77
Commercial in Confidence 14 September 2012 Australian Hearing Advisory September 2012 © 2012 KPMG, an Australian partnership and a member firm of the KPMG network of independent member firms affiliated with KPMG International Cooperative ("KPMG International"), a Swiss entity. All rights reserved. KPMG and the KPMG logo are registered trademarks of KPMG International. Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation.

14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    2

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence

14 September 2012

Australian Hearing Advisory

September 2012

© 2012 KPMG, an Australian partnership and a member firm of the KPMG network of independent member firms affiliated with KPMG International Cooperative ("KPMG International"), a Swiss entity.

All rights reserved. KPMG and the KPMG logo are registered trademarks of KPMG International.

Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation.

Page 2: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence Australian Hearing

Advisory September 2012

Recipients of this report, other than Department of Human Services ('Client?

No reliance unless reliance letter executed The basis of preparation of the attached report is discussed in the following pages.

The attached report should not be regarded as suitable for use by any person or persons other than the Client.

A party, other than the Client, may only rely on the attached report if it has executed a formal letter of reliance with KPMG (Australia) Pty Limited ('KPMG,. If you have not executed a formal letter of reliance with KPMG, KPMG:

• owes you no duty (whether in contract or in tort or under statute or otherwise) with respect to or in connection with the attached report or any part thereof; and

• will have no liability to you for any loss or damage suffered or costs incurred by you or any other person arising out of or in connection with the provision to you of the attached report or any part thereof, however the loss or damage is caused, including, but not limited to, as a result of negligence.

If you have not executed a formal letter of reliance with KPMG and you wish to rely upon the attached report or any part thereof you will do so entirely at your own risk.

Auditor independence

If you are an audit client of KPMG you should confirm with your audit committee, prior to reading this report, your policy in relation to the provision of non-audit services by your auditor. You should also consider any statutory or regulatory guidance in the jurisdiction of your incorporation.

If you are an audit client of KPMG and also SEC registered, you must notify us immediately of your intention to read this report. Such notification is required prior t6 you reading the report.

KPMG takes no responsibility for the consequences of a failure by a party" t6 adequately consider, and follow, its own auditor independence pOliCies, or ariy relevant statutory guidance or regulation.

Page 3: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence

Important Notice

Australian Hearing Advisory

September 2012

This report has been prepared in accordance with our Official Order dated 23 July 2012 (Official Order Number 0021005470) ("Order;.

The services provided under the Order ('Services') have not been undertaken in accordance with any auditing, review or assurance standards. Any reference to 'audit' and 'review', throughout this report, is not intended to convey that the Services have been conducted in accordance with any auditing, assurance or review standards. As our scope of work does not constitute an audit or review in accordance with any auditing, review or assurance standards, our work will not necessarily disclose all significant matters about Australian Hearing or reveal errors and irregularities, if any, in the under/ying information.

The information presented in this report is based on publicly available information and information provided by Australian Hearing, Office of Hearing Services and other parties. We have indicated within this report the sources of the information provided. Unless otherwise stated in this report, we have relied upon the truth, accuracy and completeness of any information provided or made available to us in connection with the Services without independently verifying it.

In relation to the forecasts and projections included in the report, we do not make any statement as to whether any forecasts or projections will be achieved, or whether the assumptions and data under/ying any such forecasts and projections are accurate, complete or reasonable. We do not warrant or guarantee the achievement of any such forecasts or projections. There will usually be differences between forecast or projected and actual results, because events and circumstances frequently do not ,occur as expected or predicted, and those differences may be material.

KPMG will not warrant that the implementation of any recommendations we make in accordance with our scope of work will deliver a desired or expected outcome. There is a considerable degree of judgement involved in the preparation of recommendations and, our recommendations are based on the information we have available to us at the date of this report. This information may not be sufficient to ensure that our recommendations produce your desired outcome. Any such recommendations are made based on the anticipated achievement of certain economic, operating, developmental and trading assumptions about future events and actions that have not yet occurred and may not necessarily occur. Further, implementation related event/3 frequently impact the outcome of applied recommendations.

Page 4: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence

KPMG 10 Shelley Street Sydney NSW 2000 Australia

Private & Confidential Department of Human Services

For the attention of the representatives of the Department of Human Services

Australiall Hearillg Advisory

September 20 12

September 2012

Procedures and Information

Our work commenced on 23 July 2012 and our fieldwork was completed on 14 September 2012. We have not undertaken to update this report for events or circumstances arising after that date. We have indicated in this report the sources of the information presented.

Distribution This report is solely to assist the Client in connection with and for Client's information. This report is not to be used for any other purpose or distribut~d to any other person, except as set out in the Official Order, or as otherwise agreed by us in writ,ing. .

Yours faithfully

II ,r,.,:, ~',::-.-".'

~"~'-:'\..." ... '\ . . --.)

Ronan Gilhawley Partner

Page 5: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence

Contents

Glossary

1 Executive summary

2 Background 2.1 Purpose of this report

3 Market overview 3.1 Hearing services market size and drivers 3.2 Competitive dynamics 3.3 Conclusions

Australian Hearing AdvisO/y

September 2012

1

3 3

5 5 8

10

9 Appendix 53

A Methodology and approach 54

B Australian Hearing stakeholder map 56

s.47/47G

Page 6: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence

D Case Studies 0.1 Expansion into the 21-26 year old market: 0.2 Current pilot of CAPO offering

Australian Hearing Advisory

September 2012

66 66 66

s.47/47G

s.47/47G

Page 7: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence

Figures

Australian Hearing Advisory

September 2012

Figure 1: Australian hearing services market, 2008 - 2017 ........................................... 6

Figure 2: Voucher and FFS relative market size and growth (based on devices fitted). 7

Figure 3: Registered hearing service providers and locations, 2000 - 2012 ................. 9

Figure 4: Australian Hearing Profit Before Tax (A$m), 2009-2017 .............................. 12

Figure 5: Australian Hearing Year-End Cash balance (A$m), 2008 - 2017 ................. 13

Figure 6: Australian Hearing dividend to the Government, 2008 - 2017 ..................... 14

Figure 7: Australian Hearing Return on Capital Employed, 2009 - 2017 .................... 14

Figure 11: Australian Hearing governance ................................................................... 36

Figure 12: Governance structures overview ................................................................ 38

Figure 15: methodology and approach ........................................................................ 54

Figure 16: Australian Hearing stakeholder map ........................................................... 56

Page 8: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence

Tables

Australian Hearing AdvisO/y

September 2012

Table 1: Australian hearing services market participants, Nov-09 and Oct-11 ............... 8

Page 9: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence

Glossary

Australian Hearing Advisory

September 2012

Page 10: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence Australian Hearing

AdvisOlY September 2012

s.47/47G

Page 11: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence Australian Hearing

Advisory September 2012

s.47/47G

Page 12: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence Australian Hearing

Advisory September 2012

2 Background Australian Hearing is a statutory authority constituted under the Australian Hearing Services Act 1991. Australian Hearing was established in 1947 in response to the high rate of hearing loss in returning World War II veterans. In 1996, the Government announced the introduction of a voucher system for hearing services, allowing for greater private sector involvement in the provision of Government funded services. In March 1997, the Office of Hearing Service ("OHS") was formally established as a unit within the Department of Health and Aging to manage stakeholders and implement reforms. Since the establishment of Australian Hearing the market for hearing services in Australia has experienced significant growth. This has been accompanied by new market entrants and increasing competition. The majority of the market participants are small local providers with a portfolio of a few locations. Recently, the industry has been going through a period of consolidation as larger international providers and equipment manufacturers try to get a larger exposure to the Australian market.

The Office of Hearing Services recently announced policy changes to the frequency of voucher re-issuance which will reduce the volume of vouchers from January 2012 onwards. Due to demographic, economic and policy changes, the outlook is for the fee­for-service ("FFS") market to grow at a significantly higher pace (-7.1 % p.a. from FY13. to FY17) than that of the voucher (-5.5% p.a. from FY13 to FY16) and the CSO (-2.5% p.a. Government funding growth from FY13 to FY17) markets, both currently serviced by Australian Hearing.3

in 2012, the Government announced the expansion of the CSO program coverage to in·tlude the 21-26 year old population segment. As such, Australian Hearing was provided the exclusive right to service 21 to 26 year old clients, with a corresponding increase in funding to undertake this~

2.1 Purpose of this report

3

s.47/47G

Page 13: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence Australian Hearing

AdvisO/y September 2012

4

s.47/47G

Page 14: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence Australian Hearing

Advisory September 2012

3 Market overview The provision of hearing services in Australia occurs via public (Australian Hearing) and private providers. The Australian hearing services industry allows hearing impaired individuals to access services (excluding cochlear implants) through:

• eso program: individuals meeting the requirements to qualify for eso can receive free services from Australian Hearing, who is the only provider in the eso market. Australian Hearing receives funding from the Government to provide this service.

• Voucher program: pensioners can access free or significantly subsidised services, provided through 208 contracted providers (including Australian Hearing) across 2,344 sites4

. Of these, there are 860 permanent sites; 1,451 visiting sites and 33 remote area sites that are staffed by 1,479 qualified practitioners.

• Fee-for-service ("FFS") market: through the private hearing services market, customers pay for services at full commercial price. Services to the FFS market are provided through all private market participants. Australian Hearing is currently not allowed to participate in this market.

3.1 Hearing services market size and drivers The Australian market for hearing services (the "Australian Market") represents the total revenue generated from assessments, fittings, audiological case management, rehabilitation services and maintenance services, as well as sales of devices, top'::ups and assisted listening devices ("ALDs") to Australian eso, Voucher and FFSmarket customers.5

The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow at -5.8% p.a. from FY13 to FY 17, as illustrated in Figure 1.

It should be noted that estimates of the size and growth in the FFS market,as well as the projected growth in the voucher market, are not readily available. The market size and growth shown below has been estimated by KPMG and then tested with Australian Hearing management, who are of the view that it is reasonable. KPMG undertook a bottom-up market sizing approach and there are no significant variations between KPMG and the Australian Hearing management market estimates.

4 Source: Unpublished OHS data as of30 June 2012. 5 Analysis throughout this document excludes ALD sales due to limited available market information.

5

Page 15: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Australian Hearing

Commercial in Confidence , AdvisO/y September 2012

Figure 1: Australian hearing services market, 2008 - 2017

Actual Hearing Services market structure

FY08A FY17F

869 822 65'

cso II Voucher [[f1 Fee-for-service

Market segments growth

CAGR CAGR CAGR '08-'12 '12-'13 '13-'17

FY08A FY09A FY10A FY11A FY12A FY13F FY14F FY15F FY16F FY17F ,. CSO,'08-'17 CAGR: +4% ~fTI Fee-for-service, '08-'17 CAGR:+7%

1\1 Voucher,'08-'17CAGR:+4%

NOle (a) analysis excludes ALDs Source: ASS, OHS, AHS, Hearing In Adulls - Oavls, 1995, FaHCSIA, A1HW, KPMG Analysis

eso Voucher

FFS

4% 11%

6% (12%)

7% 6%'

The hearing services market in Australia has grown by -6% p,a. from FY08 to FY12, mainly driven by:

2%

5%

7%

.. Ageing population: The prevalence of hearing loss increases exponentially wit.h age. The youngest of the Baby Boomer generation (1946-64) are starting to reach the age at which the prevalence of hearing loss tips above 10%. Currently the prevalence of hearing loss in Australia is estimated to be one in six6

; a figure which . is expected to more than double by 2050 to one in four, driven by the ageing baby -" boomer generation7

.

" Population growth and increased detection: Access Economics estimate the· number of children under 15 identified as having a hearing impairment is likely to .. increase from 10,268 to 11,031 during the forecast period as a result of population growth and increased detection through universal neonatal screening.

Inhibitors to the hearing services market could be technologic innovation and technological changes, which is currently expected to be minimal. There is research being undertaken to find a cure for deafness utilising stem cell technology. 8 If research is successful, the hearing aid market will be negatively impacted. However, such a change is long-term and hypothetical at this stage.

The csa market is completely funded by the government and Australian Hearing is the only eligible provider to the market. The Government funding for csa services has grown steadily at -2% p.a. In 2012, the Government expanded the csa coverage to include individuals between the ages of 21 to 26. The Government provided an additional A$7m spend over FY12 and FY13 to cover the increase in eligibility. This

6 Source: Australian Hearing 7 Source: Deloitte Access Economics Superslim model ". 8 Source: http://nature,com , Restoration of auditory ,evoked responses by human ES-cell-derived otic progenitors

6

Page 16: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence Australian Hearing

Advisory September 2012

additional funding drives the 11 % increase between FY12 and FY13, however growth is expected to return the steady -2% p.a. increase after FY13.

Even though the total hearing services market in Australia is expected to grow, there is a noticeable shift in growth from the Voucher to the FFS market due to:

" Increasing portion of self-funded retirees ineligible for the Voucher Program;

II OHS voucher issuance policy changes: OHS announced re-issuance changes of vouchers, from every 2 years to every 3 years, effective as of 1 January, 2012, Meaning there would be no vouchers issued during the CY14. OHS encouraged market participants to smooth CY 12 and CY 13 return customers oyer the three years from CY12 to CY14. This policy change and voucher life extension from OHS will have a significant impact on the volume of vouchers issued during FY13 and FY14. This is estimated to cause a drop of the voucher market by -15% in FY13, creating excess capacity in the industry and intensifying the competition. After FY15, the voucher market is expected to return to "normal" growth rates which are lower than historical rates due to the increasing portion of self-funded retirees.

As illustrated in Figure 2 below, even though the voucher market is significantly larger than the FFS market, the FFS market is growing at a higher pace and may surpass the voucher market by 2050 (assuming short term projected growth rates continue).

Figure 2: Voucher and FFS relative market size and growth (based on devices fitted)

7.0%

6.0%

~o:: ~ ~ 5.0% frO

4.0%

FFS

Voucher

3.0% -'---,.---,---,.--___ r---,---

3.4% 3.6% 3.8% 4.0% 4.2%

FY.13-17 CAG.R

Note: size denotes the relative market size Interms ofestlmateddevlcesfltted inFY12

As illustrated by the figure above:

• the voucher market is larger than the FFS market and has historically groWn at a faster rate;

• slow growth in the FFS market has been due to the lower frequency at which customers get re-fitted (voucher customers have historically been fitted

7

Page 17: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence Australian Hearing

Advisory September 2012

approximately once every 2 years, while FFS customers typically return less. frequently);

• the increasing number of self-funded retirees in Australia inflate the growth rate for FFS, which, alongside the recent voucher re-issuance policy changes, will lead to the FFS market growing at higher rates than the voucher market after FY13; and

• the FFS's higher rate of conversion from assessment to device fittings, coupled with higher profit margins, establishes a relatively more attractive market in which to compete than the voucher market.

3.2 Competitive dynamics The key sources of competitive advantage in the Australian hearing services market are location (Le. customer convenience) and marketing (Le. customer awareness). As such, many of the market participants seek to increase their geographic footprint.

The hearing services market in Australia is highly fragmented. There are currently 208 registered service providers that service the voucher market and a small number (exact number is unknown) of providers that service only the private market. Even though the market is highly fragmented, it is also highly concentrated with the top six major participants holding a combined market share of -62% outlets, as illustrated by Table 1 below.

AudioOinic 68 86 Hearing Life 45 47 Adelaide DigHal 17 16

Am plifon (Italy) National Hearing 87 118

Australian Hearing (AU Governm ent) 109 111 Wide x (06nmark)

Active Hearing 5 62 Connect Hearing (Switzerland) 40 44 Bay Audio (New Zealand) . 17 32 Zail (AU)

Attune 9 20

9 Source: Australian Hearing and OHS data

8

Page 18: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence Australian Hearing

Advisory September 2012

The number of registered service providers in Australia grew by -5% p.a. from 2000 to 2011, with the number of permanent and visiting sites growing by 9% and 4% p.a. respectively during the same period. Since 2011, the number of permanent sites continued to grow steadily at -7% p.a. to 2012; however the number of registered providers in the market shrank from 220 to 208, as illustrated by Figure 3 below.

Figure 3: Registered hearing service providers and locations, 2000 - 2012

2,500 200 199 196 205 210 Q~ ~ _____ ---- 208';::,

220 z c·

200 g. '" 2,000 c

180 ~. o

160 :::­m 140 <e.

o "" rn

120 CD r3 1,500 .2 '0 ~ 1,000 E

100 ~ 80 ~

:< ::l

Z 500 60 &i" 40· "0

(3 20 5:

O~~~~~~~~~~-=~~~~~~~-=~-=~-=~-=~o ffi 002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012

CAGR CAGR '00-'11 '11-'12

- Number of Registered providers 5% (5%)

Permanent sites 9% 9%

r~;J Visiting sites 4% 4%

Note: Analysis excludes remote sites which were 30 in 2000 and grew to 33 by 2012. Source: OHS, KPMG Analysis

There are two key themes in the Australian hearing services competitive landscape:

" Industry consolidation: key competitors (and international market participants) have been acquiring smaller market participants to create retail conglomerates. This is evident from the recent reduction in registered market participants while ·the total locations continue to exhibit strong growth (as illustrated by Figure 3). ,.

IJ Vertical integration across the value chain: with device manufacturers leveraging existing Australian market access by buying and consolidating smaller local providers. This is evident in Table 1, which illustrates the market entrance and rapid expansion of two mUlti-national hearing aid device manufacturers since 2010; William Demant Holding and Amplifon S.P.A:

• William Demant Holding took over Otix Global Inc. Within Australia, Otix Global develops and sells hearing aids under the brand of Sonic and the Hearing Life distributor network. William Demant's Australian distributor network is branded as AudioClinic. This company is now the largest Hearing Provider in Australia.

• Amplifon S.P.A. acquired 100% of the Australian Group and, National Hearing Care. This company is now the second largest hearing provider in Australia. .

9

Page 19: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence Australian Hearing

Advisory September2012

3.3 Conclusions The overall market for hearing service in Australia is projected to grow at -6% p.·a. from FY13 to FY17.

Recent policy changes caused a decline of -15% in the voucher market in FY13, however the voucher market will return to growth from the rebased lower starting value of FY13. The policy change and resulting market decline in FY13 will create excess capacity in the voucher service providers market.

The FFS market is growing at a significantly faster pace than the voucher market due to the reduction in the proportion of potential customers eligible for a pension and the ability to price services competitively. The FFS market is more attractive than the voucher market due to its higher growth rates, insulation from policy change and better margins.

The overall hearing services market in Australia is highly competitive with strong competition from multinationals and vertically-integrated device manufacturers. Key competitive advantage in the market is location. The total number of outlets in Australia has increas.ed at -9% p.a. from 2000 to 2012; faster than overall market growth which indicates intensifying competition.

10

Page 20: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence Australian Hearing

Advisory September 2012

11

Page 21: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence Australian Hearing

Advisory September 2012

12

s.47/47G

Page 22: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence . Australian Hearing

Advisory September 2012

13

s.47/47G

Page 23: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence Australian Hearing

Advisory September 2012

14

s.47/47G

Page 24: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence Australian Hearing

Advisory September 2012

4.2 Business as usual service levels KPls When reviewing the BAU performance of Australian Hearing under the status quo, there are numerous non-financial KPls that have to be assessed alongside the financial performance. Those KPls were agreed with OHS in the MoU which was renewed in early 2012 and are designed to measure Australian Hearing's ability to service the eso market.

Australian Hearing has been meeting all of its KPls.

15

Page 25: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence Australian Hearing

Advisory September 2012

16

s.47/47G

Page 26: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence Australian Hearing

Advisory September 2012

17

s.47/47G

Page 27: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence Australiall Hearillg

Advisory September 2012

18

s.47/47G

Page 28: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence Australian Hearing

Advisory September 2012

Market outlook

As previously outlined in Section 3, the recent change to the frequency of voucher issuance has lead to a 15% decline in volumes in FY13. The overall mark~t for hearing service in Australia is projected to grow at -6% p.a. from FY13 to FY17. However the FFS market is projected to grow at a faster pace than the voucher market in this period and longer term.

19

Page 29: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence Australian Hearing

. Advisory September 2012

20

s.47/47G

Page 30: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence Australian Hearing

Advisory September 2012

21

s.47/47G

Page 31: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence Australian Hearing

Advisory September 2012

22

s.47/47G

Page 32: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence Australian Hearing

Advisory September 2012

23

s.47/47G

Page 33: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence Australian Hearing

AdVisory September 2012

24

s.47/47G

Page 34: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence Australian Hearing

Advisory September 2012

25.

s.47/47G

Page 35: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence Australian Hearing

Advisory September 2012

26

s.47/47G

Page 36: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence Australian Hearing

Advisory September 2012

27

s.47/47G

Page 37: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence Australiall Hearillg

Advisory September 2012

28

s.47/47G

Page 38: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence Australian Hearing

Advisory September 2012

29

s.47/47G

Page 39: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence Australian Hearing

Advisory September 2012

30

s.47/47G

Page 40: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence Australian Hearing

Advisory September 2012

31

s.47/47G

Page 41: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence Australian Hearing

Advisory September 2012

32

s.47/47G

Page 42: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence Australian Hearing

Advisory September 2012

33

s.47/47G

Page 43: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence Australiall Hearillg

Advisory September 2012

34

s.47/47G

Page 44: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence Australian Hearing

Advisory September 2012

35

s.47/47G

Page 45: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence Australian Hearing

. Advisory September 2012

The governance structure is the mechanism by which the organisation will be directed and controlled. The optimal governance structure is fundamentally determined by the goals and reasons for existence of the organisation. The governance structure guides the organisations regulatory requirements and market competitive behaviour and the roles and relationships between the company's management, its board and other stakeholders.

The organisation governance can mitigate conflict of interests between stakeholders, determine the nature and extent of accountability of management and employees and will impact the organisations economic efficiency.

The current governance structure for hearing services in as provided in Australian Hearing Corporate Plan.

Figure 11: Australian Hearing governance 18

Office of Hearing Services

Australian Hearing Chair and Board of

Directors

Australian Hearing

Minister for Human

Department ofHlIman· . Services

18 Source: Australian Hearing Corporate Plan, 2012/2013-2014/2015.

36

Page 46: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence Australian Hearing

Advisory September 2012

37

s.47/47G

Page 47: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence

Government division

, Maximum ministerial control. Mlnlsterdlctates office holders and sets rigid direction about the entity's functions. Clear application of accountability laws and processes

, More fiexlbility, the work performed may be and has been subject to . rapid alteration by the Government of the day

, Varying levels of ministerial control, with the potential ability to appoint or remove office holders. Minister directs the performance of functions.

, Governing board or executive management structure. Moderate flexibility, as the enabling leglslatbll of a statutory body Is required to be amended to change the body's purposes or structure

, Minimal ministerial control. Minister directs in the performance of functions on general or specific matters. Direction In the actual functions to be performed Is defined In the enabling legislation.

, Requires prlmary legislation, this has less administrative fiexlbility and therefore responsiveness to Government, as well as clear accountability to Parliament through the minister.

Australian Hearing Advisory

September 2012

, No ministerial control. Entity's management responsible for both setting and meeting performance targets

, No administrative flexibility.

, Reports as part of the department , Provides reports to the Minister, the Secretary ora combination of these.

, No mlnlsterlal reporting but must ,No ministerial reporting prepare annual corporate plan, requirements statement of corporate Intent and financial statements.

, Maximum control of the CSO ' Moderate control of the CSO ' Minimal control olthe CSO , No control of the CSO delivery delivery delivery delivery (outside of agreed OHS ___________________________________________________ ~~I:L ________________________________________ _

, Staffing based onthe department, under the Public Service Act.

,. Requires complete Government funding.

, No financial autonomy, financially tight to the relEivantdepartment. Not allowed to hold money In Its own account, to borrow money or to Investment money.

'Role to be performed underthe broader department roles, less transparency on the functionality and less efficiency.

, Not allowed to participate In commercial activities

, Suitable for functions of government that require close ministerial Involvement, direction and responsibility. These Include functions such as budget Implementation, defence. fOIiCY formUlation and Incldento market failure.

, May be staffed under the Public Service Act or have the powerto engage employees on Its own

, Requires complete or partial Government funding

, Varying levels of financial autonomy, with the ability to hold money In Its own account but no ability to borrow money orlnvest money.

, Clearly defined role and function, providing greatertransparency on activities required which may Improve efficiency.

, Can only perform activities that are stated In the legislation.

, Financially part of commonwealth and require an appropriation authority to support expenditures

, Largely reliant on budget funding or raises public money

, Own staffing powers.

, Government doesn't provide significant part of the entity's funding from appropriations

, Legal and financial separation from Commonwealth. Can hold money In Its own account, ratherthan on behalf of Commonwealth. Can borrow and Invest.

, Clearly defined role and function.

, Can have commercial or entrepreneurial focus

, Body operates commercially with Intent to make a profit In a competitive environment, has an entrepreneurial focus

, Clear rational forthe assets not to be owned or controlled by the Commonwealth. Degree of Independence from general policies.

19 Source: Governance Arrangements for Australian Government Bodies, August2005

, Own staffing powers and decisions

, No Govemment funding

, Complete financial autonomy. Can entertransactlon, borrow money and conduct activities without further permissions.

, Complete transparency on the purpose and function

, Independent entity with maximum commercial fiexlbility

, Completely Independent entity that operates with a completely commercial focus and an Intent to maximise profits

38

Page 48: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence Australian Hearing

AdvisolY September 2012

39

s.47/47G

s.47/47G

Page 49: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence Australian Hearing

Advisory September 2012

40

s.47/47G

s.47/47G

Page 50: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence Australiall Hearillg

Advisory September 2012

41

s.47/47G

Page 51: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence Australian Hearing

Advisory September 2012

42

s.47/47G

Page 52: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence Australiall Hearillg

AdvisOlY September 2012

43

s.47/47G

Page 53: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

':".

Commercial in Confidence Australiall Hearillg

Advisory September 2012

44

s.47/47G

Page 54: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence Australian Hearing

:Advisory September 2012

45

s.47/47G

Page 55: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence Australian Hearing

Advisory . September 2012

46

s.47/47G

Page 56: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence Australian Hearing

Advisory September 2012

47

s.47/47G

Page 57: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence Australian Hearing

Advisory September 2012

48

s.47/47G

Page 58: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence Australian Hearing

Advisory September 2012

49

s.47/47G

Page 59: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence Australian Hearing

Advisory September 2012 .

50

s.47/47G

Page 60: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence Australian Hearing

Advisory September 20 J 2

51

s.47/47G

Page 61: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence Australiall Hearillg

Advisory September 2012

52

s.47/47G

Page 62: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence

9 Appendix

Australian Hearing Advisory

September 2012

53

Page 63: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence Australian Hearing

Advisory September 2012

54

s.47/47G

Page 64: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence Australian Hearing

Advisory September 2012

55

s.47/47G

Page 65: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence

B Australian Hearing stakeholder map

Australian Hearing Advisory

September 2012

Outlined below are the relevant Australian Hearing stakeholders which have been taken into consideration, throughout our analysis

Figure 16: Australian Hearing stakeholder map25

Minister for Health and . Ageing

Minister for Human· , Services ..

Office of Hearing Services

Department of Health and Ageing

":-:::'"':\' .;;:,~. . - - .

.... , ..... : .. ~HS ............. , . Chair and Board of

Directors:; .•.. ",C.l

Auditand risk management committee

Australian Hearing research committee

25 Source: Derived from Australian Hearing Corporate Plan.

Department of Human 'Services

Manufacturers & Industry Groups

General Practitioners

(GPs)

Minister for .Finance and . Deregulation

" MPs.& Senators

Department of Veterans'

Affairs

Office for Aboriginal and Torres Strait

Islander Health

56

Page 66: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence Australian Hearing

Advisory September 2012

57

s.47/47G

Page 67: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence Australian Hearing

Advisory September 2012

58

s.47/47G

Page 68: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence Australian Hearing

Advisory September 2012

59

s.47/47G

Page 69: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence Australian Hearing

Advisory September 2012

60

s.47/47G

Page 70: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence Australian Hearing

Advisory September 2012

61

s.47/47G

Page 71: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence Australian Hearing

AdvisolY September 2012

62

s.47/47G

Page 72: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence Australian Hearing

Advisory September 2012

63

s.47/47G

Page 73: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence Australian Hearing

Advisory September 2012

64

s.47/47G

Page 74: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence Australian Hearing

Advisory September 2012

65

s.47/47G

Page 75: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence

D Case Studies

Australian Hearing Advisory

September 2012

It should be noted that the comments in the following case studies have been sourced

from Australian Hearing management and have not been independently verified by KPMG.

0.1 Expansion into the 21-26 year old market: Background: The Government announced an expansion of the CSO offering to include individuals between the ages of 21 to 26 years old.

To facilitate a smooth transition, IT systems had to be expanded to accommodate for this new group, sales and marketing had to be modified to target individuals in the group and capacity had to be planned to be able to accommodate the increase in demand.

66

Page 76: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence Australia1l Heari1lg

Advisory September 2012

67

s.47/47G

Page 77: 14 September 2012 - Services Australia · The total market for hearing services in Australia is currently estimated to be A$729m in FY12 and A$692m in FY13 and it's expected to grow

Commercial in Confidence Australian Hearing

AdvisOlY September 2012

68

s.47/47G