Draw and Motions for the 11th Junior HKSDPSC Tournament at SIS

Preliminaries on May 9th 2015Grand Finals on May 19th 2015

THE DRAW BY ROOMRound 1 ImpromptuReleased at 8.30 am

Round 2 Prepared:THW permit schools to fundraise by selling advertising space on their campuses.

Round 3 Prepared:This House believes football clubs should be held responsible for the behaviour of their fans.

Room PROP OPP PROP OPP PROP OPP1 DGS 1 PLKCKY 1 DGS 1 WYCHK DBS DGS 1

2 HYS 2 GSIS 1 GSIS 1 DBS PLKCKY 2 GSIS 1

3 GSIS 2 IS 1 SPCC 2 IS 1 IS 1 SPSC

4 GHS SPCC 1 WIS SPCC 1 SPCC 1 QES

5 RC1 DGS 2 SIS 2 RC1 RC1 HKA 2

6 SIS 1 YCIS LSC SIS 1 SIS 1 IS 2

7 RC 2 HYS 1 HYS 1 HKA 1 WYK HYS 1

8 IS 2 WYCHK IS 2 YCIS WYCHK PLKCKY 1

9 HKA 2 DBS HKA 2 GSIS 2 GSIS 2 SIS 2

10 SPCC 2 SPSC SPSC DGS 2 DGS 2 SPCC 2

11 PLKCKY 2 SIS 2 GHS PLKCKY 2 YCIS LSC

12 WIS QES QES HYS 2 HYS 2 WIS

13 LSC QC PLKCKY 1 QC QC GHS

14 WYK HKA 1 RC 2 WYK HKA 1 RC 2

SEMI FINAL PREPARED MOTION:

THIS HOUSE WOULD ALLOW THE STATE TO MONITOR ALL SOCIAL MEDIA TO PREVENT TERRORISM

(there will be 12 teams in the semi-finals so if you wanna be a contender, you will be prepping this one as well – don’t be embarrassed on the day by coming with no research. Rules for this one are that you can bring pages of research and cases ready to go for either side – on the day you will be assigned a side randomly)

SCHOOL CODES FOR THIS EVENT – THE DRAWSchool Code on Draw

1

1 Diocesan Boys School DBS

2 Diocesan Girls School DGS 1, DGS 2

3 German Swiss International School GSIS 1, GSIS 2

4 Good Hope School GHS

5 Heep Yunn School HYS 1, HYS 2

6 Hong Kong Academy HKA 1, HKA 2

7 Island School IS 1, IS 2

8 La Salle College LSC

9 Po Leung Kuk Choi Kai Yau School PLKCKY 1, PLKCKY 2

10 Queen's College QC

11 Queen Elizabeth School QES

12 Renaissance College RC1, RC 2

13 St. Paul's Co-educational College SPCC 1, SPCC 2

14 St Paul's Secondary School SPSC

15 South Island School SIS 1, SIS 2

16 Wah Yan College Hong Kong WYCHK

17 Wah Yan Kowloon WYK

18 West Island School WIS

19 Yew Chung International School YCIS

19 Schools, 9 second teams, 28 team event

2

THE DRAW BY TEAMS ALPHABETICALLYImpromptu – released at 8.30

Round 2 prepared:THW permit schools to fundraise by selling advertising space on their campuses.

Round 3 Prepared:This House believes football clubs should be held responsible for the behaviour of their fans.

TEAM(sides of motion)

Round 1Opponent

RM Round 2Opponent

RM Round 3Opponent

RM

DBS(opp/opp/prop)

HKA 2 (prop) 9 GSIS 1 (prop) 2 DGS 1 (opp) 1

DGS 1(prop/prop/opp)

PLKCKY 1 (opp)

1 WYCHK (opp) 1 DBS (prop) 1

DGS 2(opp/opp/prop)

RC1 (prop) 5 SPSC (prop) 10 SPCC 2 (opp) 10

GSIS 1(opp/prop/opp)

HYS 2 (prop) 2 DBS (opp) 2 PLKCKY 2 ((prop)

2

GSIS 2(prop/opp/prop)

IS 1 (opp) 3 HKA 2 (prop) 9 SIS 2 (opp) 9

GHS(prop/prop/opp)

SPCC 1 (opp) 4 PLKCKY 2 (opp) 11 QC (prop) 13

HKA 1(opp/opp/prop)

WYK (prop) 14 HYS 1 (prop) 7 RC 2 (opp) 14

HKA 2(prop/prop/opp)

DBS (opp) 9 GSIS 2(opp)

9 RC 1 (prop) 5

HYS 1(opp/prop/opp)

RC 2 (prop) 7 HKA 1 (opp) 7 WYK (prop) 7

HYS 2(prop/opp/prop)

GSIS 1 (opp) 2 QES (prop) 12 WIS (opp) 12

IS 1(opp/opp/prop)

GSIS 2 (prop) 3 SPCC 2 (prop) 3 SPSC (opp) 3

IS 2(prop/prop/opp)

WYCHK (opp) 8 YCIS (opp) 8 SIS 1 (prop) 6

LSC(prop/prop/opp)

QC (opp) 13 SIS 1 (opp) 6 YCIS (prop) 11

PLKCKY 1(opp/prop/opp)

DGS 1 (prop) 1 QC (opp) 13 WYCHK (prop) 8

PLKCKY 2(prop/opp/prop)

SIS 2 (opp) 11 GHS (prop) 11 GSIS 1 (opp) 2

QC(opp/opp/prop)

LSC (prop) 13 PLKCKY 1 (prop) 13 GHS (opp) 13

QES(opp/prop/opp)

WIS (prop) 12 HYS 2 (opp) 12 SPCC 1 (prop) 4

RC1(prop/opp/prop)

DGS 2 (opp) 5 SIS 2 (prop) 5 HKA 2 (opp) 5

RC 2(prop/prop/opp)

HYS 1 (opp) 7 WYK (opp) 14 HKA 1 (prop) 14

SPCC 1(opp/opp/prop)

GHS (prop) 4 WIS (prop) 4 QES (opp) 4

SPCC 2(prop/prop/opp)

SPSC (opp) 10 IS 1 (opp) 3 DGS 2 (prop) 10

SPSC(opp/prop/opp)

SPCC 2 (prop) 10 DGS 2 (opp) 10 IS 1 (prop) 3

SIS 1(prop/opp/prop)

YCIS (opp) 6 LSC (prop) 6 IS 2 (opp) 6

SIS 2(opp/prop/opp)

PLKCKY 2 (prop)

11 RC 1 (opp) 5 GSIS 2 (prop) 9

WYCHK(opp/opp/prop)

IS 2 (prop) 8 DGS 1 (prop) 1 PLKCKY 1 (opp) 8

WYK(prop/opp/prop)

HKA 1 (opp) 14 RC 2 (prop) 14 HYS 1 (opp) 7

WIS QES (opp) 12 SPCC 1 (opp) 4 HYS 2 (prop) 12

3

(prop/prop/opp)YCIS(opp/opp/prop)

SIS 1 (prop) 6 IS 2 (prop) 9 LSC (opp) 11

ScheduleDEBATING PLAN

Preliminary Rounds

Each team has 3 rounds of preliminary debates before lunch consisting of :

■      One impromptu debate (50 minute preparation time)

■      Two prepared debates (Motions released 2 weeks before tournament)

Quarter-Finals

The top 24 teams will make the break into the Quarter Finals in three divisions: Gold, Silver and Bronze according to position. Positions 1-  8 Gold Quarters, positions 9-16 Silver quarters, 17-24 Bronze Quarters - all after lunch. Teams will have 50 minutes to prepare for an impromptu quarter final motion.

Semi-Finals

The final debate of the day will be 3 levels of semi finals (12 teams involved) and the day will end with 3 sets of grand finalists determined. Teams will have 40 minutes to prepare a motion that was released 2 weeks before the event with the initial draw.

Grand Finals

The Grand Final will be held on May 19th at SIS in 3 divisions between the semi final winners from May 9th.

SCHEDULE

In order to make the Preliminaries day run as smoothly as possible, each team will receive a personalized schedule including assigned room numbers for debates and preparation along with a map of the school on registration on the day. The general schedule is as follows:

8:00 to 8:15am - Arrival and Registration

8:15 to 8:30am - Welcome announcements

8:30 to 9:20am - Round 1 Impromptu Preparation

9:20 to 10:20am - Round 1 Impromptu Debate

10:20 to 11:20am - Round 2 Prepared Debate: THW permit schools to fundraise by selling advertising space on their campuses.

11:20 to 12:20pm - Round 3 Prepared Debate: This House believes football clubs

4

should be held responsible for the behaviour of their fans.

 12:20 to 1:00pm - Lunch

 1:00 to 1:20pm - Announcement for Break and QF motion

1:20 to 2:10pm - QF Impromptu Preparation

2:10 to 3:10pm - QF Impromptu Debate

3:10 to 3:20pm - Announcement for Break and SF positions

3:20 to 4:00pm - SF Preparation (40 minutes)

4:00 to 5:00pm - SF Debate

5:00pm – 5.15pm Announcement for GF motions and positions

5