1

Dark Matter in Galaxies

Ken Freeman Research School of Astronomy & Astrophysics, ANU

and UWA

UWA: August 14, 2008

2

The Milky Wayas seen from

the sun

NGC 4565: an edge-on spiral

(see the flat rotating disk and the central bulge)

3

There is a very important component that cannot be seen at all

How do we know it is there ? Almost all galaxies have a dark halo .... we see its gravitational effect on their rotation curves ...

For example

Rotation at large radiiis much faster than canbe understood from thegravitational field of thestars and gas alone.

the dark halo

4

For stars and gas moving around a circle of radius R withvelocity V, the inwards acceleration is V2 / R

Where does this acceleration come from in a galaxy ? it needs a force = mass x acceleration

The force is the force of gravity, so measuring the rotation speed V and the radius R tells us directly how strong the gravitational force is at radius R

5

The ratio of dark mass to stellar mass is typically about 20: 1

We now know that the halos extend 5 to 10 times further out that the disks of these galaxies

6

The discovery of dark matter in galaxies in the 1970s led to the current ideas about how galaxies form from dark matter and gas in the early universe

Early in the life of the universe, the distribution of matter was fairly smooth, with very small random fluctuations in density.

These fluctuations grew under the influence of gravity: small objects merged to form larger objects in a hierarchy of merging

The dark matter on galactic scales needs to be cold (movingslowly relative to the expansion of the universe) in order to condense into galaxy-sized dark halos

It is called Cold Dark Matter or CDM

7

Dark Matter in Galaxies

We believe that galaxies formed through a hierarchyof merging. The merging objects were a mixture ofbaryonic (ordinary matter) and dark matter.

The dark matter settled into a roughly spherical halo while the baryons (in disk galaxies) settled into

a flat rotating disk and central bulge

• What can we learn about the properties of dark halos ? • Do the properties of dark halos predicted by simulations correspond to those inferred from observational studies ?

8

Start by showing a numerical simulation of galaxy formation.

The simulation summarizes our current view of how a disk galaxylike the Milky Way came together from dark matter and baryons,through the merging of smaller objects in the cosmologicalhierarchy.

MOVIE

9

Simulation ofgalaxy formation

• cool gas • warm gas • hot gas

QuickTime™ and aMicrosoft Video 1 decompressorare needed to see this picture.

10

halo

The stars and the gas together do not provide enough gravity toexplain the rotation: we need the extra gravity of the dark halo

Reminder: in spiral galaxies ...

11

The cusp-core problem

CDM simulations consistently produce dark halos that are very dense (cusped) at the center

Near the center, where the radius r is small, the densitygoes like

so the density gets larger and larger as r gets smaller and smaller

Some problems ...

QuickTime™ and a decompressor

are needed to see this picture.

12

If the halo density gets so high near the center of real galaxies, then it will have

an effect on the shape of the rotation curves: the rotation curves would rise very steeply near the center

Do we see such an effect ?

No - most galaxies do not show such steeply rising densitiesnear their centers.

Here is an example: the nearby galaxy NGC 6822 - it is very close to us, so we can study its rotation curve in fine detail with the radio telescopes, using its neutral hydrogen (HI)

13

Near infrared imageof this

Local Group galaxy

NGC 6822

14

High spatialresolution

observationsof the nearby

galaxyNGC 6822

Weldrake et al 2002

rota

tion

al v

eloc

ity

(km

/s)

0 1 2 3 4 radius (kpc)

The rotationcurve risesgently nearthe center.

This is what we usually see

(a kpc is about 3000 light years or 3.1016 km)

15

What is wrong ? Real galaxies don’t have central cusps like the simulations

Yes - the density distribution of the dark halos provides a potentially critical test of the CDM theory on galaxy scales

Does it matter ?

16

Maybe CDM is wrong.

Alternatively ...

There are ways to convert CDM cusps into flat central cores so that we do not see the cusps now ...

17

For example ...

Bars are very common in disk galaxies - about 70% of diskgalaxies (including our Galaxy) show some kind of central bar structure when we image the galaxies in the near-infrared.

18

The nearby spiral galaxy M83 in blue light (L) and at 2.2 (R)

The blue image shows young star-forming regions and is affectedby dust obscuration. The NIR image shows mainly the old stars andis unaffected by dust. Note how clearly the central bar can be seenin the NIR image

19

Weinberg & Katz (2000) proposed that the gravitationaleffect of a rotating bar in the inner halo can remove a central cusp in ~ 1.5 Gyr (the age of the universe is about 13.7 Gyr). This idea is controversial.

radius / (bar radius)

dens

ity

20

Current belief is that halos probably do form with cusps, but the cusp structure is flattened by the action of a bar or by gas being suddenlyblown out of the inner galaxy by a burst of starformation. (This consensus keeps everyone happy but is still very uncertain)

21

In simulations of galaxy formation, the halos are quite lumpy, with a lot of substructure - simulations predict a lot more satellites and dwarf galaxies than observed.

From simulations, we would expect a galaxy like the Milky Way to have ~ 500 satellites with masses > 108 M.These are not seen optically or in HI - we see about 40.

What is wrong ?

Could be a large number of baryon-depleted dark satellites, or some problem with details of CDM

Dark Halo Substructure problem

22

CDM simulations of dark halos give

too many small sub-halos

relative to the numbersof observed

small galaxies

B. Moore

23

Moore et al 1999 showed the similarity of dark halos on different scales - clusters, large galaxies, small galaxies -note the substructure in the halos

24

More satellites of the Milky Way are being found gradually, with deeper wide-area imaging surveys. But it seems unlikelythat another ~ 400 will turn up.

A few years ago, we made a survey in neutral hydrogen of the southern sky, using the Parkes radio telescope. We expectedto find many galaxies which had just dark matter and gas (no stars). They would be candidates for the "missing" satellites. But we did not find a singleone - every galaxy that had hydrogen also had starlight. Not sure why these star-less galaxies don't exist, but they don't !

25

An alternative to dark matter is that Newton's inverse square law of gravity is not quite right. Why should that be - it is well tested in the solar system and seems to work ?

halo

Yes, but the acceleration in galaxies is very low: it is about 100,000 times lower than the accelerationthat Pluto experiences as it goes around its orbit.

Newton's law has not been tested at such low acceleration.Maybe it does not work so well. How would we have tochange Newton’s law to make galaxies rotate like this without needing dark matter ?

26

halo

The acceleration needed to go around a circle of radius Rat velocity V is V2/R. From Newton's law, the gravitationalacceleration due to a mass M is M/R2, so V2/R M/R2

and V 1/R like the (stars + gas) curve below

Milgrom (1984) postulated that the force law changes at thevery low accelerations which we see in galaxies. He proposed that the acceleration changes from M/R2 to M/R at low acceleration. Then V2/R M/R and V would be approximatelyconstant with radius (like the observed rotation below)

His idea (MOND) now has a soundtheoretical framework. This does notmean it is right, but so far it has been impossible to prove MOND wrong. Because of the problems with CDM, morepeople are starting to take MOND seriously

27

How large and massive are the dark halos of large spirals like the Milky Way ?

Flat rotation curves mean that the mass of thegalaxy increases linearly with radius: M(R) R

For the Milky Way, the mass out to a radius ofR kpc is about 1010 x R M out to at least50 kpc.

This cannot go on for ever - the halo mass would be infinite.Halos must have a finite extent and mass - how large are they ?

28Rotation of the Galaxy: Merrifield (1992)

29

M31 (Andromeda) is now approaching the Galaxy at 118 km s-1. Its distance is about 750 kpc. Assuming their initial separation

was small and the age of the universe is 13.7 Gyr, we can estimate a lower limit on the total mass of the

Andromeda + Galaxy system.

The Galaxy’s share of this mass is (13 2) x 1011 M

A similar argument using the Leo I dwarf at a distance of about230 kpc gives (12 2) x 1011 M.

Timing argument

30

118 km s -1

M31

Milky Way

The stellar mass is about 6 x 1010 M, so the ratio of dark to stellar mass is ~ 20

M31 and the Milky Way are nowapproaching at 118 km s -1. Theirseparation is about 750 kpc

(Kahn & Woltjer 1959)

To acquire this velocity of approach in the life of the universe means that

the total mass of the Milky Way is at least 120 x 10 10 M.

The dark halo extends out to at least 120 kpc, far beyond the disk's radius of ~ 20 kpc

31

This radius (120 kpc) is much larger than the extent of any directly measured rotation curves, so the

“timing argument” gives a realistic lower limit onthe total mass of the dark halo.

For our Galaxy, the luminous mass (disk + bulge) is about 6 x 1010 M

The dark halo mass is at least 120 x 1010 M

The ratio of total dark mass to stellar mass is then at least 120/6 = 20

32

The dark halo of our near neighbour,

the Andromedagalaxy M31, issimilar to the halo of the Milky Way

Its halo mass is also at least 120 x 1010 M,

similar to the Galaxy

33

Carignan et al 2006

M31 has a flat rotation curve out to a radius of about 35 kpc

34

Conclusion

The total mass of the Milky Way is ~ 1.5 x 1012 M

The MW and M31 are among the few galaxies for which we have an estimate of the total mass, rather than just the mass outto the end of a rotation curve. Their dark halos extends out toat least 120 kpc (compared to 20 kpc for the disk)

The stellar mass is about 6 x 1010 M

So the stellar baryons are only about 4% of the total mass

Compare this with the universal fraction of baryons/matter = 16%

Like most galaxies, our Galaxy has lost (or never acquired) a large fraction of its share of the baryons

35

Dwarf spheroidal galaxies

Faint satellites of our GalaxyVery low surface brightnessSome are almost invisibleTotal masses ~ 107 M

These galaxies are not rotating, but we can measure their massesby using the velocities of their individual stars. These galaxiesare almost pure dark matter: some of them have less than 1% oftheir mass in stars (compared to the cosmic fraction = 16%). They have lost almost all of their baryons.

36

The Density of Dark Halos

• Use rotation curves for disk galaxies to measure the central densities of their dark halos

Kormendy & Freeman 2003

The slope of therotation curve

for the dark halogives its central

density

37

The central densities of dark halos

Kormendy & Freeman 2003

brightfaint

The fainter galaxieshave much denserhalos. These galaxiesformed very early inthe life of the universe,when the universe wasmuch denser. That is whytheir halos are so dense.

38

Summing up: where are all the baryons and dark matter ?(Baryons are ordinary matter, made of protons and neutrons)

In the universe, most of the mass is in the form of dark energy.The total fraction of matter (dark + baryonic) is about 0.27

The fraction in baryons is 0.044The fraction in dark matter is about 0.22

About half of the dark matter is in galactic dark halos (0.12)The rest is out in space, not condensed into halos

The cosmic ratio of baryons to total matter is 0.044/0.27 = 0.16In clusters of galaxies, the ratio has thisvalue, so clustersare a fair sample of the universe. In individual galaxies, the baryon/total matter ratio is only about 0.002 to 0.05, so galaxies have lost a lot of their baryons

39

Some recent developments in dark matter research

40

A cluster of galaxies: the ratio of baryonic to dark matter in clustersis similar to that in the universe as a whole (about 16%)

41

The dark matter ring

Hubble telescope images were used to discover a vast ring of dark matter around the cluster of galaxies CL0024+17.

The diameter of the ring is about 2 Mpc. It probably comes from a collision oftwo smaller clusters about 2 billion years ago

Weak lensing of background galaxies is a new way to detect gravitational fields.

42

The Bullet ClusterClusters of galaxies contain galaxies, dark matter and hot gas.

Here, two clusters have collided: the two lots of galaxies and dark matter (blue) have passed through each other but the hot gas (pink) interacts and is left behind. Most of the baryon mass is in the gas !

The dark matter was measured by weak lensing(Hubble and groundbased telescopes: the dark matterlies with the galaxies)

The hot gas gives off X-rays measured by the CHANDRA telescope

Clowe et al 2006

43

This does not look good for MOND: most of the baryonic massis in the (pink) gas, but most of the gravity is coming fromthe regions (blue) where the galaxies lie. Not a new problem !

MOND works well for individual galaxies, but not on these larger scales of clusters of galaxies. We need some kind of extra dark matter in clusters, as

well as MOND: this could be hot dark matter (neutrinos) because clusters are large.Neutrinos are common, but do they have enough mass (~ 2 eV) ?

(Remember: we needed the cold dark matter to make halos on the smaller scales of individual galaxies. Hot dark matter is OKfor clusters which are muchlarger than galaxies)

44

And here is another example

45

What is dark matter ?

The MACHO experiment, done at Stromlo during the 1990s, showed that dark matter in our Galaxy is

not made up of compact objects (stars,

planets) with masses between about 10-7 M (much smaller than

the earth) and 30 M .

This excludes most kinds of dead stars (neutron stars, white dwarfs) or failed stars

like brown dwarfs

46

The most likely candidates for CDM are weakly interacting massiveparticles, many of which have not yet been seen in the laboratory: axions, neutralinos ... left over from the big bang.Neutrinos are candidates for hot dark matter.

Many experiments are going on in physics laboratories to detect these particles: expect some news in the next few years.

e.g the KATRINspectrometer willmeasure the massof the electronneutrino veryaccurately in thenext few years: isit about 2eV ?

47The KATRIN spectrometer vessel on the move in Leopoldshafen