Upload
others
View
2
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
1
2
Steering Committee Members
•Chair:Kelly Holmes,ResourceAssistanceforYouth,Inc.
•Phil Chiappetta,RossbrookHouse
•Marie Christian,VOICES:Manitoba’sYouthinCareNetwork
•Tammy Christensen,NdinawemaaganagEndaawaadInc.
•Paywapan Colomb,EAGLEUrbanTransitionCentre
•Marion Cooper,CanadianMentalHealthAssociation,Manitoba,andWinnipeg
•Karen Ferris,YouthAgenciesAlliance
•Randy Flett,YouthAdvisor
•Kirby Fults,MaMawiWiChiItataCentre
•Sean Gander,NewDirectionsforChildren,Youth,Adults,andFamilies
•Shohan Illsley,The595PreventionTeam
•Jamil Mahmood,SpenceNeighbourhoodAssociation
•Diane Redsky,MaMawiWiChiItataCentre
•Jason Romanyshyn,YouthMentor
•Kelly Schettler,MacdonaldYouthServices
•Mike Tutthill,RainbowResourceCentre
Ex-Officio Steering Committee Members
•BrandonNeighbourhoodRenewalCorporation
•EndHomelessnessWinnipeg
•ManitobaHousing,DepartmentofFamilies
•SocialPlanningCouncilofWinnipeg
Community Researchers
•Christina Maes Nino,ProjectCoordinator,SocialPlanningCouncilofWinnipeg
•Maria Godoy,Research,ResourceAssistanceforYouth,Inc.
Research and Facilitation Support
•Markus Beveridge
•Isidora Draskovic
•Laura McDonald
•Olena Ptukha
Facilitation of Roundtables
•LAHRKConsulting
Design
•RelishNewBrandExperienceInc
ACKNOWLEDGMENTS Theplanwouldnotbepossiblewithouttheactiveparticipationofhundredsofyouthwhosharedtheirstories,hopesandrecommendations.
Thank you for courageously sharing your wisdom.
ThedevelopmentofthisplanfirstbeganinthecollectiveimaginationoflocalleadersinWinnipegwhohavebeenworkingfordecadestoprevent,reduceandendyouthhomelessness.TogetherwiththegeneroussupportofTheWinnipegFoundationandtheGovernmentofManitoba,thevisionofasharedstrategywasrealized.
AspecialthankstoEndHomelessnessWinnipeg,theNationalLearningCommunityonYouthHomelessness,AWayHomeCanada,andtheCanadianObservatoryonHomelessnessforyourguidanceandsupport.
Thisdocumentisdedicatedtoallpersonswhohaveexperiencedorarecurrentlyexperiencinghomelessness.
HereandNow:WinnipegPlantoEndYouthHomelessness
ISBN:1-895752-85-x
October2016
TABLE OF CONTENTS
4 ABOUT THE PLAN
5 A MESSAGE
7 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY
9 BACKGROUND
20 DEVELOPMENT OF THE PLAN
23 STRATEGIC FRAMEWORK
41 IMPLEMENTATION PLAN/FRAMEWORK
43 CONCLUSION
44 APPENDICES
45 END NOTES
4
OUR STORY ThestoryofthisplanbeginswiththeexperiencesofyouthonthestreetsofWinnipeg.Forthevastmajorityhomelessness was not a choicebuttheresultofstructural,system,andfamilybreakdowns.Youthhomelessnessisacomplexsocialissuewithdireconsequencesforyouth,ourneighbourhoodsandcommunities.Yet,weknowtodaythatyouth homelessness is preventable.
Localyouth-servingagencieshavebeencooperatingtoaddresstheneedsofyouthfordecadesandbeganworkingonacollaborativemodelthatbuildsonthestrengthsandknowledgeofallstakeholdersinthefallof2014.
THE CONTEXTGlobally,thestrategyisnestedintheUniversalDeclarationofHumanRights.Nationally,theplanjoinsinsolidaritywithdozensofcitiescurrentlydevelopingandimplementingplanstoendyouthhomelessnessacrossCanada.Locally,thefollowingdocumentaspirestoembodygrowingcommunitymobilizationeffortsthatseektounderstandandaddress the enduring legacy of colonization and the meaning of reconciliationinWinnipegandManitoba.
OUR INTENTIONThisplanintendstoserveasaguideforgovernment,fundersandcommunitymemberscommittedtoendingyouthhomelessness.Bysettingacommondirectionthatisgroundedintheprinciplesofreconciliationwepointtonewpolicy,funding,andprogramdevelopment,principlesandpriorities.
Thestrategyisintendedtobealivingdocument,onethatisregularlyrevisedtoguaranteerelevancetotheemergentandchangingneedsofyouthinourcommunity.Thisisonlythefirststepofacollectivemovement.
The time is now.
ABOUTTHE PLANThegoalofHereandNow:TheWinnipegPlantoEndYouthHomelessnessistodevelopthesharedvision,actionframeworkandgroundingprinciplesneededforeffectivesystems’integration,policyandprogramalignment,andcollaborationbetweenallcommunitystakeholders.Togetherweseektoreduceandendyouthhomelessnessthroughacommunity-sanctionedstrategythatprovidesyouthandtheirfamilieswithwhattheyneedtothrive.
5
MynameisSavannah.Iamtwenty-nineyearsoldandIwasborninWinnipeg,Manitoba.
IwasinvolvedinthePlantoEndYouthHomelessnessinWinnipeg.Iwenttofocusgroups,consultationsandworkshops.Ievendidsurveys.
Youaresousedtobeingtoldthatsomethingishappeningandthenitisnot.Iwassoproudtobeapartofitandthenitcametrue.DuringtheplanIfeltveryinvolvedandimportant,itwasrewardinginitself.
Iknowaboutyouthhomelessness.Iknowthatitisnotachoice,itaffectsyourself-esteemandyourworth.Youdonotfeellikeyoubelongandsometimesyoustandoutmorethanothers.
Youcanmakebadchoiceswhenyouarehomeless,likeprostitutionandcrime.Youhavepressureswhenyouareonthestreetsandyoulearntododrugs.
Youthhomelessnessisnotsafe.Ifyouarenewonthestreetsit'slikeabigsignonyourforeheadthatyouarenewandvulnerable.
Also,youthhomelessnessinWinnipegisgettingbiggerandbigger.Whenyouarehomeless,youcangounderabridgeandthereare15peopleandyouarenotalone.Onthestreetsyouhaveasenseofbelongingandpeoplegettoocomfortablethere,sotheydon’twanttoleave.
Weneedaplantoendyouthhomelessnessbecausewedeservetofeellikeweareworthsomething,worthgettingoffthestreets.
Weneedtomakeyouthfeelliketheyarevalued,andgivepeoplethechoicetogetcleanandgethousingwhentheyareready.
Wewanttofeelacceptedinsociety.
Weneedaplanbecauseweneedtobesafe.Wecanmakethestreetssaferfortheyouththatareonthestreets,reducesuicide,andgetyouthoffthestreetsifweworktogetherwiththisplan.
Iimagineadaywhendrugdealerswon’thavepreytotakeadvantageof.
Ihopethatthisplan:
a. Buildsconfidenceandself-esteeminyouth
b. Givesyouthasenseofbelongingand
c. Givesyouthasenseoftrustandsafety
Iknowthatwhenyouhaveahouse,youhaveabase.Icouldn’tgotoschoolbecauseIdidn’thavearoofovermyheadandIwashungry.Eventhoughmyschoolhadafoodprogram,Icouldnotgetagoodnightsleeptofocusforthenextmorning.HavingahousewasthebaseIneededtoaccomplishmygoals.
Ihopethatthisplanwillreduceyouthhomelessnessandmaybesomedayendit.
A MESSAGE
7
EXECUTIVESUMMARY
PURPOSEEveryday,thereareatleasttwohundredyouthinWinnipegwithoutaplacetocallhome.Homelessnesshasdevastatingeffectsonsociety,communities,andmostimportantly,youththemselves.Despiteinnovativeresponses,strongresearch,andasectorthatworkstogetherthroughthetragedyofhomelessness,wehavenothadthesupport,alliances,orsharedvisionrequiredtoendyouthhomelessness.Bysettingacommondirection,Here and Now: The Winnipeg Plan to End Youth Homelessnesswillguidepolicy,funding,programdevelopment,andcollectiveactionpriorities,groundedintheprinciplesofreconciliation,towardsacitywhereallyouthhaveasafeplacetoliveandthrive.
OVERVIEW
Mission Topreventandendyouthhomelessnessbyimplementingacommunity-sanctionedstrategythatensuresyouthandtheirfamilieshavewhattheyneedtothrive
Vision Acitywhereallyouthhaveasafeplacetoliveandthrive
Teachings Love• Respect• Courage• Honesty• Wisdom• Humility• Truth
Principles 1. Understandyouthholistically,aspartoffamiliesandcommunities.
2. Youthhavearighttoleadthedevelopmentoftheirownplans,andtobesupportedduringandaftertransitions.
3. Buildonwhatisworking.
4. Youthself-identifywhattheywantandneed.
5. Youthhomelessnessisnotacceptable,andweallhavearoleinpreventingandendingit.
Values Respect•Inclusion•Choice•Youth-Centred•YouthVoice•Reconciliation• EquityStrength-based•Holistic•CulturallyCompetent•EvidenceandResearchInformed
8
PROCESS
COMMUNITY PRIORITIES
GuidedbythewisdomandexpertiseoftheSteeringCommittee,theprocessofdevelopingtheplanwasdesignedto:
1. Listen to the voices of youth;
2. Deeplyunderstandtheexistingsystemandservicesforyouthexperiencingandatriskofhomelessness;
3. Identifypotentialsolutionstothecausesofyouthhomelessnessandtoopportunitiestocoordinatepathwaysoutofit;
4. UnderstandthepresentdayrelationshipsbetweencolonialismandyouthhomelessnessandidentifydecolonizingstrategiesbasedinIndigenousworldviews;
5. BuildcommunityconsensusonprinciplesandvaluesthatarefoundationalforthesesolutionstobeimplementedinWinnipeg;and
6. Begintomobilizeallsectorstowardspreventingandendingyouthhomelessness.
AlloftheactionstrategiesaresignificantandrequiredifwearetoendyouthhomelessnessinWinnipeg.Wealsoneedtostartonthemostimpactfulactivitiestobeginpreventingandreducingyouthhomelessnessimmediately.Basedoninputfromyouthandcommunitystakeholdersthefollowingfouractionstrategieshavebeenprioritizedforthefirststepsofimplementation:
1. Access Priority:Developanetworkofregionalhubsopen24/7byincreasingthecapacityofexistingyouth-servingagencies.
2. Prevention Priority: Createaninterdepartmental“ZeroDischargeintoHomelessness”strategy,startingwithacoordinatedprovincialpolicydirection,thatsupportsyouthtransitioningfromanytypeofprovincialgovernmentorgovernmentfundedcare.
3. Housing Priority: Developincreasedsupplyoftransitionalhousingprogramsforyouth.
4. Supports to Thrive Priority: EncourageEmploymentandIncomeAssistance(EIA)toincreasethestabilityofincomesupportsforyouth.”
1 2 3 4Youth have immediate access to the supports needed to prevent, alleviate and respond to homelessness.
Youth and their families struggling with risk factors of homelessness are identified and supported.
Youth have access to a full range of housing, and housing with support options, based on need and choice.
All youth with experience of homelessness have the supports they need to maintain housing and thrive.
•Establishacoordinatedaccessstrategy
•Improvecollaborationamongstakeholdersbypromotingcommunication
•Removebarrierstoaccessacrossyouthservingagencies,governmentagencies,andsafespaces
•Establishacentralizedpublicinformationresource
•Fosterresilienceamongfamiliesandcommunities
•Preventnewcomeryouthhomelessness
•Adoptandimplementschool-basedpreventionstrategies
•Ensureyouthingovernmentcaredonotexitintohomelessness
•SupportIndigenousyouthmigratingtoWinnipeg
•Decolonizesystemsandapproachestoserviceprovision
•Re-envisiontheemergencyresponseforyouth
•Increasethesupplyanddiversityoftransitionalhousingoptions
•Developafullcontinuumofpermanenthousingandsupportsforyouth
•Fosterresilienceamongyouthexitinghomelessnessthroughholisticandongoingsupports
•Addresssystemicbarrierstoyouths’housingstability
•Enhancethecapacityofinformalandcommunity-basedsupports
•Embedhealingintosupportsandsystemsforyouth
PREVENTION HOUSING & SUPPORTS
SUPPORTS TO THRIVE
ACCESS
The following strategies and objectives are grounded on the principles and values of the plan:
9
BACKGROUNDDEFINING YOUTH HOMELESSNESS
YOUTHDefining‘youth’isadifficulttaskbecausethereisnoconsistentlegalorsocialstandard.AccordingtotheUnitedNations
‘youth’ is best understood as a period of transition from the dependence of childhood to adulthood’s independence and awareness of our interdependence as members of a community. Youth is a more fluid category than a fixed age-group.1
Whileweacceptthefluidityofthedefinitionof‘youth’,forthepurposesofthisstrategya‘youth’isdefinedasanypersonbetweentheagesof15and29yearsold.Inrecognitionofthebarrierstoaccessthatcanoccurfromimplementingafixedagecategory,thisplanadvocatesforbetterintegrationofadultandyouthservices.
However,wealsorecognizethatage matters.Thereisanotabledifferencebetweentheneeds,circumstances,anddevelopmentofa15yearoldcomparedtoan18or27yearold.Further,someyouthmayalsoexperiencedevelopmentaldelays.2Inordertobesuccessful,programresponsesmustbetailoredtothespecificdevelopmentalandcognitiveneedsofyouthwithinthisbroadage-range.
HOMELESSNESSConsistentwithayouth-centredandholisticapproach,theWinnipeg Plan to End Youth Homelessnessadvocatesforacomprehensivedefinitionofhomelessness.BorrowingfromtheUnitedNationsSpecialRapporteurontheRighttoAdequateHousing,weadheretoathree-dimensionalhumanrightsdefinition:1)homelessnessastheabsenceofahome;2)homelessnessassocialexclusion;and3)youthexperiencinghomelessnessasholdersofhumanrights.
Homelessness as the Absence of a HomeAccordingtotheCanadianDefinitionofHomelessness,thehomelessnesstypologyincludesexperiencesofbeing:
1. Unsheltered,orabsolutelyhomelessandlivingonthestreetsorinplacesnotintendedforhumanhabitation;
2. Emergency Sheltered,includingthosestayinginovernightsheltersforpeoplewhoarehomeless,aswellassheltersforthoseimpactedbyfamilyviolence;
3. Provisionally Accommodated,referringtothosewhoseaccommodationistemporaryorlackssecurityoftenure;and
4. At Risk of Homelessness,referringtopeoplewhoarenothomeless,butwhosecurrenteconomicand/orhousingsituationisprecariousordoesnotmeetpublichealthandsafetystandards.3
Further,researchsuggeststhatyouthmorecommonlyexperiencehiddenhomelessness.Thismeansbeing‘provisionallyaccommodated’onfriends’couchesandwithfamilymembersneverknowingiftheywillbekickedoutthenextday.4
Itiscriticaltonotethatyouthmovefromthesedifferentcategorizationsofhomelessnesstoprecarioushousing,andevenstablehousing,thenbacktohomelesssituations,sometimesinrelativelyshortperiodsoftime.Thisisevidentthroughpoint-in-timecounts,aswellastrajectoriesyouthdescribedintheSystemPathwaysintoYouthHomelessnessresearch.5Aswithfixedage-groupdefinitions,rigidcategoriesofhomelessnesscannotbeappliedtoexcludeyoungpeoplewhoarestruggling.
Homelessness as Social ExclusionImportantly,homelessnessisnotonlythelackofadequatehousingbutisalsodefinedbysocialexclusion.6Socialexclusionreferencesthestigmatizationandmarginalizationthatsubjectsyouthexperiencinghomelessnesstomultipleformsofsocialdiscrimination.
Homeless Youth as Right HoldersYouthwithexperiencesofhomelessnessareequalmembersofoursociety.Theyareresilientastheystruggleforsurvivalanddignity.Youthexperiencinghomelessnessarecentralagentsandactiveparticipantsofthesocialtransformationneededfortheimplementationofresponsestoyouthhomelessness.
10
DEFINITION OF YOUTH HOMELESSNESSForthepurposesofthisdocument“YouthHomelessness”referstothesituationand
experienceofyoungpeoplebetweentheagesof15and29whoarelivingindependentlyofcaregiversanddonothave,orhavetheimmediatemeans/abilitytoacquire,
stable,safeorconsistentresidence.
ThefollowinginfographicpresentsdataregardingyouthfromtheWinnipegStreetCensus2015.8Theresearchprojectisa‘momentintime’studyintendedtogatherinformationabouttheextentandnatureofhomelessnessinWinnipeg.Despiteitsmethodologicallimitations,itprovidesuswithimportantdemographicinformationtoimprovedecision-makingandinformstrategies.
TheWinnipegStreetCensuspointstotheneedforpreventativeapproachestoendinghomelessness.
18yearsoldwasthemostcommonagethatindividualsfirstbecamehomeless;70%ofthoseexperiencinglong-term(10+years)homelessnessfirstbecamehomelessasayouth.
OnoneinOctober,2015,26.5%ofallpeopleexperiencinghomelessnesswereyouth,betweentheages16-29.Forthoserespondents:
YOUTH HOMELESSNESS IN WINNIPEGTheGovernmentofCanadaestimatesthathomelessnessaffects150,000Canadianseveryyear,including65,000youth.YouthareconsideredtobethefastestgrowingsegmentofthehomelesspopulationinCanada.7
YOUTH HOMELESSNESS IN WINNIPEG
#1
family conflictbreakdownand/or violence
REASON WHY YOUTH BECOME HOMELESS 48%
Are Female
30%Moved to Winnipeg
in the last year
+ 16%Recieve EIA
Disability Assistance
41%Recieve Employment & Income Assistance
(EIA)
84% Indigenous
23%LGBTQ2S*Homeless for
6+ months
35% Grew-up on
68%Spent time in care of CFS
reserve
73%Had no formal
income
32%
11
Inthisstudy,wewereinformedbyanecologicalperspective,whichemphasizeshowpovertyandhomelessnessareinfluencedbytheinteractionbetweenpersonsandtheirphysicalandsocialenvironments.9Thefollowingsectiondescribeshowstructural,systemic,familyandindividualfactorsshapethepathwaysbywhichyouthbecomehomelessness.Thesenestedstructuresinteractwithoneanothertocreatetheconditionsforyouthhomelessness.
STRUCTURAL FACTORS
Colonialism
ItisimpossibletodiscussyouthhomelessnessinWinnipegwithoutaddressingthehistoricalandcontemporaryprocessesofcolonization.ColonizationreferstothecomplexsetofdiscriminatoryandoppressivepracticesthatoriginatedfromtheWesternexpansionintoNorthAmerica.10ThesepracticesestablishedunequalpowerrelationswithIndigenouspeoplesthatcontinuedthroughthedevelopmentofthemodernstateofCanada,includingthecreationofreserves,relocationtoremoteareas,andtheestablishmentofresidentialschools.11Theintroductionofsystemsofeducation,justice,health,andchildwelfarehaveresultedinacycleofdeprivation,povertyandunemploymentforIndigenouspeoplesinCanada.12
Thesuffering,poverty,andsystemsbreakdowndescribedbelowandexperiencedbyIndigenouspeoplesstemfromtheprofoundlydestructivelegacyofcolonization.Effectivedecolonizationofthestructuresofoursocietyrequiresreconciliation.
To the [Truth and Reconciliation] Commission, “reconciliation” is about establishing and maintaining a mutually respectful relationship between Aboriginal and non-Aboriginal peoples in this country. For that to happen, there has to be awareness of the past, acknowledgment of the harm that has been inflicted, atonement for the causes, and action to change behaviour.13
“Iwasn’ttaughtaboutmyculture,thatwouldhavebeenahugehelp.”—Youth
“[Weneed]moreculturalawarenessgroups:drumgroups,traditionalmedicineteachingstohavemoreofasenseofcommunity,sothatyoudon’tfeelaloneinthestruggle.”—Youth
Discrimination
•Discriminationonthebasisofsex,age,sexualorientation,race,andgenderidentityisintricatelylinkedwithinequity,povertyandthesocialexclusionthatplacesyouthatriskofhomelessness.AccordingtotheCommitteeonEconomic,SocialandCulturalRights,‘discriminationmaycausepoverty,justaspovertymaycausediscrimination’.14
Poverty
•TheincomegapinManitobaiswidening.Overthelasttwentyyears,theaverageannualincomesofthewealthiestManitobafamilieshaveincreasedby$51,929,whilethelowestincomefamilieshavegainedonly$4,937(inconstantyeardollars).15
•IndigenouspeoplesinWinnipeghavealmostdoublethepovertyratethanthegeneralpopulation(17versus10percent).Further,unemploymentratesarealmostthreetimeshigher.
•IndigenousmigrantstoWinnipegareparticularlyvulnerable,sincetheirincomesremainbelow$10,000peryear15monthsafterarrivalinthecity.16
Housing Affordability
•Homelessnesshasitsrootsinhousingmarketdynamics,andparticularlyinthedifficultyinobtainingaffordablehousing.17
•NearlyoneinfivehouseholdsinWinnipegpayover30%oftheirincomeonsheltercosts,meetingthedefinitionofcorehousingneed(22%).
•Renterhouseholdsareatincreasedrisk,37%ofthempaidmorethan30%oftheirincomeinrentin2011(34,191households).
PATHWAYS TO YOUTH HOMELESSNESS
12
SYSTEMIC FACTORSSystemsintendedtosupportthehealthydevelopmentofchildrenandyouthtendtooperatefromauniversalapproach.Thislimitstheirabilitytobeflexiblewhenrespondingtoyouthwithcomplexexperiencessuchastrauma,mentalhealthorcognitivechallenges,oranabsenceofsupportiveadultstoassistinnavigatingthesesystems.Youthwiththeseexperiencesarealsomorelikelytobeconnectedwithmultiplesystems,whichfacedifficultiescoordinatingwitheachother.Homelessnessoftenoccursasyouthtransitionfromorbetweenthesesystemswithoutthemeans,skills,orsupportsneededforsuccess.
Child and Family Services (CFS)
68.2% of youth experiencing homelessness in Winnipeg spent time in the care of CFS18
•Manitobahasoneofthehighestratesofchildreninstatecare.Thereare10,501childrenincareinManitoba.19
•Indigenouschildren(FirstNations,MetisandInuit)incareaccountforcloseto87%ofallchildrenincare.20Foravastmajorityofyouth,andparticularlyIndigenousyouth,childwelfareinvolvementisaprofoundlynegativeexperience.21Manyyouthexperiencehousinginstabilitywhileincare,includingrunningawayandplacementbreakdowns.22
•Anestimated500youthleavethecareofManitobaChildandFamilyService(CFS)everyyear.23YouthexitCFScarelargelyunpreparedforlifeasanadult;theyleavecarewithoutahigh-schooleducation,employmentexperience,ortheessentiallifeskillsrequiredforindependentliving.24
“IagedoutofCFS,theygaveme400dollars,paidonemonthofmyrentandsaid‘haveanicelife’.Yougofromhavingemotionalandcommunitysupport,likecheckinguponyouandcaringaboutyou,tonothing.” —Youth
Justice
Over half of youth experiencing homelessness have been in jail, a youth detention centre, or prison25
•Individualsleavingprisonsareatanincreasedriskofhomelessness,whilesimultaneously,thoseexperiencinghomelessnessareatanincreasedriskofincarceration.2627
Health, Mental Health and Addictions
Almost 60% of youth experiencing absolute homelessness spend a night in a hospital in a given year28
•AstudyfromLondon,Ontariofoundthat167of1,588(10.5%)individualsweredischargedfrompsychiatricwardswithnofixedaddresswithinasingleyear.29
•TheWinnipegStreetHealthReportfound50%ofyouthexperiencingabsolutehomelessnessinWinnipegwerediagnosedwithamentalillness.30
Education
Between 63-90% of homeless youth have not graduated high-school despite being of age to have done so31
•Lowschoolperformance,loweducationalattainmentandschooladjustmentproblemsarepredictiveofhomelessness.3233
•WhileManitoba’sstudenttrackedhighschoolgraduationratefor2014was87%,Indigenousstudentshadagraduationrateof54.5%.34
Employment and Income Assistance
46.7% of youth who are homeless in Winnipeg receive their income from EIA, general or disability assistance. However, 32% have no formal source of income35
•Youthovertheageof18canbeeligibleforEIAiftheyareunabletoworkorfindwork.However,incomeassistancewasdescribedbyyouthtobeoneofthemostdifficultsystemstonavigate.36
•Further,whenreceivingincomesupportsyouthareoftenunabletocomplywiththerequirementsincluding:completingforms,attendingappointments,meetingdeadlinesandmore.Withoutinterventionfromadvocates,manyfailtocomply,arecut-offfromassistance,evicted,andreturntohomelessness.37
13
FAMILY & INDIVIDUAL FACTORSFamilyandindividualfactorsleadingtohomelessnessareintricatelyconnectedtostructuralandsystemicfactors.Therelationshipbetweenfamilyconflictandyouthhomelessnessiswelldocumented.3839Familyconflict,breakdownorviolencewasthemostfrequentlycitedreasonforindividuals’firstexperienceofhomelessnessinWinnipeg,thisisconsistentwithfindingsacrossCanadaandinternationally.40Difficultfamilysituationsassociatedwithyouthhomelessnessinclude:
•Abuse. Youthmayleavehometoescapeabusivefamilysituations,includingsexual,physical,oremotionalabuse.Youngwomenandgirlsaremorelikelytohavebeenvictimsofsexualabuse.41
•Neglect.Otherfamilyrelatedfactorsmayincludeneglect,continuousarguments,andparentalcontrolissues.42
•Exposure to domestic violence.43
•Parental substance use.44
•Rejection of Gender and Sexual orientation. Importantly,manyyouthleavehomeduetofamilyconflictovertheirgenderand/orsexualorientation.Hence,LGBTQ2S*youthareoverrepresentedinthehomelessyouthpopulation.45
•Teen Pregnancy.Teenmothersaremorelikelytobecomehomelessasaresultoffamilyconflict.4647
Childrenwhoexperiencetrauma,chronicfearandabuse,sufferfromlong-termdevelopmentalandemotionalconsequencesthatpreventthemfromformingpositiveattachmentsandsocialnetworks.48
However,youthhomelessnessisnotmerelytheresultoffailureonthepartoftheyouthortheirparents,butratheritisthebreakdownoftheparent-childrelationship,whichisoftentheresultofcomplexsocialfactorssuchaseconomicstress,peerinfluences,andcommunityviolence.Indeed,whilenumerousprogramspreventingandreducingneglectandmaltreatment,oftenintheformofparentingprograms,someresearchsuggeststhatsimplyprovidingfamilieswithmoreincomeiseffectiveatreducingmaltreatmentrates.49
Indeed,whiletherearenumerousprogramsaimedatreducingfamilybreakdown,oftenintheformofparentingprograms,someresearchsuggeststhatsimplyprovidingfamilieswithmoreincomeiseffectiveatreducingmaltreatmentrates.50
•Child Welfare
•Justice
•Health, Mental Health & Addictions
•Education
•Employment & Income Assistance
•Abuse
•Neglect
•Exposure to domestic violence
•Parental substance abuse
•Rejection of gender or sexual orientation
•Teen Pregnancy
•Colonialism
•Discrimination
•Poverty
•Housing Affordability
STRUCTURAL
SYSTEMIC
FAMILY & INDIVIDUAL
14
INDIGENOUS YOUTH HOMELESSNESS
AdvocatesandresearchershavedeclaredhomelessnessamongIndigenousyouthtobearapidlygrowingnationalemergency.However,Indigenousyoutharenotahomogeneouspopulation.Theyareagroupwithamultitudeofuniqueculturalbackgrounds,legalstatus,experiences,strengths,skillsandperspectives.Assuch,theyexperiencevariedlevelsofneed.Nonetheless,manyaresurvivorsofextremepoverty,racism,ormentalhealthissuesinfamiliesandcommunities,disconnectionfrombirthfamilies,violence,sexualabuseand/orneglectallofwhichcanbetracedtothesharedandcontinuedhistoryofcolonialism.
Importantly,IndigenousyouthexperiencinghomelessnessfrequentlymovebetweenWinnipegandFirstNationscommunities.Astudyof123IndigenousyouthinManitobaexperiencinghiddenhomelessnessrevealedthatparticipantshadmovedmorethanfourtimesinaneighteenmonthperiod.52Onethirdofthosemovesinvolvedtransitioningfromortoareserve.53YouthleaveFirstNationcommunitiesduetofamilyconflict,lackofopportunities(includingeducationandemployment),andtheconditionorabsenceofhousing.WhentheyarriveinWinnipeg,theyoftenlackthesocialsupportsandmeanstofindstablehousing,leadingtohomelessness.Sometimestheyreturntotheirhomecommunitiesandbeginthecycleagain.
Indigenousyouthhavedescribedexperiencingnotonlyphysicalhomelessnessbutalsospiritualhomelessness,a“crisisofpersonalidentitywhereinaperson’sunderstandingorknowledgeofhowtheyrelatetocountry,family,andAboriginalidentitysystemsisconfusedorlacking.”54
Comparedtohomelesspeers,Indigenousyouthexperiencemoredeprivation,discriminationandharassment.Anorganizationalevaluationof180youthatResourceAssistanceforYouth(RaY)55inWinnipeg,foundthatIndigenousyouth:
•Slept outdoors more often
•Were more likely to engage in panhandling, squeegeeing, and flagging for their main income
•Were more likely to report having been harassed by police or cadets
•Were more likely to report having been harassed by the public
•Were more likely to report having been ticketed for vagrancy or trespassing
ResponsestoIndigenousyouthhomelessnessmustnecessarilyberootedinacomprehensiveunderstandingoftheeffectsofcolonization.TheymustalsoberootedinanunderstandingthatIndigenouspeoplesholdrightsundertheCanadianconstitution,includingtherighttoself-determinationandself-government,andtherighttopracticeone’sowncultureandcustomsincludinglanguageandreligion.
The system has created [youth homelessness], and it isn’t working. It has never worked. Indigenous people need to restore our place in caring for our young people.
—Indigenous Leader Discussion
84%ofyouthexperiencinghomelessnessinWinnipegidentifyasIndigenous.AlmosthalfofFirstNationsyouthgrewupinaFirstNationscommunity.51
15
YOUTH HOMELESSNESS IS NOT ADULT HOMELESSNESS
Thecauses,conditionsandconsequencesofhomelessnessforyoungpeoplearedistinctfromthoseofadults,whichmeansweneedatailoredresponse.1
•Youthareatauniquestageofphysical,cognitive,socialandidentitydevelopment
•Youthhavelittletonoexperiencelivingindependently,lessworkexperienceandfewerlifeskillsthanadults
•Manyyouthcomefromenvironmentswheretheywereexposedtofamilyconflict,includingphysical,sexualandemotionalabuse,disruptionstoschool,neglectandpoverty
•Youthareparticularlyvulnerabletoexploitationandcriminalvictimization
•Youthundertheageof18havedistinctlegalentitlementsandrestrictions
•Youthareoftenservedbyuniqueinfrastructureswithinthejustice,health,educationandchildwelfaresystems
Becauseofthesedistinctionsyouthaccessservicesdifferently.Manydonottrustimpersonalgovernmentsystemsandadultservices,usingthemonlyasalastresort.2
Youthalsohaveuniquestrengths.
•Youthexperiencinghomelessnesshavemorefriendsandhigherfrequencyofcontactwithfamilyandfriendsthanhomelessadults.3
•Youtharemoreresilient.4Generallyspeaking,youthexperiencinghomelessnesshavehopefortheirfuture,dreamsthatmotivatethemandagreatercapacityforchange.Bychangingtheirenvironmentandcapitalizingonhealthyrelationshipswecanendthecycleofhomelessnessforgood.
WHY WE NEED A YOUTH PLANTheseareallimportantthemesthatemergedduringconsultationsforthestrategy.Youthtoldusthathomelessnessforcesthemintotheresponsibilitiesofadulthoodearlywithoutthesocialsupportsandtheskillstheyneedtothrive.
“Thereshouldbemoresupportafterthingsgook.”—Youth
Youthneedadifferentapproach.ThisiswhyitisimportanttoadoptaPositiveYouthDevelopmentframeworkwhichtakesthedevelopmentalneedsandstrengthsofyouthintoaccount.Changecanoccurbypromotingthe Five C’s: competence, confidence, character, connection, and caring.5Thisdevelopmentoftheserequiresthatprogramsinclude:(1)positiveandsustainedadult-youthrelationships,(2)youthskill-buildingactivities,and(3)opportunitiesforyouthparticipationandleadershipincommunitybasedactivities.6
“Inthatprogramtheyalreadyhadaplaceforyoutomovein.Ithadfurnitureandeverythingyouneed.ButI’dratherhavelearnedhowtodothatmyself,soIknowhowto.Iwantsomeonetositwithmeandteachmehowtogetaplace.”—Youth
PositiveYouthDevelopmentapproachesareconsistentwithIndigenousphilosophiesofchilddevelopmentsuchasTheCircleofCourage,whichpromotesgenerosity,belonging,mastery,andindependence.
16
CIRCLE OF COURAGE
BELONGINGemphasizestheimportanceofindividualshavingasenseofconnectednesstosomeoneorsomething –families,clubs,churchgroups,etc.Apositivesenseofbelongingnurturesself-esteem,self-worth,andultimatelyequipschildrenwiththeabilitytodevelophealthyrelationshipswith others.
INDEPENDENCEfocusesonprovidingchildrenwithexperiencestodevelopautonomyandessentiallifeskills.Childrenandyouthlearntoacceptresponsibility.Theyareempoweredtounderstandhowtheirchoicesaffecttheirdestiny.
GENEROSITYisintendedtoprovidechildrenwithopportunitiestodemonstratealtruismandhelpingbehaviors.Childrenlearntounderstandthevalueofgivingbacktothecommunityandmakeameaningfulcontributiontosomeoneelse.
MASTERYreferstotheimportanceofchildrenandyouthdevelopingskillsthathelpthemproduceandexercisecompetence,achievement,andcontroloverself.Childrengainmasterybylearningnewskillsthroughdailylifeandenrichmentactivitiesinwhichtheirenvironmentprovidesthemwithmultipleopportunitiestotappersonaltalents.
Generosity
Mastery
Inde
pend
ence B
elongings
Brendtro,L.,Brokenleg,M.,&VanBockern,S.(1990).Reclaimingyouthatrisk:Ourhopeforthefuture.NewJersey:NationalEducationalServices
17
SHIFTING THE RESPONSEAswiththerestofCanada,Winnipeg’sresponsetoyouthhomelessnesshaslargelyfocusedonreactiveemergencyandcrisisresponsesystems.Whileemergencyresponsesarenecessary,bydefinitionemergencysystemsalonecannotreduceorendyouthhomelessness.
Toreduceandendyouthhomelessness,we must shift our collective responsetofocusonpreventionandearlyintervention.7
Withthisrecognition,communitymembers,serviceproviders,andfundersdevelopedthisplantoinformawayforwardforthesector.
Current Responses to Homelessness in Winnipeg
Whileresourcesdedicatedtoyouthhomelessnessarerelativelyfewcomparedtotheresourcesdedicatedtoadulthomelessness,existingresponsesinthecityarefocusedoncrisisandemergencyresponses.Sometimesemergencyshelter/crisisresponseleadstolongertermhousing,butnotconsistently.Preventioneffortsaresmallinscaleanddisconnectedfromemergencyservices,housing,andlong-termsupports.Long-termsupportsarenotavailableacrossallhousingprograms.Andsupportsforhealing,education,andemploymentareofteninaccessibletoyouthwhoarehomeless.
Thestrategiespresentedinthisplanfocusondevelopingacoordinatedandseamlessresponsethatbuildsuponexistingservices,whileshiftingemphasistowardspreventionandearlyintervention.Bydevelopingacommonagendaandthroughconstantcommunication,communityactivitiescanmutuallyreinforceeachother.
PREVENTION EMERGENCY HOUSING SUPPORTS
Shifting the Response: Systems Integration
PREVENTION EMERGENCY RESPONSE
HOUSING & SUPPORTS
SUPPORT TO THRIVE
Supportsforfamiliesandcommunities
School-basedpreventionSystemsexits
HostHomesRapidRe-housingFamilyReunification
Crisishealth,mentalhealth&addiction
HousingContinuumTransitionalHousing
(FoyerModels)PermanentHousing
withSupports
LifeSkillsEducationEmploymentHealing
PLANNED, SUPPORTED, AND HEALTHY TRANSITIONS
Public InformationCommunity Hubs
Street Outreach Community Hubs
Information Sharing
Street OutreachCommunity Hubs
Information Sharing
Public Information Community Hubs
Current System
Access
18
WHY INVEST IN YOUTH HOMELESSNESSYouthhomelessnessisseriousconcerninWinnipegaffectingthelivesofyouth,oursocialservices,andinterferingwithyouth’sabilitytoexercisetheirhumanrights.Aboveall,youthhomelessnessispreventable.
Issues Connected to Youth Homelessness in Winnipeg:
•Gangs
•MissingandmurderedIndigenouswomen
•Youthsuicide
•Childpoverty
•MigrationfromNorthern,remote,rural,andFirstNationscommunities
•Youthsexualexploitation
YOUTH EXPERIENCING HOMELESSNESS ARE VULNERABLE
Experiencinghomelessnesshasimmediateandenduringdetrimentaleffectstothehealthandlife-trajectoriesofyouth.Thelongerayouthspendswithoutasafeplacetocallhome,theworsetheircircumstances.6364Withoutacoordinatedandeffectiveresponsetohomelessnessyouthonthestreetsface:
1. Increased mental health issues and substance abuse
Alcoholanddrugdependencyaswellasmentalhealthconditionsaresignificantlyhigherforyouthexperiencinghomelessness.65Whilementalhealthandsubstanceabusemaypreempthomelessnessinsomecases,66homelessnessisassociatedwithadeteriorationofyouths’mentalhealthandincreasedormoreriskysubstanceabuse.67
2. Sexual exploitation and sexual violence
Youthonthestreetsarecoercedbyeconomiccircumstancesorexploitativeindividualstoexchangesexformoney,shelter,drugs,food,andotherbasicneeds.Researchsuggeststhatbetween25to27.5percentofyouthinsheltersreportbeingexploitedinthesextrade.68Further,homelessyouth,particularlywomenandgirls,commonlyreportbeingrapedandsexuallyassaultedandfearbeingsexuallyvictimized.6970
3. Worsening physical health
Youthexperiencinghomelessnesshavehigherratesofpregnancy,HepatitisC,BandHIVinfectionthantheirpeers.71Importantly,alongitudinalstudyofyouthwithpastexperiencesofhomelessnessfoundthatthehealtheffectsofhomelessnessareenduring,even8yearsaftergaininghousing.72
4. Criminal victimization
Youthonthestreetsaremorelikelytobethevictimsofcrimethanhousedyouth.73Theyarealsomorelikelytowitnessandexperienceviolenceandviolentcrimes.7475
5. Involvement in the criminal justice system
Homelessnessandprolongedhomelessnessinparticularhasbeenassociatedwithincreasesincriminalactivity.76Involvementisalsoassociatedtothecriminalizationofhomelessnessthroughtheenforcementoflawsthatrestricttheuseofpublicspacesandparticipationintheinformaleconomysuchassqueegeeingandpanhandling.77Theseresponsesfailtoaddresstheunderlyingcausesofhomelessnessandcontributetothecycleofincarcerationandhomelessness.
6. Increased mortality78
Accordingtoastudyofstreet-entrenchedyouthinMontreal,youthonthestreetsare11.4timesmorelikelytoperishthanotheryouthinthesameagegroup.79Thisincreasedmortalityislargelytheresultofdrugoverdosesandsuicide.80
YOUTH HOMELESSNESS IS COSTLY
Thehumanandfinancialcostofyouthhomelessnessislargebecausethevictimization,criminalizationandpoorhealthassociatedwithhomelessnessleadtoanincreaseinserviceutilization.81
InAustralia,thecoststothehealthandjusticesystemservicesduetoyoungpeopleexperiencinghomelessnesswasestimatedat$17,868peryouthperyear,withatotalcostof$773milliontotheAustralianeconomyeveryyear.82
WhilenoequivalentresearchexistsinCanada,thestudydemonstratesthehighcostofyouthhomelessnessinacomparablenation.Thisresearchhighlightstheimportanceofpreventionandearlyinterventiontooffsetthecostsofalifetimeofhomelessness.
By shifting our response towards prevention and rapid intervention, and focusing on youth, we can increase the effectiveness and efficiency of public resources.
19
YOUTH HOMELESSNESS IS A HUMAN RIGHTS ISSUE
Lackofaccesstoadequatehousinghasbeenrecognizedasaglobalhumanrightscrisis.83Article25oftheUniversalDeclarationofHumanRights(1948)recognizestherighttohousing:
Everyone has the right to a standard of living adequate for the health and well-being of himself and of his family, including food, clothing, housing and medical care and necessary social services, and the right to security in the event of unemployment, sickness, disability, widowhood, old age or other lack of livelihood in circumstances beyond his control.
Further,TheUnitedNationsDeclarationontheRightsofIndigenousPeoplesNo.169reaffirmstherighttohousingandanadequatestandardofliving,addingthatIndigenouspeopleshavetherighttoself-determinetheireconomic,socialandculturaldevelopment.84
Youthhomelessnesshasasevereimpactonyouths’abilitytosatisfyotherprotectedrightssuchas85:
•Therighttoenjoythehighestpossiblestandardofhealth
•Therighttopersonalsafety
•Therighttoaneducation
•Therighttowork
•Therighttonon-discrimination
•Therighttosocialsecurity
•Therighttofreedomfromcruel,inhumanordegradingtreatmentorpunishment
Therighttoadequatehousingisanintegralcomponentoftherighttoanadequatestandardofliving.86Asasignatory,Canadaisunderlegalandmoralobligationtopromoteandprotectthehumanrightsofallpeople.
Homelessnessimpactstheabilityofyouthtoenjoytheirhumanrights,assuchallCanadiancitizenshavearesponsibilitytorespondbecausehuman rights belong to everyone.
WHAT ARE HUMAN RIGHTS?“Humanrightsarerightsinherenttoallhumanbeings,whateverournationality,placeofresidence,sex,nationalorethnicorigin,colour,religion,language,oranyotherstatus.
Weareallequallyentitledtoourhumanrightswithoutdiscrimination.Theserightsareallinterrelated,interdependentandindivisible.”
—Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights87
20
LAYING THE GROUNDWORK
Winnipeg’ssystemofyouth-servingorganizationshasbeendevelopedinacrisis-orientedenvironment,respondingtochangingneedsandadaptingtotrendsinfundingandpoliticalpriorities.Theseareofteninformedbyhigh-profileincidents,commonlythetragicdeathsofvulnerablechildren.
Asacommunity,despiteinnovativeresponses,strongresearch,andasectorthatworkstogetherthroughthistragedy,wehavenothadthesupport,alliances,orsharedvisionrequiredtoendyouthhomelessness.
Community-basedorganizationshaveastronghistoryofworkingthroughcoalitionsandnetworkstotackledifficultissuesrelatedtoyouth.TheGangActionInteragencyNetwork,theAddictionsAgenciesNetwork,theSexuallyExploitedYouthCoalition,CommunityLedOrganizationsUnitedTogether(CLOUT),YouthAgenciesAlliance,andothergrassrootsgroupshavepursuedholisticstrategiesthatrecognizetheinterconnectionofchallengesaffectingyoungWinnipeggers.
In2010,apartnershipofresidentialcareproviders,community-basedorganizations,andtheUniversityofWinnipegorganizedasummitfocusedontherelationshipbetweenhomelessnessandCFScare.
DEVELOPMENTOF THE PLANThisledtoacommunity-basedresearchprojectonthepathwaysintohomelessnessforyouth,andpotentialpolicyleversavailabletopreventandendyouthhomelessness.System Pathways into Youth Homelessness(2014)foundthatsystemswithvariousresponsibilitiestocareforyouth,includingCFS,Justice,EIA,andHealthandMentalHealth,weremissingopportunitiestopreventandendhomelessness.AsecondsummitonCFSandYouthHomelessnesswasheldtoexaminetheresultsoftheresearchandfurtherrefinerecommendationsrelatedtostabilityandpreparationin,andtransitionsoutof,CFScare.
Throughoutthistime,theWinnipegPovertyReductionCounciloftheUnitedWayinitiatedandfacilitatedataskforceonaPlantoEndHomelessness.TheMentalHealthCommission’sAtHome/ChezSoiHousingFirstresearchprojectwasendingandtherewasnosystemorframeworkinplacetoretainandcoordinateHousingFirstservices.Duringthesixteen-monthprocessofdevelopingthelong-termplan,theyouth-sectorraisedimportantconsiderationsaboutthedistinctnessofyouth.
In2014,theFederalHomelessnessPartneringStrategy(HPS)shifteditsfundingapproach.Aportionof2014/15fundingwasdedicatedtowardsHousingFirstreadinesspilotprojectstobeginthetransition.
21
Beyondtherequirementthat65%offundsbemarkedforHousingFirst,therewasnomulti-sectoralplanforthehomelessnessandHousingFirstsystemthatwasbasedonWinnipeg’spopulationorexistingsystemofsupports.TwoofWinnipeg’smajoryouthservingagencies,RaYandMacdonaldYouthServices(MYS),facedmajorfundingcutsandhadtoreduceservicessubstantially.MeremonthsafterTinaFontaine’sbodywaspulledfromtheRedRiver,drop-inresourcesforyouth,whichhadbeenclosetoachieving24/7access,hadtolayoffstaffandclosetheirdoorsmoreandmoreoften.Theneedforayouthplanhadneverbeenmoreobvious.
RaYconvenedameetingwithleadersfromyouth-servingorganizationswhowouldlaterformtheSteeringCommitteefortheplan.BasedonwisdomgainedthroughnationalrelationshipswiththeMobilizingLocalCapacityprogramofEva’sInitiatives,theydevelopedaproposalforayouth-centred,community-driven,andvalue-basedPlantoEndYouthHomelessnessinWinnipeg.AttheCanadianHouseandRenewalAssociation(CHRA)CongressinApril,2015,fundingtoembarkontheplandevelopmentprocesswasconfirmedfromtheManitobaGovernment.Shortlyafterward,theWinnipegFoundationcommittedfundingtoprovideresourcesneededtogenuinelyengagecommunitystakeholders,inparticularyouth,intheplanningprocess.
THE PLANNING PROCESS
ASteeringCommitteeofpartnerswasformalizedtooverseeandguidethedevelopmentoftheplan.SteeringCommitteememberswereinvitedtorepresenttheirorganizations,basedontheirexperienceworkingwithyouthwhoareatriskof,orexperiencing,homelessness.RepresentativesfromManitobaHousing,theBrandonNeighbourhoodRenewalCorporation,andEndHomelessnessWinnipegparticipatedintheSteeringCommitteetosupportalignmentandcoordinationacrossjurisdictionsandsectors.
Theprocessisgrounded in the voices of youthwithexperiencesofhomelessnessinWinnipeg,substantiated by the experience of practitioners,andinformed by research.
Extensiveyouthengagement,communityengagement,andresearchwereallpartoftheplanningprocess.Theengagementsweredesignedtodeepenunderstandingofexistingsupportsforyouthexperiencinghomelessness,discussthegapsinthesupportsystem,andbuildmomentum/commitmenttowards
endingyouthhomelessnessacrosssectorsbasedonsharedprinciples.Researchinformedalloftheengagementsessions,soparticipantsunderstoodyouthhomelessnessanddiscussedpotentialsolutionsbasedontheirownexperiencesaswellassolidevidence.
Youth Engagement
Youthengagementprioritizedadiversity of voices, continuous engagement,andwasgrounded in social justicewithaccessible,participatoryapproachessoyouthcurrentlystrugglingwithhomelessnesscouldprovidemeaningfulfeedback.Youthwhohadexperiencedhomelessnesswereapartofalmosteveryconsultation,includingmostSteeringCommitteemeetings,thevisioningsummit,mostoftheroundtables,andtheopenhouse.DetailsontheyouthengagementprocessisinAppendixA.
Overall, at least 100 youth who experienced homelessness participated in the development of this plan.
Community Engagement
Communityengagementwasdesignedtobuild on existing knowledge and capacity,recognizetheexpertise of practitioners,andbeopen and transparent withallstakeholders.DetailsonthecommunityengagementprocessareinAppendixB.
Overall, at least 200 community and government stakeholders representing 70 different agencies, departments, or associations participated in the development of this plan.
Research
Researchandanalysisofexistingdataonyouthhomelessnesshasbeenongoingthroughouttheplanningprocess.ItbeganwithsecondaryanalysisofdatafromtheWinnipegStreetCensus,whichallowedustounderstandtheextentandnatureofyouthhomelessness.ThiswasfollowedbyareviewofexistingCanadianstrategiesandplanstoendyouthhomelessness.Ascopingreviewwasconductedonthecausesandpromisinginterventionsofyouthhomelessnessinternationally,nationally,andlocally.Researchincludedcontinuousserviceandsystemmapping,andanalysisoflocaldata.ResearchfindingsweresubstantiatedbytheexperienceofthePlanningTeamandtheSteeringCommittee.
22
STARTING VISION
Youth Vision Meetingsandfocusgroups;TurnUpYourVoiceReport
Visioning Summit129peoplefrom58governmentdepartmentsandcommunityorganizations
ResearchRevieweddata/SurveyedresearchSystemmapping/Gapanalysis
Surveys
YOUTH PRIORITIES
Indigenous Youth Feast and Forum
VOICES Youth in Care Network
STAKEHOLDER PRIORITIES
RoundtablesSixroundtableswithyouth,governmentandcommunitystakeholdersonthetopicsofAccess,Prevention,HousingSupply,HousingandSupport,SupportstoThrive,andSystemIntegration
INDIGENOUS COMMUNITIES’ PRIORITIES
Indigenous Leaders’ Discussion
REVIEW AND IMPLEMENTATION PLANNING
Presentations and FeedbackAtEagleUrbanTransitionCentre,ResourceAssistanceforYouth,YouthAgenciesAlliance,EndHomelessnessWinnipeg
Open HousePublicopenhousewithyouth,government,andcommunitystakeholders
Steering Committee Review and Planning
Steering Committee Review and Planning
Steering Committee Review and Planning
Steering Committee Review and Planning
THE PLANNING PROCESSTheprocessisgroundedinthevoicesofyouthwithexperiencesofhomelessnessinWinnipeg,substantiatedbytheexperienceofpractitioners,andinformedbyresearch.
WHO PARTICIPATED?
•Over100youthwithexperiencesofhomelessness
•200communityandgovernmentstakeholders
•70differentagencies,departmentsorassociations
23
Thestrategicframeworkincludesthevision,mission,values,pillars,objectives,andactionstrategiesoftheplan.Theframeworkcanbevisuallyrepresentedthroughacircle,withyouthinthecentre.Noneoftheactionstrategiesshouldbeseeninisolationfromtheframework:thevaluesarelikethelacesofahanddrum,inorderforthedrumtomaketherightsound,allofthelacesinthebackendneedtobeinterwovenandtiedtogetherintherightway.Thisframeworkrecognizestheinterdependencethatexistsbetweenthosewhoexperience,careabout,andrespondtoyouthhomelessness,andempowersustoacttogetherasacommunity.
STRATEGICFRAMEWORK
YOUTH
VALUES
PILLARS
TEACHINGS
CommunitiesInclusion
Strength-based
Equity
Youth-Centred
ReconciliationEvidence and Researchinformed
CulturalCompetence
Choice
Youth Voice
Holistic
Love
Respect
Courage
Honesty
Wisdom
Humility
Truth
Supports to Thrive
Access
Prevention
Housing andSupports
PeersFamilies
24
Principles and Values
Love,Respect,Courage,Honesty,Wisdom,Humility,Truth
1.Understandyouthholistically,asmembersoffamiliesandcommunities.
• Weneedtobeholisticinourapproaches
• Servicesandsupportsshouldrespondtotheuniquenessofneighbourhoods,communities,andyouth
2.Youthhavetherighttoleadthedevelopmentoftheirownplans,andtobesupportedduringandaftertransitions.
• Transitionsshouldnotleadtohomelessness
• Thereneedstobesharedaccountabilityduringtransitions
• Endingyouthhomelessnessrequiresaplannedtransitionintohealthyadulthoodandinterdependence
3.Buildonwhatisworking.
• Allyouthhavestrengths
• Evidence and researchshouldinformourapproaches
• Localserviceprovidershaveexistingcapacity,profoundunderstandingoftheissues,andtrustingrelationshipswithyouth;buildonthem
4.Youthself-identifywhattheywantandneed.
• Startwithyouth at the centre
• Weneedtoexpandchoicesforyouthandlistentothem
• Cultureiscentraltowhopeopleare;wemustbeculturally competent
5.Youthhomelessnessisnotacceptable,andweallhavearoleinpreventingandendingit.
• Reconciliationisaboutallofusandnecessitatestransforminghowweworktogether
• Allstakeholders,includingfamilies,communities,Indigenouspeoples,community-basedorganizations,governments,andfundersneedtobeincludedandhavearesponsibilitytocollaborateandaligninthebestinterestsofyouth
• Decision-makingprocessesmustrecognizepowerdynamicsandpromoteself-determinationofyouth
• Equitablepracticessupportfairoutcomesforoppressedindividualsandgroups
Teachings
25
STRATEGY ONE: ACCESSConsultationswithdiversegroupsofyouthandstakeholderssuggestthatcurrentserviceprovisionisfragmentedanduncoordinated,preventingyouthfromaccessingtheservicestheyneedquickly.
ThevisionforStrategyOneistohaveacoordinatedsystemofresourceswhereallyouthhaveimmediateandongoingaccesstothesupportsneededtoprevent,alleviateandrespondtohomelessness.
System integration can be defined broadly as the provision of services with high levels of coordination, communication, trust, and respect among service agencies so that they are better able to work together to achieve common objectives.88
What We’ve Heard:
•Youth,advocates,andagencyandsystemstaff,lackknowledgeaboutthefullrangeofresources,services,andprogramsavailable.
•Whenyouthattempttoaccessservicestheyoftenencounterbarrierssuchas:strictagemandates,no-petpolicies,shortopeninghours,requirementsforidentification,sobrietyandmore.
•Informationsharingandcollaborationamongagenciesiscomplicatedbyprivacyconcerns,lackofcommoninformationmanagementsystemsandsharedspacesforcommunication.
•Bydiversifyingaccesspointsforkeyresourcesandinformationweassistyouththatareunfamiliaranddisconnectedfromservicestoquicklyaccesstheresourcestheyneed.
•ItisessentialthatallaccesspointsadoptaNo Wrong Door Approachthatallowsyouthtobeconnectedtoservicesthatmeettheirneeds.
“Lotsofprogramswillreferyoutootherprogramsandyou’realwayssentsomewhereelse.Orwhenyou’reintheprogramstheyputyouthroughhoopsormakeitimpossibleforyoutodothingstoaccomplishwhattheywantyoutodo.”—Youth
OBJECTIVE 1.1
Establish a coordinated access strategy
•Develop a network of regional hubs open 24/7 by increasing the capacity of existing youth-serving agencies.
Thesehubswouldbeasafespaceforyouthtohangoutandaccessbasicneeds,housingservices,systemnavigators,andmeetwithsystemrepresentatives.Thehubswouldberesponsivetotheneedsoftheircommunitiesandthepopulationstheyserve.
Allhubswillbeconnectedthroughacommoncommunicationandinformationmanagementstrategy.SeeObjective1.2.
“Havemorecommunitycentresopenduringtheweekandweekendsfor[youth]tohavemoreopportunitytofindsomewheretostay.”—Youth
•Establish a comprehensive and robust network of regional street outreach teams active 24/7.
Streetoutreachteamsprovideservicestothemostvulnerableyouth.Theseteamswoulddeveloptrustingrelationshipswithyouthonthestreetsandalsohavetheabilitytosupportimmediateintakesandreferralstoarangeofservices.
TheywillbeconnectedtoeachotherthroughtheWinnipegOutreachNetworkandtohubsthroughacommoncommunicationsandinformationmanagementstrategyseeObjective1.2.
“Everybodylovesstreetoutreach!Staffactuallycare.”—Youth
•Ensure that emergency systems, such as shelters, become direct access points to long-term housing supports.
SeeObjective3.1.
Promising Practices in Winnipeg
•Winnipeg Outreach Networkcoordinatescity-widestreetoutreachamongvariousserviceprovidersinWinnipeg.
•ANo Wrong Door PolicywasimplementedbytheWinnipegRegionalHealthAuthority(WRHA)forallhealthservices.Recognizingthatpatientshavedifficultynavigatingthehealthsystem,allWRHAdepartmentsplayaroleinconnectingpatientstotherightservices.TheyhavedevelopedaHealthOutreachandCommunitySupportTeam(HOCS)toassistwithsystemnavigationifdepartmentstaffstrugglewithfindingtherightservicesforcomplexcases.
1
26
•24/7SafeSpacesthroughSpenceNeighbourhoodAssociationintheWestEnd,RossbrookHouseinCentennial,andNdinaweintheNorthEndaredrop-incentresthatrespondtocommunity/neighbourhooddemographicsoffersafeandeasytoaccessovernightservices.
Promising Responses
•TheDepartmentofHomelessServicesStreetinNewYorkCityprovidesoutreach24hoursaday,7daysperweek.Outreachteamsareconnectedtoserviceprovidersineachborough.Byquicklyconnectingadultsandyouthonthestreetswithhousingchoices,theyhavebeenabletomove4,100individualsoffthestreetsandintohousingsincetheirinception.Further,theirteamisconnectedtoa311service,wherebymembersofthepubliccancalliftheyseeanindividualwhoappearshomelessandinneedofservices.89
OBJECTIVE 1.2
Improve collaboration among stakeholders by promoting communication
•Identify existing community and system access points for youth experiencing homelessness and develop coordinated intake and referral protocols that best meet the needs of youth.
Anyprotocolsorassessmenttoolsusedshouldalignwiththecoreprinciplesandvalues.
“Idon’twanttowastemybreathtalkingtosomeonewhowon’tbeinmylife.”—Youth
•Develop consistent and compatible policies for consent to information sharing with the support of Privacy Officers.
•Create a common database that facilitates information sharing.
ThedatabasedevelopmentneedstofollowtheprinciplesofOwnership,Control,Access,andPossession.
•Organize regular networking events for service providers to communicate changes in programs and processes, participate in shared trainings, and develop effective practices specific to the needs of youth.
IncludestafftrainingonallaspectsofLGBTQ2S*andIndigenousculturalcompetency.
Promising Practices in Winnipeg
•The Building Futures programforyouthagingoutofcareisapartnershipbetweenfouragenciesandtwofundingbodies.Nomatterwhereyouthfirstaskforsupport,theycanbeconnectedtothe
rangeofservicesavailable:employmentassistance,counseling,servicenavigation,financialmanagement,and/ormentorship.
Promising Responses:
•Multiple location decentralized intake.AlamedaCountyHousingResourceCentresinCaliforniaofferdecentralizedaccesspointsthrougheightHousingResourceCentres(HRC).Atthesecentres,individualsareassessed,providedwithascorebasedonfinancialinformationandstrengths,andconnectedtoservicestheyneedatthemulti-servicecentres.Coordinationamongthecentresisthroughacommonassessmenttoolanddatacollectionmethods.
OBJECTIVE 1.3
Remove barriers to access across youth serving agencies, government agencies, and safe spaces
•Define, adopt and implement common core principles and values for working with youth.
Thisincludesharm-reduction,non-judgmentalbarrierfree,culturallyappropriate,andstrengths-basedservices.
•Promote barrier free safe spaces.
Thisincludes:child-friendly,pet-friendly,waitlist-free,appointment-free,non-judgmental,withflexiblehours,andwithbroadagemandates.
•Increase the availability and responsiveness of crisis stabilization and detox services.
“Alotofplaceswon’thelpbecauseyou’reeithertooyoungortooold.OneagencysaidIwastooyoung(age19–under21),anotherthatIwastooold(over18).Oneplaceyouhavetobe21anotherunder18.Ifyou’rebetweenthoseages,noonewantstohelpyou.”—Youth
Promising Practices in Winnipeg
•Youth Agencies Alliance (YAA)consistsof18youth-servingagencymemberswhomeetmonthly.Theyhavedevelopedcollectivevaluesincluding:
•Collaboration
•Relationships
•Bestpractices
•Safe,inclusiveandmeaningfulprograms
•Resource Assistance for Youth, Inc.providesbarrierfreedrop-inservices:
•Harm-reductionmodel
•Pet-friendlyatmosphere
27
•Broadagemandate,child-friendly(0-29years)
•Noneedforidentificationtoaccessprimaryhealth
“YoucanbringadogoranotherpethereatRaY.Mydogdoesn’thavetostayoutsideinthemiddleofwinterandfreezeorgetstolen.”—Youth
Promising Responses
•The Homeless Youth Collaborative on Developmental Evaluation90 inTwinCities,Minnesotaisacollaborativeofsixhomelessyouthserviceagenciesthatparticipatedinaresearchstudytoidentifyanddefinenineevidencebasedprinciplesforworkingwiththeirpopulation.Thefollowingprincipleswereadoptedbytheagenciesin2013:
•Journey-Oriented
•Trauma-Informed
•Non-Judgmental
•HarmReduction
•TrustingYouth-AdultRelationships
•Strengths-Based
•PositiveYouthDevelopment
•Holistic
•Collaboration
• The United States Interagency Council on Homelessness Opening Doors Plan, Washington,DC,isafederalstrategicplantopreventandendhomelessness.Theirfoundationalvaluesinclude:
•Homelessnessisunacceptable
•Therearenohomelesspeople,butratherpeoplewhohavelosttheirhomeswhodeservetobetreatedwithdignityandrespect
•Homelessnessisexpensive;itisbettertoinvestinsolutions
•Homelessnessissolvable;wehavelearnedalotaboutwhatworks
•Homelessnesscanbeprevented
•Thereisstrengthincollaboration
OBJECTIVE 1.4
Establish a centralized public information resource
•Create a single, comprehensive and updated website, mobile app, and pocket resource guide with resources for youth experiencing, or at risk of homelessness.
IncludeparticularcontentforIndigenousyouthmigratingfromFirstNations,youthfromruralandremotecommunities,LGBTQ2S*youthandotherpopulationswithuniqueneeds.
“Youthmaynothavephonesbuttheystillgoontheinternet,soweb-basedinformationoreventheabilitytomakeappointmentsonlinecouldimproveaccessibility.”—Roundtable participant
•Develop a 24/7 telephone hotline for youth experiencing or at risk of homelessness.
•Partner with northern, remote, and First Nations Communities to develop a communication and resource access strategy for youth migrating to Winnipeg.
Promising Practices in Winnipeg
•The Gang Action Interagency Network (GAIN) isdevelopingayouth-friendlyappwithresourcesandservicesforyouth,identifyinglocationsthatdonothavebarriersforthosewhohavebeeninvolvedingangs.
•Manitoba’s Contact Guide,acommunityservicesdirectoryiscurrentlybeingre-developedinpartnershipwiththeUnitedWay’s211initiative.
Promising Responses
•Youth Services and Supports in Toronto isaservicedirectoryforyouth16-29andtheirsupportscreatedbytheCityofToronto.Theguideisdevelopedwithyouthinmindandcanbefoundonline.91
What do you want service providers to hear?
• Openyourdoors
• Moreopportunitiesforourvoicestobeheard,liketoday
• Lotsmorepromotionsandadvertisingofservices.“Thisisnotasecretservice”betterpromotionlike:flyersattheschools,billboards,televisionandcableads
• 1-800numberforeasyphoneaccesstoservices
• Ionlyfoundtheseservicesthroughafamilyconnection[these]shouldbemoreavailablethanthat.[They]shouldbemoreavailablethanthat.
Youth at the Indigenous Youth Forum
28
Decolonization and Access
•Improve Equitable Access. Effortstoreducebarriersandincreasecommunicationintheyouthhomelessnesssectorwillimproveequitableaccesstosocialserviceswhichisanessentialcomponentofthedecolonizationofsystems.DuringtheIndigenousYouthForum,youthwereaskedwhatculturally-appropriateserviceslookedlike,theydescribedplacesthatmake people feel at homebecausetheyare:
•Respectful
•Genuine
•Honest
•Empathetic
•Promoteasenseofbelonging-especiallyimportantifwedon’thavefamilies
•Supportive
•Connecttoresources
•Non-judgmental
•Loyal
•Persistent
•Sillyandwithasenseofhumour
•Incorearea
•Non-institutionalbecause“Securityatthefrontisintimidating”
•Cultural Competency Training. Inparticular,theTruthandReconciliationCommissioncallstoactiontheculturalcompetencytrainingoflawyers,healthpractitioners,andpublicservants.Inthespiritofthisrecommendationwecallforthecontinuedtrainingofyouthserviceprovidersinthehomelessnesssectorsothattheymayprovideculturally-safeandappropriateservices.
•Involve Indigenous peoplesatalllevelsofserviceprovision,includinghiringIndigenousstaff,recruitingIndigenousBoardMembers,andbuildingpartnershipswithIndigenous-ledorganizationsforprogramming.
•Bridge the gaps in resources with First Nations Communities.ThroughthecollaborativedevelopmentofoutreachstrategiesforIndigenousyouthandtheircommunities,wearerecognizingthemobilityofIndigenousyouthinremoteareasandtheopportunitiesforresourcesharing.
STRATEGY TWO: PREVENTIONPreventionmeansdoingwhatwecantoaddressthestructural,systemic,family,andindividualfactorsleadingtoyouthhomelessnesssothatitneverhappens.Whenthisisnotpossible,itmeansrespondingquicklysothathomelessnessisashortexperiencethatdoesnotleadtostreet-entrenchmentandlong-termhomelessness.ThefollowingsectiondescribesobjectivesthatweredesignedtopreventyouthhomelessnessbasedonthepathwaysintoyouthhomelessnessinWinnipeg.Thisstrategycombinesdifferenttypesofprevention:primaryprevention(reducingrisk-factors),secondaryprevention(earlyintervention),andtertiaryprevention(reducingimpactsoflong-termhomelessness).92
ThevisionforStrategyTwoisthatyouthandtheirfamiliesstrugglingwithriskfactorsofhomelessnessareidentifiedandsupported.
“Alotofprogramsattackproblems,butyouguysneedtoattacktherootsoftheproblems.Notanovernightthing,thereviewprocesstakestime.EIA,Justice,CFS,Addictionsetc.,theyallplayaroleinhomelessness.Everyprobleminthecityinterconnectswithoneanother.”—Youth
What We’ve Heard:
•Families and communities are important. Thenumberonecauseofpeople’sfirstexperienceofhomelessnessisfamilybreakdown,conflict,orviolence;weneedtobuildstrengthenfamiliesinsteadofcreatingdivisions.
“Wedon’thaveaproactiveapproach,thereneedstobeafocusonthefamilyunit.”—Youth
•Schools matter. Allyouthexperiencinghomelessnesswereconnectedtoaschoolatonepoint.Yet,graduationratesarelowpreventingyouthfromgainingemploymentandtransitioningintoadulthood.
“Ifyoudon’thaveaplaceyouwon’tbeabletoconcentratebecauseofstayingupallnight.That’swhatpreventedmefromgoingbacktoschool.Lackofrest.”—Youth
2
29
System Exits. Thereareopportunitiestopreventhomelessnesswhenyouthleaveresidentialgovernmentsystems,includingjustice,CFS,health,mentalhealth,andaddictionstreatment.
“MakeanextensiontoallchildreninCFSto25not21.Itwouldprovidefinancialandemotionalstability,lessyouthhomelessness.”—Youth
•Migration from First Nations Communities. WeneedtobothpreventhomelessnesswithinNorthern,rural,andFirstNationscommunities,andprovidesafetynetswhenyouthfirstarriveinWinnipeg.
“Providefundingandadequatesupportservicestoyouthonthereserves.”—Youth
OBJECTIVE 2.1
Foster resilience among families and communities
•Support poverty reduction strategies that promote access to basic income and affordable housing for families living in poverty.
•Provide parents with access to effective, affordable, anti-oppressive, culturally-appropriate, and community-based parenting supports. These should be available, in particular, to young parents and before families are in crisis or connected with the CFS system.
•Encourage the CFS System to focus on prevention and the promotion of healthy kinship supports by reducing apprehension rates, with appropriate resources to achieve this.
•Encourage the transformation of the CFS System so youth who are in care have what they need to thrive. This includes consistent, stable, quality homes; stable support to develop and keep healthy family, peer, and community relationships, and; opportunities to explore a range of employment and educational paths.
•Support family-centred and accessible mental health and addiction strategies. Base these on evidence and evaluate them regularly through both research and community consultations.
Promising Practices in Winnipeg
•Metis Child and Family Services Living in Family Enhancement (L.I.F.E.) programoffersauniquealternativetotheapprehensionandremovalofchildrenfromtheirfamily.Familiesintheprogramresidewithatrainedfosterparentwhoactsasarole
modelandwillsupport,guideandmentortheparentsinordertorestorethestrength,health,andwell-beingofallfamilymembersandtostrengthenthecareprovidedtothechildrenwithinthecircleoftheirfamily.
•The Aboriginal Health & Wellness Centre of Winnipeg Inc. Head Start Programpromoteshealthychilddevelopmentthroughanevidence-basedparentingprogramtoFirstNations,Métis,andInuitchildren,whoare3and4yearsold.Theprogramfollowssiximportantcomponents:nutrition,parentalinvolvement,socialsupport,cultureandlanguage,healthpromotion,andeducation.
•General Child and Family Services Authority, Family Enhancement Pilot Projectsaimtoprovidelow-to-mediumriskfamilieswithintensiveservicesincludinghouseholdsupportservices,supportandmentoringtoachildand/orparentandsupportivecounseling.Duringthefirst90daysofservice54%offamiliesreceivevisitsonceaweekormore,38%offamiliesarevisitedtwotothreetimesamonthandin8%ofcasesvisitsoccurlessthantwiceamonth.
Promising Responses
•In Home Family Supports, Ben Calf Robe Society in Edmonton. Ketotayminawok(“AllmyRelations”),providesculturally-sensitiveinterventionandsupportservicestoAboriginalfamilieswiththeaimofstrengtheningandpreservingyouth,childrenandtheirfamilies.Thesehome-basedandfamily-centeredservicesaredesignedtopromotetheprotectionandwellbeingofchildrenintheirhomes,preventunnecessarylong-termout-of-homeplacements,andrespondimmediatelytothefamilyatthepointofcrisis.
•The Ottawa Inuit Children’s Centre (OICC or the Centre). TheCentreoffersavarietyofchildren’sprograms,includingAboriginalHeadStart,daycare,full-daykindergarten,andafter-schoolactivities,aswellascultural,language,literacy,andsupportprogramsforfamilies.TheCentrewascreatedin2005byparentsofchildrenattendingtheAboriginalHeadStartprogram,andallsubsequentchildren’sprogramsweredesignedusingthesameholisticcomponentsandcentralobjectives,namely:
•Earlychildhoodeducationtosupportschoolreadiness
•Promotionofhealthynutrition
•Encouragementofparentinvolvementintheprogramandchilddevelopment
•CelebrationofAboriginallanguageandculture
•Healthpromotiongenerally
•Reinforcementofsocialsupportnetworksforfamilieswithyoungchildren.
30
•Safe in the Citywasaninnovativeresponsetoyouthhomelessnesslaunchedin1988intheUnitedKingdom.Itconsistedofan‘earlyintervention’targetedatyouththatwereidentifiedtobeat-riskofhomelessness.Theinterventioncomponentsincluded:personaldevelopment,familysupportandskillsandemployability.Participantswhoengagedinallelementsreportedthatthefamilysupportpiecewasmostimportanttothem.Further,thosewhoparticipatedinpersonaldevelopmentandskillsandemployabilitywithoutfamilysupporthadlimitedoutcomes,suggestingthatfamilysupportisanessentialpieceofearlyinterventioneffortstopreventhomelessness.93
OBJECTIVE 2.2
Prevent newcomer youth homelessness
•Work with settlement sector, schools, and the Immigration Partnership Winnipeg to investigate the prevalence and experience of youth homelessness among newcomers to develop effective responses.
Promising Practices
•Hidden in Our Midst: Homeless Newcomer Youth in Toronto.In2014,theChildren'sAidSocietyinTorontoandtheCentreforAddictionandMentalHealthconductedacomprehensivestudytounderstandthespecificcircumstancesofnewcomeryouthexperiencinghomelessnessastheytendtobehiddenfromview.94Theirobjectiveswere:1)exploretheexperiencesofandpathwaysintohomelessnessamongasampleofnewcomeryouthinToronto;2)identifyserviceneedsandinvestigatewhatnewcomeryouthbelievetobecriticalcomponentsofinterventionsaimedatreducingandpreventinghomelessness;3)assesscurrentservicesystemcapacitiesforrespondingtohomelessnessamongnewcomeryouth;4)identifyservicegapsandpossiblepromisingpracticesamongbothtraditionalserviceagenciesandethno-culturalagenciesthatcurrentlyorcouldinfutureaddressthosegaps.Thishasallowedthemtoplanforbetterprogramsandservicesthatmeettheneedsofthispopulation.Topreventhomelessnesstheyrecommended:
•Wideravailabilityofnewcomeryouthpeersupportnetworks
•Agencystaffthatadvocatefortheirhousingneeds
•Intensivecasemanagementandfollow-upwhenyouthfirstarrivetoCanada
•Targetedservices
•Opportunitiesfor“self-care”
OBJECTIVE 2.3
Adopt and implement school-based prevention strategies
•Work with schools to identify youth experiencing conflict within their families and connect youth and their families to supports early.
•Work with schools to integrate life skills and Indigenous teachings that address the specific risk factors for youth homelessness into their curriculums.
•Integrate community-based resources into schools. This includes resources such as Elders, resource workers, and peer mentors to address family conflict and acceptance of gender diversity for LGBTQ2S* youth.
•Work with schools and CFS to identify youth who are disconnected from the education system and provide appropriate supports to address the barriers they face in completing school.
Promising Practices in Winnipeg
•MostschoolsinManitobateachsomeaspectsoflifeskillsandincludeIndigenousteachingsintheircurriculums.Thereisanopportunitytointegratespecificlifeskillsthatrelatetohomelessness,includingconflictresolution,systemsnavigation,housingapplications,andtenantrightsandresponsibilitiesintoexistingprograms.
•WayfindersandCEDA’sPathwaysprogramareschool-basedsupportsforyouth.Theyprovideassistancewithtransitionsbetweenschools,homework,career
VOICES Youth in Care Network participants agreed the following would make schools better:
•Solidarity against bullying
•Mental health supports
•Preparation for life after high school
•Skilled teachers
•Equity and equality
•Less institutional and a greater focus on investing in people
31
andeducationplanning,lifeskills,familyconflict,andotherneedsidentifiedbytheyouth.
Promising Responses
•RAFT Supporting Canada’s Youth. SchoolsandcommunitypartnersintheNiagaraRegionreferat-riskyouthtoacasemanagerwhodevelopsacommunity-basedplanofactionbasedonindividualneeds.
•Alone in London. WorkshopsandawarenessraisinginitiativesaboutthecausesandconsequencesofhomelessnessdeliveredtoyouthinLondonschools.Theprogramincludesmodulesonconflictresolutionandcommunication,bullying,confidenceandself-esteem.Post-workshop,96%ofstudentsreportknowingwheretogoforhelpiftheybecomehomeless.
•The Reconnect Program aimstoidentifystudents‘at-risk’ofhomelessnessandrespondquicklytohelpstabilizetheirlivingsituation,andimproveengagementwithfamily,work,andeducationinthecommunity.TheprogramhasbeenextensivelyevaluatedwithpositiveoutcomesandhasbeenculturallyadaptedtoserveIndigenousyouthinAustralia.
•The Geelong Project. InthisAustralianintervention,riskisevaluatedforeverystudentthroughariskandassetsassessmenttoolStudentNeedsSurvey(SNS)whichalsoincludesinformationfromteachersandcounselors.Thosedeemedatriskhaveascreeninginterview.Then,theyareallocatedarangeofservices,theirintensitywilldependontheneedsoftheindividual.Therearethreetiers:
1. low-intensitymonitoringandreferralstosupports,
2. caseworksupportandmonitoring,
3. wrap-aroundcasemanagementforcomplexcases,involvingnumerousagencies.
Casemanagementisbothyouth-centeredandfamily-centered.
OBJECTIVE 2.4
Ensure that youth in government care do not exit into homelessness
Homelessness is a “fusion” policy issue, and must necessarily involve health, corrections and justice, housing, education and child welfare, for instance.”
—Stephen Gaetz, 2014, p.434
•Create an interdepartmental “Zero Discharge into Homelessness” strategy, starting with a coordinated provincial policy direction, that supports youth transitioning from any type of Provincial government or government funded care.
ProvincialgovernmentcareincludesCFS,Justice/Corrections,HealthCare,MentalHealthandCrisisStabilization,andAddictionsTreatment.ConsidertheapplicabilityofasimilarstrategyformovementfromFirstNations’CommunitiesandtransitionsoutofFederalCorrections.
•Develop and enforce regulations to ensure consistent and early exit planning for youth in governmental care.
Everyeffortshouldbemadesowhentheyexit,youthhavetheresourcesandskillstobesafelyhousedandthrive–includingculturally-appropriateprogramming,abilitytonavigatesystems,practicallifeskillstraining,andahighschooleducation.Developastandardizedchecklistthatcanbeusedacrosssystems.
“Greaterplanning,choice,andoptionswhilebeingincarenotjustsuddenlywhenagingoutat18yearsold”—Youth
32
•Provide all youth who have been in the care of CFS with the choice to receive ongoing supports funded by CFS until the age of 25 regardless of legal status.
Thisincludesincome,educationandtraining,systemnavigation,healthandmentalhealthcare,andmentorshipsupportsavailabletoyouthasaright.
•Incorporate family and community reunification in the development of transition plans.
“IwasunnecessarilystrugglingforfouryearsuntilIconnectedwiththem[myfamily].They’rereallypatientwithme,that’swhatIneed.”—Youth
Promising Practices in Winnipeg
•The Manitoba Foster Family NetworkhasdevelopedatargetedtrainingprogramforFosterFamiliesincludinghowtoprovidemeasuredskilldevelopmentforyouthintheircare.
•Manitoba Youth Transitional Employment Assistance Mentorship (MYTEAM),isaprogramofKaNiKanichihkthatassistsyouthages16–21whoareagingoutofthechildwelfaresystembyprovidingarangeofindividualizedmentorshipsupportsintendedtoimproveeducationandemploymentoutcomesandsuccessfultransitiontoindependentliving.MYTEAMprovidesorarrangesforfinancialassistance,supportivehousing,educationalandtrainingassistance,employmentplacementsupports,jobcoachingandsifeskillsmentorship.Mentorscansupportyouthforaperiodofuptotwoyears.
•CLOUT Program isapartnershipbetweenninecommunityagencieswhoprovideshorttermlicensedfosterhomesandintensivesupportforbirthfamiliesworkingtowardreunification(22beds).
Promising Responses
•Eva’s Initiatives, Family Reconnect Program. Inrecognitionthatyouthexperiencinghomelessnessmainlyduetofamilybreakdownandwiththebeliefthattheroleoffamilyisessentialforyouthtransitioningintoadulthood,thisprogramworkstorebuildreconciliationwhenitissafetodosoinToronto.95
•Department for Communities and Local Development. InAugustof2012,Making every contact count, a joint approach to preventing homelessnesswaspublishedbytheMinisterialWorkingGrouponHomelessnessintheUnitedKingdom.Theysetoutanumberofrecommendationsinthehopethat“Wecanbuildafuturewheremistakesanddifficultiesinyouthordischargefromprisons,hospitalsandcaredonotleadtohomelessnessinthewaytheytoooftendonow.”Oneofthekeypolicycommitmentsofthisdocumentincludes:
•TheGovernmentwill:“helppreventprisonersfrom
becominghomelessonreleasefromcustodybykeepinginpaymentthehousingelementofthenewUniversalCreditfromOctober2013tothoseservingsentencesofsixmonthsorless,allowingthemtomaintaintheirtenancies.UndercurrentrulesHousingBenefitpaymentsceaseifapersonimprisonedlongerthanthreemonths.”(p.21)96
OBJECTIVE 2.5
Support Indigenous youth moving to Winnipeg
•Create a coordinated and collaborative strategy with Indigenous communities to support youth migrating to Winnipeg.
Thisshouldinclude:actionstosupportyouthtostayintheirhomecommunitiesiftheychooseandworkingwithCFStoprovidethesupportyouthneedtomaintaintheconnectionstheyhavetotheirhomecommunitiesiftheyareremoved.
•Provide outreach services and resources (toolkits) to youth in First Nation communities, at contact points for youth migrating across Manitoba, and at arrival points in Winnipeg.
•Develop a non-stigmatizing and non-judgmental network of care to identify and support recent migrants to the city.
•Connect youth from First Nation communities to Indigenous social supports (family or community) in the city, including host homes.
“Providemoreopportunitiestopreventhomelessnessforthosemigratingtothecities.” —Youth
Promising Practices in Winnipeg
•The Eagle Urban Transition Centre.Since2005theyhaveservedasahubofinformationandcentrallocationforclientsseekingtransitionalsupportwhilelivinginand/orrelocatingtoWinnipeg.
•Peguis First Nation Post-secondary Indigenous Transition Program, hostedbytheCanadianMennoniteUniversity(CMU). Theprogramincludeslifeskillstraining,anIndigenousculturalawarenesscomponent,andaccrediteduniversitycoursesthroughCMU.Itisintendedtosupportyouth’stransitiontoWinnipegandpost-secondaryeducation.
Promising Responses
•New in Town Aboriginal Welcome CentreinEdmontonprovidesholisticassistanceforindividualstransitioningfromprovidesholisticassistanceforindividualstransitioningfromFirstNationscommunitiesintothecitythatarewithoutthesocialandeconomicsupportstheyneed.Servicesare
33
coordinated,mobile,culturally-drivenandaccessible24hoursaday,7daysperweek.Theyincludereferralstoemployment,housing,elders,culturalandeducationprograms.
OBJECTIVE 2.6
Decolonize systems and approaches to service provision
•Work with Manitoba Child and Family Services, Manitoba Education and Training, and Manitoba Justice to understand implications of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission and develop strategies to operationalize the Calls to Action.
•Teach a respectful and truthful account of history in the educational system and to those working with youth. “De-taboo” talking about colonization.
•Educate staff and volunteers at community-based organizations and government agencies on the histories of Indigenous peoples as called for in the Truth and Reconciliation Commission, to include skills-based training in intercultural competency, conflict resolution, human rights, and anti-racism.
•Ensure programs, services, and other resources developed through this Plan integrate the Seven Sacred Teachings and the values of the Plan into their approaches and processes.
Decolonization and Prevention
•Systems Level-Change.Effectivepreventioneffortsarenecessarilydecolonizingbecausetheyareaddressingthesystemswhichwerecreatedundercolonialism.ThroughrecommendationsthatcallforsystemstofocusonstrengtheninghealthyfamilyandcommunitysupportsthisstrategyisaddressingtheongoinglegaciesofcolonialismanditisinalignmentwiththeTruthandReconciliationCommissionofCanada,CallstoAction97whichinclude:
•1.ii.ProvidingadequateresourcestoenableAboriginalcommunitiesandchild-welfareorganizationstokeepAboriginalfamiliestogetherwhereitissafetodoso,andtokeepchildreninculturallyappropriateenvironments,regardlessofwheretheyreside(p.1)
•10.iii.Developingculturally-appropriatecurricula.(p.2)
•12.Wecalluponthefederal,provincial,territorial,andAboriginalgovernmentstodevelopculturallyappropriateearlychildhoodeducationprogramsforAboriginalfamilies.(p.2)
STRATEGY 3: HOUSING & SUPPORTSThedefiningfeatureofhomelessnessisalackofadequatehousing;thesolutiontohomelessnessmustthereforealwaysincludehousing.Thoughhousingandsupportareoftenviewed,anddeveloped,astwodistinctcontinuums,theymustbecoordinatedifwearetoendyouthhomelessness.Diversitybetweenprogrammodelscanallowforagreaterrangeofoptions,however,inpracticethereisinconsistencyinthetypeofsupportyouthcanexpect.Asprogramsareplanned,evaluated,andfunded,theprinciplesandvaluesshouldpermeatenewandexistinghousingandsupportstobetteralignwithourcollectivevision.
ThevisionforStrategyThreeisafullcontinuumofhousingsupplyandsupportsforyouthbasedonneedandchoice.
What We Heard:
•Thelimitedsupplyofsafeandaffordablerentalhousingmakestransitionstopermanenthousingchallengingforyouthacrossallhousingandsupportprograms.
•Transitionalandpermanenthousingprogramsneedtoprovidelifeskillsprogrammingandongoingsupportsafterprogramcompletion
•Poorhousingconditionsandfragmentedsupportsleadtoyearsofhousinginstabilityandepisodichomelessness.
•Allhousingshouldbeintegratedintocommunityandnon-institutionalinnature.
•Youthneedtheabilitytochoosewhetherornottohaveroommates,liveincongregatedorscatteredsitehousing,andthelevelandtypeofsupporttheyreceive.Theyalsoneedthechoicetochangetheirminds.
•HousingFirstcannotbehousingonly.Follow-up
3
34
INFORMATION AND REFERRALResource centres, drop-in centres, food programs, and many other agencies provide this. It ranges from giving a list of housing resources to building the trust needed to make appropriate referrals.
RAPID REHOUSINGHomeless outreach mentors, emergency shelters, and some information and referral locations provide support specifically to get into housing quickly.
FAMILY RECONNECTA number of information and referral locations, specifically programs for youth leaving the care of CFS, actively support youth with building healthy family relationships.
CASE MANAGEMENTMost transitional housing and independent living programs have case management models.
INTENSIVE CASE MANAGEMENT (ICM)Housing First Programs operate on an ICM model, which generally has lower case loads than traditional case management. There are 3 ICM teams specifically for youth, with 60 spots in total.
SUPPORTS WITHHOUSING
24/7 safe spaces(Rossbrook House, Ndinawe, West End 24/7)
Transitional housing (RaY REST program, Ma Mawi YellowShawl Housing, Pan Am Place, Siloam Mission Exit-Up
Supportivepermanent housing (youth under 21 and in care of CFS may transition topermanent adultsupports if they havea permanent and severe disability)
Subsidized housing (Manitoba Housing, not-for-profit housing)
Market rental housing (includes rooming houses)
Independent living programs (6 programs for youth aging out of care, up to age 21)
Rent supplements(HPS temporarilythen ManitobaHousing for Housing First)
Youth emergencyshelters (Ndinawe, 16 beds up to age 21; MYS 8 beds generally ages 12-17)
Adult emergencyshelters, familyshelter, and domesticviolence shelter
Supports for housing available for youth in Winnipeg
Winnipeg’s existing housing continuum for youth, basedonCanadaMortgageandHousingCorporationhousingcontinuum.
35
supports,mentorship,andconnectionstootherholisticservicesarenecessary.
•Youthwantchoiceovertheirneighbourhoods.Mostwouldpreferinner-citylocationswhereservicesareaccessible,andfriendsandfamilyareclose.
“[Livingin]richerareas...peoplestaredatus,that’swhywereturnedandarestilllivingintheNorthEnd.” —Youth
OBJECTIVE 3.1
Re-envision the emergency response for youth
•Adopt a “no wrong door” policy so youth can be referred to immediate, safe places to stay through multiple avenues.
Emergencysheltersforyouthrequiremoreflexibility;anyimmediate,temporaryhousingforyouthshouldbeinhome-likeenvironmentsandyouth-centredspaces.
•Create direct and effective linkages between emergency housing service providers and housing support resources.
•Foster emergency housing responses that focus on meeting the needs of youth who tend to be underserved through existing services: youth ages 18-24, those with substance use issues, and LGBTQ2S* youth
“Weendupstandinginlineupsoutsideinthecoldforhourswaitingtobeaccommodated"— Youth
Promising responses in Winnipeg
•Rossbrook Househasbeenopen24/7foryouthinWinnipegsince1976.Whiletheyprovideasafespaceforyouthtospendthenightifnecessary,theyalso
connectyouthwithsafe,appropriatefamily,friends,andcommunitymembersovernightiftheirhomeenvironmentisunsafeforashorttime.Overthesummerof2016,Winnipeg’sthree24/7youthsafespaces(RossbrookHouse,SpenceNeighbourhoodAssociation,andNdinawe)coordinatedtoprovideovernightstaysforanumberofyouthexperiencinghomelessnessandquicklyconnectthemtoappropriatehousing.
Promising Responses
•The Canadian Observatory on Homelessnesssuggestsemergencysystems’rolesinendinghomelessnessinclude:
•Ensurethatallpeoplewhocomeintocontactwiththehomelessnesssectorareassessedandprovidedwithsupportstoeitherreturnhomeormoveintohousingasquicklyaspossible.
•Adoptaclient-centeredcasemanagementapproachforindividualsandfamiliesthatenterthesystem,andensuretheyaretrackedastheynavigatetheirwayoutofthesystem.
•Fundandrewardserviceprovidersforfocusingonpreventionandrapidrehousingasaservicepriority,andmakethegoalofemergencyservicesashorterexperienceofhomelessness.
•Integrate‘HousingFirst’and/ortransitionalhousingsupportswhenworkingwithchronicandlong-termhomelessclients.
•Developastrongoutreachfocustobringpeopleintotheservicewhohavehistoricallynotbeenconnected,andmakerapidrehousingapriorityforthem.
•Investinsmalleranddispersedshelterenvironmentsthatprovideindividualroomswithlockeddoors.98
•Bridging the GapinHaltonprovidesaHostHomesprogramforshort-termstays(upto4months)foryouthages16-24.HostHomesarescreenedandexpectedtoprovidesomemealsandaprivatelivingspaceforyouthforaperdiemrate.
OBJECTIVE 3.2
Increase the supply and diversity of transitional housing options
•Develop increased supply of transitional housing options for youth.
Intherangeoftransitionaloptions,includeaharm-reductionmodelforyouthactivelyusingsubstancesandbothcongregatedandscatteredsiteoptions.Transitionalhousingshouldalwaysalignwiththe
Supports for housing available for youth in Winnipeg
36
principlesandvaluesofthePlan,includingbeingcommunity-based(non-institutional),lowbarrier,andhaveflexibletimelinesbasedontheyouth’sgoalsratherthanaprogrammodel.
•Make appropriate supports available within all transitional housing models, including CFS independent living programs.
Supportsshouldrespondtoyouthchoiceandneed,andprovideyouthopportunitiestolearnindependentlivingskills.Thetransitionintomorepermanenthousingshouldbesupported.Ifthetransitionalhousingcannotmeettheneedsofayouth,supportshouldnotbedroppedwithoutatransitiontomoreappropriatehousingandsupport.
•Create targeted housing options for youth who are excluded from integrated models, or want specialized supports. This includes LGBTQ2S* specific housing options.
Specializedhousingneedstobesmallscale,non-stigmatizing,andintegratedintothecommunity.
“Thereshouldbelesspushforfosterkidstogooutontheirown.Maybeahomewherethereisafamilyandasharedhouse,withsupportivepeoplethere.Becausewe’veallbeenmovingaroundandfeltlikewe’reonourown,butweneedthatsupport.”—Youth
“I’dlikeaplacelikeahost-home,wherefriendscomingoffreservescouldstayinsteadofhotels.”—Youth
Promising Practices in Winnipeg
•RaY’s REST programprovidesimmediateaccesstoindependentManitobaHousingunitsforyouthwithongoingsupports.Thescatteredsiteunitsconnectsyouthtopermanentaffordablehousingaftertheynolongerneedtransitionalsupports.
•Ma Mawi’s Yellow Shawl Housingsupportsyouththroughcommunity-basedhousingwithlive-inmentors.
•Pan Am Placeisastructuredtransitionalhousingprogramforyoungmen.Ithasshortwaittimes(about1week)andencouragesyouthtoparticipateinvolunteering,exercise,andahealthylifestyle.
•Siloam Mission’s Exit-Up programprovidestransitionalhousingforyouthagingoutofthecareofCFS.Itstartswithcongregatedtransitionalhousingwithonsitesupportsinaneighbourhoodsetting.Youththentransitionintopermanentaffordablehousingwithoutreachsupports.Thesearegraduallyreducedbasedontheyouths’wantsandneeds.
Promising Responses
•Reviewsofpromisingpracticesforindependentlivingprogramssuggestmakingashifttowardsgoalsofinterdependence,measuredlifeskilldevelopment,andan“adultpermanencyresource”(e.g.mentor,familymember,teacher,orotherongoingresource).99
•Foyer Model. TransitionalhousingthroughtheFoyermodelhasbeenpromotedbytheCanadianObservatoryonHomelessnessaspartofthe‘systemofcare’foryouthexperiencinghomelessness.Foyerhousingisgenerallyguidedbysharedprinciples,ratherthanstrictrules,andfocusonsuccessfultransitionstoadulthoodratherthansimplyindependence.100EvaluationsofFoyersintheUKandAustraliademonstratepositiveoutcomesforyouth.Youngpeopleareabletoenhancetheireducation,socialrelationshipsandengagement,andhavebetteremploymentandhousingoutcomes.Further,thismodelhasbeenendorsedbytheEgaleCanadianHumanRightsTrustasapromisingpracticeforLGBTQ2S youth in Canada.101
OBJECTIVE 3.3
Develop a full continuum of permanent housing with appropriate supports for youth
Thedivisionbetween‘permanenthousing’comparedwith‘transitional’housingforyouthisnotastrictone.Transitionalhousingshouldnevertransitionintohomelessness,andpermanenthousingisrelativegiventhathighmobilityratesarecommonforallWinnipegyouth.102Forthepurposesofthisplan,‘permanent’housingishousingwhereyouthhaveprotectionoftenancyrightsandcanstayaslongastheychoose.HousingsupportprovidersinWinnipeghavefoundsuccessinholdingmasterleasesonunitsforaperiodoftimeuntilyouthareabletotakeovertenancyresponsibilities.Suchstagingisnotabout‘readiness’inapatronizingsense,butratheraboutbridgingsupportsforyouthsotheyarenotsetupforfailure.
•Ensure that all housing programs provide long-
37
term, continuous supports for permanent housing placement and maintenance
Capacityandfundingarerequiredforfollow-uptoprovideongoingsupport,asneeded,evenafteryouthtransitionoutofaprogram.
•Expand the capacity of Housing First programs to meet the specific needs of youth.
PriortoexpandingHousingFirstprogrammingforyouth,thereisaclearneedtodefineitsrolewithinahousingandsupportsystem.Thisincludesthedevelopmentofsharedagreementregardingtheprinciplesofyouth-focusedHousingFirstprograms.Thecapacityofexistingprogramsrequirecoordinationofrentsupplements,andpartnershipsthatfacilitateaccesstoaffordablehousing.
•Create and strengthen partnerships between youth-serving agencies and housing providers.
Partnershipswouldincreaseaccesstopermanenthousingandpreventeviction.Thisincludestrainingforprivateandnot-for-profitlandlordsandincreasedsupporttoyouthatriskofeviction.
•Develop increased supply of housing, including shared housing for youth.
Housingshouldbebasedonyouth’schoice,community-basedandlowbarrier;thereshouldbeoptionstohavelive-inmentorsor‘houseparents.’
•Ensure supports are available within shared housing models, including rooming houses.
Roominghousescurrentlyserveas‘sharedhousing’formanyyouth.Enhancingsupportsinthesehouses,whileimprovingtheirquality,willsupporthousingstability.Tothegreatestextentpossible,thesesupportsshouldincludebuildingcommunityconnectionsandlong-termmentorship/peersupport.
“…stafftocheckonus,managingeverythingbuildingrelated,butnotsomeonearoundeverydaytellinguswhattodo” —Youth
Promising Practices in Winnipeg
•Indigenous-led, youth-serving organizationshavebeensuccessfulinaccessingHPSfundingforHousingFirstprogramming.AboriginalHPSfundingcanonlybereceivedbyIndigenous-ledorganizationsmeetingthefollowingcriteria:
1.TheyhaveamajorityofBoardmemberswhoidentifyasAboriginal
2.TheyhaveamajorityofstaffwhoidentifyasAboriginal
3.Theyserveamajorityofparticipants/clientswhoidentifyasAboriginal
4.TheyarerecognizedbytheAboriginalcommunityasanAboriginalorganization
•Manitoba’s Rent Assist programprovidesparticipantswith75%ofmedian-marketrentregardlessofEIAeligibility.Thishasdramaticallyincreasedtheamountofsocialassistanceavailabletosingleindividualsinparticular.
Promising Responses
•Housing Subsidies. Evidenceforhousingsubsidiesasaveryeffectivepreventionactivityiswelldocumented.103104105Evidencefromsimulationsindicatesthatsubsidizinghousingcostsforextremelylow-incomepeoplehasthestrongesteffectonloweringhomelessnessratescomparedtoseveralotherinterventionstested.106Thuswhenusedassecondaryandtertiaryprevention,housingsubsidieshelp80–85percentoffamiliesorsingleadultsexperiencingchronichomelessnesstoachievehousingstability.107
Decolonization and Housing and Supports
•Self-determination.Article23oftheUnitedNationsDeclarationontheRightsofIndigenousPeoplesstatesthat“Indigenouspeopleshavetherighttobeactivelyinvolvedindevelopinganddetermininghealth,housingandothereconomicandsocialprogrammesaffectingthemand,asfaraspossible,toadministersuchprogrammesthroughtheirowninstitutions.”108FundingprogramsforhousingforIndigenousyouthneedtobeincreased,anddevelopedinproperconsultationwithIndigenouspeoples.Imposedoutcomesforvarioushousingandsupportprogramsmustnotunderminethevaluesofthisplan.Itisimportanttoquestionwhetherthevaluesofachieving‘independentpermanenthousing’thatmanyfundersarecurrentlylookingforalignwiththehopesanddreamsofyouth.
•Connection to First Nations communities. SupportsshouldcontinueifyouthmovebetweenWinnipegandhomecommunities.ThoughthisplanisWinnipeg-based,werecognizethattheconditionandsupplyofhousinginFirstNationscommunitiesneedsurgentaction.
•Healing from trauma is critical,andmaytakeprecedenceoverparticipationinfull-timeemploymentoreducation.Transitionalhousingexpectationsmustbedevelopedthroughanequitylens.
“DirectspecialattentiontohomelessnessamongstIndigenouspeoplescausedbydisplacementfromlandandresourcesandthedestructionofculturalidentity”—United Nations Special Rapporteur on the Right to Adequate Housing109
“Ourpeopledonotfitintoboxes.Whenthereareboxes,theyhavebeenusedtoexcludeus,always.In
38
Indigenousculture,youdon’tfitintoboxes,youjustare.”—Indigenous leader discussion
STRATEGY 4: SUPPORTS TO THRIVE
The vision for Strategy Four is that all youth with experience of homelessness have the supports they need to maintain housing and thrive.
Q: What does it mean to thrive?
Autonomous, with the dignity of choice
Interdependent
Happy
Healthy
Learning new things, ongoing growth
Confident, mastery / purpose
Healing of trauma
Sustainability
Emotional supports, community
Stability, safety, space to achieve/ fulfill goals
Success
Youth Survey Responses:
“Todosomethingbetterforyouandothers”
“Survivingthestruggle”
What we Heard:
•Agencieswithemployment,training,education,housing,andlifeskillsprogrammingallin-housecanprovideholisticsupports,butwhentheyareseparated,thereareoftenchallengescoordinatingbetweenagenciesorsectors.
•Youthwhohaveexperiencedhomelessnessfaceuniquebarriersaccessingmainstreamservicesand/ortakemoretimetobuildtrustandrelationships.
•Fundersareincreasinglydemandingoutcome-basedreportingforsupportservices,butsetthoseoutcomesthemselves(e.g.graduationrates,full-timeemploymentretentionrates).Theseoutcomesmaynotalignwiththegoalsofyouth.
“Administrativeburdenskeepgettingheavierbutthereisnotmoreadministrativefunding.Wewanttomeasuresuccess,butdon’thavestafftodoit.”—Roundtable Participant
OBJECTIVE 4.1
Foster resilience among youth exiting homelessness through holistic and ongoing supports
Holisticandongoingsupportswithlifeskills,education
4
39
andtraining,employment,andhealingrequirestaffwithspecializedskills.Onecasemanagercannotprovideallthesesupportsontheirown.Thereisaneedforappropriatecollaborationandpartnershipbetweenprogramsandservicessoyouthhaveoneholisticplantoachievetheirgoals.
•Connect housing support workers with skilled employment, training, and education workers to support youth’s goal achievement.
Opportunitiesforemployment,training,andeducationshouldbepartofyouth’sholisticplans,andcoordinatedthroughhubs.
•Coordinate existing life skills training programs to increase consistency and effective resource sharing.
Allyouthwhohaveexperiencedhomelessnessneedaccesstoqualitylifeskillstraining,witharangeofteachingmethodstosuitdiverseneeds.
Promising Practices in Winnipeg
•ManyofWinnipeg’syouth-servingagencieshavedevelopedarangeofemploymentandtrainingprogramsthatyouthcanaccessbasedontheirownpersonalgoals.Theseincludearangeofoddjobsforthosewhowanttoearnsomemoneyforjustoneday,socialenterpriseswheretheycanlearnbasicskills,andsupportgettingaccesstoformaltrainingandtraditionalemployment
Promising Responses
•ACCESS BladerunnersinVancouversupporthomelessorat-riskyouth,ages15-30tocreatepathwaystojobsintheconstructionindustrywithembeddedIndigenousculturalteachings.
•The DoorwayinCalgaryprovidessupportin13lifecategoriesincludinghousing,employment,education,finances,drug/alcohol,legal,personalproblemsolving,planning,identification,volunteering,leadership,and“other.”Participantscreatetheirownplanindifferentstagesandthendiscussitwithavolunteerorstaffmember.Eachplannedstepbecomestheircontractandtheyoutharepaida$15incentiveforeachcompletedcontract.Theprogramhasachievedaconsistentaverageof7outof10participantsleavingthestreetenvironmentbyreachingtheirpersonalgoals.
OBJECTIVE 4.2
Address System barriers to youths’ housing stability
•Ensure ongoing support from the CFS system includes transitional income for youth, available regardless of participation in education and training.
Theincomesupportshouldallowyouthtoexplore
educationalandemploymentoptions,addresstrauma,andgainindependentlivingskillswithoutfearoflosinghousing.
•Encourage EIA to increase the stability of income supports for youth.
Considerpolicyandprocedurechangestoprovidesmoothertransitionsbetweenyouthandadulthood,EIAandemployment/education/training,intoandoutofgovernmentcare,andothertransitionpointswhereyouthareatriskofexperiencingasuddenlossofincomeandthereforehomelessness.
•Support strategies to improve youth-focused service provision and responsiveness within governmental systems.
•Improve access to community-based primary health and mental health supports.
“We’rewatchingthiskiddeterioratebeforeoureyes.He’saddictedtocrystalmeth,he’snotconnectingtous.Weneedmentalhealthresources;weneedhelpfromaddictionsprograms.Thesolutionisnotjustgettinghimintohousing.”—Steering Committee member
Youth said creating more stability in income supports was a priority. They said: “It’s like you have to plan and prepare just to get off EIA.” You can only earn so much while receiving EIA, yet employment may not cover basic needs. Once youth stop receiving EIA, getting back on is very challenging and takes 4-6 weeks; this delay and gap in income has led to housing loss.
OBJECTIVE 4.3
Enhance the capacity of informal and community-based supports
Inanumberofengagementsessionswithyouth,theywereaskedtodraworwritethepeoplewhowereclosesttothem,andwhoprovidedgoodsupporttothemwhenneeded.Foramajorityofyouth,thepeopleinthosecircleswerenotstaffatcommunityorgovernmentagencies;theywerefamily,friends,andcommunitymembers.Formalmentorshipprogramshavedemonstratedresultsforyouthat-riskofhomelessness,whileyouthandcommunitymembersinWinnipegreinforcedtheimportanceofinformalmentoringthroughcaringcommunities.ThisisparticularlytrueforIndigenouscommunities.Participatinginpeacewalks,communityevents,communitykitchens,recreationactivities,andvolunteeringareallpartofthriving.
“MaMawiandNdinawehereintheNorthEndarenotjustprograms.Theyareacommunityofsupport,they
40
arefamilyforgenerationsofpeople”—Indigenous Leaders
•Increase the number and capacity of mentoring programs targeted to youth who have experienced homelessness.
Mentorsmayrequirespecializedtrainingandsupportfromtheprogramtobeahealthy,stablepersonintheyouth’slife.
•Include ongoing, community and informal supports such as peers, family, recreation programs, or volunteer opportunities, in housing support plans with youth.
•Support grassroots Indigenous community initiatives responding to immediate needs and developing anti-colonial strategies of support.
Promising Practices in Winnipeg
•Action Therapyconnectsyouth“at-risk”withtrainedmentorswhoaresupervisedbyahighly-experiencedclinician.Thewraparoundsupportprovided24/7isgroundedinIndigenousteachings.Lateralempathy,wherebyyouthparticipateinhelpingothersinneedinthecommunity,andparticipationincommunityeventsbuilda‘therapeuticcommunity.’
•Restoring the Sacred,aprogramofKaNiKanichihk,connectsyouthwhomovetoWinnipegfromFirstNationcommunitiestocontinuetheireducationwithyoungleadersinthecommunity.Thepeermentorshipprogramisyouthcentredandculturallybased.Itbuildsonthecapacityandleadershipofyoungpeopleandprovidesopportunitiestoparticipateinpositivesocial,educational,recreational,andspiritualactivities.
•Canadian Mental Health Association’s Housing and Supportprogramemployspeeroutreachworkerswhohaveexperienceofhomelessness,mentalillness,orotherchallengesparticipantsshare.Theirrolesincludebuildingsupportiverelationshipswithparticipantsandconnectingthemwithcommunityactivities.
OBJECTIVE 4.4
Embed healing into supports and systems for youth
Traumaisbothacauseandanoutcomeofhomelessness;healingfromthistraumaisanongoingjourneyformanyyouth.Allsupportsandsystemsthattouchthelivesofyouthwhohaveexperiencedhomelessnessneedatrauma-informedlens,andrecovery-orientedpractices.ColonialismisthecauseoftraumaforIndigenouspeoplesandcommunities,andmanyyouthhavefoundthatculturalconnections,supports,andspiritualpracticesarecentraltotheirhealing.
“Everyonesays‘thisisgoingtobedifficult,it’sstressful’butnoonesays‘hey,youcandothis.’That’swhatweneedtohear.”—Youth
“Healingisnotabouttalktherapyormedication.It’saboutart,culture,recreation,relationships.Community-basedagenciesaregoodatthat.Butsometimesweneedalittlehelpfromclinicianswhensignificantmentalillnessisthere.”—Roundtable participant
•Work with a cross-sectoral table of youth service providers and system representatives to establish close and ongoing relationships between hubs, outreach, and housing support staff with health and mental health practitioners.
•Encourage all health, mental health, and addictions treatment professionals working with youth who have been homeless to be educated in trauma-informed care and support them to apply it in practice.
•Resource Indigenous-led agencies to be available for any youth seeking cultural connections and culturally appropriate supports, and collaborate with non-Indigenous agencies to ensure all youth have access.
Promising Practices in Winnipeg
•Ka Ni Kanichihk’s OshkabywisprojectfollowstheCircleofCouragemodelandempowersyoungwomenwhohavebeeninvolvedwithgangsandthecriminaljusticesystem.Wraparound,holisticsupportsareprovidedthroughmentorship,skillsdevelopment,andculturallybasedactivities,andaimtoincreasetheprotectivefactorsofyouth.
Decolonization and Supports to Thrive
•Culture is a way of being.Holdingaprogramorclassforculturalconnectionsandhealingisnotsufficient.Cultureispartofwhoweareandawayofbeing,everyday,allday.ForyouthtobeconnectedorreconnectedtoIndigenousculture,Indigenous-ledorganizationsandgrassrootsinitiativesneedlong-term,sustainablesupportintermsoffunding,self-determination,andrecognition.
•Cultural humility is required of everyone working with youth.Culturalcompetenceisthestartingpointforallserviceproviders.Humilitygoesbeyondthat,requiringalifelongcommitmenttoself-evaluationandcritique,adesiretofixpowerimbalances,andaspiringtodeveloppartnershipswiththosewhoadvocateforothers.110
•Healing from trauma is critical,andmaytakeprecedenceoverparticipationinfull-timeemploymentoreducation.Outcomegoalsneedtobebasedonyouth’sgoalsandprogramsmustbeflexibleinorderto
41
IMPLEMENTATIONPLAN/FRAMEWORK
Collaborate • Coordinate Implementationthroughhiringstaffandformalizinganoversightbody
• Communicatethegoals,priorities,andnextsteps
• Engageyouth,Indigenousleaders,andnationalpartnersinongoingways.Engagekeystakeholdersthroughcross-sectoraltablesdevelopedthroughtheactionplan.EngagefundersthroughanongoingFunders’Tabletosupporttheimplementationofthestrategy.
• Alignwithallexistingactivitiesthatmayberelevanttothestrategicprioritiesidentifiedintheplan.Inparticular,developalignmentwiththeWinnipegPlantoEndHomelessness(EndHomelessnessWinnipeg),ALLAboardPovertyReductionstrategies,theHPSCommunityPlan,andprovincialinitiativestoendhomelessness.
Monitor & Evaluate
• Developanevaluationandinformationmanagementstrategythatidentifiesoutcomeindicatorsandsupportsmeaningfuldatacollectionandanalysis
• Createanaccountabilityframeworkthatincludesfeedbackfromyouthwithpastorongoingexperiencesofhomelessnessinameaningfulway,regularmeetings,andannualreporting.
• Establishongoingresearchprioritiesthatmeetthelocalinformation/researchneedsofthestrategy
IMPLEMENTATION FRAMEWORK
Plan • Createbusinessplanand5yearactionplanwithmilestonesandresponsibilities
Act • Fund Development
• Develop shared resourcesprioritizedintheplan
• Fund key service/system gapsthatcannotberesourcedthroughexistingfundingbodies
• Educate and advocateforsystemicchangescalleduponintheplan
42
FIRST STEPS
Collaborate
Year 1
•DevelopanongoingYouthHomelessnessSecretariatwithintheDepartmentofFamiliesresponsibleforpolicydevelopmentandhorizontalintegrationbetweenCFS,EIA,andHousing
•DevelopagreementbetweenSteeringCommitteeandEndHomelessnessWinnipegregardinggovernanceandadministrativeframeworkforimplementation
•Developjobdescriptionsforplanimplementationstaffandseekfundingforpositions
•Createandbeginimplementationofadisseminationstrategyforkeysectorsandstakeholders
•Recruityouthwithexperiencesofhomelessnesstoparticipateinongoingimplementation,includingactionplanningmeetings,governancestructures,andeducation/advocacyactivities
•Holdmeetingswithfundersandrelevantstakeholderstodevelopagreementonalignmentprocesses
•Holdanannualnetworkingmeetingamongstafffromyouth-servingorganizationstopromotecollaborationandtraining
Plan
Year 1
•Developabusinessplananda5-yearactionplanincludingmilestonesandresponsibilities
•Begintodevelopafundingstreamforplanimplementationandseeksupportfromkeyfundingbodies
•Assessfundinggapsastheyrelatetoactionprioritiestotargetfunddevelopment
Act
Year 1
•Influencedevelopmentofsharedresourcesalreadybeingconsideredsotheymeetyouthandcommunitypriorities(e.g.resourceguides,outreachnetwork,affordablehousingunits)
•Develop‘speakersbureau’withSteeringCommitteemembersandyouthtosupportdisseminationstrategy
•Beginactionrelatedtothefirstfourplanprioritiesof:
•Createaninterdepartmental“ZeroDischargeintoHomelessness”strategy,startingwithacoordinatedprovincialpolicydirection,thatsupportsyouthtransitioningfromanytypeofProvincialgovernmentorgovernmentfundedcare.
•DevelopanetworkofneighbourhoodHubsopen24/7byincreasingthecapacityofexistingyouth-servingagencies.
•Developincreasedsupplyoftransitionalhousingprogramsforyouth.
•EncourageEmploymentandIncomeAssistance(EIA)toincreasethestabilityofincomesupportsforyouth.
Monitor and Evaluate
Year 1
•Includeadataandevaluationframeworkinthe5-yearactionplan
•Developsharedindicators
•HoldanannualFeastandForumwithyouthexperiencinghomelessnesstogatherfeedbackontheplanimplementationandemergingissuesforyouth
•Reportonprogressofplanobjectivesannually
43
ROLES IN IMPLEMENTATION
Role of Government (Including Government Agencies and Authorities)
•Establishasharedvision,long-termprioritiesandpolicydirectionsamongstalldepartmentsandlevelsofgovernment.
•Supporttheprovisionofcoordinatedandintegratedsupportsandservicesatthecommunitylevel.
•Providethelegislativeandpolicyframeworkandfundingsupporttoaddressyouthhomelessness.
•Supportopportunitiestoshareknowledgebetweenpolicy-makers,academicsandserviceproviders.
•Supportexistingbestandpromisingpracticesandprogramming.
•Implementthe“CallstoAction”fromtheTruthandReconciliationCommissionacrossdepartmentsandagencies.
•Ensurehealthytransitionsacrossandoutsidethesystemofcareforyouth.
Role of Community-Based Organizations
•Deliverfront-lineservicesandsupportsinalignmentwiththeprinciplesandvaluesoftheplan.
•Sharepromisingpractices,evaluatecommunity-wideoutcomes,andhelptoidentifyemergingtrends.
•Workwithgovernmentandotherfundingproviderstoidentifyandaddressneeds,issuesandstrategicdirections.
•Informandinfluencegovernmentpriorities.
•Informandinfluencecommunitychange.
•Implementthe“CallstoAction”fromtheTruthandReconciliationCommissionacrossagencies,startingwithtrainingallstaffinculturalcompetency.
Role of the Private Sector
•Provideleadershipandmodelingforabroadrangeofprivatesectorchampions.
•Collaboratewithcommunity-basedorganizationsandcommunitiestoprovideskillstrainingandemploymentopportunities.
•Supportthedevelopmentofaffordablehousingoptions.
•Engageandsupportemployeesinbuildinghealthyrelationships.
•Provideeffectivecharitableandphilanthropicgivingthatalignswiththedirections,values,andprinciplesofthisplan.
•Supportemployeestobeengagedontheissue.
Role of Individuals (Youth, Families, Friends, Neighbours)
•BecomeengagedcitizenstopreventandreduceyouthhomelessnessinManitoba.
•Learnhowtoidentifyyouthat-riskofhomelessnessandwhatcanbedoneaboutit.
•Provideeffectivecharitableandphilanthropicgivingthatalignswiththedirections,valuesandprinciplesoftheplan
•Volunteertimeandskillstoplayaroleinbuildingsafe,healthy,andinclusivecommunitiesforyouth.
CONCLUSIONTheplaceishereandthetimeisnow.Moneyandliveshavebeenspentwaitingforsolutionsthatarewithinourreach.HereandNowisconnectedtoabroadermovementinWinnipeg.Anactionplan,throughtheTruthandReconciliationCommission,providesaclearroadmapforCanadiansworkingtowardsreconciliation.Theyouth-serving,not-for-profitsectorhasstrongleadership,andworkstogethertomeaningfullyaddresschallengingissuesforyouth.Leadersingovernmentunderstandthatpeopleintheseagenciesarecollaterals,andoftenknowledge-holders,andareworkingtogetheroncreativesolutions.They,too,arechallengingthemselves,theircolleagues,andtheagenciestheyworkwithtocollaborateandalign.Fundersandphilanthropicleadersarelookingtoaligntoachievecommunity-wideresultsratherthanprogrammaticoutputs.Andyouththemselvesarecallingonallsectorstoworktogetherandbesolution-oriented;theyarereadytoholdusallaccountabletothisplan.Withcommitmenttorespond,throughshiftingthewaywedothings,thevisionofacitywhereallyouthhaveasafeplacetoliveandthrivecanbeareality.
44
APPENDIX A. YOUTH ENGAGEMENT PROCESSYouthengagementstartedwithagroupofyouthwhohadpreviousexperiencesofhomelessnessandwerecurrentlyleadersinvariousinitiatives.Thisgroupreviewedplansandstrategiesfromotherjurisdictions,discussedtheirprioritiesforwhataplantoendyouthhomelessnessshouldachieve,andcommentedontheproposedyouthengagementplan.Theirinputledtofivefocusgroupswithyouthwhowerecurrentlyexperiencinghomelessness.The42youthwhoparticipatedinthefocusgroupsprovidedhigh-levelfeedbackonstrategiestheywantedtoseeincludedintheplan.Theinformationformedthebasisofthemissionandvision,andguidedthequestionsandtargetstakeholdersforfutureengagements.
Asthestrategicframeworkfortheplanwasbeingdrafted,meetingswereorganizedtohearyouthperspectivesonsomeoftheprincipalissues.TheseincludedattendingtheVOICES:ManitobaYouthinCareNetworkretreattodiscusshealthysupports,transitionsfromcare,andeducationaloutcomes;andhostinganIndigenousYouthFeastandForumfocusedonsupportduringtransitionsfromsystems,andculturallycompetentservices.Additionally,surveyswereconductedwithelevenyouthwhowereconnectedtoSteeringCommitteememberorganizations.
Oncethestrategicframeworkandobjectiveshadbeendeveloped,discussiongroupswereheldwithyouthatRaY,EagleUrbanTransitionCentre,andtheYouthAgenciesAllianceYouthLeadersCouncil.Thedraftoftheplanwaspresentedandadditionalfeedbackgathered.Apublicopenhouse,partofitdesignedspecificallyforyouthexperiencinghomelessness,washeldbeforefinalizingtheactionstrategies.Amajorityofyouthattendingthesereviewsessionshadbeenpartoftheinitialfocusgroupsand/ortargetedmeetingssocouldcommentonhowthesummarizedplanreflectedtheinitialprioritiestheyhaddiscussed.
APPENDIX B: COMMUNITY ENGAGEMENT PROCESS AND PARTICIPANTSCommunityengagementformallybeganwithavisioningsummit.Thesummitprovidedparticipantsa‘youthhomelessnessinWinnipeg101’,introducedtheSteeringCommittee,suggestedaframeworkforthePlan,andsoughtbroadinputonthevisiontoendyouthhomelessness.
Buildingoffthissummit,youthengagement,andresearch,aseriesoffactsheetsweredevelopedtoframesixroundtableconsultations.Eachroundtable–prevention,access,housingsupply,housingandsupport,supportstothrive,andsystemintegration–beganwithapresentationoftheresearch,andageneraldiscussionofvaluesandprinciples.Smallergroupsthenhadmorefocusedinputintowhatthegoalsandactionstrategieswouldinclude.
TheroundtableinformationwascompiledandutilizedduringaplanningdaywiththeSteeringCommittee,whocreatedadraftstrategicframeworkwithpillars,objectives,goals,andanimplementationframework.AnIndigenousLeadersDiscussionwasheldwithIndigenousyouth,Elders,andcommunityleaderstodiscussthisdraftandconsiderthestrategythroughalensofdecolonization.Discussioncentredaroundtheprinciplesandvaluesandemphasizedtheirimportancetoallthatwedotoaddressyouthhomelessness.AdviceandguidancewasprovidedonintegratingIndigenousrightsandreconciliationthroughouttheplan.
Anopenhouseprovidedarangeofstakeholdersandyouthwiththedraftstrategicframeworkforanotherroundoffeedback.AttendeesalsoratedtheactionstrategiesbasedonwhatwouldmakethebiggestimpactonendingyouthhomelessnessinWinnipeg.
APPENDICES
45
END NOTES1. UnitedNationsEducational,Scientific,andCultural
Organization.(2016).What do we mean by youth?Retrievedfromhttp://www.unesco.org/new/en/social-and-human-sciences/themes/youth/youth-definition/
2. Canadian Observatory on Homelessness.(2016).Canadiandefinitionofyouthhomelessness.Toronto:TheHomelessHubPress.www.homelesshub.ca/youthhomelessdefinition
3. Canadian Observatory on Homelessness.(2012)Canadiandefinitionofhomelessness.Toronto:TheHomelessHubPress.www.homelesshub.ca/homelessdefinition/
4. Gaetz,S.,Gulliver,T.,&Richter,T.(2014).The state of homelessness in Canada 2014.Toronto:TheHomelessHubPress.http://homelesshub.ca/sites/default/files/SOHC2014.pdf
5. Courtney,M.,MaesNino,C.,Peters,E.(2014).System pathways into youth homelessness.Winnipeg:SocialPlanningCouncilofWinnipeg.
6. Gaetz,S.(2004).Safestreetsforwhom?Homelessyouth,socialexclusion,andcriminalvictimization.Canadian Journal of Criminology and Criminal Justice, 46(4):423-456.
7. Hulchanski,J.D.,Campsie,P.,Chau,S.B.,Hwang,S.W.,&Paradis,E.(2009).Homelessness:What’sinaword.Finding home: Policy options for addressing homelessness in Canada (e-book), Introduction.Toronto:CitiesCentre,UniversityofToronto.
8. MaesNino,C.,Godoy,M.,McCullough,S.,Retzlaff,B.,Wiebe,A.,&Wurcherer,L.(2016).The Winnipeg street census 2015: Final report.Winnipeg:SocialPlanningCouncilofWinnipeg
9. Bronfenbrenner,U.(1977).Towardanexperimentalecologyofhumandevelopment.American psychologist,32(7),513.
10. Williams,L.,&Mumtaz,Z.(2007).Being alive and well: Aboriginal youth and evidence-based approaches to promoting mental well-being.Saskatoon:PrairieRegionHealthPromotionCentre.
11. Harris,C.(2004).Howdidcolonialismdispossess?Commentsfromanedgeofempire.Annals of the Association of American Geographers, 94(1),165-182.
12. Baskin,C.(2007).Aboriginalyouthtalkaboutstructuraldeterminantsasthecausesoftheirhomelessness.First Peoples Child & Family Review, 3(3),31-42.
13. Truth,&ReconciliationCommissionofCanada.(2015).Canada’s residential schools-The history: The final report of the Truth and Reconciliation Commission of Canada(Vol.1).McGill:McGill-Queen’sPress-MQUP,p.3
14. CommitteeonEconomic,SocialandCulturalRights(2001).Substantive issues arising in the implementation of the international covenant on economic, social and cultural rights: Poverty and the international covenant on economic, social and cultural rights.Retrievedfromhttp://www2.ohchr.org/english/bodies/cescr/docs/statements/E.C.12.2001.10Poverty-2001.pdf
15. CanadianCentreforPolicyAlternativesusingStatisticsCanada’sSLIDpre-taxdata,2011.
16. Brandon,J.,&Peters,E.(2014).Moving to the city: housing and Aboriginal migration to Winnipeg.Winnipeg:CanadianCentreforPolicyAlternativesManitoba.
17. Byrne,T.,Munley,E.A.,Fargo,J.D.,Montgomery,A.E.,&Culhane,D.P.(2013).Newperspectivesoncommunity-leveldeterminantsofhomelessness.Journal of Urban Affairs, 35(5),607-625.
18. MaesNino,C.,Godoy,M.,McCullough,S.,Retzlaff,B.,Wiebe,A.,&Wurcherer,L.(2016).The Winnipeg street census 2015: Final report. Winnipeg:SocialPlanningCouncilofWinnipeg.
19. ManitobaFamilyServices.(2016),Manitoba Family Services annual report 2015/2016.Retrievedfrom:http://www.gov.mb.ca/fs/about/pubs/fsar_2015-16.pdf
20. ManitobaFamilyServices.(2016),Manitoba Family Services annual report 2015/2016.Retrievedfrom:http://www.gov.mb.ca/fs/about/pubs/fsar_2015-16.pdf
21. Baskin,C.(2007).Aboriginalyouthtalkaboutstructuraldeterminantsasthecausesoftheirhomelessness.First Peoples Child & Family Review, 3(3),31-42.
22. Courtney,M.,MaesNino,C.,Peters,E.(2014).System pathways into youth homelessness.Winnipeg:SocialPlanningCouncilofWinnipeg.
23. Schiver,B.(2006).Strengthening our youth, the journey to competence and independence.Winnipeg:OfficeoftheChildren’sAdvocate.Retrievedfrom:https://www.gov.mb.ca/fs/changesforchildren/pubs/strengthening_our_youth.pdf
24. Courtney,M.,MaesNino,C.,Peters,E.(2014). System pathways into youth homelessness.Winnipeg:SocialPlanningCouncilofWinnipeg.
25. PublicHealthAgencyofCanada(2006).Street youth in Canada, findings from the enhanced surveillance of Canadian street youth 1999-2003.Retrievedfrom:http://www.phac-aspc.gc.ca/std-mts/reports_06/pdf/street_youth_e.pdf
26. Omura,J.D.,Wood,E.,Nguyen,P.,Kerr,T.,&DeBeck,K.(2014).Incarcerationamongstreet-involvedyouthinaCanadianstudy:implicationsforhealthandpolicyinterventions.International Journal of Drug Policy,25(2),291-296.
27. Omura,J.D.,Wood,E.,Nguyen,P.,Kerr,T.,&DeBeck,K.(2014).Incarcerationamongstreet-involvedyouthinaCanadianstudy:implicationsforhealthandpolicyinterventions.International Journal of Drug Policy,25(2),291-296.
28. Gessler,S.,Maes,C.&Skelton,I.(2010).Winnipeg street health report.Winnipeg:MainStreetProject.
29. Forchuk,C.,Ward-Griffin,C.,Csiernik,R.,&Turner,K.(2006).Openforum:Survivingthetornadoofmentalillness:Psychiatricsurvivors’experiencesofgetting,losing,andkeepinghousing.Psychiatric Services, 57(4),558-562.
30. Gessler,S.,Maes,C.&Skelton,I.(2010).Winnipeg street health report.Winnipeg:MainStreetProject.
31. CanadianMortgageandHousingCorporation.(2001).Environmental scan on youth homelessness(Socio-economicSeries86).Ottawa:Author.
32. VandenBree,M.B.,Shelton,K.,Bonner,A.,Moss,S.,Thomas,H.,&Taylor,P.J.(2009).Alongitudinalpopulation-basedstudyoffactorsinadolescencepredictinghomelessnessinyoungadulthood.Journal of Adolescent Health, 45(6),571-578.
33. Brakenhoff,B.,Jang,B.,Slesnick,N.,&Snyder,A.(2015).Longitudinalpredictorsofhomelessness:findingsfromtheNationalLongitudinalSurveyofYouth-97.Journal of Youth Studies, 18(8),1015-1034.
34. ManitobaEducaitonandTraining.(n.d.)High school graduation rates and student achievement statistics.Retrievedfromhttp://www.edu.gov.mb.ca/k12/grad_rates/index.html
35. MaesNino,C.,Godoy,M.,McCullough,S.,Retzlaff,B.,Wiebe,A.,&Wurcherer,L.(2016).The Winnipeg Street Census 2015: Final Report.Winnipeg:SocialPlanningCouncilofWinnipeg
36. Courtney,M.,MaesNino,C.,Peters,E.(2014).System pathways into youth homelessness.Winnipeg:SocialPlanningCouncilofWinnipeg.
37. Courtney,M.,MaesNino,C.,Peters,E.(2014).System pathways into youth homelessness.Winnipeg:SocialPlanningCouncilofWinnipeg.
38. Gaetz,S.,&O’Grady,B.(2002).Makingmoneyexploringtheeconomyofyounghomelessworkers.Work,Employment & Society, 16(3),433-456.
46
39. Mallett,S.,Rosenthal,D.,Keys,D.,&Averill,R.(2009).Moving out, moving on: Young people’s pathways in and through homelessness. Routledge.
40. MaesNino,C.,Godoy,M.,McCullough,S.,Retzlaff,B.,Wiebe,A.,&Wurcherer,L.(2016).The Winnipeg street census 2015: Final report. Winnipeg:SocialPlanningCouncilofWinnipeg.
41. Bao,W.N.,Whitbeck,L.B.,&Hoyt,D.R.(2000).Abuse,support,anddepressionamonghomelessandrunawayadolescents.Journal of Health and Social Behavior,408-420.
42. Whitbeck,L.B.,&Hoyt,D.R.(1999).Nowhere to grow: Homeless and runaway adolescents and their families.TransactionPublishers.
43. Holt,S.,Buckley,H.,&Whelan,S.(2008).Theimpactofexposuretodomesticviolenceonchildrenandyoungpeople:Areviewoftheliterature.Child Abuse & Neglect, 32(8),797-810.
44. McMorris,B.J.,Tyler,K.,Whitbeck,L.B.,&Hoyt,D.R.(2002).Familialand“on-the-street”riskfactorsassociatedwithalcoholuseamonghomelessandrunawayadolescents.Journal on Studies of Alcohol, 63(1):,34-43.
45. Abramovich,A.I.(2013).Nofixedaddress:Young,queer,andrestless.InS.Gaetz,B.O’Grady,K.Buccieri,J.Karabanow,&Marsolais,A.(Eds.)Youth homelessness in Canada: Implications for policy and practice. Toronto:CanadianObservatoryonHomelessness.
46. Greene,1.M.,&Ringwalt,C.(1998).Pregnancyamongthreenationalsamplesofrunawayandhomelessyouth.Journal of Adolescent Health, 23,370-377.
47. Robertson,M.l.,&Toro,P.A.(1998).Homelessyouth:Research,intervention,andpolicy.InL.B,Fosburg&D.L.Dennis(VolEds.),Practical lessons: The 1998 national symposium on homelessness research.U.S.DepartmentofHousingandUrbanDevelopmentandtheU.S.DepartmentofHealthandHumanServices.Retrievedfrom:http://aspe.hhs.gov/progsys/homeless/symposium/3-youth.htm
48. Baker-Collins,S.(2013).Fromhomelessteentochronicallyhomelessadult:Aqualitativestudyoftheimpactofchildhoodeventsonadulthomelessness.Critical Social Work, 14(2).
49. Haber,M.G.,&Toro,P.A(2004).Homelessnessamongchildren,families,adolescents:Anecologicaldevelopmentalperspective.Clinical Child and Psychology Review, 7(3),123-164.
50. Cancian,M.,Yang,M.Y.,&Slack,K.S.(2013).Theeffectofadditionalchildsupportincomeontheriskofchildmaltreatment.Social Service Review, 87(3),417-437.
51. MaesNino,C.,Godoy,M.,McCullough,S.,Retzlaff,B.,Wiebe,A.,&Wurcherer,L.(2016).The Winnipeg street census 2015: Final report.Winnipeg:SocialPlanningCouncilofWinnipeg.
52. Peters,E.J.,&Robillard,V.(2009).Everythingyouwantisthere:TheplaceofthereserveinFirstNations’homelessmobility.Urban Geography, 30(6),652-680.
53. Peters,E.J.,&Robillard,V.(2009).Everythingyouwantisthere:TheplaceofthereserveinFirstNations’homelessmobility.Urban Geography, 30(6),652-680.
54. Memmott,P.,&Chambers,C.(2010).IndigenoushomelessnessinAustralia:Anintroduction.Parity, 23(9),8.p.10.
55. ResourceAssistanceforYouth.(2015).Aboriginal youth homelessness in Manitoba. Retrievedfrom:http://www.caeh.ca/wp-content/uploads/2014/11/Y1_HolmesK-2.pdf
56. Gaetz,S.,Scott,F.,&Gulliver,T.(2013).HousingfirstinCanada:Supporting communities to end homelessness.Toronto:CanadianObservatoryonHomelessness.Retrievedfrom:http://www.homelesshub.ca/sites/default/files/HousingFirstInCanada.pdf
57. Martijn,C.,&Sharpe,L.(2006).Pathwaystoyouthhomelessness.Social science & medicine, 62(1),1-12.
58. Tompsett,C.J.,Fowler,P.J.,&Toro,P.A.(2009).Agedifferencesamonghomelessindividuals:adolescencethroughadulthood.Journal of prevention & intervention in the community, 37(2),86-99.
59. Tompsett,C.J.,Fowler,P.J.,&Toro,P.A.(2009).Agedifferencesamonghomelessindividuals:adolescencethroughadulthood.Journal of prevention & intervention in the community, 37(2),86-99.
60. Lerner,J.V.,Phelps,E.,Forman,Y.E.,&Bowers,E.P.(2009).Positive youth development.JohnWiley&Sons,Inc.
61. Lerner,R.M.(2004).Liberty:Thriving and civic engagement among America’s youth.ThousandOaks,CA:Sage.
62. Gaetz,S.(2014).Coming of age: Reimagining the response to youth homelessness in Canada.Toronto:TheCanadianHomelessnessResearchNetworkPress.
63. Worthington,C.A.,&MacLaurin,B.J.(2009).LevelofstreetinvolvementandhealthandhealthservicesuseofCalgarystreetyouth.Canadian Journal of Public Health/Revue Canadienne de Sante’e Publique,384-388.
64. Cleverley,K.,&Kidd,S.A.(2011).Resilienceandsuicidalityamonghomelessyouth.Journal of adolescence, 34(5),1049-1054.
65. Fazel,S.,Khosla,V.,Doll,H.,&Geddes,J.(2008).Theprevalenceofmentaldisordersamongthehomelessinwesterncountries:systematicreviewandmeta-regressionanalysis.PLoS Med, 5(12),e225.
66. Goering,P.,Tolomiczenko,G.,Sheldon,T.,Boydell,K.,&Wasylenki,D.(2002).Characteristicsofpersonswhoarehomelessforthefirsttime.Psychiatric Services, 53(11),1472-1474.
67. Frankish,C.J.,Hwang,S.W.,&Quantz,D.(2005).HomelessnessandhealthinCanada:researchlessonsandpriorities.Canadian Journal of Public Health/Revue Canadienne de Sante’e Publique,S23-S29.
68. Greene,J.M.,Ennett,S.T.,&Ringwalt,C.L.(1999).Prevalenceandcorrelatesofsurvivalsexamongrunawayandhomelessyouth.American Journal of Public Health, 89(9),1406-1409.
69. Heerde,J.A.,Scholes-Balog,K.E.,&Hemphill,S.A.(2015).Associationsbetweenyouthhomelessness,sexualoffenses,sexualvictimization,andsexualriskbehaviors:asystematicliteraturereview.Archives of sexual behavior, 44(1),181-212.
70. Cauce,A.M.,Paradise,M.,Ginzler,J.A.,Embry,L.,Morgan,C.J.,Lohr,Y.,&Theofelis,J.(2000).Thecharacteristicsandmentalhealthofhomelessadolescentsageandgenderdifferences.Journal of Emotional and Behavioral Disorders, 8(4),230-239.
71. Boivin,J.F.,Roy,É.,Haley,N.,&duFort,G.G.(2005).Thehealthofstreetyouth:ACanadianperspective.Canadian Journal of Public Health/Revue Canadienne de Sante’e Publique,432-437.
72. Stablein,T.,&Appleton,A.A.(2013).Alongitudinalexaminationofadolescentandyoungadulthomelessexperience,lifecoursetransitions,andhealth.Emerging Adulthood, 1(4),305-313.
73. Gaetz,S.(2004).Safestreetsforwhom?Homelessyouth,socialexclusion,andcriminalvictimization.Canadian Journal of Criminology and Criminal Justice, 46(4),423-456.
74. Gaetz,S.,O’Grady,B.,Buccieri,K.(2010).Surviving crime and violence street youth and victimization in Toronto.Toronto:JFCY&HomelessHub.
75. Kipke,M.D.,Simon,T.R.,Montgomery,S.B.,Unger,J.B.,&Iversen,E.F.(1997).Homelessyouthandtheirexposuretoandinvolvementinviolencewhilelivingonthestreets.Journal of Adolescent Health, 20(5),360-367.
76. Baron,S.W.(2008).StreetYouth,unemployment,andcrime:Isitthatsimple?Usinggeneralstraintheorytountangletherelationship.Canadian Journal of Criminology and Criminal Justice, 50(4),399-434.
47
77. O’Grady,B.,Gaetz,S.,&Buccieri,K.(2011).Can I see your ID? The policing of youth homelessness in Toronto.Toronto:CanadianHomelessnessResearchNetwork.
78. Morrison,D.S.(2009).Homelessnessasanindependentriskfactorformortality:resultsfromaretrospectivecohortstudy.International Journal of Epidemiology,160.
79. Roy,É.,Haley,N.,Leclerc,P.,Sochanski,B.,Boudreau,J.F.,&Boivin,J.F.(2004).MortalityinacohortofstreetyouthinMontreal.Jama, 292(5),569-574.
80. Boivin,J.F.,Roy,É.,Haley,N.,&duFort,G.G.(2005).Thehealthofstreetyouth:ACanadianperspective.Canadian Journal of Public Health/Revue Canadienne de Sante’e Publique,432-437.
81. Gaetz,S.(2012):The real cost of homelessness: Can we save money by doing the right thing?Toronto:CanadianHomelessnessResearchNetworkPress.
82. MacKenzie,D.,Flatau.,P.,Steen,A.,&Thielking,M.(2015).The cost of youth homelessness in Australia.Retrievedfrom:http://www.csi.edu.au/media/uploads/CYHA_FINAL_REPORT_18April2016_v0dqGpT.pdf
83. UnitedNationsOfficeoftheHighCommissioner.(2013).Fact sheet No.9/Rev 2. Indigenous peoples and the United Nations human rights system.Retrievedfrom:http://www.ohchr.org/Documents/Publications/fs9Rev.2.pdf
84. UnitedNationsOfficeoftheHighCommissioner.(2013).Fact sheet No.9/Rev 2. Indigenous peoples and the United Nations human rights system. Retrievedfrom:http://www.ohchr.org/Documents/Publications/fs9Rev.2.pdf
85. AustralianHumanRightsCommission.(2008,September2016)Homelessness is a human right.Retrievedfrom:https://www.humanrights.gov.au/publications/homelessness-human-rights-issue
86. UnitedNationsOfficeoftheHighCommissionerforHumanRights.(September2016).Whatarehumanrights?Retrievedfrom:http://www.ohchr.org/EN/Issues/Pages/WhatareHumanRights.aspx
87. UnitedNationsOfficeoftheHighCommissionerforHumanRights.(September2016).What are human rights?Retrievedfrom:http://www.ohchr.org/EN/Issues/Pages/WhatareHumanRights.aspx
88. Greenberg,G.A.,&Rosenheck,R.A.(2010).Anevaluationofaninitiativetoimprovecoordinationandservicedeliveryofhomelessservicesnetworks.TheJournal of Behavioral Health Services & Research, 37(2),184-196.
89. Formoreinformationsee:http://www1.nyc.gov/site/dhs/outreach/street-outreach.page
90. Murphy,N.F.(2014).Developing evidence-based effective principles for working with homeless youth: A developmental evaluation of the Otto Bremer Foundation’s support for collaboration among agencies serving homeless youth(DoctoralDissertation).UniversityofMinnesota,Minneapolis.
91. CityofToronto.(2014).Youth supports and services in Toronto. Retrievedfrom:https://www1.toronto.ca/City%20Of%20Toronto/Shelter%20Support%20&%20Housing%20Administration/Files/pdf/S/youthservicesandsupports.pdf
92. Burt,M.R.(2005)Strategies for preventing homelessness.USDepartmentofHousingandUrbanDevelopment.Retrievedfrom:https://www.huduser.gov/Publications/pdf/Strategies_for_preventing_Homelessness.pdf
93. Dickens,S.,&Woodfield,K.(2004).New approaches to youth homelessness prevention: A qualitative evaluation of the Safe in the City cluster schemes.JosephRowntreeFoundation.
94. CentreforAddictionsandMentalHealth.(2014).Hidden in our midst: Homeless newcomer youth in Toronto – Uncovering the supports to prevent and reduce homelessness.Retrievedfrom:https://www.camh.ca/en/research/news_and_publications/reports_and_books/Documents/Hidden%20in%20Our%20Midst%20Final%20Report_Nov%202014.pdf
95. Winland,D.,Gaetz,S.,&Patton,T.(2011). Family matters - Homeless youth and Eva’s Initiatives “Family Reconnect” program.Toronto:TheCanadianHomelessnessResearchNetworkPress.
96. DepartmentforCommunitiesandLocalGovernment.(2012).A joint approach to preventing homelessness. Retrievedfromhttps://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/7597/2200459.pdf
97. TheTruthandReconciliationCommissionofCanada.(2015).Calls to action.Retrievedfrom:http://nctr.ca/assets/reports/Calls_to_Action_English2.pdf
98. Gaetz,S.(2014).Coming of age: Reimagining the response to youth homelessness in Canada.Toronto:CanadianObservatoryonHomelessnessPress.Retrievedfromhttp://www.homelesshub.ca/sites/default/files/ComingOfAgeHH_0.pdf
99. Fallis,J.(2012). Literature review: The needs of youth transitioning from care, and best practices approaches to improve outcomes. TheGeneralAuthority.Retrievedfromhttp://www.generalauthority.ca/docs/Literature%20Review%20The%20Needs%20of%20Youth%20Transitioning%20from%20Care%20Final%20July%2012.pdf
100. Gaetz,S.&Scott,F.(2012).Live, learn, grow: Supporting transitions to adulthood for homeless youth, a framework for the Foyer in Canada.York,ON:TheHomelessHub.Retrievedfromhttp://homelesshub.ca/sites/default/files/foyer_report23112012.pdf
101. EgaleCanadaHumanRightsTrust.(2014)Out @ home, 2014 LGBTQ@S youth homelessness summit.Retrievedfrom:http://outatnight.ca/wp-content/uploads/2015/02/OUT-at-Home-Conference-Paper.pdf
102. AccordingtotheNationalHouseholdSurvey,almost1/3youthaged25-29hadmovedatleastonceinthepreviousyear.StatisticsCanada.(2011).National household survey table 99-013-X201128[Datafile].Retrievedfromhttp://www5.statcan.gc.ca/olc-cel/olc.action?objId=99-013-X2011028&objType=46&lang=en&limit=0
103. ShinnM.,Baumohl,J.,&Hopper,K.(2001).Thepreventionofhomelessnessrevisited.Analyses of Social Issues and Public Policy,95-127.
104. Stojanovic,D.,Weitzman,B.C.,Shinn,M.,Labay,L.E.,&Williams,N.P.(1999).Tracingthepathoutofhomelessness:Thehousingpatternsoffamiliesafterexitingshelters.Journal of Community Psychology,27,199-208.
105. Rog,D.J.,McCombs-Thornton,K.L.,Gilbert-Mongelli,A.M.,Brito,M.C.,&Holupka,C.S.(1995).Implementationofthehomelessfamiliesprogram:Characteristics,strengths,andneedsofparticipantfamilies.American Journal of Orthopsychiatry,514-527.
106. Quigley,J.M.,Raphael,S.,&Smolensky,E.(2001). The links between income inequality, housing markets, and homelessness in California. Researchbrief:PublicPolicyInstituteofCalifornia.
107. Burt,M.R.(2005).Strategies for preventing homelessness.USDepartmentofHousingandUrbanDevelopment.Retrievedfrom:https://www.huduser.gov/Publications/pdf/Strategies_for_preventing_Homelessness.pdf
108. UnitedNations.(2008).United Nations declaration on the rights of Indigenous peoples.Retrievedfromhttp://www.un.org/esa/socdev/unpfii/documents/DRIPS_en.pdf
109. UnitedNationsOfficeoftheHighCommissioner.(2016).Homelessness and human rights.AnnualReportA/HRC/31/54.Retrievedfrom:http://www.ohchr.org/Documents/Publications/fs9Rev.2.pdf
110. Tervalon,M.,&Murray-Garcia,J.(1998).Culturalhumilityversusculturalcompetence:Acriticaldistinctionindefiningphysiciantrainingoutcomesinmulticulturaleducation.Journal of Health Care for the Poor and Undeserved,9,117-125.
48