15
1. Is terrorism significant for IR? 2. Prescriptions on counteracting terrorism. 3. Distinguishing what globalization is and how significant.

1. Is terrorism significant for IR? 2. Prescriptions on counteracting terrorism. 3. Distinguishing what globalization is and how significant

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: 1. Is terrorism significant for IR? 2. Prescriptions on counteracting terrorism. 3. Distinguishing what globalization is and how significant

1. Is terrorism significant for IR?2. Prescriptions on counteracting

terrorism.3. Distinguishing what

globalization is and how significant.

Page 2: 1. Is terrorism significant for IR? 2. Prescriptions on counteracting terrorism. 3. Distinguishing what globalization is and how significant

Has world politics Has world politics fundamentally changed?fundamentally changed?

Page 3: 1. Is terrorism significant for IR? 2. Prescriptions on counteracting terrorism. 3. Distinguishing what globalization is and how significant

Except 2001, more Americans killed by lightning or drowning in toilets than by terrorism. (Mueller)

Until terrorism hit US, no thought that IR theories had to change to account for terrorism.

Need to redefine actors, threats, definition of security in theories?

Page 4: 1. Is terrorism significant for IR? 2. Prescriptions on counteracting terrorism. 3. Distinguishing what globalization is and how significant

At least 4 suggested approaches: Approach 1 broadly compatible

with realism. Approach 2 less clearly linked to

debates among IR theories. Approach 3 taken from

bureaucratic politics/ organizational process.

Approach 4 suggested by postcolonial theory.

Page 5: 1. Is terrorism significant for IR? 2. Prescriptions on counteracting terrorism. 3. Distinguishing what globalization is and how significant

Pursue and eliminate groups with military action.

Do not bargain with terrorists and they will give up.

Military response especially needed when terrorists have no demands (common today).

Page 6: 1. Is terrorism significant for IR? 2. Prescriptions on counteracting terrorism. 3. Distinguishing what globalization is and how significant

Takes a long time but effective in finding and destroying terrorists.

Need reform & strengthening of counterterrorist intelligence. (Hoffman)

Need strengthening of homeland border security. (Pape)

Military campaigns increase hostility from countries where terrorists based.

Page 7: 1. Is terrorism significant for IR? 2. Prescriptions on counteracting terrorism. 3. Distinguishing what globalization is and how significant

Strike level of terrorist groups: groups motivated NOT by external goals but by need to sustain organization.

Don’t try to eliminate groups by force or erect defenses.

Solution to prevent people from joining groups and give incentives to leave.

Page 8: 1. Is terrorism significant for IR? 2. Prescriptions on counteracting terrorism. 3. Distinguishing what globalization is and how significant

View of “us” vs “them” and linkage of Islam to terrorism is a cultural construction born from particular history.

We tend to view Islamic fundamentalism as “premodern”, while it is specifically modern political project.

Need to resolve by addressing root political issues directly – retreat from imperialist projects in Middle East.

Page 9: 1. Is terrorism significant for IR? 2. Prescriptions on counteracting terrorism. 3. Distinguishing what globalization is and how significant

GLOBALIZATION

Page 10: 1. Is terrorism significant for IR? 2. Prescriptions on counteracting terrorism. 3. Distinguishing what globalization is and how significant

WHAT DO WE MEAN BY “GLOBALIZATION”?

Globalization: “entrenched and enduring patterns of worldwide interconnectedness” (Held & McGrew).

Distinct from random encounters.

Page 11: 1. Is terrorism significant for IR? 2. Prescriptions on counteracting terrorism. 3. Distinguishing what globalization is and how significant

MODERN CHARACTER OF GLOBALIZATION

Since WWII, communication & transportation technology improved dramatically connecting groups, institutions, states in new ways.

World is smaller and faster. Brings both benefits & harm to actors.

Page 12: 1. Is terrorism significant for IR? 2. Prescriptions on counteracting terrorism. 3. Distinguishing what globalization is and how significant

GLOBALIZATION: ECONOMIC, POLITICAL, CULTURAL

1. Economic: Trade, capital flows, MNCs, macroeconomic policy

decisions. 2. Political:

International law & regional institutions governing world.

Transborder military/ political problems. Institutions, ideas (democracy, HR).

3. Cultural: Homogenization of world culture?

Page 13: 1. Is terrorism significant for IR? 2. Prescriptions on counteracting terrorism. 3. Distinguishing what globalization is and how significant

GLOBALIZATION: ECONOMIC, POLITICAL, CULTURAL

3 dimensions of globalization operate with different patterns and speeds.

Varying configurations in different places.

Page 14: 1. Is terrorism significant for IR? 2. Prescriptions on counteracting terrorism. 3. Distinguishing what globalization is and how significant

SKEPTICS:IS GLOBALIZATION NEW? NO

In previous centuries, world has been as globalized as now in many ways.

16th C onward: trade & cultural diffusion. Underlying argument: we are historically

myopic. 1930s-1970s may have been anomaly.

Page 15: 1. Is terrorism significant for IR? 2. Prescriptions on counteracting terrorism. 3. Distinguishing what globalization is and how significant

SKEPTICS:IS GLOBALIZATION INEVITABLE? NO

1. Realists: globalized economic and social relations created by preferences of powerful states.

Hegemon needed to support open economy.

2. Marxists: globalization is ideological construction to legitimize neoliberal capitalist project.