Upload
ravi-bhateja
View
216
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/17/2019 216654659 Criminal Writ of Errors
1/42
.T,NITtrAr-T,UVd g O H.T,P {)I S ri dG T'il\r'[i[3ddv
0
6
uvlll
da6 puz'120[000'AN'?10Z uolFrreH
rr a1doa4
,
09
6?
It It
SAN ol acrrBgep
snou[uuun uo peseq suoqcrluoc plpuoul, asoql aleprlosuoc ol alorrr I
'sfqFIJ feuoqntr1suoC
LV
9?
v,e?
z,0t6t80
LE
It
t{lln truarBdde erou saruoceg }I 'PtmoJord sr sasec turinollo;
'enssr lueunueeJd ar{r sI l€r{J .s}qtlJ lguoqnlrlsuoc [pJapeJ prra els]s du pastcrexa Sur,req dldruls JoJ sunoc arp uro{ rusrcrqso luorrerrrJed pue uoqncasord 'luanrqsrund luannrrarrot i',111HC eleurnlr\ eql peraJJns seq dpurg 1eq1z(lanrsnlcuoc anord sasBc aleredes z(lttmuaas asaql 'srsr(1eue eqf uI 'JaIJq luenbasqns rCrarra 1eug uI u/rlogs acqsnftrr eqJar1l
'e^Rce.ue eg ol pJBetl aq lsntu euo ',resunoft e,4/t'€4geq, Jo ttrnreau eW eururBxa-eJ plnoqs {JoA lneN perot.6r r(pualsrsuoJ os ueaq Eurner{ }Br11 lFrrqns I
9g 98
,t tt
"PelPcIpnfoe ueeq re^eu eABr{
sunoc alegaddu
8/17/2019 216654659 Criminal Writ of Errors
2/42
zt,
te
Iel4 uI Pesrtr rflnp sasuegap alqezn€oc rarTlo 'o8e srea/C [2] uenes pedde es orduo puB unor IBI4 ar{r o1 pasodap s? rNgcoNNI A.ITVnJ,CVd ruB t€rD rr/rlorDl eq I tsntu }I JaSer uoqcr^uor lsod ro; r,ScNScoNNI TVnJCV, secBrqrra /neN 1el{l ttryop^\ou
0t6Z 8Z LZ 9Z
\
{rol
suoqe8el[e dru;o Soord
^\oqs
o1
@
',no1aq dlpaleader
pelsenbor sy
9Z
tzez
zz
tz
oz
'setpeure, one4uaop teqlo lo \cet [6] puB pelsenb€/ se sfupeeq vowtr- 7eltter lo qelrusp Fueq filenpcotd-uou [g] suonetor 'rcuotnursuoc (t) ste^e, unoc q|€'iledde pue fiune rosuno{, e^rwlsut (g) ,sne1nu alr/il"dde eFeldtuof,ul pue prepueFqns (g) pnpu(x,sru, ,errotnces(Ud (fl uol}clpqtnf ngleulgofgns pue f,pt lo r]ce, G) totteqeq lc,utwttc ltoddns ol xruapr^e lo \cq (7) ,auecouq .rlrycE ft) uo pas€q JaIIer IBuorlrpuocun 'rtrolepuBur epraord ol pup Jorrg Jo lF/n roJ luerrrrEdac [.{,ul qunod erfl a^oru '.r[purg >Icrrtrd ur^a) Jo slrqFlxa gtrn:oddns prrE s]!^EpIIp aq1 uod6 ^rou I
6t 8t LI 9t 9t vt et
zt
N\fuoo cnnucar! .rasJo l!^BplgBPIIB
tt sccff g^ttvu,tsrNrr{cv 0t)IUOI./t{f,NdO indosd6 8 L 9
8/17/2019 216654659 Criminal Writ of Errors
3/42
SUOUUfl dO IIUrV\ UOd flCIJON
A(f$f,g XCIU.f,Vd NIAIDI
NOISIAIC g.tVTIgddV
J'TUTSI(I
I , xuol/r,tflN do g,tvJs t z TVIJI(Iff HINSAgS t
8/17/2019 216654659 Criminal Writ of Errors
4/42
09
6t 8tLV
It
9?
tv et ztLT
0,6e 8eLE
9t9e
tt
TE
'eleF e$Jo uorsr tpgrc )o fcue?e fue to e;eF et f fq rc,uo1ytg1su1 to'uopetodtoo
'ung fue fq rc uowed.eqgo fue qqilu tw nq rc sH rcl uoneurutttcr;|p ^q go rue o7 pelgpr[qrc eq'uolflilu to p&rlr'totop'gp,et esnsoeg 'ileqe uos;re,d oN -loolpltll uolslslpqns Aue to eleF srr0 Jo snet eql lo uol}'Fiptd lenbe pe///ep eq oil .rr gilet/F uosred
ze
tt
0t6Z 8Z LZgz,
9Zvz,
tzzz
'ssald eql7olo qceedslo frUeqil eql eflppqelout,easer olpessed egtteqsr.qoupue $qtpl- ,t$loesnge eqtnlerqrsuodsar Fupq gs'spefgns ile uo queurBues Eq
n qq qq|plnd pue €wr.'4eeds [pe4 tfuu ue4ryc ftete,
tz0z 6t
ol palcedxa aq I plnoqs rou ,ursrcBr;so PIIB esnqB slr{l alnpua raEuol ou rruc I 'elqu1unouunsrn flaar1cn-rlsuoc sr slq3F
8t LI 9t 9t
Jraql acro5ra ol ldurelle oqrn slrretqq es ord JoJ uoqerrrunrcsrp a{J .eru st rrqorurm pue paldduc sBtI lBql ecrreseeJuou pup ecuBsreJTeru'ecuesea;s1ruJo urerl
8/17/2019 216654659 Criminal Writ of Errors
5/42
{erneuru ure I .slqt roy fiplfdlEdffi e^Br{ I lng€ Jo urqcra et1t : ,JNSCONNI
IllVnIOVd,
tt ttzt
'eAIoseJ
lt
0t6
fueru
JeAo peJegns eABq
/ll\ou lsnrn gedaq r{Unod arD lgr{l Jellpur lcafqns lrretGndar luasard s-rear( I sasnqe suorsJaarad et;l lero epecuoc I .pa/ho[oJ Jo rr/lloqs
uaaq JeAe seq lcedsal qcns ou 'eta11 'peinoTloJ eJB
I
leql turprzrord slqtF crs€q lmry puorsecco 01 selels ro3 dlrssaceu er{l sepecuoc fperg I I t,'sreed Jegpe.rnces sefe161td
]rltlr eql lJeloJd o1 sueau
at€1arellg
L
rc sftloto
tlueu,Fpnf
eqi rc ,pue1 eql lo lnet eq|,fg sse;un
e
sttt]Fu
to
petpdep n'pes1qcue4s,p eg rreqs atets srt
loareql ue4q Aueot lJo /F,qUN,ilUU oN, T S
z
:-
8/17/2019 216654659 Criminal Writ of Errors
6/42
uIN3rsSv
Nt
oSturAur
,o pes aql pexge pue pueqUnoC rtyg ralsaqcou
.JO3U3HM les opnareq e^eq | SS3N1M Nl'uogsenb ur uogpodslp eql 6u;pre6a.lW!,u
e$ ql!,yr puB suolplpsunl pcolet$
)pe[p eseeld
lo se
agg
s,IrelC fiunog eoluoyl eql le punoJ ueaq seq pr@eJ rtuogq
op n
lo sB eoUO s.IJelC Auno-J eoluoy1 erg le puno, uaoq seq prooa,r 1ap oN I I
JOJ
s psl$ a^eq lou op eM 'sts
lBuB
Ja len puosrusuoo e peu
e Bt{TotIoBm
:6u;ruolgo; etg pug pue
[email protected]@uo{eoUO
s,IrelC rtpnog eotuol l eqlto spr@er e$Jo qcrees
B epetu a^Bq
t1eql
tXI
:Alllu3c A€3U3H OO 'lees uoutruor e 6upeq 'proceu ,o spnoC 6upq qpq 'Unog anradnseU p pue ,Alunog pps rgunog er$ro IJoIC 'olloul6 iltar{C 'lJo UnoC
fiunog e$ro 'eoruoyl
p
(.ralseqcou Jo &!O 'ss (eoruoyg lo Apnog (ryort,v\eN lo e1els
8/17/2019 216654659 Criminal Writ of Errors
7/42
u3HIO
[J
ANOl3lnVN[,ttHC n sr-rns3u H9uv3s
]ruC
[X]
lbIC rQwnC oJloqqlfteqJ,^tr J o,,l
lneN'r(lunoC
eorurl-16[
i)
,{tuno3 eql {o ac,,
(
I
8/17/2019 216654659 Criminal Writ of Errors
8/42
-t-
09
'uteql q atot 4aqt oasratuot ou ue., feq1ptp sasdel p ue|;'ed e ol peuroFn xre os eur@eg sreuorssqrord p?et p firyunuuo e ueqr- sryr]sa, erlpnfut heulptg.;sellJ/rl qceg lutylau:oueJalsaqcou',yno7sptoH HueuvluoH,\ooqJaq ul
6t 8tL?
9'€tzv
9t
t,
' 'flunoC eoruoltJ ro/pue >IroI .dleN Jo elels arn fq lqtnoql puoces B lnoqlr,rl(puel dur pue elu 01 secuanbasuoc elqBruoroBJun r{lr/Y\ suorsraarad snonlNvNl'I /noqs sesrc z(ur leql tutsodap nre 1 'd1uam1 [OZl ro eeJr{l ro o/yq ro /YrBI pue ernpecordgo uolsra,uad [1] auo lou sr ]I 'uno3 snn aroJaq /!rou sprocar erp wpelueurncop erp suoseeJ eqJ
0t6e 88LE
It
9€
90
++++++eot#o wot, atotaet rc ecpcetd utotl puedsns'aJnsu(x, ol pe4nqpe q 7luletlllyedep qcee q Un(n ourardns eql p uo.s1 tp elelpdde eql pue 'r.et ecpceil of Fur
uasse rc Futcncetd suosted pe pue r,e|tRd.roresun(n pue sfeutolpie tuo f.rercrpnp ol luensJru
ruuoo pue rcnod eteq ileqsyn@ etzandns a{l, 06'casCOgNgddVH SIHI SVH /T\OH
weeZETE
"nB-[
0t
'ler{t qsllqelse o} secuar:edxa
fu
puofaq
6Z8Z LZ 9Z 9Z
8/17/2019 216654659 Criminal Writ of Errors
9/42
{oo[ ot peeu ION SgOC auo 'szrfBar a1doa4 er{l uer{t eroru qcnru qcleg p4q1 egfEugqrrreser luaruureaot o1rn qcrrerq p{nn qecrraruv paurroJsue4 ser{ 9.I e1nIMV
?z acJoJue
'uoltrrlrossy JDg tmcyinav eW ot lnq slqtlJ Jrarlt
tzzz
tz0z
ol uJnl ol eJer?h ou flelnlosqe eltq srazfrnul-uou 'srsfleue 1eug erT| u1 ',ae1ue-rent, pps fJerre uelueJrp prre sr1leo Jrer{l oleq eJeq u.{vior{s suoqrnrJdap aql 'ruerp aes daql uaqm tuet{l eatdocar uele luop ueuo r(aq1 '.a1doed er{t ol pealuerer€ slq8p prre sr Eunrl B JoJ /nrl Ewcrlcerd uosrad zc.raaa lBr{l ssalpretegsmul r(eqo ol r{lBo
fq punoq
'.a1doa4
erp'o/l\,
6t 8t LI 9t 9t iL
tt6 8 L
zt
It
Jo slsaJalu lseq eql uT lou rarnod uElsro;.{rreu aruos o1 ecueGege pa8pald flraelc eABr{ sJeculo unoc palsn4ua puB elq€rouoH '/nB-I Jo selnu rer{lo pue sF{} pJuop
rrBqE eABq sunoc sBcIJeruV legl uoBctluoc o/oOgl r{lur\ tsepe 1 'luetun as ord B sB secuaFedxa e^Rcrlllsep f1e1llrr.pn pu€ lBuosrad'aso1c dnSo sapEcep [zl ornl flreau:auv9 u I P u elsqa /ttrlo u A/, etluoa, ,t(qa/F,ql punaq ogneqs ele|s
0t
I I ,
E
fuats ut s€Frpnf pue lpue1 eql/o r.el e,aatdns oH eg llerls ++ +{,F+ !oorcq|aouens;lnd ut epew eg ,re{s qcqil selets acipun eqt p e}te7 €tn pue 'uo;pggsuog s1r4 .tq
go4uor IIps sr lueurpuelllv r{lueagnog/asnu13 fceurardns 's'n aql Jerfeq puE uoBBurroJul uodn4
z
,t'
8/17/2019 216654659 Criminal Writ of Errors
10/42
't-
09
6t 8tL?
'fieuoqlpuocun pue dlalulpatrrun slr{Elr ;uilc fur erolser pue dpadord l(ru tuuaqurncua sluau€pnl CIO^ z(geuogclpslrnf aerql a]Bcpl'sEurpug sll uI uraql elpls ,slcu3rasarn pq] lsnru unoc srqJ[gJ
It
'flanqcegoc pe/narlal eq lsruu faql ,leq] qsllqBlsa oJ 'sunoc q>IroA /reN uo ,es oJd ,turflec JoJ uoBcrrBs sE oJ pelcefqns uooqe^Bq I
9' w
flrpq4unorcvJo slsFc eql a^eal s8urpaacord aleredas fl8rmueas eglJo [[v
et zt
It
0? 6e8S
'9'I eInU V€tVJo esrntslp rapun sJorJnu pue e>1otus ol qunccns lou lsruu ,$l$afulIBIcIpn[pue qfruJ 'erer{ enssr tB sr ler#$ pal€csrgqo f;uo e^Er{ qCW ar41'aler{l pue lsnru prre lueuqJBde6 aql qlrrn tre8aq asnqe [Buo4nlqsuoc
LT
90 90
wgg
ztte
prre tracep aql '9'I elnd V€IV dq lclguoc w retilrry epeur JSSUSINI.{O ICI.ISNOC elqPlunoulrnsur 'lea1c sr dcecoapu IBuLrou sB eru o1 pereadde ls4l lBrlt\ .e14S ^lou aql roJ sdetrrollu st pelorrreJ eq Jo luerrrgedaq /prauag sfaurol]V erp lsenbar 1^rB'I
0t
6Z 8ZLZ,
'ap€cep
r roJ ps
llqourun pur
st
8/17/2019 216654659 Criminal Writ of Errors
11/42
pan8eld sEtI lBtn uo 'f11rg3tmreetu preaq eq 01 pue lttl@fmiog- tuunoqs lueplgns epBru e^BrI I lsn4 I 'eur 01elq€lrB^r gps iflqrsuelso sr ]Bq] unoc els]s rcpo arp pJBtlcRI atpnp;o JVId dq ern uo pasodnn suoqgrurq ororu ol Euring
ffi'rettrmoq
9Z 9Z
I
tzez,
'r(l8tnnroccp
unoC sF{f puv ,sanlaslaatlTtof yoads sprurar a4tr .alelncnru ol dfmqe fur puofeq
lcr ISnn
zz
tz0z
lppuecs B sI tI 'sseussel/ne1 l(lenlpnf peupqserun ruo-g JeTler urErlqo ol flIIqBuI l(ur l(q pesn€c saFnlur eql roJ .arec luprp pue .en1c B eABr{ lou pIp rfFealcspnoc dyrl'sp'uewpuel/Jv
6t 8t LI 9t 9t
tttl
qw€'€unot puBlsrrJ al|lJo uone/ot Haq q 'otr;y'sr(auloBelueurureao? woU sre/lrsue fuplnDe't vtoqun'sflutp,ee4 e^rtr€l ,pflqlwegso pueute ol fuuryroddo lnoqgn,gll1rou
vroqtti*t 'aluods
et
ensfipnuassa@
zt0t6 8 L
'p4eup/Efl
uq
seq
uotrie/tujffiF>]o^ut
'uo1}c1psyn[
peq t qcrufii uo ilqEiFF?EE qcnw os pe}eclpnfpe te a SBUIUnol.? ON.psF,l/Uercn?eq ot c€.Feile /F/Ae q qqq,'- ygp fue fuptolue u, popeeq?ns U:lngrr, e^eq , ,tuole
8/17/2019 216654659 Criminal Writ of Errors
12/42
pueut eq ol aro{ uflioqs pilet u|f/lqo ol qrno., o3 suopged snouou/F,lJ/ fi1epe1ssafluno{, egdseg
I I , t
ltuvnnns
j-
z
8/17/2019 216654659 Criminal Writ of Errors
13/42
09
6t
gWbI
e90z t8e 989>IroA meN
'ralsaqco lseg
8' L'9t 9t
eup-I lsnsozl gos I.CVUS XStUJVdNtAgX
w
I
et z, 0t6e8S LE
t,
vTgtT 11i1 'ralsaqcou 3c[snf Jo l]vH ru.Nnoc 30uo1tl ojloNto lNtcNtA'tzN3u x3'lv'Nvuoo eHuc sSeonf iTgVl lp 'relsaqcou lao4s ulew '/n 6e tn\n lo lNSwluvdto lrNnoc 3ouNotl
,Tgw 1p'telsaqcou p^8 e'ueqcx3 ttT,v\\n Jo lN31[uvd30 yuo i 3N
90 98
uapl sassorppr eW le sarlred 8uuno11o; aql ol paxarrrre sraded arp Bugpn Errrqlfta,ra;o serdoc alalduroc prre anq paprnord 1
te etZE
uo
It
0e 6Z8Z
anp eJB sJ3/nsuv'
-4'gi
uo unoc aql ol elqBurnleJ eprtu sr JauEur
snll
LZ9Z 9Z
.fitep
8/17/2019 216654659 Criminal Writ of Errors
14/42
sqltot@
tz tzzz
lz0z
' tue4uorr st,l ot uoBeBq|le tuese afluerlp,qc t puy Wtil s^tt lsrru, ONll oey,agns a eq t sesngB a^eq t,lce! q.pooq41retl4, uno rfia p6,6otl5B1p rc qtlflt rBuoflnlpsuoc uno tru 0pile/rc,tl'gesfiu rF/leuntettq pue palncesord tgplfuot/v. 'sne1 fue uerlary {u eteq I 'urcruu uoqltiyt fie1e1ducp rc/pue,sno;3exaa 'sno1otp11o fue ul uonae fue pelg fitueu slleq L
,ilet
eql ol oso, 'tqie,{/lcn/4suu,
to'fi1efq
'Flqlynor,
esodap I trcBJ uI
6t 8t LI 9t 9t
ttZL
er
ll
''llraur lnoqlT/s flalaldnroc rc/pue Surssunaq'Eurssu:leqrza'sno1o^l{ eq ol papuelq sr aleq paSege turq1o1,1 .an-r; eq ol sJeDrrrr esoql olerleq I pug TeTIaq pug uorleurroJul uo pe8age sJelleru:oy ldecxa Fgrilnrl prre tcerroc sr uleraq perrretuoc tqqttraaa trEtn t€ql asodap t.q3SnOV lg
'apvrord ol peullsrn sr unoc alqBrouor{ srlllJerleJ Jer{lo 1e lsanbar t puv
OL
I I
6 8 L
ve
'peJepual Je^au eJef\ lErfl secLues ptal ro3 i(pearJe lueds e^Bq I 0OO,g$ prre uonce sFIt JoJ zf.ressecau Jr slsoc lsanber 1
z
t-
8/17/2019 216654659 Criminal Writ of Errors
15/42
-9-
09
''
6t
'llJarrr Jo acuno uB lnorDull\ eru o1
eq
paueddet{ let}r sI leqJ rqtlr rlegl Jo pauofue pue .luerussererl Te8at Jo posncce eq pFoc daq.1. 'IBussJe pE ool aruoceq ool rualsz(s [BLrEsJaApe Jno /hol[" lou ol pauo4nec es ord 'ae-6e lqnop ou llllyr unoc sF;l sv
lsnu
sanred Eulns uo lslsw oqm
sluetp[
It L' It 9? ,t
E'
zt'ly anord saFrnfur
tuualp et;l a^Eq I pue acuapradxa
tf
0?6e 8eLE
Jualsrsuoc fru uaaq sBq srr{J'p.rBeq 1ou'gnoc ur uees eq o} palcedxa are daq;'f1ddu tou peeu daql 'srar0nel tou eJp sluetnS as ord 'tr{t1J ler{l popJoJJE arB sunoc eq} Jo sracllJo pelsrulua fluo 'dyed e sy luanrrrranot eJeq/h lErIl rBalc s!lI'acJoIua o7 ft1ypqo s.auo w poo6 sa ITNO s7 ft1apos Wu! mq teqt uoqcrluoc o/o1gl rp&t\ lsege ol elqe rrrP J sunoc lerepal pup e14s aldnpur ur 1netnl as ord ese srBaf [oz] druaror ratJv
tt
9e 9g ve
ze
te08 6Z
"600Z 966I uee,nrleq seuqt [Al rq81e flpnuessa 'selrrr I puu 'uec aq /rotDl I /r\oN 'ssel ou Unoc fptueg'pnoc q slsa.relul tllno sn{ luasardar o1 Surlduraflr- ro! pelncasord rflJetrrunrc eq ppoc rreru B let;l enIJ e e €q l.uPlp t ]OOJ a sBtrUnoo: q pesurry sluesardar oqr ueaa E ler{t prcs uego os se/}l fqm ue^e t uprp I w uorlclpspnf gnoc fpurey ol lcafqns aureceq I lpun ^rorDl1r
8/17/2019 216654659 Criminal Writ of Errors
16/42
'66I
8Z LZ 9Z
9Z
'luaururelot
tzcz27,
tz0z
sr elqBlunoccEun PUB ssePlceJ moq puB sE/rl I e^Isu moq pellrcel ecurs aABq I 'Tnaql roJ e^Pcalord prre eleuorssed s€/n J 'tuqelop rrro4 pallqlqord sern luaunrranofl leql flsrcos yo slqtu ulPuec psq I pe^arlaq ecuo tuureH ''g6I acurs /(1uno3eoJuolt pue Z96l ecurs >IJoA /heN Jo lueprsal .uecl'3111y uroq lgrnlgu E sI JeuoBqad
6l
[IAV(II.{.{V
8t LI 9t 9t
Ntruoc crHuJ gcqff gAIIvu.tsINIn[(rH )tUO /nf,NdogfdogdgH.tSOUUT dO IrUrV\UOd
tl tt zt tl0t6 8 L 9
AOlrUg XJTU.LVd NIATDI
I
v
t
NOISIAIO fl,IVTItrddV
xuol/r,tflN.{o IIJVIS J'IU.ISIO TVICI(Iff HINSASS
z
:'
8/17/2019 216654659 Criminal Writ of Errors
17/42
-L-
09
COAZ'
6t
tOOe fuenuef'sunoC ulopol l Jol punJ eql s g66t '61 Ieyl 'uo1u1'1 seqg lueqp .uriolag pnog luadurg LuoO r .sunoC aql puonl ,Z fteruqe3 'sau;1 UoA Lusaoq lueqy Iqiq , ^^aN aunr 'souilf lro^ eN ,sunoc aql lneqla^o ol ourlt lllls z
966l
'zl
8'L? 9?9V
^
we?
pue sue4uc
awun
s ;qqflp qaql Aunstnd wot!,sasseu;sng woq 'quearyt se,€d,|///- pue #en@slp pu" Fupntuoc .Att$p @1,
zv
0t6e 8eLT
t,
"fulip,es sseursng /€'uofl?/ tlue ul snor go pue |f,tneu eq pno,' lF/qlfe''- e u,sE s3o Futaeueu figualcgp urdJ urels(s tero4plnl eW q;nqotd spnoo no lo elrnleuTueufe4 eqy
9g
9e
, ;suonclpq/f',flo ercl///lnlalu e, I..f4und,/pue
ft
ul
ualsfsynoo snonqpl,
"rysusdr(€,payrpsuoptsou,
ot
8/17/2019 216654659 Criminal Writ of Errors
18/42
l
sB
paufwt
fieryr,',
0c ze
te0e 6Z 8ZLZ
.'quqfgl
ile
q
eqcepeeq pue uneq sasnaeprfl uralgfs ple$ea }ualo4[eq uV,
c.'uoneu eqlq utale(syno
rc11eolldwuttsou, eqg .ssarz e arc s1rnGr FnOL
gz9Z
,z t7zz
'sldrecxe are Euuro[oJ ew 'poder naql panssr uorssnuruoc reqtueru [ogl d}r.n{l arp 'LOOZ f.ren:qag uI 'suLIoJeJ asodord pue a.rnlcnqs unoJ qeluls eqtJo sseue4qcega er{l ssessB ol uorssnEruo3 prcadg e peltnodde etrqr rnlpnf eipnjlelqc gooz .d1np u1
tz0z
sovHc TvNorJ'cr(Isfum
6t 8t LI 9t 9t
,t
ssaltwueaur erB slt{tlr l4uerrrupurg 'urar$ Jod 'lrrB^alern sr /nBI eql ,turssererl ro/ puB .snoIoAI+ petsqBl esorrl ro; 'spaddy Jo unoc 1r1 Etrypqcur ,asptrrar{}o prcs e^Bq sunoc reqtF{ qtnoqlp puv'unor ol ssecce z(ur uado pue paznfocer aq
1pm suonnad aJnlru eJoJeq uorsstulred
sgnoc eql rrtulqo lsnru I IBIO acrns ra,re patage ueeq sgq lI il6 8 L
0t zt
0tsE/n I 'scuBlerJt roJ lustrnuanot
8/17/2019 216654659 Criminal Writ of Errors
19/42
' lueunlrelot uoqrlad ol fqtlJ fruyo paurofua fpuauenrrad du pauogged z(lgylel ecuo Euureq ro3 .dpuanbesuo3
I I0
I'I'OtI UdC.f,N ZZ repun 3ur uoBcr,rBs ol uoBolu uo papeeccns sl(arrro11e lueurrrreaot tursoddo,{ur ilueursserpq pta13o eur pasncce rela s€q rJ}IVd.IVgu oN r{tnot{rlv .suoqBlol^
v z
'ate1s lurelduroc aqg lsed 1ot renau uoqce ar{J stqglr pluared pue II Ic ueAoro;sr@bunocaruardnspuefprrre3enso}pa1edurocsB/nI.s66IuI
:
8/17/2019 216654659 Criminal Writ of Errors
20/42
-8-
g00z 'ge requeldes
'seul!l-IJoA
^
aN 'uosJoqelc uellllM'JoJl:l pue leullo xtn e qltl aollsnf ul^ol lleus
6upen11eq
,
09
6t
.
ItLOOZ s4qpp
8? L?
9?
fuenuel
'$!$nf g i el rc! /eluaC-
et
w
zv
,'tellaq op ueo eil fiatng'aentes tou q acinsnf pue pquotduoo erc ,que?Hl +++ 5ltoAilaN q /nou qqxl rzals{synafuyapunlq,q1oeqc tno sy.,
L' 0t6e 8eLC
,
9e
9t t0 tezt,
Grcfl uo4etcossv reg atets aW p 'oN ilun uoncy .'ue;s(s3uaunc eqllprpun utnn! al?uts e q peuosat eq louue., 'etn}eu f,rar qt fiq'qctqnfsrarrorluoo a peluasard se{ eq esnecag rc ltnoTuatn el,| peparas fiolncesotd pue e?pnn asneoeg e/f/ileu puollqpqtnl eJo seiruenDesuoc esra pB +++ rqgns pnoqs alefsqn u, [shue?m Rlnuoseu ou f,1dw1s s, ereut-pe$nd
te
0t
8/17/2019 216654659 Criminal Writ of Errors
21/42
67,
-;Ucuq
gg6t 'eZ '1o,O'seu44 tr11 ,utoleg UnoJ .sa sefpny dJl eql Uo pue uo sueplglod ot sa^rFt, an6reslepads €ql frq op41rnf Iq fulpue1srepunNvwnHsegep
eq louueo e^ras ol pasoddns g t, esot;1
prp uegsfs y,
8Z LZ 9Z
9Zv7,
t{!us s ctvrlaw uno Jorsa?
lHr
EZ
zz
tz0zJO Ser"? qa^^/€qt(0,ue auo
',saopsnf unol rreurs lueladuroouf esnurB oqns/,efrttet li/ior! sefa aq1,,10 rat epFsynoc eseur_
'au4 e fied Touun fet13 esnaceg tpl ut s1tee,il ot paluelues lo 'srafne, posqe,Futpeepr,td rcdofi e voqur.sirurou 4eqt uaq pessof rc lepl e n eap fi11nf e irnoqpn ilel qtuos ua€rg ercq qdoa4,
6t 8t LI 9t 9t vt 8t
zttL
0t6 8 L 9
'rilo[/r'.au E^o Ip fe/nocJ enil, osan ul uaddeq 9l'luut snopasylg .slrnq2 srl.snf pqnfulnourl lo esuegardepilt seteu, ++ uoltarlstut,upy UnoC,eqltr4 sueddeq
e .'sapeTpr pue s-unol (nO,T ueql ercu q er4uns leql as treiqottJ etn lo sapepq
eset1; q uowwut fiqalyewu sl saldpultd p?q ersBg qgn fye111utelun uV,
I , t
sluna?
z
levllr[ ouv Nlnot gruo
8/17/2019 216654659 Criminal Writ of Errors
22/42
tt#JN
t-
8/17/2019 216654659 Criminal Writ of Errors
23/42
-6-
'{curtdsuoc srrn
u1
paledlcrlred seq
0s
lsl
EuunogoJ et1l uo pelJguepr l(ged f.raaa ,dlrcudec eruos Ln .eurq eruos lB
lBrll SJON
glt'SIt pZ'q'V I a1doa4 1LIT p1g g99 ,ecrpon set€ts ^ '6'gory pelFn :O6e p6'A'gr11g 'raurvl7 a1doa4 lZtA pZ'X.N gS ,{e1geg n aldoag gb1 pZ qV ^ LgI :9L9 pZSAN g6S (S66I) ew(e4 selrer{C n e1doa4 efrlop.tadttt4prm fiipf druelrry
It L? It It w ttz?L?
6t
0t68 8eLC
tuqaduo 1ntasatd a, $q ntolgcyua D uqno q, fi1atau tou s! uopt { sttl, /Sg Sn g2g 'puoyfuoy1 n fipang) ,,tgof ato slzilu4 luuttttlrc ptn axrs a, $q pall,ol4tocan fr47tr6 tttluanlm fr1uo gou,, 'bgg p6'1,'N L 'saplnnas n aydoafl ugrr4 aqltlr1rt" a, srlnourl aV pqil rcirr"tm, c, frt tp., art4osqo s.l.ot E ttll st ltpm aspfaq
"satd
9t
9t
tt
Cpuslsrepun 1 uop leuorsseJord Je8a1 r(1uno3 eorrrol1l ler{t seqr6qesrp uoqcrAuoc ptal asnqe lellolncesord pue 'dcerrdsuoc'asnqe es ord lnoqe lI sl lerlrtrr 'leeddu as ord Aggng uo pesrtr era^r pue luareddu flppug aru slcaJap egl sB r€Josul
ee
ztt80e
Jotrnt''/ptaw7', clnmrabpan ql epwt "g ql $mn \uop 'p,ut1stapuln *uop s7.t toc /l4rutttC anuoyg fo ungffo ?ttn 4lnlals frq pqycsud uolqclpsTtnf nlptm ssacord/oasnqD at enp uorgp|lpsltn/.po fo ssol ,l?D, ,rtoqD t, q lmlm,3uo11clps7tnf ta11mu *cenna Jo uo1gr4ry
8/17/2019 216654659 Criminal Writ of Errors
24/42
*tnf
lmtostarl
fo
6Z 8Z LZ 9Z 9Z
vz
sNorussno snonso,;foanaq| uoFqFruroc s,ltmlruafap ptm antatfo tlctts fo fiiaoe uppp 'rualtualtat gDuosTral o puo@ 6u1r1s71qvlsa puD lua'F,f/ns fi7o64 sl urnlm ixrue,',l'l'€ l'','!q. aodn p"soq ssalua pnna 4 1r9tp'ter, frq asuatfo tm to uopytum, oN,, OZ.OL,IdC ees 'pa4nbar;oordyo sprepuels eql sleeur ]eql procar IEI4 lfue ut gCNqCIng ON sr erat{l 'suorlrrauoc z(ru alldsaq 'IBIrr ol papaacord pue rrraql
EZ
zz
tzoz
6t 8t LI 9t 9t
,l
8t
zt0t6
parotfr [s]rolncasord pue [s]gnoc aql'luannfrerre,craaa ]B s]caJap [g]eJ eql pauasse I qEnoqrv 'uoqctpslrnf rnotrrlm anr lstrrete z(purmool palcg Jolncasord mGm prrE Unoc IeI4 EIiIEi'r(puanbasuoC 'spnoc {roA meN uI alqezn€oc asuello ro eurrrc
€ alBls ol luelcglnsut fgercej se/t\ lueruulsulfuolesncce;E!ilmi rnarer,{ un1or{s sV
tl
IL 9
I ,g
'raupeJeril srBaf JoJ sJaclgo uoqeqoJd ol podar ol peJepJo pue ,paluracJucrn ,paug 'salrnf peulroJul-m rnq tucsnrl dq palcyruoc 'slrnoc drp pue ur\ol z(1uno3 ao
ruor l w setml [g] {s p3}ncasord fgeuruFc uaoq e^ErI I 'S66I uI pezlcerso trnaqecqs
z
t-
8/17/2019 216654659 Criminal Writ of Errors
25/42
e6pnp
e6pnp uerog O;erg e6pnf ooreryaq "l uqof
ou1uelen qdesop
u*ffiF'sf,unocffido scorugd orw sNorrvuacrrvct{'sgnrd 'sxou.ftnuoc rvNrrttuc twnO l€l ggutrt sNoIJtIA toorvNrruuc [nI r*glmfl
gsdee1ereg puogppy
V(1y redneeylergoeg e6pn1 oIoNlC lu@uln
peddynlseqcou lssgleq011eg)puted o6erg fipy tspopg
VOV VOV e6pnpa6pnl
rqs€lpoulsB3lzueu xolv
lloos'f
repeJ'3 ua^als)ppen uen p!^eq,eppncs Irueg 'rp go6;6 eua6n3
e4nbs3 arqnbs3seEpnlelqpddvseBpnp qel1addv se6pnl alelpddv se6pnl slelpddv
etetpddry
qlepsren vov men ppuv peptn eOpnf
n]llo uoruuede6pnp
srapd ) ueJE)l -rf euolell 'f pletxe€arncJanl'3 setroqleuopleC Iuorguy
qqpddrt
vov
peddygeaWoUAndaO
orolJ lclAed lzuau xelv
se6pnp etetteddV se6pnp etelpddV sa6pnp etqpddv
ulds'O
prer$p3
firel 1otuauryede6
8/17/2019 216654659 Criminal Writ of Errors
26/42
^Aq pluau4redeq ruel,r\e'l Jo tueunredaC
p
rcen $apuen
rertnrl Cn e6pnf
Ueu.qJedeq
nel pguaupedeq mq Jotuaurueda€,nelplueu4redegrl Bl lo tuau.Uedeg
!ue!4sen sn uell Ipe4 ryer3 lsnueo uoruo ufuen erqocl
vov
unog
'Jt ppeueg uqor qrods uey uosuqofesolel elttps unoH rqseqcou
lu"
Iesueg seuroqluoloc u€qoH en6;rpog sopeC
e6pnJ.atqpddV zuemrps'Murlol pe*fiy uquped pu@ege6pnp
vcv etelpddv
saBpnp saOpnp
etqpddV
lueq$ilruc uev qren eppled |eeddt noluuedu,$oqunreqre1
epleddv
arln9cyl'lI seuer ue lllns'4 qdaeop axes'€ p!^eo urollaled,{ql;cng
VOV aOpnp VOV
{eup5
se6pnp elelpddv se6pnp elelgeddy sedpnp etelleddvaOpnp
'I
unoc unol ppguedltepueu selOnoq
urlol.
8/17/2019 216654659 Criminal Writ of Errors
27/42
ou1uelen qdesop
eFpnp a6pnp
e6pnla6pnp e6pn1
uaog 6lerg oappBl auen uuv @relleo "l uqor zuem$cs'u uqor eu!ilec's porJ esls'3prEqclu
VOV &o6arg selOnog vov ell!^ugr9|lerg e0pn1 )pluoDl sauoql
unoc nruol uquuodoualJ )pned lzuag xelvtetptyll ueqou
aOpnl eOpnla6pnpaBpnp
vov e6pnl
a6pn1
'J
Irv'r uqof euq uqof rauery lregsuelll!/rtiA'g
peddry protsnrd
a6pn1 e6pnpeDpnp
uDpls'u ue els
luelj
a6pnr
puop,{.4gue1 n seurorll plsloc'c euojaf
e6pnp torptll ueqoH'J le llsmarpuv ratpvluoeN unoc umol prqsu
vcw vov
sNo[nc3soud'llnlc
sNoEncSsoud lvNrnruc
8/17/2019 216654659 Criminal Writ of Errors
28/42
-0t-
'8IOZ lsn8nv
qJo
uollBCI 'X ecuer/hB-I >Felc elElleddB prrB
retllrfioc .u?roq
09
6t
8'
r(q ecr}snfJo uonctrrlsqo .eJeJ-rnoz(-rr( Jergoue pacuauedxa I uer+rr peqsruel sJecgo prrB rouoq lnoqE passardxa e^?q I slqnop IIB prrs f,reag
unor pelsn4ue
&lselq
It It
L?
'ASOJVCINVIn1 ueaq
s€g sI lI ueqr$ NgAg }a5ar
we,
z,
t,
roJ peuorlned UgAg a^Bq I Unoc IUgAg dq perorf1 pue peteeqc uaeq l arruq fq6 C/nBI lEuonnlpsuoJ z(q palcalord fqtlJ lueUodu.r tsoru erI]Jo szrcJecxe ro; flrenod o1 rn ueAIJp pue uolluJecJucrrr 'uorlncesord'uoqeururuosrp snorc1feru JoJ pela8rq ueeq
0v
aneq
l(16 Cstqtlr Puonnlnsuoc
Jo IBIuap pue lcadsarslp qcns paralunocua aaeq zfr1q1
6t8eLT,
9t909€
8/17/2019 216654659 Criminal Writ of Errors
29/42
etze
'atentuel qsypug aq1 ut 'raded elTtld\ uo {uI >IcBIqyo {em fq palepunue z(1rea1c saleprrerrr leuopqllsuoc aJB erer{J'uleql ppa.t ue^a eABr[ lou pFoc rrpJoo lBrTl saqsqQs]sa 1I .uorsBcco Aug^g uo 'pernacat e^€q I s^leraer e1e11addu pJepu4sqnseql sagqdruaxa uorur.do pege,rred srq lBql lnuqns I '.snoIoArJI., Eetil punoJ prrE sesB3 lBrnuruc eql q palJ.rluapr sroua er{lroJ sJauq es ord eql IIB pe..trernsJ e^Bq ol srurelc rrBJoCJ 6TOC'Z',roN pelep uorurdo rfg
tg0e6Z 8Z LZ 9Z 9Z
'auot l(laartct,trlsuoc sr tue8rrll pessarddo snnJo lq?TII aql Lrlun salnber uonenlls luerlnc aql JeAelBq/$ 1g o1 'tuueaq lnoqllll\ .eJqou lnoqlpr ,JVId fq .rapro ErrSg-ard 3t{lJo suoqculsar etT} paPuE dxe flpaleadar seq lBql op ol peIrBJ urro(I seq fluo 1o11[ra1so13 go qtnorog aas palrlncrus lseq ueeq seq arnpacord Etryg el€rrlalls aq'1,'ulroqs sr 1r uarlr\ lFeru IBIoBJ rrr{luoc o1 lwroFad o1 alor auo dluo
tz tzzz
tz0z
sa{ rrBJoq ir\oleq ssecce eer; dur ro;.radaa1a1ut, sy .etpnp alr1e4snmrrpv sB rrBJocI A fperg papnue sr unoC sFn ol padde {oo1 I snernar alugadde prepuelsqns ar$ EuoruyNI/rIOA EIV?IC TSQNT TI'f,VUONOII
6t 8t LI 9t 9tTL
flIIJ
8t
zt
tr
'speddyyo UnoC pup suors1alq ale[addy 4rol rnap fq parelcep saseo Eurlo4uoc 'luapecard ruory paltc ant lsont 'suorurdo es ord r(ur 1ou eJB eserTl lern atoN
0t6 8 L
I I
ve
'silnoc arilJo sracrJo pelsrrrlua pue elqBJouoq fu fq are luaserd daqg [slaurucfpo aql 'seutlfrqesrp rargo ptru saFnlul tu.uarp agq dnr alenladrad o] sprocer cgqnd uo urBtuer faql lad puy 'pe4nbeJ pJeptrels aql o1 uaaord aq pFoc ro pe8ageerarn seltruo ou esnBceq suorlcrluoc [eumrtrc W eJar{l lerll flanrsnlcuoJ /$oqsdarlJ 'sunoc pue uao] [sl e^g ruo{ erB /yrolloJ lBrn sJelrq lBnpr rpw eqJ
8/17/2019 216654659 Criminal Writ of Errors
30/42
,(r1c
z
l-
8/17/2019 216654659 Criminal Writ of Errors
31/42
',8rnpue1saa4;,sB qcns suoBecllllenb o1 1cafqns 1ou 'pup1 IBoJ eq] se,t\.acuecouur IBn1cB, dIAl09
6?LV
8''uor1pumr.ratep lcaxoc'flr,gqecgddeulJoJ alnlBls eql pa8ual1eqc oq/h slrrupuaJep Suoure ecrrera:llTp erp pel€rcunue
9?
It tt
E'
z,LT
[g; ered Eur]uassrp) 'a'C ,SVp1ONV .sselatpa^aN -u/horD[ uoqcur]srp ]Bq] e{pru o1 dlaq tou plp fpreuec ItOOZ/et/69 'arq'ddy'A'N) IOtg 'op .operpenC .^ a1doa4 uopldo rQpofeu aq; 't11rr8 penmrpB,(peerJe peq oq/n asorft dq palroldxa Sqequ1
aleilr lerTl saloqdool eJnc 01 sB.{rl
ot}'Idc
pueurB o} sJa>[Brrr /nel elBls ro3 dlrssecau eqJ
0?6e 8eLE
as ord et{l JeAo turporuraals 'ecrre^pe uI sFn
'uorldacxe et1l tou pue alru aql sI fuBtpII fgereuat srafiuel eg} 61NV srefrnel^rorDl
9e
9t vt €tze
eqt ot salsrelo4uoc acsaynbce fldnns setpnl '{e^\ z(ue u.r pelTparc ueeq UgAgN al€q sasueJep es ord fur leql flaalsnlcuoc ,lor{s spJocal aq; 'Unoc z(ue ur atreqcfue o1fifTfBSfldideusrul 'atuageqc rassal e ol Er4puald ro &IIntsgrl trrepueJep es ord
0t
tt
6Z82,
tqpeald [1] raqlta l(q uopcypslrnf o1 pecsarnbce a^pq tsnur trrBpueJep et1t lrre^eler aq plnoc elnlels .pepuaurc dymarr, aJoJeg 'lu€^alarn eJe sJEq lernpecord uoRcrpslJn['IdC lJnoJ B uaq/n uorurdo {aq] ol f,rerluo3 'pexeurru ere slueurnEre pu
8/17/2019 216654659 Criminal Writ of Errors
32/42
.6lJo at11s>IcB[
LZ9Z
9Z
tzEZ
zzLZ
'asBO et{l ssarppB z(lqtsuodseJ ]ou pFoln [orrarg] ro]ncasoJd pue 1.rnoc ar{l Jolocsuo o1 dluo uoqnJesord rerfrea agl Jo sJorra etn }uo{uoc ol unoc pJoJsllld aql peuoqFed I 'ere^l se8regc HJ.OS alqecgdduu.r pue sselrlcer rnor{ pezrrear I unoC fl13 ralsar{rol{ u-r patncasord ptre lzoozl ot'obz 'Id rDr,r tr.re8e pa8reqcsg/n I ueqrt\
0z6t.
'luuleleJ peJeprsuoc ruoples erp sra,Onal_uoN
.z(Bmr(ua
srecso Unoc l(q pear tuoples are s:aded as ord esneceq dlqrsuelso mel fq pennber
8r LI 9t 9t
st peAlosar ro patpal/nolx{J€ Je^eu sBlu, JOAsAloq eEuageqc etIJ '{JoA /!\eN uI gnoc /(ue uo uoqcrpslrnl[Btrrrrruc ro/pue atnlpls puad B e>tolrn ,tlpynq plnoc ,trolesnccu aq1 epnlouoc plnoiyr reuonqc€rd pEel duu leql raprsuoc ol Eudladnls lI pq} t l(ep s1q1 og
,t t!
ll0t. 6
zt
I I I
L
'uoncllslrnf sgnoc fptuey dlaarsnlcxa aq plnoln 1nq 'ronuqeq lermrruc Jo Ia el atll oJ asrr lou pIp,tal{l'anr1 aram suoqe8elle aqljr uela (t)feql tnuqns 1 .luanrutrsrrg le satuageqo lsuoqcpsFnf d.r4ueuale apBru oslB pBr{ I 'unoc u/!\oJ proJsltld uI pesrBJ I esuaJap er{l Jo s}Lreru eql peruJutrroc }ueuruedaq puoces aq}
bloz,f.renuep u1SCNSCONNI 'IVNJCV
v0
l*
z
8/17/2019 216654659 Criminal Writ of Errors
33/42
8/17/2019 216654659 Criminal Writ of Errors
34/42
09
6? 8?
Itbt0?0€/01serFbclut
LV
9?
w
etuoFquu€&IpeHmc,
r5
SOuNon
zt
tv ot 6t8eLE
,$eNpetlgi{flctdlqoil,il09090010#.fiNOOO.ilt{or
98 9g
7%
,t,
ee
,/t"y/ t//rIutet$ elou 'cNV
ze
te0e6Z82,
lueu lnoqrm Iplalduroc.ro/pue Dutssaeq
s! alaq pe6a11e Outqlou leql esodep Jaqury | 'arul sq ot sleueu esoql e^erleq pue ,lerleq pue uoleuuolu! I uo pa6elle s.raIeu ro; ldecxe Inlqn{ pue pelroc s! uteratl peuleluoo $ulqU$ene leql esodap lqererl I
'rapeu slql u! pe$lurqns U^epUfB lsrg eql ut papnput sen elngeuOls pezpelou 'Ougssarequra ,sno;ong4 eq ol papualur
LZ 9Z 9Z
8/17/2019 216654659 Criminal Writ of Errors
35/42
tzcz zz
tzoz
gVWt. AN 'ralsoqcoH lse3 auel lsftro'l g0g ,berg F$ed u!^ay
6t 8t LI 9t 9t et
ttTT
zt0t6 8 L 9
I
t
v
z
t._
8/17/2019 216654659 Criminal Writ of Errors
36/42
0s
'dlpuopSpuocun ,pelecerr aq lsntu pue prol flpuoqcrpslJnf surerueJ luauqsrund dlerra 'uorlcvruoc zirarra ,rne11o Jellgru B sV .uopsluasa:dar JIes Jo lqEFr srq pesrcJexa lrrepuaJap esneceq peuncco uoRncasord ,Crana lcEJ Jo JeUBru B sV
6t 8t9t t?
It
L'
' 'salcrqa^ trueprseJ-uou ol elqeclldde JON suorlelor cll1prtr pue elclqen pa8elp ol Eurmo eArrp 01 esuacq dur pepuadsns prre ogz$ lrrBpueJap slgt peuu unoc u/r\oJ uolulred lotozl .fperg ,r e1doe6 u1'
tt6e
z,lv 0t8e
Lt,
LOO6 Jeqolco Euruudeq uoquracJecrrr sr{luoru
[sl aag o] lu€pueJep pecu4ues unoc
&Ic relser{cou ltoozl,dperg r
e1doed u1
9e
9t
wt0ze
'ecuelues proJsllld r11yrn dlaapncasuoc urur ol spodar uoneqord z(p1aen;o sreaf[z] omr pue uoqcues,irelauour ,s.r(emq8g r(1uno3 aoruol l Euop salcrqel tuo{ rrd\orr.{l qseq dn tuglcrd spuarlea/h {ro/v\ [91t uaalxrs ol luepuaJap es ord pacuelues unoc u/noJ uolulrad [gootl ,dperg a a1doa6 u1
0t6Z87,
It
auo 01 luBpueJep as ord pacuetrues
'spodar uoneqo.rd fplaamyo reaf [1] euo prrB uoqcues.&relauou 'sr(e/trq8F{ .Quno3 aoJuoIAI Euop selcn{el uro{ rlnoJql qs€Jt dn Euqcrd pue>1aern lrorn [11 unoc rr\otr proJsllld [soor] ,fpe.rg zr e1doad u1
LZ 9Z 9Z
8/17/2019 216654659 Criminal Writ of Errors
37/42
tz tzzz
tzoz
'pedde es ord ,traaa uo paurasns 1ed pue sJolncesord pug sunoc IBIJr eql dq peleclpnfpe fgnS ro pecFou uaeq Euyreq lou sluaurqsrund pue suoqcrluoc lBurtul.lc plol dlpuonclpslrnf luaredde fgerceg [11] uenale urarer.{ atou eseeld
ilolrcrcsrum ugIJvn Jcqfgns q$u rwuJ, HJrfr, .gsnvc rnoH&ta u{gnHsrtrnd cr[v sl[ol.tncqsoud
6t 8t LI 9t 9t
tt ttzt
Nlfuoc cryuc
flccff
q^r.wu.tsrNlru(rv
$
0t6 8 L
xuol./ttflN co tr-Idotrdsuouug do Jrul|t uodA(IHUA XCrU.f,Vd NIAIDI
I I t
0
NOISIAIC
gM'IUddv
JOTUISI(I
zt.,
xuoa/r,tflN do fl,tvJs TYICI(Iff l{tNflAfl S
8/17/2019 216654659 Criminal Writ of Errors
38/42
a
roqunN lxx
eurnlon
erec ot @
'sluepuolop e6 ord {q pes;a spolop leuollctpsunf s! a6pn[ leut :IION
poqe Ig
ttg,d:fl nuts dqceg talnteg t,ctt14
oq 'afltepq Inq q 8a1p2 puoneN aW lo requan ptata8 e pve'tqrtsle leppnf prryaqtro! ssil]tld yn r4rereq7SJIBSVe sE
uo ngpnurl W! p ngwwr e ,filuumt st aH mapag /!re.I pluauuorl ug aEa11o3 uolsoqetp uo ro:4reI uonlnrydpa^nn eq anp'Iontqn5
ilq 8a1p2 uolsog p
aynperd 7661 e
1ou s! unof, aql
-ru1sq f.rolusncce aql ol lcedsar qlpn uosrad s.1ue;p rnor( Je^o lorluotr as!f,Jexa Jaqllau upf unof, elo .lpsal s sv 'pautJeue aq louuec luayp rnoz( 1alf,F aruarsadde ue go alpp uJnleJ ar.il uo uolssas ul lou sl unoc arpJl .preSar s1q; q,,'(acpnfard lnoqlyn lgaqJe) passpusp eq plnoqs eeleql aqt (r) snr{l prre 'luaururnofpe redord ou eq uBf, araq (O 'parpbce lou sJ luafp Jnor(.rano uoprgpspnf (e).uolssas u1 leql pug ol fpogoaratp elup urnlal an uosJeadde pup
parnu
s'l qrg 'vo ilaN p pl4slQ ura{rroN eg nJ unoS t4rtqo set4s lplfun eqt lo tflltEuS '/ dlry €pnf arwsaery serers pellun q \DIt ilel e ss paNin ryg',(pnogau4.{JoA,$aN uf ase3
,Eunwys.rag
laplf
aruereadde
ue;o (1g1) lellll ]rJeU
uuoJlun s pensq q lua[] rno{ araqa,r.lstC .querurulsul ,trolesnece unoJ [BuIurIJJ IBcoJ Jo 1essguslp aW q lJnsaruEc
to wrg
n1a4 Uv\O aqf Euqpueg 1og aq1!o ropnerlr aq1 s1 q\ym nt11afu7 'pue &unw1s-rag A,bpIH 'unH,O 'Eureluars.ryJ
8/17/2019 216654659 Criminal Writ of Errors
39/42
^q l{ueqry uI asult^ 'AN
leql
"sa1r1q8"
prnparold alqetou o^r.l aJB aJaql
q1 rq nqtd e q eH '?sw!ap llt1e w sar;rrn! r,ptud .H 'bttqp xuajep FuWLrt p sl {IIS rlrfl.,
,,sawutg,, ptnwcou
p
efieu?4/wv aryI'uopsulurPxe-ssonpe}Jarp VOV ue {q pama6ar }ou irrp pue.acJlod aW ^q ars quarurufsrrf Unof, luutrrrlJr lecol lsohl ^Jolesnrce r'sluaturulsul ,(rolesnree aq1 3o {cua;c
uo (s)rarg;o aJfiod ae q]edtul ol pasn aq usr leqt saliltal -slsuoru! pug v(emp|sorup 11m no{ tsqr q (ae11od aqt {q tno palg
-nrre arp Suptupms
lrona.raded raqto IIB pup) sluer.uruFuf ,(loles {1aso1ogo lgauaq 1euoplppe uV
-UJns o1 a8ua11erp B sl-pa{oolrano ,{luounuol lsoru aql Jo "r;t auo lart pue-ase3 unoJ lpulruuJ Isf,ol e ut {leDB Jo sanuanp InJrtruJ lsou aqlJo auo z..uopnf,asord pupq:o eo1
-lpps uI '(awo op saSpnf fsotu 'uonuqle rlaqf ol lqEnorq .pus) q peJap eleuppalB uer{rt\ pue pns^ lueplgns st Alolesnrce uB Ja$aqA\ par;nber arer luaurulsul (o; ,{geuopnlpsuor q pue) plnoqs aEpnf aq .lle tsrlC q,(ruegr;gnsul pppJ
lsfr JoJ {pear aq touus) uolfnf,osord aql acugs .ssaJpru8ag 'patu-al Janau lsor[lB are safueqr aql Klrap$nsul pIJBJ JoJ passFuslp aJE sluarunqsul ,tolesnf,f,e unof, lsullulJf, IeJol ueqA\ 'ecualradxa {ur u1 'arouraqlnd . fipdtU, pu-lualaduol pus 1uat11p qool noz( sa{Bu luaurufsu! ,(rolesnrre uB u| qmJep lppaleru 1no 8q1u;od ,uog1
'pa4dxa seq aurn 0g'0t 'IdJ s.uonncasord aql Jt ,qfipnJ ul eqf,Jaxo ua aq {eu Suqg-ar ,.'luerurulsul Arolesnme p[B pJo atruasqs arp uJ
allqnbarard puopepspnfialqenpaauou
B
{lofesmre lualrlgns pue plIB [el, ,a1ru p:auaE e sy ctuautruI_6l4 tbotg''nccy d$ azturltuts'sessr 1t\O u1 sapgunyoddo passlru,(luoturuoc r{tt,r\ spap iHIOdgU arp Jo ansstalnlry B ug readde [;m Wlr.1nr 1red puoles aql 'sasef, unof, pulru1Jf, pJol Jo sedr(1 11e q alqe JIs^s sepruqroddo rp6 spap ued tsrg aql .sunotr pu -tlupt lecol ug saplunyoddo prppr SugssJru ppne ol salt -ele4s aldurp snopen quoJ s1es sa;ras ged-om1 sJr11
sl luarunlsul
8/17/2019 216654659 Criminal Writ of Errors
40/42
Jo .aartuqp {1tuo:1s 1'arpnfard lnoqlp{JoJ [ess1us1p,{ue asnef,aq
'sassf, unof, IeuFuIJJ lsrol Jfar{l suopnlosar elqero^eJ aroru 8u;rra;rpe u[ pts uBf, Jo go qq81r 'e^te,rr ipuaq pu? .uassB ot ltBJ
teql $ueqf, rno{
tou st ansq aqf lsrtl lseJ ro :"{pldlp" 1oo1 {aurope arp sa{su uaql tu1s1u: leql laal :apnlnle or{ A. "sarn B tltptr slloJap qtrns man v(aurope asua3ap ,(uury 'sluaurar;nbar SupealdalBlof^ Jo slsJap ulsluoJ asl/I,\Iaqlo (r) [elJelBtu rc/ptlP.:pau8ysun ary7 (q):'tsatep/saup Sullcgguoc/palJof,ul ulsluo3(E)
tueuodrrl
-oard ,(auolle asuaJep s sB 1sqt lerplrc sg 1g .,(ltulprocey 'setuolal se sasuello arnlnJ Eugtreqe ro; saler;pa:d sB pasn eq uene upf, auos 'r1a .sa8alyrpd SuJnlrp .sapp -nuoddo JaarcJ aJnlry'eof luarrnr s.luallc lnor( uo lcedu; asJa^pe luecgp8Js p a^pq uBJ .sauo Joulru {18upuaas ue^a 'suollf,I^uof, unoJ IsuFupf, tslol .uopppe uI
K;Jeuopualuyun lou op no,('qJnoJ leurutp3 pcol ug 8u1rg1
t'saluolaJ
:609'09143 ,fspes 1ou oCI 0) :S0'00I 163 {;sPes lou oC (a) :r299'0/l puP (t)09'00t 'IdJ &qres lou oC (p) :s((c)(r)O}'OO1 143 {lrelnrprd} 0}.m t (taC) mq arnparo.rd leutrupJ {yspes pu oC p) :qalnlg|s
qtpn paSreqr quppuaJap su qqSJr leuopntpsuo3 puB letnparord au.tss aql Jo IIs lsolule ssassod sluspuaJap urxlr pufupJ letrol le4 peJ at1; Jo tq8ls asol ol ,tsea q lt 'arun [e[ pnuetsqns;o ft1ggq;ssod cpslJear aql sa]€J ,(1arer luepuaJep aql aJuls pus .(suopoergul JSE4 pue suopelo!^ '$oupauapspu '"T) sasueJo Joupu flanpelar a^lo^ul qrno) [euFrrlJ3 lpcol ut sasm puIrrIJJ aJuls uotrcJrPo$u,
eql ul paufBluor uopdarxa
ue a1e8au ot l|edgeC
(O(B)
,'b€'st1s 'H r;rJ
Ag
:)asueJJo aqlJo slueuala €uoru ro auo a8a11e o1
:,(laupnor
$ueurulsut ,ftolesnroe qlns llnsal z sy'Eugg
o1
ropd
0 ued sunuJ leurut,u FroT ul ,,sewunuoddo pass-r/u., uoutuoJ ppnv ",,
8/17/2019 216654659 Criminal Writ of Errors
41/42
sd4 aclperd esuola@l
8/17/2019 216654659 Criminal Writ of Errors
42/42