-

MALAYSIA

US

SINGAPORE

THAILAND

HONG KONGMIDDLE EAST

SWITZERLAND

MALAYSIAWhere it all began■ Originally called Terengganu Investment Authority, the firm was set up in February 2009 to tap the state’s bountiful oil royalty. Cracks appeared soon after it raised RM5 billion via bonds and within just seven months, it was moved to MOF and renamed 1MDB. ■ The strategic invest ment vehicle came armed with lofty goals of wooing FDI and catalysing sustainable development. It would eventually buckle under insurmountable debt, losses and deals with poor commercial value, compelling a restructuring that is now under way. ■ Allegations of egregious wrongdoing at 1MDB have triggered a sweeping probe by multiple agencies, assisted by foreign regulators.■ The allegations have also roiled the country’s highest office − Prime Minister Najib Razak, who has denied the allegations.

SINGAPORENot too close for comfort■ An international financial hub known for its tough laws against “dirty” money. Singapore Police have launched a probe into possible money laundering offences and has frozen two bank accounts related to the 1MDB money trail. It is not clear which banks and whose accounts are involved.■ Bank accounts in Singapore belonging to Jho Low, an individual at the centre of the controversy who was TIA’s special adviser and owns luxury condo units here, are also reportedly under scrutiny.■ The Monetary Authority of Singapore has said it was committed to provide assistance “within the full ambit” of its laws to Malaysian authorities.■ Swiss wealth manager BSI’s Singapore branch is where 1MDB CEO Arul Kanda said the firm was keeping US$1.1 billion worth of ‘units’, a portion of its US$2.318 billion controversial investment in Cayman- registered funds redeemed last year.

HONG KONGWater under the Bridge■ One of the biggest sore points among critics was that 1MDB had ploughed US$2.318 billion into Cayman Islands- registered investments. The funds,which arose from a convoluted deal with PetroSaudi International (PSI) − its first and most scutinised deal − was managed by Hong Kong-based fund manager Bridge Partners, a little-known firm, deemed too modestly sized to manage funds of a state-backed entity.■ Following a BT report last year that the funds were managed by Bridge Partners − 1MDB had not disclosed the identity of the fund managers prior to that although it was urged to do so by critics − the fund manager removed details of its key executives from the website and it remains so till today.■ HK is also the base of Jynwel Capital, a private equity firm helmed by Mr Low.

THAILANDThe X-avier factor■ The plot thickened when Thai police in June arrested a former PSI executive Xavier Justo in his posh home in Koh Samui for allegedly blackmailing his former employer PSI on information related to the 1MDB-PSI deal. He has also confessed to leaking the information to some media outlets and politicians from UMNO and the opposition. Following Mr Justo’s arrest, PSI said it has been a victim of “a regrettable crime that has unfortunately been politicised in Malaysia”.■ The Malaysian police is seeking permission from Thai authorities to interrogate the 49-year-old Swiss national on matters related to 1MDB.■ Justo has not been formally charged but according to Thai police, has admitted to committing blackmail. According to a report by The Straits Times, Mr Justo has given a “full confession” and has identified 10 individuals who bought the documents from him which were used to attack Mr Najib.

MIDDLE EASTIn the middle of the storm■ At the heart of the scrutiny is 1MDB’s pact in 2009 with PSI which is owned by Saudi businessman Tarek Obaid and Prince Turki Abdullah Al Saud, the seventh son of Saudi Arabia’s King Abdullah who died earlier this year. This pact was inked under Shahrol Halmi, 1MDB’s first chief executive who left the firm in 2013. ■ 1MDB’s investments with Abu Dhabi’s Aabar Investments whose parent is International Petroleum Investment Co (IPIC) has also raised eyebrows.■ Last month, IPIC provided 1MDB with US$1 billion cash to help repay a US$975 million loan and also agreed to assume a portion of its debt, in exchange for assets that have not been disclosed.

SWITZERLANDWhere the monied elite keep their stash■ The 1MDB money trail reportedly involves several accounts in Zurich- based banks which has prompted Swiss authorities to share information with authorities in the 1MDB probe. ■ The Wall Street Journal reported that US$681 million was moved from a bank account in Aabar-owned Swiss bank Falcon’s Singapore branch into accounts in a KL bank allegedly held by Mr Najib in 2013, damning allegations that the leader has rebuffed as lies.■ WSJ also reported that US$529 million was deposited into a business account in Singapore allegedly held by Mr Low between 2011 and 2013 from a Swiss bank account.

UKOf botched deals & police reports■ In 2010/2011, 1MDB was invited by Aabar to bid for three hotel properties in London. The bid fell through but it piqued interest as Mr Low, who has consistently denied having any involvement with 1MDB, was also a co-investor in the bid. ■ One of the main offices of PSI which, according to its website is an oil exploration and production firm, is in the UK. ■ In March, PSI reportedly lodged a report with London’s Police Action Fraud Unit at the National Fraud and Cyber Crime Reporting Centre over an article in Sarawak Report which alleged that the firm was used as a front to siphon money from 1MDB.

USThe stuff of Hollywood movies■ US bank Goldman Sachs has suffered a reputational hit in Malaysia’s corporate scene after it arranged a US$3 billion bond issue for 1MDB in 2013 and pocketed profits of US$300 million, an amount deemed unusually large and has raised the ire of 1MDB’s critics. With the fallout involving 1MDB, many Malaysian corporates have shunned the bank. ■ Of 1MDB’s many ambitious projects, its solar power aspirations are relatively less widely known. BT reported in June last year that it tied up with Washington-based private equity firm DuSable Capital Management. Dusable was co-founded by Frank White, Jr, a top individual fundraiser for Mr Obama, and another of the president’s backers, Shomik Dutta. The tie- up fell through for reasons not known. ■ The New York Times reported in February that wheeler-dealer Jho Low bought prime real estate in the US that he later sold to pal and Hollywood producer Riza Aziz who funded The Wolf of Wall Street, for healthy profits. Mr Riza is Mr Najib’s stepson.

UK

BT Design: Ludwig Ilio & Simon Ang

US$2.318 billion controversial investment in Cayman- registered funds redeemed last year.

Najib Razak

Jho Low

Arul Kanda

Shahrol Halmi

Tarek Obaid

BT Explains

1MDB‘Tentacles’

The big fallout of Malaysia’s troubled 1Malaysia Development Berhad (1MDB),

a state-owned strategic investment firm saddled with over RM42 billion

debt, may appear to be largely a local dilemma but its tentacles extend to

organisations and personalities across the globe which

underscores the extraordinary reach of the scandal.

BY ANITA GABRIEL

Continued from Page 1

And it’s tricky. “Whatever the outcome, there willprobablybe equal numberofpeople unhappy with PAC’s conclusion. I am preparing myself to lose the nextgeneral election, whatever the result.”

As far as lack ofpublic faith is concerned,PAC mayhave it relatively easyasmuchof it ismostlydirected at the concurrent probe that isbeing led byaspe-cial task force headed by Attorney-General Abdul Gani Patail and comprisingofficers fromtheAttorney-General’sChambers,centralbank,anti-graft agencyand police.

The task force is probing allegations raised in a report in The Wall StreetJournal that US$700 million was moved from firms and government agencieslinked to 1MDB to personal bank accounts allegedly belonging to Mr Najibback in2013as the countrywas preparing for itsmost hotly contestedgeneralelection.

MrJazlan isquick tomakethedistinctionbetweenPAC andthismulti-agen-cy force. “The task force can be deemed as not independent as they report tothe executive. Their investigations are done in-house and can be deemed asnot transparent.”

“But they do have the resources to conduct forensic audits and have the au-thority to procure data from their foreign counterparts which the PAC doesn’thave,” he said, adding that ultimately, the probes are meant to complementone another.

Events in recent days have fuelled some hope that things may be crankingupinwhatearlier appearedtobeaprobewhosepacewas far too languid giventhe seriousness of the allegations.

Two board members of firms linked to 1MDB have been nabbed this weekto assist the task force in its probe. One of them is the managing director of afirm which, according to the WSJ report, was allegedly involved in the transferof funds to Mr Najib’s accounts, an allegation that the firm had earlier deniedas baseless and untrue.

It was also reported by a Malaysian newspaper that more than 10 peoplefrom the business and financial sectors as well as politicians are on the “watchlist” of the task force and may be arrested.

In Singapore, the investigation into 1MDB’s money trail to assist Malaysian

authorities has led the police to launch a probe into possible money launder-ing offences, with freeze orders issued on two accounts in banks here on July15. The banks and owner(s) of the accounts were not disclosed.

Over two weeks ago, the Auditor-General’s office presented its initial find-ings in an interim audit report to PAC for further action. Since then, there havebeen calls for the report, which insiders say had flagged key oversights by theboard and management, to be made public but that hasn’t happened.

“The Auditor-General’s report is his property and it is up to him to releaseto the public,” said Mr Jazlan. “We will incorporate his findings in our report. Itis dangerous to derive conclusions from interim reports as its substance maychange depending on new information.

“The A-G (Auditor-General) reported to us that he hasn’t received some in-formationfrom 1MDB to completehis report. PAC canhelp him by demandingand persuading 1MDB to forward the documents.”

All the testimonies during PAC’s interview sessions are written down in theHansard in verbatim which will be public statements that can be used in acourt of law for legal proceedings.

“That is a powerful weapon toget ourwitnesses to tell the truth. Thosewhoare summoned have a great deal to lose in reputation, be it the auditors, civilservants or businessmen like Jho Low,” he added.

Lack of corporategovernance the causeof 1MDB’s troubles

The task force is probing allegations raised in a report in The Wall StreetJournal that US$700 million was moved from firms and governmentagencies linked to 1MDB to personal bank accounts allegedly belongingto Mr Najib back in 2013 as the country was preparing for its most hotlycontested general election. PHOTO: BLOOMBERG

2 | TOP STORIESThe Business Times | Thursday, July 23, 2015