2:13-cv-05090 #140 - Transcript Mar 14 2014

8/11/2019 2:13-cv-05090 #140 - Transcript Mar 14 2014

http://slidepdf.com/reader/full/213-cv-05090-140-transcript-mar-14-2014 1/21

1

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

EASTERN DISTRICT OF LOUISIANA

JONATHAN P. ROBICHEAUX, et al. * Docket 13 C! "#$#* c%& 1' C! ##$(

)e + + * 1' C! #3-(*

JA ES D. CALD/ELL, et al. * Sect0o F** a c2 1', -#1'

* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *

STATUS CONFERENCE BEFORE THEHONORABLE ARTIN L.C. FELD ANUNITED STATES DISTRICT JUD E

A44ea a ce+5

Fo t2e Pla0 t066+5 Sto e P078a /alt2e /0tt8a , LLCB95 DALTON COURSON, ES:.

LESLI D. HARRIS, ES:."'; Ca o <elet St eetNe& O lea +, Lo 0+0a a (#13#

Fo t2e Pla0 t066+5 SCOTT J. SPI!E9, ES:.=1" Da 420 e St eet, S 0te DNe& O lea +, Lo 0+0a a (#11;

Fo t2e De6e <a t+5 D ca , PLLCB95 >9LE DUNCAN, ES:.1;-$ > St eet N/, S 0te 3##/a+20 7to , D.C. -###;

O660c0al Co t Re4o te 5 To 0 Do?le T +a, CCR, FCRR"## Po?< a+ St eet, Roo8 B '#;Ne& O lea +, Lo 0+0a a (#13#@"#' "=$ (((=

P ocee<0 7+ eco <e< ? 8ec2a 0cal +te o7 a42? +0 7co84 te a0<e< t a +c 04t0o +o6t&a e.

1

-

3

'

"

;

(

=

$1#

11

1-

13

1'

1"

1;

1(

1=

1$

-#

-1

--

-3

-'

-"

Case 2:13-cv-05090-MLCF-ALC Document 140 Filed 09/23/14 Page 1 of 21

14-31037.1997



-

PROCEEDINGS IN CHAMBERS

(March 14, 2014)

THE COURT: F0 +t, I &a t to &elco8e all o6 ?o . I

k o& ?o e 7oo< la&?e +. T20+ 0+ a )e ?, )e ? +e 0o + 0++ e

o6 at0o al 0 te e+t a < 084o t, 8a? e 0 te at0o al, +o t2e e

a e a co 4le o6 <0+clo+ e+ t2at I 2a)e to 8ake t2at I <o ot

t20 k &a a t ec +al, t 06 +o8e o<? 2a+ a 7oo<, co )0 c0 7

ea+o a < ?o <o t 2a)e to <ec0<e 072t o& to a+k 8e

to ec +e 8?+el6, I &0ll ce ta0 l? 70)e 0t e)e ? 4 o6e++0o alco +0<e at0o .

T2e 60 +t <0+clo+ e 0+ 6o ?ea + Sto e P078a

2a)e ee 8? 4e +o al la&?e +. P20l /0tt8a 0+ 8? 4e +o al

la&?e . Fo t atel?, I 2a)e t ee<e< Sto e P078a 0 a o t

3# ?ea +, t a o t 3# ?ea + a7o P20l e4 e+e te< 8e 0 a )e ?

co t o)e +0al eal e+tate <0+4 te a < 2e <0< 0t + cce++6 ll? o

8? e2al6. T2at &a+ a o t 3# ?ea + a7o.

A o t, I <o t k o&, 1$=$, I t20 k 0t &a+,

Sto e P078a 2a <le< 8? 4a e t+ e+tate. I +t &a t ?o all

to k o& t2at. Sto e P078a 2a+ 8? &0ll. So I +t &a t t2at

o t t2e e. Sto e P078a 2a+ a44ea e< e6o e 8e o6te . It +

e)e ee a 0++ e. I <o t co +0<e 0t a 0++ e, t 06

+o8e o<? 6eel+ co86o ta le a o t 0t, I &a t e)e ? o<? to

k o&.

Seco <l?, a7a0 a o t 3# ?ea + a7o, 3# 4l +

?ea + a7o o&, I 7 e++, I &a+ a l080te< 4a t e 0 a eal;

11

-=

3"

'"

""

;"

("

="

$"

1#"

11"

1-"

13"

1'"

1";

1;;

1(;

1=;

1$;

-#;

-1;

--;

-3;

-';

-"


14-31037.1998



3

e+tate <e)elo48e t &0t2 He ? La8 e t a < Ca e? Bo < calle<

U44e l0 e A4a t8e t+. /e o 72t t2e ol< 4 l0c +c2ool o

U44e l0 e ea P ?ta 0a. He ? a < Ca e? &e e t2e 7e e al

4a t e +. I 6o 7et &2o all t2e l080te< 4a t e + &e e, t a

7 ? calle< Ho&a < Ba ett, &2o 0+ o& <ea<, &2o &a+ 8? 4a t e

0 Co Co88 0cat0o +, 0 t o< ce< 8e to He ? a < Ca e? a < I

0 )e+te< + cce++6 ll? 0 a l080te< 4a t e +204 calle< U44e l0 e

A4a t8e t+.

Be6o e I 7ot a44o0 te< to t2e e c2, I +ol< 8?0 te e+t ack to t2e8. I 6o 7et &2et2e t2e? o 72t 0t o

&2et2e Ho&a < Ba ett o 72t 0t, I <o t e8e8 e , t I +ol<

0t ack. I <0< 7et o)e t2e ?ea + +o8e 0 co8e ta c e<0t+ ?

)0 t e o6 e0 7 a l080te< 4a t e . A7a0 , I <o t t20 k I 2a)e

+ee He ? o Ca e? 8a? e o ce 0 t2e la+t 3# ?ea +, t I +t

&a t e)e ? o<? to k o& t2at 8a ?, 8a ? ?ea + a7o, e6o e I &a+

a <7e, I &a+ a 0 )e+to 0 o e o6 t2e0 )e t e+.

So 8 c2 6o t2e 4 l0c <0+clo+ e+. I k o& ?o

all 2a)e 7otte to7et2e a < k0 < o6 + 77e+te< ca+e 8a a7e8e t

<ea<l0 e+ a < +t 66. I 8 7o0 7 to e70 a e& &0t2 t2at 6o

+e)e al ea+o + &20c2 I &0ll 7o o)e &0t2 ?o , t I <o 2a)e

+o8e e+t0o +.

I 8 ot 7o0 7 to 4e 80t 0e6+ 0 e ce++ o6 t2e

4a7e l080t+. 9 all a e 7oo< la&?e +. 9o ca +a? &2at ?o

ee< to +a?.

B? t2e &a?, I 2a)e t ea< a ? o6 t2e+e ot2e=

1;

-;

3(

'(

"(

;(

((

=(

$(

1#(

11(

1-(

13(

1'(

1"=

1;=

1(=

1==

1$=

-#=

-1=

--=

-3=

-'=

-"


14-31037.1999



'

ca+e+ t2at 2a)e ee <ec0<e<. I <e +ta < t2e !0 70 0a <7e

2a+ ee c 0t0c0Ge< eca +e +2e co 6 +e< t2e Decla at0o o6

I <e4e <e ce &0t2 t2e Co +t0t t0o . I <o t k o& &2et2e

t2at + t e o ot. I 2a)e t ea< a ? o6 t2e ca+e+ eca +e I

&a t to kee4 a o4e 80 <, a < I <o t &a t to ea< t2e ca+e+

t0l I 2a)e co +0<e e< e)e ?t20 7 el+e.

I 2a)e ea< Windsor . I 2a)e +t <0e< Windsor

0te <ee4l?. I <o &a t ?o all to k o& t2at. A < I <o t

&a t 0e6+ e cee<0 7 t2e 4a7e l080t+.No&, &e 2a)e t2 ee ca+e+. S2o l< &e co +ol0<ate

t2e8 I <o t 2a)e a ? 6eel 6o t2at.

MR. COURSON: /ell, J <7e, t2e e a e +o8e <066e e ce+

et&ee t2e ca+e+. O ca+e 0+ a eco7 0t0o ca+e.

. S40)e? + 4la0 t066+ a e +eek0 7 8a 0a7e l0ce +e+. So

t2e e a e +o8e

MR. DUNCAN: I+ t2at co ect, Scott

MR. SPIVE : 9e+. T2e a8e <8e t a+ o6 Ja a ?, I

el0e)e 0t &a+, &e 2a)e a<<e< t&o 4la0 t066+ t2at a e

+eek0 7 t2e? a44l0e< 6o 8a 0a7e 0 O lea + Pa 0+2 a < &e e

<e 0e<, a < +o &e a e +eek0 7 t2e 0 ct0o

THE COURT: /20c2 &o l< a +&e t2e 0+<0ct0o

e+t0o t2at I a0+e< 0 t2e ea l0e

MR. DUNCAN: Oka?.

THE COURT: /ell, I &0ll <o &2ate)e ? all &a t to <o

o t2at. I <o t 2a)e a ? 6eel 6o t2at at all. It 8072t#

1=

-$

3$

'$

"$

;$

($

=$

$$

1#$

11$

1-$

13$

1'$

1"$

1;$

1($

1=$

1$#

-##

-1#

--#

-3#

-'#

-"


14-31037.2000



"

co 6 +e t20 7+ 06 &e <o t co +ol0<ate t2e8. I 2a)e t & a44e<

8? a 8+ a o < t2at eca +e I <o t k o&. It 8072t e clea e

a < 6a0 e 06 t2e e &a+ +t o e o40 0o 6o all t2e ca+e+.

/2at I 8 7o0 7 to <o 0+ lt08atel? +e < ?o a o < &0t2 C2a le+

to co8e 4 &0t2 a ca+e 8a a7e8e t o <e , +o ?o ca t ? to

e+ol)e 0t a8o 7 ?o +el)e+. I 2a)e t 6o 8e< a o40 0o a o t

t2at. It + 8o e o6 a e+t0o o6 co ce to 8e a o t e0 7

e660c0e t 0 7ett0 7 t2e+e ca+e+ e+ol)e<, 06 t2e? +2o l< e

e+ol)e< o&.T2at 0 7+ 4 t2e e t 0++ e, a < t2at 0+

+2o l< &e 4e 2a4+ o at lea+t 2a)e a +c2e< le t2at + co84at0 le

&0t2 t2e Te t2 C0 c 0t ca+e a < t2e F06t2 C0 c 0t Te a+ ca+e

T2e Te t2 C0 c 0t ca+e, I el0e)e, 0+ e0 7 a 7 e< a c2 -1.

MR. DUNCAN: A4 0l 1# 6o t2e Uta2 ca+e, A4 0l 1( 6o

t2e Okla2o8a ca+e 0 t2e Te t2 C0 c 0t, J <7e.

THE COURT: So t2e e a e t&o ca+e+ 0 t2e Te t2

C0 c 0t.

MR. DUNCAN: T&o ca+e+ 0 t2e Te t2 C0 c 0t. T2e?

a e e0 7 2ea < ? t2e +a8e 4a el o e &eek a4a t.

THE COURT: Oka?.

MR. DUNCAN: Al+o, J <7e, t2e !0 70 0a ca+e 2a+ ee

e 4e<0te< 0 t2e Fo t2 C0 c 0t.

THE COURT: I k o& t2e e + ee a a44eal to t2e

F06t2 C0 c 0t 0 t2e Te a+ ca+e.

MR. DUNCAN: T2e F06t2 C0 c 0t a44eal &a+ lo<7e<, I-

1#

-#

3#

'#

"#

;#

(1

=1

$1

1#1

111

1-1

131

1'1

1"1

1;1

1(1

1=1

1$1

-#1

-11

--1

-3-

-'-

-"


14-31037.2001



;

&a t to +a?, a c2 1.

THE COURT: 9e+, ece tl?.

MR. DUNCAN: No eco < o a44eal ?et 6 o8 t2e /e+te

D0+t 0ct o6 Te a+, o 0e60 7 +c2e< le ?et.

THE COURT: Sa A to 0o.

MR. DUNCAN: T2at + 072t.

THE COURT: Tell 8e &2? &e +2o l< t at lea+t 2a)e a

+c2e< le t2at + co84at0 le &0t2 7ett0 7 +o8et20 7 6 o8 a co t

o6 a44eal t2at 8072t e 2el46 l.MR. DUNCAN: J <7e, 2e e + o )0e& o t2at. T2e

Te a+ ca+e <oe+ 4 e+e t 0++ e+ t2at o)e la4 &0t2 t2e+e ca+e+.

Ho&e)e , 8? cl0e t+ +t o 7l? 6eel t2at Lo 0+0a a 2a+ 0t+ o&

co +t0t t0o a < 0t+ o& co84le o6 la&+, 0t+ o& le7al

t a<0t0o +, a < t2o+e ee< to e l0t07ate< o 0t+ o& 8e 0t+.

/e ce ta0 l? <o t &a t to +ee Te a+ l0t07at0 7 Lo 0+0a a +

ca+e 6o +.

I k o& ?o 2a)e t ea< t2e ca+e+ eca +e ?o

+t tol< + t2at, a < &2e ?o <o ea< t2e8 I t20 k &2at ?o

&0ll +ee 0+ t2at t2e+e <0+t 0ct co t o40 0o + t2at a e co80 7

at2e a40<l? a o < t2e co t ? a e all a+e< 8o e o le++ o

t2e +a8e ea+o 0 7. T2e? a e all 7o0 7 t2e +a8e <0 ect0o .

Lo 0+0a a, 0te +084l?, &a t+ ?o )0e& o 0t, J <7e. Rat2e

t2a &a0t0 7 to +ee &2at t2e F06t2 C0 c 0t <oe+, I t20 k t2e

F06t2 C0 c 0t &o l< e 2el4e< ? 2a)0 7 ?o )0e& o 0t.

THE COURT: I <o t k o& 8a ? <7e+ o t2e3

1-

--

3-

'-

"-

;-

(-

=-

$-

1#-

11-

1--

13-

1'-

1"-

1;-

1(-

1=-

1$3

-#3

-13

--3

-33

-'3

-"


14-31037.2002



(

F06t2 C0 c 0t &2o 2a)e e)e a<80tte< t2at. I t20 k 8a? e +o8e

o6 t2e8 <o <e60 0tel? 6eel t2at &a?, t I k o& at lea+t t2 ee

&2o &o l< t a<80t t2at.

MR. DUNCAN: I 2a)e to e 0te 6 a k. T2at +

&2et2e ?o a7 ee &0t2 t2e +tate + a 7 8e t+ o ot. Lo 0+0a a

&a t+ to +ta < o 0t+ o& otto8 2e e, a < I t20 k t2at

THE COURT: B? t2e &a?, let 8e +t < o4 a 6oot ote

to &2at ?o +t +a0<. I <ecla e< co +t0t t0o al 4o t0o + o6

t2e +e e70+t at0o la& ot lo 7 a7o. I 6o < t2e +tate +0e60 7 0te te o + at e+t, al8o+t 4 o6e++0o al. I k o&

?o 2a)e a 7oo< e4 tat0o .

MR. DUNCAN: T2a k ?o .

THE COURT: I +t t20 k ?o o 72t to 4a++ ack to

?o + 4e 0o + t2at I 8 7o0 7 to e e 4ect0 7 +o8e 7oo< +t 66

6 o8 t2e +tate, &20c2 I <o t + all? 7et.

MR. DUNCAN: /ell, I <0< t 2a <le t2at ca+e, J <7e.

THE COURT: I k o& ?o <0< t. I k o& ?o <0< t. I

<o t &a t to a8e 0 4 l0c &2o <0<.

MR. DUNCAN: A+ ?o k o&, I &a+ a44ellate c20e6 t2e e

6 o8 -##= to -#1-. I )e ee 0 4 0)ate 4 act0ce. No& I 8 0

4 0)ate 4 act0ce

THE COURT: I 8 a&a e o6 t2at.

MR. DUNCAN: +o I ll e 2a <l0 7 t20+ ca+e

4e +o all?.

THE COURT: Oka?.'

13

-3

33

'3

"3

;3

(3

=3

$3

1#3

11'

1-'

13'

1''

1"'

1;'

1('

1='

1$'

-#'

-1'

--'

-3'

-''

-"


14-31037.2003



=

MR. DUNCAN: I ll &o k 8?+el6 t0l 8? e?e+ lee< to

<o t2e e+t I ca o 0t.

THE COURT: oo<.

MR. DUNCAN: Ha)0 7 +a0< t2at, J <7e, &e &a t t2e

o44o t 0t? to l0t07ate t20+ ca+e e6o e ?o a < ot let Te a+

<ec0<e 0t 6o +.

THE COURT: 9o <o t &a t to +ee &2at t2e Te t2

C0 c 0t +a?+

MR. DUNCAN: I )e ee 0 6 o t o6 t2e Te t2 C0 c 0tece tl?, J <7e, a < I 8 + e &e ca all ea< &2ate)e t2e?

+a?, t ?o e 7o0 7 to 7o t2e &a? t2at ?o o 72t to 7o.

THE COURT: All 072t. Fa0 e o 72.

Do ?o all <0+a7 ee &0t2 a ? o6 t2at

MS. HARRIS: /e <o t <0+a7 ee.

MR. COURSON: No.

MR. DUNCAN: I6 I co l< a<< ot2e t20 7, J <7e, a <

8a? e &e ll 7et to t20+ 0 a +eco <. /e +t o 7l? al+o t20 k

t2at t2e+e a e le7al e+t0o +.

THE COURT: T2at t2e+e a e

MR. DUNCAN: T2e+e a e 4 e le7al e+t0o +. T2e+e

a e ot 6act e+t0o +. /e a e ot 7o0 7 to a 7 e to ?o

a o t at lea+t I <o t 4la o a 7 0 7 a o t t2e 6act+.

THE COURT: I <o t t2at I &0ll <0+a7 ee &0t2 t2at.

I 8 o4e to 0t, t I <o t t2at I &0ll <0+a7 ee &0t2 t2at.

MR. DUNCAN: I <o t 8ea to +4eak 6o t2e"

1'

-'

3'

''

"'

;'

('

='

$'

1#'

11'

1-'

13'

1'"

1""

1;"

1("

1="

1$"

-#"

-1"

--"

-3"

-'"

-"


14-31037.2004



$

4la0 t066+. I &o l< e 4ect t2e? k o& &2at t2e? a e 7o0 7 to

a 7 e. I ce ta0 l? k o& &2at I 8 7o0 7 to a 7 e 6o t2e +tate.

T2e e 0+ o lack o6 <0c0al o40 0o a <

co88e ta ? o t t2e e. L0ke ?o , I 2a)e +t <0e< Windsor

ca e6 ll?. I k o& &2at I t20 k a o t Windsor . So t2e+e a e

le7al a 7 8e t+. I +t look 6o &a < to a 7 0 7 t20+ ca+e 0

6 o t o6 ?o a < 2ea 0 7 &2at ?o 2a)e to +a? a o t 0t.

MR. COURSON: I <o t <0+a7 ee. I el0e)e t2e+e a e

le7al a 7 8e t+ a+ &ell, J <7e. I 7 e++ I &0ll +a? 0 t2eot2e ca+e+ t2e e 2a+ ee a lot o6

THE COURT: T2e ot2e <0+t 0ct co t ca+e+

MR. COURSON: 9e+, +0 , t2e ot2e <0+t 0ct co t

ca+e+. T2e e + ee a lot o6 +oc0al +c0e ce e)0<e ce 0 +o8e

o6 t2e ot2e ca+e+. I 8 ot 0te + e &2at +t060cat0o + t2e

+tate 0+ 7o0 7 to +e 0 t20+ ca+e, t ce ta0 l? 06 t2e +tate

4la + to co8e 6o &a < &0t2 +o8e +o t o6

THE COURT: St <0e+.

MR. COURSON: +t <0e+, I &a t a o44o t 0t? to

e+4o < to t2o+e.

THE COURT: S e.

MR. DUNCAN: T2at + a 7 eat 4o0 t. I ce ta0 l? &o l<

e 2a44? to talk a o t t2at 072t o& 0 6 o t o6 ?o , J <7e.

/2e ea+ I ca 08a70 e +o8e a o& +e o6 +oc0al +c0e ce

l0te at e, I 2a)e o 0 te t0o o6 8ak0 7 t2e +tate + ca+e t

o + c2 t20 7+ a < I ll e )e ? 6 a k a o t 0t eca +e 8?;

1"

-"

3"

'"

""

;"

("

="

$"

1#"

11"

1-"

13"

1';

1";

1;;

1(;

1=;

1$;

-#;

-1;

--;

-3;

-';

-"


14-31037.2005



1#

4o+0t0o 0+ 7o0 7 to e t2at 6e<e al <7e+ <o t 2a)e t2e

a t2o 0t? to &e072 +oc0al +c0e ce e)0<e ce, &0t2 all < e

e+4ect.

THE COURT: I k o& +o8e S 4 e8e Co t +t0ce+ &2o

2a)e 8a<e t2at o +e )at0o too, a < I k o& +o8e &2o 2a)e 7o e

t2e ot2e &a?.

MR. DUNCAN: Bel0e)e 8e, I 8 a&a e o6 t2at. I 8 ot

a +oc0al +c0e t0+t. I k o& +o8e. 9o a e ot. J <7e Fel<8a

0+ ot.THE COURT: O2, 6e<e al <7e+ k o& e)e ?t20 7.

MR. DUNCAN: R072t. A < 8? 4o+0t0o

MR. SPIVE : 9e+, ?o <o, J <7e.

MR. DUNCAN: I ca tell ?o , &0t2o t e)eal0 7 too

8 c2, o 4 08a ? a 7 8e t 0+ 7o0 7 to e a+e< o Windsor a <

0t + 7o0 7 to e a+e< o a 6e<e al0+8 a 7 8e t. T2e e 0+ a

4o++0 0l0t? t2at &e 8072t e6e

THE COURT: A < t2e0 a 7 8e t 0+ 7o0 7 to e a+e<

o Windsor a < 0t + 7o0 7 to e a+e< o a 6e<e al0+8 a 7 8e t.

MR. DUNCAN: T2at + 072t.

THE COURT: I 8 ot 8ak0 7 l072t o6 0t. /e a e all

7 o& 4 2e e. Le+l0 2a+ e)e <ate< >e)0 Co+t e , +o +2e 2a+

ee a o < 6o a &20le.

MR. DUNCAN: A+ 6a a+ I 8 co ce e<, t20+ ca+e

e70 + a < e <+ &0t2 Windsor a < +o8e ot2e F06t2 C0 c 0t

4 ece<e t+ l0ke t2e ca+e t2at I 2a <le< 6o t2e +tate ack 0(

1;

-;

3;

';

";

;;

(;

=;

$;

1#(

11(

1-(

13(

1'(

1"(

1;(

1((

1=(

1$(

-#(

-1(

--(

-3(

-'(

-"


14-31037.2006







13

MR. DUNCAN: a? I a+k a e+t0o a o t 4a7e l080t+,

J <7e I <e +ta < o e ce++ 4a7e l080t+, t +0 ce I 8

clea l? o t 8 e e<

THE COURT: 9o 8072t e o t 8 e e< t ot

ece++a 0l? o t7 e<.

MR. DUNCAN: I <o t k o&. /e &0ll &a0t a < +ee.

/2at I e 4ect, &2ate)e &e <ec0<e a o t co +ol0<at0o o

&2ate)e ?o <ec0<e, I ll e 7ett0 7 a + 88a ? <78e t 8ot0o

6 o8 Dalto a < I ll e 7ett0 7 a + 88a ? <78e t 8ot0o 6 o8Scott. I a++ 8e I ll e e+4o <0 7 +e4a atel? to t2e8 a < I ll

2a)e -" a < -"

THE COURT: I6 t2e ca+e+ a e t co +ol0<ate<, ?e+.

I6 t2e ca+e+ a e co +ol0<ate<, t2e o e 0e6 4e +0<e 0+ 7o0 7

to e oka?. I ca 8 lt0ta+k a < ca co +0<e 0++ e+ 0 ot2

ca+e+.

MR. DUNCAN: ea 0 7 t2e? &0ll 60le a co +ol0<ate<

0e6

THE COURT: 9e+, a < &0t20 t2e 4a7e l080t.

MR. DUNCAN: /0t20 t2e -" 4a7e+

THE COURT: 9e+. I6 t2e ca+e+ a e ot co +ol0<ate<

a < ?o ee< to 8ake +e4a ate e+4o +e+, ?o ca <o +o.

MR. DUNCAN: I 8 + e &e &0ll talk a o t t2at. A+ I

+ee t2e le7al 0++ e+, &e 2a)e e al 4 otect0o a < < e 4 oce++

+o t o6 o0 0 7 t2e t&o ca+e+. T2e ?o 2a)e t2e F0 +t

A8e <8e t 6 ee +4eec2 cla08. 9o 2a)e 7ot, a+ I ecall, a 6 ll-

11

-1

31

'1

"1

;1

(1

=1

$1

1#1

11-

1--

13-

1'-

1"-

1;-

1(-

1=-

1$-

-#-

-1-

---

-3-

-'-

-"


14-31037.2009



1'

6a0t2 a < c e<0t cla08. I+ t2at 072t

THE COURT: 9e+, I t20 k +o.

MR. SPIVE : I k o& 0 0t0all? 0t &a+. I <o t

t20 k

THE COURT: No& 0t 8072t ot e.

MR. SPIVE : I t20 k t2e 0 0t0al co84la0 t &a+ a 6 ll

6a0t2 a < c e<0t.

MR. DUNCAN: I 2a)e t20+ 60le a < I <o t 2a)e

a ?t20 7 e?o < t2at. /2e <0< ?o 60le t2e I +t t2o 72tI 2a< t2e 8o+t ece t.

MR. SPIVE : I ll 8ake + e 2e 2a+ e)e ?t20 7,

9o Ho o . I <o t &a t to &a+te ?o t08e o t2e eco <.

T2e e a e t&o <066e e t ca+e+.

MR. DUNCAN: I <e +ta < t2e? a e co +ol0<ate<.

THE COURT: 9o 8072t e o t 8 e e<, t ?o &o t

e o t7 e<.

MR. DUNCAN: I l0ke & 0t0 7 +2o t 0e6+, J <7e.

THE COURT: /ell, I <o too. I, 6 a kl?, <o t l0ke

t2e la 7 a7e o6 t2e la&. I t20 k la&?e + +4eak a o)e 4eo4le

a < t2e? 6o 7et t2at t2e? a e +t +to ?telle + a < t2e? o 72t

to act l0ke t2e? a e +0tt0 7 0 t2e0 l0)0 7 oo8 tell0 7 a

+to ? to t2e0 e+t 6 0e <, ot t2at I &a t to e a ? o<? +

e+t 6 0e <. I 2a)e a e+t 6 0e <, &2o 0+ ot 7o0 7 to & 0te

t20+ o40 0o .

A ?t20 7 el+e3

1-

--

3-

'-

"-

;-

(-

=-

$-

1#3

113

1-3

133

1'3

1"3

1;3

1(3

1=3

1$3

-#3

-13

--3

-33

-'3

-"


14-31037.2010



1"

MR. DUNCAN: /e ll 607 e 0t o t. T2at + all.

@D0+c ++0o o66 t2e eco <.

THE COURT: J +t to co cl <e, I 8 7o0 7 to a+k ?o

all to +0t &0t2 C2a le+. No&, 06 ?o ee< to take a 6e& <a?+

a < co +0<e &2at &e 2a)e <0+c ++e< 2e e a < t2e 7et ack &0t2

C2a le+, t2at + 60 e too. I 8 +t tell0 7 ?o &2at t2e e t

+te4 0 t2e 4 oce++ &0ll e.

MR. DUNCAN: 9o e 4ect + to talk to C2a le+ a o t

co +ol0<at0o a < THE COURT: A < to 4 e+e t 8e &0t2 a ca+e 8a a7e8e t

o <e a < +c2e< le

MR. DUNCAN: Oka?.

THE COURT: 6o 8e to a44 o)e, &20c2 0 cl <e+

a80c + 0e6+ ot late t2a '" <a?+ e6o e 2ea 0 7 o 8ot0o +.

9o <o t 2a)e to co8e 4 &0t2 t2at o&. 9o ca 7et ack &0t2

C2a le+. He &0ll 70)e ?o 20+ 8 e . O ?o ca +ta? 2e e,

06 ?o &a t, a < &o k 0t o t. It + 4 to ?o all. I 8

co84letel? 6le 0 le. I <0< &a t to clea t2e a0 a o t 8e<0a,

a < I <0< t &a t a ? o<? to 6eel at all co86o ta le a o t 8?

6 0e <+204+.

@P ocee<0 7+ a< o e<.

! ! !

13

-3

3;

';

";

;;

(;

=;

$;

1#;

11;

1-;

13;

1';

1";

1;;

1((

1=(

1$(

-#(

-1(

--

-3

-'

-"


14-31037.2011



1;

CERTI"ICATE

I, To 0 Do?le T +a, CCR, FCRR, O660c0al Co t

Re4o te 6o t2e U 0te< State+ D0+t 0ct Co t, Ea+te D0+t 0ct

o6 Lo 0+0a a, ce t06? t2at t2e 6o e7o0 7 0+ a t e a < co ect

t a +c 04t, to t2e e+t o6 8? a 0l0t? a < <e +ta <0 7, 6 o8

t2e eco < o6 4 ocee<0 7+ 0 t2e a o)e e t0tle< 8atte .

s/ Toni Doyle TusaTo 0 Do?le T +a, CCR, FCRRO660c0al Co t Re4o te

1

-

3

'

"

;

(

=

$1#

11

1-

13

1'

1"

1;

1(

1=

1$

-#

-1

--

-3

-'

-"


14-31037.2012



MR. COURSON: [5] 4/11 8/14 9/7 9/11 9/17 MR. DUNCAN: [41]MR. SPIVEY: [5] 4/16 10/11 14/2 14/5

14/10 MS. HARRIS: [1] 8/13 Omit elements: Timecodes [1] 15/21 Page break [2] 1/25 15/21 Resume elements: Timecodes [1] 1/25 THE COURT: [43]

''12 [1] 11/1'90s [1] 12/25

00097 [1] 1/40327 [1] 1/5

110 [1] 5/1413-CV-5090 [1] 1/414 [2] 1/7 2/214-CV-0097 [1] 1/414-CV-0327 [1] 1/51629 [1] 1/1917 [1] 5/141989 [1] 2/17220006 [1] 1/202008 [1] 7/202012 [1] 7/202014 [2] 1/7 2/221 [1] 5/1325 [3] 13/11 13/11 13/19330 years [5] 2/14 2/14 2/16 2/24 3/1430-plus [1] 2/24300 [1] 1/194406 [1] 1/2145 [3] 11/22 12/5 15/14

5500 [1] 1/21504 [1] 1/225090 [1] 1/4546 [1] 1/15589-7778 [1] 1/22770116 [1] 1/1770130 [2] 1/15 1/227778 [1] 1/228815 [1] 1/17

Aability [1] 16/5about [23]above [2] 14/19 16/6above-entitled [1] 16/6act [1] 14/21add [1] 8/16added [1] 4/18adequate [1] 11/17adjourned [1] 15/21admit [1] 7/3admitted [1] 7/1

Advocate [1] 11/6again [3] 2/24 3/13 11/19ago [6] 2/14 2/16 2/24 2/25 3/15 7/9agree [1] 7/5aided [1] 1/25air [1] 15/18al [2] 1/4 1/6all [19]almost [1] 7/10already [1] 11/20also [3] 5/21 8/17 12/17am [1] 11/21amendment [2] 4/17 13/25amicus [5] 11/24 12/7 12/10 12/12 15/14among [1] 5/6anew [1] 3/19answer [1] 4/21Antonio [1] 6/5any [8] 3/25 4/4 4/11 4/25 8/13 12/14 12/15 12/24anybody [1] 15/19anybody's [1] 14/22anyone [1] 11/23anything [3] 12/1 14/9 14/25anywhere [1] 11/23apart [1] 5/19Apartments [2] 3/2 3/8appeal [4] 5/23 5/25 6/3 6/9Appearances [1] 1/12appeared [1] 2/20appellate [1] 7/19applied [1] 4/19appointed [1] 3/9approve [1] 15/13April [2] 5/14 5/14April 10 [1] 5/14April 17 [1] 5/14are [28]aren't [1] 13/12argue [3] 8/21 9/2 9/2argued [1] 5/13arguing [2] 8/22 9/6

argument [4] 10/14 10/15 10/17 10/18arguments [4] 7/5 9/6 9/9 11/18arms [1] 5/2around [6] 5/2 5/4 6/20 10/22 11/23 12/15as [8] 4/17 7/19 9/9 10/23 10/23 11/5 13/22 13/25ask [3] 2/8 13/1 15/3assume [1] 13/10at [7] 4/25 5/11 6/7 7/2 7/10 8/22 15/19authority [1] 10/2aware [2] 7/22 10/7

BB-406 [1] 1/21back [7] 3/10 3/12 7/13 10/25 12/25 15/5 15/15banc [1] 12/18Barnett [2] 3/5 3/11based [5] 6/20 10/14 10/15 10/17 10/18battle [1] 11/11be [27]because [8] 4/2 4/4 5/2 6/17 9/25 11/11 11/25 12/20been [11] 2/12 2/21 4/1 4/2 5/21 5/23 7/20 8/9 9/10 9/13 10/22

before [10] 1/9 2/20 3/9 3/15 8/5 11/22 12/6 12/17 12/23 15/14begin [1] 3/19begins [1] 10/24behalf [1] 2/16being [4] 3/13 5/7 5/13 5/19believe [4] 4/18 5/13 9/8 10/7bench [1] 3/9benefit [1] 11/25best [7] 7/10 8/2 11/7 14/22 14/23 14/23 16/5between [1] 4/13beyond [1] 14/9bleed [1] 8/1blistering [1] 11/5Bond [1] 3/1both [4] 11/21 12/8 12/9 13/14bottom [1] 7/6bought [3] 3/2 3/10 3/11brief [3] 12/12 13/13 13/17briefing [2] 6/4 7/10briefs [8] 3/22 4/9 11/18 11/24 12/7 12/11 14/17 15/14brings [1] 5/10buddy [1] 11/7but [16] 2/7 2/14 2/21 3/4 3/11 3/14 3/20 7/2 8/11 8/24 9/15 12/11 12/24 13/2 13/4 14/15

Cc/w [1] 1/4CALDWELL [1] 1/6called [3] 3/1 3/5 3/7came [1] 12/17can [12] 3/23 5/5 8/2 8/10 9/23 10/13 12/3 13/14 13/14 13/21 15/15 15/16carefully [1] 9/5Carey [4] 3/1 3/3 3/6 3/14Carondelet [1] 1/15case [24]cases [22]CCR [3] 1/21 16/2 16/9certainly [6] 2/9 6/15 9/2 9/15 9/21

12/12CERTIFICATE [1] 16/1certify [1] 16/4CHAMBERS [1] 2/1Charles [6] 5/4 11/20 15/4 15/6 15/8 15/16chief [2] 7/19 12/17Circuit [15] 5/12 5/12 5/13 5/15 5/17 5/18 5/22 5/24 5/25 6/23 6/24 7/1 8/8 8/9 10/24citing [1] 11/9claim [2] 13/25 14/1clear [1] 15/18clearer [1] 5/2clearly [1] 13/3clients [1] 6/12cocktail [1] 12/19come [4] 5/5 9/16 11/21 15/15coming [1] 6/19commentary [1] 9/4Communications [1] 3/6compatible [2] 5/11 6/8complaint [1] 14/6completely [1] 15/18complex [1] 6/13computer [1] 1/25computer-aided [1] 1/25


14-31037.2013



Cconcern [2] 5/7 11/10concerned [1] 10/23conclude [1] 15/3CONFERENCE [1] 1/9confuse [1] 5/1confused [1] 4/2consider [4] 2/21 12/12 13/14 15/5consideration [1] 2/10considered [1] 4/6consolidate [2] 4/10 5/1consolidated [5] 13/12 13/13 13/16 13/20 14/14

consolidation [2] 13/7 15/9constitution [2] 4/3 6/13controversial [1] 2/15convincing [1] 2/7correct [2] 4/16 16/4Costner [1] 10/21could [1] 8/16country [3] 6/20 11/23 12/15couple [1] 2/6course [1] 11/8COURSON [1] 1/14court [10] 1/1 1/21 6/8 6/19 9/11 9/12 10/4 16/2 16/3 16/10Cox [1] 3/6credit [2] 14/1 14/7credits [1] 3/12criticized [1] 4/2CV [3] 1/4 1/4 1/5

DD.C [1] 1/20DALTON [2] 1/14 13/9date [2] 12/5 12/6dated [1] 10/21Dauphine [1] 1/17days [6] 11/22 12/5 12/17 12/22 15/4 15/14dead [1] 3/5deadline [1] 12/6deadlines [1] 3/19decide [7] 2/8 8/6 11/6 12/2 12/4 13/7 13/8decided [1] 4/1Declaration [1] 4/2declared [1] 7/8deeply [1] 4/8Defendants [1] 1/18definitely [1] 7/2denied [1] 4/20development [1] 3/1did [6] 2/15 3/12 7/18 12/24 14/9 15/18didn't [6] 7/16 7/17 7/17 12/23 12/24 15/19differences [1] 4/12

different [1] 14/13direction [1] 6/21disadvantage [1] 11/3disagree [5] 8/13 8/14 8/23 8/24 9/8disclosure [1] 2/11disclosures [2] 2/6 3/17discussed [1] 15/5Discussion [1] 15/2dispute [1] 2/15dissent [2] 11/5 11/8district [9] 1/1 1/2 1/10 6/4 6/19 9/11 9/12 16/3 16/3do [16] 2/6 3/20 4/8 4/24 4/24 5/4 6/18

7/2 8/2 8/13 10/12 11/16 11/25 11/25 13/21 14/18Docket [1] 1/4does [2] 6/11 6/23don't [34]done [1] 12/15doubt [3] 8/23 8/24 12/9Doyle [4] 1/21 16/2 16/9 16/9drop [1] 7/7due [2] 10/2 13/23Duncan [2] 1/18 1/19

Eeach [1] 11/17

earlier [1] 4/22EASTERN [2] 1/2 16/3efficient [1] 5/8else [2] 4/6 14/25en [1] 12/18en banc [1] 12/18ends [1] 10/24enough [1] 8/12entitled [1] 16/6equal [1] 13/23ESQ [4] 1/14 1/14 1/16 1/19estate [3] 2/15 2/18 3/1et [2] 1/4 1/6even [2] 10/21 11/4ever [1] 7/1every [1] 2/9everybody [2] 2/22 3/15everything [4] 4/6 10/10 12/1 14/11evidence [2] 9/13 10/2exceeding [1] 4/9excess [2] 3/22 13/2expect [3] 9/1 13/7 15/8expecting [1] 7/14expedited [1] 5/22experts [1] 11/11eyes [1] 8/1Ffact [1] 8/21facts [1] 8/22Fair [1] 8/12fairer [1] 5/3faith [2] 14/1 14/7far [1] 10/23FCRR [3] 1/21 16/2 16/9federal [2] 10/1 10/10federalism [2] 10/15 10/18feel [5] 4/11 4/25 6/12 7/2 15/19feels [1] 2/22FELDMAN [3] 1/10 10/8 12/10few [1] 15/4Fifth [7] 5/12 5/24 5/25 6/23 6/24 7/1 10/24Fifth Circuit [6] 5/12 5/24 6/23 6/24 7/1

10/24figure [1] 15/1file [4] 12/11 13/16 14/8 14/9fine [1] 15/6first [4] 2/3 2/11 12/17 13/24flexible [1] 15/18following [1] 11/22footnote [1] 7/7foregoing [1] 16/4forget [3] 3/4 3/10 14/20formed [1] 5/6Fortunately [1] 2/13forward [2] 9/6 9/16

found [1] 7/9four [2] 12/17 12/22Fourth [1] 5/22Fourth Circuit [1] 5/22frank [2] 7/4 9/25frankly [3] 11/10 12/16 14/18free [1] 13/25friend [4] 11/7 14/22 14/23 14/23friendships [1] 15/20front [3] 8/9 9/7 9/22full [2] 13/25 14/6

Ggeneral [1] 3/3

get [5] 3/12 7/15 8/17 15/5 15/15gets [1] 11/13getting [4] 5/8 6/8 13/8 13/9give [2] 2/9 15/16gives [1] 11/17go [4] 3/20 8/11 8/11 11/2going [21]gone [1] 10/5good [6] 2/4 2/7 3/23 7/11 7/14 8/3got [2] 3/9 13/25Gotcha [1] 12/8gotten [1] 3/18great [1] 9/21grown [1] 10/21guess [2] 2/25 9/9guy [1] 3/5Hhad [6] 12/18 12/19 12/20 12/23 12/24 14/10handle [1] 7/16handled [2] 2/18 10/25handling [1] 7/23happened [1] 12/16happy [1] 9/22HARRIS [1] 1/14has [10] 2/7 2/19 2/20 4/2 5/21 6/12 9/10 10/21 10/21 14/11have [37]haven't [7] 2/13 3/25 4/4 5/1 5/6 6/17 12/15having [3] 6/24 8/4 11/3he [7] 2/15 11/7 12/17 12/23 12/24 14/11 15/16heard [1] 5/19hearing [6] 9/7 11/23 12/4 12/5 12/6 15/14help [1] 12/2helped [1] 6/24helpful [1] 6/9Henry [4] 3/1 3/3 3/6 3/14here [5] 7/6 10/21 12/19 15/5 15/16here's [1] 6/10Heyburn [2] 12/16 12/20

him [1] 12/25his [3] 11/8 12/17 15/16Honor [1] 14/12HONORABLE [1] 1/10Howard [2] 3/5 3/11However [1] 6/12

II'll [8] 7/23 8/1 9/25 13/8 13/9 13/10 13/10 14/11I'm [21]I've [2] 7/20 8/9if [15] 2/7 2/21 5/1 5/3 5/8 8/16 9/15


14-31037.2014



Iif... [8] 12/11 12/14 12/23 13/12 13/13 13/20 15/4 15/17imagine [1] 9/23import [1] 2/5in [35]inappropriate [1] 11/12includes [1] 15/13income [1] 3/12Independence [1] 4/3initial [1] 14/6initially [1] 14/3injunction [1] 4/20

insist [1] 11/22intention [1] 9/24interest [2] 2/5 3/10international [1] 2/5into [2] 11/2 11/11introduced [1] 3/6invested [1] 3/7investor [1] 3/16invited [1] 12/19is [30]issue [4] 2/4 2/21 2/21 5/10issues [4] 6/11 12/2 13/14 13/23it [29]it's [5] 2/20 5/7 10/15 10/18 15/17its [5] 6/12 6/13 6/13 6/14 7/6JJAMES [1] 1/6January [1] 4/17John [2] 12/16 12/22

joining [1] 13/24JONATHAN [1] 1/4

judge [22]Judge Feldman [1] 10/8Judge Vance [1] 12/19

judges [4] 6/25 10/1 10/10 12/14 judgment [2] 13/8 13/9 judicial [1] 9/3 jurisdiction [1] 4/21 just [17]Justice [1] 11/4

justices [1] 10/4 justifications [1] 9/14Kkeep [1] 4/5Kevin [1] 10/21kind [1] 3/18knew [1] 12/23know [31]knows [1] 11/20KYLE [1] 1/19LL.C [1] 1/10lack [1] 9/3Lambert [1] 3/1language [1] 14/19last [1] 3/14later [1] 15/14law [3] 7/9 11/8 14/19laws [1] 6/13lawyer [1] 2/13lawyers [4] 2/4 2/12 3/23 14/19least [4] 5/11 6/7 7/2 8/22legal [6] 6/13 8/18 8/20 9/6 9/9 13/23LESLI [2] 1/14 10/21

less [1] 6/20let [2] 7/7 8/5licenses [1] 4/14light [1] 10/20like [8] 9/4 10/25 11/4 12/10 12/11 14/17 14/18 14/21limit [1] 13/18limited [4] 2/25 3/4 3/7 3/13limits [5] 3/23 4/9 11/19 13/1 13/2literature [1] 9/24litigate [1] 8/5litigated [1] 6/14litigating [1] 6/15little [1] 12/19living [1] 14/21LLC [1] 1/13lodged [1] 5/25long [1] 7/9look [1] 9/6lot [2] 9/10 9/13LOUISIANA [8] 1/2 1/15 1/17 1/22 6/12 6/22 7/5 16/4Louisiana's [1] 6/15

Mmade [1] 10/5make [5] 2/6 11/21 12/9 13/21 14/11making [2] 9/24 10/20management [4] 3/18 5/5 11/15 15/10many [3] 3/15 3/15 6/25March [4] 1/7 2/2 5/13 6/1March 21 [1] 5/13marriage [2] 4/14 4/19MARTIN [1] 1/10matter [2] 11/24 16/6May [1] 13/1maybe [4] 2/5 3/14 7/1 8/17me [13] 2/8 2/14 2/20 3/6 5/7 6/7 7/7 10/7 11/16 12/2 12/20 15/10 15/13mean [1] 8/25Meaning [1] 13/16mechanical [1] 1/24media [1] 15/18

mentor [1] 12/25mentored [1] 12/20merits [1] 6/14might [7] 4/25 5/2 6/9 10/16 13/4 14/5 14/15mind [1] 4/5more [2] 5/7 6/20most [1] 14/10motion [3] 11/22 13/8 13/9motions [1] 15/14Mr. [1] 4/14Mr. Spivey's [1] 4/14much [2] 3/17 10/14multidistrict [2] 12/18 12/21multitask [1] 13/14my [18]myself [2] 2/9 8/1Nname [1] 7/18narrow [1] 9/23national [1] 2/5near [1] 3/3necessarily [1] 13/5need [5] 3/24 6/14 11/2 13/21 15/4needed [1] 2/13never [1] 2/21New [4] 1/15 1/17 1/22 11/6

New Orleans Advocate [1] 11/6next [3] 5/10 11/14 15/6no [7] 6/3 6/4 8/15 9/3 9/24 12/9 13/2not [22]now [10] 2/8 2/25 3/5 4/10 5/9 7/20 9/22 14/5 15/4 15/15number [1] 15/16NW [1] 1/19Oobservation [1] 10/5off [1] 15/2Official [3] 1/21 16/2 16/10often [1] 2/20

Oh [1] 10/10okay [5] 4/23 5/20 7/25 13/14 15/12Oklahoma [1] 5/15old [1] 3/2on [24]once [1] 3/14one [4] 3/16 5/3 5/19 13/13open [2] 4/5 8/24opinion [5] 5/3 5/6 9/3 12/17 14/24opinions [1] 6/19opportunity [2] 8/5 9/18or [10] 3/10 3/14 4/4 5/11 6/20 7/5 11/23 12/22 13/7 15/16order [2] 5/5 15/11Orleans [5] 1/15 1/17 1/22 4/19 11/6Orleans Parish [1] 4/19other [10] 3/25 8/16 9/10 9/11 9/12 9/14 10/6 10/24 11/3 12/14ought [3] 7/13 8/11 14/20our [3] 4/13 6/10 10/14out [6] 2/20 9/4 11/6 12/17 15/1 15/17outgunned [2] 13/5 14/16outnumbered [3] 13/3 13/4 14/15over [2] 3/12 3/20overlap [1] 6/11own [5] 6/12 6/13 6/13 6/14 7/6Ppage [6] 3/23 4/9 11/19 13/1 13/2 13/18pages [1] 13/19panel [3] 5/19 12/18 12/21parents' [1] 2/18Parish [1] 4/19partner [3] 2/25 3/5 3/13partners [2] 3/4 3/4partnership [1] 3/7party [1] 12/19pass [1] 7/13people [1] 14/19per [1] 13/13perhaps [1] 5/11permit [3] 3/22 11/25 12/12personal [2] 2/12 2/12

personally [1] 7/24Phil [2] 2/12 2/14Pigman [6] 1/13 2/11 2/13 2/18 2/19 2/20plaintiffs [5] 1/13 1/16 4/14 4/18 9/1plan [2] 8/22 11/9plans [1] 9/16PLLC [1] 1/18plus [1] 2/24point [4] 9/21 11/10 11/14 11/21pointed [1] 11/6portions [1] 7/8position [2] 10/1 10/11


14-31037.2015



Ppossibility [1] 10/16Poydras [1] 1/21practice [2] 7/20 7/21precedents [1] 10/25prepare [2] 11/18 11/18present [3] 6/11 11/16 15/10primary [1] 10/14private [2] 7/20 7/21proceedings [4] 1/24 2/1 15/21 16/6process [2] 13/23 15/7professional [2] 2/9 11/17protection [1] 13/23

Prytania [1] 3/3public [3] 3/2 3/17 7/18pure [1] 8/20Qquestion [3] 4/22 5/7 13/1questions [4] 3/21 8/18 8/20 8/21quite [5] 4/8 6/22 7/4 7/10 9/14Rraised [1] 4/22rapidly [1] 6/20rather [2] 6/20 6/22read [7] 3/25 4/4 4/5 4/7 6/17 6/18 8/10real [2] 2/15 2/25

reason [1] 2/8reasonable [2] 11/16 12/1reasoning [1] 6/21reasons [1] 3/20recall [1] 13/25recent [1] 14/10recently [2] 6/2 8/10recognition [1] 4/13record [4] 6/3 14/12 15/2 16/6recorded [1] 1/24recusal [1] 2/7recuse [1] 2/9refer [1] 10/16registration [1] 7/9remember [1] 3/11Reporter [3] 1/21 16/3 16/10represented [1] 2/14reputation [1] 7/11resolve [1] 5/6resolved [2] 5/8 5/9respect [1] 10/3respective [1] 12/10respond [3] 9/19 11/13 11/18responding [1] 13/10responses [1] 13/21responsible [1] 12/1revealing [1] 10/13right [7] 2/8 6/6 8/12 9/22 10/11 10/19 14/1ROBICHEAUX [1] 1/4room [2] 1/21 14/21Ssaid [3] 7/8 8/4 11/4same [3] 5/19 6/21 6/21San [1] 6/5San Antonio [1] 6/5say [6] 3/23 3/24 6/1 8/11 9/7 9/9says [1] 8/8Scalia [1] 11/5schedule [7] 5/11 6/4 6/8 11/15 11/17 11/21 15/11

school [1] 3/2science [5] 9/13 9/23 10/2 11/9 11/11scientist [1] 10/8SCOTT [3] 1/16 4/16 13/10second [1] 8/17Secondly [1] 2/24Section [1] 1/6see [7] 6/15 6/19 6/23 8/7 11/10 13/6 13/23seeking [3] 4/14 4/19 4/20seen [1] 3/14send [1] 5/4separate [1] 13/21separately [1] 13/10serious [1] 2/4several [1] 3/20sex [1] 7/9she [3] 4/2 10/21 12/19short [1] 14/17should [3] 4/10 5/8 5/11shouldn't [1] 6/7side [4] 11/3 11/3 11/17 13/13sides [3] 12/8 12/9 12/10simply [1] 6/22since [1] 13/2sir [1] 9/12sit [1] 15/4sitting [1] 14/21so [16] 2/5 2/19 3/17 4/14 4/20 5/5 5/16 7/23 9/5 10/21 11/9 11/25 12/3 12/13 13/21 14/2social [6] 9/13 9/23 10/2 10/8 11/9 11/11software [1] 1/25sold [2] 3/9 3/11some [13] 3/12 3/21 4/12 4/15 7/1 7/14 9/13 9/16 9/23 10/4 10/5 10/8 10/24somebody [3] 2/7 2/22 12/11something [1] 6/8sort [2] 9/16 13/24speak [2] 8/25 14/19speech [1] 13/25SPIVEY [1] 1/16

Spivey's [1] 4/14spoken [1] 12/15stand [1] 7/6state [5] 7/15 9/2 9/15 9/15 10/25state's [3] 7/5 7/9 9/24STATES [3] 1/1 1/10 16/3STATUS [1] 1/9stay [1] 15/16stenography [1] 1/24step [1] 15/7Stone [6] 1/13 2/11 2/13 2/18 2/19 2/20Stone Pigman [1] 2/18story [1] 14/22storytellers [1] 14/20Street [4] 1/15 1/17 1/19 1/21strongly [2] 6/12 8/17studied [2] 4/7 9/4studies [2] 9/17 9/18stuff [2] 3/19 7/14submission [1] 12/6submit [1] 11/24successfully [2] 2/15 3/7such [1] 9/25suggested [1] 3/18Suite [2] 1/17 1/19summary [2] 13/8 13/9superiors [1] 7/14

Supreme [1] 10/4Supreme Court [1] 10/4sure [5] 8/10 9/14 9/20 13/22 14/11Ttake [1] 15/4talk [4] 9/22 12/24 13/22 15/8tax [1] 3/12tell [2] 6/7 10/13telling [2] 14/21 15/6Tenth [7] 5/12 5/13 5/15 5/16 5/18 8/7 8/9tenuous [1] 7/10Texas [6] 5/12 5/24 6/4 6/11 6/15 8/5

than [2] 6/23 15/14Thank [1] 7/12that [63]that's [10] 4/4 5/11 6/6 6/8 7/4 9/21 10/19 11/12 15/1 15/6their [5] 3/16 10/17 12/18 14/21 14/22them [7] 3/10 4/11 5/1 6/18 7/2 12/16 13/10then [3] 13/13 13/24 15/5there [12] 2/5 2/20 4/12 4/15 5/3 5/16 7/19 9/3 9/4 9/10 10/15 14/13there's [2] 5/23 9/13these [12] 3/25 5/8 6/11 6/19 8/18 8/19 8/20 8/20 9/5 9/8 12/2 12/23they [15] 3/10 4/19 5/8 5/18 6/21 8/10 9/1 9/1 12/18 13/16 14/14 14/20 14/20 14/20 14/21thing [1] 8/16things [2] 5/1 9/25think [17]this [14] 2/4 7/23 8/5 8/17 9/6 9/15 10/23 11/6 11/11 11/20 11/20 11/23 14/8 14/24those [3] 6/14 9/19 12/24though [1] 11/4thought [1] 14/9three [3] 4/10 7/2 12/22time [2] 11/17 14/12together [1] 3/18

told [1] 6/18Toni [4] 1/21 16/2 16/9 16/9too [4] 10/5 10/13 14/18 15/6traditions [1] 6/14transcript [1] 16/5transcription [1] 1/25true [2] 4/4 16/4trust [1] 11/15try [1] 5/5turn [2] 9/24 11/11Tusa [4] 1/21 16/2 16/9 16/9two [5] 4/18 5/16 5/18 13/24 14/13

Uultimately [1] 5/4

uncomfortable [2] 2/22 15/19unconstitutional [1] 7/8understand [4] 4/1 12/3 13/2 14/14understanding [1] 16/5UNITED [3] 1/1 1/10 16/3Unless [1] 11/13unprofessional [1] 7/10until [2] 4/6 8/1up [6] 5/5 5/10 10/21 11/21 15/15 15/17Upperline [3] 3/2 3/3 3/7us [4] 6/16 6/18 8/6 15/8use [2] 9/15 9/23


14-31037.2016



Uusing [1] 1/24usually [1] 7/15Utah [1] 5/14VVance [2] 12/19 12/20ventures [1] 3/16versus [1] 1/5very [4] 2/4 2/4 2/14 9/25view [4] 6/10 6/22 6/24 11/10Virginia [2] 4/1 5/21virtue [1] 3/13

Wwait [1] 13/6waiting [1] 6/23Walther [1] 1/13want [26]wants [3] 6/22 7/6 12/11warrant [1] 2/7was [13] 2/16 2/17 2/25 3/5 3/15 3/16 4/18 5/3 5/25 7/19 12/22 14/3 14/6Washington [1] 1/20waste [1] 14/12way [5] 3/25 7/2 7/7 8/11 10/6we [24]we'll [2] 8/17 15/1

week [1] 5/19weigh [1] 10/2welcome [1] 2/3well [5] 4/12 4/24 7/16 9/9 14/18were [3] 3/3 3/4 4/19Western [1] 6/3what [15] 3/23 5/4 6/18 6/23 7/8 8/7 9/1 9/2 9/5 9/7 9/14 11/4 13/7 15/5 15/6whatever [7] 4/24 8/10 11/15 11/21 12/5 13/7 13/8when [2] 6/18 14/9whenever [1] 12/3Whereas [1] 9/23whether [4] 3/10 3/11 4/3 7/5which [5] 3/20 4/21 7/15 12/1 15/13while [1] 10/22who [10] 3/4 3/5 3/5 7/1 7/3 7/18 10/4 10/5 11/24 14/23why [1] 6/7will [16] 2/9 2/19 3/20 4/24 6/19 8/23 8/24 9/9 12/6 12/9 12/12 13/6 13/16 13/22 15/7 15/16Windsor [9] 4/7 4/7 9/4 9/5 10/14 10/18 10/24 11/4 11/5within [3] 11/18 13/18 13/19without [1] 10/13Wittmann [2] 1/13 2/12won't [1] 14/15work [2] 8/1 15/17world [1] 11/24would [6] 4/21 6/24 9/1 9/21 12/10 12/11wouldn't [1] 7/3wrapped [1] 5/1write [1] 14/23writing [1] 14/17wrote [1] 11/5Yy'all [2] 3/23 4/24years [9] 2/11 2/14 2/14 2/16 2/24 2/25

3/12 3/14 3/15yes [8] 4/17 6/2 9/12 10/12 13/12 13/18 13/20 14/2yet [2] 6/3 6/4you [59]you're [2] 2/4 8/11your [7] 6/22 6/24 7/14 11/3 12/10 14/12 14/12Your Honor [1] 14/12yourselves [1] 5/6


Documents

2:13-cv-05090 #140 - Transcript Mar 14 2014