Upload
seth-rees
View
212
Download
2
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
©2007 ViTAL Economy, Inc.— 1 —
Executive OverviewExecutive OverviewStay cool
Southern Illinois: Garden of the Gods
Readiness Assessment
Executive Overview
December 14, 2007; revised Feb 14, 2008
CONNECT SI
ViTAL Economy AllianceFrank Knott, Project Lead; Stan Halle, Senior Editor;
Jim Haguewood, Rob Beynon, & Neil Gamroth, Principal Economic Researchers
[email protected]; http://www.vitaleconomy.com
©2007 ViTAL Economy, Inc.— 2 —
Executive OverviewExecutive OverviewTerms of Use
Limited License: Subject to these Terms of Use, we grant to the local sponsor and its
funding partners for this ViTAL Economy Readiness Assessment a non-exclusive, non-transferable, limited license to access and use the information, text, graphics, data, and other content in this report for their personal and noncommercial use. You may also incorporate portions of the content of this report in documents and other works of authorship that are mainly the product of your own intellectual effort, and may distribute and disseminate those documents and other works, but only if neither you nor anyone else receives any payment or other value that is primarily attributable to the content used.
Proprietary Rights: You acknowledge that the content of this report is the property of ViTAL Economy, Inc. and is protected by copyright, trademark and other intellectual property laws. You agree not to use this content for any unlawful or unauthorized purpose, or in any manner that would harm the reputation of ViTAL Economy, Inc. or its partners. You agree not to use any name, emblem, logo, or trademark of ViTAL Economy, Inc. in any manner, except in the form of attribution and copyright notice required by these Terms of Use.
Copyright Notice: On any print-out, download, or copy of this content you make that does not already include a copyright notice, you agree to include a copyright notice as follows: "Copyright © 2007, ViTAL Economy, Inc. All rights reserved.”
Executive OverviewExecutive Overview
©2007 ViTAL Economy, Inc.— 3 —
Executive OverviewExecutive OverviewExecutive Overview Table of Contents
READINESS ASSESSMENT (RA) Executive OverviewREADINESS ASSESSMENT (RA) Executive Overview Slide #Slide #
Letter to Letter to ConnectConnect SISI Leaders .…………………………………………..…. 4 Leaders .…………………………………………..…. 4
m Understanding the Readiness Assessment Process ..………….. 6Understanding the Readiness Assessment Process ..………….. 6
m TheThe SI SI Opportunity and Dilemma Opportunity and Dilemma ………………………………….. ………………………………….. 1414
m State, National and Global Trends and Implications for State, National and Global Trends and Implications for SI SI . ..……. .……. 2121
m Assessing Assessing SI’sSI’s Climate to Support Growth …………………………. 25 Climate to Support Growth …………………………. 25
m Community of Interest (COI) Perspective and Goals ……….…… 36Community of Interest (COI) Perspective and Goals ……….…… 36
m Connect SIConnect SI: Crossing the Boundaries ……………………….……. 49: Crossing the Boundaries ……………………….……. 49
m How Does How Does SISI Organize to Succeed? ………………………………. 56 Organize to Succeed? ………………………………. 56
m Call to Excellence…a Destiny of Prosperity! ………………….… 61Call to Excellence…a Destiny of Prosperity! ………………….… 61
Stay cool
©2007 ViTAL Economy, Inc.— 4 —
Executive OverviewExecutive OverviewLetter to the Reader
This Readiness Assessment (RA) Executive Summary provides a condensed view of the readiness of Southern Illinois (SI) to successfully support and implement the Connect SI Phase 2 multi-year economic development strategy. It summarizes the key findings contained in the detailed RA issued to Connect SI on December 2007.
The RA is a multi-faceted assessment of SI economic history and current conditions. It involves more than 235 interview sessions with 940+ business, public sector, labor union, community and not-for-profit leaders living and working in SI. It includes a review of over 250 studies of the SI economy. The RA highlights global, national and regional trends critical to understand as Connect SI proposes a five year strategy for transforming the SI economy by 2012. The RA assessment process took place between Sept 2006 - Nov 2007.
The RA is an independent 360º view of all aspects of the SI economy designed to provide subjective and objective assessments of community vitality as well as economic opportunity. It enables uncomfortable but necessary realities to be reviewed openly, so that Connect SI leaders can plan for long-term success. The RA is the work product of ViTAL Economy, not Connect SI. The results of the RA provide both opportunities and challenges for SI.
Opportunities: SI indigenous resources are a perfect match for current global and national market trends. SI has the opportunity to grow its economy at an annual growth rate of 3.85% by 2012 versus its 1.34% growth rate over the past 25 years, resulting in $2 billion in new annual wages, $3.6 billion rise in annual GDP, 43,000+ new high wage jobs, 10,000 citizens lifted out of poverty and over $162 million more annual state and local tax revenue.
Challenges: SI has a major dilemma. There is a need to build a better climate of trust so that meaningful collaboration increases and the risk environment for visionary leaders improves. A pervasive willingness to accept mediocrity is evidenced by a lack of excellence in many aspects of SI life. There is an overarching belief that “the cavalry is coming” despite evidence to the contrary. Policies continue to prioritize & fund initiatives that emphasize declining sectors of the current economy rather than expanding into 21st century economic realities.
As discussed in this RA, SI has the opportunity to become a “regional gateway” for America’s Heartland to the global economy and for the global economy to America’s Heartland, if and only if SI chooses to believe it can.
Frank Knott, PresidentViTAL Economy, Inc.
©2007 ViTAL Economy, Inc.— 5 —
Executive OverviewExecutive Overview
— 5 —
We See A Bountiful Southern Illinois
Vital Economy’s View:
— We have fallen in love with SI. We see it as the land of the “Garden of the Gods” —
Prime central North American location in close proximity to over 11M people 425,000 population that produces a $17.6B economy — equivalent to a major metro-area Multi-directional Interstate highway, waterway and rail road infrastructure Major research university, robust community college system and workforce development
assets Modern and growing healthcare facilities Large national forest and numerous unique tourist attractions Extensive mineral, agricultural and unique natural environmental assets Rich soils, mild climate and abundant water resources Numerous innovative and leading industry companies and an entrepreneurship spirit Special, welcoming, talented and caring people who want better for their families Young and old who see SI for the treasure it is, and desire stewardship that reflects its value
ViTAL Economy Conclusion:Southern Illinois has more assets at its disposal than
any other region it has advised in 15 years
ViTAL Economy Conclusion:Southern Illinois has more assets at its disposal than
any other region it has advised in 15 years
©2007 ViTAL Economy, Inc.— 6 —
Executive OverviewExecutive Overview
Southern Illinois — "Garden of the Gods"
Section A: Understanding the Readiness Assessment ProcessUnderstanding the Readiness Assessment Process
Executive OverviewExecutive Overview
The What, Why and How of a Readiness Assessment
Stay cool
©2007 ViTAL Economy, Inc.— 7 —
Executive OverviewExecutive Overview
Readiness Assessment
The Readiness Assessment is a 360° review of an economic region from two perspectives, including:
1. Community internal opinions and impressions
2. Outside-in perspective based upon years of experience and research in other rural communities and a review of national & global trends relative to SI asset mapping results
( )Internal Insights + External Insights x VE Analysis =•Interviews•Local Research/Reports
•3rd Party Observations•External Research
Connect SI 20-County Economic Strategy
Connect SI 20-County Economic Strategy
Readiness Assessment
Readiness Assessment
Phase 2 COI StrategiesPhase 2 COI Strategies
Greater Wabash COI
Southern Five COI
Southeastern COI
Greater Egypt COI
Healthcare COI
Network Provider COI
©2007 ViTAL Economy, Inc.— 8 —
Executive OverviewExecutive Overview
Readiness Assessment Process
The Readiness Assessment is built from the ground upThe Readiness Assessment is built from the ground up
Assess Economic Development Needs & Local Leadership Vision
COI Milestone Meetings
ConnectivityAssessment
AssessClimate ofInnovation
Livable CommunityAssessment
State, Nat’l, Global Trends
Primary &SecondaryResearch
Assess Knowledge, Service, Infrastructure, Finance, Leadership Gaps
Long TermInitiative
Readiness toConnect &Collaborate
Assess
VisionaryLeadership
DeterminePublicSector& NGOSupport
DeterminePrivate-Sector
SupportMeasureClimate ofSuccess
Ability & Will to
Collaborate & Fund at
Local Level
Connect SI Phase 2 Multi-Year Initiative
Developed High-Value Jobs Accelerated GDP Growth Transformed Economy
SI RA Components
©2007 ViTAL Economy, Inc.— 9 —
Executive OverviewExecutive Overview
The Job of the RA
Provide a mirror that reflects to leaders
what those they lead are thinking and saying
————
Highlight the opportunities that are before you
————
Communicate an unvarnished view of the challenges
————
Determine if the key ingredients are in place to achieve success,
despite the perceived difficulty of the challenges
————
Develop the RA as a qualifying filter for prioritizing choices for the completion and launch of the Connect SI long-term strategy
See: RA Chapter 6
©2007 ViTAL Economy, Inc.— 10 —
Executive OverviewExecutive Overview
Readiness Assessment Process in Context
June 2006
VISION
&
GOALS
Year One Year Two
PHASE 1COI Launch
COI Milestone Meetings & Goal Setting
Asset Mapping
Economic Scenario Models
Readiness Assessment
PHASE 2Industry Cluster Analysis & Strategies
Integrated Finance Strategy
Youth Engagement Strategy
Collaborative Leadership Institute
Innovation Ecosystem
Action Implementation Through 2012
You Are Here Now!
*
Phase 1 Strategy ApprovedPhase 2 Launch 2008
July 2007
July 2008
©2007 ViTAL Economy, Inc.— 11 —
Executive OverviewExecutive Overview
ACTUAL Client Communities Success Since 1992 (Average)
• 30-40% increase in regional job base over five years
• 25-35% growth in average wage
• 30-40% reduction in rate of poverty
• 20-25% of lowest wage jobs raised by at least $5,000/year
• 20-30% increase in families with health insurance
• 35-50% increase in average wage of new jobs
• 50-90% increase in annual rate of new business formation
• Above average acceleration in growth of gross regional product
• Expanded KBE based innovation economy enabling broadband expansion
• Improved economic diversification and lower economic risk
• Increased access to capital for financing of innovation
©2007 ViTAL Economy, Inc.— 12 —
Executive OverviewExecutive Overview
Connect SI – Overall Logic Flow
Asset Maps help us understand what makes SI
unique!
Opportunity Realized
Measures of Success
Short / Long Term Wins
Connect the Dots
Barriers
Barrier Strategies
Local Opportunity
Local Innovation
Global Innovation
Industry / State
Best Practices
Innovation
Who We Are
Knowledge
The foundation of sustainable economic
growth is building on what makes a region
unique, NOT copying what others are doing
Global Opportunity
©2007 ViTAL Economy, Inc.— 13 —
Executive OverviewExecutive Overview
Asset Maps Focus Opportunity Analysis
• Enables SI to define how indigenous resources make it unique and special
• Identifies resources in economic sub-regions to share across SI
• Helps to filter, prioritize and focus competing economic strategies
• Defines what industry clusters can be home grown based on local assets
• Identifies industry value chain assets to be connected across SI Region
•Natural•Human
•Knowledge•Cultural
•Geographic•Excellence
•Infrastructure•Government
•Natural•Human
•Knowledge•Cultural
•Geographic•Excellence
•Infrastructure•Government
Map Indigenous Assets
++ ==
•Agriculture•Healthcare
•Tourism•Energy
•Manufacturing•Education•KBE Firms•Logistics
•Agriculture•Healthcare
•Tourism•Energy
•Manufacturing•Education•KBE Firms•Logistics
Map Industry Assets
Priority industry clusters with the
greatest ability to deliver economic
growth goals
See: RA Chapter 2
©2007 ViTAL Economy, Inc.— 14 —
Executive OverviewExecutive Overview
What COI’s Learned from Asset Maps
SIU’s 138 year history with students from over 100 cultures positions SI to access expanding global markets which are seeking access to U.S. markets
SIU’s research ‘centers-of-excellence’ in energy, environment, materials and neuroscience perfectly align with global priorities for market growth
SI has a more significant base of workforce development and research university assets to respond to the 10 million worker shortage than other U.S. rural economies
There are more innovation, incubation and entrepreneur assets in SI than anyone imagined; this positions SI to build an Innovation Ecosystem fueling KBE growth
Intermodal logistics assets and heartland location align with the redevelopment and expansion of inland waterway logistics connecting to Midwest logistic gateways
Regional tourism assets are aligned with authentic and active lifestyle tourism trends involving 50-80 million annual tourists in the U.S.
SI’s region has the right mix of assets for attracting the financially independent active retirement demographic, which is fueling the growth of senior living opportunities
SI has a significant base of diversified alternative and traditional energy assets, which if collaboratively organized, provide a basis for a diversified energy sector
Asset Mapping proves SI already has what it needs to drive its own economic destinyAsset Mapping proves SI already has what it needs to drive its own economic destiny
See: RA Chapter 2
©2007 ViTAL Economy, Inc.— 15 —
Executive OverviewExecutive Overview
Southern Illinois — "Garden of the Gods"
Section B: The SI Opportunity and DilemmaThe SI Opportunity and Dilemma
This section compares what SI has going for it versus what’s in the way — painting the picture of the enormous opportunity SI has to transform its economy
Stay cool
©2007 ViTAL Economy, Inc.— 16 —
Executive OverviewExecutive Overview
Regional AssetsRegional Assets
• Heartland of America location, equidistant to 2/3 of U.S. markets, central to economic expansion of the Americas
• SIU - a major R&D university with 138 years of history serving students from over 100 world cultures supports global KBE growth
• Robust education and training resources position SI for global workforce training opportunity
• Mild climate, unique natural environment, active lifestyle assets, arts and culture amenities, and attractive quality of life characteristics are important factors for KBE, tourism and senior living growth
• Inter-modal logistics, transportation and distribution resources have a strong foundation in SI
• SI has plentiful legacy and alternative-energy assets. SI is a coal leader and is strong in 2 of 4 areas of projected alternative energy growth by 2030
• Heartland of America location, equidistant to 2/3 of U.S. markets, central to economic expansion of the Americas
• SIU - a major R&D university with 138 years of history serving students from over 100 world cultures supports global KBE growth
• Robust education and training resources position SI for global workforce training opportunity
• Mild climate, unique natural environment, active lifestyle assets, arts and culture amenities, and attractive quality of life characteristics are important factors for KBE, tourism and senior living growth
• Inter-modal logistics, transportation and distribution resources have a strong foundation in SI
• SI has plentiful legacy and alternative-energy assets. SI is a coal leader and is strong in 2 of 4 areas of projected alternative energy growth by 2030
The BIG SI Opportunity
>$2 BillionNew Annual
Wages
>$2 BillionNew Annual
Wages
41,461 Existing Jobs>$5,000/Yr
41,461 Existing Jobs>$5,000/Yr
27,298 NewHi-Wage Jobs27,298 New
Hi-Wage Jobs
$642 MillionNew KBE Activity
1,600+ Firms
$642 MillionNew KBE Activity
1,600+ Firms
4,500+ Families with Healthcare
Coverage
4,500+ Families with Healthcare
Coverage
Lift 10,000 Citizens Out Of Poverty
Lift 10,000 Citizens Out Of Poverty
$200 Million Information Technology Investment
$200 Million Information Technology Investment
Global & Nat’l TrendsGlobal & Nat’l Trends
• Global growth presents SI with opportunity to accelerate its economic growth from 1.34% to 3.85% per year
• KBE activity now accounts for 50% plus of GDP growth, 3x’s the growth in occupations and pays double the average wage of other jobs
• By 2010, the U.S. will have a 10M worker shortfall requiring strong workforce development resources
• 3 of 4 factors required to support KBE activity in rural America are SI strengths
• 58% of all U.S. and global tourists want authentic active, historic and cultural experiences (50-80 million)
• Logistics is a $900 billion U.S. industry in a global $3.43 trillion market growing at 10-15% per year
• 74% global increase in coal consumption, 138% in coal-to-liquid and 66% in bio-fuels by 2030
• Global growth presents SI with opportunity to accelerate its economic growth from 1.34% to 3.85% per year
• KBE activity now accounts for 50% plus of GDP growth, 3x’s the growth in occupations and pays double the average wage of other jobs
• By 2010, the U.S. will have a 10M worker shortfall requiring strong workforce development resources
• 3 of 4 factors required to support KBE activity in rural America are SI strengths
• 58% of all U.S. and global tourists want authentic active, historic and cultural experiences (50-80 million)
• Logistics is a $900 billion U.S. industry in a global $3.43 trillion market growing at 10-15% per year
• 74% global increase in coal consumption, 138% in coal-to-liquid and 66% in bio-fuels by 2030
++ ==
CSI 2012 Goals*
* These Connect SI Goals were announced to the Public 26 Feb 2007
©2007 ViTAL Economy, Inc.— 17 —
Executive OverviewExecutive Overview
Source: “State of Working Illinois”, by Northern Illinois University (Nov 2005); “21st Century Workforce” (May 2004); IMF; ViTAL Economy research
Ave
rag
e A
nn
ual
G
row
th R
ate
%
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
3.85%
“Stay the Course” vs. “Change the Course”
AAGR Connect SI Goals 2008 - 2012
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
AAGR 1977-2001
Worldwide USA State-wide Southern Illinois
1.34%
2.19%
3.14%
5.62%
2012: increase SI’s economy by $3.6B in GDP to $21.2B, which translates into $162M in additional State and Local tax revenue
2012: increase SI’s economy by $3.6B in GDP to $21.2B, which translates into $162M in additional State and Local tax revenue
Result of Taking Control of SI’s Destiny
©2007 ViTAL Economy, Inc.— 18 —
Executive OverviewExecutive Overview
Highest % in rural region
Highest poverty rate
Highest unemployment
rate since 09/03
Lowest % college
graduates
Highest % enrolled in Medicaid
Highest % age 5+ with a disability
#1 #1 #1 #1 #1 #1Highest % of population over age 65
Highest % age 65+ in
poverty
Highest % age 65+ with a disability
Lowest % of population
0-10
Highest % age 0-17 in
poverty
Highest % households
owner burdened
#1 #1 #1 #1 #1 #4Highest %
households lack
complete plumbing
Highest % households
lacking complete kitchen
Highest % commuting to
work from other IL counties
Lowest % population work and
live in same county
Highest % households
rent burdened
Highest % of Adults with no High School
Diploma
#1 #1 #1 #3 #3 #1
Source: IL Poverty Summit, “2004 Report on Illinois Poverty,” Based on U.S. 2000 Census or IL Dept of Employment Security data & Atlas of Illinois Poverty Spring 2003
Result Of Not Taking Control Of SI’s Destiny
Southern Illinois Ranking: 2004 Report on Illinois Poverty
©2007 ViTAL Economy, Inc.— 19 —
Executive OverviewExecutive Overview
“We lose the best and brightest, because SI adults tell our children that there will be no 21st century opportunity in SI”
Losing Your Future Workforce SIU and the community colleges
generate an above average 20-30 year old population
This young population leaves the region for more attractive opportunities, despite SI having resources that should help retain them
Increasing Your Burden Losing the most productive age
group while increasing the resource-demanding demographic
Source: U.S. Census Bureau – Table QT-P1: Age Groups and Sex: 2000 and RA Interviews
0.00%
1.00%
2.00%
3.00%
4.00%
5.00%
6.00%
7.00%
8.00%
9.00%
under 515 to 1930 to 3440 to 4960 to 6475 to 79
90+
Proportion of Population (%)
SI Illinois
Age Distribution Comparison
Increasing Your Burden
Losing Your
Future Workforce
All is not lost — SI needs a Youth Retention Strategy
All is not lost — SI needs a Youth Retention Strategy
©2007 ViTAL Economy, Inc.— 20 —
Executive OverviewExecutive Overview
• Limiting mindset: willingness to accept mediocrity and lack of a sense of excellence
• Insufficient climate of collaboration and trust, making change very difficult
• Continued belief that “the cavalry is coming” despite proof to the contrary
• Losing the best and brightest — youth brain drain• Lack of participation in the global economy• Continued focus on traditional economic sectors
in decline rather than rising economic sectors• Climate of economic (and community) despair• Public policy reinforces & funds old economy
strategies, and inhibits new ones
SI’s Big Dilemma:Climate of Limited Opportunity
Resulted in only 1.35%
AAGR for last 25 Years
Resulted in only 1.35%
AAGR for last 25 Years
SI’s future hangs in the balance!SI’s future hangs in the balance!
• Fragmented and poorly leveraged
• Primary focus on local opportunities
• Insufficient # of visionary leaders
• Too many boundaries
Issues Weighing
Down SI
Indigenous
Resources &
Innate Talents
©2007 ViTAL Economy, Inc.— 21 —
Executive OverviewExecutive Overview
• Less willingness to accept mediocrity• Improving climate of collaboration and
trust making change less difficult• Losing fewer of the best and brightest• Less focus on traditional economic
sectors in decline • Less of a climate of economic despair• Public policy/funding priorities shifting
SI’s Potential:Climate of Unlimited Opportunity
• Linked across the region & highly leveraged
• Active visionary leaders• Collaboration abounds• Boundaries are being
crossed• New behaviors• Global focus
Issues Weighing Down SI Indigenous Resources &InnateTalents
Results in over 3.85% or
better AAGR for NEXT 25
Years
Results in over 3.85% or
better AAGR for NEXT 25
Years
Growth & prosperity realized!Growth & prosperity realized!
©2007 ViTAL Economy, Inc.— 22 —
Executive OverviewExecutive Overview
Southern Illinois — "Garden of the Gods"
Section C: State, National and Global Trends and State, National and Global Trends and
Implications for SIImplications for SI
Translating the most relevant trends into potential new jobs for the region
Stay cool
©2007 ViTAL Economy, Inc.— 23 —
Executive OverviewExecutive Overview
Chapter 1:State, National & Global Trends
1.01 Globalization: The World is Flat
1.02 eCommerce & Connectivity
1.03 KBE and Innovation
1.04 Livable Communities
1.05 Transformation of U.S. Economy
1.06 Manpower & Immigration
1.07 Aging Population
1.08 Tourism
1.09 Logistics, Transportation & Distribution
1.10 Energy
1.11 Sustainable Economies
1.12 Conclusions
Rural communities typically focus on their local geographic area and have limited insight into the larger world around them. This chapter provides key trend information and what it means for Southern Illinois. Each of these trends represents potential opportunities for Connect SI.
FYI: From the RA Itself
©2007 ViTAL Economy, Inc.— 24 —
Executive OverviewExecutive Overview
Potential SI Jobs by Sector (1 of 2)
• Global growth opens up opportunities to expand SI economy beyond its traditional growth rate
• 10 million U.S. worker shortage is an opportunity for SI workforce development resources
• Growth in services exports enable SI to move away from uncompetitive legacy economic activities
• Global growth opens up opportunities to expand SI economy beyond its traditional growth rate
• 10 million U.S. worker shortage is an opportunity for SI workforce development resources
• Growth in services exports enable SI to move away from uncompetitive legacy economic activities
ICT investments contribute 33% to U.S. productivity
growth…this validates importance of NPCOI
SI’s 64% increase in broadband access can better
leverage six-fold increase in e-commerce activity
4 of 5** factors in rural KBE growth are SI strengths
— need to be leveraged for SI economic growth Livable community assets present in SI are an
attraction asset for KBE, Senior Living and Tourism Alternative energy, global warming and “greening”
of society is creating innovation opportunities
ICT investments contribute 33% to U.S. productivity
growth…this validates importance of NPCOI
SI’s 64% increase in broadband access can better
leverage six-fold increase in e-commerce activity
4 of 5** factors in rural KBE growth are SI strengths
— need to be leveraged for SI economic growth Livable community assets present in SI are an
attraction asset for KBE, Senior Living and Tourism Alternative energy, global warming and “greening”
of society is creating innovation opportunities
See: RA Chapter 1
**Five Factors are: • High Quality Workforce• College or Universities• Local Amenities• Transportation Infrastructure• Size
KBE
8,023New Jobs
KBE
8,023New Jobs
Global Workforce
Opportunities
18,750New Jobs
Global Workforce
Opportunities
18,750New Jobs
©2007 ViTAL Economy, Inc.— 25 —
Executive OverviewExecutive Overview
Potential SI Jobs by Sector (2 of 2)
Climate of Economic Opportunity = an additional 10,210 new jobsNEW GRAND TOTAL = 50,789 Jobs (vs. 27,298 Jobs Feb ‘07)
Climate of Economic Opportunity = an additional 10,210 new jobsNEW GRAND TOTAL = 50,789 Jobs (vs. 27,298 Jobs Feb ‘07)
See: RA Chapter 1
• 77 million retiring baby boomers present an affluent
senior living growth opportunity for SI
• 77 million retiring baby boomers present an affluent
senior living growth opportunity for SI
• Preferred tourism growth sectors indicate SI is
positioned for accelerated tourism growth
• Preferred tourism growth sectors indicate SI is
positioned for accelerated tourism growth
SI energy assets and knowledge are in the sweet spot of energy priorities for growth
SI energy assets and knowledge are in the sweet spot of energy priorities for growth
Significant transportation labor shortages are moving transportation and distribution centers from the coast to the center of North America. SI location and logistics assets position it for growth
Significant transportation labor shortages are moving transportation and distribution centers from the coast to the center of North America. SI location and logistics assets position it for growth
Senior Living
3,676New Jobs
Senior Living
3,676New Jobs
Energy & Mining5,680
New Jobs
Energy & Mining5,680
New Jobs
Tourism4,450
New Jobs
Tourism4,450
New Jobs
Log/Trans//Dist1,675
New Jobs
Log/Trans//Dist1,675
New Jobs
©2007 ViTAL Economy, Inc.— 26 —
Executive OverviewExecutive Overview
Southern Illinois — "Garden of the Gods"
Section D: Assessing SI’s Climate to Support GrowthAssessing SI’s Climate to Support Growth
There is good news and bad news about what SI has in place — focused onEnabling Environment, Innovation & Tech-Transfer, and Competitiveness.
VE assessments are based on primary research (interviews), secondary research (regional, national & global studies), best practices, and our professional experience
Stay cool
©2007 ViTAL Economy, Inc.— 27 —
Executive OverviewExecutive Overview
Enabling Environment: VE Assessment
Chapter 3 of the RA assesses several Enabling Environment Criteria
(summarized here)
Climate of Collaboration
Regulatory, Policy & Governance
Business Climate
Broadband Access & Penetration
Livable Communities
Adaptability to Change
Global Focus
Visionary Leadership Depth & Breadth
Climate of Opportunity
WEAK
IMPROVING
GOOD
AVERAGE
STRONG
See: RA Chapter 3
©2007 ViTAL Economy, Inc.— 28 —
Executive OverviewExecutive Overview
Enabling Environment: Implications
Lack of collaboration is hampering prosperity Creates a climate of distrust and conflict Results in an inability to fund or achieve project success due to lack of resources
Unattractive business climate for retention and attraction IL’s court system is rated as unreasonable to business Multiple government and taxing districts cause a confusing business environment
Telecommunications expansion is a marketable opportunity The recent expansion of broadband service, supported by a clearly defined goal is positioning SI
for KBE growth and attraction
SI’s natural environment is not valued enough or being leveraged The region has the largest concentration of natural environment assets in mid-America SI is missing out on substantial tourism, senior living, KBE and other revenues
Reluctance to change will perpetuate an atmosphere of dependency The global economy is changing faster than ever before, primarily driven by innovation and
technological advancements that will not wait for individuals and companies to keep pace Rural regional economies that can effectively meet the workforce needs and business demands
of a KBE economy will be the envy of others
Lack of visionary leadership will keep SI on the same low-growth economic path A larger core group of champions must step forward and lead the change for SI
©2007 ViTAL Economy, Inc.— 29 —
Executive OverviewExecutive Overview
Enabling Environment: SI Citizens See the Stark Reality
So many things in SI are one-person, one-business or one-organization thin
Local population does not want their neighbors to be too successful
SI is a risk-averse region — if you are too successful, we criticize you and assume success was obtained dishonestly; if you fail you are branded as a
failure for life
There is a significant lack of unity across the community, including churches, local governments, schools, business interests, etc.; at the municipal level,
decisions are based on emotion rather than facts
We lack a vision of success — we prefer to dwell on our failures
Overlapping government at the local and regional level gets in the way of success. Our parochial interests win out over our economic interests
People here seem to be afraid to take a chance. They have a great fear of failure. They are deeply concerned at how they will be perceived. This leads
to a lack of action. It maintains the status quo
If you going to be poor, this is the place to be
Source: RA & EF Hutton Interviews; See: RA Chapter 3Note: Quotes in this RA from interviews & other sources are shown as centered italics
©2007 ViTAL Economy, Inc.— 30 —
Executive OverviewExecutive Overview
Fertile Ground to Change
SI citizens across the Region do see the stark reality and understand what needs to change
The good news: Awareness of this reality goes far and wide Folks, young and old, want SI, as a region, to finally deal with this
The bad news: There is a deeply held belief that neither individuals, nor SI as a whole, will change Far too many lifelong SI residents have become numb to the decades of gradual
decline in so many communities SI is at a crossroads — and there are reasons for hope:
The concept of One Region-One Vision is gaining traction There are pockets of prosperity — so it can be done Short-term wins across SI are providing further “proof” that the collaborative
approach works — building momentum is key The TIME is now; the CHOICE is yours — all it takes is will and leadership
If you’re going to have a self-fulfilling prophecy, let’s make it a great one!If you’re going to have a self-fulfilling prophecy, let’s make it a great one!
See: RA Chapter 3
©2007 ViTAL Economy, Inc.— 31 —
Executive OverviewExecutive Overview
RA Chapter 4 provides a detailed assessment of SI’s Climate for Innovation and Entrepreneurship, summarized here:
Entrepreneurship Culture and Networks
Financial Literacy
Existence of Early Stage Capital for Startups
Rate of Business Startups
Partnerships and Community Outreach
Technology Transfer, Licensing and Commercialization
Entrepreneurship Development and Tracking
Space and Facility Support Services
WEAK
IMPROVING
GOOD
AVERAGE
STRONG
See: RA Chapter 5
SI Innovation, Entrepreneurship & Incubation: VE Assessment
©2007 ViTAL Economy, Inc.— 32 —
Executive OverviewExecutive Overview
SI Innovation, Entrepreneurship & Incubation: Implications
Entrepreneurship culture and networks Entrepreneurship is not seen as a “real job” — this suppresses a spirit of innovation
Financial literacy Limited risk assessment capacity for KBE soft asset business startups — this limits access to capital Entrepreneurs understanding of equity & debt is low — this results in poor deal flow quality
Partnerships and community outreach are centered in Carbondale A regional climate of innovation can not be achieved when the vast majority of resources are
centralized Underperformance of technology transfer, licensing and commercialization
SI cannot grow regional KBE innovation firms without regional access to SIU tech-transfer assets Disconnected entrepreneurship development and tracking systems
The Region’s business support services are not linked — result is KBE firms leave SI or innovations die on the vine
Lack of business startup-tracking demonstrates lack of policy commitment to entrepreneurship SI cannot manage what it cannot track or measure
Limited and unconnected incubation space and facility support services Incubation resources cannot supply diverse expertise needs of young emerging KBEs Incubator firms are not linked to potential value-chain partners in other parts of SI
Innovation knowledge is silo-based, not shared and, therefore, not leveraged
See: RA Chapter 5
©2007 ViTAL Economy, Inc.— 33 —
Executive OverviewExecutive Overview
Climate of Innovation, Entrepreneurship and Incubation
Climate of Innovation*:Zero-sum game mentality exists in the way of collaboration or
even basic idea sharing — we are fragmented, jealous and secretive and motivated by risk aversion
Climate of Entrepreneurship:• Entrepreneurship is not considered to be a “real job”
• Entrepreneurs exist but mostly underground
• Early stage capital is limited, access is not well known
• Research focus at SIUC: high potential for more tech transfer
• Entrepreneur development resources in SI are very limited
• Support systems for entrepreneurs need bolstering
Climate of Incubation*:There are too few, unconnected incubation resources and staff
— have limited budgets and business experience; several incubated firms left SI to get access to a system of support
SIU is one of the top 100 Research Universities in the U.S — 67% of SIU business and engineering students want to stay in SI —
SIU presents an opportunity to address SI’s KBE Worker Gap
SIU is one of the top 100 Research Universities in the U.S — 67% of SIU business and engineering students want to stay in SI —
SIU presents an opportunity to address SI’s KBE Worker Gap
*Source of Quotes: RA & EF Hutton Interviews; chart data from BLS; Note: quotes are shown centered in italics
0
2
4
6
8
10
U.S. IL SI
The KBE Worker Gap:SI is well below the State and National
Averages for KBE as % of total employment
7.7%
8.5%
4.3%
Gap
©2007 ViTAL Economy, Inc.— 34 —
Executive OverviewExecutive Overview
Economic Growth Can Be Greatly Stimulated by Implementing an Innovation Eco-System™
SI Incubator, Finance & Innovation Starfish Network
— the KBE-Engine of Connect SI —
SI Entrepreneurs Served by SharedRegional Network
Of Incubator Centers of Excellence
Life Cycle Equity and Debt
Finance Resources
Global Best PracticeTechnical Support
Teams
Broadband-Enabled
SI Entrepreneurs Served by SharedRegional Network
Of Incubator Centers of Excellence
Life Cycle Equity and Debt
Finance Resources
Global Best PracticeTechnical Support
Teams
Broadband-Enabled
W. FrankfortBusinessIncubator
GE IncubatorTech Transfer
Dixon SpringsAg-Tech Incubator
SWI Retail Incubator
Edwardsville
Ethanol Research
Center
SIU MedicalSchool
GW Incubator
Coal ResearchCenter
S5 SBDC
SE SBDC
EntrepreneurCenter
Centralia EC
SIUE-EC
IMEC
MedicalTechnologyIncubator
InternationalIncubator
See: RA Chapter 4
©2007 ViTAL Economy, Inc.— 35 —
Executive OverviewExecutive Overview
SI Competitiveness: VE Assessment
RA Chapter 5 provides a detailed assessment of SI’s competitiveness,
summarized here:
Global Market Readiness
Climate for Investment Attraction
Workforce
Knowledge Infrastructure
Location Advantages
Connectivity LiteracyWEAK
IMPROVING
GOOD
AVERAGE
STRONG
See: RA Chapter 5
The lack of Global Market Readiness is holding back the region from leveraging its Knowledge Infrastructure and Location Advantages to build a high growth economy
The lack of Global Market Readiness is holding back the region from leveraging its Knowledge Infrastructure and Location Advantages to build a high growth economy
©2007 ViTAL Economy, Inc.— 36 —
Executive OverviewExecutive Overview
SI Competitiveness: Implications
Limited Global Market Participation $1 billion export gap: 2.4% of SI GRP vs. 8.4% of the Illinois GSP participates in the global economy Global market niches exist in energy technologies, bio-ag, int’l innovation and incubation, logistics, etc.
Cloudy Climate for Investment Attraction Long history of a weak, trailing economy and reputation of inferiority limits SI’s ability to attract investment Livable community standards are a fundamental requirement for investment attraction Targeted, consistent & authentic communications/marketing can shift the internal and external perceptions of SI
Solid and Improving Workforce SI’s 66.5% labor participation rate challenges the region’s growth opportunities The incumbent workforce has a strong work ethic and desire to stay in the SI region SI’s extensive workforce development assets are positioned to help address the projected U.S. 10M worker shortfall
Robust Knowledge Infrastructure SI already has a broad array of knowledge assets, but needs to better align towards a common strategic direction An education Center of Excellence could coalesce regional KBE resources to pursue global workforce opportunities
Strong Location Advantages SI is in a geographic “sweet spot” to take advantage of major trends SI’s location advantage benefits Tourism, Energy, and Transportation, Logistics & Warehousing sectors
Improving Global Connectivity Readiness SI has begun to transform its connectivity infrastructure but has low connectivity awareness and literacy Linking NP-COI with all industry clusters can help identify applications to increase competitiveness and market-share
Only as a unified region can SI leverage the critical mass already in place to become a formidable force on the global stage
Only as a unified region can SI leverage the critical mass already in place to become a formidable force on the global stage
See: RA Chapter 5
GRP = Gross Regional ProductGSP = Gross State Product
©2007 ViTAL Economy, Inc.— 37 —
Executive OverviewExecutive Overview
Southern Illinois — "Garden of the Gods"
Section E: Community of Interest (COI) Perspective Community of Interest (COI) Perspective
and Goalsand Goals
Laying out the key demographic and economic picture of SI as a whole and acknowledging thesignificant work from each of the six Communities of Interest (COIs), as well as “What’s In It for Me?”
Step back and think about SI as a major metropolitan community made up of individual neighborhoods —it is the uniqueness of each neighborhood, when combined to make a large whole,
that creates a unique sense of personality that we call Minneapolis, Memphis, Boston, San Francisco, etc. When you says these names and close your eyes certain images, impressions, and characteristics come to mind.
It is called the Voice and Personality of a Brand — this is where SI needs to go
Stay cool
©2007 ViTAL Economy, Inc.— 38 —
Executive OverviewExecutive Overview
Regional Perspective… SI is a Potential Giant if it Acts as a Unified Region
Population Over 425,000 residents in the region, comparable
to a single major city SI represents 3.3% of total IL population Median age higher in SI (37.5) than state (34.7) 61% of population is in Greater Egypt making SI
unbalanced 1980-2005 Cumulative Population Trend
SI = (-3.0%) Declined! Illinois = +11.6% U.S. = +30.5%
Labor Force Region average wages are almost 40% lower
than the state average SI region has a 66.5% labor force participation rate,
10% below Illinois Meaning that 24,995 are employable, but for one
reason or another they are not employed
Economy SI has a $17.6B economy
SI economy is 3.47% of State GSP Largest sector of SI GRP is government 20% (11% IL) 64% of SI GRP is in Greater Egypt 3% of SI landmass is urban & built
Exports Exports are only 1% of state level at $420M
8.4% of IL’s GDP is exports vs. only 2.4% for SI Matching IL’s level would mean +$1.06B
See: RA Chapter 6Sources: U.S.Census Bureau, BEA, & Dept of Commerce
2006 Government Transfer Payments as % of Total Earnings
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
% of Total Earnings
Southern Five Southeastern
Greater Wabash Greater Egypt
SI
IL
U.S.
-5%0%5%
10%15%20%25%30%35%
USILSI
Cumulative Population Trend (1980 – 2005)
30.5%
11.6%
(-3.0%)
©2007 ViTAL Economy, Inc.— 39 —
Executive OverviewExecutive Overview
Only 46% of SI Personal Income is Generated by Private Sector Employment
Conclusions:
• SI cannot afford the community and economy it wants
• A 30% increase in private vs. public sector earnings is required to equal U.S.
• Low % of at-risk sources of personal income creates a risk-averse environment
0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
70%
Private SectorPayroll & Benefits
Transfer Payments,All Gov't &
Education Earnings
U.S.
IL
SI
54%
33%36%
46%
67%64%
Increasing private sector % of personal income generation is critical to building a climate of innovation
Increasing private sector % of personal income generation is critical to building a climate of innovation
©2007 ViTAL Economy, Inc.— 40 —
Executive OverviewExecutive OverviewSI Needs Investment Attraction: Exports
SI gap in exports (vs. Illinois) is its biggest opportunity to fill the pool
SI gap in exports (vs. Illinois) is its biggest opportunity to fill the pool
$$$
IMPORT ACTIVITIES— Take $ Out —
bring in goods and services to serve the needs and
desires of the community; but capital flows out
EXPORT ACTIVITIES*— Helps Fill the Pool —
bring money into the region by selling goods and/or services of value and
importance to national or international markets
SI Economy
*Exports are the only source of new
capital that the region can use to pay for goods and services to meet its needs and desires
$$$
CONSUMER SERVICES SECTOR— Circulates $ Locally —
activities that directly and indirectly address the consumption demands of
the local residents
$$$
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
Exports as a % ofGDP
U.S.
Illinois
SI
11%
8.4%
2.4%
©2007 ViTAL Economy, Inc.— 41 —
Executive OverviewExecutive Overview
Connect SI: Phase 1 Roadmap
See: RA Chapter 6
Greater Egypt COI Strategy
Southeastern COI Strategy
Southern Five COI Strategy
Greater Wabash COI Strategy
Phase 1 Outcomes
GIS Asset Maps
Broadband Strategy
Economic Benchmarks
Regional Economic Strategy
Healthcare Strategy
Regional EconomicFramework
Five-Year Measurable Goals
Implementation &Funding Plan
GIS Mapping Team Supports COI’s
Connect SIRegional CED COIStrategy
HealthcareProviders
COI Strategy
Network Providers
COI Strategy
VALUE-ADDED RESEARCH: Regional Economic Model, Healthcare Economic Model, Incubation, Research Park and Entrepreneurship Assessment, 20-county Readiness Assessment
>$2 BillionNew Annual
Wages
41,461 Existing Jobs>$5,000/Yr
27,298 NewHi-Wage Jobs
$642 MillionNew KBE Activity
1,600+ Firms
+4500 Families with Healthcare
Coverage
Lift 10,000 Citizens Out Of Poverty
$200 Million Information Technology Investment
2012 Goals
©2007 ViTAL Economy, Inc.— 42 —
Executive OverviewExecutive Overview
COI Perspective: Southern 5
Challenges:• Lack of skilled workforce for
current and future jobs • Lack of cooperation,
collaboration, and regionalism
• Does the region have the assets to grow and retain tech based jobs?
• No sense of urgency• K-12 performance
Opportunities:• Geography, logistics and
transportation • Community College System
and SIU• Local healthcare availability• Tourism, bed & breakfast,
Shawnee National Forest, historical assets, wineries
• Agribusiness opportunities (e.g., ethanol)
Sense of Urgency•Changing our mindset — how we view poverty!
•Stop the bleeding — put a triage process in place for the economy, now!
•How will your children grow up and where will they go?
Sense of Urgency•Changing our mindset — how we view poverty!
•Stop the bleeding — put a triage process in place for the economy, now!
•How will your children grow up and where will they go?
S5 COI 2012 Goals
$90.3 M in New Wages
784 New Jobs @$43,500
4,863 Existing JobsRaised by $5,000/Year
522 jobs at New Average Wage $36,517
Increase Youth Retention:6.9% to 7.2% (15-19yrs)
18.7% to 21.5% (20-34yrs)
Reduce PovertyFrom 14.5% to 12.5%
S5 COI 2012 Goals
$90.3 M in New Wages
784 New Jobs @$43,500
4,863 Existing JobsRaised by $5,000/Year
522 jobs at New Average Wage $36,517
Increase Youth Retention:6.9% to 7.2% (15-19yrs)
18.7% to 21.5% (20-34yrs)
Reduce PovertyFrom 14.5% to 12.5%
2004 2012
Population 58,664 63,000
Total Employed 24,317 26,856
Average Wage $27,959 $37,591
Total Wages $679.9M $1.01B
Regional Economic Benchmarks
See: RA Chapter 6
©2007 ViTAL Economy, Inc.— 43 —
Executive OverviewExecutive Overview
COI Perspective: Southeastern
Sense of Urgency• We MUST stop the decline, we are
asleep at the wheel.
• Shock Value: “If you are going to be poor, this is the place to be!”
• What is our legacy going to be for our children? There is declining infrastructure, tax base declining, demographics getting worse
• WHAT CAN BE? We need to paint a compelling picture of the future
Sense of Urgency• We MUST stop the decline, we are
asleep at the wheel.
• Shock Value: “If you are going to be poor, this is the place to be!”
• What is our legacy going to be for our children? There is declining infrastructure, tax base declining, demographics getting worse
• WHAT CAN BE? We need to paint a compelling picture of the future
Challenges:• Get local gov’t officials involved • Reverse population decline• Increase tax revenue base• Increase average wage• Change age demographic• Increase incentives for broadband
penetration in the rural areas• Low awareness of ICT benefits• Create a more diversified economy• Overcome apathetic attitudes• Limited affordable housing
Opportunities:• Get county boards & city councils
engaged• Show local stakeholders that they
have a “VOICE”!• Further enhance working
relationships with other communities
• Become a positive place to live, work and play
• Promote area as an affordable place to live
• Challenge negative thinking• Promote and develop self-reliance
in our community• Foster entrepreneurship
2004 2012
Population 49,454 56,000
Total Employed 21,903 25,500
Average Wage 27,494 40,276
Total Wages $602.2M $1,027B
Regional Economic Benchmarks
SE COI2007-2012 Goals
2,158 New Jobs @$43,500
4,380 Existing JobsRaised by $5,000/Year
1,438 jobs at the new average wage
$40,276
34% Private Payer Healthcare %
$500M EAV Tax Base
Broadband Penetration Rate – 50%
$44,420,000 Tourism Expenditures
$180,000 Regional Room Tax Revenues
SE COI2007-2012 Goals
2,158 New Jobs @$43,500
4,380 Existing JobsRaised by $5,000/Year
1,438 jobs at the new average wage
$40,276
34% Private Payer Healthcare %
$500M EAV Tax Base
Broadband Penetration Rate – 50%
$44,420,000 Tourism Expenditures
$180,000 Regional Room Tax Revenues
See: RA Chapter 6
©2007 ViTAL Economy, Inc.— 44 —
Executive OverviewExecutive Overview
COI Perspective: Greater Wabash
Sense of Urgency• Population decline — educate them but
they leave• More jobs outside of the area• Lost appreciation of the area• Rekindling the romance for the area:
o The Beauty of the place that we liveo Our quality of lifeo The positive attitude of the area
• “Live, Work, Play and Stay in Southern Illinois” — and create excellence generation to generation
• Prosper in spite of Springfield!• Stop the population drain — what we can
do now!
Sense of Urgency• Population decline — educate them but
they leave• More jobs outside of the area• Lost appreciation of the area• Rekindling the romance for the area:
o The Beauty of the place that we liveo Our quality of lifeo The positive attitude of the area
• “Live, Work, Play and Stay in Southern Illinois” — and create excellence generation to generation
• Prosper in spite of Springfield!• Stop the population drain — what we can
do now!
Challenges:• Spirit of poverty!• Youth brain drain• Need to change our attitude• No collaboration between risk
takers• Lack of discussion due to
territorial battles• Lack of appreciation of
business by public officials
Opportunities:• Take control of our own destiny• Tap our youth — get them
engaged in this process• Publicize our great assets —
what makes us unique• Tie colleges to skill needs;
educate our parents! • Leverage our renewable
resources in this area; not just raw exports — invest in non-renewable as well
• Fill key gaps (e.g., need Pediatrics, Obstetrics); lots of ripple effects
GW COI2007-2012 Goals
1,381 New Jobs @$43,500
5,280 Existing JobsRaised by $5,000/Year
920 jobs at the new average wage
$36,517
$36,406 Per Capital Income
GW COI2007-2012 Goals
1,381 New Jobs @$43,500
5,280 Existing JobsRaised by $5,000/Year
920 jobs at the new average wage
$36,517
$36,406 Per Capital Income2004 2012
Population 51,421 53,000
Total Employed 26,400 27,746
Average Wage $26,311 $36,517
Total Wages $694.6M $1.013B
Regional Economic Benchmarks
See: RA Chapter 6
©2007 ViTAL Economy, Inc.— 45 —
Executive OverviewExecutive Overview
COI Perspective: Greater Egypt
Challenges:• Culture of poverty• Increase average wage• Reverse population decline• Youth brain drain• 2000 recent dislocated workers• Lack of quality and
commitment of leadership• Weak region wide
communication• Limited access to public and
private capital
Opportunities:• Highly educated population• Technology transfer from
educational facilities• Quality of place• Energy sector: coal, alternative
fuels, etc.• Value-added agriculture• Foreign student population• Workforce Development
•Man-Tra-Con•SIU & Community Colleges•State and Federal programs
Sense of Urgency•We have got to break the cycle of hopelessness!
•Don’t tell me what we can’t do – tell me what WE CAN do!
Sense of Urgency•We have got to break the cycle of hopelessness!
•Don’t tell me what we can’t do – tell me what WE CAN do!
GE COI2007-2012 Goals
10,468 New Jobs @$43,500
26,937 Existing JobsRaised by $5,000/Year
6,979 jobs at the new average wage
$40,765
Educational Degree Attainment
High School 85.3%Bachelor 25.2%
17.1% Youth Retention (20-29 age group)
12% Poverty Rate
GE COI2007-2012 Goals
10,468 New Jobs @$43,500
26,937 Existing JobsRaised by $5,000/Year
6,979 jobs at the new average wage
$40,765
Educational Degree Attainment
High School 85.3%Bachelor 25.2%
17.1% Youth Retention (20-29 age group)
12% Poverty Rate
2004 2012
Population 253,049 274,432
Total Employed 134,685 157,787
Average Wage $27,830 $40,765
Total Wages $3.7B $6.4B
Regional Economic Benchmarks
See: RA Chapter 6
©2007 ViTAL Economy, Inc.— 46 —
Executive OverviewExecutive Overview
COI Perspective: Network Providers
Source: Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) Broadband Statistics Dec 2005 (Survey of 14 Countries);Pew Internet and American Life Project — Rural Broadband Internet Use Feb 2006
COI Observations:• Competitors have become collaborators• Through collaboration, Connect SI has identified
even more resources and possibilities to improve broadband penetration
• Resources are greater than originally perceived• Connect SI is the focal point:
• Sharing maps and resources• Common goals
COI Results (2006-2007):• Created a demand driven customer aggregation
model generating thousands of open-access sales leads (www.iwantmybroadband.com)
• Over 35+ small towns have received broadband
• Over $24M+ in new private sector broadband infrastructure
• Reached 16% Penetration and 41% Broadband Coverage after only 18 months (starting point was 12% and 25% respectively)
COI Results (2006-2007):• Created a demand driven customer aggregation
model generating thousands of open-access sales leads (www.iwantmybroadband.com)
• Over 35+ small towns have received broadband
• Over $24M+ in new private sector broadband infrastructure
• Reached 16% Penetration and 41% Broadband Coverage after only 18 months (starting point was 12% and 25% respectively)
Executive OverviewExecutive Overview
See: RA Chapter 6
25-to-85% Broadband
Coverage
12-to-54% Penetration
25-to-85% Broadband
Coverage
12-to-54% Penetration
2012 Goals:
0.00
10.00
20.00
30.00
40.00
50.00
60.00
2005
Southern Illinois USA-rural
USA-average #1 in World
% P
enet
rati
on
of
Po
pu
lati
on
12%
24%
34%
54%Network
Provider COI has set an ambitious
goal to increase the
SI penetration rate to world class levels!
©2007 ViTAL Economy, Inc.— 47 —
Executive OverviewExecutive Overview
COI Perspective: Healthcare
COI Vision:Supporting the collaboration and interconnection among healthcare providers and patients to improve:
Healthcare access Health outcomes Provider profitability The qualified healthcare
workforce in Southern Illinois
COI Vision:Supporting the collaboration and interconnection among healthcare providers and patients to improve:
Healthcare access Health outcomes Provider profitability The qualified healthcare
workforce in Southern Illinois
Jobs Earnings GDP
Direct SI impacts 4,676 $214.7M $260.3M
Indirect and induced 2,408 $75.4M $156.3M
TOTAL 7,084 $282.3M $424.5M
COI Results:• Two state healthcare pilot
projects initiated and managed locally
• Collaborate nursing workforce solutions underway
• Prescription Drug Monitoring System
COI Results:• Two state healthcare pilot
projects initiated and managed locally
• Collaborate nursing workforce solutions underway
• Prescription Drug Monitoring System
Potential Impact of New Healthcare Positions by 2012:
Impact of Healthcare GoalsImpact of Healthcare Goals
Desired SI Future State 2012
Desired SI Future State 2012
1. Economic growth will
improve payer mix
1. Economic growth will
improve payer mix
2. New health jobs will promote
economic growth
2. New health jobs will promote
economic growth
Insured population +10%
Medicaid -26%
Medicare +18%
Uninsured -32%Uninsured -32%
Executive OverviewExecutive Overview
See: RA Chapter 6
©2007 ViTAL Economy, Inc.— 48 —
Executive OverviewExecutive Overview
COI Views: What’s In This for Me?
My family gets to stay together, my kids don't even think of leaving because of all the opportunity, self-esteem, and pride in our community
We go from surviving to thriving
The inhibitive walls ALL come crashing down — the boundaries created by narrow-thinking, local rivalry, fighting over crumbs and the belief that
‘poverty-is-an-unaddressable-fact-of-life’
I will be linked into this wonderful collaborative network & infrastructure, yet feel this amazing sense of creative freedom
I want my three valedictorian sons to come back home!
Executive OverviewExecutive Overview
See: RA Chapter 6; quotes are from RA & EF Hutton interviews
©2007 ViTAL Economy, Inc.— 49 —
Executive OverviewExecutive OverviewPerspective — Connect SI
Bottom Line:
“Until everyone involved sees and believes that this effort is the most important initiative that Southern
Illinois has ever undertaken, it will be relegated to a hobby that folks do in
their spare time”- RA Interview
Executive OverviewExecutive Overview
©2007 ViTAL Economy, Inc.— 50 —
Executive OverviewExecutive Overview
Southern Illinois — "Garden of the Gods"
Section F: Connect SI: Crossing the BoundariesConnect SI: Crossing the Boundaries
Executive OverviewExecutive Overview
• Summarizes key findings of RA • Assesses SI readiness to pursue a long term strategy that will transform the SI economy
• Provides recommendations for moving forward
©2007 ViTAL Economy, Inc.— 51 —
Executive OverviewExecutive Overview
Progress Towards One Region-One Vision: Last 16 Months
1,000+ Connect SI participants have worked toward building a foundation for hope through investment of tens of thousands of service hours
Collaborative funding from local governments, corporations, NGO’s, higher education institutions, small and large healthcare systems, state and federal agencies attests to the desire to achieve a regional vision for a robust SI future
Network provider collaboration has increased broadband availability by 64% across the Connect SI Region through over $24 million of private investments
Healthcare provider collaboration has achieved significant progress towards addressing critical skills shortages and improved health outcomes by prioritizing cooperation over competition
Connect SI asset mapping has enabled COI’s to uncover opportunities to collaborate across the SI region that would have never before been possible. This has led to numerous short term wins and long-term strategies for growth
Executive OverviewExecutive Overview
©2007 ViTAL Economy, Inc.— 52 —
Executive OverviewExecutive Overview
Barriers to One Region-One Vision: Last 16 Months
Breaking old behaviors in terms of continued reliance on state and federal resources as primary sources of capital to fund long-term initiatives rather than prioritize collaborative funding alliances at the local level
Critical mass of Connect SI champions has not yet been achieved — need to triple its champions to >3,000 active participants, who believe that a climate of economic opportunity is possible for Southern Illinois
Imbedded focus of funding, policy and behaviors on industrial attraction, and big employment announcements as the solution to economic growth vs. growing small employer KBE firms (21st century growth engines) that don’t garner big headlines
Limited recognition of the depth, breadth and length of commitment needed at the leadership, citizen, government, business and media levels to transform a limited growth old economy into an innovation growth economy of unlimited opportunity
Insufficient commitment of the time, talent and resources of existing leadership to the expansion of next generation leadership and to growing the skills necessary to collaboratively lead Southern Illinois to become One Region with One Vision
Executive OverviewExecutive Overview
©2007 ViTAL Economy, Inc.— 53 —
Executive OverviewExecutive Overview
Actions Fundamental to SI Economic Prosperity (1 of 2)
Address SI Dilemma — transition from a climate of limited potential to unlimited opportunity
SI citizens must believe that they have the ability to take control of their destiny Education of SI uniqueness and opportunity is critical to turning belief into action
Increase SI’s private sector contribution from 46% to national level of 65%; reduce SI’s dependence on public sector income from 54% to national level of 36% by 2012
Critical to establish an SI climate of innovation versus a climate of risk-aversion Requires a 30% increase in private sector wage contribution to personal income
Improve global export literacy and double global export value in SI’s economy Required to increase flow of external capital into SI…Investment Attraction Leverages SI indigenous resources…Sow Our Own to Grow Our Own
Implement economic strategies to grow SI economy at 3.85% vs 1.34% annually Increased prosperity is dependent on accelerated growth SI infrastructure investments cannot be met without increasing economic growth
Executive OverviewExecutive Overview
©2007 ViTAL Economy, Inc.— 54 —
Executive OverviewExecutive Overview
Actions Fundamental to SI Economic Prosperity (2 of 2)
Change economic development focus from legacy (manufacturing & commodity agriculture) to KBE global products and services
This is where the high value, high wage job growth opportunities abound
Emphasizes growth of firms not negatively impacted by Illinois weaknesses
Grow breadth and depth of Connect SI visionary leaders and champions Commitment to passionate long-term vision by more leaders is critical
Critical mass of 3,000+ champions is critical to sustainability of change
Expand base of collaborative funding support for Connect SI strategies Long-term consistency in strategy focus is dependent on regional control
“Cavalry-is-coming” mentality must be dispelled to transform expectations
Support a long-term regional framework to guide regional growth Regional collaboration can only take place through a regional framework
Access to a broader base of financial, data and human resources is assured
Executive OverviewExecutive Overview
©2007 ViTAL Economy, Inc.— 55 —
Executive OverviewExecutive Overview
LOOKLOOK FEELFEELACTACT
Source: Milestone Visioning Exercise from GW, GE and S5
CSI Participants Vision of the Future
Construction is going onDowntowns look niceSense of pride in our
properties; less trash, more flowers
More ideal retail availableBroadband is everywhereNatural beauty, farmlands
are preservedNew housingMaintain our historical
buildings; respect our heritage
Good mix of industry and business
Healthcare is widely available
Smart use of the brownfields
Construction is going onDowntowns look niceSense of pride in our
properties; less trash, more flowers
More ideal retail availableBroadband is everywhereNatural beauty, farmlands
are preservedNew housingMaintain our historical
buildings; respect our heritage
Good mix of industry and business
Healthcare is widely available
Smart use of the brownfields
More educational opportunities
People are doing business outside of the area; world markets
Intentionally acting in a collaborative manner
Street talk has changed to newest activities and additions to the community
Business able to compete in the global economy
People are proud of their community
“Walk the Talk”Comfort with risk and
entrepreneurship and innovation
Middle-aged and older folks are not afraid of IT
More educational opportunities
People are doing business outside of the area; world markets
Intentionally acting in a collaborative manner
Street talk has changed to newest activities and additions to the community
Business able to compete in the global economy
People are proud of their community
“Walk the Talk”Comfort with risk and
entrepreneurship and innovation
Middle-aged and older folks are not afraid of IT
Positive perception of the area
Pride in the communityNew people feel welcome,
open door feelingWe are a “20 county” regionSI is a world recognized
regional brandValue education and a
sense of communityHigh school students feel
good about staying in the region
A new cultural atmosphereMore young people bring a
vibrancy to the regionStrong small town
environment
Positive perception of the area
Pride in the communityNew people feel welcome,
open door feelingWe are a “20 county” regionSI is a world recognized
regional brandValue education and a
sense of communityHigh school students feel
good about staying in the region
A new cultural atmosphereMore young people bring a
vibrancy to the regionStrong small town
environment
Executive OverviewExecutive Overview
©2007 ViTAL Economy, Inc.— 56 —
Executive OverviewExecutive Overview
VE Vision of SI Tomorrow
Southern Illinois is the global location where inter-generation active lifestyle families, visitors & KBE workers choose to live work and play — growth abounds
SI’s historic liability of remoteness and lack of access becomes an asset; instead of forgotten by Chicago, Springfield and Washington, SI is a land and lifestyle treasured, respected, sought after and envied — there is only one SI in the World
SI communities see themselves in a new light; they are respectful of their place; they see themselves as gateways to a land that is "The Garden of The Gods"
Tourism venues, town centers,rural lands, business locations and neighborhoods all demonstrate by their look and feel that SI is a very special place to be preserved and enhanced for all time
SI is a place of welcome for people of all cultures whether visiting or living here; in the land of "The Garden of the Gods” all are welcome and of value
It is a place many want to be, but only the fortunate choose to take advantage of this unique opportunity; SI becomes a place that is worth a premium, rather than one that feels it must offer a discount to be desired
Source: ViTAL Economy Alliance
Executive OverviewExecutive Overview
©2007 ViTAL Economy, Inc.— 57 —
Executive OverviewExecutive Overview
Southern Illinois — "Garden of the Gods"
Section G: How Does SI Organize to Succeed?How Does SI Organize to Succeed?
Suggests the framework to progress into Phase 2
Stay cool
©2007 ViTAL Economy, Inc.— 58 —
Executive OverviewExecutive Overview
All new jobs created byIndustry Clusters will be
targeted to include private payer health benefits for
workers and families
All new jobs created byIndustry Clusters will be
targeted to include private payer health benefits for
workers and families
Phase 2 Framework is Built Around Industry Clusters
Tourism Bio-Agriculture Knowledge Based Enterprises (KBE)
Healthcare Technology Products & Services Advanced Manufacturing Recreational, Marine, Hunting, Technology Products & Services Visual Creative & Performing Arts and Services International Incubation and Innovation Green Technologies Homeland Security Response and Services Life Sciences, Plant and Animal
Global Workforce Opportunities Energy Mining Technology Transportation, Logistics & Warehousing Senior Living
©2007 ViTAL Economy, Inc.— 59 —
Executive OverviewExecutive Overview
Phase 2 Priorities for Success (1 of 2)
1. Expand NP-COI connectivity broadband deployment with professional support for an additional twelve months — including expansion of enterprise applications for healthcare, education, R&D and tech transfer research collaboration with private sector
2. Broaden base of Connect SI champions and gain re-commitment of Phase 1 champions — repeat January-June 2006 road show using RA data to garner additional support
3. Invest robust resources in a collaborative funding strategy to raise $1.5 million in cash and in-kind resource commitments to Connect SI for each FY 2008 and FY 2009
4. Establish Connect SI as a regional data portal for SI — Local municipalities are already benefiting from regional data assembled by Connect SI, which has helped local economic development professionals attract businesses to SI — there is no other long-term reliable source for consistent, accurate and integrated data for the SI region
5. Select four industry clusters for Phase 2 research and implementation in 2008. Recruit private sector leadership teams during first quarter of 2008 for each industry cluster — identify experienced rural industry cluster research teams to guide cluster teams
6. Commit to a sense of urgency that is communicated region wide — educate citizens and leaders of the economic realities of the need for change today rather than tomorrow — invest in Connect SI marketing strategy in support of broadband, champion development, collaborative funding and private sector recruitment goals
©2007 ViTAL Economy, Inc.— 60 —
Executive OverviewExecutive Overview
Phase 2 Priorities for Success (2 of 2)
7. Leadership Advisory Committee agrees to resource the Healthcare COI to aggressively achieve the transformative qualitative and quantitative goals it established in Phase 1
8. Focus four regional COI’s on recruitment of industry cluster participants for prioritized SI-wide industry clusters — have COI leadership guide implementation of at least two short term win opportunities every six months, which are connected to achieving COI goals
9. Fund and establish a collaborative leadership institute to address critical shortage of visionary leadership across SI — include youth engagement in this, so that youth brain drain can be successfully addressed for the long-term
10. Review RA findings and work with ViTAL Economy to integrate RA findings into the SI-wide economic strategy to be released in 1st quarter 2008
11. Commit to obtain and invest resources required to implement Connect SI Phase 2 economic strategy and achieve qualitative and quantitative goals starting April 1 2008 — including approval of Connect SI Phase 2 implementation timelines, funding and professional resources
12. Develop a 501(c)3 framework for Connect SI, so that independent government and foundation funding that cannot be received by SIU or Man-Tra-Con can be accessed — particularly critical with regard to approved legislation dealing with digital divide funds from state and federal sources
©2007 ViTAL Economy, Inc.— 61 —
Executive OverviewExecutive Overview
Immediate Action Items
1. Utilize this Readiness Assessment as a resource tool and foundation in support of the Connect SI COI’s and strategic actions underway — Now!
2. Promote this Readiness Assessment report around the region in a variety of forms; web-posting, presentations, hardcopy, CD’s, etc. — Now!
3. Assemble and expand the Connect SI Leadership Team to completely understand the Readiness Assessment — Ongoing!
4. Commit to a sense of urgency to staff, fund, and lead this initiative through Phase 2 and beyond — Ongoing!
See: RA Chapters 6 & 7
©2007 ViTAL Economy, Inc.— 62 —
Executive OverviewExecutive Overview
Southern Illinois — "Garden of the Gods"
Section H: Call to Excellence…a Destiny of Prosperity!Call to Excellence…a Destiny of Prosperity!
Stay cool
©2007 ViTAL Economy, Inc.— 63 —
Executive OverviewExecutive Overview
What SI’s Future Can Become
It’s Time to Go Global!
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
Exports as a % ofGDP
U.S.
Illinois
SI
11%
8.4%
2.4%0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
60%
70%
Private SectorPayroll & Benefits
Transfer Payments,All Gov't &
Education Earnings
U.S.
IL
SI
54%
33%36%
46%
67%64%
SI Becomes
an Innovation Economy
0.00
10.00
20.00
30.00
40.00
50.00
60.00
2005Southern Illinois USA-RuralUSA-Average Best in World
% P
enet
rati
on
o
f P
op
ula
tio
n
SI is a Global Broadband Leader
12%
24%
34%
54%
Insured population +10%
Medicaid -26%
Medicare +18%
UninsuredUninsured -32% -32%
Healthcare Economics are Transformed!
©2007 ViTAL Economy, Inc.— 64 —
Executive OverviewExecutive Overview
Source: “State of Working Illinois”, by Northern Illinois University (Nov 2005); “21st Century Workforce” (May 2004); IMF; ViTAL Economy research
Ave
rag
e A
nn
ual
G
row
th R
ate
%
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
3.85%
“Stay the Course” vs. “Change the Course”
AAGR Connect SI Goals 2008 - 2012
0
1
2
3
4
5
6
AAGR 1977-2001
Worldwide USA State-wide Southern Illinois
1.34%
2.19%
3.14%
5.62%
2012: increase of $3.6B in GDP to $21.2B SI economy, which translates into $162M in additional State and Local tax revenue
2012: increase of $3.6B in GDP to $21.2B SI economy, which translates into $162M in additional State and Local tax revenue
SI Becomes the National Model forRural Economic Transformation
©2007 ViTAL Economy, Inc.— 65 —
Executive OverviewExecutive Overview
“A Return to Love” by Marianne Williamson
Our deepest fear is not that we are inadequate Our deepest fear is that we are powerful beyond measure
It is our light, not our darkness that most frightens us We ask ourselves, who am I to be brilliant, gorgeous, talented, fabulous?
Actually, who are you not to be? You are a child of God
Your playing small does not serve the world There is nothing enlightened about shrinkingso that other people
won't feel insecure around you We are all meant to shine, as children do
We were born to make manifest the glory of God that is within us It is not just in some of us, it is in everyone
And as we let our own light shine, we unconsciously give other people permission to do the same
As we are liberated from our own fear,our presence automatically liberates others.
The future of Southern Illinois is in your hands!The future of Southern Illinois is in your hands!