Upload
steven-glassman
View
212
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
54S Proceedings of the NASS 24th Annual Meeting / The Spine Journal 9 (2009) 1S-205S
STUDY DESIGN/SETTING: We reviewed a consecutive series of 300
one, two, three or four level instrumented fusions by a single surgeon at
a single institution. One hundred and fifty consecutive cases were con-
ducted in routine fashion with standardized preoperative and postoperative
antibiotic administration. Attention to intraoperative care and detail was
standardized with intraoperative pulsed wound lavage of 3 liters of sterile
saline completed prior to grafting and closure. One hundred and fifty con-
secutive cases were conducted identically save for a three minute wound
lavage of 3.5% betadine solution prior to the 3 liter sterile saline
irrigation.
PATIENT SAMPLE: Three hundred consecutive patients undergoing 1-4
level instrumented posterolateral fusions treated without or with dilute be-
tadine wound lavage as infection prophylaxis.
OUTCOME MEASURES: Demographics, health history and diagnosis
were collected for both groups. Preoperative and postoperative visual ana-
log pain values, ODI values, clinical examinations and work status were
documented.
METHODS: Physical exam and surgery was conducted by one surgeon.
Diagnosis for surgical care included spondylolithesis, degenerative scolio-
sis or flatback and the remainder spondylosis with herniation or stenosis.
Group 1 utilized rhBMP-2 with local bone as the graft material in 64%
cases, while Group 2 utilized rhBMP-2 with local bone in 94% of cases.
In all other cases iliac crest was utilized. Pedicle screw instrumentation
was used in all cases. Routine followup included physical exam, outcomes
evaluations with radiographs and/or CT scans. Statistical analysis of data
was conducted.
RESULTS: Mean age was 57.5 yrs in group 1 vs 55.0 yrs in group 2,
p5.05. Mean followup was 30mos vs 18.2 mos respectively. Mean levels
fused were 1.6 vs 1.7 and was not different between groups. 60.7% were
female in both groups. Mean wt was 192 lbs for both groups. Diabetics
comprised 12.7% of group 1 and 15.3% of group 2. Mean patient comor-
bidities were 2.5 vs 2.1 and not different between groups. In Group 1 stan-
dard prophylaxis yielded a 4.66% infection rate (6 deep/1 superficial)
while Group 2 dilute betadine lavage yielded a 0.66% infection rate with
p5.03. The lone infection in group 2 occurred in an obese diabetic patient
with a grade 2 lytic spondylolithesis. Both groups revealed statistical im-
provement in pre vs postoperative pain scores. Postoperative ODI was 16.8
vs 14.4 and not statistically different between groups. No adverse events
were documented with the use of betadine.
CONCLUSIONS: In this consecutive series, dilute 3.5% betadine lavage
for three minutes yielded superior infection rates compared to standard
care with minimal cost and risk to the patient.
FDA DEVICE/DRUG STATUS: BMP-2 Posterolateral Use: Investiga-
tional/Not approved.
doi: 10.1016/j.spinee.2009.08.127
104. Complications with rhBMP-2 in Posterolateral Spine Fusion:
886 Consecutive Cases
Steven Glassman, MD1, Jennifer Howard, MPH1, John Dimar, II, MD1,
John Johnson, MD1, Alexander Sweet, BS2, Greg Wilson, BS2,
Leah Carreon, MD, MSC1; 1Leatherman Spine Center, Louisville, KY,
USA; 2University of Louisville School of Medicine, Louisville, KY, USA
BACKGROUND CONTEXT: Bone Morphogenetic Protein (BMP) is
widely used as an ICBG substitute for posterolateral spine fusion (PSF).
While this application has been extensively studied in IDE trials and clin-
ical series, the serious complications reported for anterior cervical usage
have raised new concerns regarding potentially unidentified risks for
PSF as well. As complications are often reported in isolation, without
a clear denominator, actual complications rates may be difficult to
determine.
PURPOSE: To characterize perioperative complications and complication
rates in a large consecutive series of posterolateral spine fusion procedures
with rhBMP-2.
STUDY DESIGN/SETTING: Retrospective review of a consecutive
series.
PATIENT SAMPLE: 886 patients (547 females, 339 males), mean age
58.5 (19 to 90) years.
OUTCOME MEASURES: Observed complications.
METHODS: We reviewed inpatient and outpatient medical records for
a consecutive series of 886 patients who underwent PSF using rhBMP-2
between 2003 and 2006. Patients undergoing interbody fusion were ex-
cluded. Complications observed within a 3 month perioperative interval
were categorized as to etiology and severity. Wound problems were delin-
eated as wound infection, hematoma/seroma or persistent drainage/super-
ficial dehiscence. Neurologic deficits and radiculopathies were analyzed to
determine the presence of a clear etiology (screw misplacement) and to
identify any potential relationship to rhBMP-2 usage.
RESULTS: One or more complication or adverse event was observed in 168
of 886 patients (19.0%) during the 3 month perioperative period. Major com-
plications were reported in 79 patients (8.9%) and minor complications in 88
patients (9.9%). Major medical complications were pulmonary (19), cardiac
(7), renal (3) or other (5). Major surgical complications included deep wound
infection in 19 patients (2.1%) and hematoma with negative cultures in 8 pa-
tients (0.9%). Neurologic complications were related to screw malposition in
4 patients and epidural hematoma in 2 patients. New or more severe postop-
erative radicular symptoms were noted in 9 patients (1.1%). Psoas hematoma
was identified by CT scan in 8 patients (0.9%), and in 1 case was accompa-
nied by severe pain and reactive changes on MRI scan as previously seen with
osteolysis related to interbody BMP reactions.
Table. Summary of Complications.
CONCLUSIONS: This study analyzes a consecutive series of 886 patients
treated by posterolateral spine fusion using rhBMP-2 and reports a modest
complication rate consistent with literature standards for posterolateral fu-
sion with ICBG. In particular, the high incidence of wound edema or
swelling noted in anterior cervical spine fusion was not observed. Simi-
larly, the incidence of postoperative radiculopathy was only 1% suggesting
that BMP related radiculopathy, as reported with TLIF, does not occur with
rhBMP-2 in posterolateral fusion. Importantly, this large consecutive series
study design facilitates a reasonable determination of expected complica-
tion rates by providing an adequate denominator. Overall, this study dem-
onstrates a relatively low complication rate for posterolateral fusion using
rhBMP-2, and gives no indication of specific BMP related complications
with this application.
FDA DEVICE/DRUG STATUS: rhBMP-2 for Posterolateral Fusion: In-
vestigational/Not approved.
doi: 10.1016/j.spinee.2009.08.128