26-Jun-08 For Computer Society Internal Use Only 1 Computer Society Topics for Standards Committees (SC) Design Automation SC 26-Jun-08 John Walz, IEEE-CS

26-Jun-08 For Computer Society Internal Use Only 1

Computer Society Topics for Standards Committees (SC)

Design Automation SC 26-Jun-08John Walz,

IEEE-CS VP for Standards


Objectives• Improve standards sponsor (SC) vitality• Improve IEEE brand and relevance by producing

timely and excellent standards• Leverage cooperation with IEEE Technical

Committee’s experts• Expand relations to ISO, IEC, ANSI SDO• Expand world-wide presence: China, India• Standards excellence: acceptance criteria, road-

map, modeling• Publicity for sponsors & volunteers work• Awards for volunteers • Need for collaboration tools


Your Vitality measures

Discuss DASC best accomplishments• New/revised Par/Std increased over 2006 • Participate on IEEE-SA Standards Board• Participate on IEEE Council on EDA• Joint SA CAG sponsorship of Standards• IEEE-SA Sponsor 2007 Award for

outstanding contributions to corporate standards

• TC on Design Automation (TCDA) incl. DASC

– TCDA Purpose includes Standards– TCDA has roadmap & new technologies– Design standards processes at EDPS

conference• Consortia relationships including

specifications for IEEE standards and technology roadmap (SPIRIT)

• . . .

Your DASC areas to work?• Attended 1 of last 3 CS/SAB mtg• DASC Status Report – Out of date

September 2006• Appeals to IEEE-SA (2006)• Today’s meeting date not on web• TC on VLSI (TCVLSI) involvement?• Adoption of IEC standards?• . . .

• Companies conformance to DASC Standards?

– High coverage measurement in terms of market share

• Growth & worldwide diversity & IEEE memberships?


SC/Technical Committees (TC) Relationships Objectives

• Create relevant and timely standards by engaging CS Technical Committees (TC) membership into Standards Committee (SC) Groups: Study, Working, & Balloting

• Promote awareness and deployment of Standards and sales of CS derivative supportive products by engaging CS Technical Committees to use Standards information and products in their conferences and publications

• DASC work area maps to – TC on Design Automation (TCDA)– TC on VLSI (TCVLSI)


SC/TC Relationships Benefits • TC experts & GOLD members are quick to uncover

emerging technology for Standards• TC experts can drive new SC Study Groups to propose

standards. • TC experts can comment / ballot on SC Working Group

draft standards as to the relevancy to the current problem

• TC experts can recommend channels for SC products supporting deployment of standards

GOLD = Graduates Of the Last Decade


Society model for developing standards

SC are designed to use Society’s infrastructure of technical activities, conferences, awards, publications, and Chapters, for:

• Access to technical experts for the Standards Study Group, Working Group, & Balloting Group

• Contribution to Standards Committee “roadmap” of current and future projects

• Early detection of emerging technologies• Expert reviews of draft PAR and draft standards• Co-location of Standards Working Group meetings with

Conference• Support of standards deployment and implementation • Recognize volunteers• Provide opportunities for volunteers to be authors


Society model for developing standards

Study Group Working Group Ballot Group User Group

Standards Committees

Technical Activities

Conferences Publications

Awards Chapters

Society governance & infrastructure


Your interactions w/ Technical Committee(s)

• Validate the TC mapping TC for DA & VLSI• Validate the Conference mapping• Propose Contact with TC “Standards Champion” to:

– Add Standards Champion name to your web page organization chart

– Invitation for TC GOLD industry practitioners to join existing Standards Working Groups

– Review your current Projects and invitation to join Standards Balloting Groups

– Reveal your SC view of the technology road map and where your current & future PARs fit in

– Start up discussion forum on emerging technology and invitation for future Standards Study Groups

– Call for contributions for the future direction of these standards projects

– Ask for an speaking invitation for next relevant Conference


Your involvement with other CS Boards

• Conferences– Electronic Design Processes (EDP)– Design Automation and Test – Symposium on VLSI

• Publications– ?

• Chapters– ?

• Awards– ?


Your Standards Technology Roadmap• Benefits

– Interoperability Standards– Relevant Standards– Invitation for experts

• TC, Industry executives

– Awareness• Articles, white papers, conference BoF

– TCDA has roadmap & new technologies


Your Standards Technology Roadmap• Modeling framework with a set

of views which, when consistent and read together, defines a complete model of a system of users, technology, & Standards– Requirements view

– Information view

– Stakeholder view

– Process structure view

– Process content view

– Process behavioral view

– Process instance view

Examples• Semiconductors Roadmap (ITRS)

• Nanotechnology Standards Roadmap

• NIST Information Security document Roadmap

• ICT Security Standards Roadmap


Your Industry inputs / feedback for the SC

• IEEE-SA Corporate Advisory Group (CAG)– ?

• IEEE-CS Advanced Technology Executive Forum (ATEF)– ?


Your PAR & draft standard approval criteria, e.g. LMSC(802) Criteria for Standards

• Broad Market Potential– Broad sets of applicability– Multiple vendors and numerous

users– Balanced costs

• Compatibility– Conformance with Architecture,

Management, and Interworking documents

– Each standard shall include a definition of managed objects that are compatible with systems management standards

• Distinct Identity– Substantially different from other

standards– One unique solution per problem

(not two solutions to a problem)– Easy for the document reader to

select the relevant specification• Technical Feasibility

– Demonstrated system feasibility– Proven technology, reasonable

testing– Confidence in reliability

• Economic Feasibility– Known cost factors, reliable data– Reasonable cost for performance– Consideration of installation costs


Your experiences with IEEE standards groups

• Joint Sponsorship of Standardization Projects– Test Technologies?

• IEEE-SA CAG, – P1800, P1801, P1850, P1685, P1735,

• IEEE-SA SCC, – SCC20 Test and Diagnosis for Electronic Systems?

• IEEE Councils, – CEDA Standards Committee

• Victor Berman

• Dennis Brophy

• Gary Delp

• Stanley Krolikoski


Your Relationships with your International Standards Development Organization (SDO)

• Validate the International SDO mapping– IEC TC 93 - Design Automation

• Benefits: – Fast track IEEE Std for Dual Logo– Adoption of IEC standards?

• Victor Berman • Dennis Brophy

• National TAG to ISO, IEC committees– ?

• Opportunities to use ISO/JTC1 PSDO– ?


Your Relationships with Consortia

• Joint memberships• Joint leaders such as established liaisons• Formal / MOU • IEEE-SA Corporate Advisory Group (CAG)

member


DASC relations w/ Consortia

IEEE Relationship key:M: joint membershipsL: joint leaders such as established liaisonsF: Formal / MOU CAG: member of IEEE-SA Corporate Advisory Group

Consortium IEEE projects IEEE Relationship (M,L,F,CAG) Japan Electronics & Information Technology Industries Association (JEITA)

1666 SystemC 1076 VHDL 1364 Verilog 1800 SystemVerilog

M,L,CAG

Electronic Design & Solution Fair (EDSF)

1666, 1364, 1800 Note: this is an annual tradeshow/conference in Japan. The organizers generally have technical forums on SystemC and Verilog with DASC and Accellera participation.

Open SystemC Initiative (OSCI) 1666 M,L Accellera 1076, 1364, 1800

1801 Unified Power Format 1850 PSL

M,L,CAG

The SPIRIT Consortium 1685 IP-XACT M,L European Electronic Chips & Systems design Initiative (ECSI)

1076, 1800, 1685 M,L

Si2 1481 IC Open Library Format

M,L

IEC TC93 1076,1364, 1850 M,L We have setup a Dual Logo program with IEC to publish many of our standards internationally under IEC.

Victor Berman, 23-Apr-08


Your Recognition: Awards, Appointments, Authorship for experts

• IEEE-CS Service Awards: CoA & OCA– ?

• SA-SB & SAB Appointments– Dennis Brophy, SA BoG– Victor Berman, SA SB– Karen Bartleson, SA SB NesCom

• Experts as Authors – Conferences: – e.g. Podcasts & Webinars


Your volunteers’ authorship experiences

• Podcasts• Webinars• Video• Computer Standards Column• White Papers• Journal• Tutorials• Workshop• ReadyNotes (e.g. eBooks)• Books


IEEE-CS Consensus IP Products

Value Chain

Authors capability

Elevator Speech

Video overviewStd Summary Sheet

Podcast Q&A

Webinar

Tutorial

CS Press BookReadyNotes/eBook

Web White paper

Video WebinarComputer Standards Column

Computer article


Your Plans aligned with IEEE-SA Strategic Planning Five Key Focus Areas

• Organizational Business Model– Reflect the full life cycle of standards

• Nurturing Strategic Technologies– Incubate technologies that may become

market-relevant standards

• Process Efficiency– Streamlined process time to completion

for the 4 stages of standards development:

• 1. time to initiation, • 2. time to draft document creation, • 3. ballot and resolution, • 4. full life cycle support.

– The overall results will include faster time to completion.

• Education about Standards– 1. Improve the understanding of

standards– 2. Speed the adoption of standards

and standards related products– 3. Increase global participation /

acceptance and get more people involved in the process

• Global Participation and Perception– Collaborate across world time zone

for relevant standards– Recognize and adopt/assimilate

the best


Collaboration tools• Web page (MS, Google, Yahoo)• Email accounts (MS Hotmail, Google Gmail, Yahoo)• Email group alias (IEEE, Yahoo)• Shared documents for editing & peer review (e.g Google Doc’s, MS

Office Live, MS SkyDrive)• Group calendar (e.g. Google, , MSN Calendar)• Web presentations (e.g. MS LiveMeeting, WebEx)• Telecommunications (e.g. Skype, freeconference.com)• Wiki (sharedinsights.com)• Mind Mapping (mindmeister.com)• Forum discussions (sharedinsights.com, CS Communities: CS SE Online,

CS Distributed Systems Online, WEB Development Online, CS Newsfeed)• blogs (sharedinsights.com)• Polls • Social network (Linkedin.com, Plaxo, IEEE)• ?


Your Action Plans for excellence

•

•

•

Documents

26-Jun-08 For Computer Society Internal Use Only 1 Computer Society Topics for Standards Committees (SC) Design Automation SC 26-Jun-08 John Walz, IEEE-CS