WORKING DRAFT

16th Nov 17 rough copy

Abuse of Mental Health Procedures by South Wales Police [SWP]

On the Multi-Agency Efforts to Prevent my Civil Damages Claim for over Fifty Failed Malicious Prosecutions BS614159 etc.

WITNESS and POSITION STATEMENT by Maurice John Kirk BVScBrief Background Summary1) What is certain is we have an exceptional number of failed prosecutions brought by the same police with little or no member of the public as a complainant or witness, ever since my Bristol lawyers wrote a Pre-Action Protocol letter for Civil Damages to SWP in 1993.

On 28th January in 2000, HHJ Ray S Jack QC said in Bristol Crown Court: “It is a pretty remarkable tale, if there is any truth in it, I am voicing little disquiet. Just look at the number of incidents. One asks what is going on?”

2) Then, in 2001, when SWP's aim to remove my name from the veterinary register almost all the prosecutions were entirely stopped for eight or so years.

3) But when in early 2009 my civil claims against the police were again looming, for the substantive trial on the oral evidence now down to half, only a hundred witnesses, following the ravages of time, then the prosecutions started again, but this time, unlike with previously ones, SWP tried to focus on mental health and ‘risk’, to avoid cross examining the police officers, under the Youth and Justice’s Act and instead drew in their forensic psychiatrist under their own control.

As with Stalin or Hitler, there is ‘nothing new under the sun’,first the enemy ignores your complaint and when that fails,they ridicule you and when that fails,they play the ‘Gulag card’ and when that fails,they kill you.

Medical Background prior to 20094) Because SWP tried to manufacture a psychiatric history of ‘risk’, it is useful to know that many “all clear” assessments on me had taken place, e.g. when I landed my aeroplane in the USA in 2008.

Mental Health Developments during 20095) The Royal Family are well known for links with rural life and the farming community and I was a veterinary surgeon for one of Prince Charles’ farms. From this link I was assessed by the fixed threat unit [FTAC] but again, given the “all clear”.

6) In April 2009 I requested my GP in Bridgend for an assessment and although I do not have copies, it is believed Dr Metters and his colleague gave an “all clear” or else the police would have used any negative comments by Dr Metters.

Page 1 of 21

WORKING DRAFT

7) Despite these “all clears”, a MAPPA meeting was initiated by SWP at police HQ and followed up on 8 June 2009 in Barry police station which required the forensic psychiatrist to follow their agenda.

Extreme and Exceptional Traumatisation and Torture8) As a statistical summary,

SWP prevented me from attending Court and hospital appointments nine times, whilst I was imprisoned;

I reported the crimes committed by SWP’s forensic psychiatrist eight times to Police;

13 judges made Orders in favour of SWP against me, when they would have or should have known the malicious and sinister circumstances surrounding all reports that had originated from Caswell Clinic;

four jury trials were initiated and three held with the intention of convicting and sentencing me for the breach of a supposed Restraining Order by SWP’s psychiatrist, when in fact, I was reporting his crimes against me.

To be continued with throughout

60 odd hyperlinks yet to be added of key incriminating documents identifying the manner in which Welsh judiciary has allowed their own police force to behave with incessant bullying

Page 2 of 21

WORKING DRAFT

Time Line

Contents33+ Malicious Prosecutions...................................................................................................................3

2008: First Psychiatric Report due to Landing Close to the US President’s Ranch.................................4

2009: SWP, Cardiff Crown Court, CPS and NHS collude for Sectioning..................................................4

Seven Weeks in HMP Cardiff based on Spurious Medical Records....................................................5

Three Months in Caswell Clinic with Monthly Court Hearings...........................................................6

Ten More Weeks in HMP Cardiff.......................................................................................................7

2010: Serious Physical Pain Problems and Consequences due to the Reports by Caswell Clinic...........8

2011: Hip Problem Solved in France......................................................................................................9

5 Arrests due to SWP when Helping the Nigerian Musas in family courts.........................................9

SWP’s Psychiatrist Initiates Actions for alleged Harassment via my Website....................................9

Allegations of Harassing SWP’s Psychiatrist result in Three Years in Prison so far..........................10

2012: Who’s Harassing Whom?...........................................................................................................11

2013: Harassment by Arrests...............................................................................................................12

2014: Medical means Physical, Emotional and Mental.......................................................................13

2015: The Desperate Attempts to Get me Back to Prison with the Aid of an RO................................14

2016: Who Complains about Whom on Whose Behalf?......................................................................15

2017: Who Benefits from the Restraining Order?...............................................................................15

33+ Malicious Prosecutions Between 1992-2002 I was prosecuted around 40 times by South Wales Police [SWP]. 89% of all criminal allegations prosecutions were concluded in my favour.

Between 2013-2015 I litigated in court against SWP for malicious prosecutions and was granted judgment in my favour in three of the aforesaid actions. The civil case bore the case number BS 614159+2 At least three more are no doubt following the not so mysterious release of my May 1993 police interview tape at gross variance to the official police made transcript.

I pleaded the sheer number of incidents (33) made for the irresistible inference of an agreement between two or more persons to either maliciously prosecute me or do injury. At paragraph 1151 of a judgment in that case His Honour Judge Seys Llewellyn QC stated he was not convinced the Claimant was universally known outside his own

Page 3 of 21

WORKING DRAFT

geographical area in addressing the inference of conspiracy. All the incidents occurred in The Vale of Glamorgan or that part of Cardiff closest to The Vale.

If one looks at The A-Z Atlas of Wales Edition 11 all the incidents occurred at pages 64-65. The incidents occurred in my own ‘back garden’. The third listed prosecution (20th May 1993) concerned my being arrested outside my own veterinary surgery for possession of offensive weapons namely ‘garrotte’ wire, a common veterinary tool, on the premise that the ’general arrest provisions’ of The Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984 applied. That is to say the police had no idea who I was or where I could be found. They therefore had no address for summons service. I had 4 days in prison as ‘unidentifiable’ whilst Guernsey extradition was attempted.

Towards the end of the above chronology on 6th January 2001 SWP complained to The Royal College of Veterinary Surgeons and my name was removed from the veterinary register on the 19th January 2004. This complaint had the consequence of curtailing my income in his fight with the police through the civil courts.

By 2008 a civil jury trial was ordered by HHJ Chambers QC, Queen’s Counsel.

2008: First Psychiatric Report due to Landing Close to the US President’s RanchJuly 2008 A brain scan was carried out in Waco Texas: all clear.August 2008 Austin Texas State Psychiatric Hospital psychiatric report caused immediate release despite wrong information supplied by South Wales Police [SWP].This ‘course of conduct’, tantamount to harassment, was triggered by my October 2008 disclosure application arising from 70 odd police incidents. This was now essential as my original Bristol lawyers had promised me a jury or I would not proceed. But this was overturned much later and far too late to withdraw. I had been conned. I now had to rely on previously unneeded disclosure from the incidents mainly involving my being regularly stopped whilst going about my 24/7 veterinary work.

2009: SWP, Cardiff Crown Court, CPS and NHS collude for Sectioning

Page 4 of 21

WORKING DRAFT

January 2009 Dr Phillips from Fixed Threat Assessment Centre [FTAC] at the Home Office writes a medical letter of no threat, i.e. all clear. April 2009 With a view to getting me registered as a dangerous terrorist on MAPPA [Multi-Agency Public Protection Agreement] a police psychiatrist, not allowed to be identified, sent a fax and also spoke to my GP of 18 years standing to see a psychiatrist called Dr Metters and a colleague at Princess Elizabeth Hospital in Bridgend.This doctor who has produced another psychiatric report has not supplied me with either. I have been refused copies from both the Cardiff Crown Court and Cardiff County Court as it may identify the police psychiatrist and hence the true reason for the ‘cloak and dagger’‘ stuff Despite trying numerous avenues, including NHS (Wales) I have been persistently denied a copy of this report. I was soon banned from the GP practice, after eighteen years as a patient by asking, in writing, why? 1ST June 2009 Chief Constable Barbara Wilding convenes the first meeting of the Independent Advisory Group [IAG] at SWP HQ with the purpose of getting me registered on MAPPA so that different agencies can collaborate to treat me as a terrorist.8th June 2009 A meeting took place at Barry police station of The Multi Agency Public Protection Arrangement (MAPPA). These events concern another civil case ICF03361 (machine-gun conspiracy). That case, I argue, is the apex of my argument (the ultimate proof) that SWP were driven by what lawyers term ‘an animus’, a hostile intent, behind all their arrests and prosecutions. Hence I request the pleadings in 1CF03361 be read in their entirety to fully understand what I aver was the absurdity of the prosecution that lay behind it.

The MAPPA Referral information stated “Maurice John Kirk has a long history with law enforcement agencies with a number of criminal convictions together with a large number of civil actions and complaints being instigated. At present Kirk has just over 100 civil actions pending against South Wales Police focused on a variety of individuals.”

SWP’s psychiatrist recommends to use s35 of the Mental Health Act 1983 to send me to Caswell Clinic, registered on MAPPA on level 3 category 3, the top 5% most dangerous people in the UK.

Seven Weeks in HMP Cardiff based on Spurious Medical Records 22nd June 2009 After armed police arrived with a helicopter, I was arrested for the possession of a de-commissioned Lewis machine gun,

Page 5 of 21

WORKING DRAFT

attached to a vintage aircraft used, inter alia, for filming and air shows. I have evidence that SWP’s psychiatrist caused members of his staff to attend Barry police station for the MAPPA meeting that led to his knowledge that I was to be arrested, remanded in custody and, should I “approach the Chief Constable of Wales”, on the pretext of “mutual exchange of witness statements”, in the civil action, “he was likely to be shot” by an armed police unit. My daughter, Genevieve, was threatened to be taken by Social Services.In the police cell, prior to an interview, the forensic psychiatrist Dr Craddock examined me medically and told me that “there was no reason to believe there was a medical condition for not being interviewed.” But I was denied copies of this report, also. 24th June 2009 At Barry Magistrates Court I was granted unconditional bail. SWP appealed and I was remanded into Cardiff prison to attend court the next day. 25th June 2009 Judge Hughes refused bail on medical grounds. 16th July 2009 HMP Cardiff prevented me from attending a court hearing in which the Recorder of Cardiff Court ordered a psychiatric report due to my ‘failure to attend’. 30th July 2009 The Recorder of Cardiff Court decides that the psychiatric report needs to be speeded up. Three Months in Caswell Clinic with Monthly Court Hearings7th August 2009 Cardiff Crown Court received the first medical report produced by the SWP’s psychiatrist recommending incarceration at Caswell Clinic without even examining me.The Recorder of Cardiff Crown Court orders that I am to be further detained in a first hearing. I was to serve this further period of remand whilst unconvicted in the police psychiatrist’s experimental unit at Caswell Clinic, Bridgend. Experimental, I found out later, because the doctor had been blackmailed, in the first place, by the Chief Constable, to first have me sectioned under s35 of the 1983 Mental Health Act for my MAPPA level 3 category 3 registration, in the absence of essential agents, on 8th June 2009 in Barry police station.Her purpose was to disrupt and delay new civil proceedings against her in the County Court.On or about 28th August 2009 the psychiatrist caused me to undergo a SPEC scan requiring the infusion of radioactive isotopes into my brain. As a consequence, he gave further reports: “Maurice Kirk has evidence of significant brain damage to an area of brain significantly related to self-awareness, judgment, decision making, self

Page 6 of 21

WORKING DRAFT

regulation of behaviour and control of emotions” and “Maurice Kirk presents with symptoms entirely consistent with a mental illness namely Paranoid Delusional Disorder (fixed false beliefs unamenable to reason).”

In consequence I suffered 8 months imprisonment for a crime of which I was not guilty and was nearly placed in Ashworth High Security Psychiatric Hospital. A number of psychiatrists, forensic psychologists and a leading neuro-radiologist, a Dr. Kemp, all opined that I was not mentally ill. 20th August 2009 The Second MAPPA meeting is held to establish both my medical and in particular mental health which is monitored monthly by the Court for up to 3 months. 28th August 2009 Ordered by SWP’s psychiatrist, SPECT & CAT scans were taken at Princess Elizabeth Hospital Bridgend which reveal nothing significant.3rd September 2009 Second court hearing to keep me in Caswell Clinic, based on a report which I was given only once I was in court. SWP’s psychiatrist was only present to provide support for continued incarceration but I was again not allowed to cross examine him or offer my rebuttal concerning his purported facts that were clearly preposterous.9th September 2009 The SWP’s psychiatrist produces his second medical report identifying ‘significant brain damage’ despite the content of his full clinical examinations by more than ten doctors: “He has also been submitted to a full clinical examination, blood investigations. KCG (heart wave recording), LLG (brainwave recording), MRI and SPECT scans (brain imaging).”

18th September 2009 Professor of Psychology Rodger Wood, with no medical degree, wrote a letter to Caswell Clinic that he could not support any of the police psychiatrist’s conclusions relating to brain damage. 30th September 2009 After I was refused a private examination by my own GP, I was seen by the one resident in Caswell Clinic who confirmed “no indication of risk, brain damage or relevant physical damage such as frontal lobe damage resulting from aircraft engine failures.” 1st October 2009 The 3 rd Court hearing referred me back to HMP Cardiff, even though a Professor Nicholas Read had given a most favourable medical report to the Recorder of Cardiff, without my knowing, with the professor having personally known me for some forty odd years. Again, I was promised both free legal representation and free transcripts of the machine-gun proceedings but neither blackmail ever materialised. (See severely redacted court transcript re cancer being the cause of my ‘threat’ to the forensic psychiatrist and Chief Constable only).

Page 7 of 21

WORKING DRAFT

Ten More Weeks in HMP Cardiff 19th October 2009 The third report by the SWP’s psychiatrist recommended that I, as the claimant in now the first forty -three SWP failed malicious prosecutions, be transferred to Ashworth high security psychiatric hospital for his own safety and the one of the Chief Constable. Not for the safety of the general public or members of my own family! It ends with “The risk of Maurice Kirk continuing with his activities against South Wales Police and acting in a way that he feels justified to achieve his ends is high, though whether Maurice Kirk himself would be involved in inter-personal violence is less, it cannot be discounted, nor can the risk that others would act violently with his encouragement.”

26th October 2009 Bail application refused on medical grounds by Recorder Judge Eleri Rees and again my not being given the reason or any confirmation as to why SWP had MAPPA registered me in the top 5% most dangerous individuals in the UK. November 2009 Bail application refused on medical grounds by Judge Jones1st December 2009 Report by neuro-radiologist Dr Kemp in rebuttal to Caswell Clinic 2009 erroneous medical records with his castigation over the use of such inappropriate procedures.1st December 2009 Dr Edward Silva’s 26-page report concludes: “Having read Dr W’s reports, I agree with Dr W that Mr Kirk does not currently appear to be suffering from a mental disorder of a nature or degree that would make detention in hospital appropriate.”

2nd December 2009 Despite Dr Silva’s report, new medical evidence was then presented to Cardiff Crown Court by SWP’s psychiatrist with the judge finding in favour of both Dr Kemp and Dr Silva. As a result I was not sectioned to Ashworth but again denied copies of the new forensic evidence served on the court the Crown Prosecution Service needed for the SWP’s further sectioning application (see severely redacted court transcript re cancer being the cause of my ‘threat’ to the forensic psychiatrist and Chief Constable only).17th December 2009 Bail application refused on medical grounds by Judge Neil Bidder QC. In the afternoon an officer in the prison casually told me that I was no longer MAPPA registered. I was retained in HMP Cardiff until 09th February 2010 despite my being no longer MAPPA registered. I believe that this was due to SWP wanting to stop communication with my supporters: Peter Oakes, Patrick Cullinane

Page 8 of 21

WORKING DRAFT

and Norman Scarth and now others who had all personally complained to the SWP psychiatrist and then Recorder of Cardiff, His Honour Judge Nicholas Cooke QC for what was clearly going on.

2010: Serious Physical Pain Problems and Consequences due to the Reports by Caswell Clinic

25th January 2010 In Cardiff Crown Court the SWP ask for the mandatory prison term of 5 years for being in possession of a prohibitive weapon and 5 years for selling it.9th February 2010 A jury at Cardiff Crown Court acquitted me of all charges connected with the Lewis gun without even the need of having to call evidence in my defence. I had been remanded in custody with regard to the Lewis gun. A police psychiatrist found I had no relevant medical abnormality to require detention or treatment. As a consequence, Barry magistrates granted me unconditional bail. The Prosecution appealed.

Acquitted despite the police having painted the decommissioned gun a different colour to try and fool the jury, at least nine of which were convinced there was a ‘police plant’ amongst them and a miraculous ‘sex change’ by one undercover agent that could not avoid facing cross examination.

March 2010 I attended a meeting at the House of Lords where some 20 victims of white collar crimes introduced themselves, including the three supporters who had written to Caswell Clinic on my behalf. Videos can be found here1 with my introduction here2.

April 2010 I make videoed and written complaint at Barry police station but instead of acting on my complaint SWP made fun of me with their newly acquired body cameras goading me on in order to have me arrested again.April 2010: The Recorder of Cardiff refused to release the previously promised police and Caswell Clinic records and in particular, the new Caswell Clinic evidence the 2nd December 2009 prosecutor had relied upon. My being again ignored resulted in my imprisonment for ‘contempt of court’.May 2010 Violently assaulted at 6am in my own living room by SWP in the guise of an arrest for public order after having caught vandals caused an estimated £10,000 worth of damage on my property.

1 https://edm1297.wordpress.com/2010/03/11/tackling-the-serious-oppression-of-hm-subjects/ 2 https://mauricejohnkirk.com/videos/

Page 9 of 21

WORKING DRAFT

The usual complaints on criminal damage are ignored and charges dropped.June 2010 The Civil Aviation Authority [CAA] restored my licences to fly aircraft following two of their psychiatrists stating, when referring to SWP complaint to them in June 2009, that “it was not a medical issue.”

22nd June 2010 An anaesthetist of the Vale Hospital South Glamorgan refuses to assist in my urgently needed total hip replacement until the Caswell Clinic medical reports are corrected. I was assured attempts had been made. This lead to nine months on daily doses morphine sulphate which has left me partially incapacitated.June 2010 Following police seizure of my gun collection in June 2009, I made a magistrate’s application and refused for the return of my collection of both antique and licenced working shot guns with loss in excess of £10,000

July 2010 Following a physical assault in Merdrignac France the resulting brain scan resulted in another ‘all clear.’

2nd August 2010 My GP writes to Judge N Cooke QC3 seeking help from the court to correct the medical records based on the erroneous interpretation of the 2009 Caswell Clinic brain scans. 28th August 2010 I had applied for a court order to release my MAPPA records that allowed SWP’s actions against me and included the phrase, “that I was likely to be shot”. The trial judge, in civil proceedings, HHJ Seys Llewellyn QC refused to disclose the MAPPA records.2nd September 2010 My UK GP confirms the need for my continuous pain relief medication including daily morphine and now need for crutches supplied by NHS Wales but continuing to refuse to carry out my needed total hip replacement or even review the 2009 Caswell clinic medical reports.

2011: Hip Problem Solved in France

5 Arrests due to SWP when Helping the Nigerian Musas in family courtsSWP’s Psychiatrist Initiates Actions for alleged Harassment via my Website15th February 2011 French GP prescribes more morphine prior to hip operation.March 2011 French brain scan prior to total hip replacement in Pontivy shows “all clear.”

3 https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B8aTrTXscxFFMWhTWkRwcmhuakE/view?usp=sharing

Page 10 of 21

WORKING DRAFT

August 2011` I assisted the Nigerian Musa parents as a McKenzie Friend in the High Court in London and at Tottenham Police Station. They had been charged with “conspiracy to abduct their own six children” back to Africa.

I was first arrested at the High Court because I was falsely suspected by four Haringey Council lawyers of tape recording the secret family hearing. Police afterwards apologised profusely on acting on deliberately wrong information.

The second arrest followed after I was first unlawfully detained without arrest while I listened in to lengthy banter with SWP staff on the telephone on the precise subject of my current forensic record when specifically, I had only been there to witness the Musa weekly reporting and proof a ‘Return to Bail’ date.

The third arrest was first due to Tottenham Police believing that I would fly the Nigerian children in my WW2 two seater Piper Cub out of the UK to safety in France but changed, following information from SWP, to one of s125 under the 1983 Mental Health Act

The fourth arrest was due to London Police believing that I had committed a ‘race related’ offence during our attempts for the Musas to regain possession of their legal papers from a lawyer wishing to continue drawing the legal aid on the eight coloured individuals.

The fifth arrest, on 1st December 2011, was for ‘failing to attend’ Highbury Corner Magistrates Court on 28th November 2011 because SWP had ordered HMP Cardiff not to produce me to the London court despite my protests.

All five arrests originated from communication with SWP who shared the same spurious medical information about me with the Metropolitan Police that led to my initial s135/136 detention.September 2011 At Tottenham Police Station I was examined by a local forensic psychiatrist and senior psychiatric nurse who said and wrote that there were no symptoms to justify implementation of further detention under the Mental Health Act. But based on what SWP had then told him, he told me, he had little option but to recommend to the London police that they make an application for yet another s35 of the Mental Health Act to ensure my continuing custody.The Magistrates Court at Highbury and Islington Corner, next day, expressed their disquiet in such need for such an application under the 1983 Mental Health Act dismissed the SWP’s application. The immediate appeal applied for by the local police led their local Crown Prosecution Service to make its own ‘enquiries’ independent of the SWP. The appeal, after the statutory two hours in custody, was withdrawn.

Page 11 of 21

WORKING DRAFT

Allegations of Harassing SWP’s Psychiatrist result in Three Years in Prison so farEven though I was acquitted and released from prison, I failed to obtain copies of my medical records from Caswell Clinic. I also failed to get SWP to investigate my video evidence of collusion with other parties surrounding MAPPA and the forensic psychiatrist in the machine gun case. In the spirit of the 1997 Harassment Act, I pursued my “course of conduct of preventing or detecting crime.” However, since evidence has shown that SWP have been acting criminally themselves, crimes were not investigated, but covered up and I kept being stitched up not unlike many other whistle blowers up and down the country. 3rd September 2011 I was arrested, charged and imprisoned for the alleged harassment of SWP’s psychiatrist via my website and for the distribution of posters highlighting extracts of the overall erroneous medical report.15th November 2011 In Cardiff Magistrates Court, SWP claimed that I was not allowed to cross-examine the Police Officers and SWP psychiatrist because I was deemed not “medically fit”.28th November 2011 Cardiff prison prevented me from appearing at Highbury Magistrates Court. 1st December 2011: I was convicted for Harassment and sentenced. But the sentence was cut short due to supporters who had succeeded to get me released from Caswell Clinic early and who continue to support me in this case. However, I refused to leave the Court cell until I was given copies of the records usually given to a prisoner on day of release. I was specifically refused my request as to the outcome of what had occurred in court during my absence. Eventually I was dragged out with the force of four custody officers who threw my crutches on my head, as I lay on the floor with my possessions outside the custody suite.Instead of letting me go, I was ‘gate arrested’ by SWP for failing to attend the Musa related case in Highbury Magistrates Court two days earlier. SWP and court had recorded “mental health issues” and as to whether a ‘restraining order’ was in my pocket or not before driving me to court where I was convicted and fined for failing to attend and released.

7th Dec 2011: 1st Alleged Breach of a Restraining Order never served in the first place

Page 12 of 21

WORKING DRAFT

8th December 2011: A police sergeant t from Llantwit Major telephones to inform me, to my surprise, that I had breached a restraining order and there was an arrest out for me.9th December 2011: To give witness evidence in the Musa case, I attend the hearing in Wood Green Court where I was arrested – for the first of eight supposed breaches of a Restraining Order. However, this Restraining Order was never served on me for the following reasons:

1. The prison authorities assumed I was returning back to prison to complete a maximum term of six months, a further two weeks. In that case, HMP staff would have served such an Order upon release.

2. The ‘gate arrest’ caused me to go into SWP custody and London Court.

3. Custody Services for court cells keep CCTV logs on violent MAPPA registered prisoners

4. None of these authorities informed me of any existence of a Restraining Order and I made many attempts to have their records seized to confirm before more evidence is altered as with the magistrate’s court clerk’s contemporaneous notes and court log.

I was returned to Cardiff prison until June 2012.

2012: Who’s Harassing Whom?

1st March 2012 My appeal against the conviction for harassment is dismissed on medical grounds.4th May 2012 The jury asked by way of ‘jury note’, unbeknown to me, for sight of documentary court and custody evidence, confirmed to be in existence, that the Restraining Order had been served. The Court had heard that the Clerk of the Court had seen the Order being served on me, whilst I was coming down the cells corridor on crutches. The Custody manager said, to the contrary, that he personally gave me the Restraining Order in my cell with at least three other staff standing beside him, due to “regulations for my being a mental patient, dangerous and MAPPA registered.”

However, I am convicted and sentenced to nine months and immediately lodged an appeal. June 2012: 2nd Alleged Breach of a Restraining Order never served

in the first placeFollowing my release from prison for the 1st alleged breach of a restraining order the very same SWP’s psychiatrist made another written complaint

Page 13 of 21

WORKING DRAFT

and this time the SWP had to “move me on” when I was found, in the dead of night, supposedly in possession of a can of petrol. I was arrested and detained in prison until October 2012, when all allegations were dropped. I had no idea of where both Dr Janis Hiliar and the SWP psychiatrist lived.June 2012 While being refused the right to file my appeal papers at the public counter for the first Restraining Order conviction, to be forwarded to the Criminal Court of Appeal, this same ex-SWP court official pushed me violently down Crown Court steps and breaking my right leg. Retaliation only by verbal argument led to my arrest for ‘common assault’ and a conviction. I immediately appealed, but the appeal was delayed for over two years to gain maximum effect of the conviction to affect bail applications. The appeal was moved to Bristol Crown Court where the hearing went unopposed and denied costs.September 2012 Arrest and remanded to prison until November 2012 for ‘assault on prison officer. I had actually gained entry to the Cardiff prison and had arrested the specific prison officer who had thought it very amusing to keep back my passport, upon release all knowing it was required for my travelling to France for the preparation of my legal proceedings against the SWP. I was denied any film from the seven separately positioned surveillance cameras as it clearly revealed I was the one assaulted and not the prison officer. At the appeal the sentence was reduced to 6 weeks but my ‘case stated’ application in the RCJ was finally upheld on 4th Feb 2016 by the current Lord Chief Justice originating from the fact that my first wife nor a member of the public had been allowed to take notes on my behalf caged in a glorified gold fish bowl with no easy way of seeing, hearing when denied access to my own legal papers whilst unrepresented.

2013: Harassment by ArrestsJanuary 2013 French police detain and take me to the psychiatric hospital in Pontivy for no apparent reason but later established to have been malicious information from SWP.14th March 2013 The 1st breach of a restraining order appeal was before Lord Justice Leveson in the Criminal Court of Appeal, sitting in Cardiff Crown Court with Mr Justice Melling who stated that “there was nothing in the transcript relating to the jury requesting such information.” Not only had there been at two ‘jury notes’ on that specific request the ‘jury notes’ were also withheld from me, the appellant, which was of no surprise to me or my supporters who saw it all happen from the public gallery. A repeat

Page 14 of 21

WORKING DRAFT

scenario equally as shambolic as 1st December 2011 magistrates ‘harassment’ final hearing that led to my release two weeks too early.April 2013 The original SWP 33 failed malicious prosecutions trial, BS614159, was at last started after 20 years and heard over a few months but with only half of the original witnesses for the Claimant surviving the ravages of time.12th April 2013 1st Restraining Order allegedly now ‘varied’ following CPS application, all news to me, appears to have been done to get around the fact no first one was ever served on me in the first place.Only when found amongst the committal papers of March/April 2012 for the 1st jury trial was I aware of this prosecution exhibit. I remain unable to detect the ‘variation’ which does nothing to allay my fears, following the irregular alteration of original court records surrounding the 1st restraining order being drafted, now been proved beyond doubt after three CPS barristers’ admissions in Bristol Crown Court in November 2014 (see transcript & court log). Therefore, there is now doubt as to which order was being used for the 2nd aborted jury trial and as to the circumstances why the need for this possible 3rd order from a suspected varied 2nd order was ever correctly served on me as no one will come forward and explain. Why was there the need for the 2nd or 3rd restraining order at all or be varied? May 2013 Arrested for drink/drive on private property without request for a ‘breath test’ only to find a zero-reading breath test, at the police station but not before well over an hour’s delay while someone was trying to dream-up some excuse to keep me in custody.June 2013 I was arrested for drink / drive but was not allowed to conduct a road side breath test because SWP knew the result would be negative. At Police Station, I was held for an hour before a definitive breath test was carried out with a zero reading. . In June 2013 I conducted a Private Person’s arrest on the Crown Prosecutor who conducted the harassment conviction proceedings in 2011. This resulted in an assault conviction with an ‘unconditional discharge’. The Welsh authorities delayed my appeal again for over two years and it was eventually also heard in Bristol

July 2013 I was arrested and remanded in custody for common assault on two people, now squatting and carrying out serious vandalism on the property. Then I was further remand to prison for months for still groundless charges, this time for ‘intimidation of witnesses’. All charges

Page 15 of 21

WORKING DRAFT

were dropped in October 13 again, as late as possible before Crown Prosecution Service could scrutinise the evidence for a possible jury. 21st September 13, I had to arrest the relevant prison officer for withholding back my passport upon release. Everybody knew that I needed it to return to France for essential legal papers. However, I was arrested for common assault in 2013 and convicted on 10th December 2013. During the Crown Prosecutor’s cross examination, in November 2014, he admitted that he had no knowledge of my receiving a Restraining Order on 1 st December 2011 in the cells and that the only document that the Clerk of the Court brought to me in the cells, as far as he knew, was his own CPS prepared typed draft. This was part hand written over by the presiding magistrate, whilst in open court (see four eye witness statements), before he ordered it to be taken it to my cell for possible agreement.3rd Alleged Breach of a Restraining Order never served in the first place13th Oct 13 I had repeatedly tried, that night, to speak to a police officer re my court ordered psychiatric report appointment, in two days clashing with the Recorder of Cardiff’s Crown Court’s hearing, also in two days, to consider that doctor’s report and doctor’s particular appraisal as to whether I should remain on MAPPA registration and be transferred to Ashworth high security psychiatric hospital, indefinitely, as the police had requested due to its diagnosed ‘significant brain damage’ may be worse. Whereas in October 2009, the original blackmailed police doctor had warned of my ‘increasing risk’ to the Chief Constable alone, never the general public, if I insisted in continuing my civil damages claims against her, further investigation was long overdue and clearly needed over the progression of my alleged ‘brain tumour’ without my ever getting to know about it.The police also had new problems which meant the need to fabricate yet another ‘arrest’ of their victim, using the excuse again for implementing my indefinite incarceration under the 1983 Mental Health Act. The previous Chief Constable had now tried to get me killed and its resultant civil damages claim, 1CF03361, was the concern of the new chief constable equally worried about his large pension at risk in ‘going up in smoke’.The civil claim, of some magnitude, could not be conveniently buried beyond seven years, so far, as His Honour Judge Seys Llewellyn QC had to retire some time. The doctor had considered he was the only other one at risk in the UK, if I remained alive and able to communicate with others capable, he thought,

Page 16 of 21

WORKING DRAFT

to resorting to violence against him. He had his own restraining orders breached, been sacked from NHS and as the police chief psychiatrist and so was forced to exit the UK to seek locum employment in New Zealand when all he needed to do was correct my medical reports that have ruined my life. The police staff, that night, therefore played games on the telephone, refusing to put a police officer on to recommend my best action. I then walked down the street that night where I was seen on CCTV buying wine before returning to my flat and later going to bed.The police HQ then telephoned me back and continued to try and provoke me into a temper having been awakened and having consumed alcohol.On 14th October 2013, next day, upon arriving at the Barry police station to make a further written complaint on the continuing effect the 2009 Caswell Clinic fabricated medical reports were having on me and further complaint as to why the thief of my £1500 from my veterinary surgery (one of ongoing civil claims against SWP) had not been now arrested? His BMW car had been found and again identified by myself but, Instead, I was detained in custody for over one hour without arrest contrary PACE procedure.My subsequent arrest and again with police refusing to take my new statement of complaint of how I had briefly caught the thief but I was on crutches so he ‘got away’, had, in itself, been unlawfully delayed. I found out later because the SWP’s psychiatrist’s London solicitor, Mr Bright, was reluctant to release any more written complaints on behalf of his client in New Zealand by formulating a victim witness statement either of ‘harassment’ or that of a ‘breach of a restraining order’ as I had clearly proved on website the standard defence in the 1997 Prevention of Harassment Act----you cannot be charged for ‘harassment’ if your conduct was ‘reasonable’ and either ‘detecting’ or ‘preventing’ crime being committed.. I was detained in custody until March 2015 due to my term of imprisonment being doubled and confirmed in writing, as no local forensic or otherwise psychiatrist was prepared to sit on the Parole Board for allow my release.

2014: Medical means Physical, Emotional and Mental

March 2014 Forensic psychiatrist Dr David Seely examinations concluded “no relevant psychiatric problems but the need for a neurologist opinion” in the light of 2009 Caswell clinic medical records indicating significant brain damage and/or brain tumour.

Page 17 of 21

WORKING DRAFT

2nd May 2014 I was convicted for the 2nd breach of a Restraining Order and gaoled for eight months with a 2nd conviction and eight months sentence concerning an alleged ‘threatening telephone’ call whilst police provoked and under the influence of alcohol. But on the 28th April the learned judge, despite my being in prison throughout the relevant time, held another clandestine hearing, my seventh now, where I was denied access each time whilst unrepresented.July 2014 I was released on parole on 4th July to a secure MAPPA hostel but made to report every hour at the desk during day light hours. This meant my variation needed to meet an urgent internal medical examination was refused by the SWP as ‘too dangerous’ to travel to the Cardiff hospital. Argument led to my being returned to Swansea prison for a further eight months without the need of an inconvenient court appearance when truth had a real risk of coming being heard and recorded.I was therefore in custody until March 2015 due to my prison term having been doubled.I had to have to go abroad in order to have diagnosed the carcinogenic lesions arising from deliberate neglect by the South Wales Police, Ministry of Justice, Parole Board, NHS (Wales) and Cardiff law courts still bitter all over the number of failed malicious prosecutions and failed attempt on 22nd June 2009 in having me shot by one of twenty five police officers and helicopter that had surrounded our home to snatch our daughter, Genevieve.1st October 2014 Further leaks from MAPPA medical evidence reveal thirteen gross errors on two pages.

2015: The Desperate Attempts to Get myself back to Prison with the Aid of a Restraining Order

27th January 2015 Following Swansea prison, having wheeled me off the custody van for Cardiff Crown Court, sitting as a High Court, then Gilbart J is informed that I had ‘refused’ to get on the van to go to Court. I was wheelchair bound as a consequence of medical negligence in HMP Swansea now confirmed by off shore medical examination refused me by SWP whilst in prison and again, in July 2014 while at a MAPPA hostel.This meant my variation needed to meet an urgent internal medical examination was refused by the SWP as ‘too dangerous’ to travel to the Cardiff hospital. Argument led to my being returned to Swansea prison without the need of a court appearance.

Page 18 of 21

WORKING DRAFT

I was detained in custody until March 2015 due to my term of imprisonment being doubled and confirmed in writing, as no local forensic or otherwise psychiatrist was prepared to sit on the Parole Board for allow my release. Royal courts of Justice and just the beginning of numerous other civil and criminal actions all resulting in a judiciary in capable of keeping law and order in Wales.This has resulted in the appeal now against the Ministry of Justice, Parole Board of England and Wales and South Wales Police before the Court of Appeal in The Royal Courts of Justice all originating from the SWP psychiatrist having fabricated medical data that no one in South Wales appears to have the moral fibre to do anything about.At Bristol Crown Court my appeal against assault (arrest of Crown Prosecutor) from June 2013 was dismissed.February 2015 SWP refused to allow my attending my pre-arranged hospital appointment as they considered me ‘too dangerous’ and ‘was likely to escape’. SWP repeated this tactic, even when I was on licence on parole, in July 2014 being allowed out of custody for only one hour at a time, due to my MAPPA status. However, I am still lacking evidence of my MAPPA registrations being put on and off how many times? April 2015 The appeal of the December 2013 conviction I had entered a prison without permission and had arrested the prison officer instructed by SWP not to return my passport for fear I would be able to retrieve my files, safely stored in France well away from SWP influence or so I thought was heard, when Cardiff judge Crowther QC.The learned judge refused both my ex-wife, Janet and a member of the public the right to take notes on my behalf. The outcome of the appeal was that the conviction was upheld with the sentence reduced to six weeks which is now a matter before the European Court of Human Rights. 8th November 2015 I pass a medical examination for a CAA medical certificate.At Bristol Crown Court my appeal against assault (arrest of Crown Prosecutor) from June 2013 was dismissed.BUT as the prosecutor David Gareth Evans, on being cross examined, confirmed: there had been no 1 st Restraining Order in existence, of course, when his draft had been brought to my cell and the prosecutors for the respondent in this appeal also confirmed both the court log the original 1 st

December 2001 magistrates’ clerk’s notes still existed and the court log. But on examination by the 17 th November 2017 the Crown Court will find both were irregularly altered following the unpredicted request by the 4 th May 2012 jury, by ‘jury note’, asking to see both but were refused as ‘irrelevant’ as not ‘evidence’!

Page 19 of 21

WORKING DRAFT

2016: Who Complains about Whom on Whose Behalf?.28th Feb 2016 4th Alleged Breach of a ‘Variation', this time, of 1st December 2011 Restraining Order never served in the first place nor can I or my supporters see a difference in this document nothing more than a latest ploy to bury the truth within the withheld custody records just requiring some with the will to call in an outside police force to investigate. As sure as night follows day there will be another jury trial unless the sacked police psychiatrist corrects his own medical reports voluntarily or otherwise but let us not forget the ‘nigger in the wood pile’ in all this, retired Professor Rodger Wood, who arrogantly lied about the interpretation of the brain scans to have totally misled the already blackmailed police psychiatrist. 3rd November 2016 I pass a medical examination for a CAA medical certificate on the same day the sacked SWP psychiatrist, the one that had caused my flying licences all to be revoked in 2009 over police machine trading nonsense, no longer able to work in the NHS, wrote a formal complaint again about me but it needed a further six or so attempts on my part to try and get someone to rectify the damage continuing to be caused before I am arrested for a breach of a restraining resulting from fabricated I was released from Swansea prison on 4th July only to be returned to prison following the SWP refusing to allow my appointment for now serious abdominal problems eventually diagnosed abroad.

2017: So, Who Benefits from the Restraining Order?

10th June 2017 A violent assault to my head results in brain scan that confirms ‘all clear’.25th July 2017 Directions hearing where Dafydd Morgan handed a press statement about the Llangunnor Six to the CPS, together with a report he had produced for Thames Valley Police. The report is about serious grievances by many victims of Dyfed Powys Police.

Page 20 of 21

WORKING DRAFT

September 2017 A 3rd jury finds me guilty of having violated the Varied Restraining Order, still not identified as being any different to the original 1st December 201 Order that was never served on me, in the first place. Strangely, the CPS, repeated in November, that any court now considered it was ‘served’ on me on 1st December 2011 because the Recorder of Cardiff said so despite having had nothing to do with any of it.As a member of the Llangunnor Six, I am aware that Adrian Oliver of Dolmans is the external solicitor of SWP, Dyfed Powys and Gwent Police. Therefore, Adrian Oliver would be aware of all prominent complaints in Wales. However, instead of settling cases, Dolmans keep making money out of Police Forces. 17th November 2017 Judge Tracy Lloyd-Clarke, when presiding over ‘sentencing’ for my 3rd jury trial conviction, apologised for the near two months delay it had taken to find a psychiatrist for making a report in no conflict with a South Wales Police psychiatrist which is at least better than the seven months it purportedly took the Swansea prison parole board to find such a one, in 2015, not that the board was allowed by MAPPA to use the ‘found’ psychiatrist in any event. The learned judge was clearly told I had already arranged a psychiatric report and it was in the possession of the crown Prosecution Service. The latter refused to produce it as it was by a Dr Metters.

(17 photos)

16th Nov 17 rough copy

Page 21 of 21