59
" 2I 1rrned Services Technical Information Agency 1Rproduced 6v DOCUMENT SERVICE CENTER KNOTT IMILIINI, DAYTON, 2, ONlO This document is the property of the United States Governwent. It In furnished for the duration of the contract and shall be returned when no longer required or upon recall by ASTI to the following address: Armied Services Technical Information Agency, Document Service Center, Knott DAWIln, Dayton 2, Ohio. W ICYLCI WH= GOVIUWTW OR OIMR DRAWINGS SPECIMIATICK OR UNRR DATA XU ICR ANY PURPOSE O~r THiN ni cWINicTiCS W A DIFDIIILY RSLATED GovmOiNWr MUmnwI MhATI~ TH UU.GOIUMIT TH3UhT VXCUR NO RUPONILIT X=S AM NT SGTO A KT R AMD TIE FACT THAT T=E oovwZFOWr MYT RAVE 10~RUATD ORa BI AIY WAY SUPLIZ TRM SAID DRAW0NGS BPICIIWATOK5, OZ (liE TAi N TO WI RGROMED BY WaXLATWOIOROIg OYHERWM AS I1 A31T MANNE LICENSNG TIE HOLDER OR ANY OTlER PRONIOR COSPCSATIKS OCONVEIBG ANY UWIT ORPEROhI TO MANUFACTURE LUSE OR SELAm PATENE 1XVEWWEnU HT WAY WN ANY WAY WE RLATED THETO 4~~~ ~ WI I0K. -

1rrned Services Technical Information Agency › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 081213.pdf · The tests c%;,Gu5_te8 In the bro-h amr! sloi the water l11ne In,31csto a higher

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: 1rrned Services Technical Information Agency › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 081213.pdf · The tests c%;,Gu5_te8 In the bro-h amr! sloi the water l11ne In,31csto a higher

" 2I

1rrned Services Technical Information Agency

1Rproduced 6vDOCUMENT SERVICE CENTER

KNOTT IMILIINI, DAYTON, 2, ONlO

This document is the property of the United StatesGovernwent. It In furnished for the duration of the contract and

shall be returned when no longer required or uponrecall by ASTI to the following address:

Armied Services Technical Information Agency, Document Service Center,Knott DAWIln, Dayton 2, Ohio.

W ICYLCI WH= GOVIUWTW OR OIMR DRAWINGS SPECIMIATICK OR UNRR DATAXU ICR ANY PURPOSE O~r THiN ni cWINicTiCS W A DIFDIIILY RSLATEDGovmOiNWr MUmnwI MhATI~ TH UU.GOIUMIT TH3UhT VXCURNO RUPONILIT X=S AM NT SGTO A KT R AMD TIE FACT THAT T=EoovwZFOWr MYT RAVE 10~RUATD ORa BI AIY WAY SUPLIZ TRMSAID DRAW0NGS BPICIIWATOK5, OZ (liE TAi N TO WI RGROMED BYWaXLATWOIOROIg OYHERWM AS I1 A31T MANNE LICENSNG TIE HOLDER OR ANY OTlERPRONIOR COSPCSATIKS OCONVEIBG ANY UWIT ORPEROhI TO MANUFACTURE

LUSE OR SELAm PATENE 1XVEWWEnU HT WAY WN ANY WAY WE RLATED THETO

4~~~ ~ WI I0K. -

Page 2: 1rrned Services Technical Information Agency › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 081213.pdf · The tests c%;,Gu5_te8 In the bro-h amr! sloi the water l11ne In,31csto a higher

DISCLAIMER NOTICE

THIS DOCUMENT IS BEST

QUALITY AVAILABLE. THE COPY

FURNISHED TO DTIC CONTAINEDA SIGNIFICANT NUMBER OFPAGES WHICH DO NOTREPRODUCE LEGIBLY.

Page 3: 1rrned Services Technical Information Agency › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 081213.pdf · The tests c%;,Gu5_te8 In the bro-h amr! sloi the water l11ne In,31csto a higher

DIPIEt- REUFMT T);.

C~Technical Nits N-10 a...Jd S Augontl1954

jaw*FC

t~ tchnitcal note

TESTS OF WASKIPS ANCHO)RSV IN Mut) AND SAND~ #OTTOMSft. C. Town* and J. V. Stalcup

U. S. Naval Civil &rgin..ring Raoich cnd 1,voiuoflon LdboratoryPodt tim~crn., cotromicloi ' ,E 01

Page 4: 1rrned Services Technical Information Agency › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 081213.pdf · The tests c%;,Gu5_te8 In the bro-h amr! sloi the water l11ne In,31csto a higher

2%

4

-4

'4

i

Page 5: 1rrned Services Technical Information Agency › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 081213.pdf · The tests c%;,Gu5_te8 In the bro-h amr! sloi the water l11ne In,31csto a higher

*F~s~'eacarch* -r %-. -at &-. LA -xa or i

tXmTA1 bblpyard, 1'ztcrr point, 4: n~ r a .and~*~ ~Pert )cr-ti. _'41 kforais.

-a,.* j~.rpuee of tho tc ;t~ r5 -ur IAda h.::;,over 4:t& Of A@v~tral I~tvetighL and4 Savyi ; ,rhti4-sently bainr utili:@sl by the Dzrea4 'M h;

Thin report tntaIz a ccrp cf tht, *cr2.*! wi.ruththe resul1t& ani oboervatiocz.

M11IM 7113- APPATW~U

Tlhe test arot-i for zad Lot%,= tests colsted of two r.x1. at. larizea. ,je to :zrrv the ?.ezt cq_!;:=nt, art a 5 x 12

;,~o. war~1ng tug, used to drop and retrieve tbo anh-': Atheteat a;-xijze via compct1 of a clet-b crlt tri-dynn2V=cter to J#*sur the holding pougr of the archor. and a zaBWI-140 Skagit vimch with a six-rert line for dragging the stchor.The winch vap spooled with .,50-t of 1-3/6 in. diazete wirer,pc, and thc wire ropi wan reeved through cacr voo nuntel cn t"etwc borGas to fern the six-part lite. One ae tric 5 x 12 pontcocwbarges vas a -iiorei with to 30,0C2-1b. N~avy Stocklvms, anchoaind~the other barge vas attached to the, test anchor with auitab~elengthi of atchor chain. Figure I shows a Cenera! Yiew oft thebarges at flutterz Point during the tests. In thin view the teOtanchor Is located beneath this buoy betwon the tuo f.1irthnst tre5and th" buocy In the right foregrouind locateon one of the 3stockless anchors used to hold the barges In ,Ocltion.

T!A vertical force required to breaL the test anchor !onefro the nud bottom at the end of each t, piall w-4 ocea..ed byseans of a strain sg zoanted ou the warping tug jin,7h line. *eeFigure 2. Depth of wnter was approzlr~Atoly 30-ft a, the test alto.

The test apparatuse for sand bottom teuts .,oainlted of a 20-fteage rajilway. 300-ft Ina length, the open end of which is 100-fttaboi.a sean low tide; a 20,000-lb. gross weight, traveline instru-ment car; and a witch =vuntad on a statiorstry platform at. the I.--shore ea. Zee Fig~zre 3. The instr~ent car vwb fabricated tc.almlate tthe ~.~~ of a ship draggug its anthor and to carry

a 40A,030-lb. :aiecitj cee-tric d3otucncter, Pi.iri 4~, to cac.u-cthe holding power of the anchors. A portablo, dry-cell. batte.r..

Page 6: 1rrned Services Technical Information Agency › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 081213.pdf · The tests c%;,Gu5_te8 In the bro-h amr! sloi the water l11ne In,31csto a higher

'za .c vtt flll a v:ere taken In the ;ath :1 tt-r lot 'ulikzto a 40;th Zf -C-rz. A At~elys3:1 was.dt

by On~ S:44 1viim. of tn" 7-t;r*iy zcz *obel 1. A so!'shear ttre*tb ecr jotQr ec.itent Sc.a-fsi of the bey cui are

in 7akla 31.

A =40hAnical sae~yvL3 of tbc sani at the tart flueccm teasite shoved 9?, *r tet sa c rtlles, 42 rer cent of vh1.h vsfiner than M --%, the teattlar tbelng coa .ns-u M. = in vi:c.

?TaT AKECMtS

Tb't teat 4tcher, consisted of A 3/- ,CX-, 4aC'- nlC,C1X-*. Lightvvightj a L,'K- rj% Nav7,'.h. oystocklesa; a d a 2,110-11. krttioh H,.¢,k. The Xulock snt-or isequipped with a 12-in. lcng stabilizer ftbrioated rrcc 2.ti.steel r.-=.J tock. See Fiburez 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, &me 10. Zn orderto ineove the boldirg ;vover of the LV7 enhorn, the 2,000-,

a rA h,-t 1wT anchor. were vodiflc4 an par Bu3s.IysInstru:tics to a full fluke shape by welding fluke extecAic-plate# to tL base of the conventional fluke Ord these anchorswera retested In both " and sad. See Figure 11. Two oevdesign laldt anchors, 3,170-1b. and 3,6-lb., and a 3,060-lb.Croseck anchor were also teste. See Figurea 12, 13, ad 14.

TM-. MMMS2t, ItUD WITCH4

-he 2,000-, 3,00-, and ,0C'0-lb. Lightue-ght and 4,0Y.,and 8,000-lb. !eaty stockless anchors Vere yalled a, chain ange%of 0-, 6-, and 12 -dogreea. The proper chain lengths for '.-, t-,and 12-de4gree chain angles were obtained by the .c-rm uA pr-nentd In the U. S. Na'y Technical ?ub.icatioz entitled "XoorineGuide" ayvDocks TP-pv-2. The rezaltdor of %.-e sthcre vercpulled at a :ero degree chain angle cnly. Jix teats uore con-duted vith each anchor at each :b-t!n encle. fleaulto of thesetoots are cc ntaloe4 in Table III. -is; s 15 thr..rgh 38 aregraphs of the six test pulls on each anchcr shcvin holding peveiveros ach"or traftl. FIgures 33, 34, end 35 are the pryho ofthe 2,000-lb., 3,000-1b., and b4,(.-lb. LAI. ar.-hors vit, flukeex'enei~n plates. Tth holding ;Oer kreak."-. . .. , and ..'..angles for each anchor are shon in !he table.

Initial testo on the 3,170-lb. nov design Baldt, anchorthived a holding jower to anchor o-Ight ratio of 2.36 to I at aterto degree chain anjne. This low ratio, for an anihor of thisdesign, Indicated that the flukes -er!: not opening pioperly acthe chain length uss chrteued, to lift th- shank sitghtly hjscpcning the flukes, and the anchsr was retested. H)lding po errnt-c. wet in:reased to 6.62 to 1.

Page 7: 1rrned Services Technical Information Agency › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 081213.pdf · The tests c%;,Gu5_te8 In the bro-h amr! sloi the water l11ne In,31csto a higher

TY,,M-~0 CAST r--A -

z~tx U-ts vare con,.:tel wlth eac anct.:-r at -era JerrocTtiin aa rmcly. Pax._ta af theve testa sre - rtalosd L.u Zst.ic

@a.zh e,.7hor ah%.4L d.ru-e ra3r*4* *Fr-h trav.el~'4.:

rc~ pvAmr of 23.3 kip# f~rr ZO-ft : .- / :t. a-her P -43.3 ki;i for ;~-tof -1; !a. GaW haT bL.

The tests c%;,Gu5_te8 In the bro-h amr! sloi the water l11neIn,31csto a higher holding power than Pm~ coz-v ozet~ra %I: Vro-dtice in ased under wauter. This to Se to the 4ifferent In-plactdensities of the ser.4 ahave and below a vter. The sand beinalqsu dsed zder wvorl. The Inlitated holding powers = U~eb**s:h ae a proxLrstely 33 :vr mect higher than =In~er water.

OB=VATIC,%*

ThA holdlag pow~r of ir4ividsial achmrs y be loy vhen

In the initial setting of the s'~hor, the flukes ere r~crolyptro1~el to the tottuc and are supp- rtcd =4ren?th ty tbe =.In this positiaa tthc~c !a ta*.~; -,f afl"r %otn_-e tcTat=e thout to drop down ad vAtC !mt( the =ni.

In oa--I totc the aac~rs which have a large (like enIng, app~roximately 49-degrees, VilA ttpon -jp b-at v!!! "'-t rinto the san due to the inaorrect hag;. of Fill on shank andrl.~es. This covdltl-No has been cebaerve4 i e t-rtirlo ^n ti-,0ca<~h where the -n~hrva re vi112i and 16 n::t Iz ice.ed in thtcooperloon of the holdig ;overi vhma t.he chalm angle in chaer~l.from tero degrees to six sa twelve degrets In muS h.ttce-. Fzrthe Lightweight nnr:Lirs, t". hnod~rng pover at 12-degrer --oirmngle wss act~nl1: higher In tvco instaneo tnn at 6-4drrMctain angle. See TaLl. MI. For the Stwkleos anthora, th- In-~ivose of Loldta, ;over from zero n~evrec -hs~n azrgl to 6-, andlZ.4*Cre~s in on):, slight after Srage~ng 5C-st and becomes

greater as the 6n~atcr in drsgrced furtrnor. The laraer .*.ain angle

1. ?LV:EFMAB TivehnI.cal Yezorand=~ !J-2 , Test of Anchors or

1953, P. 13 nnd BIUDCKS Soils LabormtorI Peport, Sn SampleiLAnchor Tests, Stee. & :ncrete-Stee. An~hors, byL.A

5 January 1~Q. 3ORC --

Page 8: 1rrned Services Technical Information Agency › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 081213.pdf · The tests c%;,Gu5_te8 In the bro-h amr! sloi the water l11ne In,31csto a higher

ak,Mor~ vvIght vss Itcreatel ec 2-1b to I jzp to 'I.t.. to A.

Vt'klcv &r0nv ?Ao betta tested Lt. c-4 bctom ollth thefl~ukesa fixed at tr)- 'r =4~w fg,- -;PzInZ i.tl tV holit.k-5rwar to ua1fjiht r&1, %:.. .. 4 tr ., i-.4re4 to Z.4'9 tofor the samancstw vitha..t the f.-koa fixei Ir. an opotico, indieeting f~rther tthc In billy Cf t1. 4-..Aor f.,-as t-0asa&=* an open poaltloc. A1.-,r .tiiftal in %hear prluctests were a 6.000-, aO~~~,nd s Nivy et e:s.

The Xuic'k avha atzbtllit.r of Instufitivat let~th,12-io., to pr~yont rotation# thqrety :educing itscz=to liz'povoar. Tlho anchr sated to ;*ztra the sbend bottce repIifl;but votild rotate 10-4ogreas and poill out In a zhvrt daotoc.

The nov design Baldt ancbora voe destgued prinonily forcud tottoc atA due to tho large fluke opening, 5O-drr:, v:-ildnot ;nqrtrota the :cod bottom properly and rqsuted In 4 accholdIng ;ow'r thnn ut.ild norally b.- expected from at anchor o'fthis design.

Previous teatol made In send bottc bay-w ahovn that Fa -Aanglo of 35-degrees produces the maxim%= bol..Ing povvr for theancIhors in mud tottom tzi prcimnory Vests in mul hare Icdl.ctted that a larger f'luke angle of apprnzinately SO to 70 degreesvill produce the maximun holdin~g pover. These fluke angle testsIn w.4 bottom are twing continued.

1. (See poige3.

r

Page 9: 1rrned Services Technical Information Agency › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 081213.pdf · The tests c%;,Gu5_te8 In the bro-h amr! sloi the water l11ne In,31csto a higher

KtCILBIA aYISIS

Very FineDoI f ad slits ClAr

I.05 - C7 t .005 V;05 ., O -. 03~5

10-112 ho50

Par cent by vcjabt 6

TA=l 11

SOIL SEEM.' 5310 ANDL WArM R"~lBHitcrs Point Yud

Pot t Srnt o (1/2 UCS) - po Va o

22 325 16, 11

2 -25 230 115.0 1579.'52.5 40 k.0 ho72 o1

F rcm MAVCEPMM T'ectinical Mczaran4i- P1.019, Orouzting in Soft Soils byPhilip P. Bra"n disted SU Fm 1953.

OFF!C

Page 10: 1rrned Services Technical Information Agency › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 081213.pdf · The tests c%;,Gu5_te8 In the bro-h amr! sloi the water l11ne In,31csto a higher

0 44

4.) p84 808

0)H I LN r t ~,- H g-,-4m -I

U1% r -4 l-4 ,-(

0

o1 4-S

0cc OD 0%f00 00 -

C'-400

0In .0. 00

LF, 1 88 0 H'4.) U-,4 -1 -t -4 V -4M e

$ 0 _1 0

.. 4 Q.

..

LA RV I R14 .S24 14 H. .1i

0 A

.70 0 cr a, -~- ,,3, 0:r c m N f a.

-4a

Page 11: 1rrned Services Technical Information Agency › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 081213.pdf · The tests c%;,Gu5_te8 In the bro-h amr! sloi the water l11ne In,31csto a higher

CCI oW - 0 0 0, 1 e

0

I ti ?)4 2co0. r0. % c E Ho 86 08g8 0kf~~~,' 91 t'L . LJ O

o 0 0

8888 88e mIC\ f t , 1 ;N O co -1

Ad r-4

'-4

Tj 0 0 0 0

E-4 4

IIo

4PQ'-4I)

Adr4 4 4

A .0 4

C ,~Io O 06 ~ ~ ~ XX ~A.

Page 12: 1rrned Services Technical Information Agency › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 081213.pdf · The tests c%;,Gu5_te8 In the bro-h amr! sloi the water l11ne In,31csto a higher

T1gur 2. Strsiz Case used to 4&iur break-o'.:t force of anchors ... ,i bottom.

Page 13: 1rrned Services Technical Information Agency › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 081213.pdf · The tests c%;,Gu5_te8 In the bro-h amr! sloi the water l11ne In,31csto a higher

Tlgur* 3. Wat spywaratu used to Pullanchora In beech send.

,.ue 4. :X,00-lb. capacity e.Lectri.caidy)namometer.

Page 14: 1rrned Services Technical Information Agency › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 081213.pdf · The tests c%;,Gu5_te8 In the bro-h amr! sloi the water l11ne In,31csto a higher

eC-

a. *r

Tlgure 5- TYPICAl LVr anchr. Nt u-vshope of the upper portion or flukesWt*.n the stock and the fluk..

Tlgue 6 iOCCO~b. 1(7anrhor.

Page 15: 1rrned Services Technical Information Agency › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 081213.pdf · The tests c%;,Gu5_te8 In the bro-h amr! sloi the water l11ne In,31csto a higher

- -4

?1care 5. TyOjybl LI?? anchor. Not* curved

chaps of the upper portico of flukesbetween the stock and the flukes.

Fi gure 6. 10,000-lb. LWlT anchor.

Page 16: 1rrned Services Technical Information Agency › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 081213.pdf · The tests c%;,Gu5_te8 In the bro-h amr! sloi the water l11ne In,31csto a higher

V"

Figure 8. 8,000-lb. Rtevy Stockleiu ancbor.

Page 17: 1rrned Services Technical Information Agency › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 081213.pdf · The tests c%;,Gu5_te8 In the bro-h amr! sloi the water l11ne In,31csto a higher

Figure 9. 17#000-lb. XaVY Stocklous anchor.

2e- -

- ----

'Fiur 10 2,! - Xuc ancor

Page 18: 1rrned Services Technical Information Agency › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 081213.pdf · The tests c%;,Gu5_te8 In the bro-h amr! sloi the water l11ne In,31csto a higher

Fiv~re 11. Typical LWY a=,bo. with fluke ex-tvns on PlAtes.

Figure 12. Nov design Baldt nid achor.

Page 19: 1rrned Services Technical Information Agency › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 081213.pdf · The tests c%;,Gu5_te8 In the bro-h amr! sloi the water l11ne In,31csto a higher

K* f

rigure 13. Nov dosipi 3,65.0-lb. Dalit SWd

anclLin

Amp"!

?igun 1b. Croeck aowbor, 3,060-lb.

Page 20: 1rrned Services Technical Information Agency › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 081213.pdf · The tests c%;,Gu5_te8 In the bro-h amr! sloi the water l11ne In,31csto a higher

r..7

1-11i. ?4 1r--H

LA -Z V

2?___ ILW i ~ j-o

S -MEI -- - *- r .

R TE

EN cc~

I~

I 1 :;: ~

&-A.

Page 21: 1rrned Services Technical Information Agency › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 081213.pdf · The tests c%;,Gu5_te8 In the bro-h amr! sloi the water l11ne In,31csto a higher

j 7V

T* t

* ;i O^A .

IOf

Page 22: 1rrned Services Technical Information Agency › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 081213.pdf · The tests c%;,Gu5_te8 In the bro-h amr! sloi the water l11ne In,31csto a higher

2 . S.

* A~i. "&d1%. -7

.5irAv-I.

4- - .-. . . a .~*

~ -~ - - La

2 2

/~2 * I.. , ~.

C- I2 I 22 2

t* , 22)1 ISLL

-4I *.*-..J C1.*

.-- *

II

.1

V.>:;Nit 2 4I.................

...........

* I* - N

* * .: * 2 "1

C

tO 0-S __

- - -- -. 'r'

Oh - ---

Page 23: 1rrned Services Technical Information Agency › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 081213.pdf · The tests c%;,Gu5_te8 In the bro-h amr! sloi the water l11ne In,31csto a higher

:0

- .. .

- .- -

L . . J • ' *i " . ..*

,. " H . ;" - .. . _--:- . ,o ; * *.*" "I .* ."

i : k i I !

-' I !,K k *- ,

*i',_, -, -

Page 24: 1rrned Services Technical Information Agency › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 081213.pdf · The tests c%;,Gu5_te8 In the bro-h amr! sloi the water l11ne In,31csto a higher

~1~B~j ~~ ~-

I I IC'

S -~ I S

72 -1~

1-S. ~k:-j94 £ ~

Sn i-sii-i. I~ 4

3..- 1LI

-~ ~ ~

.~.2 .~ .- '..

.1

7.

~aa~s.:.

S -t~ *~ 1 5.* tr ~'-~-

S..... * * SI. I

5:.. * I,,

* I <10I

5 I-i I* S ,,* .-.. ~ **.

t. -- -i I S

I 1 1 7-~ 5- .10

S...* S ** . .. * 2... .*

-oSC)

-~ -S

SJSILY

Page 25: 1rrned Services Technical Information Agency › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 081213.pdf · The tests c%;,Gu5_te8 In the bro-h amr! sloi the water l11ne In,31csto a higher

I ~ f -

~1 M.1

It 1 -ii4 1 j e d Di 10

244 *1

Page 26: 1rrned Services Technical Information Agency › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 081213.pdf · The tests c%;,Gu5_te8 In the bro-h amr! sloi the water l11ne In,31csto a higher

.jI~ ~. ii -

A

4 . I I'I.'I

* iiiI~ -4 * ~

* :4.

i-It.

* itS

* *~z. LIe~4j1 --k-

-. *~trt

41 ~iv * * .:~: :~* ~ :

- - . * ~4

4 (I

Page 27: 1rrned Services Technical Information Agency › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 081213.pdf · The tests c%;,Gu5_te8 In the bro-h amr! sloi the water l11ne In,31csto a higher

4.1..1.

'.-.T-

t T I

..........

Page 28: 1rrned Services Technical Information Agency › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 081213.pdf · The tests c%;,Gu5_te8 In the bro-h amr! sloi the water l11ne In,31csto a higher

* j ~ T

-~ *1 . . .LI -

*1~ . .

I. .

~.1~ V.? tt1

I. I

I - - . 71 .;$>: L.... * *~. r-

I * Ij. ,** j.~ -* - .. t.j* :, .. ~ ~

- * t : r* .. ?. I 4- LI I ~ I~

* - .

-s . ~ *~-~- .4

* 4*

I::* * r r IL..

I-. I ''s~ Igf4 ti. 13I..,. ~ ~

I,.J

~ ~. I

I :74ji~* 4.... Icz:I ~~+Z W7~

()

I I SI rY N :

I.

I 'Si

... *I *~'

U.; - - ~91

2 o* ?~cHw~:~ .~ '-;!1,.C~ £~i'1 :Q-~QJ- O~IQ..-L i~:E Q~1LY

Page 29: 1rrned Services Technical Information Agency › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 081213.pdf · The tests c%;,Gu5_te8 In the bro-h amr! sloi the water l11ne In,31csto a higher

1.. 0

. . . . . . . . . . .. . ... f

^ MR

11

NU ~ ~ I~- rELt

........ 0

0S;

0 0 W c6) ~ ~ gl "L

Page 30: 1rrned Services Technical Information Agency › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 081213.pdf · The tests c%;,Gu5_te8 In the bro-h amr! sloi the water l11ne In,31csto a higher

I~ *q..7

+4C

F--, :_I T

JJ

Li- Fl.*

LIFE .&-4- -

II_7;____ :-1

4-4

1-4 -4 -

Page 31: 1rrned Services Technical Information Agency › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 081213.pdf · The tests c%;,Gu5_te8 In the bro-h amr! sloi the water l11ne In,31csto a higher

.. . . . . . . . .. .

* t

71- . r ....

.z . .. . . . . . .

.31. 4;

r7- -r -. rT~,-

gb~ OH)NV 30O' j3," 0,1 9N101%jH

Page 32: 1rrned Services Technical Information Agency › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 081213.pdf · The tests c%;,Gu5_te8 In the bro-h amr! sloi the water l11ne In,31csto a higher

* *..,. . a7 1

-* ~.I 2. I

I.;7 *

'1 -~V*

.

. ,,,... I

. -~ ,. II

:7 I j

-~

I * ~ C','I, ~

. It SI?.** ~ ;.

'I.. ~

*-2*7

I'.K?~ri~i ~j . 1.7,4

-. i 'i~~ t,'I ILI '~:: *~' it -r rl

: ~ *

t.;.1 .4C)~1 4')

1* 'fCJ I~ 7 1 i'~. I ~ 4~(I 1~:ij L:i

. . I -*1

I:.: . .: .~ .-. *.*....;..f*

. .

'I

I . -.

I - --*

2 -~ ~ N.7.. . ,t -. 7 I * , .

1'

7. - o LC~ C)C~3

-. 4

Page 33: 1rrned Services Technical Information Agency › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 081213.pdf · The tests c%;,Gu5_te8 In the bro-h amr! sloi the water l11ne In,31csto a higher

1... . . . . . . .

:;:I r .-- -

iif~rr.. 1 j1. A . 1

- J 2

5d ?f 73 Y O

Page 34: 1rrned Services Technical Information Agency › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 081213.pdf · The tests c%;,Gu5_te8 In the bro-h amr! sloi the water l11ne In,31csto a higher

" :' ", ! / , I ; " -

i- :. --f :'II - l' - .'

" !. .. ,- -: -- .. .. ,- ... '

I. . . I 'I*, ." + "

":.

', . t . . . . ; . . - . . .. I

, . : •z . . . . . . . • .,.V ". i " - : i , - .-- .-: I " . . .

' - .N

.. . .. . .. ' - '- "-. -:'- " • ... <"a. " •. O. .. *r-.i-.: _, * I ...+_ ... . .

: . . , .*. ...

.1 " I z - -

IIIP.. '. . o V" .,, d7iqg

Page 35: 1rrned Services Technical Information Agency › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 081213.pdf · The tests c%;,Gu5_te8 In the bro-h amr! sloi the water l11ne In,31csto a higher

. .'.~ . .

.1.1

2~~ 1 .~J1 ~f*

T 1* z I

t .n

* Is.

Page 36: 1rrned Services Technical Information Agency › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 081213.pdf · The tests c%;,Gu5_te8 In the bro-h amr! sloi the water l11ne In,31csto a higher

.i -Z-.= - ;. T

4 '44 II T_" z 2 t-

t~zzrr--r r

*:t 4.-It'

Trr. 44

x4441 *4-4U! T-

a - oLtjt a

f4I 14-

-~ -r4#t P1L0

~n C~ 'o~IMER 9

- 9dI ~ J 42Ms ,~ TG14

Page 37: 1rrned Services Technical Information Agency › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 081213.pdf · The tests c%;,Gu5_te8 In the bro-h amr! sloi the water l11ne In,31csto a higher

M- A

J,4... -

~~t.

I Mg ~-f-- p ..... . ~ ...

!1 TH Ti*

I 1 <1%tI T -

I. t

Cd'A- 1t9: W) HI 00-J

Page 38: 1rrned Services Technical Information Agency › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 081213.pdf · The tests c%;,Gu5_te8 In the bro-h amr! sloi the water l11ne In,31csto a higher

A. i 97:-

~TttS ~ - -

X-Z ;4

LO wt

1.0

It tsLJ li.

* 4

T_ 4 s -

1- X7-v - -c= 74 1 4

-

SMOOM _i l3NQd .NC00

~OHQN~r 40 ~ G1OH

Page 39: 1rrned Services Technical Information Agency › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 081213.pdf · The tests c%;,Gu5_te8 In the bro-h amr! sloi the water l11ne In,31csto a higher

4-4j

L K

i T

t =-T

M I

I IA~

A- c~ H )N !-

Page 40: 1rrned Services Technical Information Agency › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 081213.pdf · The tests c%;,Gu5_te8 In the bro-h amr! sloi the water l11ne In,31csto a higher

?17

114

£4- In

$OIU44-11IN 40Ut d JCC4a _, L

ti

Page 41: 1rrned Services Technical Information Agency › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 081213.pdf · The tests c%;,Gu5_te8 In the bro-h amr! sloi the water l11ne In,31csto a higher

Z :-t_ -

IiTT , I I

fil I~ It's

*1j I' ti

~'10

4 4c

Page 42: 1rrned Services Technical Information Agency › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 081213.pdf · The tests c%;,Gu5_te8 In the bro-h amr! sloi the water l11ne In,31csto a higher

*T- 1 . * .T. 4 4 - 1

I.HS ~ ~ ~ 7 * * i* * I I .

.4..!..'1-, j--- -4t h ITfr I ISOZ4Ii7 12 in Hi

.,: , I~i ..:- "*ntA 9 Z

I~- *" .7 *

T i. r_ ff- 4i A

*1. 42

t 1) T Ac 1 tcflOi c T2 J. Eo-

Page 43: 1rrned Services Technical Information Agency › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 081213.pdf · The tests c%;,Gu5_te8 In the bro-h amr! sloi the water l11ne In,31csto a higher

t r .

I j

r) nj; 7

4 ji;:i"n Ac.1

Page 44: 1rrned Services Technical Information Agency › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 081213.pdf · The tests c%;,Gu5_te8 In the bro-h amr! sloi the water l11ne In,31csto a higher

I~ T

II

Jim. *

vii

Page 45: 1rrned Services Technical Information Agency › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 081213.pdf · The tests c%;,Gu5_te8 In the bro-h amr! sloi the water l11ne In,31csto a higher

. .. ... ......

~I r

-V!~ it 4

* t t

il 1H ONLY

Page 46: 1rrned Services Technical Information Agency › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 081213.pdf · The tests c%;,Gu5_te8 In the bro-h amr! sloi the water l11ne In,31csto a higher

. ... ..... ..1 71

IAI

"+-~-- " :t-

7 4 10'lI I

I :

.~ T T- ___ .. .. . .f: L-

I,:' : >I ij-1 1-4 4, 14

t 1 10

::"++i :5.... ... F"+-:t-* "4;;.'- Th : j-, . ii. f

I :1.-"-- -t -.....

it* - " j4+ 4jt, + tj 4-fl4 ' 1 -:• . 44'+'"::"': ; " +: i++ +' i; :+ .. .l + l _. : -t+ i j

... .. +4 f. .. > P !. : t "2 I; 1}S x ,. i

:_X : . : .- - ". §j5- 15,,1 t *.+ _} ' " I i ti... . " -. ... I+ •: ' T - i -

.1_ rtt i:*1t-"ri i '+ Ti..ii1...} ; -. .. .,-',_I I--' ;.,. N' .+o g -3,a, o~ 9N ~ -l¢! l L ... .'1+ ,'L

Page 47: 1rrned Services Technical Information Agency › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 081213.pdf · The tests c%;,Gu5_te8 In the bro-h amr! sloi the water l11ne In,31csto a higher

1A ~~~ i i..

--- If.&F LIST !T

f

ITI

WIT

4A-*r~

TYh

j:E ONLY

Page 48: 1rrned Services Technical Information Agency › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 081213.pdf · The tests c%;,Gu5_te8 In the bro-h amr! sloi the water l11ne In,31csto a higher

.t.

• i" _ ... ... . 4 " ' .': " " " "

..u:: " : . . -

'. ,V .. ,.'

I

.. .. .. - .-- I " .. .. - -4" " .,6!' . ""-

.I ''- 1"....

*6 . . ; f,, *

.........-.. . 4 4

blI , -E O ILY

Page 49: 1rrned Services Technical Information Agency › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 081213.pdf · The tests c%;,Gu5_te8 In the bro-h amr! sloi the water l11ne In,31csto a higher

4:; 44 .I- .

r-T

ML

.04

4_A W~ 1N 40 7.-Z ~ ''~

T~~ ri rHY

Page 50: 1rrned Services Technical Information Agency › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 081213.pdf · The tests c%;,Gu5_te8 In the bro-h amr! sloi the water l11ne In,31csto a higher

I z . . . . *:~

I' .. .. +

1A;. .. :.:

I/

£ / ~I Jr

12 2I ~.

0~

;TtTi~.T .12 ~ A

: : i [z.

11.

-.

.- a

A *

.r~Y:1£ A; ~.4-J.j-- 'a

- - -~ Li.y..! 'i~1!~4..i' I

A A

. 1*~ (j. 2

f I jt f

r .. :

A - . - I

A- . ~.

NI---.:

Page 51: 1rrned Services Technical Information Agency › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 081213.pdf · The tests c%;,Gu5_te8 In the bro-h amr! sloi the water l11ne In,31csto a higher

4~'1 TJT5T

* # TjZ~ ;~-- :-- NA. ___.*

r* J

Li

IT 1.

11:4~

T .4

ww 4

*~~ ___'-j

E~i1- tG j H 0 20 d -3PA~ 9NI-C)

7 A * ; IL

Page 52: 1rrned Services Technical Information Agency › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 081213.pdf · The tests c%;,Gu5_te8 In the bro-h amr! sloi the water l11ne In,31csto a higher

$ .$~, .. *... ... ,.r V

p... . . ."

.z:~:~* jA/. I* - . I

. ~.. .. ". .

ii: . . 2

I . I Ii:* * . I *

I 2,f. If j1-?

t -~ 71* - . ~ * ~

3 . t 2 ~.X .~

~1 ~~ -.s.iI.I.3 ? -

-t * *

[:L~±~>~.L*.t!:~: * .~2

.z / )~

.4 -

... * .1- * .- ~f5-. -J,

2 ... j 4 .I~aA..Lf. iZ~ ~4L... ~ .~L~Lv 7 3...

i'~i *.4 m~'~L$ L~' . .Y P

[14 ~ 41 :z~~i ' *

I I I*1

~2 *~--~~ ~

.1

1~~*~~~~ I

7

I

I

~Ji~'i ~J(H.~-'P"V *'~ ~::~C~ E~;'4Lr>.-I

Page 53: 1rrned Services Technical Information Agency › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 081213.pdf · The tests c%;,Gu5_te8 In the bro-h amr! sloi the water l11ne In,31csto a higher

I.. ~

t.

4.... ,-I~I .. ,

.:~' . .46 464. 4

* 1I . ~ r . ...

I '* .. ~ .4 . , 4

-,.,--..?--i-r. * t~7...,. 4 4 -44 4 4. 4 4

4 . 34 '. a' :.V. . 4:> :. : \ *'L~ , 6

1 1 .

---- 4-'

I ~ :' 3

* (4ii.. L.f 4 * J. . :":-~ d.L-*..-* -.

* 3 t ~' .11~'~ a4 .1* I.--.. 1.*~ ?~4 a,

4 4I I * U

~ ~

.4-*a'

I .- I

- 1

L -

'I ~ .:- C.A@ 5 -

* CLY

Page 54: 1rrned Services Technical Information Agency › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 081213.pdf · The tests c%;,Gu5_te8 In the bro-h amr! sloi the water l11ne In,31csto a higher

*~~ J ~~ . I

1 i zZ III~r *cc)

-A .1.4T

I?~r T 17

0- 1 IS Lto

i fo US OL

Page 55: 1rrned Services Technical Information Agency › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 081213.pdf · The tests c%;,Gu5_te8 In the bro-h amr! sloi the water l11ne In,31csto a higher

____ *~qjrF

=1 4

{j1-4

Z~flJT --

_~ Ji

4_d*-SO2V JQ 3AAO4 VNWfl1014

s E ONLY

Page 56: 1rrned Services Technical Information Agency › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 081213.pdf · The tests c%;,Gu5_te8 In the bro-h amr! sloi the water l11ne In,31csto a higher

t.-7. r

j':7t7i. ' LV ,

1, 1 I1014

ojiCAL US

Page 57: 1rrned Services Technical Information Agency › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 081213.pdf · The tests c%;,Gu5_te8 In the bro-h amr! sloi the water l11ne In,31csto a higher

LII I'1

1

4r

LT.

T'(9a r 2- 2 1

*.J ~ ~II

A._ il

L

IL. iEi i J

US

Page 58: 1rrned Services Technical Information Agency › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 081213.pdf · The tests c%;,Gu5_te8 In the bro-h amr! sloi the water l11ne In,31csto a higher

7::

J) I

J_ L

r+4-4-

tj. *' 4--

14-

Page 59: 1rrned Services Technical Information Agency › dtic › tr › fulltext › u2 › 081213.pdf · The tests c%;,Gu5_te8 In the bro-h amr! sloi the water l11ne In,31csto a higher

+- ,..4..4

711:

:7

4W

1 14

I i77

VV~

I~~w l Rf am , R--.I-'-. Tom". V. t- O ** * "l4 r