "' r O):kln! rJ![
~tA.JU•• ~<O)'fg'jt*~J:~-CM.~~~
~••~=t~~t>h-C:io'J. 7-'1"?K~~L--C
UM<'Ni'lI:tJriWrtJl;:f.'f~'1.'~ Q t:t. L- J: "> t ~Q
y "'7 IviJj'cO)'fg'jt:j\;-I:t. j,·t" < t t. = 0) j!(Wa O)m
~~ J![fii7I-;- Q <!Z,'Jl! 1;;;5 Q0
4.5 *¥*O)ft!ljfili
jjlJ:f!fil;:11I'jt(tJ tJ:rnlliE~.g Iv '1.'IH' Q 1;\ 7 - '1"?
O)~ifni~J.R.~Q~'1.'J:'J'./:/~~~o)l:tr••;5
Qj;r-*J v'·tJ:-lffillifiilv";5Qo)f)'1;:0~'-C. 7-'1"?
O)~.ti:t~o).'1.'.;t. -t=I;'GA~;1l):~;:t~
tJ:-lf/fIE '1.';5 Q 0) v'l;:"n· -C lJl] 0)~JWI~l*ffl~ Q ;:
t'1.';5~t,~.bhQo =~GfH?j,'L-jj$L-<~-C
:io~t.:.~·o
7' - co:/ (Boonin, 2003) l:t. /V.: * ~ t t.:. tJ: ~·fJJ
lllIO)IJil)'CI;;H*~ t -::> t L- -C t. H':1'ok* IH ..,-C
~.t,,~,O)'1.'. -to)H*f:t-tO)IJil)'CI;:t ..,-C;J:t.:. r.
fi!i;5~J to)-C'I:ttJ:~·tJ.R.LJ:?t L--C\"Qo ;:
=~;5Qo)f:t. :bh:bhf:t••~;5Qto)~/V.:*~
Q 0) f)'. /V.:*~Q 1;' G -t O)/V.:;]( O»)(aU;: (iffi(ffi[I;;;5 Q
0) v'b' "> i1iEr~9-C';5 Qo 7 - '1"? v":io -t G < bh:b
hf:t••~;5~I;'G~~/V.:*~Qo)'1.';5Qt~;tQ
o)l;:~L-';). ~-co :/f;t:bh:bhl;"~~/V.:*~QI;'
G;: -t~I;:(ilfi(i!if/';57.> O)t.: t"T Qo
rfmilOCi;5 QH*J t ~·bh Q ~1.g.O)j;r-*O)filfifi1if:t.
~;$:I¥JI;:-tO)~A (;5~ H:t~O)1'fmlf*) I;: t ..,-C
0) (ilfi(i!i'1.';5 Q0 t = -':> '1.'. filfi(OCi l:t~tmrtJjl1:?r-I;::'Ji!1E
~Qto)'1.'f:t~<. :bh:bh~%!:I,I,X~J:..,-C~.~
lll:W L -C ~. Q b 0) -C';5 Q (;: 0) J: ? tJ:.lL~'if:t;l }l iIfu
• 25 •
llli~1:(J)~H:\±i1J(~W€W.~:tEilliii c P¥litL. ;<" ifilIllli
~(J)±lifEz-7r%Ii:L"(I,'Q)0 U-:b'..,-c, ~_Me:c
..,~(J)~*(J)••lt. ~A(J)B.~.~'17~O
:; '" !7 l- c 1,' .., t-: lj, (J) fe:WfJl ~ tL Q -: c fUJ: Q0 't
n.g,;t, ;l' t.:&,\Y!:Z- lj, t-: tJ:1, 'KlIIJlli! ~IJa}I'.Ie:ltbtLb
M'il L. .{iirih Q~*lttJ:I,'c ~:t GtL Q0 -: (J)jjt'i'lj
~. 7-~~(J)~illiii't(J)~(J)c~.~"~r~cJ
(J)\JJI;~IUtrJf:t ~ 1,' tJ:l,< <!:Ie: lj, tt~ L ~.:I: L 1,'0
~~. j;J1:(J):lL~z-ctL.i. 7-~Afe:jjZL~,
(2 't'hVft-:) 7E(J)ilf.~~1JI:A(J)~jf~Ie:01,·~(J)
~*~Z-CQCC~~Q00;l'9.1JI:A~~jf't'h
Q(J)lt, f1Iii!l~(J)1=. e- ~lTt-: 1,' c 1,' ; ~;Jae:jjZTQ
b·G't'hQo~lt-:(J)~.(J)~~7-~~(J)~.1
9 lj, ~ :/ 7' I~'t';l' t-: ~ l- 1/ - l- 't':i/!;;l' L 1,' lj, (J) fe:,'B
btLQ o
)'f;fe:~t-:l; Ie:, 7-~~b'~*~z-1*Jfl LtJ:I,'
(J)lt, 'ttL 't'lt(I)ttllifj~1il\(J),\!).~"~, (2); 0Wl't'7E
z-:i/!;A.,'t'I,'Q'i1f$z-7EtJ:-ltQ C c b,~jf't'hQ -: c
z-~IJJJ C' e- tJ:I,' c ~-;t GtL t-:b' GC'h Q0 t-: U'Ie:
E-~ G (J)?" - ~ 't' lj" 't (J)~Alt~e- ~lTt-: 1,' c 1,'
; ~*z-9<:.., ~ 1,' Qb\ 't tL ~'lj, ~ft 9 7EtJ:-lt Q -:
c ft~jfle:,'!I.btL Qo
'ttLC'ft~*~'t'~*~~1:(J)?"-~z-~IJJJC'e
tJ:I,'t':6; b·o ;G'=r-f."(' L <~~ ;;,;.t-:I,'o ~*~IU"
1,'~ It. i1!!fAlB'JIe:1ll:~C'h Q C;;,;. tJ: ~ tL QbtLhh
(J)~*(J)I:I:c A., Eft. ,!jHe:~.~h ~I,' Q~*'t'lt
tJ: <, (IjI1cJ c L ~(J)~* (dispositional desire) C'
h Q C 1,' ; ..ii. C' h Q (Boon;n, 2(03) 0 t-: c ;tli,
btLbhlt B'ii';1=.f.5 IU" I, ,~ jUri¥.- r1=. e- ~lTt-: I,.J
c ~.TQ -: C Itlt>.., t-: Ie: tJ: I, '0 r1=. e- ,wllTt-:1,' b.J
C~lb~~tLt-: 9 I3r"~ L ~;;,;.t-: IJ U-: c e-Ie:. hM'
It1=.{,lf(J)fG;mHe:~U-: c e-Ie:~. ~ tL Gt':ITC'h..,
~, il!!(J)liiliYfiC'lt~.~tLtJ:I,·(ljlIoJC L~ 't ; 1,. ;
~*z- lj, .., ~I,' Q fe:T e--tJ:1, '0 Lb- U':b-G c 1"..,
~bhbtLb'~e-~lTt-:1,' c 1,. ; ~;j(z- lj, .., ~ 1" tJ:
l,'blTC'lttJ:I,'o (IjIlcJc L~(J)i'J,:;j(cltC(J).t "lIe:
't\t1~lJ~tLt-:c e-(J) (llJl:t':!B'JtJ:) :)§:c tJ:Q lj,(J)~'hQo
lj,L-:"lLk(ljllcJcL~(J)~*-:'t~1ll:~~(J)C'
h Q c TtL Ii. IliI!lrm~t}lliI!(J)tb~lI1!ltlX(J) 1 ; 1e:~1JJJ
~tLQo ttllil!~W.Ie:hQ~C lj" lj, L~.;/)\hMJ:
G~r1~~J t:)§::tQC'h6;t ••C'e-Q(J)C'
htL~, (IjIlcJcL~(J)~*tL~~e-~ITQ~*z-
lj, .., n, Q t I,':t Q0 't tL.g,:t ttllil! L~ 1,' QA z-1&
T -: c lj, 't (J) A (J)~;j( le:jjZ L~ 1,' Q;/)\.g,:t fe:~jf C'
hQtTQ-: t;/)\C'e-Q o U-:;/)''''~' ~*m~'lj,
ttllil!~W.(J)~cZ-7E~-ltQct(J)~jf~~~IJJJC'e
tJ:\, 'b 1TC'lttJ:I, '0
'ttL't'lt, ;0~W.(J)W$(J)?"-~ltE;~6;
;/)'0 ~r.ili (J)1: ~'lj, ; -0<i6,igi tJ: (J) It. i1!!f@B'J~ID:~
c~tLQ«e-~*lt.m~~illiiillli~jjZLk~~llli~
lj, (J)'t'h.., ~ IttJ: G tJ:I,' t 1,'; ~i4'C'hQo 4l+~Ie:
;l' ..,t-: < lj, t-:5\,'~I"tJ:I,,~;j(~illiiillliEt',jIe:ilMLLt-:
~*~ilif@B'J~m~~~~t.;tQ(J)~~'tG<~
~llli't'hQo~llliB'J~m~i1!!f@B'J~m~.TQ(J)
It. 't; U-:~~J'dli1H)F~U-:~*(J)ltfC'hQ
(Brandt, 1979)0 i1!!fAlfI91e:1ll:~tJ:(J)ft, ; 0~11!\C'
7Ez-:i/!;A., ~'I,. Ql~r~p z-7E tJ:-lt Q (J)tJ\~jf tJ: (J)ft, 't
; U-: (7Ez-:i/!;tst I"..,t-:) ~*ft-AlHe:-I1!ji¥JtJ:
~*hQ Ht~'t<:;EtJ:ti'I!JYJle: lj, c -:51,'k~~lllitJ:~
*C'h9, 't;Lk~*z-.kTCt~ft-.~.
{f[[b·-tJ:l"tJ·i?~·hQo ~ Gle:. I3ff'J-'H3l:I*lffile:lj,
tt 13 T Q« ~ C'h Qo mfi;/)';/)\ 13 7t(J)1Ez-:i/!;A., C'I,' Q
t L~ lj" t-:l"n'(J)j~1~ftl3;,)-(J)7E't(J) lj, (J) lj, (J)
~'lttJ: < 'is'1i\'i ~lIftli!i;/)· G (J)!9'IWcz-:i/!;A., 't'1,' Q Ie:T e-
tJ: 1,'7E It~'t<:;E tJ:1j'I!JYJle: .t .., ~~lt> GtL~ L ;l' .., t-:
tlJ.!Iffl0'i1.:t t-: =H3l:Ie:T e--tJ:I,' (J) C'lt tJ:I,';/). t ,'!I,btL
Qo U.:;/)'..,~~'tG <. 'f!&c L~7Ez-~*TQ
C t It~~j!JltJ:Jj;j~;/)\*~eC'h6; 0
.{iiric~*(J)llIl{;f,Ie:01,'~ -:; U-:i\F!r,~;/)\jf1..-\"
~lcJfe:hQ c TtLli, ttllifj~11!\(J),\!).~~;0Wl(J)'Ff
$(J)?" - ~ Z-JlJl, ·t-: 7 - ~ ~ (J)7E(J)~ ~ Ie:01,'~ (J)
~*mz-iJ!IT.t; cTQr,!lif,;lt'ttLl:l:E2liI,·lj,(J)C'
IttJ:1, '0 {I!! Ie: lj, ~r.ili LtJ:lTtLlttJ: i? tJ:I,' ,<!i.ltf,(3'- <
tJt~ tLn, Qb\ ~*mftfilliiiiric ~*(J)r':l(J)WjJ'UJ:
.ffiz-~IJJJC'~QA't'tsL67-~~(J)M.m.t9
lj,:i/!;;l' L 1,' lj, me: ,'!I.btl Qo
~:/~~'t'2li~~7-~~(J)jjZU.~M(J)~if,;~
'<t L ~, ~ -< 7 Iv (J)~~Ie:~ "t-: 1,' t ~:t QliJf:1t~
~7-~~(J)~:/~~~i\F!if,;z-~A.,G;/)·(J)B't'~.
TQ~~~hQo~~~7-~~(J)r.iliX (t'tnz
~ 71 l- Lt-:lj,(J) It1990$5fUJ'Glt1=.{,lf{filIllli~·
lGmiifuJ1dl~(J)7 :/ '/ 0 ;,'-Ie:liffi\;;,;.i2;;l' tLQ C t ;/)\-
• 26 •
·~K~0d).••~.K~~k~~~~K~.~
<O)~~~fFBXtJ;t±ft.}ln -CV'Qo
~ni~~k15K7-~A~~~K~L~~R
~f;t\,' < ":)b'iiJfjg~h;;'o I:: < K.4.41::4.5~h~t-.:
.~~.~~~k~~I~b'~0~m~R~K~05
;;, I::.'i!:.:bn;;,o LiJ'L~nGIH"'I::~~iIi~IITJ-t't
K.!>llT ;;, Tf[OJ.:J:~ltfEr"~~, 1iIIi([i I:: li!oJ<~ !>lli,%IC":) l '
~ ~:' }l ffitlJmOJ.:J:~ltfEll,~~1J;Iv ~l' ~m.tJ(~·f~i*:iE
~t,t: ~ ~ I:: I~ ~ l 'b:t-.: <, flljijj.lca~~iiib:tJ:j~-'t 5
ICt,t:l'o i t-':3~~'P;IC ,-,,:/ 7'I"t,t:7-~ A~~~~R
Rt";;, t-.:It.JIC. j,jEfb' ~ ~'m*t,t:Jm~iii~t,t:tJ:tlM"IZ,
Jt}! fC t,t: ;;, .¢.', ~ ~WB ~h ;;, 0
~ t,~A, 7 - ~.A ~W!~iiib:l' i t':-~ L ~~::tJt':
b'G I:: l''J~. t-.:t.:t,lckf~rN;{'lICl ~ Jii!iLl'~~
tdl1.1!iljHl!lT'" ~ t.: I:: l' 5 ~ I:: ICltf,t: 10, t,t:l '0 m.~
~KaU~~M~Jii!iL<.~T;;'~I::I~§*~aQ
~~m~~kGT~~50.~~a~~·~R~~
W!~I::~.~~W!~~.IITJ#n;;,a~~h;;,~~tt
mT;;''''~~h;;'o LiJ'L. ~·t,t:< I:: ~~ft1E,,"lckf
~~M~~BT;;'klt.J~Tf[OJ.:~.~I~i~i~~Jt}!
I:: #nn,;;,o H-.:. kH",~M~r"~Ji'lj1~. {t!J~~ffl
~.~~kGT.Jm~M.~~~Gf. ~.~.*
a~~oo~~.Jm~M.I::~~.T;;'~~~1J;~~
iIi.JmOJ.:~~*~M.~h;;'o .~~~W!~~Jm~
~kIt.JK~~~~kIt.JK~7~77-c#n. ik
~~#n;;''''~~h~51::~:bn;;,0
(;1)--------------
1lilf'J "ltiE L. <P1Wl '" tt _C,. tH':t; 'ttttl·'" ;; .:. I: ,.:....",_c
'tiI <:l (2007) ,,~lft L.tc.
ii) 1lilf'J,,'tT5ti1 Il '" tt_c,. t<e 'fJ\ !iE!l!<9'1i'!1.:.1l'...,h;; r("
I:J~.*~~MI:L._C,t~-U-~~~19~~.~~~
~ ~ ~1J fJ;J1;. <11: H"Att I?tt~.i'li!t.JfJ·'''';;,
iii) OO~~~1LfiLlf~'iff-llr~~-y'i~~J K~~~~
.",tt;;':'I:~.;;~, iE~K~.~~~ft~ltrDI:J ~
.*,~,t ""~ c fRl!I\ L. t. H;!Jf'J3'.!1l1"'" o. i tcll1M\"'Ii'!~
%.,,~"3'..,t8~.t.J~~~".01:.htto~, *~
,,~j;IliN U.'·,iv) 1<~ll?tt_c'·;;15'~. ~ >-U-'t.:.~I~JIill~. lIiot
~.L.~j£.re"'tto~.~.,,0.:.1:~.~_CL.1l'5.:.I:K
1?_cWle~L.15I:T;;fJ\ 11:H"Attl?ilt.'·I:~x.o'"'o\\;·
,t~", ~. ~~~'t~-A"t'''';;o
v) •••'t~~~~~-~~v.~1?r~~."'J ~•• I:
L. _c 't3'.iilt~ 'Itx.;j ~-...,"t'''';;. ~~. '" ,~...". _c ~-¥I~
A 9 -'(>THil", t L. _C Nagel (1979) :t; 1 V' Singer (993) til
4 f,l:~1$J¥.l.-lt 1.
vi) r!l'J~~.J r/i!(;lliiiI.J :t;lU' rillli'!.J ~{,lli',~7-~~'~
1 ;; ~ ~"t'.O. Marquis (1989). p.195.
I'ii) ~-"'~,t.;r-8'J'~f1;;t....,_C'·t.,·fJ\ t L.fJ'L.tcl? 1
9*"H*~~ ?_C,.;;~"t'. 'f.~,·td~A~*'tT':'1: 19
~'fiEl: ",x.efx.ofj·~L.ttt.h
,iii) r~Mt1liJ ItA1.MI~t.l!il*,,'H.'·t "''';;fJ\ ~~t1lifJ;iiIi:
iL L. _C";;':'I: ~c~ 1 5'~ "jf;;H'!<B-'j'~) ftOiETo~tJ·1:
" ? ~IJ ~lllJlillfJ;!t t.: ;;
ix) A!t~{ilij{i"'~..."._c ~l\!~~ft~I':' ...". _C hfJ. 9 ~"T"1ll
irl: ~?jf,t Parli' (1984) ~W-1 0
x) ~~L., ~~.2~...,t...,~01:.~~ill.8'JK'fj£~.:.
I: "t'''' 0 .:. I: ~T5l",~.[lJJ"t' t t. < t.;; fJ' ~ L.tt t.,·
xi) ~?I:t, ~-"'~~!1',t.:.~,o!i,'~...,,·_CI»Jl?fJ.td!1!I£~
~{.T0':' t ~il!!H"_C ,.;;.
xii) Kuhse and Singer (]999). Bonnin (2005), Timmons (2007)
(*Jffi%il!)-------------
Bunnin, David (ZOO;{) A Defellse of Abortion. Cambridge Univer
sity Press.
Boonin. David and Graham Odie (eds.) (2005) What's Wrong?:
Ap/J!ied Ethicists and Their Critics, Oxford University Press.
Brandt. R.B. (1979) A Theory vf the Good and the Right, Claren-
dOll Press.
Cudd. Ann E. (1990) "Sensationalized Philosophy: A Reply to
Marquis's "Why Abortion is Immoral" ," Thejvltmal oj Philoso
phy. Vo1.87. No.5. pp.26Z-264.
Kuhsc. Helga and Peter Singer (I 999) . Bive/hies: A11 Anthology,
Blackwell.
Marquis. Don (989) "Why Abortion 15 Immoral." Thejo/lmal of
PJlilosophy, Vo1.86, No.4.
Mcinerney, Peter K. (1990) "Does a Fetus Already Have a Fu
ture-Like-Ours?" journal of Philosophy. Vat87.
McMahan. Jeff (2002) The Ethics of Killi1lg: Problems at the Mar
gi1ls of Life, Oxford University Press.
Nagel, Thomas (1979) "Death," in Mortal (Juesli01ls, Cambridge
University Press. (to "7.7. • .;(. - 7' II.- r:J '/ --l;- I) -C' tV;:' cIt c.'
• 27 •
UH? t,,,- i:b'J, 7k!FJ!llR, IYJ1,'il'JlJI, 1989)0
Noonan. John T .• Jr. (1970) "An Almost Absolute Value in His
tory," in The Morality ofAbortion: Legal aud Historical Perspec
tives, Harvard University Press.
Norcross. Alastair (1990) "Killing. Abortion. and Contraception:
A Reply to Marquis." jOltmal of Pizilosophy, Val.S?, No.5.
Parfit. Derek (1971) "Personal Identity," The Philosophical Re·
view, Vo1.80. No.1.
-- (19&0 "What Makes Someone's Life Go Best." in Reosot's
alld Persons. Oxford Universit)' Press. ('7 t,.;? • r~ - 7 .f '7
" rJillEb i:AIlI ; .~AIlIM;U)!fIJ!Il""J, l!littiffilR, !YJl,~ TlJ,
1998)0
Singer. Peter (I979) Practical Ethics. Cambridge University Press.
( ,,- !I - , '''' 1/-, rjl!~J<U)!fIJ!IlJ (l!l 11'.fD, UJ1"!1i:=flIl '
Jli!iltl'1'lR, II'lfOR;, 1991)0
-- (l99:·n Practical Ethics, Cambridge University Press, 2nd
edition. (e'-!l-' '''':!l-, r~~U)f$~JU frrli!i, IlJr'J1i:=
Jlil' J1j;/til'1'll<lR. 1I'l'fl1R;, 1999)0
Sinnou·Armstrong. Waller (997) "You Can't Lose What You
Ain't 'ever Had: A Reply to Marquis on Abortion." Phi/osop/II-.
col Studies, Vo1.96_
Strong, C (2008) "A critique of 'the best secular argument
against abortion'" ,joun/al ofMedical Ethics, Vo/.34. 2009.
Thomson. Judith Jarvis (1971) "A Defense of Abortion," Philoso·
phy & Pllblic Affairs. Vol.!. No.1.
Timmons. Mark ed_ (2007) Disputed Moral Issues: A Reader. Ox·
ford Universit)' Press.
Tooley. Michael (I972) "Abortion and Infanticide." Philosophy &
Public Affairs. Vo1.2, No, I.
Warren, Mary Anne (1973) "The Moral and Legal Status of
Abortion," The Monist. Vol.57.
i:IClIlll (~IJ07) rfjl I"! U)1'.1fIi !fIJ!Il'l"IU.It '" r,<- ~ "'illiJ U)'Ji:
~J, W!fUl:it?ilf~J, mlO'Fr, )iCml:!r'T#f:o
• 28 •