Upload
katification
View
220
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
7/29/2019 101717414 S15 Comparison of Satipatthana Contents 5 1 4
1/20
SatipahnaMaterials
Ajahn SujtosScrutiny of
Vibhaga Dharmaskandha riputrbhidharma
Ekyana Stra
Smtyupasthna StraSatipahna Sutta
Prajpramita Stra
Four
gamas
Other BuddhistSources
Five
NikyasPre-Buddhist
Sources
7/29/2019 101717414 S15 Comparison of Satipatthana Contents 5 1 4
2/20
2
Concordance of the 7 main texts
Internal coherence of material
Intertextual relationship with the rest ofthe scriptures
Cultural & philosophical contexts at the
Buddhas time Evolution of sectarian positions
Based on
7/29/2019 101717414 S15 Comparison of Satipatthana Contents 5 1 4
3/20
3
That the Satipahna Sutta (MN 10)
is not an authentic discourse of the Buddha,
but a padded up discourse, with passages copied and pasted from
other discourses,
showing a sectarian bias towards pure
vipassan practice.
Suggests
7/29/2019 101717414 S15 Comparison of Satipatthana Contents 5 1 4
4/20
4
DetailsA History of
MindfulnessHow insight worsted tranquility in
the Satipatthana Sutta
By Bhikkhu Sujato
7/29/2019 101717414 S15 Comparison of Satipatthana Contents 5 1 4
5/20
5
Comparing contents ofSatipahnain the 7 major texts
Vibhaga Dharmaskandha riputrbhidharma
Ekyana Stra
Smtyupasthna StraSatipahna Sutta
Prajpramita Stra
7/29/2019 101717414 S15 Comparison of Satipatthana Contents 5 1 4
6/20
6
Vi Vibhaga
Dh Dharmaskandha
riputrbhidharma
EkEkyana StraSS Smtyupasthna Stra
PS Satipahna Sutta
Pr Prajpramita Stra
Pli Tradition
Sarvstivda
Dharmaguptaka
Pli Tradition
SarvstivdaMahsaghika
Mahsaghika
Intro to Texts & SchoolsText School
7/29/2019 101717414 S15 Comparison of Satipatthana Contents 5 1 4
7/20
7
4 postures
Clear knowing
Cut off thoughts
Suppress thoughts
Breathing4 jhna similies
Perception of light
1a. Contemplation of BodyVi Dh
1
2
3
PS
2
3
1
SS
1
2
3
4
5
Ek Pr
1
2
3
7/29/2019 101717414 S15 Comparison of Satipatthana Contents 5 1 4
8/20
8
Basis of reviewing
Parts of body
Elements
Food
SpaceOozing orifices
Charnel ground
1b. Contemplation of BodyVi
1
Dh
1
26
4
54
6
78
9
SS
6
7
86
9
Ek
1
24
3
4
Pr
4
54
PS
4
54
6
7/29/2019 101717414 S15 Comparison of Satipatthana Contents 5 1 4
9/20
9
Pleasant/painful/neutral
Bodily/mentalCarnal/spiritual
Sensual/not
No mixed feeling
2. Contemplation of FeelingsVi
1
2
Dh
1
23
4
1
2
PS
1
2
SS
1
23
4
Ek
1
2
Pr
7/29/2019 101717414 S15 Comparison of Satipatthana Contents 5 1 4
10/20
10
With/w/o lust
With/w/o anger
With/w/o delusion
Defiled/undefiled
With/w/o affection
3a. Contemplation of MindVi
1
2
3
Dh
1
2
3
1
2
3
PS
1
2
3
SS
1
2
3
4
Ek
1
2
3
45
6
Pr
With/w/o attainment
With/w/o confusion
7/29/2019 101717414 S15 Comparison of Satipatthana Contents 5 1 4
11/20
11
Contracted/scattered
Slothful/energetic
Universal/not
Exalted/unexalted
Small/great
3b. Contemplation of MindVi
4
5
Dh
4
5
6
4
5
6
PS
4
5
6
SS
4
5
6
Ek
4
5
6
7
Pr
Surpassed/not
Lower/higher
7/29/2019 101717414 S15 Comparison of Satipatthana Contents 5 1 4
12/20
12
Developed/not
Distracted /not
Quiet/not
Composed/not
Released/not
3c. Contemplation of MindVi
6
7
Dh10
7
8
9
11
7
8
PS
7
8
SS7
8
9
Ek
8
9
Pr
7/29/2019 101717414 S15 Comparison of Satipatthana Contents 5 1 4
13/20
13
5 Hindrances
5 Aggregates
6 Sense bases
7 Awakeningfactors
4 Jhnas
4. Contemplation of DhammasVi1
2
Dh1
2
3
1
2
3
4
PS1
2
3
4
5
SS1
2
3
Ek1
2
3
Pr
4 Noble truths
7/29/2019 101717414 S15 Comparison of Satipatthana Contents 5 1 4
14/20
14
Internal/external
Tribulations
Arising/vanishing
Knowledge
Independance
5. RefrainVi1
Dh1
2
1
2
3
4
5
PS1
2
3
4
SS1
2
Ek1*
2
3
45
Pr1
2Arahantship
7/29/2019 101717414 S15 Comparison of Satipatthana Contents 5 1 4
15/20
15
TribulationsObserves and contemplates all their many tribu-lations, namely: this body (etc.) is like a sickness,like a boil, like a dart, troublesome, impermanent,suffering, empty, not-self, changing, wearisome,a great entanglement. It is of a nature to be lostand to decay, rapidly and incessantly becoming
weak, not enduring. It cannot be relied on ortrusted. It is of a nature to change and decay.
At the end of each anupassan
Trans. Bhikkhu Sujato
7/29/2019 101717414 S15 Comparison of Satipatthana Contents 5 1 4
16/20
16
Structure of Satipahna Mla
definition
proclamationabstract
Based on Bhikkhu Sujtos A History of Mindfulness
7/29/2019 101717414 S15 Comparison of Satipatthana Contents 5 1 4
17/20
17
Definition in Mla body as body feelings as feelings
mind as mind dhammas as dhammas
Repeated contemplation of...
being ardent clearly knowing being mindful
having subduedlonging & dejection
in (regard to) the world
internally, externally, both internally
& externally while
7/29/2019 101717414 S15 Comparison of Satipatthana Contents 5 1 4
18/20
18
Structure of Satipahna Mla
31 body partsdefinition
proclamation
refrainbody
abstract
Based on Bhikkhu Sujtos A History of Mindfulness
7/29/2019 101717414 S15 Comparison of Satipatthana Contents 5 1 4
19/20
19
Refrain in Mla Is mindful for the sake of
knowledge & visionthat
there is/are a body,feelings, mind, dhammas
Is independent, & does
not cling to anything in
the world.
7/29/2019 101717414 S15 Comparison of Satipatthana Contents 5 1 4
20/20
20
Structure of Satipahna Mla
31 body parts
mind
definition
feelings
7 awakening factors
5 hindrances
prediction
proclamation
refrainrefrain
body dhammas
abstract conclusion
Based on Bhikkhu Sujtos A History of Mindfulness