1

Week 2: Congress1. Essay Feedback and work at home2. 20 mins: Q and A summary & Mind map

Update: Supreme Court3. 20 mins: Revision: What is Congress and

its functions? 4. 20 mins: The Powers and Importance of

Congress: Analysis (essay discussion content) PP lecture with worksheet

5. 15 mins: Essay Planning with q and a 6. 25 mins: Timed Essay7. 5 mins: Homework: Essay 2 (Congress)

and Revision activity

2

20 mins: Mindmap update

Return to your mind map and update: Supreme Court

Constitution Congress The Presidency Elections Political Parties and Pressure Groups Judiciary

3

20 mins What is Congress?

Complete the worksheet’ Roles and Functions of Congress’

For Homework: Complete the remaining questions

4

The Powers and Importance of Congress

Powers/ Strengths: Has power to ‘coin money’ Different houses have different powers Senate –ratify treaties, try cases of impeachment ,elect

vice president if deadlock in electoral college House of Reps: initiate money bills, impeachment (e.g: Bill

Clinton, 1998, 3 federal judges, 1980’s) elect president if electoral college is deadlocked. (only been used twice in 1820/1824)

Bill Clintons Impeachment (See article on gun law reform, Obama)

Both houses pass legislation, over ride presidents veto, initiate amendments to constitution, declare war, confirm new vice president. In 2006, Donald Rumsfeld resigned. Bush had to get approval of senate to appoint Gates

5

Both houses are co equal: both pass legislation, all bills pass both houses.

Can over ride presidents veto by 2/3rs majority (e.g: in 2007, Congress over rode Bushs water resources bill)

Can approve constitutional amendments by 2/3rds majority Both houses must agree on declaration of war (only five times,

last: 1941 –WW2 against Japan) Both Houses are clearly ‘separate’ unlike British system* Serve set times, unlike British MP’s (house -2 rs, senate -6)

Senate as more Powerful?

Bennett (2009) Mckay (2010) Argue that the senate can be seen as more powerful and prestigious than the House of Reps………

Senators represent the entire state Senators serve longer terms Only 100 senators More likely to chair a committee or hold leadership position

6

Senators get more media and global recognition (Obama, pre election)

Seen as recruiting pool for vice/presidents (16 presidents were senators inc: Nixon, Truman, Johnson, Obama)

*Clinton was a State Governor, before becoming President

House members frequently to get elected to Senate Have exclusive powers (ratify foreign treaties, global

powers, try cases of impeachment)

Not as powerful? (Nader, 2002) Both houses have equal legislative power Both houses approve constitutional amendments Both house members have equal salaries * Senate members lose seats easily, have to satisfy local

vote to get re elected, house members are re elected more

7

Congress Weaknesses:

Some powers are vague ‘to provide for general welfare of the US’

Congress is often in a state of ‘gridlock’ in US system like a ‘tug of war’. If houses are dominated by one party, at loggerheads with President and each party due to equal legislative powers (see tug of war clip).

Does not allow for radical politics like UK (ie: Welfare reforms, 1945)

Tug of War

(UK is less gridlocked as commons initiates legislation) Ex: Obama Health Care Bill was blocked by Congress ,

took to supreme court and upheld.* (see handout) However, US has had periods of radicalism (1970’s,:

Abortion, civil rights movement)

8

Current Party Political Composition of Congress

How could the current composition of congress cause problems for Barack Obama?

113th

2013–2015

100 53 45 2 — 435 201 234 — —

Congress

Years

Total

Democrats

Republicans

Others

Vacancies

Total

Democrats

Republicans

Others

Vacancies

President

Senate House of Representatives

9

Majority party redraws electoral boundaries to congress to gain power/seats (similar to Labour, UK, pre 97) ‘Gerrymandering’

Most members of congress have been white, mid class. Only recent increase in women (Democrats) & ethnic minorities

Members not representative: mostly lawyers Have a whip system similar to UK 20th Century been a growth in committees:

fewer people for pressure groups to lobby * Public Opinion, party pressure and pressure

groups mean few bills are passed (static , gridlock system)

Noam Chomsky (2011) argues ‘Congress is controlled by pressure groups not voters ’

10

Essay ‘25 mins’ 25 marks

1. Media Search: Find examples to use in this essay, add to diary

2. Essay: Outline and discuss what is meant by ‘gridlock’ in

the US Congressional System. (25 mins)

1. Intro: Outline the functions of the supreme court (2-4 mins)

2. Discussion: Outline what is meant by gridlock. Discuss different roles of house/senate. Powers of senate and congress. Strengths and weaknesses.

3. Include examples and one from your media diary 4. Conclusion: Summarise key arguments, comparisons

with UK. Decide what argument to finish on, Stay objective in tone!

11

Homework1. Essay:

Members of Congress are more concerned with local issues than with national or

international issues.’ Discuss How significant is the role of political parties within Congress? (25 marks, 25 mins)

2. Complete a chart outlining powers and merits of congressional system, versus criticisms, add examples

3. Update your media diary 4. Make sure you finish the worksheet on

‘Congress Roles and Functions’