Upload
charla-morton
View
213
Download
0
Tags:
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
1
Civilian Stabilization InitiativeCivilian Stabilization Initiative
UNCLASSIFIED
U.S. Department of State
Coordinator for Reconstruction and Stabilization
February 4, 2008
Building a USG Civilian Response Capability to Support Stabilization
and Reconstruction Operations
2
Strategic Environment: Stabilization missions are an increasingly
important part of the international landscape.
The United States has been involved in or contributed significant resources to at least 3 post-conflict operations per year in more than 17 countries since the end of the Cold War.
2
3
Preparing for the Next CrisisPreparing for the Next Crisis
Recent RAND-USIP study finds peace operations are a new security reality, and worth the investment.
Since the end of the Cold War, the pace of U.S. military interventions has risen to about one every two years, while the frequency of new UN peacekeeping missions is up to nearly one every six months.
…conflicts impose greater costs on the international community than the expense necessary to ensure that the cycle of violence, once halted for whatever reason, is not renewed.
Crises can arise unexpectedly –
• Changes in leadership from elections or civil unrest
• Sudden refugee movements sparking conflict
• Terrorist organizations and organized crime exploiting vacuums of governance
Military solution alone is insufficient.
NSPD-44 mandates the USG to be prepared to respond.
DODD 3000.05 puts stability operations on par with combat operations.
"In this international atmosphere, the United States must have the right structures, personnel, "In this international atmosphere, the United States must have the right structures, personnel, and resources in place when an emergency occurs. A delay in our response of a few weeks,and resources in place when an emergency occurs. A delay in our response of a few weeks,
or even days, can mean the difference between success and failure." – or even days, can mean the difference between success and failure." – Senator Richard Lugar (R-IN)Senator Richard Lugar (R-IN)
4
Country Reconstruction& Stabilization Group (CRSG)
• Washington-based, decision-making body
• Planning and Operations Staff
• Co Chaired by
1. Regional A/S
2. S/CRS Coordinator
3. NSC Director
Country Reconstruction& Stabilization Group (CRSG)
• Washington-based, decision-making body
• Planning and Operations Staff
• Co Chaired by
1. Regional A/S
2. S/CRS Coordinator
3. NSC Director
A New Interagency Management System A New Interagency Management System
Integration Planning Cell (IPC)• Integrates with relevant Geographic
Combatant Command or with equivalent multinational headquarters
• Assists in harmonizing the civilian and military planning processes and operations
• Consists of interagency planners, regional and sectoral experts
Integration Planning Cell (IPC)• Integrates with relevant Geographic
Combatant Command or with equivalent multinational headquarters
• Assists in harmonizing the civilian and military planning processes and operations
• Consists of interagency planners, regional and sectoral experts
Field Advance Civilian Team
(FACT)
Field Advance Civilian Team
(FACT) Field Advance Civilian Team
(FACT)
Field Advance Civilian Team
(FACT) Field Advance Civilian Team
(FACT)
Field Advance Civilian Team
(FACT)
Advance Civilian Team (ACT)
• Interagency field management coordination team(s)
• Support Chief of Mission in the fieldto coordinate and execute plans
Advance Civilian Team (ACT)
• Interagency field management coordination team(s)
• Support Chief of Mission in the fieldto coordinate and execute plans
5
Meeting the Needs of TodayMeeting the Needs of Today
The pilot deployment of Active Response Corps members opened the US field office in Darfur and continue to provide support to the peace process
S/CRS and ARC members deployed to Afghanistan to assist Provincial Reconstruction Teams to create Provincial Support plans
In the last month alone, S/CRS has received requests for civilian conflict and R&S expertise in Darfur, Kosovo, Liberia, Pakistan, SOUTHCOM and AFRICOM
The inaugural team of State’s R&S first responders has deployed to Sudan, Chad, Iraq, Afghanistan, Lebanon, Liberia, Nepal, Kosovo, and Haiti.
““We obviously had inadequate plans, concepts, organizations, resources, and We obviously had inadequate plans, concepts, organizations, resources, and policies for the conduct of stability and reconstruction operations; consequently, policies for the conduct of stability and reconstruction operations; consequently,
we were slow to move...”we were slow to move...” -- Lt.Gen David Petraeus, Confirmation hearing, January 2007 -- Lt.Gen David Petraeus, Confirmation hearing, January 2007
6
Challenge of ResponseChallenge of ResponseResponse to conflict must be:
Fast• “Golden hour” ends quickly. Response needs to rapidly establish a stable
environment, laying the ground work for recovery.
Flexible• Conditions are fluid. Response must take immediate advantage of
opportunities and change course as necessary.
Localized• Response must be rooted in the unique culture of the country. Staff must be
trained to work with host nationals who are ultimately responsible for peace.
Comprehensive• Response cannot be piecemeal. Police cannot operate without courts and
prisons. Military cannot provide security without roads and water. Governments cannot ensure stability if young men do not have jobs.
““Unless I can get the sewage off the streets and get potable water into the houses Unless I can get the sewage off the streets and get potable water into the houses of the people who live on those streets – unless that happens – fast – I am going of the people who live on those streets – unless that happens – fast – I am going
to be run out of Baghdad.” – to be run out of Baghdad.” – Maj. General Peter ChiarelliMaj. General Peter Chiarelli
7
Expert Personnel to provide rapid response oversight, management, programming and advisory capacity
Active and Standby Response Corps $75.2Training and EquipmentU.S. Civilian Reserve Corps $86.8Training and Equipment
Deployment Supportto put civilians on the ground quickly, protect and sustain them for first 60 days
Deploying and Sustaining US experts $42.0Civilian Force Protection $22.1
Coordinator for Reconstruction and Stabilizationto manage Washington coordination and leadership of R&S planning and operations and the development of prevention mechanisms and best practices
Operating Costs $23.0Total Request $248.6
A New State of ReadinessA New State of ReadinessTo be fast, flexible, localized and comprehensive – the USG must be READY.
The Civilian Stabilization Initiative provides the capacity the USG needs to respond quickly and effectively. In FY09 the request includes:
FY09 Request (in mil)
8
• Lack of common planning approach, assessment tools and reliable measures of progress
• No unified operating system to ensure command and control.
• Limited civilian capacity to manage and implement R&S response
• Critical shortage of rapid, flexible funding for non-humanitarian activities -- constrains effective allocation and management of R&S resources; slows rate of U.S. civilian deployments.
• Gap in specialized training and preparation for civilians deploying quickly to conflict and unstable environments.
• No common repository for capturing and applying lessons learned and best practices.
Civilian Stabilization Initiative addresses civilian capacity gaps:
Active Response Corps: Dedicated USG staff trained and ready to deploy within days. Serves as the standing agency capacity for rapid response. Will assess situation, design response and begin R&S implementation. FY09 request: 250 new Interagency ARC members
Standby Response Corps: USG employees from civilian agencies who have ongoing job responsibilities. Trained and available for deployment in 30 days for up to 180 days.FY09 request: training for 750 new Interagency SRC members
Civilian Reserve Corps: Experts drawn from outside the federal government. Provide sector-specific expertise. Become USG employees when mobilized. Have regular jobs outside the USG. Traing and deployable in 30-60 days for up to one year. FY09 request: build the CRC to 2000 members
Meeting the Challenge of Civilian CapacityMeeting the Challenge of Civilian Capacity
Common R&S Challenges Civilian Stabilization Initiative
Civilian Stabilization
Initiative will build this capacity
9
ACTIVE RESPONSE CORPS (ARC)
STANDBY RESPONSE CORPS
CIVILIAN RESERVE CORPS (CRC)
DAYS FOLLOWING A CRISIS
• USG staff trained and ready to go in 48 hours to one week.
• Standing agency capacity for rapid response.
• Will assess situation, design response and begin R&S implementation
• USG employees
• Civilian agency employees who have ongoing job responsibilities but are trained and available for deployments.
• Deployable within 30 days for up to 180 days
• USG employees when mobilized
• Have regular jobs outside the USG
• Fully trained and deployable in 30-60 days
• Provide sector-specific Civilian Response expertise
Putting Civilian Experts on the GroundPutting Civilian Experts on the Ground
250 New ARC
750 new trained SRC
2000 recruited CRC
The new Interagency Management System puts experts on the ground
10
What is the Active Response Corps?What is the Active Response Corps?
Active Response Corps (ARC) are:
FAST – deploy within 48 hours to 1 week
EXPEDITIONARY – able to deploy to difficult environments for up to 6 months
SPECIALIZED – receive minimum 8 weeks of training per year with specialized R&S skills
-- The right people in the right place at the right time --
Request: 250 new Interagency Active Responders in FY09
$75.2 million request provides for:
• 250 new Interagency ARC positions
• 8 weeks of mandatory training
• Armored vehicles, communications and personal equipment
• Basic office support
• 2 weeks mandatory training for 750 SRC members in FY09
11
R&S Planning, operations and program management
R&S Planning, operations and program management
Criminal Justiceand PolicingCriminal Justiceand Policing
Economic RecoveryEconomic Recovery
Essential ServicesEssential Services
Diplomacy and GovernanceDiplomacy and Governance
Diplomatic SecurityDiplomatic Security
Who are the Active Response Corps?Who are the Active Response Corps?
99 DOS, DOJ, DHS and USAID integrated team of police, legal, judicial, and corrections personnel task-organized to assess, plan and start up full-spectrum criminal justice operations and development
59 DOS and USAID core group of officers to manage mission set up and field teams in assessment, operations setup, planning, program design/startup, military liaison, local engagement
25 USDA, Treasury, Commerce, and USAID experts in agriculture, rural development, commerce, taxes, monetary policy, and business and financial services task-organized to assess, plan, and help stand up economic recovery programs;
23 USAID and HHS experts covering public health, infrastructure, education, and labor task-organized to assess, plan, and help stand up essential public services;
24 DS Agents task-organized to serve as security officers and security planners in the IMS;
20 DOS and USAID officers covering ROL, Human Rights, Protection, Governance/Democracy, Conflict Mitigation, Civil Society/Media, and SSR, task-organized to assess, plan, and stand up diplomatic, democracy, and governance programs in a crisis environment.
12
What is the Standby Response Corps?What is the Standby Response Corps?
Request: Training for 2000 Standby Response Corps members in FY09
$75.2 million request also provides for:
• 250 new Interagency ARC positions
• 8 weeks of mandatory training
• Armored vehicles, communications and personal equipment
• Basic office support
• 2 weeks mandatory training for 750 SRC members in FY09
The SRC is:
INTERAGENCY – employees from State, USAID, Justice, Commerce, Treasury, Agriculture, Health and Human Services, Homeland Security
VOLUNTARILY “ON CALL” – SRC members are “on call” to deploy from their current assignment in support of a regional crisis or transition requiring a surge of US civilian expertise with 30 days notice for up to 180 days
SPECIALIZED – SRC members are specialized in language, skills and a range of sectoral and functional expertise and receive an additional minimum 2 weeks of R&S training per year
Currently there are 91 State SRC members supported by additional retirees. Currently there are 91 State SRC members supported by additional retirees. Two SRC experts have deployed to Sudan and Chad. The SRC will grow to 500 Two SRC experts have deployed to Sudan and Chad. The SRC will grow to 500
interagency members in FY08 and to 2000 in FY09.interagency members in FY08 and to 2000 in FY09.
13
Who is in the Standby Response Corps?Who is in the Standby Response Corps?
SRC Total by Agency
FY08 Total FY08 Total
DOS166 - 194 664 - 776
Homeland Security
6 24
USAID186 744
Health & Human Services 10 40
Justice74 - 102 296 - 408
Treasury4 16
Commerce10 40
Agriculture16 64
Total FY08 500 Total FY09 2000
14
Mission StatementThe U.S. Civilian Reserve Corps (CRC) is a rapid response corps that draws on American expertise to respond to critical international crises. It complements the standing response capacity of U.S. civilian agencies to address stabilization and reconstruction challenges as a priority component of U.S. national security. When mobilized by the President its job is to assist the USG to facilitate efforts to:
• Establish or reestablish the rule of law;
• Establish or reestablish operability of government institutions;
• Prepare local leaders to operate in a democratic, market system; and
• Support democratic political transitions.
“…“…A volunteer Civilian Reserve Corps…would ease the burden on the Armed Forces by allowingA volunteer Civilian Reserve Corps…would ease the burden on the Armed Forces by allowing us to hire civilian with critical skills to serve on missions abroad when America needs them. And itus to hire civilian with critical skills to serve on missions abroad when America needs them. And it
would give people across America who do not wear a uniform a chance to serve in the defining would give people across America who do not wear a uniform a chance to serve in the defining struggle of our timestruggle of our time.. – President’s State of the Union Address, 2007 – President’s State of the Union Address, 2007
What is the Civilian Reserve Corps?What is the Civilian Reserve Corps?
15
Employing American Expertise OverseasEmploying American Expertise Overseas
The Civilian Reserve is composed of expertise external to the USG to complement USG civilian agencies’ internal capacities and is:
• Appropriate to the mission
• Expert and Accountable
• Trained and Reliable
Recruitment goal of 500 in the first year with a focus on public security and rule of law. The FY09 request allows the Department to build to a Civilian Reserve of 2000.
• Other areas of emphasis include: essential services, public administration, transitional governance, and economic stability
Deploy overseas as part of a USG R&S mission, serving under Chief of Mission authority
• Advise, mentor, and strengthen local capacity
• Manage the work of USG contractors and coordinate common sectoral initiatives
• Work with US military and other peacekeeping forces to help create the stability necessary to permit reconstruction
$86.8 million request provides for CRC management:
• 2000 Reservists recruited, screened, cleared and hired
• Home Office Established including U.S. Deployment support center and 25 positions
• 4 weeks training designed and delivered
• Equipment Purchased and Deployable
““The U.S. Government [has a] critical need for a reserve civilian corps of talented The U.S. Government [has a] critical need for a reserve civilian corps of talented professionals with the proper expertise…Such a contingency organization ideally would professionals with the proper expertise…Such a contingency organization ideally would be identified, recruited, trained in advance, exercised regularly, and be ready.” be identified, recruited, trained in advance, exercised regularly, and be ready.” – SIGIR– SIGIR
Request: Build a Corps of 2000 Civilian Reservists in FY09
16
Deployment, Protection and SupportDeployment, Protection and Support
In order to effectively yet rapidly deploy and begin R&S assessment, programming and operations, we need to:
PREPARE – includes mission-specific pre-deployment training, with mission-specific equipment, vehicles and communications systems
SUPPORT – allows U.S. Civilians, including critical contracted personnel, to deploy on the ground for the first 2 months of assessment, planning, and initial project implementation before re-programming and longer-term contracts can be put in place
PROTECT – provides protection for deployed civilians for first 2 months of R&S activities including for 3 civilian-military teams
Request includes:
• $12.5 for Expert Contract Deployment
• $29.0 for pre-mission-specific deployment training and preparation, mission-specific equipment, vehicles and communications gear and first 2 months of salaries and benefits
• $22.1 for civilian force protection for first 2 months of R&S activities including security personnel and support
Request: Deploy, Protect and Support Civilian experts for “jump-start” period of 2 months
17
Coordinator for Reconstruction and StabilizationCoordinator for Reconstruction and Stabilization
Account (in mil) FY07 FY08 FY09
Operating costs 5.9 5.7 14.7
Salaries 1.8 1.8 8.3
Total Funding 7.7 7.5 23.0
Conflict Prevention – S/CRS is engaged in conflict assessment and prevention activities in key countries around the world and currently oversees DOD 1207 transfer authority projects in Haiti, Nepal, SE Asia, Colombia, Somalia, Lebanon, Yemen and the trans-Sahel
Planning – S/CRS coordinates whole-of-government R&S contingency and operations planning for US efforts in countries in crisis and transition
Training and Exercises – S/CRS provides R&S training to the interagency, assists in military training efforts and exercises interagency planning and operations with the interagency and the military
Interagency Management System – S/CRS develops, trains and operationalizes the IMS, keeping staff ready to stand up the IMS as needed
ARC/SRC Reach-back and Support – S/CRS supports ARC and SRC in the field with sectoral, best practice, planning, logistics, operations, and Information reach-back
S/CRS Request for $23.014 mil includes a $15.5 mil increase:
• 57 positions to regularize temporary Foreign Service staff, provide ARC and SRC reach-back, management and operations support
• $8.8 - Support for expert field assessments, planning and deployments for conflict prevention and non-IMS country engagements
• Planning and best practices development to inform effective R&S responses
• $6.5- Salary support for S/CRS’ 76 staff
Request: Increase S/CRS planning, operations and management in FY09
18
BACK UP SLIDES
19
1
2
3
Country Plan Overview Template
OVERARCHING POLICY GOALThe overall objective, stated as an outcome, that the U.S. Government (as a whole) would like to achieve and is capable of achieving with the resources available and in a specified timeframe.
Subgoal 1: A more specific and textured statement of the overarching policy goal.Subgoal 2: Subgoal 3:
Essential Task Area #1
Essential Task Area #2
Essential Task Area #3
Essential Task Area #4
Essential Task Area #1
Essential Task Area #2
Essential Task Area #3
Essential Task Area #4
Essential Task Area #1
Essential Task Area #2
Essential Task Area #3
Essential Task Area #4
Essential Task Area #1
Essential Task Area #2
Essential Task Area #1
Essential Task Area #2
Essential Task Area #3
Essential Task Area #1
Essential Task Area #2
Essential Task Area #3
Essential Task Area #4
Essential Task Area #5
Essential Task Area #6
Major Mission Element #5
Major Mission Element #1
Major Mission Element #2
Major Mission Element #3
Major Mission Element #4
Major Mission Element #6
OVERARCHING POLICY GOALThe overall objective, stated as an outcome, that the U.S. Government (as a whole) would like to achieve and is capable of achieving with the resources available and in a specified timeframe.
Subgoal 1: A more specific and textured statement of the overarching policy goal.Subgoal 2: Subgoal 3:
Essential Task Area #1
Essential Task Area #2
Essential Task Area #3
Essential Task Area #4
Essential Task Area #1
Essential Task Area #2
Essential Task Area #3
Essential Task Area #4
Essential Task Area #1
Essential Task Area #2
Essential Task Area #3
Essential Task Area #4
Essential Task Area #1
Essential Task Area #2
Essential Task Area #1
Essential Task Area #2
Essential Task Area #3
Essential Task Area #1
Essential Task Area #2
Essential Task Area #3
Essential Task Area #4
Essential Task Area #5
Essential Task Area #6
Major Mission Element #5
Major Mission Element #1
Major Mission Element #2
Major Mission Element #3
Major Mission Element #4
Major Mission Element #6
Policy FormulationStrategic Planning Team:
• Performs Situation Assessment• Develops Goals achievable within 2-3 years
Multiple Options (Phasing, Resource Levels, Assumptions, etc)
• Develops Major Mission Elements (MMEs)- (Lines of operation and strategic direction)
Product for Deputies Committee/Principals Committee
CRSG Secretariat or S/CRS Led:
Strategy DevelopmentMME Planning Team:
• Develops MME (Lines of operation) Strategy (which must include metrics and a resource strategy)
• Identifies Essential Task Areas• Determines Lead Agency for Each Task Area• Tracks Other Donor Contributions
Product for Policy Coordinating Committee/CRSG
CRSG Secretariat or S/CRS Led:
GOALS
MMEs
Implementation PlanningLead Agency or Essential Task Area Team:
• Develops ETA Strategy (sub-tasks, resources) • Develops and Monitors Essential Task metrics• Performs Program Management
ACT or Country Team: • Integrates Agency or ETA Team strategies into interagency
implementation plan
Agency and ACT/Country Team Led:
ETAs
A New System of Interagency Planning A New System of Interagency Planning
20
Situation Analysis Overview
Situation Analysis Overview
Whole-of-Government PlanningWhole-of-Government Planning
Policy Guidance
Memo
Policy Guidance
Memo
USG Strategic Plan for R&S
Includes Overview Template & Narrative, MME Concepts, and
Comprehensive Resource and Management Plan
USG Strategic Plan for R&S
Includes Overview Template & Narrative, MME Concepts, and
Comprehensive Resource and Management Plan
Interagency Implementation
PlanIncludes ETA
Concepts
Interagency Implementation
PlanIncludes ETA
Concepts
Policy FormulationLed by CRSG Secretariat Strategic Planning Team
Implementation Planning In support of COM - Led by Implementation Planning Team and ETA Teams
On-the-ground monitoring,
reassessment and revision of
plans
On-the-ground monitoring,
reassessment and revision of
plans
PlanImplementation
COM, then CRSG PCC,
approve changes to the Strategic Plan
COM, then CRSG PCC,
approve changes to the Strategic Plan
DC or PC approves policy
option and provides planning
guidance
DC or PC approves policy
option and provides planning
guidance
COM, then CRSG PCC, approves IIP
COM, then CRSG PCC, approves IIP
CRSG approves USG Strategic Plan
for R&S
CRSG approves USG Strategic Plan
for R&S
Strategy DevelopmentIn support of CRSG - Led by Strategic Planning Team and MME Teams
21
Design for Civilian Reserve Corps Home Office
Total staff: 32 through FY09
Civilian Reserve Administration
Resource Development
Training and Education
Executive Office
• Force Generation
• Budget
• Standards and Evaluation
• Recruitment
• Selection
• Employment
• Performance Management
• Employee Management
• Employee Relations
• Training standards
• Reserve Orientation
• Agency-Specific Training
• Field/IMS training
• Pre-Deployment
• Operations• Family Liaison• Medical• Logistics• Finance• Travel• Field Contracting
• General Services
• Financial Management
• HQ HR
• Information Management
• Security
Secretary of State
SCRS
Office of the Chief Operating Officer
Civilian Reserve CorpsCivilian Reserve Corps
Deployment Support Center (USAID)
22
CRC Terms of Service Contract can be terminated at anytime by the USG
Contract can be extended within 90 days following each deployment, reservists can apply to extend for another 4 years of service.
If not renewed, contract automatically terminated 90 days after full 1-year deployment.
Acceptable Service Deferments:• For up to twelve weeks due to a serious health condition, as defined
in the Family and Medical Leave Act of 1993 (“FMLA”) • For up to twelve weeks within the first year following the birth or
adoption of a child;• For such other grounds and for such period as may be deemed
acceptable by the Department of State.
Deploy within 30-45 days of call up.
Civilian Reserve CorpsCivilian Reserve Corps
23
Reservists may be drawn upon for a full range of R&S roles including:
• Security and ROL
• Essential services (water, sewage, trash collection, electricity, roads and communications)
• Re-establishing vital government institutions including police, courts and prisons;
• Supporting transition to new political and economic structures; and
• Program management.
• Provides a reliable source of trained and screened expertise required to address the specific challenges that arise in the first year of an R&S mission.
• Scalable, flexible resource tool to mobilize experts outside the Federal Government.
• Supplements USG expertise.
• Designed for major R&S operations, not for routine USG activities or to fill routine staffing gaps.
• Taps the expertise in the American public and provides a unique opportunity to serve.
As USG Personnel Reservists may:
• Evaluate conditions and design R&S programs;
• Identify personnel requirements;
• Manage contractors/grantees;
• Execute plans;
• Fill local institutional roles;
• Negotiate agreements; and
• Provide counsel/training to local leaders to facilitate transition to local control.
Terms: Four years of service – expected deployment for one year. Deploy within 30-60 days of call up.
Compensation: Same as for USG employees abroad. Service is voluntary, but governed by a written agreement.
Training: Introductory, annual, leadership, and pre-deployment training. Additional agency-based training.
Equipment: Basic equipment issued to reservists by function, and specialized equipment tailored to mission.
Authority: Falls under the authority of the Secretary of State.
Trigger: Presidential call-up.
USG personnel: When mobilized, reservists become USG employees
Supplements internal surge: Requires complementary internal surge capacity to be effective.
Agency Proponency: Agencies with sectoral expertise responsible for vetting and integration with internal operations.
Civilian Reserve CorpsCivilian Reserve Corps
ResponsibilitiesResponsibilitiesManagementManagementStructureStructure
PurposePurpose FunctionFunction
24
CRC CompositionCRC Composition
Sectoral Composition of first 500 Reservists:
25
Civilian Reserve Task ForceCivilian Reserve Task Force
S/CRS DODUSAIDDOJ
DOS/INL TreasuryDOS/L Commerce DOS/HR HHS Agriculture DHS
WorkstreamEstablish CRC
Management Structure
Identify Training, Equip, Logistics and
Mobilization to support personnel in the field
Develop selection process, criteria, and hiring, and retention
mechanisms
CRC Tasks
1. Develop Financial plan for FY07, FY08, FY092. Develop Home office3. Proposal for final management structure
1. Identify first 500 positions; 2. Recruitment, Selection and Screening plan; 3. Marketing strategy, 4. Proposal for Active and Standby components
1. Equipment plan for Response Corps2. Deployment plan for Response Corps3. Training Plan
Task Force Members
Workstream
Workstream
26
Costs of Stability Operations Costs of Stability Operations
2500
1000
2000
1500
0
500
Hostile Deaths
-Non- Hostile Deaths
Major Combat Operations
Hostile Deaths
-Non-Hostile Deaths
Stability Operations
Major Combat Operations vs. Stability Operations 1990- 2006
U.S. Casualty Comparison
U.S
. Mili
tary
Per
son
nel
Dea
ths
• Stability Operations take Stability Operations take place in hostile environmentsplace in hostile environments
• Number of U.S. military Number of U.S. military deaths in stability operations deaths in stability operations over six times that of major over six times that of major combat operationscombat operations
• Stability Operations take Stability Operations take place in hostile environmentsplace in hostile environments
• Number of U.S. military Number of U.S. military deaths in stability operations deaths in stability operations over six times that of major over six times that of major combat operationscombat operations
$300
$150
$250
$200
$50
$100
Major Combat Incremental Costs
Cost Comparison
Major Combat Operations vs. Stability Operations 1990- 2006
Bill
ion
s o
f F
Y0
4 d
oll
ars
Stability OperationsIncremental Costs
• In the last 15 years, the U.S. In the last 15 years, the U.S. has spent over five times as has spent over five times as much on stability operations much on stability operations compared to major combatcompared to major combat
• In the last 15 years, the U.S. In the last 15 years, the U.S. has spent over five times as has spent over five times as much on stability operations much on stability operations compared to major combatcompared to major combat
27
Civilian Response Capacity TimelineCivilian Response Capacity Timeline
NSPD-44 issued
ARC establishedInitial deployments
FY 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010
S/CRS established
Assumptions: 1) Timely passage of authorizing legislation2) Fast transfer to State and internal dispersal of funding
S/CRS
ARC
SRC
CRC
First FSI coursesoffered
NSPD-44 transitions to PCC Process; initial Operational Readiness
Achieved
Abbreviations:
SRC: Standby Response Corps
ARC: Active Response Corps
CRC: Civilian Reserve Corps
Training Initiated
10 Member Corps. Capable of launching initial operations at end of year
12-member State Department Corps trained and deployed
Full ARC funding expected; build interagency Corps to 250 members
Fully trained 250-member interagency ARC
SRC established Initial deployment
90-member State Corps; capable of launching initial operations at end of year
Build expanded interagency Corps of up to 500 by end of year
Full funding expected; train 750 interagency Corps
Train full Corps of up to 2000 members
Design approved; funding sought through legislation
Funding expected; recruitment and training of up to first 500 members; pilot group of Civilian reservists trained by end of year
Funding for 2000-member CRC expected
Fully deployable 2000 reservist CRC