86
5x5 Presentations

5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

Your logo here

5x5 Presentations

Page 2: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

Your logo here

CSE

Page 3: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

Your logo here

3

Page 4: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

Your logo here

4

Page 5: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

Your logo here

5

Page 6: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

Your logo here

6

Page 7: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

Your logo here

7

Page 8: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

Your logo here

CICV

Page 9: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

Your logo here

9

Page 10: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

Your logo here

10

Page 11: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

Your logo here

11

Page 12: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

Your logo here

12

Page 13: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

Your logo here

13

Page 14: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

Your logo here

Q & A

Page 15: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

Your logo here

MREA

Page 16: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

Your logo here

16

Page 17: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

Your logo here

17

Page 18: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

Your logo here

18

Page 19: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

Your logo here

19

Page 20: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

Your logo here

20

Page 21: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

Your logo here

Cook County

Page 22: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

Cook County Community Solar Project

Deborah Stone, Chief Sustainability Officer

Establish models for community solar and ways to eliminate barriers to

implementation

Page 23: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

What have you accomplished that might serve as a model to others?

• Capacity maps/analysis• Costing tool• Valuation• Stakeholder participation• Case Studies – to come

Insert a pic or graphic

0

500

1000

1500

2000Capacity >100…Capacity >25 kW…

1

3

0

4

6

5

5

0

8

4

2

8

8

3

7

1

8

5

7

9

6

1

6

9

1

8

22

6

7

8 1

9

3

61

7

1

7

1 1

($4,000.00)

($2,000.00)

$0.00

$2,000.00

$4,000.00

$6,000.00

$8,000.00

$10,000.00

Cumulative Cash Flow: Subscriber

Page 24: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

Lessons Learned

• Right partners at the right time!

• Unique utility markets• Unique policy

frameworks• Importance of equity• Stakeholder

participation• Great stories

Page 25: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

What did you learn from your fellow SMPers that you really put to use?

We solicited technical support and workshop participation to inform the development of of our Value Proposition Analysis

Involved Groups: Smart Electric Power Alliance, Pace Energy and Climate Center, National Renewable Energy Laboratory, Sacramento Municipal Utility District, Regulatory Assistance Project, National Community Solar Partnership, AND MORE

Page 26: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

What do you want the world to know about your project?

Community solar spreads benefits to all, regardless of income. #CookCounty pilots to show how #smpathways https://www.cookcountyil.gov/service/solar-energy

Page 27: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

Your logo here

Q & A

Page 28: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

Your logo here

Extensible/CSVP

Page 29: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

The Community Solar Value Project

•Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms

•Focused on utility-led community solar programs, using a variety of project ownership options and program innovations

•5 ways to “Make Community Solar Better,” i.e., strategic design, target marketing, procurement, pricing, & solar triple play

www.communitysolarvalueproject.com

Page 30: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

1. Defined a successful solar business model for community solar that incorporates “solar plus” measures, including demand response and storage. Tools: DR Guide, Storage Guide, Industry Support Networks.

2. Defined a pragmatic process model, including a streamlined approach to the value of solar analysis, as it applies directly to pricing for utility community solar programs.

3. Guide to community solar market research, using market segmentation.

4. Case studies of utility best practices documented in a variety of media and available via our site: www.communitysolarvalueproject.com

Sample CSVP

Accomplishments

Page 31: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

1. The importance of internal stakeholder processes and cross-departmental engagement.

2. The importance of external stakeholder processes, which still require some innovation in the interest of getting to “go.”

3. Don’t be afraid to convene the smartest people you can find to crack tough technical nuts to move project forward.

Lessons Learned

Page 32: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

1. Community solar specific: Fantastic SEPA-sponsored market research; NCSP networks; low/moderate income market innovations; site selection innovations from Cook County

2. Other approaches to lowering grid integration costs and instructive struggles with the value of solar

3. Specific case studies that extend beyond community solar, but build the case for solar as part of a DER portfolio

What We Take From You

Page 33: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

CSVP: not all, but some answers on how to make the 21st C DER utility happen today. Utilities: call us. Policy folk: let’s talk. #smpathways

Short story

Page 34: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

Your logo here

Dominion

Page 35: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

Virginia Solar Pathways Project

Rachel Snead, Project Manager

Project Goals: Statewide utility-administered solar strategy

Utility-administered community solar program

Assessment of Dominion’s solar programs

Technical studies to identify PV integration

Economic study of utility-administered solar

Create a solar workforce development strategy

Project Goals

Core Advisory Team

Page 36: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

Project Accomplishments & 2017 Deliverables

Accomplishments Completed four studies:

Solar Integration Studies I & II by Navigant

Community Solar Study by SEPA Solar Economic Study by NREL

Virginia Solar Deployment Group Led to consensus framework

2017 Deliverables Community Solar Program Design

Virginia Solar Pathways Strategy

Solar Career Pathways Plan

Publication & Dissemination Plan

Public Information Session

Page 37: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

Lessons Learned

Substantial technical information about solar’s potential impact on our grid is critical to developing long-term plans

Benefit of utilizing stakeholder engagement to create a consensus framework to move solar forward in Virginia

Importance of common understanding of energy industry technical & policy framework for project team

Utilize the talents of your core advisory team

SEPA Community Solar

Summary Findings:

Page 38: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

Upcoming Tweets

Dominion will be conducting input sessions to help design our

new Community Solar Program. Help us create a successful

Community Solar Program by joining us at one of our

stakeholder sessions throughout Virginia! #smpathways

Page 39: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

Your logo here

SEPA

Page 40: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

Your logo here

40

Page 41: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

Your logo here

41

Page 42: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

Your logo here

42

Page 43: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

Your logo here

43

Page 44: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

Your logo here

Q & A

Page 45: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

Your logo here

Lunch

Page 46: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

Your logo here

Ecolibrium3

Page 47: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

Your logo here

Ecolibrium3

Page 48: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

Your logo here

Ecolibrium3

Page 49: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

Your logo here

Ecolibrium3

Page 50: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

Your logo here

Ecolibrium3

Page 51: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

Your logo here

Ecolibrium3

Page 52: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

Your logo here

Salt Lake City

Page 53: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

Your logo here

53

Page 54: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

Your logo here

54

Page 55: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

Keeping Pace With Solar Growth:

www.solarsimplified.org

APR 14

Page 56: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

Good technical resources and smart policies have paved the way for solar market growth in Utah

Page 57: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

Your logo here

A Bright Future in Utah: #smpathways team propels Utah to 6th in the nation for installed solar

Page 58: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

Your logo here

Q & A

Page 59: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

Your logo here

CUNY

Page 60: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

Resilient Solar ProjectDaniella Leifer, DG

Ombudsman/Project Manager

https://goo.gl/maps/tQ2KbtaAqko

Insert a pic

Project objective: reduce barriers & costs of Resilient Solar PV for

emergency/resiliency planning in NYC, and leverage results to NYS through

tools & educational resources.

Page 61: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

Tools or approaches others can replicate, or adapt:• NYC Resilient Solar

Roadmap• Solar+Storage Fact

Sheets & Guides (Hardware Guide, Permitting Guide, Retrofit Guide, etc.): https://www.nysolarmap.com/resources/reports/solarplusstorage/

Insert a pic or graphic

Page 62: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

Lessons Learned• Energy storage is cross-

cutting technology –renewable/clean, also backup/emergency, also financial saving tool for real estate mgmt.

• Significant concerns (fire safety, etc.) impacting permitting/codes, little formally established.

Page 63: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

What did you learn from your fellow SMPers that you really put to use?

• Valuable info & lessons learned from Minnesota team Hartley Nature Ctr resilient PV retrofit project.

Page 64: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

What do you want the world to know about your project?

CUNY Smart DG Hub Resilient Solar Project provides roadmap & market barrier solutions that enable rapid scale up of NYC ESS market #smpathways

Page 65: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

Your logo here

San Francisco

Page 66: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

Your logo here

66

Page 67: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

Your logo here

67

Page 68: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

Your logo here

68

Page 69: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

Your logo here

69

Page 70: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

Your logo here

70

Page 71: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

Your logo here

71

Page 72: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

Your logo here

Q & A

Page 73: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

Your logo here

VEIC

Page 74: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

Vermont Solar Pathways

20% of annual electricity

from solar by 2025

Damon LaneLead Analyst, VEIC

Solar array vegetation managed by Prairie Restorations Inc.

0%

5%

10%

15%

20%

25%

30%

35%

2010 2015 2020 2025 2030 2035 2040 2045 2050

Per

cen

t o

f el

ectr

icit

y fr

om

so

lar

Solar growing in Vermont

20% by 2025

Page 75: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

Surprisingly effective project approach

Stakeholder engagement

• Over time create a shared understanding and buy-in (10 meetings)

• Distinct from contentious hearings on specific policy

• Respond to input

Scenario Modeling

• Gets people talking

• Define future states

• Compare to business as usual

and other paths

• Examine issues and impacts,

costs and benefits

Page 76: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

Key finding:

20% solar

electricity & 40%

renewable energy

is achievable &

costs the same as

business as usual

Page 77: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

Other projects taught us

VPR: Remembering the ice storm of January 1998

VT has enviable relationships between utilities, regulators, legislature, advocates

Lars Gange & Mansfield Heliflight

VT has resiliency needs that could be

more prominent in solar planning

Page 78: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

Vermont SMP tweets

•Buy one, get one free: 2x the renewable energy for the same price.

•VT can get 20% of electricity from solar by 2025 with no change total energy spending

•Don’t go solar alone, it’s better plus something! Solar+pollinators, +pasture, +community, +storage, +EV, +heat pump

Page 79: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

Your logo here

Pace/Northeast Solar Coalition

Page 80: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

NORTHEAST

SOLAR

COALITION

Page 81: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar
Page 82: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

ACCOMPLISHMENTS

ME, VT, NH,MA GREEN BANK REPORTS (UCS/MEISTER)

•VALUE OF SOLAR EDUCATION

•INTERCONNECTION STUDY (9 EDCS)

•SET UP WELL TO CARRY ON POST 2017

Page 83: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

January 3rd, 2017

“Small Public Investment In Solar Could Produce Large Benefits For Vermont”

A Union of Concerned Scientists report says $7M of public investments to encourage solar installations would leverage $148M in private sector investments over 15 years.

Page 84: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

LESSON #1

•FOCUS: TRIED NOT TO BE ALL THINGS;

FOCUSED ON “FOUR PILLARS”

•Value of Solar

•Interconnection Policy Harmony

•Permitting Harmony

•Green Banking

Page 85: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

LESSON #2

“Nobody knew health care (solar) could be so

complicated.”(Unknown Author)

Page 86: 5x5 Presentations - us.sustain.org · The Community Solar Value Project •Led by Extensible Energy, w/ expertise of several additional firms •Focused on utility-led community solar

Your logo here

Q & A