Upload
truongngoc
View
231
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/30/2017
1
ASHOK LEYLAND, UNIT 1
175, SIPCOT INDUSTRIAL AREA
HOSUR – 635 126 (TN)
CII 18th National Award for Excellence in Energy Management 2017
CII 2017 Energy Award 2
COMPANY PROFILE
Buses Trucks
Light Commercial Vehicles
Defense Vehicles
Power Solution
Ashokleyland Seven Manufacturing Plants in India
Products
Ashokleyland , Hosur unit 1
Resources Hosur-1
Total Area (Acres) 102.58
Plant and Machinery ~ 566 Rs. Cr
Permitted Maximum Demand 6000 kVA
Manpower (Associates +Exe) 832
Trees (no's) 4592
CII 2017 Energy Award
Process
3
AL Energy Policy Energy Improvement
Energy Management Policy
12891153
1038
500
700
900
1100
1300
2015-16 2016-17 2017-18
Kwh per HECU - Hosur, Unit1
Hosur, Unit1 - Key Mile stone
Setting targets for energy reduction and achieving them through Energy Management and regular monitoring.• FY 17 : 10.55% reduction • FY 18 : Target reduction 10%
CII 2017 Energy Award 4
Specific Energy Consumption (SEC) Benchmarking
995 963 1042 962905 909 953
100
300
500
700
900
1100
2016-17 2015-16 2014-15 2013-14
Kwh
/veh
icle
National Bench marking - Kwh per Eq Vehicle
1153 1289
999 10441080 1083 1110 1123956 970
11261209
0
200
400
600
800
1000
1200
1400
2016-17 2015-16 2014-15 2013-14
Internal Bench Marking - Kwh per HECU
Hosur, Unit 1 Ennore Panthnagar
0.730.82 0.77
0.67
0.83 0.83 0.93
0.00
0.20
0.40
0.60
0.80
1.00
2016-17 2015-16 2014-15 2013-14
National Bench Marking % Power cost to Mfg cost
Energy and Cost Bench marking is difficult… Since :
Ashokleyland Nearest Competitor
CII 2017 Energy Award
8/30/2017
5
Energy Management Organization Structure
Monitoring & Reporting- SAP Continual improvement
Improvement activities Awareness thro’ campaigns Promoting involvement
Horizontal deployment Best practices Waste elimination
Self-Calibration System compliances
Energy awareness at the Gemba Level - Deep rooted in the AL culture.
Continuous improvement through Power Cost Management initiatives. Review & Monitoring from Plant Head till Line executive.
CII 2017 Energy Award
• Cloud hosted infrastructure to all manufacturing units can be accessed by any internet enabled devices.
• Effective utilization of internal expertise across all Units.
6
Energy Management – Implementation methodology
ERP –IT Based GEMBA Mpower Programme
Continuous improvements through Small group activity / Cross Functional team. Projects identified & registration is done in the ERP portal. The ideas generated through brainstorming is evaluated and approved by TQM and Process Leader. The idea is then implemented and tracked for consistency & Successful project will be awarded.
CII 2017 Energy Award
7
Energy Management : Review of Reports
Shopwise wise: Reviewed dailyPlant wise: Reviewed daily Shift wise / Component wise (Daily)
Current Power consumption patternDaily • Plant-wise, Aggregate-wise reports circulated to Line Executives & Section Heads
Weekly • Power cost discussed weekly with the respective Sponsors and Process owners.
Monthly•Gap Analysis reviewed by Plant head on monthly basis.• Inter-unit comparison by AL Manufacturing Head in Plant Performance Meets
CII 2017 Energy Award 8
Team work & Motivation
• Best among the best 70 projects selected from Plants and Corporate functions
• Held at BANGALORE
• Hosur 1 team won One ‘Gold’ award in support Service category , One ‘Silver ’ award in support services category and Two ‘Merit’ awards
2014-15• Best among the best 70 projects selected from all
Plants.
• Held at DUBAI between 14-17th Sep15
• Hosur 1 won One ‘Bronze’ award in Manufacturing support services category & One ‘Super Merit’ awards and Four ‘Merit’ awards
2015-16
• Best among the best 72 projects selected from Plants and Corporate functions
• Held at AGRA between 16-19th Oct’16
• Hosur 1 won One ‘Silver’ award in support Service category, One ‘Bronze’ award in Manufacturing category Three ‘Super Merit’ awards and Two ‘Merit’ awards
2016-17
CII 2017 Energy Award
8/30/2017
9
Significant Energy saving Projects – FY14-15
S.no Project Description
Rs In LakhsROI
MonthInvestment Saving /Annum
1Energy regeneration during Engine testing.
… 10.6 …
2Engine testing cycle modification to reduce cycle time & HSD consumption
0 0.70 0
3Energy saving through Programmodification 7nos CNC machines.
0.5 0.5 12
4
Restriction of main air to shop 3 and using portable compressor avoiding wastage of 100cfm/Hour.
0.5 1.6 4
5Energy saving through air circuit modification in 2areas.
0.70 2.60 3
S.no Project Description
Rs In LakhsROI
MonthInvestment Saving /Annum
6Replacement of Power hoist instead of air hoist.
1.5 1.8 10
7Elimination of idle running by circuit modification in 22 SPMmachines.
2.20 38.60 1
8
Energy saving through introduction of VFD and Derating of Motors in 4 machines.
2.70 9.50 3
9
Energy saving through rescheduling of Production plan and optimized usage of Captive Power & TNEB Demand.
3.00 112.2 0
10Energy saving through introduction LED/CFL/T5 lamps in 13areas/650nos.
10.70 6.40 20
CII 2017 Energy Award 10
Significant Energy saving Projects – FY15-16
S.no Project Description
Rs In LakhsROI
MonthInvestment Saving /Annum
1
Energy cost saving through utilization of demand/resource management & power mix 3projects.
3.00 49.7 1
2Energy regeneration during Engine testing.
… 10.0 ….
3Energy saving through boiler steam for canteen plate washing.
0.50 0.80 7.7
4Idle running elimination through set up time reduction
0.50 3.00 2
5Energy saving through introduction LED/CFL/T5 lamps in 9areas/132nos.
1.00 1.10 11.2
S.no Project Description
Rs In LakhsROI
MonthInvestment Saving /Annum
6Energy saving through Pressure regulating valve for compressor running optimization .
0.00 49.7 0.0
7
Energy saving through introduction of VFD and Derating of Motors in 17 machines.
0.00 10.0 0.0
8
Energy saving through Elimination of idle running by circuit modification in 36 machines.
0.50 0.80 7.7
9
Energy saving through incorporation of Mingling valve in airline for compressor running optimization .
0.50 3.00 2
10Kwh Cost reduction through introduction of alternate power source.
1.00 1.10 11.2
CII 2017 Energy Award
11
Significant Energy saving Projects – FY16-17
S.no Project DescriptionRs In Lakhs
ROI Month
Investment Saving /Annum
1Energy regeneration during Engine testing .
0.00 10.00 0
2Energy saving through rough Block weight reduction
0.00 0.04 0
3 Rainwater for Process 0.50 1.70 4
4Energy saving through introduction of VFD and Derating of Motors
2.50 6.00 5
5Energy saving through Heat recovery in screw compressor
3.80 4.40 10
S.no Project Description
Rs In LakhsROI
MonthInvestment Saving /Annum
6Turbo Ventilator for shop ventilation
7.50 13.00 7
7Daylight improvement in Machine shops
8.00 19.50 5
8Energy saving through introduction LED/CFL/T5 lamps in shop floor/Office/Street light
9.70 9.10 13
9Derating of Man cooler to air circulator
11.30 8.10 17
10Introduction of Heat pumps instead of Electrical heaters in High intensive washing M/Cs
24.90 18.90 16
CII 2017 Energy Award 12
#1 Innovative Project
Elimination of Stress Relieving Process in Cylinder Head by introduction of multi-stage milling
Before : After:
Power consumed 38 Kwh / Cy head
2 Rocker Face Rough Milling
3 Combustion Face Rough Milling
4 Rocker Face Finish Milling
5 Combustion Face Finish Milling 1
6 Valve Guide Valve Seat Parent Bore
7 Injector mouth profile forming
8 Valve Guide Valve Seat Insitu Bore
9 Combustion Face Dowel
Stress Relieving in Muffle Furnace
1
1Rocker Face Rough Milling
2Combustion Face Rough Milling
3Combustion Face Semi finish Milling
4Combustion Face Finish Milling 1
5Rocker Face Finish Milling
6Combustion Face Finish Milling 1 & Valve Guide Valve Seat Parent Bore
7Injector mouth profile forming , Valve Guide
valve seat insitu bore & Combustion dowel
Stress Relieving in Muffle Furnace
41,209Number of head / year
13Reduction Kwh / Cy
head
5.33 lakhsSavings in Kwh / year
37.50Cost Saving Rs. In lakhs
By modifying the milling process and introducing semi-finish milling, furnace operation is eliminated.
Power consumed 25 Kwh / Cy head
CII 2017 Energy Award
8/30/2017
13
#2 Innovative Project
Introduction of General purpose CNC route machining using guide pad tooling and multi spindle Honing SPM by replacing conventional SPM route machining.Before : After :
Power consumed 16.4 units Per Block Power consumed 9.5 units Per Block
Head face Dowel
Head finish
Milling Finish BoringLine Bore Honing
Line Bore Honing
Line Bore HoningFinish Boring
Finish Boring
Head Face Dowel & Finish
Milling
Line Bore Finish Boring
Multistage Honing
44,267Number of block / year
6.90Reduction in
Kwh / Cy block
3.05 Total Units
saved / year in lakhs
21.38Cost Saving Rs. In Lakhs
By introducing multi-spindle machines and combining processes in a single machine, energy per component reduced.
CII 2017 Energy Award 14
#3 Innovative Project
Introduction of Tempering in Induction Hardening SPM and eliminated conventional tempering furnace
Before : After :
Power consumed 2.6 units Per Camshaft
Induction Hardening
Tempering Furnace
Straightening Operation
Induction Hardening Tempering
Tempering Furnace
Straightening Operation
Power consumed 1.6 units Per Camshaft
50,587Number of CS / year
1.00Reduction in Kwh per CS
0.51Savings / year Kwh in lakhs
3.54Cost Saving Rs. in lakhs
By combining tempering operation along with hardening process, Eliminated tempering furnace.
CII 2017 Energy Award
15
#4 Innovative Project
HEAT PUMP for Power Intensive washing machines:
Before : After :
No of Engines / year 47573
Reduction / year Kwh 6.34 L
Savings Rs in lakhs 44.39
Investment Rs in lakhs 32.50
Payback in years 1.37
Electric heaters replaced by HEAT PUMP in four washing machines & realized 60% reduction in fluid heating by maintain same tempt & Quality parameters
No of Machines 4
Heating load in KW 72 x 4 = 288
Fluid Tempt in Deg C 52
Kwh per Engine 38.83
Reduction in Kwh NIL
No of machine 4
Heat pump load in KW 10 X 4 = 40
Fluid Tempt in Deg C 52
Kwh per Engine 25.50
Reduction in Kwh 13.33
CII 2017 Energy Award 16
#5 Innovative Project
Waste HEAT RECOVERY from Rotary Screw Compressor
Before : After :
Washing Tempt : 55 Deg CElectrical heaters : 48 KW Units / per Aggregate : 2.01
Heat Exchanger Retrofit unit fixed with
existing air Compressor + piping
31,410Number / year
0.59 Kwh / setReduction
Kwh 0.19 in LUnits saved / year
Rs 1.30 L / YrROI – 2.5 years
Cost Savings
Recovered heat utilized in two washing machines at P15 Engine Assembly
Washing Tempt : 55 Deg CPump : 1 KW Units / per Aggregate : 1.42
CII 2017 Energy Award
8/30/2017
17
#6 Innovative Project
Cylinder Block Casting modifications to optimize casting weight and machining allowance in rough machining
Before : After :
Power consumption in rough machining (13 m/cs) per Cy Block : 12.48 Kwh
Power consumption in rough machining (13 m/cs) per Cy block : 10.91 Kwh
8,200Number of block / year
1.57Reduction Kwh / Cy block
0.13Savings Kwh in lakhs / Yr
0.90Savings Rs in lakhs
Rough casting weight optimized 3% by reducing the stock in specified areas.
CII 2017 Energy Award 18
#7 Innovative Project
SMED Set-up change time reduction in Cy block machining to minimize idle running
Before : After :
Setup change time in 12 m/cs : 300 MinConsumption : 270 Kwh
Position for B-platform
knob
Position for A- platform
Movable guide
Fixed guide
Guide for B-platform Guide for A-platform
Setup change time in 12 m/cs : 12 Min Consumption : 11 Kwh
24No of setup change / Year
259Reduction in Kwh / Change
6,216Kwh savings / year
0.44Savings Rs in lakhs
Idle running of auxiliary equipment minimized during setup change through single minute die change concept (SMED).
CII 2017 Energy Award
19
#8 Innovative Project
Energy saving through Pressure regulating valve
Before : After :
300No of working days
200Reduction in Kwh / WD
0.60Savings in Kwh / year in lakhs
4.20Savings Rs in lakhs / year
High Pressure air converted to low pressure air through pressure regulating valve & unloading of compressors hours minimized.
CII 2017 Energy Award 20
#9 Innovative Project
Energy saving by interconnecting two production lines through ring main distribution
Before : After :
Power consumption / day = 3000 units Power consumption / day = 2700 units
300No of Working days
300Reduction in Kwh / WD
0.9 lakhSavings in Kwh / year
Rs 6.30 LSavings per year
Two Engine Assembly & Machine interconnected with ring main & avoided running of dedicated Air compressor
CII 2017 Energy Award
8/30/2017
21
Elimination of Painting in Engine Assembly by introduction of pre-painted casting without Heat treatment
Before : After :
Casting Red Oxide Painting
Machining Operation
Painting
Engine Assembly
Casting Enamel Painting
Machining Operation
Painting
Engine Assembly
54,000No of Engines / Year
0.60Reduction in Kwh / Engine
0.32Reduction / year Kwh in lakhs
2.27Cost Saving Rs. In lakhs / Yr
In line with change in heat treatment process, Painting operation Eliminated in Engine Assembly
#10 Innovative Project
Power consumption by paint booth: 0.60 Kwh / Engine
Painting Eliminated
CII 2017 Energy Award 22
Reduction of SEC Trend
1013 966
13291207
FY13-14 FY14-15 FY15-16 FY16-17
H Engine: SEC – kWh/HECU
11521000 1026
863
FY13-14 FY14-15 FY15-16 FY16-17
P15: Engine SEC – kWh/HECU
2.552.90
3.20 3.19
FY13-14 FY14-15 FY15-16 FY16-17
Fixed Power: kWh/month in lacs
The increase in FY 15-16 is due to MS 1 renovation , decrease in
volume, increase in Engine R&D activity (BS4) & introduction of
Spare parts warehouse.
9.1 % 15.9%
• More focus on renovation of process manufacturing
• Introduction of Energy Efficient Products
• Lean manufacturing
• Synergy between Production plan & Energy Management
• Total Employee involvement
• Energy cross audits by other plants (Horizontal deployment)
Energy Conservation @ Hosur 1 (Approach adopted)
CII 2017 Energy Award
23
Reduction of SEC – H Engine & P15 Engine
H Engine Production
Lines
P15 Engine Production
Lines
9181013
784
FY14-15 FY15-16 FY16-17
H-Block SEC – kWh/HECU
619
785669
FY14-15 FY15-16 FY16-17
H-Head SEC – kWh/HECU
1467 14411207
FY14-15 FY15-16 FY16-17
H-Engine Assy SEC – kWh/HECU
932 933
816
FY14-15 FY15-16 FY16-17
P15-Block SEC – kWh/HECU
670 669
523
FY14-15 FY15-16 FY16-17
P15-Head SEC – kWh/HECU
691 741614
FY14-15 FY15-16 FY16-17
P15-Engine Assy SEC – kWh/HECU
23% 15% 16%
13% 22% 17%
CII 2017 Energy Award 24
Specific Energy Reduction Trend
11
910
8
0
24
6
8
1012
2013-14 2014-15 2015-16 2016-17
Water KL / HECU20%26
2016
10
0
10
20
30
2013-14 2014-15 2015-16 2016-17
Diesel Litre / HECU
37%Good
13 13 12
8
0
5
10
15
2013-14 2014-15 2015-16 2016-17
Cutting & Hyd Fluids Litre / HECU
33%Good
130109
156 166
0
50
100
150
200
2013-14 2014-15 2015-16 2016-17
Compressed Air Unit / HECU
Increased no of Shifts & Lines
CII 2017 Energy Award
8/30/2017
25
Renewable Energy Sources
Hosur 1 – Shop 1 & 2 (1 MW)
Sh1
Sh2
Roof Top Solar : Shift towards clean, reliable, affordable Electricity
Key Differentiation factors: 1st Major Solar Renewable
Power project. ZERO CAPEX by AL. Existing metallic roof tops
used to generate own power within our premises.
CII 2017 Energy Award 26
Renewable Energy Sources
93
76
55
105
FY13-14 FY14-15 FY15-16 FY16-17
Windmill Energy Utilization – Units in Lacs
Windmill Energy - % contribution to Overall Power
Overall Windmill energy generation in Tamil Nadu reduced in FY15-16 due to evacuation issues
Windmill utilization is up to 48% of total consumption
Expecting 8% Solar Energy contribution in FY’18
87.3, 47%
55.1, 30%
35.7, 19%
7.7, 4%
FY15-16
TNEB WM GCP DG
30.9, 14%104.9, 48%
78.3, 36%
4.5, 2%
FY16-17
TNEB WM GCP DG
Predominant Source is from Green Energy
CII 2017 Energy Award
27
Renewable Energy Sources
Turbo Ventilators in M/C shop – 150 numbers installed Natural light through transparent sheets in M/C shop
Rainwater Harvesting - 500 KL Utilized for Process 9 KL Solar Water Heater for canteen dish washing
CII 2017 Energy Award
P15 M/C shop SH-5 M/C shop
SH-1 M/C shop
Shop2 E Assy
R&D Block
28
GHG Inventorization
Diesel Consumption reduction in Forklift by introducing a Tractor-Trailer arrangement which can hold up to 10 engines & by bringing stores and dispatch areas near to the shop floor
54.7
51.0
48.0
50.0
52.0
54.0
56.0
2015-16 2016-17
Cons
umpt
ion
in K
L
Fork Lift Diesel ConsumptionBefore After
• No .of Buses inducted : 8
• No of two wheelers reduced : 230
• Carbon emission reduction/Annum: 62 MT
Bio Diesel for Canteen BoilerCommon Pooling arrangement for Associates enabled the reduction of number of people
coming in bikes
-73
-161-137
Base Line 13-14 FY14-15 FY15-16 FY16-17
% E
MIS
SIO
N IN
TEN
SITY
RED
UCT
ION
Carbon foot print
6.7%
• HSD procurement minimized
• Cost Saving : Rs 0.50 millions per year
• GHG Emissions Reduction : 80%
• Carbon Neutral Initiatives
CII 2017 Energy Award
8/30/2017
29
Carbon Foot Print
CII 2017 Energy Award
• Increased green coverage from 27% to 30%.• Wind mill Generation increased up to 48 %
ASHOK LEYLAND - CARBON CREDITS / DEBITSCategory 2013-14 2014-15 2015-16 2016-17
Carbon debits: mtCO2e mtCO2e mtCO2e mtCO2eScope 1 Foot print -13-14 base year 2340 2021 1677 1825
Scope 2 Foot print (Electricity purchased) 5632 9899 13892 8063
Scope 1 & 2 Total emissions 7972 11920 15569 9888Carbon Credits:Wind Power 10295 9374 9223 13756Plantation 64 61 70 91KWH reduced through EC projects
396 218 343 358
Total credits earned 10755 9653 9636 14205Net credit / debit wrt Scope1 -8415 -7632 -7959 -12380Net credit / debit wrt Scope1 & Scope2 -2783 2267 5933 -4317
Remarks wrt Scope1 C -ve C -ve C -ve C - veRemarks wrt Scope1 & Scope2 C -ve C +ve C +ve C - ve Carbon negative in terms of
Scope 1 & Scope 2
30
Carbon foot print negative (scope 1 & 2)
Water consumption reduced by 20%
Food wastage reduced by 15%
Green coverage increased from 43.72 to 46.63 Sq.mt
Celebration of, • Earth day celebration• World Environment day • Energy conservation day • World water day
Biodiversity Enhancement
Implementation of Dr. Miyawaki Afforestation
Rainwater Perculation Well
Go Green Initiative
CII 2017 Energy Award
31
Sewage treatment Plant : Treated water to Garden 180 KLD Per day.
Effluent Treatment Plant : Treated water to RO, 25 KLD Per day for Industrial use.
Waste Coolant Recovery : Recovery, Recycle & Reuse of 3 KL of coolant per month.
Utilisation of waste & reuse
CII 2017 Energy Award 32
Waste Recovery trend …
4.00
1.48
2.80
0
2
4
6
2014-15 2015-16 2016-17
Reus
e in
kL
Coolant / Cutting Oil Recovery
3.2
1.5 1.6
1.0
2.0
3.0
4.0
2014-15 2015-16 2016-17
In M
tonn
e
Paint Sludge
48
81 82
0
50
100
2014-15 2015-16 2016-17
In M
T
Oil Soaked Waste
54,339 54,188
56,220
53000
54000
55000
56000
57000
2014-15 2015-16 2016-17
Reus
e in
kL
ETP Water for Garden
6,9007,260
7,467
6500
7000
7500
8000
2014-15 2015-16 2016-17
Re u
se in
KL
Canteen/Drinking RO Reject Reuse
4,350
4,260
4,440
4100
4200
4300
4400
4500
2014-15 2015-16 2016-17
Re u
se in
KL
Industrial RO Reject Reuse
Crusher Digester CookingFood Waste
Canteen Food wastage to Biogas
CII 2017 Energy Award
8/30/2017
33
Horizontal Deployment
Regeneration of Energy during Engine testing – Implemented at PNR & Technical Center (nine test beds completed & six in pipe line).
4.12 MW Roof top solar power plant Horizontally deployed at other four plants & Hosur Management development center.
Heat pumps for power intensive washing machines implemented at other three plants (six no completed & nine no in pipe line).
Elimination of tempering operation: Implemented in Ennore plant through program modification in induction heating.
On line monitoring: Comparing best practices with other plants & implemented Power Quality correction issues, Peak load management & eliminated wastages.
CII 2017 Energy Award 34
Significant Energy saving projects planned in FY 18
Sl.no Description Capex(Rs in L)
Payback in years PDC Remarks
1 Replace Reciprocating air comp by Energy efficient screw comp. 13.75 1 Jul'17 Completed
2 Introduce on line MOTOR ANALYTICS in powerintensive motors like Air comp, blowers & pumps 0.75 … Jul'17 System improvement , Completed in air
compressors
3 Implementation of energy saving products in works office renovation. 10.00 8 Jun'17 Completed
4 Eliminate CH stress relieving process in line 1 60.00 3.50 Sep'17 Work in progress
5 Heat Pump for P15 two ROBO washing machines 18.00 1 Dec'17 Horizontal deployment
6 Heat Recovery from screw compressor 30.00 2 Feb'18 Horizontal deployment
7 Power Quality Improvement at P15 machine shop 24 3 Oct '17 Low cost automation - Maintain PF & harmonics with in limit at load side
8 Introduce Energy efficient AHU, LED & Light pipe at new Engine assembly 30 4 Jan'18 Planned Energy saving products in
Project stage.
9 Replace & optimize 15 years old A/C Units & lighting at MS 5 & Metrology Lab 16 4 Dec '17 To reduce maintenance & operating cost
10 Improve process changes & avoid HT & gear machining in-house. … … Mar’18 Estimated 1500 Units reduction per WD
Total investment planned in FY’18 : 202.50 lakhsTotal investment planned in FY’18 : 202.50 lakhsCII 2017 Energy Award
35
ISO Certifications
TS16949:2009• Our Processes are getting
refined thru TS Standards
• ISO/ TS 16949 is expiring in Oct 2018
• New IATF Standard released by ISO
• This year, We are migrating to New Standard (IATF16949:2015)
• 17nos minor NC logged and resolved in the past 3years.
ISO14001:2015• Revised edition adopted in
2016
• Six major resource conservation projects captured through O & T and completed.
• 14 no OFIs logged during IRQS Audits & resolved in time
CII 2017 Energy Award 36
Accolades
ExternalExternal
InternalInternal
AL – 2014: Silver AwardAL - 2014 : Gold Award AL - 2015 : Bronze Award
CII - 2014 “Energy Efficient Unit” & Innovative Project Awards
2015 –IMTANational Productivity Merit Award
2017- CMO Asia“Asia Best CSR Practices Award”
AL - 2016 : Silver Award
CII - 2015 “Energy Efficient Unit”
CII 2017 Energy Award