148
7/21/2019 9789088903113 - Docter Et Al. 2015 - Carthage - eBook http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/9789088903113-docter-et-al-2015-carthage-ebook 1/148 nmotnm ay Qde`m Mdbtnr Qomge Adussdffere Zontnr tnr Hnurs febt eim cytg  ertgekn

9789088903113 - Docter Et Al. 2015 - Carthage - eBook

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 7/21/2019 9789088903113 - Docter Et Al. 2015 - Carthage - eBook

    1/148

    nmotnm ay

    Qde`m Mdbtnr

    Qomge Adussdffere

    Zontnr tnr Hnurs

    febt eim cytg

    ertgekn

  • 7/21/2019 9789088903113 - Docter Et Al. 2015 - Carthage - eBook

    2/148

    Romnstdin ZrnssE inw kninretodi df Zua`osgoik

    _du ern rnemoik e fu`` vnrsodi df tgos addh, fdr frnn!

    ]gos addh os pert df tgn Romnstdin n-`oarery wgnrn cdst df dur

    pua`obetodis ern fu``y ebbnssoa`n fdr frnn. Fdr ebbnss td cdrn

    frnn addhs vosot< www.somnstdin.bdc/`oarery

    Mdwi`dem Fu`` ZMFVosot tgn Romnstdin n-`oarery td ardwsn dur n-addhs. Fdr e coioce`

    fnn ydu bei purbgesn e fu``y fuibtodie` ZMF eim ay mdoik sd, ydu

    gn`p td hnnp dur `oarery ruiioik.

    www.somnstdin.bdc/`oarery

  • 7/21/2019 9789088903113 - Docter Et Al. 2015 - Carthage - eBook

    3/148

  • 7/21/2019 9789088903113 - Docter Et Al. 2015 - Carthage - eBook

    4/148

  • 7/21/2019 9789088903113 - Docter Et Al. 2015 - Carthage - eBook

    5/148

  • 7/21/2019 9789088903113 - Docter Et Al. 2015 - Carthage - eBook

    6/148

    BD@DZGDI

    Krepgob Mnsoki

    Etn`onr @uhns, @nomni

    Bdvnr MnsokiEtn`onr @uhns & Romnstdin Zrnss,@nomni. Bdvnr mnsoki aesnm diBertgekn becpeoki mnsokinm ayMdua`nCeturnm, @nomni

    Zgdtdkrepgy bdvnr (frdit)Eiinhn mn Hncp eim Zntnr LeiAdcgdf (Mutbg Ietodie` Cusnuc

    df Eitoquotons)< Rtetun Kdmmnsswotg `odi gnem8Beidicei1? | mrnecstocn.bdca8 1::?81:528 tgn tnxt df bgeptnr ? os aesnmdi ei ertob`n eadut Geiioae` pua-`osgnm oi @ecpes (Mdbtnr 1::>b)

    Zrdlnbt nemnreile vei mnr \di

    Zrdlnbt essostnit

    Oikn mni Dumstni

    ]n nxgoaotodi bditeoinm dalnbts

    di `dei frdcCusn Ietodie` mu Aermd,Cusn Ietodie` mn Bertgekn, tgn@duvrn, tgn Arotosg Cusnuc, tgnRdproitnimnize mn` Cern, Ze`nrcd,tgn Inmnr`eimsbgn Aeih (MutbgIetodie` Aeih), tgn Qolhscusnucoi Ecstnrmec, @nomni iovnrsoty,tgn E``erm Zonrsdi Cusnuc,

    tgn Nyn Fo`c Cusnuc, tgnHdioih`olhn Aoa`odtgnnh (Qdye`@oarery), tgn Krdioiknr Cusnuc(Vnnihd`dioee` CusnucVnnimec), tgn Hdioih`olhDumgnomhuimok Kniddtsbgep,Cusnuc Adyceis vei Anuioiknieim e provetn bd``nbtodi (@nuvni)

    1:5> Qde`m Mdbtnr, Qomge Adussdere eim Zontnr tnr Hnurs

    Zua`osgnm ay Romnstdin Zrnss, @nomniwww.somnstdin.bdc

    ORAI ?;7-?:-77?:-255-2

  • 7/21/2019 9789088903113 - Docter Et Al. 2015 - Carthage - eBook

    7/148

    BDI]NI]R

    5=:@otnreturn& Oimnx

    55:

    55

    51

    52

    5=

    5>

    56

    5;

    1

    2

    =

    >

    6

    ;

    7

    ?

    7Bertgekn:]gn ]dpgnt

    df Bertgekn

    6:Bertgekn es

    e Cerotocn Zdwnr

    ;=]gn Zuiob

    [ers

    ?:Qdcei Bertgekn. Ot bdisostnmdf tgrnn perts. ]gnstrst rddc prnsnitnmtgn stdry df ZuiobBertgekn frdc otsfduimoik oi tgn ioitgbnitury A.B. td tgn nimdf tgn Rnbdim Zuiob[er oi 1:5 A.B. ]gnsnbdim rddc stertnmwotg Betds becpeokifdr tgn mnstrubtodidf Bertgekn eimceoi`y mne`t wotgtgn Qdcei pnrodm.Rnperetn`y, tgnrnwes e prnsnitetodidi tgn gostdry dferbgend`dkobe`rnsnerbg oi Bertgekn,frdc tgn rnmosbdvnry

    ay Lnei-co`nGucanrt (575;) td tgnwdrh df erbgend`dkostsfrdc tgn ^iovnrsotydf Ecstnrmec oi1:::/1::5.

    ]gn nxgoaotodi wescemn pdssoa`n aytgn suppdrt df tgnOistotut Ietodie` muZetrocdoin oi ]uios.Ceiy ocpdrteit `deis

    becn frdc tgn CusnIetodie` mu Aermd eimtgn Cusn Ietodie`mn Bertgekn.

  • 7/21/2019 9789088903113 - Docter Et Al. 2015 - Carthage - eBook

    10/148

    7

  • 7/21/2019 9789088903113 - Docter Et Al. 2015 - Carthage - eBook

    11/148

    BEQ]GEKN5>

    Rtetuns frdc Ome`odi,Byprus. Bd``nbtodi

    Arotosg Cusnuc,@dimdi (pgdtd< N. vei

    mni Aeimt).

  • 7/21/2019 9789088903113 - Docter Et Al. 2015 - Carthage - eBook

    18/148

    56

  • 7/21/2019 9789088903113 - Docter Et Al. 2015 - Carthage - eBook

    19/148

    ZGDNIOBOE AB.Ietodie` Cusnuc dfEitoquotons , @nomni .

  • 7/21/2019 9789088903113 - Docter Et Al. 2015 - Carthage - eBook

    20/148

    Beieei eim @naeidi

    Frdc erbgend`dkobe` rnsnerbg eim vnry ner`ytnxts, wn hidw tget Zgdnioboe wes e stretnkob `d-betodi oi tgn eibonit Iner Nest es fer aebh es tgntgorm co``niiouc AB. ]n bdeste` rnkodi wes e

    ierrdw fnrto`n bdrromdr tgrdukg wgobg nvnrytgoikeim nvnrydin cdst idtea`y cnrbgeits gem tdpess di tgn wey td Eietd`oe, Cnsdpdtecoe eimNkypt. Di b`ey tea`nts fduim oi Na`e oi prns-nitmey Ryroe, tgos bdeste` strop os be``nm Keiein(Beieei) dr @eaeieei (@naeidi), eim ots aok-knst boty wes Kua`e. ]os boty os anttnr hidwi ayots Krnnh iecn df Aya`ds/. Ot ges anniseom tget tgos wes ei Nkyptoei sntt`ncnit, aut otcey gevn cnrn`y anni e p`ebn df treisot fdr bn-merwddm eim epos ezu`o. Erbgend`dkobe` rnceois

    prdvn tget tgnrn wnrn oi eiy besn b`dsn eim frn-qunit tons wotg Nkypt oi tgos pnrodm. Dtgnr ce-ldr sntt`ncnits erduim tgos tocn wnrn tgdsn dfRomdi eim yrn. ]os cneis tget dvnr e tgduseimyners anfdrn tgn strst rnfnrnibns oi tgn sdurbns tdZgdnioboei cnrbgeits, tgnor eibnstdrs wnrn e`-rnemy p`eyoik e hny rd`n oi tgn nbdidcy df tgneibonit Iner Nest. Erduim 11:: AB tgnsn bdest-e` botons seih oitd e ce`eosn eim wnrn eaeimdinm.@ohn dtgnr botons, tgny wnrn uiea`n td rnspdimemnquetn`y td tgn snvnrn rnkodie` brosos tget wes

    Rerbdpgekusdf Egorec, wotg

    mnbdretodis eimoisbroptodis gdiduroik

    tgn cncdry df Egorec,Hoik df Aya`ds.

    beusnm, ecdik dtgnr tgoiks, ay mntnrodretoikb`ocetn bdimotodis. ]os `nm td celdr nbdidcobeim pd`otobe` tnisodis oi tgn rnkodi, pert`y beusnmay wevns df cokretodi.

    Ei Nkyptoei Z`ebn df ]reisot

    Et tgn ankoiioik df tgn snbdim co``niioucAB, cdst df tgn botons oi tgn bdeste` rnkodi nx-pnronibnm e rnvove`. Aya`ds sto`` prdvnm td an dfkrnet stretnkob ocpdrteibn td Nkypt. Rucptuduskrevns st``nm wotg kd`m eim so`vnr gevn anni fduimoi tgn boty, eim tgn Nkyptoeioispornm Dan`oshncp`n, wgnrn tgn botykdmmnss Aee`etKua`ewes wdrsgoppnm, metns frdc tgn snbdim co``ni-

    iouc AB. Cubg df dur oifdrcetodi eadut tgospnrodm bdcns frdc tgn Nkyptoei bdrrnspdimnibnerbgovns et N`Ecerie. ]nsn erbgovns ern e veststdrngdusn df mop`dcetob bdrrnspdimnibn dib`ey tea`nts antwnni Nkyptoei eim fdrnoki dfl-boe`s, oib`umoik oigeaoteits df tgn botons df yrneim Aya`ds, eim prdvomn e uioqun pobturn df tgnnbdidcob `ofn df tgn fdurtnnitg bnitury AB. [n`neri frdc tgnsn tnxts tget botons oi Zgdnioboewnrn bruboe` pertinrs eim tremoik bnitrns fdr tgnNkyptoei Zgeredg.

    1 ZGDNIOBOE< FQDC Z@EBN DF ]QEIRO] ]D ]QEMOIK IE]ODI1 ZGDNIOBOE< FQDC Z@EBN DF ]QEIRO] ]D ]QEMOIK IE]ODI

    57

  • 7/21/2019 9789088903113 - Docter Et Al. 2015 - Carthage - eBook

    21/148

    Erduim 51:: AB ankei ei e`cdst 1::yner pnrodm df mnb`oin muroikwgobg ceiy df tgn ocpdrteit botons df tgn Iner Nest bruca`nm oitd ruois.]n nxp`eietodi fdr tgn turau`nibn cey `on, pnrgeps, oi tgn movnrsn rnkodie`

    bgeikns< tgn Nkyptoei Ncporn gem bd``epsnm, tgn Osren`otns wnrn strniktgni-oik tgnor pdwnr aesn oi tgn Rdutgnri @nveit, tgn Zgo`ostoins eim dtgnr cer-otocn pndp`ns sntt`nm oi tgn bdeste` rnkodi, eim tgn Erecneis bdiqunrnm`erkn swetgns df wget gem anni Beieei. [go`n ceiy dtgnr sntt`ncnits, ns-pnboe``y tgdsn wotgoi tgn Zgo`ostoins mornbt spgnrn df oifiunibn, wnrn eaei-mdinm, tgn Zgdnioboei botons wotgstddm tgn prnssurns df tgn tocns. ]nybnrteoi`y sunrnm frdc tgn tnisn sotuetodi oi tgn nestnri Cnmotnrreinei,aut Zgdnioboei sdbonty mom idt bd``epsn. ]nrn ern sdcn oimobetodis tgettremn bditoiunm oi tgos pnrodm, idt di`y wotg tgn oitnrodr, aut e`sd wotgtgn os`eims eim bdeste` rnkodis oi tgn Cnmotnrreinei. Idintgn`nss, tgnrnwes bnrteoi`y e sgoft oi tgn ae`eibn df pdwnr< Romdi gem tehni dvnr frdc

    Aya`ds es tgn cdst ocpdrteit boty oi Zgdnioboe. Ot wes oi tgos pnrodm tgettgn Zgdnioboei `eikuekn eim sbropt mnvn`dpnm eim anbecn mossncoietnm.

    E Vnry Ner`y E`pgeant

    Zgdnioboei os e Rncotob `eikuekn, wgobg strdik`y rnsnca`ns tgn (`et-nr) Ereceob eim aoa`obe` Gnarnw. Df pertobu`er oitnrnst wes ots usndf ei e`pgeantobe` sbropt bdisostoik df twnitytwd `nttnrs. ]nrn wese hoim df e`pgeant oi ^kerot es fer aebh es tgn stftnnitg bnitury, wgobgusnm buinofdrc sbropt, aut cdst `oikuosts essucn tget Zgdnioboei sbroptmnrovns frdc tgn ZrdtdRoieotob df tgn Comm`n eim @etn Ardizn Ekn

    Mnbdretnm ]romebie sgn` ` usnmes e bditeoinr fdr bdscntobs8b. ;:: AB8 Ietodie` Cusnuc dfEitoquotons , @nomni .

    ]_ZOBE@ ZGDNIOBOEI

    BQEF]R]gn Zgdnioboeis wnrn idt lust sub-

    bnssfu` cnrbgeits8 tgny wnrn e`sd

    gokg`y sho``nm oi k`esscehoik, ovdry

    bervoik, eim cnte`wdrhoik. ]gny brn-

    etnm e gyarom bu`turn, wgobg sprnem

    tgrdukg tgnor `erkn tremn intwdrh,

    pnrcnetoik tgn nitorn Cnmotnrreinei

    rnkodi ay eadut ;:: AB. ]gnor so`-

    vnrko`t mosgns gevn anni fduim oi

    krevns frdc Ote`y td Cnsdpdtecoe.

    ]gnsn Zgdnioboei wdrhs df ert mosp`eye coxturn df sty`ns< Nkyptoei bgerodt-

    nnrs mrovoik Gottotn bgerodts, e gdvnr-

    oik aorm df prny mnpobtnm oi Nkyptoei

    sty`n eadvn e Cnsdpdtecoei go``, eim

    Essyroeis spdrtoik dik anerms e`dik-

    somn b`neisgevni Nkyptoei sd`monrs.

    @ubes Zntot

    5?

  • 7/21/2019 9789088903113 - Docter Et Al. 2015 - Carthage - eBook

    22/148

    ]yrn. Quois df QdceiZe`enstre, wotgbd`ucis cemn dfNkyptoei kreiotn.( Mmhk |mrnecstocn.bdc)

    1:

  • 7/21/2019 9789088903113 - Docter Et Al. 2015 - Carthage - eBook

    23/148

    ]ncp`n df tgn Dan`oshsoi Aya`ds.

    ]GN [DQM ZGDNIOBOEI]gn Zgdnioboeis mom idt rnfnr td tgnc-

    sn`vns ay tget iecn. ]gny wnrn beieio

    dr Beieeiotns. Ot wes tgn Krnnhs wgd

    tgdukgt up tgn iecn pgdoiox fdr tgn

    oigeaoteits df prnsnitmey @naeidi.

    ]gn wdrms ntycd`dky rnceois ui-

    b`ner. Ot cey rnfnr td tgn brocsdi myn

    df tgn bd`durfu` b`dtgs fdr wgobg tgnZgdnioboeis wnrn hidwi. E`tnrietovn`y,

    ot cey mnrovn frdc tgn iecn df tgn

    gnrd Zgdniox, tgn Zgdnioboeis procd-

    kniotdr. ]gn Qdceis, aesoik tgnc-

    sn`vns di Krnnh `otnreturn, usnm tgn

    tnrcspdnius eimpgdniox. ]gn fdrcnr,

    frdc wgobg tgn Nik`osg wdrm Zuiob mn-

    rovns, rnfnrs td tgn Zgdnioboeis Idrtg

    Efrobei mnsbnimeits.

    @ubes Zntot

    Keze

    MnemRne

    QovnrLdrmei

    ZG

    DNIOBOE

    Lnruse`nc

    Leffe

    Cnkommd

    Ebrn

    ]yrn

    Erwem

    Aya`ds

    Rernpte

    Romdi

    B_ZQ^R

    Cep df Zgdniobo

    15

  • 7/21/2019 9789088903113 - Docter Et Al. 2015 - Carthage - eBook

    24/148

    11

  • 7/21/2019 9789088903113 - Docter Et Al. 2015 - Carthage - eBook

    25/148

    ]ncp`n df tgn dan`oshsoi Aya`ds.

    12

    (b. 1:::-51:: AB). ]n d`mnst hidwi Zgdnioboei oisbroptodi os tgnEgorec npotepg, ei oisbroptodi di e rdye` serbdpgekus metoik frdc b. 51::AB. Ot wdu`m eppner tget tgn `eikuekn eim sbropt wnrn idt fu``y emdptnmay sdbonty, gdwnvnr, uito` tgn n`nvnitg bnitury AB. ]n sbropt wes wrot-tni nitorn`y wotgdut vdwn`s, oi bditrest td Ereceob eim aoa`obe` Gnarnw.

    ]eihs td tgn botystetns bdccnrboe` intwdrh, tgn Zgdnioboei `eikueknsprnem tgrdukgdut tgn Cnmotnrreinei rnkodi frdc tgn ioitg bnitury ABdiwerms, e prdbnss tget wes ieture``y essostnm ay tgn febt tget tgos e`pge-antobe` systnc, ui`ohn buinofdrc sbropt eim Nkyptoei gonrdk`ypgobs, wesidt di`y nesy td `neri aut bdu`m e`sd an usnm oi dtgnr `eikuekns. Adtg tgnKrnnh eim @etoi e`pgeants ern aesnm di tgn drokoie` Zgdnioboei sbropt. Estgn verodus bd`dions ebquornm krnetnr oimnpnimnibn, tgn sbropt bgeiknm.Fdr oisteibn, erduim tgn tgorm bnitury AB tgn sbropt oi Bertgekn, e`sdhidwi es Zuiob, wes bursovn (snn bgeptnr =).

    E ]remoik Ietodi

    remn fidurosgnm, eim tgn nxp`dsovn pdpu`etodi krdwtg oi tgn Zgdnioboeibdeste` rnkodi cneit tget ceiy wnrn bdcpn``nm td cokretn wnst. [getgeppninm oi tgnor gdcn bduitry dvnr tgn inxt twd bniturons os pert`yvno`nm oi dasburoty. Ot os strohoik tget wn hidw cdrn eadut tgn Zgdnioboeiswnstnri bdccnrboe` rn`etodis eim bd`dions tgei wn md eadut Zgdnioboeotsn`f. ]os os ceoi`y anbeusn vnry fnw drokoie` tnxts gevn anni fduim oitgn cdtgnr bduitry. Cdst df tgn oifdrcetodi wn pdssnss eadut Zgdnioboebdcns frdc Essyroei eiie`s, aoa`obe` tnxts eim `etnr Krnnh wdrhs. Zert`yfdr tgos rnesdi, wn md idt stim eiy rnfnrnibns td ocpdrteit botons subg esyrn uito` e rn`etovn`y `etn pnrodm, wgnrnes wn hidw tget tgny gem p`eynm

    ei ocpdrteit pert `dik anfdrn tget. Ot bei an essucnm tget yrn wes tgncdst pdwnrfu` boty oi tgn bdeste` rnkodi frdc tgn tnitg bnitury AB di-werms, gevoik dvnrtehni Aya`ds eim Romdi. Ot wes sotuetnm di ei os`eim

    lust d tgn bdest eim pdssnssnm e setn``otn boty di tgn ceoi`eim. Oi emmotoditd twd `erkn geradurs, e cerhnt eim e pe`ebn, yrn e`sd pdssnssnm snvnre`tncp`ns tget wnrn mnmobetnm td tgn botys cdst prdcoinit mnotons< Cn`qert,

    Estertn eim Aee`Rgecnc.

    ]gn Zgdnioboei Mnotons]n Zgdnioboeis kdms wnrn b`dsn`y `oihnm td tgn peitgndi df dtgnr

    @nveitoin bu`turns. Bgonf ecdik tgnc wnrn tgn cdtgnr kdmmnss Estertn e`sd hidwi es Osgter eim Esgnreg, tgn fnrto`oty kdmmnss, wgd wes frn-qunit`y mnpobtnm wotg e trnn df `ofn. Es tgn Zgdnioboei wdr`m keoinm oiocpdrteibn, wn snn e krdwtg oi tgn iucanr df ce`n kdms. ]us, Esgnregebquornm e gusaeim iecnm N`, eim dtgnr kdms tdd eppnernm di tgn stekn,subg es Emdios (tgn kdm df arnem), _ec (tgn kdm df tgn sne) eim Qnsgnf(tgn kdm df `okgtioik eim p`ekuns). Nebg df tgn celdr Zgdnioboei botonsgem ots dwi botykdm, wgd wes wdrsgoppnm oi din df tgn ceoi tncp`ns.

    [go`n Emdios wes df krnet ocpdrteibn oi Aya`ds, eim sdcnwget etnr e`sddi Byprus, ot wes Cn`qert, tgn kdm df tgn sne eim tgn uimnrwdr`m, wgdprnveo`nm oi yrn eim Bertgekn.

    ZGDNIOBOE< FQDC Z@EBN DF ]QEIRO] ]D ]QEMOIK IE]ODI 1

    Hotodi. Oi tgnZgdnioboei pnrodm,Hotodi, `ohn Bertgekn,wes hidwi es tgnInw Boty. Zgdnioboeitncp`n df Estertn,]ncnrds.

  • 7/21/2019 9789088903113 - Docter Et Al. 2015 - Carthage - eBook

    26/148

    Zgdnioboei so`vnrko`tmosg. b. ;::-6;> AB.Ietodie` Cusnuc dfEitoquotons , @nomni .

    Frdc Nest td [nst

    ]n bd`diosetodi prdbnss oi tgn Cnmotnrreinei tdwgobg tgn Zgdnioboeis dwn tgnor fecn eppnerstd gevn anni oiotoetnm procero`y ay tgn boty df

    yrn. Ot wes tgnrn, oi tgn tnitg bnitury AB, tgetHoik Gorec O ebquornm e tremn cdidpd`y, kov-oik rosn td ei nxpeisodi tget cemn tgn boty tgncdst ocpdrteit Zgdnioboei pdrt oi tgn nestnriCnmotnrreinei. Gn stertnm ay fdbusoik di tremn

    1=

    wotg tgn oitnrodr eim tgn Qnm Rne. Aut wrottnisdurbns sgdw tget Gorec e`sd nxnrbosnm bditrd`di Byprus. Rto``, tgn os`eim wes idt e rne` bd`d-

    iy et tgos pdoit. Ot wes idt uito` tgn comioitgbnitury AB, uimnr gos subbnssdr, tget tgn strstsntt`ncnit wes auo`t di Byprus< Hotodi. ]nprnsnibn df bdppnr di tgn os`eim wes e celdrettrebtodi et strst. Aut Byprus wes e`sd usnm es

    1 ZGDNIOBOE< FQDC Z@EBN DF ]QEIRO] ]D ]QEMOIK IE]ODI

  • 7/21/2019 9789088903113 - Docter Et Al. 2015 - Carthage - eBook

    27/148

    Kemns

    ]gerrds

    Bertgekn

    ^tobe HnrhdueinRyrebusn

    Qdcn

    Beiien

    Etgnis

    Romdi

    ]yrn

    REQMOIOE

    BQN]N

    B_ZQ^R

    N]Q^QOE

    ROBO@_

    Gemrucntuc

    e treisot pdrt eim `etnr es e p`ebn fdr tgn krdw-oik pdpu`etodi td `ovn. Ansomns anoik sho``nm oibdccnrbn, tgn Zgdnioboeis wnrn e`sd hidwi fdrtgnor nxbn``nit breftsceisgop, prdmuboik prdm-ubts tget wnrn cubg oi mnceim, ceiy df wgobg

    wnrn sddi rnebgoik Byprus. Idt di`y Byprus

    ]gn Cnmotnrreineirnkodi oi tgnZgdnioboei-Zuiobpnrodm.

    ZGDNIOBOE< FQDC Z@EBN DF ]QEIRO] ]D ]QEMOIK IE]ODI 1

  • 7/21/2019 9789088903113 - Docter Et Al. 2015 - Carthage - eBook

    28/148

    16

  • 7/21/2019 9789088903113 - Docter Et Al. 2015 - Carthage - eBook

    29/148

    Z^IOBBEQ]GEKN

    Qde`m Mdbtnr

    1;

    EBBDQMOIK ]D @NKNIM, ]GN Z^IOB

    CN]QDZD@OR DF BEQ]GEKN [ER FD^IMNM

    [O]G ]GN EOM DF E BQEF]_ ]QOBH EIM EI

    DW GOMN. ]GN NEQ@ONR] VNQRODI DF ]GN

    R]DQ_ OR ]D@M A_ ]OCEN^R DF ]E^QDCNIO^C

    ]EDQCOIE, E KQNNH [QO]NQ FQDC ]GN @E]]NQ

    GE@F DF ]GN FD^Q]G BNI]^Q_ AB. EF]NQ ER]Q^KK@N FDQ ZD[NQ ECDIK ]GN IDA@NR

    DF ]_QN OI ZQNRNI]ME_ @NAEIDI, ZQOIBNRR

    N@ORRE MOMD EIM E KQD^Z DF EQOR]DBQE]OB

    BDCZEIODIR ADEQMNM RNVNQE@ RGOZR EIM

    REO@NM [NR][EQMR ]D[EQMR ]GN BDER]

    DF IDQ]G EFQOBE, [GOBG [ER HID[I OI

    EI]OU^O]_ ER @OA_E.

    ]gn ]dpgnt, tgnBertgekoioei auroe`krduim oi tgn sdutg dftgn boty. Ceiy rnceoisdf yduik bgo`mrni wnrnfduim gnrn, fun``oikgypdtgnsns eadutbgo`m sebrostbns.

  • 7/21/2019 9789088903113 - Docter Et Al. 2015 - Carthage - eBook

    30/148

    ]ny p`eiinm td fduim e inw bepote` boty tgnrn, e inw yrn. Di tgn weytd Efrobe, tgn rnfuknns mrdppnm eibgdr et tgn os`eim df Byprus, wgnrn tgnytddh di aderm tgn Gokg Zronst df Estertn eim nokgty kor`s wgd wnrn oivd`vnmoi tncp`n prdstotutodi. Eftnr e``, tgn subbnssfu` nxpeisodi df e bd`diy rn-quorns wdcni es wn`` es cni.

    ocenus rn`etns tget tgn bdcpeiy errovnm di tgn bdest df @oaye (prnsnitmey uiosoe) oi tgn tgortynokgtg yner anfdrn tgn strst D`ycpoem, tget os, oi75=/52 AB. ]nrn, tgny nitnrnm oitd inkdtoetodis wotg tgn `dbe` pdpu`e-todi, wgd ekrnnm td sn`` tgnc e ponbn df `eim es `erkn es bdu`m an bdvnrnmay ei dx gomn. [otg mnvodus buiioik, gdwnvnr, tgn inwbdcnrs but ei dxgomn oitd toiy strops, `eyoik tgnc mdwi sd es td niborb`n tgn go`` df Ayrse, efer `erknr erne tgei tgn @oayeis gem oitnimnm. ]os sgdu`m e`cdst bnrteoi`yan rnkermnm es ei epdbrypge` stdry, oivnitnm anbeusn Ayrse sduims soco`ertd tgn Krnnh wdrm fdr dx gomn. Nvni sd, tgn stdry bditeois n`ncnitstget bgocn pnrfnbt`y wotg tgn inketovn ocekn df tgn Zgdnioboeis oi eitoqun

    sdurbns rokgt aebh td Gdcnr, wgd mnsbroans tgn Zgdnioboeis es e breftyeim cnimebodus pndp`n wgd wo`` snozn nvnry dppdrtuioty td cehn e prdsttwgnrnvnr tgny kd, eim wgd wo`` idt sbrup`n, fdr oisteibn, td bdcaoin ea-mubtodis wotg s`evn tremn. Nvni tgn rnfnrnibn td ei dx es pert df tgn fdui-metodi df ei eibonit boty cey bditeoi e kreoi df trutg. Ecdik tgn Krnnhseim tgn Qdceis, eim prdaea`y tgn Zgdnioboeis, tgn aduimerons df e futurnboty wnrn cerhnm dut oi e rotue` bnrncdiy wotg tgn eom df e p`dukg mrewiay e au`` eim e bdw.

    ]n burrnit iecn df Bertgekn mnrovns frdc tgn Zgdnioboei Urtgmt(HertGemesgt) cneioik inw boty e pere``n` td (Iep`ns)ecdik tgn Krnnhs. Oi tgos bditnxt ot os bnrteoi`y idt uiocpdrteit tget

    Bertgekn os tgn di`y boty oi tgn ZgdnioboeiZuiob wdr`m df wgobg wnpdssnss ei n`eadretn `nknim eadut ots fduimetodi. ]os eibonit tremotodib`ner`y bditeois n`ncnits, emmnm procero`y td brnetn e idiKrnnh eimidiQdcei rnprnsnitetodi df Bertgekn oi tgn `etnr Krnnh eim @etoisdurbns. Nvni sd, tgn stdry e`sd bditeois n`ncnits tget ern sd typobe`-`y Dronite` eim idib`essobe` tget tgny ern vnry ui`ohn`y td bdcn frdcKrnnh dr Qdcei gostdroeis. ]n cdierbgob nxp`eietodi uimnr`yoik tgnbd`diys fduimetodi oi tgos cytg os bnrteoi`y etypobe` oi tgos rnkerm, autpdssnssns e bnrteoi dkob pertobu`er`y fdr e sntt`ncnit iecnm Inw Boty.Ner`onr Zgdnioboei bd`dions oi tgn bnitre` eim wnstnri Cnmotnrreinei gemanni fduimnm fdr bdccnrboe` rnesdis, fdr oisteibn anbeusn df tgn prdx-

    ocoty df drncoioik ernes. Qne` ekrobu`ture` bd`dions, subg es tgdsn sddftni nibduitnrnm oi Krnnh bd`diosetodi, wnrn quotn uibdccdi oi tgnZgdnioboei wdr`m. Bertgekn cdvnm oitd tgn esbnimeiby ecdik tgn Zuiobbd`dions, bnrteoi`y frdc tgn nim df tgn soxtg bnitury AB diwerms8 anfdrntgni, ot gem anni da`oknm td sgern tgos prnncoinit pdsotodi wotg dtgnrkrnet bd`dioe` sntt`ncnits cnitodinm oi eibonit sdurbns< Bmoz oi Rpeoi,^tobe oi uiosoe, eim @oxus oi Cdrdbbd.

    Idt sd `dik ekd, tgn ner`y metn df tgn botys fduimetodi, es sukknstnm ay tgneibonit sdurbns, bdu`m idt an bdrrdadretnm ay erbgend`dkobe` stims. rebnsdf tgn d`mnst boty bdu`m idt an metnm eiy ner`onr tgei tgn snbdim quertnr

    Rtetun frdc Ome`odi,ei d`m Zgdnioboei

    sntt`ncnit di Byprus.Arotosg Cusnuc,

    @dimdi.

    17

    2 Z^IOB BEQ]GEKN

  • 7/21/2019 9789088903113 - Docter Et Al. 2015 - Carthage - eBook

    31/148

    df tgn nokgtg bnitury AB, di tgn aesos df cn-tobu`dus stumons df Krnnh bnrecob sgnrms. Uuotnrnbnit`y, gdwnvnr, eioce` adins frdc tgn ner`onst`eynrs df tgn sntt`ncnit gevn anni metnm, usoikremodberadi metoik tnbgid`dky, td tgn nim df tgn

    ioitg bnitury AB, wgobg wdu`m an bdcpetoa`nwotg tgn botys fduimetodi oi 75=/752 AB.

    ^raei Mnvn`dpcnit eim@ovoik Bu`turn

    [otg tgn aninstt df sdcn twd bniturons df erbgen-d`dkobe` rnsnerbg (soibn Gucanrt), wn ern feor`ywn`` oifdrcnm di wget tgn Zuiob boty `ddhnm `ohneim gdw ot mnvn`dpnm. Roibn tgn 5?;:s oi per-tobu`er, tgnrn ges anni ei upsurkn oi rnsnerbg di

    tgn strubturn df tgn eibonit boty. Ot os strohoik tgettgn ner`onst boty wes idt auo`t di tgn pneh df tgn`etnr bnitre` go`` df Ayrse, aut di tgn go``s sdutg-nest eim nestnri s`dpns, feboik tgn sne. ]n ner`onsttrebns df gucei prnsnibn gevn anni fduim gnrnoi `eynrs es mnnp es sox cntrns an`dw tgn burrnit

    krduim `nvn`. ]os ner`y sntt`ncnit erne `ons die pnioisu`e nxtnimoik oitd tgn Ku`f df uios, egokg`y stretnkob pdsotodi tget mup`obetnm tgn bger-ebtnrostob cdmn` df Zgdnioboei bdeste` botons df tgn@nveit, nspnboe``y tgn cdtgnr boty df yrn, wotg ots

    twd eimoik ernes fdr sgops din td tgn sdutg, tgndtgnr td tgn idrtg. ]nsn wnrn prdaea`y e`sd tgnernes wgnrn tgn pnropgnre` perts df tgn sntt`ncnitwnrn `dbetnm, wotg e`` tgn movnrsn fuibtodis tgetern typobe` df geradurs< werngdusns, sgopyerms,gdusns fdr seo`drs eim cnrbgeits, oiis eim ardtg-n`s. ^ifdrtuietn`y, ot ges idt ynt anni pdssoa`ntd nxecoin tgnsn perts df tgn boty, wgobg cey anbe``nm, ay eie`dky wotg tgn @nveitoin nxecp`ns,tgn @dwnr Boty (dr pnrgeps @dwnr Botons). Ecerhntp`ebn (ceqdc) oi tgn voboioty df tgnsn ger-

    adurs bei e`sd an rnbdistrubtnm, ay eie`dky wotgtgn fecdus Nurybgdrds oi yrn.

    Foims frdc nxbevetodis niea`n us td nstocetntgn surfebn erne df Bertgekn oi ots ner`onst pgesnet epprdxocetn`y 1> gnbterns. ]os uraei rnkodi

    K`ess anems,Bertgekn8 =tg -2rmbnitury AB8 CusnIetodie` mn Bertgekn.Znimeits `ohn tgos,cemn frdc k`esspestn, wnrn fduim oikrevns.

    1?

    Z^IOB BEQ]GEKN 2

  • 7/21/2019 9789088903113 - Docter Et Al. 2015 - Carthage - eBook

    32/148

    wdu`m gevn gem e pdpu`etodi df >,::: td 7,:::oi tgn snvnitg bnitury AB, wgobg os vnry `erknoi tgn bditnxt df eibonit bovo`osetodis. Ay tgnsnbdim bnitury AB tgos stkurn gem krdwi td et`nest >:,:::, of idt 5::,:::, eim nvni 2::,:::

    os cnitodinm. Frdc et `nest tgn snvnitg bnituryAB diwerms, tgn ^ppnr Boty wes surrduim-nm ay boty we``s wotg ketns eim aestodis. Oi tgnstftg bnitury AB, tgnsn we``s wnrn rninwnm eimnxpeimnm td nib`dsn e `erknr surfebn erne. Eswes bustdcery oi tgn eibonit wdr`m, tgn auroe`krduims eim sdcn df tgn ertoseis quertnrs `eyanydim tgn boty we``s (nxtre curds). ]n dpgntdf Bertgekn wes e`sd oiotoe``y nxtre curds. Ditgos sebrnm sotn, tgn brncetnm rnceois df tnis dftgduseims df oifeits wnrn `eom td rnst oi uris). Idtfer frdc tgn dpgnt, ei ertostboe` beie`, 5> td1: cntrns womn eim twd cntrns mnnp, rei pere`-`n` td tgn bdest. Roibn tgos wes auo`t anfdrn tgncomfdurtg bnitury AB, tgos beie` tdd custgevn anni wotgoi tgn `etnr boty we``. Ot wes st``nmoi eftnr b. 2>: AB eim rnp`ebnm ay e mdua`ngeradur sdutgnest df ots bdursn. ]n stie` vnr-sodi df tgos mdua`n geradur os mnsbroanm oi ei-bonit `otnreturn (ay Eppoei) eim bei an metnm

    erbgend`dkobe``y td lust anfdrn tgn dutarneh dftgn ]orm Zuiob [er. E sce`` beie` bdiinbts tgnrnbteiku`er bdccnrboe` geradur td e borbu`erieve` geradur eim sgnms tget bdu`m ebbdccd-metn 5;: td 57: wersgops (trorncns). ]os iuc-anr os quotn b`dsn td tgn 11: sgops cnitodinm ay

    Eppoei es tgn geradurs bepeboty.

    E`` tgos sukknsts tget tgn boty wes auo`t frdc tgndutsnt ebbdrmoik td e wn``mnstinm strubture`mnsoki, wotg rnbteiku`er gdusns sgeroik tgnor

    dutnr we``s eim erreiknm oi a`dbhs (oisu`en)surrduimnm ay strnnts. Ot eppners tget tgn strstbd`diosts gem e`rnemy movomnm up tgn uraei erneebbdrmoik td e retodie` mnsoki aesnm di e remoe`,feisgepnm auo`tup erne wotg strnnts `nemoiktd tgn s`dpns df tgn Ayrse. Ei drtgdkdie` pet-tnri df auo`moik os e`sd fduim oi tgn dwnr`yoikbdeste` p`eoi. Frdc tgn ner`onst yners, tgn strnntsdf Bertgekn wnrn pevnm wotg stdin bgops eimgem orrnku`er, dpni mreoiekn bdimuots. dwermstgn `est quertnr df tgn stftg bnitury AB, et `nest

    2:

    2 Z^IOB BEQ]GEKN

    ]gn serbdpgekn dftgn pronstnss df Osos,es ot os hidwi. Fduim

    oi e sgeft tdca, 51cntrns mnnp8 Cusn

    Ietodie` mn Bertgekn.

  • 7/21/2019 9789088903113 - Docter Et Al. 2015 - Carthage - eBook

    33/148

    sdcn df tgn strnnts wnrn rnbdistrubtnm oi estrohoik`y cdiucnite` fdrc, wotg `erkn `ocn-stdin p`etns eim bnitre` mreoiekn bdimuots. ]nstie` rnidvetodi df tgn strnnts, et tgn ankoiioikdf tgn snbdim bnitury AB, nvni oib`umnm mreoi-

    ekn bdimuots bdisostoik df ocnstdin p`etns wotgbernfu``ybervnm bgeiin`s. Cdiucnite` strnntpevoik df tgos hoim bdu`m `est fdr kninretodiseim put ei nim td tgn uirnku`etnm pnrodmob reos-oik df tgn rdem surfebn tget gem anni bustdceryanfdrn tgni, usoik sgnrms eim dtgnr westn ce-tnroe`s frdc tgn sntt`ncnit. Roibn tgnrn wes id`diknr eiy rnesdi td fner tgn bdisteit reosoik dftgn strnnt `nvn`, wgobg beusnm reoiwetnr td ruioitd tgn gdusns, wn e`sd snn e ge`t oi tgn repomsubbnssodi df fiddr `nvn`s oi tgn gdusns. Oistnem

    df tgn tecpnmmdwi `ocnstdin fiddrs tget gemanni bustdcery uito` tgni, pndp`n stertnm oi-

    vnstoik oi cdrn nxpnisovn `ocn cdrter eim tns-sn``etnm (cdseob) fiddrs, tgn Zevocnite Zuiobe,wgobg wdu`m `ohnwosn nimurn fdr snvnre` kninr-etodis. Ei nssnitoe` bdimotodi fdr ceoiteoioik epnrceinit strnnt `nvn` wes tgn drkeiosetodi df

    e keraekn bd``nbtodi snrvobn. Muik eim keraeknbd``nbtodi snrvobns ern feco`oer frdc wrottnisdurbns rn`etoik td eibonit Krnnh botons subg es

    Etgnis< tgn wdrhnrs wgd prdvomnm tgos snrvobnwnrn hidwi es hdprd`dkdo. Ot os id bdoibomnibntget tgn rnceois df tdo`nts tget gevn anni fduimoi movnrsn perts df tgn boty metn frdc tgos pnrodm.]n bd``nbtnm muik wes prdaea`y usnm oi tgn or-roketnm gdrtobu`ture` erne td tgn wnst df tgn boty,oi Cnkere. [gntgnr uroin wes e`sd bd``nbtnmsnperetn`y eim usnm oi teiinrons, es wes bdc-

    cdi oi Qdcei tocns, os idt hidwi aut gokg`yprdaea`n.

    @nft< Cesh, Mncntnrdr Cnmuse8 Bertgekn82rm-1im bnitury AB8Cusn Ietodie` mnBertgekn.

    25

    Z^IOB BEQ]GEKN 2

    Qokgt< Cesh8 Bertgekn,inbrdpd`os df Mnrcnbg8`etn 6tg bnitury AB8Cusn Ietodie` muAermd. Ceshs df tgoshoim wnrn fduim oikrevns. ]gny wnrnprdaea`y oitnimnm tdwerm dff nvo` sporots.

  • 7/21/2019 9789088903113 - Docter Et Al. 2015 - Carthage - eBook

    34/148

    ]GN A@EBHRCO]GR RNBQN]Nxbevetodis berronm dut ay tgn ^iovnrsoty df

    Ecstnrmec oi Bertgekn rnvne`nm tgn rnceois df e

    `erkn oimustroe` sotn metoik frdc tgn ;tg td >tg bni-

    tury AB. E wne`tg df ordi dalnbts wnrn prdmubnm gnrn

    oi sce`` fdrkns. ]gn Ecstnrmec cnte``urkost GeisHdnis eie`ysnm tgn westn frdc tgos sotn (n.k. df tnr-

    rebdtte an``dws popns), eim mosbdvnrnm tget e`` tgn

    secp`ns wnrn robg oi drkeiob `ocnstdin tget os,

    be`bouc. Roco`er ordi westn frdc tgos pnrodm oi Ryroe

    eim Ntruroe, eim di N`ae eim Osbgoe, bditeois di`y

    spdremob trebns df be`bouc. ]gos os tgn pettnri sto``

    fduim oi tgn cnmoenve` Intgnr`eims, eim oi Nik`eim

    nvni uito` tgn ner`y iointnnitg bnitury. ]gnsn sce``

    queitotons rnfinbt ieture` ocpurotons oi tgn drn dr tgn

    cetnroe` frdc wgobg tgn fdrkns wnrn cemn.

    Ceiy typns df ordi drn bditeoi su`pgur oi tgnor ietu-

    re` stetn. ]gn prnsnibn df su`pgur, gdwnvnr sce`` tgn

    queitoty, `nems td e arott`n nim prdmubt. Nvni coidr

    strnssns prdmubn brebhs tget wnehni tgn ordi dalnbt.

    ^ito` tgn com5?tg bnitury, su`pgur wes rncdvnm ay

    gnetoik tgn su`pgurdus ordi drn oi tgn prnsnibn df eor

    oi rdestoik furiebns uito` ot wes rnmgdt, aut wotgdut

    cn`toik ot.

    ]gn strst petnit fdr tgn prdmubtodi df gokgque`oty

    stnn` frdc rew ordi, oi din uioitnrruptnm prdbnss,

    wes kreitnm td Gniry Anssncnr di 5; Dbtdanr 57>>.Ocpdrteit`y, tgos petnit wes `etnr nxpeimnm td oi-

    b`umn e cntgdm td inutre`osn su`pgur muroik prdmub-

    todi ay emmoik be`bouc, tgus rncdvoik et e strdhn tgn

    innm fdr tgn rdestoik prdbnss, sevoik adtg tocn eim

    fun`. ]gn Ecstnrmec rnsnerbg prdlnbt sgdws tget tgn

    Bertgekoioei fdrkns gem e`rnemy cestnrnm tgos sn-

    brnt prdbnmurn. ]gos wes bdistrcnm ay tgn stimoiks

    df Hdniss ner`onr eie`ysns df ordi dalnbts frdc Zuiob

    Bertgekn, wgobg e`sd turinm up gokg pnrbnitekns df

    be`bouc. ]gn nxbevetodis rnvne`nm tget tgos be`bouc

    prdaea`y mnrovnm frdc tgn brusgnm sgn``s df Curnxsne sieo`s. E`` tgn nvomnibn sukknsts tget tgn ner`y

    Bertgekoioeis bdu`m prdmubn ordi df gokg dr oimnnm

    supnrodr que`oty, eim tget tgny mom sd di e erkn sbe`n.

    [otg tgn Qdcei bdiqunst, tgos hidw`nmkn wes `dst.

    Qde`m Mdbtnr

    ]n wetnr supp`y df tgn uraei pdpu`etodi oiotoe``y becnfrdc mnnp wn``s muk dut df tgn vorkoi sdo`. Bnrteoi`y aytgn comfdurtg bnitury AB, tgnsn wn``s gem anni rn-p`ebnm ay bostnris. Rubg wes tgn tnbgiobe` pnrfnbtodi dftgnsn Zuiob bostnris eim tgn gymreu`ob cdrters innmnm td

    dpnretn tgnc tget tgn Qdceis bditoiunm td usn tgnc fdrceiy bniturons eftnr tgn fe`` df tgn boty. Oi tgn stie` ynersdf Bertgekn, oi tgn strst ge`f df tgn snbdim bnitury AB,nvnry gdusn gem et `nest din bostnri.

    ]n fiddr p`eis df tgn Bertgekoioei gdusns `erkn`y fd`-`dwnm tgn bustdcery mnsoki oi tgn cdtgnr botons df tgn@nveit, bnrteoi`y oi tgn strst fnw bniturons eftnr tgn botysfduimetodi. Gdusn mnsokis tget ern hidwi td us oib`umntgn bdurtyerm gdusn eim frdc tgn snbdim quertnr df tgnsnvnitg bnitury diwerms tgn fdurrddc gdusn. Idt

    uito` tgn `etn fdurtg bnitury AB mdns tgn erbgotnbturnstert td oibdrpdretn Krnnh, Gn``niostob n`ncnits subg estgn `erknr dpni bdurtyerm hidwi es e pnrosty`n eim tgn

    Aee`Geccdi8seibtuery df eibonit

    ]goiossut8 5st bnituryEM8 Cusn Ietodie` mu

    Aermd.

    Aee`Geccdi wesdin df Bertgekns

    cdst ocpdrteit kdms.]gn wdrsgop df tgosmnoty wes ocpdrtnm

    frdc ]yrn.

    21

    2 Z^IOB BEQ]GEKN

  • 7/21/2019 9789088903113 - Docter Et Al. 2015 - Carthage - eBook

    35/148

    we`` mnbdretodis oi tgn sdbe``nm BdistrubtovnRty`n (oi tgn Vnsuvous botons anttnr hidwi estgn Forst Zdcpnoei Rty`n). ]os typn df mnbdre-tovn wdrh cehns ecp`n, nxuanreit usn df Krnnhcdu`moiks oi stubbd rn`onf. Oi Bertgekn eim oi

    dtgnr Zuiob botons oi Idrtg Efrobe, tgn bditoiu-oik pdpu`eroty df tgn Mdrob drmnr os pertobu`er`ystrohoik. Aut wn e`sd snn Nkyptoei oifiunibns oitgn we`` mnbdretodis, nspnboe``y oi tgn cdu`moiks.Idtwotgsteimoik tgnsn oitnrietodie` oifiunibns,oi nssnibn tgn fiddr p`eis rnceoinm typobe``yZuiob, `erkn`y anbeusn df tgn `dik bdiinbtoikbdrromdrs antwnni rddcs (kovoik rosn td tgniecn Bdrromdr gdusns). d Krnnh eim Qdceivosotdrs, tgn boty cust gevn prnsnitnm ei Dronite`espnbt, anbeusn df tgn sne df fiet rddfs tget wes

    sd ui`ohn tgn uraei `eimsbepn oi dtgnr perts dftgn Krnnh eim Qdcei wdr`m8 oimnnm, pndp`n`ovnm pert df tgnor `ovns di tgn rddf. Rberbn`y eiyrddf to`ns gevn anni fduim muroik tgn nxbevetodisdf tgn Zuiob boty, cehoik ot nxtrncn`y ui`ohn`ytget tgnrn wnrn eiy kea`n dr semm`n rddfs. Frdcet `nest tgn `ettnr ge`f df tgn nokgtg bnitury AB,tgn gdusns wnrn snvnre` stdrnys gokg. Eppoeis eb-bduit df tgn sonkn eim bepturn df tgn boty oi tgn]orm Zuiob [er stetns tget sdcn df tgn gdusnswnrn sox stdrnys gokg. ]os cey idt an trun< pds-soa`y tgn Qdceis wnrn bdifusnm ay e bnrteoi dp-

    tobe` mostdrtodi. @ddhoik et tgn boty frdc e krnetmosteibn, tgny sew gdusns auo`t oi tnrrebnm fdrcekeoist tgn somn df tgn go``8 oi rne`oty, nebg ceygevn anni di`y twd dr tgrnn stdrnys gokg.

    ]gn Hoikmdc df tgn Mnem

    Ceiy stumons gevn anni cemn df tgn Bertgekoi-oei inbrdpd`osns soibn tgn iointnnitg bnitury,e`tgdukg idt e`` ern aesnm di sd`om sbgd`ersgop.Oi tgn ner`onst hidwi pgesn, tgn krduims nx-

    tnimnm erduim tgn boty oi ei erb< oi tgn wnstdi tgn Ayrse, eim oi tgn idrtg eim idrtgnestdi tgn Luid eim Mnrcnbg go``s. Qnbnit`y e

    ldoit uiosoeiAn`koei tnec wdrhoik di tgnAor Cnssedume sotn mosbdvnrnm tgn rnceois dfei nokgtgbnitury inbrdpd`os, wgobg eppnerstd b`dsn tgn borb`n erduim tgn boty oi tgn sdutg.]os auroe` krduim wes e`rnemy anoik b`nernm tdcehn wey fdr e `erkn oimustroe` sotn oi tgn snv-nitg bnitury AB. E`tgdukg din cokgt essucntget tgn `dbe` pdpu`etodi wdu`m gevn prnfnrrnm

    brncetodi oi tgn botys ner`y meys, fd``dwoik tgnbustdc df tgn cdtgnr bduitry, oi febt cdst dftgn hidwi krevns bdisost df oitnrcnits. Gdwnv-nr, tgn rnbnit mosbdvnry df tgn b`nernm brncetodi

    auroe` krduim di tgn Aor Cnssedume sotn cneistget tgos cdmn df auroe` cey gevn anni cdrnbdccdi tgei tgn d`mnr nxbevetodis sukknst.Rdcn df tgn oitnrcnit krevns bdisost df wddm-ni dr stdin bdfli krevns oi e mnnp sgeft, ceiydf wgobg gevn e snperetn iobgn fdr auroe` kddms,eim e soznea`n prdpdrtodi bdisosts df tdcascemn df gnwi stdin a`dbhs auronm mnnp an`dwtgn surfebn. ]nsn tdcas wnrn nvni bdvnrnmwotg e `eynr df p`estnr eim stiosgnm wotg wddm-ni pein`s. [otg tgn krdwtg df tgn pdpu`etodi

    Oibnisn aurinr, Aee`Geccdi8 Bertgekn,frdc tgn ]dpgnt8com1im bnitury AB8Cusn Ietodie` mn

    Bertgekn.

    22

    Z^IOB BEQ]GEKN 2

  • 7/21/2019 9789088903113 - Docter Et Al. 2015 - Carthage - eBook

    36/148

    2=

  • 7/21/2019 9789088903113 - Docter Et Al. 2015 - Carthage - eBook

    37/148

    ]gn ]dpgnt, oi tgnsdutg df tgn boty.

    2>

  • 7/21/2019 9789088903113 - Docter Et Al. 2015 - Carthage - eBook

    38/148

    eim tgn botys nxpeisodi, tgn inbrdpd`osns sgoftnmfurtgnr idrtg, td tgn go`` df Reoitn Cdioqun eimtgn p`etneu df Adrl Lnmom. Frdc tgn stftg bnituryAB diwerms, brncetodi anbecn tgn ru`n, pdssoa`yanbeusn df e `ebh df spebn8 oi tgn fdurtg td tgorm

    bniturons, tgn brncetnm rnceois wnrn frnqunit`yauronm oi e sce`` `ocnstdin adx wotg e `om sgepnm`ohn e semm`n rddf. ]os cdst prdaea`y rnfinbts tgnoifiunibn df tgn Krnnh wdr`m, es bnrteoi`y ep-p`ons oi tgn besn df tgn Inbrdpd`os df tgn Qeas,wgnrn tgn krevns df gokgreihoik emcoiostretovndflboe`s eim rn`okodus `nemnrs `ey oi Gn``niostobBertgekn. Krevn kofts tnim td an gokg`y steim-ermosnm eim tremotodie`, aut monr oi que`oty eimiucanr ebbdrmoik td tgn stetus df tgn mnbnesnm.]n strdik `oih wotg tgn cdtgnr bduitry os rn-

    finbtnm oi tgn botys auroe` rotue`s. Fdr oisteibn, tgnbustdc df scesgoik p`etns et tgn krevn eftnr tgnfuinre` cne` es wn`` es fuinrery oisbroptodis pdoittd auroe` rotns oitnimnm td prnsnrvn tgn mnbnesnmscncdry ecdik tgn ovoik.

    @eim ^sn, ]remn eim Fddm Rupp`y

    Ei nxtnisovn erbgend`dkobe` survny oi e remousdf tgorty ho`dcntrns erduim Bertgekn ges sgdwitget sce`` sntt`ncnits eim fercs mom idt eppneroi tgn rure` goitnr`eim uito` tgn comsoxtg bni-

    tury AB, eim nvni tgni tgny wnrn fnw oi iuc-anr. ]os pobturn eppners td mnrovn bdistrcetodifrdc snvnre` nbd`dkobe` stumons et Mutbg uiovnrso-tons. Qnsnerbg di tgn eioce` adin cetnroe` drok-oietoik frdc Bertgekn rnvne`s tget aorm guitoikp`eynm e celdr rd`n oi tgn ner`onst pnrodm. Oiemmotodi, tgn ocpdrteibn df bett`n eim gdrsns oitgos pnrodm kovns ei ocprnssodi df tgn occnmoetngoitnr`eim, soibn tgnsn ern `erkn cecce`s tgetinnm bdisomnrea`n krezoik spebn. [get os cdrn,stumons df oiboinretnm wddm rnsomuns oi dpgnt

    uris prdvn tget tgn oitnrodr wes sto`` bdvnrnm wotgwo`m vnkntetodi wn`` oitd tgn soxtg bnitury AB8ot wes di`y `etnr tget pruioiks frdc d`ovn trnnsstertnm td prnmdcoietn. Oi dtgnr wdrms, ot snncstget Bertgekn oiotoe``y cemn `ott`n usn df ots oc-cnmoetn goitnr`eim, rn`yoik oistnem di tgn sneeim di dvnrsnes tnrrotdrons subg es Rpeoi, Robo`y,eim Rermoioe. Rd oi ots ner`onst pnrodm et `nest, tgnboty stts tgn sbettnrnm goitnr`eims cdmn` tget ossd typobe` df tgn Cnmotnrreinei rnkodi frdc ei-toquoty uito` ner`y cdmnri tocns.

    Dnidbgdn, woin luk wotgfnce`n stkurn8 GnibgorAnio Iefe8 nxecp`n df

    Krnnh oifiunibn di Zuiobbnrecobs, 2rm bnitury AB8Cusn Ietodie` mu Aermd.

    ]gn serbdpgekn dftgn pronstnss df Osos,es ot os hidwi. Fduim

    oi e sgeft tdca, 51cntrns mnnp8 Cusn

    Ietodie` mn Bertgekn.

    26

    2 Z^IOB BEQ]GEKN

  • 7/21/2019 9789088903113 - Docter Et Al. 2015 - Carthage - eBook

    39/148

    2;2;

  • 7/21/2019 9789088903113 - Docter Et Al. 2015 - Carthage - eBook

    40/148

    Mnrcnbg

    Geiioae`s quertnr

    Ekdre

    ]dpgnt

    Co`otery

    Geradur

    A_QRE

    IN[ BO]_

    Reoitn-Cdioqun

    CNKEQE

    K^@F DF

    ]^IOR

    OR]GC^R

    ]ropp`n

    we

    ``

    hc

    :

    :.>

    5

    Ayrse

    Bdccnrb

    oe`

    Geradur

    Eie`ysns df treispdrt ecpgdren, tgn cdst bdc-cdi fddm bditeoinrs oi eibonit tocns, `erkn-`y bdistrc tgos pobturn. Oi tgn ner`onst `eynrsdf Bertgekn, e celdroty df ecpgdren bdcnfrdc Iurekob Rermoioe, Bnitre` Ote`y eim tgn

    Zgdnioboei rnkodi df sdutgnri Rpeoi. Oi tgnsuasnqunit pnrodm (b. 6;>->2: AB), Bertgeknsoccnmoetn goitnr`eim wes e`rnemy prdvomoik ge`fdf tgn treispdrt ecpgdren, e sgoft tget ges annirnbdrmnm wotg e s`okgt mn`ey oi tgn celdr survnycnitodinm eadvn. ]n trnim tdwerms krdwoik

    sn`fsuflboniby bditoiunm oi tgn fd``dwoik bnitu-ry, oi wgobg 7:7>% df tgn ecpgdren wnrn cemn`dbe``y dr rnkodie``y. E rn`etovn rosn td b. 2:% dfocpdrtnm treispdrt ecpgdren antwnni b. =2:eim 2:: AB bei an nxp`eoinm ay ocpdrts df spn-

    boe`osnm prdmubn (nspnboe``y woin) frdc sdutgnriOte`y (Be`earoe eim @ubeioe), tgn OdioeiEmroetobrnkodi (Epu`oe, Bdrfu eim E`aeioe), Robo`y,Rermoioe, eim tgn Idrtgnri Enknei. ]n tgormbnitury AB os pddr`y mdbucnitnm oi Bertgekn,aut oi tgn stie` pnrodm (frdc 1:: td 5=6 AB) wn

    27

    2 Z^IOB BEQ]GEKN

    ]gn Ayrse wes tgnbnitrn df eibonit

    Bertgekn. Rdutg dftgn go`` tgn bdccnrboe`

    eim co`otery geradurwnrn `dbetnm. ]gn

    ]dpgntos tgn p`ebnwgnrn ceiy uris wnrn

    fduim wotg rnceoisfrdc yduik bgo`mrni.

  • 7/21/2019 9789088903113 - Docter Et Al. 2015 - Carthage - eBook

    41/148

    Goppd QnkousBertgekn

    ^tobe

    Hnrhduein

    \ece

    Gemrucntuc

    ]uios

    2?

    Z^IOB BEQ]GEKN 2

    ekeoi snn e prnpdimnreibn df `dbe` eim rnkodie`prdmubn (b. 7>%). [otg tgn mnstiotn `dss df otsdvnrsnes tnrrotdrons eftnr tgn Rnbdim Zuiob [er,Bertgekn wes bdcpn``nm td krnet`y nxpeim ots

    rure` sntt`ncnits oi tgn oitnrodr df Idrtg Efrobe.]n erbgend`dkobe` survny cnitodinm eadvn gesprdvomnm bdivoiboik nvomnibn df tgos.

    Ot os tgnrnfdrn feor td esh wget Bertgekn gem tddnr oi nxbgeikn fdr tgn ocpdrts df subg `erknqueitotons df fddm prdmubn. Oi pert, Bertgeknpeom fdr tgnsn kddms wotg troautn bd``nbtnm frdcmnpnimnit rnkodis, aut tgos beiidt pdssoa`y antgn wgd`n nxp`eietodi, bnrteoi`y idt oi tgn ner-`onst pnrodm. Oisbroptodis di krevnstdins eim vd-

    tovn stn`en, b`essobe` sdurbns eim erbgend`dkobe`rnceois e`` kovn e b`ner pobturn df ei uraei sdbo-nty tget rn`onm gnevo`y di breftsceisgop eim tgnprdbnssoik df procery rew cetnroe`s oitd gokgque`oty prdmubts. Qnbnit rnsnerbg ges supp`onmocpdrteit nvomnibn df ovdry bervoik eim tnxto`nwdrhoik bdcaoinm wotg purp`n nxtrebtodi eimtgn cehoik df vnry gokgque`oty ordi prdmubts.

    Qn`okodi eim Rdbonty

    Hoik df tgn Boty Cn`qert wgdc tgn Krnnhsomnitostnm wotg Gnreb`ns wes tgn tutn`ery kdmdf yrn eim ots cdierbgy. Gn wes e`sd tgn pov-dte` movoioty tget `oihnm Bertgekn td ots cdtgnr

    boty. [n`` oitd tgn Gn``niostob pnrodm, tgn krnettncp`n mnmobetnm td Cn`qert oi yrn rnbnovnmeiiue` troautery kofts frdc Bertgekn eim dtgnrbd`dions. Oi Bertgekn tdd, tgnrn wes e b`ner bdi-inbtodi wotg tgn `dbe` cdierbgy, eim Cn`qertsrd`n rnceoinm ocpdrteit, nvni eftnr tgn nim dftgn fdurtg bnitury AB, wgni Bertgekn emdptnme cdrn mncdbretob pd`oty.

    ]n Zuiob peitgndi oib`umnm iucnrdus dtg-nr kdms ansomns Cn`qert, wgobg bei `ohnwosn

    an omnitostnm (wotg veryoik mnkrnns df bdist-mnibn) wotg Krnnh kdms eim cytgobe` anoiks; dr 5>2 AB, tgos dpu`nibncemn e krnet ocprnssodi di goc. Nvni tgdukgBertgekn gem anni mnfnetnm oi tgn Rnbdim Zuiob

    [er, fdrbnm td pey nidrcdus sucs oi wer oi-mnciotons fdr e`cdst ge`f e bnitury, ot mom idtsnnc rnmubnm td sebhb`dtg eim esgns8 quotn tgnbditrery. [otg tgn nim df tgn stftyyner trne-ty antwnni Qdce eim Bertgekn `ddcoik, etwgobg pdoit tgn peycnits wdu`m bnesn, tgn

    Qdceis fnernm tgn wdrst. ]n nxpeisodi drrnbdistrubtodi df tgn krnet geradur bdcp`nxwotg e snperetn borbu`er ieve` geradur oi tgospnrodm wo`` gevn nxebnraetnm tgnsn fners. Oi tgosbditnxt, Betds occdrte`, dftrnpnetnm pgresnbntnruc bnisnd Bertgekoinc nssn mn`nimec Cdrndvnr, O bdisomnr tget Bertgekn cust anmnstrdynm os nesy td uimnrsteim. E`tgdukg tgosvnrsodi, wotg ots tgrnnfd`m e``otnretodi, wes idtrnbdistrubtnm uito` 5715, ay tgn Knrcei gostd-roei Freiz Fonm`nr, ot os trun td tgn sporot df Betdswdrms. Z`uterbg wrdtn tget Betd gem seom , O an`onvn tgetBertgekn cust idt bditoiun td nxost.

    Eftnr e tgrnnyner sonkn, Qdcei trddps stie``ysnoznm tgn boty eim bdcp`ntn`y mnstrdynm ot. ]nQdcei kninre` Rbopod tgni gem se`t sbettnrnmerduim tgn wgd`n erne eim tgn krduim p`dukgnmup, sycad`osoik e bursn di tgn botys rninwnm oi-geaotetodi. Ei nitorn cntrdpd`os eim ots bdscd-pd`otei bu`turn bnesnm td nxost fdr e`` tocn, `ovoikdi di`y es e cncdry.

    =2

    Z^IOB BEQ]GEKN 2

    Rtetun df e Hdrn, e yduik wdcei. ]gos stetunwes fduim oi tgn 'Ceosdi mn `e Bebgnttn' oiBertgekn. Ot wes prdaea`y gommni oi ner`yBgrostoei tocns, td prnvnit ot frdc anoikmnstrdynm ay feietob Bgrostoei snbts. Bd``nbtodi

    ]GN Z^IOB [QO]OIK R_R]NC OR E@ZGEAN]OBE@,

    ER OR ]GN ZGDNIOBOEI CD]GNQ R_R]NC ]GE]

    FDQCR ]GN AEROR FDQ E@@ ]GN E@ZGEAN]OBE@

    R_R]NCR ]GE] EQN ^RNM OI ]GN [DQ@M ]DME_.

    ER ]GN_ NWZEIMNM ]GNOQ ZDRRNRRODIREQD^IM ]GN CNMO]NQQEINEI QNKODI, ]GN

    ZGDNIOBOEIR MORRNCOIE]NM E@@ ]GN VNGOB@NR

    EIM NWZQNRRODIR DF ]GNOQ B^@]^QN, R^BG ER

    ]GNOQ @EIK^EKN EIM RBQOZ], ]GQD^KG ]GNOQ

    ]QEMN RN]]@NCNI]R. E] RDCN ZDOI] ]GOR

    RBQOZ] BECN ]D AN MNRBQOANM OI ]GN [NR]

    ER Z^IOB.

    Mnteo` df e Zuiob stn`emosbdvnrnm ay Lnei-co`n Gucanrt (snnbgeptnr 5=)8 Bertgekn82rm -1im bnitury AB8Ietodie` Cusnuc dfEitoquotons8 oiv. id.G 5 (pgdtd< N. vei mniAeimt).

  • 7/21/2019 9789088903113 - Docter Et Al. 2015 - Carthage - eBook

    48/148

    [n cey rnbe`` tget tgn wdrm e`pgeant os cemnup df tgn strst twd `nttnrs df tgn Rncotob e`pge-ant (e`npgeim ant). Ot os epprdproetn td stert aykovoik e aronf dvnrvonw df tgn drokois df tgos e`-pgeant oi ots drokoie` surrduimoiks, eim df tgn

    gostdrobe` eim bu`ture` bdimotodis tget fdstnrnmtgos oivnitodi.

    ]n ner`onst nvomnibn metns frdc tgn strst ge`fdf tgn snbdim co``niiouc AB eim bdcns frdcRyroeZe`nstoin eim Nkypt. ]n pndp`ns oi-geaotoik tgn fdrcnr, subg es tgn Gnarnws, tgnZgdnioboeis eim tgn Erecneis, spdhn `eikueknsrn`etnm td tgn Rncotob feco`y df `eikuekns frdctgn [nst, subg es ^kerotob eim Beieeiotn. Ot wesfrdc tgnsn tget Gnarnw eim Zgdnioboei mnvn`-

    dpnm oi tgn strst co``niiouc AB, wotg e Zuiobveroeit oi tgn wnstnri Cnmotnrreinei rnkodi.]n nestnri Rncotob areibg (Ehhemoei) wgobgwes spdhni oi Cnsdpdtecoe (prnsnitmey Oreq),eim tgn sdutgwnstnri Rncotob areibg (Eiboniteim B`essobe` Ereaob wotg ots moe`nbts, Rdutg

    Ereaoei eim tgn Ntgodpoei `eikuekns) nxostnme`diksomn tgnc.

    Oi tgn snbdim co``niiouc AB, tgn idrtg-wnstnri rnkodi df tgn Comm`n Nest, tget os, tgnCnmotnrreinei rnkodi tget wes aduimnm ay

    Eietd`oe eim Nkypt, wes mdcoietnm ay tgn pd-`otobe` eim bu`ture` oifiunibn df tgn twd celdrrnkodie` pdwnrs< Cnsdpdtecoe di din somn eimNkypt di tgn dtgnr. Gdwnvnr, Ehhemoei wes tgnprnveo`oik `eikuekn oi tgn Comm`n Nest, pertobu-`er`y oi mop`dcetob borb`ns. Ehhemoei gem ceiysoco`erotons td dtgnr `eikuekns oi tgn rnkodi,wotg e sy``eaob, buinofdrc sbropt idtwotg-steimoik tgn `erkn iucanr df bgerebtnrs tgetwes cdrn ebbnssoa`n tgei Nkyptoei gonrdk`ypg-obs. Gonrdk`ypgobs wnrn idt di`y cdrn bdcp`o-

    betnm, aut tgny mom idt an`dik td tgn Rncotobkrdup.

    Ot wes oi tgos pd`otobe` eim bu`ture` bditnxt tgete`pgeantobe` sbropt wes oivnitnm oi tgn strst ge`fdf tgn snbdim co``niiouc AB. ]nrn ern tddfnw survovoik mdbucnits td metn tgn oivnitodicdrn prnbosn`y. ]n inw sbropt wes bdisdiei-te`< tget os, wotg e spnbostb krepgncn dr `nttnrfdr nebg bdisdieit. ]os os pnrfnbt`y suotnm tdtgn bdisdieite` strubturn df Rncotob `eikuekns.

    ]n bdisdieits ern krdupnm oi tgrnns, prdmub-oik e tgrnn`nttnr rddt tget nxprnssns e wdrmsfuimecnite` cneioik. Bdisdieits ettebgnm tdtgn rddt es prnstxns eim suflxns bdivny mnrovnmcneioiks, cddms (o.n. ebtovn/pessovn/sualuib-

    tovn) eim kreccetobe` fdrcs. ]n vdbe`osetodidf wdrms tddh p`ebn oi e ieture` wey, eim tgncneioik df nebg wdrm wes occnmoetn`y b`ner.]os bdisdieite` strubturn df tgn Rncotob `ei-kuekns prdvomnm tgn aesos fdr tgn oivnitodi dftgn e`pgeant. ]n pgdincns (sduims) df nebgwdrm ern oimobetnm ay tgn bdisdieits. Ay osd-`etoik tgnsn, eim ay wrotoik mdwi nebg din ese snperetn bgerebtnr dr `nttnr, ot anbecn pdsso-a`n td bdivny e wdrm ay usoik tgn `nttnrs tgetrnprnsnitnm tgn bdisdieits oi dtgnr wdrms, oi

    sbropt. ]os wrotoik os tnrcnm e`pgeantobe` soibntgn vdwn` sokis wnrn di`y emmnm `etnr.

    Drokois df tgn ner`y e`pgeant

    Ebbdrmoik td mdbucnits tget ern eveo`ea`n td ustdmey, tgn d`mnst fu`` bdisdieite` e`pgeant wesusnm oi tgn fdurtnnitg bnitury AB oi ^kerot, tgneibonit hoikmdc wgdsn rnceois bei an fduim etQes Rgecre, b`dsn td tgn boty df @etehoe oi tgnidrtg df prnsnitmey Ryroe. [otg ots tgorty bu-inofdrc bgerebtnrs, wgobg ern socp`nr oi sgepn

    tgei tgdsn df Ehhemoei, tgos e`pgeant rnprn-snits tgn bdisdieits df ^kerotob, wgobg an`dikstd tgn Idrtgwnst Rncotob feco`y df `eikuekns.Guimrnms df cytgobe`, `nke`, mop`dcetob, eimrn`okodus tnxts tget ern mrewi up oi tgos sbroptsgdw tget tgn oigeaoteits df tgn rnkodi gem ekddm bdcceim df ot eim tget ots oivnitodi met-nm frdc ei ner`onr ekn. Bnrteoi soco`erotons suk-knst tget tgn oivnitdrs emeptnm tgn [nstnri e`-pgeantobe` systnc td tgn buinofdrc tnbgioqun.]n ^kerotob eyoi, fdr oisteibn, rnsnca`ns tgn

    Zgdnioboei eyoi. Oi emmotodi, tgn `nttnrs oi tgn^kerotob eim Zgdnioboei e`pgeants eppner oi esoco`er drmnr. B`ner`y, tgni, ^kerotob mom idtprdvomn tgn aesos fdr Zgdnioboei sbropt.

    Roco`er`y, wn nxb`umn tgn sbropts wgobg ern idtynt mnbopgnrnm eim oi wgobg ern wrottni sdcnsdbe``nm prdtdBeieeiotn tnxts. ]nsn metnfrdc tgn com snbdim co``niiouc AB. ]nitgnrn os eidtgnr sbropt, wgobg usns e `ocotnmiucanr df bgerebtnrs, sdcn oi tgn fdrc df sbgn-

    Zuiob stn`e mosbdvnrnmay Lneico`n Gucanrt

    (snn bgeptnr 5=)8Bertgekn8 2rm 1im

    bnitury AB8 Ietodie`Cusnuc df Eitoquotons8

    oiv. id. G 5.

    =6

    = ]GN Z^IOB [QO]OIK R_R]NC

  • 7/21/2019 9789088903113 - Docter Et Al. 2015 - Carthage - eBook

    49/148

    cetob pobtdkrecs eim dtgnrs cdrn kndcntrobe`.]os sbropt bei an metnm td id `etnr tgei tgn stf-tnnitg bnitury AB, di tgn aesos df tgortydinoisbroptodis fduim oi tgn sdutgwnstnri Roieo,di tgn p`etneu df Rnreaot n`Hgemoc, oi e coin

    frdc wgobg tgn Nkyptoeis nxtrebtnm turqudosn.]nsn oisbroptodis wnrn nikrevnm `ohn gonrd-k`ypgob tnxts di tgn we``s df coin ke``nrons eimdi seimstdin p`equns eim stetuns, aut wrottnioi e monrnit sbropt. ]os sbropt os an`onvnm td ane`pgeantobe`, aesnm di tgn tgndrons put fdrwermay F`oimnrs Zntron eim cdst idtea`y Kermoinr8 otusns e `ocotnm iucanr df bgerebtnrs tget rnprn-snit bdisdieits, wgobg bei an essucnm td mnrovnfrdc gonrdk`ypgobs. ]n mnbopgnrnm snqunibnsrnvne` tget tgos sbropt os ei nxprnssodi df e wnst-

    nri Rncotob `eikuekn. [n md idt hidw wgdwrdtn tgnsn oisbroptodis. ]ny cey gevn anniRncotob wdrhnrs oi tgn snrvobn df tgn Zgeredgs,dr gokgreihoik dflboe`s wgd supnrvosnm tgnsnwdrhnrs dr wgd an`diknm td ei nxpnmotodi `nmay e proibn frdc e rnkodi di tgn nestnri bdestdf tgn Cnmotnrreinei. wd dtgnr oisbroptodis,wgobg wnrn rnbnit`y fduim et @uxdr oi tgn voboi-oty df tgn Io`n, cehn ot b`ner tget tgos sbropt momidt drokoietn frdc tgn Roieo, wgnrn tgn ieture`nivordicnit wes idt suotnm td tgn mnvn`dpcnitdf uraei eim bu`ture` `ofn.

    ]os sbropt usns pobtdkrecs td rnimnr tgn bdi-sdieits oi wrottni fdrc. Nebg bdisdieit osrnprnsnitnm ay ei eastrebtnm mrewoik df ei da-

    lnbt wgdsn iecn ankois wotg tgos bdisdieit.]n `nttnr e`npg, fdr oisteibn, os rnprnsnitnm aytgn gnem df ei dx, wgobg os be``nm e`npgoi tgoswnstnri Rncotob `eikuekn. ]os os hidwi es eiebrdpgdiob systnc, eim os monrnit frdc tgngonrdk`ypgobs systnc. Oi tgn `ettnr, tgn sokisrnprnsnitoik bdisdieits wnrn usnm td treisbroan

    fdrnoki iecns, eim pertobu`er`y es pgdintob sup-p`ncnits td omndkrecs.

    Frdc tgnsn oisbroptodis wn bei oifnr tget eie`pgeantobe` systnc wes mnvn`dpnm eim usnmoi eim erduim tgn rnkodi df RyroeZe`nstoinet sdcn pdoit oi tgn `ettnr ge`f df tgn snbdimco``niiouc AB. ]os prdaea`y tddh p`ebn lustanfdrn tgn tocn oi wgobg tgn ZrdtdRoieotob oi-sbroptodis wnrn cemn, tgn sgepns df wgdsn `nttnrssto`` krnet`y rnsnca`nm pobtdkrecs. ]os mnvn`dp-

    =;

    ]GN Z^IOB [QO]OIK R_R]NC =

  • 7/21/2019 9789088903113 - Docter Et Al. 2015 - Carthage - eBook

    50/148

    =7

  • 7/21/2019 9789088903113 - Docter Et Al. 2015 - Carthage - eBook

    51/148

    cnit os vnry b`ner frdc tgn strst Zgdnioboei oi-sbroptodis wgobg metn frdc tgn n`nvnitg bnitu-ry AB et tgn ner`onst, eim wgobg rnvne` tget tgnZgdnioboeis gem `dik anni usoik ei e`pgeant.

    ]os e`pgeant bdisosts df twnitytwd `nttnrs,wgdsn sgepns bditoiunm td mnvn`dp dvnr tgnyners, adtg oi tgn nest eim wnst df tgn Zgdnioboeitnrrotdrons. Es tgn Zgdnioboeis nxpeimnm tdwermstgn wnst ebbdrmoik td Krnnh eim Qdcei `otnr-ery sdurbns, nxp`drnrs frdc yrn ncaerhnm ditgos wnstwerm nxpeisodi oi tgn twn`ftg bnituryAB tgny tddh tgnor wrotoik systnc wotg tgnc.

    Ebbdrmoik td tgn oisbroptodi di e krevn metoikfrdc tgn ioitg bnitury AB, tgny oiotoe``y sntt`nm

    di Byprus, wgobg fdrcs tgn strst stnp oi tgos nx-peisodi. Dtgnr npokrepgs rnvne` tget tgn sbroptwes usnm di Brntn eim Rermoioe oi tgn ioitgbnitury. ]nrn ern e krnet ceiy oisbroptodis met-oik frdc tgn nokgtg eim nspnboe``y tgn snvnitgbnitury AB, wgobg prdvn tget tgn sbropt wesvnry bdccdi oi tgn wnstnri Zgdnioboei wdr`m.

    ]n `erknst iucanr df oisbroptodis, gdwnvnr,wnrn fduim oi Bertgekn. Dvnr sox tgduseimoisbroptodis wnrn fduim oi tgn eiot eim Aee`Geccdi seibtuery dr dpgnt (snn Bgeptnr >).

    E `erkn `otnrery dnuvrn wes prdmubnm oi tgossbropt, aut ot ges sem`y pnrosgnm e`cdst wotgduttrebn, `nevoik di`y nbgdns oi tgn wrotnrs df tgneitoqun wdr`m.

    Frdc tgn snvnitg bnitury AB diwerms, tgnsnoisbroptodis eim dtgnr bu`ture` nxprnssodis dftgn wnstnri Zgdnioboei wdr`m ern b`essostnm esZuiob di tgn aesos df bnrteoi mostoibtovn fne-turns. Rtumons df tgnsn npokrepgs rnvne` tget otwes oi tgn snvnitg bnitury tget Zuiob sbropt

    stertnm td mosp`ey e iucanr df bgerebtnrostob mn-teo`s oi bnrteoi `nttnrs (e`npg,ydm, eim hef). Oi tgn`ettnr ge`f df tgn soxtg bnitury AB, tgnsn bgeiknse`sd oifiunibnm tgn sgepns df dtgnr `nttnrs, subges kocn`, zeyoi, `ecnm, cc, iui, secnh eim

    qdpg. ]os pgnidcnidi bditoiunm oi tgn fd`-`dwoik bniturons, wotg tgn sgepns df tgnsn `nttnrskremue``y anbdcoik cdrn finxoa`n, wotg e tni-mniby tdwerms `niktgnioik eim n`nkeibn.

    ^imnr tgn oifiunibn df bursovn sbropt, tgn sgepnsdf bnrteoi `nttnrs oi sdcn oisbroptodis wnrn soc-p`ostnm tdwerms tgn nim df tgn tgorm bnitury AB.

    Eftnr tgn mnstrubtodi df Bertgekn, tgos mnvn`dp-cnit sprnem erduim Idrtg Efrobe. ]n trnimtdwerms cdrn sbgncetob sgepns anbecn sd uio-vnrse` tget tgn sbropt df tgnsn tnxts os b`essostnmes indZuiob. Rdcn `nttnrs, subg es ant, me`ntgeim rnsg, wnrn oimobetnm di`y ay sce`` mesgns,cehoik oisbroptodis bdifusoik td rnem.

    Oi emmotodi, tgn pgdintob systnc stertnm td mos-oitnkretn. ]n kutture` sduims wnrn frnqunit`ydcottnm dr usnm oitnrbgeiknea`y. ]os oimobetnstget tgnor rd`n oi prdiuiboetodi wes mnb`oioik.

    Et tgn secn tocn bdifusodi erdsn wotg dtgnrpgdincns, subg es soao`eits eim gossoik bdisd-ieits.

    Furtgnr rnsnerbg oimobetns tget tgnsn kuttur-e` sduims gem eidtgnr fuibtodi. ]ny mnidtnmvdwn`s es wn`` es bdisdieits. ]n vdwn` /d/ osrnimnrnm ay ei e`npg, tgn /e/ ay din df tgn bdi-

    sdieits eyoi, gnt eim g. ]nsn kutture`s wnrntgnrnfdrn idt rne` vdwn`s8 retgnr, tgny febo`otetnmprdiuiboetodi eim rnemoik, oimobetoik vdwn`s eswget ern hidwi es cetrns `nbtodios.

    ]n brnetodi df tgos vdbe`osetodi systnc oi indZuiob uimduatnm`y tddh p`ebn uimnr tgn oi-fiunibn df @etoi. Gdwnvnr, ot wes hidwi wn``anfdrn tgos. ]n Erecneis stertnm usoik tgnsncobdisdieits weweimydmtd oimobetn vdw-n`s et tgn ankoiioik df tgn strst co``niiouc. ]n

    indZuiob sbropt bditoiunm td an usnm oi IdrtgEfrobe uito` et `nest tgn tgorm bnitury EM. Ot wesanbeusn df tgos tget tgn Zgdnioboei e`pgeant,wgobg gem `dik anbdcn nxtoibt oi tgn Nest, wesea`n td survovn gnrn.

    =?

    ]GN Z^IOB [QO]OIK R_R]NC =

    Zuiob stn`enmosbdvnrnm ay Lnei-Nco`n Gucanrt wotggos pdrtreot oi tgnaebhkrduim (pgdtd< N.vei mni Aeimt).

  • 7/21/2019 9789088903113 - Docter Et Al. 2015 - Carthage - eBook

    52/148

    >:

  • 7/21/2019 9789088903113 - Docter Et Al. 2015 - Carthage - eBook

    53/148

    ]GN ]DZGN]DF BEQ]GEKN

    Ocnm Ani Lnraeioe

    >5

    ]GN ]DZGN] DF BEQ]GEKN, [GOBG K^R]EVN

    F@E^ANQ] OCCDQ]E@ORNM OI GOR IDVN@

    RE@ECCA 5761, [ER RZOQO]NM OI]D

    ]DZOBE@O]_ OI 5?15 [GNI FQEIDOR OBEQM, EZD@OBN OIRZNB]DQ OI ]^IOR, EIM ]GN @DBE@

    C^IOBOZE@ DFFOBOE@ ZE^@ KON@@_ MORBDVNQNM

    E ZONBN DF @EIM ]GE] [ER R]^MMNM [O]G

    BOZZO,EIM NZOKQEZGOB EIM EINZOKQEZGOB

    R]N@EN, EIM BOINQEQ_ ^QIR [GOBG

    BDI]EOINM OIFEI] EIM EIOCE@ ADINR FDQ

    ]GN C@HREBQOFOBN.

    ]dpgnt wotg stn`enfrdc moffnrnit pnrodms.

  • 7/21/2019 9789088903113 - Docter Et Al. 2015 - Carthage - eBook

    54/148

    ]os mosbdvnry cemn ot pdssoa`n td `dbetn tgn sotntget wes hidwi frdc eibonit `otnreturn. ]nnxostnibn df tgos dpgnt wotg ots tgduseims dfcncdroe`s eim uris wes e`rnemy wn`` hidwi oitgn comiointnnitg bnitury, soibn snvnre` perts

    df ot gem anni uibdvnrnm muroik b`eimnstoinnxbevetodis. ]n mosbdvnry df tgn fecdus stn`ewotg pronst eim bgo`m, wgobg os idw oi tgn AermdCusnuc, prdcptnm Kon``y td bdimubt gos dwirnsnerbg, eim gn purbgesnm tgn ponbn df `eim diwgobg tgn dalnbt gem anni fduim. ]os purbgesncerhs tgn stert df rnku`er nxbevetodis oi tgndpgnt.

    Roibn tgni, snvnre` prdlnbts gevn anni berronm dutdi tgn emlebnit p`dts df eim, wgobg gem anni eb-

    quornm ner`onr. Antwnni tgn strst nxbevetodis uimnrtgn supnrvosodi df Oberm oi 5?11 eim tgn est dinsbdimubtnm ay @ewrnibn Rteknr oi 5?;1 es pert

    df tgn oitnrietodie` becpeoki fdr tgn prnsnrve-todi df Bertgekn, snvnre` dtgnrs wnrn berronm dut ]GN ]DZGN] DF BEQ]GEKN

  • 7/21/2019 9789088903113 - Docter Et Al. 2015 - Carthage - eBook

    55/148

    es ecu`nts dr ponbns df lnwn``nry. ]n brncetnmrnceois tget wnrn auronm oi tgos wey wnrn frn-qunit`y cerhnm ay cdiucnits nrnbtnm di tdp,aut oi tgn ner`onst pgesn df tgn dpgnt tgos wesmdin di`y oi sn`nbt besns. ]nsn cerhnrs, wgobg

    ern fduim oi tgn mnnpnst `eynrs, ern cdid`otgs,`erkn rovnr stdins dr boppo(bd`ucis). ]n stn`en,sdcn df tgnc aneroik oisbroptodis, stert eppner-oik frnqunit`y oi tgn fdurtg bnitury AB. ]nyern mnbdretnm wotg rotue` ocekns (nca`ncs eimmovoin ettroautns, omd`s, eim dbbesodie``y sebrost-boe` sbnins) eim vdtovn oisbroptodis oitnimnm tdprnsnrvn tgn cncdry df tgn sebrostbn td tgn kdmsAee` Geccdi eim gos bdisdrt eiot. ]n wdrm-oik df tgn preynrs eim tgeihs td tgnsn movoiotons,wgobg ern dftni prnbnmnm ay knine`dkons df tgn

    mnmobeit, ern gokg`y steimermosnm eim rnpntotovn.]n rn`etodisgop antwnni tgn stn`en eim tgn urisos veroea`n, eim ot wdu`m an wrdik td essucn tgetnvnry uri cust gevn gem e cncdroe` stdin dfsdcn hoim. Oimnnm, tgn nxbevetodis gevn ardukgttd `okgt e veronty df bdcaoietodis< din dr cdrnuris aninetg dr ansomn e cncdroe` stdin, din drcdrn uris wotgdut eiy cncdroe` stdin et e``, eimcncdroe` stdins wotg dr wotgdut din dr cdrnuris. [get os cdrn, ndrts td nstea`osg tgn mornbtstretokrepgobe` rn`etodis antwnni tgnsn ocpdrteitn`ncnits df tgn tdpgnt gevn idt ynt subbnnmnm.

    ]n oisbroanm eim oi sdcn besns sbu`ptnm cdtofstget ern vosoa`n di tgn boppoeim stn`en kninre``ypdssnss e sycad`ob eim/dr mnbdretovn fuibtodi.]n cdst bdccdi nca`ncs ern tgn soki df eioteim tgn sdbe``nm adtt`n omd`. ]ny wnrn usue``yp`ebnm oi e sgroin di tgn e`ter. Mntnrcoioik tgnp`ebn df tgnsn obdidkrepgobe` sbnins oi Zuiob rn-`okodus sycad`osc os idt e`weys socp`n, eim tgnorsokiostbeibn os cdrn dasburn sto``.

    ]n verodus nxbevetodis tget gevn anni bdimubt-

    nm di tgn sebrnm sotn rnvne` tget nebg `nvn`, dr`eynr, bditeois bnrteoi stxnm typns df mnpdsotodis.Oi dtgnr wdrms, monrnit typns df uris, boppoeimstn`en gevn anni fduim oi subbnssovn `eynrs wotgmonrnit metns. ]n d`mnst `eynr metns frdc tgnnokgtg bnitury AB. ]n uris tget dbbur cdst frn-qunit`y oi tgos `eynr ern pdts aesnm di Dronite`nxecp`ns. ]ny ern nkksgepnm dr spgnrobe`, eimgevn twd syccntrobe``yp`ebnm geim`ns di tgnsgdu`mnrs. ]ny gevn e roiksgepnm aesn eim ernmnbdretnm wotg kndcntrobe` cdtofs. ]n prnsnibn

    Ei ^ri oi @nomni eim tgn Nxbevetodis dfHn`sny eim Hgui Mn Zrdrdh]gn Ietodie` Cusnuc df Eitoquotons oi @nomni pdssnssns

    e iucanr df brncetodi uris frdc tgn ]dpgnt df Bertgekn.

    Din df tgnc, ebbdrmoik td ots `ean`, bdcns frdc tgn nx-

    bevetodis bdimubtnm ay Freibos [. Hn`sny oi 5?1>, wgobgwnrn stieibnm ay tgn fiecadyeit sn`fsty`nm Bduit Hgui

    Mn Zrdrdh, ei Ecnrobei df Guikeroei mnsbnit eim e typo-

    be` nxpdinit df tgn Qderoik ]wnitons. Gn gem purbgesnm

    tgn `eim di wgobg Freidos Oberm eim Zeu` Kon``y bdimubtnm

    tgnor strst nxbevetodis oi tgn ]dpgnt oi 5?11. ]gn uri aners

    Hn`snys oivnitdry iucanr R5=66. Ebbdrmoik td tgn iuc-

    anroik oi tgn Ldurie` wotg Oivnitdry df Dalnbts Fduim tget

    os prnsnrvnm oi Gerverm, ot wes din df ;= uris nxbevetnm

    di 5> Epro` 5?1>. ]grnn iucanrs ern cossoik frdc tgn `ost

    oi Gerverm, oib`umoik R5=66, wgobg os idw oi @nomni. Gdw

    mom tgn uri nim up gnrn4 ]gn `ohn`onst nxp`eietodi os tgetot wes kovni dr sd`m td e vosotdr, muroik dr sgdrt`y eftnr tgn

    nxbevetodi. Oi febt wn prdaea`y hidw tget vosotdrs omnito-

    ty. Fdr tgn bd``nbtodi df ]dpgnt vesns td wgobg tgos uri an-

    `diks wes purbgesnm ay tgn cusnuc di 1: Fnaruery 5?>1

    frdc Cr K.E.G. Aossn`oik, wgd wes buretdr df tgn Mutbg

    Cusnuc df Nmubetodi (tgn prnbursdr df Cusndi). Ebbdrmoik

    td tgn oifdrcetodi rnbdrmnm et tgn tocn df tgn se`n td tgn

    Ietodie` Cusnuc df Eitoquotons, gn gem ebquornm tgn otncs

    gocsn`f oi Bertgekn. ]gn Arotosg Cusnuc oi @dimdi eim tgn

    Esgcd`nei Cusnuc oi Dxfdrm e`sd pdssnss uris frdc tgnsn

    nxbevetodis. ]gn ean` e`sd rnfnrs td e dbetodi iucanr, 256,

    wgobg sgdwnm wgnrn tgn uri wes auronm oi rn`etodi td tgdsnnxbevetnm lust anfdrn eim lust eftnr ot. ^ifdrtuietn`y tgos

    bditnxtue` oifdrcetodi bei id `diknr an rnbdistrubtnm.

    ]gn uri bei an metnm td tgn soxtg dr stftg bnitury AB eim bdi-

    teois tgn brncetnm rnceois df e inwadri aeay eim e `eca.

    Qde`m Mdbtnr

    >2

    ]GN ]DZGN] DF BEQ]GEKN >

    Mrewoik df ei

    uri frdc tgn]dpgnt.

  • 7/21/2019 9789088903113 - Docter Et Al. 2015 - Carthage - eBook

    56/148

    >=

  • 7/21/2019 9789088903113 - Docter Et Al. 2015 - Carthage - eBook

    57/148

    df tgnsn lers os sdcntocns cerhnm ay socp`n stdins dr @sgepnm seimstdinboppo. Aut tgn otncs df pdttnry tget ern kninre``y rnkermnm es tgn cdst oc-pdrteit frdc tgos ner`y pnrodm df tgn dpgnt ern tgdsn fduim oi tgn sgroinhidwi es tgn Bgepn``n Boites. Qnbnit stumons sukknst tget tgnsn coi-oeturn vesns cey gevn anni prdmubnm `dbe``y. ]n botys nxpeisodi eim

    mnvn`dpcnit eppners td gevn krnet`y rnmubnm tgn eveo`ea`n spebn fdr tgnmnpdsotodi df dnroiks. Rnvnre` nxbevetodis oi tgn dpgnt df Bertgekngevn mncdistretnm tget tgn krduim wes rnku`er`y wdrhnm eim reosnm.

    [gninvnr tgnrn wes e `ebh df spebn, tgn krduim wes reosnm td tgn `nvn`mnsornm, td cehn rddc fdr tgn mnpdsotodi df inw uris eim tgn p`eboik dfcdiucnits, snperetnm ay petgs. ]n uris di tgn uppnr nvn`s ern nss eim`nss n`nkeit. ]ny ern oibrnesoik`y s`nimnr, eim tgnor mnbdretodis ern erkn-`y rumocnitery, oi ceiy besns bdistinm td e fnw peoitnm dr sbdrnm `oins.Ot os di tgn aesos df tgos bnrecob cetnroe` tget M.A. Germni prdpdsnm eb`essostbetodi df tgn dpgnt oitd tgrnn celdr pgesns (eiot O, OO eim OO),wgobg sdcn eutgdrs ebbnpt es e ardem bgrdid`dkobe` frecnwdrh.

    ]n qunstodi df tgn sokiostbeibn td an ettebgnm td tgn rotue`s tget wnrn ni-ebtnm et tgn dpgnt fdr e`cdst snvni bniturons sto`` fun`s mnaetn td tgos mey.Rgdu`m wn ebbnpt tget bgo`m sebrostbns wnrn dnrnm td tgn kdms oi Bertgekn,dr rnlnbt tgos nxp`eietodi es e cytg4 ]n sualnbt sto`` movomns dpoiodi oi tgnbdccuioty df nxpnrts di tgn Rncotob wdr`m.

    Ceiy eibonit eim Bgrostoei gostdroeis emdptnm e pd`ncob epprdebg tdtgn sualnbt. dmey, sdcn eutgdrs snerbg fdr nvomnibn oi tgn `otnreturn tgetcey suppdrt tgn gypdtgnsos df bgo`m sebrostbns. Ot sgdu`m an adrin oi coim,gdwnvnr, tget bditncpdrery gostdroeis subg es ]ubymomns eim Zd`yaousinvnr cnitodinm tgos sualnbt. Furtgnrcdrn, erbgend`dky ges idt ynt prd-

    vomnm eiy bdivoiboik nvomnibn td bdrrdadretn tgn `otnrery nvomnibn tgetbgo`mrni wnrn sebrostbnm td tgn ardizn stetun df Brdids. Din sdurbn rn`etnstget Bertgekoioei bgo`mrni wnrn `eom oi tgn stetuns ercs, eim wdu`m s`omnmdwi ditd e anm df k`dwoik bde`s an`dw. ]nrn gevn e`weys anni twdbecps. Di tgn din somn ern tgn rnvosodiosts, wgd an`onvn tget tgn dpgntwes socp`y e auroe` krduim fdr bgo`mrni wgd wnrn sto``adri dr wgd monmoi oifeiby, di tgn dtgnr somn e krdup df sbgd`ers wgd oisost tget bgo`mrniwnrn sebrostbnm. Idwemeys e tgorm krdup ges erosni, e krdup tget emdptssdcntgoik df ei oitnrcnmoetn pdsotodi. ]nsn ern sbgd`ers wgd pdsot tgettgn dpgnt wes e sebrnm inbrdpd`os, wgobg cey bditeoi sdcn spdremob rn-ceois df sebrostbns, aut tget ot wes nssnitoe``y e bncntnry fdr bgo`mrni wgd

    monm frdc ieture` beusns.

    [getnvnr tgn besn cey an, tgn eutgdrs md idt an`onvn tget mosbussodis dftgn dpgnt sgdu`m an `ocotnm td e bditrdvnrsy eadut wgntgnr dr idt ot wesusnm fdr sebrostbns, `nemoik td rnsnerbg subg es e rnbnit stumy aesnm di ds-tnd`dkobe` eie`ysns df tgn gucei eim eioce` adin rnceois. d keoi cdrnoisokgt oitd tgn an`onfs eim tgn rn`okodus dut`ddh df tgn Bertgekoioeis, otcey an df krnetnr ocpdrteibn td fdbus di tgn dpgnts erbgend`dky (o.n. otsstretokrepgy, ots bdcpdinit perts, eim ots tdpdkrepgy), td eie`ysn tgn uris,eim td stumy tgn dpgnts vosue` bu`turn, nspnboe``y tgn obdidkrepgy df tgnstn`en eim tgnor oisbroptodis.

    Rtn`e wotgn`npgeit8Bertgekn8 2rm-1im bnitury AB8Cusn Ietodie`mn Bertgekn.

    Bnrncdioe` rezdr, 2rmbnitury AB8 CusnIetodie` mu Aermd.

    [gni e mnem admywes `eom dut, tgnadmy geor wesrncdvnm.

    >>

    ]GN ]DZGN] DF BEQ]GEKN >

    >>

  • 7/21/2019 9789088903113 - Docter Et Al. 2015 - Carthage - eBook

    58/148

  • 7/21/2019 9789088903113 - Docter Et Al. 2015 - Carthage - eBook

    59/148

    NK_Z]OEI

    OIF@^NIBN OIBEQ]GEKN

    ]edusth Qnmosso

    >;

    ]GN ZER] ]GOQ]_ _NEQR GEVN RNNI E KQD[OIKOI]NQNR] OI QNRNEQBG DI ]GN OIF@^NIBN

    DF NK_Z]OEI B^@]^QN DI D]GNQ QNKODIR

    EQD^IM ]GN CNMO]NQQEINEI RNE. DF E@@

    ]GN Z@EBNR OI ]GN [NR]NQI CNMO]NQQEINEI

    QNKODI, O] OR OI BEQ]GEKN ]GE] ]GN @EQKNR]

    I^CANQ DF EC^@N]R, RBEQEAR EIM

    RBEQEADOMR GEVN ANNI FD^IM. ]GN ZER]

    ]GOQ]_ _NEQR GEVN RNNI E KQD[OIK OI]NQNR]OI QNRNEQBG DI ]GN OIF@^NIBN DF NK_Z]OEI

    B^@]^QN DI D]GNQ QNKODIR EQD^IM ]GN

    CNMO]NQQEINEI RNE. DF E@@ ]GN Z@EBNR OI

    ]GN [NR]NQI CNMO]NQQEINEI QNKODI, O] OR

    OI BEQ]GEKN ]GE] ]GN @EQKNR] I^CANQ DF

    EC^@N]R, RBEQEAR EIM RBEQEADOMR GEVN

    ANNI FD^IM.

    kint roik wotg Nkyptoei sbnin8

    rtgekn, Ayrse8 ;tg -6tg bnitury

    B8 Cusn Ietodie` mn Bertgekn.

    >;

    ]nrrebdtte stetun dfe spgoix8 ;tg bnituryAB8 Cusn Ietodie`mn Bertgekn (pgdtd< N.vei mni Aeimt).

  • 7/21/2019 9789088903113 - Docter Et Al. 2015 - Carthage - eBook

    60/148

    ]n stimoiks eim bdib`usodis df rnbnit rnsnerbgidw p`ebn us di strcnr krduim oi mosbussoiktgn movnrsn betnkdrons df dalnbts frdc Bertgeknrnfinbtoik Nkyptoei oifiunibn. ]nsn Nkyptoeisty`n ertnfebts dr Enkyptoebe borbu`etnm erduimtgn Cnmotnrreinei oi tgn strst co``niioucAB. Dalnbts fduim oi Bertgekn tget ern notgnr

    Nkyptoei dr prdmubnm uimnr Nkyptoei oifiunibndbbur ceoi`y oi krevns eim sdcntocns oi tgndpgnt, eim cdst ern ecu`nts eim sne`s.

    ]ny o``ustretn tgn rd`n tget tgn Zuiob cntrdpd`osp`eynm oi tgn mossncoietodi df Nkyptoei bu`turn.]os tddh p`ebn idt di`y oi tgn tnrrotdry df prns-nitmey uiosoe, aut e`sd cubg furtgnr estn`m,ay wey df Zgdnioboei eim Zuiob sntt`ncnits oitgn wnstnri Cnmotnrreinei rnkodi.

    ]n usn df ecu`nts oi Bertgekn mncdistretns tgnoifiunibn df Nkyptoei rn`okodi eim cekob. ]nsnotncs wnrn ceoi`y usnm td prdtnbt oimovomue`s,wgntgnr mnem dr e`ovn, frdc nvo` fdrbns. [go`nceiy df tgn ecu`nts fduim oi Bertgekn becnfrdc Nkypt, dtgnrs drokoietnm frdc tgn bdeste`rnkodis df tgn eibonit Iner Nest. Bdcperetovnstumons niea`n us td omnitofy soco`erotons wotgecu`nts fduim oi Bertgekn eim erbgend`dk-obe` stims frdc tgn Io`n Mn`te, tgn bdest dfZgdnioboeZe`nstoin, eim Byprus.

    >7

    6 NK_Z]OEI OIF@^NIBN OI BEQ]GEKN

    Cdst df tgn ecu`nts drokoietoik frdc Nkypteim tgn Dronit metn frdc tgn ner`y Ordi Ekn OOO(6::-222 AB). Frdc tgn comsnvnitg bniturytd tgn fdurtg bnitury AB, ecu`nts df tgos hoimwnrn fduim oi Bertgekn procero`y oi fuinrne`

    bditnxts. Oi kninre`, tgn Nkyptoei dr Nestnriprdtdtypns, cemn oi quertzaneroik pestn frdctgn soxtg bnitury AB, snrvnm es ei oisporetodifdr Zuiob ocotetodis oi sdepstdin, eim rnceoinmpdpu`er uito` tgn nim df tgn tgorm bnitury AB.]n strst ecu`nts prdmubnm ay Bertgekoioei eimZuiob ertoseis wnrn e`sd oiotoe``y cemn frdcquertzaneroik pestn. ]nsn metn frdc tgn nimdf tgn stftg bnitury AB, aut wnrn fduim cdrnfrnqunit`y frdc tgn ner`y fdurtg bnitury ABdiwerms. Oi bditrest td tgn Nkyptoei ecu`nts

    eim tgn rern spnbocnis frdc tgn Iner Nest, tgnZuiob ocotetodis ern bgerebtnrosnm ay e cdrn ru-mocnitery cdmn df nxnbutodi, wgobg os nesy tdomnitofy frdc tgn gokg`y sty`osnm eim mostdrtnmfeboe` fneturns mosp`eynm di tgnc.

    ]n usn df sbereas oi Bertgekn mnrovns frdcEibonit Nkypt. ]n sberea sycad`osns tgn ef-tnr`ofn, eim os usnm nspnboe``y oi fuinrery bdi-tnxts. Emcoiostretovn admons e`sd usnm ot disne`s td eutgnitobetn wrottni mdbucnits. ]nsbnins bervnm oitd tgn sne`s ern notgnr Nkyptoei

    dr aesnm di Nkyptoei nxecp`ns< tgny mnpobtkdms, tgn iecns df tgn pgeredgs, eim `nknimsdr sycad`s. ]os os sukknstovn df tgn rotue` usndf Nkyptoei cekob. Ebbdrmoik td tgn rn`etovnbgrdid`dky df tgn krevns, tgn sbereas eim sber-eadoms cemn df quertzaneroik pestn dr sdep-stdin fduim oi Bertgekn metn frdc tgn snvnitgeim soxtg bniturons AB. ]n sne` ocproits df tgnb`essobe` Nkyptoei typn, wgobg ern bdponm eftnrobdidkrepgob cdmn`s metoik frdc tgn snbdimco``niiouc AB, ern rern oi Bertgekn. Gdwnvnr,

    ei ocprnssovn iucanr df sne` ocproits oi b`eyfrdc Bertgekn aner tgn strst iecn df ]utcdsnOOO (CigprQb) eim tget df tgn Gyhsds hoik(C2boaQb). ]os prdvns tget sne`s cemn eftnrNkyptoei nxecp`ns wnrn usnm frdc et `nest tgnstftg bnitury AB diwerms.

    ]n prnsnibn df monrnit hoims df sne`s, notgnrb`essobe` Nkyptoei dr prdmubnm uimnr Nkyptoeioifiunibn, oi tgn strst co``niiouc AB di tgnZgdnioboei bdest eim di Byprus, Brntn, Qgdmns,

    Ovdry p`equn frdcBertgekn8 ?::-;::AB8 Arotosg Cusnuc

    (pgdtd< N. vei mniAeimt).

  • 7/21/2019 9789088903113 - Docter Et Al. 2015 - Carthage - eBook

    61/148

    Ce`te eim oi dtgnr perts df tgn bnitre` eim wnst-nri Cnmotnrreinei rnkodi, `nims suppdrt td tgngypdtgnsos tget sgoppoik rdutns antwnni os`eimsp`eynm e hny rd`n oi tgn cdvncnits df Enkyptoebemuroik tgn strst co``niiouc AB. Bertgekn wes

    ei ocpdrteit bnitrn fdr tgn ocpdrt eim mostro-autodi df sne`s cemn oi tgn wdrhsgdps df tgnIo`n Mn`te, di tgn bdest df RyroeZgdnioboe, eimdi Byprus. _nt tgn movnrsn b`essobe` Nkyptoei,Zgdnioboei, Krnnh eim Dronite` typns df sbereaseim sbereadoms gevn idt anni fduim gnrn. ]ossgdws tget tgn intwdrh df os`eims tget mostroaut-nm tgn Nkyptoei eim Nkyptoeioispornm nxec-p`ns mom idt inbnssero`y pess tgrdukg Bertgekn.

    ]n typd`dkobe` eim obdidkrepgobe` drokois df

    sbereas eim sbereadoms cemn df krnni lespnr (everonty df quertz) `on oi tgn Dronit. Rne`s cemndf verodus germstdin typns ern strst nibduitnrnmoi tgn Ordi Ekn OO (5:::-6:: AB). ]ny erntgn geraoiknrs df tgn prdmubtodi df Zgdnioboeibervnm stdins, wgobg wnrn strst prdmubnm oi tgnioitg eim nokgtg bniturons AB. Oi emmotodi,tgny krnet`y oifiunibnm tgn mnvn`dpcnit df tgnstkuretovn bervoiks df sbereas eim sbereadomsoi krnni lespnr eim dtgnr germstdin typns oiDronite` wdrhsgdps. ]nsn wdrhsgdps wnrn nx-trncn`y prdmubtovn oi tgn Znrsoei pnrodm (soxtg

    td fdurtg bniturons AB). Antwnni tgn stftg eimtgorm bniturons AB, breftscni wdrhoik oi tgnwnstnri Cnmotnrreinei rnkodi, sdcn df tgncfrdc ]errds, dtgnrs frdc Oaoze dr Bertgekn,cemn spnbocnis df stin que`oty frdc tgn secnrew cetnroe`s.

    Frdc tgn snvnitg/soxtg bniturons AB diwerms,bervnm sne`s cemn df krnni lespnr eppner spd-remobe``y oi Bertgekn oi Erbgeob fuinrery eimvdtovn bditnxts. ]ny wnrn prdaea`y ocpdrtnm

    frdc tgn Dronit eim mosp`ey e prdiduibnm coxdf Nkyptoei eim Dronite` obdidkrepgy. Frdctgn fdurtg/tgorm bniturons AB diwerms, tgn oi-fiunibn df Gn``niostob obdidkrepgy anbdcns id-tobnea`n.

    Ansomns tgn sbereas eim sbereadoms bervnm oikrnni lespnr, spnbocnis eppnernm oi Bertgekntget gem anni but oi dtgnr germstdin typns.]nsn gevn anni fduim oi rnesdiea`y `erkn quei-totons oi Bertgekoioei krevns metoik frdc tgn

    Rne` roik wotgNkyptoei sbnin8Bertgekn, Ayrse8 ;tg-6tg bnitury AB8Cusn Ietodie` mnBertgekn.

    >?

    NK_Z]OEI OIF@^NIBN OI BEQ]GEKN 6

    snvnitg eim soxtg bniturons AB. Obdidkrepgobe`tgncns oispornm ay Nkyptoei nxecp`ns ern prdc-oinit ecdik tgnc. Roco`er typns bei an trebnmtd tgn Zgdnioboei bdest oi tgn Nest. E`tgdukgspnbocnis wotg Dronite` cdtofs ern fduim oi

    Bertgekn frdc tgn snvnitg/soxtg bniturons ABdiwerms, tgny ern fnw oi iucanr.

    Nvomnibn df eibonit Krnnh stdinbervoik oiBertgekn os nxtrncn`y sberbn8 tgn d`mnst nxecp`nsmetn frdc tgn soxtg bnitury AB. Ay tgn usue`steimerms df Krnnh stdinbervoik, tgn spnbocnisessokinm td tgn soxtg eim stftg bniturons AB ernrncerhea`n fdr tgn bern wotg wgobg tgn coiut-nst mnteo`s df tgn sbnins wnrn nxnbutnm. ]n di`yocekns di tgn iucnrdus Bertgekoioei sne`s wotg

    Gn``niostob snttoiks metoik frdc tgn fdurtg eimtgorm bniturons AB ern werrodrs eim ce`n gnems.]dukg tgn iucanr df Bertgekoioei sne`s frdctgn =tg-2rm b. AB mnbdretnm wotg Gn``niostobmnbdr os ocpdrteit, ots rnpnrtdorn os vnry `ocotnm,rnprnsnitoik di`y werrodrs eim ce`n gnems.

    ]eihs td ots strdik rn`etodis wotg tgn `nemoikZgdnioboei cnrbgeits, Bertgekn auo`t up e ce-tnroe` bu`turn, oi tgn strst co``niiouc AB, tgetwes krnet`y oifiunibnm ay tgn Nkyptoei bovo`ose-todi. ]n obdidkrepgy df tgn ecu`nts eim tgn

    rnpnrtdorn df bervoiks ern tgn cdst ocpdrteitnxprnssodis df tget oifiunibn. [otg tgn bd``epsndf tgn Znrsoei Ncporn oi tgn `est quertnr df tgnfdurtg bnitury AB, eim tgn emvnit df Gn``niosc,snvnre` betnkdrons df Enkyptoebe veiosgnm frdctgn Iner Nest. Nvni sd, Bertgekn bditoiunm tdp`ey e `nemoik rd`n oi prdmuboik ocotetodis. Fdrceiy yners, ot wdu`m stocu`etn tgn mostroautodieim mossncoietodi df tgn ve`uns df Nkyptoei bu`-turn oi tgn wnstnri Cnmotnrreinei rnkodi.

  • 7/21/2019 9789088903113 - Docter Et Al. 2015 - Carthage - eBook

    62/148

    6:6:

  • 7/21/2019 9789088903113 - Docter Et Al. 2015 - Carthage - eBook

    63/148

    BEQ]GEKN ER

    E CEQO]OCNZD[NQ

    Foh Cnolnr

    65

    ]GN RNE [ER OI ]GN BEQ]GEKOIOEIR

    A@DDM. ]GN_ MNRBNIMNM FQDC ZGDNIOBOEIRNEFEQNQR DF ]GN ZDQ] DF ]_QN. OI 75= AB

    ]GN_ GEM ADEQMNM ]GNOQ RGOZR EIM Z^]

    ]D RNE OI RNEQBG DF IN[ Z@EBNR ]D @OVN.

    ]GN_ GEM REO@NM E@DIK ]GN BDER] DF

    IDQ]G EFQOBE EIM FD^IMNM BEQ]GEKN,

    OI [GE] OR ID[ ]^IOROE. E] @NIK]G, ]GN

    BO]_R IN[ OIGEAO]EI]R FD^IMNM D]GNQ

    BD@DIONR OI ]GNOQ ]^QI. [O]G ]GN ZERREKNDF ]OCN, E IN][DQH DF RN]]@NCNI]R [O]GOI

    BEQ]GEKNR RZGNQN DF OIF@^NIBN KQN[

    ^Z E@DIK ]GN BDER] DF ]GN [NR]NQI

    CNMO]NQQEINEI. FQDC ]GNRN AERNR, RZEOI,

    ]GN AE@NEQOB OR@EIMR, REQMOIOE, BDQROBE

    EIM ]GN [NR] DF ROBO@_ [NQN E@@ AQD^KG]

    ^IMNQ BEQ]GEKOIOEI Q^@N.

    Vonw td tgn sdutgfrdc Ayrse Go``, wotg

    tgn bditdurs dftgn Zuiob geradursb`ner`y omnitostea`n

    ecom tgn cdmnri vo``e`eimsbepn.

  • 7/21/2019 9789088903113 - Docter Et Al. 2015 - Carthage - eBook

    64/148

    okgt`ydrkeiosnm emcoiostretodi wes et tgngnert df tgos ru`n. Idtgoik wes `nft td bgeibn. E`erkn`y cnrbniery ercy hnpt strc bditrd` df tgnpdpu`etodi oi tgn oitnrodr, wgo`n tgn wersgopsbrnws mom tgn secn fdr tgn bd`dioe` tnrrotdrons.

    Frdc tgn snbdim bnitury AB diwerms, tgn pd`-oby di tgn finnt wes bddrmoietnm frdc tgn wergeradur, wgobg wes dut df aduims fdr e`` idiBertgekoioeis. Fdrnokinrs epprdebgoik Bertgeknfrdc tgn sne seo`nm oitd tgn bdccnrboe` geradurtgrdukg e bgeiin` eim sew di`y tgn borbu`ermdua`n we``s nib`dsoik tgn wer geradur. ]nrnwnrn adet sgnms di tgn geradur queysomns eimdi tgn `ott`n bnitre` os`eim, ebbdccdmetoik dvnrtwd guimrnm wersgops oi tdte`. Di tgn frdit dfnebg adet sgnm stddm twd Odioei bd`ucis, wgobg

    kevn tgn geradur eim tgn os`eim tgn eppnereibndf e soik`n bditoiudus erbemn. Frdc gos gdusn,rosoik gokg up di tgn os`eim, tgn emcore` bdu`msnn nvnrytgoik tget geppninm et sne.

    Dtgnr geradurs oi tgn tnrrotdrons uimnrBertgekoioei ru`n prdaea`y gem adet sgnms tdd.Frdc tgnrn, tgn wersgops petrd``nm oi tgn occn-moetn surrduimoiks, sd tget eiy oiboponit rnvd`tbdu`m an ioppnm oi tgn aum. [gni tgn pdpu`etodianbecn rnstovn, wersgop brnws prdtnbtnm tgn iu-cnrdus berkd vnssn`s tget seo`nm oi e`` mornbtodis,

    aroikoik prnbodus cnte`s td Bertgekn oi nxbgeiknfdr kreoi, stsg eim d`ovn do`. ]n Bertgekoioeisrnfusnm td e``dw tgnor rove`s sgops td seo` bnrteoirdutns. ]n fer wnst df tgn Cnmotnrreinei, oipertobu`er, tgny rnkermnm es tgnor spnboe` mdceoi.]n pessekn tgrdukg tgn Rtreots df Koare`ter wesb`dsnm td idiBertgekoioeis.

    ]rorncns]n wer finnt tget snrvnm es tgn procery oistru-

    cnit df Bertgekoioei ocpnroe`osc wes bdcpdsnmet e`` tocns df tgn cdst cdmnri typns df sgops.]n Bertgekoioeis hnpt e b`dsn nyn di tgn typns dfwersgops anoik usnm ay dtgnr botons, eim put tgnorhidw`nmkn td kddm usn. ]ny wnrn pertobu`er`yhnni td wetbg inw trnims oi Krnnbn, Nkypt, eimNtruroe. ]ny tgncsn`vns e`sd nxpnrocnitnm wotginw typns df sgops. ]n treisotodi oi tgn snvnitgbnitury AB frdc cdidrncns (sgops wotg din nv-n` df derscni) td aorncns, wotg e snbdim `nvn`,wes prdcptnm oi pert ay subg nxpnrocnits. Oi tgn

    soxtg bnitury AB, tgn Bertgekoioeis idtnm tgnrepom rosn df tgn trorncn, e sgop wotg tgrnn rdwsdf derscni eadvn din eidtgnr. ]ny occnmoetn`ynxpeimnm tgnor finnt td oib`umn tgn inw cdmn`.

    Ot os burodus gdw `ott`n wn hidw eadut tgn tro-rncn, tgn steimerm sgop df tgn finnts oi tgn eibonitCnmotnrreinei. [n ern idt nvni surn df ots prnbosn`niktg dr womtg. Frdc tgn mocnisodis df tgn adetsgnms oi Zorenus, tgn geradur df Etgnis, ot beian oifnrrnm tget tgn trorncn wes 2; td =: cntrns`dik. ]n fu`` bditoiknit df derscni bdisostnmdf 5;: cni snetnm di tgrnn `nvn`s< >= tge`ecodoet tgn adttdc, wotg >= zukodoeadvn tgnc, eim efurtgnr 61 tgreioteodi tdp. ]n trorncns bdet dfercs wes tgn rec.

    ]n Bertgekoioeis sddi anbecn cestnrs df teb-tobe` ceidnuvrns wotg tgn trorncn. ]n dalnbtwes td mosea`n nincy sgops ay reccoik tgnc,prnfnrea`y oi tgnor vu`inrea`n fieihs, eim arneh-oik d tgn ders. ]n tebtobs fevdurnm ay tgn et-tebhnrs tgn Bertgekoioeis cdst frnqunit rd`n wnrn monhp`dus (seo`oik tgrdukg tgn `oins eimaebh ekeoi) eim pnrop`dus (niborb`ncnit). ]nanst rnsu`ts wnrn ebgonvnm wgni trorncns fdrbnmtgnor wey tgrdukg tgn `oins eim tgni occnmoetn-`y turinm oi e sncoborb`n. ]os put tgnc angoim

    tgn nincy, cehoik ot fer `nss gezermdus td rectgn nincy sgops tgei mdoik sd frdc tgnor oiotoe`pdsotodis. Ettebhoik frdc angoim, tgny scesgnmtgnor fdns ders, eftnr wgobg tgny rnturinm td tgnordwi `oins. ]n cdrn sgops oi e finnt pnrfdrcnm emonhp`dusdf tgos hoim, tgn krnetnr tgn bgeibn tgettgn nincy wdu`m an fdrbnm td nikekn.

    Emcore`s wgd fduim tgncsn`vns bdifrditoik tgnBertgekoioeis wdu`m tnim td hnnp tgnor sgops oie vnry b`dsn, bdcpebt fdrcetodi, procero`y es

    e mnfnisovn stretnky. ]ny dftni fdrcnm e mn-fnisovn borb`n dr huh`ds, tgn sgops remoetoik `ohntgn spdhns df e wgnn`, tgnor stnris b`dsn tdkntgnreim aettnroikrecs feboik dutwerm. ]n ei-swnr td tgos fdrcetodi wes niborb`ncnit. ]nBertgekoioei gn`cscni wdu`m rdw erduim tgnmnfnisovn borb`n oi tgn gdpn df stimoik wneh`oihs. Ot wes e`weys pdssoa`n tget e sgop cokgtarneh ewey frdc tgn borb`n fdrcetodi eim ettebhdin df tgn ansonkoik vnssn`s.

    61

    ; BEQ]GEKN ER E CEQO]OCN ZD[NQ

  • 7/21/2019 9789088903113 - Docter Et Al. 2015 - Carthage - eBook

    65/148

    Rto`` @erknr [ersgops

    Et tgn ankoiioik df tgn fdurtg bnitury AB, tgnrnwes e b`ner sgoft oi tgn fdbus df tgn nxpnrocnitswotg inw wersgops. ]n procery terknt wes idw

    Robo`y. E stnrbn strukk`n wes tehoik p`ebn antwnniRyrebusn, wgobg gem keoinm suprnceby dvnr tgndtgnr Krnnh botons di tgn os`eim uimnr tgn tyreitModiysous, eim tgn Bertgekoioeis, wgd bdi-trd``nm tgn wnstnri pert df tgn os`eim. ]n inw-`ymnsokinm sgops wnrn quemrorncns/fdurs, quoi-qunrncns/stvns eim gnxerncns/soxns. Nvni tgnsninw typns df sgops wnrn invnr rdwnm ay cdrntgei tgrnn `nvn`s df derscni, gdwnvnr. ]n oiid-vetodi bdisostnm df p`eboik cdrn derscni et nebgder. Di`y tgn cei et tgn nim df tgn der innmnm

    td pdssnss nxpnrtosn, oi drmnr td snt tgn rdwoikpebn. ]n dtgnr derscni socp`y fd``dwnm goc.E quemrorncn bdu`m an rdwnm wotg tgrnn `nvn`s

    62

    BEQ]GEKN ER E CEQO]OCN ZD[NQ ;

    ]gn aettnroik recfduim oi 1:5:, tgndi`y din wotg e

    Zuiob oisbroptodi8Rdproitnimnize mn`Cern, Ze`nrcd.

    df derscni ay gevoik din cei et tgn `dwnst eimcomm`n ders eim twd et tgn tdp. Oi sdcn besns, equemrorncn gem twd `eynrs df derscni. Oi tget

    besn tgnrn wnrn twd derscni et tgn adttdc dereim twd et tgn tdp. Roco`er erreikncnits wnrnusnm fdr quoiqunrncns eim gnxerncns.

    Nvni tdmey wn md idt hidw prnbosn`y wget tgnsnsgops `ddhnm `ohn. Ot os tgdukgt tget tgn quem-rorncns gem epprdxocetn`y 2:: derscni, wgo`nquoiqunrncns eim gnxerncns gem nvni cdrn.

    E`cdst nvnrytgoik n`sn eadut tgnsn sgops os ui-bnrteoi. ]n cdst ocpdrteit rnesdi fdr tgos kepoi dur hidw`nmkn os tget id suasteitoe` rnceois

    df wer ke``nys gevn anni fduim. E`` dur bdib`u-sodis cust an mosto``nm frdc tgn fnw tnxts wn pds-snss ay eibonit eutgdrs eim, frdc tgn frnqunit`y

  • 7/21/2019 9789088903113 - Docter Et Al. 2015 - Carthage - eBook

    66/148

    ocprnbosn ocekns di bdois, vesns eim rn`onfs. ]nmosbdvnry df tgn gu`` df e Bertgekoioei wersgopd tgn wnst bdest df Robo`y, iner Cerse`e, mom idtfuriosg eiy b`eroty, soibn tgos os e sce``nr typn dfvnssn` wotgdut eiy rdwoik anibgns et e``.

    ]gn Errove` df tgn Qdceis

    Fdr ceiy bniturons, tgn Bertgekoioeis gem ru`nmdvnr tgn wnstnri Cnmotnrreinei. [get geppninmoi Bertgekn eim tgn tnrrotdrons ot bditrd``nmsberbn`y rnkostnrnm wotg pndp`n oi tgn dutsomnwdr`m. ]et tgn Bertgekoioeis wnrn prdspnroik,gdwnvnr, wes b`ner td nvnrydin. ]n boty krnw, otspdpu`etodi swn``oik td pnrgeps 2::,:::, cdst dfwgdc wnrn oivd`vnm oi sdcn wey oi tremn eim

    oimustry. @erkn squerns, tgn ceiy womn eim ier-rdw strnnts tget `nm td tgnc, eim cdiucnite`auo`moiks e`` tnstostnm td tgn botys wne`tg.

    Idt e soik`n Bertgekoioei bei gevn suspnbt-nm, es tgn fdurtg bnitury mrnw td e b`dsn, tgettgnor cerotocn suprnceby wes e`cdst et ei nim.

    ]gn aettnroik recfduim oi 1:5: oi sotu.

    Zgdtd< Rdproitnimnizemn` Cern, Ze`nrcd.

    6=

    ; BEQ]GEKN ER E CEQO]OCN ZD[NQ

    ]ny bnrteoi`y invnr nitnrteoinm tgn omne tget otwdu`m an tgn Qdceis wgd wdu`m sne` tgnor fetn.

    Eftnr e``, wget mom tgn Qdceis hidw eadut tgnsne4 ]ny gem bdiqunrnm tgn nitorn Ote`oei pni-oisu`e wotgdut e soik`n sgop. Erduim 1;: AB,

    `ddhoik dut frdc Qgnkouc (prnsnitmey QnkkodBe`earod), tgn Qdceis bdu`m snn Robo`y `yoik ditgn dtgnr somn df tgn Rtreot df Cnssoie. Id mduattgn tgdukgt df seo`oik td tget `erkn os`eim wotg otsp`nitofu` kreoi dbbesodie``y brdssnm tgnor coims,aut idt fdr `dik. ]n Bertgekoioeis eim tgnRyrebuseis strubh fner oitd tgnc. ]n Qdceisrne`osnm tget ot wes pdoit`nss td nikekn tgnsn fdnsoi aett`n di Robo`y of tgny mom idt gevn e rne` finntdf tgnor dwi.

    Oi 16= AB tgn Qdceis emdptnm e inw stretnky.E bdifiobt fdr tgn boty df Cnssoie oi tgn idrtgdf Robo`y ui`nesgnm e wer tget wdu`m uttnr`ytreisfdrc tgn ae`eibn df pdwnr oi tgn wnstnriCnmotnrreinei. ]nrn wes e repom nsbe`etodi dftnisodi antwnni tgn Qdceis eim Bertgekoioeis.

    Eftnr `dik gnsotetodi, tgn Qdceis stie``y mn-

  • 7/21/2019 9789088903113 - Docter Et Al. 2015 - Carthage - eBook

    67/148

    6>

    bomnm td mospetbg ei ercy td Robo`y. Ot wes eroshy vniturn. Mnfnet di Robo`y wdu`m kovn tgnBertgekoioeis ei dppdrtuioty td brdss tgn wetnroi tgn dppdsotn mornbtodi eim tgrnetni tgn bdestsdf Ote`y.

    ]n Qdceis wn`` uimnrstddm tgn bruboe` oc-pdrteibn df auo`moik up e kddm finnt. Aut gdwbdu`m tgny ebquorn nidukg sgops4 ]ny geminotgnr sgopyerms idr derscni. _nt wotgoi tgnspebn df sox cditgs, tgny subbnnmnm oi stetodi-oik 51: inw wersgops oi tgn boty geradurs dfsdutgnri Ote`y. ]n gostdroei Zd`yaous, wgdpreosns tgn Qdceis fdr meroik td bdifrdit tgnru`nrs df tgn sne, stims ot wn``iokg ocpdssoa`n tdan`onvn tget tgny ebgonvnm e`` tgos uieomnm. Gn

    sukknsts tget bgeibn p`eynm e krnet rd`n oi tgnorvobtdry tgn Qdceis ebquornm e Bertgekoioeiwersgop, e quoiqunrncn, tget gem rui ekrduim,eim gem sgopauo`mnrs bdpy ots mnsoki. ]os vnr-sodi os e `ott`n tdd k`oa td an trun8 ot `nevns dut dfbdisomnretodi tgn sho`` df tgn Krnnh sgopauo`m-nrs oi sdutgnri Ote`y. ]n ohn`onst nxp`eietodi os

    tget tgn Qdceis snit drmnrs td sgops erbgotnbtsoi snvnre` df Ote`ys Krnnh botons, bdccossodioikfrdc tgnc mdznis df tgn wersgops tget wnrncdst oi usn trorncns, quemrorncns eim quoi-qunrncns.

    ]gn Aett`n df Cy`en

    Ay 16: AB tgn Qdceis gem et tgnor mospdse` ewer finnt df 5:: quoiqunrncns eim 1: trorncns oitgn wetnrs erduim Robo`y. ]ny gem rnbruotnm dvnr2:,::: derscni frdc e`` perts df tgn pnioisu`e.Rto``, tgn bgeibn df subbnss snncnm sce``, soibntgn Qdcei emcore`s eim tgnor brnws wnrn `nsssho``nm eim nxpnronibnm tgei tgnor Bertgekoioeibduitnrperts. ]n strst shorcosgns snncnm td

    bdistrc tgn monrnibns oi strniktg. ]n Qdceibdisu` Kienus Bdrin`ous Rbopod fduim gocsn`feim gos snvnitnni sgops gnccnm oi ay twnitysgops df tgn Bertgekoioei finnt eim surrnimnrnm.]os sntaebh wnehninm tgn Qdceis cdre`n.]nor mnlnbtodi oibrnesnm wgni tgn Bertgekoioeiemcore` Geiioae` (idt td an bdifusnm wotg tgn

    BEQ]GEKN ER E CEQO]OCN ZD[NQ ;

    Vonw frdc tgn Ayrsetdwerms tgn sdutg.]gn eibonit geradursern sto`` vosoa`n oi tgn`eimsbepn.

  • 7/21/2019 9789088903113 - Docter Et Al. 2015 - Carthage - eBook

    68/148

    Z^IOB AQDI\N IEVE@AE]]NQOIK QEC(Nkemo Os`eims)Di`y din df tgn n`nvni aettnroik recs

    tget gevn anni fduim td metn oi tgn

    erne df tgn Aett`n df tgn Nkemo Os`eims,td tgn wnst df Robo`y, os Zuiob. ]gn dtgnrs

    bdcn frdc Qdcei sgops. ]gos aettnroik

    rec wes fduim oi 1:5: et e mnptg df

    75 cntrns, muroik e systncetob snerbg

    bdimubtnm ay tgn Rdproitnimnize mn`

    Cern (Qnkodin Robo`oeie) eim tgn QZC

    Ieutobe` Fduimetodi. Rnvnre` ecpgd-

    ren, oib`umoik KrnbdOte`ob eim Zuiob

    typns, wnrn fduim wotgoi e stvnco`n

    remous df tgn aettnroik rec. Id `erkn

    cossoik perts ern mosbnrioa`n8 tgndi`y mecekn os e snrons df Vsgepnm

    idtbgns ebrdss tgn gdrozdite` snbtodis.

    ]gnsn idtbgns mosp`ey e furrdwnm pet-

    tnri beusnm ay e frdite` bd``osodi wotg

    eidtgnr rec. ]gos aettnroik rec wes

    cemn usoik tgn `dst wex tnbgioqun,

    aut ots `dwnr snbtodi, wgobg bdvnrnm

    tgn hnn`, wes nvomnit`y emmnm `etnr dr

    rnpeornm, soibn tgnrn ern b`ner sokis df

    perts anoik wn`mnm tdkntgnr.

    ]gn bervnm oisbroptodi, oi Zuiob `nt-tnrs, ges anni stumonm ay tgn spnboe`ost

    Kodveiio Keraoio. ]gn oisbroptodi bdi-

    sosts df din 2>`nttnr `oin eim aners e

    strdik rnsnca`eibn td aoa`obe` Gnarnw.

    Ot os ei emluretodi td tgn kdm Aee`< Cey

    tgos XrecS an mornbtnm ekeoist tgn sgop), wgd nxprnssns gocsn`f bdi-tncptudus`y eadut tgn Rperteis wrotoiks< tgnbdccdi kdssop df tgn aeranrs sgdp. ]n febttget Geiioae` wes ea`n td dpnretn wotgdut eiy

    prda`nc wgetsdnvnr muroik gos pnrodm df nxo`noi tgn Krnnhspnehoik Nest sukknsts tget gn weswn`` vnrsnm oi Krnnh. ]n pnrodm gn spnit oiKrnnhru`nm sdutgnri Ote`y (Cekie Krenboe)wdu`m gevn anni gn`pfu` oi tgos rnspnbt. Gnprdaea`y spdhn @etoi es wn``.]os gostdrobe` shntbg df Geiioae`s `ofn os aesnmdi tgn n`ncnits tget cdst oitnrnstnm tgn Qdceis,wgobg ieture``y rn`etnm ceoi`y td co`otery eimpd`otobe` nvnits. ]n ebbduits bdivny `ott`n eadut

    tgn Zuiob wdr`m oi wgobg Geiioae` `ovnm eimkrnw up, gdwnvnr. Erbgend`dkobe` stims, cdstidtea`y oi Bertgekn, gevn gn`pnm td ecp`ofy eimb`erofy tgos pobturn (snn e`sd bgeptnr 2).

    Geiioae`s Bertgekn

    ]n Zuiob erbgend`dky df Idrtg Efrobe os bger-ebtnrosnm ay ei uraei aoes, e gnevy ncpgesos diuraei bu`turn, nspnboe``y tget df tgn cntrdpd`os dfBertgekn. ]os cehns pnrfnbt snisn, soibn frdc

  • 7/21/2019 9789088903113 - Docter Et Al. 2015 - Carthage - eBook

    81/148

    ;?

  • 7/21/2019 9789088903113 - Docter Et Al. 2015 - Carthage - eBook

    82/148

    tgn vnry cdcnit et wgobg bd`diosts frdc yrnfduimnm Bertgekn (3 Inw Boty) oi 75=/52 AB,Bertgekoioei bu`turn wes prnncoinit`y ei uraeibu`turn wotg e strdik bdiinbtodi td tgn sne. Oi tgossnisn ot monrnm fuimecnite``y frdc vortue``y e``

    dtgnr Cnmotnrreinei bu`turns (Krnnh, Ntrusbei,ntb.), oi wgobg tgn uraei dr prnuraei bnitrnswnrn ncanmmnm fer cdrn b`ner`y oi ekrobu`ture`sdbontons. Geiioae` gocsn`f os e typobe` prdmubt dftgos uraei bu`turn.Idwgnrn oi Bertgekn os tgn iecn df Geiioae`cdrn b`ner`y `oihnm td erbgend`dkobe` rnceoistgei oi tgn sdbe``nm Geiioae` Uuertnr di tgnsdutgnest s`dpn df tgn Ayrse go``. Ot wes gnrn tgetFrnibg erbgend`dkosts nxbevetnm e Zuiob uraei

    mostrobt oi tgn 5?;:s eim 5?7:s, e mostrobt tgetcust gevn anni auo`t oi tgn yners erduim 1::

    7:

    ? ]GN Z^IOB [EQR

    AB. ]os erbgend`dkyaesnm metn te``ons wn`` wotgGeiioae`s pnrodm es suntn df Bertgekn eim tgnvokdrdus emcoiostretodi ettroautnm td goc. Cdrnocpdrteit`y, ot te``ons wotg gos rnputetodi es eiuraei p`eiinr muroik gos `etnr nxo`n. Oimnnm,

    gn os seom td gevn p`eiinm tgn boty df Ertgesget(Ertexete) oi Ercnioe. Oi Bertgekn wn bei snnb`ner`y tget tgn inw mostrobt os aesnm di e tokgt`ymnsokinm rnbteiku`er p`ei wotg strnnts nib`dsoikrn`etovn`y sce`` a`dbhs df gdusns< e kddm nxecp`ndf Goppdmecoei p`eiioik. ]n uraei mwn``oiksern `dik eim ierrdw, eim nebg ges ots dwi sce``bdurtyerm eim e sce`` bostnri fdr wetnr stdrekn.]nsn gdusns wo`` gevn anni snvnre` stdrnys gokg,eim tgn eie`ysos df tgn nxbevetnm cetnroe` rnvne`stget tgny wnrn oigeaotnm ay ei eunit comm`n

    b`ess, wgobg wdu`m gevn oib`umnm breftscni. ]nFrnibg cemn ceiy mosbdvnrons, oib`umoik tgn

    ]gn Aett`n df \eceges anni tgn sualnbt

    df snvnre` peoitoikseim proits oi Nurdpnei

    ert gostdry. ]gnproits wnrn womn`y

    mostroautnm. Bdrin`osBdrt8 5>6;.

  • 7/21/2019 9789088903113 - Docter Et Al. 2015 - Carthage - eBook

    83/148

    rnceois df e p`ebn fdr co``oik kreoi eim e wdrh-sgdp usnm ay e breftscei wgd fesgodinm otncs oirnm bdre`. Ceiy df tgn gdusns ern mnbdretnm wotgKrnnhGn``niostob cure`s oi tgn Bdistrubtovnsty`n, wgobg os hidwi oi tgn botons erduim Cduit

    Vnsuvous es tgn Forst Zdcpnoei Rty`n. Ot os stroh-oik tget tgn strnnts oi tgn Geiioae` Uuertnr ernuipevnm. Rtdin s`eas wnrn `eom di`y et tgn luib-todis, prdaea`y td prnvnit nrdsodi.

    [er Mnat

    Oi tgn pnebn trnety sokinm oi 1:5 AB, tgn bdimo-todis ocpdsnm di tgn mnfnetnm Bertgekoioeis wnrnmrebdioei, pertobu`er`y oi stieiboe` tnrcs. Qdcnmnceimnm tget Bertgekn pey ei occnmoetn suc

    df 5,::: te`nits, p`us ei emmotodie` suc df 1>:Nuadob te`nits eiiue``y fdr stfty