180
REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 0351 0 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-Elastic CC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 Prepared by WILLIAM P. RODDEN and EDITH F. FARKAS Aeromechanics Department Aerodynamics and Propulsion Research Laboratory Laboratories Division and HEATHER A. MALCOM Computation and Data Processing Center Prepared for COMMANDER SPACE SYSTEMS DIVISION UNITED STATES AIR FORCE Inglewood, California LABORATORIES DIVISIONS AE I ROSPACUL ( CORPORATION CONTRACT NO. AF 04(695)-169

403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

REPORT NO.

SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I

"0 403 03510

j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development

and Computational Procedure

1 MARCH 1963

Prepared by WILLIAM P. RODDEN and EDITH F. FARKAS

Aeromechanics Department

Aerodynamics and Propulsion Research Laboratory

Laboratories Divisionand

HEATHER A. MALCOM

Computation and Data Processing Center

Prepared for COMMANDER SPACE SYSTEMS DIVISION

UNITED STATES AIR FORCEInglewood, California

LABORATORIES DIVISIONS AE I ROSPACUL ( CORPORATIONCONTRACT NO. AF 04(695)-169

Page 2: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

' € Report No.

SSD-TDR-63-14 TDR-169(3Z30-11 )TN-8

QUASI- STATIC AERO- THERMO- ELASTIC

ANALYSIS: ANALYTICAL DEVELOPMENT

AND COMPUTATIONAL PROCEDURE

Prepared by

William P. Rodden and Edith F. FarkasAeromechanic s Department

Aerodynamics and Propulsion Research LaboratoryLaboratories Division

and

Heather A. MalcomComputation and Data Processing Center

AEROSPACE CORPORATIONEl Segundo, California

Contract No. AF 04(695)-169

1 March 1963

Prepared for

COMMANDER SPACE SYSTEMS DIVISION( UNITED STATES AIR FORCE

Inglewood, California

Page 3: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

ABSTRACT

A collocation formulation is used as the basis for a unified approach to

the various quasi-static aero-thermo-elastic problems. These problems

include rigid and flexible load distributions, divergence, estimation of rigid

and flexible static and dynamic stability derivatives, and the correction of

wind tunnel data measured on flexible models. The formulation utilizes

structural, thermal, and aerodynamic influence coefficients.

The Aerospace IBM 7090 Computer Program No. LD003A provides the

solution to the above problems. The program capacity is fifty collocation

control points and ten values of dynamic pressure.

-ii -

Page 4: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

(

CONTENTS

ABSTRA CT ... .... .... .. . ... .... .. .. .. ... ... .... ...

SYMBOLS .......................................... iv

I. FORMULATION OF PROBLEM ....................... 1

A . Introduction .. ....... .... ................ ... 1B. Sign Convention ............................. 1C. Derivation of Equations ........................ 2D . References ...... ... .................... ... 15

II. GENERAL DESCRIPTION OF INPUT ................... 17

A . U nits . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 17B. Example Problem ............................ 17C. Program Restriction and Options .................. 20

III. DATA DECK SETUP .............................. 22

A. Loading Order .............................. 22B. Input Data Description ......................... 23C. Table of Option Requirements .................... 33D. Example Keypunch Forms ...................... 34

IV. PROGRAM OUTPUT .............................. 43

A. Output for Each Option ........................ 43B. Example Printout ............................ 44

V. PROCESSING INFORMATION ........................ 66

A . Ope ration ... ........... .. .............. ... 66B. Estimated Machine Time ....................... 66C. Machine Components Used ...................... 66

VI. PROGRAM NOTES ............................... 67

A. Subroutines Used .. .......................... 67B. Generalized Tapes ........................... 68

VII. FLOW DIAGRAMS ............................... 69

VIII. SYMBOLIC LISTING .............................. 75

-114

Page 5: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

(-

SYMBOLS

a Element of flexibility matrix

aT Element of thermal influence coefficient matrix

b Reference semichordr

Ch Element of oscillatory aerodynamic influence coefficientmatrix

Chs Element of steady aerodynamic influence coefficient matrix

C Z Aerodynamic rolling moment coefficient

Cm Aerodynamic pitching moment coefficient

CZ Aerodynamic normal force coefficient

C Element of aerodynamic normal force coefficient distributionz matrix

C (e) Element of experimentally determined aerodynamic normalZ force coefficient distribution matrix

c Local chord

c Mean aerodynamic chord

c" Average chord

c• Local spanwise lift coefficient

F Element of force matrix

H Generalized reference deflection

H Reference deflection for initial deflection mode0

h Element of deflection matrix

I Element of unit matrix

K Flexibility matrix normalizing constant

k Refe'e.ace reduced frequencyr(

- iv-

Page 6: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

Rolling moment

M Element of mass matrix; bending moment

Pitching moment

N Reference load factor

n Element of load factor matrix

q Dynamic pressure

q div Divergence dynamic pressure

S Surface reference area

s Surface span measured from root to tip

T Reference temperature; torque

t Element of temperature distribution matrix

V Shear

W Element of aerodynamic weighting matrix

x, y Cartesian coordinates

5z, YCoordinates of aerodynamic center

x° 0Coordinate of pitching moment reference axis

Z Normal force

A( ) Denotes incremental value

e Angle of pitch

X Eigenvalue

Control point location as fraction of local chord

p Atmospheric density

W Frequency

-V-

Page 7: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

Subsc ripts

a Aerodynamic

f Flexible

H, T, N As subscript to CZ, Cm, and Cý, denotes partial differ-entiation with respect to H, T, or N, respectively, e.g.CZH = BCz/8H; as subscript to Cz, merely denotesreference to H, T, or N

Inertial; also used as dummy index, e. g., Ayi denotes

width of ith strip

m Model; moment

0 Initial value

r Rigid

Matrices

[ ] Square

l I Column

L I Row[ F- Inverse

r ]Diagonal

-Vi-

Page 8: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

SECTION I

FORMULATION OF PROBLEM

A. Introduction

The most general numerical formulation that can be made of the various

aeroelastic problems is a collocation formulation expressed in terms of

matrices of structural, inertial, and aerodynamic influence coefficients.

Such a formulation of the flutter problem has been discussed in Ref. 1, and

of the static aeroelastic problems in Ref. Z. The present report reconsiders

the static aeroelastic problems by reviewing the derivations and extending

the computational procedures of Ref. 2 in treating the problems of rigid and

flexible load distributions, divergence, estimation of rigid and flexible static

and dynamic stability derivatives, and correction of wind tunnel data meas-

ured on flexible models.

The basis for the present generalized aero-thermo-elastic analysis is

found in recent advances in both aerodynamic and structural theories. The

aerodynamic developments have proffered aerodynamic influence coefficients

based on a number of theories, covering the entire Mach number range of

current interest. The structural developments have provided structural

and thermal influence coefficients for external and temperature loadings,

respectively, for surfaces of arbitrary aspect ratio. The current state of

the art of aerodynamic and structural influence coefficient analyses is sur-

veyed in Refs. 3 and 4, respectively.

B. Sign Convention

We choose the NASA body stability axis system as our coordinate

system: x forward, y starboard, and z down. Positive loads and deflections

are in the same directions, and positive moments are given by applying the

right-hand rule to the coordinate directions.

-1-

Page 9: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

C. Derivation of Equations

The force distribution IF} acting on a flexible lifting surface or body

arises from two sources: the aerodynamic forces resulting from the attitude

(as specified by the deflection mode 1h.), and the inertial forces resulting

from a distribution of load factor InI. The aerodynamic forces are found

from the weighted (the weighting matrix must be derived from experimental

data on the force changes resulting from changes in attitude; see Refs. 5 and 6)

steady aerodynamic influence coefficients (AICs), and/or a set of experi-

mentally determined control point force coefficients

IFal = (qS/ )[W1[ChsI IhI + qS IC, r} (1)

The use of the experimental force coefficients is generally necessary to

account for the aeroelastic behavior arising from camber and/or wing-body

interference. The inertial forces are found from the mass matrix

JFiI = [M] Inj (2)

The total force distribution therefore becomnes

{FJ = IFJ + JFi] (3a)

: (qS/X)[Wl[Chs lh} + qSIC~zr + [M]1n} (3b)

-2-

Page 10: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

The deflection mode IhI is composed of the initial deflection mode of the

rigid surface JhrI* the thermal distortion mode (which may be considered

to be initially built in) which is found from the incremental temperature dis-

tribution and the matrix of thermal influence coefficients (TICs), and the

deformation mode of the flexible surface {hf I

{hI = JhrI +[arTItI + {hfI (4)

The deformation mode of the flexible surface is found from the total force

distribution and the matrix of structural influence coefficients (SICs)

jhfI = Kaa] fF} (5)

where K is a normalizing factor to the SICs (introduced for convenience in

studying variations in stiffness levels). Combining Eqs. (3b), (4), and (5)

permits the solution for the deformation mode

IhfI = K[A][a] I Fr (6)

where IFrj is the force distribution on the rigid system (again considering

the thermal distortion to be initially built in).

{Fri = (qS/U)[WI[Chs](Ihr} + [aT] t 1) + qS{Cz)} + [Min} (7)

A distinction is made later in the derivation [see discussion precedingEq. (31)] between two sources of the initial deflection mode: that arisingfrom any built-in twist or camber and that arising from the attitude (some-times called the additional deflection mode). The program computes theinitial deflection mode as the sum of these, IhrI = Holhr/Ho} + HNh/Hi, and

both sets of data are required. The distinction is not made at this point

because it is not essential to the derivation.

-3-

Page 11: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

whe re

[Al (fl - (KqS/T)[a][W][Chs])- 1 (8)

The total force distribution is found by returning to Eq. (3b) with Eqs. (4)

and (6)

IFI= [B]IFri (9)

where

[B] = ['j + (KqS/E)[W][Chs][A][a] (10)

For the purpose of structural analysis, it is often convenient to convert the

control point forces into the structural loads of shear, moment and torque at

particular stations. A set of transformation matrices may be defined to

compute

tY-e shear

lVi = [V/FlIFI (11)

the moment

IMI [M/F]{I•t (12)

and the torque

IT1 = [T/FI IFI (13)

-4-

Page 12: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

Each element in the load coefficient matrices is the load at a particular

station due to a unit control point force.

In certain longitudinal problems, it is desirable to adjust the attitude

so that the flexible system sustains a specified total aerodynamic force. If

we denote the specified total by Z, then

1IJ(tFt - [MIlnI)-- Z (14)

and if we extend the definition of {hrl in Eq. (4) to include the change in pitch

attitude, we have

{hr = Ihrol - A61X1 (15)

The substitution of Eqs. (7), (9), and (15) into Eq. (14) leads to the solution

for the incremental pitch angle

Ae = (I/D)(C - Z) (16)

where

C = I]([BJLFro} - [M]{n}) (17)

D (qS/•-)1IJ [B] [W] [Chs]I x } (18)

and

lFroi (qS/•-)[W][Ch] (Ihrol + [aTltI) + qstc )t + [MZtnl (19)

-5-

Page 13: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

The final force distribution in this case follows from Eqs. (7), (9), (15),

and (19)

IFI= [BI Frol- A9(qS/-)[Bl[Wl[ChslJjx} (20)

The final deflection mode follows from Eqs. (4), (5), (15), and (20)

h1= Jhro - AeIx} + K[aIIF} + [aT]1tl (21)

A variation of the foregoing is found in maintaining a constant total force

equal to that given by the rigid condition (without the thermal distortion). In

this case

Z = qS[Ij((1/'-)[W][ChsflhroI + Ic (e)}) (22)

and Eqs. (16), (17), (18), (20), and (l) provide the solution for the final force

distribution and deflection mode.

The possibility of divergence is seen in Eq. (6) as the inverse of the

matrix [A] approaches singularity. The critical values of (Kqs/-) that yield

a singularity are related o the eigenvalues of the matrix, and the divergence

condition is specified by the eigenvalues of the equation

%jhf = [a1w] [WChs lhf} , (23)

where

X F/KSqdi , (24)

from which the divergence dynamic pressure is found

q /div = X/KS (25)

-6-

Page 14: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

Any positive value of qdiv shows a divergence possibility although

usually only the first or second values have any practical significance. The

corresponding eigenvectors of Eq. (23) are the divergence modes.

The foregoing development of the force distribution on the flexible

system provides the basis for estimating aerodynamic stability derivatives.

The aerodynamic coefficients are defined by the follnwing:

CZ = Z/qS (26a)

= (I/qS)LI(IF} - [M]In}) (26b)

Cm = f/qSZ (27a)

- -(l /qsE)[x - xoj(IFI - [M] ni) (27b)

C? = X/qSs (28a)

= (1/qSs)LyJ(IF} - [M]ln.) (?8b)

The center of pressure is found from

( X - = (29a)

= -C m/C z (29b)

y/s = /Z (30a)

= C, /Cz (30b)

-7-

Page 15: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

The force distribution for use in the above equations is found from Eqs. (7)

and (9). To derive the stability derivatives, it is convenient to define a

reference generalized deflection H, a reference temperature change T, and

a reference load factor N. It is further convenient to consider an initial

deflection mode jhr- = Holhr/Ho} where Ho is a reference initial deflection as

distinct from that caused by the attitude change (additional deflection) specified

by H. * These modifications permit Eq. (7) to be rewritten in a more general

form

IFrI: qSC(zcer)r + (I/0)[W] [Chsi (Holhr/SHo

+ Hjh/HI + T[aT1It/TI))+ N[M] n/N1 (31)

The initial coefficients and the stability derivatives are defined by

CZ = CZ + C H+C + C ZNN (32)

C = C + C H + C T + C N (33)m m° mH mT mN

C? = C + CZ H + C• T + C| N (34)o H T N

where CZH, CZT, and CZN are examples of aerodynamic, thermal and

inertial derivatives, respectively. The substitutions of Eqs. (9) and (31)

into Eqs. (26b), (27b), and (28b) and a comparison with the coefficients of

H, T, and N in Eqs. (32) through (34) yields the following. The initial

SSee footnote, p. 3.

-8-

Page 16: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

()

coefficients are

Cz L I][B] fCzr (35)0

Cm = -(l/Z)Lx - xoJ[BI GCz r (36)

C,= (l/s)LYJ[B I Czr (37)

where

ICZr I = I + (Ho/) WI[Ch]1h/H° (38)

rl Zr | F[l[hsihr(8

The aerodynamic stability derivatives are

Czs = L II [B] CzHr} (39)

CH -(/)L x - XJ[B] CzHr (40)

m H

CH= ( /s)LyJL[B]CzHrI (41)

where

jCzHr = (1/-)[W][Chs jh/H 1 (42)

The thermal derivatives are

SCZT =IJ[B]ICzTI (43)

(T

Page 17: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

)

Cm -(l/-c-) x - XoJ[B]ICzTI (44)

CT =(1/s)L yI [B]I CZTI (45)

where

ICZTI = (1/U)[W] [Ch.] [aTI It/TI (46)

Finally, the inertial derivatives are

CZ L I] I CzNI (47)

zN

C m -(1/ / -7 " x 0ICzNI (48)

C1N = (1/s)L y I ICzNI (49)

where

ICZNI = (K/Z[W] [Chs [Al [a] [M] In/NI (50)

The center of pressure for each of these loadings is found from Eqs. (29b)

and (30b) using the appropriate coefficients or derivatives.

The rigid aerodynamic stability derivatives may be estimated from

Eqs. (39) through (42) by taking [B] = [ Ij (i. e. , q = 0). Equations (39)

through (42) may also be used to estimate dynamic stability derivatives by

using the (complex) oscillatory AICs which are defined by

IFI = pw b2bS[WI[Ch]IhI (51)

-10-

Page 18: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

IBy comparing chis detinition to the steady definition of Eq. (1), we see it is

only necessary to replace [Ch.] by 2k(r (s/S)[Ch] and to permit {h/H} to

become complex in order to make all of the preceding development applicable

to the oscillatory case. Since this is a significant feature of the present

analysis, we digress to illustrate the calculation in some detail. We choose

as an example the estimation of the symmetrical longitudinal stability deriv-

atives. We begin with the general expressions for the lift and moment coef-

ficients for transient longitudinal motion.

C z C z a + CD (&z/2V) + Cz (6z-/2V)a ZDa q

+ CZD(ala-I4V ) +CZ (Dql /4V) +. (52)

C =C a + C (a+/2V) + C ( +9(/ZV)mm m ma mDa q

SC +4V)+C (-k C14V 2) (53)DD a mDq

If we truncate the series at the points shown in Eqs. (5Z-) and (53), and con-

sider the case of harmonic pitching (8 = a) with amplitude ao, then

Cm = aoCma + ik(CmDa +mq) -k(mDZ -a) (5

S~-11-

Page 19: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

where the reduced frequency k = uZ/MV. In the case of harmonic plunging

(0 = 0, a = h/V) with amplitude ho, then

Cz =ho0(2 /)[likCZ - kCZDa ik3 CZDa (56)- ~- ik56)z

C = hol/r) ikCma kZ C D ik 3 C mDZa (57)

The lift and moment coefficients can also be found from Eqs. (39), (40), and

(42) by making the substitutions noted above (i. e. , B] [ IJ, and replacing

[Chs] by 2k(ZrS/S)[ChI).

Cz = HIIfJlCzHrI (58)

Cm - H(l/-c)Lx - x J I'CzHrI (59)

where

1CZHrl = -kr(s/S)[WI[Ch]lh/Hj (60)

To appraise the various longitudinal derivatives it is necessary to evaluate

Eqs. (58) through (60) for both motions, pitching and plunging. For pitching

about station x1 , the reference deflection is taken as H = a0 , and the addi-

tional deflection mode is Ih/H}= IxI - xj; for plunging, the reference deflec-

tion is H = h0, and the additional deflection mode is [h/Hl= III. The

computational sequence is now evident. The evaluation of Eqs. (58) and (59)

for the plunging motion yields two complex numbers which, when identifie4

with the real and imaginary parts of Eqs. (56) and (57), lead to the four

derivatives CZD), CmDa, CZDZ , and CmDZa (assuming, of course, that

the static stability derivatives CZ and Cma ha,.z hdready been determined).

i -it-

Page 20: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

A similar evaluation of Eqs. (58) and (59) for the pitching motion yields

another set of two complex numbers which, when identified with the real and

imaginary parts of Eqs. (54) and (55), and with appropriate utilization of

the angle of attack derivatives determfned previously, lead to the remaining

derivatives CZq, Cnmq, CZDq, and CmDq. In a similar manner, many of

the lateral-directional dynamic stability derivatives can be found from

oscillatory AICs.

Our treatment of the stability derivatives provides a means of estimating

a dimensionless spanwise load distribution and the spanwise variation of the

chordwise center of pressure on a lifting surface. This calculation requires

the data on which the AICs are based, i. e., the location and number of th&

chordwise control points, and the widths of the strips into which the surface

has been divided. The load distribution coeffl ients are needed to make these

calculations. The flexible load distribution coefficients are given by

ICZf =[B]IlC , (61)

where JCz} denotes any of the various distributions for the different loads

except for the inertial loads; i.e. , .CzJ can be taken to represent any of

JCzr1 _ICzHr1' or ICzTj; in the inertial case, ICZN1 is used directly, i. e.,

IeCf1= JCzNI. The elements of ICzf, are listed in order for each surface

strip as derived in the AICs and can be used to find the local dimensionless

loading and center of pressure. Let us denote the sum of the load coefficients

on the ith strip by

AC Z cf (6Z)

1 strip i

and the moment about the leading edge by

ACm E .Czf (63)i stripi

-13-

Page 21: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

where t is the dimensionless chordwise location of each control point aft of

the leading edge. Then the spanwise loading on the ith strip is given by

(cIcl/)i = -AC z.(sl/Ay) (64)1

where Ayi is the load strip width. The local center of pressure is given by

Ai= Cm./ACz. (65)

1 1

The problem of reducingwind tunnel data is our last consideration. The

purpose of a wind tunnel test is the measurement of the so-called rigid loads

on the configuration (unless the model is specifically designed for aeroelastic

measurements). But since no model is completely rigid, some aeroelastic

correction can be made to any wind tunnel measurement. We now consider

this correction. The situation is described by Eq. (61), which may be

written as

C~zf BmI Czr(66)

where {C~e)l is the set of force coefficients measured on the flexible model,

[Bm] is the aeroelastic amplification matrix based on the model properties

from Eq. (10), and IC () is the set of desired force coefficients on the rigid

configuration. Obviously the rigid force coefficients follow from the inverse

of Eq. (66)

czr = [Bm]I - Z1)f (67)

The rigid force coefficients so determined then provide the starting point for

the aeroelastic analysis of the prototype.

-14-

Page 22: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

I

S(

D. References

I. W. P. Rodden. "A Matrix Approach to Flutter Analysis." Institute

of the Aeronautical Sciences Fairchild Fund Paper No. FF-23, May 1958.

2. W. P. Rodden, E. F. Farkas, and F. C. Slack. "Quasi-Steady

Aero-Thermo-Elastic Analysis: Analytical Development and Procedure for

the IBM 7090 Computer. " Norair Division, Northrop Corporation, Report

NOR-61-58, 14 April 1961.

3. W. P. Rodden and J. D. Revell. "The Status of Unsteady

Aerodynamic Influence Coefficients. " Institute of the Aerospace Sciences

Fairchild Fund Paper No. FF-33, January 1962.

4. R. H. Gallagher, I. Rattinger, and J. S. Archer. "A Correlation

Study of Methods of Matrix Structural Analysis. " Structures and Materials

Panel, Advisory Group for Aeronautical Research and Development, NATO,

Report to the 14th Meeting, 6 July 1962.

5. J. D. Revell and W. P. Rodden. "A Rational Method for Utilizing

Experimental Aerodynamic Data in Flutter Analyses Through the Use of

Aerodynamic Influence Coefficient Matrices. " North American Aviation, Inc. ,

Report NA-59-867, 30 January 1959.

6. W. P. Rodden. "An Empirical Weighting Matrix for Use with

Aerodynamic Influence Coefficients in Aeroelastic Analyses. " Norair

Division, Northrop Corporation, Report NOR-59-320, 1 April 1959.

7. R. L. Bisplinghdff, H. Ashley, and R. L. Halfman. Aeroelasticity.

Reading: Addison-Wesley Publishing Company, Inc., 1955.

8. W. P. Rodden, C. H. Hodson, and J. D. Revell. "Subsonic and

Sonic Aerodynamic Influence Coefficients from Unsteady Lifting Surface

Theory." North American Aviation, Inc., Report NA-57-1104, 25 October 1957.

-15-

Page 23: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

X

• - - I-c- X' I•! - Mc . •oPITCH AXIS- - -1 - 2 35%YELASTnI Ais - -I - Ye10

ROLL AXIS

Fig. 1. Jet transport wing geometry.

S~-16-

75M em

Page 24: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

SECTION II

GENERAL DESCRIPTION OF INPUT

A. Units

All units are taken in the pound-inch system with two exceptions: the

surface area is in square feet, and the dynamic pressure is in pounds per

square foot.

B. Example Problem

We consider the static aeroelastic analysis of the five strip wing whose

geometry is shown in Fig. 1. This is the jet transport wing analyzed by

Bisplinghoff, Ashley, and Halfman throughout Ref. 7. We will use the follow-

ing program options: trimmed loads with the structural loads suboption, di-

vergence, aerodynamic stability derivatives (due to angle of attack), and

inertial derivatives (due to symmetrical load factor). We proceed to assemble

the data required as input to the program when it is to perform these options.

The flexibility, mass, and aerodynamic influence coefficient matrices (all size

10 X 10) are printed in the program output example (pp. 45 through 48) and

need not be shown here. The flexibility and mass matrices are taken from

Ref. 1; the aerodynamic influence coefficients are developed from the subsonic

lifting surface method of Ref. 8 at a Mach number of zero. We shall list only

the additional data needed for the representative options. A basic list of con-

stants can be used for all of the options and is given below:

c = 225 inches

K = 1.0X 10-7

S = 564. 236 square feet

Z = -41,919 pounds (this is the lift on one wing required in level flightneglecting any tail load or fuselage lift, and taking one-half thefuselage weight as 17, 400 pounds)

H =1.0

-17-

Page 25: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

T =0

N =1.0

s = 500 inches

x ;00

H 00

For the loads option we make the following assumptions: the aircraft is

to be trimmed at three values of dynamic pressure: q = 400, 800, and 1200

psf; the aerodynamic matrix needs no experimental correction (the weighting

matrix is taken as unity); no lift has been derived experimentally (lCze"il=10;,

size 10 1); there is no initial deflection mode (Ihr/Hol = 101, size 10 X

the additional deflection mode corresponds to zero angle of attack (lh/H} = 101,

size 10 X 1); and the symmetrical load factor distribution matrix is a unit

column (0n/Nj = III, size 10 X 1). The control point chordwise coordinate

matrix for use in the trim analysis is

20. 25'-81.00

17. 85-71.40

15.80IxI -63. ZO (inches)

13. 30-53. ZO

11.05-44.20

measured from the (unswept) 35 percent chord line as shown in Fig. 1. The

final data necessary to compute the structural loads are the shear, moment,

and torque coefficient matrices. Considering only the loads at the side of the

fuselage, we have

[V/F] = jI], size 1 X 10,

[M/F] = [45 45 141 141 223 223 323 323 413 413J,

[T/F] = [-20. 25 +81.00 -17.85 +71.40 -15.80 +63.20 -13. 30 +53.20 -11.05

+44. Z0].

-18-

Page 26: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

I

The divergence option may be run simultaneously with the loads option

since it requires only a pc~rtion of the above information. We request two

divergence modes and dynamic pressures to be found.

The aerodynamic derive*•ves options will be carried out for the rigid

case (q = 0) in addition to the previous list of dynamic pressures. The addi-

tional deflection mode ih/Hj used in the aerodynamic stability derivatives will

be based on a one-radian angle of attack mode and is found from

-0. 353431.41371

-0. 311541.24616

Sh/HI = -{x/57. 2961 = -0. 27576 per degrec)1. 10304

-0. 232130.92851

-0.192860. 77143,

The calculation of the load distribution and the rolling moment coefficientrequires the following additional data shown in Fig. 1: the spanwise coordinate

matrix

Lyl = 190 90 186 186 268 268 368 368 458 458] (inches),

and the width of each strip and the dimensionless chcrdwise location of each

control point on the strip.

Strip No. AY gf a1 93 0.25 0.752 89 0.25 0.753 91 0.25 0.754 95 0.25 0.755 87 0.25 0.,5

-19-

Page 27: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

It is possible to perform all or any selected number of program options

with one input deck if all data are real, although, in the example problem

taking jh/HI = 101 in the loads option does not permit calculation of the aero-

dynamic stability derivatives and taking q = 0 in the stability derivative op-

tion (to find derivatives for a rigid system) is not compatible with the trimmed

loads option which requires q > 0. To avoid computing irrelevant results, we

use two data decks, reproducing the cards (data) in the first deck that can be

used as a part of the second deck.

C. Program Restrictions and Options

1. Maximum matrix size is 50 X 50.

2. Maximum number of dynamic pressures per deck is 10.

3. Provision has been made to reserve a partition in the upper left-

hand corner of the total AIC matrix for control points (and the flexibility and

mass matrices must be compatible with this order of control points) whose )aerodynamic forces may be neglected or found from an alternate theory to

that used for the primary control points. This partition is termed the "external

store" region since external stores are an example of a source of additional

control points requiring such special consideration. The maximum number of

control points that can be reserved for external stores is 49.

4. Maximuni number of modes to be evaluated for the divergence op-

tion is 25.

5. For real and complex derivative calculations, the maximum number

of strips is 20; the maximum number of control points per strip is 10.

6. Multiple options may be performed with one deck except for the

following restrictions:

a. The structural loads option must be used as a suboption to the

other loads options.

-20-

Page 28: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

b. In any one input deck, all data must be for steady case (real)

options or all data must be for oscillatory case (complex) options.

c. The divergence option cannot be used in the complex case.

7. Only one matrix of associated aerodynamic influence coefficients

may be included in any one deck. When external stores are present, the

matrix includes the AICs for the stores; however, this area may be set to

zero.

8. In the oscillatory case, the following data must be input in complex

form: AIC matrix, temperature .mode, experimental forces, initial deflection

mode, additional deflection modes, and load factor mode.

9. Program options and significant equation numbers as assigned in

Part C, Section I are listed below.

a. Loads for constant root angle of attack; Eqs. (31) and (9).

b. Loads for trimmed condition; Eqs. (31) and (20).

c. Loads for constant lift coefficient; Eqs. (22), (31), and (20).

d. Divergence, Eq. (23).

e. Initial coefficients; Eqs. (35) through (37).

f. Aerodynamic stability derivatives; Eqs. (39) through (41).

g. Thermal derivatives; Eqs. (43) through (45).

h. Inertial derivatives; Eqs. (47) through (49).

i. Experimental data reduction; Eq. (67).

j. Structural loads; Eqs. (11) through (13).

-21-

Page 29: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

SECTION III

DATA DECK SETUP

A. Loading Order

Data decks are loaded behind column binary deck LD003A. There are

nineteen items that can be used in the data deck. The deck is set up with the

items entered in the following order:

1. Heading card

2. Data deck control card

3. Constants cards

4. Dynamic pressure card(s)

5. Flexibility matrix

6. Aerodynamic matrix /

7. Weighting matrix

8. Thermal matrix

9. Temperature mode

10. Experimental force column

11. Initial deflection mode

12. Additional deflection mode

13. Mass matrix

14. Load factor column

15. Chordwise coordinates

16. Spanwise coordinates

17. Strip widths and control point locations (percent chord)

-22-

Page 30: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

18. Load coefficient matrices (shear, moment, torque)

19. Second and successive "additional deflection mode" columns

Items 1, 2, 3, and 6 must be present in all data decks; the presence (or

absence) of the other items is determined by the option and data indicators

used in the data deck control card (Item 2).

B. Input Data Description

1. The heading card may contain any alphanumeric characters desired

in Columns 2 through 80. It is normally used for job title, engineer's name,

and data.

2. Data deck control card (FORMAT 1814): This card specifies which

options are to be performed and also indicates the presence of certain data.

The eighteen fields of this card are used as follows:

Field 1. Column 4 contains a 1 if load option I (LOADS FOR

CONSTANT ROOT ANGLE OF ATTACK) is to be

performed; it contains a zero or blank if not to be

performed.

Field 2. Column 8 contains a 1 if load option 2 (LOADS FOR

TRIMMED CONDITION) is to be performed, a zero

or blank if not.

Field 3. Column 12 contains a I if load option 3 (LOADS FOR

CONSTANT LIFT COEFFICIENT) is to be performed,

a zero or blank if not.

Field 4. Column 16 contains the number of modes (25

maximum) of the DIVERGENCE option to be

performed, a zero or blank if not.

Field 5. Column 20 contains a I if the INITIAL COEFFICIENTS

option is to be performed, a zero or blank if not.

-23-

Page 31: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

Field 6. Columns 23 and 24 contain the number of solutions

for AERODYNAMIC STABILITY DERIVATIVES

desired. This option permits varying the "additional

deflection mode" jh/Hi when the other data are

unchanged. The first mode is included as Data Item

12, and the second and successive modes are

included as Data Item(s) 19.

Field 7. Column 28 contains a 1 if the problem is complex, a

zero or blank if all data are real.

Field 8. Column 32 contains a I if the THERMAL STABILITY

DERIVATIVES option is to be performed, a zero or

blank if not.

Field 9. Column 36 contains a 1 if the INERTIAL DERIVA-

TIVES option is to be performed, a zero or blank

if not.

Field 10. Column 40 contains a 1 if a weighting matrix is

included in the data deck, a zero or blank if excluded.

Field 11. Column 44 contains a 1 if a thermal matrix and

associated temperature mode are included in the

data deck, a zero or blank if excluded.

Field 12. Column 48 contains a 1 if an experimental force

column matrix is included in the data deck, a zero or

blank if exluded.

Field 13. Columns 51 and 52 contain the number of elements

(control points) reserved for external stores, a zero

or blank if none is reserved.

Field 14. Columns 55 and 56 contain the number of dynamic

pressures (10 maximum) for which cycling options

(repeated for each "q") are to be performed.

-24-

Page 32: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

Field 15. Column 60 contains a 1 if the EXPERIMENTAL

DATA REDUCTION option is to be performed, azero or blank if not.

Field 16. Column 64 contains a 1 if the STRUCTURAL LOADS

option is to be performed, a zero or blank if not.

Field 17. Columns 67 and 68 indicate the order of the system

contained in the data deck (50 maximum).

Field 18. Column 7Z contains a 1 if the flexibility matrix is

present in the data deck, a zero or blank if absent.

In the subsequent description of input data we find it convenient to

refer to above fields 1, Z, 3-, 4, 5, 6, 8, 9, 15, and 16 as Options identified

by the respective field numbers. The other fields contain control numbers

and will be referred to as Item Z, Field (respective number).

3. Constants cards (FORMAT 6E12.8): The two constants cards

contain the items listed in the following order:

a. CBAR: mean aerodynamic chord

b. FLEXK: flexibility matrix normalizing constant (or scaling

factor); when the matrix has not been normalized FLEXK = 1.0

c. CAPS: surface reference area

d. CAPZ: vertical force

e. CAPH: generalized reference deflection

f. CAPT: reference temperature change

g. CAPN: reference load factor

h. SMALS: surface span measured from root to tip

i. CAPXO: coordinate pitching moment reference axis

Sj. CAPHO: reference deflection for initial deflection mode

--25-

Page 33: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

4. Dynamic pressures (FORMAT 6EI2. 8): If six or fewer dynamic

pressures are liste', one card is used; seven through 10 pressures require

two cards. The q card(s) are not required when performing Option 4(divergence) above, but unless Item 2, Field 14 is zero or blank, the q's

must be input and must agree with the number in this field.

5. The flexibility matrix [a] is input if its presence has been indicated

in the data deck control card (Item 2, Field 18). If not included as input, a

rigid case is assumed ([a] = [0]). The following card order and formats

must be used when the matrix is input.

a. Control card (FORMAT 1814)

Field 1. Columns 3 and 4 contain m, the number of rows in

the matrix (< 50).

Field 2. This field is not used; it may be left blank.

Field 3. Column 12 contains IFORM; if IFORM = 1, thematrix elements are to be input using FORTRAN

FORMAT 6EI2. 8; if IFORM = 0, the elements will

be input using column binary format.

Field 4. Column 16 contains IROW; if IROW = I, the matrixelements are input by row; if IROW = 0, the elements

are input by column.

b. Matrix elements (use format specified above)

If IFORM = I, and IROW = 1: use FORMAT 6EI2. 8 and input

the matrix element by row; each new row starts on a new card (line).

I If IFORM = 1, and IROW = 0: use FORMAT 6EI2. 8 and inputthe elements by column with each new column beginning on a new card.

If IFORM = 0, IROW must = 0: the. matrix elements are input

using column binary format. This format should be used only if the data are

available as punched-card output from appropriate computer programs. Theelements must be punched by columns; Column 1 starts in Origin I and

Column 2 starts in Location (1 + m). A TRA card must end the deck. (This

transfer card has a 7 and a 9 punch in Column 1, Columns 2 through 72 areblank, and Columns 73 through 80 will contain the characters used foridentifying and sequencing the deck.)

-26.

Page 34: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

6. The aerodynamic matrix [Ch] is always present in the data deck.

It consists of two parts if external stores have been reserved in Item 2,

Field 13, and it is real (steady case) unless indicated as complex (oscillatory

case) in Item 2, Field 7. The [Ch] matrix must be entered as follows with

this exception: Items a and b (below) will be omitted when no external stores

are reserved:

a. Control card for store[ Ch] (FORMAT 1814)

Field 1. Columns 3 and 4 contain m, number of control

points reserved for external stores (S.49); m = 0

will direct the program to set the store [Ch] to

zero.

Field 2. This field is not used, it may be left blank.

Field 3. Column 12 contain IFORM as defined in Item 5a.

Field 4. Column 16 contains IROW as defined in Item 5a.

b. Store matrix elements (format specified in Fields 3 and 4,

above control card): Omit this input if mn = 0 is used in the control card.

When the external stores [ Ch] matrix is input, use the format in the manner

described in Item 5b. If the matrix elements are complex numbers

(oscillatory case) consider the matrix size as m X 2m (imaginary parts of

the elements form the even-numbered columns) and input as though all

elements were real numbers.

c. 1/kr card (FORMAT 6E12. 8): The reference reduced velocity

card is always present. For the steady case, it may be blank or contain any

number, but for the oscillatory case it must be the 1/kr associated with the

aerodynamic matrix.

d. Control card for surface [Ch] matrix (FORMAT 1814)

Field 1. Columns 3 and 4 contain m, the number of controlpoints on the surface. ( m = size of system minus

number of store control point.)

-27-

Page 35: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

Field 2. Columns 7 and 8 contain L, the number of strips

(partitions) in the surface. L = 1 for a full

(unpartitioned) matrix.

Field 3. Column 12 contains IFORM as previously defined.

Field 4. Column 16 contains IROW as previously defined.

e. The input listed below must be repeated for each partition

(i = 1, L).

(1) Partition size (FORMAT 1814)

Field 1. Columns 3 and 4 contain n, the number of control

points on strip i (size of partition i). If L = 1,

n = total number of control points on the surface.

(2) Matrix elements in partition i (format specified in

control card, Item 6d).

When the matrix is for the steady case the elements in each partition are

input in the same manner as the elements in the [a] matrix (Item 5b). In

the oscillatory case, the elements are entered in the same manner as

described for the stores oscillatory [Chi matrix (Item 6b).

Note: Punched cards output from IBM programs based on the sources listed

below may be used (with no alterations) for Items 6c, 6d, and 6e when the

theory is appropriate to the problem. Punched cards output from the pro-

gram based on slender-body theory may be used for Items 6a and 6b if the

first card (1/k r) is removed from the deck. The list shown is complete only

at this writing; additional compatible sources are currently under development.

W. P. Rodden, E. F. Farkas, H. Malcom, and A. M. Kliszewski.

"Aerodynamic Influence Coefficients from Incompressible Strip Theory:

Analytical Development and Computational Procedure." Aerospace Corp.

Report No. TDR-169(3230-11)TN-5, 3 September 1962.

-28-

Page 36: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

S(

W. P. Rodden, E. F. Farkas, H. Malcom, and A. M. Kliszewski."Aerodynamic Influence Coefficients from Supersonic Strip Theory:

Analytical Development and Computational Procedure." Aerospace Corp.

Report No. TDR-169(3230-11)TN-I, 1 August 1962.

W. P. Rodden, E. F. Farkas, H. Malcom, and A. M. Kliszewski.

"Aerodynamic Influence Coefficients from Piston Theory: Analytical

Development and Computational Procedure." Aerospace Corp. Report

No. TDR-169(3230-l1)TN-2, 15 August 1962.

W. P. Rodden, E. F. Farkas, and G. Y. Takata. "Aerodynamic

Influence Coefficients from Slender-Body Theory: Analytical Development

and Computational Procedure." Aerospace Corp. Report No.

TDR-169(3230-11)TN-6, 31 October 1962.

7. Weighting matrix: The weighting matrix [W] is input if its

presence has been indicated in Item 2, Field 10. The matrix is entered

with formats identical to those given for the [Ch] matrix (Item 6a, b, c, d, e)

with three exceptions: (1) the I/kr card (Item 6c) is omitted; (Z) in

repeating Item 6a if m = 0 the program will use a unit matrix for the store

[W]; and (3) the matrix is always real. It is not required that [ChI and [W]

be input with the same format in the same data deck; i.e., one may be in

column binary while the other uses FORTRAN format, and one may be

partitioned while the other is a full matrix.

8. Thermal influence coefficients matrix: The thermal matrix [aTI

is input when Item 2, Field 11 notes its presence. The matrix is required

input for Option 8. The formats for entering [aTI are the same as those

used for the flexibility matrix: Items 5a and 5b.

9. Temperature distribution column (FORMAT 6E12. 8): The temper-

ature mode It/Tj always accompanies the above thermal matrix. For

steady cases (real AICs), the It/TI matrix is entered as one column, six

elements per card. For oscillatory cases (complex AICs), the mode is

complex with the imaginary part considered as a second column; tabulate by

( column with the second column starting a new card.

-29-

Page 37: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

)

10. Experimental force column (FORMAT 6E12. 8): The experimental

force column {Czr)r is input only if its presence has been indicated by Item 2,

Field 12. The column (real or complex) is entered in the same manner as

the column in Item 9.

11. Initial deflection mode (FORMAT 6E12. 8): The initial deflection

mode 1hr/Hol, must be present to perform Option(s) 1, 2, 3, and/or 5.

Again refer to Item 9 for entering the column (real or complex). If all

elements in the column are zero, a sufficient number of blank cards may

be used.

12. Additional deflection mode (FORMAT 6E12. 8): The additional

deflection jh/HI must be included for Option(s) 1, 2, 3, and/or 6. See

Items 9 and 11 for inputing this column (real or complex).

13. Mass matrix: The mass matrix [M] must be in the data deck

when performing Option(s) 1, 2, 3, and/or 9. The matrix is input as follows:

a. Control card 1 (FORMAT 1814): Field 1 must contain NRC,

order of the matrix (same as Item 2, Field 17).

b. Control card(s) 2 through 7 (FORMAT 1814): Field I and

consecutive fields in control card Z and successive control cards contain in

order LL1, LH1, LL, LH, ... ,LL NRC, LH NRC. LL. is the row

number where the first nonzero element appears in column i; LHi is the

row number where the last nonzero element appears in column i. If only

one nonzero element is in column i, its row number must be used for both

LL. and LH..1 1

c. Elements in [M] matrix (FORMAT 6EI2.8): The elements are

entered by column as shown below. Each column starts on a new line (card).

Column 1: elements LL1 through LH1

Column 2: elements LL2 through LH2

Column NRC: elements LLNRC through LHNRC

-30-

Page 38: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

Any zero elements between LLi and LHi must be entered or their respective

fields left blank. If all elements ina column are zero, then at least one

element must be entered as zero (a blank card may be used); LLi and LH.

for this zero element must appear in the above control cards.

14. Load factor column (FORMAT 6E12.8): The load factor column

In/NJ is included if [M] is used (Option(s) 1, 2, 3, and/or 9). If no

correction is desired, input a unit column. The column is real for steady

cases and complex for oscillatory cases. (See Item 9 for column input.)

15. Chordwise coordinates (FORMAT 6E12.8): The control point

coordinate matrix fxJ or {xJ is input for Option(s) 2, 3, 5, 6, 8, 9, and/or

15. The matrix is entered only once (six elements per card) for any combi-

nation of the above options.

16. Spanwise coordinates (FORMAT 6E12. 8): A spanwise control

point coordinate matrix tyJ must be used with Option(s) 5, 6, 8, 9, and/or

15. The elements in LyJ are the control point distances from the roll axis.

17. Strip widths and control point locations (percent chord): The strip

widths Ayi and the control point locations gi, j (given as a fraction of the

local chords) are required for Option(s) 5, 6, 8, 9, and/or 15. These data

have the following input format.

a. Control card(s) (FORMAT 1814)

Field 1. This field must contain NSTRP = number of surface

strips (maximum of 20 for above options). Do not

include external stores as strips.

Field 2. Field 2 and successive fields contain NCPT. = numberI

of control points (L< 10) on strip i. (i = 1, NSTRP)

b. Ayi and 9i,j (j = 1, NCPTi) (FORMAT 6E12.8): These data

are entered by strips; each strip requires one line (card) when NCPT < 5 and

two cards when NCPT > 5. Start with the first card for strip 1 and input the

data as follows:

Field 1. Ayl: width of strip 1.

-31-

Page 39: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

Field 2. 1f: location of first control point for strip 1.

Field 3. 2: location of second control point for strip 1.

Field (NCPT1 + 1). 91NCPTI: location of last control pointfor strip 1. (If NCPT > 5, then •16 would be in

Field 1, second card).

Repeat the above for each strip

18. Transformation matrices for structural loads: The shear, moment,

and torque matrices, [V/Fl, [M/F], and [T/F], are input only if Option 16

is selected in conjunction with Option(s) 1, 2, or 3. The elements in any

specific row of each matrix are the loads at a particular station due to a

unit control point force.

The matrices are input in the order in which they are listed (above

pp. ) with each using the same format (similar to the mass matrix but input

by rows instead of columns). The format for [V/F] is given below; the same

format is used for [M/F] dnd [T/F].

a. Control card 1 (FORMAT 1814): Field I contains NVMT, the

number of rows in [V/F]. Note the matrix size is (NVMT X NRC), where

NRC agrees with Item 2, Field 17 and NVMT < 20.

b. Control card(s) 2 through 7 (FORM.AT 1814): Field 1 and

consecutive fields of these cards contain LOW1 , LHIGH 1 , LOW2 , LHIGH.,

... I LOWNVMT, LHIGHNVMT. LOWi is the column number of the first

nonzero element in row i, and LHIGH. is the column number of the last

nonzero element in row i. (i = 1, NVMT)

c. Elements of [V/F] (FORMAT 6E12.8): The elements are

entered by row in the same manner as the columns in [M]. (Item 13c).

Page 40: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

¶19. Second and successive "additional deflection mode" columns

(FOR MAT 6E12. 8): It is possible to vary the additional deflection modal column

Sh/HI to obtain two or more solutions for real or complex aerodynamic

stability derivatives. Use the input format given for Item 9 (or IZ) repeating

the format for each new column.

C. Table of Option Requirements

To aid the program user in data deck setup, the following table shows

which of the above described 19 data items are required to make up a data

deck for any option.

DATA ITEM

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19

1 P P P P P P OO O O P P P P A AA A

2 P p P P P P O OO O P P P P P AA -A

z3 P P P P P P OO O O P P P P P AA -A

S4 P P P A P P O A A A A A A A A A A A AS5 P P P P 0 P 0 A A 0 P A A A. P P P A A

06 "P P P P 0 P 0 A A A A P A A P P P A 0

8 P P PP O P O P P A A A A A P P P A A

9 P P P P O P 0 A A A A A P P P P P A A

15 P P P P P P 0 A A P A A A A P P P A A

16 - Set up for option (1, 2, or 3) being performed A P A

P = must be present; A = must be absent; 0 = optional inclusion;

-= present when Option 16 is used with Option 1, 2, or 3.

Note: The above table applies to options performed singly with the exception

of Option 16 which must be used concurrently with Option 1, Z, or 3. Where

multiple options are to be performed with one data deck and an item must be

present for one of the options and absent for another, that item must be in-

cluded in the data deck. Also any data item indicated as present in the con-

trol card (Item 2) must be included in the deck, even though it may not be used

in the particular option(s) chosen.

-33-

Page 41: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

D. Example Keypunch Forms

Example keypunch forms are given on the following pages. Columns 73

through 80 are reserved for data deck identification and sequencing. Only

the cards with sequencing are used in the two data decks set up for the exam-

ple problem; the lines with Columns 73 through 80 left blank are for descrip-

tion of input.

-34-

Page 42: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

on I I* in0 0 1 o 0 ey 2

1 0 *0 t:in it'

01 0al 2x I

00

81 1 1w Iuz

ccw

ab 0 iR

04 It'R S a

w

-5-

04fn -A-N ov 0 ai-D N- -In+ rl mnfn 0-- W-

cc1.- 14

0

0-- 0

InIn +a Fn 2cc 0G6

w

j

IL

in 0 0- o

X cy

0

......... . . .....

+

-35-

Page 43: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

0 1

0 0

1 3

7j")

-36-L

Page 44: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

Ix 9

a ft

I -0

ft-c 0 - - - -0 -y 0- -0 AyW 0 0 r

- - - - - -37-

Page 45: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

I~~ ol I N ' - m

1 0

a 0 0- ei

Vr I

0 - ) N .

1W)F T W W

cm 0 0- 0 0 IVP 0 W 0)

0W W 0 0 W

O" to 0 _U N - 1W)

-38-

Page 46: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

30 1

10 1a+

If

0 __

v aIr -18 i

S Nq0 1

+a

3-39

Page 47: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

3I o

0 2_

1 N

2 01

3q 0 0 P

at fffmitN 0 0 I

A IR

-40-

Page 48: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

ty in I 1 0 0 e4 in0 1 1 0- 0 1 1 0 40

1! 1 oil 1 0 v

T0

3121

0 0

040

w+00+

It

it

12In

j 40.9 N CY

0 0+ +

04

0

al o 0

6 z 0

0

a N CY N+ + It

0 0 0 0 0 0 0 aj 0 0 0 0 0 0 si

+ + + +

ccr-4 CY

co a In ALA 40 to IV P.

I o 0 0 0 0 0 Ao 0 0 0 0 0 a

ror C4

M-4 in4n

cyW 0 CY-j V CY N 44 N

+ +0 00 0

a. + +

W CYJIL - I" m2

0 cyx fn

in ty

Page 49: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

iC Iaa AI

AH

- -U

U1

4 111A4

V4 0 .5 -

Va a -

a 0 1

2-42

Page 50: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

SECTION IV

PROGRAM OUTPUT

A. Output for Each Option

In addition to all input data, the following is printed for each option.

1. Option 1 (for each dynamic pressure)

a. Deformation mode

b. Total deflection mode

c. Final aerodynamic force distribution

d. Total force distribution

2. Option 2 (for each dynamic pressure)

a. Incremental pitch angle

b. Deformation mode

c. Total deflection mode

d. Final aerodynamic force distribution

e. Total force distribution

3. Option 3 (for each dynamic pressure)

a. Aerodynamic lift

b. Incremental pitch angle

c. Deformation mode

d. Total deflection mode

e. Final aerodynamic force distribution

f. Total force distribution

-43-

Page 51: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

4. Option 4 (divergence)

a. For each mode: mode number, eigenvalue, divergence

pressure, and number of iterations

b. Divergence modes (eigenvectors)

c. Check eigenvalues

d. Check eigenvectors

5. Options 5, 6, 7, 8, and 9 (for each dynamic pressure)

a. Distributed force coefficients

b. Aerodynamic normal force, pitching moment, and rolling

moment coefficients

c. Total chordwise center of pressure

d. Total spanwise center of pressure

e. For each strip: spanwise loading and local center of pressure.

6. Option 15 (for each dynamic pressure)

a. Corrected experimental force coefficients

b. Aerodynamic normal force, pitching moment, and

rolling moment coefficients

c. Total chordwise center of pressure

d. Total spanwise center of pressure

e. For each strip: spanwise loading and local center of pressure.

7. Option 16 (for each dynamic pressure)

a. All data listed under the associated option (1,2, or 3).

b. Shear, moment, and torque at load stations.

B. Example Printout

The printout for the example problem is shown on th. following pages.

Some of the results shown may be compared with similar calculations presented

in Ref. 7.

-44-

Page 52: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

.00000000000

1L0~ ~~~ 0 V0N I LI0,N. aM0 00M&&&-.OQN4Q

* LU 0 *****0400 m

w V. *" %1 1( ,-

.Va. ~~~ 0 C 00f. 0 00 0N-t00

a- U. m000 w4 0.4 N N

000000.00000.

0-.~C 0 KONU4F&.P-0 O.E0 a

0o 0. 0 0P-N-a.0U 0 00 &4 N. 0 C00. 0 9 ,- 0. 0 0000000000

00% ItL 00N.m -N N -.1 4M 4 44g

-- 0 *0 O o o o o 0 F- ooe 0&Aooo

0 0 0 0

4000.00.0.0000 0.000.0.000.000

x ýr-L 0 - -N 0 XN400m4-d.O000

- j N P- P-.O-im0 m W -j 4 P- m WN N m mf

4. 0* ** * 0* **0* .Lu U K 0 0 000 0000000000;8 C 4 C00 a, 0

AI VIUN & 0

z 4u4n 49N io 0 ... MO0o0o00oo0 0.OOOOOOOOOOIA W - U'r 0 Ciez t -. 0 0 m w LULUwLUwLUUww wwwwwwwwww0f -l U 0 01 &~ 0 .00 .00.0.&0.0 00=000.0000

-0~* . '4A~ UO0OMQ0C0Cr00 000.000.0QOO1 0 0 w LU z UMOMOu'~l.0U zOO0QOo0%0ooO

. ON Ni z J 20 N m W% f- m P I0 211 0.0fMO MMLA 0000 de CL4 . = -4Um ~~VN 0N W m " Pf ~0 0Ar- 0 a, - f-.t.-4A-q 0 ~ ryN4N .JNONNNO.4O

LU." NZ.-:-0 m 'N~~ tu0 % c0uooo =ýrN4N.LI 0 - W fn p .0-'0 0 UNN0.0NNI14W14Wcy gO .90 C;OO C; * 00 0 *

1. P '- 2 0

l- 1- 00o44 1w LU. 0 NM0NMM er4MMM ~ 0I4444,

-a a, tO.0.INN NOOOOOOOOOO W000000000003 0 CPUULULWU WLUWLUUWL-6.

0 00 (P 4.0a- 0 0 cý0 0 000.ocp oo0. &00ý00000..00z I Kz CP w c 00.0.000..000 CIO00.000. CO 00

0.4-0I -N W N r- -r xO0.0.ON0.0N00. Z0.000000.0 00 ~ oz op 0. 40 1-0 Q - &N N 0.-m9-N Z.4-0 O.N 0"m -i oLAm ? N ýN 0u 0 0 N t- -1 4 M 0 N4u0 ~N'0 N f-4

o LU 040NN0MUNMOO Ot40U4 r 00WN 1N.4r-

O an 0

00

1.- 0-0 0w w ww w LUW WLUWU WwLUW UlULUwWLUI i LU 0.0 0.0000 .o 00.00000.000

I a .QUQMO000.00 0 (P .0.a,0 Qa .0 000. ~-Z0QUW0.0NuiPrj ZOtpt000.0.00K -0 eg0. 0 Z -s-4 WU60.NOU'a %N X 0 0Mf-0 -0 -4 6%LUj -- L. U. M r4~-a - Ln 0rF- NW0 m r- N 0 m0 4 0 r-.1 W 04 LU LUJ .J- 4m p-p-N 4 -r ,ON ' i- .J'N4m-mPO0 00.O

0 4 W e 0 u r- m N N a0 0ont u L0 I W(. 0 Q 4N "Io N 0 W 0 -0 .4 PO N -1.NNN W N -1 O ."o...4 m min

ccN 0 0 0 0 o . 0 0 0 0 00f 0 0;

LU 0j 0

m r%%1 ý0NM4 0 4 M 7-

-45-

Page 53: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

-*Coooco e cc 0

w) w)uj w wj

9 NY0ON r 0 eyoa 0 .t0 ry'r 0,0 '0 0

It 4 -d~d .0~ a

M tC-4 a00 CA

UAOOOOOOOCO00

4U & uJWUJ -ujW 0N 4Wee NeUOON Co~lof- 0.

Z004Qtap0N0 -J U0iS0 r- It 4 0 0 0Dg (

*ý M 0* *. w *4 0 N * .j000 .0,000n0%W00 000000

I

zU1 0 -i0.Ow 0 0.. 4.0 N0 0 .. -

LA. PW0 CP 4 p N 0. Q.UNO.4~N0

0 ~ ~~~~ 0NI~--' f.

.JjO~0 N N ~ ~ ooa m ..F 000 & j asLU 0.47, 0 r-.01 0 -0C t - O N o x( 0 g.

U.

u Lw wWWWWWWWw wwwwwuw wtww I- w-m 04 IfSIfS.50.tU. 0U. 0NcOw ON x a-

4 -Z IfN P-N a ZN 0 -'fS- a 0 awrr - 2 uZ z A0P N Ký -0 r- p-P-P z -ý- - LU z 0P

)..~~ aM-L't0.4S ~U.N - in 4 V0 U. 3 Z U

0 U 7~. :0 0 .4 OO0 -sON0 0 - 0 CP

pd00N 0. ~0 0-40-0--ý--ýN0000000000 U0000000000 NY 0

1111111 B B1,BBI 1 oilLUwLUwwwwUww www w wwLwWUUL Lu0 r--'N M 0 0 n0.0U.O. t- r- 0 - W0. -0

Z S-D M00~~~i~ m ~. P-' w @ 404(1 z aOct -r lt 6r~. 0U. 0,0 r- W% 0 U-i K &

O04N0 N mý 0IA.40oUNU'0 0

.0000000000 10000000000 00000I IBIBII I I LI BI II .I I I

WWWLAWWLU W !U LAwjj U#IJ LU

ZUI.OmmW.mw-.NN 2OS.CU.UNNNZZr 20zOOr-4wW4#N,- X0004*r-miinu Ku

m m m 0 0 =ro Uf-00.Q N4 4 00 .0 ý )%

0000000..to O 00?O*00*0000900

.4e5,sAB- a0. 0 4N m 4 0 41- a U.0 .4N m In4 P-0 . 0

-46-.

Page 54: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

CCi

II

0 0

o 0

0~z 00

U 0

U.

zw

m f" tnQr D4 4C " ar 000 m 5 K

8K0a.

U 0 -0

* * * * * * * * *-47-

Page 55: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

In 00

0A0

0 0 0Z

K 000 z

0 -0 04r

Li Li

0000000000

* 0 0r 00. e

00 z f 0 0 0

z zr ou .

r.. a ý r-w 4 .. a 0 PC 4C0 -- D0 . 00 -0%a ý04 P U

0000000000 000000000

0 2ww wU z

00 00,

000000cc

0 in 11 U. 0 0 0 0 '

.400 00 00 0 00

'U 00 0 00 0 (P

r'J0 0ý 00 00 0 0 0 0

ccJ 1.10

uoo loo

M,#54 0 00.am d m o r o

Li-4-48i

Page 56: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

0000000000

a-0ý 0 a-.) .0% ý

Nýo 0Q P a, 0. N N 04

N C P. -n fn f, Or-nt0M* It 1 -. . 1 * ý t

0000000000

-49-

Page 57: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

tu wU LU

0' 0 0%

00 ey0 e

m0 0 c

z Q. z z0 z zC

oy 0 0 t

LU L U lU u LU L

0. a, 0 0 M'20 Z z0 z 20z Z cz a P x go x g 0 g.j0 m ~ i m j -J M .I-i f"00 0cr ON0 0 Om 0

o1 0 u0 r u-

1. 4. IL

z 0 0-0 wt0 00 M40 P00

0 LU) LU LU LW LU z L uz 0 0 o. 0ý

z' o.ip z m 0 z 00 zL) O.,20r ZM 20 ZO 2' zo.=o 4 o. Do a, go. M gp0o.=Ml

LL j . 1o 0o U. - 4 1 L o c -00'o 0 ' 0.4 0Wt 0- 04

* 0 X . .u( 0 0 - 0 0 - 0 0

0- 4-

uj - - N ML a N Nx CY 0~ w 0 N0 cc 0 Y0 co0

Z 0 U 0' LU 0j 0 w0- 7 ZO Z. a 2 20 M EU 0

M M. o 0 0 - 0 a'u m goag. - o go -a o o.

3c a, o. . 0 z 0 U. (Y. zM. 00' 0M w 4 04 LU 0

U 04 000 0 0 0"

A4

w . g N 4V4 N N0 .4O .40 0. NO0 O

LU LU LU LU LU LUM 0, 0 0 0' 0

m. 0' 0 0 0 0

20'w &0 0 0 20

00 0 04 NN 00 Od~4* 4p 0 0 in u* o Qi

w0 0 a0 4 q 0% w 0- w

.4 - N IO-sN-

Page 58: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

0 2

p- Q 0 Uý 0 . 0 *%A0P. 0 N 4

u. ~ 00.t m r- 1-. 0Th 040.0N4 -Co .** e* *A . .* * . . 9U . 6 . .

0000000000 LI0000000000-j I i l I I4 0

I- U.

00

z 0 4-o 0

-j 01- 0 I U0 0

- w 0 Z9

o 0 0 0

cx 0 4 m- 49

LU 09 L

N 2 . 0 0 4 00 4j~UL Z -o 0 O0P 4O ' -M6

I- a 0 .0 (P0Na0I-P "N0 40pLL, 0 ý- P. 4 4-ý0NNp # .0mo 04m4a

4 p- N 0 III 4 amX w 'o N0 Z 1--0W 0w40C-p

o. m -.4 m0 0U 0% M 2 LU0M WU.0 00 0 0 O400004 LU 0

UC - U z01L

o i0 0 - IU I.-

0U 0 . . i N4N4N4M frIS

a.. LU j4-0 A 4~. a-N k0n-dGU-C .ie Co.~.ed4~%l0P LI -f"4Q a-0- 40 . f

I- ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ f InS U N D .S~N .MS ?.U.~~~~ ~p 4 O N - ,. . m 44l0~

- ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ L kn~0d.C~ %JNA..~N~

Page 59: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

00

0000 - 00 000PO0000-

I- C-~NO4 em or-rN 0u-N N

10 N NIAn 0w P.dfN a M IAI 0 NQfN -a Q

4M 400 0 0,N 6 -9-, U.

0 9-wA 0,0r-6 (P0 b.- N m 4 0 4 Or 0 M00 -4 0 .4

2 00 0

0 0A0 2 z

o 0 .

0 6Wj 0

0 0 ~~-M 0 04 0

%A 0 M~9 4 919 C 0 0440 W 0 c- 2U. CC -c z 0 LZ

0~4 LI4 Z0

O K 0 0 -4 09-rv' Y y'

0 000000000o0 .- 0000000000

p4 W 0 NIa 4 P 4 W M mQl r- . N M N f--. 0 m . G LI.o4 m4 6% 0 A

o 40 I OýlO4it4~ P0*. 00m9--.4 0u w ý4.4010N4DPCPW

0 04;48ý4IA ff04; 9 9 x0 0 0 0 0 00 0

-. o cc ILOOOOO 0000000000£0. il uj g III 1111 I III1 II Ia 0

14 0 0 0 002 w w wIs W .J a.N m4I Na 0 0 4 N~t4 z -6 C 6 0

49 * U. i a-90

o 0 0

-52-

Page 60: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

IW(z

wwwiwwwwW W WW WUW UW WNI-M6% 4- ýw0 1 -N 1- 0 w mN I- IN ' .- M N - 4MN- N N No

mN U~ O .O F- in Q eS0

.Jog~ " 4O -40PrgfN

4;I 1 ; 8131 8 I 8 Iw ;1 ; ;C44 0

I.- N "' A0Uý P0 1- Nf"rLN1p-M04

2 0 I-

W 0j 0

I- D Z 0

4- uA -

00

UJ 0000 00 00 00 0

W N WNM m Ifa O WN- 0 49- m0I2. 0N0O 0 a OW w4 4ý0 r P

z- -00 a- I- "o . 7LL t-NNVUwQN 0 wm n0f 0 N 4 4%

00 N 0 0 -4 m 47 -a

.4.~ -. 88 00 0 0 40008 008.9 0 .1 - 4

U, .4 NLa LM P. 00 .U 4 C3 C 0 0

u 0- * r

m K u 0 0cc 4 4A

0~~~~~ 00 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0

"8

N UJ N4N~0-0N0 WNP .053-O

Page 61: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

zLuzLU

IA

-U I-F -a

4LU

I -

z

a 00

in v.*Ij N - m

2 2 161 N LUz

0D L 0 0

p-'o z LU UII

- ~4 I KLUw0 0 N

0 w.4- 0 U 00- 49 d U -

LU LUWu UU UU jw Ui i U UU UWU

ggP *r4 Ma 0 co 00 00-' 0 4 P ~0 A in0 o M

o %P jia CC *O InMdS~ co # N-8 kQ0 45 -1 y0o-0 "c 00 C"( 0 0'M6t0 0@ - Ef 0 Ok f" 0. c

4 4 8I 0, 1; 00 C; Jd i0 0 0 0 0

0 00 0NMN00@ 0Nt LU. -00 0 0.4 0@ N

00 0000000000 0000000

0 ~0 00 0i P-4 N LM u E0ww 0 0 l l -0

W &N inALU W WWJ P.W ItLnUmLUWIU42LMULa- UIUL #cm40LU

ZU4Q 1 " naC Z 0 4 z IA I* #O. O.N M 0 WOa 0 N

0 Q# L#.? O N1m1r-OP-O

4*.l 0 00000000e @OOS@O

0% 0 .444 -W t" f #O InN hI P. a 0-S0

-54-

Page 62: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

O ZNO 6%40-0 CM

U.A 0 0 = a- N 0 00 0

090 0.00

.4. x N0f -r0 0 M~.i N M K

0 0- Isl M I- N Z 0* 0 61 *

-r o oo o o O0 00 00 0 0 00 0

~~~~4 0 0 0000 00I p0 L %z( -000000 0 0ýZ 07 0- -, 0t N 0 M - 0

-J0aN- 00.0. o m 0o ~ 000.~.oLLI en 0 w o~mo mfo laooo 0 QUN0e.0@00I0 -4

00 - 04m ' ZON0mO " N UN U ZO A . 01

L -40 &~ 0 0 ~ 0 JA 0' W 0 A- '~~~~~l .. 0 0 1- I 0 ' - NfI I NAA0

I" LUm LU 0 Kn 0000000000 00000000000 0d It 0 0

a 0 0 0- )-w w ww w w~ w w-i tN %I IflI xA 0 0I0- ý .ý o w oR rQa,0r U)- O0fý wO 0fQ OOC CPO 00II M'4444

0 -. LI4 0 w~ N u Z- -0t rC P0U lv0(o. -e .0 z 0- 0. NW W WU w UJNW mM f-mW 00 z0 . wmmLn.

ac oe CL on 6L = 1- ý 0 N V M -40 0000 w 0 0 p N 0 0 -r--

ui .- -1?ý - fNp-NM0 I a ..wm JNNWMNNyo-OUMz Z LI 0 N Np- LM W I4Uw0 0 -TOIAM0 0 w N - -

- ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ W 0 --w L '0O0 LIN~ N IIS

0 00 49000 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 04 W 0 .0

-- 00) 4'fI% UW LU 0 ~rrlI~~44444

*- -'-4 a- 0' 0t N0000000000 00000000000- - 00. 2 a- c

- 00 0 L3'U LOP' 0 0 -0 0 000a- 0 0a, 0 0 '0 00 (7 O'0 471 0 Id' Wu 0 a.'l0 00 o 0 a00 mc00.00000'00

M) MI~ N20'00Nr- - 1 0 0 &O0ON~~ 0 N M44 IA .N

LI - 0 LU 0MO~NN0IMILA0IA% 0 WU 4 a0 N AN N P

K 00 0 @.I1 1 1 *I* *I

2 WN 0-- 0

0 NNMNIMM0

-9 f" r -IM00OOOO0'-0000000000LM 0

LUA 000.'0'0 0 C-cý0000m a0 a 00 00 Qý000I 4 0, 0 0'u O*0 0 0 0 0. 0 g- QOQ0 00 m0 0

z 0d al' K-I-4mwoONWWOIN XZ,00m0- 00 -4 WA mLU wa? m- 0 U. t'- N

00 1.N 0 M 0 'D.0Int-

-i 00' mU P.-9rI- - N &4 4 ,N 4 .4"0N (" 40 0 -4CO LI4 -r oe Uf NNQ00knw w0 0m0 LJOIAM4'0'4 N -4

0 0LUI

C 0 '-4 -4

LU

Page 63: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

so 0 coo 10 0 0

0; 0IIvo.0U 44w 01ZmfN.CNOmi4c#.t z O

.j OfWN t-0" (A t- 0 0 ry

ucyr"0 000M m 4 00 0 0

09 4; 0 q;4 0C i0 4,, c -c ca c

4. CWW WWW4 W.

w C P. 4 ýo -o40100N 4 o-af *N 40. 0 N 0C 4 f

z 00O3N 4 - 0 4 10 z K 0momrp- #40000 0 = m 0(

ai 0 0ý . 4dN0 0 0.4

00000000opo 00000 0 0000 0 0

IL Ma 00-0N040-W - 00V N00.M40 .4.-4ui z0 0 0 0 0 0nF -i -Na zN0000000000 Q0 to wwwwwuP-p-P-ftwww -ýw wwwww wwwu w

U.~Ma 00 lN4 0N " In4 0 0N G0.

UW t Zy in N -WN U Z0 4,.4 .~0U P MZ 0.z 0 0 0 0 -Ie 0 . 0 .0 V0 04;

w 0000000000 0000000000 0- 0000000000mi I II IIg I i l lIl I 4 .

U.2 050 40.i0. O 8.O.i-440d ~ -

- o El0000000 0 .00w0000000 0 ZI 0

U w w ww WWWWWJ Ww wv www I.- wK 0.0.eQQ0.00% d 00 0 f"0E a0-4 0 0y.

4 ; ZUN r FN . Na ZN 0 -1 %n .o 0 0 W - Z (P2 x 0 0 N - K *0lC'lO0II.-m w K 0'C3 AR0.000#10UIC0.SWr jr.molar-0004m j %p00 0.?OSwoONOqwOO.- 010-0"40 0-oo 0 a-

N0000000000 00000000000 N' 0

0 1--0 Nm 0 4 0 % cy r~- 10 r- a 0 0.InmaWr -0W M0.t~O* I Ký 0 4 " W% f-U A MK F.m

0 0 r- w ~0 4 'a 4 N ?0.50044P0~00" 0 0

0000000000 000000000 0 09001 til ili il 11 1 #1 1

..-- 0 -40 N 0 - 40 0.4040 ".4.4. "."-0000000000 P-0oo0e0oooo 0

zII~omMl6OmQ6-NN Z4 O0.ONNN-SI- gsacooP.....*.,N?- Zap:Q~~v-eW%om-e K= 't l.4 - '0 mwON0.4 0 W% .POQNN@OQ UP

* ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ J 4; 00 4; * 9SSO * * S*C SS

-56-

Page 64: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

m00

F 00

00z ~00

00

0 00 0

0 00

Z 00

& 2U Z. 00K% 00 K

0 oooom0 0 ' 00 N .4 ~ 0

000000000 u 4 0 0000000000e

co 0 wo 00 000000 NOO

a- - 00%2~ 0 z ug

0 r 0 0o- 0z .Jý 0 4a

0 CF. 0 0-4 0

0000000000 x 00 000

0 0 2 00

LU w L

K~f 0 % I IK N

i - a99 ** 999 a 0l

* 0 0 000000000-57-

Page 65: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

00

Li iW0-0

oc7.

pN 14

LUf" LU a- LU00 0 1.a-

0 z .4wuJ W x z00~ 0-

0 %P of a,.4c NNNNNNNNNN 0

*.'.*aa..*42, 0 0 V, *000000000a

LL M *0 @O O ,a %0 .a 040 0 - -L m M~ o-0Z4mo

wu 0000000000 w 0P-. 4WL

00 0000000000 0 0000000000 0

LU LU

00

N 40

0g0

40 t

N r

-58-

Page 66: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

Ci

0

co CI 0 00

000000 0 .

00 0 0 0 0 4 LMoUOOUOU 0 -oo

0044000woj - 0000000 0 4 4 1 1 ' CL 0 0000 1

go It A- Im 4t 0 0

00 Z O0 0 U. I- 000000OIn 40- .0 0 00 0

0 0 000000- NNN 000OO

NN~E 9 U 00000

00 0 00 0 m 2t Ln 4 *g 0 0 0

00000000 0 ~ 00e00

00000000 0 00 00000000 0000000000~J0U0 0 0. -900000

M 1.- 0 W LUWW****99***9_ 0 U' wNfl 00000

4j 0%04I 00P-C P00 000QO

4 00000

o u59-u

Page 67: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

-4i

ILU-u j Uu3 0.

m . ar- N 006

vi U CP . f"CP OLU N 00 0 f -d V

N y k 0

ac 0000

ua LA - 0 00 0 0io 0c LUOOOOO

U. 0All 0>

f- 00i 00000NO w4*~~~ 0 0xAUt0~~ P 00000A

'A 0' 0. It4f I I I I -LU in Nm01 -00 UOOP-.-dIAU

z LU 04 M mct. 4 4 in kn .z MO 4 M.4 z 0 0 000 0

40 w tf mv )P- wA VI *J'

LU U I P N N LUde L6 2i 0

0. LU 4f A 0 'A00 .

- 0 LU * 0

KU U. * L- j 4%.U.4Nf4N U .. 4 -44-

LU 2 .oo oo o LU 0 Z 000000

0.1 N - P N ' P It I 4O .0 U LULWUU 0CSL

'A~ ~ ~~~~~~~~~u %Af4f4' L .tU~4i'A .PP0.0j- ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ % IA . PLIUOO I u 4 P4 ~ ~ M4O-L

I~~~ ~~~~~~~ ZIAfO P - f NL 4 2 WL~L.PW4~~~~~ LU 2fO4fI'4f 2 -APff U IN-4'4

2 . *ff4 IA~fIA .. U~~fI00.i J A0 A4

~ 0 -N-LU4WO'44- 0LU .JfI'Ii.4 04N604..

Page 68: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

II*iii 000

p. 47Nnaa,064 c -4

o 0 40r t t

r4 r . 0 yawF N r

N 01 0000 0ý 1 "N - 0:0 9 0 LUCOO 0 0

LU L LL w L w U Lp.A .-4 in4~ 00 U

CO 0 a u6 1.- N 0Z 0 t0.0t 0 z Nr

*.t c Nu In~i O 16 64A

m N LL .JNNNN.-4- NL 0 >coo ~ ... LU 0 4 000 0 001 0 0 >OO O I 0 0

LUL 0 1 o 0 w ww wlw t

r -0 N6 II LU 6-l I II I -* .. 9MMNZ N, tAC 2C . U .wf A . m..4 u

go w %ýp-P % 0 00 0 ý mn 0. LU mn OltdN 4 44 44 z 0 O O1- -4 -0 N : :r% o,. U 0 .9u1 .N 0 m 2 4 0' 0y ld,- #w

o LU a- -9 u AU. * -U 0 C. e

000 LU 0O ZD 00 0 00 0 LU 0- 0 C0I 0A 88 80 UU 44lll l 0 A

LUW0 U) (A 00 0 w ww ww w

-40N 0OU~4 LU 0r.I0 4 40 Z A

4.N. 0m LU .. O4CU K4I~'.-

000 - L" I. in~O' 0. 0 0 00 00,a I- ZLU F4 In z

N n LU 0 Z LU40 LU Li N Ut6 LU Q

0 Li Cc 0 u LP- LU 0o 0 U

3 w

41 QU 6 0~6

Page 69: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

LUN00

00000 00 0000W0000 0 0 "0000

INI I1. 1 00LU U1 L Uj U LJ 0

0ý m t ey4 Go 10 ( F4a ccCID 4 ý cvý0 rl04V

CC O t 04 GOce M0 0 y Pt LAP- r cv,10 I 0 4 N k

0 0 LU 0

34.4..44. 4.-4 U. cc 0OriO

~~4.04.00 00 * 00uf40PN e. N y IV > 0 .0 N. 044ry ry0000 E~0 wLSw .4 0~0000

> 0 -'r" w a- 4 . 0W w00 z CD >aI fe Ur -N Vm 'tv P2- -0 P00t4w -. N ,O4 p-0 LI

wJ NO Ny N N N r- I- a,.m.0P.wF. u ýV n I"MO- . ~ .i N .0 'ra0r. w M Z" 0 CM . 4.....

LJO OO IN In 0n 00 - j001 -Nc. .uOItOO I0w u A4#.9

40 LO '0

LU LU OL I

u. L 0 i4.0ce ~ ~ ~ 4. 4- 0,0Li

- - - L4 U 4.4j m 0U4U 4 . 0.I. 00 0 00 0 LU IL 0

c% NN ry ii in~ 0 Il 0 w NNnN00000 ~ ~ ~ ~ L AALWJLLWUL 0 0gig i - 0LUO U%0O ii lii

LULUUWLU 0~O''~0~00.r-U 4 W.L00WL

*U~e~N~-r ~. 40L~eoO4. 62U.

Page 70: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

LUU

CL

uu

0 00000 000 w00000 0

uJ LU L- JLUwUJW 0

* 11% ~ C- NN- P .

II~C N P 44U- i 't

r~ - U' jt . N NN NLU 0 4 4 * * 0

If 0 0 u OO OLU0

LU I.- f" 4 -i

I.. -j - U 44 Z ~U. * 0

4 "rr M I i 'IC".t U. 0 I -9 f" It eEIMAM lz 0000000000 Lu 1 0 Z 0000000-> I I I 1 i C 0 CtN N N N N I II gI II

Lu 0 . Iwwww~ I I 00000 0 1Mw LwLww0 e CfN m 4 0 IV 4wowo 10 1 t 0 0 iI gIIg - I-N NOMfI

470.r- 0U'N W N u 4 U WWLU LU w -NtIrPam-1 0 N-.N 0 10 eEm0 f- m ; > 00 ). ýP.-N0 a In m4 f4 I-ý 04.v r04 .-t 0 U4 u 4 N001A0 1.- 0 m l0 .II0- o0r-mgoc0onuow 49 - UN-0I0f0-o

4- LU uI1c-ý0-oaboo z NS A LU -. ON .4

LU 4c .F- I- w j M 0 LU .Jf.4N U 4 Q efP~-P42 -w 1 0 . ; * -t . * t oo j LU U4.0m0V - w . .*

- U. 0000000000 of 4.~l~ = n U.e L i 0000000U. I M*A* IU.LU 49 Ln ' 00000 LU0 LU LU 5LU N I. LUu 0 tL uCi -N m-t O r- 0 0 I II. 0 Ge Nm 0410 -4 LU 0 0LL. N ILe

LU 0 M- a .ij

I- E~L LA0 U;I

0 LU U

0 0 4IAAq S

* U 10

* -63-

Page 71: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

0

CLC

IAU,. 003- .P %- r

0 N0 U -0 0 4 1-

0;0

j0. 0 -on U0 0U

- 01 00 0 0-

wi ur% -wwg 0 & LM v U

o0 f0 't4.-~v *.m m0m0m& r - >.

IA '0 0CY . 0 CY N 9. I I I I I0000 0NtN 0ww w w u0

Ný '0 P- ;u0Nin 0-wr- 4A 4 -( ýf e "W z cND -. 044A,. N -i N.a - 0 0wI nm0C

T- UY WJ N N .9a 4W m' P r- IAt

0 0 LU 4....? .-r 0 n1 j c

I0 0i 00000 #A 0 40'A 0i 1 w t

C- & i LU I- -

W U o I 0 U. LA W%, P-W 1 0U 4 0 U 0- ý N : U -. NI . 4 0U 0 IL *

ULf" ~ U. M MAvIAv4 0% 1-000 LU 0 on m 00 0 00 0 uI

IA I04 a, W UJ WN-LOW

14 1-

9-0- K ~ N~i00- n 'Oo9-Mfr-64-- K

Page 72: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

0000

00 00

0. ujLU1 0w 1 . AN 0% 10 3 0a(U0000 0 a 4 P 0 000

e n N I % c " -fn w'.-0 U' .0 3.0CQ0N

11 0:', ýN n W 0 loc.-0 .ry04 N

--ty N4 ff 14U

.44

f"fi.0 f" N 44.

UO O 00 0 00 0 w 0 0 U000 w 0004

wl~~~~~f I w -01 4- 444 tA a-04C 9 A U jWL

0. aWY N N 0 UN 0i I 4 Wi

0 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ -A* a. 5. !0%.0., w 1u na(ow A0 M a 4t

Z1 -0L 0000000000 w 0f00 I g l g g 0, 0 0 0-40=

coco cj I^WUW A UA 00000WUJ WW S.0 O.OL4' U 4 U W W

U4fym00tn 4fNOON-04. wo -L

.. 4N-6 0U 0 0 WU I.J44

ag '0f- NA. 00 0 00 0 9% m 0 a 4mm

U W ,

z aW-

U 65.

Page 73: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

SECTION V

PROCESSING INFORMATION

A. Operation

FORTRAN II MONITOR system

B. Estimated Machine Time

Because of the number of variables involved such as options, order of

system, number of dynamic pressures, etc. , it is not possible to give a

practical method of estimating machine time. When the data are appropriate,

considerable time may be saved by performing as many options as possible in

one machine pass. Also, complete but independent data decks may be stacked

to save program read-in time.

C. Machine Components Used

About 26,000 core storages

Standard FORTRAN input tape (NTAPEZ)

Standard FORTRAN output print tape (NTAPE3)

Four utility tapes (NTAPE4, NTAPE5, NTAPE6, NTAPE8)

-66-

Page 74: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

SECTION VI

PROGRAM NOTES

A. Subroutines Used

In addition to the main program (page 77) the following subprograms

were used.

1. MPRINT, prints matrix in matrix format (page 91).

2. MMULTD, computes the product [C] of the two matrices [A] and

[B] (page 95).

3. MREAD, reads a matrix in either column binary or FORTRAN

format (page 98).

4. BINRD, reads column binary cards (page 103).

5. RDLN, reads and prints title card (page 113).

6. MNVRSX( computes the inverse of a complex matrix (page 115).

7. INVERS, computes the inverse of a real matrix (page 118).

8. SWEEPX, computes true mode and sweeps it from the related

matrix (page 123).

9. CENTER, computes the aerodynamic coefficients, centers of

pressure, and spanwise loadings (page 128).

10. LOADS, computes the three loads options and the structural loads

suboption (page 133).

11. DERIV, computes the flexible load coefficients used in the derivative

options (page 143).

12. MITER, matrix iteration (page 149).

13. NPNRMX, vector normalization (page 160).

14. DIVERG, divergent pressure calculations (page 165).

-67-

Page 75: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

B. Generalized Tapes

Input, print, and utility tapes in this coding are defined as logical units

2, 3, 5, 6,7, and 8; however, these may be altered by pi" &,g the desired units

on symbolic cards HM030827 through HM030832 in the main program.

-68-

Page 76: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

SECTION VII

FLOW DIAGRAMS

-( -

, -69-

Page 77: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

FLOW DIAGRAM -MAIN PROGRA

TAPE REWINDSTAR DIENSONS QUIALECE CMMO FOMATSDEFNITONSTAPES

NO 98 99 50 10 101 102

50 &O'oYES

VFEIS NCNRC ~ IF >0 IF NONC g CMLE C2 NkNR 6(O READ: 0 -(i -I NO) PRINT: FLEXIBILITY [a][3-1NC= NxNC(N)NQ,Oi PRESENT

107 NO 108 NO 110 CALL NO 112

IF RED IF ES MCALLjE

IF YE RED F ES MRADREAD READ: IF YES[A [] NEXST NXSTN XT>O [A] CIOKR H M,L,IFORM,IROW IFORMzO[

>0 IFRRWNXST x NXST

121 12 235NO &126 &12 NO

NO CALL

STORE [A] IF s [w] [~i READ: IF YES MREAD READ ' _ FNTAPE 5 NEXST)O (NEXST xNEXST) NXST NXST>O [w] M, L, IFORM IFORM=ONXSTx NXST

119 133 137132 NO 136 PRINT

IF CLL CALL CALL THERM)JIF YES CALL THERMAL YE READ MRAD MREAD MMULTD MATRI)

DIVEG DTA MNIORMROWr rTEMPERATNQ: DVEG AT MNFOM IOW{,TlATTITplz[?Jtt/Tj MODE

PRESENT[a]

NO

-70-

Page 78: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

GRAM - MAIN PROGRAM

90

TIT LI :REALTAPE REWIND TITL2:COMPLX CALL RDLN READ: READ: PRINT.

DEFINITIOjNS TAPES MAXR 50 TITLE CARD OPT IONS CARD ,f CONSTANT CARD OPTIONSIMAXQs2O CONSTANTS

101 10( 2 15106

YESIF NO PRINT:

FLXBIIY [a o STORE [a]J READ: CALL MREAD STORE []FLEXIBILITYPRESENILTY NTAPE 4 M, N, IFORM, IROW[a NTAPE 4 MATRIX

NO 112 10 1 2

READ: IF YES READ. READ. PRINT: CALLE[[A[CIFAEONAE4WEIGHTING MUT TR

MLIOM,,IFOR FORM ORM: [A] SIN BIAY [w] IN FORTRAN MATRIX RCOR [ 2][RESENTAP

[w]

1237N 1 34 12 393

17PRINT: 1419 10 PRINT,

CAULL MTERIAL YEF EXPERIMENTAL

TEMPERD ATURIX {ATTIT} -0 C~I RE AD: C FORCEL

{ATTIT}: [a]{t/T} MODE PRESENT f

L!J.1/TJNO

-70-

Page 79: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

FLOW DIAGRAM - MAIN PROGRAI

143 144 147 148 15115

IF NO CALL PRINT: IF NO CALL PRINT:YE S INITIAL YES ADDITIONAL. IF Y

,MREAD DEFLECTION MREAD DEFLECTION MASS READ. M

MODE ,,-I MODE MATRIXNEDE L 0 J{h/H} NEEDED tJ{/} NEEDED

15159IS15 nIS? NO 158

ISNOPRINT: IF PRINT: IF NOPRINT:P

LOAD FACTOR READ: CHORDWISE YE READ: SPANWISE READMODE READj :IR CORDNAE COORDINATES NSTRPNCPT*

{X) Xi,-,,NRC i i 1,,,..C V co •-.-, NSTA

{/J NEEDED {XJ NEEDED {)NT

[so NO ITO

REWIND CALL STORE [( W] [Ch] DO CON:q K43/ IF A: [A] REALNTAPE4, MMULTD AND REWIND 204 [A] CON [A] COMPLEX

NTAPE- Ac [W] [Cwh] [CINTAPE6 + :IN[A] ["m

164 ias no

REA[] CLL: CAL MMLCTD A CN +: STORE IF EV

LJLJ~~TAE NDATA A:WLJ [] ~ ~RED

NO196 197 200 202 YES

PRINT:

IF AYEAS CALL MMULTD CORRECTED CALL CENT~ER READ: REWINDCOMPLEX A FORCE COEFF T'(6) [a] [w] [c TAPES20

.-- e] -' {Cc..zJz, NTAPE6 -

-71-

Page 80: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

RAM -MAIN PROGRAM (CONTINUED)

151 152 153 154

YAS READ:. - READ: C2RADL PMwCA.MUTYAS E E DI IL i. L~ M ASSJ s MASS MATRIX MATRIX {CN i}

MATRIX LEISS

NONOD

164 166

PRINT: PITPANWISE Clio-READ: PRINT: REWIND READ: READ:)RDINATES NSTRP, MOPTi PODINT TE4Ca

i:I, NTPDATA AyE, Zi AY1 , Zi TAPES NTAPE 5 [W]NAP4Ci

fI q STRIP. NCPT, [Ch]

NO rio 172 NO 174 176 177lo

4[ARELCAL.L IF PRINT: IF SOE ACA] a. VRSX MGOOF*O INVERSE IFACOA]+M9PLEX A8 [A] MM[CMPLE NTAPES

COPLEX -1[A ERROR

18919ISO No 190 192

[A]RIN[A PRINT:

STORE [] IF EXPER 'YE TITLE IF [EA] REAL CALL MNVRSX IF YSINVERSE

NTAPE* DAIAE COMLE IS [A] IMAG. [A]-' MSOOF 0 0 ERROR

No

YES No 206 207 N 208 209 NO 210

REWIND IF YEOF DER. OPT YES IF DIVERS. YES EG04 LOADS OPT CALL LOADS CALL DERIV. OPTION CALL DIVE.NTAPE6 0 ND REQUES S REQUESTED REQUESTED

-71-

Page 81: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

FLOW DIAGRAM - LOADS SUBROUTINE

424 a 4211426

DIMENSIONS IF DOIAD: So TOE TITEASTART EQUIVLENCE MUSS 'D 411111 SIVNT Lr-L MU GITSSEACOMMON TAPE$ Loan 1143 EFPICENl

PORINATS OfO143MATRIX

no3

429 431 4126ES 40

IFM]-A PRES TIFLE CALL o E I IFA CALL{cTORQUEL! 40] -LOD 2 CMIJ Z;AZ 003 h.II. UJT

PRESEN - {C ~ al -4 N {D}:[W432N{C}COFFCIN NO am

4572 46 0 462 46

IF ESU IF CALLO CATUNLO(a) YE 47659- LOADS 2 mm-Ul

noN~ l{C) NO NO72 IST

472 4?040-72-

Page 82: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

DRAM -LOADS SUBROUTINE

44426 42? 426434 e2

00 11oEAI PRINT TITLE: [s.9Aatj-[A] PRINT TITLE:6WWT LHSH 0 TO $HEAR MOMENT

L49 1 COEFFICIENT N4VMSB COEFFICIENT

7n4 2 MATRIX NVMT MATRIX

460 45

+b T READ CALL DO{}Su C

412 470

D of CALL DOZZ3CAPZ LOADS 3 %/H. MIUJLTD J4-!I?,:LNj 0

4U40 48344 9

YES YES YES

READ IF TRIN IF TINNIF TURN ONNYAPE 4 LODSI SES LOANS 2 EFE LOADS 3 SENSE 416

a: [uJLIM? I GM?2 USTE UISHT 3

No Nono

-72-

Page 83: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

FLOW DIAGRAM -LOADS SUBROUri

OFF

49490 492

46 OoF I}Q{Ir READ IF ONTURN ON CALL CALLRE554 NTAPE 8 SENSE SENSE MMULTD MMULTDNTP

00I,141 +N{CNIN} A -[A] L1H LI1 D4]F}Af

4968 500 02511 512 514

XFTU R N ON DTh - CA LLZ t LLI~SENSE SES 'IZ FFMULTO LIGHT MMULT

LIGHT LIHT .J Ii2HI 2 4a] f {F} +{H-TX f H4 4

2 2 - T fH)- D

1

X

OFF

LOADS FOR SENSE ON SENSE LOADS FOR LOADS FOR PRINT SENSE ON SENSE PRINT:ROANLIGHT LIGHT TRIMMED Sl LIGHT LIGHT Z, DT

ON 57 OFF 56 ON

CALLT ir CAULL NONT REWIN SENSE F SENSE ON SENSE OF

D-[MMULT {T MMLT PRNT NTAPE 6 LIGHT LIGHT LIGHT

0-TRU L {l L YES 1 2 3

-73-

Page 84: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

)IAGRAM -LOADS SUBROUTINE

492 494 496

CALL CALL CALL FF CALL IlNCIMMMMULTDUT TP MMULTD SENSE M~LTD

{D}. f Fr} IH . [A] {D} A =[0] {F}I [B fF4 IHTo 0-u- {WCHx W. [ 64 E wc~xl

ON

512 514 516 518) 524

{4z K {Hf} SENSE CALL t'H.VK IHIl IF ON TURN ON

LIGHT MMULTO DxJ 1,IH SENSE SENSE

+{}OTX {}O]F JJJ F.{}{CNIN LIGHT LIGHT

L= D[.]OFF"

OFFF

4TN SENSE SENSE t RN: ff.Hl SRCUPITAP S LIGHT LIGHT LIGHT LIH LGT IH

-73-{F

Page 85: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

FLOW DIAGRAM - DERIVATIVES SUBI

NO 23 24 25 26 27IF NO No

DIMENSIONS REIDTPS INITIAL TURN ON AERO TURN ON THRAL TUISTRTEQUIVALENCE TURN OFF COFIINS~ SENSE STABILITY 'U SENSE SAILITY S 91

COMMON SENSE LIGHTS REQSTED LIGHT DERIVATIVES LIGHT DERIVATIVES LFORMATS NX-O REQUESTED REQUESTED

OF 35 38 39 4243OF4 OFF 42

IF TURN ON PRINT TITLE: IF TURN ONPRINT TITLE: IF TURN ON P1SENSE ON SENSE LIGHT 2 AERODYNAMIC SENSE ON SENSE LIGHT 3 THERMAL SNSELIGHT f =STABILITY LIGHT /Dlr~~T* STABILITY LIGHT LIGHT D1

L ONOFF

**OFFjOF45 46 47-

II

READ CALL IF TURN ON EXP I-NX-U NTAPE 5 MMULTD SENSE ON SENSE MENTAL MM

[{W][ChI] £C = [W] [C@ D1 f LIGHT LIGHT FORCE+II COL.UMN I}

1JLJLMJ I I PRESEN

OFF 0

71 53 54 555+

+ 5I -. 0

IF _ FI CALL CALL READIF IF f-, fDICj IF MMULTD MMULTD NTAPE 8

0 N LLJNX{C} [A]{JE} {DI[wJ C~ TRASH

61 62 63 6

IF IFREWIND SENSE OFF SENSE ON NOP(6) IF + SENSE CALTAPES LIGHT LIGHT =NOP(6)-I NOP(6) LIGHT 2 cRA

1 2 ON D 2{h/H}

ON OFF -,0

I -74-

Page 86: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

IRAM - DERIVATIVES SUBROUTINE

24 25 26 27 28 29 so 3

IF NO IF No NoAERO __TURN ON TRAL TURN ON IF TURN ONIF TURN ON PRINT

STABILITY *~SENSE STABILITY SENSE INERTIAL BENS SENSE ONSENSE LIGHT I TITLE:DERVATVES LIGT DRIVTIVS LGHT DERIVATIVE

REQUESTED 2 REQUESTED REUSLisH LIGHT IDj-H, fr/ INITAL2 3 1H COEFFICIENTS

OFF

43 4442

PRINT TITLE: IF TURN ON PRINT TITLE: REDCALL READTHERMAL SENSE ON SENSE INERTIAL RELTADUINAPSTABILITY LIGHT LIGHT DERITV EATIVS, NTAPE 45

"DERIVATIVES 4 4 A'[a] P[ 14]Nlt"t/N,

OFFL

47 4450

O IFO UN O EXPERI- CjCfDO READSENSE MENTAL NTAPE 60 NTAPE RLIGHT FORCE

COLUMN +{'•01 1.•c ,NQ A[.A]I PRESEN A IOL

0

5556 57 70

CALL READ READ CALL CALL YESMNULTD NTPEsNTAPE S MMULTD PRINT: CENTER 6

I [W][WIN{C} TRASH A = [] {o} =[B] {C} q.{D} {D} NO

63 n64 6?

LIGHTE MREAD ADDITIONAL SENSE OF RTRON D2{VH DEFLECTION LIGHT

-74-

Page 87: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

SECTION VIII

SYMBOLIC LISTING

Some of the program FORTRAN symbols are defined below.

FORTRAN Symbols Definitions

A(I,J),B(I,3),C(I,J) Elements of matrix "working" arrays; also elementsof [a], [Chl, and [W]

ATTIT(I,J) Element of column matrix representing the product[aT] It/T}

CIOKR I/kr

CAPH H

CAPHO H0

CAPN N

CAPS S (reference area)

CAPT T

CAPXO x 0CAPZ Z

CBAR z

CNIN(I, J) Element of column matrix representing the product[M]In/Nj

CZRE(I,J) Element of experimental force column matrix

DELY(J) Ayj (width of strip j)

F(I,J) Element of total force distribution column

FA(I, J) Element of final aerodynamic force distributioncolumn

FLEXK K

FMOM(J, K) Element in load coefficient matrix [M/F]

FR(I,J) Element of rigid force distribution column

HADD(I, J) Element of additional deflection mode column

HR(I, J) Element of initial deflection mode column

-75-

Page 88: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

FORTRAN Symbols Definitions

IFORM IFORM = 1 if matrix is in FORTRAN format;= 0 if matrix is in column binary format

IROW IROW = 1 if matrix is input by rows;= 0 if matrix is input by columns

L Number of strips (partitions) in the surfaceaerodynamic matrix

LH(K) Row number of last nonzero element in column k ofmass matrix

LHIGH(J) Column number of last nonzero element in row jof [V/F], [M/F], or [T/F]

LL(k) Row number of first nonzero element in column kof mass matrix

LOW(J) Column number of first nonzero element in row jof [V/F], [M/F],or [T/F]

NCPT(J) Number of control points for strip j

NEXST Number of external stores reserved

NOP(I) Option i, Field i of control card (data Item 2) -NQ Number of dynamic pressures read in

NRC Order of current case

NSTRP Number of surface strips used for derivatives options

NVMT Number of rows in [V/F], [M/F], or [T/F]

Q(I) (ith) dynamic pressure

SHEAR(J,K) Element in load coefficient matrix [V/F]

SMALS s

TCCP Chordwise center of pressure

TORQU(J, K) Element in load coefficient matrix [T/F]

TSCP Spanwise center of pressure

X(I) Element in chordwise coordinate matrix

Y(I) Element in spanwise coordinate matrixZI(IJ) Location of jth control point for strip i

The symbolic listing of the program is shown on the following pages.

-76-

Page 89: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

-l 0

*~ .0 1. PO -O

a, - 4U 4-4 U.~t' "m 9- usOU

Inc * 2.. - 2 0z 0Z m U 0, M. 4- 01 -.. I% ~ 0 4 N 'D N4.; .0 we 'A .

M ; ui0iU. 1. - 24 .W

C; 4a aA A P. 04 -44 0 IL I soo x Z~n - :; - : N .. 0-- .. u W " QN% in woJu 4- -.. 422 2 " Z W% :"I Z N a4 * NN- ~ i r 0 0.. h W4 . .0

00.. - Kz Q.L a 4-s ;. .4 L - xwU.Wz

%A Iua -. . Z4U zn4.. z N .- ZN W

-- 04 0. .4 4 KK2 at. 04i x2 2 -UZ *U N6.. II 1KW

-2 -0.i- N~NI w ow b mw Wo -0204 - 1-l .UU -4 Z N .m -C2, z O U, .M 6l

0w~x Q0 #0 %IIWwlX4*~ 61-.. ii2 nn..- W UU WX

IL4 Z9- r"9 U .. 44 4 1- w ZU-4 aI4 0-.J W00. ;: - 4L L.-- .4 KK C U.%%- U - -=0 a I

in- .0 !A o- - -0 z 3-- O 0-.4 -Z *W " .j 4 z 4-04 4 1 0l a co-i9 NN0NN a KK t - 9 z UJ

I.ZlA -4- -4 1 in-- z aU 4 a I---

-. 0 . JZ4 j. W z z 0 :-L. a A- ý - Z &-. 4A 4c

U.. 0 so N 5;UNZ t4 0^-N O ZU W. 4..4-.*% W Z W X C 4ar0-C Z I- 0 - -- 4* P4 OC U. I-lU- A-4K .J

P4AC -i z 2 .4 . . .4- n . 0..i. .4-U..OX N- Ný l - nZ;ZZU. Ix OWWU.W--In

-i-CI a-.. .9. A-r 2 I @ %%U4W 00.

C a-% oo wu o 0 C .coU. 4W ZmrW40 1.-0 z z ; ;P &- ; NN09 O4244i mgmZNi22222

Qa IL in C- 0ie l - .I O 4 4 ~ * ~N 4 -QK 20C 4- I-4 -~3 -.-. 49 44- 4 449.-x .. 0- 0- W .; 4 40 x!0 0.4a z x-10

0.00.z(I --- -4wN -------0--

0 0 uj_4 - jAt In 4 2196 ---- 1 -. 99I1II

2 z >4494 4 444 ;;444444wj w -. 22 2222 I2 z z2222z x ac ac ccUU l cUc c a a a a

a- - l 000 00000 00000000 0 WL U UU. %, U..LL LU. LL. UL.U.U. U.bLU.IL &

ý4~~~~ ~ ~ ~ -4 -n' n01-C p 4 N4 m 4 It -%

-77-

Page 90: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

cli)

In 0

0 L

a0 Z 0 L

o -ww co-

ce- -x- U)JI

- C4l .OLIf0'O4A aI-in4 - C~ 0 JL

Z-o-NZX WO-i 4

Coe *.Z- Wx LA 10 flr ' .wj" 0czO 6-l

C) l' M'~0 LL4 J CLi C m - I.-NWU.1

41-4r'd . 0-0 - I- CL- .A~2 - -

a u.-.uui 2-IL~ CL .* n

W :a - 0WWX0Lu =0 -I% W =0 00 ij zN rý A Wa 00.1l0Z - w z u.e .4 0

x M z .0 W N Ii -- WU * 0In-0

040. 000 Ouh 4d N

0x~ ~ rx .1 LiiZ

r ( l -4 0 M, ad L

x. I.-.* - UJ U W - t < I-X)()(..-1 OL?..* M. a.i 0 .i 'NIT

el4 N4~C-4 0 W- N M'j 0 .r4Wo.94 t-. I-. 0.- *- 0. 10 -tI' 0-.?

It4 i 11 It 0..00 #14 It Z 7Z In - j

-00. -I-I I- 'a0zt.- N In ItI Om Qaz0 oI nN -

-d -1 < z z z z N000 If IfUi. f- -rX X x x xX 11If11 11 11 1 1C 0.0.0(.0M0. . .. J%.Z 0 -j Q

w c 0 t ( ccý (- 44 44 xz~ A x x Z-j.j4Oorn 0 0 00 ) 0N m4 A0a -0Q I-.l-I-Iý-Il- WWWW L L -- 44 W

'N CL 0. 0.0.%.0. 0.r.- 00 a, ýj -1 N In < .444444 4

.4,.. N N N NI.-I-I-ý- I-' 3'

-78-

Page 91: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

N,a

ax

4Ai z X6

U . IL A. 0

IL 41 49U

aZ0 0 at x

W X 00 CL 2 -z 4

U0-4 2 -Z Uvi O . "i z I0.-

44.U .9 . 0 Cut, A

Uc A- - W 0,; ;; 92 -. .* Z.

0.I ao Z O A ULU4-U~~~ z-O -Z 0- a U

mii~ 2 a a., 9 -0, 0A

ai aU e a aC a. 09 in

g2Z4 * 0 -0 A- 9L ZO. a -k4 wL on 0-m I-aa ~ K a

cm . de. CW !t via0*4 vA5

4 0. 0. LU- a g A

N a .4 CL Na 00 - .. 4a a 0..'

a LU z aLU AL a 4i aIý v eN j a. or IC 0 .- (: -. NI.- . 09-CLU 4 e 01 CLU I- -4Q LU -4 CL W a

a. A- 7. zi.0I a- CL 4c I-- a j 4 z

A .- 44 1.- - 0- zJ a P..a-2x LU LU 0,, =2 .C . .* =a w LU U

a. z 30 - . -.- U L w . A-z i

LU 9L z U w 4y za 0. "0 -.1a K x

4 jC - o x z0 aA . Ul 44 A- -

19 a e I. w 0 0-f *A -- Ag cc.- ce Z ) -L 2 Lj I- ALw a . LL - a- 0 A-w 0 9 A-

Ci A- 0- Z 2 * 3a A .. J. tl f . 4 t . 4 . 9- -C &L va. .4 N 0 U ) a. -- w mm aaa 0a W~ Z

zi 0 0ý a. 2d cliin0 0a..--A.29-a r .- L- U 0 A 2- ~00 aU. -Z wo 00 a -

LU A 2 U .". U X - 99.W LW 0 of

o A- W-N~ g-0 -7LU- -A-0 AA4 0

Page 92: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

10

M MI IA49-Uý8NA #MI4 I'-m0.@NM 4Nm4IA49m-w0m#4IAP-MM..N

000000t0000 0 000000 04040 (lo0 08

IL -419 1- m

mu m 49 M

4 (4 upI- uj Z CL

z z C. Ca

- 4 3 4 z -

z 0 K -

oK to m

U. - 00 0- -K 9c; 0; U $A %A

19 3j .a * 0. aý

V- 0 4.. M Z .4 W ý4#A 09 0 I-K 4946 Ux of -. " 1 -

K 0 -O 4

-4 0 . d -W atI zIA.~~MW &4 6 44 .- N

t . 4 - . W2- 0NN:o f 4%CY IL 0 B It - .44

WW -4 mu Ki 42' 0i W&.. -0 z B & & IL 1 .- 4.44.: * 44 .4 - 4 z. U) N

9,I I .-- of. - - LIL 42. IA 2 Id 4 2 4i of4 .

-4 K If IL z Sj B. NW,: 2 WWL .4 49 w 4 49 I. x I'4BCL. CL SB ."4 - CL.9 -* 44.4 44 .49 ot1 4 9

ow P --4 ~ - .' .4 - z 9- z:z 9 a-9 I- ; &~I UO -0 %2 K N

2 9LI z.4gZd I t vc2 .4 0 CL zB . .04,.mu t.nZ $..0 W. v. W z o -,c w4 U, !41

z 1 2K* A K-~ A f 4zA-4 42z0A1 1- 1-:.. 1- - - 0 .-. I-.Z U -29-K A -. 4Il .*K -- K* N .J -a 0 .4mG -o 0

1-I K-Lm In 10 W WP -a 0W

0rIU WUL4U .W, 44 ON. 04ow U

0 .4 .4 . .4.4.4 "1.4. . N

.4 ..4 .4 . .4 .4. .4. -so-.

Page 93: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

- ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 0 aoeooaoooooOooe00 0000000.

-U A

1. 0a- 4 0

z -

& 4. -jCec

4 WU CL

3 )(Nx(

Sz a.

- 0 4 9 -

o~~~ z i.U.) U di-Li

x 0c - 1. ac 1 49-0 0 Z. ~Z * Of9

LL -r 0. . U .I; 1; 1 0e a.a 0IX C; 0 f"404

2 ~ 0 1 2 2

N .- . .)( X - 0 00.N w j ZK - V14 U L- ).- -n-

- I.- & .- a2 & a. C aI g- 0- .J-1 .I: 'A 4. 4N- 4. 2 Z2 Z. ; -1:

?--I.-x I- 1.-- 1 - - -. aOZ .NIA 0 ~ f Zi .z ZY &A zLu~i 4W, .4 LU M. ui

a.- x az .4x. Lof z.-a i0 - of-u:LU. LA) N!! WJ le -Z 0 M 0. Lu 211

5, 0, " I.-a z.a. I- ; -d Z: o L..Ncc'4N 49 Co .4~ 1.- m4. CL -

-a-' VI a - 1.- - P4I- - P- - .. a..- -=I 1. I - 0 0 i. 9 - : A

t.- o.. 6- 0 -0 10-0 a.Z z LU cc I.- - " -M. *ýW 4 .44 =4 x 4 ).9 0 J0 WL W -L 4 - 01.4- M

IA NJ CLa- *a.w4. + ~ CL Of0 Lu e m4 ui >00 a.CL 4".a4.mx Ln 0- aen I--o- Z2 oa OC. 2 C L XI- Z 0- 0 0 4-ui N - Z 4A - LL X 0 4.'. K K z LUZ z. Zn I-

2- ui 2 0( -9 m4 2 U 4!-Oo . x 0 a 0-i W+-J I..-j .i I.- cc.J 0 X -. 0 0

0 w 4 -1 -24 1.4- < .J ;..j -. 1;- L W $..- w I.9--. 0 ui U.. L-d 0 Li3i Lii ".Li. -C -. 0 40

C= NN N N NY N M.4. ILA. M4 U. m.4. m m

Li P4 4 - -

Page 94: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

I0

in c n#i aita4p 4o#ipr opowr n#m, -aa 4m w -waota 40 tm~ o.cp

ME 11111 zz!z~zlzzzxzzzzzl

CLa. z 20 . w49 x * -m z IL0- 14 of~ N 49 4 -2- z N - C.L- L

-L L 4 z cc. 2CM IL X I. z

W4 4 .9 Li4 . 4 Z 2~ OZ N-IL K I- Z -I N I

I.- ow Ge .4 u - - W N 4 -2-K - m 0 a. 0 LD. m ~ i.

K 4 I. N 4 0 It .40 X 2

WK in i-4 N4 u .- m -Cc ac a I- 2 U W . -

K4.4w - 0 M W f- 0 Z4-4. -- 1 N -a -U 1 -0 o

2K2L -1 -2 Z NJ IL 2.C;4g - - a. ~~ '.J - . K - 0 K 4

- 4 i 0. I I.- I. I--*U 0-

U.O~~i' a. -L . 4 K- In a . * I..- .I- 4; 0- N * UN2. . 0 -

P: .4 4; y .4 go 0 - w4 . 0 .-Z 0 .- z 4L ~ - -- 4 0 -o

9- .; 1n 0 0- . U.L- U .40K- .A Q W aN w Z4- ~ a.4 .j M a.41. tj1 0 U WNKa- K& &0 a. aM & 02 -CZ.4 IL I 02I -C

Wu .- 4Z41'1 4 .4.Aj 4 - 4 -9 L - 1 .9 -4 O0 IL49Q 49a.9L 0~- 1.- .4 P- 1.- 0 1.in-i - Rn ol.-0 I.-1I- 1 N.0i- 0t4ZZcZ z -~z 2 Lif42e2~z Zzli42 2 2224

2 a. M"4wW WU WU 4; ZW aW W; 0W2 aw 2; W- z aW U ;u,;

a. ;; a -0 ain &i.. -- P-N-.I in Lai4 1-.41.-

0.. $n -. S- .JZ I-- I - ZI I-

= 44.11.- ;,- 0n- i- 4 5 t - mi41n 0- Q.4 1.- 4 .i I -.- z - 4 ?-1n--.4

ZWW4KLO&.Oa.41 we. 00.040 .JM.I&0#00 ýa.04.0.4-KKKc Z 0 .4 202 0 490 a0 - 1.-0 i20

Wi WZW w -Z WZW W 2ZW ZW W -2W 2W0 .J.4 .- J 0- -Ji--0I. 0- W-. In- 1-. n0 0- 1n--.4 .i-0 P- 0 P- _-4 -P.04..ja4I-..J-. .1-- W .-A- i-0 4- 4 -iW444w4wi.~w 0.inL44U0404 ZLU.44I4.4 4 U. w LLme0

K..LUM.IOM -"20i-.303R "NO~-liWl W 0

4 .0 0- .4 N 0114 A4 4 4 P.0 014w M4 4 .M4 4 4*# # 4 w 44

- - 4 -44.4 1 .i W.4 - .4 .4 -. -

-82-

Page 95: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

10

-4 0~ 888 (~NC.NNIN CYJNM mm am mm m

- 00 cocoa coao 001o0ocoo

- Z-

*z U

W ~ - -YzmJ01 W9 IL

-4~ z-- - 0It -

49 1N 49 1 'P: 419 ; 4 I * '

o~~. N -Z . - .oY 39 1 -- --0 1: on 0 -af I4 - .'L - -g

I. z O ZK 0 Z .~- u .- K; -0 * -C- .4 -i . 0 . , 9L - P. CL - W ,;-- z a VId K4 f- 0-.4, A

Z Z LiU 2 .-

CL ul 0. .z -a 0C C LC LCL- ki -ý - Z W -9 LL .- 9 9 9L.W -4-

I. u a.&I- z0* 1.- 1- .- I-L a. - I---z -z . 4 -9 z0 -Q- n -9 - Az.z+0- 1- -u 0f u P. I- 0- I- OU-Uu W Z( LU Z of-- U L ULU I-Iý J

CLC x. 1.-n .9 z 1.4 1- 1- CL(9- CL0

CL-4 0 Z- & 0 -' I-- & & 0 -I.0I4 -1 0- .. 1- 1- uN =I- - Q N.

zU 0I z OC WWWO -M ZOOIA UJ In*W 0*

4- W0. "n- - in2%JX 0-i P- 00O -- 00.-IZ 9P j 9u WZ44 ZLu - ZZA 2L IA4Z -Z LUL

A444 U f W J 4 .J-P- W1- -0-1 --W4. -LU -Zr W w W0 W -11 W. I.-- .9--.Z ~ z -C "

0. LLN UZ 0.0. 020 C 0.00.9 0. W ~ .. W4 W0.0.LLofd4A a- W UU-0 44f 3 0 -4A 4: Z-J4 3-

-04 InI f- CO -a 00. 00W% )(4--4n. in4 L--4 4- 4- W24-I-4- L4in-'a

0 * aN 04 0q 00- 0 . CC 00 -4.00

0. ~ -.-4... - 0..83-010.0 . 0-.. 0408

Page 96: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

Pd m)

z-4

- 1-. .. .j 0 wU

0 4e 2

-2 - 0W W0.' .~ 0 .5 0.n

- W ZA X) 0 z

W Z -W CL.-N *0 > OK U

IA..4~ ~ Z -2 - 04gU- ..- a 04. -Z. W~

Cie I. z Q -u ;z0. L)-- -0 * Cc -. :

-2 W0 N z 2 (- 2IflJ w 4-P In. IN

1-- . 2 1 4 4 .J3! U.2 .IW WJ u . w LLU of

G~- Q 0 a ~ 2. aZU W-CZ ! ~ L 0 0 02 -f

00.If -A I- -

-- IL on *U Wzcc -f z. 0.. 0 Z4) Inv

bU $- N- - - 20 ui-- 4- WO Nf LO 1- 4A C19 z

0 *W a. 2 * -

Q W Y W4. I ! 1020- - 04NO0. 0%1 - I 2 W41 z.

z CL-S - 0 - 10 -- 2- -910.42 2W 2j .4 I -,CD1 010"ly CL 9 . 2L I- 0 z or-

ZWw-i - -W 4 U U,. 0 24II.- I..- 1,5- 0 - 0 -1 4 O O 2

U.4 CL IL Ge U 14 u14 -4 1 41 u

I.- CL 0...0 1--.0. 0. I.- W 03 rIA -0.9 .9 44 - u -9 at4 4 J 44-W CL *

m2 0 0 lAD I-- 04 I.-1- 10e-U. 001 m -iW 00,00 Md1-1 m-00 04 0 J

= =w-Z P- .- 0 IL I22 0. a. wZ N- ILa 9W I- CL 3 6. U 1 - 3332 W4 43.- 2 w-W22I-I-09 C 1-0 1- *~ I.-W Ww www 01- 029I.

Z a30 a - -- 222 Us2 U3 00 0 Il-ox 0 0 AZ 0L 4Z =a z z 0 Z j z N L.4 0 W

64 1 -- '0 4A oL'0 W9 a,01 IC w w w ~ w O.

2 U a4 4 a.

-84-

Page 97: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

10

IALA.

- if

of zz z

cc z

ata

o U of-

W 2e aer j :i e c o p

>0 -9 -9 Z U -Go2x N U -

0i -- 0 4- _a a

"" 4 C) a- 4~ I-- 0 ju 9 .

14 a - aco ~ ja9 U N -- .4

f ~ 2 - P-4 1- p-Z 2 . co O w .-.. 14 ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ C Ucc . * 4 9U a a .4

Page 98: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

-1 "dP 4P- 4.%. " 4ý m" 4" 4 wv wv -44444444 m4.4 P lP p om -1 4-f 4 P4 P4-4---4 dPmP4-4 ýd

OV000002000000 ooooooaoooaaooo loccoo

4 4KE K

4 4

K K

K: 0

zL a. a

.40 cc.42

-. o m 0u- tu 0.

w 0

.4 u .4 0 4 P

N4 P- "1 14 Z .- "I- w -11 - - -% 041-110P

Z a6 0 - X : - N 2-, 2j M, W 9- -I

49 It a--*rW+ - 0~0 K z

*j - 1w 4 W p.. Uoa !. 410 In 10. - N0 4 1~.- 0 -

cr ofu 4o -0

P4 - ý~4 P4 .1.

A. -a N-s6- 2

Page 99: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

P4 P4 4 U W.4mmm m 0 0

x 2 N c

of y C M

oY i

C4 - ad 0*

N 1 0 0 0;ui - f" 2D 1

49 9 . .

-i - - 00. - - N

4 c 4 0. +

0. + NI.- ui0- - - a

D. z 4 N : wC Z- >

I- ~- a. a. a. N

j za. U U. j , -- 0a. w w 4 - 4 7~-

CY I- UI 0 P-l w w 00 0

U 10 .. 00 0;-4w Z Z2 2N

1- .. 0- J '--87-

Page 100: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

SNNNOIANN P- 10 inN

z xCYw W.N ZOa0 @ p a L -. NN C

.o 1- W*.tE#I0ME4 MMON4NMn K U.0

WOW ww j lo 4o - I.- 40 ow

9L x, I- 4w w

-qu Q ~a 4j Uh WUIJ Z , I.

K 1.Z - 41 4z z

0 2

4 -9

ar ~ ~ ~ in42 oý

Ia.N m U * -. 0 N N 4m 0 N0P PI-r-8W% 4m r-? d4f rtp np r- P-r-P- P. w Amm4#44g

u.. d P P i P mt-m - r,- P-P-r-p a. 000000 aA. ma.Nm0 ý-4P n4NcP w MI nC

us LU 0" 0 " In In 4c IL.0U N N -.4 N 10 N a -0 N NN N N 0

4 c P4 ~ .U a J LU.I UM40 -W 3. ef - cIL 2 -)o -9 &a. a .JOZ4WW...i Ci 4z - 494 49 0 Za aILI1- 0 a aco 0 0

4e 4 O 0 0-Ko z I. I.

0 at

6-f It 0 1 "W 04IC 4nW tmC 4I 00W j u t &n 4 in inLi 4 - U)NNNO N .0 ttv N 4fYN 't 0 N a - - % IN

0, .-- 0 - .- P e-t.P - fft 0 Pr- P- F- - a .jmWn qI # t I 0mE 49 P. ("2 "p .ft -P ý -I 000000 IL

In 0 V, a r a0 a 0 ,ccFeft In r N4Y U a U,0 Y tUO 04 A IO W.Ne *l OoM70.#ndtqrJNt 0 Z ~-4.4 ZLUNe LU * ý# CY -#44 n *. WkItI&I t In AJ IL0DID Lu 0 N cm( N4 Y 0N em.40N N NNN 0 mi

LO I" " - m a w M 0-O nM % C

of04 -Z ZvKZZ4-ON.yOUK > N.04LU-. L0 -4&K0K0xojx.Z~ww- -U, -- 0P.- 0-40.LiL 4u M&a4 *eemee AIin U- 4 AI- KZ .44Ka u IL ý -W

oUn k f t.NN- 0.0 et - mP.-I~N ' 4 4- - r Ain n 4 to P.ff - fl-r- mmP- e' - P - m 0000010

kiIA .8-40*01-cO "N r ý 4

o N 0 " NNN P4 4 -N.m4"NN4 lu

In In (El In In .. 4 In 0% an InInIn40*-z-gac xaeoae.in - - - - -

IAWWO. 4 X04W

-88-

Page 101: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

IzP4 p In n I -0 0 C (0

sr#N N.404I~ MmU 0 0N4"#4P

WfyC ~ .u Lu;:- 4 4 z . -0NgvMu,N4 N 4N 40

w i.- z 0 Z 4 A aI go goMP-

4 Wj j K- 4O U 4-4P.

cc - .

r-NNIN4 0144m M# W N 0r-o 0 1- x nK- Zf-i

I.- xK- LUP. 1 a4 0N N 0 I a z It 0- fm CoM . A a LL w -4I.4.

W -

-t W 0 20-.4 -4 P. Z (D--.-- 8- M P.N0404jO44r.NN.. 4 WhI-OgW C% 0'. a CyC.r

W Z w4 - og- 11-j 0 .jZ 2 U. .a2 w = 1.-~ 0 Lu

4 000000LL -- ~ 0 KZ g C

00

in ý L -aZ n A N - 0 1 I-0

NaN40 Z Uf- 4 Icc * - 0w - UO4N N.-rM r-in0N 4000000 0 4.1 j ..J000000'00000000.000 &cc 00e 000000ec

r-- ofa 6n0 ftNp0in0 0 0 Cie w-. UJ Z La aVL0-4Mw mM ,P- r- 4 40. 0N N Lu 1.- 90 LL~

ON NN CA. NNI- X 4 0 4 K4 N

Lu 0

4# inUIA 14 Mtn 000080 -uz:k J0 0 0004000 000 0-0 0 j0 0 0

P- M ?* -tom P-w P-r- t arJeg

a.000 0J a- oo0%0 40 o r-#agZe0o003000000 v 0 - -1z c WLl- Z K0..

u 00 00

-89--

Page 102: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

o 4 32NMON # F. mr- m )

.4 M. m.4mI P"d.4M M MM NN

0 #M.4mor0- am~ ai N 4,04 a- 0m P--. ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ 4 mp1i NNNEýe~ V

0-NO4QQ NNNAMN*

In %ok4 04 .N0~0 4.4P- NQ

P4- 4- M.4 - ------ M - .4M4ý4- N N

P.-m m MN "N 4 IA r-rdm 0 m4E # 41

0 N fol m r- P0 P4 mA 0 N f'0 1 -. 4 ON m0

P-.004 n o 3 a 7 mmr 4 0% N 10 0 a. 0%.NN444P. m0 mm -: I a m A

P4 .4 0.4 pqý.4 .4 M- P44 N. N N

-900

Page 103: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

% 0000000000000000 0000000000000 @00MO 000 mm0 mmmmmmmm 0000~0o 000

OK 0

IL&Z4

-wI -

4 w I* 0 a- 00 PS4W . F

4 %soO Kw ac * 0Cl 16 X6W

0IIU a F-- F-OJ 4

0. UU .~.0w xg 4&K4 09.

2 433 SW F-F 9 In1

j WE' N" W 0F- *WJ OW

-91-

Page 104: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

oiloN 9,

00

-92

Page 105: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

Z zw1

0 N td

N 4L-ur- u PI. f"

3. I4 4

$- w W dodC4A U K N

w w 00f w .jw00

09Z z W0 0 i

de t3 009

IA I U IL CI

c 0 oo at

CL z u N N 8 .mW -0 U N NZ

U1 w In I00I

64 I

I.- I- 4N N I$-

0 zcc A000 00w0 0 00 0

A4 W q 0 - -

.j w 0

q4 46 seN wl'0-"" -4# -Ltal .'0 e - P 4 1-4 Ju 10*

u~~~~~ C u yN 0NMQN0u.0

cc140 a000A0Pb 0 00 0 I-93-I

Page 106: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

cc

0 0P

U. U4, ty

N J 8 n4N 9 W

-aM

Do0 N

0 0w

ac49 4

I N.doin.0

94-

Page 107: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

ON

.00

* i +

Z+Q

0 00000000 r- -)

M t i 0 P. G q t

.95

Page 108: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

10

ocooolloooooe c ooooo

xzzz~xzztzzozzz zzz

10 0

077 .0 Z-U U. 00 u

4.u at S I)

bg 4 0

- I~-96-

Page 109: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

IIin

z3

0

LU 0000 co 0IuJ -4

z i ý4~ P. of &1 0 z NNLUI 02 0 0 ua ý ...aNoo

-a 0 0002. CL47

0 - Lum Ox- wU 4 F- 0 4dLQ -- 0 .0 z 2 z

-. U.0 .- LU

0aa

4 0

0 2 N N o 100 np-tA. 6)I U4 It -9 4 It N 49 0 -4 N M-0000 LU 0000 Z J.i08000

0 000 0. 000 of 000'i A. N N w W d0 n, uc O0N p- ziN z N 4 LA

LU 0 w PffIM 3- w JNN.-4 U.

LA 22 j 04. N 4U- 0 o'- 0 LL

LU3 u 0 A.

Cie

44 LU x0

0-4 A.4 ýa Ufl% nooN 1 0 NMP- .4 OU' 0o. 4 j It 0 It U -r o 4 fr - 0N'm .i04 001.131 a UO .tOt m-P. 0 000oo 0000 0000

2vinF. On W'lQ vin N -4 in m

wul n u LU WM MN W UJVN ca U.0 N -1 0 2

- O LLU. u N a -ioe Z2 0 MOO- -C 2 -44 j -NW LU LL

0 0

z A0 2aA It 0010ON 10 I c 4i '0 N. .CP- . a1 W% wt0U P- N o o.I wJ O I4 Wof-It.- 4 #44It 484It4 4 P- 0.- -4 4N MCu00000 0000 XC JO08000 0 0000 0000 LU 0000

-J

0 0 Luj 00a000ý u. 0 'D. 0 Z1..fOLa W" L mMMN LU N YNNN U.

0~ 4 zgkau

3- 4LU~I -97-

Page 110: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

k)

.cceaccco~occcccco cocccc

u "

499 -9in W..J 2UW 0.0 U.&. awUw 0 N:4 WWJ VI #A1.- 0- 1- a -. j g A.

zw 0 0 . -j 0.0. 44 .49 - 0 i wd

-U LW S-L Z

of 44 U. 2 me b-

oo 0 0 0 II

4 - ZW =I NIL 4ý

-j 4 AQ 00 -0 0

0 + 0 x --.9- 2 0 0 r n dcc VI w

-I..x VI 0

'h 42 4919,4W

2 0 OIL ILLU. w4 4-3 -GO 3~ a -

W .0 -

:NNNMy 4~4 9,

IA a 911n . IN1 0

oil 01-420- Z1,-p -~ - 04 a-E -i

04 4 90WU 0 9IL I& YA

-98-

Page 111: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

4 a a mmI4 -: V M n 0 0 4

co o a o R(m m m M M " o

N

N WN-. ~ ~ ~ ~ 3 4Dd44444d44.-~------ N 0

ff40

+ , oZN ;

w 4 fn%

14 U. .

04 4 4 0a1N9" - 00F

-99-

Page 112: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

z 44~-NII~.~

TA zz o z

)U 4 w 4 CL0

-100

Page 113: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

IzJc I 11IIz

F- 0U 0A iDDu6%I 4e 0 0

q* 0.2U

.0j j " " U. 00 U - 1

0 a LU 0.o a0 GN N A4- i. e i

P. Cy wJO' 0 I SA w I.'N 2 U-U 000 d .JC LU- 00 0 j0

I- z. 6-0

LU0 4Aef ~ U 6- W M~ U IIn I ~ L 00 U.

CA I LU -L0 K 0 .e C0- 4% J" r- 0

IL z2 14 0I 4 0 in01 NW 2 u- 0 x

>I co a &0oo a 0 1- $6-4 6- LU M 6-%r m4

In L U 0C ý u zLDa 4 z -

4A 0 -S- 0 = du 0 a NC' 0 4 nC 6

o -0 00 0 wC0 0 0 0 J 0 0 0 6u- 4 000 Z 1"0 U. 0000 00 .2 4 0 1

U. In UOO In 2 U. 0Oe PNLS LU UJ.M oo U. 04SM N U

ON .J COW i 00 Zz 4A

11 U.0

ILN 6- I.-S4 9. - 4-A OS r 60IL 4 4 In .4 0 ItA N I O4N UQ. 16

00 r-1- 0C0 000000 j000 -.f- coo z 0 U 00000 00ILc

ff-1 0 u - 0I0 @ NM

aU N( W x0~ %A.060LU.

N m ~ II. 0(f1 %fP1N..4

8 00 0 NqO -i- 00

-1 1

Page 114: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

0

A-4

U.

cc 0IA 0.l 0at z

Nf 6A f"-

ujZ Z 4N J%0P

z U.ILW

I4

IA A~A~

w

-* NU. %P-W rt

P- - 44f tI

x 0008088~f~

w N0m00 0~U

z a 4A f If

-102

Page 115: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

d ey

44 e*coo

we 0 c cc a c ccl c a-e z zz z~ elz

cc Is )4

z u5 0 ac 9 - *Wo

#A c .zU w It u

I * 0 1. a cOV: 0 WU 0

o at cg u w~ 0 (.-5

4 C f 0 4 9U 0 Ze WLU ~ ~ ~ .0 a. b ud

0 ue ag w u atWwOCzou 0z in gw 0

out le 4 z .we 4

I0 aw w w cfwg-e.G-e P.0 -01jWCL c 04 -- V e

w MI- 0 P4 OCU-ia. . Ze Iw wj 0 g0~z el r4* 11www@. ZO 0 0 awe 4

U .. -12 w

a.xx 0- *.- .- 9 wC -- C

z LU i-a * -a. N N4Jeww o ww- acN~ w w w X

Kl 1- w 4~ - 0 Z 000a44A-u 0g 0 - -0N N 00 * 0 06 6 0 4 0gj - d

in eo ina

o ow fm fq0a 4Puv omv4N~in 0 g

.0t F- w 0nin

A A- a 0'

000

00 4440 woo00

-103- 440

Page 116: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

0020000 2

0 0 0 0 0 02000000

0 64g. 50

* 4u.30 0 z* .0 ww 66L 0

0~ ~ 0 %N 4 z40 4 wu.g W * 31 *

M 46 1 P. S 4 5

s~ ow * w. 1491 -. 1

*0. 4 Z44

03 w~ IAL .J SO wN4 ac coo A z 4A 49.JZ t- 0

.w 4* . 4 .0 4 04 W 44 1- 0- 50 eaw. 034 0- I44 j 4A AR a

%L:Ujw ~ ~ ~ w nww w W We0 ag "-W *5 IL -at0 0. b

.4~ 0 X V49 W* S*.tf- - 1 0 0.

Xc. Nu ;44 10to-w *3 W;4

0 3U toN49 0 MA 0

b,4~ cc0 04 :"0 - 4 4*. HIMS44 t- Is * W

S6 02 * sm~~.SB.~~~ M.A S 0 0 *

V. u 00 01 64W% 9n tWQXdaX4Xq W01

9500-H 0440* 01-0 01 q4fy~0 N :4 e usu;

C0 400009 504 5 0s S S 000

P. P. 2 1 on~~Uvu~ju~U~54. S U~4KK4MU44M*onHs ISHIS.4 T I .4 Ib t I*

* 55 * 09 W00S c4

0000000 0009soo 9009313300

O4QOEQO4QO Q14Of4-Q 4

Page 117: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

. e -" on A m O0" dfk m A M A M A m A

N 0 0

* o *; deg0

a U, 0 3 00. 00 u 4 4*

4N .9 * 2 0 0 .- * 0 0*Z

2u 0 z - *iC U, U, 0 29*1U* de .= U=g u at 4 0

x * wj 0 0 9-Pbo

Cv'. Pd X*U4guUU 1 0z Zo IC 0I*x -.u at i * I X0 mo 0 at 0 1- 0U.

ofdo4 I. Z0r- 0 4. SWi . 4i 0 . 9* - *r U0. U, *0 4 WW0 0 01 tz4 41 gU *0 .0

Uj~~~~ 00 u AU

.4 ~ ~ ~ ~ 4 Z *j:V m 9-W4 X :bu AK U-9 ýO ub at - a of

W uv *n.00S . gK ac j 0 A -W0

-r I... .~ U n~ n 2U4 ~O ln 0 w lg WWW 0

j *UK co ougr- 20m. 0 - 1- * 1. 0

*i jW z0*C.i .

U WU 200W0~WL It.2 0~l OLW - .0

U ~~ ~ ~ U go-~ I- *0-o..gU 0 a,4 U N .or 0.* *.W 2z~~~~~~~ 2rog IL 0g- i*g. g U. 0~-

U. r0 b.- *4 U oWO U.C - 0 .U uuu. *IU SPA0z U.OCZU.0C0 IL~ UCrZ U.Z I 4 *U.C 0 -- 20-00 = gcc eLO=Geg ow, g Mm Ode* 0~ Ig mU UcVTUSTZ.S=occ 0 'ado- 0 WCD 0 4Ain- mooo 40 ; 0 *oo0*000 00ad 0 ~ @U. 04~ *9 *W4Wc @

in 0 W *u 0 ccOU 0IA 1-I 0 Z..9 0 U.RW

01 1-U = v 0*I j -9 WV).j -9 *U * .Jog K4-0C -- CO-..J..ax4RN 0~ W 21 *UiU

U 9 4Z N 4 ZZ 0 uU. 0 0Z~ X K X Ug X z X )P.u 49 . - U -K 0- s 0 U49 - 4bInA1-Ck449 14 W -in4U49 Wrc 0. - Z 1-0- 0- W

-~~~ u-00i

K 0 ( a, 0 0* Mf.0NW 0 U 0 In-dIf- f4 .4 0- 4 Z0 *-d p co p Pr-00 P 2r 0 Q 00 0 Z PQ 0f- 0 *

4 0 P.ON 0 0- r-00@nl'-000vlOO rl-e

c-ooo 00 OO090 Q rOOCOCPoor-

00000 00 0000Q

am 00 1

cog 000 0000- 0 QQoQNOOQj pg ij I T IfI I

-4 in* *mnmn0 000 00co0o000 0

00o 000 00000000 0009 000 Ovupco~~

-105-

Page 118: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

C0oo 0000000 ~00 Coco a ~0 o"000000003 3333 0000 03333 3333 3333 3333

z z C zzzzZz z C

0 *

*. 4C I

'0- C C00 4 - 0 flW4

0 0. m C), g l- 40 bft

CC z 4 Owg1 U.C .. W J .-..

0 49 OCp C - 040ob-wgw-out "~ fg L4'1 g zw

* K CIJ C3 C 91 = o "QC W K~~~~ P C4- C -9 .K ~ ~ ~ N I- UIW O.J AOI-nU"0. V C tC K - 60 G

ex.~ U. Z LJ. w mg ...

I- * i CO .W . J W 1 Z

a f". 3. MAO jO- w

z ty 0 C. C £ C Q y w O

W 01 -"' CZ cc On -40 0 em.ZO4O-0 we *4C Nil C; cc U K 4gat

4 ~ ~ ~ W ZCC xxUb -M 09dC6 C9 C j Cm

of CC1 a

41 C'A C y0t tP-A C C w C 0

If 0 a. . .0el na0mV .

a a

0 09000911. 0 ~ K,0 LX C cUN ucoo.

K~~ IL C O 4 . * C C O O o o0 Q Q.4 oo u N

in f'£ * i~ a ", *I CKC #aL * 'a4 2

0 C4 C 4. C d.CC C IvCco

48 *0 ccoaI-.2- a'A 014 0u1.2wuq xU~ ~~~ cc0K4J M cWocoaCwK 4JK~g4

U~40In4U l1--1- 1-C Jt4 -106- 4 Uu n.J4n1

Page 119: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

M m A 1#4 1* # 04kk06m W4 4 4 44 4P .P

N40

N '

N '4

00 & 0=o 0 z

a f -W- a4.nuI-I #cc U. z -ac -9 K 0o W 0A

.9 * ' 0 0. Q u LO w uj4A -oO 4 Z- b4 0- U.-1.- WA4 0 W b-w w W. jW I-u

0 N U. C X N - CLg %1 -4 I Z. W Il-0~~m U. 0 .4L L L 0'

- 01 0WU U -Z LW

O N U. 0'4( w N 40 0. oU. 4 0. b.4 3 -w0 1 - VL4 bZ ZLW 1- '41It.2

U.

4L

* a a 099 a6U W a 4L 21 fa0aZ g # CC N 4 " at-I. 4 1- ofz L -y f

K 000 a w uw 0i ' .0 4 00a .4 a0It040 OIL 4.r 't 0 000 WWL. 2W Z ~zwww.Lmw.L w6**a 00004 0 0000-0 0C 040 W0.N 04

U.d oCD d d o aoS WD90 0 wIL

U Wj 0 ItN- 00. 1- '4 W a, Z10 Ui 0- x ( x W0 a 0 0o0 0

U 0 .SD 6 .0 *0

In on P44. m4 dm f"-440-4.0N 0 4 Ps04. m mON NOOO4 0444NW n 4V44O m 404444mtn 0P- 0UI40I Ifl4NOOOOO mv0'Q0o

N N-40 -4 N 0 N fy0 @OO 00 * 0 paN 0.4 0 g-so co m 000 NO.4000000 00000000000 008g030 P- 0U00o 0 000

0 00000 coooaooooooo 00 0 ~oe-coooe Coco

Z 00000 00000000000 000000 00000000 0000'.4 U040 QOOQOUQO'QQ U00,000 000,00000 0409

CA 0~tQ 0.-1N004ON##0 440 ra*o F%0

N4wwQ NNOO0m QFMriN:OOr-F% F.m or-" Q P- F.,-. 9O0"N40C 00 oo00OOQ000000 000000e00009 0Qooo

II I I TiQ .0 -0Nmw4p4V0o NM 4'40F-O. Nm44IA4P-0-4 Nf" -ein

mNNmf*0 04~0000044 *44 in4tl In In 0 6N4 4440

000 000000000 0 0990 00 00 0000 0000

-107-

Page 120: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

Cd)mmoleE

2211,111111HIIII I m z

i ; so 0

U. 90 e 5 .

W 0 5 5*A L I- 5U0

x 5 5

1- 0 0 u z

'0 U) Oc 5 A 0 w2

C 525 0*j at U ue O

U . 4 us )I.. ~

0 ~ ~~ z 9 O* U.WO 0 W *s~~

fSW 569 0- : 44ZLUdIL 0a S I 5 5 0 g~~~~~~ 0 ~ SS 5 WA

P.. '; N W. 'A Va -M 0,9 0u uz %

Got .. LOU go UI0 0- 095 09--Ia.e 0 o -se ~.

e~0 sf 01- swg IL sa wj m s

b. 5 x~ at 5j . jo J u

*. .OIO : U

*aW0 a 5050a g

s-ud iA 0 N - e 0dN N"

Al 4 N ly .me 4 .. Wi0 N~ Uy ftO

o e xol us '0801881800 P-90U. wuwu UW

w ~ -- I-020U *4.s IL- eciUI

Aggf444 I * s*a

t I IW I . t s o

4 .J4 4 50 5 -4.j.I j UX 5 44 C9 Ad (I NU ~.J 5 S 44MX0eM5W 0ML000U~

020903 5- ~ oQQ uMI44*s30000003939388I-

z 5 5 0 5

Page 121: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

z:z zz~zzzxzzzzz~zxzzzzzZz:Zxzzzzzzzz::

S. 600u

00 0

0 - 0 zV# U 0 -9 0

9 - 0 . r a. --j >- IA -U L u C I

OU -0. W u-of z 1 zu a U.Z zLW 41 g b- .4 z U4 2-9 C0 4 0. 00

I-J b- 44 zWz g0o gj C 1- uC g 0 1

-4 u 1 -

IA.

w

12.44

Oo w o W0 0 0 Ma "aff( PO

Q Q IL C 90 4 Oig -UJ .gga~Uw . . . . . .o~ OF .. O LZzzz 0-.--100 0341N3a 0 00000 -10U. L.0 00 g.0- --- - - * 0 . . . . -a -. ~ = fcac 0 4 A 0 0' A*4 at 0-WO0000-4ft00 cc a

0 g * J * * 0 *1-00

U XWXW44gww(xwxwCWg NNi4N0P 000 Wj

Z 4 ju0 xx4x0 L C

ixg x z. p- a-zo> o0c L'i g Q 0 4 0 0 0 m0 W%4L 0 r £ ,zWj M. %) W-ONC" ZCOUI4ý0U u t.L u W!C1 LI- 1-0 ZOOOOCJOOQWLLUu. U ~CLt! 2

4 OM.4N0.tF.40N.0-000000 000 ONf.W .4Q'QU000M.0 QOOOOQN 040o W44OC9 NNNOONNO0 00000000 OP-0 P.NN

0000000000000000000000F.0P-0 F-00

o~ ~ ~ ~~~oooopo cooooouooo00001-F0,oo

w p..z 000000000000000000 f.-4ffr-N000Ma'

QU00000900000 009o

0 WN *No It0VNW N4tNN4N 0 O00000000000 900u m P~. N r 0F N ft " .I'NMFtNm ft N 00 0 CJ 0 00 0

000000000000000000 000O00000Q.400 mooU I I r

In r.N~ -o0 Nm -to41F.Om- r 1 "N m4 .F04CdIU,0 P. 0 -4

* NN NNN NNN NNN NNN NNN NNN NNN NNNc00000000000000000 000000000000 000

000000 00000 09000 00000 00000 000

-109-

Page 122: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

onA f" In InI

141

0 cIL 1914

1 40000x zK

*0

'0

ac

-4 z

-1 Q

10 0

WN M 0 m 44

0. o 4I M efw t

4 U

Nm msfl two"44NNN0:0800000

Page 123: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

IuI0f0

II.

Noe4NLc

0 1.

IA a ; 1 .4rz . 1

00 0a.i Of :A1;;A. 4 .r

Q~ N f" P.4%at Y yM NWU.9

Cf 0 j .0

fLU kU M

U -

0 0 -j U. 4i If. 0 -4 0 a p00P u0zw>P

00 0w. b- af- a a a~i cu aN m - 0-A4 au

Ln . W Q m.m P.Q0 % m e P N NM N ftmew tv 0y N cm N NN y

WU~ U~0 ~4 K

z U. .4.. CU ~U.W 4 0 0 0 'm 0 ~ K ~ P Z 4

Page 124: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

(YN

UN

CLC

16 10

0 IA In

LU.t

B.4 -4

-4 -o S.J

f". MNItNoo ,tv .i

0 K 6 te o0I %4m4 N

Page 125: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

N #Am m lo .r

a coomMW

z z

z . ow o -w- a

Page 126: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

40 49 a

I- ac 0

I2 1. 0

'C z IL 0 U. -U

0G4LN I- e.y

01 001- UJ D uiIL 0 4 z u 0 2 10

4 04 0 0 -2jCL a n CL-c 0 ac4

cc CL I-

:) U) 0 00 z NA z L N 10 iwUS 1l~ in 1 . i

0.% 0 004 z -J ; C 4 0

z0. 0 0. 0 Z 0. - z 0.U. cc a 0 W

wU U. U. cc CL W i0n %A 0 0%A0 W

0 2 Ln 2 j

0 19 .J - 40c

2 -0 60 QU P.- 2r oo w 41 0 Q W

f. 0 U. 0 0 00.I., z L 0 in

5 ~ 0 in N SUt.U1Ao -i UJ o 1iJ I- cc0

in % In - U

S~- U UU.

I-w Z u 0 a. - 0 f'1 .4 0 in0. 0

wi ja U 0 00 00 b.. x d.0N0 L 0 0 e 2

~~ f" 0iini i I2

at4 u

* N 4 M S i

Page 127: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

IL

.0

Is. in82

w* -d.

2

V) V) 00 ON 0001 )i AO VV )P -V A0jV4: A.i -' .- aLem

I 4OL M2 Su.4W 2

a K 3qN 04

caa

' i iN. ~ 0NN N.J NN~N.I - ON

Page 128: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

ooeoloo looeeoceoeecoooeeooeooeooooe

zzz zzxz zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz

wxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxxx

CI 1

4 0-~C;

N 0;

0 . Q - a

a -0 ae U .4 !j C- do 0- -4 34 4

0 0 j 4A# -o 0 %AJ IN %A a Z P- W0 t;

-~a 0 a *U* q.

Ud IL Z &00 J z N mj 4 Z440,01 - 010 09-

ML JW -*.e ., *, *a 4 .lAQ .00 04t. wo wu~d(JNN co Qwx U~m -QU -4 caMa 0"90

a ay * N- 4d*.w N 'd

Page 129: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

4A4z2

'4 1UU --% uu N4 4P

LU 00 00.0000z 99 a0tz 4&1

Nu LU Lo U. 00 Qi 4 z m 4 410 0. LU 0 WJN LUi ) U.

cc0 ~ 0 ac '4 -

y cc LUS UJ -. J f" C ~N 0

LU j LL U

0 0 00 1. -0

* 2LU U.

14 bZ -94e 0

z f- U, 0 y

LU o- AA 4- ~ ' - D -l r O 0 t. 41 1- 4 " 0- 2 L 0 14 0 N r t

-0 1U 000 of 0 Z ..JOOOOa C. 00 1 at 0000

um . 6- 0Y %A0 ly Li QiO Z Li Ir 0-~

LU 0 LU 4- %AN -Y LU 4A - U.'4 0 0 0 0 LU

0 LU - 2

0-J '00 4 0 0 2 z -Z Z 0 Ny z 0 Z U.

cc of- 0 LUwU z U. a, .C0 0 0 LA'4 Z 4A OA LU

CL 4- ' F. .I.- '4 1.- 0 . 'oP-~ 4 Q- z 2 u0 %0

L It Li u Pi~- P- 0 Li - N- "U1P - 0 C 0 0000 -1 Q 0 -1 0.JOOO

P.0 U. 000 CL 0000

WI 0 U LUQ 0 WIALa u c LU 4- N U.Oi N .J 0 - V% 0 Z do .

-4 4 0 2c

-o LiP N .4 i

0 ~ ~ LUz

;; U

0 0

2 4c

0- P -1- 10 Pt N 0.au u N0 -. f"in~4-0 44 Q4- 0 1- f.' in -Q0 0- Li0PMItMor

0- L 0-. 0000 00 ( .1O000O00 0 000 0 LU 00000

-iN r 0 N 0 rF

W% 0 IA'4 LU 4Pbf wWA La u IV

04- 0 ..0 cc '4IxN

-*LU ..t- LU

00 2 2

Page 130: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

~0 0000000000000000000000000000000000000zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzxzzzzzz

- 0

-0 lLL0 6% --0-00 0

E0 z0in 0~-'A z -

ZII0000 w 0*-.J o .j

- W.J 0 - U. UN z P~. a

LIe O 6 0 dt *u o vi * -1- 0%W* W- 1.1 U 42 -9A - 4. IC 4. 0 o

>Qw ~ 0 f .0 0 It 00 * UzAuww 49 *~ A * wJ . Ud j c * 0x

0'.- X o1 4 I U oA --. OKgIAU -14 A - v z XzZ Q W MfZZNW rz~d -Z= me.

ZZj W j . *z ~ de U - 4p4.um"00u- II 3k 10 - - 4 LU U N-A44g I N -4.J#UU IWE

'70 tU 0 3-.0 U 1000 49 04 4N7 w 0j mu4Ww A-ULM U

000 0 Q AUI CCIoIII -WN 14 Mv 44 f" ~ M It o

Page 131: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

N 0209 08 a 0000444 44 444 44 444 44 44

dwl

at 01. k0 0 )1- W % 0 in

%m ww I

Z.1 I- a wi *00

a in " * -dIn 4 0 34 .% 4 ~ ~ 0 ** 9

atz.011-04w~ 9-vwvvidwl1 *WWVQ0 e

Inr 00M in 00R~~~q t4 8:3:"""t

I, a vo d'.

Page 132: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

)

N

-IZO-

Page 133: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

cIA4A4

Z

w wIn In t

In In0

uj w cc c00 e P. z000 0

fy Q0 a 4 P, Kd q 4

%0 40 0 ONN4 IL 4U"

Q wa-oeo z

4a 0 eOO-00

z z4 0 0

to -

01 In 't0mA .I

IL P.. I-4i P. P.~C I P. P.P.a8 4 m

s 0 oo00 000o0 o a. 008008800z 4 6% 4 afI#0a.N 0 4 %m

0 -U z QO 4 WDP 0 : U4,0~ me aw w a t# U #e It W.~ N f"N -4 -GA 0D a xx 00a

0 z z0

19 U J4 0n a C N U U~0 . 04 0' -a e~t0 0 000 Pz W z ~ 0 z-Nw-e

I. ca -a a a ~W1 4 I

4 IL0 m . 0 0F wmP 4 0

lo 4 . 4A gI-InmP

wo 4j .4 U - - ; .C4fI4 4Op. o 1- 00 C 0,0 0 0

P. 0 0 00 I00000000000

.d 0 *ul OkIn 4 N -d 0 mP-. aN mN0fU ' IL wl 04 $ gi410f P 9-06 It C CNwNin wi w 0 # 4

04e

f O 0 N000000.i00.-44 4 J -I4.4N N ".4m 4P-

0 0ilif

- ~-0 - OC NON4N#00-fflm at

AN 49¶ 9*9l-m1ý I

0,0

Page 134: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

MN It4 6% 61% '

0j 00000 00000000000

N -N 6% IA4

-4 zeu 0 4 I

-J0 000 00000

00%0000000

ZJOOOI'II OOON

000000000

2 NflIEr4'4'IA4

U. I

Page 135: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

10

N 0000000000000000000000000000000000000

0000000200o000000000000000000000000xxZZZKZZZ ZZxZZZWZZIZZKZZKZZKZZZZZZMZZZ

LU

Q. X LU

01.- ~ujOlt-

4. 0 .S-2 Z

49 m LUZ

40 U O LAX

6- 011 11I 3- U9 -.1

1- 99 99 9L K

4 M.JZ 0 c

af uof 0w0 x

0 _J _J .0 x0 -9 .44 0 (

%A Zl ow = 0 -jC

u j K K O . a u 0 =D LU Z Lu W L0 0jO w o

0 LU Zx0U0

Z- 000 Z-¶ I L4 KKWO 11111 a.C -4 wx _j ccWUj.j LU - oz -m IO 0ZLU -9L. U. z occ Uj -0 U K- 0 - 1- oOz

&. 0 OOOMOOO M - z*- 99KKxx 7 T #,._o 0 0 - d ac cc A9 -in .__ .- -

LU K Zoouzuoma 4-.. -*_ - 1 - -Nit9

0~ ~ ~ ~~1 0~0-.-04 .~us uj UziW0 . 9-. -11. z ox ",- " +; ; nZ Z4- -

Z- Z ae of0 Z 0-10 9W.-9 ~ n99 919 0-9+-5Z

Id) 0 z0* :1 9 cK-N99 -9..juo. -1 j 9 9H

in i - W"L O of L9-.OZ 99. 099011" 0 0 r0U 01 OOK x9 If~ 10 0 .- 0 j 0l . _ 1_PK 9- K #A LA 4 o o 0 -4

093.093. cc ) 0 1

-123-

Page 136: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

0 no. IN n4-9 04N p n4P 0coNmrI p .04

I N

* .j

-. cy

U. N

-~ NN

S I- X-Iz; +-

IA ty 1 N- deIA I - -(3 L-. x

+- - 1 -6 (3- M L. S.M I..U. I ~ . r

-w .. w .4-- P

AA ~ I- I- U.-

WL w a - j(

a Sa a. U. x.a

iJ UJ j L.- + ;WU. I -. I.N~ .. 1- af

o4 W, w. U.--- U. - -2 "1K

aN D 0N . I 4 Id -- -i x'CD - 00m 4- 0 00 . N - a

IA I j m0 9 - .4 g3eij0x .

0 x I- -4 I. - 0 ( 1- 5 ;o -1~~OO L 3 D~ '

mf ItI 0 10 - O .a- at a inm2 w (3 wo PI S..J .N N

s5 - I a . *-124-a

Page 137: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

@ @ @@m -dNNN NNN N

w "Z + + 2 + -

N 19,MIA_! W N - Z

0 _4A LL-0 m

I. a n -01-1

in ¶ic ym4

Page 138: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

LA-I

z 2W WiW W

I-I- b f .

U U

ro 5 0 & " pw NN 0P-

0 0 4 P- f- P0 0P mI09 o ae.

N li 4000J(000.4W WU 4 -NNNNO

20 i

z

0 0 0 W

0 z 2 .In w p- r. m p- m p-f- 0 U..al W W ý04 I.0.-4N N~ .. a -, .

a. K U K E~~ 4 UNMMMMMMtnr. 2

0 0 ~000 CL 00000000 1394iW .-- i.0in CP mr I

0 -U 2 u m fN 0 C NN 0O 47 zUW 6u 0 W t-t-~ P-I W 0 - P.N - W

In Q. 0 0 00

- 0 WIs 9z 4d U4 6% Gin -I'- O 01 z

0 49 -1 M00I.00000 49

0. - UCL cc 00U

0 W Ci of6- -j 4 W

2 -4i a . NOa N04 .ON.Oain 0 4I-O of I ItI . W4 N~ 'O~ NN In

-j 't -9 U Uff( m 4" a UNenennfrO N O0 - 0 0 0-W.-i- 0 0d-i-i-i-i-Wi-i .4i

p.0 000 U. 000e0000at 2

- 0 * kC In N0 O t0

ON in 0MM ZJ - w- 0 0

C N # o 4 0

on tj CP N(. U,

in% 0 N0 0 W4UOO

4A

a.0

4 - p- P 4N ..o 000 00oo00000

inow U W umImEm [email protected]

o 0 49 0 0 0

090. - .NNC - -

-126-

Page 139: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

Izi--J atLEUCN

cc 0N 4 04 4

4 z -d - ý' Nm N= U.o 4

0 u .z I- %

0 Z UII. 0 w

m I

0 0%b. 0.

I- I-:-Iw *OO-NOO

oM Nzf - U.NN

LU 6

-L zL - - - Fý04P d6

60 0 N2 ... NinN4 0-

0 Z U.

0 0 0.

LU0u

I-

LU127

Page 140: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

M ow MM Pd ' M @4M - dM dM M-m .4Ne MM m 04 pdMPdp

o~~~~~~?- O rrp,-Wmmm U @

a KU.43

a. Pd M -U "~4 %- 4 419 WN .I 465 .w.4 SWj VI

- ~ ~ ~ ~ u 0. -. j..~..- ..

N~~~~ 9- w(. P.. Z e Wu... g~ - 0.4w M N V

WZA WZ

-. N .3 0.4 .4U

.R-0 t - E t- 44J1 owl~ N .1. *Z- U - tS Z0 U-00.1 u WUU.%9JOA 44-

MN3 4.O liX 00 -u; 4f -N4.4 - .4 x4. uWS u-%f U .

0 M ... Do 0 l KU. x~ a w4NU.tf a a- KS- 49 W.U U .4 4 a Io, - Co. M

& &m .z a a3 am 14 e.xw M

.2~~ at -- 0 4 .4) * 54V .0. aZ

V'. 3 445 a v 9i a 3S 04 NH

aa - E.2 4 .4w P4 0% 0.;@ou man . 0313% NO 1- u-*k-

W13~ M W K W 2Wz J.a ;00 U 44.;3 [email protected] z 43.";4v

a fml~ 00 ZO 4 31U U Z 4325w f" mw 9Z . 2I- .4 !- 2 Z ;4. MVUV4. r-*U %

w .0..) .2 -C Q 4W a - W%

W ku 4.. W ;111OZus M * 4.- .4 2 0WZL.0N

a-14a -- e. .P0 2 -. 2 U in

0 N-- 00 0.4 a. NznC Z~W - 0 -0 jZ .4- M)f .i6% 44P

IL 2 3q to 34 0 I- a4 a4. zCCV

1- -z = a at a N9w w

w :)Z 0C 0 00 00aP. An 0u 0 W. U L64. Q6. 0

It .4N c d~m M . 4 d4" % 0 .4owm -rIA0W 0 r4U 0 0 0

Page 141: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

II

I- IL

UA- -

U ---

-0 - uvv4 la

.1 0 .0 "f

ON x *.44 M N

9 000 N.

I. w- g - L0 -b2 V I-I-I U

z 1011 UuU0 0 * S 0 f" It- e im N -4N*Ud~~~~t NXCN4.e.

2 eB. * ~-129N

Page 142: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

10

N 4 N- 4..... 40

I N w

z -i0 -oUi - --

$I p- V- 2 C

0i ;W NSU a

wf In -

g~c NN~-

~ U130-

Page 143: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

10 InA

a A

04NNN No* 40 4

IA 0 -A 4C4 -4 0N ZO~ IaU I~ 319 V'sI.

4 U W

m N 34 Uz . U4Po &

I4 .4 r- cl0 -Tmm0P

w W NFM*W.4 In~ W 840 ~ ~ ~ w CN0. Nt 0 S.

k. a0 I .4 0 z se uO 49 40

zIIIIImm &~3Z4-9 o I &!0z

-a I-I3.z.9t IA

z z

-U. j.41

.4 Z P. aU-4M 4

U ~ -UNNMIN NNW P4 lCU-r0 In . ýr- ?~. P- -4 P-P0.t F- 3 .4 Ow - oco 0 a*0

InM. 1 4 r--~P~~P 0 0 0 b 0 N

wo -a UNNMMIA@OvIm w. 9.4 IA UO nA 20WIA M WW W ln mw in w wU In b% U.N0.4 W ONNNNN".NNNN OA 0 .J 0 0 vi

w ~ f (a A~mAAAIII z In do249 0 4-9 m £I wgug.am- wN z W..J X. (pb

8- 0 &4 .8.ZWW.j $- w Io 4A SZ~. 4 4 -0

9, j U. . I--- 0'm zz -j

IA W .WU 49 I

o 094 MN4N -N.-.n..iIAO 0- mm 2 m- on

IA m -*0 m ~n4I.4 4I0 'aIAo 1.- .F- .0 - 1- F wi

82l .r 1 -M -ýP -1 ý4 1 0P CoaL. a 0. Is Nc 40t aP1r "4chc -0 -f

o W." UC NýIA4Im0I w.. sU 0 maWinV wE.WSIt i8n.n Wi4 a %m Ma8 M Win blbl ILt

£m 0 oNNN4-qNvqNN N.. 1 44 0W

I- a2 8-N 3.Z W . N.O . .ia - Na1, .4S a. 9.Aj at0 w.8 l UUj NIA U..J

U -44cw ZZaLa.- IA1-8J8J0 w 4

4~ ~~ 2 -8

Page 144: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

IA

IL -9

fm p. a

%~~~0 -e.Q ap

f" r- N

z #A-h z

0 U U00

vi.

a. 00. - z

A 4.I0 Z

0w 0

o 9 -- 00 0 2 I OONK U ta 0 0 .C 0

U U&0 0 0

W I- - 0z -9 z

o ;.. o. ain

e-az

It f" 1 .0 !n " 2

4 . 00 0 A . o

f"N42,I a It a 4

%J.000 0j 2.f 4

e- 0 N0 2 0.4.4

I.

W12

Page 145: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

0~~ ~ 040 N~*cc 6 66Uz

z~~ ~ ~ ; I0 t 0

IfUJ O .3 -I- 1-i-)( 'U UI.- iIU U. Wi 600-- CIA ~ ~ ~ * ..NJ 1; 9 ZUz(. NO.-u. '.I LL.W

* --.. 0- IL 4 *. JA W U. I~ 2ý 0 0 1A r Wd u-0 00- 4c .4 0~ u .J

I 0 ; x- -N " ;UPJL Z LU. u4 memo4Z0.0 -. 0 2 VOO( -W 4M .P2I 41

XIA60'10 1 4 0 ;u. IS.l16Z a cc x L4 mm2

- )00 4--c U N4 .W 0000.. z 9(maO O

-iP.2 ZZ 0. W 0('JZUm N4 g14-1 0 .9 0.. of.. z2 of 04. j 4 U ' 0~ z-

* .0 atO~~ W0IFQY O4N mag NZXO--.*N0 Aw.- W...4 X u No - *NW 1~n .. - C" $.- ý-- I-- Z.0 I - U. )(CL(X z 2w.9 - - I '4 U. LL 9N 4C OCW -. 46zI. x o N -

!2!2 C; %A 04- fn- Z Xm- J2 -Z 41zu .)W -..m40 O..l- o wo- - Z;O.ol 00o

W4 M-U3: u. . I J- 220~ 2 0 2 4 0 2

60 60 4; -0 I-I-I-I- U,-I I-I-c op. II-1

~- - a;aXU.N0 0 C .X L 4 ýN o om 9z

6 W% U- 'C M.0040, U.O&I z. 04-f

ii . nm q.4 .9N I~ a .4UA P .4 1" .4

C 4 f"6 (A N uI

z ~ ~ ~ ~ IL W.4 .9-04..0044- z o

( 6LZ~-*X X X x vx~o X-133-x -. 4-91 z

Page 146: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

'0

o op

:zzmzzzz! zzz xx xxZ Zz: zz~z:z:zzz

SP4 z

IA Zj

z N.

990 aaas 4 K I

z' It-

9, 0 4 91 9 01

z t z - ao~j In :.d-.

lo s 3 P. 0 - r.

4 0 J; 0 4i0

4441 .-eIt ,o" a~ 4' .in

0.' coa o o- H O a a X a0 -

-134

Page 147: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

-W z

D I

IL

r- U) a

Z: "V -IU

N N

I-* 1 x I.- .

U.-. tL ' .* N z aVut IA .1% 920 -

0 ~ ~ ~ ~ 4 32 a.ZjU d . A.a N wu* 9 - .9 a

- 1- U -

9 w* .9

Le .. -'

g E - -1- 135-

Page 148: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

.4 P P4.4 m d md ý .4 4 ..4 -0 . ;. d .4 4 . .4-4 . d m)

NX

E . z . i~.

u W

P4 4 Ig em

M. -o t4 1

' 4

.4 p 4 .

eb6. 0 Z 0

.2 U, M I.; t- ; Iwo a

UD, avg. a0 404..

wale It 4, Tl t

.136-* 4

Page 149: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

-I of 44 d~4 -WI~~ . . . . .mdflff

Qu - Z

00 0 * 00

4 a ag -

0000 Ow a

0* -- La't N6 4 4-

=z U coo - 4 00 4

* j 4 04 -j UU am 0

-a w 00 .4 a- -- .4 z- a .

t ~ c 00 a aoo- 0 w 1 -- a so z

#A a ' (-- (D IU in - 0 a0 44 w

*p ss a0 .4066 *It% N IA I In In

-137-IlU

Page 150: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

A t -4 ff IA F6S q.4 ff .IA

.4

.0.

at- 4 b"t I"I I Is

K ry.. I i -- I .

0- 01 waz N1 .

* q fy t -LUw

a4 -04 0- $-: ps0-S,

96 -J;8 .1 a .4

Z 0 Cc, "a x ft-00"00 a I

K 9 A 92

t W% in W n 0A A4 0. 0.400 1

* * 94 * *ve -138-

Page 151: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

at x

x z z -9

-~1 -1 i g-g :

N a 10r -. 'r *zre 4 ~ -I r n

W%4 . L tit t00 M 0 1" Z M 10N0 P

z #o 4;Z 4N4

&. -j t- t-9- U9 - LI. P- a-. M

-~ ~ - - Z4 *.d

49 0- -

KG* t I", W"a-- 4 A 4 lK K

.9b-. -zl

-- - ~-139a,- z0

Page 152: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

uj W

0 -do ~ ~ n 4 MAN100 4 a r az OR0~

4#NNNE PN 4 0# wt in UA z In sE~f- P-0 ~ #~ a -d0r NNN-dNNN 9 a )N

0 Z I ~ P P W tn 000 0 % 3.

.4 W 19 E I~~0 .ILfNM 49 Ui. - w a 2jIA 70 I W44 a0 U 49 O4In I. & I. IL4~ 0N N.0--0'NN -N N 0 0t I. W

0 I-~~~~ zIIaa N - iI.-mf~ at

-~~~ ~ 0 40 u 4 0

UU0

94 40A0m- .m- " 9 ' --IA -0 K-MMMMWW44N "N w 1- -cy N 0 A*ffloi"flP-m'i 44ma u &A' 5 4f

2 9 1-" -4 94"O10.P -41. r-P4. - ON N cm ey>. 4L4- -rrUfr - - 0 . coo

I0. l4 N a% m mvP.mp- . 9% inn or- in * In 4 04

4A In CYb NNP- bo0- 0 N V4 pd-fNP.NN0 z 0-4 m Wjuj N m. N 4"m f mmMM.4 m m N K 0-j 0 OA60 g zO 62 W543 -9 x a .a6)N u 0n-2

0 44 M&WA44ILIL .JX IKWK.i 01 z ac UUUz - 4944NZ z 4 Z & . $- z V, a ---

19 z 4 z; Z U. co

K Ix"C9 0

0~49

IL 4 ILwn 0D 1-mI4Nr s 404Ni rWoI %. fp

In 0.f~n v % tII-P Z .. d 0 r- w -d -d.40 40;! P. P .r- r- 8ý I jtyN

-4 1-~n~P. M% m 0 44I4 1ý F- r- coo.

- 8 % aNN P.In I~nn 0 D 0 0cyIn I f *V in q%*1 4 j P Ce 0 v -I'--P0-44 00

u 30n . 1.- 1ll U. .0lzln' a 0 x N zI.; IfN0 AMC In UP In 2000

Ue 49 C J 0 I ~ .J 4c. 3Ico

M -a. M~~ #3 A., " In W iu iP. P4. W% N N Bm.44 4U .4 F- 0 ---0

In mU 09 FU In m4tmm0m 4 KZ N m 666w s 0I I

.0 In in P- r- . F- r- .4~0 In 0 coo0. PAaI Nndn N i4..- 4 U O

u 04 8 In00 0 .c , , wlbJ~r

-140-

Page 153: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

j(.MOt- M N 0

u ccor a, 4 z 0 10 t- 0 0 0Nj MNA LIQ 'A U .0-NMII weI.

0. 0c 99 0 00 0.id0 L0

&l z NSN M. Z% N0C CN P 00S 0i 0 C!4 CO 4' 044'

0 .4A

LD of 0 - 4LU

0 z U U. r n4 0 M N O

0 6 6- P.P. $-. c 0t P. U*40NM F Uam P0MP UNO InF Z uCO 0 P. 4 o-N M 4 %0aP.1P.-NN O~ NNN-i 4 000 z J0..000000O.".0 CL 0000 cc 00 cc de~ 00UC3000000

0. z1- 0 -7 w f 06UO @ ' Z Z4,tl'0o'0-N O4'

I.P. uJ.M U co UJý P. U.0 0~- 0 .UJ2 %A Z L

U .M04 4 .1 iL 4 Z N uI.F O00 0~N 7 .. 0 2 2 IL444tt1CD ccIA c P O

0- 4AFA 'A w

0 a

F- 0 NN'DNo0 0 P. 0 '

P.4I=I0NO 6C00 U P.00 - -f r- ý0NPM400M1 -Nev N C ON N N fN0 ..J 000 0 -1JQC 1, .J 0 0 0 000 LL 00000 00 2. a 0000000000

U) I- cc L

44~~ 0 WZM M , . * Ub- Uj z

4u 2

0.-.0

IL

M CY 0 0 00 P..40 M 'o UMO0'.4INMI NN N ONNNNO 0000 ccx .J000000O0-I-"00 00000 000 0. uj 0000000000

4A 0 .. i.Ni N M'.- 0 0 PJ411P NO a(P-13.000 P2 .. t N U4.6.

UUO - P

Page 154: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

IN 100 p %P NMfW

*LALA'0' N0N.

.W m -4 .4 m N N00000000

'0 ~44NN NN

0 N POOpqN N0 P. PUwIn -W

m 4 0 L 0 10 fý N Nfpo. .4 -4 N N00000000

M 4N N N N N

ON4P.4NN

0 00000 00

w4. N4 Nq N NN

- -4 N mIti. -# in .0ta PAAA Wk in LALnAk I

-142-A'~

Page 155: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

10

- . .4 Pd d 0 .4 4 @4 m w4 .4.O4. 4.4. 4 .4.4W.4 .4 .4 .4-1.4.4.4 .4.4 .4 Pd 4 d .4.4 .4 .4-4 MMM(1MAMM MvM l"MMMMMMMMMi ,i nffM4 %4

C;t

UN an 0 U4K W ~ 0j:. N & &U Z aa OM~e . *- eL U

U~l 0 0. Wt . W S.Z - X- IL .0w I- A LU

I! :; I IL dl 2 f4~Ca Kg -K 0-A -. :

-. u *j 22 u. z a~U WI- 0 0- 4

49 P 0 *a .2E C0 C 21a .2- * -J W4& 3. ueU. O I-

aON K-1= 002..m of

too, 0-C 2E j mJ ~ -- 4.WOwl a 4 Z 0 0-9: Ag .0 U9

)fI- CLE 0 E b-- 4i* -- Q0WW

nozo o -- i 0. ;4 1.f- .4e0 A,0 at -. ;%!. P WU4AIWJ X . U,

IA o P" 00 02 2 C -l''4aaO UI.- UKVIOW 2% I

IL & " - in'. 049 *.J j wm W2 J2J 4 W ;:z

.J -1 o -UUW .099S wCowK zP4 te I2 U. -gw w Ge 14i M W- .0 . ; ZWZ ZW2*W24 Uw N NCya - aa N:& cc . iS I'2 *- Sc1. t

N a -*.W4NO 222Sz2mIA.. * '* =a IL. 0.U 0 L; 0 M iný i VA0 NOD N

2- N-n-' 00 Z00 jC K.0W fN- 050 2 4- It 22 . 0.Z~nf .

LW 0 4U w'4 w-OU *1%0 a in .4 NY0 22249 1 K t; oU 0~n-;: W W -U a

Wj x 4KC innM in2 M0.0M.0.5 && - z1 a5

2 z Z 2 .J4 0 22-.-.2--- I- I.-- 0 ..- W- 0 0 W" uz Lz -4 -4-4 P4 222 5-L. 2 1

~~Q U, U -- II.III 000 02 20 2 2 m- 0 44 44 22W -

m j K i & CC C2WA 0 W 2a 0000 0000 WUWWWK UILW LU.W

n0ý 0 W u UL U.U.IU. L U. U.I.LU.L OCC~ -in Ge A104 .N. .4N -y " M0 M 4

P-o 4 .4UJ N NNe

-143-

Page 156: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

4 m P.:0 C" 'm M .p- 0 a NM A,0- 0"Nm b,40)

P4 0 0 04 1 .N ý -P k - " 04 0004 1,1,0 ý0 .0.0 AAAI nv lA4 %i ni ni AM i ,. ti %W %W %.W %9

coo0.00000000000000000000 000000000000000

LU

# 0 z; ff% 0i

0 - 4Zi fI j .0 01 w w- - P.-

X - wz I- WO- 0f6 AO* x -4 azNI-. z m m Pf6 a P. &D CL

0- * 4 1- w rn 'U N. x w 4L 'N (D - S.A LO0 0- - 6 0-. 0 .$- "

* 0 a. N - -%0 0-M O p - In z = xN m w j -- z -0 m It z -. "W wj

a a U 0 c 0u 0 - km 9 I.0m 0 1- 0-0 -op- N- W W 0- w w U- W I-- J

N. 06 U. a. w Ge U ac 0 L ac 0 p 6-. 44of L

.0 ~ P. O4 0.. p. 4- c0 It 4ý 2o % 4 in Wx mm toa f" M aL m en a6 M cc

06 4 - -- .4U t~N 2 144-0 .1 .4 .

Page 157: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

IE

IE- 9 - .

ac K 01

1 .1KdZ ac 44

44 4 4u fK Kg

U I K

M ;. P.#

P. *-4 0

* 1. . u J + 0Ki-9 ac 9 -4W n f0 -&L 2

w CLL LLI LI ILILI Zj ZZ 49 z -2.-Z12z & z

N WL.- I.- W L*~Z "I - P: .

I- N N u . LI- a N - .I- " V.) - 0 - 00. L

- in 4a aO w a 00 ,4:4 4W n wi

0. LI 1 0-'iw n W2 0 W .0 NZj 0 4A- 0-40 Jj 0 -

U. 0 -* P 4 * -M-i x 0 -I- 0 LL LI -. 0ae-t

2 0 -w o w 4- 0f Il- '4 C -4-0

P- a -ý 0 0 0Y m in0~~I 0- M Z% MN~ inL U-4

Page 158: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

44

I- I

0 ce I ccoc ccc ooc oacoccK~KKK KKKK KZK KKS KK6

owe zz

ki0f

4y

-9 F- IL IL 4 CLI L 4

9L IL IqLU0 I- I.

o=* 2 = me 0;0.C

Uj-1- 0- b- 0- P-I-I n0 L 41-1 - 0- 0 A C& m LU -z z :W =db o

A- o 1 0-0 .i0 W o81 0

c~z !:I - z -~ & -""I-

-e -0 U Wa- O X-QN - M

.a (- cc a, 0 0 N M N VSin 0 In In InV r- -4

44146-

Page 159: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

0 In

I-W mI'-N. W4I... mr 0. 0.e '

B-mf.4'4..e.' 00w U F z .4

b. j Ww~0@m .n z. U. 04 ON NNM NNd NN NN 49 0 W W ofo- I

0 -a4..oJ. w .90 W -4 4ULI - 0 aL u I.- I- 1- K 4

0 zZ 0 Kt at

at a CAof -* 0 nA4440InM W 1 m

(.L a WmN OM 4*NNN i 0 O M O

4 0m . F- 1 -P nP - f-0- 0 9 ..I.i.. WW 4P- - P. r- P- #t- P. P P 0 A. 00 a.IL W N .ca04- m-w C a. a.

0 9 WONN0MM0OIMMNM z u 41ZW ~ w AM6 t0 u W at U. B(A A 0 oNNN N N .4N NN NN K 0 = LU 0W Nm f.m 0 z

-l0 4AaZ~~Xa.,OA, Wu W0 I4C at i INC 0 ww..i of - -K . 44NW 22a&&. z 0 cow 0K UUU..J u 44K - U. CD

(.5zz IAz z 4A

IA W -9IA CL u I.

N .~04 -eN IAr(q. a. B- 0 00 0wo UNNNOP.4N ItNN N0 UN 0 N.4 Ci0 -4 B- r 0P~.F 4 -4 M- F-4 P- P-. 0 0- 0 .4 0 j 14 .4 0

UN -4 - P-r- In In M -P.- I- - W% 0 0 z 00 &Lu 2 49N 0 0ý04i n0a -#0Mc 1--..4 4A

Uoo uJ U0NN 0 00.4It0 m N 0 vp UB - VA Z .4 z0.-B LU NN.44.4N N .BN N. .4 1 0 0 w

N 9 -. '0m N 'BN a a0K x0 B-O W 0- & a - ) 3. P- do U

-0 C6a. x xUK 4 A C K w ) oIA - - 0B- B-.9 L I.B- I 49 4 OD cc

49 U z z1- 0-z K9

01A,

(Az

0-B in -. 4 WInN N in 4 [email protected] 4 BM0 1.- 0- WtU N .4 N N ?(Bm'B.-B4 . tN a 4.4 4 U N WN-0-4 CI Pf40-14IB .. o M-1 U 0.4 -

In r- ON61% p M -InI0 0 100

UW U0 N00~f~ QUwJ U .

Ma..4 x'CKKw2.JN WA5 L 4 z 49 za M -0.OC

z

-147-

Page 160: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

z)

20 nmm %4qP

Nmmi N *.Nimnlf-0 0.4 m 1*

0 00 at 0 00 00. 400 .4 ofoo oo o

69 w

NC9 U. b- I.- z Qwm

%a 0 0l .

IL P 4 mW % r nmP %I

o 4 000- I- 2 WO OO O c0 - K U

0- 0 zw U

z ~ ~ I 04W %N14 4 z0 ZNt -i n.

z w .I.-.

Uc 0 ccO 0 - 4 0-eIinj

4W 19I - U

0 c I -P %40 0 rWa

K .C mW 0n int -4 4m 40 iU0 4Z 0 0 .4 " N 4 UWIn -- 04

a in- 0 P. ac NIMN OI.LIA u at J w

w . In 1- 0. U 4ý ..

0 0 z

U U

- zn* 69 N I~044nn

.4I t0 0 0 m -VI m40I

P- 0 0 w m n 4 f -lN- 4 4 0P4 U0 P- 004 4 4N 4 P- aiinn

In 44 .. % 0 ..

r- 4m 0 K r

I.- jU.z w z aUJ 4

Page 161: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

C',

0%

N m.4~. 9. " - dAP 944 -. 1-l 44141 0 10414 . 4.. 14 ... . 14 - . .4 (414414441 1441411(41II1141141411("4 n "f "0 "Mf n(

-Ju x

LU 19 1

4- 4i LInuj C~L t g

0 L U AL. i - 80 ;-j.. K* LU 9u Nu.j MU A. IC -j J--+ 0

I- .. LU 0 u 4L NW

-U . ..JU .Jo LU *4-

IU -LUJ a I-LU0 A CI. OfL1 -9 LU OK LU X C 0 W

- ~ - cc I-L 4- .OzL 0 z .LU C l 4JQI U - N LL 0 LU.

x( .. zO N LU 02 u I. u . kmL~ K.4 0.- ZK=* - .9 . cc.

ui K L L xC N 2 I C LU ne 4 U An-LUg c .40 41I 8* 0 ww 45 Li ICCU n

z L w4 44 zII S i - - ZL 4 A. 2 LU2

ag -2 -O U4 K LU C0 24 LU - -LU0 1

0 0 ZN/ > LU Lu 0 0 - I.- -A - 2- 0 21. OW 0U LU - W234. at LA LUJ

ICIC - 4I 0 K -J 2 4/ - 3 Lu44j IC W n - nnn Z~ 0 'A Z 9Li CLL41.-O - 4.o-4LU L 2 c ui : Lu 0 0 Z LZ 4A LU LiA- -at 44>

-a0- X C mCC LU -L 0 CL 0 n K I.-=IL .4 LWz KK4 - L0- 4 wU 0 QmwUI t-

LU o 'A a ) Zn AA aU.- ILK Aw w-2 LU4/A i tL ZO 0a 0- Of of-L Qi -

J -70 0) LU - LU b- LU0 2A CL .9 a I.- .. L- 400 IW 0 I

O z o - L I--z 4 L M ~ % i 4 0 Z U. ý .JLI%at * 0 U Mi 2LUJ - 99 zULmLa cc .Z...aALU-co . wIL 00o00 LU~ 00 U. Qi 0 K4

0 /IA L > iL Q / Z 4-A z W41 - 0 or aLUO0C Lu0d * M a.c LU uO LU - 9 UiL .j " w0uUw

4 LU -91'.- 4A z ~ 4A 6-U =4 0 . .. 2 c 0 -z LU K - A-w - 0 U..u -.a .L6 w-~ LUw -KA.OKKZ x0 Li - K LU I.-WOWu .4 LKD 02 GeZ= L 3 4 U Lu cc

z 0 >. = z.ZL 3 > > 0;aczj 4 z #A n..jJýg0- LU 0- U. 0 0WL 2 LICU.-1&D Z LUc . 449 = . -0 a[L U Uj LU W49 - L2 LU WJ0 0 K - 2

LU LU - 9 0.4 .KZ - K 00 - 49 A.A.L 2w. an L +Lad o w wU =N iL "C 0 e l - 0 46

-Q N0 N z N " z Ci Lu ICi .* N 0C, -C NL~ a n " 6 fA "A.HWN LN LU 0 N NNZ ac

m( z K UOO/ an wo 4 La IA 3 LUI LULa- 0. inI LU a$ > LULA.x i .0 LccN w it AL # II M6 W OUi CD 1-- 1 A N -4 6 I f 4-I1a

$-. D. Q- C 1W - " C.ALa I%% - -Ci -. 94 4 z 4 2C3 x z~ LU 22W-.M x z K2 49Z

K Q

-149-

Page 162: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

F_ it P F.I. .ff P.P. .1. of P.0. .P 0.P. P P.P. .P P. .P 1-r- .P

00zzO zi z0 z X01220221222000020000

L4-392

4 4-.2 I:

or Ge Q0J 2 W

. W U

o9 * 0- f: 0

Wj a,-*

L4 In f 0 n-P0 = 4 in 0 4 m 9t

or U, 0 -4 ty N aU

00 ~ 4 '0~ 1" 44 0 0

.0 f"4N CY m%;U w- w 2 N 0 #A z0,' 0 UU Z U C 0. 4L 0 1

a N PN 10 0 9L 4 Z 4L-IuU,.=U~ 0 1 *1- 49 z. 4A

-~~~- 040 4U 2 * aw* I

0000-- U. iL .N NL O 00 0o w 0 00 I.- . & Uof ~ 0-400 Z4W do Z UN z-w

N N : 2c c-K U. W.4 -

-150-

Page 163: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

I-c %0- n4PN 44U %i nU %i 0004.4I - 4 4 dC

Nx Z

x49

0..

04

22

zz-I

LU Ney 3

0 30KL:ý 1 4

0 1--

CA z I+z . UJ0 z- zU A - o

ae 0 U, w .1 1 + 4- on

000 oo 0 Z(0~ ~ ~ 0ULJC C0 U 1T U

a: - AV -9 x *o z zoxaIi 01 -2 U'- I-zZý L 9CLU m m - a.. z -4 0 0 i

U 9 0 0 Lo Z 4Z %* %M aW" 0 ; -. xU,& aZ3 04 U CC -U-0 NE -i N~ gux N1

2 ~ 9 0 "AN 'n.O O 2 - Il Z - 24 1.- -

Nw 1W t 00 iS ,~

0x WZZ WZ- IC gu '0 4NWNWJu 1 0is

LU ul

K in F- 0o -i --

Page 164: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

510

N maC MV - CPO 04P000 0.0090 0a 000090

N

z

IL

*- -z I M

- 40 0

.j 40A

IA cc4A0 .. K

;; IA

I0 -

0 9 4 wo 399 1at v I .0 Cie 0

z z% - N ;

U. u - - I' z 1VWI 0 0 .S. 4A Z N

-U R a . 0 44 U . U 0 -zi 0 *M- = 4 -xj 15- I 4 -a

z - U. )V LWI. k .0 A4 a09 0 Vw0 2 4 -- :4 - M V -ce + 1 + WI +A Z2 4 0 ZN

.. - LW3 OX WI- CO %n )Z1 0WUO to 0I 0 4u c wN2 -MgU -- I

LD - 2 j N V - 0 0A-0 020 I V4

U. * .A 41 00 z U. I- 2 U. 0 b0

-C 40 - 4~ .4 N4 f"4 -i N- 4

4 Ni- Al N y 0 0S We V. -ui MWI N -4 *. I-Ne - 104. 0 Z I -N -

WI .. J Z NV Z'-~ . WI? -15-- C -. 4 * 0

Page 165: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

N ln~%nwb m

00020000000000000000002000 a 00o000zzz zzzzz xxx zEZKZZ xxii xi

Kg:::xxxx K K: KKzKKKzKKK22zEEEzxlzz

xN

-a-

K -

9 >

0 3949 Wi cc -

x 0 01 -

9 z u

J~ :

b.- ,,- K it X X 0 W ~ I -0 o .- I IA 0- 44 < =-

zMN 99 ;N S U -- g-0u"IW .~ .~ art+ N W- *,.0 , It.U

x 12 - 0 ) UAW Z31091 MS~ * -- -5 x 0 -93

-* -040 ~ 40 00 0 U

I- > C

Z. Of M oIf n I

-153-

Page 166: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

4 P--r-.P.P-pp.-Pp- m m w aa a a M00.0,0 , a .0

N 9 X

SI

L I N 1- *-

a n L:UP

9 -44

*p a,-

cc -,9 0

+ + % I I

*U -- Z -

LU ifý Z 40

-, -4 A -I-

.J -40 0 00 J -z4 z4 9 ý- -ý 0 a 1-NI

0.9 -. . 0 LLLL.O

liz13L 0 Q0

o9 N-c-. -- c

0-4.r -n 0-0-04 -4

2 44 21-4.- Z -154-g -

Page 167: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

I % 0 4 4 I .04"00

a-.

0 jN .9

a z

I- K4z

0. L£ -i L -

-a 0 0oe go .0 0

. o In W 40 0y n a!

ee C 0 OD

P: w1: Na 6-

CL CLF 9 -I

-a 00 . >09 C0 K NO K N- P Ci

4A a.t 1. 0+ W 04 09C; a tv cctt a HZ 0. 1. a ~ 1.0; -- 0 .Z - z -x

z m a -i 1L w a ac 0j m ac

I- CL0 CL-x w0 aL . 1. CL & W & I. 0.C-M o- b.. 01 l ý L$- I 1- -9 -9 L . 1- - 0of 22) XCY z 0 K . - :) z 20y a4 11IAi-- z z z M,0x N0- ý

ww~ a>z. -42 . -j 0. 0. t' 0Z Z 0.W'--Z ~ 70 ~ 0 0 I.- I.- '-4

0 *0 1E 1 -U -9 + 4

0: CC I-44 0 LL0 &- of w o ý z i- 'I -g WW~~~ O O A4~~. N LL- 00 2 2 0Ci- 3 xW~ 2~Ii -0 0 n~ He W le4 P.- 30-.

K - 0 H W% 0I N i 1 0 0.J-- aU~ M- 6N 310 U% -0 2-IK P4 r-- 40-

-155-

Page 168: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

0 p-w 0 0.4 M 4UN o- 00. .4ty 4 % 4r 0 l~o c~m4 I

cy m m4# 4#44-%%i wUL Awtt 00 ~ 0 0 0 0 0 O 0 4 4

- - - 9 c c c

LU LU

K- z cc W

x LAJ C*. %4 X

Lu 4 K ' - 0 0

-j z. 4- = 0l,

LU 4e (3 ~ f *0.I-CZ -i -i _j - 0J- >SO *- _

M -9 -4> wzd I.- Z . -9ixU > zC~U OLUJ :)u

0. 4 -&A >LU - -Zof 419 ui x- x LUW cuj

of CL - 1. , V )1- 0Z 04 .4 C. X 3e &A 0 .0N0O -ý xK 4-r -- 0C;~s

OD M ZOO- 0 -L x 0.tDýu K 0LOU am. Z 9O -w A X . , =-'O !

cc M ' M M N x( e t- x N. 0.-LU 0-9 040 z L" XX . 1- - o

LU N - PJ *N.44 0 c WIA8 rm*suzo! MUL L W -J&wW)( 't0Z0 - $-Do

& C. . M. a6 . M M 4 - 00)( -'S-b- 49 4 4 49 2 44K9 .- W-LO-0 0- u0D I- I- I- I. b... I.- t ;S~-N x w .

ce0 w O C .co LU LUJ LU Lu I-. w U 0,

0 .0. CL CL U CL0 CL LU W S % .~ UL4 .4 Z4 4 49 Lu .9-90 10w x w % 4 z 0

1.- .5- 6-% X- ý -I0 0I 4.4 aeu- Ou2 - 0 - w -0 p. 0X S-0l - + Z Z Z Z

5- W- C.& *C. M. MUC 20 CLZ 0' I~~ N-I- S-I-- I- M0b- 0 - 4 P- -US- - -;;4-S

oe O M = I D zozz b-ooM -! :-:wi 0-0 -0 -. Ko*C.2000 0

- 0 o ~u.;ý Xs 4s&ýý;4LU00 0000000 zcr it~ C -M.U.-.33 uwwwwU w wU. LL.U.U.U LU

4c P-Ur. in M0 ýo 0 N en t A 10 F- a,- N 4K ODG G D o G 0 0ý 00 c. 0000 0 0sO0'Cyýfn M M~f

-156-

Page 169: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

II

2 zwLU

44 r-f"o t mP

B- - I- f- '0 kf% LA U 0 6- P-9N N m m 4 r4A 0 0 (1mf" m " C JryI 01IflIWmfE%

w (" 000f n 00 ff f" jt"0M00000mm

LU LU oc o V) coI ~ C, fU o~~ccrII'0'0u Qj bU 49U.1*P U N~ 1-

- 4. 0 4 in LU LN a aLU ~ ~ I 0. t-p -P.P-P - -. P

o 0 - w I- a~ CU ~N '04ILJ-fI

N ON0

I- co wL U0 ccCUU

2~ 0 Iz C 2;

4 0 0-e - C

2 ý 40 t0 It *I - 0O1NO1N -0N 10ce LU I Ui 0-.PO i F-fC,0tn U U .0- of - -I N f~

I. K u. K MIIMMf 0 ONN 4 It- 0 - M M M 4 CEj f£ l .f~f% LU ommm m

0. 0 00000 0L. 00 0. 000000000 9L

0 Q 0 M ri-I P- zooý#4 ni O%LU LU 0 w P- ?-r- P I--r c L. I- L U- -P -vi Z~0 0.d4II--4 m LU0

- 0 InI-U X ml 0fI fA 0ý 0 0 LLU04c LU)i f at V ..i M0001.0002 LU 0 20 0 - -NNN

0L - 2U. aD OD 0 UU0030LU 0. - KA

4 %A 0

-j 0- -1 49L0L fA LU) 40 ý 4 0. 9L b% i dI mi diQ P- -- .0 -0I'I 0 'A*NuUB- n - 0 YN i" t

U M- M M- en B--'.OAt ty U 'NU aC f"N n m 0% 0Or- 0 P. > 0 0 C" "m( f" f" 0 1 0 C 1 mm ' f

0 r- 0000000 Z 000 L. 00000000

.j 0 ON kn " - o (In IýI DI A Ny0 kn IUm4 U' U. u cc co PQ- f- 0 Z~ zo0,M 2 u-.MntrlA'0LU w in LU LU w P- # P P P. j IL - w U. FI P. P~-r- t-

c o N -A 0 i aJ 0I-I ý-0 0 LU- --~-- 4I.4 -I

0 N0 4 w x4.0Mpit 1- -li 3&0 I0 NM C" NvooCco00

-9 4- _4 -C .1 .N

OD 0CD4 U -- U

0 -1 c

0 C,

b. 10 B-i N - . N N N 't 0 NP-'-~ýf-r 4- 4A I0* 0 Q''0~ U~0 M -OMNNMM44*

0 00000000 00o 00000000

0 1 ~N GoIt0 N in NI'r0N 40 -ro i o w 00o LU U - t- t- zooM0 f UIN w 4In IA 4 0

L P. LUj. o wP- CF PU~- t-P P1 U. w .1 .Pt -r .r

0DcoO UQUIU--

-157-

Page 170: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

Z :; o 4 10 0OOC4

feyNN NENNN-'4N 000o 0 .. ooo0"ý00o00900000000 00o 000000

af P~- r.7N 40- N4 w0QL 4 z N 0 - CO'0 1-4 - Lý0 M0 0Ui U.

04Ny LU

N~~ ~ zfI N." -4 ZY 2 -M 4V r -I - ..J b.. = LL

UJ Lo~l 3 z LU

LnLU IL

0~ ~ 0- 0 jý

M NN. N0Nm 'I-f Q~ -0 00 a 0 ..J LiM440N

NN N N..N 4 Qi000 -J Z .Jo00c-00000000000000 Of 000 0- ofa 000000

b- U - LLU

LU (A U.

LU -

-dW Zx I- - 0 LU4

0 or3 a 0 - A

LL0.c U. CL

LU N O N N . cc 0 0 U 3 .J 0 .

000 L.3000

M --.4 0 0 Q 6 z zL M-j ~ ~ 000 w-Jo ý

00000000 co CL- 3 000000

Z~~~a 010NNN f Go K- 1" 4-- LA -4JI U ~ ccI IL z -4

LUW LI2. 0 uat 0

CLM

coU

0 Or0 0P0 UINr-O lo IA-a V- Ln at- IN 4m0 10N m 9 N 0 4Qp-4 I0-4M t. LU Li' F~-4

mmr 1 -N %Ar ct -r It tj 0 N0 0i C in 4- 1IIC0 .4 N4 NNN~4 0000 W ( 0 x jo000 -4-'

19 o0 Coco00000 co 000 0.!- LU 000000

0 4N 0N 0 .4C* 4O -4 0 o Li ZNM4?V0ma

r- P- 00 - -0 F- m It 0 -jU

4~- 00 40N fn- 10.J a- In 47.fn

WLU WII 04- Luu~oOouoOoOoo LU K-

K K-

Page 171: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

C'.

!d 4 No N NNN

f~~ 000 0 0 0

0

N r

% 00P0'00O.00N 00N 0 N r 0 0 r I* m m

.z -N N N N Ný N w 7

0 P- N -. 04' 14- WN N -

::~ N kn Q'~ 0 ' N 0 . momm4 4WN It .4 r

a,

0, MA N. 6A 44 % N (1% '0 -to oooo oof-ooo

4 . 10 4 99.O-N

'r P.4-.-- N. w.4 N N NA

N NN0m 0 km

-159

Page 172: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

4 de

I- IuL

a :)

4 .. 9or LU -4 .0 -WJi o

-J40 ~U.01 0

U z U£~ ccLU amz 'ww- w o

92U. a. 9 J a.

zJ x 0 x-0. z z WZxW LU ta. Oooau 0Q Z U

N N F-4 &ACK * -- - -. 9

WUjN -44 X U..j0- &a aL.- zz

41 zJ -i ae f0 00 *LU -. 9 00 Q D -- Z

z a. ZZ UJVI)U --~ 0 .J *-- ~;. Iau -- *- Iu coI~ W

2 U. Z 3. ~-Lf9aw Xn W W0 J o- o - u- o- 0 * LC .4-

wl z~ W z ZWU - 0

Ui -Q U 00 .2e W of Wi Uj 0

LO a.WLZ OC ; 2 0490 +0 1. d W:0 2~ *- z

LU P- 6lW 01 of -z Z NS+UN) au N .X *0U4-

W 6 "Wi ; UI4N.: 1:W 2; SI O N -4 zz a.5 20 0* Q I N0I U -j WX a - 0ccj~ 9 of2QK 0-4 2f bc . %9 0W c 49 %z 4 zWo i z W C6 at2- 4oW- " XU . -

UU Z * *U- -X-I It U dw 9cc LU lm a 0 LU IIu..jz W4 0 4wU

LU -j z . .t . 0- " UQ-U. 11 1- NQ1 49 - -.4 N W .0. O ..J 0u z0

4.1 Wvi U 2 Z . U.9 (.W U. w L3

cc Q 00 mi

-160-

Page 173: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

Il

000 19.0 0 0P a 0 0 0. 0 0 00 0 l 0 00 Q P4 00 .4. 00 0 0000 N

zxzxzxxzzxzzzxzzxzxxxxzxzxzxxzzzzzzxzz

4

LU

V-

U..U

LLU

U.1Ccc

CL L 1

a.zU - 1 L

4x N I

,. L.1 U. L o0 u I)t -. -Z T

m I- U.

W 1 lIn w *4 *4p- C

4w -o *Y - C14 N0 ry--C

Q 4- Z i fi

Page 174: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

C. N N N NyyNf"fn M~% J a~ ka 0 ' o w % J .% I.0 .

-4mmmmmmmmm

ac CCC.C~)C~Ctu .a ;a ;a .ad X.L X a.C

w

w

-LJ

UiUX

.. W0u. ~

-162

Page 175: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

'4 0 . . O

x z vF-0P -C

LU L L U i % w

I.-

W IM

4 0 4 00CXN I- U 0. z40

02 'a - -Qu4aP- 10 M It Xm--

-0 0 0 U. '0 0J 00

X U UU0 in I.- Kjr-L r %OfZ 0 4 I- N Uj

C4 0 W r£

4 . Z; - -C4 co U.

* i 2. Q Q-U U a)

2 -4 Z4 vi Z L?

U U£ I I- -A3~f m ILi-j 4A uJ LU 10 £ ~ Q 4"4 ' -CL C a. IU a. U' 4 eiV 4 c

4 0) -C U.4 P- U1--40. 4 ry r u I-uc z-J .- U 0 t- 0 0. Li . 80i 00d0 i 0 -i

oe C2 UL. Wo UCQI

£~~~ '4 0 0 % 0 O 0 rMu lu U .u "w '4 Q )z -r-wMQI

Ki -% UU LU -Ui jW n nt % %

O~~ ~ N UJZ .-- NW 0 0; UI- 0. - UU-- U .

LU~~~ Q

LU .j 4 .

10 m'n n4 woo

U~ ~~~~~ U4 4 U- 0-~ 0 0 coo -

U 0 0 0 0 U.) Q L00 0 0 .

cc M . 4 -0 ODOD 1 -.M ND 10

j VU% Wjin LD U UV Wl W% LU M IN fnN wt LU I

0L a 4 4ic

.4 UJ IL' LUA

x U.

LU LU63-

Page 176: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

z

LA.

0,-a

at

4 wm Ir 4%n QQ

OL wocboaoo-

j I- UNin- N. m ý m W NN 4 y ~ N~ f".tIt Na.U

m a 7. -- f u

z. w

x C,W U.

z M. d.Na.4 .. d4

a . 4 V V C r- 0-4 .

at 2

4 X. Pw PA N PI-

U.

L W6x - .- .NUAC

-164- U

Page 177: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

cc .1)1fl141 0.-4 4 9) UU)))))I). . 0 4 4'.1f

000 U) 0CC tJ CL CL0 00 C z00 rJ 000 0000 C)a ~ ~ ~ . -a cc. IN ZL2 w..222 0-22 ... Z2L Z LZ K.

j * U 0N >0 M 4%u

if LU -4 04 z

CL " I. -. Q A xIll 0 -9 3.t.L x~/ LU 0 C-- -- o-) 04 CL U) x Ui

WN a W .0 a 0 -& U 0 jQP. X9 ie.J LZ W 9- u xLiLA If - - 0i.4 L0.- 4 - U 0 -

.e 0.- 44N M N cc UU x 4xcx0.4 4 -a r.) )4I . L I d LUw

N (. a.IJ 0 .4 Z LU Q 0 11 W

-l x- LiJ L.) 1i LU-3.LAN~: LU *O. 0.4 00u 40

-- -tj41- Z 0 In - 2w >1- % - "I 0. . -i ULUm Z Li 1.- 60 cza -f a

1 IA * 4.~ -. LU 0 00 0

ZO - - U)0. 14 WCU-W U - w 111 474-Q4 C, W4U .I- z 00 -L U. x 9 QCL9U. 0.LI-1 )4 Q 1 U .. -J k

*0U). 4 *.e > -ac L z LUg ) W- D jU"j ;)I Q u I- u U LD 2. ý4, U.) vi x Ao i 0l LU Z Z.4 -:: I- . -

U) l.)4 0.4 i. UI- U 1 1. - -- U.1 W -4 WA. 14 A) Q1 44 X tI4u

-I -I0 441 W1) .0 > 4. 4- . 0U' .,* 0Z *022 w41 ac~ UII

-A UU1 0.. LU ZU. 0 -a) (2 1 i * -

x19)1 Ile00. 00i .4 "u. 01-0 w0 I 0 09

X 4.Jm ZI- -9 *' x.9J. a:LU 0: '1 1 U L I-C -.I.- -- ~ u zLI.- 449 .L-L I d 4 L .U L -

''LU j 4 0 -1~'0 U 04 .cu0N 2U.PJ .0 X Z .- j)JU. LU) P1 9-

- 1 -. 44 -9 .0 0- 14 1.-J 0. amL ) dc le Ld - a - a 4 0O:iC e -

0 i 49)1)9) x...0-U .1 aw x x a; 741 x I- a u

L. ce irL xZ?0 - at9't 4 2 - .41 .4L 0z 04 - L, -)4 w0 CS w w J00 LUl) 440 Uui uL 4.L4. *XII . L LL. LA. itLat %L at).1-1-

LU~~~ 0o C.20 4 4. U' .14 -~ z ~ LLL--------------------------979- ..JLIs

U U LULi 4 0165-

Page 178: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

Ny Nm * rw ~O-4Nm LA O0.ala4NMWUI% lot4OW v

N4 N ryNNNNNNN yNN4t Yc N N N N YN qNNN N NN N C4NN

0

ujK

o~ o

3c co e

I- - c a&

W.. Lm 4

zlM ad * -a 43 .4- -4e Q * L N a I. q b-1.- 6- 2

P . Ifl w 4 or1. "- Q~ -

u w. La~ 3. .0 W WZ. -j7UN t CL W.J 0. a. O a . z A. -. 9 .

X.4 li U.'d 1' MM 1- LJLU 34. W Ua LJ U-~-

-- R -9 ILCC IL4 0. Z~.' 0 0. 0 o.Z0 NV% lLa 2'. 1.-' L 1.- 0- *l.,

a-4. J W4 li ID j j ztA. u4 0. OW 00 1. 0.0.4

I.' :; uw U- 1-a ul--a4.u LC z4L z a x - 1 1 "o 0

J 0. N.4 0.e 0.0 0.vZ0.L-ZZL atLoW i - U. 1 -. 4I .

4. .i .W a a

CL 0 0. 4 L6 a c a 0 IL 31. 6 c wU x ~49 4 0, 4D Li I . -.- Z 1 ~ de U ~ 3 U3(

I.- 0y r. W% 10ALu ... we . 4 .I.4 Pkn .01 0 1010 Q'00

-166-

Page 179: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

SS '0

I El 4: E U

i;x 09 00 4: eý zi

64 r i ac o--C 3"k4 .. go.'.e u80S 0 k

z zu

~ ~E E

FJ go UiOUz 1

4Z IE 303 UP

X.4 coa

of. - = aSF o;r*. 0 1 0 t

W~41, 0 Al @ E

4=,

Page 180: 403 0351REPORT NO. SSD-TDR-63-14 TOR-169(3230-I1)TN.I "0 403 03510 j Quasi-Static Aero-Thermo-ElasticCC) Analysis: Analytical Development and Computational Procedure 1 MARCH 1963 …

a a a ai )

0 13 13 13Z z Z

b

0 a

I IS

I 'Io

hI -

'S 'S�4I

�A. Os.

''0

)

Qhi hi

__________ I