23
31 3 Hydrology and Landscape Connectivity of Vernal Pools Scott G. Leibowitz and Robert T. Brooks CONTENTS Definitions ................................................................................................................ 32 Vernal Pool Hydrology ............................................................................................ 33 Hydrologic Budget ...................................................................................... 33 Precipitation ....................................................................................... 33 Groundwater ....................................................................................... 33 Surface Water ..................................................................................... 35 Evapotranspiration.............................................................................. 36 Basin and Catchment Morphology.............................................................. 37 Hydrologic Dynamics .................................................................................. 38 Hydrologic Connectivity ............................................................................. 39 Population Dynamics and Landscape Connectivity................................................ 42 Metapopulation Theory ............................................................................... 42 Connectivity and Dispersal.......................................................................... 44 Wetland–Terrestrial Connectivity ................................................................ 46 Conservation Implications ....................................................................................... 47 Hydrologic Impacts ..................................................................................... 47 Timber Harvesting.............................................................................. 47 Land Development ............................................................................. 48 Climate Change .................................................................................. 49 Loss of Landscape Connectivity ................................................................. 49 Summary .................................................................................................................. 50 Acknowledgments.................................................................................................... 50 References ................................................................................................................ 51 Hydrology is fundamental to wetland establishment and maintenance of wetland processes (Cole et al. 2002). Hydrology has been shown to affect, if not control,

3675 C003.fm Page 31 Tuesday, June 12, 2007 7:39 AM 3 ... · Hydrology is fundamental to wetland establishment and maintenance of wetland processes (Cole et al. 2002). Hydrology has

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    2

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: 3675 C003.fm Page 31 Tuesday, June 12, 2007 7:39 AM 3 ... · Hydrology is fundamental to wetland establishment and maintenance of wetland processes (Cole et al. 2002). Hydrology has

31

3

Hydrology and Landscape Connectivity of Vernal Pools

Scott G. Leibowitz and Robert T. Brooks

CONTENTS

Definitions................................................................................................................32Vernal Pool Hydrology............................................................................................33

Hydrologic Budget ......................................................................................33Precipitation .......................................................................................33Groundwater.......................................................................................33Surface Water .....................................................................................35Evapotranspiration..............................................................................36

Basin and Catchment Morphology..............................................................37Hydrologic Dynamics..................................................................................38Hydrologic Connectivity .............................................................................39

Population Dynamics and Landscape Connectivity................................................42Metapopulation Theory ...............................................................................42Connectivity and Dispersal..........................................................................44Wetland–Terrestrial Connectivity ................................................................46

Conservation Implications .......................................................................................47Hydrologic Impacts .....................................................................................47

Timber Harvesting..............................................................................47Land Development .............................................................................48Climate Change..................................................................................49

Loss of Landscape Connectivity .................................................................49Summary ..................................................................................................................50Acknowledgments....................................................................................................50References................................................................................................................51

Hydrology is fundamental to wetland establishment and maintenance of wetlandprocesses (Cole et al. 2002). Hydrology has been shown to affect, if not control,

3675_C003.fm Page 31 Tuesday, June 12, 2007 7:39 AM

Page 2: 3675 C003.fm Page 31 Tuesday, June 12, 2007 7:39 AM 3 ... · Hydrology is fundamental to wetland establishment and maintenance of wetland processes (Cole et al. 2002). Hydrology has

32

Science and Conservation of Vernal Pools in Northeastern North America

many aspects of wetland ecology, including litter decomposition and the accumula-tion of organic matter and sediment (Bärlocher et al. 1978), the composition andproductivity of pool fauna (Paton and Couch 2002), and amphibian diversity (Burneand Griffin 2005).

Vernal pools are a type of wetland that normally experiences drawdowns anddry periods. Tiner (2003) notes that although alternating wet and dry periods occurin most wetlands, vernal pools experience extreme fluctuations in moisture condi-tions. This hydrologic variability, both within- and between-year, is a primary factorinfluencing species composition and productivity (Paton and Couch 2002).

Vernal pool organisms have special life history strategies for completing theirlife cycle under fluctuating wet and dry conditions (Chapter 6, Colburn et al., Colburn2004). Despite these strategies, a pool species can go locally extinct if hydrologicconditions are sufficiently harsh. In spite of this, the biotic diversity of vernal poolscan be maintained over time if local extinctions are offset by recolonizations fromsurrounding sites. This can occur through passive or active dispersal of organismsbetween pools, either over the ground or through the air. Recolonization may alsooccur, to a more limited extent, through surface-water connections. Landscape con-nectivity between vernal pools can be a major factor that influences recolonizationof unoccupied pools.

This chapter examines the hydrology and landscape connectivity of vernal poolsof glaciated northeastern North America. We begin by defining vernal pools andaddressing their relationship to isolated wetlands. We then review the hydrology ofnortheastern pools, and population dynamics and landscape connectivity. The chapterconcludes with a discussion of conservation implications.

DEFINITIONS

Northeastern vernal pools are temporary to semipermanent bodies of water occurringin shallow depressions that typically fill during the spring or fall and may dry duringthe summer or in drought years. These systems are bounded on the drier end byephemeral pools that do not normally contain standing water, and on the wetter endby semipermanent ponds that only rarely dry (see Preface, Calhoun anddeMaynadier). This book focuses on vernal pools associated with forests in theglaciated northeast of North America. Distinguishing features of these pools includefluctuating hydrologic conditions, presence of seasonally standing water, and occur-rence within the glaciated forest biome (see Figure 1, Preface).

Vernal pools often occur as depressional wetlands surrounded by uplands. Thesepools conform to Tiner’s (2003: 495) definition of a

geographically isolated wetland

:“wetlands that are completely surrounded by upland at the local scale.” However,vernal pools are often embedded within larger wetlands, and they can also occur infloodplains (Preface, Calhoun and deMaynadier, and Chapter 2, Rheinhardt andHollands). For example, Colburn (2004) reports that 7% of 48 vernal pools in theglaciated northeast were found in flood plain settings. Although they are oftenincluded as a type of isolated wetland (Tiner 2003), northeastern vernal pools donot have geographic isolation as a distinguishing feature.

3675_C003.fm Page 32 Tuesday, June 12, 2007 7:39 AM

Page 3: 3675 C003.fm Page 31 Tuesday, June 12, 2007 7:39 AM 3 ... · Hydrology is fundamental to wetland establishment and maintenance of wetland processes (Cole et al. 2002). Hydrology has

Hydrology and Landscape Connectivity of Vernal Pools

33

VERNAL POOL HYDROLOGY

The hydrology of vernal pools is determined by patterns in precipitation and tem-perature, connections to ground- and surface-water resources, losses from evapo-transpiration, and the physical and biotic features (including plant community com-position and structure) of pool basins and catchments. Factors related to weather areexternal to the pools and vary with time; physical site characteristics are intrinsicto each pool, are essentially fixed, and vary spatially among pools.

The hydrology of vernal pools is characterized by both

hydroregime

, which isthe temporal pattern of inundation, drying, and water-level change, and

hydroperiod

,or the duration of inundation (a component of hydroregime). The physical attributesof pools determine the general length of pool hydroperiod, whereas annual patternsin precipitation and temperature-driven evapotranspiration determine the year-to-year variation in hydroregime and hydroperiod.

In the following, we discuss the hydrologic budget of vernal pools, some of thephysical characteristics of pools and their basins that affect pool hydrology, and theirhydrologic dynamics and connectivity. As there are few published studies on thehydrology of northeastern vernal pools, we also draw on information from otherephemeral, ponded wetland systems.

H

YDROLOGIC

B

UDGET

The hydrology of vernal pools can be characterized by a simplified climate–waterbalance equation where the change in the amount of water in a pool is equal to thesum of inputs from precipitation, groundwater, and surface water, minus loss fromevapotranspiration (Lide et al. 1995; Figure 3.1); note that groundwater or surfacewater inputs can be negative, representing net losses. Studies have shown thatwetlands in different hydrogeologic and climatic settings vary considerably in theinfluence of these factors on the change in storage (Winter et al. 2001).

Precipitation

Precipitation is, almost by definition, a major source of water input to many typesof wetlands such as vernal pools. Precipitation can enter a vernal pool directly atthe pool surface or indirectly as surface runoff from the adjacent catchment duringa rainfall event. In a 10-year study of geographically isolated pools in centralMassachusetts, Brooks (2004) showed that amounts of weekly precipitationaccounted for more than half the variation in the change in weekly pool depths. Theimportance of precipitation as a major water source has also been reported for someCalifornia vernal pools (Zedler 1987; Pyke 2004), Carolina bays (Lide et al. 1995),cypress pond–pine flatwood ecosystems (Mansell et al. 2000), Mississippi forestpools (Bonner et al. 1997), and prairie potholes (Hayashi et al. 1998).

Groundwater

Groundwater–surface water interactions occur in nearly all freshwater systems,including wetlands and vernal pools (Winter and LaBaugh 2003). The interactions

3675_C003.fm Page 33 Tuesday, June 12, 2007 7:39 AM

Page 4: 3675 C003.fm Page 31 Tuesday, June 12, 2007 7:39 AM 3 ... · Hydrology is fundamental to wetland establishment and maintenance of wetland processes (Cole et al. 2002). Hydrology has

34

Science and Conservation of Vernal Pools in Northeastern North America

are affected by the positions of the pools relative to groundwater level or flow andthe geologic, climatic, and edaphic (soil-related) settings of the pools (Chapter 3,Rheinhardt and Hollands). Groundwater flow can occur at scales ranging fromregional to local (Winter and LaBaugh 2003; Figure 3.1). On a regional scale,topographically high locations function as recharge areas and topographic lows aredischarge areas. Local groundwater flow, relative elevations, and site-specific hydro-logic processes also need to be considered and may have greater influence (Rainset al. 2006). Changes in direction of groundwater flow, from recharge (outflow ofpool water to groundwater) to discharge (inflow of groundwater to the pool), aredetermined by the relative elevations of a pool and local groundwater. These direc-tional changes are mostly climate driven, as long-term weather patterns controlgroundwater levels.

The hydraulic conductivity (rate of water movement through the soil) of poolbasins and catchments depends on soil permeability and controls the exchange ofpool water and groundwater (Winter and LaBaugh 2003). These authors suggest thata hydraulic conductivity of 0.3 m d

–1

(1.0 ft d

–1

) separates permeable from nonper-meable soils. Vernal pools often occur because local soils have relatively low hydrau-lic conductivity or because topographic depressions have filled with impervious

FIGURE 3.1

Schematic diagram illustrating elements of a vernal pool water budget. Inputscan include precipitation, ground water discharge, and surface-water runoff. Ground watercan originate from local, intermediate, or regional flow systems. Outputs can include evapo-ration, transpiration, ground water discharge, and intermittent surface-water spillage. Vernalpools in riverine settings can also have stream input and output (not shown). (Adapted fromSando, S.K. (1996). South Dakota wetland resources. In Fretwell, J.D., Williams, J.S., andRedman, P.J. [compilers] National Water Summary on Wetland Resources. U.S. GeologicalSurvey, Reston, VA. Water-Supply Paper 2425, pp. 351–356.)

Precipitation Transpiration

Evaporation

Water table

GW dischargeGW recharge

Local flow system

Intermediate flow system

Regional flow systemConfining layer

SW runoffSW spillage

3675_C003.fm Page 34 Tuesday, June 12, 2007 7:39 AM

Page 5: 3675 C003.fm Page 31 Tuesday, June 12, 2007 7:39 AM 3 ... · Hydrology is fundamental to wetland establishment and maintenance of wetland processes (Cole et al. 2002). Hydrology has

Hydrology and Landscape Connectivity of Vernal Pools

35

sediments. Gay (1998) found the till soils adjacent to vernal pools in central Mas-sachusetts had hydraulic conductivities between 1.5

×

10

–3

and 6.4

×

10

–6

m d

–1

(4.9

×

10

–3

and 2.1

×

10

–5

ft d

–1

), clearly indicating they occurred on low-permeabilitymaterials. Pools can also occur on highly permeable soils where the water table ishigh. On the outer Cape Cod, vernal pools occur on fine to coarse grain glacialoutwash sediments with horizontal hydraulic conductivities of 100 m d

–1

(328 ft d

–1

)(Sobczak et al. 2003). Water levels in these pools match regional groundwater levelsduring periods of high groundwater levels. During periods of low groundwater levels,pool levels are perched above the ground water with exchange restricted by relativelyimpervious peat mats. At these times, pool water levels are largely affected byfrequency and intensity of precipitation events.

Where it has been investigated, groundwater exchange appears to occur mostlyat the pool margins, resulting in short groundwater flow paths (Phillips and Shedlock1993). Loss of pool water to adjacent catchment groundwater seems to be drivenmainly by transpiration from plants along the margins of the pools (Hayashi et al.1998). In prairie potholes, lateral infiltration to shallow groundwater, driven bytranspiration from adjacent catchment vegetation, was estimated to be up to 70% oftotal pool water loss in the summer months (Parsons et al. 2004).

Pool water specific conductance measures that are in excess of precipitationconductance values indicate the contribution of groundwater, which has a greatermineral concentration than precipitation or surface runoff. Palik et al. (2001) sug-gested that conductance measurements above 100 µS cm

–1

indicate groundwatercontributions for seasonal pools in Minnesota forests. For 65 vernal pools in RhodeIsland, pool water conductance measurements ranged between 19 and 376 µS cm

–1

,with a mean of 64 µS cm

–1

(Skidds and Golet 2005).

Surface Water

Surface water can enter a pool through runoff or surface water inlets and exit throughsurface water outlets. There is no published quantification of surface water inputsto, or outflow from, geographically isolated vernal pools, and groundwater isassumed to be a more significant water source (Brooks 2005). However, surfacerunoff from the adjacent catchment should play a significant role during snow meltor rainfall events when soils are saturated (Chapter 2, Rheinhardt and Hollands,Colburn 2004). Small depressional wetlands that have low storage capacity, such assome vernal pools, are vulnerable to filling at these times, which can cause surface-water overflow or spillage. Whether spillage will enter neighboring water bodiesdepends on the volume of outflow, the distance to the neighboring surface water,the permeability of the soils over which the flow travels, and the elevational differ-ence between the water bodies (Leibowitz and Vining 2003; Winter and LaBaugh2003). Low-volume surface outflows will generally infiltrate into the ground beforereaching neighboring waters. However, intermittent connections between isolatedwetlands and other waters have been reported (Leibowitz 2003; Leibowitz and Vining2003). In addition, vernal pools that occur within riverine settings are not strictlyisolated and can be connected by surface waters from ephemeral or intermittentstreams or be inundated by flooding of larger streams and rivers. Thus, surface-water

3675_C003.fm Page 35 Tuesday, June 12, 2007 7:39 AM

Page 6: 3675 C003.fm Page 31 Tuesday, June 12, 2007 7:39 AM 3 ... · Hydrology is fundamental to wetland establishment and maintenance of wetland processes (Cole et al. 2002). Hydrology has

36

Science and Conservation of Vernal Pools in Northeastern North America

input from other vernal pools or other aquatic systems may occur during episodicevents in these settings.

Evapotranspiration

Evapotranspiration includes evaporation of pool surface water and transpiration frompool and adjacent catchment vegetation, especially forest trees. Evapotranspirationis the principal pathway for water loss from geographically isolated pools (Brooks2004, 2005). Many pools experience a drop in water after trees leaf out in the spring.Evapotranspiration has also been reported as the major source of water loss for otherisolated, ponded wetlands including Carolina bays (Lide et al. 1995), cypress ponds(Mansell et al. 2000), prairie potholes (Hayashi et al. 1998), and California vernalpools (Pyke 2004).

Evapotranspiration is principally a temperature-driven process. Annual temper-ature patterns are less variable in the Northeast than annual precipitation patterns.Brooks (2004) showed that weekly water level change was significantly related topotential evapotranspiration (PEt) but that the effect of precipitation was 2–5 timesgreater. PEt peaks in the late spring and summer months when forest trees are infull foliage. PEt losses typically exceed precipitation inputs from mid-June throughmid-September (Figure 3.2). This period of water deficit coincides with the periodof maximum vernal pool drying. Pools dried earlier in those years with largercumulative water deficits, especially when early spring groundwater resources werebelow long-term means and late winter snowpack was reduced or absent.

FIGURE 3.2

Thirty-year average (1971–2000) precipitation (Ppt) and potential evapotrans-piration (PEt) for the Quabbin Reservoir watershed, central Massachusetts, and eight-yearaverage monthly surface-water depths for two vernal pools (503, 1710) on the Quabbin.

16

14

12

10

8

6

4

2

0

60

50

40

30

20

10

0AugJulJunMayAprMarFebJanDecNovOct Sep

Month

Ppt and PEt (cm) Pool depth (cm)

503PEtPpt 1710

3675_C003.fm Page 36 Tuesday, June 12, 2007 7:39 AM

Page 7: 3675 C003.fm Page 31 Tuesday, June 12, 2007 7:39 AM 3 ... · Hydrology is fundamental to wetland establishment and maintenance of wetland processes (Cole et al. 2002). Hydrology has

Hydrology and Landscape Connectivity of Vernal Pools

37

B

ASIN

AND

C

ATCHMENT

M

ORPHOLOGY

The effects of precipitation inputs and evapotranspiration losses on vernal poolhydrology are dependent on the pool’s basin and catchment characteristics. Basinvolume also determines storage capacity. In addition, the soil characteristics of thebasin and catchment control permeability, which affects groundwater dynamics,groundwater storage, and surface runoff. Thus, basin and catchment characteristicsare fundamental factors in the hydrologic budget of a vernal pool. Surprisingly littleis known about the morphology of vernal pool basins and catchments, or theirrelationships to pool hydrology. What information is available has been reviewedby Brooks and Hayashi (2002) and Brooks (2005).

Surface area is the most commonly reported morphological attribute of poolbasins, probably as it is most easily determined (Brooks 2005). Limited empiricaldata show that 66% of 430 Massachusetts pools (Brooks et al. 1998) and about 75%of 304 Maine pools (Calhoun et al. 2003) are less than 500 m

2

(0.12 ac) in maximumsurface area. Longer hydroperiods generally occur in pools that exceed 1000 m

2

(0.25 ac) (Brooks and Hayashi 2002). Pool size, either surface area or volume, affectsthe duration of standing water. Smaller or shallower pools have a larger perimeter-to-area (or volume) ratio, and higher rates of water loss (relative to maximum poolvolume). This is caused by either transpiration from forest trees along the perimeteror groundwater leakage (Millar 1973). For larger pools, water loss relative to avail-able volume is so low that these pools may be permanent.

Measures of basin volume, area, and depth are positively correlated (Brooks andHayashi 2002). Larger pools typically have greater maximum depths, but this rela-tionship is also dependent upon the basin profile. For pools of equal surface area,concave basins will have greater depths. Lastly, maximum pool volume is a math-ematical function of maximum pool surface area, depth, and basin profile (Brooksand Hayashi 2002).

We are unaware of any published studies on the extent and characteristics ofvernal pool catchments and their effects on pool hydrology. However, an unpublishedthesis by Gay (1998) concluded that differences in the hydrologic systems of twopairs of vernal pools were attributable to differences in bedrock beneath pool catch-ments, catchment morphologies, and transmissivities of catchment soils. The pairof pools with the longer hydroperiods occurred in catchments over bedrocks com-posed of gabbro, which weathers more easily than the gneiss underlying the shorterhydroperiod pools. The longer hydroperiod pools were located in bowl-shapedcatchments, whereas the shorter hydroperiod pools were located on relatively flatterrain. Finally, hydraulic conductivities were one to two orders of magnitude lowerin the shorter hydroperiod pools. Gay (1998) felt that these characteristics collec-tively resulted in greater surface-water/groundwater connections in the catchmentsof the longer hydroperiod pools. The shorter hydroperiod pools, with weaker ground-water connections, were more direct expressions of precipitation.

The area that actually contributes surface water or groundwater to a pool maybe different than the catchment area defined strictly by topography. Two studies thatattempted to quantify the spatial extent of catchments of cypress ponds (Mansell etal. 2000) and karst ponds (O’Driscoll and Parizek 2003) determined that the area

3675_C003.fm Page 37 Tuesday, June 12, 2007 7:39 AM

Page 8: 3675 C003.fm Page 31 Tuesday, June 12, 2007 7:39 AM 3 ... · Hydrology is fundamental to wetland establishment and maintenance of wetland processes (Cole et al. 2002). Hydrology has

38

Science and Conservation of Vernal Pools in Northeastern North America

of potential surface-water and groundwater contributions to the pools was muchsmaller (i.e., an order of magnitude) than the catchment areas defined by surficialtopography. Conversely, groundwater that originates outside a catchment may entera pool if intermediate or regional groundwater flow discharges to the pool (Winterand LaBaugh 2003; Figure 3.1).

H

YDROLOGIC

D

YNAMICS

Hydroregime and hydroperiod vary among vernal pools and, over time, within anysingle pool. These important characteristics affect pool structure and habitat avail-ability, which strongly influence the composition and reproductive success of poolbiota. For example, vernal pool-breeding species are adapted to fluctuating waterlevels, whereas annual drying precludes organisms that require permanent standingwater. Effects of hydrologic dynamics on pool biota are discussed by Colburn et al.(Chapter 6) and Semlitsch and Skelly (Chapter 7). Despite its importance, there hasbeen little research on the hydrologic variability of vernal pools.

The hydroperiods of ephemeral forest pools occur over a temporal gradient,from highly ephemeral rainwater pools to semipermanent water regimes (Colburn2004). Historically, there has been very limited information on the occurrence anddistribution of pools by hydroperiod. On a year-to-year basis, Brooks (2004) foundthat pool hydroperiods were shorter and pools dried earlier in years with less rainfalland larger cumulative water deficits. Hydroperiod can be correlated with pool depthand volume, but it is only moderately to poorly correlated with pool area (Brooksand Hayashi 2002; Skidds and Golet 2005).

The hydroregime of vernal pools is best described by a repeating, annual patternof inundation and drying. In central Massachusetts, this pattern is best captured bya hydrologic year that starts in October and ends the following September (Brooks2004). Geographically isolated pools in this area are typically dry or at minimumdepths by the first of October, fill partially with late fall rains after leaf fall, fill tocapacity with spring rains and snow melt, and then dry through late spring andsummer after full forest canopy development (Figure 3.2). This hydroregime patterncan differ dramatically for any single pool in any one year, e.g., a pool can be dryor full to overflowing in almost any month (Table 3.1). This pattern can also differfor pools in other locations and in other hydrogeomorphic settings.

Colburn (2004) has proposed a hydrologic classification for vernal pools thatconsiders the timing of annual drying and filling. Short-cycle, spring-filling poolsare usually dry or mostly dry during the winter. They then fill and reach theirmaximum depth and volume in the spring due to snow melt and spring rains. Thesepools quickly shrink in size as inputs decline and evapotranspiration increases, dryingby late June or early July. Short-cycle, fall-filling pools behave similarly, except theyfill in late fall or early to mid winter. Short-cycle, spring-filling pools are typicallyflooded for three to four months per year, compared with seven to nine months forshort-cycle, fall-filling pools. Long-cycle pools, in contrast, usually dry in mid tolate summer or early fall. These pools are also divided into spring or fall filling.Long-cycle, spring-filling pools typically have water for five to eight months,

3675_C003.fm Page 38 Tuesday, June 12, 2007 7:39 AM

Page 9: 3675 C003.fm Page 31 Tuesday, June 12, 2007 7:39 AM 3 ... · Hydrology is fundamental to wetland establishment and maintenance of wetland processes (Cole et al. 2002). Hydrology has

Hydrology and Landscape Connectivity of Vernal Pools

39

compared to nine to eleven months for long-cycle, fall-filling pools. Finally, semi-permanent vernal pools contain water throughout the year, generally remainingflooded for several years at a time. Water levels in these pools also reach a maximumduring the spring and then decrease during the summer. These five classes representa continuum of increasing hydroperiod (Colburn 2004); however, hydroperiod alsovaries between years within classes. Given the lack of field data on hydrologicvariability, a classification system such as Colburn’s may be useful for categorizingpools according to their hydrologic variability and for inferring possible effects onpool organisms.

H

YDROLOGIC

C

ONNECTIVITY

A vernal pool can have hydrologic connections to other pools and water bodies throughgroundwater flow. In addition to local groundwater flows, this may also include con-nections between distant pools through regional flow systems (Winter and LaBaugh2003; Figure 3.1). It is also possible that vernal pools can have permanent surface-water connections to other bodies of water, as pools can occur in larger wetlands thathave perennial inlets (Garret Hollands, personal communication). Permanent

TABLE 3.1Thirteen-Year (1993–2005) Average Monthly Mean, Standard Deviation, Minimum, and Maximum Water Depths for Vernal Pool PR243, Quabbin Watershed, Central Massachusetts

Month

AverageMonthly

MeanStandardDeviation Minimum Maximum

Number ofWeekly

Observations

October 4.8 (1.9) 12.0 (4.7) 0 (0) 51 (20) 48November 14.3 (5.6) 18.6 (7.3) 0 (0) 51 (20) 43December 30.4 (12.0) 21.3 (8.4) 0 (0) 51 (20) 31January 34.0 (13.4) 21.6 (8.5) 0 (0) 51 (20) 5

a

February 22.5 (8.9) 31.8 (12.5) 0 (0) 45 (18) 2

a

March 39.2 (15.4) 13.7 (5.4) 16 (6) 51 (20) 9

a

April 46.2 (18.2) 6.7 (2.6) 26 (10) 51 (20) 32May 40.6 (16.0) 11.2 (4.4) 3 (1) 51 (20) 52June 23.9 (9.4) 17.2 (6.8) 0 (0) 51 (20) 50July 7.0 (2.8) 14.8 (5.8) 0 (0) 50 (20) 50August 5.2 (2.0) 13.1 (5.2) 0 (0) 50 (20) 49September 1.8 (0.7) 6.6 (2.6) 0 (0) 33 (13) 49

Note:

Depths in cm (inches). Maximum depth before surface overflow is 51 cm (20 in.)for this pool.

a

Pool is frozen during the winter season; accessibility is limited and few visits weremade to the pool.

Source:

Brooks (unpublished data).

3675_C003.fm Page 39 Tuesday, June 12, 2007 7:39 AM

Page 10: 3675 C003.fm Page 31 Tuesday, June 12, 2007 7:39 AM 3 ... · Hydrology is fundamental to wetland establishment and maintenance of wetland processes (Cole et al. 2002). Hydrology has

40

Science and Conservation of Vernal Pools in Northeastern North America

surface-water connections would be expected to occur in a relatively small number ofpools. However, a larger number of northeastern vernal pools may be connected bysurface water intermittently. Such intermittent connections have been reported forCalifornia vernal pools (Zedler 1987), prairie potholes (Leibowitz and Vining 2003),and other wetland types (e.g., Snodgrass et al. 1996; Babbitt and Tanner 2000).Intermittent surface-water connections could occur between vernal pools during wetterconditions in various ways. For example: geographically isolated vernal pools couldbe connected to each other through swale zones during snow melt and spring runoff(Figure 3.3a); individual pools within a larger forested wetland can merge if conditionsare wet enough to cause standing water in the larger wetland (Figure 3.3b); riverinevernal pools occurring in floodplains of permanent streams can connect to each otherand to the stream during floodplain inundation (Figure 3.3c); and riverine vernal poolsthat occur as a headwater complex connect to each other during times of intermittentor ephemeral stream flow (Figure 3.3d).

Intermittent surface-water connections should occur at a hierarchy of scales(Figure 3.4). There is also a temporal hierarchy of intermittent connections, though

FIGURE 3.3

Examples of intermittent surface-water connections between vernal pools (dot-ted lines denote intermittent connections). (a) Geographically isolated pools connectedthrough a swale zone by snow melt and spring runoff. (b) Depressional pools occurring withina larger, forested wetland merged during high water events. (c) Riverine pools within thefloodplain of a permanent stream connected during floodplain inundation. (d) Riverine poolsoccurring as a headwater complex are connected when the intermittent or ephemeral streamis flowing.

3675_C003.fm Page 40 Tuesday, June 12, 2007 7:39 AM

Page 11: 3675 C003.fm Page 31 Tuesday, June 12, 2007 7:39 AM 3 ... · Hydrology is fundamental to wetland establishment and maintenance of wetland processes (Cole et al. 2002). Hydrology has

Hydrology and Landscape Connectivity of Vernal Pools

41

this need not match the spatial pattern. For example, micropools, riverine pools ina 1-year floodplain, and vernal pools connected through swale zones will usuallyhave annual intermittent connections, though the micropool connections should havethe longest duration. At the other extreme, geographically isolated pools in areaswith large relief and riverine pools in 100-year floodplains will rarely have inter-mittent surface-water connections. Thus, vernal pools occur within an isolation-connectivity continuum over time and space (Leibowitz and Vining 2003).

Groundwater connections can serve as an important mechanism for transport-ing soluble materials between vernal pools and other waters. Surface-water con-nections can transport not only soluble compounds but also insoluble materialssuch as sediment, organisms, and reproductive propagules. While there have beensome studies of groundwater interactions between vernal pools, surface-waterinteractions have received almost no attention. Thus, we are not able to say at thistime how widespread or significant these connections are. Characterizing thefrequency distribution of these surface-water connections (Leibowitz and Vining2003) could promote a better understanding of the ecological functioning of thesesystems.

FIGURE 3.4

Spatial hierarchy of hydrologic interactions (dotted lines denote intermittentsurface-water connections). (a) Micropools connect annually as water fills the entire pool. (b)Pools within a geographically isolated wetland connect during flood events (annual or lessfrequent) when the larger wetland fills. (c) Geographically isolated wetlands containing poolscan connect during extreme flood events when the wetland spills over into an adjacent isolatedwetland. Some hydrologic interactions may not fit in this hierarchy, e.g., connections betweenriverine pools or between geographically isolated pools.

3675_C003.fm Page 41 Tuesday, June 12, 2007 7:39 AM

Page 12: 3675 C003.fm Page 31 Tuesday, June 12, 2007 7:39 AM 3 ... · Hydrology is fundamental to wetland establishment and maintenance of wetland processes (Cole et al. 2002). Hydrology has

42

Science and Conservation of Vernal Pools in Northeastern North America

POPULATION DYNAMICS AND LANDSCAPE CONNECTIVITY

Vernal pools support a diversity of aquatic organisms. These organisms must survivein a stressful environment that experiences regular drying. Survival is made possibleby a number of life-history strategies that allow organisms to successfully grow andreproduce in these systems (Colburn 2004). Eggs of pool-breeding organisms musthatch and develop while water is present, and populations must be able to withstandor avoid drought. Yet the timing and duration of water availability is highly variable,both spatially (among pools) and temporally (among years). Thus, in spite of adaptivelife-history strategies, populations of a particular species may go locally extinct inpools that experience particularly harsh conditions.

Classical ecological theory dealt with complete extirpation of a species over itsentire range. More recently, metapopulation theory has been proposed to explain thedynamics of local extinctions and recolonizations over a group of individual sites(Hanski 1999). In the absence of field studies on these dynamics, metapopulationtheory can provide an explanation of how a species might persist in the face of localextinctions, and the factors that could influence their persistence (Chapter 8, Gibbsand Reed).

M

ETAPOPULATION

T

HEORY

Levins (1970) introduced the term

metapopulation

to refer to a population of localpopulations. His theory examines the long-term viability of a species in a landscapewhere various factors affect its ability to persist. Metapopulation dynamics areincreasingly recognized as playing an important role in the long-term sustainabilityof certain wetland species (Gibbs 1993; Lehtinen et al. 1999).

Metapopulation dynamics are a function of extinctions of local populationswithin distinct sites, due to random environmental and demographic variation, andrecolonization from neighboring sites (Hanski 1999). Levins (1970) was able todemonstrate that the metapopulation could be maintained if the rate of recoloniza-tions is greater than the rate of extinctions. According to this perspective, it is themetapopulation that can persist over time; local populations wink on and off inresponse to local extinction and recolonization events. If recolonizations do not offsetlocal extinctions, the proportion of occupied sites will decrease over time, and themetapopulation will eventually go extinct.

A species’ extinction rate is related to local population dynamics, communitystructure, and genetic change (Figure 3.5). For vernal pools, extreme hydrologicvariability would be expected to have a major influence on the extinction rate. Thiscould include direct effects on the population, such as increased mortality fromdesiccation and reduced reproduction because of delayed flooding, as well as indirecteffects through lowered habitat quality.

The recolonization rate of a species depends on the rate of emigration fromoccupied sites, which is a function of local population dynamics (for example,movement due to overcrowding) and behavior, e.g., emigration in response to poorconditions (Hanksi 1999). The recolonization rate also depends on the probability

3675_C003.fm Page 42 Tuesday, June 12, 2007 7:39 AM

Page 13: 3675 C003.fm Page 31 Tuesday, June 12, 2007 7:39 AM 3 ... · Hydrology is fundamental to wetland establishment and maintenance of wetland processes (Cole et al. 2002). Hydrology has

Hydrology and Landscape Connectivity of Vernal Pools

43

FIG

UR

E 3.

5

Fact

ors

influ

enci

ng m

etap

opul

atio

n dy

nam

ics.

The

equ

ilibr

ium

num

ber

of o

ccup

ied

site

s is

a b

alan

ce b

etw

een

the

e xtin

ctio

n an

d re

colo

-ni

zatio

n ra

tes.

Met

apop

ulat

ions

can

sur

vive

onl

y if

the

reco

loni

zatio

n ra

te is

gre

ater

or

equa

l to

the

e xtin

ctio

n ra

te. A

spe

cies

’ beh

avio

r af

fect

s th

e di

stan

ceit

can

disp

erse

(

d

), w

here

as t

he d

istr

ibut

ion

of d

ista

nces

bet

wee

n si

tes

(

D

) is

a f

unct

ion

of t

he e

nvir

onm

ent’s

spa

tial

patte

rn.

(Ada

pted

fro

m L

e vin

s, R

.(1

970)

. E

xtin

ctio

n. I

n G

erst

enha

ber,

M.

(Ed.

)

Som

e M

athe

mat

ical

Que

stio

ns i

n B

iolo

gy

. Am

eric

an M

athe

mat

ical

Soc

iety

, Pr

ovid

ence

, R

I. p

p. 7

5–10

7.W

ith p

erm

issi

on.)

3675_C003.fm Page 43 Tuesday, June 12, 2007 7:39 AM

Page 14: 3675 C003.fm Page 31 Tuesday, June 12, 2007 7:39 AM 3 ... · Hydrology is fundamental to wetland establishment and maintenance of wetland processes (Cole et al. 2002). Hydrology has

44

Science and Conservation of Vernal Pools in Northeastern North America

that these emigrants will successfully recolonize an empty site (Figure 3.5). This isaffected by the emigrants’ ability to arrive at an unoccupied site and, once there, tobecome successfully established.

In the original Levins (1970) model, extinction is random with an average ratethat is constant across all sites. This would cause local populations to wink on andoff independently of each other. However, local extinctions in vernal pools are likelyto be clustered in time during harsh hydrologic conditions. In addition, some poolswill have greater hydrologic variability than others and therefore experience higherrates of extinction. For example, pools that are shallow and totally dependent onprecipitation would experience more frequent than average dry conditions. Thiswould represent marginal habitat for a species requiring longer and more predictablewet periods, and so local extinctions would be relatively common.

In contrast, deeper pools that receive groundwater would be less responsive tovariations in precipitation, and would have a lower than average extinction rate forthat species. These pools would remain wet during mild droughts, when other poolswere dry. At such times the wet sites could function as source pools (Hanksi 1999),producing emigrants that could recolonize pools with marginal habitat (sinks) thatexperienced more frequent extinctions. However, pools may shift from being sourcesto sinks and

vice versa

, due to year-to-year variability within and between pools.This suggests that long-term maintenance of metapopulations may require a varietyof pools having different hydrologic regimes to sustain local populations and serveas source areas under different conditions (Elizabeth Colburn, Harvard University,personal communication).

C

ONNECTIVITY

AND

D

ISPERSAL

We noted in the previous section that recolonization is dependent on the emigrants’ability to arrive at an unoccupied site. The probability that an emigrant will success-fully get to an unoccupied site depends on the dispersal distance of the species (afunction of behavior) and the distribution of distances between sites, which is afunction of the spatial pattern of the environment (Figure 3.5). For a given specieswith a fixed dispersal distance, the level of connectivity is higher in landscape settingswith smaller distances between pools (Figure 3.6). Distances between sites are afunction of pool density, which has been reported in the literature to range between0–13.5 pools km

–2

(0–35 pools mi

–2

) over the glaciated northeastern United States(Chapter 3 in Colburn 2004). This means that regions with higher pool densitiesshould have greater recolonization rates and, consequently, sustain more species.Similarly, connectivity in a given landscape is greater for species with larger dispersaldistances. For example, wood frogs are highly mobile, with first-time breeders ableto disperse 1.1–1.2 km (0.68–0.75 mi) (Colburn 2004). Thus, these frogs should beable to readily move between pools. Colburn (2004), deMaynadier and Houlahan(Chapter 13), and Semlitsch and Skelly (Chapter 7) include dispersal distances forsome vernal pool organisms.

There are many different mechanisms by which species disperse between vernalpools. Dispersal can be active or passive, can happen during different life stages,and can occur over land or through the air. For example, adult frogs and salamanders

3675_C003.fm Page 44 Tuesday, June 12, 2007 7:39 AM

Page 15: 3675 C003.fm Page 31 Tuesday, June 12, 2007 7:39 AM 3 ... · Hydrology is fundamental to wetland establishment and maintenance of wetland processes (Cole et al. 2002). Hydrology has

Hydrology and Landscape Connectivity of Vernal Pools

45

actively travel between pools over land, whereas birds and certain insects dispersethrough flight. For many other species, reproductive propagules or resting stages arepassively dispersed between sites. As an example, plant seeds can be transported bywind, and fingernail clams and fairy shrimp can be carried on the feet or feathersof birds (Chapter 6, Colburn et al.).

Although it has not received much attention, surface-water connections betweenwetlands — both permanent and intermittent — may also serve as corridors formovement (Leibowitz 2003). Dispersal of seeds by water (hydrochory) has beenobserved in southeastern swamp forests (Schneider and Sharitz 1988). Small-fruitedspike-rush (

Eleocharis microcarpa

Torrey var.

filiculmis

), which can be abundant invernal pools south of New England, may disperse through hydrochory (Hickler2004). Thus, it is possible that certain animals, plant parts, and reproductivepropagules disperse between northeastern vernal pools through surface-water con-nections. As few vernal pool animals have adaptations to disperse through flowingwater (Elizabeth Colburn, personal communication), surface water is probably not amajor dispersal mechanism. However, surface water could be important for particular

FIGURE 3.6

Effect of reduced pool density on landscape connectivity. Pools were randomlygenerated in a 100 km

2

(38.6 mi

2

) landscape and then randomly removed to simulate theeffects of pool conversion. Initial pool density is based on a glacial collapse valley in CapeCod, MA, and connections are for a species having a fixed dispersal distance of 1.15 km (0.7mi), e.g., wood frog (Colburn 2004). (a) Density of 5.8 pools km

–2

(15.0 pools mi

–2

). (b)Density of 3 pools km

–2

(7.8 pools mi

–2

). (c) Density of 1 pool km

–2

(2.6 pools mi

–2

). (d) Plotshowing number of connections vs. pool density.

(b)

(d)

(a) (c)

7000

6000

5000

4000

3000

2000

1000

0123

Pool Density (# km–1)456 0

Co

nn

ecti

on

s (#

)

3675_C003.fm Page 45 Tuesday, June 12, 2007 7:39 AM

Page 16: 3675 C003.fm Page 31 Tuesday, June 12, 2007 7:39 AM 3 ... · Hydrology is fundamental to wetland establishment and maintenance of wetland processes (Cole et al. 2002). Hydrology has

46

Science and Conservation of Vernal Pools in Northeastern North America

taxa (e.g., crayfish) and for certain types of pools, such as those occurring infloodplains.

Given these different modes of dispersal, interpreting distances between poolsas straight line distances — as we implicitly did above — can be problematic. Forexample, an organism might require forest cover, moist habitat, or a hedgerow formovement. In this case, the effective distance between sites would need to reflectthe length of the actual travel path — which would take into account the presenceof corridors and barriers — rather than straight-line distance (Wiens 1997).

The use of simple, straight-line distances can also be inappropriate for aquaticorganisms and reproductive propagules that are carried between sites through per-manent or intermittent surface-water connections. Another complication in this caseis that downstream flow — either through swale zones (Figure 3.3a) or intermittentor ephemeral streams (Figure 3.3d) — adds directionality; e.g., passively transportedorganisms and propagules cannot travel upstream and actively transported organismscan move greater distances and expend less energy in the downstream direction.This would not be the case with bi-directional connections that occur when watersurfaces merge (Figure 3.3b) or floodplains fill (Figure 3.3c).

The temporal pattern of intermittent surface-water connections, both frequencyand duration, must also be considered. Timing could be the more critical factor fororganisms that disperse in this manner. For example, two riverine pools located 1km (0.6 mi) apart within a 1-year floodplain would have greater hydrologic connec-tivity than two geographically isolated pools that are 0.1 km (0.06 mi) apart but,due to high relief, only merge during 10-year storm events.

W

ETLAND

–T

ERRESTRIAL

C

ONNECTIVITY

The Levins metapopulation model conceptualizes the landscape as consisting ofsites, or “pockets of suitable habitat” (Levins 1970: 80), embedded within surround-ing unsuitable habitat. Up until this point, we have interpreted “site” as an individualvernal pool. This would be the case for obligate wetland species that live their entirelives within the confines of the pool basin. Such permanent residents include fin-gernail clams, nematodes, flatworms, fairy shrimp, spreadwing damselflies, and clamshrimp (Chapter 6, Colburn et al.). These organisms have different life-historystrategies that allow them to feed and breed during wet conditions and survive dryperiods. Permanent residents would also include plants adapted to vernal poolhydrology.

Many other organisms, however, are migrants that use the pool for only a portionof their life. This includes nonbreeding migrants (e.g., some species of predaceousdiving beetles, turtles, snakes, birds, and mammals) that feed but do not breed invernal pools (Chapter 6, Colburn et al.; and Chapter 9, Mitchell et al.). Nonbreedingmigrants can include both wetland obligate and facultative wetland (not requiringwetlands to survive) species. In contrast, migratory breeders use the vernal poolbasins to breed (this may take place during wet or dry conditions, depending on thespecies) but then leave as the pool dries out. These species are pool-dependent, theybreed most successfully in seasonal pools. Migratory breeders include mole

3675_C003.fm Page 46 Tuesday, June 12, 2007 7:39 AM

Page 17: 3675 C003.fm Page 31 Tuesday, June 12, 2007 7:39 AM 3 ... · Hydrology is fundamental to wetland establishment and maintenance of wetland processes (Cole et al. 2002). Hydrology has

Hydrology and Landscape Connectivity of Vernal Pools

47

salamanders (

Ambystoma

spp.), wood frogs, and certain dragonflies and caddisflies(Chapter 6, Colburn et al.; and Chapter 7, Semlitsch and Skelly).

Migrants that are wetland obligates require vernal pools to complete their lifecycle. However, they are only obligates during a particular life stage. These “stage-specific” wetland obligates also require core terrestrial habitat (Chapter 7, Semlitschand Skelly). Gibbons (2003) argued eloquently that the strong focus on jurisdictionaldelineation and presence of hydric conditions for defining wetlands has causedwetland scientists to overlook how critical terrestrial habitat is for many wetlandspecies. Thus, the term “site” needs to take on a different meaning for these migratoryspecies; it does not represent a single, homogeneous habitat type, but rather a mixtureof core habitats, including vernal pools, that fulfill the particular species’ life historyrequirements. The arrangement of these habitats is also important; e.g., amphibianmigratory breeders require vernal pools and terrestrial forests to be located withintheir maximum adult migratory travel distance (Regosin et al. 2005; Baldwin et al.2006). This means that the concept of landscape connectivity must be expanded toinclude not only movement between pools but also movement between vernal poolsand other required habitat (Chapter 7, Semlitsch and Skelly; Chapter 8, Gibbs andReed; and Chapter 12, Windmiller and Calhoun).

CONSERVATION IMPLICATIONS

H

YDROLOGIC

I

MPACTS

Vernal pool organisms have numerous life history strategies for surviving, includingdifferent life stages for wet and dry conditions. These stages are tightly linked tothe timing of flooding and drawdown. Although flooding and drawdown exhibitsignificant temporal variability from year-to-year, any impacts that have a long-termeffect on the frequency, duration, magnitude, or variability of flooding will inevitablyalter community composition. We discuss several potential impacts below. Theserange in scale from impacts to individual pools to large-scale effects throughout theentire glaciated northeast.

Timber Harvesting

The hydrologic effects of timber harvesting on forest pools are determined by theimpacts of the harvesting on the sensitive components of the hydrologic budget,namely runoff, evapotranspiration, and soil permeability. The effects of timber har-vesting and associated reductions in evapotranspiration on isolated ponds have beenstudied for various types of forest in the southeastern United States. This researchhas generally revealed elevated groundwater levels and an increase in runoff toponds, resulting in longer hydroperiods (Sun et al. 2000). However, these effectsare very ephemeral and become insignificant by the tenth year following harvesting,due to rapid regeneration and growth of other forest vegetation (Sun et al. 2000).Although relatively short-lived, these effects could still be significant for speciesrequiring short hydroperiods if source populations are unavailable for recolonization.

3675_C003.fm Page 47 Tuesday, June 12, 2007 7:39 AM

Page 18: 3675 C003.fm Page 31 Tuesday, June 12, 2007 7:39 AM 3 ... · Hydrology is fundamental to wetland establishment and maintenance of wetland processes (Cole et al. 2002). Hydrology has

48

Science and Conservation of Vernal Pools in Northeastern North America

In contrast to the effects observed by Sun et al. (2000), no relationship wasfound in Minnesota between time since harvesting and forest pool hydroperiod (Paliket al. 2001). However, these researchers observed that the youngest stand in theirstudy had been harvested seven years prior, so that hydrology may have alreadyreturned to preharvest conditions. Batzer et al. (2000) also were unable to find aneffect of timber harvesting on pond hydrology, concluding that natural annual vari-ation in hydroperiods overwhelmed any timber harvesting effect.

Although informative, studies in other areas may not reflect the impact of timberharvesting on northeastern vernal pools. Based on a conceptual understanding ofpool hydrology, any impacts that do occur should be greater in dry climates withlow potential evapotranspiration than in wetter areas, and greater for geographicallyisolated pools vs. pools associated with other waters. Impacts should also be directlyrelated to the intensity of the management. Recommended modifications of timbermanagement practices for protecting vernal pools and their biota are discussed bydeMaynadier and Houlahan (Chapter 13).

Land Development

Urbanization and development for associated land uses is a significant threat tovernal pools in many areas of the glaciated Northeast (McKinney 2002). Urbaniza-tion can cause hydrologic impacts through cumulative watershed modifications thatalter hydrology (Richter and Azous 1995). Windmiller and Calhoun (Chapter 12)discuss best management practices for minimizing the impact of development onvernal pools.

Wetland hydrology in urban areas is usually highly altered in amounts, sources,and flow rates. Urbanization can increase the area of impervious surfaces (e.g.,buildings, roads, parking lots) and alter natural flow pathways (e.g., construction ofstorm drainage systems). These changes can be expected to alter the hydrology ofurban wetlands so that they will have more frequent, rapid, and large (“flashy”)changes in water level and have a lower frequency of flooded and/or saturatedconditions (Ehrenfeld et al. 2003). In a study of 21 wetlands in northeastern NewJersey, including four depressional wetlands, flashiness was significantly differentamong disturbance classes; sites with high levels of disturbance had larger fluctua-tions (Ehrenfeld et al. 2003). However, Rubbo and Kiesecker (2005) found that themodified hydrologic regimes of urbanized wetlands in central Pennsylvania tendedto result in longer hydroperiods and a tendency towards permanence of standingwater.

Other land use changes can also impact vernal pool hydrology. Permanentclearing of forests for field crops or pastures could alter evapotranspiration rates andcause surface-water temperatures to rise (due to reduced shading). Farm machinerycould also alter soil permeability. The impact of this change in land use can beregional in scope: according to Colburn (2004), up to 85% of most of southern andcentral New England and much of the Canadian Maritime Provinces were convertedfrom forest to fields and pastures by the mid-1800s. However, much of this landsubsequently reverted to forest cover.

3675_C003.fm Page 48 Tuesday, June 12, 2007 7:39 AM

Page 19: 3675 C003.fm Page 31 Tuesday, June 12, 2007 7:39 AM 3 ... · Hydrology is fundamental to wetland establishment and maintenance of wetland processes (Cole et al. 2002). Hydrology has

Hydrology and Landscape Connectivity of Vernal Pools

49

Climate Change

The dominant effect of weather patterns on pool hydrology means that these systemswill be affected by climate change (Sun et al. 2002). Furthermore, vernal pools andtheir biota are likely to be affected by climate change early on, due to their relativehydrologic isolation and location at the land/water interface (Root and Schneider2002). Climate change predictions of more episodic precipitation and increasedevapotranspiration would cause pools to dry earlier in the year and remain dry longer(Brooks 2004). In addition, climate change could increase the frequency of extremerainfall events and cause more frequent and longer interevent droughts. This couldincrease the frequency of the drying and refilling cycle, compared with the slow,extended drying that now occurs (Brooks 2004). Increasing magnitude and variabil-ity of temperature could alter quantities and timing of snow melt. This could poten-tially affect many species, especially early spring migrants that deposit eggs aroundthe time of snow melt. Finally, any of these hydrologic changes could affect streamflow, thereby impacting riverine pools.

LOSS OF LANDSCAPE CONNECTIVITY

According to metapopulation theory (Levins 1970), the distribution of pool speciesacross a region represents a dynamic equilibrium between factors that cause localextinctions and those that affect recolonization. Any impacts that increase localextinctions or reduce recolonization will therefore decrease species distributions.One such impact is the conversion of pools to different land uses, which can causethe local extinctions of all the species dependent on those pools. Conversion canalso indirectly affect populations in surrounding pools by lowering recolonizationrates. This might occur because the converted pools are no longer able to serve assources of emigrants. Conversion can also reduce recolonization because the cumu-lative loss of pools increases the average distance between remaining sites (Figure3.6).

Reduced landscape connectivity can be caused by other impacts besides directconversion. Impacts that decrease pool flooding, such as climate change, wouldlower landscape connectivity by making intermittent surface-water connections lessfrequent or shorter in duration. In addition, roads in upland areas can act as barriersto dispersal by increasing mortality or changing behavior. Pool-dependent speciescan also be affected by impacts that alter the spatial relationship between pools andother core habitat areas. For example, deforestation can cause the direct loss of asemiaquatic pool species that also requires forested habitat if the distance betweenthe pool and remaining forest exceeds its maximum migratory travel distance.

Vernal pool conservation has historically focused on protecting pool habitat. Yetbecause pool species depend on landscape connectivity for long-term persistence,conservation programs must also preserve connectivity. In addition, conservationefforts should include the other core habitat types needed by some pool organisms.A landscape perspective that considers connectivity and supplemental habitat isnecessary to conserve the rich biota associated with these seasonally flooded pools.

3675_C003.fm Page 49 Tuesday, June 12, 2007 7:39 AM

Page 20: 3675 C003.fm Page 31 Tuesday, June 12, 2007 7:39 AM 3 ... · Hydrology is fundamental to wetland establishment and maintenance of wetland processes (Cole et al. 2002). Hydrology has

50 Science and Conservation of Vernal Pools in Northeastern North America

SUMMARY

Vernal pools are shaped by hydrologic processes which influence many aspects ofpool function. The hydrologic budget of a pool can be summarized by a water-balance equation that relates changes in the amount of water in the pool to precip-itation, ground- and surface-water flows, and evapotranspiration. For many vernalpools, precipitation and evapotranspiration are the major determinants of the watercycle. However, groundwater can also be significant in specific settings and atparticular times. Surface-water flows can be important for certain vernal pools, e.g.,those in riverine settings. Basin and catchment characteristics influence the relativerole of surface water and groundwater.

A limited number of vernal pools may have permanent surface-water connectionsto other waters. Intermittent surface-water connections may also occur during epi-sodic events, either annually or less frequently. It is suggested that these intermittentsurface-water connections result in a spatial hierarchy of hydrologic interactions.There is also a temporal hierarchy of intermittent connections, though this need notmatch the spatial pattern. Thus, vernal pools occur within an isolation-connectivitycontinuum over time and space.

Theory suggests that the persistence of a species across vernal pools representsa balance between factors that cause local extinctions and those that allow forunoccupied areas to be recolonized. Landscape connectivity makes it possible forspecies to disperse between vernal pools and recolonize pools that are unoccupieddue to local extinctions. Connectivity is greater for species with larger dispersaldistances and in landscape settings with greater pool densities. In addition to con-nections between pools, migratory species also require landscape connectivitybetween pools and other core habitat areas, such as forests.

Any impacts to vernal pools that have a long-term effect on the frequency,duration, magnitude, or variability of flooding will inevitably alter community com-position. These impacts, which range in scale from changes to individual pools tolarge-scale effects throughout the entire glaciated Northeast, include timber harvest-ing, land development, and climate change. A landscape perspective that considersconnectivity and supplemental habitat is necessary to conserve the rich biota asso-ciated with these seasonally flooded pools.

ACKNOWLEDGMENTS

Special thanks to E. Colburn, R. McKinney, P. Zedler, and an anonymous reviewerfor their thoughtful comments on this manuscript. We also received useful sugges-tions from A. Calhoun, G. Hollands, and R. Rheinhardt. Thanks to D. White forhelpful discussions on metapopulations and dispersal. The information in this doc-ument has been funded by the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) andthe U.S. Forest Service. This document has been subjected to EPA’s peer andadministrative review, and it has been approved for publication as an EPA document.Mention of trade names or commercial products does not constitute endorsement orrecommendation for use.

3675_C003.fm Page 50 Tuesday, June 12, 2007 7:39 AM

Page 21: 3675 C003.fm Page 31 Tuesday, June 12, 2007 7:39 AM 3 ... · Hydrology is fundamental to wetland establishment and maintenance of wetland processes (Cole et al. 2002). Hydrology has

Hydrology and Landscape Connectivity of Vernal Pools 51

REFERENCES

Babbitt, K.J. and Tanner, G.W. (2000). Use of temporary wetlands by anurans in a hydrolog-ically modified landscape. Wetlands 20: 313–322.

Baldwin, R.F., Calhoun, A.J.K., and deMaynadier, P.G. (2006). Conservation planning foramphibian species with complex habitat requirements: a case study using movementsand habitat selection of the wood frog (Rana sylvatica). Journal of Herpetology 40:443–454.

Bärlocher, F., Mackay, R.J., and Wiggins, G.B. (1978). Detritus processing in a temporaryvernal pool in southern Ontario. Archiv für Hydrobiologie 81: 269–295.

Batzer, D.P., Jackson, C.R., and Mosner, M. (2000). Influences of riparian logging on plantsand invertebrates in small, depressional wetlands of Georgia, USA. Hydrobiologia441: 123–132.

Bonner, L.A., Diehl, W.J., and Altig, R. (1997). Physical, chemical and biological dynamicsof five temporary dystrophic forest pools in central Mississippi. Hydrobiologia 353:77–89.

Brooks, R.T. (2004). Weather-related effects on woodland vernal pool hydrology and hydro-period. Wetlands 24: 104–114.

Brooks, R.T. (2005). A review of basin morphology and pool hydrology of isolated pondedwetlands: implications for seasonal forest pools of the northeastern United States.Wetlands Ecology and Management 13: 335–348.

Brooks, R.T. and Hayashi, M. (2002). Depth-area-volume and hydroperiod relationships ofephemeral (vernal) forest pools in southern New England. Wetlands 22: 247–255.

Brooks, R.T., Stone, J., and Lyons, P. (1998). An inventory of seasonal forest ponds on theQuabbin Reservoir watershed, Massachusetts. Northeastern Naturalist 5: 219–230.

Burne, M.R. and Griffin, C.R. (2005). Habitat associations of pool-breeding amphibians ineastern Massachusetts, USA. Wetlands Ecology and Management 13: 247–259.

Calhoun, A.J.K., Halls, T.E., Stockwell, S.S., and McCollough, M. (2003). Evaluating vernalpools as a basis for conservation strategies: a Maine case study. Wetlands 23: 70–81.

Colburn, E.A. (2004). Vernal Pools: Natural History and Conservation. The McDonald andWoodward Publishing Company, Blacksburg, VA.

Cole, C.A., Brooks, R.P., Shaffer, P.W., and Kentula, M.E. (2002). Comparison of hydrologyof wetlands in Pennsylvania and Oregon (USA) as an indicator of transferability ofhydrogeomorphic (HGM) functional models between regions. Environmental Man-agement 30: 265–278.

Ehrenfeld, J.G., Cutway, H.B., Hamilton, R., IV, and Stander, E. (2003). Hydrologic descrip-tion of forested wetlands in northeastern New Jersey, USA — an urban/suburbanregion. Wetlands 23: 685–700.

Gay, D.E. (1998). A comparison of the hydrology and aqueous geochemistry of temporaryponds on the Prescott Peninsula of the Quabbin Reservoir watershed in centralMassachusetts. M.S. thesis. University of Massachusetts, Amherst, MA.

Gibbons, J.W. (2003). Terrestrial habitat: a vital component for herpetofauna of isolatedwetlands. Wetlands 23: 630–635.

Gibbs, J.P. (1993). Importance of small wetlands for the persistence of local populations ofwetland-associated animals. Wetlands 13: 25–31.

Hanski, I. (1999). Metapopulation Ecology. Oxford University Press, New York.Hayashi, M., van der Kamp, G., and Rudolph, D.L. (1998). Water and solute transfer between

a prairie wetland and adjacent uplands, 1. Water balance. Journal of Hydrology 207:42–55.

3675_C003.fm Page 51 Tuesday, June 12, 2007 7:39 AM

Page 22: 3675 C003.fm Page 31 Tuesday, June 12, 2007 7:39 AM 3 ... · Hydrology is fundamental to wetland establishment and maintenance of wetland processes (Cole et al. 2002). Hydrology has

52 Science and Conservation of Vernal Pools in Northeastern North America

Hickler, M.G. (2004). Eleocharis microcarpa var. filiculmis (tiny-fruited spikerush): Conser-vation and Research Plan for New England. New England Wild Flower Society,Framingham, MA.

Lehtinen, R.M., Galatowitsch, S.M., and Tester, J.R. (1999). Consequences of habitat lossand fragmentation for wetland amphibian assemblages. Wetlands 19: 1–12.

Leibowitz, S.G. (2003). Isolated wetlands and their functions: an ecological perspective.Wetlands 23: 517–531.

Leibowitz, S.G. and Vining, K.C. (2003). Temporal connectivity in a prairie pothole complex.Wetlands 23: 13–25.

Levins, R. (1970). Extinction. In Gerstenhaber, M. (Ed.) Some Mathematical Questions inBiology. American Mathematical Society, Providence, RI. pp. 75–107.

Lide, R.F., Meentemeyer, V.G., Pinder, J.E., III, and Beatty, L.M. (1995). Hydrology of aCarolina Bay located on the upper coastal plain of western South Carolina. Wetlands15: 47–57.

Mansell, R.S., Bloom, S.A., and Sun, G. (2000). A model for wetland hydrology: descriptionand validation. Soil Science 165: 384–397.

McKinney, M.L. (2002). Urbanization, biodiversity, and conservation. BioScience 52:883–890.

Millar, J.B. (1973). Estimation of area and circumference of small wetlands. Journal ofWildlife Management 37: 30–38.

O’Driscoll, M.A. and Parizek, R.R. (2003). The hydrologic catchment area of a chain of karstwetlands in central Pennsylvania. Wetlands 23: 171–179.

Palik, B., Batzer, D.P., Buech, R., Nichols, D., Cease, K., Egeland, L., and Streblow, D.E.(2001). Seasonal pond characteristics across a chronosequence of adjacent forest agesin northern Minnesota, USA. Wetlands 21: 532–542.

Parsons, D.F., Hayashi, M., and van der Kamp, G. (2004). Infiltration and solute transportunder a seasonal wetland: bromide tracer experiments in Saskatoon, Canada. Hydro-logical Processes 18: 2011–2027.

Paton, P.W.C. and Couch, W.B., III. (2002). Using the phenology of pond-breeding amphibiansto develop conservation strategies. Conservation Biology 16: 194–204.

Phillips, P.J. and Shedlock, R.J. (1993). Hydrology and chemistry of groundwater and seasonalponds in the Atlantic Coastal Plain in Delaware, USA. Journal of Hydrology 141:157–178.

Pyke, C.R. (2004). Simulating vernal pool hydrologic regimes for two locations in California,USA. Ecological Modelling 173: 10–127.

Rains, M.C., Fogg, G.E., Harter, T.H., Dahlgren, R.A., and Williamson, R.J. (2006). The roleof perched aquifers in hydrological connectivity and biogeochemical processes invernal pool landscapes, Central Valley, California. Hydrological Processes 20:1157–1175.

Regosin, J.V., Windmiller, B.S., Homan, R.N., and Reed, J.M. (2005). Variation in terrestrialhabitat use by four poolbreeding amphibian species. Journal of Wildlife Management69: 1481–1493.

Richter, K.O. and Azous, A.L. (1995). Amphibian occurrence and wetland characteristics inthe Puget Sound Basin. Wetlands 15: 305–312.

Root, T.L. and Schneider, S.H. (2002). Climate change: overview and implications for wildlife.In Schneider, S.H. and Root, T.L. (Eds.). Wildlife Responses to Climate Change:North American Case Studies. Island Press, Washington, D.C., pp. 1–56.

Rubbo, M.J. and Kiesecker, J.M. (2005). Amphibian breeding distribution in an urbanizedlandscape. Conservation Biology 19: 504–511.

3675_C003.fm Page 52 Tuesday, June 12, 2007 7:39 AM

Page 23: 3675 C003.fm Page 31 Tuesday, June 12, 2007 7:39 AM 3 ... · Hydrology is fundamental to wetland establishment and maintenance of wetland processes (Cole et al. 2002). Hydrology has

Hydrology and Landscape Connectivity of Vernal Pools 53

Schneider, R.L. and Sharitz, R.R. (1988). Hydrochory and regeneration in a bald cypress-water tupelo swamp forest. Ecology 69: 1055–1063.

Skidds, D.E. and Golet, F.C. (2005). Estimating hydroperiod suitability for breeding amphib-ians in southern Rhode Island seasonal forest ponds. Wetlands Ecology and Manage-ment 13: 349–366.

Snodgrass, J.W., Bryan, A.L., Jr., Lide, R.F., and Smith, G.M. (1996). Factors affecting theoccurrence and structure of fish assemblages in isolated wetlands of the upper coastalplain, U.S.A. Canadian Journal of Fisheries and Aquatic Sciences 53: 443–454.

Sobczak, R.V., Cambareri, T.C., and Portnoy, J.W. (2003). Physical hydrology of selectedvernal pools and kettle ponds in the Cape Cod National Seashore, Massachusetts:ground and surface water interactions. Cape Cod Commission, Water ResourcesOffice, Barnstable, MA.

Sun, G., McNulty, S.G., Amatya, D.M., Skaggs, R.W., Swift, L.W., Jr., Shepard, J.P., andRiekerk, H. (2002). A comparison of the watershed hydrology of coastal forestedwetlands and the mountainous uplands in the southern U.S. Journal of Hydrology263: 92–104.

Sun, G., Riekerk, H., and Kornhak, L.V. (2000). Gound-water table rise after forest harvestingon cypress-pine flatwoods in Florida. Wetlands 20: 101–112.

Tiner, R.W. (2003). Geographically isolated wetlands of the United States. Wetlands 23:494–516.

Wiens, J.A. (1997). Metapopulation dynamics and landscape ecology. In Hanski, I.A. andGilpin, M.E. (Eds.) Metapopulation Biology: Ecology, Genetics, and Evolution. Aca-demic Press, New York, pp. 43–62.

Winter, T.C. and LaBaugh, J.W. (2003). Hydrologic considerations in defining isolated wet-lands. Wetlands 23: 532–540.

Winter, T.C., Rosenberry, D.O., Buso, D., and Merk, D.A. (2001). Water source to four U.S.wetlands: implications for wetland management. Wetlands 21: 462–473.

Zedler, P.H. (1987). The ecology of southern California vernal pools: a community profile.U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, Washington, D.C. Biological Report 85(7.11).

3675_C003.fm Page 53 Tuesday, June 12, 2007 7:39 AM