!"#$%&$&%'(&)'$*+,"*"&-&%'#"./0"'

1"2'2031#"0#'

30'

431'53'6""+'73/0'.30"#'2/#7'830'513'

#".3&)#'(5'('-*"'

9:0$#';0$"0(&%?'@$&%'

A3-B(-3&'

•! C031#"0'*3#5'.3**3&,7'/#")'(++,$.(-3&'53)(7'

•! C031#"0#'(0"'(&'(++,$.(-3&'+,(D30*'

–! E*($,

X&(53*7'38'('2031#"0'(W(.6'

•! V:(5'.3/,)'('2031#"0'(W(.6',336',$6"Y''

>:"'RZ'C031#"0'

•! ;3(,I'2/$,)'('#"./0"'1"2'2031#"0'

•! Z03B$)"'(&'(0.:$5".5/0"'830'#"./0"'1"2'2031#$&%'–!A($&5($&'#"./0$57'%/(0(&5""#'"B"&'1:"&'.3*+03*$#")'

–! G&5"%0(5"'+,/%$&'+3,$.7'$&53'3B"0(,,'2031#"0'+3,$.7'

•! U#"'R='5".:&$[/"#

;(L",,"'

•! ;3(,I'$*+03B")')$#+,(7'#"./0$57'

•! A30"']&"^%0($&")'$#3,(-3&'

–!E&(2,"#'&3B",')$#+,(7'#"./0$57'+3,$.$"#'

•! >0()"'3_'.3*+(-2$,$57'830'#"./0$57'

RZP'

•! 9/,*$&(-3&'38'0"."&5'1306'$&'#"./0"'2031#"0#'

–!C(#")'3&'RZ'

–!C30031#'$)"(#'803*'9:03*"'(&)';(L",,"'

•! =/0+0$#$&%'+0",$*$&(07'+"0830*(&."'0"#/,5#'

–!A3)$].(-3'830'#"./0$57'$*+03B")'+"0830*(&."'

R/5,$&"'

•! RZ'2031#"0')"#$%&'–!U#$&%'830*(,'*"5:3)#'53'B"0$87'$&B(0$(&5#'

–! Z"0830*(&."'

•! RZP'(&)';(L",,"'–!!$#+,(7'#"./0$57'

•! !"#$%&'()'*+,-&$

•! R5:"0'0"#"(0.:'803*'*7'%03/+'

>:0"(5'A3)",'

•! >:0"(5'*3)",I'5:"'(W(.6"0'$#'5(0%"-&%'5:"'

2031#"0'(&)':(#'.3*+,"5"'.3&503,'3B"0'

.3&5"&5'2"$&%'#"0B")'$&'5:"'1"2'+(%"'

RZ')"#$%&'

•! !".3*+3#"'$&53'2031#"0'#/2#7#5"*#'–! V"2'+(%"'$(&."'

8/05:"0')$B$)")'

•! U#"'*"##(%"'+(##$&%'–! X,,'*"##(%"#'5:03/%:'

2031#"0'6"0&",'

•! !")$.(5")'#/2#7#5"*#'830'R='3+"0(-3'

•! 43#5'R='#(&)23H$&%'

!"#$%&'"&(2,"#'#"./0$57'

•! Z(0--3&$&%'(&)'.32($&")'.3**/&$.(-3&'"&(2,"'&"1'#"./0$57'*".:(&$#*#'–! 9,"(&'#"+(0(-3&'38'2031#"0'8/&.-3&(,$57'(&)'#"./0$57'

•! Z3,$.7'–! E(#$"0'53'0"(#3&'(23/5'./00"&5'+3,$.$"#'

–! `3B",'+3,$.$"#'$&.,/)$&%'830'+,/%$&'#"./0$57'

•! N30*(,'*"5:3)#'

•! N30"$.#'

U#"'38'830*(,'*"5:3)#'

•! A3)",'/#$&%'A(/)"'

•! XW(.6'*3)",")'27'#"&)$&%'(02$50(07'*"##(%"#'

•! 9:".6'=RZ'+3,$.7'

•! U\a'2(0'b'U\a',3()")'1$5:'.3*+03*$#"'–!A3)",'.:".6$&%'0"B"(,")'+(5:#'53'2()'#5(5"'

–! XW(.6"0'.3/,)'#"&)'3/5'38'30)"0'*"##(%"#'

•! U#"'53')0$B"')"B",3+*"&5'–! N$H'2/%#

G*+,"*"&5(-3&'

•! U#"'@4>Aa'(#'0"&)"0$&%'"&%$&"''

•! \:$&3'830'c(B(=.0$+5'

•! U#"'c(B('1:"0"'$5'*(6"#'#""'

–!9QQ'830'2031#"0'6"0&",

Z"0830*(&."'e.$0.('PddKf'

•! a3()',(5"&.$"#')3'&35'$*+(.5'/#(2$,$57'

d' Jdd' Oddd' OJdd' Pddd' PJdd' gddd'

,$B"?.3*'

%33%,"?.3*'

.0($%#,$#5?30%'

.#?/$/.?")/'

1$6$+")$(?30%'

RZ'XB"0(%"'

N$0"83H'XB"0(%"'

a3()'-*"'$&'*$,,$#".3&)#'

>:"';(L",,"'V"2'C031#"0'

4","&'c?'V(&%

R+"0(-&%'=7#5"*'

;(L",,"'(0.:$5".5/0"'

•! Z"0^30$%$&'+03."##"#'–! =(&)23H")'

•! ;(L",,"'#7#5"*'.(,,#'830'(.."##$&%'0"#3/0."#'–! :(&),")'27'2031#"0'6"0&",'

•! C031#"0'$(&."'$#',$2.'830'1"2'–! ;(L",,"'#7#.(,,#'2/$,5^$&'

–! 4>Aa'':(&),$&%'

–! c='"H"./-3&'

•! C031#"0'@"0&",'–! X.."##'53'#7#5"*'0"#3/0."#'

–! E&830."#'(,,'#"./0$57'+3,$.7'

C031#"0'6"0&",'

C031#"0'

G(&."'

Z,/%$'

G(&."'

C031#"0'

G(&."'

Z,/%$'

G(&."'

*$.03#3T?.3*' /$/.?")/'

=(&)23H")'R='+03."##"#'

!$#+,(7' `"51306' =530(%"' GZ9'

;(L",,"'#7#.(,,#'

!$#+,(7'#"./0$57'$&';(L",,"'

•! ;3(,I'Z03B$)"'#503&%'$#3,(-3&'2"51""&'0"&)"0")'.3&5"&5'

•! 93*+3#"'.3&5"&5'803*'*(&7')$_"0"&5'#"0B$."#'#"./0",7'

•! `35'(#'.,"(0')".$#$3'(#'50()$-3&(,'R=')$#+,(7'–! 903##'+0$&.$+(,'.3&5"&5'$&:"0"&5'$&'0"&)"0$&%'3&'1"2'

•! !$i./,5'.(#"#'.(&'0($#"'+3,$.7'[/"#-3'–! N0(*"#'.(&'2"'50(+(0"&5'

–! G*(%"#'/&)"0'5"H5'

–! a(7"0#'$&'9=='

V:(5'$#')$#+,(7'$#3,(-3&Y'

•! :W+IMM111?j$.60?.3*M+:353#MPklSKKJlm`ddMPlPkllJKgPM'

X'1"2#$5"'803*'()32"n'

•! :W+IMM111?j$.60?.3*M+:353#MPklSKKJlm`ddMPlPkllJKgPM'

!","%(5"'3&."'+3,$.7'

•! !","%(5"'3&."'+3,$.7'–!!","%(5"

!$#+,(7'$#3,(-3&'*".:(&$#*#'

•! E&830."')$#+,(7'+3,$.7'$&'2031#"0'6"0&",'

•! 903##^)3*($&'$80(*"#'(&)'+,/%$'$#3,(5")'

–!\"&)"0")'$&'#"+(0(5"'+03."##"#''

•! 2')*$%+%&'3$4,-5&+'$0($6708$9055$:&$%'+-;-+5$

–!=$%&$].(&5'3B"0:"()'830'&7-*"#?.3*'

RZPI'*(6$&%'#"./0"'2031#"0#'

*30"'+0(.-.(,'

=:/3'>(&%

RZP'

•! C(#")'3&'30$%$&(,'RZ'2031#"0'

•! N03*'9:03*"I'.3*2$&"'c='(&)'4>Aa'0"&)?'–! 93&5"&5'#&$i&%'(,%30$5:*'803*'C(05:'!"#$%&'

•! N03*';(L",,"I')$#+,(7'#"./0$57'*".:'(&)'+3,$.7'

RZP'$*+,"*"&5(-3&'

•! G*+,"*"&5")'/#$&%'V"2@$5'(&)'r5'–! a$&/H'(&)'A(.'B"0#$3&

RZP'+"0830*(&."'

•! Z"0830*(&."'"H+"0$*"&5#'

–!Z(%"',3()',(5"&.7'-*"#

0

0.5

1

1.5

2

2.5

3

google.com cs.illinois.edu bing.com en.wikipedia.org sfbay.craigslist.org nytimes.com

Tim

e i

n s

econ

ds

OP2 no optimizations

Arora

'C031#"0'6"0&",'

UG'+03."##'

V"2'+(%"'

$(&."'+03."##'

e.#?/$/.?")/f'

:W+IMM2"06","7?")/'

/0,'b':W+IMM2"06","7?")/'

'C031#"0'6"0&",'

UG'+03."##'

:W+IMM2"06","7?")/'

V"2'+(%"'

$(&."'+03."##'

e2"06","7?")/f'

=$*+,"'3+-*$L(-3'

•! Z0"^.0"(5"'1"2'+(%"'$(&."'+03."##"#'

•! RB"0,(+'1$&)31'*%0'3+#'1'+(%"',3()$&%'

0

0.5

1

1.5

2

2.5

3

google.com cs.illinois.edu bing.com en.wikipedia.org sfbay.craigslist.org nytimes.com

Tim

e i

n s

econ

ds

OP2 no optimizations

OP2 with process pre-creation

OP2 with parallel win mgr operations

Arora

X))$&%'+(0(,,",$#*'$&'RZP'X030('M'V"2@$5'

U#"0'#+(."'

@"0&",'#+(."'

N"5.:'U\a'

="5/+':"()"0#'

9:".6'830'.(.:"':$5'

n'

X#7&.'#7#.(,,'

93&5'

+03."##$&%'

X))$&%'+(0(,,",$#*'$&'RZP'RZP'V"2'Z(%"'G(&."'

eV"2@$5f'

U#"0'#+(."'

@"0&",'#+(."'

N"5.:'U\a'

RZP'`"5'Z03."##'

N"5.:'U\a'

="5/+':"()"0#'

9:".6'830'.(.:"':$5'

n'

X#7&.'#7#.(,,'X#7&.'#7#.(,,'

93&5'

+03."##$&%'

0

0.5

1

1.5

2

2.5

3

google.com cs.illinois.edu bing.com en.wikipedia.org sfbay.craigslist.org nytimes.com

Tim

e i

n s

econ

ds

OP2 no optimizations

OP2 with process pre-creation

OP2 with parallel win mgr operations

Arora

Z03."##'.(.:"'3+-*$L(-3&'

•! V"2@$5'2/$,5'(##/*$&%'+03."##'0"/#"'

–!9(.:"'1"2'32t".5'$&'*"*307'

•! =5(0-&%'803*'('80"#:'#5(5"'8/&)(*"&5(,'53'RZ'

–!="./0$57'+/0+3#"#'

•! =3,/-3&I'.(.:"'3,)'1"2'+(%"'$(&."#'

–!4$5#'3&,7'1:"&'1"'B$#$5'5:"'"H(.5'#(*"'U\a'

–!A$&$*$L"'(*3/&5'38'#5(5"'5:(5'.3/,)'2"',"(6")'

0

0.5

1

1.5

2

2.5

3

google.com cs.illinois.edu bing.com en.wikipedia.org sfbay.craigslist.org nytimes.com

Tim

e i

n s

econ

ds

OP2 no optimizations

OP2 with process pre-creation

OP2 with parallel win mgr operations

OP2 with process cache

Arora

!$#+,(7'$#3,(-3&'*".:(&$#*#'

•! 4(B"'('8/,,7'3+-*$L")'RZP'2031#"0'

–!!"5"0*$&"'$8')$#+,(7'$#3,(-3&'.3/,)'2"'+0(.-.(,'

•! Z/5'.03##'30$%$&'$80(*"#'$&'#"+(0(5"'+03."##"#'

–!!3&"'830'#"./0$57'0"(#3

0

0.5

1

1.5

2

2.5

3

google.com cs.illinois.edu bing.com en.wikipedia.org sfbay.craigslist.org nytimes.com

Tim

e i

n s

econ

ds

OP2 no optimizations

OP2 with process pre-creation

OP2 with parallel win mgr operations

OP2 with process cache

OP2 with frame isolation

Arora

d' d?dJ' d?O' d?OJ' d?P' d?PJ' d?g' d?gJ' d?k'

RZ

a"##3',"(0&")'803*'RZP'"B(,'

•! 9:(&%"#'830'#"./0$57'$*+03B")'+"0830*(&."'

–!U#/(,,7'#:335'830'Oddu'3B"0:"()'30',"##'

•! PJu')3&o5'"B"&':(B"'53'"H+,($&'

•! 4/%"'3++305/&$-"#'830'+"0830*(&."'%($'

–!Z"0830*(&."'3+-*$L(-3'830'(0.:$5".5/0"'

–!X..$)"&5(,,7'$*+03B")'+"0830*(&."'

\",(5")'V306'

•! `"1'(0.:$5".5/0"#'–! U#$&%'hAA#I'>(:3*('vR(6,(&)'wdSx'

–! N$,"'#7#5"*'83./#")I''()%*)+,#$#-!.(/!#0!1#1/20-!/'vN\EE`Gy'wdOx'

–! Z03."##'2(#")I'3/.4)"!."(/$%#5/)+.)5%!-#62/#-$6!#0!1#5/2,/$7-'v4R>`E>='odKx#

•! ="./0$&%'"H$#-&%'(++,$.(-3'(&)'&"1'(2#50(.-3'–! c(B(#.0$+5I'C031#"0#:$",)

93&.,/#$3'

•! >0"(5'2031#"0',$6"'(&'R=

r/"#-3Y'

•! e`35"I'5:$#'$#'&35'5:"'"&)'38'*7'5(,6'7"5f'

U&50/#5")'.3*+/-&%'2(#"I'

)"8"&)$&%'(%($'*(,$.$3/#'

:(0)1(0"'

A(W'4$.6#

C/$,)$&%'#"./0"'#7#5"*#'

•! V"'*(6"'(##/*+-3'1:"&')"#$%&$&%'#"./0"'

#7#5"*#'

•! C0"(6'#"./0"'#7#5"*

A(,$.$3/#':(0)1(0"'

•! G#'$5'+3##$2,"'53'*3)$87')"#$%&'38'+03."##30#Y'

•! G*+,"*"&-&%':(0)1(0"'$#')$i./,5'

•! G*+,"*"&-&%'4V^2(#")'(W(.6#'$#'"(#7F'

–! =*(,,':(0)1(0"',"B",'622"42%*-#

–! EH"./5"':$%:^,"B",':$%:^B(,/"'(W(.6#'VG>4RU>'"H+,3$-&%'(&7'#3T1(0"'2/%#'

!"8""#'

•! C(#")'3&'$$%:5#'803*'8335:3,)')"B",?'

•! X&(,7L"'.$0./$5'(5')"#$%&'-*"'

•! 4$%:,$%:5'+35"&-(,,7'*(,$.$3/#'.$0./$5#'

•! 43+"'53':(B"'0"#/,5#'#33&'

!"5"0*$&$#-.'0"+,(7'

•! \".30)'"H"./-3&

!$%%$&%'830'!(5('

=50/.5/0"#'

X&5:3&7'93LL$"

!(5('=50/.5/0"'2(#")'X&-B$0/#'

•! !"5".5'+03%0(*#'2(#")'3&'5:"$0')(5('#50/.5#'

•! 93&B"05'#""*$&%,7'0(&)3*'275"#'38'+03%0(*'*"*307'$&53')(5('#50/.5/0"#'(/53*(-.(,,7'

–!A(06'"(.:'130)'(#'(&'$&5

R5:"0'+03t".5#'

•! X/53*(-.'8(/,5'0".3B"07'

–!Z(+"0'$&'X=ZaR='wdl'

–! c3$&5'1306'1$5:'X&)0"1'a"&:(05:'(&)'h$60(*'

X)B"'

•! A30"'#"./0"'1"2'2031#"0'1306'

r/"#-3Y'

•! e`35"I'5:$#'08'5:"'"&)'38'5:"'5(,6f'

\"+,$.(5"'+30-3'38'5:"'R='

•! EH50(.5#'+(05#'38'R='&"")")'830'1"2'.,$"&5'#".'

–!9/#53*',(2",$&%'(&)'(.."##'.3&503,'#7#5"*'

–!\Z9'M'*"##(%"'+(##$&%',(7"0'

–!V$&)31'*(&(%"0'e,$*$5")'"H5"&5f'

JSMOk'

X##/*+-3'(23/5'R='

•! Z03."##^,"B",'$#3,(-3&'

–!A"*307'+035".-3&'

–!1",,^6&31&'GZ9'*".:(&$#*#'

•! =7#5"*^,"B",'#(&)23H$&%'

–! G#3,(5"'+03."##"#'803*'#7#5"*'0"#3/0."#'

–!\"#50$.5'#7#5"*'.(,,'.(+(2$,$-"#'

•! \"#3/0."'*(&(%"*"&5'

–!90"(5"'+03."##"#

!$_"0"&."#'2"51""&'RZ