A Comparative Analysis between General Commercial Banks and Islamic Shariah Banks

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 8/18/2019 A Comparative Analysis between General Commercial Banks and Islamic Shariah Banks

    1/71

       a  l  y  s  i  s   b  e  t   w  e  e   n    G  e   n  e  r  a  l   C  o    m    m  e  r  c  i  a  l   B  a   n   k  s  a   n   d  I  s  l  a    m ic  

  • 8/18/2019 A Comparative Analysis between General Commercial Banks and Islamic Shariah Banks

    2/71

    1

    1

      Course Title: Project eport

      Course Code! B"S#$%

    Prepared To

    Leo Vashkor Dewri

     Lecturer 

    Department of Business

    Administration

    East West University

    Prepared By

    Saifu !sam

    !D: "##$%&%1&%#"'

    (a)or: Accountin*

    Sprin*+1,

  • 8/18/2019 A Comparative Analysis between General Commercial Banks and Islamic Shariah Banks

    3/71

    &

    1- Apri "#1,

    LeoVashkor Dewri

     Lecturer.

    Department of Business Administration

    East West University

    Dhaka/

    Su0)ect: e*ardin* Su0mission of BUS,$2 3ro)ect eport

    Dear Sir:

    With *reat peasure ! su0mit this pro)ect that ! have 0een assi*ned as an important re4uirement of 

    BBA pro*ram at East West University/ ! found the study to 0e 4uite interestin*. 0eneficia and

    knowed*e/ ! have tried my eve 0est to prepare an effective 5 credita0e report/

    6his pro)ect report is a0out 7A comparative financia anaysis 0etween *enera commercia 0ank 

    And !samishariah 0ank8/

    ! aso want to thank you for your support and patience with me and ! appreciate the opportunity

     provided 0y East West University to work on this wonderfu pro)ect report/

    Sincerey 9ours.

    Saifu !sam

    !D: "##$%&%1&%#"'

    (a)or: Accountin*

    Department of Business Administration

    East West University

    "

  • 8/18/2019 A Comparative Analysis between General Commercial Banks and Islamic Shariah Banks

    4/71

    '

    Acknowled(ement

    Assistance and cooperation of different peope in different sta*es of my pro)ect paper preparation

    heped me to add more 0eauties to the report/ 3reparin* this pro)ect a have worked a ot and

    went to different paces to coect data/ Without those peope hep it woud not have 0een

     possi0e for me to work on this pro)ect/ ! faced many pro0ems when started the work on report

     0ut ! am *reaty thankfu to Aah for ena0in* me to *et successfuy throu*h my

    responsi0iities/

    ! woud ike to thank (s/ Leo Vashkor Dewri who is my pro)ect advisor. heped me ot to prepare

    this pro)ect. time to time she advised me how to work on it/ Aso my cousin (r/ (ohammad Asif 

    who worked in Dhaka Stock Echan*e whose assistance priced me hu*e. thanks to that person

    too/ 6here are many peope who heped me; it is not possi0e to mention a the names thou*h !

    remem0er your hep/

    ! have prepared this report as an inte*ra part of BBA pro*ram Under the Business

    Administration department. East West University/ ! am hi*hy inde0ted to a num0er of person for 

    their kind advice. su**estions. directions and cooperation that have ena0ed me to prepare this

    report/

    ! am very *ratefu to my teacher for a his kind cooperation and *uideine in preparin* this

     paper/

    ! aso ike to thank the entire departmenta heads and stuff who heped me in various ways/ 6he

    mem0ers of the mana*ement of a the 0anks ! worked with were very co%operative and hepfu

    to me from top to 0ottom eve/

  • 8/18/2019 A Comparative Analysis between General Commercial Banks and Islamic Shariah Banks

    5/71

    #

    )*ecutive Summary

    6his pro)ect report is 0ased on my anaysis of financia statements of "##2. "##$. "#1#. "#11

    and "#1" of 3rime Bank Limited. Brac 0ank Limited. Dutch%Ban*a Bank Limited. !samic

    Bank. Shah)aa Bank. and A%Arafah !samic Bank Limited/ ! have done my anaysis mainy

    focusin* on the comparative anaysis 0etween these si Banks/ !n this period. ! have chosen three

    !samic and three =enera >ommercia Banks to done this performance >omparison/ !t was a

    *reat opportunity to know and *ather knowed*e different types of 0ankin* operations/ (y

    facuty supervisor heped me to choose the topic% 7Comparative analysis between General

    Commercial Banks and Islamic Shariah Banks8/ !n the new competitive 0usiness era. *enera

     0ankin* sector is *ettin* more competitive in Ban*adesh/ But it is aso true that. !samic

    Bankin* sector has drawn the attention of many in this competitive Bankin* !ndustry/

    6his paper focuses on the comprehensive comparison a0out the performance of *enera and

    !samic 0ankin* system operation in Ban*adesh/

  • 8/18/2019 A Comparative Analysis between General Commercial Banks and Islamic Shariah Banks

    6/71

    +

    had to anay?e and *ive si*nificant comments re*ardin* the chan*es in the financia position/

    Anaysis and interpretation of these financia statements throu*h ratio anaysis has now 0ecome

    an important techni4ue for performance appraisa 0ecause the investors. financia eperts.

    mana*ement eecutives and the 0ankers are aways rey on these ratios to make important

    decisions/ 6he mana*ement team of any 0ank. investor and the *overnment a*encies aways

    concern a0out i4uidity ratios and ade4uacy ratios of a 0ank which interprets the efficiency of a

     0ank/

    As a part of my B/B/A pro*ram. ! have spent three months 0y anay?in* the activities of these

    !samic and 6raditiona Banks/ ! have anay?ed the financia statements of these 0anks to find out

    its ratios 0y usin* its past records/ After preparin* this report ! came to know that anaysis of 

    financia statements throu*h ratios heps to overcome the past faws and make the future

    decisions and strate*ies/ 6herefore. it is very necessary for every or*ani?ation whether the

    company+s si?e is to make financia statement and to anay?e it 0y ratios/

    -

  • 8/18/2019 A Comparative Analysis between General Commercial Banks and Islamic Shariah Banks

    7/71

    ,

    Table of contents

    Topic Page no.

    Letter of Transmittal I

    Acknowledgement Ii

    Executive summary iii-iv

    Chapter 0

    1.1 Introduction 10-11

    .! "ackground of the study 11

    .# $%&ective of the report 11-12.' (cope of the pro&ect 12

    .) Limitation of the study 12

    .* +ethodology , data sources 13

      .*. -ata analysis 14

      .*.! Conceptual framework 15

      .*.# Theoretical ramework 

     

    16-18

      .*.) Population 18

      .*.* (ample 18

    Chapter 0!

    2.1 Literature Review 19-20

    Chapter 0#

    3.1 Overview of banking system of Bangladesh 21

    #.! /mpact of "anking /ndustry in the "angladesh

    economy

    21-22

    #.# Current (tructure of "ank  22-23

    #.' /slamic %anking 24

    #.) Comparison %etween /slamic %ank and general

    %ank 

    24

    @

  • 8/18/2019 A Comparative Analysis between General Commercial Banks and Islamic Shariah Banks

    8/71

    -

    Chapter 0'

     .1 Ratio analysis 25

    '.! Prota%ility ratio 26

      '.!. 1eturn on sales 26-29

      '.!.! 1eturn on asset 21$A3 28-29

      '.!.# 4et interest margin 29-31

      '.!.' 4et operating margin 30-32

      '.!.) Earnings per share2EP(3 32-34

    '.# Li5uidity ratios 34

      '.#. Current ratio2C13 35-36

      '.#.! Current asset ratio2CA13 36-37

      '.#.# Loan ratio 38-39

    '.' 1isk ratios 39  '.'. Credit risk  39

      '.'..Ttotal loans6 total deposits 40-41

      '.'.! /nterest rate risk ratio 41

      #.'.!. /nterest sensitive asset6 interest

    sensitive lia%ilities

    41-43

      '.'.# Price risk 43

      '.'.#. Price earnings ratio 43-45

    '.) E5uity ratio 46-47

    '.* $ther nancial ratios 47

      '.*. 1ate of return on loans 47-49  '.*.! Loan to asset ratio 49-51

      '.*.# total de%t to e5uity ratio 51-53

      '.*.' -e%t ratio 53-55

    Chapter 0)

     !1 "ndings of the #ro$ect at a glance 56

    ).! Performance indicator 57  ).!. Prota%ility 57

      ).!.! Li5uidity 58

      ).!.# 1isk  58-59

      ).!.' Capital Ade5uacy 59

      ).!.) $thers 59-60

    '

  • 8/18/2019 A Comparative Analysis between General Commercial Banks and Islamic Shariah Banks

    9/71

  • 8/18/2019 A Comparative Analysis between General Commercial Banks and Islamic Shariah Banks

    10/71

    $

     List of tables

    Ta%le

    no.Ta%le name Page no.

    0 (teps o& presenting ratio ana"ysis 14

    0! !urrent stru%ture o& 'an)ing system in

    *ang"a$es

    22-23

    0# !omparison o& genera" 'an)ing an$ Is"ami%

    'an)ing

    24

    0' Return on equity 260) Return on assets 28

    0* Net interest in%ome 29

    07 Net operating margin 31

    08 Earnings per sare 33

    09 !urrent ratio 35

    0 !urrent asset ratio 36

    "oan ratio 38

    !  #ota" "oan to tota" $eposit 40

    # Interest sensitive 42

    ' pri%e earnings ratio 44) Equity ratio 46

    * Rate o& return on "oans 48

    7 "oan to asset ratio 50

    8 tota" $e't to equity ratio 52

    9 $e't ratio 54

    $

  • 8/18/2019 A Comparative Analysis between General Commercial Banks and Islamic Shariah Banks

    11/71

    1.

    !0 +n$ings o& te pro,e%t at a g"an%e 56

    Chapter! .1

    1/1 Introduction

    Ban*adesh is the country where more than $# peope are (usim 3ew search

    ei*ion53u0ic Life 3ro)ect. "#11C/ / aturay. it remains a deep cry in their hearts to fashion

    1#

  • 8/18/2019 A Comparative Analysis between General Commercial Banks and Islamic Shariah Banks

    12/71

    11

    and desi*n their economic ives in accordance with the precepts of !sam/ 6herefore. with a view

    to provide !samic 0ankin* services at first !samic Bank Ban*adesh td was esta0ished 1$2&/

    Assi*nmentpoint/com. 1$$-C/ ow we have severa !samic Banks those are providin* different

     0ankin* services than that of *enera commercia 0ank/ !samic Bankin* has 0een *rowin*

    wordwide si*nificanty in the past three decades and is deveopin* remarka0y in the Southeast

    Asia. (idde East and even in Europe and in orth America/ Ban*adesh aso has this dua

     0ankin* system where !samic shariah Bank and *enera Bank 0anks are operatin* side 0y side/

    6he num0er of *enera commercia 0anks are more than the !samic Shariah 0anks. contri0utin*

    more in the economy/ 6he 0anks pay an important roe in the economy of the country/ Bankin*

    sector in Ban*adesh demonstrated a moderate eve of resiience in S activities and =reen Bankin* initiatives/

    (oreover. preparation of revised risk mana*ement *uideines is at fina sta*e/ 6he foowin*

     para*raphs hi*hi*ht the recent re*uatory and supervisory measures initiated 0y BB for 0anks.

    industry statistics and performance trends of the 0ankin* sector/ 6he contri0ution of 0ankin*

    sector to the =D3 of Ban*adesh is very impressive/ !n the

  • 8/18/2019 A Comparative Analysis between General Commercial Banks and Islamic Shariah Banks

    13/71

    1&

    theoretica knowed*e into the pro)ect work/ 6his pro)ect ena0es a student for deveopin* their 

    anaytica skis/ At the end of the day it refects what they earned throu*hout the pro*ram/

    1/' bjective o0 the project

    The primary objective!

    6he primary o0)ective of preparin* this report is to compare financia performance anaysis of

    =enera >ommercia Bank and !samic Shariah Banks. and to have a cear conception a0out a

    of the essentia parts of this pro)ect/

    Secondary objective!

     

    6o evauate the 3rofita0iity of these 0anks in a view to compare performance/

     

    >ompare the performance of these 0anks throu*h various financia ratios/

      Gverview of these Banks/

     

    6o identify the pro0em facin* 0y them/

     

    At east to reate theoretica knowed*e with practica eperience in severa functions of 

    these 0anks/

      6o show the compara0e areas of =enera >ommercia Bank and !samic Shariah Banks/

    6o know a0out the competiveness amon* the !samicshariah0anks of Ban*adesh in respect to

    the services provided 0y the =enera >ommercia Bank 0anks/

    1/# Scope o0 the project

    1"

  • 8/18/2019 A Comparative Analysis between General Commercial Banks and Islamic Shariah Banks

    14/71

    1'

    6he pro)ect covers the topic 7A >omparative anaysis0etween !samic Shariah Banks and

    =enera >ommercia Banks/8 6o conduct a study on this topic ! have *athered vaua0e

    information from EWU i0rary. 5 Dhaka stock echan*e i0rary/ ! have aso *ot some

    information from we0 sites that are reated to my topics/ ! have aso coected much information

    from Security Echan*e >ommission i0rary/

    1/+ 2imitation o0 the study

    Shorta(e o0 time period!

    ! had to compete this report writin* within a shorter period of time/ So the time constraint of the

    study hinderin* the course of vast area and time for preparin* a report within the mentioned period is reay difficut/

    2ack o0 su00icient well in0ormed o00icials!

    (any officias of the 0ranch are not we informed a0out some re4uired information/ ! had to

    face many difficuties to coect this information/

    1/, 3ethodolo(y 4 data sources

    Project desi(n!

    6his pro)ect report typicay focused on ratio anaysis 0ut there is some descriptive information

    too/ 6wo *enera commercia 0anks and two !samic shariah 0anks are taken to evauate the two

    different 0ankin* stye performances/

    5ata sources!

    6his report is prepared mainy on the etensive use of secondary data avaia0e in annua reports/

    Based on the data from the annua reports the overa pro)ect report is prepared/ 6he overa

    conceptua and theoretica framework has 0een epained as we as the how the data are

    anay?ed is epained 0eow:

    1&

  • 8/18/2019 A Comparative Analysis between General Commercial Banks and Islamic Shariah Banks

    15/71

  • 8/18/2019 A Comparative Analysis between General Commercial Banks and Islamic Shariah Banks

    16/71

    1+

    1/,/1 5ata analysis!

  • 8/18/2019 A Comparative Analysis between General Commercial Banks and Islamic Shariah Banks

    17/71

    1,

    1/,/& Conceptual 0ramework 

    1@

    apita

    atio

    Sovency

    atio

    Li4uidity

    atio

    3rofit ratio Gther

    ED!6  GE

    LA 

    >A 

    !6EES6GA

    3!>E 6DE !(

    LD 

     G( DE 

    E3S

  • 8/18/2019 A Comparative Analysis between General Commercial Banks and Islamic Shariah Banks

    18/71

    1-

    1/,/' Theoretical 8ramework 

    6he ratio anaysis invoves method of cacuatin* and interpretin* financia ratios to asses+ 0anks

     performance/ !n order to compare performance of !samic 0anks and =enera commercia 0anks

    for the period of "##2%"#1" the study uses inter%0ank anaysis/ 6he study evauates inter%0ank 

    financia performance of !samic and =enera commercia 0anks in term of profita0iity. i4uidity.

    risk. capita ade4uacy. and others efficiency/ apita GEC J et !ncome 6ota E4uity >apita

    o eturn on Assets GAC J et !ncome 6ota Assets

    o  et !nterest (ar*in !(C J K!nterest !ncome%!nterest EpenseC 6ota Assets

    o  et Gperatin* (ar*in G(C J et Gperatin* evenues 6ota Assetso Earnin*s 3er Share E3SC J et !ncome >ommon E4uity Shares Gutstandin*

      2i9uidity atios

    Li4uidity ratios measure the 0ank a0iity to meet its short%term o0i*ations/ Banks face i4uidity

     pro0em due to ecess withdrawa from current and savin* account eadyratios/com. "##1C/

    6here are severa measures of i4uidity/ Li4uidity position of 0anks is measured 0y usin* four 

    foowin* ratios/o >urrent atio >C J >ash and account with 0anks6ota deposits

    o  >urrent Asset atio >AC J >urrent asset 6ota asset

    o  Loan Deposit atio LDC J Loans Deposits

    1'

  • 8/18/2019 A Comparative Analysis between General Commercial Banks and Islamic Shariah Banks

    19/71

    1%

    isk atios

    isk to the mana*er of a financia institution or to a re*uator supervisin* a financia institution

    means the perceived uncertainty associated with a particuar event !nvestopedia/com. "###C/

    Bankers aways try to achieve the hi*h stock vaue and hi*h profita0iity/ !n this case. ! have

    chosen some vita risk that encountered daiy 0y financia institutions/ 6his are%

    a/ Credit isk :6he 3ro0a0iity that Some of the Bank+s Assets Wi Decine in Vaue and

    3erhaps Become Worthess/

    o 6ota Loans6ota Deposits

     0/ Interest ate isk 3easures! 6he Dan*er that Shiftin* !nterest ates (ay Adversey

    Affect a Bank+s et !ncome. the Vaue of its Assets or E4uity/

    o !nterest Sensitive Assets!nterest Sensitive Lia0iities

      >/ Price isk! (arket vaue ratios reate the o0serva0e market vaues ike the stock price with

    the 0ook vaues o0tained from the firmMs financia statements/

    o 3rice Earnin*s atio

    Capital Ade9uacy atios

    >apita ratios indicate the heathiness of financia institution to shock withstandin* osses

    !nvestopedia/com. "##"C/ 6hese ratios identify the aready eistin* 0ankin* pro0ems/ Adverse

    trends in these ratios may increase risk eposure and capita ade4uacy pro0ems/ 6his study

    focused on two foowin* >apita ratios/

    o E4uity atio J Sharehoder+s E4uity 6ota Assets

      ther 8inancial atios

    12

  • 8/18/2019 A Comparative Analysis between General Commercial Banks and Islamic Shariah Banks

    20/71

  • 8/18/2019 A Comparative Analysis between General Commercial Banks and Islamic Shariah Banks

    21/71

    &.

    Chapter .&

      !. L/TE1AT;1E 1E

  • 8/18/2019 A Comparative Analysis between General Commercial Banks and Islamic Shariah Banks

    22/71

    &1

    measured 0y the etent of its or*ani?ationa effectiveness/ !n the contet of services rendered

    towards pu0ic the performance of an or*ani?ation can 0e viewed as Nthe etent to which its work 

    is carried out within esta0ished specifications for *oods and services produced to the *enera

    satisfaction of the cientee served. within *iven cost and time constraints. and in such a manner

    as to support or contri0ute to the achievement of the or*ani?ation o0)ectives/

    Ber(er 4=umphery Fumhery. 1$$'C opinion that the measurement of performance of 0ankin*

    sector is that which represent the scenario of *ood and 0ad performance of 0ankin* sector a

    over the word/ By measurin* the performance a 0ank can resove the ackin* and perform 0etter

    in future/

    Bhattacharjee Bhattachar)ee. 1$2$C found that there are five different sets of productivity

    represent the five different dimensions/ 6hree sets of showin* the productivity measurement and

    the rest of the two showin* the risin* trend a0out the performance of a 0ank/ Bankin* Sector inBan*adesh to 0e associated with variations in poicies pertainin* to structure and processes as

    we as variations in deposit mi. credit mi and service packa*e offered 0y 0anks/ Each of these

    factors represented specific *roup of homo*enous productivity measures/ 6hey are empoyee

     productivity. a0or productivity etc/

    Chowdhury and Ahmed >howdhury. "##"C stated a0out the net income and the E3S of the

    seected private commercia 0anks have increased from the previous year durin* "##& to "##@ 0y

    conducted the research of the performance of the 0ankin* sectors/ Loans recovery rate indicated

    that the 0anks are a0e to mana*e their credit efficienty/

    Accordin( to ;cube cu0e. "##$C noticed that there are two 0road approaches to measure the

     performance of the 0ankin* sector and accountin* approaches/ 6his makes use of economic

    techni4ue and financia ratios/ 6raditionay accountin* methods primariy 0ased upon the use of

    financia ratios have 0een empoyed for assessin* 0ank performance/

    "1

  • 8/18/2019 A Comparative Analysis between General Commercial Banks and Islamic Shariah Banks

    23/71

    &&

    Chapter .'

    '/1 verview o0 bankin( system o0 Ban(ladesh

    6he financia system of Ban*adesh is comprised of three 0road fra*mented sectors:

    1/

  • 8/18/2019 A Comparative Analysis between General Commercial Banks and Islamic Shariah Banks

    24/71

    &'

    voume of non%performin* oans 3LsC/ ed Commercial "anks 24C"s31 (ona"i *an) 3 grani *an)

    2 anata *an) 4 Rupa"i *an)

    Private Commercial "anks 2PC"s3

    1u'a"i *an) 16"-ra&a Is"ami *an) t$

    2ttara *an) 17(o%ia" Investment *an) t$

    "&

  • 8/18/2019 A Comparative Analysis between General Commercial Banks and Islamic Shariah Banks

    25/71

    3Nationa" *an) t$ 18ut%-*ang"a *an) t$

    4#e !ity *an) t$ 19er%anti"e *an) t$

    5nite$ !ommer%ia" *an) t$ 20(tan$ar$ *an) t$

    6 ra' *ang"a$es *an) t$ 21:ne *an) t$

    7II! *an) t$ 22E;I *an)

    8Is"ami 'an) *ang"a$es t$ 23*ang"a$es !ommer%e *an) t$

    9" *ara)a *an) *ang"a$es t$ 24utua" #rust *an) t$

    10Eastern *an) t$ 25irst (e%urity *an) t$

    11N!! *an) t$ 26#e remier *an) t$

    12rime *an) t$ 27*an) sia t$

    13(out East *an) t$ 28#e #rust *an) t$

    14 a)a *an) t$ 29 (a a"a" *an) imite$

    15 I!* Is"ami% *an) 30 * *an)

    8orei(n Bank 

    1 meri%an E .#e

    *an)

    11 (ami"Is"ami *an) :& *arain E!

    6 Nationa" *an) o& a)istan 12 (tan$ar$ !artere$ *an)

    5evelopment Banks

    1*ang"a$es ?risi *an) 3 *ang"a$es (i"paRin(angsta

    *an)

    2Ra,sai?risinnayan *an) 4 *an) o& (ma"" In$ustries @

    !ommer%e *ang"a$es t$

    thers

    1 nsar A nnayan *an) 3 rameen *an)

    2 *ang"a$es (ama'ai *an) t$

    .*(*

    4 ?armasanstan *an)

    Table # 02: Current Structure of Banking System in Bangladesh.

    '/# Islamic bank 

    ",

    http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=ICB_Islamic_Bank&action=edit&redlink=1http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=AB_Bank&action=edit&redlink=1http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=AB_Bank&action=edit&redlink=1http://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=ICB_Islamic_Bank&action=edit&redlink=1

  • 8/18/2019 A Comparative Analysis between General Commercial Banks and Islamic Shariah Banks

    26/71

    &+

    !samic 0anks in the 0ankin* sector demonstrated a remarka0e *rowth in >911/ 6he epansion

    of the !samic Bankin* network was aso impressive/ As a proportion of the overa 0ankin*

    industry. the com0ined share of !samic 0anks. ecudin* !samic Bankin* Branches windows of 

    conventiona 0anks was found around 1@ percent in assets. 12 percent in investments. 1'percent

    in deposits. 1& percent in e4uity and 1@ percent in ia0iities as of end%Decem0er "#11 Ohan.

    "#1,C/

    '/+comparisons between Islamic bank and (eneral bank 

    ?eneral commercial %ank 

    ing

    /slamic "anking

    oney is a %ommo$ity 'esi$es

    me$ium o& e

  • 8/18/2019 A Comparative Analysis between General Commercial Banks and Islamic Shariah Banks

    27/71

    &,

    enera" %ommer%ia" 'an)s use

    money as a %ommo$ity /i%

    "ea$s to ination

    Is"ami% 'an)ing ten$s to %reate "in) /it

    te rea" se%tors o& te e%onomi% system

    'y using tra$e re"ate$ a%tivities (in%eB

    te money is "in)e$ /it te rea" assets

    tere&ore it %ontri'utes $ire%t"y in te

    e%onomi% $eve"opment

    Table # 0: Comparison of !eneral banking" slamic Banking.

    Chapter! .#

    #/1 atio analysis

    atio anaysis is a study of the reationships 0etween financia varia0es/ !t is very important in

    fundamenta anaysis which investi*ates the financia heath of any financia institution/ 6his

    ratio anaysis *ives frank financia information in this current 0usiness word/ By *ivin* a *ance

    anyone wi 0e a0e to know what the position that institution is in now/ 6herefore a

    stakehoders take interest in ratio anaysis/

  • 8/18/2019 A Comparative Analysis between General Commercial Banks and Islamic Shariah Banks

    28/71

    &-

    #/& Pro0itability ratios

    3rofita0iity atios measure the overa earnin*s performance of an institution and its efficiency

    in utii?in* assets. ia0iities and e4uity investopedia/com. "##"C/ 3rofita0iity  ratios show a

    companyMs overa efficiency and performance/ atios that show returns represent the firmMs

    a0iity to measure the overa efficiency of the firm in *eneratin* returns for its sharehoders/

    #/&/1 eturn on )9uity

    eturn on e4uity measures a 0ank+s profita0iity which cacuates how much net profit that 0ank 

    may *enerates with the money that sharehoders have invested as e4uity !nvestin*answers/com.

    "##-C/ 6he eturn on E4uity of a company measures the a0iity of the mana*ement of the

    company to *enerate ade4uate returns for the capita invested 0y the owners of a company/ 6he

  • 8/18/2019 A Comparative Analysis between General Commercial Banks and Islamic Shariah Banks

    29/71

    &%

    !'@  ""L!!.88

     

    9.9

     

    8.9)

     

    7.9

     

    ).'7

    *.87

      /"L 9 *.9# 9 7.'! #.9 7.!)

    (/"L !).)8 !). #0.7

    #.8

    7.0 !!.''

    A/"L

    !'.7

     

    !'.

     

    !0.0

     

    8.#'

     

    #.)

    !0.#

    Table # 0$: %eturn on &'uity.

     Interpretations:

    GE is very popuar ratio toward the sharehoders of any 0ank/ After doin* the anaysis on the

    si seected 0anks the industry avera*e comes at ",/

  • 8/18/2019 A Comparative Analysis between General Commercial Banks and Islamic Shariah Banks

    30/71

    &$

    0

    5

    10

    15

    2025

    30

    35

    40

    ut% 'ang"a 'an)

    prime 'an)

    *ra% 'an)

    Is"ami 'an)

    sa,"a" 'an)

    "-ra&aIs"ami 'an)

    Chart ( 01: %eturn on &'uity

    #/&/& eturn on Assets @A

    6he eturn on Assets of a company determines its a0iity to utii?e the assets empoyed in that

    company efficienty and effectivey to earn a *ood return !nvestopedia/com. "##,C/ eturn on

    assets measures the amount of profit that the company *enerates as a percenta*e of the vaue of 

    its tota assets/ A companyMs return on assets GAC is cacuated as the ratio of its net income in

    a *iven period to the tota vaue of its assets this ratio+s formua is%

    4ame of 

    "ank 

    !008

    2@3

    !009

    2@3

    !00

    2@3

    !0

    2@3

    !0!

    2@3

    Avera

    ge

    2@3

    /ndust

    ry

    Avera

    "$

     

  • 8/18/2019 A Comparative Analysis between General Commercial Banks and Islamic Shariah Banks

    31/71

    '.

    ge

     

    -""L

    .)0 .*0 !.!0 .90 .70 .78

    !.'0

    @

      P"L .#0 !.#7 !.* !.07 !.0 .98

      ""L

    .*'

     

    .)*

     

    .))

     

    .#*

     

    0.#)

    .!9

      /"L .!7 .#' .'7 .#) .!7 .#'

     

    (/"L

    !.!* !.07 #.0 .!* .'' !

      A/"L

    .80

     

    .77

     

    !.*)

     

    !.0*

     

    .#

    .9!

    Table # 0): %eturn on *ssets. Interpretations:

    atio Anaysis for the eturn on Assets of seected si 0anks shows those in years "##2.

    "##$."#1#. "#11. and "#1" the avera*e return from 1## taka invested is assets is respectivey

    1/'2. 1/$2. 1/"$. 1/&,. ". and 1/$" respectivey for the Banks% DBBL. 3BL. BBL.

    !BL. SF!BL and A!BL; and there avera*e is "/,#/ 6he hi*her the percenta*e is the 0etter for 

    the 0ank+s asset *rowth/ So we can say that !>B! !>B !samic BankC an !samic Bank without

    any dou0t is in the 0est position compare to these other 0anks in respect to return on assets/ 6he

     positions return on e4uity is shown in a *raph 0eow:

  • 8/18/2019 A Comparative Analysis between General Commercial Banks and Islamic Shariah Banks

    32/71

    '1

    0

    05

    1

    15

    2

    25

    3

    35

    ut% 'ang"a 'an)

    prime 'an)

    *ra% 'an)

    Is"ami 'an)

    sa,"a" 'an)

    "-ra&aIs"ami 'an)

    Chart ( 02: %eturn on *ssets.

    #/&/' ;et Interest 3ar(in @;I3

     et interest mar*in !(C is a measure of the difference 0etween the interest income *enerated

     0y 0anks or other financia institutions and the amount of interest paid out to their enders for 

    eampe. depositsC. reative to the amount of their interest%earnin*C assets Answers/com. "##'C/

    !t is simiar to the *ross mar*in of non%financia companies/

    4ame of 

    "ank 

    !008

    2@3

    !009

    2@3

    !00

    2@3

    !0

    2@3

    !0!

    2@3

    Avera

    ge

    2@3

    /ndustr

    y

    Averag

    e

    -""L #.# !.90 '.0 '.90 '.#8 #.9!

    !.'#

    @

    P"L !.!8 !.# #.'9 !.* !.)! !.*'

    ""L

    !.'*

     

    !.##

     

    .97

    !.*7 !.0 !.)*

    /"L '.0 #.7 #.8# '.!9 #.#9 #.8)

    &1

    ;et Interest 3ar(in @;I3 D@Interest Income?Interest )*pense Total

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Interesthttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Interest

  • 8/18/2019 A Comparative Analysis between General Commercial Banks and Islamic Shariah Banks

    33/71

    '&

    (/"L #.9 !.8* !.9! #.'! #.## #.!9

    A/"L 0.79 0.8

    !.)

    0.!9 .0# .'

    Table # 0+: ,et nterest ncome.

     Interpretations:

    As the net interest mar*in measures how ar*e a spread 0etween interest revenues and interest

    epenses mana*ement has 0een a0e to achieve 0y cose contro over earnin* assets and pursuit

    of the cheapest source of fundin*. thus from the a0ove cacuation we can definitey say that

    Dutch%Ban*a Bank imited is in the 0est position in terms of the net interest mar*in comparin*

    with other five 0anks/ DBBLhas a net interest ratio of &/$" whereas the industry avera*e of 

    these 0anks is "/,&/ 6wo !samic 0anks are havin* simiar type of percenta*es i/e/ &/2- and

    &/"$ . on the other hand 3rime Bank Limited is havin* a percenta*e of "/@,/

    0

    051

    15

    2

    25

    3

    35

    4

    45

    5

    ut% 'ang"a 'an)

    prime 'an)

    *ra% 'an)

    Is"ami 'an)

    sa,"a" 'an)

    "-ra&aIs"ami 'an)

    Chart ( 0: ,et nterest -argin.

    #/&/# ;et peratin( 3ar(in @;3

    &"

  • 8/18/2019 A Comparative Analysis between General Commercial Banks and Islamic Shariah Banks

    34/71

    ''

    6his ratio says how effectivey mana*ement is runnin* its operations 0y usin* assets to *enerate

    income and epenses !nvestopedia/com. 1$$$C/ A companyMs operatin* income after operatin*

    epenses are deducted. 0ut 0efore income taes and interest are deducted/ 6he formua is%

    4ame of 

    "ank 

    !008

    2@3

    !009

    2@3

    !00

    2@3

    !0

    2@3

    !0!

    2@3

    Avera

    ge

    2@3

    /ndust

    ry

    Avera

    ge

    -""L #.9 #.# '.) #.88 #.#' #.)7

    #.#0

    @

    P"L !.9 382 #.0) #.*8 278 #.!)

    ""L ).)! #.)0 '.0! #.* #.') '.0!

    /"L #.) #.!0 #.!) !.0 !.#0 !.87

    (/"L '.0 #.'* '.)0 !.78 !.*) #.)0

    A/"L

    #.#9

     

    #.!8

     

    #.8)

     

    #.70

     

    #.')

    #.)#

    Table # 0: ,et /perating -argin.

     Interpretations:

    atio Anaysis for the et Gperatin* (ar*in shows that the industry avera*e is &// Amon*

    the si seected 0anks BBL and Shah Haa !samic Bank Limited SF!BLC is in the 0est position

    with havin* an a0ove avera*e operatin* mar*in of ,/#" and &/-' whereas the two seected

     0ank DBBL and BBL aso achieved a0ove avera*e mar*in/ !t means SF!BL. DBBL. BBL. A!BL

    a four 0anks are havin* effective mana*ement for their operations/ 6he positionof these 0anks

    is shown in a *raph 0eow:

    &&

    ;et peratin( 3ar(in @;3 ;et peratin( evenues Total

  • 8/18/2019 A Comparative Analysis between General Commercial Banks and Islamic Shariah Banks

    35/71

    '#

    0

    1

    2

    3

    4

    5

    6

    ut% 'ang"a 'an)

    prime 'an)

    *ra% 'an)

    Is"ami 'an)

    sa,"a" 'an)

    "-ra&aIs"ami 'an)

    Chart ( 0$: ,et /perating -argin.

    #/&/+ )arnin(s per Share @)PS

    6he portion of a companyMs profit aocated to each outstandin* share of common stock /

    >ompanies usuay report the wei*hted avera*e of the num0er of shares outstandin* over the

    reportin* period !nvestopedia/com. "###C/ Earnin*s per Share are a widey used measure of 

     profita0iity/ et income of a firm divided 0y the num0er of its outstandin* shares the shareshed

     0y the stockhoders sharehodersC/ 6he formua is

    &,

    http://www.allbusiness.com/glossaries/common-stock/4948841-1.html?lc=int_mb_1001http://www.allbusiness.com/glossaries/shares-outstanding/4954094-1.html?lc=int_mb_1001http://www.businessdictionary.com/definition/net-income.htmlhttp://www.businessdictionary.com/definition/outstanding-shares.htmlhttp://www.businessdictionary.com/definition/outstanding-shares.htmlhttp://www.businessdictionary.com/definition/share.htmlhttp://www.businessdictionary.com/definition/held.htmlhttp://www.businessdictionary.com/definition/stockholder.htmlhttp://www.businessdictionary.com/definition/stockholder.htmlhttp://www.businessdictionary.com/definition/shareholder.htmlhttp://www.allbusiness.com/glossaries/common-stock/4948841-1.html?lc=int_mb_1001http://www.allbusiness.com/glossaries/shares-outstanding/4954094-1.html?lc=int_mb_1001http://www.businessdictionary.com/definition/net-income.htmlhttp://www.businessdictionary.com/definition/outstanding-shares.htmlhttp://www.businessdictionary.com/definition/share.htmlhttp://www.businessdictionary.com/definition/held.htmlhttp://www.businessdictionary.com/definition/stockholder.htmlhttp://www.businessdictionary.com/definition/shareholder.html

  • 8/18/2019 A Comparative Analysis between General Commercial Banks and Islamic Shariah Banks

    36/71

    '+

    4ame of 

    "ank 

    !008

    2@3

    !009

    2@3

    !00

    2@3

    !0

    2@3

    !0!

    2@3

    Avera

    ge

    2@3

    /ndust

    ry

    Avera

    ge

    -""L ).7 ).7 0 0.80 .*0 8.7*

    *.!

    @

    P"L #/'. -/%. +/-. #/-. &/&& '.9'

    ""L

    #.9)

     

    !.9'

     

    ).0)

     

    '.!9

     

    .#!

    #.)

    /"L '.## '.)9 '.'* '.8' '.'! '.)#(/"L !.98 #.9 '.*) !.0 #.*! #.'*

    A/"L

    #.7!

      !

    '.'

     

    #.7#

     

    !.#8

    #.9

    Table # 0: &arnings er Share.

     Interpretations:

    atio Anaysis for the Earnin*s per Share shows that the industry avera*e is @/1"/ Amon* the

    si seected 0anks a DBBL is in the 0est position with havin* a earnin*s per share is 2/'@

     0ecause of the num0er of outstandin* shares increased tremendousy in ast two years/ Whereas

    a other three 0anks are havin* an E3S of 0eow industry avera*e that is ,/$, for 3BL. &/-1for 

    BBL for !BL ,/-& for A!BL is &/1$./ 6he positionof these 0anks is shown in a *raph 0eow:

    &-

     

  • 8/18/2019 A Comparative Analysis between General Commercial Banks and Islamic Shariah Banks

    37/71

    ',

    0

    2

    4

    6

    8

    10

    12

    14

    ut% 'ang"a 'an)

    prime 'an)

    *ra% 'an)

    Is"ami 'an)

    sa,"a" 'an)

    "-ra&aIs"ami 'an)

    Chart ( 0): &arnings er Share.

    #/'2i9uidity ratio

    Li4uidity ratios measure the 0ank a0iity to meet its short%term o0i*ations/ Banks face i4uidity

     pro0em due to ecess withdrawa from current and savin* account/ 6here are severa measures

    of i4uidity/ Li4uidity position of 0anks is measured 0y usin* four foowin* ratios/

    &@

  • 8/18/2019 A Comparative Analysis between General Commercial Banks and Islamic Shariah Banks

    38/71

    '-

    #/'/1 Current atio @C6he ratio is mainy used to *ive an idea of the 0ankMs a0iity to pay 0ack its short%term

    ia0iities with its short%term assets investorwords. 1$$2C/ 6he hi*her the current ratio. the more

    capa0e the 0ank is of payin* its o0i*ations/

    4ame of 

    "ank 

    !008 !009 !00 !0 !0! Avera

    ge

    /ndustr

    y

    Average

    -""L .7 .9

    .!)

    .' .! .7

    *.'0P"L .' .0).09

    .0! .0! .0*

    BB2  

    .0#

     

    !.)0

     

    !.#!

     

    #.*0

     

    !.'0

     

    !.#7

    /"L .09 .! .09 .08 .* .(/"L .'9 #.09 #.#7 #.!8 .0 !.')

    A/"L

    #.0)

     

    #.9

     

    #.#0

     

    !.97

     

    !.8'

    #.07

    Table # 0: Current %atio.

     Interpretations

    Accordin* to resut the current ratio the industry avera*e is @/,#/ Which mean the industry has

    11/-1 taka of currents assets a*ainst 1 taka of short term de0t or ia0iityP !t means the industry

    has the a0iity to pay off its current ia0iities with its current assets/

  • 8/18/2019 A Comparative Analysis between General Commercial Banks and Islamic Shariah Banks

    39/71

    '%

    they invested ess in short term assets/ Gn the other hand !BL and BBLis 1/11 and "/&' times

    respectivey/ !n fact the hi*her the current ratio is 0etter for the institution 0ecause this hi*her 

    ratio heps to prevent *ettin* defaut/ 6hus SF!BL is in the 0etter position to prevent *ettin*

    defaut/

    0

    2

    4

    6

    8

    10

    12

    14

    ut% 'ang"a 'an)

    prime 'an)

    *ra% 'an)

    Is"ami 'an)

    sa,"a" 'an)

    "-ra&aIs"ami 'an)

    Chart ( 0+: Current %atio.

     #/'/& Current Asset atio @CA

    6he current assets ratio measures a companyMs a0iity to pay the ia0iities that it is most ikey to

    have to pay soon with that assets that shoud yied cash the 4uickest/ 6he

  • 8/18/2019 A Comparative Analysis between General Commercial Banks and Islamic Shariah Banks

    40/71

    '$

    -""L 8.'* 8.# 9.9' 8.** !.0* 9.')

    ).7

    @

    P"L 7.8 7.## ).!8 *.87 *.#8 *.7#

    ""L

    0.#7

     

    !.8'

     

    .'9

     

    .'0

     

    *.*'

    !.))

    /"L #.)7 #.'7 .8 0.'# 8.** .)9

    (/"L !0.88 7.8! *.) *.)0 9.)* *.8

    A/"L

    *.!

     

    7.)

     

    ).*#

     

    *.87

     

    8.'9

    *.9!

    Table # 10:Current *sset %atio.

     Interpretations:

    Accordin* to resut the current asset ratio the industry avera*e is 1-/1'/ Which mean the

    industry has 1-/1' taka of currents assets a*ainst 1 taka of short term de0t or ia0iity/ !t means

    the industry has the a0iity to pay off its current ia0iities with its current assets/

  • 8/18/2019 A Comparative Analysis between General Commercial Banks and Islamic Shariah Banks

    41/71

  • 8/18/2019 A Comparative Analysis between General Commercial Banks and Islamic Shariah Banks

    42/71

    #1

    -""L *8.79 )9.' **.7' *'.*! )8.77 **.*7

    7'.)#

    @

    P"L 7!.89 7'.08 7'.*7 7#.98 7!.08 7#.)8

    ""L

    7!.89

     

    79.!#

     

    78.0#

     

    7*.07

     

    7).90

    7*.'!

    /"L 79.* 78.') 80.#0 7*.' 7).'! 78.0

    (/"L 7'.*# 7'.* 78.9 7*.*# 7'.*) 7).7'

    A/"L 7'.*!

    7'.'8

     

    7!.'0

     

    7!.79

     

    7.'!

    7#.'

    Table # 11: 3oan %atio.

     Interpretations:

    Accordin* to resut the 6ota Loans to tota asset ratio+s industry avera*e is ',/-&.which mean

    that the industry has used their assets of 1## 6aka to *ive ',/-& taka vaued oans/

  • 8/18/2019 A Comparative Analysis between General Commercial Banks and Islamic Shariah Banks

    43/71

  • 8/18/2019 A Comparative Analysis between General Commercial Banks and Islamic Shariah Banks

    44/71

  • 8/18/2019 A Comparative Analysis between General Commercial Banks and Islamic Shariah Banks

    45/71

    ##

    0

    20

    40

    60

    80

    100

    120

    ut% 'ang"a 'an)

    prime 'an)

    *ra% 'an)

    Is"ami 'an)

    sa,"a" 'an)

    "-ra&aIs"ami 'an)

    Chart ( 0: Total 3oans To 4eposits.

    #/#/& Interest ate isk atio

    !nterest ate isk in the dan*er that shiftin* interest rates may adversey affect a 0ank+s net

    income. the vaue of its assets or e4uity/6he risk that an investmentMs vaue wi chan*e due to a

    chan*e in the a0soute eve of interest rates. in the spread 0etween two rates. in the shape of the

    yied curve or in any other interest rate reationship/

    #/#/&/1 Interest Sensitive Gap

    !nterest sensitive assets to interest sensitive ia0iities or repica0e assets to ia0iity shows that

     portion of !nterest sensitive assets for interest sensitive ia0iity/6o achieve smooth runnin* for 

    the or*ani?ation 0anks must have hi*her per cent of retracea0e asset to ia0iity ratio/

    ,,

  • 8/18/2019 A Comparative Analysis between General Commercial Banks and Islamic Shariah Banks

    46/71

    #+

    4ame of 

    "ank 

    !007

    2@3

    !009

    2@3

    !00

    2@3

    !0

    2@3

    !0!

    2@3

    Avera

    ge

    2@3

    /ndustr

    y

    Average

    -""L 88.8* 8*.88 8).'! 89.!) 89.90 88.0*

    88.0#

    @

    P"L

    9.0*

     

    88.*

     

    8#.78

     

    8.89

     

    80.!)

    8).0!

    ""L 90.') 87.08 9.)* 8).09 8.*7 87.7/"L 87.)# 88.! 8*.') 88 88.90 87.08

    (/"L 0!.8

    *

    0#.*

    *

    0.7

    7

    0!.)

    '

    0#.

    *

    0!.*

    0

    A/"L 89

    89.78

     

    87.'!

     

    8*.)#

     

    89.)#

    88.')

    Table # 1: nterest Sensiti5e 6*sset73iabilities8.

     Interpretations:

    Accordin* to resut the !nterest Sensitive Asset to !nterest Sensitive Lia0iities the industry

    avera*e is 22/#& or #/22.which mean that the industry is ia0iity sensitive that is they have ess

    interest sensitive asset then interest sensitive ia0iity/

  • 8/18/2019 A Comparative Analysis between General Commercial Banks and Islamic Shariah Banks

    47/71

    #,

    0

    20

    40

    60

    80

    100

    120

    ut% 'ang"a 'an)

    prime 'an)

    *ra% 'an)

    Is"ami 'an)

    sa,"a" 'an)

    "-ra&aIs"ami 'an)

    Chart?1.! Interest Sensitive Gap

    #/#/' Price risk 

    Especiay to these market vaue movements are 0ond. portfoios and stockhoders+ e4uity. which

    can dive suddeny as market prices move a*ainst a financia firm !nvestopedia/com. "##1C/

    (arket vaue ratios reate the o0serva0e market vaues ike the stock price with the 0ook vaues

    o0tained from the firmMs financia statements/

    #/#/'/1 Price )arnin(s atio @P) atio

    3rice earnin*s ratio shows how much an investor is wiin* to pay per taka of reported profit/ !t is

    cacuated 0y dividin* the stock price per share 0y the earnin*s per share E3SC Leicon/ft/com.

    "###C/ 6he formua is *iven 0eow:

    ,@

  • 8/18/2019 A Comparative Analysis between General Commercial Banks and Islamic Shariah Banks

    48/71

    #-

    4ame of 

    "ank 

    !008

    Times

    !009

    Times

    !00

    Times

    !0

    Times

    !0!

    Times

    Avera

    ge

    Times

    /ndustry

    Average

    -""L 78.70 #'.'0 !!.90 ) 9.90 #!.8

    #.

    Times

    P"L !.88 9.'7 *.*0 8.#' !.'* .9)

    ""L

    9.)7

     

    .0'

     

    *.9)

     

    8.87

     

    0.80

    #.')

    /"L 0.78 !.87 #.!9 .!7 9.*8 .)8

    (/"L 8.)) !.!' #. ).'8 9.7 .7

    A/"L

    9.)#

     

    .!#

     

    #.!'

     

    0.#

     

    0.!

    0.89

    Table # 1$: 7& %atio.

     Interpretations:

    Accordin* to the anaysis of 3rice Earnin*s atio the industry avera*e is 1&/11 times.which

    mean that the industryinvestors are wiin* to pay 1&/11times per taka of reported profit/

  • 8/18/2019 A Comparative Analysis between General Commercial Banks and Islamic Shariah Banks

    49/71

    #%

    0

    10

    20

    30

    40

    50

    60

    70

    80

    90

    ut% 'ang"a 'an)

    prime 'an)

    *ra% 'an)

    Is"ami 'an)

    sa,"a" 'an)

    "-ra&aIs"ami 'an)

    Chart ( 11: rice &arnings %atio.

    #/+Capital ade9uacy ratio

    6his ratio is a measure of a 0ankMs capita/ !t is epressed as a percenta*e of a 0ankMs risk 

    wei*hted credit eposures/ 6his ratio is used to protect depositors and promote the sta0iity and

    efficiency of financia systems around the word/ !t is aso known as Q>apita to isk Wei*hted

    Assets atio >AC/Q

    #/+/1 )9uity ratio

    E4uity atio indicatin* the reative proportion of e4uity  used to finance a companyMs assets

    eadyratios/com. "###C/ 6he E4uity ratio measures the proportion of the tota assets that are

    financed 0y stockhoders and not creditors/ A ow e4uity ratio wi produce *ood resuts for 

    ,2

    http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Equity_(finance)http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Equity_(finance)

  • 8/18/2019 A Comparative Analysis between General Commercial Banks and Islamic Shariah Banks

    50/71

  • 8/18/2019 A Comparative Analysis between General Commercial Banks and Islamic Shariah Banks

    51/71

    +.

    0

    2

    4

    6

    8

    10

    12

    14

    ut% 'ang"a 'an)

    prime 'an)

    *ra% 'an)

    Is"ami 'an)sa,"a" 'an)

    "-ra&aIs"ami 'an)

    Chart ( 12: &'uity %atio.

    #/, ther0inancialratios

    #/,/1 ate o0 eturn on 2oans

    6his ratio indicates the rate of return on oans means in which rate the 0orrowers of oan return

    their oans/ Fi*her rate of return for a company means 0etter the position of i4uid assets

    !nvestopedia. "###C/ So that 0anks can further end money and earn interest incomes/

    -#

  • 8/18/2019 A Comparative Analysis between General Commercial Banks and Islamic Shariah Banks

    52/71

    +1

    4ame of 

    "ank 

    !008

    2@3

    !009

    2@3

    !00

    2@3

    !0

    2@3

    !0!

    2@3

    Avera

    ge

    2@3

    /ndustry

    Average

      -""L .97 !.#) !.9* !.7 !.)! !.)0

    #.0#@

    P"L !.99 !.77. #.!' #.'9 #.#) #.7

    ""L .08 .#* !.#7 !.) .8) .8#

    /"L 0.8* 0.79 0.99 0.8 0.89

    (/"L #.87 #.0# !.8* #.'# #.*! #.#*

    A/"L

    0.8)

     

    .)0

     

    !.#'

     

    .7!

     

    0.9

    .'*

    Table # 1+: %ate of %eturn on 3oans.

     Interpretations:

    Accordin* to the anaysis of rate of return on oans the industry avera*e is &/#&.which mean

    that the Borrowers have returned &/#& of their tota oans/

  • 8/18/2019 A Comparative Analysis between General Commercial Banks and Islamic Shariah Banks

    53/71

    +&

    0

    05

    1

    15

    2

    25

    3

    35

    4

    45

    ut% 'ang"a 'an)

    prime 'an)

    *ra% 'an)

    Is"ami 'an)

    sa,"a" 'an)

    "-ra&aIs"ami 'an)

    Chart ( 1: %ate of %eturn on 3oans.

    #/,/& 2oan to Assets atio

    Loan to asset ratio is used to measure the reation of the 0ank+s oan portfoio to the tota

    assets/Fi*h Noans to assets+ ratio mi*ht mean two thin*s:

    Bank is at hi*her risk 0ecause oans are ess i4uid assets than other financia assets/

    Loans usuay are the most profita0e assets of the 0ank. and it is hi*hy epected that

     0ank with hi*h Noans to assets ratio+ wi have hi*her Nnet interest income+/

    -"

    2oan to Asset atio Total 2oansTotal Asset

    http://www.investingforbeginners.eu/liquidityhttp://www.investingforbeginners.eu/liquidityhttp://www.investingforbeginners.eu/financial_assetshttp://www.investingforbeginners.eu/net_interest_incomehttp://www.investingforbeginners.eu/liquidityhttp://www.investingforbeginners.eu/financial_assetshttp://www.investingforbeginners.eu/net_interest_income

  • 8/18/2019 A Comparative Analysis between General Commercial Banks and Islamic Shariah Banks

    54/71

  • 8/18/2019 A Comparative Analysis between General Commercial Banks and Islamic Shariah Banks

    55/71

    +#

    0

    10

    20

    30

    40

    50

    60

    70

    80

    90

    ut% 'ang"a 'an)

    prime 'an)

    *ra% 'an)

    Is"ami 'an)

    sa,"a" 'an)

    "-ra&aIs"ami 'an)

     

    Chart ? 1#! 2oan To Asset atio

    #/,/' Total 5ebt to )9uity atio

    6he de0t%to%e4uity ratio is a financia ratio indicatin* the reative proportion of entityMs e4uity

    and de0t used to finance an entityMs assets

  • 8/18/2019 A Comparative Analysis between General Commercial Banks and Islamic Shariah Banks

    56/71

  • 8/18/2019 A Comparative Analysis between General Commercial Banks and Islamic Shariah Banks

    57/71

    +,

    0

    5

    10

    15

    20

    25

    30

    35

    40

    45

    ut% 'ang"a 'an)

    prime 'an)

    *ra% 'an)

    Is"ami 'an)

    sa,"a" 'an)

    "-ra&aIs"ami 'an)

    Chart ( 1): 4ebts to &'uity %atio.

    #/,/# 5ebt to assetatio

    De0t ratio is a ratio that indicates the proportion of a companyMs de0t to its tota assets/ !t shows

    how much the company reies on de0t to finance assets !nvestorwords/com. "###C/ 6he de0t

    ratio *ives users a 4uick measure of the amount of de0t that the company has on its 0aance

    sheets compared to its assets/ 6he hi*her the ratio. the *reater the risk associated with the firmMs

    operation/ A ow de0t ratio indicates conservative financin* with an opportunity to 0orrow in the

    future at no si*nificant risk/ 6he formua for cacuatin* de0t ratio is R

    -@

  • 8/18/2019 A Comparative Analysis between General Commercial Banks and Islamic Shariah Banks

    58/71

  • 8/18/2019 A Comparative Analysis between General Commercial Banks and Islamic Shariah Banks

    59/71

    +%

    0

    10

    20

    30

    40

    5060

    70

    80

    90

    100

    ut% 'ang"a 'an)

    prime 'an)

    *ra% 'an)

    Is"ami 'an)

    sa,"a" 'an)

    "-ra&aIs"ami 'an)

      >hart%1@: De0ts to Asset atio/

    -2

  • 8/18/2019 A Comparative Analysis between General Commercial Banks and Islamic Shariah Banks

    60/71

    +$

    Chapter! +

    +/1 8indin(s o0 theprojectata(lance

    After doin* the ratio anaysis on the seected traditiona and !samic Banks. ! have found too

    many thin*s reatin* to my 3ro)ect topic “A comparative analysis between General Commercial 

     Banks and IslamicShariah Banks”. 0ut everythin* is not possi0e to show in this report/ 6hus !

    have summari?ed the overa ratio anaysis in a Sin*e ta0e it is *iven 0eow:%

    1atio 4ame

    *an)s er&orman%e on an verage

    &rom

     2008-2012

    ut%

    *ang"a

    rime

    *an)

    *ra%

    *an)

    Is"ami

    *an)

    (a,"a"

    *an)

    I

    ra&a

    *an

    1 Return on Equity 2918F 2087F 168

    7F

    1725

    F

    2244F 201

    2 Return on sset 178F 198F 129F

    134F 2F 192

    3 Net Interest argin 392F 264F 256

    F

    385F 329F

    4 Net :perating

    argin

    357F 325F 402

    F

    287F 35F 353

    5 Earnings er (are 876F 494F 351

    F

    453F 346F 319

    *. Current

    1atio%times&

    117F 106F 237

    F

    111F 1245F 307

    7 !urrent sset Ratio 945F

    673F

    125

    5F

    1159

    F

    1618F 692

    8 oan Ratio 6667F 7358F 764

    2F

    781F 7574F 731

    -$

  • 8/18/2019 A Comparative Analysis between General Commercial Banks and Islamic Shariah Banks

    61/71

    ,.

    9 oans to eposit

    Ratio

     

    7593F

    8585F 872

    5F

    8916

    F

    9682F 942

    10 I( sset to ia'i"ity

    Ratio

    8806F 8502F 871

    7F

    878F 1026F 884

    . P6E 1atio

    2'imes&

    3218F 1195F 134

    5F

    1158

    F

    1171F 108

    12 Equity Ratio 633F 115F 75F 715F 794F 949

    13 Rate o& Return on

    oans

    25F 317F 183

    F

    089F 336F 146

    14 oan to ssets 6365F 711F 677

    5F

    78F 755F 731

    15 e't to Equity 2508F 1023F 1292F

    1311F

    1318F 832

    16 e't Ratio 9335F 9107F 921

    4F

    9285

    F

    9174F 804

    Table &.! 8indin(s at a Glance/

    +/&Per0ormance indicator

    Based on the ratio anaysis the performance indicator is se*mented into five cate*ories/ 6hese are

    summari?ed 0eow:

    +/&/1 Pro0itability

    !n terms of profita0iity. the performance 0etween traditiona and !samic Banks is ceary

    indicatin* that *enera commercia 0anks are doin* tremendous work compare to the !samic

     0anks/ Like the return on e4uity and net interest mar*in shows the proof of my statement/ Durin*

    the anaysis ! have found that !>B !samic Bank in their financia statement is too much

    fuctuatin* in fi*ures/ 6hus the resut varies too much/

    @#

  • 8/18/2019 A Comparative Analysis between General Commercial Banks and Islamic Shariah Banks

    62/71

    ,1

    6he reasons for hi*h profita0iity prospect 0y !>B !samic Bank indicate the various interna and

    eterna factors that are directy or indirecty infuencin* their performance/ 6hese reasons are

    summari?ed 0eow:

    By ookin* at the GA of !>B !samic 0ank we can say that their mana*eria efficiency is

    up to the mark and eacty e4ua to the industry avera*e/

    6he rate of return fowin* to the sharehoders is another factor that indicates hi*her 

     profita0iity/

    Fi*her return on asset directy indicates the fact that they are doin* we enou*h to run

    their 0usiness with accepta0e eve of profit/

    Another reason of havin* profit is hi*her interest revenue compare to the interest

    ependitures/

    B! have fair enou*h i4uidity compare to the

    *enera commercia 0anks in case of Loan ratio. current asset ratio as we as current ratio/ !n

    every case the outcome of this 0ank which is representin* !samic 0anks is hi*her than the

    industry avera*e/

    !n terms of i4uidity. the !samic 0anks of Ban*adesh are doin* a tremendous )o0 compare to the

    *enera commercia 0anks/ 6he reasons are summari?ed 0eow:

  • 8/18/2019 A Comparative Analysis between General Commercial Banks and Islamic Shariah Banks

    63/71

    ,&

    By ookin* at the ratio anaysis we can easiy comments that in terms of the current

    ratio. current asset ratio and oan ratio. !samic 0anks are *oin* faster than the *enera

    commercia 0anks/

    6hey are havin* enou*h cash on their hand compare to the deposits as we as they

    are providin* more oans to the 0orrowers compare to the deposits in a 0aanced way/

  • 8/18/2019 A Comparative Analysis between General Commercial Banks and Islamic Shariah Banks

    64/71

    ,'

    +/&/+ thers

    6hrou*h the oan and de0t reated ratios. the performance comparison is done smoothy. where

    differences can 0e identified easiy/ !s case of return on oan and de0t to e4uity. the *enera

    commercia 0anks are far ahead of !samic 0anks/ Gn the other hand !samic 0anks are far ahead

    of *enera commercia 0anks in case of oan to asset and de0t ratio/ But in reaity they are

    tremendousy 0ehind from *enera commercia 0anks/ As 0ecause they may 0e hi*her in num0ers

    in outcomes 0ut that was ne*ative measures that a**in* them 0ehind/

      6he proportions of net interest income to tota oans are hi*her in terms of the *enera

    commercia 0anks/ Because =enera commercia 0anks a0e to coect their interest

    incomes propery. this is o0viousy hi*her than the tota interest ependiture/ 6he *enera commercia 0anks are havin* enou*h assets incudin* tan*i0e as we as

    intan*i0e to cover up the overa oans compare to the !samic 0anks/

  • 8/18/2019 A Comparative Analysis between General Commercial Banks and Islamic Shariah Banks

    65/71

    ,#

     0ecause in our country ma)ority peope are (usim. !samic 0ankin* has an opportunity to *ear 

    up their 4uaity of services and *ra0 maimum amount of market shares/ 6o compete in this

    competitive market with *enera commercia 0ankin* system they must have ade4uate capita/

  • 8/18/2019 A Comparative Analysis between General Commercial Banks and Islamic Shariah Banks

    66/71

  • 8/18/2019 A Comparative Analysis between General Commercial Banks and Islamic Shariah Banks

    67/71

    ,,

    *.# "i%liography

    A Arafah Bank. "##2."##$."#1#."#11."#1"/ Annual Report / Dhaka: A Arafah Bank/

    Answers/com. "##'/ Deinition o !et Interest "ar#in/ KGnine Avaia0e at:

    www/answers/comtopicnet%interest%mar*in%1 KAccessed 12 howdhury. A/. "##"/ 3oitics. Society and ommerciaa ! Ban*adesh/ Sonali

     Bank . 111#1C/

    Fumhery. B/5/. 1$$'/ Efficiency of

  • 8/18/2019 A Comparative Analysis between General Commercial Banks and Islamic Shariah Banks

    68/71

    ,-

    !nvestin*answers/com. "##-/ Deinition o Return o )+uity/ KGnine Avaia0e at:

    www/investin*answers/comfinancia%dictionaryfinancia%statement%anaysisreturn%e4uity%roe%

    $1@ KAccessed 12 ontet of Ban*adesh Bankin*

    !ndustry/ ABAC . "'"C/

    @'

    http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_3/www.investinganswers.com%2Ffinancial-dictionary%2Ffinancial-statement-analysis%2Freturn-equity-roe-916http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_3/www.investinganswers.com%2Ffinancial-dictionary%2Ffinancial-statement-analysis%2Freturn-equity-roe-916http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_3/www.investopedia.com%2Fterms%2Fn%2Fnet_margin.asphttp://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_3/www.investopedia.com%2Fterms%2Fe%2Feps.asphttp://www.investopedia.com/terms/a/asset-liability-committee.asphttp://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_3/www.investopedia.com%2Fterms%2Fc%2Fcommodity-price-risk.asphttp://www.investopedia.com/terms/p/profitabilityratios.asphttp://www.investopedia.com/terms/w/workingcapital.asphttp://www.investopedia.com/articles/fundamental/04/012804.asphttp://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_3/www.investopedia.com%2Fterms%2Fr%2Frateofreturn.asphttp://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_3/www.investopedia.com%2Fterms%2Fl%2Floan-to-deposit-ratio.asphttp://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_3/www.investorwords.com%2F1326%2Fdebt_ratio.htmlhttp://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_3/www.investorwords.com%2F1326%2Fdebt_ratio.htmlhttp://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_3/www.investorwords.com%2F1258%2Fcurrent_ratio.htmlhttp://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_3/www.investinganswers.com%2Ffinancial-dictionary%2Ffinancial-statement-analysis%2Freturn-equity-roe-916http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_3/www.investinganswers.com%2Ffinancial-dictionary%2Ffinancial-statement-analysis%2Freturn-equity-roe-916http://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_3/www.investopedia.com%2Fterms%2Fn%2Fnet_margin.asphttp://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_3/www.investopedia.com%2Fterms%2Fe%2Feps.asphttp://www.investopedia.com/terms/a/asset-liability-committee.asphttp://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_3/www.investopedia.com%2Fterms%2Fc%2Fcommodity-price-risk.asphttp://www.investopedia.com/terms/p/profitabilityratios.asphttp://www.investopedia.com/terms/w/workingcapital.asphttp://www.investopedia.com/articles/fundamental/04/012804.asphttp://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_3/www.investopedia.com%2Fterms%2Fr%2Frateofreturn.asphttp://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_3/www.investopedia.com%2Fterms%2Fl%2Floan-to-deposit-ratio.asphttp://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_3/www.investorwords.com%2F1326%2Fdebt_ratio.htmlhttp://var/www/apps/conversion/tmp/scratch_3/www.investorwords.com%2F1258%2Fcurrent_ratio.html

  • 8/18/2019 A Comparative Analysis between General Commercial Banks and Islamic Shariah Banks

    69/71

    ,%

    Ohan. (/6/A/. "#1,/ $u#e Demand orIslamic Bankin# In Ban#ladesh/ !samic

  • 8/18/2019 A Comparative Analysis between General Commercial Banks and Islamic Shariah Banks

    70/71

  • 8/18/2019 A Comparative Analysis between General Commercial Banks and Islamic Shariah Banks

    71/71

    -.

    $TE1( Loan to Assets

    1atio

     #ota" oansG#ota" sset

    Total -e%t to

    E5uity 1atio

     #ota" ia'i"ities G #ota" Equity

    -e%t 1atio  #ota" e't G #ota" ssets