24
JOHN N. POST FREDERICK B. POLAK * ROBERT A. GOODSELL DAVID L. EPSTEIN STEVEN C. ROTHER DOUGLAS J. SHERMAN * MITCHELL H. PORTNOI t* CLYDE L. OTIS III * MARSHA M. MOORE * JEFFREY A. WARSH RAUL GARCIA * SIOBHAN BEERE * KYLE S. REED KATHRYN A. KOPP * ERIC A. NEGRI Post Polak, p.a. COUNSELLORS AT LAW 425 EAGLE ROCK AVENUE - SUITE 200 ROSELAND, NEW JERSEY 07068-1717 (973) 228-9900 FAX (973) 994-1705 www.postpolak.com Writers Email: [email protected] REPLY TO ROSELAND OFFICE OF COUNSEL ELLEN C. KIM JERRY FISCHER ANNE L.H. STUDHOLME SCOTT H. NOVAK * J. WESLEY GEISELMAN MICHELE J AKER BAYE ADO FO-WILSON PRINCETON OFFICE 134 NASSAU STREET PRINCETON, NJ 08542 (609) 651-621 1 NEW YORK OFFICE SUITE 1006 575 MADISON AVENUE NEW YORK, NY 10022 (212) 486-1455 | CERTIFIED BY THE SUPREME COURT OF NEW JERSEY AS A CIVIL TRIAL ATTORNEY * NJ AND NY BAR NJ, NY AND PA BAR NJ, NY AND FL BAR ^ NY BAR ONLY PAUL D. STRAUCHLER (1951-2018) May 27, 2020 VIA ELECTRONIC MAIL Marta Rivera-Sullivan, LUA, Principal Planning Aide/Board Clerk City of Elizabeth Dept, of Planning & Community Development Bureau of Planning & Zoning, Land Use Division 50 Winfield Scott Plaza, Room 403 Elizabeth, New Jersey RE: Variance Application - Julio E. Cucullu Property: 1034 William Street, Elizabeth, NJ Block: 9, Lot 1420 Hearing Date: June 11,2020 Application No: Z-01-20 Post Polak File No. 6519.00001 Dear Ms. Rivera-Sullivan: As you are aware this firm represents Julio E. Cucullu in connection with the above-referenced matter. This matter is scheduled for a Virtual Public Hearing before the City of Elizabeth Zoning Board of Adjustment June 11, 2020 (the Virtual Public Hearing). Attached for filing, please find electronic (PDF) copies of the following Application Materials, which the Applicant and/or its professionals will rely upon during the Virtual Public Hearing. Please note that the Applicant previously filed nineteen (19) hard copies on March 10, 2020 in accordance with the Municipal Land Use Law (the “MLUL”). 1. Application for Variance (DCP Form #00) consisting of the following supplemental pages: a. DCP Form #03 b. DCP Form #03 c. DCP Form #04 d. DCP Form #12 with two (2) supplemental pages. e. W-9 {00926857.2}

6&'B5'2-.6.-BB'BC 'D)E8 0-&D .)&3 '(? 0F .'G -H) (I )2( 0F

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    5

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

JOHN N. POST FREDERICK B. POLAK * ROBERT A. GOODSELL DAVID L. EPSTEIN STEVEN C. ROTHER DOUGLAS J. SHERMAN *

MITCHELL H. PORTNOI t*

CLYDE L. OTIS III *

MARSHA M. MOORE *

JEFFREY A. WARSH

RAUL GARCIA *

SIOBHAN BEERE *

KYLE S. REED

KATHRYN A. KOPP *

ERIC A. NEGRI ♦

Post Polak, p.a.COUNSELLORS AT LAW

425 EAGLE ROCK AVENUE - SUITE 200

ROSELAND, NEW JERSEY 07068-1717

(973) 228-9900 FAX (973) 994-1705

www.postpolak.com

Writer’s Email: [email protected]

REPLY TO ROSELAND OFFICE

OF COUNSEL

ELLEN C. KIM ►

JERRY FISCHER

ANNE L.H. STUDHOLME

SCOTT H. NOVAK *

J. WESLEY GEISELMAN

MICHELE J AKER

BA YE ADO FO-WILSON

PRINCETON OFFICE 134 NASSAU STREET

PRINCETON, NJ 08542

(609) 651-621 1

NEW YORK OFFICE SUITE 1006

575 MADISON AVENUE NEW YORK, NY 10022

(212) 486-1455

| CERTIFIED BY THESUPREME COURT OF NEW JERSEY AS A CIVIL TRIAL ATTORNEY

* NJ AND NY BAR■ NJ, NY AND PA BAR♦ NJ, NY AND FL BAR ^ NY BAR ONLY

PAUL D. STRAUCHLER (1951-2018)

May 27, 2020VIA ELECTRONIC MAILMarta Rivera-Sullivan, LUA,Principal Planning Aide/Board Clerk City of ElizabethDept, of Planning & Community Development Bureau of Planning & Zoning, Land Use Division 50 Winfield Scott Plaza, Room 403 Elizabeth, New Jersey

RE: Variance Application - Julio E. CuculluProperty: 1034 William Street, Elizabeth, NJBlock: 9, Lot 1420Hearing Date: June 11,2020Application No: Z-01-20Post Polak File No. 6519.00001

Dear Ms. Rivera-Sullivan:

As you are aware this firm represents Julio E. Cucullu in connection with the above-referenced matter. This matter is scheduled for a Virtual Public Hearing before the City of Elizabeth Zoning Board of Adjustment June 11, 2020 (the “Virtual Public Hearing”). Attached for filing, please find electronic (PDF) copies of the following Application Materials, which the Applicant and/or its professionals will rely upon during the Virtual Public Hearing. Please note that the Applicant previously filed nineteen (19) hard copies on March 10, 2020 in accordance with the Municipal Land Use Law (the “MLUL”).

1. Application for Variance (DCP Form #00) consisting of the following supplementalpages:

a. DCP Form #03b. DCP Form #03c. DCP Form #04d. DCP Form #12 with two (2) supplemental pages.e. W-9

{00926857.2}

May 27, 2020 Page 2

2. Copy of list of property owners within 200 feet.

3. Boundary Survey prepared by Pronesti Surveying, Inc. dated March 26, 2019, consisting of one (1) sheet;

4. Site and Architectural Plans prepared by Palermo Edwards Architecture dated March 2, 2020 consisting of the seven (7) sheets:

a. Coversheet (Sheet 1 of 7)b. Owners List (Sheet 2 of 7)c. Site and Drainage Plan (Sheet 3 of 7)d. Soil Erosion Plan Grading & Utilities Plan (Sheet 4 of 7)e. Site Details (Sheet 5 of 7)f. Floor Plans (Sheet 6 of 7)g. Elevations (Sheet 7 of 7)

The Applicant further submits the following exhibits to be referenced by our witness/professionals. The exhibits are:

1. Color rendering undated, consisting of one (1) sheet.

2. List of Witness/Professional Experts.

In compliance with the MLUL the above listed Application Materials are on file with your office at least ten (10) days prior to the Virtual Public Hearing and the exhibits are submitted in PDF format only. The Affidavit of Service and related documents will be submitted under separate cover.

If you have any questions or should you require any additional information, please do not hesitate to contact this office.

Should you have any questions, please do not hesitate to contact me.

Very truly yours,

POST POLAK, P.A.

Marsha M. Moore

MMM/bahEnclosurescc: Julio E. Cucullu (via email)

Jennifer L. Palermo, RA c/o Palermo Edwards Architecture (via email)John McDonough, LA, PP, AICP c/o John McDonough Associates, LLC (via email) Pablo Tagliani (via email)

{00926857.2}

APPLICATION FOR BOARD HEARING

APPLICATION FOR BOARD ACTION Planning BoardDCP FORM #00, PAGE 1 of 5(Revised March 14,1988) Zoning Board _

Application #Date FiledReceived byHearing DateFinal Hearing

APPLICATION IS HEREBY MADE FOR:

L _____ Appeal of Administrative Action Pursuant to Serfion C.40:55-70a (Attach Form #01)

2. _____ Appeal for Interpretation Pursuant to Section C.40:55D-70b (Attach Form #02)

3. X Application for Hearing (Attach Form #00)

4. X Relief from Zoning Requirements Pursuant to Section C.40:55D-70c (Attach Form #03)

5. _____ Use Variance Pursuant to Section C.40:55D-70d (Attach Form #04)

6. _____ Conditional Use Authorization Pursuant to Section C,40:55D-67 (Attach Form #05)

7. _____ Approval of Subdivision (Attach Form #06)

8. _____ Final Approval ofMajor Subdivision (Attach Fonn #07)

9. _____ Preliminary Approval of Site Plan (Attach Form #08)

10. _____ Final Approval of Site Plan (Attach Fonn #09)

11. _____ Direction to Issue a Building Permit Pursuant to Section 602 or 604 of foe Blizabeft Development

Control Ordinance

12. x Hearing Application Checklist (Attach Form #18)

NOTE: BP AN APPLICATION FOR DEVELOPMENT HAS BEEN SUBMITTED FOR THIS PROPERTY WITHIN THE LAST TEN

YEARS, PLEASE PROVIDE THE FOLLOWING INFORMATION:

DATE OF APPLICATION TYRE OF DEVELOPMENT

APPLICATION FOR BOARD HEARING (ConHi

APPLICATION FOR BOARD ACTION Planning Board____DCP FORM #00, PAGE 2 of 5(Revised March 14, 1988) Zoning Board____

Application #Date FiledReceived byHearing DateFinal Hearing

PROJECT’S GENERAL INFORMATION

PROPERTY:Address lOSA William Street Owner (s) Julio E. CuculluAddress (es) 126 Riverview Avenue, North Arlington, NJ 07031

Date of Purchase Property Tax Account # 9-1420

APPLICANT:Name Julio E. CuculluAddress 126 Riverview Avenue, North Arlington, NJ 07031 Contact Person Julio E, Cucullu Telephone &08) 644-0745

PROPOSED OWNERSHIP STATUS*:Proprietorship ____ Partnership ______ Corporation _____Lessee _____ Contingent Purchaser _____Other x - Individual (Explain)

PROJECT’S ATTORNEY:Name Marsha M. Moore, Esq. Telephone (97$ 228-9900 x220Firm Post Polak, P.A.Address 425 Eagle Rock Ave., Suite 200, Roseland, NJ 07068

PROJECT’S ARCHITECT: Telephone (201) 532-4453Name Jennifer L Palermo, RA Finn Palermo Edwards ArchitectureAddress 600 Mountain Road, Kinnelon, NJ 07405 New Jersey License #A1015932

PROJECT’S ENGINEER:Name Telephone ( )Firm N/AAddressNew Jersey License #

PROJECT'S LAND SURVEYOR:Name George R. Pronesti, P.L.s. Telephone (97$ 857-3319Finn Pronesti Surveying, Inc.Address 870 Pompton Ave., Suite B1, Cedar Grove, NJ 07009 New Jersey License # 16202

♦Note: If the applicant is sot the proprietor, then the applicant is required to submit a letter signed by the property owner, authorizing the tilling and processing of this application (attach Form #13). Corporations and partnerships must attach Form #14. CORPORATIONS MUST BE REPRESENTED BY AN ATTORNEY.

APPLICATION FOR BOARD ACTION Planning BoardDCP FORM #00, PAGE 3 of 5(Revised March 14, 1986) Zoning Board _

APPLICATION FOR BOARD HEARING icont’d)

Application #Date FiledReceived byHearing DateFinal Hearing

: s: **= ja ^ = e? a

PHYSICAL DEVELOPMENT INTENT

Property Description Proposed new two (2) family dwellina Address 1034 William Street Owner (s) dul'0 E. CuculloProperly Tax Account # 9-1420 Zoning R-2

Lot Area S.F. 1,984 TYact Area

FRONTAGE: STREET LINEAR FEET

STRUCTURES'CONSTRUCTION USB** FLOOR AREA EFF. #OFBR/IMT

INTENT* STORIES T\TE TYPE fSp.Ftl UNITS 1 2 2 £ 1________ 3 1/2 5 B_____________ . R (Grmind Floor&/I at Floa^J__________ ____ 1_________

___________ __________ __________________ _____ 1,050 (2nd Floor) 1 j__________________

**Note: Definition of Use Type

t ResidentialCommercial

W: WarehousingM: ManufacturingA: Accessory1: InstitutionalO: Office

BUILDING LOTS (Please complete if property is to be subdivided):

______ LOT AREA fSo. Ftl

*Note: Definition of IntentA:tD:

Addition to Existing New Construction Existing to Remain To Be Demolished

LotLot

LOT FRONTAGE fSo-Pt)

APPLICATION FOR BOARD ACTION Planning BoardDCP FORM #00, PAGE 4 of 5(Revised March 14, 1988) Zoning Board _

APPLICATION FOR BOARD HEARING con’t i

Application #Date FiledReceived byHearing DateFinal Hearing

CERTTFICATTON FOR EXEMPTION FROM SITE PLAN APPROVAL (Please complete for projects other than

one or two family residence):

NOT APPLICABLE

m m1,

2.

3.

4.

5.

6.

7.

Will the development require conditional use authorization ?

Will tiie project involve a use requiring screening ?

Does the lot width exceed 80 feet and will there be a change of use from one Schedule 11 Category to another ?

Will the building construction or reconstruction cover more than 300 square feet 7

Will the lot have S or more parking stalls and will stalls, aisles or driveways be established, altered or eliminated ?

Will tire development involve the removal of soil exceeding ! foot in depth ?

Will 5,000 square feet or more of residential open space be provided 7

Note: A Xes response to one or more of the above questions indicates the need for a site plan review or, a certification from the City Engineer, City Planner and Zoning Administrator that improvements meet the criteria for exemption from site plan hearing requirements.

APPLICATION FOR BOARD ACTION Planning BoardDCP FORM #00, PAGE 5 of 5(Revised March 14, 1988) Zoning Board _

APPLICATION FOR BOARD BEARING f con’fi

Present Use Category: Vacant Lot Principal Use (s): Two (2) family dwelling Major Accessory Use (s): None Proposed Use Category: Two (2) family dwelling Principal Use (s)Major Accessory Use (s)

Application #Date FiledReceived byHearing DateFinal Hearing

USE:Describe tee PRESENT USE of fee property including both indoor and outdoor activities: Vacant

Describe the PROPOSED USE of the properly including both indoor and outdoor activities: Two (2) family dwelling

REQUIRED ATTACHMENTS:

m m1. _____ X Is a new public street right-of-way proposed ? If yes, please attach description,

2. _____ X Are off-tract facilities proposed ? If yes, please attach description.

3. _____ x Are there any deed restrictions which affect the subject properly in effect orcontemplated? If yes, please attach description.

4. _____ X Is the subject property located in “A” Flood Hazard Area 7 If yes, please attach copy ofnecessary permit or waiver.

5. _____ X Is fee subject property within 500 feet of a tidal water body ? If yes, please attach a copyof the necessary permit or waiver.

I hereby depose and say feat all fee statements contained in these papers submitted herewith are true and correct, I also authorize City Officials and Board members to have physical access to the property and any, structures on fee property as necessary for fee purpose of gathering information relevant to tins

STAMP OF NOTARY PUBLIC

SANDRA M FERREIRAID # 2330050

NOTARY PUBLIC STATE OF NEW JERSEY

My Commission Expires June 9, 2020

DCP FORM #03 APPEAL FOR RELIEF FROM ZONING REQUIREMENTS (Revised 3/25/83)

Planning Board Application No:Zoning Board Date Filed:

Filing Fee: Received by:

Appeal is hereby made, pursuant to Section C.40: 55D>70c of the New Jersey Municipal Land Use Law, far permission to vary requirements of the zoning article of the Development Control Ordinance of the City of Elizabeth as fallows;

SECTION REQUIREMENTS RELIEF REQUESTED

See Attached

Arguments must be submitted in support of die requested relief. On a separate sheet, for each variance requested, explain fully how the physical characteristics of die property in question prevents compliance with the strict application ofthe code requirements creating an undue hardship for the applicant.

2, Public Hearing Notification Information:

Notice shad be given by the applicant at least ten (10) days prior to the date ofthe hearing to die following parties where applicable, Notice shall be by personal service or certified mail. An affidavit of proof of service demonstrating compliance with this requirement shall be filed with (he city agency holding the hearing at least two (2) days prior to (he date ofthe hearing

Yes (0)a) Is die subject property located within two hundred (200) feet of any

municipal boundary? If yes. City Clerk of adjacent municipality and County Planning Board shall be notified of hearing by applicant (Note 1)

b) Is the subject property adjacent to an existing or proposed county road or adjoining other County land? If yes, County Planning Board shall be notified of hearing by applicant (Note 1)

c) Is die subject property adjacent to a State highway? If yes, applicant shall notify the Commissioner of Transportation ofthe hearing. (Note 2)

THE APPLICANT SHALL NOTIFY ALL OWNERS OF PROPERTY LOCATED IN THE STATE AND WITHIN TWO HUNDRED (200) FEET IN ALL DIRECTIONS OF PROPERTY IN QUESTION.

3. Disclosure Information N/AIs applicant and/or owner a corporation or partnership and does the application involve variances to construct a multiple dwelling of 25 or more fondly dwellings? If yes, submit disclosure of all stockholders holding 10% or more stock or partners with 10% or greater interest in the partnership pursuant to NJSA 40:55£M8.1 et. seq. (Form #14)

Yes (R9)

ffes) No

Yes No

DCP FORM #03 Planning BoardAPPEAL FOR RELIEF Zoning Board_FROM ZONING REQUIREMENTS (Revised 3/25/83)Page 2

Application No: Date Filed: Filing Fee: Received by:

NOTES:

“l” Union County Planning Board, Attn: Union County Department of Engineering and Planning, Union County Administration Building, Elizabethtown Plaza, Elizabeth, NJ 07207

"2” New Jersey Department of Transportation, 1035 Parkway Avenue, P.O. Box 101, Trenton, NJ 08625

APPLICATION FOR BOARD ACTIONDCP FORM #04, PAGE 2 OF 2(Revised March 14, 1988)

APPEAL FOR USE VARIANCE CONT’D

Application No:Date Filed;Received by:Hearing Date:Final Hearing:

Note #1: If die subject property is located within two-hundred (200) feet of a municipal boundary, or ifdie subjectpropoty is adjacent.to a county road or land, the applicant should file Form #15 and submit it to:

Union County Planning BoardUnion County Department of Engineering & PlanningUnion County Administrative BuildingElizabethtown PlazaElizabeth, NJ 07201

Note #2; If die subject property is located adjacent to a state highway or property, die applicant shouldfile Form #15 end submit it to:

New Jersey Department of Transportation 1035 Parkway Avenue P.O. Box 101 Trenton, NJ 08525

APPLICATION FOR BOARD ACTION Planning BoardDCP FORM #13, PAGE 1 of 1(Revised March 14, 1988) Zoning Boards

OWNER'S CONSENT FORM

Application #Date FiledReceived fayHearing DateFinal Hearing

5j-te=jcc3C;j=ts=^:^:^Jc:ss»:<& s

I, Julio E. Cucullu ______ AM THE OWNER OF THE PREMISES

KNOWN AS 1034 William Street__________ , Elizabeth, NJ, TAX ACCOUNT NUMBER BL 9 ,

Lot(s), 1420________________________________________________________________FOR WHICH AN

APPLICATION OF DEVELOPMENT HAS BEEN SUBMITTED

BY Julio E. Cucullu______________ , OWNER x /LESSEE___________ /

CONTINGENT PURCHASER______ / OTHER___________ (EXPLAIN)________________________

WHICH INVOLVESConstruction of new two (2) family dwelling.

.AND REQUIRES THE GRANTING OF "c” variances on the attached list._________________ .

I HEREBY CERTIFY THAT I HAVE READ THE APPLICATION AND GRANT PERMISSION TO

THE APPLICANT TO PROCEED BEFORE THE PROPER BOARD. I FURTHER CERTIFY THAT I

AM AWARE THAT THE ENTIRE PROPERTY IS SUBJECT TO THE ACTIONS OF THE

REVIEWING BOARD WHICH MAY AFFECT THE PROPERTY RIGHTS OF MYSELF OR MY

SUCCESSORS, AND THAT, AS THE OWNER OF SAID PROPERTY, I AM ULTIMATELY

RESPONSIBLE FOR COMPLYING WITH ANY AND ALL CONDITIONS IMPOSED BY THE

REVIEWING BOARD.

I FURTHER CERTIFY THAT I AM AWARE THAT INFORMATION REGARDING THE

APPLICATION AND ANY PROSPECTIVE CONDITIONS OF APPROVAL WILL BE AVAILABLE

FOR PUBLIC INSPECTION FOR TEN (10) DAYS PRIOR TO THE HEARING AND THAT THE

ACTUAL DECISION CONTAINING THE CONDITIONS IMPOSED WILL BE AVAILABLE FOR

PUBLIC INSPECTION NOT LATER THAN TEN (10) DAYS AFTER SAID HEARING.

INFORMATION IS AVAILABLE DURING NORMAL BUSINESS HOURS AT THE OFFICE OF THE

DIVISION OF ZONING AND LAND USE CONTROL, 50 WINFIELD SCOTT PLAZA, 4<t‘ FLOOR,

ELIZABETH, NEW JERSEY 07201.

NOTARY PUBLIC DATE: *7

SANDRA M FERREIRA

VARIANCES REQUESTEDATTACHMENT TO BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT APPLICATION

REGULATION1. Lot Area

2. Lot Width

3- Rear Yard Setback (Prevailing)

4. Left Side Yard Setback (Prevailing)

5. Max. Impervious Surface Coverage

6. Maximum Building Height

7. Maximum Number of Stories

Re< mired Proposed10,500 sf 1,984 sf

70.0’ 19.3’

26.5’ 20.83 s

3.0’ O’

35% 69.6%

35.0’ 36.5s

2 Vi Stories

3 Vi Stories

{00892722.1}

Arguments in support of “c” variance

Applicant to present planning testimony in support of relief at the time of the Public Hearing.

{00892762.1}

W-9Form(Rev. October 2018) Department of the Treasury Internal Revenue Service

Request for Taxpayer Identification Number and Certification

► Go to www.lrs.gov/FormW9 for Instructions and the latest Information.1 Name (as shown on your Income tax return). Name is required on this line; do not leave this line blank.

Give Form to the requester. Do not send to the IRS.

Julio E. Cucullu2 Business nama/dlsregarded entity name, if different from above

3 Check appropriate box for federal tax classification of Ore person whose name is entered on line 1. Check only one of the following seven boxes.

□ Individual/sols proprietor or Cl C Corporation Q S Corporation D Partnership Q Trust/estatesingle-member LUC

i~l Limited liability company. Enter the tax classification (C=C corporation, S=S corporation. P=Partnership) ► PNote: Check the appropriate box In the line above for the tax classification of the single-member owner. Do not check LLC if the LL.C is classified as a single-member LLC that is disregarded from the owner unless the owner of the LLC is another LLC that Is not disregarded from the owner for U.S, federal tax purposes. Otherwise, a single-member LLC that is disregarded from the owner should check the appropriate box for the tax classification of its owner.

3 Other (see Instructions) ►

4 Exemptions (codes apply only to certain entities, not Individuals; see instructions on page 3):

Exempt payee code (jf any)

Exemption from FATCA reporting code (if any)

(Applies to GCCOUfits ma/nte/netf oulsffife ttte U.S.)

5 Address (number, street, and apt. or suite no.) See instructions.

126 Rlvervlew AvenueRequester’s name and address (optional)

6 City, state, and ZIP code

North Arlington, NJ 070317 List account numbers) here (optional)

Part I Taxpayer Identification Number (TIN)Enter your TIN in the appropriate box. The TIN provided must match the name given on line 1 to avoid backup withholding. For Individuals, this is generally your social security number (SSN). However, for a resident aiien, sole proprietor, or disregarded entity, see the instructions for Part I, later. For other entities, it is your employer Identification number (EIN). If you do not have a number, see How to get a TIN, later.Note: If the account is In more than one name, see the instructions for line 1. Also see What Name and Number To Give the Requester for guidelines on whose number to enter.

Part II CertificationUnder penalties of perjury, I certify that:

Social security number

1 5 0 - 0 8 - 6 5 5 2

orEmployer Identification number

-

1. The number shown on this form is my correct taxpayer identification number (or I am waiting for a number to be issued to me); and 2.1 am not subject to backup withholding because: (a) I am exempt from backup withholding, or (b) I have not been notified by the Internal Revenue

Service (IRS) that I am subject to backup withholding as a result of a failure to report all interest or dividends, or (c) the IRS has notified me that I am no longer subject to backup withholding; and

3.1 am a U.S. citizen or other U.S. person (defined below); and4. The FATCA code(s) entered on this form (if any) indicating that I am exempt from FATCA reporting Is correct.Certification Instructions. You must cross out item 2 above If you have been notified by the IRS that you are currently subject to backup withholding because you have failed to report all interest and dividends on your tax return. For real estate transactions, item 2 does not apply. For mortgage interest paid, acquisition or abandonment of secured property, cancellation of debt, contributions to an individual retirement arrangement (IRA), and generally, paymentsacquisition or abandonment of secured property, cancellation of deb contributions to an individual retirement arrangement (IRA), and generany, payments other than interest and dividends, you are no: quirv:; ic sign ttwrcytification. byt ou must provide your correct TIN. See the Instructions for Part II, later.

SignHere

Signature of U.S. [

General InstructionsSection references are to the internal Revenue Code unless otherwise noted.Future developments. For the latest Information about developments related to Form W-9 and its instructions, such as legislation enacted after they were published, go to www.ire.govlTomWS.

Purpose of Form

Date*'

■ Form 1099-DIV (dividends, including those from stocks or mutual funds)• Form 1099-MISC (various types of Income, prizes, awards, or gross proceeds)• Form 1099-B (stock or mutual fund sales and certain other transactions by brokers)• Form 1099-S (proceeds from real estate transactions)• Form 1099-K (merchant card and third party network transactions)

An individual or entity (Form W-9 requester) who is required to file an information return with the IRS must obtain your correct taxpayer identification number (TIN) which may be your social security number (SSN), individual taxpayer identification number (TTIN), adoption taxpayer identification number (AT1N), or employer identification number (EIN), to report on an information return the amount paid to you, or other amount reportable on an Information return. Examples of information returns Include, but are not limited to, the following.• Form 1099-1NT (interest earned or paid)

• Form 1098 (home mortgage interest), 1098-E (student loan Interest), 1098-T (tuition)• Form 1099-C (canceled debt)• Form 1099-A (acquisition or abandonment of secured property)

Use Form W-9 only if you are a U.S. person (including a resident alien), to provide your correct UN.

If you do not return Form W-9 to the requester with a TIN, you might be subject to backup withholding. See What is backup withholding,later.

Cat No. 10231X Form W-9 (Rev. 10-2018)

y

CITY OF ELIZABETH, NEW JERSEY -DIVISION OF ASSESSEMENT OFFICE OF THE cnY ASSESSOR

50 WINFIELD SCOTT PLAZA ELIZABETH, NX 07201-2462 TEL. (908) 820-4136 ‘ FAX (908)820-0915

Enrico C. Emma, CTA J. Cristian BollwageCity Tax Assessor Mayor

Date Z73-7A-

Re:200’ Radius--------Account No. ^ ^ /V ________________ ______f

Location /P3f4 {j]t , _______ ________

Requested by pQcfh Pq£~A ____Request received on: 3 - // —

THIS IS TO CERTIFY THAT THE ATTACHED IS A COMPLETE AND CURRENT LIST OF OWNERS AND ADDRESSES, AS SHOWN IN OUR RECORDS, WHICH MUST BE GIVEN NOTICE PURSUANT TO THE REQUIREMENTS OF N. J.S.A40:55D-12. — For Liquor. Lic./Trausfer check here( )

THIS LIST IS BASED ON THE ACCOUNT INFORMATIONS AND OR THE 200 FT. RADIUS MAP LAYOUT, AS SUPPLIED BY:

[) THE APPLICANTS ENGINEER/ARCHITECT

[YeNGMEERING DIVISION-CITY OF ELIZABETH

Enclosure: List Of Property Owners Utilities Companies

/5W~Line Items ''v —'

♦Batch No.

Note

♦IF IT BECOMES NECESSARY FOR YOU TO REQUEST AN UPDATED LIST, PLEASE REFER TO THE ABOVE BATCH NUMBER AND SUBMIT THE REQUIRED FEE, PAYBLE TO THE CITY OF ELIZABETH.

&

March 11, 202001:01 PM

CITY OF ELIZABETH Block and Lot Listing

Page No: 1

Batch Id: 91420

identification Namestreet Address city, state property Location

Zip

Block: 9 Lot: 1420 Qua!:

Block: 9 Lot: 1419 Qua!:

Block: 9 Lot: 1418 Qual:

CUCULLU, JULIO 126 (OVERVIEW AVE N ARLINGTON, N J 070311034 WILLIAM ST

MAYERS, RAYMOND R 1030 WILLIAMS STELIZABETH, NJ 072011032 WILLIAM ST

MAYERS, RAYMOND R 1030 WILLIAM STELIZABETH, N 3 072011030 WILLIAM ST

Block: 9Lot: 1417.AQual:

Block: 9 Lot: 1417 Qual:

HALL, PAULETTE 1028 1/2 WILLIAM ST ELIZABETH, N J 072011028 1/2 WILLIAM ST

SCALES, DONNA 1053 WILIAM STELIZABETH, N J 072011028 WILLIAM ST

Block: 9Lot: 1416.AQual:

DUKES, BELINDA 1026 WILLIAM ST ELIZABETH, N J 1026 WILLIAM ST

07201

Block: 9 Lot: 1416 Qual:

BOLES, ETHEL 1024 WILLIAM ST ELIZABETH, N J 1024 WILLIAM ST

07201

Block: 9 Lot: 1415 Qual:

RILEY, A & RILEY, N & SCOTT, L 5 ROOSEVELT PLACE APT 6C MONTCLAIR, N J 07042-33741022 WILLIAM ST

Block: 9 Lot: 1414 Qual:

RYAN, JOIN 1020 WILLIAM ST ELIZABETH, N 3 1020 WILLIAM ST

07201

Block: 9Lot: 1413Qual:

GALVAN, RODMAN - GALVAN, ELFIDO 1018 WILLIAM STELIZABETH, N J 072011018 WILLIAM ST

March 11, 202001:01 PM

CITY OF ELIZABETH Block and Lot Listing

page No: 2

Identification NameStreet AddressCity, State zipProperty Location

Block: 9 Lot: 1412 Qual:

Block:Lot:Qual:

Block:Lot:Qual:

987S

9876

TORRES, RUDESINDO & MILAGROS 1016 WILLIAM STELIZABETH, N J 072011016 WILLIAM ST

CONTRERAS-MUNOZ, DOSE A 1015 LAFAYETTE ST ELIZABETH, N D 072011015 LAFAYETTE ST

HERNANDEZ, OFELIA1017 LAFAYETTE STELIZABETH, N D 072011017 19 LAFAYETTE ST

Block:Lot:Qual:

9877

HUACCHO, NORMAN 1021 LAFAYETTE ST ELIZABETH, N D 1021 LAFAYETTE ST

07201

Block: 9 RAMOS, CARLOS & MARIALot: 877.A 1023 LAFAYETTE STQual: ELIZABETH, N3

1023 LAFAYETTE ST,07201

Block:Lot:Qual:

9878

GH REAL REALTY CORP 1614 83RD ST N BERGEN, N 3 1025-1027 LAFAYETTE ST

07047

Block:Lot:Qual:

9879

COSTA, GISELLE R 1029 LAFAYETTE ST ELIZABETH, N D 1029 LAFAYETTE ST

07208

Block:Lot:Qual:

FREDUSTE, BERTHONY & YUROSE 1033 LAFAYETTE ST ELIZABETH, N D 072011031 33 LAFAYETTE ST

Block:Lot:Qual:

9881

ANKOMAH, REBECCA - AMO, LETICIA 1035 LAFAYETTE ST ELIZABETH, N D 072011035-1037 LAFAYETTE ST

Block:Lot:Qual:

9882

ASITIMBAY, DOSE 1039 LAFAYETTE ST ELIZABETH, N D 1039-1041 LAFAYETTE ST

07201

March 11, 202001:01 PM

CITY OF ELIZABETH Block and Lot Listing

Page No: 3

Identification NameStreet Addresscity, state zipproperty Location

Block:Lot:Qua!:

Block:Lot:qua!:

9117

9118

NJ 159 CATHERINE STREET, LLC 9 HILL HOLLOW RDWARREN, N 3 07059159 CATHERINE ST

OLIVEIRA, A8ILIO & DEOLINDA 161-63 CATHERINE ST ELIZABETH, N 3 07206161-163 CATHERINE ST

Block:Lot:Qua!:

9119

CITY OF ELIZABETH 50 WINFIELD SCOTT PLAZA ELIZABETH, N 3 165 CATHERINE ST

07201

Block:Lot:Qual:

Block:Lot:Qual:

9916

9917

VELEZ, DAISY 1020 LAFAYETTE ST ELIZABETH, N 3 1020 22 LAFAYETTE ST

07202

ACE HOLDING PARTNERS, LLC 1416 AVE LBROOKLYN, NY 112301024 LAFAYETTE ST

Block: 9 PINKNEY, ASSAD - PINKNEY, VERONICALot: 918,A 1028 LAFAYETTE STQual; ELIZABETH, N 3 07201

1028 LAFAYETTE ST

Block:Lot:Qual:

9918. E

AMAYA, ALEX A - CASTILLO, 30SELINE 1030 LAFAYETTE ST ELIZABETH, N 3 072011030 LAFAYETTE ST

Block:Lot:Qual:

9115

ALMENDAREZ, CARLOS 3 & MA WUENDI E 141 CATHERINE STELIZABETH, N 3 07201141 CATHERINE ST

Block: Lot: Qual:

9116

ELIZABETH CATHERINE VENTURES, LLC 143 CATHERINE STELIZABETH, N 3 07201143 CATHERINE ST

Block:Lot:Qual:

9883

SENATUS, DANIEL 3EROME 1043-1045 LAFAYETTE ST ELIZABETH, N 3 1043-1045 LAFAYETTE ST

07201

Block: 708 EMERALD LLC

March 11, 202001:01 PM

CITY OF ELIZABETH Block and Lot Listing

Page No: 4

identification NameStreet Addresscity, State zipproperty Location

Lot:Qua!;

146 618 BARTELL PL RIDGBWOD, N J 152-154 CATHERINE ST

07450

Block:Lot:Qual;

9147

WAITHE, SINCLAIR 156 CATHERINE ST ELIZABETH, N J 156 CATHERINE ST

07201

Block:Lot:Qual:

9148

WANG, YI GE 158 CATHERINE ST ELIZABETH, N J 158 CATHERINE ST

07201

Block:Lot:Qual:

9149

DA ROCHA, JOSE C M & VIOLETA LANUZA 160 CATHERINE STELIZABETH, N J 07201160 CATHERINE ST

Block:Lot:Qual:

9150

ALVAREZ, GILBERTO & MARIE 162 CATHERINE STELIZABETH, N J 07201162 CATHERINE ST

Block:Lot:Qual:

9151

NAULA, WILSON - RUIZ, CLAUDIA 426 HENRY STELIZABETH, N J 07201168 CATHERINE ST

Block:Lot:Qual:

9152

MITCHELL, KENNETH 5021 ALLEN DR BETHLEHEM, PA 170-172 CATHERINE ST

18017

Block: 8 Lot: 1856 Qual:

RODAS-VARGAS, ELSI & ELOISA 1041-1043 WILLIAM ST ELIZABETH, N J 072011041-1043 WILLIAM ST

Block: 8 Lot: 1855 Qual:

JOSEPH, SWANSTO, CLAIRNA - GUEDWINE 1039-1041 WILLIAM ST ELIZABETH, N J 072011039-1041 WILLIAM ST

Block: 8 Lot: 1854 Qual:

MATTHEWS, RICHMOND 1037 WILLIAM ST ELIZABETH, N J 1037 WILLIAM ST

07201

Block: 8 PARKINSON, MARTIKA & AKEEMLot: 1853 1035 WILLIAM ST

March 11, 202001:01 PM

CITY OF ELIZABETH Block and Lot Listing

Page No: 5

Identification NameStreet Addresscity, State zipProperty Location

Qual:

Block: 8 Lot: 1852 Qual:

Block:Lot:Qual:

81851

ELIZABETH, N 1 072011035 WILLIAM ST

SALES, JEROME & MARGARET 1033 WILLIAM STELIZABETH, N J 072011033 WILLIAM ST

CASTANO, JHON ARDILA 1031 WILLIAM STELIZABETH, N J 072011031 WILLIAM ST

Block: 8 Lot: 1850 Qual:

BOTROS, NAGAH & SAMIA SALAMA 1029 WILLIAM STELIZABETH, N J 072011029 WILLIAM ST

Block: 8 Lot: 1849 Qual:

Block: 8 Lot: 1848 Qual:

Block: 8 Lot: 1847 Qual:

Block:Lot;Qual:

458

TINEO, MAXIMO 1025-1027 WILLIAM ST ELIZABETH, N J 1025-1027 WILLIAM ST

WALLACE, LAURECE 1023 WILLIAM ST ELIZABETH, N J 1023 WILLIAM ST

MIKETEN, ELISANDRO E 201 MOUNTAINVIEW RD WARREN, N J 1019-1021 WILLIAM ST

DIAZ, ROSA 179 CATHERINE ST ELIZABETH, N J 1038-1040 E GRAND ST

07201

07201

07059-8038

07201

Block:Lot:Qual:

8457

PENAFIEL, HECTOR O ANGAMARCA 1036 E GRAND STELIZABETH, N 3 072011036 E GRAND ST

Block:Lot:Qual:

Block:Lot:Qual:

8456

8455

DE OLIVEIRA, JOAREZ A & NUBIA 1034 E GRAND STELIZABETH, NJ 1034 E GRAND ST

LITUMA, MIRIAM R 1032 E GRAND ST ELIZABETH, N J

07201

ORDONEZ, ZOILA

07201

March 11, 2020 01:01 pm

CITY OF ELIZABETH Block and Lot Listing

Page no: 6

Identification NameStreet Address City, State Property Location

1032 E GRAND ST

Block:Lot:Qual:

Block:Lot:Qual:

Block:Lot:Qual:

Block:Lot:Qual:

8454

8453

8452

8451

JOHNSON, SHAUN 1030 E GRAND ST ELIZABETH, N J 1030 E GRAND ST

1028 E GRAND STREET, LLC 971 ROOSEVELT AVE UNION, N I 1028 E GRAND ST

MONTAGUTH, SAMMY & SALOMON 1026 E GRAND ST ELIZABETH, N J 1026 E GRAND ST

RUIZ, YONNATAN 1022-1024 E GRAND ST ELIZABETH, N 3 1022-1024 E GRAND ST

Zip

07201

07083-8328

07201

07201

UTILITIES COMPANIES

NAMESTREET ADDRESS CITY,STATE,ZIP PROPERTY LOCATION

IDENTIFICATION

BLOCK 11 LOT 1069 QUAL. Wll

CABLEVISION OF NJ. 536 N.BROAD ST. ELIZABETH,NJ 07208 532-534 NBROAD ST.

BLOCK 4 LOT 183 QUAL. W04

P.S.ELECTRIC & GAS CO., 80 PARK PLAZA T24A NEWARK.NJ 07101 269-275 BAYWAY

BLOCK 9 LOT 366 QUAL. W09

VERIZON P.O.BOX 152206 IRWING.TX, 75015 1184 E. GRAND ST.

BLOCK 5 LOT 1381 QUAL. W05

ELIZABETHTOWN GAS CO. P.O.BOX4569,DEPT.l 150 ATLANTA,GA. 30302 200-334 THIRD AVE.

LIBERTY WATER CO.1341 NORTH AVE.PLAINFIELD,NJ 07062-ELIZ.WATER CO-OPERATIONS

Revised:APR/18/2008

List of Witness/Professional Experts

Applicant: Julio E. CuculluApplication No.: Z-01-20Properties: 1034 William Street, Elizabeth, NJBlock: 9, Lot: 1420Virtual Hearing Date: June 11,2020Attorney: Marsha M. Moore, Esq, Post Polak, P.A.

1. Licensed Architect:Jennifer L. Palermo, R.A.Palermo Edwards Architecture

2. Licensed Planner:John McDonough, LA, PP, AICP John McDonough Associates, LLC

3. Owner/Applicant:Julio E. Cucullu(Available if Board has questions)

The Applicant reserves the right to determine the order of testimony.

{00927127.1}

CNW T'lomr OMW CM1* CNW OHW or* an OHW Of* Of* OfM OHW Of* Of* — — •

BLUESTONE CURBGAS MAIN (MARK OUT) ?

IzzGAS MAIN (MARK OUT) f

Il

12" PVC SEWER MAIN /I

f

^S> 1

IWILLIAM STREET

I GAS SERVICE______ __(MARK OUT) |(55.00’ R.O.W.)

I SITE PHOTOI IWATER MAIN (MARK OUT)BLUESTONE CURB

z JZ _______ - -TT 'a __ .A

S 49*30’00”4E r - 19.30"'

-4—-t. JL4 '

P.OB.' *t■ A GENERAL NOTESi WOOD4, FENCE *

* 3.6‘ NORTH V/ I/

1 7-

W\^I

1. Locations and types of utilities shown hereon are derived from field location -and available utility maps. Prior to any excavation contact the City of Elizabeth Engineer’s office, sewer, and water departments, the local carriers of telephone and cable, and Public Service Electric <Sc Gas Co.

For location, depth and mark-out of utilities you must call 800-272—1000

2. Total lot area = 1,984 sq. ft. or 0.046 acres.

3. This survey is subject to the facts and findings of a complete title search.

4. This survey is not valid unless signed and sealed by the licensed surveyor.

100.00’91 ITO CATHERINE STREETi: **H I i DESCRIPTION55 'i8. -

SS I z it; -

!**s* !* 1 *

STR. NO. 1034 <l BEGINNING at a point in the southerly sideline of William Street, said point being distant easterly 100.00 feet from the comer formed by the intersection of the said southerly sideline of William Street with the easterly sideline of Catherine Street; thence running

<

Si8 I LJ <To hS hq Along the said southerly sideline of William Street, South

49 degrees 30 minutes 00 seconds East, 19.30 feet to a point, thence

i)p: «- i *so,_s 5S i

s/s''z South 40 degrees 30 minutes 00 seconds West, 100.84 feet to a point, thence

2)I

^ 1 LEGENDWJMMQZ. \

&A IUJ 5

#

■I

; Jfei V! o

o

North 49 degrees 30 minutes 00 seconds West, 19.36 feet to a point, thence

3)wK

PROJECT BOUNDARY UNE: i!l<OVERHEAD WIRES-------OHW----------North 39 degrees 44 minutes 40 seconds East, 29.82 feet to

a point, thence4)z£ 3' CURB UNE/fin

r 2.9'- DROP CURBNorth 49 degrees 25 minutes 20 seconds West, 0.39 feet to a point, thence

North 41 degrees 10 minutes 35 seconds East, 71.03 feet to the aforesaid southerly sideline of William Street and the POINT AND PLACE OF BEGINNING.

5)O SANITARY MAN HOLE©J- *- tn

<2

§3

FENCE5 6)oGV GAS VALVE

z 0wv WATER VALVE

oa SIGN POST

UGHT POLE

The above described parcel contains 1,984 square feet or 0.046 acres of land.

LJ OZ

in325S

li! ■>ObP32

5SUT1UTT POLEcOjoCONCRETE

ASPHALTto7

0.39’N 49*25’20’’ W

uI z8

GRAPHIC SCALE7 BYDESCRIP VONNo. DATEID 10 20 40D

BOUNDARY & UTILITY SURVEYOF( IN FEET )

1 inch " 10 ft1034 WILLIAM STREET

ACCOUNT NUMBER 9-1420 ON TAX MAPS OF32i'« o o

or cmmI WOOD FENCE *y 1.0' NORTH WOOD FENCE

/ 1.1' NORTHZ NEW JERSEYUNION COUNTYCITY OF ELIZABETHt PREPARED FOR

A written waiver and direction not to set comer markers has been obtained from the ultimate user pursuant to P.L 2003, c.14 (N.J.S.A. 45:8-36.3) and N.J.A.C. 13:40—5.2(d).

JUUO CUCULLU19.36’

N 49'30’00” W 01ONESP/ 870 POMPTON AVENUE. SUITE B1 CEDAR GROVE. NJ 07009

TEL (973) 857-3319 ■ FAX (973) 857-3608 www.PRONESTI.comSNJ ORTVlCtJZ OF AU7HORtZAT}M: 24GA23072100

DRAWN BY:G. R. PRONESH

DATE:GEORGE R. PR0NEST1, P*LS.03-26-2019

PROFESSIONAL LAND SURVEYOR NJ UC. No. 16202

CHECKED BY: M. PRONESH

SCALE:r-io’ SURVEYING, INC.

JOB No. PROFESSIONAL LAND SURVEYORSSHEET 1 OF 1© PRONESH SURVEYING, INC. 53751