NRECA The Agile Fractal Grid “The Gathering of Eagles”

Tuesday, February 25, 2014

Arlington, VA

Coffee and Breakfast

Agenda for NRECA Agile Fractal Grid Kickoff Meeting

8:00 Welcome by Martin Lowery; Opening by Chuck Speicher

8:15 Introductions of the Participants – John Reynolds

8:45 Achieving the Common Language through Design Patterns

9:20 The Vision of the Agile Fractal Grid – Craig Miller

9:45 Break

10:00 Discussion of the Managed Services Store and Applications

10:20 Discussion of the Distributed Systems Elements

11:45 Discussion of the Industrial Internet – Security, Resiliency, Efficiency

12:15 Lunch

1:00 Scope of the SmartAmerica Challenge vs. the Production Rollout

2:00 SEIT Process and Phase 1 Planning

2:30 Break

3:00 Phase 2 Implementation and Thread Assignments

3:30 General Discussion, Issues, Action Items, and Understandings

4:00 Wrap Up and Conclusion

Welcome to NRECA Martin Lowrie

Background on the National Rural Electric Cooperative Association

Convening of the Security Fabric Alliance Chuck Speicher

Announcement of House SFA Rules John Reynolds

It has been said that the greatest engineering achievement of the 20th century

has been the building of the electric grid.

- The National Academy of Engineering

Invited Visitors

Department of Energy

Carol Hawk

Program Manager, Cyber Security for Energy Delivery Systems

Ivanpah World's largest solar plant started producing electricity today

Ivanpah was supported by $1.6 billion in investments from the Energy Department's Loan Programs Office.

It represents the future of energy – utility-scale renewable power generation

that uses the latest technology to harness the sun where it is most abundant.

Federal Communications Commission

Henning Schulzerinne

Office of the Secretary of Defense

Rollie Wicks

Department of Homeland Security

Lisa Kaiser Sarah Mahmood

Executive Order (EO) 13636: Improving Critical Infrastructure Cybersecurity Presidential Policy Directive (PPD)-21: Critical Infrastructure Security and Resilience,

Critical Infrastructure Cyber Community Voluntary Program

Secretary of Homeland Security Jeh Johnson

PM – ISE DNI

Pamela Wise-Martinez Mike Howell

Kshemendra Paul

Mission Partners

Congress

Diane Rinaldo Legislative Director

For Mike Rogers Mike Rogers – Michigan 8th District

U.S. House of Representatives Chairman, House Intelligence Committee

Member, Energy and Commerce Committee

United States House Energy Subcommittee on Communications and Technology United States House Energy Subcommittee on Health

Cyberthreat Data Sharing and Protection

SmartAmerica Challenge

Sokwoo Rhee Presidential Innovation Fellow

The Challenge

We are planning to support the 940 rural co-ops in the U.S. with hybrid cloud/device services protected by the Security Fabric.

This is also the candidate energy “testbed” for the SmartAmerica demonstration.

What NRECA has asked us to do.

1. Stand up an “app store” for both operational and analytical applications for the cooperatives.

2. Participate in the “Substation of the Future” for the remote equipment and subsystems.

3. Apply the Security Fabric within the emerging Industrial Internet to protect all communications between the elements.

Introduction to the Security Fabric Alliance

• The Security Fabric Alliance is a working association dedicated to practical deployment of the power grid and critical infrastructure complex system solution in the United States:

– Utilities and telecommunications providers

– Systems integrators

– Manufacturers

– Technology partners

– National certification and interoperability entity

• The alliance is intended to give the CEO of a utility the purview of up-to-the moment knowledge of the options available to make wise investment decisions regarding infrastructure deployment for optimal returns.

The variation includes the proper orientation for large, medium, and small utilities.

There are many participants at different levels in the Security Fabric Alliance.

Components Products Subsystems

Research Integration Utility

Customers

• Intel – servers with Quark + TPM • Wind River – Security Connect • Middleware

• RTI – DDS • GridStat • Indra - iSpeed • MultiSpeak

• TeamF1 – Secure Communications • Secure Crossing – Protocol Whitelisting • PsiNaptic – Secure Service Distribution • SNMP Research – SNMP Agent • Freescale – HSM w/Vybrid SoC • Xilinx – CompactRIO SOC • Green Hills Software - INTEGRITY • Altera - tamper proofing • Microsoft – Active Directory • Red Hat – Auth Hub

• General Electric – EMS • Alstom Grid – EMS • Siemens – DMS • Viridity Energy – DR + DER

+ Microgrid • Lemko – LTE systems • Intel Security – SIEM + GTI

• Intel – Encanto + silicon support

• Sypris – Supply Chain Root of Trust

• TCIPG • EPRI – CIM Standards • MIT – Security &

Privacy Standards

• EPG – Phasor Data Portfolio • GridSense– NAN & Line Sensors • S&C IntelliTeam • SafeNet – Secure Key Management • Heart - Transverter • Freescale One Box • Cisco Cloud-in-a-Box

• Integrated Architectures – SEIT • MACE Fusion - DoD • Kryptos Logic – Red Team Certification • M2M Dynamics • Drummond Group – C&IT • Intel Security - Distribution

...First Stage…… • ERCOT • ONCOR • AEP • NRECA • NRTC

Suppliers

• Verizon • Level3 • AT&T • Internet2 • BT

• ViaSat • Hughes • ARINC • Stratus • Symmetricom

…Second Stage…… • APPA • SDG&E • PJM • NYISO • Southern Company • Duke Energy • CAISO

• Pecan Street • Mueller Community • Pike Powers

• PNNL – CyberSecurity Test Center

• Lincoln Labs • OMG SIG • SmartAmerica

Managed Services

• Tazca – Connect • CSG International • Digi International • N-Dimension

• SETI • Lockheed Martin • SAIC • Threat Connect

To establish the security of end-to-end systems using the Security Fabric elements, you need to do all seven… not just some.

4. Audit

– Records noteworthy events for later analysis

5. Confidentiality

– Encrypts sensitive data for matters of privacy.

6. Integrity

– Ensures that messages have not been altered.

7. Availability

– Prevents denial of service attacks

1. Identity Management

– Ensures the device identity is established genuinely

2. Mutual Authentication

– Allows both the Device Node and the Controller to verify the trustworthiness their identity to each other.

3. Authorization

– Manages permission to proceed with specific operations.

These are the seven tenets of security as described in the NIST-IR 7628 Guidelines.

The OMG process is more about establishing markets as opposed to just setting standards.

SFA Reference Builds

Certification of Conformance & Interoperability

The OMG is planning to standardize the Security Fabric

for all critical infrastructure.

SFA Participants Introductions

Systems Engineering, Integration, and Test

• President – Energy One Solutions • Secretary General – GO15

Very Large Power Grid Operators • President and CEO

Alstom ESCA Corporation • CTO – PJM Interconnection • Co-founder Viridity Energy Alain Steven

John Reynolds Alain Steven Rick Schaal Mike Sisto Jim Baller

Bob Lamont Paul Carroll

Mike Sisto

• IBM’s Wireless Emerging Business Opportunities • AT&T, Lucent Technologies and Hewlett-Packard • Lemko Distributed Mobile Wireless Network solutions

Rick Schaal

• VP, Engineering – Viridity • Executive Program Director –

Alstom ESCA • Program Director – AREVA • DMS Lead – Puget Sound Energy

• American Public Power Association • Fiber to the Home Council • Google Inc. • National Association of Telecommunications

Officers and Advisors • + several hundred specific broadband projects

Internet2

Christian Todorov

Texas A&M University

Named second in the nation by The Wall Street Journal among all universities, public and private, in a survey of top U.S. corporations, non-profits and government agencies,

based on graduates that recruiters prefer to hire.

“Home of the 12th Man”

Walt Magnussen

Real-Time Innovations

AEGIS Weapons System

Total Ship Computing Environment

NASA Robotic Controls Unmanned Aircraft Systems

Tom O’Conner Mark Hamilton

Indra

Michael Peck Eloy Gonzalez Ortega

GridSense

Transformer IQ

Line IQ

Inspection

Brett Sargent • System Capacity • Phase Imbalance • Metering / Theft • Conservation Voltage

Reduction • Four Quadrant True

Power Factor • Line Fault Directionality • PQ – voltage sags/swells,

interruptions, surges, unbalance

• Transformer Asset Management

Lemko

LTE over Satellite

Cellular on Wheels

Utility Industry

WiMax Replacement Security Industry

Transportation Industry

Mike Sisto

Public Safety Healthcare industry

Subnet Solutions

SEL Substation Controller

Message Management from Substations

Ameen Hamdon

CSGi

Jarrid Hall Eddie Day

Over 8 trillion revenue event records processed annually for major clients.

InterMediate

Electric Power Group

Direction of Grid Stress

Voltage Stability Monitoring

Vikram Budhraja Vivek Bhaman

BaseN

Anders Viden

BearingPoint Infonova

Concept-to-Cash

Andrew Thomson

The Orchestration of the Ecosystem.

BT America

Milton Keynes

Tom Wolf Bryan Fite

Milsoft

Engineering Analysis

Geographic Information

Field Engineering

Outage Management

Wayne Carr

TOA

Neil Ringers Mike Carpenter

Kevin Cantoli

TeMix

Ed Cazalet

Transactive Energy

Netronome

DJ Root Jerome Taylor

256 GB

Green Hills Software

Smart Farming

Smart Medical Systems

GE Aircraft Engines

EMC High End Storage Systems

Transportation Systems

Phase Array Radar Systems

Weapons Control Systems

Guidance Systems

Game Systems

Automotive Systems

John Warther John Killam

Brad Jackson Brian Riley

LocalGrid Technologies

Power Quality Analyzer

Microgrid controls: • Microgrid and Generation Control • Generation and Asset Monitoring • Storage Integration

Device Environment Controller Environment

Hypervisor

Application Management

Agent

Hypervisor

Application Management

Agent

David Berg

CryoKey

Chris Ho

Identity Management Mutual Authentication Authorization

Secure Crossing

Randy Reeves Robert Lorente

N-Dimension

Andrew Wright Bruce Gordon

Secure Exchange Technology SETI

Richard Marshall Elysa Jones

Threat data collaboration. Community Emergency Management.

National footprint today!

Threat Connect

Leigh Reichel

1300 Communities of Interest already in production!

Cornice Engineering

Gary McNaughton

HereNow

Brian Reynolds

Utilities Telecommunications Council

Eric Wagner Brett Kilbourne

• Advocacy and Training • License Sentry • Frequency Coordination • Microwave Coordination • PLC Database • RF Safety and Training • Regulatory Filing and Tracking

General Electric

Substation Simplification

Transformer Protection System

Energy Management System

Wide Area Monitoring

System Integrity Solution

Joe Salvo

National Rural Telecommunications Cooperative

Kurt Schaubach

National Rural Electrical Cooperative Association

Martin Lowery Robbin Christianson

David Pinney Maurice Martin Barry Lawson

Bridgette Bourge Bob Lamouth Doug Lambert

Paul Carrol Craig Miller