8/12/2019 15. NTC vs Hamoy

1/29

EN BANC

NATIONAL TRANSMISSION G.R. No. 179255

CORPORATION,

Petitioner, Present:

PUNO, C.J.,

QUISUMBING,

NAR!S"SANTIAGO,

CARPIO,

" #ers$s " AUSTRIA"MARTIN!%,

CORONA,

CARPIO MORAL!S,

TINGA,

C&ICO"NA%ARIO,

'!LASCO, (R.,

'!NUSTO ). &AMO, (R., NAC&URA,

Res*on+ent. L!ONAR)O )! CASTRO, n+

BRION, n+

P!RALTA,JJ.

8/12/2019 15. NTC vs Hamoy

2/29

Pro-$/te+:

A*ri 2, 2009

"""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""""

D E C I S I O N

TINGA,J.:

Tis trets o3 te *etition 3or re#ie4 o3 te +eision161 n+ reso$tion262 o3

te Co$rt o3 A**es +te+ 80 M 2007 n+ 7 A$/$st 2007, res*eti#e, in CA"

G.R. SP No. 9;87 entite+, Venusto D. Hamoy, Jr. v. National Transmission

Corporation & Civil Service Commission, or+erin/ te i--e+ite ret$rn o3

'en$sto &-o, (r. to is ori/in *osition s 'ie"Presi+ent 3or 'isMin

O*ertions < Mintenne.

Te ntee+ents 3oo4.

1

61Rollo, **. 51"78= Penne+ > Assoite ($stie Art$ro G. T/, 4it te on$rrene

o3 Assoite ($stie Mrtin S. 'ir-, (r. n+ Assoite ($stie &?i- S. A>+$4i+.

262I+. t 75"7.

8/12/2019 15. NTC vs Hamoy

3/29

Te Ntion Trns-ission Cor*ortion @*etitioner, tro$/ Reso$tion No.

TC 2008"007868 +te+ 5 e>r$r 2008, **ointe+ 'en$sto ). &-o, (r.

@res*on+ent s 'ie Presi+ent $n+er Ite- No. 700010"C2008 'isMin

O*ertions < Mintenne. Aor+in/, *etitioners Presi+ent n+ Cie3

!e$ti#e O33ier @C!O An OrtiD @OrtiD iss$e+ on 1 Mr 2008 Ci#i Ser#ie

Co--ission @CSC or- No. 88 4i sttes tt res*on+ent s >een **ointe+

E@'IC!"PR!SI)!NT (G"1; 'IC!"PR!SI)!NT SG"2; 4it P!RMAN!NT

@stt$s t te Ntion Trns-ission Cor*ortion.F6 Res*on+ent ss$-e+ is

+$ties on 1 Mr 2008.

On 19 (n$r 200, OrtiD iss$e+ O33ie Or+er No. 200"178 +etiin/

res*on+ent to *etitioners Po4er Center")ii-n, E$n+er te O33ie o3 te

Presi+ent n+ C!O, to n+e S*ei ProHets.F565 O33ie Or+er No. 200"178

4s ter -en+e+ > O33ie Or+er No. 200"12296 $n+er 4i OrtiD ssi/ne+

res*on+ent ++ition +$ties o3 *ro#i+in/ Eo#er" s$*er#ision, -onitorin/ n+

8

68I+. t 77"7;.

6I+. t 79.

5

65I+. t ;1.

6I+. t ;2.

8/12/2019 15. NTC vs Hamoy

4/29

ontro o3 ti#ities rete+ to te se o3 *etitioners s$>"trns-ission ssets

n+ *e+ $n+er is s$*er#ision ertin *ersonne o3 te S$>"Trns-ission

)i#est-ent )e*rt-ent.

In -e-orn+$- +te+ 2 (n$r 2005 3ro- *etitioners &$-n

Reso$res )e*rt-ent, res*on+ent 4s noti3ie+ o3 te i-*en+in/ e*irtion o3 te

te-*orr **oint-ent o3 so-e o3 *etitioners ?e o33iis n+ te 3t tt e

4s >ein/ onsi+ere+ 3or one o3 te *ositions to >e #te+.767 et on 15

e>r$r 2005, O33ie Or+er No. 2005"025 4s iss$e+ +esi/ntin/ res*on+ent sO33ier"In"Cr/e @OIC o3 te Po4er Sste-s Rei>iit Gro$* @PSRG,

on$rrent 4it is +$ties s 'ie Presi+ent 3or S*ei ProHets.;6;

On 1 e>r$r 2005, res*on+ent 4rote OrtiD, s?in/ tt e >e ret$rne+ to

is ori/in ssi/n-ent s 'ie Presi+ent o3 'isMin O*ertions < Mintenne.

&e resone+ tt is +eti $n+er O33ie Or+ers No. 200"178 n+ No. 200"1229

re+ eee+e+ one @1 er, n+ tt is +esi/ntion $n+er O33ie Or+er No.

2005"025 #iote+ Setion 2 o3 CSC Me-orn+$- Cir$r No. 21, s. 2002

>e$se e +i+ not /i#e is onsent tereto.969 &o4e#er, on te s-e +te, O33ie

7

67I+. t 2.

;

6;I+. t ;.

9

69I+. t ;5";.

8/12/2019 15. NTC vs Hamoy

5/29

8/12/2019 15. NTC vs Hamoy

6/29

tter or+er sttin/ tt res*on+ent 4s +esi/nte+ s OIC o3 te Po4er Sste-s

Rei>iit Gro$* @PSRG.10610 Res*on+ent 4s t$s onstrine+ to 4rite noter

etter to OrtiD, re$estin/ reonsi+ertion o3 O33ie Or+er No. 2005"02; n+

reitertin/ te resons e ite+ in is *re#io$s etter.11611

On 1 Mr 2005, OrtiD iss$e+ -e-orn+$- in3or-in/ res*on+ent tt

is +eti to te Presi+ents O33ie 4s no on/er in e33et n+, in #ie4 o3 te

#n rete+ > te e*irtion o3 te te-*orr **oint-ent o3 te 'ie

Presi+ent o3 te PSRG, res*on+ent 4s +esi/nte+ s its OIC. &e 3$rter stte+

tt te -tter o3 ressi/n-ent 4o$+ >e 3or- rise+ t te Bor+ -eetin/ n+,

so$+ te Bor+ on3ir- it, orres*on+in/ O33ie Or+er 4o$+ >e iss$e+

ressi/nin/ res*on+ent s e+ o3 te PSRG.12612 On 27 A*ri 2005, te Bor+

iss$e+ Reso$tion No. TC 2005"01;,18618 **ro#in/ n+ on3ir-in/

10

610I+. t ;8.

11

611I+. t ;7";;.

12

612I+. t ;9"90.

18

618I+. t 98"9.

8/12/2019 15. NTC vs Hamoy

7/29

res*on+ents ressi/n-ent to PSRG, n+ nno$nin/ te o*enin/ o3 seetion 3or

te *osition o3 'ie Presi+ent 3or 'isMin O*ertions < Mintenne.

Res*on+ent **ee+ to te CSC, *rin/ 3or te nn$-ent o3 Reso$tion

No. TC 2005"01; n+ O33ie Or+er No. 2005"02; on te /ro$n+ tt te

ressi/n-ent #iote+ is se$rit o3 ten$re. 161

In Reso$tion No. 01080 +te+ ; ($ne 200,15615 te CSC +enie+

res*on+ents **e. It 3o$n+ tt res*on+ent 3ie+ to so4 tt is ressi/n-ent

4s tinte+ 4it >$se o3 +isretion. Aor+in/ to te CSC, te *osition to 4i

res*on+ent 4s **ointe+ 4s ssi3ie+ s tir+"e#e *osition, 4i 4s not

sttion"s*ei3i, n+ t$s e o$+ >e ressi/ne+ or trns3erre+ 3ro- one

or/niDtion $nit to noter 4itin te s-e /en, 4ito$t #iotin/ is

ri/t to se$rit o3 ten$re.161 Moreo#er, te CSC r$e+ tt is +eti +i+ not

eee+ te one"er *erio+, s it 4s s$*erse+e+ initi > is ressi/n-ent= n+

tt is +esi/ntion n+ ressi/n-ent + >ot >een +one to -eet te nee+s o3 te

o-*n, 4ito$t -?in/ i- s$33er re+$tion in sr stt$s n+ rn?.

1

61I+. t 95"97.

15

615I+. t 150"17;.

1

61I+.

8/12/2019 15. NTC vs Hamoy

8/29

Res*on+ent so$/t reonsi+ertion o3 te +eision, >$t is -otion 4s +enie+ >

te CSC tro$/ Reso$tion No. 01;0 *ro-$/te+ on 1 Oto>er 200.17617

Res*on+ent >ro$/t te -tter to te Co$rt o3 A**es @CA 4i

+is/ree+ 4it te 3in+in/s o3 te CSC. Citin/ te A+-inistrti#e Co+e,1;61;

Home Insurance Guaranty Corporation v. Civil Service Commission,19619 n+

Oice o t!e Om"u#sman v. Civil Service Commission,20620 te Co$rt o3 A**es

e+ tt on *resi+enti **ointees >eon/ to te tir+"e#e or reer ee$ti#e

ser#ie. T$s, res*on+ent, #in/ >een **ointe+ > *etitioners *resi+ent n+ notte Presi+ent o3 te Pii**ines, o$*ies seon+" e#e *osition on.21621 Te

**ete o$rt so r$e+ tt res*on+ents *osition 4s sttion"s*ei3i, +es*ite

te >sene o3 *e o3 ssi/n-ent in CSC or- No. 88, sine te si+ 3or-

s*ei3i re3erre+ to *etitioners Bor+ Reso$tion No. TC 2008"2007, 4i

in+ite+ tt is **oint-ent is to te *osition o3 'ie Presi+ent $n+er EIte- No.

17

617I+. t 199"207.

18

[18]Executive Order No. 292 (1987), Book V, Title I (u!title "), #$%&ter 2

19619G.R. No. 9550, 19 Mr 1998, 220 SCRA 1;.

20

620G.R. No. 15990, 1 e>r$r 2002.

21

621Rollo, **. 0"8.

8/12/2019 15. NTC vs Hamoy

9/29

700010"'isMin O*ertions < Mintenne.F Te *osition o3 res*on+ent >ein/

sttion"s*ei3i, is ressi/n-ent o$+ not eee+ one @1 er *er Me-orn+$-

Cir$r No. 2.22622

Te Co$rt o3 A**es so +is$sse+ te #rio$s *ersonne -o#e-ents

e33ete+ on res*on+ent. T$s, 4en e re*orte+ to is ne4 ssi/n-ent s E'ie

Presi+ent o3 S*ei ProHetsF *er O33ie Or+er No. 200"178, s -en+e+ >

O33ie Or+er No. 200"1229, s$ -o#e-ent 4s ressi/n-ent n+ not -ere

+eti, sine tere 4s -o#e-ent 3ro- one or/niDtion $nit to noter 4itinte s-e +e*rt-ent or /en= tt is, 3ro- is sttion t te o33ie o3 te 'ie

Presi+ent 'isMin O*ertions < Mintenne to te O33ie o3 te Presi+ent n+

C!O. Res*on+ent re-ine+ in is *e o3 ressi/n-ent >eon+ 1 e>r$r 2005

>e$se e 4s +esi/nte+ ++ition +$ties, #irt$ eten+in/ is ressi/n-ent

>eon+ te one"er *erio+. Te tir+ *ersonne -o#e-ent on 1 e>r$r 2005,

s OIC o3 te PSRG, 4s so n$it >e$se it eten+e+ 3$rter is ori/in

ressi/n-ent, n+ 4orse, te **oint-ent 4s -+e +es*ite res*on+ents #i/oro$s

o>Hetion, si+ te Co$rt o3 A**es.28628 in, it on$+e+ tt 4ie

res*on+ents *osition, rn? n+ sr + re-ine+ $nn/e+ tro$/o$t te

22

[22]#IVI' EVI#E #OIION, e*or%+du* #ircul%r No. 2 ( # No. 2), $ic$ &rovide-

rule- o+ %&&oi+t*e+t %+d ot$er &er-o++el %ctio+-, %+d cover- e*&loee- %&&oi+ted to /ir-t %+d -eco+d

level &o-itio+ i+ t$e c%reer %+d +o+0c%reer -ervice, &rovide- % o+e (1) e%r re-trictio+ o+ re%--i+*e+t

out-ide t$e eor%&$ic%l loc%tio+ i/ it$out t$e co+-e+t o/ t$e e*&loee.

28

628Rollo, *. 9.

8/12/2019 15. NTC vs Hamoy

10/29

8/12/2019 15. NTC vs Hamoy

11/29

On te oter n+, res*on+ent -intins tt e 4s **ointe+ to seon+"

e#e *osition n+, t$s, e is not $n+er te Creer !e$ti#e Ser#ie @C!S. &e

++s tt e 4s, in 3t, **ointe+ to sttion"s*ei3i *osition. Moreo#er, e

i-s tt is ressi/n-ents 4ere -+e in #iotion o3 te r$es n+ onstit$te

onstr$ti#e +is-iss.27627

Te *etition s no -erit.

In r/$in/ tt res*on+ent >eon/s to te C!S, *etitioner in#o?es

Me-orn+$- Cir$r No. 21, 4i re+s in *rt:

1. Positions o#ere+ > te Creer !e$ti#e Ser#ie

@

@> In ++ition to te >o#e i+enti3ie+ *ositions n+ oter *ositions o3 te s-e

te/or 4i + >een *re#io$s ssi3ie+ n+ in$+e+ in te C!S,

2

62I+. t 18"1.

27

627I+. t 89"28= Co--ent +te+ 8 Oto>er 2007.

8/12/2019 15. NTC vs Hamoy

12/29

oter tir+ e#e *ositions o3 e$i#ent te/or in >rnes n+

instr$-entities o3 te ntion /o#ern-ent, in$+in/ /o#ern-ent o4ne+ n+

ontroe+ or*ortions 4it ori/in rters re e->re+ 4itin teCreer !e$ti#e Ser#ie *ro#i+e+ tt te -eet te 3oo4in/ riteri:

1. te *osition is reer *osition=2. te *osition is >o#e +i#ision ie3 e#e=

8. te +$ties n+ res*onsi>iities o3 te *osition re$ire te *er3or-ne o3

ee$ti#e n+ -n/eri 3$ntions.

8/12/2019 15. NTC vs Hamoy

13/29

Petitioner so ites Carin$al v. %!ilippine C!arity Seepsta'es Oice

(%CSO)2;62; n+ *rasmo v. Home Insurance Guaranty Corporation29629 to

so4 tt *resi+enti **oint-ent is not re$ire+ >e3ore *osition in

/o#ern-ent or*ortion is ssi3ie+ s in$+e+ in te C!S. 80680 Ke re not

on#ine+.

Te A+-inistrti#e Co+e s*ei3ies te *ositions in te Ci#i Ser#ie s

3oo4s:

Setion ;. Classes o positions in t!e Career Service.@ 1 Csses o3

*ositions in te reer ser#ie **oint-ent to 4i re$ires e-intions s >e/ro$*e+ into tree -Hor e#es s 3oo4s:

@ Te 3irst e#e s in$+e eri, tr+es, r3ts n+ $sto+i ser#ie

*ositions 4i in#o#e non"*ro3ession or s$>"*ro3ession 4or? in non"

s$*er#isor or s$*er#isor *it re$irin/ ess tn 3o$r ers o3 oe/itest$+ies=

2;

62;G.R. No. 1192, 18 Oto>er 2005, 72 SCRA 577.

29

6298 Pi. ;9 @2002.

80

680Rollo, **. 19"22.

8/12/2019 15. NTC vs Hamoy

14/29

@> Te seon+ e#e s in$+e *ro3ession, teni, n+ sienti3i *ositions

4i in#o#e *ro3ession, teni or sienti3i 4or? in non"s$*er#isor or

s$*er#isor *it re$irin/ t est 3o$r ers o3 oe/e 4or? $* to )i#isionCie3 e#es= n+

@ Te tir+ e#e s o#er *ositions in te Creer !e$ti#e Ser#ie.81681

Positions in te C!S $n+er te A+-inistrti#e Co+e in$+e tose o3

Un+erseretr, Assistnt Seretr, B$re$ )iretor, Re/ion )iretor, Assistnt

Re/ion )iretor, Cie3 o3 )e*rt-ent Ser#ie n+ oter o33iers o3 e$i#ent

rn? s - >e i+enti3ie+ > te Creer !e$ti#e Ser#ie Bor+, o3 4o- re

**ointe+ > te Presi+ent.82682 Si-* *$t, tir+"e#e *ositions in te Ci#i

Ser#ie re on tose >eon/in/ to te Creer !e$ti#e Ser#ie, or tose

**ointe+ > te Presi+ent o3 te Pii**ines. Tis 4s te s-e r$in/ n+e+

+o4n > te Co$rt in Oice o t!e Om"u#sman v. Civil Service Commission ,88688

4erein te Co$rt +ere+ tt te C!S o#ers *resi+enti **ointees on.

In te si+ se, te CSC +is**ro#e+ te O33ie o3 te O->$+s-ns

@OMBs re$est 3or **ro# o3 te *ro*ose+ $i3ition stn+r+s 3or te

)iretor II *osition in te Centr A+-inistrti#e Ser#ie n+ inne

81

681!e$ti#e Or+er No. 292 @19;7, Boo? ', Tite 1 @S$>tite A, C*ter 2, Se. ;.

82

682!e$ti#e Or+er No. 292 @19;7, Boo? ', Tite I @S$>tite A, C*ter 2, Se. 7@8.

88

688G.R. No. 12215, 80 ($ 2007, 52; SCRA 585.

8/12/2019 15. NTC vs Hamoy

15/29

Mn/e-ent Ser#ie. Te OMB *ro*ose+ tt si+ *osition re$ire+ ECreer

Ser#ie Pro3essionRee#nt !i/i>iit 3or Seon+ Le#e *osition.F Aor+in/ to

te CSC, te )iretor II *osition >eon/e+ to tir+"e#e ei/i>iit n+ is t$s

o#ere+ > te Creer !e$ti#e Ser#ie. Settin/ te iss$e, tis Co$rt r$e+ t$s:

T$s, te C!S o#ers *resi+enti **ointees on. As tis Co$rt r$e+ in

Oice o t!e Om"u#sman v. CSC:

Ero- te >o#e"$ote+ *ro#ision o3 te A+-inistrti#e

Co+e, persons occupying positions in the CES are presidential

appointees. F @e-*sis s$**ie+

Un+er te Constit$tion, te O->$+s-n is te **ointin/ $torit 3or o33iis n+ e-*oees o3 te O33ie o3 te O->$+s-n, ee*t te )e*$t

O->$+s-en. T$s, *erson o$*in/ te Position o3 )iretor II in te Centr

A+-inistrti#e Ser#ie or inne n+ Mn/e-ent Ser#ie o3 te O33ie o3 te

O->$+s-n is **ointe+ > te O->$+s-n, not > te Presi+ent. As s$, e isneiter e->re+ in te C!S nor +oes e nee+ to *ossess C!S ei/i>iit. 868

Res*on+ent 4s **ointe+ 'ie"Presi+ent o3 'isMin O*ertions Trnso Presi+ent n+ C!O An OrtiD, n+ not > te Presi+ent

o3 te Re*$>i. On tis >sis one, res*on+ent nnot >e onsi+ere+ s *rt o3 te

C!S.

Carin$aln+*rasmo ite+ > *etitioner re not in *oint. Tere, te Co$rt

r$e+ tt **ointees to C!S *ositions 4o +o not *ossess te re$ire+ C!S

8

68Oice o t!e Om"u#sman v. Civil Service Commission, G.R. No. 12215, 80 ($

2007, 52; SCRA 585,52.

8/12/2019 15. NTC vs Hamoy

16/29

ei/i>iit +o not enHo se$rit o3 ten$re. More i-*ortnt, 3r 3ro- o+in/ tt

*resi+enti **oint-ent is not re$ire+ o3 *osition to >e in$+e+ in te C!S, 4e

ern 3ro- Carin$al tt te **oint-ent > te Presi+ent o-*etes te

ttin-ent o3 te C!S rn?, t$s:

A**oint-ent to C!S Rn?

U*on on3er-ent o3 C!S ei/i>iit n+ o-*ine 4it te oter re$ire-ents

*resri>e+ > te Bor+, n in$->ent o3 C!S *osition - $i3 3or

**oint-ent to C!S rn?. A**oint-ent to C!S rn? is -+e > te Presi+ent$*on te reo--en+tion o3 te Bor+. Tis *roess o-*etes te o33iis

-e->ersi* in te C!S n+ -ost i-*ortnt, on3ers on i- se$rit o3 ten$re in

te C!S.

To ssi3 oter *ositions not in$+e+ in te >o#e en$-ertion s

o#ere+ > te C!S n+ re$ire **ointees tereto to $ire C!S or CS!ei/i>iit >e3ore $irin/ se$rit o3 ten$re 4i e+ to $nonstit$tion n+

$n43$ onse$enes. It 4i res$t eiter in @1 #estin/ te **ointin/ *o4er 3or

non" C!S *ositions in te Presi+ent, in #iotion o3 te Constit$tion= or @2in$+in/ in te C!S *osition not e+ > *resi+enti **ointee, ontrr to te

A+-inistrti#e Co+e85685

Interestin/, on 9 A*ri 200;, CSC Atin/ Cir-n Cesr ). B$en3or

iss$e+ O33ie Me-orn+$- No. 27, s. 200;, 4i sttes in *rt:

or ers, te Co--ission s *ro-$/te+ se#er *oiies n+ iss$nes

i+enti3in/ *ositions in te Creer Ser#ie >o#e )i#ision Cie3 Le#e *er3or-in/

85

685Cari$nal v. %!ilippine c!arity Seepsta'es Oice, s$*r note 2; t 5;, itin/ te

R$es n+ Re/$tions o3 te C!S Bor+.

8/12/2019 15. NTC vs Hamoy

17/29

ee$ti#e n+ -n/eri 3$ntions s >eon/in/ to te Tir+ Le#e o#ere+ > te

Creer !e$ti#e Ser#ie @C!S n+ tose o$tsi+e te C!S, t$s, re$irin/ tir+

e#e ei/i>iit 3or *$r*oses o3 *er-nent **oint-ent n+ se$rit o3 ten$re.

&o4e#er, te iss$e s to 4eter *rti$r *osition >eon/s to te Tir+

Le#e s >een sette+ > H$ris*r$+ene ensrine+ in Home Insurance an#Guaranty Corporation v. Civil Service Commission, G.R. No. 9550 +te+ Mr

19, 1998 n+ Oice o t!e Om"u#sman (O+) v. Civil Service Commission = G.R.

No. 12215 +te+ ($ 80, 2007, 4ere te &onor>e S$*re-e Co$rt r$e+ itin/te *ro#ision o3 Setion 7@8 C*ter 2, Tite I"A, Boo? ' o3 A+-inistrti#e Co+e

o3 19;7, tt te Tir+ Le#e s o#er *ositions in te Creer !e$ti#e Ser#ie

@C!S. Positions in te Creer !e$ti#e Ser#ie onsists o3 Un+erseretr,

Assistnt Seretr, B$re$ )iretor, Assistnt B$re$ )iretor, Re/ion)iretor, Assistnt Re/ion )iretor, Cie3 o3 )e*rt-ent Ser#ie n+ oter

o33iers o3 e$i#ent rn? s - >e i+enti3ie+ > te Creer !e$ti#e Ser#ie

Bor+ @C!SB, o3 4o- re **ointe+ > te Presi+ent. To ssi3 oter

*ositions not in$+e+ in te >o#e en$-ertion s o#ere+ > te C!S n+ re$ire**ointees tereto to $ire C!S or CS! ei/i>iit >e3ore $irin/ se$rit o3

ten$re 4i e+ to $nonstit$tion n+ $n43$ onse$enes. It 4i res$teiter: in @1 #estin/ te **ointin/ *o4er 3or non"C!S *ositions in te Presi+ent,

in #iotion o3 te Constit$tion= or, @2 in$+in/ in te C!S *osition not e+

> *resi+enti **ointee, ontrr to te A+-inistrti#e Co+e.

8/12/2019 15. NTC vs Hamoy

18/29

Kie te >o#e"ite+ r$in/ o3 te S$*re-e Co$rt re3er to *rti$r

*ositions in te OMB n+ &IGC, it is er, o4e#er, tt te intention 4s to-?e te +otrine en$nite+ terein **i>e to si-ir n+ o-*r>e

*ositions in te >$re$r. To reiterate, the Third Level covers only thepositions in the CES as enuerated in the Adinistrative Code o! "#$% and

those identi!ied &y the CESB as o! e'uivalent ran(, all o! )ho are appointed

&y the *resident o! the *hilippines. Conse'uently, the doctrine enshrined in

these Supree Court decisions has ipso facto nulli!ied all resolutions,

'uali!ication standards, pronounceents and+or issuances o! the Coission

inso!ar as the re'uireent i! third level eligi&ility to nonCES positions is

concerned.

In vie) thereo!, O- No. , series o! /00$ and all other issuances o! theCoission inconsistent )ith the a!orestated la) and 1urisprudence are

li(e)ise deeed repealed, superseded and a&andoned. 868 @!-*siss$**ie+

T$s, *etitioner n no on/er in#o?e Setion 1@> o3 Me-orn+$- Cir$r

@MC No. 21, it >ein/ inonsistent 4it te 3ore"$ote+ O33ie Me-orn+$- n+

t$s +ee-e+ re*ee+ > no ess tn te CSC itse3.

in/ sette+ te nt$re o3 res*on+ents *osition, 4e no4 +eter-ine te

#i+it o3 res*on+ents ressi/n-ent 3ro- 'ie Presi+ent 3or 'isMin O*ertions

< Mintenne to 'ie Presi+ent o3 S*ei ProHets $n+er O33ie Or+er No. 200"

178, s -en+e+ > O33ie Or+er No. 200"1229.

8

68Ci#i Ser#ie Co--ission O33ie Me-orn+$- No. 27 @200;

8/12/2019 15. NTC vs Hamoy

19/29

Te Re#ise+ R$es on Ressi/n-ent87687 *ro#i+es in *rt:

Se. . . Ressi/n-ent s >e /o#erne+ > te 3oo4in/ r$es:

1. Tese r$es s ** on to e-*oees **ointe+ to 3irst n+ seon+ e#e*ositions in te reer n+ non"reer ser#ies. Ressi/n-ent o3 tir+ e#e

**ointees is /o#erne+ > te *ro#isions o3 Presi+enti )eree No. 1.

2. Personne -o#e-ents in#o#in/ trns3er or +eti so$+ not on3$se+ 4it

ressi/n-ent sine te re /o#erne+ > se*rte r$es.

8. Ressi/n-ent o3 e-*oees 4it sttion"s*ei3i *e o3 4or? in+ite+ in

teir res*eti#e **oint-ents s >e o4e+ on 3or -i-$- *erio+ o3 one@1 er. An appointent is considered stationspeci!ic )hen the particularo!!ice or station )here the position is located is speci!ically indicated on the

!ace o! the appointent paper. Sttion"s*ei3i **oint-ent +oes not re3er to s*ei3ie+ *nti ite- n$->er sine it is $se+ 3or *$r*oses o3 i+enti3in/ te

*rti$r *osition to >e 3ie+ or o$*ie+ > te e-*oee.

. I3 **oint-ent is not sttion"s*ei3i, te one"er -i-$- s not **.T$s, ressi/n-ent o3 e-*oees 4ose **oint-ents +o not s*ei3i in+ite

te *rti$r o33ie or *e o3 4or? s no +e3inite *erio+ $ness oter4ise

re#o?e+ or ree+ > te &e+ o3 A/en, te Ci#i Ser#ie Co--ission or

o-*etent o$rt.

87

687R!'IS!) RUL!S ON R!ASSIGNM!NT, CI'IL S!R'IC! COMMISSION

R!SOLUTION NO. 0"15;, +te+ 28 )ee->er 200

8/12/2019 15. NTC vs Hamoy

20/29

5. I3 n **oint-ent is not sttion"s*ei3i, ressi/n-ent to n or/niDtion $nit

4itin te s-e >$i+in/ or 3ro- one >$i+in/ to noter or onti/$o$s to eoter in one 4or? re or o-*o$n+ is o4e+. Or/niDtion $nit re3ers to

setions, +i#isions, n+ +e*rt-ents 4itin n or/niDtion.

. Ressi/n-ent o$tsi+e /eo/r*i otion i3 4it onsent s #e no

i-it. &o4e#er, i3 it is 4ito$t onsent, ressi/n-ent s >e 3or one @1 eron. Ressi/n-ent o$tsi+e o3 /eo/r*i otion - >e 3ro- one Re/ion

O33ie @RO to noter RO or 3ro- te RO to te Centr O33ie @CO n+ #ie"

#ers.

7. Ressi/n-ent is *res$-e+ to >e re/$r n+ -+e in te interest o3 *$>i

ser#ie $ness *ro#en oter4ise or i3 it onstit$tes onstr$ti#e +is-iss

Ressi/n-ent o3 n e-*oee to *er3or- +$ties n+ res*onsi>iitiesinonsistent 4it te +$ties n+ res*onsi>iities o3 iser *osition s$

s 3ro- *osition o3 +i/nit to -ore ser#ie or -eni Ho>=

> Ressi/n-ent to n o33ie not in te eistin/ or/niDtion str$t$re=

Ressi/n-ent to n eistin/ o33ie >$t te e-*oee is not /i#en n+e3inite +$ties n+ res*onsi>iities=

+ Ressi/n-ent tt 4i $se si/ni3int 3inni +isotion or 4i$se +i33i$t or r+si* on te *rt o3 te e-*oee >e$se o3

/eo/r*i otion= n+

e Ressi/n-ent tt is +one in+isri-inte or 4i-si >e$se te4 is not inten+e+ s on#enient sie+ 3or te

**ointin/+isi*inin/ $torit to rss or o**ress s$>or+inte onte *retet o3 +#nin/ n+ *ro-otin/ *$>i interest.8;68;6!-*sis s$**ie+.

8;

68;CI'IL S!R'IC! COMMISSION R!SOLUTION NO. 0"15; @200, Se. .

8/12/2019 15. NTC vs Hamoy

21/29

Petitioner i-s tt res*on+ent 4s not **ointe+ to sttion"s*ei3i

*osition >e$se is **oint-ent **er, CS or- No. 88, +oes not in+ite n

s*ei3i 4or? sttion.89689 Tis >ein/ te se, e is entite+ to se$rit o3 ten$re

4it res*et on to te *osition o3 'ie Presi+ent, n+ e - >e ressi/ne+

3ro- is ori/in ssi/n-ent in te 'isMin O*ertions < Mintenne to is ne4

ssi/n-ent in te Po4er Sste-s Rei>iit Gro$*.060 On te oter n+, te

Co$rt o3 A**es, rein/ on Bor+ Reso$tion No. TC 2008"2007, 4i

in+ite+ tt res*on+ents **oint-ent 4s to te *osition o3 'ie Presi+ent

$n+er EIte- No. 700010"'isMin O*ertions n+ Mintenne,F e+ tt is

**oint-ent 4s sttion"s*ei3i.161

Ke +o not /ree 4it *etitioner. It is not +is*$te+ tt n **oint-ent is

onsi+ere+ sttion"s*ei3i 4en te *rti$r o33ie or sttion 4ere te *osition

is ote+ is s*ei3i in+ite+ on te 3e o3 te etter o3 **oint-ent @or-No. 88. In tis se, te etter o3 **oint-ent itse3 -?es s*ei3i re3erene to

Bor+ Reso$tion, > #irt$e o3 4i res*on+ent 4s **ointe+ s 'ie Presi+ent

3or 'isMin O*ertions n+ Mintenne, tere> ren+erin/ te Bor+ Reso$tion

n inte/r *rt o3 te etter o3 **oint-ent. Te etter o3 **oint-ent sttes:

89

689Rollo, **. .21"22.

0

60I+. t 28.

1

61I+. t 7.

8/12/2019 15. NTC vs Hamoy

22/29

Re*$>i? n/ Pii*insNATIONAL TRANSMISSION CORPORATION

)ii-n, L$n/so+ n/ Q$eDon

MR. '!NUSTO ). &AMO, (R.

Ntion Trns-ission Cor*ortion

)ii-n, Q$eDon Cit

MR. &AMO:

o nirn/ n @'IC! PR!SI)!NT (G"1; @'IC! PR!SI)!NT SG"2; n - ?t$n/ P!RMAN!NT s P->nsn/ or*orson s

Trns-ison s *so+ n !IG&T &UN)R!) IT SI T&OUSAN) T&R!!

&UN)R!) TK!NT P!SOS @ P;5,820 *iso. Ito -/??>is s *ets n/

*//n* n/ t$n/?$in s$>it +i / s *ets n/ */*ir- n/ *$no n/ tn//*no **ointin/ $torit.

Ang appointent na ito ay 2EE-*LO3-ENT *42S4ANT TO

T2ANSCO BOA2D 2ES. NO. /0050% DATED /+6+05 &ilang (apalit ni N+A

na N+A at ayon sa *lantilya Ite Blg. %0000"0 C3/005, *ahina 777777.8/98/:

@!-*sis s$**ie+

S$-sino,

ALAN T. ORTI%, P.).

Presi+ent < C!O P$no n/ Tn//*n

2

62I+. t 79.

8/12/2019 15. NTC vs Hamoy

23/29

MAR 01 2008

Pets n/ P/*ir-

Te *ertinent *ortions o3 Bor+ Reso$tion No. TC 2008"007 re+, t$s:

2ESOL4TION NO. TC /00500%

;ertion o3 te$i3itions o3 te **ints onsistent 4it te Bor+s G$i+eines, the

!ollo)ing e=ecutives are here&y appointed as !ollo)s>

H. Ite No. %000"0?is-in Operations @-aintenance

-r. ?enusto D.

8/12/2019 15. NTC vs Hamoy

24/29

In oter 4or+s, it is er 3ro- te 3ie+"$* or- No. 88 or te etter o3

**oint-ent tt te **oint-ent 4s iss$e+ *$rs$nt to Bor+ Reso$tion No.

TC 2008"007. Te **oint-ent **ers e*iit re3erene to te Bor+ Reso$tion,

4i in t$rn ite+ EIte- No. 700010"'isMin O*ertions < Mintenne,F

in+ite+ tt res*on+ents 4or? sttion 4s te 'isMin O*ertions e eten+e+ to res*on+ent nnot eee+ one er.

A ressi/n-ent is -o#e-ent o3 n e-*oee 3ro- one or/niDtion $nit

to noter in te s-e +e*rt-ent or /en 4i +oes not in#o#e re+$tion in

rn?, stt$s or sr n+ +oes not re$ire te iss$ne o3 n **oint-ent. A

+eti, on te oter n+, is -o#e-ent 3ro- one /en to noter.6

Res*on+ents -o#e-ent 3ro- te O33ie o3 te 'ie"Presi+ent 'is"Min

O*ertions < Mn/e-ent in (n$r o3 200 to te O33ie o3 te Presi+ent n+

C!O in )ii-n, Q$eDon Cit to n+e S*ei ProHets on 1 e>r$r 200

4s ressi/n-ent, s e 4s -o#e+ 3ro- one +e*rt-ent to noter 4itin te

s-e /en. Neessri tere3ore,

6!e$ti#e Or+er No. 292 @19;7, Boo? '. Tite I, S$>tite A, C*ter ', Setion

2@ n+ @7.

8/12/2019 15. NTC vs Hamoy

25/29

s$ -o#e-ent so$+ st on $nti 1 e>r$r 2005, or one er tere3ter.

&o4e#er, res*on+ent 4s +esi/nte+ ++ition +$ties on 1 e>r$r 2005, 4i

3$rter eten+e+ is st in te )ii-n o33ie. Ken res*on+ent 4s +esi/nte+

s OIC o3 te PSRG, is ressi/n-ent 4s eten+e+ one -ore. In ++ition, te

ressi/n-ents 4ere -+e 4ito$t is onsent, n, +es*ite is o>Hetions. Tese

*ersonne -o#e-ents re er #iotions o3 te Re#ise+ R$es.

A to+, te Co$rt 3in+s no reson to o#ert$rn te )eision o3 te Co$rt o3

A**es.

;

8/12/2019 15. NTC vs Hamoy

26/29

)ANT! O. TINGA

-ssociate Justice

K! CONCUR:

R!NATO S. PUNO

C!ie Justice

8/12/2019 15. NTC vs Hamoy

27/29

L!ONAR)O A. QUISUMBING

-ssociate Justice

CONSU!LO NAR!S"SANTIAGO

-ssociate Justice

ANTONIO T. CARPIO

-ssociate Justice

MA. ALICIA AUSTRIA"MARTIN!%

-ssociate Justice

R!NATO C. CORONA

-ssociate Justice

CONC&ITA CARPIO MORAL!S

-ssociate Justice

8/12/2019 15. NTC vs Hamoy

28/29

@On Le#e

MINITA '. C&ICO"NA%ARIO

-ssociate Justice

PR!SBIT!RO (. '!LASCO, (R.

-ssociate Justice

ANTONIO !)UAR)O B. NAC&URA

-ssociate Justice

T!R!SITA (. L!ONAR)O )! CASTRO

-ssociate Justice

@On Le#e

ARTURO ). BRION

-ssociate Justice

)IOS)A)O M. P!RALTA

-ssociate Justice

8/12/2019 15. NTC vs Hamoy

29/29

C ! R T I I C A T I O N

P$rs$nt to Artie 'III, Setion 18 o3 te Constit$tion, it is ere>

erti3ie+ tt te on$sions in te >o#e )eision 4ere ree+ in

ons$ttion >e3ore te se 4s ssi/ne+ to te 4riter o3 te o*inion o3 te

Co$rt.

R!NATO S. PUNO

C!ie Justice