Upload
others
View
0
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
08:30-09:15 Keynote: People development – the role of business
Bohbot, A., EOH, South Africa
Unlike the role of business in the developed world, business in the developing world (specifically in
the African continent) has a major contribution to make in developing people and the well-being in
society. This presentation considers the role business has to play in people development in Africa
and other developing countries.
09:15-10:00 Keynote: Searching for answers to ‘race’ and ethnic discrimination in the workplace:
Integrating learning from psychology and organisation behaviour
Nkomo, S.M., University of Pretoria, South Africa
Race and ethnic discrimination in the workplace remains a global issue. While the nature of
discrimination differs across national contexts, there are commonalities in how discrimination occurs.
At the same time, there is a need to create inclusive 21st century organisations that fully leverage
human capital for competitive advantage. My talk will discuss how psychological and organisation
behaviour research can help organisations manage difference and value diversity.
10:30-11:05 How leader’s strengths and behaviours impact leadership effectiveness
Brook, J.H., Strengths Partnership, UK
This study seeks to investigate leaders’ strengths and behaviours and how they affect leadership
effectiveness. Through developing skills and agility in areas of natural strength and reducing the
impact of risks/weaker areas, leaders become more authentic and help people to perform at their
best. This study seeks to contribute to the body of knowledge of leadership effectiveness, particularly
using a strengths based approach. The term strengths in this context refers to “core qualities or
characteristics which energise you, enable you to do your best work and help you feel more confident
in the face of challenges and pressure”. The aim of this study is to understand and investigate the
relationship between a leader’s strengths (what you bring to leadership), the leadership habits (how
you behave) and the confidence the followers have in the leader’s ability to deliver across four critical
outcomes (performance indicators). Four hypothesis were investigated. Hypothesis 1: Leaders who
optimise their strengths are likely to be more effective. Hypothesis 2: Leaders with specific clusters of
strengths are likely to be more effective in developing certain leadership habits Hypothesis 3: Leaders
who optimise their strengths and are effective across the leadership habits generate better outcomes
Participants completed the online StrengthscopeLeader™ questionnaire. Quantitative, self-report
data was collected via online questionnaire for 94 participants. This process also allowed for a full 360
feedback to be provided by the respondent’s nominated raters. Feedback was obtained from at least
one rater for each respondent. To test the above hypotheses, the main analyses that we anticipate
conducting involve correlating the variables.
10:30-11:05 Human Capital priorities in Africa
Crous, W., Knowledge Resources, South Africa
Attlee, Z., Knowledge Resources, South Africa
Africa’s richness and potential are not only locked-up in minerals and commodities, but in the
opportunity and challenges diversity and human capital offer. Human capital is imperative for
economic success. Raising human capital does not only refer to education and training, but also to the
improvement of health levels, community involvement and employment prospects. Despite the vast
potential pool of talent on the continent, a lack of high level skills exists and this is where Africa is at
a disadvantage. A number of studies and various analyses refer to the economic and political
dispensation of African countries, however information about the human capital and labour force of
any African country is fragmented. The aim of this presentation is to offer an integrated view and
analysis of the quality and quantity of human capital in African countries.
This paper uses descriptive statistics to present in-depth analysis of the labour force in Ghana, Kenya,
Nigeria, South Africa, Tanzania, Uganda and Zambia. The focus will be on the demographics of the
labour force, education and skills levels, economically active population, employment and
unemployment trends, employment by sectors, industrial relations framework and labour market
efficiency.
Where appropriate, data is benchmarked against Nigeria, South Africa and Kenya to provide context
and perspective. Nigeria was selected because it is the largest economy in Africa; South Africa the
second largest and Kenya for being the largest economy in East Africa. The findings shared in this
paper focus on the quality and quantity of human capital, which is essential in making human
resources management decisions. Based on the findings the ten major human capital priorities in
Africa will be shared.
10:30-11:05 Using non-directive groups as a platform for the development of life skills in high school
girls
Otto, C., Oprah Winfrey Leadership Academy for Girls, South Africa
The development of life-skills, grit and resilience has often been argued to be one of the primary tasks
of education. The Oprah Winfrey Leadership Academy for Girls has a unique approach to developing
such skills and enhancing the psychological health and maturity of learners. Non-directive groups,
coined Stepping Groups, are facilitated by psychologists as a part of the curriculum of the Academy.
Every learner in the school is required to participate as a member of a Stepping Group from Grade 8
to Grade 12. The Stepping approach depends on the creation of a safe space where learners can
explore current issues, make sense of events in the world and learn from the experiences of others.
This paper explores the ethos behind the Stepping Groups as well as the various advantages of
incorporating them as part of the formal school curriculum. Some of the benefits of participation in a
Stepping Group include: 1) a decreased number of referrals to the psychology department, 2) reduced
stigmatisation of psychologists and their role within a school, and 3) the development of life-skills and
resilience factors without the need to engage in a formalised therapeutic process.
At the end of each term a report is compiled on the various themes emerging from each high school
grade. These themes have provided meaningful insights into the challenges and experiences faced at
different developmental stages across adolescence within the context of a residential high school in
South Africa.
10:30-11:45 Symposium: The good, the bad & the ugly of assessments in South Africa, and the
implications for Africa
De Bruin, G.P., University of Johannesburg, South Africa
Taylor, N., JvR Psychometrics, South Africa
De Beer, M., M&M Initiatives, South Africa
South Africa is one of only a few countries where the development and application of psychometric
assessments is highly regulated and legislated. This legislation creates an equivocal situation: Tests
and questionnaires could either be viewed with suspicion and mistrust, or they could be blindly trusted
and applied indiscriminately. The trick is to ensure balance in the perspective. This presentation covers
three critical areas in psychological assessment. Each area is discussed from the perspective of what
is good, bad and ugly, with recommendations for the way forward in South Africa and in Africa.
The first focus area has to do with the challenges, gaps, and developments in test development and
research in psychometrics in South Africa. South Africa has a vibrant test development tradition, and
with no national centre focused on the development and research of psychological tests and
questionnaires, it is up to academics and private enterprises to ensure standards are upheld. Issues in
the training of psychologists and psychometrists in psychometric research are also highlighted.
The second focus area is on application of tests and questionnaires in practice in South Africa. South
African practitioners appear to use tests frequently for selection in organisations. This provides an
opportunity to ensure best practice and to set standards in assessment for use in other parts of the
world. However, there are still many cases where the misuse of tests adds to the already negative
picture of psychological assessment in South Africa.
Finally, the good, the bad, and the ugly of the legislative environment around assessment in South
Africa will be discussed. There have recently been very positive moves towards greater collaboration
and support across stakeholder groups, with the emphasis on ensuring that the quality of tests used
in South Africa is of the highest standard. There is also a drive towards greater efficiency in the
evaluation of tests. The obstacles, hurdles, and highlights in the South African context will be
described, with lessons learnt as recommendations to implementing public policy in other African
countries.
11:10-11:45 Mental models and ineffective leadership behaviour in South African management
practice: A theory of action perspective
Johnson, A.J., Eskom Leadership Institute, South Africa
The high incidence of failure in organisational change efforts points to the topicality of leadership
effectiveness. This study explored the barriers to leadership effectiveness as residing in the tacit
master programs/mental models of five senior executives. By discovering and describing these master
programs and mental models, with their accompanying defensive reasoning processes, mismatches
between intention and action can be identified. An action science approach effectively explained this
gap by confirming that human action is not accidental but deliberately planned. These executives
imagined the envisioned consequences but their action rules, formed over many years of socialisation,
automatically influenced their behaviour in practice; contrary to their stated espoused intentions:
Action Science, in the critical social science tradition of the Frankfurt School, seeks to engage human
agents in public self-reflection in order to transform their world. The methodological strategy implies,
identifying a theory of action that underlies the action, critiquing its adequacy, and identifying
pathways for learning and practising more effective theories-in-use. As such the focus of data
collection is on what people say or do, and the consequences of this. Irrespective of biographical
differences, the executives’ actions were consistent with their tacit theories-in-use, and contrary to
their own explicitly stated, espoused theories. The study, as one of the few local studies in the field
of action science, confirmed the validity of an action science approach in a South African context, and
contributes to critical-reflective management and organisational development practices in South
African organisations. It should also stimulate academic interest in developing reflective industrial and
organisational psychologists.
11:10-11:45 The opportunities and challenges of learnerships
Appelgryn, J., Signa, South Africa
B-BBEE compliance has become a pre-requisite to being able to do business within South Africa. A
priority area to rectify the discrimination of the past and address unemployment is the upskilling of
the previously educationally side-lined population. A solution to addressing this challenge is the
rollout of learnerships. Learnerships are a formal training program consisting of a practical and
theoretical component, which delivers a portable, accredited qualification. Learnerships is an effective
way to maximise BEE scoring, and, utilising tax rebates, can effectively make this a no-cost, high
benefit training model to implement. This paper aims to explore the challenge of Sector Education
Training Authorities (SETA) in the allocation and management of these learnerships and the recipe of
implementing successful learnerships and claiming tax rebates.
11:10-11:45
The relationship between a physical literacy programme and the basic sports skills of
young children
Jacobs, M., University of Johannesburg, South Africa
Millions of young people are involved in sport participation all over the world. Sport bridges the
boundaries between cultures, age groups, gender, and language barriers. It is also documented that
physically active children have better learning capacity, social skills and decision-making skills than
their less physically active counterparts. It has also been demonstrated that being physically active
later in life is dependent on feeling confident in activity environments and that adults with good self-
esteem often learned fundamental movement and sport skills as a child. It is argued therefore that
physical literacy programmes have the potential to create and active and healthy population.
The South African Sports Confederation and Olympic Committee (SASCOC) have embarked on the
Long Term Participant Development (LTPD) programme in 25% of the country’s sport codes. The need
for the LTPD arose in part to enhance international performance but more so to broaden the base of
athletics participation of all South African children. LTPD aspires to encourage recreational sport as
lifelong activity. This research aims to measure the visual and sport skill levels of six to ten year old
school children. It explores the influence of physical literacy programmes and the influence that
electronic devices might have on skills development at an early age. Appropriate inferential statistics
are employed in the comparison of samples of township and private school children. Initial findings
indicate that early exposure to a structured physical literacy programme was effective in developing
sport skills and in enhancing learning.
11:50-12:25 Accountable leadership for culture change: Using data as an influencer strategy
Cuyler, C., MTN, South Africa
Scherrer, R., JvR Consulting Psychologists, South Africa
The ability of organisations to rapidly adapt to external and internal forces of change (referred to as
organisational adaptability) is becoming increasingly important in order to remain competitive. Some
of the most challenging external driving forces impacting organisations today include the management
of changing customer needs and expectations, integrating new legal and regulatory
requirements, staying abreast of technological advancements and dealing with disruptive
competition. The internal forces driving organisational change range from talent attraction and
retention, leadership and management skills to transforming organisational cultures and re-
engineering business processes and internal systems. In this context of increased volatility and multi-
faceted forces of change; the ability of the organisation to respond effectively is critically important.
For the sake of the future sustainability of the organisation and its stakeholders, leaders have to make
more complex decisions, identify the most appropriate course of action, and establish a long term
vision and agenda for change. One of the key strategic decisions required of leaders, is whether or not
to transform the organisational culture or cultural operating system (new values, behaviours
and goals).
In this case study we will unpack the process followed to transform a global organisational culture or
cultural operating system, the lessons learnt, and the implications for leadership development. Most
importantly, we will focus on how various forms of data were used as an influencing strategy to guide
the culture change journey and drive accountable leadership - from storytelling and leader discovery
sessions, to individual, team and organisational behavioural and 360 degree surveys. Through an
action research approach, the focus was on continuous measurement, analysis, and feedback to adjust
actions, build best practice and drive accountable leadership for culture change.
11:50-12:25 Establishing infrastructure – opportunities for people development
Steyn, L., Aurecon, South Africa
Lack of infrastructure and the degradation of natural resources are often found to be leading causes
of poverty and food insecurity. In addition, there are critical needs for basic healthcare infrastructures
in rural areas. Creating infrastructure in African countries can pave the way (sometimes literally) for
enhancing quality of life, providing access to resources, and improving the socio-economic situation
of people in underdeveloped African countries.
Aurecon provides global engineering, management and specialist technical services to government
and private sector clients in the establishment of specific infrastructure. This presentation will focus
on two key projects completed in Malawi and Lesotho, which highlight the challenges faced in creating
infrastructure in third-world countries. The Malawi project focuses on the design of a programme
across various sectors to encourage, stimulate and sustain rural economies through the creation of
infrastructure. The Lesotho project focuses on a Health sector improvement project which was
designed to mitigate the negative economic impact of HIV and AIDS, tuberculosis and other diseases
on the country’s economy. The practical problems of each project will be described, along with the
successes and recommendations and advice for working in African countries from a people
development perspective.
11:50-12:25 Old but young! Over three decades of I-O psychology in Ghana- Practice, challenges and
prospects
Asumeng, M., University of Ghana, Ghana
Agyemang, C., University of Ghana, Ghana
This paper covers the practice of industrial and organisational psychology (I/O) in Ghana, which,
although not well-marketed, is becoming increasingly popular. First, it traces the history of I/O
psychology in Ghana. Second, it highlights the activities of industrial psychologists in academia,
particularly, teaching and research in I/O psychology in Universities in Ghana. Third, it highlights the
practice of I/O psychology in business and organizational settings. It explores how I/O psychology can
be applied in informal/semi-structured/unstructured business settings such as the market place,
fishing industry, cocoa farming and small scale mining, as the majority of Ghanaians are employed in
these settings. Finally, it highlights the problems, challenges and prospects of I/O psychologists, and
how they can make significant contributions to the well-being of employees, organisational
effectiveness and Ghanaian society as a whole.
11:50-12:25 The assessment model, development, psychometric results and utility of the Career
Preference Test (CPT)
De Beer, M., University of South Africa, South Africa
Nel, L.F.H., M&M Initiatives, South Africa
Marais, C.P., M&M Initiatives, South Africa
Maree, D.J.F., University of Pretoria, South Africa
The CPT is based on a three-dimensioned model for career preference assessment including 16 career-
related fields, 12 career-related activities and 6 career-related environments. A dimension-adaptive
process is used during which the top 6 fields, top 6 activities and top 4 environments are identified
relative to each other. This makes available useful information for individuals faced with career-
related decisions. Data was gathered over time by means of separate cross-sectional survey design
studies for different sub-groups. Participants included specific groups such as secondary school
learners (N=346), post-school learnership participants (N=903), engineering applicants (N=254),
postgraduate psychology students (N=90), call centre agents (N=231), security domain applicants
(N=249) and participants from the general population (N=885).
The CPT was administered in all cases and in some groups additional assessments were also
administered, such as learning potential, career interest and hardiness, sense of coherence and locus
of control. Item analysis was based on Classical Test Theory (CTT) and Rasch analysis for the CPT items
and correlation analysis was performed for construct validity evaluation. The factor analysis and item
analysis shows the expected loading of items per sub-dimension. The CPT shows acceptable
psychometric properties across different education level and vocational groupings. The way in which
individual results are displayed in comparison with norm-based results provides useful interpretive
data for career guidance purposes. The CPT shows psychometrically acceptable and practically useful
results for its use for career-related guidance purposes. Its availability in 6 of the local South African
languages as well as a number of African and European languages is likely to enhance its utility in the
multicultural and multilingual South African as well as wider African and European contexts.
13:30-14:05 Executive coaching as an organisational leadership culture transformation intervention
De Jager, W., Ernst & Young, South Africa
Executive coaching as a profession is growing and the 2015 Sherpa Global executive coaching survey
indicated that there is a 40% growth in the demand for executive coaching services to drive
organisational transformational change. At EY we have more than 10 years reputable experience in
organisational growth and turnaround transformational change strategies through executive
coaching. Our holistic systemic executive coaching process driven interventions are grounded in
perception and evidence based assessments. A diagnostic leadership culture phase will normally
include a Culture Values Alignment Survey (Barrett CVA) and matrix based psychometric assessments
aligned to a custom designed strategic leadership competency framework. Assessment outcomes
inform the shape of bespoke executive coaching interventions such as the development of a
Leadership Behaviour Charter with values aligned and values limiting behaviours to drive leadership
culture alignment. The use of 360 degree feedback and leadership proficiency assessment against
competency based psychometric assessment batteries is used for executive leaders, senior leaders
and HIPO emerging leaders to inform the development of Coaching Plans for individuals, intact teams
and organisational portfolios EY uses an integrated systems coaching model based on inside-out
coaching (intra-personal and inter-personal effectiveness) and outside-in (intra- and inter group
effectiveness and intra- and inter-organisational effectiveness) models.
This presentation describes the process whereby the results from content analysis of coaching
interventions are used to inform crucial conversations for board and executive members to lead the
desired organisational behaviour change by example. This is supported by ongoing change
management communication from the top to engage and energise all employees in the organisation
towards a pre-defined transformational change end state. Both pre- and post- quantitative and
qualitative assessments are conducted throughout the duration of the transformational change
process to demonstrate the Business Impact of the coaching with evidence of behaviour change that
drives the organisational leadership culture turnaround or growth transformational change strategy.
Implications for holistic systems coaching processes in Africa are discussed.
13:30-14:05 Exploring and celebrating the uniqueness of Africa
Havemann-Serfontein, A., Joint Prosperity, South Africa
Hermanson, C., Joint Prosperity, South Africa
Morris, J., Joint Prosperity, South Africa
One of the challenges for organisations looking to resource and develop talent in Africa is the limited
information and insight available about talent trends on the continent. The challenges are multiple:
what talent exists, the demographics of that talent, what makes them successful and unsuccessful in
that environment and what organisations can do to attract and retain that talent. It is also important
to note that Africa is a continent and not a country, and each region and country has clear cultural
differences which impacts leadership style and effective engagement. With psychometrics, the tools
we use are generally designed from a Western perspective and evaluated and applied with that culture
in mind. Over the last ten years, we have reviewed trends using the Joint Prosperity assessment tool
(MBTI, Belbin, EQ and CNT together with business scenarios assessed). The sample covers leaders in
the financial services industry in Africa.
There are distinctive trends and differences in the following areas, which at times challenge the
traditional stereotypes, such as: Approach to structure and time; Leadership – collaboration vs
shaping; Relationship and hierarchy; and Business acumen and approach to complexity. The trends
and implications of the findings will be discussed in the presentation. We have also explored the
degree to which the results speak to the Enneagram, which may provide some explanation of these
trends. We provide suggestions on best practice in using assessments for leadership development in
African countries.
13:30-14:05 Technology integration in teaching of life orientation to second year university students: A
motivating factor in academic performance
Mbatha, N. N., University of KZN, South Africa
The change in the education system has advocated for the integration of information and
communications technology (ICT) in teaching and learning. The White Paper 7 on e-Education outlines
five levels of knowledge in ICT: entry, adoption, adaptation, appropriation, and innovation. The ICT
knowledge and skills were transmitted to student teachers from the University of Zululand, who will
also transfer such knowledge to their prospective learners. The University of Zululand has a high
student/ lecturer ratio which limits individual or small group attention. In large groups students may
hesitate to ask questions Furthermore, the high student/ lecturer ratio results in vast amount of
paperwork, including marking of assignments, tests and examinations These problems faced by
lecturers and students could be alleviated by the use of technology in the classrooms. The University
of Zululand had adopted Moodle and Testmoz as a virtual learning management system (LMS) to aid
in teaching and learning challenges faced by the lecturers and students.
This study investigates the effect of the Moodle and Testmoz tools on the academic performance of
Life Orientation student teachers, and its impact on student-cantered learning. Students’ perceptions
and learning content mastery were evaluated by pre- and post- assessments administered online. The
study involved 150 second year students. Data was analysed by comparing pre-and post- test results
using Pearson’s correlation coefficient. The results in student performance indicated that the ICT
method had a positive effect on content mastery. The use of Moodle made the module interactive
and motivated students.
13:30-14:05 The development of the Work-related Risk and Integrity Scale (WRISc)
Van Zyl, C.J.J., University of Johannesburg, South Africa
De Bruin, G.P., University of Johannesburg, South Africa
The Work-related Risk and Integrity Scale (WRISc) is a recently developed, personality based inventory
designed to identify persons likely to engage in counterproductive work behaviour (CWB). The
purpose of this study is to describe the theoretical basis underlying the development of the WRISc and
to demonstrate its ability to predict organisational and interpersonal forms of counterproductive work
behaviour. The WRISc assessment contains a number of primary personality scales including
Manipulation, Risk-Taking, Impulse Control, Narcissism, Aggression, Trust, Effortful Control; Locus of
Control, Rule-Defiance; along with a number of multi-dimensional index scales including
Machiavellianism, sub-clinical Narcissism and sub-clinical Psychopathy. Participants were 1250
working adults. Data were collected by Honours level I/O students as a partial requirement of their
course in Research Methodology. Statistical analysis employed in the study includes reliability analysis,
confirmatory factor analysis, multiple regression including a dominance analysis and Rasch analysis.
Good evidence demonstrating the reliability, construct validity and predictive validity of the WRISc
assessment will be presented in support of its claim as an important tool with which to reduce the
destructive impact of CWB.
14:10-14:45 Coaching on leadership role conflicts
Koortzen, P., Investec, South Africa
South Africa has a significant shortage of leaders, which results in leaders being promoted into
leadership roles at a much earlier age than elsewhere. Very little time and effort is spent on them for
leading in an emerging country. In an attempt to fast track their development, coaching has been used
extensively. Coaching psychology can be viewed as the art and science of using psychology in practical
ways to support clients (including leaders) in creating their own success at work and in life. The tools
and techniques currently applied by practicing coaching psychologists are drawn from the domains of
clinical, counselling and industrial/organisational psychology and are predominantly cognitive
behavioural in nature. There are, however, many coaching psychologists applying the systems
psychodynamic approach. The primary task of systems psychodynamic leadership coaching is to
provide developmentally and psycho-educationally focused reflection and learning opportunities for
leaders to explore, become aware of and gain insight into how their performance is influenced by both
conscious and unconscious dynamics. One of the techniques which assist in doing this is the role
analysis technique. When working from this approach the focus is on coaching the leader, within his/
her role in the organisation and assisting them to explore the impact of their own dynamics and that
of the system, by way of taking up their roles. This presentation also focuses on the use of the role
analysis technique in terms of its practical application.
14:10-14:45 Transforming board governance in Africa
Redelinghuys, J., Heidrick & Struggles, South Africa
Transforming board governance in Africa is a slow but necessary process. Boards on the African
continent face many of the same challenges that are experienced by listed company boards in other
countries, but there are some unique obstacles. The purpose of board governance is to ensure that
sound management of the enterprise is in place and that the executives are doing what is necessary
to sustain it. Governance is a hands-off process where influence is its key instrument. It is directing
and not managing.
Boards everywhere experience similar challenges. Most importantly they must understand the
difference between governance and management. Many boards, especially in times of trouble, fall
into the trap of trying to manage. Transformation is a value that everyone says they buy into. But it
comes with challenges. Many young board members from previously disadvantaged backgrounds are
unable to collaborate effectively with older legacy directors and usually do not have the depth of
general business experience to participate meaningfully in decision making and debate
Research conducted by Jeffrey Sonnenfeld published in the Harvard Business Review “What makes
great boards great?” highlighted trust, respect and candour as critical values. All are important but
candour is the standout problem on many African boards. Unwillingness to challenge authority is
rooted in the culture. A possible solution, already found in South Africa, is that much of the work is
devolved to board committees. They are smaller, and easier to manage. Carefully curated coaching
programmes could add substantially to the governance capability and the transformation of boards in
Africa. The implications of the implementation of these programmes are discussed in this
presentation.
14:10-14:45 Psychological effects of brain drain on trainee educational psychologists
Makumbe, T. E., Great Commission International Ministries, Zimbabwe
Political instability and economic hardships forced many people, especially professionals, to look for
greener pastures outside of Zimbabwe. This has resulted in a brain drain that has affected skills
development in many fields, such as in Educational Psychology. The paradigm shift in the health
professions from the medical perspective, which focused on infectious diseases, to psychological
factors, has made the demand for psychologists increase. The need to fill the demand for psychologists
led to a much bigger problem, as those who were training to be Educational Psychologists in Zimbabwe
faced a major challenge in that there were no trained Educational Psychologists to impart the
necessary skills to the trainees. The psychological effects that the trainee Educational Psychologists
went through made it necessary for this research to be carried out. The research was carried out in
Mashonaland East Province in Zimbabwe. The research participants were the trainee Educational
Psychologists employed in The Ministry of Education, Arts and Culture in Zimbabwe. A descriptive,
interpretive, qualitative research method was used. Participant observation and interviews were used
to gather data. Data was analysed using an interpretive method of analysis with codes, themes and
categories. The results showed that there were severe psychological effects that the trainee
Educational Psychologists experienced due to the brain drain in their professional field. The conclusion
and recommendations was that the Health Professions Authority, through the offices of the Allied
Practitioners Council, would look into the matter objectively and come up with ways to alleviate the
problems of brain drain. There is need to ensure that skills development takes place even if it means
hiring competent professionals from neighbouring countries.
14:10-14:45 Validity of assessment centres (ACs) as a selection or development measure
Mulder, G., JvR Psychometrics, South Africa
Taylor, N., JvR Psychometrics, South Africa
Currently Assessment Centres (ACs) are implemented in 82 countries, with South Africa being the third
biggest user globally. In addition, South Africa is one of the first countries to implement the AC
methodology in their organisations. General psychometric practice in South Africa is that
psychometric assessment methods be analysed to ensure that the assessment is valid. With ACs
typically having good predictive validity, practitioners assumed that construct, convergent and
discriminant validity also hold. However, when data were evaluated the opposite was found. In order
to address the dilemma in validity, some design fixes such as trait-activation-theory, mixed model
design and overt observation were recommended. However, the question could be asked as to
whether or not AC exercises without these design fixes and validation data can be seen as fair and
therefore whether it should be used in selection or development decisions. Two of the biggest gaps
in the AC field for practitioners in South Africa are the lack of validation studies and the incorporation
of possible design fixes. A possible reason could be that validation studies is not general practice in
South Africa and that South African AC practitioners might not be completely aware of the
requirements or benefits of conducting validation studies. For this reason, JvR Psychometrics
embarked on a study to investigate the internal structure of three exercises from the JvR Competency
Assessment Series (CAS) by assessing 60 middle managers from various organisations within South
Africa. The exercises used were revised to include principles of trait-activation-theory, overt
observation and mixed model design to also investigate the effectiveness of these proposed design
fixes.
15:15-15:50 Team coaching for system transformation
Wrogemann, G.C., GCW Consulting, South Africa
Teams and organisations can sometimes not achieve the high level of performance they strive for. This
occurs for a variety of reasons, such as limiting unconscious patterns of functioning, low grade trauma
responses, the impact of entrenched silo behaviour, and the effect of wider systemic discord. At times
a team may take up a role for the system, and, without awareness, the ability of the team to perform
in that system can be undermined. The demands of delivery can therefore not be realised without first
managing complex internal and external challenges. Team coaching for transformation resolves
internal team dynamics-as well as those with external stakeholders-at the level of psychodynamic
complexity and at the depth of systemic conscience. The outcome of such a process is an inherent
change in the individual, and also in the team. This can lead to healing and transformation of old
paradigms and entrenched dogmas/cultures across the whole system. This process therefore allows
for regenerative change and sustainable growth to occur. The aim of this paper is to describe two case
studies where team coaching was used as a systems transformation tool. The method was grounded
in systems psychodynamics, systems coaching perspectives and complexity theory. The findings
demonstrated that qualitative and quantitative measurements of change in team behaviour resulting
from progressive and deep shifts in the identity of the team to itself, and a constructive integration
of, and resourcing from, the ego state parts of the team. These integrations have resulted in an
increased ability of the teams to take up an effective, and, at times, a strategic change role, action
effective solutions, manage complex circumstances and focus on purpose and delivery in the face of
constant change. This implies that a focus on building teams, repairing internal relationships, building
relationships with external teams, understanding the patterning of themes across stakeholders
(including into the coach or consultant teams) creates opportunity for systems transformation and
resolution on a broad and significant scale.
15:15-15:50 Global leadership matters: Exploring emerging trends in Africa from a values-driven
leadership perspective
Croukamp, A., JvR Consulting Psychologists, South Africa
Grant, J., Illovo Sugar Ltd., South Africa
Organisational dynamics and change are often viewed as a synchronistic process aimed at enhancing
organisational performance and creating that “organisational edge” in a competitive market. The
future of organisational sustainability seems to be reliant on its leadership, and in a multinational
organisation this “Leadership” persona becomes more complex. The following two burning questions
arise from this need: Will our traditional theories of leadership be able to address the very different
expectations of future leaders whilst they are trying to navigate more and more unpredictability?
What can organisations hold on to during such fluctuations to try and maintain organisational
stability?
This paper represents a case study of a prominent South African organisation, Illovo Sugar Limited,
with a footprint across the African continent. Illovo embarked on a leadership development journey
in 2012, with a guiding emphasis on Values-Driven Leadership. This paper will map the story of this
journey to date. Practical perspectives on theoretical tenets related to the concept of leadership and
being a leader will be discussed. The presenters will also describe the Illovo leaders in Africa,
identifying underlying motivational forces and characteristics driving leaders in a multinational
organisation. The role of context, culture and business challenges in rolling out a Leadership
Development Programme in a multinational organisation will be highlighted, along with a description
of how the Illovo Leadership Development Programme relates to the Illovo vision and what the
intention of driving leadership from a Values perspective is in Illovo. Key organisational, leadership,
and applied psychology lessons learnt will be provided.
15:15-15:50 From adversity to diversity - the role of assessments in the transformation of South Africa
- implications for the global workplace
Newman, A.D., Counselling Psychologist, South Africa
Assessments have played a vital role in the transformation of the workplace in South Africa. Coming
from a background of discriminatory practice, including education systems favouring Whites, has
made the identification of talented people from other racial groupings difficult. This is because
educational standards are not a fair measure if potential. It was there for essential that potential be
measured in a different way. This gave rise to the development of assessment tools that measure raw
potential and not learned skills. The Employment Equity Act, the South African legislation on
affirmative action, defines psychological assessment and includes a clause on the measurement of
potential. This clause was included because of the recommendations of concerned psychologists who
feared continued discrimination in the assessment domain. Some of these assessment tools are now
being used worldwide.
The need to broaden diversity in the workplace also required a lot of focus and gave rise to
interventions aimed at creating better working relationships and understanding amongst the diverse
people of South Africa. However, this is not unique to South Africa, as the work of Hofstede, Stein and
Gardner has demonstrated.
Diversity does not only relate to gender and race – it also relates to cultural beliefs, ways of doing
things, emotional and other intelligences. This paper covers these issues as they relate to the personal
experience of the author. The author is a psychologist who has worked in South Africa and others
countries using assessments to identify a wide variety of competencies, talents and beliefs, and
incorporated these into her work in selection and talent development over many years. This study
aims to tell the story of how South Africa has moved from an era of adversity to diversity. This may
generate valuable insights for other African and non-African countries who are dealing with diversity
challenges in psychological testing.
15:15-15:50 What risk type are you? An introduction to Risk Type Compass
Trickey, G.E., Psychological Consultancy Ltd., UK
Survival relies on balancing opportunity against risk, and the stakes are high. Risk related themes
permeate personality and establish individual predispositions towards risk. At one extreme are people
who are apprehensive, anxious and restrained and, at the other extreme, imperturbable and calm.
The former remain covert, secure in their familiar surroundings, while the latter intrepidly venture to
explore the unknown and seek out new opportunities. Survival is the predominant preoccupation of
our species and a source of personal insecurity. The media thrives on human anxieties: through
recreational activities people toy with fear, from cartoons to horror movies. Through suspense
television, roller-coasters, extreme sports and violent computer games people push their exposure to
fear to the extreme of manageable their limits. Through competitive sports people simulate tribal
conflict and test their metal. Thus, risk, and avoidance of it, is central to the human condition and to
human nature. At Psychological Consultancy Ltd. we have identified eight distinct Risk Types based on
personality. Building on the global consensus achieved by the Five Factor Model of personality, we
extracted all the risk related themes as a platform for our research. Exploratory Factor analysis
identified two bipolar dimensions that provide the architecture for the Risk Type Compass. The Risk
Type Compass is thus a personality questionnaire that defines a continuous spectrum of risk
dispositions, with the eight Risk Types providing the reference points to structure interpretation and
communication. In this presentation delegates will be introduced to this interesting new measure, its
background, its theoretical and conceptual under-pinning, and its psychometric properties.
15:55-16:30 A business case for consulting in Agriculture
Wiggett, J.J., JvR Psychometrics, South Africa
The Agriculture Industry is the foundation of any developing economy. In South Africa it contributes
between two to six percent toward the South African Gross Domestic Product (GDP). The agriculture
industry is also essential for food security, social welfare, job creation and ecotourism. This industry
has undergone significant structural changes in South Africa over the past 20 years. Farming units is
dependent on large-scale intensive production, intended for export due to economies of scale that
kicks in as farming units became bigger. Competing with international markets (import and export)
implies that farmers need to change the way they have been farming. One area where change is
evident is within human resources. Traditionally the industry is known to be highly dependent on
unskilled workers. There has, however, been a dramatic decrease in the Agriculture sector’s
contribution to employment. For example, a 19.2% decrease in employment was recorded between
2009 and 2011. The industry did recover from these losses with only a 3.8% decline between 2009 and
2013. Similar trends are occurring internationally. There are various reasons for the decrease in
employment, such as mechanisation and drastic increase in wages. Interestingly enough president
Zuma identified Agriculture as a key job driver, recommitting to the target set out in the National
Development Plan (NDP) for the agriculture sector to create one million jobs by 2030. Worldwide,
however, it appears that farmers are becoming more reliant on a smaller and a semi-skilled and skilled
workforce. Being dependent on a smaller workforce with unique skills requires effective Human
Resource (HR) strategies. Farmers are faced with challenges especially regarding selection, motivation,
development, management and the retaining of talent in the workforce. It has therefore become
essential to provide appropriate consulting services to the Agricultural sector to support their human
resource needs. This presentation highlights the human resource needs as illustrated by thematic
analysis of interviews with commercial farm owners.
15:55-16:30 A critical look at educational psychology in a rural context in South Africa
Osler, M., JvR Psychometrics, South Africa
The focus of this paper will be on a study that is investigating Educational Psychology practice in rural
areas of South Africa. More specifically, it will focus on the way in which Educational Psychology
presents itself in rural areas, the need for Educational Psychology in rural communities, the benefit of
Educational Psychology for rural areas, the changes that have occurred in the practice of psychology
in rural communities, the challenges psychology faces in rural communities and whether or not
Educational Psychologists received adequate training to deal with the psychological needs of people
residing in rural communities. The data will be collected using semi-structured interviews with
Educational Psychologists from rural areas in South Africa. A thematic content analysis will be used to
analyse the data.
15:55-16:30 Being visually deaf and auditory blind and the effect of dyslexia in our SA schools
Stark, S., Red Apple Dyslexia Association, South Africa
The development of the Stark-Griffin Dyslexia Range of diagnostic tools and therapeutic manuals, with
standardised norms, is an excellent opportunity to diagnose dyslexia in scholars as well as dyslexic
adults in South Africa. This test is unique in the sense that it defines seven types of dyslexia as well as
the severity thereof. Inadequate eidetic- and phonetic processing in the left hemisphere cause
dyslexics to be visually deaf and auditory blind. We are now able to identify dyslexics in our country
and therefore need to adapt to setting the appropriate concessions and accommodations in schools
and the work environment. Problems with implementing the latest conduct policy that was introduced
by the Department of Education in 2014 may need some investigation and will be discussed.
Diagnostic procedures as well as measures to assist the dyslexic person in South Africa, will be
discussed.
15:55-16:30 The measurement of unconscious constructs
Du Toit, D.H., North West University, South Africa
Botha, E., North West University, South Africa
Koen, V., North West University, South Africa
The purpose of this paper is to explore the measurement of unconscious constructs. The primary
question raised is: how can a person answer a questionnaire on constructs which are unknown to
him/herself? The issue of test takers’ rights to present themselves in a positive light and the difference
between the test taker’s perceptions of themselves compared to how others view them will also be
discussed. The relevant paradigms used in understanding psychological constructs, such as
reductionist, social constructivist and interpretative, will be discussed. Many of the constructs of
importance in the development of a person, such as leadership and emotional Intelligence, is
recognised to be built on largely unconscious intra-personal aspects, such as awareness, resilience,
emotional control, maturity, openness to change, flexibility, agility, grit, low defensiveness and low
sensitivity. Most people are unable to objectively answer questions on aspects such as these.
The method is mainly literature study based, though some findings from different field studies will be
reported. Recommendations will be made regarding the need for developing measurement
instruments to measure unconscious aspects. Scope of practice concerns and constraints will also be
discussed.
08:15-09:00 Keynote: Guiding the individual through ages and stages of lifelong development
Murphy, E., CAPT, USA
Understanding human development gives us fresh tools for guiding individuals toward self-knowledge
and helping them learn to be the best they can be. One of these tools is the theory of personality
developed by Carl Jung and further refined by Isabel Myers. His theory has multiple facets, but this
session focuses on the development of the mental functions of psychological type: Sensing, Intuition,
Thinking, and Feeling. Examples and stories will demonstrate how type is expressed as a toddler,
young child, adolescent, and older adult. Factors that inhibit and enrich development at each of these
ages can alert us to ways we might adjust our communication and interaction patterns to
accommodate the type developmental level of another person.
Type predispositions are only one of the multiple factors that influence human growth and
development. Jung provides a model that has universal application, giving us insight into how people
across cultures gather information and make decisions. Although these type patterns are consistent,
the expression of these patterns varies individually across ages and stages of development and can be
altered by cultural norms. If the functions develop, people can move from unconscious expression to
conscious management, or they can remain locked at the unconscious level. Behaviour is always a
choice but energy for that behaviour is an innate part of human composition.
This session reveals patterns of development as a way of giving practical insight into a complicated
theory. Real-world examples are accompanied with practical hints for enriching the developmental
process. The more we understand the levels of human development, the more likely we can use that
information to help improve the human condition of all.
09:00-09:45 Keynote: Hiring, leading and developing a 21st century workforce – Are you ready?
Wheldon, H., MHS, Canada
The world is changing faster than ever. Consider the following:
A person today handles more information in a day that a person in the 1500’s did in their
whole life
Jobs such as Social Media Manager, Wind Farm Engineer and App Designer did not exist 5 years
ago – and no one knows how long any job will exist any more
Jobs such as Switchboard Operator, Typesetter have disappeared, and any within many jobs,
any task that can be automated is being automated changing what people do every day
The pace of change is only anticipated to accelerate, posing challenges for employees, hiring
personnel, manager, leaders and organisations. What people are hired to do today, may not be what
they do tomorrow. As a result, employees need to come armed with the ability to learn, not just a
fixed set of knowledge and skills. Workers in the 21st century need to be flexible, culturally adaptable,
self-motivated and above all curious.
Hiring is no longer about matching a set of skills and experiences with a job description. Screening for
potential is new and challenging. This presentation will address how we can screen, assess and hire
for potential as well as how we can adapt and change our leadership and management practices to
keep these employees engage and retain them within the organisation.
10:30-11:05 Professional HR practice: The emergence of HR standards and competencies in Africa
Meyer, M., SABPP, South Africa
Despite vast human capital gaps, the continent of Africa is leading the world regarding HR making the
transition from a “pseudo-profession” to a fully-fledged statutory profession, with Zambia being the
first country for HR achieving legal status as a profession. Furthermore, Kenya and Zimbabwe are in
an advanced stage of development towards statutory recognition. Likewise, in 2013, South Africa
became the first country in the world with national HR standards. Developed by the SA Board for
People Practices (SABPP), the South African HR Standards provide a solid framework on how HR should
be practised based on 13 national HR standards, ranging from strategic HR management, talent
management, HR risk management, organisation development, to HR measurement. These standards
have attracted interest from 17 countries and have already been exported to Zambia, Namibia and
Swaziland, in addition to significant appetite from Zimbabwe, Botswana, Kenya and Ghana. Moreover,
rather than adopting western HR Competencies models not relevant in the African context, a South
African HR competency model has been developed taking cognisance of local socio-economic realities.
Thus, uniquely positioned HR standards and competencies for the African environment have emerged
to professionalise HR in Africa, and therefore usher in a new era of significance for HR professional
practice. A more human approach to HR Management balanced with business needs has been
achieved. Hence, the contribution of African HR practices to the body of knowledge and standards of
practice embodies a new era of people-driven organisation cultures in Africa. The paper concludes
with an integration of HR standards and competencies positioned as two sides of the same coin in
moving the HR profession forward in Africa. Ultimately, a mix of technical HR, people skills and
business acumen constitute African HR professional practice.
10:30-11:05 Selected African capacity building initiatives and priority skills: Some missing links
Magadlela, D., Development Bank of Southern Africa, South Africa
The objective of the Pan Africa Capacity Building Programme (PACBP) is to help develop critical skills
needed to advance Africa’s development, and promote sustainable infrastructure development across
the rest of the Sub -Saharan region. The rationale for the capacity building partnership was the
identification of a growing professional skills gap in the current African educational and professional
training landscape. The gap is preventing the continent from meeting its infrastructure development
objectives and is also considered as one of the main obstacles to an efficient and timely delivery of
adequate basic infrastructure. The PACBP has three pillars: a Masters in Infrastructure Programme, a
Young Professionals Graduate Internship Programme and a Short Courses for Professional Skills
Enhancement. As African economies establish new markets and seek to attract global businesses with
the promise of rich investment returns, the continent’s search for knowledgeable, committed and
highly skilled Africans to drive the continent’s growth towards new levels of development that benefit
the majority of the people is required. Africa needs to build a large pool of business leaders that
represent their businesses, and their national and regional development objectives. This calls for a
shared understanding of the priority skills that Africa needs to focus on. These skills will help Africa
sustain the current levels of economic growth that have seen Africa become, once again, attractive as
an investment destination. The same skills will also ensure that there are capable Africans that are
able to drive, manage, re-focus, and sustain high levels of economic development required to address
infrastructure backlogs, and other gaps/lags that the continent experiences. Not only does investing
in Africa promise rich returns, it also carries with it great potential for growth into so-far uncharted
markets and business territories. It is vital for African businesses and governments to ensure that the
thrust to build high-levels skills does not focus only on technical areas, but also addresses
management, leadership, and human interrelationship skills that include coaching, mentoring, and
emotional intelligence. A winning skills development combination requires a suit of multiple skills that
help to grow a well-rounded African professional.
10:30-12:25 Symposium: Type and Culture
Do out-of-preference (OOPs) results on the MBTI® Step II results offer insights into the
culture of a collective? An exploration
Venkat, J., Anahat, India
Mahesh, C.S., Anahat, India
The MBTI® Step II Form Q report offers the opportunity for an understanding of an individual that goes
beyond the four preferences highlighted in Step I of the MBTI®. The twenty facet pairs offer a nuanced
approach to understanding the individual’s distinctive profile. The Out of Preference scores (OOPs) in
particular add great value in helping an individual understand how she has incorporated aspects of
the less preferred preferences into her unique ways of living.
The OOPs are understood to be the result of significant long-term influences. Culture could be one
such influence. This exploratory research looks at differences in OOPs scores across cultures to see if
these differences might highlight some cultural differences too. MBTI® Step II results were drawn from
samples of employed adults across different countries. Numerical differences in the OOPs across each
facet were tested for significance. The results offer hypotheses about the culture and about cultural
differences to be explored further. While the research thus far focuses on India with other countries
as reference for comparison, people familiar with both the MBTI® Step II and the culture of a country
may be able to explain some of the cultural nuances of the country through the interpretation of the
OOPs.
Type distribution and the expression of type in Africa
Taylor, N., JvR Psychometrics, South Africa
Olivier, S., JvR Psychometrics, South Africa
The application of psychometric questionnaires in countries in Africa has presented a number of
challenges for practitioners from numerous quarters. There are furious debates as to whether the
internationally accepted theories on psychology hold “as is” on the African continent, or whether
there should be a purely indigenous psychology in each African country. The balance between the
purely universal and purely relative views is how cross-cultural psychology is established. The practice
of “transporting and testing” existing models and instruments from an etic perspective is vital in
establishing the cross-cultural utility of theories. Nonetheless, while some countries may be more
familiar with assessment than others, psychometric instruments are still used only sparingly in many
African countries.
Data from over 30000 participants in 16 African countries were obtained through use of the MBTI
assessment in applied settings. The distribution of type across these 16 countries appears very similar,
with the overwhelming majority of reported types being STJ. The implications around whether these
results are indeed representative of respondents throughout Africa or reflect issues around
psychometric measurement, self-report questionnaires, self-awareness and the practice of reflection
in collective cultures will be discussed. Implications for using self-report assessments in African
countries will be presented.
A view on Type and Culture through the lens of Rosinski’s Cultural Orientation Framework
Moyle, P., OPP Ltd, UK
Kendall, E.B., OPP Ltd, UK
The purpose of this symposium is to establish the influence of a number of individual differences on
cultural orientation in order to guide the design of effective teambuilding interventions for
multicultural teams. The aim is to establish the relative influence of personality (as measured by the
MBTI assessment), country of origin, country of residence, age, gender and level of seniority on
greater cultural orientation (as measured by Rosinski’s Cultural orientations Framework). All
participants supplied their MBTI Best Fit type, along with some biographical information at the same
time as completing the Cultural Orientations Framework questionnaire. A sample of 880 participants
drawn from Australia, France, Germany, India, South Africa and UK provided data. The participants
were working mostly in coaching, consulting, education, HR or learning and development.
Differences in 17 dimensions of cultural orientation were examined using a series of univariate ANOVA
Findings. Individual differences in personality were found to have a greater effect on cultural
orientation than country of origin, country of residence, age, gender, and level of seniority. Country
of residence was found to have a greater impact than country of origin, probably reflecting adaptation
to the current culture – particularly in terms of the competitive-collaborative dimension. While
national differences do exist, both in terms of country of residence and country of origin, this study
suggests that personality differences, irrespective of nationality of location are more important when
it comes to understanding our cultural orientation. It is suggested therefore that an understanding of
personality type can be an effective bridge between cultures.
Scalar equivalence of the MBTI assessment across 18 countries
Morris, M.L., CPP Inc., USA
Cooley, T.C., Deluxe Corporation, USA
Using a large international data set, Bartram showed that country level Big Five personality means and
standard deviations (SDs) strongly predicted independent country level measures of Hofstede’s
cultural dimensions and other indicators (e.g., cultural tightness, global competitiveness). Using a
different personality measure, the current study attempted to replicate and extend Bartram’s
findings. In the current study, the MBTI assessment, which measures four personality dimensions
(Extraversion-Introversion [EI], Sensing-Intuition [SN], Thinking-Feeling [TF], and Judging-Perceiving
[JP]) that are similar to the Big Five, with the exception of neuroticism , was completed by 15,064
people across 18 countries and 16 languages, and compared to a variety of independent county level
measures.
The current study generally replicated Bartram’s results around SDs, where applicable. An overall
measure of SDs (α=.89) on the MBTI was correlated with Hofstede’s power distance (r = -.78),
pragmatism (-.70), individualism (.76), and indulgence (.62), but not with masculinity/femininity (-.13)
or uncertainty avoidance (-.20). SDs on the MBTI were also correlated with cultural tightness (r = -
.52), human development index (.74), overall life satisfaction (.76), economic freedom (.89), global
peace index (-.50; higher scores indicating less peace), globalization (.65), proportion atheist (-.78),
and good governance (.74). Bartram’s findings around mean personality scores were not generally
replicated, however. The current findings provide some support the scalar equivalence of the MBTI
assessment and suggest that broad, normal personality measures can account for significant variance
in a variety of country level measures. Measures of personality variance, in particular, may be useful
in explaining and understanding cultural differences.
10:40-12:25 Symposium: Young children mathematic conceptual development assessment and
intervention
Key numerical concepts at the age of 4-8 years: An integrative six-level model of
cumulative arithmetic skills development
Fritz-Stratmann, A., University of Duisburg-Essen, Germany and University of Johannesburg, South
Africa
Ehlert, A., University of Potsdam, Germany and University of Johannesburg, South Africa
As in other countries, there has also been a rise in demand for better early mathematics assessments
in Germany. Until recently, most of the tests were based on the school curriculum. More recently,
there has been a shift, and nowadays achievement tests are based on models and theories of
psychological development of early mathematics skills. Our starting point for the construction of a test
was the question whether arithmetic key concepts are developed hierarchically and whether children
develop more sophisticated cognitive structures step by step. Such a developmental sequence would
allow researchers and teachers to allocate every child to a certain developmental level of conceptual
understanding and to describe its knowledge qualitatively. Based on literature and empirical results
concerning central concepts in arithmetical learning, a six level model was created. In two cross-
sectional studies, 1583 pre-school and early primary-school children completed an arithmetic test
based on this model. The results provide evidence for the validity of the proposed model as a model
of cumulative numerical concepts and arithmetic skills development. In this paper the comprehensive
model of cumulative arithmetic competence development at the age of four to eight years will be
presented.
The migration of an instrument from Europe to South Africa: Validating the conceptual
model and moving on to standardisation
Henning, E., University of Johannesburg, South Africa
Herholdt, R., Jet Education Services, South Africa
Balzer, L., Swiss Federal Institute for Vocational Education and Training, Switzerland
Ragpot, L., University of Johannesburg, South Africa
The research reported in this paper is the narrative of a migration of a diagnostic test for young
children (the MARKO-D), when they are first making their world mathematical and symbolical. To
explore how children develop in maths in the early years, it is important to utilise a test that has
already gone through the original processes of standardisation and that is based on contemporary
theories of conceptual development, as found in both cognitive developmental psychology and in
neuroscience. Arguing that research on conceptual development of young children is a neglected area
in educational research in South Africa and that there is no standardised test to assess children, with
local norms, we propose to show how a test from Europe developed in South Africa from the time it
was encountered three years ago.
We also discuss what the pilot studies on 1600 children have yielded so far and what some of the
linguistic issues of the translations are highlighted.) In this paper we will illustrate how the pilot studies
yielded data that, after five different tests administrations, show that the test is functional for South
African conditions (in four languages) and that the Rasch modelling held successfully in these
languages. We thus report that the conceptual model of five levels of competence was sustained in
the Such a test is essential for the country, where there are only imported tests in English, and where
the norms are not South African. This means that only privileged children will have access to a
diagnostic test, which is expensive in use in private practice. When the MARKO-D is standardised and
normed, it will be made available to the public education departments in all nine provinces of the
country, where the majority of children’s achievements drops radically after Grade 3, and where
suitable support (remedial) material is not always aligned with what current theory of conceptual
development and conceptual change argue.
Iterations of translations from German to four South African languages in a mathematics
competence test
Ragpot, L., University of Johannesburg, South Africa
Henning, E., University of Johannesburg, South Africa
This paper aims to analyse examples of translation issues of the MARKO-D test. During two years of
translations from German to four languages used in South Africa, it was evident that although we aim
to minimise shifts in meaning across languages, it remains a challenge to capture meaning in the same
way. In pilot tests with back-translations and cross translations it was found that not only are there
dialectical influences within a language such as isiZulu or Sesotho, but also that translations via English
pose specific problems. We selected all the items that showed signs of translation problems in the
MARKO-D test during the Rasch modelling process and found that the ‘gremlins’ were indeed
attributable to language. The research is a form of discourse analysis, with the central argument being,
in the words of Elizabeth Spelke, that “(n)atural language plays a pivotal role in the development of
abstract numerical and geometric concepts and does so by serving as the primary medium for
combining information productively across distinct systems of core knowledge”. We have some
evidence from the research on 1600 children that language effect can be minimised (if not completely
neutralised) to ensure unidimensionality of the instrument used to test mathematics competence.
Our argument is that if it is language that serves as combinatory agent in assembling knowledge to
form concepts once children learn through language and other symbols , then it would mean that they
lodge much of their early understanding of maths (in the forming of concepts) in their use of language.
Tests that assess their knowledge in oral interview format are thus not free of the effects of language,
although, after several iterations, such a test could come close to a reliable translation.
In the analysis we make use of Vygotsky’s proposition that external speech becomes internal speech
(thinking) and that words are thus semiotic tools that do not actually form, but that facilitate concept
formation by becoming placeholders during conceptual change or agents for assembling information
to form concepts. The following results will be discussed: 1) Number names as activity: In isiZulu
“shiya” means to “leave behind or abandon.” Thus, for example, “yisishiyagalombili” means you leave
two behind. This gives an indication of moving on with the new quantity. It gives a clear image of
partitioning and pre-empts an understanding of part and whole while the learner is still at the counting
level. In addition, the following will be elaborated upon: 2) Number names as ‘to be’, as some counting
names precurse cardinality; 3) Number names as concrete notions; and 4) Number names that
presuppose finger counting.
A diagnostic test to assist in the early identification of South African grade R-1 learners
with severe learning difficulties in mathematics
Herholdt, R., Jet Education Services, South Africa
Henning, E., University of Johannesburg, South Africa
The paper explores the potential benefits of a diagnostic test that could be used to assist in the early
identification of South African grade R or 1 learners with severe learning difficulties in mathematics.
These benefits become apparent when learner performance in South Africa is considered. We argue
that, in the absence of standardized tests or test batteries that have been specifically designed and
standardized for the identification of dyscalculia in South Africa, a test which could assist in identifying
learners with severe difficulties in arithmetic and early numerical concepts, could serve as an initial
screening tool in a wider clinical investigation. Henning and Ragpot found that there are no
standardised tests of arithmetic and numerical skills, which are based on a solid theoretical model and
have been standardized in more than one of the official languages, available in South Africa. The
Mathematik–und Rechenkonzepte für de 1. Klasse- Diagnose (MARKO-D) test was developed as a
measure of numerical concepts and arithmetic skills for learners aged between four and eight. . In
Germany, research reported that dyscalculic grade 1, 2 and 3 learners had significantly lower scores
on the MARKO-D.
This study explores evidence of validity of the South African MARKO-D in the identification of learners
with severe difficulties in the numerical concepts and arithmetic through the research question: What
is the evidence of utility validity for the South African MARKO-D test with regard to identifying grade
1 English second language speakers with difficulties in the development of numerical concepts and
arithmetic? Supporting evidence for the hypothesis that learners with identified learning difficulties
in mathematics (number concept and arithmetical calculation specifically) ,in both full-time
mainstream and remedial schooling, obtain significantly lower scores on the MARKO-D than their
typical developing peers, would provide evidence of utility validity for the MARKO-D.
Such evidence of validity could be used in a validity argument for the interpretation of scores
significantly below the expected norm on the MARKO-D as an indication of the existence difficulties
of in the measured construct, namely numerical concepts and arithmetical calculation. An argument
can then be made for the MARKO-D serving as a useful starting point in a wider clinical investigation
to diagnose dyscalculia or other causes of poor achievement in mathematics.. This study falls within
the broader category of studies in the arena of test development, and specifically within the area of
psychometric validation of a test. Results from the mix modality research data that was collected
during this study will be presented. Quantitative data of person rank orders according to probalistic
calculations of person ability is suitable for this particular study because it is an acknowledged source
for validity evidence stemming from test responses We will present findings from both quantitative
and qualitative concomitant mathematical achievement information which was gathered from school
reports, teacher’s rating of mathematical achievement by teachers and/or previous educational or
psychological assessments.
11:10-11:45 Hitting the mark but missing the point: Reflecting on the design, implementation and
monitoring of a performance management programme across African borders
Veldsman, D., The HR Touch, SAB, South Africa
Mojapelo, M., The HR Touch, SAB, South Africa
Globalisation, innovation and a need for leaner organisations that are agile and responsive
characterises the knowledge economy work place. A key focus on enabling a high performance culture
seems to be prevalent on most executive score cards. Within this context however, it seems as if
performance management is currently characterised in most organisations through its irrelevance to
actual delivery, the lack of transparency and sense of favouritism and confusion that it creates. Line
Managers cringe with the burden of managing the performance process; employees experience a
sense of fear and above all performance is still seen as an isolated event as opposed to an integral part
of the business life cycle.
The research will reflect on lessons learnt through the design, development and implementation of a
performance process for a multi-national organisation with operations in Nigeria, South Africa,
Namibia, Botswana, Lesotho, Swaziland and Zambia. The study is based upon a qualitative action
research design that focused on a personal narrative inquiry based upon the experiences of two team
leaders that implemented the different phases of the over a 12 month period. The study will further
also contextualise the interventions, process and lessons learnt from a cultural, behavioural and
contextual perspective. The findings will focus on describing the understanding of the lessons learnt
in terms of cultural differences and nuances across African boundaries, call for a new type of
performance approach that focuses on principles versus process and a need to enable managerial
competency as opposed to technological efficiency.
11:10-11:45 People development in Africa – Lessons learnt
Marais, C., Leadership for Conservation in Africa, South Africa
Having worked in 16 African countries for 10 years doing conservation development work and having
been to more than 30 Africa countries, Chris Marais will share his experiences of people development
in Africa.
From an economic growth perspective, Africa is the place to be! Stimulated by the extraction
industries such as mining, oil and forestry, the economic growth in Africa is drawing companies from
all over the world to explore the fast growing markets. In parallel to the economic growth Africa is
also the fastest growing continent in terms of population, with a “younger-growing” populace which
is speeding up urbanisation and related challenges.
In light of all the challenges Africa has faced in the past, people development has not received much
or the right attention. On the other hand there seems to be a tendency for international investors and
developers not to contextualise assessment methodologies in the process of standardisation and
validation. Without going into the detail of these processes, Chris will share his Africa-experience and
lessons learned with reference to the Africa perception, resistance, limitations, opportunities, the
need for contextualisation and proposed way forward.
11:50-12:25 Organisational and climate surveys: The casualties of psychometric ignorance
Rothmann, I., WorkWell Research Unit, North West University, & Afriforte, South Africa
Rothmann, I., WorkWell Research Unit, North West University, & Afriforte, South Africa
De Beer, L., WorkWell Research Unit, North West University, South Africa
Organisational and climate surveys are widely used by companies to investigate perceived issues,
benchmark against peers, measure progress and guide interventions. In many cases, custom surveys
are developed to serve this purpose constructed with consensus-based questions, and reporting for
this generally takes the form of descriptive statistics that does not consider measurement error.
Therefore, the reality is that survey development is often driven solely by business requirements,
ignoring important psychometric requirements. A “what you don’t know, can’t hurt you” approach.
The question is: How many important business decisions are be based on survey results that do not
control for reliability, validity, equivalence and bias? Without confirming the latter, a survey is merely
an unscientific opinion poll. This presentation builds the case for scientific psychometric practices
when implementing organisational and climate surveys in industry.
11:50-12:25 How behaviour mediates the relationship between personality and organisational safety
Nei, D.S., Hogan Assessments, USA
Foster, J., Hogan Assessments, USA
Nichols, S., Hogan Assessments, USA
Research on organisational safety has traditionally focused on job-tasks and working conditions. Due
to advancements in these areas, some have concluded that human error is now the most significant
cause of workplace accidents and injuries in many industries. In this presentation, we will present data
illustrating the role of personality in organisational safety. It will also be demonstrated that this
relationship can best be explained by focusing on the mediating role of safety-related
behaviours. Most research on personality and organisational safety focuses either on specific
personality scales or Five Factor Model (FFM) measures. These results indicate that a range of
personality measures predict organisational safety. Correlations between FFM scales and safety
outcomes fail to account for how specific personality facets predict safety-related behaviours. This
has three implications for research on personality and safety namely: (1) that broad inventories that
reliably measure personality scales are better at predicting organisational safety than narrow
inventories;(2) that personality facets are more predictive of organisational safety than broad
personality scales; and (3) that measuring and understanding the role of safety-related behaviours is
critical to understanding the relationship between personality and safety. In this session, we will
review six behaviours (i.e., Complying with Rules, Avoiding Unnecessary Risks, Remaining Vigilant,
Responding Appropriately to Safety Threats, Managing Stress, and Adhering to Training) that impact
organisational safety and their personality-based antecedents. We will also discuss the value of using
this information to develop customised selection and training programs tailored to the individual
personality characteristics associated with critical safety-related behaviours within specific jobs and
organisations.
13:25-14:00 Personality can give you wings
Fitzsimmons, M., Psychometrics Canada, Canada
Visagie, A., MGI, South Africa
One of the critical elements in ensuring the safety of passengers and optimal flight performance is the
selection and development of an excellent flight crew. Most airlines focus on the technical aptitude
and proficiency of flight crew during the recruitment process, but is ability the only factor that
distinguishes excellence? Working with South African and Canadian airlines this presentation
examines the recruitment approaches of carriers that operate in unique environments, with different
fleets, cultures and staff requirements. How does personality impact success in the role of pilot or
flight atte