61
"&* )-,"'&+ "& "&* $* E7;E?;5 63F3 8AD F:7 7CG3F;A@E 3D7 A4F3;@76 8DA? G@67DI3F7D E:A5= I3H7E 5D73F76 4K 7JB>AE;A@E 8DA? 3;D 9G@E ,:7 I3H7E 4AG@57 A88 EG4EGD8357 DA5=E 3@6 3D7 ?73EGD76 4K 97AB:A@7E 3FF35:76 FA ?;>7>A@9 534>7E 47:;@6 F:7 E:;B %) ')&)$$% &3@K ;?BADF3@F ?3@397?7@F 675;E;A@E FA63K 3D7 ?367 A@ F:7 43E;E A8 >;@73D BDA9D3??;@9 ?A67>E F:3F GF;>;L7 :G@6D76E A8 H3D;34>7E ,:7 3;D>;@7 ;@6GEFDK 8AD ;@EF3@57 7?B>AKE >;@73D BDA9D3?E F:3F E5:76G>7 T;9:F 5D7IE ?A@;FAD F:7 >A53F;A@E A8 3;D5D38F AD B>3@ F:7 H3D;76 E5:76G>7E A8 EGBBADF E7DH;57E EG5: 3E ?3;@F7@3@57 3@6 F7D?;@3> AB7D3F;A@E #+)# %+.&)"* @9;@77DE GE7 E;?G>3F;A@ EA8FI3D7 FA 67E;9@ 7>75FD;53> 5;D5G;FE 3@6 ?;5DA5:;BE ;@HA>H;@9 ?;>>;A@E A8 FD3@E;EFADE +G5: EA8FI3D7 D7>;7E A@ >;@73D 3>974D3 F75:@;CG7E 3@6 EKEF7?E A8 >;@73D 7CG3F;A@E WEB +KEF7?E A8 >;@73D 7CG3F;A@E >;7 3F F:7 :73DF A8 >;@73D 3>974D3 3@6 F:;E 5:3BF7D GE7E F:7? FA ;@FDA6G57 EA?7 A8 F:7 57@FD3> 5A@57BFE A8 >;@73D 3>974D3 ;@ 3 E;?B>7 3@6 5A@5D7F7 E7FF;@9 +75F;A@E 3@6 BD7E7@F 3 EKEF7?3F;5 ?7F:A6 8AD EA>H;@9 EKEF7?E A8 >;@73D 7CG3F;A@E ,:;E 3>9AD;F:? I;>> 47 GE76 8AD 5A?BGF3F;A@E F:DAG9:AGF F:7 F7JF +75F;A@E 3@6 E:AI :AI 3 EKEF7? A8 >;@73D 7CG3F;A@E ;E 7CG;H3>7@F FA 3 -+&) (,+&% 3@6 FA 3 $+)/ (,+&% ,:;E 7CG;H3>7@57 I;>> D76G57 BDA4>7?E ;@HA>H;@9 >;@73D 5A?4;@3F;A@E A8 H75FADE FA CG7EF;A@E 34AGF EKEF7?E A8 >;@73D 7CG3F;A@E ,:7 8G@63?7@F3> 5A@57BFE A8 EB3@@;@9 >;@73D ;@67B7@67@57 3@6 >;@73D FD3@E8AD?3F;A@E EFG6;76 ;@ F:7 E75A@6 :3>8 A8 F:7 5:3BF7D I;>> B>3K 3@ 7EE7@F;3> DA>7 F:DAG9:AGF F:7 F7JF 3E I7 7JB>AD7 F:7 473GFK 3@6 BAI7D A8 >;@73D 3>974D3 /-1)%5 )48%7-21 ;@ F:7 H3D;34>7E x 1 ;:::;x n ;E 3@ 7CG3F;A@ F:3F 53@ 47 ID;FF7@ ;@ F:7 8AD? a 1 x 1 C a 2 x 2 C C a n x n D b I:7D7 b 3@6 F:7 '2)*>'-)176 a 1 ;:::;a n 3D7 D73> AD 5A?B>7J @G?47DE GEG3>>K =@AI@ ;@ 36H3@57 ,:7 EG4E5D;BF n ?3K 47 3@K BAE;F;H7 ;@F797D "@ F7JF4AA= 7J3?B>7E 3@6 7J7D5;E7E n ;E @AD?3>>K 47FI77@ 3@6 "@ D73>>;87 BDA4>7?E n ?;9:F 47 AD AD 7H7@ >3D97D ,:7 7CG3F;A@E 4x 1 5x 2 C 2 D x 1 3@6 x 2 D 2 p 6 x 1 C x 3 3D7 4AF: >;@73D 4753GE7 F:7K 53@ 47 D73DD3@976 3>974D3;53>>K 3E ;@ 7CG3F;A@ 3x 1 5x 2 D 2 3@6 2x 1 C x 2 x 3 D 2 p 6 ,:7 7CG3F;A@E 4x 1 5x 2 D x 1 x 2 3@6 x 2 D 2 p x 1 6 3D7 @AF >;@73D 4753GE7 A8 F:7 BD7E7@57 A8 x 1 x 2 ;@ F:7 SDEF 7CG3F;A@ 3@6 p x 1 ;@ F:7 E75A@6 6<67)0 2* /-1)%5 )48%7-216 AD 3 /-1)%5 6<67)0 ;E 3 5A>>75F;A@ A8 A@7 AD ?AD7 >;@73D 7CG3F;A@E ;@HA>H;@9 F:7 E3?7 H3D;34>7EOE3K x 1 ;:::;x n @ 7J3?B>7 ;E 2x 1 x 2 C 1:5x 3 D 8 x 1 4x 3 D 7

$)15&3 & * )- ,'&+ & & * $ * - University of Utah

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: $)15&3 & * )- ,'&+ & & * $ * - University of Utah

�"&��*�)-�,"'&+�"&��"&��*��$ ��*�

E7;E?;5�63F3�8AD�F:7�7CG3F;A@E�3D7�A4F3;@76�8DA?G@67DI3F7D�E:A5=�I3H7E�5D73F76�4K�7JB>AE;A@E8DA?�3;D�9G@E ,:7�I3H7E�4AG@57�A88�EG4EGD8357DA5=E�3@6�3D7�?73EGD76�4K�97AB:A@7E�3FF35:76�FA?;>7>A@9�534>7E�47:;@6�F:7�E:;B

! � %��)�')&�)�$$ %� &3@K�;?BADF3@F�?3@397?7@F675;E;A@E�FA63K�3D7�?367�A@�F:7�43E;E�A8�>;@73DBDA9D3??;@9�?A67>E � F:3F �GF;>;L7 �:G@6D76E�A8H3D;34>7E ,:7�3;D>;@7 � ;@6GEFDK� 8AD � ;@EF3@57�

7?B>AKE�>;@73D�BDA9D3?E�F:3F�E5:76G>7�T;9:F�5D7IE�?A@;FAD�F:7�>A53F;A@E�A8�3;D5D38F� AD�B>3@�F:7�H3D;76E5:76G>7E�A8�EGBBADF�E7DH;57E�EG5:�3E�?3;@F7@3@573@6�F7D?;@3>�AB7D3F;A@E

! �#��+) ��#�%�+.&)"* �@9;@77DE�GE7�E;?G>3F;A@EA8FI3D7�FA�67E;9@�7>75FD;53>�5;D5G;FE�3@6�?;5DA5:;BE;@HA>H;@9�?;>>;A@E�A8�FD3@E;EFADE +G5:�EA8FI3D7D7>;7E�A@�>;@73D�3>974D3�F75:@;CG7E�3@6�EKEF7?E�A8>;@73D�7CG3F;A@E

WEB

+KEF7?E�A8�>;@73D�7CG3F;A@E�>;7�3F�F:7�:73DF�A8�>;@73D�3>974D3� 3@6�F:;E�5:3BF7D�GE7E�F:7?�FA;@FDA6G57�EA?7�A8�F:7�57@FD3>�5A@57BFE�A8�>;@73D�3>974D3�;@�3�E;?B>7�3@6�5A@5D7F7�E7FF;@9+75F;A@E� �3@6� ��BD7E7@F�3�EKEF7?3F;5�?7F:A6�8AD�EA>H;@9�EKEF7?E�A8�>;@73D�7CG3F;A@E,:;E�3>9AD;F:?�I;>>�47�GE76�8AD�5A?BGF3F;A@E�F:DAG9:AGF�F:7�F7JF +75F;A@E� ��3@6 ��E:AI�:AI�3�EKEF7?�A8�>;@73D�7CG3F;A@E�;E�7CG;H3>7@F�FA�3 -��+&)��(,�+ &% 3@6�FA�3$�+) /��(,�+ &% ,:;E�7CG;H3>7@57�I;>>�D76G57�BDA4>7?E�;@HA>H;@9�>;@73D�5A?4;@3F;A@EA8�H75FADE�FA�CG7EF;A@E�34AGF�EKEF7?E�A8�>;@73D�7CG3F;A@E ,:7�8G@63?7@F3>�5A@57BFE�A8EB3@@;@9� >;@73D�;@67B7@67@57� 3@6�>;@73D�FD3@E8AD?3F;A@E� EFG6;76�;@�F:7�E75A@6�:3>8�A8F:7�5:3BF7D� I;>>�B>3K�3@�7EE7@F;3>�DA>7�F:DAG9:AGF�F:7�F7JF�3E�I7�7JB>AD7�F:7�473GFK�3@6BAI7D�A8�>;@73D�3>974D3

� /-1)%5�)48%7-21 ;@�F:7�H3D;34>7E x1; : : : ; xn ;E�3@�7CG3F;A@�F:3F�53@�47�ID;FF7@�;@�F:78AD?

a1x1 C a2x2 C ! ! ! C anxn D b � �I:7D7 b 3@6�F:7 '2)*>'-)176 a1; : : : ; an 3D7�D73>�AD�5A?B>7J�@G?47DE� GEG3>>K�=@AI@;@�36H3@57 ,:7�EG4E5D;BF n ?3K�47�3@K�BAE;F;H7�;@F797D "@�F7JF4AA=�7J3?B>7E�3@67J7D5;E7E� n ;E�@AD?3>>K�47FI77@���3@6�� "@�D73>>;87�BDA4>7?E� n ?;9:F�47����AD������AD�7H7@�>3D97D

,:7�7CG3F;A@E

4x1 " 5x2 C 2 D x1 3@6 x2 D 2!p

6 " x1

"C x3

3D7�4AF:�>;@73D�4753GE7�F:7K�53@�47�D73DD3@976�3>974D3;53>>K�3E�;@�7CG3F;A@ � ��

3x1 " 5x2 D "2 3@6 2x1 C x2 " x3 D 2p

6

,:7�7CG3F;A@E4x1 " 5x2 D x1x2 3@6 x2 D 2

px1 " 6

3D7�@AF�>;@73D�4753GE7�A8�F:7�BD7E7@57�A8 x1x2 ;@�F:7�SDEF�7CG3F;A@�3@6p

x1 ;@�F:7�E75A@6� 6<67)0�2*�/-1)%5�)48%7-216 �AD�3 /-1)%5�6<67)0��;E�3�5A>>75F;A@�A8�A@7�AD�?AD7

>;@73D�7CG3F;A@E�;@HA>H;@9�F:7�E3?7�H3D;34>7EOE3K� x1; : : : ; xn �@�7J3?B>7�;E

2x1 " x2 C 1:5x3 D 8

x1 " 4x3 D "7���

Page 2: $)15&3 & * )- ,'&+ & & * $ * - University of Utah

�1+,�%+�'���"&��*�)-�,"'&+

� 62/87-21 A8�F:7�EKEF7?�;E�3�>;EF .s1; s2; : : : ; sn/ A8�@G?47DE�F:3F�?3=7E�735:�7CG3F;A@�3FDG7�EF3F7?7@F�I:7@�F:7�H3>G7E s1; : : : ; sn 3D7�EG4EF;FGF76�8AD x1; : : : ; xn� D7EB75F;H7>K �AD;@EF3@57� .5; 6:5; 3/ ;E�3�EA>GF;A@�A8�EKEF7?�����4753GE7� I:7@�F:7E7�H3>G7E�3D7�EG4EF;FGF76;@�����8AD x1; x2; x3� D7EB75F;H7>K� F:7�7CG3F;A@E�E;?B>;8K�FA 8 D 8 3@6 "7 D "7

,:7�E7F�A8�3>>�BAEE;4>7�EA>GF;A@E�;E�53>>76�F:7 62/87-21�6)7 A8�F:7�>;@73D�EKEF7? ,IA>;@73D�EKEF7?E�3D7�53>>76 )48-9%/)17 ;8�F:7K�:3H7�F:7�E3?7�EA>GF;A@�E7F ,:3F�;E� 735:EA>GF;A@�A8�F:7�SDEF�EKEF7?�;E�3�EA>GF;A@�A8�F:7�E75A@6�EKEF7?� 3@6�735:�EA>GF;A@�A8�F:7E75A@6�EKEF7?�;E�3�EA>GF;A@�A8�F:7�SDEF

�;@6;@9�F:7�EA>GF;A@�E7F�A8�3�EKEF7?�A8�FIA�>;@73D�7CG3F;A@E�;@�FIA�H3D;34>7E�;E�73EK4753GE7�;F�3?AG@FE�FA�S@6;@9�F:7�;@F7DE75F;A@�A8�FIA�>;@7E � FKB;53>�BDA4>7?�;E

x1 " 2x2 D "1

"x1 C 3x2 D 3

,:7�9D3B:E�A8�F:7E7�7CG3F;A@E�3D7�>;@7E� I:;5:�I7�67@AF7�4K `1 3@6 `2 � B3;D�A8�@G?47DE.x1; x2/ E3F;ES7E �&+� 7CG3F;A@E�;@�F:7�EKEF7?�;8�3@6�A@>K�;8�F:7�BA;@F .x1; x2/ >;7E�A@�4AF:`1 3@6 `2 "@�F:7�EKEF7?�34AH7� F:7�EA>GF;A@�;E�F:7�E;@9>7�BA;@F .3; 2/� 3E�KAG�53@�73E;>KH7D;8K +77��;9

2

3

x2

x1

l1

l2

�J35F>K�A@7�EA>GF;A@

(8�5AGDE7� FIA�>;@7E�@776�@AF�;@F7DE75F�;@�3�E;@9>7�BA;@FOF:7K�5AG>6�47�B3D3>>7>� ADF:7K�5AG>6�5A;@5;67�3@6�:7@57�P;@F7DE75FQ�3F�7H7DK�BA;@F�A@�F:7�>;@7 �;9GD7���E:AIE�F:79D3B:E�F:3F�5ADD7EBA@6�FA�F:7�8A>>AI;@9�EKEF7?E�

�3� x1 " 2x2 D "1

"x1 C 2x2 D 3

�4� x1 " 2x2 D "1

"x1 C 2x2 D 1

2

3

x2

x1

l1l2

(a)

2

3

x2

x1

l1

(b)

�3��'A�EA>GF;A@ �4��"@S@;F7>K�?3@K�EA>GF;A@E

�;9GD7E� �3@6���;>>GEFD3F7�F:7�8A>>AI;@9�97@7D3>�835F�34AGF�>;@73D�EKEF7?E� FA�47H7D;S76�;@�+75F;A@ �

Page 3: $)15&3 & * )- ,'&+ & & * $ * - University of Utah

�"&��*�)-�,"'&+�"&��"&��*��$ ��*�

� EKEF7?�A8�>;@73D�7CG3F;A@E�:3E

�� @A�EA>GF;A@� AD� 7J35F>K�A@7�EA>GF;A@� AD� ;@S@;F7>K�?3@K�EA>GF;A@E

� EKEF7?�A8�>;@73D�7CG3F;A@E�;E�E3;6�FA�47 '216-67)17 ;8�;F�:3E�7;F:7D�A@7�EA>GF;A@�AD;@S@;F7>K�?3@K�EA>GF;A@E� 3�EKEF7?�;E -1'216-67)17 ;8�;F�:3E�@A�EA>GF;A@

��,*"0��',�,"'&,:7�7EE7@F;3>�;@8AD?3F;A@�A8�3�>;@73D�EKEF7?�53@�47�D75AD676�5A?B35F>K�;@�3�D75F3@9G>3D3DD3K�53>>76�3 0%75-; ;H7@�F:7�EKEF7?

x1 " 2x2 C x3 D 0

2x2 " 8x3 D 8

"4x1 C 5x2 C 9x3 D "9

���

I;F:�F:7�5A78S5;7@FE�A8�735:�H3D;34>7�3>;9@76�;@�5A>G?@E� F:7�?3FD;J24

1 "2 10 2 "8

"4 5 9

35

;E�53>>76�F:7 '2)*>'-)17�0%75-; �AD 0%75-;�2*�'2)*>'-)176��A8�F:7�EKEF7?����� 3@624

1 "2 1 00 2 "8 8

"4 5 9 "9

35 ���

;E�53>>76�F:7 %8+0)17)(�0%75-; A8�F:7�EKEF7? �,:7�E75A@6�DAI�:7D7�5A@F3;@E�3�L7DA�4753GE7�F:7�E75A@6�7CG3F;A@�5AG>6�47�ID;FF7@�3E 0 ! x1 C 2x2 " 8x3 D 8� �@�3G9?7@F76?3FD;J�A8�3�EKEF7?�5A@E;EFE�A8�F:7�5A78S5;7@F�?3FD;J�I;F:�3@�36676�5A>G?@�5A@F3;@;@9F:7�5A@EF3@FE�8DA?�F:7�D;9:F�E;67E�A8�F:7�7CG3F;A@E

,:7 6-=) A8�3�?3FD;J�F7>>E�:AI�?3@K�DAIE�3@6�5A>G?@E�;F�:3E ,:7�3G9?7@F76�?3FD;J����34AH7�:3E���DAIE�3@6���5A>G?@E�3@6�;E�53>>76�3 3 # 4 �D736�P��4K��Q��?3FD;J "8 m3@6 n 3D7�BAE;F;H7�;@F797DE� 3@ m ! n 0%75-; ;E�3�D75F3@9G>3D�3DD3K�A8�@G?47DE�I;F: mDAIE�3@6 n 5A>G?@E �,:7�@G?47D�A8�DAIE�3>I3KE�5A?7E�SDEF� &3FD;J�@AF3F;A@�I;>>E;?B>;8K�F:7�53>5G>3F;A@E�;@�F:7�7J3?B>7E�F:3F�8A>>AI

�'$."& ����"&��*��1+,�%,:;E�E75F;A@�3@6�F:7�@7JF�67E5D;47�3@�3>9AD;F:?� AD�3�EKEF7?3F;5�BDA576GD7� 8AD�EA>H;@9>;@73D�EKEF7?E ,:7�43E;5�EFD3F79K�;E +&�)�'#����&%��*0*+�$�. +���%��(, -�#�%+�*0*+�$� ���� &%��. +��+���*�$��*&#,+ &%�*�+��+��+� *���* �)�+&�*&#-�

*AG9:>K�EB73=;@9� GE7�F:7 x1 F7D?�;@�F:7�SDEF�7CG3F;A@�A8�3�EKEF7?�FA�7>;?;@3F7F:7 x1 F7D?E�;@�F:7�AF:7D�7CG3F;A@E ,:7@�GE7�F:7 x2 F7D?�;@�F:7�E75A@6�7CG3F;A@�FA7>;?;@3F7�F:7 x2 F7D?E�;@�F:7�AF:7D�7CG3F;A@E� 3@6�EA�A@� G@F;>�KAG�S@3>>K�A4F3;@�3�H7DKE;?B>7�7CG;H3>7@F�EKEF7?�A8�7CG3F;A@E

,:D77�43E;5�AB7D3F;A@E�3D7�GE76�FA�E;?B>;8K�3�>;@73D�EKEF7?� *7B>357�A@7�7CG3F;A@4K�F:7�EG?�A8�;FE7>8�3@6�3�?G>F;B>7�A8�3@AF:7D�7CG3F;A@� ;@F7D5:3@97�FIA�7CG3F;A@E� 3@6?G>F;B>K�3>>�F:7�F7D?E�;@�3@�7CG3F;A@�4K�3�@A@L7DA�5A@EF3@F �8F7D�F:7�SDEF�7J3?B>7� KAGI;>>�E77�I:K�F:7E7�F:D77�AB7D3F;A@E�6A�@AF�5:3@97�F:7�EA>GF;A@�E7F�A8�F:7�EKEF7?

Page 4: $)15&3 & * )- ,'&+ & & * $ * - University of Utah

�1+,�%+�'���"&��*�)-�,"'&+

+A>H7�EKEF7?����

,:7�7>;?;@3F;A@�BDA576GD7�;E�E:AI@�:7D7�I;F:�3@6�I;F:AGF�?3FD;J�@AF3F;A@�3@6�F:7�D7EG>FE�3D7�B>3576�E;67�4K�E;67�8AD�5A?B3D;EA@�

x1 " 2x2 C x3 D 0

2x2 " 8x3 D 8

"4x1 C 5x2 C 9x3 D "9

24

1 "2 1 00 2 "8 8

"4 5 9 "9

35

���' x1 %�+���3)*+��(,�+ &%��%���# $ %�+�� +��)&$�+���&+��)��(,�+ &%*� ,A�6A�EA� 366��F;?7E�7CG3F;A@� �FA�7CG3F;A@�� �8F7D�EA?7�BD35F;57� F:;E�FKB7�A8�53>5G>3F;A@�;E�GEG3>>KB7D8AD?76�?7@F3>>K�

4 ! Œ7CG3F;A@� !WC Œ7CG3F;A@��!W

Œ@7I�7CG3F;A@��!W

4x1 " 8x2 C 4x3 D 0

"4x1 C 5x2 C 9x3 D "9

" 3x2 C 13x3 D "9

,:7�D7EG>F�A8�F:;E�53>5G>3F;A@�;E�ID;FF7@�;@�B>357�A8�F:7�AD;9;@3>�F:;D6�7CG3F;A@�

x1 " 2x2 C x3 D 0

2x2 " 8x3 D 8

" 3x2 C 13x3 D "9

24

1 "2 1 00 2 "8 80 "3 13 "9

35

'AI� ?G>F;B>K�7CG3F;A@���4K 1=2 ;@�AD67D�FA�A4F3;@� �3E�F:7�5A78S5;7@F�8AD x2 �,:;E53>5G>3F;A@�I;>>�E;?B>;8K�F:7�3D;F:?7F;5�;@�F:7�@7JF�EF7B�

x1 " 2x2 C x3 D 0

x2 " 4x3 D 4

" 3x2 C 13x3 D "9

24

1 "2 1 00 1 "4 40 "3 13 "9

35

-E7�F:7 x2 ;@�7CG3F;A@���FA�7>;?;@3F7�F:7"3x2 ;@�7CG3F;A@�� ,:7�P?7@F3>Q�5A?BGF3F;A@;E

3 ! Œ7CG3F;A@��!WC Œ7CG3F;A@��!W

1@7I�7CG3F;A@��!W

3x2 " 12x3 D 12

"3x2 C 13x3 D "9

x3 D 3

,:7�@7I�EKEF7?�:3E�3 +) �%�,#�) 8AD?�U

x1 " 2x2 C x3 D 0

x2 " 4x3 D 4

x3 D 3

24

1 "2 1 00 1 "4 40 0 1 3

35

�H7@FG3>>K� KAG�I3@F�FA�7>;?;@3F7�F:7"2x2 F7D?�8DA?�7CG3F;A@� � 4GF�;F�;E�?AD7�78S5;7@FFA�GE7�F:7 x3 ;@�7CG3F;A@���SDEF� FA�7>;?;@3F7�F:7"4x3 3@6Cx3 F7D?E�;@�7CG3F;A@E���3@6 ,:7�FIA�P?7@F3>Q�53>5G>3F;A@E�3D7

4 ! Œ7C �!WC Œ7C �!W

Œ@7I�7C �!W

4x3 D 12

x2 " 4x3 D 4

x2 D 16

"1 ! Œ7C �!WC Œ7C !W

Œ@7I�7C !W

" x3 D "3

x1 " 2x2 C x3 D 0

x1 " 2x2 D "3

U,:7�;@FG;F;H7�F7D? +) �%�,#�) I;>>�47�D7B>3576�4K�3�BD75;E7�F7D?�;@�F:7�@7JF�E75F;A@

Page 5: $)15&3 & * )- ,'&+ & & * $ * - University of Utah

�"&��*�)-�,"'&+�"&��"&��*��$ ��*�

"F�;E�5A@H7@;7@F�FA�5A?4;@7�F:7�D7EG>FE�A8�F:7E7�FIA�AB7D3F;A@E�

x1 " 2x2 D "3

x2 D 16

x3 D 3

24

1 "2 0 "30 1 0 160 0 1 3

35

'AI� :3H;@9�5>73@76�AGF�F:7�5A>G?@�34AH7�F:7 x3 ;@�7CG3F;A@��� ?AH7�435=�FA�F:7 x2 ;@7CG3F;A@���3@6�GE7�;F�FA�7>;?;@3F7�F:7 "2x2 34AH7�;F �753GE7�A8�F:7�BD7H;AGE�IAD=�I;F:x3� F:7D7�;E�@AI�@A�3D;F:?7F;5�;@HA>H;@9 x3 F7D?E �66���F;?7E�7CG3F;A@���FA�7CG3F;A@ �3@6�A4F3;@�F:7�EKEF7?�

8̂<:̂

x1 D 29

x2 D 16

x3 D 3

24

1 0 0 290 1 0 160 0 1 3

35

,:7�IAD=�;E�7EE7@F;3>>K�6A@7 "F�E:AIE�F:3F�F:7�A@>K�EA>GF;A@�A8�F:7�AD;9;@3>�EKEF7?�;E.29; 16; 3/ !AI7H7D� E;@57�F:7D7�3D7�EA�?3@K�53>5G>3F;A@E�;@HA>H76� ;F�;E�3�9AA6�BD35F;57FA�5:75=�F:7�IAD= ,A�H7D;8K�F:3F .29; 16; 3/ * 3�EA>GF;A@� EG4EF;FGF7�F:7E7�H3>G7E�;@FAF:7�>78F�E;67�A8�F:7�AD;9;@3>�EKEF7?� 3@6�5A?BGF7�

.29/ " 2.16/ C .3/ D 29 " 32 C 3 D 0

2.16/ " 8.3/ D 32 " 24 D 8

"4.29/ C 5.16/ C 9.3/ D "116 C 80 C 27 D "9

,:7�D7EG>FE�39D77�I;F:�F:7�D;9:F�E;67�A8�F:7�AD;9;@3>�EKEF7?� EA .29; 16; 3/ ;E�3�EA>GF;A@A8�F:7�EKEF7?

(29, 16, 3)

�35:�A8�F:7�AD;9;@3>�7CG3F;A@E67F7D?;@7E�3�B>3@7�;@�F:D776;?7@E;A@3>�EB357 ,:7�BA;@F.29; 16; 3/ >;7E�;@�3>>�F:D77�B>3@7E

�J3?B>7� �;>>GEFD3F7E�:AI�AB7D3F;A@E�A@�7CG3F;A@E�;@�3�>;@73D�EKEF7?�5ADD7EBA@6�FAAB7D3F;A@E�A@�F:7�3BBDABD;3F7�DAIE�A8�F:7�3G9?7@F76�?3FD;J ,:7�F:D77�43E;5�AB7D3F;A@E>;EF76�73D>;7D�5ADD7EBA@6�FA�F:7�8A>>AI;@9�AB7D3F;A@E�A@�F:7�3G9?7@F76�?3FD;J

�� �*7B>357?7@F��*7B>357�A@7�DAI�4K�F:7�EG?�A8�;FE7>8�3@6�3�?G>F;B>7�A8�3@AF:7DDAI�

� �"@F7D5:3@97��"@F7D5:3@97�FIA�DAIE� �+53>;@9��&G>F;B>K�3>>�7@FD;7E�;@�3�DAI�4K�3�@A@L7DA�5A@EF3@F

*AI�AB7D3F;A@E�53@�47�3BB>;76�FA�3@K�?3FD;J� @AF�?7D7>K�FA�A@7�F:3F�3D;E7E�3E�F:73G9?7@F76�?3FD;J�A8�3�>;@73D�EKEF7? ,IA�?3FD;57E�3D7�53>>76 52:�)48-9%/)17 ;8�F:7D7;E�3�E7CG7@57�A8�7>7?7@F3DK�DAI�AB7D3F;A@E�F:3F�FD3@E8AD?E�A@7�?3FD;J�;@FA�F:7�AF:7D

"F�;E�;?BADF3@F�FA�@AF7�F:3F�DAI�AB7D3F;A@E�3D7 )�-�)* �#� "8�FIA�DAIE�3D7�;@F7D5:3@976� F:7K�53@�47�D7FGD@76�FA�F:7;D�AD;9;@3>�BAE;F;A@E�4K�3@AF:7D�;@F7D5:3@97 "8�3DAI�;E�E53>76�4K�3�@A@L7DA�5A@EF3@F c� F:7@�?G>F;B>K;@9�F:7�@7I�DAI�4K 1=c BDA6G57EF:7�AD;9;@3>�DAI �;@3>>K� 5A@E;67D�3�D7B>357?7@F�AB7D3F;A@�;@HA>H;@9�FIA�DAIEOE3K�DAIE� �3@6��O3@6�EGBBAE7�F:3F c F;?7E�DAI� �;E�36676�FA�DAI���FA�BDA6G57�3�@7I�DAI��,A�PD7H7DE7Q�F:;E�AB7D3F;A@� 366 "c F;?7E�DAI� �FA��@7I��DAI���3@6�A4F3;@�F:7�AD;9;@3>DAI � +77��J7D5;E7E���N���3F�F:7�7@6�A8�F:;E�E75F;A@

V� 5A??A@�B3D3B:D3E7�A8�DAI�D7B>357?7@F�;E�P�66�FA�A@7�DAI�3�?G>F;B>7�A8�3@AF:7D�DAIQ

Page 6: $)15&3 & * )- ,'&+ & & * $ * - University of Utah

�1+,�%+�'���"&��*�)-�,"'&+

�F�F:7�?A?7@F� I7�3D7�;@F7D7EF76�;@�DAI�AB7D3F;A@E�A@�F:7�3G9?7@F76�?3FD;J�A8�3EKEF7?�A8�>;@73D�7CG3F;A@E +GBBAE7�3�EKEF7?�;E�5:3@976�FA�3�@7I�A@7�H;3�DAI�AB7D3F;A@E �K�5A@E;67D;@9�735:�FKB7�A8�DAI�AB7D3F;A@� KAG�53@�E77�F:3F�3@K�EA>GF;A@�A8�F:7AD;9;@3>�EKEF7?�D7?3;@E�3�EA>GF;A@�A8�F:7�@7I�EKEF7? �A@H7DE7>K� E;@57�F:7�AD;9;@3>EKEF7?�53@�47�BDA6G576�H;3�DAI�AB7D3F;A@E�A@�F:7�@7I�EKEF7?� 735:�EA>GF;A@�A8�F:7�@7IEKEF7?�;E�3>EA�3�EA>GF;A@�A8�F:7�AD;9;@3>�EKEF7? ,:;E�6;E5GEE;A@�<GEF;S7E�F:7�8A>>AI;@9EF3F7?7@F

"8�F:7�3G9?7@F76�?3FD;57E�A8�FIA�>;@73D�EKEF7?E�3D7�DAI�7CG;H3>7@F� F:7@�F:7�FIAEKEF7?E�:3H7�F:7�E3?7�EA>GF;A@�E7F

,:AG9:��J3?B>7� �;E�>7@9F:K� KAG�I;>>�S@6�F:3F�38F7D�EA?7�BD35F;57� F:7�53>5G>3F;A@E9A�CG;5=>K *AI�AB7D3F;A@E�;@�F:7�F7JF�3@6�7J7D5;E7E�I;>>�GEG3>>K�47�7JFD7?7>K�73EK�FAB7D8AD?� 3>>AI;@9�KAG�FA�8A5GE�A@�F:7�G@67D>K;@9�5A@57BFE +F;>>� KAG�?GEF�>73D@�FAB7D8AD?�DAI�AB7D3F;A@E�355GD3F7>K�4753GE7�F:7K�I;>>�47�GE76�F:DAG9:AGF�F:7�F7JF

,:7�D7EF�A8�F:;E�E75F;A@�E:AIE�:AI�FA�GE7�DAI�AB7D3F;A@E�FA�67F7D?;@7�F:7�E;L7�A8�3EA>GF;A@�E7F� I;F:AGF�5A?B>7F7>K�EA>H;@9�F:7�>;@73D�EKEF7?

0"+,�&����&���&")-�&�++��-�+,"'&++75F;A@ ��I;>>�E:AI�I:K�3�EA>GF;A@�E7F�8AD�3�>;@73D�EKEF7?�5A@F3;@E�7;F:7D�@A�EA>GF;A@E�A@7�EA>GF;A@� AD�;@S@;F7>K�?3@K�EA>GF;A@E �@EI7DE�FA�F:7�8A>>AI;@9�FIA�CG7EF;A@E�I;>>67F7D?;@7�F:7�@3FGD7�A8�F:7�EA>GF;A@�E7F�8AD�3�>;@73D�EKEF7?

,A�67F7D?;@7�I:;5:�BAEE;4;>;FK�;E�FDG7�8AD�3�B3DF;5G>3D�EKEF7?� I7�3E=�FIA�CG7EF;A@E

�� "E�F:7�EKEF7?�5A@E;EF7@F� F:3F�;E� 6A7E�3F�>73EF�A@7�EA>GF;A@ �/ *+�� "8�3�EA>GF;A@�7J;EFE� ;E�;F�F:7 &%#0 A@7� F:3F�;E� ;E�F:7�EA>GF;A@ ,% (,��

,:7E7�FIA�CG7EF;A@E�I;>>�3BB73D�F:DAG9:AGF�F:7�F7JF� ;@�?3@K�6;887D7@F�9G;E7E ,:;EE75F;A@�3@6�F:7�@7JF�I;>>�E:AI�:AI�FA�3@EI7D�F:7E7�CG7EF;A@E�H;3�DAI�AB7D3F;A@E�A@�F:73G9?7@F76�?3FD;J

�7F7D?;@7�;8�F:7�8A>>AI;@9�EKEF7?�;E�5A@E;EF7@F�

x1 " 2x2 C x3 D 0

2x2 " 8x3 D 8

"4x1 C 5x2 C 9x3 D "9

,:;E�;E�F:7�EKEF7?�8DA?��J3?B>7� +GBBAE7�F:3F�I7�:3H7�B7D8AD?76�F:7DAI�AB7D3F;A@E�@757EE3DK�FA�A4F3;@�F:7�FD;3@9G>3D�8AD?

x1 " 2x2 C x3 D 0

x2 " 4x3 D 4

x3 D 3

24

1 "2 1 00 1 "4 40 0 1 3

35

�F�F:;E�BA;@F� I7�=@AI x3 /7D7�I7�FA�EG4EF;FGF7�F:7�H3>G7�A8 x3 ;@FA�7CG3F;A@��� I75AG>6�5A?BGF7 x2 3@6�:7@57�5AG>6�67F7D?;@7 x1 8DA?�7CG3F;A@� +A�3�EA>GF;A@�7J;EFE�F:7�EKEF7?�;E�5A@E;EF7@F �"@�835F� x2 ;E�G@;CG7>K�67F7D?;@76�4K�7CG3F;A@���E;@57 x3 :3E

Page 7: $)15&3 & * )- ,'&+ & & * $ * - University of Utah

�"&��*�)-�,"'&+�"&��"&��*��$ ��*�

A@>K�A@7�BAEE;4>7�H3>G7� 3@6 x1 ;E�F:7D78AD7�G@;CG7>K�67F7D?;@76�4K�7CG3F;A@� +A�F:7EA>GF;A@�;E�G@;CG7�

�7F7D?;@7�;8�F:7�8A>>AI;@9�EKEF7?�;E�5A@E;EF7@F�

x2 " 4x3 D 8

2x1 " 3x2 C 2x3 D 1

5x1 " 8x2 C 7x3 D 1

���

,:7�3G9?7@F76�?3FD;J�;E

24

0 1 "4 82 "3 2 15 "8 7 1

35

,A�A4F3;@�3@ x1 ;@�F:7�SDEF�7CG3F;A@� ;@F7D5:3@97�DAIE� �3@6���

24

2 "3 2 10 1 "4 85 "8 7 1

35

,A�7>;?;@3F7�F:7 5x1 F7D?�;@�F:7�F:;D6�7CG3F;A@� 366 "5=2 F;?7E�DAI� �FA�DAI���

24

2 "3 2 10 1 "4 80 "1=2 2 "3=2

35 ���

'7JF� GE7�F:7 x2 F7D?�;@�F:7�E75A@6�7CG3F;A@�FA�7>;?;@3F7�F:7 ".1=2/x2 F7D?�8DA?�F:7F:;D6�7CG3F;A@ �66 1=2 F;?7E�DAI���FA�DAI ��

24

2 "3 2 10 1 "4 80 0 0 5=2

35 ���

,:7�3G9?7@F76�?3FD;J�;E�@AI�;@�FD;3@9G>3D�8AD? ,A�;@F7DBD7F�;F�5ADD75F>K� 9A�435=�FA7CG3F;A@�@AF3F;A@�

2x1 " 3x2 C 2x3 D 1

x2 " 4x3 D 8

0 D 5=2

���

,:7�7CG3F;A@ 0 D 5=2 ;E�3�E:ADF�8AD?�A8 0x1 C 0x2 C 0x3 D 5=2 ,:;E�EKEF7?�;@�FD;3@9G>3D�8AD?�A4H;AGE>K�:3E�3�4G;>F;@�5A@FD36;5F;A@ ,:7D7�3D7�@A�H3>G7E�A8 x1; x2; x3 F:3FE3F;E8K�����4753GE7�F:7�7CG3F;A@ 0 D 5=2 ;E�@7H7D�FDG7 +;@57�����3@6�����:3H7�F:7�E3?7EA>GF;A@�E7F� F:7�AD;9;@3>�EKEF7?�;E�;@5A@E;EF7@F��;7� :3E�@A�EA>GF;A@�

,:;E�EKEF7?�;E�;@5A@E;EF7@F4753GE7�F:7D7�;E�@A�BA;@F�F:3F�>;7E;@�3>>�F:D77�B>3@7E

)3K�5>AE7�3FF7@F;A@�FA�F:7�3G9?7@F76�?3FD;J�;@���� "FE�>3EF�DAI�;E�FKB;53>�A8�3@;@5A@E;EF7@F�EKEF7?�;@�FD;3@9G>3D�8AD?

Page 8: $)15&3 & * )- ,'&+ & & * $ * - University of Utah

�1+,�%+�'���"&��*�)-�,"'&+

"@�D73>IAD>6�BDA4>7?E� EKEF7?E�A8�>;@73D�7CG3F;A@E�3D7�EA>H76�4K�3�5A?BGF7D �AD3�ECG3D7�5A78S5;7@F�?3FD;J� 5A?BGF7D�BDA9D3?E�@73D>K�3>I3KE�GE7�F:7�7>;?;@3F;A@3>9AD;F:?�9;H7@�:7D7�3@6�;@�+75F;A@ �� ?A6;S76�E>;9:F>K�8AD�;?BDAH76�355GD35K

,:7�H3EF�?3<AD;FK�A8�>;@73D�3>974D3�BDA4>7?E�;@�4GE;@7EE�3@6�;@6GEFDK�3D7EA>H76�I;F:�BDA9D3?E�F:3F�GE7 4&�+ %��'& %+��) +�$�+ � 'G?47DE�3D7�D7BD7E7@F763E�675;?3>E˙:d1 ! ! ! dp # 10r � I:7D7 r ;E�3@�;@F797D�3@6�F:7�@G?47D p A8�6;9;FE�FAF:7�D;9:F�A8�F:7�675;?3>�BA;@F�;E�GEG3>>K�47FI77@���3@6� � �D;F:?7F;5�I;F:�EG5:@G?47DE�FKB;53>>K�;E�;@7J35F� 4753GE7�F:7�D7EG>F�?GEF�47�DAG@676��AD�FDG@53F76��FAF:7�@G?47D�A8�6;9;FE�EFAD76 P*AG@6A88�7DDADQ�;E�3>EA�;@FDA6G576�I:7@�3�@G?47DEG5:�3E 1=3 ;E�7@F7D76�;@FA�F:7�5A?BGF7D� E;@57�;FE�675;?3>�D7BD7E7@F3F;A@�?GEF�473BBDAJ;?3F76�4K�3�S@;F7�@G?47D�A8�6;9;FE �ADFG@3F7>K� ;@355GD35;7E�;@�TA3F;@9BA;@F�3D;F:?7F;5�E7>6A?�53GE7�BDA4>7?E ,:7�@G?7D;53>�@AF7E�;@�F:;E�4AA=�I;>>A553E;A@3>>K�I3D@�A8�;EEG7E�F:3F�KAG�?3K�@776�FA�5A@E;67D�>3F7D�;@�KAGD�53D77D

,:DAG9:AGF�F:7�F7JF� BD35F;57�BDA4>7?E�E:AG>6�47�3FF7?BF76�478AD7�IAD=;@9�F:7�7J7D5;E7E +A>GF;A@E�3BB73D�38F7D�735:�7J7D5;E7�E7F

�� +F3F7�;@�IAD6E�F:7�@7JF�7>7?7@F3DK�DAI�AB7D3F;A@�F:3F�E:AG>6�47�B7D8AD?76�A@�F:7EKEF7?�;@�AD67D�FA�EA>H7�;F 1&AD7�F:3@�A@7�3@EI7D�;E�BAEE;4>7�;@��3�23 x1 C 4x2 " 2x3 C 8x4 D 12

x2 " 7x3 C 2x4 D "4

5x3 " x4 D 7

x3 C 3x4 D "5

4 x1 " 3x2 C 5x3 " 2x4 D 0

x2 C 8x3 D "4

2x3 D 3

x4 D 1

� ,:7�3G9?7@F76�?3FD;J�A8�3�>;@73D�EKEF7?�:3E�477@�FD3@E8AD?76�4K�DAI�AB7D3F;A@E;@FA�F:7�8AD?�47>AI �7F7D?;@7�;8�F:7�EKEF7?�;E�5A@E;EF7@F2

41 5 2 "60 4 "7 20 0 5 0

35

� "E .3; 4; "2/ 3�EA>GF;A@�A8�F:7�8A>>AI;@9�EKEF7?�

5x1 " x2 C 2x3 D 7

"2x1 C 6x2 C 9x3 D 0

"7x1 C 5x2 " 3x3 D "7

�� �AD�I:3F�H3>G7E�A8 h 3@6 k ;E�F:7�8A>>AI;@9�EKEF7?�5A@E;EF7@F�

2x1 " x2 D h

"6x1 C 3x2 D k

Page 9: $)15&3 & * )- ,'&+ & & * $ * - University of Utah

�"&��*�)-�,"'&+�"&��"&��*��$ ��*�

+A>H7�735:�EKEF7?�;@��J7D5;E7E� N��4K�GE;@9�7>7?7@F3DK�DAIAB7D3F;A@E�A@�F:7�7CG3F;A@E�AD�A@�F:7�3G9?7@F76�?3FD;J �A>>AIF:7�EKEF7?3F;5�7>;?;@3F;A@�BDA576GD7�67E5D;476�;@�F:;E�E75F;A@

�� x1 C 5x2 D 7

"2x1 " 7x2 D "5

� 3x1 C 6x2 D "3

5x1 C 7x2 D 10

� �;@6�F:7�BA;@F .x1; x2/ F:3F�>;7E�A@�F:7�>;@7 x1 C 2x2 D 4 3@6A@�F:7�>;@7 x1 " x2 D 1 +77�F:7�S9GD7

x1 – x2 = 1

x1 + 2x2 = 4

x2

x1

�� �;@6�F:7�BA;@F�A8�;@F7DE75F;A@�A8�F:7�>;@7E x1 C 2x2 D "133@6 3x1 " 2x2 D 1

�A@E;67D�735:�?3FD;J�;@��J7D5;E7E���3@6���3E�F:7�3G9?7@F76�?3FD;JA8�3�>;@73D�EKEF7? +F3F7�;@�IAD6E�F:7�@7JF�FIA�7>7?7@F3DK�DAIAB7D3F;A@E�F:3F�E:AG>6�47�B7D8AD?76�;@�F:7�BDA57EE�A8�EA>H;@9�F:7EKEF7?

��

2664

1 "4 "3 0 70 1 4 0 60 0 1 0 20 0 0 1 "5

3775

2664

1 "6 4 0 "10 2 "7 0 40 0 1 2 "30 0 4 1 2

3775

"@��J7D5;E7E��N �� F:7�3G9?7@F76�?3FD;J�A8�3�>;@73D�EKEF7?�:3E477@�D76G576�4K�DAI�AB7D3F;A@E�FA�F:7�8AD?�E:AI@ "@�735:�53E7�5A@F;@G7�F:7�3BBDABD;3F7�DAI�AB7D3F;A@E�3@6�67E5D;47�F:7�EA>GF;A@E7F�A8�F:7�AD;9;@3>�EKEF7?

��

2664

1 7 3 "40 1 "1 30 0 0 10 0 1 "2

3775

��

2664

1 "5 4 0 00 1 0 1 00 0 3 0 00 0 0 2 0

3775

��

2664

1 "1 0 0 "50 1 "2 0 "70 0 1 "3 20 0 0 1 4

3775

���

2664

1 3 0 "2 "70 1 0 3 60 0 1 0 20 0 0 1 "2

3775

+A>H7�F:7�EKEF7?E�;@��J7D5;E7E� N �

��� x2 C 5x3 D "4

x1 C 4x2 C 3x3 D "2

2x1 C 7x2 C x3 D "2

�� x1 " 5x2 C 4x3 D "3

2x1 " 7x2 C 3x3 D "2

"2x1 C x2 C 7x3 D "1

�� x1 " 3x3 D 8

2x1 C 2x2 C 9x3 D 7

x2 C 5x3 D "2

��� 2x1 " 6x3 D "8

x2 C 2x3 D 3

3x1 C 6x2 " 2x3 D "4

�7F7D?;@7�;8�F:7�EKEF7?E�;@��J7D5;E7E� ��3@6� ��3D7�5A@E;EF7@F�A�@AF�5A?B>7F7>K�EA>H7�F:7�EKEF7?E

��� x1 " 6x2 D 5

x2 " 4x3 C x4 D 0

"x1 C 6x2 C x3 C 5x4 D 3

"x2 C 5x3 C 4x4 D 0

� � 2x1 " 4x4 D "10

3x2 C 3x3 D 0

x3 C 4x4 D "1

"3x1 C 2x2 C 3x3 C x4 D 5

��� �A� F:7 � F:D77 � >;@7E 2x1 C 3x2 D "1� 6x1 C 5x2 D 0� 3@62x1 " 5x2 D 7 :3H7�3�5A??A@�BA;@F�A8�;@F7DE75F;A@� �JB>3;@

��� �A�F:7�F:D77�B>3@7E 2x1 C 4x2 C 4x3 D 4� x2 " 2x3 D "2�3@6 2x1 C 3x2 D 0 :3H7�3F�>73EF�A@7�5A??A@�BA;@F�A8�;@F7DE75F;A@� �JB>3;@

"@��J7D5;E7E� �N��� 67F7D?;@7�F:7�H3>G7�E��A8 h EG5:�F:3F�F:7?3FD;J�;E�F:7�3G9?7@F76�?3FD;J�A8�3�5A@E;EF7@F�>;@73D�EKEF7?

���#

1 h 43 6 8

$��

#1 h "52 "8 6

$

��#

1 4 "23 h "6

$�

#"4 12 h

2 "6 "3

$

"@ ��J7D5;E7E ����3@6���� =7K�EF3F7?7@FE � 8DA?�F:;E �E75F;A@�3D77;F:7D�CGAF76�6;D75F>K� D7EF3F76�E>;9:F>K��4GF�EF;>>�FDG7�� AD�3>F7D76;@�EA?7�I3K�F:3F�?3=7E�F:7?�83>E7�;@�EA?7�53E7E &3D=�735:EF3F7?7@F�,DG7�AD��3>E7� 3@6 !,*+ �0 KAGD�3@EI7D �"8�FDG7� 9;H7�F:7

Page 10: $)15&3 & * )- ,'&+ & & * $ * - University of Utah

�1+,�%+�'���"&��*�)-�,"'&+

3BBDAJ;?3F7�>A53F;A@�I:7D7�3�E;?;>3D�EF3F7?7@F�3BB73DE� AD�D787DFA�3�67S@;F;A@�AD�F:7AD7? "8�83>E7� 9;H7�F:7�>A53F;A@�A8�3�EF3F7?7@FF:3F�:3E�477@�CGAF76�AD�GE76�;@5ADD75F>K� AD�5;F7�3@�7J3?B>7�F:3FE:AIE�F:7�EF3F7?7@F�;E�@AF�FDG7�;@�3>>�53E7E� +;?;>3D�FDG7�83>E7CG7EF;A@E�I;>>�3BB73D�;@�?3@K�E75F;A@E�A8�F:7�F7JF

� 3 �H7DK�7>7?7@F3DK�DAI�AB7D3F;A@�;E�D7H7DE;4>74 � 5 # 6 ?3FD;J�:3E�E;J�DAIE5 ,:7�EA>GF;A@�E7F�A8�3�>;@73D�EKEF7?�;@HA>H;@9�H3D;34>7E

x1; : : : ; xn ;E�3�>;EF�A8�@G?47DE .s1; : : : ; sn/ F:3F�?3=7E�735:7CG3F;A@�;@�F:7�EKEF7?�3�FDG7�EF3F7?7@F�I:7@�F:7�H3>G7Es1; : : : ; sn 3D7�EG4EF;FGF76�8AD x1; : : : ; xn� D7EB75F;H7>K

6 ,IA�8G@63?7@F3>�CG7EF;A@E�34AGF�3�>;@73D�EKEF7?�;@HA>H77J;EF7@57�3@6�G@;CG7@7EE

�� 3 ,IA�?3FD;57E�3D7�DAI�7CG;H3>7@F�;8�F:7K�:3H7�F:7�E3?7@G?47D�A8�DAIE

4 �>7?7@F3DK�DAI�AB7D3F;A@E�A@�3@�3G9?7@F76�?3FD;J�@7H7D5:3@97�F:7�EA>GF;A@�E7F�A8�F:7�3EEA5;3F76�>;@73D�EKEF7?

5 ,IA�7CG;H3>7@F�>;@73D�EKEF7?E�53@�:3H7�6;887D7@F�EA>GF;A@E7FE

6 � 5A@E;EF7@F�EKEF7?�A8�>;@73D�7CG3F;A@E�:3E�A@7�AD�?AD7EA>GF;A@E

�� �;@6 � 3@ � 7CG3F;A@ � ;@HA>H;@9 g� h� 3@6 k F:3F � ?3=7EF:;E�3G9?7@F76�?3FD;J�5ADD7EBA@6�FA�3�5A@E;EF7@F�EKEF7?�24

1 "4 7 g0 3 "5 h

"2 5 "9 k

35

� +GBBAE7�F:7�EKEF7?�47>AI�;E�5A@E;EF7@F�8AD�3>>�BAEE;4>7�H3>G7EA8 f 3@6 g /:3F�53@�KAG�E3K�34AGF�F:7�5A78S5;7@FE c 3@6d� #GEF;8K�KAGD�3@EI7D

2x1 C 4x2 D f

cx1 C dx2 D g

�� +GBBAE7 a� b� c� 3@6 d 3D7�5A@EF3@FE�EG5:�F:3F a ;E�@AF�L7DA3@6�F:7�EKEF7?�47>AI�;E�5A@E;EF7@F�8AD�3>>�BAEE;4>7�H3>G7E�A8f 3@6 g /:3F�53@�KAG�E3K�34AGF�F:7�@G?47DE a� b� c� 3@6d� #GEF;8K�KAGD�3@EI7D

ax1 C bx2 D f

cx1 C dx2 D g

�� �A@EFDG5F�F:D77�6;887D7@F�3G9?7@F76�?3FD;57E�8AD�>;@73D�EKEF7?E�I:AE7�EA>GF;A@�E7F�;E x1 D 3� x2 D "2� x3 D "1

"@��J7D5;E7E���N��� S@6�F:7�7>7?7@F3DK�DAI�AB7D3F;A@�F:3F�FD3@E8AD?E�F:7�SDEF�?3FD;J�;@FA�F:7�E75A@6� 3@6�F:7@�S@6�F:7�D7H7DE7DAI�AB7D3F;A@�F:3F�FD3@E8AD?E�F:7�E75A@6�?3FD;J�;@FA�F:7�SDEF

��

24

0 "2 51 3 "53 "1 6

35�

24

3 "1 61 3 "50 "2 5

35

��

24

1 3 "40 "2 60 "5 10

35�

24

1 3 "40 "2 60 1 "2

35

��

24

1 "2 1 00 5 "2 84 "1 3 "6

35�

24

1 "2 1 00 5 "2 80 7 "1 "6

35

24

1 2 "5 00 1 "3 "20 4 "12 7

35�

24

1 2 "5 00 1 "3 "20 0 0 15

35

�@�;?BADF3@F�5A@57D@�;@�F:7�EFG6K�A8�:73F�FD3@E87D�;E�FA�67F7D?;@7F:7�EF736KEF3F7�F7?B7D3FGD7�6;EFD;4GF;A@�A8�3�F:;@�B>3F7�I:7@�F:7F7?B7D3FGD7�3DAG@6�F:7�4AG@63DK�;E�=@AI@ �EEG?7�F:7�B>3F7E:AI@�;@�F:7�S9GD7�D7BD7E7@FE�3�5DAEE�E75F;A@�A8�3�?7F3>�473?�I;F:�@79>;9;4>7�:73F�TAI�;@�F:7�6;D75F;A@�B7DB7@6;5G>3D�FA�F:7B>3F7 %7F T1; : : : ; T4 67@AF7�F:7�F7?B7D3FGD7E�3F�F:7�8AGD�;@F7D;AD@A67E�A8�F:7�?7E:�;@�F:7�S9GD7 ,:7�F7?B7D3FGD7�3F�3�@A67�;E3BBDAJ;?3F7>K�7CG3>�FA�F:7�3H7D397�A8�F:7�8AGD�@73D7EF�@A67EOFAF:7�>78F� 34AH7� FA�F:7�D;9:F� 3@6�47>AI� �AD�;@EF3@57�T1 D .10 C 20 C T2 C T4/=4; AD 4T1 " T2 " T4 D 30

10°

10°

40°

40°

20° 20°

30° 30°

1 2

4 3

� /D;F7�3�EKEF7?�A8�8AGD�7CG3F;A@E�I:AE7�EA>GF;A@�9;H7E�7EF;?3F7E�8AD�F:7�F7?B7D3FGD7E T1; : : : ; T4

�� +A>H7�F:7�EKEF7?�A8�7CG3F;A@E�8DA?��J7D5;E7��� 1� %+� ,AEB776�GB�F:7�53>5G>3F;A@E� ;@F7D5:3@97�DAIE� �3@6���478AD7EF3DF;@9�PD7B>357Q�AB7D3F;A@E2

3 +77��D3@=�&�/:;F7� ���+��%����**��)�%*��) �*736;@9� &���66;EA@/7E>7K�)G4>;E:;@9� �� �� BB ��N ��

�� 3 �AD�P:3@6�5A?BGF3F;A@�Q F:7�47EF�5:A;57�;E�FA�;@F7D5:3@97�7CG3F;A@E���3@6���@AF:7D�BAEE;4;>;FK�;E�FA�?G>F;B>K�7CG3F;A@���4K 1=5 (D� D7B>357�7CG3F;A@���4K;FE�EG?�I;F: "1=5 F;?7E�DAI�� �"@�3@K�53E7� 6A�@AF�GE7�F:7 x2 ;@�7CG3F;A@ ��FA7>;?;@3F7�F:7 4x2 ;@�7CG3F;A@� /3;F�G@F;>�3�FD;3@9G>3D�8AD?�:3E�477@�D735:76�3@6F:7 x3 F7D?E�3@6 x4 F7D?E�:3H7�477@�7>;?;@3F76�8DA?�F:7�SDEF�FIA�7CG3F;A@E�

Page 11: $)15&3 & * )- ,'&+ & & * $ * - University of Utah

�"&��*�)-�,"'&+�"&��"&��*��$ ��*�

4 ,:7�EKEF7?�;E�;@�FD;3@9G>3D�8AD? �GDF:7D�E;?B>;S53F;A@�479;@E�I;F:�F:7 x4 ;@�F:78AGDF:�7CG3F;A@ -E7�F:7 x4 FA�7>;?;@3F7�3>> x4 F7D?E�34AH7�;F ,:7�3BBDABD;3F7EF7B�@AI�;E�FA�366���F;?7E�7CG3F;A@���FA�7CG3F;A@� ��8F7D�F:3F� ?AH7�FA�7CG3F;A@�� ?G>F;B>K�;F�4K 1=2� 3@6�F:7@�GE7�F:7�7CG3F;A@�FA�7>;?;@3F7�F:7 x3 F7D?E�34AH7;F�

� ,:7�EKEF7?�5ADD7EBA@6;@9�FA�F:7�3G9?7@F76�?3FD;J�;E

x1 C 5x2 C 2x3 D "6

4x2 " 7x3 D 2

5x3 D 0

,:7�F:;D6�7CG3F;A@�?3=7E x3 D 0� I:;5:�;E�57DF3;@>K�3@�3>>AI34>7�H3>G7�8AD x3 �8F7D7>;?;@3F;@9�F:7 x3 F7D?E�;@�7CG3F;A@E� �3@6��� KAG�5AG>6�9A�A@�FA�EA>H7�8AD�G@;CG7H3>G7E�8AD x2 3@6 x1 !7@57�3�EA>GF;A@�7J;EFE� 3@6�;F�;E�G@;CG7 �A@FD3EF�F:;E�E;FG3F;A@I;F:�F:3F�;@��J3?B>7 �

� "F�;E�73EK�FA�5:75=�;8�3�EB75;S5�>;EF�A8�@G?47DE�;E�3�EA>GF;A@ +7F x1 D 3� x2 D 4� 3@6x3 D "2� 3@6�S@6�F:3F

5.3/ " .4/ C 2."2/ D 15 " 4 " 4 D 7

"2.3/ C 6.4/ C 9."2/ D "6 C 24 " 18 D 0

"7.3/ C 5.4/ " 3."2/ D "21 C 20 C 6 D 5

�>F:AG9:�F:7�SDEF�FIA�7CG3F;A@E�3D7�E3F;ES76� F:7�F:;D6�;E�@AF� EA .3; 4; "2/ ;E�@AF�3EA>GF;A@�A8�F:7�EKEF7? 'AF;57�F:7�GE7�A8�B3D7@F:7E7E�I:7@�?3=;@9�F:7�EG4EF;FGF;A@E,:7K�3D7�EFDA@9>K�D75A??7@676�3E�3�9G3D6�393;@EF�3D;F:?7F;5�7DDADE

(3, 4, –2)

+;@57 .3; 4; "2/ E3F;ES7E�F:7�SDEFFIA�7CG3F;A@E� ;F�;E�A@�F:7�>;@7�A8F:7�;@F7DE75F;A@�A8�F:7�SDEF�FIAB>3@7E +;@57 .3; 4; "2/ 6A7E�@AFE3F;E8K�3>>�F:D77�7CG3F;A@E� ;F�6A7E@AF�>;7�A@�3>>�F:D77�B>3@7E

�� /:7@�F:7�E75A@6�7CG3F;A@�;E�D7B>3576�4K�;FE�EG?�I;F:���F;?7E�F:7�SDEF�7CG3F;A@� F:7EKEF7?�475A?7E

2x1 " x2 D h

0 D k C 3h

"8 k C 3h ;E�@A@L7DA� F:7�EKEF7?�:3E�@A�EA>GF;A@ ,:7�EKEF7?�;E�5A@E;EF7@F�8AD�3@KH3>G7E�A8 h 3@6 k F:3F�?3=7 k C 3h D 0

,:;E�E75F;A@�D7S@7E�F:7�?7F:A6�A8�+75F;A@ �;@FA�3�DAI�D76G5F;A@�3>9AD;F:?�F:3F�I;>>7@34>7�GE�FA�3@3>KL7�3@K�EKEF7?�A8�>;@73D�7CG3F;A@EU �K�GE;@9�A@>K�F:7�SDEF�B3DF�A8F:7�3>9AD;F:?� I7�I;>>�47�34>7�FA�3@EI7D�F:7�8G@63?7@F3>�7J;EF7@57�3@6�G@;CG7@7EECG7EF;A@E�BAE76�;@�+75F;A@

,:7�3>9AD;F:?�3BB>;7E�FA�3@K�?3FD;J� I:7F:7D�AD�@AF�F:7�?3FD;J�;E�H;7I76�3E�3@3G9?7@F76�?3FD;J�8AD�3�>;@73D�EKEF7? +A�F:7�SDEF�B3DF�A8�F:;E�E75F;A@�5A@57D@E�3@3D4;FD3DK�D75F3@9G>3D�?3FD;J�3@6�479;@E�4K�;@FDA6G5;@9�FIA�;?BADF3@F�5>3EE7E�A8�?3FD;57EF:3F�;@5>G67�F:7�PFD;3@9G>3DQ�?3FD;57E�A8�+75F;A@ "@�F:7�67S@;F;A@E�F:3F�8A>>AI� 3%&%1�)& DAI�AD�5A>G?@�;@�3�?3FD;J�?73@E�3�DAI�AD�5A>G?@�F:3F�5A@F3;@E�3F�>73EF�A@7@A@L7DA�7@FDK� 3 /)%(-1+�)175< A8�3�DAI�D787DE�FA�F:7�>78F?AEF�@A@L7DA�7@FDK��;@�3�@A@L7DADAI�

U,:7�3>9AD;F:?�:7D7�;E�3�H3D;3@F�A8�I:3F�;E�5A??A@>K�53>>76 �,** �%��# $ %�+ &% � E;?;>3D�7>;?;@3F;A@?7F:A6�8AD�>;@73D�EKEF7?E�I3E�GE76�4K��:;@7E7�?3F:7?3F;5;3@E�;@�34AGF���� �� ,:7�BDA57EE�I3E�G@=@AI@;@�/7EF7D@�5G>FGD7�G@F;>�F:7�@;@7F77@F:�57@FGDK� I:7@�3�83?AGE� 7D?3@�?3F:7?3F;5;3@� �3D>��D;76D;5:� 3GEE�6;E5AH7D76�;F � 7D?3@�7@9;@77D� /;>:7>?�#AD63@� BABG>3D;L76�F:7�3>9AD;F:?�;@�3@� ����F7JF�A@�97A67EK

Page 12: $)15&3 & * )- ,'&+ & & * $ * - University of Utah

�'/����-�,"'&��&���!�$'&�'*%+

� D75F3@9G>3D�?3FD;J�;E�;@ )',)/21�*250 �AD 52:�)',)/21�*250��;8�;F�:3E�F:78A>>AI;@9�F:D77�BDAB7DF;7E�

�� �>>�@A@L7DA�DAIE�3D7�34AH7�3@K�DAIE�A8�3>>�L7DAE� �35:�>736;@9�7@FDK�A8�3�DAI�;E�;@�3�5A>G?@�FA�F:7�D;9:F�A8�F:7�>736;@9�7@FDK�A8F:7�DAI�34AH7�;F

� �>>�7@FD;7E�;@�3�5A>G?@�47>AI�3�>736;@9�7@FDK�3D7�L7DAE

"8�3�?3FD;J�;@�75:7>A@�8AD?�E3F;ES7E�F:7�8A>>AI;@9�366;F;A@3>�5A@6;F;A@E� F:7@�;F�;E;@ 5)(8')(�)',)/21�*250 �AD 5)(8')(�52:�)',)/21�*250��

�� ,:7�>736;@9�7@FDK�;@�735:�@A@L7DA�DAI�;E� �� �35:�>736;@9� �;E�F:7�A@>K�@A@L7DA�7@FDK�;@�;FE�5A>G?@

�@ )',)/21�0%75-; �D7EB75F;H7>K� 5)(8')(�)',)/21�0%75-;��;E�A@7�F:3F�;E�;@�75:7>A@8AD?��D7EB75F;H7>K� D76G576�75:7>A@�8AD?� )DAB7DFK���E3KE�F:3F�F:7�>736;@9�7@FD;7E�8AD?3@ ����#&% �PEF7B>;=7Q��B3FF7D@�F:3F�?AH7E�6AI@�3@6�FA�F:7�D;9:F�F:DAG9:�F:7�?3FD;J)DAB7DFK���;E�3�E;?B>7�5A@E7CG7@57�A8�BDAB7DFK��� 4GF�I7�;@5>G67�;F�8AD�7?B:3E;E

,:7�PFD;3@9G>3DQ�?3FD;57E�A8�+75F;A@ � EG5:�3E24

2 "3 2 10 1 "4 80 0 0 5=2

35 3@6

24

1 0 0 290 1 0 160 0 1 3

35

3D7�;@�75:7>A@�8AD? "@�835F� F:7�E75A@6�?3FD;J�;E�;@�D76G576�75:7>A@�8AD? !7D7�3D7366;F;A@3>�7J3?B>7E

,:7�8A>>AI;@9�?3FD;57E�3D7�;@�75:7>A@�8AD? ,:7�>736;@9�7@FD;7E�� �?3K�:3H7�3@K�@A@L7DA�H3>G7� F:7�EF3DD76�7@FD;7E��$��?3K�:3H7�3@K�H3>G7��;@5>G6;@9�L7DA�

2664

$ $ $0 $ $0 0 0 00 0 0 0

3775;

266664

0 $ $ $ $ $ $ $ $0 0 0 $ $ $ $ $ $0 0 0 0 $ $ $ $ $0 0 0 0 0 $ $ $ $0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 $

377775

,:7�8A>>AI;@9�?3FD;57E�3D7�;@�D76G576�75:7>A@�8AD?�4753GE7�F:7�>736;@9�7@FD;7E�3D7� RE�3@6�F:7D7�3D7��RE�47>AI �%����&-� 735:�>736;@9�

2664

1 0 $ $0 1 $ $0 0 0 00 0 0 0

3775;

266664

0 1 $ 0 0 0 $ $ 0 $0 0 0 1 0 0 $ $ 0 $0 0 0 0 1 0 $ $ 0 $0 0 0 0 0 1 $ $ 0 $0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 $

377775

�@K�@A@L7DA�?3FD;J�?3K�47 52:�5)(8')( �F:3F�;E� FD3@E8AD?76�4K�7>7?7@F3DK�DAIAB7D3F;A@E��;@FA�?AD7�F:3@�A@7�?3FD;J�;@�75:7>A@�8AD?� GE;@9�6;887D7@F�E7CG7@57E�A8�DAIAB7D3F;A@E !AI7H7D� F:7�D76G576�75:7>A@�8AD?�A@7�A4F3;@E�8DA?�3�?3FD;J�;E�G@;CG7,:7�8A>>AI;@9�F:7AD7?�;E�BDAH76�;@��BB7@6;J�� 3F�F:7�7@6�A8�F:7�F7JF

�35:�?3FD;J�;E�DAI�7CG;H3>7@F�FA�A@7�3@6�A@>K�A@7�D76G576�75:7>A@�?3FD;J

Page 13: $)15&3 & * )- ,'&+ & & * $ * - University of Utah

�"&��*�)-�,"'&+�"&��"&��*��$ ��*�

"8�3�?3FD;J A ;E�DAI�7CG;H3>7@F�FA�3@�75:7>A@�?3FD;J U � I7�53>> U %1�)',)/21�*250�AD�DAI�75:7>A@�8AD?� 2* A� ;8 U ;E�;@�D76G576�75:7>A@�8AD?� I7�53>> U 7,)�5)(8')()',)/21�*250�2* A 1&AEF�?3FD;J�BDA9D3?E�3@6�53>5G>3FADE�I;F:�?3FD;J�53B34;>;F;7EGE7�F:7�344D7H;3F;A@�**�� 8AD�D76G576��DAI��75:7>A@�8AD? +A?7�GE7�*�� 8AD��DAI�75:7>A@�8AD?2

�".',��'+","'&+/:7@�DAI�AB7D3F;A@E�A@�3�?3FD;J�BDA6G57�3@�75:7>A@�8AD?� 8GDF:7D�DAI�AB7D3F;A@E�FAA4F3;@�F:7�D76G576�75:7>A@�8AD?�6A�@AF�5:3@97�F:7�BAE;F;A@E�A8�F:7�>736;@9�7@FD;7E +;@57F:7�D76G576�75:7>A@�8AD?�;E�G@;CG7� +���#��� %���%+) �*��)���#.�0*� %�+���*�$��'&* + &%* %��%0�����#&%��&)$�&�+� %����)&$���� -�%�$�+) /� ,:7E7�>736;@9�7@FD;7E�5ADD7EBA@6�FA>736;@9� RE�;@�F:7�D76G576�75:7>A@�8AD?

� 3-927�326-7-21 ;@�3�?3FD;J A ;E�3�>A53F;A@�;@ A F:3F�5ADD7EBA@6E�FA�3�>736;@9� ;@�F:7�D76G576�75:7>A@�8AD?�A8 A � 3-927�'2/801 ;E�3�5A>G?@�A8 A F:3F�5A@F3;@E3�B;HAF�BAE;F;A@

"@��J3?B>7� � F:7�ECG3D7E�� ��;67@F;8K�F:7�B;HAF�BAE;F;A@E &3@K�8G@63?7@F3>5A@57BFE�;@�F:7�SDEF�8AGD�5:3BF7DE�I;>>�47�5A@@75F76�;@�A@7�I3K�AD�3@AF:7D�I;F:�B;HAFBAE;F;A@E�;@�3�?3FD;J

*AI�D76G57�F:7�?3FD;J A 47>AI�FA�75:7>A@�8AD?� 3@6�>A53F7�F:7�B;HAF5A>G?@E�A8 A

A D

2664

0 "3 "6 4 9"1 "2 "1 3 1"2 "3 0 3 "1

1 4 5 "9 "7

3775

-E7�F:7�E3?7�43E;5�EFD3F79K�3E�;@�+75F;A@ ,:7�FAB�A8�F:7�>78F?AEF@A@L7DA�5A>G?@�;E�F:7�SDEF�B;HAF�BAE;F;A@ � @A@L7DA�7@FDK� AD ' -&+� ?GEF�47�B>3576;@�F:;E�BAE;F;A@ � 9AA6�5:A;57�;E�FA�;@F7D5:3@97�DAIE� �3@6����4753GE7�F:7�?7@F3>5A?BGF3F;A@E�;@�F:7�@7JF�EF7B�I;>>�@AF�;@HA>H7�8D35F;A@E�

2664

1 ✛);HAF

4 5 "9 "7"1 "2 "1 3 1"2 "3 0 3 "1

0

✻ );HAF�5A>G?@

"3 "6 4 9

3775

�D73F7�L7DAE�47>AI�F:7�B;HAF� � 4K�366;@9�?G>F;B>7E�A8�F:7�SDEF�DAI�FA�F:7�DAIE�47>AI�3@6�A4F3;@�?3FD;J�� ��47>AI ,:7�B;HAF�BAE;F;A@�;@�F:7�E75A@6�DAI�?GEF�47�3E�83D�>78F3E�BAEE;4>7O@3?7>K� ;@�F:7�E75A@6�5A>G?@ �:AAE7�F:7���;@�F:;E�BAE;F;A@�3E�F:7�@7JFB;HAF

2664

1 4 5 "9 "70 2 ✛

);HAF

4 "6 "60 5 10 "15 "150 "3

✻ '7JF�B;HAF�5A>G?@

"6 4 9

3775 � �

Page 14: $)15&3 & * )- ,'&+ & & * $ * - University of Utah

�'/����-�,"'&��&���!�$'&�'*%+

�66 "5=2 F;?7E�DAI���FA�DAI��� 3@6�366 3=2 F;?7E�DAI���FA�DAI��2664

1 4 5 "9 "70 2 4 "6 "60 0 0 0 00 0 0 "5 0

3775 ���

,:7�?3FD;J�;@�����;E�6;887D7@F�8DA?�3@K�7@5AG@F7D76�;@�+75F;A@ ,:7D7�;E�@A�I3K�FA5D73F7�3�>736;@9�7@FDK�;@�5A>G?@��� �/7�53@RF�GE7�DAI� �AD���4753GE7�6A;@9�EA�IAG>667EFDAK�F:7�75:7>A@�3DD3@97?7@F�A8�F:7�>736;@9�7@FD;7E�3>D736K�BDA6G576� !AI7H7D� ;8I7�;@F7D5:3@97�DAIE���3@6��� I7�53@�BDA6G57�3�>736;@9�7@FDK�;@�5A>G?@��

2664

1 4 5 "9 "70 2 4 "6 "60 0 0 "5✛

);HAF

00

✻ ✻ ✻ );HAF�5A>G?@E

0 0 0 0

3775 7@7D3>�8AD?�

2664

$ $ $ $0 $ $ $0 0 0 $0 0 0 0 0

3775

,:7�?3FD;J�;E�;@�75:7>A@�8AD?�3@6�F:GE�D7H73>E�F:3F�5A>G?@E� � �� 3@6���A8 A 3D7�B;HAF5A>G?@E

A D

2664

0✛✛

);HAF�BAE;F;A@E"3 "6 4 9

"1 "2 "1 3 1"2 "3 0 3 "1

1

✻ ✻ ✻ );HAF�5A>G?@E

4 5 "9 "7

3775 ���

� 3-927� 3E�;>>GEFD3F76�;@��J3?B>7��� ;E�3�@A@L7DA�@G?47D�;@�3�B;HAF�BAE;F;A@�F:3F�;EGE76�3E�@77676�FA�5D73F7�L7DAE�H;3�DAI�AB7D3F;A@E ,:7�B;HAFE�;@��J3?B>7���I7D7� � ��3@6 "5 'AF;57�F:3F�F:7E7�@G?47DE�3D7�@AF�F:7�E3?7�3E�F:7�35FG3>�7>7?7@FE�A8 A ;@�F:7:;9:>;9:F76�B;HAF�BAE;F;A@E�E:AI@�;@����

/;F:��J3?B>7���3E�3�9G;67� I7�3D7�D736K�FA�67E5D;47�3@�78S5;7@F�BDA576GD7�8ADFD3@E8AD?;@9�3�?3FD;J�;@FA�3@�75:7>A@�AD�D76G576�75:7>A@�?3FD;J �3D78G>�EFG6K�3@6?3EF7DK�A8�F:;E�BDA576GD7�@AI�I;>>�B3K�D;5:�6;H;67@6E�>3F7D�;@�F:7�5AGDE7

�!���'/����-�,"'&��$ '*",!%,:7�3>9AD;F:?�F:3F�8A>>AIE�5A@E;EFE�A8�8AGD�EF7BE� 3@6�;F�BDA6G57E�3�?3FD;J�;@�75:7>A@8AD? � S8F:�EF7B�BDA6G57E�3�?3FD;J�;@�D76G576�75:7>A@�8AD? /7�;>>GEFD3F7�F:7�3>9AD;F:?4K�3@�7J3?B>7

�BB>K�7>7?7@F3DK�DAI�AB7D3F;A@E�FA�FD3@E8AD?�F:7�8A>>AI;@9�?3FD;JSDEF�;@FA�75:7>A@�8AD?�3@6�F:7@�;@FA�D76G576�75:7>A@�8AD?�2

40 3 "6 6 4 "53 "7 8 "5 8 93 "9 12 "9 6 15

35

�79;@�I;F:�F:7�>78F?AEF�@A@L7DA�5A>G?@ ,:;E�;E�3�B;HAF�5A>G?@ ,:7�B;HAFBAE;F;A@�;E�3F�F:7�FAB

Page 15: $)15&3 & * )- ,'&+ & & * $ * - University of Utah

�"&��*�)-�,"'&+�"&��"&��*��$ ��*�

24

0 3 "6 6 4 "53 "7 8 "5 8 93

✻ );HAF�5A>G?@"9 12 "9 6 15

35

+7>75F�3�@A@L7DA�7@FDK�;@�F:7�B;HAF�5A>G?@�3E�3�B;HAF "8�@757EE3DK� ;@F7D5:3@97DAIE�FA�?AH7�F:;E�7@FDK�;@FA�F:7�B;HAF�BAE;F;A@

"@F7D5:3@97�DAIE� �3@6�� �/7�5AG>6�:3H7�;@F7D5:3@976�DAIE� �3@6���;@EF736�

24

3✛);HAF

"9 12 "9 6 153 "7 8 "5 8 90 3 "6 6 4 "5

35

-E7�DAI�D7B>357?7@F�AB7D3F;A@E�FA�5D73F7�L7DAE�;@�3>>�BAE;F;A@E�47>AI�F:7�B;HAF

�E�3�BD7>;?;@3DK�EF7B� I7�5AG>6�6;H;67�F:7�FAB�DAI�4K�F:7�B;HAF� � �GF�I;F:�FIA��RE�;@5A>G?@� � ;F�;E�<GEF�3E�73EK�FA�366 "1 F;?7E�DAI� �FA�DAI��

24

3✛);HAF

"9 12 "9 6 150 2 "4 4 2 "60 3 "6 6 4 "5

35

�AH7D��AD�;9@AD7��F:7�DAI�5A@F3;@;@9�F:7�B;HAF�BAE;F;A@�3@6�5AH7D�3>>�DAIE� ;8�3@K�34AH7�;F �BB>K�EF7BE� N��FA�F:7�EG4?3FD;J�F:3F�D7?3;@E *7B73F�F:7�BDA57EE�G@F;>F:7D7�3D7�@A�?AD7�@A@L7DA�DAIE�FA�?A6;8K

/;F:�DAI� �5AH7D76� EF7B� �E:AIE�F:3F�5A>G?@���;E�F:7�@7JF�B;HAF�5A>G?@� 8AD�EF7B���E7>75F�3E�3�B;HAF�F:7�PFABQ�7@FDK�;@�F:3F�5A>G?@

24

3 "9 12 "9 6 150 2 ✛

);HAF

"4 4 2 "60 3

✻ '7I�B;HAF�5A>G?@

"6 6 4 "5

35

�AD�EF7B��� I7�5AG>6�;@E7DF�3@�ABF;A@3>�EF7B�A8�6;H;6;@9�F:7�PFABQ�DAI�A8�F:7�EG4?3FD;J�4KF:7�B;HAF� � "@EF736� I7�366 "3=2 F;?7E�F:7�PFABQ�DAI�FA�F:7�DAI�47>AI ,:;E�BDA6G57E

24

3 "9 12 "9 6 150 2 "4 4 2 "60 0 0 0 1 4

35

Page 16: $)15&3 & * )- ,'&+ & & * $ * - University of Utah

�'/����-�,"'&��&���!�$'&�'*%+

/:7@�I7�5AH7D�F:7�DAI�5A@F3;@;@9�F:7�E75A@6�B;HAF�BAE;F;A@�8AD�EF7B��� I7�3D7�>78F�I;F:3�@7I�EG4?3FD;J�:3H;@9�A@>K�A@7�DAI�

24

3 "9 12 "9 6 150 2 "4 4 2 "60 0 0 0 1 ✛

);HAF4

35

+F7BE� N��D7CG;D7�@A�IAD=�8AD�F:;E�EG4?3FD;J� 3@6�I7�:3H7�D735:76�3@�75:7>A@�8AD?�A8F:7�8G>>�?3FD;J "8�I7�I3@F�F:7�D76G576�75:7>A@�8AD?� I7�B7D8AD?�A@7�?AD7�EF7B

�79;@@;@9�I;F:�F:7�D;9:F?AEF�B;HAF�3@6�IAD=;@9�GBI3D6�3@6�FA�F:7�>78F� 5D73F7L7DAE�34AH7�735:�B;HAF "8�3�B;HAF�;E�@AF� � ?3=7�;F� �4K�3�E53>;@9�AB7D3F;A@

,:7�D;9:F?AEF�B;HAF�;E�;@�DAI�� �D73F7�L7DAE�34AH7�;F� 366;@9�EG;F34>7�?G>F;B>7E�A8�DAI��FA�DAIE���3@6

24

3 "9 12 "9 0 "90 2 "4 4 0 "140 0 0 0 1 4

35

✛ *AI� C ."6/ ! DAI��✛ *AI��C ."2/ ! DAI��

,:7�@7JF�B;HAF�;E�;@�DAI�� +53>7�F:;E�DAI� 6;H;6;@9�4K�F:7�B;HAF24

3 "9 12 "9 0 "90 1 "2 2 0 "70 0 0 0 1 4

35 ✛ *AI�E53>76�4K 1

2

�D73F7�3�L7DA�;@�5A>G?@���4K�366;@9���F;?7E�DAI���FA�DAI� 24

3 0 "6 9 0 "720 1 "2 2 0 "70 0 0 0 1 4

35

✛ *AI� C .9/ ! DAI��

�;@3>>K� E53>7�DAI� � 6;H;6;@9�4K�F:7�B;HAF� �24

1 0 "2 3 0 "240 1 "2 2 0 "70 0 0 0 1 4

35

✛ *AI�E53>76�4K 13

,:;E�;E�F:7�D76G576�75:7>A@�8AD?�A8�F:7�AD;9;@3>�?3FD;J

,:7�5A?4;@3F;A@�A8�EF7BE� N��;E�53>>76�F:7 *25:%5(�3,%6) A8�F:7�DAI�D76G5F;A@3>9AD;F:? +F7B��� I:;5:�BDA6G57E�F:7�G@;CG7�D76G576�75:7>A@�8AD?� ;E�53>>76�F:7&%'.:%5(�3,%6)

"@�EF7B���34AH7� 3�5A?BGF7D�BDA9D3?�GEG3>>K�E7>75FE�3E�3�B;HAF�F:7�7@FDK�;@�35A>G?@�:3H;@9�F:7�>3D97EF�34EA>GF7�H3>G7 ,:;E�EFD3F79K� 53>>76 3%57-%/�3-927-1+�;E�GE76�4753GE7�;F�D76G57E�DAG@6A88�7DDADE�;@�F:7�53>5G>3F;A@E

Page 17: $)15&3 & * )- ,'&+ & & * $ * - University of Utah

�"&��*�)-�,"'&+�"&��"&��*��$ ��*�

�'$-,"'&+�'���"&��*��1+,�%+,:7�DAI�D76G5F;A@�3>9AD;F:?�>736E�6;D75F>K�FA�3@�7JB>;5;F�67E5D;BF;A@�A8�F:7�EA>GF;A@�E7FA8�3�>;@73D�EKEF7?�I:7@�F:7�3>9AD;F:?�;E�3BB>;76�FA�F:7�3G9?7@F76�?3FD;J�A8�F:7�EKEF7?

+GBBAE7� 8AD�7J3?B>7� F:3F� F:7�3G9?7@F76�?3FD;J�A8�3�>;@73D�EKEF7?�:3E�477@5:3@976�;@FA�F:7�7CG;H3>7@F )��,��� 75:7>A@�8AD?2

41 0 "5 10 1 1 40 0 0 0

35

,:7D7�3D7�F:D77�H3D;34>7E�4753GE7�F:7�3G9?7@F76�?3FD;J�:3E�8AGD�5A>G?@E ,:73EEA5;3F76�EKEF7?�A8�7CG3F;A@E�;E

x1 " 5x3 D 1

x2 C x3 D 4

0 D 0

���

,:7�H3D;34>7E x1 3@6 x2 5ADD7EBA@6;@9�FA�B;HAF�5A>G?@E�;@�F:7�?3FD;J�3D7�53>>76 &%6-'9%5-%&/)6V ,:7�AF:7D�H3D;34>7� x3� ;E�53>>76�3 *5))�9%5-%&/)

/:7@7H7D �3 �EKEF7?�;E �5A@E;EF7@F� 3E � ;@ � ���� F:7�EA>GF;A@�E7F �53@�47�67E5D;4767JB>;5;F>K�4K�EA>H;@9�F:7 )��,��� EKEF7?�A8�7CG3F;A@E�8AD�F:7�43E;5�H3D;34>7E�;@�F7D?E�A8F:7�8D77�H3D;34>7E ,:;E�AB7D3F;A@�;E�BAEE;4>7�4753GE7�F:7�D76G576�75:7>A@�8AD?�B>357E735:�43E;5�H3D;34>7�;@�A@7�3@6�A@>K�A@7�7CG3F;A@ "@����� EA>H7�F:7�SDEF�7CG3F;A@�8AD x1

3@6�F:7�E75A@6�8AD x2 �"9@AD7�F:7�F:;D6�7CG3F;A@� ;F�A887DE�@A�D7EFD;5F;A@�A@�F:7�H3D;34>7E�8̂<:̂

x1 D 1 C 5x3

x2 D 4 " x3

x3 ;E�8D77���

,:7�EF3F7?7@F�Px3 ;E�8D77Q�?73@E�F:3F�KAG�3D7�8D77�FA�5:AAE7�3@K�H3>G7�8AD x3 (@57F:3F�;E�6A@7� F:7�8AD?G>3E�;@�����67F7D?;@7�F:7�H3>G7E�8AD x1 3@6 x2 �AD�;@EF3@57� I:7@x3 D 0� F:7�EA>GF;A@�;E .1; 4; 0/� I:7@ x3 D 1� F:7�EA>GF;A@�;E .6; 3; 1/ ������ ���)�%+��& ���&� x3 ��+�)$ %�*����� ���)�%+��*&#,+ &%�&��+���*0*+�$� �%���-�)0�*&#,+ &%�&��+��*0*+�$� *���+�)$ %����0�����& ���&� x3�

�;@6�F:7�97@7D3>�EA>GF;A@�A8�F:7�>;@73D�EKEF7?�I:AE7�3G9?7@F76�?3FD;J�:3E�477@�D76G576�FA 2

41 6 2 "5 "2 "40 0 2 "8 "1 30 0 0 0 1 7

35

,:7�?3FD;J�;E�;@�75:7>A@�8AD?� 4GF�I7�I3@F�F:7�D76G576�75:7>A@�8AD?478AD7�EA>H;@9�8AD�F:7�43E;5�H3D;34>7E ,:7�DAI�D76G5F;A@�;E�5A?B>7F76�@7JF ,:7�EK?4A>% 478AD7�3�?3FD;J�;@6;53F7E�F:3F�F:7�?3FD;J�;E�DAI�7CG;H3>7@F�FA�F:7�BD7576;@9�?3FD;J2

41 6 2 "5 "2 "40 0 2 "8 "1 30 0 0 0 1 7

35 %

24

1 6 2 "5 0 100 0 2 "8 0 100 0 0 0 1 7

35

%

24

1 6 2 "5 0 100 0 1 "4 0 50 0 0 0 1 7

35 %

24

1 6 0 3 0 00 0 1 "4 0 50 0 0 0 1 7

35

V+A?7�F7JFE�GE7�F:7�F7D? #��� %��-�) ��#�* 4753GE7�F:7K�5ADD7EBA@6�FA�F:7�5A>G?@E�5A@F3;@;@9�>736;@97@FD;7E

Page 18: $)15&3 & * )- ,'&+ & & * $ * - University of Utah

�'/����-�,"'&��&���!�$'&�'*%+

,:7D7�3D7�SH7�H3D;34>7E�4753GE7�F:7�3G9?7@F76�?3FD;J�:3E�E;J�5A>G?@E ,:7�3EEA5;3F76EKEF7?�@AI�;E

x1 C 6x2 C 3x4 D 0

x3 " 4x4 D 5

x5 D 7

���

,:7�B;HAF�5A>G?@E�A8�F:7�?3FD;J�3D7� � �� 3@6��� EA�F:7�43E;5�H3D;34>7E�3D7 x1� x3� 3@6x5 ,:7�D7?3;@;@9�H3D;34>7E� x2 3@6 x4� ?GEF�47�8D77 +A>H7�8AD�F:7�43E;5�H3D;34>7E�FAA4F3;@�F:7�97@7D3>�EA>GF;A@� 8̂

ˆ̂̂̂<̂ˆ̂̂̂ˆ̂:

x1 D "6x2 " 3x4

x2 ;E�8D77x3 D 5 C 4x4

x4 ;E�8D77x5 D 7

���

'AF7�F:3F�F:7�H3>G7�A8 x5 ;E�3>D736K�SJ76�4K�F:7�F:;D6�7CG3F;A@�;@�EKEF7?����

��*�%�,*"����+�*"(,"'&+�'���'$-,"'&���,+,:7�67E5D;BF;A@E�;@�����3@6�����3D7 '�)�$�+) ����*�) '+ &%* A8�EA>GF;A@�E7FE�;@�I:;5:F:7�8D77�H3D;34>7E�35F�3E�B3D3?7F7DE �&#- %����*0*+�$ 3?AG@FE�FA�S@6;@9�3�B3D3?7FD;567E5D;BF;A@�A8�F:7�EA>GF;A@�E7F�AD�67F7D?;@;@9�F:3F�F:7�EA>GF;A@�E7F�;E�7?BFK

/:7@7H7D�3�EKEF7?�;E�5A@E;EF7@F�3@6�:3E�8D77�H3D;34>7E� F:7�EA>GF;A@�E7F�:3E�?3@KB3D3?7FD;5�67E5D;BF;A@E �AD�;@EF3@57� ;@�EKEF7?����� I7�?3K�366���F;?7E�7CG3F;A@���FA7CG3F;A@� �3@6�A4F3;@�F:7�7CG;H3>7@F�EKEF7?

x1 C 5x2 D 21

x2 C x3 D 4

/7�5AG>6�FD73F x2 3E�3�B3D3?7F7D�3@6�EA>H7�8AD x1 3@6 x3 ;@�F7D?E�A8 x2� 3@6�I7�IAG>6:3H7�3@�355GD3F7�67E5D;BF;A@�A8�F:7�EA>GF;A@�E7F !AI7H7D� FA�47�5A@E;EF7@F� I7�?3=7�F:7�3D4;FD3DK��5A@H7@F;A@�A8�3>I3KE�GE;@9�F:7�8D77�H3D;34>7E�3E�F:7�B3D3?7F7DE�8AD�67E5D;4;@93�EA>GF;A@�E7F �,:7�3@EI7D�E75F;A@�3F�F:7�7@6�A8�F:7�F7JF�3>EA�D7T75FE�F:;E�5A@H7@F;A@�

/:7@7H7D�3�EKEF7?�;E�;@5A@E;EF7@F� F:7�EA>GF;A@�E7F�;E�7?BFK� 7H7@�I:7@�F:7�EKEF7?:3E�8D77�H3D;34>7E "@�F:;E�53E7� F:7�EA>GF;A@�E7F�:3E %& B3D3?7FD;5�D7BD7E7@F3F;A@

���#��-�+,",-,"'&�A@E;67D�F:7�8A>>AI;@9�EKEF7?� I:AE7�3G9?7@F76�?3FD;J�;E�;@�75:7>A@�8AD?�4GF�;E %&+;@�D76G576�75:7>A@�8AD?�

x1 " 7x2 C 2x3 " 5x4 C 8x5 D 10

x2 " 3x3 C 3x4 C x5 D "5

x4 " x5 D 4

� 5A?BGF7D�BDA9D3?�IAG>6�EA>H7�F:;E�EKEF7?�4K�435=EG4EF;FGF;A@� D3F:7D�F:3@�4K�5A?BGF;@9�F:7�D76G576�75:7>A@�8AD? ,:3F�;E� F:7�BDA9D3?�IAG>6�EA>H7�7CG3F;A@���8AD x4 ;@F7D?E�A8 x5 3@6�EG4EF;FGF7�F:7�7JBD7EE;A@�8AD x4 ;@FA�7CG3F;A@��� EA>H7�7CG3F;A@���8AD x2�3@6�F:7@�EG4EF;FGF7�F:7�7JBD7EE;A@E�8AD x2 3@6 x4 ;@FA�7CG3F;A@� �3@6�EA>H7�8AD x1

(GD�?3FD;J�8AD?3F�8AD�F:7�435=I3D6�B:3E7�A8�DAI�D76G5F;A@� I:;5:�BDA6G57E�F:7�D76G576�75:7>A@�8AD?� :3E�F:7�E3?7�@G?47D�A8�3D;F:?7F;5�AB7D3F;A@E�3E�435=EG4EF;FGF;A@�GF�F:7�6;E5;B>;@7�A8�F:7�?3FD;J�8AD?3F�EG4EF3@F;3>>K�D76G57E�F:7�>;=7>;:AA6�A8�7DDADE

Page 19: $)15&3 & * )- ,'&+ & & * $ * - University of Utah

�"&��*�)-�,"'&+�"&��"&��*��$ ��*�

6GD;@9�:3@6�5A?BGF3F;A@E ,:7�47EF�EFD3F79K�;E�FA�GE7�A@>K�F:7 )��,��� 75:7>A@�8AD?FA�EA>H7�3�EKEF7?� ,:7 �+,�0� , �� F:3F�355A?B3@;7E�F:;E�F7JF�A887DE�E7H7D3>�:7>B8G>EG997EF;A@E�8AD�B7D8AD?;@9�DAI�AB7D3F;A@E�355GD3F7>K�3@6�D3B;6>K

"@ �97@7D3>� F:7 � 8ADI3D6�B:3E7�A8 � DAI�D76G5F;A@� F3=7E �?G5:� >A@97D � F:3@� F:7435=I3D6�B:3E7 �@�3>9AD;F:?�8AD�EA>H;@9�3�EKEF7?�;E�GEG3>>K�?73EGD76�;@�TABE�AD�TA3F;@9�BA;@F�AB7D3F;A@E� � ?23 ;E�A@7�3D;F:?7F;5�AB7D3F;A@��C; "; $; = �A@�FIA�D73>�TA3F;@9�BA;@F�@G?47DE� �AD�3@ n # .n C 1/ ?3FD;J� F:7�D76G5F;A@FA�75:7>A@�8AD?�53@�F3=7 2n3=3 C n2=2 " 7n=6 TABE��I:;5:�;E�3BBDAJ;?3F7>K2n3=3 TABE�I:7@ n ;E �?A67D3F7>K�>3D97OE3K� n & 30/ "@�5A@FD3EF� 8GDF:7DD76G5F;A@�FA�D76G576�75:7>A@�8AD?�@776E�3F�?AEF n2 TABE

0"+,�&����&���&")-�&�++��-�+,"'&+�>F:AG9:�3�@A@D76G576�75:7>A@�8AD?�;E�3�BAAD�FAA>�8AD�EA>H;@9�3�EKEF7?� F:;E�8AD?�;E<GEF�F:7�D;9:F�67H;57�8AD�3@EI7D;@9�FIA�8G@63?7@F3>�CG7EF;A@E�BAE76�;@�+75F;A@

�7F7D?;@7�F:7�7J;EF7@57�3@6�G@;CG7@7EE�A8�F:7�EA>GF;A@E�FA�F:7�EKEF7?

3x2 " 6x3 C 6x4 C 4x5 D "5

3x1 " 7x2 C 8x3 " 5x4 C 8x5 D 9

3x1 " 9x2 C 12x3 " 9x4 C 6x5 D 15

,:7�3G9?7@F76�?3FD;J�A8�F:;E�EKEF7?�I3E�DAI�D76G576�;@��J3?B>7���FA24

3 "9 12 "9 6 150 2 "4 4 2 "60 0 0 0 1 4

35 ���

,:7�43E;5�H3D;34>7E�3D7 x1� x2� 3@6 x5� F:7�8D77�H3D;34>7E�3D7 x3 3@6 x4 ,:7D7�;E�@A7CG3F;A@�EG5:�3E 0 D 1 F:3F�IAG>6�;@6;53F7�3@�;@5A@E;EF7@F�EKEF7?� EA�I7�5AG>6�GE7435=EG4EF;FGF;A@�FA�S@6�3�EA>GF;A@ �GF�F:7 �/ *+�%�� A8�3�EA>GF;A@�;E�3>D736K�5>73D;@���� �>EA� F:7�EA>GF;A@�;E %&+�,% (,� 4753GE7�F:7D7�3D7�8D77�H3D;34>7E �35:�6;887D7@F5:A;57�A8 x3 3@6 x4 67F7D?;@7E�3�6;887D7@F�EA>GF;A@ ,:GE�F:7�EKEF7?�:3E�;@S@;F7>K�?3@KEA>GF;A@E

/:7@�3�EKEF7?�;E�;@�75:7>A@�8AD?�3@6�5A@F3;@E�@A�7CG3F;A@�A8�F:7�8AD? 0 D b� I;F:b @A@L7DA� 7H7DK�@A@L7DA�7CG3F;A@�5A@F3;@E�3�43E;5�H3D;34>7�I;F:�3�@A@L7DA�5A78S5;7@F�;F:7D�F:7�43E;5�H3D;34>7E�3D7�5A?B>7F7>K�67F7D?;@76��I;F:�@A�8D77�H3D;34>7E��AD�3F�>73EFA@7�A8�F:7�43E;5�H3D;34>7E�?3K�47�7JBD7EE76�;@�F7D?E�A8�A@7�AD�?AD7�8D77�H3D;34>7E "@F:7�8AD?7D�53E7� F:7D7�;E�3�G@;CG7�EA>GF;A@� ;@�F:7�>3FF7D�53E7� F:7D7�3D7�;@S@;F7>K�?3@KEA>GF;A@E��A@7�8AD�735:�5:A;57�A8�H3>G7E�8AD�F:7�8D77�H3D;34>7E�

,:7E7�D7?3D=E�<GEF;8K�F:7�8A>>AI;@9�F:7AD7?

W,D36;F;A@3>>K� 3 4&' I3E�A@>K�3�?G>F;B>;53F;A@�AD�6;H;E;A@� 4753GE7�366;F;A@�3@6�EG4FD35F;A@�FAA=�?G5:�>7EEF;?7�3@6�5AG>6�47�;9@AD76 ,:7�67S@;F;A@�A8 4&' 9;H7@�:7D7�;E�BD787DD76�@AI� 3E�3�D7EG>F�A8�36H3@57E�;@5A?BGF7D�3D5:;F75FGD7 +77� A>G4�3@6�.3@�%A3@� ��+) /�&$',+�+ &%*� �@6�76 ��3>F;?AD7� ,:7�#A:@E!AB=;@E�)D7EE� ����� BB �N��

Page 20: $)15&3 & * )- ,'&+ & & * $ * - University of Utah

�'/����-�,"'&��&���!�$'&�'*%+

� >;@73D�EKEF7?�;E�5A@E;EF7@F�;8�3@6�A@>K�;8�F:7�D;9:F?AEF�5A>G?@�A8�F:7�3G9?7@F76?3FD;J�;E %&+ 3�B;HAF�5A>G?@OF:3F�;E� ;8 �3@6�A@>K�;8�3@�75:7>A@�8AD?�A8�F:73G9?7@F76�?3FD;J�:3E %& DAI�A8�F:7�8AD?

Π0 ! ! ! 0 b ! I;F: b @A@L7DA

"8�3�>;@73D�EKEF7?�;E�5A@E;EF7@F� F:7@�F:7�EA>GF;A@�E7F�5A@F3;@E�7;F:7D��;��3�G@;CG7EA>GF;A@� I:7@�F:7D7�3D7�@A�8D77�H3D;34>7E� AD��;;��;@S@;F7>K�?3@K�EA>GF;A@E� I:7@F:7D7�;E�3F�>73EF�A@7�8D77�H3D;34>7

,:7�8A>>AI;@9�BDA576GD7�AGF>;@7E�:AI�FA�S@6�3@6�67E5D;47�3>>�EA>GF;A@E�A8�3�>;@73DEKEF7?

�� /D;F7�F:7�3G9?7@F76�?3FD;J�A8�F:7�EKEF7?� -E7�F:7�DAI�D76G5F;A@�3>9AD;F:?�FA�A4F3;@�3@�7CG;H3>7@F�3G9?7@F76�?3FD;J�;@75:7>A@�8AD? �75;67�I:7F:7D�F:7�EKEF7?�;E�5A@E;EF7@F "8�F:7D7�;E�@A�EA>GF;A@�EFAB� AF:7DI;E7� 9A�FA�F:7�@7JF�EF7B

� �A@F;@G7�DAI�D76G5F;A@�FA�A4F3;@�F:7�D76G576�75:7>A@�8AD?�� /D;F7�F:7�EKEF7?�A8�7CG3F;A@E�5ADD7EBA@6;@9�FA�F:7�?3FD;J�A4F3;@76�;@�EF7B���� *7ID;F7�735:�@A@L7DA�7CG3F;A@�8DA?�EF7B���EA�F:3F�;FE�A@7�43E;5�H3D;34>7�;E7JBD7EE76�;@�F7D?E�A8�3@K�8D77�H3D;34>7E�3BB73D;@9�;@�F:7�7CG3F;A@

�� �;@6�F:7�97@7D3>�EA>GF;A@�A8�F:7�>;@73D�EKEF7?�I:AE7�3G9?7@F76�?3FD;J�;E#

1 "3 "5 00 1 1 3

$

� �;@6�F:7�97@7D3>�EA>GF;A@�A8�F:7�EKEF7?

x1 " 2x2 " x3 C 3x4 D 0

"2x1 C 4x2 C 5x3 " 5x4 D 3

3x1 " 6x2 " 6x3 C 8x4 D 2

"@��J7D5;E7E� �3@6��� 67F7D?;@7�I:;5:�?3FD;57E�3D7�;@�D76G57675:7>A@�8AD?�3@6�I:;5:�AF:7DE�3D7�A@>K�;@�75:7>A@�8AD?

�� 3

24

1 0 0 00 1 0 00 0 1 1

35 4

24

1 0 1 00 1 1 00 0 0 1

35 5

2664

1 0 0 00 1 1 00 0 0 00 0 0 1

3775 6

2664

1 1 0 1 10 2 0 2 20 0 0 3 30 0 0 0 4

3775

Page 21: $)15&3 & * )- ,'&+ & & * $ * - University of Utah

�"&��*�)-�,"'&+�"&��"&��*��$ ��*�

� 3

24

1 0 1 10 1 1 10 0 0 0

35 4

24

1 0 0 00 2 0 00 0 1 1

35

5

2664

0 0 0 01 2 0 00 0 1 00 0 0 1

3775

6

2664

0 1 1 1 10 0 1 1 10 0 0 0 10 0 0 0 0

3775

*AI�D76G57�F:7�?3FD;57E�;@��J7D5;E7E���3@6���FA�D76G576�75:7>A@8AD? �;D5>7�F:7�B;HAF�BAE;F;A@E�;@�F:7�S@3>�?3FD;J�3@6�;@�F:7AD;9;@3>�?3FD;J� 3@6�>;EF�F:7�B;HAF�5A>G?@E

24

1 2 4 82 4 6 83 6 9 12

35 ��

24

1 2 4 52 4 5 44 5 4 2

35

�� �7E5D;47 � F:7 � BAEE;4>7 � 75:7>A@ � 8AD?E �A8 � 3 � @A@L7DA 2 # 2?3FD;J -E7�F:7�EK?4A>E � $� 3@6��� 3E�;@�F:7�SDEF�B3DF�A8�J3?B>7�

� *7B73F��J7D5;E7���8AD�3�@A@L7DA 3 # 2 ?3FD;J

�;@6�F:7�97@7D3>�EA>GF;A@E�A8�F:7�EKEF7?E�I:AE7�3G9?7@F76�?3FD;57E�3D7�9;H7@�;@��J7D5;E7E��N �

��#

1 3 4 73 9 7 6

$��

#1 "3 0 "5

"3 7 0 9

$

��#

0 1 "2 31 "3 4 "6

$���

#1 "2 "1 4

"2 4 "5 6

$

���

24

3 "2 4 09 "6 12 06 "4 8 0

35 ��

2664

1 0 "9 0 40 1 3 0 "10 0 0 1 "70 0 0 0 1

3775

��

2664

1 "3 0 "1 0 "20 1 0 0 "4 10 0 0 1 9 40 0 0 0 0 0

3775

���

2664

1 0 "5 0 "8 30 1 4 "1 0 60 0 0 0 1 00 0 0 0 0 0

3775

�J7D5;E7E� ��3@6� ��GE7�F:7�@AF3F;A@�A8��J3?B>7� �8AD�?3FD;57E;@�75:7>A@�8AD? +GBBAE7�735:�?3FD;J�D7BD7E7@FE�F:7�3G9?7@F76?3FD;J�8AD�3�EKEF7?�A8�>;@73D�7CG3F;A@E "@�735:�53E7� 67F7D?;@7�;8F:7�EKEF7?�;E�5A@E;EF7@F "8�F:7�EKEF7?�;E�5A@E;EF7@F� 67F7D?;@7�;8F:7�EA>GF;A@�;E�G@;CG7

��� 3

24

$ $ $0 $ $0 0 0 0

35

4

24

0 $ $ $0 0 $ $0 0 0 0

35

� � 3

24

$ $0 $0 0

35

4

24

$ $ $ $0 0 $ $0 0 0 $

35

"@��J7D5;E7E� ��3@6� �� 67F7D?;@7�F:7�H3>G7�E��A8 h EG5:�F:3F�F:7?3FD;J�;E�F:7�3G9?7@F76�?3FD;J�A8�3�5A@E;EF7@F�>;@73D�EKEF7?

���#

1 "1 4"2 3 h

$���

#1 "3 1h 6 "2

$

"@��J7D5;E7E� ��3@6���� 5:AAE7 h 3@6 k EG5:�F:3F�F:7�EKEF7?�:3E��3�@A�EA>GF;A@� �4��3�G@;CG7�EA>GF;A@� 3@6��5��?3@K�EA>GF;A@E ;H7E7B3D3F7�3@EI7DE�8AD�735:�B3DF

��� x1 C hx2 D 2

4x1 C 8x2 D k

�� x1 " 3x2 D 1

2x1 C hx2 D k

"@��J7D5;E7E�� �3@6���� ?3D=�735:�EF3F7?7@F�,DG7�AD��3>E7 #GEF;8K735:�3@EI7D�

�� 3 "@�EA?7�53E7E� 3�?3FD;J�?3K�47�DAI�D76G576�FA�?AD7F:3@�A@7�?3FD;J�;@�D76G576�75:7>A@�8AD?� GE;@9�6;887D7@FE7CG7@57E�A8�DAI�AB7D3F;A@E

4 ,:7�DAI�D76G5F;A@�3>9AD;F:?�3BB>;7E�A@>K�FA�3G9?7@F76?3FD;57E�8AD�3�>;@73D�EKEF7?

5 � 43E;5 �H3D;34>7 � ;@ �3 � >;@73D � EKEF7?� ;E �3 �H3D;34>7 � F:3F5ADD7EBA@6E�FA�3�B;HAF�5A>G?@�;@�F:7�5A78S5;7@F�?3FD;J

6 �;@6;@9�3�B3D3?7FD;5�67E5D;BF;A@�A8�F:7�EA>GF;A@�E7F�A8�3>;@73D�EKEF7?�;E�F:7�E3?7�3E *&#- %� F:7�EKEF7?

7 "8�A@7�DAI�;@�3@�75:7>A@�8AD?�A8�3@�3G9?7@F76�?3FD;J;E Œ 0 0 0 5 0 !� F:7@�F:7�3EEA5;3F76�>;@73D�EKEF7?�;E;@5A@E;EF7@F

� 3 ,:7�D76G576�75:7>A@�8AD?�A8�3�?3FD;J�;E�G@;CG74 "8�7H7DK�5A>G?@�A8�3@�3G9?7@F76�?3FD;J�5A@F3;@E�3�B;HAF�F:7@�F:7�5ADD7EBA@6;@9�EKEF7?�;E�5A@E;EF7@F

5 ,:7�B;HAF�BAE;F;A@E�;@�3�?3FD;J�67B7@6�A@�I:7F:7D�DAI;@F7D5:3@97E�3D7�GE76�;@�F:7�DAI�D76G5F;A@�BDA57EE

6 � 97@7D3>�EA>GF;A@�A8�3�EKEF7?�;E�3@�7JB>;5;F�67E5D;BF;A@A8�3>>�EA>GF;A@E�A8�F:7�EKEF7?

7 /:7@7H7D�3�EKEF7?�:3E�8D77�H3D;34>7E� F:7�EA>GF;A@�E7F5A@F3;@E�?3@K�EA>GF;A@E

� +GBBAE7�F:7�5A78S5;7@F�?3FD;J�A8�3� >;@73D�EKEF7?�A8�8AGD7CG3F;A@E�;@�8AGD�H3D;34>7E�:3E�3�B;HAF�;@�735:�5A>G?@ �JB>3;@�I:K�F:7�EKEF7?�:3E�3�G@;CG7�EA>GF;A@

�� +GBBAE7�3�EKEF7?�A8�>;@73D�7CG3F;A@E�:3E�3 3 # 5 �,�$�%+��?3FD;J�I:AE7�S8F:�5A>G?@�;E�@AF�3�B;HAF�5A>G?@ "E�F:7EKEF7?�5A@E;EF7@F� /:K��AD�I:K�@AF��

4 ,DG7�83>E7�CG7EF;A@E�A8�F:;E�FKB7�I;>>�3BB73D�;@�?3@K�E75F;A@E &7F:A6E8AD�<GEF;8K;@9�KAGD�3@EI7DE�I7D7�67E5D;476�478AD7��J7D5;E7E����3@6����;@+75F;A@

Page 22: $)15&3 & * )- ,'&+ & & * $ * - University of Utah

�'/����-�,"'&��&���!�$'&�'*%+

�� +GBBAE7�F:7�5A78S5;7@F�?3FD;J�A8�3�EKEF7?�A8�>;@73D�7CG3F;A@E:3E�3�B;HAF�BAE;F;A@�;@�7H7DK�DAI �JB>3;@�I:K�F:7�EKEF7?�;E5A@E;EF7@F

� +GBBAE7�3 3 # 5 �&��3� �%+ ?3FD;J�8AD�3�EKEF7?�:3E�F:D77B;HAF�5A>G?@E "E�F:7�EKEF7?�5A@E;EF7@F� /:K�AD�I:K�@AF�

�� *7EF3F7�F:7�>3EF�E7@F7@57�;@�,:7AD7?���GE;@9�F:7�5A@57BF�A8B;HAF�5A>G?@E� P"8�3�>;@73D�EKEF7?�;E�5A@E;EF7@F� F:7@�F:7EA>GF;A@�;E�G@;CG7�;8�3@6�A@>K�;8 Q

�� /:3F�IAG>6�KAG�:3H7�FA�=@AI�34AGF�F:7�B;HAF�5A>G?@E�;@�3@3G9?7@F76�?3FD;J�;@�AD67D�FA�=@AI�F:3F�F:7�>;@73D�EKEF7?�;E5A@E;EF7@F�3@6�:3E�3�G@;CG7�EA>GF;A@�

�� � EKEF7?�A8�>;@73D�7CG3F;A@E�I;F:�87I7D�7CG3F;A@E�F:3@�G@=@AI@E�;E�EA?7F;?7E�53>>76�3@ ,%��)��+�)$ %���*0*+�$ �3@EG5:�3�EKEF7?�:3H7�3�G@;CG7�EA>GF;A@� �JB>3;@

�� ;H7�3@�7J3?B>7�A8�3@�;@5A@E;EF7@F�G@67D67F7D?;@76�EKEF7?A8�FIA�7CG3F;A@E�;@�F:D77�G@=@AI@E

�� � EKEF7?�A8�>;@73D�7CG3F;A@E�I;F:�?AD7�7CG3F;A@E�F:3@�G@=@AI@E�;E�EA?7F;?7E�53>>76�3@ &-�)��+�)$ %���*0*+�$ �3@EG5:�3�EKEF7?�47�5A@E;EF7@F� ">>GEFD3F7�KAGD�3@EI7D�I;F:�3EB75;S5�EKEF7?�A8�F:D77�7CG3F;A@E�;@�FIA�G@=@AI@E

� +GBBAE7�3@ n # .n C 1/ ?3FD;J�;E�DAI�D76G576�FA�D76G57675:7>A@ � 8AD? �BBDAJ;?3F7>K �I:3F � 8D35F;A@ �A8 � F:7 � FAF3>@G?47D�A8�AB7D3F;A@E��TABE��;E� ;@HA>H76�;@�F:7�435=I3D6B:3E7�A8�F:7�D76G5F;A@�I:7@ n D 20� I:7@ n D 200�

+GBBAE7�7JB7D;?7@F3>�63F3�3D7�D7BD7E7@F76�4K�3�E7F�A8�BA;@FE�;@�F:7B>3@7 �@ -17)532/%7-1+�32/<120-%/ 8AD�F:7�63F3�;E�3�BA>K@A?;3>I:AE7 �9D3B: �B3EE7E � F:DAG9:�7H7DK �BA;@F "@ � E5;7@F;S5 �IAD=�

EG5:�3�BA>K@A?;3>�53@�47�GE76� 8AD�7J3?B>7� FA�7EF;?3F7�H3>G7E47FI77@�F:7�=@AI@�63F3�BA;@FE �@AF:7D�GE7�;E�FA�5D73F7�5GDH7E�8AD9D3B:;53>�;?397E�A@�3�5A?BGF7D�E5D77@ (@7�?7F:A6�8AD�S@6;@9�3@;@F7DBA>3F;@9�BA>K@A?;3>�;E�FA�EA>H7�3�EKEF7?�A8�>;@73D�7CG3F;A@E

WEB

� �;@6�F:7�;@F7DBA>3F;@9�BA>K@A?;3> p.t/ D a0 C a1t C a2t2

8AD�F:7�63F3 .1; 6/� .2; 15/� .3; 28/ ,:3F�;E� S@6 a0� a1� 3@6a2 EG5:�F:3F

a0 C a1.1/ C a2.1/2 D 6

a0 C a1.2/ C a2.2/2 D 15

a0 C a1.3/ C a2.3/2 D 28

�� 1�2 "@�3�I;@6�FG@@7>�7JB7D;?7@F� F:7�8AD57�A@�3�BDA<75F;>76G7�FA�3;D�D7E;EF3@57�I3E�?73EGD76�3F�6;887D7@F�H7>A5;F;7E�.7>A5;FK�� ���8F�E75� � � � � � ��AD57�� ���>4� � ��� �� ��� ��� ��;@6�3@�;@F7DBA>3F;@9�BA>K@A?;3>�8AD�F:7E7�63F3�3@6�7EF;?3F7F:7�8AD57�A@�F:7�BDA<75F;>7�I:7@�F:7�BDA<75F;>7�;E�FD3H7>;@93F�����8F�E75 -E7 p.t/ D a0 C a1t C a2t

2 C a3t3 C a4t

4 Ca5t

5 /:3F�:3BB7@E�;8�KAG�FDK�FA�GE7�3�BA>K@A?;3>�A8�679D77>7EE�F:3@��� �,DK�3�5G4;5�BA>K@A?;3>� 8AD�;@EF3@57��

5 �J7D5;E7E�?3D=76�I;F:�F:7�EK?4A>�1�2 3D7�67E;9@76�FA�47�IAD=76�I;F:F:7�3;6�A8�3�P�3FD;J�BDA9D3?Q��3�5A?BGF7D�BDA9D3?� EG5:�3E��,%��M��3B>7,&��3F:7?3F;53M��3F:�36M� AD��7D;H7,&� AD�3BDA9D3??34>7�53>5G>3FAD�I;F:�?3FD;J�53B34;>;F;7E� EG5:�3E�F:AE7?3@G835FGD76�4K�,7J3E�"@EFDG?7@FE�AD�!7I>7FF)35=3D6�

�� ,:7�D76G576�75:7>A@�8AD?�A8�F:7�3G9?7@F76�?3FD;J�3@6�F:7�5ADD7EBA@6;@9�EKEF7?

,:7�97@7D3>�EA>GF;A@�A8�F:7EKEF7?�A8�7CG3F;A@E�;E�F:7�>;@7�A8;@F7DE75F;A@�A8�F:7�FIA�B>3@7E

3D7 #1 0 "2 90 1 1 3

$3@6

x1 " 2x3 D 9

x2 C x3 D 3

,:7�43E;5�H3D;34>7E�3D7 x1 3@6 x2� 3@6�F:7�97@7D3>�EA>GF;A@�;E8̂<:̂

x1 D 9 C 2x3

x2 D 3 " x3

x3 ;E�8D77

�&+�� "F�;E�7EE7@F;3>�F:3F�F:7�97@7D3>�EA>GF;A@�67E5D;47�735:�H3D;34>7� I;F:�3@K�B3D3?7F7DE�5>73D>K�;67@F;S76 ,:7�8A>>AI;@9�EF3F7?7@F�6A7E %&+ 67E5D;47�F:7�EA>GF;A@�

8̂<:̂

x1 D 9 C 2x3

x2 D 3 " x3

x3 D 3 " x2 "@5ADD75F�EA>GF;A@

,:;E�67E5D;BF;A@�;?B>;7E�F:3F x2 3@6 x3 3D7 �&+� 8D77� I:;5:�57DF3;@>K�;E�@AF�F:7�53E7

Page 23: $)15&3 & * )- ,'&+ & & * $ * - University of Utah

�"&��*�)-�,"'&+�"&��"&��*��$ ��*�

� *AI�D76G57�F:7�EKEF7?RE�3G9?7@F76�?3FD;J�24

1 "2 "1 3 0"2 4 5 "5 3

3 "6 "6 8 2

35 %

24

1 "2 "1 3 00 0 3 1 30 0 "3 "1 2

35

%

24

1 "2 "1 3 00 0 3 1 30 0 0 0 5

35

,:;E�75:7>A@�?3FD;J�E:AIE�F:3F�F:7�EKEF7?�;E %�&%* *+�%+� 4753GE7�;FE�D;9:F?AEF5A>G?@�;E�3�B;HAF�5A>G?@� F:7�F:;D6�DAI�5ADD7EBA@6E�FA�F:7�7CG3F;A@������ ,:7D7;E�@A�@776�FA�B7D8AD?�3@K�?AD7�DAI�AB7D3F;A@E 'AF7�F:3F�F:7�BD7E7@57�A8�F:7�8D77H3D;34>7E�;@�F:;E�BDA4>7?�;E�;DD7>7H3@F�4753GE7�F:7�EKEF7?�;E�;@5A@E;EF7@F

"?BADF3@F�BDAB7DF;7E�A8�>;@73D�EKEF7?E�53@�47�67E5D;476�I;F:�F:7�5A@57BF�3@6�@AF3F;A@A8�H75FADE ,:;E�E75F;A@�5A@@75FE�7CG3F;A@E�;@HA>H;@9�H75FADE�FA�AD6;@3DK�EKEF7?E�A87CG3F;A@E ,:7�F7D? -��+&) 3BB73DE�;@�3�H3D;7FK�A8�?3F:7?3F;53>�3@6�B:KE;53>�5A@F7JFE�I:;5:�I7�I;>>�6;E5GEE�;@��:3BF7D �� P.75FAD�+B357EQ -@F;>�F:7@� -��+&) I;>>�?73@�3@&)��)���# *+�&��%,$��)* ,:;E�E;?B>7�;673�7@34>7E�GE�FA�97F�FA�;@F7D7EF;@9�3@6�;?BADF3@F3BB>;53F;A@E�3E�CG;5=>K�3E�BAEE;4>7

���,'*+�"& R2

�?3FD;J�I;F:�A@>K�A@7�5A>G?@�;E�53>>76�3 '2/801�9)'725� AD�E;?B>K�3 9)'725 �J3?B>7EA8�H75FADE�I;F:�FIA�7@FD;7E�3D7

8 D#

3"1

$; 9 D

#:2:3

$; : D

#w1

w2

$

I:7D7w1 3@6w2 3D7�3@K�D73>�@G?47DE ,:7�E7F�A8�3>>�H75FADE�I;F:�FIA�7@FD;7E�;E�67@AF764K R2 �D736�PDFIAQ� ,:7 R EF3@6E�8AD�F:7�D73>�@G?47DE�F:3F�3BB73D�3E�7@FD;7E�;@�F:7H75FADE� 3@6�F:7�7JBA@7@F���;@6;53F7E�F:3F�735:�H75FAD�5A@F3;@E�FIA�7@FD;7EU

,IA�H75FADE�;@ R2 3D7 )48%/ ;8�3@6�A@>K�;8�F:7;D�5ADD7EBA@6;@9�7@FD;7E�3D7�7CG3>

,:GE#

47

$3@6

#74

$3D7 %&+ 7CG3>� 4753GE7�H75FADE�;@ R2 3D7 &)��)���'� )* A8�D73>

@G?47DE ;H7@�FIA�H75FADE 8 3@6 9 ;@ R2� F:7;D 680 ;E�F:7�H75FAD 8C 9 A4F3;@76�4K�366;@9

5ADD7EBA@6;@9�7@FD;7E�A8 8 3@6 9 �AD�7J3?B>7�#

1"2

$C

#25

$D

#1 C 2

"2 C 5

$D

#33

$

;H7@�3�H75FAD 8 3@6�3�D73>�@G?47D c� F:7 6'%/%5�08/7-3/) A8 8 4K c ;E�F:7�H75FAD c8A4F3;@76�4K�?G>F;B>K;@9�735:�7@FDK�;@ 8 4K c �AD�;@EF3@57�

;8 8 D#

3"1

$3@6 c D 5; F:7@ c8 D 5

#3

"1

$D

#15"5

$

U&AEF�A8�F:7�F7JF�5A@57D@E�H75FADE�3@6�?3FD;57E�F:3F�:3H7�A@>K�D73>�7@FD;7E !AI7H7D� 3>>�67S@;F;A@E�3@6F:7AD7?E�;@��:3BF7DE N�� 3@6�;@�?AEF�A8�F:7�D7EF�A8�F:7�F7JF� D7?3;@�H3>;6�;8�F:7�7@FD;7E�3D7�5A?B>7J@G?47DE �A?B>7J�H75FADE�3@6�?3FD;57E�3D;E7�@3FGD3>>K� 8AD�7J3?B>7� ;@�7>75FD;53>�7@9;@77D;@9�3@6�B:KE;5E

Page 24: $)15&3 & * )- ,'&+ & & * $ * - University of Utah

���,'*�)-�,"'&+

,:7�@G?47D c ;@ c8 ;E�53>>76�3 6'%/%5� ;F�;E�ID;FF7@�;@�>;9:F8357�FKB7�FA�6;EF;@9G;E:�;F�8DA?F:7�4A>68357�H75FAD 8

,:7�AB7D3F;A@E�A8�E53>3D�?G>F;B>;53F;A@�3@6�H75FAD�366;F;A@�53@�47�5A?4;@76� 3E�;@F:7�8A>>AI;@9�7J3?B>7

;H7@ 8 D#

1"2

$3@6 9 D

#2

"5

$� S@6 48� ."3/9� 3@6 48C ."3/9

48 D#

4"8

$; ."3/9 D

#"615

$

3@6

48C ."3/9 D#

4"8

$C

#"615

$D

#"2

7

$

+A?7F;?7E� 8AD�5A@H7@;7@57��3@6�3>EA�FA�E3H7�EB357�� F:;E�F7JF�?3K�ID;F7�3�5A>G?@

H75FAD�EG5:�3E#

3"1

$;@�F:7�8AD? .3; "1/ "@�F:;E�53E7� F:7�B3D7@F:7E7E�3@6�F:7�5A??3

6;EF;@9G;E:�F:7�H75FAD .3; "1/ 8DA?�F:7 1 # 2 DAI�?3FD;J%

3 "1&� ID;FF7@�I;F:�4D35=7FE

3@6�@A�5A??3 ,:GE #3

"1

%3 "1

&

4753GE7�F:7�?3FD;57E�:3H7�6;887D7@F�E:3B7E� 7H7@�F:AG9:�F:7K�:3H7�F:7�E3?7�7@FD;7E

��'%�,*"����+�*"(,"'&+�'� R2

�A@E;67D�3�D75F3@9G>3D�5AAD6;@3F7�EKEF7?�;@�F:7�B>3@7 �753GE7�735:�BA;@F�;@�F:7�B>3@7;E�67F7D?;@76�4K�3@�AD67D76�B3;D�A8�@G?47DE� .����%� ��%+ �0�����&$�+) ��'& %+ .a; b/

. +��+����&#,$%�-��+&)#

ab

$ +A�I7�?3K�D793D6 R2 3E�F:7�E7F�A8�3>>�BA;@FE�;@�F:7�B>3@7

+77��;9

x2

x1

(2, 2)

(3, –1)(–2, –1)

.75FADE�3E�BA;@FE

x2

x1

(2, 2)

(3, –1)(–2, –1)

.75FADE�I;F:�3DDAIE

,:7�97A?7FD;5�H;EG3>;L3F;A@�A8�3�H75FAD�EG5:�3E#

3"1

$;E�A8F7@�3;676�4K�;@5>G6;@9

3@�3DDAI��6;D75F76�>;@7�E79?7@F��8DA?�F:7�AD;9;@ .0; 0/ FA�F:7�BA;@F .3; "1/� 3E�;@��;9 �"@�F:;E�53E7� F:7�;@6;H;6G3>�BA;@FE�3>A@9�F:7�3DDAI�;FE7>8�:3H7�@A�EB75;3>�E;9@;S53@57V

,:7�EG?�A8�FIA�H75FADE�:3E�3�GE78G>�97A?7FD;5�D7BD7E7@F3F;A@ ,:7�8A>>AI;@9�DG>753@�47�H7D;S76�4K�3@3>KF;5�97A?7FDK

V "@�B:KE;5E� 3DDAIE�53@�D7BD7E7@F�8AD57E�3@6�GEG3>>K�3D7�8D77�FA�?AH7�34AGF�;@�EB357 ,:;E�;@F7DBD7F3F;A@�A8H75FADE�I;>>�47�6;E5GEE76�;@�+75F;A@ �

Page 25: $)15&3 & * )- ,'&+ & & * $ * - University of Utah

�"&��*�)-�,"'&+�"&��"&��*��$ ��*�

"8 8 3@6 9 ;@ R2 3D7�D7BD7E7@F76�3E�BA;@FE�;@�F:7�B>3@7� F:7@ 8C 9 5ADD7EBA@6E�FAF:7�8AGDF:�H7DF7J�A8�F:7�B3D3>>7>A9D3?�I:AE7�AF:7D�H7DF;57E�3D7 8� �� 3@6 9 +77�;9 �

v

u

x2

x1

u

v

u + v

0

,:7�B3D3>>7>A9D3?�DG>7

,:7�H75FADE 8 D#

22

$� 9 D

#"6

1

$� 3@6 8C 9 D

#"4

3

$3D7�6;EB>3K76

;@��;9 �x2

x1

u

v

u + v

2–6

3

,:7�@7JF�7J3?B>7�;>>GEFD3F7E�F:7�835F�F:3F�F:7�E7F�A8�3>>�E53>3D�?G>F;B>7E�A8�A@7�SJ76@A@L7DA�H75FAD�;E�3�>;@7�F:DAG9:�F:7�AD;9;@� .0; 0/

%7F 8 D#

3"1

$ �;EB>3K�F:7�H75FADE 8� 28� 3@6 " 2

38 A@�3�9D3B:

+77��;9 �� I:7D7 8� 28 D#

6"2

$� 3@6 " 2

38 D

#"2

2=3

$3D7�6;EB>3K76 ,:7

3DDAI�8AD 28 ;E�FI;57�3E�>A@9�3E�F:7�3DDAI�8AD 8� 3@6�F:7�3DDAIE�BA;@F�;@�F:7�E3?76;D75F;A@ ,:7�3DDAI�8AD " 2

38 ;E�FIAF:;D6E�F:7�>7@9F:�A8�F:7�3DDAI�8AD 8� 3@6�F:7�3DDAIE

BA;@F�;@�ABBAE;F7�6;D75F;A@E "@�97@7D3>� F:7�>7@9F:�A8�F:7�3DDAI�8AD c8 ;E jcj F;?7E�F:7

x2

x1

u

x2

x1

u

0u

2u

u

The set of all multiples of uTypical multiples of u

23

– –

Page 26: $)15&3 & * )- ,'&+ & & * $ * - University of Utah

���,'*�)-�,"'&+

>7@9F:�A8�F:7�3DDAI�8AD 8 1*753>>�F:3F�F:7�>7@9F:�A8�F:7�>;@7�E79?7@F�8DA? .0; 0/ FA .a; b/;E

pa2 C b2 /7�E:3>>�6;E5GEE�F:;E�8GDF:7D�;@��:3BF7D �2

���,'*+�"& R3

.75FADE�;@ R3 3D7 3 # 1 5A>G?@�?3FD;57E�I;F:�F:D77�7@FD;7E ,:7K�3D7�D7BD7E7@F76�97A?7FD;53>>K�4K�BA;@FE�;@�3�F:D776;?7@E;A@3>�5AAD6;@3F7�EB357� I;F:�3DDAIE�8DA?�F:7�AD;

2a

a

x2x1

x3

+53>3D�?G>F;B>7E�

9;@�EA?7F;?7E�;@5>G676�8AD�H;EG3>�5>3D;FK ,:7�H75FADE % D

24

234

35 3@6 2% 3D7�6;EB>3K76

;@��;9 �

���,'*+�"& Rn

"8 n ;E�3�BAE;F;H7�;@F797D� Rn �D736�PD@Q��67@AF7E�F:7�5A>>75F;A@�A8�3>>�>;EFE��AD &)��)��n+,'#�*��A8 n D73>�@G?47DE� GEG3>>K�ID;FF7@�3E n # 1 5A>G?@�?3FD;57E� EG5:�3E

8 D

26664

u1

u2

:::un

37775

,:7�H75FAD�I:AE7�7@FD;7E�3D7�3>>�L7DA�;E�53>>76�F:7 =)52�9)'725 3@6�;E�67@AF76�4K ��,:7�@G?47D�A8�7@FD;7E�;@ � I;>>�47�5>73D�8DA?�F:7�5A@F7JF�

�CG3>;FK�A8�H75FADE�;@ Rn 3@6�F:7�AB7D3F;A@E�A8�E53>3D�?G>F;B>;53F;A@�3@6�H75FAD366;F;A@�;@ Rn 3D7�67S@76�7@FDK�4K�7@FDK�<GEF�3E�;@ R2 ,:7E7�AB7D3F;A@E�A@�H75FADE:3H7�F:7�8A>>AI;@9�BDAB7DF;7E� I:;5:�53@�47�H7D;S76�6;D75F>K�8DA?�F:7�5ADD7EBA@6;@9BDAB7DF;7E�8AD�D73>�@G?47DE +77�)D35F;57�)DA4>7?� �3@6��J7D5;E7E����3@6����3F�F:7�7@6A8�F:;E�E75F;A@

Rn

�AD�3>> 8; 9;: ;@ Rn 3@6�3>>�E53>3DE c 3@6 d �

�;� 8C 9 D 9C 8 �H� c.8C 9/ D c8C c9�;;� .8C 9/ C : D 8C .9C :/ �H;� .c C d/8 D c8C d8�;;;� 8C � D �C 8 D 8 �H;;� c.d8/ D .cd/.8/

�;H� 8C ."8/ D "8C 8 D �� �H;;;� 18 D 8I:7D7 "8 67@AF7E ."1/8

�AD�E;?B>;5;FK�A8�@AF3F;A@� 3�H75FAD�EG5:�3E 8C ."1/9 ;E�A8F7@�ID;FF7@�3E 8 " 9�;9GD7 ��E:AIE 8 " 9 3E�F:7�EG?�A8 8 3@6 "9

�"&��*��'%�"&�,"'&+ ;H7@�H75FADE 91; 92; : : : ; 9p ;@ Rn 3@6�9;H7@�E53>3DE c1; c2; : : : ; cp � F:7�H75FAD < 67S@76

x1

x2

v

u

–v

u – v

.75FAD�EG4FD35F;A@4K

< D c191 C ! ! ! C cp9p

;E�53>>76�3 /-1)%5�'20&-1%7-21 A8 91; : : : ; 9p I;F: :)-+,76 c1; : : : ; cp )DAB7DFK��;;�34AH7�B7D?;FE�GE�FA�A?;F�B3D7@F:7E7E�I:7@�8AD?;@9�EG5:�3�>;@73D�5A?4;@3F;A@ ,:7

Page 27: $)15&3 & * )- ,'&+ & & * $ * - University of Utah

�"&��*�)-�,"'&+�"&��"&��*��$ ��*�

I7;9:FE�;@�3�>;@73D�5A?4;@3F;A@�53@�47�3@K�D73>�@G?47DE� ;@5>G6;@9�L7DA �AD�7J3?B>7�EA?7�>;@73D�5A?4;@3F;A@E�A8�H75FADE 91 3@6 92 3D7p

3 91 C 92; 1291 .D 1

291 C 092/; 3@6 � .D 091 C 092/

�;9GD7���;67@F;S7E�E7>75F76�>;@73D�5A?4;@3F;A@E�A8 91 D#

"11

$3@6

92 D#

21

$ �'AF7�F:3F�E7FE�A8�B3D3>>7>�9D;6�>;@7E�3D7�6D3I@�F:DAG9:�;@F797D�?G>F;B>7E�A8

91 3@6 92� �EF;?3F7�F:7�>;@73D�5A?4;@3F;A@E�A8 91 3@6 92 F:3F�97@7D3F7�F:7�H75FADE 83@6 :

3v2

2v22v1

–2v1–2v2

v1 – v2 –2v1 + v2

3v1

v1

–v1–v2

wu

v2

v1 + v2 3v2

32–

0

%;@73D�5A?4;@3F;A@E�A8 91 3@6 92

,:7�B3D3>>7>A9D3?�DG>7�E:AIE�F:3F 8 ;E�F:7�EG?�A8 391 3@6 "292� F:3F�;E�8 D 391 " 292

,:;E�7JBD7EE;A@�8AD 8 53@�47�;@F7DBD7F76�3E�;@EFDG5F;A@E�8AD�FD3H7>;@9�8DA?�F:7�AD;9;@FA 8 3>A@9�FIA�EFD3;9:F�B3F:E �;DEF� FD3H7>���G@;FE�;@�F:7 91 6;D75F;A@�FA 391� 3@6�F:7@FD3H7> "��G@;FE�;@�F:7 92 6;D75F;A@��B3D3>>7>�FA�F:7�>;@7�F:DAG9: 92 3@6 �� '7JF� 3>F:AG9:F:7�H75FAD : ;E�@AF�A@�3�9D;6�>;@7� : 3BB73DE�FA�47�34AGF�:3>8I3K�47FI77@�FIA�B3;DE�A89D;6�>;@7E� 3F�F:7�H7DF7J�A8�3�B3D3>>7>A9D3?�67F7D?;@76�4K .5=2/91 3@6 ."1=2/92 �+77�;9 �� ,:GE�3�D73EA@34>7�7EF;?3F7�8AD : ;E

v1

w

–v2

2v1

3v1

0

: D 5291 " 1

292

,:7�@7JF�7J3?B>7�5A@@75FE�3�BDA4>7?�34AGF�>;@73D�5A?4;@3F;A@E�FA�F:7�8G@63?7@F3>7J;EF7@57�CG7EF;A@�EFG6;76�;@�+75F;A@E� �3@6� �

%7F %1 D

24

1"2"5

35� %2 D

24

256

35� 3@6 & D

24

74

"3

35 �7F7D?;@7�I:7F:7D

& 53@�47�97@7D3F76��AD�ID;FF7@��3E�3�>;@73D�5A?4;@3F;A@�A8 %1 3@6 %2 ,:3F�;E� 67F7D?;@7I:7F:7D�I7;9:FE x1 3@6 x2 7J;EF�EG5:�F:3F

x1%1 C x2%2 D & � �"8�H75FAD�7CG3F;A@�� ��:3E�3�EA>GF;A@� S@6�;F

-E7�F:7�67S@;F;A@E�A8�E53>3D�?G>F;B>;53F;A@�3@6�H75FAD�366;F;A@�FA�D7ID;F7F:7�H75FAD�7CG3F;A@

x1

24

1"2"5

35

✻%1

C x2

24

256

35

✻%2

D

24

74

"3

35

✻&

Page 28: $)15&3 & * )- ,'&+ & & * $ * - University of Utah

���,'*�)-�,"'&+

I:;5:�;E�F:7�E3?7�3E 24

x1

"2x1

"5x1

35 C

24

2x2

5x2

6x2

35 D

24

74

"3

35

3@6 24

x1 C 2x2

"2x1 C 5x2

"5x1 C 6x2

35 D

24

74

"3

35 ���

,:7�H75FADE�A@�F:7�>78F�3@6�D;9:F�E;67E�A8�����3D7�7CG3>�;8�3@6�A@>K�;8�F:7;D�5ADD7EBA@6;@97@FD;7E�3D7�4AF:�7CG3> ,:3F�;E� x1 3@6 x2 ?3=7�F:7�H75FAD�7CG3F;A@�� ��FDG7�;8�3@6�A@>K;8 x1 3@6 x2 E3F;E8K�F:7�EKEF7?

x1 C 2x2 D 7

"2x1 C 5x2 D 4

"5x1 C 6x2 D "3

���

,A�EA>H7�F:;E�EKEF7?� DAI�D76G57�F:7�3G9?7@F76�?3FD;J�A8�F:7�EKEF7?�3E�8A>>AIE�W24

1 2 7"2 5 4"5 6 "3

35 %

24

1 2 70 9 180 16 32

35 %

24

1 2 70 1 20 16 32

35 %

24

1 0 30 1 20 0 0

35

,:7�EA>GF;A@�A8�����;E x1 D 3 3@6 x2 D 2 !7@57 & ;E�3�>;@73D�5A?4;@3F;A@�A8 %1 3@6 %2�I;F:�I7;9:FE x1 D 3 3@6 x2 D 2 ,:3F�;E�

3

24

1"2"5

35 C 2

24

256

35 D

24

74

"3

35

(4E7DH7�;@��J3?B>7���F:3F�F:7�AD;9;@3>�H75FADE %1� %2� 3@6 & 3D7�F:7�5A>G?@E�A8�F:73G9?7@F76�?3FD;J�F:3F�I7�DAI�D76G576�2

41 2 7

"2 5 4"5

✻ ✻ ✻%1 %2 &

6 "3

35

�AD�4D7H;FK� ID;F7�F:;E�?3FD;J�;@�3�I3K�F:3F�;67@F;S7E�;FE�5A>G?@EO@3?7>K�Œ %1 %2 & ! ���

"F�;E�5>73D�:AI�FA�ID;F7�F:;E�3G9?7@F76�?3FD;J�;??76;3F7>K�8DA?�H75FAD�7CG3F;A@�� ��I;F:AGF�9A;@9�F:DAG9:�F:7�;@F7D?76;3F7�EF7BE�A8��J3?B>7�� ,3=7�F:7�H75FADE�;@�F:7AD67D�;@�I:;5:�F:7K�3BB73D�;@�� ��3@6�BGF�F:7?�;@FA�F:7�5A>G?@E�A8�3�?3FD;J�3E�;@ ���

,:7�6;E5GEE;A@�34AH7�;E�73E;>K�?A6;S76�FA�7EF34>;E:�F:7�8A>>AI;@9�8G@63?7@F3>�835F

� H75FAD�7CG3F;A@x1%1 C x2%2 C ! ! ! C xn%n D &

:3E�F:7�E3?7�EA>GF;A@�E7F�3E�F:7�>;@73D�EKEF7?�I:AE7�3G9?7@F76�?3FD;J�;E%%1 %2 ! ! ! %n &

&���

"@�B3DF;5G>3D� & 53@�47�97@7D3F76�4K�3�>;@73D�5A?4;@3F;A@�A8 %1; : : : ; %n ;8�3@6�A@>K;8�F:7D7�7J;EFE�3�EA>GF;A@�FA�F:7�>;@73D�EKEF7?�5ADD7EBA@6;@9�FA�F:7�?3FD;J����

W,:7�EK?4A> " 47FI77@�?3FD;57E�67@AF7E�DAI�7CG;H3>7@57��+75F;A@ ��

Page 29: $)15&3 & * )- ,'&+ & & * $ * - University of Utah

�"&��*�)-�,"'&+�"&��"&��*��$ ��*�

(@7�A8�F:7�=7K�;673E�;@�>;@73D�3>974D3�;E�FA�EFG6K�F:7�E7F�A8�3>>�H75FADE�F:3F�53@�4797@7D3F76�AD�ID;FF7@�3E�3�>;@73D�5A?4;@3F;A@�A8�3�SJ76�E7F f91; : : : ; 9pg A8�H75FADE

"8 91; : : : ; 9p 3D7�;@ Rn� F:7@�F:7�E7F�A8�3>> � >;@73D�5A?4;@3F;A@E�A8 91; : : : ; 9p

;E �67@AF76�4K +B3@ f91; : : : ; 9pg 3@6�;E �53>>76� F:7 68&6)7�2* Rn 63%11)( �AD+)1)5%7)(� &< 91; : : : ; 9p ,:3F � ;E� +B3@ f91; : : : ; 9pg ;E � F:7�5A>>75F;A@�A8�3>>H75FADE�F:3F�53@�47�ID;FF7@�;@�F:7�8AD?

c191 C c292 C ! ! ! C cp9p

I;F: c1; : : : ; cp E53>3DE

�E=;@9�I:7F:7D�3�H75FAD & ;E�;@ +B3@ f91; : : : ; 9pg 3?AG@FE�FA�3E=;@9�I:7F:7D�F:7H75FAD�7CG3F;A@

x191 C x292 C ! ! ! C xp9p D &

:3E�3�EA>GF;A@� AD� 7CG;H3>7@F>K� 3E=;@9�I:7F:7D�F:7�>;@73D�EKEF7?�I;F:�3G9?7@F76�?3FD;JŒ 91 ! ! ! 9p & ! :3E�3�EA>GF;A@

'AF7 � F:3F +B3@ f91; : : : ; 9pg 5A@F3;@E � 7H7DK � E53>3D �?G>F;B>7 � A8 91 �8AD � 7J3?B>7�� E;@57 c91 D c91 C 092 C ! ! ! C 09p "@�B3DF;5G>3D� F:7�L7DA�H75FAD�?GEF�47�;@+B3@ f91; : : : ; 9pg

� ��'%�,*"����+�*"(,"'&�'���(�&f�g �&���(�&f�� �g%7F 9 47�3�@A@L7DA�H75FAD�;@ R3 ,:7@ +B3@ f9g ;E�F:7�E7F�A8�3>>�E53>3D�?G>F;B>7E�A8 9�I:;5:�;E�F:7�E7F�A8�BA;@FE�A@�F:7�>;@7�;@ R3 F:DAG9: 9 3@6 � +77��;9 �

"8 8 3@6 9 3D7�@A@L7DA�H75FADE�;@ R3� I;F: 9 @AF�3�?G>F;B>7�A8 8� F:7@ +B3@ f8; 9g ;EF:7�B>3@7�;@ R3 F:3F�5A@F3;@E 8� 9� 3@6 � "@�B3DF;5G>3D� +B3@ f8; 9g 5A@F3;@E�F:7�>;@7�;@R3 F:DAG9: 8 3@6 � 3@6�F:7�>;@7�F:DAG9: 9 3@6 � +77��;9

x3

x1

Span{v}

x2

v

+B3@ f9g 3E�3�>;@7F:DAG9:�F:7�AD;9;@

x1

x3

x2

3u

3v2vv

u

5u

+B3@ f8; 9g 3E�3B>3@7�F:DAG9:�F:7�AD;9;@

%7F %1 D

24

1"2

3

35� %2 D

24

5"13"3

35� 3@6 & D

24

"381

35 ,:7@

+B3@ f%1; %2g ;E�3�B>3@7�F:DAG9:�F:7�AD;9;@�;@ R3 "E & ;@�F:3F�B>3@7�

Page 30: $)15&3 & * )- ,'&+ & & * $ * - University of Utah

���,'*�)-�,"'&+

�A7E�F:7�7CG3F;A@ x1%1 C x2%2 D & :3H7�3�EA>GF;A@� ,A�3@EI7D�F:;E� DAID76G57�F:7�3G9?7@F76�?3FD;J Œ %1 %2 & !�

24

1 5 "3"2 "13 8

3 "3 1

35 %

24

1 5 "30 "3 20 "18 10

35 %

24

1 5 "30 "3 20 0 "2

35

,:7�F:;D6�7CG3F;A@�;E 0 D "2� I:;5:�E:AIE�F:3F�F:7�EKEF7?�:3E�@A�EA>GF;A@ ,:7�H75FAD7CG3F;A@ x1%1 C x2%2 D & :3E�@A�EA>GF;A@� 3@6�EA & ;E %&+ ;@ +B3@ f%1; %2g

�"&��*��'%�"&�,"'&+�"&��(($"��,"'&+,:7�S@3>�7J3?B>7�E:AIE�:AI�E53>3D�?G>F;B>7E�3@6�>;@73D�5A?4;@3F;A@E�53@�3D;E7�I:7@3�CG3@F;FK�EG5:�3E�P5AEFQ�;E�4DA=7@�6AI@�;@FA�E7H7D3>�53F79AD;7E ,:7�43E;5�BD;@5;B>7�8ADF:7�7J3?B>7�5A@57D@E�F:7�5AEF�A8�BDA6G5;@9�E7H7D3>�G@;FE�A8�3@�;F7?�I:7@�F:7�5AEF�B7DG@;F�;E�=@AI@� '

@G?47DA8�G@;FE

(!'5AEF

B7D�G@;F

(D

'FAF3>5AEF

(

� 5A?B3@K�?3@G835FGD7E�FIA�BDA6G5FE �AD�� ���IADF:�A8�BDA6G5F���F:7�5A?B3@K�EB7@6E�����A@�?3F7D;3>E� ����A@�>34AD� 3@6�� ��A@�AH7D:736 �AD� ���IADF:�A8�BDA6G5F����F:7�5A?B3@K�EB7@6E�����A@�?3F7D;3>E� ����A@�>34AD� 3@6� ��A@�AH7D:736 %7F

& D

24

:45:25:15

35 3@6 ' D

24

:40:30:15

35

,:7@ & 3@6 ' D7BD7E7@F�F:7�P5AEFE�B7D�6A>>3D�A8�;@5A?7Q�8AD�F:7�FIA�BDA6G5FE

3 /:3F�75A@A?;5�;@F7DBD7F3F;A@�53@�47�9;H7@�FA�F:7�H75FAD 100&�4 +GBBAE7�F:7�5A?B3@K�I;E:7E�FA�?3@G835FGD7 x1 6A>>3DE�IADF:�A8�BDA6G5F�� 3@6

x2 6A>>3DE�IADF:�A8�BDA6G5F��� ;H7�3�H75FAD�F:3F�67E5D;47E�F:7�H3D;AGE�5AEFE�F:75A?B3@K�I;>>�:3H7��8AD�?3F7D;3>E� >34AD� 3@6�AH7D:736�

3 �A?BGF7

100& D 100

24

:45:25:15

35 D

24

452515

35

,:7 �H75FAD 100& >;EFE � F:7 � H3D;AGE � 5AEFE � 8AD � BDA6G5;@9 �� �� �IADF: � A8 � BDA6G5F�O@3?7>K� ����8AD�?3F7D;3>E� ����8AD�>34AD� 3@6�� ��8AD�AH7D:736

4 ,:7�5AEFE�A8�?3@G835FGD;@9 x1 6A>>3DE�IADF:�A8�� 3D7�9;H7@�4K�F:7�H75FAD x1&� 3@6F:7�5AEFE�A8�?3@G835FGD;@9 x2 6A>>3DE�IADF:�A8�� 3D7�9;H7@�4K x2' !7@57�F:7�FAF3>5AEFE�8AD�4AF:�BDA6G5FE�3D7�9;H7@�4K�F:7�H75FAD x1&C x2'

�� )DAH7�F:3F 8C 9 D 9C 8 8AD�3@K 8 3@6 9 ;@ Rn� �AD�I:3F�H3>G7�E��A8 h I;>> < 47�;@ +B3@f91; 92; 93g ;8

91 D

24

1"1"2

35; 92 D

24

5"4"7

35; 93 D

24

"310

35; 3@6 < D

24

"43h

35

Page 31: $)15&3 & * )- ,'&+ & & * $ * - University of Utah

�"&��*�)-�,"'&+�"&��"&��*��$ ��*�

"@��J7D5;E7E� �3@6��� 5A?BGF7 8C 9 3@6 8 " 29

�� 8 D#

"12

$� 9 D

#"3"1

$� 8 D

#32

$� 9 D

#2

"1

$

"@��J7D5;E7E���3@6��� 6;EB>3K�F:7�8A>>AI;@9�H75FADE�GE;@9�3DDAIEA@�3@ /09D3B:� 8� 9� "9� "29� 8C 9� 8 " 9� 3@6 8 " 29 'AF;57F:3F 8 " 9 ;E�F:7�H7DF7J�A8�3�B3D3>>7>A9D3?�I:AE7�AF:7D�H7DF;57E�3D78� �� 3@6 "9� 8 3@6 9 3E�;@��J7D5;E7� �� 8 3@6 9 3E�;@��J7D5;E7��

"@��J7D5;E7E���3@6��� ID;F7�3�EKEF7?�A8�7CG3F;A@E�F:3F�;E�7CG;H3>7@FFA�F:7�9;H7@�H75FAD�7CG3F;A@

�� x1

24

3"2

8

35 C x2

24

50

"9

35 D

24

2"3

8

35

� x1

#3

"2

$C x2

#73

$C x3

#"2

1

$D

#00

$

-E7�F:7�355A?B3@K;@9�S9GD7�FA�ID;F7�735:�H75FAD�>;EF76�;@��J7D5;E7E���3@6���3E�3�>;@73D�5A?4;@3F;A@�A8 8 3@6 9 "E�7H7DK�H75FAD;@ R2 3�>;@73D�5A?4;@3F;A@�A8 8 3@6 9�

w

x

v

u

ac

d

2vb

z

y–2v –u

–v0

�� .75FADE %� &� '� 3@6 (

�� .75FADE :� ;� <� 3@6 =

"@��J7D5;E7E���3@6� �� ID;F7�3�H75FAD�7CG3F;A@�F:3F�;E�7CG;H3>7@F�FAF:7�9;H7@�EKEF7?�A8�7CG3F;A@E

�� x2 C 5x3 D 0

4x1 C 6x2 " x3 D 0

"x1 C 3x2 " 8x3 D 0

��� 3x1 " 2x2 C 4x3 D 3

"2x1 " 7x2 C 5x3 D 1

5x1 C 4x2 " 3x3 D 2

"@��J7D5;E7E� �3@6� �� 67F7D?;@7�;8 & ;E�3�>;@73D�5A?4;@3F;A@�A8%1� %2� 3@6 %3

��� %1 D

24

1"2

0

35� %2 D

24

012

35� %3 D

24

5"6

8

35� & D

24

2"1

6

35

�� %1 D

24

101

35� %2 D

24

"23

"2

35� %3 D

24

"675

35� & D

24

11"5

9

35

"@��J7D5;E7E� ��3@6� �� 67F7D?;@7�;8 & ;E�3�>;@73D�5A?4;@3F;A@�A8F:7�H75FADE�8AD?76�8DA?�F:7�5A>G?@E�A8�F:7�?3FD;J A

�� A D

24

1 "4 20 3 5

"2 8 "4

35� & D

24

3"7"3

35

��� A D

24

1 0 5"2 1 "6

0 2 8

35� & D

24

2"1

6

35

��� %7F %1 D

24

13

"1

35� %2 D

24

"5"8

2

35� 3@6 & D

24

3"5

h

35 �AD�I:3F

H3>G7�E��A8 h ;E & ;@�F:7�B>3@7�EB3@@76�4K %1 3@6 %2�

� � %7F 91 D

24

10

"2

35� 92 D

24

"217

35� 3@6 < D

24

h"3"5

35 �AD�I:3F

H3>G7�E��A8 h ;E < ;@�F:7�B>3@7�97@7D3F76�4K 91 3@6 92�

"@��J7D5;E7E� ��3@6� �� >;EF�SH7�H75FADE�;@ +B3@ f91; 92g �AD�735:H75FAD� E:AI�F:7�I7;9:FE�A@ 91 3@6 92 GE76�FA�97@7D3F7�F:7�H75FAD3@6�>;EF�F:7�F:D77�7@FD;7E�A8�F:7�H75FAD �A�@AF�?3=7�3�E=7F5:

��� 91 D

24

312

35� 92 D

24

"401

35

��� 91 D

24

11

"2

35� 92 D

24

"230

35

��� ;H7�3�97A?7FD;5�67E5D;BF;A@�A8 +B3@ f91; 92g 8AD�F:7�H75FADE

91 D

24

82

"6

35 3@6 92 D

24

123

"9

35

�� ;H7�3�97A?7FD;5�67E5D;BF;A@�A8 +B3@ f91; 92g 8AD�F:7�H75FADE;@��J7D5;E7� �

�� %7F 8 D#

2"1

$3@6 9 D

#21

$ +:AI � F:3F

#hk

$;E � ;@

+B3@ f8; 9g 8AD�3>> h 3@6 k

� �A@EFDG5F�3 3 # 3?3FD;JA� I;F:�@A@L7DA�7@FD;7E� 3@6�3�H75FAD& ;@ R3 EG5:�F:3F & ;E %&+ ;@�F:7�E7F�EB3@@76�4K�F:7�5A>G?@EA8 A

"@��J7D5;E7E����3@6���� ?3D=�735:�EF3F7?7@F�,DG7�AD��3>E7 #GEF;8K735:�3@EI7D

� 3 �@AF:7D�@AF3F;A@�8AD�F:7�H75FAD#

"43

$;E Π"4 3 !

4 ,:7 �BA;@FE � ;@ � F:7 �B>3@7 �5ADD7EBA@6;@9 � FA#

"25

$3@6

#"5

2

$>;7�A@�3�>;@7�F:DAG9:�F:7�AD;9;@

5 �@�7J3?B>7�A8�3�>;@73D�5A?4;@3F;A@�A8�H75FADE 91 3@6 92

;E�F:7�H75FAD 1291

Page 32: $)15&3 & * )- ,'&+ & & * $ * - University of Utah

���,'*�)-�,"'&+

6 ,:7�EA>GF;A@�E7F�A8�F:7�>;@73D�EKEF7?�I:AE7�3G9?7@F76?3FD;J�;E Œ %1 %2 %3 & ! ;E�F:7�E3?7�3E�F:7�EA>GF;A@E7F�A8�F:7�7CG3F;A@ x1%1 C x2%2 C x3%3 D &

7 ,:7�E7F +B3@ f8; 9g ;E�3>I3KE�H;EG3>;L76�3E�3�B>3@7�F:DAG9:F:7�AD;9;@

�� 3 /:7@ 8 3@6 9 3D7�@A@L7DA�H75FADE� +B3@ f8; 9g 5A@F3;@EA@>K�F:7�>;@7�F:DAG9: 8 3@6�F:7�AD;9;@� 3@6�F:7�>;@7�F:DAG9:9 3@6�F:7�AD;9;@

4 �@K�>;EF�A8�SH7�D73>�@G?47DE�;E�3�H75FAD�;@ R55 �E=;@9 � I:7F:7D � F:7 � >;@73D � EKEF7? � 5ADD7EBA@6;@9 � FA3@�3G9?7@F76�?3FD;J Œ %1 %2 %3 & ! :3E�3�EA>GF;A@3?AG@FE�FA�3E=;@9�I:7F:7D & ;E�;@ +B3@ f%1; %2; %3g

6 ,:7�H75FAD 9 D7EG>FE�I:7@�3�H75FAD 8 " 9 ;E�36676�FA�F:7H75FAD 9

7 ,:7 � I7;9:FE c1; : : : ; cp ;@ � 3 � >;@73D � 5A?4;@3F;A@c191 C ! ! ! C cp9p 53@@AF�3>>�47�L7DA

�� %7F A D

24

1 0 "40 3 "2

"2 6 3

35 3@6 & D

24

41

"4

35 �7@AF7�F:7

5A>G?@E�A8 A 4K %1� %2� %3� 3@6�>7F W D +B3@ f%1; %2; %3g3 "E & ;@ f%1; %2; %3g� !AI�?3@K�H75FADE�3D7�;@ f%1; %2; %3g�4 "E & ;@ W � !AI�?3@K�H75FADE�3D7�;@ W �5 +:AI�F:3F %1 ;E�;@ W 1� %+� *AI�AB7D3F;A@E�3D7�G@@757EE3DK2

� %7F A D

24

2 0 6"1 8 5

1 "2 1

35� >7F & D

24

1037

35� 3@6�>7F W 47

F:7�E7F�A8�3>>�>;@73D�5A?4;@3F;A@E�A8�F:7�5A>G?@E�A8 A3 "E & ;@ W �4 +:AI�F:3F�F:7�E75A@6�5A>G?@�A8 A ;E�;@ W

�� � ?;@;@9�5A?B3@K�:3E�FIA�?;@7E (@7�63KRE�AB7D3F;A@3F �?;@7 �� �BDA6G57E �AD7 � F:3F �5A@F3;@E ��� �?7FD;5 � FA@E �A85ABB7D�3@6�����=;>A9D3?E�A8�E;>H7D� I:;>7�A@7�63KRE�AB7D3F;A@3F �?;@7 ��� �BDA6G57E �AD7 � F:3F �5A@F3;@E ��� �?7FD;5 � FA@E �A8

5ABB7D�3@6�����=;>A9D3?E�A8�E;>H7D %7F 91 D#

30600

$3@6

92 D#

40380

$ ,:7@ 91 3@6 92 D7BD7E7@F�F:7�PAGFBGF�B7D�63KQ

A8�?;@7�� �3@6�?;@7���� D7EB75F;H7>K3 /:3F�B:KE;53>�;@F7DBD7F3F;A@�53@�47�9;H7@�FA�F:7�H75FAD

591�4 +GBBAE7�F:7�5A?B3@K�AB7D3F7E�?;@7�� �8AD x1 63KE�3@6?;@7����8AD x2 63KE /D;F7�3�H75FAD�7CG3F;A@�I:AE7EA>GF;A@ �9;H7E � F:7 �@G?47D �A8 �63KE � 735: �?;@7 � E:AG>6AB7D3F7�;@�AD67D�FA�BDA6G57�����FA@E�A8�5ABB7D�3@6�����=;>A9D3?E�A8�E;>H7D �A�@AF�EA>H7�F:7�7CG3F;A@

5 1�2 +A>H7�F:7�7CG3F;A@�;@��4�

�� � EF73?�B>3@F�4GD@E�FIA�FKB7E�A8�5A3>� 3@F:D35;F7���� 3@64;FG?;@AGE������AD�735:�FA@�A8�� 4GD@76� F:7�B>3@F�BDA6G57E����?;>>;A@��FG�A8�:73F� � �� 9D3?E �9��A8�EG>8GD�6;AJ;67�3@6���� 9�A8�B3DF;5G>3F7�?3FF7D��EA>;6B3DF;5>7�BA>>GF3@FE� �AD

735:�FA@�A8�� 4GD@76� F:7�B>3@F�BDA6G57E�����?;>>;A@��FG����� 9�A8�EG>8GD�6;AJ;67� 3@6���� 9�A8�B3DF;5G>3F7�?3FF7D3 !AI�?G5:�:73F�6A7E�F:7�EF73?�B>3@F�BDA6G57�I:7@�;F4GD@E x1 FA@E�A8�� 3@6 x2 FA@E�A8���

4 +GBBAE7�F:7�AGFBGF�A8�F:7�EF73?�B>3@F�;E�67E5D;476�4K3�H75FAD�F:3F�>;EFE�F:7�3?AG@FE�A8�:73F� EG>8GD�6;AJ;67�3@6�B3DF;5G>3F7�?3FF7D �JBD7EE�F:;E�AGFBGF�3E�3�>;@73D5A?4;@3F;A@�A8�FIA�H75FADE� 3EEG?;@9�F:3F�F:7�B>3@F�4GD@Ex1 FA@E�A8�� 3@6 x2 FA@E�A8��

5 1�2 (H7D�3�57DF3;@�F;?7�B7D;A6� F:7�EF73?�B>3@F�BDA6G576 ���?;>>;A@��FG�A8�:73F� ���� � 9�A8�EG>8GD�6;AJ;67� 3@6 ��� 9�A8�B3DF;5G>3F7�?3FF7D �7F7D?;@7�:AI�?3@K�FA@EA8�735:�FKB7�A8�5A3>�F:7�EF73?�B>3@F�?GEF�:3H7�4GD@76"@5>G67�3�H75FAD�7CG3F;A@�3E�B3DF�A8�KAGD�EA>GF;A@

�� %7F 91; : : : ; 9k 47 � BA;@FE � ;@ R3 3@6 � EGBBAE7 � F:3F � 8ADj D 1; : : : ; k 3@�A4<75F�I;F:�?3EE mj ;E�>A53F76�3F�BA;@F 9j ):KE;5;EFE�53>>�EG5:�A4<75FE '& %+�$�**�* ,:7�FAF3>�?3EE�A8F:7�EKEF7?�A8�BA;@F�?3EE7E�;E

m D m1 C ! ! ! C mk

,:7 ��%+�)�&���)�- +0 �AD ��%+�)�&��$�**��A8�F:7�EKEF7?�;E

9 D 1

mŒm191 C ! ! ! C mk9k !

�A?BGF7�F:7�57@F7D�A8�9D3H;FK�A8�F:7�EKEF7?�5A@E;EF;@9�A8�F:78A>>AI;@9�BA;@F�?3EE7E��E77�F:7�S9GD7��

�2-17 �%6691 D .2; "2; 4/ ��992 D ."4; 2; 3/ ��993 D .4; 0; "2/ ��994 D .1; "6; 0/ ��9

x2

x1

v1v2

v4v3

x3

0

�� %7F 9 47 � F:7 � 57@F7D � A8 � ?3EE � A8 � 3 � EKEF7? � A8 � BA;@F?3EE7E � >A53F76 �3F 91; : : : ; 9k 3E � ;@ ��J7D5;E7 ��� "E 9 ;@+B3@ f91; : : : ; 9kg� �JB>3;@

Page 33: $)15&3 & * )- ,'&+ & & * $ * - University of Utah

�"&��*�)-�,"'&+�"&��"&��*��$ ��*�

�� � F:;@�FD;3@9G>3D�B>3F7�A8�G@;8AD?�67@E;FK�3@6�F:;5=@7EE�:3EH7DF;57E�3F 91 D .0; 1/� 92 D .8; 1/� 3@6 93 D .2; 4/� 3E�;@�F:7S9GD7�47>AI� 3@6�F:7�?3EE�A8�F:7�B>3F7�;E���9

v2

v3

v1

x1

4

8

x2

Metal Plate

3 �;@6�F:7 .x; y/5AAD6;@3F7E�A8�F:7�57@F7D�A8�?3EE�A8�F:7B>3F7 ,:;E�P43>3@57�BA;@FQ�A8�F:7�B>3F7�5A;@5;67E�I;F:F:7�57@F7D�A8�?3EE�A8�3�EKEF7?�5A@E;EF;@9�A8�F:D77� 9D3?BA;@F�?3EE7E�>A53F76�3F�F:7�H7DF;57E�A8�F:7�B>3F7

4 �7F7D?;@7�:AI�FA�6;EFD;4GF7�3@�366;F;A@3>�?3EE�A8���93F � F:7� F:D77�H7DF;57E�A8 � F:7�B>3F7� FA�?AH7�F:7�43>3@57BA;@F�A8�F:7�B>3F7�FA .2; 2/ 1� %+� %7F w1� w2� 3@6 w3

67@AF7�F:7�?3EE7E�36676�3F � F:7�F:D77�H7DF;57E� EA�F:3Fw1 C w2 C w3 D 62

� �A@E;67D�F:7�H75FADE 91� 92� 93� 3@6 & ;@ R2� E:AI@�;@�F:7S9GD7 �A7E�F:7�7CG3F;A@ x191 C x292 C x393 D & :3H7�3

EA>GF;A@� "E�F:7�EA>GF;A@�G@;CG7� -E7�F:7�S9GD7�FA�7JB>3;@KAGD�3@EI7DE

0

x2

x1

v3

v1

v2

b

� -E7 � F:7 � H75FADE 8 D .u1; : : : ; un/� 9 D .v1; : : : ; vn/� 3@6: D .w1; : : : ; wn/ FA�H7D;8K�F:7�8A>>AI;@9�3>974D3;5�BDAB7DF;7E�A8 Rn3 .8C 9/ C : D 8C .9C :/

4 c.8C 9/ D c8C c9 8AD�735:�E53>3D c

�� -E7�F:7�H75FAD 8 D .u1; : : : ; un/ FA�H7D;8K�F:7�8A>>AI;@9�3>974D3;5�BDAB7DF;7E�A8 Rn3 8C ."8/ D ."8/ C 8 D �4 c.d8/ D .cd/8 8AD�3>>�E53>3DE c 3@6 d

�� ,3=7�3D4;FD3DK�H75FADE 8 D .u1; : : : ; un/ 3@6 9 D .v1; : : : ; vn/ ;@ Rn� 3@6�5A?BGF78C 9 D .u1 C v1; : : : ; un C vn/ �7S@;F;A@�A8�H75FAD�366;F;A@

D .v1 C u1; : : : ; vn C un/ �A??GF3F;H;FK�A8�366;F;A@�;@ R

D 9C 8 �7S@;F;A@�A8�H75FAD�366;F;A@

� ,:7�H75FAD < 47>A@9E�FA +B3@ f91; 92; 93g ;8�3@6�A@>K�;8�F:7D7�7J;EF�E53>3DE x1; x2; x3

EG5:�F:3F

x1

24

1"1"2

35 C x2

24

5"4"7

35 C x3

24

"310

35 D

24

"43h

35

,:;E�H75FAD�7CG3F;A@�;E�7CG;H3>7@F�FA�3�EKEF7?�A8�F:D77�>;@73D�7CG3F;A@E�;@�F:D77G@=@AI@E "8�KAG�DAI�D76G57�F:7�3G9?7@F76�?3FD;J�8AD�F:;E�EKEF7?� KAG�S@6�F:3F2

41 5 "3 "4

"1 "4 1 3"2 "7 0 h

35 %

24

1 5 "3 "40 1 "2 "10 3 "6 h " 8

35 %

24

1 5 "3 "40 1 "2 "10 0 0 h " 5

35

,:7�EKEF7?�;E�5A@E;EF7@F�;8�3@6�A@>K�;8�F:7D7�;E�@A�B;HAF�;@�F:7�8AGDF:�5A>G?@ ,:3F

Span {v1, v2, v3}

h = 9

h = 1

h = 5 v3v1

v2

,:7�BA;@FE

24

"43h

35 >;7�A@�3�>;@7

F:3F�;@F7DE75FE�F:7�B>3@7�I:7@h D 5

;E� h " 5 ?GEF�47�� +A < ;E�;@ +B3@ f91; 92; 93g ;8�3@6�A@>K�;8 h D 5

������� ,:7�BD7E7@57�A8�3�8D77�H3D;34>7�;@�3�EKEF7?�6A7E�@AF�9G3D3@F77�F:3F�F:7EKEF7?�;E�5A@E;EF7@F

� 8G@63?7@F3>�;673�;@�>;@73D�3>974D3�;E�FA�H;7I�3�>;@73D�5A?4;@3F;A@�A8�H75FADE�3E�F:7BDA6G5F�A8�3�?3FD;J�3@6�3�H75FAD ,:7�8A>>AI;@9�67S@;F;A@�B7D?;FE�GE�FA�D7B:D3E7�EA?7A8�F:7�5A@57BFE�A8�+75F;A@ ��;@�@7I�I3KE

Page 34: $)15&3 & * )- ,'&+ & & * $ * - University of Utah

�!����,*"0�)-�,"'& A� D �

"8 A ;E�3@ m # n ?3FD;J� I;F:�5A>G?@E %1; : : : ; %n� 3@6�;8 ; ;E�;@ Rn� F:7@�F:7352(8'7�2* A %1(�;� 67@AF76�4K A;� ;E 7,)�/-1)%5�'20&-1%7-21�2*�7,)�'2/80162* A 86-1+�7,)�'255)6321(-1+�)175-)6�-1�;�%6�:)-+,76� F:3F�;E�

A; D%%1 %2 ! ! ! %n

&264

x1

:::xn

375 D x1%1 C x2%2 C ! ! ! C xn%n

'AF7�F:3FA; ;E�67S@76�A@>K�;8�F:7�@G?47D�A8�5A>G?@E�A8A 7CG3>E�F:7�@G?47D�A8�7@FD;7E;@ ;

3#

1 2 "10 "5 3

$24

437

35 D 4

#10

$C 3

#2

"5

$C 7

#"1

3

$

D#

40

$C

#6

"15

$C

#"721

$D

#36

$

4

24

2 "38 0

"5 2

35

#47

$D 4

24

28

"5

35 C 7

24

"302

35 D

24

832

"20

35 C

24

"210

14

35 D

24

"1332"6

35

�AD 91; 92; 93 ;@Rm� ID;F7�F:7�>;@73D�5A?4;@3F;A@ 391 " 592 C 793 3E3�?3FD;J�F;?7E�3�H75FAD

)>357 91; 92; 93 ;@FA�F:7�5A>G?@E�A8�3�?3FD;JA 3@6�B>357�F:7�I7;9:FE���"5�3@6���;@FA�3�H75FAD ; ,:3F�;E�

391 " 592 C 793 D%91 92 93

&24

3"5

7

35 D A;

+75F;A@ ��E:AI76�:AI�FA�ID;F7�3�EKEF7?�A8�>;@73D�7CG3F;A@E�3E�3�H75FAD�7CG3F;A@;@HA>H;@9�3�>;@73D�5A?4;@3F;A@�A8�H75FADE �AD�7J3?B>7� F:7�EKEF7?

x1 C 2x2 " x3 D 4

"5x2 C 3x3 D 1� �

;E�7CG;H3>7@F�FA

x1

#10

$C x2

#2

"5

$C x3

#"1

3

$D

#41

$���

�E�;@��J3?B>7��� F:7�>;@73D�5A?4;@3F;A@�A@�F:7�>78F�E;67�;E�3�?3FD;J�F;?7E�3�H75FAD� EAF:3F�����475A?7E #

1 2 "10 "5 3

$24

x1

x2

x3

35 D

#41

$���

�CG3F;A@�����:3E�F:7�8AD? A; D & +G5:�3@�7CG3F;A@�;E�53>>76�3 0%75-;�)48%7-21�FA�6;EF;@9G;E:�;F�8DA?�3�H75FAD�7CG3F;A@�EG5:�3E�;E�E:AI@�;@����

'AF;57�:AI�F:7�?3FD;J�;@�����;E�<GEF�F:7�?3FD;J�A8�5A78S5;7@FE�A8�F:7�EKEF7?�� �+;?;>3D�53>5G>3F;A@E�E:AI�F:3F�3@K�EKEF7?�A8�>;@73D�7CG3F;A@E� AD�3@K�H75FAD�7CG3F;A@EG5:�3E����� 53@�47�ID;FF7@�3E�3@�7CG;H3>7@F�?3FD;J�7CG3F;A@�;@�F:7�8AD? A; D & ,:;EE;?B>7�A4E7DH3F;A@�I;>>�47�GE76�D7B73F76>K�F:DAG9:AGF�F:7�F7JF

!7D7�;E�F:7�8AD?3>�D7EG>F

Page 35: $)15&3 & * )- ,'&+ & & * $ * - University of Utah

�"&��*�)-�,"'&+�"&��"&��*��$ ��*�

"8 A ;E�3@ m # n ?3FD;J� I;F:�5A>G?@E %1; : : : ; %n� 3@6�;8 & ;E�;@ Rm� F:7�?3FD;J7CG3F;A@

A; D & ���

:3E�F:7�E3?7�EA>GF;A@�E7F�3E�F:7�H75FAD�7CG3F;A@

x1%1 C x2%2 C ! ! ! C xn%n D & ���

I:;5:� ;@�FGD@� :3E�F:7�E3?7�EA>GF;A@�E7F�3E�F:7�EKEF7?�A8�>;@73D�7CG3F;A@E�I:AE73G9?7@F76�?3FD;J�;E %

%1 %2 ! ! ! %n &&

���

,:7AD7?���BDAH;67E�3�BAI7D8G>�FAA>�8AD�93;@;@9�;@E;9:F�;@FA�BDA4>7?E�;@�>;@73D3>974D3� 4753GE7�3�EKEF7?�A8�>;@73D�7CG3F;A@E�?3K�@AI�47�H;7I76�;@�F:D77�6;887D7@F4GF�7CG;H3>7@F�I3KE� 3E�3�?3FD;J�7CG3F;A@� 3E�3�H75FAD�7CG3F;A@� AD�3E�3�EKEF7?�A8�>;@73D7CG3F;A@E /:7@7H7D�KAG�5A@EFDG5F�3�?3F:7?3F;53>�?A67>�A8�3�BDA4>7?�;@�D73>�>;87� KAG3D7�8D77�FA�5:AAE7�I:;5:7H7D�H;7IBA;@F�;E�?AEF�@3FGD3> ,:7@�KAG�?3K�EI;F5:�8DA?�A@78AD?G>3F;A@�A8�3�BDA4>7?�FA�3@AF:7D�I:7@7H7D�;F�;E�5A@H7@;7@F "@�3@K�53E7� F:7�?3FD;J7CG3F;A@����� F:7�H75FAD�7CG3F;A@����� 3@6�F:7�EKEF7?�A8�7CG3F;A@E�3D7�3>>�EA>H76�;@�F:7E3?7�I3KO4K�DAI�D76G5;@9�F:7�3G9?7@F76�?3FD;J���� (F:7D�?7F:A6E�A8�EA>GF;A@�I;>>47�6;E5GEE76�>3F7D

0"+,�&���'���'$-,"'&+,:7�67S@;F;A@�A8 A; >736E�6;D75F>K�FA�F:7�8A>>AI;@9�GE78G>�835F

,:7�7CG3F;A@ A; D & :3E�3�EA>GF;A@�;8�3@6�A@>K�;8 & ;E�3�>;@73D�5A?4;@3F;A@�A8�F:75A>G?@E�A8 A

+75F;A@ ��5A@E;67D76�F:7�7J;EF7@57�CG7EF;A@� P"E & ;@ +B3@ f%1; : : : ; %ng�Q �CG;H3>7@F>K� P"E A; D & 5A@E;EF7@F�Q � :3D67D�7J;EF7@57�BDA4>7?�;E�FA�67F7D?;@7�I:7F:7DF:7�7CG3F;A@ A; D & ;E�5A@E;EF7@F �&)��## BAEE;4>7 &

%7F A D

24

1 3 4"4 2 "6"3 "2 "7

35 3@6 & D

24

b1

b2

b3

35 "E�F:7�7CG3F;A@ A; D &

5A@E;EF7@F�8AD�3>>�BAEE;4>7 b1; b2; b3�

*AI�D76G57�F:7�3G9?7@F76�?3FD;J�8AD A; D &�24

1 3 4 b1

"4 2 "6 b2

"3 "2 "7 b3

35 %

24

1 3 4 b1

0 14 10 b2 C 4b1

0 7 5 b3 C 3b1

35

%

24

1 3 4 b1

0 14 10 b2 C 4b1

0 0 0 b3 C 3b1 " 12.b2 C 4b1/

35

,:7 � F:;D6 �7@FDK � ;@ �5A>G?@�� �7CG3>E b1 " 12b2 C b3 ,:7 �7CG3F;A@ A; D & ;E %&+

5A@E;EF7@F�8AD�7H7DK & 4753GE7�EA?7�5:A;57E�A8 & 53@�?3=7 b1 " 12b2 C b3 @A@L7DA

Page 36: $)15&3 & * )- ,'&+ & & * $ * - University of Utah

�!����,*"0�)-�,"'& A� D �

,:7�D76G576�?3FD;J�;@��J3?B>7���BDAH;67E�3�67E5D;BF;A@�A8�3>> & 8AD�I:;5:�F:77CG3F;A@ A; D & * 5A@E;EF7@F� ,:7�7@FD;7E�;@ & ?GEF�E3F;E8K

b1 " 12b2 C b3 D 0

,:;E�;E�F:7�7CG3F;A@�A8�3�B>3@7�F:DAG9:�F:7�AD;9;@�;@R3 ,:7�B>3@7�;E�F:7�E7F�A8�3>>�>;@73D5A?4;@3F;A@E�A8�F:7�F:D77�5A>G?@E�A8 A +77��;9

,:7�7CG3F;A@ A; D & ;@��J3?B>7���83;>E�FA�47�5A@E;EF7@F�8AD�3>> & 4753GE7�F:775:7>A@�8AD?�A8 A :3E�3�DAI�A8�L7DAE "8 A :36�3�B;HAF�;@�3>>�F:D77�DAIE� I7�IAG>6@AF�53D7�34AGF�F:7�53>5G>3F;A@E�;@�F:7�3G9?7@F76�5A>G?@�4753GE7�;@�F:;E�53E7�3@�75:7>A@8AD?�A8�F:7�3G9?7@F76�?3FD;J�5AG>6�@AF�:3H7�3�DAI�EG5:�3E Œ 0 0 0 1 !

"@�F:7�@7JF�F:7AD7?� F:7�E7@F7@57�P,:7�5A>G?@E�A8A EB3@RmQ�?73@E�F:3F �-�)0 & ;@

x3

x1x2

0

Span{a1, a2

, a3}

,:7�5A>G?@E�A8A D Œ %1 %2 %3 ! EB3@�3�B>3@7F:DAG9: �

Rm ;E�3�>;@73D�5A?4;@3F;A@�A8�F:7�5A>G?@E�A8A "@�97@7D3>� 3�E7F�A8�H75FADE f91; : : : ; 9pg;@ Rm 63%16 �AD +)1)5%7)6� Rm ;8 �7H7DK�H75FAD� ;@ Rm ;E �3 � >;@73D�5A?4;@3F;A@�A891; : : : ; 9pOF:3F�;E� ;8 +B3@ f91; : : : ; 9pg D Rm

%7FA 47�3@m # n?3FD;J ,:7@�F:7�8A>>AI;@9�EF3F7?7@FE�3D7�>A9;53>>K�7CG;H3>7@F,:3F�;E� 8AD�3�B3DF;5G>3D A� 7;F:7D�F:7K�3D7�3>>�FDG7�EF3F7?7@FE�AD�F:7K�3D7�3>>�83>E7

3 �AD�735: & ;@ Rm� F:7�7CG3F;A@ A; D & :3E�3�EA>GF;A@4 �35: & ;@ Rm ;E�3�>;@73D�5A?4;@3F;A@�A8�F:7�5A>G?@E�A8 A5 ,:7�5A>G?@E�A8 A EB3@ Rm6 A :3E�3�B;HAF�BAE;F;A@�;@�7H7DK�DAI

,:7AD7?���;E�A@7�A8�F:7�?AEF�GE78G>�F:7AD7?E�;@�F:;E�5:3BF7D +F3F7?7@FE��3���4�� 3@6��5��3D7�7CG;H3>7@F�4753GE7�A8�F:7�67S@;F;A@�A8 A; 3@6�I:3F�;F�?73@E�8AD�3E7F�A8�H75FADE�FA�EB3@ Rm ,:7�6;E5GEE;A@�38F7D��J3?B>7���EG997EFE�I:K��3��3@6��6�3D7�7CG;H3>7@F� 3�BDAA8�;E�9;H7@�3F�F:7�7@6�A8�F:7�E75F;A@ ,:7�7J7D5;E7E�I;>>�BDAH;677J3?B>7E�A8�:AI�,:7AD7?���;E�GE76

������ ,:7AD7?���;E�34AGF�3 �&��3� �%+�$�+) /� @AF�3@�3G9?7@F76�?3FD;J "8�3@3G9?7@F76�?3FD;J Œ A & ! :3E�3�B;HAF�BAE;F;A@�;@�7H7DK�DAI� F:7@�F:7�7CG3F;A@ A; D &?3K�AD�?3K�@AF�47�5A@E;EF7@F

�'%(-,�,"'&�'� A�

,:7�53>5G>3F;A@E�;@��J3?B>7� �I7D7�43E76�A@�F:7�67S@;F;A@�A8�F:7�BDA6G5F�A8�3�?3FD;J A3@6�3�H75FAD ; ,:7�8A>>AI;@9�E;?B>7�7J3?B>7�I;>>�>736�FA�3�?AD7�78S5;7@F�?7F:A6�8AD53>5G>3F;@9�F:7�7@FD;7E�;@ A; I:7@�IAD=;@9�BDA4>7?E�4K�:3@6

�A?BGF7 A;� I:7D7 A D

24

2 3 4"1 5 "3

6 "2 8

35 3@6 ; D

24

x1

x2

x3

35

Page 37: $)15&3 & * )- ,'&+ & & * $ * - University of Utah

�"&��*�)-�,"'&+�"&��"&��*��$ ��*�

�DA?�F:7�67S@;F;A@�24

2 3 4"1 5 "3

6 "2 8

35

24

x1

x2

x3

35 D x1

24

2"1

6

35 C x2

24

35

"2

35 C x3

24

4"3

8

35

D

24

2x1

"x1

6x1

35 C

24

3x2

5x2

"2x2

35 C

24

4x3

"3x3

8x3

35 ���

D

24

2x1 C 3x2 C 4x3

"x1 C 5x2 " 3x3

6x1 " 2x2 C 8x3

35

,:7�SDEF�7@FDK�;@�F:7�BDA6G5F A; ;E�3�EG?�A8�BDA6G5FE��EA?7F;?7E�53>>76�3 �&+�')&�,�+��GE;@9�F:7�SDEF�DAI�A8 A 3@6�F:7�7@FD;7E�;@ ; ,:3F�;E�

24

2 3 435

24

x1

x2

x3

35 D

24

2x1 C 3x2 C 4x3

35

,:;E�?3FD;J�E:AIE�:AI�FA�5A?BGF7�F:7�SDEF�7@FDK�;@ A; 6;D75F>K� I;F:AGF�ID;F;@9�6AI@3>>�F:7�53>5G>3F;A@E�E:AI@�;@���� +;?;>3D>K� F:7�E75A@6�7@FDK�;@ A; 53@�47�53>5G>3F76�3FA@57�4K�?G>F;B>K;@9�F:7�7@FD;7E�;@�F:7�E75A@6�DAI�A8 A 4K�F:7�5ADD7EBA@6;@9�7@FD;7E�;@; 3@6�F:7@�EG??;@9�F:7�D7EG>F;@9�BDA6G5FE�

24 "1 5 "3

35

24

x1

x2

x3

35 D

24 "x1 C 5x2 " 3x3

35

%;=7I;E7� F:7�F:;D6�7@FDK�;@ A; 53@�47�53>5G>3F76�8DA?�F:7�F:;D6�DAI�A8 A 3@6�F:7�7@FD;7E;@ ;

"8�F:7�BDA6G5F A; ;E�67S@76� F:7@�F:7 i F:�7@FDK�;@ A; ;E�F:7�EG?�A8�F:7�BDA6G5FE�A85ADD7EBA@6;@9�7@FD;7E�8DA?�DAI i A8 A 3@6�8DA?�F:7�H75FAD ;

3#

1 2 "10 "5 3

$24

437

35 D

#1 ! 4 C 2 ! 3 C ."1/ ! 70 ! 4 C ."5/ ! 3 C 3 ! 7

$D

#36

$

4

24

2 "38 0

"5 2

35

#47

$D

24

2 ! 4 C ."3/ ! 78 ! 4 C 0 ! 7

."5/ ! 4 C 2 ! 7

35 D

24

"1332"6

35

5

24

1 0 00 1 00 0 1

35

24

rst

35 D

24

1 ! r C 0 ! s C 0 ! t0 ! r C 1 ! s C 0 ! t0 ! r C 0 ! s C 1 ! t

35 D

24

rst

35

�K�67S@;F;A@� F:7�?3FD;J�;@��J3?B>7���5��I;F:� RE�A@�F:7�6;39A@3>�3@6��RE�7>E7I:7D7;E�53>>76�3@ -()17-7<�0%75-; 3@6�;E�67@AF76�4K I ,:7�53>5G>3F;A@�;@�B3DF��5��E:AIE�F:3FI; D ; 8AD�7H7DK ; ;@ R3 ,:7D7�;E�3@�3@3>A9AGE n # n ;67@F;FK�?3FD;J� EA?7F;?7EID;FF7@�3E In �E�;@�B3DF��5�� In; D ; 8AD�7H7DK ; ;@ Rn

Page 38: $)15&3 & * )- ,'&+ & & * $ * - University of Utah

�!����,*"0�)-�,"'& A� D �

�*'(�*,"�+�'��,!����,*"02���,'*��*'�-�, A�,:7�835FE�;@�F:7�@7JF�F:7AD7?�3D7�;?BADF3@F�3@6�I;>>�47�GE76�F:DAG9:AGF�F:7�F7JF ,:7BDAA8�D7>;7E�A@�F:7�67S@;F;A@�A8 A; 3@6�F:7�3>974D3;5�BDAB7DF;7E�A8 Rn

"8 A ;E�3@ m # n ?3FD;J� 8 3@6 9 3D7�H75FADE�;@ Rn� 3@6 c ;E�3�E53>3D� F:7@�

3 A.8C 9/ D A8C A9�4 A.c8/ D c.A8/

�AD�E;?B>;5;FK� F3=7 n D 3� A D Œ %1 %2 %3 !� 3@6 8� 9 ;@ R3 �,:7�BDAA8�A8F:7�97@7D3>�53E7�;E�E;?;>3D� �AD i D 1; 2; 3� >7F ui 3@6 vi 47�F:7 i F:�7@FD;7E�;@ 8 3@6 9�D7EB75F;H7>K ,A�BDAH7�EF3F7?7@F��3�� 5A?BGF7 A.8C 9/ 3E�3�>;@73D�5A?4;@3F;A@�A8�F:75A>G?@E�A8 A GE;@9�F:7�7@FD;7E�;@ 8C 9 3E�I7;9:FE

A.8C 9/ D Π%1 %2 %3 !

24

u1 C v1

u2 C v2

u3 C v3

35

# # # �@FD;7E�;@ 8C 9

D .u1 C v1/%1 C .u2 C v2/%2 C .u3 C v3/%3

" " " �A>G?@E�A8 A

D .u1%1 C u2%2 C u3%3/ C .v1%1 C v2%2 C v3%3/

D A8C A9,A�BDAH7�EF3F7?7@F��4�� 5A?BGF7 A.c8/ 3E�3�>;@73D�5A?4;@3F;A@�A8�F:7�5A>G?@E�A8 AGE;@9�F:7�7@FD;7E�;@ c8 3E�I7;9:FE

A.c8/ D Π%1 %2 %3 !

24

cu1

cu2

cu3

35 D .cu1/%1 C .cu2/%2 C .cu3/%3

D c.u1%1/ C c.u2%2/ C c.u3%3/

D c.u1%1 C u2%2 C u3%3/

D c.A8/

,A�ABF;?;L7�3�5A?BGF7D�3>9AD;F:?�FA�5A?BGF7 A;� F:7�E7CG7@57�A8�53>5G>3F;A@EE:AG>6�;@HA>H7�63F3�EFAD76�;@�5A@F;9GAGE�?7?ADK�>A53F;A@E ,:7�?AEF�I;67>KGE76�BDA87EE;A@3>�3>9AD;F:?E�8AD�?3FD;J�5A?BGF3F;A@E�3D7�ID;FF7@�;@��ADFD3@� 3>3@9G397�F:3F�EFAD7E�3�?3FD;J�3E�3�E7F�A8�5A>G?@E +G5:�3>9AD;F:?E�5A?BGF7 A;3E�3�>;@73D�5A?4;@3F;A@�A8�F:7�5A>G?@E�A8A "@�5A@FD3EF� ;8�3�BDA9D3?�;E�ID;FF7@�;@F:7�BABG>3D�>3@9G397����I:;5:�EFAD7E�?3FD;57E�4K�DAIE� A; E:AG>6�47�5A?BGF76H;3�F:7�3>F7D@3F;H7�DG>7�F:3F�GE7E�F:7�DAIE�A8 A

�E�I3E�BA;@F76�AGF�38F7D�,:7AD7?��� EF3F7?7@FE��3�� �4�� 3@6�5��3D7�>A9;53>>K�7CG;H3>7@F +A� ;F�EG8S57E�FA�E:AI��8AD�3@�3D4;FD3DK�?3FD;J A��F:3F��3�3@6��6��3D7�7;F:7D�4AF:�FDG7�AD�4AF:�83>E7 ,:3F�I;>>�F;7�3>>�8AGD�EF3F7?7@FE�FA97F:7D

%7F U 47�3@�75:7>A@�8AD?�A8 A ;H7@ & ;@ Rm� I7�53@�DAI�D76G57�F:7�3G9?7@F76?3FD;J Œ A & ! FA�3@�3G9?7@F76�?3FD;J Œ U ( ! 8AD�EA?7 ( ;@ Rm�

ΠA & ! % ! ! ! % ΠU ( !

Page 39: $)15&3 & * )- ,'&+ & & * $ * - University of Utah

�"&��*�)-�,"'&+�"&��"&��*��$ ��*�

"8�EF3F7?7@F��6��;E�FDG7� F:7@�735:�DAI�A8 U 5A@F3;@E�3�B;HAF�BAE;F;A@�3@6�F:7D7�53@�47@A�B;HAF�;@�F:7�3G9?7@F76�5A>G?@ +A A; D & :3E�3�EA>GF;A@�8AD�3@K &� 3@6��3��;E�FDG7"8��6��;E�83>E7� F:7�>3EF�DAI�A8 U ;E�3>>�L7DAE %7F ( 47�3@K�H75FAD�I;F:�3� �;@�;FE�>3EF�7@FDK,:7@ Œ U ( ! D7BD7E7@FE�3@ %�&%* *+�%+ EKEF7? +;@57�DAI�AB7D3F;A@E�3D7�D7H7DE;4>7�Œ U ( ! 53@�47�FD3@E8AD?76�;@FA�F:7�8AD? Œ A & ! ,:7�@7I�EKEF7? A; D & ;E�3>EA;@5A@E;EF7@F� 3@6��3��;E�83>E7

�� %7F A D

24

1 5 "2 0"3 1 9 "5

4 "8 "1 7

35� 3 D

2664

3"2

0"4

3775� 3@6 & D

24

"790

35 "F�53@�47�E:AI@

F:3F 3 ;E �3 �EA>GF;A@�A8 A; D & -E7� F:;E �835F � FA�7J:;4;F & 3E�3 �EB75;S5� >;@73D5A?4;@3F;A@�A8�F:7�5A>G?@E�A8 A

� %7F A D#

2 53 1

$� 8 D

#4

"1

$� 3@6 9 D

#"3

5

$ .7D;8K�,:7AD7?���3��;@�F:;E�53E7

4K�5A?BGF;@9 A.8C 9/ 3@6 A8C A9

�A?BGF7�F:7�BDA6G5FE�;@��J7D5;E7E� N��GE;@9��3��F:7�67S@;F;A@� 3E;@��J3?B>7� � 3@6��4��F:7�DAINH75FAD�DG>7�8AD�5A?BGF;@9 A; "8�3BDA6G5F�;E�G@67S@76� 7JB>3;@�I:K

��

24

"4 21 60 1

35

24

3"2

7

35 �

24

131

35

#5

"1

$

24

1 2"3 1

1 6

35

#"2

3

$��

#1 3 "43 2 1

$24

121

35

"@��J7D5;E7E��N�� GE7�F:7�67S@;F;A@�A8 A; FA�ID;F7�F:7�?3FD;J7CG3F;A@�3E�3�H75FAD�7CG3F;A@� AD�H;57�H7DE3

��#

1 2 "3 1"2 "3 1 "1

$2664

2"1

1"1

3775 D

#"4

1

$

2664

2 "33 28 "5

"2 1

3775

#"3

5

$D

2664

"211

"4911

3775

�� x1

2664

4"1

7"4

3775 C x2

2664

"53

"51

3775 C x3

2664

7"8

02

3775 D

2664

6"8

0"7

3775

�� ´1

#2

"4

$C ´2

#"1

5

$C ´3

#"4

3

$C ´4

#02

$D

#5

12

$

"@��J7D5;E7E���3@6� �� ID;F7�F:7�EKEF7?�SDEF�3E�3�H75FAD�7CG3F;A@3@6�F:7@�3E�3�?3FD;J�7CG3F;A@

�� 5x1 C x2 " 3x3 D 8

2x2 C 4x3 D 0

��� 4x1 " x2 D 8

5x1 C 3x2 D 2

3x1 " x2 D 1

;H7@A 3@6 & ;@��J7D5;E7E� �3@6� �� ID;F7�F:7�3G9?7@F76�?3FD;J8AD � F:7 � >;@73D � EKEF7?� F:3F �5ADD7EBA@6E � FA � F:7 �?3FD;J �7CG3F;A@A; D & ,:7@�EA>H7�F:7�EKEF7?�3@6�ID;F7�F:7�EA>GF;A@�3E�3�H75FAD

��� A D

24

1 3 "41 5 2

"3 "7 6

35� & D

24

"24

12

35

�� A D

24

1 2 "1"3 "4 2

5 2 3

35� & D

24

12

"3

35

�� %7F 8 D

24

044

35 3@6 A D

24

3 "5"2 6

1 1

35 "E 8 ;@�F:7�B>3@7�;@

R3 EB3@@76�4K�F:7�5A>G?@E�A8 A� �+77�F:7�S9GD7� /:K�ADI:K�@AF�

u?

u?

Plane spanned bythe columns of A

Where is u?

��� %7F 8 D

24

4"1

4

35 3@6A D

24

2 5 "10 1 "11 2 0

35 "E 8 ;@�F:7�EG4E7F

A8 R3 EB3@@76�4K�F:7�5A>G?@E�A8 A� /:K�AD�I:K�@AF�

Page 40: $)15&3 & * )- ,'&+ & & * $ * - University of Utah

�!����,*"0�)-�,"'& A� D �

��� %7FA D#

3 "1"9 3

$3@6 & D

#b1

b2

$ +:AI�F:3F�F:7�7CG3F;A@

A; D & 6A7E �@AF �:3H7�3 �EA>GF;A@� 8AD �3>> �BAEE;4>7 &� 3@667E5D;47 � F:7 �E7F �A8 �3>> & 8AD �I:;5: A; D & �&�* :3H7 �3EA>GF;A@

� � *7B73F�F:7�D7CG7EFE�8DA?��J7D5;E7� ��I;F:

A D

24

1 "2 "1"2 2 0

4 "1 3

35; 3@6 & D

24

b1

b2

b3

35:

�J7D5;E7E� �N���D787D�FA�F:7�?3FD;57E A 3@6 B 47>AI &3=73BBDABD;3F7�53>5G>3F;A@E�F:3F�<GEF;8K�KAGD�3@EI7DE�3@6�?7@F;A@�3@3BBDABD;3F7�F:7AD7?

A D

2664

1 3 0 3"1 "1 "1 1

0 "4 2 "82 0 3 "1

3775 B D

2664

1 4 1 20 1 3 "40 2 6 72 9 5 "7

3775

��� !AI�?3@K�DAIE�A8 A 5A@F3;@�3�B;HAF�BAE;F;A@� �A7E�F:77CG3F;A@ A; D & :3H7�3�EA>GF;A@�8AD�735: & ;@ R4�

��� �3@�7H7DK�H75FAD�;@ R4 47�ID;FF7@�3E�3�>;@73D�5A?4;@3F;A@�A8F:7�5A>G?@E�A8�F:7�?3FD;J B 34AH7� �A�F:7�5A>G?@E�A8 BEB3@ R3�

��� �3@�735:�H75FAD�;@ R4 47�ID;FF7@�3E�3�>;@73D�5A?4;@3F;A@�A8F:7�5A>G?@E�A8�F:7�?3FD;J A 34AH7� �A�F:7�5A>G?@E�A8 AEB3@ R4�

�� �A�F:7�5A>G?@E�A8 B EB3@ R4� �A7E�F:7�7CG3F;A@ B; D <:3H7�3�EA>GF;A@�8AD�735: < ;@ R4�

�� %7F 91 D

2664

10

"10

3775� 92 D

2664

0"1

01

3775� 93 D

2664

100

"1

3775 �A7E

f91; 92; 93g EB3@ R4� /:K AD�I:K�@AF�

� %7F 91 D

24

00

"3

35� 92 D

24

0"3

9

35� 93 D

24

4"2"6

35 �A7E

f91; 92; 93g EB3@ R3� /:K AD�I:K�@AF�

"@��J7D5;E7E����3@6���� ?3D=�735:�EF3F7?7@F�,DG7�AD��3>E7 #GEF;8K735:�3@EI7D

� 3 ,:7�7CG3F;A@ A; D & ;E�D787DD76�FA�3E�3 -��+&)��(,�+ &%4 � H75FAD & ;E�3�>;@73D�5A?4;@3F;A@�A8�F:7�5A>G?@E�A8�3?3FD;J A ;8�3@6�A@>K�;8�F:7�7CG3F;A@ A; D & :3E�3F�>73EFA@7�EA>GF;A@

5 ,:7�7CG3F;A@ A; D & ;E�5A@E;EF7@F�;8�F:7�3G9?7@F76�?3FD;J Œ A & ! :3E�3�B;HAF�BAE;F;A@�;@�7H7DK�DAI

6 ,:7�SDEF�7@FDK�;@�F:7�BDA6G5F A; ;E�3�EG?�A8�BDA6G5FE7 "8�F:7�5A>G?@E�A8�3@ m # n ?3FD;J A EB3@ Rm� F:7@�F:77CG3F;A@ A; D & ;E�5A@E;EF7@F�8AD�735: & ;@ Rm

8 "8 A ;E�3@ m # n ?3FD;J�3@6�;8�F:7�7CG3F;A@ A; D & ;E;@5A@E;EF7@F�8AD�EA?7 & ;@Rm� F:7@A 53@@AF�:3H7�3�B;HAFBAE;F;A@�;@�7H7DK�DAI

�� 3 �H7DK�?3FD;J�7CG3F;A@ A; D & 5ADD7EBA@6E�FA�3�H75FAD7CG3F;A@�I;F:�F:7�E3?7�EA>GF;A@�E7F

4 "8�F:7�7CG3F;A@ A; D & ;E�5A@E;EF7@F� F:7@ & ;E�;@�F:7�E7FEB3@@76�4K�F:7�5A>G?@E�A8 A

5 �@K�>;@73D�5A?4;@3F;A@�A8�H75FADE�53@�3>I3KE�47�ID;FF7@;@�F:7�8AD? A; 8AD�3�EG;F34>7�?3FD;J A 3@6�H75FAD ;

6 "8�F:7�5A78S5;7@F�?3FD;J A :3E�3�B;HAF�BAE;F;A@�;@�7H7DKDAI� F:7@�F:7�7CG3F;A@ A; D & ;E�;@5A@E;EF7@F

7 ,:7�EA>GF;A@�E7F �A8 �3 � >;@73D �EKEF7?�I:AE7�3G9?7@F76?3FD;J�;E Œ %1 %2 %3 & ! ;E�F:7�E3?7�3E�F:7�EA>GF;A@�E7FA8 A; D &� ;8 A D Œ %1 %2 %3 !

8 "8 A ;E�3@ m # n ?3FD;J�I:AE7�5A>G?@E�6A�@AF�EB3@ Rm�F:7@�F:7�7CG3F;A@A; D & ;E�5A@E;EF7@F�8AD�7H7DK & ;@Rm

�� 'AF7 � F:3F

24

4 "3 15 "2 5

"6 2 "3

35

24

"3"1

2

35 D

24

"7"310

35 -E7 � F:;E

835F��3@6�@A�DAI�AB7D3F;A@E��FA�S@6�E53>3DE c1� c2� c3 EG5:

F:3F

24

"7"310

35 D c1

24

45

"6

35 C c2

24

"3"2

2

35 C c3

24

15

"3

35

� %7F 8 D

24

725

35� 9 D

24

313

35� 3@6 : D

24

511

35 "F � 53@ � 47

E:AI@�F:3F 28 " 39 " : D � -E7�F:;E �835F ��3@6�@A�DAIAB7D3F;A@E� � FA � S@6 x1 3@6 x2 F:3F � E3F;E8K � F:7 � 7CG3F;A@24

7 32 15 3

35

#x1

x2

$D

24

511

35

�� *7ID;F7�F:7��@G?7D;53>��?3FD;J�7CG3F;A@�47>AI�;@�EK?4A>;58AD?�3E�3�H75FAD�7CG3F;A@� GE;@9�EK?4A>E 91; 92; : : : 8AD�F:7H75FADE�3@6 c1; c2; : : : 8AD�E53>3DE �7S@7�I:3F�735:�EK?4A>D7BD7E7@FE� GE;@9�F:7�63F3�9;H7@�;@�F:7�?3FD;J�7CG3F;A@

#"3 5 "4 9 7

5 8 1 "2 "4

$266664

"312

"12

377775

D#

11"11

$

�� %7F 41� 42� 43� 3@6 9 D7BD7E7@F�H75FADE�;@ R5� 3@6�>7F x1� x2�3@6 x3 67@AF7�E53>3DE /D;F7�F:7�8A>>AI;@9�H75FAD�7CG3F;A@�3E3�?3FD;J�7CG3F;A@ "67@F;8K�3@K�EK?4A>E�KAG�5:AAE7�FA�GE7x141 C x242 C x343 D 9

�� �A@EFDG5F � 3 3 # 3 ?3FD;J� @AF � ;@ � 75:7>A@ � 8AD?� I:AE75A>G?@E�EB3@ R3 +:AI�F:3F�F:7�?3FD;J�KAG�5A@EFDG5F�:3EF:7�67E;D76�BDAB7DFK

�� �A@EFDG5F � 3 3 # 3 ?3FD;J� @AF � ;@ � 75:7>A@ � 8AD?� I:AE75A>G?@E�6A %&+ EB3@ R3 +:AI�F:3F�F:7�?3FD;J�KAG�5A@EFDG5F:3E�F:7�67E;D76�BDAB7DFK

�� %7F A 47�3 3 # 2 ?3FD;J �JB>3;@�I:K�F:7�7CG3F;A@ A; D &53@@AF�47�5A@E;EF7@F�8AD�3>> & ;@ R3 7@7D3>;L7�KAGD�3D9G?7@F�FA�F:7�53E7�A8�3@�3D4;FD3DK A I;F:�?AD7�DAIE�F:3@5A>G?@E

Page 41: $)15&3 & * )- ,'&+ & & * $ * - University of Utah

�"&��*�)-�,"'&+�"&��"&��*��$ ��*�

� �AG>6�3�E7F�A8�F:D77�H75FADE�;@ R4 EB3@�3>>�A8 R4� �JB>3;@/:3F�34AGF n H75FADE�;@ Rm I:7@ n ;E�>7EE�F:3@ m�

� +GBBAE7 A ;E�3 4 # 3 ?3FD;J�3@6 & ;E�3�H75FAD�;@ R4 I;F:F:7�BDAB7DFK�F:3F A; D & :3E�3�G@;CG7�EA>GF;A@ /:3F�53@KAG�E3K�34AGF�F:7�D76G576�75:7>A@�8AD?�A8 A� #GEF;8K�KAGD3@EI7D

�� %7F A 47�3 3 # 4 ?3FD;J� >7F 91 3@6 92 47�H75FADE�;@ R3� 3@6>7F : D 91 C 92 +GBBAE7 91 D A81 3@6 92 D A82 8AD�EA?7H75FADE 81 3@6 82 ;@ R4 /:3F�835F�3>>AIE�KAG�FA�5A@5>G67F:3F�F:7�EKEF7? A; D : ;E�5A@E;EF7@F� ��&+�� 81 3@6 82

67@AF7�H75FADE� @AF�E53>3D�7@FD;7E�;@�H75FADE��� %7F A 47�3 5 # 3 ?3FD;J� >7F < 47�3�H75FAD�;@ R3� 3@6�>7F = 47

3�H75FAD�;@ R5 +GBBAE7 A< D = /:3F�835F�3>>AIE�KAG�FA5A@5>G67�F:3F�F:7�EKEF7? A; D 5= ;E�5A@E;EF7@F�

� +GBBAE7 A ;E�3 4 # 4 ?3FD;J�3@6 & ;E�3�H75FAD�;@ R4 I;F:�F:7BDAB7DFK�F:3FA; D & :3E�3�G@;CG7�EA>GF;A@ �JB>3;@�I:K�F:75A>G?@E�A8 A ?GEF�EB3@ R4

1�2 "@��J7D5;E7E���N��� 67F7D?;@7�;8�F:7�5A>G?@E�A8�F:7�?3FD;JEB3@ R4

��

2664

7 2 "5 8"5 "3 4 "9

6 10 "2 7"7 9 2 15

3775 ��

2664

4 "5 "1 83 "7 "4 25 "6 "1 49 1 10 7

3775

��

2664

10 "7 1 4 6"8 4 "6 "10 "3"7 11 "5 "1 "8

3 "1 10 12 12

3775

���

2664

5 11 "6 "7 12"7 "3 "4 6 "911 5 6 "9 "3"3 4 "7 2 7

3775

��� 1�2 �;@6�3�5A>G?@�A8�F:7�?3FD;J�;@��J7D5;E7����F:3F�53@�4767>7F76�3@6�K7F�:3H7�F:7�D7?3;@;@9�?3FD;J�5A>G?@E�EF;>>�EB3@R4

�� 1�2 �;@6�3�5A>G?@�A8�F:7�?3FD;J�;@��J7D5;E7����F:3F�53@�4767>7F76�3@6�K7F�:3H7�F:7�D7?3;@;@9�?3FD;J�5A>G?@E�EF;>>�EB3@R4 �3@�KAG�67>7F7�?AD7�F:3@�A@7�5A>G?@�

SG WEB

�� ,:7�?3FD;J�7CG3F;A@

24

1 5 "2 0"3 1 9 "5

4 "8 "1 7

35

2664

3"2

0"4

3775 D

24

"790

35

;E�7CG;H3>7@F�FA�F:7�H75FAD�7CG3F;A@

3

24

1"3

4

35 " 2

24

51

"8

35 C 0

24

"29

"1

35 " 4

24

0"5

7

35 D

24

"790

35

I:;5:�7JBD7EE7E & 3E�3�>;@73D�5A?4;@3F;A@�A8�F:7�5A>G?@E�A8 A

� 8C 9 D#

4"1

$C

#"3

5

$D

#14

$

A.8C 9/ D#

2 53 1

$#14

$D

#2 C 203 C 4

$D

#227

$

A8C A9 D#

2 53 1

$#4

"1

$C

#2 53 1

$#"3

5

$

D#

311

$C

#19"4

$D

#227

$

Page 42: $)15&3 & * )- ,'&+ & & * $ * - University of Utah

�'$-,"'&���,+�'���"&��*��1+,�%+

+A>GF;A@�E7FE�A8�>;@73D�EKEF7?E�3D7�;?BADF3@F�A4<75FE�A8�EFG6K�;@�>;@73D�3>974D3 ,:7KI;>>�3BB73D�>3F7D�;@�E7H7D3>�6;887D7@F�5A@F7JFE ,:;E�E75F;A@�GE7E�H75FAD�@AF3F;A@�FA�9;H77JB>;5;F�3@6�97A?7FD;5�67E5D;BF;A@E�A8�EG5:�EA>GF;A@�E7FE

�'%' �&�'-+��"&��*��1+,�%+� EKEF7?�A8�>;@73D�7CG3F;A@E�;E�E3;6�FA�47 ,202+)1)286 ;8�;F�53@�47�ID;FF7@�;@�F:78AD? A; D �� I:7D7 A ;E�3@ m # n ?3FD;J�3@6 � ;E�F:7�L7DA�H75FAD�;@ Rm +G5:�3EKEF7? A; D � �#.�0* :3E�3F�>73EF�A@7�EA>GF;A@� @3?7>K� ; D � �F:7�L7DA�H75FAD�;@ Rn/,:;E�L7DA�EA>GF;A@�;E�GEG3>>K�53>>76�F:7 75-9-%/�62/87-21 �AD�3�9;H7@�7CG3F;A@ A; D �;F:7�;?BADF3@F�CG7EF;A@�;E�I:7F:7D�F:7D7�7J;EFE�3 12175-9-%/�62/87-21� F:3F�;E� 3�@A@L7DAH75FAD ; F:3F�E3F;ES7E A; D �: ,:7��J;EF7@57�3@6�-@;CG7@7EE�,:7AD7?�;@�+75F;A@ ��,:7AD7? ���>736E�;??76;3F7>K�FA�F:7�8A>>AI;@9�835F

,:7�:A?A97@7AGE�7CG3F;A@ A; D � :3E�3�@A@FD;H;3>�EA>GF;A@�;8�3@6�A@>K�;8�F:77CG3F;A@�:3E�3F�>73EF�A@7�8D77�H3D;34>7

�7F7D?;@7�;8 � F:7�8A>>AI;@9�:A?A97@7AGE�EKEF7?�:3E�3�@A@FD;H;3>EA>GF;A@ ,:7@�67E5D;47�F:7�EA>GF;A@�E7F

3x1 C 5x2 " 4x3 D 0

"3x1 " 2x2 C 4x3 D 0

6x1 C x2 " 8x3 D 0

%7F A 47�F:7�?3FD;J�A8�5A78S5;7@FE�A8�F:7�EKEF7?�3@6�DAI�D76G57�F:73G9?7@F76�?3FD;J Œ A � ! FA�75:7>A@�8AD?�

24

3 5 "4 0"3 "2 4 0

6 1 "8 0

35 %

24

3 5 "4 00 3 0 00 "9 0 0

35 %

24

3 5 "4 00 3 0 00 0 0 0

35

+;@57 x3 ;E�3�8D77�H3D;34>7� A; D � :3E�@A@FD;H;3>�EA>GF;A@E��A@7�8AD�735:�5:A;57�A8 x3�,A�67E5D;47�F:7�EA>GF;A@�E7F� 5A@F;@G7�F:7�DAI�D76G5F;A@�A8 Œ A � ! FA )��,��� 75:7>A@8AD?� 2

41 0 " 4

30

0 1 0 00 0 0 0

35

x1 " 43x3 D 0

x2 D 0

0 D 0

+A>H7�8AD�F:7�43E;5�H3D;34>7E x1 3@6 x2 3@6�A4F3;@ x1 D 43x3� x2 D 0� I;F: x3 8D77 �E�3

H75FAD� F:7�97@7D3>�EA>GF;A@�A8 A; D � :3E�F:7�8AD?

; D

264

x1

x2

x3

375 D

264

43x3

0

x3

375 D x3

264

43

0

1

375 D x39; I:7D7 9 D

264

43

0

1

375

!7D7 x3 ;E�835FAD76�AGF�A8�F:7�7JBD7EE;A@�8AD�F:7�97@7D3>�EA>GF;A@�H75FAD ,:;E�E:AIE�F:3F7H7DK�EA>GF;A@�A8 A; D � ;@�F:;E�53E7�;E�3�E53>3D�?G>F;B>7�A8 9 ,:7�FD;H;3>�EA>GF;A@�;EA4F3;@76�4K�5:AAE;@9 x3 D 0: 7A?7FD;53>>K� F:7�EA>GF;A@�E7F�;E�3�>;@7�F:DAG9: � ;@ R3+77��;9

Span{v}

0

x3

x1

x2

v

Page 43: $)15&3 & * )- ,'&+ & & * $ * - University of Utah

�"&��*�)-�,"'&+�"&��"&��*��$ ��*�

'AF;57�F:3F�3�@A@FD;H;3>�EA>GF;A@ ; 53@�:3H7�EA?7�L7DA�7@FD;7E�EA�>A@9�3E�@AF�3>>�A8;FE�7@FD;7E�3D7�L7DA

� E;@9>7�>;@73D�7CG3F;A@�53@�47�FD73F76�3E�3�H7DK�E;?B>7�EKEF7?�A87CG3F;A@E �7E5D;47�3>>�EA>GF;A@E�A8�F:7�:A?A97@7AGE�PEKEF7?Q

10x1 " 3x2 " 2x3 D 0 � �

,:7D7�;E�@A�@776�8AD�?3FD;J�@AF3F;A@ +A>H7�8AD�F:7�43E;5�H3D;34>7 x1 ;@F7D?E�A8�F:7�8D77�H3D;34>7E ,:7�97@7D3>�EA>GF;A@�;E x1 D :3x2 C :2x3� I;F: x2 3@6 x3

8D77 �E�3�H75FAD� F:7�97@7D3>�EA>GF;A@�;E

; D

24

x1

x2

x3

35 D

24

:3x2 C :2x3

x2

x3

35 D

24

:3x2

x2

0

35 C

24

:2x3

0x3

35

D x2

24

:310

35

✻8

C x3

24

:201

35

✻9

�I;F: x2� x3 8D77� ���

,:;E�53>5G>3F;A@�E:AIE�F:3F�7H7DK�EA>GF;A@�A8�� ��;E�3�>;@73D�5A?4;@3F;A@�A8�F:7�H75FADE8 3@6 9� E:AI@�;@���� ,:3F�;E� F:7�EA>GF;A@�E7F�;E +B3@ f8; 9g +;@57�@7;F:7D 8 @AD 9 ;E�3E53>3D�?G>F;B>7�A8�F:7�AF:7D� F:7�EA>GF;A@�E7F�;E�3�B>3@7�F:DAG9:�F:7�AD;9;@ +77��;9 �

u

x3

x1

x2

v

�J3?B>7E � �3@6 ��� 3>A@9 �I;F: � F:7 �7J7D5;E7E� ;>>GEFD3F7 � F:7 � 835F � F:3F � F:7 � EA>GF;A@�E7F�A8�3�:A?A97@7AGE�7CG3F;A@ A; D � 53@�3>I3KE�47�7JBD7EE76�7JB>;5;F>K�3E+B3@ f91; : : : ; 9pg 8AD�EG;F34>7�H75FADE 91; : : : ; 9p "8�F:7�A@>K�EA>GF;A@�;E�F:7�L7DA�H75FAD�F:7@�F:7�EA>GF;A@�E7F�;E +B3@ f�g "8�F:7�7CG3F;A@ A; D � :3E�A@>K�A@7�8D77�H3D;34>7�F:7�EA>GF;A@�E7F�;E�3�>;@7�F:DAG9:�F:7�AD;9;@� 3E�;@��;9 � B>3@7�F:DAG9:�F:7�AD;9;@�3E�;@��;9 �� BDAH;67E�3�9AA6�?7@F3>�;?397�8AD�F:7�EA>GF;A@�E7F�A8 A; D � I:7@�F:7D73D7�FIA�AD�?AD7�8D77�H3D;34>7E 'AF7� :AI7H7D� F:3F�3�E;?;>3D�S9GD7�53@�47�GE76�FAH;EG3>;L7 +B3@ f8; 9g 7H7@�I:7@ 8 3@6 9 6A�@AF�3D;E7�3E�EA>GF;A@E�A8A; D �: +77��;9 ;@�+75F;A@ �

��*�%�,*"�����,'*�'*%,:7�AD;9;@3>�7CG3F;A@�� ��8AD�F:7�B>3@7�;@��J3?B>7���;E�3@ $'# � + 67E5D;BF;A@�A8�F:7B>3@7 +A>H;@9�F:;E�7CG3F;A@�3?AG@FE�FA�S@6;@9�3@ �/'# � + 67E5D;BF;A@�A8�F:7�B>3@7�3EF:7�E7F�EB3@@76�4K 8 3@6 9 �CG3F;A@�����;E�53>>76�3 3%5%0)75-'�9)'725�)48%7-21 A8�F:7B>3@7 +A?7F;?7E�EG5:�3@�7CG3F;A@�;E�ID;FF7@�3E

; D s8C t9 .s; t ;@ R/

FA�7?B:3E;L7�F:3F�F:7�B3D3?7F7DE�H3DK�AH7D�3>>�D73>�@G?47DE "@��J3?B>7� � F:7�7CG3F;A@; D x39 �I;F: x3 8D77�� AD ; D t9 �I;F: t ;@R�� ;E�3�B3D3?7FD;5�H75FAD�7CG3F;A@�A8�3�>;@7/:7@7H7D�3�EA>GF;A@�E7F�;E�67E5D;476�7JB>;5;F>K�I;F:�H75FADE�3E�;@��J3?B>7E� �3@6��� I7E3K�F:3F�F:7�EA>GF;A@�;E�;@ 3%5%0)75-'�9)'725�*250

�'$-,"'&+�'���'&!'%' �&�'-+��1+,�%+/:7@�3�@A@:A?A97@7AGE�>;@73D�EKEF7?�:3E�?3@K�EA>GF;A@E� F:7�97@7D3>�EA>GF;A@�53@�47ID;FF7@�;@�B3D3?7FD;5�H75FAD�8AD?�3E�A@7�H75FAD�B>GE�3@�3D4;FD3DK�>;@73D�5A?4;@3F;A@�A8H75FADE�F:3F�E3F;E8K�F:7�5ADD7EBA@6;@9�:A?A97@7AGE�EKEF7?

Page 44: $)15&3 & * )- ,'&+ & & * $ * - University of Utah

�'$-,"'&���,+�'���"&��*��1+,�%+

�7E5D;47�3>>�EA>GF;A@E�A8 A; D &� I:7D7

A D

24

3 5 "4"3 "2 4

6 1 "8

35 3@6 & D

24

7"1"4

35

!7D7 A ;E�F:7�?3FD;J�A8�5A78S5;7@FE�8DA?��J3?B>7� *AI�AB7D3F;A@E�A@Œ A & ! BDA6G57

24

3 5 "4 7"3 "2 4 "1

6 1 "8 "4

35 %

24

1 0 " 43

"10 1 0 20 0 0 0

35;

x1 " 43x3 D "1

x2 D 20 D 0

,:GE x1 D "1 C 43x3� x2 D 2� 3@6 x3 ;E�8D77 �E�3�H75FAD� F:7�97@7D3>�EA>GF;A@�A8

A; D & :3E�F:7�8AD?

; D

264

x1

x2

x3

375 D

264

"1 C 43x3

2

x3

375 D

264

"1

2

0

375 C

264

43x3

0

x3

375 D

264

"1

2

0

375

✻3

C x3

264

43

0

1

375

✻9

,:7�7CG3F;A@ ; D 3C x39� AD� ID;F;@9 t 3E�3�97@7D3>�B3D3?7F7D�; D 3C t9 �t ;@ R� ���

67E5D;47E�F:7�EA>GF;A@�E7F�A8 A; D & ;@�B3D3?7FD;5�H75FAD�8AD? *753>>�8DA?��J3?B>7� F:3F�F:7�EA>GF;A@�E7F�A8 A; D � :3E�F:7�B3D3?7FD;5�H75FAD�7CG3F;A@

; D t9 �t ;@ R� ���1I;F:�F:7�E3?7 9 F:3F�3BB73DE�;@����2 ,:GE�F:7�EA>GF;A@E�A8 A; D & 3D7�A4F3;@76�4K366;@9�F:7�H75FAD 3 FA�F:7�EA>GF;A@E�A8 A; D � ,:7�H75FAD 3 ;FE7>8�;E�<GEF�A@7�B3DF;5G>3DEA>GF;A@�A8 A; D & 15ADD7EBA@6;@9�FA t D 0 ;@����2

p

v

v + p

�66;@9 3 FA 9 FD3@E>3F7E 9 FA 9C 3

,A�67E5D;47� F:7�EA>GF;A@�E7F �A8 A; D & 97A?7FD;53>>K� I7�53@� F:;@=�A8 �H75FAD366;F;A@�3E�3 +)�%*#�+ &% ;H7@ 9 3@6 3 ;@ R2 AD R3� F:7�78875F�A8�366;@9 3 FA 9 ;EFA $&-� 9 ;@�3�6;D75F;A@�B3D3>>7>�FA�F:7�>;@7�F:DAG9: 3 3@6 � /7�E3K�F:3F 9 ;E 75%16/%7)(L + p

L

,D3@E>3F76�>;@7

&< 3 FA 9C 3 +77��;9 � "8�735:�BA;@F�A@�3�>;@7 L ;@ R2 AD R3 ;E�FD3@E>3F76�4K�3�H75FAD3� F:7�D7EG>F�;E�3�>;@7�B3D3>>7>�FA L +77��;9 �

+GBBAE7 L ;E�F:7�>;@7�F:DAG9: � 3@6 9� 67E5D;476�4K�7CG3F;A@���� �66;@9 3 FA�735:BA;@F�A@ L BDA6G57E�F:7�FD3@E>3F76�>;@7�67E5D;476�4K�7CG3F;A@���� 'AF7�F:3F 3 ;E�A@�F:7>;@7�;@�7CG3F;A@���� /7�53>>���� 7,)�)48%7-21�2*�7,)�/-1)�7,528+, 3 3%5%//)/�72�9 ,:GE+���*&#,+ &%�*�+�&� A; D & *���# %��+�)&,�� 3 '�)�##�#�+&�+���*&#,+ &%�*�+�&� A; D ��;9GD7���;>>GEFD3F7E�F:;E�53E7

p

v tv

p + tvAx = b

Ax = 0

)3D3>>7>�EA>GF;A@�E7FE�A8 A; D & 3@6A; D �

,:7�D7>3F;A@�47FI77@�F:7�EA>GF;A@�E7FE�A8 A; D & 3@6 A; D � E:AI@�;@��;9 �97@7D3>;L7E�FA�3@K �&%* *+�%+ 7CG3F;A@ A; D &� 3>F:AG9:�F:7�EA>GF;A@�E7F�I;>>�47�>3D97DF:3@�3�>;@7�I:7@�F:7D7�3D7�E7H7D3>�8D77�H3D;34>7E ,:7�8A>>AI;@9�F:7AD7?�9;H7E�F:7�BD75;E7EF3F7?7@F +77��J7D5;E7����8AD�3�BDAA8

Page 45: $)15&3 & * )- ,'&+ & & * $ * - University of Utah

�"&��*�)-�,"'&+�"&��"&��*��$ ��*�

+GBBAE7�F:7�7CG3F;A@ A; D & ;E�5A@E;EF7@F�8AD�EA?7�9;H7@ &� 3@6�>7F 3 47�3EA>GF;A@ ,:7@�F:7�EA>GF;A@�E7F�A8 A; D & ;E�F:7�E7F�A8�3>>�H75FADE�A8�F:7�8AD?: D 3C 9h� I:7D7 9h ;E�3@K�EA>GF;A@�A8�F:7�:A?A97@7AGE�7CG3F;A@ A; D �

,:7AD7?���E3KE�F:3F�;8 A; D & :3E�3�EA>GF;A@� F:7@�F:7�EA>GF;A@�E7F�;E�A4F3;@76�4KFD3@E>3F;@9�F:7�EA>GF;A@�E7F�A8 A; D �� GE;@9�3@K�B3DF;5G>3D�EA>GF;A@ 3 A8 A; D & 8ADF:7�FD3@E>3F;A@ �;9GD7���;>>GEFD3F7E�F:7�53E7�;@�I:;5:�F:7D7�3D7�FIA�8D77�H3D;34>7E �H7@I:7@ n > 3� AGD�?7@F3>�;?397�A8�F:7�EA>GF;A@�E7F�A8�3�5A@E;EF7@F�EKEF7? A; D & �I;F:& ¤ ���;E�7;F:7D�3�E;@9>7�@A@L7DA�BA;@F�AD�3�>;@7�AD�B>3@7�@AF�B3EE;@9�F:DAG9:�F:7�AD;9;@

Ax = b

Ax = 0p

)3D3>>7>�EA>GF;A@�E7FE�A8A; D & 3@6 A; D �

������ ,:7AD7?���3@6��;9 ��3BB>K�A@>K�FA�3@�7CG3F;A@ A; D & F:3F�:3E�3F�>73EFA@7�@A@L7DA�EA>GF;A@ 3 /:7@ A; D & :3E�@A�EA>GF;A@� F:7�EA>GF;A@�E7F�;E�7?BFK

,:7�8A>>AI;@9�3>9AD;F:?�AGF>;@7E�F:7�53>5G>3F;A@E�E:AI@�;@��J3?B>7E� � �� 3@6��

�� *AI�D76G57�F:7�3G9?7@F76�?3FD;J�FA�D76G576�75:7>A@�8AD?� �JBD7EE�735:�43E;5�H3D;34>7�;@�F7D?E�A8�3@K�8D77�H3D;34>7E�3BB73D;@9�;@�3@7CG3F;A@

� /D;F7 �3 � FKB;53> � EA>GF;A@ ; 3E �3 �H75FAD �I:AE7 �7@FD;7E �67B7@6�A@� F:7 � 8D77H3D;34>7E� ;8�3@K

�� �75A?BAE7 ; ;@FA�3�>;@73D�5A?4;@3F;A@�A8�H75FADE��I;F:�@G?7D;5�7@FD;7E��GE;@9F:7�8D77�H3D;34>7E�3E�B3D3?7F7DE

�� �35:�A8�F:7�8A>>AI;@9�7CG3F;A@E�67F7D?;@7E�3�B>3@7�;@ R3 �A�F:7�FIA�B>3@7E;@F7DE75F� "8�EA� 67E5D;47�F:7;D�;@F7DE75F;A@

x1 C 4x2 " 5x3 D 0

2x1 " x2 C 8x3 D 9

� /D;F7�F:7�97@7D3>�EA>GF;A@�A8 10x1 " 3x2 " 2x3 D 7 ;@�B3D3?7FD;5�H75FAD�8AD?� 3@6D7>3F7�F:7�EA>GF;A@�E7F�FA�F:7�A@7�8AG@6�;@��J3?B>7��

Page 46: $)15&3 & * )- ,'&+ & & * $ * - University of Utah

�'$-,"'&���,+�'���"&��*��1+,�%+

"@��J7D5;E7E� N�� 67F7D?;@7�;8�F:7�EKEF7?�:3E�3�@A@FD;H;3>�EA>GF;A@,DK�FA�GE7�3E�87I�DAI�AB7D3F;A@E�3E�BAEE;4>7

�� 2x1 " 5x2 C 8x3 D 0

"2x1 " 7x2 C x3 D 0

4x1 C 2x2 C 7x3 D 0

� x1 " 2x2 C 3x3 D 0

"2x1 " 3x2 " 4x3 D 0

2x1 " 4x2 C 9x3 D 0

� "3x1 C 4x2 " 8x3 D 0

"2x1 C 5x2 C 4x3 D 0

�� 5x1 " 3x2 C 2x3 D 0

"3x1 " 4x2 C 2x3 D 0

"@��J7D5;E7E���3@6��� 8A>>AI�F:7�?7F:A6�A8��J3?B>7E� �3@6��FA�ID;F7�F:7�EA>GF;A@�E7F�A8� F:7�9;H7@�:A?A97@7AGE�EKEF7?�;@B3D3?7FD;5�H75FAD�8AD?

�� 2x1 C 2x2 C 4x3 D 0

"4x1 " 4x2 " 8x3 D 0

" 3x2 " 3x3 D 0

� x1 C 2x2 " 3x3 D 0

2x1 C x2 " 3x3 D 0

"1x1 C x2 D 0

"@��J7D5;E7E��N �� 67E5D;47�3>>�EA>GF;A@E�A8 A; D � ;@�B3D3?7FD;5H75FAD�8AD?� I:7D7 A ;E�DAI�7CG;H3>7@F�FA�F:7�9;H7@�?3FD;J

��#

1 3 "3 70 1 "4 5

$��

#1 "3 "8 50 1 2 "4

$

��#

3 "6 6"2 4 "2

$���

#"1 "4 0 "4

2 "8 0 8

$

���

2664

1 "4 "2 0 3 "50 0 1 0 0 "10 0 0 0 1 "40 0 0 0 0 0

3775

��

2664

1 "2 3 "6 5 00 0 0 1 4 "60 0 0 0 0 10 0 0 0 0 0

3775

�� +GBBAE7�F:7�EA>GF;A@�E7F�A8�3�57DF3;@�EKEF7?�A8�>;@73D�7CG3F;A@E�53@�47�67E5D;476�3E x1 D 5 C 4x3� x2 D "2 " 7x3� I;F:x3 8D77 -E7�H75FADE�FA�67E5D;47�F:;E�E7F�3E�3�>;@7�;@ R3

��� +GBBAE7 � F:7 � EA>GF;A@ � E7F � A8 � 3 � 57DF3;@ � EKEF7? � A8 � >;@73D7CG3F;A@E � 53@ � 47 � 67E5D;476 � 3E x1 D 5x4� x2 D 3 " 2x4�x3 D 2 C 5x4� I;F: x4 8D77 -E7�H75FADE�FA�67E5D;47�F:;E�E7F3E�3�P>;@7Q�;@ R4

��� �7E5D;47 � 3@6 � 5A?B3D7 � F:7 � EA>GF;A@ � E7FE � A8 x1 C 5x2 "3x3 D 0 3@6 x1 C 5x2 " 3x3 D "2

� � �7E5D;47 � 3@6 � 5A?B3D7 � F:7 � EA>GF;A@ � E7FE � A8 x1 " 2x2 C3x3 D 0 3@6 x1 " 2x2 C 3x3 D 4

��� �A>>AI�F:7�?7F:A6�A8��J3?B>7���FA�67E5D;47�F:7�EA>GF;A@E�A8F:7�8A>>AI;@9�EKEF7?�;@�B3D3?7FD;5�H75FAD�8AD? �>EA� 9;H73�97A?7FD;5�67E5D;BF;A@�A8�F:7�EA>GF;A@�E7F�3@6�5A?B3D7�;F�FAF:3F�;@��J7D5;E7��

2x1 C 2x2 C 4x3 D 8

"4x1 " 4x2 " 8x3 D "16

" 3x2 " 3x3 D 12

��� �E�;@��J7D5;E7� �� 67E5D;47�F:7�EA>GF;A@E�A8�F:7�8A>>AI;@9EKEF7?�;@�B3D3?7FD;5�H75FAD�8AD?� 3@6�BDAH;67�3�97A?7FD;55A?B3D;EA@�I;F:�F:7�EA>GF;A@�E7F�;@��J7D5;E7��

x1 C 2x2 " 3x3 D 5

2x1 C x2 " 3x3 D 13

"x1 C x2 D "8

"@��J7D5;E7E� ��3@6���� S@6�F:7�B3D3?7FD;5�7CG3F;A@�A8�F:7�>;@7F:DAG9: % B3D3>>7>�FA &

��� % D#

"20

$� & D

#"5

3

$�� % D

#3

"2

$� & D

#"7

6

$

"@��J7D5;E7E�� �3@6���� S@6�3�B3D3?7FD;5�7CG3F;A@�A8�F:7�>;@7 MF:DAG9: 3 3@6 4 1� %+� M ;E�B3D3>>7>�FA�F:7�H75FAD 4 " 3 +77�F:7S9GD7�47>AI2

�� 3 D#

3"3

$� 4 D

#41

$� 3 D

#"3

2

$� 4 D

#0

"3

$

0

q – p

q

p

–p

x2

M

x1

"@��J7D5;E7E����3@6���� ?3D=�735:�EF3F7?7@F�,DG7�AD��3>E7 #GEF;8K735:�3@EI7D

� 3 � :A?A97@7AGE�7CG3F;A@�;E�3>I3KE�5A@E;EF7@F4 ,:7�7CG3F;A@ A; D � 9;H7E�3@�7JB>;5;F�67E5D;BF;A@�A8�;FEEA>GF;A@�E7F

5 ,:7�:A?A97@7AGE�7CG3F;A@ A; D � :3E�F:7�FD;H;3>�EA>GF;A@�;8�3@6�A@>K�;8�F:7�7CG3F;A@�:3E�3F�>73EF�A@7�8D77H3D;34>7

6 ,:7�7CG3F;A@ ; D 3C t9 67E5D;47E�3�>;@7�F:DAG9: 9 B3D3>>7>�FA 3

7 ,:7�EA>GF;A@�E7F�A8 A; D & ;E�F:7�E7F�A8�3>>�H75FADE�A8F:7�8AD? : D 3C 9h� I:7D7 9h ;E�3@K�EA>GF;A@�A8�F:77CG3F;A@ A; D �

�� 3 � :A?A97@7AGE�EKEF7?�A8�7CG3F;A@E�53@�47�;@5A@E;EF7@F4 "8 ; ;E�3�@A@FD;H;3>�EA>GF;A@�A8A; D �� F:7@�7H7DK�7@FDK�;@

; ;E�@A@L7DA5 ,:7�78875F�A8�366;@9 3 FA�3�H75FAD�;E�FA�?AH7�F:7�H75FAD�;@3�6;D75F;A@�B3D3>>7>�FA 3

6 ,:7�7CG3F;A@ A; D & ;E�:A?A97@7AGE�;8�F:7�L7DA�H75FAD;E�3�EA>GF;A@

Page 47: $)15&3 & * )- ,'&+ & & * $ * - University of Utah

�"&��*�)-�,"'&+�"&��"&��*��$ ��*�

7 "8 A; D & ;E�5A@E;EF7@F� F:7@�F:7�EA>GF;A@�E7F�A8 A; D &;E�A4F3;@76�4K�FD3@E>3F;@9�F:7�EA>GF;A@�E7F�A8 A; D �

�� )DAH7�,:7AD7?���3 +GBBAE7 3 ;E�3�EA>GF;A@�A8 A; D &� EA�F:3F A3 D & %7F

9h 47�3@K�EA>GF;A@�A8�F:7�:A?A97@7AGE�7CG3F;A@ A; D ��3@6�>7F: D 3C 9h +:AI�F:3F: ;E�3�EA>GF;A@�A8A; D &

4 %7F: 47�3@K�EA>GF;A@�A8A; D &� 3@6�67S@7 9h D : " 3+:AI�F:3F 9h ;E�3�EA>GF;A@�A8 A; D � ,:;E�E:AIE�F:3F7H7DK�EA>GF;A@�A8 A; D & :3E�F:7�8AD? : D 3C 9h� I;F:3 3�B3DF;5G>3D�EA>GF;A@�A8 A; D & 3@6 9h 3�EA>GF;A@�A8A; D �

� +GBBAE7 A ;E�F:7 3 # 3 1�)& ?3FD;J��I;F:�3>>�L7DA�7@FD;7E��7E5D;47�F:7�EA>GF;A@�E7F�A8�F:7�7CG3F;A@ A; D �

�� +GBBAE7 A; D & :3E�3�EA>GF;A@ �JB>3;@�I:K�F:7�EA>GF;A@�;EG@;CG7�BD75;E7>K�I:7@ A; D � :3E�A@>K�F:7�FD;H;3>�EA>GF;A@

"@��J7D5;E7E���N� � �3��6A7E�F:7�7CG3F;A@ A; D � :3H7�3�@A@FD;H;3>�EA>GF;A@�3@6��4��6A7E�F:7�7CG3F;A@ A; D & :3H7�3F�>73EF�A@7EA>GF;A@�8AD�7H7DK�BAEE;4>7 &�

�� A ;E�3 3 # 3 ?3FD;J�I;F:�F:D77�B;HAF�BAE;F;A@E�� A ;E�3 4 # 4 ?3FD;J�I;F:�F:D77�B;HAF�BAE;F;A@E�� A ;E�3 2 # 5 ?3FD;J�I;F:�FIA�B;HAF�BAE;F;A@E�� A ;E�3 3 # 2 ?3FD;J�I;F:�FIA�B;HAF�BAE;F;A@E� "8 & ¤ �� 53@�F:7�EA>GF;A@�E7F�A8 A; D & 47�3�B>3@7�F:DAG9:

F:7�AD;9;@� �JB>3;@

� �A@EFDG5F�3 3 # 3 @A@L7DA�?3FD;JA EG5:�F:3F�F:7�H75FAD

24

111

35

;E�3�EA>GF;A@�A8 A; D �

�� �A@EFDG5F �3 3 # 3 @A@L7DA�?3FD;J A EG5:� F:3F � F:7 �H75FAD24

2"1

1

35 ;E�3�EA>GF;A@�A8 A; D �

�� ;H7@ A D

24

"1 "37 21

"2 "6

35� S@6 � A@7 � @A@FD;H;3> � EA>GF;A@ � A8

A; D � 4K�;@EB75F;A@ 1� %+� ,:;@=�A8�F:7�7CG3F;A@ A; D �ID;FF7@�3E�3�H75FAD�7CG3F;A@2

� ;H7@ A D

24

3 "2"6 412 "8

35� S@6 � A@7 � @A@FD;H;3> � EA>GF;A@ � A8

A; D � 4K�;@EB75F;A@

�� �A@EFDG5F�3 2 # 2 ?3FD;J A EG5:�F:3F�F:7�EA>GF;A@�E7F�A8�F:77CG3F;A@ A; D � ;E � F:7�>;@7�;@ R2 F:DAG9: .4; 1/ 3@6�F:7AD;9;@ ,:7@� S@6�3�H75FAD & ;@ R2 EG5:�F:3F�F:7�EA>GF;A@E7F�A8 A; D & ;E %&+ 3�>;@7�;@ R2 B3D3>>7>�FA�F:7�EA>GF;A@�E7FA8 A; D � /:K�6A7E�F:;E %&+ 5A@FD36;5F�,:7AD7?���

�� %7F A 47�3@ m # n ?3FD;J�3@6�>7F : 47�3�H75FAD�;@ Rn F:3FE3F;ES7E�F:7�7CG3F;A@ A; D � +:AI�F:3F�8AD�3@K�E53>3D c�F:7�H75FAD c: 3>EA�E3F;ES7E A; D � 1,:3F� ;E� E:AI�F:3FA.c:/ D �2

�� %7F A 47�3@ m # n ?3FD;J� 3@6�>7F 9 3@6 : 47�H75FADE�;@Rn I;F:�F:7�BDAB7DFK�F:3F A9 D � 3@6 A: D � �JB>3;@I:K A.9C :/ ?GEF�47�F:7�L7DA�H75FAD ,:7@�7JB>3;@�I:KA.c9C d:/ D � 8AD�735:�B3;D�A8�E53>3DE c 3@6 d

��� +GBBAE7 A ;E�3 3 # 3 ?3FD;J�3@6 & ;E�3�H75FAD�;@ R3 EG5:�F:3FF:7�7CG3F;A@ A; D & 6A7E %&+ :3H7�3�EA>GF;A@ �A7E�F:7D77J;EF�3�H75FAD < ;@ R3 EG5:�F:3F�F:7�7CG3F;A@ A; D < :3E�3G@;CG7�EA>GF;A@� �;E5GEE

�� *AI�D76G57�F:7�3G9?7@F76�?3FD;J�#

1 4 "5 02 "1 8 9

$%

#1 4 "5 00 "9 18 9

$%

#1 0 3 40 1 "2 "1

$

x1 C 3x3 D 4

x2 " 2x3 D "1

,:GE x1 D 4 " 3x3; x2 D "1 C 2x3� I;F: x3 8D77 ,:7�97@7D3>�EA>GF;A@�;@�B3D3?7FD;5�H75FAD�8AD?�;E

24

x1

x2

x3

35 D

24

4 " 3x3

"1 C 2x3

x3

35 D

24

4"1

0

35

✻3

C x3

24

"321

35

✻9

,:7�;@F7DE75F;A@�A8�F:7�FIA�B>3@7E�;E�F:7�>;@7�F:DAG9: 3 ;@�F:7�6;D75F;A@�A8 9

Page 48: $)15&3 & * )- ,'&+ & & * $ * - University of Utah

�(($"��,"'&+�'���"&��*��1+,�%+

� ,:7�3G9?7@F76�?3FD;J%

10 "3 "2 7&;E�DAI�7CG;H3>7@F�FA

%1 ":3 ":2 :7

&�

3@6�F:7�97@7D3>�EA>GF;A@�;E x1 D :7 C :3x2 C :2x3� I;F: x2 3@6 x3 8D77 ,:3F�;E�

; D

24

x1

x2

x3

35 D

24

:7 C :3x2 C :2x3

x2

x3

35 D

24

:700

35 C x2

24

:310

35 C x3

24

:201

35

D 3 C x28 C x39

,:7�EA>GF;A@�E7F�A8�F:7�@A@:A?A97@7AGE�7CG3F;A@ A; D & ;E�F:7�FD3@E>3F76�B>3@73C +B3@ f8; 9g� I:;5:�B3EE7E�F:DAG9: 3 3@6�;E�B3D3>>7>�FA�F:7�EA>GF;A@�E7F�A8�F:7:A?A97@7AGE�7CG3F;A@�;@��J3?B>7��

0AG�?;9:F�7JB75F�F:3F�3�D73>>;87�BDA4>7?�;@HA>H;@9�>;@73D�3>974D3�IAG>6�:3H7�A@>K�A@7EA>GF;A@� AD�B7D:3BE�@A�EA>GF;A@ ,:7�BGDBAE7�A8�F:;E�E75F;A@�;E�FA�E:AI�:AI�>;@73DEKEF7?E�I;F:�?3@K�EA>GF;A@E�53@�3D;E7�@3FGD3>>K ,:7�3BB>;53F;A@E�:7D7�5A?7�8DA?75A@A?;5E� 5:7?;EFDK� 3@6�@7FIAD=�TAI

� �'%' �&�'-+��1+,�%�"&��'&'%"�+,:7�EKEF7?�A8�����7CG3F;A@E�;@�����H3D;34>7E� ?7@F;A@76�;@�F:;E�5:3BF7DRE�;@FDA6G5F;A@�WEB;E�@AI�=@AI@�3E�3�%7A@F;78�P;@BGFNAGFBGFQ��AD�PBDA6G5F;A@Q��?A67>U +75F;A@ ���I;>>7J3?;@7�F:;E�?A67>�;@�?AD7�67F3;>� I:7@�?AD7�F:7ADK�3@6�47FF7D�@AF3F;A@�3D7�3H3;>34>7�AD�@AI� I7�>AA=�3F�3�E;?B>7D�P7J5:3@97�?A67>�Q 3>EA�6G7�FA�%7A@F;78

+GBBAE7�3�@3F;A@RE�75A@A?K�;E�6;H;676�;@FA�?3@K�E75FADE� EG5:�3E�H3D;AGE�?3@G835FGD;@9� 5A??G@;53F;A@� 7@F7DF3;@?7@F� 3@6�E7DH;57�;@6GEFD;7E +GBBAE7�F:3F�8AD�735:E75FAD�I7�=@AI�;FE�FAF3>�AGFBGF�8AD�A@7�K73D�3@6�I7�=@AI�7J35F>K�:AI�F:;E�AGFBGF�;E6;H;676�AD�P7J5:3@976Q�3?A@9�F:7�AF:7D�E75FADE�A8�F:7�75A@A?K %7F�F:7�FAF3>�6A>>3DH3>G7�A8�3�E75FADRE�AGFBGF�47�53>>76�F:7 35-') A8�F:3F�AGFBGF %7A@F;78�BDAH76�F:78A>>AI;@9�D7EG>F

,:7D7�7J;EF �(, # �) ,$�') ��* F:3F�53@�47�3EE;9@76�FA�F:7�FAF3>�AGFBGFE�A8�F:7H3D;AGE�E75FADE�;@�EG5:�3�I3K�F:3F�F:7�;@5A?7�A8�735:�E75FAD�7J35F>K�43>3@57E�;FE7JB7@E7E

,:7�8A>>AI;@9�7J3?B>7�E:AIE�:AI�FA�S@6�F:7�7CG;>;4D;G?�BD;57E

+GBBAE7�3@�75A@A?K�5A@E;EFE�A8�F:7��A3>� �>75FD;5��BAI7D�� 3@6�+F77>E75FADE� 3@6�F:7�AGFBGF�A8�735:�E75FAD�;E�6;EFD;4GF76�3?A@9�F:7�H3D;AGE�E75FADE�3E�E:AI@;@�,34>7 �A@�B397���� I:7D7�F:7�7@FD;7E�;@�3�5A>G?@�D7BD7E7@F�F:7�8D35F;A@3>�B3DFE�A8�3E75FADRE�FAF3>�AGFBGF

,:7�E75A@6�5A>G?@�A8�,34>7� � 8AD�;@EF3@57� E3KE�F:3F�F:7�FAF3>�AGFBGF�A8�F:7��>75FD;5E75FAD�;E�6;H;676�3E�8A>>AIE� ����FA��A3>� ����FA�+F77>� 3@6�F:7�D7?3;@;@9� ���FA�>75FD;5 ��>75FD;5�FD73FE�F:;E� ���3E�3@�7JB7@E7�;F�;@5GDE�;@�AD67D�FA�AB7D3F7�;FE�4GE;@7EE�+;@57�3>>�AGFBGF�?GEF�47�F3=7@�;@FA�355AG@F� F:7�675;?3>�8D35F;A@E�;@�735:�5A>G?@�?GEFEG?�FA�

U+77�/3EE;>K�/�%7A@F;78� P"@BGFN(GFBGF��5A@A?;5E�Q �� �%+ 3���$�) ��%� (5FA47D� �� � BB �N�

Page 49: $)15&3 & * )- ,'&+ & & * $ * - University of Utah

�"&��*�)-�,"'&+�"&��"&��*��$ ��*�

�7@AF7� F:7�BD;57E��;7� 6A>>3D �H3>G7E� �A8 � F:7� FAF3> �3@@G3> �AGFBGFE �A8 � F:7��A3>��>75FD;5� 3@6�+F77>�E75FADE�4K p�� p�� 3@6 p+� D7EB75F;H7>K "8�BAEE;4>7� S@6�7CG;>;4D;G?BD;57E�F:3F�?3=7�735:�E75FADRE�;@5A?7�?3F5:�;FE�7JB7@6;FGD7E

.1

.2

.2 .5

Steel

.4

.4

.6

.6

Coal

Electric

�-675-&87-21�2*��87387�*520��2%/ �/)'75-' �7))/ �85',%6)(�&<�� � � �A3>� � �>75FD;5� � � +F77>

� E75FAD�>AA=E�6AI@�3�5A>G?@�FA�E77�I:7D7�;FE�AGFBGF�9A7E� 3@6�;F�>AA=E35DAEE�3�DAI�FA�E77�I:3F�;F�@776E�3E�;@BGFE �AD�;@EF3@57� F:7�SDEF�DAI�A8�,34>7� E3KE�F:3F��A3>�D757;H7E��3@6�B3KE�8AD������A8�F:7��>75FD;5�AGFBGF�3@6�����A8�F:7�+F77>AGFBGF +;@57�F:7�D7EB75F;H7�H3>G7E�A8�F:7�FAF3>�AGFBGFE�3D7 p� 3@6 p+� �A3>�?GEF�EB7@6:4p� 6A>>3DE�8AD�;FE�E:3D7�A8��>75FD;5RE�AGFBGF�3@6 :6p+ 8AD�;FE�E:3D7�A8�+F77>RE�AGFBGF,:GE��A3>RE�FAF3>�7JB7@E7E�3D7 :4p� C :6p+ ,A�?3=7��A3>RE�;@5A?7� p�� 7CG3>�FA�;FE7JB7@E7E� I7�I3@F

p� D :4p� C :6p+ � �

,:7�E75A@6�DAI�A8�F:7�7J5:3@97�F34>7�E:AIE�F:3F�F:7��>75FD;5�E75FAD�EB7@6E :6p�8AD�5A3>� :1p� 8AD�7>75FD;5;FK� 3@6 :2p+ 8AD�EF77> !7@57�F:7�;@5A?7�7JB7@E7�D7CG;D7?7@F8AD��>75FD;5�;E

p� D :6p� C :1p� C :2p+ ���

�;@3>>K� F:7�F:;D6�DAI�A8�F:7�7J5:3@97�F34>7�>736E�FA�F:7�S@3>�D7CG;D7?7@F�

p+ D :4p� C :5p� C :2p+ ���

,A�EA>H7�F:7�EKEF7?�A8�7CG3F;A@E�� �� ���� 3@6����� ?AH7�3>>�F:7�G@=@AI@E�FA�F:7�>78FE;67E�A8�F:7�7CG3F;A@E�3@6�5A?4;@7�>;=7�F7D?E 1�AD�;@EF3@57� A@�F:7�>78F�E;67�A8�����ID;F7 p� " :1p� 3E :9p�2

p� " :4p� " :6p+ D 0

":6p� C :9p� " :2p+ D 0

":4p� " :5p� C :8p+ D 0

*AI�D76G5F;A@�;E�@7JF �AD�E;?B>;5;FK�:7D7� 675;?3>E�3D7�DAG@676�FA�FIA�B>357E24

1 ":4 ":6 0":6 :9 ":2 0":4 ":5 :8 0

35 %

24

1 ":4 ":6 00 :66 ":56 00 ":66 :56 0

35 %

24

1 ":4 ":6 00 :66 ":56 00 0 0 0

35

%

24

1 ":4 ":6 00 1 ":85 00 0 0 0

35 %

24

1 0 ":94 00 1 ":85 00 0 0 0

35

Page 50: $)15&3 & * )- ,'&+ & & * $ * - University of Utah

�(($"��,"'&+�'���"&��*��1+,�%+

,:7�97@7D3>�EA>GF;A@�;E p� D :94p+� p� D :85p+� 3@6 p+ ;E�8D77 ,:7�7CG;>;4D;G?�BD;57H75FAD�8AD�F:7�75A@A?K�:3E�F:7�8AD?

3 D

24

p�p�p+

35 D

24

:94p+:85p+

p+

35 D p+

24

:94:851

35

�@K��@A@@793F;H7��5:A;57�8AD p+ D7EG>FE�;@�3�5:A;57�A8�7CG;>;4D;G?�BD;57E �AD�;@EF3@57�;8�I7�F3=7 p+ FA�47� ����AD�� ���?;>>;A@�� F:7@ p� D 94 3@6 p� D 85 ,:7�;@5A?7E�3@67JB7@6;FGD7E�A8�735:�E75FAD�I;>>�47�7CG3>�;8�F:7�AGFBGF�A8��A3>�;E�BD;576�3F�����?;>>;A@�F:3F�A8��>75FD;5�3F�����?;>>;A@� 3@6�F:3F�A8�+F77>�3F�� ���?;>>;A@

��$�&�"& ��!�%"��$�)-�,"'&+�:7?;53> �7CG3F;A@E �67E5D;47 � F:7 �CG3@F;F;7E �A8 � EG4EF3@57E �5A@EG?76�3@6 �BDA6G5764K�5:7?;53>�D735F;A@E �AD�;@EF3@57� I:7@�BDAB3@7�93E�4GD@E� F:7�BDAB3@7���3!8�5A?4;@7E�I;F:�AJK97@��(2��FA�8AD?�53D4A@�6;AJ;67���(2��3@6�I3F7D��!2(���355AD6;@9FA�3@�7CG3F;A@�A8�F:7�8AD?

.x1/�3!8 C .x2/(2 ! .x3/�(2 C .x4/!2( ���

,A�P43>3@57Q�F:;E�7CG3F;A@� 3�5:7?;EF�?GEF�S@6�I:A>7�@G?47DE x1; : : : ; x4 EG5:�F:3F�F:7FAF3>�@G?47DE�A8�53D4A@������:K6DA97@��!���3@6�AJK97@��(� 3FA?E�A@�F:7�>78F�?3F5:�F:75ADD7EBA@6;@9�@G?47DE�A8�3FA?E�A@�F:7�D;9:F��4753GE7�3FA?E�3D7�@7;F:7D�67EFDAK76�@AD5D73F76�;@�F:7�D735F;A@�

� EKEF7?3F;5�?7F:A6�8AD�43>3@5;@9�5:7?;53>�7CG3F;A@E�;E�FA�E7F�GB�3�H75FAD�7CG3F;A@F:3F�67E5D;47E�F:7�@G?47DE�A8�3FA?E�A8�735:�FKB7�BD7E7@F�;@�3�D735F;A@ +;@57�7CG3F;A@����;@HA>H7E�F:D77�FKB7E�A8�3FA?E��53D4A@� :K6DA97@� 3@6�AJK97@�� 5A@EFDG5F�3�H75FAD�;@R3 8AD�735:�D735F3@F�3@6�BDA6G5F�;@�����F:3F�>;EFE�F:7�@G?47DE�A8�P3FA?E�B7D�?A>75G>7�Q3E�8A>>AIE�

�3!8W

24

380

35; (2W

24

002

35; �(2W

24

102

35; !2(W

24

021

35

✛ �3D4A@✛ !K6DA97@✛ (JK97@

,A�43>3@57�7CG3F;A@����� F:7�5A78S5;7@FE x1; : : : ; x4 ?GEF�E3F;E8K

x1

24

380

35 C x2

24

002

35 D x3

24

102

35 C x4

24

021

35

,A�EA>H7� ?AH7�3>>�F:7�F7D?E�FA�F:7�>78F��5:3@9;@9�F:7�E;9@E�;@�F:7�F:;D6�3@6�8AGDF:H75FADE��

x1

24

380

35 C x2

24

002

35 C x3

24

"10

"2

35 C x4

24

0"2"1

35 D

24

000

35

*AI�D76G5F;A@�A8�F:7�3G9?7@F76�?3FD;J�8AD�F:;E�7CG3F;A@�>736E�FA�F:7�97@7D3>�EA>GF;A@

x1 D 14x4; x2 D 5

4x4; x3 D 3

4x4; I;F: x4 8D77

+;@57�F:7�5A78S5;7@FE�;@�3�5:7?;53>�7CG3F;A@�?GEF�47�;@F797DE� F3=7 x4 D 4� ;@�I:;5:53E7 x1 D 1� x2 D 5� 3@6 x3 D 3 ,:7�43>3@576�7CG3F;A@�;E

�3!8 C 5(2 ! 3�(2 C 4!2(

,:7�7CG3F;A@�IAG>6�3>EA�47�43>3@576�;8� 8AD�7J3?B>7� 735:�5A78S5;7@F�I7D7�6AG4>76 �AD?AEF�BGDBAE7E� :AI7H7D� 5:7?;EFE�BD787D�FA�GE7�3�43>3@576�7CG3F;A@�I:AE7�5A78S5;7@FE3D7�F:7�E?3>>7EF�BAEE;4>7�I:A>7�@G?47DE

Page 51: $)15&3 & * )- ,'&+ & & * $ * - University of Utah

�"&��*�)-�,"'&+�"&��"&��*��$ ��*�

��,/'*#�$'/+KEF7?E�A8�>;@73D�7CG3F;A@E�3D;E7�@3FGD3>>K�I:7@�E5;7@F;EFE� 7@9;@77DE� AD�75A@A?;EFEWEBEFG6K�F:7�TAI�A8�EA?7�CG3@F;FK�F:DAG9:�3�@7FIAD= �AD�;@EF3@57� GD43@�B>3@@7DE�3@6FD38S5�7@9;@77DE�?A@;FAD�F:7�B3FF7D@�A8�FD38S5�TAI�;@�3�9D;6�A8�5;FK�EFD77FE �>75FD;53>7@9;@77DE�53>5G>3F7�5GDD7@F�TAI�F:DAG9:�7>75FD;53>�5;D5G;FE �@6�75A@A?;EFE�3@3>KL7F:7�6;EFD;4GF;A@�A8�BDA6G5FE�8DA?�?3@G835FGD7DE�FA�5A@EG?7DE�F:DAG9:�3�@7FIAD=�A8I:A>7E3>7DE � 3@6 � D7F3;>7DE �AD �?3@K �@7FIAD=E� F:7 � EKEF7?E �A8 � 7CG3F;A@E � ;@HA>H7:G@6D76E�AD�7H7@�F:AGE3@6E�A8�H3D;34>7E�3@6�7CG3F;A@E

� %�+.&)" 5A@E;EFE�A8�3�E7F�A8�BA;@FE�53>>76 !,%�+ &%*� AD %&��*� I;F:�>;@7E�AD�3D5E53>>76 �)�%���* 5A@@75F;@9�EA?7�AD�3>>�A8�F:7�<G@5F;A@E ,:7�6;D75F;A@�A8�TAI�;@�735:4D3@5:�;E�;@6;53F76� 3@6�F:7�TAI�3?AG@F��AD�D3F7��;E�7;F:7D�E:AI@�AD�;E�67@AF76�4K�3H3D;34>7

,:7�43E;5�3EEG?BF;A@�A8�@7FIAD=�TAI�;E�F:3F�F:7�FAF3>�TAI�;@FA�F:7�@7FIAD=�7CG3>EF:7�FAF3>�TAI�AGF�A8�F:7�@7FIAD=�3@6�F:3F�F:7�FAF3>�TAI�;@FA�3�<G@5F;A@�7CG3>E�F:7�FAF3>TAI�AGF�A8�F:7�<G@5F;A@ �AD�7J3?B>7� �;9 �E:AIE����G@;FE�TAI;@9�;@FA�3�<G@5F;A@F:DAG9:�A@7�4D3@5:� I;F: x1 3@6 x2 67@AF;@9�F:7�TAIE�AGF�A8�F:7�<G@5F;A@�F:DAG9:�AF:7D4D3@5:7E +;@57�F:7�TAI�;E�P5A@E7DH76Q�3F�735:�<G@5F;A@� I7�?GEF�:3H7 x1 C x2 D 30"@�3�E;?;>3D�83E:;A@� F:7�TAI�3F�735:�<G@5F;A@�;E�67E5D;476�4K�3�>;@73D�7CG3F;A@ ,:7BDA4>7?�A8�@7FIAD=�3@3>KE;E� ;E � FA�67F7D?;@7�F:7�TAI�;@�735:�4D3@5:�I:7@�B3DF;3>;@8AD?3F;A@��EG5:�3E�F:7�TAI�;@FA�3@6�AGF�A8�F:7�@7FIAD=��;E�=@AI@

30

x1

x2

� <G@5F;A@� AD�@A67

,:7�@7FIAD=�;@��;9 ��E:AIE�F:7�FD38S5�TAI��;@�H7:;5>7E�B7D�:AGD�AH7D�E7H7D3>�A@7I3K�EFD77FE�;@�6AI@FAI@��3>F;?AD7�6GD;@9�3�FKB;53>�73D>K�38F7D@AA@�7F7D?;@7�F:7�97@7D3>�TAI�B3FF7D@�8AD�F:7�@7FIAD=

300

300

400

600

500

A

B

D

C

x1

x4

x2 x5

x3 100

Calvert St. South St.

Lombard St.

Pratt St.

N

�3>F;?AD7�EFD77FE

/D;F7�7CG3F;A@E�F:3F�67E5D;47�F:7�TAI� 3@6�F:7@�S@6�F:7�97@7D3>�EA>GF;A@A8�F:7�EKEF7? %347>�F:7�EFD77F�;@F7DE75F;A@E��<G@5F;A@E��3@6�F:7�G@=@AI@�TAIE�;@�F:74D3@5:7E� 3E�E:AI@�;@��;9 � �F�735:�;@F7DE75F;A@� E7F�F:7�TAI�;@�7CG3>�FA�F:7�TAI�AGF

�17)56)'7-21 �/2:�-1 �/2:�287� 300 C 500 D x1 C x2

� x2 C x4 D 300 C x3

� 100 C 400 D x4 C x5

� x1 C x5 D 600

Page 52: $)15&3 & * )- ,'&+ & & * $ * - University of Utah

�(($"��,"'&+�'���"&��*��1+,�%+

�>EA� F:7�FAF3>�TAI�;@FA�F:7�@7FIAD= .500 C 300 C 100 C 400/ 7CG3>E�F:7�FAF3>�TAIAGF�A8�F:7�@7FIAD= .300 C x3 C 600/� I:;5:�E;?B>;S7E�FA x3 D 400 �A?4;@7�F:;E7CG3F;A@�I;F:�3�D73DD3@97?7@F�A8�F:7�SDEF�8AGD�7CG3F;A@E�FA�A4F3;@�F:7�8A>>AI;@9�EKEF7?A8�7CG3F;A@E�

x1 C x2 D 800

x2 " x3 C x4 D 300

x4 C x5 D 500

x1 C x5 D 600

x3 D 400

*AI�D76G5F;A@�A8�F:7�3EEA5;3F76�3G9?7@F76�?3FD;J�>736E�FA

x1 C x5 D 600

x2 " x5 D 200

x3 D 400

x4 C x5 D 500

,:7�97@7D3>�TAI�B3FF7D@�8AD�F:7�@7FIAD=�;E�67E5D;476�4K

8̂ˆ̂̂̂<̂ˆ̂̂̂ˆ̂:

x1 D 600 " x5

x2 D 200 C x5

x3 D 400

x4 D 500 " x5

x5 ;E�8D77

� @793F;H7�TAI�;@�3�@7FIAD=�4D3@5:�5ADD7EBA@6E�FA�TAI�;@�F:7�6;D75F;A@�ABBAE;F7FA�F:3F�E:AI@�A@�F:7�?A67> +;@57�F:7�EFD77FE�;@�F:;E�BDA4>7?�3D7�A@7I3K� @A@7�A8�F:7H3D;34>7E�:7D7�53@�47�@793F;H7 ,:;E�835F�>736E�FA�57DF3;@�>;?;F3F;A@E�A@�F:7�BAEE;4>7H3>G7E�A8�F:7�H3D;34>7E �AD�;@EF3@57� x5 ' 500 4753GE7 x4 53@@AF�47�@793F;H7 (F:7D5A@EFD3;@FE�A@�F:7�H3D;34>7E�3D7�5A@E;67D76�;@�)D35F;57�)DA4>7?��

�� +GBBAE7�3@�75A@A?K�:3E�F:D77�E75FADE� �9D;5G>FGD7� &;@;@9� 3@6�&3@G835FGD;@9�9D;5G>FGD7�E7>>E����A8�;FE�AGFBGF�FA�&;@;@9�3@6�����FA�&3@G835FGD;@9� 3@6�D7F3;@EF:7�D7EF &;@;@9�E7>>E�����A8�;FE�AGFBGF�FA��9D;5G>FGD7�3@6�����FA�&3@G835FGD;@9�3@6�D7F3;@E�F:7�D7EF &3@G835FGD;@9�E7>>E�����A8�;FE�AGFBGF�FA��9D;5G>FGD7�3@6�����FA&;@;@9� 3@6�D7F3;@E�F:7�D7EF �7F7D?;@7�F:7�7J5:3@97�F34>7�8AD�F:;E�75A@A?K� I:7D7F:7�5A>G?@E�67E5D;47�:AI�F:7�AGFBGF�A8�735:�E75FAD�;E�7J5:3@976�3?A@9�F:7�F:D77E75FADE

� �A@E;67D�F:7�@7FIAD=�TAI�EFG6;76�;@��J3?B>7�� �7F7D?;@7�F:7�BAEE;4>7�D3@97�A8H3>G7E�A8 x1 3@6 x2 1� %+� ,:7�7J3?B>7�E:AI76�F:3F x5 ' 500 /:3F�6A7E�F:;E;?B>K�34AGF x1 3@6 x2� �>EA� GE7�F:7�835F�F:3F x5 & 02

Page 53: $)15&3 & * )- ,'&+ & & * $ * - University of Utah

�"&��*�)-�,"'&+�"&��"&��*��$ ��*�

�� +GBBAE7�3@�75A@A?K�:3E�A@>K�FIA�E75FADE� AA6E�3@6�+7DH;57E �35:�K73D� AA6E�E7>>E�����A8�;FE�AGFBGF�FA�+7DH;57E3@6�=77BE�F:7�D7EF� I:;>7�+7DH;57E�E7>>E�����A8�;FE�AGFBGF�FA AA6E�3@6�D7F3;@E�F:7�D7EF �;@6�7CG;>;4D;G?�BD;57E�8AD�F:73@@G3>�AGFBGFE�A8�F:7� AA6E�3@6�+7DH;57E�E75FADE�F:3F�?3=7735:�E75FADRE�;@5A?7�?3F5:�;FE�7JB7@6;FGD7E

.7

.8

.2 .3

Goods Services

� �;@6�3@AF:7D�E7F�A8�7CG;>;4D;G?�BD;57E�8AD�F:7�75A@A?K�;@�J3?B>7 � +GBBAE7 � F:7 � E3?7 � 75A@A?K �GE76 � #3B3@7E7K7@�;@EF736�A8�6A>>3DE�FA�?73EGD7�F:7�H3>G7E�A8�F:7�H3D;AGEE75FADER�AGFBGFE /AG>6�F:;E�5:3@97�F:7�BDA4>7?�;@�3@K�I3K��;E5GEE

� �A@E;67D�3@�75A@A?K�I;F:�F:D77�E75FADE� �G7>E�3@6�)AI7D�&3@G835FGD;@9� 3@6�+7DH;57E �G7>E�3@6�)AI7D�E7>>E����A8�;FE�AGFBGF�FA�&3@G835FGD;@9� ���FA�+7DH;57E� 3@6�D7F3;@EF:7�D7EF &3@G835FGD;@9�E7>>E� ���A8�;FE�AGFBGF�FA��G7>E�3@6)AI7D� ����FA�+7DH;57E� 3@6�D7F3;@E�F:7�D7EF +7DH;57E�E7>>E����FA��G7>E�3@6�)AI7D� ����FA�&3@G835FGD;@9� 3@6�D7F3;@EF:7�D7EF3 �A@EFDG5F�F:7�7J5:3@97�F34>7�8AD�F:;E�75A@A?K4 �7H7>AB�3 �EKEF7?�A8 �7CG3F;A@E� F:3F � >736E� FA�BD;57E�3FI:;5:�735:�E75FADRE�;@5A?7�?3F5:7E�;FE�7JB7@E7E ,:7@ID;F7�F:7�3G9?7@F76�?3FD;J�F:3F�53@�47�DAI�D76G576�FAS@6�F:7E7�BD;57E

5 1�2 �;@6�3�E7F�A8�7CG;>;4D;G?�BD;57E�I:7@�F:7�BD;57�8ADF:7�+7DH;57E�AGFBGF�;E� ���G@;FE

�� +GBBAE7�3@�75A@A?K�:3E � 8AGD �E75FADE� &;@;@9� %G?47D��@7D9K� 3@6�,D3@EBADF3F;A@ &;@;@9�E7>>E� ���A8�;FE�AGFBGFFA�%G?47D� ����FA��@7D9K� 3@6�D7F3;@E�F:7�D7EF %G?47DE7>>E� ���A8�;FE�AGFBGF�FA�&;@;@9� ����FA��@7D9K� ����FA,D3@EBADF3F;A@� 3@6�D7F3;@E�F:7�D7EF �@7D9K�E7>>E�����A8�;FEAGFBGF�FA�&;@;@9� ���FA�%G?47D� ����FA�,D3@EBADF3F;A@�3@6�D7F3;@E�F:7�D7EF ,D3@EBADF3F;A@�E7>>E�����A8�;FE�AGFBGF�FA&;@;@9� ���FA�%G?47D� ����FA��@7D9K� 3@6�D7F3;@E�F:7�D7EF3 �A@EFDG5F�F:7�7J5:3@97�F34>7�8AD�F:;E�75A@A?K4 1�2 �;@6�3�E7F�A8�7CG;>;4D;G?�BD;57E�8AD�F:7�75A@A?K

�� �@�75A@A?K�:3E�8AGD�E75FADE� �9D;5G>FGD7� &3@G835FGD;@9�+7DH;57E� 3@6�,D3@EBADF3F;A@ �9D;5G>FGD7�E7>>E�����A8�;FEAGFBGF�FA�&3@G835FGD;@9� ����FA�+7DH;57E� ����FA�,D3@EBADF3F;A@� 3@6�D7F3;@E�F:7�D7EF &3@G835FGD;@9�E7>>E�����A8�;FEAGFBGF�FA��9D;5G>FGD7� ����FA�+7DH;57E� ����FA�,D3@EBADF3F;A@� 3@6�D7F3;@E�F:7�D7EF +7DH;57E�E7>>E� ���A8�;FE�AGFBGF�FA�9D;5G>FGD7� ����FA�&3@G835FGD;@9� ����FA�,D3@EBADF3F;A@�

3@6�D7F3;@E�F:7�D7EF ,D3@EBADF3F;A@�E7>>E�����A8�;FE�AGFBGFFA��9D;5G>FGD7� ����FA�&3@G835FGD;@9� ����FA�+7DH;57E� 3@6D7F3;@E�F:7�D7EF3 �A@EFDG5F�F:7�7J5:3@97�F34>7�8AD�F:;E�75A@A?K4 1�2 �;@6�3�E7F�A8�7CG;>;4D;G?�BD;57E�8AD�F:7�75A@A?K�;8F:7�H3>G7�A8�,D3@EBADF3F;A@�;E�� ����B7D�G@;F

5 ,:7�+7DH;57E�E75FAD�>3G@5:7E�3�EG557EE8G>�P73F�83D?�8D7E:Q53?B3;9@� 3@6�;@5D73E7E�;FE�E:3D7�A8�F:7�AGFBGF�8DA?�F:7�9D;5G>FGD3>�E75FAD�FA����� I:7D73E�F:7�E:3D7�A8��9D;5G>FGD3>�BDA6G5F;A@�9A;@9�FA�&3@G835FGD;@9�83>>E�FA� ���A@EFDG5F�F:7�7J5:3@97�F34>7�8AD�F:;E�@7I�75A@A?K

6 1�2 �;@6�3�E7F�A8�7CG;>;4D;G?�BD;57E�8AD�F:;E�@7I�75A@A?K;8 � F:7�H3>G7�A8 �,D3@EBADF3F;A@� ;E �EF;>> �� ����B7D �G@;F/:3F�78875F�:3E�F:7�P73F�83D?�8D7E:Q�53?B3;9@�:36�A@�F:77CG;>;4D;G?�BD;57E�8AD�F:7�E75FADE�;@�F:;E�75A@A?K�

�3>3@57�F:7�5:7?;53>�7CG3F;A@E�;@��J7D5;E7E��N �GE;@9�F:7�H75FAD7CG3F;A@�3BBDA35:�6;E5GEE76�;@�F:;E�E75F;A@

� �>G?;@G?�AJ;67�3@6�53D4A@�D735F�FA�5D73F7�7>7?7@F3>�3>G?;@G?�3@6�53D4A@�6;AJ;67�

�>2(3 C � ! �>C �(2

1�AD�735:�5A?BAG@6� 5A@EFDG5F�3�H75FAD�F:3F�>;EFE�F:7�@G?47DEA8�3FA?E�A8�3>G?;@G?� AJK97@� 3@6�53D4A@2

�� �>=3+7>FL7D �5A@F3;@E � EA6;G?�4;53D4A@3F7 � �'3!�(3� �3@65;FD;5�35;6��!3�6!5(7� /:7@�3�F34>7F�;E�6;EEA>H76�;@�I3F7D�F:7�8A>>AI;@9�D735F;A@�BDA6G57E�EA6;G?�5;FD3F7� I3F7D� 3@653D4A@�6;AJ;67��93E��

'3!�(3 C !3�6!5(7 ! '33�6!5(7 C !2(C �(2

�� %;?7EFA@7� �3�(3; @7GFD3>;L7E�F:7�35;6� !3(��;@�35;6�D3;@�4KF:7�8A>>AI;@9�G@43>3@576�7CG3F;A@�

!3(C �3�(3 ! !2(C �3C �(2

�� �ADA@�EG>S67�D735FE�H;A>7@F>K�I;F:�I3F7D�FA�8AD?�4AD;5�35;63@6�:K6DA97@�EG>S67�93E��F:7�E?7>>�A8�DAFF7@�799E� ,:7G@43>3@576�7CG3F;A@�;E

�2+3 C !2( ! !3�(3 C !2+

��� 1�2 "8�BAEE;4>7� GE7�7J35F�3D;F:?7F;5�AD�3�D3F;A@3>�8AD?3F�8AD53>5G>3F;A@E�;@�43>3@5;@9�F:7�8A>>AI;@9�5:7?;53>�D735F;A@�

)4'6 C �D&@2(8 ! )43(4 C �D2(3 C&@(2 C '(

��� 1�2 ,:7�5:7?;53>�D735F;A@�47>AI�53@�47�GE76�;@�EA?7�;@6GEFD;3>�BDA57EE7E� EG5:�3E�F:7�BDA6G5F;A@�A8�3DE7@7���E!3�-E7�7J35F�3D;F:?7F;5�AD�3�D3F;A@3>�8AD?3F�8AD�53>5G>3F;A@E�FA43>3@57�F:;E�7CG3F;A@

&@+C �E2�D10(35 C !2+(4

! !&@(4 C �E!3 C �D+3(12 C !2(

Page 54: $)15&3 & * )- ,'&+ & & * $ * - University of Utah

�"&��*� &��(�&��&��

�� �;@6�F:7�97@7D3>�TAI�B3FF7D@�A8�F:7�@7FIAD=�E:AI@�;@�F:7S9GD7 �EEG?;@9�F:3F�F:7�TAIE�3D7�3>>�@A@@793F;H7� I:3F�;EF:7�E?3>>7EF�BAEE;4>7�H3>G7�8AD x4�

80

100A

B

C

x1

x2

x4

x3

�� 3 �;@6�F:7�97@7D3>�TAI�B3FF7D@�A8�F:7�@7FIAD=�E:AI@�;@�F:7S9GD7

4 �EEG?;@9�F:3F�F:7�TAI�?GEF�47�;@�F:7�6;D75F;A@E�;@6;53F76� S@6�F:7�?;@;?G?�TAIE�;@�F:7�4D3@5:7E�67@AF764K x2� x3� x4� 3@6 x5

60

80

90

100x1 x6

x2

x3

x5

x4

20 40

30 40

A

E

C

D

B

��� 3 �;@6�F:7�97@7D3>�FD38S5�B3FF7D@�A8�F:7�8D77I3K�@7FIAD=

E:AI@�;@�F:7�S9GD7 ��>AI�D3F7E�3D7�;@�53DE�?;@GF7�4 �7E5D;47�F:7�97@7D3>�FD38S5�B3FF7D@�I:7@�F:7�DA36�I:AE7TAI�;E x5 ;E�5>AE76

5 /:7@ x5 D 0� I:3F�;E�F:7�?;@;?G?�H3>G7�A8 x4�

x1

x3

x4 x2x5

100

90

80

90

BA

CD

��� "@F7DE75F;A@E�;@��@9>3@6�3D7�A8F7@�5A@EFDG5F76�3E�A@7I3KPDAG@634AGFE�Q EG5:�3E�F:7�A@7�E:AI@�;@�F:7�S9GD7 �EEG?7F:3F�FD38S5�?GEF�FD3H7>�;@�F:7�6;D75F;A@E�E:AI@ �;@6�F:797@7D3> � EA>GF;A@ �A8 � F:7 �@7FIAD= �TAI �;@6 � F:7 � E?3>>7EFBAEE;4>7�H3>G7�8AD x6

x1

x4

x6 x2

x3x5

70

100

60

80

80 90

DE

A B

F C

�� /D;F7�F:7�B7D57@F397E�3E�675;?3>E +;@57�3>>�AGFBGF�?GEF�47�F3=7@�;@FA�355AG@F� 735:5A>G?@�?GEF�EG?�FA� ,:;E�835F�:7>BE�FA�S>>�;@�3@K�?;EE;@9�7@FD;7E

�-675-&87-21�2*��87387�*520��+5-'8/785) �-1-1+ �%18*%'785-1+ �85',%6)(�&<�

�� �� �� �9D;5G>FGD7�� � �� &;@;@9�� �� �� &3@G835FGD;@9

� +;@57 x5 ' 500� F:7 � 7CG3F;A@E �� 3@6 �� 8AD x1 3@6 x2 ;?B>K � F:3F x1 & 1003@6 x2 ' 700 ,:7�835F � F:3F x5 & 0 ;?B>;7E� F:3F x1 ' 600 3@6 x2 & 200 +A�100 ' x1 ' 600� 3@6 200 ' x2 ' 700

,:7�:A?A97@7AGE�7CG3F;A@E�;@�+75F;A@ ��53@�47�EFG6;76�8DA?�3�6;887D7@F�B7DEB75F;H74K�ID;F;@9�F:7?�3E�H75FAD�7CG3F;A@E "@�F:;E�I3K� F:7�8A5GE�E:;8FE�8DA?�F:7�G@=@AI@EA>GF;A@E�A8 A; D � FA�F:7�H75FADE�F:3F�3BB73D�;@�F:7�H75FAD�7CG3F;A@E

Page 55: $)15&3 & * )- ,'&+ & & * $ * - University of Utah

�"&��*�)-�,"'&+�"&��"&��*��$ ��*�

�AD�;@EF3@57� 5A@E;67D�F:7�7CG3F;A@

x1

24

123

35 C x2

24

456

35 C x3

24

210

35 D

24

000

35 � �

,:;E � 7CG3F;A@ �:3E � 3 � FD;H;3> � EA>GF;A@� A8 � 5AGDE7� I:7D7 x1 D x2 D x3 D 0 �E � ;@+75F;A@ �� F:7�?3;@�;EEG7�;E�I:7F:7D�F:7�FD;H;3>�EA>GF;A@�;E�F:7 &%#0�&%�

�@�;@67J76�E7F�A8�H75FADE f91; : : : ; 9pg ;@ Rn ;E�E3;6�FA�47 /-1)%5/<�-1()3)1()17;8�F:7�H75FAD�7CG3F;A@

x191 C x292 C ! ! ! C xp9p D �

:3E�A@>K�F:7�FD;H;3>�EA>GF;A@ ,:7�E7F f91; : : : ; 9pg ;E�E3;6�FA�47 /-1)%5/<�()3)1()17;8�F:7D7�7J;EF�I7;9:FE c1; : : : ; cp � @AF�3>>�L7DA� EG5:�F:3F

c191 C c292 C ! ! ! C cp9p D � ���

�CG3F;A@�����;E�53>>76�3 /-1)%5�()3)1()1')�5)/%7-21 3?A@9 91; : : : ; 9p I:7@�F:7I7;9:FE�3D7�@AF�3>>�L7DA �@�;@67J76�E7F�;E�>;@73D>K�67B7@67@F�;8�3@6�A@>K�;8�;F�;E�@AF>;@73D>K�;@67B7@67@F �AD�4D7H;FK� I7�?3K�E3K�F:3F 91; : : : ; 9p 3D7�>;@73D>K�67B7@67@FI:7@ �I7 �?73@ � F:3F f91; : : : ; 9pg ;E � 3 � >;@73D>K �67B7@67@F � E7F /7 �GE7 � 3@3>A9AGEF7D?;@A>A9K�8AD�>;@73D>K�;@67B7@67@F�E7FE

%7F 91 D

24

123

35� 92 D

24

456

35� 3@6 93 D

24

210

35

3 �7F7D?;@7�;8�F:7�E7F f91; 92; 93g ;E�>;@73D>K�;@67B7@67@F4 "8�BAEE;4>7� S@6�3�>;@73D�67B7@67@57�D7>3F;A@�3?A@9 91� 92� 3@6 93

3 /7�?GEF�67F7D?;@7�;8�F:7D7�;E�3�@A@FD;H;3>�EA>GF;A@�A8�7CG3F;A@�� ��34AH7 *AI�AB7D3F;A@E�A@�F:7�3EEA5;3F76�3G9?7@F76�?3FD;J�E:AI�F:3F2

41 4 2 02 5 1 03 6 0 0

35 %

24

1 4 2 00 "3 "3 00 0 0 0

35

�>73D>K� x1 3@6 x2 3D7�43E;5�H3D;34>7E� 3@6 x3 ;E�8D77 �35:�@A@L7DA�H3>G7�A8 x3

67F7D?;@7E�3�@A@FD;H;3>�EA>GF;A@�A8�� � !7@57 91; 92; 93 3D7�>;@73D>K�67B7@67@F��3@6@AF�>;@73D>K�;@67B7@67@F�

4 ,A�S@6�3�>;@73D�67B7@67@57�D7>3F;A@�3?A@9 91� 92� 3@6 93� 5A?B>7F7>K�DAI�D76G57F:7�3G9?7@F76�?3FD;J�3@6�ID;F7�F:7�@7I�EKEF7?�

24

1 0 "2 00 1 1 00 0 0 0

35

x1 " 2x3 D 0

x2 C x3 D 0

0 D 0

,:GE x1 D 2x3� x2 D "x3� 3@6 x3 ;E�8D77 �:AAE7�3@K�@A@L7DA�H3>G7�8AD x3OE3K�x3 D 5 ,:7@ x1 D 10 3@6 x2 D "5 +G4EF;FGF7�F:7E7�H3>G7E�;@FA�7CG3F;A@�� ��3@6A4F3;@

1091 " 592 C 593 D �,:;E�;E�A@7��AGF�A8�;@S@;F7>K�?3@K��BAEE;4>7�>;@73D�67B7@67@57�D7>3F;A@E�3?A@9 91�92� 3@6 93

Page 56: $)15&3 & * )- ,'&+ & & * $ * - University of Utah

�"&��*� &��(�&��&��

�"&��*� &��(�&��&���'����,*"0��'$-%&++GBBAE7�F:3F�I7�479;@�I;F:�3�?3FD;JA D Œ %1 ! ! ! %n ! ;@EF736�A8�3�E7F�A8�H75FADE ,:7?3FD;J�7CG3F;A@ A; D � 53@�47�ID;FF7@�3E

x1%1 C x2%2 C ! ! ! C xn%n D �

�����# %��)���'�%��%���)�#�+ &%��$&%��+����&#,$%*�&� A �&))�*'&%�*�+&���%&%+) - �#*&#,+ &%�&� A; D � ,:GE�I7�:3H7�F:7�8A>>AI;@9�;?BADF3@F�835F

,:7�5A>G?@E�A8�3�?3FD;J A 3D7�>;@73D>K�;@67B7@67@F�;8�3@6�A@>K�;8�F:7�7CG3F;A@A; D � :3E &%#0 F:7�FD;H;3>�EA>GF;A@ ���

�7F7D?;@7� ;8 � F:7 �5A>G?@E�A8 � F:7 �?3FD;J A D

24

0 1 41 2 "15 8 0

35 3D7

>;@73D>K�;@67B7@67@F

,A�EFG6K A; D �� DAI�D76G57�F:7�3G9?7@F76�?3FD;J�24

0 1 4 01 2 "1 05 8 0 0

35 %

24

1 2 "1 00 1 4 00 "2 5 0

35 %

24

1 2 "1 00 1 4 00 0 13 0

35

�F�F:;E�BA;@F� ;F�;E�5>73D�F:3F�F:7D7�3D7�F:D77�43E;5�H3D;34>7E�3@6�@A�8D77�H3D;34>7E +AF:7�7CG3F;A@ A; D � :3E�A@>K�F:7�FD;H;3>�EA>GF;A@� 3@6�F:7�5A>G?@E�A8 A 3D7�>;@73D>K;@67B7@67@F

��,+�'���&��'*��/'����,'*+� E7F�5A@F3;@;@9�A@>K�A@7�H75FADOE3K� 9O;E�>;@73D>K�;@67B7@67@F�;8�3@6�A@>K�;8 9 ;E@AF�F:7�L7DA�H75FAD ,:;E�;E�4753GE7�F:7�H75FAD�7CG3F;A@ x19 D � :3E�A@>K�F:7�FD;H;3>EA>GF;A@�I:7@ 9 ¤ � ,:7�L7DA�H75FAD�;E�>;@73D>K�67B7@67@F�4753GE7 x1� D � :3E�?3@K@A@FD;H;3>�EA>GF;A@E

,:7�@7JF�7J3?B>7�I;>>�7JB>3;@�F:7�@3FGD7�A8�3�>;@73D>K�67B7@67@F�E7F�A8�FIA�H75FADE

�7F7D?;@7�;8�F:7�8A>>AI;@9�E7FE�A8�H75FADE�3D7�>;@73D>K�;@67B7@67@F

3 91 D#

31

$� 92 D

#62

$4 91 D

#32

$� 92 D

#62

$

3 'AF;57�F:3F 92 ;E�3�?G>F;B>7�A8 91� @3?7>K� 92 D 291 !7@57 "291 C 92 D �� I:;5:E:AIE�F:3F f91; 92g ;E�>;@73D>K�67B7@67@F

4 ,:7�H75FADE 91 3@6 92 3D7�57DF3;@>K %&+ ?G>F;B>7E�A8�A@7�3@AF:7D �AG>6�F:7K�47>;@73D>K�67B7@67@F� +GBBAE7 c 3@6 d E3F;E8K

c91 C d92 D �

"8 c ¤ 0� F:7@�I7�53@�EA>H7�8AD 91 ;@�F7D?E�A8 92� @3?7>K� 91 D ."d=c/92 ,:;ED7EG>F�;E�;?BAEE;4>7�4753GE7 91 ;E %&+ 3�?G>F;B>7�A8 92 +A c ?GEF�47�L7DA +;?;>3D>K�d ?GEF�3>EA�47�L7DA ,:GE f91; 92g ;E�3�>;@73D>K�;@67B7@67@F�E7F

Page 57: $)15&3 & * )- ,'&+ & & * $ * - University of Utah

�"&��*�)-�,"'&+�"&��"&��*��$ ��*�

,:7�3D9G?7@FE�;@��J3?B>7���E:AI�F:3F�KAG�53@�3>I3KE�675;67 �0� %*'��+ &%I:7@�3

x1

x2

Linearly dependent

(3, 1)

(6, 2)

x1

x2

Linearly independent

(3, 2) (6, 2)

E7F�A8�FIA�H75FADE�;E�>;@73D>K�67B7@67@F *AI�AB7D3F;A@E�3D7�G@@757EE3DK +;?B>K�5:75=I:7F:7D�3F�>73EF�A@7�A8�F:7�H75FADE�;E�3�E53>3D�F;?7E�F:7�AF:7D �,:7�F7EF�3BB>;7E�A@>K�FAE7FE�A8 +.& H75FADE�

� E7F�A8�FIA�H75FADE f91; 92g ;E�>;@73D>K�67B7@67@F�;8�3F�>73EF�A@7�A8�F:7�H75FADE�;E3�?G>F;B>7�A8�F:7�AF:7D ,:7�E7F�;E�>;@73D>K�;@67B7@67@F�;8�3@6�A@>K�;8�@7;F:7D�A8�F:7H75FADE�;E�3�?G>F;B>7�A8�F:7�AF:7D

"@�97A?7FD;5�F7D?E� FIA�H75FADE�3D7�>;@73D>K�67B7@67@F�;8�3@6�A@>K�;8�F:7K�>;7�A@�F:7E3?7�>;@7�F:DAG9:�F:7�AD;9;@ �;9GD7� �E:AIE�F:7�H75FADE�8DA?��J3?B>7��

��,+�'���/'�'*��'*�����,'*+,:7�BDAA8�A8�F:7�@7JF�F:7AD7?�;E�E;?;>3D�FA�F:7�EA>GF;A@�A8��J3?B>7�� �7F3;>E�3D7�9;H7@3F�F:7�7@6�A8�F:;E�E75F;A@

�@�;@67J76�E7F S D f91; : : : ; 9pg A8�FIA�AD�?AD7�H75FADE�;E�>;@73D>K�67B7@67@F�;83@6�A@>K�;8�3F�>73EF�A@7�A8�F:7�H75FADE�;@ S ;E�3�>;@73D�5A?4;@3F;A@�A8�F:7�AF:7DE "@835F� ;8 S ;E�>;@73D>K�67B7@67@F�3@6 91 ¤ �� F:7@�EA?7 9j �I;F: j > 1��;E�3�>;@73D5A?4;@3F;A@�A8�F:7�BD7576;@9�H75FADE� 91; : : : ; 9j #1

������ ,:7AD7?���6A7E %&+ E3K�F:3F �-�)0 H75FAD�;@�3�>;@73D>K�67B7@67@F�E7F�;E�3>;@73D�5A?4;@3F;A@�A8�F:7�BD7576;@9�H75FADE � H75FAD�;@�3�>;@73D>K�67B7@67@F�E7F�?3K83;>�FA�47�3�>;@73D�5A?4;@3F;A@�A8�F:7�AF:7D�H75FADE +77�)D35F;57�)DA4>7?��

%7F 8 D

24

310

35 3@6 9 D

24

160

35 �7E5D;47�F:7�E7F�EB3@@76�4K 8 3@6 9�

3@6�7JB>3;@�I:K�3�H75FAD: ;E�;@ +B3@ f8; 9g ;8�3@6�A@>K�;8 f8; 9;:g ;E�>;@73D>K�67B7@67@F,:7�H75FADE 8 3@6 9 3D7�>;@73D>K�;@67B7@67@F�4753GE7�@7;F:7D�H75FAD�;E�3

?G>F;B>7�A8�F:7�AF:7D� 3@6�EA�F:7K�EB3@�3�B>3@7�;@ R3 �+77�+75F;A@ �� "@�835F�+B3@ f8; 9g ;E�F:7 x1x2B>3@7��I;F: x3 D 0/ "8 : ;E�3�>;@73D�5A?4;@3F;A@�A8 8 3@6 9�F:7@ f8; 9;:g ;E�>;@73D>K�67B7@67@F� 4K�,:7AD7?�� �A@H7DE7>K� EGBBAE7�F:3F f8; 9;:g;E�>;@73D>K�67B7@67@F �K�,:7AD7?��� EA?7�H75FAD�;@ f8; 9;:g ;E�3�>;@73D�5A?4;@3F;A@A8�F:7�BD7576;@9�H75FADE��E;@57 8 ¤ �/ ,:3F�H75FAD�?GEF�47:� E;@57 9 ;E�@AF�3�?G>F;B>7A8 8 +A : ;E�;@ +B3@ f8; 9g +77��;9 �

x1

x2

x3

vwu

Linearly dependent,w in Span{u, v}

x1

x2

x3

v

w

u

Linearly independent,w not in Span{u, v}

%;@73D�67B7@67@57�;@ R3

Page 58: $)15&3 & * )- ,'&+ & & * $ * - University of Utah

�"&��*� &��(�&��&��

�J3?B>7���97@7D3>;L7E�FA�3@K�E7F f8; 9;:g ;@R3 I;F: 8 3@6 9 >;@73D>K�;@67B7@67@F,:7�E7F f8; 9;:g I;>>�47�>;@73D>K�67B7@67@F�;8�3@6�A@>K�;8 : ;E�;@�F:7�B>3@7�EB3@@76�4K8 3@6 9

,:7�@7JF�FIA�F:7AD7?E�67E5D;47�EB75;3>�53E7E�;@�I:;5:�F:7�>;@73D�67B7@67@57�A8�3E7F�;E�3GFA?3F;5 &AD7AH7D� ,:7AD7?���I;>>�47�3�=7K�D7EG>F�8AD�IAD=�;@�>3F7D�5:3BF7DE

"8�3�E7F�5A@F3;@E�?AD7�H75FADE�F:3@�F:7D7�3D7�7@FD;7E�;@�735:�H75FAD� F:7@�F:7�E7F;E�>;@73D>K�67B7@67@F ,:3F�;E� 3@K�E7F f91; : : : ; 9pg ;@ Rn ;E�>;@73D>K�67B7@67@F�;8p > n

%7F A D Œ 91 ! ! ! 9p ! ,:7@ A ;E n # p� 3@6�F:7�7CG3F;A@ A; D � 5ADD7EBA@6E�FA�3�EKEF7?�A8 n 7CG3F;A@E�;@ p G@=@AI@E "8 p > n� F:7D7�3D7�?AD7�H3D;34>7EF:3@�7CG3F;A@E� EA�F:7D7�?GEF�47�3�8D77�H3D;34>7 !7@57A; D � :3E�3�@A@FD;H;3>�EA>GF;A@�

***

***

*p

n **

***

***

"8 p > n� F:7�5A>G?@E�3D7�>;@73D>K67B7@67@F

3@6�F:7�5A>G?@E�A8 A 3D7�>;@73D>K�67B7@67@F +77��;9 ��8AD�3�?3FD;J�H7DE;A@�A8�F:;EF:7AD7?

������ ,:7AD7?���E3KE�@AF:;@9�34AGF�F:7�53E7�;@�I:;5:�F:7�@G?47D�A8�H75FADE�;@F:7�E7F�6A7E %&+ 7J5776�F:7�@G?47D�A8�7@FD;7E�;@�735:�H75FAD

,:7�H75FADE#

21

$�#

4"1

$�#

"22

$3D7�>;@73D>K�67B7@67@F�4K�,:7AD7?

�� 4753GE7�F:7D7�3D7�F:D77�H75FADE�;@�F:7�E7F�3@6�F:7D7�3D7�A@>K�FIA�7@FD;7E�;@�735:�H75FAD'AF;57� :AI7H7D� F:3F�@A@7�A8�F:7�H75FADE�;E�3�?G>F;B>7�A8�A@7�A8�F:7�AF:7D�H75FADE +77�;9 �

x1

x2

(2, 1)

(4, –1)

(–2, 2)

� >;@73D>K�67B7@67@F�E7F�;@ R2

"8�3�E7F S D f91; : : : ; 9pg ;@ Rn 5A@F3;@E�F:7�L7DA�H75FAD� F:7@�F:7�E7F�;E�>;@73D>K67B7@67@F

�K�D7@G?47D;@9�F:7�H75FADE� I7�?3K�EGBBAE7 91 D � ,:7@�F:7�7CG3F;A@191 C 092 C ! ! ! C 09p D � E:AIE�F:3F S ;E�>;@73D>K�67B7@67@F

�7F7D?;@7�4K�;@EB75F;A@�;8�F:7�9;H7@�E7F�;E�>;@73D>K�67B7@67@F

3

24

176

35�

24

209

35�

24

315

35�

24

418

35 4

24

235

35�

24

000

35�

24

118

35 5

2664

"246

10

3775�

2664

3"6"915

3775

3 ,:7�E7F�5A@F3;@E�8AGD�H75FADE� 735:�A8�I:;5:�:3E�A@>K�F:D77�7@FD;7E +A�F:7�E7F�;E>;@73D>K�67B7@67@F�4K�,:7AD7?��

4 ,:7AD7?���6A7E�@AF�3BB>K�:7D7�4753GE7�F:7�@G?47D�A8�H75FADE�6A7E�@AF�7J5776�F:7@G?47D�A8�7@FD;7E�;@�735:�H75FAD +;@57�F:7�L7DA�H75FAD�;E�;@�F:7�E7F� F:7�E7F�;E�>;@73D>K67B7@67@F�4K�,:7AD7?��

5 �A?B3D7�F:7�5ADD7EBA@6;@9�7@FD;7E�A8�F:7�FIA�H75FADE ,:7�E75A@6�H75FAD�E77?E�FA47 "3=2 F;?7E�F:7�SDEF�H75FAD ,:;E�D7>3F;A@�:A>6E�8AD�F:7�SDEF�F:D77�B3;DE�A8�7@FD;7E�4GF�83;>E�8AD�F:7�8AGDF:�B3;D ,:GE�@7;F:7D�A8�F:7�H75FADE�;E�3�?G>F;B>7�A8�F:7�AF:7D� 3@6:7@57�F:7K�3D7�>;@73D>K�;@67B7@67@F

Page 59: $)15&3 & * )- ,'&+ & & * $ * - University of Utah

�"&��*�)-�,"'&+�"&��"&��*��$ ��*�

"@ �97@7D3>� KAG � E:AG>6 � D736 �3 � E75F;A@ � F:ADAG9:>K *�-�)�# F;?7E � FA � 34EAD4 �3@SG ;?BADF3@F�5A@57BF�EG5:�3E�>;@73D�;@67B7@67@57 ,:7�@AF7E�;@�F:7 �+,�0� , �� 8AD

F:;E�E75F;A@�I;>>�:7>B�KAG�>73D@�FA�8AD?�?7@F3>�;?397E�A8�=7K�;673E�;@�>;@73D�3>974D3�AD�;@EF3@57� F:7�8A>>AI;@9�BDAA8�;E�IADF:�D736;@9�53D78G>>K�4753GE7�;F�E:AIE�:AI�F:767S@;F;A@�A8�>;@73D�;@67B7@67@57�53@�47 ,*��

"8 �EA?7 9j ;@ S 7CG3>E�3� >;@73D�5A?4;@3F;A@�A8� F:7�AF:7D�H75FADE� F:7@ 9j 53@�47EG4FD35F76�8DA?�4AF:�E;67E�A8�F:7�7CG3F;A@� BDA6G5;@9�3�>;@73D�67B7@67@57�D7>3F;A@I;F:�3 �@A@L7DA�I7;9:F ."1/ A@ 9j 1�AD� ;@EF3@57� ;8 91 D c292 C c393� F:7@ � D."1/91 C c292 C c393 C 094 C ! ! ! C 09p 2 ,:GE S ;E�>;@73D>K�67B7@67@F

�A@H7DE7>K� EGBBAE7 S ;E�>;@73D>K�67B7@67@F "8 91 ;E�L7DA� F:7@�;F�;E�3��FD;H;3>�>;@73D�5A?4;@3F;A@�A8�F:7�AF:7D�H75FADE�;@ S (F:7DI;E7� 91 ¤ �� 3@6�F:7D7�7J;EF�I7;9:FEc1; : : : ; cp � @AF�3>>�L7DA� EG5:�F:3F

c191 C c292 C ! ! ! C cp9p D �

%7F j 47�F:7�>3D97EF�EG4E5D;BF�8AD�I:;5: cj ¤ 0 "8 j D 1� F:7@ c191 D �� I:;5:�;E;?BAEE;4>7�4753GE7 91 ¤ � +A j > 1� 3@6

c191 C ! ! ! C cj 9j C 09j C1 C ! ! ! C 09p D �cj 9j D "c191 " ! ! ! " cj #19j #1

9j D)

" c1

cj

*91 C ! ! ! C

)"cj #1

cj

*9j #1

%7F 8 D

24

32

"4

35� 9 D

24

"617

35� : D

24

0"5

2

35� 3@6 = D

24

37

"5

35

�� �D7�F:7�E7FE f8; 9g; f8;:g; f8; =g; f9;:g; f9; =g� 3@6 f:; =g 735:�>;@73D>K�;@67B7@67@F� /:K�AD�I:K�@AF�

� �A7E�F:7�3@EI7D�FA�)DA4>7?� �;?B>K�F:3F f8; 9;:; =g ;E�>;@73D>K�;@67B7@67@F�� ,A�67F7D?;@7�;8 f8; 9;:; =g ;E�>;@73D>K�67B7@67@F� ;E�;F�I;E7�FA�5:75=�;8� E3K� : ;E�3>;@73D�5A?4;@3F;A@�A8 8� 9� 3@6 =�

�� "E f8; 9;:; =g >;@73D>K�67B7@67@F�

"@��J7D5;E7E� N�� 67F7D?;@7�;8�F:7�H75FADE�3D7�>;@73D>K�;@67B7@67@F #GEF;8K�735:�3@EI7D

��

24

500

35�

24

72

"6

35�

24

94

"8

35 �

24

023

35�

24

00

"8

35�

24

"131

35

�#

2"3

$�#

"46

$��

#"1

3

$�#

"3"9

$

"@��J7D5;E7E��N�� 67F7D?;@7�;8�F:7�5A>G?@E�A8�F:7�?3FD;J�8AD?�3>;@73D>K�;@67B7@67@F�E7F #GEF;8K�735:�3@EI7D

��

2664

0 "3 92 1 "7

"1 4 "51 "4 "2

3775 �

2664

"4 "3 00 "1 51 1 "52 1 "10

3775

��

24

1 4 "3 0"2 "7 5 1"4 "5 7 5

35 ��

24

1 "2 3 2"2 4 "6 2

0 1 "1 3

35

"@ � �J7D5;E7E � � � 3@6 � �� �3� � 8AD � I:3F � H3>G7E � A8 h ;E 93 ;@+B3@ f91; 92g� 3@6��4��8AD�I:3F�H3>G7E�A8 h ;E f91; 92; 93g >;@73D>K��'�%��%+� #GEF;8K�735:�3@EI7D

Page 60: $)15&3 & * )- ,'&+ & & * $ * - University of Utah

�"&��*� &��(�&��&��

�� 91 D

24

1"3

2

35� 92 D

24

"39

"6

35� 93 D

24

5"7

h

35

��� 91 D

24

1"3"5

35� 92 D

24

"39

15

35� 93 D

24

2"5

h

35

"@��J7D5;E7E� N �� S@6�F:7�H3>G7�E��A8 h 8AD�I:;5:�F:7�H75FADE3D7�>;@73D>K ��'�%��%+ #GEF;8K�735:�3@EI7D

���

24

2"2

4

35�

24

4"6

7

35�

24

"22h

35 ��

24

3"6

1

35�

24

"64

"3

35�

24

9h3

35

��

24

15

"3

35�

24

"2"9

6

35�

24

3h

"9

35 ���

24

1"2"4

35�

24

"376

35�

24

21h

35

�7F7D?;@7�4K�;@EB75F;A@�I:7F:7D�F:7�H75FADE�;@��J7D5;E7E� �N��3D7�>;@73D>K %��'�%��%+ #GEF;8K�735:�3@EI7D

���#

51

$�#

28

$�#

13

$�#

"17

$� �

24

2"4

8

35�

24

"36

"12

35

���

24

5"3"1

35�

24

000

35�

24

"724

35 ���

#34

$�#

"15

$�#

35

$�#

71

$

���

24

"812"4

35�

24

2"3"1

35 ��

24

14

"7

35�

24

"253

35�

24

000

35

"@��J7D5;E7E�� �3@6���� ?3D=�735:�EF3F7?7@F�,DG7�AD��3>E7 #GEF;8K735:�3@EI7D�A@�F:7�43E;E�A8�3�53D78G>�D736;@9�A8�F:7�F7JF

�� 3 ,:7�5A>G?@E�A8�3�?3FD;JA 3D7�>;@73D>K�;@67B7@67@F�;8�F:77CG3F;A@ A; D � :3E�F:7�FD;H;3>�EA>GF;A@

4 "8 S ;E�3�>;@73D>K�67B7@67@F�E7F� F:7@�735:�H75FAD�;E�3�>;@73D5A?4;@3F;A@�A8�F:7�AF:7D�H75FADE�;@ S

5 ,:7�5A>G?@E�A8�3@K 4 # 5 ?3FD;J�3D7�>;@73D>K�67B7@67@F6 "8 ; 3@6 < 3D7�>;@73D>K�;@67B7@67@F� 3@6�;8 f;; <; =g ;E>;@73D>K�67B7@67@F� F:7@ = ;E�;@ +B3@ f;; <g

� 3 "8 8 3@6 9 3D7 � >;@73D>K � ;@67B7@67@F� 3@6 � ;8 : ;E � ;@+B3@ f8; 9g� F:7@ f8; 9;:g ;E�>;@73D>K�67B7@67@F

4 "8�F:D77�H75FADE�;@ R3 >;7�;@�F:7�E3?7�B>3@7�;@ R3� F:7@F:7K�3D7�>;@73D>K�67B7@67@F

5 "8�3�E7F�5A@F3;@E�87I7D�H75FADE�F:3@�F:7D7�3D7�7@FD;7E�;@�F:7H75FADE� F:7@�F:7�E7F�;E�>;@73D>K�;@67B7@67@F

6 "8�3�E7F�;@ Rn ;E�>;@73D>K�67B7@67@F� F:7@�F:7�E7F�5A@F3;@E?AD7�F:3@ n H75FADE

"@��J7D5;E7E���N��� 67E5D;47�F:7�BAEE;4>7�75:7>A@�8AD?E�A8�F:7?3FD;J -E7�F:7�@AF3F;A@�A8��J3?B>7� �;@�+75F;A@ �

� A ;E�3 2 # 2 ?3FD;J�I;F:�>;@73D>K�67B7@67@F�5A>G?@E

�� A ;E�3 3 # 3 ?3FD;J�I;F:�>;@73D>K�;@67B7@67@F�5A>G?@E

�� A ;E�3 4 # 2?3FD;J� A D Œ%1 %2!� 3@6 %2 ;E�@AF�3�?G>F;B>7�A8%1

� A ;E�3 4 # 3 ?3FD;J� A D Œ%1 %2 %3!� EG5:�F:3F f%1; %2g ;E>;@73D>K�;@67B7@67@F�3@6 %3 ;E�@AF�;@ +B3@ f%1; %2g

�� !AI�?3@K�B;HAF�5A>G?@E�?GEF�3 6 # 4 ?3FD;J�:3H7�;8�;FE5A>G?@E�3D7�>;@73D>K�;@67B7@67@F� /:K�

�� !AI�?3@K�B;HAF�5A>G?@E�?GEF�3 4 # 6 ?3FD;J�:3H7�;8�;FE5A>G?@E�EB3@ R4� /:K�

�� �A@EFDG5F 3 # 2 ?3FD;57E A 3@6 B EG5:�F:3F A; D � :3E�3@A@FD;H;3>�EA>GF;A@� 4GF B; D � :3E�A@>K�F:7�FD;H;3>�EA>GF;A@

�� 3 �;>> � ;@� F:7�4>3@=�;@� F:7�8A>>AI;@9�EF3F7?7@F� P"8 A ;E3@ m # n ?3FD;J� F:7@ � F:7 �5A>G?@E �A8 A 3D7 � >;@73D>K;@67B7@67@F�;8�3@6�A@>K�;8 A :3E B;HAF�5A>G?@EQ

4 �JB>3;@�I:K�F:7�EF3F7?7@F�;@��3��;E�FDG7

�J7D5;E7E�� �3@6����E:AG>6�47�EA>H76 . +�&,+�'�)�&)$ %��)&.&'�)�+ &%* 1� %+� /D;F7 A; D � 3E�3�H75FAD�7CG3F;A@2

�� ;H7@A D

2664

2 3 5"5 1 "4"3 "1 "4

1 0 1

3775� A4E7DH7�F:3F�F:7�F:;D6�5A>G?@

;E�F:7�EG?�A8�F:7�SDEF�FIA�5A>G?@E �;@6�3�@A@FD;H;3>�EA>GF;A@A8 A; D �

� ;H7@ A D

24

4 3 "5"2 "2 4"2 "3 7

35� A4E7DH7�F:3F�F:7�SDEF�5A>G?@

?;@GE�F:D77�F;?7E�F:7�E75A@6�5A>G?@�7CG3>E�F:7�F:;D6�5A>G?@�;@6�3�@A@FD;H;3>�EA>GF;A@�A8 A; D �

�35:�EF3F7?7@F�;@��J7D5;E7E���N���;E�7;F:7D�FDG7��;@�3>>�53E7E�AD�83>E7��8AD�3F�>73EF�A@7�7J3?B>7� "8�83>E7� 5A@EFDG5F�3�EB75;S57J3?B>7�FA�E:AI�F:3F�F:7�EF3F7?7@F�;E�@AF�3>I3KE�FDG7 +G5:3@�7J3?B>7�;E�53>>76�3 �&,%+�)�/�$'#� FA�F:7�EF3F7?7@F "8�3EF3F7?7@F � ;E � FDG7� 9;H7�3 � <GEF;S53F;A@ �(@7�EB75;S5�7J3?B>753@@AF�7JB>3;@�I:K�3�EF3F7?7@F�;E�3>I3KE�FDG7 0AG�I;>>�:3H7�FA6A�?AD7�IAD=�:7D7�F:3@�;@��J7D5;E7E�� �3@6����

� "8 91; : : : ; 94 3D7�;@R4 3@6 93 D 291 C 92� F:7@ f91; 92; 93; 94g;E�>;@73D>K�67B7@67@F

�� "8 91 3@6 92 3D7�;@ R4 3@6 92 ;E�@AF�3�E53>3D�?G>F;B>7�A8 91�F:7@ f91; 92g ;E�>;@73D>K�;@67B7@67@F

�� "8 91; : : : ; 95 3D7�;@ R5 3@6 93 D �� F:7@ f91; 92; 93; 94; 95g ;E>;@73D>K�67B7@67@F

� "8 91� 92� 93 3D7�;@ R3 3@6 93 ;E %&+ 3�>;@73D�5A?4;@3F;A@�A891; 92� F:7@ f91; 92; 93g ;E�>;@73D>K�;@67B7@67@F

�� "8 91; : : : ; 94 3D7�;@ R4 3@6 f91; 92; 93g ;E�>;@73D>K�67B7@67@F�F:7@ f91; 92; 93; 94g ;E�3>EA�>;@73D>K�67B7@67@F

�� "8 f91; : : : ; 94g ;E�3�>;@73D>K�;@67B7@67@F�E7F�A8�H75FADE�;@ R4�F:7@ f91; 92; 93g ;E�3>EA�>;@73D>K�;@67B7@67@F 1� %+� ,:;@=34AGF x191 C x292 C x393 C 0 ! 94 D �2

�� +GBBAE7 A ;E�3@m # n?3FD;J�I;F:�F:7�BDAB7DFK�F:3F�8AD�3>> &;@Rm F:7�7CG3F;A@A; D & :3E�3F�?AEF�A@7�EA>GF;A@ -E7�F:7

Page 61: $)15&3 & * )- ,'&+ & & * $ * - University of Utah

�"&��*�)-�,"'&+�"&��"&��*��$ ��*�

67S@;F;A@�A8�>;@73D�;@67B7@67@57�FA�7JB>3;@�I:K�F:7�5A>G?@EA8 A ?GEF�47�>;@73D>K�;@67B7@67@F

��� +GBBAE7�3@ m # n ?3FD;J A :3E n B;HAF�5A>G?@E �JB>3;@I:K�8AD�735: & ;@ Rm F:7�7CG3F;A@ A; D & :3E�3F�?AEF�A@7EA>GF;A@ 1� %+� �JB>3;@�I:K A; D & 53@@AF�:3H7�;@S@;F7>K?3@K�EA>GF;A@E2

1�2 "@��J7D5;E7E�� �3@6���� GE7�3E�?3@K�5A>G?@E�A8A 3E�BAEE;4>7FA�5A@EFDG5F�3�?3FD;JB I;F:�F:7�BDAB7DFK�F:3F�F:7�7CG3F;A@B; D �:3E�A@>K�F:7�FD;H;3>�EA>GF;A@ +A>H7 B; D � FA�H7D;8K�KAGD�IAD=

��� A D

2664

3 "4 10 7 "4"5 "3 "7 "11 15

4 3 5 2 18 "7 23 4 15

3775

�� A D

266664

12 10 "6 8 4 "14"7 "6 4 "5 "7 9

9 9 "9 9 9 "18"4 "3 "1 0 "8 1

8 7 "5 6 1 "11

377775

�� 1�2 /;F: A 3@6 B 3E�;@��J7D5;E7�� � E7>75F�3�5A>G?@ 9 A8 AF:3F�I3E�@AF�GE76�;@�F:7�5A@EFDG5F;A@�A8 B 3@6�67F7D?;@7�;89 ;E�;@�F:7�E7F�EB3@@76�4K�F:7�5A>G?@E�A8 B ��7E5D;47�KAGD53>5G>3F;A@E�

��� 1�2 *7B73F��J7D5;E7����I;F:�F:7�?3FD;57E A 3@6 B 8DA?�J7D5;E7��� ,:7@�9;H7�3@�7JB>3@3F;A@�8AD�I:3F�KAG�6;E5AH7D�3EEG?;@9�F:3F B I3E�5A@EFDG5F76�3E�EB75;S76

�� 07E "@�735:�53E7� @7;F:7D�H75FAD�;E�3�?G>F;B>7�A8�F:7�AF:7D ,:GE�735:�E7F�;E�>;@73D>K;@67B7@67@F

� 'A ,:7�A4E7DH3F;A@�;@�)D35F;57�)DA4>7?� � 4K�;FE7>8� E3KE�@AF:;@9�34AGF�F:7�>;@73D;@67B7@67@57�A8 f8; 9;:; =g

� 'A /:7@�F7EF;@9�8AD�>;@73D�;@67B7@67@57� ;F�;E�GEG3>>K�3�BAAD�;673�FA�5:75=�;8�A@7E7>75F76�H75FAD�;E�3�>;@73D�5A?4;@3F;A@�A8�F:7�AF:7DE "F�?3K�:3BB7@�F:3F�F:7�E7>75F76H75FAD�;E�@AF�3�>;@73D�5A?4;@3F;A@�A8�F:7�AF:7DE�3@6�K7F�F:7�I:A>7�E7F�A8�H75FADE�;E>;@73D>K�67B7@67@F "@�F:;E�BD35F;57�BDA4>7?� : ;E�@AF�3�>;@73D�5A?4;@3F;A@�A8 8� 9�3@6 =

Span{u, v, z}

w

x3

x1 x2

�� 07E� 4K�,:7AD7?�� ,:7D7�3D7�?AD7�H75FADE��8AGD��F:3@�7@FD;7E��F:D77��;@�F:7?

,:7�6;887D7@57�47FI77@�3�?3FD;J�7CG3F;A@ A; D & 3@6�F:7�3EEA5;3F76�H75FAD�7CG3F;A@x1%1 C ! ! ! C xn%n D & ;E�?7D7>K�3�?3FF7D�A8�@AF3F;A@ !AI7H7D� 3�?3FD;J�7CG3F;A@A; D & 53@�3D;E7�;@�>;@73D�3>974D3��3@6�;@�3BB>;53F;A@E�EG5:�3E�5A?BGF7D�9D3B:;5E�3@6E;9@3>�BDA57EE;@9��;@�3�I3K�F:3F�;E�@AF�6;D75F>K�5A@@75F76�I;F:�>;@73D�5A?4;@3F;A@E�A8H75FADE ,:;E�:3BB7@E�I:7@�I7�F:;@=�A8�F:7�?3FD;JA 3E�3@�A4<75F�F:3F�P35FEQ�A@�3�H75FAD; 4K�?G>F;B>;53F;A@�FA�BDA6G57�3�@7I�H75FAD�53>>76 A;

�AD�;@EF3@57� F:7�7CG3F;A@E

#4 "3 1 32 0 5 1

$2664

1111

3775 D

#58

$3@6

#4 "3 1 32 0 5 1

$2664

14

"13

3775 D

#00

$

✻ ✻ ✻ ✻ ✻ ✻A ; & A 8 �

E3K�F:3F�?G>F;B>;53F;A@�4K A FD3@E8AD?E ; ;@FA & 3@6�FD3@E8AD?E 8 ;@FA�F:7�L7DA�H75FAD+77��;9