105

9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    3

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

����������� ������������ � ����������� �������� ��!" #%$&���'�()$* ���+& ,-��.��������/0 1 $*23��! $*� 45�

687

9.:<;>=@?BA>CED&FHGJI�:LK

MON�PRQSQST ?.U M U PRV�W

Q ;>X>IZY\[][^D`_a[^bcdYeFHf>Y\gh:LK Q [H:i[^D�jEKSY\kLD&lnm]Y\[o7

Y\Kap>:Ll][nYq:L=srt;S=\uv=\=\I�D`Kh[wbLrx[^fSDBl]D&yJ;>Y\lnD`I�D`Kh[^mrtbzl{[nf>D�_>D&gzl]D&DBbLr

N�V�| U V ? V�} 9~C P��xV�Q>V 9~C0�

N D`pv:Ll][nIZD&Kh[�bLr�9�fh7�mnY\F&mw:LK>_ M m][nlnbzKSbzI�7

�L�z�z�

Page 2: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

�������������

�� ��������������������! "���$# �%�'&! "�����(��)*�+ -,.�!/"�(0213�4)5�+6217�8 -93�:;�%&< -)"�4)"=>�$? 1A@B�!/C1A)EDF)

687

9.:<;>=@?BA>CED&FHGJI�:LK

U f>D`bzlnD [^Y\F*:L=>F&:L=\F&;>=e:<[^Y\bzK>mHG0Y [^fSYeK [^fSD0:L_>Ye:LXv:<[nYeF [nf>D&l]I�:L=Sm]fv:Lp D*Iv;>F`[n;v:<[nYebzKZIZb�_>D&= p>lnD`_>YeF [_>YKJ�D`lnD`K>F&D`m Y\K�[^f>D~X D&fv:*k�YebLl bLr [nf>DML�Yq:LKh[ N Y\p bL=eD�?0D&m]bzKv:LKSF&DFNOL N ?QP!G0Ye_S[nf�X D [RG D`D&K�KJ;>F`=eD`YG0Y [^f�:LK>_SG0Y [^f>bL;S[�mnfSD&=\=>DTJ D&F [^m&A M [�=ebUG[^D&IZp D&ln:<[^;>l]D&mTVzYeK KJ;>F`=eD`Y!G0Y\[nf m][nlnbzK>g�m]f>D&=\=vDTJ D&F [^mTV[^fSDWG0Y\_S[^f Yem�p>l]D&_>Y\F`[nD&_ [nb�X D0mn;>p>pSlnD&m]mnD`_dl]D&=e:<[^Y kzD0[^bBKJ;>F&=\D&YXG0f>D`lnDwm]f>D&=\= DTJ D&F [^m{:<lnD�G D&:LG AQ [^;S_>YeD`m�fv:*kLD X D&D&K p D`l]rtbzl]IZD&_ bzK [^fSD.L N ? p>l]bzp D`l][nYeD`m�bLr K�;SF&=\D&Y4G0Y\[nf�m][nlnbzKSg3mnfSD&=\=

DTJ D&F [^mYN[ZR\R] 9�X^P_V@:LK>_`G D&:LG�mnf>D`=e=~DaJ�D`F`[^mYN Q K�:LKS_ | ;^P^A U f>D�_v:<[H:'rtbzl�KJ;>F`=eD`Y4G0fSD&lnD�mnfSD&=\=DTJ D&F [^m�:<lnD-G8D*:<G�m]f>bUG :�_>D`k�Ye:<[^Y\bzK rtl]bzI p>lnD`_>YeF [^Y\bzK>m�:i[.=\bUG[nD&IZp D&l^:i[^;>l]D&m&A<U bwYeKhkzD`m][nYegh:i[^D[^fSYem�_SYem]F&lnD`pv:LK>F 7bV@:LK3Dac p D`lnY\IZD&Kh[dG{:Lmwp D`l]rtbzl]I�D`_"[^b�IZD*:<mn;>l]D�[^f>DeL N ?fG0Ye_ [^f�Y\Khg ZR\ Q K:<[0=\bUG D`l�[nD&IZp D`l^:<[n;>lnD`m�[nfv:LKdfv:*kzD�p>l]D`k�YebL;>mn= 7dX D`D&KdI�D&:Lmn;SlnD&_�AU f>DeG0Ye_ [^f bLr~[^f>DeL N ? X>;>Y\=\[�bLK�Dac F&Y [^D`_ mR[H:<[nD&m�YeKhg ZR\ Q K`G :Lm�mR[^;>_>Y\D&_ Xh7"IZD*:<K>m�bLr

Y\K>D&=e:Lm][nYeF&:L=\=\7�mnF&:<[n[nD&l]D&_ gji V p>:Ll][nYeF`=eD`m&A�U f>Yem~[^D`FHf>K>Y\yJ;>D�:L=\=ebUG8D&_ rtbLl~[nf>D0uvlnmR[ IZD*:<mn;>l]D&IZD&Kh[bLr�[^f>D-L N ?�G0Y\_S[^f�:<[x:{[^D`I�p D&ln:<[^;SlnD8:Lm =ebUG :Lm4k cdDTl YeK Q KsA M L N ?�G0Y\_S[^f�bLrnmBo2k8caDalF&bLK>mnY\m][nD&Kh[dG0Y\[nf [nf>DpL N ?$G0Y\_S[^f bLr~[nf>D gzlnbL;>K>_�m][^:<[^DSG :Lm�Dqc [nl^:LF [^D`_sA U f>Y\m�lnD&m];>= [�_>b D`mK>bL[�F`bzKSuvl]I [^f>Dd:L_>Ye:LXv:i[^Y\FdF`bz;>p>=\Y\K>g�F&:L=eF`;>=e:<[^Y\bzK>m�bLrw[nf>D5D`kLbz=e; [^Y\bzK bLrE[^f>DrG0Y\_S[^f :Lm�:rt;>K>F [^Y\bzK3b<r.[^D`IZp D`l^:<[n;>lnDsV�:LKS_3Y\K>_>Y\F*:<[nD&m�:<Kab kzD`lnD`m][^Y\I�:<[^Y\bzK�bLr [^f>DBY\K<Iv;>D`K>F&D�bLr.[nf>D&l]I :<=Iv;>F [^;v:i[^Y\bzK>m&A

Page 3: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

���������� ��� ����������

Y\YeY

Page 4: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

������������ ������� ������

U f>D{F`bzIZp>=eD [^Y\bzK bLr>[nf>Y\m [^fSD&mnY\m�I�:Ll]G�m [^f>D8D&K>_ b<rvI�7�=eY rtD{:<m�:EgLl^:L_>;>:<[^D8m][^;S_>D&Kh[*A P [�fv:<mX D&D&K�:�=\bzK>g!VL:LK>_ZmnbzIZD [^Y\I�D`m�rtl];>m][nl^:<[nYeKSg�Dac p D`lnY\D&K>F`DLAJU fv:<[~X D&Y\K>g�m^:<Ye_ VLY\[~fv:<m~:L=em]b�X D`D&K�:kzD`l]7�l]DTG :Lln_SYeK>gZDqcSp D&l]YeD`K>F&D�p D&l]mnbzKv:<=e= 7zA P :LI YeKS_>D&XS[nD&_�[^b I�:LKh7 rtbzl [^fSD&Y\l{F&bzKh[nlnY\X>;S[^Y\bzK>m`A} Y\lnm][�:LKS_ rtbzl]D&IZbzmR[ P G bL;>=e_ =\YeG<D�[nb5[nfv:LK>G�IB7 :L_Sk�Y\mnbzlTV N l&A@caY\FHfv:LD`=~U f>b D`K>K>D`mnmnD`KsA

U f>Y\m�[^f>D`mnY\mdG8bz;>=\_ K>bL[�fv:*kLD�X D&D`K p bzm]mnY\X>=eDZY r�K>bL[�rtbzlw7Lbz;>l�gz;SYe_v:<K>F&D�:LK>_ m];>p>p bzl][�b kzD`l[^fSDBp>:Lm][0rtDTG 7zD&:Llnm`A P [�fv:<m0[nln;>= 7�X D&D`K3:LKdD&K��Rb 7z:LX>=\D�Dqc p D`lnY\D&K>F`D�G8bzlnGJY\K>gpG0Y [^f57zbL;sAP :LI :L=\mnbEgzl^:i[^D`rt;S=z[^b�:<=e=z[nfv:<[ f>D&=\p D`_�Y\K�[nf>D l];>K>K>Y\K>gwb<rS[^fSD8DqcSp D&l]YeIZD`KJ[&ALU f>Y\m.Y\K>F`=e;>_SD&m

D`kLD&lR7zbzK>D�rtl]bzI bz;>l{gzl]bz;>p VJ[^fSD Q�� �z� gzlnbz;Sp V V ? Ww� VSj�K>Y kzD&l]mnY [o75bLr���:Lmnf>Y\K>gL[nbzK VS:LK>_'[^fSDW�QS|{� m][^:sJ.AvU fSDBl];>K>K>Y\K>g bLr [nf>Y\m�Dqc p D`lnY\I�D`Kh[BG :Lm�:ZgLlnbz;>pdDTJ bzlR[*AU f>D =eD`K>gL[^fh7 _v:i[H: :LKv:L= 7�mnY\mal]D&=\YeD`_ f>D&:*k Y\= 7 bLK [nf>D F&bzIZp>; [^Y\K>g p bUG D`laf>D`lnD :<[5[^fSD

W�QS|{� AJU f>D�F&bLI�pS;S[^D`l8_>D`pv:LlR[^IZD&Kh[ :LK>_�mn;>p>p bzlR[8mR[H:sJ5f>:Lm~_>bzK>DE:dG8bzK>_SD&l]rt;S=��RbLX�I�:LGJY\K>gmn;SlnD�[^fv:i[�[nf>D�K>D&F`D&m]m^:LlR7al]D&m]bz;>lnF`D&m�G D`lnD�:L=KG{:*7�mw:*k<:LY\=q:<X>=eD<A } bzl{[^f>Y\m V P [^fv:<K>G 7zbL;sA} Y\Kv:L=\=\7�V P G8bz;>=\_ =\YeG<D3[^b [^fv:LKSGD kzD`l]7zbLK>D"[^fv:i['fv:Lm�I�:L_>DaI�7[^Y\I�D3:Lm': gzl^:<_>;v:<[nD

m][n;>_>D`KJ[�I�bLlnD�D`K��Rb 7h:LXS=eD<A ��bz;aG�KSb G$G0f>b 7zbz;�:<lnD! P :LI�K>b<[wD kzD&K�gLbzYeKSg [^b�[^lR73:<K>_3=\YemR[D`kLD&lR7zbzK>D<A U fSD&lnD�:Ll]DBI�:LKh7�b<r 7Lbz; V :LK>_5;>K>_Sbz;>XS[nD&_>= 7 P G8bz;>=\_3IZY\mnm�mnbzIZD&bLK>DLA

Y\k

Page 5: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

� �����������

� �� ������������������� �kzA k 6{:LFHGJgzl]bz;>K>_ ABABA�A�ABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�ABA�A�ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA �

kzA kzA k L N ? 68;>Ye= [�bzK L�l]bz;>K>_ Q [^:<[^D`m A�A�ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA �kzA kzA � ca:LF&l]bzmnF`bzp>Y\F�9�Y\F`[^;SlnD ABA�ABA�ABA�A�ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA �kzA kzA � cdYeF`lnbzm]F&bzp>Y\F�9~Y\F`[n;>lnD�ABABA�ABA�ABA�A�ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA �kzA kzA m L N ? 68;>Ye= [�bzK T c F`Y\[nD&_ Q [H:<[nD&m A�A�ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA �kzA kzA�� L N ? � Y\_S[nf ABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�ABA�A�ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA

kzA � cabL[nY\k<:<[nYebzK A�ABABA�A�ABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�ABA�A�ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA !kzA � T cSp D&l]YeIZD`KJ[^:L= | bzK>m]Ye_>D`l^:<[nYebLK>m ABA�ABA�ABA�A�ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA kbk

" #%$�&(')�*�,+�'- ���.0/213'4��.0�5/56 �87� A k N D`[nD&F`[nbzlnm�:LKS_ T c p D`lnY\IZD&Kh[H:L= N D k Y\F&D`m A�A�ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA k�9

� A kzA k 6 : } Z Q F&Y\Kh[^Y\=e=e:<[nbzlnmdA�ABABA�ABA�ABA�A�ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA k�9� A kzA � | m P M lnl^:*7 A�ABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�ABA�A�ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA k �� A kzA � Q � �z� c3:LgzKSD`[^Y\F Q p D&F`[nlnbzgLl^:Lp>f ABA�A�ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA k�!

� A � T =eD`F`[^l]bzK>Y\F&mBA�ABABA�A�ABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�ABA�A�ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA � k� A � A k 6 : } Z T =eD`F`[^l]bzK>Y\F&m A�ABABA�ABA�ABA�A�ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA �z�� A � A � | m P{T =\D&F`[nlnbzKSYeF`m ABA�ABABA�ABA�ABA�A�ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA �L�� A � A � Q � �z� T =eD`F`[^l]bzK>Y\F&m ABA�ABABA�ABA�ABA�A�ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA �L�� A � A m UxlnY\gzgzD`l�6 b c T =eD`F`[^l]bzK>Y\F&mEA�ABA�ABA�A�ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA �

7 13.:��.�;3 �.0/=<>6?�56 "A@� A k | :L=\YeX>ln:<[^Y\bzK>m ABABA�A�ABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�ABA�A�ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA � �

� A kzA k 6 : } Z M l]l^:*7 ABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�ABA�A�ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA � �� A kzA � | m P M lnl^:*7 A�ABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�ABA�A�ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA � k� A kzA � | ? N�| N D [^D`F`[^bLlnm A�ABABA�ABA�ABA�A�ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA �z�

� A � Q�� �z� M Kv:L= 7 m]Yem ABA�A�ABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�ABA�A�ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA �z�� A � A k 9 :Ll][nYeF`=eD P _>D`KJ[nY\u>F*:<[nYebzK ABA�ABA�ABA�A�ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA �z�� A � A � } ln:LgzIZD&Kh[ T K>D&l]gL7 � bzmnm A�ABA�ABA�A�ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA � 9

� A � 6{: } Z M lnl^:*7 M Kv:L= 7�mnY\m A�ABA�ABABA�ABA�ABA�A�ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA m �� A � A k Q D&=\D&F`[nYebLK3bLr�B"?�:*7 m ABABA�ABA�ABA�A�ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA m �� A � A � Q f>bUG D`lw?0D&F`bzK>m][nln;>F [^Y\bzK A�ABA�ABA�A�ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA m!k� A � A � BDC l^:*7 N D`F*:*7 Q p D&F`[nl^: ABA�ABA�ABA�A�ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA mbm

� A m | m P8M lnln:*7 M Kv:<=\7�mnY\m ABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�ABA�A�ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA m4!� A m>A k P _SD&Kh[^Y uvF*:i[^Y\bzK3bLr T kzD`KJ[nm5A�ABA�ABA�A�ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA m4!

k

Page 6: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

� A m>A � 9�l]bL[^bzK Q p D&F [^ln: ABA�ABABA�ABA�ABA�A�ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA �nk� �2� ��/56 �?� � ��')��&���'4� ���>' B�� ��.4<�� &('8������. �

m>A k Q [H:i[^Y\m][^Y\F*:<=xcab _SD&= | :L=\F&;>=e:<[nYebzKSm A�ABA�ABA�A�ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA � 9m>A kzA k P KSY\[nYq:L=@9xbzp>;>=e:<[nYebzKdbLr W ;>F`=eD`;>m�ABA�A�ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA � �m>A kzA � N D`F*:*75?�:<[^D`m'ABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�ABA�A�ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA �m>A kzA � � D kzD&= N D`K>mnY [o7 A�ABA�ABABA�ABA�ABA�A�ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA 4�m>A kzA m L N ? � Y\_S[nf ABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�ABA�A�ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA 49

m>A � 6 lnD`IZmnm][nl^:LfS=e;>KSg'?�:L_>Ye:<[^Y\bzK ABABA�ABA�ABA�A�ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA �m>A � L T�MwW U Q YeI�;>=q:i[^Y\bzK ABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�ABA�A�ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA !m>A m W ;>F`=eD&:Ll0U D`IZp D`l^:<[n;>lnD A�ABA�ABABA�ABA�ABA�A�ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA 9 �

m>A m>A k } bzl]I�:L=eY\mnI [^b | :L=\F&;>=e:<[^D�[nf>D�U D`I�p D&ln:<[^;SlnD A�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA 9 �m>A m>A � ?0D&=\D`k<:LKh[���;v:LKh[^Y [^Y\D&m ABABA�ABA�ABA�A�ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA 9�

� �� ���')�*&���'4��.:������ �� ����' B�� ��.4<�� &('8������. @��� A k �L��� �L� caDTl T K>D&l]gL7 � bzmnm Q p D&F [^l];>I ABA�A�ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA � �� A � CEY\gzf>D`l T K>D`lngL7 � bLmnm N :<[H:5A�ABABA�ABA�ABA�A�ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA � �

� � � ��4/5��6?���� �6 @� ����� � ��� � ����� � A�ABA�ABABA�A�ABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�ABA�A�ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA ! �

k�Y

Page 7: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

� � � ��� � ����� �

kzA k | :Ll][nb bLKdb<r Q [nD&Y\K G D`_>D&= :LK>_�LD&K>m]bzKdI�b�_>D`=ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA mkzA � | :Ll][nb bLKdb<r'L�bz=\_>fv:LX D&l0:LKS_aUxD&=\=eD`l"L N ? k�Y\X>l^:i[^Y\bzKv:L= IZb�_>D&=dA�A�ABA�ABABA mkzA � } lnD&D�D`K>D&l]gL75mn;Sl]r :LF`D&m0rtbzlBg ZR\ Q Ka:LK>_ ZR\R] 9~X ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA �

kzA m N :<[H: :<K>_d[nf>D&bLl]7'rtbzl Q K3:LKS_39�XdK�;SF&=\D&Y A�A�ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA k �� A k Q FHf>D`I :i[^Y\F�bLrx[^fSDBDqc p D`lnY\I�D`Kh[H:L=xmnD [^;>p A�A�ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA k m� A � Q FHf>D`I :i[^Y\F�bLrx[^fSD�6 : } Z :Llnln: 7OABA�ABA�ABA�A�ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA k��� A � 9 D`lnmnp D&F [^Y kzD�_>l^: G0Y\K>g bLrx[^fSD Q � �z� [H:Ll]gzD`[0FHf>:LI�X D&l�_>b�bzl�A�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA k� � A m 9�f>bL[^b�:LKS_d[nbzp�k Y\DTG bLr [nf>D | m P :<lnl^:*7 A�A�ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA k� � A � 9 D`lnmnp D&F [^Y kzD�_>l^: G0Y\K>g bLr.:LK5Y\K>_>Y k Y\_>;v:<= 6 : } Z mnF&Y\Kh[^Y\=e=e:<[nbzl A�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA k �� A N Yq:<gzl^:LI bLrx[^f>DB6{: } Z D`=eD`F`[nlnbzK>Y\F&m ABA�ABA�A�ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA � m� A 9 N Yq:<gzl^:LI bLrx[^f>D | m P D&=\D&F [^lnbLK>YeF`m A�ABA�ABA�A�ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA � �� A � N Yq:<gzl^:LI bLrx[^f>D�[nlnY\gzgzD&l0X b c ABABA�ABA�ABA�A�ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA � 9� A k ]R] � :LK>_a9�;v6 D�F*:L=\Y\X>l^:<[nYebLKam]p D`F`[^ln: A�ABA�A�ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA � !� A � T K>D&l]gL7�F*:<=eY\X>l^:i[^Y\bzKaF`;>l]kLDBrtbLl0: 6{: } Z _>D`[nD&F`[nbzl A�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA �z�� A � | :L=\YeX>ln:<[^D`_aF`bzmnIZY\F C l^:*75mnp D&F [^l^: A�ABA�ABA�A�ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA �z�� A m U YeIZD�mnp D&F [^ln: ;>m]D&_5[^b�F*:L=\YeXSl^:<[nD�[nf>DB6{: } Z :Ll]l^:*7 ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA � k� A � | :L=\YeX>ln:<[^D`_d[nYeIZD�mnp D&F [^l];>I�rtlnbzI [^f>D | m P _>D`[nD&F [^bzl]m ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA �h�� A 9�lnbL[nbzKd:LK>_���F*:L=\YeXSl^:<[nYebzKdF&;Sl]kzD`m�rtbLl{[^f>D | m P :Llnln: 7 ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA �z�� A 9 c3:Lm]G'mnp D&F [^ln;SI�rtbzl | ? N�| kBp bzmnY [^Y\bzKdF*:L=\YeXSl^:<[nYebzK A�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA � m� A � 9�=ebL[nm0;>mnD`_a[^b�:L_��R;>m][0[^fSDBU V�} pv:Lln:LIZD`[nD&l rtbzl pv:LlR[^Y\F&=\D�Y\_>D`KJ[nY\u>F*:<[nYebzK ABA � �� A ! P K>Y [^Ye:L= p>=\bL[^m0;>m]D&_5rtbzl pv:LlR[^Y\F&=\D�Y\_>D&Kh[nY\uvF&:<[^Y\bzK ABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA � � A k � } Y\Kv:L=sp>=\bL[�;>m]D&_5rtbzl pv:LlR[^Y\F&=\D�Y\_>D&Kh[nY\uvF&:<[^Y\bzK ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA � 9� A kbk Q�� �z� m]YeK>gL=eD`mED`K>D&l]gL74Co=\bzmnm�mnp D&F [^ln;SI A�ABA�A�ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA � !� A k � 9�=ebL[nm0;>mnD`_a[^bZD`=eY\IZYeKv:i[^DBf>YegLf-CoD`K>D&l]gL7�K>D`;S[^l]bzK>m0rtlnbzI [^f>DB:LKv:<=\7�mnY\m A�ABABA m �� A k � 9�=ebL[nm0;>mnD`_artbzl{uvK>:L= BDColn: 7'mnD&=\D&F [^Y\bzK A�ABA�A�ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA m �� A k m Q FHf>D`I :i[^Y\FB[nb�_SD&IZbzK>mR[^l^:i[^D�[^f>D�mnfSb G8D&l�lnD`F&bzKSm][^l];>F`[nYebLK3p>l]b F`D&mnm ABA�ABABA m �� A k�� Q p D&F`[nl^: rtlnbzI 9�;v6 DB_v:<[H: [nb�m]f>bUG [^fSDBDaJ�D`F`[nmEbLr lnD`F&bzKSm][^l];>F`[nYebLK ABA�ABABA mbm� A k� Q p D&F`[nln;>I ;>mnD`_a[^bZDqcSF`=e;S_>D�_>D`F*:*7�m�[nb�[nf>D�gzlnbL;>K>_5m][^:<[^D A�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA m)�� A k�9 �L��� �L� caDTl D&KSD&lng<75=ebzm]m B0C l^:*7�m]p D`F`[^l];>I X>l]D*:LGJ_>bUG0K ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA m4 � A k � ?E: G :LK>_5l^:LKS_>bzI BDColn:*7'mnp D&F [^l];>I�rtbzl � ��� ! � caDTl D&KSD&lng<75=ebzm]m ABA�ABABA m4 � A k�! BDCol^:*7 _>D&F&: 75m]p D`F`[nl^:SA A�ABA�ABABA�ABA�ABA�A�ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA m)9� A �L� L�l]bz;>K>_5mR[H:<[nD BDC l^:*7�_>D`F*:*75mnp D&F [^l^: A�ABA�A�ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA m �� A � k | m P r :Lm][0k�m&Avm]=ebUG m]p D`F`[^ln: A�ABABA�ABA�ABA�A�ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA � �� A �z� P =e=\;>mR[^l^:i[^Y\bzKd[nf>D | m P� �������� [nl^:LKSm]rtbzl]I :i[^Y\bzK ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA �nk

k Y\Y

Page 8: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

� A �L� U ln:LK>mRrtbzlnIZD&_ | m P p>=eb<[^m rtbzl FHfv:Ll]gzD&_8Copv:LlR[^Y\F&=\D�Y\_>D`KJ[nY\u>F*:<[nYebzK A�A�ABA�ABABA �nk� A � m 9�=ebL[0b<r.D`K>D&l]gL75=ebLmnm k�m&A p>lnb<[^bzK5D&KSD&lng<7 A�A�ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA � �� A � � 9�lnb��RD`F`[^Y\bzKdbLr D&K>D`lngL75=\bzmnm rtl]bzI } Y\g>A � A � mA�ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA � �� A � 9�=ebL[wbLr�D`K>D&l]gL73=\bzm]mEk�m&A p>lnbL[nbzK3D`K>D&l]gL7drtbzlw:�rtbzl7G :Lln_":LK>_"Xv:<FHG G :Ll]_ | m P

_>D`[nD&F [^bzl`A�ABA�ABABA�A�ABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�ABA�A�ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA �sm� A � 9 9�lnbL[nbzK5D&K>D`lngL75m]p D`F`[^ln: ABA�ABABA�ABA�ABA�A�ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA � �m>A k Q p D&F`[nln;>I bLrxYeK>D`=q:<m][^Y\F*:<=e= 75mnF&:<[n[nD&lnD`_`gji V pv:LlR[^Y\F&=\D&m0YeK5F`bzYeKSF&Y\_>D&K>F`D�G0Y [^f B

l^:*7�m G0Y\[nf T���� m caDTl A�ABA�ABABA�ABA�ABA�A�ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA ��!m>A � N YemR[^l]YeX>; [^Y\bzKab<r T�� lnD&m];>= [^Y\K>g rtl]bzI�: gzY kzD`K3D&KSD&lng<75=ebzm]m ABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA �m>A � N YemR[^l]YeX>; [^Y\bzK>m�bLr T�� ;>m]D&_ Y\K [nf>Y\mpG8bzlnG rtbLl D`K>D&l]gL7 =ebLmnmnD`m gzl]D*:<[nD&lZ[^fv:<K

�z� caDTl ABA�ABABA�A�ABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�ABA�A�ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA <km>A m Q�� �z� m]YeK>gL=eD`mED`K>D&l]gL7�=\bzmnm�mnp D&F [^ln;SI A�ABA�A�ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA �m>A � | :Ll][nb bLKdb<r.Y\K>D&=e:LmR[^Y\F Com]F*:<[][^D`lnY\K>g p>l]b F`D&m]m A�ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA �m>A 9 bzpS;>=q:i[^Y\bzK b<r [^fSDZ[^:LlngLD`[BKJ;>F&=\D&;>m�YeK [^D`lnIZmBbLr{D`K>D&l]gL7 :LK>_ :LK>gz;S=q:Ll�IZb C

IZD&Kh[^;>I ABA�ABABA�A�ABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�ABA�A�ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA �mm>A 9 � D`kzD`=@_>D&K>m]Y\[o75p>:Ll^:LIZD [^D&l0F`bzIZpv:LlnY\mnbLKABA�A�ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA m>A � L N ? G0Ye_ [^fd_>D&m]F&lnY\pS[nYebzKSmwY\K>F&bzl]p bLl^:<[nD&_dYeKh[^b | M�QS| M�N�T A�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA �m>A ! T K>D&l]gL7�lnD`mnbz=\;S[nYebzKabLrx[^f>DB6{: } Z :<lnl^:*7�ABA�A�ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA 9 �m>A k � | bzIZpv:Ll]Yem]bzKab<r.m]bz;>lnF`D�_>:<[H:Z:LK>_dmnY\I�;S=q:<[nYebLK ABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA 9 �m>A kbk ?�D`mnp bzK>m]D�bLrx[^fSD�6 : } Z :Llnln:*7 m�:Lm0m]YeI�;>=q:i[^D&_aXh7 L T�M�W U A�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA 9nkm>A k � N YemR[^l]YeX>; [^Y\bzKab<r Bal^:*7�mED`I�Y [n[nD&_dYeK5[^fSD8L T�M�W U mnY\I�;S=q:<[nYebLK A�A�ABA�ABABA 9 �m>A k � ?�D`mnp bzK>m]D�bLrx[^fSD�6 : } Z :Llnln:*7'[^bZmnp D&F`Y\u>F�D`K>D&l]gzYeD`mwABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA 9 �m>A k m T c>:<I�pS=eD�[^bZ_>D`I�bLK>m][nl^:<[nDB[nf>D�DTJ D&F`[nmEb<r rtbz=\_>Y\K>g ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA 9 �m>A k�� U D`IZp D`l^:<[n;>lnDBF&bzIZpv:<lnY\mnbzK5rtbzl{k<:LlnY\bz;>m0=\D`kLD&=@_>D&KSmnY [o7a_SD&mnF`lnY\pS[^Y\bzK>m A�ABABA 9 �m>A k� � b G D&K>D`lngL7'lnD&gLYebzKdbLr DacS:LF [�[nD&IZp D&l^:i[^;>l]D�F&:L=eF`;>=e:<[^Y\bzK ABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA 9 �� A k ?�D`mn;>= [�bLrx[^f>D�u>[nm0[nb�[nf>D �L��� �L� caDTl D&KSD&lng<75=ebzm]m0mnp D&F`[nln;>I A�A�ABA�ABABA � k� A � | bzIZpv:Ll]Yem]bzKab<r._v:i[H:Z:LK>_5[^f>D`bzl]7 rtbzl Q K A�ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA � �� A � | bzIZpv:Ll]Yem]bzK>m�bLr [nf>D�Dac p D&F`[nD&_amnp D&F`[nl^:L=@m]fv:Lp D&m�:LK>_d_v:<[^: ABA�A�ABA�ABABA � m� A m T J�D`F`[^m�bLrx[^f>D�Y\K>Y [^Ye:L= Dac F&Y [H:i[^Y\bzKaD`K>D&l]gL75_>Y\m][nlnY\X>;S[^Y\bzK>m ABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA � � SA k caY\F&lnbLmnF&bLp>YeFBF&bLlnlnD`F`[nYebzK5[^b [nf>D�gzlnbz;SK>_amR[H:<[nD�D&K>D`lngL7 ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA � �

SA � U f>D&bLlnD`[nYeF&:L=@p>lnD`_>Y\F`[^Y\bzK>mE:LK>_5_v:i[H: rtbzl09�X V Q K V | ; V :<K>_ M ; A�A�ABA�ABABA � ! SA � | bzIZpv:Ll]Yem]bzKab<r Q Kd_v:<[^:Z:LK>_dI�Y\F&l]bzmnF`bzp>Y\F�IZb�_>D&= pSlnD&_SYeF [^Y\bzK>m A�ABA�ABABA ! �

k�Y\YeY

Page 9: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

� � � ��� � ��� �>�

kzA k Q ;>IZI�:Ll]7'bLr [nD&IZp D&l^:i[^;>l]D&mE:Lmnm]b F`Yq:<[nD&_ G0Y\[nfaD&:LFHf3F`;>l]kLD�Y\K } Yeg>A kzA � ABABA �

� A k � :LXd:LK>gz=\D&m0bLrx[^f>D | m P _>D`[nD&F [^bzl]m ABA�ABA�A�ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA k�9� A k 9.:Lln:LIZD`[nD&lnm0[^b�:L_��R;>m][0[^fSDBU V�} pv:Lln:LIZD`[nD&l rtbzl pv:LlR[^Y\F&=\D�Y\_>D`KJ[nY\u>F*:<[nYebzK A � m>A k Q ;>IZI�:Ll]7abLr�[nf>D�F`bzlnl]D&=e:<[^Y\bzK�X D`[RG8D&D&K p>l]b��RD&F [^Y\=eD�D&K>D`lngL7a=ebLmnm�:LKS_"[H:Ll]gzD`[

Dac F&Y [H:i[^Y\bzKaD`K>D&l]gL7zA5A�ABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�ABA�A�ABABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA ��!m>A � Q :LIZp>=\D�p bzpS;>=q:i[^Y\bzKaI�:<[nlnY c�rtlnbLI | M�QS| M�N�T A�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA 9 9m>A � Q ;>IZI�:Ll]7'bLr.KJ;>F`=eD`Y p bzp>;S=q:<[nD&_a:L=\bzK>gZ_>D&F&:*7 ABA�ABA�ABABA�ABA�A�ABA�ABABA 9 �

YKc

Page 10: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

� � ��� ��� �

� ��� ��� � � � � � �

L�Yq:LKh[ lnD`mnbzKv:<K>F&D`m�:LlnDa:LK YeIZp bzl][^:LKh[ [nbzp>Y\F3Y\K KJ;>F&=\D*:<l p>fh7�mnY\F&m`A{U f>D&m]D"lnD`mnbzK>:LK>F&D`m�:Ll]DF*:<=e=\D&_�]gzYe:LKh[��_>;>D [nb�[nf>D&Y\l~F&bz=\=\D&F`[nY\kLDwKv:i[^;>l]DLA�cabzl]D mnp D&F`Y\uvF&:L=\=\7�VS:L=\=>bLr [^fSD�KJ;>F`=eD`bzK>m~[H:LG<Dpv:LlR[0YeK�[nf>D�lnD&m]bzKv:LKSF&DLA Q D`kzD`l^:L=@gzYe:LKh[0lnD`mnbzK>:LK>F&D`mEf>: kLD�X D`D&KdYe_>D`Kh[^Y uvD&_ V l]D&mn;S=\[nYeK>g�Y\K5[RG8bF&=e:Lm]mnY uvF*:<[nYebLK>m&AU f>Dwuvl]m][ F&=e:Lmnm]Y\uvF&:<[^Y\bzK�bLrsgzYq:<KJ[ lnD`mnbzKv:<K>F&D`m Yem8D&=\D&F`[nlnY\Fwk�YeXSl^:<[nYebzK>:L= IZb�_>D&m`A Q D`kzD`l^:L= bLr

[^fSD&mnD IZb�_>D&m�f>: kLD X D`D&K�rtbz;>KS_sA P K�bzl]_>D&l�b<r�[nf>D&Y\l�_>Y\mnF`b kzD&lR7bV [^fSD`7�:<lnD�[nf>D gzYe:LKh[�_>Y\p bL=eDsVyJ;v:L_>l];>p bz=eDsV@I�bLK>bzp bz=eDsV@:LK>_ b F [^;>p bz=\DZlnD&m]bzKv:LKSF&D&m`A@U f>D&m]D [^D`lnIZm�:LlnY\mnD rtlnbLI [^f>DZKv:<I�D`mrtbzl�D`=eD`F`[^l]YeF0uvD`=e_>m�bLr�:BgLY\kLD&K�mnpv:<[nYq:<=vF&bzIZp>=\Dac Y [o7 � k�� A } bzl�DacS:LIZp>=\D�Vh[^fSD�IZbL[nYebLK bLr p>l]bL[^bzKSmY\K [^f>D K�;SF&=\D&;>m k�YeXSl^:<[nYeK>g3YeK [nf>D'_>Y\p bL=eD I�b�_>D'gLY\kLD'lnY\mnD [nb�:LK bLmnF&Y\=\=q:<[nYeKSg�D&=\D&F`[nlnY\F'uvD&=\_[^f>:<[0lnD`mnD&I�X>=\D&mw[nf>D�uvD&=\_agLD&K>D`l^:<[nD&_dXJ7�[RG8b�p bz=\D&mTVvbzl0p bLYeKh[0FHfv:Ll]gzD&m`AU f>D m]D&F&bLK>_�F&=e:Lmnm]Y\u>F*:<[nYebzK�b<r�gzYe:LKh[wl]D&mnbLKv:LK>F`D&m�Y\mwI�:LgzK>D [^Y\F�k�Y\X>l^:<[nYebLKv:L=xI�b�_>D`m&A U f>D

I�:LgzK>D [^Y\FZgzYq:<KJ[�l]D&m]bzKv:LK>F`D&mBYeKhkLbz=\kLD [nf>D mnp>Y\K�bLlnY\D&Kh[H:<[nYebLK b<r8[nf>D KJ;>F&=\D&bzKSm&A P K [nf>Y\m�[o7�p DbLr�gLYq:LKh[ lnD&m]bzKv:LKSF&D�V~[^fSD&lnD3Yem : F&b�bzl]_>YeK>:<[^D`_ p>lnD`F&D`mnmnY\bzK bLrw[^f>DaK�;SF&=\D&bzK>m`A M m : l]D&mn;S=\[ V[^fSDaKJ;>F`=eD`;>m'F*:<K :LF`yJ;>Yel]D": K>D`[ mnpSYeK bLl�KSD`[ I :<gzK>D`[nYeFdIZbzIZD&Kh[ [nfv:<[�bzm]F&Y\=e=e:<[^D`m':<[�[^fSDp>l]D&F&D`mnm]YebzK rtlnD`y�;SD&K>F 7zA�U f>D Kv:LIZD&m5bLr�[^fSD gLYq:LKh[5l]D&mnbLKv:LK>F`D&mdYeK [^fSYem5F*:i[^D&gLbzl]7 :LlnD�[^fSDgzYe:LKh[BLB:LIZbUG CoUxD&=\=\D&l�:LK>_dgzYe:LKh[0I :<gzK>D`[nYeF Co_>Y\p bz=eD�l]D&mnbLKv:LK>F`D&m&AP K [^f>Y\m�[nf>D&m]YemTV [^fSD'gzYe:LKh[ _>Y\p bL=eD lnD&m]bzKv:LKSF&D�NOL N ?"P�X>;SYe= [ bzK�Dac F&Y [^D`_mR[H:<[nD&m8G0Y\=\= X D

k

Page 11: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

Y\KJkLD&mR[^Y\gh:<[^D`_sA�U fSD�m][n;>_S7dbLr [^f>Y\mwl]D&mnbLKv:LK>F`D�F*:<K3p>l]b k�Y\_>D�KJ;>F`=eD&:LlwmR[^l];>F`[n;>lnD�YeKSrtbLlnI�:<[^Y\bzKsA} bzl DqcS:LIZp>=eDsVS[^fSD�m][^l]bzK>g KJ;>F`=eD&:Ll{rtbzl]F&D&m{[nfv:<[ f>bz=\_'[^f>D�KJ;>F`=eD`;>m{[^bzgLD`[^fSD&l{F&:LK5X D�pSlnbzX D&_sAU f>D'mR[^;>_ 7 b<r{[^f>Y\m l]D&mnbLKv:LK>F`D�:L=\mnb3pSlnb k�Ye_>D`m :LK Dqc p D`lnY\I�D`Kh[H:L={FHfSD&FHG bzK�[^fSD k<:L=\Ye_>Y [o7 bLrk<:LlnY\bz;>m [nf>D&bzl]D`[nYeF&:L= IZb _>D`=em`A~U f>Dd:L_>Ye:LXv:<[nYeF�[^fSD&lnI�:L= m]fv:Lp DrIv;>F`[n;v:<[nYebzK IZb _>D`=5G0Y\=e=0X D[^D`m][nD&_3Y\K5[^f>Y\m [^f>D`mnY\m&A

����� � ��/�������������2���� 0 62: Q179 �� 5)E0 �� - Q)"@ED �!���<�%&

U f>DBuvlnmR[wIZD*:<mn;>l]D&IZD&Kh[^mwbLr.[nf>DSL N ? X>;>Y\= [wbzKdKJ;>F&=\D*:<lwgzl]bz;>K>_am][H:i[^D&m�G8D&lnD�YeKd[^f>DBIZYe_8Ck�!�m ��� m �Kk � A<U f>D{Dac p D&l]YeIZD&Kh[nm4G8D&l]D p D`l]rtbzl]IZD&_SG0Y [^f [^fSD{;>mnD b<r p>f>bL[nbzKJ;>F&=\D*:Ll.F&lnbLmnm C mnD`F`[^Y\bzKIZD*:Lm];>lnD`IZD&Kh[^m � � � AvU f>DBp>f>bL[nb C�:<X>mnbzl]pS[^Y\bzK5F&l]bzmnm0m]D&F`[nYebLK�N�� ����� P�Y\m0gzY kzD&KaXh7

� ����� N � P�� m���� Z����� �! " k# Z� # Z$ Z�&% Z')(+*-, Z/. Z� # Z10 N3kzA k P

G0f>D`lnD � Y\m~[nf>D BDCol^:*7�D&K>D`lngL7�V ')(+* Y\m~[nf>D lnD`mnbzK>:LK>F&D�D&KSD&lng<7bV2#3Y\m�[^f>D l]D&mnbLKv:LK>F`DWG0Y\_S[^f V� Y\m�[^f>D0I�:Lm]m8bLr�:�K�;SF&=\D&bzK V3��Yem�[nf>D0K�;SI�X D&l�bLrsK>D`;S[^l]bzK>mTV� Y\m�[nf>D0KJ;>I�X D&l�bLrspSlnbL[nbzK>m V:LK>_ " Yem�[nf>D{KJ;>I�X D&l�b<r KJ;>F`=eD`bzK>m`AhU f>Yem�rt;SK>F`[nYebzK>:L= rtbzl]IOb<r-� ����� p>l]b k Y\_>D`m~:�gzb b�_ _>D`mnF`lnY\p-C[^Y\bzK5bLrx[^f>D�m]fv:Lp D�bLr@[^f>D�L N ? Y\KaIZD`_>Ye;SI :LK>_5f>D&: kJ75KJ;>F`=eD`Y XJ7 [^lnD&:<[^Y\K>g [^fSDBl]D&m]bzKv:LK>F`DD&KSD&lng<7bV G0Y\_S[^f V@:<K>_ mn;>I l];>=\D�mR[^l]D&K>gL[nf :Lm�D&K>D`lngL74CoY\K>_>D`p D`K>_>D`KJ[ V@D&IZp>Y\lnY\F*:L=\=\7 :<_��R;>m][^:LX>=\Dpv:Lln:LIZD`[nD&lnm � � � ASU f>D�m];>I�l];>=eD�mR[^lnD`K>gL[nf3Y\m�_SD`uvK>D`_ G0Y [^f5[^f>D�rtbz=\=\b G0Y\K>g�Dac p>l]D&mnm]YebLK54

�768�:9<;\

� ����� N � P>= � � � � Z � Z���:� �! " � � �? " N@���BADCFE PHG N3kzA � P

U f>Y\m5Dac p>lnD`mnm]YebzK F&bzl]lnD`mnp bzK>_>m�[^b :�F`=q:Lm]mnY\F*:L= T k mn;SI ln;S=eDsV0:LK>_ Y\mdl]D`rtD`lnlnD`_ [^b:Lm'[^fSDU f>bzI�:Lm C�?0D&Y\FHf-CJI�;>fSK�N U0?KI8P�mn;>I l];>=\D � m � AU f>D�L N ? mnpS=eY [^m0Y\KJ[nb [RG b�F&bzIZp bzK>D`KJ[nm rtbzl : c Ye:L=e= 7�mR7 IZIZD`[nlnY\F�_SD`rtbzl]I�D`_5K�;SF&=\D&Y[VvF&bzl C

lnD`mnp bzK>_>Y\K>g�[^b�bzm]F&Y\=e=e:<[nYebzKSm :L=\bzK>g�[nf>D0mnf>bLl][�: c Y\mBNtf>Y\gzf-CoD`K>D&l]gL7 F`bzIZp bLK>D&Kh[TP.:LKS_�=\bzK>gB: c Y\m

Page 12: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

N =\bUG CoD`K>D&l]gL73F`bzIZp bLK>D&Kh[TP^A U fSD l^:<[nYeb bLr�[nf>D�mR[^lnD`K>gL[nf3rtbzl0[^f>DB[RG b'F`bzIZp bLK>D&Kh[^mwp>lnb k�Ye_SD&m: mnD`K>mnDBbLr@[^f>D�_>D rtbzlnI�:<[nYebLKhNtY A DLAvpSlnbz=e:<[^D�bLl bzX>=e:<[^D�_>D rtbzlnIZD`_^P V :LKS_5[nf>D�D&K>D`lngL7'mnp>=\Y\[][^Y\K>gY\m�lnD&=e:<[nD&_ [^b�[^f>D I�:LgLK>Y\[n;>_>DZbLr~[^fSD�_SD`rtbzl]I :i[^Y\bzK � � � A } bzlw[nf>D F*:<mnDZbLr8_>D`rtbzl]IZD&_ KJ;>F&=\D&Y[V� ����� F*:LKdX D�gzD`K>D&ln:L=\Y��`D&_a[nbZYeK>F`=e;S_>DB[RG8b � bzl]D&Kh[��`Yq:<KaF`bzIZp bzKSD&Kh[^m`A����� # �'=>�� M&<=> -�Q1A=���13= �� "���

U f>D�D&:LmnY\D&mR[ G{:*7 [nb _>D`mnF&l]YeX D�[^fSD�IZbL[^Y\bzK�bLr [nf>D L N ? Y\m{I�:LF&l]bzmnF`bzp>Y\F*:L=\= 7zAvU f>D�F`D&Kh[^D`l bLrI�:Lmnm�Y\m0uncSD`_ V :LK>_5[^fSDBpSlnbL[nbzK>m0IZb kLD�F`bz=\=eD`F`[^Y kzD`=\7a:Lm�: gzl]bz;>p V :Lm0_>b [nf>D�K>D&;S[nlnbzKSm&AV K>DaI�:LF`lnbzm]F&bzpSYeFa_>D&m]F&lnY\pS[nYebzK Y\m�Kv:LIZD&_ :<r [^D`l Q [nD&Y\K G D`_>D&=w:LK>_ LD`K>mnbLK � � � A P K[^f>Y\m

IZb _SD&=[Vx[nf>D IZbL[nYebzK YemB[^f>bL;>gzfh[�b<r0:Lm�_SD&K>m]Y\[o7 k�YeX>ln:<[^Y\bzK>m�bLr K>D`;S[^l]bzK�:LKS_ p>lnb<[^bzK�Iv;>Y\_>m:Lgh:<YeK>mR[�D*:LFHf bL[^f>D`l'G0Y\[nf [^fSDEm];>l]r :LF`D&m~u<c D&_ � �jVJ:Lm�_>D&pSYeF [^D&_ YeK } Y\g>A!kzA kzAhU f>Y\m8_SD&mnF`lnY\pS[^Y\bzK=\D*:L_>m [nb : rtbzl]I rtbzl{[nf>D�lnD&m]bzKv:LKSF&DBD&K>D`lngL75Y\K�[^D&l]IZmEbLrx[^fSDBKJ;>I�X D`lEb<r.KJ;>F`=eD`bzK>m M gLY\kLD&KXh7

')(+*�� " g��� G N3kzA � P

M mnD&F`bzK>_ _SD&mnF`lnY\pS[^Y\bzK YemdKv:LIZD&_ :<r [^D`l L�bz=\_>fv:<X D`la:<K>_ UxD&=\=\D&l� 9 � A0CED`lnDsV0[nf>D p>lnb C[^bLK>m�:<K>_ KSD&;S[nlnbzK>mBX D&fv:*kzD :Lm�[RG bamnD&p>:Ll^:<[nD l]YegLYe_ X>;S[�YeKh[nD&lnp D&KSD`[^ln:<[^Y\K>ga_>D&K>m]Y\[o7 _>Y\m][nlnY CX>;S[nYebLK>m&AsU fSD&mnDZl]YegzY\_�_>Y\m][nlnY\X>;S[^Y\bzK>m�;>KS_>D&l]gzbd:'fv:LlnIZbzKSYeF _SYem]p>=q:<F&D&IZD`KJ[ G0Y [^f lnD`mnp D&F`[�[nbD*:<FHf"bL[^fSD&l � �jV :Lm�_>D&p>Y\F`[nD&_"Y\K } Y\g>A>kzA � A U f>Y\mwIZb�_>D�:<=em]b =\D*:L_>m�[^b :LK3Dqc p>lnD`mnmnY\bzK"rtbzl0[^fSDlnD`mnbzK>:LK>F&DBD&KSD&lng<7bV :LK>_5fv:Lm [nf>D�rtbz=e=\bUG0YeKSg�rtbzl]IF4

')(+*�� " g���� G N3kzA m P

U f>D�L N ?�F*:LK :<=em]b�X D8_>D&m]F&l]YeX D&_Z:Lm.:wmn;Sp D`lnp bzmnY [^Y\bzK bLr>[nf>D{:<X b kzD8[RG b�IZb�_>D&m � � AiU f>Dmn;Sp D`lnp bzmnY [^Y\bzK bLr [^f>D`mnD [RG8b"IZb�_>D&m�=eD&:L_>m�[nba[nf>D rtbz=\=\b G0Y\K>gaD&yJ;v:<[nYebzK rtbzlB[nf>D l]D&m]bzKv:LK>F`DD&KSD&lng<7 4

')(+* � N3k G k ��� k � ��H" Z �� . 97G � m � k � ��H" g��� P g�� Z G N3kzA�� P

Page 13: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

} Y\gz;>l]DWkLA k 4 | :Ll][nb bzKBbLr Q [^D`YeK G8D&_>D`=>:LKS_ LD`K>mnbzK�IZb _>D`=z[^b�mnf>bUGL N ? k�Y\X>l^:<[nYebLKv:L=hIZbL[^Y\bzKsAU f>DBp>lnb<[^bzK>m0:<lnD�mnf>bUG0KaYeKdX>=\;>D�V :LKS_d[nf>D�K>D&;S[nlnbzKSmEY\K�7zD&=\=\b G�A�� ��� � ��� � ��� � ����� � ������� ������ ����� ����� ��� ��� � � � ��

} Y\gz;>l]D kzA � 4 | :Ll][nb bLK�bLrQL�bz=\_>fv:LX D&l :LK>_ U D`=e=\D&l�L N ? IZb�_>D&= A�U f>D�l]YegzY\_ p>lnb<[^bzK _>Y\m][nlnY CX>;S[nYebLKY\m mnfSb G0KY\KXS=e;>DsVHG0f>Y\=eD�[^f>:<[ bLr0[^fSD�K>D&;S[nlnbzKSm�Y\m mnfSb G0KY\K 7LD&=\=ebUG�A~U f>D5Y\KJ[nD&l Cp D&K>D [^l^:i[^Y\K>g�:<lnD*:�Y\mZmnf>bUG0K :<m�gLlnD&D`KsA�U f>D5F&D`Kh[^D&l�bLrEI�:Lmnm�Yem u<c D`_ :LKS_ m]f>bUG0K :Lm [^fSDF&l]bzmnm`A

m

Page 14: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

U f>DBl^:<[nYebZbLrx[^fSDBF`bzKh[^l]YeX>; [^Y\bzK>m0rtlnbzI [^f>D�L�U :LKS_ Q ZIZb _>D`m0Yem

������

� �G m4! � " g��� 0 N3kzA P

:LK>_ [nf>D�F&bLKJ[nlnY\X>;S[nYebzK rtl]bzI [^f>D Q IZb�_>D"X D&F&bLI�D`m5I�bLlnD"m]YegzKSY\uvF&:LKh[rG0Y\[nf YeK>F`lnD&:LmnY\K>gI�:Lmnm � m � A

����� # 13=>�� -&n=> 5�Q13=���1A= �! "���

U f>D�I�Y\F&l]bzmnF`bzp>Y\F p>Y\F`[^;SlnD�b<r�[^f>DSL N ? Y\mwIZbzl]D�F`bzIZp>=eY\F*:i[^D&_"[nfv:LK3[nf>D�I�:LF`lnbzm]F&bzpSYeF pSYeF C[^;SlnDLA P K3[^fSD IZYeF`lnbzm]F&bzp>Y\F p>Y\F`[n;>lnDsV [^fSD F&bz=\=\D&F`[nY\kLD bzmnF`Ye=\=e:<[^Y\bzK>m�b<r�[^f>D�K�;SF&=\D*:Ll�mR7 mR[^D`I :Ll]D_>D`mnF&l]YeX D&_aYeK5[^D`lnIZm0bLrxpv:LlR[^Y\F&=\D CofSbz=eD�DqcSF`Y\[^:<[^Y\bzK>mTV bzXS[H:<YeK>D`_aXh7�pSlnbzIZbL[nYeK>gZKJ;>F`=eD`bzK>m0rtlnbzIb�F&F&;Sp>YeD`_ m]f>D&=\=\m�[nb�;>K>b�F&F&;Sp>YeD`_ m]f>D&=\=em � � � A P KbLln_>D`l [^b _>D&m]F&l]YeX D�[^f>D5lnD`mnbzK>:LK>F&D5Y\K�[^f>Y\mG : 7�V [nf>D�p>:Ll][nYeF`=eD Cof>bz=\DBYeKh[^D`l^:LF [^Y\bzK"fv:<m�[nb X DB[^:LGLD`K"YeKh[nb':LF`F&bz;>Kh[&A U f>Y\mwF&:LK3X D�_SbzK>DBXJ7;>m]YeK>g�[^fSDEln:LK>_>bzI C p>fv:Lm]DE:<p>p>lnb c Y\I :i[^Y\bzK N ?E9 M P � � � A T cS:LIZp>=\D&m�bLr�[nf>Y\m~[nlnD&:<[^IZD&Kh[8F*:LK�X Drtbz;>KS_aY\Kd?�D rtm&A � � � k � � AcaY\F&lnbLmnF&bLp>YeF IZb�_>D&=\m�fv:*kLD X D`D&K :LpSp>=eY\D&_"[nb k<:LlnY\bz;>mEKJ;>F&=\D&Y A N D&m]p>Y [^D�[nf>YemTV [nf>D�IZY\F&lnb*C

mnF`bzp>Y\F p>Y\F`[n;>lnD�fv:Lmw=\Y\I�Y [H:i[^Y\bzK>m&A M mED&K>D`lngL7aYeKSF&lnD&:LmnD`m V Y\[wX D`F&bzIZD&mwDac�[^l]D&IZD&= 7"_>Y��F&;>= [w[nbp D&l]rtbLlnI IZY\F&l]bzmnF`bzp>Y\FEF&:L=eF`;>=e:<[^Y\bzK>m`AhU f>Yem~Y\m~_>;>D [^b�[nf>D r :LF`[�[nfv:<[�:L=\=>D&KSD&lngLD`[^Y\F*:<=e= 7�:L=\=ebUG8D&_FHfv:LKSK>D&=\m�I�;>m][�X DZF&bLK>mnY\_>D&l]D&_sA U f>D&m]D FHfv:<K>K>D&=\m�F&:LK�Y\K>F`=e;>_SD�[nf>lnD`D�V rtbz;>lTVxbLlBIZbzl]D rtl^:Lg CIZD&Kh[^m`A@9�lnD&m]D&Kh[^= 7bV@:'F&:L=\F&;>=e:<[^Y\bzK G0Y [^f IZbzlnD�[^fv:LK"[nf>lnD`D rtl^:LgLI�D`Kh[^m�Y\K"[^f>D F`bzKh[^Y\K�;S;>I Y\mbz;S[0b<r�lnD&:LFHfa:<[0lnD`mnbzKv:<K>F&DBD&K>D`lngzY\D&m � ! � A

���� 0 62: Q179 �� 5) ���B=%1 �<��@ D �<���!�%&

U f>DBL N ? X>;>Y\=\[8bzK�Dac F&Y [^D`_'m][^:<[^D`m8_>YKJ D&lnm~rtlnbLIO[^fSD"L N ? X>;>Y\= [ bzK�KJ;>F&=\D*:<l8gzl]bz;>K>_�m][^:<[^D`mY\K [^fv:i[{Y [ Y\m{X>;>Y\= [{bzK'Dqc F&Y [^D&_�mR[H:<[nD&mTV>:Lm�[^f>DEKv:LIZD�mn;SgzgzD&mR[^m`ASU f>D�mR[^;>_ 7 bLr�[^f>D�l]D&m]bzKv:LK>F`DX>;>Y\= [ bzK Dac F&Y [^D`_'m][^:<[^D`m p>l]b k Y\_>D`m{YeK rtbzlnI�:<[nYebzK :LX bz;S[~[^fSDwKJ;>F&=\D&;Sm :<[~[^D`I�p D&ln:<[^;SlnD&m :LX b kLD� caDal A U f>Yem�I�:LG<D&m�[nf>YemE[o7 p D bLr~mR[^;>_ 73D`mnp D&F&Ye:L=\=\7";>mnD rt;>=.Y\K"_>D [^D&l]IZYeK>Y\K>g5p>l]bzp D`l][nYeD`m�bLr

Page 15: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

KJ;>F&=\D&Yx:<[0fSYegzf�[nD&IZp D`l^:<[n;>lnD`m&A } bzl DacS:LIZp>=\D�V Y [0Yem0p bzmnm]YeXS=eD�[^bZmR[^;>_S7�[nf>D�mnfv:<p D�D`kLbz=\;S[^Y\bzKbLrx[^f>D�KJ;>F`=eD`;>mFG0Y [^fdYeKSF&lnD&:LmnY\K>g�[^D&IZp D&ln:<[^;>l]DLAU f>D�Dqc YemR[^D&KSF&D bLr�[^f>DhL N ? X>;>Y\=\[abzK Dac F&Y [^D`_ m][^:<[^D`m G :Lm3p bzm][n;>=e:<[^D`_ :LmdD*:Ll]=\7 :<m

k�!4����XJ7 N :*k Y\_ 6 lnY\K>G � m � A C�D�p>lnbzp bzm]D&_ [^fv:i[�[^f>D�D`K>D&l]gL7 _>D`p D`K>_>D`K>F&D bLrB[^f>D�p>fSbL[^b C:LX>m]bzlnp [^Y\bzK�F`lnbzm]m�m]D&F`[nYebLK�Y\m�Y\K>_>D`p D`K>_>D&Kh[�bLr [nf>D _SD`[H:<Ye=\D&_ m][^l];>F`[n;>lnD bLr�[^f>D�YeKSY\[nYq:L=~mR[H:<[nDbLr�[^f>D�KJ;>F`=eD`;>m � � � A�U f>Y\m�G D&:LG CoF&bL;>p>=\YeK>g fh7�p bL[nf>D&m]YemTV8GJK>bUG0K :Lm [^fSDa68lnY\K>G fh7�p bL[nf>D&m]YemTVY\I�pS=eY\D&m0[^fv:i[ T yJKsA%kzA k�mnf>bL;>=e_3:L=\mnb�:Lp>p>= 7�[^b [nf>D�L N ? X>;>Y\=\[�bzKdDac F&Y [^D`_3mR[H:<[nD&m&AP [8G :Lm m]b bzK�lnD*:<=eY �&D`_ [^fv:<[�[^f>D 6 lnY\K>G fh7�p bL[nf>D&m]Yem [nbzgzD [^f>D`l8G0Y\[nf�[^fSD Dac Y\m][nD&K>F`Ddb<r0:

mn;SX>m][^:LKh[^Ye:L= m]p>lnD&:L_>Y\K>g G0Ye_ [^f rtbzlB[^f>D gzlnbz;SK>_-ComR[H:<[nDrL N ? I�D&:LKh[ [^f>:<[�[nf>D f>Y\gzf-C D&K>D`lngL7B _>D&F&:*7 bLr�f>YegLf>=\7DqcSF`Y\[nD&_ F&bLI�p bz;>KS_ KJ;>F&=\D&Y�rtbzlnIZD&_ YeK KJ;>F`=eD&:Ll'l]D*:LF [^Y\bzK>m m]f>bz;>=\_ X DbzX>m]D&lRkL:<X>=eD�:LK>_ X D k�Yem]YeX>=\D�:Lma:LK D&K>f>:LK>F&D`IZD&Kh[ bzl �]X>;>IZp :<[ B0C l^:*7 D&KSD&lngLYeD`m3D&yJ;v:<=[^b T ')(+* � � � A U f>Y\m �]X>;>IZp G{:<mBuvl]m][BbzX>m]D&lRkzD&_�Dac p D`lnY\IZD&Kh[H:L=\= 7�G0Y [^f p>l]bL[^bzK V CED�V@:<K>_� C�D CoY\K>_>;SF&D&_�l]D*:LF [^Y\bzK>m �Kkbk�Vak � � A P Ka[^f>D`mnD�u>lnm][wDac p D&lnY\IZD&Kh[^mTV�[^fSD�D&KSfv:LK>F`D&IZD&Kh["G :LmwbLK>=\7bzX>m]D&lRkzD&_�A U fSD�u>lnm][�yJ;v:LKh[nY\[^:<[^Y kzD�:LKv:L= 7�mnY\m0bLr :ZfSYegzf8CoD&KSD&lng<73BDCol^:*7 mnp D&F`[nln;>I G :Lm0bzK�[^fSDKJ;>F&=\D&;Sm Z��RZ | r YeK�k�!49sm � k � � AQ Y\K>F&D�[^fSD u>lnm][5IZD&:Lmn;>l]D&IZD&Kh[nm3bLrB[^f>D�L N ?-XS;>Ye= [5bzK Dac F`Y\[nD&_ mR[H:<[nD&mTV Y\[5fv:<m�X D`D&K

m][n;>_>Y\D&_ Dqc�[^D&KSmnY kzD&= 7�Xh7 ;>mnD bLr{rt;>m]YebLK-CoD kL:<p bzln:<[^Y\bzK lnD&:LF`[nYebzKSm � � V k m ���z� � A cabzlnD�lnD`F&D`KJ[n=\7�VY\K>D&=e:Lm][nYeF0m]F*:<[][^D&l]YeKSg�fv:<m�X D&D`K ;SmnD&_Z[^b�mR[^;>_S7�[^f>Y\m~lnD&m]bzKv:LKSF&D � �<���S� 9 � ALU fSD�IZbzmR[�Dac�[^D`K>mnY kzDm][n;>_>Y\D&m�fv:*kzDBX D`D&Kd_>bzK>DBbzK Q KdYem]bL[^bLp D`m&A

����� 0 62: ? 13@B��/

U f>DaD`kzbL=e;S[nYebLK bLr�[^fSD L N ? G0Ye_S[nf�G0Y [^f Y\K>F&l]D*:Lm]YeK>g [^D&IZp D&ln:<[^;>l]D"fv:Lm X D`D&K [nf>Dartb�F&;SmbLr~I�:LKh7"Dqc p D`lnY\I�D`Kh[H:L=�mR[^;>_>Y\D&m � � Vak m � � 9 � A U f>D&m]D m][n;>_>Y\D&m�fv:*kzD l]D&mn;S=\[nD&_ YeK :'m]YegzKSY\uvF&:LKh[:LIZbz;>Kh[�bLr�_v:i[H:'F&b kLD&lnY\K>ga:'lnD`=q:<[nY\kLD&= 7 =q:<lngzD ln:LK>gzD b<r�[nD&IZp D&l^:i[^;>l]D&m�N ��� U � � caDal�P^AU f>D�:*k<:LY\=q:LXSYe=\Y\[o7 bLrx_v:<[^: b kLD&l m];>FHf3: XSlnbh:L_�ln:LK>gzDwbLr [^D`I�p D&ln:<[^;SlnD&m0fv:<m =eD&:L_'[^b [nf>D&bzl]YeD`m[^f>:<[0p>lnD`_>Y\F`[�[^f>DQG0Y\_S[^fdbLrx[^f>D�L N ? :Lm�: rt;>K>F`[nYebLKabLrx[^D`IZp D`l^:<[n;>lnD<AP K gzD&K>D`l^:L=[V [nf>D8G0Y\_S[^f bLr�[nf>DpL N ? Y\K>F`lnD*:<mnD&mQG0Y [^f"[nD&IZp D`l^:<[n;>lnD<AsU f>Y\m�YeKSF&lnD&:LmnDZF&:LK

Page 16: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

X DBDqc p>=q:<YeK>D`_3IZY\F&lnbLmnF&bLp>YeF&:L=\=\7LA U f>D�L N ? G0Y\_S[^fhN�# ')(+* P f>:Lm [RG b�F&bzIZp bzK>D`KJ[nm# ')(+* ��#�� . #�� 0 N3kzA�9 P

G0f>D`lnD #��'Y\m [^f>D�D`mnF*:<p DdG0Ye_ [^fa:LK>_ #��'Y\m [^f>D�m]p>lnD&:L_>Y\K>gpG0Y\_S[nf3bLrx[^f>D�KJ;>F`=eD`;>m&AU f>D3D`mnF&:Lp D G0Ye_S[nf bzl]YegLYeKv:i[^D&m�rtlnbzI [nf>Dd_>D&F&: 7 bLrE[^f>DaF&bz=\=eD`F`[nY\kLD"_>b�bzl7G :*7 mR[H:<[nDd[nb

lnD`mnY\_>;v:L=xKJ;>F&=\D&Y%G0Y [^f":�bzK>D Cof>bz=\D�F&bzK uvgz;>ln:<[^Y\bzK3l]D&m];>=\[nYeKSg rtlnbzI [^f>DBD&IZY\mnmnY\bzK�bLr�:�pSlnbL[nbzKbzl : K>D`;S[^l]bzKsA P K :LK Dac F`Y\[nD&_ KJ;>F&=\D&;Sm V [nf>D"D&m]F*:Lp D G0Y\_S[^f Y\m m]I�:L=e=[V bLK [^fSD"bzln_SD&l b<r�:rtDTG fJ;>K>_>l]D&_3G<DTl � � � � A>U fJ;>m Vv[^fSDBY\K>F`lnD*:<mnDBbLr [nf>DQG0Ye_ [^f G0Y\[nfd[nD&IZp D`l^:<[n;>lnD�Y\m0p>lnY\I�:LlnY\=\7_>;>D�[nb [^f>D�m]p>lnD&:L_>Y\K>gpG0Y\_S[nf V!G0f>Y\FHfaY\m [^f>D�l]D&mn;S=\[�bLr@[^fSD�F&bz;>pS=eY\K>g�bLr@[^f>D�F`bzf>D&l]D&Kh[�k*p-C k&fDac F`Y\[^:<[^Y\bzKa[nb � p-C � fa:<K>_5bL[^f>D`l0F&bzIZp>=\YeF&:<[^D`_3pv:<l][^Y\F&=\D C f>bz=\D�F&bzKSu>gz;>l^:i[^Y\bzK>m�N K>p8CoK>f^P � m � AU f>D�I :<gzK>Y [^;>_>D�bLr�[^f>DZm]p>lnD&:L_>Y\K>g G0Y\_S[^f Y\m�_>D [^D`lnIZYeKSD&_�Xh7 Y [^m�F&bL;>p>=\YeK>g G0Y [^f�b<[^f>D`l

KJ;>F&=\D*:<l{_>D&gLlnD&D`m{bLrsrtl]D&D`_>bzI V m];>FHf5:Lm�[^f>DEK�;SF&=\D*:Ll{m]fv:Lp DLA 6 D&F&:L;>m]D�bLrs[nf>YemTVSm]fv:Lp DFIv;>F [^;v:�C[^Y\bzK>m8:Ll]DEY\IZp bzlR[H:LKh[�Y\K [^fSDEX D&fv:*k�Y\bzl bLr [^f>DBL N ?BAzU fSDwmnf>:Lp D�bLr [^f>D�KJ;>F&=\D&;>m Yem�mnD`K>mnY [^Y kzD[^b [nf>DB:LK>gz;>=e:Ll IZbzIZD&Kh[n;>I :LK>_�[^D`I�p D&ln:<[^;SlnDBbLr [nf>D�KJ;>F&=\D&;>m`AU f>D�I�:LgzKSY\[n;>_>D�bLr�[^f>DEmnfv:Lp DBIv;SF`[^;>:<[^Y\bzK>m{Y\m _SD`[^D`lnIZY\K>D&_5Y\K'pv:LlR[{Xh7Z[^f>Dwrtl]D&DED&K>D`lngL7LA

Q D kzD&ln:L= rtl]D&D D`K>D&l]gL7 mn;>lRr :LF&D`mZ:LlnD mnf>bUG0K�Y\K } Y\g>A-kLA � rtbLl Q K :<K>_�9�XsA.U fSD'mn;>lRr :LF&D`m :Ll]DI�;SFHf�X>lnbh:<_>D&lEYeK Q Ka[^f>:LK"Y\K�9�X�:<[w: gzY kzD`K"[^D&IZp D&ln:<[^;>l]D�V _>;>D�[nb [nf>D�p>l]D&m]D&K>F`D bLr�mnfSD&=\=DTJ D&F [^m YeK 9�XsA M mZ[^f>D5[^D`I�p D&ln:<[^;SlnDdYeK>F`lnD&:LmnD`m V8[nf>D5[^f>D`lnI�:L= Iv;>F [^;v:<[nYebLK>m Y\K>F`lnD*:<mnD":<K>_[^fSDdKJ;>F`=eD`;>m pSlnbzX D&mZ_>YKJ�D`lnD`KJ[ mnf>:Lp D`m&A~U f>D L N ? F&bz;Sp>=eD`m�[nb�[^f>D`mnDdmnfv:Lp DrIv;>F [^;v:<[nYebLK>m:LK>_ [^f>D'l]D&m]bzKv:LK>F`D'p>l]bzp D`l][nYeD`m F&bzKhkLD`7�Y\KSrtbzl]I :i[^Y\bzK�bzK [^f>D [nYeIZD'm]F*:L=\D&m�bLr [^f>D`mnD'm]fv:Lp Dk<:LlnYe:<[nYebzKSm � � ! � AP K�I�bLm][xKJ;>F&=\D&Y[V*[^f>DHG0Y\_S[nf�bLrJ[nf>DML N ? Yem>m � � caDTl:i[@=ebUG [^D&IZp D&ln:<[^;>l]D&m-N U�� � caDal�PHA

U f>DE=eY rtD`[nYeIZD�bLr�[^f>DElnD&m]bzKv:LKSF&D�Y\m8[nf>D&K'bLK [^fSDwbzl]_>D&l8bLr'k � ZRZ8m&A M m�[^f>DEK�;SF&=\D&;>m gzD [^m8f>bL[ C[^D`l V~[^f>D G0Ye_ [^f bLrw[^f>DalnD&m]bzKv:LKSF&D3Y\K>F`lnD*:<mnD&mTV :LK>_[^f>Da=eY rtD`[nYeIZD"_SD&F&l]D*:Lm]D&m`A{U f>D3=\Y rtD`[^Y\IZDbLr�[^f>D L N ? Y\mZI�;>FHfmnfSbzl][nD&l [^fv:<K=\Y rtD`[^Y\IZD&m�bLr�lnbL[^:<[^Y\bzKv:<={:LK>_mnY\K>gz=\D C pv:LlR[^Y\F&=\DdmR[H:<[nD&mTVG0f>Y\FHf fv:*kLDE=\Y\rtD [^Y\IZD&m�bzK [^f>D0bzl]_>D&l~bLr�k � g ��� k � g � m&AhU f>D`mnDED&m][nYeI�:<[nD&m�YeKS_>YeF&:<[^D [nf>DFL N ?

9

Page 17: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

0.0-0.2 0.2 0.4b

0

1

2

3

4

5

Fre

e E

ner

gy (

MeV

) (a)

0.0-0.2 0.2 0.4b

0

1

2

3

4

5

Fre

e E

ner

gy

(M

eV) (b)

} Y\gz;>l]DekzA � 4 } l]D&D�D`K>D&l]gL7�mn;Sl]r :LF`D&mE:Lm0:Zrt;SK>F`[nYebzK5bLrx[^fSDByJ;v:<_>ln;>p bz=\D�_>D`rtbzl]I�:<[^Y\bzKdpv:Ll^:<I CD`[nD&l���A U f>D _>D rtbzlnI�:<[nYebzK�p>:Ll^:LIZD [^D&l%B`G :Lm�m]D`[�[nb �&D`lnb>A�9.:LK>D`=�N : P Y\mwrtbzl g ZR\ Q K :LK>_N X PY\m0rtbLl ZR\R] 9~X�A Q D&DBU.:<X>=eD�kzA k�rtbzl{[^fSD�[nD&IZp D&l^:i[^;>l]D&mE:Lmnm]b F`Yq:<[nD&_ G0Y\[nfaD&:LFHfa_SYemR[^lnY\X>;S[nYebLKsA

=\Y\rtD [^Y\I�D5Y\mZ:Lp>p>l]b cSY\I�:<[^D`=\7 mnD`kLD&K[^b D&Y\gzfh[Zbzln_SD&lnm b<rEI�:LgLK>Y\[n;>_>D5mnfSbzl][nD&l [^f>:LK�[^f>bzm]D�bLrmnY\K>gz=\D C pv:LlR[^Y\F&=\D�mR[H:<[nD&m�:LK>_dlnbL[^:<[^Y\bzKv:<=sm][^:<[^D`m VvlnD`mnp D&F [^Y kzD&= 7zAQ D`kLD&ln:L=.IZb�_>D&=\m�fv:*kzD�X D`D&K"p>l]bzp bzmnD`_3[^fv:i[�;>m]D�mnf>:Lp D�Iv;>F`[n;v:<[nYebzKSmwY\K"_>D&m]F&l]YeX>Y\K>g�[^fSD

L N ? p>lnbzp D&lR[^Y\D&m � �L� � A U f>D�IZb _SD&=J[^fv:<[xfv:<m X D&D`K gzD&KSD&l^:<=e= 7�:L_>bzpS[nD&_�Yem@[^f>D8:L_>Ye:LXv:i[^Y\F�[nf>D&l CI�:L=�mnfv:Lp D5Iv;SF`[^;>:<[^Y\bzK IZb�_>D&= ALU f>D{:L_>Ye:LXv:<[nYeF :Lmnm];>IZpS[^Y\bzK Y\m.[^fv:i[ [nf>D{KJ;>F&=\D*:<l�mnfv:<p D8_>b D`mK>bL[xFHfv:<K>gzD _S;>lnY\K>gE[nf>D~[^Y\I�D�Y [x[^:LGLD`m [nf>D*L N ? [nbw_v:LIZpsA U f>D�m][nlnD`K>gL[^f�Yem@[^f>D`K : G D`YegLfJ[nD&_mn;SI bLr [nf>D�m][nlnD&KSgL[^fa_>YemR[^l]YeX>; [^Y\bzK>m0[^fv:<[�F`bzlnl]D&mnp bzK>_5[^bZk�YeXSl^:<[nYebzKSm�XS;>Ye= [EbzK�[^f>DBp bLmnmnY\X>=\Dmnf>:Lp D`m [^fv:i[�[^fSD�K�;SF&=\D&;>mZF*:<K�fv:*kzDLA.U f>D'Y\K>F&l]D*:Lm]Ddb<r [^f>D L N ? G0Ye_S[nf G0Y\[nf YeK>F`lnD&:LmnY\K>g[^D`IZp D`l^:<[n;>lnD Y\mE[nf>D&K :i[n[^l]YeXS;S[^D`_3[^b�[^f>D l]D&m]bzKv:LK>F`D m^:<I�pS=eY\K>g�:L=\=xp bzm]mnY\X>=\D mnfv:<p D`m V^G0fSYeFHfX D&F&bLI�DBIZbzlnD�KJ;>IZD`lnbz;>mw:Lm{[^fSD�rtl]D&D�D&KSD&lng<75mn;>lRr :LF&D`mEX D&F`bzIZDBIZbzl]D�X>lnbh:<_3:LKS_dm]fv:L=\=ebUG�AP K5mnbzIZD�IZb _>D`=em [nfv:<[ ;>m]D�mnfv:Lp DQIv;>F [^;v:<[nYebLK>m V>[nf>D�:L_>Ye:LXv:<[nYeF�:<mnmn;SI�p [^Y\bzKaY\m _>l]bzp>p D&_

| bz=\bzl g ZR\ Q K ZR\R] 9�XlnD`_ � A � � A �XS=e;>D kzA � � A �X>=e:LFHG � A � kzA �gzl]D&D`K � A � kzA �gzln: 7 m>A � � A �

U :LX>=\D�kzA k�4 Q ;>IZI�:Ll]75b<r [nD&IZp D`l^:<[n;>lnD`mEY\K3caDTlO:Lm]mnb�F&Ye:<[^D`_ G0Y [^fdD*:LFHfdF&;>lRkzD�YeK } Y\g>A kzA � A�

Page 18: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

:<[�f>Y\gzfZ[^D&IZp D&ln:<[^;>l]D&m`A U f>D`mnDEI�b�_>D`=em~[H:LG<D�[nf>D�lnD&=e:<[nY\kLDE[^Y\IZDEm]F*:L=\D&m~rtbzl�[^fSDEm]fv:Lp DWIv;SF`[^;8C:<[nYebzKSm�Y\Kh[^b�:LF`F&bz;>Kh[ � �L� � A P Kd[nf>D&m]D�IZb�_>D&=\m V>[nf>D�[^Y\I�D�m]p D`KJ[EY\KdD&:LFHf3m]fv:Lp D�F&bzKSu>gz;>l^:i[^Y\bzK_>D`F&lnD&:LmnD`m G0Y\[nf�YeK>F`lnD&:LmnY\K>g [^D`IZp D`l^:<[n;>lnDsVv:LK>_'D`K>bz;>gLf'[^Y\I�DwI :*7 K>bL[{X Dwm]p D`Kh[0YeK5:�gLY\kLD&Kmnf>:Lp D�rtbzl [^fSDSL N ? [^b :L_��R;>mR[wY [^m0rtlnD`yJ;>D&K>F 75[^b [nf>DBF&bzl]lnD&m]p bLK>_>Y\K>g KJ;>F`=eD&:Llwm]fv:Lp DLA M mE:lnD`mn;>= [ V [^f>DSL N ? bLK>=\75rtD`D&=\mw[^f>D�:*kzD&ln:LgzD�mnfv:Lp D�b<r�[^f>D�KJ;>F&=\D&;>m`AsU f>D Y\IZp>=\YeF&:<[^Y\bzK"bLr.[^f>Y\mY\m�IZbL[nYebLKv:L= Kv:Ll]lnbUG0Y\K>g � � k � AU f>D L N ?�G0Y\_S[nf fv:<m :<=em]b X D&D`K IZb _SD&=\D&_ G0Y [^fSbz;S[Z[^f>D5;>m]Dab<rwm]fv:Lp D Iv;SF`[^;>:<[^Y\bzK>m`A

caY\F&l]bzmnF`bzp>Y\F"F*:L=\F&;S=q:<[nYebLK>m'Xv:Lm]D&_ bzK [^f>Da=eY\K>D*:<lnY �&D&_+lw=q:<mnb kD&yJ;v:<[nYebzK [nfv:<[ YeKSF&=\;>_>D"[^fSDY\KJ[nD&l]p>=q:*7�X D`[RG8D&D`K bzKSD CoX b�_S7 � :LK>_>:L; _v:LIZp>Y\K>g :LK>_�[RG b*CoX b _S7�F&bz=\=\Yem]YebzK>:L= _v:LIZp>Y\K>g bLrKJ;>F&=\D&bLK>mEf>: kLD�X D&D`K3p D&lRrtbzlnIZD&_� � 9nV �h� � A

����� � � ��$����B��$&���

U f>DZD`kLbz=\;S[^Y\bzK bLr~[^f>D gzYe:LKh[�_>Y\p bL=eD l]D&mnbLKv:LK>F`D NjL N ?"P0fv:<m�X D`D&K�[^f>D rtb�F&;>m�b<r8I�:LKh7�Dqc)Cp D&lnY\IZD&Kh[H:<=.m][n;>_>Y\D&m`AsU f>D�_SD&p D&K>_>D`K>F&D b<r�[^f>DSL N ?2G0Y\_S[^f�bLK3[^D`I�p D&ln:<[^;SlnD :<K>_�:LK>gL;>=q:<lIZbzIZD&Kh[^;SI fv:Lm X D&D&KBbLr pv:LlR[^Y\F&;>=e:Ll Y\KJ[nD&l]D&m][&A } ;SmnY\bzK-CoD k<:Lp bLl^:<[nYebzK�:<K>_�YeK>D`=q:<m][^Y\F C mnF&:<[n[nD&lnY\K>glnD&:LF`[nYebLK>m.fv:*kLD{X D`D&K�;>mnD`_ [^bwDqc�[^l^:<F`[x[^f>D*L N ?hG0Y\_S[^f :<[ k<:Ll]YebL;>mx[nD&IZp D&l^:i[^;>l]D&m � �z� V � �nV � 9 �:LK>_a:LK>gL;>=q:<l I�bLI�D`Kh[H: � �L� V � k��jV>p>lnY\I�:LlnY\= 7�YeK Q Ka:LK>_a9�XsAQ f>D`=e=@DTJ D&F [^mw:LlnD�[^fSbz;>gzfh[�[^b�p>=q:*7d:LKdY\I�p bzlR[H:LKh[�lnbz=\D�YeKap>lnD`_>Y\F`[^Y\K>g�[^f>DdG0Ye_ [^f3b<r.[^fSD

L N ? � �L����� � � A U f>D�gzD`K>D&ln:L=e= 7B:LF`F&D&p [^D&_�IZb _>D`=hYem@[^fSD8:<_>Yq:<Xv:<[^Y\F�[^f>D`lnI�:L=Jmnf>:Lp D'Iv;SF`[^;>:<[^Y\bzKIZb _SD&= A P KB[^f>Y\m.IZb�_>D&=[Vi[nf>D-G0Y\_S[nf bLrS[nf>D L N ? Y\m._>D [^D&l]IZYeK>D`_ Xh7�:*kLD&l^:<gzYeKSg�b kzD&l.:�[nf>D&l]I :<=D&KSmnD&I�X>=\D�b<r~K�;SF&=\D*:Ll�m]fv:Lp D&m&A�U f>D Y\K>F&l]D*:Lm]D bLr�[^f>DeL N ?fG0Ye_ [^f�Y\mw[^f>D`K :<[n[nlnY\X>;S[nD&_ G0Y [^f:LK�Y\K>F&l]D*:Lm]D YeK�m]fv:Lp DSIv;>F [^;v:<[nYebLK>m"G0Y\[nf"[^D`I�p D&ln:<[^;SlnDLA P K�K�;SF&=\D&YHG0f>D`lnD mnfSD&=\=�DTJ D&F [^m�:Ll]DG8D*:LGXV mn;>FHf :Lm Q K V [^fSD�m]fv:Lp D�Iv;>F [^;v:i[^Y\bzK>m�:<lnDBDac p D`F`[nD&_"[^b X D`fv:*kzD�:LmE_SD`[^D`lnIZY\K>D&_�Xh7a:lnb<[H:<[nYeK>g�=eY\yJ;>Ye_�_SlnbzpsA�U f>Y\m Yem K>bL[ [nf>D�F&:LmnDwrtbLl KJ;>F&=\D&Y G0Y\[nf�m][nlnbzK>g m]f>D&=\=�DaJ�D`F`[nm&A P K'KJ;>F`=eD`YG0f>D`lnD�mnf>D`=e=~DTJ D&F [^m�:LlnD mR[^l]bzK>g!V m];>FHf :LmB9�X V m]f>D&=\=~DTJ D&F`[nm�I�;>m][�X D�F`bzK>m]Ye_>D`lnD`_sA@U b5[H:LG<DmnfSD&=\=�DaJ�D`F`[nm�Y\Kh[^ba:LF&F`bz;>Kh[ V W Y\=\mnmnbLK-C Q [nln;S[nYeKSG�mR7 F*:L=\F&;>=e:<[nYebzKSm�:Ll]DZ;>mnD`_ [^b5_>D [^D`lnIZYeKSD [^fSD

!

Page 19: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0

Temperature (MeV)

5

10

G(M

eV)

(a) (b)

} Y\gz;>l]D kLA m14 N :i[H:5:LK>_ [^f>D`bzl]7�rtbzl Q K :LK>_�9�X�KJ;>F&=\D&Y A 9.:LK>D`=FN : P � Q KsAx9.:LKSD&=BN X^P � 9~X�AU f>D�mnbz=\Y\_�F`;>l]kLD&m�:<lnD�:L_>Ye:LXv:<[nYeF�[nf>D&l]I :<=hmnfv:Lp D4Iv;>F`[n;v:<[nYebzKBF*:<=eF`;>=q:i[^Y\bzK>m&A U f>D�mnf>:Lp D`m�G8D&l]D_>D [^D&l]IZYeK>D`_a;SmnY\K>g W Ye=\mnm]bzK-C Q [^l];S[^Y\K>mnGh75F&:L=eF`;>=e:<[^Y\bzK>m rtbzl [nf>D�lnD`_5F&;>lRkzD�V!G0fSYe=\D�=eY\yJ;>Ye_d_>l]bzpF*:<=eF`;>=q:i[^Y\bzK>mBG8D&l]D�;>m]D&_"rtbzl0[^f>D�gzl^:*7dF&;Sl]kzD<A�U f>D�F*:L=\F&;>=e:<[nYebzKSm�:Ll]D�[H:<GLD&KartlnbzI ?0D`r�A � � � � AU f>DEX>=q:<FHG�F`Yel]F&=\D&m :<K>_ gzl]D&D`K _>Ye:LIZbzK>_>m :LlnD�_v:<[^:�p bzY\KJ[nm�[^:LGLD`K rtlnbLI ?�D r�A � � � � AJU f>DwXS=q:LFHGF&Y\lnF`=eD`mMG8D&l]D0I�D&:Lmn;SlnD&_�;>m]YeK>gBY\K>D&=e:Lm][nYeF0m]F*:<[][^D&l]YeKSg!VbG0f>D&l]D*:Lm�[nf>D0gzlnD`D&KZ_>Ye:LIZbzK>_>m�:Ll]D{rtlnbzIrt;>m]YebzK8CoD`k<:Lp bzln:<[^Y\bzK IZD*:<mn;>l]D&IZD&Kh[^m`A�U f>D XS=e;>D [^lnYe:LK>gL=eD`m :LlnD�[H:LG<D&K rtl]bzI ?�D r�A � �z� � AxU f>Dbzln:LK>gzD�l]D&F`[^:LK>gz=\D&m�mnfSb G [^f>D�l^:<K>gzD�bLr�G0Ye_ [^f>m�IZD*:Lm];>lnD`_artbzl{[nf>D�gzlnbz;SK>_amR[H:<[nDLA

mnf>:Lp D`m&A6 bL[nf pv:LK>D`=em YeK } Yeg>A�kzA m�m]f>bUG-:L_>Ye:LXv:<[nYeFd[^f>D`lnI�:L=�mnfv:Lp D I>;>F`[n;v:<[^Y\bzK F&:L=eF`;>=e:<[^Y\bzK>m`A

| :L=\F&;>=e:<[nYebzKSmdG8D&l]DZp D`l]rtbzl]I�D`_ G0f>D&l]DZ[nf>DZmnfv:<p D`mdG8D&l]DZ_>D`[nD&lnIZY\K>D&_`G0Y [^f>Y\K [nf>D W Y\=\mnmnbLK-CQ [nln;S[nYeK>m]Gh7 rtbzl]I�:L=eY\mnI NtlnD&_ F&;>lRkzD P�:LK>_ =\Y\y�;SYe_ _Slnbzp rtbLlnI�:L=\Yem]I N gzln: 7 F`;>l]kLD PHA P K [^fSDW Y\=\mnmnbLK-C Q [nln;S[nYeKSmnGh75rtbzlnI�:L=\Yem]I Vvmnf>D`=e= DaJ�D`F`[^mE:Ll]D�F&bzK>m]Ye_SD&lnD`_ V�G0f>D&l]D*:Lm�Y\Kd[nf>D�=eY\yJ;>Y\_3_>l]bzprtbzl]I :<=eY\mnI [^fSD`7 :LlnDaK>bL[*A T cS:LIZYeKv:i[^Y\bzK bLr } Y\g>AWkzA mh: m]f>bUG0m'[^fv:<[ [^f>DaF*:L=\F&;S=q:<[nYebLK>m�:Ll]DK>D&:Lln= 7�Y\_>D`KJ[nYeF&:L= A.U f>Y\m mn;SgzgzD&mR[^m [nfv:<[�[nf>D pSlnbzp D&lR[^Y\D&m bLr :3lnbL[^:<[^Y\K>ga=eY\yJ;>Ye_�_Slnbzp F&:LK�X D;>m]D&_ [^b�_>D [^D&l]IZYeK>D [nf>D mnfv:<p DSIv;SF`[^;>:<[^Y\bzK>m�Y\K Q K V :Lm�:L=el]D*:L_ 7"IZD&Kh[^Y\bzK>D`_sA M m�_SYem]F&;>m]mnD&_p>l]D`k�YebL;>mn= 7bVJ=\YeyJ;>Y\_ _>l]bzp�p>lnD`_>YeF [^Y\bzK>m�F*:LKSK>bL[~X D�;SmnD&_Zrtbzl~9�XsAhU f>Y\m�Yem~D`k�Y\_>D&Kh[8YeK } Y\g>A!kzA mzXsAU f>DBYeKSY\[nYq:L=�mn;>p>pSlnD&m]mnY\bzK"bLrx[^fSD8L N ? G0Y\_S[^f5rtbz;>KS_aY\K39�Xdmnf>bL;>=e_dX D�:<X>mnD`KJ[EY\K Q KsAU f>D Dac Y\m][nYeK>g�_>:<[H: rtbzl Q K :LKS_ 9~X�gLD&K>D`l^:L=\=\73:Lgzl]D&D8G0Y [^f�F&:L=\F&;>=e:<[^Y\bzK>m � �z��� � � � A�C�bUG C

D`kLD&lTV>[^f>D�=\bUG D`m][0[^D`I�p D&ln:<[^;SlnD�_v:<[^: p bzY\Kh[0YeK Q K�Y\m0bzK'[^fSD�bzln_>D`l bLrMk �S� caDal =ebUG8D&l [^f>:LKp>l]D&_>Y\F`[nD&_ NtmnD&D } Y\g>A'kzA mh: PHA U fSYem�_>Yem]F&l]D&pv:LKSF`7 mn;>gzgLD&m][nm :5p bLmnmnY\X>= 7 mnY\gzK>Y uvF*:LKh[�_>D`k�Ye:<[^Y\bzKX D`[RG8D&D&K [nf>D&bzlR7 :LK>_ DqcSp D&l]YeIZD`KJ[&A U b�YeKhkzD`m][nYegh:i[^D3[nf>Yem _>Yem]F&l]D&pv:LKSF`7bV8[^f>D G0Ye_S[nf bLr�[^fSD

k �

Page 20: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

L N ? I�;>mR[{X D0I�D&:Lmn;SlnD&_':<[ D kzD`K'=ebUG8D&l~[^D`I�p D&ln:<[^;SlnD&m`A U fJ;>mTV�[nf>D�gzbh:L=vbLr [^f>Y\m~[^f>D`mnY\m-G :Lm[^bZIZD*:<mn;>l]DB[nf>D�L N ? G0Ye_S[nf":<[�: [nD&IZp D`l^:<[n;>lnDBX D&=\b G kzA � cdDTl A

����� ��� ����$&� ��'����+�� � ���.$*2"��~�B��$&�����

U f>D I�:��Rbzl]Y\[o7�bLr Dac p D&lnY\IZD&Kh[^m�p D&l]rtbLlnIZD&_ [nb�I�D&:Lmn;SlnD [^f>DWL N ?�G0Ye_S[nfZYeK Q KZ;>m]D&_ rt;>m]YebzK8CD`k<:Lp bzln:<[^Y\bzK5lnD&:LF`[nYebzKSm&A>U f>D`mnD�[o7�p D`mEbLrxl]D*:LF [^Y\bzK>m0F*:LKSK>bL[0X D�;>mnD`_d[nb�mR[^;>_ 7'[^f>D�L N ? :i[=\b G [nD&IZp D&l^:i[^;>l]D&m&A U ln:L_>Y [^Y\bzKv:L=~rt;>m]YebzK8CoD`k<:Lp bzln:<[^Y\bzK�Dqc p D`lnY\I�D`Kh[^m�:LlnD�=\YeIZY [^D&_ [nb3f>Y\gzf>D`l[^D`IZp D`l^:<[n;>lnD`mEX D&F&:L;>mnDBbLrx[^f>D | bz;S=ebzI�X3Xv:<lnlnY\D&l Y\K5[^f>D�D&Kh[nl^:LK>F`D�FHf>:LK>K>D`= AP K>D&=e:LmR[^Y\F�m]F*:<[][^D&l]YeKSg F&:LKaX D�;>mnD`_d[nbZm][^;S_S7�[^f>D�L N ? :<[0=\bUG [nD&IZp D`l^:<[n;>lnD`m&A P K>D`=q:LmR[^Y\F

��C mnF&:<[n[nD&lnY\K>g fv:Lm X D&D`K ;>m]D&_ [nb�IZD*:Lm];>lnDa[^f>D L N ? G0Y\_S[^f :Lm : rt;>K>F [^Y\bzK bLr�[nD&IZp D&l^:�C[^;SlnD � � � V � 9 �~Y\K�[^fSD pv:<m][*A � f>Y\=eD�[^f>Y\m�[o7 p D b<r lnD&:LF`[nYebzK Yem�K>bL[�=eY\IZY\[nD&_�[nbafSYegzf [^D&IZp D&l C:<[n;>lnD`m V [^f>D`lnD Y\m�:�_>Y ��F`;>=\[o73:Lm]mnb�F&Ye:<[^D`_ G0Y\[nf"Y\[&A P KSD&=e:Lm][nYeF ComnF&:<[n[nD&l]YeK>g�l]D*:LF [^Y\bzK>m�f>: kLD�[^fSD_>Y\m^:L_ kL:<KJ[^:LgzD [^f>:<[~Y\[�Yem~_>Y��F&;>= [~[^b�_>D`[nD&l]I�Y\K>D [^fSD�Y\K>Y [^Ye:L=>DqcSF`Y\[^:<[^Y\bzK�D&K>D`lngL7 � � nV � 9 � ALU f>Y\mY\m _>;>D�[^bZGJK>b�FHGLbz;S[�l]D*:LF [^Y\bzK>m�:LK>_5F&bLKJ[nlnY\X>;S[nYebzKSm0rtl]bzI b<[^f>D`l lnD*:<F`[^Y\bzK>m{[nfv:<[0_>bZK>b<[0=eD&:L_[^b�rt;>=\=vD&K>D`lngL7ZD`yJ;>Ye=\Y\X>lnY\;>I bLr�[nf>D0D&K>D`lngL7�=\bzmnm~bLr [^f>D�mnF&:<[n[nD&l]D&_ p>:Ll][nYeF`=eD<A�U fSDE=e:<[n[nD&l~DTJ D&F [X D&F&bLI�D`m{IZbzlnD�Y\I�p bzlR[H:LKh[5G0Y [^f YeKSF&lnD&:LmnY\K>g p>l]b��RD&F [^Y\=eDED&K>D`lngL7 =\bzmnm`A U f>DEF&bzKh[nlnY\X>;S[^Y\bzK'_S;>D[^b�GJK>b�FHGLbL;S[�lnD*:<F`[^Y\bzK>m F&:LK X D�l]D&_>;SF&D&_Xh7 ;>m]YeKSg f>D&:*k�74C YebzK m]F*:<[][^D&l]YeKSg :<m bzp>p bzmnD`_ [nb��C mnF&:<[n[nD&lnY\K>g � � m � AU f>Dwl]D*:LF [^Y\bzK D`IZp>=eb 7LD&_�Y\K [^f>Y\m�Dac p D`lnY\IZD&Kh[*G :Lm g ZR\ Q K>N gji V V gji V�� PHAJU f>D�p>lnb��RD`F`[nYe=\D gji V

G :Lm0FHf>bzmnD`Kartbzl m]D`kLD&l^:<=xl]D*:Lm]bzK>m`A M m0I�D`Kh[^Y\bzK>D&_3:LX b kLD�V>[nf>D�F&bzKh[^l]YeXS;S[^Y\bzK5rtlnbzI�GJK>b�FHGLbL;S[lnD&:LF`[nYebLK>m�:LK>_ bL[nf>D&l�p>l]b F`D&m]mnD&m~[^f>:<[~_>b�K>bL[~=\D*:<_Z[nb�rt;>=\=>D&K>D`lngL7 D&yJ;>Y\=eY\X>lnY\;>I bLr [nf>D D&K>D`lngL7=\bzmnmdbLr�[nf>D mnF&:<[n[nD&lnD`_ p>l]b��RD&F [^Y\=eD mnf>bL;>=e_ X D lnD`_>;>F`D&_2G0Y [^f f>D*:*kJ74CoY\bzK m]F*:<[][^D&l]YeKSg>A0U f>DK>D`;S[^l]bzK X>Y\K>_>Y\K>g�D&K>D`lngL7 bLrSgji V Y\m�:L=\mnb�kLD&l]7 =ebUG N[mSA k m�caDTl PHA U fSYem'Y\m'Y\IZp bzlR[H:LKh[5:<mG8DYG0Yem]f�[^b3mR[^;>_ 7�[H:<lngzD [ Dac F`Y\[^:<[^Y\bzK>m :<K>_�K>bL[�p>lnb��RD`F`[nYe=\D'Dac F`Y\[^:<[^Y\bzK>m`A P r [^f>D p>lnb��RD`F`[nYe=\DX D&F&bLI�D`mEDqc F&Y [^D&_dY\Kd[nf>D�mnF&:<[n[nD&lnY\K>g�p>lnb�F&D`mnmTV Y [ G0Y\=e= D`I�Y [ B3ln: 7�m G0Y [^fdD&K>D`lngzY\D&m0;>p5[^b [^fSDK>D`;S[^l]bzK X>Y\K>_>Y\K>gwD`K>D&l]gL7zA Q Y\K>F&D�[^f>D�K>D&; [^lnbLK X>Y\K>_>Y\K>g�D&KSD&lng<7�Y\m.=\bUGdV [^f>D`mnD B ln: 7�m�G0Ye=\= f>: kLD

kbk

Page 21: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

D&KSD&lngLYeD`m�X D&=\b G [nf>D�lnD&gLYebzK bLr{Y\Kh[^D`lnD&mR[*AxU f>D BDC l^:*7�D&KSD&lngLYeD`m p>lnbLX D`_�Y\K [nf>Yem�Dac p D&lnY\IZD&Kh[l^:<K>gzD�rtlnbzI � �S� �0caDal A P rS[nf>D8pSlnb��RD`F`[^Y\=\D8Y\m Dqc F&Y [^D&_�[^b0D&K>D`lngzY\D&m.:LX b kLD�[nf>D�K>D&;S[nlnbzKBX>Y\K>_>Y\K>gD&KSD&lng<7bV.Y [SG0Y\=e=8=ebLmnD [nf>D =\b bLmnD&= 7 X bz;SK>_�K>D&; [^lnbLK [^b3rtbzl]I g � V A.U f>D`mnD�D`kLD&Kh[^mZ:<lnD'D&:LmnY\=\7_>Y\mnF`lnY\I�Y\Kv:<[nD&_�:Lgh:LY\K>m][B:<m"G D _>D`I�:LK>_ :LK gji V rtln:LgzIZD&Kh[�[^b5X D YeK F`bzYeKSF&Y\_>D&K>F`DpG0Y [^f [^fSD_>D [^D&F [^D`_ B"ln: 7�m`A

k �

Page 22: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

� � ��� ��� �

� � � � ��� � ��� � � � � � � � �

U f>D Dqc p D`lnY\I�D`Kh[QG{:Lmwp D`l]rtbzl]I�D`_�:<[E[^f>D W :<[nYebzK>:L= Q ;>p D`lnF`bzK>_>;>F [^Y\K>g | 7�F&=\bL[^l]bzK � :LX bzl^:*C[^bLl]7 N WwQ>|{� PHA M p>l]YeI�:LlR7X D&:LI bLr8gji V G :Lm':<F&F&D`=eD`l^:<[nD&_ Xh7 [^f>D!Iek �L�z� F`7�F&=\bL[nlnbzK [nb� � cdDTl��iK�;SF&=\D&bzKsA.U f>D'X D*:LICG :Lm mnD`Kh[ _>bUG0K [^f>D':LKv:L= 7�mnY\m =eY\K>D [nba[nf>D Q�� �L� I�:LgzK>D [^Y\Fmnp D&F [^l]bzgzl^:<p>fsA CED`lnD�[^f>D�X D*:LI X bLI�Xv:Ll]_>D&_3: 9 A m4� IZg��iF&I Z [^:LlngLD`[�bLr4g ZR\ Q KsAU f>lnD`D5I : �Rbzl _>D`[nD&F [^bzlZm]7�mR[^D&IZm�G D`lnD5;>m]D&_YeK [^f>Y\m Dac p D&l]YeIZD&Kh[&A�U fSD&mnDdm]7�mR[^D&IZm�YeK8C

F&=\;>_>D`_ :LK :Ll]l^:*7"b<r{6{:<lnY\;>I } =\;>bzl]Ye_SD N 6{: } Z PEmnF&Y\Kh[^Y\=e=e:<[nbzlnmTV@:LK :Llnln: 7"bLr | D&mnY\;>I P b�_>Y\_>DN | m P P�mnF`YeKh[nYe=\=q:i[^bzl]m V�:LKS_�[^f>D Q�� �z� mnp D&F`[nlnbzIZD [^D&l`A�U f>D�6 : } Z m]F&Y\KJ[nYe=\=e:<[^bzl]mSG D`lnD';SmnD&_ [nbIZD*:Lm];>lnD�fSYegzf8CoD&KSD&lng<7 B l^:*7�m&A{U fSD | m P mnF&Y\Kh[^Y\=e=e:<[nbzlnm�_>D [^D`F`[^D`_ FHfv:LlngLD&_ pv:LlR[^Y\F&=\D&m&A U f>DQ�� �L� I�D&:Lmn;SlnD&_dY\K>D&=e:Lm][nYeF&:L=\=\7�m]F*:<[][^D`lnD&_ gji V pv:Ll][nYeF`=eD`m�:LK>_�bL[nf>D&l l]D*:LF [^Y\bzK5p>lnb�_>;>F [^m&ASU f>DQ�� �L� rtb�F*:L= p>=e:LK>D�_>D`[nD&F [^bzl]mw;>= [^Y\I�:<[^D`=\7a_>D`[nD&l]I�Y\K>D`_�mnF*:i[n[^D`lnD`_"pv:LlR[^Y\F&=\D�D&KSD&lng<7a=\bzm]m&A U f>Drtb�F*:L= p>=e:LK>DB_>D [^D&F [^bzl]mw:<=em]b':L=\=ebUG8D&_drtbzl�:LF&F`;>l^:<[nD�p>:Ll][nYeF`=eDBYe_SD&Kh[^Y uvF*:i[^Y\bzKsA M m]FHf>D&I�:<[nYeF�bLr[^fSDBm]D`[n;>p3Y\m0mnf>bUG0K3Y\K } Y\g>A � A kzAU f>D�6{: } Z mnF`YeKh[nYe=\=q:i[^bzl]mYG D`lnD�:<lnl^:<K>gzD&_ YeKh[nb�[RG b�F`=ebLmnD C pv:LFHG<D&_ :Llnln:*7 m`A T :LFHf :<lnl^:*7

F&bLK>mnY\m][nD&_ bLr � mnF`YeKh[^Y\=\=q:<[nbzlnm`A U fSD :Ll]l^:*7�m G8D&l]D p>=e:LF`D&_ :i[�:<K>gz=\D&mBbLr o ! � G0Y\[nf�l]D&mnp D&F [[^b [^f>DB[H:Ll]gzD`[EFHfv:LI�X D`l�bLr�[^fSD Q�� �L� A U fSD�gzD`bzIZD`[^lR73b<r�[^f>D :Llnln: 7�mEYem�m]f>bUG0K�YeK } YegSA � A � AU f>DZmnF`YeKh[nYe=\=q:i[^bzl]mdG8D&l]DZm][H:<FHGLD&_ YeK :YG :L=e=�[o7�p DZF&bzKSu>gz;>l^:i[^Y\bzKsAsU f>DZgh:<p�YeK�[^fSD�mR[H:LFHGJY\K>gmnFHfSD&IZD�G :Lm0K>D&F`D&m]m^:LlR7aX D&F&:L;>m]D�bLrx[^fSDB_SD&mnY\gzKabLr [nf>D Q�� �z� [^:LlngzD [0FHfv:LI�X D`lE_>b�bzl]m&A

k �

Page 23: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

Quad

rupole

Double

t

Sex

tupole

Ben

din

gD

ipole

Quad

rupole

Tri

ple

t

Tar

get

Cham

ber

Quad

rupole

s Q

1 a

nd Q

2

Inte

rmed

iate

Imag

e

D1 D

ipole

D2 D

ipole

Foca

l P

lane

Targ

et C

ham

ber

Are

a

CsI

Arr

ay

BaF

Arr

ay2

BaF

Arr

ay2

Bea

mT

o S

800

Tar

get

Cham

ber

Ion

Cham

ber C

RD

C2

E3E

2 E1S800 F

oca

l P

lan

e

CR

DC

1

} Y\gz;>l]D � A k 4 Q FHf>D&I�:<[nYeFBbLr.Dac p D`lnY\IZD&Kh[H:L=@m]D`[^;SpsA U f>Yem�_>ln:UG0Y\K>g�Yem0K>b<[ [^b�mnF*:<=eD<A

k m

Page 24: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

12345678

9101112131415

1617181920212223

24252627282930

3132333435363738

3940414243444546

47484950515253

5455565758596061

62636465666768

} Y\gz;>l]D � A � 4 Q FHf>D&I�:<[nYeF�k Y\DTG b<rsbzK>D�bLrs[nf>DE6{: } Z :Llnln:*7 m`A U fSDE_>D [^D`F`[^bLlnm{:<lnD�mnf>bUG0K�:Lm~[^fSDbzln:LK>gzD�fSDacS:LgzbzKSm&AvU f>DQG0f>Y [^D�[^ln:Lp D �&bLYe_>m*G8D&l]D�p>=q:<m][^Y\F�[^fv:i[0:LY\_>D&_5Y\K5[nf>D�m][^:LFHGJYeKSg bLrx[^fSD:Ll]l^:*7�m&AvU f>D�:L=\;>IZYeKJ;>I�rtln:LIZD�;>mnD`_a[^bZf>bL=e_5[^f>DB:Ll]l^:*7'[nbzgzD`[nf>D&l0Y\m�:L=em]bZD`k�Ye_SD&Kh[*A

U f>D Q�� �z� [H:<lngzD [0FHfv:LI�X D&l�_>b�bzlnm G8D&l]D�IZb�_>Y\u>D&_dYeKdbzln_SD&l [^bZgzD [�[nf>DB6{: } Z :Ll]l^:*7�mw:<mF&=\bzm]DB[nb�[nf>D�[H:Ll]gzD`[E:Lm0p bzmnm]YeX>=\DLA T :LFHfa_>b bLl fv:L_": F&: k�Y [o75[^fv:<[�Dqc [nD&K>_SD&_"Y\Kh[^bZ[^f>D�[H:<lngzD [FHfv:LI�X D`l&A M p>Y\D&F`D bLr�:L=\;>IZYeKJ;>I G :LmFG8D&=\_>D&_�[nb [^f>D�Xv:LFHG G{:<=e=xbLr�[^fSD�F*:*k�Y [o7a[nb'p>lnb k�Y\_>Dm][nlnD`K>gL[^f�ASU f>Y\m p>Y\D&F&D�b<rx:L=e;SI�Y\KJ;>I Dqc�[^D&KS_>D&_5Y\KJ[nb [^f>DwF*:*k�Y\[o7�Vv:LK>_�Y\m{D`k�Y\_>D&Kh[0Y\K } Y\g>A � A � AM m�:�lnD`mn;>= [ VhY [4G{:<m�KSD&F&D`mnmn:Ll]7Z[^b�mR[H:LFHG [nf>D06{: } Z mnF`YeKh[nYe=\=q:i[^bzl]mMG0Y [^f :�gh:LpZX D [RG D`D&K�[RG bBbLr[^fSD{lnbUG0m&AL9 bzm]Y\[nYebLK>YeKSg�[^f>D :<lnl^:*7�m.F`=ebLmnD&l�[nbE[nf>D [H:<lngzD [�gzY kzD`m�:w=e:LlngzD`l.m]bz=eY\_Z:LK>gL=eD{F`b kzD&ln:LgzDsVG0f>Y\FHf3l]D&mn;S=\[nmEY\K3: f>Y\gzf>D`l0_>D`[nD&F`[nYebLK3D ��F`YeD`K>F`7LAU f>D | m P m]F&Y\Kh[^Y\=e=e:<[^bLlnm'G D`lnD�IZbz;>Kh[^D`_ Y\K>mnY\_>D [^fSD Q � �z� [H:<lngzD [~FHfv:LI�X D&l`AJU f>D&l]D�G8D&l]Ddkbk

bLr [nf>D&m]D�mnF`YeKh[^Y\=\=q:<[nbzlnm Y\K5:L=\= A W Y\K>D�b<r [^f>D`mnD�m]F&Y\KJ[nYe=\=e:<[^bzl]m*G D`lnD�:<[][H:LFHfSD&_'[^b�[^f>DElnb�bLr@bLr [^fSD[H:<lngzD [�FHfv:LI�X D`l V G0fSYe=\D [^f>D�[RG b�IZbzmR[�rtbzl7G :Ll]_�_>D`[nD&F`[nbzlnmFG D`lnDZ:<[][H:LFHf>D`_�[^b [nf>D�rtbzlAG{:Ll]_G :L=e= A M p>Y\F`[n;>lnDZbLr�[^f>D | m P :Ll]l^:*7"Y\m�mnf>bUG0K�Y\K } Y\g>A � A m>AsU f>DZIZbzmR[�rtbzl7G :Lln_ _>D [^D&F [^bzl�Y\K[^fSDEp>Y\F`[n;>lnD�G :Lm8l]D&IZb kzD`_'rtbzl�[^f>D0ln;SKsAJU f>Dw:<lnl^:*7ZF`b kLD&l]D&_'m]F*:<[][^D&l]YeKSg :LK>gL=eD`m :Lm�Y\K>_>Y\F*:<[nD&_Y\KaU :LX>=\D � A kLA

k��

Page 25: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

} Y\gz;>l]D � A � 4v9xD&lnm]p D`F`[nY\kLD _>ln: G0YeK>g�b<r�[^f>D Q�� �z� [^:LlngLD`['FHf>:LI�X D&l'_Sb bzl`A W bL[^Y\F&Da[^f>D3:L=e;8CIZYeKJ;>I Dqc�[^ln;SmnY\bzKartl]bzI [nf>D�_>b bLl F*:*k�Y\[o7LA

1

23

4

5

6

7

89

10

11

} Y\gz;>l]D � A m14>U fSDw_>Y\lnD`F`[^Y\bzK'b<rs[^f>D�X D*:LI Y\m�rtl]bzI =eD r [8[nb�l]Yegzfh[8YeK X bL[nf pv:<K>D&=\m&A � D`r [ 4�9�f>bL[nbbLr�[nf>D | m P :Llnln:*7zA~U f>D"IZbzmR[ rtbzlAG{:<ln_ _>D [^D`F`[^bLl�G :Lm l]D&IZb kzD&_ _S;>lnY\K>g�[nf>D3DqcSp D&l]YeIZD`KJ[&A?0Yegzfh[�4vU bzp5k�YeDaG bLr [^f>D | m P :Ll]l^:*7zAvU f>D | m P _>D`[nD&F [^bzl]mw:Ll]D�_>D&pSYeF [^D&_":Lm gzlnD`D&KaF`7�=eY\K>_>D`lnm`A

k�

Page 26: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

W ;>I�X D&l � N _>D`gzlnD`D&maP ��N _SD&gzl]D&D&mqPk �z� �L�� � �� ! � �m k �L� �� k�� � � k � � �9 C k�� � �� C k �L� �! C ! � �k � C � �kbk C �z� �L�

U :LX>=\D � A k 4 � :LX :LK>gz=\D&m�bLrE[^f>D | m P _>D [^D`F`[^bLlnm&A���YemZ[^fSDam]F*:<[][^D&l]YeKSg�:LK>gz=\D�V�:LKS_�� Y\m [^fSD: �`YeI�;S[^fv:<= :LK>gz=\DLA U f>D � C�: c Y\m Yem gLY\kLD&K Xh7 [nf>D�_>Y\lnD&F [^Y\bzK�bLr0[^fSD'X D&:LI5A.U f>D K�;SI�X D&lnY\K>gmnFHfSD&IZD�Y\m�:Lm0YeK } Y\g>A � A m>A

� ��� ( w���/ �����~� ����2 � � ��~$*� ��'����+ ( �d$*/���

� ��� �����hDW=%17)5�!179A9A���< M��&6{: } Z Yem�:<K�YeK>bLlngh:LKSYeF m]F&Y\Kh[^Y\=e=e:<[^bLl&AsU f>D m]F&Y\Kh[^Y\=e=e:<[^Y\bzK =\Yegzfh[�F`bzK>mnY\m][nm�bLr~[RG b�F`bzIZp bLK>D&Kh[^mTVKv:LIZD`=\7 [nf>D r :Lm][~F`bzIZp bLK>D&Kh[8:LK>_ [^fSD�m]=ebUG F&bzIZp bzK>D&Kh[&AhU f>D r :Lm][~F`bzIZp bzKSD&Kh[�fv:Lm�:�_>D&F&: 7[^Y\IZD0bLr � A �K>m~D&IZY [n[nD&_�YeKZ[^f>D m]f>bzlR[MG :*kzD`=eD`K>gL[^f N �z�L� KSIrP l]D&gzY\bzKZbLr [^f>D0mnp D&F [^l];>I V G0fSYe=\D[^fSD mn=\bUGF&bzIZp bzK>D&Kh[�f>:Lm�: �z� KSm�_>D&F&:*7�[nYeIZD{:i[�G : kLD&=\D&K>g<[^f>m�=\bzK>gzD`l N � k � KSIrP�[^fv:<K�[^fv:i[bLr�[nf>D�r :LmR[�F&bLI�p bzK>D`Kh[ � � � � A U f>D�kLD&l]73mnf>bLl][�_>D`F*:*73[nYeIZD b<r�[^f>D�r :<m][�F`bzIZp bLK>D&Kh[�I�:LG<D&m6{: } Z :LK Dac F`D&=\=eD`KJ[�m];>X-CoK>:LK>bzm]D&F&bLK>_ [^Y\I�Y\K>g�_>D [^D`F`[^bLl&A P KZ:L_S_>Y\[nYebLK�[^b�[nf>D{Dac F`D&=\=eD`KJ[~[nYeIZY\K>gF*:<pv:LX>Y\=eY [^Y\D&m�bLr06{: } Z V Y [ :L=\mnbafv:Lm�:af>Y\gzf _>D&K>m]Y\[o7+N[mSA � !5g��<F`I�Z P � � ! � A@U f>D fSYegzf _>D&KSmnY [o7I�:LGLD`m�[nf>Y\m�I�:<[nD&l]Yq:L= gLb b�_�rtbzl B3ln: 7'_>D`[nD&F`[nYebLKsAU f>D0[RG b�:Llnln: 7�m�bLr�6{: } Z mnF`YeKh[^Y\=\=q:<[nYebLK _>D [^D&F [^bzl]m-G8D&l]Dw:Lm]mnD`I�X>=\D&_5:LKS_ Y\K>m][^:L=\=eD`_':<[~[^fSD

W�QS|{� A<U f>D06{: } Z _>D`[nD&F [^bzl]m�X D`=ebzKSgw[^b V :LG�?0Ye_>gLD W :<[nYebLKv:L= � :<X bzln:<[^bLl]7�N V ? Ww� P V<U DqcS:LmM� c j�K>Y kzD&l]mnY [o7 N U M cajdP VL:LK>_ZcdYeFHf>Y\gh:LK Q [H:<[nD{jEKSY\kLD&lnm]Y\[o7 N c Q jQPHA M =\= m]F&Y\Kh[^Y\=e=e:<[^bLlnm~:Ll]DlnD`gz;>=e:Ll{f>DqcS:LgzbzK>m`ASU f>D V ? Ww� :LK>_�U M caj mnF`YeKh[^Y\=\=q:<[nbzlnm f>: kLD�:�=\D&K>gL[nf�+� k�!7G���F`I :<K>_f>Dqc>:<gzbzKv:L=@F`lnbzm]mwmnD`F`[nYebzK3bLr�Y\K>mnF`lnY\X D`_"l^:L_SYe;>m � � � G � � F&I5A U f>D c Q j _>Y\IZD&K>m]YebLK>m�_>YKJ�D`lY\K�[^fv:i[�[^fSD`7 fv:*kzD�K� � m1G��5F&I):LK>_��!� � G �L� F&I5A U f>D k<:LlnY\bz;>m�6{: } Z _>D`[nD&F`[nbzlnmSG8D&l]D

k�9

Page 27: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

BaF Crystal2

Strap

PMT

Frame

Base

} Y\gz;>l]D � A �74 9 D`lnmnp D&F [^Y kzD _>l^: G0Y\K>g bLr�: 6{: } Z m]F&Y\KJ[nYe=\=e:<[^bzl`A M =\=wF`bzIZp bzKSD&Kh[^md:Ll]D�mnf>bUG0KDac F`D&pS[�rtbzl{[^fSDBI�:<[nD&l]Yq:L=\m0;>mnD`_a[nb�G0ln:Lp5[^f>D�F&lR7�m][H:<= A

m][^:LFHGLD`_�YeKh[nb [^fSD�:Ll]l^:*7�m�:Lm0rtbz=\=ebUG0m 4�k � k�� U M c3j�V�k� � nk V ? Ww� V :LK>_ ��� � c Q j�A U f>DKJ;>I�X D&l]YeKSg�m]FHf>D&IZD rtbz=\=ebUG0m�[^f>:<[�bLr } Y\g>A � A � A M =\= [nbzgzD`[nf>D&l k � �6{: } Z _SD`[^D`F`[nbzlnmHG8D&l]D�;SmnD&_�AT :LFHf 6{: } Z _>D`[nD&F`[nbzl'F`bzK>mnY\m][nD&_ bLr�:�6{: } Z F`l]7�m][^:L=[V p>f>b<[^bzI�;>=\[nYepS=eY\D&l [n;>X D N 9�caUBP_V

m][nl^:Lp VLrtl^:LIZDsVh:LK>_�Xv:Lm]DLAzU f>D0F`l]7�m][^:L=!G{:<m8:i[n[H:<FHf>D&_Z[^b�[nf>D�98cdU Xh7 ;>m]D�b<r bLpS[^Y\F*:L=SgzlnD&:LmnD<AU f>Y\m�gzlnD&:LmnD Y\m�[^ln:LK>mnp>:LlnD`KJ[�[nb'[^f>DZ;>= [^ln: k�Y\bz=\D`[�=\Yegzfh[�D`I�Y [n[nD&_ YeK 6{: } Z AsU f>D F`l]7�m][^:L=HG :Lm[^fSD&K G0l^:<p>p D`_ YeK"[nDTIvbzK"[^:Lp DLA�U fSD [^DTI>bzK"[H:Lp D gzY kzD`m�[^f>D�D&_>gzD`m�bLr~[^f>D�F&l]7�mR[H:L=�: f>YegLf>=\7lnDaIvD&F [^Y kzD�m];>l]r :LF`D�V%G0f>Y\FHf lnD`mn;>= [^m Y\K�I�: c Y\I�;>I =\Yegzfh[�F&bz=\=eD`F`[nYebzK�A V K>F`D F&bz:<[^D`_hG0Y\[nf�[^fSD[^DaIvbzK3[^:Lp D�V [^f>D�F&l]7�mR[H:L=�G{:LmWG0l^:LpSp D`_ G0Y\[nf"X>=e:LFHGaD`=eD`F`[nlnY\F*:L=x[H:Lp DLA U f>D�XS=q:LFHG5[H:<p D�p>lnb C_>;>F`D&_�:5F`b kzD&l]YeKSga[^f>:<[QG{:<m�=\YegLfJ[�[nYegzfh[&AsU ba:LY\_ YeK [^f>DZmR[^lnD`K>gL[nf bLr�[^fSD�F`bz;>p>=\Y\K>gab<r [^fSD9�caU [nbd[nf>DZF&l]7�mR[H:L=[Vx:5rtln:LIZD :<K>_ mR[^ln:Lp�G8D&l]D ;>m]D&_sA@U f>Y\m�:L=em]bafSD&=\p D`_�Y\K [nf>D mR[H:LFHGJY\K>gbLr8[^f>D :Llnln:*7 m`A M Xv:<mnD�G{:LmB[^f>D`K :<[][H:LFHfSD&_ [nbd[nf>D 98cdU rtbzlB:Lp>p>= 7�YeK>gdkzbz= [H:<gzDLA } Y\g>A � A �mnfSb G0m�DacS:LF [^= 75f>bUG [nf>D�kL:<lnY\bz;>m0F&bzIZp bzK>D`KJ[nmEb<r [nf>DB6{: } Z _>D`[nD&F [^bzl]mWG8D&l]D�F`bzK>K>D`F`[^D`_sA

� ���� � &���� �������

| m P Y\m :LK�Y\K>bzlngz:LK>Y\F'mnF`YeKh[^Y\=\=q:<[nbzl&A | m P Yem�[o7�p>Y\F*:<=e= 7 :LF [^Y kL:i[^D&_ G0Y [^f�D`Y\[nf>D&l [nfv:L=\=eY\;>I N U = PbzlZmnb�_>Y\;>I N W : PHA�U f>DamnF`YeKh[^Y\=\=q:<[nbzlnm ;>mnD`_ Y\K [^fSYem Dac p D`lnY\IZD&Kh[.G8D&lnD3:LF`[nY\k<:<[nD&_G0Y\[nf U = AU f>DElnD&m];>= [^Y\K>g mnF`YeKh[nYe=\=q:i[^Y\bzK�=eY\gzfh[8F&bzK>m]YemR[^m{b<rs[RG b�F&bzIZp bzK>D&Kh[nm VSK>:LIZD&= 7�[nf>DEr :<m][ :LK>_ m]=ebUG

k �

Page 28: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

F&bLI�p bzK>D`Kh[*AJU f>D r :Lm][~F`bzIZp bLK>D&Kh[�fv:Lm�:�_>D&F&:*7 [^Y\I�D0bLr � A ��� m Vz:LK>_Z[^f>D0mn=\bUG F`bzIZp bzKSD&Kh[fv:Lm�:a_>D`F*:*7 [^Y\I�D bLr � A � m � m&A@U f>D [RG8b"F&bLI�p bzK>D`Kh[^m bLr{=eY\gzfh[ D`I�Y [n[nD&_ :L=\=\b G0m�rtbzl�pS;>=em]Dmnf>:Lp DB_>Y\mnF`lnY\I�Y\Kv:<[nYebLK3[^b�_>YKJ�D`lnD&Kh[nYq:<[nD�:<I�bLK>g _SY J D&l]D&Kh[w[o7�p D&mwb<r�l^:<_>Yq:i[^Y\bzKsAvU f>DB_>D&KSmnY [o7Y\m5m>A �nkwIZg��iF&I Z � � ! � A�U fSDwmnF`YeKh[nYe=\=q:i[^bzl]m5G D`lnD�F 7�=eY\K>_>l]YeF&:L=�Y\K m]fv:Lp D�V G0Y\[nf�:�=\D&K>gL[nf bLr � F&I:LK>_d_>Ye:LIZD`[nD&l0bLr-kzA�� F`IdAU f>D | m P m]F&Y\KJ[nYe=\=e:<[^bzl]mMG8D&l]Dw:<mnmnD`I�X>=\D&_':Lm�rtbz=e=\bUG0m�4zuvl]m][ V :<=e=>XS;S[�bzK>D0D&K>_ bLr [^f>D0F&lR7�m][H:<=

G :Lm5G0l^:<p>p D`_�YeK [^DTI>bzK [H:<p D<A M m{YeK [^f>D�F&:LmnDEbLrx6{: } Z V�[nf>Y\m{gh:*kzD�[^f>D�D`_>gzD`m{bLr [^fSDwF&lR7�m][H:<=: f>Y\gzf>= 7 l]DTIvD`F`[^Y kzD mn;Sl]r :LF`DLA{U f>Y\m5Yem�Y\IZp bLl][H:<KJ[ rtbzl'I�: c YeI�;>I =\YegLfJ['F&bz=\=eD`F`[nYebzK�A W Dac�[ V[^fSD G0ln:Lp>p D&_F&lR7 mR[H:L= G :LmZp>;S[�Y\KJ[nb�:<K :<=e;>IZY\KJ;>I F*:LK�A�U f>D3:<=e;>IZY\KJ;>I F*:LKmnD`l]kLD&_ [nbp>l]bL[^D`F`[�[^fSD F&lR7 mR[H:L=�:LK>_�[^b�m]D*:L=�Y [�rtl]bzI-bL;S[^m]Ye_>D =\Y\gzfh[*A } Y\Kv:L=\= 7bVs:'pSf>bL[^bLI�;>= [^Y\p>=\YeD`l�[n;>X DG :Lmw:i[n[H:<FHf>D&_5[^b [^fSDBD`K>_dbLr [nf>D�F&lR7 mR[H:L=@K>b<[ G0l^:Lp>p D&_aYeK5[H:<p D<A

� ���� D������(# ���-)"�>�!13= DF����= �<�� ��-���4�Q/

U f>D Q � �z� m]p D`F`[^l]bzIZD`[nD&l Y\m{F&bzIZp bzmnD`_5bLr@:LK5:LK>:L=\7�m]Yem{=\Y\K>D�:LK>_�:�I :<gzK>D`[nYeFwmnp D&F`[nlnbzgLl^:Lp>f�AU f>D�:LKv:L= 7�mnY\mw=\YeK>DBF&bLK>mnY\m][nm�bLr.rtbL;>lEX D&KS_>YeKSg _>Y\p bL=eD`m V bzK>DBy�;>:L_>ln;Sp bz=\DB_>bz;>X>=\D`[ V uSkzD�yJ;v:�C_>l];>p bL=eD�[^l]YepS=eD [^m V :LKS_drtbz;Sl�m]Dac�[^;Sp bz=\D&mSN Q D`D } YegSA � A k PHA>U f>DBI�:LgzK>D [^Y\F�m]p D`F`[nlnbzgzln:Lp>fdF&bzK8C[H:<YeK>m�[RG8bd_>Yep bz=\D I�:LgzK>D [^mpN N kZ:<K>_ N � P V [RG b5yJ;v:L_>l];>p bz=eD`m�N �Sk�:LK>_ � � P V�:LK>_ :'mnD`lnY\D&mbLr�_>D [^D&F [^bzl]m�YeK Y [^m�rtb�F*:L= p>=q:<K>D � m � � A U f>D rtb F&:L=.pS=q:LKSD _>D`[nD&F`[nbzlnm�F`bzK>mnY\m][�b<r�[RG8bdF*:<[nf>b _SDlnD&:L_>bz; [E_SlnY r [0FHfv:LI�X D&l]m V :LK5YebLKaFHfv:<I�X D&l V :LKS_5[nf>lnD`D�pS=q:LmR[^Y\F�mnF&Y\Kh[^Y\=e=e:<[nbzlnm � m<k�� AU f>D�I�:LgzK>D [^Y\F�mnp D&F [^l]bzgzl^:<p>f�X D`K>_>m m]F*:<[][^D&l]D&_'rtln:LgzIZD&Kh[^m{[nb Y [^m rtb�F*:L= p>=e:LK>D<ASU f>Dw[RG8b

yJ;v:L_>l];>p bz=eD`m�rtb F`;>m�rtl^:<gzIZD&Kh[^m�Y\K"[^f>D�_>Yem]p D`lnm]Y\kLD N c PE:<K>_�K>bzK-C _>Y\mnp D&lnm]Y\kLD Nt7�P0_>Y\lnD`F`[^Y\bzK>m`AU f>D�[RG8b�_>Y\p bL=eD�I�:LgzKSD`[^m�fv:*kzDd: X D`K>_>Y\K>g l^:L_>Y\;>mZbLr � A � IEG0Y\[nf :�I�: c YeI�;>I F&D`Kh[^l^:<=uvD`=e_ bLr"kzA 5UQVxgLY\k�Y\K>g3:<K�b kzD`l^:L=\=~X D`K>_>Y\K>g3p bUG D`l�bLr5maU I5A@U f>Y\m�l]D&mn;S=\[nm�Y\K :LK :LK>gL;>=q:<l:LF`F&D&p [H:LK>F`D�bLr 9 :LK>_`k � Y\K�[^f>D�_SYem]p D`lnmnY kzD�:LK>_�KSbzK-Co_SYem]p D`lnmnY kzDB_>Y\lnD`F`[^Y\bzK>mTVvlnD`mnp D&F`[nY\kLD&= 7� m!k�� Ah?�;SK>K>Y\K>g�[^f>D m]p D`F`[^l]bzgzln:Lp>fZYeKZ_>Y\mnp D&l]mnY\bzK-C I :i[^FHf>D`_ VJD&K>D`lngL74Co=\bzm]m�IZb�_>D F&bLI�p D&KSm^:<[nD&mrtbzl@Y\KJ[nlnY\K>mnY\F X D*:<I IZbzIZD&Kh[^;>I m]p>lnD&:L_>Y\K>g�Y\KB[nf>D8_SYem]p D`lnmnY kzD _>Yel]D&F [^Y\bzK VUG0f>Y\FHf Ye_SD*:L=\=\7BgzY kzD`m:��&D&l]b C G0Y\_S[nf Y\I�:LgzD�:<[�[^f>D rtb�F*:L=.p>=q:<K>D � m � � A U f>D Q�� �L� Y\m�F*:Lpv:<X>=eD�bLr8F&bzl]lnD`F`[^Y\K>gZp �<p

k�!

Page 29: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

Xh72k��)rtbzl D kzD`l]7 k � F&I :<[�[^fSD3_>Y\mnp D&l]mnY kzD�Y\I :<gzDLA�U f>D"b kzD`l^:L=\=wD`K>D&l]gL7 :LF&F`D&pS[^:LK>F`D"bLr[^fSD _>D`k�Y\F&D�Yemek � ��A } bLl�: kzD`l]7�_>D [H:LY\=\D&_ _>D&m]F&lnY\pS[nYebzK bLr~[^f>D Q � �z� :LK>_ Y [^m�bzp D&ln:<[^Y\bzK mnD`D?0D`r�A � m � � A

� .:���>���>'�� ').0�>� ��� 1 �*� � � ��.D+��(')�*6

U f>D | :<[^f>b�_>D�?�D&:L_>bz;S[ N lnY r [ | fv:LI�X D&l]m�N | ? N�| k :<K>_ | ? N�| � P :<lnD�p bzm]Y\[nYebzKamnD`K>mnY [^Y kzD_>D [^D&F [^bzl]m0YeK5[^f>D Q � �z� rtb F&:L=sp>=e:LK>D<AvU f>DB:LF`[nY\kLDB:LlnD&:Zb<r.D&:LFHfa_SD`[^D`F`[nbzl0Yem �z� F`I � ��! F&IG0Y [^f�:LK3:LF`[nY\kLD�_>D`pS[^f3bLr kzA �ZF`I5A U f>DBkzbz=\;>IZD bLr.[^f>DB_>D`[nD&F [^bzl]mwY\mEuv=\=eD`_ G0Y [^f�:�I�Y c�[^;>l]DbLr � � � |{} � :LKS_ �<� � | � C g \ gh:Lm0:i[w: p>l]D&m]mn;>l]D�bLr-k m � Uxbzlnl � m!k�� AU f>D�gh:<m{YeK [^f>D�_SD`[^D`F`[nbzl kzbL=e;>IZD�Y\m{Y\bzK>Y �&D`_�XJ7 FHfv:Ll]gzD&_�p>:Ll][nYeF`=eD`m pv:Lmnm]YeKSg [^f>l]bz;>gzf'Y [*A

U f>D D`=eD`F`[^l]bzK>m�F`lnD*:i[^D&_ Y\K�[^f>Y\m�p>l]b F`D&mnm�_SlnY r [�[^f>l]bz;>gzf :'l]D&gzY\bzK G0Y [^f :'F&bLK>m][^:LKh[�D&=\D&F`[nlnY\FuvD`=e_;>Kh[^Y\={[^f>D 7�lnD&:LFHf : gLlnbz;>KS_>D&_ } lnY\mnFHfgzlnY\_sA V K>F&D�[nf>D5gzlnY\_ YemZpv:Lm]mnD`_ V�FHfv:Ll]gzDd:LI Cp>=\Y\u>F*:<[nYebzKhN D`=eD`F`[nlnbzKa:*kL:<=q:LKSFHf>D P�[H:<GLD&m�p>=e:LF&DB:LKS_5[nf>D�D&=\D&F [^lnbLK>mw:<lnD�:LF`F&D&=\D&ln:<[^D`_a[nb G :Ll]_>m[^fSD5:LK>b�_>DYG0Y\lnDLA�U fSD5:LK>b�_>D.G0Yel]D�Yem [o7�p>Y\F*:<=e= 7�GLD`pS[ :<[rk m �z� l~bz= [^m`A | :<[^fSb _>D�p>:L_>mZ:Ll]D=\b F&:<[^D`_ Y\K�rtl]bzKh[8b<r :LK>_ X D`f>Y\K>_ [nf>Dw:<K>b _SD�G0Y\lnD<A U fSD&lnDE:Ll]D �z� mBF&:<[^fSb _>D�pv:L_Sm8Y\K':L=\= AhU f>D} lnY\mnFHf'gLlnY\_ Y\K>mn;SlnD&m8[^fv:<[~[nf>DEY\Kh[^D`gzl^:<[nYebLK b kzD`l{:L=\= pv:L_�mnY\gzKv:L=\m-G0Y\=e= X DEY\K>_>D`p D`K>_>D`KJ[{bLrs[^fSDFHfv:Ll]gzD&_artl^:LgzIZD`KJ[ � mEYeKh[nD&l^:<F`[^Y\bzK"_SYemR[H:LK>F`D�rtl]bzI�[^f>D�:LK>b�_>D<A U fSYemEYemE_>;>D�[^b [nf>D�r :LF`[�[^fv:i[K>bZFHfv:Ll]gzD�:LIZp>=eY uvF&:<[^Y\bzK5[H:LG<D&m�p>=q:<F&D�YeK5[^fSDBl]D&gzY\bzKdbLr F&bzK>mR[H:LKh[�D&=\D&F [^l]YeF�uvD&=\_� m � � AU f>D�_>Yem]p D`lnm]Y\kLD N cXP�p bzmnY [^Y\bzK Yem�_>D [^D`lnIZYeKSD&_�G0Y [^f : LB:<;>mnm]Yq:LK u>[�b kzD`l�K>bzK-C��&D&l]bap>:L_

mnY\gzKv:<=em`A�U f>D F`D&Kh[^l]bzY\_ b<r�[^f>DBu>[�gzY kzD`mw[^f>D�p bzm]Y\[nYebLKsA�U f>D�K>bzK-C _>Yem]p D`lnm]Y\kLD Nt7�P0p bzmnY [^Y\bzK"Y\m_>D [^D&l]IZYeK>D`_5XJ7 IZD*:Lm];>lnY\K>g [^fSDw_>l]Y\r [{[nYeIZD�b<rs[^f>DwD&=\D&F`[nlnbzKSm{rtlnbzI [^fSD�p bLYeKh[{b<r@YeKh[^D`l^:LF [^Y\bzK[^b�[^f>D�:<K>b _SDLA�U f>D�p bzmnY [^Y\bzK�lnD`mnbz=\;S[nYebzK�b<r [^f>D`mnD�_>D [^D`F`[^bLlnm Y\m{_>D&m]YegLK>D&_�[^b�X DEX D [n[^D`l [^f>:LK� A m � IZI�YeKdX bL[^f5_>Y\lnD`F`[^Y\bzK>m`A

� � ����4.:����� � ��.0+��(')�

U f>D'Y\bzK>Y �*:i[^Y\bzK FHfv:LI�X D`l N PR| P�Y\m :a_>D`[nD&F`[nbzl�[nfv:<[ gLY\kLD&m D&KSD&lng<7�=\bzmnm�YeKSrtbLlnI�:<[^Y\bzKsAxU f>Y\m_>D [^D&F [^bzl Yem : mR[H:LKS_v:Lln_ } l]Yem]FHf5gzlnY\_>_>D`_�YebzK FHfv:LI�X D&l{[nfv:<[ Y\m{m]D&gzIZD&Kh[nD&_5YeKh[nbrk� �bzK>D CoY\K>FHf

�L�

Page 30: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

:LK>b�_>D`m�p D`lnp D&K>_>Y\F&;S=q:Ll�[nb'[^f>D p>:<[^f�bLr~[nf>D YebLK>m � m!k�� A�U f>D PR| kzbz=\;>IZD Yem�u>=e=\D&_ G0Y [^f 9 k �gh:Lm :<[ :�p>lnD`mnm];>lnD�b<r �z�z� Uxbzl]l&AJU f>Y\m{gh:Lm8Yem2! � � :LlngLbzK':LKS_ k � � IZD`[nfv:LK>D<A Q :<I�pS=eY\K>g [^fSDD&KSD&lng<7 =ebLmnm~:L=\bzK>g�[nf>D0pv:<[^f [nf>lnbL;>gzf [^f>D PR| lnD`_>;>F`D&m~[^f>D K>bLYem]D�VJ:LK>_ pSlnb k�Ye_>D`m :<KZ:LF&F`;>l^:<[nDD&KSD&lng<7)C =ebLmnm�mnY\gzKv:L= A

� �4�, ���,/5/5.-���5�� 13'4��'8�����A�*6

U f>D"=e:LmR[�mnD [�bLr�_>D [^D`F`[^bLlnm�Y\K [^f>D Q�� �z� rtb�F*:<=�pS=q:LKSD�:LlnD3:�mnD`lnY\D&m�bLr�m]F&Y\Kh[^Y\=e=e:<[^bLlnm&A U f>DmnF`YeKh[nYe=\=q:i[^bzl]m�p>lnb k�Ye_SD"rtl^:LgzIZD`KJ['D&K>D`lngL7 =ebzm]m5:LK>_ [nbL[H:L=�D&KSD&lng<7 Y\KSrtbzlnI�:<[nYebLKsA8U fSD`7 F&:LK:L=\mnb�X D';>m]D&_�rtbzl�[nYeIZY\K>g�p>;>l]p bzm]D&m`A�U f>D&l]D5:LlnD [^f>l]D&D�mnF`YeKh[nYe=\=q:i[^bzl]m YeK :L=\= A.U f>D'uvl]m][ZbzKSDN T ksP�Yem �3F`I)[nf>YeFHGXV�G0fSYe=\D'[^f>D�m]D&F`bzK>_ N T � PB:<K>_ [^f>Y\ln_ N T � PB:Ll]D k � :LKS_ �<� F&I [^f>Y\FHGXVlnD`mnp D&F [^Y kzD&= 7zA M =e=x[^f>l]D&D mnF`YeKh[nYe=\=q:i[^bzl]m�:LlnD I�:L_SD bLr~p>=e:Lm][nYeF<A � Yegzfh[�gz;SYe_>D`m�:LlnD :<[n[^:LFHf>D&_"[nbX bL[^f D&K>_>m bLrs[^fSDwp>=e:Lm][nYeFsVS:<K>_�9�caU m :Ll]D�:<[][H:LFHfSD&_ [nb�[^fSDw=\Yegzfh[ gz;>Y\_>D&m`ASU f>DE=eY\gzfh[{gz;SYe_>D`m_>Y\lnD`F`[~[^f>D0=\YegLfJ[�F`lnD*:i[^D&_�Y\K�[nf>D0mnF&Y\Kh[^Y\=e=e:<[nYebzK p>lnb�F&D`mnm~rtlnbzI [^f>D0p>=e:LmR[^Y\F0[nbB[nf>D�9�caU m&AJU f>Y\mlnD`mn;>= [^m�Y\K�f>Y\gzf>D`l�=eY\gzfh[�F&bL=e=\D&F [^Y\bzKsAsU f>D T k m]F&Y\KJ[nYe=\=e:<[^bzl"G :Lm�:<=em]b�;>mnD`_ [nb�_>D`[nD&l]I�Y\K>D [^fSD[^Y\IZD C bLr C IvY\gzfh[0bLrxrtl^:LgLI�D`Kh[^m�lnD&=e:<[nY\kLDB[nbZ[nf>D�F`7�F&=\bL[nlnbzKdl^:L_SYebZrtlnD`y�;SD&K>F 7�N ? } PHA

� ��� � +&�/0���~����$*/��

U f>Y\m8Dqc p D`lnY\I�D`Kh[ ;S[nYe=\Y �&D&_�[^f>l]D&D0_>YKJ�D`lnD`KJ[�D`=eD`F`[^l]bzK>Y\FEmR7�m][^D`IZm&A�U f>D&m]DEmR7 mR[^D`I�m8F&bzl]lnD`mnp bzK>_[^b�[nf>Dw6 : } Z :Llnln:*7bV | m P :Llnln: 7�VJ:LK>_ Q�� �z� mnp D&F [^l]bzIZD`[^D`l&AJU*G8b�_>YKJ�D`lnD`KJ[�[^fSlnD&m]f>bz=\_ m]D`[n[nYeKSgzmG8D&lnD�;>mnD`_3Y\Ka[nf>D�6 : } Z D&=\D&F`[nlnbzKSYeF`m&A N ;>lnY\K>gZ[^f>DBln;>K V [nf>D�6{: } Z :LF&yJ;>Y\mnY [^Y\bzK G :Lm�m][^:Ll][nD&_Y r~:LKh75bLr�[nf>D�Y\K>_>Y k�Ye_S;v:L=x_>D`[nD&F`[nbzlwD`=eD`IZD&Kh[^m�f>:L_3D`K>D&l]gL7d_>D&p bzmnY [^Y\bzKagzlnD&:<[^D`l�[nfv:LK":�f>Y\gzf[^fSlnD&m]f>bz=\_ VxU��hA P K [^f>D�D`kLD&Kh[ [^f>:<[�U���G{:Lm�Dac F&D`D&_>D`_ XJ7 :LKh7 bLr [^f>D�_>D`[nD&F [^bzl�mnY\gzKv:L=\m V :f>Y\gzf'gh:<I�I�:�[nlnY\gzgzD`lMG :Lm{F`lnD*:i[^D&_�A M =\mnb<V D`K>D&l]gL7':<K>_ [^Y\IZD�Y\KSrtbzlnI�:<[nYebLK�G :Lm{F&bL=e=\D&F [^D&_'rtbLl:L=\= _>D`[nD&F [^bzl0D&=\D&IZD`KJ[nmFG0Y [^fdD&K>D`lngL75_SD&p bzmnY [^Y\bzKdgzlnD&:<[^D`l0[nfv:LK5[^f>D�=\bUG [^fSlnD&m]f>bz=\_ V U��tAvU f>D| m P :LF&yJ;>Y\mnY [^Y\bzK G :Lm�m][^:Ll][nD&_3X>:LmnD`_abzK5[^fSDBD`K>D&l]gL75_>D`p bzm]Y\[nD&_aYeKd[^f>D�Y\K>_>Y k Y\_>;v:<=x_SD`[^D`F`[nbzlD&=\D&IZD`KJ[nm&A P rE:LKh7 bLr0[nf>D�YeKS_>Y\k�Y\_>;v:L= _SD`[^D`F`[nbzlnm fv:<_D`K>D&l]gL7 _SD&p bzmnY [^D`_ gzl]D*:<[nD&l�[nfv:LK�[^fSD

� k

Page 31: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

[^fSlnD&m]f>bz=\_ V�: | m P I�:Lm][nD&l�[^l]YegzgLD&l'G{:<m8gzD`K>D&ln:<[^D`_sA M _>_>Y [^Y\bzKv:<=e= 7bVJD&KSD&lng<7�:LK>_Z[^Y\I�D CobLr COIvY\gzfh[Y\KSrtbzlnI�:<[nYebLK�G :Lm�F`bz=e=\D&F [^D`_�rtbzl�:L=e= | m P _>D`[nD&F`[nbzlnm`A U fSD Q�� �L� :LF`yJ;>Yem]Y\[nYebLK G{:Lm�m][^:Ll][nD&_�Y rX bL[^f�9�caU mZ:i[n[H:<FHf>D&_ [nb3[^f>D T k�mnF&Y\Kh[^Y\=e=e:<[nbzl fv:L_ :3mnY\gzKv:L= A P r�:amnY\gzKv:L=MG{:Lm�p>lnD`mnD&Kh[ZY\KX bL[^f 98cdU m V>: Q�� �z� I�:Lm][nD&l8[nlnY\gzgzD`lMG :Lm gLD&K>D`l^:<[nD&_�:LKS_ Y\KSrtbzlnI�:<[nYebLK�G :Lm F`bz=e=\D&F [^D`_'rtlnbzI:L=\= Q�� �L� rtb�F*:L=�p>=q:<K>D�_>D`[nD&F`[nbzl0D&=\D&IZD&Kh[nm&A

� �� � ��� � � 93��= �<�� -)Q1A=>&T :LFHfbLrE[nf>D`k � 6{: } Z m]F&Y\Kh[^Y\=e=e:<[^Y\bzK _>D`[nD&F`[nbzlnm�fv:L_ [RG8b bz; [^p>;S[Zm]YegLKv:L=\m&A V K>D5bLrE[nf>D&m]DmnY\gzKv:<=emdG{:<mB_SD&=e: 7LD&_�:<K>_ m]p>=\Y\[BY\KJ[nbd[RG8b3p>:Ll][nm V Kv:LIZD`=\7�[nf>D r :Lm][�:LK>_ m]=ebUG m]YegzK>:L=em`A@U f>Dr :LmR[�:LK>_Zmn=\bUG mnY\gzKv:<=emHG8D&l]DEm]D&Kh[~[^b�:�FHfv:Ll]gzD C [^b C _>YegLY\[^:L=SF`bzKhkzD&lR[^D`l"N � N�| P ;>K>Y [*AzU f>D � N�|;>K>Y [^m�Y\KJ[nD&gzln:<[^D`_ [nf>D5FHfv:LlngLD3:LKS_ _>Y\gzY [^Y �&D`_ Y [�[nb gLY\kLDaD`K>D&l]gL7 YeK rtbzlnI�:<[nYebzK�A�U f>Dab<[^f>D`lbz;S[np>;S[ rtl]bzI D&:LFHfa_SD`[^D`F`[nbzl G{:Lm0;>m]D&_5rtbzl =\bzgzY\F�:LK>_�[^Y\IZYeK>gSA>U f>Y\mEm]YegzK>:L= G :Lm�:<[n[nD&KJ;v:<[nD&_:LK>_dr :LK>K>D`_3Y\Kh[^bZ[RG b pv:Ll][nm&A U f>D�mnY\gzKv:L=\mWG8D&l]D :<[][^D`K�;>:<[^D`_a[^b :Lp>pSlnb c YeI�:<[nD&= 7aI�:<[nFHf3[^fSD[^fSlnD&m]f>bz=\_>m�rtl]bzI _>D`[nD&F`[nbzl�[nb"_>D [^D&F [^bzl`A U fSD r :LK>K>D`_ =\bzgzY\F mnY\gzKv:<=em G D`lnD'm]D&Kh[ [^b3=eD&:L_>Y\K>gD&_SgzD"_>Y\mnF`lnY\I�Y\Kv:<[nbzlnmTV{bzK>D G0Y\[nf [^f>l]D&m]f>bz=\_ U��E:<K>_ [^f>DabL[^fSD&lYG0Y [^f [nf>lnD`mnf>bL=e_ U��JA�U f>DmnY\gzKv:<=em mnD&Kh[ [^b [nf>Dd_>Yem]F&l]YeIZY\Kv:<[^bLl�G0Y [^f [nf>lnD`mnf>bz=\_ U��*G8D&l]D";>mnD`_ [^b gzD`K>D&ln:<[^Dd[^f>Dd=ebUGgh:LIZI�: Nt=eb*C B PE=ebzgLYeFsV�G0f>Y\=\D [^fSD bL[nf>D&l]m�G8D&lnD ;>mnD`_ [^bdgzD&KSD&l^:i[^D [nf>D fSYegzf gh:LIZI�: Ntf>Y C B P=\bzgzY\FLAxU f>D'=\b C B :LKS_ f>Y C B�=\bzgzY\F�G :Lm ;>m]D&_ [^bagzD&KSD&l^:i[^D'gh:i[^D&mBrtbzl�[^f>D�kL:<lnY\bz;>m D`=eD`F`[^l]bzK>Y\FIZb _S;>=eD`m Vv[^l]YegLgzD&l]m0rtbLl{[^f>D�_v:<[^:Z:LF&yJ;>Y\mnY [^Y\bzK V :LK>_5rtbzl{[nYeIZY\K>gZp>;>lnp bzm]D&m&AU f>DB=eb C B3=\bzgzY\F�pv:<[^fdX D&gh:LK G0Y [^f5[^f>D�k � Y\K>_>Y k�Ye_>;>:L=@_>D`[nD&F`[nbzl�mnY\gzKv:L=\m&A U f>D`mnDBmnY\gzKv:L=\m

G8D&lnD0m]D&Kh[8[nb�k � _>YKJ�D`lnD&Kh[Fk� �FHfv:LKSK>D&= _>Y\mnF`lnY\I�Y\Kv:<[nbzlnmTV�:L=e=nG0Y\[nfZ[nf>lnD`mnf>bL=e_ U�� ALU f>Yem~rtbzl]I�D`_k � X>:LK>GJm V D*:LFHf G0Y [^f ;Sp [^b k� d_>D`[nD&F [^bzl]m&A�U f>D YeK>_SY\k�Y\_>;v:L=8bz;S[^pS;S[^m�rtl]bzI D*:LFHf�FHf>:LK>K>D`=G8D&lnD�mnD`KJ[E[^b :�[nYeIZD C [^b C _>Y\gzY\[^:L= F&bLKJkLD&lR[^D&leN U N�| P ;>K>Y [*A U f>D&m]D�m]YegzK>:L=emWG D`lnD�_>D&=e:*7zD&_ :<K>_mnD`l]kLD&_":<m YeK>_SY\k�Y\_>;v:L=@m][nbzp>m [^b [nf>D�U N�| rtbzl D*:LFHfd_>D`[nD&F [^bzl0D&=\D&IZD`KJ[&A U f>D�U N�| ;>K>Y [ G :Lmln;SK YeK F`bzIZI�bLK m][H:<l][�IZb�_>DLA<U f>D{F&bLI�IZbzK mR[H:LlR[HG :Lm�p>l]b k�Y\_>D&_ZXh7�[nf>D{D kzD&Kh[~bz; [^p>;S[.rtlnbzI[^fSD�[nlnY\gzgzD`l X b c�N [^bZX D�_>Y\mnF`;>mnm]D&_"Y\K Q D&F<A � A � A mnP^A P Kd:L_>_>Y [^Y\bzK5[^b [^f>D�Y\K>_>Y k�Ye_>;>:L=@bz;S[^pS;S[^mTVD*:<FHf b<r�[nf>D.k � _SYem]F&lnY\IZYeK>:<[^bzl]mB:L=em]b�fv:L_ :'m]YeK>gL=eDZbz;S[np>;S[�[nfv:<["G8bzl]GLD&_ :Lm�:'=\bzgzY\F*:<= V ?BA

�z�

Page 32: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

U f>D�=\bzgzY\F*:L= V ? mnY\gzKv:L=�rtl]bzI D*:LFHfdbLr@[^f>Dek � _>Yem]F&l]YeIZY\Kv:<[^bLlnm G D`lnD�Y\K>p>;S[0[^bZ:<K>bL[^fSD&l =\bzgzY\F;>K>Y [*AxU f>Y\m�=\bzgzY\F ;SK>Y\[�mnD`l]kzD`_ :Lm :d=ebLgzYeF&:L= V ? [nbd[nf>D k � V ? C D&_ _>Yem]F&l]YeIZY\Kv:<[^bLl�mnY\gzKv:<=em`AU f>Y\mEl]D&m];>=\[nD&_"Y\K":ZmnY\K>gz=\DBbz;S[^pS;S[0[^fv:<[�G :LmE[nln;>D�Y r�:LKh75bLr [^f>Dpk � _>D [^D`F`[^bLlnmEu>lnDLA P [�G :Lm[^fSYemEmnY\gzKv:L=[V�Y\K"F&bLYeK>F`Ye_SD&K>F`DSG0Y\[nf3[^f>D�I�:Lm][nD&lwD kzD`KJ[�m]YegLKv:L=[V [nfv:<[BG :LmE;>=\[nYeI�:<[nD&= 73;SmnD&_"[nbgzD`K>D&ln:<[^D�[^fSD � N�| gh:<[^D`m&A>U fSYem�mnY\gzKv:L= G :LmE:L=\mnbZ;>mnD`_":Lm [nf>D�=eb C Ba[nlnY\gzgzD&l`AU f>D�f>Y C B =\bzgzY\F'pv:<[nf�X D`gh:LK Y\K [^f>D m^:LIZD.G : 7 :Lm�[nf>D'=\b C B =\bzgzY\FLA.U fSD k � 3_SD`[^D`F`[nbzl

mnY\gzKv:<=em�G8D&l]D{mnD`Kh[�[^bSk � _>Y\mnF&l]YeIZY\Kv:<[nbzlnmTVLD*:<FHfSG0Y\[nf [^f>l]D&mnfSbz=e_ U��hA M m.YeK�[nf>D{F&:LmnD{b<r>[^f>D =eb CB'=\bzgzY\F�VzD&:LFHf b<r [nf>Ddk � _>Yem]F&l]YeIZY\Kv:<[^bLlnm�fv:L_ :�=\bzgzY\F*:<= V ? bz;S[^pS;S[*AzU fSD�k � V ? CoD&_Zbz; [^p>;S[nmG8D&lnD0m]D&Kh[�[^b�:�=\bzgzY\F{;>K>Y [*ALU f>Yem�;SK>Y\[~m]D&lRkzD&_ :Lm~:LKSbL[^f>D`l�=\bzgzY\F*:L= V ?�ALU fSD�l]D&m];>=\[nYeKSgBbL;S[^p>; [G :LmE;SmnD&_5[^bZgzD`K>D&ln:<[^D�[^fSDBfSY C Ba[^l]YegLgzD&l`AM _>Ye:Lgzl^:<I bLrx[^fSD�D&=\D&F`[nlnbzKSYeF`m�Y\m mnfSb G0KdY\K } Yeg>A � A ASU f>D�=\b C Ba:LK>_�f>Y C Bd[^l]YegzgLD&lnm*G8D&l]D

Y\K>p>;S[�[nb [^fSD�[^l]YegzgLD&lwX b c";SmnD&_ Y\K3[^fSYem�Dqc p D`lnY\I�D`Kh[*A U f>D F`=eD&:LlnmwrtbLlE[^fSD U N�| :LK>_ � N�|;>K>Y [^m0F&:LIZDBrtl]bzI [nf>D�F&bzIZp>;S[nD&l`A

� �� �� � &�� � 93�%= �!�� -)Q1A=>&

U f>D | m P D&=\D&F [^lnbLK>YeF`mYG8D&lnD3lnD&m]p bLK>mnY\X>=\D3rtbzl�lnD*:<_>YeKSg�bz;S[ D&KSD&lng<7 :LKS_ [^Y\IZD3Y\KSrtbzl]I :i[^Y\bzKrtlnbLI)[^fSD�YeK>_SY\k�Y\_>;v:L= | m P _>D [^D&F [^bzl]m&A�U f>D5l]D*:L_>bL;S[eG{:<m [^lnY\gzgzD`lnD`_X>:LmnD`_ bzK�[nf>D�D&K>D`lngL7_>D`p bzm]Y\[nD&_ Y\K�[nf>D�YeK>_SY\k�Y\_>;v:L= | m P _>D [^D`F`[^bLlnm&A P r :LKh7�bLr [^f>D8_>D`[nD&F [^bzl]m.fv:L_BD&KSD&lng<7�_SD&p bzmnY [^Y\bzKgzl]D*:<[nD&l [^fv:<Kd[nf>DB[nf>lnD`mnf>bL=e_amnD`[][^Y\K>g!VvD`K>D&l]gL7a:LK>_5[^Y\I�D�Y\KSrtbzl]I :i[^Y\bzK G :Lm�gh:<[nf>D&l]D&_artbLl0:L=e=kbk D`=eD`I�D`Kh[^m&AxU f>D [^Y\IZDSG{:<mB_SD`[^D`lnIZY\K>D&_�G0Y\[nf�:'U N�| V G0f>D`lnD [^fSD YeK>_SY\k�Y\_>;v:L=~_>D [^D&F [^bzl]mp>l]b k�Y\_>D&_3: m][^bLpa:<K>_�[^f>D�I�:Lm][nD&l0D`kLD&Kh[EmnY\gzKv:L= p>l]b k Y\_>D`_3: F&bLI�IZbzKdm][^:Ll][&Av6 bL[nf�[^f>D�r :LmR[:LK>_�m]=ebUG D&K>D`lngzY\D&m*G8D&l]D�lnD&:L_�bz;S[*G0Y [^f'[nf>D�;>m]D�bLrx: � N�| A M _>Yq:<gzl^:LI bLr [nf>D�D&=\D&F [^l]bzK>Y\F&mY\m8m]f>bUG0K�YeK } YegSA � A�9�A | =\D*:<lnm~rtbzl�[nf>D�� N�| :LK>_�U N�| I�b�_>;>=\D&m�F*:<I�D�rtlnbzI [nf>D�F&bzIZp>;S[nD&l`A

� �� �� D������ � 93��= �<�� -)Q1A=>&

U f>D Q � �z� D`=eD`F`[^l]bzK>Y\F&m.G8D&l]D"lnD`mnp bzK>mnY\X>=\D"rtbzl l]D*:L_SYeK>g�bz;S['m]YegLKv:L=\m rtlnbzI :L=\=0rtb F&:L=0p>=q:<K>D_>D [^D&F [^bzl D`=eD`IZD&Kh[^m`A�U fSD�lnD*:<_>bz;S[eG :Lm [^l]YegLgzD&l]D&_ Xv:Lm]D&_ bzK�[^f>D T k�m]F&Y\KJ[nYe=\=e:<[^bzl`A P r�X bL[nf

�L�

Page 33: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

HV

X1

Lea

din

g E

dg

eD

iscr

imin

ato

rX

10

Dis

crim

inat

or

OR

OR

X1

Lea

din

g E

dg

eD

iscr

imin

ato

r

OR

X1

0D

iscr

imin

ato

rO

R

X1

36

Sp

litt

er

Gat

eQ

DC

Fas

t

Fas

t

Gat

eG

ener

ato

r

Gat

eG

ener

ato

r

Slo

w

Gat

eQ

DC

Slo

w

TD

CC

om

mo

n S

tart

AN

DA

tten

uat

or

0.1

-1.0

X

Ind

ivid

ual

Sto

ps

X1

36

X1

36

50

0n

s

OR

X1

0L

oT

rig

ger

g

Hi

Tri

gg

erg

X1

36

X1

36

X1

36

X1

36

Mas

ter

Ev

ent

X1

} YegL;>lnD � A �4 N Ye:Lgzln:LI b<r.[^fSD�6 : } Z D&=\D&F [^lnbLK>YeF`m&A

� m

Page 34: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

Pre

amp

Dis

crim

inat

or

Gat

eG

ener

ato

rO

R

TD

CIn

div

idu

al S

top

s

Gat

eG

ener

ato

r

QD

C

QD

C

Sp

litt

er

CsI

Tri

gg

er

Mas

ter

Ev

ent

Del

ay

Co

mm

on

Sta

rt

Fas

t

Fas

t

Slo

w

Slo

w

Gat

e

Gat

eH

VX

11

X11

X11

X1

X1

1

} Y\gz;>l]D � A�974 N Yq:LgLl^:LI bLr [nf>D | m P D`=eD`F`[nlnbzK>Y\F&m`A

� �

Page 35: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

9�caU mZbzK�[^f>Y\mZmnF`YeKh[^Y\=\=q:<[nbzlZfv:L_:"mnY\gzKv:<=jV.[nf>D�[^l]YegzgLD&l8G :LmZgzD&KSD&l^:i[^D&_�A Q p D`F&Y uvF*:<=e= 7bV�[^fSDgh:<[nD&m�rtbzl�[nf>D Q�� �z� D`=eD`F`[^l]bzK>Y\F&m G D`lnD�F&lnD&:<[^D`_ Xh7"[nf>DZ=ebLgzYeF&:L= M�WEN b<r F`bzK>m][^:LKh[�rtl^:LF [^Y\bzK_>Y\mnF`lnY\I�Y\Kv:<[nbzl�N |{}�N P�mnY\gzKv:L=\m rtlnbzI X b<[^f T kBm]F&Y\Kh[^Y\=e=e:<[^bLl098cdU m&A U f>Y\m�m]YegLKv:L= :L=\mnbZm]D&l]kLD&_:LmZ[^f>Ddm][^:Ll][�m]YegzK>:L= rtbzlZD*:LFHf | ? N�| [nYeIZD C [^b*C�:LKv:<=ebzg F&bLKJkLD&lR[^D&l N U M�| PHA�U f>Ddm][^bLp>m�rtbLlD*:<FHf bLr [^f>D`mnDwU M�| m�F*:LIZD0rtlnbzI [nf>D�YeK>_SY\k�Y\_>;v:L= | ? N�| :LK>b�_>D&m`A M _>_>Y [^Y\bzKv:<=e= 7bVh[^fSDE=\bzgzY\F*:L=M�WEN X D`[RG8D&D`K3X bL[^f T k�98cdU m�G :Lm0[^f>D�mR[^bzp5rtbzl : U M�| G0f>Y\FHfaIZD&:Lmn;>l]D&_d[^Y\I�D CobLr COIvY\gzfh[lnD`=q:i[^Y kzD�[^b [nf>D�F`7�F`=ebL[nlnbzK5? } A U f>D�F`7�F&=\bL[nlnbzKd? } p>lnb k�Y\_>D&_5[^f>Dwm][H:<l][{rtbzl8[^f>Y\m U M�| ASU f>D:LKv:<=ebzg mnY\gzKv:L=\mwrtlnbLI-D&:LFHf�U M�| G8D&lnD m]D&Kh[�[^b':LK :LKv:L=\bzg C [^b C _>Y\gzY\[^:L= F&bLKJkLD&lR[^D&l�N M�N�| P{[nbX DBl]D*:L_dXh7'[^fSD�:<F&yJ;>Y\mnY [^Y\bzKsA N Yq:<gzl^:LIZm bLrx[^fSDBD`=eD`F`[nlnbzK>Y\F&mEF*:LKdX D�rtbz;>K>_dYeKa?0D`r�A � m � � A

� �� � ���X1 � �M�%� � � 93�%= �!�� -)Q1A=>&

U f>D�[^l]YegLgzD&l X b c�N U06 � �z�z� P�mnD&lRkzD`_":Lm{[nf>D�F&bzKh[^l]bz=smR7 mR[^D`I X D [RG D`D&Ka[nf>D�k<:LlnY\bz;>m _SD`[^D`F`[nbzlm]7�mR[^D&IZm :LK>_ _v:<[^:�:LF&yJ;>Y\mnY [^Y\bzKsA M _SYq:LgLl^:LI)bLr�U06 � �z�z� Y\mZmnf>bUG0KYeK } Y\g>A � A � A.U06 � �L�z�:L=\=ebUG8D&_ rtbzl D*:LmR7 m]D&=\D&F [^Y\bzK bLr"G0f>Y\FHf D`kzD`Kh[^m�m][^:Ll][nD&_ [nf>D":LF`yJ;>Yem]Y\[nYebLK V :Lm�[^f>D"_SY J D&l]D&Kh[[^l]YegLgzD&l]m*G D`lnD�mnD`=eD`F`[^D`_ G0Y [^f5[^f>D"I>YepdbLr : m7G0Y [^FHfsA P [�:L=\mnb�:L=\=ebUG8D&_5rtbzl{_>bUG0K>m]F*:L=\Y\K>g bLrx[^fSD_>YKJ�D`lnD`KJ[�Y\K>p>;S[nm&A M _S_>Y\[nYebLKv:L=\=\7�VvY\rx[^f>D�F`bzIZp>;S[nD&l G{:<m�XS;>m]7�V U06 � �z�z� G :Lm0YeKSf>YeXSY\[nD&_sA U f>Y\mG :Lm�[nb3X>=\b FHG D kzD&Kh[nm [^fv:<[�b�F&F&;Sl�G0f>Y\=eD�[^f>D F&bzIZp>; [^D&l G{:<m�m][nYe=\=�p>lnb�F&D`mnmnY\K>g"[nf>D F`;>lnl]D&Kh[D`kLD&Kh[*A 6 bL[nf5l^: G :LKS_a_>bUG0K>m]F*:L=\D&_amnY\gzKv:L=\m�G D`lnDBmnD&Kh[0[^b�mnF&:L=\D&l0IZb _>;S=eD`m&AU f>D�[nlnY\gzgzD&lEYeKSp>;S[^mE[^b'U06 � �z�z� G8D&l]D � b C B%V CEY C B%V Q�� �z� I :<m][^D`l V | m P I�:Lm][nD&l V : F`bzYeK8C

F&Y\_>D`K>F&D [nlnY\gzgzD`l�rtbLlnIZD&_ X D`[RG8D&D`K :d=\bzgzY\F*:<= MwWwN X D`[RG8D&D`K CEY C B :LKS_ Q�� �L� I�:LmR[^D&lTV.:<K>_: mnD`F&bzK>_aF&bzY\K>F`Ye_>D`K>F&DB[^l]YegzgLD&l rtbzlnIZD`_aX D`[RG8D&D`K�: =ebzgLYeF&:L= M�WEN X D`[RG8D&D`K | m P I :<m][^D`lw:<K>_Q�� �L� I�:LmR[^D&l`A Q D`kLD&l^:<=@[nlnY\gzgzD`lnm�G D`lnDBmnD&=\D&F [^D`_�_>;>lnY\K>gZ[^f>DBDac p D&l]YeIZD&Kh[&As6 bL[nfaF`bzY\K>F&Y\_>D&KSF&D[^l]YegLgzD&l]mFG8D&lnD�;>mnD`_3[^b [nlnY\gzgzD`l�[nf>D :LF`yJ;>Yem]Y\[nYebLKsA�U f>D Q�� �z� I :<m][^D`l�:L=\mnb�[^l]YegzgLD&lnD`_3[^fSD :LF CyJ;>Y\mnY [^Y\bzKa_S;>lnY\K>gZ[^f>D�l];>KsA>U f>D Q�� �z� I :<m][^D`l*G{:<m�_Sb G0KSmnF*:<=eD`_3Xh75: r :LF`[nbzl bLrMk � � [nbZgzY\kLDQ�� �L� mnY\K>gz=\D&m�D`kLD&Kh[^m`AxU fSD � b C B�[^lnY\gzgzD`l"G{:<m�;>mnD`_ rtbzlwmnbz;>l]F&DZF*:<=eY\X>l^:i[^Y\bzK�p>;>l]p bzm]D&mQG0Y [^f[^fSD 6{: } Z :Ll]l^:*7zA Q YeIZY\=q:Ll]=\7�Vx[nf>D | m P I�:Lm][nD&l�[^l]YegzgLD&lQG{:<m�;>m]D&_�rtbzl�F&:L=eY\X>ln:<[^Y\bzK�pS;>lnp bzmnD`mG0Y [^f5[^f>D | m P :Llnln: 7LA

Page 36: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

Out Reduced Out

CoincidenceRegister

TB8000

OROut

Inhibit Busy

MasterEvent

Scaler Scaler

Hi g

S800 Master

CsI Master

AND

Lo g 1

2

3

4

AND 5

6

} Y\gz;>l]D � A � 4 N Yq:LgLl^:LIObLr [nlnY\gzgzD`l�X b c^VhU06 � �z�L� V�G0f>Y\FHf'F&bLKJ[nlnbz=\=\D&_Z[^f>D0_v:<[^:�:LF&yJ;>Y\mnY [^Y\bzK rtbLl[^fSYem0Dac p D&l]YeIZD&Kh[&A M =e= Y\K>p>;S[nm�:LK>_dbz;S[^pS;S[^m�:Ll]DB_SD&mnF`lnY\X D`_3Y\Kd[nf>D�[^Dqc [&A

� 9

Page 37: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

� � ��� ��� �

� ��� � � � � ��� �

U f>D Dac p D&l]YeIZD&Kh[^:L=�_v:<[H: :LK>:L=\7�m]Yem5F&bLK>mnY\m][nD&_ b<r�m]D`kzD`l^:L=�p>:Ll][nm&A } Y\lnmR[5F*:L=\YeXSl^:<[nYebzKSm G8D&l]Dp D&l]rtbLlnIZD&_sA M =\=8_SD`[^D`F`[nbzlnm Y\K�[^fSD�6{: } Z :Llnln: 7 :LKS_ | m P :Llnln:*7�G8D&l]D�F*:L=\Y\X>l^:<[nD&_ rtbzl�[^Y\IZD:LK>_�D&K>D`lngL7LA U f>D bzKS=\7�D`=eD`I�D`Kh[^m.[nfv:<[xK>D&D`_>D&_�F*:L=\YeXSl^:<[nYebzK�YeKB[^f>D Q�� �L� rtb�F*:L=hpS=q:LKSDMG8D&l]D8[^fSD| ? N�| _SD`[^D`F`[nbzlnm`A�U f>D`mnDZ_>D`[nD&F [^bzl]m"G D`lnD F&:L=eY\X>ln:<[^D`_"rtbzlwp bzmnY [^Y\bzKsA M r [nD&lw[nf>D F*:<=eY\X>l^:i[^Y\bzKp>l]b F`D&mnmTV�Y [BG :Lm�K>D`F&D`mnm^:<l]73[nb'Y\_>D&Kh[^Y r 7d[^f>D�rtln:LgzIZD&Kh[nmw_>D [^D&F [^D`_ Y\K3[nf>D Q�� �z� rtb�F*:L=@p>=e:LK>D<AU f>Y\mMG :Lm~[^b�D&KSmn;>l]D�[nfv:<[�bzK>= 7 Y\K>D&=e:Lm][nYeF&:L=\=\74Com]F*:<[][^D`lnD&_ gji V D`kLD&Kh[^mMG D`lnD�F&bzK>m]Ye_SD&lnD`_sA W Dac�[ V[^fSD BDC l^:*7�D`kLD&Kh[^m�_>D`[nD&F [^D&_�G0Y\[nf [nf>D�6{: } Z :Ll]l^:*7 G8D&l]D Y\mnbz=e:<[nD&_sA@U f>D B ln: 7�mQG8D&lnDZ[^fSD&KF&bLlnlnD`=q:i[^D&_rG0Y [^f5p>l]b��RD&F [^Y\=eD�D`K>D&l]gL7'=\bzmnm Y\K�bzl]_>D&l{[nb Dac�[^ln:LF`[ BDC l^:*7 m]p D`F`[nl^: F&bzl]lnD`mnp bzK>_>Y\K>g[^b0k<:LlnY\bz;>mxp>l]b��RD&F [^Y\=eD8D&K>D`lngL7B=\bzmnm]D&m&A } Y\Kv:L=\=\7�VipSlnbL[nbzK�D kzD`KJ[nm�Y\K�[^fSD | m P :Llnln: 7QG8D&l]D Y\mnbz=e:<[nD&_rtlnbLI bL[nf>D&l0D`kLD&Kh[^m`A U fSD&mnDBD`kLD&Kh[^mWG D`lnD�:L=\mnb�F&bzl]lnD&=e:<[nD&_ G0Y\[nfap>l]b��RD&F [^Y\=eDBD&KSD&lng<75=ebzm]m&A

�F��� � ��+&$����~�B��$`� ���

� ��� ��� � � �������T :LFHf'bLr [^f>D k � B6{: } Z _>D [^D&F [^bzl]m-G :Lm F&:L=\YeX>ln:<[^D`_ rtbzl�D&KSD&lng<7zAJU f>DwD`K>D&l]gL7�F*:L=\Y\X>l^:<[nYebLK�G :LmF*:<lnlnY\D&_ bz;S[BXh7 ;>mnY\K>g3:dm]bz;>lnF`D b<r ]R] ��:LK>_ 9�;v6 DLA@U f>D`mnD�[RG bamnbz;>l]F&D`m�gh:*kzD�F*:<=eY\X>l^:i[^Y\bzKp bzYeKh[nm{:<[ � A � ! � caDalSV kzA � � cdDTlSV � A ! � 9�cdDTlSV :LK>_Ym>A m � � caDal A�U f>Dw[RG8b =ebUG8D&mR[ D&K>D`lngL7

� �

Page 38: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

0.898 MeV

1.836 MeV

0 20 40 60 80 1000

200

400

600

800

1000

Counts

Slow Signal (Channels)

4.438 MeV3.927 MeV

75 100 125 150 175 200Slow Signal (Channels)

0

500

1000

1500

Co

un

ts

} Y\gz;>l]D � A k 4 � D r [ 4�]R]]�%mnbz;SlnF&D F*:<=eY\X>l^:i[^Y\bzK m]p D`F`[nln;>I5AE?�Y\gzfh[ 409�;v6 D mnbz;SlnF&D F*:<=eY\X>l^:i[^Y\bzKmnp D&F [^l];>I5A U fSD�=\bUG D`l�D`K>D&l]gL75p D*:LG'Y\K5[^f>Y\m0p>=eb<[EY\m [^f>D�uvl]m][�D&m]F*:Lp D�p D&:LG A

p bzYeKh[nm�G8D&l]D�rtlnbzI [^f>D ]R]]�-mnbL;>lnF`D�VHG0f>Y\=eD�[nf>D5bL[^f>D`l [RG b`G8D&lnD�rtl]bzI)[nf>Dd9~;>6 D5mnbz;>l]F&D<A} Y\g>A � A k�m]f>bUG0mZ:3[o7 pSYeF&:L= mnp D&F [^ln;SI%lnD`mn;>= [^Y\K>g rtlnbzI [^fSD [RG b m]bz;>lnF`D&m`A�U f>D'uvlnmR[ZD&m]F*:Lp Dp D*:LGBYem.D`k�Ye_SD&Kh[�YeK�[nf>D 9�;v6 D m]p D`F`[nln;>I Vh:LKS_ gh:*kzD [nf>D{F*:<=eY\X>l^:i[^Y\bzK p bLYeKh[�:i[ � A ! � 9wcdDTl A Mf>Y\gzf>D`l D&KSD&lng<7 F&:L=\YeX>ln:<[^Y\bzK'p bzY\Kh[-G :Lm bLXS[H:LY\K>D`_ rtlnbzI F`bzmnIZY\F�l^:*7�m&A�U f>DED&K>D`lngL7 _>D&p bzm]Y\[nD&_Y\K'[^f>D�Y\K>_>Y k�Ye_S;v:L= _>D [^D&F [^bzl D&=\D&IZD&Kh[^m rtl]bzI F`bzmnIZY\F�l^:*7�m _>D&p D&KS_>m bzK'[^fSD�gzD&bLI�D [^lR7'bLr@[^fSD_>D [^D&F [^bzl]m&AxCED`K>F&DsVx[nf>DZD&K>D`lngL7 _SD&p bzmnY [^D`_�Y\K [nf>D V ? Ww� :LK>_�U M caj _SD`[^D`F`[nbzlnm G{:Lm�[^fSDm^:<I�D<AsU f>D _SD`[^D`F`[nbzlnm�X D&=\bzK>gzY\K>g'[nb5c Q j f>:L_ :'=ebUG8D&l�:<I�bL;>Kh[�bLr�D&K>D`lngL7a_>D`p bzm]Y\[nYebLK :<mF&bLI�p>:LlnD`_ [nb"[^f>D bL[^f>D`l [RG b�[o7�p D&m&A.U f>D�D&K>D`lngL7 _>D&p bzmnY [^D`_ YeK [nf>D V ? WE� :LKS_�U M c3j_>D [^D&F [^bzl]m�F`bzlnl]D&m]p bzKS_>mB[nb3:<K D`K>D&l]gL7 bLr-m � A � ! � caDalSV>G0f>Y\=eD�YeK [^fSD c Q j _>D`[nD&F`[nbzlBY\[�Y\m� 9 A ! �z� caDal AxU f>D&m]D D&KSD&lngLYeD`m :LlnD�Xv:Lm]D&_ bLK m]YeI�;>=q:i[^Y\bzK>m l];>K :<[ V ? WE� A P K�[^f>Y\m�:LKv:L= 74CmnY\m V~bzKS=\7 [nf>D5mn=\bUG F&bzIZp bzK>D`KJ[�G :Lm�F*:L=\YeXSl^:<[nD&_sA M [o7�p>Y\F*:L=0D&KSD&lng<7�F*:L=\Y\X>l^:<[nYebLK F`;>l]kLDaY\mmnfSb G0K3YeK } Yeg>A � A � A M F*:L=\YeXSl^:<[nD&_3F`bzmnIZY\F C l^:*73m]p D`F`[nln;>I�Y\mwmnfSb G0KartbzlEX bL[nf":LK"c Q j :<K>_V ? WE� �<U M c3j _>D`[nD&F [^bzl0Y\K } Y\g>A � A � AU f>D�[^Y\IZDdF&:L=\YeX>ln:<[^Y\bzK bLr�[^f>D56 : } Z _>D`[nD&F [^bzl]m F`bzK>mnY\m][nD&_bLr�[RG b pv:LlR[^m&A } Yel]m][ V�:L=\={bLr

[^fSD�[^Y\IZYeKSg FHfv:LKSK>D&=\mBG8D&lnD�gh:LY\K3I�:<[nFHf>D&_sA U f>Y\mFG :Lm�:LF`F&bzIZp>=\Y\mnf>D`_�XJ7d;>m]YeKSg�: p>;S=em]D&lE[nb[^l]YegLgzD&l~[^f>D�D&=\D&F [^l]bzK>Y\F&m&A � Y\[nf [^fSDED`=eD`F`[^l]bzK>Y\F&m [nlnY\gzgzD`lnD&_ YeK�[^f>Y\m I�:LK>KSD&l V :�m]p D`F`[nln;>I G :LmIZD*:Lm];>lnD`_pG0Y [^fZm]D`kzD`l^:L=vp D*:<G�mWN } Y\g>A � A mnP^A<U f>D [nYeIZD X D`[RG8D&D&K�p D*:LGJm�F&bLlnlnD`mnp bzK>_>m�[nb"m � K>mTV

� !

Page 39: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

0 400 800 1200 1600

Slow Signal (Channels)

0

10

20

30

40

50

En

erg

y (

MeV

)

} Y\gz;>l]D � A � 4>U�7�p>Y\F*:<=�D`K>D&l]gL7�F&:L=eY\X>ln:<[^Y\bzK F&;>lRkzD rtbzl�:56{: } Z _>D`[nD&F`[nbzl&A U fSD�m]bz=\Ye_ F&;Sl]kzDZY\m[^fSD lnD`mn;>= [�bLr8: yJ;v:L_>ln:<[^Y\F u>[�[nf>lnbL;>gzf"[^fSD p bzY\Kh[^m�m]f>bUG0KsA U f>D p bzY\Kh[^m"G8D&lnD bLXS[H:LY\K>D`_ :<mDac p>=e:LY\K>D&_aYeK5[^fSD�[nDac�[*A

0

100

200

300

400

20 30 40 50 60Energy (MeV)

Co

un

ts

(a)

0

100

200

300

400

20 30 40 50 60Energy (MeV)

Co

un

ts

500

(b)

} Y\gz;>l]D � A � 4 | :L=\YeXSl^:<[nD&_ZF&bzm]IZYeF Col^:*7�mnp D&F`[nl^:SAL9.:LKSD&=%N : P@Y\m.rtbzl�:<K V ? Ww� �<U M caj _>D`[nD&F [^bzlTVG0f>Y\=eDBpv:LKSD&=MN X P�Yem0rtbzl0:LKac Q j _>D [^D`F`[^bLl&A

G0f>Y\FHfYG :Lm D&:LmnY\=\7�_>D [^D`lnIZYeKSD&_'rtlnbLI [^f>D0rtlnD`y�;SD&K>F 7 bLr�[^f>D�p>;>=\mnD`l&A � Y\[nf [^fSYem8YeKSrtbLlnI�:<[^Y\bzK V[^fSD�[^Y\IZD gh:LY\K>m�bLr�[nf>D Y\K>_>Y k�Ye_>;>:L=�FHfv:LKSK>D&=\m�YeK"[nf>D D`=eD`F`[^l]bzK>Y\F&m"G8D&l]D I :i[^FHf>D`_sA � Y [^f"[^fSDgh:LY\K>m0I�:<[^FHfSD&_ V : lnD rtD&lnD`K>F&DBp bzYeKh[�G :LmEmR[^Y\=e= KSD&D&_SD&_a[nbZF&bzIZp>=\D`[nDB[nf>D�[^Y\I�D�F&:L=eY\X>ln:<[^Y\bzKsAU f>D�lnD rtD&l]D&K>F`D�p bzY\Kh['[^b�F`bzIZp>=\D`[^D"[nf>D"F&:L=eY\X>ln:<[^Y\bzK+G :Lm'bzXS[^:LY\K>D&_ rtl]bzI :<F`[^;>:L=wl];>K

_v:<[^:SAvU f>D�[^Y\IZDBm]p D`F`[nln;>I�bLr D*:LFHfaYeKS_>Y\k�Y\_>;v:L=@_>D [^D`F`[^bLlEF`bzKh[H:LY\K>mE:�p>l]bzIZpS[�p D&:LG5:Lm G8D&=\=:Lm ln:LK>_>bzI p D&:LGJm5N } Y\g>A � A mnP^A*U f>D~p>lnbLI�p [ p D*:<GwF&bLlnlnD`mnp bzK>_>m@[^b0D kzD&Kh[nmx[nfv:<[x:Ll]D�F&bzl]lnD&=e:<[nD&_G0Y [^f�[nf>D~F&;>l]lnD`KJ[ X D*:LI XS;>lnmR[*A U f>D�l^:LK>_SbzI p D*:LGJm :LlnY\mnD~X D&F*:<;>mnD�bLrS[nf>D'G0Ye_ [^f�b<r [nf>D8gz:<[^D`m

�z�

Page 40: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

0 1000 2000 3000 40000

100

200

300

Co

un

ts

Time Signal (Channels)0 100 200 300 400

Time (ns)

0

200

400

600

800

Counts

PromptPeak

RandomPeak

} Y\gz;>l]D � A m14>U Y\IZD�m]p D`F`[nl^: ;>m]D&_d[^b F&:L=\YeX>ln:<[^D�[^fSD�6{: } Z :<lnl^:*7LA � D r [ 4 9�;>=\mnD&lE_v:<[^: ;>m]D&_a[nbgh:LY\K I�:<[nFHf [nf>DEY\K>_>Y k�Ye_S;v:L=�D`=eD`F`[nlnbzK>Y\FwFHf>:LK>K>D`=em`A>?0Yegzfh[�4hU YeIZDwm]p D`F`[nl^:�rtl]bzI _v:<[^:�;>m]D&_�:<mlnD rtD&l]D&K>F`D�p bzY\KJ[&AvU f>D�p>lnbLI�p [Ep D*:<G'Yem0Y\K>_>Y\F*:<[nD&_ V :Lm0Y\m�:Zln:LK>_>bLI�p D&:LG A

;>m]D&_5YeK�[nf>D�D&=\D&F [^l]bzK>Y\F&m&A U f>D"G0Y\_S[nfdY\m{m]; ��F&Y\D&Kh[^= 75=q:<lngzDwrtbLl{D`kLD&Kh[^m0rtlnbzI D`Y\[nf>D&l p>l]D`k�Y\bz;>mbzl�=q:i[^D&l�X D*:LI X>;Slnm][nmE[nb�[nlnY\gzgzD&l0[^fSD :LF`y�;SYem]Y\[nYebzK�A U f>D`mnD D kzD`KJ[nm�:Ll]D�K>b<[wF`bzlnl]D&=e:<[^D`_ G0Y [^f[^fSD�F`;>lnl]D&Kh[�X D*:LI X>;Slnm][ V�:<K>_a[nf>D�b�F&F`;>lnl]D&K>F`D�bLr�mn;>FHf"D kzD`KJ[nm�Yem�l^:<K>_>bzI5A U f>D�l]D`rtD`lnD&KSF&Dp bzYeKh[�;>m]D&_dYeK5[^f>D�F&:L=eY\X>ln:<[^Y\bzKdF&bzl]lnD&m]p bLK>_>m0[^b [^f>D�F`D&Kh[^l]bzYe_abLrx[^f>D�p>l]bzIZpS[�p D&:LG AU f>D�[nYeIZD�Y\KSrtbzl]I�:<[^Y\bzKartl]bzI�[^fSD 6{: } Z _>D`[nD&F [^bzl]mFG :Lm�;>m]D&_"Y\K"F&bLK��R;>K>F [^Y\bzK G0Y [^f"[^fSD

[^Y\IZDZX D [RG D`D&K [nf>D�? } :LKS_ [nf>D T k m]F&Y\KJ[nYe=\=e:<[^bzl�Y\K [nf>D Q�� �z� rtb�F*:L= p>=e:LK>DLA U fSD :LF`F&;>ln:LF`7bLr�[^f>D 6{: } Z [nYeIZD�V G0fSD&K�IZD&:Lmn;>l]D&_ l]D&=e:<[^Y kzDZ[^b5[^fSD T k�mnF`YeKh[^Y\=\=q:<[nbzl V>G :LmBYeK>m]; ��F&Y\D&Kh[�[nblnD`mnbz= kzDZ[^fSD B�l^:*7�m�rtlnbzI�[^fSD�KSD&;S[nlnbzK>m`A@687"m];>XS[nl^:LF [^Y\K>gd[nf>D [^Y\IZD X D [RG D`D&K [nf>DZ? } :<K>_T kwm]F&Y\KJ[nYe=\=e:<[^bzl�rtlnbzI [nf>D�6 : } Z [nYeIZD`m VJ[^f>D0[^Y\IZD&m5G8D&l]DwlnD`=q:i[^Y kzDE[nb�[nf>DwF 7 F`=eb<[^lnbLK'? } AJU f>DlnD`mn;>= [^Y\K>g5lnD`mnbz=\;S[nYebzK G0Y [^f"[nf>Y\m�lnD`rtD`lnD`K>F&D p bzY\KJ[BG{:Lmwgzb b�_"D`K>bz;>gzf"[nb'lnD`mnbz= kzD [nf>D B l^:*7�m:LK>_dK>D`;S[^l]bzK>m&A

� ���� � &���� �������

U f>D | m P _SD`[^D`F`[nbzlnm8G8D&l]D�F*:L=\Y\X>l^:<[nD&_ rtbzlB[^Y\IZD'YeK [^f>D'DqcS:LF`[ mn:LIZD�I�:LK>K>D`l :Lm�[nf>D�6{: } Z:Ll]l^:*7 NtmnD&D Q D`FLA � A kzA ksP^A�U f>DZY\K>_>Y k Y\_>;v:<=�gh:LY\K>m"G D`lnDZI�:<[^FHfSD&_ rtlnbzI _>D`[nD&F [^bzl�[^b�_SD`[^D`F`[nbzlG0Y [^f p>;>=\mnD`l�_>:<[H:<V�G0f>Y\=eD'[nf>D�p>lnbLI�p [Zp D&:LG�l]D&mn;S=\[nYeK>g�rtl]bzI)_SD`[^D`F`[nD&_ FHf>:LlngzD`_ pv:Ll][nYeF`=eD`m

� k

Page 41: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

100 200 300Time (ns)

0

500

1000

1500

Co

un

ts

PromptPeak

RandomPeak

} Y\gz;>l]D � A��74 | :L=eY\X>ln:<[^D`_�[^Y\IZD8m]p D`F`[nln;>I rtl]bzI [^fSD | m P _>D`[nD&F [^bzl]m&A U f>D�p>lnbzIZpS[.:LK>_Bl^:<K>_>bzIp D*:LGJmE:LlnD�Y\K>_>Y\F*:<[nD&_aYeK5[^f>D�m]p D`F`[^l];>I5A

G :LmE;SmnD&_a:Lm [^fSDBl]D`rtD`lnD&KSF&DBp bzY\Kh[*AvU f>DBF*:<=eY\X>l^:i[^D&_5[^Y\IZD�mnp D&F`[nln;>I Y\m0mnf>bUG0KaYeK } Y\g>A � A � AU f>D�YeKS_>Y\k�Y\_>;v:L= | m P _SD`[^D`F`[nbzlnm*G8D&l]DBF&:L=\YeX>ln:<[^D`_�rtbzl{D&KSD&lng<7zA T K>D`lngL7�F&:L=\YeX>ln:<[^Y\bzK>m*G8D&l]D

p D&l]rtbLlnIZD&_Zrtbzl �3pv:LlR[^Y\F&=\D&m8:LK>_�p>lnbL[nbzK>m`A P [MG :Lm�K>D&F`D&m]m^:LlR7�[nb�fv:*kzD�:�m]D&pv:Lln:<[^D�F*:<=eY\X>l^:i[^Y\bzKrtbzl0D*:<FHf3[o7�p D�bLr�pv:LlR[^Y\F&=\D :Lm0[^fSD�l]D&mnp bzK>m]D bLr [^f>D�_>D`[nD&F`[nbzlwY\m�K>bL[�[^f>DBm^:LIZDBrtbzlE_SY J D&l]D&Kh[pv:LlR[^Y\F&=\D&m`A } bzl�[^fSD F&:L=eY\X>ln:<[^Y\bzK p>l]b F`D&m]m V0[^f>D | m P _>D [^D`F`[^bLlnm G8D&l]D�l]D&IZb kzD&_ rtl]bzI [nf>D&Y\lp bzmnY [^Y\bzK _>;>l]YeK>g�[nf>D ln;>K :LKS_�m][H:<FHGLD&_ YeKh[nba:'fSbz=e_SD&l&A U fSD f>bz=\_>D&l"G :Lm�[^f>D`K p>=q:<F&D&_ Y\KJ[nb[^fSD�p>:<[^f bLr�[^f>DZX D*:LI5A UxbdgLD`[BF*:L=\Y\X>l^:<[nYebLK p bzY\Kh[^m V@X D*:LIZm�bLr8p>lnb<[^bzK>mB:LKS_�:L=\p>fv:<mdG8D&l]D;>m]D&_sA Uxb gzD [0D&K>bL;>gzf3p bzY\Kh[^m rtbzl F*:<=eY\X>l^:i[^Y\bzK V>[^fSDBX D*:<I�m�G8D&lnDB_>D`gzl^:L_SD&_ G0Y\[nfa[^fSDB;SmnD�bLr:L=\;>IZYeKJ;>I5A M _>_SY\[nYebzK>:L=e= 7bV [^fSD�����G{:Lm0k<:LlnY\D&_�A U*G8b'_>YKJ D&lnD`Kh[�_>D`gzl^:L_SD&lnm�G8D&lnD�;>mnD`_sA U f>D[RG8b3_>D`gzl^:L_SD&lnm�fv:L_ [^f>Y\FHGJK>D&m]mnD&m b<r m �L� IZg��<F&I�Z�:LK>_ �<� !dIZg��iF&I�Z A@U f>D k<:L=\;>D&m�rtbzl����k<:LlnY\D&_ X D [RG D`D&K � A 4��U I :LK>_kzA � � U IdA P K [^f>D�F*:Lm]D b<r [^fSD � F&:L=eY\X>ln:<[^Y\bzK Vx:5mnbz;>l]F&D�bLrZ Z j G :Lm :<=em]b�;>mnD`_sA M [o7�p>Y\F*:<= F*:<=eY\X>l^:i[^Y\bzK rtbzlBX bL[nf p>l]bL[^bzK :LK>_ � pv:Ll][nYeF`=eD`m Yem�mnf>bUG0KY\K } YegSA � A SA P K"[nf>D F*:<mnD bLr~[^fSD p>lnb<[^bzK>mTV :'=\YeK>D&:Llwu>[�gh:*kzDZ:'gzb�b _au>[�[^b'[nf>D F*:<=eY\X>l^:i[^Y\bzKp bzYeKh[nm&A M yJ;v:L_>ln:<[^Y\F�u>[�G{:Lm0K>D`D&_>D`_3rtbzl{[nf>D ��F*:L=\YeXSl^:<[nYebzK�A

�h�

Page 42: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

0 100 200 300 400Fast Signal (Channels)

0

20

40

60

80

En

erg

y (

MeV

)

0 100 200 300 400Fast Signal (Channels)

0

20

40

60

80

En

erg

y (

MeV

)

} Y\gz;>l]D � A �4 | :L=\YeXSl^:<[nYebzK�F`;>l]kLD&m rtbzl8bzK>D�bLr@[nf>D | m P _>D [^D&F [^bzl]m&A>U fSD�p bzY\Kh[^m5G8D&l]D�bzXS[^:LYeKSD&_:Lm�Dac p>=e:LY\K>D&_'Y\K [nf>D0[^Dac�[&A�U fSDEm]bz=eY\_ F`;>l]kLD�Y\K D&:LFHf'pv:LKSD&= mnf>bUG0m�[^f>D�lnD`mn;>= [^Y\K>g�uS[8[nf>lnbz;Sgzf[^fSDBp bzY\Kh[^m&A � D r [ 4 9�lnbL[nbzK5F*:L=\Y\X>l^:<[nYebLKsA ?�Y\gzfh[ 4 ��F&:L=\YeX>ln:<[^Y\bzKsA� ���� � :;6 � 6 � �!�%= �< -��&

U f>D�[RG8b | ? N�| _>D [^D`F`[^bLlnm�G D`lnDBF*:L=\YeXSl^:<[nD&_5rtbzl p bLmnY [^Y\bzKaY\KdX bL[nf�[^f>D�_>Y\mnp D&l]mnY kzDrN cXP{:<K>_K>bzK8Co_>Y\mnp D&l]mnY kzD�Nt7�Pw_>Y\lnD&F [^Y\bzK>m`A.U f>Y\m8G :Lm :LF`F&bzIZp>=\Y\mnf>D`_ G0Y [^f [^f>D ;>mnD bLr0:aI�:Lm]G A T :LFHf_>D [^D&F [^bzlZfv:<_ Y [^m bUG0KI :<mnGXV�:LK>_ D*:LFHf I�:LmnG f>:L_ f>bz=\D&m :LK>_ mn=\Y\[nmZYeKY\[&A�U f>Ddp bLmnY [^Y\bzKbLr�[^f>Ddf>bz=\D&m�:LKS_ m]=eY [^m�G{:<m GJK>bUG0KsA � Y\[nf[nf>D5I�:LmnGJm Y\Kp>=q:<F&D�V�[nf>DdX D&:LI bzK>= 7�mR[^ln;SFHG[^fSD�_>D [^D&F [^bzlFG0f>D&l]D�[^f>D�f>bz=\D&mw:LK>_"m]=eY [^m�l]D&m]Ye_>DsVs:Lm�[^f>D�I�:LmnGdY\[nmnD`=\r'G :Lmw[nf>YeFHGdD&KSbz;>gzf3[nbm][nbzp [^fSD�X D&:LI5A�U f>Y\m lnD&m];>= [^D&_Y\K :"mnp D&F`[nln;>I [^fv:i[SG{:<m ;>mnD`_[nb�F*:L=\YeXSl^:<[nD [^f>D | ? N�|_>D [^D&F [^bzl]m�rtbzlwp bzm]Y\[nYebzK�A U f>D m]p D`F`[nln;>I-;>mnD`_"[^b'F&:L=eY\X>ln:<[^D | ? N�| k Y\m�mnf>bUG0K Y\K } Y\g>A � A�9 AP Ka[nf>D�uvgz;>l]D�Vv[^fSD�K>bLK-Co_>Y\mnp D&l]mnY kzD p bzm]Y\[nYebzKdY\mEgzY kzD`K"Xh7 Q�� � k U M�| VXG0f>Y\=eDB[^f>D�_>Y\mnp D&l]mnY kzDp bzmnY [^Y\bzKdYem0gzY kzD`K3Xh7 Q�� � k | D&K } Y [*A

�F��� 4������ � ����+��d��$*�

� �� � � �'�<�!1A=%93� � @Q��)5�!1�d=>���!13 5)

U f>D�p>:Ll][nYeF`=eDEYe_>D`Kh[^Y uvF*:<[nYebLK�N 9 P�N P�Y\K [^fSYem{Dqc p D`lnY\I�D`Kh[0YeKhkzbL=\kLD&_5mnD kzD&ln:L=�mR[^D`p>m&A>U~7�p>Y\F*:L=\=\7�V:�[RG8b C _>YeIZD`K>mnY\bzKv:L=Sp>=eb<[�bLr>[nf>D D`K>D&l]gL7�=ebzm]m.bLrvrtln:LgzIZD&Kh[nm [^fSlnbz;>gLf�[^f>D8YebLK-CoFHfv:<I�X D&l.kLD&lnm];>m

�z�

Page 43: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

0 100 200 300 400 500

S801_Cen_Fit (Channels)

S801_T

AC

(C

han

nel

s)

100

0

200

300

400

500

} Y\gz;>l]D � A�934vU f>D5I :<mnG m]p D`F`[^l];>I ;>m]D&_ [^b F*:L=\Y\X>l^:<[nD | ? N�| k�rtbzl p bzmnY [^Y\bzKYeK X bL[^f [^fSD_>Y\mnp D&l]mnY kzD5:LK>_ K>bzK-C _>Y\mnp D&lnm]Y\kLD'_>Y\lnD`F`[^Y\bzK>m�YemBmnf>bUG0KsA U f>D p bzY\Kh[^m�Y\K [nf>Y\m�mnp D&F [^l];>I F&bzl ClnD`mnp bzK>_ [^b�fSbz=eD`m�YeK [nf>D�I�:LmnGXV5G0fSYe=\D"[^f>D"kLD&lR[^Y\F*:L=�X>:LK>_>m�F`bzlnl]D&mnp bzK>_ [nb�mn=\Y\[nm�YeK [^fSDI�:LmnG A

[^fSD�[^Y\IZD C bLr C IvY\gzfh[SN U V�} P YemE;>mnD`_"rtbzlEY\_>D`KJ[nY\u>F*:<[nYebzK�pS;>lnp bzmnD`m&A P K3bzl]_>D&l�rtbzl�[nf>Y\mE[o7�p D�bLr:Lp>pSlnbh:LFHf[^b X D5;>m]D`rt;>=�Y\K [^fSYem :LKv:L= 7�mnY\m V�[^fSDaU V�} fv:L_ [nb X Da:L_��R;>mR[^D&_�A P [�m]f>bz;>=\_ X DIZD&Kh[^Y\bzK>D`_ [nfv:<[ [^f>D�U V�} G :Lm�m][^:Ll][nD&_+G0Y [^f [^f>D3F`7�F&=\bL[^l]bzK ? } :<K>_ m][nbzp>p D&_ Xh7 [^fSDmnY\gzKv:<=srtlnbzI [^f>D T k�mnF&Y\Kh[^Y\=e=e:<[nbzl&A U f>D�U V�} G :Lm�:L_��R;Sm][^D`_3Y\K5mn;>FHf3:eG :*7d:Lm [^bZD&=\Y\I�Y\Kv:<[nD[^fSD"_>D&p D&KS_>D&K>F`D�bzK [nf>D"_>Y\mnp D&l]mnY kzD :LK>gz=\D�V��nV�rtbzl KJ;>F`=eD`YFG0Y [^f m]YeIZY\=q:Ll I :<mnm [nb FHfv:Ll]gzDN I �<y!P�l^:<[nYebzm`A@U f>D U V�} G :Lm�mn;>X>m]D&yJ;>D`KJ[n=\7�:L_��R;>mR[^D&_ [^b3D`=eY\IZYeK>:<[^D [nf>D�_>D&p D&K>_SD&K>F`D�bzK[^fSD�_>Y\mnp D&l]mnY kzD�p bzm]Y\[nYebLKartbzl | ? N�| k.N Q�� � k | D&K } Y [TP�rtbzl m]YeIZY\=q:Ll�I �<y A U f>D�gLD&K>D`l^:L=>G : 7Y\KYG0f>Y\FHf'[^f>Y\m-G :Lm _SbzK>DFG :Lm�[^f>D�rtbz=e=\bUG0YeKSg14�u>lnm][ VS:�[RG b*Co_>Y\IZD&K>m]YebzK>:L=�p>=\bL[ bLrsU V�} kLD&lnm];>m��N =\D`r [�pv:LK>D`= YeK } YegSA � A � P�G :Lm�F&l]D*:<[nD&_sA � Y\[nf [nf>Yem�p>=\bL[ Vz[nf>D�U V�} G{:<m :L_��R;>m][nD&_ ;SmnY\K>g�[^fSDrtbz=\=ebUG0Y\K>g�D&yJ;v:<[nYebzK-4

����� � � ����� � k . �MN � % � \ P .�� N � % � \ P Z �@G N � A k P

U f>D�pv:Lln:LIZD`[nD&lnm �'V � Vv:LKS_ � \ G8D&lnD�_>D [^D`lnIZYeKSD&_3Xh7�l]D*:L_SYeK>gZp bzY\KJ[nm rtlnbzI [^f>D�=\D`r [0p>=\bL[0Y\K} Y\g>A � A � ASU V�} � G{:Lm fSD&=\_aF`bzK>m][^:LKh[ rtbzl :L=\=sp bzY\KJ[nm lnD&:L_�rtlnbzI [^f>D�p>=\bL[{rtbLl : gzY\kLD&KdI �<y Y\K

� m

Page 44: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

0 100 200 300

q (a.u.)

0

100

200

300

400

500

TO

F (

a.u.)

100 200 300 400 500

S801_Cen_Fit (Channels)

0

100

200

300

400

500

TO

F(a

.u.)

} Y\gz;>l]D � A � 4v9�=\bL[^m�;SmnD&_"[nb�:L_��R;Sm][w[nf>D U V�} pv:<l^:LIZD`[nD&l�rtbzlwpv:<l][^Y\F&=\D�Y\_>D`KJ[nY\u>F*:<[nYebzK�A � D`r [ 4U V�} k�m`A � A ?0Yegzfh[�4vU V�} k�m&A | ? N�| k�_>Yem]p D`lnm]Y\kLD�p bzmnY [^Y\bzK[^fSYem{pSlnb�F&D&m]m&Av?0D*:<_>YeKSg b�Jd[^f>l]D&Dwk<:L=\;>D&m{rtbLl �nV � V>:LK>_ U V�} 7 Y\D&=\_>D`_d[nf>lnD`D�D&yJ;v:<[nYebLK>m5G0Y [^f[^fSlnD&DE;>K>GJK>bUG0K>mTV<G0f>Y\FHf5:L=e=\bUG D`_'rtbzl8:�mnY\IZp>=\D�:L=egLD&X>ln:LYeF�mnbL=e;S[nYebLKsASU f>D�[^f>l]D&DEp bzY\Kh[^m5G8D&l]DFHf>bzm]D&K3:L=ebLK>g [^f>D�F`D&Kh[^D`lEb<r bLK>D�bLrx[^f>D�Xv:<K>_>m�:<[{[nf>D�X D`gzYeKSK>YeKSg!V>IZYe_S_>=eDsV :LK>_5D&KS_abLrx[^fSDlnD`gzY\bzKsA U f>D K>DTG pv:<l^:LIZD`[nD&lTV U V�} � VXG :Lmwrt;>lR[^f>D`l�:L_��R;>mR[^D`_"rtlnbzI : p>=\bL[wbLr�U V�} � kLD&lnm];>mQ�� � k | D&K } Y [dN���P^A>U f>Y\m p>=eb<[ Yem mnf>bUG0KdYeK'[nf>D�lnY\gzfh[ mnY\_>D�bLr } Y\g>A � A � ASU f>D�D`yJ;v:<[^Y\bzK5;>m]D&_Y\Kd[nf>Yem0mR[^D&paYem0m]YeIZY\=q:Ll [nb T yJKsA � A kbVv:LKS_aY\m�4

����� � � � � ��� � � k .�� N�� % � \ P ��G N � A � P

U f>Y\m�[^Y\IZD [nf>D&l]D':Ll]D bzK>= 7 [RG b3;>K>GJK>bUG0K>m V.Kv:LIZD&= 7 � :<K>_�� \ AxU f>D&m]D'pv:Lln:LIZD`[^D`lnm8G8D&l]D_>D [^D&l]IZYeK>D`_aY\K�[^f>D�mn:LIZD�r :Lmnf>Y\bzKd:Lm �'V � Vv:LKS_�� \ A>U f>D�k<:L=\;>D&m rtbz;>KS_5rtbLl [^f>D�p>:Ll^:LIZD [^D&l]m:Ll]DBm]f>bUG0KaY\KdU.:LXS=eD � A kzAU f>DBK>DTG U V�} pv:Lln:LIZD`[nD&l VvU V�} � � VvY\KdF`bzK��R;>KSF`[^Y\bzK G0Y\[nfd[nf>D�D&K>D`lngL7�=\bzm]m�b<r [nf>D�rtl^:Lg C

IZD&Kh[^m [nf>lnbz;Sgzf�[^f>D�Y\bzK-C FHfv:LI�X D&l-N PR| Q ;>I.P V :L=\=\b G8D&_Brtbzl�[nf>D�uvlnmR[xm][^D`p�YeK�[^fSD89 P�N p>lnb�F&D`mnm`AU f>Y\mwp>=\bL[EYem�mnfSb G0K�Y\Ka[nf>DBlnY\gzfh[wm]Ye_>D�bLr } Y\g>A � A !SA M =\mnb mnf>bUG0K"Y\K3[nf>Yem0uvgz;SlnDBYemw: p>=\bL[�bLrPR| Q ;>I k�m&A@U V�} A U f>Y\m�pS=ebL[Bm]f>bUG0m�[^f>:<[�[^f>D :L_��R;>mR[^IZD&Kh[B[^b5[^f>D�U V�} p>:Ll^:LIZD [^D&ldG :LmY\K>_>D&D`_ K>D`F&D`mnm^:<l]7bV :Lm~Y [MG :Lm~Y\I�p bzm]mnY\X>=eD�[^b�_>Y\m][nYeK>gL;>Yem]f'X D`[RG8D&D&K Yem]bL[^bLp D`mMG0Y [^f>bL;S[�Y\[&AhU f>D

� �

Page 45: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

400 600 800

TOF (a.u.)

50

100

150

200

IC_

Su

m (

a.u

.)17O

Gate

16O

15N

14N13C

12C

200 300 400

TOF (a.u.)’’

IC_S

um

(a.

u.)

100

200

300

400

} Y\gz;>l]D � A !�4 � D r [ 4J9�=\bL[�bLr PR| Q ;SI k m`AJU V�} AJ?�Y\gzfh[ 4J9�=\bL[�bLr PR| Q ;SI k m`AJU V�} � � AhU f>Y\m�p>=eb<[G :Lm�;SmnD&_ YeKSY\[nYq:L=\= 7�rtbzl�pv:LlR[^Y\F&=\D Y\_>D&Kh[nY\uvF&:<[^Y\bzKsA@U f>D�gh:<[nD ;>mnD`_ Y\mBm]f>bUG0KsA@U f>D�Ye_>D`Kh[^Y uvD&_Y\mnbL[nbzp D`m�:LlnDB:L=\mnb�YeKS_>YeF&:<[^D`_sA

Y\K>Y\[nYq:<=sgh:<[nD�;>mnD`_artbzl 9 P�N Yem0m]f>bUG0KaY\Kd[nf>D�lnY\gzfh[�mnY\_>D�bLr } YegSA � A !SA M K>DaG gh:i[^D"G :Lm0I :<_>Drtbzl D&:LFHf3Y\K>_>Y k�Ye_>;>:L= ln;>K�AvU f>Yem�G :Lm�[nb�:LF&F`bz;>Kh[0rtbzl0:LKh75_>lnY r [^m0Y\K�[^f>DB? } AM m]D&F`bzK>_"gh:i[^DdG{:LmEp>=e:LF&D`_"bzK":Zp>=\bL[EbLr PR| Q ;>I kLD&lnm];>mw[nf>D�gLD&bzIZD`[nlnY\F�IZD*:<K3bLr T kzA

U f>Y\m0Yem0mnfSb G0KdY\Kd[nf>D�lnY\gzfh[0mnY\_>D�bLr } YegSA � A k � A } bzl F&bzIZpv:Ll]Yem]bzK V>[nf>D�=eD r [0mnY\_>D�bLr } Yeg>A � A k �mnfSb G0mx[^f>D~mn:LIZD8p>=\bL[@X D`rtbzl]D�[^f>D�gh:<[nD�mnf>bUG0K Y\K } Yeg>A � A ! G :Lm Y\IZp>=\D&IZD&Kh[^D`_sAiU f>D8gLD&bzIZD`[nlnY\FIZD*:LK5rtbzl T kBYem0gzY kzD`K3Xh7 4

� ���BCF��� ���@��CF��� k ��� N k ��^PaN k ������%P 0 N � A � P

U :LX>=\D � A k�4v9.:Lln:LIZD`[nD&lnm�;>m]D&_�[^b5:<_��R;>m][w[^f>D U V�} pv:Lln:LIZD`[nD&lwrtbzlwpv:Ll][nYeF`=eD�Ye_>D`Kh[^Y uvF*:<[nYebLKsAM =\= ;>K>Y [^m�:Ll]DB:LlnX>Y [^ln:Ll]7LA

9.:<l^:LIZD`[nD&l l�:<=e;>D� � A � � k ��� �� m>A k�9 � k ��� i� \ � �h� A k � k� � A �� � k � � �� \ � 9sm4!SA 4�

Page 46: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

100 200 300Geometric Mean E1 (a.u.)

50

100

150

200

IC_

Su

m (

a.u

.)

100 200 300Geometric Mean E1 (a.u.)

50

100

150

200

IC_S

um

(a.

u.)

Gate

} Y\gz;>l]D � A k � 4 � D`r [ 409�=\bL[5bLr PR| Q ;>I k�m&AFL�D&bzIZD`[nlnY\F caD*:LK T k X D`rtbLlnD�[^f>D Y\K>Y [^Ye:L=�gh:<[nDmnfSb G0K Y\K } Yeg>A � A !rG :Lm�Y\IZp>=eD`IZD&Kh[^D`_sA.?0Y\gzfh[ 4s9�=\bL[�bLr PR| Q ;>I k�m`A%L�D`bzIZD`[nlnY\F cdD*:LK T k:<r [nD&l{[^fSD�gh:i[^D�mnfSb G0KaYeK } Y\g>A � A !SG{:<mEY\IZp>=eD`IZD&Kh[^D`_sA U fSYem�p>=\bL[�;>=\[nYeI�:<[nD&= 75gh:*kzD�pv:LlR[^Y\F&=\DY\_>D&Kh[^Y uvF&:<[^Y\bzKsA U f>DBgh:<[nD�;>mnD`_artbzl{uvK>:L= pv:LlR[^Y\F&=\DBY\_>D`KJ[nY\u>F*:<[nYebzKaYem0m]f>bUG0KsA

G0f>D`lnD k ��a:LKS_ k ������3:LlnD�[nf>D�m]YegzK>:L=em{rtl]bzI [^f>Dw[nbzp5:LK>_5X bL[n[nbzI 9�caU m Vvl]D&mnp D&F C[^Y kzD`=\7LA U~7�p>Y\F*:L=\=\7�V [nf>D�gzD&bzIZD [^lnY\FBI�D&:LK3Y\m�K>bL[�p bLmnY [^Y\bzK3m]D&K>m]Y\[nY\kLD���fSb G8D`kLD&lTV [^fSYem�G{:<mEK>b<[[^fSD�F*:Lm]D�YeK'[nf>Yem Dqc p D`lnY\I�D`Kh[*A gji V rtln:LgzIZD&Kh[nm{[^fv:<[{f>Y\[ [^f>D�=\D`r [ f>:L=\rxbLr@[nf>D T k�mnF&Y\Kh[^Y\=e=e:<[nbzllnD`mn;>= [^D`_�YeK": _>YKJ�D`lnD`KJ[wgzD&bLI�D [^l]YeF IZD&:LK3[^f>:LKartln:LgzIZD&Kh[^mWG0f>Y\FHf�f>Y\[E[^f>D�lnY\gzfh[wf>:L=\r�A U f>Y\mY\mwD`k�Y\_>D&Kh[�Y\K3[^fSD lnY\gzfh[�m]Ye_>D�bLr } Y\g>A � A k � A | =eD&:Lln= 73[nf>D&l]D :Ll]D�[RG8b�YeKh[^D`K>mnD l]D&gzY\bzK>mEYeKa[^f>Y\mp>=\bL[*A4gji V rtl^:LgzIZD`KJ[nm f>Y [n[nYeK>g"[nf>D F`D&Kh[^D`l bLr T k�mnf>bUG ;>p Y\K [^f>Y\m p>=\bL[ X D`[RG8D&D`K�[^f>D [RG8blnD`gzY\bzK>m D`K>F&=\bzm]D&_5Xh7�[nf>Dwgz:<[^D<A U f>Y\m{DaJ�D`F`[{I�:*7 fv:*kzD�X D&D`K'_>;>D�[^b m]bzIZDw_>D&:L_�:Ll]D*:�Y\K [^fSDmnF`YeKh[nYe=\=q:i[^bzl`ALU f>Y\m�gh:<[nD�ViYeK�F&bzK��R;SK>F`[nYebzKSG0Y [^f [nf>D b<[^f>D`l N l]YegLfJ[.mnY\_>D{bLr } Yeg>A � A ! P_V<;>= [^Y\I�:<[^D`=\7:L=\=ebUG8D&_drtbzl YeKSD&=e:Lm][nYeF&:L=e= 75mnF&:<[n[nD&l]D&_ gji V D`kLD&Kh[^m�[^bZX D�Y\mnbz=e:<[nD&_sA

� �� �� �"�����-� ��)5� � )"�%� � � �� -&n&

U f>D D&K>D`lngL7 =ebLmnm�b<r gji V rtl^:LgLI�D`Kh[^m�G :Lm�_>D`[nD&lnIZY\K>D&_ G0Y [^f [^f>D Q�� �z� I :<gzK>D`[nYeF mnp D&F [^lnb*Cgzln:Lp>fsAxU f>D Y\KSrtbzl]I�:<[^Y\bzK F`bz=e=\D&F [^D`_ rtlnbzI [nf>D | ? N�| _>D`[nD&F [^bzl]m F&bzIZp>=\D`[nD&= 7�_SD`[^D`lnIZY\K>D&_[^fSD5[nl^:��RD`F`[nbzl]7�bLrErtln:LgzIZD&Kh[nm�l]D*:LFHfSYeK>g [^fSD5rtb�F*:<= p>=e:LK>D<A�U f>D5pv:Ll^:<I�D [^D`lnmZbLr�rtl^:LgzIZD`KJ[nmlnD&:LFHf>Y\K>g�[^f>D rtb�F*:<=.p>=e:LK>DZ:Ll]D gzY kzD&K Xh7�� � V � � V�� � Vs:<K>_ � � AsU f>D p>:Ll^:LIZD [^D&l]m�� � :LKS_�� �

� 9

Page 47: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

gzY kzDw[nf>Dwp bzm]Y\[nYebzK':<[ [nf>DErtb�F&;>mTVnG0f>Y\=\D � � :LK>_�� � gzY kzDw[nf>D�:LK>gL=eD`m bLr [nl^:��RD`F`[^bLl]7�YeK [^f>DFc)C��:LK>_d74C���pS=q:LKSD&m V lnD`mnp D&F [^Y kzD&= 7zA�U f>D&m]D pv:Lln:LIZD`[^D`lnmTV�:L=\bzK>gpG0Y\[nf3I�:LgzKSD`[^Y\F�u>D&=\_"I�:Lp>p>Y\K>gzmTVG8D&lnDB;>m]D&_a[nbZ_>D`[nD&lnIZY\K>D�[^f>D�D&KSD&lng<75=ebzm]m&AU f>D0I�:LgzK>D [^Y\F0u>D&=\_>m~F&lnD&:<[^D`_ Xh7�[^f>D0I�:LgzK>D [^mHG0Y [^f>Y\KZ[^f>D0mnp D&F [^l]bzgzl^:<p>feG D`lnD0I�:Lp>p D&_

:Lm8_>D&m]F&lnY\X D&_5YeK'?�D r�A � m � � A�� Y\[nf [^f>Y\m{Y\KSrtbzl]I :i[^Y\bzK V�Y\[MG{:<m{p bLmnmnY\X>=\Dw[^b :LKv:L= 7J[^Y\F*:L=\=\7 lnD`F&bzK8Cm][nln;>F [ [^fSD [^ln:��RD&F [^bzlR7 bLr{rtl^:<gzIZD&Kh[^m8G0Y [^f�G�KSb G0K�I�:LgLK>D`[nYeF'l]YegLYe_>Y [o7 [^f>l]bz;>gzf [^f>D Q�� �z� AU f>D�:LX>Y\=\Y\[o7"[nb5lnD&F`bzK>mR[^ln;SF`[B[^f>D [^ln:��RD&F [^bzlR7bVsF`bz;>p>=\D&_�G0Y\[nf [nf>D IZD*:Lm];>lnD`_�pv:<l^:LIZD`[nD&l]m�:i[[^fSD rtb F`;>m V.:L=\=ebUG8D&_�rtbzl�[^f>D'F&:L=\F&;>=e:<[^Y\bzK�bLr0yJ;v:<KJ[nY\[nYeD`m [^fv:<[�_>D&m]F&l]YeX D'[^f>D I�b<[^Y\bzK�bLr [^fSDrtl^:<gzIZD&Kh[^m :Lm�[nf>D`7=\D`r [�[^f>Dd[H:Ll]gzD`[ N � � V � � V�� � V � � P^A~U f>D3yJ;v:LKh[nY\[o7 � � Y\m�lnD&=e:<[nD&_ [nb [^fSDrtl^:<gzIZD&Kh[ � m0G�Y\K>D [^Y\F�D`K>D&l]gL7zA Q p D&F`Y\uvF&:L=\=\7�V [nf>D�yJ;v:LKh[^Y [o7 � � Yem0gzY kzD`K3Xh7

� � � % �� �� 0 N � A m P

G0f>D`lnD �� Y\m [^f>D�GJY\K>D`[nYeF�D`K>D&l]gL7�bLr0rtln:LgzIZD&Kh[^m [nl^:*kzD`=eY\K>g :L=\bzK>g"[nf>D�F&D`KJ[nl^:L={: c YemZbLr0[^fSDmnp D&F [^l]bzIZD`[^D`l&A U f>DByJ;v:LKh[^Y [o7 �� Y\m�_SD`[^D`lnIZY\K>D&_"Xh7

����� ]R\R\ � � �� �� � C ��� G N � A�� P

U f>D�yJ;v:LKh[^Y [^Y\D&m ����� ]R\R\ V�C V :LK>_ � :LlnD�[nf>D~I :<gzK>D`[nYeF~l]YegzY\_>Y [o7�mnD [n[^Y\K>g�bLr�[^f>D Q�� �L� V*rtl^:LgLI�D`Kh[I�:LmnmTV�:<K>_artln:LgzIZD&Kh[EFHfv:LlngLD�V lnD&m]p D`F`[nY\kLD&= 7zAsU f>DB[H:Ll]gzD`[E:LKS_artb�F&;>mEy�;>:LKh[^Y [^Y\D&m�:<lnDBlnD&=e:<[nD&_[^fSlnbz;>gLfd[nf>D�I :i[^lnY c5D`y�;>:<[^Y\bzK

��������

� �� �� �� �

���������� �

��������

� �� �� �� �

��������� 0 N � A P

G0f>D`lnD � Y\m [^f>D�Y\KhkzD&l]mnD�I :i[^lnY c^V!G0f>Y\FHf3Y\m�F&:L=\F&;>=e:<[^D`_3Xh7'[nf>D�F&b�_>D���������������� �!�#"$� � m � � AU f>Dwp>:Ll^:LIZD [^D&l]m � � :LK>_ �� :<lnD�:<=e=v[^f>:<[�Yem8K>D&D`_>D&_'[nb�F&:L=eF`;>=e:<[^D�[^f>DED&K>D`lngL7�=\bzmnm8bLrs[^fSD

� �

Page 48: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

0 20 40 60 80 100 120Energy Loss (MeV)

0

1

2

3

4

5

Counts

(10

/MeV

)4

} Y\gz;>l]D � A kbk�4>U f>D Q�� �z� mnY\K>gz=\D&m�D&KSD&lng<7)C =ebLmnm�mnp D&F`[nln;>I Y\m�mnf>bUG0K rtbLl5gji V D`kLD&Kh[^m`ASU f>D0p D*:LG:<[�� k��ZcaDal Y\m rtlnbzI [^f>D�gzl]bz;>K>_8Com][^:<[^D�L N ?BA

rtl^:<gzIZD&Kh[^m`AvU f>D�D`K>D&l]gL75bLrx[^f>D�rtln:LgzIZD&Kh[^mTV � VvY\m0gzY kzD&KdXh7

� � � � �� . �� G N � A�9 P

U f>DBpv:Lln:LIZD`[^D`l B3Y\m�F&:L=\F&;>=e:<[^D`_artl]bzI [nf>Yem0D`K>D&l]gL7zA cabzl]D�mnp D&F&Y uvF&:L=e= 7bV

B�� k� k %����� �

� �CF� Z . k 0 N � A � P

G0f>D`lnD�ZY\m [^f>D�kzD`=eb�F&Y [o7'bLr [nf>DErtln:LgzIZD&Kh[{:LK>_F�0Yem�[^f>D�m]p D`D&_�bLr@=\Y\gzfh[*A } YeK>:L=e= 7bVJ[^fSD�D&K>D`lngL7=\bzmnm�N � P Y\m0gzY kzD&KaXh7

� � CF�qZB N5B \ % B P 0 N � A ! P

G0f>D`lnD B \ Y\m�F&:L=eF`;>=e:<[^D`_�YeK�[nf>D'mn:LIZD I�:LK>K>D`l :Lm B�VxDac F`D&pS[SG0Y [^f � l]D&p>=e:LF&D`_ G0Y\[nf �� AU f>DBD&K>D`lngL74C =ebzm]m0mnp D&F`[nln;>I�rtbLl Q�� �z� mnY\K>gz=\D&m gji V D kzD&Kh[nmwY\m�m]f>bUG0K3Y\K } YegSA � A kbkzA

� !

Page 49: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

E (a.u.)slow

100 200 300 400 500

100

200

300

400

500

n s’

Gate

g’s

Pile-up

E(a

.u.)

fast

00

E (a.u.)slow

100 200 300 400 500

E(a

.u.)

fast

100

200

300

400

500

Gate

n s’

g’s

00

} Y\gz;>l]D � A k � 4>9~=\bL[nm ;>m]D&_ [nb D`=eY\IZYeK>:<[^Daf>YegLf-CoD`K>D&l]gL7K>D&;S[nlnbzKSm�rtl]bzI [^f>Da:LKv:<=\7�mnY\m&A86 bL[nfp>=\bL[^mwmnf>bUG T�� � � � kLD&lnm];>m T � ����� A � D`r [�4s9�=eb<[�rtbzlErtbLl7G :Lln_�_>D [^D`F`[^bLl&A ?0YegLfJ[�4s9�=\bL[�rtbzlEXv:LFHG CG :Lln_�_>D [^D`F`[^bLl&AsU f>D�gh:<[^D�;>mnD`_"[^b�Dac F`=e;>_SD K>D&;S[nlnbzKSm�Yem�m]f>bUG0K YeK�D&:LFHf�p>=\bL[*A U f>D Xv:LKS_>mF&bLlnlnD`mnp bzK>_>Y\K>gZ[^b�p>Y\=eD Co;>p VvKSD&;S[nlnbzK V :<K>_ BaD`kLD&Kh[^mw:LlnDB:L=\mnb�YeKS_>YeF&:<[^D`_sA

�F��� � ��� � � �~��� � �)����+ �d��$*�

� �� � DW��9A�%= �!1A -)C -,��:;� �W&

P K'bzl]_>D&l8[^b mR[^;>_S7�[^fSD�D`kLbz=e; [^Y\bzK�bLrs[nf>DdL N ?;G0Y\_S[nf.G0Y\[nf'[^D&IZp D&ln:<[^;>l]D�V�[^f>D B0C l^:*7 _>D&F&: 7mnp D&F [^l];>I�fv:L_a[nb X D�Dqc�[^l^:<F`[^D`_3rtlnbLI�[^f>D�_v:<[H: AvU f>D�DqcSF`Y\[nD&_ Q KaKJ;>F&=\D&;>mwp>lnD`_>bzIZYeK>:LKh[^= 7_>D`F*:*7�m8Xh7 K>D`;S[^l]bzK�D&IZYem]mnY\bzK':i[~D&K>D`lngzY\D&m8:LX b kLD [^f>D K>D`;S[^l]bzK�X>YeKS_>YeKSg�D`K>D&l]gL7zA M m8:�l]D&mn;S=\[ VI�:LKh7 K>D&; [^lnbLK>mpG8D&l]DaD`IZY\[][^D&_ :Lm [^f>D5KJ;>F`=eD`;>m _>D`F*:*7zD`_sA�U f>DaKSD&;S[nlnbzK>m�G8D&lnDd_>D [^D&F [^D`_ V:L=\bzK>gSG0Y [^f�[^fSD B3l^:*7�m VSXJ7 [^f>D�6 : } Z _>D`[nD&F [^bzl]m&A P r@[^f>D BDC l^:*7 _SD&F*:*7�b<rx[nf>D L N ? Y\m{[^b X Dm][n;>_>Y\D&_ V>[nf>D�K>D&; [^lnbLKdD kzD`KJ[nmwI�;>m][�X D�_>Yem]F&l]YeIZY\Kv:<[^D`_":Lgz:LYeKSm][ VSmnb [^fv:i[0bzK>= 73BDCol^:*7 D`kzD`Kh[^m:Ll]DBF`bzK>m]Ye_>D`lnD`_sA U f>D�_SYem]F&lnY\IZYeK>:<[^Y\bzK3b<r.K>D`;S[^l]bzK>m0F&bLK>mnY\m][nD&_"bLrx[RG8b pv:<l][^m`AU f>D�uvlnmR[�m][^D`p Y\KmnD&=\D&F [^Y\K>g BDC l^:*7 D kzD&Kh[nmpG :LmZ[^b"[H:<GLDd:L_Sk<:LKh[H:<gzD5bLr0[^f>D�[RG8b F`bzI C

p bzK>D&Kh[nm bLr�=eY\gzfh[ZD&IZY [n[^D`_ YeK 6{: } Z A�U f>D�ln:<[^Y\b"bLr0[nf>D'r :Lm][ C [nb Com]=ebUG F&bzIZp bzK>D`KJ[Zb<rE=\Y\gzfh[Y\m _>YKJ�D`lnD&Kh[ rtbzl�K>D&; [^lnbLK>m [^fv:<K�Y\[�Yem rtbzl B ln:*7 m`A M mZ:3lnD`mn;>= [ V�Y [8G :Lm p bzmnm]YeXS=eD'[nb�D&=\YeIZY CKv:<[nD I�:LKh73b<r�[^f>D�K>D&;S[nlnbzK�D kzD`KJ[nm�XJ7agh:<[nYeKSg'bzK�: pS=ebL[wbLr�[^fSD�r :Lm][EkzD`lnmn;SmBm]=ebUG mnY\gzKv:<=em`A} Y\g>A � A k � mnfSb G0m mn;>FHf :�p>=eb<[*A�U f>Ddgh:<[nD�mnf>bUG0K Y\KD*:LFHf mnY\_>Dab<rE[nf>D5p>=eb<[pG :LmZ;>m]D&_ [nb

m �

Page 50: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

Dac F`=e;>_SD D`kLD&Kh[^m`A M m]D&pv:<l^:<[nD�gz:<[^DeG :Lm�I :<_>D rtbzl�D*:LFHf YeKS_>Y\k�Y\_>;v:L=~_>D [^D`F`[^bLl&Axc3:LKh7 IZbzl]DK>D`;S[^l]bzK>mSG8D&lnD5D`I�Y [n[nD&_ Y\K [^f>D'rtbzlAG{:<ln_�_>Y\lnD`F`[^Y\bzK�[^f>:LK YeK [nf>D�Xv:LFHG G :Lln__>Y\lnD&F [^Y\bzK V�:<mD`k�Y\_>D&Kh[0Y\K'[^f>Dwp>=eb<[*A�U f>D&l]D�Yem :L=em]bZ:�lnD`gzY\bzK [^f>:<[ F&bLlnlnD`mnp bzK>_>m8[^b p>Y\=\D Co;Sp'rtbzl8[nf>DwrtbzlAG{:Ll]__>D [^D&F [^bzl`A 9�Ye=\D C ;>pab�F&F`;>lnm G0f>D`K3I�;>=\[nYepS=eDB=ebUG C D&K>D`lngL73Bal^:*7�m0f>Y\[0[nf>D�m^:LIZD�_>D`[nD&F [^bzl`AvU f>Db�F&F&;SlnlnD`K>F&DBbLr p>Y\=eD Co;>pdYem0F`bzIZp>=eD [^D`=\7dl^:<K>_>bzI5AP K bzl]_>D&l@[^bED&=\YeIZY\Kv:<[^D =ebUG CoD`K>D&l]gL7BK>D&; [^lnbLK>m V<Y\[�G{:<m�K>D&F`D&m]m^:LlR7�[nbwF&bLK>mnY\_>D&l [^f>D�[^Y\I�D CobLr C

IvY\gzfh[�:Lm IZD*:Lm];>lnD`_ X D [RG D`D&K [^fSD Y\K>_>Y k Y\_>;v:<=>6{: } Z _>D`[nD&F [^bzl]m�:LK>_B[^f>D ? } N U V�}�� � � � PHAiU f>DIvY\gzfh[{[^Y\IZDwm]f>bz;>=\_�X Dwmnf>bzlR[^D`l rtbzl Bdln:*7 m{[nfv:LK'KSD&;S[nlnbzK>m{:<[{=\bUG D`K>D&l]gzY\D&m V X D`F*:L;SmnD B5l^:*7�mIZb kzD :i[�[nf>DBmnp D&D&_abLr�=\Y\gzfh[*A CED`K>F&DsV Xh75p>=\bL[n[nYeKSg�[nf>D�D`K>D&l]gL7d_>D&p bzm]Y\[nD&_3Y\K3D&:LFHf3_SD`[^D`F`[nbzl:Lgh:<YeK>mR[8[nf>DwU V�}�� � � � V�Y\[MG{:<m p bzmnm]YeX>=\Dw[nb�D&=\Y\I�Y\Kv:<[nD�:L=\= K>D&; [^lnbLK>m rtlnbLI [^f>DE:LKv:L= 7�mnY\m&A U f>Dp>=\bL[�;>m]D&_Z[^b�_>b�[nf>Yem�Y\m�mnfSb G0K�Y\K } YegSA � A k � A } YegSA � A k � :wm]f>bUG0m~[nf>D b kzD`l^:L=\=vmnp D&F [^ln;SI VbG0fSYe=\D[^fSD�bL[^fSD&l{p>=\bL[nm{YeK } Yeg>A � A k � m]f>bUG m]I :<=e=\D&l{ln:LK>gzD`m{bLr [nYeIZD&m`A } Y\g>A � A k � X�mnf>bUG0m{[nf>D�lnD`gzY\bzKF&bLlnlnD`mnp bzK>_>Y\K>gB[^b�[^f>D0p>l]bzIZpS[2B l^:*7�m V G0f>Y\=eD } Y\g>A � A k � F0Yem~rtbzl�[nfv:<[�bLr�[nf>D�l^:LK>_SbzI�B'ln: 7�m`AU f>D gh:<[^DZm]f>bUG0K YeK } YegSA � A k � X�G :Lm�;>mnD`_�rtbzl�uvKv:L= BDColn:*7 mnD&=\D&F [^Y\bzKsA U f>D&m]D B�l^:*7�m�G8D&l]D;>= [^Y\I�:<[^D`=\7 ;>mnD`_'[^b F`lnD&:<[^D BDC l^:*7�_>D&F&: 7 mnp D&F [^ln:SA P K'bLln_>D`l8[^b�_>D`[nD&lnIZY\K>Dw[nf>D�Xv:LFHGJgzl]bz;>K>_ V:LK>_�[nf>D�F&bzKh[^l]YeXS;S[^Y\bzK5[^b [^f>D�p>l]bzIZpS[ B3ln:*7 m rtl]bzI [nf>D�l^:LK>_SbzI bzKSD&m V : m]D&F&bLK>_3gh:i[^D"G :LmY\I�pS=eD`I�D`Kh[^D&_�AvU f>Yem gz:<[^DEYem{m]f>bUG0K5YeK } Y\g>A � A k � FLA U f>D�gh:i[^Dwm]f>bUG0K5f>D&l]D�Yem [nf>D�mn:LIZD�gh:<[nD:Lm�;>mnD`_�rtbzl�[^f>D p>lnbzIZpS[ B�l^:*7�m V Dac F&D`pS[ [nfv:<[�Y\[�Yem�mnf>Y r [^D`_ Xh7 [nf>DZ[^Y\I�D X D [RG D`D&K X D*:LIX>;>l]m][nm�rtlnbzI [nf>D F 7 F`=eb<[^lnbLK N �sm>A � KSmaPHAxU f>Y\mZ:L=\=ebUG8D&_ rtbzl�[^f>D F&l]D*:<[nYebzK�b<r0:LK>bL[nf>D&l BDCol^:*7mnp D&F [^l];>I5A U f>Y\m�mnp D&F`[nln;>I gz: kLD�[nf>D�Xv:LFHGJgzlnbL;>K>_':<K>_�[nf>D�F&bzKh[^l]YeXS;S[^Y\bzK b<r�ln:LK>_>bzIZm`A W DTGgh:<[nD&mSG8D&l]DaF`lnD*:i[^D&_ rtbzl D kzD`l]7 ln;SK[nb :<F&F&bL;>Kh[�rtbLl :LKh7�_>l]Y\r [nm�Y\K�[^f>Dd? } A.U fSDdm]p D`F`[nl^:mnfSb G0KaYeK } Y\g>A � A k � :Ll]D�rtbzlQk � ln;>KSm&A

� �� �� DF/" ��h���;:;�%=> -)"& �<�X "= ��13 -)

Uxb Y\IZp>lnb kzD [^f>D l]D&mnp bzK>m]D b<r�[^fSD 6 : } Z :Llnln: 7�V0:m]f>bUG D`lal]D&F`bzK>m][nln;>F [^Y\bzK l]bz;S[^Y\K>D G :LmY\I�pS=eD`I�D`Kh[^D&_�A M =\= 6{: } Z D`kLD&Kh[^m mnD&Kh[�[^b�[^f>D�lnbL;S[^Y\K>D�G D`lnDE:LKv:L= 7 �&D&_ YeKZ[^f>D0rtbz=\=ebUG0Y\K>g�G :*7 4uvl]m][ V>[nf>D&m]D�D`kzD`Kh[^mFG8D&l]D�mnbzlR[^D&_dY\KJ[nb _SD&mnF`D&K>_SYeK>g bzln_SD&l&A W Dac�[ V [nf>D�_>D [^D&F [^bzl G0Y [^fdf>Y\gzf>D&mR[

m!k

Page 51: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

120 160 200 240 280

8

16

24

32

40

180 190 200 210 220

8

16

24

32

40

g’s n s’

Gate

126 136 146 166 186

8

16

24

32

40

g’sn s’

Gate

(a)

(b) (c)

E(M

eV)

BaF

20

TOF (ns)BaF2

E(M

eV)

BaF

2

E(M

eV)

BaF

2

TOF (ns)BaF2TOF (ns)BaF2

00

} Y\gz;>l]D � A k � 4>9~=\bL[nm.;>m]D&_ rtbzl@uvKv:L=8BDColn: 7�m]D&=\D&F [^Y\bzKsA�N : P } ;S=e=�mnp D&F [^ln;SI ;SmnD&_ Y\K�[nf>D{:LK>:L=\7�m]Yem`AN X P ?�D`gzYebLK b<r�m]p D`F`[^l];>I F&bLlnlnD`mnp bzK>_>Y\K>g [^b p>l]bzIZpS[ B l^:*7�m&A NtF P ?0D&gzY\bzK bLr�mnp D&F`[nln;>IF&bLlnlnD`mnp bzK>_>Y\K>g"[nb3l^:<K>_>bzI B�l^:*7�m&A W D`;S[^l]bzK�:LK>_ B0C l^:*7 D`kLD&Kh[^mZ:Ll]D Y\K>_>Y\F*:i[^D&_�Y\K pv:<K>D&=\mN X P{:<K>_�N F P^AvU f>DBgh:<[^D`m ;>mnD`_3Y\Kd[nf>DB:LKv:L= 7�mnY\mw:<lnD�:L=\mnb�mnf>bUG0KsA

D&KSD&lng<7 G{:Lm�:Lm]mnY\gzK>D&_�:Lm�[^f>DZp>l]YeI�:LlR7 _>D`[nD&F [^bzl�Y\K [nf>D pSlnY\I :<l]7�m]f>bUG D`l&A M r [^D`l�[^f>Y\m V [^fSD_>D [^D&F [^bzl>G0Y [^f�[^f>D�m]D&F`bzK>_Bf>YegLf>D&mR[.D`K>D&l]gL7"G :Lm@F&bzK>m]Ye_SD&lnD`_sA P r [nf>Y\mx_SD`[^D`F`[nbzl K>D&Y\gzfJX bzlnD`_�[^fSDp>l]YeI�:LlR75_>D`[nD&F`[nbzl�YeK5[^f>DBp>l]YeI�:LlR75mnf>bUG8D&l V Y [WG :Lmw:L=em]b :<mnmnY\gzK>D`_3[^b [nf>D�pSlnY\I :<l]75mnfSb G8D&l`AV [^f>D`l7G0Y\mnDsV�Y [WG :Lmw:Lmnm]YegzKSD&_�:Lm0[^fSD�p>l]YeI�:LlR75_>D`[nD&F`[nbzlwY\K":ZmnD`F&bzKS_v:Ll]7amnfSb G8D&l`A�U f>D`K3[^fSD_>D [^D&F [^bzlFG0Y\[nf3[^f>D�K>Dac�[�fSYegzfSD&m][�D&K>D`lngL7 G{:<m�:LKv:<=\7 �&D`_sA P r�[nf>Y\m�_>D`[nD&F [^bzlEK>D&Y\gzfJX bLlnD&_ :<KJ7

m �

Page 52: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

g13.1

g

1.2g

0.5

E =14.8 MeVg

g

g

g g

2.3

8.3

0.7 0.3

E =0.0 MeVg

E =0.0 MeVg

} Y\gz;>l]D � A k m14 Q FHf>D`I�:<[^Y\F [^b5_>D&IZbzKSm][^ln:<[^D [nf>D mnf>bUG8D&l�lnD`F&bzKSm][^l];>F`[nYebLK p>l]b F`D&m]mB;SmnD&_`G0Y [^f[^fSD�6{: } Z :Llnln: 7LA M KdDacS:LIZp>=\D�bLr X b<[^fa:�gzb�b�_dm]f>bUG D`leN 7zD&=\=\b G"P{:LK>_aXv:L_dmnf>bUG8D&lSN gzl]D&D&K P:Ll]DBm]f>bUG0KsA

_>D [^D&F [^bzl]mZ:L=\lnD*:<_S7�:Lm]mnY\gzK>D`_ [nb�:"mnfSb G8D&lTV�Y\[�G{:<mZ:Lmnm]YegzKSD&_�[^b"[nfv:<[ m]f>bUG D`l&A V [^fSD&l7G0Y\mnDsVY [.G{:<m5:Lmnm]YegzKSD&_ :Lm [^fSD�p>lnY\I�:Ll]7 _>D`[nD&F`[nbzl�Y\K : mnD&F`bzK>_v:<l]7 m]f>bUG D`l&A U f>Y\m5p>lnb�F&D`mnm.G :LmF&bLKJ[nYeKJ;>D`_�;>Kh[^Y\= :<=e=~_>D [^D&F [^bzl]m8G8D&lnD F&bzKSmnY\_>D&l]D&_sA V KSF&D':<=e=~_>D [^D&F [^bzl]m8G8D&lnD gzlnbL;>p D`_ Y\KJ[nbmnfSb G8D&l]m Vs[nf>D D&KSD&lngLYeD`mBb<r~_>D`[nD&F`[nbzlnm�X D&=\bzK>gLYeK>g'[nb5: gzY kzD`K m]f>bUG D`lQG D`lnDZ:L_>_SD&_�[^bzgLD`[^fSD&l&AU f>Y\m�mn;>I-gh:*kzD [nf>D [^bL[^:L=xD&K>D`lngL73bLr~[^f>D B l^:*7�N T�� PHA P r :<KJ7a_>D [^D&F [^bzl�X D&=\bzK>gLD&_�[^b�IZbzl]D[^f>:LK bzK>D'm]f>bUG D`l V�[^f>D�m];>IZIZD&_D&K>D`lngL7�b<r�[nf>D&m]D5mnf>bUG8D&lnmeG :LmZlnD �RD&F`[nD&_Xh7 mnD [n[nYeK>g [^fSDD&KSD&lng<7 [^b �&D`lnb>A M F&l]Y\[nD&l]YebzK YeKZ[^fSDE:<_>_ X>:LFHG p>lnb�F&D`mnm4G{:<m�[nfv:<[�[^fSD�D`K>D&l]gL7ZI�;Sm][8_>D&F`lnD*:<mnDG0f>D`K�I�b k�Y\K>g�: G{:*7drtlnbzI [nf>D�p>l]YeI�:LlR7d_>D`[nD&F`[nbzl&A } Y\g>A � A k m Y\=e=\;>m][nl^:<[nD&mw[nf>D�pSlnb�F&D&m]m&A U f>D_>D [^D&F [^bzl]m@F&bz=\bzlnD`_B7LD&=\=ebUG G8D&l]D�:L_>_>D`_B[nbzgzD`[nf>D&lTV :LK>_�mnY\gzK>Y r 7�: gzb�b _�m]f>bUG D`l&A U f>D~_>D [^D&F [^bzl]mF&bL=ebzl]D&_'gLlnD&D`K�mnY\gzK>Y r 7':BlnD �RD&F`[nD&_5mnfSb G8D&l`A M Kv:L= 7 m]Yem b<rx:L=e= [^fSDw_v:<[^:�mnfSb G8D&_'[nfv:<[ bzK>= 7 bzKSDY\K �L� m]f>bUG D`lnm�G{:<mEl]D �RD&F [^D`_sAU f>DBDTJ D&F`[�bLrx[^fSDBl]D&F`bzK>m][nln;>F [^Y\bzK3pSlnb�F&D&m]m0Yem0D`k�Y\_>D&Kh[wYeK } Y\g>A � A k�� ASU f>D�XS=e;>D�F`;>l]kLD�Y\K

} Y\g>A � A k��{mnfSb G0m@[^fSD�m]p D`F`[nln;>I l]D&m];>=\[nYeKSgErtlnbLI 9�;v6 D~mnbL;>lnF`D8_v:i[H:<V G0fSD&KBK>b0lnD&F`bzK>mR[^ln;SF`[^Y\bzKG :Lmwp D&lRrtbzlnIZD&_�A�U f>D�lnD&_3F&;>lRkzD Y\K } Y\g>A � A k�� :L=\mnb mnf>bUG0m�:�mnp D&F [^ln;SI rtl]bzI�9�;v6 D m]bz;>lnF`D

m �

Page 53: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

3.02.5 3.5 4.0 4.5 5.0 5.5Energy (MeV)

0

5

10

15Photopeak

1 EscapePeak

st

Co

un

ts (

10

/MeV

)4

} Y\gz;>l]D � A k��74 Q p D&F [^l^:wrtl]bzI 9�;v68D mnbz;>l]F&D [^b�m]f>bUG [nf>D DTJ D&F [^m�bLr lnD`F&bzK>mR[^l];>F`[nYebzK�AhU f>D X>=\;>Dmnp D&F [^l];>I)Y\m�[nf>D l]D&mn;S=\[ b<r f>Y\m][^bLgzl^:LIZIZY\K>g�D*:LFHf�Y\K>_>Y k�Ye_S;v:L= _SD`[^D`F`[nbzl D&KSD&lng<7bV%G0f>Ye=\D'[^fSDlnD`_am]p D`F`[nln;>I ;>m]D&m0[^f>D�l]D&F&bLK>m][nln;>F [^Y\bzK3l]bz;S[^Y\K>D<A

_v:<[^:SA } bzl [^f>Y\mEm]p D`F`[nln;>I V D`kzD`Kh[^mBG8D&l]D :LKv:L= 7 �&D`_";>mnY\K>g�[^f>DBlnD`F&bzK>mR[^l];>F`[nYebzK�l]bz;S[nYeK>D<A U f>Duvl]m][�D`mnF&:Lp D�p D&:LG5Yem�mnY\gzK>Y uvF&:LKh[^= 73=\bUG D`lwrtbzl [^f>D�lnD`_"mnp D&F [^ln;SI-:<mwF&bLI�p>:LlnD`_3[^b�[^f>DBX>=\;>Dmnp D&F [^l];>I5A M =em]b!V>[^fSDBpSf>bL[^bLp D&:LG'Y\m�I�;>FHf3Y\IZp>lnb kLD&_"Y\Kd[nf>D�lnD`_am]p D`F`[^l];>I5A

� �� �� �M�s����� 62�%=>��� DF�8�%= �!���

U f>D uvKv:<=vm][^D`p Y\K [^f>D�6{: } Z _v:i[H:�:LKv:L= 7�mnY\mMG :Lm�[^bBDac�[nl^:LF [ BDC l^:*7 _>D`F*:*7Zmnp D&F [^ln:�:<[~k<:Ll]Yebz;Smp>l]b��RD&F [^Y\=eD D&K>D`lngL7 =\bzm]mnD&m`A0U bD&K>m];>lnD [^f>:<[5_>D`[nD&F [^D&_ B l^:*7�m G D`lnD F&bzl]lnD&=e:<[nD&_ G0Y\[nf [^fSDp>l]b��RD&F [^Y\=eD D&K>D`lngL7 =\bzmnmTV bzKS=\7 D`kLD&Kh[^m�G0f>D&l]D [^fSD&lnDpG{:<m�X bL[^f�:a6{: } Z :LKS_ Q�� �L� D`kLD&Kh[ Y\KF&bLYeK>F`Ye_SD&K>F`D G8D&lnD5F`bzK>mnY\_>D`lnD&_�A � Y [^f T�� :LKS_pSlnb��RD`F`[^Y\=\DaD`K>D&l]gL7�=\bzmnmZF&bLlnlnD`=q:i[^D&_ V�Y [eG :LmlnD`=q:i[^Y kzD&= 75mnY\IZp>=\DB[nb Dqc [nl^:LF [�_>D&F&: 75m]p D`F`[nl^: rtbzl _>YKJ�D`lnD&Kh[ED&K>D`lngL75=\bzm]mnD&m`AU f>D B0C l^:*7"m]p D`F`[nl^:rG D`lnD�Dac�[^ln:LF`[nD&_ XJ7"I :<G�Y\K>gdF&;S[nm�bLK pSlnb��RD`F`[^Y\=\D�D`K>D&l]gL7 =\bzmnm`A U f>D

F&; [^m'G D`lnD�I�:L_>D Y\K k � cdDTl m][nD&p>m~rtlnbzI �L��� ! � caDTl N Y A DLA �L��� �z� V �z��� m � V>AeA\A!V � ��� ! � caDal�P^AM _S_>Y\[nYebLKv:L=\=\7�V�[^f>D3BDColn:*7�m]p D`F`[^l];>I F`bzlnl]D&mnp bzK>_SYeK>g [^b�_SD&F*:*7�mZ[^b"[^fSD�gzlnbz;SK>_ m][H:i[^D.G :LmIZD*:Lm];>lnD`_sA P K :L=\=[VhD&Y\gzfh[ m]p D`F`[^ln: G8D&l]DEDqc [nl^:LF [^D`_sA } bzl�[nf>D �L��� �L� cdDTl D&K>D`lngL7ZF`;S[ VJmnp D&F`Yq:<=F*:<lnD�fv:L_5[^bZX D�[^:LGLD`KsA

mbm

Page 54: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

0 10 20 30 40E Sum (MeV)

g

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

EL

(M

eV)

Gate

} Y\gz;>l]D � A k� �4SU f>DBrtln:LgzIZD&Kh[ED&K>D`lngL7d=\bzmnm�Y\mwp>=\bL[n[nD&_3:Lgh:LY\K>m][0[nf>D�m];>I�bLr�_SD`[^D`F`[nD&_ B�ln: 7�m`AU f>Y\m�mnp D&F`[nln;>I G :Lm�;>m]D&_ [^b5Dac F&=\;>_>D B�_SD&F*:*7�m�[nb'[^f>DZgzl]bz;>K>_ mR[H:<[nDLA U f>DZgh:<[nD ;>mnD`_ [nbDac F`=e;>_SD BDColn: 7 D`kLD&Kh[^m�[^fv:<[0_SD&F*:*7�[nb�[nf>D�gzlnbz;SK>_5m][H:i[^D�Yem0m]f>bUG0KsA

P Kd[nf>D�F*:Lm]D�b<r [nf>D �L��� �z� caDal D&K>D`lngL75=\bzmnm0F`;S[ V _>D`F*:*7�m�[nb�[nf>D�gzlnbz;SK>_5m][H:i[^DQG D`lnDBbLrF&bLK>F&D`lnKsA U b m][^;S_S7a[nf>D8L N ? X>;>Y\= [wbzK3Dac F&Y [^D`_�m][H:i[^D&mTV [nf>D&m]D D`kLD&Kh[^m�f>:L_a[nb X D�lnD �RD&F [^D&_�AU f>D�uvl]m][�m][nD&p3Y\KdD&=\YeIZY\Kv:<[^Y\K>gZ[^f>D`mnDBD`kLD&Kh[^mWG{:Lm [nb�m];>I ;>pd:L=\=�BDCol^:*7 D&K>D`lngzY\D&m8N T�� Q ;>I.PrtlnbLI D&:LFHf�D`kLD&Kh[B:LK>_�pS=ebL[E[^f>D`I :<gh:LY\K>m][wD&K>D`lngL7a=ebLmnm V�:Lm�m]f>bUG0K Y\K } Y\g>A � A k� SA U f>Yemwp>=eb<[:L=\=ebUG8D&_�rtbzl�_>D&F&: 7�m [^ba[^f>D'gLlnbz;>KS_�m][H:i[^D [nb�X D'D`=eY\IZYeK>:<[^D`_Xh7 gh:<[nYeK>g�bLK�[^f>D _>Yq:<gzbzKv:L=Xv:LKS_ V :Lm [^f>D�_>Ye:LgzbLKv:L= Xv:LKS_aF`bzlnl]D&mnp bzK>_Sm�[nb�[nf>D&m]D�_>D`F*:*7�m&A M =\= D`kLD&Kh[^mwYeK5[^f>Y\m0gh:<[nDdG8D&l]DDac F`=e;>_SD&_�rtlnbzI [nf>D �<��� �z� caDTl D&K>D`lngL7 =\bzmnm :LKv:L= 7�mnY\m&ASU fSDwmnp D&F [^ln:�YeK } YegSA � A k�9�mnf>bUG [^fSDlnD`mn;>= [ b<r{[^f>D :LKv:L= 7�mnY\m Y\K�[^f>D �L��� �L� caDal�D`K>D&l]gL7�=\bzm]m�lnD`gzY\bzKsAxU f>D DaJ�D`F`[ b<r Dac F&=\;>_>Y\K>gD`kLD&Kh[^m�Y\K [nf>D�gh:<[nD �R;>mR[ _SD&mnF`lnY\X D`_ bLK>=\7 :sJ D&F`[nm [^f>D'uvK>:L={mnp D&F [^l];>I%rtbzl BDC l^:*7�D`K>D&l]gzY\D&mgzl]D*:<[nD&l [nfv:LK �L� caDal A M [ [nf>D&m]D�D&K>D`lngzY\D&mTV>[^f>DwF&bzKh[^l]YeXS;S[^Y\bzK5[^b�[nf>D�uvKv:L= BDCol^:*7 mnp D&F`[nln;>IrtlnbLI [^fSD8L N ? X>;SYe= [�bzK5Dac F&Y [^D`_3m][^:<[^D`mEY\m0IZYeK>Y\I�:L= AU f>DZD`kLD&Kh[^mBYeK�[nf>D gh:<[nD mnf>bUG0K YeK } Y\g>A � A k� �:L=\=\b G8D&_ rtbzlw[nf>D BDColn: 73mnp D&F [^ln;SI F&bzl]lnD C

mnp bzK>_SYeK>g [nb _>D&F&: 7�m0[^b [nf>D�gzlnbL;>K>_5m][^:<[^D�[nb X D�Dqc [nl^:LF [^D`_sAvU f>D�D`kLD&Kh[^m�Y\K5[nf>Y\m gh:<[^D"G8D&l]Df>Y\m][nbzgzl^:<I�IZD`_sA P [wm]f>bz;>=\_3X D�I�D`Kh[^Y\bzK>D&_a[^fv:<[ T�� G :Lm�f>Y\m][^bLgzl^:LIZIZD&_ V :<K>_aKSbL[0[^f>DBmn;>IbLr T�� A

m)�

Page 55: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

1

10

102

103

104

Counts

10 15 20 25

E (MeV)g

} Y\gz;>l]D � A k�934v6 lnD&:LGJ_>bUG0K"bLr�BDCol^:*75m]p D`F`[^l];>I F&bLlnlnD`mnp bzK>_>Y\K>g�[^b �L��� �z� caDal D`K>D&l]gL75=\bzmnm`AU f>DBmnbz=\Y\_"lnD`_3F&Y\lnF`=eD`mwDqcSF`=e;S_>D�D kzD&Kh[nmwrtlnbzI [^f>DBgh:<[nD�Y\K } Yeg>A � A k� nV!G0f>Ye=\D�[nf>DBX>=e;SD�F`Yel]F&=\D&m:Ll]D D`kzD`Kh[^m�rtl]bzI [nf>Yem�gh:i[^DLA�U f>DZbzp D`K XS=q:LFHG�F`Yel]F&=\D&mBmnf>bUGO[^f>DZlnD`mn;>= [^Y\K>gamnp D&F`[nln;>I Y r8K>bgh:<[nD"G bL;>=e_afv:*kzDBX D`D&KdYeIZp>=\D&IZD`KJ[nD&_sA

10 15 20 25

E (MeV)g

1

10

102

103

104

Counts

} Y\gz;>l]D � A k � 4v?E: G :LK>_ l^:LKS_>bzI BDColn:*7"mnp D&F [^l];>I rtbzl�D&KSD&lng<7 =ebzm]mnD`m�bLr � ��� ! � caDTl�A U f>DX>=\;>D�mnp D&F [^ln;SI Yem{[nf>D�l^: G m]p D`F`[^l];>I V!G0f>Y\=eD�[^f>D�l]D&_dmnp D&F [^ln;SI Yem{[nf>D�l^:LK>_SbzI m]p D`F`[^l];>I5AU f>D�D&l]lnbzl]m YeK�[nf>D�kzD&lR[^Y\F*:L= _SYel]D&F`[nYebLK3:Ll]D�m][^:<[^Y\m][nYeF&:L=[V!G0f>Ye=\D�[^f>D�f>bLlnY �&bzKh[H:<=sD&l]lnbzl Xv:<lnm0:Ll]D[^bZm]f>bUG [^f>DQG0Y\_S[^fdbLrx[^f>D�f>Y\m][nbzgzln:LI�X>Y\K>m&A

m4

Page 56: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

Counts

104

103

102

10

1

Counts

104

103

102

10

1

Counts

104

103

102

10

110 15 20 25

E (MeV)g

10 15 20 25

E (MeV)g

10 15 20 25

E (MeV)g

(e)(d) (f)

10 15 20 25

E (MeV)g

10 15 20 25

E (MeV)g

Counts

104

103

102

10

Counts

104

103

102

10

(g) (h)

Counts

Counts

104

103

102

10

Counts

104

103

102

10

110 15 20 25

E (MeV)g

10 15 20 25

E (MeV)g

10 15 20 25

E (MeV)g

(a) (b) (c)

105

104

103

10

1

102

} Y\gz;>l]D � A k�!�4DBDColn:*7�_>D`F*:*7 m]p D`F`[^ln:SAh9 :LK>D&=>N : P@F`bzlnl]D&m]p bzKS_>m�[^b�_>D`F*:*7�m~[nb�[^f>D gzlnbz;SK>_ m][^:<[^D<A9.:<K>D&=�NtX^P@F&bLlnlnD`mnp bzK>_>m�[nb�D&K>D`lngL7 =\bzm]mnD&m~bLr �L��� �z� caDalSVXNtF P �z��� m � caDalSV N _ P�m ��� � � caDTl8VN D P � ��� � cdDTlSV�N raP ��� 9 � caDalSV�N gnP29 ��� � � caDalSV�N f P � ��� ! � caDal A

m)9

Page 57: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

1

10

100

d/d

dE

(b/s

r M

eV)

2s

Wm

8 10 12 14 16

Excitation Energy (MeV)

1

10

102

103

104

Counts

10 15 20 25

E (MeV)g

(a) (b)

} Y\gz;>l]D � A �L� 4v9.:LKSD&=-N : P8m]f>bUG0mE[^fSDBgLlnbz;>KS_amR[H:<[nD BDColn:*7�mnp D&F [^ln;SI I�D&:Lmn;SlnD&_3XJ7d?0D`r�A � �L� �rtbzl ZR\R] 9�XsA@U f>D�gzlnD`D&K F&;>lRkzD mnf>bUG0m :�F&:L=eF`;>=e:<[^Y\bzK rtbLl�[^f>DZ7�YeD`=e_ bLr _SYel]D&F`[�_>D`F*:*7�m�[^b5[^fSDgzl]bz;>K>_ m][^:<[^DsV�G0f>Y\=eD'[nf>D�X>=e:LFHG F`;>l]kLDdm]f>bUG0mZF&bzIZp bz;>K>_ _>D`F*:*7�m&A~U f>D�mnbL=eY\_ X>=e;SD�F&;>lRkzDY\m�[nf>D�m];>I bLr�[nf>D�XS=e;>D�:LK>_agzlnD`D&K3F`;>l]kLD&m`As9.:<K>D&=5N X^P mnfSb G0m�[^f>D�gzlnbL;>K>_-C m][H:i[^DBmnp D&F`[nln;>IrtlnbLI [^fSYem�G bLlnG A

U f>DEu>Kv:L=ABDCol^:*7 m]p D`F`[nln;>I rtbzl~D*:<FHf D&KSD&lng<7 =\bzm]m8F`;S[-G :Lm8bzXS[H:<YeK>D`_ Xh7ZF&l]D*:<[nYeKSg�X bL[^f :l^: G :LK>_Zl^:<K>_>bzI N Xv:LFHGJgzl]bz;>K>_ P.m]p D`F`[nln;>I5AhU f>D0l^: G mnp D&F [^ln;SI G{:Lm�I�:L_SD�Xh7 F`bzK>m]Ye_>D`lnY\K>gp>l]bzIZpS[(BDColn: 7�D`kLD&Kh[^mFNtgh:<[^D8YeK } Yeg>A � A k � X^P^A<U f>D`mnD0D`kLD&Kh[^m'G8D&l]D mnD&Kh[�[nbw[^f>D lnD&F`bzK>mR[^ln;SF`[^Y\bzKlnbL;S[^Y\K>D0_>D&m]F&l]YeX D&_'Y\KZ[^f>D0p>l]D`k�YebL;>m m]D&F`[nYebLKsA M =\=0B0C l^:*7 D`K>D&l]gzYeD`mMG8D&l]D�[nf>D&K f>Y\m][^bLgzl^:LIZIZD&_ VG0f>Y\FHf�l]D&mn;S=\[nD&_�Y\K�[^f>D~l^: G�mnp D&F`[nln;>I5A U f>D�Xv:LFHGJgzl]bz;>K>_�F&bzKh[^l]YeXS;S[^Y\bzK�[^b [^f>D�l^: G�mnp D&F`[nln;>IG :Lm0_>D`[nD&lnIZY\K>D&_aYeKd: mnY\IZYe=e:Ll*G :*7bV!G0Y [^f5[^f>D�_>YKJ D&lnD`K>F&DBX D&Y\K>geG0f>YeFHfaD`kLD&Kh[^m�G D`lnD�mnD`Kh[�[nb[^fSD�l]D&F`bzK>m][nln;>F [^Y\bzK l]bz;S[nYeK>D<A P K�[nf>D0F*:Lm]DEbLr [^fSD�X>:LFHGJgzlnbz;SK>_ Vh[^f>D0D kzD&Kh[nm{F&bzKSmnY\_>D&l]D&_ F&:LIZDrtlnbLI%[^f>Ddgh:<[nD5mnf>bUG0K Y\K } Y\g>A � A k � F<A } Y\g>A � A k � m]f>bUG0m X bL[^f [^fSDaln:UG�:LK>_ Xv:LFHGJgzlnbL;>K>_mnp D&F [^l];>I F`bzlnl]D&m]p bzKS_>YeKSg�[^b [^f>D � ��� ! � caDal D&KSD&lng<7)C =ebLmnm'l]D&gzY\bzKsA�U f>Dau>Kv:L=�mnp D&F`[nln;>IG :LmEbLXS[H:LY\K>D`_aXh7�m];>XS[^ln:LF`[nYeKSg�[nf>D�Xv:LFHGJgzlnbL;>K>_3m]p D`F`[nln;>I�rtl]bzI [nf>D�l^: G m]p D`F`[^l];>I5AU f>D~uvKv:L= BDC l^:*7�_>D`F*:*7�mnp D&F [^ln:0rtbzl@:<=e=zD`K>D&l]gL7�=\bzmnm]D&mxF&bzK>m]Ye_SD&lnD`_ :Ll]D�mnf>bUG0K�YeK } Y\g>A � A k�!SA

U f>D BDCol^:*7Zm]p D`F`[^l];>I F&bzl]lnD`mnp bzK>_>Y\K>g�[nb�_SD&F*:*7�m [nbB[nf>DEgLlnbz;>KS_ mR[H:<[nDSN } YegSA � A k?!z: P�G{:<m8K>b<[:LKv:<=\7 �&D`_ Y\K�[^f>Y\meG bLlnG A W bL[ bzK>= 7�_>b�D&m [^fSYem m]p D`F`[^l];>I F&bLKJ[^:LY\K_SD&F*:*7�m�_>Yel]D&F [^= 7 [^b�[^fSDgzl]bz;>K>_ m][^:<[^DsV X>;S[�Y [B:L=\mnb5F&bzKh[^:LYeKSmB_SD&F*:*7�m�[^fv:<[wuvlnmR[�gLb'[^f>l]bz;>gzf Dac F`Y\[nD&_�mR[H:<[nD&m�X D`rtbzl]D

m �

Page 58: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

uvKv:<=e= 7�_>D`F*:*7�YeK>g0[^b [nf>D�gzlnbL;>K>_�m][^:<[^D<A P [@Yem Dqc [nlnD`I�D`=\7�_SY ��F&;S=\[@[^b0_>Y\mnD`Kh[H:LK>gL=eD�[^fSD�_SY J D&l]D&Kh[F&bLKJ[nlnY\X>;S[nYebzKSm&A U f>DBbzK>= 7�mn;>FHf3:LKv:L= 7�mnY\mEb<r [nf>Yem [o7�p DBf>:Lm0X D`D&K3p D&lRrtbzlnIZD`_abzKd9�X� �L� � AN D&m]p>Y\[nD [^f>D r :<F`[�[nfv:<[�[nf>D gzl]bz;>K>_�mR[H:<[nD B0C l^:*7amnp D&F`[nln;>I G{:<m�K>bL[�:LK>:L=\7 �`D&_ y�;>:LKh[^Y C

[H:i[^Y kzD&= 7bV Y\[EY\mwm][nYe=\=xYeKh[^D`lnD`m][^Y\K>g�[^b F&bzIZpv:<lnD�[nf>Y\mwmnp D&F [^l];>I [nb [nf>D�bzKSD�Y\K"?0D`r�A � �L� � A 6 bL[nfmnp D&F [^ln: :Ll]D�mnf>bUG0K3Y\K } Y\g>A � A �L� A>U fSD�m]p D`F`[^l];>I�rtlnbLI [^fSYem G8bzlnG`N } Y\g>A � A �L� X^P�f>:Lm�: kLD&lR7mnY\IZYe=e:Ll�mnfv:<p Dd[^b [^f>DdX>=\;>DaF`;>l]kLD3Y\K } Y\g>A � A �L� : A�U f>Yem YeKS_>YeF&:<[^D`m [nf>DapSlnD&m]D&K>F`D"bLrwX bL[nf_>Y\lnD`F`[E:LK>_dF&bzIZp bz;>K>_d_>D`F*:*7�mE[^b [nf>D�gzlnbz;SK>_amR[H:<[nDLA

�F��� � ��� �)�~�~� � � ����+��d��$*�

� � � � @Q��)*�!1 �d=>����13 5)C M,����-��)5�<&

U f>D | m P :Llnln: 7�G :Lm ;>m]D&_ [^b3_>D`[nD&F`[ZFHf>:LlngzD`_�pv:LlR[^Y\F&=\D&m&A P K�bzln_SD&l�[nb"m][n;>_S7 [^f>D FHfv:LlngLD&_pv:LlR[^Y\F&=\D&mTVz[^f>D k<:Ll]YebL;>m�pv:LlR[^Y\F&=\D&m'G D`lnD Y\_>D&Kh[nY\uvD`_sA P KZpv:Ll][nYeF`;>=e:Ll V �3:LK>_Zp>l]bL[^bzK D kzD`KJ[nmMG8D&l]DY\mnbz=e:<[^D`_sA M m YeK [^f>D�F&:LmnD'b<r�6{: } Z V | m P fv:Lm�[RG8b�F&bLI�p bzK>D`Kh[^m bLr0=\YegLfJ[ N mnD`D Q D&F<A � A kzA � P VG0f>Y\FHf :<=e=\bUG0m~rtbLl�p>;>=\mnD0mnf>:Lp D0_>Y\mnF`lnY\IZYeKv:i[^Y\bzKsAhU f>D0p>l]bL[^bzK�:LKS_ �dpv:Ll][nYeF`=eD`m~=eD&: kLD�:�_SY J D&l CD&Kh[0ln:<[^Y\bZbLr@r :Lm][ C [^b*Comn=\bUG D&K>D`lngL7�V :LK>_5p>=\bL[n[nYeK>g [nf>D&m]DBm]YegLKv:L=\m0:Lgh:LY\K>m][0D&:LFHfdbL[^f>D`l0:L=\=ebUG8D&_rtbzl@[^f>D8mnD`pv:Ll^:i[^Y\bzK bLrv[nf>D&m]D D`kLD&Kh[^m`AhU*G bwmn;>FHf p>=\bL[nm�:Ll]D mnfSb G0K Y\K } Y\g>A � A � kzA P K } Y\g>A � A � k :<VIZbzlnD�p>:Ll][nYeF`=eD`m�G8D&l]D�_>D`[nD&F`[nD&_5[^fv:<KdY\K } Y\g>A � A � k*X�ASU f>Y\m0Yem0:Lm Dqc p D`F`[^D`_ VvmnY\K>F`D�[nf>D�_>D [^D&F C[^bLl�F&bzl]lnD&m]p bLK>_>Y\K>ga[nb } Yeg>A � A � k :�Yem�IZbzlnD rtbzlAG{:<ln_ YeK [^f>D�:Ll]l^:*7zA U fSD�m]p D`F`[nl^:am]f>bUG0K�Y\K} Y\g>A � A � k :LlnDZK>bL[Bgh:i[^D&_ bzK�gji V D`kLD&Kh[^m`A.U f>D�bzK>= 7 lnD`y�;SYel]D&IZD&Kh[ Y\K�I�:LGJY\K>ga[nf>D&m]D p>=\bL[nmG :Lm�[^f>:<[ :dFHfv:Ll]gzD&_�pv:<l][^Y\F&=\D F&:LIZD Y\K F&bLYeK>F`Ye_SD&K>F`D.G0Y\[nf�:artl^:<gzIZD&Kh[ Y\K [nf>D Q�� �z� rtb�F*:L=p>=e:LK>D<AU f>D�p>=eb<[^m�YeK } Y\g>A � A � k�:Ll]D kzD&lR7 ;>mnD rt;>=�rtbzl�Y\_>D&Kh[^Y uvF&:<[^Y\bzK�pS;>lnp bzmnD`m&AxCEbUG8D`kLD&l VxD`kLD&K

G0Y [^f3[nf>D&m]D�p>=\bL[^m�Y [wY\mw_>Y��F&;>= [w[nb gz:<[^DBbzKa[nf>D�_SY J D&l]D&Kh[�D kzD&Kh[nm&A�U fSD�Xv:LKS_>mwY\Ka[nf>D�p>=\bL[nm:Ll]D�kLD&l]7 F&=\bzm]D [^bzgLD`[^fSD&l&A M =q:Ll]gzD&lBmnD`pv:Lln:<[^Y\bzK X D`[RG8D&D`K [nf>D X>:LK>_>m�F*:LK X D :LFHf>Y\D`kzD`_ XJ7I�:LK>Y\p>;>=e:<[^Y\K>g�[^fSD'r :Lm][Zm]YegzK>:L= A.U f>D'r :Lm][Zm]YegLKv:L=dN ��� � � PdG :Lm [^ln:LK>m]rtbLlnIZD&_:LF`F&bzl]_>YeKSg [nb

m4!

Page 59: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

0 100 200 300 400 500

E (Channels)slow

0

100

200

300

400

500

p s’

d s’

t s’a’s

0 100 200 300 400 500

E (Channels)slow

0

100

200

300

400

500

p s’

a’s

(a) (b)

E(C

han

nel

s)fa

st

E(C

han

nel

s)fa

st

} Y\gz;>l]D � A � k 4 | m P r :LmR[�k�m`A m]=ebUG mnp D&F [^ln:SA U fSD�mnp D&F [^l];>I�YeKapv:LK>D`=5N : P-G{:Lm�IZD*:Lm];>lnD`_ :<[E:mnF&:<[n[nD&l]YeK>g5:<K>gz=\D bLr � V G0f>Y\=\D YeK"p>:LK>D&=*N X^P{[^f>D m]F*:<[][^D`lnY\K>g5:LK>gz=\D�G :Lmek�� � A U f>D Xv:LKS_>mF&bLlnlnD`mnp bzK>_>Y\K>gd[^b �MVs[nlnY [^bzK V _SD&;S[nD&lnbLK V@p>lnbL[nbzK D`kLD&Kh[^m :<lnD Y\K>_>Y\F*:<[nD&_sAxU f>D&m]D pS=ebL[nm G8D&l]D[^ln:LK>mRrtbzlnIZD&_ V :LK>_d;>mnD`_artbzl Y\_>D&Kh[nY\uvF&:<[^Y\bzKap>;>lnp bzm]D&m&A

?0D`r�A � m � ASU f>DB[nl^:LKSm]rtbzl]I�D`_am]YegLKv:L=MN �������� P�Yem0gzY kzD`K3Xh7

���� � � � � Z % �� Z % � g G N � A k � P

U f>D y�;>:LKh[^Y [^Y\D&m�� V � Z VE:<K>_ � g :Ll]D _>D uvK>D`_ YeK } Y\g>A � A �z� V0:LK>_ :LlnD _>D`p D`K>_>D&Kh[�bLK [^fSDX bz;>K>_v:<l]7a=eY\K>D&m�NtX>=e;SD =eY\K>D`mBY\K } Y\g>A � A �L� PHA U f>D p>=e:LF&D`I�D`Kh[�b<r�[^f>D`mnDZ=eY\K>D`m"G{:Lm�m];>FHf�[^fv:i[:L=\=s_v:<[^:�G :Lm0X D`[RG8D&D&Ka[^f>D`IdAU f>D"[^ln:LK>mRrtbzlnI�:<[nYebzK bLr�[^f>D3r :<m]['m]YegLKv:L=�:<=e=\bUG D`_ rtbLl gh:<[nD&m [nb�X DaI�:L_>D�bzK pSlnbL[nbzK

:LK>_ � pv:LlR[^Y\F&=\D&m&A U fSD p>=\bL[^m�Y\K } Y\g>A � A �L� mnf>bUG [^f>D l]D&mn;S=\[&A�U f>D m]D&pv:Lln:<[^Y\bzK X D`[RG8D&D&K [^fSDXv:LKS_>m�F&bzl]lnD&m]p bLK>_>Y\K>gd[nb�[^f>DZp>l]bL[^bzK :LKS_ � p>:Ll][nYeF`=eD`m�Y\m�I�;>FHf X D [n[^D`l�YeK [^fSYem�p>=\bL[�[^f>:LKY\K } YegSA � A � kzA jE= [^Y\I�:<[^D`=\7�V.gh:i[^D&m�G D`lnD�bzK>= 7 YeIZp>=\D&IZD&Kh[nD&_ rtbzl�p>l]bL[^bLK D`kLD&Kh[^m`A V KSF&D gji VD`kLD&Kh[^m G8D&l]D�gh:<[nD&_�bzK VJkzD`l]7 rtDTG � pv:<l][^Y\F&=\D&m-G D`lnD�_>D [^D&F [^D`_sA M =\mnb<VSbzK>= 7�m � bLr [^f>DwD`kzD`Kh[^mmnfSb G0KaYeK } Y\g>A � A � kB:LK>_ } Y\g>A � A �L� G8D&lnD�=\D`r [E:<r [nD&l0gh:<[nYeK>gZbzK gji V A

� �

Page 60: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

Efa

st

Eslow

y2

y1

y

} Y\gz;>l]D � A �z� 4 P =e=\;>mR[^l^:i[^Y\bzK b<rspv:Lln:LIZD`[nD&lnm�;>m]D&_ [nb�[^l^:<K>m]rtbzl]I �� � � � AhU fSDEpv:<l^:LIZD`[nD&l]m�7�Vz7 g V:LK>_57 Z G8D&l]D�;SmnD&_d[^b [^ln:LK>mRrtbzlnI �������� :<m�m]f>bUG0K3Y\K T yJKsA � A k � A

0 100 200 300 400 500

E (Channels)slow

0

100

200

300

400

500

p s’

a’s

0 100 200 300 400 500

E (Channels)slow

0

100

200

300

400

500

p s’

d s’

t s’

a’s

(a) (b)

E(C

han

nel

s)fa

st’

E(C

han

nel

s)fa

st’

} Y\gz;>l]D � A �L� 4>U ln:LK>mRrtbzlnIZD&_ | m P m]p D`F`[^ln:drtbzl�FHfv:<lngzD`_-Copv:<l][^Y\F&=\D Y\_>D`KJ[nY\u>F*:<[nYebzK�A U f>DZ[^ln:LK>m Crtbzl]I :i[^Y\bzKrG{:Lm0p D&lRrtbzlnIZD&_5bzK�[nf>D�p>=eb<[^m0mnf>bUG0KdYeK } Y\g>A � A � kLA M m0Y\K } Yeg>A � A � kbV �4V>p>lnb<[^bzK V[^l]Y\[nbzK V�:LK>_ _>D&; [^D&l]bzK'D kzD&Kh[nm :LlnD�Y\K>_>Y\F*:<[nD&_sA jE= [^Y\I�:<[^D`=\7�gh:<[nD&mMG D`lnDwpS=q:LF`D&m8bzK [nf>DEpSlnbL[nbzKXv:LKS_>m&A

� � �� ���� '�< 5)EDF�8�%= �<���

9�lnbL[nbzK�D kzD`KJ[nm�G8D&lnD Yem]bz=q:i[^D&_�YeK�bzln_SD&l [nb�[nl]7�[nbw_>D [^D&l]IZYeK>D8[^f>D�YeKSY\[nYq:L=JDqcSF`Y\[^:<[^Y\bzK D`K>D&l]gL7BbLr[^fSD�[^:LlngzD [.KJ;>F`=eD`;>m&A P K :�pv:Lm][ Dac p D&l]YeIZD&Kh[ VL[^f>D�F&bLlnlnD`=q:i[^Y\bzK�X D`[RG8D&D`K p>lnb��RD`F`[nYe=\D D`K>D&l]gL7B=ebzm]m:LK>_a[H:Ll]gzD`[wDac F&Y [H:<[nYebLK�D&K>D`lngL7 G{:Lmwm][^;S_>YeD`_ � � � A P [BG :Lm�f>bLp D`_"[^fv:<[�: mnY\IZYe=e:Ll�:<p>p>lnbz:LFHf

�nk

Page 61: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

0 20 40 60 80 100 120E (MeV)p

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

EL

(M

eV)

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

EL

(M

eV)

0 20 40 60 80 100 120E (MeV)p

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

EL

(M

eV)

0 20 40 60 80 100 120E (MeV)p

(a) (b)

(c)

} Y\gz;>l]D � A � m14>9~=\bL[ bLrvD`K>D&l]gL7B=ebzm]m k�m&A<p>lnb<[^bzK�D&K>D`lngL7�rtbzlx:L=\= | m P _>D`[nD&F [^bzl]m&A<9.:LK>D`=>N : P mnf>bUG0m[^fSD{lnD`mn;>= [^Y\K>g�mnp D&F [^ln;SI rtlnbzI p>l]bzIZpS[�D`kLD&Kh[^mTVbG0f>Y\=eD NtX^P@mnfSb G0m�[nf>D{l^:<K>_>bzI D`kLD&Kh[^m`A 9 :LK>D`=N F P8mnf>bUG0m0[^f>D�l^:<K>_>bzI�m];>XS[nl^:LF [^D&_dmnp D&F [^l];>I5A

F&bL;>=e_dX DB;SmnD&_af>D&l]D�VvXh75IZD*:Lm];>lnY\K>g�p>lnb<[^bzKdmnp D&F [^l^: AU f>D�rtl^:LgLI�D`Kh[�D&K>D`lngL7 =ebzm]m.G{:<m�F&bzl]lnD&=e:<[nD&_;G0Y\[nf [^f>D"_SD`[^D`F`[nD&_ p>lnbL[nbzK>m`A Q Y\K>F&D�[^fSD

D&KSD&lng<7 =\bzm]m�:LK>_ p>lnbL[nbzK D`K>D&l]gL7G D`lnD"GJK>bUG0K V8Y\[pG{:<m p bzmnm]YeX>=\D3[nb�F&bLK>m][nln;>F [5: p>=\bL[ bLrrtl^:<gzIZD&Kh[~D&K>D`lngL7�=ebLmnmFN T~� Px:Lgh:<YeK>mR[~p>lnb<[^bzK D`K>D&l]gL7 N � P^AzU f>Y\m�p>=eb<[~Yem�m]f>bUG0K Y\K } Y\g>A � A � m!V:LK>_":L=e=\bUG D`_�rtbzlE[nf>D p>l]bL[^bzK3D&K>D`lngL7amnp D&F [^ln;SI-[^b X D�Dac�[^ln:LF`[nD&_ :Lm�:�rt;>K>F`[nYebLK�bLr~D&K>D`lngL7=\bzmnm`A

� �

Page 62: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

0 20 40 60 80 100 120EL (MeV)

0

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

Counts

} Y\gz;>l]D � A � �74>U f>D'rtln:LgzIZD&Kh[ZD&KSD&lng<7�=ebLmnmZYeK F`bzYeKSF&Y\_>D&K>F`DrG0Y\[nf p>l]bL[^bLK�D`kzD`Kh[^m�YemZmnfSb G0K�AU f>Y\m0mnp D&F`[nln;>I Yem{[nf>D�p>lnb��RD&F`[nYebLKabzKh[nb [^f>D�D&KSD&lng<7)C =ebLmnm�: c Yem{rtl]bzI } Yeg>A � A � mzFLA U f>D�X>lnbz:L_p D*:LG�:i[ � � caDTlOYem0Y\K>_>Y\F*:<[nY\kLD�b<r.p>Y\FHGJ;>p-C _>D&F&: 7alnD&:LF`[nYebLK>m&A

9�lnbL[nbzK>m'_>;SD"[^b GJK>b�FHGLbz; [d:LK>_ p>Y\FHGJ;>p-Co_SD&F*:*7 l]D*:LF [^Y\bzK>m.G8D&l]D"bLrBF&bzKSF&D&l]KsA{9�Y\FHGJ;>p-C_>D`F*:*7'l]D*:LF [^Y\bzK>m{b�F&F`;>l-G0f>D`K'[^f>D gji V pSlnb��RD`F`[^Y\=\D�p>Y\FHG�m ;Sp5:�p>l]bL[^bzK rtlnbzI [^fSDw[H:Ll]gzD`[ VS:<K>_mn;SX>mnD`y�;SD&Kh[^= 75_>D&F&:*7 m Xh7 [^f>DED&IZYem]mnY\bzKdbLrx:�p>l]bL[^bzK�A�I�K>b�FHGLbz; [ lnD&:LF`[nYebzKSm{b F`F&;>l-G0f>D&K�[^fSDp>l]b��RD&F [^Y\=eDBGJK>b FHGJmE: p>lnbL[nbzKdbz;S[0bLrx[^f>D�[^:LlngzD [*AU f>D�p>lnD`mnD&KSF&D�bLr�GJK>b�FHGLbL;S[{:<K>_Zp>YeFHGJ;>p8Co_>D`F*:*7�lnD*:<F`[^Y\bzK>m4G :Lm~YeKhkzD`m][nYegh:i[^D&_ Xh7Zp>lnb��RD`F`[ C

Y\K>g } Y\g>A � A � mLF'bzK [^b"[nf>D T~� : c Yem`A�U f>Y\m Yem m]f>bUG0KY\K } Y\g>A � A � � V.:LKS_�gzY\kLD&m [^fSD'D&K>D`lngL7=\bzmnm�_>Y\m][^l]YeXS;S[^Y\bzK":<mnmnb�F&Ye:<[nD&_ G0Y [^f5[^f>DB_>D [^D&F [^D`_"p>lnb<[^bzK>m`A U f>D&l]D�Y\mEF`=eD&:Lln= 7d:ZX>lnbh:<_ap D*:LGY\Kd[nf>Yem�mnp D&F [^l];>I :<[ � � caDTl8VXG0fSYeFHf"Y\K>_>Y\F*:i[^D&m�[^f>D�p>l]D&m]D&K>F`D�bLr.p>YeFHGJ;>p8Co_>D`F*:*73l]D*:LF [^Y\bzK>m`AU f>D`lnDwY\m8:L=em]b�D k Y\_>D`K>F&DwrtbLl�GJK>b�FHGLbL;S[{l]D*:LF [^Y\bzK>m�YeK } YegSA � A � mzFLAJU f>D�D&K>D`lngL7�bLr [^f>D�D&IZY [n[nD&_p>l]bL[^bzKSm�ln:LK>gzD`m�rtl]bzI :�F&bL;>p>=\DEbLrscaDal :L=\=>[^fSD�G :*7�;>p�[nbB[nf>D0p>lnb��RD&F`[nYe=\D�D&K>D`lngL7Z=\bzmnm`AJU f>Dp>l]D&mnD`K>F&D b<r~G�KSb FHG<bz;S[B:LK>_3p>YeFHGJ;>p8Co_>D`F*:*7�D`kLD&Kh[^m�Y\K3[^fSD | m P :Ll]l^:*7dmnf>bz;S=e_ X D�=\YeIZY [^D&_"[nbrtbzlAG{:Ll]_ m]F*:<[][^D`lnY\K>g :LKSgz=eD`m&AJUxb�D`=eY\IZYeKv:i[^D0[^f>D`mnD�D`kzD`Kh[^m8rtl]bzI [nf>D�:LKv:L= 7�mnY\m V�bzK>= 7 Xv:LFHG G :Lln__>D [^D&F [^bzl]mEF`bz;>=\_aX D�F&bzKSmnY\_>D&l]D&_sA9�=ebL[][^Y\K>g�[nf>Ddrtln:LgzIZD&Kh[ D&K>D`lngL7=\bzmnm :Lgh:LY\K>m][ [^f>Ddp>l]bL[^bzK D&K>D`lngL7rtbzlZY\K>_>Y k Y\_>;v:<=w_>D C

[^D`F`[nbzlnm gzY kzD`m�:LK�YeKS_>YeF&:<[^Y\bzK bLr�G0f>D [^f>D`l�bLl K>bL[ZGJK>b�FHGLbz; [�:LK>_ p>Y\FHG�;Sp-Co_>D`F*:*7 lnD&:LF`[nYebLK>mF*:<K�X D D`=eY\IZYeKv:i[^D&_�XJ7 F`bzK>m]Ye_>D`lnY\K>g"bzKS=\7 Xv:LFHG G :Lln_�_>D`[nD&F`[nbzlnm`A U fSD mnp D&F [^l];>I mnf>bUG0K Y\K

� �

Page 63: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

EL

(M

eV)

0 20 40 60 80 100 120E (MeV)p

(a)

0 20 40 60 80 100 120E (MeV)p

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

EL

(M

eV)

(b)

} Y\gz;>l]D � A � 74v9�=ebL[8bLr�D&K>D`lngL7Z=\bzmnm~k�m&A�p>lnb<[^bzK�D&K>D`lngL7LA�9.:LK>D`=HN : P mnf>bUG0m�[^f>D0mnp D&F [^l];>I rtlnbzI[^fSDEXv:<FHG G :Ll]_�I�bLm][8_>D`[nD&F`[nbzl V G0f>Y\=eDSN X^P.mnfSb G0m8[^f>D�m^:LIZD�rtbzl�[^f>D�rtbzl7G :Lln_ IZbzm][8_>D`[nD&F [^bzl`A

} Y\g>A � A � z:YG :Lm�IZD*:<mn;>l]D&_ :i[B:'mnF*:i[n[^D`lnY\K>ga:LK>gz=\D bLrFk � � V G0f>Y\=eDZY\K } Y\g>A � A � LX�[^f>D m]F*:<[ C[^D`lnY\K>ga:LK>gz=\DSG{:<m �z� A U f>DZmnp D&F [^ln;SI I�D&:Lmn;SlnD&_�:<[�Xv:LFHG G :Lln_�:LK>gz=\D&mBY\mBI�;>FHf�_SY J D&l]D&Kh[[^f>:LK[nf>D5bzK>Dd:<[ZrtbzlAG{:Ll]_ :<K>gz=\D&m V�:Lm [nf>D5f>YegLf-CoD`K>D&l]gL7 p>lnb<[^bzK>m�:Ll]Dd:L=eIZbzmR[�F&bzIZp>=\D`[nD&= 7:LX>m]D&Kh[�rtlnbzI [^f>DBmnp D&F [^ln;SI�rtlnbzI [^f>D�Xv:LFHG G :Lln_3_>D`[nD&F`[nbzl&A P [E:LpSp D&:Llnm [^f>:<[�p>lnbL[nbzK>m0bzl]Yeg CY\Kv:<[^Y\K>g'rtl]bzI�G�KSb FHG<bz;S[B:LK>_�pSYeFHGJ;>p-C _>D&F&:*7�lnD&:LF`[nYebzKSm�F*:LK�X D D`=eY\IZYeKv:i[^D&_ Xh7"F`bzK>m]Ye_>D`lnY\K>gbzK>= 7�Xv:<FHG G :Ll]_3_>D [^D&F [^bzl]m&AU f>D uvK>:L=8pSlnbL[nbzK�m]p D`F`[^ln:"mnf>bUG0K�Y\K } Y\g>A � A � 9 G8D&l]D'Dac�[^ln:LF`[nD&_�Xh7 bzK>= 7�F`bzK>m]Ye_>D`lnY\K>g

_>D [^D&F [^bzl]m F&b kzD`lnY\K>gZmnF&:<[n[nD&lnY\K>g�:LK>gL=eD`m{X D [RG D`D&K�k �L� :<K>_ k � � ASU f>D�pSlnbL[nbzK'mnp D&F [^ln:eG8D&l]DDac�[nl^:LF [^D&_ :<m :art;>KSF`[^Y\bzK b<r0Dac F&Y [H:<[nYebLK�D&K>D`lngL7LA�jEK rtbzl][n;>Kv:<[nD&= 7bV@[^f>D m][H:i[^Y\m][^Y\F&mZ:<lnD p b�bzl&AM m{:�lnD`mn;>= [0bLr [^fSD�p b�bzl8m][H:i[^Y\m][^Y\F&mTVS[^fSYem{_>:<[H:�F`bz;>=\_�K>bL[ X D�;>m]D&_'[nb _>D`[nD&l]I�Y\K>D�[^fSD�YeKSY\[nYq:L=Dac F`Y\[^:<[^Y\bzK3D`K>D&l]gL7�bLrx[^fSD�[^:LlngLD`[0KJ;>F&=\D&;Sm&AM = [^f>bL;>gzf3[nf>D | m P _v:<[H:�G{:<m�K>bL[�kzD`l]7a;>mnD rt;>= Y\K3[nf>YemEDac p D&lnY\IZD&Kh[ V Y\[w_>b�D&mwm]f>bUG [^fv:i[

_>D [^D&F [^Y\bzK bLr~FHfv:Ll]gzD&_ pv:<l][^Y\F&=\D&m�Y\K"[^fSD _>D&F&:*7"bLr�[nf>D Dac F`Y\[nD&_ K�;SF&=\D&;>m�Y\K�L N ? m][n;>_>Y\D&m�Y\mrtD*:<mnY\X>=eD<A P r�:�mnY\IZYe=e:Ll�:Lp>p>l]bh:LFHf Yem [^b X D5;>mnD`_ Y\Krt;S[n;>lnD5DqcSp D&l]YeIZD`KJ[nm V~[^f>DdmnbL=eY\_ :<K>gz=\DF&b kLD&l^:<gzD�b<rx[nf>D | m P :Llnln: 7 mnf>bL;>=e_aX D�Y\K>F`lnD*:<mnD&_�A U fSYem0Y\m�D&:LmnY\= 75:LF&F`bzIZp>=\Yem]f>D&_"Xh75:<_>_>Y\K>gIZbzlnDw_>D`[nD&F`[nbzlnm{[nb [^f>D�:Llnln: 7LA M _>_>Y [^Y\bzKv:L=\=\7�VS[^fSD�:Llnln:*7 m]f>bz;>=\_5p>lnY\I�:LlnY\=\7 F&b kzD`l Xv:LFHG G :Lln_

�sm

Page 64: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

0

10

20

30

40

0

10

20

30

0

10

20

30

0 30 60 90 0 30 60 90 120

E (MeV)p

Counts

(a) (b)

(c) (d)

(e) (f)

} Y\gz;>l]D � A � 974>9~l]bL[^bLK D`K>D&l]gL7�mnp D&F`[nl^:SA�U f>DEpv:LK>D`=em�F&bzl]lnD`mnp bzK>_ [nbB[nf>DErtbz=\=\b G0Y\K>g�p>lnb��RD`F`[nYe=\DD&KSD&lng<7 =ebzm]mnD`m�4-N : P �z��� m � caDalSV-N X^PFm ��� � � caDTl8VMN F P � ��� � caDalSV-N _^P ��� 9 � caDalSV-N D P9 ��� � � caDTl8V :LK>_hNtrqP � ��� ! � cdDTl A

� �

Page 65: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

:LK>gL=eD`m&A M m IZD`KJ[nYebLK>D&_aD*:Ll]=eY\D&lTVS[^f>D�p>l]D&m]D&K>F`D�bLrxGJK>b�FHGLbz; [�:LKS_dpSYeFHGJ;>p-C _>D&F&:*7al]D*:LF [^Y\bzK>m Y\mkzD`l]75m]I :<=e=@:<[�Xv:<FHG G :Ll]_3mnF&:<[n[nD&l]YeK>g :LK>gL=eD`m&A

��

Page 66: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

� � ��� ��� �

� � � � ��� � ����� � � � � � � ��� � �

� � � � � �

Uxb Y\Kh[^D&l]p>lnD [ [nf>D5lnD&m];>= [^m b<rw[^fSDd_>:<[H: :LKv:L= 7�mnY\m p>l]D&m]D&Kh[^D`_ YeK[^f>D5=e:Lm][ FHfv:Lp [^D&lTV~mnD`kLD&ln:L=[^b�bz=\m*G D`lnDBK>D&D`_>D&_�A P [�G :Lm�K>D&F`D&mnmn:Ll]75[nb�p D&lRrtbzlnI m][^:<[^Y\m][nYeF&:L=@I�b�_>D`= F*:L=\F&;>=e:<[nYebzKSm&A P K5[^f>Y\mDac p D&l]YeIZD&Kh[BX>l]D&IZmnmR[^l^:<f>=e;SK>g3ln:L_>Ye:<[^Y\bzK G :Lm�:L=\mnb5:�F&bzKSF&D&l]K V :LKS_ f>:L_"[^b�X D _>D*:<=\["G0Y [^f�AU f>D�lnD`mnp bzK>m]D�bLrx[^fSD�6 : } Z _>D`[nD&F [^bzl�:Ll]l^:*7�m�G :LmE:L=\mnbZK>D&D`_>D&_aYeKdbzl]_>D&l{[nb�F`bzIZpv:Ll]D�[nf>D&b*ClnD [^Y\F*:L=xF*:<=eF`;>=q:i[^Y\bzK>mFG0Y [^fa_v:<[^:SA } YeK>:L=e= 7bVv[nf>D�KJ;>F`=eD&:LlE[nD&IZp D`l^:<[n;>lnD�fv:L_d[^b X DBF*:L=\F&;>=e:<[nD&_Y\Kabzl]_>D&l [nb�F`bzIZpv:Ll]DB[nf>Yem0_v:i[H:SG0Y\[nf3p>l]D`k�Y\bz;>m�I�D&:Lmn;SlnD&IZD`KJ[nm&A P Kabzl]_>D&l [nb�F&:L=\F&;>=e:<[^D�[^fSD[^D`IZp D`l^:<[n;>lnDsV�Y [4G{:<m�KSD&F&D`mnmn:Ll]7Z[^bB_>D [^D&l]IZYeK>D0[^fSD�IZD&:LK DqcSF`Y\[^:<[^Y\bzK D&K>D`lngL7 b<r�[^fSD�KJ;>F`=eD`;>m:L=\bzK>g [^fSD8L N ? _SD&F*:*7LA

�?��� 4'���B��$*� ��$&/E��+ � �52"�+�� ��+*/���+*�B��$&�����

U f>D�rt;>K>_>:LIZD&Kh[H:L=�:Lmnm];>IZpS[^Y\bzK b<rB[nf>D�m][^:<[^Y\m][nYeF&:L=�IZb _SD&=wrtbzl [^f>D�_>D`F*:*7 bLr�:LK DqcSF`Y\[nD&_KJ;>F&=\D&;Sm�Yem [nfv:<[ :L=\=El]D&=\D`k<:LKh[�KJ;>F&=\D*:<l'_>D&gLlnD&D`m�bLr�rtl]D&D&_SbzI :<lnD3D`yJ;>Ye=\Y\X>l^:<[nD&_ X D`rtbzl]D3[^fSD_>D`F*:*7 F&:LK [H:LG<D'p>=e:LF&D � � � A.U fSD'F&bzIZp>; [^D&l F`b _SD ;>m]D&_�[^b"p D&lRrtbzlnI [^fSD F*:<=eF`;>=q:i[^Y\bzK>mSG :Lm| M�QS| M�N�T � mbm!V m)� � A P K�[^f>Y\m�F&b�_>DsV<[^fSD{;>mnD`l�mnp D&F`Y\u>D&m�[^f>D YeK>Y [^Ye:L=�p bLp>;>=e:<[^Y\bzK bLr>[nf>D{DqcSF`Y\[nD&_KJ;>F&=\D&;SmwY\Ka[^D`lnIZm�bLr�D`K>D&l]gL7a:LK>_a:LK>gz;>=e:Ll0IZbzIZD&Kh[^;SIdA 6{:Lm]D&_abzKa[nf>D�YeK>Y [^Ye:L=@p bzp>;>=e:<[^Y\bzK V

� 9

Page 67: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

[^fSD F&b�_>D�F*:L=\F&;S=q:<[nD&m.:�uvKv:<= _>D`F*:*7Bmnp D&F [^ln;SI rtbzlx:L=\p>fv:nV<p>l]bL[^bLK V K>D&; [^lnbLK VL:<K>_ BDColn:*7�_SD&F*:*7LAU f>D`mnD'm]p D`F`[^ln:":Ll]D bz;S[np>;S[�:LF&F`bzln_SYeK>ga[^ba[nf>D':<I�bL;>Kh[�bLr [^f>D�[^bL[^:L=~YeK>Y [^Ye:L=~F&l]bzmnm�mnD&F [^Y\bzK[^f>:<[QG D`Kh[�Y\Kh[^b5D*:<FHf _SD&F*:*7LA P [BG{:Lm�[nf>D BDCol^:*73_>D&F&: 7"mnp D&F`[nln;>I-rtlnbzI [^f>D`mnDZF*:L=\F&;S=q:<[nYebLK>m[^f>:<[FG :Lm�D`kLD&Kh[^;v:<=e= 73F`bzIZpv:Ll]D&_ G0Y [^fa_v:<[H: A U fSD�l]D&=e:<[^Y kzD�p>lnbzX>:LX>Y\=eY [o7dbLr~:ZgzY\kLD&K"KJ;>F`=eD`;>m_>D`F*:*7�YeK>g Xh7d:L=epSfv:<V>p>l]bL[^bLK VvK>D&; [^lnbLK Vvbzl gh:LIZI�: D&IZY\mnmnY\bzK"Y\m0_>D&p D&KS_>D&Kh[EbzKd[nf>D�lnD`=q:<[nY\kLD_>D`F*:*75l^:<[nD&m�:Lm0F*:<=eF`;>=q:i[^D&_dY\Kd[nf>D�F&b�_>DLA

��� � )Q1R�!13�49 � -�Q Q93����13 5)C M,��$ "=%93�� "&

P K�pv:LmR[ Y\K>D&=e:LmR[^Y\F Com]F*:<[][^D`lnY\K>g Dac p D`lnY\IZD&Kh[^mTV~[nf>D D`K>D&l]gL7 =\bzm]m bLr0mnF&:<[n[nD&l]D&_ rtl^:<gzIZD&Kh[^m fv:<mX D&D&K ;>mnD`_ [nba_>D [^D`lnIZYeKSD�[nf>D Y\K>Y [^Ye:L=�Dac F`Y\[^:<[^Y\bzK�D`K>D&l]gL7 bLr�[^f>D�KJ;>F&=\D&;Sm&A P K [nf>D&m]D DqcSp D&l CY\I�D`Kh[^m V [nf>D�YeKSY\[nYq:L=�Dqc F&Y [H:<[nYebzK D&KSD&lng<7+G{:<mdD`yJ;v:<[^D`_ _>Y\lnD`F`[n=\7 [nb�[^f>D"rtln:LgzIZD&Kh[dD&K>D`lngL7=\bzmnm � � �nV � 9 � A U f>Yem0p>l]b F`D&_>;SlnD�fv:Lm0mnY\K>F`DBX D&D`Kam]f>bUG0Kd[nbZX D�Y\Kv:LF`F&;>ln:<[^D � � <V � 9 � A M m]YegLK>Y\u-CF*:<KJ[�ln:LK>gzD�bLr.D&K>D`lngzY\D&mE:LlnD�p bzp>;>=e:<[nD&_ G D`=e=@X D&=\b G [^fv:<[�bLrx[^fSD�D`K>D&l]gL7�=\bzmnm]D&mwF`bzK>m]Ye_>D`lnD`_ V:Lm�D k Y\_>D`KJ[8Xh7�[nf>D{rtbzl7G :Ll]_ | m P _>D [^D`F`[^bLlnmFN m]D&D } Y\g>A � A � mzF PHAzU fSYem~X D&F&bLI�D`m~I�bLlnD0:LK>_ZIZbzl]Dp>l]bzX>=\D&I�:<[^Y\F�:Lm f>Y\gzf>D&l�:LKS_af>Y\gzf>D`l0D&K>D`lngL75=\bzmnm]D&mE:LlnD�F`bzK>m]Ye_>D`lnD`_sAM KDac p D&lnY\IZD&Kh[pG{:Lm�p D&l]rtbLlnIZD&_ [^b Y\KJkLD&mR[^Y\gh:<[^D5[^fSDdF`bzlnl]D&=e:<[^Y\bzK bLrED&K>D`lngL7 =\bzm]m :<K>_

Dac F`Y\[^:<[^Y\bzK D&K>D`lngL7LA U f>Y\mBmR[^;>_ 7 G :Lm�p D`l]rtbzl]I�D`_ G0Y\[nf [nf>D ;>m]D bLr � pv:LlR[^Y\F&=\D&mB:Lm�[^fSD p>lnb C�RD&F [^Y\=eDsVs:LKS_ ZR\�� 6 Y :LmE[nf>D�[^:LlngLD`[ � � nV � 9 � A M =\[nf>bz;>gzfa[^f>D�p>lnb��RD`F`[nYe=\D :LK>_a[H:Ll]gzD`[E;>mnD`_�f>D&l]D_>YKJ�D`l Vv[^fSDBl]D&m];>=\[nmwbLr [^f>D�mR[^;>_S7dF&:LKaX DB;>mnD`_a[^b :LY\_aY\Ka[nf>D�_>D`[nD&l]I�Y\Kv:<[nYebLK"bLrx[^f>DBD&K>D`lngL7_>Y\m][nlnY\X>;S[^Y\bzK lnD`mn;>= [^Y\K>g�rtlnbLI%:"gzY kzD`K D&K>D`lngL7�=ebzm]m&A�U :LX>=\D.m>A k�mnfSb G0mZf>bUG [^fSD�p>lnb��RD`F`[nYe=\DD&KSD&lng<7"=\bzmnm�:LKS_ : kLD&ln:LgzD Dac F`Y\[^:<[^Y\bzK D&K>D`lngL7 N T � P0F`bzIZpv:LlnD<A M m�[nf>D�[^:LX>=\D YeK>_SYeF&:<[^D`m Vs[^fSD:*kzD`l^:LgzDwDac F&Y [H:<[nYebLK�D&K>D`lngL7 Yem8=eD`mnm{[^f>:LK [^f>:<[{bLr [nf>D�D`K>D&l]gL7 =\bzm]m rtbzl D`K>D&l]gL7 =ebzm]mnD`m gzlnD&:<[^D`l[^f>:LK���acaDal AxU f>D�_>Yem]F&l]D&pv:LKSF`7 X D [RG D`D&K D`K>D&l]gL7 =ebzm]m�:<K>_�DqcSF`Y\[^:<[^Y\bzK D&K>D`lngL7 X D&F`bzIZD&m=e:LlngzD`l0:LK>_d=q:<lngzD`l0:Lm [^f>D�D&KSD&lng<75=ebzm]m0YeK>F`lnD&:LmnD`m&AP K':L_S_>Y\[nYebLK�[nbB[nf>DWG8bzl]G bLr ?0D`r�A � � �jVz[^f>D`lnD�Yem8:LK>b<[^f>D`lMG :*7 [^bBgzD`[�mnbLI�D�Y\K>_>Y\F*:<[nYebzK bLr

[^fSD F&bzl]lnD`=q:<[nYebLK�X D [RG D`D&K YeKSY\[nYq:L= Dac F&Y [H:i[^Y\bzK D&K>D`lngL73:LK>_�D`K>D&l]gL7"=\bzmnm`A } Y\g>A m>A k mnf>bUG0m�[^fSDD&KSD&lng<7 =ebLmnm~mnp D&F [^ln;SI YeKZF&bLYeK>F`Ye_SD&K>F`DFG0Y [^f B'l^:*7�m'G0Y\[nfZD&K>D`lngL7Zgzl]D*:<[nD&l�[nfv:LK�m�caDTl�AhU f>D

� �

Page 68: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

T~� N caDTl P T � N caDal�Pm)� m4�� � ��� 4� �9 � �� � 9 m!4� 9 !k � � � m

U :LX>=\DpmSA k 4 Q ;>IZI�:Ll]7�b<r8[nf>D p>lnb��RD&F`[nYe=\DZD&K>D`lngL7"=ebzm]mB:LK>_�[H:Ll]gzD`[�Dqc F&Y [H:<[nYebzK D&KSD&lng<7zA U f>Y\mY\KSrtbzlnI�:<[nYebLKdY\m [H:LG<D&KdrtlnbzI ?�D r�A � � �OV<G0fSD&lnD�[^fSDBl]D*:LF [^Y\bzK ZR\�� 6 Y N �MV � � P4G{:Lm�Y\KJkLD&mR[^Y\gh:<[^D`_sA

m][nln;>F [^;>l]D&m�Y\Ka[nf>Y\mwp>=\bL[EF&bzl]lnD&m]p bLK>_3[^b�[^f>DBmn;SX>mnD`y�;SD&Kh[Bbzp D`K>Y\K>g bLr�K>D&;S[nlnbzKaD`k<:Lp bzl^:i[^Y\bzKFHfv:LKSK>D&=\m Vx:LK>_ Y\K>_>Y\F*:<[nDZ:�F&bzl]lnD&=e:<[nYebzK X D`[RG8D&D`K D`K>D&l]gL7�=\bzmnmB:LK>_ DqcSF`Y\[^:<[^Y\bzK D&KSD&lng<7 � � m � AU f>D�m][nln;>F [^;>l]D&m.F&:LKBF&=\D*:Ll]=\7�X D8Y\_>D`KJ[nY\u>D&_ ;>p�[^b � �0caDal F`bzlnl]D&mnp bzK>_SYeK>g�[^b0[^f>D4mzKBFHfv:LKSK>D&= AU fJ;>m Vz[nf>D{D`K>D&l]gL7 =\bzmnm.F*:LK X D{D&yJ;v:i[^D&_�_>Y\lnD`F`[^= 78G0Y [^f [nf>D Dac F`Y\[^:<[^Y\bzK D&KSD&lng<7 ;>p [nb�:<[�=\D*:LmR[� �ZcaDal A } bzl{D&KSD&lngLYeD`mEf>Y\gzf>D`l [^fv:LK5[^fSYemTV>[^f>DQG8bzlnG�bLr�l�Y\D&mR[^Y � � � � � � � f>:L_d[nbZX D�;>m]D&_sAM _>Y\m][nlnY\X>;S[^Y\bzK bLrBDac F`Y\[^:<[^Y\bzK D&KSD&lng<7�G :Lm�_>D`[nD&l]I�Y\K>D`_ rtbzl : gzY kzD&K D`K>D&l]gL7 =\bzm]m�XJ7

l�Y\D&mR[^Y � � � � � � � A U f>DB_>Y\m][^l]YeXS;S[^Y\bzK>mElnD&=\D`k<:LKh[E[^bZ[^f>Y\mFG8bzlnG5:<lnDBmnf>bUG0K"Y\K } Y\g>A�m>A � :L=ebLK>g

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90

Energy Loss (MeV)

0

1

2

3

4

5

Counts

(10

/MeV

)4

1n

2n

3n

4n

} Y\gz;>l]D5m>A k 4 Q p D&F [^l];>IOb<r YeK>D`=q:<m][^Y\F*:<=e= 7�m]F*:<[][^D`lnD&_ gji V pv:<l][^Y\F&=\D&m.YeK F`bzY\K>F&Y\_>D&KSF&D G0Y\[nf BZl^:*7�mG0Y [^f T�� � m�caDTl�A>U f>D�m];>F&F`D&mnm]Y\kLD�bzp D&KSYeK>g b<r KSD&;S[nlnbzK�D kL:<p bzln:<[^Y\bzK�FHfv:<K>K>D&=\m Vv;Sp'[^bemzK VY\m�Y\K>_>Y\F*:i[^D&_�A

��!

Page 69: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

1

2

3

4

Rel

ativ

e P

robab

ilit

y

EL=65 MeV EL=85 MeV

0 20 40 60 80 100 0 20 40 60 80 100

Excitation Energy (MeV)

0120

} Y\gz;>l]DFm>A � 4v9�=\bL[^m8:L_v:<pS[^D`_ rtlnbLI ?�D r�A � � � AhU f>DE_>YemR[^l]YeX>; [^Y\bzK'bLr�Dac F&Y [H:<[nYebLK'D&K>D`lngL7Zl]D&m];>=\[ CY\K>g rtlnbzI :ZgLY\kLD&KdD&K>D`lngL7�=\bzm]m�Y\m0mnf>bUG0KsA U f>D�F`bzlnl]D&mnp bzK>_SYeK>g�D&KSD&lng<7�=ebLmnmnD`mw:<lnD�Y\K>_>Y\F*:<[nD&_Xh7a[nf>D :<lnlnbUG0mEYeK3[nf>D�pS=ebL[nm&A U f>D p bzY\KJ[nm�:Ll]D�_v:i[H:�rtl]bzI�?0D`r�A � � �OV�G0f>Y\=eD�[^f>D�mnbz=\Ye_3F&;>lRkzD[^fSlnbz;>gLfd[nf>D�p bzY\Kh[^m0Y\mE: u>[&A

G0Y [^f [nf>D�F&bzl]lnD&m]p bLK>_>Y\K>g D&KSD&lng<7 =\bzm]m&A M =\= _>YemR[^l]YeX>; [^Y\bzK>m8rtl]bzI ?0D`r�A � � � fv:*kzDw:�=\bUG D&K>D`lngL7[H:<Ye= AvU f>Y\m0[^:LY\= Yem0p>l]D&_>bzIZY\Kv:LKh[^= 75_>;>D�[nb GJK>b�FHGLbz; [�:LKS_dpSYeFHGJ;>p-C _>D&F&:*73l]D*:LF [^Y\bzK>m&AU f>D�F&bzKh[nlnY\X>;S[^Y\bzKdbLr G�KSb FHG<bz;S[w:LK>_5p>Y\FHG�;Sp-Co_>D`F*:*7dlnD&:LF`[nYebzKSm�Y\m Dac p D&F [^D&_d[^bZX D�I�;>FHf

=\b G8D&lEYeKaf>D*:*kJ74CoY\bzK"m]F*:<[][^D&l]YeKSg [^f>:LK3Y\K ��mnF&:<[n[nD&lnY\K>g � � m � A M =\mnb<V [nf>DBF&bzKh[^l]YeXS;S[^Y\bzK3[nb [^fSDF*:<=eF`;>=q:i[^D&_ BDColn: 7wmnp D&F [^l^:<=zmnfv:<p D`m@rtl]bzI [nf>D�=\b G C D&K>D`lngL7w[H:LY\=LY\m@K>D&gz=\Y\gzYeXS=eD�rtbzl�BDC l^:*7wD`K>D&l]gzY\D&m:LX b kzD � caDal A M m8:Bl]D&mn;S=\[ V�[nf>DE=\bUG CoD`K>D&l]gL7Z[H:LY\=�G{:Lm�K>bL[8Y\K>F&=\;>_>D`_'YeK�[^f>D�_>Y\m][nlnY\X>;S[^Y\bzK>m8bLrDac F`Y\[^:<[^Y\bzK�D&K>D`lngL7Z;>m]D&_�YeKZ[^fSYem'G8bzlnG AhU f>D0_>Y\m][nlnY\X>;S[^Y\bzK>m�;>m]D&_':<lnD mnfSb G0K YeK } Y\g>AbmSA � ALU f>DF&bLlnlnD`mnp bzK>_>Y\K>g�D`K>D&l]gL73=\bzm]mnD&m�F`bzK>m]Ye_>D`lnD`_ :<lnD :L=\mnb mnf>bUG0K�Y\K"[^f>Y\mwuvgz;SlnD�rtbLlwF&bLI�p>:LlnY\mnbzK�AU f>D0D&KSD&lng<7 =\bzmnm~_>Y\m][nlnY\X>;S[^Y\bzK>m~m]f>bUG0K Y\K } YegSA�m>A � G D`lnD0_>D [^D&l]IZYeK>D`_ rtl]bzI [nf>D Q�� �L� m]YeKSgz=eD`m_v:<[^:;N m]D&D } Y\g>A-m>A m PHA�U f>D�p D&:LG :<[�:LpSp>lnb c YeI�:<[nD&= 7 � � cdDTl Y\K } YegSA-m>A m Y\K>_>Y\F*:<[nD&m�[^fSDp>l]D&mnD`K>F&DEbLr p>YeFHGJ;>p8Co_>D`F*:*7�lnD*:<F`[^Y\bzK>m`A } bLl�mnp D&F [^l^:Bgh:<[nD&_ZbzK�D&K>D`lngL7 =\bzm]mnD&m8X D`=ebUG �z� caDTl8V[^fSDBD`K>D&l]gL75=\bzmnm G :Lm0D&yJ;v:<[nD&_ G0Y [^f5[^fSDBY\K>Y [^Ye:L= Dac F`Y\[^:<[^Y\bzK3D`K>D&l]gL7�Y\Kd[nf>D�F*:L=\F&;S=q:<[nYebLK>m&A| M�Q>| MwN�T G0Y\=e=vF&:L=eF`;>=e:<[^D [^fSD�Y\K>Y [^Ye:L=>_>Y\m][nlnY\X>;S[nYebzK�bLr :LK>gL;>=q:<l�I�bLI�D`Kh[^;>I rtbzl�:�gLY\kLD&K

D&KSD&lng<7���f>bUG D kzD&lTV [^f>Y\m�F*:L=\F&;S=q:<[nYebLK�Yem�bzKS=\7":Lp>p>=\YeF&:LX>=\D rtbzlErt;SmnY\bzK-CoD k<:Lp bLl^:<[nYebzK�l]D*:LF [^Y\bzK>m`AP K Y\K>D`=q:LmR[^Y\F C mnF*:i[n[^D`lnY\K>g DqcSp D&l]YeIZD`KJ[nm V�[^f>D5Dac F`Y\[nD&_ KJ;>F`=eD`;>m'p bzp>;>=e:<[^D`m =\bUG :LKSgz;>=e:LlZI�b*C

Page 70: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

0

1

2

3

4

5

0

1

2

3

4

5

Rel

ativ

e P

robab

ilit

y

0 20 40 60 80 0 20 40 60 80 100

Excitation Energy (MeV)

(a) (b)

(c) (d)

(f)(e)

} Y\gz;>l]D'm>A � 4 N YemR[^l]YeX>; [^Y\bzK>m@bLr T � ;>m]D&_BYeK�[^f>Y\m G8bzlnGwrtbLl D&K>D`lngL7�=\bzm]mnD&mxgzl]D*:<[nD&ls[^f>:LK �z� caDTl�AP K':<=e= pv:LKSD&=\m VJ[^f>DElnD&_ F&;>lRkzDEmnf>bUG0m [nf>DE_SYemR[^lnY\X>;S[nYebLK>m{;>m]D&_'Y\K [nf>DEF&:L=\F&;>=e:<[^Y\bzK>mTV G0fSYe=\Dw[^fSDX>=\;>D3F`;>l]kLD"mnfSb G0m�[^f>Da_>Y\m][^l]YeXS;S[^Y\bzK bLr�D&K>D`lngL7=\bzmnm]D&m'F`bzK>mnY\_>D`lnD&_ V{:Lm�_>D`[nD&l]I�Y\K>D`_ rtlnbzI[^fSD Q � �z� mnY\K>gz=\D&md_v:<[^:SA 9.:<K>D&=pN : P�F&bzl]lnD`mnp bzK>_>m5[^b �z��� m � caDTl8V�N X^Ppm ��� � � caDalSV�N F P� ��� � caDTl8V�N _^P ��� 9 � caDTl8V�N D P 9 ��� � � caDalSV :LK>_hNtrqP � ��� ! � caDTlOD&KSD&lng<7�=ebLmnmnD`m&A

IZD&Kh[^;SI mR[H:<[nD&m`A | M�Q>| M�N�T fv:Lm�[^fSD bzp [^Y\bzK b<r lnD&:L_>Y\K>g3Y\K :�[RG b*Co_>Y\IZD&K>m]YebzK>:L=8I�:<[nlnY c^VG0f>Y\FHf�mnp D&F`Y\uvD`m�[^f>D�YeKSY\[nYq:L= :LK>gL;>=q:<lEIZbzIZD&Kh[n;>I :<K>_"D&KSD&lng<7zA U b [^:LGLD :L_Sk<:LKh[H:LgLD�bLr.[^f>Y\mbzpS[nYebLK V>[^f>D�Y\K>Y [^Ye:L=s_>Y\m][nlnY\X>;S[^Y\bzKabLr�:<K>gz;>=e:Ll IZbzIZD&Kh[^;SI I�;>m][�X D�_>D`[nD&lnIZY\K>D&_�A

<k

Page 71: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

0 20 40 60 80 100 120Energy Loss (MeV)

0

1

2

3

4

5

Counts

(10

/MeV

)4

} Y\gz;>l]D mSA m14SU f>DaD`K>D&l]gL7=ebLmnmZ_>D`[nD&l]I�Y\K>D`_ rtlnbzI)[^f>D Q�� �z� m]YeK>gL=eD`m _v:<[^: Y\mZmnf>bUG0KsA�U f>Y\m[o7�p D�bLr�m]p D`F`[^l];>I fv:LmwX D&D`K";>m]D&_"Y\K"pv:LmR[�DqcSp D&l]YeIZD`KJ[nm � � � � � 9 �x[nb _>D [^D`lnIZYeKSD�[^f>D�YeKSY\[nYq:L=Dac F`Y\[^:<[^Y\bzK3D`K>D&l]gL7�bLrx[^fSD�[^:LlngLD`[0KJ;>F&=\D&;Sm&A

M l^:LKSgzD�bLrE:LK>gz;S=q:Ll�I�bLI�D`Kh[H: G{:Lm F&:L=\F&;>=e:<[^D`_rtbLl :�gzY\kLD&KDac F&Y [H:i[^Y\bzK D&K>D`lngL7LA�U f>D;>p>p D&lZ=\YeIZY [ N ��� � � P G :LmZ_>D`[nD&l]I�Y\K>D`_ ;>mnY\K>g [^f>Ddmn;SI bLrw[nf>D5I�:<[n[nD&lZfv:L= rw_SD&K>m]Y\[o7l^:<_>YeYN X ����� P.bLr [^f>D�[H:Ll]gzD`[8:LK>_ p>lnb��RD&F`[nYe=\D�KJ;>F`=eD`Y A�U f>Dw=\bUG D`l{=\YeIZY [QN ����� P�G{:<m F*:<=eF`;>=q:i[^D&_ ;>mnY\K>g[^fSDBKJ;>F`=eD&:Ll�YeKh[^D`l^:LF [^Y\bzKdl^:L_>Y\;>m�N X � ��� P^AvU f>Yem�yJ;v:LKh[^Y [o75Y\m�_SD`uvK>D`_":Lm 4

X � ��� ��� 6 . ��� . m�G m4! % � 6 . ��� 7G � � 0 N m>A k P

G0f>D`lnD�� 65:LK>_����":Ll]D0[nf>DwI�:<[][^D`l�f>:L=\rs_>D&K>m]Y\[o7 l^:<_>YeY bLr [^f>D0[H:<lngzD [ :<K>_ p>l]b��RD&F [^Y\=eDEKJ;>F&=\D&Y[VlnD`mnp D&F [^Y kzD&= 7 � m � A U f>DZI :i[n[^D`l�fv:L= r�_>D&K>m]Y\[o7"l^:L_>Y\;>m�Y\m � A m � rtI rtbzl g ZR\ Q K :LK>_ � A � � rtI rtbLlgji V A � Y [^f�[^fSD&mnD5yJ;v:LKh[nY\[nYeD`m _>D [^D`lnIZYeKSD&_ V~Y [SG{:<m�mR[^ln:LYegLfJ[]rtbzl7G :Ll]_ [nb F*:L=\F&;>=e:<[nD5: =\bUG D`l:LK>_d;>p>p D&l�X bz;>K>_5rtbzl [^f>DB:LKSgz;>=e:Ll0I�bLI�D`Kh[^;>I�[nl^:LK>mRrtD&l]lnD&_d[^bZ[^f>D�[H:<lngzD [*A>U f>DBl^:<K>gzD�bLr:LK>gL;>=q:<l I�bLI�D`Kh[^;>I N � P8bLrx[^f>D�[H:<lngzD [�:<r [^D`l0[nf>D�mnF&:<[n[nD&lnY\K>g�p>lnb�F&D`mnm�Yem0gzY kzD`K3Xh7 4

� ���� � � � � � kk�! 9 E ��� � � � � � � 0 N m>A � P

Page 72: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

p1

p 2

bmin/max

b min/max

120Sn

17O

17 O’

} Y\gz;>l]D"m>A �74 | :LlR[^b�bzK'bLr@Y\K>D&=e:LmR[^Y\F Com]F*:<[][^D`lnY\K>g pSlnb�F&D&m]m{[^b Y\=\=e;>mR[^ln:<[^D�[nf>D�IZbzIZD&Kh[^;SI [^ln:LK>m CrtD&l]lnD`_5[nb�[^fSD�[H:Ll]gzD`[8rtlnbzI [^f>D�pSlnb��RD`F`[^Y\=\DLA M =e=syJ;v:<KJ[nY\[nYeD`m0:LlnDwDac p>=e:LYeKSD&_dYeK'[nf>D�[^Dqc [&A>U f>Y\muvgz;SlnDQG{:<mE:<_v:LpS[nD&_5rtlnbzI ?0D`r�A � m � A

G0f>D`lnD �5Y\m{[^f>D�IZbzIZD`KJ[n;>I [nl^:LK>mRrtD&l]lnD&_�[nb [^f>Dw[^:LlngLD`[*A U f>D�k<:L=\;>D�bLr �5Y\m _>D`[nD&lnIZY\K>D&_dXh7 4� ��� %�� g � % � %�� Z � 0 N m>A � P

G0f>D`lnD %�� g :<K>_ %�� Z :<lnDa[nf>DdI�bLI�D`Kh[^;>I bLr�[nf>D3p>l]b��RD&F [^Y\=eD3X D rtbzlnDa:LK>_ :ir [^D&l�mnF&:<[n[nD&l]YeK>g<VlnD`mnp D&F [^Y kzD&= 7zA M F*:LlR[^b�bzK5bLrx[^f>D�p>l]b F`D&mnm�Y\m�m]f>bUG0K3Y\K } Yeg>A<m>A���AU f>D�[RG b*Co_>Y\IZD&K>m]YebzK>:L=@I :i[^lnY c5;>m]D&_5rtbzl{[^fSDBD`K>D&l]gL7�=\bzmnm]D&m�bLr �L��� �L� caDTl Y\m�m]f>bUG0K3Y\K

} Y\g>A m>A SA P [�Y\m�D`k�Y\_>D&Kh[BrtlnbzI [^f>Y\m�uvgz;>l]D [^fv:<[B:<m�[^f>DZD&KSD&lng<7�=ebLmnm�YeKSF&lnD&:LmnD`m V@mnbd_>b�D&m�[^fSD:LK>gL;>=q:<l I�bLI�D`Kh[^;>I�[nl^:LK>mRrtD&l]lnD&_d[^b [^fSD�[^:LlngLD`[0Y\Kd[nf>D�mnF*:i[n[^D`lnY\K>g�p>lnb�F&D`mnm&A

���� 62�%=>��� :;���<�%&

| M�QS| M�N�T F&:L=eF`;>=e:<[^D`m�[^f>D _>D`F*:*7�ln:<[^D`m�rtlnbzI�[^f>DZ:<X>mnbzl]pS[^Y\bzK F&l]bzmnm�m]D&F [^Y\bzK>m�rtbzlw[nf>D YeK8CkzD`lnm]D N Dac F`Y\[^:<[^Y\bzK^P�p>l]b F`D&m]m Vs;>m]YeKSg'[^f>D l]D&F`Yep>l]b F`Y\[o7a[^f>D`bzlnD`I � m4 � A P K"[nf>Y\m�IZb _>D`=jV [^f>D Dqc)CF&Y [^D`_aKJ;>F`=eD`;>mwI�:*7�_>D`F*:*75Xh75D&IZY\mnmnY\bzKabLr�:Zp>l]bL[^bzK V>K>D&; [^lnbLK V :L=\p>fv:Zpv:Ll][nYeF`=eDsVvbzl B"ln: 7LAU f>D"G0Y\_S[^f�p D&l8;>K>Y [ D&K>D`lngL7�VS_)# � NtD � P �<_>D � V rtbzl�D&IZY [n[nYeK>gZ:�pv:Ll][nYeF`=eD �drtl]bzI :LK'DqcSF`Y\[nD&_

KJ;>F&=\D&;SmFk NtDac F&Y [H:<[nYebLK D`K>D&l]gL7 g Vh:LK>gL;>=q:<l�IZbzIZD&Kh[^;>I � g Vzpv:Ll]Y\[o7 � g P [^b�rtbzl]I :�_>:L;>gzfh[^D`l

Page 73: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

20

25

30

0

54

32

1

0

1

E(M

eV)

*

Angular Momentum ( )h

RelativeProbability

} Y\gz;>l]D'm>A 74v9 bzpS;>=q:i[^Y\bzK�bLr [nf>D�[H:<lngzD [ KJ;>F&=\D&;>mxY\K�[nD&l]I�m@bLr�D`K>D&l]gL7�:LK>_B:LKSgz;>=e:LlsIZbzIZD&Kh[^;SIrtbzl [nf>D"D`K>D&l]gL7 =\bzmnm]D&m5bLr �L�����z� caDTl�A{U f>D�l]D&=e:<[^Y kzD p bzp>;>=e:<[^Y\bzK rtbzl D*:LFHf D&KSD&lng<7�G :Lm_>D [^D&l]IZYeK>D`_3Xh7�[^fSD Q � �z� mnY\K>gz=\D&m�_v:<[^:Zm]f>bUG0K3Y\K } Yeg>A<m>A mSA

KJ;>F&=\D&;Sm � N :<[ Z V � Z V7� Z P Y\m [^f>D`KagLY\kLD&K3Xh7 � � ��4_1#-N � � P_)� � � � Z N Z 0 � Z 0 � Z P� � � g N g 0 � g 0 � g P

� ��� � ������� � � � � �� � ��

� ��� �� � � � �� N�� � PHG N m>A m P

U f>D�GJYeK>D [^Y\FwD`K>D&l]gL7ZbLrsp>:Ll][nYeF`=eD �'Y\m�� � � g % Z % � � VbG0fSD&lnD � � Yem�[^fSDEX>Y\K>_>Y\K>g�D&K>D`lngL7LAV [^f>D`l~y�;>:LKh[^Y [^Y\D&m Y\K T yJKsA m>A mB:LlnD0[^f>D0=\D`kLD&= _>D&K>m]Y\[o7 N �<P Vhbzl]X>Y\[^:L= :LK>gL;>=q:<l�IZbzIZD`KJ[n;>I N P VFHfv:LKSK>D&= m]p>YeKhN � � � Z . � � P VS:LK>_�[^ln:LK>m]I�Y\mnm]YebLK3F&b�D ��F`YeD`KJ[nmSN � �� N�� � P7PHA U f>D�[^l^:<K>mnIZY\mnmnY\bzKF&b�D ��F`YeD`KJ[nm�:Ll]DBrtbzl0[^fSD�m]F*:<[][^D&l]YeKSg'bLr�pv:<l][^Y\F&=\D � bzK3KJ;>F`=eD`;>m � V :LK>_d[^f>D�k<:L=\;>D&m�rtbzl�[nf>D&m]DF&b�D ��F`YeD`KJ[nm�:Ll]D�bzXS[^:LYeKSD&_5rtlnbzI [nf>D�bzpS[nYeF&:L=sIZb _SD&= AU f>D"G0Y\_S[^f5p D&l{;>KSY\[ D`K>D&l]gL7bVS_)# � �<_ � V rtbzl T k Bd_>D`F*:*7'Y\m bzXS[^:LYeKSD&_�Y\K5: mnY\I�Y\=e:Ll*G{:*7�V

:LK>_dY\m�gLY\kLD&KdXJ7 � � ��4_ # � N � P_ � � � g N Z 0 � Z 0 � Z P� g N g 0 � g 0 � g P

� ����� N � P�

Z�N � � �UP Z 0 N m>A�� P

G0f>D`lnD � � g % Z :LK>_ � Z � � g bzl � g o�kLAzU f>D�y�;>:LKh[^Y [o7 � ����� N � PxlnD`p>lnD`mnD&Kh[nm8[^fSD�F`lnbzm]m �m

Page 74: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

mnD`F`[nYebzK5rtbzl T k�p>f>bL[nb Dqc F&Y [H:<[nYebzKdbLr.: mnY\K>gz=\DB=\D`kLD&=[V : kLD&ln:LgzD&_ab kzD&l�:L=\=s=\D`kLD&=\mEp bzp>;>=e:<[nD&_dXJ7B"_>D`F*:*75Y\Ka:ZgzY kzD`KaKJ;>F`=eD&:LlEl]D*:LF [^Y\bzK V :LKS_aY\m0_>D`uvKSD&_3Xh7 4

� ����� � m���� Z ���� �! " Z� �� g

�� # � Z�$ Z� % Z� , Z/. Z� # Z� G N m>A P

U f>D�yJ;v:<KJ[nY\[nYeD`m ��V

�V :LK>_F# � :LlnDE[^f>D�kL:<=e;>D`m{rtbzl~[^f>D�mR[^l]D&K>gL[nf�N Y\K�;>K>Y [^m{b<r [^f>DEF&=e:Lmnm]YeF&:L=

_>Y\p bL=eD�mn;SI�ln;>=\D P_V D&K>D`lngL75:<K>_ G0Y\_S[nfabLrx[^fSD T kBlnD`mnbzKv:<K>F&DsV l]D&m]p D`F`[^Y kzD`=\7LAU f>DBp>lnbzX>:LX>Y\=eY [o75bLr.:�KJ;>F`=eD`;>mw_>D`F*:*7�YeKSg [^fSlnbz;>gLfd[nf>DB: k<:LY\=e:LX>=\D�FHfv:<K>K>D&=\m8N K V p V �MV B>P8Y\m

_>D`p D`K>_>D&Kh[ bzK [^fSD'kL:<=e;>D`mZF*:L=\F&;>=e:<[nD&_ rtbzl�[^fSD.G0Ye_S[nf p D`l ;>K>Y [ZD&K>D`lngL7LA Q p D`F&Y uvF*:<=e= 7bV�[^fSDlnD`=q:i[^Y kzD�I�:LgzK>Y [^;S_>D'bLr [nf>D&m]D�F*:L=\F&;>=e:<[nYebzKSm rtbzl�[nf>D'Y\K>_>Y k Y\_>;v:<={FHfv:LK>KSD&=\m�_SD`[^D`lnIZY\K>D&m [^fSDp D&lnF`D&Kh[H:<gzD bLr [^f>D YeK>Y [^Ye:L=~F&l]bzmnm�mnD`F`[^Y\bzK�[nfv:<[�gzb�D&m�[^ba[nf>D k<:Ll]YebL;>m�_SD&F*:*7�m&A Q Y\K>F&D [nf>Y\m�Y\m[^fSDwF*:<mnD�V Y\[ Yem8kzD&lR7 Y\IZp bLl][H:<KJ[8[^fv:i[ [^fSD�yJ;v:LKh[^Y [^Y\D&m{;SmnD&_�[nb�F*:<=eF`;>=q:i[^Dw[nf>DBG0Y\_S[^f'p D&l ;>K>Y [D&KSD&lng<7d:LlnD�:LF`F&;>ln:<[^D<A cabzmR[wbLrx[^fSDByJ;v:<KJ[nY\[nYeD`mw:<lnDQG D`=e= GJK>bUG0K V bzl0F&:LKaX D�F*:<=eF`;>=q:i[^D&_�A

���� ��� �-��9�6 ��)"&<1R� �

P [BYem�kLD&lR7 YeIZp bzl][^:LKh[B[nb5_>D&m]F&lnY\X D�[nf>DZ=eD kzD&=~_>D`K>mnY [o7 :LmB:LF`F&;>ln:<[^D`=\7 :Lm�p bzm]mnY\X>=eD<A@U f>D Dqc)Cp>l]D&mnm]YebLK3;>m]D&_a[nbZF*:L=\F&;>=e:<[nD�[nf>D�=eD kzD`= _>D`K>mnY [o75Y\K | M�Q>| M�N�T Y\m0gzY\kLD&KaXJ7 � � VRm�m �@4

� � �!g�� Z N � � . ksPk � � � Z N . � P Z � Z�� ��� 0 N m>A�9 P

G0f>D`lnD�V :� % % � N � . ksP

� �� � � Z % � 0 N m>A � P

� �" g�� Z N m>A ! P

� � ����� � ��� � Z 0 N[m>A k � P

� � � �!N3k . � � Z . � � � � P G N[m>A kbksP

4�

Page 75: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

0 20 40 60 80 100Energy (MeV)

11

12

13

14

15

16

a(M

eV)

-1

} Y\gz;>l]D8m>A 974 � D`kLD&=�_SD&K>m]Y\[o73pv:Ll^:<I�D [^D`lwF&bLI�p>:LlnY\mnbzK"rtbLl g ZR\ Q KsA U f>D F`;>l]kLD&m�F`bzlnl]D&mnp bzK>_"[nb[^fSD�rtbL=e=\bUG0YeK>gZrtbzl]I :<=eY\mnIZm�4 gzl]D&D`K � M � � V>X>=e:LFHG � M � !<VvX>=\;>D � M �nk � V :<K>_al]D&_ � ?�D`Yem]_>bzl]r�AP K [nf>D�:LX b kzD�D`y�;>:<[^Y\bzK>mTV Y\m8[nf>D�D`K>D&l]gL7bV Y\m [nf>Dwpv:<Yel]YeK>g�D&K>D`lngL7�V>:LK>_ � Y\m8[nf>D�KJ;>F`=eD&:Ll[^D`IZp D`l^:<[n;>lnD<A P K[^f>DdDac p>l]D&mnm]YebLK rtbzl V�: K>DTG�p>:Ll^:LIZD [^D&l�Y\m Y\Kh[^lnb�_>;>F`D&_ V�Kv:LIZD`=\7 [^fSDF&bLK>m][^:LKh[ �>V G0fSYeFHf�Yem � A��wcaDTl�AzU f>D yJ;v:LKh[^Y [o7 �EYem�_SD`[^D`lnIZY\K>D&_�Xh7�[nf>D{lnY\gzY\_ X b�_S7�IZbzIZD&Kh[bLr8YeKSD&l][nYq:nV G0f>Ye=\D � � lnD`p>lnD`mnD`KJ[nm�[nf>D IZbzIZD&Kh[�b<r Y\K>D&lR[^Ye:�bLr{:�_>D rtbzlnI�:LXS=eDZlnb<[H:<[nYeK>g5=\YeyJ;>Y\__>l]bzp � � � A U f>D~bzK>= 7�bL[^fSD&l yJ;v:LKh[^Y [o7BK>bL[@_>D uvK>D`_ YeK T yJKsAUm>A 90Y\m [^f>D~=\D`kzD`= _SD&K>m]Y\[o7�pv:<l^:LIZD`[nD&lTV� AQ D`kLD&ln:L=s:LpSp>lnbh:<FHf>D&m{f>: kLD�X D&D&K ;>mnD`_'[^b�F&:L=\F&;>=e:<[^D�� A P K p>:Lm][ Dac p D`lnY\IZD&Kh[^mTV>[^f>Y\m yJ;v:LK8C

[^Y [o7fv:Lm X D`D&K u<c D&_ b kLD&l�:<=e=�D&K>D`lngzY\D&m':LK>_ :<K>gz;>=e:Ll IZbzIZD`KJ[^:�F&bLK>mnY\_>D&l]D&_sA P [YG :Lm K>b<[;>K>F`bzIZIZbzK3[^b�u<cd[^f>D�k<:L=\;>D�Xv:<mnD&_3bzKa[nf>D�I�:Lm]meN M P{b<r�[^f>DBKJ;>F&=\D&;Sm&AsU f>DB[o7�p>YeF&:L=xl^:LK>gLD;>m]D&_'rtbzl Q K'F`bzlnl]D&mnp bzK>_Sm [^b M �nk ��� M � � A P K I�bLlnDwl]D&F`D&Kh[ Dac p D&l]YeIZD&Kh[nm V>[^fSDErtbzl]I :<=eY\mnI mnD [rtbzlR[^f�Xh7�?0D&Y\mn_>bLl]r � m)9 �{fv:Lm X D&D`K:L_>bzpS[nD&_sA M F&bzIZpv:<lnY\mnbzKbLr0[^f>D _>Y J D&l]D&Kh[ZrtbzlnI�:L=\Y\mnIZmrtbzlB[^f>D�=\D`kLD&={_>D`K>mnY [o7�pv:<l^:LIZD`[nD&l Y\m m]f>bUG0K Y\K } Y\g>A�mSA�9 A P K [^f>D'?�D`Yem]_>bzl]r�_>D`mnF`lnY\pS[^Y\bzK V �Y\mwX bL[^f"D`K>D&l]gL73:LK>_"I�:Lm]mw_>D`p D`K>_>D&Kh[&A M _>_SY\[nYebzK>:L=e= 7bV [^f>Y\mw_SD&mnF`lnY\pS[^Y\bzK�[H:<GLD&mwmnf>D`=e= DTJ D&F`[nmY\KJ[nb�:LF&F`bz;>Kh[*A P K'[nf>D�_>D`mnF&l]Yep [^Y\bzKam]D`[ rtbzlR[^f�Xh7�?0D&Y\mn_Sbzl]r3V ��Y\m F*:L=\F&;>=e:<[nD&_5YeK�[nf>D�rtbz=\=ebUG0Y\K>gG : 7 4

��� � G � m4�sm � � \ " . � G k � � � � Z\ " Z �� . � G k m � � \ " g��� N[m>A k � P

Page 76: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

����

� � k . � � $ k % � � ����� ,�� G N[m>A k � P

U f>D�yJ;v:<KJ[nY\[nYeD`m � \ :LKS_ ( :LlnDEF&bzKSm][H:<KJ[nm{gzY kzD`K�XJ7 kzA k� BrtI :LKS_ k � A ��caDalSV lnD&m]p D`F`[nY\kLD&= 7bV:LK>_ � � Yem�_>D`[nD&l]I�Y\K>D`_�XJ75[nf>D�I�:LgLK>Y\[n;>_>DBbLr�m]f>D&=\=xDTJ D&F`[nm&A U f>D ?0D&Y\mn_Sbzl]r�_SD&mnF`lnY\pS[^Y\bzK3rtbLl[^fSDw=\D`kzD`=s_>D`K>mnY [o7�G :Lm :<_>bzpS[nD&_'Y\K [^fSD�m][^:<[^Y\m][nYeF&:L= F&:L=\F&;>=e:<[^Y\bzK>m ;>mnD`_�YeK [nf>Y\m :LKv:L= 7�mnY\m&A U f>D;>m]D3bLrE[^f>Y\m =\D`kLD&=�_>D&K>m]Y\[o7 _>D`mnF&l]Yep [^Y\bzK Yem�D`kLD&K IZbzl]DaY\IZp bzlR[H:LKh[�rtbzlZKJ;>F&=\D&YWG0f>D&l]D3mnfSD&=\=DTJ D&F [^mE:LlnD�=e:Ll]gzDLA

��� 0 62: ? 13@B��/

U f>DrG0Y\_S[^f bLr0[^fSD L N ? Yem [o7�p>Y\F*:L=\= 7�f>D&=\_F&bzK>mR[H:LKh[ [nf>lnbz;Sgzf>bz;S[ [nf>D�_>D`F*:*7�p>l]b F`D&mnmZY\K| M�QS| M�N�T V :LK>_ F`bzlnl]D&m]p bzKS_>m'[^b�:<K : kLD&ln:LgzD�:L=\bzK>g [^f>D�D`KJ[nYel]D"_>D`F*:*7zA{U fSD�F&b�_>D G :LmIZb _SY\uvD`_�[^bEYeKSF&=\;>_>D [nf>D bzp [^Y\bzK bLr :�K>bzK-C F&bzKSm][H:<KJ[�G0Ye_ [^fsA P K :El]D&F`D&Kh[�pv:Lp D&l Xh7DI�;>m]K>D �`b k� � � � � � � �jV : pv:Ll^:<I�D [^D`lnY �*:<[nYebzK G{:<m�pSlnD&m]D&Kh[^D`_3rtbzl [^fSDdG0Y\_S[nfabLrx[^fSDSL N ? :Lm�: rt;>K>F [^Y\bzKbLr8[^D&IZp D&ln:<[^;>l]D NtUBP Vx:LK>gz;S=q:Ll�IZbzIZD&Kh[n;>I N P V@:LKS_ [^fSD I�:Lm]mrN M P�b<r [^fSD KJ;>F`=eD`;>m&A U f>Dpv:Lln:LIZD`[nD&lnY �*:i[^Y\bzKaY\m0gzY kzD&KaXh7 4

#MN � 0 � 0 " P � #MN � 0 � � � 0 " P � N��nP � � � 6 � �� N[m>A k mnP

#MN � 0 � � � 0 " P/��# \ N " P . �sN " P�=eK NAk . � P 0 N[m>A k�� P

G0f>D`lnD # \ N " P Y\m�[^f>D0gzl]bz;>K>_�m][^:<[^D G0Y\_S[^f�bLr�[nf>DFL N ?dV �sN " P � �G m4� % "� k �L� V�� � � " � ��� V:LK>_ N��nP % k � k G � � k . �� g�� �� � � \ � Z � gaVz:<m�_>D`u>K>D&_�YeKZ?0D`r�A � � � � A<U f>Yem�p>:Ll^:LIZD [^D&l]Y��&:<[^Y\bzKeG :LmY\K>F&bzl]p bLl^:<[nD&_3Y\Kh[^b | M�Q>| MwN�T V�:LKS_":L=\=ebUG8D&_drtbzl [^f>DdG0Ye_ [^f3b<r.[^fSDSL N ? [^b�X D�:L_��R;>m][nD&_F&bLKJ[nYeKJ;>bL;>mn= 7a:L=ebLK>g [^f>D�_>D`F*:*7zAP Kd:L_>_>Y [^Y\bzK�[^b [nf>D�pv:Lln:LIZD`[^D`lnY �*:<[nYebLKdb<r.?0D`r�A � � � �OV>: mnD&F`bzK>_5[^D`I�p D&ln:<[^;SlnD C _>D&p D&KS_>D&Kh[

G0Y\_S[^f8G :Lm�Y\K>F`bzlnp bzl^:i[^D&_�YeKh[^b | M�Q>| MwN�T rtbLl Q K VL:Lm mnf>bUG0K Xh7�[^f>D8X>=\;>D F`;>l]kLD{YeK } YegSA mSA � AU f>Y\m~F&;>lRkzD0Yem~:<K D&IZp>Y\lnY\F*:L=>u>[.[^b�[^fSD Dac YemR[^Y\K>gB_v:<[H:wrtbLl Q KsAzU fSD _>D&p D&K>_SD&K>F`DEbLr [nf>D*G0Ye_ [^fbzK�:<K>gz;>=e:LlBI�bLI�D`Kh[^;>I G{:<m K>bL[�F&bzK>m]Ye_SD&lnD`_sA.U fSD'Dac F&Y [^D`_ K�;SF&=\D&;>m Y\K�[nf>Yem�G bzl]G K>D`kLD&l

49

Page 77: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

5

10

G(M

eV)

0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5Temperature (MeV)

} Y\gz;>l]D m>A � 4XL N ? G0Ye_ [^f _>D&m]F&lnY\pS[nYebzKSmaY\K>F&bLlnp bzl^:<[nD&_ YeKh[nb | M�Q>| M�N�T A0U f>D lnD`_ F&;>lRkzDG :Lm F*:L=\F&;S=q:<[nD&_ rtlnbzI T yJKsAHm>A k m :<[�=ebUG :LK>gz;>=e:Ll IZbzIZD`KJ[n;>I V~:LK>_ [nf>D�X>=\;>D�F&;>lRkzDrG :LmD&IZp>Y\lnY\F*:<=e= 7�_>D [^D&l]IZYeK>D`_�rtlnbzI Dac Y\m][^Y\K>g _v:<[^:SA�68bL[^f b<r�[nf>D&m]D�F&;>lRkzD`m�G8D&l]D�YeKSF&bzl]p bzln:<[^D`_Y\KJ[nb | M�Q>| M�N�T A

p bzp>;>=e:<[^D`m :<K>gz;>=e:Ll�I�bLI�D`Kh[^;>I m][^:<[^D`m f>Y\gzf>D`l�[nfv:LK �L� � VJ:LKS_':LK>gL;>=q:<l�IZbzIZD`KJ[n;>I DTJ D&F`[nm:Ll]DwY\K>mnY\gzK>Y uvF*:<KJ[0X D&=\bUG �L� � Y\K Q K � �z� V � � � A�U f>DBG0Y\_S[^f'_SD&mnF`lnY\pS[^Y\bzK5Xh7�I�;>m]K>D �`b k � � � � Y\m:L=\mnb�mnf>bUG0K3:Lm{[^f>D�l]D&_dF&;>lRkzDBYeK } Y\g>A!m>A � rtbLl F&bzIZpv:Ll]Yem]bzKsA

�?��� � ���� �.� ���~��!�+&���?� , ��2�$*�B��$&���P K :L_>_>Y [^Y\bzK"[nb'[^f>D mR[H:<[nYemR[^Y\F*:L=(B l^:*7�m V [^f>D`lnDSG :Lm�:L=\mnb5:'K>bzK8Com][^:<[^Y\m][nYeF&:L=�F`bzKh[^lnY\X>;S[nYebLK [nb[^fSD BDC l^:*7'm]p D`F`[^ln:SA 6 l]D&IZmnmR[^l^:<f>=e;SK>g ln:L_>Ye:<[^Y\bzKrG{:<m�pSlnD&m]D&Kh[EYeK5[^f>Y\m0_v:<[^:<Vv:Lm0F*:<KdX D�mnD`D&K:<[0f>Y\gzf BDColn: 7'D&K>D`lngzY\D&m�N m]D&D } Y\g>A � A k�! P^ASU f>D�rtbzlnI bLr@[^f>D�X>l]D&IZmnmR[^ln:Lf>=\;>K>g F`bzIZp bLK>D&Kh[�bLr[^fSD�m]p D`F`[^ln:�G :Lmw:Lmnm];>IZD&_a[nb f>: kLD�[nf>D�rtbzlnI�Dqc p%N=C T � � T \ P_V!G0f>D&l]D T \ G :Lm�mnD [E[nb : k<:L=e;SDbLr � ��caDal�� m � V m4! � A.U f>Y\m kL:<=e;>D�Y\mZmnI�:L=\=eD`l [^fv:<K [nfv:<[ gLY\kLD&KYeK?0D`r�A � m � �jV.X D&F&:L;>mnD5[^fSDF&bL=e=\Yem]YebLKaY\mEp D&l]YepSf>D&ln:L= � m ! � Y\Kd[nf>Yem0DqcSp D&l]YeIZD`KJ[&AU f>D�m][n;>_S7�bLr0X>lnD`IZmnm][nl^:LfS=e;>KSg ln:L_>Ye:<[^Y\bzK Y\m Y\KJ[nD&l]D&m][nYeKSg Y\K�Y\[nmnD`=\r�A W ;>IZD&l]bz;>m DqcSp D&l C

Y\I�D`Kh[^mZfv:*kzDdX D`D&K p D&l]rtbLlnIZD&_ [^b�mR[^;>_S7 X>lnD`I�m]m][nl^:Lf>=\;>K>g l^:L_SYq:<[nYebLK � m � V m ! � A U f>D BDCol^:*7mnp D&F [^ln:3rtlnbzI [^f>Y\m8G8bzlnG F&bzKh[^:LYeK�XSlnD&IZm]m][^ln:Lf>=\;>K>g YeK rtbzlnI�:<[nYebzK � f>bUG8D`kLD&l V~mR[H:<[nYemR[^Y\F&mZ:Ll]D[^b�bZp b�bzl [nb p D&lRrtbzlnI : _>D`[^:LYe=\D&_3:LKv:L= 7�mnY\m&A

Page 78: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

�?��� # � ��� � 45$*� ��+*����$&���

U f>D~lnD`mnp bzK>m]D�b<r�[nf>D~6{: } Z :<lnl^:*7�m G :Lm@mnY\I�;>=e:<[^D`_ G0Y [^f�[^fSD�cabzKh[^D | :Ll]=eb0F`b _>DML T�M�W U � � � � AU f>Y\m�F`b _>D :L=\=ebUG0m�[^f>D�;>m]D&l�[^b3m]p D`F&Y r 7�[^f>D�DacS:LF [ gzD`bzIZD`[nl]7 bLr8[^f>D�Dac p D&lnY\IZD&Kh[H:<= mnD [^;>p�AU f>D Q�� �z� [H:Ll]gzD`[�FHfv:LI�X D`l V�[H:Ll]gzD`[�FHfv:LI�X D`l{_>b�bzlnmTV�6{: } Z :Llnln: 7�mTV :<K>_�:L=\;>IZYeKJ;>I ;>m]D&_ [nbf>bz=\_�[^f>DZ6 : } Z :Llnln:*7 m�[nbzgzD`[nf>D&l"G8D&l]DZmnp D&F&Y uvD`_sA�L T�M�W U :L=\mnbd:L=\=\b G0m�rtbzlE[^f>D I�:<[nD&lnYe:L=\m;>m]D&_"Y\K3[^fSD�DqcSp D&l]YeIZD`KJ[w[^b X DB_>D`uvKSD&_sA U f>YemEYemED&m]p D`F&Ye:L=e= 7aYeIZp bzl][^:LKh[wm]YeK>F`D 6{: } Z Y\mwK>b<[bzK>D�bLrx[^fSDBmR[H:LKS_v:Lln_dI�:<[^D`lnYe:L=\m�Y\K5[^f>D�F&b�_>D<AP K�[^f>D�m]YeI�;>=e:<[^Y\bzK5Y\[0Y\m{Y\IZp bzlR[H:LKh[{[nb [H:LG<D�[^f>DwD&K>D`lngL7 lnD&m]bz=\;S[^Y\bzK5bLr@[^f>D�6{: } Z :Ll]l^:*7�m

Y\KJ[nb :<F&F&bL;>Kh[*A P [�G{:<mEK>b<[0p bzm]mnY\X>=\DB[nb�_SD`[^D`lnIZY\K>D�[nf>D�lnD&m]bz=\;S[^Y\bzKdbLr [nf>DB:Llnln:*7 mE:Lm�: rt;>K>F C[^Y\bzK5bLr D&K>D`lngL7'YeK�[^fSYem0Dac p D&l]YeIZD&Kh[&A U fSDBbLK>=\7 _v:<[^: [nfv:<[ G :Lm�:*kL:<Ye=e:LX>=\D�[^bZ_>D [^D&l]IZYeK>D�[^fSDlnD`mnbz=\;S[nYebzK�G{:Lm~[^fSDEm]bz;>lnF`Dw_v:i[H:SAJU f>D�f>Y\gzf>D&mR[{D`K>D&l]gL7�p bzY\Kh[-G :Lm�bzK>= 7pm>A m�caDal A P KSrtbzlnI�:*C[^Y\bzK G :Lm�K>D`D&_>D`_ rtbLl�D&K>D`lngzY\D&m�I�;>FHf f>YegLf>D&l�[nfv:LK"[^fSYem`A�Uxb5:LF&F`bz;>Kh[�rtbzlw[nf>YemTV [nf>D D&K>D`lngL7lnD`mnbz=\;S[nYebzK _>D [^D`lnIZYeKSD&_YeK [nf>DYG8bzlnG bLr�?�D r�A � �nk��-G{:LmZ:<_v:LpS[nD&_sA U f>D�_>D`[nD&F [^bzl]m�;SmnD&_ Y\K?0D`r�A � �nk �MG8D&l]D [^fSD'm^:LIZD _>D`[nD&F`[nbzlnm�;>mnD`_�YeK�[nf>Y\m Dac p D&lnY\IZD&Kh[*A } bLlB[nf>Yem�Dac p D&lnY\IZD&Kh[ V�:L=e=mnF`YeKh[nYe=\=q:i[^bzl]mSG D`lnD'l]D&F&bL;>p>=\D&_�[^b3[nf>D&Y\l p>fSbL[^bzI�;>= [^Y\p>=eY\D&l [n;>X D&m&A U f>D'l]D&F&bL;>p>=\YeK>g�l]D&m];>=\[nD&_:LK�D`K>D&l]gL7'l]D&mnbL=e;S[nYebLK'[^fv:<[5G{:Lm m]=eY\gzfh[^= 7'X D`[][^D`l [^fv:<K'[^fv:<[ bLr ?�D r�A � �nk��jV m]b [^f>Dwmnp>l]D*:L_�N��%PIZD*:Lm];>lnD`_�Xh7 ?0D`r�A � �nk���:<[B:�gzY\kLD&K D&K>D`lngL7 G :Lm�mnF&:L=\D&_�Xh7 ! � �'AsU f>DZlnD`mnbz=\;S[^Y\bzK ;>mnD`_�Y\K[^fSDBm]YeI�;>=e:<[^Y\bzK3Y\m0mnf>bUG0KaYeK } Y\g>A!m>A !SAP [SG :Lm p bLmnmnY\X>=\D'[^b�;>m]D [^fSD�m^:LIZD�:LK>:L=\7�m]Yem l]bz;S[^Y\K>D`m rtlnbzI [^f>D _v:<[H:3:LKv:L= 7�mnY\m YeK�[^fSD

mnY\I�;S=q:<[nYebLKsA Q Y\K>F&D L T�M�W U Y\m : cdbzKh[^D | :Ll]=eb F`b _SD�VSD kzD`KJ[nm0F*:LK�X Dw[^ln:LFHGLD`_5YeK>_SY\k�Y\_>;v:L=\=\7LA} bzl8:�gzY kzD`K�D`kzD`Kh[ YeK [^f>DEmnY\I�;>=e:<[^Y\bzK V :L=\= _SD`[^D`F`[nbzlnm5G8D&l]DwF`bzK>mnY\_>D`lnD&_�A M Kh7�_>D`[nD&F [^bzl]m [^fv:i[fv:L_�D`K>D&l]gL7 m]YegLKv:L=\mSG D`lnDrI :LgzgLD&_ rtbzl�D`kzD`Kh[ l]D&F`bzK>m][nln;>F [^Y\bzK2N mnD`D Q D&F<A � A � A � PHA V KSF&D'[^fSDD&KSD&lng<75lnD&F`bzK>mR[^ln;SF`[^Y\bzK G{:Lm0F`bzIZp>=eD [^DsV [nf>D�D&K>D`lngzY\D&m�G8D&lnDBf>Y\m][nbzgzl^:<I�IZD`_sAU f>D�:LF&F`;>l^:<F`7 bLr [^fSD mnY\I�;>=e:<[^Y\bzK�G{:<m~[nD&mR[^D&_�Xh7 F`bzIZpv:LlnY\K>gBDac p D&lnY\IZD&Kh[H:<=vmnbz;>l]F&D0_v:<[^:

[^b mnY\I�;>=e:<[^D`_ mnbz;>l]F&D _v:i[H:SA U f>Y\m"G{:Lm�_SbzK>D�rtbzlEX b<[^f3[nf>D ]R] � :<K>_ 9�;v6 D mnbL;>lnF`D&m Vs:LK>_"Y\mmnfSb G0KaYeK } Y\g>A!m>A k � ASU f>D�gLb b�_5:Lgzl]D&D&IZD`KJ[EX D`[RG8D&D&K3_v:<[H:Z:LKS_am]YeI�;>=q:i[^Y\bzK3Y\K>_>Y\F*:<[nD&m0[^fv:i[L T~MwW U F&:LK'X DE;>m]D&_'[nb�gzD`K>D&ln:<[^Dw:�lnD&:L=\YemR[^Y\F�lnD`mnp bzK>mnD�rt;>K>F [^Y\bzK rtbzl~[^f>DE_>D`[nD&F [^bzl :Llnln: 7�m`A

!

Page 79: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

0.02

0.04

0.06

0.08

0.10

0.00

s(E

)/E

gg

0 5 10 15 20 25 30

E (MeV)g

s(E )g

Eg

= 0.0207 +0.0405

Eg

} Y\gz;>l]DBm>A !�4 T K>D`lngL7�lnD`mnbz=\;S[nYebzK�b<rs[^f>Dw6{: } Z :Llnln:*7 m`ASU f>Y\m{p>=\bL[8Yem :L_v:Lp [^D&_ rtlnbzI ?0D`r�A � � k�� AU f>D�m]bz=\Ye_�p bzY\KJ[nm{mnfSb G G0f>D`lnD�IZD&:Lmn;>l]D&IZD&Kh[nm0rtbLl8[^fSDwlnD`mnbz=\;S[nYebzK�b<r [^f>D�:<lnl^:*7�G8D&lnDwI :<_>DXh7Z?0D`r�A � �nk�� AzU f>D0mnbz=\Y\_ F&;Sl]kzD�Y\m�[^f>D0mnF&:L=\D&_ l]D&m]bz=e; [^Y\bzK ;SmnD&_ YeKZ[^fSYem�:LKv:<=\7�mnY\m V�:Lm�_SYem]F&;>m]mnD&_Y\Kd[nf>D�[^Dac�[&A

0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5

E (MeV)g

0

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

Counts

(10

/MeV

)4

3.0 3.5 4.0 4.5 5.55.0 6.0E (MeV)

g

0

5

10

15

Counts

(10

/MeV

)4

} Y\gz;>l]Dem>A k � 4 | bzIZpv:Ll]Yem]bzK>m�bLr�mnbL;>lnF`D�_>:<[H:5:LK>_�m]YeI�;>=e:<[^Y\bzKsA � D`r [ � ]R] � A ?�Y\gzfh[ � 9�;v6 D<AP K3D&:LFHf�pv:LKSD&=[V [nf>D�m]bz=\Ye_"l]D&_a_>Yq:<I�bLK>_>m�:<lnD�[nf>DBlnD&m];>= [�bLr�[nf>DBmnY\I�;>=e:<[^Y\bzK V�:LK>_d[^f>D�bzp D`KX>=\;>D�F&Y\lnF`=eD`m�:Ll]D�[^f>D�_v:<[^:SA

U b5gzD`K>D&ln:<[^D�:�lnD`mnp bzK>m]DZrt;SK>F`[nYebzK�rtbzl�[nf>DZ:Ll]l^:*7�m V Y [QG{:Lm�K>D`F&D`mnm^:<l]7�[^b5D`I�Y [B:3BDCol^:*7G0Y [^f':�gzY kzD`K D&KSD&lng<7�:LK>_�p>=eb<[�[nf>D�lnD&m];>= [^Y\K>g�_>D [^D`F`[^D`_'D&KSD&lng<7ZYeKZ[^f>DE6{: } Z :Ll]l^:*7�m&A P KZ[^f>Y\mDac p D&l]YeIZD&Kh[�G8D�_>D*:L= [*G0Y [^f�D`K>D&l]gzYeD`m ;>p'[^b :Lp>p>l]bUc Y\I�:<[^D`=\7 �z� caDTl�A>U f>D�l]D&m]p bzKSmnD�bLr@[^fSD:Ll]l^:*7�m*G{:Lm _SD`[^D`lnIZY\K>D&_aYeK k �L� GLDTl mR[^D&pSm ;>p�[^b [^fSYem D`K>D&l]gL7zAvU f>Y\m*G :Lm�:LF&F`bzIZp>=eY\mnfSD&_dXJ7D&IZY [n[nYeK>gdl^:<K>_>bzI-D&K>D`lngL7 B�l^:*7�mBY\K l^:LKS_>bzI _>Y\lnD`F`[nYebzKSm&A M � C N f>Y\m][nbzgzln:LI G :Lm�F&l]D*:<[nD&_

9 �

Page 80: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

10

20

30

0

10

20

30

10

102103

Detected Energy (MeV)

Incident Energy (M

eV)

Co

un

ts

} Y\gz;>l]D mSA kbk�4v?�D`mnp bzK>m]DBb<r.[^fSD�6 : } Z :Llnln:*75:Lm0mnY\I�;>=e:<[nD&_3Xh7 L T�M�W U�AG0Y [^f [^fSD Y\K>F&Y\_>D&Kh[ BDColn:*7�D`K>D&l]gL7 bLK bzK>D : c YemTVz:LK>_�[^f>D{_SD`[^D`F`[nD&_ BDCol^:*7BD&KSD&lng<7�bzK�[^f>D{b<[^f>D`l: c Y\m&A�U f>Yem8f>Y\m][^bLgzl^:LI Y\m�_>Yem]p>=e: 7LD&_5:Lm :Bm];>l]r :<F&DwpS=ebL[8Y\K } Y\g>A m>A kbkzA Q Y\K>F`D�:L=\= D&K>D`lngzY\D&m5G8D&l]Dl^:<K>_>bzI V{Y [.G :Lm5K>D&F`D&mnmn:Ll]7 [^b GLD`D&p [^l^:<FHG bLr�[^fSD�K�;SI�X D&l5bLr B ln:*7 m5D`I�Y [n[nD&_ Y\K D&:LFHfk �z� G<DTl YeKh[^D`l]k<:L= AJU f>Yem4G :Lm~D*:Lm]Ye= 7�:LF&F`bzIZp>=\Yem]f>D&_'Xh7Zf>Y\m][nbzgzln:LIZI�Y\K>g�[^f>D0Y\K>F&Y\_>D`KJ[ D&K>D`lngL7D`kLD&Kh[EXJ75D kzD`KJ[&A U f>D�l]D&m];>=\[nYeKSg _>Y\m][nlnY\X>;S[^Y\bzKdbLr YeK>F`Ye_SD&Kh[ Bal^:*7�mEY\m0mnf>bUG0K3Y\K } Y\g>A!m>A k � Ac3:LGJY\K>g'F&; [^m�bzKa[nf>D�fSYemR[^bzgzln:LI mnfSb G0K3YeK } YegSA mSA kbk�:L=\=ebUG8D&_3rtbLl0[nf>DBlnD&m]p bLK>mnD�bLr�[^fSD

6{: } Z :Llnln: 7�m�[nb5:'gzY\kLD&K D&K>D`lngL7a[^b�X D DacS:LIZY\K>D&_sA Q D`kzD`l^:L=�F`;S[^m�:<lnD m]f>bUG0K Y\K } YegSA^m>A k � AU f>D`mnD{F`;S[^m�m]f>bUG [^f>D8b kLD&ln:L=e= X D`fv:*k�Yebzl bLrv[^fSD{:Ll]l^:*7�[^b�:�gzY kzD&K D`K>D&l]gL7zA<U f>D&m]D{p>=\bL[^m _>b�K>b<[[H:<GLD{[^fSD{gzD&bLI�D [^l]YeF D � F`YeD`K>F`7ZY\Kh[^b�:LF`F&bz;SKJ[&AzU f>D l]D&mnp bzK>m]D bLr [^f>D{:Llnln: 7B[^b�:�gLY\kLD&KZD&K>D`lngL7G :LmEbLXS[H:LY\K>D`_3Xh75I�:LGJYeK>g :ZF&;S[�bzK } Y\g>A�m>A kbkbV :LK>_dmnF&:L=\YeK>g Xh7�[^f>D�KJ;>I�X D&lEbLr YeK>F`Ye_SD&Kh[ Bl^:*7�m�:<[0[^f>D�gzY kzD`KaD`K>D&l]gL7zA U f>DBKJ;>I�X D&l�bLr YeKSF&Y\_>D&Kh[ B3l^:*7�m�Yem0mnfSb G0KaYeK } Y\g>A!m>A k � AU f>D�lnD`mnp bzK>m]D�rt;>K>F`[nYebLK�bLr [^f>D�:Llnln: 7�m :<=e=\bUG D`_'rtbzl8[nf>D | M�QS| M�N�T F&:L=\F&;>=e:<[^Y\bzK>m{[nb X D

rtbz=\_>D&_�A � fSD&K�F`bzIZpv:Ll]YeK>ga_v:<[^:a:LKS_ [nf>D&bzlR7bV@Y [�Y\m�KSD&F&D`mnmn:Ll]7 [^bdD&Y [^f>D`l�;SKSrtbz=\_ [nf>D _>:<[H:<V

9nk

Page 81: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

2

4

00 10 20 30

Incident Energy (MeV)

Counts

(10

/MeV

)4

} Y\gz;>l]D mSA k � 4 N YemR[^l]YeX>; [^Y\bzKab<r Bal^:*7�mED`I�Y [n[nD&_aYeK�[^fSD8L T�M�W U mnY\I�;S=q:<[nYebLKsA

0 5 10 15 20 250

100

200

0

200

4000

200

400

Detected Energy (MeV)

Rel

ativ

e P

robab

ilit

y

(a)

(b)

(c)

} Y\gz;>l]DFm>A k � 4SU f>D�lnD`mnp bzK>m]DwbLrs[nf>D�6 : } Z :<lnl^:*7�Y\m mnfSb G0K'rtbLl�m]D`kLD&l^:<=�D&KSD&lngLYeD`m&A>9 :LK>D`=emdN : P VN X P V>:<K>_�N F P~F&bzl]lnD`mnp bzK>_�[^b Y\K>F`Ye_>D`Kh[ BDC l^:*7 D`K>D&l]gzY\D&m bLr �nV k � VS:LK>_ �L� cdDTlSVSlnD&m]p D`F`[nY\kLD&= 7zAU f>DBYeKSF&Y\_>D&Kh[ B0C l^:*7'D`K>D&l]gL75Y\m�Y\K>_>Y\F*:i[^D&_aXh7'[^f>D�kLD&l][nYeF&:L=@=eY\K>D�Y\KaD&:LFHf3pv:<K>D&= A

9 �

Page 82: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

5 10 15 20 2510-7

10-5

10-3

10-1

10

E (MeV)g

Cro

ss S

ecti

on

(a.

u.)

} Y\gz;>l]D8m>A k m14 T cS:LIZp>=\D [^b'_SD&IZbzK>mR[^l^:i[^D [^fSD�DTJ D&F [^m�bLr�rtbL=e_>Y\K>g>A 6 =\;>D F`;>l]kLD � ?E: G | M�Q C| M�N�T F*:<=eF`;>=q:i[^Y\bzKsA�?0D&_�F&;>lRkzD � } bz=\_>D&_ | M�Q>| M�N�T F*:<=eF`;>=q:i[^Y\bzKsA.U fSD'lnD`_�F&;>lRkzD.G :LmK>bzl]I�:L=eY �&D`_a[nbZ[nf>D�X>=\;>D�F&;>lRkzD�:<[ cdDTl A

bzl�rtbz=e_a[^f>D�F*:L=\F&;>=e:<[nYebzKSm&A Q YeK>F`D Y\[wYem�kzD`l]7"_SY ��F&;S=\[�[nb';>KSrtbL=e_3[nf>D _v:i[H:<Vv[^fSD F*:L=\F&;S=q:<[nYebLK>mG8D&lnD�rtbz=\_>D&_�A M KdDacS:LIZp>=\D�bLrx[^fSDBDaJ�D`F`[nmEbLrxrtbz=\_>Y\K>g�:LlnD�mnfSb G0KaYeK } Y\g>A!m>A k m>A

�?��� � ��/�+&���� ��� ���~��������

� � �" M�X� �49A1A&<� �< � �493=% Q9A���<� �!/"� ���������������! "���

U f>D F&bzKhkzD`lnm]YebzK�b<r Dac F&Y [H:i[^Y\bzK D&KSD&lng<7 [nba[nD&IZp D`l^:<[n;>lnD YemBK>D`F&D&m]m^:LlR7 Y r F&bLI�p>:LlnY\mnbzKSm :Ll]D[^b X DdI�:L_>DdX D [RG D`D&K [nf>D&bzl]D`[nYeF&:L=EpSlnD&_SYeF [^Y\bzK>m':<K>_ DqcSp D&l]YeIZD`KJ[^:L=wl]D&m];>=\[nm&A8U f>D3KJ;>F`=eD&:Ll[^D`IZp D`l^:<[n;>lnD�N � P8Y\m�_SD`uvK>D`_":Lm 4

� � � == � pN �<P � � g 0 N[m>A k� P

G0f>D`lnD �BYem.[nf>D =\D`kzD`=>_>D`K>mnY [o7Z:LK>_� Yem�[nf>D{D`K>D&l]gL7zA M [�fSYegzf D`K>D&l]gzY\D&m Vz[nf>D } D&l]IZY>gh:Lm�IZb�_>D&=bLrx[^f>D�KJ;>F`=eD`;>mwY\m kL:<=eY\_ V :LK>_�[nf>D�=eD kzD&=x_>D`K>mnY [o75fv:Lm [^fSD�rtbL=e=\bUG0YeK>gZrtbzl]I � � � ��4

� � � � ��N � � � �P G N[m>A k�9 P

9 �

Page 83: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

U f>Y\m�rtbzl]I bLr8[^f>D�=eD kzD`=8_>D`K>mnY [o7bV.:L=\bzK>g G0Y\[nf T yJKsA�mSA k� nV =eD&:L_>m�[^ba:LK�DqcSpSlnD&m]mnY\bzK rtbzl�[^fSDKJ;>F&=\D*:<l�[nD&IZp D`l^:<[n;>lnD�gzY kzD`K3Xh7 4

� ��� � G N[m>A k � P

U f>D�Dac p>l]D&m]mnY\bzK"gzY kzD`K3Y\K T yJKsAXm>A k � fv:Lm{[nl^:L_>Y [^Y\bzKv:<=e= 7�X D&D&Kd;>m]D&_a[nbZ_>D`[nD&lnIZY\K>D�[^f>D�[^D`I Cp D&l^:i[^;>l]D8Y\KSL N ?�DqcSp D&l]YeIZD`KJ[nm � � V k� <V �L� V � �nV � 9 � A P [xmnf>bL;>=e_�X D~K>bL[nD&_B[^fv:<[@[nf>D8=\D`kLD&=�_>D&KSmnY [o7pv:Lln:LIZD`[nD&l G{:<mEF`bzK>m][^:LKh[�YeK5[^f>D�_>D`lnY k<:<[^Y\bzKdbLr T yJKsAXm>A k � AU f>D Q KZ:<K>_ 9�X _v:<[^:wDac Y\m][^Y\K>g�p>l]YebLl [^b8k�! ! � fv:*kzD X D&D&K�lnD C D`k<:L=\;v:<[nD&_ � � � � A P K�[nf>D5G8bzlnG

bLrx?0D`r�A � � � �OVJ[^f>D�?0D&Y\mn_Sbzl]r � m)9 � =eD kzD&=�_>D&K>m]Y\[o7 rtbzlnI�:L=\Yem]I G :Lm ;>m]D&_sA>jEmnY\K>g [nf>Yem8rtbzlnI�:L=\Yem]I V:LK>_ [^fSDd=\D`kLD&=0_>D`K>mnY [o7YeK | M�QS| M�N�T N T yJKsA4m>A 9 P V [^f>D�[^D`IZp D`l^:<[n;>lnD G{:<m�l]D C F*:L=\F&;>=e:<[nD&_;>m]YeK>g T yJKsAXm>A k? SA>U f>D�Dac p>l]D&m]mnY\bzK"bzXS[^:LY\K>D&_dXh7d?�D r�A � � � �>G{:<m�4

� ��� % � . =�= k� �

. � � . = �= �

��� g 0 N[m>A k�! P

G0f>D`lnD =�= � �

� � � Z � % k G � . � k G � .

( � � � ��� ��� G N[m>A �L� P

P K [^fSYem�_SD&lnY k<:<[^Y\bzK V [^fSD{yJ;v:LKh[^Y [o7 N . � P Y\K T yJKsA�m>A 9WG :Lm�lnD`p>=e:LF&D`_ XJ7 �ALU f>Y\m�Y\m �R;>m][nY\u>D&_:Lm � YemEmnI�:L=\= F`bzIZpv:LlnD`_3[^b �A�U f>D�Dac p>lnD`mnm]YebzK Y\K T yJKsA^mSA k�!�G{:<mw;>m]D&_"[^b F*:L=\F&;S=q:<[nD�[^fSD[^D`IZp D`l^:<[n;>lnD�Y\Kd[nf>Yem�G8bzlnG AU f>D�F*:L=\F&;>=e:<[nYebzK�bLr [^D`I�p D&ln:<[^;SlnD�Yem~_>D`p D`K>_>D&Kh[8bzKZ[^f>D0=\D`kzD`= _>D&K>m]Y\[o7�_>D`mnF`lnY\pS[^Y\bzK ;SmnD&_�A

Q Y\K>F&DZ_>YKJ D&lnD`Kh[�=\D`kLD&=~_>D&KSmnY [o7 _>D&m]F&lnY\pS[nYebzKSm�:Ll]D ;>mnD`_�Y\K :LKv:L= 7 �&Y\K>ga_>:<[H:<V�Y\[�Y\m�YeIZp bzl][^:LKh[[^b�_>D`[nD&l]I�Y\K>D�[^f>D0[^D`I�p D&ln:<[^;SlnDwY\K':BI�:LK>K>D`l F&bLK>mnY\m][nD&Kh[*G0Y [^f [nf>D�_v:<[H:�[^fv:i[ F`bzIZpv:LlnY\mnbLK>m:Ll]DE[^b�X DEI :<_>DFG0Y [^fsA U f>D�DaJ�D`F`[ bLrs;>mnY\K>g _>YKJ�D`lnD`KJ[{=eD kzD&=�_>D&K>m]Y\[o7 _>D&m]F&l]YepS[nYebLK>m Yem8D`k�Y\_>D&Kh[Y\K } Y\g>A!mSA k���AQ bzIZD�F*:Ll]D�f>:Lm�[^b�X D [^:LGLD`K�G0f>D`K F*:<=eF`;>=q:i[^Y\K>gB[nf>D [^D`I�p D&ln:<[^;SlnD�;>mnY\K>g T yJKsA m>A k�!SALU f>D

_>D [^D&l]IZYeKv:i[^Y\bzK bLr [^f>D =eD kzD&= _>D&K>m]Y\[o7 N T yJKsA�m>A 9 P�Yem KSbL[Z:LF`F&;>ln:<[^D rtbLl�kzD`l]7�=ebUG D&K>D`lngzY\D&m`AU f>Y\m�Yem�D k Y\_>D`KJ[�Y\K } Yeg>A m>A k�� A M kLD&l][nYeF&:L=~:LmR7 IZpS[nbL[^DZY\m�p>lnD`mnD&Kh[�:<[�� � A �h� cdDTl rtbzl�[^fSD

9sm

Page 84: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

0

1

2

3

T (

MeV

)0 20 40 60 80 100

U (MeV)

} Y\gz;>l]DBm>A k��74>UxD&IZp D&ln:<[^;>l]D�F&bzIZpv:<lnY\mnbzK'rtbzl~k<:LlnY\bz;>m =eD kzD&=�_>D&K>m]Y\[o7 _>D&m]F&l]YepS[nYebLK>m&A>U fSD�X>=\;>DF&;Sl]kzDEmnf>bUG0m�[^f>D0lnD`mn;>= [8bLr T yJKsA m>A k � V�G0f>Y\=eD�[^f>D0l]D&_ F`;>l]kLDwm]f>bUG0m8[^fSD�l]D&m];>=\[8bLr T yJKsA m>A k�!SAU f>DBX>=e:LFHG'F&;Sl]kzDdG :LmE_SD`[^D`lnIZY\K>D&_ G0Y\[nfa[^fSD�68D`[^fSD � � � V � � � =\D`kzD`=@_>D&K>m]Y\[o75_SD&mnF`lnY\pS[^Y\bzKsA

0.0 0.5 1.0U (MeV)

-3

-2

-1

0

1

2

3

T (

MeV

)

Asymptote

} Y\gz;>l]D�m>A k� �4 � bUG D`K>D&l]gL7 lnD`gzYebLK bLr DqcS:LF`[a[^D&IZp D&ln:<[^;>l]D�F&:L=eF`;>=e:<[^Y\bzK NtlnD`_ F&;>lRkzD rtlnbzI} Y\g>A5mSA k�� PHA�U f>D"kzD`l][^Y\F*:<=�:Lm]7�IZpS[^b<[^D :<['j � � A �h� caDal Yem5:<p>pv:Ll]D&Kh[ V :<K>_ mnf>bUG0m�[^fSD_v:LKSgzD&l0Y\Ka;>m]YeKSg�[nf>Yem�:LpSp>lnbh:<FHfd[nb�F&:L=\F&;>=e:<[^D�[^fSD�[nD&IZp D&l^:i[^;>l]D�:i[0=ebUG D`K>D&l]gzYeD`m&A

lnD`_aF`;>l]kLD�m]f>bUG0K3Y\K } Yeg>A<m>A k�� A>U f>Y\mEY\m0F&=\D*:Ll]D&l0Y\K } Y\g>A!mSA k� AM [�D&K>D`lngzY\D&m X D`=ebUG � ����� cdDTlSV�[nf>D�[^D&IZp D&ln:<[^;>l]Dam]f>bz;>=\_ KSbL[ZX D5F&:L=eF`;>=e:<[^D`_ G0Y [^f

T yJKsA5m>A k�!SA~U f>D3=eD kzD&=E_>D&KSmnY [o7bV :Lm F*:L=\F&;S=q:<[nD&_ Y\K | M�QS| M�N�T V Y\m K>b<[�:LF`F&;>ln:<[^D3:<[ kLD&lR7=\b G D`K>D&l]gzY\D&m&A U f>Y\mwfv:LmEX D`D&K�:<F&F&bL;>Kh[^D&_artbzlEY\K3[nf>D�F&:L=\F&;>=e:<[^Y\bzK>mTVs:Lm�_>Y\mnF`lnD`[nD =\D`kzD`=em"G8D&l]DY\K>F&=\;>_>D`_ YeK�[nf>D | M�Q>| M�N�T F*:<=eF`;>=q:i[^Y\bzK>m&A } bzlx[nf>D Dqc p D`lnY\I�D`Kh[~_>Yem]F&;>m]mnD`_ f>D`lnDsVi[nf>D =\bUG D`m][

9 �

Page 85: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

D&KSD&lng<7 [^fv:<[�fv:<_�[nb�X D0F&bzKhkzD`l][nD&_ [nb�:�[^D`IZp D`l^:<[n;>lnD�G{:<m :LpSp>lnb c YeI�:<[nD&= 7 !�cdDTlSV�:LKS_ [^fSDp>l]bzX>=\D&IZmw:<mnmnb�F&Ye:<[nD&_ G0Y\[nf T yJKsAXm>A k�!Z:LlnD�;>K>Y\IZp bLl][H:<KJ[&A

� �� :;��9A� �'�4)5���� "�4)5�!1R�!1A�%&

Uxb F&:L=eF`;>=e:<[^DB[^f>D�KJ;>F&=\D*:<lE[^D`IZp D`l^:<[n;>lnDB;>mnY\K>g T yJKsA m>A k�!<VS[RG8b'yJ;v:LKh[nY\[nYeD`mwI�;Sm][EX DB_>D`[nD&l CIZYeKSD&_sA V K>D�bLr [nf>D&m]D yJ;v:LKh[nY\[nYeD`m�Y\mB[nf>DZI�D&:LK�Dqc F&Y [H:<[nYebzK D&K>D`lngL7 b<r [^fSD�KJ;>F`=eD`;>m _>;SlnY\K>g[^fSD"_>D&F&:*7zA Q Y\K>F`D"[^f>D�?0D&Y\mn_Sbzl]rB=\D`kzD`=�_>D`K>mnY [o7 rtbzl]I :<=eY\mnI Yem ;>mnD`_ YeK [nf>Yem':LKv:L= 7�mnY\m V{[^fSDI�:LgzK>Y [^;S_>D�bLr.m]f>D&=\=@DTJ D&F [^mE:L=em]b I�;>m][�X D�_>D`[nD&lnIZY\K>D&_�A

� ').0 #%$>�4�=��.:������ # >')���A<

U f>DdIZD*:LK Dac F&Y [H:<[nYebLK D&K>D`lngL7 N �� � � P�bLrE[^f>DdKJ;>F&=\D&;Sm�:L=\bzK>g [^f>D5_>D`F*:*7bLrw[nf>D L N ? Y\m

K>D`D&_>D`_3Y\Kabzl]_>D&l [nb�F&:L=\F&;>=e:<[^D�[nf>D�[^D&IZp D&ln:<[^;>l]DLA U f>D�yJ;v:LKh[^Y [o7 �� � � Y\m�_SD`[^D`lnIZY\K>D&_aXJ7 4

�� � � � �� � % � � �� � % ')(+* 0 N[m>A � ksP

G0f>D`lnD �� � Yem [^fSD�:*kLD&l^:<gzD�D`K>D&l]gL7bV � � �� � Y\m [^f>D�:*kzD&ln:LgzDBlnbL[^:<[^Y\bzKv:<=sD&K>D`lngL7�V :LK>_ ')(+* Y\m[^fSD�gzlnbL;>K>_'mR[H:<[nD�D&K>D`lngL7 bLr [nf>DQL N ?BA P [{Y\m{K>D`F&D`mnm^:<l]7 [nb mn;SXS[^ln:LF`[ � � �� � :LK>_ ')(+* rtlnbzI � � X D`F*:L;>m]D [^f>D�D&K>D`lngL7":Lmnm]b F`Yq:<[nD&_ G0Y [^f�L N ? F&bzl]lnD&m]p bLK>_>m�[^b'[nf>D�D`K>D&l]gL7�:<mnmnb�F&Ye:<[nD&_G0Y [^f5[^f>D�m][^:<[^D`mE;Sp bzK G0f>Y\FHfa[nf>D�L N ? Yem�X>;>Y\=\[ � � � A>U f>DBlnbL[^:<[^Y\bzKv:L=�D&K>D`lngL75Y\m0F*:L=\F&;>=e:<[nD&_G0Y [^f5[^f>D�rtbz=\=ebUG0Y\K>g�Dac p>lnD`mnm]YebzK-4

� � �� � � � � � $ � � � . k ,� � 0 N[m>A �z� P

G0f>D`lnD � � � Y\m [^f>DB:*kzD`l^:LgLD�:<K>gz;>=e:Ll0IZbzIZD&Kh[^;>I b<r [nf>D�K�;SF&=\D&;>m�_>;>l]YeK>gZ[^fSDB_SD&F*:*7LAU f>D3_SD`[^D`lnIZY\Kv:<[^Y\bzK bLrw[nf>DayJ;v:<KJ[nY\[nYeD`m � � :LKS_ � � � Yem�lnD`=q:i[^Y kzD&= 7m][nl^:LY\gzfh[nrtbzlAG{:<ln_

rtlnbLI-[^fSD F&bzIZp>;S[nD&l�F&b�_>D | M�QS| M�N�T A M m�_>Y\mnF`;>mnm]D&_ D&:Lln=\YeD`l V | M�Q>| M�N�T F&:L=\F&;>=e:<[^D`mB:LKDac p D&F [^D&_ mnp D&F [^ln;SI bLr B ln:*7 mTV G0f>Y\FHf Y\m�_>D&p D&KS_>D&Kh[�bzK�[^f>D m]p D`F&Y uvD&_ YeKSY\[nYq:L=.p bzpS;>=q:i[^Y\bzKbLr [nf>D�KJ;>F&=\D&;>m`A } lnbzI [^fSYem Y\K>Y [^Ye:L=�p bzp>;>=e:<[nYebzK V [^fSD�F&b�_>D�_>D [^D`lnIZYeKSD&m [^f>DwlnD&=e:<[nY\kLDBp bzp>;S=q:*C

9�

Page 86: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

T � � k � � �� � ! � � k � � � k�9� � � k � � � �� � � ! � �� � A m � k kbk � kbk m4� k�k � m ! � k �m !SA m � k � � 9� � !�m<k � m)9 � m � k � �m � A m � m � k � 9 m 9 � � � � � � � 9 � � �m49 A m � kbk� �L� k � ! � 9 � 9�9 �L� k � � � ! �m SA m k � k � �h� !�! k �z� � � ! � k � k�9 � ! kbk� km4� A m � �z� m m � � � k m � !�m ! � � � � k �L� k� 49 �m�m>A m � m4 ! � � ! � k�� 9 k � k � 9 �L� k � �L� 9 mm � A m �L� � m � k� ! � � k �L� k m �L� � �z� ! m � A m ! 9�! ! 9sm!k � k�9 � 4� !� <k�9 �z� !�m �L� � �

m<kzA m k m ! ! � � �nk? k � m 4� !nk� � � k m)� �z� 9 k �m � A m �L� kbk � � � ! � k� �!� 9 � � k�! 4� �L� � k �� !SA m � � k � ! 9 � � 9 k � ! �z� �! � � k�9sm � k � k k �� � A m � � kbk� �sm �<� � ! ! 9 � �z�h� k m � k k�� � !� 9 A m � ! ! �m � 9 9 � ��!49 k � 9 9 � kbk � 9 k � � �

� SA m � 9 9 �h� � � � � � � ! � � � � � � � k � � 9� � A m �h� �nk � k���!nk �L� 9 k k? �mbm <k�! � � � m>A m � � �z�z� !49 � k m � � k � k � m � � m�L� A m k � � k � � � k � m � � � � <k m4! m�z� A m k � k � ! � m � m � ! � ��! k� � � � �� kzA m � 9 � k�! ! � � � � k � ! ! � m ��L� A m � m4 kbk� k� � k �z� � k� �� !SA m � � 9 49 !sm 9 � � � k � k� � A m � k� � � � m m � � k k� 9 A m k ! �z� � k �L� k � m k� SA m k � k � k � k � 9 � �� � A m � � 9 k�k � m k �� m>A m � � m m � k ��<� A m � k � � � k � ��L� A m � k k � k k � �� kzA m � � k k k � � �

U :LX>=\D m>A � 4 Q :<I�pS=eDap bzpS;>=q:i[^Y\bzK I�:<[nlnY crtlnbzI | M�Q>| M�N�T A8U f>Dal]D&=e:<[^Y kzD3p>lnbzX>:LX>Y\=eY [o7 bLrp bzp>;>=e:<[^Y\bzK'Y\K'[^D`lnIZm{bLrsD&K>D`lngL7':LK>_�:LKSgz;>=e:Ll IZbzIZD&Kh[n;>I Y\m{mnfSb G0K�ASU f>D�D`K>D&l]gL7bVSYeK';SK>Y\[nmbLr�caDTl8V Yem0Y\K>_>Y\F*:<[nD&_3Y\K5[^f>D�=\D`r [�IZbzm][�F&bL=e;>IZK V�G0f>Y\=\DB[nf>DB:LK>gz;>=e:Ll0IZbzIZD&Kh[^;SI V Y\Ka;SK>Y\[nmbLr � VvY\m�Y\K>_>Y\F*:i[^D&_dY\Kd[nf>D�[^bzpdlnbUG�A[^Y\bzKdbLr _v:L;>gzfh[nD&l0KJ;>F&=\D&Yx:L=\bzK>gZ[^f>D�_>D`F*:*7zA 687'DacS:LIZYeKSYeK>g�[^f>D`mnDBp bLp>;>=e:<[^Y\bzK>mTV :LK3:*kLD&l^:<gzDD&KSD&lng<7 :<K>_ :LK>gL;>=q:<l IZbzIZD&Kh[n;>I F&:LK X Da_SD`[^D`lnIZY\K>D&_ rtbzl�D*:<FHf K�;SF&=\D&;>m�:<=ebzKSg [^fSD3_>D CF*:*7LA U.:LXS=eD�m>A � mnf>bUG0m�:'[o7 pSYeF&:L=�p bLp>;>=e:<[^Y\bzK bz;S[np>;S[�rtlnbLI-[^fSD F&b�_>DLA } bzlw[nf>Y\mBp>:Ll][nYeF`;>=q:<lDacS:LIZp>=\D�V � � �"m � A � !ZcaDTl :LK>_ � � � � SA � 9 � AU f>D : kLD&ln:LgzD�D&K>D`lngL7 :LKS_�:LKSgz;>=e:Ll�IZbzIZD&Kh[^;>I bLr8D*:<FHf�_v:L;Sgzfh[^D&l�KJ;>F`=eD`;>m :L=\bzK>g5[^fSD

9 9

Page 87: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

W ;SF&=\D&;>m �� � N caDal�P � � � N � P �<Q N caDTl P � ?0D&=e:<[^Y kzD � D&Y\gzfh[eN ��Pg ZR\ Q K �sm>A � ! SA 9nk C_kzA � kbk � A ! � � !SA m gRg � Q K m � A � ! SA � 9 C � A m � � � A � m �L� A�9 �gRg � P K � � A m)9 SA � 9 � A � kbk kzA !� � A � mgRg ] Q K �h� A ! � SA ! � C � A ! � � kzA � m �L� A � gRg ] P K � m>A 9 � SA !�m � A � � kzA �z� � A k�9gRgji Q K � kzA k� 9 A �h� C � A � <k � A � m ��A � �gRgji P K k� SA � SA !�m � A ��! � � A �z� � A � mgRg � Q K k � A m � SA !49 C � A � �z� � A � m � A��smgRg � | _ � m>A ! � 9 A �z� � A � 9 � � A �z� � A �z�gRg � | _ �L� A ! � 9 A �z� kzA k�! ! m>A �z� � A k �gRg � | _ k� SA � m 9 A k�� � A � m � A �z� � A �h�

U :LX>=\D8m>A � 4 Q ;SI�I�:LlR73b<r�KJ;>F&=\D&Y p bLp>;>=e:<[^D`_�:L=\bzK>g [nf>D�_SD&F*:*7LA Q D kzD`l^:L= y�;>:LKh[^Y [^Y\D&m�l]D&=\D`k<:LKh[Y\KaF&:L=eF`;>=e:<[^Y\K>gZ[^f>D�[^D`IZp D`l^:<[n;>lnDB:Ll]DBm]f>bUG0KsA U f>DBy�;>:LKh[^Y [^Y\D&mE:LlnD�_>D`mnF&l]YeX D&_aYeK5[^fSD�[nDac�[*A

_>D`F*:*7�:L=\=\b G0m�rtbzl�[nf>D�_>D`[nD&l]I�Y\Kv:<[nYebLK�bLr �� � � AxUxb�F*:L=\F&;>=e:<[nD'[^f>Y\m yJ;v:LKh[^Y [o7bV [^f>D�:*kLD&l^:<gzD

D&KSD&lng<7 bLrBD*:<FHf _v:<;>gzfh[^D`l�K�;SF&=\D&;>m5fv:Lm'[nb�X D�_SD`[^D`lnIZY\K>D&_sA | :<=eF`;>=q:i[^Y\K>g �� � rtbzl'D&:LFHf_v:L;Sgzfh[^D&l KJ;>F&=\D&;>m Yem m][^ln:LY\gzfh[ rtbzlAG{:<ln_ V�:Lm _>Yem]F&;>m]mnD`_ Y\K [nf>D3pSlnD`k�Y\bz;>m pv:Ll^:<gzl^:LpSfsA~U f>DG8D&Y\gzfh[EgLY\kLD&K�[^b D&:LFHf5_v:L;>gzfh[nD&l KJ;>F&=\D&;Sm�Y\K5F*:L=\F&;S=q:<[nYeKSg � � Y\m _>D`[nD&lnIZY\K>D&_dXh7 [nf>D BDCol^:*7F&l]bzmnm mnD&F [^Y\bzK5:<[Fk�� caDal bLrs[nfv:<[ K�;SF&=\D&;>m l]D&=e:<[^Y kzDw[nb�[^fSDE[^b<[H:L= F&l]bzmnm mnD&F [^Y\bzK�bLr>B�ln: 7�m :i[k���caDTl8V :LmE_SD`[^D`lnIZY\K>D&_"Xh7 | M�Q>| M�N�T A N D`[^D`lnIZY\K>YeKSg � � � Yem�F&bzIZp>=\D`[nD&= 7a:LKv:L=\bzgzbz;Sm0[nbF*:<=eF`;>=q:i[^Y\K>g �� � A�U f>D BDCol^:*7aD&K>D`lngL73bLrWk��'caDal G{:<m�FHf>bzmnD`K X D&F&:L;>m]DZ[nf>D gzl]bz;>K>_ mR[H:<[nDD&KSD&lng<7 YeK g ZR\ Q K�Y\m�k�� A m"caDal � �sm � A Q Y\K>F&D | M�Q>| MwN�T F*:L=\F&;S=q:<[nD&m�D`kzD`l]7J[^fSYeK>g�Y\Kk'caDalm][nD&p>mTV%k�� A m cdDTl$G{:<mEl]bz;>K>_>D`_a_Sb G0K5[^b k��ZcaDal A U :LX>=\D mSA � mnfSb G0mE:LKdDacS:LIZp>=\D�b<r�G0fv:i[F*:<K X D"Dqc p D`F`[^D`_sA P K [nf>Yem DacS:LIZp>=\D�V � � �"m � A � caDal :LK>_ � � � � A � m � A � Y [^f [nf>D&m]DyJ;v:LKh[^Y [^Y\D&m�_SD`[^D`lnIZY\K>D&_ V Y\[�Y\m'D&:Lm]7[^b F&:L=\F&;>=e:<[^D �

� � � A P ['Y\m [^fSYem k<:L=\;>D"b<r�D&K>D`lngL7[^fv:i[mnfSbz;>=\_aX D�;>mnD`_a[^bZF&:L=eF`;>=e:<[^D�[^f>D�[nD&IZp D`l^:<[n;>lnD�bLrx[^fSDBKJ;>F`=eD`;>mw_S;>lnY\K>gZ[^f>D�_>D`F*:*7zA

� . �� ��=������' � � ��'8/5/ # � '8����6

U f>DBI�:LgzK>Y [^;>_SD�bLr.mnf>D`=e=@DTJ D&F [^mSN � � YeK T y�K�A mSA �L� P Y\m�_>D`[nD&lnIZY\K>D&_�Xh7�[nf>D�KJ;>F`=eD`;>mFG0fSYeFHffv:Lm�[nf>D0KJ;>I�X D&l�bLr p>lnb<[^bzK>m�:LKS_�KSD&;S[nlnbzK>m~F`=ebzm]D&mR[�[nb�[^fv:<[~b<r � :LKS_ BAhU f>D0y�;>:LKh[^Y [^Y\D&m �:LK>_ :LlnD�_>D [^D`lnIZYeKSD&_3Xh75p D&lRrtbzlnIZY\K>g :SG8D&Y\gzfh[^D`_":*kzD`l^:LgzDBbLr� :<K>_8� A U f>DB:*kzD&ln:LgzY\K>g

9 �

Page 88: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

p>l]b F`D&_>;>l]D0Yem�F`bzIZp>=eD [^D`=\7Z:<Kv:L=\bzgzbz;>m�[nb�[^fv:i[~YeK [^fSD p>lnD k Y\bz;>m~m]D&F`[nYebLKpG0f>D`lnD � � :<K>_ � � � G8D&lnDB_>D [^D&l]IZYeK>D`_sA U f>DBK�;SF&=\D&;>mEYem [^fSD&K5rtbz;>K>_dXh7�_>D`u>K>YeKSg [^fSDByJ;v:<KJ[nY\[o78��V<G0f>D&l]D

� � � % � . � � % � � G N[m>A �L� P

U f>D5yJ;v:LKh[^Y [o7 � F*:<KX D�F*:<=eF`;>=q:i[^D&_ rtbzl D&:LFHfK�;SF&=\D&;>m�p bLp>;>=e:<[^D`__S;>lnY\K>g�[^f>D5_>D`F*:*7bV~:<mmnfSb G0K YeK U.:<X>=eDWm>A � AhU f>D�KJ;>F&=\D&;>mMG0f>Y\FHf'fv:Lm�[^fSDEm]I :<=e=\D&mR[8k<:L=\;>D�bLr5�d_>D`[nD&l]I�Y\K>D`m � � A } bzl[^fSD�DqcS:LIZp>=eDZY\K [nf>DZp>lnD k�Yebz;SmBm]D&F [^Y\bzK V � � !�G �z� :LK>_ � m4!�G ! !<V G0f>YeFHf IZD*:LK>m � � Y\m_>D [^D&l]IZYeK>D`_3Xh7 gRg � Q KsA

9�!

Page 89: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

� � ��� ��� �

� ����� � � � � � � ��� � � � � � ��� � � � � � � � �

U f>DBYeKh[nD&lnpSlnD`[^:<[^Y\bzKabLr.[nf>D BDC l^:*7�mnp D&F [^ln: lnD`=eY\D&_abzK5[^f>D�[^b�bz=\m�_SD`kzD`=ebLp D`_"YeKd[^f>D�p>l]D`k�Y\bz;>mFHfv:Lp [^D&l`A�U f>D�pv:Ll^:<I�D [^D`lnm�bLr.[^f>D�L N ? :Ll]D�[^fSD�mn;SI-l];>=eD�m][^l]D&K>g<[^f N Q P V D&K>D`lngL7 N T������ P V:LK>_eG0Y\_S[^f N #HP^ALU f>D`mnD0pv:Lln:LIZD`[nD&lnm'G8D&l]D Dac�[^ln:LF`[nD&_ZrtlnbzI [^f>D _>:<[H:�Xh7 F`bzIZpv:Ll]YeK>g�[nf>D&bzl]D`[ CY\F*:L=�F*:L=\F&;S=q:<[nYebLK>m�G0Y [^f _v:<[^:SAiU f>D [^fSD&bzl]D`[^Y\F*:<= F&:L=eF`;>=e:<[^Y\bzK>m�F`bzK>m]YemR[~bLr>[RG8b�p>YeD`F&D`m&AzU f>D�uvlnmR[p>Y\D&F`DBY\m0: m][^:<[^Y\m][nYeF&:L= IZb _>D`=sF*:<=eF`;>=q:i[^Y\bzK5p D`l]rtbzl]I�D`_rG0Y\[nf | M�Q>| M�N�T AvU f>D�mnD`F&bzKS_ap>Y\D&F`DY\m :aXSlnD&IZm]m][^ln:Lf>=\;>K>g�F&:L=eF`;>=e:<[^Y\bzKsA 6 bL[nf�bLr{[nf>D&m]D'F*:<=eF`;>=q:i[^Y\bzK>m�G8D&l]D rtbz=\_>D&_ V K>bLlnI�:L=\Y��`D&_[^b [nf>D�_v:<[H:nV :LK>_d:L_>_>D`_d[nbzgzD [^f>D`l&AvU f>Y\mEm]p D`F`[nln;>I G :Lm0[^f>D`KaF`bzIZpv:LlnD`_d[nbZ_v:<[H: AP Ka[nf>D�F*:Lm]D�bLrx[^fSD BDColn:*7'mnp D&F [^l];>I�gh:<[^D`_abLKdD`K>D&l]gL75=\bzmnm]D&mwb<r �L��� �z� caDTl8Vv[^f>D�_v:<[^:

G :Lm{u>[ Xh7�kL:<l]7�YeKSgZ[nf>DdL N ? p>:Ll^:LIZD [^D&l]m{Y\K | M�Q>| MwN�T [^bZ:<FHf>YeD kzD�[^fSD�X D`m][�:LgLlnD&D`IZD&Kh[X D`[RG8D&D&K F*:L=\F&;>=e:<[nYebzK :LK>_Z_v:i[H:�;>mnY\K>g��%Z�� �� �� ������ �������������� ����� ��� ���!���#"�$%��&'&(����)�"G*�#&���#����+�#$," �!� (- ���.���/&��#�����0�#����� �!�213������� �TV��.��%&�(+���.�QG*�#&4�&��!(0���65)��� 5)798:���;5!����&�%&'��� ��5<"= �!�RG>� � �?�.��%&/(+���)���#��(?@��'�!A�%��4�&��0� �#&�4���� ���!�2��& �

B ��� � �DC?E�� F G3H �JI GLK ��� MON0PQPSRUTVGDW�X;K�Y[Z

�����]\#^`_ba#^?cd�!ef� ���!���#"g$%��&�&h&�@i� 5<�.�'4��S &j$%�`kl� ����4����V%�m�!��� �'�#"[�.�d� n24+�o�.���.���0 ��%��p�#$�<qb5!%�.���.%���r� ���!���#"sk/,�.�t�.���d�!��� �'�#"O$%��&�&��#8��.���d&'5����'�.�!��� (vuxwzy9�Q����%&0k*�#&�(�%&�5!4�&�&'� ({%�| �!5#��}�� ~��%~��b�#��(]k/%$%$������ = ��(�%&�5!4�&�&'� (U8:4��'����� ����� �����b�����L ��%��p�#$��#����4�$p�#�������� ���.4��fk*�#&

� ^

Page 90: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

10 15 20 25

10

102

103

104

Counts

E (MeV)g

� %��4��'���b�%~������������ ����"g&�@i� 5!����4��S%&6&'��� k/�O�#&j�.���0&��#$ %(s@i�� ����&h8:���6\#^ _ba�^dc?�!e � ���!���#"$%��&�&'� & � ����� = $ 4�� 5 4�� A��� &3�.��� �'� &�4�$%�j�#8���������������k/�� $%�9�.��� �'� ([5!4��'A#�0%&L�.���9���!&�4�$,�j�#84�&' �����.���h(�� &�5!��%@��.%���d8:�����.���Dk/%(��.�?&��<��8:�#�'�.� = "8ID4�&���� � � A� ����� �� a����x�

�#$%&��s(��!�.�!����%��� ( �#&](� &'5 4�&'&�� ( %� | � 5��*}��%~��%~���� ,�.�{����� %��,�. �#$3�zqb5 ,�)���� ���v�!��� �'�#"v����(�#���#4�$p�����0�#�0�!���.4�� &'@��!5 ��+� ( ����� | ����� �{5���$ 5!4�$p�o�.%����&�k*�!���h@��!�'8:���'��� ( �! � �.���65 �#$ 5!4�$ ���.%����&!�i������@+���.�#���!��� �'&��#8 �.���#"$�D1 k>� �'��A��#��%� (d�.�-�0%��%��&%!�9� � �����

���!&�4�$,���#8 �.����5��#$%5 4�$p���� �#��&��#���*&���� k/�0 �'� %�����b�%~/�#& �.����&���$% ( = $ 4���5!4��'A#�#��������@��#�.�#���<�.� �'&k>� ���h8:��4���(U�.� = � |)( ~��%~#* ^�� \b�+� ����� ( ~-,��.�'* ^��0/0c?�<e9���#��()1 ( }�* ~�c?�!e����+����.�� &U5���&��#�������g�0� �#� �zqb5 ,�)���� ��� � ��� ����"v8:��$ $%� k/ ���r�����2"$�D1 (�� 5���"vk*�#&U8:��4���(v�.� = �3 �./ c?�<e9������ &D�������[�<qb5 ,�)���� �#�[� ���!���#"dk���&D5 ����A��!�'��� ([�.� �0�.� ��@i� �����.4��'���#&�(� &'5 4�&'&�� (%� | � 5#� }�� }�������� �.� ��@i� �����.4��'�9k���&j8:�#4���([�.� = � ~]cd�!e9� �����'�����.�!([k/ (����V�������!� &Lk/,�.��.���6���'��4���(?&'�.���.�#"$�D1 k/%(��.�?�#8;}�� 3 c?�!e4�5��}6� � �����$������� ( �'� &'���+�#��5!�9� ��� ����"��7� ����� � %&&��#�0�<k/�+������ ����� �*���+�#�]���������'��4���( & �)�����3A��#$%4��L�#8Q~8�b� }�c?�!e9�5�o}�� ����� k>�!A��!� � ���'� &'���+�#��5!�� ��� ����" ��%����� �Q���+�#� �.�����;�#8 �.�����#����4���( &'�)�o�.��A��#$ 4���k��#&���$ &'�h��� �#&�4��'� (-����$%�`k �<qb5!%�.���.%���� ��� ���# �!&3%� 1/�!8:&!�:� \��b� \�/��x�

�����0$ � k;� ��� ��@i� �.�o�.4��'�0k/%(��.� %&h&'��� k/�V%�<� ����b� \]k/,�.� �#�.��� �j�<qb%&'�.%���?(+���)� @i��%�2��&�)��7#� �h8:����� 1��<8:& �=� \#\b�%a����x� �������� ��@i� �.�o�.4��'�>�#8��#$%$2(+���)��@i��%�2��& %�>� �����b� \�k*�#& (��!�.�!����%��� (�#&D(��!&�5!�� = �!(V%� | � 5#��}�� }�� �����9A��#$%4����#8��.���9k/%(��.�m��� %!� �'�U��� ��@i� �.�o�.4��'��k*�#&j&��<�D�.� �.���

� ~

Page 91: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5

Temperature (MeV)

10

5G

(MeV

)

� %��4��'�'�b� \=�+�*����@+�#�' &'���g�#8�(+���.� �#��( ����� �#�'" 8:�#� | � ������� ���!([5 %��5!$ � %&�8:���#� ���� &3k*���'7 ������ = $ 4���5 %��5 $%� &/����( �����!� � (�p�#������(�&/�#����8:����� 1/�!8 ��� a���� �2k/���!���L�.���L5 %��5!$ �!&��#���38:��������&�5 ������� �' ���j����(9�.���*(�p���0�#��(�&;�#�'�>8:�'���J8:4�&�%���=� �!A��#@i���.���� �#�9��� �#5!�� ����& ������� = $ 4��*�.�'p�#����$ �!&�#�'�-8:���#� 1/�!8 � � \�\��*�#��(O�����-8:�'��� 8:4�&' ��� � �!A��#@i�������.%���s�'���#5<�.%����& � ����� �����#�����0���!5!�.�#����$%�%&]�.���?�.�#����� �#8Dk/%(�����& �����#&'4����!(v8:���-����� ���'��4���( &'�)�o�.�#�>����� �'� (v5 4��'A�� &]�����[�#(�p���= ���� 5��.���!���0�#$ &����#@����+4�5<�.4+���� �#� 5��#$%5 4�$p���� �#� ������(-����� = $%4��35 4�� A��L%&�������!��@� �' 5 �#$i5 4�� A��(�%&�5!4�&�&'� ( %� | � 5#� }��%~�� }��

A��#$%4��9�#8�ab� � cd�!e � �����x����&�%�[1��<8 � � a����x� ����� ���!( 5 4�� A�� %� � %�����b� \0&���� k/&������ �#(� � = �o�.%5�.��� ���0�#$&����#@����+4�5<�.4+���� �#�Vk/ (b�.�s5 �#$ 5!4�$ ���.�!(O �O1/�!8 � � a����>���6$ � k �#����4�$ �#�6�������!�2��4��U������h���!(?5!4��'A#��%&��#� ���!�.�#$%$%"U5!����&' & �.� ���3k/%���d�����6(����)��������%�����!�/��� ��@i� �.�o�.4��'� & � = 4��/8 �#%$%&�.��(��!&�5!�� = �j�.���j(+�o�)�0���/$ � k �.� ��@i� �����.4��'� &!�

��������� ��@��!�.����4���� � (��!@��!��(��!�2��k/ (���� &����`k/� = "U�.�������!( 5 4��'A��� � � ������� \ k��#&3 ��5 ��� �@i���.����� (s%���.� ��� | ����� ��� &'� � | �!5#� }�� ~�� }��.���&�%��� �.��%&���� ��@��!�.����4���� � (��!@��!��(��!�2��k/%(��.����.���-�zq�@i� 5<�.�!( � � �.��"[&'@��!5!�.�'4��S&��+��@���8:���j� ���!���#" $%��&�&'� &6�#8/\#^ _ba�^?c?�!e k���&�5���$ 5!4�$p�o�.� (���#&'&�4���%���<� ����� ( ~-,��.�gc?�!e �#��( | ( ~#� ~d�#& (��<�.�!���� ��� ( %�t�.���U�'�����;�����U�'� &�4�$%� �&����`k/�?�#&������L���!(U5 4�� A��j � � %�����b� ~#��(���� &������/(�� &'5 �� = �j�����D(+���.��k*�!$ $ �+�����Lk/%(��.�U�#8 �.���5���$ 5!4�$p�o�.� (U&'@��!5!�.�'4�� &��+�#@i�L%&�5 $%������$,"]�.����$ �#�'���#�b(� & �.�' = 4b�.%���9�.����&'�.�'� �����.� � A��!�/��$p�������!�� ��� ����"U�.�#���#�L�.�+�#�U�.���h(����)���

�����9�!�0@� �' 5 �#$ ��� ��@i� �.�o�.4��'� � (�� @i� ��(��!���Dk/ (���� &����`k/� = "U����� = $%4��65 4�� A��9%� � %��� �b� \k*�#&L�#$%&��] ��5!����@i�������.�!( %�2��� ��� | ����� �� &��!� | �!5#��}�� ~#� }��.�+! 8Q�.���6(+���.�08:���#� �.��%&3k>����7U%&

� \

Page 92: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

5 �#��&�%&'��� ����k/,�.�?@����<Ab%��4�&3�����#&'4����!�0�!���.&D�#8 �.��� " �D1 k/ (b�.� � �.���!�?�����6�!��@� �' 5 �#$ k/ (b�.�(��!&�5 �' @b�.%��� %� � %��� �b� \V&�����4�$%( (�� &�5!�� = �[�����[� A�� ���#$%$ = �!�+��A� ���U�#8D�����[(+���.�O��� ��%�����!��.�!��@��!�.����4����!& �

B���� ����� GDK�� I GLK �� MON0PQP����hX��

�����/��%�����!��!��� �'�#"�� $%��&�&(+���.�Lk��#&�4�&'� (0�.�j5)��� 5)798:�#�;5 ����&' & �.�!��5!"�k/,�.�0@����<Ab%��4�&�����#&'4���� ���� ���.&��#8Q�.��� " �D1 k/ (���� ������� ��� ��� "d&'@��!5!�.���]�����#&'4����!( 8:����� ���!���#"?$ �#&�&��!&L��%�����!�3�.���#�a�^mc?�!e k>� �'� ���#�'���04�&' ���V�]��%��%�0 %��o�.%��� � ��(�(�%�� �����#$ $,"��;�����dk/%(����rk*�#&0���#�0��� $%(5 �#��&'�.�#���3%�U�.���>��� | ����� � 5 �#$ 5!4�$ ���.%����&!��1�������� �!���.���j�zq�@i� 5<�.�!( &�@i� 5<�.���#$ &��+��@��!&3�#8 �.���(�����!���!�2�3�����#&'4����!( &'@��!5!�.����k>� �'�65 �#$%5 4�$ ���.�!( �

�����L5 �#$ 5!4�$ ���.%��� �#8 �����L�zq�@i� 5<�.�!( &�@i� 5!���.�#$�&��+��@��!&� ��A#��$%A#� (d&��<A�� ���#$�& �.�!@�& �������L ��%��p�#$�<qb5!%�.���.%��� � ��� ����"�����( �#���#4�$p��� ������� ����4�� ��8��.���>�24�5 $%� 4�&Qk>� �'��(��<�.� �'�� ���!(��#& (� &'5 4�&'&�� (%� | �!5#� }�� ~#� ~�� �����0k/ (b�.�s�#8*�.��� "$�D1l%�V�����-5 �#$%5 4�$ ���.%����&6k��#&��#(�� 4�& �.�!(s5 ������ �24���4�&�$,"�#$%�����O�.���[(�� 5 � "v�#&U(��!��� ����%��� ( = " �.��� �!��@� �' 5 �#$Lk/%(��.� � � %��� ��� \b�*�����[&�4�� ��4�$%�&'�����!���#�.��� | ��k���& �bq��!( �o�j~ ^�^�� �������j�'� &��#�+�#��5!�6�!��� �'�#"��+� ����� ��k*�#& ��qb� ( �o�D~-,�� ^0c?�!e���3�6���'�.� ��@���k*�#&��0�#(����.� �����.���/(+�o�)���������3����$%"98:�'� �/@+�#���#���!��� �� ���.����5 �#$%5 4�$ ���.%����&�k*�#&�.���h� A#� �.��$ $ �����'�0�#$ %��o�.%��� = �<� k*�!� � �����j5��#$%5 4�$ ���� ���?�#��(d(+���.���

�������'� &'4�$%��&��#8 �.���65��#$%5 4�$p���� �#��&������h&���� k/� %� � %���7�b� a���� ��%$ �h�.���6�#���'� �!�0�!���L%&3�����@i� �'8:�!5!� = �<� k*�!� �[5 �#$ 5!4�$ ���.%���[�#��( (+���.�����.����� A��!�.�#$%$ &'�+�#@i�6��8Q�.���h5���$ 5!4�$p�o�.%����&�%&�&�%�0%$ �#��.�L������(+���.����������� A#� �.��$ $ �#�#��� �!��� ��� ��(� 5 ���.�!&����+���Q����%&;(+���)�D%&;5 ����&�%&'�.�!���k/,�.��@��'�!A�%��4�&�����#&'4����!��� ���.&!�

�����L�����!5!�.&*�#8 4�&�%��� � = ������(]�.����������8 � ���!����%� &�8:�#�������%��,�. �#$��zqb5 ,�)���� ��� �!��� �'�#" � &��!�� %���+}�� a �* �d�.���h5��#$%5 4�$p���� �#��&�5 �#�[�#$%&�� = �h ��A#� &'�� �����.�!( ������%&�%&�@���&'&� = $%� = "?5!����&' (��!��%����.��� �� �#��� & �6�!��� �'�#"[$%��&�& � � ^`_ 3 ^Ucd�!e � ��� �.��" &'@��!5!�.�'4�� �����#&'4����!( � ��������%�����!&'�h� ���!���#"$%��&�&U&�@i� 5<�.�'4�� �+�#(v�.��� = �����#(�� &'�d���#�����[�#86� ��� ���# �!& ���#��( �#&U&�4�5)� �.���[����� 5!��&?&'����4�$%(= �-$ �#���#� &'�h8:���j�.��%&h&�@i� 5!����4��U� �����-�����!5!��&9&����#4�$ ( = �-�!A�%(�� ��� = " @i� �'8:�#���� ��� �?&'� 5!����(

� a

Page 93: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

10

102

103

104

10

102

103

104

Co

un

ts

10 15 20 25

E (MeV)g

(a)

(c)

(e)

10

102

103

104

110 15 20 25

(b)

(d)

E (MeV)g

(f)

10

102

103

10410

102

103

104

10

102

103

104

1

Co

un

ts

� %��4��'� �b� a=� �*����@+�#��%&��#��&U�#8�(����)�r�#��( �<qb@i� 5<�.� ( &�@i� 5<�.�.��$h&'�+�#@i� &d�#&U5���$ 5!4�$p�o�.� ( k/,�.���� | ����� ��������� ��� �.��"d&�@i� 5!���.� �#�'�����o�.� ( ��� �.����8:��$%$ � k/%��� �.�������9�#8Q@������ �!5!�� $%� � ���!���#"$%��&�&'� & � � � �-a�^`_�}�^tc?�!e�� � = �-}�^`_=�#^tc?�!e�� � 5 � �#^`_=,�^tcd�!e9� �:( ��,�^`_ /�^tc?�!e�� � � ��/#^ _� ^6c?�!e����#��( � 8 � � ^ _ 3 ^hc?�!e�� ! � �#$%$+@+�#���!$ &�.����(+���.�h%&&���� k/� ��&�����3&'��$% (-@���%���.&!�2k/�� $%��.���D5��#$%5 4�$ ���� ����&/�#���L&'��� k/� = "-�.���D&'��$% ( = $%4��L5!4��'A#� & � �����D5 �#$%5 4�$ ���.%����&�k>� �'�D@��!�'8:���'��� (�#&/(��!&�5 �' = � (? �U�.���j���<q����

� }

Page 94: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

0 50 100E (MeV)*

0 50 100E (MeV)*

10 15 20 25 10 15 20 25

E (MeV)g

10

102

103

104

Counts

(a) (b)

� %��4��'� �b� } ������� � ^`_ 3 ^Ucd�!e � ���!���#" $ ��&'& � � �.��" &'@��!5!����4�� %&D&���� k/�m � = �#�.�g@+�#��� $%& � ! �@+�#��� $��x� �)�������� ��%��p�#$ �<qb5 ,�)���� �#�m�!��� �'�#"[%�g����� ��� | ����� � 5���$ 5!4�$p�o�.%���[k��#&j&'�!�j�.� �.���@��'��� � 5<�.%$ �3� ���!���#"�$%��&�&>�#&&���� k/�- �0�.���� ��&�� � ���2�����35��#$%5 4�$ ���� ���- &�&'��� k/� �#&��.����&���$%%(]���!(5 4��'A���� ! �s@��#��� $ � = �)� �.���- ��%��p�#$�<qb5!%�.���.%���s�!��� �'�#"V%�V��������� | ����� � 5���$ 5!4�$p�o�.%���Vk*�#&&��<�6�#5 5!����(�%��� �.� ����� ��&�� � ��� �������'� &�4�$%�� ���d5���$ 5!4�$p�o�.� ( &�@i� 5<�.�'4�� %&h&'��� k/�V��&L�.��� &'��$ %(= $%4��j5 4�� A����

5���$ 5!4�$p�o�.%��� � k/��� �'���.���6 ��%��p�#$ �zq�5!%�.���.%��� �!��� �'�#"? &3� n24+����� ( k/,�.� ������@������ �!5!�.%$%�9� ���!���#"$%��&�&!�+���� &�5���$ 5!4�$p�o�.%���?5 �#�U�.���!� = �j5 ����@+�#�'� (dk/%���d�����j5��#$%5 4�$ ���� ���d%� � %���+��� a�8 �

�����d��� &'4�$,�-��83���� & &'� 5!����( 5 �#$%5 4�$ ���.%���r &�&'��� k/� %� � ��� �b� }���� �����U�#����� ��@+����� $�%��.�� & ����4����� &L%(��!�2�� 5 �#$ ��� � ��� �b� a�8 � ! � = ���.� 5 �#$ 5!4�$ ���.%����&�� � ��� �b� }���� = �.���.����k/ (b�.� k*�#&�#(�� 4�&'�.�!(m5!�����.%�24���4�&'$%" �#$%����� ����� (�� 5 ��" �#&D&���� k/� = " �.��� �!��@� �' 5 �#$;k/ (b�.�g �2� %������ \b���$%&������.��� �'� &'���+�#��5!��� ���!���#"?k��#& ��qb�!(V���9~-,�� ^Uc?�!e�� ����������$," (����� ���!��5 � = �!� k>� �!�m�.���5���$ 5!4�$p�o�.%����&L%&3�����9%��%��p��$ �zq�5!%�.���.%��� �!��� �'�#"?4�&��!( � &��!�9%��&��!�'�.&��#8�� %���7�b� } �)� ! � �.���65��#&'�k/���!���>������ ��%��p�#$2�!��� �'�#"Dk���& &��<� ���������@������ �!5!�� $%�>�!��� �'�#"h$ �#&�& �`,� k��#& ��� 5!� &'&.�#� "6���3�'� (�4�5!��.���>&'4�� ��4�$%�>& �.�'� ���#���68:�'��� ~ ^�^�� �.�3a�,�� ���*�#�.�h5���$ 5!4�$p�o�.%����& &'��� kt�����b(h�#���'� �!�0�!��� k/,�.�(+���.���+�#��(d��� ��5!�h�����D5)����%5 �h�#8 �.���j%��,�. �#$ �<qb5!%�.���.%��� �!��� �'�#" (�%&'���� = 4��� ����&�%� �+4�� ��5!�6�.����#@�@��#���!�2�#" �D1l&'�.�'� �����.� � = 4��6�+�#&h����$,"g�� �����6%� �+4�� ��5!� &9��� �.��� " �D1 k/ (b�.� � ����%&6%&5 �#��&�%&'��� ����k/,�.�U�.��� �+��(� ����&/�#8;1/�!8 � � a�,6�x�

����� = �����#( (� & �.�' = 4b�.%����&U4�&��!( 8:�#� �.���[%��,�. �#$L�<qb5!%�.���.%��� � ���!���#"v�zq��.� ��( ���O��4�5)�$%�`k>� ��� ���!����%� &��.�+�#�?�.���6� ���!���#"d$%��&�&'� &L5!����&�%(��!��� (�� ������@i��@�4�$p���� �#� �#8;$%� k*�!�L�<qb5!%�.���.%���� ��� ���# �!&/�#(�(�&*���9�.����&'�)�o�.%&'�.%5���$��d�.��"�& ������( (���� &�������%� �+4��!��5 �D�.���L��%���=� �!��� �'�#"��?��� "�&!�

� �

Page 95: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

�����D��%���=� � ���!���#" �?����"b&/�����L@��'� (��#�0%�+�#����$%" 8:�'��� �.���L�� ����� &'���!��� �'�� �!&�@��#@�4�$ ���.�!( ������%&���!&�4�$,�.&6 � �������0&'�.���.%&'�� 5 �#$ �O�.��"�&6�'� $ ���.,A����.�U�.���-��%���=� � ���!���#" �O����"b&!� �#��(m�����!5!��&6�.���� A��!�.�#$%$ &�4�� �'4�$%�h& �.�'� ���#��� �#&����#�.�!( � = � A����

� ,

Page 96: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

� � ������� �

� �� ����� ������ �

�����'" �D1 k*�#&�& �.4�(�%� ( = "?�����#��&3�#8;��� ��A�"�� ���[&'5����'�.�!��%��� 4�&' ��� uxw y �i����%&D�#$%$ � k>� ( 8:�#��.��� ����&'��������&�4��'� ��� ���L��8 �����>"$�D1 k/ (���� �����9��� ��@��!�.����4����6�#&/$%�`k �#&j~6c?�!e %� | ���! � �.���j@��'�!A� �#4�&/5)�+�#@���� � ������� ��� ��� "]&�@i� 5<�.�.�9k>� �'���#���#$%" %!� ( � ! � �.���D5��#&'�h��8 �����D&�@i� 5 �

�.�'4�� k/��� �'�*�.���>�.� ��@i� �����.4��'�*k*�#&Q8:��4���(6�.� = ��~�c?�<e9�o�.����@��#�.�#���<�.� �'&Q�#8+����� " �D1Ok>� �'��<q����.�#5<�.� (�� �����0@+�#���#���!��� �h�#8��0�#%�m%���.�!��� & ��k*�#&j�.����k/ (b�.� � ������k/ (b�.� �:} * ~]c?�!e ��<q����.�#5<�.� ( 8:�#����� &>�.� ��@i� �����.4��'��k*�#&�5 �#�0@��#���!(]k/%��� @����<A� ��4�&������#&'4����!�0�!���.& � � %���=�b� \ �)������U5 �#��&�%&'��� ��5<"t�#8/�.��%&�(+���)� k*�#&9����� �tA��!����+� ( = "t�#�+�#$," % %���[�.��� �� ����� ��� ���!���#"�� $ ��&'&(+���.���

����� " �D1 k/%(���� 8:�#4���( ��� �V�.� ��@i� �����.4��'� �#8�~ c?�<e %& &�%������+5����2��$%"{$ � k>� � �.���#�@��'� (�%5!��� ( �:&��!��� ��� �b� \ �#� � %���,�� \ = �.� ������(�%&�5 �'� @+����5!" ���D����%&L�.� ��@i� �����.4��'�� &j���[�.������'(�� ���#8;a-c?�<e9� ������(� ��� �'� ��5!� = �!� k>� � �?�.���!���'"d�#��( �<qb@i� �' ��� ���D%&�� &�@i� 5!p��$ $,"d&'�.�' 72%���k/���!� 5!����@+�#�' ���-�.���9@���� (� 5<�.%����&Lk/,�.� �.���9� ��@�%��%5��#$ 5 4�� A�� %� � %��� ��� \b�i����%&D ��(� 5 ���.�!&�.�����/�.���j5���$ 5!4�$p�o�.%����&��`A#� �'� &'�� �0�������.���h%� �+4�� ��5!���#8 �.���!���0�#$ &����#@�� �+4�5<�.4+�o�.%����&3���/$ � k�.�!��@��!�.����4����!& ��+4��'����� � ��&�%����� %���.�3����� = �!�+��Ab%��� �#8�������"$�D1Vk/%(��.�6�0� " = �� = �)�� ���!( = "h5 ����@+����%���

| � k/,�.�0�#�.���!�;�24�5 $%� � �����#����� �;�24�5!$ �!4�&�k/��� �'���!����4��#�-(+�o�)�D�#��( ����� ���'�!�� 5 �#$+5��#$%5 4�$p���� �#��&�<qb%&'�* &��*4 �2����%&*�24�5 $%� 4�&*�+�#&�k>���#7�&���� $%$������!5!�.& � &'� � � ��� ,�� ~ �)��� 4�& ���#&%� | � �2�����!���<8:�������

� /

Page 97: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

0 20 40 60 80 100 120 140 160 180 200

Neutron Number N

0

20

40

60

80

100

120

140

Pro

ton N

um

ber

Z

E (MeV)mic

4

0

-4

-8

� %��4��'� ,��%~�� c?%5 �'��&�5!��@�%505!�����'� 5<�.%��� �.� �����9���'��4���([& �)�����9� ���!���#" � ��� �'�0&��#8�� �#��(��6������D$ �#���#� �>�����j� = &'��$%4��.�L�0�#�#��%��4�(��D�#8 �����D5 �#�����!5!�� �����b�.���D$p�#�'��� ��.����&����!$ $ �����!5!��& �+����%&@�$%�#�� &��#(��#@��.�!(d8:�'��� 1/�!8 ��5��,�� �

�.��� &��+�#@i� �+4�5<�.4+�o�.%����& &�����4�$%( = � (��<�.� �'�� ���!( = "m�.��� @��'��@i� �'�� �!& �#83� ���#�.���.%���[$% n24�%((��'��@ � �����0(+���.�?�#��(m@��'� (�%5!�� �#��&68:���>�*4m�#����&'��� k/�s �2� %��� ,�� \�5#� ����� = � �+��A�%���6��8*�.����*4O(+���.� %&9&�%�� $ �#����� �.�+�o� �#8 | � � ����� �zq�@i� �' ���!�2�.�#$�k/%(��.�O%&9��� �#��$,"V5!����& �)�#��� 4�@s����.�!��@��!�.����4����!&6�#8�� ~ c?�<e9� �����!� ����� k/ (���� = � ��%��&D�.�U%��5 �'���#&'�#�:��&j%� ������5��#&'�0��8 | � ��.���h$%%n�4� (?(�����@U@��'� (�%5!�� �#��&�8 �� $ ���0(�� &�5!�� = �j�.���h(����)����� &�@i� 5!p��$ $,"?���/$ � k �.� ��@i� �����.4��'� &!�� �����#&'4����!�0�!���-��8������ " �D1 k/%(��.�t%�{uxw�� ��4t�+�#& ��$ &'� = � �!�t@��!�'8:���'�0�!( �5��/8� � �����

�<q����.�#5<�.� (-k/ (����-k*�#&�8:��4���(��.� = � �hc?�!e��b����(]%&�&���� k/� %��� %����,b� \�(��������3&'��$ %(]5!4��'A#��%��.�� &;�+�#4����D%&/� 5��#$%5 4�$ ���� ���U�#8 �����Lk/ (b�.�d�#&�(��<�.� �'�� ���!(d8:�'��� 1/�!8 � � a���� k/,�.�d�#�U�#���#4�$p���������� ���.4�� �#8�~8/b�.�� � | ��� $%$;����� 5!��&h�#���9k>���#7 � uxw�� ��4 � �#��( � 4�&'�6�#&D%�2�*4V����( | � � �.���@��'� (�%5!�� ����&3&' ���� �+5 �#���.$,"d�`A#� �'� &'�� �0�����h�����Dk/ (b�.� �o�/$ � k ��� ��@i� �.�o�.4��'� & �

����� = � �+��A� �#� �#8j�.��� �<qb@��!��%��� ���)�#$�(+���)�V8:�#�]�24�5 $%� 3k/��� �'�[&����!$ $L�����!5!��&U�#���?&��0�#$%$

���

Page 98: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0

Temperature (MeV)

G(M

eV)

5

10

(a)

Temperature (MeV)0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.52.0

G(M

eV)

5

10

(b)

15

10

5

G(M

eV)

0 1 2 3Temperature (MeV)

(c)

5

10

G(M

eV)

0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0Temperature (MeV)

(d)

� %��4��'� ,�� \=������� ���'�!�.%5���$�@��'� (�%5!�� ����& �#��( (+���.� 8:����� = � | � � �*4 �>�#��( �34 ��� �#���!$ � � �D_� = ��� �#��� $ � = ��_ | � ��� �#��� $ �:5 ��_ �*4���� �#���!$ �:( ��_ ��4 � �����0&���$%%(m5!4��'A#�]%�m@+����� $%& � � �)�� = �)� �#��( �:5 �> &��#�?�#(� � = �o�.%5L�.���!���0�#$ &����#@�� �+4�5<�.4+�o�.%���?5 �#$%5 4�$ ���.%��� � ! �d@+�#��� $%& � � �)� � = �)��#��( �:5 �j�.��� = $p��5)7s5 %��5!$ �!&-����(t�����!� �t(� �#������(�&0�#�'� 8:����� 1��<8 � � a����x�Q����� = $ �#5)7s5! �'5 $%� &�#�'�?8:���#� ���!$p��&'�.%5 &'5����'�.� �' ���s�����#&'4����!�0�!���.& ��k/��� ��� �#&]����� ���'� �!�{(� �#������(�& �����U8:�����8:4�&' ��� � �!A��#@i�������.%���0�0� �#&�4���� ���!�2��& �b����� = $%4��/�.�'p�#����$ �!&*������8:�����l1��<8 ��� \�\��x�2�#��(0�.���/&'��$ %(���!( 5 %��5!$ � %&38:�'��� �.��%&�k>����7 �������9�����#�����6��� 5<�)�#����$ �� � @��#��� $%& � � �/�#��( � = �� &��.�����.�#���#��#83k/ (�����&]��� �#&�4��'� (r8:��� �.���d�����#4���(r&'�)�o�.�UA#��$ 4���� ! � @+�#��� $%& �:5 �9�#��( � ( �6�.���U���'��4���( �&'�.���.�hk/ (b�.� %&���,A��!� = "U�.���65 4�� A�� ����� ( ^]c?�!e���������&���$% (?5 4�� A��9%� @+����� $ � ( ��%&3�.���5���$ 5!4�$p�o�.� (dk/ (b�.�U8:����� ��n2� � }��%~�}��������6(����)� @i�� ���/%�d����%&3@+����� $ %&�8:����� 1��<8 �:�5��/8� �

� | � � �*4 � �#��( ��4 �*%&��#&/@����!(�%5!�.�!( 8:�����24�5!$ �! k/��� ���h&���� $%$ �����!5!��&��#�'�j$p�#�'������� = �.� ���� &/%&�!A�%(�� ��� = "j�zq��#�� �+�o�.%�����#8�� %���8,�� \b� ! �6�����5��#&'�>�#8�� = � �.����" �D1mk/ (b�.��%& @����!(�%5!�.�!(��.� = �&�4�@�@����!&�&'� ( �'� $ ���.,A��j�.��$% n24�%( (��'��@U@����!(�%5!�.%����&!� ���� &�&�4�@�@����!&�&' ��� &����'�.�� = 4���� (U�.��&���� $%$����� 5<�.&!� � �� $%�3,� &�5!$ � �#�;�.�+���&'��� $%$ ����� 5!��&>$%%�0,�&��+��@�� �+4�5<�.4+���� �#��&*�o��$ � k{��� ��@��!�.����4����!&%��� = ��%�%&*���#�>5 $%��������+����.���!&��������!5!��&��#�'�3�'� &�@i����&' = $ ��8:�#��������&�4�@�@���� &'&�%��� �#8 ����� "$�D1

��3

Page 99: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

5

10

G(M

eV)

0.0 0.5 1.0 1.5 2.0 2.5Temperature (MeV)

� %��4��'� ,b� a � �*����@+�#��%&��#� �#8 | �](+�o�)�h�#��(0�0%5 �'��&�5!��@�%5�����(�� $+@��'� (�%5!�� �#��& ��������&���$% ( = $%4��5 4��'A��?&���� k/&0�.���d@����!(�%5!�.�!( " �D1 k/ (����{�#&0(��<�.� �'�� ���!( 8:���#� �.���d�� 5!����&'5 ��@� 5 ����(�� $(�%&�5!4�&�&'� ( %�d�����D�.�zqb� �+�����h(+���)� %&��#&/ �)� %��� ,�� \ = �

k/%(��.� �=! �]8 �#5<�����.���3 ����� ��@����!�.���.%��� ���+���>&����!$ $������ 5!��&��#�'�����!&�@i����&' = $%��8:����.���3&�4�@�@����!&�&�%����#8 �.���>" �D1 k/%(��.�? � � = �o�/$ � k ��� ��@i� �.�o�.4��'� &��+�#&��.� = �hn24��!&'�� ����� ( �

����� &�4�@�@����!&�&' ���m�#8;�.���'"$�D1Jk/%(��.� ���D$%� k �.� ��@i� �����.4��'� &j%&L�!A�%(�� ���h � �����9�zq�@i� � �%�0�!���)�#$(+���.�U8:���6�#$%$���4�5 $%� (� &'5 4�&'&��!(r��� ��� � | � � �*4��:�34 � �#��( � = �)�:! �m�.���-5 �#&��-�#8 | � ��*4 �+����( ��4 ��&����!$ $ �����!5!�.&/�����Lk>���#7 � �L�!&�@�,�.�L���� &�8 ��5!���b�.��� = � ��� A�%�����#8 �.���$"$�D1vk/ (b�.�%&6��&D@����!(� 5<�.�!(m8:���D�24�5!$ �!�k/,�.�g& �.���#���?&'��� $%$;����� 5<�.&!�:! �h��@�@�� �#��&D���+���D�.��� " �D1 k/,�.�g%&&�4�@�@����!&�&'� ( �o��$ � k �.�!�0@i� �����.4���� &/�'� ���#�'(�$%� &�&/�#8 k/���<�.���!��&����!$ $ �����!5!��&3�����L@��'� &'� �����#8 ���#���

�����j�.���!���0�#$ &��+��@�� �+4�5<�.4+�o�.%��� 5 �#$ 5!4�$ ���.%����&���� �#$ �!5!�3@+�#%��%���-�����!5!��& � � �#%��%���-����� 5!��&�#�'�d@���� (� 5<�.� (r�.� = �d4��� ��@i���'�.�#���-��� �.���U�!��� �'�� �!&-�zqb@�$ �#��� ( �t�.�� &��<qb@i� �' ��� ��� � ! ��%&�.����4������L���+���L@��# �' ��� ����� 5!��&j�#��������$," %��@���� �)�#���L8:�#�3A��!�'" $ � k � ���!����%� &!� | �.%$%$x��%�Lk>��4�$%(= �h%���.�!��� & �.%���-�����+��A��6��5 �#$%5 4�$ ���.%���dk/��� �'�h@��# �' ���0k*�#&/ ��5 $%4�(�� (���������.���!�]���'�.�!�0@b�0���g@����!(� 5<�-�����)"$�D1 k/ (b�.� %& = �#&'� ( �#�t�����d ���.�!��@�$ ��" = �<� k*�!� �

����� � = �b(b"�� �#��(��#4v(+�#��@�%���t�#��({� k>�6� = ��(�" 5 ��$%$ %&�%���+��$L(+�#��@�%���O�#8j�24�5!$ �!����&2� \�/b� a�\�� ������h@����!(�%5!�.�!( k/%(��.�d8:����� ����%&������ ��� "U &/&'��� k/� �)� %���+,�� a�� �#$%������k/%���d�����h(+���)�b�+�����5���$ 5!4�$p�o�.%���?k*�#&�&���,8 �.�!( &�4�5)�?�.�+���/�����6�#����4���(?& �)�����hA��#$%4�� � � ( ^-c?�<e �>8:�����.���jk/ (b�.�k*�#&�a�� � cd�!e9�=���*$%� kv�.�!�0@i� �����.4���� & � ���J~Dcd�!e �.������%&>�.��� ��� "-(�� &�5!�� = �!&��<qb%&'�� ��� (����)������ k>�!A��!� � �.���h�#�#��� �!��� ���L�o�/�� �#��� ���.�!��@��!�.����4����!& �:��� ~6c?�!e ��%&/@������ �

3 ^

Page 100: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

! �D%&L5 $%���#�L���+���3�.���9�zqb & �.%��� �.���!����%� &L��� (�� &'5 �� = �9�.���'" �D1Jk/ (����g�#�������#�LA#� �'" ���6�= 4�& ���! �g8 �#5!� � = �#&'� ( ���[�.����$ �#5)7[�#8*�#�����!� ��� ��� = �!� k>� � �m�.���!���'"g����(m(����)����%�j%&D8 �# �L���&.��"[���+���D�.���0�<A���$%4��� ���m�#8�.��� "$�D1 k/ (b�.�mk/,�.�g�.�!��@��!�.����4����0 &j�����Dk*�!$ $�4���(�� ��& �.���b(���������� &>@��# �����b������������� �#���!�� 5 �#$�k>���'7-%&����!� (��!( ��! 8 �.���L�#(� � = �o�.%5��.���!���0�#$�&��+�#@i� �+4�5!�.4 ����� ���[����(�� $ &L��� = �94�&'� ( � �����9k*� " �[k/��%5)� ����� &����#@��!&j�#��� (��!�.�!����%��� ( ��� �!(�&j�.� = ����!5 ����&�%(�� �'� ( � � ��&'&� = $,"?�����'�D����� 5<�.&�5 ��4�$%( = �D%��5 $%4�(��!( �

3 ~

Page 101: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

� ��� � ����� � � ���

� ~ � "�� �>� �>� �'��&�5)� �{e� = �.���� ����&]�#83�.��� ���.����%5?�24�5!$ �!4�& ����� � ���� ������ �������� +�Q@+�#���!&,�\ _ /�a��+c ��"[~ 3�� a��

� \�� | � | � �L%�!�.�' 5)�g����( ��� �;� �*� �'�-��� � ���.$ �#&L�#8�@����#�.����� 4��������g5 �'��&�&D&'� 5<�.%���[� = �.�# ��� (k/%�����0�#���b�!��� �'���!�� 5�@����#�.�#��& ������� �!���"�!�� #%$�&' �(� �!�����*)��,+ � .-<�0/'1 � ~ 3�3 _ba�a � �b~ 3���� �

� a6�!2D4��'� �6� | ��� A��!� �"D �#���>�'� &'���+�#��5!� & �0�<qb5!%��� (]�24�5!$ �!x�3�� � �&4� 5 �67�'$�&' �(��8������"�������p�/'9�.��} ��_=,�^�a���~ 3�� ,;:

� }��>�<:�1>=�?@=#72��A%&��4B4=�B:DC����� ��E�%�GF�H�� I5 .-JH7 �� K ��L NM��PORQ �TSVUXW;��L� �# ZYZ[\8<+�$�&' � ��L:��^] �_ ]4`ba�A(a ��ccA%5.]4A(d,=�B | _ = _ ` �DB4A,A0`be�a�A _Zf � ~ 3�3 �;:

� ���!g!: | _ `\A(B�kh`bi4`\j�=�B4ickl:'g!: k�`bB4a�`bB:ImE�n$%����&o�qprH7�s-J.Q�� t'u � }�~ a�� ~ 3 �#^l:� ,6� �v:��w:�c f `\exa �6�v:�kl: | kIAy= _ `\z.{|A ��}~:R2~�;i�=R?�=b� �^:�kl:��^j ��k0=�A(z.{ �0=�Bli#�<:��%:RgDA(j(��:=��e��0�lj�` _

?��;i4`bj��� _ ]4`%d0A�=�B _ i4A(���0j(`%e�`ba��0B�=RB4z\`R:I8�QoSJ-\��5 �67���Q�n�;t � \#^�a�\�_�\#^#}�ab��~ 3 /�/;:� /���c�:="%��j�i4]4=���`beh=RB4i��<:o}E`bj�j(`\eb: y�B�Bo�lz\j(`r=�e�ilA�� �0j(`>�oA(�4es= _ A���B4a\:X8�QoS�-\�K5 �67�p�4�l� �%~ ^#}�, _

~ ^#} 3 ��~ 3 } � :� � ��}~: �^B4d0`bjy=RB4i �^kl:��>`b{|a _ =Ri �^=�B4i�kl: | : e�=�=�d0`\BK:���H�� � .����L6� @8�Q � KH7� � ���L ����ZH7����

$�&� � ��L: ���0e�j(i | z\A(`\B _ A���z#� ~ 3#� }4:� 3 � ��:+y�exjy=�Bli4A�BlAx��eV:��w: �^�qex�0a �4=�B4i��v: �3`\A(i4`b?�=RB4B: ���4j(j f ?�A�zbe��0axz\�0�4A(z%zr=�j(z\�ljy= _ A���B4a<���

d0A�=�B _ e�`\ax�0B�=�Blz\`\aDA�BN�q`<k;�Z� �;i f a f a _ `\?�a\:I$�&� �(��8�QoS�-\�3�D� 94�K� � \b~rz)_�\�}0z�� ~ 3�3�3 :� ~ ^6�>�w:>e�ex` _ `bB�=�e!� �E:I�IA�Bld�� "�:;�V: ��=Rjy=�%bA�axa�A(a �I=�Bli ��: ��=0=Re\:��I`\j�= _ A(�oA(a _ A(z�?�`r=�B=� ��`\j(i

i4`\axz\exA�� _ A���B��R� _ ]4`Ni f B�=R?@A(z\a����Id�Ay=�B _ ex`\ax�0B�=�B4zb`\ab: $�&' �(��8�QoS�-\���j�X9���� � \ 3 zz_�a�,�z#�~ 3�3�3 :

� ~�~ �>�w:���e�=�{�`�� | : �^: �¡]4` _ a _ �0B4`��I=�B4i !.:�gD=�j(��`be�B: | � `\z _ e�=�����]4A�d�]=�Z`bB4`\exd f �l]4� _ ��B4a`\?�A _�_ `bi¢�qe��0? _ ]4`£z\��?@� �0�4Bli¤a f a _ `b? ¥"¦b§KB¢A(B¢�R=�e�A(�0�4a�Bo�lz\j(`r=�e¨ex`r=�z _ A(�0B4ab:©8�QoSJ-\�ª ������ �/�'/'u � a�} 3 _ba���^���~ 3 /#^l:

� ~`\��>�w:���e�=�{�`�� | : �^:��¡]4` _ a _ �0B4`��;=RB4i'!.:,g�=�j(� `\e�BK:�}<]4`Ie�=�i4A�= _ AP�0`Izr=R� _ �4ex`I������=Ra _ �4ex� _ �0Bla� f ?�`\i4A(�4?#�Z?@=�axaDB|�4zbj�`bA�:<$�&� �(�E8�QoS�-\��D� u�« /� \���/�_�\�/ 3 ��~ 3 /#al:

� ~ a6�>�h: | : ��A(` _ e�A(z.] �Ekl::��: �he�� kIB4`���v:�kl: y�¬.�h�0B4Bl`\j(jx��=�B4iVc�:�kl:n2%= f : | � `\z _ e��4?­�R���es= f a�A�B _ ]4` � � _ � \#^��"?@`��®e�=�B4d0`¨�qex�0? Z¯ ���Dax����B _ =�B4`b�0�4a ��a�axA���B:�8�QoSJ-\�<5 �67���Q��|« �./ 3 ��_ � ^�\b��~ 3 /�}l:

3 \

Page 102: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

� ~�}��Vkl:�kl:�"�=0=Re�i4]�����`#� ��:���j(j(`\d,=0=Re�i � ��:�gD`be�ax{oA(B4i �'=RB4i | :+"�: | _ `r=Ri4?@=�B: �>�4z\j(`r=�e<ax]�=�� `= _ ]4A(d0]*a��4A(B�=RB4ic`zq;z\A _ = _ A��0B*`\Bl`\e�d f :<8�QoSJ-\�n5 �67��ª ������p� t'/ � ~�} � _i~8�b~#��~ 3�� }4:

� ~8���Vkl:;kl: "%=0=�exi4]�����`��=��:=�^j(j�`bd,=0=�exi � ��:ogD`\exa�{|A(B4i �4�%:bc�: ��Ay=R?@��B4i �bc�: �V: ��`\j(`\�4j�=�B�n|�4`��"�: ��A�B4`ba �8�V:oyw:oc�=Rz\z.]4A�=r�0`\j(j(Ax��=�B4i>�h: | : | _ `\�4]l`\B4ab:�"%=�?�?@=Iil`\zr= f ���;A�ax�J�0`\z _ �0eEd0A�=�B _e�`ba��0B�=RB4z\`baE�4�lA�j _ ��B!]4A(d0]4j f `zqlzbA _ `\iwa _ = _ `\a�A�B u u u | B:l8�QoSJ-\�;5 �67�;ª ����"�p�Rt'9 � ~8/ � a`_i~8/ � ,��~ 3�� ,;:

� ~-,6�>�w:o��:��h]�=�{|es=��4=�e _Zf � | : | `\B ��c�:l}<]l�;`bB4B4`\axa�`bB � �!:=��j�=�?@=�B4�0a!� �E:���=��ljx�l��: | z.]4A(z.{�`be �kl: | _ =Rz.]4`\j �K=RB4i£kl:�kl: "%=0=�exi4]�����`R: "~Ay=�B _ e�`ba��0B4=�B4z\`ba�A(B�`zqlzbA _ `\i | BcA(a�� _ �0� `\a\:>8�QoSJ-\�5 �67�h�Q�'/'9 � ~ �#� ,`_i~ ��3 �b��~ 3�� /;:

� ~8/��$�V: �he�=�z\zb���Ekl:�kl:�"%=0=�exi4]�����`���V: c�: �he��4zb`#��kl::�w: "%=�exe�` _x_ � ��:�g>`\e�ax{|A�B4i��;c�:��^A�d��B�=�B4`bj�j(A � �w: �h=�e�B��`b�0�4i �>g�: �>A(�q`bB4`\z.{R`\e!�~kl: �V: �^A(B4a _ �0B � ��:D�IA(a _ ��e�A � ��: | z.]|�4a�axj�`be �kl: ��=�zb`\j�=�e �n=RB4i®g�:ngD���q?@=�BlB: | = _ �4es= _ A���B �R� _ ]4` kIA�i _ ]��R� _ ]l`�d0Ay=RB _ i4A(� �0j�`�ex`\a����B�=�B4zb`�= _ ]4A(d0] _ `\?�� `\es= _ �4ex`�:�8�QoS�-\��5 �67��ª ������p� 9'u � \#^ � ^`_�\#^ � a���~ 3���3 :

� ~ � � "�:+�^B4il`\e�a!����:7�w: ��`\e�d���2�: g�=Rd0`\j � �v:�2���4]4B���ew:�cc` _ =�d�� �%: �>�J�0� _ B f � c : �X�q`bA ��`\e!�yw: | z.]�kh=�j(� �n��:kl:�h]�=Re�A _Zf � �!:"~�0�4�4A ��%: ��e�`bA(�q`bj�il`\e � �v:g>`\B4B4A(B4d��2�:��w:Kg>A�j(i4`bB=��4es=RB4i �R��:RgD�0j %\?@=�BlB �0�%: | :�c�= f `\e ����: | : | A(?@��B �,kl: �E:8�®`ba�ax`\j(a � "�:���=Ra�A(B4Ax�6�V:�y~j(?�Ax�=�B4i �V: �V: | _ `b��=�BlA�B4A�: � q;z\A _ = _ A��0B �Z`\Bl`\e�d f il`\� `\B4i4`bB4z\`���� _ ]l`Dd0A�=�B _ i4A(���0j(`�ex`\ax�0B�=�B4zb`kIA�i _ ]:�8�QoS�-\��5 �67�nª ����"�p� 9'� � \�} 3 _�\���\b� ~ 3�3 \;:

� ~ 3 �$!.::��A���a %\`bd0Ax�:�w:Ekl:�gD���q?@=�B�� ��:��E: cc�0B _ � f =�� | : | z.]�=�i4?@=�Bli �X=�Bli �E:���=R�4j�: "~A�=�B _i4A(���0j(`<e�`ba��0B4=�B4z\`>i4`bzr= f �qe��0? �q�4a�A(�0B=� ��a�axA���B¨=�B4i0n|��=�axA ��axa�A(�0B��R�K]4� _^_ ]4�0exA��l?�B|�4z\j(`\A�:8�QoS�-\�n5 �67���Q�4��9 �5,�\�/ _=,#a�,���~ 3�3 \;:

� \#^6�$�V: �hes=Rz\z\�����h: ��=�?�`\e�=��+c�:�c�= _x_ A(��% %bAx� ��:+ccA(j(j�A(�0B ��c�: �^A(d0B�=�B4`bj�j(A ��kl:�kl:�"�=�=�e�i4]�����`#��V: cc= �<�n}~:n�D=�?�a�� f �3}~:n}��0` _ `be ��=�B4i®§�: �§K`\j�=�%\B f : !ZBlz\e�`\=�a�`�A�BgkIA(i _ ] ��� _ ]4`�d0A�=�B _i4A(���0j(`�ex`\a���B�=�B4zb`~A�B¨]l� _ B|�4z\j(`\A � | ]4=���`�z.]�=�B4d0`~��ehz\��j�j(A�axA���B�=�ji�=R?@�lA�B4d�8�QoSJ-\�35 �67�ª ������p�K�;�:� a�/�} � _ba�/���~���~ 3�3 �;:

� \b~ ��c�:�c�= _�_ A�� % %\A ���!: ��es=�zbz\�����h: ��=R?@`bes=��+�v: �<:�y�e�?@=�B4i �Kkl:3kl:�"%=0=�e�il]�����`#�+�!: c�= �<���:�ccA(j�j(A(�0B �bc�: �^A�d�B�=�B4`bj�j(Ax�o=�Bli�}~:|}��0` _ `be\:��Bld0�4j�=�e�?@��?@`bB _ �4? i4`b��`bB4i4`bB4z\`��R� _ ]l`d0i4e�kIA(i _ ]�A(B�a�B Bo�lz\j(`\A�= _ ��q;`bi�`zqlzbA _ = _ A(�0B `\B4`be�d f :�$�&' �(��8�QoSJ-\�X�D�n93�;u � \�,�\ _b\�/ � �~ 3�3 /o:

� \�\���c�: �E:|2~`\j(j f �;2�:��!: | B4�J�0`be �lkl: ��: | :,��=RB | z.]4=�d0`\B���c�:o2~A(z\A��Bla�{7=���gD=��4A(�0e �|=RB4iN§�:,}�e % �B�=�i4`bj�:�"~Ay=RB _ i4A(����j�`De�`\ax�0B�=�Blz\`�A(B¨]4A(d0]4j f `<q;z\A _ `biNBo�lz\j(`\A � ���;`ba _ ]4`3kIA(i _ ]Nas= _ �4es= _ `�8�QoS�-\�n5 �67��ª ����"�p� 1'u � a�}�^#}o_ba�}�^�/b��~ 3�3�3 :

� \#a6�Vkl:3�%: �h`\`bB4`#�:�h: �I: ��`\e _ es=�Bli � c�: �^:3g�=Rj�� `\e _ �n�%: �^: ���4�lj�`����w:��:3gD`bB4a�j(` f � �w:nkl:gD�0ex`\B �0��: �^:,�I�0�4A(B4ax�0B �|�%:2yw: | = f `be �o=�B4i�}~: �E: | ���0e�`b`\B:�gD`\=r� f �"A��0B�`<q;z\A _ = _ A(�0B�=RB4i�4]4� _ �0B i4`\z\= f ����d�Ay=�B _ e�`ba��0B4=�B4z\`baDA(B ZYZ[ ���K:<8�QoSJ-\��5 �67�h�Q� /'��%~ a�^�/ _i~ a�~ 3 ��~ 3���3 :

� \�}���c�:|}<]4�o`\B4B4`ba�ax`\B �'kl:;�%: ��`\`\Bl`#����:=�<: �h`\e _ e�=�B4i �=�w:;kl:;g>�0e�`bB ��c�:��^:og�=Rj�� `\e _ �=�w: ��:gD`bB4a�j(` f �0kl:��<: �nA(as=RB _x_ A �-�v:#c*A _x_ A(d��� �: | z.]|� _ %�� ��:8��j�=�?@=�B4�0a!�6��:��D�4d0`be �Rkl:���=�e�ex` _x_ `#���:���`\e�B4=�B4i4` %#���V:�"%A(j�j(A(��`be _ ����:Rg�=�=�a �Rkl: �E:`e�AP�;A(`\B���=�Bli#�V:�c�:���= _ ]�=�B:;gDA(d0]=�"`\B4`be�d f

3 a

Page 103: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

_ =�exd0` _ `<q;zbA _ = _ A(�0B4a�A(B£]4`\=r� f A���B�A(B4`\j�=�a _ A�zVa�zr= _�_ `be�A(B4d4:%8�QoSJ-\��5 �67�I�Q�'��/� �j~`\ _;�j~8�b�~ 3�3 ~�:

� \����>�<:3�D=R?�=R{oexA�ax]4B�=�B��3}~: ��=��4?@=�BlB ��V: � %\]�=Re�A �3��:��V:32~e f d0`be �n�%: �X��=�� � c�:3}<]4�o`\B �B4`\axa�`bB � | : ��0{�� f =R?�=b�|kl:0�%: ��`\`\Bl`#�2c�: �^:�gD=�j�� `\e _ � �E:��<:�cc�4`\j(j(`\e ���w:��v: | _ e�=�z\`bB4`\e!���: �^:�e�=�exB4`\e!�|��:;kl:=�h]�=�exA _Zf �lkl: �h: ��`b?@�la�` f � �w: "�: | =�e�=�B _ A _ `ba �;=�B4i �^: "�: | �0� � _ {7=l:"%A�=�B _ i4A(� �0j�`�ex`\a���B�=�B4zb`@�l�4A�j _ �0B�]4A(d0]4j f `<q;zbA _ `\i®a _ = _ `\a%��� u ZY | B�B|�4z\j(`\A�� �0�4�4j�= _ `bi� f A�Bl`\j�=�a _ A�z �®a�z\= _�_ `\e�A(B4d4:�8�QoSJ-\��5 �67��ª ����"�p�K�49 � \#^�\�� _b\#^�\ � ��~ 3�3 ,;:

� \�,6�>�<:E�>=�?@=�{|e�A(a�]lB�=�B � �V: � %\]�=�exAx�Ekl:��%: ��`\`\Bl`#�E��:�kl:��h]�=�exA _Zf �Qc : �^:ngD=�j�� `\e _ ���E::�h:gD��=b����: �!:�2~e f d0`\e!� �E: �<:cc�4`bj�j(`\e!�h�%: �X��=�� � �w:�"�: | =�es=�B _ A _ `\a � �^:�"�: | �0� � _ {7=��c�: }<]4�;`bB4B4`ba�a�`bB �:"�:ie�=�B �h�4e�`bB ��%: ��: e�=�exB4`\e!�=�B4i | : ���{�� f =�?@=l:~}�`\?�� `\e�= _ �4ex`i4`\� `\Bli4`\B4zb`<��� _ ]l`hd0A�=�B _ i4A(����j�`�e�`\ax�0B�=�Blz\`�kIA(i _ ]�A(B#ZYZ[ �^�:�8�QoSJ-\��ª ��������/��/'1'/� \���\�_\���/b��~ 3�3 ,;:

� \�/���}~: ��=��4?@=�B4B�� �<:��D=R?�=R{oexA�ax]4B�=�B�� �!:�� %\]�=Re�A �hkl:��%: �h`\`bB4`#����:�kl: �h]�=�exA _Zf ��kl:��h:��`\?��4ax` f ��c�: ��:;g�=Rj�� `\e _ � �E:=�h:ogD��=��;�%:=�!:;2~e f d�`\e ���E:=�<:�cc�l`\j(j�`be �4�%: �X��=�� �=�w:="�:| =�e�=�B _ A _ `\a!� ��: "�: | �0� � _ {7=�� �w: �v: | _ e�=�z\`bB4`\e!��c :�}<]l�;`bB4B4`\axa�`bB � "�:Qe�=�B �h�le�`\B����: �^:�e�=�e�B4`be �<=RB4i | :� ��0{R� f =�?@=l: �X�0�0j(� _ A��0B ��� _ ]4`�d0A�=�B _ i4A(����j�` ex`\a���B�=�B4zb`�A(B`<q;z\A _ `bi u ZY.a�B¤=�B4i ZYZ[.�4��B|�4zbj�`bA�� �0�4�4j�= _ `bi¡� f A�Bl`\j�=�a _ A�z�=�j(�4]�=�axzr= _x_ `be�A(B4d4:�$�&� �(�8�QoS�-\��D� 9'/'t� }2\ � _�}�} �b��~ 3�3�� :

� \ � �$�V: | ?�`\e %\A � �V: �h�0B4Bla�`\e�=��X=RB4itc�: ��A�}��0e��l: �~=�?��4A(B4d£����d0Ay=RB _ e�`\ax�0B�=�Blz\`\a�A(B�]4� _B|�4z\j(`\A�:�8�QoSJ-\��5 �67���Q�4�'� � ~8/�~ a`_i~8/�~-,���~ 3�3 ~0:

� \ 3 �$�V: �^:�"%�o�;il?�=RB: | _ = _ A(a _ A�z\=�ja�]4=���` ���lz _ �4= _ A(�0B4aIA(B u ¥Z¥ �^eb:�8�QoS�-\�n5 �67�h�Q��/K�7� \b~-,�\�_\b~-, 3 ��~ 3��#� :

� a�^6�Vkl: kl:7"�=0=Re�i4]�����`�: �D�4zbj�`\=�eDa _ ex�4z _ �4e�`V= _ ]4A�d�]c`zqlzbA _ = _ A(�0B£`bB4`\exd f a _ �4i4A(`\i kIA _ ]cd0A�=�B _e�`ba��0B�=RB4z\`ba\:h�� � �&4�n5 �67��$�&' �(��8��������E�����p�4��u� } � a _ �#a�,���~ 3�3 \o:

� a�~ � �v: �<: y~ex?@=�B4i � ��:���: �h�0e _ A(d0B4�0B �n�%:�V: ��e��0d0j(A�=��}~::� ��a�axA�Bld��n=�B4i ��: �n=��4exA _ %\`\BK:}<A�?�` �Zi4`b��`bB4i4`\B _�_ ]l`\e�?@=�j ���4z _ ��= _ A���B4a�=�B4i _ ]4`¨d0A�=�B _ e�`ba��0B4=�B4z\`NA(B ]4� _ ��ex� _ = _ A�BldB|�4z\j(`\A�:�8�QoSJ-\��5 �67��ª ������p� 94�:� \�\��o}o_�\�\���/b��~ 3�3 ^l:

� a�\��jew: ��=�e�=�B �]c�: �h�0j(�0B4B4=�� c :���A(}E�0ex��� �V: "%��=Re�B4`bes=���ew: �!:�2%��B4i4es= _Zf `b�i�N=RB4i�V: | ?�`\e %bA�: }<]4` ?@=�B f ��=Rz\` _ aN���%d0A�=�B _ e�`ba��0B4=�B4z\`ba*= _ ]4A(d0]�`<q;zbA _ = _ A(�0B¡`\B4`be�d0A(`\ab:$�&� �(��8�QoS�-\�3�D� t'�'�� \ 3 z)_�} � z�� ~ 3�3 ,l:

� a�a6� �v: �<: y~ex?@=�B4i � ��: �h: �h�0e _ A(d0B4�0B��n=�B4i ��:�!: �he���d0j�A�=l:�}�`\?�� `\es= _ �4ex`�i4`b��`bB4i�=�Blz\`��� _ ]4`jkIA�i _ ]���� _ ]4`!d0A�=�B _ ilA�� �0j(`!ex`\a���B�=�B4zb`VA(B u ZY | B�=�B4i ZYZ[ �^�:>8�QoSJ-\�E5 �67��ª: ������p��'���5,�^�/�_=,�~ ^���~ 3�3 ,;:

� a#}�� �v: �<:�y~ex?@=�B4i � ��:+�h: �h�0e _ A(d0B4�0B�����: �!: �he���d0j�A�=���=RB4i)�!: �hes=Rz\z\�l: ��`\]�=r�oA���e>�R� _ ]l`d0A�=�B _ �ZilA�� �0j(`�e�`ba��0B4=�B4z\`~A(B u ZY | B =�Bli ZYZ[ ��� = _ ]4A(d0]N`<q;z\A _ = _ A(�0BN`\B4`be�d f :�$�&' �(�8�QoSJ-\��j� 93�,� � \�~8/ _�\#a�/b��~ 3�3 /;:

3 }

Page 104: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

� a����>�w:^2~�4a�Bl` %\�J�i� �: ��j(]�=�axa�A(i ��=�B4i 2�: �V: | B4�J��`\e\: | zr=Rj�A(B4d �4e��0� `\e _ A(`\a@��� _ ]4` d0A�=�B _i4A(���0j(`£ex`\a���B�=�B4zb` kIA�i _ ]¡A�B�]4� _ e�� _ = _ A(B4d B|�4zbj�`bA�: 8�QoS�-\��5 �67��ª ����"�p��1n� �.��}2\ _=��} �b�~ 3�3�� :

� a�,6� "�:�e�A(`\a _ A � c�: �3�4B�=Re�i4�0B�� �w:��'=��4exA�a!�+"�: �D`b�4�4A�=�� c�: �hA�B�=R�4a�`be����+�<: ��A(�0ex` _�_ �����w:l��:��=�� �0j(Ax� "�: �^e�` _ `#�X2�:�g�=�d�`\j �^kl: �D: ��= _ � kIA _ %#�X�%:��®=�i�=b� �E: "%�0B _ ]4A�`be �X§�:;c�= ��{7=����::��jP��=�exe���� �:X§K]�=���� ��:Qccil`\A,k�= f `b] ��=�B4i�}~:�gD�4: �^B4`\exd f il`\� �0a�A _ A(�0B =�B4i "$�~�`\?�A(a�a�A(�0B�A(B _ ]4`�e�`\=�z _ A��0B ZY � ��A � �� � � �3= _ \o}�^Lcc`<ew:�$�&� �(�'8�QoS�-\�;�j��9't u �%~8/ _ba#a��b~ 3�3�3 :

� a�/��>�w:��'=��4exA�a!� "�: �>`\�4�4A�=�� "�:be�A�`ba _ A � c�: �n�lB�=�e�il�0B � c�: �hA�B�=R�4a�`be����+�<: ��A(�0ex` _�_ �����w:l��:��=�� �0j(Ax� "�: �^e�` _ `#�X2�:�g�=�d�`\j �^kl: �D: ��= _ � kIA _ %#�X�%:��®=�i�=b� �E: "%�0B _ ]4A�`be �X§�:;c�= ��{7=����: �Dj(��=Re�e���� �:�§K]�=���� ��:cci4`bA%kh= f `\]��<=�B4i }~:�g>�4: �^B4`be�d f il`\� �0a�A _ A(�0B¢A(B � �� � � �e�`\=�z _ A��0BlaD= _ ,�^0cc`b� ��� u :��o��8�QoSJ-\��C�� u / �%~ a�/�/�_i~ a � \���~ 3�3 /;:

� a � ��c�: �n=r�R=�j ��c�:�cc�0a % f �B4a�{|A �'��: ��j(j�`b?@=�B4i � �<:��h�0e�?��0ex`\z.]4`�� �E: "%�4A(B4` _ �4�%:+y�i4ex� �4=RB4ikl:Qe�=�z.]4`be\: �h=�e�A(�4? ���l�0e�A(i4` _ A(B4�0exd,=�B4A(z a�z\A(B _ A(j�j�= _ �0e��q�0e�ax�4�4B�=RB4�0a�`bz\�0Bli _ A(?@A(B4d4:$�&� �(���. l-����b�X�� #�� ��qQl�p� u�« 9 � ~ , 3 _i~8/6,�� ~ 3�� al:

� a 3 � "%j(`\BlB ��:X2~B4�0j(j�: 5��,#���������H7  �# �� .�����H7 �� #� ��7-�&;� �� � ���: k��0]4B �¡A(j�` f� | �0B4a!�!ZB4z�:%� a�exi*`bi4A _ A(�0B ��\#^�^�^;:

� }�^6�>�<:okl:,}Ee f d�d0`\a _ =�i:�ª�H ����ªES7�L |O!�%�GF�H�� <�'��� � |O0�qQ��L ZY���: ��]�� _ ]l`\a�A(a ��ccA(z.]4A(d,=�B | _ = _ `�DB4AP�0`be�axA _Zf � \#^#^�~0:

� }�~ �Vkl: ��4ex{��0B�� �w: ��=�%bA�B�� �v: �h`\Bl`\B4ax�0B � �w:^kl:;cc�0e�exA�axa�` f � ��:�c�: | ]4`\exe�A(j�j � �w: | k�=�B��=�B4i���: | kh=�B4ax�0B::���;z\=�j��4j�=�B4`�il` _ `bz _ �0e��q�0e _ ]l`�a � ^�^!]4A(d0]=�"e�`ba��0j(� _ A(�0B�a�� `\z _ e��0?�` _ `\eb:$�&� �(���. l-����b�X�� #�� ��qQl�n�D����u u � \ 3 ~<_b\ 3 �b��~ 3�3�3 :

� }2\��Vkl:��!:��=�d0d�Ay=�Bl�4:��0F .����sHJ-J.H.F S�H�p� xW;H7����� �&� � ����^�L�LQ �LQ w�������@-ZF .����.HxO��x��F�Qo: �^] �_ ]4`ba�A(a ��ccA(z.]4A(d,=�B | _ = _ ` �DB4AP�0`be�a�A _Zf � ~ 3�3�3 :

� }�a6��c�: �h`be %��n2�:k��0] �nkl:��V: �>�0j�`bB � ��: c : | ]4`be�e�A(j(jx�n=�Bli �!:�h:n§K`bj�j(`\eb:w�I`\zb�0B4a _ e��4z _ AP�0`z\�0exe�`bz _ A(�0B!����=�� `\exes= _ A���B4anA�B!Bo�lz\j(`r=�e���=�e _ A(z\j(`�ax��`bz _ ex�0d0e�=��4]4ab:'8�QoSJ-\�l5 �67�n�Q�J����.�#a�/�_��}�}���~ 3�3 a;:

� }�}��>�h: � ��l]4j�]l���q`\eb:Qy�B _ ]4`�A(B _ `\ex�4e�` _ = _ A��0BN�R�3`b�R=�� �0es= _ A(�0B¨e�`ba�A(i4�4`~?@=�axa�i4A(a _ exA��l� _ A(�0B4a<A(B]4`r=r� f �ZA(�0B*A�B4il�4z\`bic�q�4axA��0B*e�`\=�z _ A���B4a\:<$�&� �(��8�QoS�-\�3�D� u'1�« � \�,�/�_�\ � }���~ 3 /�/o:

� } ���!��:��h� _ a�z.]���c�:7}<]4�o`\B4B4`ba�ax`\B ���w:7�%:6�h]�=�{|es=��4=�e _Zf ��c�:�"�:Rg>`\ex?�=RB ��=RB4i �E: �E=��4j�: �D� �z\j(`r=�eIi4`��q�0e�?@= _ A���B�A(B�`<q;zbA _ `\i£�4�*A(a�� _ �0��`baD�qex�0? d0A�=�B _ i4A�� �0j(`>���"es= f _ ��a�axA���B£=�B4d��4jy=Rez\�0exe�`bjy= _ A���B4a\:�8�QoS�-\�35 �67���Q�l�E� �%~8�#a�^ _i~8��}�}���~ 3�3 ^l:

� }�,6�Vkl: c�: �hj�= _x_ =RB4i ew:+�h: ��`\A(a�ax{��0�;��:�)Q .H � ��������� $�&� � �����8�QoSJ-���.-�: �¡A(j�` f � ~ 3 �#\;:� } /�� �v:l�I`\A(a�il�0ex��:���B�=�j f a�A(a<�����axa�A(�0B�=��4A(j(A _Zf i4= _ =w= _ ]4A(d0]N`<q;zbA _ = _ A(�0B `\B4`be�d0A(`\ab:�mE�8�QoSJ-\�

�j� /�«'«� \#\�/ _�\#a � ��~ 3#� ~0:� } � �!g!: �DAP�q`\B4`bz.{�`be�=�Bli¡kl:��!: �^A�Bla _ ��B:vgDA(d0]�`\Bl`\e�d f �4]l� _ �0B��le��oi4�4z _ A���B�A�B�B|�4zbj�`\=�e

e�`\=�z _ A��0Bla\:��� � �&4�35 �67��$�&� �(��8<�������E�����p�4� «� ~�~�a`_i~�}�ab��~ 3�3 ^l:

3 �

Page 105: 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK - Michigan State Universitythoennes/personal/theses/heckman.pdf · /0 1 $*23 ! $* 45 687 9.:=@?BA>CED&FHGJI :LK MON PRQSQST?.U M U PRV

� } 3 � "�:�c�=�e _ �� B4` %�� �h:2c�:�c�=Re�n|���`\a!� �: | z.]|� _ %#�=" f :����0jP� �|kl:�� �� =�%#�2c : �'e�=�B4{R`#� | :,g>jy=r� �=��z����:�gD�0j %\?@=�BlB � �E: ��=R� _ exA�i4��� � �h: �n`����`b�oe�`���g!: � ��0]lB4`\e!� �V:�cc=�e��� B �X}~:�cc= _ �4j(`!kIA(z %���v:�ccA _x_ A(d�� ��:��v:�y�a _ `\B4il�0ex� �Kkl: g!:7"�:4�R=�B �E�0j ��kl:��~���`\� `\e _ � �E: �>���4a�ax`\j � �h]4�0?@=�%���V: | z.]|�4��`be _ ���%:�g�: | A(`\?�a�ax`\B � �%: | : | A(?��0B �'§�: | ����{R�`kIax{|Ax� ew: �®=�d0Bl`\e �4=�B4i*g!: �v:�¡A�j(a�z.]|� _ : �hex`\?�a�a _ es=R]4j��lB4d �l]4� _ ��B4a =�a = �4e�����`£�R�V]4� _ B|�4z\j(`\A�: 8�QoS�-\��ª ������ �/�/4�K� � \#a�� ~ 3�3 �;:

� �#^6�>��` _ `\z _ �0e�i4`ba�z\exA�� _ A(�0B¢=�Bli�axA�?!�4j�= _ A(�0B _ �o�0j�d0`\=�B _ ����`\e�axA���B{al: \b~��Xzb`\exB��le��0d0e�=�? j(A ��4es=Re f �ld0`\B4`��R=l:

� �b~ � �!: ��: | ]�=�k%:�M��PORQ�Uh � ��O0S ��� �x��SJ-np �sH7�©M��PORQ �TS%UXW;��L� �#c)Q�H ���L&;���������T� prH �� ��L&o���E�� #� ��L�� � ���L&;��: �^] � _ ]4`ba�A(a � | _ = _ ` �>B4A(��`\exA�a _Zf ��� �D`<k ��0ex{N= _ | _ �0B f �he��o�0{ � ~ 3�3�3 :

� ��\��$�V: "~A(j�� `\e _ =RB4i2�!::"�:7�v::��=�?�`\e���B:�� zb�0?�����a�A _ `@Bo�lz\j(`r=�e �Zj(`b�0`bj�il`\B4axA _Zf �q�0ex?V�4j�=kIA _ ]cax]4`\j(j3z\��e�e�`bz _ A��0Bla\:!���� �,#����� �lH7&��� ����H�p�8�QoSJ-���.-<�4��/�%~�}�}�,`_i~�} 3 ,���~ 3 ,��;:

� �#a6�!g!:��!: �h` _ ]4`�:�5 �67� ��H\#,��8�QoSJ-\�p�'� �5, 3 � ~ 3 a�/;:� ��}�� ��: �^: �h`\ex?�=RB: � _ j�=�aX��� �4]l� _ �0Bl`\� _ e��0B�zbe��0axa^a�`\z _ A(�0B4a��0� _ =�A(B4`\i9kIA _ ]�?��0B4�o`\B4`be�d0` _ A(z

�4]4� _ �0B4ab:����"���!�����N�� #�$�&' �(�������"��)��,+ � .-<��ot � a�~ 3 _ba 3 ^b��~ 3 /��;:� ����� �: �Dj�]4=�a�axA�i®=�B4i ��: �h�4ax]: � ��`\z _ a���� _ ]4`be�?@=�j ���4z _ ��= _ A(�0B4a��0B�d0Ay=RB _ i4A(� �0j�`�ex`\a����

B�=�B4zb`\aIA(Bc]4� _ ex� _ = _ A(B4d�Bo�lz\j(`\A�:<$�&� �(��8�QoSJ-\�3�j� t�« � � }�,�~<_�} 3#� ��~ 3�3 ^l:� ��,6� �E:{cc�0j(j�`be �¤kl:¢�%: �>A,q�� �v: �w:{c f `be�a!�¡=�B4i �v:¡kl: | kIAy= _ `\z.{|A�: kh`b�4a�A _ `6�

] _�_ ���� _ \;: jy=RB4j�: d0�J��R�4�4�lj�A(zr= _ A���B4a R?@=�axa�`ba RB4��e�?@=�j�: ] _ ?�j�:� ��/��>�h: ��=�?�`\e�=�� �!: �hes=�zbz\����ew: �D=�B�=�j ��c :���:;��=Re�� `\B _ `be �;��: i4`bj�j�= e�`bi4�J�R=�� | : �3`\��B4Ax�

��: ccA(j(j�A(�0B � | : cc=�B _ �J�R=�B4A(jx��c�: �^A(d0B�=�B4`bj�j(A ��yw: �¡A(`\j�=�B4i�� �D: ��: ��=�z.{ �+�V:ic :'gD`\A(B�%����: eV: �h:�k0=�B4axa�`bB4a � �w:�k�`\B4{|A(B4a ��}~: ��:n2~]4�o��� �h::"�:n2~�0B4i4`��i��}~: �n=��4exA _ a�`bB ����:�kl:�3A�a _ `\e!� �D:�c*z\z\j(A(B _ �;z.{ � | : cczbz\j(A�B _ �;z.{ � | :�ccA _ ax�4�0{7=��7�I:7�h:�cc�o�0e�`�� �w: | `!k�`\e f B4A�=�{ ���:Rkl: e�=�B | kh�0j �6�w:Rg>���q?@=�B �#c�:�}<]4�o`\B4B4`ba�ax`\B �|2�:��^A�ax`\B4?@=�B � �E:RgD`bz.{o?@=�B��,kl: | `\A _ %����: �^:�e�=�exB4`\e!��c�: �^:�g�=�j(��`be _ ��!.:���A(�0a %b`\d0A �0=RB4i �V: �3�0� ` % � c�=Re _ `bB4a\: �>=�i4A�= _ AP�0`��q�4a�A(�0B�qe��0?���`\e f a f ?�?�` _ e�A(z~e�`\=�z _ A��0Bla �l}<]l`�d0A�=�B _ i4A(� �0j�`De�`ba��0B�=RB4z\`�A(B _ ]4` uxw�� �D�¨B|�4z\j(`\�4ab:_ ��� `��l�4�4j(A�ax]4`\i:

3 ,