44

9= . >@?A . B C D1 E › files › docs › colloqpapers › w05 › Sc… · 0 (* %-$#+1 $3245$768&3 9:;&< # 9=" . >@?A . B C" D1 E FHGJILKMGON5PRQLSTPRQ UMSVK W;XZY\[^]`_Vacbd_eY\fZahgjilknmpo_eY\]

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: 9= . >@?A . B C D1 E › files › docs › colloqpapers › w05 › Sc… · 0 (* %-$#+1 $3245$768&3 9:;&< # 9=" . >@?A . B C" D1 E FHGJILKMGON5PRQLSTPRQ UMSVK W;XZY\[^]`_Vacbd_eY\fZahgjilknmpo_eY\]

������������ ��������� ��� ����������� �! #"%$��'&)(* +�,�� ����-$.$/0 (*�%�-$#�+1 �$324�5$768&3� 9:�;&<�� #� �� 9="� .��>@?A�� .�B�C"��D1�E

FHGJILKMGON5PRQLSTPRQ�UMSVKW;XZY\[^]`_Vacbd_eY\fZahgjilknmpo�_eY\]�krq5]�o�seo�tu[^]`m

vDwyx k`YdzZknack`{e|}�~h��S�����SVK��L�;�'���'�

���J�`�����4�Z�il_eY�fZa,f�YdknfZmBoZ�-�ek`�ZknacoZ�V[^s4X�]�o�_Vs�bpY\[^knmBoZ��bpkns�a^fZ]dz�k���kn]�bd[^�ZkCack`X�fZa,knse���oZY\]�kntukns�b`�,�;o�� k`�Zk`Yn¡T�R[^a^a¢f�XZk`Y\m,�l£eo¤z¥seo¦�@knfZ]�£§oZbd£ek`Y;�5kna¢a¨fZs4�§[¢s�bpk`Y\fZ]�bYdk`�©knf�bpkn�4ac{ªtufn{*_4mdkr[^tB�Va¢[^]`[cbL]�o�s�bpY\fZ]�bdm-bpo�tu[^s4[¢tu[c«`k-]�Y\[^tBkZ� ¬,]�o�s4mpbpY\_4]�bf;�e{Rs4fZtu[¢]5a^[¢tu[cbpkn�R�­]�o�tut¤[cbdtBknsMb+tBoR�eknaR[^sr�;£4[^]\£Hf;bd£4[ck`�V]`fZs4s4oZb�]�Y\kn�4[c®Vac{]�o�tutu[cb�bpo¯�°oZYdk`XZormpbpknfZa¢[^seX-��Y\o�t±£4[^mJ�°kna^aco����R[^a^a¢f�XZk`Y\m�®V_eb�tuf�{®©k²[^s4�V_4]�kn�bpoªa¢[^tu[cb�£4[^m�mpbpknfZa^[^seX�®¥{§bd£ekH�4Ydo�tu[¢mpkoZ�5�°_4bd_eYdkrX�[^��bdm-�°Ydo�t³£4[^m;�©oZbpkns�bd[^fZa�¥[^]�bd[¢t´� v m\[^seX*f§_Vs4[^µ¥_ekHm\_eYd�Zk`{���Y\o�t¶Y\_eY\fZa�·�f�Y\f�X�_Vfn{%�l£V[^]\£�]�o�t®V[^seknmbpY\fZ�4[cbd[co�sVfZa#�4f�bdfCo�s%�4YdoR�4_4]�bd[^o�s��l[cbd£�[^se�°oZY\tuf�bd[co�s�o�s�bd£ek`�°b`¡�X�[c��bdmn¡JfZs4�bpY\_4mpb`¡�fZmH�5kna¢a5fZmH�l[cbd£�k�¸¥�©k`Y\[¢tBkns�bdmHtBknfZmd_4Y\[^seX*bpY�_4mpb¹fZs4��bpY�_4mpb­� oZYdbd£4[c�seknmdm`¡¨¬;bpknmpb¯�l£4k`bd£ek`YDbd£ek¤�4f�bdf´[¢mD]�o�s4md[^mpbpknsMbD�l[cbd£��VYdkn�4[^]�bd[co�sVm;�°Ydo�t¶bd£4k�e{¥sVfZtu[^]¹tBoR�eknaº�B»²£ekBYdknm\_4acbdm-�4Ydo¦�¥[¢�ekBk`�¥[¢�ekns4]�kBbd£4f�b`¡J[^s�]�o�s�bpY�fZmpbr�l[^bd£�4Ydkn�4[^]�bd[^o�s4m,�°Ydo�t¼f�o�sek��½�©k`Y\[coR�*tBoR�ekna¨�;[cbd£§fZs�fZseo�sM{¥tBo�_Vmlbd£4[^k`�¾¡T�°f�Y\tB�k`Y\mB�eo�[^tB�Va¢[^]`[cbdac{�]�o�sMbpY\fZ]�bu�l[cbd£�o�sek*fZs4oZbd£ek`YBbpo%a^[^tu[^brbd£ek`�°b`��¿Vf�Y\tBk`Y\m�l£eo¤£4f��ZktBoZY\k]`aco�mpk�°fZt¤[^ac{ªtBkntr®©k`Y\m;[^s´bd£ekn[^Y²�¥[¢a^a^f�XZk¯X�[c�Zk��k`� k`Y�X�[c��bdmn¡fZs4�r�Àf�Y\tBk`Y�m+�l[^bd£r�Va^oZbdm+�l£V[^]\£Hf�YdkLtBoZYdk,�4[cÁ¤]`_Vacb¨bpo-mpbpknfZa¥��Ydo�tÂX�[c�Zk �°k`�5k`YX�[c��bdmn¡�k�¸¥�©k`Y\[^kns4]�k,acknmdm�bd£ek`�°b`¡MfZs4�¹bpY�_4mpb#tBoZYdkZ�.Ã-[^��bÄ�½X�[c�R[^seXD[^sV]�YdknfZmpknm��l£4knsbpY\_4mpb#[^m5aco�� k`Y5fZsV�ubd£ek²bd£4Ydknf�b.oZ�©bd£ek`�°b5[^m#XZYdknf�bpk`Yn¡¥bd_eY\s4[^s4X�bd£4k;mpoR]`[^fZa4]`f��e�[cbdfZaha^[cbpk`Y\f�bd_4YdkDo�s*[cbdm²£4knfZ�h�

Å\Æ�Ç�ÈÊÉ-ËÍÌ�ɾÌ�Î�ËÍÏÄÇ´ÇMÎ�É�ÐMÌ�Ì\Ñ�É­Ò�Ó�ÓMԦ˭ÕÍÌ�ÖCÐ�תվÇ�ÌuØ�ÔZÏdÈÙÎnÚ#ØZÏ\ÈÛÌ�Ñ�ÏdÌBÜ�ÌÝÉ­ÌÝÎnËÄÏÄÇ�Þ'Ô�Ò�Ñ�ÏdÈÊÚ,ß�Ø�ØZÜ#Þ�àdáÕ¾Ç�Ì�Ü�Ò�ÉÍÉ­Ì�ÚÛÚLØZÎnâ¦Ìuã�Ô�Ò�Ñ�Ö�Î`ÕÍÈÛÔ¦ÑäߢÜ.Ø�ã©àdáJåJÌ�˾æ¦Ì\ÚÊÌ\קçºÑMɽÕÍÈèÕÍÒZÕ¾Ì�Ôné²åJÒ�É­ÈÊÑ�ÌÝɾɯÎ�Ñ�Ö�ê+Ï\Ô�Ñ�Ô¦ë-ÈÊÏBÜ�Ì\ìÉ­ÌÝÎnËÄÏÄǧß^ç½å�ê'Ü.àpáeåJÌ\ËÍæ�Ì�ÚÛÌ�×uÞ'Ì�Ñ�Õ¾Ì\Ë é^ԦˠçºÑ�ÕÍÌ\ËÍÑ�Î`ÕÍÈÛÔ¦Ñ�ÎnÚhÎnÑMÖ¤í5Ì\î�Ì�ÚÛÔ¦Ó�ë-Ì\Ñ�Õ,ê+ÏdÔ¦Ñ�Ô�ë-ÈÙÏ\É Ü�Ì�ɾÌ�Î�ËÍÏÄÇß°Þ'ç½í ê+Ü.àdá4ÎnÑ�ÖuÕ¾Ç�̯ï ÈÙÎnÑ�Ñ�ÈÛÑ�Ȩã�Ô�Ò�ÑMÖ�Î`ÕÍÈÛÔ¦Ñ4ðlç.Î�ëjâ�ËÄÎ`ÕÍÌdé^Ò�Ú�Õ¾ÔBñ¦Ô¦ÉZòÌlóBÔ¦ÚÛÈÊÑ�ΦɠÎ�Ñ�ÖuÌ�î�Ì�˾צÔ�Ñ�Ì�Î`ÕçºÑ�É­Õ¾ÈÛÕ¾ÒZÕÍÔ�í5Ì�ÉÍÎnËÍ˾ԦÚÛÚÊÔLé^Ô�Ë+Õ¾Ç�Ì�ÈÛË�ɾÒ�Ó�Ó¥Ô�˾ÕJô�Ç�ÈÊÚÊÌ.ÈÊÑrõhÎnËÄÎnâ¦Ò�Î�×�ð4çpö Ö¯ÚÊÈÊæ�Ì�ÕÍÔ²Õ¾ÇMÎnÑ�ærï Ì�Ô�ËÍâ�Ì#÷#æ¦Ì\ËÍÚÛÔ�é½áÆVÌÝÖ�óuÈÛâ¦Ò�Ì\Ú°áVóuÎnÕ­Õ¾Ç�Ì\ôøÜ.ÎnÐ�ÈÊÑ4áVù.Ì�Î`ÕÍÇ�Ì\Ë,Ü�Ô`צÌ\ËÝáeê¨ÚÊÈÊÉÍÎnÐ¥ÌdÕÍǪØZΦÖZÔ�Ò�ÚÛÌ\Õ�áVÎ�Ñ�Ö¤õ©Ì�˾ËÍ×uØ�Ç�ÎnÓ�ÈÛËÍÔré^Ô¦ËÏdÔ¦ë�ë-Ì�ѦÕÄÉ\á�Î�Ñ�ÖçJÎ�ë@ÈÊÑ�ÖZÌ\Ð�Õ¾Ì�ÖÕÍÔ-ê¨Õ¾Ç�Î�ÑBú4ÈÊâ�Ô�Ñré^Ô�Ë�Ç�ÈÙÉ�ÈÊÑ�î�Î�ÚÛÒMÎnÐ�ÚÊÌ,Î�ÖZî�ÈÙÏdÌ,ÎnÑ�ÖÓ�ÎnÕ¾ÈÊÌ\Ñ�Ï\Ì�ðû õ¨ÚÊÌ�Î�ɾÌ,Î�Ö�Ö�˾ÌÝɾÉ�ÏdԦ˾ËÍÌ�ɾӥÔ�Ñ�ÖZÌ�Ñ�ÏdÌÝɨÕÍÔ¹ü�ýÝþ�ÿ�ý�þ��Zÿ�������ÿ���ÿ�����ÿ���ÿ� ��­ÿ����eð�

Page 2: 9= . >@?A . B C D1 E › files › docs › colloqpapers › w05 › Sc… · 0 (* %-$#+1 $3245$768&3 9:;&< # 9=" . >@?A . B C" D1 E FHGJILKMGON5PRQLSTPRQ UMSVK W;XZY\[^]`_Vacbd_eY\fZahgjilknmpo_eY\]

���������������� !���#"$ %� &

' (*),+.-./1032345+76!/8)

9;:=<?>A@CBEDB�F%GH@�IJDK<�LMB�DN<!OPIQ@SRAF�<!T8<!OM>VUWOXRY:=R�BZD[BZRA<�BZ\]BZRA@S:=O�^X>�_�<a`b@SRADW^dcb>A_=<�Ie>f <�>$`b<!<�OgIhB�RAT8<!RY\iUK\jB1F!@ST8T8@SO3@PF�F!:=RYRA<�O=F!<ZkmlXnoUpIe>$qsr#<!RYF!<!OM>t@�Iu\Y:=RYv�<�qERY<!\Ar#@SOPw^=<�OM>�\jUKOERA:�R�B�D.xyB�R�BZLS:zB�q|{tRY<!r#@SRY>A<!^3>�_zB}>j\A@ST8<~UW>A<!T�`�B�\j\Y>A@SDK<�O3IQRA@ST�>�_=<�T�UKO>A_=<irzB�\�>NqS<�BZR!k.�JT8@SO=L�>A_=@S\Y<;IQRA@ST�`5_=@ST�\Y@ST8<�>�_�UKO=L�`�B�\5\Y>A@SDK<�Odc�T8<!^�UB�OV>A_=<�Ie>B�F�F!@S:�O�>A<!^VIQ@�R�BjDK@S\Y\b@ZId>$`�@tr�<�RAF�<!OM>u@�I�B�O=O�:zB�D�UKO�F!@ST8<�k.��@�>�@SO=Dpq�UK\.>�_=<�Ie>uDKB�RALS<ZcUp>�B�DK\Y@jF%_zB�O=LS<�\bUWOMvS<!\�>�T8<!OM>b^=<!F�UK\AUW@SO=\�cPBZ\7IQ@SRY>$qMw�>$`b@�r�<�RAF!<�OM>�@�I�RA<�\Ar#@SO=^=<�OM>�\�\AB�UK^>A_=<!RY<�`uBZ\iBZ>[DK<�BZ\Y>;@�O=<�F�RA@Srs>A_=<�qa`�<�RA<�^�UK\AF�@S:=RAB�LS<!^�IQRA@ST�r=DKB�OM>�UKO�L f <!F�BZ:=\A<�@ZIIQ<!B�RN@�I�>�_=<�Ie>�k

� B�\Y:zB�D|@ f \A<�RYvZBZ>AUK@SO�UKOtxoB�RAB�LS:zB�q�\A:�LSLS<!\�>�\�>�_zBZ>�>�_�<!RA<�UK\*DW<!\A\�>�_=<�Ie>yIQRY@ST��z<�DK^=\`5_=UWF%_3B�RY<tT8@SRA<�^=Up�]F�:=DW>�>�@]\Y>A<�B�D*IQRA@STac#B�O=^�>A_zBZ>�>�_=<�RA<tUK\�T]@SRY<�>A_=<�Ie>J@�I.F�RA@Sr=\\Y:=F%_�BZ\�`uB}>�<!RYT]<�DK@SOC`5_�UKF%_dc�UKO f <!UWO=L3<�BZ\YqC>A@3F!@SO=\Y:=T8<�c�B�RA<?@ZI[L�RA<�B}>�<!Rtv�BZDK:=<>A@a>A_=UK<�vS<!\�kan�@�RY>$qMw�>$`b@�r#<!RYF!<!OM>�@�Iu_=@�:=\A<�_=@SDK^�\�B�DW\A@�B�^=T8UW>i>�@aLSUpvPUWO=L1LSUWIe>A\i>�@sBr#<!RY\A@SO�`5_=@;UK\*G�O=@�`5O�>�@ f <�B5>�_=UW<�I=UWOt>A_=<b_�@Sr�<�\y>A_zBZ>�>�_=UW\�:�O�>ARA:=\�>$`�@�RY>�_Mq�r�<�RA\A@�O`5UWDKD�DWUKT8UW>�>�_=<�B�T8@S:=OM>5_=<j\�>�<�BZDK\NIQRA@ST�>�_=<�T�k

��rzB�r#<!R f qt��<�F%G�<�R5� �����S�M  r�@�RY>�RAB�qP\yB[RABZ>�UW@SOzB�DSB�O=@SOMq|T]@�:=\�>A_=UK<�I=`5_=@�`�<�UKLS_=\>A_=< f <�O=<���>�\i@�I�\Y>A<�B�DWUKO=L,B�LMB�UWO=\Y>[>�_=<~F�@S\Y>A\�@ZI�r�@S\Y\AU f DK<�r�:=O=UK\Y_=T8<!OM>�k�¡N_=UK\i@�O=<�wr#<!RYUK@|^]T8@P^�<!D#r=RA<�^=UKF�>�\b>A_zBZ>�>�_=<�RA<J`5UWDKD f <JT8@SRA<5>�_�<�Ie>�`5_�<!O,>�_�<Jr#@�>�<�O�>AUB�D�LMBZUKO=\B�RY<1LSRA<!BZ>�<�R]BZO=^X>A_=<1r=RA@ f B f UKDWUW>$q¢@�I;L�<�>A>AUKO=LEF!B�:=LS_M>]UK\�\AT]B�DKDW<!R�kH���b<!F%G�<�RAUKB�OT8@P^�<!D;F!B�O=O=@�>1\Y_=<!^£DKUWLS_M>?@SO¤_=@�`¥\Y@PF�UB�DJ>AUK<�\?F�B�O¦DKUWT]Up>8>A_=<�Ie>!k�¡N_|:�\!cJ`5_=UWDK<��<�F%G�<�R!§¨\VT8@P^=<�DNF�B�O�<�©Pr=DKB�UKOH>A_=<�F!B�\A:=B�DN@ f \Y<!RYvZBZ>AUK@SO�\]B f @�vS<1`5UW>A_XRY<!LMBZRA^=\~>�@>A_=<�Ie>!c�Up>~F�BZO=O=@�>�<ª©�r�DB�UWOC`5_�qg>�_=<?\AB�T]<?_�@S:=\A<�_=@SDW^=\�`5_=UKF%_XB�RY<,vP:�DKO=<�R�B f DW<V>�@>A_=<�Ie>�B�DW\A@�L�UWvS<iT8@SRY<;LSUWIe>A\�@SRb`5_�q?B�_�@S:=\A<�_=@SDW^1`b@S:=DW^?LSUWv�<iLSUWIe>A\b>A@�B�O1:=OM>�RA:�\Y>Yw`b@SRY>A_Mq1O=<!UWLS_ f @SR�k

«5<!\A<!B�RAF%_V_zB�\�\Y_=@�`5OV>�_=BZ>�IhB�RAT8<!RY\bUWO]RY:=R�B�D#B�RY<�B�\�_zB�vS<[<�©|>�<�O=\AUpvS<;G�O=@�`5DW<!^=LS<@�I�<�B�F%_¢@�>�_�<!R!§¨\tB�F�>AUK@SO=\�cyUWOM>�<!RAB�F�>j`5Up>�_¬<�B�F%_¢@�>�_=<�Rt@�OgB1^zB�UWDWq f B�\AUW\!cyB�O=^gF�@SOPw>AR�B�F�>u@�vS<�RNTVB�OMq]B�\Yr�<�F�>�\N@ZI�>�_=<�UKR�DWUWv�<!\i�hx.DBZ>Y>�<�BZ:?­®�[:=LS<�OM> ���S� &Pc|¯�^=RYq ���S��°�  k± UWv�<!O�>A_=<�DKB�F%G1@�I�B�O�@SOMqPT8UW>$qaBZO=^�>�_�<�DK@�O=LZw�>A<!RYT²OzBZ>�:�RA<�@ZI.RA<�DBZ>AUK@SO=\Y_=UKr�\5>A_zBZ>F%_zBZR�B�F�>�<!RYUK³�<]DWUWIQ<�UWO¬RY:=R�BZD�xoB�RAB�LS:zB�qSc*v|UKDWDB�LS<�RA\;\Y_=@S:=DW^ f <8B f DW<�>A@�:�\A<8UKO�IQ@SRYTVBZDF�@SOM>�R�BZF�>�\Y´[`5Up>�_1@SO=<�B�O=@Z>�_=<�Ru>�@8r=RA<�vS<!OM>[<�©PF!<�\A\YUWvS<t>�_=<�Ie>�B�\N`�<�DKDµk

¶$OE>�_=UW\�r=B�r�<�Rj¶[<ª©�r=B�O=^g@�Og��<�F%G�<�R!§¨\�@SO=<ªw$r#<!RYUK@|^¬T8@|^=<!D7@ZIuB1R�BZ>AUK@SO=B�Dy>A_=UK<�If qEF!@�O=\Y>ARA:=F�>�UKO�L�B?^�q|OzB�T8UKF�DWUKT8UW>�<�^Pw$F�@ST8T]Up>�T�<!OM>�T]@|^=<�D7UKO3`5_=UWF%_¢>�_�<�IQ@�RAT]B�D· ÷#Ñ�Õ¾Ç�ËÍÔ�Ó¥Ô�ÚÊÔ�â¦ÈÊÉ­ÕÍɨÇ�Î�î�Ì#ÖZÈÙÉÍÏdÒ�ÉÍÉ­ÌÝÖ�Õ¾Ç�Ì\écÕ'Ð¥ÌdÕ½ôJÌ\Ì�Ñ-é^Ì\ÚÊÚÛÔ`ô�î�ÈÛÚÊÚÙÎnâ�Ì�ËÍÉ©ÈÊÑDÕÍÇ�Ì.ÏdÔ¦Ñ�վ̹¸�Õ+Ô�é4óB̹¸ZÈÙÏdÔߢã�ԦɭվÌ\Ë.ºA»�¼!½�àpá�¾5ÈÛÌ\Õ¾Ñ�Î�ëAߢõhÎ�ÈÛâ¦ÌbºA»!¿�½�àpá�çÀÕÄÎnÚÊ×�ߢå�Î�Ñ�À�Ì\ÚÙÖtºY»�½�Á¦àdá�Î�Ñ�Ö¹óuÎnÚÙÎ�×ZÉ­ÈÙÎrß°ØZÏdÔ�Õ­Õ�ºA»�Á�½¦àpð Æ�Ç�̲ɭÒ�˾î¦Ì\ׯÏdÔ`î¦Ì\ËÍÌ�ÖJÃ�Ã�½lÇ�Ô¦Ò�É­Ì�Ç�Ô�ÚÙÖ�É�ÈÊѹ˾Ò�ËÄÎnÚeõhÎ�ËÍÎ�â�Ò�Î�×�ÈÛÑjÃ�Ä�Ä�Ã�ðÅ ù#Ì\ËÍÌ�áMÎDÏdÔ�Ñ�ÕÍËÍΦÏpÕ#ÖZÔ�Ì�É�Ñ�Ô�Õ#˾Ì\é^Ì\Ë�ÕÍÔ¯Î;é^Ô�ËÍë-Î�Ú4ô�ËÍÈèÕ¾Õ¾Ì\ÑBÏ\Ô�Ñ�Õ¾ËÄÎ�ÏdÕ�áZÐ�ÒZÕ5ËÍÎnÕ¾Ç�Ì�Ë#ÎnѹÒ�Ñ�ô�˾ÈÛÕ­ÕÍÌ\ÑÉ­×ZÉ­Õ¾Ì�ë ÔnéhɾÎ�Ñ�ÏpÕÍÈÛÔ¦Ñ�É�ÎnÑ�ÖHËÍÌ\ô�ÎnËÄÖ�É�ð

Page 3: 9= . >@?A . B C D1 E › files › docs › colloqpapers › w05 › Sc… · 0 (* %-$#+1 $3245$768&3 9:;&< # 9=" . >@?A . B C" D1 E FHGJILKMGON5PRQLSTPRQ UMSVK W;XZY\[^]`_Vacbd_eY\fZahgjilknmpo_eY\]

���������������� !���#"$ %� Æ

Ç :=^�UKF!UKB�D�\Yq|\Y>A<!TÈUK\~UWO=<�É�<!F�>�UpvS<�k¢�JOXB�LS<�O�>�F!B�O=O=@Z>�F!RA<�^=U f DWq¢F!@ST8T]Up>�>A@¬RY<�IQRAB�UKOIQRY@STÊ\Y>A<�B�DWUKO=L5IQRA@�T®B�O=@�>A_=<!RyB�LS<�O�>!cSB�O�^�\A@[T�:=\�> f <bUWO=^=:=F�<!^�>A@[DWUKT8UW>�_�UK\*>�_=<�Ie> f q>A_=<Nr=RA@�T]UW\A<u@�I�IQ:�>A:=RA<NL�UWIe>�\�kyË8¡N_=UW\7>$qPr#<5@�I#T]@|^=<�D�_zB�\ f <!<�O8:�\A<!^�>�@jUWO�v�<!\�>�UKLSBZ>�<<��]F�UK<�O�>8^�q|OzBZT]UWF,F!@SOM>AR�B�F�>�\�UKOH>�_�<1B f \A<�O=F!<a@�I[F!@ST8T8UW>�T8<!OM>t`5UW>�_HRY<!LMBZRA^=\~>�@\Y@Ìv�<!RY<!UKL�Og^=< f >V�ÎÍiDK<�>�³!<�R�­ÐÏgRYUKLS_M>t&�Ñ�ÑSÑ   B�O=^¢T�:�>A:zB�D7UWO=\A:=RAB�O=F�<]T8<!F%_zBZO=UK\YT]\�hÒ*UWLS@SO¢<�>8B�DÎk7&�Ñ�ÑM&PcyÍj@|F%_=<�RADBZG�@�>�B ���S�S�S  c7>�_�@S:=LS_HUp>�_zB�\�O=@�>~r=RY<�v|UK@�:=\ADpq f <!<�OB�r�r=DKUW<!^,>�@~>A_=<�Ie>!k

¡N_=<�RA<;UW\uB�DKB�RALS<�DKUp>�<�R�BZ>A:=RA<�@SO,r=RY@Sr#<!RY>$q8F�RAUKT8<�UKOV>A_=<;¯�O=UW>A<!^1Ó|>�BZ>�<�\j�ÎÒ�<�vPUp>A>&�Ñ�Ñ ° c ± @S:=DK^Ô<�>,B�DÎk�&�ÑSÑS&   c f :�>8>�_=UW\8DWUW>A<!R�B}>�:=RY<,IQ@PF�:=\A<�\V@SOXB�O=@SOMq|T8@S:=\8:=R f BZOF�RAUKT8< f q1>�_=UW<�vS<�\[`5_=@]^=@VO�@�>�G|O�@Ì`Õ>A_=<�r�<�@Sr=DK<jIQRA@�TÖ`5_=@ST�>A_=<�q�B�RY<t\�>�<�BZDKUKO�L=k¡N_=<�T8@P^�<!D�r�RA<!\Y<!OM>�<�^�_=<�RA<.UW\�O=@�vS<!DMUWO;>�_=<.<�F!@SO�@ST]UWF7DKUp>�<�R�BZ>A:=RA<y@SOjF!RAUWT]<ZcÌB�\�T8@S\Y>@�>A_=<!RNr=B�r�<�RA\5^=@~O=@Z>5F!@SO=\YUK^=<�R5UKOM>�<�R�B�F�>�UK@�O=\ f <�>$`b<!<!Oa>�_=UW<�v�<!\�B�O=^?>�_�<!UKRuv|UWF�>�UWT]\�k×.F!@�O=@ST8UK\Y>A\�@�Ie>�<�O]T8@P^�<!D=>�_�UK<�v�<!\bUKOM>�<�R�B�F�>�UKO�Lj`5Up>�_8@�>�_�<!R�>�_=UW<�vS<�\!c�>�<!B�F%_=UKO�L�<�BZF%_@�>A_=<!RNT8<�>A_=@|^=\5@SRN<�©P<!R�>�UWO=L]r#<!<�R5r=RA<�\A\A:�RA<V� ± DB�<�\A<!RN<�>[B�Dµk ���S�S�M  c=@SRuv|UKF�>�UWT]\uUWOPw>A<!R�BZF�>�UWO=LiUKO�O=<!UWLS_ f @SRY_=@|@P^�`�BZ>�F%_8r=RY@SLSR�BZT]\u�ÎØ[:�F%G~­�Íi@S\�IQ<!DK^8&ZÑSÑ °�  koØ�@Ì`b<�v�<!R�c>A_=<!RY<JB�RY<�IQ<�`ÙT8@P^=<�DK\.UWO8`5_=UWF%_]v|UKF�>�UWT]\�UKOM>A<!R�BZF�>�`5UW>A_8>A_=UK<�vS<!\�c=B�O�^]>�_�<!RA<[B�RY<[O=@<�T]r=UWRAUWF�B�D�rzB�r#<!RA\N>A_zBZ>5¶�G�O=@�`�@�I7@SO?>A_=<i>�@Sr=UWF�k

¡N_=<�RA<8B�RA<�>$`b@1O=@�>�B f DK<�rzB�r#<!RA\;`5_�UKF%_ET]@|^=<�DoUKOM>A<!R�BZF�>�UW@SO=\ f <�>$`b<!<�O¬>A_=UK<�vS<�\B�O�^¬v|UKF�>�UWT]\;IQRY@STÚB?>�_=<�@SRA<�>�UKF!B�D�r�<�RA\Yr�<�F�>�UpvS<ZkVϤ_=UKDW<~�JGZ<!RADW@�IN­�Û�<!DKDW<!O�� ������°� IQ@|F!:=\j@SO¢:=R f B�O¢F�RAUWT]<�B�O�^CB1F!@ST8T�:=O=Up>$q#§Ü\j^=<�F!UK\YUK@SOE>�@aB�F�F!<�r�>�F�RAUKT8< f qELMB�O=LT8<!T f <!RY\!cPÝ�:=Uy� ���S�MÞS  IQ@|F!:=\Y<!\�@SOVRY:=R�BZDzF!RAUWT]<Zk.ß;O=<5IhB�RAT8<!R.\AB f @�>%B�L�<!\bB�\Y<!F!@�O=^IhB�RYT]<�R!§¨\�r=RY@P^=:�F�>�^=:=<,>A@3_=UK\�IQ<�<!DWUKO=LS\�@�I�<!OMv�qScbB�O=^H>�_=<?\Y<!F�@SO=^ÔIhB�RAT8<!R�DWUKT8UW>A\\AB f @Z>%B�LS< f qaLSUWv|UKO�L]LSUpIe>�\�ku¡N_=<~B�F�>J@ZI.\�B f @�>�B�LS<�LSUWv�<!\�O=@,T8@SO=<�>�B�RYq f <!O�<��=>A\JUKOÝ�:�Uµ§¨\�T8@|^=<!DÎc=@SO=Dpq,\A<�RYv|UKO�L8>A@]RY<!^=:=F�<�>A_=<�\�B f @�>�<�:=R!§¨\5<!OMv�qSku¶$O1>�_�<�<�OMv|qaT8@P^�<!D>A_=UK<�vS<!\5T�:�\Y> f <�r#@|@SRA<�R�>�_zBZOa>A_=<!UWR�v|UKF�>AUKT8\!c�B�O=^aLSUWIe>�w$LSUpvPUWO=Lj`5UKDKD�@PF�F!:=R5<�vS<!OaUKO>A_=<j@SO=<�w�\A_=@Z>[LSB�T]<Zk

×.F!@SO�@ST]UW\Y>A\�B�RY<,B�F�F!:=\�>�@ST8<!^¢>�@�>A_=UKO�G|UWO=La@�INLSUpIe>tL�UWv|UKO=L�B�\t\A@ST8<�>A_=UKO=La@SO=<^=@|<!\j@SO3>A_=<�_=@SDKUW^zB�q|\!c*B?T]<!B�O=\i@�I�>�RAB�^=<Zc�@�RjB1T8<�BZO=\j@�I�RY<!F�UKr=RY@PF!B�D7<�©PF%_zBZO=LS<�k¡N_=<�r=RY<!^=UWF�>AUK@SO=\i@ZIb>A_=<�^�q|OzB�T8UKF~DKUWT]Up>�<�^Pw$F�@ST]T8UW>AT]<�OM>5T]@|^=<!Do\A_=@�`à>A_zBZ>�LSUpIe>�\B�RY<JBZDK\A@tLSUWv�<!OV>A@�r#@�>�<�OM>�UBZD�>A_=UK<�vS<�\b>�@�^=<�>A<!Rb>A_=<�Ie>!k.¡N_=UK\�UK\�F!@�O�>AR�B�R�q�>�@�>A_=<Jr=RY<�w^=UWF�>AUK@SO=\�@ZI=IhB�UKRYO=<!\Y\*T]@|^=<!DW\*UKOi`5_=UKF%_�B�LS<!OM>A\yRY<�`�B�RA^�B�F�>A@SRA\*`5UW>A_tLS@|@|^tUWO�>A<!OM>�UW@SO=\�h«[B f UKO ���S� Æ   @SRyLSUWv�<�LSUpIe>�\*>�@JRY<!^=:�F!<uUWO=<!á�:zB�DWUW>$q]�hn�<�_=R7­¤Ó|F%_=T]UW^�> ���S�S�M  c�B�\�`�<�DKDB�\NF�@SOM>�RAB�^=UKF�>�UWO=L~r=RA<�^=UKF�>�UW@SO=\u@�I�T�:P>�:zB�D�UKO=\Y:=R�B�O�F!<iT8@P^=<�DK\j� � @MBZ>A<j­à«�B�vZB�DWDKUW@SO����� Æ   UWOC`5_=UKF%_�_=@S:=\Y<!_=@�DK^=\�LSUpvS<?LSUpIe>�\�>A@E>A_=@S\Y<?_=@S:=\Y<!_=@SDW^=\~`5UW>A_Ô`5_�@STâ>�_�<�q_zB�v�<;IQ<�`b<!Ru<�O�IQ@SRAF�<!T8<!OM>Nr=RY@ f DW<!T8\!k�ßJI�F!@S:�RA\A<J_=@S:=\Y<!_=@SDW^=\uLSUpvS<;L�UWIe>�\�IQ@SR�B�T�q|R�wãAä ÖZËÍ×�ßhºY»�»�å�à�À�Ñ�Ö�É#Õ¾Ç�ÎnÕ�Õ¾Ç�Ì,ÈÊÑ�Î�Ð�ÈÛÚÊÈÛսׯվÔDÏ\Ô�ë-ë-ÈèÕ#ÈÙÉ�ë-Ô�ËÍÌLÈÛë-Ó¥Ô�˾ÕÍÎnÑ�Õ�ÕÍÇ�ÎnѹÈÊÑZé^Ô�ËÍëDÎ`Õ¾ÈÊÔ�ÑMÎnÚÏdÔ¦Ñ�ɽÕÍËÍÎ�ÈÛÑ�ÕÄÉ'ÈÊÑBÖZÌdÕÍÌ\ËÍë-ÈÛÑ�ÈÊÑ�âDÏdÔ¦Ñ�Õ¾ËÄÎ�ÏpÕÄÉJÈÛѹËÍÒ�ËÍÎ�Ú�æ#ÈÊâ�Ì�˾ÈÙÎ�ð

Page 4: 9= . >@?A . B C D1 E › files › docs › colloqpapers › w05 › Sc… · 0 (* %-$#+1 $3245$768&3 9:;&< # 9=" . >@?A . B C" D1 E FHGJILKMGON5PRQLSTPRQ UMSVK W;XZY\[^]`_Vacbd_eY\fZahgjilknmpo_eY\]

���������������� !���#"$ %� °

UKB�^s@�I�RA<!B�\A@�O=\!çjB,r=RY<�IQ<�RA<!O�F!<~IQ@SRJIhB�UWRAO=<�\A\�c*BVIQ@SRAT�@�I�T�:�>A:zB�DoUWO=\A:�R�B�O=F�<�c*B�O�^¢B^=<�\AUWRA<N>�@�B�r=r#<�BZ\A<�r�@�>A<!OM>�UKB�D�>A_=UK<�vS<!\�k.¡N_=UK\.DKB�\Y>�RY<�B�\Y@SO]IQ@�R.LSUWIe>�w$LSUpvPUWO=L=cÌ`5_=UKDW<NO=@�>>A_=<;@SO=DpqVRY<�B�\Y@SOdc=_=B�\ f <!<!O1LS<�O=<!RAB�DKDpq8UKLSO=@�RA<!^VUKO,>�_�<;<!F�@SO=@ST8UKF[DKUW>A<!RABZ>�:=RY< f :P>NUK\<�F!@SO=@�T]UWF�B�DWDWq8\AUWLSO=UW�=F�B�OM>5UKO1RY:=R�B�DdxoB�RAB�LS:zB�qSk

¯[\YUKO=L[^zBZ>�B5IQRY@STÕRA:=RAB�D|xoB�RAB�LS:zB�q�cS¶�>�<�\Y>�IQ@SR�<�v|UK^=<�O=F!<b@�IzF�@SOM>�R�BZF�>�UWO=L f <�>$`b<!<�O>A_=UK<�vS<!\[B�O=^a>�_=<�UKRNv|UKF�>�UKT8\!k�«5<!\Y<�B�RYF%_=<!RY\;UKO�xoB�RAB�LS:zB�qaB�O�^�BZ>5>A_=<�¯�O=UWv�<!RY\AUW>$q1@ZIϤUW\AF!@�O=\AUWOèF!@SDWDK<�F�>�<�^èrzB�O�<!DJ^=BZ>%BgIQRY@ST @Ìv�<!R1&ZÑSÑgRA:�R�B�D[_=@S:=\Y<!_=@SDW^=\,UWOè\AUm©P>A<!<�ORAB�O=^=@ST8DWqt\A<�DK<�F�>�<�^]v|UKDWDB�L�<!\o@ZIdRA:�R�B�DzxyB�R�BZLS:zB�q�BZ>�>�_�RA<!<5r#@SUKOM>A\.UKO~>�UWT]<�>A_=RA@�:=LS_Pw@S:P>;>�_=< ���S� Ñ�§¨\�� � B�RY>A<!Ri­Ðß;DKUKOM>A@?&�ÑSÑ�Æ   k;¶5F�@SO=^=:=F�>�<�^gBVIQ@S:�RY>�_�RA@S:=O�^3@�I�^zBZ>%BF�@SDKDW<!F�>AUK@SO8UKOV&�ÑSÑS&tB�^=^�UKO=Ltá|:�<!\Y>AUK@SO�\u^=<!\YUKLSO�<!^V>A@�DK@|@SG�\Yr�<�F!UW�=F�B�DWDWq8BZ>�>�_=<JUK\A\Y:=<!\RAB�UK\Y<!^8UKO�>�_=UW\brzBZr�<�R!k7¶$OVB�^=^=Up>�UK@�O8>A@�>A_=<[@�RAUKL�UKOzB�DÎcST8@SRA<5\Y>�B�O=^zBZRA^dc|á�:=<!\�>�UK@�O=\�@SOUWO=F!@ST8<jB�O=^�r=RA@|^=:=F�>�UW@SOdcz^=<�>%B�UWDK<!^1á�:=<�\Y>�UW@SO=\[@SOa>A_=<�Ie>[<�©Pr#<!RYUK<!O�F!<!^ f qaB�_=@S:�\A<�w_=@�DK^dcSL�UWIe>�\�>�_=<�q�LMB�v�<�c�B�O=^�\Y:=RYv�<�q~^zB}>%B;@SO�>A_=<!UWR7DK<�vS<!D�@�Iz>�RY:=\Y>�UWO�IQ<!DKDW@�`HvPUWDKDKB�LS<!RY\`b<!RY<NB�^=^=<�^�>�@J>A_=<�\Y:=RYv�<�q�k.¶*B�DK\Y@JR�BZO~BJ\A<�RAUW<!\7@�I=<!F!@�O=@ST8UKF�<�©Pr�<�RAUWT]<�O�>A\7T8<�B�\Y:=R�wUWO=L�>ARA:=\�>�c�>�RY:=\Y>$`b@SRY>A_=UKO�<!\A\�czB�O=^VRAUK\YG�B�vS<!RY\AUW@SOV`5UW>A_8>A_=<J\AB�T8<[_=@�:=\A<�_=@SDK^�\b`5_=UWF%_RY<!\Ar#@SO=^�<!^?>�@�>A_=<;\Y:=RYv�<�qSk�¡N_=<iT]B�UWOVDKUWT]Up>%BZ>AUK@SO�@�I�>�_=<J^zBZ>%BZ\A<�>uUK\b>A_=<;RY<!DB}>�UWv�<!Dpq\YTVB�DWDN\�B�T8r=DW<a\YUK³�<�@�I�&�&�Æ¢_=@�:=\A<�_=@SDK^�\!k¤¡N_=<!RY<sUK\]B¬>AR�B�^�<!@�ɤ>�_�@S:=LS_ f <�>$`b<!<�O^zB}>%B]á�:zBZDKUW>$q�B�O�^sá�:zB�OM>�Up>$qSkJ¡N_�UK\;:=O�UKá�:=<�^=BZ>%B�\Y<�>iF�@ST f UWO=<!\[RA<�r�<!BZ>�<�^3@ f \A<�RYvZB}w>AUK@SO=\o@�I�RA<!B�Dpwµ`�@SRYDK^�^�<!F!UW\AUW@SO=\.T]B�^=< f q�>A_=<N_=@S:�\A<!_�@SDK^dcM\Y:=RYv�<�q~T8<�BZ\A:=RY<!\.@�I�>�RY:=\Y>B�O�^Vr#<!RAF�<!r�>AUK@SO�\�@�Id>A_=<�Ie>!c�BZO=^,<�©Pr#<!RYUKT8<!OM>%B�D�^zB}>%Bt@�O]>�RY:=\Y>AUKO=L�B�O=^V>ARA:=\�>$`�@�RY>�_Mqf <!_zB�v|UK@�R!k

¡�@a<�T]r�UKRAUWF�B�DWDWq,>A<!\�>�>A_=<~r=RY<!^=UWF�>�UW@SO=\;@ZIb>A_=<~T]@|^=<�Dµc�¶�<!\�>�UWTVBZ>A<~B,\Yq|\�>�<!TÚ@ZI>A_=RA<�<�<�á�:zBZ>�UW@SO=\�:=\AUWO=Li>�_=<�LS<�O=<!RAB�DKUW³!<!^�T8<�>A_=@P^8@�I�T]@�T]<�O�>A\[� ± ÝsÝ   `5UW>A_�>A_=<�Ie><ª©�r#<!RYUK<�O=F!<�^dc�LSUWIe>A\7LSUWv�<!OdcSB�O=^~>�RY:=\Y>�B�\y>�_=<NDW<�Ie>._zBZO=^�\AUK^�<�vZB�RAUKB f DK<�\!ky×7vPUW^=<!O�F!<5UK\r=RY@�vPUW^=<!^1>�_=BZ>5IhB�RAT8<!RY\�^�@]F�@SOM>�R�BZF�>�`5UW>�_1<!B�F%_�@�>A_=<!R5>�@�DWUKT8UW>�>A_=<�Ie>!c�\A:=LSL�<!\Y>AUKO=L>A_zBZ>1>�_=<¬DKUWT]Up>�<�^Pw$F�@ST]T8UW>AT]<�OM>]T8@|^=<!DiF�@SO=\Y>AUW>A:�>�<�\sB�O¦<!T8r=UKRYUKF!B�DKDpq�UWT]r#@SRY>�B�OM><ª©P>A<!O=\YUK@SO�>�@V>A_=<���<�F%G�<�RAUBZO3T]@|^=<!DÎk5Ò�UWv|UKO=L8F!DW@S\A<�R[>A@,BVr#@SDKUWF!<j\Y>�BZ>�UW@SOsBZF�>�:=B�DKDpqUWO=F!RY<�B�\Y<!\o>A_=<uB�T8@S:=OM>o@�I=>�_�<�Ie>7<ª©Pr�<�RAUK<�O=F!<�^ f q�BJ_=@�:=\A<�_=@SDK^�c�F!@�O=\AUW\Y>�<�OM>.`5UW>�_�>�_=<DW@PF!B�D=r#<!RAF�<!r�>AUK@SO�>�_=BZ>�>�_=<�r�@�DKUKF�<NB�RY<[F�@SRARY:=r�>�k7Ø[@S:=\Y<!_=@�DK^=\�`5UW>A_��=<!DK^�\�`5_=UWF%_V^=@O=@Z> f @�RA^=<�RiF!@ST8T]@�O=DWqa:=\Y<!^EIQ@P@�>ArzBZ>A_=\;<�©Pr#<!RYUK<!O�F!<8DK<!\Y\;>�_=<�Ie>�c�LSUpvS<�IQ<�`�<�RiLSUWIe>A\!cB�O�^¬_=B�v�<VB,L�RA<�B}>�<!RjDW<�vS<�D7@�I�>�RY:=\Y>�UKOs>A_=<!UWR;IQ<!DWDK@�`Õv|UKDKDKB�LS<�RA\!kt¡N_�:=\jr�<�@Sr=DK<�`5_�@@�`5O1�z<!DW^=\N`5_=UKF%_�B�RA<jT8@SRA<i^�UW�8F!:=Dp>N>�@�\Y>A<�B�DdIQRY@ST²B�RY<i^=@S: f DWq?RY<�`�B�RA^=<�^dk�¡N_=<�qF!B�O�L�UWvS<;IQ<�`�<�R�>AR�B�O�\YIQ<!RY\ f @�>A_�UWO?>�_=<iIQ@SRYTÖ@�I�>�_=<�Ie>[B�O=^aUKO?>�_=<iIQ@SRYTÖ@�IyLSUpIe>�\u>�@>A_=<!UWRuIQ<!DKDW@�`¦v|UWDKDBZLS<!RY\!k

Ø[@�:=\A<�_=@SDK^�\u`5_=UKF%_?DWUWvS<[UKOV>A_=<;\AB�T]<[vPUWDKDKB�LS<N`5UW>A_?T]@SRY<J@�I�>A_=<!UWR�F�DK@S\Y<JIhB�T8UKDWqT8<!T f <!RY\�LSUWv�<aIQ<�`�<�RVLSUpIe>�\!k�¡N_=UK\8F!@SOM>AR�B�^=UWF�>A\8>A_=<�r#<!RYF!<�r�>�UW@SO�UWO�>A_=<�<ª©PUK\Y>AUKO=Lé \A@|F!UKB�D�F!B�r=UW>�B�Dµ§�DWUW>�<�R�BZ>A:=RA<�>�_zB}>NRA<�DBZ>AUWvS<�\NLSUWv�<;<�BZF%_a@Z>�_=<�RNT]@SRY<;LSUpIe>�\b>A_zB�O?@�>A_=<!R

Page 5: 9= . >@?A . B C D1 E › files › docs › colloqpapers › w05 › Sc… · 0 (* %-$#+1 $3245$768&3 9:;&< # 9=" . >@?A . B C" D1 E FHGJILKMGON5PRQLSTPRQ UMSVK W;XZY\[^]`_Vacbd_eY\fZahgjilknmpo_eY\]

���������������� !���#"$ %� Þ

_=@�:=\A<�_=@SDK^�\!k¨ê,x.:�>�O=B�T�\Y>�BZ>�<�\N>�_zBZ>�ëYUKO?F�@ST]T�:=O=UW>AUK<�\�`5_=<!RY<jr�<�@Sr=DK<JF�B�O f <iF�@SOPw�z^�<!OM>�>�_zBZ>o>�RA:�\Y>�UWO=Li`5UKDWD f <NRA<�á|:�UW>�<�^dc�O=@�>�<ª©�r�DK@SUp>�<!^�cS<�©PF%_zB�O�LS<[UW\7T8@SRA<uDWUKGZ<!DWq�>�@<�O=\A:=<ZkÜì¬�hx.:�>�OzBZT ����� Æ�c#rzB�LS< �Ìí &   Ø[@�`b<�vS<�R!cd>A_=<!\Y<~RA<!\Y:=DW>A\;B�RY<�UWO3B�F!F�@SRA^�`5UW>�_>A_=<~r=RA<�^=UKF�>�UW@SO=\;@�I�>A_=<~DKUWT]Up>�<!^|w$F!@�T]T8UW>AT8<�OM>5T]@|^=<!D�UWI�IhB�T8UKDpq1T]<�T f <!RA\;B�RA<~<�Upw>A_=<!RbT]@SRY<�>ARA:=\�>$`�@�RY>�_Mq]`5_=<!O1B�F�>�UWO=Lt`5Up>�_V@�O=<;B�O�@�>�_=<�R�@SRbUWI�>�_=<�qVT8@SO=Up>�@SR�<�BZF%_@�>A_=<!R�§Ü\u�=<!DK^�\NT]@SRY<�k.¶$O=\�>�RY:=T]<�OM>�UKO�L�IQ@�RuF!RY@Sr1F%_=@SUKF�<jB�O=^1F!@�O�>ARA@SDWDKUWO=LtIQ@SRu`b<�BZDW>�_<�É�<�F�>�\�¶��=O=^�>A_zBZ>�_=@S:�\A<!_�@SDK^=\�`5_=UWF%_�r=DKB�OM>�>�_=<.�=v�<bT8@S\�>*F!@ST8T]@�O=DWq[\Y>A@SDK<�OtF�RA@Sr=\LSUpvS<1\AUWLSO=Up�zF�B�OM>ADWqCT8@SRY<aL�UWIe>�\�>A_zB�OX_=@S:=\Y<!_=@SDW^=\�`5_=UKF%_�^=@gO�@�>�k�¡N_=<!\Y<�RY<!\A:�DW>�\>�B�G�<�Oa>A@SLS<�>A_=<!R�\A_=@�`�>A_=<jUKT8r�@�RY>%BZO=F!<[@�I�UKO�IQ@SRYTVBZD�<�O�IQ@SRAF�<!T8<!OM>5T8<!F%_zB�O�UK\AT8\u>�@DWUKT8UW>�>�_=<�Ie>�k

¡N_=<�RA<!T]B�UWO=^=<!R�@�IJ>�_=UW\]rzBZr�<�R]UW\8@�RALMB�O�UK³!<�^èB�\�IQ@SDWDK@�`5\!k¤Ó|<!F�>AUK@SOè& f RAUK<�î=q^=UW\AF�:=\A\Y<!\�B�OM>�_=RY@Sr#@SDK@SL�UKF�BZD|DWUW>A<!R�B}>�:=RY<�@SO�>A_=<�Ie>�BZO=^�>�_=<�O�DKUK\�>�\y<!UKL�_�>7\Y>$q|DKUW³!<!^�IhBZF�>�\B f @S:�>[>�_=<�Ie>iUKO�RA:=RAB�DoxyB�R�BZLS:zB�qSkj¶$O¬ÓP<�F�>�UW@SO3Æ�c�¶5DB�qa@S:�>;>A_=<�^�q|OzB�T8UKFtDKUWT]Up>�<!^|wF�@ST]T8UW>AT]<�OM>[T8@|^=<!DyB�O=^sF�@ST8rzB�RA<�>�_=<�UKT8r=DKUWF�BZ>AUK@SO=\N@ZI.>�_zBZ>JT]@|^=<�D�`5Up>�_�>A_=@S\A<@�I�B]��<!F%GZ<!RYUB�OET8@P^=<�DµkJÓP<!F�>�UW@SO ° ^=<�\AF�RAU f <!\[>�_=<t\A:=R�vS<�qs^zBZ>%BVB�O=^s<ª©�r#<!RYUKT8<!OM>�\`5_=UWDK<�ÓP<�F�>�UW@SO Þ :=\A<�\V>�_�<�^zBZ>�BE>A@¢>A<!\Y>]>�_=<�UKT8r=DKUWF�BZ>AUK@SO�\�@�I;>A_=<�>$`b@CT8@P^�<!DK\�kÓP<�F�>AUK@SO � F!@SO=F�DK:=^�<!\!k

ï ð,+dñaò�6!ó�ôi0 õ?ö�4N+.÷�ö�øg/82�+¥ùûúsô;ü�+

�[O�>A_=RA@�r�@SDW@SLSUW\Y>�\5^=UW\AF�:=\A\[^=UWÉ�<!RY<!OM>;RY<�B�\Y@SO=\[IQ@�R[\Y_zB�RAUWO=L=c�UKO�F!DK:�^=UKO=L~>AR�B�^=<Zc�BZDW>�RY:PwUW\ATac=RA<�F!UKr�RA@|F!UW>$q�czB�O=^ é >�@SDW<!R�B}>�<!^?>A_=<�Ie>!§Wkb��DK:�RY>�@�OPw�ý�@SO�<!\t� �����MíS  F�DB�UWT]\�>A_zBZ>�^=:=<>A@8^�UKT8UKO=UW\A_=UWO=L�T]B�RALSUWOzB�D�RA<�>A:=RAO�\!c�UW>N`5UWDKDdO=@Z>JBZDW`�B�q|\5rzB�q?>�_�<�@�`5O=<�R[@ZI.B�\Y>�@|F%G@�IJIQ@P@|^�>A@C^=<�IQ<!O=^èUp>,BZLMB�UKO�\Y>]Bg_�:=O=LSR�qÔvPUWDKDKB�LS<�w�TVB}>�<,`5_=@¬`5UKDKD f <�`5UWDKDKUWO=Ls>�@�zL�_�>5_=B�RA^=<�RuIQ@SRu>�_�<;IQ@P@|^dk.nz@|@P^,>�B�G�<�O�:=O�^=<!RN>�_�<iLS:=UK\Y<i@�I*>�@SDW<!RABZ>�<�^1>A_=<�Ie>5T]B�qf <t>�B�G�<�Os>�_=RY@S:=LS_�IQ@�RAF!<Zc�@�RJUW>[T]B�q f <�r=B�\A\YUWvS<�DWqa>�RAB�O=\YIQ<�RARY<!^3UKO�B�O3BZ>Y>�<�T]r�>�>�@B�vS@�UK^]IQ@�RAF!<Zk�ØJB�`5G�<�\�� ����� Æ   r�@SUWOM>�\�@S:�>�>A_zBZ>uBtF!<�OM>�R�BZD�^=UpÉ�<�RA<!O�F!< f <�>$`b<!<�O1RA<!F�Upwr=RY@PF�UW>$q]B�O=^,>A@SDK<�R�BZ>A<!^V>A_=<�Ie>uUK\�>A_zBZ>uUWOV>�_�<JIQ@SRAT8<!R�>�_=@�\A<;`5_=@�B�F�á�:=UKRY<;RA<�\A@S:=RYF!<�\_zB�v�<tF�@SOM>�RA@�D�@Ìv�<!R�þoÿ��~RY<!F!<�UWv�<!\J\Y_zB�RY<!\!cz`5_=UWDK<i:=O�^=<!R5>�_=<jDKBZ>A>A<!Ru>�_�<�q1@SO=Dpq,_zB�v�<F�@SOM>�RA@�Dd@�vS<!R5BZ\NT�:=F%_1@�I*>�_=<JRA<!\Y@S:=RYF!<�B�\u>�_�<�q,F!B�O1^=<�IQ<�O=^dk���DWUK<!L�<�w¹�bUKRA^V­ �bUKRA^� ���S�MíS  IQ@S:�O=^�>�_=BZ>[`5_�<!OEB]\Y<�BV>A:=RY>ADK<j`uB�\[F�B�:�LS_M>;UKO��J:=\�>�RAB�DKUKB�§Ü\5¡�@SRARY<!\jÓ�>�R�BZUW>>A_=@S\A<~_�@S:=\A<�_=@SDW^=\iDKUpvPUWO=LVO�<�B�RJ>A_=< f :�>AF%_=<!RYUKO=L?_�@S:=\A<�_=@SDW^dc�O=@�>iO�<�B�RJ>A_=<~_=@S:�\A<�w_=@�DK^�RA<�\Ar#@SO=\AU f DK<[email protected]!BZ>�F%_�UKO=Lj>�_=<5\Y<�B�>A:=RY>ADK<ZcMRA<!F�<!UpvS<!^]LSRA<!BZ>�<�R�\A_zB�RY<!\�@�I�>A_=<5\A<!B>A:=RY>ADK<�c|\A:�r=r�@�RY>�UWO=L�>A_=<;_Mq|r�@�>A_=<!\YUK\u@ZI�>�@SDW<!R�B}>�<!^]>�_=<�Ie>N@�vS<!R�RA<!F�UKr=RY@PF�UW>$q8@SR�>�R�BZ^=<�k

� Æ�Ç�Ì#â�ÈÊî�ÈÛÑ�â ôJÌ�ë-Ì�ΦɭÒ�ËÍÌ�Ç�Ì\ËÍÌ#ÖZÔ�Ì�ɨÑ�ÔnÕ+ÈÊÑ�Ï\ÚÛÒ�Ö�Ì5Þ'Ç�˾ÈÙÉ­Õ¾ëDÎ�ÉhÔ¦ËhÐ�ÈÊË­ÕÍÇ�Ö�Î�×lÓ�˾ÌÝÉ­Ì�ѦÕÄÉ\á�Ô�Ñ�ÚÊײÕÍÇ�Ìâ�ÈÊî�ÈÛÑ�â-Ô�é�Înâ¦Ë¾ÈÙÏdÒ�ÚèÕÍÒ�ËÍÎ�ÚRÓ�˾ÔZÖZÒMÏpÕÍÉ�Ô¦Ë�ÚÛÈÊî�ÌÝɽÕÍÔZÏÄæ¥ð

Page 6: 9= . >@?A . B C D1 E › files › docs › colloqpapers › w05 › Sc… · 0 (* %-$#+1 $3245$768&3 9:;&< # 9=" . >@?A . B C" D1 E FHGJILKMGON5PRQLSTPRQ UMSVK W;XZY\[^]`_Vacbd_eY\fZahgjilknmpo_eY\]

���������������� !���#"$ %� �

ÓPF�@�>A>[� ���S�MÞS  r=RA@Sr#@S\Y<!\�B�O=@Z>�_=<�R7vPUW<�`X@�I�>�_=<�Ie>�B�\�B�O¢ëY<�vS<!R�q|^zB�q~IQ@SRAT @�I�r�<!B�\�wB�OM>iRY<!\YUK\Y>�B�O=F�<!ì=kj¶$O¬Ý�B�DKB�qP\YUB]>A_=<�v|UKF�>�UWT]\�@�I�>�_=<�Ie>;>�<�O=^=<�^E>A@ f <�>�_=<�r�<!B�\�B�OM>A\`5_=@�_zB�^¬T]<�F%_zB�O=UW³!<�^gUKO�\Y>�<!B�^g@ZIu<!T8r=DW@Ìq|UWO=L1r�@|@SRA<�Rjr�<!B�\�B�OM>A\�>A@�^=@a>�_=<8\�BZT]<`b@SRAG�k�¶$O1Ý�BZDB�q|\AUB�>�_=<J>A_=RA<!BZ>N@�I�>A_=<�Ie>�`uB�\�:=\A<�^1>A@�<!O�\A:=RY<jB�F!@SOM>AUKO�:=<!^1\�>�RA<!B�T@�I�>�R�BZO=\YIQ<�RA\�\Yr�<�F!Up�zF�B�DWDWq3UWO¢>A_=<]IQ@SRYTÚ@�I Ç @ f \!cy`5_�UKDK<8UKO¢xoBZR�B�LS:=B�q¬Up>�<�O=\A:=RY<!\~BF�@SOM>�UKO�:=<�^�\�>�RY<�B�T�@ZIo>�RAB�O=\�IQ<!RA\5UWO1>A_=<iIQ@SRATÐ@�I Ç @ f \!czDW@MB�O=\�czB�O=^aLSUpIe>�\!k

¶N`5UKDWD�O�@Ì` DB�qa@S:�>J\A@ST8<�\�>$qPDWUK³�<!^sIhB�F�>�\iB f @S:�>[>�_=<�Ie>iUKO�RA:=RAB�DoxyB�R�BZLS:zB�q�IQ@�DpwDW@Ì`b<!^ f q?<�v|UW^=<!O=F�<t\Y:=r=r#@SRY>AUKO=L�<!B�F%_�IhB�F�>�k

� k��dÿ��������� ������������������������� �"! ���#�����$����%&��'���(�)�$�+*�� ,-���.����/eÿ0���1eÿ��)������ ��2�����3����4��'��������� �5! �6����� ���7%8��'���(�&9�Ó|TVB�DWD�UW>�<�T]\�UKO=F�DK:=^=<;B�DKD#F!RY@Sr=\!c�F%_=UKF%GZ<!O=\�cr�UKLS\�cdB�O=^�\AT]B�DKD*>�@|@SDK\�\A:�F%_¢BZ\;TVBZF%_=<�>A<!\iB�O�^3_=@P<�\!kjÒ*B�RYLS<�Up>�<!T8\JUWO=F!DW:=^=<F�@�`5\!c�_=@SRY\A<!\�c�B�O=^�DBZRALS<�>�@|@SDK\y\A:=F%_8B�\.F%_zBZUKOPw�\�B�`5\�B�O=^�>AR�B�F�>�@SRY\!k7nz@SRo<�vS<�RYqUp>�<�TÖ\Y>A@SDK<�O?IQRA@ST�>�_=<�T�cz\Y:=RYv�<�qaRA<�\Ar#@SO=^=<�O�>A\�`b<!RY<�BZ\AG�<�^�UpI�>A_=<�q1G�O=<�`Õ@SR\Y:=\Ar#<!F�>�<�^Ô`5_�@s\Y>A@SDK<]UW>�B�O=^CUpIu>�_=<�qg\AB�UK^¢qS<!\�c7>�_=<�q¢`b<!RY<1B�\AGZ<!^ÔB�\Y<�>~@ZIá�:=<�\Y>AUK@SO=\uB f @�:�>u>�_�<J>�_=UW<�I¹k�ßJI*>�_�@S\A<;Up>�<�T]\�IQ@SRb`5_=UWF%_?>�_=<J>A_=UK<�I!§¨\uUW^=<!OM>�Up>$q`�B�\5G�O=@�`5Odc í Ñ~r#<!RAF�<!OM>�@�I�\AT]B�DKDW<!RbUW>�<�T]\b`�<�RA<�\Y>�@�DK<!O f q1B~O=<�UKLS_ f @SRu@SR5BRY<!DKBZ>�UpvS<N`5_=UKDW<[@�O=DWq ��� r#<!RAF�<!OM>N@�IdDB�RYLS<!R�UW>A<!T8\.`�<�RA<;\�>�@SDW<!O f q]BtO�<!UKL�_ f @SR�hB�O=^1O=@SO�< f q1RY<!DB}>�UWv�<!\   k¡N_�<[>�_�<�Ie>u@ZI�DB�RYLS<5UW>A<!T8\bUW\bT8@SRA<�DKUWG�<�DWq�>A@ f <JRA<�r�@�RY>�<�^V>�@�>�_=<JB�:�>A_=@SRAUp>�UW<!\>A_zB�O�>�_=<N>A_=<�Ie>b@�I�\AT]B�DKD=Up>�<�T]\�ko¶�>�T]UWLS_M> f <5^=Up�8F!:=Dp>.>�@�r=RA@�vS<5>�_�<[UW^=<!OM>�Up>$q@ZIJB�>A_=UK<�I[`5_�@¬\�>�<!B�DK\�B f Up>~@�I�F!@�RAOÔ<�v�<!RYqH`b<!<�G�c f :�>�Up>~UK\�DK<!\Y\~^=UW�8F�:=DW>>A@Cr=RY@Ìv�<3>�_=<sUW^=<!OM>AUW>$qX@�Ij>�_=<�>A_=UK<�I�@�I�B f R�BZO=^=<!^¤F�@Ì`�@SRVBCF%_zB�UKO|w$\�B�`jkϤ_�UKDK<[@SO=Dpq]IQ@S:�Rur�<�RAF�<!OM>�@�I�G|O�@Ì`5O?>A_=UK<�vS<!\5@�I�\YTVB�DWD�Up>�<�T]\�`�<�RA<jRA<�r�@SR�>�<�^>A@t>A_=<Jr#@SDKUWF!<Zc �Z° r�<�RAF�<!OM>N@�Id>A_=UK<�vS<�\u@�I�DKB�RALS<�UW>A<!T8\�`b<!RY<;RA<�r�@�RY>�<�^dk�ÓPUm©P>$qMw\YUp©Er#<!RYF!<�O�>�@�Iu>A_=<]G�O=@�`5Og>A_=UK<�vS<�\�@�I�\AT]B�DKD.Up>�<!T8\;`b<!RA<]LSUWv�<!O¢LSUWIe>A\!c�DK<!OM>T8@SO=<�qSc|@SR�_�UKRA<�^ f q]>A_=<Jv|UKF�>�UWT f <�IQ@SRA<J>A_=<[>A_=<�Ie>�`5_=UKDW<[@SO�DWq]Æ � r#<!RYF!<!OM>N@ZI>A_=<8G|O�@Ì`5O¢>�_=UW<�vS<�\�@�I�DB�RYLS<�UW>A<!T8\;`�<�RA<VL�UWvS<�O¢>A_=<!\Y<]>�RAB�O=\�IQ<!RA\�k1��<!F!B�:=\Y<@ZI�>�_=<i^=UpÉ�<�RA<�O=F!<iUWO,T]@Z>�UWvZBZ>AUK@SO�\b:=O�^=<!RYDWq|UKO=L�>A_=<J>A_=<�Ie>5@�I*\YTVBZDKD�B�O=^1DB�RYLS<Up>�<�T]\.¶�`5UKDKD�@SO=DWq�IQ@PF�:=\b@�O8>A_=<�>A_=<�Ie>�@�I�\AT]B�DKDW<!R7Up>�<�T]\�c�B�O=^]>A_=<5`�@SRY^8>A_=<�Ie>UWO3>�_=<8RA<�\Y>t@�I�>A_=<!\Y<]\�>$qPDWUK³�<!^¢IhBZF�>�\tB�O=^¬@�Ib>�_=UW\�r=B�r�<�RjRA<�IQ<�RA\�@SO=Dpqs>�@1>�_=<>A_=<�Ie>5@ZI7\AT]B�DWDK<!RbUW>A<!T8\!k

&|k��dÿ��:�;��$�=<>��?����@���A*B�><>��C��?��<�������D����4E���;�����F9,nz@SR�>$q�wµ>�_=RY<!<�r#<!RAF�<!OM>�@ZI_�@S:=\A<�_=@SDW^=\]_=B�^è\A@�T]<a\AT]B�DKD�UW>�<�TÈ\Y>A@SDK<�OXIQRA@�T >�_=<�TÈUKOX>A_=<arzB�\Y>]qS<!B�R!k¡N_�<JT8<!^=UKB�O8vZB�DW:=<�\Y>�@�DK<!O�cPF�@SO=^=Up>�UK@�OzB�Dz@SO f <�UKO=L�\Y>A@SDK<�OVIQRA@ST `�B�\ � ÑSÑ�cÜÑSÑSѱ :zB�RAB�O=UW<!\b�ÎB�RY@S:=O=^(G �Ìí�  `5_�UKF%_�UW\�B[@SO=<�r#<!RYF!<!OM>oDK@S\Y\y@�I�T]<�^=UBZO�_�@S:=\A<�_=@SDW^

Page 7: 9= . >@?A . B C D1 E › files › docs › colloqpapers › w05 › Sc… · 0 (* %-$#+1 $3245$768&3 9:;&< # 9=" . >@?A . B C" D1 E FHGJILKMGON5PRQLSTPRQ UMSVK W;XZY\[^]`_Vacbd_eY\fZahgjilknmpo_eY\]

���������������� !���#"$ %� í

UWO=F!@�T]<ZkIHÆPkKJ/��<�����(�ML�C�}þÙþoÿ��#�$�N��'��������� �O�;�.��PQÿ����#9Nnz@SRY>$qMw�\A<�v�<!O3r#<!RYF!<!OM>J@�Io>A_=@S\A<`5_�@8<ª©Pr�<�RAUK<�O=F!<�^�>A_=<�Ie>5G�O=<�`Õ@SRN\A:�\Ar#<!F�>A<!^a`5_=@~>�_=<i>�_�UK<�I*`�B�\�@�IyBZ>5DK<!B�\Y>@�O=<j@�Iy>A_=<jUW>A<!T8\u\Y>A@SDK<�OaIQRY@STÐ>A_=<!T�UWO?>�_=<jrzB�\�>5qS<�BZR!kIQ

° k��dÿ ���� ��>�R�.�><>���� ��#�$�>�>�S*��$��TU��������D3�;�.��Veÿ ���� W��� �KQÿ0���@* �X�eÿ�����ÿ��TY�W�%ÿ���6*�&9Ó|<�vS<�OM>$q�r#<!RYF!<!OM>o@�I�>A_=<�v|UWF�>�UWT]\d`5_�@J\A:�\Ar#<!F�>A<!^�B�\Ar#<!F!Up�zF�r�<�RAr#<�>�RABZ>�@�R�\AB�UK^>A_=<[>A_=UK<�I*F!@ST8T8UW>A>A<!^�>�_=<JF!RAUWT]< f <!F�BZ:=\A<i@�Idr�@�vS<�RY>$q�c=>$`�@~r#<!RYF!<!OM> f <!F!B�:=\Y<@ZIzRA<�vS<!O�LS<NB�O=^tIQ@S:=R�r�<�RAF!<�OM> f <�F�B�:�\A<u@�I=<!OMv�qSk.¡u`b<!OM>$qMw��=v�<�r#<!RYF!<�O�>.B�^=^=<�^UWO,>�_=<�UKR5@�`5O�@�r�>�UW@SO?@�Iy<!UW>A_=<!R5_zB f UW>N@�R é O=@�\A_=B�T]<Z§��'�����Z ������\[T���� ]W�   kI^

Þ kKJ/��<�����(�S* �_�C���>�'E���;+Qÿ ���� ��>�?��_eÿ��`E������<>�1��-EATU���$�%ÿXQÿ����aEzÿ DW����<�������D�9ß;O=Dpq ��° r#<!RAF�<!OM>b@�I�_�@S:=\A<�_=@SDW^=\�`5_�UKF%_8\A:=\Yr�<�F�>�<�^V>�_�<[UW^=<!OM>�Up>$q�@�I�>�_=<N>A_=UK<�Iq�<!DWDK<!^CBZ>~_=UWT BZO=^H@SO=Dpq¢IQ@S:�R�r#<!RAF�<!OM>�RA<�r�@�RY>�<�^Ô_=UKTÚ>�@�>�_=<1B�:P>�_=@SRYUW>AUK<!\�kØ�@S:=\Y<!_=@SDW^=\5`�<�RA<~B�\YG�<�^s`5_�q1>A_=<�q�^=UK^aO=@�>[RA<�r�@�RY>JB8>�_�UK<�Io>�@]>A_=<tB�:�>�_�@SR�wUp>�UW<!\!kC�[UKO�<ar#<!RYF!<�O�>8`b<!RA<aO=@�>�RY<!r#@SRY>A<!^ f <�F�B�:�\A<a@�I[IQ<!B�R�@�I[RA<!r�RAUK\AB�Dµc�ÆSÑr#<!RYF!<�O�>J`�<�RA<~O=@�>JRA<�r�@SR�>�<�^ f <�F�B�:=\Y<�>�_=<tvPUWF�>AUKT²\�BZUK^sRY<!r#@SRY>AUKO=LV>A_=<t>A_=<�Ie>`b@S:=DW^=Od§ >�^�@3B�OMq¬LS@P@|^dc*>�_=<�RA<V`�B�\tO=@sr=DKB�F!<�>�@�RA<!r#@SR�>�UW>!cy@�RtUp>t`�B�\t>A@P@^�UW�8F!:=Dp>�B�O=^ ÞSí r#<!RYF!<�O�>8`b<!RA<1O=@Z>�RA<!r#@SR�>�<!^ f <!F!B�:=\A<?>A_=<?vPUWF�>AUKT ^=UK^=O�§¨>IQ<�<!Dd>A_=<jF!RAUWT]<[`uB�\�\A<�RAUW@S:=\!k

� kKJ/�6�����6���C<>�?ÿ���� E��_�����?��(eÿ��:�;�9£Ï¤_=<!OÙB¬F!RY@SrèUK\8r=DKB�OM>�<!^�F!DK@�\A<!R8>�@¢_=@ST8<�c@�R[@SO�B]r=DW@�>5`5_=UKF%_�UK\�O=@�>[DK@|F�BZ>A<!^�B�DK@SO�LVB8TVB Ç @�R�IQ@|@�>�r=BZ>�_dc=>A_=<!RY<�UW\[DW<!\A\>A_=<�Ie>!ko¡yB f DW< � F!@�T]rzBZRA<!\yF!RY@Sr=\.r=DKB�OM>�<!^�@SO~r=DK@Z>�\y`5_�UKF%_~O=@iO=@�OPw$_=@�:=\A<�_=@SDK^T8<!T f <�R�`uBZDKG�\*rzB�\Y>yB�O�^�>A_=@S\A<�r=DKB�OM>�<�^�@�Otr=DW@�>�\�`5_=UKF%_�@SO=<�@SR�T8@SRA<.r#<!@�r=DK<`�B�DWG3rzB�\Y>tr#<!Rj`�<�<!G�k���@�>�<�>�_=BZ>t>A_=<,BZT]@S:�O�>�@�I�>�_=<�Ie>�UW\tO=@Z>�O=<�LSDKUWLSU f DK<�kÝa@SRA<uUW\7\Y>A@SDK<�O�IQRA@ST®�z<�DK^=\o`5_�UKF%_�T]@�RA<�r#<!@�r=DK<�`�B�DWGtrzBZ\Y>�cS>A_=@S:=L�_�IQ@SR7@SO=Dpq>$`b@�@�I�>�_=<jF!RY@Sr=\NUW\u>�_=<j^=UpÉ�<�RA<!O�F!<i\AUWLSO=Up�zF�B�OM>!k.¶�IoT]B�OMq,r#<!@Sr�DK<;`�B�DKG]rzB�\Y>BV�=<!DK^s>A_=<�q3B�DKD�G�O=@�`à`5_zBZ>jUW\;r=DKB�OM>�<!^3>A_=<!RY<�B�O=^3`5_=<!OEUp>;`5UKDWD f <~RA<!B�^�q>A@�_zBZRYvS<�\Y>!czB�O=^8>�_=<�qVF!B�O,<�BZ\AUKDpq�\Y>AUKF%G8B f Up>�@ZI�r=RA@|^=:=F�<;UKO8>�_=<�UKR�r�@|F%G�<�>NB�\>A_=<�q?`�B�DWG,rzB�\�>�k�� \YUKT8UKDKB�RuB�O=B�DWq|\AUW\N\A_=@�`5\�>�_zBZ>�F�RA@Sr=\[B�RY<�T8@SRY<iDKUKGZ<!DpqV>�@f <i\Y>A@SDK<�Oa`5_�<!O�>A_=<�q?B�RA<jr=DKB�OM>�<!^1@SOar=DW@�>�\uIQ:=R�>�_=<�RuIQRA@STÖ_=@ST8<�k

b ÆVÔ�ÕÍÎnÚ�ÕÍÇ�ÌdécÕ,ÈÙÉ.Õ½ôJÔrÓ¥Ì\ËÄÏdÌ�Ñ�Õ Ô�é+ë-Ì�ÖZÈÙÎnÑ�Ç�Ô�Ò�ɾÌ\Ç�Ô�ÚÙÖBÈÛÑMÏdÔ�ë-̦áeô�Ç�ÈÛÚÊÌ;Õ¾Ç�Ì\écÕLÔ�é'ɾë-Î�ÚÛÚ©ÈÛÕ¾Ì�ë-É ÈÙÉÔ�Ñ�ÌLÓ¥Ì\ËÄÏdÌ�ѦÕÝðc ú4ÔZÏ\Î�Ú¨ÈÛÑ�é^Ô�ËÍë-Î�Ñ�ÕÍÉ,ÏdÚÙÎnÈÊë±ÕÍÇ�Î`Õ;Ì\î�Ì�Ñ�ÈÛé�Õ¾Ç�Ì�×�ÖZÔBÑ�ÔnÕlæ�Ñ�Ô`ôø̹¸�Î�ÏdÕ¾ÚÊפô�Ç�ÔBÉ­Õ¾Ô�ÚÊÌ-é^ËÍÔ�ë±ÕÍÇ�Ì\ëÕ¾Ç�ÎnÕ�Õ¾Ç�Ì�×rÏ\Î�ѹÔnécÕ¾Ì�ѹÑ�ÎnËÍ˾Ô`ô�ÈÛÕ.ÖZÔ`ô�ÑÕ¾ÔDÔ¦Ñ�ÌLÔnéVÕ½ôJÔ-Ô�Ë�ÕÍÇ�˾Ì�Ì,ÖZÈedRÌ\ËÍÌ\Ñ�Õ#Ç�Ô¦Ò�ɾÌ\Ç�Ô¦ÚÊÖ�É�ðf.g Ñ�ÌLë�ÈÊâ�Ç�ÕJÕ¾Ç�ÈÊÑ�ærÕ¾Ç�ÎnÕ�Ì�î�Ì�Ñrë-Ô�ËÍÌ5î�ÈÙÏpÕÍÈÛëDÉ�ôJÔ�Ò�ÚÙÖ¯Ç�Î�î¦Ì ÏÄÇ�ԦɾÌ\Ñ`h Ñ�ÔDÉ­ÇMÎnë-Ì�ö�ÈÛé�ÈÛÕ�Ç�Î�ÖrÐMÌ�Ì\ÑÎnÑHÔ�ÓZÕÍÈÛÔ¦ÑÔ¦ÑHÕ¾Ç�Ì,ÚÊÈÊÉ­Õ�ð

Page 8: 9= . >@?A . B C D1 E › files › docs › colloqpapers › w05 › Sc… · 0 (* %-$#+1 $3245$768&3 9:;&< # 9=" . >@?A . B C" D1 E FHGJILKMGON5PRQLSTPRQ UMSVK W;XZY\[^]`_Vacbd_eY\fZahgjilknmpo_eY\]

���������������� !���#"$ %� �

¡yB f DW< � ç(iKjlkXmon prqts?ulv:wxnYpyn z|{X}onYqt}�~:n��S�lq��R��~:��}l����{X{W�ln���nU~�u�n �7����(n nY�=��zluK��k�q|jlz|{+��{�q|~:n z��bÓ|>�B�O=^zBZRA^�<!RARY@SRA\*UWO�r=B�RA<�O�>A_=<!\YUK\�c�O�:=T f <!R*@�IP@ f \Y<!R�wvZBZ>AUK@SO=\�UKO f RAB�F%G�<�>�\!k�¡N_=<[F!@SDW:=T]O�\b@SO]>�_=<[DK<�Ie>�B�RY<�>A_=<[>A@�>%B�D�á�:zB�OM>AUW>$q8@�I�@S:P>�r=:�>\�>�@SDW<!O�IQRY@ST²�z<!DW^=\Jr=B�\Y>[`5_=UKF%_sO�@Zw$@SO�<t`�B�DKG�\>�}r�<�@Sr=DK<�`uBZDKG?UKOa>�_=<�<!OM>�UWRA<�\A:=R�vS<�q^=Upv|UK^=<�^ f q�>A_=<N>�@�>�B�D=á�:zB�OM>AUW>$q�@�I�F!RY@Sr]@�:�>�r=:P>�LSRA@�`5O8@SO8>A_=@S\Y<�\AB�T8<5�=<!DK^�\!k7¡N_=<F�@SDK:=T8O=\�@SO�>A_=<�RYUKLS_M>oB�RA<�>�_=<�B�v�<!RAB�LS<ur#<!RYF!<!OM>.\�>�@SDW<!O�IQRY@ST B�DKDM_�@S:=\A<�_=@SDW^=\7UKO�>�_=<\Y:=RYv�<�qSkR�N�ÌwNUW\[>�_�<~\AUKL�Os@�I.>�_�<~^=UWÉ�<!RY<!O=F�<~UKOsr#<!RYF!<!OM>�B�LS<!\i\�>�@SDW<!OdcdB�O=^r�iT]<!B�O=\>A_=<j^=UWÉ�<!RY<!O=F�<�UW\N\AUWLSO=UW�=F�B�OM>�BZ>N>A_=< � Ñ8�ÐDW<�vS<�D�UKOaB~@SO=<ªw�>%BZUKDK<�^1��w�>A<!\Y>!k

��á|:=B�OM>�UW>$q,\Y>�@�DK<!O1UWOa\Y:=RYv�<�q �Ðá�:zB�OM>�Up>$q?\Y>A@SDK<�O1IQ@�RN<�B�F%_�_=@S:=\Y<!_=@SDW^� RA@�r Ñ~r#<!@Sr�DK< � @SRNT8@SRA<ir#<!@�r=DK< Ñ�r#<!@�r=DK< � @SRNT8@SRA<ir#<!@Sr�DK<�uBZOzB�OzB � k íSÞ � ° k &�Ñ8� &Pk íZ� � Æ�kÜÆ � �

� �µ&|k �Ìí�  � � k � Ñ  � ��� � ÆM& �

«5<!^ � @SRAO ÑPk �Ìí � � kÜÑM&�� Ñ�k °Mí � Ñ�k ��° �� �ÎÑPk °�í�  �hÑ�k �SíS 

� ÞZ°�� � �S�ÌÞy�Ϥ_�UW>�< � @�RAO ÑPk ÑSÑ�� &PkÜÆ ° � Ñ�k Ñ�Ñ8� � k °M� �

�`� �ÎÑPk ÑSÑ   �hÑ�k í|�Ì � °�Þ� � � Ñ °��

nzRA<�\A_ � @SRAO ÑPk ÞSí � � k �S� � &Pk &�&�� Æ�k Þ &��� � � k �S�S  � � k °MÞS 

� ÞP�&� � � &�Æ �Ý�<�DK@SO ÑPk ÑSÑ�� &Pk ÞSí � Ñ�k Ñ�Ñ8� &Pk °�Þ �� �ÎÑPk ÑSÑ   � � k ÞZ�M 

� � & � � &S& �ÏgBZ>�<�RAT8<!DW@SO ÑPk Æ � � � Ñ�k � Æ8� Ñ�k � Æ8� � k &S&��

� � �ÎÑPk � &   � ° k �P�Ì � &�Ñ � � & ���

Û�:=F�F�B ÑPk ÞP� � Ñ�k ÞSí � � k & � � � kÜÑ � ��M��w �ÎÑPk í��S  �hÑ�k ÆS&  

� � Æ � � ��° Ñ �

Page 9: 9= . >@?A . B C D1 E › files › docs › colloqpapers › w05 › Sc… · 0 (* %-$#+1 $3245$768&3 9:;&< # 9=" . >@?A . B C" D1 E FHGJILKMGON5PRQLSTPRQ UMSVK W;XZY\[^]`_Vacbd_eY\fZahgjilknmpo_eY\]

���������������� !���#"$ %� �

í k`�M�T8�W�%ÿ���6*�3���� ���������0�:�����.��'�_eÿ ���� W��� �?ÿ��T8�W�%ÿ���6*����K�� ����*"������� ����'��$����;�.��#9ÔØ[@S:�\A<!_�@SDK^=\~`b<!RY<aL�UWvS<�O�B3DWUK\Y>�@�I�@Sr�>�UW@SO=\~@�IJB�F�>�UK@�O=\�>�_=<�qHT8UKLS_M>:�O=^=<!R�>%B�GZ<s>�@ÔB�vS@�UK^è>�_�<�Ie>?\Y:=F%_¦B�\,T8@SO=UW>A@SRAUWO=LE>�_=<�UKRV�z<�DK^=\,BZ>?O=UWLS_M>,@SRr�DB�OM>�UWO=L�<!B�\AUWDWq]\Y>�<!B�DB f DK<[F!RA@�r=\uIQ:=RY>A_=<!RuIQRY@STÐIQ@|@�>ArzBZ>�_�\!k�ß;O=<i@SrP>�UK@�O,`uB�\ë�¶�I�q�@S:1G�O=@�`�\Y@ST]<�@SO=<;UW\NB�>�_�UK<�I¹cP^=@�qS@�:aL�UWvS<J_=UKT�LSUWIe>A\�>�@�B�v�@SUK^1LS<�>A>AUKO=L\�>�@SDW<!O?IQRA@�T1��ì�nz@SRY>$qMwµ>$`�@8r�<�RAF�<!OM>J@ZIo_=@�:=\A<�_=@SDK^�\[BZO=\Y`b<!RY<!^�q�<!\!k¶$O~L�<!O=<�R�B�DÎc�v|UKF�>AUKT8\7B�RY<u@SO�IQRYUK<!O�^=DWqj>�<�RAT8\o`5UW>A_�>�_=UW<�v�<!\!k.ÓPUp©|>$qMw$\YUp©�r�<�RAF!<�OM>@ZI�>�_�<J\A:�\Ar#<!F�>A<!^,>A_=UK<�vS<!\�RA<!F�<!UpvS<!^VLSUWIe>A\!cM`�@�RAG�c�@SR�DK@SB�O=\�IQRA@ST >A_=<!UWR�v|UWF�>�UWTf <�IQ@�RA<V>A_=<,>�_=<�Ie>�c.`5_=UWDK< � &�r#<!RYF!<�O�>�`b<!RY<1IQRY@ST >�_=<?\AB�T]<]vPUWDKDKB�LS<]B�\�>�_=<v|UWF�>�UWT�k1¶$OgIhBZF�>�cy>�_=<8>�_=UW<�vS<�\~B�RY<V@�Ie>A<!OCF�DK@S\Y<VO=<�UKLS_ f @SRA\,� ÞZ° r#<!RYF!<�O�>   @SRRY<!DKBZ>�UpvS<!\�� ��� r#<!RYF!<�O�>   @�I.>�_�<�v|UKF�>AUKTakjÓP@ST8<�_�@S:=\A<�_=@SDW^=\iF!@SOM>AUKO�:=<�LSUpv|UKO=L>AR�B�O�\YIQ<!RY\;>�@?>�_�UK<�v�<!\j<�v�<!O¢BZIe>�<�R;>�_=<�qEB�RY<�\Y>A@SDK<�OEIQRY@STac�`5_=UKDW<�@�>A_=<!RY\i\Y>�@�r>AR�B�O�\YIQ<!RY\iBZIe>A<!RJ>A_=<�qsB�RA<t\Y>�@�DK<!OsIQRY@STak;¡N_=<~\A:�RYvS<�q3B�\YG�<�^ÊëA9;UW^�q�@S: � LSUpvS<L�UWIe>�\�>�@�>A_=<J>A_=UK<�I��Z_=UKRY<[_�UKT��ZDK<�O=^V_=UWT�T]@SO�<�q � f <�IQ@SRY<J>�_�<J>�_=<�Ie>;��B}Ie>�<!R�>�_=<>A_=<�Ie>>��ì~¡u`�<�O�>$qMw�\A<�v�<!Osr#<!RYF!<�O�>5@ZI*_=@S:=\Y<!_=@SDW^=\NF!@�O�>AUKO�:=<iLSUpv|UKO=Lt\A@ST8<J>$q|r�<@ZI�>AR�B�O�\YIQ<!RN>A@�>A_=<i>�_=UW<�IyBZIe>A<!Ru>�_�<j>A_=<�Ie>�BZO=^ ÞZ° r�<�RAF!<�OM>J\�>�@Sr1LSUpvPUWO=L~\A@�T]<>$q|r#<j@�Iy>AR�B�O�\YIQ<!RN>A@�>A_=<i>�_=UW<�IoBZIe>�<�RN>�_=<i>�_�<�Ie>�k

� k4�;�� ��>����������* �><��$������0�����>�)*��$��'���'��*M*�Tt����4eÿ���E��'����������7���\Qÿ��:�;�97�JO=@�>A_=<!R@�r�>�UW@SO�@�O�>�_=<tDKUW\Y>�@�I7>A_=UKO=L�\;B]_�@S:=\A<�_=@SDW^sF!@S:�DK^�^�@V>�@]r=RA<�vS<!OM>i>A_=<�Ie>[`uB�\>A@�B�v�@SUK^8r=DBZO�>AUKO=LjT8@SRA<5<!B�\AUWDWq~\�>�<�BZDB f DW<NF!RY@Sr=\�UWO�r=DK@�>A\�B�^ Ç @SUWO=UKO=Ljr#@Sr=:=DKB�RIQ@|@�>ArzBZ>�_�\!kynoUWIe>$qMw$\YUp©�r#<!RYF!<!OM>�@�I=_=@S:=\Y<!_=@SDW^=\7F�DB�UWT]<�^�>A@;^=@;\Y@=ko¡N_=<�\A:=R�vS<�qBZDK\A@�BZ\AG�<�^�<!B�F%_�_=@�:=\A<�_=@SDK^aUWI*>A_=<!RY<�`�B�\�B~F!RA@�ra>A_=<�q?`b@S:=DW^a_=B�v�<�`�B�OM>�<�^>A@Xr�DB�OM>�c f :�>a^=UK^�Od§¨> f <!F!B�:=\A<¢@�I�IQ<!B�R1@�I�>A_=<�Ie>!k�nz@SR�>$q�wµ>$`�@�r#<!RAF�<!OM>s@ZIRY<!\Yr�@SO�^=<!OM>�\�\�B�UW^8>A_=<!RY<[`�B�\uB�F!RA@�r]>�_�<�q�`�<�RA<[^=UK\YF!@S:=RAB�LS<�^]IQRA@�Tûr=DB�OM>AUKO=LBZO=^]<�UKLS_M>�r#<!RYF!<!OM>�\�B�UW^�>A_=<!RY<�`�B�\bB�O8B�O=UWTVB�DP>�_=<�q�`�<�RA<[^=UK\YF!@S:=RAB�LS<�^8IQRY@STRAB�UK\YUKO=L f <!F!B�:=\Y<�@ZIoIQ<�BZRN@�Iy>A_=<�Ie>!k

¡N_=<�\A<,\�>$qPDWUK³�<!^¢IhBZF�>�\�F�BZOCLSUWv�<�:=\�Ba\AUKT8r=DW<~F%_zB�R�BZF�>�<�RAUW³�BZ>AUK@SO¬@�INRY:=R�B�D7>A_=<�Ie>UWO�xyB�R�BZLS:zB�qSk�Ø[@S:=\Y<!_=@�DK^=\�F!DKB�UKT�>�@8LSUWv�<j>AR�B�O�\YIQ<!RY\~�Q@�IoF�@SRAO�c#F%_�UKF%G�<�Odc�q|:=F�F�B   >�@>A_=@S\A<1_=@�:=\A<�_=@SDK^�\�`5_�@¬>A_=<�qHG�O=@�`�BZRA<?O=@�>~>ARA:=\�>$`�@�RY>�_Mq�kX�[^=^=UW>AUK@SO=B�DKDpqSco>A_=<!\Y<_=@�:=\A<�_=@SDK^�\uB�RY<JUKT8r=DWUKF!Up>�Dpq�BZDKDK@�`b<!^8>�@�\�>�<!B�DdB f B�\AUWF;B�T8@S:=OM>bUKO8@SRA^�<!Rb>A@�r=RY<�vS<�OM>>A_=<!T�IQRA@ST²\�>�<!B�DKUWO=LVDKB�RALS<�RJBZT]@S:�O�>A\!k[Ø[@S:�\A<!_�@SDK^=\;B�RA<t\�B�O=F�>�UW@SO=<!^�UWI7>A_=<�q�\Y>A<�B�DT8@SRA<;>A_zB�O1UK\5BZF!F!<�r�>%B f DK< f q f <�UKO=L�F�:�>�@�ÉsIQRA@�TÐIQ:�>A:=RA<i>�RAB�O=\�IQ<!RA\�k

Page 10: 9= . >@?A . B C D1 E › files › docs › colloqpapers › w05 › Sc… · 0 (* %-$#+1 $3245$768&3 9:;&< # 9=" . >@?A . B C" D1 E FHGJILKMGON5PRQLSTPRQ UMSVK W;XZY\[^]`_Vacbd_eY\fZahgjilknmpo_eY\]

���������������� !���#"$ %� � Ñ

�   ña)söR¡ 6!4 ¢H6�¡ 6�+oôi0"£¥¤�/#¡ ¡ 6�+o¡ ôi),+§¦ /10sôiò

¨)©«ª ¬�­/®�¯\°O±²¯�³�´ ¯�µ`¶l·¡N_=<E^=<�\AF�RAUKrP>�UK@�O¤B f @�v�<¬UW\?UKO¤B�F�F!@SRY^¦`5Up>�_¤BHT8@P^=<�D;@�I�DKUWT]Up>�<�^Pw$F�@ST]T8UW>AT]<�OM>�k¡N_=<1IhB�RYT]<�R8L�UWvS<�\8>$`b@¢>$q|r#<!\]@�IJ>AR�B�O=\�IQ<!RY\]>�@E>�_�<a>A_=UK<�I¹ç�LSUpIe>�\�B�O�^�r=RY<!\AF�RAU f <�^>A_=<�Ie>!k�¡N_=<�>�_=UW<�I7F!B�O=O=@Z>[F�@ST8T]Up>u>�@]\Y>�<!B�D*@SO=Dpq,>�_=<�r=RY<!\AF�RAU f <�^�á�:zB�OM>�Up>$qSku¶�Iy>�_=<>A_=UK<�I5^=@P<�\�\Y>A<�B�DbT]@�RA<]>A_zB�OH_=<VUK\�r=RY<!\YF!RAU f <�^C>�@3\�>�<�BZDµco>A_=<VIhB�RYT]<�Rt`5UKDWD�G|O�@Ì`jcB�O�^¤`5UWDKD;r�:=O=UK\Y_¤_=UKT f q¤F�:�>A>AUKO=LÔ_=UWT @�É�IQRA@ST IQ:�>�:=RY<3>�R�BZO=\YIQ<�RA\¢� f @�>�_¦LSUpIe>�\B�O�^�r=RY<!\AF�RAU f <�^�>�_=<�Ie>   kI¸�¡N_=UK\[LMB�T8<�UW\[RY<!r#<�BZ>A<!^�IQ@�RA<�v�<!R�k�¡N_�<�IQ@SDKDW@�`5UKO=L~T8@P^�<!DUW\�\AUWT]UWDB�Ri>A@3T]@|^=<!DW\�:=\Y<!^ f qHÒ�UKL�@SOC<�>8BZDµk��µ&�ÑSÑS&   Íi@|F%_=<!RYDB�GZ@�>%BH� ���S�S�S  c.B�O�^ÍiDK<�>�³�<!R5­ Ï¢RAUWLS_M>��µ&�Ñ�ÑSÑ   k

��<�IQ@SRA<?<!B�F%_Xr#<!RYUK@|^g>�_�<!RA<1UW\�:=O=F�<!RY>�B�UKOM>$qÔBZ\�>�@s`5_zBZ>~>A_=<?F!@�\Y>8@�I�\Y>A<�B�DWUKO=L`5UWDKD f <�UKOa>�_zB}>Jr#<!RYUK@|^dk�n�@�R�<ª©�B�T]r�DK<�c�B]IhB�RYT]<�R5TVB�q f <�_=@ST8<�<!BZ>�UWO=L8_=UK\[T]UW^PwT8@SRAO�UKO=L f RA<!B�GMIhB�\Y>[`5_=<!O¬B8r�@�>A<!OM>�UKB�D�>�_=UW<�I.`�B�DKG�\[rzB�\Y>J_=UK\��z<!DW^dk�¶�I.>�_zBZ>JUK\5>�_=<F!B�\A<Zc#>A_=<�>A_=UK<�I7F!B�O�T�:�F%_�T8@SRA<j<�BZ\AUKDpq?r=UWF%G1B8IQ<�`�`uBZ>A<!RYT]<�DK@SO=\�B�\�_=<j`uBZDKG�\ f q\YUKO=F�<?O=@ f @P^�q¢UK\t>�_=<�RA<,>�@3\Y<!<1_=UWT�k¢ß;OC>�_=<?@Z>�_=<�R~_zB�O=^dc.>A_=<,IhB�RAT8<!RtTVB�q f <`b@SRAG�UWO=LVUWOa>A_=<��=<!DK^1`5_=<�O�>�_=<tr�@Z>�<!OM>AUB�Dd>A_=UK<�Io`�B�DKG�\�rzB�\Y>!c�BZO=^�>A_=<!O�UW>5`5UKDWD f <á�:=Up>�<u^=Up�8F!:=Dp>o>�@i\�>�<!B�Dµky¡N_=<NIhB�RAT8<!RyF�B�O�LSUpvS<uLSUpIe>�\�cZ`5_=UWF%_8^�@iO=@�>�^=<�r�<�O=^�@SO�>�_=<\�>%BZ>A<;@�I�OzBZ>A:=RA<8�QUµk¨<�kpc�^=@~O=@Z>N^=<!r#<!O�^a@�Oa_�@Ì`¦<!B�\Yq?Up>uUW\�>�@�\�>�<!B�DdUKO,>A_zBZ>Nr#<!RYUK@|^  B�O�^HB�RA<8O=@�>�F!@S\�>�Dpq¬IQ@�R�>A_=<]>A_=UK<�I¹c7B�O=^g_=<VF!B�OCr=RY<!\AF�RAU f <8>�_=<�Ie>�co`5_=UWF%_CUK\�\Y>�BZ>�<^=<�r�<�O=^=<�O�>,�h^�<!r#<!O=^=UWO=L1@SOE_=@�` <!B�\Yq3Up>jUK\J>A@1\Y>�<!B�D.UKOs>A_zBZ>jr#<!RYUK@|^   B�O=^¬F!@�\Y>�DpqIQ@SR.>A_=<[>A_=UK<�I�B�\�_=<JT�:=\Y>�`uBZUW>�IQ@SR.>�_=<[T]@ST8<!OM>�`5_=<�O,O=@�@�O=<[UW\�BZRA@S:=O�^V@SR�\AO�<�B�G@S:P>5UKO?>�_=<jRAB�UKO?>�@8B�vS@�UK^ f <�UKO=L�\Y<!<!O�k

�[@Z>�<N>�_zB}>�>A_=<N>�_=UW<�I�r=RA<�IQ<!RY\b_=UW\.>�R�BZO=\YIQ<�RbBZ\bBiLSUpIe>�cMRABZ>�_=<�R.>�_zB�O]B�\�r=RY<!\AF�RAU f <�^>A_=<�Ie>!c7\A@3BZ\�O=@�>t>�@�UKO=F�:=Rt>A_=<VF�@S\Y>A\�@�Iu>A_=<�Ie>!k�¡N_=<VIhBZRAT8<!R�B�DK\Y@�r=RY<�IQ<�RA\�LSUpv|UKO=LLSUpIe>�\ f <!F�BZ:=\A<�>�_=<jvZB�DK:=<j@�Io>�_=<j>�RAB�O=\YIQ<�R[_�<t_zBZ\�>A@VLSUpvS<j>�@8TVB�UWOM>%B�UWO1>A_=<j>�_=UW<�I�§Ü\:�>AUKDWUW>$qVBZ>�\A@ST8<jDK<�v�<!D*UK\N\YTVBZDKDK<�R�`5_=<�OsUW>5UW\�UWO?>�_=<jIQ@SRATÐ@�I.B�LSUpIe>�k�¶�Io>A_=<�IhBZRAT8<!R`b<!RY<jB f DK<�>�@~LSUpvS<JB�\Y>%B}>�<�w�F!@SOM>AUKO=LS<�OM>NLSUWIe>b>�_=<�O,>�_=<�RA<;`b@S:=DW^,O=<�v�<!R f <iB�OMq]>A_=<�Ie>UWO¢<�á|:�UKDKU f RAUW:=Tac f :�>�coB�\�_�<]UW\tO=@Z>�cy>A_=<!RY<]`5UWDKD f <]\Y@ST]<8r=RY<!\AF�RAU f <�^g>�_=<�Ie>�cy<�vS<�O>A_=@S:=LS_1Up>5UK\NF!@�\Y>�Dpq,IQ@SR f @�>�_aB�L�<!OM>�\�k

��<�IQ@SRA<�>A_=<�\Y>%B}>�<~UK\JRA<�BZDKUK³�<!^dc�>�_=<~IhB�RYT]<�R;\A<�>�\i>�_=<~DW<�v�<!D7@�Ibr=RY<!\AF�RAU f <�^E>A_=<�Ie>IQ@SR�<�vS<!R�qVr#@S\Y\AU f DK<5\Y>�BZ>�<JB�O=^]>A_=<�\AUK³�<J@�I�>�_=<[\Y>�BZ>�<ªw$UKO�^=<!r#<!O=^�<!OM>uLSUpIe>�_=<[`5UWDKDzLSUpvS<>A_=<,>�_=UW<�I[BZ>�>A_=<?<!O�^�@ZI[>A_=<?r�<�RAUW@P^dc.UpI5_=<,�zO=^�\�>A_zBZ>�>A_=<,>�_�UK<�I�_zBZ\~\Y>�@�DK<!OÔO=@T8@SRA<�>�_zBZO1`�B�\Nr=RY<!\YF!RAU f <�^dk�¡N_=<i\Y>�BZ>�<i@ZI*OzBZ>�:�RA<iUK\b>�_=<�OaRY<�B�DWUK³�<!^?B�O�^1>A_=<J>A_=UK<�I^=<�F!UW^=<!\._=@�`XT�:=F%_~>�@J\Y>�<!B�D*�hB�O=^~\Y>A<�B�DW\7>�_zB}>�B�T8@S:=OM>   ky�u>.>A_=UK\7r#@SUWO�>y>�_=<uIhBZRAT8<!R

¹ çÀéTÕÍÇ�ÌLé¢ÎnËÍë-Ì\Ë#ÖZÔ�Ì�ɾÑ4ö Õ#â�ÈÊî�Ì5Õ¾Ç�Ì,â¦ÈèécÕÝáZÕ¾Ç�ÌLÕ¾Ç�ÈÊÌdé¨Ï\Î�ÑÓ�Ò�Ñ�ÈÙɭǹÇ�ÈÊë@Ð�×rÉ­Õ¾ÌÝÎnÚÊÈÛÑ�âMð

Page 11: 9= . >@?A . B C D1 E › files › docs › colloqpapers › w05 › Sc… · 0 (* %-$#+1 $3245$768&3 9:;&< # 9=" . >@?A . B C" D1 E FHGJILKMGON5PRQLSTPRQ UMSVK W;XZY\[^]`_Vacbd_eY\fZahgjilknmpo_eY\]

���������������� !���#"$ %� �S�

UW\uO=@�DK@SO�LS<!R�B f DK<[>�@�F%_zB�O=L�<i_=UK\Nr=RY@ST8UK\A<�^?LSUWIe>�DK<�vS<!DÎk.¡N_=<;IhB�RYT]<�Ru@ f \Y<!RYv�<!\�_=@�`T�:�F%_�>�_=<�>�_=UW<�I.\�>�@SDW<�BZO=^s^=<�F!UK^�<!\[`5_�<�>�_�<!R;@SR�O=@�>[>�@]LSUWv�<�_=UWT�>�_=<tLSUWIe>!kN¶�I7>�_=<>A_=UK<�I[\�>�@SDW<,T8@SRA<,>A_zB�OH>�_=<?r�RA<!\YF!RYU f <!^XB�T]@�:=OM>�c7>�_�<1IhBZRAT8<!R�_zBZ\~O=@ERA<�BZ\A@SOH>�@LSUpvS<�_=UWT�>�_�<8L�UWIe>�k~¶�Ib>�_=<�>�_�UK<�Ib\Y>A@SDK<�>A_=<8r=RA<�\AF!RYU f <!^¢B�T8@S:=OM>j>�_=<�O¬>A_=<8IhBZRAT8<!RT]B�qV>�RAB�O=\�IQ<!R5_=UKT�>�_=<jLSUpIe>�k

¡N_=<�IhB�RAT8<!R�r=DBZO�>A\�B�F!RY@Sr]`5Up>�_V\Y:=RA<[@S:�>Ar=:�>\º�lªcPB�O=^8>�_=<�>�_=UW<�I�r=DB�OM>A\�B�F!RA@�r`5Up>�_~\A:�RA<N@S:�>Ar=:�>xº { k7¶�I#@S:P>�r=:�>o`�<�RA<5RAUW\AGMq�>A_=<!O~>�_�<�Ie>7`b@S:=DW^8\Y<!R�vS<�B�O~UKO�\A:=RAB�O=F!<IQ:=O�F�>�UW@SOdc f :�>7IQ@SR*>�_�<ur=:=RYr�@S\Y<!\.@�Iz>A_=UK\yrzB�r#<!Ry¶*B�\A\Y:=T]<�O=@;@S:�>Ar=:�>.:�O=F!<�RY>%BZUKOM>$qSk l�»¡N_=<[IhB�RAT8<!R�>�R�BZO=\YIQ<�RA\NB é LSUWIe>!§�@�I�¼Ô>�@�>A_=<J>A_=UK<�I¹k7¡N_=UK\b>�R�BZO=\YIQ<�Ru^=@|<!\uO=@Z>u^=<�r�<�O=^@SOa>�_=<�\Y>�BZ>�<t@�I.OzB}>�:=RY<�k5Ø[<�B�DK\Y@]r�RA<!\YF!RYU f <!\;B8r�<�RAT8UK\Y\AU f DK<8�¾½   B�T8@S:=OM>[@�Io>A_=<�Ie>¿�À Á IQ@SRb<�vS<�RYqVr�@S\Y\AU f DK<[\Y>%B}>�<~��   @�I*OzB}>�:=RY<�k.¶$O,<�á|:�UKDKU f RAUW:=T >�_�<[IhB�RYT]<�R�F!@�O=\A:=T8<!\ºzllÃ5¼Äà ¿�À Á B�O=^1>�_=<i>A_=UK<�IoF�@SO=\A:�T]<�\+º { ��¼Z� ¿�À Á k

¶�I�>A_=<�>�_=UW<�Iu^�<�v|UBZ>A<!\�co\Y>A<�B�DWUKO=LaB�O¢B�T8@S:=OM> ¿�ÅÁ LSRA<!BZ>�<�R�>A_zB�OE>�_=<8r=RY<!\AF�RAU f <�^B�T8@S:=OM> ¿ À Á c*_=<�RA<�F!<!UpvS<�\�>ARA:=\�>$`�@SR�>�_=UWO=<!\Y\t^�UK\A:P>�UKDWUW>$q1IQRA@�T�^=@SUWO=L1\A@=c�B�G�UWOE>A@1_=UK\IQ<�<!DKUWO=La@�INLS:=UWDW>�@SR�r=RAUW^=<�k l$l ¡N_=<]T]@SRY<]^�UK\A:P>�UKDWUW>$qEBZOCB�LS<�OM>�LS<�>�\�IQRY@STÚ\Y>A<�B�DWUKO=L>A_=<�T8@SRA< é >�RY:=\Y>$`b@SRY>A_Mq�§�_=<�UW\!k¤¡N_=UK\]^=UK\Y:�>�UWDKUp>$qgIQRA@�TÈ\Y>�<!B�DKUWO=L¬UK\���� ¿ ÅÁ   B�O=^�UW>UWO=F!RY<�B�\Y<!\�UWO¬>A_=<]B�T]@�:=OM>�\�>�@SDW<!OCB}>�BaO=@SOPw�^=<!F�RA<!B�\AUWO=L�RABZ>�<��hUÎkÜ<ZkWcl�'ÆQ�ÈÇ  RÉ Ñ�B�O�^�'Æ Æe�ÈÇ  )Ê Ñ   ko¡�RA:�\Y>$`b@SRY>A_=UKO=<�\A\�^=UK\Y:�>�UWDKUp>$qjF�B�O f <uO=<!LSBZ>�UpvS<uIQ@SR7\YTVBZDKD|DK<�v�<!DW\7@�I�>�_=<�Ie>�cT8<�B�O�UKO=LJ>A_zBZ>.>A_=<N>�_=UW<�I#RA<�F!<!UpvS<�\b:�>AUKDWUW>$qjIQRA@ST \Y>A<�B�DWUKO=L=k�¶�>�UK\.@�O=DWqtO=<!F�<!\Y\�B�R�q8>A_zBZ>>A_=<tIQ:=O�F�>�UW@SO f <�F�@SOMvS<�©�ki¡N_=<�F!@S\�>;@�I�\�>�<�BZDKUKO�LVUK\OËZ��Â�Ì ¿ Á   c#`5_=UKF%_3UW\[^�UWÉ�<!RA<�OM>;UKO<!B�F%_1\Y>%B}>�<i@�I�OzBZ>A:=RA<Zk.¡N_=UK\NF�@S\Y>�BZDK\A@~UWO=F!RY<�B�\Y<!\NUWO,>�_=<jB�T8@S:=OM>�\Y>�@�DK<!OaBZ>NB�O=@SOPw^=<�F!RY<�B�\YUKO=L¬R�BZ>A<�c�UKOÔ<�v�<!R�qX\�>%BZ>A<¢�hUµk¨<_Ë;Æe��Â�Ì�Ç  �É ÑEB�O=^ÍË;Æ Æh��Â�Ì�Ç  �Ê ÑKÎ�   kX��@�>�<>A_zBZ>�B�DWDo>�_=<�Ie>jUK\iF�@S\Y>ADWqSc f :P>t@�O=DWq�^=<�v|UB}>�UK@�O¬DW<�v�<!D7>�_�<�Ie>iq|UK<�DK^=\i>�RY:=\Y>$`b@SR�>�_=UWO=<!\Y\^=UW\A:�>AUKDWUW>$qSk

¶�I�>�_�UK\�`�<�RA<;O=@Z>NB�RY<!r#<�BZ>A<!^,LMBZT]<[B�O=^V>A_=<[>A_=UK<�I*B�O=^]IhB�RAT8<!R�@SO=Dpq]T8<�>b@SO=F�<�c>A_=<!O1>�_=<�RA<i`b@S:=DK^ f <tB~_=UWLS_1DK<�vS<!D�@ZIo^=<�v|UBZ>AUK@SO?>�_�<�Ie>[B�O=^aO=@�LSUWIe>uLSUWv�<!Odk�«5<!F�BZDKD>A_zBZ>u>A_=<;>�UWT]UWO=Lt@ZI�>A_=<iT8@P^=<�D�UW\ �Ì  >A_=<;IhB�RYT]<�R�\A<�>�\u>A_=<iLSUWIe>�DK<�vS<!DdB�O=^,>�_�<iDK<�v�<!D@�I#r=RY<!\YF!RAU f <�^8>A_=<�Ie>�UWO�<�B�F%_�r#@S\A\YU f DW<N\Y>%B}>�<�c|&   >�_=<5\Y>�BZ>�<NUW\.RA<!B�DKUW³!<!^�BZO=^~>�_=<u>A_=UK<�I^=<�F!UW^=<!\i`5_=<�>�_=<�R�>A@?\Y>�<!B�D7>�_�<8r�RA<!\YF!RYU f <!^¢B�T]@�:=OM>j@SR;\A@�T]<�LSRY<�BZ>A<!RjB�T8@S:=OM>i\Y@B�\5>�@8T]B}©PUKT8UK³!<i_�UK\5T]@�T]<�O�>�B�RYq,:�>�UWDKUW>$q�czÆ   >�_=<jIhB�RYT]<�R�^�<!F!UW^=<!\5`5_=<�>�_=<�RJ@SR�O=@�>>A@¬L�UWvS<?>A_=<a>A_=UK<�I[>A_=<1LSUWIe>!k�ß;O=<�F!B�O�:=\A< f B�F%GM`�B�RA^=\]UKO=^�:=F�>AUK@SO�B�O=^�\A<�<a>A_zBZ>UWO�>�_�<�@SO=<ªw$\A_�@�>iLMB�T8<j>�_=<�IhBZRAT8<!R5`5UKDKD*O=<�vS<�RiLSUWv�<t>�_�<�LSUWIe>!k;ÍiO=@�`5UKO�L]>�_�UK\!c#>�_=<>A_=UK<�I�`5UKDWDz\Y>A<�B�Dz>�_�<;B�T8@S:=OM>�`5_=UKF%_VTVB}©PUWT]UW³!<!\._�UK\�T]@ST8<!OM>�B�RYq~:P>�UKDWUW>$q?�ÎB�O=^]UK\�UKO·�Ï ã�Î`é¢ÏÄÇMÎnë-Ó�É Ð�óuÈÛÑ�Õ¾Ì�ѯßWÃ�Ä�Īå�àeɾÇ�Ô`ô¤ÕÍÇ�Î`Õ©ÏdËÍÔ�ÓLÕÍÇ�ÌdécÕhÖZÔ�Ì�ÉVÈÛÑ�Ï\˾ÌÝÎ�ɾÌhô�ÈèÕÍÇ,Õ¾ËÄÎnÑMÉ­ÈÛվԦ˾×5ÓMÔ`î¦Ì\˾ս×�ð·Î· ÷#Ñ�ÖZËÍÌ\Ô¦Ñ�È ÐøóBÈÛÚÊÚÊÌ\ËlßKêÄ�Ä!Ã�à'ÎnÑ�Ö¹ã�Ì\Ç�ËlÐ ï�ÑÎ�ÏÄÇ�Õ¾Ì�˲ßWÃ�Ä�Ä�Ä�à¨ÒMÉ­ÌÝÖÌ�¸ZÓMÌ�˾ÈÊë-Ì\Ñ�ÕÍÉ�ÕÍÔDÉ­Ç�Ô`ô�Õ¾Ç�ÎnÕÈÛÑMÖZÈÛî�ÈÙÖZÒ�Î�ÚÊÉrÇ�Î�î�ÌuÇ�ÌdÕ¾Ì�˾Ԧâ�Ì�Ñ�Ì\Ô¦Ò�ÉDÓ�ËÍÌdé^Ì�˾Ì�Ñ�ÏdÌÝÉ\á�ɾÔ�ë-̤ХÌ\ÈÊÑ�â§É¾Ì\ÚÜÀMɾÇ�ÎnÑ�Ö�Ô�Õ¾Ç�Ì�ËÍÉÎnÚÛÕ¾ËÍÒ�ÈÙɽÕÍÈÊϤÔ�Ë˾ÌÝÏdÈÊÓ�ËÍÔ�Ï�Î`ÕÍÈÛÑ�âMð+õ©Ô¦É¾Ñ�Ì�˲ßQºY»�»�Á�à+ÒMÉ­ÌÝÉ)Ò­ë-Ô�ËÄÎnÚeÓ�˾ÈÙÖZÌ«ÓDΦÉ#ÎnѹÌ�¸�Ó�ÚÊÎ�Ñ�Î`ÕÍÈÛÔ¦Ñé^Ô¦Ë#Ñ�Ô¦ÑZìÀɾÌ\ÚÛé©ÈÛÑ�Õ¾Ì�˾ÌÝɽÕÍÌ�ÖÐMÌ�Ç�Î�î�ÈÛÔ¦Ë,ß^È°ð ̦ðÛá�ɾÔ�ë-ÌLÓ¥Ì\Ô�Ó�ÚÛ̲ÖZÔ-Ñ�Ô�Õ#ÚÛÈÊæ�Ì ÕÍÔ;ÕÍÇ�ÈÊÑ�ærÔ�éTÕÍÇ�Ì\ëDɾÌ\ÚÊî�Ì�É�ΦÉJÕ¾Ç�ÈÊÌ\î¦Ì�ÉÄàpð

Page 12: 9= . >@?A . B C D1 E › files › docs › colloqpapers › w05 › Sc… · 0 (* %-$#+1 $3245$768&3 9:;&< # 9=" . >@?A . B C" D1 E FHGJILKMGON5PRQLSTPRQ UMSVK W;XZY\[^]`_Vacbd_eY\fZahgjilknmpo_eY\]

���������������� !���#"$ %� � &

LS<�O=<!RAB�D�LSRY<�BZ>A<!Ru>�_=B�Oa>A_=<jr=RA<�\AF�RAU f <!^�B�T8@S:=OM>   k

¨)©'Ô Õ�°`Ö`×ÈØ0Ù`ÚÛ¶lÖ�±Ü³;¯�ݲÞ�¶/ßO×È­�±7×ÈÖ-à¶$Og>A_=<VUWO��zO=Up>�<�DWq3RY<!r#<�BZ>A<!^CLMBZT]<ZcoB�Og<!á�:=UKDWU f RYUK:=T�`5UW>A_gO=@s\�>�<!B�DKUWO=L�B f @�vS<8>�_=<r=RY<!\YF!RAU f <�^gBZT]@S:�O�>;UK\i<!OPIQ@SRAF�<�B f DW<�`5UW>A_E>A_=RA<!BZ>j@�I�r=:=O�UK\A_�T]<�O�>!k~� f RY<!:�� �����S�M r=RY@�vS<!\[>�_zBZ>;B�DKD*r#<!R�IQ<!F�>J<!á�:=UWDKU f RAUB�F�BZO f <�IQ@S:=O=^�:=\AUWO=L]>A_=<�`b@SRA\�>ir�<�RYIQ<�F�>;<�á�:=UpwDWU f RYUB�IQ@�R7<�B�F%_�r=DKB�qS<!R�BZ\.r=:=O=UW\A_=T8<!OM>.`5_=<�O�>A_zBZ>�r=DKB�qS<!R.^�<�v|UBZ>A<!\�k7�J\�B�:P>%B�RYG�q�UK\>A_=<i:=O=UWá|:�<t�[B�\A_a<!á�:=UWDKU f RAUW:=TûIQ@SR�>�_�<�\YUKO=L�DK<�w�r�<�RAUW@P^]LMB�T8<�c=r#<!RYTVB�O�<!OM>�B�:�>�B�RAGMqUW\]@SO�<�\A: f w$LMBZT]<�r�<�RYIQ<!F�>?�[B�\A_è<�á�:=UKDWU f RYUK:=TâIQ@�R]>�_�<�UKOP�zO=UW>A<!DpqHRA<�r�<!BZ>�<�^ÙO=@SOPwF�@P@Sr#<!RABZ>�UpvS<iLMBZT]<jB�O�^�B�r#@�>�<�O�>AUB�D�F�B�O=^�UK^zBZ>A<;IQ@SRu>�_�<�r�:=O=UK\Y_=T8<!OM>�\Y>�RABZ>�<�L�qSk

� f RA<!:�� ���S�S�M  ^=UW\AF!:�\A\A<�\.>�_zBZ>7UW>7UW\o@�Ie>A<!O~r#@S\A\YU f DW<b>A@i^=<!\YUKLSO é \Y>AUKF%G�B�O=^~F�BZRARA@Z>�§r=:�O=UK\Y_=T]<�OM>�\5`5_=UKF%_�B�RA<�T]@�RA<j_zB�RY\A_�>A_zB�O�\AUKT8r=DW<iRA<�v�<!RY\AUK@�O�>�@VB�:�>�B�RAGMqSk�¡N_=<!\Y<\�>�R�B}>�<!L�UK<!\~<�T]r�DK@�qHB é \�>�UWF%G#§.r�:=O=UK\Y_=T8<!OM>�>%B�GZ<!O�UWOH>�_=<?�zRY\Y>�IQ<�`Ör�<�RAUK@|^=\�BZIe>A<!R^=<�v|UBZ>AUK@SOdc�IQ@SDKDW@Ì`b<!^ f q¬B?T8@SRA<�^�<!\AUWR�B f DK< é F�B�RYRA@�>!§dr=DB�q�<!^¬:=OM>�UKD7B�O=@�>A_=<!Rir=DKB�qS<!R^=<�v|UBZ>A<!\!kV¡N_=<V<ª©�UW\Y>A<!O=F�<V@�IuB é \Y>AUKF%GEB�O=^¢F�B�RYRA@�>!§�r=:=O=UW\A_=T8<!OM>t^=<!r#<!O�^=\�@SOE>�_=<<ª©�UW\Y>A<!O=F�<u@�I#B�O~BZF�>�UW@SOt>A_=<uO=@�OPw$^=<�v|UBZ>AUKO=L[B�LS<�O�>7F�B�O�:�O=^=<!R�>%B�GZ<u`5_=UKF%_�`5UWDKDMT]B�G�<>A_=<j^=<�v|UB}>�@SRu`b@SRA\Y<t@ZÉ3O=@�TVB}>A>�<�Ru`5_zBZ>[B�F�>�UK@�Oa_�<�:�O=^=<!R�>%B�GZ<!\�kml {

¶$Os>�_�<~F!:=RYRA<!OM>jT8@P^�<!Dµc�UWI7>A_=<�>�_�UK<�I�^�<�v|UBZ>A<!\�cd>�_=<�RA<~UK\[O=@ é \Y>�UWF%G�§�>�_=<�IhBZRAT8<!RF!B�O�:�\A<i`5_=UKF%_aUK\u`b@SRY\A<j>�_zB�OaB�:P>%B�RYG�q�czUµk¨<�kpc=LSUpvPUWO=L~O=@�>�RAB�O=\YIQ<�R!k l ´ ß;O1>�_=<i@�>A_=<!R_zBZO=^dcd>�_�<!RA<~UW\jB é \�>�UWF%G#§d`b@SRY\A<�>�_=B�O¬B�:�>%BZRAGMq�`5_=UWF%_¬>A_=<�>�_�UK<�I�F!B�OE<!T8r=DK@�qSktØ[<F!B�O¤\Y>�<!B�D;T8@SRA<�>�_zB�OÙ>A_=<EB�T8@S:=OM>?T]B}©PUKT8UK³!UWO=L¬_=UK\?T8@ST8<!OM>%B�R�q�:P>�UKDWUW>$qÔIQ@SR?BIQ<�`¥r#<!RAUW@P^�\!cJUWO£@�RA^=<�R1>A@Ôr=:=O=UW\A_¤>�_=<EIhB�RAT8<!R�kû¡N_=<E>�_=UW<�I�`�@S:�DK^=Od§ >1`uBZO�>a>�@<�O�IQ@SRAF�<[>A_=UK\�r=:=O=UW\A_=T8<!OM>!c f <!F�BZ:=\A<[_=<Jr=RY<�IQ<�RA\u\�>�<�BZDKUKO�Lt_=UW\b@�r�>�UWTVB�D�BZT]@S:�O�>bB�O�^O=@�T]@�RA<~>�_zBZO¢>�_=BZ>�k?¶�Iu>A_=<]>A_=UK<�IuIhB�UWDK<!^3>A@�UKT8r#@S\A<~>�_�<]r=:�O=UK\Y_=T]<�OM>~B�O=^¢\Y>A@SDK<@SO�DWqH>�_�<�@SrP>�UKT]B�D5B�T8@S:=OM>VBZIe>�<�R8>A_=<�IhBZRAT8<!R�^=<�v|UKBZ>�<�^dcu>�_=<1IhB�RYT]<�R]F�@S:=DK^XO=@�>UWT]r#@S\A<5BZO�q8r=:�O=UK\Y_=T]<�OM>�@SO]_=UKTà_zB�RA\Y_=<!R�>�_zBZO,B�:�>�B�RAGMq�k7¡N_�:=\!c|>�_=UW\ é F�B�RYRA@�>bB�O�^\�>�UKF%G�§�r=:=O=UW\A_=T8<!OM> f q¬>�_�<]>�_�UK<�IuUK\�O=@�>�F�RA<�^=U f DW<�coB�O=^g\Y@3B�:�>�B�RAGMq¬UK\�>�_=<8`�@�RA\Y>\Y: f w$LSB�T]<ir#<!R�IQ<!F�>J�[B�\A_a<!á�:=UWDKU f RAUW:=TÐUWO?>�_=UW\NLMB�T8<�k·Q çºÑ�÷#Ð�˾Ì�Ò4ö É Ô¦ÚÛÈÊâ�Ô¦ÓMÔ¦ÚÛ׹̹¸�Î�ë�Ó�ÚÛÌ;Õ¾Ç�Ì�Ó�Ò�Ñ�ÈÊɾÇ�Ì\ËLÓ�ËÍÔZÖZÒ�Ï\Ì�É ÎrÇ�ÈÊâ�Ç�Înë-Ô�Ò�ѦÕÝáRë-Î�æ�ÈÛÑ�âÕ¾Ç�Ì�ÖZÌ\ìî�ÈÊÎnÕ¾Ô�Ë�ôJÔ�ËÄɭ̯Ô�d�Õ¾Ç�Î�ѧÇ�ÌHôJÔ�Ò�ÚÙÖ*Ç�Î�î¦ÌrÐ¥Ì\Ì�ÑCô�ÈÛÕ¾ÇCÕ¾Ç�ÌuÞ'Ô�Ò�˾Ñ�Ô�Õ­ìeæ.ΦɭÇ*ËÍÌ\î¦Ì\ËÄÉ­ÈÊÔ�Ñ*ɾÔ�ÚÊÒZÕÍÈÛԦѧÔnéÓ�ËÍÔ�Ö�Ò�ÏdÈÊÑ�âDÎ�ë�ÌÝÖZÈÊÒ�ëOÎ�ë�Ô¦Ò�Ñ�Õ�ð·QÅ Æ�Ç�Ì;Ï\Ô�ë-Ó�ÎnËÄÎ`ÕÍÈÛî¦Ì²É½ÕÄÎ`ÕÍÈÊÏ�É.ÖZÌ�˾ÈÊî�ÌÝÖHé^˾ԦëOÕÍÇ�Ìlë-ÔZÖZÌ�ÚTôJÔ�Ò�ÚÙÖ¹Ñ�Ô�Õ ÏÄÇ�Î�Ñ�â�̲ÈÛéhÕ¾Ç�̲é¢ÎnËÍë-Ì\Ë5Ç�Î�ÖÎ�Ï�ÏdÌ�ÉÍÉ�ÕÍÔɾÔ�ë-ÌlÏdÔ�ɽÕÍÚÛ×HÓ�Ò�Ñ�ÈÊɾÇ�ë-Ì\Ñ�Õ5Ç�Ì;ÏdÔ¦Ò�ÚÙÖBÈÛë-ӥԦɾ̲Ô�ÑuÕ¾Ç�ÌlÕ¾Ç�ÈÊÌdé¨ÈÊѤÎ�Ö�ÖZÈèÕÍÈÛÔ¦ÑBÕ¾ÔHÏdÒZÕ¾Õ¾ÈÊÑ�ârÔ�dé^ÒZÕ¾Ò�˾Ì,â¦ÈèécÕÄÉ\á�ÕÍÇ�Ô�Ò�â¦ÇHÕ¾Ç�Ì,ÚÊÌ\î¦Ì\ÚeÔné©ÏdÔ�Ô�Ó¥Ì\ËÄÎ`ÕÍÈÛÔ¦ÑôJÔ�Ò�ÚÊÖÐMÌ,Ç�ÈÛâ¦Ç�Ì\ËÝð

Page 13: 9= . >@?A . B C D1 E › files › docs › colloqpapers › w05 › Sc… · 0 (* %-$#+1 $3245$768&3 9:;&< # 9=" . >@?A . B C" D1 E FHGJILKMGON5PRQLSTPRQ UMSVK W;XZY\[^]`_Vacbd_eY\fZahgjilknmpo_eY\]

���������������� !���#"$ %� � Æ

¨)©F¨ á�×ÈÖ-µN׫Ö-àâ±�Ù-¶äã5¯�Ö-ØY±7Ý�­x×ÈÖ-¶¥µOå�æ"çaè¥×ȶlÖ�±�á-Ý�¯\Ö�±�×�¶¥Ý¡N_=<5^=<�v|UBZ>AUK@SO�F!@�O�>AUKO�:zBZ>AUK@SO~:P>�UKDWUW>$q,�h:�>AUKDWUW>$qjIQRA@STàB�:�>�B�RAGMq   IQ@SR7>�_=<NIhB�RYT]<�R.UK\xé lB�O�^¬IQ@SR;>A_=<~>�_=UW<�I�éV{�k�¶;BZ\A\A:�T]<~>�_=BZ>�UKO¬B�:�>�B�RAGMqs>A_=<~>�_=UW<�IbRA<!F�<!UpvS<!\�>�RY:=\Y>$`b@SR�w>A_=UKO=<�\A\�^=UK\Y:�>�UWDKUp>$qVIQ@SR5`5_zBZ>A<�vS<�RJ_=<t\Y>A<�B�DW\!kN¡N_=<jIhB�RAT8<!R�B�O�^�>�_�UK<�I�§¨\[T8@ST8<!OM>%B�R�q:�>AUKDWUW>$qHIQ:=O=F�>�UW@SO=\,BZRA<sRY<!r=RY<!\A<�OM>�<!^ f qëê��ÈÇ   B�O�^²ìo��Ç   RA<!\Yr�<�F�>AUWvS<�DWq�k ¡N_�<sv�BZDK:=<IQ:=O�F�>�UW@SO�IQ@�R�>A_=<�F�@SOM>�UKO�:zB}>�UK@�O�:�>AUKDKUp>$q?@�I7>A_=<tIhBZRAT8<!R�UK\`í]�ÈÇ   c�B�O=^�î RA<�r=RA<�\A<�O�>A\>A_=<i>�_=UW<�I�§Ü\NF�@SOM>�UKO�:zB}>�UK@�Oa:P>�UKDWUW>$q�k

¡N_=<�xyB�RA<�>�@1<��8F!UW<!OM>iIQRA@�O�>AUK<�RJUK\[IQ@S:=O=^ f qsT]B}©PUKT8UK³�UKO=L~>A_=<�IhB�RAT8<!R�§Ü\J:�>�UWDKUW>$q\Y: f Ç <!F�>*>�@5G�<�<!r=UWO=L�>A_=<7>�_�UK<�I�§¨\��h<�©�w$B�OM>�<.<�©Pr#<!F�>�<!^   :�>AUKDWUW>$q[BZ>ïîCIQ@�R*B�DKDZr�@S\Y\AU f DK<\îtk¡N_=<Nr�RA@ f B f UKDWUW>$qj@�I�<!B�F%_�\Y>%B}>�<u@�I#OzB}>�:=RY<uUK\lð Á B�O=^?ñaUK\�>�_=<�^=UK\YF!@S:=OM>.IhB�F�>�@SR�ko¡N_=<¶$OzBZ^zB,F!@SO�^=UW>AUK@SO=\J_=@SDK^�c�`5UW>A_3DKUWTRò.ó » ì�ÆQ��º  �ôâõ cdDKUWT(ò�ó+öXì�ÆQ�:º  �ô Ñ�c/ì�Æ�ÈÇ  NÊ Ñ�cB�O�^÷ì�Æ Æe�ÈÇ  �ø Ѧ�ÎBZO=^¤DKUKGZ<�`5UW\A<�IQ@SR=ê���Ç  A  kà¡N_=<3L�UWIe>1B�O�^¦r�RA<!\YF!RYU f <!^Ù>�_=<�Ie>�B�RA<F�@SO=\Y>AR�B�UWO=<!^1>�@ f <jO=@SOPw�O=<!LMB}>�UWv�<�k.¡N_=<jIhB�RYT]<�R!§¨\NTVB}©PUWT]UW³�BZ>AUK@SO8r=RA@ f DK<�T�UK\�ç

íV�Fî  \ô TVB}©ù ú û'üyýÈú þ�ÿý�� ý � Á ð Á � ê���º l Ã5¼�à ¿ À Á   � ñ�íV�Fî Á  ��

\Y: f Ç <!F�>[>A@~>�_=<iIQ@SDWDK@�`5UKO=L�F!@SO=\�>�RAB�UKOM>�\�k�Áð Á � ìy��º { ��¼X� ¿ À Á   Ã@ËZ��Â�Ì ¿ À Á   � ñïî Á �|ô î � �Ì 

ìy��º { �(¼-� ¿ À Á   ÃRËZ��Â�Ì ¿ À Á   �?ñïî Á Ê ìy�:º { � ¿ ÅÁ   ÃRËZ��Â�Ì ¿ ÅÁ   Ã3��� ¿ ÅÁ   ��ñlé { Î�Â�Ì ¿ ÅÁ �µ&  ê��:º l Ã�¼5à ¿ À Á   � ñ�íV�Fî Á  �Ê ê���º l à ¿ À Á   � ñlé l Î� �ÎÆ  

¿ À Á Ê Ñ Î� � °� ¼ Ê Ñ � ÞS 

¡N_=<��zRA\�>NF!@�O=\Y>AR�B�UWO�>bUK\�>�_=<[r=RA@�T]UW\A<�G�<!<�r=UKO�L�F!@SO�\Y>�RAB�UKOM>b`5_=UKF%_,<�O=\A:�RA<!\u>A_zBZ>�>�_=<>A_=UK<�I!§¨\�<ª©�r#<!F�>�<�^H:�>�UWDKUW>$qEUW\tT]B�UWO�>�B�UKO�<!^¢BZ>�\Y@ST]<]DK<�vS<!DÎk�¡N_�<,\A<�F!@SO=^ÔBZO=^g>�_�UKRA^B�RY<J>�_�<J>�_=UW<�IyB�O=^,>A_=<JIhB�RYT]<�R!§¨\uUKO�F!<!OM>AUWvS<iF�@ST8rzBZ>�U f UKDWUW>$q?�h¶ �   F!@�O=\Y>AR�B�UWO�>A\�`5_=UWF%_<�O=\A:=RY<�>A_zBZ>�UKO�<!B�F%_V\�>%BZ>A<[@�I�OzBZ>A:=RA<5>�_�<[BZLS<!OM>�\bB�RY<[B}>�DK<�BZ\Y>�UKO=^�UWÉ�<!RA<�OM> f <�>$`b<!<�O>A_=<¢<�á�:=UKDWU f RYUK:=T \Y>AR�BZ>A<!L�q¦B�O�^�^=<�vPUKBZ>�UWO=L=k�¡N_=<¬DB�\�>a>$`b@èBZRA<¬O=@SOPw�O=<!LMB}>�UWv|Up>$qF�@SO=\Y>AR�B�UWOM>�\5@SO?>�_=<�Ie>[B�O=^1>�_=<jLSUpIe>�k

¡N_=<]F!@SOM>�RAB�F�>�F!B�O f <]F�@ST8r=:�>�<�^gRY<!F!:�RA\AUpvS<�DWqSc�LSUpvS<!OgB�O¬UKO=Up>�UBZDyvZB�DK:�<�IQ@�R?îtcf qH\Y@SDWv|UKO�Ls>�_=<?^�q|OzBZT]UWF?r=RA@SL�R�B�T IQ@SR�>�_�<aUWO=UW>AUB�D.>AR�B�O=\�IQ<!RY\!c�r=RA<�\AF!RYU f <!^Ô>�_=<�Ie>�cB�O�^3F!@SOM>�UWO�:zBZ>�UW@SOs:�>AUKDWUW>�UW<!\5UKO3<!B�F%_Er�@�\A\AU f DK<t\Y>�BZ>�<#ÂSkj¡N_=<!OEUWO�>�_=<~O�<�©|>jr�<�RAUW@P^@SO�<�\Y@SDWv�<!\N>�_�<�r�RA@SLSRAB�T²B�LSB�UKO?LSUpvS<�Oa>A_=<jO=<�`ÊvZB�DW:=<;IQ@SRu>A_=<i>%B�RYLS<�>5:�>AUKDWUW>$q]DK<�v�<!D

Page 14: 9= . >@?A . B C D1 E › files › docs › colloqpapers › w05 › Sc… · 0 (* %-$#+1 $3245$768&3 9:;&< # 9=" . >@?A . B C" D1 E FHGJILKMGON5PRQLSTPRQ UMSVK W;XZY\[^]`_Vacbd_eY\fZahgjilknmpo_eY\]

���������������� !���#"$ %� ��°

î��Q`5_�UKF%_s`5UKDWD�<!á�:zB�Dxî Á IQRY@ST�>�_=<tr=RA<�v|UK@S:=\Jr�<�RAUK@|^dc�^=<�r�<�O=^=UKO�L,@SO�`5_=UWF%_s\Y>�BZ>�<`�B�\5RA<!B�DKUW³!<!^   k

¡N_=<�B�T]@�:=OM>o@�I=^=<�v|UB}>�UK@�OtDW<�vS<�DM>�_=<�Ie>o>�_�<�>A_=UK<�I=`�@�:=DK^t:=O=^=<�RY>%BZG�<�`5_=<�O�O=@�>yUKO<�á|:�UKDKU f RAUW:=T£`5UWDKDM\Y@SDWv�<�_=UW\yT]B}©PUKT8UK³!BZ>�UW@SO;r=RY@ f DK<�T®\A@[>A_zBZ> ¿ � ÅÁ ô B�RYLSTVBÌ© þ ìy��º { �¿   ÃëË���Â�Ì ¿   Ã@��� ¿   @�vS<!R�B�DWD ¿ � ÅÁ Ê Ñ�kt¶�I�>�_�<�>�_=UW<�I�§Ü\;¶ � F!@�O=\Y>AR�B�UWO�>]�Î&   f UWO=^=\�c�UW>`5UWDKD�@SO=DWq f UKO�^sIQ@SR ¿ ô ¿ � ÅÁ c*B�O=^E\Y@a@�O=<~F�B�OEUWLSO=@SRY<~B�DKD ¿��ô ¿ � ÅÁ k�¶$OM>A<!RA<�\Y>AUKO=LSDpqSc_=@�:=\A<�_=@SDK^�\�IQ@SRi`5_=UWF%_5ì�ÆQ�:º {  Rø Ë>Æh��Â�Ì%Ñ   �²�'ÆQ�ÎÑ   IQ@SRj<�v�<!R�q¢r#@S\Y\AU f DK<�\Y>�BZ>�<�Â8`5UKDWD_zB�v�<�BNF!@�RAO=<�R�\Y@SDK:P>�UK@�Odk�¡N_=<!\Y<�BZRA<�_=@S:=\Y<!_=@�DK^=\�`5UW>A_j\A:=F%_�B5_�UKLS_i>�RY:=\Y>$`b@SR�>�_=UWO=<!\Y\^=UW\A:�>AUKDWUW>$qH>�_=BZ>?>�_=<�q�`5UWDKDJO�<�vS<�R1\Y>�<!B�D;T8@SRA<�>�_zB�OÙ>A_=<3r=RA<�\AF�RAU f <!^£B�T8@S:=OM>?O=@T]BZ>A>A<!R�`5_zBZ>!k�¡N_=UW\VUK\]BgLS@|@|^XT8@�>�UpvZBZ>�UW@SOHIQ@SR]^�UWv|UK^=UWO=LE>�_=<sT8@|^=<!D5UKOM>A@¢>$`b@B�L�<!OM>�\�cz@SO=<i`5_=@8UK\5B~r�@Z>�<!OM>AUB�D�>A_=UK<�I7BZO=^�@�O=<i`5_=@]UW\NO=@�>!k

¡N_=<j�zRA\�>Yw�@SRA^=<�RNF!@SO�^=UW>AUK@SO?IQ@SR4î Á \YUKT8r=DKUp�z<!\�>A@

í Æ �'î Á  xô Ã�� ��� Á� � Á�� � �M 

`5_=<�RA< � UK\u>A_=<jT�:=Dp>�UKr�DKUK<�Rb@�Oa>A_=<jr=RA@ST8UK\Y<;G�<�<!r=UWO=LVF�@SO=\�>�R�BZUKOM>t� �Ì  c � Á ð Á @SO?>�_=<>A_=UK<�I!§¨\JUWO=F!<�O�>AUWv�<�F!@ST8rzBZ>AU f UWDKUp>$q,F!@�O=\Y>AR�B�UWO�>~�µ&   c� Á ð Á @SO�>A_=<�IhB�RYT]<�R!§¨\JUKO�F!<!OM>AUWvS<F�@ST]r=BZ>�U f UKDWUW>$q�F�@SO=\�>�R�BZUKOM>j�hÆ   c�� Á ð Á @SO,>A_=<J>A_=<�Ie>NO�@SOPw$O�<!LMBZ>AUWv|UW>$q�F�@SO=\�>�R�BZUKOM>�� °M  cB�O�^��V@SOs>A_=<�LSUpIe>JO�@SOPw$O�<!LMBZ>AUWv|UW>$qaF�@SO=\Y>AR�B�UWOM>�� Þ�  ki¶NF�BZOEB�DK\Y@,:=\A<�>A_=<�<�O�v�<!DW@Sr�<>A_=<!@SRY<!TÖ>A@�\A_=@�`Ê>A_zBZ>

í Æ �'î  xô Ã � � � íS ¡N_=<j�zRA\�>�@SRA^=<�RNF!@SO�^=UW>AUK@SO=\u`5Up>�_1RA<�\Ar#<!F�>[>A@ ¿ À Á UK\

ê8ÆQ�:º�llÃ5¼5à ¿�À Á  ì Æ ��º { �ļZ� ¿ À Á   Ã@Ë Æ ��Â�Ì ¿ À Á  

à ��� Á � Á ê8ÆQ��ºzl�à ¿�À Á  A � � � Á   ��ì Æ ��º { �ļZ� ¿ À Á   Ã@Ë Æ ��Â�Ì ¿ À Á  A 

ô � ��� Á� � Á��

� �M � @ST f UKO=UWO=LN>�_=<��zRA\�>o@�RA^=<�R�F�@SO=^=Up>�UW@SO=\�`5UW>A_tRY<!\Ar#<!F�>o>A@ ¿�À Á � �M  B�O=^?î Á � �M  `5UW>�_

>A_=<[<�OMvS<!DW@Sr#<JF!@�O=^=UW>AUK@SO�� íS  `b<J\Y<!<�>�_zBZ> � <!á�:zBZDK\b>A_=<�R�BZ>AUK@j@�I�T]B�RAL�UKOzB�DP:�>�UWDKUp>�UK<�\UWO¬>A_=<Vr=RY<�v|UK@�:=\�r#<!RYUK@|^¢UpIur=RY<!\AF�RAU f <�^g>�_=<�Ie>�`�B�\�r#@S\YUW>�UpvS<]B�O=^¬>�_=<8IhB�RAT8<!R�§Ü\�¶ �F�@SO=\Y>AR�B�UWOM>u^=UW^=Od§ > f UWO=^1B�O=^ � <!á�:zB�DW\�>�_�<;R�BZ>AUK@t@�I*TVBZRALSUWOzB�Dz:�>AUKDKUp>�UW<!\�UKOV>A_=<;F�:=R�wRY<!OM>7r#<!RYUK@|^�UWI=O=<!Up>�_=<�R7B�LS<�OM>�§¨\oF!@�O=\Y>AR�B�UWO�>A\ f UWO=^�B�O�^�r=RA<�\AF�RAU f <!^�>A_=<�Ie>oUK\�r�@�\AUW>AUWv�<�k

¨)©�� ãÄÙ-­oÝ�­oèC±7¶¥Ýt×��/­�±�×�¯�Ö ¯�³Xã5¯\Ö�±0Ý�­oèC±0ض�>�UK\*r#@S\A\YU f DW<.>�@�r=RA@�vS<bB5r=RA@Sr#@S\YUW>�UW@SOiRA<�DBZ>A<!^j>�@�@SO=<�IQ@S:=O=^�UKOtÒ�UKLS@�O�<�>yB�Dµk|�Î&�ÑSÑM&   cB�O�^?B�\�>A_=<;r=RY@P@�I*UW\uB�DWT]@�\Y>bUK^=<�O�>AUKF!B�D�Up>�UW\�@ST8UW>Y>�<�^,_=<!RY<JIQ@SR�>�_=<;\AB�G�<i@ZI f RA<�vPUp>$qSk¡N_=<j_=UW\Y>A@SRYq?@ZIo\�>%BZ>A<!\5:=r1>�@8B�O=^aUKO=F�DK:=^�UKO=L~^zB}>�<`��UW\���� ô �� l Ì; { Ì ����� Ì;Â��   k

Page 15: 9= . >@?A . B C D1 E › files › docs › colloqpapers › w05 › Sc… · 0 (* %-$#+1 $3245$768&3 9:;&< # 9=" . >@?A . B C" D1 E FHGJILKMGON5PRQLSTPRQ UMSVK W;XZY\[^]`_Vacbd_eY\fZahgjilknmpo_eY\]

���������������� !���#"$ %� �ÌÞ

�MpyqA}oqA��v�{yv:qAz����! 4��D5<>��0����«�����C��*�2��#"²<�������M<>�����«� <�(<����Ü���_<%ÿ0���«� <�����;�6]��*B��������$�}þ���$`�dÿ����>�)�&%��$��('���������* �'E����A* ����t����'���� ��� � � � Á Ì � Á � ��T�<%ÿNeÿ0�� � �)���   �� ���� ��>�� <><>��«*���� �=��1Qÿ���������$�}þo��� �=�;T �$�&9+*¥��,���`���M���� ����5���A*��$��\Â"���?eÿ��(��������þoÿ ��<%ÿ�W<><�T �.�3��\��������.-�eÿ����

� �)���  oô /01 02� Á � � � �����43 l  �ø � Á� �)���43 l   � � � �����43 l  65 � � Á Ì � Á �� Á � � � �����43 l  �É � Á � �M 

þoÿ����.� � Á ô Ã-íNÆh�'î Á  �7 ���A* � Á ô Ã4íMÆe� î Á   9-�R* �#8x�C�Nî Á ��3Qÿ��(�$�}þ��>�����T8���������2�8�&�$�=<>��������T7�������KE0��D8��, Qÿ0��-eÿ��#eÿ ���:��<>�T �6*K�.�><>���� ��#���Ä��F��'�RÂK�W�Z��#'�:9;TY���&����$�:�;DVÿ �$�M�<;�<>��0�����������:=?>�@�9+*��$L8��þo�$�W� î Á �$�?eÿ���ÿ �6�}ÿ��>�����T8��������A�8�&�$��<>��������2T0�������KE0��D8��,âeÿ0��4eÿ��#Qÿ ���:�1<>�T �6*"�.�><>���� ��#�����������RÂ"�W�"��#'�A9;TY����&����$�:�;D_eÿ�������;�����7% �N�<;�<>��0����«������A=CBD@�9��dÿ �$��<>��4EA�$��'����DK<%ÿ0����� <�'���;�6]�>�Reÿ��1<>�����«� <�4��C<>����Z������������/ ����T��o���� � �����43 l   �$�O���� ����A9¡N_�:=\.`�<N\Y<!<u>A_zBZ>�cMUpI�r�@�\A\AU f DK<ZcZ>A_=<u>�RAB�O=\YIQ<�RA\�B�RY<���©P<!^�\Y@tBZ\o>�@iGZ<!<!r�>�_�<uR�BZ>AUK@

@�IbT]B�RALSUWOzB�D�:�>�UWDKUp>�UK<�\~� E�FHG òJI�3 ù 3 þ ÿ ýLKM F G ò.NCO ù O þ ÿý K 3QP F G Á ú þ ÿý K   F�@SO=\�>%B�OM>�@�vS<!Rj>�UWT]<�B�O=^E@�vS<!R�\Y>�BZ>�<�\!k¶�Ij\Y@ST]<�F!@SO=\�>�RAB�UKOM>,UW\ f UWO=^=UWO=L=c�>A_=<sR�B}>�UK@¬`5UKDWD f <sF%_zBZO=LS<!^ f q�>�_=<sT8UKO�UKT�:=Tr#@S\A\YU f DW<;>�@�\�B}>�UK\�IeqV>A_=<jF!@SO=\�>�RAB�UKOM>�\�k

¨)©CR ã5¯�ÚTS-­oÝ�­�±�×'ß\¶TU)±0­�±�×�è/ض~`5UKDWD5O=@�`�^�<!RAUpvS<3F�@ST]r=B�R�BZ>AUWv�<�\Y>�BZ>�UWF!\V>A@CDK@|@SGÔBZ>V>�_=<s<�É�<�F�>A\?@�IjF%_zB�O=L�<!\?UKO<ª©�@�LS<!O=@�:=\yIQ<!BZ>�:=RY<!\y\A:=F%_�B�\yB   >�_=<bF!@S\�>7@�I�\Y>A<�B�DWUKO=L���ËZ��Â�Ì ¿ Á  A  c f   >�RY:=\Y>$`b@SR�>�_=UWO=<!\Y\����� ¿ Á  A  c�B�O=^8F   RAUW\AG~B�v�<!RA\YUK@SO8@SO�<!O�^=@SLS<�O=@S:=\�vZB�RAUKB f DK<�\7\A:�F%_,B�\�U   LSUWIe>A\.LSUWv�<!O���¼  UWU   r�RA<!\YF!RYU f <!^�>A_=<�Ie>�� ¿ À Á   BZO=^�UWUKU   >�RY:=\Y>!k

¶7F�@SO=\AUW^=<!R.>ARA:=\�>b>A@ f <�B�O]<�O=^=@SL�<!O=@S:�\bvZB�RAUKB f DW<j�Q`5_=UWDK<N>�RY:=\Y>$`b@SR�>�_=UWO=<!\Y\�UK\�B�O<ª©�@�LS<!O=@�:=\�vZB�RAUKB f DW<�<�É�<�F�>AUKO=L�>ARA:=\�>   kmlQË,ØJB�RY^=UKOs�µ&�ÑSÑS&   <�T]r�_zB�\AUW³!<�\�>�_zB}>�>�RY:=\Y>�UK\RY<!DB}>�UK@�OzB�D��QUµk¨<�kpc#>$`b@,r#<!@Sr=DW<!\�§�DW<�vS<�Dy@ZI7>�RY:=\Y>J^=<!r#<!O=^�\i@SO�>A_=<!UWR[@SO�LS@SUKO�L]UWO�>A<!RAB�F�w>AUK@SO   BZ\�UW\i>�_=<8F�B�\Y<]_�<!RA<Zk,Ø�<]^=<��zO=<�\t>�RY:=\Y>tB�\�ëY<�O=F�B�r�\A:=DKBZ>�<�^¢UWO�>A<!RY<!\Y>Aì=k?ß;O=<B�L�<!OM>1�e>�_=<8IhB�RAT8<!R   >ARA:=\�>�\~Ba\A<!F�@SO=^�B�LS<�OM>1�Q>A_=<]>A_=UK<�I   f <!F�BZ:=\A<,_�<,G�O=@�`5\�>�_=<>A_=UK<�IyvZB�DW:=<!\u>A_=<jF!@SOM>�UWO�:zBZ>�UW@SO?@�I�>�_=<jRY<!DB}>�UK@�O=\A_=UWrdc=BZO=^ f <�F�B�:=\Y<t@ZIy>A_zBZ>5_=<i`5UKDWD>�B�G�<u>A_=<uUKOM>A<!RA<�\Y>A\�@ZIz>�_=<uIhB�RYT]<�RoUWO�>A@jB�F!F�@S:=OM>�k7Ò*<�v|U*�µ&�Ñ�Ñ �Ì  F�DB�UWT]\*>�_=BZ>.^=UW\Y>�RY:=\Y>RAB�UK\Y<!\u>�_�<�ë¹>�R�BZO=\�B�F�>�UW@SO1F!@S\�>�\Aì8@�IoF!@|@Sr�<�R�BZ>AUK@SO�k· ã óBÒ�ÏÄǯÔ�éeÕ¾Ç�Ì É­ÔZÏdÈÙÎnÚ¥Ï\Î�Ó�ÈèÕÄÎnÚMÚÛÈÛÕ¾Ì�ËÍÎnÕ¾Ò�ËÍÌ.ÏdÔ¦Ñ�ɾÈÊÖZÌ�ËÍɨվËÍÒ�É­Õ+Õ¾ÔlÐMÌ Ì\Ñ�Ö�Ô�â�Ì�Ñ�Ô�ÒMÉ\á�Õ¾Ç�Ô¦Ò�â�Ç-ÕÍÇ�Ì\ËÍÌ.ÈÙÉίɭվËÄÎnÈÊÑHÔ�é¨Ì\ë-Ó�ÈÊ˾ÈÙÏ\Î�Ú4ôJÔ�ËÍærô�Ç�ÈÙÏÄÇuÏdÔ¦Ñ�É­ÈÙÖZÌ�ËÍÉ�ÕÍ˾ÒMɽÕ5վԯХÌlÌ�¸�Ô¦â�Ì�Ñ�Ô�Ò�É�Î�Ñ�Ö¹ÚÊÔ�Ô¦æZÉ.Î`Õ.Õ¾Ç�̲ÌÈd¥ÌÝÏpÕÄÉÔnéTÕ¾ËÍÒ�ɽÕ#ô�ÈÛÕ¾Ç�Ô�ÒZÕ#ÚÊÔ�Ô�æ�ÈÛÑ�â-ÎnÕ�ÈèÕÄÉ#Ï\Î�Ò�É­ÌÝÉ\ð

Page 16: 9= . >@?A . B C D1 E › files › docs › colloqpapers › w05 › Sc… · 0 (* %-$#+1 $3245$768&3 9:;&< # 9=" . >@?A . B C" D1 E FHGJILKMGON5PRQLSTPRQ UMSVK W;XZY\[^]`_Vacbd_eY\fZahgjilknmpo_eY\]

���������������� !���#"$ %� ���

¶$O3B�F�F!@SRY^dc#¶uT]<!B�\A:�RA<V�hDBZF%G?@�I   >�RY:=\Y>;B�\5>�_=<t\A:=T�@�Iy>�_=<tT�:=DW>AUKr=DWUK<�RA\u@SOa>�_=<>A_=UK<�I!§¨\�UKO=F�<!OM>�UpvS<�F!@ST8rzBZ>AU f UWDKUp>$q5F!@SO=\�>�RAB�UKOM>��µ&   @�v�<!R�\Y>%B}>�<!\��)V Á ð Á � Á   LSUpvS<!O�\A@�T]<RY<�IQ<!RY<!O=F�<,:�>AUKDKUp>$q�î�IQ@SRj>�_=<8>�_=UW<�I¹k1¡N_=UW\�RA<�IQ<!RY<!O=F�<,:�>�UWDKUp>$qsF!@�:=DK^ f <8>�_=<8>�_=UW<�I�§Ü\:�>AUKDWUW>$qsUWOCB�`b@SRYDK^gUWO¢`5_=UWF%_g>�_�<�Ie>�`uB�\�UKT8r�@S\Y\AU f DK<Zk,¡N_=UK\�Ò*B�LSR�BZO=LS<8T�:=DW>AUKr=DWUK<�RUW\1BÔT8<�BZ\A:=RY<¬@ZI�_=@�`�>�_=<3IhB�RYT]<�R!§¨\?TVB}©PUWT]UW³!<!^�<�©Pr�<�F�>A<!^Ê:�>AUKDWUW>$q�RA<!B�F�>A\a>A@XB\YDKUKL�_�>�RY<!DBÌ©=B}>�UK@�O¢@�I�>�_=UW<�I�§Ü\�UKO=F�<!OM>�UpvS<]F!@ST8rzBZ>AU f UWDKUW>$q�F!@�O=\Y>AR�B�UWO�>!k1¶�IN>�_=<8>�_=UW<�I�§Ü\UWO=F!<�O�>AUWv�<,F!@ST8rzBZ>AU f UWDKUp>$q3F!@SO�\Y>�RAB�UKOM>�`b<!RY<?O=<�v�<!R f UWO=^=UKO�L=c.B�O=^H_�<V`�@�:=DK^HO=<�vS<�R\�>�<�BZDPBZO�q�>A_=UKO=L[UKOtB�OMq�\Y>%B}>�<�c}>�_=<�Ot>A_=<�T�:�DW>�UWr=DKUW<!R#`5UKDKD�<!á�:zB�D|³!<�RA@=c�B�O=^t>A_=<bIhBZRAT8<!R_zBZ\uF!@ST8r=DW<�>�<[>�RA:�\Y>5UKO]>�_=<;>A_=UK<�I¹k7�J\u>A_=<;>�_=UW<�I f <!F!@�T]<�\uT]@�RA<iB�O�^?T]@SRY<J`5UKDWDKUWO=L>A@C\Y>A<�B�D[B�O=^ÙT8@SRA<aF!@�\Y>�DpqÔ>�@CF�@SOMvPUWO=F!<3O�@�>V>A@g\Y>A<�B�D�>�_=<�T�:=DW>AUKr=DWUK<�R~UKO=F�RA<�BZ\A<!\B�O�^1>A_=<;IhB�RYT]<�R�>�RY:=\Y>A\�_�UKT�DK<!\Y\!k�¡N_=UW\NF!@SRYRA<!\Yr�@�O=^=\N`5UW>A_1ØJB�RY^=UKOd§¨\N^=<��zO=UW>AUK@SO?@ZI>ARA:=\�>~UKOC>A_zBZ>~BZ\�>�_=<V>A_=UK<�I!§¨\�:�>AUKDWUW>$qEUKOÔBZ:�>%B�RYGMqgUWO=F!RY<�B�\Y<!\~_=<?F!B�RA<�\~DK<!\Y\~B f @S:�>>A_=<�F�@SOM>�UWO|:=BZ>�UW@SOX@ZI;>�_=<aLSUpIe>Yw$L�UWv|UKO=L3RY<!DKBZ>�UW@SO=\A_�UKrH`5UW>A_X>�_�<aIhB�RYT]<�R!kè¡N_�<!Oè_=<f <!F�@ST]<�\uT8@SRA<[F!@S\�>�DWq�>A@~F!@SOMv|UKO=F�<;O=@�>�>�@�\�>�<�BZDdB�O=^,>A_=<JIhB�RYT]<�Rb>ARA:=\�>�\u_=UWT�DK<!\Y\!k

Ò�@P@�G|UWO=L]BZ>;×.á�:zBZ>AUK@SOC� �M  @SO=<j�zO=^�\J>�_zB}>[`5_=<�OW� Á ô Ñs�hr�RA<!\YF!RYU f <!^�>A_=<�Ie>[UK\LSRY<�BZ>A<!R.>�_=B�O]³�<!RY@   BZO=^X Á ô Ñ]�Q>A_=<�IhBZRAT8<!R!§¨\.F!@�O=\Y>AR�B�UWO�>b^=@|<!\�O=@�> f UWO=^   c�î Á UW\bBO=@�OPw$^=<�F!RY<�B�\YUKO=L�IQ:=O=F�>AUK@SO]@�IC¼@� ¿�À Á k��b<!F�BZ:=\A<i×.á�:zBZ>AUK@SOs� �M  _zBZ\b>�@t_=@SDW^]UWOV<�BZF%_\�>%BZ>A<N@�I�O=BZ>�:=RY<5B�O=^8<�B�F%_8r#<!RAUW@P^�cS\Y>�BZ>�<�\�`5_�UKF%_8@�É�<�R._=UKL�_=<!R7F�@SOM>�UWO|:=BZ>�UW@SO�:�>�UWDKUW>$qT�:�\Y>�B�DW\A@1r=RA<�\AF�RAU f <�T]@�RA<�>�_�<�Ie>�c*BZO=^¢\Y@�<!B�F%_�î Á UK\jB�O¬UKO=F�RA<!B�\AUWO=L,IQ:=O=F�>�UK@�O¬@ZI>A_=<jr=RA<�\AF!RYU f <!^1>�_=<�Ie> ¿�À Á UKO?>�_=BZ>5\Y>�BZ>�<�B�O=^a@�I¥¼Z� ¿�À Á k

¶�I�>�_�<[>�_�UK<�I�§¨\bUWO=F!<�O�>AUWv�<;F!@ST8rzBZ>AU f UWDKUp>$q�F�@SO=\Y>AR�B�UWOM>i�Î&   UW\ f UWO=^=UWO=L=cM>�_=<�O?B�\b_=UK\>ARA:=\�>$`�@SR�>�_=UWO=<!\Y\i^=<!F�RA<!B�\A<�\8�hUµk¨<�kpc�B�\O����Ç   IhBZDKDK\NIQ@SRJB�DKDd>A_=<�Ie>;DK<�v�<!DW\   _�<�T�:=\�>;_zB�v�<f @�>�_8_=UWLS_=<!R�F�@SO=\A:�T]r�>AUK@SO8B�O�^V_=UWLS_=<!R�F�@SOM>�UKO�:zB}>�UK@�O8:P>�UKDWUW>$q,�h\YUKO=F�<[¶7_=B�v�<[\Y_=@�`5OB f @�vS<�>�_zBZ>5>A_=<t>$`b@,T�:=\�>JL�@]UWO�>�_�<t\AB�T]<�^=UWRA<!F�>�UW@SO   k�¡N_|:�\!c�F�@SOM>�RAB�RYq1>�@�`5_zBZ>@SO�<[T8UKLS_M>�<ª©�r#<!F�>�c¥<>������;�$�xE0���;���&TY��c�T8@SRA<5>�RY:=\Y>$`b@SRY>A_MqVBZLS<!OM>�\bF!@SO�\A:=T8<[DW<!\Y\�B�O�^_zB�v�<¬DW@�`�<�R,:�>�UWDKUp>$qSkÕ�¥IhB�RYT]<�R,LSUWv�<!\V>AR�B�O�\YIQ<!RY\?>�@C>�_�@S\A<EB�L�<!OM>�\,`5_=@�B�RY<3O=@�>>ARA:=\�>$`�@SR�>�_Mq,UWOV@SRY^=<!R�>�@~B�v�@SUK^ f <!UWO=L�\�>�@SDW<!OVIQRY@STako¡�RA:=\�>$`�@SR�>�_Mq1B�L�<!OM>�\br=RA@�v|UK^=<B~DK@�`b<!RN>�_�RA<�B}>�c�B�O=^1\Y@]^=@�O=@Z>[_=B�v�<�>A@ f < f RYU f <!^ f q f <�UKO=L�LSUpvS<�Oa>AR�B�O=\�IQ<!RY\!k l ê

¶�>,_=B�\ f <!<!OÙ\Y_=@�`5OÙ>�_zBZ>,BgDK<�\A\8>�RA:�\Y>$`b@SRY>A_�qÙB�LS<!OM>V_zB�\,_=UWLS_=<�RVF!@�O=\A:=T8rPw>AUK@SOdc f :P>i^=@|<!\[>A_=UK\[F!@ST8<jIQRA@ST�BV_=UWLS_=<�R[LSUpIe>+¼Ù@SRJ_=UWLS_=<�R[r=RY<!\YF!RAU f <�^s>�_=<�Ie> ¿�À Á ���<�F�B�:�\A<,>�_�UK\�DW<!\A\t>�RA:�\Y>$`b@SRY>A_�qHB�LS<!OM>�_zBZ\~Bs_=UKL�_=<!RtF!@SOM>�UWO�:zBZ>�UW@SOH:�>AUKDKUp>$qX�'î Á   c_=UW\NT]@�T]<�O�>�B�RYqV:�>�UWDKUp>$qVT�:�\Y> f <�_�UKLS_=<�RNUKO?>�_�<�O�<�©|>�r�<�RAUK@|^aB�\u`b<!DKDÎk.�J\N>�_�<�Ie>�UK\F�@S\Y>ADWqScÌ>�_�<�IhB�RYT]<�Rd`5UKDWDSr=RA<�IQ<!R*>�@5UKO�F!RA<!B�\A<�>�_�<�>A_=UK<�I!§¨\*T]@ST8<!OM>�B�RYqJ:�>�UWDKUW>$q[>�_=RY@S:=LS_LSUpIe>�\iRABZ>�_=<�Ri>�_zB�OE>�_�RA@S:=L�_¢r=RY<!\YF!RAU f <�^¢>A_=<�Ie>�`5_=<!O¢r�@�\A\AU f DK<Zk�¡N_=UK\�F�B�O¢B�DW\A@ f <\Y<!<!O f q?O=@�>AUKO=L�>A_zBZ>NIQ@SRuB�DW<!\Y\u>�RA:�\Y>$`b@SRY>A_�q�B�L�<!OM>-î Á `5UKDWD f <i_=UKLS_�<!R!c=B�O=^1\A@�UKO·:� ç5Ç�Î�î¦Ì�ΦɾɾÒ�ë-Ì�Ö¤Õ¾ÇMÎ`Õ²î�ÈÛÚÊÚÙÎnâ�Ì�ËÍÉ æ�Ñ�Ô`ôøÌ�Î�ÏÄÇ�ÔnÕÍÇ�Ì\ËÝö ÉLÚÛÌ�î�Ì\ÚÙÉLÔné'Õ¾ËÍÒ�É­Õ½ô'Ԧ˭ÕÍÇ�ÈÛÑ�Ì�ÉÍÉ\áVɾÔBÎÕ¾Ç�ÈÊÌdéÏ\Î�Ñ�Ñ�ÔnÕ�ë-ÈÙÉ­ËÍÌ\Ó�ËÍÌ�ɾÌ\Ñ�Õ�Ç�ÈÊë-ɾÌ\ÚÛéhÎ�É�Ð¥Ì\ÈÊÑ�âDÒ�Ñ�Õ¾ËÍÒ�É­Õ½ô'Ԧ˭ÕÍÇ�×DÈÊѹÔ�ËÄÖZÌ\ËJÕÍÔ�ËÍÌ�Ï\Ì\ÈÊî�ÌLë-Ô�ËÍÌLâ�ÈÛécÕÍÉ�ð

Page 17: 9= . >@?A . B C D1 E › files › docs › colloqpapers › w05 › Sc… · 0 (* %-$#+1 $3245$768&3 9:;&< # 9=" . >@?A . B C" D1 E FHGJILKMGON5PRQLSTPRQ UMSVK W;XZY\[^]`_Vacbd_eY\fZahgjilknmpo_eY\]

���������������� !���#"$ %� �Ìí

>A_=<�\Y>A@PF%_=B�\Y>AUKF~\Y>A<�B�^Pqs\Y>�BZ>�<~_�<�`5UKDKD�F!@�O=\A:=T8<~T8@SRA<Zki�J\;>�_�<~LSUWIe>JUK\JO�@�>jF!@S\�>�DpqScT8@S\Y>5@ZIy>A_=UK\N_=UWLS_=<�RNF!@SO=\Y:=T8r�>�UW@SO?`5UKDKD�F!@ST8<i>�_=RY@S:=LS_aB�_=UKL�_=<!RNLSUpIe>�k

Ϥ_=<�OVBJIhB�RYT]<�Ro_zBZ\.DK<!\Y\7>�RY:=\Y>$`b@SRY>A_Mq�O=<!UWLS_ f @SRY\!cM_=UW\o>�RY:=\Y>�^�<!F!RY<�B�\Y<!\bB�\o`b<!DWDµk��<�F�B�:�\A<#íNÆe�'î Á  )ô Ã+Y O�Z ýl O�[ ý >�_�<�_=UWLS_=<!RNî Á @ f >%B�UWO=<!^ f q�DK<�\A\J>ARA:=\�>$`�@SR�>�_Mq3BZLS<!OM>�\UWT]r=DWUK<�\�>A_zBZ>\Y O�Z ýl O�[ ý T�:�\Y> f <�_=UWLS_=<�R,B�\V`b<!DWDµkÊ�[\ � ^=@P<�\,O=@�>V^=<!r#<!O�^¦@�O�>�_=<\�>%BZ>A<�ÂScdB�O=^3Up>JF!B�O=O=@Z> f <t>�_=<�F!B�\A<t>�_zBZ> f @Z>�_EB�LS<�OM>�\!§�UKO=F�<!OM>�UpvS<�F�@ST8rzBZ>�U f UKDWUW>$qF�@SO=\Y>AR�B�UWOM>�\ f UWO=^dcPUWI�>�_�<J>�_=UW<�I�§Ü\�¶ � F�@SO=\Y>AR�B�UWOM>��µ&   f UKO�^=\�>�_�<!O] Á ô Ñ�k.¡N_�:=\u>�_=<_=UWLS_=<�R8F�@SOM>�UWO|:=BZ>�UW@SOX:P>�UKDWUW>$q@î Á @ f >%B�UWO=<!^ f q�DK<!\Y\8>ARA:=\�>$`�@�RY>�_Mq�B�LS<�O�>A\]UWT]r�DKUK<�\>A_zBZ>^� Á UK\�_�UKLS_=<�R�BZ\b`b<!DKDÎko¡N_=UW\�T8<�B�O�\b>�_=BZ>NB�DK<!\Y\b>ARA:=\�>$`�@SR�>�_MqV>A_=UK<�I�F�BZ:=\A<�\�>�_=<IhB�RYT]<�R�>�@ f <iDK<!\Y\N>�RA:�\Y>�UWO=L=k

�JO�B�OzB�Dpq|\AUK\~@ZIJ>�_�<a<�É�<�F�>A\V@�IJB¬F%_=B�O=LS<aUKOÔ>�_=<1F�@S\Y>]\Y>ARA:=F�>�:=RY<�@�IJ\Y>A<�B�DWUKO=LUW\~\AUKT8UKDKB�Rj>�@3>�_=<1BZOzB�DWq|\YUK\~@�IJB3F%_zB�O=LS<1UWOC>�RA:�\Y>$`b@SRY>A_=UKO=<�\A\�kX¶�I�>�_=<?>A_=UK<�I!§¨\~¶ �F�@SO=\Y>AR�B�UWOM>s�Î&   UK\ f UKO�^=UKO=LEUWO�B¬r�<�RAUK@|^�UKOÔ`5_=UKF%_XUW>8UK\�<�BZ\YqÔ>�@¬\Y>A<�B�DÎcuB�O=^�>�_=<r=RY@ f B f UKDKUp>$qg@ZIJ>�_=BZ>8<�B�\�qX\�>%BZ>A<1UKO=F�RA<�BZ\A<!\]@SR~>�_=<1T]B�RAL�UKOzB�D�F!@S\�>]UWO�>A_zBZ>8\Y>�BZ>�<^=<�F!RY<�B�\Y<!\�>�_=<,>A_=UK<�IN`5UKDKDb\Y>A<�B�DuT8@SRY<V`5_=<!OÔ^=<�v|UBZ>AUKO=L=kE¡N_=<?>A_=UK<�I�`5UWDKD�_zB�vS<?>�@_zB�v�<iUKO=F�RA<�BZ\A<!^?F�@SO=\Y:=T]rP>�UK@�OE��¼=� ¿�À Á   B�O=^?F�@SOM>�UWO|:=BZ>�UW@SO,:�>AUKDKUp>$q�î Á >A@�F!@ST8r#<!OPw\ABZ>�<8_=UKTak~Ϥ_=UKDW<�BaF%_=B�O=LS<8UKO3>�RY:=\Y>$`b@SR�>�_=UWO=<!\Y\~BZÉ�<!F�>A\�>A_=<~>�_=UW<�I�§Ü\jT8@ST8<!OM>%B�R�q:�>AUKDWUW>$q~`5_=<�Oa^�<�v|UBZ>AUKO=L�UKO1B�DWD�\�>%BZ>A<!\!c=B�F%_zB�O=LS<iUWOV>�_�<iTVB�RYLSUKO=B�D�F!@S\�>N@�I�\Y>A<�B�DWUKO=L@SO�DWqVBZÉ�<�F�>A\NT]@ST8<!OM>�B�RYq8:�>AUKDKUp>$q�`5_=<!O1^=<�vPUKBZ>�UWO=L�UWO,>�_=<;\�>%BZ>A<iUKO,`5_=UWF%_,>�_=<iF�@S\Y>F%_zBZO=LS<!\�k.��^=<�F!RY<�B�\Y<JUKO�>�_�<JF!@�\Y>b@�I�\Y>A<�B�DWUKO=LjUWO,B�DWDz\Y>%B}>�<!\�`5UKDWDzF�B�:�\A<;BZOVUKO�F!RA<!B�\A<UWOt>�_�<u\AUW³!<u@�I�>�_=<uL�UWIe>�cZ\AUWT]UWDB�Rd>A@J>�_=<bF�B�\Y<N@�I�BJ^�<!F!RY<�B�\Y<NUKO�>ARA:=\�>$`�@�RY>�_�UKO=<�\A\.^=UW\A:Pw>AUKDKUp>$qSk7�[O�UWO=F!RY<�B�\Y<jUKO?>�_=<ivZB�RYUB�O=F�<j@�Iy>A_=<jF!@S\�>�@�I7\�>�<�BZDKUKO�L=c�@SO1>�_�<�@Z>�_=<�R�_=B�O=^dc`5UWDKD*F�B�:�\A<8B�OsUWO=F!RY<�B�\Y<~UKO�>A_=<�Ie>iUWO�>�_�<~\Y>%B}>�<!\iUWO�`5_=UWF%_s>�_=<�Ie>jUK\J<!B�\AUW<!\�>�kj�J\jB�O<!B�\Yq1\�>%BZ>A< f <!F�@ST8<!\5T]@�RA<jr=RA@ f B f DW<i@SRN>�_=<jT]B�RALSUWOzB�D�F!@S\�>[UWOaB8\�>%BZ>A<�^�<!F!RY<�B�\Y<!\�c>A_=<�`b<!UWLS_M>�<�^?B�vS<!RAB�LS<[@�I�î Á B�DK\Y@tUWO=F!RY<�B�\Y<!\!cPF�B�:�\AUKO�Lt>�_�<�`b<!UWLS_M>�<!^,B�v�<!RAB�LS<;@�I_� Á>A@,UKO=F�RA<!B�\A<Zc�`5_=UKF%_ET8<�B�O�\[>�_=BZ>;>�_�<�IhB�RAT8<!R�§Ü\[DK<�vS<!Do@�I.>�RY:=\Y>iUW\;DK@�`b<!R�`5_=<!OEUW>JUK\<!B�\AUW<!Ru>�@8\Y>A<�B�DÎk

ß;O=<JF!B�O,\Y_=@�`¦>A_zBZ>uB�\b>A_=<[IhB�RYT]<�R f <!F�@ST8<!\�T8@SRY<[RYUK\AG8B�vS<�RA\Y<i_=<JLSUpvS<�\�T8@SRA<LSUpIe>�\�ka�[\�>�_�<]IhB�RYT]<�R!§¨\�RAUW\AG¬B�vS<�RA\AUW@SOCUWO=F!RY<�B�\Y<!\!c._�UK\�F�@SOM>�UWO|:=BZ>�UW@SOg:�>AUKDWUW>$qsIQRY@STB�:P>%B�RYG�qX��é l   ^=<�F!RA<!B�\A<�\!kE�Q¡N_=UK\�UK\ f <!F!B�:=\A<8UKO¢B�:�>�B�RAGMq3_�UK\jF!@SO�\A:=T8r�>�UW@SO¬DK<�v�<!D`5UWDKDuvZB�RYq�T8@SRA<�B�\]_=<�`5UKDWDNLS<�>V\Y>A@SDK<�OXIQRA@�T T8@SRY<�UWO�<�BZ\YqX\Y>%B}>�<!\VB�O=^èDW<!\Y\VUKO^=Up�8F!:=Dp>]\�>%BZ>A<!\�k   �J\�>�_=UW\]RY<!DBÌ©�<�\V_=UW\]UWO=F!<�OM>�UWv�<�F�@ST]r=BZ>�U f UKDWUW>$q¢F!@SO=\�>�RAB�UKOM>s�ÎÆ  >A_=<t>A@�>%B�D*>�RAB�O=\�IQ<!RJ_�<�LSUpvS<!\[`5UKDKD�UWO=F!RY<�B�\Y<�kJ��<!F!B�:=\A<~_�<�UK\[T]@�RA<�RAUK\YGaB�v�<!RY\A<~B�O�^f <!F!B�:=\A<]>�_=<�Ie>�UK\tF!@S\�>�Dpq¢_�<VT�:=\�>~LSUpvS<,Ba_=UKL�_=<!R,�h\Y>�BZ>�<ªw$UWO=^=<!r#<!O�^=<!OM>   LSUWIe>!coB�O�^O=@Z>5_=UKLS_�<!R��h\�>%BZ>A<�w�^=<!r#<!O=^�<!OM>   r=RA<�\AF!RYU f <!^1>�_=<�Ie>�k

Page 18: 9= . >@?A . B C D1 E › files › docs › colloqpapers › w05 › Sc… · 0 (* %-$#+1 $3245$768&3 9:;&< # 9=" . >@?A . B C" D1 E FHGJILKMGON5PRQLSTPRQ UMSVK W;XZY\[^]`_Vacbd_eY\fZahgjilknmpo_eY\]

���������������� !���#"$ %� ���

¨)©?` ´ ¯�µ`¶l·baÜ×F±�Ù ã5Ý�¯^S ã�Ù-¯\×Èè/¶¶$T]B�LSUWO=<V>�_=BZ>8BsIhB�RAT8<!R�F!B�O�F%_=@P@�\A< f <�>$`�<�<!OXr=DB�OM>AUKO=Ls>$`b@¢F�RA@Sr�\!kH¡N_=<1T8@SRA<é <�B�\YUKDpq�\Y>A<�B�DKB f DW<�§SF�RA@Srs�h<�k¨L=ko`�BZ>A<!RAT8<!DW@SO   _zBZ\�Bj_=UKL�_=<!R7vZB�DW:=<5r�<�R�_=B�O=^�IQ:=D f :�>uB\YDKUKL�_�>ADWq?DW@�`�<�RJá�:zB�OM>�Up>$q�@�:�>�r=:P>�kJ¡N_�<�DK<�\A\ é <�B�\YUKDpq1\Y>�<!B�DB f DK<Z§#F�RA@Sr��Q<�k¨L=kJF�@�>A>A@SO  _zBZ\uB�DW@Ì`b<!Rbv�BZDK:=<�r�<�Ru_zB�O�^�IQ:=D f :�>5B�\YDKUWLS_M>�DWq�_=UKLS_�<!R�á�:zBZO�>AUW>$q]@S:�>Ar=:�>�k.�[\A\Y:=T]<>A_zBZ>;UWO3B]`b@SRADW^s`5UW>A_sO=@V>A_=<�Ie>;>A_=<�T8@SRA<t<�B�\YUKDpq�\�>�<!B�DB f DK<�F!RA@�rs`�@S:�DK^ f <�T8@SRA<r=RY@��=>�B f DK<Zk ± UWv�<!O3>�_=<~r#@S\Y\AU f UKDKUp>$qa@�I�>�_=<�Ie>�c�>�_=<~DW<!\Y\i<�B�\YUKDWq�\Y>A<�B�DKB f DK<�F!RA@�r¬T]B�qf <�T8@SRA<�r=RY@��=>%B f DK<Zc�B�O�^3\A@V>A_=<�r#@�>�<�OM>�UBZD�IQ@SR5>�_�<�Ie>;T]B�q�BZÉ�<�F�>JF!RA@�rsF%_=@SUWF!<�kJ¶�IIQ<!B�R�@�I�>A_=<�Ie>b^=UK\YF!@S:�R�B�LS<�\�BiIhB�RYT]<�R�IQRY@ST r=DKB�OM>�UWO=L�B�T8@SRA<5r=RY@��=>�B f DK<5F�RA@Srdc�>�_�<!RA<`5UWDKD f <�B~^=<!F�RA<�BZ\A<�UKO1<��8F!UW<!O=F�q1^=:=<j>�@~>�_�<�DKB�F%GV@ZIo<�O�IQ@SRAF�<!T8<!OM>�k l H

� @SO=^�UW>�UW@SOzB�DM@�O�F!RY@Sr�F%_�@SUKF�<�>A_=<bF�@ST8rzB�R�B}>�UWv�<b\�>%BZ>AUKF�\y^=<�RAUpvS<!^tUKO�>�_=<�r=RA<�v|UK@S:=\\Y<!F�>AUK@SO~\Y_=@S:=DW^�\Y>AUKDWD|_�@SDK^dcSB�DW>A_=@S:=LS_�>�_=<�q�`5UWDKD�O=@�>o_=@SDK^�UWI�@SO=<�^=@P<�\7O=@�>oF!@SO�^=UW>AUK@SO@SO3F�RA@Sr3F%_�@SUKF�<�k��J\iBV>A_=UK<�I f <!F�@ST8<!\;DW<!\A\;>ARA:=\�>$`�@�RY>�_Mq3_�<�`5UKDKD f <�>�RAB�O=\YIQ<�RA<�^¢B_=UWLS_=<�RdLSUWIe>dUWI�>�_=<.IhB�RYT]<�RdF!@�O�>AUKO�:=<�\�r�DB�OM>�UWO=L�>A_=<�\�B�T8<.F!RY@Srdk�¶�IP>A_=<.>�_=UW<�I f <�F!@ST8<!\\Y@]:=OM>ARA:=\�>$`�@SR�>�_Mqa>�_zBZ>N>A_=<jIhB�RAT8<!RN\�`5UW>�F%_�<!\5>�@]B�DW@�`�<�R5vZB�DW:=<jF!RY@Srdc=>�_�<!OsB~DW<!\A\>ARA:=\�>$`�@SR�>�_Mqg>A_=UK<�IN`5UKDWDbBZF�>�:=B�DKDpq3RA<�F!<!UpvS<1B�L�UWIe>�`5_=UKF%_CUW\�DW@Ì`b<!RtUKOgvZB�DW:=<�kC�h¡N_=<\AB�T]<jBZOzB�DWq|\YUK\N_=@SDW^=\5B�\N>�_�<�r�RA@ f B f UKDWUW>$q]@�I7B~DW@Ì`£F!@�\Y>�\Y>�BZ>�<jLS@|<!\5:=r   k

¶$T]B�LSUKO�<;>$`�@VIhBZRAT8<!RA\N`5_=@VB�RA< f @�>�_�UKO=^�UWÉ�<!RA<�OM> f <�>$`b<!<�Osr=DKB�OM>�UKO�L�>A_=<�_=UKLS_vZB�DW:=<JBZO=^VDW@Ì`�v�BZDK:=<�F!RY@Sr=\!c f :�>bIQ@SR�_=UK\�>�@SRYUKF�BZDzRA<�BZ\A@SO=\b@SO=<[F%_=@P@�\A<!\�>�@tr=DB�OM>�>�_=<_=UWLS_gvZB�DW:=<,F!RY@SrÔB�O=^C>A_=<?@�>A_=<!R�F%_�@P@S\Y<!\~>�@�r=DB�OM>�>A_=<,DW@Ì`�vZB�DW:=<,F!RY@Srdk¬¯[\YUKO=LB�OsB�OzB�DpqP\YUK\�\AUWT]UWDB�Ru>A@V>�_zB}>JIQ@SR[BV^=<�F!RA<!B�\A<~UWO�>�RY:=\Y>$`b@SR�>�_=UWO=<!\Y\!cd¶N�zO=^�>�_zBZ>[>�_=<IhB�RYT]<�R�`5_=@gr�DB�OM>�\~>A_=<�T8@SRY<a<!B�\AUWDWqH\�>�<!B�DB f DK<?F!RY@SrX`5UWDKDuL�UWvS<1T8@SRA<1LSUpIe>�\�B�O�^>ARA:=\�>[DW<!\Y\!k

¨)©Cc ã5¯�ÚTS-­oÝ�­�±�×'ß\¶ U)±0­�±7×Èè/Ø ³�Ý�¯\Ú ­ dëÖ-¶Cå�ÕK¶¥Ýt×�¯+µ e Ö-¯\Ö�®�åÚ ¯�°-ØÍ´ ¯�µ`¶l·

¶8^=<!RYUWv�<!^¤F!@ST8rzB�RABZ>�UpvS<s\�>%BZ>AUKF�\,IQRA@ST BC^�q|OzB�T8UKFsDWUKT8UW>A<!^Pw�F!@ST8T]Up>�T8<!OM>~T8@P^�<!DB f @�vS<Zc�B�O�^tO=@�`g^=<!RYUWvS<�F!@�T]rzBZR�B f DW<7F!@�T]rzBZR�BZ>AUWvS<.\�>%BZ>AUKF�\dIQRA@STÕB5��<�F%G�<�RAUBZO?�h@�O=<�wr#<!RYUK@|^~B�O=@SOMq|T8@S:=\7>�_�UK<�I   T8@P^�<!Dµk*¶$O8B;\AUWT]r�DK<u�b<!F%G�<�RAUKB�O]T8@|^=<!DÎcSB�O�B�O�@SOMqPT8@S:=\>A_=UK<�Iu^=<�F!UK^�<!\t`5_�<�>�_�<!R�@�RtO=@Z>t>A@�\�>�<�BZD f qEF!@�T]rzBZRAUKO�La>A_=<]LSB�UKO=\iIQRY@STÚ\Y>A<�B�DWUKO=L`5Up>�_E>�_=<8r=RA@ f B f UWDKUW>$q�@�I f <�UKO=L1F�BZ:=LS_M>�BZO=^gr=:�O=UK\Y_=<!^dk]¡N_=<Vr�RA@ f B f UKDWUW>$q�@�I f <�wUWO=L3F�B�:�LS_M>VUWOC>�_=UW\8T8@|^=<!DNBZO=^H>�_=<aF!@S\�>8@�IJ\�>�<!B�DKUWO=L3UKOH>�_�<a^PqPO=B�T]UWF?DKUWT]Up>�<!^|wF�@ST]T8UW>AT]<�OM>[T8@|^=<!D�F�B�O f <�T8<�BZ\A:=RY<!^ f q�á�:=Up>�<t\AUKT8UKDKB�RuvZB�RAUKB f DW<!\�UKO�>A_=<�^zBZ>�B�k�[\�>A_=<br�RA@ f B f UKDWUW>$q[@�I f <!UKO�L�F!B�:=LS_M>yRAUW\A<!\�cZ>A_=<br#@�>A<!OM>�UKB�DS>�_=UW<�I f <�F!@ST8<!\�DK<�\A\�DKUKGZ<!Dpq·:b Æ�Ç�ÌrÞ'Ô¦Î�ɾ̲ÕÍÇ�Ì\Ԧ˾Ì�ë±ÖZÔ�Ì�É Ñ�Ô�ÕLÇ�Ô�ÚÙÖuÐ¥Ì�Ï\Î�Ò�ɾÌ;Ô�é+Õ¾Ç�Ì�ÈÊÑ�Î�Ð�ÈÛÚÊÈÛÕ½×BÔné¨ÕÍÇ�Ì�Õ¾Ç�ÈÊÌdéJÕ¾Ô¹ÏdÔ¦ë�ë-ÈÛÕLÕ¾ÔÚÛÈÊë-ÈèÕÍÈÛÑ�â-Õ¾Ç�Ì\écÕ�ð

Page 19: 9= . >@?A . B C D1 E › files › docs › colloqpapers › w05 › Sc… · 0 (* %-$#+1 $3245$768&3 9:;&< # 9=" . >@?A . B C" D1 E FHGJILKMGON5PRQLSTPRQ UMSVK W;XZY\[^]`_Vacbd_eY\fZahgjilknmpo_eY\]

���������������� !���#"$ %� ���

>A@aF%_�@P@S\Y<8>A@�\�>�<!B�Dµk8�JDW\A@=c*B�\tB,IhB�RAT8<!Rjr=DKB�OM>�\iF�RA@Sr=\j`5_=UWF%_CB�RY<8T8@SRY<�v�BZDK:zB f DK<r#<!RN_zBZO=^�IQ:=D�\�>�@SDW<!O1>�_=<�Ie>�`5UWDKD�UKO=F�RA<�BZ\A<�k

¶�>5UK\�r�@S\Y\AU f DK<J>A@~<�©|>�<�O=^1>�_=<���<�F%G�<!RYUB�O1T8@P^�<!D�>A@8B�F!F�@S:=OM>NIQ@SR�>A_=<iRAUW\AG,B�v�<!R�w\YUK@SOÔ@�I�>�_=<?IhB�RYT]<�R!kH¶$OÔ>�_=<a@SO=<ªw$r#<!RYUK@|^ÔB�O=@SOMq|T]@�:=\�T]@|^=<!DÎc�B3IhBZRAT8<!R�`5_=@¬UK\T8@SRA<�RAUK\YG�B�vS<�RA\Y<[`b@S:=DK^�RABZ>�_=<�R.\Ar#<!O=^]B;��©P<!^VB�T]@�:=OM>.@SO�r=RA@Z>�<!F�>�UW@SO~>�_zB�O�RY:=OVBLSRY<�BZ>A<!R5RAUW\AG,@ZI f <!UWO=L�\Y>�@�DK<!O1IQRA@�T�k.¡N_�:=\�c�B~T8@SRA<jRAUW\AGVB�v�<!RY\A<tIhBZRAT8<!Ru`5UKDWDdT8@SOPwUp>�@SR;T8@SRY<�c�UKO�F!RA<!B�\AUWO=L?>�_=<~>A_=UK<�I!§¨\ir=RA@ f B f UWDKUW>$q�@�I f <�UKO=L1F!B�:=LS_M>�k�¡N_�:=\�coB?T8@SRA<RYUK\AGVB�vS<!RY\A<�IhB�RAT8<!R�`5UWDKDd<ª©Pr�<�RAUK<�O=F!<�DK<�\A\u>A_=<�Ie>5>�_=B�O�B~DW<!\A\5RYUK\AG,B�v�<!RY\A<jIhB�RAT8<!R�k

¡N_=<3�b<!F%G�<�RAUKB�OÙT]@|^=<�D[F!B�OÙB�DW\A@ f <�<ª©P>A<!O=^�<!^Ù>�@g>�B�G�<�UKOM>�@gB�F!F�@S:=OM>,>�RY:=\Y>B�O�^a>ARA:=\�>$`�@SR�>�_=UWO=<!\Y\!k�¶�Io>A_=<jr�@�>A<!OM>�UKB�D�>A_=UK<�IoRY<!F!<�UWv�<!\5>�RA:�\Y>$`b@SRY>A_=UKO=<�\A\[^=UK\Y:�>�UWDKUW>$q`5_=<�O]_�<N\Y>�<!B�DK\�c�B�\�B;r#@�>�<�O�>AUB�D|>�_=UW<�I f <!F!@�T]<�\.T]@SRY<�>�RY:=\Y>$`b@SR�>�_Mq�_=<NUK\.DW<!\Y\.DKUKGZ<!Dpq>A@]F%_=@|@S\Y<�>A@V\Y>A<�B�DÎkNß;O=<�F�B�O�B�DK\Y@�^=<��zO�<t>�RY:=\Y>!c�UKO�B]R�B}>�_=<�R[BZ^�_=@|Fi`uB�qSc�B�\5>�_=<r=RY@ f B f UKDKUp>$qH`5UW>A_è`5_=UKF%_¤BgIhB�RYT]<�R]>A_=UKO=G�\?_=UW\VO=<�UKLS_ f @SRA\]`5UKDKD�F%_=@|@S\A<s>A@H\Y>A<�B�DIQRY@STÐ_�UKTak7¶$O?>�_=UW\NF�B�\Y<�c�B�\u>A_=<ir=RA@ f B f UWDKUW>$q8@�I f <!UWO=L~F�B�:�LS_M>[RYUK\Y<!\!c=B�O�<!UKL�_ f @SR�§Ü\>ARA:=\�>$`�@SR�>�_=UWO=<!\Y\;RAUW\A<�\!c�@SR5>�_=<jIhB�RAT8<!R�§Ü\5RYUK\AG1B�v�<!RA\YUK@SO�UKO=F�RA<�BZ\A<!\�c#>A_=<jIhB�RAT8<!RN`5UKDWDf <!F�@ST]<iT8@SRY<;>�RA:�\Y>�UWO=L=k

¡N_=@S:�LS_H>�_=<1\AUWT]r�DK<VT8@|^=<!Db@�I[BE@�O=<�w�\A_=@�>�LSB�T]<,B�O=^ÔB�O�B�O=@�O�q|T8@S:=\�>A_=UK<�IF!B�O f <1<�©|>A<!O=^=<�^X>A@¢BZF!F!@�:=OM>8IQ@�R�>�RA:�\Y>]B�O=^H>�RY:=\Y>$`b@SR�>�_=UWO=<!\Y\!cuUp>�`5UKDWD�O=@�>8LSUpvS<F�@ST]r=B�R�BZ>AUWv�<8\�>%BZ>AUKF�\tIQ@SR�LSUWIe>A\jLSUWv�<!Odka¡N_=<]IhBZF�>�>�_zBZ>�UW>�UK\tB�@�O=<Vr#<!RYUK@|^¢T8@P^�<!DB�O�^¬>A_=<8>A_=UK<�I�UW\�B�O=@SOMq|T]@�:=\jr=RA<�F!DK:�^=<!\j>�_=<8r#@�>�<�O�>AUB�DyIQ@SRj:=\AUWO=La>AR�B�O�\YIQ<!RY\�BZ\tBT8<�B�O�\N@�IoF�@SOM>�RAB�F�>AUKO=L8UKO?@SRY^=<!RN>A@8DWUKT8UW>�>�_=<�Ie>�k

¨)©?f ã5¯�ÚTS-­oÝt×ÈØU¯�Ö ¯�³gdÜÖ-¶CåhUOÙ-¯o±1­xÖ-µ ¬#×ÈÚa×F±0¶lµOåYã5¯\ÚaÚÛ×'±7Ú ¶�Ö�±ÕBÝ�¶lµN×�èC±7×ȯ\Ö-Ø

Ò�<�>j:�\iRA<�v|UW<�`àB�O=^EF!@ST8rzB�RY<�>�_=<~F�@ST8rzB�R�B}>�UWv�<�\Y>�BZ>�UWF!\;UWT]r�DKUK<�^ f qs>A_=<~DKUWT]Up>�<!^|wF�@ST]T8UW>AT]<�OM>�BZO=^,@SO=<Jr�<�RAUK@|^VT8@|^=<!DW\b@�I�>A_=<�Ie>!k � @ST8rzB�R�B}>�UWv�<J\�>%BZ>AUKF!\b_zB�vS< f <!<�O^=<�RAUpvS<!^�IQ@SR~>�_=<?>A_=RA<�<�<�O=^=@SLS<�O=@S:=\8vZB�RAUKB f DK<�\!ç?LSUpIe>�\~LSUpvS<�Odc�>�_�<�Ie>8<�©Pr#<!RAUW<!O=F�<!^dcB�O�^X>�RY:=\Y>!kÙ¡N_=<�>A_=RA<�<�T]B�UKOÔF!BZ>�<�LS@SRAUW<!\8@�Ii<ª©�@�LS<!O=@�:=\]vZB�RYUB f DW<!\8B�RY<a>A_=<�F�@S\Y>@�I�\�>�<�BZDKUKO�L=c7>�_=<1RYUK\AGgB�vS<!RY\AUW@SOÔ@�I[>A_=<,IhB�RYT]<�R!c�B�O=^H>�_�<,>�RA:�\Y>$`b@SRY>A_=UKO=<�\A\8@�I[_=UK\O=<�UKLS_ f @SRA\�k7�JDW\A@=cM>A_=<JF�RA@Sr]F%_=@SUKF�<[^�<!F!UW\AUW@SOVUW\�T]B�^=< f q�>�_=<5IhB�RAT8<!R�UKO�>�_�<[T8@P^�<!Df <�IQ@SRY<�_=UW\J@�>A_=<!R[^=<!F�UK\YUK@SO=\[RA<�LMB�RA^�UKO=L]LSUWIe>A\;B�O=^�>�_=<�Ie>�c�\Y@=c�@�O=<�F!B�O3^=<!RYUWv�<�F!@ST~wrzBZR�BZ>AUWvS<�\Y>%B}>�UKF�\;IQ@SR;>�_=BZ>;vZB�RAUKB f DW<�B�\;`b<!DWDµk�¶5`5UKDWDoDW@P@SGaBZ>j<!B�F%_¬UKOs>�:�RAOdc*B�O�^¢B\Y:=T]T]B�R�q,@�I�>�_=<jF�@ST]r=B�R�BZ>AUWv�<i\Y>%B}>�UKF�\NF�B�O f <jIQ@�:=O=^aUKO?¡yB f DK<t&Pk

¡N_=<iDWUKT8UW>�<�^Pw$F�@ST8T]Up>�T8<!OM>7T8@P^�<!D�r�RA<!^�UKF�>A\�>�_=BZ>5B�\�>A_=<;F�@S\Y>5@�I*\�>�<!B�DKUWO=L�LS@|<!\:=r�B�IhBZRAT8<!Ru`5UKDWD*B   LSUWv�<�B8DW@Ì`b<!R5>�@Z>%B�DdvZB�DW:=<j@�I7LSUpIe>�\�c f   <ª©Pr�<�RAUK<�O=F!<�DK<�\A\5>�_=<�Ie>�cB�O�^XF   >ARA:=\�>8T]@SRY<�kÔ�J\~>A_=<?IhB�RAT8<!R f <!F�@ST]<�\�T]@SRY<?RAUW\AGHB�vS<�RA\Y<�_=<1\A_�@S:=DK^XB  

Page 20: 9= . >@?A . B C D1 E › files › docs › colloqpapers › w05 › Sc… · 0 (* %-$#+1 $3245$768&3 9:;&< # 9=" . >@?A . B C" D1 E FHGJILKMGON5PRQLSTPRQ UMSVK W;XZY\[^]`_Vacbd_eY\fZahgjilknmpo_eY\]

���������������� !���#"$ %� &�Ñ

¡yB f DW<8&Pçji3q|k�}��7py�0{Wv#kAn���{��0{yv��8��s�pqAk {y�¥n�~�v�kÄv�{Wn u�l.��qAkÄkÄv�{yk5n z|{Sk5q/u¥n ~��zluÜ�Bq|z¥nml.}onYpv:q/uÜ��z¥q|zon¥k5qAj��]prqs�ut]v3k5q/u¥n ~

¡N_=<�Ie>��Q¡N_   ± UWv|UWO=La� ±   ¡�RA:�\Y>��h¡�R  � @�\Y>�@�Iy\Y>�<!B�DKUWO=L�� �   Å?w(xÅ?ymz?{ G}| K É Ñ Å�~Å | ø Ñ Å?w þÅ | É Ñ¶$T8r=DWUK<!^ f q�ßix��-� Å?w(xÅ | ø Ñ Å�~Å |�� Ñ Û�<�\

«5UK\YG,B�vS<�RA\YUK@SOC�#�   Å?w(xÅ?� ø Ñ Å�~Å?� É Ñ Å?w þÅ?� � Ѷ$T8r=DWUK<!^ f q�ßix��-� Û�<!\ Å�~Å?� � Ñ Å?w þÅ?� É Ñ

¡�RA:�\Y>$`b@SRY>A_=UKO=<�\A\��h¡u`   Å?w(xÅ?wQ� � Ñ Å&~Å?wQ� ø Ñ ÅCw þÅ?wQ� É Ñ¶$T8r=DWUK<!^ f q�ßix��-� Å?w(xÅ?wQ� ø Ñ Å&~Å?wQ� � Ñ Û�<�\

x.DKB�OM>5\Y>�<!B�DB f DK<iF�RA@Srg�Îx.D   Å?w(xÅ�� � � Ñ Å�~Å�� � É Ñ Å?w þÅ�� � ø Ѷ$T8r=DWUK<!^ f q�ßix��-� Å?w(xÅ�� � É Ñ Å�~Å�� � � Ñ Û�<�\

LSUpvS<[T]@SRY<JLSUpIe>�\bB�O=^ f   <�©Pr#<!RAUW<!O=F�<iDK<�\A\b>A_=<�Ie>!k.¡N_=<iDKUWT]Up>�<�^Pw$F�@ST]T8UW>AT�<!OM>7T8@P^�<!DB�DW\A@¬\A_=@�`5\8>�_zBZ>VB3IhB�RAT8<!R~`5UW>A_�T8@SRA<?>ARA:=\�>$`�@SR�>�_MqXO=<!UWLS_ f @SRY\�\A_=@S:�DK^èB   LSUpvS<T8@SRA<�LSUpIe>�\�B�O=^ f   >�RY:=\Y>JT]@�RA<�k�Ò*B�\�>�DWq�c#>A_=<�DWUKT8UW>A<!^Pw�F!@ST8T]Up>�T8<!OM>bT]@|^=<!D*\Y_=@�`5\>A_zBZ>�cdB�DKD�<!DW\A<�<�á|:=B�DµcdUpI�BVIhB�RAT8<!R[r=DBZO�>A\;T8@SRA<t<�B�\YUKDWq�\Y>A<�B�DKB f DW<�F!RY@Sr=\i_=<t`5UKDKDyB  LSUpvS<�T8@SRA<�LSUpIe>�\jB�O=^ f   >�RY:=\Y>tDK<�\A\]�Q`5_=UWDK<~>�_�<]<�É�<�F�>�\�@SOE>�_=<8DK<�vS<�D�@ZI�>�_�<�Ie>�B�RA<UWO=^=<�>A<!RYT]UWOzBZ>�<   ky¶$O]LS<�O=<!RAB�DµcM>A_=<[@�O=<�w�\A_=@�>bT8@P^=<�Dz@�I�BZOVB�O�@SOMqPT8@S:=\�>�_�UK<�I�TVBZG�<!\O=@�r=RA<�^=UKF�>�UK@�O=\�B f @S:P>uLSUpIe>Yw$L�UWv|UKO=L�koß;OV>A_=<J@Z>�_=<�R�_zB�O�^dc�\Y@ST]<[@�I�>�_�<Jr=RY<!^=UWF�>�UW@SO=\B f @S:�>�>�_�<�Ie>[<�©Pr�<�RAUW<!O=F�<!^s`5_=UWF%_3B�RA<tá�:=UW>A<t\�>�RA@�O=L,UKOa>�_=<t@SO=<ªw$r#<!RAUW@P^aT8@P^=<�D�B�RA<UWO=^=<�>A<!RYT]UWOzBZ>�<JUKO?>�_=<j^�q|OzBZT]UWFiDKUKT8UW>A<!^Pw�F!@ST8T8UW>�T�<�O�>�T8@P^�<!Dµk

�   öt+oö

¶$O£&�ÑSÑS&gUKO¤xoBZR�B�LS:=B�q�¶]F�@SDKDW<!F�>�<!^¦B�OÙ<ª©PF!UW>AUKO=LÔO=<�`�^=BZ>%BH\A<�>1F!@ST f UKO=UWO=Lg>AR�B}w^=Up>�UW@SOzB�Dy\A:=R�vS<�qE^=BZ>%B1@SOEr=RA@|^=:=F�>�UW@SO3`5UW>�_EO=@�OPw$\�>%B�O=^=B�RA^¬á�:=<!\�>�UK@�O=\tT8<�BZ\A:=RYUKO=LRY<�B�Dmw�`b@SRADW^]<�F!@SO=@�T]UWF5vZB�RYUB f DK<!\�\Y:=F%_1B�\�>�_=<�Ie>u<�©Pr#<!RYUK<!O�F!<!^1BZO=^,B�L�RAUKF�:=DW>A:=R�BZDzLSUWvMwUWO=L=k�«�<�\Ar#@SO=^=<�O�>A\�`�<�RA<?BZDK\A@�B�\AGZ<!^H>�_�<!UKR�DK<�vS<�D�@�IN>ARA:=\�>�k�¡�@sF�@ST]r�DK<!T8<!OM>�>�_=<\Y:=RYv�<�q¢^zBZ>%BaB�O=^ f < f <�>A>A<!R�B f DK<~>A@sB�O=\�`�<�R�á�:=<�\Y>�UW@SO=\tR�B�UW\A<!^ f qE>�_=<]T]@|^=<!DÎc�¶B�DW\A@�RAB�O?<�©Pr#<!RYUKT8<!OM>�\NT8<�B�\Y:=RAUWO=L�>�_�<;>�RA:�\Y>�cP>�RA:�\Y>$`b@SRY>A_=UKO=<�\A\�c�B�O=^1RAUW\AG]B�v�<!RY\AUK@�O@�I�>A_=<NRA<�\Ar#@SO=^=<�O�>A\!k.¶�>�UW\7á�:=UW>A<N:=O�:=\A:zBZD=>�@i_zB�vS< f @�>�_~^�<�>%BZUKDK<�^~<!F�@SO=@ST8UKFb\A:=R�vS<�q

Page 21: 9= . >@?A . B C D1 E › files › docs › colloqpapers › w05 › Sc… · 0 (* %-$#+1 $3245$768&3 9:;&< # 9=" . >@?A . B C" D1 E FHGJILKMGON5PRQLSTPRQ UMSVK W;XZY\[^]`_Vacbd_eY\fZahgjilknmpo_eY\]

���������������� !���#"$ %� & �

^zB}>%B�B�O=^a<�©Pr#<!RAUWT]<�OM>%B�DdT8<�BZ\A:=RY<!\!k¶$O ���S��� >�_=<iÒ*B�O�^a¡�<!O�:=RY< � <!OM>�<�R5BZ>u>�_�<j¯[O=UpvS<!RY\AUp>$q,@�I�ϤUW\AF!@�O=\AUWO?UKOaÝ�B�^�Upw

\Y@SOaB�O=^1>�_=< � <!OM>ARA@]xoB�RAB�LS:zB�qS@8^=<j×.\Y>A:=^=UW@S\[ÓP@PF�UK@SD��@SLSUWF!@S\bUKO?�J\Y:=O=F�U��@SO1`�@�RAG�<�^>A@SLS<�>A_=<!R�UKO~>A_=<J^=<�\AUWLSOVBZO=^VUWT]r=DW<!T8<!OM>%B}>�UK@�O�@�Id>A_=<[@�RAUKL�UKOzB�DP\A:=R�vS<�qV@�IdÆSÑSÑjRA:=RAB�DxyB�R�B�L�:zB�qMB�OH_=@�:=\A<�_=@SDK^�\~UKOC\YUp©|>�<�<!OHv|UKDKDKB�LS<�\tUWOg>�_=RY<!<,^�<!rzB�R�>�T8<!OM>�\a�QF!@ST8rzB�RAB}wf DW<~>�@a\Y>%B}>�<!\   BZF!RA@�\A\t>A_=<8F!@S:=OM>ARYqSkV¡N_=UK\j`uBZ\�B1R�B�O�^=@STÚ\�BZT]r=DW<�c*\Y>AR�BZ>AUW�z<�^ f qDKB�O=^Pw�_=@SDK^�UKO=LS\�ko¡N_=<j@SRYUKLSUWOzB�D#\A:=R�vS<�qa`�B�\NIQ@SDWDK@�`�<�^1:=r f q?\Y: f \Y<!á�:=<!OM>iRY@S:=O=^�\�@ZI^zB}>%BVF�@SDKDW<!F�>AUK@SO�UKO ������° c ���S�S� c�B�O=^dcdT8@S\�>;RA<�F!<�O�>ADWq�c�¶�F�@SDKDW<!F�>�<!^s>A_=<�DKB�\Y>JRA@S:=O�^UWO�&ZÑSÑM&Pk7�[DKDdRY@S:=O=^�\�UWO=F!DW:=^=<i^=<�>%B�UWDK<�^?UKO�IQ@SRYTVB}>�UK@�O,@SO1r=RA@|^=:=F�>�UW@SOaB�O=^1UKO=F�@ST8<�k¶$OC&�ÑSÑM&,¶iB�^�^=<!^¢á|:�<!\Y>AUK@SO�\tRY<!DB}>�<!^E>�@1>�_�<�Ie>t<�©Pr�<�RAUW<!O=F�<!^dcyDK<�v�<!DW\t@�Ib>�RY:=\Y>!coB�O�^LSUpIe>�\NLSUpvS<�Odkb�[DW>A_=@S:=LS_?>A_=<t^=BZ>%B�\A<�>[UW\5R�BZ>A_=<!R5\AT]B�DWDµcP`5Up>�_a@SO=Dpqa&S&�Æ~_=@S:�\A<!_�@SDK^=\UWO�>A<!R�vPUW<�`b<!^�UKO�&�ÑSÑM&PczUp>5UK\�á�:=UW>A<�^�<�>%BZUKDK<�^dczRA<�^=:=F�UKO=L8r�@Z>�<!OM>AUB�D�@ST8UW>Y>�<�^1vZB�RYUB f DK<r=RY@ f DW<!T8\!k

¡N_=<�Ie>]<ª©Pr�<�RAUK<�O=F!<�^�BZO=^ÔLSUWIe>A\�LSUWv�<!OC`b<!RY<�T8<�B�\Y:=RA<�^�B�\~^=<��=O=<!^ f qC>�_=<?RY<�w\Yr�@SO�^=<!OM>�\~>A_=<!T8\A<�DWvS<�\!kgn�@�R�<�v�<!R�qHF!RY@SrH`5_=UKF%_C>A_=<?_=@S:=\Y<!_=@�DK^Hr=DKB�OM>�<!^ÔUWOg>�_=<DKB�\Y>5qS<!B�RJ>A_=<�q1`b<!RA<�B�\AGZ<!^s>�_�<�>A@�>%B�D�B�T8@S:=OM>�>�_=<�qar=RA@|^=:=F�<!^dk�¡N_=<!Os>A_=<�q1`b<!RY<B�\YG�<�^a_�@Ì`¦T�:�F%_?@�I�>�_zB}>�`�B�\NF!@SO�\A:=T8<!^,`5Up>�_=UWO]>�_�<;_=@S:=\Y<!_=@�DK^dcP_=@�`�T�:�F%_,`uB�\IQ<�^a>A@,B�O=UWTVBZDK\!cP_=@�`ÕT�:=F%_a`uBZ\[LSUpvS<�OsB�`uB�q?>A@]IQRAUW<!O=^�\�@�R5IQ<�DKDW@Ì`¦v|UKDWDB�LS<�RA\�c=_=@�`T�:�F%_�`�B�\�\Y>A@SDK<�OdcMB�O�^8_�@Ì`XT�:=F%_�`�B�\.\Y>AUKDKDPUKO�\�>�@SRAB�LS<Zk7�Ù\AUWT]UWDB�R*r=RY@PF�<!^=:=RY<N`uB�\:=\Y<!^�IQ@�R[BZO=UKT]B�DK\�@Ì`5O�<!^3B�O�^a>A_=<!UWR�^�<!RAUpvZBZ>�<�\��Q\A:=F%_3BZ\[<�LSLS\!c�_=@�O=<�q�c�B�O�^�T8UKDKG   cB�O�^aIQ@SRN<ª©|>�R�BZF�>�UpvS<�\��Q\A:=F%_3BZ\5�=RA<�`b@|@P^�B�O=^aF!@MBZD   k�Ø�@S:=\Y<!_=@SDW^=\5`�<�RA<tB�DK\Y@]BZ\AG�<�^`5_zB}>�>A@P@�DK\o`b<!RY<[\�>�@SDW<!O~IQRA@ST >�_=<�T UKO~>�_�<�DKB�\Y>.q�<�B�R�c|B�O=^�>�@jDKUW\Y>�B�OMq�@�>A_=<!R.Up>�<�T]\\�>�@SDW<!OEIQRA@ST�>�_=<�T�kVÓP:=T8TVBZRYqs\�>%BZ>AUK\�>�UKF�\jF�B�O f <~IQ@S:�O=^¢UWOE¡oB f DK<8Æ�k]�[@�>A<�>A_zBZ>LSUpIe>�\jLSUpvS<!OCB�RA<VB�r=r=RY@�©PUWTVBZ>A<!Dpqs>�_=RY<!<8>�UKT8<!\j>�_�<V\AUW³!<]@�Iu>�_�<�Ie>,�h@�IN\YTVBZDKD�UW>A<!T8\  <ª©�r#<!RYUK<�O=F!<�^dk ± UpvS<!O?>A_=<i^�q|OzB�T8UKF;DWUKT8UW>A<!^Pw�F!@ST8T]Up>�T�<!OM>.T8@|^=<!DÎcPUp>u`�@�:=DK^ f <i<�Iw�zF�UK<�O�>�@SO1>�_�<�<�á�:=UKDWU f RYUK:=T�rzBZ>A_aIQ@SRNL�UWIe>�\u>A@ f <jDB�RYLS<!Ru>A_zB�O?>�_�<�Ie>�k�¶$O�B�^=^=Up>�UK@�Odc>A_=<?T]<!B�\A:�RA<?@�I�LSUpIe>�\�UWO=F!DW:=^=<�\~LSUWIe>A\�LSUpvS<!OH>A@3DKUKT8UW>j>A_=<�Ie>8B�O�^C>�_=@S\Y<?LSUWv�<!OHIQ@SR@�>A_=<!RNRY<�B�\Y@SO=\�k

¶�B�DK\Y@VF!B�RARYUK<!^�@S:�>J>$`b@?<!F�@SO=@ST8UKF�<�©Pr#<!RYUKT8<!OM>�\iBZT]@SO�LV\A:�RYvS<�qsRY<!\Ar#@SO=^�<!OM>�\�c@SO�<JT8<�B�\Y:=RAUWO=L�>�RY:=\Y>uB�O=^,>ARA:=\�>$`�@SR�>�_=UWO=<!\Y\!czBZO=^,>�_=<[@�>�_�<!RuT8<�B�\Y:=RAUWO=L�RYUK\YG]B�v�<!R�w\YUK@SOdk��ÖT8@SRA<8^=<�>%B�UWDK<!^¢^=<!\YF!RYUKr�>AUK@SOC@ZIN>�_=<,LSB�T]<�\tF!B�O f <]IQ@S:=O�^CUKOÔÓ|F%_=<!F%_M>�<�R�Î&�ÑSÑ °�  c f :�>,¶�`5UWDKDu^�<!\AF�RAU f <a>�_=<�T f RAUW<�î=qÔ_=<�RA<ZkÙ�[Ie>�<�R8>A_=RA<�<�@SR�IQ@S:=R�^zB�q|\V@ZI\Y:=RYv�<�q|UKO=LVUKO�<!B�F%_�v|UKDWDB�L�<;>�_=<t<!O�:=T8<!R�B}>�@SRY\JUKOMv|UW>A<!^�B]r=DKB�q�<!R�IQRA@ST²<!B�F%_s_=@S:�\A<�w_=@�DK^V`5_=UWF%_1_zB�^?rzB�R�>�UWF!UKr=BZ>�<�^,UKO,>A_=<i\A:=R�vS<�q,>�@~r=DKB�q]>A_=<iLMB�T8<!\�k ���S� @�I*>A_=<j&S&�ÆIhB�T8UKDWUK<�\o\A:�RYvS<�qS<�^?\A<!OM>�BjIhBZT]UWDWqtT]<�T f <�R7>�@�r=DB�q�>A_=<5LMB�T8<�k l�Q���<�>$`b<!<�OV>�_=<5>$`b@· c Æ�Ç�Ì;Ñ�ÈÛÑ�Ì�Ç�Ô¦Ò�É­Ì�Ç�Ô�ÚÙÖ�É É­Ò�˾î¦Ì\×�ÌÝÖ¹ÈÛÑ�Õ¾Ç�Ì�ñ�ÎnÓ�Î�Ñ�Ì�ɾ̲ÈÊë-ë�ÈÊâ�ËÄÎnÑ�Õ î�ÈÊÚÊÚÊÎ�â�Ì;Ö�ÈÊÖ¤Ñ�ÔnÕLÓ�În˾վÈÙÏdÈÊÓ�ÎnÕ¾ÌÈÛÑ%Õ¾Ç�Ì�â¦Î�ë�ÌÝÉ\ð êz¸�ÏdÚÊÒ�ÖZÈÊÑ�â´ÕÍÇ�̪ñ¦Î�Ó�ÎnÑ�ÌÝɭ̦á�ô�Ç�ÔCÎ�˾̤ëlÒ�ÏÄÇ%ôJÌ�Î�ÚèÕÍÇ�ÈÊÌ\˯ÕÍÇ�ÎnÑ�Õ¾Ç�Ì�˾ÌÝɽÕHÔné,ÕÍÇ�Ì

Page 22: 9= . >@?A . B C D1 E › files › docs › colloqpapers › w05 › Sc… · 0 (* %-$#+1 $3245$768&3 9:;&< # 9=" . >@?A . B C" D1 E FHGJILKMGON5PRQLSTPRQ UMSVK W;XZY\[^]`_Vacbd_eY\fZahgjilknmpo_eY\]

���������������� !���#"$ %� &S&

¡oB f DK<jÆ�çu��jlkÄk5�7p�n��C{W�U{yv���{yv��8���BZRAUB f DK< Ý�<�B�O �ÎÓ|>�^dk�9;<�v#k  ¡N_�<�Ie>[×o©�r#<!RYUK<�O=F!<�^_� ���S� cÜÑSÑSÑ �ÎÆSÆ � c ÑSÑ�Ñ  ± UWIe>A\ ± UWvS<�O Æ�Ñ � cÜÑSÑSÑ � Þ & ° c ÑSÑ�Ñ  �[O=O�:zB�D�¶$O=F�@ST8< & � c Æ�ÑSÑ�cÜÑSÑSÑ � í &Pc � ÑSÑPc ÑSÑ�Ñ  n�B�T8UKDpqVÓPUK³�< Þ k � �µ&Pk °� �[^=:=Dp>[Ý�B�DK<�\ � k � � � k &  � DW@S\A<j«5<!DKBZ>�UpvS<�\�UWOX�;UWDKDBZLS< Æ�k ��� �ÎÆ�kÜÑ  ��@�@SO=<�xoB�\Y\A<�\;noUW<!DK^ °S° �ÍiT�>�@]xy@SDWUKF!< ° kÜÑ � �Î&Pk �S�M � @�I.Ó�>�<�BZDB f DW< � RA@�r=\ &|k Æ � � k �Ì �JUKDWDB�LS<;Ý�<!^�UB�OaÒ*B�O=^�ßJ`5O=<!^ & ° k °S° � �Sí k ���M ß f \ &S&�Æ� Æ�Ç�Ì,˾Ì�ÚÛÌ�î`ÎnÑ�Õ�̹¸�ÏÄÇ�ÎnÑ�â�Ì ËÍÎnÕ¾ÌLÈÊÉ�Î�Ó�Ó�ËÍÔ�¸ZÈÛëDÎ`ÕÍÌ\ÚÊ×Nå�á Á�Ä�Ä�ï Ò�Î�ËÍÎ�Ñ�ÈÊÌ�É'Õ¾Ô-ÕÍÇ�̲ÖZÔ�ÚÊÚÙÎnËÝð

LMBZT]<�\!cz>�_=<tr=DB�q�<!RA\�`�@�O3B�O3B�vS<�R�B�L�<�@�I7>$`b@,^zB�q|\!§#`uBZLS<!\[UKOsB8r�<�RAUW@P^a@�I7>$`b@,@SR>A_=RA<�<�_�@S:=RA\�k

¡N_=<ELMB�T8<�§¨\?UKO�\Y>�RY:=F�>AUK@SO�\,`�<�RA<ELSUWv�<!O¦UKO¤BHLSRY@S:=r¤\A<�>A>�UWO=LÔUKOÙ<!B�F%_¦v|UWDKDBZLS<`5Up>�_3O=@?á�:=<�\Y>�UW@SO=\jB�DWDK@�`b<!^dkj¡N_=<�O¬>A_=<�r=DKB�q�<!RY\j`b<!RY<~F�B�DWDK<�^sUKOM>�@,>A_=<~RA@|@ST�@SO=<BZ>?BH>AUKT8<�cNLSUpvS<�O£BH\Y<!F!@�O=^£<ª©Pr=DB�O=BZ>�UW@SOdc�B�O=^¦B�DWDK@�`�<�^è>�@ÔB�\YGèB�OMqÙá�:=<�\Y>AUK@SO=\UWOgr=RYUWvZBZ>�<Zk?¡N_=<,RYUK\AG3LSB�T]<�`�B�\�r=DKB�qS<!^C�=RA\Y>!k1¡N_=<,UKOMv�<!\Y>A@SRt`�B�\�L�UWvS<�OCB�\Y:=T@�I5T8@SO=<�q��h<!á�:=UpvZB�DK<�O�>t>�@�>$`b@Zwµ>�_=UWRA^=\t@�I5@SO=<]^zB�q�§¨\�`�B�LS<!\   B�O=^C`�B�\�L�UWvS<�Og�=v�<F%_=@�UKF!<�\i@�I�_=@�` T�:�F%_��QUWI�B�OMq   >�@?UWO�v�<!\�>�k�¡N_=<~<ª©Pr�<�RAUKT8<!OM>A<!R;>�_�<!O¬RA@SDWDK<!^sB,^=UK<>A@8^�<�>�<�RAT8UKO=<;>A_=<jUKOMvS<�\Y>A@SR!§¨\[r=B�q�@�É�\!k

�[Ie>A<!R�>A_zBZ>b>�_=<J>ARA:=\�>uLMBZT]<�`uB�\�r=DB�qS<�^dk l�^V¶�R�B�O]>�_=<J>ARA:=\�>;�ZUWOMvS<!\�>�T8<!OM>NLMBZT]<@SRYUKLSUWOzB�DWDWq�^=<!\YF!RAU f <�^CUKOg��<!RYL�<�>~B�DÎk�� ���S�MÞ�  k?¡N_=<8>�RA:�\Y>�@�Rt`�B�\�LSUpvS<!OgB�\A:�T @ZIT8@SO=<�qSk7¶$O�>�_=<N�zRY\Y>�T8@Ìv�<�cM>�_�<5>ARA:=\�>�@SR�^=<�F!UW^=<!^]_=@�`èT�:=F%_�c|UpIdBZO�q�cM>�@j\A<�O=^]>A@�B�OB�O�@SOMqPT8@S:=\*>�RY:=\Y>A<!<Zkml ¸ �JOMq�T]@�O=<�qj\Y<!OM>7>�@�>�_=<�>�RY:=\Y>A<!<�`�B�\�>�RAUWr=DK<�^dk*¡N_=<b>ARA:=\�>�<�<ÓMÔ¦Ó�Ò�ÚÙÎ`ÕÍÈÛÔ¦Ñ4á�ÕÍÇ�ԦɾÌ.Ç�Ô�Ò�ɾÌ\Ç�Ô¦ÚÊÖ�ɨô�Ç�ÈÙÏÄÇrÖZÈÙÖDÑ�Ô�ÕJɾÌ\Ñ�Ö¯ÎlÓ�ÚÙÎ�×�Ì\Ë+ô'Ì�˾Ì5ô'ÌÝÎnÚÛÕ¾Ç�ÈÊÌ\ËJÎnÑ�ÖDÇMÎ�Ö-×�Ô¦Ò�Ñ�â¦Ì\ËÇ�Ô�ÒMÉ­Ì�Ç�Ô�ÚÙÖrÇ�Ì�Î�Ö�É\ð·:f ÷.ÉhÈÙÉhÔnécÕÍÌ\Ñ�Õ¾Ç�Ì#Ï\Î�ɾÌ�ô�Ç�Ì\Ñ-â�Înë-Ì�ÉhÎ�˾ÌJÓ�ÚÙÎ�×�Ì�Ö;ÈÊÑ�ËÍÒ�ËÄÎnÚZî�ÈÊÚÛÚÙÎnâ¦Ì�ÉTÕ¾Ç�Ì�â�Înë-Ì�É©ôJÌ\ËÍÌ�Ñ�ÔnÕ+Ö�Ô�Ò�Ð�ÚÊÌÐ�ÚÊÈÛÑ�Ö¹ß�åJÎ�˾Ë#Ã�Ä�ÄD��á��,ÎnËÍÚÊÎ�Ñ�Ã�Ä�ÄJ��àpð�Æ�Ç�ÈÊɨÈÊɨÖ�Ò�Ì�Õ¾ÔLÕÍÇ�Ì�ÈÛë-Ó¥Ô�˾ÕÍÎ�Ñ�ÏdÌ�Ô�é¥ëDÎnæ�ÈÊÑ�â,É­Ò�˾Ì�Ó�ÚÙÎ�×�Ì�ËÍÉ�ô�ÈÛÕ¾Çî`ÎnËÍ×�ÈÊÑ�â�ÚÛÌ�î�Ì�ÚÊÉJÔné©Ì�Ö�Ò�Ï\ÎnÕ¾ÈÊÔ�ÑHÒ�Ñ�ÖZÌ�ËÍÉ­ÕÍÎ�Ñ�Ö¯ÕÍÇ�ÌLâ¦Î�ë�ÌÝÉ\á�Î�Ñ�ÖHÖZÈ��¯Ï\Ò�ÚèÕÍÈÛÌÝÉ�ÈÊÑËÍÒ�Ñ�Ñ�ÈÊÑ�â-̹¸ZÓ¥Ì\ËÍÈÛë-Ì�ѦÕÄÉÈÛÑBÎ�î�ÈÛÚÊÚÙÎnâ�ÌLɾÌdÕ­ÕÍÈÛÑ�â�ð·:¹ ÷.ÉJÕ¾Ç�Ì5î�ÈÊÚÛÚÙÎnâ¦Ì\ËÄÉ'Î�ÚÛÚRÓ�ÚÙÎ�×�ÌÝÖ-Õ¾Ô¦â�ÌdÕÍÇ�Ì\ËÝá�Õ¾Ç�Ì�×Dæ�Ñ�Ì\ô�ÕÍÇ�ÌLÓMÔ�Ô¦ÚMé^ËÍÔ�ë�ô�Ç�ÈÊÏÄÇrÕ¾Ç�Ì�ÈÛË�Ó�Î�Ë­ÕÍÑ�Ì\Ë�ô�Î�ÉÖZËÄÎ�ô�Ñ4á�Õ¾Ç�Ô¦Ò�â�ÇHÕ¾Ç�Ì\×Ö�ÈÊÖHÑ�Ô�Õ�æ�Ñ�Ô`ô�ô�ÈèÕÍǹô�Ç�Ô�ë@Õ¾Ç�Ì�ׯô'Ì�˾ÌLÓ�Î�ÈÛËÍÌ�ÖÒ�Ó4ð

Page 23: 9= . >@?A . B C D1 E › files › docs › colloqpapers › w05 › Sc… · 0 (* %-$#+1 $3245$768&3 9:;&< # 9=" . >@?A . B C" D1 E FHGJILKMGON5PRQLSTPRQ UMSVK W;XZY\[^]`_Vacbd_eY\fZahgjilknmpo_eY\]

���������������� !���#"$ %� &�Æ

T]B�^=<j>�_=<�\A<!F�@SO=^3T8@�vS<�c�^=<!F�UK^=UWO=LV_=@�` T�:=F%_�T]@SO�<�qa>�@VRY<�>A:=RAOs>A@V>�_=<�>�RY:=\Y>A@SR!k¯�O=^=<!R�>�_=<;B�\A\Y:=T]rP>�UK@�OV@�I*\Y<!DW�=\A_,r=RY<�IQ<�RA<!O�F!<!\�c=>�_=<J@SO=DWq�\Y: f w�LMB�T8<Jr#<!RYIQ<�F�>u�JB�\Y_<�á|:�UKDKU f RAUW:=T�UW\�IQ@SR�>A_=<b>ARA:=\�>�@SR*>�@�\A<�O=^~O=@[T]@SO�<�qi>�@�>�_=<�>�RY:=\Y>A<!<ZcS:=\AUWO=L f B�F%GM`uB�RY^UWO=^=:=F�>�UK@�O,>�@�UKO�IQ<�R�>�_=BZ>N>�_=<i>ARA:=\�>�<!<i`5UWDKD�O�<�vS<�R[RY<�>A:=RAO�B�OMq?T8@SO=<�q�k�Ý�@SO=<�q?\A<�OM>f q3>�_�<8>ARA:=\�>�@SR�UK\jF!@�T]T8@SO=Dpqs:=\Y<!^g>A@�T8<�B�\Y:=RA<8_=UW\j>ARA:=\�>t>A_zBZ>j>�_�<VB�O�@SOMqPT8@S:=\>ARA:=\�>�<!<s`5UWDKD5RA<�>�:=RYOÙ_=UK\VT]@SO�<�qSk Ýa@SO=<�qXRA<�>�:=RYO=<!^ f q�>A_=<�>ARA:=\�>�<!<3UW\V:=\Y<!^Ù>�@T8<�B�\Y:=RA<j_=UW\u>�RY:=\Y>$`b@SRY>A_=UKO�<!\A\�k

¶$OE@SRA^�<!RJ>A@a_=B�v�<~T]<!B�\A:�RA<!\j@�I f @�>�_s>ARA:=\�>�B�O=^s>ARA:=\�>$`�@SR�>�_=UWO=<!\Y\�IQRY@ST�<�vS<�RYq_=@�:=\A<�_=@SDK^aUKO?>A_=<t\Y:=RYv�<�q�c�¶b_zB�^a<�vS<�RYqar=DKB�q�<!R5r=DKB�qV>�_=<jRA@�DK<i@�Iy>�RA:�\Y>�@�R5�=RA\Y>[B�O�^>A_=<!O3>�_�<�RA@SDW<�@�I�>�RY:=\Y>A<!<Zk���:�RAG�\j<�>jB�DÎk7�Î&�ÑSÑSÆ   �zO=^s>A_zBZ>ir=DKB�qPUWO=L f @�>�_3RY@SDK<�\;UKO>A_=<u>�RY:=\Y>.LSB�T]<�^=<!F�RA<�BZ\A<!\ f @�>�_�>A_=<5B�T8@S:=OM>.\Y<!OM>�B�O=^~>�_�<N\A_zB�RY<NRA<�>�:=RYO=<!^dko¡N_=<�q_Mq|r�@Z>�_=<�\AUK³�<�>A_zBZ>*r=DKB�qPUWO=L f @�>�_jRA@�DK<!\�RY<!^=:�F!<!\*>�_�<�r�DB�qS<�R!§¨\�\Y<!O=\Y<b@ZI�RY<!\Ar#@SO=\YU f UWDKUp>$qIQ@SRd>A_=<.`�<�DKD f <!UWO=L5@�I�_�UK\*rzB�R�>�O=<�R!k�¶�I�>�_�UK\�UK\d>A_=<�F�B�\Y<�cÌ>�_=<�O�r=DKB�q|UWO=L f @Z>�_�RA@SDW<!\d`5UKDWD^=<�F!RY<�B�\Y<aF�@SRARY<!DKBZ>�UW@SO f <�>$`�<�<!O�>�_=<?T8<�B�\Y:=RA<?@ZI[>ARA:=\�>$`�@SR�>�_=UWO=<!\Y\VBZO=^�B�DW>ARA:=UW\ATacB�O�^1`5UWDKD�BZDKDK@�`¤>�RY:=\Y>$`b@SR�>�_=UWO=<!\Y\�>A@ f <jT]<!B�\A:�RA<!^aT8@SRA<ir=:�RA<!DpqSk

� � ¡ �36�-�6�4[÷R�©«ª U�®+Ø ±0¶lÚ æKØ ±7×ÈÚÛ­�±7×ȯ\Ö �@¶¥³�¯�Ý�¶ ã5¯�Ö�±0Ý�¯�·È·«×ÈÖ-à ³�¯�Ý ã5Ý�¯^S

ãÄÙ-¯�×�è/¶� ������� � nY{W�lq/u¥qA~�q�� n¶$OèÓP<!F�>�UK@�OÙÆ¢@�IJ>�_=UW\]rzBZr�<�R]¶~^=<�RAUpvS<!^�F!@ST8rzB�RABZ>�UpvS<1\Y>�BZ>�UWF!\]IQRY@ST >$`b@CT]@|^=<�DK\IQ@SRb>�_=<i>�_�RA<!<i<�O=^=@SL�<!O=@S:�\�vZB�RYUB f DW<!\�ç7LSUWIe>A\uLSUpvS<!O�c�>�_=<�Ie>5<�©Pr#<!RAUW<!O=F�<!^dc#B�O�^1>ARA:=\�>�c`5Up>�_3RA<�LMB�RY^=\;>�@?<ª©�@�LS<!O=@�:=\jF%_zB�O=LS<�\jUKOs>�_�<~F!@S\�>t@ZIb\�>�<!B�DKUWO=L=c�>A_=<~RAUW\AG�B�v�<!RY\AUK@�O@�Ib>�_=<8IhB�RAT8<!R�coBZO=^¢>A_=<8>ARA:=\�>$`�@�RY>�_�UKO=<�\A\�@�Iu_=UK\�O=<!UWLS_ f @�RA\!k1�b<�IQ@SRY<]F�@SOM>�RA@�DKDKUWO=LIQ@SR�F!RY@SrCF%_=@�UKF!<8>�_=<]RA<�LSRA<�\A\A@�RA\~B�RY<,B�DWD.<�©P@SLS<�O=@S:=\�B�O=^C\Y@�>�_=<�RA<]UK\�O�@�O=<�<!^C>�@UWO=\Y>ARA:=T8<!OM>�k.¡N_�:=\�c�¶�<!\�>�UWTVBZ>A<jB~\Yq|\Y>A<!T�@�Iy<!á�:zBZ>AUK@SO=\

º l ô�� ñ l �@ì lº { ô�� ñ { �@ì {º ´ ô�� ñ ´ �@ì ´

UWOE`5_�UKF%_5º l UW\jLSUWIe>A\�L�UWvS<�Odclº { UK\i>�_=<�Ie>�<�©Pr�<�RAUW<!O=F�<!^dcoB�O=^5º ´ UW\i>�RA:�\Y>�kV��<!F!B�:=\Y<>A_=UK\y\Yq|\Y>A<!T UW\ Ç :=\�>7UK^�<!OM>�Up�z<!^�B�O�^ f <�F�B�:=\Y<�>�_�<!RA<5BZRA<�O�@iUKO=\�>�RA:�T]<�O�>A\o>�_�<u\Yq|\Y>A<!TB�O=B�DWq|\AUW\u`5UKDWD�\AUWT]r�DKUWIeq�>A@8<�á�:zBZ>�UW@SO f q,<!á�:zBZ>AUK@SO�ßiÒ�Ó¢����<!DKDWO=<!Ru­ ¡N_=<�UKD ���S� &   k

Page 24: 9= . >@?A . B C D1 E › files › docs › colloqpapers › w05 › Sc… · 0 (* %-$#+1 $3245$768&3 9:;&< # 9=" . >@?A . B C" D1 E FHGJILKMGON5PRQLSTPRQ UMSVK W;XZY\[^]`_Vacbd_eY\fZahgjilknmpo_eY\]

���������������� !���#"$ %� & °

Ϥ_=<�OX<�\Y>�UWTVB}>�UKO�L�>�_=UW\�\Yq|\�>�<!Tac�>�_=<1T8<�B�\Y:=RA<?@�I+º l UW\�>�_�<aDW@SLs@�I[@SO=<?r�DK:=\>A_=<�vZB�DK:�<�@�Ii>A_=<�Ie>V<�©Pr�<�RAUW<!O=F�<!^dcOº { UW\VT8<�B�\Y:=RA<�^¤B�\V>�_�<sDK@SL¢@�Ij@SO=<�r=DK:=\8>�_=<vZB�DW:=<3@�ItLSUWIe>A\?LSUWv�<!Odk�¡N_=<EvZB�RAUKB f DK<Kº ´ UK\,>ARA:=\�>sB�\1T8<�B�\Y:=RA<�^ f qè>A_=<EÏg@SRYDK^��B�DW:=<!\]ÓP:�RYvS<�q�á|:�<!\Y>AUK@SO ë�Ϥ_zBZ>8\Y_zB�RA<1@�I[qS@S:�R8IQ<�DKDK@�`�v|UKDKDKB�LS<�RA\�`b@S:=DW^�>ARYqH>�@>�B�G�<�B�^�vZB�OM>�B�LS<j@�I�qS@S:�UWI*>�_=<�q1_zB�^1>�_=<j@Sr�r�@SR�>�:=O�UW>$q0��ì=c�`5_=<�RA<j>�_=<�B�O=\�`�<�RA\JB�RA<� w$B�DKDÎc�&Ìw�T]@SRY<]>A_zB�O�_zB�DWI¹c�ÆÌw$_zB�DpI¹c ° w$DW<!\Y\�>�_zB�OÔ_zBZDWI¹c�B�O=^ Þ w�O=@SO=<ZkC¶$OÔ�Jr=r#<!O=^�Up©� ¶uRA:�O�>�_�<�\�BZT]<�B�OzBZDWq|\AUW\ f :P>J:=\Y<t>A_=<t<ª©Pr�<�RAUKT8<!OM>�B�D*T]<!B�\A:=RY<�@�Iy>�RY:=\Y>JR�BZ>A_=<!R>A_zB�Os>�_�<�\A:=R�vS<�q3T]<!B�\A:�RA<~B�O�^s>�_=<�RY<!\Y:=DW>A\ f <�F!@ST8<�\Y@ST]<�`5_zBZ>i`b<�B�GZ<!R�kt¶$Os>A_=UK\\Y<�>A>AUKO=Lt¶7IQ<!<�D�>�_=BZ>b>A_=<J\Y:=RYv�<�qVT]<!B�\A:=RY<;@�Id>ARA:=\�>uUW\bT8@SRA<JB�r=r=RY@Sr=RYUBZ>A< f <!F!B�:=\Y<iUW>T8<�B�\Y:=RA<�\i_=@�` T�:=F%_ERA<�\Ar#@SO=^=<�O�>A\i>�RA:�\Y>;>A_=<!UWRJIQ<!DWDK@�`Õv|UKDKDKB�LS<�RA\�LSUWv�<!Os>�_=BZ>;>�_�<�qG�O=@�`û>�_�<]\�qP\�>�<�T @�I�RA<�`uB�RY^=\�BZO=^g\AB�O=F�>AUK@SO�\�>A_=<�q¬F�BZOgUKT8r#@S\A<�@SO¢<�B�F%_¢@�>�_=<�R!k¡�RA:=\�>�B�\iT8<�B�\Y:=RA<�^ f qs>A_=<~<�©Pr#<!RYUKT8<!OM>jUK\iBZO=@SOMq|T]@S:�\;>�RA:�\Y>i`5_=<�O¢O=@?RY<�`�B�RA^�\@SRN\AB�O=F�>�UK@�O=\�B�RA<ir#@S\A\YU f DW<�k

¡N_=<uvZB�RYUB f DW<!\y:=\A<�^]BZ\.<�©P@SLS<�O=@S:=\.RY<!LSRY<!\A\Y@SRA\�F�@ST]T8@SO�>A@iB�DWD|>A_=RA<�<N<!á�:zBZ>AUK@SO=\UWO=F!DW:=^=<svZB�RAUKB f DW<!\?RA<�r=RA<�\A<�O�>AUKO=L�RAUK\YGÙB�vS<�RA\AUW@SOdc;>A_=<EF!@S\�>�@�I�\Y>A<�B�DWUKO=L=cJB�O=^¤>�_=<>ARA:=\�>$`�@SR�>�_=UWO=<!\Y\�@ZI�O=<�UKLS_ f @SRA\�kû¡N_=<¬B�T8@S:=OM>?>�_=<E_=@�:=\A<�_=@SDK^ f <�>1UKOÙ>A_=<ERAUK\YG<ª©�r#<!RYUKT8<!OM>jUK\iUWO=F!DW:=^=<�^gB�\jB1T8<�B�\Y:=RA<~@�I;�hDKB�F%Gs@�I   RAUW\AG�B�v�<!RY\AUK@�OdcoBZ\;>�_=<�T8@SRA<>A_=<�q f <�>�c�>�_�<�DK<�\A\[RAUK\YG1B�vS<!RY\A<�>A_=<�q�B�RY<�k5�JOsUWO=^=UWF�BZ>A@SRuvZB�RAUKB f DK<iIQ@SR�_=@S:�\A<!_�@SDK^=\`5_=UWF%_�^=UW^£O�@�>arzB�RY>AUKF�UKrzBZ>A<3UKO¤>�_=<¬<�©Pr#<!RYUKT8<!OM>�\aUK\1UKO�F!DK:�^=<!^£B�\?`�<�DKDÎkÖ¶?B�DW\A@UWO=F!DW:=^=<�_�@S:=\A<�_=@SDW^s\AUW³!<~B�O�^s>�_=<�O�:=T f <�R;@�I�B�^=:�DW>[TVB�DW<!\�>�@,RY<!r=RY<!\A<�OM>i>�_=<�F�@S\Y>@�I5\�>�<!B�DKUWO=L=ks¶�>�UK\�T8@SRA<]^=UW�8F�:=DW>t>�@s\�>�<�BZDbIQRA@�TâB�_�@S:=\A<�_=@SDW^C`5UW>�_gT]@SRY<,B�^�:=DW>T]B�DK<�\!c�B�\bB�IhBZT]UWDWqtT]<�T f <�R.`5UKDKD f <5`�@�RAG�UKO=LtUKO�>�_=<5�z<�DK^=\�T]@�RA<5@�Ie>�<�Odk7¶7UWO=F!DW:=^=<B1v�BZRAUB f DK<~UWO=^=UKF!BZ>�UWO=L1UWIuB�OMqEO=@SOPw�_=@S:=\Y<!_=@SDW^gT8<!T f <!Rj`�B�DKG�\�r=B�\Y>�>�_=<8IhB�T8UKDWq#§¨\T]B�UKO¢r=DK@Z>~UKOHBZO�qgLSUWv�<!OC`b<!<�G#c�`5_=UKF%_Ô<�É�<�F�>�\�>A_=<?F!@�\Y>�@�I5\�>�<�BZDKUKO�L3B�\�`b<!DKDÎkE¶�IO=@8O=@SO|w$_=@S:�\A<!_�@SDK^aT]<�T f <!RN`uBZDKG�\[r=B�\Y>[B~�z<!DW^�>�_�<!Oar�<�@Sr=DK<j^=@]O=@�>�G�O=@�`Ê`5_zBZ>F�RA@Sr¬UK\iUWOs>�_=<~�z<�DK^¬@SR;`5_=<!O¢UW>;`5UWDKD f <�RAUWr�<Zc*B�O=^E`5UKDWDoDK@|@SG�T]@SRY<�@S:�>�@�Ibr=DKB�F!<UpI.>�_=<�q3B�RY<~\A<!<�O3`uB�DWG�UKO=L?rzBZ\Y>;>A_=<��z<!DW^dktnoUK<�DK^=\[@SO3F!@ST8T8@SO=DWqa:=\Y<!^3IQ@|@�>�rzB}>�_=\B�RY<j<�B�\YUK<!RN>A@]\�>�<�BZD*IQRY@STak�¶uB�DK\Y@8UWO=F!DW:=^=<i>�_�<tO�:=T f <!R5@�Io_=@S:=\Y<!_=@�DK^=\5`5UW>A_=UKO�& Þ ÑT8<�>A<!RA\�@�IN>�_=<]\A:=R�vS<�qS<!^X_=@S:=\Y<!_=@�DK^H\A@�>�_zBZ>�>�_=<,UWO=^=UWF�BZ>A@SRiIQ@SR�O=@}w$@SO=<8`uBZDKG�UKO=LrzBZ\Y>N>�_�<;�z<!DW^?UK\NO=@�> Ç :=\Y>5r=RY@�©Pq|UWO=L~IQ@SRNB~_=@S:=\Y<!_=@�DK^1_zB�v|UKO=L�IQ<�`�O=<�UKLS_ f @SRA\�c f :�>B�F�>�:zBZDKDWq]RA<�r=RA<�\A<�O�>A\;B~F%_zB�RAB�F�>A<!RYUK\Y>AUKFj@�I�>�_=<jr=DW@�>NUWO1`5_�UKF%_aF!RA@�r=\JBZRA<ir=DKB�OM>�<!^�k

¶�B�DW\A@�UWO=F!DW:=^=<�v�BZRAUB f DK<�\bRY<!r=RY<!\A<�OM>�UKO�L�>�_=<�>�RA:�\Y>$`b@SRY>A_=UKO=<�\A\N@�I*O�<!UKL�_ f @SRY\�B�O�^v|UKDWDB�L�<!RA\�ky¶�_zB�v�< ± x�Ó]^=BZ>%B�@�O,<�B�F%_?_�@S:=\A<�_=@SDW^,UKO8>�_=<[\A:=R�vS<�q?B�O=^V>A_=<JT8<�B�\Y:=RA<@�Iz>ARA:=\�>$`�@�RY>�_�UKO=<�\A\7IQRA@�T®>A_=<u<ª©�r#<!RYUKT8<!OM>�ky¶�F!@ST f UKO=<�>�_=<�\A<u>A@;T]<!B�\A:�RA<�O�<!UKL�_ f @SR>ARA:=\�>$`�@SR�>�_=UWO=<!\Y\NB�\�>�_=<[DK<�vS<!D#@�I�>�RA:�\Y>$`b@SRY>A_=UKO=<�\A\u@ZId>�_=<[DK<!B�\Y>�>�RY:=\Y>$`b@SR�>�_MqV@ZId>�_=<_=@�:=\A<�_=@SDK^�§Ü\~IQ@S:=R~F�DK@S\Y<!\�>]O�<!UKL�_ f @SRY\!kÔ¶�IQ@|F!:�\8@�OÔ>A_=<1DK<�vS<!D5@�I�>�RY:=\Y>$`b@SR�>�_=UWO=<!\Y\@�Ib>�_=<]DK<!B�\Y>j>�RY:=\Y>$`b@SR�>�_Mqgr#<!RY\A@SOgR�BZ>A_=<!Rj>�_zBZO¢>�_�<VT8<!^=UKB�O f <�F�B�:=\Y<V>�_�<]T8@P^�<!Dr=RY<!^=UWF�>A\�>�_zB}>NUW>bUK\�>A_=<;DW<�B�\�>�>�RY:=\Y>$`b@SR�>�_Mq?r#<!@Sr=DW<[`5_=@~T�:=\Y> f <;F�@SOM>�R�BZF�>�<�^?`5UW>�_

Page 25: 9= . >@?A . B C D1 E › files › docs › colloqpapers › w05 › Sc… · 0 (* %-$#+1 $3245$768&3 9:;&< # 9=" . >@?A . B C" D1 E FHGJILKMGON5PRQLSTPRQ UMSVK W;XZY\[^]`_Vacbd_eY\fZahgjilknmpo_eY\]

���������������� !���#"$ %� & Þ

>A@�RY<!^=:=F�<V>�_�<�Ie>�k?¶[IQ@PF�:=\t@�OgF!DW@S\A<8O=<�UKLS_ f @SRA\ f <�F�B�:�\A<V>A_=<]<�v|UK^=<�O=F!<]r=RA<�\A<!OM>A<!^UWO?ÓP<�F�>�UW@SO1&tUWO1Ó|>$q|DKUW³!<�^?n�B�F�> � í \A:=LSL�<!\Y>A<!^,>A_zBZ>uF�DK@S\Y<;O=<�UKLS_ f @SRA\�B�RA<[@�Ie>�<�OV>�_=<F�:=DKr=RYUW>A\!k.�Õr=RY@�©|q?IQ@SRuv|UWDKDBZLS<JDW<�vS<�Dd>�RY:=\Y>$`b@SRY>A_=UKO�<!\A\[F!@ST8<!\uIQRY@ST²B~F!@�T]T�:�O=UW>$qMwDW<�vS<�Dd\A:�RYvS<�qaB�O=^1UK\b>�_=<jB�O�\Y`b<!R5>�@�>�_�<iá|:�<!\Y>AUK@SOXë�Ϥ_=BZ>5\A_zBZRA<i@�Iyr�<�@Sr=DW<;UKO,>A_=UK\v|UKDWDB�L�<JF!@�O�>ARAU f :�>�<i`5Up>�_?>�UWT]<;@�RNT]@SO�<�q,>A@8F%_�:=RYF%_t��ì { »

��DKB�\Y>or=RA@�©|q�IQ@SRy>ARA:=\�>$`�@SR�>�_=UWO=<!\Y\.UK\�>�_=<bO|:�T f <�R7@�I�_=@�:=\A<�_=@SDK^�\7UKO�>�_=<�v|UWDKDBZLS<`5Up>�_�T8<!T f <�RA\*`5_=@iB�RY<bF�DK@S\Y<bRY<!DB}>�UWv�<!\y@�I�>A_=<�\Y:=RYv�<�qS<�^]_�@S:=\A<�_=@SDW^dk � DW@S\A<�IhB�T8UKDWqT8<!T f <!RY\;UKO�F!DK:�^=<�rzB�RY<!OM>�\�c*F%_=UKDW^=RA<�Odcd@SR;\YU f DWUKO=L�\J@�I�>�_�<~_=@S:=\Y<!_=@SDW^E_=<�B�^E@SRJ_=UK\`5UpIQ<�k7¡N_=<�q?^=@�O�@�>NUKO�F!DK:�^=<;F!@�:=\AUWO=\u@SRb@�>�_=<�Ru<�©|>A<!O=^=<�^aIhBZT]UWDWq�T8<!T f <!RY\!k.��r#@Zw>A<!OM>�UKB�D#>A_=UK<�I*TVB�q]<�©Pr#<!RAUW<!O=F�<jB�DBZRALS<�Rb>�RY:=\Y>$`b@SR�>�_=UWO=<!\Y\N^=UK\Y:�>�UWDKUW>$q~`5_�<!O1\Y>A<�B�DWUKO=LIQRY@ST�_=UK\[@Ì`5O3RY<!DKBZ>�UpvS<�kJ�[@�>A<t>A_zBZ>;_=B�v|UWO=L,F!DW@S\A<�IhB�T8UKDWq,T]<�T f <�RA\JB�\;O=<�UKLS_ f @SRA\`5_=@a_=<�DKrET]@�O=UW>A@SR[>A_=<~�z<!DW^=\jF!@S:=DW^¬B�DK\Y@?TVB�GZ<�UW>iT8@SRA<~^�UW�8F!:=Dp>;IQ@SR;>A_=UK<�vS<!\j>�@\�>�<�BZD*IQRY@STÖ>A_zBZ>�_=@S:=\Y<!_=@�DK^dcz>�_�:=\5`b@SRAG�UKO�L]>�_�RA@S:=L�_a>A_=<tF�@S\Y>[@�Io\Y>�<!B�DKUWO=L8B�\N`�<�DKDB�\N>ARA:=\�>$`�@SR�>�_=UWO=<!\Y\!k

¡N_=<sDW@SLg@ZIj_=@S:=\Y<!_=@SDW^è`�<!B�DW>A_dcNT8<!^=UKB�OèDBZO=^Pw$_�@SDK^=UWO=LS\�UKO�>�_=<�vPUWDKDKB�LS<�c�>�_=<O�:=T f <!R5@�IyqS<!B�RA\5>�_=<j_=@�:=\A<�_=@SDK^�_zB�\5DKUpvS<�^aUWOa>A_=<iv|UKDKDKB�LS<Zc=B�O=^1>�_�<t^=UW\Y>�B�O=F!< f <�w>$`b<!<�O�>�_�<i_=@S:=\Y<tBZO=^?>�_=<jO=<!B�RA<�\Y>�r�@�DKUKF�<J\�>%BZ>AUK@SOaB�RY<jB�DK\Y@~UKO=F�DK:=^=<�^1B�\5F!@SOM>ARA@SDW\!k¶[^=@�O�@�>�F!@SOM>�RY@SD7IQ@SRiv|UKDWDB�LS<���©P<!^C<�É�<�F�>A\tUWOE>A_=<]B�OzB�DpqP\YUK\iUWOE>A_=<8TVB�UWOs>�<ª©P>�>�@r=RY<!\Y<!RYv�<~r=RA<�F!UW@S:=\;^=<�LSRA<�<!\;@ZI.IQRA<!<�^=@STac�>A_=@S:=LS_�¶N_zB�vS< f @P@�>A\Y>AR�B�r=r#<!^�F!DK:�\Y>�<�RA<�^\�>%B�O=^=B�RA^X<!RARY@SRA\�k { l�¶$O��[r=r�<�O=^=Um©è��¶�\A_�@Ì`²>A_=<aRA<!\Y:=DW>A\]IQRY@STÈB¢\Yr�<�F!Up�zF�BZ>AUK@SOUWO=F!DW:=^=UKO�L�v|UKDKDKB�LS<���©P<!^�<�É�<�F�>A\!c#B�O=^aB�Dp>�_=@S:�LS_?>�_=<i\�>%B�O=^=B�RA^a<!RYRA@SRY\�@�O1>A_=<jF!@|<�Iw�zF�UK<�O�>A\�B�RA<�B�DWD�T�:=F%_aDBZRALS<�R!c�>A_=<jRA<!\Y:=DW>A\�B�RA<iá�:=Up>�<j\AUWT]UWDB�R�k

� �������  &k�}�~:n k5n z|{W�0{yv:qAzϤ_=<�O~O=@�>.F�@SOM>�RY@SDKDWUKO=L5IQ@SR7F�RA@Sr~F%_=@�UKF!<�¶�<�\Y>AUKT]BZ>�<�>�_=<u\�q|\Y>�<�T @�I�<�á|:=BZ>�UW@SO=\7:=\YUKO=L<�á|:=BZ>�UW@SO f qE<�á|:=BZ>�UW@SOCßiÒ�Ó�k*��@�>�<~>�_=BZ>�LSUWv�<!Og@�T]Up>A>�<�^svZB�RAUKB f DK<�\i\A:=F%_CB�\jF!RA@�rF%_=@�UKF!<7>A_=<�RA<�\A:=Dp>�\*\A_=@�`5OtUKOi¡yB f DK< ° T]B�q f < f UB�\Y<!^dc f :�>�>A_=<�qiL�UWvS<�B�OjUWO�>A<!RY<!\Y>AUKO=L@�vS<�RYv|UK<�`�@�I;>A_=<�\YUW>A:zBZ>�UW@SOdkè��vZB�RAUKB f DW<,`5_=UKF%_èRY<!r=RY<!\Y<!OM>�\?BZO�UKO�F!RA<!B�\A<�UKOÔ>�_=<F�@S\Y>t@�IN\�>�<�BZDKUKO�L�UW\ é �[@}w$@SO=<8rzB�\Y\A<�\��z<!DW^d§pk1Ø[@S:=\Y<!_=@�DK^=\j`5UW>A_¢�z<�DK^=\j`5_=UKF%_gO=@SOPw_=@�:=\A<�_=@SDK^HT8<!T f <�RA\�^�@3O=@�>�`�B�DKGErzBZ\Y>~LSUpvS<?B�\AUKL�O=UW�zF!B�OM>�Dpq¢DW@�`�<�R�>�@�>�B�D�v�BZDK:=<Â�Ï Æ�Ç�Ì�Ï\Ô�ë-ëlÒ�Ñ�ÈèÕ½×�ìÀÚÛÌ�î�Ì�Ú�ɾÒ�ËÍî�Ì\×¹ÎnÚÙɾÔÎ�ɾæ�ÌÝÖBô�Ç�ÎnÕLɾÇ�ÎnËÍÌlÔ�é+Ó¥Ì\Ô�Ó�ÚÛÌ;ÈÛÑ�Õ¾Ç�Ì-ÏdÔ¦ë-ëlÒ�Ñ�ÈÛÕ½×BÏdÔ¦ÑZìÕ¾ËÍÈÛÐ�ÒZվ̹ô�ÈÛÕ¾ÇCÕ¾ÈÊë�ÌBÔ¦Ë-ë�Ô¦Ñ�Ì\תÕÍÔ´ÏdÔ�ë-ë;Ò�Ñ�ÎnÚ�â¦Ô¦ÎnÚÙɹß^ô�Ç�ÈÙÏÄÇ�ÈÛÑ�Ï\ÚÛÒMÖZ̹Ì\ÚÊÌ�ÏpÕÍ˾ÈÜÀMÏ�Î`Õ¾ÈÊÔ�Ñ�ÎnÑ�ÖCËÍÔ¦Î�ÖÐ�Ò�ÈÊÚÊÖ�ÈÛÑ�â�àpð�¡�Ç�ÈÊÚÛÌ#Ï\Ô�Ñ�Õ¾ËÍÈÛÐ�ÒZÕ¾ÈÊÑ�â5Õ¾ÔLÌ\ÚÊÌ�ÏdÕ¾ËÍȨÀMÏ�Î`ÕÍÈÛÔ¦ÑlëDÎ�×,ÐMÌ�Ï\Ô�Ñ�ɾÈÊÖ�Ì\ËÍÌ�ÖlÎ5â�ÈÛécÕ©Õ¾Ô Õ¾Ç�Ì�Ï\Ô�ë-ëlÒ�Ñ�ÈèսצáÏdԦѦÕÍ˾ÈÊÐ�ÒZÕÍÈÛÑ�â;ÕÍÔ-Õ¾Ç�Ì;ÏÄÇ�Ò�ËÍÏÄÇHÈÊÉ�Î-Ð¥ÌdÕ¾Õ¾Ì�Ë.ë-Ì�ΦɭÒ�ËÍÌLÔné©Ë¾Ì�ÚÛÈÊâ�ÈÊԦɾÈÛսׯÎnÑ�Öeá�ÓMÔ�Õ¾Ì\Ñ�ÕÍÈÊÎ�ÚÛÚÊ×�áZÕÍ˾ÒMɽսôJÔ�˾վÇ�ÈÛìÑ�Ì�ÉÍÉ�ðÂ�· Æ�Ç�ÌL˾ÌÝɾÎ�ë�Ó�ÚÛÈÊÑ�â-ɾÏÄÇ�Ì�ë-Ì ÈÙÉ�ÎnÓ�Ó�ÚÛÈÊÌ�ÖHɾÌ\Ó�Î�ËÍÎnÕ¾Ì\ÚÊ×DÈÊÑHÌÝÎ�ÏÄÇî�ÈÊÚÊÚÊÎ�â�Ì�áZΦÉ�É­Ò�â¦â�ÌÝɽÕÍÌ�Ö¯Ð�×rí Î�î�ÈÊɾÔ�Ñ

Ð�ù.ÈÛÑ�æ�ÚÊÌ\×�ßQºY»�»!¿�àpð

Page 26: 9= . >@?A . B C D1 E › files › docs › colloqpapers › w05 › Sc… · 0 (* %-$#+1 $3245$768&3 9:;&< # 9=" . >@?A . B C" D1 E FHGJILKMGON5PRQLSTPRQ UMSVK W;XZY\[^]`_Vacbd_eY\fZahgjilknmpo_eY\]

���������������� !���#"$ %� & �

¡yB f DW< ° ç¢i3qApypyn ~��U{Wn ��qts��|v:s�{£�Av¤k¥v�z¥�§¦U{W�lnYs�{)n©¨/}onYpv:nUzl��n u,¦��7z�u"{�p�jl��{)monYsFqtpyn��qAz|{WpyqA~�~�v�z¥��sFqtp(��pyqt}5��¥q|v���n#j��&v�z§�Wqsª£���z��@|@�>�\�>�RAB�r=r#<!^~F!DW:=\Y>A<!RY<!^8\Y>%BZO=^zB�RY^<�RARA@�RA\5UKO1rzB�RY<!OM>�_�<!\AUW\!k6«�w � Ñ8�,c¬«m«�w �MÞ �,czB�O�^­«®«m«�w ��� ��\YUKLSO�UW�zF!B�OM>�k

¯ oZXQ°À»²£4k`��b&± ¯ oZXQ°½Ã-[c�R[^seX²± »'Y\_4mdbx k`b ³m´µ³<¶�· ¸¹³m´µ³©ºr» ¸¹³m´µ³�³<¶G »L¼ » ¸$ê K G »L¼ »'^ ´ K G »L¼ » ´ Q K½ [^�Vs ¾ b²·.a^f�{´ÃDfZtBknm ³m´�¿mºrÀ ¸¹³m´µ³Á¿� ¸¹³m´ÃÂ�Â<ÄG »L¼ H l ¸ K G »L¼ H${'H K G »L¼ ´${ » KÅ ojÆ-s4k¯·JfZm\mpknml¿�[ckna^� ¸,³m´Ç¶DÂ<»W�'� ¸¹³m´�È�³ÁÈW�'� ³m´�·�»�ÈW�G »L¼ ´${'¸ K G »L¼ ´ l H K G »L¼ l ê${ KÉ �;��ml[^ss·�Ä�³�t ilfZ�V[^_4m ³m´µ³ÁÀÁ¶ ¸¹³m´µ³Á¿�Â�'�'� ¸¹³m´µ³�³Á»G »L¼ » {'H K G »L¼ » { Ë K G »L¼ »Al ´ KÉ W;�4_Vacb¹Ê§fZacknm ¸¹³m´Ëºr»mº ³m´�·�Â<·W� ³m´µ³©ºr·G »L¼ l ´'¸ K G »L¼ l ´ Ë K G »L¼ »�QYl K¿VfZtu[^ac{sÌR[c«`k ³m´µ³Á·�Ä ³m´µ³Á»�Ä ³m´µ³�³ÁÀG »L¼ »'^ ê K G »L¼ » H'H K G »L¼ » ´ ^ K¯ oZXQ°�Í�knfZacbd£(± ³m´Ëºr·�À ³m´�·Á¶�Ä �'�'� ¸¹³m´µ³ÁÄmºG »L¼ » ¸ Q K G »L¼ » ¸'H K G »L¼ »�ËÈQ KÉ w aco�mpk¯ilkna^f�bd[c�Zknml[¢sÏÎ�[^a¢a ¸¹³m´µ³<¶�¿ ¸¹³m´Ëº�º�º �'� ³m´µ³�Â<·G »L¼ » ê Q K G »L¼ » ê$´ K G »L¼ » { ^ KÐ knf�Y�m;[^sÏÎ-[^a^a¢f�XZk ³m´µ³©º�³ ³m´µ³Á·�ÀW�'�'� ³m´µ³©ºr·W�'�'�G »L¼ »'» ¸ K G »L¼ »'» ¸ K G »L¼ »'»�Ë KÎ-[^a^a�ʧkn�4[^fZs ¯ fZs4�ÑÆ��;sekn� ¸¹³m´µ³Á·mº ¸¹³m´Ëº�³Á»W�'�'� ³m´µ³©ºr¿G »L¼ » ´ l K G »L¼ » ´ l K G »L¼ »Al H KÅ kn[cX�£M®©oZYl»+Y�_4mpb­� oZYdbd£4[¢seknmdm ³m´�À�À�¿ º�´Ç¶®ºr» º�´Ëº�³Á»W�'�G lC¼ » ¸ Ë K G lC¼ »�QF» K G »L¼ ê${ Ë KÒ oZ�_Î-[^a^a©�;knac�Vm w £M_eY�]\£ ¸¹³m´µ³Á·�»W�'�'� ¸¹³m´µ³�³Á¿ ³m´µ³©ºr¿W�'�'�G »L¼ »Al�» K G »L¼ »'» ¸ K G »L¼ »'» ê KÓ [^aco�tBk`bpk`Y\m²bpo¤·Jo�a^[^]�k ¸¹³m´Ëº�ºrÀ � ³m´µ³ÁÄ�Ä ³m´µ³©ºJ¶G »L¼ » H$´ K G »L¼ » ê » K G »L¼ » {'¸ KÔ { ³R�˺�ºrÄ ³R��·�Ä� ³R�˺�º�³Æ-®Vm`� ·�·�À ·�·�À ·�·�À

Page 27: 9= . >@?A . B C D1 E › files › docs › colloqpapers › w05 › Sc… · 0 (* %-$#+1 $3245$768&3 9:;&< # 9=" . >@?A . B C" D1 E FHGJILKMGON5PRQLSTPRQ UMSVK W;XZY\[^]`_Vacbd_eY\fZahgjilknmpo_eY\]

���������������� !���#"$ %� & í

@�I�LSUpIe>�\�c7<�©Pr#<!RAUW<!O=F�<1\AUKL�O=UW�zF!B�OM>�Dpq¢DW<!\Y\�>�_=<�Ie>8B�O=^C>�RY:=\Y>�\YUKLSO�UW�zF!B�OM>�DWq¬T8@SRA<ZkE¶$OIhB�F�>�c�B�_=@S:=\Y<!_=@�DK^V`5_=UWF%_?r�@�\A\A<�\A\NO=@~r�DK@�>�`5_=UKF%_?O�@Zw$@SO�<[`�B�DKG�\urzBZ\Y>N<ª©�r#<!RYUK<�O=F!<�\B�r�r=RA@�©PUKT]BZ>�<�DWq � Ñ�r�<�RAF�<!OM>~T8@SRA<�>�_=<�Ie>~B�O�^CLSUWv�<!\ � Ñ�r#<!RYF!<!OM>�T8@SRA<8LSUpIe>�\j>�_zB�OBH_=@S:�\A<!_�@SDK^¤`5_=UKF%_£_zB�\aBÔr=DK@�>1O�@Zw$@SO�<s`uB�DWG�\�rzBZ\Y>�kÐß;O=<¬T]UWLS_M>,>�_�UKO=G�>A_zBZ>>A_=<,RA<!B�\A@�OH_=@S:=\Y<!_=@SDW^=\�`5UW>A_g�z<�DK^=\�`5_�UKF%_ÔO=@Zw�@SO=<]`�B�DWG|\~r=B�\Y>~L�UWvS<]IQ<�`b<!R~LSUpIe>�\B�O�^�<ª©Pr�<�RAUK<�O=F!<aDK<�\A\~>�_�<�Ie>�UK\�>A_zBZ>�r#<!@Sr�DK<,`5_=@¬DKUpvS<,@SOÔ>�_�<a@�:�>�\YG|UWRY>A\~@�I[>A@�`5O_zB�v�<~O=@,O=<�UKLS_ f @SRA\�>�@,`5_=@ST�>�@VLSUWv�<�LSUpIe>�\!k;��:�>�c#>�_=UW\JRY<!\A:�DW>iF�@SOM>�UKO�:=<�\J>�@V_=@SDK^<�vS<!O£`5_=<!O£UKO=F�DK:=^=UWO=LC>�_�<¢O�:=T f <!Ra@�It_=@S:=\Y<!_=@�DK^=\aUKO£B�& Þ ÑHT]<�>�<!R1RAB�^=UK:�\a@ZI>A_zBZ>t_=@S:=\Y<!_=@SDW^CB�\tB�O¢<�©Pr=DBZOzBZ>�@�RYq3vZB�RAUKB f DW<�kV¡N_�:=\�co>�_�UK\�RA<!\Y:=DW>tUK\jO=@Z>�F!B�:=\A<�^f q�F!<!R�>%B�UWO3_=@S:=\Y<!_=@�DK^=\;_=B�v|UWO=L,IQ<�`b<!RiO=<�UKLS_ f @SRA\�c f :P>iUK\[^=UKRY<!F�>ADWqaRA<�DBZ>A<!^s>A@V>�_=<O�:=T f <!R5@�Ior�<�@Sr=DW<;`uB�DWG�UKO=L8rzB�\�>�>A_=<i�z<!DW^dkbØ[@S:=\Y<!_=@�DK^=\5`5UW>A_aT8@SRY<jB�^=:=Dp>[T]B�DW<!\^=@[LS<�>o\Y>A@SDK<�OtIQRA@�TÕ\ADKUWLS_M>�DpqiDK<�\A\!c f :�>y>�_=<�q�BZDK\A@[LSUWv�<bT8@SRY<bLSUpIe>�\b�Q>A_=@S:=L�_�>�_=UW\yT]B�qf < f <�F�B�:=\Y<[>A_=<�q�r=RY@P^�:=F!<5T8@SRA<�B�O=^8\A@�_zB�vS<[T]@�RA<u>�@�LSUpvS<   k7¡N_=<�RA<�\A:=Dp>�\�IQ@SR7>�_=<F�@S\Y>.@ZI�\Y>�<!B�DKUWO=LJ\Y_=@�`X>A_zBZ>7BJ^�q|OzB�T8UKFbDKUKT8UW>A<!^Pw�F!@ST8T8UW>�T8<!OM>�T]@|^=<!D|UK\y\A:=r�r�@SR�>�<�^B f @�vS<jB�O�^ f <�q�@SO=^?>�_�<ir=RA<�^=UKF�>�UK@�O=\u@�IyB~@SO=<ªw$r#<!RAUW@P^VT]@|^=<!DÎc�BZ\ f @�>A_?LSUWIe>A\�LSUpvS<�OB�O�^1>A_=<�Ie>�<ª©�r#<!RYUK<�O=F!<�^�UKO�F!RA<!B�\A<i`5_=<�O�>A_=<jF!@S\�>[@ZIo\�>�<�BZDKUKO�L~LS@P<�\5^=@�`5Odk

�u>?BE�zRA\�>,LSDKB�O=F�<�c�>A_=<�RY<!\A:�DW>�\]@SOX>ARA:=\�>$`�@�RY>�_�UKO=<�\A\?^=@¢O=@�>,\Y_=@�`�<�v|UK^�<!O=F�<@�IbLSUpIe>Yw$L�UWv|UKO=L f <�UKO=L1:=\Y<!^E>�@aDKUWT]Up>[>A_=<�Ie>!k~¡N_=<]_�UKLS_=<�R;>�_=<�\Y_zB�RA<�@�I�>�_�<�v|UWDKDBZLS<_=<�DKr=UWO=L¢`5Up>�_èF%_�:=RYF%_£r�RA@ Ç <�F�>�\�c�>A_=<sDW<!\A\]>�_=<�Ie>1B¢IhB�RYT]<�RV<�©Pr#<!RYUK<!O�F!<!\1BZO=^è>�_=<T8@SRA<;>ARA:=\�>�UWO=L]_�<�UW\!k�¡N_=<�DKUKT8UW>A<!^Pw�F!@ST8T8UW>�T8<!OM>�T8@P^=<�Ddr=RY<!^=UWF�>�<�^�>A_zBZ>�UKO1T8@SRA<>ARA:=\�>$`�@SR�>�_Mq¬vPUWDKDKB�LS<!\�cdIhB�RAT8<!RY\�`b@S:=DW^¢L�UWvS<�IQ<�`b<!RtLSUWIe>A\�B�O=^gF�@S:=DW^¢O=@Z>�\YUKLSOE>�_=<F�@ST]r=B�R�BZ>AUWv�<3\Y>%B}>�UKF�\?IQ@SR,>�_=<�Ie>�<ª©Pr�<�RAUK<�O=F!<�^dkÖ�[\1_=UK\1DK<!B�\Y>1>ARA:=\�>$`�@SR�>�_Mq¦F!DW@S\A<O=<�UKLS_ f @SR f <�F!@ST8<!\tT]@SRY<]>ARA:=\�>$`�@SR�>�_MqSc�BaIhB�RAT8<!Rj>�RY:=\Y>A\�T]@�RA<�c f :�>t>�_=<�RA<VUW\�O=@<�É�<�F�>�@SOaLSUWIe>A\u@SRN>�_=<�Ie>�k

Ø[@�`b<�v�<!R!cPBi^=UWÉ�<!RY<!OM>.T8<�B�\Y:=RA<N@ZI�>ARA:=\�>$`�@SR�>�_=UWO=<!\Y\!cM>�_�<NO|:�T f <�R.@�I�F!DK@�\A<�IhB�T~wUWDWq8T]<�T f <!RA\NDWUWv|UKO�L�UKO,>A_=<i\�BZT]<;v|UKDWDB�L�<�c|^=@P<�\N\A_=@�`�<�É�<!F�>A\5F!@SO=\YUK\�>�<!OM>5`5UW>A_,>�_=<^�q|OzBZT]UWF3DKUKT8UW>A<!^Pw�F!@ST8T8UW>�T�<�O�>8T8@P^�<!Dµk Ø[@S:=\Y<!_=@�DK^=\?`5UW>A_�����>�3F!DK@�\A<3IhB�T8UKDWqT8<!T f <!RY\~UKOC>A_=<,v|UKDKDKB�LS<]LSUWv�<?\AUKL�O=UW�zF!B�OM>�Dpq"����þ�����LSUWIe>A\!c�<�©Pr#<!RAUW<!O=F�<1DK<!\Y\�>�_=<�Ie>�cB�O�^s>�RA:�\Y>jT8@SRA<Zkjn�@�R;<�v�<!RYq3B�^=^=Up>�UK@�OzB�D�IhB�T8UKDWq,T]<�T f <�R;DKUpv|UKO=L]UKO�>A_=<!UWRJv|UKDKDKB�LS<ZcB~_=@S:�\A<!_�@SDK^aLSUWv�<!\�B�r=r�RA@�©PUKT]BZ>�<�DWq8>�<!Oar#<!RAF�<!OM>�IQ<�`b<!R5LSUWIe>A\!k.¡N_=UW\5UK\NF!@�O�>AR�B�R�q,>�@`5_zB}>�@SO�<]T8UKLS_M>�<�©Pr#<!F�>�c7UÎkÜ<ZkWc*>�_zB}>�_=@�:=\A<�_=@SDK^�\t`5UW>A_¢T8@SRY<]F�DK@S\Y<8IhB�T8UKDpq�T8<!T~wf <!RY\�`b@S:=DW^,LSUWv�<[T8@SRY<�L�UWIe>�\�c�O=@�>bDK<!\Y\!cPB�O=^]F!@SOM>�RAB�\Y>A\b`5Up>�_]>A_=<[v|UW<�`Ù@�IdLSUWIe>A\�_�<!DK^f qÔx.:�>AOzB�T � ���S� Æ   B�O=^�x.DBZ>Y>�<�BZ:�� ���S�Mí�  kg¡N_�UK\�RA<�\A:=Dp>~�=>�\�^=UWRA<!F�>�Dpq¢`5Up>�_H>�_=<DWUKT8UW>�<�^Pw$F�@ST8T]Up>�T�<!OM>]T]@|^=<!DΧÜ\?r�RA<!^�UKF�>AUK@SO�\1>A_zBZ>�B�\1>�RY:=\Y>$`b@SRY>A_=UKO�<!\A\�UKO=F�RA<�BZ\A<!\LSUpIe>�\�LSUWv�<!O,^�<!F!RY<�B�\Y<iB�O=^]>�RA:�\Y>uUWO=F!RY<�B�\Y<!\�c�`5_=UKDW<�>A_=<J<�É�<�F�>�@SOV>�_�<�Ie>u<ª©Pr�<�RAUK<�O=F!<�^UW\5B�T f UWLS:=@S:=\�k

¡N_=<[F!@|<��8F!UW<!OM>�\b@SOVRYUK\AG�B�v�<!RA\YUK@SOVB�RA<[B�DWDzUKO=\YUKLSO=Up�zF�BZO�>!cMr�<�RA_zBZr=\ f <!F!B�:=\A<�>�_=<T8<�B�\Y:=RA<�@�I�RYUK\YG�B�v�<!RY\AUK@�O,UK\�@SO=Dpq~IQ@SRb@�O=<[T8<!T f <�Rb@�I�>�_=<[_=@S:=\Y<!_=@�DK^?B�O�^VO=@�>�IQ@SR

Page 28: 9= . >@?A . B C D1 E › files › docs › colloqpapers › w05 › Sc… · 0 (* %-$#+1 $3245$768&3 9:;&< # 9=" . >@?A . B C" D1 E FHGJILKMGON5PRQLSTPRQ UMSVK W;XZY\[^]`_Vacbd_eY\fZahgjilknmpo_eY\]

���������������� !���#"$ %� & �

>A_=<~IhB�T]UWDWqaB�\�B,`5_=@SDW<�k¨{${X¶JB�DK\Y@,�zO=^E>�_zB}>j_=@S:=\Y<!_=@SDW^=\jUKO3v|UKDWDB�LS<�\[`5Up>�_E_=UKL�_=<!RT8<!^=UKB�O8DB�O=^]_=@SDW^=UKO=L�\bLSUpvS<�IQ<�`b<!RuLSUpIe>�\�ko¡N_=UW\�RA<�\A:=Dp>u\Y_=@S:=DW^,O=@�>�_zB�\Y>AUKDpq f <[:=\A<�^>A@�F!@�O=F!DW:=^=<[>A_zBZ>�_=@S:=\Y<!_=@SDW^=\�UWO]>A_=<!\Y<Jv|UKDKDKB�LS<�\bBZRA<JT8@SRY<�>ARA:=\�>$`�@SR�>�_MqSc=B�\�¶._zB�v�<O=@Z>�qS<�>5F!@SOM>ARA@SDWDK<!^8IQ@SR�F�RA@Sr?F%_�@SUKF�<iB�O=^Vv|UWDKDBZLS<!\�`5UW>A_,DB�RYLS<�DB�O=^|w$_=@SDW^=UKO�LS\�r=DB�OM>á�:=Up>�<�^�UWÉ�<!RA<�OM>iF!RY@Sr=\J>A_zB�O3^=@Vv|UWDKDBZLS<!\5`5UW>A_s\AT]B�DKDW<!R�DB�O�^Pw$_=@�DK^=UWO=LS\!k5Ï¢<�B�Dp>�_=UW<!R_=@�:=\A<�_=@SDK^�\yLSUpvS<�\AUWLSO=UW�=F�B�OM>�DpqiT8@SRA<�LSUpIe>�\ f :�>y^=@[O=@�>y<�©Pr�<�RAUW<!O=F�<�T8@SRA<.>�_�<�Ie>�>�_zB�Or#@P@�RA<!RN_�@S:=\A<�_=@SDW^=\!k�¡N_=UK\5<�É�<�F�>[UK\NO=@�>[B�\5DKB�RALS<i<�F!@SO�@ST]UWF�B�DWDWqVB�\5@SO=<jT8UKLS_M>N<ª©|wr#<!F�>�k.��_�@S:=\A<�_=@SDW^V>�_zB}>uUK\�>�<�O?r�<�RAF�<!OM>u`b<�B�Dp>�_=UW<!R�LSUWv�<!\�DW<!\Y\�>�_zBZOV>�_=RY<!<[r�<�RAF!<�OM>T8@SRA<�LSUpIe>�\!ko¡N_=UK\bUKT8r=DKUW<!\7>�_=BZ>NB�Dp>�_=@�:=LS_]`b<�BZDW>�_�UK<!R�_=@S:�\A<!_�@SDK^=\�^=@�LSUpvS<[B�_=UKL�_=<!R>A@�>%B�D.vZB�DW:=<]@ZIuLSUpIe>�\!c�>�_=<�q¬LSUWv�<VB�\YTVBZDKDK<�Rir=RA@�r�@SR�>�UW@SO¢@ZIu>�_=<�UKRj`�<!B�DW>A_¢>A_zB�OC^=@r#@P@�RA<!Ri_�@S:=\A<�_=@SDW^=\!k~¡N_=<8RA<�DBZ>AUWv�<!DWq�\AT]B�DWDoF!@|<��8F�UK<!OM>�@SO3`b<�B�Dp>�_¬\A:=LSL�<!\Y>A\�>A_zBZ>T8@P^�<!DK\5UWO�`5_=UWF%_sLSUWIe>A\�B�RA<�LSUWv�<!Os@�:�>J@ZI�B�DW>ARA:=UW\AT�@�R[UWO�@SRY^=<!R5>�@]T]Up>�UKLSBZ>�<i<�O�v�qB�RY<~O=@�>j^=RYUWv|UKO�L,>�_=<~RY<!\A:�DW>�\�k~¶�>j\A:=L�LS<!\�>�\i>�_zB}>i>�_=UW<�vS<�\�B�RA<~\�>�<�BZDKUKO�L?\AUKT8r=Dpq f <�wF!B�:=\A<[>�_=<�q]^�<!\AUWRA<J>A_=<J@ f Ç <!F�>u>�_=<�q]B�RA<[\Y>�<!B�DKUWO=L=c|B�O=^]>�_zBZ>bIhB�RAT8<!RY\�BZRA<JL�UWv|UKO=L�UKO@SRY^=<!Ru>A@]DWUKT8UW>�>�_=<�B�T8@S:=OM>N>�B�G�<�Odk

Ø[@�:=\A<�_=@SDK^�\u`5_=UKF%_?DWUWvS<[F!DW@S\A<�R�>�@�B�r#@SDKUWF!<�\Y>�BZ>�UW@SO?B�F�>�:zB�DWDWq8<�©Pr#<!RYUK<!O�F!<iT8@SRA<>A_=<�Ie>!c�`5_�UKF%_HUK\t`5_zBZ>�@SO=<VT]UWLS_M>�<�©Pr#<!F�>]UpIN>�_=<?r#@SDWUKF!<8`�<�RA<?F�@SRARY:=r�>8B�O=^Hr=B�R�w>AUKF!UWrzBZ>AUKO=L1UKO¬>�_=<]>�_=<�Ie>�k {$´ ¡y@�>A<!\�>�>�_=BZ>�^=UW\Y>�B�O=F!<8>�@3Bar�@�DKUKF�<]\�>%BZ>AUK@SO¬`uBZ\�O=@�>r=RY@�©Pq|UWO=L�IQ@SRtDK@|F�B�D�^=<�v�<!DW@Sr=T8<!OM>~¶i<!\�>�UWTVBZ>A<!^g>A_=<,\�qP\�>�<�T UKO=F�DK:=^�UKO=L f @Z>�_C^=UW\�w>�B�O=F!<�>�@�Bar#@SDWUKF!<�\�>%BZ>AUK@SO¢B�O=^¬^=UK\�>%B�O�F!<]>A@�BarzB�vS<�^CRA@MBZ^ f :P>�>�_�<]^=UW\Y>�B�O=F!<�>�@>A_=<�r#@SDKUWF!<�\Y>�BZ>�UW@SO�T]B�UKOM>�B�UKO=<�^sB8\AUKL�O=UW�zF!B�OM>;O=<�LMBZ>AUWvS<tF!@|<��8F!UW<!OM>;`5_=UWDK<j>�_=<�F!@Zw<��]F�UK<�O�>�@SOa^=UW\Y>%BZO=F!<i>�@8B~rzB�vS<�^�RY@MB�^?`uBZ\[UWO=\AUWLSO=UW�=F�B�OM>�k

R�©'Ô U�®+Ø ±0¶lÚ æ"Ø ±7×«Ú ­�±�×�¯\Ö ã5¯�Ö�±0Ý�¯�·È·È׫Ö-à ³;¯�Ý�ãÄÝ�¯^S ãÄÙ-¯�×�è/¶� �H����� � nY{W�lq/u¥qA~�q�� nϤ_=<�OtF�@SOM>�RY@SDKDWUKO=L�IQ@�R�F!RA@�r�F%_�@SUKF�<�cZB�Ot<�O=^=@SL�<!O=@S:�\�^�<!F!UW\AUW@SOjTVB�^�< f qi>A_=<7IhB�RYT]<�R!cUp>.`5UKDKD�_zB�vS<[>A@ f <�UKO=\�>�RA:�T]<�O�>A<!^8IQ@SR!ky¡N_=<!RY<;B�RY<[T�:�DW>�UWr=DK<br�@Z>�<!OM>AUB�DzUWO=\Y>ARA:=T8<!OM>�\IQ@SR�F!RA@�r�F%_�@SUKF�<�kg¶$O�\Y>�<!B�^�@�I�:=\AUWO=L¬ßiÒyÓC¶jT�:=\�>�O=@�`�<�\Y>�UWTVB}>�<]>A_=<?\Yq|\�>�<!TÈ@ZIÂΠçLÎ�ÚÊɾԹÇ�Î�î�Ì-ÈÊÑZé^Ô�ËÍëDÎ`ÕÍÈÛԦѪɾÇ�Ô`ô�ÈÊÑ�â¹Èèé�ÕÍÇ�̯Ç�Ô¦Ò�É­Ì�Ç�Ô�ÚÙÖªÖZÈÙÖªÑ�ÔnÕ,ÕÄÎnæ�ÌDÔ¦ÒZÕ;Ï\˾ÌÝÖZÈèÕ,é^Ô¦Ë,é^Ì�Î�˲ÔnéÓ�ÒZÕ¾Õ¾ÈÊÑ�â-Õ¾Ç�Ì�ëDÉ­Ì�ÚÛî¦Ì�É�Î`Õ�ËÍÈÊɾæRáZÐ�ÒZÕ#ÕÍÇ�ÈÙÉ�î�Î�˾ÈÙÎnÐ�ÚÛÌ,ÎnÚÙɾÔ�ÇMÎ�ÖHÎnÑHÈÛÑ�ɾÈÊâ�Ñ�ÈÜÀMÏ\Î�Ñ�Õ�Ï\Ô�Ì��¯ÏdÈÊÌ\Ñ�Õ�ðÂÎÅ ç+ÖZÔ�Ñ�ÔnÕ�ÐMÌ�ÚÛÈÊÌ\î¦Ì.ÕÍÇ�ÈÙÉ'ÌÈd¥ÌÝÏpÕ�ÈÙÉJÖ�Ò�Ì.ÕÍÔlÕÍÇ�Ì5é¢Î�ÏpÕJÕ¾ÇMÎ`Õ�ÓMÔ¦ÚÛÈÙÏd̠ɽÕÄÎ`ÕÍÈÛÔ¦Ñ�ÉJë-Î�×-Ð¥ÌLÓ�ÚÊΦÏdÌÝÖDô�Ç�Ì\ËÍÌÏdËÍÈÛë-ÌÈÊÉ;ô'Ô¦ËÍÉ­Õ�ð�Æ�Ç�Ì�ɾÌrÓ¥Ô�ÚÊÈÙÏdÌÉ­ÕÍÎnÕ¾ÈÊÔ�Ñ�ÉlÇ�Î�î�ÌÐMÌ�Ì\Ñ´ÕÍÇ�Ì\ËÍÌΤÚÛÔ¦Ñ�âuÕÍÈÛë-̦ð�÷5Ö�ÖZÈÛÕ¾ÈÊÔ�Ñ�Î�ÚÛÚÊ×�áhÕÍÇ�Ì�ɾÌ˾ÌÝÉ­Ò�ÚèÕÄɨËÍÌdé^Ì\Ë+Õ¾Ô,ÕÍÇ�Ì#ÕÍÇ�ÌdécÕ�Ôné4ɾëDÎnÚÊÚÛÌ�Ë+ÈÛÕ¾Ì\ëDÉ�á¦ô�Ç�ÈÛÚÊÌ#ÕÍÇ�Ì.Ó¥Ô�ÚÊÈÊÏ\Ì#é^ÔZÏdÒMɨÔ�ѯÏ\Ô�ë;Ð�Î`ÕÍÈÛÑ�â;Ï\Î`Õ¾Õ¾ÚÊÌ#ÕÍÇ�ÌdécÕÝáÎnËÍë-Ì�Ö˾ԦÐ�ÐMÌ�˾ÈÊÌ�É�áZÎnÑ�ÖHÇ�Ô¦ë-ÈÊÏ\ÈÊÖZ̦ð

Page 29: 9= . >@?A . B C D1 E › files › docs › colloqpapers › w05 › Sc… · 0 (* %-$#+1 $3245$768&3 9:;&< # 9=" . >@?A . B C" D1 E FHGJILKMGON5PRQLSTPRQ UMSVK W;XZY\[^]`_Vacbd_eY\fZahgjilknmpo_eY\]

���������������� !���#"$ %� & �

<�á|:=BZ>�UW@SO=\5:=\AUWO=L ± Ý�Ý¢kz¡N_=<j\Yq|\Y>A<!T�@�Iy<!á�:zBZ>AUK@SO�\�<�\Y>AUKT]BZ>�<�^aUW\º l ôÕ� ñ l �@ê©� l �@ì lº { ôÕ� ñ { �@ê©� { �@ì {º ´ ôÕ� ñ ´ �@ê©� ´ �@ì ´

`5_=<�RA< � B�RY<�>�_=<~<ª©P@SLS<!O�@S:=\iRA<�LSRA<�\A\Y@SRA\jB�O�^Xê�UW\;F!RY@Sr3F%_=@SUWF!<�kj¡N_=<~UWO=\Y>ARA:=T8<!OM>\Y<�>uÖ�UKO=F�DK:=^�<!\bB�DKDz@�I�>�_=<[<!DW<!T8<!OM>�\�@�I � cPB�\�`�<�DKD#B�\bBt\A<�>�@ZI�UKO=\�>�RY:=T]<�OM>�\�IQ@SR�F!RA@�rF%_=@�UKF!<Zk[¡N_�<�T]@�T]<�O�>[F!@�O=^=UW>AUK@SO�\�RY<!á�:=UWRA<�>A_zBZ>J×[��Ö�Æ�ì ×  �ô Ñ8IQ@SR�<�v�<!RYq�<!á�:zBZ>AUK@SOØ k

9;<��=O=<i>�_=<jT]BZ>�RYUp©V@�IoRY<!LSRY<!\Y\A@SRY\

Ù+Ú ô ÛÜ � Ú l Ñ ÑÑ � Ú { ÑÑ Ñ � Ú ´

ÝÞIQ@SR]<�B�F%_ÙUWO=^=UpvPUW^=:zB�D£ß�\A@g>A_zBZ> � Ú l UKO=F�DK:=^=<�\?B�DWD�@ZIi>�_=<�RA<!L�RA<!\Y\A@SRY\?UKO�>�_=<��=RA\Y><�á|:=BZ>�UW@SOÙ�QUKO=F�DK:=^=UWO=L f @Z>�_ � B�O=^5ê   c � Ú { UWO=F!DW:=^=<�\�B�DWD.@�Iu>A_=<]RY<!LSRY<!\Y\A@SRY\�UKOE>�_=<\Y<!F!@�O=^1<!á�:zBZ>AUK@SOdcP<�>AF�k�¡N_=<;T]BZ>�RYUp©+ÙÚUW\u@ f >�B�UKO=<�^ f q,\�>%B�F%G�UKO�L�>�_=<;T]BZ>ARAUKF�<!\uÙsÚIQ@SR�BZDKD=UWO=^=UWv|UW^=:zB�DW\!k�¡N_=<5TVBZ>ARAUm©~@�I�UKO=\�>�RY:=T]<�OM>�\^à¤_=B�\�B�\YUKT8UKDBZRy\�>�RA:�F�>�:�RA<�k�¡N_=<T]BZ>�RYUp©XáûUK\N@ f >�B�UKO�<!^ f q?\Y>�B�F%G�UKO=L�>�_=<jUWO=^=UWv|UW^=:zB�D#vS<!F�>�@SRY\

á�Ú ô ÛÜ º²Ú lº²Ú {º²Ú ´ÝÞ

¶�<�\Y>AUKT]BZ>�<;>A_=<jF!@|<��8F!UW<!OM>�\5UKO?>A_=<iIQ@SDKDW@Ì`5UWO=L�`�B�qSk

� k[×.\�>�UKT]BZ>A<NB�O�UKO=Up>�UKB�DPF�@SO=\YUK\Y>A<!OM>�<!\�>�UKT]BZ>A@SR7@�I|ñsB�O�^8F!B�DKD�UW>ãâ âñ�k7nz@SR7>A_=UK\.\�>�<�r¶�:=\Y<�>A_=<t&SÓ�Ò�Ó1<�\Y>AUKT]BZ>�@SR�kâ âñ ô � Ù Æ à��)à Æ à   3 l à Æ Ù � 3 l Ù Æ à��)à Æ à   3 l à Æ á

&|k[nzRY@STÐ>A_=UK\N@SO�<�@ f >%B�UWO=\u>�_�<�RY<!\YUK^=:zBZD�vS<�F�>�@�RA\ â â ì�Ú ô º²ÚtÃäÙsÚ â âñÆPk[¯�\AUWO=L�>�_�<!\A<?RY<!\YUK^=:zBZDK\!c.¶j<�\Y>�UWTVB}>�<]>A_=<?@Sr�>AUKT]B�D.`�<�UKLS_M>AUKO=LsT]BZ>ARAUp©�åæ ô��ç 3 l�VéèÚËê l à+ÆÚ â âì�Ú â âì ÆÚ àëÚ   3 l

° k[¯�\AUWO=La>A_=UK\i`b<!UWLS_M>�UKO�L�T]BZ>�RYUp©s@SO=<8F�B�O¢@ f >%BZUKOE>�_=<8@Sr�>AUKT]B�DoDWUKO=<!B�R ± Ý�Ý<�\Y>AUKT]BZ>�@SR âñ ô � Ù Æ àìåæíà Æ Ù � 3 l Ù Æ à!åæîà Æ á

Page 30: 9= . >@?A . B C D1 E › files › docs › colloqpapers › w05 › Sc… · 0 (* %-$#+1 $3245$768&3 9:;&< # 9=" . >@?A . B C" D1 E FHGJILKMGON5PRQLSTPRQ UMSVK W;XZY\[^]`_Vacbd_eY\fZahgjilknmpo_eY\]

���������������� !���#"$ %� ÆSÑ

� �H�����  &k�}�~:n k5n z|{W�0{yv:qAz¡N_=<�T]@S\�>,F�@ST]T8@SO=DpqÔ\Y>A@SDK<�OèF!RY@Sr=\,UWO�>�_=<�\A:=R�vS<�qèB�RA<�`uBZ>A<!RYT]<�DK@SO=\�cNT]<�DK@SO�\!cf BZOzB�OzB�\�c�F!@SRYOdc|B�O=^]q|:=F�F�B�k.¡N_�<[^�q|OzBZT]UWFNDKUKT8UW>A<!^Pw�F!@ST8T8UW>�T8<!OM>�T8@P^=<�D=r=RY<!^=UWF�>�\>A_zBZ>5B~_=@S:�\A<!_�@SDK^?r=DKB�OM>�UWO=L�>�_=<�\A<iF�RA@Sr=\N>A_=<;`5UKDWD�LSUpvS<iT8@SRA<JLSUWIe>A\uB�O=^?>ARA:=\�>5DK<!\Y\!k� RY@SrtF%_�@SUKF�<bUW\�UWO=F!DW:=^=<�^tBZ\oB�O�<�©Pr=DKB�OzBZ>A@SRYqJv�BZRAUB f DK<.UWO=^=UKF!BZ>�UWO=Lu_=@�`HT]B�OMqi@�IP>�_=<B f @�vS<;DWUK\�>�<!^VF!RA@�r=\u>�_=<J_=@S:=\Y<!_=@SDW^?r=DBZO�>A<!^dk7�[@�>A<J>�_zB}>NF!RY@Sr?F%_=@SUWF!<;UW\�T8<�B�\Y:=RA<�^B�\i>A_=<]O�:=T f <�Rt@�Ib<�BZ\AUKDpq3\Y>A<�B�DKB f DW<~F!RA@�r=\tr�DB�OM>�<�^¢RABZ>�_�<!Ri>�_zBZO¢>�_�<�>A@�>%BZD7v�BZDK:=<r=DKB�OM>�<�^�UWOa>A_=<!\Y<�F!RY@Sr=\�kN¡N_=UK\�UK\N>�_�<�B�r�r=RA@Sr�RAUB}>�<jF%_=@SUWF!<�UWI7Up>5UK\5>�_=<�^=<�F!UK\YUK@SO1>�@r=DKB�OM>�`�BZ>�<�RAT8<!DK@�O=\!c�B�O=^HO�@�>�_=@�`ÖT]B�OMqg>A@3r=DBZO�>�`5_=UKF%_Ô<�É�<!F�>�\~>�_�<�Ie>�c�UÎkÜ<ZkWc�UWI`5_=<�>�_=<�RiB8IhBZRAT8<!R�r=DB�OM>A\i&�ÑSÑ�`uB}>�<!RYT]<�DK@SO�\J@SR � ÑSÑSÑPc�>A_=<�>A_=UK<�I.\Y>A<�B�DW\[>�_�<�\�BZT]<B�T8@S:=OM>!k { Ë

Ϥ_=UWDK<HF!@�O=\A<�RYv|UKO=L¦^=<�LSRA<�<!\¬@�I]IQRY<!<�^=@ST UWO F�@ST8rzB�RAUW\A@SOÊ`5Up>�_®UKO�F!DK:�^=UKO=L¤B^=:�T]T�qJIQ@SR�<�B�F%_t@�I�>A_=@S\Y<���vS<�F�RA@Sr�\�r�DB�OM>�<�^dc�:�\AUKO�L5>A_=<�O|:�T f <�R*@�I=F�RA@Sr=\�r=DKB�OM>�<!^B�\tB�O¬<�©Pr=DKB�OzBZ>A@SRYq3vZB�RYUB f DW<~UKT8r�@�\A<!\�BaDKUKO�<�B�RYUW>$qs@�O¬>A_=<]<�É�<�F�>�@�IuF�RA@Sr¢F%_=@SUKF�<�k¶;_=B�v�<,B�DW\A@1>�RYUK<!^¢:=\AUWO=L�>A_=<8\Aá�:zB�RY<,B�O=^¬>�_=<]DK@SL1@�I�>�_=<8O�:=T f <!R�@ZIuF!@�T]T8@SO=Dpq\�>�@SDW<!OaF!RA@�r=\�`5_�UKF%_sBZRA<jr=DBZO�>A<!^dc#B�\5`b<!DKD*BZ\[F�@SOMvS<!R�>�UWO=L]>A_=<tF�@S:=OM>[^zBZ>%B�UKOM>A@VB�OUWO=^=UKF!BZ>�@�RJvZB�RAUKB f DK<�IQ@SRir=DKB�OM>�UKO�L1>A_=RA<�<�@SRiT]@�RA<~@�I�>�_=@�\A<�F!RY@Sr=\tB�O=^3>�_=<�RY<!\A:�DW>�\B�RY<iO=@�>�\A: f \Y>�B�OM>�UBZDKDWq]^=UpÉ�<�RA<!OM>!k {$ê

�J\yF!RY@Sr�F%_=@SUWF!<bUK\*<!O=^�@SLS<!O�@S:=\7¶�UWO=\Y>ARA:=T8<!OM>�IQ@SR�>A_=<�O�:=T f <�Ro@�I�F!RA@�r=\7r=DKB�OM>�<!^UWO8&�ÑSÑM&J`5UW>A_~>�_=<Nv|UKDWDB�LS<br=RAUWF!<�\.@�I f B�OzB�OzBZ\!cM`uB}>�<!RYT]<�DK@SO�c�B�O=^�qP:�F!F�BjUKO �����S� cMB�\`b<!DWD=B�\oB�O~UKO=^�UKF�B}>�@SR*vZB�RAUKB f DK<�IQ@SR�`5_=<�>A_=<!R.@SRyO=@�>y>�_=<u_�@S:=\A<�_=@SDW^~r=DB�OM>A<!^�BJLSRY<!<�OT]B�O�:=RA<8F!@�v�<!R~F!RY@SrCUWOC&�Ñ�ÑM&Pk1¶$OC�Jr�r�<�O=^=Up©C9Ö¶i\Y_=@�`�RA<!\Y:=DW>A\�`5_=<�OCUKO=F�DK:=^�UKO=L>A_=<NO�:=T f <!R.@�I#\Y>A<�B�DKB f DW<�F!RY@Sr=\.r=DKB�OM>�<�^8UWO ���S�S� B�\�B�O�B�^=^�UW>�UW@SOzB�D|UKO�\Y>�RY:=T8<!OM>7IQ@SR>A_=<~O�:=T f <!R;r=DKB�OM>�<�^¬UWO¬&�ÑSÑM&|k�¶5:=\Y<�rzB�\Y>;R�BZ>A_=<!R;>A_zB�O3F!:�RARA<�OM>tr�RAUKF�<!\;>A@1B�v�@SUK^UWO=F!@SRYr�@�R�BZ>AUKO=L�<�É�<�F�>A\�>A_=<�B�T]@�:=OM>5r=DB�OM>A<!^1UKOaB�qS<!B�R5TVB�q?_zB�v�<t@SO?>A_=<jr=RAUWF!<iUKO>A_zBZ>NqS<!B�R!k

¡N_=<�r=DBZO�>AUKO=L~@ZIoLSRY<!<�O�T]B�O�:=RA<�\5UK\5B�RA<!DKBZ>�UpvS<�DWq]O=<�`Õ\Y@SUKD�F!@SO=\Y<!R�v�B}>�UK@�O1>A<!F%_PwO=UWá�:=<uUKO�xyB�R�BZLS:zB�qSk7¡N_�<N_=@S:=\Y<!_=@SDW^=\o`5_=UWF%_�r=DB�OM>.L�RA<!<�O�TVB�O�:=RY<!\.BZRA<uO=@Z>.O=<!F�<!\¹w\AB�RAUWDWq~>�_�<i_=@S:=\Y<!_=@SDW^=\�`5Up>�_V>A_=<;`�@�RA\Y>u\A@SUWDµk7¡N_=<�qV>A<!O=^,>A@ f <;_�@S:=\A<�_=@SDW^=\�`5_=UWF%_B�RY<VF�:=RAUW@S:=\tB�O=^C<�O Ç @�q¢>ARYq|UKO=L�O=<�`�F�RA@Sr=\�k�¡N_�<,r=DBZO�>AUKO=La@�I5LSRY<!<�OCTVBZO|:�RA<!\tUK\r#@�>�<�OM>�UBZDKDWq;BJLS@|@P^tUKO=\�>�RY:=T]<�OM>yIQ@SR�F!RY@Sr�F%_=@�UKF!< f <�F�B�:�\A<u_=@�:=\A<�_=@SDK^�\o`5_=UKF%_�r=DB�OM> ã Æ�Ç�ÈÊɠɾÌ\Ì\ëDÉ#Õ¾ËÍÒ�̲é^ËÍÔ�ë Ï\ΦɭÒ�Î�ÚVÏdÔ¦Ñ�î�Ì\ËÄÉÍÎ`Õ¾ÈÊÔ�ÑMÉ�ô�ÈèÕÍÇBé¢ÎnËÍë-Ì\ËÄÉ.ÎnÑMÖ¹ÈÊÉ ÎnÚÙɭԯɾÒ�â¦â�Ì�É­Õ¾ÌÝÖ¹Ð�×rÕÍÇ�ÌÏdÔ�Ì��¯Ï\ÈÛÌ�ѦÕÄÉ�é^Ô�Ò�ÑMÖ;ÈÊÑDÆTÎ�Ð�ÚÊÌ�å Ô¦Ñ-ô'ÌÝÎnÚÛÕ¾Ç�ô�Ç�ÈÊÏÄÇDɾÇ�Ô`ôJÌ�ÖlÕ¾Ç�ÎnÕ¨ë�Ԧ˾Ì�ôJÌ�Î�ÚèÕÍÇ�ײé¢ÎnËÍë�Ì�ËÍÉ�â¦ÈÛî¦Ì'é^Ì�ô'Ì�Ëâ�ÈÛécÕÍÉhÎ�Ñ�ÖlÌ�¸ZÓMÌ�˾ÈÊÌ\Ñ�Ï\Ì�ÚÛÌÝɾÉTÕ¾Ç�ÌdécÕ'ΦÉ�ΠÓ�ËÍÔ�Ó¥Ô�˾վÈÊÔ�Ñ;Ôné¥ÈÛÑ�Ï\Ô�ë-ÌJÕ¾Ç�Î�Ñ;Ó¥Ô�Ô�ËÍÌ\Ë�é¢ÎnËÍë-Ì\ËÄÉ�ßcÕ¾Ç�Ô�Ò�â¦Ç�ë-Ԧ˾ÌÔ`î�Ì�ËÍÎ�ÚÛÚcàpðÂ�� Æ�Ç�ÌB˾ÌÝÉ­Ò�ÚèÕÄÉDô�Ç�Ì\Ñ�Ò�ɾÈÊÑ�âªÕ¾Ç�ÌBÑ�Ò�ë;ÐMÌ�˯Ôné,ÏdËÍÔ�ÓMÉ-Ó�ÚÊÎ�Ñ�Õ¾Ì�Ö�Ô¦Ë-Õ¾Ç�̤É)ï�Ò�ÎnËÍÌHÔnéLÕ¾Ç�ÌBÑ�Ò�ë;ÐMÌ�ËÓ�ÚÙÎnÑ�Õ¾ÌÝÖuÎnËÍ̲ÕÍÇ�Ì�É­Õ¾ËÍÔ�Ñ�â�Ì�É­Õ�ð Æ�Ç�ÈÙɠɾÒ�â¦â�Ì�É­ÕÍÉ#Õ¾Ç�ÎnÕ5ÕÍÇ�ÌlÌÈd¥ÌÝÏpÕ,Ôné¨Ó�ÚÊÎ�ѦÕÍÈÛÑ�ârë-Ô�ËÍÌlÌÝÎ�ɾÈÛÚÊ×BɽÕÍÌ�ÎnÚÙÎnÐ�ÚÛÌÏdËÍÔ�Ó�ÉJÈÊÑ�ÏdËÍÌ�ΦɭÌÝÉ�Î`Õ.ÎnÑHÈÊÑ�ÏdËÍÌ�ΦɭÈÊÑ�â�ËÍÎnÕ¾Ì�ð

Page 31: 9= . >@?A . B C D1 E › files › docs › colloqpapers › w05 › Sc… · 0 (* %-$#+1 $3245$768&3 9:;&< # 9=" . >@?A . B C" D1 E FHGJILKMGON5PRQLSTPRQ UMSVK W;XZY\[^]`_Vacbd_eY\fZahgjilknmpo_eY\]

���������������� !���#"$ %� Æ �

¡yB f DW< Þ ç�ðHñ)v�p��{@��{W���tn�ò(pynh�Apyn ����v:qAzÛqts���pyqt} ��lqAv���n�q|z {y�¥n÷n©¨/q��tn zlqAjl�k0�7pv��7m�~:nU�Mjl��v�z§�\q+ª6�5�Sv�{y�Ä��zlu@�Sv�{y�¥q|j/{(v�zl�8~�jlulv�z§�Zv�z���{Wpj�k5n z|{W��� x o¥oZbÄ�mpbpY\f��4�©kn�%]`a¢_4mpbpk`Ydkn��mpbdfZs4�4f�Y\��k`YdYdoZY\m[^s��Vf�Y\kns�bd£eknm\[^m`�Ñó`��»�³ Ò ¡ëó�ó`��»�Ä Ò ¡#fZs4�Wó�ó�ó`��»�» Òmd[cX�s4[ËôV]`fZs�b`� É oZ�¥Ì¥bpknfZa^f�®Vack w Y\oZ�Vmx k`b ³m´µ³�³Á· ³m´µ³©ºr· ¸,³m´µ³�³�ÂG »L¼ » ´ Q K G »L¼ » ´'H K G »L¼ »�Ë ´ K½ [^�4s ¾ b,·.a¢fn{§Ã-fZtBknm ³m´µ³Á·Á¶ ³m´ËºrÈ�È ¸,³m´µ³<¶�»G »L¼ { ^�Ë K G »L¼ {'¸${ K G »L¼ ´ » ¸ KÅ oÏÆ-sekD·�fZmdmpknm�¿J[^kna^� ¸¹³m´Ëº�ºrÄ ¸¹³m´Ëºr·�» ¸,³m´µ³ÁÄmºG »L¼ lQË { K G »L¼ l ´ Q K G »L¼ l ê$ê KÉ ���;m²[¢ss·�Ä�³¤t i;fZ�4[^_4m ¸¹³m´µ³ÁÀ�³ �'�'� ¸¹³m´µ³Á·�Ä �'� ¸,³m´µ³©ºr¿G »L¼ »Al$l K G »L¼ »Al { K G »L¼ »Al$l KÉ W��4_4acb¹ÊCfZacknm ¸¹³m´µ³Á·�Ä ¸¹³m´µ³�³Á¿ ¸,³m´µ³ÁÄ�»G »L¼ » H » K G »L¼ » H » K G »L¼ » H l K¿4fZtu[^a^{ÏÌR[c«`k ³m´Ëºr·mº �'�'� ³m´Ëº�ºr· �'�'� ³m´Ëº�ºJ¶ �'�'�G »L¼ » ´ ^ K G »L¼ » ´ Q K G »L¼ »�Ë�l K¯ oZXQ°�Í�knfZacbd£�± ³m´µ³ÁÀ� ¸¹³m´µ³�³ÁÀ ¸,³m´µ³Á·mºG »L¼ »�Ë ê K G »L¼ »�Ë ¸ K G »L¼ » ê Ë KÉ w aco�mdk¯i²kna^f�bd[c�Zknml[^sÏÎ�[¢a^a^f�XZk ¸¹³m´µ³Á·�À ¸¹³m´µ³Á·mº ¸,³m´µ³�³ÁÈG »L¼ » { Ë K G »L¼ » { Ë K G »L¼ » {'H KÐ knf�Y\ml[¢sÏÎ�[^a¢a^f�XZk ³m´µ³�³©º ³m´µ³�³ÁÀ ³m´µ³�³Á¿G »L¼ »'»�Ë K G »L¼ »'» ê K G »L¼ {$´'H KÎ�[¢a^a Ê*kn�4[¢fZs ¯ fZs4�+Æ-�lsekn� ¸¹³m´µ³�Â<»W�'�'� ¸¹³m´µ³ÁÄmº;�'�'� ¸¹³m´µ³ÁÀ�¿W�'�G »L¼ »Al { K G »L¼ »Al { K G »L¼ »AlQË KÅ kn[^X�£�®©oZY²»'Y\_4mpb¾�5oZYdbd£V[^seknmdm ³m´Ç¶�È�¿W� ³m´�È�Ä�¿W� º�´µ³�³<¶��'�G »L¼ ËÈQYl K G »L¼ Ë H ^ K G »L¼ ê »�Ë KÒ oZ�_Î�[^a¢a^f�XZk¯�lkna^�V[^seXB[^s w £¥_eY\]�£ ¸¹³m´µ³�³ÁÀ ¸¹³m´µ³�³ÁÀ ³m´µ³�³©ºG »L¼ »'»�Ë K G »L¼ »'»�Ë K G »L¼ »'»�Ë KÓ [^aco�tuk`bpk`Y\mLbpo¤·Jo�a^[^]�k ³m´µ³©ºr· ³m´µ³Á·Á¶ ³m´µ³�Â<ÀG »L¼ » {'H K G »L¼ » { Q K G »L¼ » ´$´ K·.a^fZsMb;Ã�Ydk`knsÑʧfZs¥_eYdk ³m´�ÀÁ¶�ÄW� ³m´Ã²¶�·W�'�G »L¼ { l ´ K G »L¼ {$´'H KÎ�[¢a^a^f�XZk6Í%f�bpk`Y\tBknaco�s�·#Y�[^]�kD[^sõºr»�»�» ³m´�·�È�³ �'� ³m´ÃÂhºr» �'�'�G »L¼ l$l�» K G »L¼ l$l�Q KÎ�[¢a^a^f�XZk x fZs4fZs4fu·.Y\[^]�k¯[^sõºr»�»�» ¸¹³m´µ³�³ÁÈ ¸,³m´µ³�³ÁÄG »L¼ » ´$ê K G »L¼ » ´ ^ KÎ�[¢a^a^f�XZk Ð _4]`]`f¤·.Y\[^]�k¯[^sõºr»�»�» ¸¹³m´ÃÂ<»�» ¸,³m´Ç¶�¶®ºG »L¼ ^�Ë�» K G »L¼ Q H'H KÉ oZ�§Ì¥bpknfZa^f�®Vack w YdoZ�Vm,[^söºr»�»�» ³m´�·�¿�À �'�'�G »L¼ » ¸ l KÔ { ³R��·�·�¿ ³R��·�¿� ³R��À�·�ÈÍ%fZa^�*»'knmpb²�°oZY²¬Äs4mpb`�÷ÌR[cXe� »¥��»�ÀÁ¶+°ÇøÏùú³m´�»�¿Á± ·�»¥��À�»�¿+°Çøsùûº�´µ³�³<±ü »'knmpb²�°oZY²¬ÍsVmpb`�÷ÌR[cXe� ·¥��¿�·�³�°ÇøÏùú³m´�»�·Á± ¿¥�˺r·�³X°ÇøÏùûº�´µ³�³<±Æ�®Vm`� ·�·�À ·�·�À ºJ¶�¶

Page 32: 9= . >@?A . B C D1 E › files › docs › colloqpapers › w05 › Sc… · 0 (* %-$#+1 $3245$768&3 9:;&< # 9=" . >@?A . B C" D1 E FHGJILKMGON5PRQLSTPRQ UMSVK W;XZY\[^]`_Vacbd_eY\fZahgjilknmpo_eY\]

���������������� !���#"$ %� ÆM&

LSRY<!<�O¢T]B�O�:=RA<�\i>�<!O�^¬>A@ f <~T8@SRA<�B�^PvS<!OM>A:=RA@S:�\�UKOs>A_=<!UWRiF!RY@Sr¢F%_�@SUKF�<]BZO=^Er=DB�OM>T8@SRA<5@�I�>�_=<[<�B�\YUKDWq�\Y>�<!B�DB f DK<�F!RY@Sr=\!k�ß;O8>�_=<[@�>�_=<�Rb_=B�O=^dc�B�\�Bj>�_=UW<�Id`b@S:=DW^VO=<�vS<�R`�B�OM>N>�@~\�>�<�BZD*B�LSRA<�<!O1TVBZO|:�RA<�cP>�_=<ir=DKB�OM>�UWO=L�@�I�LSRY<!<!O1T]B�O�:=RA<�\N\A_=@�:=DK^1_zB�vS<jO=@^=UWRA<�F�>5<�É�<!F�>J@�OaL�UWIe>NLSUpv|UKO=L=c|>�_=<�Ie>�cz@SRu>ARA:=\�>�k

Ϥ_=<�O?<!\Y>AUKT]BZ>�UWO=L�B�\Yq|\�>�<!T�@�I*<�á|:=BZ>�UW@SO=\�:�\AUKO�L ± ÝsÝ¢c�>�_=<�RA<JUW\�O=@tRA<!B�D#�=RA\Y>\�>%B�LS<~RY<!LSRY<!\Y\AUK@�OgB�\i>A_=<!RY<8UW\;`5UW>A_g&�Ó�Ò�Ó�k�Ø[@�`b<�v�<!R!cy¶JUWO=F!DW:=^=<~B,>%B f DK<�`5Up>�_3>�_=<RY<!LSRY<!\A\YUK@SO¬@�IbF!RY@Sr¢F%_�@SUKF�<8@�OgB�DWD7@�I�>�_=<�UWO=\Y>ARA:=T8<!OM>�\�cy\YUKT8UKDKB�R�>A@�B é �zRA\�>Yw�\Y>%BZLS<�§RY<!LSRY<!\A\YUK@SO�>�@jLSUpvS<N>�_�<�RY<�B�^�<!R�\A@ST8<5UK^=<!Bi@�I�>A_=<�F!@SRYRA<!DKBZ>�<�\.@�IdF�RA@Sr8F%_=@SUWF!<Zk7¡oB f DK<Þ \Y_=@�`5\�>�_=<V^=<�>A<!RAT8UKO=B�OM>�\�@�I5F�RA@SrgF%_=@SUKF�< f @�>�_HUWO=F!DW:=^=UKO�L�B�O�^H<�©PF!DW:=^=UKO�L�>�_=<UWO=\Y>ARA:=T8<!OM>�\��hB�\7`b<!DKD�BZ\�BZIe>�<�R.UKO=F�DK:=^=UWO=L;rzBZ\Y>�F!RY@Sr�F%_=@SUKF�<   k7¡N_=<�ýiw�\Y>�BZ>�UW\Y>�UWFuB�O�^>A_=<j_=<�>A<!RA@�\AG�<�^zB�\�>�UKF�UW>$q1F�@SO=\AUW\Y>A<!OM>[ÏgB�DW^Pw$\�>%BZ>AUK\Y>AUKF�>�<!\�>�UWO=L8>A_=< Ç @SUKOM>5\YUKLSO=Up�zF�BZO=F!<@�I�>�_�<jIQ@�:=RNUKO=\�>�RY:=T]<�OM>�\�B�RA<t&Pk � &~B�O=^ � k ��° RA<�\Ar#<!F�>�UWv�<!Dpq?`5_=UKF%_aT]<!B�O=\N>�_=BZ>N>�_=<UWO=\Y>ARA:=T8<!OM>�\�B�RY< Ç @SUKOM>ADWq]\AUKL�O=UW�zF!B�OM>�BZ>[B f @Ìv�<i>�_=< �MÞ ��DK<�vS<!DÎk

Ø[@�:=\A<�_=@SDK^�\yUWOjv|UWDKDBZLS<!\#`5UW>�_�_=UWLS_jT]<�^=UB�OjDKB�O=^Pw�_=@SDK^�UKO=LS\�r=DBZO�>�IQ<�`�<�Ry@ZIP>A_=<!\Y<T8@SRA<t<�B�\YUKDpq�\�>�<�BZDB f DW<�F�RA@Sr=\�k�n�B�RYT]<�RA\[UKO�>A_=<!\Y<�v|UWDKDBZLS<!\[B�RA<�T�:=F%_EDB�RYLS<!R[\AF!B�DK<IhB�RYT]<�RA\8B�O=^�>�<�O=^X>A@¢r=DKB�OM>8\A@�qXB�O=^Ô`5_=<�BZ>8IQ@SR�<�©Pr#@SRY>!kÙn�B�RAT8<!RY\~`5UW>�_�T8@SRA<>ARA:=\�>$`�@SR�>�_Mq¤O=<�UKLS_ f @SRA\1r=DKB�OM>1T]@SRY<3<�B�\YUKDpq�\�>�<�BZDB f DW<3F!RY@Sr=\!cJr�<�RA_zB�r�\ f <!F!B�:=\Y<>A_=<�q¢`�@SRYRYq¢DK<�\A\�B f @S:�>t>�_=<�Ie>�k¬Ø[@S:�\A<!_�@SDK^=\�DKUWv|UWO=L�UWOCT]@�RA<V^�<!O=\Y<!DWqgr�@�r=:=DB}>�<!^B�RY<�B�\Nr�DB�OM>uIQ<�`�<�R�\�>�<!B�DB f DK<JF�RA@Sr�\!cz_=UWO�>AUKO=L�BZ>N`5_Mq,>�_=<�q,LSUpvS<;IQ<�`�<�R�L�UWIe>�\ f <�IQ@SRA<F�@SOM>�RA@�DKDKUWO=L�IQ@SR�F�RA@SrXF%_=@SUKF�<�kXÒ*B�RALS<�R~IhB�T]UWDKUW<!\�r�DB�OM>8T]@�RA<?@�I[>�_=<aT]@�RA<?<�BZ\AUKDpq\�>�<�BZDB f DW<�F�RA@Sr=\�ko¡N_=<Nr�DB�OM>�UWO=LJ@ZI�B[LSRA<�<!O~T]B�O�:=RA<NBZO=^�>�_=<�r=RAUWF!<�@ZI#`�BZ>A<!RAT8<!DW@SO=\UWO ���S��� B�RY< f @�>�_�_=UKLS_�DWqi\YUKLSO=Up�zF�BZO�>oUKOtr=RA<�^=UKF�>�UKO�L[F�:=RARY<!OM>.F!RY@Sr�F%_=@�UKF!<ZcMB�\yUK\�rzB�\Y>F�RA@SraF%_=@SUWF!<�k

¡yB f DK< � \Y_=@�`5\o>�_�< ± ÝsÝÐRA<�\A:=Dp>�\�ko¡N_=<��zRA\�>o>�_�RA<!<�F!@SDW:=T]O�\�<�\Y>AUKT]BZ>�<�>�_=<b\Yq|\�w>A<!TÕ:=\YUKO=L�TVBZO�q;<�©Pr=DBZOzBZ>�@�RYq;vZB�RYUB f DW<!\�cÌ`5_�UKDK<7>A_=<�DB�\�>�>A_=RA<�<bF�@SDK:�T]O=\�:�\A<�IQ<�`b<!R!c^=:�<5>A@tF�@SO=F�<!RAO�\b@�I�^=<!L�RA<!<�\b@ZI�IQRY<!<!^�@ST�k7ØJB�O=\Y<!Od§¨\ÿþ�w$\�>%BZ>AUK\�>�UKFu>A<!\�>�\�`5_=<�>A_=<!R�>�_=<UWO=\Y>ARA:=T8<!OM>*\A<�>�UK\d:=O�F!@SRYRA<!DKBZ>�<�^i`5UW>�_i>A_=<�<!RARY@SRA\��hØJB�O�\A<!O ���S� &   k*¡N_=<£þ�w�\Y>�BZ>�UW\Y>�UWF!\IQ@SR�>�_�<[\�qP\�>�<�T�B�RY< � ÑPk �S� B�O=^ �S� kÜÆ � �eIQ@SR�>�_=<[DB�RYLS<!R�B�O=^]\AT]B�DKDW<!R.\Y<�>u@ZI�<�©Pr=DKB�OzB}w>A@SRYq3vZB�RYUB f DW<!\iRY<!\Ar#<!F�>�UpvS<!Dpq   `5UW>A__½Pw�vZB�DK:�<!\j@�I;k í ÑaB�O=^Xk íSÞ k,¡N_=@S:=L�_¢`b<]G�O=@�`>A_zBZ>;>A_=<!\Y<�>A<!\�>�\;>�<�O=^3>�@ f <�`�<!B�G�`5Up>�_3\YTVB�DWDy^=BZ>%B,\Y<�>�\]�hÍj@|F%_=<�RADBZG�@�>�B ���S� Ñ   c>A_=<j_�q|r#@�>�_�<!\AUW\N>�_zBZ>5>A_=<jUKO=\�>�RA:�T]<�O�>A\�B�RA<i<ª©�@�LS<!O=@�:=\[F!B�O=O=@Z> f <jRA< Ç <!F�>A<!^dk

Ø[@�:=\A<�_=@SDK^�\y`5_=UWF%_�r=DKB�OM>oT8@SRA<�<!B�\AUWDWqj\Y>A<�B�DKB f DW<�F�RA@Sr�\yLSUpvS<�\AUWLSO=UW�=F�B�OM>�DpqiT8@SRA<LSUpIe>�\�cb>�_�@S:=LS_�>�_=<�RA<�UW\]O�@g\AUWLSO=Up�zF�B�OM>8<�É�<!F�>,@SO�>�_=<�Ie>,@SR~>ARA:=\�>�k¤��_�@S:=\A<�_=@SDW^r=DKB�OM>�UWO=Ls@SO=<1<!B�\AUWDWq¢\Y>�<!B�DB f DK<,F�RA@Sr�LSUpvS<!\�BZr=r=RA@�©PUKT]BZ>A<!DWq¢^=@S: f DK<,>A_=<,vZB�DK:=<?@ZILSUpIe>�\5B�\[B�_=@S:=\Y<!_=@SDW^�r=DKB�OM>�UWO=L�O=@V<!B�\AUWDWq,\�>�<!B�DB f DK<jF!RY@Srdku�®_=@S:�\A<!_�@SDK^�r=DB�OM>AUKO=L>$`b@V@�I�>�_�<tF�RA@Sr=\�LSUpvS<!\N>ARAUKr�DK<;>�_�<jvZB�DW:=<j@�I7L�UWIe>�\5BZ\[B�_=@S:�\A<!_�@SDK^ar=DBZO�>AUKO=L�O=@�O=<�k¡N_=UW\�UK\�UKO]B�F!F�@SRA^8`5UW>A_8>A_=<5r=RA<�^=UKF�>�UK@�O=\�@�I�>A_=<[DWUKT8UW>A<!^Pw�F!@ST8T]Up>�T8<!OM>�T]@|^=<�DµcMB�O�^\YDKUKL�_�>ADWqVF!@SOM>�RAB�RYq1>A@]>�_�@S\A<t@�Io>A_=<�@SO�<�w$r#<!RYUK@|^�T8@|^=<!Dd`5_=UWF%_sr=RY<!^=UWF�>�\�>�_zB}>�>A_=<�Ie>

Page 33: 9= . >@?A . B C D1 E › files › docs › colloqpapers › w05 › Sc… · 0 (* %-$#+1 $3245$768&3 9:;&< # 9=" . >@?A . B C" D1 E FHGJILKMGON5PRQLSTPRQ UMSVK W;XZY\[^]`_Vacbd_eY\fZahgjilknmpo_eY\]

���������������� !���#"$ %� ÆSÆ

¡yB f DW< � çui3qApypyn ~��U{Wn �RqAsÿ�Av:s�{b�Av#k/v�z§�§¦l{y�¥nYs�{#n©¨/}onYp�v:n z���n u¹¦���zluë{Wpjl��{#��qAz�l{WpyqA~�~�v�z¥�5sFqtpK��pyqt} ��lqAv���nBj���v�z§���õ�í�â�o��@P@Z>�\Y>AR�B�r�r�<�^3F!DK:�\Y>�<�RA<�^3\Y>%BZO=^zB�RY^<�RARA@�RA\5UKO1rzB�RY<!OM>�_�<!\AUW\!k6«�w � Ñ8�,c¬«m«�w �MÞ �,czB�O�^­«®«m«�w ��� ��\YUKLSO�UW�zF!B�OM>�k¯ oZXQ°À»²£ek`�°b&± ¯ oZXQ°½Ã-[c�R[^seX²± »+Y\_Vmpb ¯ oZXQ°À»²£4k`��b&± ¯ oZXQ°½Ã-[c�R[^seX²± »'Y\_4mdb

x k`b ³m´µ³<¶�¶ ¸,³m´µ³�Â<· ¸,³m´µ³�³�ÂG »L¼ l$l { K G »L¼ »'^'» K G »L¼ »�Ë�l K½ [^�Vs ¾ b²·.a^f�{´ÃDfZtBknm ³m´�»�»�È ¸,³m´ËºrÀ�³ ¸,³m´�À�È�¿G »L¼ H'¸ Q K G »L¼ ê'¸$ê K G »L¼ ´$ê Q KÅ ojÆ-s4k¯·JfZm\mpknml¿�[ckna^� ¸¹³m´�È�»mº;�'� ¸¹³m´�¿�À�Â�'� ³m´�À�·�¿W� ¸¹³m´�»�ÄÁ¶��'�'� ¸¹³m´�»�³©º;�'�'� ³m´ËºrÄ�ÀG »L¼ ´'¸ » K G »L¼ ´ l$l K G »L¼ l�QµË K G »L¼ ´$ê'¸ K G »L¼ ´ » { K G »L¼ l�QµË KÉ �;��ml[^ss·�Ä�³¤t ilfZ�4[¢_4m ³m´µ³�Â<À ¸,³m´µ³Á·�· ¸,³m´µ³©ºrÀG »L¼ »�Ë$Ë K G »L¼ » {'¸ K G »L¼ »Al�^ KÉ W;�4_Vacb¹Ê§fZacknm ¸¹³m´�·�³Á· ³m´�·�¿� � ³m´µ³©ºr· ¸¹³m´Ëºr»�À ³m´ËºrÈ� ¸¹³m´µ³Á·�ÄG »L¼ l H'H K G »L¼ l ´$ê K G »L¼ »�Q H K G »L¼ l�Q { K G »L¼ l {$ê K G »L¼ »�Q ´ K¿VfZtu[^ac{sÌR[c«`k ³m´µ³ÁÄ�³ ¸,³m´µ³ÁÀÁ¶ ³m´µ³�³�ÂG »L¼ l ê Q K G »L¼ » ¸'¸ K G »L¼ » ê Ë K¯ oZXQ°�Í�knfZacbd£(± ³m´µ³ÁÈ�Ä ³m´�·�¿mº �'�'� ¸,³m´µ³�Â<Ä ³m´µ³Á·� ³m´Ëº.ÂÁ³ � ¸¹³m´µ³©ºrÄG »L¼ l$l ê K G »L¼ » ¸ » K G »L¼ » ê Ë K G »L¼ » ¸'H K G »L¼ »�Q ´ K G »L¼ »�Ë ´ KÉ w aco�mpk¯ilkna^f�bd[c�Zknml[¢sÏÎ�[^a¢a^f�XZk ¸¹³m´µ³<¶�¿ ¸,³m´µ³Á»�ÀW� ³m´µ³ÁÀ�À ¸¹³m´µ³ÁÄ�¿ ¸¹³m´µ³ÁÈ�ÀW� ³m´µ³Á·�·G »L¼ » H'H K G »L¼ » ê$´ K G »L¼ » ´${ K G »L¼ » ê'¸ K G »L¼ »�Ë�^ K G »L¼ » {'¸ KÐ knf�Y�ml[^sÏÎ-[^a^a^f�XZk ³m´µ³©º�º ³m´µ³Á·�·W�'�'� ³m´µ³©ºr·W�'�'�G »L¼ »Al�» K G »L¼ »'»'^ K G »L¼ »'»�Ë KÎ-[^a^a ʧkn�4[^fZs ¯ fZs4�ÑÆ��;sekn� ¸¹³m´µ³©ºrÄ ¸,³m´µ³ÁÄ�À ³m´µ³©ºr·G »L¼ » ê Ë K G »L¼ »�Ë { K G »L¼ » {$´ KÅ kn[cX�£M®©oZYl»+Y�_4mpb­� oZYdbd£4[¢seknmdm ³m´ËºrÈ� ³m´�»�·�Ä º�´Ëº�º�º � º�´�»�»�Ä º�´�È�ÀÁ¶ ³m´�À�¿�ÄG lC¼ ´'¸${ K G lC¼ l�^Al K G »L¼ ê QF^ K G lC¼ ê'H${ K G lC¼ {'H Ë K G »L¼ H$ê${ KÒ oZ�_Î-[^a^a¢f�XZk-�;knac�§[¢s w £M_4Y\]\£ ¸¹³m´µ³Á·�È �'� ¸,³m´µ³�³©º ³m´µ³©ºrÄ �'�'�G »L¼ »Al$l K G »L¼ »'» ¸ K G »L¼ »'» H KÓ [^aco�tBk`bpk`Y\mLbpo�·'o�a¢[^]�k ¸¹³m´Ëº�º�³ ³m´µ³�Â<» ³m´µ³©ºJ¶G »L¼ »�Q { K G »L¼ » ê${ K G »L¼ » ´${ KÉ oZ�§ÌRbpknfZa^f�®Vack w Y\oZ�Vm ³m´µ³ÁÄ�Ä º�´�·�·�ÀW� ¸,³m´µ³Á¿�¿ ¸¹³m´�À�¿�Ä ³m´�»�¿�Â� ¸¹³m´µ³ÁÄ�ÀG »L¼ ¸${ ^ K G »L¼ H$´ » K G »L¼ ´${$ê K G »L¼ H Q { K G »L¼ ê Ë ê K G »L¼ ´ »Al KÆ-�Zk`Y\[^�eknsMbd[}ôV]`f�bd[co�sö°��¬±L»'knmpb º�³R��¿�ÄÁ¶+°Çøbùä³m´Ç¶�³<± º�º���À�È�¿+°Çøbùú³m´Ç¶�ÄÁ±Æ-®Vm`� ·�·�À ·�·�À ·�·�À ·�·�À ·�·�À ·�·�À

Page 34: 9= . >@?A . B C D1 E › files › docs › colloqpapers › w05 › Sc… · 0 (* %-$#+1 $3245$768&3 9:;&< # 9=" . >@?A . B C" D1 E FHGJILKMGON5PRQLSTPRQ UMSVK W;XZY\[^]`_Vacbd_eY\fZahgjilknmpo_eY\]

���������������� !���#"$ %� Æ °

`5UWDKD�L�@8:�r�B�\�B~_=@S:�\A<!_�@SDK^ar=DBZO�>A\NT]@�RA<i<�BZ\AUKDpq,\�>�<�BZDB f DW<iF!RY@Sr=\ f :�>�O=@�>5L�UWIe>�\�k�JDW\A@=c*`5_=UWDK<�>�_�<]F�@P<��]F�UK<�O�>t@SO¬`�<!B�DW>A_¢RY<!T]B�UKO=\j\YUKLSO=Up�zF�BZO�>!c*UW>�^=<!F�RA<!B�\A<�\�UKO

\YUK³!<�B f Up>,BZIe>A<!R]F!@SOM>�RY@SDKDWUKO=L3IQ@SR]F!RY@SrèF%_=@SUWF!<ZkÊ¡N_=<�IhB�F�>]>A_zBZ>]`�<!B�DW>A_�qX_=@S:�\A<�w_=@�DK^=\�LSUpvS<[Bt\AT]B�DWDK<!Ror=RA@Sr#@SR�>�UK@�O]@�I�>�_=<�UKR.`b<�B�Dp>�_VUWO]L�UWIe>�\.>A_zB�OV^�@�r#@P@SRY<!R�_=@S:�\A<�w_=@�DK^=\�cM\A:=LSL�<!\Y>A\b>A_zBZ>.>�_�UK<�v�<!\bB�RA<5O=@Z>b\�>�<!B�DKUWO=Li^=:=<5>�@j<!OMv�q]B�O=^~>�_=BZ>�vPUWF�>AUKT8\�B�RA<O=@Z>jLSUWv|UKO�L?^=:=<~>�@�B�DW>ARA:=UW\AT�@SRiUKO�<!á�:zB�DWUW>$q3B�v�<!RA\YUK@SO�k8¶�>�\Y:=r=r#@SRY>A\j>A_=<�^�q|OzB�T8UKFDWUKT8UW>�<�^Pw$F�@ST8T]Up>�T�<!OM>NT8@P^�<!D�UKO�`5_=UWF%_3IhB�RAT8<!RY\JLSUpvS<�LSUpIe>�\[UKOs@SRY^=<!R[>�@?DKUWT]Up>N>�_=<B�T8@S:=OM>5\�>�@SDW<!O?IQRA@ST�>�_=<�T�k

¡N_=<�@SO=DpqJvZB�RYUB f DW<!\�`5_�UKF%_�DK@S\Y<.\AUKL�O=UW�zF!B�O=F�<�B�RA<.v|UKDWDB�LS<yT]<�^=UBZOiDB�O=^|w$_=@SDW^=UKO�LS\B�O�^�>�_�<�O�:=T f <!R[@�I._=@S:�\A<!_�@SDK^=\[UKO�B,& Þ Ñ8T²R�B�^�UK:=\�k���Ie>�<�RJF!@�O�>ARA@SDWDKUWO=L�IQ@SR�F!RA@�rF%_=@�UKF!<ZcZ_�@S:=\A<�_=@SDW^=\*UKOiv|UKDKDKB�LS<�\�`5UW>A_�DKB�RAL�<.T]<�^=UB�OiDKB�O=^Pw�_=@SDW^=UKO=L�\dB�O=^�_=@S:�\A<!_�@SDK^=\UWOH^=<!O=\Y<!DpqHr�@�r=:=DB}>�<!^ÔBZRA<�BZ\~^=@3O=@�>�LSUpvS<,\YUKLSO�UW�zF!B�OM>�DWq¬IQ<�`b<!R�LSUpIe>�\�>A_zB�OH@�>A_=<!R_=@�:=\A<�_=@SDK^�\!k�¡N_=UW\jUK\ f <!F!B�:=\A<�>�_�@S\A<~_=@�:=\A<�_=@SDK^�\�r�DB�OM>�<�^E\AUKL�O=UW�zF!B�OM>�Dpq�IQ<�`�<�R�@ZI>A_=<j<�B�\YUKDWqV\Y>A<�B�DKB f DK<JF!RA@�r=\�B�O=^1>�_zBZ>5UW\N`5_zBZ>5F�BZ:=\A<�\[>�_�<!TÖ>A@8L�UWvS<iIQ<�`�<�R�L�UWIe>�\�k

¡N_=<tTVB�UWO1RA<!\Y:=DW>A\�`5_�UKF%_�_�<!DK^ f <�IQ@SRY<tF�@SOM>�RA@�DKDKUWO=L�IQ@SR5F!RY@Sr�F%_�@SUKF�<t\�>�UKDWDd_=@SDW^dkØ�@S:=\A<�_=@SDW^=\J`5UW>A_s�z<!DW^=\J`5_=UWF%_3O=@Zw�@SO=<�rzBZ\A\A<�\i\Y>AUKDKD�LSUpvS<�IQ<�`�<�R;LSUWIe>A\!c�<�©Pr�<�RAUW<!O=F�<DW<!\A\5>�_�<�Ie>�c#B�O�^�>�RY:=\Y>[T8@SRA<ZkNØ[@S:�\A<!_�@SDK^=\�UKOa>�_=<�\�BZT]<iv|UKDWDB�LS<;`5Up>�_aF!DW@S\A<jIhB�T8UKDWqT8<!T f <!RY\�\�>�UKDWD�LSUWv�<V\AUWLSO=Up�zF�B�OM>ADWq3IQ<�`b<!R�LSUWIe>A\!co<ª©Pr�<�RAUK<�O=F!<?DW<!\Y\�>�_=<�Ie>�c.BZO=^g>�RY:=\Y>T8@SRA<Zk]�[\�>A_=<!RY<VBZRA<�TVBZO�qsRA<�BZ\A@SO=\j`5_Mq¬r�<�@Sr=DK<�LSUpvS<�LSUpIe>�\!c*@SO�DWq3@SO�<8@ZI�`5_=UWF%_UW\�>�_=<a^=<!\YUKRY<1>A@EDKUKT8UW>t>�_=<�Ie>�c�>�_=<?IhB�F�>8>A_zBZ>�>�_�<aF�@P<��8F!UK<�OM>V@SOH>A_=<�O�:=T f <�R8@ZIF�DK@S\Y<�RY<!DKBZ>�UpvS<!\5UWOa>A_=<�v|UWDKDBZLS<;UKO1>�_�<tLSUpIe>Yw�LSUWv|UKO�L�<!á�:zBZ>AUK@SOaUK\5\YUKLSO=Up�zF�BZO�>�UW\�á�:=Up>�<F�@SOMvPUWO=F!UWO=L=k

� ¤Ð/8)34�ò�23÷76!/8)

«5:=R�BZD�>A_=<�Ie>tUKO¢xoBZR�B�LS:=B�q¬UW\tO=@Z>�F!B�RARYUK<!^¢@S:�> f qgBZO=@SOMq|T]@S:�\�B�L�<!OM>�\�k�n�B�RYT]<�RA\F�DB�UWT >�@CG�O=@�`�`5_=@CUK\]\Y>A<�B�DWUKO=LgIQRY@STÈ>�_=<�T BZO=^Ù_zB�vS<s^�<!\AUWLSO=<�^¤BC\Yq|\Y>A<!T @ZIUWO�IQ@SRAT]B�D=\AB�O=F�>�UK@�O=\�BZO=^,RA<�`uBZRA^=\�>�@�DWUKT8UW>7>A_=<[B�T]@�:=OM>�@�I�>�_=<�Ie>b>A_=<�q8<�©Pr#<!RYUK<!O�F!<�k¶;_=B�v�<VDKB�UK^3@S:P>�B1^�q|OzB�T8UKF8DKUWT]Up>�<!^|w$F!@�T]T8UW>AT8<�OM>JT8@P^�<!D.UKOE`5_=UWF%_CB1r�@�>A<!OM>�UKB�D>A_=UK<�INF�B�O�O=@�>�F�@ST8T]Up>�>A@sRA<�IQR�B�UWO¢IQRY@ST \Y>�<!B�DKUWO=L=k1�ÐIhBZRAT8<!Rj`5UKDKD.>A_|:�\�LSUWv�<V_=UWTLSUpIe>�\�c*B�O=^¬r=RA@ST8UK\Y<�_=UWT¥F!@SOM>AUKO�:=<!^¬LSUpIe>�\iUKO3>A_=<~IQ:�>�:=RY<�UWIb_=<�DKUKT8UW>A\[_�UK\jDK<�vS<!D.@ZI>A_=<�Ie>u>A@�\A@�T]<iBZF!F!<�r�>%B f DK<;DW<�v�<!Dµko¡N_=UK\uT8@|^=<!D�q|UK<!DW^=\uO=<�`�r�RA<!^�UKF�>AUK@SO�\uB f @�vS<iB�O�^f <�q�@SO=^H>�_=@�\A<1@�I[Bs@SO=<ªw$r#<!RAUW@P^C��<!F%GZ<!RAUKB�O�T]@|^=<!D�`5UW>A_ÔBsR�BZ>AUK@SOzBZD�B�O�@SOMqPT8@S:=\>A_=UK<�I¹kû¡N_=<!\Y<gRA<�\A:=Dp>�\aB�DW\A@ÔF!@SOM>AR�B�\�>�`5Up>�_¤TVBZO�qèT]@|^=<!DW\?@�I�IhB�UKRYO=<!\Y\�BZO=^£L�UWIe><ª©�F%_=B�O=LS<tUKO1`5_=UKF%_�UKO=F�RA<�BZ\A<!^a>�RY:=\Y>JUK\�B�\A\Y@PF�UBZ>A<!^1`5UW>A_�T8@SRA<jLSUpIe>Yw�LSUWv|UKO�L~R�BZ>A_=<!R>A_zB�O1DK<�\A\!k

¯[\YUKO=LaB�OE:=O�:=\Y:zB�D�O=<�` ^zBZ>�B?\A<�>iIQRY@ST�RY:=R�BZD.xoB�RAB�LS:zB�q3¶�>�<�\Y>i`5_=<�>�_=<�R�>A_=UK\

Page 35: 9= . >@?A . B C D1 E › files › docs › colloqpapers › w05 › Sc… · 0 (* %-$#+1 $3245$768&3 9:;&< # 9=" . >@?A . B C" D1 E FHGJILKMGON5PRQLSTPRQ UMSVK W;XZY\[^]`_Vacbd_eY\fZahgjilknmpo_eY\]

���������������� !���#"$ %� Æ Þ

T8@P^�<!DJ_=B�\?r=RA<�^=UKF�>�UpvS<3r#@Ì`b<!R1@�vS<�RaBC@SO=<�w�r�<�RAUW@P^ÙT8@P^�<!D[`5Up>�_¤B�O¦B�O�@SOMqPT8@S:=\>A_=UK<�I¹ko¡N_=<[^zBZ>%Bj\A<�>uUWO=F!DW:=^=<!\�<�©|>A<!O=\YUWvS<[UKO�IQ@�RAT]BZ>�UW@SO~@SO�>�_=<�Ie>�<ª©�r#<!RYUK<�O=F!<�^dc=LSUpIe>�\LSUpvS<�Odc�B�O=^8\A:=R�vS<�q�T]<!B�\A:=RY<!\�@�I#>�RY:=\Y>!cPBZ\�`b<!DWDzB�\�rzB�O�<!Dz^zBZ>�B;@SO8rzB�\Y>�r�RA@|^=:=F�>AUK@SO^=<�F!UW\AUK@�O=\!kÔ¶$OèBZ^=^=UW>AUK@SO�c�Up>�UKO=F�DK:=^�<!\�T]<!B�\A:�RA<!\�@�I[>�RY:=\Y>$`b@SRY>A_=UKO�<!\A\�c�>�RY:=\Y>!cuB�O�^RYUK\AG8B�vS<�RA\YUK@SOVIQRY@ST�Bt\Y<�>N@�Id<!F!@�O=@ST8UKF�<�©Pr�<�RAUWT]<�O�>A\uF�BZRARAUW<!^]@S:�>�`5Up>�_8>�_=<[\A:=R�vS<�qRY<!\Ar#@SO=^�<!OM>�\�k�¡N_�UK\�<ª©Pr�<�RAUKT8<!OM>�B�D�^=BZ>%B�r=RA@�v|UK^=<�\�O=@�v�<!D�F�@SOM>�RY@SDK\�`5_=UKF%_?BZDKDK@�`�T]<>A@8r=B�RY>AUB�DWDWq8@�vS<!RYF!@ST8<j@ST8UW>A>A<!^,vZB�RYUB f DW< f UKB�\!k

¶$OERA:=RAB�D7xyB�R�BZLS:zB�qs>�_�<~r=RA<�^=UKF�>�UK@�O=\;@�I�>�_�<~DKUKT8UW>A<!^Pw�F!@ST8T8UW>�T�<�O�>5T8@|^=<!DoB�RA<\Y:=r=r#@SRY>A<!^dk1Ø�@S:=\A<�_=@SDW^=\�`5Up>�_¢T]@SRY<�F!DK@�\A<8RA<!DKBZ>�UpvS<�\�DWUWv|UKO�LaUWO¬>A_=<8\�B�T8<8v|UWDKDBZLS<LSUpvS<,DW<!\Y\�LSUWIe>A\!c.F�@SOM>�R�BZRYq¬>�@s`5_zBZ>�@�O=<,T8UKLS_M>�<ª©Pr�<�F�>�k¬¡N_=<�\A<1_=@S:=\Y<!_=@�DK^=\~LSUpvS<DW<!\A\�LSUpIe>�\ f <!F!B�:=\A<5>�_�<�q�G�O=@�`è>�_=BZ>.>�_=<�UKR.IhB�T8UKDpqtT8<!T f <�RA\�B�RA<5DW<!\A\�DWUKG�<�DWqt>�@j\Y>A<�B�DIQRY@ST >A_=<!Tac�B�O=^�\Y@j>A_=<�q�^=@jO=@�>.O=<�<!^�>�@j<!OM>AUKF!<u>A_=<!T B�`�B�q�IQRA@�T >A_=<�Ie> f q~LSUpv|UKO=L>A_=<!T�LSUWIe>A\!k.Ø�@S:=\Y<!_=@SDW^=\uIQRA@�T�`5_=UWF%_?UW>�UK\�T8@SRY<J^=Up�]F�:=DW>b>�@~\�>�<�BZD�LSUpvS<;DW<!\A\�LSUWIe>A\!c<ª©�r#<!RYUK<�O=F!<8DK<�\A\;>�_�<�Ie>�c�B�O�^¬>ARA:=\�>tT8@SRY<�k�¶�F!@SO�F!DK:�^=<~>�_zBZ>iIhBZRAT8<!RA\iUWO¬xoB�RAB�LS:zB�q^=@�:=\Y<tL�UWv|UKO=L�BZO=^?>�_=<jr=RY@ST]UW\A<i@�I�IQ:�>A:=RA<jLSUpvPUWO=L�B�\�B~T]<!B�O=\5@�IyDKUWT]Up>�UKO�L�>A_=<�Ie>!k

Page 36: 9= . >@?A . B C D1 E › files › docs › colloqpapers › w05 › Sc… · 0 (* %-$#+1 $3245$768&3 9:;&< # 9=" . >@?A . B C" D1 E FHGJILKMGON5PRQLSTPRQ UMSVK W;XZY\[^]`_Vacbd_eY\fZahgjilknmpo_eY\]

���������������� !���#"$ %� Æ �

� � ÷76�)�� �]�gôi-�6�¡ ôi),+7ö�ò8ùX-�23÷y+���öt+.úsô;-¤+7úsö�) ð123-�£ ô[ñ ùX-�23÷y+

¶$O�>�_=<bTVB�UWOi>�<�©|>o¶�:=\A<�^�>�_=<bT]<!B�\A:�RA<�@�Iz\A<�DWIw�RA<!r#@SR�>�<!^�>�RY:=\Y>�IQRA@STÊ>A_=<�\Y:=RYv�<�q�B�\7B^=<�r�<�O=^=<�O�>�vZB�RAUKB f DW<�k�¶$O�>A_=UK\�BZr=r�<�O=^=Um©~¶�:=\A<N>�_�<�<ª©Pr�<�RAUKT8<!OM>�B�D=T8<�B�\Y:=RA<5@�I�>�RY:=\Y>UWO=\Y>A<�B�^dkE¡N_=UW\~RA<�\Y>�RYUKF�>�\�>A_=<?O�:=T f <!R~@�I5@ f \A<!R�vZBZ>�UW@SO=\�>�@�>�_=< ����� RA<!\Yr�@�O=^=<!OM>A\`5_=@�rzB�R�>�UWF!UKr=BZ>�<�^ÙUKOÙ>�_=<¬<�©Pr#<!RYUKT8<!OM>�\�k�¡N_�UK\aB�DK\Y@�B�DKDW@Ì`5\?:�\1>A@XRY<!T8@�vS<3>�_=<UWO=^=UKF!BZ>�@�R�vZB�RAUKB f DK<;IQ@�R�^�UK^=Od§ >�r=DB�q?UWO�LSB�T]<�\!k��J\�\A<�<!O�UWO�¡yB f DW< í c�B�DW>A_=@S:=L�_�B�DWD@�I#>�_�<�r�RA<�v|UW@S:=\ADpq~\AUWLSO=Up�zF�B�OM>.vZB�RYUB f DW<!\.UWO�>A_=<N>�RY:=\Y>�RA<�LSRA<�\A\YUK@SO8DK@S\Y<5\AUKL�O=UW�zF!B�O=F�<�cT8@S\Y>u@�Iy>A_=<iRA<�\A:=Dp>�\NIQ@S:=O�^aUWO,>�_=<jT]B�UKO]>�<�©|>�F!@�O�>AUKO�:=<;>A@8_�@SDK^,IQ@SRu>A_=<iLSUpIe>�\NB�O�^>A_=<�Ie>[rzB�R�>[@ZIo>�_�<t\�qP\�>�<�T�kN¡N_=<t@SO=Dpq?\AUWLSO=UW�=F�B�OM>�r=RA<�^=UKF�>�@SR5@�Iy>�RY:=\Y>[UKO1>�_=<j>�RY:=\Y><ª©�r#<!RYUKT8<!OM>tUK\j>�_=<8\AUW³!<8@�Iu>�_�< f <�>tUKOE>�_=<]RAUK\YG3<�©Pr#<!RAUWT]<�OM>�k?¡N_=UW\tF�@SRARY<!\Ar#@SO=^�\`5Up>�_sRY<!\A:�DW>�\;IQ@�:=O=^3UKO3ÓPF%_=<!F%_M>A<!RV�µ&�ÑSÑ °�  \Y_=@�`5UKO=L,>A_zBZ>ir=DKB�q�UWOs>�_=<t>�RA:�\Y>iLMBZT]<B�F�>�:zBZDKDWq]T8<�B�\Y:=RA<�\[B�F!@�T f UKO=BZ>�UW@SO,@�I�>�RY:=\Y>[B�O=^aRAUW\AGVB�v�<!RY\AUK@�Odk

��@�>A_Ù>�_=<sIhB�F�>,>�_=BZ>?\AUWLSO=Up�zF�B�OM>?r�RA<!^�UKF�>A@SRA\?@ZIt\Y<!DpIw$RA<�r�@�RY>�<�^è>�RY:=\Y>aB�RY<3O=@�>\YUKLSO=Up�zF�BZO�>�UKOÔr=RA<�^=UKF�>�UWO=Ls>�RY:=\Y>8UKOH>A_=<1<�©Pr�<�RAUWT]<�O�>!c�BZO=^H>�_=<?IhB�F�>~>�_zBZ>~>A_=<­þ�w\�>%BZ>AUK\Y>AUKF�`5_=<!OH:�\AUKO�Ls<�©Pr#<!RAUWT]<�OM>%B�D�>�RY:=\Y>�UK\�T�:=F%_C_=UWLS_=<!R�B�O=^g>A_=<V_Mq|r#@�>�_=<�\AUW\>A_zBZ>�B�DWD�>�_=<�T8@ST8<!OM>*F!@SO�^=UW>AUK@SO=\�_�@SDK^jF�BZO f <�RY< Ç <�F�>�<�^dcSBZRA<�O=@�>*:=O�<�©Pr�<�F�>A<!^�LSUpvS<�O>A_=<tO�<�`®T8<�B�\Y:=RA<t@�I7>�RY:=\Y> f <!UKO�LV:=\Y<!^dk5¡N_=<t<�©Pr�<�RAUWT]<�O�>[T8<�B�\Y:=RA<�\JLS<�O=<!RAB�DKUW³!<!^>ARA:=\�>[UWO1B�O�B�O=@SOMq|T]@�:=\5\A<�>Y>�UWO=L~`5UW>�_1O=@�RY<!F!@�:=RA\Y<�>A@�IQ:P>�:=RY<�r�:=O=UK\Y_=T8<!OM>�\�kb¡N_=<\Y:=RYv�<�q?á�:=<�\Y>�UW@SO1B�\YG|\u`5_�<�>�_�<!RN@SRbO=@�>5BtIhBZRAT8<!Rb>ARA:=\�>�\N_=UW\bIQ<�DKDK@�`Ùv|UKDWDB�L�<!RA\�ko¡N_=<IhB�RYT]<�RJG�O=@�`5\j_=UK\[vPUWDKDKB�LS<�w�TVB}>�<!\[B�O=^3UWOs`5_=UKF%_E\YUW>�:=BZ>�UW@SO=\J_�<~F�B�O¬B�O=^3F!B�OEO=@�>>ARA:=\�>N<�B�F%_?@ZI�>�_=<�TÖB�O�^,>�_=<;r�:=O=UK\Y_=T8<!OM>�\u_�<J`�@�:=DK^ f <iB f DK<[>A@�UKT8r#@S\A<�@SO?<�BZF%_@�Io>�_=<�T�kNϤ_=<�RA<�BZ\J>�_=<tO�:=T f <!RJ@ZI7qS<!B�RA\iB8_=@S:=\Y<!_=@�DK^s_zBZ\JDKUpvS<�^�UKOa>�_=<�v|UKDKDKB�LS<ZcB�O�^�`5_=<�>�_=<�R;@SR�O=@�>J>A_=<�qa_zB�v�<~B8�z<�DK^�`5_�UKF%_sO=@]@SO=<trzB�\A\Y<!\;r�RA<!^�UKF�>JRA<�DBZ>AUK@SOzBZD>ARA:=\�> f <�>$`b<!<!O,v|UWDKDBZLS<�w�TVBZ>A<!\�cS>�_=<�q]^�@�O=@�>�<�É�<!F�>uLS<�O=<!RAB�DKUW³!<!^VB�O=@SOMq|T8@S:=\b>ARA:=\�>�kß;Os>�_�<~@�>�_=<�Ri_zB�O=^�cd>�_=<�RA<�B�RY<�\A:=RY<!Dpqs@ST8UW>Y>�<!^�v�BZRAUB f DK<�\;\A:=F%_¢B�\;\Y@PF�UB�DyO=@SRYT]\B�O�^H:=r f RYUKO=LSUWO=L�`5_=UWF%_Ô^=<�>A<!RAT8UKO�<VLS<�O=<!RAB�DKUW³!<!^C>ARA:=\�> f :�>~O�@�>�>�_�<?T�:=F%_HT8@SRA<\Yr�<�F!UW�=F�RY<!DKBZ>�UW@SOzB�D#>�RA:�\Y>�k

� � ÷76!)�� � 6�ò!ò!ö���ô õè6�aôi0 ���Hô;45+7÷

¶$O1>�_=<�B�O=B�DWq|\AUW\NUKO,>A_=<tT]B�UWOV>�<ª©P>�v|UKDWDB�LS<���©P<!^�<�É�<!F�>A\�`b<!RY<tUWO=F!DW:=^=<�^dk.�J\N>�_�<!RA<B�RY< ��� v|UKDWDB�LS<�\��hB�O=^3>�_�RA<!<~<�á�:zBZ>�UW@SO=\   c�UKO�F!DK:�^=UKO=L]vPUWDKDKB�LS<j��©P<!^¬<�É�<!F�>A\j:=\A<�\�:�rvZB�DW:zB f DW<�^�<!LSRY<!<!\J@�I.IQRA<�<!^=@ST�UWOsBV\YTVB�DWD�^zBZ>�B]\A<�>�k;ßiO�>�_=<t@�>�_=<�RJ_zBZO=^dc�Up>JUW\[@ZIUWO�>A<!RY<!\Y>~>A@3\A<�<?_=@�`Ð>A_=<?RA<�\A:=Dp>�\~F%_zB�O�LS<,`5_=<!O�UKO�F!DK:�^=UKO=L�vPUWDKDKB�LS<���©P<!^Ô<�É�<!F�>�\!k¶�I�¶5UKO�F!DK:�^=<tv|UKDWDB�L�<j�P©�<�^E<�É�<!F�>A\!c�¶5F�BZO3O=@,DK@�O=LS<!R[:=\A<~r=B�\Y>;v|UWDKDBZLS<jDK<�v�<!Dyr=RAUWF!<!\

Page 37: 9= . >@?A . B C D1 E › files › docs › colloqpapers › w05 › Sc… · 0 (* %-$#+1 $3245$768&3 9:;&< # 9=" . >@?A . B C" D1 E FHGJILKMGON5PRQLSTPRQ UMSVK W;XZY\[^]`_Vacbd_eY\fZahgjilknmpo_eY\]

���������������� !���#"$ %� Æ í

¡yB f DW< í çi3qtpypn ~:�0{Wn �@qAs �Av�s�{ �Av¤k¥v�z§�§¦S{y�¥nYs�{Ính¨�}on pv:n z���n u¹¦������������ �"!�#$&% ���(')�+*,'-!/.10/'5jl��v�z¥�2�õ�î� ����@|@�>A\Y>�RAB�r=r#<!^�F!DW:=\Y>A<!RA<�^è\Y>�B�O=^zBZRA^�<!RARY@SRA\8UKOrzBZRA<!OM>A_=<!\YUK\!k£«�w � Ñ8�,co«m«!w �MÞ �,czBZO=^�«m«m«�w �S� ��\YUKLSO�UW�zF!B�OM>�k¯43 XQ°À»²£ek`�°b&± ¯+3 XQ°½Ã-[c�R[^seX²± »'Y\_4mpb ¯+3 XQ°À»²£4k`��b&± ¯43 XQ°½Ã-[c�R[^seX²± »'Y\_4mpb

x k`b ³m´Ëº�ºrÀ ¸,³m´µ³Á·� ³m´�·�³Á¿W�'�G »L¼ l$l ê K G »L¼ »�QF^ K G »L¼ »'^�Q KÅ53 Æ-s4k¯·JfZm\mpknml¿�[ckna^� ¸¹³m´Ç¶DÂhº;� ¸,³m´�¿�ÄÁ¶�� ³m´µ³�³ÁÈ ¸¹³m´Ç¶DÂ<·W� ¸,³m´Ç¶�·�Â�'� ³m´µ³ÁÄ�³G »L¼ Ë$Ë ´ K G »L¼ ´ Ë ´ K G »L¼ ´ Ë�» K G »L¼ ´'¸ Q K G »L¼ ´${ l K G »L¼ ´ l�» KÉ �;��ml[^ss·�Ä�³¤t ilfZ�4[¢_4m ³m´µ³�Âhº ¸,³m´µ³©ºr¿ ³m´µ³ÁÄmºG »L¼ » ê l K G »L¼ » { ^ K G »L¼ » ´'¸ KÉ W;�4_Vacb¹Ê§fZacknm ¸¹³m´�·�³ÁÄ ³m´�·�À�¿ � ¸¹³m´Ëº�º�º ¸¹³m´�À�·Á¶ �'� ³m´Ëº.²¶ ¸¹³m´ËºrÄ�¿G »L¼ l�QF^ K G »L¼ lQË ´ K G »L¼ l { ^ K G »L¼ l ê Ë K G »L¼ l { Ë K G »L¼ l ´ » K¿VfZtu[^ac{sÌR[c«`k ¸¹³m´µ³©ºrÄ ¸,³m´µ³�Â<À ¸¹³m´µ³<¶DÂG »L¼ l�^ ´ K G »L¼ l$l ê K G »L¼ l$l { K¯43 XQ°�Í�knfZacbd£(± ³m´Ëº�ºr¿ ³m´�À�Ä�³y�'�'� ³m´Ëº�ºrÄ ³m´µ³Á»� ³m´�À�³©º;�'�'� ³m´ËºrÀ�·G »L¼ l ´$´ K G »L¼ » ¸ Q K G »L¼ » ¸ ^ K G »L¼ l$l�^ K G »L¼ »'^ H K G »L¼ »'^'^ KÉ w a 3 mpk¯ilkna^f�bd[c�Zknml[¢sÏÎ�[^a¢a^f�XZk ¸¹³m´µ³�²¶ ¸,³m´Ëº�³©º;� ¸¹³m´µ³�³� ¸¹³m´µ³©ºr» ¸¹³m´µ³ÁÄmº ¸¹³m´µ³�³ÁÈG »L¼ »�Q H K G »L¼ » ê'H K G »L¼ » H Ë K G »L¼ »�Q ´ K G »L¼ » ê l K G »L¼ » H$ê KÐ knf�Y�ml[^sÏÎ-[^a^a^f�XZk ³m´µ³�³Á¿ ³m´µ³Á·mº;�'� ¸¹³m´µ³�³<¶G »L¼ »Al ´ K G »L¼ »Al�» K G »L¼ »Al�» KÎ-[^a^a ʧkn�4[^fZs ¯ fZs4�ÑÆ��;sekn� ¸¹³m´�·�·�Ä ¸,³m´�·�ÈÁ¶ ³m´�·�·�ÈG »L¼ Ë {$ê K G »L¼ ´$ê'¸ K G »L¼ ´ » ¸ KÅ kn[cX�£M® 3 Yl»+Y�_4mpb­� 3 Ydbd£4[¢seknmdm ¸¹³m´�»�Â<¿ ³m´ËºJ¶�¿ ¸¹³m´�È�»�¿ ¸¹³m´ÃÂ�Â<È ³m´�¿�Ä�Ä ¸¹³m´Ëº.Â�ÂG lC¼ H l ¸ K G lC¼ {'H l K G lC¼ ´ » { K G lC¼ ê »'» K G lC¼ {${$ê K G lC¼ ´ »�Q KÒ 3 �_Î-[^a^a¢f�XZk-�;knac�§[¢s w £M_4Y\]\£ ¸¹³m´µ³Á·�Â� ¸,³m´µ³©º. ¸¹³m´µ³©º�ºG »L¼ »Al ´ K G »L¼ »'» ¸ K G »L¼ »Al$l KÓ [^a 3 tBk`bpk`Y\mLb 3 · 3 a¢[^]�k ¸¹³m´Ëº�³Á· ³m´µ³©º�º ¸¹³m´µ³Á·�ÈG »L¼ »'^'^ K G »L¼ » H$ê K G »L¼ » H$´ KÉ 3 �§ÌRbpknfZa^f�®Vack w Y 3 �Vm ³m´ÃÂ<È�À º�´ÃÂ<»�ÈW�'�'� ³m´ÃÂ�Â<· ³m´�À�¿�À ³m´�»�¿mº;� ³m´ÃÂ�Â<·G »L¼ ¸ Q ´ K G »L¼ ê'H'¸ K G »L¼ H ^Al K G »L¼ Q'Q ´ K G »L¼ ê » H K G »L¼ H l ´ KÆ-�Zk`Y\[^�eknsMbd[}ôV]`f�bd[ 3 sö°��¬±L»'knmpb ºJ¶M��È�³Á·�°ÇøÏùä³m´�»�¿Á± ºr¿¥��»Á¶�¶Ñ°ÇøÏùä³m´�»�ÄÁ±Æ-®Vm`� ºrÈ�È ºrÈ�È ºrÈ�È ºrÈ�È ºrÈ�È ºrÈ�È

Page 38: 9= . >@?A . B C D1 E › files › docs › colloqpapers › w05 › Sc… · 0 (* %-$#+1 $3245$768&3 9:;&< # 9=" . >@?A . B C" D1 E FHGJILKMGON5PRQLSTPRQ UMSVK W;XZY\[^]`_Vacbd_eY\fZahgjilknmpo_eY\]

���������������� !���#"$ %� Æ �

¡yB f DW< � ç¹i3qtpypynU~:�0{Wn �4qts¹�Av�s�{ �Av#k¥v�z§�¥¦t{y�¥nYs�{Nn©¨/}onYp�v:n z���n u¹¦���zlu�{Wpjl��{Mj��&v�z§��õ�í� 6 $ '-798 $ *:*;�=<>�@?A� �B�C�EDF�HG/'I0KJ���@|@�>�\�>�R�BZr=r�<�^~F!DW:=\Y>A<!RA<�^�\Y>%BZO=^zB�RY^~<!RARY@SRA\UWOar=B�RA<�O�>A_=<!\YUK\�k£«!w � Ñ8�,c¬«®«�w �MÞ �?c=B�O=^�«m«m«�w �S� �û\AUWLSO=UW�=F�B�OM>�k¯43 XQ°À»²£ek`�°b&± ¯+3 XQ°½Ã-[^�¥[^s4X²± »'Y\_4mpbÅ53 Æ-sek¯·�fZmdmdknml¿�[ckna^� ¸¹³m´ÃÂ<·mº ¸�º�´ËºrÄ�» �'�'� ³m´�À�À�³G »L¼ Ë H Ë K G »L¼ ´ ^ ê K G »L¼ { l ´ KÉ W��4_4a^bãÊCfZacknm ¸¹³m´ÃÂhºrÄW�'� ³m´�·mºrÀ ¸¹³m´µ³�Â�ÂG »L¼ l�QYl K G »L¼ l H » K G »L¼ »'^'^ K¯43 XQ°�Í�knfZacbd£(± ¸¹³m´Ëº�³�³ ³m´Ëºr»�À ¸¹³m´µ³ÁÈ�ÀG »L¼ l ê'H K G »L¼ l { Q K G »L¼ »'^ ê KÉ w a 3 mpk¯i²kna¢f�bd[c�Zknm²[^sÏÎ-[^a^a^f�XZk ¸¹³m´µ³ÁÄÁ¶ ¸,³m´µ³ÁÄ� ³m´µ³ÁÈ�»W�'�G »L¼ »�Q H K G »L¼ »�QF^ K G »L¼ »�Ë�» KÅ kn[cX�£M® 3 Y²»'Y\_4mdb­� 3 Ydbd£4[^seknm\m ³m´�ÄÁ¶�¶ ³m´µ³Á»�¿ ³m´�¿�»�¿G { ¼ ´ ^Al K G lC¼ ¸ Q { K G lC¼ »Al ´ KÉ 3 �§Ì¥bpknfZa^f�®Tack w Y 3 �Vm º�´ÃÂ<À�È º�´�»�³� �'� ³m´ÃÂ<·mºG lC¼ »�Q H K G »L¼ ^ ´ l K G »L¼ Ë H'H KÆ��Zk`Y�[^�eknsMbd[}ôV]`f�bd[ 3 sö°��¬±L»'knmpb º���À�È�»+°Çøbùä³m´�·�»Á±Æ�®Tm`� ºJ¶�¶ ºJ¶�¶ ºJ¶�¶B�\tUKO=\�>�RY:=T]<�OM>�\!k��J\�>�_=<,r�DB�OM>�UWO=La@�I5LSRA<�<!OCT]B�O�:=RY<,B�DW@SO=<8UK\�O=@�>~B�\Y>�RY@SO=LsUWOPw\�>�RA:�T]<�O�>!c=¶�:=\A< f @�>A_,>�_=<ir=DKB�OM>�UWO=L�@�IyB�LSRY<!<!O?T]B�O�:=RY<iB�O=^1rzB�\�>NF!RY@Sr1F%_=@SUWF!<iB�\UWO=\Y>ARA:=T8<!OM>�\t_=<!RY<�ka¶iUKO=F�DK:=^�<8>A_=<V\AB�T]<]<�©Pr=DKB�OzBZ>A@SRYq3vZB�RYUB f DW<!\tB�\�UKO¢>A_=<VRYUKLS_M>_zBZO=^V\YUK^=<5F!@�DK:=T8O=\�@�Id¡yB f DW< � k7¡N_=<[RA<!\Y:=DW>A\bUWO�¡oB f DK< � B�RY<N`�<!B�G�<�R�>�_zBZO f <�IQ@SRY<�cf :P>[>A_=<�T]B�UKO1>�RY<!O=^�\J\Y>AUKDWD�_=@SDK^�k5Ø[@S:=\Y<!_=@�DK^=\5`5UW>A_��z<�DK^=\[@�ɬ@�I.T]B�UKO?IQ@|@�>�rzB}>�_=\\�>�UKDWDy<ª©Pr�<�RAUK<�O=F!<�DW<!\A\;>A_=<�Ie>!cdLSUpvS<�IQ<�`b<!RjLSUpIe>�\�cdB�O=^3>ARA:=\�>jT]@SRY<�L�_=@�:=\A<�_=@SDK^�\;`5UW>�_T8@SRA<1F�DK@S\Y<�RA<�DBZ>AUWv�<!\8DKUWv|UWO=LEUKOX>A_=<!UWR~vPUWDKDKB�LS<?LSUpvS<�IQ<�`�<�RVLSUpIe>�\�cu<�©Pr#<!RAUW<!O=F�<�DW<!\A\>A_=<�Ie>!c7B�O=^¬>�RY:=\Y>�T]@SRY<�L.BZO=^C_=@S:�\A<!_�@SDK^=\tr=DBZO�>AUKO=L1T8@SRA<8<�BZ\AUKDpqE\Y>A<�B�DKB f DK<�F�RA@Sr=\LSUpvS<aT]@�RA<aLSUWIe>A\!kÙ¡N_=UW\]UW\]RY<�B�\Y\A:=RYUKO=LC<�v|UK^=<�O=F!<a>�_zBZ>8>�_�<��zO=^�UKO=LS\]UKO�r=RA<�v|UK@S:=\\Y<!F�>AUK@SO�\�@ZIy>A_=UK\NrzBZr�<�R[BZRA<jO=@�>5^=:�<j>A@�:=O=@ f \Y<!R�vS<!^�vPUWDKDKB�LS<;<�É�<�F�>�\�k

¤ ���4�ò�23036�)�� +7úsô MONÏ��N�P�QARSQ TVUXWYRSQ[Z�UO\^]YR

_[`=acb�d[egf=aFhIikj�eEala^`nm�ipoqosr�t�a^huip`veEf=awhgx=y-m"a�z"{|d}ygb"~V��fKip��f�`=iq`=acf=b"x=hIa^f=b"oq�=h,yIa��hI��b"`K�=a^��{��^b"`Khgiph-eEh@b�d�f=b"xKhga^fKb"op�=h@b�d(�"r��=r�`=a^hIa�f=alygike�r�t"aH�|�|f=a^hIauf=b"x=hIa^f=b�op�=h�r�yga~�xK��f���a^r�oqegf=ipaly1eEf=r�`�eEfKa�f=b"x=hIa^f=b�op�=h�b�d4�1r�yErHt"x�r�z/r�`ub�y���ygr��^iqopisrH`�f=alygike�r�t"aH{"r�`K�

Page 39: 9= . >@?A . B C D1 E › files › docs › colloqpapers › w05 › Sc… · 0 (* %-$#+1 $3245$768&3 9:;&< # 9=" . >@?A . B C" D1 E FHGJILKMGON5PRQLSTPRQ UMSVK W;XZY\[^]`_Vacbd_eY\fZahgjilknmpo_eY\]

� �K���E���+�-���^�-�4�&���  "¡

egf=alz,�=osr�`/e�~Ob"h-eEokzOhIb¢z£r�`=�¤��fKa�rHe|d}b"y(eEf=aAa)j¥��b"y-e|~Or�yg¦Hale���� bu§4a[hgx=yIa[eEf�rBe�eEf=aiq`=�^oqx=hgiqb"`£b�dSegf=a^hIa�`=iq`=a¨f=b"x=hIa^f=b�op�=h©iph�`=b�e©§=ipr�hgiq`=tueEf=a¨yIa^hgxKoqeEh©ª�yIa^alhIeEiq~,rBeEaAeEf=ah-z¥h-eEal~2b�d+al«�x=rHeEiqb"`=h�a)jK�lopx=�Kip`=t�egf=a^hIa|f=b"x=hIa^f=b�op�=hl���|f=a|ygalhgx=okeEh�iq`��1r�§=opa ¡ ��f=iq��f�=b�`=bHe@iq`=�^oqx=�=a[egf=a��"r���r�`=alhga¬r�yIa¬«­x=ikeEa¨hgiq~Oiqosr�y®eEbuegf=a¨a�r�yIopipaly�ygalhgx=okeEhl�

¯ ° PY±©\�WY]Y²�P�³ ´µN�R ¶ ·¹¸�UOº ·»Z�UX²�±�Q N�R¼N�P ° PYR1¶�¸®Ww½

¾ QAP¤¶

ª&`£eEfKa¬~Or�iq`¤eEa�j�e�eEfKa¬iq`=hIegygx=~Xa^`/egh|x=hgal�wd}b"y|��rHhIe��^yIb"�c��f=b"ip�laA��alyga¨��r�h-e©m�iqoposrHt"aoqalm"alo¥�Kygip�la^hSr�`=����fKaleEfKa^y�b"y `=b�e1eEf=a5f=b"x=hIa^f=b�op���Kosr�`/eEal�ur@t�yga^al`�~Or�`­x=ygaH�Sª&`�egf=iphr��K��al`=�=ikj��5a�r�ophIbAip`=�lopx=�=a5�^yIb"����f=b"ip�la�ip`£¿ ¡"¡"¡ r�h�r�`uip`=h-eEyIx=~Oal`/e�d}b"y��lygb"�u��f=b�ip�^aiq`CÀ�Á�Á/À¥�¤ª&`=�lopx=�Kip`=tc��r�h-e��lygb"����f=b"ip�laOoqip~Xiqegh�eEf=aOhEr�~X�=oqaXhIip�laXd}yIb"~ÂÀ"À   eEbÃeEf=a¿ÅÄ�Ä�f=b"x=hIa^f=b�op�=h�d}b"y(��f=b"~¹��rHe�r�iph|r�mHr�ipopr�§=oqa©iq`¤§4b�eEfY¿ ¡�¡"¡ r�`=�cÀHÁ"Á/À¥��Æ@oqegf=b"x=t"fegf=a�mHr�opxKa�b�d®opr�t"t"al�wmHr�yIisr�§=oqa^h�r�h�iq`=hIegygx=~Xa^`/eEh�f�r�h�§4a^al`Ç«�xKa^hIegipb"`Ka^��{��=r�hIe��^ygb����f=b�ip�^a�f�rHh(h-eEyIb"`=t¬�=ygal�=ip��eEiqm�a���b¢�5a^y®d}b"y��^x=yIygal`­e5�^yIb"�X��f=b"ip�la�ÈÉr�h®hgf=b¢��`Oip`��SrH§=opaÊ"Ë ���|f=a�hIz�hIega^~Ìyga^hIx=oqegh@��f=al`�ip`K�^opxK�=ip`=t���rHhIe[�lygb"�w��f=b"iq�^a�r�h[r�`Fr��=�=ikeEiqb"`�r�o�iq`¥�h-eEygxK~Oal`­e(d}b"y®�^xKygygal`/e��lygb"�O��f=b"ip�la�rHyga©hgf=b¢��`,iq`O�1r�§=oqa¨¿¢ÁK��Í�m"al`£rHdÎega^y®ip`=�lopx=�Kip`=topr�t"t"al�¤�^yIb"�£��f=b"iq�^aAr�h�rH`¤ip`=h-eEyIx=~Oal`/e�eEf=aAf/z��4b�eEf=alhgiqh�eEf�rHe�eEf=a[iq`=hIegygx=~Xa^`/egh�r�ygaa)jKb�t"a^`=b�x=h@�^r�`=`=bHe�§�a¨yga&ÏIa^��eEa^�>�5Æ@t/r�ip`>{KeEf=a¨~Or�ip`OeEygal`=�=h©�=bX`=b�e���f�r�`Kt"a��

Ð Q[Ñ�QA¸�QAPY±©Q[R

Æ@§=ygalx�{=Ò��4È:¿ ¡"Ó"Ó Ë {�ÔÕ_[`,egf=a©egf=a^b�yIzXb�dÖiq`K×�`=ikeEa^okzuygal��a^rHeEal�¤t/r�~Xa^h®��iqegf,�=iqhg�lb"x=`/eI�ip`=tKØq{�Ù�Ú�ÛBÜ>ÛBÝ,Þ�ßÉà)á;Úgâ�ã+äåÈ;À Ë {  "Ó" ¢æ¥ "¡"ç �

Æ@¦�a^yIopb�d:{"è��Béëê(alopopal`�{/�K�Bì��KÈ-¿ ¡"¡Hí Ë {�è¬rH`=t�§4a^f�r�m�ipb�y^{�opr��9a^`Kd}b�yg�^al~Oal`/e�{/r�`K���^b"~u�~�x=`=ike&z¤mHr�opxKa^h^{>áÎÜcÔïî(r�opxKa^h©r�`=�w��x=§=opiq�A�1b�opip��z4Øq{��|f=a¬��yIb¥b�¦�iq`=t"h|ª&`=h-eEikeExKegipb"`��

Æ@`=�=ygalb"`=i�{��K�®éñðwiqopopaly^{(�K��È�À�Á"Á/À Ë {|ÔÕèAiqm�iq`=tYr��l�^b"yI�=ip`=tYegbòèAÆ[ó©�|ô�Æ�`õa)jK�4a^yIik�~Oal`/e�r�o�eEalhIe�b�d�egf=aX�^b"`=hIiph-eEa^`K�lz�b�d��=yIald}alyga^`K�^a^h�d}b"y¬r�oqegygx=iqhg~cØq{SÙ�Ú�ÛBÜ>ÛBÝ,Þ�ßÉà�á;ÚgâöK÷ È�À Ë {4Ä   Ä æ Ä Ê   �

��rH`K×�a^oq��{(Í|�®ø��©È-¿ ¡ Ê Ó Ë {�ù�ú�ÞXûüÛBàgâ�ý(þ@âBÿ�ápÿwÛ��£âÇþ@â�Ú����(â�à����Û¢Ú�á;Þ�ß�B{®�|f=a ��yga^a��yga^hIh^�

��rHygy^{HÆ��KÈ;À�Á�Á   Ë {�Ô � ygxKhIe®r�`K��a�j¥�4a^�lega^�ueEyIx=hIe&�5b"y-eEf=iq`=a^hIh^ô�ÍSj¥�4a^ygiq~Oal`/e�r�o�alm�ip�Ka^`=�lad}ygb"~��>ip~�§�rH§­�5a�rH`Ãm�iqoposrHt"a^hlØq{(ù�ú�Þ[Ù�Ú�ÛBÜ>ÛBÝuá;Ú���Û��¥à)Ü4â�ý������åÈ í"Ó"¡ Ë { ç ¿ íBæ¥ç�  ÁK�

Page 40: 9= . >@?A . B C D1 E › files › docs › colloqpapers › w05 › Sc… · 0 (* %-$#+1 $3245$768&3 9:;&< # 9=" . >@?A . B C" D1 E FHGJILKMGON5PRQLSTPRQ UMSVK W;XZY\[^]`_Vacbd_eY\fZahgjilknmpo_eY\]

� �K���E���+�-���^�-�4�&��� í Á

�1r�§=oqa ¡ ô����������! #"%$&��'(��)�*�+,)�$�*�+#-.+,/.*10�$�2.�3)4$5�7698:�3�;+#��/=<>��?�0@"A/1?B$&��C1'D$EC='F+�/.*GIHJH KML.N7OQP�RASUTWVYX[Z\K^]:_7`1_ATaK7b�Kdc �5b¥b�eghIegyEr��=�4a^�Ã�lopx=h-eEa^yIa^�chIeEr�`=��r�yI�Ãa^ygyIb"yghiq`c�=r�ygal`­egf=a^hIiphl�fe^� ¡ Á7g¤{�eMe�� ¡ Ê g£{=r�`=�e>e>e�� ¡"¡ g hgiqt"`=iq×=��r�`/e��

h�i&j�kQl�m7n�oqp�r h�i&j�k#satvu>txw7j;r l�y[z�{Up h�i&j�kQl�m3n�o|p�r h�i&j�k#satvu>txw7j;r l�y[z3{�p}\n�p ~>��~��>� ��~>��~��&� ��~>��~&~��

�;�����U�,��� �;��� �U����� �;��� ��������atx��wA��p��1�x����sf�&��n�{ ~>� �F��~ ��~>� ¡>��¢ ��~>� £&£&�

�;��� ¤4����� �;��� ¥��,¦�� �;��� §�¤�¦��¨©i«ªaw3n¬�­�&{[{Un�{�®@tvn��x� ��~>� �>��~�¯ ��~>� ¢&�F��¯ ~>� ¡&�F� ��~>� �&����¯U¯ ��~>�°���&�&¯U¯ ~>�x��¡>�

�;��� ���,±�� �;��� §U¦�¤U� �;�����,�U§�� �;��� §�¤���� �;��� §U�U��� �;������¤�¥��²´³©³ {�txwµ¡&¢�~E�·¶��&�3t¸z3{ ~>��~��&� ��~>��~7��� ��~>��~7���

�;��� ����±�� �;��� �U§���� �;��� ���,���²´¹ �3z��vp�º»�&�vn�{ ��~>� ¡&¡�~ ~>� ¡&�&�&¯U¯ ��~>��~7�&� ��~>� ¡&¡F� ~>�x���F~ ��~>��~�¡F�

�;�����,�U§�� �;�����#�U�[� �;��� �U�U¦�� �;������¤�±�� �;�����,¦U§�� �;��� ��¤�§��®��&�5tx�v�µ¼>tv½�n ~>��~�£&� ��~>��~�¾&£ ~>��~�¡&£

�;������¤���� �;�����U�,��� �;��� �U±U���h�i&j�kq¿In��&�vp�m!r ~>�x��~�� ~>� ¡&��� ¯U¯U¯ ��~>��~��F~ ~>�x�&��¡ ~>� ¡F�;� ¯U¯U¯ ��~>��~���¾

�;�����,¦U��� �;��� �U��¤U� �;��� �U±U¥�� �;�����U�,±�� �;��� �U���[� �;��� �U±U���²JÀ �vi�{Un¬¶�n��x��p�tvu&n�{�t¸wÂÁÃtx�¸�x��j&n ��~>��~���£ ��~>�x��~7� ¯ ~>��~�£&£ ��~>��~���� ��~>��~��&� ¯ ~>��~�¡F�

�;��� �U¥U��� �;��� �U±U§�� �;��� �U§U§�� �;��� �U¥��[� �;��� ������� �;��� �U§U���Ä.n���y�{�txwÂÁatx�x�x��j&n ~>��~&~�� ~>��~7���&¯ ~>��~7��¢&¯U¯U¯

�;��� ���U��� �;��� ���,��� �;��� �U�U±��Áatx�x�Aº»n��3tx�&wµh��&w3�ŪÃÆ©w7n�� ��~>� ¡&�&¾ ��~>� £&¢F� ~>�x���&¡

�;��� ����¤U� �;��� §���¥�� �;�����,±��[�¨©n�tvj�m;Çdi&y�l�y�z3{Up,Æ\i&y�p�m3t¸w7n�{�{ ~>� ¡&¢F� ~>� ��~&~ ����~��&¾&¯ ��� ¡F�3� ����~7��¢ ~>� ¢F��~

�3�U� �[¤U¤U� �3�U���,�U��� �;��� ¥U�U§�� �3�U� �[¤���� �3�U���,�U¦�� �;��� ¥U¦����È i&o­Áatx�x�¸��j&n ³ n��vÉ»t¸w À m;z3y[Ê[m ��~>��~�£>��¯U¯U¯ ��~>��~&~�£ ~>��~7����¯U¯U¯

�;��� ���,¦�� �;��� �U�U��� �;��� �U�U¥��ËÌtx�vi���n�pUn�y[{WpUi���i��¸txÊ�n ��~>�x��¾�~ ¯U¯ ~>��~�¡F� ~>��~�£>�

�;��� �U�U��� �;��� �U¥U¦�� �;��� �U§U§��² i&o.¼>pUn��&�x��Ç��vn À y[i&É�{ ~>�x��¡>� ������~�� ¯ ��~>�x����¾ ��~>� ¾�~&~ ~>� �&��~ ��~>��~�¾F�

�3�U� �U�U��� �;��� ¤�§U��� �;��� §U±��[� �;��� �U¦�¤U� �;��� ¥��,��� �;��� §U§U±��ªau&n�y[tx�7n�w;p�tvÍ�Ê���p�tvi�w k�Î�rWl�n�{Up ��¡MÏ°�D��£Åk°Ð�ÑÒ~>� �&£�r �&��Ïx��~7��k°Ð�ÑY~>�°��£�rªaÇ�{�Ï ¡>��� ¡>��� ¡>��� ¡>��� ¡>��� ¡>���

Page 41: 9= . >@?A . B C D1 E › files › docs › colloqpapers › w05 › Sc… · 0 (* %-$#+1 $3245$768&3 9:;&< # 9=" . >@?A . B C" D1 E FHGJILKMGON5PRQLSTPRQ UMSVK W;XZY\[^]`_Vacbd_eY\fZahgjilknmpo_eY\]

� �K���E���+�-���^�-�4�&��� í ¿

�1r�§=oqa|¿¢ÁKô\���������� #"%$&��'Ã��)9*�+,)4$Ã*�+#-.+,/.*10�$�2.��)�$¬�36@8:����+#��/=<>��?�0d"A/1?Ó$&��C='�$¬C='F+�/.*GIHJH SUTaN7OQP�RASUTWVÒ`1_�b7XIN>ÔMÕ7`ÖN>Z\ÕAS�N�K×_AbØ_ATÙSUT�b7X�Ô7P=ÚÛK>T�X�c �5b¥b�eghIegyEr��=�4a^��lopx=h-eEa^yIa^��hIe�rH`=��r�yI�òa^yIygb"yIh�iq`Ç��r�ygal`/eEf=alhgiphl�Óe�� ¡ Á7g¤{We>e�� ¡ Ê g¤{1rH`=�Øe>eMe�� ¡"¡ gÌhgiqtH�`=ik×���rH`­e^�

h�i&j�kQl�m7n�oqp�r h�i&j�k#satvu>txw7j;r l�y[z�{Up h�i&j�kQl�m3n�o|p�r h�i&j�k#satvu>txw7j;r l�y[z3{�p}\n�p ~>��~�¢�~ ��~>��~���£ ~>��~&~��

�;�����U�,��� �;��� �U�U±�� �;��� ����±���atx��wA��p��1�x����sf�&��n�{ ~>� ¾>��¡ ~>�x���M� ��~>�x���F�

�;��� ¤U¤�±�� �;��� ¥U�U��� �;��� �U�����¨©i«ªaw3n¬�­�&{[{Un�{�®@tvn��x� ��~>�°�M���&¯ ��~>� �&¢&¾&¯U¯U¯ ~>���;���&¯U¯ ��~>� ¾&¾&¢&¯ �¬���x��¾&£&¯U¯U¯ ~>� £&£&¢&¯

�;��� ���U��� �;��� §U±U��� �;��� ¦U���[� �;��� §U�U¥�� �;��� §U§U��� �;�����,�U±��²´³©³ {�txwµ¡&¢�~E�·¶��&�3t¸z3{ ~>��~���¢ ��~>��~&~�� ��~>��~&~��

�;��� �U§���� �;��� �U¦U§�� �;��� ���,¥��²´¹ �3z��vp�º»�&�vn�{ ��~>� ¡&¾&¾ ~>� ¡&¢&�&¯ ��~>��~&~�¡ ��~>� £����&¯U¯U¯ ~>�x����¾ ��~>��~���£

�;������¤���� �;�����,±���� �;��� �U�U��� �;�����,§U��� �;�����,¦U±�� �;��� ��¤�¥��®��&�5tx�v�µ¼>tv½�n ~>��~�¡&£ ��~>��~&~�� ��~>��~�¡&¢

�;�����U��¤U� �;��� �U���[� �;��� �������h�i&j�kq¿In��&�vp�m!r ��~>�x��~�� ~>�x���F~ ��~>��~�¢�� ��~>�x�&��� ~>�x��¡&¾ ��~>��~7���

�;�����U�,��� �;�����,��¤U� �;��� �U¥U��� �;��� �U���[� �;��� �U��¤U� �;��� �U±U¦��²JÀ �vi�{Un¬¶�n��x��p�tvu&n�{�t¸wÂÁÃtx�¸�x��j&n ��~>��~��&� ��~>�x��~���¯ ~>��~�¢F� ��~>��~���� ��~>��~�����¯ ~>��~�¡&�

�;��� �U¥U±�� �;��� �U¥U¦�� �;��� �U§U¥�� �;��� �U¥U§�� �;��� �U±U��� �;��� �U§��[�Ä.n���y�{�txwÂÁatx�x�x��j&n ~>��~&~�� ~>��~�¡F��¯U¯ ~>��~7����¯U¯

�;��� ���,¦�� �;��� ���,��� �;��� �U�U¥��Áatx�x�Aº»n��3tx�&wµh��&w3�ŪÃÆ©w7n�� ~>��~&~�£ ��~>��~�¡&£ ~>��~�¡&£

�;��� �U§U��� �;��� ������� �;��� �U¦U§��¨©n�tvj�m;Çdi&y�l�y�z3{Up,Æ\i&y�p�m3t¸w7n�{�{ ~>� �&�&� ��� ¾&¾F� ���x���&¢&¯ ���°���&¢ ��� �>����¯ ~>����¡F�

�3�U� §U±U±�� �3�U���,¥U��� �;��� ¥��,��� �3�U� ¦U�U��� �3�U� �U�U��� �;��� ±�¤�¦��È i&o­Áatx�x�¸��j&n ³ n��vÉ»t¸w À m;z3y[Ê[m ��~>��~�£�~ ¯U¯U¯ ~>��~&~&~ ~>��~7��� ¯U¯U¯

�;��� ���U��� �;��� �U�U��� �;��� �U�U¥��ËÌtx�vi���n�pUn�y[{WpUi���i��¸txÊ�n ��~>�x��¾&� ¯U¯ ~>��~7��� ~>��~�¢&¢

�;��� �U����� �;��� �U¥U��� �;��� �U§�¤U�² i&o.¼>pUn��&�x��Ç��vn À y[i&É�{ ~>��~��&� ��� £�~7��¯U¯U¯ ~>� ¡�~&~ ~>�x��£&£ ���x����~�¯U¯U¯ ~>�x��£&�

�;��� ��±��[� �;��� §U¥��[� �;��� ¦U�U§�� �;��� ���,¦�� �;��� §������ �;��� ¦U�U���ªau&n�y[tx�7n�w;p�tvÍ�Ê���p�tvi�w k�Î�rWl�n�{Up �MÏ°�&��¾Åk°ÐÂÑÒ~>� ¡&��r �&��Ï £>��¾»k°Ð�ÑY~>� ¢�~�rªaÇ�{�Ï ���&� ���&� ���&� ���&� ���&� ���&�

Page 42: 9= . >@?A . B C D1 E › files › docs › colloqpapers › w05 › Sc… · 0 (* %-$#+1 $3245$768&3 9:;&< # 9=" . >@?A . B C" D1 E FHGJILKMGON5PRQLSTPRQ UMSVK W;XZY\[^]`_Vacbd_eY\fZahgjilknmpo_eY\]

� �K���E���+�-���^�-�4�&��� í À

��al��¦�aly^{Öèu��Ü��1È-¿ ¡�ç"Ó Ë {ÖÔ ø�ygiq~Oa¬r�`=�w�=x=`=iqhgf=~Xa^`/e^ô�Æ�`wa^�^b�`=b"~Xip�¬r��=�=yIb/r���f�Øk{�ù�ú�Þ��Û��¥à)Ü4â�ýSÛ��ÞÝ�ÛBýÕáÎß�á;Úgâ�ý4Ù©Ú�ÛBÜ>ÛBÝ� ö äåÈ�À Ë {�¿ ç"¡Åæ À¥¿¢Ä¥�

��alygt={Ö�K�q{åÒ[iq��¦�f=r�xKe�{ �K�>é ðw��ø�r�§4a�{.ßu�®È-¿ ¡"¡ Ê"Ë {1Ô �1yIx=hIe^{ yIa^�lip�=yIb¥�liqe&z"{�r�`=�Yhgb��^ipr�of=iph-eEb"y-z4Øq{�à�â�Ý,Þ�ÿ�â�Ü��XÙ�Ú�ÛBÜ>ÛBÝuá;Ú@þ[Þ�úKâMá¢á;ÛBàÞ� ÷ È-¿ Ë {�¿ÅÀ"À æ ¿ í À¥�

��oqipalt"a��&��ipyI��{�ó¨�+ì®�4é ��iqyg��{+Ò��Aâ �1È-¿ ¡"¡ Ä Ë {�Ô Ò[alosr�z"al�Fygal�^iq�=ygb��^ike&zÃr�`=�ceEb"oqa^yErBeEa^�eEf=a�dÎe�ô®�|f=aA§4a^f�r�m�ipb�yEr�o�a^�^b�opb"t�zOb�dåd}b�b¥�¥� hgf�rHygip`Kt�hIegyErHega^t"iqa^h^Øk{:ãW��à)à�Þ�Ü�ß=ä�Ü�ßÎú�àEÛ�åæ ÛBýpÛ�çM5��èåÈ-¿ Ë { í/¡Åæ Ä Ó �

��oqx=yIegb"`¥�:��b"`=a^hl{Wé¬��èu�5È-¿ ¡"Ó Ä Ë {(Ô � b"opalyErHega^�òegf=aldÎe^ô»Ü¥x=t"t�a^hIegipb"`Kh�r�§4b"xKe¬eEf=a,a^�^b�ok�b"t�zvr�`K�ëa�m"b"oqxKeEiqb"`õb�d[hIf�r�ygiq`=t={(f=b/r�yI�=ip`Kt={�rH`=�ëhI�^yIb"x=`=t"iq`=t=Øk{ê��Û¢Ú�áÉâ�ýÃ��Ú�á;Þ�Ü>Ú�Þë Ü���ÛBà)ÝXâ�ßÉá;ÛBÜíì+ä�{   ¿ æ Ê í �

��xKyg¦­h^{%Ü��"î��k{Kø�r�yg�4a^`/eEaly^{K�K�­�1�­é�î®alygf=b�b"t"al`�{�Í|�>È�À�Á"Á   Ë {=Ô �®opr�z¥iq`=t¨§�bHeEfXygb"oqa^h�ip`eEf=a|egygx=h-e5t"r�~OaHØq{d��Û���à)Ü4â�ý>Û���Ù©Ú�ÛBÜ>ÛBÝuá;Ú�þ[Þ�úKâMá¢á;ÛBà©â�Ü��ïî�à�ç/â�Ü�á¸ð¢â�ß�á;ÛBÜ�ã9��{�¿ ¡ Ê æÀ¥¿ ç �

ø�r�y-eEaly^{>ð���ó¨�4é¹_[oqip`/eEb={+� ��È�À�Á"Á   Ë {ÖÔÕèAaleIeEiq`=t,iq`=hIegiqeEx¥eEipb�`=hÅñIygiqt"f/e�òOd}b�y©��f=b�~ïó"ôø�ygal�=iqe��lb"`=hIegyEr�iq`/eEh�r�`=�£egf=a¨ip~X��r��le�b�d1�=ygb"�4a^y-e&z¤yIipt"f/eEh|b�`Ãegf=aA«­x�r�`=ikeEike&z¤r�`K��^b"~X�4b"hgikeEipb�`�b�d(ip`/m"alhIeg~Oal`­e^Øq{=ä�Ý,Þ�à)á;Úgâ�Üô�+Û���à)Ü4â�ý(Û��Eä�ç�à)á;Ú��¥ýÕß,��àgâ�ý Ù©Ú�ÛBÜ>ÛBÝuá;Ú�ÿè+ã È:¿ Ë {Ö¿¢Ä  Åæ ¿ Ó�ç �

ø�b/rBeEa�{�Ü��4é ó©r�m�rHopopiqb"`�{=ð��1È-¿ ¡"¡�  Ë {�Ô ó©al�^iq�=ygb��^ike&z£��iqeEfKb"xKe©�^b"~X~XiqeE~Xa^`/e^ô�ø�f=r�y-�r��lega^yIip��rBeEipb�`�rH`=�ò�4a^y-d}b"yg~Or�`=�laXbHd�ip`¥d}b"yg~Or�o�iq`=hgx=ygr�`=�la,r�t�yga^al~Oal`/eEh^Øk{©��Û���à)Ü4â�ýÛ��Þõ�Þ�á�Þ�ýpÛ æ Ý,Þ�Ü�ßSÙ�Ú�ÛBÜ>ÛBÝuá;Ú�ÿ©ö ÷ È:¿ Ë {Ö¿ æ À í �

ÒAr�m�iphIb"`�{�Æ��åø��Öéø÷©ip`=¦­oqalz"{�Ò���î���È-¿ ¡"¡ Ä Ë {1þ�Û¢ÛBß}ÿ�ßÉàIâ æ ûüÞ�ß}ú�ÛF�Bÿ�â�Ü��vù�ú�Þ�áÎà5ä æ åæ ýÕá;Úgâ�ß�á;ÛBÜ�{�ø�r�~�§=yIip�=t"a5ù©`=iqm�a^yIhgiqe&z£�®yIa^hIh^�

�+rHd}��f�rH~O�=hl{/ð��Hé�ðwiq`­ega^`�{"���¥È;À�Á"Á í Ë {�ø�ygiq~OaH{HeEygr�`=hIiqeEb�yIz¨�4bÅm�a^y-e&z"{­r�`=��iphIb"osrHegipb"`>ôÍ�m¥iq�=a^`K�^a¨d}ygb"~ ðwr���r�t/rHhg��rHy^��ù@`K�=x=§=oqiphgfKa^�FðFr�`­x=hg�lygiq�Ke��

��a^fKy^{ Í|�1é»èÅúrH��f­ega^yl{:Ü��(È�À�Á"Á"Á Ë {�Ôû�+r�iqyg`=alhgh¬r�`=�üyga�e�r�oqisrHegipb"`>ô��|f=aXa^�lb"`=b"~Xip�lh¬bHdygal�^ip�Kygb��^iqe&z4Øk{@��Û��¥à)Ü4â�ý1Û��[Ù�Ú�ÛBÜ>ÛBÝuá;ÚÞÝ�Þ�àEÿ æ Þ�Ú�ß�áüá�Þ�ÿ(�7ö1È   Ë {Ö¿ Ê ¡Åæ ¿ Ó ¿"�

��a^fKy^{1Í�� é�Ü���f=~Oiq�Ke�{1ßu�1ð��(È-¿ ¡"¡"¡ Ë {®Ô Æ eEf=alb"yIzÇb�d5dÉr�ipyI`=a^hIh^{ �^b"~X�4aleEikeEiqb"`�{Ör�`K��^b�b"�4a^yErBeEipb�`�Øq{Wýa�=â�à)ß&Þ�à�ývµ��Û��¥à)Ü4â�ýSÛ���Ù�Ú�ÛBÜ>ÛBÝuá;Ú�ÿ(���7öSÈ   Ë { Ó ¿ÅÄ æ¥Ó"ç�Ó �

��b"h-eEa^yl{�è��/ð��4È-¿ ¡�ç Ê"Ë {=Ô �1a^r�hErH`­e(hIb¥�lipale&zur�`=��eEf=a�ip~Or�t"a5b�d�opip~Xiqega^��t�b¥b���Øk{3ä�Ý,Þ�à�åá;Úgâ�Üþä�Ü�ß}ú�àEÛ æ ÛBýpÛ�ç�ápÿ�ß�ä ö È�À Ë {4À ¡� Å楠 ¿ Ê �

Page 43: 9= . >@?A . B C D1 E › files › docs › colloqpapers › w05 › Sc… · 0 (* %-$#+1 $3245$768&3 9:;&< # 9=" . >@?A . B C" D1 E FHGJILKMGON5PRQLSTPRQ UMSVK W;XZY\[^]`_Vacbd_eY\fZahgjilknmpo_eY\]

� �K���E���+�-���^�-�4�&��� í/ 

èAosr�alhgaly^{=Í|�+ì��k{�ÜKr��la^yg�Kb�eEaH{+����éÿÜ���f=a^iq`=¦­~,r�`>{+�K�=Æ��ÖÈ-¿ ¡"¡�ç Ë {4ÔÕø�yIip~XaAr�`=�Ãhgb��^ipr�oip`/eEalyEr���eEiqb"`=h^Øk{:ýa�Kâ�à)ß:Þ�à)ývÅ��Û���à)Ü4â�ýSÛ���Ù�Ú�ÛBÜ>ÛBÝuá;Ú�ÿÞ�����4È;À Ë { Ê Á/Ä æ Ê í/Ó �

èAb"x=oq��{ÖÍ|�åÒ��q{9â�a^iq`�§4a^yIt={å���ÖÆ��åé ðwx=h-e�r�yI��{1Ò��Ö���®È�À�Á"Á/À Ë {�ÔÕø�yIip~XauyErHega^h¨r�`K�opb���r�o4osrH§�b"y5~,rHyg¦�a�e|b"�=�4b"y-eEx=`=ikeEiqa^h�iq`,eEfKa5ù@`=ikeEa^�þÜ­e�rHega^h^ô|¿ ¡ Ä ¡ �E¿ ¡"¡ Ä¥Øk{���Þ�á¢á;Þ��Û��[Ù�Ú�ÛBÜ>ÛBÝuá;Ú�ÿ¬â�Ü��Å�+ß;â�ß�ápÿ�ßÉá;Ú�ÿ¬èdö1È-¿ Ë { í Ê æ�ç ¿"�

÷@r�`=hgal`�{¨ì����1��È-¿ ¡"Ó À Ë {�Ô ì rHygt"aÇhErH~O�=oqaÇ�=ygb"�4a^y-eEiqa^hÃb�d�t�a^`=alyEr�oqip�^al��~Oa�eEf=b���bHd~Ob�~Oal`­egh|a^h-eEip~OrHegb"yghlØq{�Ù�Ú�ÛBÜ>ÛBÝ,Þ�ßÉà)á;Úgâ�ã ÷ È í Ë {�¿¢Á/À ¡Åæ ¿¢Á Ê í �

÷@r�yg�=iq`�{�ó¨�åÈ;ÀHÁ"Á/À Ë {�ù=à��/ÿ�ß�â�Ü���ùKà��­ÿ�ß,��ÛBà)ß}ú�áÎÜ>Þ�ÿ�ÿ�{Kó©x=hIhgalopo1ÜKr�t�a���b"xK`=��rHegipb"`��÷@r¢��¦Ha^hl{dßu��È-¿ ¡"¡�  Ë {=Ô ó©al�=oqz�� eEb�ßu��÷@ipoqo=r�`K�ï÷���ߨr��=opr�`���ô�_[`X��f­zX~Or�opa�d}b�yEr�t"alyghf­x=`/e[r�`K�whIf�r�ygaAd}b�b¥�>Øq{:ãW��à)àEÞ�Ü�ßWä�Ü�ßÎú�àEÛ æ ÛBýpÛ�çM5�dö {�Ä�ÁK¿ æ ÄHÁ ¡ �

÷©x=��¦+{.Ü���é ßAb"h-d}a^op�>{�ð���È;À�Á�Á í Ë {4�|f=a��¥z¥`=r�~Oiq�^h@b�d®`=a^iqt"f­§�b�x=ygf=b�b��w��rHeE��fÇr�`K�`=b"yI~ al`Kd}b"yI�^a^~Xa^`/e^{\âòb�yg¦­ip`=tw�SrH��aly,¿ ¡"¡ {1ª&`=h-eEikeExKegaOd}b"y�Í�~O�=iqygiq��r�o�ó�a^hIa�r�yI��fip`cÍ��^b"`Kb"~Oiq�^hl�

ߨr�yIosr�`�{�Ò��>Ü4��È;ÀHÁ"Á   Ë {>ù@hIip`=t�a�j¥��alygiq~Oal`­eEr�oKal�^b"`Kb"~Oiq�^h eEb[~Xa�r�hIx=yga�hgb��^isrHo¥�^r��=iqeEr�or�`=�c�=ygal�=ip��e�×�`�r�`=�lisr�o>�=a^�liphgiqb"`=hl��ù@`=�=xK§=opiqhgf=al��ðFrH`�xKhg�^yIip�Ke^�

ßAopa�eE�la^y^{aß���ð��5é âòyIipt"f/e�{�����Ò��@È�À�Á"Á"Á Ë {�ÔûÜ¥b¢m"a^yIa^iqt"`��=al§KeÃr�hOip`/eEalyIeEal~O�4b"ygr�o§�r�y-eEa^ylØq{�ä�Ý,Þ�à)á;Úgâ�ÜwÙ�Ú�ÛBÜ>ÛBÝuá;Ú���Þ�á¢á;Þ���� ÷ È   Ë { ç À¥¿ æ¥ç� "¡ �

ßAb���f=a^yIosr�¦Hb�e�rK{�é¬�Åó¬�"È-¿ ¡�¡ Á Ë {"Ô _[`AeEa^h-eEhåb�d¥ygal�=ygalhga^`/eErHeEikm"a(�^b"`=hIx=~Xa^yår�hIhgale �=yIip�lip`=t~Ob��=aloph^Øk{­��Û���à�Ü4â�ýSÛ��@û�ÛBÜ>Þ�ß;â�à�XÙ�Ú�ÛBÜ>ÛBÝuá;Ú�ÿaì4äåÈ�À Ë {+À Ó Ê æ¥  Á í �

ßAb���f=a^yIosr�¦Hb�e�rK{Ãé��(ó¨�©È-¿ ¡"¡�ç Ë {©Ô ª&~X�=opiq��rHegipb"`Kh�b�d[aX�^ipal`/e,yIiphg¦9hIf�r�yIip`=tÇ��iqegf=b"xKe�^b"~X~XiqeE~Xa^`/e^Øq{��©Þ�á¢á;Þ��Û��[Ù©Ú�ÛBÜ>ÛBÝuá;Ú(�+ß��%��á;Þ�ÿ©ä��åÈ í Ë { Ê ¡ Ê æ¥ç Á ¡ �

ìÖalm�i�{�ðü��È�À�Á"ÁK¿ Ë {Þâ�f=a^`µt"b¥b��µ�Kald}a^`Khga^hY~Or�¦Haòt"b�b¥�`=alipt"f­§4b"yghlô�Æ eEygr�`=hgr����eEiqb"`w�lb"hIe[r��=�=ygr�b���fweEbXeEyIx=hIe�r�`=���KiphIegygx=h-e�{åáÎÜÃø���ð �al`�r�yg�>{>a^�>�q{åÔ ª&`KhIeEikeExKegipb"`Kh^{ø�b"`/eEygr��legh^{®r�`=�C_[ygt/r�`Kip��rBeEipb�`=h^ô��1a^yIhg�4a^��eEiqm�a^h�d}yIb"~ é@a�� ª&`=hIegiqeEx¥eEipb�`�r�o(Í��^bH�`=b"~Xip�lh^Øk{�Í��K��rHyg��Í�oqt/r�y^{K�=���Ö¿   Ä æ ¿ Ê Ä¥�

ìÖalm�ikege�{9Ü��ÖÒ���È�À�Á"Á í Ë {SÔ ù@`=�Ka^ygh-e�r�`K�=ip`=t£��f/zY�lygip~Xa�d}alopo1ip`�eEfKa£¿ ¡"¡ Á�hlôÞ��b"x=y@dÉr����eEb"yIh�eEf=rHeua�j¥�=opr�ip`�eEf=a¤�Ka^�^oqip`=a,r�`=�9hIikj�eEf�rHe��=b�`=b�e^Øq{a��Û���à)Ü4â�ý©Û���Ù©Ú�ÛBÜ>ÛBÝuá;ÚÝ�Þ�à�ÿ æ Þ�Ú�ßÉáüá�Þ�ÿÞ�!èåÈ:¿ Ë {�¿ ç" Åæ ¿ ¡ ÁK�

Page 44: 9= . >@?A . B C D1 E › files › docs › colloqpapers › w05 › Sc… · 0 (* %-$#+1 $3245$768&3 9:;&< # 9=" . >@?A . B C" D1 E FHGJILKMGON5PRQLSTPRQ UMSVK W;XZY\[^]`_Vacbd_eY\fZahgjilknmpo_eY\]

� �K���E���+�-���^�-�4�&��� í"í

ìÖipt�b"`�{�Í��k{��|f=b�~,r�hl{u�K���1�Aé âòb"yIyEr�oqo;{¨�A��È�À�Á"Á/À Ë {XÔ ª&`Kd}b"yI~,rHo�iq`=hgx=ygr�`=�laõr�y-�yEr�`Kt"a^~Xa^`/eEhA��ikeEfYopiq~OikeEal�F�^b�~O~Xiqeg~Oal`­e^ô��|f=alb"yIzYr�`=�Çalm�ip�Ka^`=�la�d}yIb"~ñm�iqoposrHt"aa^�lb"`=b"~Xipalh^Øk{��©Þ�á¢á;Þ��Û���Ù�Ú�ÛBÜ>ÛBÝuá;Ú��+ß��%��á;Þ�ÿ|ä���{4À�Á ¡Åæ À í"í �

ðwxKi;{>î�� �&ì®�SÈ-¿ ¡"¡ Ê"Ë {1Ô �|f=a�a^�^b�`=b"~Xip�^h@b�d(a^`/m­z4Øq{:��Û��¥à)Ü4â�ý®Û���Ù�Ú�ÛBÜ>ÛBÝuá;Ú�þ�Þ�úKâMá¢á;ÛBàâ�Ü��î�à�ç/â�Ü�á¸ð¢â�ß�á;ÛBÜÅì+ä�{   ¿"¿ 楠� "ç �

�1r�ipt"aH{+�K� È-¿ ¡ Ä Ê"Ë {Aä�ç�àgâ�à)áÉâ�Ü���Þ�á�ÛBýv��ß�á;ÛBÜ�{=�|fKa«��ygala¬�®yIa^hIh^���osrBegeEa^r�x�{��K� �:� �>È:¿ ¡"¡ Ä Ë {=Ô ðwxKeEx=r�o+ip`=hIx=yEr�`K�^a@r�h(r�`Oalopx=hIiqm�a@�lb"`=�^al�Ke5ip`�eEyErH�=iqegipb"`�rHoygx=ygr�oÖhgb��^iqalegipa^hlØq{��+Û���à)Ü4â�ýSÛ��(õ�Þ�á�Þ�ýpÛ æ Ý,Þ�Ü�ß:�+ß,�d��á;Þ�ÿf��� È ç Ë {�Ä ç�íBæ Ä ¡"ç �

��osrBegeEa^r�x�{��K� �:� �(é é@x=t"al`/e�{©�K��È-¿ ¡"¡ À Ë {©ÔvÜ¥f=r�ygaw�^b"`/eEygr��legh¤r�`K�neEf=alipyXyErHegipb"`=r�opaHôìÖa^hghIb"`=h|d}ygb�~¹~Or�ygiq`=a�×�hgf=iq`=t=Øk{���Û���à�Ü4â�ý Û��êõ�Þ�á�Þ�ýpÛ æ Ý,Þ�Ü�ß1�+ß��%��á;Þ�ÿaì�èåÈ   Ë {  "Ó"çÅæí À"À¥�

� b"hg`=aly^{Öó¨�>Æ���È:¿ ¡"¡"Ó Ë {1ÔûÜ¥b��^ipr�oå`=b"yg~Xh^{�hgb��^ipr�o1~Xa�rH`=ip`=tK{>r�`K�Ya^�^b�`=b"~Xip��r�`�r�okz¥hIiphb�d1osr��¨ô®Æ �^b"~X~Oal`/e�Øk{�ù�ú�Þ5��Û��¥à)Ü4â�ý1Û����åÞ4ç/â�ý­�+ß,�d��á;Þ�ÿ¬ì ö È�À Ë { Ê"Ê  Åæ Ê ç Ê �

��xKeg`�r�~c{�ó¨�ÅÒ��­È-¿ ¡"¡"  Ë {/ûYâ��BáÎÜ�çêõ�Þ�Ý,Û¢Ú�àIâ�Ú���FÛBà�����ã�áüá¢á;Ú¨ù=àIâ7��áÎß�á;ÛBÜKÿ(áÎÜ�ûüÛF��Þ�à)Üë ß;â�ývH{+��yIip`=�laleEb�` ù©`=iqm�a^yghIiqe&zÃ��yIa^hghl�

ó©r�§=iq`�{�ð���È:¿ ¡"¡"  Ë {åÔ ª&`=�lb"yg�4b"ygrHeEiq`=tOdÉr�iqyg`=alhgh©ip`/eEbOt/r�~Xa¬egf=a^b�yIzFr�`=��al�^b"`=b�~Oiq�^h^Øk{ä�Ý,Þ�à)á;Úgâ�ÜwÙ�Ú�ÛBÜ>ÛBÝuá;Ú���Þ�á¢á;Þ��Òè+äåÈ Ê"Ë {�¿ÅÀ Ó ¿ æ ¿   Á"À¥�

Ü¥��fKa^��f/eEaly^{åì���È�À�Á"Á í Ë {4�1ygr��=iqegipb"`=r�o�eEyIx=hIeA~Xa�rHhgx=yIa^~Xa^`/eAr�`K��eEf=a�ygiphI¦Ã�^b"`Kd}b�x=`=��ôÆ�`ca�j¥�4a^ygiq~Oal`/e@iq`Ãygx=ygr�oÖ�®r�yErHt"x�r�z"��ù@`K�=x=§=oqiphgfKa^�FðFr�`­x=hg�lygiq�Ke��

Ü¥�lb�ege^{Ö�K��ø���È-¿ ¡"Ó Ê"Ë {��FÞgâ æ ÛBÜKÿ�Û���ßÎú�Þ��FÞgâ����¬Ù©á�Þ�à�M�/âM�� ÛBà�Ý�ÿ�Û��5Ý�ÞgâBÿ^â�Ü�ß���Þ�åÿ�ápÿ�ß â�Ü>Ú�Þ�{�ê5r�opa5ù©`=iqm�a^yghIiqe&zÃ��yIa^hghl�

ù©�=yIz�{>ø�� È:¿ ¡"¡�í Ë {�Ô ó©iqhg¦£r�`K�wiq`=hgx=ygr�`=�la�iq`wr�ygxKyEr�oÖ�lyga^�Kiqe©~,rHyg¦�a�e�ô(Æ�`ca^~X�=ipyIip�^r�oip`/m"alhIegipt/rHegipb"`�ip`�`Kb"yIegf=a^yI`µé@ipt�a^ygiprKØk{���Þ�á¢á;Þ��9Û��5Ù�Ú�ÛBÜ>ÛBÝuá;ÚÃ�+ß,�%��á;Þ�ÿSä.�4È   Ë { í/¡ Ê æÊ À ç �

�>alopop`Ka^y^{©Æ���é �|f=a^iqo;{(÷��¬È-¿ ¡"ç À Ë {¬Ô �|f=ygala�� hIe�rHt"a�oqa�r�h-eÃhg«­x�r�yIa^hlô Ü¥iq~�x=oqeEr�`=alb"x=ha^h-eEip~OrHegipb"`£b�d1hgiq~�x=oke�r�`=alb"x=h|al«�x=rHeEiqb"`=h^Øk{>Ù�Ú�ÛBÜ>ÛBÝ,Þ�ß�à)á;Úgâ5� ÷ È-¿ Ë { Ê íBæ Ä Ó �