157
!"#$% ’()*’+,-".+/$*"01$2 $3/(’$4 56+78" 9"’’+0.$ +:#(3+7(’$%; !"#$%&’(")%* , "#-./",.%01*("’ & 203.4"4&50)6"’ 307%01*(")%& 8 9:;< =>8>

01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

  • Upload
    doxuyen

  • View
    222

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

!"#$%&'()*'+,-".+/$*"01$2&$3/('$4

56+78"&9"''+0.$&+:#(3+7('$%;

!"#$%&'(")%*+,+"#-./",.%01*("'+&+203.4"4&50)6"'

307%01*(")%&

8+9:;<+=>8>

Page 2: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

=

Page 3: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

!"#$$%&''#$$$&(

)$&**

!"#$%&'()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8

")(",.(.+,+8??@+4AB+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4A+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.C&&+)-03)%,.+D.))","'+&(E"-D.C&&+FG+H+IIJ8=KK?+"%+8I+&L(7+=>>=4A

+,-./0123345$627,89$3A2A(A+<=>=>?"10('/#+7(B+3A2A(A+MAFAN030-O.(",.B+3A2A(A+@=A=A"-(1+7(B+3A2A(A+!=A=B+?%1+7B+3A2)A(A+C=@=!?+:+/*$1+7B+3A2A(A+>=D=E$#)?F'$1+7A+

:2;48153268<$7$2;=.>27.8,?<325$1$@,-.A2A1B,6/25$-,C8,?<32681D$F"3+-03.6C&0'+PANAQ-$1","'+&+RASAT&1&("'AP.U5($'+-03.6%"-+)0-&&+PANAQ-$1",.A+M$2U)6+8+9:;<B+=>8>A+

VWWX+8I=YJ@;>:M + ,$2U)60 + .(.1&/&-UL%)7 + D0%"3"1"4&50)6&0B + %0"-0%&50)6&0B+

D0%"3&50)6&0 + & + 3&3.6%&50)6&0 + .)206%$ + 2-"7,10(&7+!ZN[\G]PZ!\G + , + "#-./",.(&&A + !"#$%&'(")%*+-.))D.%-&,.0%)7 + 6.6 + ")"#"0 + ),"')%," + )"J"-4.(&/",.((")%&+C0((")%("J/(.5&D$O + 501",050)6&O + "%("^0(&' + , + )E0-0+"#-./",.(&7A+M+)#"-(&60+.(.1&/&-UL%)7+U)1",&7+,"/(&6(",0(&7+&+2-"7,10(&7 + E0("D0(. + )"#$%&'(")%& + , + "#-./",.%01*("D+)""#_0)%,0A+`.))D.%-&,.L%)7+^&-"6&0+,"/D"a(")%&+"#0)2050(&7+"#-./",.%01*($O+)"#$%&'+%*L%"-.D&+&+203.4"4.D&A!#"-(&6 + 2-03(./(.50( + 317 + 203.4"4", + & + .3D&(&)%-.%&,($O+

-.#"%(&6", +^6"1 +& + )&)%0D$ +U2-.,10(&7B + 2-02"3.,.%010' + ,U/",B+.)2&-.(%",+&+)%U30(%",B+/.&(%0-0)",.(($O+,+6U1*%U-")""#-./("D+-./,&%&&+"#-./",.%01*($O+2-"C0))",A+

!"#$$%&''#$$$&()$&**

b+PANAQ-$1",.B+=>8>E=1A13.?FG./,8$-.332A2$1>-.31C$C7?C,86C$62;687,33268<H$1>-.8,?CI$,A2$726@=21>7,-,31,$;,>$62A?.61C$@=.722;?.-.8,?C$>.@=,J.,86C

VWWX+8I=YJ@;>:

;

Page 4: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

:E"K+LM)NK

OD$E382?2A1C$62F;481532681$7$2;=.>27.311

C=@=!?+:+/*$1+7A+!"J#$%&'(.7+"#-./",.%01*(.7+"#_(")%*+c+&)%"5(&6+-./,&%&7+&+)U#d06%+"#-./",.(&7eeeeeeeeeeeeAe@>=>=G0.(H"'1+A+P.)%"7_0)%*+)"#$%&'+&+f2"(.-"^05(")%*g+D0-"2-&7%&'+,+,")2&%.(&&eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeAee8:+@=I=J)0.+7(A+h0%)6"J,/-")1.7+"#_(")%*+&+00+)"J#$%&'($0+O.-.6%0-&)%&6&eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeAAAAAAAA==>=C=J)7(?+7A+Z#-./",.(&0+,+2"&)60+)&DE"(&&eeeeeeeeeeAA;@>>=B+H+7A+!"#$%&0+6.6+03&(&C.+"#-./",.%01*("4"+2-"06%&-",.(&7eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeAAAAAAA:KI=!=D(')4?+7A$i/$6+f!"JgeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA@86=A=K+#*(?+7(A+j&1")"E&7+203.4"4&6&+ZAjAN"1*(",.+&+"#-./$+"#-./",.(&7+eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeAAAAAA@YL=M=C(?""7A+F"/(.,.%01*(.7+).D")%"7%01*(")%*+U5._&O)7+6.6+2-032")$16.+&+-0/U1*%.%+"#-./",.%01*($O+)"#$%&'eeeeAAAAAAAAY;<=C=N+#+701(%A+!"#$%&'($'+2"%0(C&.1+"#-./.+a&/(&+-0#0(6.eAAAeAY?

PD$:2;48153268<$O$@=1301@$28/=4825$@,-.A2A1/1

I=P=Q#+$91$4A+!"#$%&0+6.6+"#-./",.%01*(.7+)%-.%04&7AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAIIQ=D=K+7(?"7(R&&D=I=S$?$'(D$!-03.+&+)"#$%&0k+6+3&3.6%&60+%*L%"-)6"4"+)"2-","a30(&7eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeAAK:D=D=D$#1"0R&6=C=D)2(=+Z#-./",.%01*("0+)"#$%&0+6.6+%*L%"-)6.7+2-.6%&6.eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeAA?8C=I=B)38#"701$4A+Z#-./",.%01*("0+)"#$%&0+E0("D0("1"4&50)6"'+,)%-05&+)+)"C&UD"D+9(.+2-&D0-0+301","'+&4-$+fTU-(.1&)%g<eeeeeeeeeeeeeA??Q=>=K+0."'1+=+Z#-./",.%01*("0+)"#$%&0+f!")03)%,"g+6.6+,)%-05.+)+)"#"'B+)+6U1*%U-"'B+)+D&-"DeeeeeeeeeeeeeeAA88>6=>=J(?$-+7(A+R0%"3$+"%6-$%"4"+"#-./",.(&7+6.6+-0)U-)+04"+)"#$%&'(")%&eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeA+eee88;6=C=B$?$H*"701(%R&6=C=B".#+H(7?+701(%=&Z#-./",.%01*("0+)"#$%&0+6.6+-0)U-)+2-"E0))&"(.1*("4"+)%.(",10(&7+)%U30(%",+203.4"4&50)6"4"+,U/.AAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA88I<=!=M+:+7(R&G=6=@T'(.+7(=&\&2"1"4&7+2-03)%.,10(&'+"+)0#0AAAAAAAAAAAAA8=>>=!=B(#('U1A+!"#$%&7+6.6+)-03.+,/.&D"30')%,&7+)+30%*D&eeAAeAAA8=I6=N=K#8?+7(A+l)1",&7+2-"7,10(&7+)"#$%&'(")%&+"#-./",.(&7eeAA8;Y

:

Page 5: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

mM\Z`[eeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeeAAAAAAAA8:@

OD

E382?2A1C$

62F;481532681$

7$2;=.>27.311

@

Page 6: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

:2F;48153.C$2;=.>27.8,?<3.C$2;J3268<$Q1682B31/$=.>7181C$1$6R;S,/8$2;=.>27.31C

C=@=!?+:+/*$1+7

B#+:?"-( & +/$'+1+4 & 0.(#+0.$=== & B#+:?"-(&

#(0H(/(UV"40% & & & 0"-F$=== &B#+:?"-( & /".01+T+ & & 0$#+.0.7( & $&

:"0H#$3+#'+0.$= & B#+:?"-( & 5-+?+/"W'+4 & 1)?F.)#8;R & 78,

387(UV"&'"H+2+W"4&'(&'(X)&,&H#$78*')U===&B#+:?"-(&X1+?8R &

7#(W/)UV"4&0&)*"'$1(-$===&B#+:?"-(&+:+#7(''82&.#(/$9$4&$&

H#""-0.7"''+0.$=== & ?U/01+4 & #(3+:V"''+0.$R & +/$'+1+0.$&

*"?+7"1(&0#"/$&?U/"4=== &'"7#+3+7& , &Y.+4&:+?"3'$ &*"?+7"*"01$2&

+.'+X"'$4===&@&01+?F1+&"V"&3'(1+-82&1(W/+-)&$3&'(0&$-"'&) &

'(X"4 & +:X"4 & :"/8 & $ & ).#(.8Z & -8 & H+."#%?$ & H+?'+.)&

*"?+7"*"01+4 & +:V'+0.$R & 9"?F'+0.$[ & ( & 3'(*$.R & $ & 9"''+0.F&

0+7-"0.'+4 &W$3'$R & 7'" &1+.+#+4&'"7+3-+W'+&'$ &H+?'+9"''+"&

#(37$.$" & /"."4R & '$ & *)70.7+ & 0+:0.7"''+4R & ?$*'+4&

H+?'+9"''+0.$&)&'(0R&73#+0?82=&L(3#)X"'+&.+R&*.+&07%387(?+ &

?U/"4 & H#"/8/)V$2 & H+1+?"'$4= & 6(/"W'8" & )1?(/8 & +:V$''+4&

W$3'$R & 0.(#+4 & /"#"7'$R & T+#+/01+T+ & /7+#(= & </$'0.7+ & 7"#8R &

/(#+7(7X""&+V)V"'$"&0H?+*"''+0.$&/+7+"''+-)&H+1+?"'$U=&@&

"/7(&?$&0.+$.&'(/"%.F0%R&*.+&70"&Y.+&H+//(".0%&:)17(?F'+-)&

7+3#+W/"'$UR &7+00.('+7?"'$UR&*.+&7+3-+W'+&7+37#(V"'$"&1&

H#+X?+-)= &\.+& O &1 & 0+W(?"'$U & /?% & +/'$2 & $ & 1 & 0*(0.FU & /?% &

/#)T$2&O&/"40.7$."?F'+R&H#+X"/X""=&N"/(&'(0.+%V"T+&,&7&.+-R &

*.+ &'( &#(37(?$'(2 &:8?82 &+:V'+0."4 &'" & 78#+0?$ &'+78"R &H+,

'+7+-)&07%387(UV$"&?U/"4&#(3'82&H+1+?"'$4R&W$7)V$2&#%/+-&,&

'+&7#+3FR&7&+/'+-&-"0."&,&'+&'"&7-"0."=

M + )"C&.1*($O + (.U6.O + 2-& + .(.1&/0 + %&2", + & + E"-D + )"C&.1*($O+"#d03&(0(&' + 1L30' + 2-&(7%. + 6 + -.))D"%-0(&L + "22"/&C&7 + D0a3U+2"(7%&0D +6201.?<3.C $ 68=R/8R=. $9"-4.(&/",.((")%*< + & + 2"(7%&0D+3,68=R/8R=1=27.33.C$T#$%&'(.7<+2;J3268<$92"+1.%$(&+O+noppqrstuv<A+P.&#"100 + 2-"-.#"%.(" + 2"(7%&0 + )%-U6%U-$B + 6"%"-.7 + "2-030170%)7+"%50%1&,"' + -.))%.(",6"' + )"C&.1*($O + -"10'B + EU(6C&' + & + )%.%U)",B+6"%"-$0 + /.(&D.L% +1L3&A +!%-U6%U-. +,)043. +,"/(&6.0% + , + 0)%0)%,0(("D+%050(&&+)"#$%&'B +6"43.+4-U22$+1L30'+)+%0D&+&1&+&($D&+(Ua3.D&+&+,"/D"a(")%7D&+,/.&D"30')%,UL%+3-U4+)+3-U4"D+&+"#d03&(7L%)7A+

Q"DDU(&%.) +,"/(&6.0% + %.DB + 430 +(0% +a0)%6" + /.3.(("' +)"C&.1*("'+)%-U6%U-$w + (0)%-U6%U-&-",.((.7 + "#_(")%* +O& x%" + a&/(* + D("a0)%,.+1L30' + 9(" +3, $ =C-2GI $ . $ 7G,68,UI $D0a3U + 6"%"-$D& + )U_0)%,U0%+-"3)%,0((.7 +),7/* +& +"#U)1",10(("0+0L+5U,)%,"+2-&(.310a(")%&+3-U4+3-U4UA + \.6.7 + "#_(")%*B + 6.6 + 2-.,&1"B + 2-&(.310a&% + .6%U.1*("DU+

Y

Page 7: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

(.)%"7_0DUw+)%-U6%U-.+a0+6"-0(&%)7+,+2-"^1"D+&+-.)2-")%-.(70%)7+(.+#U3U_00+2")-03)%,"D+7/$6.B+/.6"(",B+"#$5.0,A$

Q"()%&%U&-UL_&D& + 6.%04"-&7D& + 1L#"4" + 501",050)6"4"+"#d03&(0(&7 + 7,17L%)7 + 2"(7%&7 +67C>1 $ 1 $ 2832V,31CD $F"(7%&0+f"%("^0(&0g +,"/(&6.0% +6.6 +-0/U1*%.% + )""%(0)0(&7+3,UO +)U#d06%", +2"+,$#-.(("DU + "#_0DU + 9&1& + /.3.(("DU< + 317 + (&O + ")(",.(&LA + M + ),"L+"50-03*+f),7/*g+c+x%"+,$-"a30(("0+"%("^0(&0B+2-&+6"%"-"D+&/D0(0(&0+"3(&O + 7,10(&' + 0)%* +@=1B13.+ &/D0(0(&' + 3-U4&Ow + ),7/* + c + x%"+,/.&D"/.,&)&D")%*+7,10(&'B+(0-./1&5&D$O+,+2-0301.O+).D"'+),7/&A+M+501",050)6&O + )""#_0)%,.O + ,$3017L% + D("4""#-./($0 + ),7/& + &+"%("^0(&7k + 2-"E0))&"(.1*($0B + )"C&.1*($0B + 2)&O"1"4&50)6&0B+3UO",($0B + xD"C&"(.1*($0 + & + 3-A + M + -./,&,.L_&O)7 + )"C&.1*($O+"#d03&(0(&7O + 2-"&)O"3&% + 2")%"7(("0 + 2-0"#-./",.(&0 + ),7/0' + &+"%("^0(&'B+&O+,/.&D"2-0,-._0(&0+3-U4+,+3-U4.A

M)0 + %&2$+)"C&.1*("' +"-4.(&/",.((")%& +1L30' +30%0-D&(&-",.($+0,?,74G1$2=1,381=.G1D+ Z-4.(&/",.((")%* +,)043. +"-&0(%&-",.(. +(.+301"w+-,?2$c$1$,68<$0,?<$2;S,-13,31CA+GD0(("+)",D0)%(.7B+4-U22",.7+307%01*(")%* + 7,170%)7 + 41.,($D + &(%04-&-UL_&D + E.6%"-"Dw + 00+6"(6-0%($' + ,&3 + & + O.-.6%0- + "2-03017L% + %&2 + )"C&.1*("'+"-4.(&/",.((")%& + & + 00 + )%-U6%U-UA + \.6&0 + "#d03&(0(&7B + 6.6 +T#)HH( & 0&?$/"#+-R & 1+??"1.$7 & 0 & 0+7".+-R & H(#.$% & 0 & 7+W/"-R & (00+9$(9$% & 0 &

H#"3$/"'.+-R+ 7,17L%)7 + (.&#"100 + -.)2-")%-.(0(($D& + E"-D.D&+)"C&.1*($O+"#d03&(0(&'A+

!04"3(7 +, +"#_0)%,0(("' +a&/(&+)%-.($+3"D&(&-U0% +%.6.7 +E"-D.+)"C&.1*("'+"-4.(&/",.((")%&B+6.6+f6"D.(3.g+6"%"-.7+)",D0_.0%+,+)0#0+f-"3",$0g+50-%$+2-.6%&50)6&+,)0O+,$^020-05&)10(($O+)%-U6%U-A+

!",-0D0((.7 + f6"D.(3.g + ,)043. + &D00% + 1&30-. + 9&("43.+O.-&/D.%&50)6"4"<B + 50%6"0 + -.)2-03010(&0 +EU(6C&'B +a0)%6UL +C010,UL+"-&0(%.C&L+9",1.30(&0+&1&+2")%-"0(&0+/(.5&D"'+)"C&.1*("'+(&^&+c+,+2"1&%&60B +#&/(0)0B +(.U60<B +6"%"-.7+)"+,-0D0(0D+)%.(",&%)7+#./","'+c+,)0D&+-./30170D"'+C0((")%*L+,1.)%&B+#"4.%)%,.+&+.,%"-&%0%.A+

!"C&.1*($0 + "-4.(&/",.((")%&B + &D07 + 307%01*(")%(UL + ")(",U + &+C010,UL+30%0-D&(.C&L+),"0'+)%-U6%U-$B+3"1a($+)U_0)%,",.%*+-",("+)%"1*6"B+)6"1*6"+2-"3"1a.0%)7+).D.+)",D0)%(.7+307%01*(")%*A+F"+("-D0+-0.1&/.C&7 + 6"(6-0%("4" + 301.B + 3")%&a0(&0 + C01& + 3"1a($ + f-.))$2.%*g+3.((UL + "-4.(&/",.((")%*A + Z3(.6" + , + )&1U + %"4"B + 5%" +-+.$7(9$%&/+0.$W"'$%R & )0H"X'+0.$R & +:?(/('$%+ #./","' + C0((")%*L +3,$3.64J.,G.+ , + 2-&(C&20B + 3.(("0 + "#d03&(0(&0 + )%.-.0%)7 + 2"J(","DU+C010"2-0301&%*)7+&+)U_0)%,0(("+20-0)%-"&%*+)%-U6%U-U+)1"a&,^&O)7+"%("^0(&'B+5%"#$+2-"31&%*)7+,"+,-0D0(&A

Z50,&3("B+5%"+317+-0^0(&7+/.3.5+)"C&.1*("'+.3.2%.C&&+&(3&,&3.+6+(.1&5($D+)&)%0D.D+307%01*(")%&+2"3"#($0+"-4.(&/",.((")%&+(.&#"100+xEE06%&,($A+Z(&+#U6,.1*("+f/.%.5&,.L%g+&(3&,&3.+904"+")"#0((")%&B+/.3.%6&< + 2"3 + 6"(6-0%($' + %&2 + )"C&.1*("4" + 2-"&/,"3)%,.A + 9M + )6"#6.O+

I

Page 8: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

/.D05UB+&D0(("+/30)*+6-"0%)7+%.'(.+D"3("4"+)04"3(7+6"D20%0(%(")%("4"+2"3O"3.+,+"#-./",.(&&<A

Z)"#$D + %&2"D + "#d03&(0(&' + c + 2-"%&,"2"1"a($D + )"C&.1*("'+"-4.(&/",.((")%& + c + 7,170%)7 + (0)%-U6%U-&-",.((.7$ ;48153.C$2;J3268<B + 6"%"-.7 + )61.3$,.0%)7 + (. + "#_0' +0,3326832F6G46?2725$")(",0+00+U5.)%(&6",A+j&1")"E+RAy.'30440-+2&).1B+5%"+501",06+c+x%"+(0+%"1*6" + f#$%&0J,JD&-0gB + (" + 5%" + "(B + 41.,($D +"#-./"DB + 0)%* + f#$%&0J)J3-U4&D&gA+\.+a0+&307+,$-.a0(.+).D"'+x%&D"1"4&0'+)1",.+f"#_0)%,"gw+2" + ),"0DU + 2-"&)O"a30(&L +vonsztszv+ c + /(.5&% + f%",.-&_0)%,"g + 9"%+1.%&()6"4"+vonsqv+c+%",.-&_B+3-U4B+2-&7%01*<A+\.6&D+"#-./"DB$2;J3268<I$2;J18,?<3268< $ C7?CH86C $ 6RJ326834G $ .8=1;R82G $ @=1=2-4$B,?27,/.D

Z#_0)%," + )U_0)%,U0% + (0 + 2"%"DUB + 5%" + ,)0 + D$ + & + 6.a3$' + &/ + (.)+)U_0)%,U0Dw+"#_0)%,"+)U_0)%,U0%+2"%"DUB+5%"+"-&0(%.C&7+(.+h-U4"4"+2-&)U_.+6.a3"DU+&/+(.)A+{01",06+0)%*+)U_0)%,"B+,+2-&-"30+6"%"-"4"+D$+(.O"3&D+)%-0D10(&0+,$'%&+/.+2-0301$+).D"4"+)0#7B +)%-0D10(&0 +;48<$62;2H$6$-=RA1G1D+

F-"#10D. + "#_(")%&B + 2"x%"DU + (0 + %"1*6" + )"C&.1*(.7 + &1&+&)%"-&50)6.7w+"(.B+2-&+#"100+41U#"6"D+-.))D"%-0(&&B+7,170%)7+41U#"6"+a&/(0(("'B + "(%"1"4&50)6"'B +?1B326832F6G46?2725 $ @=2;?,G25D$F"(7%("B + 5%" + &D0((" + , + #$%&'("' + "#_(")%& + ,$-._&,.0%)7 + ).D.+a&/(0)2")"#(")%* + &(3&,&3.B + &D0((" + /30)* + "#-0%.0% + "( + /._&%U + "%+,(0^(&O+(0,/4"3+&+2)&O"1"4&50)6"0+#1.4"2"1U5&0A+

M$)^.7 + E"-D. + -./,&%&7 + #$%&'("' + "#_(")%& + O.-.6%0-&/U0%)7+)20C&E&50)6&D&+50-%.D&+c+317+(00+O.-.6%0-("+2-&(7%&0+1L3*D&+3-U4+3-U4.A+G)O"3("'+("-D"'+"#_(")%&+7,170%)7+U)%"'5&,.7+-RW273.C$67C><$D0a3U + 00 + U5.)%(&6.D&B + "#0)205&,.L_.7 + 2"(&D.(&0 + "3("'+&(3&,&3U.1*(")%*L+3-U4"'+&(3&,&3U.1*(")%&A+

|%. + ,"/D"a(")%* + -0.1&/U0%)7 + %"1*6" + 2-& + U)1",&& + 2")%"7(("4"+"#_0(&7B + 3&.1"4.B + ,/.&D("4" +3",0-&7 +& + )"20-0a&,.(&7A +M +"#_(")%&+1L3&+,)%-05.L%)7B+"(.+)"/3.0%)7+)",D0)%($D&+U)&1&7D&+00+U5.)%(&6",w+("-D$B+C01&B+C0((")%&B+)D$)1$+"#_0(&7+&+,/.&D"30')%,&7+,+"#_(")%&+2-&,(")7%)7+&D&+).D&D&B+301.7+00+2"31&(("+62F;4815325$2;J3268<HD

!"J#$%&'(.7 + "#_(")%* + 0)%* + a&,"0 + 03&()%,"B + )210%0(&0 + &+,/.&D"),7/*+3,UO+&+#"100+a&/(0'B+&O+,(U%-0((00+)-"3)%,"+2-&+,(0^(0'+&O + 2-"%&,"2")%.,10((")%&w + )"J#$%&0 + 2-032"1.4.0%B + 5%"B + (0)D"%-7 + (.+2-027%)%,&7+&+f(02-"/-.5(")%*g+3-U4&OB+,)0J%.6&+,"/D"a("+2"(&D.(&0+92")%&a0(&0< + 1&5(")%& +h-U4"4"B + . + %.6a0 +5U,)%," +"%,0%)%,0((")%& + /.+3-U4&O+&+2-03.((")%&B+6"%"-"0+,61L5.0%+,+)0#7+&+iB+&+\$B+&+R$A

!"J#$%&'(UL+"#_(")%*+(0"#O"3&D"+"%1&5.%*+"% +61G;1281B,6/25$6=.J,332681 $ 1 $ X2=G.?<325 $ 2=A.31>27.332681D $M + )&D#&"/0+"%("^0(&7+2-.6%&50)6&+"%)U%)%,UL%B+30')%,UL%+%"1*6"+),7/&B +&D0(("+2"x%"DU+317+)&D#&"/.+O.-.6%0-($+(0-./1&50((")%*+04"+U5.)%(&6",A+M+E"-D.1*("' + "-4.(&/",.((")%& + c + 3-U4.7 + 6-.'(")%*B + /30)* +E.6%&50)6&+

K

Page 9: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

"%)U%)%,UL%+),7/&+900+U5.)%(&6&+(.O"37%)7+1&^*+,+"%("^0(&7O+3-U4+)+3-U4"D<A

G + %"1*6" + , + )"J#$%&'("' + "#_(")%& + )","6U2(")%* + ),7/0' + &+"%("^0(&'+(.O"37%)7+7$A.=G231B,6/2G$,-13687,$9-&)A+8<A+

`&)A8A+\&2$+)%-U6%U-("'+"-4.(&/.C&&+"#_(")%0'

+

F"31&((" + )"J#$%&'(.7 + "#_(")%* + "3(",-0D0((" + (0)0% + , + )0#0 + &+C010,$0+"-&0(%&-$+)",D0)%("'+307%01*(")%&B+&+C0((")%($0+")(",.(&7+),"04"+03&()%,.+6.6+00+6"1106%&,("4"+)U#d06%.A+Z(.+,$)%U2.0%+)-./U+,+3,UO +&2")%.)7Ok +1(1 & 0.#)1.)#'(% & +#T('$3+7(''+0.F &$ & 1(1 & 07%3(''(%&+:V'+0.FA+h-U4"'+"#-./+c+2-&(C&2+3"2"1(&%01*(")%&B+6"43.+"#_(")%*+0)%*+EU(3.D0(%.1*("0+U)1",&0+C0((")%&+&+")D$)10((")%&+(.^&O+C010'B+. + "-4.(&/",.((")%* + 0)%* + )2")"# + E"-D&-",.(&7 + & + 2"3%,0-a30(&7+")(",.%01*(")%&+)",D0)%("+")U_0)%,170D"4"+301.A

F"(7%("B+5%"+,+%.6"D+6.50)%,0+"(.+(0+D"a0%+,"/(&6(U%*+)%&O&'("B+).D.+2"+)0#0w+00+)%.(",10(&0+),7/.("+)"+)20C&.1*($D&+&+")"/(.(($D&+U)&1&7D& + 6.a3"4" + &/ + 00 + U5.)%(&6",A + M(0 + x%&O + U)&1&' + "(. + #$)%-"+,$-"a3.0%)7+1&#"+,+)&D#&"%&50)6UL+)-._0((")%*B+1&#"+,+E"-D.1*(UL+"-4.(&/",.((")%*B+5%"+"#$5("+(.#1L3.0%)7+,+-0.1*($O+"#_0)%,0(($O+2-.6%&6.O+-./("4"+%&2.A++

?

+"%("^0(&7

!"#$%&'&!"#$(

$$$$67C>1$

:1G;1281B,6/.C$2;J3268<Y2=G.?<3.C$2;J3268<

!"#$% &&&&!"#$(}}

+ !"#$%

%

+ !"#$&

2832V,31C

09&'64*,:%"/0&6;%&-*<+13-DO +13-DP

67C>1

Page 10: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

M+%.6"D+6.50)%,0+"(.+(0+D"a0%+,"/(&6(U%*+)%&O&'("B+).D.+2"+)0#0w+00 + )%.(",10(&0 + ),7/.(" + )" + )20C&.1*($D& + & + ")"/(.(($D& + U)&1&7D&+6.a3"4"+&/+00+U5.)%(&6",A+M(0+x%&O+U)&1&'B+"(.+#$)%-"+,$-"a3.0%)7+1&#" + , + )&D#&"%&50)6UL + )-._0((")%*B + 1&#" + , + E"-D.1*(UL+"-4.(&/",.((")%*B+5%"+"#$5("+(.#1L3.0%)7+,+-0.1*($O+"#_0)%,0(($O+2-.6%&6.O+-./("4"+%&2.A

F-& + )"30-a.%01*("D + "2&).(&& + 2-")%-.()%,. + )%.(",10(&7+&(3&,&3U.1*("' + )U#d06%(")%& + 501",06. + (0"#O"3&D" + 2"D(&%*+)103UL_00 + )U_0)%,0(("0 + "#)%"7%01*)%,"k + 501",06 + 2-& + -"a30(&&+2"2.3.0%+,+Ua0+"#a&%"'B+2@2>3.3345$D&-A+

{01",06 + /.-"a3.0%)7B + -"a3.0%)7 + & + a&,0% + , + )&)%0D0 + -0.1*($OB+a&,$OB +O"%7 +& +-./("-"3($O+),7/0'+)+3-U4&D&+1L3*D&B +, +&O+M)%-050k+20-,"(.5.1*(" + ) + -"3&%017D&B + /.%0D + c + ) + #1&/6&D&B + ,2")103)%,&& + & + )+3.1*(&D&A+l)&1&,.7+x%U+D$)1*B+D"a("+,""#_0+)6./.%*k+31A-,$1$31/2A-.$G4$3,$R71-1G$B,?27,/.$-2$1$73,$,A2$67C>,5$6$-=RA1G1D+ Z(+,)043.+)U_0)%,U0%+&+-./,&,.0%)7+,+"#_(")%&+&+50-0/+"#_(")%*A+

T&,.7 + "#_(")%*B + )210%0(&0 + & + ,/.&D"),7/* + a&/(0' + U5.)%(&6",+M)%-05&+U6./$,.0%+(.+%"B+5%"+"3&(+501",06+317+3-U4"4"+(0+2-")%"+"3("+&/ + U)1",&' + &O + )",D0)%("4" + 9, + "3("D + D0)%0< + a&%01*)%,. + (.-73U + )"+D("4&D&+3-U4&D&+U)1",&7D&A+

\.6.7+"#_(")%*+0)%*+EU(3.D0(%.1*("0+2382?2A1B,6/2,$26327.31,$).D"' + ,"/D"a(")%& + ,"/(&6(",0(&7 + )"#)%,0((" + 501",050)6"4" + ,+501",060B +")(",.(&0+04"+("-D.1*("4"+-./,&%&7+&+2"1("C0(("'+a&/(&A+F"+)U%&B+%.6.7+"#_(")%*+3"1a(.+#$%*+2-&(C&2&.1*(" +62F;4815325 $,+)&1U+%"4"B+5%"+00+U5.)%(&6& +Z(0)1&7(($J(0-./301*($[9 $(0)1&7(($+c+,+),"0'+2-0301*("'+&(3&,&3U.1*(")%& +6.a3"4"B +(0-./301*($+c+, +),"0D+2-0301*("D+3UO",("D+03&()%,0A+

M + )"J#$%&'("' + M)%-050 + 1L3& + "#0)205&,.L%B + & + E.6%&50)6&+4.-.(%&-UL%+ +=1)7#(=5,> 0 $)?&3)$%&-*,+ 3-U4 + 3-U4Uw + 2-.," + &+,"/D"a(")%*+)%"7%*+(.+501",050)6"D+2U%&+-./,&%&7B+2"+D0-0+,/-")10(&7+)%.(",&%*)7 +30')%,&%01*($D+-.)2"-73&%010D +& +.,%"-"D +)"#)%,0(("4"+-./,&%&7A

F"1("%. +& +3&(.D&6. +2-0"#-./",.(&'+),7/0' +& +"%("^0(&'+D0a3U+1L3*D&B + 6"%"-$0 + -0.1&/UL%)7 + , + )%-U6%U-0 + )"J#$%&'("' + "#_(")%&B+"#0)205&,.L% + 00 + 41.,(UL + EU(6C&L + , + #$%&& + 501",06. + c +@#%.5,>01"73,*,/A+!+,:8.$"&$&"0.F&+:]"1.&#(37$.$% &c& .+R&*.+&#(37$7(".&$ &#(37$7(".0%w +-0/U1*%.% +-./,&%&7 +/30)* +c +%. +&1& +&(.7 +E"-D.B + %"% +&1&+&("'+U-",0(*+&(3&,&3U.1*("'+&+6"1106%&,("'+)U#d06%(")%&A+

Z3(&D + &/ + #0/U)1",($O + ,$/",", + (.^04" + ,-0D0(& + 7,170%)7+%-0#",.(&0 + 2-7D"4" + & + 2-"E0))&"(.1*(" + "#0)2050(("4" + -0^0(&7+2-"#10D$+2-"&/,"3)%,.+&+,")2-"&/,"3)%,.+B,?27,B32681$Q+62;687,332$B,?27,B,6/2A2+ 7 $ B,?27,/,A + P0)"D(0(("B + 5%" + &/ + ,)0O + E"-D+"#_0)%,0(("' + 2-.6%&6& + &D0((" + "#-./",.(&0 + 2-&/,.(" + -0^.%* + x%U+2-"#10DU+(0+U%&1&%.-("B+.+2"+)U_0)%,UA+M+2"3.,17L_0D+#"1*^&()%,0+)",-0D0(($O + 6"(C02C&' + & + 2-"4-.DD + -./,&%&7 + "#-./",.(&7+

8>

Page 11: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

)61.3$,.0%)7 + 2-&(C&2&.1*(" + (","0 + &/D0-0(&0 + c +ARG.318.=32F.38=2@2?2A1B,6/2,A + j.6%&50)6&B + -05* + &30% + " + 2")%.(",60+#0)2-0C030(%("'+/.3.5&+317+)",-0D0(("4"+"%050)%,0(("4"+"#-./",.(&7k+"(" + 3"1a(" + )%.%* + U(&,0-).1*("' + E"-D"' + )%.(",10(&7 + & + -./,&%&7+#./",$OB + -"3",$O + )2")"#(")%0' + 501",06.B + 2"/,"17L_&O + 0DU + #$%* + &+"%)%.&,.%* + )"#)%,0((UL +501",05(")%*w + #$%* + (0 + %"1*6" +D.%0-&.1"D +&+-0)U-)"D + )"C&.1*("4" + 2-"&/,"3)%,.B + ("B + 2-0a30 + ,)04" + c + 2"31&(($D+)U#d06%"D+6U1*%U-$+&+&)%"-&50)6"4"+30')%,&7A+

h&.106%&6. + )""%("^0(&7 + 3,UO + EU(3.D0(%.1*($O + 6.%04"-&' + c + ,+3.(("D+)1U5.0k+2;=.>27.31,$Q$1(1&^+#-($&+=.>7181,$Q$1(1&0+/"#W('$"B+2-"3"1a.0%+")%.,.%*)7+3.106"+(0+2-"7)(0(($DA+M+"#_0D+)1U5.0B+E"-D.+2"1.4.0%+&+"2-030170%+92"1.4.0%+2-0301$<+)"30-a.(&0w+,+),"L+"50-03*B+)"30-a.(&0+#U6,.1*("+(._U2$,.0%B+&_0%+),"0'+.306,.%("'+E"-D$A+

M+&)%"-&50)6&+(03.,(00+,-0D7B+.+,+(06"%"-$O+)1U5.7O+c+&+2"+)0'+30(*B+)""%("^0(&0+x%&O+3,UO+6.%04"-&'+2-"5&%$,.1")*+3,"76"A+M+"3(&O+6U1*%U-($O + "#)%"7%01*)%,.OB + 6"43. +=.>7181,+ 2"(&D.1")* + 6.6+,68,687,3345I [email protected]$@=20,66B + -./,"-.5&,.,^&')7 +," +,-0D0(&+2" + )"#)%,0(($D + /.6"(.DB + "#-./",.(&0 +?1V< $B.681B32 $,-=&?<7&3"?&02"%0(C&.1+3.(("4"+2-"C0)).+317+-0^0(&7+),"&O+)"C&"6U1*%U-($O+/.3.5A

M+3-U4&O+)"C&.1*("+6U1*%U-($O+"#)%"7%01*)%,.O + 9/30)* +(.&#"100+O.-.6%0-0( + "2$% + )"C&.1&)%&50)6"4" + )%-"&%01*)%,. + , + !!!`<B + 6"43.+3",101+2.E")+2-"06%&-",.(&7B+)%-"&%01*)%,.+(","4"+"#_0)%,.B+(","4"+"#-./. + a&/(&B + (","4" + 501",06.B +=.>7181,+ )%.1" + 2"(&D.%*)7 + 6.6+@=2-R/8I $ >.=.3,, $ @2?.A.,G45 $ =,>R?<8.8 $ R672,31C+ )20C&.1*("+"%E"-D.%&-",.(("4" + "#_0)%,0(("J&)%"-&50)6"4" + "2$%.A +!H"9$(?F'+&+.^+#-(.$#+7(''84 & +:V"0.7"''+,$0.+#$*"01$4 & +H8. & $ & :8?&

0+/"#W('$"-&+:#(3+7('$%A +P.3" +)6./.%*B +5%"+f"#. +U61"(. +c +OUa0gk +&+2.E") + )2"(%.(0'("4" + -./,&%&7B + & + 2.E") + E.#-&6.C&& + &(3&,&3. + )+/.3.(($D& + 6.50)%,.D&A + \"1*6" + ) + D"D0(%. + 2")%.(",6& + ,"2-"). + "+-./1&50(&& + )"#)%,0(("4" + )"30-a.(&7 + "#-./",.(&7 + & + )"#)%,0(("4"+)"30-a.(&7 + -./,&%&7 + "6./.1")* + ,"/D"a($D + 2-"3U6%&,(" + "#)U3&%*+2-"#10DU+)""%("^0(&7+x%&O+6.%04"-&'8A

Z50,&3("B + 5%" + "#-./",.(&0B + 2"(&D.0D"0 + 6.6 + .#)"1L%(.7+30%0-D&(.(%.+2-"C0))",+-./,&%&7B+&+"#-./",.(&0+c+6.6+#"100+&1&+D0(00+U)20^($'+2-"C0)) +2/R?<8R=17.31C+ (.%U-.1*($OB+f)$-$Og+2-"C0))",+)"/-0,.(&7+96.6+)2"(%.(("0+-./,&%&0<+&D0L%+-./($0+)"30-a.(&7A+\"5("+%.6a0B + & + %-& + &(%0-2-0%.C&& + 6.%04"-&& + -./,&%&7k + 6.6 +76,2;J,A2$@=1301@.+ )U_0)%,",.(&7 + 30')%,&%01*("4" + D&-. + & + 501",06.B + 6.6+=,.?<32A2 $ @=20,66.+ &/D0(0(&' + & + 2-0"#-./",.(&' + , + (&OB + 6.6+.;62?H8325 $ 0,332681+ 0,-"20')6"' + 6U1*%U-$ + 9-./,&%&0 + c + 6.6+).D"-./,&%&0<+)+%"'+a0+"50,&3(")%*L+2"1.4.0%+-./("0+&+)20C&E&50)6"0+)"30-a.(&0+3.(("'+6.%04"-&&A+

8+N"100+2"3-"#("+"#+x%"D+)DAk+!1"#"35&6",+MAGAB+G).0,+~AGA+fF)&O"1"4&7+-./,&%&7+501",06.gA+RAB+=>>>w+!1"#"35&6",+MAGA+fm(%-"2"1"4&50)6.7+20-)206%&,.+"%050)%,0(("4"+"#-./",.(&7gA+~6.%0-&(#U-4B+=>8>A

88

Page 12: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

F0-)206%&,($D + -./-0^0(&0D + -0.1*("4"B + a&,"4" + 2-"%&,"-05&7+E"-D$ +& + )"30-a.(&7 + c + "#-./",.(&7 +& + -./,&%&7 + c + ,"/D"a(" + 1&^* + ,+2"(7%&'("D + 2"10 + %.6"' + )&(%0%&50)6"' + 6.%04"-&&B$ 6.6 +=.>717.HJ,,$2;=.>27.31,A + �30)* + ,"/D"a(" + )-./U + a0 + U30-a.%* + & + ,)0 + )D$)1$+2-"C0))",+-./,&%&7+c+@2$6RJ32681$@=1=2-4I$@2$6RJ32681$6201RG.I$@2$6RJ32681$B,?27,/.B +&+2")%.,&%*+&D+,+"-4.(&5("0+)""%,0%)%,&0+%.6"0+2-03)%.,10(&0B + 6.6 +@2?32, $ 2;=.>27.31,+ c ++0'+7'+" & $ & 7+0H+?'%UV""&93"2"1(&%01*("0B+U61.3("0B+)20C&.1*("0<A+

!04"3(7 + , + (.U6.OB + "-&0(%&-",.(($O + (. + "#-./",.(&0B + ,)0 + #"100+U6"-0(70%)7 +.38=2@2?2A1B,6/.C$@.=.-1AG.+ c+&+(0+%"1*6"+,+6.50)%,0+(","4" + "#d7)(&%01*("4" + 2-&(C&2. + fX,32G,3. $ B,?27,/.gA+m(%-"2"1"4&50)6&'+2"3O"3+,+)E0-0+4UD.(&%.-("4"+/(.(&7+c+,+20-,UL+"50-03*B+"-&0(%.C&7+(.+501",050)6UL+-0.1*(")%* +72$76,5$,,$@2?328,B+,"+,)0O+00+3UO",("J3U^0,("J%010)($O+&/D0-0(&7Ow+x%"+2"&)6+)-03)%,+&+U)1",&' +68.327?,31C $ @2?32A2I $ 76,A2 $ B,?27,/.w + 501",06. + c + 6.6+6R;S,/8.+)"#)%,0(("'+a&/(&B+6.6 +?1B32681+,"+,)%-050+)+h-U4&D&B+6.6+13-171-R.?<32681+20-03+1&C"D+m#)"1L%("4"+N$%&7B+20-03+N"4"DA+

!+).D"'+"#_0'+%"56&+/-0(&7B+"#-./",.(&0+c+x%" +"0."0.7"''+" &&B+D"a0% + #$%*B + (.&#"100 ++H.$-(?F'+" & -"0.+ & 70.#"*$0 ?,$%&-*A 0 ,0&6;)-*3"R& D0)%" + 2-"3U6%&,("4" + & + ,/.&D"-./,&,.L_04" + -./-0^0(&7+#$%&'($O + 2-"%&,"-05&' + D0a3U + (&D&A + F" + )U%&B + ,)76"0 + "#-./",.(&0+,)043. + &D01"B + 2" + 6-.'(0' +D0-0B + 3,. + )%-.%04&50)6&O + "-&0(%&-. + c +3.$?1B3268<+ 900+3UO",("0+)%.(",10(&0+&+-./,&%&0+#./",$O+)2")"#(")%0'<+&+ 3. $ 2;J,6872+ 904" + U)%"'5&,"0 + -./,&%&0 + & + )2")"#(")%* + 6+&((",.C&"(($D+2-0"#-./",.(&7D<A+la0+)+x%"'+%"56&+/-0(&7+)%.(",&%)7+2"(7%($DB + "#-./",.(&0 + (0 + 0)%* + (05%" + "3("D0-("0 + & + 6.50)%,0(("+"3(""#-./("+"2-03010(("0A+

M+ )",-0D0(("'+)"C&"6U1*%U-("'+)&%U.C&&+(.5&(.0%+)61.3$,.%*)7+(",$'+"#1&6+c+'+784&+:#(3&#+00$401+T+&+:#(3+7('$%=&

! + .(%-"2"1"4&50)6"' + %"56& + /-0(&7 +2;=.>27.31,+ c + ,)0"#_.7+6U1*%U-("J&)%"-&50)6.7+E"-D.+)%.(",10(&7+&+-./,&%&7+)U_(")%($O+)&1+501",06.B + "#-0%0(&7 + &D + "#-./. + 501",050)6"4" + ," + ,-0D0(& + &)%"-&& + &+2-")%-.()%,0+6U1*%U-$B+501",06.+)2")"#("4"+6+).D""#-./",.(&LB+.+%0D+).D$D+&+6+).D"-./,&%&LA+

!%.(",10(&0 + )"#)%,0((" + 501",050)6"4" + , + 501",060 + c + x%"+)%.(",10(&0+&+D.(&E0)%.C&7+04"++&(3&,&3U.1*("4"+3UO.B+2-&"#_0(&0+6+-"3","' + 501",050)6"' + )U_(")%&B + )103",.(&0 + ,$)^&D + "#-./C.D+501",050)6"' + 6U1*%U-$B + (-.,)%,0(($D + 2-&(C&2.DB + U%,0-a30(&0+C0((")%0' + -"3","4" + #$%&7 + 501",06.B + 2-.6%&50)6"0 + 2-0"#-./",.(&0+30')%,&%01*(")%&B + ")(",.(("0 + (. + 1L#,& + 6 + 6.50)%,U +a&/(& + & + ,"10 + 6+)",0-^0()%,U+,"+,)0O+00+"#1.)%7O=&+

!"#)%,0(("+4","-7B +) +x%&D+6.6+-./ +& +),7/.($+")(","2"1.4.L_&0+)D$)1$ + )",-0D0(("4" + &((",.C&"(("4" + & + .(%-"2"1"4&50)6&+"-&0(%&-",.(("4" + "#-./",.(&7A + Z50,&3("B + 5%" + %.6 + 2"(&D.0D"0+"#-./",.(&0+%-0#U0%+(",$O+6.%04"-&.1*($O+)-03)%,B+(",$O+%0O("1"4&'+

8=

Page 13: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

2")%-"0(&7 + 04" + 6.6 + )20C&E&50)6"' + E"-D$ +.38=2@2F@=./81/1+ c+2-.6%&6&+6U1*%&,&-",.(&7+#./",$OB+-"3",$O+)2")"#(")%0'+501",06.A

G:#(3+7('$"&1(1&('.#+H+,H#(1.$1(+c+")"#.7+-.#"%.+,+2-")%-.()%,0+)U#d06%&,("' + -0.1*(")%& + 501",06.k + , + 2-")%-.()%,0 + )",D0)%("J-.)2-03010(("'+307%01*(")%&B+,+2-")%-.()%,0+)"J#$%&'("'+"#_(")%&B+,+2-")%-.()%,0 + -0E106)&,("4" + )"/(.(&7A + GD0((" + , + x%"D + 2-")%-.()%,0+D"a0% + 2-"&)O"3&%* + ")"/(.(("0 + & + C010(.2-.,10(("0 + 2-"06%&-",.(&0+%.6&O +a&/(0(($OB + . +2" +)U%& +c +"#-./",.%01*($O +)&%U.C&'B +, +6"%"-$O+)%.(",&%)7 + ,"/D"a($D + & + 2"31&((" + 1&5(")%("0 + ).D""2-03010(&0B + &+"#-0%0(&0 + )U#d06%(")%&B + & + )%.(",10(&0 + .,%"-)%,. + )"#)%,0(($O+")D$)10(($O+30')%,&'A+

�30)*B + , + x%"D + 2-")%-.()%,0 + ,"/D"a(" + )%.(",10(&0 + .,%"("D&& + &+).D"30%0-D&(.C&&+501",06.B+04"+).D"-./,&%&7+&+).D""#-./",.(&7B+.+,+2-03010+c+04"+E.6%&50)6"4"+).D")%"7(&7+,+)"#)%,0(("'+a&/(&A

P",$0 + C0((")%&B + C01& + & + )"30-a.(&0 + "#-./",.(&7 + (0,"/D"a("+-0.1&/",.%* + , + (02")-03)%,0(("D + 203.4"4&50)6"D + ,"/30')%,&&A+!2")"#(")%& + 6 + ).D""#-./",.(&L + & + 6 + ).D"-./,&%&L + (01*/7+)E"-D&-",.%*+2U%0D+2-7D"4"+203.4"4&50)6"4"+30')%,&7A+~)1&+U50(&6+(0+/(.0%+5%"J%"+&1&+(0+UD00%+5%"J%"+301.%*B+%"+203.4"4+04"+(.U5&%A+

!(-+#(37$.$U & '()*$.F & '"?F3%R & H#%-8- & +:#(3+- & +. & H"/(T+T( & 1 &

)*"'$1)&Y.(&0H+0+:'+0.F&'"&H"#"/(".0%A+M+.(%-"2"1"4&50)6&+"-&0(%&-",.(("D+"#-./",.(&&+-0#0(6.+(01*/7+

/.)%.,&%* + #$%* + ).D")%"7%01*($DB + ).D"#$%($DB + ).D"30')%,UL_&DB+(0,"/D"a(" + 2-&(U3&%* + 04" + )%.%* + & + #$%* + 1&5(")%*LA +F03.4"4 + D"a0%+1&^*+)"/3.%*+")"#$0+U)1",&7B+,+6"%"-$O+U+,")2&%.((&6.+30')%,&%01*("+2"7,&%)7 +^.() + ).D"DU + ,$-.)%& + , +D0-U + x%&O + 2"31&((" + 501",050)6&O+)2")"#(")%0'B+,)%.%*+(.+2U%*+&O+"#-0%0(&7A+

GD0((" + %.6&0 + U)1",&7 + ,20-,$0 +2"7,17L%)7 + %"43.B + 6"43. + 203.4"4+C010(.2-.,10(("B + )20C&.1*(" + & + ")"/(.((" + (.5&(.0% + ,$)%-.&,.%* +-&'64*,:%#> 0 &61"7&3"*)?<%#> 0 &6;%&-*<+ c + 6.6 + )","6U2("4"+96"1106%&,("4"< + )U#d06%. + )",D0)%("J-.)2-03010(("' + "#-./",.%01*("'+307%01*(")%&A + h.(("0 + "#)%"7%01*)%," + 5-0/,$5.'(" + ,.a(" + 317+)%.(",10(&7 + 2-"E0))&"(.1*("' + 6"D20%0(%(")%& + 203.4"4.B + 317+,$-.#"%6&+"%,0%)%,0(("'+2-"E0))&"(.1*("'+2"/&C&&+04"w+2-0a30+,)04"+2"%"DUB + 5%" + "#_(")%* + %.6"4" + %&2. + ,)043. + 2"/&C&"((. + 317 + ,)0O + 00+U5.)%(&6",A

�(.(&0+("-D.%&,($O+4-.(&C+&+30%0-D&(.(%+)%.(",10(&7+&D0(("+62F;481534W $ 2;=.>27.8,?<34W $ 2;J3268,5+ , + -./($O + ,"/-.)%($O+20-&"3.O + -./,&%&7 + 501",06. + 2"/,"170% + ,2"1(0 + 2-"E0))&"(.1*("+2-&)%U2&%* + 6 + 2-"06%&-",.(&L + .306,.%($O + E"-D + "-4.(&/.C&& + &+6U1*%U-("J&)%"-&50)6"4" + )"30-a.(&7 + "#-./",.(&7B + /.3.L_&O+")D$)10(($0 + U61.3$ + a&/(& + 30%)6"J,/-")1$O + & + U50#("J2-"E0))&"(.1*($O+"#_(")%0'B +%0O+"#_(")%0'B +6"%"-$0+3"1a($+)%.%*+30')%,&%01*($D + a&/(0(($D + 2-")%-.()%,"DB + .(%-"2"J2-.6%&6"'+92-.6%&6"' + ,"501",05&,.(&7< + "#-0%0(&7 + 30%*D&B + 2"3-")%6.D&B+

8;

Page 14: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

D"1"3$D& + 1L3*D& + )"#)%,0(("'B + &(3&,&3U.1*("' + )U#d06%(")%& + ,+307%01*(")%&+&+1&5(")%("'+2"/&C&&+,"+,)%-05.O+)+3-U4&D&A

M + /.61L50(&0 + O"5U + 2"350-6(U%*B + 5%" + 2"1("%. + & + C01")%(")%*+&(3&,&3U.1*("4"+#$%&7+6.a3"4"+501",06.+"6.aU%)7+,"/D"a($D&B+0)1&+1&(&7+04" +a&/(&+#U30% +),7/.(. +) +R/2=,3,31,G+ , +"%050)6"'+6U1*%U-0B+0)1& +#U30% + 6U1*%&,&-",.%*)7 +@=,,G687,33268<+ C0((")%0' +& + )D$)1",+&)%"-&50)6"4" + #$%&7 + ),"04" + (.-"3.B + 0)1& + #U3U% + -.)6-$,.%*)7+20-)206%&,$+&+2.("-.D.+3UO",($O +R68=,G?,315+ 6.a3"4"+/. +2-0301$+(.1&5("4"B+"#$30(("4"+)U_0)%,",.(&7A+

M.a("+"%D0%&%*+)103UL_00k

• C0((")%* + U6"-0(0(&7& , + "%050)6"' + 6U1*%U-0 + ),7/.(. + )+E"-D&-",.(&0D+).D"%"a30)%,0((")%&B +) +2-0"3"10(&0D +6)7'1&+%&-*,+ & +6)7'=?)()%%&-*,+ 9E0("D0(. + c + f&,((",B + (0+2"D(7_&O+),"04"+-"3)%,.g<B +) +E"-D&-",.(&0D+4-.a3.()6"'+2"/&C&& + c + 6.6 + 1&5("' + "%,0%)%,0((")%& + /. + #1.4"2"1U5&0+)%-.($w

• C0((")%*+2-00D)%,0((")%&&,"))%.(.,1&,.0%+&+/._&_.0%+),7/*+,-0D0( + & + + )"J#$%&'("0 + 03&()%," + 2"6"10(&'B + 2-0"3"10,.7+(.-.)%.L_UL+;,>F@=1>2=3268<+,)04"+&+,)0Ow

• C0((")%* +U)%-0D10(&'& , +(.3JD&-("0 +Z%050)%," +"2-030170%+,06%"- + & + D.)^%.# + 501",050)6&O + 307(&' + , + &(%0-,.10 + 04"+&(3&,&3U.1*("' + a&/(&B + )"-./D0-(")%* + 20-,$O + 3,UO+"#-./UL_&O+2"31&(("'+.(%-"2"J2-.6%&60+&+x(0-40%&60+%.6&O+U)%-0D10(&'B +2-0"3"10,.7+"#0/3U^0((")%*+& +#0/3UO",(")%*+(.1&5("4"+)U_0)%,",.(&7A

).682CJ,68<$62;4815$1$Z@23.=2V,B3268<[$G,=2@[email protected]

>=>=G0.(H"'1+

8:

Page 15: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

F","3"D+317+20-0-.#"%6&+x%"4"B+Ua0+-.(00+"2U#1&6",.(("4"+%06)%.=+

" + O-"("%"2&& + ,")2&%.(&7B + 2")1Ua&1 + 3&.1"4 + ) + R.-&0' + T&1&("' + &+-03.6%"-)6.7+-.#"%.+(.3+0�+)%.%*�';+"+)"#$%&'(")%&+6.6+2-03D0%(")%&+3&3.6%&6&A +h&)6U))&7 + ,"/(&61. + 2" + 2","3U + %"4"B +*._+ D"a(" + )5&%.%*+.(%"(&D&50)6"' + 2-"%&,"2"1"a(")%*L + 2"(7%&7 + f)"#$%&'(")%*gA + Z(.+2-031.4.1. + 2"(7%&0 + f"%5Ua3�((")%*gB + SA�A\-"&C6&' + c+f2",)03(0,(")%*gB +7+c+f"#$30((")%*gA+P"+1&5("+U+D0(7+,)�+)%.1"+(.+),"&+D0)%.B+6"43.+7+,)2"D(&1+30%)6"0+)1","+f2"(.-"^6Uge

\=23282@$/./$@,=,/=]682/$@=2V?2A2$1$;R-RJ,A2I$3.682CJ,A2$1^$@23.=2V,B32A2

J h.,.'+&4-.%*+,+.(%"(&D$�J h.,.'�J {�-("0�J N01"0�J M$)"6"0�J P&/6"0�J F-"^03^00�J NU3U_00�J P.)%"7_00�J �e+F"(.-"^05("0���@3&H+/0?)X(''+T+&/$(?+T(&-?(/X$2&

/+*"#"4&.+T/(R&1+T/(&+'$&:8?$&

/+X1+?F'$9(-$

~)%* + %"1*6" + D&4 + D0a3U + 2-"^1$D + &+#U3U_&De+++++++++++++++++++++++++ +@3&$37"0.'+4&H"0'$

!U#d06%&,("0 + ,-0D7 + 501",06. + (.D + ,)043. + #$1" + &(%0-0)(" + 6.6+6"D2"(0(% + 04" + )U#d06%&,("' + -0.1*(")%&B + . + )U#d06%&,(.7 + -0.1*(")%*+&(%0-0)(. + , + 2-"C0))0 + 0� + )%.(",10(&7B + &#" + x%"% +2-"C0)) +& + 0)%* + )U%*+2-"C0)) + 203.4"4&50)6&'B + )U%* + 2-"C0)) + ,")2&%.(&7 + 9, + )D$)10+QAhAl^&()6"4"<A + M")2&%.%01*($' + 2-"C0)) + ,")})%.(",10(&7+2"1("C0((")%& + 92"1("JC01*(")%&< + 501",06. + c + 2-"C0)) + ,-0D0(("'B+31&%01*($'B + 317_&')7B + (0 + "3("D"D0(%($'B + (0 + D4(",0(($'B + (0+%"505($'B+&#"+f501",06+3"1a0(+301.%*+),"�+,-0D7gB+.+(0+,-0D7+3"1a("+)%.(",&%)7 + 04" + O"/7&("DA + `./#0-�D)7 + 2"3-"#(00 + , + x%"D + %0/&)0B+"3(",-0D0(("+)%.,7+/.3.5U+-./,0)%&+2"(7%&7+57+0H$.('$"&-&64*,/(,;&

=+ Z)%.20(6" + mAmA + M-0D0(("' + .)206% + "-4.(&/.C&& + "#-./",.%01*("4" + 2-"C0)). + ��+�6"1*($0+%0O("1"4&&A+c+=>>@A+J+H+@A+c+!A+;KJ:?A;+ T&1&(.+ZA+!"#$%&0+&+)"#$%&'(.7+2-03D0%(")%*+,+"#-./",.(&&k+3&3.6%&50)6&'+.)206%+��+�6"1*($0+%0O("1"4&&A+=>>?A+H+8A

8@

Page 16: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

&& 57+0H$.('$" &-"#+H#$%.$%-$;=+ h17 + x%"4" + ,")2"1*/U0D)7 + 2"(7%&0D+2#+'+.+H(A

M +(.U5($' +"#"-"% +2"(7%&0 +fO-"("%"2g +(0 +#0/ + ,"/30')%,&7 +&30'+�AR&(6",)6"4"+&+mA|'(^%0'(.+,+8?=@4A+,,�1+mAmAlO%"D)6&':A+f!+%"56&+/-0(&7+O-"("%"2.+)U_0)%,UL%+Ua0+(0+"%,1050(($0+%"56&B+("+a&,$0+&+(0&/41.3&D$0+&/+#$%&7+)"#$%&7w+%0+/.,&)&D")%&+9EU(6C&&<B+,+6"%"-$O+D$ + ,$-.a.0D + /.6"($ + #$%&7B + Ua0 + (0 + "%,1050(($0 + 6-&,$0 + 1&(&& + ,+2-")%-.()%,0B + . + �D&-",$0 + 1&(&&�B + 6"%"-$D& + ),7/$,.L%)7 + 3.,("+2-"^03^&0+)"#$%&7+)+)"#$%&7D&+3.(("4"+D4(",0(&7B+.+50-0/+(&O+c+)+)"#$%&7D&+&)50/.L_04"+,3.1&+#U3U_04"g@A

+ �&-"6" + &/,0)%($D + %0-D&( + )%.1 + #1.4"3.-7 + 04" + .6%&,("DU+2-&D0(0(&L + , + "#1.)%& + x)%0%&6& + RARAN.O%&($Dk + f!U_0)%,0((UL+,/.&D"),7/*+,-0D0(($O+&+2-")%-.()%,0(($O+"%("^0(&'B+OU3"a0)%,0(("+"),"0(($O+,+1&%0-.%U-0B+D$+#U30D+(./$,.%*+O -"("%"2"D +95%"+/(.5&%+, + 3")1",("D + 20-0,"30 + c + f,-0D72-")%-.()%,"g<A + \0-D&( + x%"%+U2"%-0#170%)7 + , + D.%0D.%&50)6"D + 0)%0)%,"/(.(&& + & + #$1 + ,,030( + &+"#")(",.(+(.+2"5,0+%0"-&&+"%(")&%01*(")%&+9|'(^%0'(.<gYA+P.5&(.7+)+(.5.1.+?>JO+4"3",+&30L+O-"("%"2.+2-&D0(&%01*("+6+2)&O"1"4&&+.6%&,("+-./,&,.0%+MAFA�&(50(6"k+f!,"0"#-./&0+O-"("%"2.+)")%"&%+,+%"DB+5%"+"(+)"03&(70% + , + )0#0B + 6./.1")* + #$B + (0)"03&(&D"0A + m + &D0((" + c+2-")%-.()%,0(("J,-0D0(($0 + , + E&/&50)6"D + )D$)10 + x%"4" + )1",.B+%010)($0+"4-.(&50(&7+)+#0/4-.(&5(")%*L+,-0D0(&+&+2-")%-.()%,.B+%A+0A+)+,05(")%*L+&+)+#0)6"(05(")%*LA+F0-,$'+c+x%"+&+0)%*+"(%"1"4&50)6&'+21.(B+/.61L5.L_&'+,+)0#0+,)L+)U-",")%*+#$%&7B+6"%"-"0+,+6"(C0+6"(C",+(.4-.a3.0%+501",06.+)D0-%*Lw+,%"-"'+c+E0("D0("1"4&50)6&'B+&3U_&'+&/ + 6U1*%U-$B + &)%"-&&B + &/ + ("")E0-$B + "% + N"4.B + "% +m#)"1L%.B + %A + 0A + &/+,05(")%& + , + ,05(")%* + )" + ,)0D& + D$)1&D$D& + "#_0501",050)6&D&+C0((")%7D&+&+)D$)1.D&A+M+1L#"D+2",030(50)6"D+&1&+307%01*(")%("D+.6%0B + )",0-^.0D"D + 501",06"DB + D$ + &D00D + ,)0 + %-& + fC,0%. + ,-0D0(&gk+2-"^1"0B+(.)%"7_00+&+#U3U_00B+%A +0A +3.a0+O-"("%"2+a&,"4"+3,&a0(&7+D"a0% + -.))D.%-&,.%*)7 + 6.6 + x10D0(%.-(.7 + 03&(&C.B + /.-"3$^ + 9&1&+2-"3U6%�<+,05(")%&A+F"x%"DU+,+(0D+2"%0(C&.1*("+)"30-a.%)7+(0+%"1*6"+3"1*(&'B+("+&+4"-(&'+D&-$A+Q"(05("B+O-"("%"2+c+x%"+2"6.+D0%.E"-.B+U3.5("+"2&)$,.L_.7+a&,"'+2-")%-.()%,0(("J,-0D0(("'+6"(%&(UUDB+,+6"%"-"D + 2-"%06.0% + -./,&%&0 + 501",06.B + 2"(&D.0D"0 + 6.6 + U(&6.1*($'+2-"C0)) + , + )")%.,0 + 6")D").gIA + + F"/3(00 + "(B + Ua0 + (0 + U2"D&(.7 + "+D0%.E"-&5(")%& + 2"(7%&7B + 2&^0%k + fy-"("%"2 + c + x%" +W$7+" & $3-"#"'$"&2-")%-.()%,. + & + ,-0D0(&B + , + 6"%"-"D + "(& + (0-./301*($A + y-"("%"2+

:+ Z2U#1&6",.( + 50-(",&6 + 04" + 3"61.3. + 8?=@4A + fZ + ,-0D0(("J2-")%-.()%,0(("D+6"D2106)0B+&1&+O-"("%"20gA!DAklO%"D)6&'+mAmA+h"D&(.(%.Ac!F#AkF&%0-B=>>=AJ!AYIJI8A@+lO%"D)6&'+mAmA+G(%U&C&7+)",0)%&A+c+!F#Ak+F0%0-#U-4)6&'+2&).%01*B8??YA+c+!A+=YIY+N.O%&(+RA+RA+M"2-")$+1&%0-.%U-$+&+x)%0%&6&A+c+RAk+yU3"aA+1&%AB+8?I@A+c+!A=;:AI+ �&(50(6" + MAFA+ QU1*%U-("J&)%"-&50)6.7 + 2)&O"1"4&7k + "2$% + .D21&E&6.C&& + ��+M"2-")$+2)&O"1"4&&A+c+8??;A+J+H+:A+c+9�tt�k��pu��8?K=Aru�o�A�q��srn�zr�oA�tp<A

8Y

Page 17: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

)"/(.(&7 + 3,U1&6A + |%" + , + %.6"' + a0 + )%020(& + �",-0D0(�((")%*+2-")%-.()%,.�B+,+6.6"'+&+�"2-")%-.()%,0((")%*+,-0D0(&�gKA+

`./30177+&+2-")%-.()%,"B+&+,-0D7+(.+"#d06%&,("0+&+)U#d06%&,("0B+D$ + U2"%-0#170D + 317 + )U#d06%&,("4" + 2-")%-.()%,. + %0-D&(+f20-)"(.1*("0gB + . + 317 + )U#d06%&,("4" + ,-0D0(& + c + %0-D&(+f2)&O"1"4&50)6"0g+&1&+,)103+/.+MAFA�&(50(6"+fa&,"0gA+P0)D"%-7+(.+%"B+5%"+,+)%.%*0+8??84A+"(+(0+U2"%-0#170%+%0-D&(.+fO-"("%"2gB+,"2-")+&D+/.3.(k + fP0 + "%)L3. + 1& + �2-")%-.()%,. + ,(U%-0((&' + &/#$%"6�B + 6"%"-"0+&_0%B+6.6+)0#7+-0.1&/",.%*+,+-0.1*("D+2-")%-.()%,0+&+,-0D0(&B+)"/3.,.7+317+x%"4"+")"#"0 +^)'19$+'(?F'+"&H#+0.#('0.7++& +$0.+#$*"01+"&7#"-%&96U-)&,+c+mAZA<�gA

!103U7+&300+fEU(6C&"(.1*($O+"-4.(",g+mAmAlO%"D)6"4"B+�&(50(6"+,,"3&%+2"(7%&0+fEU(6C&"(.1*("4"+2-")%-.()%,.gB +. +fEU(6C&"(.1*("0+,-0D7g + (./$,.0% + f&)%"-&50)6&DgA + !","6U2(")%* + x%&O + 3,UO+)")%.,17L_&O + & + )")%.,170% + U + MAFA�&(50(6" + 2"(7%&0 + fO-"("%"2gA+R"a(" +2"1.4.%*B + 5%" +"(" + , + 6.6"'J%" + )%020(& + )""%,0%)%,U0% + 2"(7%&L+f)U#d06%&,("' + 30')%,&%01*(")%&g + MAGAP0)D01",. + & + f)U#d06%&,("'+-0.1*(")%&g + MAGA!1"#"35&6",.A + G307 + O-"("%"2. + )""%,0%)%,U0% + &300+"%C. +F.,1. +j1"-0()6"4" +" + %"DB +5%" +f-")%B +a&/(* +301.0% +,-0D7B + . +(0+,-0D7 + 3,&a0% + a&/(*A + !103",.%01*("B + 2-"C0)).D& + a&/(& + 3"1a("+&/D0-7%* + #&"4-.E&50)6"0 + ,-0D7B + . + (0 + ,-0D0(0D + c + 2-"C0))$+#&"4-.E&50)6"4"+-")%.g?A

�&(50(6" + U6./$,.0%B + 5%" + O-"("%"2 + f(0)D"%-7 + (. + C01*(")%*B + (0+"#1.3.0%+),"')%,.D&+(.4173(")%&A+Z(+%-U3("+2-03)%.,&D+&/J/.+%"4"B+5%"+2-")%-.()%,"+&+,-0D7+2"3,0-41&)*+,+(�D+307%01*(")%("J)0D&"%&50)6"'+20-0-.#"%60B +"(&+,$)%U2.L%+, +(�D+, +2-0,-._0(("'+E"-D0+,21"%* +3"+%"4"B + 5%" + -0.1*("0 + 3,&a0(&0 + , + 2-")%-.()%,0 + %-.()E"-D&-U0%)7 + ,+")%.(",10(("0+,-0D7B+.+2")103(00+,+),"L+"50-03*+%-.()E"-D&-U0%)7+,+3,&aU_00)7 +2-")%-.()%,"A +Z%)U%)%,&0 +50-% +(.4173(")%& +U +O-"("%"2.+),7/.("+)+(.1&5&0D+,+(�D+"#d06%&,("4"+&+)U#d06%&,("4"B+)+&O+"#D0("D+&+,/.&D"2-"(&6(",0(&0Dg8>A

{01",06+a&,�%+"3(",-0D0(("+,+%-�O+fC,0%.Og+,-0D0(&k+2-"^03^0DB+(.)%"7_0D+&+#U3U_0D+&+0)1&+)U#d06%&,("+&O+(0+"#d03&(70%+,+)0#0B+%"+"(+)%.(",&%)7+(0+O"/7&("DB+.+-.#"D+,-0D0(&A+{01",06+"#d03&(70%+,+)0#0+,-0D0(.B+0)1&+"(B+U5&%$,.7 +6,5B.6I$6,A2-3C+ 9'(0.+%V""<+(.6"210(($'+2@48$9H#+X"/X""<B+&3�%+6+2")%.,10(("'+0,?1+9:)/)V""<A+

F-"&11L)%-&-U0D+x%U+D$)1*A

K+ �&(50(6"+MAFA+R$)1*+&+!1","+�U)%.,.+�20%.+9,"/,-._0(&0+&/+&/4(.(&7<A+c+RAk+G/3J,"+l mZB+=>>>A+c+!A+KIA?+j1"-0()6&'+FAmA+!"5A+M+:+%A+\A+;98<A+c+RAk+R$)1*B+=>>>A+c+!A+:IIA8>+ �&(50(6" + MAFA+ QU1*%U-("J&)%"-&50)6.7 + 2)&O"1"4&7k + "2$% + .D21&E&6.C&& + ��+M"2-")$+2)&O"1"4&&A+c+8??;A+J+H+:A

8I

Page 18: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

+

+`&)A+8A+R"301*+)"50%.(&7+fC,0%",g+,-0D0(&+9,-0D�(<+,+O-"("%"20+9U6./.($++,06%"-$+f)"30-a.%01*("4"g+&+f.6%U.1*("4"g+,-0D0(&<A

T&/(* + 501",06.B + "#U)1",10((.7 +9"?%-$R & -"*.(-$R & H?('(-$R&'(/"W/(-$R+ (.2"1(0(. +62_;481CG1B + 6"%"-$0 + & + 7,17L%)7+x10D0(%.-($D&+03&(&C.D&+,05(")%&A+!"#$%&0+c +%7?"'$"&'(0.+%V""+ 9.+(0 + f2"(.-"^05("0g< + & +%7?"'$" & '(0.+%V"T+A + Z(" + &D00% + ),"')%,"+/?$.F0%+ , + (.)%"7_0DA + fy-"("%"2 + 2-032"1.4.0% + )&DU1*%.(&/.C&L+2)&O"1"4&50)6"4"+,-0D0(&+c+310(&0B+,61L5.L_00+2-"^1"0B+(.)%"7_00+&+#U3U_00g88A+G+&D0(("+"("+"#d03&(70%+,+)0#0+30')%,&0+(.)%"7_04"B+"2$%+2-"^03^04" +& +D05%$ + 9C01&< + #U3U_04"A +y-"("%"2 +(.@2?30(B + ) + "3("'+)%"-"($B +H(-%.FU&$&+H8.+-+ &B +)+3-U4"'+)%"-"($B +9"?%-$R &-"*.(-$R&H?('(-$&$&'(/"W/(-$B+2"x%"DU+"(+@2?23+0-80?+-B+.+f,(0+)D$)1","4"+&/D0-0(&7+O-"("%"2+,+2-&(C&20+(0,"/D"a0(g8=A+

M+20-,"D+2-&#1&a0(&&+)"/3.�%)7+"_U_0(&0B+5%"B+,"J20-,$OB+9"?$R &-"*.8R & H?('8 & $ & '(/"W/8+ 0)%* + (06&0 + &11L/&& + 9. + (0 + -0.1*(")%&<B+6"%"-$0+(0,"/D"a("+f2"%-"4.%*gA+M"J,%"-$OB+"(&+2-&(.310a.%+%"1*6"+#U3U_0DUB +6"%"-"0 +).D" +2" +)0#0 +2-&/-.5(" +& +&11L/"-("A +P"B + x%" +(0+"50,&3("A+P.2-&D0-B+&/+3,UO+2.-+D"1"3$O+1L30'B+)%"7_&O+2"3+,0(C"DB+"3(. + "#d7)(70% + ),"� + -0^0(&0 + ,)%U2&%* + , + #-.6 + (06&D& +-"*.(-$ & $&H?('(-$+ (. + )5.)%1&,"0 + )",D0)%("0 +:)/)V""B + . + ,%"-.7 + c + #.(.1*("'+#0-0D0((")%*L + (0,0)%$B + 6"%"-.7 + Ua0 + )1U5&1.)* + ,50-. + 97 & H#+X?+-<A+

88+ �&(50(6"+MAFA+R$)1*+&+!1","+�U)%.,.+�20%.+9,"/,-._0(&0+&/+&/4(.(&7<A+c+RAk+G/3J,"+l mZB+=>>>A+c+!A+K?J?>A8=+�&(50(6"+MAFA+{01",06+,+2-")%-.()%,0+,-0D�(+��+`./,&%&0+1&5(")%&A+c+=>>=A+J+H+;A+c+!A+;=A

8K

Page 19: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

F")6"1*6U+"#0+2.-$+#"(?F'++9.+(0+,&-%U.1*("+&1&+&11L/"-("<+)%"7%+2"3+,0(C"DB +%"B +2" +,)0' +,&3&D")%&B +#"(?F'+0.F+ 9(.)%"7_0)%*< +-"*.('$4R &H?('+7 & $ & '(/"W/+ (&)6"1*6" + (0 + "%1&5.0%)7 + "% +#"(?F'+0.$+ 9& + 3.a0+D.%0-&.1*(")%&< + )1U5&,^0')7 + #0-0D0((")%&A + h01" + , + %"DB + 5%" + "#0+2-&,03�(($0+,+2-&D0-0+-0.1*(")%&+7,17L%)7+)D$)1.D&+9)"30-a.(&0D<+O-"("%"2.B + & + D05%$ + " + #U3U_0D + , + (0 + D0(*^0' + )%020(& + ,1&7L% + (.+(.)%"7_00 + 9U-",0(* + (.)%"7_0)%&<B + 50D + (.5.,^.7)7 + 9/.5.,^.7)7< + ,+2-"^1"D+#0-0D0((")%*A+

`[email protected],$1G,,8$6G46?I$,6?1$3.@2?3,32$3.682CJ1G1$62;481CG1

M"/,-._.7)* + , + 203.4"4&50)6UL + -0.1*(")%*B + D$ + 4","-&DB + 5%"+7+0H$.('$" & $-"". & 0-80?R & "0?$ & +'+ & '(H+?'"'+ & '(0.+%V$-$ & `$ & 7 &

'(0.+%V"-a & 0+:8.$%-$B + %.6 + 6.6 + 41.,($' + 2-&/(.6 + )"#$%&7 + c + x%"+(.1&5&0+)D$)1.B+"#U)1",10(("4"+H(-%.FU&$&+H8.+-&H#+X?+T+B+.+%.6a0+9"?%-$R & -"*.(-$R & H?('(-$ & $ & '(/"W/(-$ & :)/)V"T+A + f~)1&B + )"41.)("+RARAN.O%&(UB + ,-0D7 + c + x%" + 50%,�-%.7 + 6""-3&(.%. + 6"(%&(UUD. + #$%&7J)"/(.(&7B+%"+)D$)1+c+27%.7+&1&+20-,.7B+-./UD00%)7B+(0+2"+O-"("1"4&&B+.+2" + /(.5&D")%&g8;A + !-.,(&D + 3.(("0 + 2"1"a0(&0 + ) + -0/U1*%.%.D&+&))103",.(&7 + GAmAm-^.,)6"4"B + U50(&6. + mAmAlO%"D)6"4"k + fa&,$0+)&)%0D$B + , + "%1&5&0 + "% + (0a&,$O + c + 50%$-�OD0-($OB + 7,17L%)7+27%&D0-($D&B + O.-.6%0-&/U7)* + %-0D7 + 2-")%-.()%,0(($D& + & + 3,UD7+,-0D0(($D&+-./D0-(")%7D&+c+x(%-"2&'("'+&+(04x(%-"2&'("'A+GD0(("+(04x(%-"2&'(.7 + -./D0-(")%* + & + "2-030170% + %,"-50)6&0 + ,"/D"a(")%&+a&,"4"A + N1.4"3.-7 + (04x(%-"2&'("DU + ,-0D0(&B + a&,$0 + )&)%0D$+"#"4._.L)7 + 3"2"1(&%01*($D& + 21.)%&50)6&D& + D.%0-&.1.D& + &+x(0-40%&50)6&D& + -0/0-,.D&g8:A + F"3 + (04x(%-"2&'("' + )")%.,17L_0'+,-0D0(&+m-^.,)6&'+6.6+-./+&+2"(&D.0%+%U+).DUL+)"/3.,.0DUL+).D&D+501",06"D + .6%&,(")%*B + 6"%"-.7 + & + 301.0% + 04" + O"/7&("DB + . + (0 + -.#"D+,-0D0(&A+!"#$%&'(")%*+,")2&%.(&7+&+3.�%+,")2&%U0D"DU+")%"-"a($'+"2$% + DU3-")%&A + fG%.6B + )D"%-&%0B + 2")%U2.'%0 + ")%"-"a("B + (0 + 6.6+(0-./UD($0B+("+6.6+DU3-$0B+3"-"a.+,-0D0(0DB+2"%"DU+5%"+3(&+1U6.,$g+9~E0)A+@w+8YJ8I<A+

{%"+a0+2-"&)O"3&%+)+(0-./UD($D&B+)+%0D&B+6%"+2"+)"#)%,0(("'+,"10+(0 + "#-0%.0% + DU3-")%& + & + "2$%.� + {01",06 + #0/ + C01&B + #0/ + D05%$B + #0/+(.30a3$ + 2U)%B + U + (04" + (0% + (.)%"7_04"B + U + (04" + a&/(* + (0 + (.2"1(0(.+)"#$%&'(")%*LB +.B +)%.1"+#$%*B +"(+(0+(.6.21&,.0% +DU3-")%&+&+"2$%.A+fF"%0-7+/.D$)1.+&+04"+#U3U_04"+-0/U1*%.%.+2-06-._.0%+30')%,&0B+1&#"+2-0,-._.0%+04"+,+D"%"-($0+20-)0,0-.C&&g8@A+f�&^�(("0+)"#$%&'(")%&+

8;+\.D+a0A+c+!A+;=A8:+m-^.,)6&'+GAmA+F-"#10D.+,-0D0(&+a&,"4"+&+),7/.(($0+)+(0L+2-"#10D$+-./,&%&7+c +&(3&,&3U.1*("4" +& +E&1"40(0%&50)6"4"+ �� +F-&-"3. +,-0D0(&+&+)U_(")%& +a&/(&A+|106%-"(($'+aU-(.1Ac+=>>:A+J+H8A+8@+�&(50(6"+MAF=+{01",06+,+2-")%-.()%,0+,-0D�(+��+`./,&%&0+1&5(")%&A+c+=>>=A+J+H+;A+c+!A+:YA

8?

Page 20: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

E&/&50)6"0 + ,-0D7 + c + x%" + ,-0D7 + -.)2.3.B + -./1"a0(&7A + Z(" + (0+U30-a&,.0%)7 + 501",050)6"' + 2.D7%*LB + 6"%"-.7 + )"#$%&'(.B + . + (0+O-"("4-.E&5(.g8YA +G+%"43.+x%.+2U)%"%.+/.2"1(70%)7+1&#" +-.#.&:B +1&#"+-#)*&:A + MD0)%" + )"#$%&' + a&/(* + /.2"1(70%)7 + 1&#" + #0)C01*($D&+2"&)6.D&+-./,1050(&'+&+U3","1*)%,&'+9&+,+%.6"D+)1U5.0+D$+4","-&DB+5%"+,-0D7+fU#&,.0%)7g +&1&+f%-.(a&-&%)7gB +. +x%" +& +0)%* +)U0%.<B +1&#"+(&50D+(0+/.2"1(70%)7+9%"43.+,-0D7+f%7(0%)7g+&+f,"1$(&%)7gB+.+x%"+0)%*+)6U6.+&+%")6.<A+\"43.+(.)%"7_00+)a&D.0%)7B+O-"("%"2++UD0(*^.0%)7A+

+

+16D$P

~)1&+O-"("%"2+)a&D.0%)7+3"+(U17+&+2-0,-._.0%)7+,+fD&4+D0a3U+2-"^1$D+&+#U3U_0DgB +%" +&)50/.0% +")* +)"30-a.%01*("4"+,-0D0(&B +%A0A+&)50/.0%B + ,$-.a.7)* + )1",.D& + GAmAm-^.,)6"4"B + (04x(%-"2&'(.7+6"D2"(0(%.+,-0D0(&A+M+%.6"D+)1U5.0+501",06+)%.(",&%)7+-.#"D+,-0D0(&B+&/+04"+a&/(&+&)50/.L%+)D$)1$+9C01&B+D05%$B+21.($B+(.30a3$<B+UO"3&%+(.)%"7_0)%*B+(.)%"7_00+)%.(",&%)7+2"(.-"^05($DB+a&/(*+/.2"1(70%)7+,-0D0((")%*L+)U0%$+&+)6U6&A

+

+16D$%

8Y+\.D+a0A+c+!A+:8A

=>

Page 21: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

F-& + U%0-0 + O-"("%"2.B + U%0-0 + 6"(%-"17 + (.3 + ,-0D0(0DB + U%0-0+(.)%"7_04"B+U%0-0 +'"TY'.#+H$4'+4&1+-H+'"'.8 &3)$%&-*,+ )"O-.(70%)7+1&^* +Y'.#+H$4'(% & 1+-H+'"'.( &31)()%%&-*,B + & + Ua0 + (0 + 501",06+7,170%)7+O"/7&("D+,-0D0(&B+.+,-0D7+O"/7'(&5.0%+(.3+(&DA+M+x%"D+)1U5.0+,$#"-+317+),"#"3("'+,"1&+501",06.+"4-.(&5&,.0%)7+3,UD7+,.-&.(%.D&+,-0D0((")%&+c+)6U6"'+&+)U0%"'A+

Z#-.%&D)7 + 6 + )1",.-L +MAGAh.17k + f!6U6. + c + %74")%("0 + 5U,)%," + "%+6")("4"B + 2-./3("4"B + (0307%01*("4" + )")%"7(&7 + 3U^&w + %"D10(*0+#0/30')%,&7g8Iw+ f)U0%. + c + )U0%(")%*B + )U0%)%,"w + %_0%.B + 2U)%"%. + &1&+(&5%"a(")%*B+#0)2"10/(")%*+2"D$)1",B+)%-0D10(&'+&+301+1L3)6&Ow+,)�+Ds-)6"0B +/0D("0B + ,-0D0(("0B ++ )6U301*("0B +(&5%"a("0B+ )-.,(&%01*("+ )+,05($Dw+,)�+,/3"-("0+&1&+2-"%&,("0++ ,05("DU+#1.4U+(.^0DU+,+"#$5.7O+(.^&O+&+,+-"30+a&/(&g8KA+Z#_00+,+x%&O+2"(7%&7O+%"B+5%"+&+/.+2"(7%&0D+f)6U6.gB+&+/.+2"(7%&0D+f)U0%.g+6-"0%)7+"%)U%)%,&0+%0O+).D$O+0-80?+7B+6"%"-$0 +-0.1&/UL%)7 +50-0/& 9"?$R &-"*.8R &H?('8&$ &'(/"W/8A+ `./(&C.+1&^* +, +%"DB +5%" +)U0%. +c + x%" +#0)C01*(.7 +307%01*(")%*B + . +)6U6. +c +x%"+#0)C01*(.7 + #0/307%01*(")%*A + \" + & + 3-U4"0 + 2" + 2-&/(.6U + #0)C01*(")%&+,$2.3.0% + /. +2-0301$+O-"("%"2.B +(0 +2-&(.310a&% +6 +(04x(%-"2&'("DU+%,"-50)6"DU+,-0D0(&+501",06.A +�(.5&%B +2" +"2-03010(&L+(&+)U0%.B +(&+)6U6.+(0+D"4U%+#$%*+&)%"5(&6.D&+%,"-50)%,.B+.B+)103",.%01*("B+"2$%.+&+DU3-")%&A +F"(&D.7 + &4-U + 6.6 + f2"(.-"^05(ULg +307%01*(")%* + &1& + 6.6+307%01*(")%*B +9"?F+ 6"%"-"'+/.61L5.0%)7+,+).D"'+307%01*(")%&B+D"a("+2-032"1"a&%*B + 5%" + 50D + D0(*^0 + U + 501",06. + C010,$O + )D$)1",B + %0D+#"1*^0 + , + 04" + a&/(& + &4-$ + 6.6 + f2"(.-"^05(")%&gB + 6.6 + )U--"4.%.+(.)%"7_0)%&A+

!",-0D0(($' + #UD + 2",)0D0)%("4" + )"/3.(&7 + &4-",$O + & + &4"-($O+).1"(",+&+61U#",B+2"4"1",("0+U,1050(&0+6"D2*L%0-($D&+&4-.D&+c+x%"B+,&3&D"B + /(.6 + #0)C01*(")%& + & + #0/(.30a93<(")%& + x2"O&B + 0�+#0))D$)10((")%& + & + 2"(.-"^05(")%&B + /(.6 + %"4"B + 5%" + f(.^. + a&/(* + c+&4-.gA+`&)6(U+,$)6./.%*+2-032"1"a0(&0B+")(",.(("0+(.+(.#1L30(&7O+/.+3"50-*D&J3"^6"1*(&C.D&B+"+%"DB+5%"+3.a0+,+3"^6"1*("D+,"/-.)%0+&4-.+7,170%)7+,03U_&D+,&3"D+307%01*(")%&+-0#�(6.+1&^*+,+%"D+)1U5.0B+0)1&+#1&/6&'+,/-")1$'+(0+2-031.4.0%+-0#�(6U+&("'+")D$)10(("' +H+?"3'+4&/#)T$-+ 307%01*(")%&A +Z2$% +2"6./$,.0%B +5%" +, + )1U5.0 +(.1&5&7 +%.6"4"+,$#"-.B + -0#�("6 + 5._0 + 2-032"5&%.0% + -0.1*("0 + (Ua("0 + 301" + 92"D"_*+-"3&%017D + & + %A2A<B + (0a01& + &4-UA + M"/,-._.7)* + 6 + (.^&D + %0-D&(.DB+/.D0%&DB +5%" +%.6 +2"(&D.0D.7 +&4-. +c + 7,10(&0B + ,$O"37_00 + /. +2-0301$+O-"("%"2.+-0#�(6.A

F-& + "%)U%)%,&& + U + ,")2&%.((&6. + )"#)%,0(($O& 9"?"4R & H?('+7 & $&'(/"W/B+f,")2&%.(&0g+),"3&%)7+6+/.3.50+2",$^0(&7+/.(7%")%&B+"O,.%.B+/.30')%,",.((")%&B+(.3/"-.+/.+-0#�(6"DA+\.+a0+)&%U.C&7+2-"&)O"3&%+,+

8I+h.1*+MAGA+\"16",$'+)1",.-*+a&,"4"+,01&6"-U))6"4"+7/$6.A+\A+:A+c+RAk+F-"4-0))Jl(&,0-)B+8??:A+c+!A+=;8A8K+\.D+a0A+c+!A+Y=:A

=8

Page 22: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

)1U5.0 + 0)1& + C01& + 307%01*(")%& + (.,7/.($ + ,/-")1$D&A + \"43. + a&/(*+2"3-")%6.+,/-")1$0+2$%.L%)7+3('%.F+9.+(0+/.2"1(&%*<+D0-"2-&7%&7D&B+C01&+6"%"-$O+&/,0)%($+&+7)($+90)1&+7)($�<+%"1*6"+,/-")1$DA+|%&+C01&+(0 + 2-"a&%$B + (0 + 2-"5U,)%,",.($ + ,")2&%.((&6"DB + "(& + f)2U_0($g+,/-")1$D&B+"(&+&D&+(.,7/.($B+.B+6.6+Ua0+4","-&1")*B+(.,7/.(($0+C01&+"),"#"a3.L%+"%+"%,0%)%,0((")%&+/.+&O+3")%&a0(&0A+�010(.2-.,10((.7+,")2&%.%01*(.7 + 307%01*(")%* + ,/-")1"4" + )%.(",&%)7 + #0))D$)10(("'+)U0%"' +317 + ,")2&%.((&6.A +�01* +203.4"4.B + ,/-")1"4" + ),"3&%)7 + 6 + %"DUB+5%"#$ + f/.(7%*gB + f/.2"1(&%*g + 3")U4B + f"O,.%&%*g + 6.6"'J1&#"+307%01*(")%*LA + {.)%" + D0-"2-&7%&7 + 2-","37%)7 +/?%+ 30%0' + & + (0+)%.(",7%)7+)"#$%&7D&+&O+a&/(&A +GO+f"%#$,.L%gB +f"%)&a&,.L%g+9&1&+f"%)%.&,.L%g<+.+(0+2-"a&,.L%A+

M+x%"D+&+0)%*+-./(&C.+D0a3U+(.)%"7_&[email protected],G$62;481CG1$9"(&+(.2"1(0($+)D$)1"DB+%.6+6.6+&O+C01&+7)($+&+2-&(7%$+-0#�(6"DB+/(.5&%B+2"-"a3.L%+"2$%+&+DU3-")%*<+&+f2"(.-"^05([email protected],G$G,=2@=1C81CG1+ 9&O + C01& + 1&#" + (0 + 7)($B + 1&#" + (.,7/.($ + -0#�(6UB + .+)D$)1+7)0(+1&^*+,/-")1$Dw+&O+f"%#$,.L%gB+.+(0+2-"a&,.L%<A+:2;481,$O-"("%"2&5("+&+2-&5.)%("+7"*'+0.$B+G,=2@=1C81,+,(0O-"("%"2&5("+&+,)043. +7#"-"''+A + M + ),"0' + 6-.'(0' + E"-D0 + 2"(.-"^05("0 + ,")2&%.(&0+D0-"2-&7%&7D& + ,$-"a3.0%)7 + , + 2",)0D0)%(UL + 2-&D&%&,(UL+2-"E&1.6%&6U + 2"-"6", + %&2. + -./1&5($O + 2-"4-.DD + fm(%&)2&3gB+fm(%&%0-"-gB +fm(%&(.-6"gB +fm(%&.#"-%gB +6"%"-$0+,+&%"40+)%.(",7%)7+-061.D"'+x%&O+2"-"6",A+

!,03�D+,")2&%.%01*($0+)&)%0D$+,+)-.,(&%01*(UL+%.#1&CUk

fF"(.-"^05("0g+9"#$30(("0<+,")2&%.(&0+D0-"2-&7%&7D&

P.)%"7_00+,")2&%.(&0+)"#$%&7D&

Z)(",(.7+E"-D.

R0-"2-&7%&0 !"#$%&0

!"30-a.(&0

G4-.+6.6+f2"(.-"^05(")%*g+ h01"+6.6+(.)%"7_0)%*+M(0^(77+6"(%-"1&-U0D.7+"-4.(&/.C&7+3")U4.

!",D0)%("0+2-"a&,.(&0+/(.5&D$O+)"#$%&'

!U0%.+6.6+f2"(.-"^05(.7gB+%_0%(.7+307%01*(")%*

F"1*/.+6.6+(.)%"7_.7+307%01*(")%*

Z),"0(&0+2-.,+&+),"#"3+501",06.A+F-"E&1.6%&6.+2"-"6",

F-&,&%&0+C0((")%0'+&+3")%"&()%,.A+M/-._&,.(&0+3"#-"30%010'

�01&P.,7/.((")%*+,")2&%.((&6U+,(0^(&O+C010'B+)D$)1",B+21.(",+&+(.30a3

P.1&5&0+U+,")2&%.((&6.+)"#)%,0(($O+C010'B+)D$)1",B+21.(",+&+(.30a3

!-03)%,. h"D&(.(%.+(.+)0#7 h"D&(.(%.+(.+3-U4"4"!")%"7(&0+ M-0D0((")%*A+

y-"("%"2+f&)50/.0%g+&+F-&5.)%(")%*+,05(")%&A+y-"("%"2+(.2"1(0(+

==

Page 23: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

O-"("%"2.+,")2&%.((&6.

),"3&%)7+6+fD&4U+D0a3U+2-"^1$D+&+#U3U_&Dg

310(&0DA

",86/2F7>=26?.C$2;J3268<$1$,,$62F;481534,$W.=./8,=1681/1

@=I=J)0.+7(

Z3("' +&/ + /.3.5 + )",-0D0(("4" +"#-./",.(&7 + ,&3&%)7 +2"330-a6. +&+-./,&%&0+,+-0#0(60+#./",$OB+-"3",$O+)2")"#(")%0'B+2"/,"17L_&O+0DU+"%)%.&,.%* + )"#)%,0((UL + 501",05(")%*B + #$%* + (0 + %"1*6" + -0)U-)"D+)"C&.1*("4" + 2-"&/,"3)%,.B + ("B + 2-0a30 + ,)04" + )U#d06%"D + 6U1*%U-$ + &+&)%"-&50)6"4" + 30')%,&7B + )U#d06%"D + ),"0' + a&/(&A + M.a(" + )"/3.,.%*+U)1",&7B+2-&+6"%"-$O+-0#0("6+(.O"3&1+#$+#1.4"2-&7%($0+U)1",&7+317+-.)6-$%&7 + )"#)%,0(("4" + figB + 2"31&(("4" + 1&5(")%("4"+).D""2-03010(&7B + (.O"a30(&7 + & + "%)%.&,.(&7 + )"#)%,0(($O + )D$)1",A+M.-&.(%"D + %.6"' + "#-./",.%01*("' + )&%U.C&& + 2-03)%.,170%)7 + 30%)6"J,/-")1.7+"#_(")%*B+00+)"J#$%&'($0+O.-.6%0-&)%&6&A

E;J3268<D $h0%)6"J,/-")1.7+"#_(")%* +6.6+7,10(&0+"#_0)%,0(("0+E"-D&-U0% + U + U5.)%(&6", + )&)%0DU + a&/(0(($O + U)%.(","6B + (.2-.,170%+)"C&"6U1*%U-(UL + &30(%&E&6.C&L + & + E"-D&-",.(&0 + a&/(0(($O+C0((")%0' + & + )D$)1",A + N"1*^"0 + /(.50(&0 + &D00%B + 6.6&0 + C0((")%& + &+)D$)1$+2-0"#1.3.L%+,+"#_(")%&B+5%"+2-&,(")&%+,+"#_(")%*+,/-")1$'A+h0%)6"J,/-")1.7 + "#_(")%* + 3"1a(. + ,$)%U2.%* + 2-")%-.()%,"D + 317+-./,&%&7+4UD.(&)%&50)6&O+C0((")%0'A

Z)%.(",&D)7 +2"3-"#(00 +(. + )""%(0)0(&0 +2"(7%&' +,")2&%.%01*($'+6"1106%&, + & + 30%)6"J,/-")1.7 + "#_(")%*A +Z#_(")%* + "2-030170%)7+ 6.6+,/.&D""%("^0(&7+&+),7/&B +(0"#O"3&D$'+)2")"#+)U_0)%,",.(&7+1L30'B+&O+,/.&D"),7/&+&+,/.&D"30')%,&7+D0a3U+)"#"'+&+)+"#_0)%,"D+,+C01"DA+GD0((" + , + "#_(")%& + ) + 3-U4&D& + )"/3.L%)7 + (0"#O"3&D$0 + U)1",&7B+U3",10%,"-7L_&0+&(%0-0)$+501",06.+&+)2")"#)%,UL_&0+04"+-./,&%&LA

Z)(","' + E"-D&-",.(&7 + "#_(")%& + QA�0,&( + )5&%.0% + xD2.%&LA+Z#_(")%* + ,"/(&6.0% + 50-0/ + (02")-03)%,0(("0 + ,/.&D"30')%,&0 + &+,/.&D"/.,&)&D")%* + 1L30' + & + 2-"7,170%)7 + 6.6 + (05%" + 2"3"#("0+4-U22","DU + 03&()%,UB + ")(",.(("D + (. + xD2.%&& + �;�A + mAPA�U%"^6&(+,"/(&6(",0(&0 + "#_(")%& + ,&3&% + 50-0/ + 2-0#$,.(&0 + 1L30' + , + "3("'+xD"C&"(.1*("' + )&%U.C&&B + 50-0/ + 20-0a&,.(&0 + &D& + "3("4" + )")%"7(&7+9-.3")%& + &1& + "%-&C.%01*($O + xD"C&'< + �:�A + NAhAF.-$4&( + U)1",&0D+,"/(&6(",0(&7+"#_(")%&+)5&%.0%+"#_0(&0B+,"/(&6.L_00+f20-0a&,.(&0+%"'+&1&+&("'+),7/&+)+3-U4&D&+U5.)%(&6.D&+)",D0)%("4"+30')%,&7g+�K�A

=;

Page 24: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

Q"1106%&, + 5._0 + ,)04" + -.))D.%-&,.0%)7 + 6.6 + D.1.7 + )"C&.1*(.7+4-U22.B+"#d03&(0((.7+"#_&D&+C017D&+&+/.3.5.D&+9/.3.(($D&+&/+,(0+&+)",D0)%(" + "2-030170D$D& + , + 6"1106%&,0<B + (02")-03)%,0(("'+307%01*(")%*LB+)&)%0D"'+),7/0'+&+"%("^0(&'+,"/(&6.L_&O+,+2-"C0))0+307%01*(")%&B+"#_&D&+C0((")%($D&+"-&0(%.C&7D&+1L30'B+3")%&4^.7+,+2-"C0))0+)"C&.1*("+C0(("'+)",D0)%("'+307%01*(")%&+,$)"6"4"+U-",(7+-./,&%&7A + �AGAP",&6","' + & + mA\AQU-.6&($D + "%D05.1")*B + 5%" + 1L#"'+30%)6&' + 930%)6"J,/-")1$'< + 6"1106%&, + &D00% + 3,"76UL + )%-U6%U-U + c+,$)%U2.0% + 6.6 + "-4.(&/.C&7B + 6.6 + )&)%0D. + E"-D.1*($O + ),7/0' + &+"%("^0(&'B + ) + 3-U4"' + )%"-"($ + 2-"7,170%)7 + 6.6 + )"C&.1*("J2)&O"1"4&50)6.7 + "#_(")%*B + )&)%0D. + xD"C&"(.1*("J2)&O"1"4&50)6&O+),7/0' + & + "%("^0(&'A +h0%)6"J,/-")1.7 + "#_(")%* + "%-.a.0%+(0"E&C&.1*(UL + )%-U6%U-U + 1L#"4" + ,")2&%.%01*("4" + 6"1106%&,.B+O.-.6%0- + xD"C&"(.1*("J2)&O"1"4&50)6&O + ),7/0' + & + "%("^0(&'B+C0((")%("J)D$)1",UL + )")%.,17L_ULB + (02")-03)%,0(("0 + 6"(%.6%("0+,/.&D"30')%,&0 + (0 + "2-03010(("0 + 9(0 + /.3.(("0 + &/,(0< + "E&C&.1*("A+F"(7%&7 + ,")2&%.%01*("4" + 6"1106%&,. + & + 30%)6"J,/-")1"' + "#_(")%&+#1&/6&B + "#_(")%* + -.))D.%-&,.0%)7 + )%-U6%U-("' + 03&(&C0' + 1L#"4"+,")2&%.%01*("4" +6"1106%&,.B +"%-.a.7 +04" + )"C&.1*("J2)&O"1"4&50)6UL+O.-.6%0-&)%&6UB+)&)%0DU+(0E"-D.1*($O+),7/0'+&+"%("^0(&'+,+(0DA

P0"#O"3&D" + ,$7,&%* + 203.4"4&50)6&0 + U)1",&7B + )2")"#)%,UL_&0+f,$-._&,.(&Lg+&+EU(6C&"(&-",.(&L+,")2&%.%01*("4"+6"1106%&,.+6.6+30%)6"J,/-")1"' + "#_(")%& + ) + )&)%0D"' + (0E"-D.1*($O + ),7/0' + &+"%("^0(&'+D0a3U+30%*D&+&+,/-")1$D&B+"#_&D+C0((")%("J)D$)1",$D+2-")%-.()%,"DB +) +2-"7,10(&0D+"#_&O +&(%0-0)", +& +)",D0)%($O +C010'+307%01*(")%&A + Z)(",("0 + U)1",&0 + c + "%6-$%"0 + D0a2"/&C&"(("0+,/.&D"30')%,&0 + 30%0' + & + ,/-")1$O + & + 4-U22",.7 + & + &(3&,&3U.1*(.7+-0E106)&7A

F"3 + 30%)6"J,/-")1"' + "#_(")%*L + D$ + 2"(&D.0D + 20-,&5(UL+6"(%.6%(UL + 4-U22U + 30%0' + & + ,/-")1$OB + 2-"7,17L_UL + )O"a&0+2"%-0#(")%& +& +&(%0-0)$B +")U_0)%,17L_UL+20-0)050(&0 +C0((")%0' +&+)D$)1", + U5.)%(&6", + , + )",D0)%("' + 307%01*(")%& + & + "#_0(&&B+"%-.a.L_UL + O.-.6%0- + ),7/0' + & + "%("^0(&' + D0a3U + U5.)%(&6.D&A +M+6.50)%,0 + ,/-")1$O + D"4U% + ,$)%U2.%* + (0 + %"1*6" + 203.4"4& + 9U5&%017B+61.))($0+-U6","3&%01&<B+("+&+3-U4&0+,/-")1$0B+2-&(&D.0D$0+30%*D&+,+"#_0D + ,/.&D"30')%,&&A +G)%"5(&6"D + ,"/(&6(",0(&7 + & + -./,&%&7+"#_(")%& + D0a3U + 203.4"4"D + & + ,")2&%.((&6"DB + D0a3U + ^6"1*(&6.D&B+&(%04-.%&,($D + 2-&/(.6"D + )"C&.1*("J203.4"4&50)6&O + & + 2)&O"1"4"J203.4"4&50)6&O + 7,10(&'B + 2" + 6"%"-$D + )"/3.0%)7 + "#_(")%*B + D"4U%+7,17%*)7k+

J+03&($'+&(%0-0)B+6"%"-$'+"#d03&(70%+1L30'+,+03&("0+C01"0w+J + )",D0)%(.7 + 307%01*(")%*B + )"C&.1*("0 + 2",030(&0 + 1L30'B+

"#d03&(0(($O+"#_0'+C01*Lw+J+"#_0(&0B+20-0a&,.(&0+),7/&+)+3-U4&D&+1L3*D&B+xD"C&"(.1*("0+

03&()%,"w+

=:

Page 25: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

J + )",D0)%("0 + 2-"a&,.(&0 + )"#$%&'B + a&/(0(($O + %-.403&' + &+%-U3(")%0'B+"#_0'+-.3")%&+/(.5&D"'+317+,)0Ow+

J+6U1*%U-(.7+),7/*B+)&)%0D.+("-D+&+C0((")%0'B+6"%"-UL+&)2",03U0%+4-U22.+1L30'B+"#-./U7+,"6-U4+)0#7+"#_(")%*+03&("D$^10((&6",A

h0%)6"J,/-")1.7+"#_(")%*+2-"7,170%)7+6.6+"3(.+&/+)%"-"(+a&/(&+1L#"4" + ,")2&%.%01*("4" + 6"1106%&,.B + "3(.6" + )U_0)%,0(($D+2-03)%.,17L%)7 + 2-&(C&2&.1*($O + "%1&5&' + 6"1106%&,. + & + "#_(")%&A+!-.,(&D + 6.50)%,0(($0 + O.-.6%0-&)%&6& + 30%)6"J,/-")1"' + "#_(")%& + &+30%)6"4"+6"1106%&,.k

\.#1&C.+8A+:=.7318,?<3.C$W.=./8,=1681/.$2;J32681$1$/2??,/817.

\.=./8,=1681/19

",86/15$/2??,/817 ",86/2F7>=26?.C$2;J3268<

N682B31/$72>31/327,31C

M(0^(&0+E.6%"-$B+"#_0)%,0(("+&+)"C&.1*("+/.3.($A

M(U%-0((&0+E.6%"-$B+&(%0-0)+&+a01.(&0+)U#d06%.B+xD"C&"(.1*(.7+&1&+307%01*(")%(.7+,61L50((")%*A

",C8,?<3268<

�1.,($'+E.6%"-k+E"-D&-UL_&'+6"1106%&,+&+(.2-.,17L_&'+307%01*(")%*+(.+"#_0)%,0(("+&+6"1106%&,("+/(.5&DUL+C01*A+G(3&,&3U.1*(.7+307%01*(")%*+2"35&(0(.+6"1106%&,("'A

h07%01*(")%*+,+"#_(")%&+"2-030170%)7+&(3&,&3U.1*($D&+&(%0-0).D&+&+&(&C&.%&,.D&+"%301*($O+)U#d06%",B+"#d03&(7L_&O+&+(.2-.,17L_&O+E"-D&-",.(&0+"#_&O+C010'A+Q"1106%&,(.7+307%01*(")%*+/.,&)&%+"%+).D""2-03010(&7+6.a3"4"A

:7C>1 $ 1$2832V,31C

!%-U6%U-&-",.($+&+3")%.%"5("+E"-D.1&/",.($B+/.3.($+"#_0'+C01*L+307%01*(")%&A

P0E"-D.1*($0B+"%6-$%$0+&+4&#6&0B+2-032"1.4.L%+-.,0()%,"+)"1&3.-(")%*+&+,/.&D(.7+2"330-a6.A

a,3326832F6G46?272,$@=268=.36872

F-"&)O"3&%+"%+"2-03017L_0'+307%01*(")%&+6"1106%&,.+C01&+&+"a&3.0D$O+-0/U1*%.%",A+F-"7,170%)7+,+("-D.OB+2-.,&1.OB+%-.3&C&7OA

Z)(",.+)U_0)%,",.(&7+"#_(")%&+,+D0a2"/&C&"(("D+"%6-$%"D+,/.&D"30')%,&&+00+U5.)%(&6",B+(.+")(",.(&&+C0((")%("4"+&+)D$)1","4"+).D""2-03010(&7+6.a3"4"A+F-"7,170%)7+,+f3UO",("'+#1&/")%&gB+"#_&O+2"/&C&7OA

!@=.7?,31, G/,(0B+(.2-.,10("+(.+-0^0(&0+6"1106%&,("+/(.5&D$O+C010'+&+/.3.5A+M"/D"a0(+,$O"3+(.+).D"U2-.,10(&0

�.%-U3(0("B+"#_(")%*+2-032"1.4.0%+-.,0()%,"A+R"a0%+")U_0)%,17%*)7+6.a3$D+510("D+"#_(")%&+,+%"%+&1&+&("'+D"D0(%+00+)U_0)%,",.(&7A

),2;W2-1G4, $ R6?271C$

J+6"1106%&,("J/(.5&D.7+C01*B+")"/(.,.0D.7+

J+xD"C&"(.1*(.7+&+307%01*(")%(.7+,61L50((")%*w

=@

Page 26: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

-?C$=.>7181C$1$XR3/01231=27.31C9

U5.)%(&6.D&+6.6+1&5(")%("+/(.5&D.7wJ+2")%.(",6.+(",$O+C010'+&+/.3.5B+#"100+)"C&.1*("+&+1&5(")%("+/(.5&D$OwJ+6"()%-U6%&,("0+,/.&D"30')%,&0B+,$O"3+(.+).D"U2-.,10(&0B+6"1106%&,("0+C0102"1.4.(&0+&+21.(&-",.(&0wJ+2-"7,10(&0+(0E"-D.1*("'+)"C&.1*("J2)&O"1"4&50)6"'+"#_(")%&+,+6"1106%&,0A

J+2-"7,10(&0+C0((")%("J)D$)1","4"+2-")%-.()%,.wJ+)%&DU1&-",.(&0+&(3&,&3U.1*("4"+).D""2-03010(&7+U+6.a3"4"+510(.+"#_(")%&B+E"-D&-",.(&7+04"+")"/(.(("'+2"/&C&&+2"+"%("^0(&L+6+"#_(")%&+&+),"0'+307%01*(")%&+,+(0'wJ+2-"7,10(&0+&+2"330-a6.+&(%0-0).B+)2"(%.((")%&+&+),"#"3$+,+).D"-0.1&/.C&&B+.,%"-)6&O+&(&C&.%&,wJ+-0E106)&,($0+6"1106%&,($0+&+&(3&,&3U.1*($0+2-"C0))$A

`./1&5.0%)7+&)%"5(&6+&O+)%.(",10(&7A +M"/(&6(",0(&0 +6"1106%&,.+"2-03010("+,(0^(&D&+E.6%"-.D&B +"(+E"-D&-U0%)7+50-0/+"#d03&(0(&0+1L30' + ,"6-U4 + 3")%&a0(&7 + "#_0)%,0((" + /(.5&D"' + C01&A + Z#_(")%*+D"a0% + ,"/(&6(U%* + , + 6"1106%&,0 + 9&1& + (0%<B + 0)1& + "( + )U_0)%,U0% + 6.6+E"-D.1*(.7 + "-4.(&/.C&7 + 317 + 00 + -0^0(&7A + `./,&%&0 + 6"1106%&,.+2-032"1.4.0%+")"/(.((UL+6"1106%&,("+/(.5&DUL+C01*B+(.2-.,17L_UL+6"1106%&,(UL+307%01*(")%*B+2")%.(",6U+(",$O+"#_0)%,0(("+/(.5&D$O+C010'B+6"%"-$0+20-0)06.L%)7+)+&(3&,&3U.1*($D&+C017D&A

Z#_(")%* + -"a3.0%)7B + )61.3$,.0%)7 + (02-"&/,"1*("B + 50-0/+3"#-","1*("0+"#d03&(0(&0+1L30'B+&O+xD"C&"(.1*(UL+"%6-$%")%*+3-U4+3-U4UA + G)%"5(&6 + ,"/(&6(",0(&7 + "#_(")%& + c + xD"C&"(.1*("0 + fig+)U#d06%.B+2-&)"03&(0(&0+)U#d06%"D+)0#7+6+3-U4"DU+&+3-U4&DA+F03.4"4+(0+D"a0%+)E"-D&-",.%*+"#_(")%*B +&)O"37+&/+,(0^(0+/.3.(($O+/.3.5B+"(+D"a0% + %"1*6" + )"/3.%* + U)1",&7 + 00 + 2"-"a3.L_&0B + )"30')%,U7+,"/(&6(",0(&L+&+EU(6C&"(&-",.(&L+30%)6"J,/-")1"'+"#_(")%&B+430+"(+,$)%U2.0% + 6.6 + -.,($' + 3-U4&DA + `./,&%&0 + &30% + "% + xD"C&"(.1*("'+,61L50((")%& + 1L30' + , + "#_00 + 20-0a&,.(&0 + & + 307%01*(")%* + 6+E"-D&-",.(&L + C0((")%("J)D$)1","4" + 2-")%-.()%,. + "#_(")%&B + 6+).D""2-03010(&L+, +(0' + 6.a3"4"B + 2-"7,10(&L +2"/&C&& +& +-0.1&/.C&&+.,%"-)6&O+&(&C&.%&,+00+U5.)%(&6",A

M")2&%.(&0+&+-./,&%&0+,")2&%.((&6.+, +"#_(")%&+2-032"1.4.0%B+5%"+"(+c+"3(",-0D0(("+510(+(0)6"1*6&O+"#_(")%0'B+4-U22B+6"1106%&,",A+P. + 6.a3"D + ,"/-.)%("D + x%.20 + 501",06 + ,",1050( + , + -./(""#-./($0+"#_(")%&B + , + 6.a3"' + &/ + 6"%"-$O + 317 + (04" + )61.3$,.0%)7 + U(&6.1*(.7+)"C&.1*("J2)&O"1"4&50)6.7+)&%U.C&7+D0a1&5(")%("4"+,/.&D"30')%,&7B+")"#$0 + U)1",&7 + 317 + 04" + -./,&%&7A + Z(" + ")U_0)%,170%)7 + 2"J-./("DUk+50-0/ +,O"a30(&0 +, +-./1&5($0 +"#_(")%& +& +)"C&.1*($0+4-U22$w +50-0/+

=Y

Page 27: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

)D0(U+#./",$O+317+-./,&%&7+501",06.+"#_(")%0'+(.+6.a3"D+,"/-.)%("D+x%.20A

M+6.50)%,0+D.1"'+4-U22$B+30%)6"J,/-")1.7+"#_(")%*+D"a0%+#$%*+2-03)%.,10(. + 6.6 + 61.))B + 61U#B + 6"D.(3.B + D"1"30a(.7 + "-4.(&/.C&7B+)U#6U1*%U-(.7+"#_(")%*B+3-Ua0)6.7+4-U22.+&+%A3A+�6"1*(&6+D"a0%+#$%*+,61L50( + , + -./1&5($0 + "#_(")%& + & + 2"J-./("DU + 2-"7,17%*)7 + , + (&OA+h0%)6"J,/-")1.7 +"#_(")%* +D"a0% +,"/(&6.%* +, +-.D6.O+"-4.(&/",.(("'+4-U22$ + 96"1106%&,.<B + &1& + )%&O&'(" + E"-D&-",.%*)7 + ,)103)%,&0+)",2.30(&7+&(%0-0)",B+,"6-U4+&(%0-0)("4"+301.B+U,1050(("4"+,/-")1"4"A+Z(. +D"a0% + #$%* + 31&%01*("' + &1& + (")&%* + 6-.%6",-0D0(($' + O.-.6%0-B+)U_0)%,",.%*+,+%050(&0+3(7B +(0)6"1*6&O+3(0'B +2-"7,&%*)7 +6.6+")"#"0+)")%"7(&0+D.1"'+4-U22$B+,")2&%.%01*("4"+6"1106%&,.A

:2F;48153.C$2;J3268<A+Z)"#"0+/(.50(&0+&D00%+%"B+5%"+"#_(")%*+D"a0%+(")&%*+)"J#$%&'($'+O.-.6%0-A+!"J#$%&'(.7+"#_(")%*+c+")"#"0+)")%"7(&0B + 6"%"-"0 +D"a0% +2-"7,&%*)7 + , + 1L#"' +D.1"' + 4-U220 + 9D0a3U+,/-")1$D+&+-0#0(6"DB+,+61.))0B+%,"-50)6"D+6"1106%&,0B+)06C&&B+61U#0+&+2-A<A+M+)"J#$%&'("'+"#_(")%&+2-"&)O"3&%+20-0)050(&0+fig+501",06.+)+,(0^(&D+D&-"DA+!"J#$%&'(.7+"#_(")%*+501",06.+)+3-U4&D&+1L3*D&B+6.6+0)%0)%,0(("+)61.3$,.L_.7)7B+(0+/.3.,.0D.7+,(0^(&D&+.%-&#U%.D&B+3.0% + ,"/D"a(")%* + 2-"7,&%*)7 + ,(U%-0((0' + )2"(%.(("' + .6%&,(")%&B+,$'%& + (. + .,%"-)6&0 + )2")"#$ + ).D"-0.1&/.C&& + ," + ,(0B + "#0)205&,.0%+)%.(",10(&0 +)U#d06%(")%&A +MAGA!1"#"35&6", +"2-030170% + )"J#$%&'(UL+"#_(")%* + 6.6 + (0"#O"3&DUL + )&%U.C&L + -./,&%&7 + 501",06.k + fF"1("%.+),7/0'+&+"%("^0(&'+D0a3U+1L3*D&+"#0)205&,.0%)7+%"1*6"+,+)%-U6%U-0+)"J#$%&'("' + "#_(")%&B + ")(",(.7 + EU(6C&7 + 6"%"-"' + c + -./,&%&0A +!"J#$%&0+0)%*+%"B+5%"+-./,&,.0%+&+-./,&,.0%)7w+-0/U1*%.%+-./,&%&7+/30)*+c+%.+&1&+&(.7+E"-D.B+%"%+&1&+ &("'+U-",0(*+&(3&,&3U.1*("'+6"1106%&,("'+)U#d06%(")%&g+�?B+�A8@;J8@I�A

!"J#$%&'(.7 + "#_(")%* + D"a0% + #$%* + "O.-.6%0-&/",.(. + 6.6+)",D0)%("0 + #$%&0B + 6.6 + )"2-&6")(",0(&0 + a&/(0' + 9#$%&7< + (0)6"1*6&O+1L30'B + 20-0)050(&0 + , + "#_0D + xD"C&"(.1*("J2)&O"1"4&50)6"D + &+C0((")%("J)D$)1","D + 2-")%-.()%,.OB + 6"%"-"0 + "_U_.0%)7 + &D& + 6.6+,)%-05. + iJ\$ + 9RANU#0-<B + 3UO",(.7 + "#_(")%*B + 5U,)%," + fR[gA + !"J#$%&'(.7+"#_(")%*+(.5&(.0%)7+)+xD"C&"(.1*("4"+,")2-&7%&7+)U#d06%"D+3-U4"4" + 93-U4&O<B + 6.6 + /(.5&D"4" + & + &(%0-0)("4" + 501",06.B + )+,"/(&6(",0(&7+"#_04"+2-")%-.()%,.+,/.&D"30')%,&7B+,+6"%"-"D+6.a3$'+D"a0%+"%6-$%"+2-"7,&%*+)0#7B+(.'%&+f)0#7+,+3-U4"Dg+&+f3-U4"4"+,+)0#0g+,+U)1",&7O+"%6-$%"4"+3&.1"4.+(.+U-",(0+)D$)1",A+!"J#$%&'(")%*+6.6+6.50)%,0((.7+O.-.6%0-&)%&6.+D.1"'+4-U22$B+2-03U)D.%-&,.0%+,$O"3+(.+")"/(.(&0+),"&O+C0((")%0'+&+)D$)1",+6.a3$D+U5.)%(&6"DA+Z)"/(.(&0+)D$)1.+)"J#$%&7+2-"&)O"3&%+,+2-"C0))0+EU(6C&"(&-",.(&7+"#_(")%&+&+2")10B+6.6+")D$)10(&0+2-"&/"^03^04"+317+)0#7A

{10($ +"#_(")%& +"_U_.L% + 03&()%,"B + /(.5&D")%* +2-"&)O"37_04"+317 + ,)0OB + E"-D&-U0%)7 + 5U,)%," + fR$gB + f6.6 + )0D*7gA + M + )"#$%&'("'+"#_(")%& + 501",06 + &)2$%$,.0% + ,$)"6"0 + xD"C&"(.1*("J

=I

Page 28: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

&(%01106%U.1*("0+(.2-7a0(&0B+2-0#$,.(&0+,+(0'+D"a0%+,$,"3&%*+04"+(.+E0("D0( + f2-"/-0(&7g + & + f"%6-$%&7g + (","4" + /(.(&7 + 317 + )0#7B+&(3&,&3U.1*("4" + )D$)1.B + (","4" + "2$%. + ).D"-0.1&/.C&&A + \.6&0+f"%6-$%&7g + )%&DU1&-UL% + 501",06. + 20-0)D.%-&,.%* + ),"L + -0.1*(")%*B+#$%&0B+(.2-.,17L%+2-"C0))+&(3&,&3U.1&/.C&&A+F"+MAGA!1"#"35&6",UB+,+)"J#$%&'("' + "#_(")%& + 3"1a($ + EU(6C&"(&-",.%* + 2-"C0))$++.+W/"0.7?"'$%&9E"-D&-",.(&0+),7/0'<+&++:+0+:?"'$%+9&O+-./-U^0(&0B+20-0,"3+,+")"/(.(("0+"%("^0(&0+(.+")(",.(&&+)"#)%,0(($O+C0((")%0'+&+)D$)1",<A +|%"+c+")(",($0+D0O.(&/D$+x6/&)%0(C&.1*($O+2-"C0))",+)"C&.1&/.C&& + & + &(3&,&3U.1&/.C&&B + "2-03017L_&O + C01")%("0 + #$%&0+501",06.B + , + 6"%"-"D + E"-D&-U0%)7 + ),"#"3(.7 + )U#d06%(.7 + 2"/&C&7+6.a3"4" + & + "3(",-0D0((" + , + )",D0)%("' + 307%01*(")%& + & + "#_0(&&+")U_0)%,170%)7+04"+&(3&,&3U.1&/.C&7A

!"J#$%&'(.7 + "#_(")%* + D"a0% + #$%* + 2-"7,10(. + 317 + U5.)%(&6",+"#_(")%&+6.6+a&/(0(("0+)"#$%&0B+430+2-"&/"^1"+"%6-$%&0B+-"3&1")*+(","0+/(.(&0B+,&30(&0B+2"(&D.(&0+)0#7+&+3-U4"4"B+2"7,&1)7+(",$'+"2$%+307%01*(")%&A +F")10 +-./-U^0(&7 +00 +, +2-")%-.()%,0 +& +,-0D0(&B +"#-./+"#_(")%&+92"(7%"0+&+20-0a&%"0+,+(0'+&+50-0/+(00<+(.3"14"+")%.0%)7+,+)U#d06%&,("D+D&-0+501",06.B+2"7,170%)7+6.6+(06.7+f)&%U.C&7+"#-./0Cg+"%6-$%$O + "%("^0(&' + & + )",D0)%("4" + C0((")%("J)D$)1","4" + 2"&)6.B+C0(($'+"2$%B+"-&0(%&-+317+).D""2-03010(&7+&+).D"-0.1&/.C&&A

M + ,")2&%.(&& + x%"% + 2"3O"3 + 2-03U)D.%-&,.0% + )"/3.(&0 + 317+^6"1*(&6",+)&%U.C&'+)+")"#"+7-6&D&+,205.%10(&7D&B+/.3.L_&O+x%.1"(+4UD.(&)%&50)6&O+C0((")%0'+&+"%6-$%$O+"%("^0(&'+)"+),0-)%(&6.D&+&+,/-")1$D&B+,$,"37_&O+,")2&%.((&6",+(.+a&/(0(("0+).D""2-03010(&0B+(.+2-&"#-0%0(&0+(","4"+C0(("4"+"2$%.A +T&/(*+501",06.+,"+D("4"D+&+"2-03017L%+)"J#$%&'($0B +/(.5&D$0+& +)D$)1"2"-"a3.L_&0+,)%-05&+)+1L3*D&B+"#_(")%*+)+(&D&A+

!"J#$%&'(.7 + "#_(")%* + c + 6.%04"-&7 + (0 + 2")%"7((.7B + "(. + (")&%+fD0-C.%01*($'gB+f2U1*)&-UL_&'g+O.-.6%0-A+M+2"3%,0-a30(&&+3.(("4"+%0/&).B + D"a(" + 2-&,0)%& + 2-&D0- + "2&).(($' + mA!A+R.6.-0(6"B + &+(./,.(($'+&D+fD0%"3+,/-$,.g+�@�k+)"/3.(&0+)&%U.C&&B+6"%"-$0+2&%.L%+xD"C&"(.1*($0 + 20-0a&,.(&7 + "%301*("4" + 510(. + 6"1106%&,. + &+,")2&%.((&6",B+D0(77+501",06.B+04"+"%("^0(&0+6+D&-U+&+).D"DU+)0#0A+Z%D05.7 + -"1* + fD0%"3. + ,/-$,. + , + C01")%("D + 2-"C0))0 + ,")2&%.(&7+6"1106%&,.+&+"%301*("'+1&5(")%&+mA!AR.6.-0(6"+2&^0%k+fei+(&6"43.+(0 +2-&3.,.1 +")"#0(("4"+,0). +x,"1LC&"(($D+2U%7DA +M+"2$%0+),"0D+7+U#03&1)7B+5%"+6.6+#$+/3"-","B+-.3")%("+&+2-.,&1*("+(0+a&1+6"1106%&,B+(&6"43. + (01*/7 + 2"1.4.%*)7 + %"1*6" + (. + )2.).%01*("0 + /(.50(&0 + "3("'+x,"1LC&&B + (. + 2")%020(("0 + )%.(",10(&0 + 501",06.e +M + x,"1LC&"(("D+2"-7360 + )"#&-.L%)7B + 2"34"%",17L%)7 + 6.6&0J%" + 2-03-.)2"1"a0(&7B+(.D05.L%)7 + &/D0(0(&7 + , + 3UO",("' + )%-U6%U-0B + (" + ,)0 + -.,(" + 317+-0.1&/.C&& + &O + (Ua($ + 6.6&0J%" + #"100 + ")%-$0 + D"D0(%$B + ,/-$,$B+2"%-7)0(&7e+7+(0+&D01+2-.,"+"-4.(&/",$,.%*+%.6&0+,/-$,$B+("B+6"43.+"(&+2-"&)O"3&1&+,+0)%0)%,0(("D+2"-7360B+7+,&301+&+(.U5&1)7+U5&%$,.%*+

=K

Page 29: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

&O + ,01&6"0 + /(.50(&0gA + F"J,&3&D"DUB + )"J#$%&'(.7 + "#_(")%* + 6.6+/(.5&D.7+&+xD"C&"(.1*("+2-"a&,.0D.7+-0#0(6"D+)&%U.C&7B+&D00%+D("4"+"#_04"+)+x%&D+D0%"3"D+mA!AR.6.-0(6"A

j.6%"-"DB+"2-03017L_&D+-./,&%&0+)U#d06%(")%&+,+30%)6"J,/-")1"'+"#_(")%&B + 7,170%)7 + )""%("^0(&0 + ,(0^(&O + & + ,(U%-0((&O + U)1",&'B+"2-03017L_&O+-./,&%&0+501",06.A+

iA�AQ"1"D&()6&' + .(.1&/&-U0% + )"C&.1*("J2)&O"1"4&50)6&0+&))103",.(&7 + 2-"C0))", + U),"0(&7 + 30%*D& + (-.,)%,0(($O + ("-D + &+x%.1"(",B + 6"%"-$0 + fU2-.,17L%g + &O + D0a1&5(")%($D&+,/.&D""%("^0(&7D&B+&+2"350-6&,.0%B+5%"+&D0(("+,+6"(%.6%($O+9D.1$O<+4-U22.O + & + 6"1106%&,.OB + , + 2-"C0)).O + D0a1&5(")%("4" + "#_0(&7+f,"/(&6.0% + 317 + 1&5(")%& + %" + x6)%0-"2)&O&50)6"0 + f2"10gB + , + 6"%"-"D+&(%0-"2)&O&50)6&0+E0("D0($+f20-021.,17L%)7g+,+&(%-.2)&O&50)6&0g+�=B +!A +;Y�A +Z(+"%D05.0% +-"1*+,+x%&O+2-"C0)).O+(0E"-D.1*("'+30%)6"J,/-")1"' + "#_(")%&B + (06"%"-$O + 6-.%6",-0D0(($O + "#_(")%0'+9)&%U.%&,($0 + 6"1106%&,$<B + ,"/(&6.L_&O + , + U)1",&7O + #"1*^"4"+xD"C&"(.1*("4" + 2"3d0D. + &1& + (02-03,&30(($O + %-U3($O + )&%U.C&7OA+\.6&D + "#-./"DB + D"a(" + -.))D.%-&,.%* + )"J#$%&'(UL + "#_(")%* + %0D+(0"#O"3&D$D+)"C&.1*($D+U)1",&0DB+6"%"-"0+-0/"(&-U0%+)+,(U%-0((&D&+6.50)%,.D&+)U#d06%.B+&O+2-"7,10(&0D+,",(0+&+-./,&%&0DA

E632734,$@=1>3./1$62F;4815325$2;J326819• )"J#$%&'(")%*+6.6+)",D0)%("0+#$%&0B+)"2-&6")(",0(&0+a&/(0'B+&O+20-0)050(&0+,+"#_0D+xD"C&"(.1*("J2)&O"1"4&50)6"D+&+C0((")%("J)D$)1","D + 2-")%-.()%,.OB + O.-.6%0-&/UL_00)7 + 2-&(7%&0D + 3-U4+3-U4.B + ,/.&D"2"(&D.(&0Dw + 3UO",("' + ),7/*L + 9"#_(")%*L<B+#1&/")%*LB+5U,)%,"D+R[w

• (0E"-D.1*($'B + "%6-$%$' + %&2 + "%("^0(&'w + "#_(")%* + )"/3.0%)7+)",D0)%($D&+U)&1&7D&+U5.)%(&6",w

• ,/.&D"30')%,&0 + , + )"J#$%&'("' + "#_(")%& + c + D0a2"/&C&"(("0B+%-0#UL_00+).D""2-03010(&7B+,$#"-.B+2-"7,10(&7+"%6-$%"'+2"/&C&&B+5%"+(0"#O"3&D"+317+,")2&%.(&7+&+-./,&%&7+)U#d06%(")%&+L("^0)%,.w

• 03&(.7 + C010,.7 + "-&0(%.C&7 + , + 307%01*(")%&B + )21"50(&0 + U5.)%(&6",+,"6-U4+"#_0'+/(.5&D"'+317+,)0O+C01&w

• -0E106)&,(.7 + "#_(")%*B + , + (0' + ")U_0)%,170%)7 + &(3&,&3U.1*(.7 + &+4-U22",.7 + -0E106)&7B + 2"/,"17L_.7 + L("^0)%,U + ")"/(.,.%*+2-"&)O"37_&0 + , + "#_(")%& + 2-"C0))$ + & + 7,10(&7B + ,$,"3&%* + &O + (.+&(3&,&3U.1*("0+")"/(.(&0+)0#7B+),"0'+2"/&C&&+,+"#_(")%&+&+a&/(&A

E632734,$@,-.A2A1B,6/1,$.6@,/84B+2"/,"17L_&0+"2-0301&%*+)"J#$%&'(")%* + 6.50)%,0(($D +2-&/(.6"D + 30%)6"J,/-")1"' + "#_(")%&A +!"J#$%&'(.7+"#_(")%*+D"a0%+,"/(&6(U%*+,(U%-&+2")%"7(("'+E"-D.1*("'+4-U22$ + 961.)).B + 61U#.B + 6"D.(3$ + & + 3-A< + & + 6.6 + (",.7 + (0E"-D.1*(.7+6-.%6",-0D0((.7+"#_(")%*+9)&%U.%&,(.7+"#_(")%*<A+M+"#-./",.%01*("'+2-.6%&60 + 6 + )"J#$%&'($D + "#_(")%7D + D"a(" + "%(0)%&k +0:+#&

=?

Page 30: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

`1+--)'(#01$4 & 0:+#aR & #+?"78" & $T#8R & .#"'$'T+78" & 3('%.$% & 0+&

0.(#X"1?(00'$1(-$&$&0.)/"'.(-$R&$'."#"0'8"&3(H+-'$7X$"0%&)#+1$&

`)#+1 & 1(1 & 0+,:8.$"<A + Z(. + D"a0% + 2-"7,&%*)7 + 50-0/ + &(%0-0)($0B+/.2"D(&,^&0)7 + 2" + xD"C&"(.1*("JC0((")%("' + (.)$_0((")%&B + 301. + &+U-"6&B+430+2-"&/"^1"+"%6-$%&0B+-"3&1")*+(","0+/(.(&0B+2"(&D.(&0+)0#7+& + 3-U4"4"B + 2"7,&1)7 + (",$' + "2$% + 307%01*(")%&A + P0 + )1U5.'(" + )"J#$%&'(.7+"#_(")%*+2")10+2-06-._0(&7+),"04"+)U_0)%,",.(&7+(.3"14"+")%.0%)7 + , + )U#d06%&,("D + D&-0 + 501",06.B + 2"7,170%)7 + 6.6 + (06.7+f)&%U.C&7J("-D.g + "%6-$%$O + "%("^0(&' + & + )",D0)%("4" + C0((")%("J)D$)1","4"+2"&)6.A

MAGA!1"#"35&6", + "%D05.0% + (.1&5&0 + 3,UO +(02-0D0(($O +E.6%"-",B+O.-.6%0-&/UL_&O + )"J#$%&'(UL+"#_(")%* +c +C0((")%($0 +")(",.(&7 +&+C010,$0 + "-&0(%&-$B + "#_&0 + U)%-0D10(&7 + U5.)%(&6", + 6"1106%&,("4"+,/.&D"30')%,&7A+fF"31&(("+)"J#$%&'(.7+"#_(")%*+"3(",-0D0(("+(0)0%+,+)0#0+&+C010,$0+"-&0(%&-$+)",D0)%("'+307%01*(")%&B +&+C0((")%($0+")(",.(&7+),"04"+03&()%,.+6.6+00+6"1106%&,("4"+)U#d06%.A+F"(7%("B+5%"+, + %.6"D + 6.50)%,0 + "(. + (0 + ,"/(&6.0% + )%&O&'("B + ).D. + 2" + )0#0w + 00+)%.(",10(&0 + ),7/.(" + )" + )20C&.1*($D& + & + ")"/(.(($D& + U)&1&7D&+6.a3"4"+&/+00 +U5.)%(&6",A +M(0 +x%&O+U)&1&'+"(. +#$)%-"+,$-"a3.0%)7+1&#" + , + )&D#&"%&50)6UL + )-._0((")%*B + 1&#" + , + E"-D.1*(UL+"-4.(&/",.((")%*B + 5%" + "#$5(" + & + (.#1L3.0%)7 + , + -0.1*("'+203.4"4&50)6"'+2-.6%&60g+�?B+!A+8@Y�A

|%& + ,.a($0 + O.-.6%0-&)%&6& + "2-03017L% + O.-.6%0- + "%("^0(&' + &+)"30-a.(&0+307%01*(")%&+)"J#$%&'("'+"#_(")%&B+6"%"-$0+,$)%-.&,.0%+203.4"4+)",D0)%("+)+30%*D&A+�010,$0+"-&0(%.C&&+)"J#$%&'("'+30%)6"J,/-")1"' + "#_(")%& + E"-D&-UL%)7 + , + 2-"7,10(&& + "#_04" + &(%0-0).B+2")%-"0(&& + 203.4"4"D + 6"1106%&,("4" + C0102"1.4.(&7B + 2-& + 6"%"-"D+U5&%$,.L%)7 + /(.5&D$0 + C01& + 317 + ,)0O + & + "%301*("4" + U5.)%(&6.B + ,+6"1106%&,("' + %,"-50)6"' + 307%01*(")%& + U5.)%(&6",B + "#0)205&,.L_0'+307%01*(")%(UL+,61L50((")%*+&+U,1050((")%*+,)0O+"#_&D+301"DA

`0E106)&,($0+2-"C0))$+,+"#_(")%&+(.2-.,17L%+E"-D&-",.(&0+00+C010,$O + U)%-0D10(&'B + 03&("4" + C0((")%("J)D$)1","4" + 2-")%-.()%,.A+F")6"1*6U+)"J#$%&'(.7+"#_(")%*+2-&(.310a&%+.6%U.1*("+(.)%"7_0DU+D"D0(%U+-0.1*("4"+#$%&7B+-0E106)&7+"#-._.0%+U5.)%(&6",+6+2-"^1"DU+"2$%U+&+2"3Ua3.0%+")D$)10(&0+),"&O+C0((")%0'+&+)D$)1",B+&(%0-0)",+&+C010'+6.6+2-")%-.()%,.+a&/(&+,+#U3U_0DA+\.6+)"J#$%&'(.7+"#_(")%*+,$O"3&% + (. + C0((")%("J)D$)1","0 + 2-")%-.()%," + 6.a3"4" + U5.)%(&6.B+.6%U.1&/&-U0%+")"/(.(&0+2-03)%.,10(&'+"+a&/(&B+a&/(0(($O+C0((")%0'+& + )D$)1",B + 6"--06%&-U0% + E"-D&-",.(&0 + )"#)%,0(("' + 2"/&C&& + 96.6+2-"7,10(&0 + ),"&O + C0((")%0' + , + -0.1*("' + )&%U.C&&<B + )%&DU1&-U0%+)U#d06%(")%* + L("^0)%,.A + M + )"#$%&'("' + 30%)6"J,/-")1"' + "#_(")%&+,"/(&6.0% + 2-")%-.()%," + ,/.&D""#"4._0(&7 + & + ,/.&D"2"330-a6& + ,+)",D0)%("D+2"&)60+)D$)1",+&+"-&0(%&-",+,+a&/(0307%01*(")%&A

",86/2F7>=26?.C$2;J3268<+c+7,10(&0+)"C&.1*("J203.4"4&50)6"0B+,+(0' + 2-"%06.L% + 2-"C0))$B + /.3.,.0D$0 + & + U2-.,170D$0 + 203.4"4"D + &+

;>

Page 31: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

).D"2"-"a3.L_&0)7B+2-&)U_&0+,(U%-0((&D+/.6"(.D+-./,&%&7+"%6-$%"'+)&)%0D$A+~0+,1&7(&0+(.+U5.)%(&6",+,"+D("4"D+(02-03)6./U0D"B+,.a("B+5%" + "(. + O.-.6%0-&/U0%)7 + ),"#"3($D + O.-.6%0-"D + "%("^0(&'B + 2-&+6"%"-"D+,")2&%.((&6+(0+%"1*6"+)%-0D&%*)7+)""%,0%)%,",.%*+("-D.D+&+2-.,&1.D+"#_(")%&+9%A6A+"(.+/(.5&D.+317+(04"<B+("+&+).D"-0.1&/",.%*)7+,+307%01*(")%&+&+"#_0(&&B+&)O"37+&/+1&5("'+2"/&C&&B+2-"7,17%*+),"&+)U#d06%($0+6.50)%,.A

!"#$%&'(.7+"#_(")%*+D"a0%+#$%*+)D"301&-",.(.+203.4"4"DB +"(.+,61L5.0%+,/-")1$O+&+30%0'+,+"#_&'+O"3+,/.&D"30')%,&7B+6.6+)"J#$%&7B+6"%"-$' + -./,"-.5&,.0%)7 + #1.4"3.-7 + /.D$)1U + & + 21.(U + 4-U22$+"-4.(&/.%"-",A +P" + -./,&,.7)* + )%&O&'("B + "(. + (0 +D"a0% +&D0%* +a0)%6"+/.3.(($O+"#7/.%01*($O+E"-D+2-"a&,.(&7+)"J#$%&7B+"2-03010(.+1&^*+,"/D"a(.7 +&O +,.-&.%&,(")%*A +F"x%"DU +,.a(.+"-&0(%.C&7+203.4"4. +(.+(.)%-"0(&7+&+&(%0-0)$+,")2&%.((&6",+,+2-"a&,.(&&+"#-./",.%01*("'+)&%U.C&&A

T&,.7 + ),7/* + ,"/(&6.0% + , + 2-"C0))0 + "#_04" + 2-"a&,.(&7 + (","4"+#$%&7B + 2")%"7(("' + -0E106)&,("' + 307%01*(")%& + 9&(3&,&3U.1*("' + &+6"1106%&,("'<+)+")D$)10(&0D+,)04"+2-"&)O"37_04"+317+D0(7+9i<+&+317+(.)+9R$<B+)+#"1*^&D+%0D2"D+&+,$)"6"'+&(%0()&,(")%*L+%050(&7+a&/(&+9#$%&7 + , + 3(0<B + 5%" + )"/3.0% +3"2"1(&%01*(UL+%-U3(")%*B + (" + ,1&70% +(.+E"-D&-",.(&0 + "#_(")%&A + Z%("^0(&7 + D0a3U + ,)0D& + U5.)%(&6.D& + &+"-4.(&/.%"-.D&+c+-.,0()%,"B+3&.1"4B+"%6-$%")%*+2"/&C&'B+,"/D"a(")%*+2-"7,&%* + )0#7 + & + 2"D"5* + ).D"-0.1&/.C&& + 3-U4"4"A + P",$0+"%6-$,.L_&0)7 +)D$)1$+/.)%.,17L%+501",06.+20-0)D.%-&,.%*+)&)%0DU+C0((")%0'B + 2",030(&0 + & + 307%01*(")%*B + )%&DU1&-UL% + 2-"C0))$+).D"2"/(.(&7B+).D""%("^0(&7B+).D""-4.(&/.C&&+&+).D"-04U17C&&A

b.-.B1 $@,-.A2A. $ 1 $ @61W2?2A.+ 7 $G2-,?1=27.311 $1 $=,.?1>.011$R6?2715 $ @2 $ @=2C7?,31H $ -,86/2F7>=26?25 $ 2;J32681k + "#0)205&%*+),"#"3UB + ,$#"- + U5.)%&7 + 9(0 + U5.)%&7< + , + 6"1106%&,("' + 307%01*(")%&B+,$#"- + 30%*D& + (.2-.,10(&' + & + )2")"#", + 307%01*(")%&B + 2"/&C&&A+M/-")1$0 + 2"330-a&,.L% + "%("^0(&7 + -.,0()%,.B + ,/.&D("4" + &(%0-0).B+,/.&D"2-&(7%&7 +& +,/.&D"U,.a0(&7w +)"/3.L%+, +"#_(")%& +U)1",&7+317+D0a2"/&C&"(("4" + ,/.&D"30')%,&7B + )%&DU1&-UL% + 2-"7,10(&0+U5.)%(&6.D& + ),"0' + 2"/&C&&B + 2"(&D.(&0 + 2"/&C&& + 3-U4"4"A +P.2-.,177+EU(6C&"(&-",.(&0 + 30%)6"J,/-")1"' + "#_(")%&B + ,/-")1$' + 3"1a0(+U5&%$,.%* + "2$% + "2$% + 307%01*(")%&B + "%("^0(&'B + %,"-50)6"'+).D"-0.1&/.C&&B + 6"%"-$' + -0#0("6 + , + (0' + 2"1U5&%A + M/-")1"DU + (.3"+)%&DU1&-",.%* + -0E106)&,($0 + 2-"C0))$B + ,$,"37 + ,/.&D"30')%,&0+U5.)%(&6",+,+"#_(")%&+(.+")"/(.(($'+U-",0(*w+2"(&D.%*+&+U5&%$,.%*+,1&7(&0 + ,$)%-.&,.0D$O + "%("^0(&' + & + -0E106)&& + (. + E"-D&-",.(&0+03&("4"+C0((")%("J)D$)1","4"+2-")%-.()%,.A

M.a(" + 2"D(&%*B + 5%" + "#_(")%* + c + x%" + a&,"0 + "#-./",.(&0B + "(.+E"-D&-U0%)7 + ).D&D& + U5.)%(&6.D& + , + ),"#"3("D + "#_0(&& + -.,($O+)U#d06%",B +/30)*+(0%+2-032&).(($O+("-D+&+2-.,&1B+"(&+E"-D&-UL%)7+).D&D& + U5.)%(&6.D& + , + "%6-$%"D + D0a2"/&C&"(("D + 3&.1"40B + ,+

;8

Page 32: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

&(%0-0)("' + f/.O,.%&,^0'g + ,)0O + 307%01*(")%&A + Z#_(")%* + -"a3.0%)7+,D0)%0+)+)U#d06%.D&+00+"#-./UL_&D&B+")%.0%)7+,+&O+,(U%-0((0D+D&-0A

:2F;48153RH $ 2;J3268< $ Q $ 6?2c34, $ @,=,W2-4 $ 62682C315$6RJ,687RHJ,5$A=R@@4I$430+,/.&D"),7/.($k+OD /.&(%0-0)",.((")%* + "#_(")%& + 2-"&)O"37_&D + 930')%,&0DB+)"#$%&0DB+20-0a&,.(&0D<w

PD xD"C&"(.1*($' + ,$O"3 + &/ + 2"4-Ua0((")%& + , + 2",)03(0,(")%*+9xD"C&"(.1*("J2)&O"1"4&50)6.7+E"-D.+"#_(")%&<w+

%D ")"/(.(&0 + 2-"&)O"37_04" + & + 04" + /(.50(&7 + 9"#_(")%*L + &+"%301*($D+U5.)%(&6"D<+c+-0E106)&,(.7+"#_(")%*w+

:A ,$O"3+"#_(")%&+,+03&("0+C0((")%("J)D$)1","0+2-")%-.()%,"w+dD -0E106)&,(.7 + "#_(")%* + , + C0102"1.4.(&& + & + 2-"06%&-",.(&&+307%01*(")%&+2"+-0.1&/.C&&+"#_&O+C0((")%($O+")(",.(&'w+

YA ,$O"3 +"#_(")%& + , + 307%01*(")%* + 2" +-0.1&/.C&& +"#_0' +C010,"'+U)%-0D10((")%&A+M$O"3 + "#_(")%& + (. + 307%01*(")%($' + U-",0(* + 9@JY + /,0(*7<+

2-032"1.4.0%B + 5%" + ,"/(&6^.7 + )"J#$%&'(.7 + "#_(")%* + 98J: + /,0(*7<+2"3%"16(U1. + 20-0")D$)10(&0 + U5.)%(&6.D& + ),"04" + )U_0)%,",.(&7 + &+)%&DU1&-",.1.+2-"7,10(&0+307%01*(")%&B+6.6+,$-.a0(&0+/(.5&D$O+317+,)0O+C0((")%0'+&+)D$)1",A+F")10+%.6"4"+)")%"7(&7B+20-03+"#_(")%*L+D"a0%+,)%.%*+-73+,"2-")",k+fQ.6+x%"+2-"&/"^1"�gw+fh17+(.)+/(.5&D$+%.6&0 + "#_00 + 20-0a&,.(&7 + & + %.6"' + U-",0(* + ,/.&D"2"(&D.(&7B+6"1106%&,(.7 +307%01*(")%*�gw +fR"a(" +1& +3")%&5* +%.6"' +"#_(")%& +&+,/.&D"2"(&D.(&7�gA + F03.4"4B + 2"330-a&,.7 + ,")2"D&(.(&7 + -0#7% + "+20-0a&%"D+)")%"7(&&B+D"a0%+,0)%&+&O+6+D"301&-",.(&L+&+-0.1&/.C&&+(","' + )"J#$%&'("' + "#_(")%&A + R"a(" + -.))D.%-&,.%* + )"J#$%&'(UL+"#_(")%*+&+,+-.D6.O+,(",*+)"/3.,.0D"'B+6-.%6",-0D0(("'+4-U22$A+

E@48D ${._0 + ,)04" + )"J#$%&'(.7 + "#_(")%* + &/ + (0/(.6"D$O + &+D.1"/(.6"D$O + 1L30' + D"a0% + )E"-D&-",.%*)7 + , + &4-0 + 9ZA!A�./D.(B+NAMAQU2-&7(",B + FAMA!%02.(",<B + (. + %-0(&(40 + 9GAMAM.56",B+mARAF-&O"a.(B+mA!AF-U%50(6",<B+)#"-0+9MAmAQ.-.6",)6&'B+PAmA!.1$6B+!AFA`"D.(0(6",.B+\A!A�.O",.<A+

!"J#$%&'(.7 + "#_(")%*B + 6.6 + 6-.%6",-0D0((.7 + (",.7 + 4-U22.B+7,170%)7 + ," + D("4"D + )2"(%.((" + "#-./UL_0')7 + 9mA�AQ&-2&5(&6<A + Z(.+E"-D&-UL0%)7 + (. + ")(",.(&& + ),"#"3("4" + "2-03010(&7 + L("^0)%,"D+),"04" + U5.)%&7 + , + (0'A + M"/(&6.L_.7 + 30%)6"J,/-")1.7 + )"J#$%&'(.7+"#_(")%*+,61L5.0%+203.4"4.+93-U4&O+,/-")1$O<+&+L("^0'+,+"#_&'+O"3+2-"&)O"37_04" + ,/.&D"30')%,&7 + 6.6 + )"J#$%&7B + -./,"-.5&,.0%)7+#1.4"3.-7 + /.D$)1U + & + 21.(U + 4-U22$ + "-4.(&/.%"-",B + &B + , + %"a0 + ,-0D7B+-./,&,.0%)7 + )%&O&'("B + %.6 + 6.6 + (0 + D"a0% + #$%* + a0)%6" + /.3.(($O+"#7/.%01*($O + E"-D + 2-"a&,.(&7 + )"J#$%&7A + !"J#$%&'(.7 + "#_(")%*+O.-.6%0-&/U0%)7 + (0E"-D.1*($D + %&2"D + "%("^0(&'B + )%&DU1&-U0%+),"#"3($0+30')%,&7+U5.)%(&6",B+2"330-a&,.0%+2-"7,10(&0+&(&C&.%&,$+&+%,"-50)6&O+)2")"#",+).D"-0.1&/.C&&A

;=

Page 33: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

!&%U.%&,(.7 + )"J#$%&'(.7 + "#_(")%*B + )61.3$,.L_.7)7 + ,+2-")%-.()%,0 + ),"#"3("4" + "#_0(&7B + 2-"7,170%)7 + 6.6 + (0E"-D.1*("0+)""#_0)%,"A + Z(. + -./D$%. + 2" + )")%.,U + U5.)%(&6",A + ~0 + ,"/(&6(",0(&0+),7/.(" + ) + "#_0'B + /(.5&D"' +& +&(%0-0)("' +317 + ,)0O +307%01*(")%*LB + )+"%6-$%$D+1&5(")%("+/(.5&D$D+"#_0(&0D+D0a3U+203.4"4"DB +3-U4&D&+,/-")1$D&B + & + ,")2&%.((&6.D&A + !,"#"3("0 + "#_0(&0B + %-0#UL_00+).D""2-03010(&7+&+,$#"-.B+")"/(.(&7+&+,$-.a0(&7+"%6-$%"'+2"/&C&&+(0"#O"3&D"+317+,")2&%.(&7+&+-./,&%&7+)U#d06%($O+),"')%,+L("^0'+&+30,U^06A +F-"&11L)%-&-U0D + 2"1"a0(&7 + " + )"J#$%&'("' + "#_(")%&+"2$%"D + 2-.6%&50)6"' + -.#"%$ + ) + 203.4"4.D& + & + ) + L("^0)%,"D+9)%.-^061.))(&6.D&+&+)%U30(%.D&+(.5.1*($O+6U-)",<+"#-./",.%01*($O+U5-0a30(&7O+l1*7(",)6.A

P.&#"100 +7-6" +)"J#$%&'($0+"#_(")%& +, +-.D6.O +"%301*("4" +301.+2-"7,&1&)*+,+307%01*(")%&+61U#.A+F"+)U%&B+21"3"%,"-(.7+a&/(*+61U#.+J+x%" + 50-03. + )"J#$%&'B + 6"%"-$0 + -"a3.L% + (",$0 + &30&B + (",UL + C010,UL+U)%-0D10((")%*+U5.)%(&6",B+)"/3.L%+U)1",&7+317+-0.1&/.C&&+.,%"-)6&O+2-"06%", + "%301*($O + U5.)%(&6",A + F-& + x6)20-&D0(%.1*("' + -.#"%0 + )+61.))($D&+-U6","3&%017D&B+&D&+2-","3&1")*+"%301*("0+301"+,+61.))0B+,$,"37_00 +^6"1*(&6", + (. + "%6-$%"0 + "#_0(&0 + & + -0E106)&LB + 6"%"-"0+D"a("+-.))D.%-&,.%*+6.6+2-"7,10(&0+)"J#$%&'("'+"#_(")%&+,+61.))0A+

F-& + (.^0D + 6"()U1*%&-",.(&& + -./-.#.%$,.1.)* + )&)%0D.+"#"#_.L_&O + U-"6", + 1&%0-.%U-$B + 2-",030(($O + ~AMAl#. + 9U5&%010D+1&%0-.%U-$+4&D(./&&+H;;+l1*7(",)6.<A+F-032"1.4.1")*B+5%"+"%301*($'+U-"6 + 9/.61L5&%01*($' + U-"6 + 2" + %0D0< + D"a0% + D"301&-",.%*)7 + 317+2-"7,10(&7 + , + 61.))0 + )"J#$%&'("' + "#_(")%&B + )%&DU1&-UL_0'+)U#d06%($0 + 6.50)%,. + U50(&6",A + Z)"#0((" + U3.5($D& + #$1& + U-"6& + 2"+MA�06)2&-U + 9f�.D10%g<B + jARAh")%"0,)6"DU + 9fF-0)%U210(&0 + &+(.6./.(&0g<A + \"B + 5%" + 2-"&)O"3&1" + (. + U-"60B + a&,"' + )2"-B + "%6-$%.7+3&)6U))&7 + ^6"1*(&6", + & + 203.4"4.B + 20-01"a0(&0 + )D$)1",+OU3"a0)%,0(("4" + 2-"&/,030(&7 + (. + -0.1*(UL + a&/(* + & + C0((")%&+)%.-^061.))(&6",B+.6%&,(.7+,61L50((")%*+U50(&6",+,+O"3+U-"6.B+D"4U%+),&30%01*)%,",.%* + " + ,"/(&6(",0(&& + )"J#$%&'("' + "#_(")%& + 6.6+)")%"7(&7+61.)).A+F"3%,0-a30(&0+x%&O+2"/&C&'+D"a("+(.'%&+,+-.#"%0+2"#03&%017 + 6"(6U-). + fl5&%01* + 4"3. + `"))&&c=>>Yg + mA�Al)20()6"4"A+F")10 + "%6-$%"4" + U-"6.B + "( + 3.1 + )103UL_&' + .14"-&%D + ),"&O + U-"6",k+7>[email protected], $ 6 $ RB,31/.G1 $ Q $ 62@=1/26327,31, $ B,=,> $ 2;J15$138,=,6 $ Q $ @231G.31, $ 1>RB.,G2A2 $ G.8,=1.?. $ Q $ 627G,6832,$872=B,6872A

F" + (.^0DU + "2$%UB + &4-",$0 + & + %-0(&(4",$0 + E"-D$ + -.#"%$ + )+,")2&%.((&6.D&B + 2"5%& + ,)043. + ,$,"37% + U5.)%(&6", + , + )")%"7(&0 + )"J#$%&'("'+"#_(")%&k + , +(&O +2-&)U%)%,U0% +,$O"3 +, + 03&("0 +C0((")%("J)D$)1","0+2-")%-.()%,"B+/.3.,.0D"0+&4-"'+&1&+"#_&D+&(3&,&3U.1*("+&+1&5(")%(" + /(.5&D$D + "#_0(&0DA + !"J#$%&'(.7 + 30%)6"J,/-")1.7+"#_(")%* + D"a0% + D"301&-",.%*)7 + & + -0.1&/",$,.%*)7 + , + "-4.(&/U0D$O+203.4"4"D + U)1",&7OB + 6.6 + 6-.%6",-0D0((.7 + 4-U22. + ) + (",$D + )")%.,"D+

;;

Page 34: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

U5.)%(&6",A+h1&%01*(")%*+)U_0)%,",.(&7+%.6"'+"#_(")%&+"%+8>+5.)",+3" + @J8> + 3(0'A + F-&D0-"D + D"a0% + )1Ua&%* + "2&).(&0 + 2"4-Ua0(&7+f`"3R&-gB + 2-","3&D"4" + )" + )%.-^061.))(&6.D& + 4&D(./&& + H + ;;+l1*7(",)6.+�8>�A+

b.-.B1$@,-.A2A.$7$=,.?1>.011$G2-,?1$62F;4815325$2;J326819! "#0)205&%* + ),"#"3UB + 3"#-","1*(")%* + ,$#"-. + U5.)%&7 + 9(0+

U5.)%&7< + , + )",D0)%("' + 307%01*(")%&B + ,"/D"a(")%* + ,$#"-. + 9,+2-")%-.()%,0 + 30%)6"J,/-")1"' + "#_(")%&< + (.2-.,10(&' + & + )2")"#",+307%01*(")%&w

! ,$)%-.&,.%* + & + 2"330-a&,.%* + "%("^0(&7 + -.,0()%,.B+,/.&D("4"+&(%0-0).B+,/.&D"2-&(7%&7+&+,/.&D"U,.a0(&7w

! )"/3.%* + , + "#_(")%& + U)1",&7 + 317 + D0a2"/&C&"(("4"+,/.&D"30')%,&7B+)%&DU1&-",.%*+2-"7,10(&0+&+")"/(.(&0+L("^.D&+),"0'+2"/&C&&B+)2")"#(")%&+U,.a.%*+&+2"(&D.%*+2"/&C&L+3-U4"4"w

! D"301&-U7 + )"J#$%&'(UL + "#_(")%*B + U5&%$,.%* + "2$%B+6"%"-$'+,+(0'+2"1U5.%+D"1"3$0+1L3&w

! )%&DU1&-",.%* + -0E106)&,($0 + 2-"C0))$B + U3017%* + &D+3")%.%"5(" + #"1*^"0 + ,-0D7B + %0D + ).D$D + ,$,"37 + ,/.&D"30')%,&0+U5.)%(&6", + (. + ")"/(.(($' + U-",0(*B + )%&DU1&-",.%* + 2"(&D.(&0 + &D&+),"0'+2"/&C&&+2"+"%("^0(&L+6+"#_(")%&+&+),"0'+a&/(&w

! 2"(&D.%* + & + U5&%$,.%* + , + ),"0' + -.#"%0 + ,1&7(&0+,$)%-.&,.0D$O + "%("^0(&' + & + -0E106)&& + (. + E"-D&-",.(&0 + 03&("4"+C0((")%("J)D$)1","4"+2-")%-.()%,.+,(U%-&+"#_(")%&A

G%.6B + )"J#$%&'(")%* + c +1(*"0.7"''84 & H#$3'(1 & /".01+,73#+0?+4&+:V'+0.$=+Z(+(.O"3&%+,$-.a0(&0k+,+xD"C&"(.1*("D+)#1&a0(&&+510(",+"#_(")%&w+),"#"3("D+O.-.6%0-0+),7/0'+&+"%("^0(&'+,(U%-&+"#_(")%&w+2"7,10(&& + "#_04" + C0((")%("J)D$)1","4" + 2-")%-.()%,. + "#_(")%&w+"%6-$%"D + D0a2"/&C&"(("D + ,/.&D"30')%,&& + D0a3U + U5.)%(&6.D&w+/(.5&D")%& + 317 + U5.)%(&6", + &(3&,&3U.1*($O + & + )",D0)%($O+-0E106)&,($O + 2-"C0))",B + 2"/,"17L_&O + ")"/(.%* + & + 2-"7,&%*+)U#d06%(")%*A

!"J#$%&'(")%*+2"(&D.0%)7+6.6+")"#"0+fD0-C.%01*("0g+)")%"7(&0+30%)6"J,/-")1"'+"#_(")%&B+2-"7,170%)7+,+4-U220+6.6++0+:+"&0+0.+%'$"&xD"C&"(.1*("' + & + )D$)1","' + (.)$_0((")%& + ," + ,/.&D"30')%,&&w+O.-.6%0-&/U0%)7 + 2-"7,10(&0D ++:V"T+ & 9"''+0.'+,0-80?+7+T+&

H#+0.#('0.7(+ , + 30%)6"J,/-")1"' + "#_(")%&B + ,"/(&6.L_04" + 50-0/+20-0)050(&0 + ("-DB + C0((")%0' + & + )D$)1", + U5.)%(&6", + 2-& + "%6-$%"D+D0a2"/&C&"(("D+,/.&D"30')%,&&+U5.)%(&6",A

!"J#$%&'(.7 + 30%)6"J,/-")1.7 + "#_(")%* + )"/3.0% + U)1",&7 + 317+-./,&%&7 +0)V'+0.'82R & :8.$4'82 & 1(*"0.7+ L("^0)%,. + 9),"#"3("'+).D"-0.1&/.C&& + & + ).D"-./,&%&7<B + 3.0% + "2$% + "%("^0(&' + (. + ")(",0+4UD.(&)%&50)6&O + C0((")%0'B + ,")2&%$,.0% + )"C&"6U1*%U-($0 + )2")"#$+2-"7,10(&7 + )U#d06%(")%&B + 5U,)%," + "%,0%)%,0((")%&B + E"-D&-U0%+3"D&(.(%U+

;:

Page 35: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

!"J#$%&'(.7+"#_(")%*+6.6+")"#"0+)")%"7(&0+D"a0%+#$%*+2-"7,10(.+203.4"4"D+,(U%-&+2")%"7(("'+30%)6"J,/-")1"'+"#_(")%&+961.)).B+61U#.B+6"D.(3$<w + 6.6 + (",.7 + (0E"-D.1*(.7 + 6-.%6",-0D0((.7 + "#_(")%*+9)&%U.%&,(.7+"#_(")%*<A+F")10+2-06-._0(&7+)U_0)%,",.(&7+,+6.50)%,0+)"J#$%&'("' + 30%)6"J,/-")1"' + "#_(")%&B + "(. + ")%.0%)7 + , + 2.D7%&+U5.)%(&6",+1(1&0$.)(9$%,+:#(3"9B+2-"3"1a.0%+,1&7%*+(.+&O+-./,&%&0A

e18,=.8R=.8A +N):"#&D=+ i+&+\[�+RANU#0-+ �F0-A +) +(0DA+SA!A\0-0(*0,.B +PAj.'(4"1*30w+2")10)1A+FA!A�U-0,&5.�A+c+RAk+M$)^.7+^6"1.B+8??;A=A +K+?+-$'01$4 &b=P=+ Q +2")%-"0(&L+)"C&.1*("J2)&O"1"4&50)6"' +6"(C02C&&+,"/-.)%("4" + -./,&%&7 + D0a1&5(")%($O + ,/.&D"30')%,&' + �� + M/.&D"30')%,&0+6"1106%&,. + & + 1&5(")%& + , + 6"DDU(&)%&50)6"D + ,")2&%.(&& + � + \0/A3"61.3",A+\.11&(k+\.11&()6&'+203.4"4&50)6&'+&(J%+&DA+|AM&1*30B+8?K=A+c+!A+;@+c+;IA;A+P"7$'&K=+\0"-&7+2"17+,+)"C&.1*($O+(.U6.O+�+QA�0,&(+J+!F#Ak+`05*B+=>>>A:A +P).+X1$'&>=6=+|D"C&"(.1*($0+2"%0(C&.1$+6"1106%&,.AJRAfF03.4"4&6.gB+8?KKA@A+ D(1(#"'1+ & >=!=+ R0%"3&6. + "-4.(&/.C&& + ,")2&%.%01*("4" + 2-"C0)).�+mA!AR.6.-0(6"+�F"3+-03A+�A!AR.6.-0(6"�AJ+RAk+G/3J,"+mFP+`!j! B+8?@>AYA+6+7$1+7(&P=@=+h0%)6&'+6"1106%&,+6.6+)"C&.1*("J203.4"4&50)6.7+)&)%0D.+�+�AGAP",&6",.B + mA\AQU-.6&( + �� + \0"-0%&50)6&0 + 2-"#10D$ + ,")2&%.%01*("4"+6"1106%&,.A+c+\.-%Uk+\.-%U)6&'+4")U3A+U(&,0-)&%0%B+8?I@A+c+!A+:K+c+@IAIA +6+7$1+7( & P=@=+ F03.4"4&6. + 30%)6"4" + 6"1106%&,.A + 9M"2-")$ + %0"-&&< + �+�AGAP",&6",.A+J+RAk+F03.4"4&6.B+8?IKAKA +B(#8T$'&N=A=+!"C&.1*(.7+2)&O"1"4&7A+F-"#10D$+D0%"3"1"4&&B+&)%"-&&+&+%0"-&&+�+NAhAF.-$4&(A+c+!F#AB+8???A?A +!?+:+/*$1+7 & C=@=+ Z50-6& + 2)&O"1"4&& + "#-./",.(&7A + =J0 + &/3.(&0B+20-0-.#"%.(("0+&+3"2"1(0(("0A+c+N&-"#&3a.(k+G/3J,"+N�FGB+=>>@A8>A+J)0.+7(&@=I=+!"#$%&'(.7+"#_(")%*+6.6+E.6%"-+-./,&%&7+&+,")2&%.(&7+)U#d06%(")%&+L("^0'+&+30,U^06+��+M0)%(&6+Q")%-"D)6"4"+4")U3.-)%,0(("4"+U(&,0-)&%0%.+&DA+PAmAP06-.)",.A+J+=>>YA+J+\A+8=A+!0-&7+4UD.(&%.-($0+(.U6&AJ+H + :A + J + !A + Y + c + 8=w +�U)%",. + GASA+ F"4-Ua0(&0 + f-"a30(&0 + D&-",g + ��+M")2&%.%01*(.7+-.#"%.+,+^6"10A+J+=>>IA+J+H+;A+J+!A+8;8+c+8:>w+�U)%",.+GASA+h0%)6"J,/-")1.7 + "#_(")%* + c + /(.5&D"0 + U)1",&0 + ,")2&%.(&7 + L("^0)%,. + ��+!&#&-)6&'+203.4"4&50)6&'+aU-(.1A+J+=>>KA+J+H+88A+J!A=;>J=;?A

;@

Page 36: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

!"4."&#(3)-'+"R&/+:#+"R&7"*'+"R

!"4."c&!H(0$:+&C(-&01(W".&0"#/"*'+"&

L)001$4&'(#+/&d

6=>=&6"1#(0+7&

E;=.>27.31,$7$@216/,$61GX2311

>=C=&J)7(?+7

`4>27$627=,G,332681!,7%&%01* + P&6"1.' + !0-#)6&' + 2&).1B + 5%" + )U_0)%,U0% + 50%$-0+

")(",($O + &D2U1*).B + 3,&aU_&O + 1L3*D&k + 1&5("0 + #1.4")")%"7(&0 + &+)"#)%,0(($0 + U3","1*)%,&7w + )0D0'($0 + & + 6-",($0 + U/$w + "#_0)%,0(($0+/.6"($w+)",0)%*+&+5U,)%,"+2-&)U%)%,&7+T&,"4"+N"4.A+{0%,0-%$'+&D2U1*)+c+20-,.7+1&(&7+"#"-"($B+0)1&+501",06+(0+U30-a&,.0%+#.)%&"($+)",0)%&B+"(+"%)%U2.0%+(.+,%"-UL+1&(&L+c+2$%.0%)7+/._&%&%*)7+"#_0)%,0(($D&+/.6"(.D&w+(0+U30-a.,+,%"-ULB+"%)%U2.0%+(.+%-0%*LB+&+%.6+c+3"+2")103(0'A+GD0((" +, + %.6"' +2")103",.%01*(")%& +2-"&)O"3&% +304-.3.C&7 +501",06.B+&#"+&+2")103(LL+1&(&L+"#"-"($+%0-70%+501",06B+2-&O"37+,+)")%"7(&0+"3&("50)%,.B + 2"%0-& + )D$)1. + a&/(&B + %U2"4" + #0/-./1&5&7 + & + 2"1("4"+"%5.7(&7A

P. + (.^&O + 41./.O + &/D0(&1)7 + 3UO",("J2)&O"1"4&50)6&' + 61&D.%+"#_0)%,.A + Q.-3&(.1*(" + D0(70%)7 + )"30-a.(&0 + ,(U%-0((0' + a&/(&+)",-0D0(("4" + 501",06.B + #.1.()&-UL_04" + (. + 4-.(& + f2")103(0' + 1&(&&+"#"-"($gA + Z3&( + &/ + #0/U)1",($O + ,$/",", + (.^04" + ,-0D0(& + c+3,2;W2-1G268<$@=CG2A2$1$@=2X,66123.?<32$2;,6@,B,332A2$=,V,31C$@=2;?,G4 $/R?<8171=27.31C $ B,?27,B,6/2A2 $ 7 $ B,?27,/,D $|%. + /.3.5.+2-7D" + ),7/.(. + ) + 2-0"3"10(&0D+ "%5Ua30((")%&B + 30/"-&0(%&-",.((")%&+&1& +"2U)%"^0((")%& +"%301*("' + 501",050)6"' +a&/(&A+ l + "#_0)%,. +(0%+&("4"+2U%&+&)%"-&50)6"4"+-./,&%&7k+,")2-"&/,"3)%,"+")(",+4-.a3.()6"'+& +(-.,)%,0(("' +)"1&3.-(")%& +1L30'B +1&#" +)2"1/.(&0 +6 + 4UD.(&%.-("'+6.%.)%-"E0B + , + 6"%"-"' + (0 + ")%.(0%)7 + (& + )"C&.1*($O + 1&30-",B + (&+.U%).'30-",A+

M01&5.'^&' + 2)&O"1"4 +yy + ,06. +MAj-.(61 + %.6 + 2-"6"DD0(%&-",.1+2-"#10DUk +56"0-+.#% & '( & '(X) & 7"#) & 7 & H+."'9$(? & *"?+7"1(R & -8 & '" &/+?W'8&3(1#87(.F&T?(3(&'(&.+R&*.+&*"?+7"*'8"&?U/$&%7?%U.0%&$R&:8.F &

-+W".R&70"T/(&:)/).&+0.(7(.F0%&-"'FX$'0.7+-=&6+&$-"''+&H+Y.+-)&

1(W/84&$3&'(0&*)70.7)".&783+7&H#$0+"/$'$.F0%&1&Y.+-)&-"'FX$'0.7)= &

A"?(&H?+2$=&6+&+'$&0.(').&"V"&2)W"R&"0?$&-8&'"&:)/"-&/"?(.F&70"R&*.+ &

7&'(X$2&0$?(2R&*.+:8&)?)*X$.F&$2;AM + (.)%"7_00 + ,-0D7 + Ua0 + "50,&3(. + EU(3.D0(%.1*(.7 + /.,&)&D")%*+

20-)206%&,+(.^0'+C&,&1&/.C&&+"%+%0O+)2")"#(")%0'+&+6.50)%,+501",06.B+6"%"-$0 + )%.(",7%)7 + & + E"-D&-UL%)7 + , + "#-./",.(&&A + !",-0D0(("0+203.4"4&50)6"0+)""#_0)%,"+6.6+(&6"43.+-.(00+)%"&%+(.+20-02U%*0k+1&#"+2-0#$,.%* + , + 2"/&C&& + (.#1L3.%017 + & + 6"DD0(%.%"-. + 92" + )U%&B+f/.1"a(&6.g<+(.)U_($O+2-"#10D+)"C&.1*("'+&+6U1*%U-("'+a&/(&w+1&#"+

;Y

Page 37: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

&)6.%* + & + 2-0%,"-7%* + E"-D$ + ")D$)10(("4" + & + 307%01*("4" + "%,0%. + (.+,$/",$+��V+,06.A

M + &)%"-&50)6"D + "2$%0 + 501",050)%,. + )1"a&1&)* + ,2"1(0+"2-03010(($0 + D&-","//-0(50)6&0 + "-&0(%.C&& + & + ),7/.(($0 + ) + (&D&+203.4"4&50)6&0 + U#0a30(&7A + F-&D0(&%01*(" + 6 + )",-0D0(("DU+"%050)%,0(("DU + "#-./",.(&L + D"a(" + ,$301&%* + %-& + %&2. + C0(%-.C&&+203.4"4&50)6"' + D$)1&k +8,W32/=.81B,6/15I $ ARG.31681B,6/15 $ 1$.38=2@2?2A1B,6/15A + Z(& + )U_0)%,0((" + -./1&5.L%)7 + &)O"3($D&+2"1"a0(&7D& + & + D"4U% + #$%* + "2&).($ + 6.6 + #./",$0 + "#-./",.%01*($0+D"301&A + Q.a3.7 + &/ + (&O + 7,170%)7 + &)%"5(&6"D + U)%"'5&,$O + x%.1"(($O+")(",.(&'B + , + )""%,0%)%,&& + ) + 6"%"-$D& + "#-./",.(&0 + )%-"&% + ),"L+2",)03(0,(UL+2-.6%&6UA +MD0)%0 +"(&+"6./$,.L% +"_U%&D"0 +,1&7(&0 +(.+.-O&%06%U-U + ,)0' + )&)%0D$ + "#-./",.(&7B + E"-D&-UL% + 00 + "#1&6 + &+)%-.%04&50)6&'+-0)U-)A+`.))D"%-&D+&O+2"3-"#(00A

f,W32/=.81B,6/.C $ G2-,?<D $\0O("6-.%&50)6.7 + D"301* + 7,170%)7+20-03","' +,0-)&0' + 61.))&50)6"' +f/(.(&0,"J2-"),0%&%01*)6"'g +D"301&+"#-./",.(&7A +Z(. +2-0&DU_0)%,0(("+2"1.4.0%)7 +(. +)&1U +501",050)6"4"+-./UD. + & + ,0-U + , + (.U5("J%0O(&50)6&' + 2-"4-0))B + "20-&-U0% + 2-&(C&2"D+(.U5("' + "#")(",.((")%& + & + 3")%",0-(")%& + &/1.4.0D$O + /(.(&'B+-.))D.%-&,.0% + %0O(&6U + & + %0O("1"4&L + , + 6.50)%,0 + ")(",($O + E.6%"-",+,)0)%"-"((04" + -./,&%&7 + & + -04U1&-",.(&7 + a&/(&A + M + ")(",U+%0O("6-.%&50)6"'+D"301&+2"1"a0(+6"D20%0(%(")%($'+2"3O"3B +6"%"-$'+2-03)%.,170% + )"#"' +2"2$%6U +20-0O"3. +"% + )O"1.)%&5("4" +2-02"3.,.(&7+-./-"/(0(($O + 3&)C&21&( + 6 + )"/3.(&L + U)1",&' + 317 + &O + 6"D2106)("4"+"),"0(&7+U50(&6.D&A+

m6C0(% + , + "#U50(&& + 20-0(")&%)7 + ) + -02-"3U6%&,("' + 307%01*(")%&+9307%01*(")%&+2"+/.3.(("DU+^.#1"(U<B+(.+2-"3U6%&,(UL+307%01*(")%*B+6"%"-.7 + 2"D&D" + )%.(3.-%("4" + (.#"-. + /(.(&'B + UD0(&' + & + (.,$6",+2-032"1.4.0%+)2")"#(")%*+&O+307%01*("4"+2-&D0(0(&7+,+-./(""#-./($O+2-"#10D($O + )&%U.C&7OA + M + 2-.6%&6U + "#U50(&7 + ,(03-7L%)7 + x10D0(%$+&))103",.%01*)6"' + & + 2-"06%("' + 307%01*(")%&A + Z)"#"0 + /(.50(&0+2-&3.0%)7 + E"-D&-",.(&L + D0a2-03D0%($O + /(.(&' + & + "#_0U50#($O+UD0(&' + & + (.,$6", + 9f61L50,$O + 6"D20%0(%(")%0'g< + , + 6.50)%,0 + ")(",+-./,&%&7+-0#0(6.+6.6+0):]"1.(&/"%."?F'+0.$A+

M+-.D6.O+%0O("6-.%&50)6"'+D"301&+C01*+c +H+-+*F&H+/#(0.(UV"-)&*"?+7"1)&0+#$"'.$#+7(.F0%&7&0?+W'82&)0?+7$%2&+1#)W(UV"T+&-$#(&$&

'()*$.F0% & H#+/)1.$7'+ & 73($-+/"40.7+7(.F & 0 & '$-$A + Z#-./",.%01*(.7+2-.6%&6.+)")-03"%"50(.+(.+E"-D&-",.(&&+U+U5._&O)7+5^)'19$+'(?F'+T+&b;A+Z-&0(%&-.D&+3.(("4"+2"3O"3.+D"a("+)5&%.%*+2-"E0))&"(.1&/.C&L+& + 2")103UL_UL +(/(H.(9$U+ 501",06. + 6 + U)1",&7D + a&/(&A + h17+"#"/(.50(&7 + 2"1.4.0D"4" + x%.1"(. + "#-./",.(&7 + D"a(" + &)2"1*/",.%*+1.%&()6"0 + )1",")"50%.(&0 +5efgf& hijkl;R+ 5-(0."#+7$.84 & *"?+7"1;B+"),"&,^&'+"2-03010((UL+2-"E0))&"(.1*(UL+(&^U+&+6-026"+,)%.,^&'+(.+("4&A+

;I

Page 38: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

gRG.31681B,6/.C $ G2-,?<D $�UD.(&)%&50)6.7 + D"301* + U%,0-a3.0%+2-&"-&%0% +-./,&%&7 +$'/$7$/)(?F'+0.$+ (.3 +"#U50(&0DA +|EE06%&,(")%*+"#-./",.(&7+"C0(&,.0%)7 +Ua0+(0 +6"1&50)%,"D+& +6.50)%,"D+U),"0(("4"+D.%0-&.1.B + . + -.))D.%-&,.0%)7 + , + ),7/& + ) + 2-"&)O"37_&D& + , + U50(&6.O+2"/&%&,($D&+&/D0(0(&7D&B+6"%"-$0+"2&)$,.L%)7+%.6&D&+2"(7%&7D&+6.6+&30(%&5(")%* + 98<B + iJ6"(C02C&7 + 9=<B + .,%"("D&7 + 9;<A + F-& + x%"D + /(.(&7B+UD0(&7 +& + (.,$6& + 96"D20%0(C&&< + ,")2-&(&D.L%)7 + (0 + %"1*6" + 6.6 + C01*+"#U50(&7B+("+&+6.6+)-03)%,.+-./,&%&7+&+%,"-50)6"'+-0.1&/.C&&+U5._&O)7A+

�UD.(&)%&50)6.7 + 203.4"4&6. + 2-"2",03U0% + "%("^0(&0 + 6 + 6.a3"DU+6"(6-0%("DU + -0#0(6U + 6.6 + 6 + ).D"C0((")%& + c + (")&%01L + U(&6.1*("'+&(3&,&3U.1*("' + )U_(")%&A + M + 2-.6%&50)6"' + 5.)%& + "(. + %74"%00% + 6+f),"#"3("DU+,")2&%.(&Lg+&+f(03&-06%&,("DU+"#U50(&LgB+(.)%-.&,.0%+(.+x4.1&%.-($'+9"%+)1",.+f-.,0()%,"g<+%&2+"%("^0(&'+,+"#-./",.%01*("'+"#_(")%&+&+(.+2.-%(0-)6&'+)%&1*+,/.&D"30')%,&7+)%.-^&O+&+D1.3^&OA+�.3.5. + 203.4"4. + )")%"&% + , + %"DB + 5%"#$B + (0 + )%0)(77 + -./,&%&0 + 30%0'+E"-D.1*($D& + %-0#",.(&7D& + & + "4-.(&50(&7D&B + 2")%.-.%*)7 + 2"D"5*+6.a3"DU + -0#0(6U + 2"(7%* + & + 2-"7,&%* + )0#7B + "2-0301&%*)7 + , + ),"&O+&(%0-0).O + & + (.U5&%*)7 + &O + )"41.)",$,.%* + ) + &(%0-0).D& + "6-Ua.L_&O+1L30'B +(0 +%"1*6" +6-026"+,)%.%* +(. +("4&B +("+& +2"'%& +2"+a&/(&+),"&D+2U%0DA+

�UD.(&)%&50)6.7+D"301*+"-&0(%&-U0%+"#-./",.(&0+(.+,.-&.%&,(")%*+U50#($O + 2-"4-.DD + & + -0.1&/.C&L + &(3&,&3U.1*($O + "#-./",.%01*($O+%-.06%"-&'A +F03.4"4&50)6&' +2-"C0)) +#"4.% +&D2-",&/.C&7D&A +�30)* +(0+D"a0%+#$%*+#0/U)1",("'+&+("-D.%&,("'+&)%&($B+"(.+,)043.+)U#d06%&,(.+& + D("a0)%,0((.A + M + "#U50(&& + ")"#"0 + /(.50(&0 + 2-&3.0%)7+).D""2-03010(&L+&+)"2U%)%,UL_0DU+"2$%U+20-0a&,.(&'k+"%+20-,&5("'+"),03"D10((")%&+3"+E"-D&-",.(&7+),"0'+%"56&+/-0(&7B+"%+2-"7)(0(&7+2-&-"3$ + ,0_0' +3" +"2-03010(&7 + )U#d06%&,(" + /(.5&D$O +C0((")%0'B + "%+(02")-03)%,0(("4" + xD"C&"(.1*("4" + "%61&6. + 3" + )"/&3.(&7 + )D$)1.+)"#)%,0(($O+30')%,&'A+M+U50#("'+307%01*(")%&+2"/(.(&0+2-0"#-./U0%)7+, + ).D"2"/(.(&0B + 2")%020((" + "E"-D170%)7 + , + U)%-0D10(&7 + ).D&O+U5._&O)7A + M$-.a.7)* + )1",.D& + �A�0))0B + "(& + 2"1U5.L% + ,"/D"a(")%*+(.-73U + ) + ,(0^(0' + )U3*#"' + "#-0)%& + )U3*#U + ,(U%-0((LLB + #"100+)U_(")%(ULB+(0+)1U5.'(ULA+

!+2"/&C&'+4UD.(&)%&50)6"'+6"(C02C&&+C01*+"#-./",.(&7+c +H+-+*F&*"?+7"1) & 70.#".$.F0% & 0 & 0+:+4 & `+:#"0.$ & 0":%aR & +0+3'(.F & T?(7'8"&

)0.#"-?"'$%&$&+.?$*$.F0%&7&$2&#"(?$3(9$$A+F-&"-&%0%+"#-./",.%01*("'+2-.6%&6& + c + ,/-._&,.(&0 + & + 6U1*%&,&-",.(&0 + U + -0#0(6. + 04"+5$'/$7$/)(?F'+T+&b;A +QU1*D&(.C&0'+3.(("4"+2"3O"3.+2-&(7%"+)5&%.%*+0(-+(1.)(?$3(9$U+ 501",06.A + h17 + "#"/(.50(&7 + x%.1"(("4" + -0/U1*%.%.+"#-./",.(&7+%"5(00+,)04"+2"3O"3&%+1.%&()6"0+"2-03010(&0+5efgf&mnjkl;B+507+:+/'84&`0(-+:8.'84a&*"?+7"1;B +U)20^("+&3U_&'+2"+a&/(&+),"&D+2U%0DA+

M38=2@2?2A1B,6/.C$G2-,?<D $M+")(",U+.(%-"2"1"4&50)6"'+D"301&+"#-./",.(&7 + 2"1"a0(. + &307 + ,"/D"a(")%& +& + (0"#O"3&D")%& + "#-0%0(&7+

;K

Page 39: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

501",06"D+2"1("%$+)"#)%,0(("'+-0.1*(")%&B+6"%"-.7+"%(L3*+(0+),"3&%)7+6 + )U,0-0(&%0%U + & + 4040D"(&& + f&(3&,&3U.1*("4" + igA + {01",06 + /30)*+2-03)%.0%+,+-./1&5($O+"#1&6.OB+-.)6-$,.L_&O+)U_(")%($0+)%"-"($+&+U-",(& +0):]"1.$7'+4 & #"(?F'+0.$ & `oak + #$%&0 + , + 6.50)%,0 +6R;S,/8.$9EU(6C&"(.1*("0 + & + "#$30(("0<B +13-171-R.?<32681+ 903&(&5("0 + &+U(&6.1*("0<+&+?1B32681+9C01")%("0+&+(.3J"#$30(("0<A+

{01",06+6.6+1&5(")%*+(.+2-"%7a0(&&+a&/(0(("4"+2U%&+(02-0)%.(("+x6/.D0(U0%)7+DU5&%01*("'+2-"#10D"'+3"#-.+&+/1.+&+,$%06.L_0'+&/+(00+2-"#10D"' + 3")%"'("4" + & + (03")%"'("4" + #$%&7 + , + D&-0A + F"x%"DU+,")O"a30(&0+(.+U-",0(*+1&5(")%("4"+#$%&7+D"a0%+2-&(")&%*+)%-.3.(&0A+Z3(.6"+"("+D"a0%+3.%*+&+(.)1.a30(&0+2"1("%"'+a&/(&A

m(%-"2"1"4&50)6.7 + D"301* + "-&0(%&-U0% + 203.4"4&50)6UL+307%01*(")%* + (. + &)6"(($0 + 3UO",($0 + %-.3&C&&B + 6"%"-$0 + )")%.,17L%+6U1*%U-("J&)%"-&50)6UL+&30(%&5(")%*+(.-"3",+& +)""#_.L%+1L37D+&O+&)%&((" + 501",050)6"0 + &/D0-0(&0A + |,-&)%&50)6.7 + C0((")%* + D"301&+)")%"&%+,+E&6).C&&+.(%&("D&&+501",050)6"'+)U#d06%&,(")%&k+"(.+0)%*+)-03)%," + 9f"-4.(g< + ).D"-./,&%&7 + 501",06.B + & + "(. + a0 + 3"1a(. + #$%*+2-0"3"10(. + 92-0"#-.a0(.< + , + 04" + 3UO",("D + ,"/-.)%.(&&A + F" + )U%&B+-0.1&/.C&7 + .(%-"2"1"4&50)6"4" + 2"3O"3. + "/(.5.0% + ,,030(&0+"#-./",.%01*("'+2-.6%&6&+,+3UO",($'+6"(%06)%A+

!06U17-("0 + D&-","//-0(&0 + "%(")&%)7 + 6 + %0D0 + 3UO",("4"+(.)%"-"a0(("+6.6+6+-01&4&"/("'+.-O.&60B+U)D.%-&,.7+,+(0'+5U%*+1&+(0+2-"&)6& +D-.6"#0)&7A +R0a3U + %0D + -0.1*(")%* + 3UO",("4" + (.)%"'5&," + &+2")103",.%01*(" +2-03d7,170% + )0#7 +1L37D +," +,)0O + 6U1*%U-.O +& +," + ,)0+,-0D0(.A + !.D + %0-D&( + f3UO",(")%*g + 2"3-./UD0,.0% + ,.a("0 + 317+203.4"4&6& + 2-&61.3("0 + )"30-a.(&0k + 3UO",(")%* + 0)%* + 2-0301*("0+"2-03010(&0+501",050)6"4"+)2")"#.+a&/(&B+2-"7,17L_04")7+,+-"3","'+)1+#"'"''+0.$B + 6U1*%U-("' +H#""-0.7"''+0.$+ & + 1&5(")%("' + 9(.3J"#$30(("'< +)0.#"-?"''+0.$+ 501",06.B + 04" + )"2-7a0((")%& + , +D"%&,.OB+301.O + & + 2")%U26.O + ) + 3"#-"DB + 1&#" + )" + /1"D + 9&#" + #$,.0% + -./(.7+3UO",(")%*<A+

F-&/(.(&0+3UO",(")%&+,+6.a3"D+501",060+2-032"1.4.0%+"#"/(.5&%*+00+6.6+a&,"0+(.5.1"B+6+6"%"-"DU+D"a("+"#-._.%*)7A+M+-.D6.O+3UO",("J"-&0(%&-",.(("' + 203.4"4&6& + & + 2)&O"1"4&& + "(" + 2"&D0(",.(" + 6.6+f3UO",("0+igA+Q+04"+2-"7,10(&7D+"%(")7%+2"/&%&,(UL+),"#"3U+&+5U,)%,"+2-.,3$B+%,"-50)6UL+&(%U&C&L+&+"_U_0(&0+2-06-.)("4"B+,0-U+&+(.30a3UB+1L#",* + & + ,0-(")%*A + Q1L50,$D + ),&30%01*)%,"D + )U_0)%,",.(&7+f3UO",("4" + ig + 7,170%)7 + 4"1") + )",0)%&B + /(.6"D$' + 6.a3"DU + 3U^0,("+/3"-","DU + 501",06UA + M + (0D + 2-&"%6-$,.0%)7 + )"6-",0((.7 + %.'(. + 3U^&+501",06.+9@<B+301.7+04"+2"%0(C&.1*("+#0)6"(05("+#"4.%$D+&+,+%"a0+,-0D7+.6%U.1*(" + (0/.,0-^0(($DA + M + (0D + a0 + /.61L50(. + )&1. + 1&5(")%&B+U)%-0D17L_.7+501",06.+6+3"#-"DU+&+,0-("DU+3.a0+20-03+1&C"D+U4-"/+&+&)2$%.(&' + 9MAj-.(61 + (./$,.1 + x%" + 6.50)%," + 1&5(")%& + fU2-7D)%,"D+3UO.g<A + �"1") + )",0)%& +D"a(" + -./,&,.%* + , + )0#0B + 6.6 + & + 1L#UL +3-U4UL+)2")"#(")%*B +&+%"43.+"(+)%.(",&%)7+317+501",06.+1&5($D+,(U%-0((&D+

;?

Page 40: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

(.)%.,(&6"DA + ~)1& + 4"1") + )",0)%& + /.41U^.0%)7 + -.))U3"5($D+).D""2-.,3.(&0DB + 4")2"3)%,"D + )%-.)%0'B + 3U-($O + (.61"((")%0' + &+2-&,$506B + 501",06 + )61"(70%)7 + (. + 2U%* + 3UO",("4" + ,$-"a30(&7 + &+U%-.5&,.0%+),"0+501",050)6"0+3")%"&()%,"A

h1&%01*($' + 20-&"3 + 3"^6"1*("4" + & + ^6"1*("4" + 30%)%,.+2-")%-.()%,"D + ,$(.^&,.(&7 + & + .6%U.1&/.C&& + U + -0#0(6. + 501",050)6&O+6.50)%,+&+)2")"#(")%0'+c+0+,:8.$4'(%&+:V'+0.FB+D0O.(&/D"D+-./,&%&7+c+ 7'"X'%% & #"^?"10$%+ & +0+H"#"W$7('$"B + U)1",&7D& + -./,&%&7 + c+/$(?+T$*"01+" & +:V"'$"+ & +0+.#)/'$*"0.7+ & 7 & /"%."?F'+0.$+ 9&4-","'B+U50#("'B + "-4.(&/.C&"(("'B + 2-.6%&50)6"'<B + )-03)%,"D + (-.,)%,0(("4"+,")2&%.(&7+c+?$*'84&H#$-"#+&+/+:#84&0+7".+90+7"0.F<+)%.-^&OA+

P. + (.5.1*($O + x%.2.O + "(%"40(0/. + &D0((" + 30%)6"J,/-")1.7 + )"J#$%&'(.7 + "#_(")%* + 7,170%)7 + )U#d06%"D + 9%"5(00B + 2"1&)U#d06%"D<+a&/(0307%01*(")%&+-0#0(6.+&+"#d06%"D+9%"5(00B+&)%"5(&6"DB+)&%U.C&0'<+-./,&%&7+04"+1&5(")%&A+Z#-./",.(&0+c+x%"+0)%0)%,0(("0+&B+D"a0%+#$%*B+(.&#"100 + "2%&D.1*("0 + D0)%" + ,)%-05& + 1&5(")%& + & + "#_0)%,.A+!""%,0%)%,0((" + (.&,.a(0'^&D + 2-&"-&%0%"D + )&)%0D$ + "#-./",.(&7+7,170%)7+203.4"4&50)6"0+)"2-","a30(&0+30%0'+6+50-%0+).D""2-03010(&7+,+"%("^0(&&+2-"#10D$+3")%"'("4"+&+(03")%"'("4"+#$%&7B+3"#-.+&+/1.A

M + -U)10 + .(%-"2"1"4&50)6"' + D"301& + C01* + "#-./",.(&7 + c +H+-+*F&#":"'1)&70.(.F&$-"''+&'(&*"?+7"*"01$4&H).F&#(37$.$%&$&)0.+%.F&'( &

'"-A +F-.6%&6.+"#-./",.(&7+,")O"3&%+6 +/.3.5.D+3UO",("J(-.,)%,0(("4"+,")2&%.(&7+&+2-"#Ua30(&7+5/)2+7'+T+&b;+501",06.A+M06%"-"D+&+("-D"'+-./,&%&7+/30)*+7,17L%)7& )'$7"#0(?$3(9$%+ #$%&7+& +0(-+.#('09"'/"'9$%&501",06.k+,$O"3+/.+2-0301$+)6"1*+U4"3("+-./,&%"'+&(3&,&3U.1*(")%&+&+"3(",-0D0((" + ,O"3 + , + 2-")%-.()%," + "#_0J + & + ),0-O501",050)6&O+x6/&)%0(C&.1*($O + C0((")%0'B + )"U5.)%(&6"D + , + 2")%-"0(&& + 6"%"-$O + &+)"#0)03(&6"D+,+")D$)10(&&+6"%"-$O+)%.(",&%)7+N+T+,*"?+7"*"0.7+A+

h17 + "#"/(.50(&7 + x%.1"(. + "#-./",.(&7 + ,")2"1*/U0D)7 + 1.%&()6&D+"#"-"%"D +5efgf& pfqrs;R+ 5'+784 & `$?$ & +:'+7?"''84a & *"?+7"1;B+"%61&6(U,^&')7+(.+2-&/$,+),"04"+f3UO",("4"+ig+&+2-0"#-.a0(($'+,+307%01*("D+)%-0D10(&&+6+h"#-U+&+G)%&(0A

h0%.1*("+#./",$0+"#-./",.%01*($0+D"301&+2-03)%.,10($+,+%.#1&C0k$

Z'.>274,$G2-,?1$2;=.>27.31C[

E;J1,$8,G.81B,6/1,$@.=.G,8=4

f,W32/=.81B,6/.C

gRG.31681B,6/.C

M38=2@2?2A1B,6/.C

Y1?262X6/2FG1=272>>=,3B,6/.C$-2G13.38.

`.C&"(.1&)%&50)6.7

F0-)"(.1&)%&50)6.7

hUO",("Jx%&50)6.7

E;S,/8$@,-.A2A1B,6/25$-,C8,?<32681

`0#0("6 + 6.6+)U#d06%+307%01*(")%&

`0#0("6 + 6.6+&(3&,&3U.1*(")%* + & + 6.6+

h0%)6"J,/-")1.7+)"J#$%&'(.7+"#_(")%* + 6.6+

:>

Page 41: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

)U,0-0(($'+)U#d06%+a&/(0307%01*(")%&

2"1&)U#d06%+a&/(0307%01*(")%&+-0#0(6.+&+6.6+2-")%-.()%,"+9&)%"5(&6<+-./,&%&7 + 04"+)U#d06%&,(")%&

h,-.A2A1B,6/.C$67,=W>.-.B.

L(37$.$"&#":"'1(&

1(1 & 0):]"1.(&

/"%."?F'+0.$B+E"-D&-",.(&0+6"D20%0(%(")%0'B+"%,05.L_&O+6"(dL(6%U-0+9%-0#",.(&7D + &+%0(30(C&7D<+)",-0D0(("4"+)"C&"6U1*%U-("4"+6"(%06)%.

L(37$.$"&

#":"'1( & 1(1&

$'/$7$/)(?F'+0.

$B + 2"330-a6. + ,+).D"&30(%&E&6.C&& + &+2")%-"0(&&+)"#)%,0(("4"+figB+6U1*%&,&-",.(&0+5U,)%,.+,(U%-0((0'+),"#"3$B+)2")"#(")%&+-.)6-$%* + ),"0+2-&/,.(&0 + &+-0.1&/",.%*)7 + ,+a&/(&

L(37$.$"&

#":"'1( & 1(1&

?$*'+0.$B+2"330-a6. + ,+)U_(")%("D+2"/(.(&& + &+.6%U.1&/.C&&+f3UO",("4" + ig+501",06.B+)"2-","a30(&0 + 6+50-%0+).D""2-03010(&7+, + "%("^0(&&+2-"#10D$+3")%"'("4" + &+(03")%"'("4"+#$%&7B + 3"#-. + &+/1.

a,38=.01C F-03D0%"C0(%-&/D+9^6"1"C0(%-&/D<

h0%"C0(%-&/D+920-)"("C0(%-&/D<

\-.3&C&"(.1&/D+9Y<

).@=.7?,33268< m6%&,(.7+.3.2%.C&7 + 6+U)1",&7D+3&(.D&5("+&/D0(7L_04")7+D&-.

!.D")",0-^0()%,",.(&0 + 9I< + &+%,"-50)6.7+).D"-0.1&/.C&7

l(&,0-).1&/.C&7+&(3&,&3U.1*("4"+#$%&7B+).D"%-.()C0(30(C&7+&+)&(0-4&7

E632734,$G2-,?<34,$W.=./8,=1681/1

!")%.,17L_&0+61L50,$0+6"D20%0(%(")%&+)U#d06%.+307%01*(")%&k+3'('$%B+ )-"'$%B+'(781$

m%-&#U%$+&(3&,&3U.1*(")%&k+$/"'.$*'+0.FB+b,1+'9"H9$%B+(7.+'+-$%

!U_(")%($0+)&1$ + 501",06.k+0):]"1.'+0.FB+#"^?"10$7'+0.FB+0+7"0.?$7+0.F

#?HB,74,$>.-.B1$@,-.A2A1B,6/25$-,C8,?<32681

j"-D&-",.(&0+5^)'19$+'(?F'+T

+ &b;B + ,,030(&0 + ,+6U1*%U-U+501",050)6"4"+"#-./. + a&/(&B+2-&"#_0(&0 + 6+

m6%U.1&/.C&7+$'/$7$/)(?F'+T+&

b;B + ,")2&%.(&0+)"#)%,0(("4"+"%("^0(&7 + 6+30')%,&%01*(")%&B + )2")"#(")%&+

F-"#Ua30(&0+5/)2+7'+T+ & b;B+,,030(&0 + ,+2-")%-.()%,"+x6/&)%0(C&.1*($O+9a&/(0)D$)1",$

:8

Page 42: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

-0D0)1.DB+,")2&%.(&0+EU(6C&"(.1*("'+4-.D"%(")%& + &+%"10-.(%(")%& + 6+(0"2-03010((")%& + 2-"#10D($O+)&%U.C&'

4","-&%*B+30')%,",.%*B+2-&(&D.%*+-0^0(&7 + &+)",0-^.%*+2")%U26& + "%+20-,"4"+1&C.

O< + 2-"#10DB+2"/&%&,(.7+)"C&.1&/.C&7B+,")2&%.(&0+)2")"#(")%&+3.,.%*+x6"1"4&50)6UL + &+(-.,)%,0((UL+"C0(6& + ),"&D+30')%,&7D + &+2")%U26.D

i-=2$@=2X,66123.?<325 $ 1-,381B32681$@,-.A2A.

F03.4"4&50)6.7+6"D20%0(%(")%*

F03.4"4&50)6.7+).D"#$%(")%*

�&5(")%(.7+/-01")%*

!6?271C$=,.?1>.011$2;=.>27.8,?<325$G2-,?1

�-.D"%(.7+"-4.(&/.C&7 + &+D0%"3&6.+"#U50(&7B+"#0)205&,.L_&0+6"D2106)("0+"),"0(&0+-0#0(6"D+)2")"#",+&(%01106%U.1*("'B+"-4.(&/.C&"(("'+& + 2-.6%&50)6"'+307%01*(")%&

f{01",050)6&'+E.6%"-g + &+203.4"4&50)6&'+%.6%k+3"#-"a01.%01*("0 + "%("^0(&0 + &+3",0-&0 + )"+)%"-"($+)%.-^&OB+2""_-0(&0+2"/(.,.%01*($OB+%,"-50)6&OB+2-.6%&50)6&O+&(%0-0)", + &+&(&C&.%&,B+"#0)205&,.L_&0+2-"7,10(&0+)61"((")%0'+-0#0(6. + &+-0.1&/.C&L+&(3&,&3U.1*("'+"#-./",.%01*("'+%-.06%"-&&

hUO",(.7 + ),7/*+6.6 + ")(",.+2-00D)%,0((")%&+2"6"10(&'B+2-&"#_0(&0 + 6+),7%$(7DB+,")2&%.(&0 + ,+3UO0 + "%050)6"'+6U1*%U-$B+1&5($'+2-&D0-+&+3"#-$' + )",0%+9)",0)%*<+)%.-^&OB+"#0)205&,.L_&0+,-.)%.(&0+-0#0(6. + , + D&-+%-.3&C&"(($O+3UO",($O+C0((")%0'

)2=G.$=.>7181C !(-++:?(/('$"&

`5:8.F & 7 & 0":";ak+,"17 + 6 + a&/(& + &+)2")"#(")%*+2"1.4.%*)7 + (.+)"#)%,0(($0+)&1$B+-0.1&)%&5(")%*+C010'+&+-./UD("0+21.(&-",.(&0+

!(-+:8.'+0.F&

`5:8.F & 0(-$-&

0+:+4;ak + ,0-. + ,+),"0+2-03(./(.50(&0B+,$#"- + &+2-"61.3$,.(&0+a&/(0(("4"+2U%&B+3.L_04"+"_U_0(&0+

!(-+.#('09"'/"

'.'+0.F & `5:8.F&

78X" & 0":%;ak+5U,)%,"+)"1&3.-(")%& + &+"%,0%)%,0((")%&+20-03 + 1L3*D&B+)"/(.%01*("0B+3"#-","1*("0+2-&(7%&0+

:=

Page 43: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

a&/(&B + ,0-(")%*+&/#-.(("DU+301U

,(U%-0((0'+)"41.)",.((")%&+& + 2"31&((")%&+&(3&,&3U.1*("4"+#$%&7B+)%-0D10(&0 + 6+"#-0%0(&L+)D$)1. + a&/(& + &+,0-(")%* + ),"0DU+2-&/,.(&L

D"-.1*($O+"#7/.%01*)%, + &+)103",.(&0 + &DB+)1Ua0(&0 + &+,0-(")%* + ),"0DU+3"14U

E;J15 $=,>R?<8.8$=.>7181C

!.D")%"7%01*(")%* + &+2-"3U6%&,(")%*+,+307%01*(")%&

!.D"#$%(")%* + &+a&/(0%,"-50)%,"

P-.,)%,0(("0+3")%"&()%," + &+307%01*("0+)%-0D10(&0 + 6+3"#-U+93"#-"30%01*<

",X10184 P03")%.%"5(")%*+fEU(6C&"(.1*("4"+ig+&+),7/.(($O+) + (&D+.3.2%.C&"(($O+-0)U-)",B+"4-.(&50((")%*+2",030(50)6"4"+-020-%U.-. + &+D$)10307%01*(")%($O+)%-.%04&'

P03")%.%"5(")%*+f&(3&,&3U.1*("4" + igB+"4-.(&50((")%*+D"%&,.C&"(("J)D$)1","'+)E0-$+92",0-O(")%(")%*B+2-&/0D10((")%*<B+)"J/.,&)&D")%*

M$%0)(0(&0 + &1&+"%-&C.(&0+f3UO",("4" + igB+"%5Ua30(&0+(-.,)%,0(($O+5U,)%,B+D"-.1*(.7+(0/-01")%* + &1&+D"-.1*(.7+-.)2U_0((")%*B+),"0(-.,&0B+)103",.(&0 + ,+301.O + &+2")%U26.O+2-&(C&2U+f(&504"+),7%"4"g

",X2=G.011 �&20-%-"E&7+fEU(6C&"(.1*("4" + igB+-./,-._0(&0+UD"D +& + UD0(&0DB+E"-D.1*($'B+)U4U#"+%0O(&50)6&'+2"3O"3 + 6+-0^0(&L+)1"a($O+2-"#10D+501",050)6"'+a&/(&+9fx6)%-0D&/D+2-")%$O+-0^0(&'g<

�&20-%-"E&7+f&(3&,&3U.1*("4" + igB+-./,-._0(&0+).D"D(0(&0D+9f6"D2106)+2"1("C0((")%&g<B + &11L/&7+).D"3")%.%"5(")%&B+"3(")%"-"((")%*+D"%&,.C&"(("J)D$)1","'+)E0-$+9x4"C0(%-&/D<B+).D"/.D6(U%")%*B+

Z#-./",.(&0+f2)0,3"3UO",("4" + igB+D0%.E&/&50)6.7+&(%"6)&6.C&7+9K<B+).D""#"1*_0(&0B+"30-a&D")%*+),0-OC0(($D&+&307D&B+E.(.%&/D

:;

Page 44: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

4"-3$(7

`$@216/,$61GX2311!")03)%,UL_&0 + , + %.#1&C0 + 203.4"4&50)6&0 + 6"(C02C&& + , + ),"0'+

%0"-0%&50)6"'+&+2-.6%&50)6"'+5.)%&+-./1&5.L%)7+%.6+a0B+6.6B+(.2-&D0-B+61.))&50)6.7 + D0O.(&6. + "%1&5.0%)7 + "% + 6,.(%","' + D0O.(&6&B + &1&+5-0/,$5.'("+(.30a($'+&+2"+)0'+30(*+x6)21U.%&-U0D$'+.x-"21.(+mPJ=+"%+)",-0D0(($O+).D"10%",+%&2.+RG�J=?+&1&+!lJ=IA+N0))D$)10(("+&O+)-.,(&,.%*+)+%"56&+/-0(&7+f1U5^0�OUa0gB+U5&%$,.7B+5%"+E&/&6.+G)..6.+P*L%"(. + & + E&/&6. + m1*#0-%. + |'(^%0'(. + "20-&-UL% + 2-&(C&2&.1*("+-./1&5($D& +6.-%&(.D& +D.%0-&.1*("4" +D&-.B + . + f6U6U-U/(&6gB + ) +"3("'+)%"-"($B + & + f)%-&a&g + &1& + f,&%7/&gB + ) + 3-U4"'B + (.3010($ + 6.50)%,0(("+-./($D& + %0O(&50)6&D& + O.-.6%0-&)%&6.D& + & + 2&1"%.a($D&+,"/D"a(")%7D&A + \.6 + a0 + & + , + "%("^0(&7O + #./",$O + "#-./",.%01*($O+D"3010'k + + "(& +-./("D.)^%.#($B +(" +"2-03010(($D+"#-./"D +),7/.($+&+,/.&D"30')%,UL%+D0a3U+)"#"'A+

\0O("6-.%&50)6.7B + 4UD.(&)%&50)6.7 + & + .(%-"2"1"4&50)6.7 + D"301&+-02-0/0(%&-UL% + U)%"'5&,$0B + ,$30-a.,^&0 + &)2$%.(&0 + ,-0D0(0D + &+U6"-0(&,^&0)7 + , + 2-"E0))&"(.1*("D + 203.4"4&50)6"D + )"/(.(&&+fx%.1"($gB+6"%"-$0+/.%-.4&,.L%+")(",$+&+EU(3.D0(%.1*($0+2-"#10D$+-./,&%&7 + & + )U_0)%,",.(&7 + 501",06.A +F" +"%301*(")%& + "(& + "O,.%$,.L%+-./1&5($0+&/D0-0(&7+&+.)206%$+2-"C0)).+"#-./",.(&7B+)",D0)%("+c+%"+,$),05&,.L% + )1"a(")%* + & +D("4"4-.((")%* + "#-./",.%01*("' + 2-.6%&6&B+2"/,"17L% + )E"-D&-",.%* + C01")%("0 + 2-03)%.,10(&0 + " + 203.4"4&50)6"D+2-"E0))&"(.1&/D0A + Z)D$)10(($' + ,$#"- + C010,$O + 2-&"-&%0%",B+"2-03010(&0 + ,$^0J + & + (&a010a._04"B + )""%(0)0(&0 + ,.-&.%&,("4" + &+&(,.-&.(%("4"+&D0L%+2-&(C&2&.1*("0+/(.50(&0+&+"6./$,.L%+,1&7(&0+(.+-0/U1*%.%$ + -.#"%$ + 203.4"4",B + )20C&.1&)%", + & + "#-./",.%01*($O+U5-0a30(&'A

h=,-@2B8,31, $ 8,W32/=.81B,6/25 $ 2=1,38.011 $ 7 $ 2;=.>27.311$-"a3.0% + , + ,""#-.a0(&& + .(.1"4&L + ) + f"-Ua0'("' + 1.,6"'gA + ~0 + D&))&7+2-0301*(" + 2-.4D.%&5(. + c + ")(.)%&%* + U5._&O)7 + ).D$D& + 20-03",$D&+/(.(&7D&+&+)-03)%,.D&+&+,$2U)%&%*+,+D&-+317+/.,"0,.(&7+),"04"+D0)%.+2"3 + )"1(C0DA +{%"#$ +f"2%&D&/&-",.%*g + 2-"C0)) + "#U50(&7 + Ua0 +(. + 04"+(.5.1*($O+x%.2.O+,,"37%)7+2-"C03U-$+)0106C&&+&+3010(&0+(.+4-U22$+2"+)2")"#(")%7D + 9%"5(00 + c +2" +E"-D.1*($D +2-&/(.6.D +U)20,.0D")%& + 9?<A+fP.+,$O"30g+2"1U5.0D+)%-.)%&+f,"-"%(&56",g98><+&+,U1*4.-("0+3010(&0+1L30' + (. + f,&(0-",g + 9)"C&.1*($O + 1&30-",B + ,$&4-.,^&O + )O,.%6U + /.+a&/(*< + & + f1U/0-",g + 9)"C&.1*($O + .U%).'30-",B + (0U3.5(&6", + J88<A+\0O("6-.%&/D +2"3O"3&% + 6 + 501",06U + ) +D0-6.D& + "#$30((")%&B + "%,0-4.7+D0%.E&/&50)6&' +21.( +04" +-./,&%&7A +l)050(($' +501",06 + /(.0% +)#+7"'F&W$3'$B + (" + (0 + ,03.0% +H+?'+.8 & W$3'$A + l-",0(* + a&/(& + c + U-",0(*+D.%0-&.1*("4" + 2"%-0#10(&7A + F"1("%. + a&/(& + c + (.2"1(0((")%* + 00+)D$)1"DB + (" + x%" + U301 + (02",%"-&D"J1&5(")%("4" + #$%&7B + 6"%"-"DU +(0%+

::

Page 45: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

D0)%. + , + -.D6.O + 3.(("' + D"301&A + R"a0% + #$%*B + 2"x%"DU + %0O("6-.%$+2-032"5&%.L%+f2-")%$0+-0^0(&7g+98=<+ ,+"%("^0(&&+)1"a($O+2-"#10D+a&/(&+1L30'A

gRG.31681B,6/.C $ 2=1,38.01C+ (&)6"1*6" + (0 + UD.170% + C0((")%&+"#U50(&7+&+,.a(")%&+"),"0(&7+6"D20%0(C&'B+.+6.6+#$+,a&,170%+&O+,+),"'+6"(%06)%B +,61L5.0%+,+(",$0+)&)%0D($0+"%("^0(&7B+2"3(&D.7+2-&+x%"D+21.(6U + "#-./",.(&7 + (. + 2-&(C&2&.1*(" + &(ULB + #1.4"-"3(ULB + ,$)"%U+-./,&%&7+&(3&,&3U.1*(")%&+&+).D".6%U.1&/.C&&+501",06.A+G+,)0+a0+0)%*+D"D0(%B + 6"%"-$' + & + /30)* + ,$/$,.0% + )"D(0(&0A + �UD.(&)%&50)6.7+203.4"4&6. +-0.1&/U0% +U)%.(",6& +20-)"("C0(%-&50)6"4" +D&-","//-0(&7B+317 + 6"%"-"4" + f&(3&,&3U.1*("0 + ig + 0)%* + 03&()%,0((.7 + & + 6"(05(.7+C0((")%*A +|%.+1&(&7+) +(0&/#0a(")%*L+,030% +6 +&(3&,&3U.1&/DU+& +c +,+6"(05("D + &%"40 + c + 6 + "3&("50)%,U + 501",06.B + /.D$6.(&L + , + ),"0D+).D")",0-^0()%,",.(&& + -.3& + ).D")",0-^0()%,",.(&7A + Q.6 + D0%6"+/.D0%&1 +E&1")"E +QAPA�0"(%*0,B + &(3&,&3U.1&/DB + )%.,^&' +3"D&(.(%"'+-./,&%&7B + 4U#&% + &(3&,&3U.1*(")%* + 1L30' + & + ),"0"#-./&0 + (.C&'A+Z4-.(&5&,^&)*+x%"'+)%0/0'B+"#-./",.(&0+-&)6U0%+U2"3"#&%*)7+fE.#-&60+/,0/3gA+m+f2")0,$g+30%"C0(%-&/D.+&+%"10-.(%(")%&B+(0+2"36-0210(($0+3UO",("J(-.,)%,0(($D+,")2&%.(&0DB+D"4U%+3.%*+)"D(&%01*($0+f,)O"3$g+x4"C0(%-&/D. + & + ).D"/.D6(U%")%&A + l5&%$,.7B + 5%" + 4&20-%-"E&7+f&(3&,&3U.1*("4" + igB + 317 + 6"%"-"4" + fh-U4&0g + c + %"1*6" + E"(B + "50(*+(.2"D&(.0% + D.(0-U + 2",030(&7 + -.6",$O + 610%"6B + 6.a3.7 + &/ + 6"%"-$O+)5&%.0%+)0#7+41.,("'A+++

M38=2@2?2A1B,6/.C$G2-,?<+2-&,(")&%+&30L+2"1("%$+"#-./",.(&7+& + x,-&)%&5("0 + 2-03)%.,10(&0 + " + 203.4"4&50)6"' + 307%01*(")%& + 6.6 + "#+.(%-"2"2-.6%&60+c +2-.6%&60+-./,&%&7 +#./",$OB +-"3",$O+)2")"#(")%0'+501",06.A + F-& + x%"D + "2-03010(&0 + ")(",("' + D&))&& + "#-./",.(&7 + c+-./,&%&0+-0#0(6.+6.6+1&5(")%&+c+(0+&)61L5.0%B+.+,61L5.0%+,+)0#7+3-U4&0+EU(6C&& + "#-./",.(&7B + 2-&,"37 + &O + (. + ")(",0 + 2-&(C&2. + &0-.-O&&+9)"2"35&(0(&7<+6+)")%"7(&L+)"41.)&7+&+,/.&D"3"2"1(0(&7A+

|%"%+(.)%-"'+)&)%0D$+"#-./",.(&7+D$+&+(./$,.0D+2-,(@&%,):8A+M+20-,"D + 2-&#1&a0(&& + "( + D"a0% + #$%* + "50-50( + , + ,&30 + %-0O + U-",(0'+"#-./",.%01*($O+2-"C0))",A+

P.+20-,"D+U-",(0+-0#0("6B+&(%01106%U.1*("+2"/(.,.7+&+2-.6%&50)6&+"),.&,.7 + -./(""#-./($0 + 2-03D0%$B + -./,&,.0%)7 + 6.6 +0(-+/"%."?F'84&0):]"1.B + 2-&)2").#1&,.L_&')7 + 6 + )1"a($D + U)1",&7D + 2-&-"3("4" + &+6U1*%U-("4" + 2-")%-.()%,A + �30)* + 6.50)%," + "#-./",.(&7 + "#0)205&,.0%)7+4-.D"%("' + "-4.(&/.C&0' + & + D0%"3&6"' + ,030(&7 + U50#("4" + 2-"C0)).A+F-&"#-0%.0D$0+/(.(&7B +UD0(&7 +& +(.,$6&+ 96"D20%0(C&&< +, +2"31&(("D+)D$)10 + "#1.4"-.a&,.L% + -0#0(6. + 1&^* + , + %"' + D0-0B + , + 6"%"-"'+#1.4"2-&7%)%,UL% + -./,&%&L + 04" +$'/$7$/)(?F'+0.$k + 2"D"4.L% + 0DU+E"-D&-",.%* + )"#)%,0(("0 + ,&30(&0 + & + 2"(&D.(&0 + 30')%,&%01*(")%&B+"%%.5&,.%* + ),"' + 2"50-6 + & + )%&1* + , + 307%01*(")%&B + U5&%*)7 + 4","-&%*B+30')%,",.%*B+2-&(&D.%*+-0^0(&7+&+)",0-^.%*+2")%U26&+"%+20-,"4"+1&C.B+)%.(",&%*)7+&+#$%*+).D&D+)"#"'A+

:@

Page 46: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

�.1"4"D +-0^0(&7 +"#-./",.%01*($O + /.3.5 + ,%"-"4" +U-",(7 + 7,170%)7+f501",050)6&' + E.6%"-gk + 1&5("0 + "#.7(&0 + & + 203.4"4&50)6&' + %.6%+,/-")1$OB+6"%"-$0+"#(.-Ua&,.L%+)0#7+,+5U%6"D+&+#0-0a("D+"%("^0(&&+6 + 2-"7,10(&7D + (.-"a3.L_0')7 + 30%)6"' + ).D"#$%(")%&B + UD0(&&+/.&(%0-0)",.%*B + ,""3U^0,&%* + -0#0(6.B + 2-03")%.,&%* + )"-./D0-($0 + 04"+,"/-.)%($D + ,"/D"a(")%7D + )%020(* + ),"#"3$ + & + 2-")%-.()%,"+).D""2-03010(&7A+

P"+&+&(3&,&3U.1&/.C&7+c+(0+).D"C01*+317+"#-./",.(&7A+Z(.B+,+),"L+"50-03*B + 3"1a(. + )%.(",&%)7 + 2-032")$16"' +?$*'+0.'+T++ -./,&%&7+-0#0(6.A +|%"% +21.( +-./,&%&7 +"2-03017L% +3,0 +,0O& +6.6 +3,0 +,)%-05&B +,+2"34"%",60+&+"#0)2050(&&+6"%"-$O+)&)%0D.+"#-./",.(&7+&4-.0%+,01&6UL+-"1*A+|%"+c+,)%-05.+)+).D&D+)"#"'+9.6%U.1&/.C&7+f&(3&,&3U.1*("4"+ig<+& + "#-._0(&0 + 6 + %"DUB + Q%" + 9{%"< + 2-0,")O"3&% + & + ,")2"1(70% + %0#7B+2-"#Ua3.0% + f3UO",("0 +igA + f�&5(")%& + 501",06. + (0%B + 0)1& + (0% + #$%&7B+,$^0+0�+)%"7_04"B+0)1&+(0%+%"4"+4"-(04"+D&-.B+6+6"%"-"DU+"(.+3"1a(.+,")O"3&%*gB +c +(.)%.&,.1 +PAmAN0-370,A +G/,05(.7 +2-"#10D. +3"#-. +& + /1.+2"#Ua3.0% +&)6.%* +,$)^&0 + 9)2.)&%01*($0< +"-&0(%&-$B +U6-0217L_&0 +&+(.2-.,17L_&0+501",06.A+M+6"(%06)%0+&)%"-&&+&+6U1*%U-$+c+x%"+3UO",(.7+%-.3&C&7+6.6+")(",.+"#-0%0(&7+501",06"D+),"0'+-"3","'+)U_(")%&w +,+-01&4&"/("D+D&-"2"(&D.(&&+c+x%"+5U,)%,"+2-&)U%)%,&7+T&,"4"+N"4.B+%,0-3.7+,0-.+&+3"#-$0+301.A+

�30)* + 501",050)6"0 + #$%&0 + )%.(",&%)7 + ).D&D + )"#"' + 1&^*+2-0,-._.7)*+,+)"J#$%&0B+6"43.+),"#"3.+6.6+1L#",*+6+!0#0+-./,&,.0%)7+3"+),"#"3$+6.6+1L#,&+6+h-U4"DUA+M"+,)02"1("%0+-./,&,^&O)7+),"#"3$+&+1L#,& + , + (.) + 2-"#Ua3.0%)7 + �&5(")%* + N"4.A + G + ,)76&' + -./B + 6"43. + D$+"%(")&D)7+6+h-U4"DU+6.6+6+),"0DU+\$B+,+%.6"D+"%("^0(&&+2-"4173$,.0%+#"a0)%,0(("0A + P0)1U5.'(" + 203.4"4&J(",.%"-$ + 2-&3.,.1& + ")"#"0+/(.50(&0 + -01&4&"/("DU + ,")2&%.(&L + 30%0'A + fF-.,&1. + 2",030(&7 + 317+L("^0)%,.g+iAmAQ"D0()6"4"+(.5&(.1&)*+)+(.)%.,10(&7k+fS("^.B+430+#$+%$ + (& + #$1B + 2"D(& + " + %"DB + 5%" + %$ + (.O"3&^*)7 + , + 2-&)U%)%,&& +N"4. + &+.(401",+c+&B+D"a0%+#$%*B+1L30'A+�AAA�+F0-,"'+D$)1*L+6.6+2-")(0^*)7B+2U)%* + #U30% + D$)1* + " + N"40gA + QAhAl^&()6&' + 4","-&1k + f`01&4&"/("0+"#-./",.(&0 + 3"1a(" + ) + -.((&O + 10% + 1"a&%*)7 + (. + 3U^U + 501",06.B + 6.6+,0-($' + /.1"4 + %"4"B + 5%" + "( + (0 + )"#*0%)7 + ) + 3"-"4&B + 6.6 + ,0-($' + 76"-*+)2.)0(&7+,+3(&+a&%0')6&O+#U-*+&+3U^0,($O+%-0,"4gA+

`./D$^177+"+-"1&+&+,"/D"a(")%7O+"#-./",.%01*($O+U5-0a30(&'+,+1&5(")%("D+-./,&%&&+30%0'B+#U30%+UD0)%("+,)2"D(&%*+)%.-UL+^U%6U+"+3,UO+3,0-7Ok+(.+"3("'+(.2&).("+fh"#-"gB+(.+3-U4"'+f�06C&7+"+3"#-0gw+,"/10 + ,%"-"' + 3,0-& + ,$)%-.&,.0%)7 + "50-03*B + ,"/10 + 20-,"' + c + (&6"4"A+Z%6-$%*+20-,UL+3,0-*+c+/(.5&%+2-&(7%*+DU6&+,$#"-.B+-&)6&+30')%,&'+&+2")%U26",B+%74"%$+"%,0%)%,0((")%&+20-03+)"#"'+&+3-U4&D&+9#1&a(&D&+&+3.1*(&D&B+2-"^1$D&+&+#U3U_&D&+2"6"10(&7D&<+&+50-0/+x%&+&)2$%.(&7+U5&%*)7+"2-03017%*)7+,+"%("^0(&&+3")%"'("4"+&+(03")%"'("4"+#$%&7B+2-"-$,.%*)7 + 50-0/ + ,(0^(&0 + )"#1./($ + & + )"#)%,0(($' + x4"C0(%-&/D + 6+h"#-U+&+G)%&(0B+3UO",("+,"/-.)%.%*A+

:Y

Page 47: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

�30)*+/.3.5.+,/-")1$O+),"3&%)7+6+%"DUB+5%"#$+(0+"^&#&%*)7+3,0-*L+,+2"&)60+")(",.(&'+)",D0)%("'+)+30%*D&+a&/(0307%01*(")%&A+\0D+#"100+5%" +(. + x%"D +2U%& +,)0 +D$+(0/.,&)&D" +"% +,"/-.)%. +& + )%.%U). +")%.0D)7+U50(&6.D&+&+"%(L3*+(0+/.)%-.O",.($+"%+2-"D.O",+&+/.#1Ua30(&'A+

b./?HB,31,

F-& + "#-._0(&& + 6 + %"' + &1& + &("' + "#-./",.%01*("' + D"301&+5-0/,$5.'("+,.a0(+f,/4173+,41U#*g+c+,21"%*+3"+C0((")%($O+")(",.(&'A+P&+)"30-a.(&0B+(&+)2")"#$+-.#"%$+203.4"4",+&+)20C&.1&)%",+)&)%0D$+"#-./",.(&7B + 2" + )U%&B + (0 + 7,17L%)7 + &30"1"4&50)6& + (0'%-.1*($D&k + /.+(&D&+,)043. + 95._0 +,)04" +&D21&C&%("< + )%"7% + %0 +&1& +&($0+C0((")%& +&+&30.1$A + P03""C0(6. + -"1& + C0((")%("4" + 21.(. + D"a0% + 2-&,"3&%* + 6+f)6-$%$D+-0/U1*%.%.Dg+-.#"%$B+6"%"-$0+(0+%"1*6"+(0+21.(&-UL%)7B+("+&B+,"/D"a("B+,)%U2.L%+,+2-"%&,"-05&0+)+(.D0-0(&7D&+203.4"4.A+F"x%"DU+&+%-0#U0%)7 + D&-","//-0(50)6"0 + U)&1&0B + (.2-.,10(("0 + (. + ,$-.#"%6U+)&)%0D$ + ,/4173",B + 2-&(C&2", + & + U#0a30(&'B + "2-03017L_&O+20-)"(.1*(UL + 2-"E0))&"(.1*(UL + 2"/&C&Lw + (. + ")D$)10(&0+)",-0D0(($O + )"C&"6U1*%U-($O + %0(30(C&' + & + "C0(6U + &O + ,1&7(&7 + (.+/3"-",*0+&+-./,&%&0+30%0'w+(.+"2-03010(&0+C0((")%($O+2-&"-&%0%",+&+2")%.(",6U+2-"E0))&"(.1*("'+),0-O/.3.5&+98;<A+

�30)*+)%0-a(0,$D+7,170%)7+,"2-")+f-.3&+504"�gB+6.6+%"56.+"%)50%.B+.1*E. + & + "D04. + 2-"E0))&"(.1*("' + 307%01*(")%&B + 6.6 + &(3&6.%"-+1&5(")%("'+/-01")%&+203.4"4.B+&#"+(.+x%"%+,"2-")+"%,05.%*+)1",.D&B+(0+)%.(",7_&D&)7+301.D&B+4-0^("k+fFU)%*+%,"0+fh.g+#U30%+fh.g+e+.+5%"+),0-O+x%"4"B+%"+"%+1U6.,"4"gA+

h=1G,B.31C

8J+F0-0a&,.(&0+501",06"D+"2-03010((")%&B+2"31&((")%&+&+2")%"7()%,.+),"04"+figw+2-&3.L_00+a&/(0(($0+)&1$+5U,)%,"+%"a30)%,0((")%&+).D"DU+)0#0k+f|%"+&+0)%*+(.)%"7_&'+i�gA= + J +!U#d06%&,($' + f"#-./ +igB + )"2-7a0(($' + ) + ).D""C0(6"'w + ,$)%U2.0% + 6.6+U)%.(",6. + 2" + "%("^0(&L + 6 + ).D"DU + )0#0 + & + 6.6 + ")(",. + ,/.&D"30')%,&7 + )+3-U4&D&A;+J+!.D"2"1.4.(&0+,+"%("^0(&&+a&/(0(($O+21.(",B+)2")"#(")%*+30')%,",.%*+(.+")(",0+2")%"7(("4"+).D""2-03010(&7: + J + !U#d06%&,(.7 + -0.1*(")%* + + 9)U#d06%&,(")%*B + ).D")%*< + J + E"-D.+)U_0)%,",.(&7 + & + )2")"# + "-4.(&/.C&& + 501",050)6"' + -0.1*(")%&B + )U%* + c+).D")%"7%01*(")%*+3UO",("'+a&/(&A

:I

Page 48: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

@+J+!"41.)("+!,7_0(("DU+2&).(&L+N"4+)"/3.1+501",06.+2"+!,"0DU+"#-./UB+3.1+0DU+#0))D0-%(UL+3U^U+&+2-&/,.1+6+#"4"2"3"#&LAY + J + jU(3.D0(%.1*($D + C0((")%7D + -"))&')6"J2-.,")1.,("' + 6U1*%U-$+)""%,0%)%,U0%+2-&(C&2+fy-&)%")"C0(%-&/D.g+c+"-&0(%.C&7+(.+/.2-0301*(UL+,$)"%U+O-&)%&.()6&O+&30.1",A+l)%.(",10((.7+%.6&D+"#-./"D+,0-%&6.1*+#$%&7+)2.)&%01*(.+317+501",06.B+U5&%$,.7+)6"1*+)&1*("+)(")&%+6+(&/^0DU+%050(&0+"#$30(("' + a&/(&A + MD0)%0 + ) + x%&D + (0/.,&)&D" + "% + D&-","//-0(&7 + &+,0-"&)2",03.(&7+,.a("+")D$)1&%*+%"%+E.6%B+5%"+,$-.a0(&7 +G.*"&'(XB+b27"&X+?+-+ & +>??(2&(1:(#+ "#-._0($+6+Z3("DU+&+\"DU+a0+N"4UB +M)030-a&%01LA+\"1*6"+)+2"/&C&&+x%"4"+2"(&D.(&7+,"/D"a0(+)"/&3.%01*($'+3&.1"4+1L30'+&+6U1*%U-AI+J+F-03)%.,&%01&+4UD.(&)%&50)6"4"+2"3O"3.+&)2"1*/UL%+,+x%"'+),7/&+%0-D&(+f1&5(")%($' + -")%gB + 2"3 + 6"%"-$D + 5._0 + ,)04" + 2"(&D.0%)7 + -./,&%&0 + %.6&O+6.50)%, + 6.6 + 2-&(7%&0 + )0#7B + 6"(4-Ux(%(")%* + 20-0a&,.(&' + & + 2",030(&7B+%"10-.(%("0+"%("^0(&0+6+"6-Ua.L_&D+1L37DAK+J+!")%"7(&0B+O.-.6%0-&/UL_00)7+)%-0D10(&0D+-./-0^.%*+"%,1050(($0+2-"#10D$+41"#.1*("4"+O.-.6%0-.+,+"%-$,0+"%+-0.1*("'+a&/(&w+D"a0%+(")&%*+#"10/(0(($'+O.-.6%0-A?+J+mA|'(^%0'(+2")-03)%,0(("+U5&1)7B+#$1+&)61L50(+&/+^6"1$A+fR"&+U5&%017+U,0-71&+D0(7B+5%"+7+(0+)301.L+,+a&/(&+(&504"+2U%("4"gB+J+,)2"D&(.1+"(A8> + J + N01$0 + ,"-"%(&56&+ c + U2-.,10(C$B + &(a0(0-("J%0O(&50)6&' + 20-)"(.1B+)1Ua._&0w +)0-$0+,"-"%(&56&+ c +-.#"%(&6& +)E0-$+"#)1Ua&,.(&7w +f)&(&0g +c+6,.1&E&C&-",.(($0+-.#"5&0A88J + !103U7 + x%"' + 2-&D&%&,("' + 1"4&60 + , + -73$ + f1U/0-",g + (Ua(" + /.2&).%*+GA!AN.O.B+M.(4"4.B+QA|A�&"16",)6"4"B+1L30'B+"20-03&,^&O+),"0+&)%"-&50)6"0+,-0D7B+("+(0+)UD0,^&O+2-0"3"10%*+#03(")%*+&+(Ua3UB+2"%"DU+5%"+&O+40(&'+&+,61.3+,+6U1*%U-U+#$1+"C0(0(+"#_0)%,"D+2"+3")%"&()%,U+2")10+&O+6"(5&($A8= + J + �&^* + (06"%"-$0 + 2-&D0-$ + fx6)%-0D&/D. + 2-")%$O + -0^0(&'gB+/.%-.4&,.L_&0 + &(%0-0)$ + D("4&O + 1L30'k + , + )&)%0D0 + /3-.,""O-.(0(&7 + c+2-.6%&6. + 1050(&7 + #"10/(0' + f2" + )O0D0g + #0/ + ,(&D.(&7 + 6 + ")"#0((")%7D+"-4.(&/D.B + 2)&O&6& + & + 1&5(")%& + 2.C&0(%.w + , + "#_0)%,0(("D + %-.()2"-%0 + c+x6)21U.%.C&7+,+U)1",&7O+D04.2"1&).+(.+(./0D($O+D.-^-U%.O+.,%"D.%&50)6"'+)&)%0D$ + 6"(%-"17w + , + )&)%0D0 + "#-./",.(&7 + c + ,,030(&0 + 2-"C03U-$ + 03&("4"+4")U3.-)%,0(("4" + x6/.D0(.A + MD0)%0 + &O + "#d03&(70% + "#_&' + 2-&(C&2+"#0/1&5&,.(&7 +& +2-0(0#-0a0(&7 +501",06"D+, +U4"3U +#L-"6-.%&50)6"' +&�&1&+x6"("D&50)6"'+C010)""#-./(")%&A8;+J+J)7(?+7&>=C=+R&-","//-0(50)6&0+.)206%$+"#-./",.(&7+��+P",$0+C0((")%&+"#-./",.(&7A+QU1*%U-(.7+2.-.3&4D.+J+RAk+=>>IA+H:+9;:<A+J+!A+@?JI=A+

:K

Page 49: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

Z#2368=R1=27.31,$'R-RJ,A2[D:201.?<32,$@2>101231=27.31,$

2382@,-.A2A1/1$7$+26611

>=>=B+H+7

G(3&,&3U.1*("J"-&0(%&-",.((.7 +203.4"4&6.+6.6+2-"06%+, +`"))&&+0_0 + (&430 + (0 + #$1 + -0.1&/",.(A + Q + )"a.10(&LB + )U_0)%,UL_.7+203.4"4&50)6.7 + "#_0)%,0((")%* + 2-"3"1a.0% + a&%* + , + )%-.%04&&+2-"E.(.C&& + )"#)%,0(("' + &((",.C&"((")%& + &/J/. + (0)2")"#(")%& + 6+2-&(C&2&.1*("' + )D0(0 + )%-U6%U-$ + ,03U_&O + "#-./",.%01*($O+&()%&%U%",A + G307 + &(3&,&3U.1*("J"-&0(%&-",.(("' + 203.4"4&6& + (0+D"a0%+#$%*+-0.1&/",.(.+,+)U_0)%,UL_0'+203.4"4&50)6"'+)%-U6%U-0+&+U61.30A + F-&(C&2&.1*("' + "^&#6"' + 7,170%)7 + 20-,&5(")%* + -./-.#"%"6+%0O("1"4&'+&+&O+,(03-0(&0+,+"#-./",.%01*($0+&()%&%U%$+)"+)%.-$D&+("-D.D&D $ N3-171-R.?<32F2=1,381=27.33.C $ @,-.A2A1/. $ T1?1$@,-.A2A1/. $ 6.G22@=,-,?,31CU $ 8=,;R,8 $ 1325 $ 13X=.68=R/8R=4 $ 1$R/?.-32681B+.+x%"+,+)&)%0D0+"#_04"+"#-./",.(&7+`j+(0,"/D"a("+2"6.+2"+)103UL_&D+2-&5&(.Dk+

!" (.1&5&0+2")%)",0%)6&O+"-4.(",+6"(%-"17w#" "%)U%)%,&0+(0"#O"3&D$O+6.3-",w$" "%)U%)%,&0+(.)%"7_04"+2-"06%.w%" (.1&5&0+"-4.(&/.C&"(($O+&+&30"1"4&50)6&O+)%0-0"%&2",w&" "%)U%)%,&0+C010'+&(3&,&3U.1&/.C&&+U+(.)010(&7AF"3 + &(3&,&3U.1&/.C&0' + & + &(3&,&3U.1*("J"-&0(%&-",.(("'+

203.4"4&6"'+ +D$+&D00D+,+,&3U+(0+D0%"3B+(0+203.4"4&50)6&'+2-&0DB+.+$'+4&.$H&('.#+H+H#(1.$1A+Z#-./",.(&0B+-.))D.%-&,.0D"0+6.6+2-.6%&6.+-./,&%&7 + 501",050)6"4" + 2"%0(C&.1.B + ")(",($D + )"30-a.(&0D + &D00%+).D""2-03010(&0+)U#d06%.+"#-./",.%01*("'+307%01*(")%&+6+(.1&5($D+&+,"/D"a($D+)"C&"6U1*%U-($D+2-.6%&6.DB+%0D+).D$D+c+f"),"#"a30(&0g+"%+307%01*(")%&+6.6+U)1",&0+,"/D"a(")%&+-0E106)&,("4"+&+2-"06%("4"+"%("^0(&7A + F.-.3&4D. + "-4.(&/.C&& + %.6"4" + "#-./",.(&7 + 0)%*+&(3&,&3U.1*(" + "-&0(%&-",.((.7 + 203.4"4&6. + 6.6 + 203.4"4&6.+"(%"1"4&50)6"4"+6"()%-U&-",.(&7+c++'.+H"/(T+T$1(A

+ M + + 2-")%-.()%,0 + "#-./",.%01*("' + 2-.6%&6& + "(%"203.4"4&6.B+"%1&5.0%)7+"%+H"/(T+T$1$&+:#(39(B+,+6"%"-"'+)"C&"6U1*%U-($0+2-.6%&6&+2-03)%.,10($ + (02")-03)%,0(("B + (0 + -0E106)&,("w +/$/(1.$*"01+4&H"/(T+T$1$B+%-.()1&-UL_0'+6U1*%U-(UL+("-DU+,+E"-D0+)&)%0D$+/(.(&'+& + ("-D + 307%01*(")%&B + "%5Ua3�(($O + "% + "#-./",.%01*("4" + )U#d06%.w+/"%."?F'+0.'+4&H"/(T+T$1$B+,61L5.L_0'+"#-./",.%01*("4"+)U#d06%.+,+)U_0)%,UL_&0+)O0D$+307%01*(")%&A

Z#-./",.(&0 + 6.6 + 2-.6%&6. + -./,&%&7 + 501",050)6"4" + 2"%0(C&.1.+%-0#U0% + )0%0,"' + & + "%6-$%"' + "-4.(&/.C&& + "#-./",.%01*("4"+2-")%-.()%,.B+,+"%1&5&0+"%+"#-./",.(&7+6.6+307%01*(")%&B+(.2-.,10(("'+

:?

Page 50: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

(. + %-.()17C&L + 6U1*%U-$B + %-0#UL_0' + "-4.(&/.C&& + "#-./",.(&7 + 6.6+1&(0'("' + 2")103",.%01*(")%& + x%.2",B + ),7/.(($O + ) + 2")%020(($D+"),"0(&0D + 6U1*%U-($O + ("-D + , + &O + 2")%020(("D + U)1"a(0(&& + 9,+3&3.6%&50)6"' + 203.4"4&60< + 1&#" + , + &O + 40(0/&)0 + 9, + 307%01*(")%("'+203.4"4&60<A+

M.a0( + 317 + "(%"203.4"4&6& + )"C&.1*($' + E.6% + /.6./.A + Z3(.6"+)&%U.C&7+(0+)",)0D+%.6",.+c+D$+)04"3(7+&D00D+301"+)+6,./&J/.6./"DB+2")6"1*6U + (",$' + "#-./ + a&/(& + (","' + x1&%$ + (0 + ,$-._0(A + G-"(&7+)&%U.C&& + %.6",.B + 5%" + D$ + (.#1L3.0D + D0%.(&0 + -"3&%010' + "%+.-&)%"6-.%&/D. + 3" + 203.(%&5("4" + )"C&.1&/D. + 9"-&0(%&-",.(("4" + (.+%-.3&C&"(($0 + 2"6./.%01&<A + G307B + 5%" + "#-./ + a&/(& + D"a0% + #$%*+&(3&,&3U.10(+&+U(&6.10(+%"1*6"+/-00%+,+6-U4.O+(.^&O+2"%0(C&.1*($O+/.6./5&6",A+

"?C$ $ [email protected] $2382@,-.A2A1/1+ + )103U0% + U6./.%* + %0 + 6"(%06)%$B+D&D"+6"%"-$O+(.3"+2-")%"+2-"'%&+&+(0+,"'%&+,+(&OA+Q"(6-0%("+3.6$3,$-2?c34$138,=,627.8<k+

J+3&)6U))&7+"+%.6+(./$,.0D$O+&(3&,&3U.1*("JU50#($O+21.(.O+c+x%"+x10D0(%.-($'+&()%-UD0(%B+(0+%-0#UL_&'+%*L%"-)6&O+U)&1&'w

J+#0))D$)10((.7+3&)6U))&7+"+6"D20%0(%(")%("D+2"3O"30B+D$+&+%.6+-0.1&/U0D + 307%01*(")%(UL + 203.4"4&6U + , + E"-D0 + `ZA +C & #(37$7(UV"-&+:)*"'$$&3'('$%&^+#-$#)U.0%&7&H#+9"00"&#"X"'$%&H#+:?"-'82&3(/(*Z&

t&7&'(*(?F'+4&X1+?"&O&Y.+&0$0."-(&)*":'82&3(/(*[&

t&7&H+/#+0.1+7+4&O&0$0."-(&H#+"1.'82&3(/(*[&

t&7&0.(#X"4&X1+?"&O&0$0."-(&+:#(3+7(."?F'82&3(/(*[

J + 2)&O"1"4&50)6&0 + 2"3O"3$B + ),7/.(($0 + ) + ,"/-.)%($D+"#)1Ua&,.(&0D + & + /.(&a0(&0D + 30%)6&O + ,"/D"a(")%0'B + D$+"-&0(%&-",.($ + (. + 2)&O"1"4&L + -./,&%&7 + & + ,61L50(&0 + 30%0' + ,+2-"#10D($0+)&%U.C&&w

J + 2")%)",0%)6.7 + 3&)6U))&7 + " + ,")2&%.(&&B + 2")6"1*6U + )04"3(7 +(0%+%.6"4"+)"C&.1*("4"+/.6./.w

J + %-.3&C&"(($' + 203.4"4&50)6&' + 7/$6B + (. + (0D + (0,"/D"a("+)E"-DU1&-",.%*+C01&+"%6-$%"4"+"#-./",.(&7w

J+2-03)%.,10(&0+"#+"#-./",.(&&+6.6+"+6"D20().%"-("'+203.4"4&60+&+203.4"4&60+f6.D0-$+O-.(0(&7gA

M)0 + x%& + 2-"#10D$ + & + "#)Ua30(&7 + (.3" + ")%.,&%* + 6"(6U-0(%.DB + .+).D&D+,$'%&+,+(",$'+"#-./",.%01*($'+U61.3B+/.3.,.%*+(",$0+"#-./C$+&+(",UL+f"#-./",.%01*(UL+D"3UgA+M+6.50)%,0+U)1",("4"+2-&D0-.+3-U4"4"+"#-./",.%01*("4"+E"-D.%.B +,"/D"a("B+,$301&%*+0,-"20')6&0+ +5.)%($0+^6"1$ + ) + f&)%"-&50)6&D + 1&C"DgB + (.2-&D0- +�6"1. + ),A + N0(03&6%.A + M+%.6"4" + -"3. + &()%&%U%.O + ,.a($ + (0 + f"6"1"J(.U5($0g + C01& + 9U + (.) + x%"+/.O,.%&1. + 2)&O"1"4&7<B + . + C0((")%& + -0.1*($O + %-.3&C&' + &+)E"-D&-",.(($O+6U1*%U-($O+U)%.(","6+/.6./5&6.A+F"J)U_0)%,UI$Y.+&O&+:#(3+7(."?F'8" & H#+"1.8 & 0+3/('$% & $ & #"(?$3(9$$ & +H#"/"?"''+4 &

1(#.$'8&-$#(R &72+W/"'$"&7 &1+.+#8"&$&H+1)H(U.= &!++.7".0.7"''+R &

Y.+ & $ & "0.F & .#"'/ & #(37$.$% & ?$/"#( & & +:#(3+7('$% & 7 & L+00$$ & O &

@>

Page 51: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

+#T('$3(9$% & '+7+T+ & +:#(3+7(."?F'+T+ & )1?(/(R & +0'+7(''+T+ & '( &

1+'0.#)$#+7('$$ &.#(/$9$$=+ GD0((" + x%" +& +3"1a(" +(.) +&(%0-0)",.%*A+\.6"0 + 6"()%-U&-",.(&0 + ),7/.(" + ) + 2"1.4.(&0D + -0.1&)%&5("J6"(%06)%U.1*("4"+&+730-("J)U_(")%("4"+%&2",+/(.(&7A +F-"&/,030D+(.+-&)U(60+2"2$%6U�4&2"%0/U+%.6"4"+2"1.4.(&7k

@8

Page 52: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

`&)U("6A$:27=,G,334,$/238,/684$1$A1@28,>.$C-=.$2382@,-.A2A1/1

&&&&

&&&&&&B+0.$'/)0.#$(?F'(%&Y1+'+-$1(u&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&& &&&&&&&A$'(-$*"01$4&-$#&

&&&&&&&#"$'/)0.#$(?$3(9$%&L+00$$&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$g=.c-.36/.C$1-,381B3268<$Q$/./$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ $$h=2;?,G32F@=20,66R.?<3.C$/2GGR31/.01CI$$$$$$$$$$$6R;S,/83268<$@=1$6G,3,$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$ $$$@=2,/83.C$2=A.31>.01C$2;=.>.$c1>31$$$$$$$$$$j/232G1B,6/2A2$R/?.-.

$$$$$$$N682=1B3268<$0,?,@2?.A.31C$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$N3-171-R.?<3268<$/./$/.@18.?1>.01C$6,;C$

$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$$

&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&E"''+0.F&H#$37('$%u&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&>'.#+H+?+T$%&0(-++H#"/"?"'$%u&

&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&@0.+#$*'+0.$&0)V"0.7+7('$%&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&5L(0H+#%W"'$"&0+:+4;&

h=./6,2?2A1B,6/2,$@=268=.36872

:201.?<32,$@=268=.36872

Z#2368=R1=27.31,$'R-RJ,A2[

E5/26h2?16k5-26h2j>16

Page 53: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

M/6,2?2A1B,6/2,$@=268=.36872

M38=2@2?2A1B,6/2,$@=268=.36872

@;

Page 54: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

h17+V+x%.2.+2"1.4.(&7+6"(%06)%$+(.+)O0D0+&/1"a0($+3")%.%"5($D+"#-./"DA + {%" + a0 + 6.).0%)7 + f73-.gB + %" + x%"% + ,"2-") + %-0#U0%+3"2"1(&%01*($O+6"DD0(%.-&0,A+fQ"()%-U&-",.(&0+NU3U_04"g+)04"3(7+c + U6./.(&0 + (0 + (. + 6"(6-0%($' + ,&3 + 307%01*(")%&B + . + (. + D0%.E"-U+30')%,&7A +Z50,&3("B +5%" +30')%,&0 +2-&(.310a&% +)",-0D0(("' +x1&%0k+20-,.7 + 4-U22. +c +2-"4("/&)%$B +EU%U-"1"4& +& +D.-60%"1"4& + 9,$)"6"4"+2"10%.<w +,%"-.7+4-U22.+c +2"1&%&6&w +%-0%*7+4-U22. +c +&((",.C&"(($0+&))103",.%01&+9(.2-&D0-B+,+)E0-0+#&"&(a0(0-&&<w+50%,0-%.7+4-U22.+c+2-03)%.,&%01&+)",-0D0(("4"+&)6U))%,.A

!""%,0%)%,0((" + 2-"4-.DD. + -0.1&/U0% + 50%$-0 + 2-"E&1*($O+(.2-.,10(&7B + )""%,0%)%,UL_&O + ,"/D"a($D + U2-.,10(50)6&D+2"/&C&7Dk + fZ'6")g +' + 40"x6"("D&50)6"0B + fF"1&)g +' + )"C&.1*("J2"1&%&50)6"0gB + f|'3")g +' + (.U5("J&))103",.%01*)6"0B + fF"x/&)g +' ((.2-.,10(&0 + 6U1*%U-$ + & + &)6U))%,.A + ~)1& + 2" + "%("^0(&L + 6 + x%&D+2-.6%&6.D + ,$301&%* + U2-.,10(50)6&0 + 2"/&C&&B + %" + ,"/D"a($ +50%$-0+%&2. + "-4.(&/.C&& + "#-./",.%01*("4" + 73-.k + 8A + Q"-2"-.%&,($0 + %"2JD0(03a0-$w+=A+{&(",(&6&w+;A+Z-4.(&/.%"-$+(.U6&w+:A+F-"3L)0-$A

N-0(3J)1"4.(+f#2368=R1=27.31,$'R-RJ,A2g+U6./$,.0%+(.+%"B+5%"+/30)* + #U3U_00 + f2-&3UD$,.0%)7g + & + 4"%",7%)7 + 50%$-0 + f%&2. + 1L30'gB+6"%"-$0 + x%" + #U3U_00 + #U3U% + 301.%* + 9&1& + , + O"30 + 6"()%-U&-",.(&7+#U3U_04"+4"%",&%)7+50%$-0+%&2.+2"/&C&"(0-",+04"+-0.1&/.C&&<A+

!""%,0%)%,0((" + (.3" + 2-"06%&-",.%* + 50%$-0 + "%3010(&7 + 317+(.5.1*("'+^6"1$+98J@61A<B+50%$-0+2-"E&17+317+2"3-")%6","'+9YJ?61A<+&+50%$-0+E.6U1*%0%.+98>J8=61A<+317+)%.-^0'+^6"1$A+`./4","-$+"+-.((0'+2-"E&1&/.C&&+/30)* +(0UD0)%($k+,+(.5.1*("'+^6"10+-./1&5&0 +D"a0%+)U_0)%,",.%* + 1&^* + (. + U-",(0 + ,(0U50#("' + 307%01*(")%&w + ,+2"3-")%6","'+ +'( Ua0+(.+U-",(0+,(0U-"5("'+307%01*(")%&+&+%"1*6"+,+)%.-^0' +' + (. + U-",(0 + U50#("4" + 21.(. + & + &(3&,&3U.1*("J"#-./",.%01*($O+2-"4-.DDA+ +F-&+x%"D+U+30%0'+3"+,%"-"4"+2"1U4"3&7+8>J4" + 61.)). + ,61L5&%01*(" + 3"1a(. + #$%* + ,"/D"a(")%*+f#0/,"/D0/3("4"g + 20-0O"3.A + \.6.7 + "-4.(&/.C&7 + "#-./",.%01*("4"+2-"C0)). + D"a0% + )%.%* + -0.1*($D + 6"(6U-0(%($D + 2-0&DU_0)%,"D + &+2-0,-.%&%* + ^6"1U + 317 + -0#0(6. + , + &(%0-0)($'B + f,"1^0#($'g + "#-./+a&/(&A++

G)O"37 + &/ + %.6"4" + 2-03)%.,10(&7 + " + 73-0B + D"a(" + )%-"&%* + ,)�+"#-./",.(&0B+,61L5.7+3")U4",$0+E"-D$+a&/(&+,+U5-0a30(&&k+2"3#"-+30%0'+,+61.))$B+2-"06%("J&))103",.%01*)6UL+307%01*(")%*B+%-0(&(4&+&+2U%0^0)%,&7B + 2-./3(&6&B + x6)6U-)&&B + ,&30"J61U#$ + & + %A3A + \.6+)%.(",&%*)7 + 7)("B + 6.6&0 + 203.4"4& + & + D.)%0-. + 3"2"1(&%01*("4"+"#-./",.(&7 + + #U3U% + (0"#O"3&D$A + |%" + "%6-$,.0% + ,"/D"a(")%*+2-&41.^0(&7 + -"3&%010' + 317 + U5.)%&7 + , + D.)%0-J61.)).OA + �30)*+(0"#O"3&D$ + D0-"2-&7%&7 + "%6-$%"4" + O.-.6%0-. + c + 3&)2U%$B + 106C&&B+2-0/0(%.C&&B + ,050-.B + 6"(C0-%$ + c + 5%" + + #U30% + 2"/&C&"(&-",.%*+U5-0a30(&0 + +6.6 +�0(%- +&((",.C&'+& +6U1*%U-($O +2-"-$,", + 9,2"1(0+,"/D"a("+,+),7/&+)+x%&D+(.1&5&0+2"/&C&&+z�zrtJD0(03a0-.<A

@:

Page 55: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

h=1?2c,31,D$:8.3-.=81>.01C$8<H82=6/1W$@2>1015\*L%"-)6.7 + 2"/&C&7 + 2" + ),"0DU + &)%"-&50)6"DU + )%.%U)U + 9%*L%"-+

"%,05.0% +/. +(-.,)%,0(($'B +.6.30D&50)6&'+& + +E&1")"E)6&'+-")% +501",06.+9�"-3"(<+,"/D"a(.+%"1*6"+,+)&%U.C&7O+"%6-$%"4"+"#-./",.(&7B+%A0A+%.DB+430+)U_0)%,UL% + &(3&,&3U.1*($0 + /.3.5& + /.6./5&6. + (. + "#-./",.%01*(UL+307%01*(")%*A + \*L%"-)6UL + 307%01*(")%* + (0 + &D00% + )D$)1. + /.3.,.%* + &/+D.))","' + "#-./",.%01*("' + &30"1"4&&B + (0 + &D00% + )D$)1. + 20-0(")&%*+)U_0)%,UL_&0 + 4")U3.-)%,0(($0 + &()%-UD0(%$ + %.6 + (./$,.0D"'+f,")2&%.%01*("'+-.#"%$g+&B+5%"+6-.'(0+"50,&3("B+(0+&D00%+)D$)1.+,,"3&%*+)U_0)%,UL_UL+,+"#$5($O+^6"1.O+)&)%0DU+D0-"2-&7%&'B+3"6UD0(%.C&&+&+"%50%(")%&+317+%*L%"-",A

Q.6+2-.,&1"B+)",-0D0(($0+2"6"10(50)6&0+)%-.%04&&+x1&%($O+61.))",+),7/.($+)"+)103UL_&D&+%&2.D&+).D""2-03010(&7k8A !%-.%04&7+(.)103",.(&7+J+20-03.5.+(.)103(&6U+),"04"+#&/(0).=A !%-.%04&7+&(3&,&3U.1&/.C&&+J+)"/3.(&0+317+-0#0(6.+,"/D"a(")%0'+

)%.%*+f).D&D+)"#"'g;A !%-.%04&7 + #0/"2.)(")%& + c + -0#0("6 + (0 + 3"1a0( + )%.%* + 2"D0O"'B + .+

)""%,0%)%,0(("+3"1a0(+"#1.3.%*+U(&,0-).1*($D&+6"D20%0(C&7D&A\*L%"-+,$)%U2.0% +)U#d06%"D+%.6&O+)%-.%04&'+&+"#1.3.0%+C01")%($D+

D$^10(&0D +2" +2","3U + %"4" +&1& +&("4" +-0#0(6. +c + f"%"a30)%,170% + )0#7 + )+,")2&%.((&6"Dg+9�"-3"(<B +%A0A +D"a0%+3UD.%*+2-"+"%301*("4"+2"3"205("4"B+"%)L3.+&+,$-.a0(&0B+5%"+%*L%"- +c+ f/.6./5&6+"#-./",.%01*("4"+2-"C0)).gA+|%"+/(.5&%B +5%" +%*L%"-)6UL+2"/&C&L+(0"#O"3&D"+/.3.,.%* +2-.6%&50)6&D+"#-./"DB+.+(0+&))103",.%01*)6&DA+F-.6%&50)6"0+c+"/(.5.0%B +2-0a30+,)04"B+C01")%("0B+)103",.%01*("B+30')%,0(("0A+m+&))103",.%01*)6"0B+2-0a30+,)04"B+2-03D0%("0+c+"%301*("0B+)103",.%01*("B+1&^*+5.)%&5("0B+"2&).%01*("0A+h17+"2&).(&7 + 9%*L%"-)6"'< + 2-.6%&6& + (0"#O"3&D" + "#"/(.5&%* + 2-")%-.()%,"+307%01*(")%&+&+EU(6C&"(&-",.(&7A+M+3.(("D+)1U5.0+%.6&O+%-&k8A + Z-4.(&/.C&7B + 6"(%-"1* + & + 2"D"_* + , + ")U_0)%,10(&&+

-0a&D(")%&+9.FU.+#&1(1&+#T('$3(.+#<w=A + Z-4.(&/.C&7 + &(&C&&-",.(&7 + &(3&,&3U.1*($O+

"#-./",.%01*($O+&(%0-0)",+9.FU.+#&1(1&^(0$?$.(.+#<w;A + Z-4.(&/.C&7 + 6"()%-U&-",.(&7 + #U3U_0' + &30(%&5(")%&B+

2-"06%&-",.(&7+&+-0.1&/.C&&+&(3&,&3U.1*($O+"#-./",.%01*($O+)%-.%04&'+&+2-"4-.DD+9.FU.+#&1(1&1+)*<Af<H82= $ $ _ $ E=A.31>.82=lY.?1618.82=l#2RBD $Z-4.(&/.C&7 + 3"1a(.+

&D0%* + 6.6 + 20-)"(.1*($0 + %*L%"-)6&0 + 21.($ + , + -.D6.O + U6./.(($O+2-")%-.()%,B + %.6 + & + "#_&' + 21.( + "-4.(&/.C&& + )6,"/($O + "%6-$%$O+"#-./",.%01*($O + 2-"4-.DDB + 6"%"-$0 + 2-03)%.,17L% + )"#"' + &()%-UD0(%+307%01*(")%&+317+6.a3"4"+%*L%"-.A+Z(.+/.3.0%+C01")%("0+"#-./",.%01*("0+2-")%-.()%," + U5-0a30(&7A + F-& + x%"D + %*L%"-$ + 3"1a($ + #$%* + .6%&,("+,61L50($+,+)U_0)%,UL_&0+U50#("J"#-./",.%01*($0+-0a&D$kJ+U50#("'+307%01*(")%&+c+,+6.50)%,0+2-02"3.,.%017+2-"06%("'+307%01*(")%&J+D0a3U(.-"3("'+2-"4-.DD$+c+,+6.50)%,0+2-02"3.,.%017+&))103",.%01*)6"'+307%01*(")%&J+%-0(&(4",+c+,+6.50)%,0+&4-"%0O(&6",J+3"2"1(&%01*("4"+"#-./",.(&7+c+,+6.50)%,0+)"C&.1*($O+203.4"4",

@@

Page 56: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

J+&(3&,&3U.1*("'+-.#"%$+c+,+6.50)%,0+.(.1&%&6",+&$.(%-"2"%0O(&6",A

i>4/$Z:2F[

I=!=D(')4?+7&

T&/(* + 501",06. + "2-030170%)7 + 50-03"' + )"#$%&'B + . + %.6a0+)"30-a.(&0D+&+E"-D.D&+04"+)"J#$%&7A+!1",.+f)"#$%&0g+&+f)"J#$%&0g+&)%"-&50)6& + ),7/.(($B + (" + &D0L% + )%.%U)($0 + "%1&5&7A + M + 2-.,10(&0+F0%-. + F0-,"4" + f)",0-^&1")* + "%3010(&0 + 3UO",("4" + 7/$6. + "%+"#$30(("4" + f4-.a3.()6"4"gB + #$% + "%301&1)7 + "% + #$%&7A +\.6 + )"#$%&0+-.)2.1")*+(.+)"#[%&0+&+)"#$%&~A+!1","+)"#[%&0+)%.1"+"%(")&%*)7+6+4-.a3.()6"DU + 7/$6UB + . + )"#$%&~ + c + 6 + C0-6",("DUA + fF"-,.1.)*+%"(5.'^.7B+($(0+(0+"_U_.0D.7+D.%0-&7+C01*(")%&+3U^&+&+-./UD.gA+!,0%)6"0 + 2"(7%&0 + )"#$%&7 + "2-")%&1")* + 3" + fE.6%. + "#_0)%,0(("'B+1&5("'+a&/(&g+9Za04",<B+)%.1"+#$%",$DA+!"#$%&<+9,+3.1*(0'^0D+)"J#$%&0< +O"%7 +2-"3"1a.1"+U2"%-0#17%*)7+%-.3&C&"(("+,+2-.,")1.,("JE&1")"E)6"J203.4"4&50)6"'+1&%0-.%U-0+9MAMA�0(*6",)6&'B+GAmAG1*&(<+, + ),0%)6"' + 4")U3.-)%,0(("' + 203.4"4&60 + #$1" + 2-03.(" + /.#,0(&LA+M"/-"a30(&L + x%"4" + 2"(7%&7 + & + ,O"a30(&L + 04" + , + )",-0D0(("0+4UD.(&%.-("0 + /(.(&0 + D$ + "#7/.($ +RARAN.O%&(UB + . + 2"/3(00 + 92")10+20-0,"3", + E&1")"E)6"4" + (.)103&7< + (0D0C6"DU + D$)1&%01L+RAy.'30440-UA+

{0D + "#0-(U1")* + 317 + 203.4"4&6& + &)61L50(&0 + &/ + "#-._0(&7+2"(7%&7+f)"J#$%&0g�+\.6a0+c+"2-"_0(&0D+,)76&O+),7/0'B+&+2U)%"%"'B+/.2"1(&%* + 6"%"-UL +(&6.6&0 +2"3O"3$ +, +203.4"4&60 +2"%0(C&.1*(" +(0+D"41&A + P.)%.1" + ,-0D7 + 20-0"C0(6& + 2"(7%&7 + & + ,"/3,&a0(&7 + 04" + (.+2"3"#.L_00+0DU+D0)%"A+!103U0%+"%D0%&%*+")"#UL+5U,)%,&%01*(")%*+6+x%"DU + )1",U + "%050)%,0(($O + 2)&O"1"4",A + MAGA!1"#"35&6",B+�AmA�U60-D.(+0_0+,+3"20-0)%-"05($'+20-&"3+"#-._.1&)*+6+2"(7%&L+f)"J#$%&0gB+&)2"1*/U7+04"+2"%0(C&.1+317+O.-.6%0-&)%&6&+501",050)6"'+"#_(")%& +& + 2"/(.,.%01*("4" + 2-"C0)).A +F"/3(00 +hAMA�-&4"-*0,$D + ,+203.4"4&60 + #$1 + -./-.#"%.( + )"#$%&'($' + 2"3O"3B + , + 6"%"-"D+"2-03010((.7+,")2&%.%01*(.7+-"1*+"%,"3&1.)*+(0+%"1*6"+)"#$%&LB+("+&+)"J#$%&LA

M + 50D + "%1&5&0 + )"#$%&7 + "% + )"J#$%&7� + !"#$%&0 + #"1*^&()%,"+&))103",.%010'+"%(")7%+6+%"DUB+5%"+"(&+(./$,.L%+)-03"'B+O"%7+U3.5(00B+6.a0%)7B + 04" +),7/$,.%* +) +"#_0)%,0(($D+#$%&0DA +P" +5%"#$+%"% +&1&+&("' + E.6% + "#_0)%,0(("' + a&/(& + )%.1 + 317 + &(3&,&3UUD. + )"#$%&0DB+(Ua("+5%"#$+"(+#$1+1&5(")%("+/(.5&D$DA +m6.30D&6+�AGAP",&6",.+"%"a30)%,171. + )"#$%&0 + ) + 50DJ%" + 7-6&DB + 6-.)"5($DB + 2-./3(&5($DB+(0-73",$DB+(0/.U-73($DB+,205.%17L_&DB+,+2-"%&,"2"1"a(")%*+)0-$D+#U3(7D + 2",)03(0,(")%&A + N$%* + &1& + (0 + #$%* + E.6%U + )"#$%&0D + c + x%"+,"2-")+&(3&,&3U.1*("4"+)"/(.(&7B+.+(0+)-03$A+

@Y

Page 57: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

G/,0)%("B + 6 + 2-&D0-UB + 5%" + 2-./3(&6& + )U_0)%,UL% + (0 + 317 + ,)0OA+P0)1U5.'(" +MAmAQ.-.6",)6&' +& +hAMA�-&4"-*0, +)5&%.L%B +5%" +, + %6.(*+"#$30(("4" + 2-0#$,.(&7 + , + "#-./",.%01*("' + )-030 + 203.4"4.D+(0"#O"3&D" + 2")%"7((" + ,(")&%* +@=,0,-,384F62;481CB + 6"%"-$0+^6"1*(&6&+)2")"#($+")U_0)%,&%*+).D")%"7%01*("+&+).D"U2-.,170D"A+P"+&(3&,&3U.1*(" +/(.5&D"0 +)"#$%&0+6-.%6",-0D0(("B +%"43. +6.6+)"J#$%&0+,05("A +Z("+),7/.("+)+#$%&0DB+)+a&/(*L+,+^&-"6"D+/(.50(&&+)1",.B+)+2",)03(0,(")%*LA

!"J#$%&0 + c +'" & $0.+*'$1 & $'^+#-(9$$R & ( & 1('(? & H+?)*"'$% & $&H"#"/(*$ & $'^+#-(9$$R & ( & .(1W" & 0H+0+: & W$3'"+:"0H"*"'$%R &

W$3'"0.#+"'$%R&W$3'".7+#*"0.7(&*"?+7"1(A+{%"#$+2"(7%*+2"31&(("0+/(.50(&0+)"J#$%&7B+04"+&)O"3($'+)D$)1+)103U0%+"#-.%&%*)7+6+2"(7%&L+fa&/(*gB + f#$%&0g + 9&D0L_&0)7 + "%1&5&7 + , + 3.(("D + )1U5.0 + (0+2-&(C&2&.1*($<A+

N$%*B + a&%* + c + /(.5&% + ,/.&D"30')%,",.%* + )" + )-03"'A + M + (.U60B+2-0a30 +,)04" +, + %0"-0%&50)6"' +2)&O"1"4&& +& +203.4"4&6& +31&%01*("0+,-0D7 + 4")2"3)%,",.1& + 2")%U1.% + (02")-03)%,0((")%&B + 2-&(C&2+2)&O"E&/&50)6"4" + 2.-.1101&/D.B + %0"-&7 + 3,UO + E.6%"-",A + {01",06 + &+)-03.+#$1&+),7/.(($+%.6&D+"#-./"DB+5%"+&/D0(0(&7+,+"3("D+2"1L)0+,01& + 6 + &/D0(0(&L + , + 3-U4"DA + |%" + 2-")10a&,.0%)7 + , + -.#"%.O+FAjA�0)4.E%.B +U+6"%"-"4"+6"(6-0%(.7+)-03.+"3("/(.5("+E"-D&-",.1.+(06&'+%&2+1&5(")%&A+

M+&)%"-&&+(.U6&+2-&(C&2+(02")-03)%,0((")%&+9O"%7+&+2-"3"1a.0%+)U_0)%,",.%*+,+(.^&+3(&<B+,)0+a0+(.+&/,0)%("D+"%-0/60+,-0D0(&+#$1+2"%0)(0( + 2-&(C&2"D + "2")-03)%,0(("' + ),7/&A + M(.5.10 + x%" + #$1"+"2")-03)%,",.(&0 + 50-0/ + "%("^0(&0 + 91&(&7 + mAjA�./U-)6"4"B+mA!AR.6.-0(6"B+MAPAR7)&_0,.B+NAjA�"D",.<B+3.100+c+307%01*(")%("4"+"2")-03)%,",.(&7 + 91&(&7 + mAPA�0"(%*0,.B + FAiA�.1*20-&(.B+mAMAF0%-",)6"4"<B + , + 203.4"4&60 +#$1& + 0_0 +& +"#_0(&0 + 9mAmAN"3.10,B+mAMARU3-&6<+&+2-"5&0+E"-D$A+

P. + �.2.30 + 2-0"#1.3.1" + 2",030(50)6"0 + "2")-03)%,",.(&0+92-.4D.%&/DB+2"/&%&,&/DB+"20-.C&"(.1&/DB+#&O0,&"-&/D+,+-./1&5($O+&(%0-2-0%.C&7OB+D("4"+2"/a0+"2")-03)%,",.(&0+,+3UO0+�ARA+R.61Lx(.+&+3-A<A +M+(.)%"7_00+,-0D7+(0%+03&("'+D0%"3"1"4&&+,+"%050)%,0(("'+(.U60B +(" +2"J2-0a(0DU+).D"'+,1&7%01*("' +%0"-&0' +2-"D0aU%"5("4"+30%0-D&(&/D.+7,170%)7+%0"-&7+307%01*(")%("4"+"2")-03)%,",.(&7A

h07%01*(")%* + -.))D.%-&,.0%)7 + 6.6 + U(&,0-).1*($' + 2-&(C&2B+,61L5.L_&'+,)�k +2",030(&0B+"%("^0(&0B+&4-UB +2"/(.(&0B +"#_0(&0+&+3-A + |6)2.()&7 + 307%01*("4"B + . + /(.5&% + )"/(.%01*("4" + 2"3O"3. + (. + ,)0+)E0-$ + 501",050)6"' + .6%&,(")%&B + 2"3D0(. + -./1&5($O + E"-D+501",050)6"' + .6%&,(")%& + 2-03D0%("' + 307%01*(")%*LB + . + /(.5&%+)"/(.%01*($D + 2-"C0))"DB + ) + "3("' + )%"-"($ + U2"-73"5&1" + (.U5(UL+6.-%&(UB+("+)+3-U4"'+c+)&1*("+"4-U#&1"+2-03)%.,10(&0+"+)"30-a.(&&+2-"C0)).+,/.&D"30')%,&7+501",06.+)"+)-03"'A+|%"+,$/,.1"+"22"/&C&L+

@I

Page 58: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

, + (.U5($O + 6-U4.OB + ,$)6./.,^&O)7 + 2-"%&, + f2.(307%01*(")%("4"+2"3O"3.gA+

P.5&(.7+)+K>+4"3",+2-"^1"4"+,06.+,+"%050)%,0(("'+203.4"4&60B+,/.&D"30')%,&0+)%.(",&%)7+)"30-a.%01*($D+).D"C0(($D+2"(7%&0D+&+-.))D.%-&,.0%)7 + , + 6.50)%,0 + 2-"D0aU%"5("' + 30%0-D&(.(%$ + D0a3U+501",06"D + & + )-03"'A +! + x%"4" + 20-&"3. + Ua0 + (&6"4" + (0 + U3&,170%B + 5%"+,/.&D"30')%,&0 + 501",06. + )" + )-03"' + %-.6%U0%)7 + (0 + %"1*6" + 50-0/+)"/(.%01*(UL + 307%01*(")%*B + (" + & + 3-U4&0 + E"-D$ + 501",050)6"'+.6%&,(")%&A+Z%O"3+"%+2-&(C&2.+D"(&/D.B+03&("4"+")(",.(&7B+2"3"-,.1+3",0-&0 +6 +&)%&(0 +& + )301.1 +,"/D"a($D+1L#$0+%"16",.(&7+2-"C0)).+,/.&D"30')%,&7A+P"+203.4"4&6.+6.6+2-&61.3(.7+3&)C&21&(.+%-0#",.1.+3&EE0-0(C&.C&& + 2"(7%&7A +F"2$%6& + -./1"a&%* + (. + )")%.,17L_&0+f,/.&D"30')%,&0gB + &)2"1*/U7 + 317 + x%"4" + 1&(4,&)%&50)6&' + 61L5B + (0+U,0(5.1&)*+U)20O"DA+N$1"+,$7,10("+(0)6"1*6"+D.1"x,-&)%&5($O+)1",+9,/.&D"2-"(&6(",0(&0B + ,/.&D"(02-&7%&0<A + \-0#",.1)7 + #"100 + %"(6&'+&()%-UD0(%.-&'A+

P.^&+"2$%$+)+2"(7%&0D+f)"J#$%&0g+"6./.1&)*+U)20^(00A+R0)%"+,/.&D"30')%,&7+/.(71"+)"J#$%&0A+G(3&,&3+)%.1+)U#d06%"D+&+2-03)%.1+"3("'+E"-D"'+#$%&7B +. +)-03.+c +0DU+2-"%&,"2"1"a("'A +F-"C0))+)"J#$%&7+&(3&,&3.+&+)-03$+)%.1+D$)1&%*)7+,+6.50)%,0+2")-03)%,UL_04"+/,0(.B+2-"D0aU%"5("'+30%0-D&(.(%$A+�.D0(.+)1",.+f,/.&D"30')%,&0g+(. + f)"J#$%&0g + "6./.1.)* + (.)%"1*6" + 21"3"%,"-("'B + 5%" + 2"7,&1.)*+,"/D"a(")%* + ,$510(&%* + 2-"D0aU%"5($0 + 20-0D0(($0 + , + %.6"D+6"1&50)%,0 +& +%.6"4" +6.50)%,.B +6"%"-$O +"6./.1&)*+3")%.%"5("B +5%"#$+"O.-.6%0-&/",.%* + -./1&5($0 + )%"-"($ + ,/.&D"30')%,&7 + 501",06. + &+)-03$A+

@K

Page 59: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

M+")(",0+(.^04"+^.4.+(.+2U%&+6+"20-.C&"(.1&/.C&&+2"(7%&7+f)"J#$%&0g + 10a.% + 3.(($0 + 2-",03�(($O + )",D0)%(" + ) + 1&(4,&)%.D&+&))103",.(&' + D"-E"1"4&50)6"' + & + )0D.(%&50)6"' + )%-U6%U-$ + x%"4"+)1",.A + Z6./.1")*B + 5%" + )"J#$%&0 + 6.6 + )2")"# + #$%&7 + &D00% + )1"a(UL+,(U%-0((LL+)%-U6%U-U+&+7,170%)7+-"3",$D+2"(7%&0D+317+"#^&-("'+4-U22$+E0("D0(",B+"#d03&(�(($O+D"-E0D"'+0+,A+

|%& + E0("D0($k + )"/0-C.(&0B + )")-03"%"50(&0B + )""%(0)0(&0B+)"&/D0-0(&0B + )"2")%.,10(&0B + )"D(0(&0B + )"5U,)%,&0B + )"20-0a&,.(&0B+)")%-.3.(&0B + )"U5.)%&0B + )"30')%,&0B + )"/3.(&0B + )"%-U3(&50)%,"B+)",0-^0()%,",.(&0B + )"41.)&0B + )")U_0)%,",.(&0B + )"2-"%&,10(&0B+)"20-(&50)%,"B + )")%7/.(&0B + )"-0,(",.(&0B + )"O-.(0(&0B + )"#1L30(&0B+)"41.)",.(&0B + )"2"35&(0(&0B + )"U2-.,10(&0B + )""#_0(&0B+)"2-","a30(&0+&+3-A

!%-U6%U-("0 + 3010(&0 + )1",. + f)"J#$%&0g + 6.6 + )2")"#. +#$%&7 + (.+&(,.-&.(%(UL +-&& & + 6"-(0,$0 + 20-0D0(($0 + 2"/,"1&1" +"2-0301&%*+5.)%($0+E"-D$ +0+J#$%&7k +0+J%-U3(&50)%,"B+0+J41.)&0B +0+J20-0a&,.(&0B+0+J)U_0)%,",.(&0 + & + 3-AB + 2"33.L_&0)7B + 6.6 + 2"6./$,.0% + "2$%B+61.))&E&6.C&7DA+ \.6B + (0-.)510(�((.7 +& + .#)%-.6%(.7 + 6.%04"-&7 + f)"J#$%&0g+"#-01.+6"(6-0%("0+)"30-a.(&0+,+,&30+,$^02-&,03�(("4"+-73.+)1",A+|%"%+E"-D.1&/",.(($'+&+U(&E&C&-",.(($'+-73+,(")&%+)%-"4UL+"2-0301�((")%*+,+%"B+5%"+)")%.,170%+")(",U+"#-./.+a&/(&A

G)%"-&6"Jx%&D"1"4&50)6"0 + &))103",.(&0B + ,$2"1(0(("0+6AE&1"1A(A +~APA\-04U#","'B +2"3%,0-3&1"+(.^0+2-032"1"a0(&0+"+%"DB+5%" + ,$^0(./,.((.7 + 106)&50)6.7 + 4-U22. + c + x%" + "2-0301�((.7+8,=G1326168,G.D+ !-.,(&%01*($' + .(.1&/ + x%"' + 4-U22$ + )1", + ,+3-0,(04-050)6"D + & + )%.-")1.,7()6"DB + , + "%1&5&0 + "% + (","4" + 7/$6.B+2"6./.1B +5%"+-.(*^0+x%&+)1",.+&D01&+^&-"6&'+E&1")"E)6&'+)D$)1B+U%-.50(($' + ) + 4"3.D&A + !-.,(&k + )"J#$%&0 + & + )"#$%&0B + )"J"#_0(&0 + &+)""#_0(&0+&+%A3A+

!0'5.)B + 2"O"a0B + ,"/,-._.0%)7 + 6 + (&D + &)O"3($' + )D$)1A+~APA\-04U#",.+2&^0%k+f!1",.+)0D.(%&50)6&+D("4"D0-($B+("+&D0L%+,+),"0'+D("4"D0-(")%&+"#_00A+�(.50(&0+"#_04"+20-03.0%)7+2-&)%.,6"'+0+JA + GD0((" + "(. + (0)�% + /(.50(&0 + 20-,"4"B + ,0-O(04" + )0D.(%&50)6"4"+U-",(7 + x10D0(%", + -73.g + 98??:<A + Z#-.%&D)7 + 6 + &))103",.(&L+2-",03�(("DU+~APA\-04U#","'k&

fG)%"-&7 + 106)&50)6"' + 4-U22$ + f!"Jg + &(%0-0)(. + %0DB + 5%"+-./-.#.%$,.1.)*+"(.+.6%&,("+,+)&)%0D0+3-0,(04-050)6"4"+7/$6.+(.+")(",0+-04U17-("' + )1",""#-./",.%01*("' + D"301&k + ��� + c + 6"-0(* + c + )UEE&6) + c+"6"(5.(&0A + M + )1.,7()6&0 + 7/$6& + x%. + 4-U22. + #$1. + 2-&,(0)0(. + 50-0/+)%.-")1.,7()6&'+7/$6B +2-&+20-0,"30+3-0,(04-050)6&O+%06)%",+#$1+)301.(+2")")%.,($'+20-0,"3k

+���+J+����� +!Z)%-.3.(&0B+!Z5U,)%,&0+���+J+� ¡¢++++ !Z"%(")&%*++++&+%A3A

@?

Page 60: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

M+4-.(&C.O+(.^04"+2-03D0%.+&(%0-0)("+"%D0%&%*B +5%"+20-0,"3&1&)*B+6.6 + &/,0)%("B + C0-6",($0B + -01&4&"/($0 + %06)%$B + , + 6"%"-$O + & + 2"1U5&1&+")D$)10(&0+,"2-")$+N[\GiB+(0+a&%*7J#$%*7B+.+N[\GiB+#$%&0+2-&+x%"D+D$)1&1")* + 6.6 + 4.-D"(&5("0 + )")U_0)%,",.(&0 + 501",06. + ) + RG`ZRB + !+NZ�ZR + & + ) + ).D&D + )"#"L + c + &(.50 + 4","-7B + , + %06).O + (.^1. + "%-.a0(&0+E&1")"E)6.7+D$)1*+2-"^1$O+,-0D�(B+&+x%"+5-0/,$5.'("+,.a("A+9M+)1",.-0+3-0,(04-050)6"4"+7/$6.+,+I>+>>>+03&(&C+106)&50)6&'+-73+!ZJ+(.)5&%$,.0%+)+2-"&/,"3($D&+"6"1"+8=>>+03&(&CB+.+,+)1",.-0+)",-0D0(("4"+-U))6"4"+7/$6.+9Rm!<+2-03)%.,10("+"6"1"+K>+03&(&CB+U5&%$,.7+(",$0+)1",.B+2"7,&,^&0)7+Ua0+,+)&)%0D0+-U))6"4"+7/$6.+(.+")(",0+&)6"(($O+x10D0(%",<A

e/(.50(&0+3.(($O+03&(&C+&D00%+#"1*^"'+"#d�DB+%.6+6.6+2-.6%&50)6&+"(" + E"-D&-",.1")* + , + U)1",&7O + %-�O + 7/$6", + c + 3-0,(04-050)6"4"B+)%.-")1.,7()6"4"+&+3-0,(0-U))6"4"B+.+/.%0D+c+)",-0D0(("4"+-U))6"4"+7/$6.A+{%"#$+2-"a&%*+)%"1*+3"14&'+,06B+)1","+3"1a("+2")%"7(("+.6%U.1&/&-",.%*+),"�+/(.50(&0B+"%-.a.%*+)U_(")%($0+)%"-"($+7,10(&'A

m(.1&/ + 4-050)6&O + 03&(&C + 2"/,"1&1 + ,$7,&%* + )103UL_&0 + ,&3$+)"C&.1*($O+6"(%.6%",k

8A +Z#_00 + %&2"1"4&50)6"0 + /(.50(&0 + 03&(&Ck + )",D0)%("0 +E&/&50)6"0B+&(%01106%U.1*("0B + 2)&O"1"4&50)6"0B + 6"DDU(&6.%&,("0 + "),"0(&0 + &+E"-D&-",.(&0+D.%0-&.1*("4"+&+)"C&.1*("4"+#$%&7A

=A+M&3",$0+)%U20(&kJ + )",D0)%("0 + 307%01*(")%("0 + "),"0(&0 + D&-.A + y.-.6%0-&)%&6.+

)",D0)%($O + 30')%,&' + 2-03)%.,10(. + D("4""#-./(" + & + -./("(.2-.,10(("A+9)"/&3.%*B+)",0-^.%*B+)"%-U3(&5.%*B+)"U(&5%"a.%*B+)"U)%-.&,.%*+&+%A3A<w

J + )",D0)%("0 + D0(%.1*("0 + "),"0(&0 + 30')%,&%01*(")%&k + )"D(0(&0+92"(&D.1")* + & + 6.6 + 03&()%," + D(0(&7<B + )"3"6./.%01*)%,"B + )""%-&C.(&0B+)"&))103",.(&0B + )"/(.(&0B + )",0)%* + 92"(&D.1")* + & + 6.6 + 6"1106%&,($'+)",D0)%($'+D0(%.1*($'+"2$%<w

J + )",D0)%("0 + xD"C&"(.1*("0 + ,")2-&7%&0 + & + "),"0(&0 + #$%&7k+)"-.3",.%*)7B+)",")%"-4.%*)7B+)")%-.3.%*B+)"20-0a&,.%*B+)"a.10%*w

J+)",D0)%("0+6"DDU(&6.%&,("0+"),"0(&0+#$%&7+9)+C01*L+U)%.(",10(&7+/.6"(", + )U_0)%,",.(&7 + 9)""#_0(&0B + )",0_.(&0B + )""#)Ua30(&0B+)"#0)03",.(&0B+)",0%",.(&0w+)",0%B+)"#"-B+)"/$,B+)"#-.(&0+&+%A3Aw

J+)",D0)%("0+E"-D&-",.(&0+&+"),"0(&0+)"C&.1*("'+30')%,&%01*(")%&A+`73+,61L5.0%+#"1*^"0+6"1&50)%,"+03&(&CB+O.-.6%0-&/UL_&O+501",06.+,+04"+"%("^0(&7O + ) + )""#_0)%,"Dk + )"41.^.%*)7B + )"2"35&(7%*)7B + )"2"2U%5&6&B+)"U)%U2.L_&0B + )"3"4",.-&,.L_&0)7B + )"2-"%&,17L_&0)7B+)"2-&)2").#1&,.L_&0)7B +)""),.&,.L_&0)7B +)")%7/.L_&0)7B+)"#"-L_&0)7+&+%A3A

Y>

Page 61: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

eP0"#O"3&D" +"#-.%&%* +,(&D.(&0 +& +(. + %"B +5%" +, +6.a3"' +U6./.(("'+4-U220 + 2-&)U%)%,U0% + ),"7 + 1"4&6. + "#"/(.50(&7 + -0.1*(")%&B + /. + 6"%"-"'+)6-$%$ + "2-0301�(($0 + D0O.(&/D$ + 2"/(.(&7B + 2-"5U,)%,",.(&7 + D&-.A+Z#(.-Ua0(&0 + x%&O + D0O.(&/D", + 2"/,"170% + 2")%-"&%* + (",$0 + D0%"3&6&+"#-.#"%6&+&+2"3.5&+D.%0-&1.+(.+U-"6.OA+\.6+2-&+-0^0(&&+1"4&50)6&O+/.3.5+(. + U-"6.O + D.%0D.%&6& + D"a(" + "#(.-Ua&%*B + 6.6.7 + )%U20(* + , + D0O.(&/D0+1"4&50)6&O + -.))Ua30(&' + U5._04")7 + (0-./,&%. + c + )""%(0)0(&0B+)"2")%.,10(&0B+)"&/D0-0(&0A+m(.1&/+a0+4-U22$+f)"5U,)%,&0+c+)")%-.3.(&0+c + )"20-0a&,.(&&g + & + 4-U22$ + f)")-03"%"50(&0 + c + )"/0-C.(&0g + 2-& + &O+)",D0_0(&& + ,$,01 + (.) + 6 + (","' + D0%"3&60 + 2-",030(&7 + C&61. + U-"6",+f)"5&(0(&0+2"+6.-%&(0g+&1&+3.a0+1L#"4"+OU3"a0)%,0(("4"+2-"&/,030(&7A+|%"% +D.%0-&.1 + &(%0-0)0( + (0 + , + )&1U + ),"0' + (",&/($B + . + , + )&1U + %"4"B + 5%"+"#(.-Ua0(($0 + D0O.(&/D$ + , + 2"/(.(&& + (","4" + "#d06%.B + 2"(&D.(&7 + 04"B+,61L50(&7 + x%"' + &(E"-D.C&& + , + )"/(.(&0 + & + 20-0,030(&7 + 0� + (. + )%U20(*+1&5("4" + "2$%.B + . + /.%0D + %"1*6" + c + (. + )%U20(* + ,$)6./$,.(&7 + c + ,)0 + x%&+D0O.(&/D$+c+"%-.a0(&0+30')%,&%01*($O+,(U%-0((&O+2-"C0))",+D$^10(&7B+.+D$+5.)%"+,+2-.6%&60+&)2"1*/U0D+%"1*6"+,(0^(&0g+9m-O&,<A

R$ + 2-032"1.4.0DB + 5%" + (. + ).D"D + 3010 + "%("^0(&7 + D0a3U+)2")"#.D& + #$%&7 + "2-03017L%)7 + )&%U.C&0'A + \.6B + )"/0-C.(&0 + &+)"/&3.(&0+D"4U%+(.O"3&%*)7+,+"%("^0(&7O+3"2"1(0(&7+&1&+"%-&C.(&7A+G(%01106%U.1*($0 + & + xD"C&"(.1*($0 + 4-U22$ + D"4U% + "%-&C.%* + &1&+3"2"1(7%* + 3-U4 + 3-U4. + , + 2"/(.,.%01*("D + 2-"C0))0A +R("4"0 + -0^.0%+)D$)1","'+6"(%06)%A+

E86H-. $ 7472-9 $ 62F;481, $ 137.=1.3832 $ @2 $ 6268.7RI $ 32$G32A27.=1.3832$@2$XR3/01CGA+F-03)%.,10(("0+3010(&0+U)1",("B+("+"(" + U2"-73"5&,.0% + 2-03)%.,10(&0 + " + )"30-a.(&& + f)"J#$%&7g + &+EU(6C&"(.1*(" + "#"4._.0% + (.^0 + ,&30(&0 + )2")"#", + #$%&7A+|6/&)%0(C&.1*($0 + E"-D$ + )"J#$%&7B + 2-03)%.,10(($0 + 106)0D.D& + )+2-0E&6)"D + f)"JgB + 2"/,"1&1& + 6"-0(($D + "#-./"D + 20-0)D"%-0%*+)"30-a.%01*(UL+)%"-"(U+,/.&D"30')%,&7+)%"-"(A+G/D0(&1)7+).D+7/$6B+6"%"-$'+)%.1+#"100+E"-D.1*($DB+"20-.C&"(.1*($D+92-&+"%)U%)%,&&+,+203.4"4&60 +)%-"4&O +2-.,&1 +)1","U2"%-0#10(&7 +& +%0-D&("1"4&50)6"'+D0^.(&($B + x%" + Ua0 + (0D.1"<B + ).D" + ,/.&D"30')%,&0 + )"30-a.%01*("+)%.1" + #"100 + -./(""#-./($DA + \020-* + 2-& + ,)%-050 + )" + )1",.D&+f)"D(0(&0g +&1& +f)"-0,(",.(&0g +)103",.1" +&O +),7/$,.%* +) +-"3",$D+317+(&O+2"(7%&0D+f)"J#$%&0g+&+-.))D.%-&,.%*+,+/(.50(&&+6.(.1.+),7/&+501",06.+)"+)-03"'A+

Y8

Page 62: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

Q"(6-0%($0 + 2-"D0aU%"5($0 + 30%0-D&(.(%$ + ," + ,/.&D"30')%,&&+&(3&,&3. + & + )-03$ + -.)^&-&1& + 2.1&%-U + ,"/D"a(")%0' + U2-.,10(&7+2-"C0))"D + ,/.&D"30')%,&7B + (0 + "4-.(&5&,.7)* + U/6&D + )206%-"D + )1",+&/,0)%("4" + -73.k + "#_0(&0B + 2"/(.(&0B + %-U3 + & + 3-A + `./1&5($0 +E"-D$+)"#$%&7 + )%.1& + )2")"#.D& + "#_0(&7B + 2"/(.(&7 + &1& + 2-.6%&50)6"4"+"%("^0(&7B+2-0"#-./",.(&7B+2-&),"0(&7+&+2-&)2")"#10(&7+6+)-030B+.+0)1& + 6.).%*)7 + -0/U1*%.%",B + %" + & + )2")"#. +E"-D&-",.(&7 + & + -./,&%&7+1&5(")%& + -0#�(6.A + \0-D&("1"4&50)6&' + -73 + f0+,g + c + (0 + )103)%,&0+1&(4,&)%&50)6&O + &4-B + . + 2-"3U6% + %,"-50)6"' + -.#"%$ + )"/(.(&7 + )"+)1","DB+-.)^&-7L_&D+,"/D"a(")%&+203.4"4&50)6"'+(.U6&+&+2-.6%&6&A

Y1?262X1C$@,-.A2A1/1$EDYD'2?<327.$1$2;=.>4$2;=.>27.31C

6=A=K+#*(?+7(

M+8?K@4A+,+mE&(.O+Z%%"+j-&3-&O+N"1*(",B+&/,0)%($'+(0D0C6&'+E&1")"EB + ,$)%U2&1 + ) + 3"61.3"D + f\0"-&7 + & + 2-.6%&6. + ,")2&%.(&7gB+,2")103)%,&& + )%.,^&D + 5.)%*L + #"100 + "#d0D("4" + &/3.(&7 + fR0a3U+E&1")"E&0'+&+203.4"4&6"'gB+"2U#1&6",.(("4"+,+�0-D.(&&+,+8?KK4A+|%"+&/3.(&0 + ,61L5.1" + 3"61.3$ + & + )%.%*&B + (.2&).(($0 + , + 8?@>J8?KI44AB+#"1*^.7 + 5.)%* + &/ + 6"%"-$O +2-0a30 +(0 + 2U#1&6",.1.)* + , +�0-D.(&&B + .+5.)%* + & + (. + (0D0C6"D + 7/$60 + ,""#_0A + P.-73U + ) + -.#"%.D& + 2"+x6/&)%0(C&.1*("' + E&1")"E&& + & + &)%"-&& + E&1")"E&&B + /(.5&%01*("0+D0)%" + , + %,"-50)%,0 +D$)1&%017 + /.(&D.L% +E&1")"E)6&0 +&/$)6.(&7 + ,+"#1.)%&+203.4"4&6&B+00+)U_(")%&+&+/.3.5B+.+%.6a0+2-"#10D+2")%-"0(&7+203.4"4&50)6"4" + /(.(&7A + P0)D"%-7 + (. + 2-&/(.(&0 + 0,-"20')6&D+&(%01106%U.1*($D + )""#_0)%,"D + /(.5&D")%& + ,61.3. +ZAjAN"1*(",. + ,+)%.(",10(&0 + )",-0D0(("' + E&1")"E)6"' + & + 203.4"4&50)6"' + D$)1&B+-U))6"7/$5("DU + 5&%.%01L + 2"6. + 2-03)%.,10($ + 1&^* + "%301*($0+2U#1&6.C&&+x%"4"+.,%"-.8?A

Z%%" +j-&3-&O +N"1*(", + 98?>;J8??8< + (.5.1 + (.U5(UL + 6.-*0-U + ,+"#1.)%& + E&/&6&B + , + 8?=@4A + "( + /._&%&1 + 3"6%"-)6UL + 3&))0-%.C&L + 2"+%0"-0%&50)6"'+E&/&60+U+RAN"-(.A+�(.6"D)%,"+)+%-U3.D&+RAy.'30440-.+)%.1" + 2","-"%($D + )"#$%&0D + , + 04" + 6.-*0-0k + ZAjAN"1*(", + (.5&(.0%+2-"E0))&"(.1*(" + /.(&D.%*)7 + E&1")"E&0' + & + )2U)%7 + (0)6"1*6" + 10%B+/._&%&,+3&))0-%.C&L+2"+E&1")"E&&+jAi6"#&B +)%.(",&%)7 +3"6%"-"D+(.U6 + 2" + E&1")"E&&=>A + Z%%" +j-&3-&O"D + N"1*(",$D + #$1" + (.2&).("+

8?+ !DAk+N"1*(",B+ZAjA+j&1")"E&7+x6/&)%0(C&.1&/D.k +j&1")"E&7+)U_0)%,",.(&7k+F0-A + ) + (0DA + !A|AP&6U1&(. + c + !F#Ak + �.(*B + 8???Ac + ===)Aw + N"1*(",B + ZAjA + P",.7+U6-$%")%*A +F-"#10D. +2-0"3"10(&7 + x6/&)%0(C&.1&/D.A +M,030(&0 + �� +j&1")"E)6.7+D$)1*A+=>>8A+H+=A+!A+8;IJ8:@A=>+m6.30D&50)6&'+2U%*+N"1*(",.+"%D050(+-.#"%"'+,+��%%&(40()6"D+U(&,0-)&%0%0+&+�0"-4.Jm,4U)%.+98?;8J8?;?<B +�&)0()6"D+U(&,0-)&%0%0+&DA +S)%U).+�&#&4.+98?;?J8?:Y<B+l(&,0-)&%0%0+]"O.(0).+�U%%0(#0-4.+,+R.'(C0+98?:YJ8?@;<B+\L#&(40()6"D+U(&,0-)&%0%0 +|#0-O.-3. + & +Q.-1. + 98?@;J8?I><A + M + 8?I@4A + #$1 + &/#-.( +F"50%($D+

Y=

Page 63: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

"6"1"+;>+6(&4B+)-03&+6"%"-$O+D$+(./",0DB+,+20-,UL+"50-03*B+%0B+5%"+"%(")7%)7 + 6 + 04" + 203.4"4&50)6&D + -./D$^10(&7Dk + fP",$' + "#-./+501",06.+&+/.3.5.+203.4"4&6&g+98?;:<B+f!U_(")%*+(.)%-"0(&'g+98?:8<B+fj&1")"E&7+x6/&)%0(C&.1&/D.+&+203.4"4&6.g+98?@?<B+fF03.4"4&50)6.7+.%D")E0-.g + 98?Y:<B + fm(%-"2"1"4&50)6&' + )2")"# + -.))D"%-0(&7 + ,+203.4"4&60g+98?Y@<B+fQ-&/&)+&+(","0+(.5.1"A+!%.%*&+"+203.4"4&50)6"'+.(%-"2"1"4&&g+98?YY<B+fF03.4"4&6.+,+.(%-"2"1"4&50)6"D+"),0_0(&&g+98?I8<B+fm(%-"2"1"4&50)6.7+203.4"4&6.g+98?K;<+&+3-A9=<A

F03.4"4&50)6&0 + &30& +Z%%" +j-&3-&O. + N"1*(",. + c + ),"0"#-./("0+,$-.a0(&0+04"+E&1")"E)6"4"+2-"06%.B+6"%"-$'+D"a0%+#$%*+"#"/(.50(+6.6 + "2%&D&)%&50)6&' + x6/&)%0(C&.1&/DA + Z)%.,177 + /. + -.D6.D&+-.))Ua30(&7+04"+"2&).(&0B+U6.a0D+1&^*+(.+)%0-a(0,UL+C0((")%*A+Z(.+2-&)U%)%,U0% + & + , + 04" + 203.4"4&50)6&O + ^%U3&7Ok + 03&()%,0((.7+,"/D"a(")%*+317+2"31&(("4"+501",050)6"4"+)U_0)%,",.(&7+,+1L#"D+&/+3")%U2($O + 0DU +D"3U)", + /.61L5.0%)7 +, + %.6"D +)2")"#0 +"%("^0(&' +)+(.)%"7_&DB +2-&+6"%"-"D+501",06+"#(.-Ua&,.0% +")"#0((")%* +6.a3"'+"%301*("' + )&%U.C&&B + 6"43. + 2")103(77 + 0)%* + "3(",-0D0((" + 04"+f)U#d06%&,(.7g + )&%U.C&7=8+ & + )&%U.C&7 + f"#d06%&,(.7gB + %A0A + "(. + 0)%*+f3.(($'+2-0a30+92-0a30+3.(("4"+6"(6-0%("4"+&(3&,&3U.1*("4"+#$%&7+c + 2-&DA +PAQA< + 6.6 +(05%" + ,(0^(00 +D.%0-&.1 +&)%"-&&g + 9;B + )A + 8=Y<B + &+#1.4"3.-7 + )"#)%,0(("' + -0^&D")%& + , + "#-._0((")%& + 6 + #U3U_0DU+U)%.(.,1&,.0%+(.2-7a0((")%*+D0a3U+2-"^1$D+&+#U3U_&D+6.6+U)1",&0+2"31&(("4"+1&5("4" +,-0D0(&A +fP.)%"7_00 +c +x%" +"27%*J%.6&+(0 +).D.+1&^0((.7+2-"%7a0((")%&+2-0O"37_.7+%"56.B+.+%.+),7/*B+5%"+"#d03&(70%+,)0+,+"50,&3(")%&+(.)%"7_04"+9�sz+£z¤zr¥u�ts¤�zst<g+9;B+)A+88?<A

Z2-030177+C0(%-.1*($'+317+)"#)%,0(($O+-./D$^10(&'+,"2-")+"+2")%-"0(&& + 203.4"4&6& + 6.6 + (.U5("4" + /(.(&7 + & + U%,0-a3.7+2-&(C&2&.1*(UL + ,"/D"a(")%* + 2"3"#("4" + &(%01106%U.1*("4"+30')%,&7B + N"1*(", + )",0-^.0% + , + "%("^0(&& + 3.(("' + 3&)C&21&($+6U1*%U-"1"4&50)6"0 + 30')%,&0A + ! + "3("' + )%"-"($B + "( + ")U_0)%,170%+"#$)6U)%,10(&0+203.4"4&6&B+"#d06%&,&-U0%+&+"3(",-0D0(("+)",0-^.0%+2-","6.C&L + %-.3&C&"(($O + 2-03)%.,10(&' + " + 203.4"4&60 + 6.6+"%(")7_0')7 + 6 + )E0-0 + &)6U))%,. + & + )"2-7a0(("4" + ) + (&D& + D(0(&7 + "+203.4"40 + 6.6 + " + %"DB + 6%" + "#1.3.0% + 2-&-"3($D&B + ,-"a30(($D&+)2")"#(")%7D& + 6 + "#U50(&L + & + ,")2&%.(&L + 96,&(%x))0(C&0' + 504"+,$)%U2.0%+E"-DU1.+f203.4"4+"%+#"4.g<A+!+3-U4"'+)%"-"($B+)"41.)("+04"+2"/&C&&B + 203.4"4&6. + 3"1a(. + #$%* + &(%01106%U.1*("' + 2-.6%&6"'B+"%1&5("' + "% + 2",)03(0,("4"B + ).D" + )"#"' + -./UD0L_04")7 + )2")"#.+

3"6%"-"D + !%-.)#U-4)6"4" + U(&,0-)&%0%.B + . + /.%0D + & + (06"%"-$O + 3-U4&O+U(&,0-)&%0%",B + "( + 7,171)7 + F"50%($D + 510("D + P0D0C6"4" + 203.4"4&50)6"4"+"#_0)%,.+98?IK<+98<A=8f\"B + 5%" + ,$^0 + -./,&,.1")* + , + C01"D + 6.6 + /.#-"^0((")%* + , + "2-03010((UL+)&%U.C&LB+0)1&+-.))D.%-&,.%*+#"100+%"5("B+).D"+7,170%)7+Ua0+/,0("D+,-0D0(("'+"2-03010((")%&+501",06.A+F")6"1*6U+D&-+501",06.+0)%*+/30)*+2-0"#-.a0(($'+&D+"6-Ua.L_&D + D&-B + %" + ,)0 + %"B + 5%" + , + 1L#"0 + D4(",0(&0 + "#-./U0% + ")"#0((UL+)&%U.C&LB+,)043.+7,170%)7+Ua0+").36"D+&)%"-&50)6"4"+)%.(",10(&7g+9;B+)A+88K<A

Y;

Page 64: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

2"(&D.(&7+&+2")%U2.(&7+203.4"4.B +, +x%"D+)D$)10+"(.+3"1a(.+)%.%*+&)6U))%,0(($D + 9)20C&.1*(" + )"/3.(($D< + /(.(&0D + " + )"#)%,0(("D+2-03D0%0+c+,")2&%.(&&A

P0+"#0)C0(&,.7+&+(0+"%-&C.7+D("a0)%,0(($0+6"(%06)%$+&+%0D$B+E&4U-&-UL_&0+,+%06)%0+N"1*(",.B+"#-.%&D)7+6+%0D+04"+2")%.(",6.DB+6"%"-$0 + &D0L% + /(.50(&0 + 317 + )%.(",10(&7 + 203.4"4. + 6.6 + f)U#d06%.g+)"#)%,0(("' + 2-"E0))&"(.1*("' + 307%01*(")%&A + M03* + &D0(("+2"34"%",6. + U5&%017B + "#-0%0(&0 + &D + 2"1("%$ + & + f2"31&(("+&)%"-&50)6"4" + )D$)1.g + ),"0' + -.#"%$ + & + a&/(& + c + )%0-a(0,.7 + &307+203.4"4&6&+N"1*(",.A+

M+50D+a0+D"a0%+#$%*+U,&30(+00+"#-./",.%01*($'+)D$)1�F-&D0D + /. + &)O"3(UL + %"56U + -./D$^10(&' + %0/&) + " + %"DB + 5%"+

"#-./",.(&0 + 0)%* + 2-032-&7%&0 + &(3&,&3U.1*("0 + & + U(&6.1*("0B+"4-.(&5&,.7 + %0D + ).D$D + )"C&.1*("J&()%&%UC&"(.1*($0 + 6"(("%.C&&+"#-./",.(&7 + & + 2"(&D.7 + 04" + , + 6.50)%,0 + E0("D0(.B + 6"%"-$' +-+W".&)1U5&%*)7+,+"#-./",.%01*("'+2-.6%&60A+G(3&,&3U.1*("+"("+2")%"1*6UB+2")6"1*6U + 2"(&D.0%)7 + (.D& + )"#$%&0D + "#-./",.%01*("' + )U3*#$+6"(6-0%("4"+501",06.B+.+(0+D.))",&3($D+2")103)%,&0D+203.4"4&50)6"'+%0O("1"4&&A

! + 504" + ,"/D"a(" + (.5.1" + f")D$)10(("4"g + 9, + %0-D&("1"4&&+N"1*(",.<+203.4"4&50)6"4"+30')%,&7+&1&B+&($D&+)1",.D&B+)+504"+D"a0%+(.5.%*)7 + )%.(",10(&0 + 203.4"4.B + 20-0)%.L_04" + "#-._.%*)7 + )" + ),"0'+-.#"%"'+6.6+)+"#$30(("'+2-.6%&6"'B+&B+)""%,0%)%,0(("B+)+504"+D"a0%+(.5.%*)7+"#-./",.(&0�+

!%.(",10(&0B + 6"%"-"0 + (.5&(.0% + 2"(&D.%*)7 + 6.6 + )"#$%&0B+20-,&5("0+2"+"%("^0(&L+6+E.6%U+2"34"%",6&+U5&%017A+\.6&D+(.5.1"D+,$)%U2.0% + )&%U.C&7B + , + 6"%"-"' + f2-03,.-&%01*(" + 3.(("0 + 2"(&D.(&0+9D&-. + & + a&/(& + c + 2-&DA + PAQA< + 2")%"7((" + (.-U^.0%)7 + ,)103)%,&0+,%"-4.L_&O)7 + &/,(0 + )1U5.'($O + ,1&7(&'A + {%"#$ + U)%"7%* + 20-03 + &O+,"/30')%,&0DB+"("+3"1a("+2"3,0-4.%*+)"2")%.,10(&L+x%&+(.-U^0(&7+&+2-0"3"10,.%*+2"-"a3.0D$0+%-U3(")%&e+!0-*0/("0+"%("^0(&0+6+x%&D+%-U3(")%7D+,030%+6+")D$)10(&L+,"/D"a(")%0'+&O+2-0"3"10(&7B+.+&/+x%"4" + (0&/#0a(" + ,$%06.0% + #"100 + "#_00 + ")D$)10(&0 + )U_(")%&+,")2&%.(&7g+9:<A+

GD0((" + 2"2$%6& + ")D$)10(&7 + (02")-03)%,0(($O + (0U3.5 + &+2-",.1",B + 6"%"-$0 + D"4U% + #$%* + 2"(7%$B + , + 20-,UL + "50-03*B + 6.6+)103)%,&0 + 3"D&(&-",.(&7 + "#$30(("4" + /(.(&7B + "2"-$ + (. + f%UD.(+2-&,(0)0(($O+&D+9203.4"4"D+c+2-&DA+PAQA<+).D&D+2-03)%.,10(&'g+9%.D+a0<B + 2-03)%.,10(&' + (0")D$)10(($O + & + (0"%-0E106)&-",.(($OB + &+2")%-"0(&7+%0"-&&+6.6+)-03)%,.+317+f)O,.%$,.(&7g+(02")-03)%,0(("'+3.((")%&+"#U50(&7A+|%&+2"2$%6&+")D$)10(&7+c+(0"#O"3&D"0+U)1",&0+-./,&%&7+203.4"4.J2-"E0))&"(.1.A

F-031.4.0D$' +,/4173 +(. + )%.(",10(&0 +203.4"4. + %-0#U0% +& +&("4"+6.50)%,.+(.U5("'+%0"-&&+203.4"4&6&k+%.6.7+f%0"-&7+#0-0%+),"0+(.5.1"+(0 +&/ +(0/.&(%0-0)",.(("4" +f5&)%"4"g + )%-0D10(&7 +6 +2"/(.(&LB + . +&/+

Y:

Page 65: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

2"%-0#(")%0'+2-.6%&6&B+2")6"1*6U+,(0/.2("+,"/(&6.L_&0+%-U3(")%&+2-&(Ua3.L% + ,")2&%.%017 + 6 + ")D$)10(&LB + -0E106)&& + , + &/(.5.1*("D+)D$)10 +x%"4" +)1",.g + �%.D+a0�B +5%"B +,"/D"a("B +)%.,&% +2"3+)"D(0(&0+6"--06%(")%* + 3010(&7 + 203.4"4", + (. + %0"-0%&6", + & + 2-.6%&6",A + ~)1&+2-"3"1a&%* +-.))Ua30(&7 +ZA+jA+N"1*(",.B + %" +D"a(" +U%,0-a3.%*B +5%"+-05* + 3"1a(. + &3%& + " + 203.4"40J2-"E0))&"(.10 + & + (02-"E0))&"(.10 + 9,+)D$)10 + 2-&(.310a(")%& + 6 + 2-"E0))&&<B + & + ,"3"-./301 + D0a3U + (&D&+2-"O"3&% + &D0((" + 2" +).#(." & H#$-(.( & '"H+0#"/0.7"''+0.$+ ,+"%("^0(&&+6+)"#)%,0(($D+30')%,&7D+&+2-03)%.,10(&7D+"#+"#U50(&&+&+2"+0H+0+:)&+:#(V"'$%+)"+),"&D+"2$%"DA

P0)D"%-7+(.+x%"B+f,"/(&6.L_.7+%.6&D+"#-./"D+%0"-&7+)2")"#(.+,$'%&+ /. +-.D6& +03&(&5("4" +)1U5.7 +& +"6./$,.%* + ),"0 +,"/30')%,&0 +,+2")103UL_0' + 2-.6%&60 + ,")2&%.%017B + 3.a0 + ,$2"1(7%* + , + 6.50)%,0+U50(&7+,.a(UL+/.3.5U+,+2"34"%",60+#U3U_&O+U5&%010'g+�%.D+a0�A+|%"+2-"%&,"-05&% + -.C&"(.1&)%&50)6&D + 6"(C02C&7D + (.U5("4" + /(.(&7B+2-&D0- +6"%"-"4"B + , + 5.)%(")%&B +D$+D"a0D+"#(.-Ua&%* +U +&/,0)%("4"+-"))&')6"4" + %0"-0%&6. + (.U6& + MA!A!%02&(.A + !"41.)(" + 2")103(0DUB+D0a"'B+"%3017L_0'+(.U5("0+/(.(&0+"%+"#$30(("4"B+7,170%)7+")"#$'+O.-.6%0-+f"#d06%",+-0.1*(")%&B+(0+),"3&D$O+6+"#d06%.D+"#$30(("4"+"2$%.gA + f~)1& + "#$30(("0 + 2"/(.(&0 + "%-.a.0% + %"1*6" + %0 + "#d06%$B+6"%"-$0 + , + 2-&(C&20 + D"4U% + #$%* + 2-0"#-./",.($ + , + (.1&5($O+&)%"-&50)6&+)1"a&,^&O)7+)2")"#.O+&+,&3.O+2-.6%&50)6"4"+30')%,&7B+%" +(.U6. + )2")"#(. +&/U5.%* +& + %.6&0 +E-.4D0(%$ +-0.1*(")%&B + 6"%"-$0+D"4U%+)%.%*+2-03D0%"D+"),"0(&7+%"1*6"+,+2-.6%&60+3.106"4"+#U3U_04"A+Z(. + 2")%"7((" + ,$O"3&% + /. + -.D6& + 2-03D0%($O + )%-U6%U- + (.1&5($O+,&3", + & + )2")"#", + 2-.6%&50)6"4" + "),"0(&7 + D&-. + & + "%6-$,.0%+501",050)%,U + (",$0 + 2-03D0%($0 + D&-$ + 04" + ,"/D"a("' + #U3U_0'+307%01*(")%&g+�@B+)A+:=�A+

!.D + )2")"# + "#)Ua30(&7 + MA�A!%02&($D + )20C&E&6& + (.U5("4"+/(.(&7+U6./$,.0%+(.+04"+"20-0a.L_&'+2"+"%("^0(&L+6+6"(6-0%("'+2-.6%&60+O.-.6%0-B+(.+04"+2-&"-&%0%+,+00+-./,&%&&A+!+%"56&+a0+/-0(&7+ZAjAN"1*(",.B + %.6"' + ,/4173 + (. + "%("^0(&7 + (.U6& + & + 2-.6%&6&+),"')%,0(0(+0)%0)%,0(($D+(.U6.D+&+2-&D0(&D+6+2"(&D.(&L+%0O(&6&+6.6 +2-03D0%U +&O +2-&1"a0(&7A +�UD.(&%.-("0 + /(.(&0B + )%-"7_00)7 +2"+2"3"#("DU + "#-./CUB + U%-.5&,.0% + (0 + %"1*6" + )20C&E&5(")%* + ,+"E"-D10(&& + ),"04" + 2-03D0%.B + (" + & + , + )U_0)%,0(("' + )%020(&+2-"3U6%&,(")%*+")U_0)%,170D$O+,+04"+(.2-.,10(&&+30')%,&'A+~)1&+a0+")(",("' + /.#"%"' + (.U5("4" + 203.4"4&50)6"4" + /(.(&7 + 2"1.4.0%)7+)%.(",10(&0 + 6"(6-0%("4" + 203.4"4.B + D$ + ) + (0"#O"3&D")%*L + 3"1a($+"#-._.%*)7+6+&($D+D0%"3"1"4&50)6&D+"-&0(%&-.D+&+2-&(C&2.DA

Z4-.(&50(&0 + -.C&"(.1&)%&50)6"4" + 2.E"). + 6.6 + 2-&"-&%0%. + 2-&+2")%-"0(&& + (.U5("4" + /(.(&7 + (0 + 2"/,"170% + "%(0)%& + 203.4"4&6U+N"1*(",. + 6 + %-.3&C&& + 2-"#10D("4" + "#U50(&7B + 61L50,$D + x10D0(%"D+6"%"-"' + ,$)%U2.0% + %.6a0 + 2-"#10D(.7 + )&%U.C&7B + fO.-.6%0-&/UL_.7+%.6"'+%&2+,/.&D"30')%,&7+)U#d06%.+&+"#d06%.B+2-&+6"%"-"D+U+501",06.+

Y@

Page 66: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

,"/(&6.0% + 2"%-0#(")%* + , + "%6-$%&& + (","4" + (0&/,0)%("4" + ),"')%,.B+/.6"("D0-(")%&+"#d06%.+&1&+)2")"#.+04"+2-0"#-./",.(&7A+P.+)%"-"(0+)U#d06%. + 2-"#10D(.7 + )&%U.C&7 + 2-03)%.,10(. + 04" + 2"/(.,.%01*("'+2"%-0#(")%*L+& +2"/(.,.%01*($D&+,"/D"a(")%7D&g + �YB + )A+8>�B +D0a3U+%0D+6.6+,+-./D$^10(&7O+N"1*(",.+D$+"#(.-Ua&,.0D+,(0^(0+)O"3(UL+2-"#10D"C0(%-&-",.((")%*A

M + 50D + a0 + "%1&5&0 + 3,UO + 203.4"4&50)6&O + )2")"#", + D$^10(&7�+F")%.-.0D)7+U6./.%*+(.+(04"+2-&+.(.1&/0+)103UL_04"+,$)6./$,.(&7k+f\.6&D + "#-./"DB + , + 3&3.6%&60 + ,$)^0' + ^6"1$ + (0"#O"3&D" + -0^&%*+(",UL + ,.a(UL + 2-"#10DU +)H#(7?"'$%+ 9,$3010(" + D("'+c + PA+QA<+2-"C0))"D + U),"0(&7 + /(.(&' + 6.6 + 2-"3U6%&,($D + 2-"C0))"DB+#(3#(:+.(.F+9,$3010("+D("'+c+PA+QA<+(",$0+%&2$+U50#($O+/.3.(&'+c+2-"#10D($0 + /.3.(&7B + 2-03^0)%,UL_&0 + U),"0(&L + (",$O + /(.(&' + &+"#0)205&,.L_&0+(0"#O"3&DUL+2"/(.,.%01*(UL+.6%&,(")%*+)%U30(%",+,+-./1&5($O+,&3.O+"#U50(&7k +106C&7OB+)0D&(.-.OB+2-"&/,"3)%,0(("'+2-.6%&60B + &))103",.(&7Og + �YB + )A + 8;�A + Q.6 + )103U0% + &/ + x%"' + C&%.%$+2-&,0-a0(C. + 2-"#10D("4" + "#U50(&7 + mARAR.%L^6&(.B + 2-"#10D(.7+)&%U.C&7 + ,$)%U2.0% + 7,10(&0D + "#d06%&,("' + -0.1*(")%&B + "(.+)U_0)%,U0%+,(0+307%01*(")%&+6"(6-0%("4"+501",06.B+2"D&D"+(04"+&+04"+30')%,&' + & + "#1.3.0% + ),"')%,"D + ,)0"#_(")%&A + |%" + (0 + 2-")%"+2-"#10D(.7+)&%U.C&7+317+,)0OB+x%"+2-03)6./U0D.7+9,+-.D6.O+U50#("4"+2-"C0)).<B + /.21.(&-",.((.7 + .6C&7B + 6"%"-.7 + ,$)%U2.0% + x10D0(%"D+%0O("1"4&&+9,+3.(("D+)1U5.0+c+203.4"4&50)6"'<A+

GD0((" + %0O("1"4&/.C&& + 203.4"4&6& + )"2-"%&,170%)7 + N"1*(",B + ,+x%"D+D"a0%+#$%*+"#(.-Ua0("+"4-.(&50(&0+203.4"4&50)6&O+2-.6%&6+,+&O + )2")"#(")%& + )"/3.,.%* + U)1",&7 + 317 + &(3&,&3U.1*($O+"#-./",.%01*($O+)"#$%&'+&1&+"#-./",.%01*($O+)"#$%&'+6.6+%.6",$OA+P" + , + x%"D + )1U5.0 + 2"7,10(&0 + (.U5("' + 203.4"4&50)6"' + %0"-&&+)%.(",&%)7+(0+U)1",&0DB+(0+2-033,0-&0D+)%.(",10(&7+203.4"4.B+.+04"+-0/U1*%.%"DA+M"/D"a("B+(.4173($D+2-&D0-"D+/30)*+D"a0%+,$)%U2&%*+203.4"4&6. + ).D"4" + N"1*(",.B + 6"%"-.7B + )"41.)(" + 04" + "2&).(&LB + ,"+D("4"D+"#7/.(.+),"&D+($(0^(&D+,&3"D+ ,"2-")UB+6"%"-$'+#$1+/.3.(+N"1*(",U + "3(&D + &/ + 04" + )1U^.%010'k + f{%" + (.DB + U5&%017DB + 301.%* + )+%0"-0%&50)6&D&+-.))Ua30(&7D&+,+"#1.)%&+2-.6%&6&�gB+&+)%.1.+)%"1*+31&%01*($D+)2")"#"D+"%,0%.+(.+(04"A

F03.4"4&6.+N"1*(",.+&+%-.3&C&7+2-"#10D("4"+"#U50(&7+)%.,7%+(.)+20-03 + (0-0^0(("'B + 6.6 + (.D + 6.a0%)7B + 2-"#10D"' + c + f2-"#10D(")%&g+203.4"4&50)6"4"+)"/(.(&7+&1&+203.4"4&50)6"'+2"/&C&&A

M+)1U5.0+2-"#10D("4"+"#U50(&7B+2"+6-.'(0'+D0-0B+%0O+04"+,0-)&'B+, + -.D6.O + 6"%"-$O + "E"-D10(&0 + 2-"#10D("' + )&%U.C&& + 7,170%)7+EU(6C&0'+203.4"4.+&+)")%.,170%+2-03D0%+04"+D0%"3&50)6&O+-./-.#"%"6B+"(+a0+9203.4"4<B+)",0-^.7+-73+D.(&2U17C&'+)+).D"'+)&%U.C&0'B+76"#$+"#0)205&,.0% + 2-&(7%&0 + 00 + )%U30(%.D& + 317 + 3.1*(0'^0' + -.#"%$ + ,+U50#("D+2-"C0))0A+M"/(&6.L_&0+2-&+x%"D+)1"a(")%&+2-&2&)$,.L%)7+

YY

Page 67: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

O.-.6%0-&)%&6.D + U50#("4" + D.%0-&.1. + 904" + (03")%U2(")%& + 317+)%U30(%",B + (03")%.%"5("' + /.")%-0((")%& + 2-"%&,"-05&7<B + ).D" + a0+)%U30(50)6"0+(02-"#10D.%&/&-U0D"0+&+(0).D"2-"#10D.%&/&-UL_00)7+)"/(.(&0+")%.0%)7+,(0+/"($+,(&D.(&7+203.4"4&50)6&O+-./D$^10(&'A+M"/(&6.0% + ,205.%10(&0 + 0)%0)%,0((")%& + "#(.-Ua0(&7 + & + 2-&(7%&7+2-"#10D(")%& + )&%U.C&& + , + )&1U + "2-03017L_0' + &O + 2-&-"3$+501",050)6"4"+D$^10(&7A+

Z3(.6"+-0.1*(")%*+2-"C0)).+"#U50(&7+)%.16&,.0%+(.)+)+%0DB+5%"+2-&,(0)0(($0 + &/,(0 + 2-"#10D$ + & + 2-"%&,"-05&,$0 + )&%U.C&& + %.6 + &+D"4U% + ")%.%*)7 + 2-03D0%"D + f(03"UD0(&7g + &)61L5&%01*(" + ).D"4"+203.4"4.B + 2-&,(0)^04" + &O + , + U50#(UL + )&%U.C&LA + M + "#d7)(0(&&+N"1*(",. + 2-031.4.0%)7 + 6.-3&(.1*(" + &("' + O"3k + 2-"#10D.%&/.C&7+&)O"3&%+&/+)"#)%,0(("'B+2",)03(0,("+")U_0)%,170D"'+203.4"4&50)6"'+307%01*(")%&A + M)103)%,&0 + x%"4" + 2-"#10D. + &/ + O.-.6%0-&)%&6&+D.%0-&.1.+%-.()E"-D&-U0%)7+,+O.-.6%0-&)%&6U+f"%("^0(&'g+203.4"4.+& +04" +2-"E0))&"(.1*("'+)&%U.C&&B +,0-(00B +203.4"4 +& +2-"#10D.+)U%*+03&("0B + 203.4"4 + 0)%* + 5.)%* + 2-"#10D("' + )&%U.C&&B + & + 2-"#10D. + 0)%*+5.)%*+04"+a&/(0(("'+)&%U.C&&A

M0-(0D)7 + 6 + ,"2-")U + " + f2-"#10D(")%&gB + . + )6"-00B + "+(02-"#10D(")%& + 203.4"4&50)6"4" + )"/(.(&7A + Q.6 + 2-& + /(.6"D)%,0 + )+-.#"%.D&+2"+2-"#10D("DU+"#U50(&LB+%.6+&+2-&+/(.6"D)%,0+)+%06)%"D+N"1*(",. + ,"/(&6.0% + ,205.%10(&0 + 0)%0)%,0((")%& + "#(.-Ua0(&7+2-"#10D.%&5(")%&+(.1&5($O+"#)%"7%01*)%,+203.4"4"DA+!%"16(",0(&0+)+(0-./-0^0(($D + 2-"%&,"-05&0D + 9D0a3U + (.1&50)%,UL_&D + &+(0"#O"3&D$D + /(.(&0DB + )"#)%,0(($D& + 30')%,&7D& + & + 2"1U5.0D$D&+-0/U1*%.%.D&< + ) + (0"#O"3&D")%*L + 2-&,"3&% + 6 + %"DUB + 5%" + f,(0/.2("+,"/(&6.L_&0 + %-U3(")%& + 2-&(Ua3.L% + ,")2&%.%017 + 6 + ")D$)10(&LB+-0E106)&&g+�:�B+#"100+%"4"B+).D"+,")2&%.(&0+)"30-a&%+,+),"�D+/30)*J")U_0)%,10(&& + 2"3,0-a0((")%* + f,)0,"/D"a($D + (.-U^0(&7DB+)%.,7_&D+2"3+,"2-")+04"+U)20^(")%*gB+,"/D"a(")%*+2"%0-20%*+6-.O+�%.D +a0�A + h.100 + %0D. + U)1",&'B + f,$(Ua3.L_&Og + 203.4"4. + &/D0(&%*+)0#7+&+),"L+2-.6%&6U+,")2&%.(&7B+.,%"-"D+(0+"#)Ua3.0%)7B+6.6+0)1&+#$ + ).D" + )"#"' + -./UD01")*B + 5%" + 317 + x%"4" + ,2"1(0 + 3")%.%"5("+2"7,&,^&O)7+)1"a(")%0'+&+)%-.O.+20-03+&O+2",%"-0(&0DA

M+2-"#10D("D+"#U50(&&+%0D0+D"%&,.C&&+"%,"3&%)7+)"#)%,0(("0+D0)%" + , + "#)Ua30(&&A + �30)* + D"%&,.C&7 + )%.(",&%)7 + 2-03D0%"D+3&3.6%&50)6"' + /.#"%$+& +,&3&%)7 +6.6 + xEE06% +(02-7D"4" +U2-.,10(&7+2-"C0))"D+"#U50(&7A +Q.6+-0^0(&0+2-031.4.0%)7+")"#.7+6"()%-U6C&7+2-"#10D("' + )&%U.C&&B + 6"%"-.7 + 3"1a(. + ,$/,.%* + 6 + a&/(&+2"/(.,.%01*($0 + D"%&,$ + & + )0-3C0,&("' + 6"%"-"' + 3"1a($ + )%.%*+f(.-U^0(&7 + , + %&20 + 307%01*(")%&B + 2-&,"37_&0 + 6 + (0,"/D"a(")%& + 00+,$2"1(0(&7+)1"a&,^&D&)7+)2")"#.D&+&+,$/$,.L_&0+(0"#O"3&D")%*+2"&)6. + (",$O + )2")"#", + ,$2"1(0(&7 + 307%01*(")%&g + �YB + )A + 8Y�A + Q.6+2"1.4.0%)7B + fx%& + (",$0 + %-0#",.(&7 + , + 307%01*(")%& + 2"-"a3.L%+

YI

Page 68: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

2"/(.,.%01*(UL+2"%-0#(")%*+&+,$/$,.L%+2"&)6",UL+2"/(.,.%01*(UL+.6%&,(")%*B+(.2-.,10((UL+(.+"#(.-Ua0(&0+(0&/,0)%("4"g+�%.D+a0�A

F-& + ,)0O + -./1&5&7O + , + 30%.17OB + 3,. + "#)Ua3.0D$O + 2"3O"3. + ,+203.4"4&60 + D"4U% + #$%* + 2"(7%$ + 6.6 + 40(0%&50)6& + )-"3($0B + #0-U_&0+(.5.1" + , + 03&("D + 2"(&D.(&& + 501",050)6"' + 2-&-"3$A + `05* + &30% + "+f0)%0)%,0((")%&g+)2")"#.+30')%,&7B+2")%U2.(&7+,+)1"a($O+)&%U.C&7O+& + " + 2"(&D.(&& + )U_(")%& + 501",050)6"4" + 2-03(./(.50(&7A + ~)1& + U+N"1*(",. + D$ + (.O"3&DB + 5%" + f2"4-.(&5($0 + )&%U.C&&==+

2-"%&,"2")%.,10($+1L#"'+U)2"6"0((")%&+,+4.-D"(&5("D+&+/.D6(U%"D+"#-./0+D&-.B+"(&+2"330-a&,.L%+,+501",060+,+#"3-)%,UL_0D+)")%"7(&&+%" + #0)2"6"')%,"B + 6"%"-"0 + 4"(&% + 04" + ,20-03g + �;B + )A + I>�B + %" + )"41.)("+mAPA�0"(%*0,UB + -.#"%$ + 6"%"-"4" + 10a.% + , + ")(",.(&& + 2-"#10D("4"+"#U50(&7B+&/D0(0(&7+,+2"#Ua30(&7O+501",050)6&O+30')%,&'+9D"%&,.OB+)"41.)("+%0-D&("1"4&&+�0"(%*0,.<+2"35&(7L%)7+/.6"(U+/"%."?F'+0.F&v&H+.#":'+0.F&v&/"%."?F'+0.F+�IB+)A+=>Y�B+6"%"-$'+U6./$,.0%+(.+%"B+5%"+&/D0(7L_&0)7+U)1",&7+307%01*(")%&+)+(0"#O"3&D")%*L+,106U%+/.+)"#"'+&/D0(0(&7+2"%-0#(")%("'+)E0-$B+5%"B+,+),"L+"50-03*B+,030%+6+&/D0(0(&7D+,"+,(0^(0'+307%01*(")%&B+2-&+x%"D+1&5(")%&+),"')%,0(("+)%-0D10(&0 +)"/&3.%*B +f301.%* +301" +),"0' +a&/(&B +")U_0)%,17%* +),"0+501",050)6"0+2-03(./(.50(&0g+�IB+)A+==Y�A

Z3(.6" + & + 20-,.7B + & + ,%"-.7 + 6"(C02C&7 + f(.%.16&,.L%)7g + (.+-0.1*(")%* + 2",)03(0,("' + 203.4"4&50)6"' + -.#"%$B + 6"%"-.7 + #$)%-"+2-&"#-0%.0%+-U%&(($'+O.-.6%0-A+M+O"30+00+,$2"1(0(&7+,"/(&6.L_&0+%-U3(")%& + 2")%020((" + "2"/(.L%)7 + 6.6 + 2",)03(0,($0B + 2-&,$5($0+)"#$%&7B+6"%"-$0+(0+)%.,7%+203.4"4.+20-03+(0"#O"3&D")%*L+5%"J1&#"+D0(7%*A + P0"#O"3&D")%* + ).D"&/D0(0(&7 + D"a0% + 3.a0 + "C0(&,.%*)7+203.4"4"D + 6.6 + f2-"%&,"0)%0)%,0((")%*gA + |%" + "#)%"7%01*)%,"+)%.(",&%)7+317+(.)+")(",.(&0D+317+2-"#10D.%&/.C&&+203.4"4&50)6&O+&30'+ZAjAN"1*(",.A

M%"-$D+-.6U-)"D+2-"#10D.%&/.C&&+"#)Ua3.0D$O+&30'+N"1*(",.+D"a0% + #$%* + &O + )",D0_0(&0 + ) + 6"(%06)%"D + )",-0D0(("4" + ,$)^04"+"#-./",.(&7B+6"%"-"0B+,"J20-,$OB+(.C010("+(.+D.))","0+2-"&/,"3)%,"+)20C&.1&)%", + 317 + )E0-$ + (.-"3("4" + O"/7')%,.B + )%.(3.-%&/.C&L + &+-041.D0(%.C&L+U50#($O+3")%&a0(&'B+&O+2-03/.3.((")%*B+.+,"J,%"-$OB+"-4.(&/U0%)7+2"+)O0D0+2-03^0)%,",.(&7+"#U50(&7+2-"E0))&"(.1*("'+307%01*(")%& +&1& +"#U50(&7 +6.6 +2"34"%",6& +6 +(0'A +G +D$+")%.,170D+"%6-$%$D + ,"2-") + " + %"DB + 430 + & + 317 + 6"4" + "6.a0%)7 + -010,.(%("'+203.4"4&50)6.7+.(%-"2"1"4&7+ZAjAN"1*(",.A

==+ M+6"(%06)%0+(.^04"+-.))Ua30(&7+D$+(.D0-0(("+f)(&a.0D+2.E")g+2"(&D.(&7+2"4-.(&5($O + )&%U.C&'B + ),"')%,0(($' + x6/&)%0(C&.1*("' +E&1")"E&&A + �30)* + 317+(.)+,.a($+%.6&0+&O+)U_(")%($0+50-%$B+6.6+2-&(.310a(")%*+6+1&5("DU+#$%&LB+"2-03010(&0 + "#_04" + 2"1"a0(&7 + 301B + ),"')%," + "#(.-Ua&,.%* + "4-.(&50((")%* + &+)"D(&%01*(")%*+1L#"4"+/(.(&7+&+30')%,&7B+.+%.6a0+2-&(C&2&.1*(.7+)1U5.'(")%*+&O+,"/(&6(",0(&7+�K�A

YK

Page 69: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

e18,=.8R=.w=&K+-$00(#+7(R&Q=C=+N"1*(",+ZAjA+�+\AMAQ"D&)).-",.+��+G)%"-&7+E&1")"E&&k+|(C&61"203&7A+c+R&()6B+=>>=Ax= & GT)#9+7R&>=B=+ Z%%" + j-&3-&O + N"1*(", + �mAFAZ4U-C",B + MAMAF1.%"(", + ��+fZ#-./$+"#-./",.(&7gA+�.2.3(.7+E&1")"E&7+"#-./",.(&7A+yy+,06A+c+!F#AB+=>>:Ay=&N+?F'+7R&G=z=+j&1")"E&7+x6/&)%0(C&.1&/D.k+j&1")"E&7+)U_0)%,",.(&7+�+ZAjAN"1*(",w+20-A+)+(0DA+!A|AP&6U1&(.A+c+!F#AB+8???Ao=&{fmmpf|R&}=~=+¦�zo�sz+qr�+§�u¨sv+sr+�z�+©��sz�qr¤+�� +{fmmpf|R&}=~=ª¥svn�zr+§�s«ovo��sz+qr�+§¬�u¤o¤s�k+­o�t�¬¤z+qr�+®q¯v¬t�zA+®un�zrk+XA°A±zst�+­z�«u¤B+8?KKA+WA+IIc?8A�=&!."H$'R&C=!=+\0"-0%&50)6"0+/(.(&0k+!%-U6%U-.B+&)%"-&50)6.7+x,"1LC&7+�+MA!A!%02&(A+c+RAB+=>>>A�=D(.UX1$'R&>=D= &m6%U.1*($0 + 2-"#10D$ + 2)&O"1"4&& + , + ,$)^0' + ^6"10�+mARAR.%L^6&(A+c+RAB+8?IIA�= & P"+'.F"7R&>&6= &G/#-.(($0 + 2)&O"1"4&50)6&0 + 2-"&/,030(&7 + �+mAPA�0"(%*0,A+c+RAB+8?K;A�= & N+?F'+7R&G=z=+ P",.7 + U6-$%")%*A + F-"#10D. + 2-0"3"10(&7+x6/&)%0(C&.1&/D.A +M,030(&0 + � +ZAjAN"1*(", + �� +j&1")"E)6.7 +D$)1*A + =>>8A+H+=A+!A+8;IJ8:@A

h2>3.7.8,?<3.C$6.G2682C8,?<3268<$RB.J1W6C/./$@=,-@264?/.$1$=,>R?<8.8$2;=.>27.8,?<34W$62;4815

L=M=C(?""7

`U#0a + %$)75010%&' + "/(.D0(",.1)7 + )%.(",10(&0D + (",$O+203.4"4&50)6&O+6"(C02C&'B+"#&1&0+&+-./(""#-./&0+6"%"-$O+/.)%.,17L%+)"D(0,.%*)7 + , + ,"/D"a(")%& + "2-03010(&7 + 317 + (&O + "#_&O+2.-.3&4D.%&50)6&O + ")(",.(&'A + R$ + 2-031"a&D + ),"' + ,.-&.(%+2"(&D.(&7 + (","' + 203.4"4&50)6"' + 2.-.3&4D$B + )")%"7_0' + ,+E"-D&-",.(&& + U + U5._&O)7 + 6"D2106)("4" + 6.50)%,. + 2"/(.,.%01*("'+).D")%"7%01*(")%&+9F!<B+,+20-,UL+"50-03*+c+2U%�D+2-03")%.,10(&7+&D+)""%,0%)%,UL_04"+)%.%U).A

�. + 2")103(&0 + ;> + 10% + 2-"#10D.%&60 + E"-D&-",.(&7+2"/(.,.%01*("' + ).D")%"7%01*(")%& + (. + 2")%)",0%)6"D + 2-")%-.()%,0+2"),7_0("+#"100+@>+3&))0-%.C&"(($O+&))103",.(&'A+M+#"1*^&()%,0+)1U5.0,+-05*+&3�%+"+E"-D&-",.(&&+6"D2106)("4"+6.50)%,.+1&5(")%&B+&(%04-&-UL_04" + D"%&,.C&"((ULB + ,"10,UL + & + 6"4(&%&,(UL + )E0-U+2)&O&6&B+4"%",(")%*+1&5(")%&+6+2"/(.(&LA+F!+2-032"1.4.0%+(0+%"1*6"+xEE06%&,(UL + 2"/(.,.%01*(UL + 307%01*(")%* + , + "#$5("D + )D$)10B + ,+D.%0-&.1*("D + 2-03D0%("D + 2"10B + (" + & + 2"/(.(&0 + )0#7B + D&-.B + ),"04"+D0)%.+,+(�DA+

m(.1&/&-U7+-.#"%U+MAMA�U/00,.+98<B+D$+2-&^1&+6+,$,"3UB+5%"+"(+,+"%1&5&0+"% +-.)2-")%-.(�(("4"+2"(&D.(&7 +B!&1(1&9"?$+ & +-0/U1*%.%.+

Y?

Page 70: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

"#-./",.(&7 + %.6a0 + &(%0-2-0%&-U0% +B! & 1(1 & 0#"/0.7+B + )2")"#+3")%&a0(&7+C01&B+6.6+2-03")%.,170D$'+)U#d06%.D+U50(&7+)%.%U)B+5%"+2-&#1&a.0% + (.) + 6 + /.-U#0a("' + "#-./",.%01*("' + %-.3&C&&+9(.2-.,10(&7D +skmh,�nlk��k�& mkilpnp�R& ir�fpfgfrs& mkilpnp�<A+!%.%U)+F!+2-03")%.,170% + U5._0DU)7 +H#(7++ 9, + -730 + )&%U.C&' + & ++:%3(''+0.F<+,$#"-. + "#-./",.%01*($O + .1*%0-(.%&, + 9D0)%.B + ,-0D0(&B + %0D2.B+%-.06%"-&&B + U-",(7 + %-U3(")%&B + "#d�D.B + (.2-.,10((")%& + D.%0-&.1.B+)%020(&+2"D"_&B+6""20-.C&&+&1&+6"(6U-0(C&&+)+3-U4&D&+U5._&D&)7B+,.-&.(%",+6"4(&%&,("'+6"3&-",6&+U50#("4"+6"(%0(%.B+04"+E-.4D0(%",<+&++.7".0.7"''+0.F+/.+-0/U1*%.%$+"#-./",.(&7A+

Z)"/(.(&0+&+")U_0)%,10(&0+U5._&D)7+)""%,0%)%,UL_04"+,$#"-.+D$ + -.))D.%-&,.0D +/./ $ 2;=.>27.8,?<32, $ 62;481,D+ Z3(.6" + ,+#"1*^&()%,0 + )1U5.0, + .6%$ + ,$#"-. + & + (02")-03)%,0(("' + -0.1&/.C&&+,$#-.(("'+.1*%0-(.%&,$+2-&O"3&%)7+%-.6%",.%*+1(1&+:#(3+7(."?F'8"&/"40.7$%R &6"%"-$0B + , + "%1&5&0 + "% + )"#$%&7B + (0 + ,106U%++.7".0.7"''+0.$Z+ 20-0a&,.(&7B + x6/&)%0(C&&B + xD"C&"(.1*("4"+"%61&6.B + ")D$)10(&7B + -0E106)&& + 9& + "#-./",.%01*("4" + xEE06%.B+2)&O&50)6"4"+&1&+1&5(")%("4"+(",""#-./",.(&7<A+

F03.4"4 + %.6a0 + "#1.3.0% + 2-.,"D + 9& + , + &/,0)%("' + )%020(&+"#7/.((")%*L< + 6"()%-U&-",.(&7 + "#-./",.%01*($O + .1*%0-(.%&,B+3&3.6%&50)6&O+U)1",&'B+"#U5.L_&O+)-03)%,B+203.4"4&50)6"'+)-03$A+M+),7/&+)+x%&D++:#(3+7(."?F'+"&0+:8.$"&H#"/0.(�.&$-"''+&0+,:8.$"-B+)",D0)%($D + #$%&0D + U5._04")7 + 9"#-./",$,.L_0D + )0#7 + ) + 2"D"_*L+U)1",&'B + 2"3"#-.(($O + &1& + )6"()%-U&-",.(($O + 2-02"3.,.%010D< + &+203.4"4. + 92"34"%",&,^04" + U)1",&0 + & + "C0(&,.L_04" + "#-./",.(&0+U5._04")7B+"#-./",.%01*($'+xEE06%<A+

P0)D"%-7 +(. +-.)2-")%-.(�((")%* +6"(C02C&&+F!+6.6 +-0/U1*%.%.+"#-./",.(&7 + & + %-&,&.1*(")%* + 2-&/$,. + "#0)2050(&7 + , + U50#("JH+3'(7(."?F'+4+ 307%01*(")%& + &D0((" + 2")103(0' + 9,$3010(("'+6U-)&,"D< + O.-.6%0-&)%&6&B + , + 203.4"4&50)6&O + &))103",.(&7O + & + %0D+#"100 + , + 2-.6%&60 + (0 + ,)043. + "C0(&,.0%)7 + & + -0.1&/U0%)7++:#(3+7(."?F'+" & H+3'('$"A + NU6,.1*("0 + 2"(&D.(&0 + 2")103(04"+)1",")"50%.(&7 + "%-.a.0% + 04" + )U%*k + 2"/(.(&0 + &/D0(70%B ++:#(3)".&H+3'(UV"T+&0):]"1.(A

F"2$%.0D)7+")U_0)%,&%*+2"&)6+&)O"3($O+(.U5($O+"#")(",.(&'+6"(C02C&& + F!A + \-0#",.(&0 + "#0)2050(&7 + )U#d06%(")%& + U5._&O)7B+10a._00 + , + ")(",0 + 6"(C02C&& + F!B + "#")(",.(" + E&1")"E&0'+x6/&)%0(C&.1&/D.B + )"41.)(" + 6"%"-"' +0)V"0.7+7('$" & *"?+7"1(&H#"/X"0.7)".&"T+&0)V'+0.$k+1&5(")%*+),"#"3(.+&+),"&D&+2")%U26.D&+).D. + )"/3.�%B + "#-./U0% + )0#7w + #$%&0 + 501",06. + )")%"&% + , + )&%U.C&7O+),"#"3("4" + ,$#"-.B + 04" + fig + &D& + 6"()%&%U&-U0%)7 + & + -0.1&/U0%)7A+Q1L50,$0 + &30& + & + 2"(7%&7 + x6/&)%0(C&.1&/D. + 7,(" + )"2-7a0($ + )+%0-D&("1"4&0' + 203.4"4&6& + 93.a0 + 2-0a(0' + 0� + 2.-.3&4D$<k+f).D"2-"06%&-",.(&0g + "%)$1.0% + (.) + 6 + f).D""#-./",.(&Lgw+f2"4-.(&5(.7+)&%U.C&7g+20-061&6.0%)7+)D$)1",$D+2"10D+)+2"(7%&7D&+

I>

Page 71: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

f203.4"4&50)6"' + )&%U.C&&gB + f"#-./",.%01*("4" + )"#$%&7gw+2-031"a0(($' +Z%%" + N"1*(",$D + , + 6.50)%,0 +E"-D$ + 203.4"4&50)6"4"+,1&7(&7 + E0("D0( + f,)%-05&g + 9²z¤z¤rqr¤<B + ,(0/.2("4"B + E.%.1*("4"+)"#$%&7B+)1",("+D"1(&7B+2"-.a.L_.7+501",06.+3"+")(",.(&'+9=B+)A@?<+/.)%.,170% + ")D$)1&%* + -.)2-")%-.(�(($' + E0("D0( + f(0J,)%-05&g + 9,+OU3"a0)%,0(("' + %-.6%",60 + yU1&" + Q"-%.).-.< + 6.6 + U2U_0(($OB+(0-0.1&/",.(($O+203.4"4&6"'+f%"506+#&EU-6.C&&gA+

\0-D&(+f"#-./",.(&0g +%-.6%U0%)7 +, +x6/&)%0(C&.1*("D+3&)6U-)0+6.6 + f"#-./",.(&0 + figA + `./,&,.7 + &30& + yAJ�A�.3.D0-.B + MAmAM"/5&6",+6"()%.%&-U0%k+f%"B+5%"+&/(.5.1*("+)U_0)%,U0%+1&^*+6.6+,"/D"a(")%*B+, + O"30 + "#-./",.%01*("4" + 2-"C0)). + 2-"7,170%)7 + "#-./"D + 501",06.B+fU%"5(0(($Dg + 203.4"4&50)6&D + %,"-50)%,"DA + Z#-./",.(&0+-./,0-%$,.0%)7 + 6.6 + f2"3d0D + 6 + ,)0"#_0DUgB + 6.6 + f)20C&E&50)6&'+501",050)6&' + )2")"# + 2-0"#-./",.(&7 + 2-&-"3($O + /.3.%6", + &+,"/D"a(")%0'g9;B+)A8@<A+

P.2-.,10((")%* + ,")2&%.(&7 + (. + 2-"#Ua30(&0 + E&1")"E)6"'+-0E106)&&+2-&,01.+6+%"DUB+5%"+).D$0+-./($0+D$)1&%01&+#$1&+)61"(($+.#(1.+7(.F&H"/(T+T$1)&1(1&H#$1?(/')U&^$?+0+^$Uk+6-"D0+&/,0)%($O+,$)6./$,.(&' + !AGA�0))0(. + & + FAFAP.%"-2. + 92")103(&' + &)2"1*/",.1+%0-D&( + f6"(6-0%(.7 + E&1")"E&7g<B + -"3)%,0((")%* + (.U6 + "%D0%&1 + &+haAh*L&k + fE&1")"E&L + D"a(" + "2-0301&%* + 6.6 + "#_UL + %0"-&L+,")2&%.(&7gA + F"2$%6& + a0 + -.))D.%-&,.%* + 203.4"4&6U + , + "%-$,0 + "%+E&1")"E&& + MAMAQ-.0,)6&' + )2-.,031&," + -.)C0(&,.1 + 6.6 + )103)%,&0+2"/&%&,&/D.B + "3(",-0D0((" + "%D05.7 + "2.)(")%* + 3-U4"' + 6-.'(")%& + c+f2)&O"1"4&/D.gB +, +)""%,0%)%,&&+)+6"%"-$D+f2)&O"1"4&7+"%(")&%)7+6+203.4"4&60 + 6.6 + %0"-&7 + 6 + 2-.6%&60B + "(. + f(.2-.,170% + & + "),0_.0%g+203.4"4&50)6UL + 2-.6%&6UB + )1Ua&% + 00 + 03&()%,0(($D + (.U5($D+")(",.(&0Dg+9:B+)AKB+;@J;Y<A

Z)"#0((")%& + )&)%0D$ + "#-./",.(&7 + U#0a3.L% + (.) + , + %"DB + 5%"+203.4"4&50)6.7 +(.U6. +2"5U,)%,",.1. + 9-.)C0(&,.0%< + )0#7 + )1U4"' +3,UO+4")2"3B + E&1")"E&& + & + 2)&O"1"4&&B + & + 2$%.0%)7 + U4"3&%* + &D + "#"&DA+M$O"3B + ,"/D"a("B + 6.6 + -./ + , + &O + 2-&D&-0(&& + 2U%�D +H#(1.$*"01+4&-0.1&/.C&&+%0"-0%&50)6&O+2"1"a0(&'+&+"3("'B+&+,%"-"'+(.U6&A+�L#.7+3-U4.7 + ),7/* + 2)&O"1"4&& + & + E&1")"E&& + (0&/#0a(" + (")&%+."+#".$*"01$4+ O.-.6%0-k + 2-&,03�(($0 + &30& + x6/&)%0(C&.1&/D. + "+#$%&&+501",06. +03,.+1& +D"4U%+#$%* +2"3,0-4(U%$+2)&O"1"4&50)6"DU+x6)20-&D0(%U+c+317+2)&O"1"4&&+f-./,&%&0+1&5(")%&+6.6+C01")%(")%&+³+D0(00 + &/U50(($' +& + 2"(7%($' +E0("D0(B + 50D + -./,&%&0 + 1L#"' + 00+.%-&#U%&,("'+)E0-$+&1&+O.-.6%0-&)%&6&g+9@B+)A8I<A+

R$ +2"1.4.0DB + 5%" ++:+0'+7('$" & +:#(3+7(."?F'+4 &H(#(/$T-8 &'"&%7?%".0% & H#"#+T(.$7+4 & H0$2+?+T$$B + 2")6"1*6U + 6"(C02C&7 + F! + 9&+2"(7%&0 + f)U#d06%(")%&g + 6.6 + 0� + 6"D2"(0(%.< + .2011&-U0% + 6 + )D$)1U+501",050)6"4"+#$%&7B+(0+,O"37_04"+,+2-03D0%+2)&O"1"4&50)6"'+(.U6&A+N0/U)1",("B+2")103(77+2-&/(.�%+)&)%0D(")%*+501",050)6"'+2)&O&6&+&+3&.106%&50)6UL+,/.&D"),7/*+0�+)E0-+&+EU(6C&'k+2"+�A!AM$4"%)6"DUB+

I8

Page 72: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

2)&O"1"4&7 +3"1a(. +&)O"3&%* +&/ + 03&()%,. +&(%01106%. +& + .EE06%. + 9YB+)A=>J=8<w + 2" +mAPA + �0"(%*0,UB + 03&($B + & + 2-& + x%"D + (0 + %"a30)%,0(($B+2)&O&6. + & + 307%01*(")%* + 9I<w + 2" + mAMAN-U^1&()6"DUB + f, + 2)&O&60+501",06. + (0% + (&504"B + 5%" + #$1" + #$ + %"1*6" + 2-&-"3($DB + (" + (0+)"C&.1*($D + &1& + %"1*6" + )"C&.1*($DB + (" + (0 + 2-&-"3($Dg + 9KB + )A8=<A+MD0)%0 + ) + %0DB + 2)&O"1"4&7 + ,$(Ua30(" + (.C010(. + (. + .(.1&%&50)6UL+306"D2"/&C&L + 501",050)6"' +H0$2$1$B + , + %" + ,-0D7 + 6.6 +E&1")"E)6&'+D0%"3+)61"(70%)7+6+%"DUB+5%"+f?$*'+0.F+)103U0%+-.))D.%-&,.%*+(0+6.6+)&)%0DUB + "-4.(&/",.((UL + &/ + x10D0(%.-($O + )")%.,17L_&OB + . + 6.6+03&("0+C01"0B +6.6+U(&,0-)UDB +(&6"&D+"#-./"D+(0+-./1.4.L_&')7+(.+2-")%$0+5.)%&C$g+9?B+)A8Y><A

Q"(C02C&7+F!+&+%-0#",.(&0+)U#d06%(")%&+U5._&O)7+"#")(",.("+,+20-,UL + "50-03* + E&1")"E&0'k + 2"(&D.(&0D + 2"/(.(&7 + 6.6+).D"%-.()E"-D.C&&B + ).D"30%0-D&(.C&& +2"/(.L_04"A +|%" +")(",.(&0+(0 + 2"310a&% + x6)20-&D0(%.1*("' + (.U5("' + ,0-&E&6.C&&B + (")&%+.6)&"D.%&50)6&'+&+6"(C02%U.1*($'+O.-.6%0-A+MD0)%0+)+%0DB+6"(C02C&7+F! + &D00% + %.6a0 + 2)&O"1"4&50)6"0 + & + )"C&"1"4&50)6"0 + "#")(",.(&7A+m(.1&/&-U7+)20C&E&6U+&(E"-D.C&"(("'+C&,&1&/.C&&B+&))103",.%01&+.6C0(%&-UL% + x6)2"(0(C&.1*($' + -")% + "#d�D", + &(E"-D.C&&B + 0�+#$)%-"0 + U)%.-0,.(&0B + &/D0(0(&0B + x,"1LC&LA + \.6&0 + O.-.6%0-&)%&6&+)",-0D0(("4" + x%.2. + -./,&%&7 + 501",050)%,.B + 6.6 + + f6"4(&%&,("0+"#_0)%,"g + 98>B + )A=?J@><B + f(0"6"4(&%&,(.7 + -0,"1LC&7g + 988B + );I<+2"35�-6&,.L% + /(.50(&0 + 317 + &(3&,&3. + 4"%",(")%& + 6 + 2"/(.(&LB + 6+"#-.#"%60+&(E"-D.C&&A

m(.1&/&-U7 + 4"%",(")%* + 6 + 20-D.(0(%("DU + 2"/(.(&L + &+"#-./",.(&LB + &))103",.%01& + "%D05.L%k + fD"a(" + )E"-DU1&-",.%*+41.,($0 + 6.50)%,. + 501",06. + ��V + ,06. + c + UD0(&0 + )%-"&%* + ),"L+"#-./",.%01*(UL+%-.06%"-&L+&+E"-D&-",.%*+(.,$6&+).D""#-./",.(&7A+!103",.%01*("B + %.6&0 + 6.50)%,. + ,$2U)6(&6", + "#_0"#-./",.%01*("'+)-03(0' + ^6"1$B + 6.6 + UD0(&0 + "20-&-",.%* + &(E"-D.C&0' + &+).D")%"7%01*(" + "-4.(&/",$,.%* + 2"/(.,.%01*(UL + 307%01*(")%*+)%.(",7%)7+"2-03017L_&D&g+98=B+)A;<A+

|%&+6.50)%,.+,")%-0#",.($+(0+%"1*6"+1&5(")%*LB+("+&+"#_0)%,"DA+R$+)"41.)&D)7+)"+)20C&.1&)%.D&B+5%"+317+&(3U)%-&.1*("4"+"#_0)%,.+41.,($D + 2-"%&,"-05&0D + 203.4"4&50)6"4" + 2-"C0)). + ,$)%U2.1"+2-"%&,"-05&0 + D0a3U + %-0#",.(&7D& + 1&5(")%& + & + ,$3,&4.0D$D&+"E&C&.1*("' + )&)%0D"' + "#-./",.(&7 + %-0#",.(&7D& + "#_0)%,.B+"#U)1",10(($D& + 2.-.3&4D"' + D.(&2U17%&,("4" + U2-.,10(&7A+!&(0-40%&50)6&'+3&)6U-)+2"/,"170%+-.)C0(&,.%*+(.D+D.(&2U17%&,("0+U2-.,10(&0B + , + %"D +5&)10 +203.4"4&50)6"0B + 6.6 +D.6)&D.1*(" +2-")%"0B+x6"("D("0B+.+317+)&)%0D+(.+(.5.1*($O+x%.2.O+&O+)%.(",10(&7+6+%"DU+a0 + (.&#"100 + xEE06%&,("0A + Z3(.6" + &(E"-D.C&"(("0 + "#_0)%,"+f4"-./3"+,+#"1*^0'+)%020(&+/.&(%0-0)",.("+,+%"DB+5%"#$+04"+4-.a3.(0+#$1&+)2")"#($+).D")%"7%01*("B+.6%&,("+30')%,",.%*g+98;B+)A+8;<A

I=

Page 73: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

!"C&UD + &(E"-D.C&"(("' + C&,&1&/.C&& + /.&(%0-0)",.( + , + %"DB+5%"#$ + ,.a(0'^0' + C01*L + )",-0D0(("4" + "#-./",.(&7 + ,$)%U2.1"+-./,&%&0 + F! + & + ,.a(0'^0' + 04" + )")%.,17L_0' + c + D$^10(&7+9).D")%"7%01*("4"B + 6-&%&50)6"4"B + %0"-0%&50)6"4"B + (.U5("4"B+3&)6U-)&,("4"B + 3&,0-40(%("4"B + 6-0.%&,("4"B + 04" + )2")"#",B + 2-&�D",+ztn<A + N"100 + %"4"B + &(E"-D.C&"(("0 + "#_0)%," + D"a0% + #$%*+/.&(%0-0)",.(" + , + F! + & + "#-./",.%01*($O + )"#$%&7O + , + ),7/& + )"+)103UL_&D&+,$,"3.D&A+

!",-0D0(($0+&))103",.%01&+6"()%.%&-UL%k+f)04"3(7+&(E"-D.C&7+Ua0 + D$)1&%)7 + 6.6 + ,.a(0'^.7 + )U#)%.(C&7B + &1& + )-03.B + 2&%.L_.7+&))103",.%010'B +1+.+#(%&$-$&W"&$ &0+3/(".0%g+98:B +)A=Y<A +F"3"#("0+2"(&D.(&0+&(E"-D.C&&+#1&/6"+6+,$)6./$,.(&L+�AFA´03-",&C6"4"+"+1)?F.)#"R & 1+.+#(% & 0+3/(�.0%R & 57+3'$1(". & 7').#$ & H"/(T+T$*"01$2&

0$.)(9$4+ , + -0/U1*%.%0 + 2-"#10D.%&/.C&& + & + )",D0)%("4" + -0^0(&7+2-"#10D+U5&%010D+&+U50(&6"Dg+98@B+)+;>J;8<A+

B"/(T+T$*"01+" & 0+:8.$" & +:#(3+787(". & '" & .+?F1+ & 1)?F.)#)&

0):]"1.(R&'+&$&1)?F.)#)R&$'^+#-(9$U&7&+:]"1.$7'+-&0-80?"B+O"%*+&+(0+,)043.+6.6+f)","6U2(")%*+D.%0-&.1*($O+%06)%",gA

F-"&/,"37+&)%"-&50)6&'+.(.1&/+C010'+"#-./",.(&7B+)20C&.1&)%$+2-&O"37%+6+,$,"3Uk+f2-"C0))+E"-D&-",.(&7+/(.(&'B+UD0(&'+&+(.,$6",+9%A(A+�lP$<+3")%.%"5("+3"14"+#$1+"#d06%"D+D("4&O+3&3.6%&50)6&O+&+D0%"3&50)6&O +&))103",.(&'B +5%" +)%.1" +6-U2(0'^&D+2-")50%"D+,)0'+"%050)%,0(("' + 203.4"4&6&A + m + %020-* + D$ + 4","-&D + " + (0"#O"3&D")%&+203.4"4&6&B + (.2-.,10(("' + (. +#(37$.$" & ?$*'+0.$+ -0#0(6.B + 5%"+)U_0)%,0((" + D0(70% + (0 + %"1*6" + (.2-.,10((")%* + & + )"30-a.(&0+203.4"4&50)6&O+&))103",.(&'B +("+&+,)L+"#-./",.%01*(UL+2-.6%&6Ug+98YB+)A=@<A+P0+,+2"1("'+D0-0+)"41.)&D)7+)+x%&D+,$)6./$,.(&0Dk+,03*+/(.(&7+&+UD0(&7+7,17L%)7+)")%.,17L_&D& +1&5(")%&A +F"1.4.0DB +5%"+"^&#"5($D + #$1" + 2"(&D.(&0 + 2-"C0)). + &O + E"-D&-",.(&7 + 6.6+1)-)?%.$7'+4 & H"#"/(*$+ 4"%","4" + ,(0^(04" + "#d06%. + 96.6 + &("43.+%-.6%",.1& + &(%0-&"-&/.C&L< + c + E"-D&-",.(&0 + "#7/.%01*("+2-032"1.4.0%+,(U%-0((00+-./,&%&0+9#0/U)1",("B+,"+,(0^(&O+U)1",&7O<A+!",-0D0(($0+E"-DU1&-",6&+6"D20%0(%(")%("4"+2"3O"3.+(0+2"/,"17L%+%-.6%",.%*+E"-D&-",.(&0+6"D20%0(C&'+6.6+U),"0(&0+4"%","4"+"#-./C.B+%.6a0 + 2-03")%0-04.0% + "% + 2"3"#("' + "^&#6& + 6"(C02C&7 + F! + &+%-0#",.(&0+)U#d06%(")%&+U5._&O)7A

M +-./,&%&0 +,$)6./.(("' +&30&B + .,%"-$+6"4(&%&,($O +%0O("1"4&'+"#U50(&7 +2-","37% +2.-.1101* +6UDU17%&,("'+D"301&+-./,&%&7 +(.U6&B+),"3&D"4" + 6 + 2-")%"DU + (.6"210(&L + E.6%", + ) + )U_0)%,",.,^&D+2"(&D.(&0D + "#-./",.(&7 + 6.6 + 20-03.5& + 4"%","4" + #.4.a. + /(.(&'B+2"35�-6&,.7k + fx6)%0()&,($' + 2U%* + #0)20-)206%&,0( + , + x2"OU+&(E"-D.C&"(("4" + #UD.AAA + (0"#O"3&D" + 2-&(7%* + 4("/"40(0%&50)6&'+/.6"(k + U50#("0 + 2"/(.(&0 + 501",06. + 2",%"-70% + (.U5("0 + 2"/(.(&0+501",050)%,.g+98I<A

I;

Page 74: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

P.U5("0+2"/(.(&0+2"-.a.0%+D("a0)%,0((")%*L+&+-./(""#-./&0D+)U#d06%&,($O + 6.-%&( + D&-.A + M + ),7/& + ) + x%&D + ")(","2"1"a(&6+)%"O.)%&50)6"' +%0O("1"4&& +MAMA�U/00, +2-"4("/&-U0%k +fD&- +)%"&% +(.+2"-"40 + "),"0(&7 + (","' + "#-./",.%01*("' + 2.-.3&4D$ + c + 41"#.1*("4"+DU1*%&6U1*%U-("4" +"#-./",.(&7A +l50(&6 +&D00% +2"1("0+2-.," +,&30%*+D&- + ,$2U61"B + 2"(&D.%* + ")(",($0 + )%"-"($ + #$%&7B + "_U_.%*+-./("4"1")&CU+,+501",050)6&O+2-03)%.,10(&7Og+98KB +)A8Y><w +f41.,("0+3&.106%&50)6"0+2-"%&,"-05&0+"#-./",.(&7+9(.+U-",(0+&(%0(C&&<+#$1"+/.1"a0(" + , + )&)%0DU + "#-./",.(&7 + : + )%"10%&7 + (./.3B + 6"43. + ~,-"2.+2-"^1. + #&EU-6.C&L + & + (.^1. + m-&)%"%010,)6UL + E"-D.1*("J1"4&50)6UL+)&)%0DUB+f(0+/.D0%&,g+D"_(UL+%-&.3U+%-�O+fFgk+F1.%"(.B+F1"%&(.+&+F-"61.g+98?B+)AY<A+

|%"%+,$,"3+)"50%.0%)7+)+/.61L50(&7D&+)",-0D0(("'+6"4(&%&,("'+2)&O"1"4&& + " + 6"(,0-40(%("D + 9(.C010(("D + (. + 2"&)6 + "3("4"+2-.,&1*("4" + "%,0%.< + & + 3&,0-40(%("D + %&20 + D$^10(&7 + 9)"/(.L_&D+,"/D"a(")%* + (0)6"1*6&O + &)%&( + c + 88B + )A@8=<B + . + %.6a0 + )+2-032"1"a0(&7D& + 40-D0(0,%&6& + "# + &(%U&%&,("D + & + 3&)6U-)&,("D+2"(&D.(&&A

l5&%$,.7 + &/1"a0(($0 + D(0(&7 + "# + "%(")&%01*(")%&B+)U#d06%&,(")%& + 2"/(.(&7 + & + 04" + -0/U1*%.%",B + . + %.6a0 + 31&%01*("0+&4("-&-",.(&0 + 6UDU17%&,("' + 2.-.3&4D"' + "#-./",.(&7 + -./,&%&7+)2")"#(")%0' + 501",06.B + 2-03)%.,170%)7 + (03"2U)%&D"'+2-"%&,"2"1"a(.7 + %0(30(C&7 + &4("-&-",.(&7 + /(.(&' + 9%"5(00B+3061.-.%&,("' + &(E"-D.C&&< + 6.6 + /.,03"D" + U)%.-0,.L_04" + x10D0(%.+6U1*%U-$B+(0+%-0#UL_04"+20-03.5&A+

Q"(C02C&7 + F! + 2-032"1.4.0% + )%.(",10(&0 + &(%04-.%&,("4"+6.50)%,. +?$*'+0.$ & $ & H0$2$1$B + )""%,0%)%,0(("k + E"-D&-",.(&0+^&-"6"4"+%0/.U-U).+3061.-.%&,($O+/(.(&'+&+2-"C03U-($O+UD0(&'+&+.6%U.1&/.C&LB + -./,&%&0 + xD"C&"(.1*("JD"%&,.C&"(("'B + ,"10,"'B+6"4(&%&,("' + )E0- + 2)&O&6&B + 5%" + 2-03)%.,170%)7 + (0-./-$,("'+203.4"4&50)6"' + /.3.50'A +F0-)206%&,($0 + (.2-.,10(&7 + 0� + -0^0(&7 + c+6-.%6" + "O.-.6%0-&/",.(($0 + (.D& + "#0)2050(&0 + 2"/(.,.%01*("4" + &+"#-./",.%01*("4" + O.-.6%0-. + U50#("' + 307%01*(")%&B + 2-03")%.,10(&0+U5._0DU)7 + )%.%U). + ).D")%"7%01*("4" + )U#d06%. + 2"/(.(&7B + )"/3.(&0+U)1",&'+-0.1&/.C&&+&D+"#-./",.%01*($O+)"#$%&'+317 +f+:#(3+7('$%&*"#"3&H+3'('$"gA

e18,=.8R=.w=&M)3""7&C=C=+F"/(.,.%01*(.7+).D")%"7%01*(")%*+U5._&O)7+&+-./,&%&0+"#-./",.%01*("'+%0O("1"4&&A+c+RAk+PGG+^6"1*($O+%0O("1"4&'B+=>>:A+J+8=K+)A++=A+C(2+701$4&P=E=+�.2.3("0,-"20')6.7+E&1")"E&7+,")2&%.(&7+x2"O&+F-"),0_0(&7A+c+�U4.()6k+m1*D.+D.%0-B+=>>>A+J+=?=+)A+c+)A+@?A+

I:

Page 75: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

;A+C+3*$1+7&C=>A+j&1")"E&7+"#-./",.(&7+&+D03&.6U1*%U-.+&(E"-D.C&"(("4"+"#_0)%,.A+�m,%"-0EA+3&))A+3"6AE&1A+(.U6k+>?A>>A>8+�+`"))&')6&'+4")U3.-)%,0(($'+203.4"4&50)6&'+U(J%.+&DA+mAGA+�0-C0(.A++!F#B+=>>IA+c+)A+8@:A+K#("701$4&C=CA+R0%"3"1"4&7+203.4"4&50)6"4"+&))103",.(&7k+F")"#&0+317+203.4"4.J&))103",.%017A+!.D.-.k+G/3J,"+!.D�FGB+8??:A+J+8Y@+)A+c+)A+K@A+!"#$1+7&C=C=+Z#-./",.(&0+&+1&5(")%*A+\0"-&7+&+2-.6%&6.+2-"06%&-",.(&7+203.4"4&50)6&O+)&)%0DA+c+RAk+G/3A+6"-2"-.C&7+f�"4")gB+8???A+c+=I=+)A+c+)A+8IYA+C8T+.01$4&P=!=+R$^10(&0+&+-05*+��+!"#-.(&0+)"5&(0(&'k+M+YJ%&+%A+\A+=A+F-"#10D$+"#_0'+2)&O"1"4&&+�+F"3+-03A+MAMAh.,$3",.A+c+RAk+F03.4"4&6.B+8?K=A+c@>:+)A+c+)A+=>J=8AIA+P"+'.F"7&>=6=+F)&O"1"4&7+2"/(.,.%01*("'+307%01*(")%&A+c+RAk+G/3J,"+R")6AU(J%.B+8?IKA+c+8@8+)AKA+N#)X?$'01$4&>=C=+!U#d06%k+D$^10(&0B+U50(&0B+,""#-.a0(&0k+G/#-.(($0+2)&O"1"4&50)6&0+%-U3$+�+=J0+&/3A+c+RAk+G/3J,"+R")6",)6"4"+2)&O"1"4"J)"C&.1*("4"+&()%&%U%.w+M"-"(0ak+G/3A+PFZ+RZh|QB+=>>;A+J+:>K+)A+c+)A+8=?A+J(X1+7&6=@=+`0C0(/&7+(.+6(Ak�APAQ"4.(A+�01*+&+)D$)1+a&/(&+501",06.A+RAB+R$)1*B+8?K:+��+j&1")A+(.U6&A+8?K@A+H@A+!A+8Y>A8>A+N"#X(/01$4&D=<=+M"/D"a($0+(.2-.,10(&7+&(%04-.C&&+"#-./",.%01*($O+&+&(E"-D.C&"(("J6"DDU(&6.%&,($O+%0O("1"4&'+��F03.4"4&50)6&0+%0O("1"4&&k+=>>YA+H+8AJ+)A=?J@>A88A+!+?0+&L=+Q"4(&%&,(.7+2)&O"1"4&7A+J+!F#Ak+F&%0-B+=>>YA+c+@K?+)A+c+)A+;I8=A+�+?+.(41+&D=P=+`./,&%&0+2"/(.,.%01*("'+).D")%"7%01*(")%&+)-03)%,.D&+&(E"-D.C&"(($O+%0O("1"4&'+(.+U-"6.O+&(E"-D.%&6&k+m,%"-0EA+3&)A++6.(3A+203A+(.U6k+8;A>>A>=A+�M1.3&,")%"6B+=>>@A+c+)A+;A8;A+P",$0+203.4"4&50)6&0+&+&(E"-D.C&"(($0+%0O("1"4&&+,+)&)%0D0+"#-./",.(&7k+l50#A+2")"#&0+317+)%U3A+203A+,U/",+&+)&)%0D$+2",$^A+6,.1&EA+203A+6.3-",+�+~A!AF"1.%B+RASANUO.-6&(.B+RAMAR"&)00,.B+mA~AF0%-",w+F"3+-03A~A!AF"1.%A+c+RAk+G/3AC0(%-+fm6.30D&7gB+=>>@A+=I=+)A+c+)A+8;A8:A+�U-",.+~AmAB+R&-7)",+mAMA+M"/D"a(")%&+&+-0.1&&+)",-0D0(("'+x2"O&A+Q+,"2-")U+.(.1&/.+&(E"-D.C&"(("'+C&,&1&/.C&&+��M0)%(&6+R")6",)6"4"+203.4"4&50)6"4"+U(&,0-)&%0%.A+!0-&7+&(E"-D.%&6.+&+&(E"-D.%&/.C&7+"#-./",.(&7Ac+=>>:A+H+=+9;<+c+=YA8@A+C&%A+2"k+N+#8.1+&6=D=+M+2-")%-.()%,0+,")2&%.%01*("'+307%01*(")%&A+c+M"14"4-.3k+F0-0D0(.B+=>>8A+c+8K8+)A+c+)A+;>J;88YA+6+7$1+7&>=D=+Q.6+-.#"%.%*+(.3+3&))0-%.C&0'k+F")"#&0+317+(.5&(.L_04"+203.4"4.+&))103",.%017A+c+RAk+G/3J,"+f|4,0)gB+8???A+c+8>:+)A+c+)A+=@8IA+@/$(.)?$'&C=!=+F-&(C&2+2-"#10D(")%&+,+6"4(&%&,("'+%0O("1"4&&+"#U50(&7+��+Z#-./",.(&0k+&))103",.("+,+D&-0+�|106%-"(A+-0)U-)�A+µAk+ospA�qB+=>>@J>=J=>B+�tt�+ +k��+ +¥¥¥+ +A++osp+ +A++�q+ +�+++8KA+M)3""7&C=C=+Z#-./",.%01*(.7+%0O("1"4&7+\Z�G!+c+-0)U-)("0+"#0)2050(&0+��+�6"1*($0+%0O("1"4&&A+=>>8A++H+8A+J+)A+8Y>A8?A+M)3""7&C=C=+Z#-./",.(&0+6.6+61L50,"'+x10D0(%+6U1*%U-("'+307%01*(")%&+4UD.(&%.-("'+)&)%0D$+��+F03.4"4&50)6&0+%0O("1"4&&A++=>>YA++H+8A+J+)A+;J==A

I@

Page 76: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

:2;4815345$@28,301.?$2;=.>.$c1>31$=,;,3/.

<=C=N+#+701(%&

Z#-./ + a&/(& + -0#�(6. + D$ + -.))D.%-&,.0D + , + 6.50)%,0 + U)1",&7+)%.(",10(&7 + 04" + 1&5(")%&A + i,177)* + &)6"((" + a&/(0(($D + 7,10(&0DB+"#-./+a&/(&+/.,03"D"+(0)�%+,+)0#0+,.a($'+#$%&'($'+2"%0(C&.1A+P"+#$%&0 + 501",06. + .2-&"-& + ,"/D"a(" + %"1*6" + , + )"J#$%&& + ) + 3-U4&D&+1L3*D&A+

M + )",-0D0(("' + (.U5("J203.4"4&50)6"' + 1&%0-.%U-0 + (0D.1"+.,%"-", + "#-._.0%)7 + 6 + )"#$%&'("DU + O.-.6%0-U + -./(""#-./($O+203.4"4&50)6&O+2-"C0))",+&+7,10(&'B+5%"#$+2"6./.%*+(.1&5&0+),7/0'+D0a3U + (&D&A + !"#$%&0 + 5._0 + ),7/$,.L% + ) + 7-6&D + 2-"&)^0)%,&0DB+/(.5&%01*($D+7,10(&0DB+04"+%.6a0+"%"a30)%,17L%+&+)+).D&D+E.6%"D+"#_0)%,0(("'+&+1&5("'+a&/(&A+M"+,%"-"D+/(.50(&&+)"#$%&0+#1&/6"+6+E&1")"E)6"DU + ")D$)10(&L + 3.(("4" + 7,10(&7 + 6.6 + 41U#&(("4"B+D0%.E&/&5("4"B + #1.4"3.-7 + 50DU + D"a(" + 2")%&5* + 04" + #$%&0A + P.)+&(%0-0)UL%+41U#&(($0+21.)%$+#$%&7+-0#�(6.B +,"/D"a(")%*+2"/(.%*B+2"(7%*+04"+a&/(*+6.6+#$%&'("0+7,10(&0B+(0")U_0)%,&D"0+#0/+3-U4&O+1L30'A + !"#$%&0 + , + x%"D + )D$)10 + 2-03)%.�% + 6.6 + )"J#$%&0B + "/(.5.0%+2-0#$,.(&0+,D0)%0+,+"3("+&+%"+a0+,-0D7A+

Q +)"J#$%&'($D+.)206%.D+, +)%.(",10(&&+501",06.+"#-._.L%)7+%.6&0 + U5�($0B + 6.6 + PARAN"-$%6"B + hAMA�-&4"-*0,B + PANAQ-$1",.B+�ARA�U/&(.B + SA!AR.(U'1",B + MAGA!1"#"35&6", + & + 3-A + F" + D(0(&L+�ARA�U/&("'B + f501",06 + c + 6.%04"-&7 + ")(",(.7 + 317 + "2-03010(&7+)%-.%04&&+&+C01&+,")2&%.(&7g+�8B+)A8@�A+�01")%($'+)"J#$%&'($'+-.(4+501",050)6"4" + )%.(",10(&7 + 2"/,"170% + (.D + "%(")&%* + "#-./ + a&/(&+-0#�(6. + 6 + 7,10(&7D + )"J#$%&'("4"B + "(%"1"4&50)6"4" + O.-.6%0-.A+{01",06B+2-"a&,.7+a&/(*+"2-0301�(($D+"#-./"DB+(.O"3&%)7+(0+2-")%"+, + #$%&&B + (" + , + )"J#$%&&A +|%. + ")"#0((")%* + 2"/,"170% + .(.1&/&-",.%*+2"(7%&0 + & + 7,10(&0 + f"#-./ + a&/(& + -0#�(6.g + , + &O + "(%"1"4&50)6"' + &+.(%-"2"1"4&50)6"'+)U_(")%&A

!%.(",10(&0 + 1&5(")%& + "2-030170%)7 + ,)0D + "#-./"D + a&/(&+501",06.B + . + (0 + %"1*6" + 307%01*(")%*LB + "#_0(&0DB + "%("^0(&0DB+2",030(&0D + & + "%301*($D& + 30')%,&7D& + , + )1U5.'($O + a&/(0(($O+)&%U.C&7OA+Z#-./+a&/(&+2")%"7(("+(.1&50)%,U0%+U+501",06.B+,$)%U2.7+"0."0.7"''8-&)0?+7$"-+2-"a&,.(&7+&+20-0a&,.(&7+&D+),"0'+a&/(&A+M+6.50)%,0+D0%"3"1"4&50)6"'+")(",$+317+203.4"4&50)6"4"+2"(&D.(&7+"#-./.+a&/(&+-0#�(6.+9501",06.<+,+6"(%06)%0+)"J#$%&'(")%&+3.(("4"+7,10(&7+D"a0%+,$)%U2.%*+)-03","'+2"3O"3+SA!AR.(U'1",.A+

IY

Page 77: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

!-03","' + 2"3O"3 + 2-03)%.,170% + )"#"' + 1"4&5("0 + -./,�-%$,.(&0+%0"-&& + ,")2&%.%01*($O + )&)%0D + �AGAP",&6","'A + M + -./,&%&& + x%"4"+2-03)%.,10(&7 + SA!AR.(U'1", + -.))D.%-&,.0% + "#-./ + a&/(& + 6.6+30')%,&%01*(")%*B+),"')%,0((UL+501",06UB+&+"2-030170%+"#-./+a&/(&+6.6 + f)2")"# + #$%&7 + , + )"J#$%&&gA + Z#-./ + a&/(& + -0#0(6. + 2-& + x%"D+2"3O"30 + -0.1*(" + 3.( + 3-U4"DU + 501",06UB + (.#1L3.0D + )" + )%"-"($B+2"(&D.0D +3-U4&D +& +&/D0(70%)7 +2"3 +,1&7(&0D +)-03$A +F-03)%.,&D +,+"#"#_�(("D + ,&30 + (06"%"-$0 + 2"1"a0(&7 + )-03","4" + 2"3O"3.B + (.+6"%"-$O + ")(",$,.0%)7 + (.^0 + ")D$)10(&0 + )"#$%&'("4" + 2"%0(C&.1.+"#-./.+a&/(&+501",06.A+

¶+Z#-./+a&/(&+7,170%)7+),7/UL_&D+/,0("D+D0a3U+1&5(")%*L+&+)-03"'A+!-03.+2")-03)%,U0%+"2-0301�(("DU+"#-./U+a&/(&+501",06.B+.+"#-./ + a&/(& + "#U)1",1&,.0% + )%.(",10(&0 + "2-0301�(($O + 6.50)%,+1&5(")%&A+Z%+%"4"B+6.6"'+"#-./+a&/(&+,03�%+501",06+,+)-030B+/.,&)&%+E"-D&-",.(&0 + 21.(&-U0D"4" + 203.4"4"D + %&2. + 1&5(")%&A + ~)1& + "#-./+a&/(& + ,")2&%.((&6. + (0 + )""%,0%)%,U0% + "#-./",.%01*($D + C017DB + %"+2"1U50(&0 + 203.4"4&50)6"4" + -0/U1*%.%. + #U30% + /.%-U3(0("A + !103U0%+U5&%$,.%*B+5%"+"3(.+)-03.+2"/,"170%+,0)%&+%"%+&1&+&("'+"#-./+a&/(&B+3-U4.7+c+2-027%)%,U0%A+

¶ + Z#-./ + a&/(&B + )U_(")%(" + 7,177)* + f)2")"#"D + #$%&7 + , + )"J#$%&&gB + "2-030170% + (.)%"7_UL +a&/(* + 501",06. + , + 04" + )-030A + \.6"0+2"(&D.(&0+2"/,"170%+203.4"4U+-.))D.%-&,.%*+1&5(")%("0+-./,&%&0+&+E"-D&-",.(&0+-0#�(6.+6.6+-0/U1*%.%+2-"a&,.(&7+&D+a&/(&+%0D+&1&+&($D+"#-./"DA+

¶+ P.#1L3.7 + /. + "#-./"D + a&/(& + -0#�(6. + 6.6 + 501",06.B+&(3&,&3UUD. + D"a(" + "C0(&%* + C010)""#-./(")%* + 203.4"4&50)6"4"+,"/30')%,&7A + {0-0/ + )U_(")%(UL + 61.))&E&6.C&L + )2")"#", + #$%&7B+-./-.#"%.((UL + SA!AR.(U'1",$DB + D"a(" + 3&.4(")%&-",.%*+xEE06%&,(")%*+"#-./",.%01*("4"+2-"C0)).B+"-4.(&/",.(("4"+,+1L#"'+203.4"4&50)6"'+E"-D0A+

F" + %0"-&& + )-03","4" + 2"3O"3.B + )-03. + )%.(",&%)7 + )-03)%,"D+-./,&%&7 + & + E"-D&-",.(&7 + 1&5(")%& + -0#�(6. + %"1*6"B + 0)1& + "(.+2")-03)%,U0%+"2-0301�(("DU+"#-./U+a&/(&+&(3&,&3UUD.+&+"2")-03U0%+-")% + 04" + 1&5(")%&A + F0-05&)10(($0 + 2"1"a0(&7 + D"4U%+),&30%01*)%,",.%* +"# +)H#(7?"'*"01$2 &7+3-+W'+0.%2+ "#-./. +a&/(&+,+6.50)%,0+U)1",&7+)%.(",10(&7+&/D0(0(&'+,+1&5(")%&A

II

Page 78: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

`.))D"%-0(&0 + "#-./. +a&/(& + 6.6 + f)2")"#. + #$%&7 + , + )"J#$%&&g+2"/,"170% + 3.%* + )U_(")%(UL + O.-.6%0-&)%&6U + "#-./. + a&/(&+&(3&,&3UUD.A + `.)^&E-",6. + "#-./. + a&/(& + 6.6 + f)"J#$%&7 + #$%&7g+)"/,U5(. + &307D + �A!AN.%&_0,.B + RARAN.O%&(. + & + RAy.'30440-.A + M+&))103",.(&7O+!A�A`U#&(^%0'(.B+MAGA!1"#"35&6",.B+PA~A´U-6","'+&+3-U4&O + .,%"-",B + (.-73U + ) + &)2"1*/",.(&0D + "(%"1"4&50)6"' + 106)&6&+f)"JgB+&D00%+D0)%"+"#-._0(&0+6+"#-./U+a&/(&A+fM+")(",0+^.4.+(.+2U%&+6 + "20-.C&"(.1&/.C&& + 2"(7%&7 + f"#-./ + a&/(&g + 10a.% + 3.(($0+2-",03�(($O + )",D0)%(" + ) + 1&(4,&)%.D& + &))103",.(&'+D"-E"1"4&50)6"' + & + )0D.(%&50)6"' + )%-U6%U-$ + 2"(7%&7 + f)"J#$%&0gA+G))103",.(&7 + 2"6./.1&B + 5%" + )"J#$%&0 + 6.6 + )2")"# + #$%&7 + &D00%+)1"a(UL+,(U%-0((LL+)%-U6%U-U +& +7,170%)7 +-"3",$D+2"(7%&0D+317+"#^&-("'+4-U22$+E0("D0(",B+"#d03&(�(($O+D"-E0D"'+f)"Jg+�=B+)AK8�A+F" +D(0(&L+SA!AR.(U'1",. +& +~APA\-04U#","' + �;�B + , +-U))6"D+7/$60+"2%&D.1*($D+,.-&.(%"D +2-.6%&50)6"4" + .(.1&/. + "#-./. +a&/(& +50-0/+)2")"#$+#$%&7+7,170%)7+2-&D0(0(&0+-73.+)1",+)+2-0E&6)"D+f)"Jg+9)"J%-U3(&50)%,"B + )"J-0,(",.(&0 + & + %A3A<A + �-.3.C&7 + )2")"#", + #$%&7 + ,+)""%,0%)%,&&+)+")(",($D&+6"D2"(0(%.D&+C0102"1.4.(&7B+6.).L_04")7+1&5(")%&+2-03)%.,10(.+,+%.#1&C0A

\.#1&C.�-.3.C&7+)2")"#",+f#$%&7+,+)"J#$%&&g+,+)""%,0%)%,&&+)+")(",($D&+6"D2"(0(%.D&+C0102"1.4.(&7+1&5(")%&+

92"+SA!A+R.(U'1",U<

IK

Page 79: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

G0'+7'8"&1+-H+'"'.8&

9"?"H+?(T('$%&?$*'+0.$

!H+0+:8&5:8.$%&7&0+,:8.$$;

Q"4(&%&,($'+6"D2"(0(%+1&5(")%& )"/0-C.(&0)")-03"%"50(&0)""%(0)0(&0)"&/D0-0(&0)"2")%.,10(&0)"D(0(&0+&+3-A

mEE06%&,($'+6"D2"(0(% )"U5.)%&0)"20-0a&,.(&0)"5U,)%,&0)")%-.3.(&0+&+3-A

I?

Page 80: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

F",030(50)6"J,"10,"'+6"D2"(0(% )"/&3.(&0)"%-U3(&50)%,")"30')%,&0)"2-"%&,10(&0)"20-(&50)%,"+&+3-A

K>

Page 81: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

!1",.B+O.-.6%0-&/UL_&0+f)2")"#$+#$%&7+,+)"J#$%&&gB+"#1.3.L%+)1"a($D+E&1")"E)6"J1&(4,&)%&50)6&D+O.-.6%0-"DB+&+#0/+")D$)10(&7+&O+2-"&)O"a30(&7+&+)0D.(%&6&+,-73+1&+D"4U%+#$%*+&)2"1*/",.($+,+203.4"4&50)6"' + 2-.6%&60A + M + 6.50)%,0 + 2-&D0-. + 2"6.a0DB + 6.6 + 2-&+"#-._0(&&+6+)1",.-($D+)%.%*7D+-U))6"4"+7/$6.+-.)6-$,.0%)7+)D$)1+%"4"+&1&+&("4"+f)2")"#.gA +!+H+0.(7?"'$"k +f)%.,&%*+,D0)%0B +-73"Dg+9MAGAh.1*<B+f)-.,(&,.7B+-.))D"%-0%*B+"#)U3&%*+)+6.6"'J(&#U3*+"#_0'+%"56&+/-0(&7g +9hAPAl^.6",<B +f317+2"1U50(&7+6.6"4"J(&#U3*+,$,"3.g+9!AGAZa04",B + PASA�,03",.<A +!+3"#9('$"+ 9MAGAh.1*<k + f,(&D.%01*("+&1&+2-"3"1a&%01*("+-.))D.%-&,.%*B+(.#1L3.%*B+)D"%-0%*+)"+)D$)1"DB+,(&6.7B+U41U#177)*+,+2-03D0%B+&/U5.7+04"B+1L#U7)*+&DgA+|%"+(0+%"1*6"+fD05%.%01*("0+).D"U41U#1�(("0+(.)%-"0(&0gB+6.6+U+hAPAl^.6",.B+&+(0+)%"1*6" + f2-"C0)) + (02")-03)%,0(("4" + ,")2-&7%&7 + 30')%,&%01*(")%&g+9!AGAZa04",+&+PASA�,03",.<A

F"350-6(�DB +D"-E0D. +f)"Jg + 9f"#_&'B +2"3"#($'B + -.,($'gB + 2"+)1",.-L+RAj.)D0-.<+c+1&(4,&)%&50)6&'+61L5+6+2"(&D.(&L+)"J#$%&7+-0#�(6.B + (0)U_&' + , + )0#0 +Y13$0."'9$(?F'84+ & +^"'+-"'+?+T$*"01$4&H+."'9$(?B + 2"/,"177 + ,)D.%-&,.%*)7B + ,)1U^&,.%*)7B + ,5U,)%,",.%*)7 + ,+a&/(*+-0#�(6.A+h17+-.)6-$%&7+0+:8.$4'+T+&H+."'9$(?(+"#-./.+a&/(&+%-0#",.1")*+2-&3.%*+0DU+(06UL+%0O("1"4&5(")%*A+`05*+&30%+"+%"DB+6.6+)"03&(&%* + x6/&)%0(C&.1*("0 + 2-03)%.,10(&0 + "# + "#-./0 + a&/(& + &+U2-.,10(50)6&' + -0)U-) + )-03","4" + 2"3O"3.A + {%"#$ + -.)6-$%* + )"J#$%&'($' + )%.%U) + "#-./. + a&/(& + & + )301.%* + 04" + "#"/-&D$D + 317+203.4"4",J2-.6%&6",B+%-0#",.1")*+U%"5(&%*+04"+%-.6%",6U+6.6+f)2")"#.+#$%&7 + , + )"J#$%&&gA + M + )-03","D + 2"3O"30 + "#-./ +a&/(& + 2-03)%.,10(+)2")"#.D&+2&%.(&7B+"#_0(&7B+307%01*(")%&B+"%("^0(&7B+2",030(&7+&+%A3A +P0)D"%-7 + (. + %"B + 5%" + 1&(4,&)%&50)6"0 + ,&30(&0 + )2")"#", + #$%&7+,$-.a.0%)7+U)%"7,^&D&)7+,+-U))6"D+7/$60+)1",.D&+)+D"-E0D"'+f)"JgB+, + 2",)03(0,("' + 203.4"4&50)6"' + 2-.6%&60 + )U_0)%,UL% + )1"a(")%&+2"3"#("4"+,")2-&7%&7+"#-./.+a&/(&A

Z2$% + 2"6./$,.0%B + 5%" + )2")"#$ + f#$%&7 + , + )"J#$%&&g + D"a("+,$7,&%*B+(.#1L3.7+/.+2",030(&0D+30%0'B+&O+307%01*(")%*LB+"#_0(&0DB+,$-.a0(&0D + "%("^0(&7 + , + -0.1*("' + a&/(&A + Z#-./ + a&/(& + -0#�(6.+2-03)%.�% + , + 6.50)%,0 + )1"a(" + )%-U6%U-&-",.(("4" +$'."T#(?F'+T+&)0?+7$%+ "#-0%0(&7 + 1&5(")%($O + 6.50)%, + #1.4"3.-7 + 03&()%,U + , + &O+)%-U6%U-0+%.6&O+x10D0(%",B+6.6k

.< + )2")"#$ + ,/.&D"30')%,&7 + 501",06. + )" + )-03"'B + ,$-.a0(($0+)1",.D&+)+D"-E0D"'+f)"Jg+9f)2")"#$+#$%&7+,+)"J#$%&&g<B+(0)U_&D&+,+)0#0 + 41U#&(($' +?$'T7$0.$*"01$4 & H+."'9$(?k + )"/0-C.(&0 + 20'/.a.B+)""#_0(&0+&(%0-0)($O+E.6%",+&+%A3Aw

#< + E"-D$ + 2",030(&7B + 307%01*(")%&B + "#_0(&7 + & + "%("^0(&'+&(3&,&3UUD.B + "#(.-Ua&,.0D$0 + )U#d06%"D + U2-.,10(&7 + , + 50-030+-./1&5($O+/.(7%&'+-0#�(6.A

K8

Page 82: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

Z#-./ + a&/(& + "2-03017L% + %"1*6" + )%.#&1*($0B + "%(")&%01*("+2")%"7(($0 + E"-D$ + 2-",030(&7 + ,-0D0(&B + %"43. + 6.6 + )1U5.'($0+2",030(50)6&0+.6%$B+O"%7+&+D"4U%+"6./$,.%*+,1&7(&0+(.+"#-./+a&/(&B+,)� +a0 +04" +(0 +O.-.6%0-&/UL%A +M+"2-0301�(("'+)%020(& +"#-./ +a&/(&+3")%U20( + 317 + )%"-"((04" + ,")2-&7%&7A + {._0 + D$ + ,&3&D + (06"%"-"0+"E"-D10(&0+a&/(&B+2"+6"%"-"DU+)U3&D+"+%"DB+50D+/.(7%+-0#�("6A+P"+"3(&O+E"-D+(03")%.%"5("+317+%"4"B+5%"#$+2"(7%*+"#-./+a&/(&+-0#0(6.+&+,$(0)%&+6.6&0J%"+)Ua30(&7+"+(�DB+317+x%"4"+(0"#O"3&D"+-./41730%*+)2")"#$B + 6"%"-$0 + 2-&,"37% + 6 + %0D + &1& + &($D + 2-0"#-./",.(&7D + ,+1&5(")%&A + h17 + (.) + 2-03)%.,170%)7 + ,.a($D + %"B + 5%" + /. + E"-D.D&+)U_0)%,",.(&7 + 501",06.B + 2-03)%.,10(($D& + , + %06)%0 + 04" + 2",030(&7B+)6-$%$ + f)2")"#$ + #$%&7 + , + )"J#$%&&gA + F")103(&0 + 2"J-./("DU+2-"7,17L%)7 + , + /.(7%&7O + 30%0'A + f!2")"#$ + #$%&7 + , + )"J#$%&&g + ,+6.50)%,0+20-0D0(($O+"#-./.+a&/(&+)"30-a.%+,.a($' +H"/(T+T$*"01$4&H+."'9$(?B +2"/,"17L_&'+203.4"4U+,(&D.%01*("+"%(")&%*)7+6+a&/(&+-0#�(6.A+

!1",.+)+D"-E0D"'+f)"Jg+,$-.a.L%+)U_(")%(UL+O.-.6%0-&)%&6U+"#-./. + a&/(&B + )6-$%UL + /. + "#"1"56"' + E"-D$B + /.,U.1&-",.((UL + "%+2",0-O(")%("4"+,/4173.A+P"+0)1&+2"2$%.%*)7+/-&D$0+E"-D$+)""%(0)%&+)" + )2")"#.D& + )U_0)%,",.(&7 + 9f)"Jg<B + %" + D"a(" + "#(.-Ua&%* + &O+)""%,0%)%,&0B + O"%7 + & + (0 + ,)043. + 7,("0A + \.6B + )",-0D0(($0 + 30%&B + ,+#"1*^&()%,0 + ),"�DB +U41U#1�((" +)")-03"%"50($+(. + %"DB +5%" +.6%&,("+2-&D.(&,.0% + 6 + )0#0 + 9%010,&/&"((.7 + 20-03.5. + ) + ,$/$,.L_&D+2",030(&0D + 0� + U5.)%(&6",B + 6"D2*L%0-($' + )0.() + ) + /.D.(&,.L_0'+&4-"' + & + %A2A<B + %"43. + 6.6 + )")-03"%"50(&0B + %-0#UL_00 + 6"(C0(%-.C&&+,(&D.(&7B + 2-"#10D.%&5("A + !"-.3",.(&0 + & + )")%-.3.(&0 + "3&(.6","+%-U3($ + 317 + 2"(&D.(&7 + 5.)%*L +^6"1*(&6",B + %"43. + 6.6 + )"&/D0-0(&0+,$4"3$+"%+%"4"+&1&+&("4"+2")%U26.+)%.(",&%)7+(0-036"+)%&DU1"D+6+30')%,&LA

M3UD5&,"0 + "%("^0(&0 + 6 + )2")"#.D + a&/(& + 30%0' + 3.�%+,"/D"a(")%* +U,&30%* +2-"#10D$+& +(0)""%,0%)%,&7 + , + 30%)6"' +a&/(&A+F-.,&1*("0 +-.)2"/(.(&0+f)2")"#",+#$%&7g+, +"2-0301�(("'+)%020(&+2"/,"170% + ,1&7%* + (. + "#-./ + a&/(& + 30%0' + 317 + %"4"B + 5%"#$ + 2"+,"/D"a(")%& + &/#0a.%* + (01&C02-&7%($O + 2")103)%,&' + , + )%.(",10(&&+6.50)%, + 1&5(")%&A + G/(.5.1*(" + D"a0% + 2"6./.%*)7B + 5%" + "#-./ + a&/(&+30%0' +"3("4" +& + %"4" +a0 + ,"/-.)%.B + 2-"a&,.L_&O +, + "3("' +& + %"' +a0+D0)%(")%&B+"3&(.6",A+Z3(.6"B+,)D.%-&,.7)*+,+)2")"#$+&+,3UD$,.7)*+,+&O +)D$)1$B +D("4"0 +D"a("+U,&30%* +&(.50A +P.D+D"a0% +6./.%*)7B +5%"+30%&+)"%-U3(&5.L%+,+&(%01106%U.1*("D+2"/(.(&&B+.+(.+).D"D+3010+"(&+)")U_0)%,UL%+6.a3$'+).D+2"+)0#0+&+(0+")"#"+D"%&,&-",.($+(.+U5�#UA+R$+2"1.4.0DB+5%"+30%&+)"U2-.,17L%B+.+(.+).D"D+3010+"(&+)"41.^.L%)7+)+U2-.,10(&0D+,/-")1$O+&+(0+")"#0(("+2-"7,17L%+&(&C&.%&,UA+{%"#$+)-03. + )2")"#)%,",.1. + )%.(",10(&L + 1&5(")%& + -0#�(6.B + 203.4"4.D+)103U0% + "-&0(%&-",.%*)7 + (0 + %"1*6" + (. + E"-DUB + (" + & + (. + 2"-73"6B+)"50%.(&0+)2")"#",+a&/(&+30%0'A

K=

Page 83: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

`0#�("6 + , + #"1*^0' + D0-0 + ,")2-&(&D.0% + )0#7 + & + ),"L + )-03U+)&(6-0%&5("A + !2")"#$ + #$%&7 + 5._0 + ,)04" + (0 + D"4U% + #$%*+2-".(.1&/&-",.($+&D+).D&DB+%.6+6.6+%-0#UL%+"C0(&,.(&7+%"4"B+6.6&D+"#-./"D+501",06+")U_0)%,170%+%0+&1&+&($0+.6%$+2",030(&7+,+)"L/0+)+3-U4&D&+1L3*D&A+P"+203.4"4B+6"%"-$'+,(&D.%01*("+"%(")&%)7+6+30%7DB+/(.0% + ")"#0((")%& + &O + 2)&O&6& + & + ),"0"#-./&0 + a&/(0(("' + )-03$+)2")"#0( + U,&30%* + x%& + )2")"#$A + \.6"' + 203.4"4 + 2"34"%",10( + 6 + %"DUB+5%"#$+/.D05.%*+f)2")"#$+,&30(&7gB+f)2")"#$+,(0)0(&7+2"-736.+,+D&-+&+,+#&"1"4&50)6&0+)")%"7(&7gB+f)2")"#$+6"()%-U&-",.(&7gB+f)2")"#$+,")2-"&/,"3)%,. + 501",050)6"4" + )U_0)%,. + , + 04" + )20C&E&60g+9RAR.D.-3.^,&1&<A

F-03)%.,10(&0+"+)%-U6%U-0+"#-./.+a&/(&+&+-./1&5($O+(L.().O+04" + ,")2-&7%&7 + 2"/,"1&1" + (.D + 6"(6-0%&/&-",.%* + 2-03)%.,10(&0 + "#+"#-./0+a&/(&+501",06.+,+203.4"4&60A+Z#-./+a&/(&+-0#�(6.+9501",06.<+"2-0301�( + 6.6 + "%(")&%01*(" + 2")%"7(($' + 2"-73"6 + 50-03",.(&7 + ,"+,-0D0(& + & + 2-")%-.()%,0 + 2",)03(0,($O + /.(7%&'B + ")U_0)%,170D$O+-./1&5($D&+f)2")"#.D&+#$%&7+,+)"J#$%&&gA+M+%.6"D+2"(&D.(&&+"(+"2-030170%)7 + 6.6 + ,.a("0 +H"/(T+T$*"01+" & )0?+7$"+ 0.('+7?"'$%&?$*'+0.$A

h17 + %"4" +5%"#$+-.)6-$%* +203.4"4&50)6UL+-"1* +"#-./. +a&/(&B+(.D&+#$1&+,$7,10($+EU(6C&&B +6"%"-$0+0DU+2-&)U_&A +l)%.(",10("B+5%" + EU(6C&"(.1*(" + "#-./ + a&/(& + 501",06. + &)2"1(70% + -"1* + 6.(.1.B+D")%.B + )"03&(7L_04" + 501",06. + & + )-03Uw + E&1*%-.B + %-.()E"-D.%"-.B+#1.4"3.-7+6"%"-"DU+501",06+2"1U5.0%+&(E"-D.C&L+&/+)-03$B+.+%.6a0+.3.2%0-.B + &/D0(7L_04" + U)1",&7 + )-03$ + 317 + 501",06.A + Z#-./ + a&/(&+-0#0(6.+,+%.6"D+)1U5.0+2-03)%.0%+6.6+")"#$D+)2")"#"D+"E"-D10(($'+),7/UL_&' + 2-"C0)) + 20-03.5& + & + 2-0"#-./",.(&7 + D("4""#-./&7+,(0^(&O+)&4(.1",B+"#0)205&,.L_&O+2-&)2")"#10(&0+501",06.+6+)-030+04"+a&/(&A+

Z#-./+a&/(&+501",06.+,$2"1(70%+)103UL_&0+EU(6C&&k+J+ 67C>1k +"#d03&(70%+)-03U+a&/(&+&(3&,&3UUD.+9-0#0(6.<+&+04"+

1&5(")%*w+J+@=,2;=.>27.31Ck+2-01"D170%+&+-.)6-$,.0%+-./1&5($0+6.50)%,.+

)-03$+&+1&5(")%&w+J+ @=16@262;?,31C9+ "#(.-Ua&,.0% + D0-U + D0a3U + 5-0/D0-("'+

/.,&)&D")%*L+-0#0(6.+"%+)-03$+&+2"1("'+),"#"3"'+"%+00+,"/30')%,&7A!+"3("'+)%"-"($B+"#-./+a&/(&+"2-030170%)7+E.6%"-.D&+)-03$B+

30%0-D&(&-UL_&D&+)%.(",10(&0+501",050)6"'+1&5(")%&B +) +3-U4"'+c+&(3&,&3U.1*($D& + ")"#0((")%7D& + 501",06.B + &(30%0-D&(&-UL_&D&+O"3 + a&/(& + , + /.,&)&D")%& + "% + 2",030(50)6&O + U)%.(","6 + &+D&-","//-0(50)6&O + 2"/&C&'A + h.(("0 + "#)%"7%01*)%," + 301.0%+C010)""#-./($D+203.4"4&50)6"0+,1&7(&0+(.+"#-./+a&/(&+&(3&,&3UUD.+,+&(%0-0).O+-./,&%&7+04"+1&5(")%&A+!-03)%,"D+%.6"4"+,1&7(&7+D"a0%+,$)%U2.%* + )-03.B + 6.6 + &()%-UD0(% + D746"4" + "2")-03",.(("4"+U2-.,10(&7A

K;

Page 84: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

ZC0(&%* + & + "2&).%* + "#-./ + a&/(& + &(3&,&3UUD. + ,"/D"a(" + (.+")(",0+2.-.D0%-&50)6&O+O.-.6%0-&)%&6B+6+6"%"-$D+"%(")7%)7k+

J + )%&10,.7 + O.-.6%0-&)%&6.+ 6.6 + �D6.7 + & + xD"C&"(.1*("J"6-.^0((.7 + "C0(6. + ),"0"#-./&7 +a&/(& + 30%0' + 9^6"1*($'B + U1&5($'B+3"D.^(&'+&+3-A<w+

J+ (.2-.,10((")%* +(. + U3",10%,"-0(&0 + 2"%-0#(")%0' + , + %"' + &1&+&("' + 2-03D0%("' + "#1.)%& + 9x)%0%&50)6"'B + 6"DDU(&6.%&,("'B+/3"-",*0)#0-04.L_0'+&+3-A<w+

J + .306,.%(")%* + 6.6 + )""%,0%)%,&0 + "#-./. + a&/(& + -0#0(6.+203.4"4&50)6&D+C017D+&+-0/U1*%.%Uw+

J + &(%0()&,(")%*+ 2-"a&,.(&7 + a&/(& + "2-03010(($D + "#-./"D+9,.a($ + %0D2B + 21"%(")%*B + (.)$_0((")%* + ,-0D0(& + "2-03010(($D&+/.(7%&7D&<w+

J + )#.1.()&-",.((")%*+ )2")"#", + #$%&7 + 6.6 + (0"#O"3&D"0 + &+3")%.%"5("0 + -.,(",0)&0 +D0a3U + )2")"#.D& + )U_0)%,",.(&7 + 501",06.B+,03U_&D&+6+203.4"4&50)6"DU+-0/U1*%.%Uw+

J+ )%.#&1*(")%*+ 9C&61&5(")%*B + 2",%"-70D")%*B + -04U17-(")%*B+U)%"'5&,")%*< + -./1&5($O + E"-D + & + )2")"#", + )U_0)%,",.(&7+&(3&,&3UUD.B+"#0)205&,.L_.7+"2-03010(($'+-&%D+a&/(&A+

N1.4"3.-7 + 3.(($D + 2.-.D0%-.D + "#-./ + a&/(& + D"a(" + )5&%.%*+3")%U2($D + 317 + 3&.4(")%&6& + & + D"301&-",.(&7A + �(.(&0 + )%-U6%U-$B+EU(6C&' + & + 2.-.D0%-", + 2-&3.�% + "#-./U + a&/(& + -0#�(6.+&()%-UD0(%.1*(UL + "2-03010((")%*A + Z#-._0(&0 + 6 + D0O.(&/DU+"2")-03",.(("4" + U2-.,10(&7 + 2-"C0)).D& + -./,&%&7 + 1&5(")%&+2"/,"1&1" + -./-.#"%.%* + )103UL_&0 + -06"D0(3.C&& + 2" + "-4.(&/.C&&+"#-./.+a&/(&+30%0'+&+,$7,10(&L+04"+)H#(7?"'*"01+T+&H+."'9$(?A+

, & B"#7+'(*(?F'+ & +H#"/"?%".0% & H"/(T+T$*"01)U & 9"?F=+ {%"#$+)E"-DU1&-",.%* + C01* + (. + U-",(0 + 1&5(")%& + -0#�(6.B + C010)""#-./("+,$7,&%*B + 5%" + 0DU + (0"#O"3&D" + 9, + 61.))0B + ^6"10B + 6-Ua60< +$-".F+ &+)-".FB+5%"#$+2-"&/"^1&+&/D0(0(&7+,+O.-.6%0-&)%&6.O+04"+1&5(")%&A+

J + G)O"37 + &/ + C01&B +H#+"1.$#)".0%+ %-0#U0D$' + 317 + "#-0%0(&7+3"1a("4"+-0/U1*%.%.++:#(3&W$3'$&)*(V$20%A+M+),7/&+)+x%&D+,.a("k

.< + "2-0301&%* + )2")"#$ +f#$%&7 + , + )"J#$%&&gB + "#U)1",1&,.L_&0B+"#-0%0(&0+(.310a._&O+6.50)%,+1&5(")%&w+-.)^&E-",$,.%*+)2")"#$+,+)""%,0%)%,&& + ) + 20-03.,.0D"' + &D& + &(E"-D.C&0' + 9-.)6-$%*+1&(4,&)%&50)6&' + 2"%0(C&.1 + 2"(&D.(&7 + 203.4"4.D& + &)2"1*/U0D$O+)1",<w

#< + "#"/(.5&%*B + , + 6.6&O + /.(7%&7O + (.&#"100 + "2%&D.1*(" + D"4U%+2-"7,&%*)7+"%"#-.(($0+)2")"#$A

,&B#+7+/$.0%&/$(T'+0.$1(+-0.1*("4"++:#(3(&W$3'$R++9"'$7(".0%&04" + "#-./",.%01*($' + 2"%0(C&.1 + 9317 + 3&.4(")%&6& + ")"#UL +C0((")%*+2-03)%.,17L%+"2&).%01*($0+,"/D"a(")%&+"#-./.+a&/(&+6.6+f)2")"#.+#$%&7+,+)"J#$%&&gB+"#(.-Ua&,.0D$0+,+)1",.O+)+D"-E0D"'+f)"Jg<A+

K:

Page 85: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

,&G9"'$7(".0%&0#"/(B+,+6"%"-"'+#U30%+2-"&)O"3&%*+6"--06%&-",6.+"#-./. + a&/(&B + 2" + 2.-.D0%-.D + ,"/D"a("4"B + ,0-"7%("4" + &+30')%,&%01*("4" + 92" +D0%"3&6.D + )-03","' + 3&.4(")%&6&<A + ~)1& + )-03.+2-027%)%,U0%+3")%&a0(&L+C01&B+. +"#-./+a&/(&B+6"%"-$'+,03U%+30%&B+2-"%&,"-05&% + a01.0D"DU + -0/U1*%.%UB + %" + 203.4"4 + (0 + )D"a0%+)E"-D&-",.%* + &1& + "#0)205&%* + -./,&%&0 + 3"1a($O + 6.50)%, + 1&5(")%&+-0#0(6.A+

P. + ")(",0 + )2-"06%&-",.(($O + 3.(($O +0.#+$.0%&0#"/++:#(3+7(."?F'(%+ H#(1.$1(+ U2-.,10(&7 + 2-"C0))"D + -./,&%&7+1&5(")%&B+"#U)1",10((.7+"#-./"D+a&/(&+30%0'B+,+6"%"-UL+,(")7%)7+2"+D0-0+(0"#O"3&D")%&+)""%,0%)%,UL_&0+&/D0(0(&7+)+2"D"_*L+)%&O&'A+M + 2-"C0))0 + "-4.(&/.C&& + "#-./. + a&/(& + U5._&O)7 + ,.a(" + U5&%$,.%*+&(3&,&3U.1*($0 + ")"#0((")%&B + &(30%0-D&(&-UL_&0 + O"3 + &O+a&/(0307%01*(")%&A

Z#-./ + a&/(& + -0#�(6. + 2-03)%.,170%)7 + 0)%0)%,0(($DB+&(%04-.1*($DB +(0"#O"3&D$D+& + , + %" +a0 + ,-0D7 + /.,&)&D$D+"% + )-03$+U)1",&0D+)%.(",10(&7+1&5(")%&+U5._04")7A+Z("+D"a0%+#$%*+3")%U2("+317+"C0(&,.(&7+,+O"30+04"+D"301&-",.(&7+&+3&.4(")%&6&B+#1.4"3.-7+(.1&5&L + )"#$%&'("4" + 2"%0(C&.1. + "#-./. + a&/(&B + (.&#"100 + 2"1("+-.)6-$,.0D"4" + , + 04" + 1&(4,&)%&50)6&O + & + U2-.,10(50)6&O+,"/D"a(")%7OA

e18,=.8R=.8A +P)3$'(R & P=D=+ j&1")"E)6"J.(%-"2"1"4&50)6&' + 2"3O"3 + , + )",-0D0(("'+D0%"3"1"4&& + ,")2&%.(&7 + � + �ARA�U/&(. + �� + !",-0D0(($0 + 4UD.(&%.-($0+2"3O"3$+,+%0"-&&+&+2-.6%&60+,")2&%.(&7k+)#A+(.U5A+)%Aw+)")%A+&+"%,A+-03A+hAMA+�-&4"-*0,B+-03A+~AGA!"6"1",.A+c+F0-D*k+G/3J,"+FZGFQ`ZB+=>>8A+c+!A+8>J=:A=A +D(')4?+7R &I=!=+ !-03","' + 2"3O"3 + , + ,")2&%.(&&A + c + =J0 + &/3AB + 20-0-.#A+�SA!AR.(U'1",A + c + RAw + PAP",4"-"3k + &/3J," + M"14"JM7%)6"' + .6.30D&&+4")U3.-)%,0(("'+)1Ua#$B+=>>=A+c+8@I)A+;A+Q#"T):+7(R&<=6=+�06)&50)6&'+-73+)+2-0E&6)"D+)"J+6.6+%0-D&("1"4&50)6.7+)&)%0D.+ ��f!-03.c)&)%0D.cU2-.,10(&0 +, +203.4"4&60gk +%0/A +3"61.3", +(.U5AJ2-.6%A+6"(EA+�`03A+SA!AR.(U'1",A+c+QU)%.(.'k+�lZB+8??:+c+!A+8?J=;A

K@

Page 86: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

=A

!"#$%&'(")%*

c+2-&(C&2+"%6-$%"'+203.4"4&6&

KY

Page 87: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

:2;481,$/./$2;=.>27.8,?<3.C$68=.8,A1C=;

I=P=Q#+$91$4

!"#$%&0+)%.(",&%)7+,0)*D.+D"3($D+2"(7%&0Dk+&D+/.(&D.L%)7+&)%"-&6&B + (.--.%"1"4&B + 1&(4,&)%$B + D.-60%"1"4&B + 2&.-_&6&B + & + ,"%+(.)%.1.+"50-03*+203.4"4&6&A +M2"1(0+,"/D"a("B +5%"+2"+)1"a&,^0')7+%-.3&C&& + &D0((" + 203.4"4&6. + )%.(0% + 2")103(&D +2-&)%.(&_0D + x%"4"+2"(7%&7A +P& + , + 6.6"' + &("' + )E0-0 + (",0'^&0 + )1",. + (0 + 2"3,0-4.L%)7+%.6"'+#$)%-"'+x-"/&&+&+/.%&-.L%)7+%.6+")(",.%01*("B+5%"+Ua0+)6"-"B+,0-"7%("B+&(E17C&7+2-0,-.%&%+0+:8.$"&+,+ +H+70"/'"7'+0.FA+F"6.+x%"4"+(0 + )1U5&1")*B + D"a(" + 6"()%.%&-",.%*k +0+:8.$" &2"2"1(70% + 5&)1"+D("4"/(.5($O+%0-D&(",B+6U3.+6.a3.7+(.U5(.7+^6"1.+&1&+(.2-.,10(&0+,2&)$,.0% + ),"0 + )"30-a.(&0A +M)0 +a0 +D"a(" + 4","-&%* + " + + (06"%"-"D+&(,.-&.(%0 + -./("5%0(&'k + )"#$%&0 + c + %"B + 5%" + 2-"%&,")%"&%+2",)03(0,(")%&B+)1U5.0%)7+3")%.%"5("+(05.)%"B+#$,.0%+(0"a&3.(($D+317+U5.)%(&6",A+

�. + 2"(&D.(&0D + )"#$%&7 + 1U5^0 + "#-.%&%*)7 + 6 + 2"x%Uk + %.DB + 430+2.)U0% + (.U5(.7 + %"5(")%*B + ,$-U5.0% + 2"x%&50)6.7 + &(%U&C&7A+ZAR.(301*^%.D + , + /.2&)("' + 6(&a60 + /.D0%&1k + fF-""#-./"D+&)%"-&50)6"4" + )"#$%&7 + c + , + 2-&-"30 + )1Ua&% + 4-"/.A +F-""#-./"D +a0+"%)U%)%,&7 + )"#$%&7 + D"a(" + )5&%.%* + 3,&a0(&0 + 5.)","' + )%-016& + 2"+C&E0-#1.%UA+N$1"+27%*+D&(U%+^0)%"4"B+)%.1"+3,.3C.%*+D&(U%A+!O0D.+&/D0(0(&7+6.6+#U3%"+0)%*B+(.+).D"D+3010+(&504"+(0+2-"&/"^1"A+Q.6+&)%"-&7 + -"3&1.)*B + %.6 + "(. + D"a0% + & + UD0-0%*w + & + 30')%,&%01*("B + 5%"+%.6"0B + 0)1& + (0 + UD&-.(&0 + &)%"-&&B + 2-& + 6"%"-"D + U10%U5&,.0%)7 + 3UO+)"#$%&7B+2-"4-0))B+30%&_0+30,7%(.3C.%"4"+,06.A+F-"4-0))+c+x%"+3,&a0J(&0+5.)","'+)%-016&B+&+2-&+,)0'+),"0'+#0))"30-a.%01*(")%&+x%"+"#_00+D0)%" +2-03)%.,170% + "4-"D(UL+"2.)(")%* +317 + ).D"4" + )U_0)%,",.(&7+&)%"-&&A + M)D"%-&D)7 + 2-&)%.1*(" + ,)103 + /. + \L%50,$DB + /(.%"6"D+4-"/","'+a&/(&B+,+-"a30(&0+4-"/$gA+F"+)1",.D+2"x%.B+)"#$%&0+c+x%"+4-"/.B+.+3,&a0(&0+5.)","'+)%-016&+c+2",)03(0,(")%*A+F-&)D"%-&D)7+6+x%"DU+2"(7%&L+, +%.6"'+2-03D0%("'+"#1.)%&+6.6+&)%"-&"4-.E&7B +430+f)"#$%&0g+c+6.%04"-&7+61L50,.7+&+"#d06%(.7A+!+C01*L+x6"("D&&+D0)%.+7 + )E"-DU1&-UL + , + %0/&)("' + E"-D0 + &)%"-&"4-.E&50)6&' + 2"3O"3 + 6+)"#$%&L + 6.6 + 6"()%-U6%UA + `./UD00%)7B + x%" + 1&^* + D"7 + ,0-)&7 + x%"4"+)La0%.A

N682=1B,6/2,$62;481,$/./$/2368=R/8

=;+ G))103",.(&0 + ,$2"1(0(" + , + -.D6.O + PG` + fZ2%&D&/.C&7 + 6"DDU(&6.%&,($O+2-"C0))", + 6.6 + 2-03D0% + D0a3&)C&21&(.-("4" + &))103",.(&7gk + 4")U3.-)%,0(($'+6"(%-.6% +>=AI:>A88A>;I>+, +-.D6.O+E030-.1*("'+C010,"'+2-"4-.DD$+fP.U5($0+&+(.U5("J203.4"4&50)6&0+6.3-$+&((",.C&"(("'+`"))&&gA

KI

Page 88: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

8A !"#$%&0+c+x%"+6"()%-U6%+&)%"-&6.B+,+")(",0+6"%"-"4"+10a&%+E.6%B + 7,17L_&')7 + -0/U1*%.%"D + E&6).C&& + E-.4D0(%.+30')%,&%01*(")%& +, +,"/D"a("+(0'%-.1*("D+,&30k +, +2-03010 +x%"+a0)%B + U6./$,.L_&' + (. + x%"% + E-.4D0(% + &1& + ("D&(.%&,("0+,$)6./$,.(&0B+)%-0D7_00)7+6+-03U6C&&+6"(("%.%&,($O+^10'E",A

=A j.6% + )%.(",&%)7 + )"#$%&0D + #1.4"3.-7 + D("a0)%,0((")%&+"2&).(&' + 92" + D0(*^0' + D0-0 + c + #"100 + 50D + "3("<A + |%" + 40(0/&)+)"#$%&7+&+(.5.1"+&)%"-&"4-.E&50)6"'+D&E"1"4&&A+

;A !"#$%&L+2-&3.0%)7+/(.50(&0+E.6%"-.B +&/D0(7L_04"+,06%"-+2-"C0))U.1*(")%&A

:A !"#$%&0 +&DD.(0(%(" +2-"%&,"-05&," +2"%"DUB + 5%" + 10a&% +(.+4-.(&C0+")U_0)%,&,^0')7+&+2"%0(C&.1*("+,"/D"a("'+&)%"-&&A

@A !"#$%&0 + "E"-D170%)7 + 6.6 +0+:8.$"+ �ovt+ ¯untqp+ & + 7,170%)7+6"(,0(C&"(.1*($D + 2-"3U6%"D + )""#_0)%,. + &)%"-&6",+9Z6%7#-*)6&' + 20-0,"-"% +�v+ M01&6.7 + Z6%7#-*)6.7+)"C&.1&)%&50)6.7+-0,"1LC&7<A

YA !"#$%&7 + D"4U% + #$%* + -.(a&-",.($ + (. + /(.5&%01*($0B + &1&+2.-.3&4D.1*($0B+&+&)%"-&50)6&0+)"#$%&7Am+ F.-.3&4D.1*($0 + )"#$%&7 + )%.(",7%)7 + x2&)%0D"1"4&50)6&D+&()%-UD0(%"D +& + 7/$6"D +"2&).(&7B + . + &("43. + & + 2-"4-.DD"' +317+)"C&.1*($O+30')%,&'+2")103UL_&O+&)%"-&50)6&O +)"#$%&'+%"4"+a0+%&2"1"4&50)6"4"+-73.+9)"#$%&7+-&D)6"'+&)%"-&&+317+307%010'+j-.(CU/)6"' + -0,"1LC&&B + )"#$%&7 + 2")103(0' + 317 + ,"a30'+Z6%7#-*)6"4"+20-0,"-"%.+,+`"))&&<Am+ M +U)1",&7O +6-&/&).+2.-.3&4D.1*($D+)"#$%&0D+D"a0% +)%.%*+-$1#+0+:8.$"&&1&+YT+0+:8.$"+9)DA+f�LC0-(g+�APA+\"1)%"4"<Am+ !U_0)%,U0% + 3,. + )2")"#. + ,2&)$,.(&7 +YT+0+:8.$% &, + D.6-"J&)%"-&Lk + 2-0C030(%($'B + 6"43. + x4")"#$%&L + 2-&3.0%)7+D0%"(&D&50)6&'+)D$)1 +& +6"43. +-0E0-0(C&.1*(.7 +)")%.,17L_.7+4&20-%-"E&-U0%)7+2"+"%("^0(&L+6+"/(.5.L_0DUA+M%"-"'+)2")"#+c + 6"43. + x4")"#$%&0 + 2-"0C&-U0%)7 + (. + )""%,0%)%,UL_&'+.-O0%&2&50)6&'+)"#$%&'($'+-73B+)%.(",7)*+04"+)")%.,("'+5.)%*LA+

IA Z3(. + &/ + ,"/D"a($O + /.3.5 + &)%"-&"4-.E&& + c + 2-0"3"10(&0+f(.--.%&,("4" + U2-"_0(&7g + , + -02-0/0(%.C&& + )"#$%&'B + . + %.6a0+"),"#"a30(&0 + "% + %"%.1*("' + %0D2"-.1*("' + 2")103",.%01*(")%&B+2"-"3&,^0' + 6.U/.1*(")%* + , + 6.50)%,0 + 3"D&(&-UL_04"+"#d7)(&%01*("4"+D0O.(&/D.+&)%"-&50)6"4"+3,&a0(&7A

KA M"/D"a($' + ,.-&.(% + %.6"4" + 2-0"3"10(&7 + c + 2-"C03U-.+-(0X.(:$#+7('$%&)"#$%&'B+6"%"-.7+/.61L5.0%)7+,+%"DB+5%"+"3("+&+%" + a0 + )"#$%&0 + 2"D0_.0%)7 + 2")103",.%01*(" + , + -./1&5($0 + 2"+D.)^%.#U + 6"(%06)%$A + F"1U50(($0 + %.6&D + "#-./"D + "2&).(&7+)")%.,17L%+&(%0-)U#d06%&,("0+2-")%-.()%,"+)"#$%&7B+,/7%"4"+,(0+6.U/.1*($O+"%("^0(&'A+M"/(&6.L_&0+2-&+%.6"D+2"3O"30+#(3#878&(02-0-$,(")%& + (.--.%&,("4" + "2&).(&7 + (0 + /.2"1(7L%)7+

KK

Page 89: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

-&%"-&50)6&D& + %"2").D& + & + ),&30%01*)%,UL% + " + 2-0"3"10(&&+&)6.a.L_04"+,"/30')%,&7+(.--.%&,("'+-02-0/0(%.C&&+)"#$%&7A

?A h-U4&D + D0O.(&/D"D + )"2-"%&,10(&7 + (.--.%&,($D + &)6.a0(&7D+D"a0% + )%.%* + )O0D. + f%-"2"1"4&50)6&O + )%-.%04&'g + "2&).(&7+)"#$%&7B+6"43.+"("+,030%)7+)+2"D"_*L+50%$-0O+%-"2"1"4&50)6&O+)%-.%04&'k + D0%"(&D&50)6"' + 9)",-0D0((&6& + )"#$%&7<B+D0%.E"-&50)6"'+9%06)%$+&(")%-.(C0,<B+)&(063"O&50)6"'+92"/&C&7+2"%"D6.<+&+&-"(&50)6"'+9)D0O",.7+2"/&C&7<A

!"41.)(" + )",-0D0(($D + (0"-&%"-&50)6&D + 2-03)%.,10(&7DB + %.6"0+"2&).(&0 + D"a0% + 2-0%0(3",.%* + (. + 2"1("%UB + (" + 2-& + x%"D + #$%*+&DD.(0(%(" +2-"%&,"-05&,$DA +M"% + 2-&D0- +&/ + .,%"-)6"' + %0O("1"4&&+&)%"-&50)6"4"+"#-./",.(&7+�6"1$+2"(&D.(&7k

:W,G.$@[email protected]$62;481C9

M0-"7%("B + 2"(&D.(&0 + )"#$%&7 + /.,&)&% + "% + 6"(%06)%.+3&3.6%&50)6"' + )&)%0D$k + 0)%* + ),"& + %&2$ + )"#$%&' + & + , + �lP",)6"D+"#U50(&&B+&+,+)&)%0D0+`./,&,.L_04"+"#-./",.(&7B+&+,+�6"10+3&.1"4.+6U1*%U-A+

M+ n/2?, $ @231G.31C $ T/2GGR31/.8173.C $ -1-./81/.U+ D$+-./UD00D + 2"3 + )"#$%&0DB + 2-0a30 + ,)04"B +1+--)'$1(.$7'+" & 0+:8.$"&U-"6.A + Q"DDU(&6.%&,(.7 + 203.4"4&6. + "-&0(%&-",.(. + (. + 2-0"3"10(&0+&)O"3("' +.,%"-&%.-(")%& +"%("^0(&7 +l5&%01*�l50(&6A +h17 + x%"4" +(.+)D0(U + U-"6UJ-&%U.1U + 3"1a0( + 2-&'%& + U-"6B + 7,17L_&')7+6"DDU(&6.%&,($D+)"#$%&0D+317+,)0O+U5.)%(&6",k+U50(&6.B+U5&%017+&+)"U50(&6.A + P. + )D0(U + &(E"-D&-",.(&L + & + U2-.,10(&L + 92-"C0))"D+U),"0(&7 + &(E"-D.C&&< + 2-&O"37% + "#_0(&0 + 9(0E"-D.1*(.7+6"DDU(&6.C&7< + & + "-4.(&/.C&7 + U5&%010D + xEE06%&,("4" + 6"(%06)%.+2"(&D.(&7A + \"B + 5%" + "#$5(" + &D0(U0%)7 +^6"1*($D& + /(.(&7D&B + 0)%*+

:E'ofNK

:E`+KpK))N# +9),&30%01*B+10%"2&)0CB+O-"(&)%<[email protected],,$62>3.31,

:pK\Mq +9^U%B+)6"D"-"OB+20-0)D0^(&6B+4.0-<k268=.3,332,$62>3.31,

N)E:f+M)Ka92U%0^0)%,0((&6B6U20CB+ 3&21"D.%B+2.1"D(&6<k+R-17?CHJ,,6C$62>3.31,

hEfEpE#9&)%"-&6B+OU3"a(&6B+^6"1*(&6<k2;SC63CHJ,,$62>3.31,

K?

Page 90: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

,)04"+1&^*+,1.30(&0+)20C&.1*($D+7/$6"D+9,)76.7+2-03D0%(.7+"#1.)%*+2"/(.(&7+%.6"'+7/$6+,$-.#.%$,.0%<A+�(.(&0+x%"4"+-"3.+2"-"'+(0+&D00%+(&504" + "#_04" + ) + 3UO",("J3U^0,($D + "2$%"D + "#U5.0D"' + 1&5(")%&A+Z%"-,.(("0 + "% + 2"(&D.(&7 + 9)D$)1""#-./",.(&7<B + "(" + ")%.0%)7+&(%01106%U.1*($D+#.11.)%"DA+

F"(&D.(&0 + 0)%* + )D$)1""#-./UL_&' + D0O.(&/D+f&(%0-&"-&/.C&&g + 9M$4"%)6&'< +c+ 20-0,"3 + (06"%"-"4" + )"30-a.(&7 + )+"#_06"DDU(&6.%&,("4"+f,(0^(04"g+7/$6.+(.+5&)%"+D0(%.1*($'+7/$6+,(U%-0((0'+-05&=:A +|%" +c+ 2-"C0))+(0+-02-"3U6%&,($'B+.+6-0.%&,($'A+M"%+2"50DU+D$+,$30170D+,+6"DDU(&6.%&,("'+3&3.6%&60+)103UL_&0+2-&"-&%0%$k• h=12=18,8 $ /2GGR31/.011 $ 3.- $ 13X2=G.01,5D $�1U#"6&D+/.#1Ua30(&0D + 7,170%)7 + -.)2-")%-.(0(("0 + 2-03)%.,10(&0B + #U3%"+U50#(.7+&(E"-D.C&7+)")%.,170%+)"30-a.(&0+U-"6.B+.+6"DDU(&6.C&7+c+ 04" + E"-DUA + l50#(.7 + &(E"-D.C&7 + , + #"1*^&()%,0 + ),"0D + (0+/.%-.4&,.0% +)E0-U +1&5("4" +"2$%. +-0#0(6.w +U),"0(&0 +&(E"-D.C&&+/30)*+2"+)U_0)%,U+"6./$,.0%)7+/.U5&,.(&0D+7/$6.+,/-")1$O+c+7/$6.+)""%,0%)%,UL_0'+"#1.)%&+(.U6&+&1&+6U1*%U-$B+.+(.+3010 +c+ 7/$6.+3.(("' + U50#("' + 3&)C&21&($A +M + x%"D + 2-"C0))0 + ,(U%-0((77 + -05*+-0#0(6.B+"E"-D17L_.7+04"+"2$%+1&5(")%("4"+2-&)U%)%,&7+,+D&-0B+2-.6%&50)6&+")%.0%)7+(0+/.%-"(U%"'A+F-&"-&%0%+6"DDU(&6.C&&+(.3+&(E"-D.C&0'+,+30')%,&%01*(")%&+0)%*+(0+5%"+&("0B+6.6+2-&"-&%0%+-./,&%&7+3.-.+-05&+(.3+2-02"3.,.(&0D+7/$6.+4"%",$OB+60DJ%"+Ua0+)E"-D&-",.(($O + 2"(7%&'A + fF-0a30 + )5&%.1&B +c+ 2&).1+�A!AM$4"%)6&'B +c+ 5%" + 6.a3$' + -0#0("6 + )2")"#0( + -./D$^17%*B+2-&,"3&%*+3","3$B+3"6./$,.%*B+&)6.%*+")(",.(&7+317+6.6"4"J(&#U3*+2"1"a0(&7A + G/ + )%"16(",0(&' + 2"3"#($O + -./D$^10(&' + -"a3.0%)7+)2"-A + P" + 301" + E.6%&50)6& + "#)%"&% + &(.50A + G))103",.(&7+2"6./$,.L%B+5%"+&/+)2"-.+-"a3.0%)7+-./D$^10(&0g=@A+

• h=12=18,8 $ @231G.31C $ 3.- $ >3.31,GD $�6"1*($0 + /(.(&7B+U-",0(*+6"%"-$O+3")%U20(+(02")-03)%,0(("DU+6"(%-"1L+&+"C0(60+)" + )%"-"($ + 3-U4"4" + 501",06.B + )U%* + (.#"- + (06"%"-$O + U),"0(($O+)"/(.(&0D + 6"(,0(C&'B + )"C&.1*($O + 3"4","-0((")%0'B+"#_0/(.5&D")%0' +c+ 6.6+2-",0-70D$O+"2$%($D+2U%0D+ 9(.2-&D0-k+)0D*L+)0D*+c+)"-"6+30,7%*<B+%.6++&+(0+,0-&E&C&-U0D$O+9(.2-&D0-k+~,40(&' + Z(04&( +c+ "#-./ + f1&^(04" + 501",06.g + ),"0' + x2"O&<A+F-",0-6. + /(.(&' + 0)%* + 2-",0-6. + -02-"3U6%&,($O + ,"/D"a(")%0'+D$^10(&7A + F"(&D.(&0 + a0 + 2-03)%.,170% + )"#"' + 20-0,"3 + )+"#_02-&(7%"4" + 7/$6. + ,(0^(0' + -05& +(. + U(&6.1*($' + 1&5(")%($'+6"3 + -05& + ,(U%-0((0'A + P02")-03)%,0(($' + 6"(%-"1* + U-",(7+

=:+!DAk+�A!AM$4"%)6&'A+R$^10(&0+&+-05*+9+41A+fR$)1*+&+)1","g<+��+A!AM$4"%)6&'A+!"#-A+)"5A+\A=A+RAB8?K=A+!DA+%.6a0k+PAGAT&(6&(A+Z+6"3",$O+20-0O"3.O+,"+,(U%-0((0'+-05&+��+PAGAT&(6&(A+i/$6+J+-05*+J+%,"-50)%,"+9G/#-.(($0+%-U3$<A+RAB+8??K=@+�A!AM$4"%)6&'A+!"#-A+)"5A+\A�A+RAB8?K;A+!A8:IA

?>

Page 91: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

2"(&D.(&7 + (0")U_0)%,&DB + /30)* + ,"/D"a0( + 1&^* + 6"),0(($'B+"2")-03",.(($' + 6"(%-"1* +c+ ,$7,10(&0 + 6-0.%&,($O + 9%,"-50)6&OB+2"-"a3.L_&O<+,"/D"a(")%0'+D$^10(&7A

• h=12=18,8$-1.?2A.$62A?.61C$3.-$-16/R661,5D $fP0)"41.)&0B+c+2&).1+N.O%&(B+c+#03("+&+(02-"3U6%&,("A+!U_0)%,0((00+-./("41.)&0w+"("B+,+)U_(")%&B+%74"%00%+6+)"41.)&LB+,+6"%"-"D+,)043.+)"O-.(70%)7+-./(")%* + & + (0)1&7((")%* + 4"1")",A + !"41.)&0 + (&6"43. + (0 + #$,.0%+D0O.(&50)6&D + &1& + 1"4&50)6&D + %"a30)%,"DB + x%" + (0 + xO"w + /. + (&D+,)043. + 2-0"3"10,.0D.7 + 3.1* + & + )#1&a0(&0 + 9(" + (0 + )1&7(&0<A + �AAA�+h&.1"4&50)6"0 + )"41.)&0 + 2" + 2-&-"30 + ),"0' + ),"#"3("A + �AAA�+F"31&(("0 + )"41.)&0 + 7,170%)7 + &300' + 9-04U17%&,("'< + & + 2")103(0'+C01*L+,)76"'+3&.1"4&5(")%&g=YA+�6"1.B + -.#"%.L_.7 + , + D"3.1*(")%& + )"41.)",.(&7 + 2"/&C&'B+

-0.#&1&%&-U0%+/(.(&0+20-03+-017%&,&/D"D+D(0(&'B+301.L_&D+&+).D+3&.1"4+E.6%&50)6&+&/#$%"5($DA+Z3(.6"+6U1*%&,&-U0D"0+/30)*+/(.(&0+c+ x%"+2"&)6","0+/(.(&0+6-0.%&,("4"+D$^10(&7+ +G)%&(.+c+"%(L3*+(0+E.(%"DB + (" + &)%&(. + f2-&)U_. + (0 + ).D"DU + #$%&LB + . + %"1*6" + #$%&L+2"/(.(("DU+& +&/-05�(("DUg=IA +F"x%"DU +&)%&(. +#$%U0%+317 +501",06.+1&^*+,"+D("a0)%,0+),"&O+,0-)&'A+!U_(")%("0+/(.(&0+c+x%"+"#1.)%*+)"41.)&7B+)E0-.+)"41.)U0D")%&+,0-)&'A

Z#_&D + ")(",.(&0D + "#-./",.%01*("' + D"301& + )%.1& + &30&+3&.1"4&)%", + " + 2-"3U6%&,("D + U50#("D + "#_0(&&B + "#0)205&,.L_0D+2-03D0%("0 + )D$)1"2"1.4.(&0 + & + %06)%"2"-"a30(&0 + U5.)%(&6",+3&.1"4.A + Q-"D0 + 2-03D0%("4"B + 2)&O"1"4&50)6"4" + & + 203.4"4&50)6"4"+.)206%", +�6"1$ + 2"(&D.(&7 + 6.6 + "#-./",.%01*("' + )&)%0D$B + D"a("+4","-&%* +2 $ /R?<8R=2?2A1B,6/1W $ ?131CW $ /2GGR31/.817325$-1-./81/1k+(0+%"1*6"+)"#)%,0(("+U50#($0+2-03D0%$B+("+&+2"(&D.(&0+6U1*%U-$ + f6.6 + 6"1")).1*("4" + 2-&D0-. + .,%"6"DDU(&6.C&&g + 9SARA+�"%D.(<A+++

F"(&D.(&0 +6U1*%U-$+6.6 + )D$)1"2"-"a3.L_0' + )&)%0D$+)%.1"+"#_&D + D0)%"D + 6U1*%U-"1"4&50)6&O + -.#"%A + !"^1L)* + (. + D(0(&0+SARA�"%D.(.k +, + )%.%*0 + fQU1*%U-. + 6.6 + )U#*06% +& + ).D.J)0#0 +"#d06%g+U50($' + 2&^0%k + fjU(3.D0(%.1*($D + ,"2-")"D +)0D&"%&6&+ 6U1*%U-$+7,170%)7 + 2-"#10D. + )D$)1"2"-"a30(&7A + !D$)1"2"-"a30(&0D + D$+#U30D+(./$,.%*+)2")"#(")%*+6.6+6U1*%U-$+,+C01"DB+%.6+&+"%301*($O+00+5.)%0' + ,$3.,.%* + (. + f,$O"30g +(0%-&,&.1*(" +(",$0 +%06)%$A +P",$D&+%06)%.D& + D$ + #U30D + (./$,.%* + %06)%$B + ,"/(&6.L_&0 + , + -0/U1*%.%0+(0"#-.%&D$O+9,+)D$)10+GA+F-&4"a&(.<+2-"C0))",B+%"+0)%*+%06)%$B+,+"2-03010(("'+D0-0+(02-03)6./U0D$0A +!D$)1"2"-"a30(&0+2-"&)O"3&%+(.+,)0O+U-",(7O+6U1*%U-$A+F-"C0))+x%"%+2"3-./UD0,.0%+2")%U210(&0+&/,(0 + , + )&)%0DU + (06"%"-$O + %06)%", + & + )20C&E&50)6ULB+(02-03)6./U0DUL + &O + %-.()E"-D.C&L + ," + ,-0D7 + 3,&a0(&7 + D0a3U+,O"3"D+&+,$O"3"D+)&)%0D$A+!&)%0D$+x%"4"+-"3.+c+"%+D&(&D.1*($O+=Y+RARA+N.O%&(A+h")%"0,)6&'A+8?Y8+4A+!A+;Y:A+9QU-)&,+N.O%&(.<A=I+RARAN.O%&(A+|)%0%&6.+)1",0)("4"+%,"-50)%,.A+!A+;:=A

?8

Page 92: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

)0D&"%&50)6&O + 03&(&C + 3" + 41"#.1*($OB + %&2. + f6U1*%U-. + 6.6 + )0#0J3")%.%"5($' + U(&,0-)UDgB + c + "#1.3.L%B + 2-& + ,)0D + -./1&5&& + &O+D.%0-&.1*("' + 2-&-"3$B + )%-U6%U-($D + &/"D"-E&/D"DA + |%"B + ) + "3("'+)%"-"($B+2"/,"170%+2")%-"&%*+&O+D&(&D.1*(UL+D"301*B+.+)+3-U4"'+c+"6.a0%)7 + 5-0/,$5.'(" + )U_0)%,0(($D + 2-& + .(.1&/0+)D$)1"2"-"a30(&7g=KA+

M"%+2"50DU+U-"6+,+�6"10+2"(&D.(&7+D"a0%+#$%*+-.))D"%-0(+6.6+/2GGR31/.81732, $ 62;481,+ & + 6.6 +,-1345 $ 8,/68B + 50D + "( + &+"6./$,.0%)7 + (. + 3010B + #U3U5& + /.205.%10( + , + )%0("4-.DD0A + \06)%"D+7,170%)7 + %.6.7 + )","6U2(")%* + 6.6&OJ1&#" + /(.6",B + 6"%"-.7+D.(&E0)%&-U0% + )"#"' + "2-03010(("0 + ,$)6./$,.(&0 + &1& + 6"D2106)+,$)6./$,.(&'A + m1E.,&%B + (.2-&D0-B + #U3U5& + )","6U2(")%*L + /(.6",B+%06)%"D+(0+7,170%)7A+

h0')%,&%01*($'+%06)%+"#1.3.0%+%-0D7+,.a(0'^&D&+EU(6C&7D&k• 6-0.%&,("' + 9U + %06)%. + 0)%* + &(&C&.%"- + ,$)6./$,.(&7k + .,%"-B+)")%.,&%01*B+"-4.(&/.%"-+3.(("4"+/(.6","4"+6"D2106).<w• -0E0-0(%("'+9U+%06)%.+0)%*+)D$)1k+,+3.(("'+)","6U2(")%&+/(.6&+(05%"+)""#_.L%<w• -0C02%&,("'+9U+%06)%.+0)%*+2"%0(C&.1*($'+.3-0).%k+60DJ%"+x%"%+)D$)1+D"a0%+#$%*+2"(7%<A

Z#-./",.(&0B + D$)1&D"0 + 6.6 + )D$)1"2"1.4.(&0 + 92U)%* + 3.a0+"4-.(&50(("0 + 2-03D0%($D& + -.D6.D&< + 301.0% + x%U + )E0-U + 6U1*%U-$+&/"D"-E("' + ).D"' + 6U1*%U-0A + |%" + "/(.5.0%B + 5%" + "#-./",.(&0 + &D00%+^.() +&/ +D0O.(&/D. + 6-.'(0 + &(0-C&"(("4"B + )%.%* + 20-03(&D + -U#0a"D+6U1*%U-("' + )&)%0D$A + h17 + x%"4" + "#-./",.%01*(.7 + )&)%0D. + 3"1a(.+2-03)%.,17%* + )"#"' + D0O.(&/D + )D$)1"2"-"a30(&7A + Q1L50,$D+2"(7%&0D+x%"4"+2"3O"3.+D"a("+)5&%.%*+f6"(%06)%+2"(&D.(&7gB+6"%"-"0+"2&)$,.0% + 3&)6U-)&,($0 + 2-.6%&6& + )U#d06%", + U50#("4" + "#_0(&7B+-0E0-0(C&0'+6"%"-$O+,$)%U2.0%+2-03D0%("0+)"30-a.(&0B+2"(&D.0D"0+6.6+).D")%"7%01*($'+4"1")+,+U50#("D+3&.1"40+96"43.+x%"+2-03D0%("0+)"30-a.(&0+2-03)%.,10("+6.6+2-"&/,030(&0B+&1&+·qvsJ2-"&/,030(&0<A+M+x%"D +)1U5.0 + ,"/D"a0( +-0.1*($' +U50#($'+3&.1"4B + 5-0,.%$' +(",$D&+)D$)1.D&+317+,)0O+U5.)%(&6",B+,61L5.7+U5&%017A+

h17+U-"6",+1&%0-.%U-$+%.6&D+2-"&/,030(&0D+7,170%)7B+6"(05("+a0B + OU3"a0)%,0(($' + %06)%A + h17 + &)%"-&& + c + )20C&.1*($' + 6"()%-U6%B+)"#-.(($' + 2" + 2-&(C&2.D + 2-"%&,"-05&' + .,%"-)6&O + 2"/&C&' + &+6"(%-.)%.+c+a.(-","4"+&+)%&10,"4"A+\.6&0+6"()%-U6%$+97+(./$,.L+&O+3"6UD0(%.1*("J&)%"-&"4-.E&50)6&D& + 6"D2106).D&< + 2"/,"17L%+U5.)%(&6.D +U50#("4" + 3&.1"4. +2"1U5&%* +(",$0 +2-03D0%($0 + )D$)1$B+6"%"-$O + (0 + )U_0)%,",.1" + 3" + (.5.1. + U-"6.A + |%& + )D$)1$+x6)21&C&-UL%)7+,+.,%"-)6&0+,0-)&&+&+2&)*D0(($0++&)%"-&&A+

`"1* + 2&)*D0(("' + -05& + , + (.^0D + 2"3O"30 + ,0)*D. + /(.5&%01*(.k+)&(%.6)&) + ),7/("4" + 2",0)%,",.(&7 + 2-0,-._.0% + -./-"/(0(($0+

=K+SA�"%D.(A+f!0D&")E0-.gA+!F#B+G)6U))%,"+³+!2#B+=>>>4AB+!A+Y:>A

?=

Page 93: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

E-.4D0(%$+ 9&30&< +, +(06"%"-"0 +C01"0A +y"1&/D+%.6&O +,0-)&'J&)%"-&'+&D00%+7,($'+-./,&,.L_&'+O.-.6%0-A+F")10+1&(4,"J6"DDU(&6.%&,($O+&))103",.(&'+PAR.6)&D","'+9"3(.+&/+-./-.#"%5&6",+6"DDU(&6.%&,("'+3&3.6%&6&<B + D$ + 2"1U5&1& + &()%-UD0(% + , + ,&30 + )&)%0D$ + -050,$O+6"DDU(&6.%&,($O + )%-.%04&'B + 2"/,"17L_&O + 2")%.,&%* + ,"2-") + "+E"-D&-",.(&&++/2GGR31/.817325$?1B32681D$

!+:8.$4'+0.F & 7 & +:#(3+7('$$ & O & Y.+ & 0H+0+: & +:#(3+7(."?F'+4&

Y13$0."'9$$R &H#+.$7+0.+%V$4&+:#(3+7(."?F'+4 &H+70"/'"7'+0.$R &'+&

'" & 3(-"'%UV$4 & ""= & !+:8.$" & $-"". & 0-80? & .+?F1+ & 7 & +HH+3$9$$ & 1 &

H+70"/'"7'+-) & +:#(3+7(."?F'+-) & +H8.)R & 1(1 & H#(3/'$1$ & $'+T/(&

H#"#87(U. & :)/'$= & B"/(T+T$*"01$4 & /$01)#0 & 0+:8.$4'+0.$ & O & Y.+&

'(##(.$7'8" & $ & -"'.(.$7'8" & ."10.++:#(3)UV$" & 0.#(."T$$= &

!+:8.$" & :+$.0% & +:+:V"'$4 & $ & +:+:V"0.7?"'$4= & G:+:V"'$" & 1(1&

?+T$1+,/$01)#0$7'(%&+H"#(9$%&)'$*.+W(".&)'$1(?F'+0.F&0+:8.$%R&(&

+:+:V"0.7?"'$" & 1(1 & 0+9$(?F'+" & /"40.7$" & $T'+#$#)". & (7.+#01+"&

'(*(?+AP0%+)"#$%&'($O+U50#($O+2-03D0%",B+%.6+a0+6.6+&+2-03D0%("'+

)"#$%&'(")%&k+0)%*+)"#$%&'(")%*+6.6+6-.%("0+6.50)%,0(("0+)")%"7(&0+,(U%-&+1L#$O+2-03D0%",+&+,"/D"a(")%*+%-.()E"-D.C&&+2-03D0%("4"+6"(%0(%. + , + 2-03)"#$%&'("0 + )")%"7(&0A + l)1",&0DB + &(&C&&-UL_0D+U50#($0 + )"#$%&7B + 7,170%)7 + `./,&,.L_.7 + Z#-./",.%01*(.7 + !-03.+9`Z!<B + "#1.3.L_.7 + )103UL_&D& + ),"')%,.D&k +28/=48268<r$3,1>;482B3268<r$/238=.683268<$>3.B,315r$1,=.=W1B3268<D

|%&+O.-.6%0-&)%&6&+&+2.-.D0%-$+`Z!+2"/,"17L%+2"1*/",.%01L+(.'%& + , + !-030 + /"(U + .6%U.1*("4" + & + #1&a.'^04" + -./,&%&7A + M)76"DU+)"#$%&L + 2-03^0)%,U0% + U50#(.7 + )&%U.C&7B + 6"%"-.7 + 2"%0(C&.1*("+)"#$%&'(.B + (" + 2")6"1*6U + )"#$%&'(")%* + c + (0 + a0)%6"+30%0-D&(&-",.(("0B+.+,0-"7%(")%("0+7,10(&0B+c+D"a("+)6./.%*k+6.a3"0+)"#$%&0 + ,$-.)%.0% + &/ + "#-./",.%01*("' + )&%U.C&&B + (" + (0 + 6.a3.7+)&%U.C&7 + 2-0,-._.0%)7 + , + "#-./",.%01*("0 + )"#$%&0A + l)1",&7 + 317+2-0,-._0(&7 + "#-./",.%01*("' + )&%U.C&& + , + "#-./",.%01*("0 + )"#$%&0+)"50%.L% + 6.6 + )20C&.1*(" + 2"34"%",10(($0 + D0-$B + %.6 + & + x10D0(%$+(02-03)6./U0D")%&+&+)1U5.'(")%&A+

B?>$)34(,& O.-.6%0-&)%&6.D& + Z#-./",.%01*("4" + !"#$%&7+D"a(" + )5&%.%*k + 6"DDU(&6.%&,("0 + 2",030(&0 + 2-02"3.,.%017B+6"DDU(&6.%&,("0 +2",030(&0 +61.)). + 9&1& +U50(&6.<B +6"DDU(&6.%&,("0+2-")%-.()%,"+U-"6.+&1&+/.(7%&7B+6"DDU(&6.%&,("0+,-0D7+U-"6.B+"#-./+2-03D0%. + U + ^6"1*(&6.B + -0E106)&7 + U50#("' + 3&)C&21&($ + U+2-02"3.,.%017A+

M"/D"a($0+&/D0-&%01&+Z#-./",.%01*("4"+!"#$%&7k+5.)%"%(")%*+&+a01.0D")%*+)"#$%&'+317+04"+U5.)%(&6",B+.+%.6a0+U-",0(*+&+,-0D7+&O+2")1030')%,&7A + ~)1& + )"#$%&0 + a&,0% + , + "#_0' + 2.D7%& + U5.)%(&6",+9),&30%01*)%,"D+504"+D"4U%+#$%*+2")%"7(($0+"%)$16&+&+C&%&-",.(&0<+&+x%"+2-"3"1a.0%)7+3")%.%"5("+3"14"0+,-0D7B +c+%" +D"a("+4","-&%*+"+/(.5&%01*(")%&+3.(("4"+)"#$%&7A+�1.,("0+"4-.(&50(&0+c+(0+2"3D0(7%*+

?;

Page 94: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

"#-./",.%01*(UL + 2",)03(0,(")%* + ·q�uvsJ)"#$%&'(")%*LB + 5%"+(0D&(U0D" + 2-&,030% + 6 + 2-"E.(.C&& + & + "#0)C0(&% + "#-./",.%01*("0+)"#$%&0B + %.6 + a0 + 6.6 + 2-0,-._0(&0 + )"#$%&7 + , + 2"34"%",10(("0+D0-"2-&7%&0A+

P.)%"7_.7 + )"#$%&'(")%* + (0 + D"a0% + #$%* + 2-02.-&-",.(. + ,+f5&)%"D+,&30gB+"(.+2"%0(C&.1*("+a&,0%+,+2-03D0%("D+6"(%0(%0+&1&+,+(0+U50#("'+2-.6%&60B+&+,+)1U5.0+.6%&,("4"+307%01*(")%("4"+2"(&D.(&7+U5.)%(&6.D& + "#-./",.%01*("' + )&%U.C&& + & + ,/.&D"30')%,&7 + 1&5($O+)D$)1",+)+2-031"a0(($D+2"10D+/(.50(&'+95%"+"#0)205&,.0%)7+`Z!<B+D"a0% + )%.%* +E;=.>27.8,?<34G $ :2;481,GD+ F"3 + )",2.30(&0D + 7+2"(&D.L+(0+%"a30)%,"B+("+%.6"0+,/.&D"30')%,&0B+6"43.+2"10+/(.50(&'+"%6-$%" +317 +(.2"1(0(&7 +(",$D& +6"(("%.C&7D&B +&/D0(7L_&D& +,)L+)D$)1",UL+6"(E&4U-.C&LA+

:=,-.$1$62;481,9/$-1-./81/,$8<H82=6/2A2$62@=272c-,31C

Q=D=K+7(?"7(R&&D=I=S$?$'(

M$/",$+)",-0D0((")%&B +)%"7_&0 +20-03 +)&)%0D"'+"#-./",.(&7+&+"#_0)%,"D +, +C01"DB + %-0#UL% + )&)%0D("4" +20-0")D$)10(&7 + %0"-&& +&+2-.6%&6&+"#-./",.(&7A+P.U5($D++)""#_0)%,"D+.(.1&/&-UL%)7+)04"3(7+(0+%"1*6"+2-&61.3($0+.)206%$++)",-0D0(("4"+203.4"4&50)6"4"+/(.(&7B+(" + & + ).D& + 3&3.6%&50)6&0 + ")(",$ + 61.))&50)6"' + 203.4"4&6&=?A + P0+2-0%0(3U7+(.+2")%-"0(&0+C01")%("'+f(","'g+3&3.6%&6&B+(.^.+(.U5(.7+4-U22. + 2-031.4.0% + )6"--06%&-",.%* + (06"%"-$0 + #./",$0 + 2"(7%&7+3&3.6%&6&+%.6&D+"#-./"DB+5%"#$+,+-.D6.O+"%050)%,0(("'+203.4"4&6&+)%.1" + ,"/D"a($D + )04"3(7 + "#)Ua3.%* + )",-0D0(($0 + 3&3.6%&50)6&0+2-"#10D$A + M + (.^0' + )%.%*0 + &/1"a0( + -73 + -0/U1*%.%", + &))103",.(&'+2")103(&O+3,UO+10%A+|%&+-0/U1*%.%$+D"41&+2"7,&%*)7+%"1*6"+,+3&.1"40+)+6"1104.D&+c+U50($D&B+-U6","3&%017D&+"#-./",.%01*($O+U5-0a30(&'B+D0%"3&)%.D&B+U5&%017D&B +&+D$+2-&/(.%01*($+,)0D+U5.)%(&6.D+x%"4"+3&.1"4.A

f,2=1C$6=,-4$1$-,C8,?<3268345$@2-W2-F-03)%.,10(&7 + " + /.3.5.O + & + ")"#0((")%7O + "-4.(&/.C&&+

%*L%"-)6"4" + )"2-","a30(&7 + 9(. + D0%"3&50)6"D + U-",(0< + ,)043.+,$)%-.&,.1&)*+(.D&+,+"2"-0+(.+2-03)%.,10(&7+"#+.6%&,("D++O.-.6%0-0+)%.(",10(&7+501",06.+50-0/+307%01*(")%*B+D$^10(&0B+-0E106)&LB+%A0A+,+"2"-0 + (. + 307%01*(")%($' + 2"3O"3A + Z3(.6"B + &)2"1*/U7 + 2"(7%&0+=?+P.2-7a0((.7+3&)6U))&7+2"+x%&D+,"2-").D+Ua0+,%"-"'+4"3+-./,"-.5&,.0%)7+(.+M)0-"))&')6"'+(.U5("JD0%"3&50)6"'+6"(E0-0(C&&+f!",-0D0((.7+3&3.6%&6.+&+6.50)%,"+"#-./",.(&7g+,+Q-.)("7-)60A

?:

Page 95: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

f307%01*(")%*gB + (.D + (0 + U3.,.1")* + , + 2"1("' +D0-0 + "#")(",.%* + ).DU+(0"#O"3&D")%*+&+,"/D"a(")%*+%*L%"-)6"4"+)"2-","a30(&7A

h17+-./-.#"%6&+)"#)%,0(("+%0"-&&+%*L%"-)%,.+ +(.D&+,+#"1*^0'+)%020(&++&)2"1*/",.1&)*+2"(7%&7+&(3&,&3U.1&/.C&&B+,.-&.%&,(")%&+&+"%6-$%")%& + "#-./",.(&7A + P.^& + 6"1104& + c + -./-.#"%5&6& + &+2")103",.%01& + )&)%0D$ + `./,&,.L_04" + "#U50(&7 + hANA|1*6"(&(. + c+MAMAh.,$3",.B + 2-032"1.4.1& + &/#$%"5(")%* + 2"/&C&& + %*L%"-. + ,+2-"C0))0 + "#U50(&7B + 6"%"-$' + /.3.0%)7 + & + &)50-2$,.0%)7 + %-&.3"'+fU5._&')7+c+U50#(.7+/.3.5.+c+U5&%01*gA+\-0#",.1")*+(06"0+2"(7%&0+c+(03")%.L_00 + /,0("B + 6"%"-"0 + 3"1a(" + #$1" + 2"D"5* + f),7/.%*g+E&1")"E)6"0 + & + %0"-0%&50)6"0 + "#")(",.(&0 + %*L%"-)6"4"+)"2-","a30(&7+)+2"(7%&0D+307%01*(")%&A+ +\.6&D+2"(7%&0D+)%.1"+317+(.)+'+7+"&H#+*."'$"&H+'%.$%&0#"/8A+

M + (.U5("D + &/3.(&& + -.#"% + �*,. + !0D0(",&5. + M$4"%)6"4"B+,$^03^0D + , + 8?K: + 4AB + (.2&).("k + fe)"C&.1*(.7 + )-03. + 7,170%)7+&)%"5(&6"D+,"/(&6(",0(&7+,)0O+)20C&E&50)6&+501",050)6&O+),"')%,+1&5(")%&B + 2")%020((" + 2-&"#-0%.0D$O + -0#0(6"DB + &1& + &)%"5(&6"D+)"C&.1*("4" + -./,&%&7 + -0#0(6.B + 6"%"-"0 + )",0-^.0%)7 + , + 2-"C0))0+-0.1*("4"+,/.&D"30')%,&7+&30.1*($O+&+(.1&5($O+E"-Dg;>A++Q+2"(7%&L+)-03$+M$4"%)6&'+,+),"&O+-.#"%.O+"#-._.1)7+(0"3("6-.%("B+"3(.6"B+6+)"a.10(&LB + %.6 + & + (0 + U)201 + 04" + 2-"-.#"%.%*A +mAPA�0"(%*0,B + U50(&6+M$4"%)6"4" + )301.1 + , + 3.1*(0'^0D + .6C0(% + Ua0 + (. + 3-U4"D + 2"(7%&&B+)%.,^0D + 61L50,$D + , + 04" + )"#)%,0(($O + -.#"%.OB + c + 2"(7%&&+-,C8,?<32681A + + M$)%-.&,.7 + 2-03)%.,10(&7 + " + 307%01*(")%& + 6.6+,03U_0D+&)%"5(&60 +-./,&%&7+501",06.B +"(+2"3,0-4+6-&%&60+f%0"-&L+)-03$gA + M + -./,0-(U%"D + ,&30 + x%. + 6-&%&6. + 2-03)%.,10(. + , + )%.%*0+mAPA�0"(%*0,.B + 6"%"-.7B + (0 + #U3U5& + "2U#1&6",.(. + 2-& + 04" + a&/(&B+,$^1.+,+205.%*+,+8??K4A+&B+#$%*+D"a0%B+(0+%.6++^&-"6"+&/,0)%(.;8A+

F-"C&%&-U0Dk + fQ.6 + D$ + ,&301&B + %0"-&7 + )-03$B + -./,&,.0D.7+�A!AM$4"%)6&DB + (0&/#0a(" + 2-&,"3&% + 04" + 6 + U%-.%0 + 6"(6-0%("'+1&5(")%&+-0#0(6.w+D$+,&301&B+)+3-U4"'+)%"-"($B+5%"+�A!AM$4"%)6&'+(.)%"'5&,"+2$%.0%)7+)"O-.(&%*+x%"+03&()%,"A+GD0(("+317+x%"4"+"(+&+,,"3&%+2"(7%&0+20-0a&,.(&7B+6"%"-"0B+)"41.)("+20-,"(.5.1*("DU+04"+"2-03010(&LB + (0 + )",2.3.0% + ) + 2"(7%&0D + /(.50(&7 + 6.6 + 03&(&C$+)"/(.(&7B + (" + )1Ua&% + 317 + "#"/(.50(&7 + 6"(6-0%("4" + "%("^0(&7B+U)%.(.,1&,.L_04")7+D0a3U+)U#d06%"DB+,/7%$D+,"+,)0'+04"+%010)(")%&B+& + )-03"'g + 9)A8Y<A + h.100 + .,%"- + U%,0-a3.0%k + feM1&7(&0 + ,(0^(0'+)&%U.C&&B + 6.6 + & + ,""#_0 + )-03$B + "2-030170%)7 + ,)76&' + -./ + (0 + ).D"'+)-03"'+& +(0 +).D&D+)U#d06%"DB +,/7%$D&+, +&O +.#)%-.6%("DB +,(0^(0D+"%("^0(&&+3-U4+6+3-U4UB +'+&$+ '"&H"#"W$7('$"-+ )U#d06%.B +. +&D0(("+)"30-a.(&0D+04"+307%01*(")%&A+M+307%01*(")%&B+.+(0+,+20-0a&,.(&&B+

;>+�A!A+M$4"%)6&'B+8?K:B+)A=Y@A;8+mAPA+�0"(%*0,+c+l50(&0+"+)-030+,+203"1"4&50)6&O+-.#"%.O+�A+!AM$4"%)6"4"��+F)&O"1"4&50)6.7+(.U6.+&+"#-./",.(&0B+8??KA+c+H+8A+c+!A+@c=8A

?@

Page 96: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

")U_0)%,170%)7B +)103",.%01*("B +30')%,&%01*("0 +03&()%," +)U#d06%. +&+04"+30')%,&%01*(")%&B+1&5(")%&+&+)-03$g+9)A=><A

F"+�0"(%*0,UB+fe2-03D0%+&+)%.(",&%)7+)-03"'+1&^*+,)%U2.7+,+30')%,&%01*(")%*+307%01*(")%&+)U#d06%.B+6.6+"3&(+&/+D"D0(%",+x%"'+30')%,&%01*(")%&g + 9)AK<A + ~)1& + )103",.%* + ,$^02-&,030(($D+-.))Ua30(&7D+�0"(%*0,.B+%"+f2-03D0%+6.6+)-03.g+)+"2-03010((")%*L+04" + ),"')%,B + 6"%"-$0 + /.3.($ + 307%01*(")%($D +"%("^0(&0D + )U#d06%.+307%01*(")%&B+D"a0%+1"4&50)6&+-.))D.%-&,.%*)7+%"1*6"+6.6+f"#d06%g+307%01*(")%&+3.(("4"+)U#d06%.A+P"+%"43.+2"(7%&0+)-03$+"6./$,.0%)7+1&^(&DB + %.6 + 6.6 + )-03. + (0 + D"a0% + )")%"7%* + &/ + 3.((")%& + "3("4"+"%301*("4"+2-03D0%.A++!+%"56&+/-0(&7+mAPA�0"(%*0,.B+2"(7%&0+)-03$+,+307%01*(")%("D+2"3O"30+E.6%&50)6&+)%.(",&%)7+&/#$%"5($DA+

M"/D"a("+1&+)04"3(7+,(",*+)%.,&%*+,"2-")+"#+"%("^0(&&+D0a3U+)U#d06%"D+&+)-03"'+,+#"100+"#_0D+6"(%06)%0�+Z%,0%+(.+x%"%+,"2-")+3.L% + &))103",.(&7 + 501",050)6"' + 30')%,&%01*(")%& + 9,")2-&7%&7B+2",030(&7B+)"C&.1*($O+"#d06%",<B+6"%"-"0+-./-.#.%$,.1")*+/.2.3("'+E&1")"E&0'+&+(.U6"'+,"+,%"-"'+2"1",&(0 +��+,06.;=A+T.(-+)%.%*&+(0+2"/,"170% + (.D + 2"3-"#(" + ")%.(",&%*)7 + )0'5.) + (. + ,)0O + + 2"/&C&7OB+,.a($O+317 +(.^04" +-.))Ua30(&7w + +"%D0%&D +1&^*B +5%" +"6-Ua.L_.7+)-03.+-.))D.%-&,.0%)7+,+)",-0D0(("'+%0"-&&+)-03$+6.6+)","6U2(")%*+,)0O + ,"/D"a(")%0' + "6-Ua.L_04" + D&-.B + "#0)205&,.L_&O + + + &1&+2-027%)%,UL_&O+U3",10%,"-0(&L+2"%-0#(")%0'+&(3&,&3.;;A+

!-03. +c +x%" + )","6U2(")%* +-0)U-)",B +f2-03D0%g +)-03$+c + x%" +(0+%"1*6"+2-03D0%J)%&DU1B+&+(0 +(02-0D0(("+f2-03D0%+307%01*(")%&gB +.+f2-03D0%J)J,"/D"a(")%7D&J317J501",06.gB + 6"%"-$0 + D"4U% + #$%*+-0.1&/",.($B + . + D"4U% + %.6 + & + ")%.%*)7 + 1&^* + 2"%0(C&.1*($D&+,"/D"a(")%7D&A

M + x%"' + 1"4&60 + -.))Ua30(&7B + "#-./",.%01*("' + )-03"' + 7,170%)7+)","6U2(")%* + ,)0O + ,"/D"a(")%0' +"6-Ua.L_04" +D&-.B + 2"%0(C&.1*("+"#0)205&,.L_&O+++"#-./",.%01*(UL+2-"4-.DDU+501",06.A+

y"%01")*+#$+)20C&.1*("+2"350-6(U%*B+5%"B+,+(.^0D+2"(&D.(&&B+)-03.+)%.(",&%)7+"#-./",.%01*("'+(0+2"%"DUB+5%"+)"/3.0%)7+,+-.D6.O+"#-./",.%01*($O+U5-0a30(&'+&+&()%&%U%",+&1&+7,170%)7+-0/U1*%.%"D+203.4"4&50)6"4" +2-"06%&-",.(&7B +. +&)61L5&%01*(" +, +)""%,0%)%,&&+)+O.-.6%0-"D+D"%&,",+92"/(.,.%01*($OB+2-"E0))&"(.1*($OB+%,"-50)6&O+&+%A2A<B+6"%"-$0+-0.1&/UL%)7+,"+,/.&D"30')%,&&+501",06.+)"+)-03"'+)+C01*L+2"1U50(&7+"#-./",.(&7A+

m6C0(%+(.+,/.&D"30')%,&&+)"+)-03"'B+(.+(.^+,/4173B+(0+"%-&C.0%+307%01*(")%("4" + 2"3O"3.B + . + 1&^* + 3"2"1(70% + )",-0D0(($0+2-03)%.,10(&7 +"# +U50#("' + 9"#-./",.%01*("'< +307%01*(")%& +501",06.+6.6+307%01*(")%&+2"+-0^0(&L+U50#($O+9"#-./",.%01*($O<+/.3.5B+5%"+

;=+!DAB+(.2-&D0-B+�tt�k��roqrs�z�vAru�o�A�q�¤p¯�voztA�tp;;+ �&#)"( +haA +|6"1"4&50)6&' +2"3O"3 + 6 + /-&%01*("DU + ,")2-&7%&Lk +F0-A + ) + .(41A+�Z#_A+-03A+&+,)%U2A+)%A+mAhA�"4,&(0(6"A+c+RAk+F-"4-0))B+8?KKA+c+:Y:+)A

?Y

Page 97: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

,2"1(0 + 2-&/(.0%)7 + & + (.^&D& + 6"1104.D&J"22"(0(%.D& + &/ + )&)%0D$+f`./,&,.L_00+"#U50(&0gA

++,6R=63.C$G2-,?<$8<H82=6/2A2$62@=272c-,31CT@2$71-.G$74C7?C,G4W$=,6R=627$6=,-4U

F0-0,"3+2"%0(C&.1*($O+,"/D"a(")%0'++,+-0)U-)+"#-./",.(&7+c+&+0)%* + ")(",(.7 + /.3.5. + %*L%"-)6"4" + )"2-","a30(&7A + \*L%"-)6"0+)"2-","a30(&0++2-032"1.4.0%+-.#"%UB+2"+6-.'(0'+D0-0B+)+%-0D7+,&3.D&+-0)U-)",k + )"C&.1*($D&B + 6U1*%U-("J2-03D0%($D&B+.(%-"2"1"4&50)6&D&B+ +6"%"-$0+&+/.3.L%+)""%,0%)%,0(("++(.2-.,10(&7+%*L%"-)6"4"+30')%,&7A

+y+c+)"C&.1*($'+,06%"-+%*L%"-)6"4"+30')%,&7B++¸+c+6U1*%U-("J+2-03D0%($'+,06%"-+%*L%"-)6"4"+30')%,&7B++ ª+c+.(%-"2"1"4&50)6&'+,06%"-+%*L%"-)6"4"+30')%,&7+9)DA+`&)A8+

(&a0<k

`&)A8A$+,6R=63.C$G2-,?<$8<H82=6/2A2$62@=272c-,31C

00000000000000000000$sF7,/82=+6U1*%U-("J2-03D0%("4"+-.)^&-0(&7&&& &

\F7,/82=+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++tF7,/82=)"C&.1*("4"+-.)^&-0(&7+++++++++++++++++++.(%-"2"1"4&50)6"4"+-.)^&-0(&7

`.))D"%-&D+6.a3$'+&/+,06%"-",+%*L%"-)6"4"+30')%,&7+2"3-"#(00A\ $ Q $ 6201.?<345 $ 7,/82= $ 8<H82=6/2A2 $ -,56871C9 $, + O"30+

%*L%"-)6"4" + )"2-","a30(&7 + , + 6.50)%,0 + + -0)U-). + 317 + 2")%-"0(&7 + &+-0.1&/.C&&+&(3&,&3U.1*("'+"#-./",.%01*("'+2-"4-.DD$+%*L%"-.(%.+

?I

Page 98: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

&))103UL%)7 + & + .6%U.1&/&-UL%)7 + -./1&5($0 + x10D0(%$ + )"C&.1*("'+)-03$+c+DU/0&B+%0.%-$B+#&#1&"%06&B+,$)%.,"5($0+/.1$+&+%A3A+

s$Q$/R?<8R=32F$@=,-G,8345$7,/82=$8<H82=6/2A2$-,56871C9$x%"%+,06%"- +U6./$,.0% +(. +(.2-.,10((")%* + -.#"%$ + %*L%"-. + ) +2-03D0%($D+D.%0-&.1"D + 9U50#($D + 2-03D0%"DB + "#1.)%*L + /(.(&7 + &1& + "#1.)%*L+2-.6%&6&<B + ,$#-.(($D + 04" + 2"3"205($DA + Z#-./",.%01*(.7 + )-03.+2-03)%.0% + /30)* + , + .)206%0 + f6U1*%U-("' + )-03$gB + (.2-&D0-B + 6.6+)","6U2(")%*+6U1*%U-($O+&)%"5(&6",B+.-%0E.6%",+&+3-A+++++

t$Q$.38=2@2?2A1B,6/15$7,/82=$8<H82=6/2A2$-,56871C9$4","-7+"+-0.1&/.C&&+)"#)%,0(("'+&(3&,&3U.1*("'+"#-./",.%01*("'+2-"4-.DD$B+6.a3$'+ + %*L%"-.(% +3"1a0(+2"(&D.%*B + 6.6&0 + %-0#",.(&7 +-0.1&/.C&7+x%"'+2-"4-.DD$+2-03d7,170%+6+(0DU+1&5("B+(.+6.6&0+),"&+6.50)%,.+"(+Ua0+D"a0%+"20-0%*)7B+.+6.6&0+%-0#UL%+-./,&%&7A+\*L%"-+,+x%"D+)1U5.0+2"D"4.0% + U,&30%* + & + "#)U3&%* + .(%-"2"1"4&50)6&0 + %-0#",.(&7+&(3&,&3U.1*("' + "#-./",.%01*("' + 2-"4-.DD$A + Q"(05($' + a0 + ,$#"-+,)043. + ")%.0%)7 + /. + %*L%"-.(%"Dk + 2-&(&D.%* + 3.(($'+.(%-"2"1"4&50)6&'+,$/",+&1&+6"--06%&-",.%*+),"L+"#-./",.%01*(UL+2-"4-.DDU+(.+")(",.(&&+Ua0+)E"-D&-",.(($O+-.(00+6.50)%,A

`.#"%.+%*L%"-.+,+6.a3"D+&/+U6./.(($O+(.D&+,$^0+(.2-.,10(&'+9)"C&.1*("DB + 6U1*%U-("J2-03D0%("DB + .(%-"2"1"4&50)6"D< + 2"/,"170%+%*L%"-.(%U+U,&30%*+,"/D"a(")%&+"#-./",.%01*("'+)-03$+317+-0^0(&7+%0O + &1& + &($O + /.3.5B + 6"%"-$0 + ,)%.L% + , + ),7/& + ) + -./-.#"%6"' + &+-0.1&/.C&0'+&(3&,&3U.1*("'+"#-./",.%01*("'+2-"4-.DD$+%*L%"-.(%.A

:2;481,$/./$-1-./81B,6/.C$,-1310.!D$)1","0 + 6"()%-U&-",.(&0 + 30')%,&%01*(")%& + 6.6 + -0/U1*%.%+

,/.&D"30')%,&7 +)" + )-03"' +,61L5.0% +")"#$0 +x10D0(%$ +c +)"#$%&7A +M+E&1")"E&&+2")%D"30-(&/D.+)"#$%&0+0)%*+03&()%,"+3,UO+(.5.1+c+N$%&7+&+M-0D0(&B+6"%"-"0+1"6.1&/U0%)7�-.)^&-70%)7+,+2-")%-.()%,0+&+&D00%+),"&O + (")&%010'A + M + %"56& + /-0(&7 + 2)&O"1"4&&B + )"#$%&0 + c + /(.5&D"0+a&/(0(("0+&/D0(0(&0B+430+/(.5&D")%*+"2-030170%)7+,61L50(&0D+04"+,+6.U/.1*($0B + &1& + 2-&5&(("J)103)%,0(($0B + ),7/&k + -0.1&/",.(($0B+.6%U.1*($0B + 2"%0(C&.1*($0;:A + !"#$%&7B + -.))D.%-&,.0D$0 + 6.6 + 5.)%*+C01")%("4"+a&/(0(("4"+2U%&B+2-&"#-0%.L%+&("0+/(.50(&0B+50D+,/7%$0+2"+"%301*(")%&B+,"/,-._.L%+"_U_0(&0+'"0?)*(4'+0.$+2-"&/"^03^04"+&+,"/D"a(")%&+#$%*+.,%"-"DB+)U#d06%"D+),"0'+a&/(&+,+(.)%"7_0D+&+#U3U_0D;@A

E;=.>27.8,?<32,$62;481,$G4$;R-,[email protected]<$/./$1>G,3,31,I$20,317.,G2, $ B,?27,/2G $ /./ $ >3.B1G2,I $ $ -?C $ ,A2 $ 2;=.>27.31C $ 1$./81732 $ 7/?HB,332, $ 7 $ G,c62;481534, $ 67C>1A + Z#-./",.%01*($0+

;:+Q-"(&6+mAmAB+mOD0-",+ AmA+Q.U/"D0%-&7k+R0%"3$+).D"2"/(.(&7B+2)&O"3&.4(")%&6&+&+2)&O"%0-.2&&+,+2)&O"1"4&&+a&/(0(("4"+2U%&A+=J0+&/3A+c+RAk+!D$)1B+=>>KA+c+=?:+)A+;@+\.D+a0B+.+%.6a0k+M.)&1L6+jA~A+m,%"#&"4-.E&7+&+1&5(")%*+��+P.U6.+&+%0O(&6.A+8?K:A+H=A+!A8@J8IA

?K

Page 99: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

)"#$%&7B + -.))D.%-&,.0D$0 + 6.6 + 5.)%* + C01")%("4" + "#-./",.%01*("4"+2-"C0)).B+7,17L%)7+-0/U1*%.%"D+2-03^0)%,UL_&O+)"#$%&'+&+2-&5&("'+2")103UL_&OB+c+50D+#"1*^0+%.6&O+),7/0'B+%0D+)"#$%&0+#"100+/(.5&D"A+9F"3 + "#-./",.%01*($D + 2-"C0))"DB + , + 6"(%06)%0 + ,$^02-&,030(($O+-.))Ua30(&'B +)103U0%+2"(&D.%*+2-"C0))+,/.&D"30')%,&7+501",06.+)"+)-03"' + 6.6 + )","6U2(")%*L + ,"/D"a(")%0' + ) + C01*L + 2")%-"0(&7+)"#)%,0(("4" + "#-./",.(&7<A + + P. + (.^ + ,/4173B + &(3&,&3U.1&/.C&7+"#-./",.(&7 + (0,"/D"a(. + #0/ + .6%U.1&/.C&& + 04" + )"#$%&'("4" + (.5.1.B+6"%"-"0 +"#0)205&% +2-"7,10(&0 +& + )%.(",10(&0 +501",06. +6.6 + )U#d06%.+),"04"+"#-./",.(&7+&+a&/(&+,+C01"DA+

F-&(&D.7 + )"#$%&'(")%* + "#-./",.%01*("4" + 2-"C0)). + , + 6.50)%,0+C0((")%& + & + , + "2"-0 + (. + 2"(&D.(&0 + 2)&O"1"4&50)6"4" + E0("D0(.+)"#$%&'(")%&B + 430 + ,.a($ + %.6&0 + 6.%04"-&& + 6.6 + f20-0a&,.(&0gB+fxD"C&"(.1*("JC0((")%("0 + "%("^0(&0gB + fD"%&,.C&"(("0+"#-./",.(&0gB+D$+)%.,&D+/.3.5U+-./,&%*+2-03)%.,10(&0+"+)"#$%&&+6.6+3&3.6%&50)6"'+03&(&C0+c+E"-D0+"#-./",.%01*("4"+2-"C0)).A+

`./-.#"%6.+2-03)%.,10(&'+"+)"#$%&&+6.6+3&3.6%&50)6"'+03&(&C0+"2&-.0%)7 + (. + "#_0203.4"4&50)6&0 + &30& + + " + %"DB + 5%"B + )"/3.,.7+"2-03010(($0 + U)1",&7 + ,/.&D"30')%,&7 + 501",06. + ) + "#-./",.%01*("'+)-03"'B+,"/D"a("+2",$)&%*+,0-"7%(")%*+2"1U50(&7++&D+%0O+&1&+&($O+"#-./",.%01*($O+-0/U1*%.%",B+xEE06%",B+2"1U50(&0+6"%"-$O+(.2-7DUL+/.21.(&-",.%* + (0,"/D"a(" + 9xD"C&"(.1*($' + "%61&6B + )%.(",10(&0+)U#d06%(")%&<A + Z2-03010(($0 + U)&1&7B + E"-D$ + & + D0%"3$ + -.#"%$B+,"/D"a("++&/#$%"5($0+)+%"56&+/-0(&7+"2%&D.1*(")%&+203.4"4&50)6"'+-.#"%$B + (.2-.,10(("' + (. + 2"1U50(&0 + )%.(3.-%&/&-",.(("4"+"#-./",.%01*("4" + 9. + )6"-00B + U50#("4"< + -0/U1*%.%.B + , + 3.(("D + )1U5.0+)%.(",7%)7+(0"#O"3&D$D&+317+2"1U50(&7+,0-"7%(")%($O+-0/U1*%.%",+&+xEE06%",B+C0((")%*+6"%"-$O+(0+)%.,&%)7+203.4"4.D&+2"3+)"D(0(&0A+

:2;481, $ 68.327186C $ 6@262;2G $ 62>-.31C $ R6?2715I $ /282=4,$G./61G.?<[email protected]$7,=2C83268<$@2C7?,31C$13-171-R.?<34W$2;=.>27.8,?<34W$@=2A=.GG$1$@=2,/827$$R$,A2$RB.6831/27A+!"#$%&0+6.6+3&3.6%&50)6.7+E"-D.+&D00%+,+),"0'+)%-U6%U-0+)")%.,17L_&0k

J+"-4.(&/.C&"((UL+96.6+U)%-"0("+2"%0(C&.1*("0+"#-./",.%01*("0+)"#$%&0<w

J+203.4"4&50)6UL+96.6+-.#"%.0%+203.4"4<wJ + -0/U1*%&-UL_UL + 95%" + 2-"&)O"3&% + ) + 501",06"DB + )20C&.1*($D+

"#-./"D+,61L50(($D+,+2"%0(C&.1*("0+"#-./",.%01*("0+)"#$%&0<w

E=A.31>.01233.C$6268.7?CHJ.C$62;481C$/./$-1-./81B,6/25$X2=G4$7/?HB.,8$W.=./8,=1681/198A !""%,0%)%,&0 +6U1*%U-("DU+"#-./CU + 9f2-./3(&6gB +fx6)203&C&7gB+

f&(&C&.C&7gB+f6.-(.,.1gB+f.U6C&"(g+&+%A3A<A+=A !,7/* + ) + 3-U4&D& + x10D0(%.D& + & + &)%"-&0' + a&/(& + )""#_0)%,.B+

U5.)%(&6",A;A P.1&5&0+2-&,106.%01*("'+20-)206%&,$A

??

Page 100: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

:A `./,0-(U%$'+x%.2+2"34"%",6&A@A !&)%0D(.7B + D("4")1"'(.7 + )%-U6%U-.B + ,61L5.L_.7+

6"DDU(&6.C&LAYA l5.)%&0 + &(%0-0)($OB + 2-&,106.%01*($OB + U)20^($O + 1L30'+

9f1&30-",gB+f.,%"-",gB+fx6)20-%",g+&+%A2A<AA+IA M"/D"a(")%*+,$#"-.+E"-D+&+O.-.6%0-.+1&5("4"+U5.)%&7AKA M"/D"a(")%*+&+UD0)%(")%* +&D2-",&/.C&&B + +2"-"a30(&7+(",$O+

)D$)1",+,+O"30+)"#$%&7A

h,-.A2A1B,6/.C$6268.7?CHJ.C$=.;284$6$62;481,Gk8A+`.#"%.+)+"#-./",.%01*($D&+)"#$%&7D&+7,170%)7+"#7/.%01*($D+

x10D0(%"D + %*L%"-)6"4" + )"2-","a30(&7 + 6.6 + "6./.(&7 + %*L%"-.(%.D+2"D"_&+,+2")%-"0(&&+&+-0.1&/.C&&+&(3&,&3U.1*($O+"#-./",.%01*($O+D.-^-U%",B+21.(",B+2-"4-.DDB+,61L5.7k

+ J+`.#"%U+2"+,$7,10(&LB+E&6).C&&B+-./,&%&L+2"/(.,.%01*($O+&(%0-0)", + %*L%"-.(%",B + "#-./",.%01*("' + D"%&,.C&& + , + C01"Dw+20-03.5U+U)%.(","6+&+)2")"#",+-.#"%$+,+x%"'+"#1.)%&A

J + Z6./.(&0 + 2"D"_& + , + ,$7,10(&& + %-0O + ,&3", + -0)U-)",+"#-./",.%01*("' + )-03$w + 20-03.5U + U)%.(","6 + & + )2")"#", + %.6"'+-.#"%$A

J + Z6./.(&0 + 2"D"_& + , + 21.(&-",.(&& + 30')%,&' + 2"+&)2"1*/",.(&L + "#-./",.%01*($O + -0)U-)", + & + 2"1U50(&&+"#-./",.%01*("4"+2-"3U6%.w+20-03.5U+)2")"#",+%.6"'+-.#"%$A

J+Z6./.(&0+2"D"_&+,+"C0(60+&+-0E106)&&+O"3.+&+-0/U1*%.%",+9xEE06%",<+"#-./",.%01*("4"+2-"C0)).w+20-03.5U+)""%,0%)%,UL_&O+)2")"#",+-.#"%$A=A + `.#"%. + ) + )"#$%&7D& + D"a0% + ,0)%&)* + (0 + %"1*6" + 317 + "3("4"+

%*L%"-.(%.B+("+&+4-U22$A+;A+`.#"%.+)+)"#$%&7D&+)%-"&%)7+2"J-./("DU+,+/.,&)&D")%&+"%+%"4"B+

"-4.(&/UL%+04"+).D&+%*L%"-.(%$+&+&O+203.4"4&B+&1&+(0%A+

#$2c1-.,G4G$=,>R?<8.8.G$=,AR?C=325$=.;284$6 $62;481CG1$/./$-1-./81B,6/1G1$,-1310.G1$G2c32$283,6819$

− "#-._0(&0 + %*L%"-.(%", + 6+2-"#10D.%&60 + %,"-50)%,.B + &))103",.(&7B + ).D",")2&%.(&7 + &+).D""#U50(&7+501",06.B+6+2-"#10D.%&60+)"C&.1*("4"+,/.&D"30')%,&7w+-./,&%&0+D"%&,.C&&+1&5(")%("4"+-./,&%&7B+"#-./",.(&7w

− -0^0(&0 + &(3&,&3U.1*($O+/.3.5+9")"/(.(("0+E"-D&-",.(&0+96"--06C&7<+&(3&,&3U.1*("4"+)%&17+D$^10(&7B +2"/(.,.%01*("'+& +%,"-50)6"'+307%01*(")%&w +2",$^0(&0+xD"C&"(.1*("'+U)%"'5&,")%&B+-./,&%&0+(.)%"'5&,")%&+&+%0-2&D")%&+6.6 + 50-% + O.-.6%0-.w + 2"7,10(&0 + (",$O + %,"-50)6&O + &(&C&.%&,w+6"--06C&7+6"DDU(&6.%&,("'+)E0-$<w

− )"C&.1&/.C&7B +U)20^(")%*+9,+2U#1&5($O+,$)%U210(&7OB+6"(6U-).OB+"1&D2&.3.O+&+%A2A<k

8>>

Page 101: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

− 3"#-$0 + + ,")2"D&(.(&7B+a01.(&0+"#_.%*)7+3-U4+)+3-U4"D+(.+3"14&0+4"3$AM)0+x%"+c+2-"7,10(&7+%"4"+E.6%.B+5%"+)"#$%&0B+-0.1&/",.(("0+6.6+

3&3.6%&50)6.7+03&(&C.B+.6%&,("+,61L50("+,+D0a)"#$%&'($0+),7/&B+%A0A+)%.1"+&(3&,&3U.1*($D+"#-./",.%01*($D+)"#$%&0DA+

kXX,/84$62;48159−!"#$%&7+,")%-0#UL%B+.+/(.5&%B+U)&1&,.L%+&+-./,&,.L%+501",06.+&+

)""#_0)%,"+950-0/+,")%-0#",.(&0+)U#d06%.B+&)%"-&&B+D&E.<A− !"#$%&7 + ,$/$,.L% + -")% + & + 2-0"#-./",.(&0 + &(3&,&3U.1*("' + &+

)",D0)%("'+x(0-4&&A− !"#$%&7 + 3.L% + ,"/D"a(")%* + 20-0'%& + "% + EU(6C&& + %*L%"-. + 6.6+

2")-03(&6.B+6"%"-$'+(.C010("+-.#"%.0%+)+30E&C&%.D&B+6+f6""-3&(.C&&+20-)206%&,$gA

− !"#$%&7 + 3.L% + ,"/D"a(")%* + 2-0"3"10%* + "2.)(")%* + E&6).C&&+%*L%"-.(%",+(.+%*L%"-0+&+)"#)%,0(("4"+20-0O"3.+%*L%"-.+,+2"/&C&L+fU5&%017g+9f6"()U1*%.(%.gB+f-U6","3&%017g<A+

F0-05&)10(($0 + (.D& + , + x%"' + )%.%*0 + (06"%"-$0 + -0/U1*%.%$ + &+xEE06%$ + )&)%0D("' + -.#"%$ + ) + )"#$%&7D& + 6.6 + 3&3.6%&50)6&D&+03&(&C.D& + D"a(" + (.#1L3.%* + + , + 6.a3"3(0,("' + + 203.4"4&50)6"'+2-.6%&60A

b./?HB,31,M + "2-03010(&& + E&1")"E)6"J%0"-0%&50)6&O + ")(", + 2")%-"0(&7+

"#-./",.%01*("4" + 2-"C0)). + D$ + 301.0D + .6C0(% + (. + 2"(7%&&+"#-./",.%01*("' + )-03$ + 6.6 + )","6U2(")%& + ,)0O + 2"%0(C&.1*($O+"#-./",.%01*($O +,"/D"a(")%0'B + 6"%"-$0 +D"4U% + )%.%* +-0)U-)"D + +2-&+-0^0(&& + "#-./",.%01*($O + /.3.5 + 6"(6-0%("4" + 501",06. + &1& + 4-U22$+1L30'A + |%"% + 20-0O"3 + ,"/D"a0( + 6.6 + )2"(%.(("B + %.6 + & + 2")-03)%,"D+)20C&.1*(" +"-4.(&/",.(("' +-.#"%$B +6"%"-.7 +)%-"&%)7 +(. +2-&(C&2.O+203.4"4&6& + %*L%"-)6"4" + )"2-","a30(&7 + & + -0^.0% + /.3.5&+&(3&,&3U.1&/.C&& + & + )"C&.1&/.C&& + 501",06.A + M + 6.50)%,0+3&3.6%&50)6"'+03&(&C$+%.6"'+-.#"%$+,$)%U2.0% +0+:8.$"B +)%-U6%U-.+6"%"-"4" + ,61L5.0% + "-4.(&/.C&"(($'B + 203.4"4&50)6&' + &+-0/U1*%&-UL_&'+.)206%$A+

E;=.>27.8,?<32,$62;481,$/./$8<H82=6/.C$@=./81/.

D=D=D$#1"0R&6=C=D)2(

8>8

Page 102: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

\*L%"-)6.7+307%01*(")%*B+")U_0)%,170D.7+,+E"-D.%0+"-4.(&/.C&&+"#-./",.%01*($O + )"#$%&' + & + -0E106)&,("4" + )"2-","a30(&7 + &O+U5.)%(&6",B + 2-03)%.,170% + )"#"' + ")"#$' + ,&3 + %*L%"-)6"' + 2-.6%&6&A+f!"#$%&'(.7g+D"301*+%*L%"-)6"'+2-.6%&6&+(.C010(.+(.+-0^0(&0+-73.+/.3.5 + , + -.D6.O + )"2-","a30(&7 + &(3&,&3U.1*("' + "#-./",.%01*("'+2-"4-.DD$ + U5._&O)7A + M + 20-,UL + "50-03*B + x%" + c + /.3.5. + )"/3.(&7+)&%U.C&'B+2-","C&-UL_&O+"50-03($0+^.4&+-./,&%&7+2"3"205("4"A+M"J,%"-$OB + )"#$%&'($0 + -0a&D$ + , + (.&#"1*^0' + )%020(& + 2-032"1.4.L%+2"7,10(&0 + "#-./",.%01*("' + &(&C&.%&,$ + & + %-0#UL% + "% + 203.4"4.J%*L%"-.+-./,"-.5&,.(&7+2"1("C0(("4"+)"2-","a30(&7+00+2-"7,10(&7+&+-0.1&/.C&&A+\-0%*0'+/.3.50'+(.+2"10+"#-./",.%01*("'+)"#$%&'(")%&+7,170%)7 + )"2-","a30(&0 + 2-&"#-0%0(&7 + (","4" + x6/&)%0(C&.1*("4"B+)"C&.1*("4"+&+"#-./",.%01*("4"+"2$%.A

E;=.>27.8,?<32, $ 62;481, $ $ TE:U $ Q $)20C&.1*(.7 + E"-D.+"-4.(&/.C&& + & + -0.1&/.C&& + "#-./",.%01*("' + 307%01*(")%&B+,$)%-"0((.7+6.6+&(%0()&,(.7+,)%-05.+-0.1*("'+&+&30.1*("'+E"-D+92"+NAhA|1*6"(&(U<A+

P.+6"(%-.)%0+)+2-&,$5($D&+E"-D.%.D&+"#U50(&7+&+"#-./",.(&7B+)"#$%&0 + 2-032"1.4.0% + "#U50(&0 + , + 30')%,&&B + ,61L50(&0 + ,+&(&C&.%&,($0 + E"-D$ + 2"-"a30(&7 + & + "E"-D10(&7 + /(.(&7A+Z#-./",.%01*("0+)"#$%&0+c+ +)2")"#+&(&C&&-",.(&7+"#-./",.%01*("'+.6%&,(")%& + U5._&O)7B + 307%01*(")%("4" + ,61L50(&7 + , + -./($0 +E"-D$+"#-./",.%01*("'+6"DDU(&6.C&&B+&(%0-0).+6+)"/3.(&L+&+2-0/0(%.C&&+2-"3U6%",+U50#("'+&+"#-./",.%01*("'+307%01*(")%&;YA

:2;48153.C $ G2-,?< $ 8<H82=6/25 $ @=./81/1+ 2-032"1.4.0%+")U_0)%,10(&0 + 6"D.(3"' + 2-"06%&-",_&6", + & + %*L%"-", + 3,UO + %&2",+-.#"%k + 2-"06%&-",.(&0 + "#-./",.%01*("4" + )"#$%&7 + 6.6 + D0)%.+-./,"-.5&,.(&7+&(%0()&,($O+2-"#+U5._&O)7+f(.+2-03010g+ +/(.(&'+&+,"/D"a(")%0'w + %*L%"-)6"0 + )"2-","a30(&0 + ,(U%-& + "#-./",.%01*("4"+)"#$%&7A

M + 2-"C0))0 + 2-"06%&-",.(&7 + (0"#O"3&D" + U5&%$,.%* + )20C&E&6U+)"#$%&'($O+"#-./",.%01*($O+E"-D.%",k

8A + M + Z! + D"301&-U0%)7 + "2-03010((.7 + )E0-. + 307%01*(")%& + �+6U1*%U-$+9&30.1*(.7+E"-D.<A+|%"+2-"&)O"3&%+/.+)50%k

¶ + ")"#"4" + -"3. + fU50#($O + /.3.5gB + -02-0/0(%&-UL_&O+307%01*(")%* + & + "#0)205&,.L_&O + -./,"-.5&,.(&0 + 61L50,$O+f-./-$,",g +& + 2-"#10D +&30.1*("' +E"-D$B + . + %.6a0 + 2-"3U6%",B+)-03)%,+&+&()%-UD0(%",+307%01*(")%&w

¶ + ,61L50(&7 + , + Z! + 2-03)%.,&%010' + 3.(("' + )E0-$+92-"E0))&"(.1",J,/-")1$O<w

;Y+ fG((",.C&"((.7 + "#-./",.%01*(.7 + D"301* + 2"3-")%6","' + & + )%.-^0' + ^6"1$+f�6"1. + xEE06%&,("4" + ,/-")10(&7ggB + U50#("0 + 2")"#&0 + + 2"3 + -03A + RUO. + PAMAB+m(%-"27()6"'+�APAB+�.-.#U-","'+~AMAB+G/3J,"+\l!l B+\"D)6B+=>>IA

8>=

Page 103: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

¶+,")2-"&/,030(&7+U61.3.B+%&2.+"-4.(&/.C&"(("'+6U1*%U-$+& + 6"DDU(&6.C&&B + O.-.6%0-("' + 317 + D"301&-U0D"'+30')%,&%01*(")%&A=A + l5.)%(&6& + ,",1050($ + , + .6%&,(UL + 307%01*(")%*B+

"-&0(%&-",.((UL + (. + 2"1U50(&0 + 2-"3U6%.A + Z! + -./,"-.5&,.0%)7 + 6.6+2-")%-.()%,"+6"D20%0(%(")%($O+2-"#A

;A + �.3.5(")%* + & + -0a&D + Z! + &D00% + 2-&(C&2&.1*("+f(03""2-03010(($'g + O.-.6%0-B + ")%.,177 + D0)%" + 317 + )U#d06%("4"+2",030(&7+U5.)%(&6",A

:A + M$)"6.7 + &(%0()&,(")%* + & + "%6-$%")%* + )"#$%&'($O + -0a&D",+/.3.0%+x(0-40%&6UB+f,$/",gB+&(&C&&-UL_&0+,"/(&6(",0(&0+)U#d06%",+3.1*(0'^0' + "#-./",.%01*("' + 307%01*(")%&A + N-0(3 + "#-./",.%01*($O+2-"4-.DD + + )0%& + ^6"1 + + & + 203.4"4&50)6&O + 6"D.(3J"-4.(&/.%"-",+)"#$%&'($O+E"-D+"#-./",.(&7;I+c+fZ#-./",.%01*($'+x6)%-&DgA

@A +|6)%-0D.1*(")%* + /.3.0%)7 +& + U30-a&,.0%)7 + /. + )50% +(0 + %"1*6"+)"30-a.(&7B + (" + & + E"-D.%.k + -./(","/-.)%($0 + 4-U22$ + U5.)%(&6",B+)"#-.(($0 + &/ + -./($O + 4"-"3", + & + ^6"1B + (",$0 + f")"#$0g + ,/-")1$0B+")"#$0 + D0)%.B + -.)2&).(&0 + 3(7B + &)2"1*/",.(&0 + V¦ + & + 2-A + M" + ,-0D7+-0.1*("4" + "#-./",.%01*("4" + )"#$%&7 + U5.)%(&6& + 2"4-Ua0($ + ,+x6)%-0D.1*($' +-0a&DB + %-0#UL_&' + 30')%,",.%* + f(. + 2-03010g + ),"&O+UD0(&'B +,-0D0(&B +2"(&D.(&7A +{01",06 +f-.)%74&,.0%)7g +6.6 +2-Ua&(.+317+%"4"B+5%"#$+3")%&5*+2-0301.+),"&O+,"/D"a(")%0'+,+x6)%-0D.1*("D+-0a&D0B + (" + 6"43. + 2-Ua&(. + f"%2U)6.0%)7g + 9x6)%-&D + /.6.(5&,.0%)7<B+501",06+(0+")%.0%)7+%0D+a0B+6.6&D+#$1+3"+)"#$%&7A+`.,("+%"DUB+6.6+-.)%7(U%.7 + 2-Ua&(. + 2" + ,"/,-._0(&& + , + ),"0 + 2-0a(00 + )")%"7(&0+"6./$,.0%)7 + #"1*^0B + 501",06 + 2")10 + "#-./",.%01*("4" + )"#$%&7 + 7,("+"_U_.0% + ),"' + 2-&-")%A + M + 5.)%(")%&B + xEE06% + -.)%7(U%"' + 2-Ua&($+,$-.a.0%)7+,+%"DB+5%"+U5.)%(&6&+2-"3UC&-UL%+f41"#.1*($0g+,$,"3$B+,$O"37_&0+/.+-.D6&+6"(6-0%($O+)&%U.C&'+&+)"30-a.(&7+-.#"%$+9f7+2"(71B+5%"+D&-+U)%-"0(+%.6J%"+&+%.6J%"e<g;KA

f<H82=6/2, $ 62@=272c-,31, $ RB.6831/27 $ 2;=.>27.8,?<34W$62;4815+&D00%+-73+%0O("1"4&50)6&O+.)206%",k

J + )20C&.1*(" + ,$)%-"0(("0 + 2-")%-.()%," + -0E106)&& + 2"/,"170%+U5.)%(&6.D + "#(.-Ua&,.%* + )"#)%,0(($0 + U)20O& + & + 30E&C&%$+9)""%,0%)%,&0 + & + -./-$,$ + D0a3U + &30.1*($D + "#-./"D + )0#7 + &+&30.1*($D<B+

J + )%.,&%* + /.3.5& + (. + )"#)%,0(("0 + 2-"3,&a0(&0B + (.O"3&%* + &1&+)"/3.,.%* + -0)U-)$ +317 + x%"4"w + , + 5.)%(")%&B + &)2"1*/UL%)7 +-./1&5($0+%0O(&6&+&+D0%"3&6&+%*L%"-)6"4"+%0O("1"4&50)6"4"+2.60%.+f�0-6.1.g+

;I+ h0%)6&' + ).3 +R"(%0))"-& + 9\"D)6<B +^6"1. + f|,-&6.J-./,&%&0g + 9\"D)6<B +�6"1.+.(%-"2"(&6& + 9Q-.)("7-)6<B + ^6"1. + `Z + flD6.g + 9P",")&#&-)6<B + �&D(./&7 + H8+fl(&,0-)g+9Q-.)("7-)6<+&+3-A;K+F"+D.%0-&.1.D+4UD.(&%.-("4"+&))103",.(&7+fj0("D0(+"#-./",.%01*("'+)"#$%&'(")%&+!&#&-)6"'+D"1"30a("'+m)).D#10&gB+PAMARUO.B+\�lB+\"D)6

8>;

Page 104: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

93(0,(&6&B + -.))6./$ + %",.-&_.DB + 4./0%$ +& +aU-(.1$B +E"%"J,$)%.,6&B+20-E"D.()$<;?B

J+-0a&D+-0E106)&&+3"1a0(+"#0)205&%*+,"/D"a(")%*+2")%.(",6&+/.3.5+(.+)"#)%,0(("0+2-"3,&a0(&0+&+2-"#$+2"+&O+-0^0(&L+2-7D"+,+2-")%-.()%,0+Z!w+"%6-$%")%*+6-&%0-&0,+xEE06%&,(")%&+2-"#+,+-.D6.O+"#-./",.%01*("4" + )"#$%&7 + 2-032"1.4.0% + 2")%"7(("0 + )""%(0)0(&0+a01.0D"4" + & + 30')%,&%01*("4" + 6.50)%,. + -0/U1*%.%", + & + 2-"3U6%",+307%01*(")%&+U5.)%(&6",A

F-&+2-"06%&-",.(&&+"#-./",.%01*("4"+)"#$%&7+"2-03017L_&D&+"6./$,.L%)7+-7,$=.G/19$

m$=.G/.$/R?<8R=4$T1-,.?<325$X2=G4Um$=.G/.$B,?27,/.$T=,.?<325$X2=G4UD$

h.(($0 + -.D6& + U30-a&,.L%)7 + )""%,0%)%,0((" + /. + )50% + 3,UO+2"/&C&'+,03U_&O+9)DA+)103A+\.#1&CU<k

`,-RJ15F@=2,/81=27J1/ $ E:I$6@,01.?168$T=.G/.$/R?<8R=4U

�.3.5. + f)20C&.1&)%. + "% + 6U1*%U-$gB + /.3.L_04"+D.%0-&.1+&+)"30-a.(&0+307%01*(")%&+c+2"1("C0(("+"%6-$%*B + -./,0-(U%* + ")(",($0 + )D$)1$B + ,$/",$B+6"11&/&&+&30.1*("'+E"-D$A

f<H82=$T=.G/.$B,?27,/.U

�.3.5. + %*L%"-. + c + "#0)205&%* + "%6-$%")%*+U5.)%(&6",+(.,)%-05U+&30.1*("'+E"-D0B+,)%-05U+&+00 + ")"/(.(&0B + 2-0,-._0(&0 + ,)%-05& + , + -0)U-)$+501",06.A + \*L%"- + )%.(",&%)7 + "3(&D + &/+2-"06%&-",_&6", + "#-./",.%01*("4" + )"#$%&7+92-"4-.DD$<A + �.3.5. + f)"2-","a30(&7g + 501",06.+2-0,-._.0%)7 + , + /.3.5U + f-./-.#"%6& + .306,.%("4"+"#-./",.%01*("4"+E"-D.%.gA

Q+ 2;=.>27.8,?<34G$=,>R?<8.8.GB + 3")%&4.0D$D +, + )"#$%&'($O+-0a&D.OB+&B+,+5.)%(")%&B+6+-0/U1*%.%.D+307%01*(")%&+%*L%"-.B+D"a("+"%(0)%& + 1&5(")%($' +& + 307%01*(")%($' +2-&-")%B + (",""#-./",.(&7 + ,+"#1.)%&+"2$%.+)U#d06%(")%&B+-0E106)&,($O+UD0(&'+&+-0E106)&,("4"+"2$%.B+"2$%.+).D""2-03010(&7+&+U2-.,10(&7+-0)U-).D&A

:R;S,/83268<k+2")%-"0(&0+("-D$+)"#)%,0(("'+307%01*(")%&B+00+U30-a.(&0B+)""%(0)0(&7+)+6U1*%U-($D&+("-D.D&A+

;?+f\0O("1"4&&+&+D0%"3&6&+%*L%"-)6"'+307%01*(")%&A+\0O("1"4&50)6&'+2.60%+f�0-6.1.ggA+F-"4-.DD.+2",$^0(&7+6,.1&E&6.C&&+f\*L%"-)6"0+)"2-","a30(&0+GZFgB+PZ�+fG()%&%U%+&((",.C&'+,+"#-./",.(&&g+\�lB+\"D)6A

8>:

Page 105: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

+,X?,/61C+ (","4" + "2$%. + 30')%,&7 + , + D"301&-U0D"' + )E0-0+307%01*(")%&B + )"#)%,0(($O + 30E&C&%", + & + )2")"#(")%0'B + )2")"#",+xEE06%&,("4" + 2",030(&7 + , + )&%U.C&& + (0"2-03010((")%&B + )2")"#",+"#U50(&7+,+30')%,&&A+

:.G22@=,-,?,31,9+ 2"/&C&"(("0B + "%(")&%01*(" + (.2-.,10(&'+),"04"+3.1*(0'^04"+"#-./",.%01*("4"+3,&a0(&7B+"2-03010(&0+C010'+&+/.3.5+2-"E0))&"(.1*("4"+&+1&5(")%("4"+-./,&%&7B+)2")"#",+&+"#-./",+-.#"%$+,+6"D.(30B+,+-./1&5($O+2-03D0%($O+)"30-a.(&7OA+

!@=.7?,31,$=,6R=6.G1k +.(.1&/+)"#)%,0(($O+-0)U-)",B +2"&)6+&+)"/3.(&0B+6"(,0-%.C&7+-0)U-)",A

Y2=G1=R,G4,$/2G@,8,3832681$1$RG,31C$RB.J1W6Ck+J+xEE06%&,("0+2",030(&0+,+)&%U.C&&+(0"2-03010((")%&B+J+C0102"1.4.(&0B+J"C0(6.+-0/U1*%.%",+&+2-"3U6%",+307%01*(")%&B+J"-4.(&/.C&"(($0+&+6"DDU(&6.%&,($0+6"D20%0(%(")%&BJ2-"06%(.7+6"D20%0(C&7AF-03D0%"D+-.#"%$+%*L%"-.+7,170%)7 +2;,6@,B,31,$68.327?,31C$

6R;S,/832A2 $ @27,-,31C $ RB.6831/27 $ 2;=.>27.8,?<32A2 $ 62;481CA+l5.)%(&6 + Z! + )%.(",&%)7 + "3(&D + &/ + )U#d06%",B + "2-03017L_&D+2-"&)O"37_00 + , +2-"4-.DD0A +Z#-./",.%01*("0 + 2-")%-.()%," + )"#$%&7+)%.(",&%)7+2-&(C&2&.1*("+@2?16R;S,/834GA+

\*L%"- + ,/.&D"30')%,U0% + ) + -73"D + )U#d06%", + &B + , + 5.)%(")%&B + )+U5.)%(&6.D& + 6.6 + ) + )U#d06%.D&A + \*L%"- + 3"1a0( + U30-a&,.%*+6"DDU(&6.C&L+&+)O0D$+30')%,&'B+2"/,"17L_&0+U)20^("+30')%,",.%*+-./1&5($D+U5.)%(&6.D+2-"4-.DD$A

:2;481534, $ 2;=.>27.8,?<34, $ @=2A=.GG4+ D"4U% + #$%*+-0.1&/",.($+6.6+"%301*("'+^6"1"'+,+-.D6.O+),"0'+"#-./",.%01*("'+2-"4-.DD$B + %.6 + & + 2.-%(0-)6&D& + )0%7D& + -./($O + ^6"1 + &+"#-./",.%01*($O+21"_.3"6B +)&1.D&+"2-03010(("4" +"#-./",.%01*("4"+)""#_0)%,.A+ |%" + D"4U% + #$%* + ")"#$0 + f)"#$%&'($0g + D"3U1&B+-./,"-.5&,.0D$0+2"+"2&).(($D+,$^0+2-&(C&2.DA+�6"1.+,61L5.0%+,+2-",030(&0+)"#$%&'($O+D"3U10'+f")"#$Og+,/-")1$OB+2-"E0))&"(.1",+, + "2-03010(("' + )E0-0 + 307%01*(")%&B + -"3&%010'A + Z2$% + 2.-%(0-)6"J)0%0,"' + "-4.(&/.C&& + "#-./",.%01*($O + )"#$%&' + & + %*L%"-)6"4"+)"2-","a30(&7 + 9f`04&"(.1*($' + )0%0,"' + 2-"06% + !&#&-)6.7+D"1"30a(.7 + m)).D#107gB + f!0%0,"0 + "#-./",.%01*("0 + )"#$%&0+Z1&D2&.3.+`./,&,.L_04"+Z#U50(&7gB+f�.50D+%*L%"-U+2.-%(0-)%,"�gB+fM$)%-.&,.(&0 + 2.-%(0-)6&O + "%("^0(&' + , + -.D6.O + "#-./",.%01*("'+&4-$ + fl(&,0-)&%0%gg< + "2&).( + , + D.%0-&.1.O + 4UD.(&%.-("4"+&))103",.(&7:>A+

#?.661B,6/1, $ 62;481534, $ X2=G.84k + h01",$0 + &4-$A+F"4-Ua0(&7A + h07%01*(")%($0 + & + 6"D20%0(%(")%($0 + "1&D2&.3$A+

:>+ fZ-4.(&/.C&7+2.-%(0-)6"J)0%0,$O+E"-D+,/.&D"30')%,&7+,+"#-./",.(&&g+9RZl+!Z�+f|,-&6.J-./,&%&0g<+2"3+-03A+h"14","'+�ARB+RUO.+PAMAB+NU#76&("'+\AMAB+G/3J,"+f¹°VJ��srtgB+\"D)6B+=>>:A

8>@

Page 106: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

Z#-./",.%01*($' + %U-&/DA + �6"1$ + -./,&%&7A + \-0(&(4&A + Z%6-$%$0+"#-./",.%01*($0+2-"06%$+&+2-"4-.DD$A

M + C017O + "#0)2050(&7 + 6.50)%,0(($O + U)1",&' + 317+&(3&,&3U.1&/.C&& + "#-./",.(&7 + )"#$%&'($0 + -0a&D$ + (0"#O"3&D"+,61L5.%*+,+"#-./",.%01*($0+2-"4-.DD$+^6"1B++)"41.)",$,.%*+)+%"56&+/-0(&7 + )"30-a.(&7B + + ("-D.%&,("J2-.,","4" + & + U2-.,10(50)6"4"+"#0)2050(&7A+

b.-.B1$@,-.A2A.F8<H82=.k• &(&C&&-",.%* + & + "#0)205&%* + 2-"06%&-",.(&0+

"#-./",.%01*($O+)"#$%&'+2"3+6"(6-0%($'+,"/-.)%B+)%U20(*+&+3.a0+317+6"(6-0%("4"+61.)).B+4-U22$+-0#7%w

• "#0)205&,.%* + )"41.)",.(&0 + )"#$%&'($O + & + U50#($O+-0a&D",w

• "#0)205&%* +-./-.#"%6U +("-D.%&,("' +#./$B + "2-03017L_0'+2-",030(&0+)"#$%&'($O+D"3U10'A

h=./81/.$=,.?1>.011$8<H82=6/25$-,C8,?<326817$G2-,?1$ZE;=.>27.8,?<32,$62;481,[

C+ J1+?( & #(37$.$% & 56++M"';ow& 9U5.)%(&6&k + 30%& + "% + YJ8I + 10%B+)%U30(%$B + ,/-")1$0B + )0D*&<A + Z#-./",.%01*(.7 + 2-"4-.DD. + �6"1$+-./,&%&7+(.)$_0(.+-./1&5($D&+"%6-$%$D&+E"-D.%.D&k+-./,&,.L_&0+/.3.5& + P""�0(",)6"4" + %&2.B + %010)($0 + %-0(&(4&B + %,"-50)6&0+D.)%0-)6&0B+"#-./",.%01*($'+%U-&/D+&+2-A+Z#-./",.%01*(.7+2-"4-.DD.+-./,"-.5&,.0%)7+)+8?KI4A+9"(.+"%-.a0(.+,+&/3.(&7Ok+fM"/D"a($0+D&-$A+G(&C&.C&7+%,"-50)6"4" +D$^10(&7gA +l50#A2")"#&0A +Q"1106%&, +.,%A + J+~E&D",+MA!AB+�.2%0,.+mAMAB+~-D.6",+!AMAB+N.-C0,+!AMAB+QU50-",.+MAMAB+R&-60) + RARAAc + R")6,.B + 8??:4w + f`"a30(&0 + -./UD.k + /(.6& + 2U%&g+)#"-(&6 + )%.%0'A + Q-.)("7-)6B + 8??K4A + f�0%(&0 + ^6"1$ + P""�0(k+"#-./",.%01*($'+x6)%-&DA+c+RAk+|,-&6.B+=>>@4AB+J+=:>)A<A+

�(/(*$ & .FU.+#(k + "#0)205&%* + "-&0(%.C&L + U5.)%(&6. + ,+"#-./",.%01*("' + 2-"4-.DD0 + �6"1$B + ,$#"- + D"3U10'B + -0E106)&L+2-"3,&a0(&7B + 2")%.(",6U + /.3.5 + (. + )"#)%,0(("0 + -./,&%&0B+&(&C&.%&,("0 + 3""2-03010(&0 + "#-./",.%01*("4" + 2-")%-.()%,.+U5.)%(&6.D&A + \*L%"- + -.#"%.0% + ) + )U#d06%(")%*LB + -0E106)&0' + &+-0)U-).D&+501",06.A+\*L%"-)%,"+-./,"-.5&,.0%)7+6.6+317+30%0'B+%.6+&+317 + ,/-")1$O + 9-"3&%010'B + 203.4"4",B + )%.a0-",B + 2-")%" + ,/-")1$O+U5.)%(&6",<A +P.+D.%0-&.10+�6"1$+-./,&%&7+P""�0(+-./,"-.5&,.0%)7+F-"4-.DD. + 2",$^0(&7 + 6,.1&E&6.C&& + f\*L%"-)6"0 + )"2-","a30(&0+

:8N&#1&"%06.+6U1*%U-("J"#-./",.%01*($O+&(&C&.%&,+ �tt�k��tzvtAzq�z�urztA�q�z¥¥¥=>>I�sr¯o�º�osA�tp«w+ �tt�+ +k��+ +z�q+ +A++urt�o�ors�u+ +A++�q+ +�++«sº+ +J+ +�u��+ +�=�+ +roo¤zr+ +J+ +v��o«�+ +J+ +�u��st+ +A++�tp«+ +

8>Y

Page 107: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

GZFgB+,+")(",0+6"%"-"'+10a&%+2"4-Ua0(&0++U5.)%(&6",+,+%*L%"-)6UL+2-.6%&6U+&+00+-0E106)&7A

C+ !$:$#01(% & -+?+/"W'(% & >00(-:?"% & 5B#+^"00$$ & :)/)V"T+;&9)%.-^061.))(&6&B + )%U30(%$ + ))U/", + & + ,U/",B + 203.4"4&B+2-032-&(&D.%01&+&+2-"E0))&"(.1$+,+-./1&5($O+,&3.O+307%01*(")%&+!&#&-)6"4" + -04&"(.<A + + m)).D#107 + 2-03)%.,170% + )"#"' + C01")%(UL+"#U5.L_UL + 301",UL + &4-UB + + 6"%"-.7 + -./,"-.5&,.0%)7 + (. + D.%0-&.10+-0.1*($O + &1& + -./-.#.%$,.0D$O + 2-032-&(&D.%01*)6&O + 2-"06%",A+!"#$%&0+(")&%+)"-0,(",.%01*($'+O.-.6%0-B+2"+&%"4.D+-./$4-$,.0%)7+%-&+6"D2106%.+(.4-.3+9Z%6-$%.7+U2-.,10(50)6.7+"1&D2&.3.+fP",$'+&(%01106%gB+N&/(0)J"1&D2&.3.+&+±zºJ"1&D2&.3.+)%.-^061.))(&6",+&+)%U30(%",<A+Q.a3$'+30(*+"2-030170%)7+&(3&,&3U.1*($'+&+4-U22","'+-0'%&(4A + \*L%"-)%," + -./,"-.5&,.0%)7 + , + 3,UO + E"-D.%.Ok + 98< + %*L%"-+)"2-","a3.0%+f),"&Og+-0#7%B+6"%"-$0+2-&0O.1&+)+(&D+&/+04"+^6"1$w+9=<+%*L%"- + -.#"%.0% + ) + 1L#"' + 4-U22"' + U5.)%(&6", + m)).D#10&A +�(/(*$&.FU.+#(Z+ "#0)205&%* + -0E106)&L + U5.)%(&6",B + "-&0(%.C&L + &+,61L50(&0 +, +2-"4-.DDUB +&(&C&.%&,("0 +30')%,&0 +, +-.D6.O + /.3.(("'+&4-$A + P. + D.%0-&.10 + m)).D#10& + -./,"-.5&,.0%)7 + F-"4-.DD.+2",$^0(&7 + 6,.1&E&6.C&& + f\*L%"-)6"0 + )"2-","a30(&0 + GZFgB + ,+")(",0 + 6"%"-"' + J + 2"4-Ua0(&0 + + U5.)%(&6", + , + 2-.6%&6U + %*L%"-)6"4"+)"2-","a30(&7+&+00+-0E106)&7A

C& G:#(3+7(."?F'(% & H#+T#(--( & /?% & -?(/X$2 & X1+?F'$1+7 &

5!+0"/0.7+;+ 9U5.)%(&6&k + D1.3^&0 + ^6"1*(&6& + )0%& + )&#&-)6&O+&((",.C&"(($O +^6"1 + 9=J@ + 61.))$<A +F-"4-.DD. + -./,"-.5&,.0%)7 + 6.6+f2U%0^0)%,&0+,+4")%&+6+)")037Dgk+^6"1*(&6&+&/+(0)6"1*6&O+4"-"3",+,D0)%0 + ) + 203.4"4.D& + 2-&0/a.L% + , + "3&( + &/ + !&#&-)6&O + 4"-"3",+9Q-.)("7-)6B + \"D)6< + 6 + ),"&D + -",0)(&6.DA + M + "%6-$%$O + 2-.6%&6"J"-&0(%&-",.(($O + E"-D.%.O + D1.3^&0 + ^6"1*(&6& + 2-"#UL% + )0#7 + ,+-./1&5($O + )E0-.OA +`./(""#-./&0 + )E0- +2-03)%.,170% + )"#"' + #"1*^"'+)&#&-)6&'+4"-"3+c+(.U5($0+"%6-$%&7+,+1.#"-.%"-&7O+U(&,0-)&%0%",B+2-"#$ + %,"-0(&7 + , + DU/07O + &)6U))%,. + & + D.)%0-)6&O + (.)%"7_&O+OU3"a(&6",+&+)6U1*2%"-",B+2-"#$+2")%.(",6&+,+%0.%-.OB+-./4.3$,.(&0+/.4.3"6 + (. + U1&C.O + 4"-"3.B + 6"D.(3(")%* + & + ,/.&D"2"D"_* + (.+Q-.)("7-)6&O + !%"1#.OB + 2-&5.)%(")%* + 6 + D.)^%.#($D + 501",050)6&D+2-"06%.D+9Q-.)("7-)6.7+�|!<+&+%A3A+l5.)%(&6&+2-"a&,.L%+,+)0D*7OB+5%" + U)&1&,.0% + "#-./",.%01*($' + xEE06% + "%6-$%"4" + )"#$%&'("4"+2-")%-.()%,.A + `0#7%. + -.#"%.L% + , + -./(","/-.)%($O + 4-U22.O + &/+-./1&5($O+4"-"3",A+

\*L%"-+"#0)205&,.0%+,61L50(&0+-0#7%+,+2-"4-.DDUB+-0E106)&L+,+")"#$O + E"-D.OB + .306,.%($O + ,"/-.)%U + 93(0,(&6&B + -&)U(6&B + )6./6&B+(.)%0(($0 + 4./0%$B + 20-E"D.()$ + & + %A3A<A + F" + &%"4.D + 6.a3"' + )0))&&+)"/3.0%)7 + 4./0%. + � + aU-(.1 + � + .1*D.(.O + � + 2-0/0(%.C&7 + � + 6(&4. + �+E"%".1*#"D+�+,&30"E&1*DB+,+6"%"-"'+"%-.a0("+2-"3,&a0(&0+6.a3"4"+

8>I

Page 108: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

U5.)%(&6.A + P. + D.%0-&.10 + f!")03)%,.g + 30')%,U0% + )0%0,"'+203.4"4&50)6&' + )0D&(.-B + (. + 6"%"-"D + "#)Ua3.L%)7 + "#-./",.%01*($0+-0/U1*%.%$+&+&O+3")%&a0(&0+,+-./1&5($O+203.4"4&50)6&O+%0O("1"4&7O+9`ZB + P""�0(B + R"(%0))"-&<B + . + %.6a0 + )"2-","a30(&0 + -0#0(6. + + ,+-./1&5($O+203.4"4&50)6&O+)&)%0D.OA

C& G:#(3+7(."?F'(% & H#+T#(--( & /?% & 0.(#X$2 & /+X1+?F'$1+7 & $&

-?(/X$2&X1+?F'$1+7&$&$2&#+/$."?"4&5L+W/"'$"&�"-?$g+9U5.)%(&6&k+)%.-^&0 + 3"^6"1*(&6& + 930%)6&' + ).3 + R"(%0))"-&< + & + D1.3^&0+^6"1*(&6& + 961.))$ + R"(%0))"-& + (.5.1*("' + ^6"1$B + RZl + !Z�+f|,-&6.J-./,&%&0g<B +-"3&%01&+30%0'B +203.4"4&A +R.%0-&.1"D+7,170%)7+fN"1*^.7 + &)%"-&7g + -"a30(&7 + �0D1&B + a&/(& + (. + �0D10A + M)0 + ,D0)%0+"#)Ua3.L% + f�0(%U + ,-0D0(&gB + -.#"%.L% + 4-U22.D& + (. + D.)%0-)6&OB+2-03)%.,17L%+-0/U1*%.%$+-.#"%$+D.)%0-)6&OB +2-","37%+-0E106)&L+&+/.,0-^.L_00 + 5.02&%&0A + l5.)%(&6& + -.#"%.L% + , + -./(","/-.)%($O+4-U22.OB+,61L5.7+-"3&%010'A

\*L%"-)%,"+-0.1&/U0%)7+-./($D&+)2")"#.D&kJ + 3" + )"#$%&7 + 9f.6%U.1*($' + )%"1g + , + 4-U22.O + 30%0'B + 2")0_0(&0+

DU/07+&+21.(0%.-&7<+c+.6%U.1&/.C&7+&(%0-0).+30%0'+&+,/-")1$O+6+%0D0+)"#$%&7w

J +2")10+)"#$%&7+(.+f-0E106)&,("D+6-U40g+30%&+"2&)$,.L%B +5%"+"(& + )301.1&B + 5%" + 2"1U5&1")*B + 5%" + (0 + 2"1U5&1")*B + f6.6 + 7 + 2"D"4+%",.-&_UB+2"%"DU+5%"+7+)%.-^&'B+7+Ua0+UD0LgB+f6.6+7+2"D"4.1+D.D0+301.%*+3&("/.,-.gB+f6.6+7+D"4U+Ua0+&+#0/+D.D$g+&+2-A

J + ," + ,-0D7 + -0E106)&& + ) + -"3&%017D& + & + 203.4"4.D& + 2-"&)O"3&%+"#D0(+(.#1L30(&7D&+/.+)"#"'+&+),"&D+-0#0(6"DB+/.+%0DB+/.+%0DB+6.6&0+-./($0+#$,.L%+-"3&%01&+&+30%&B+6.6+f2"J-./("DU+D"a("+#$%*+D.D"'+&+2.2"'gw

J+2")10+)"#$%&7+,+"#-./",.%01*("D+2-")%-.()%,0+30%)6"4"+).3.+&+^6"1$+c+203.4"4&50)6.7+-0E106)&7A

F-"4-.DD. + 9, + 5.)%(")%&B + %*L%"-)6"0 + )"2-","a30(&0<+"#0)205&,.0% + 20-0O"3 + -0#0(6. + 9& + )""%,0%)%,UL_00 + )"2-","a30(&0+-"3&%010'+&+)0D*&+,+C01"D<+(.+4-.(&C0+f30%)6&'+).3+c+^6"1.gA

C0 G:#(3+7(."?F'(% & H#+T#(--( & /?% & 0.(#X"1?(00'$1+7&

5D"T(H+?$0Z&0#"/(&$&#"0)#08&:+?FX+T+&T+#+/(;= &l5.)%(&6&k+U50(&6&+)%.-^&O+61.))",+)0%&+&((",.C&"(($O+)&#&-)6&O+^6"1+9Q-.)("7-)6B+\"D)6B +P",")&#&-)6B +Q0D0-","<A +Q.a3.7 + )0))&7 +2-03)%.,170% + )"#"'+27%&3(0,("0 + 2"4-Ua0(&0B + 6"1&50)%," + U5.)%(&6", + c + 3" + Y> + 501",06A+!-03& + U5.)%(&6", + )0))&& + 0)%* + 2-&(&D.L_.7 + )%"-"(. + 9U5.)%(&6&JO"/70,.B + a&,U_&0 + , + 3.(("' + %0--&%"-&&< + & + 2-&41.^0((.7 + )%"-"(.+9U5.)%(&6&J4")%&B + 2-&0/a.L_&0 + &/ + 3-U4&O + 4"-"3",<A + l5.)%(&6&+-.#"%.L% + , + -./(","/-.)%($O + 4-U22.O + &/ + -./($O + 4"-"3",A + `0#7%.D+)%.,&%)7+"#_.7+/.3.5.B+317+-0^0(&7+6"%"-"'+(0"#O"3&D"+,+-0.1*("D+

8>K

Page 109: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

2-")%-.()%,0+4"-"3.+2-",0)%&+&))103",.(&0B+-./-.#"%.%*+D&(&J2-"06%B+04"+.2-"#&-",.%*B+/.%0D+2-03)%.,&%*+-0/U1*%.%$+x6)20-%UA

\*L%"-)6.7 + 307%01*(")%* + (.2-.,10(. + (. + %"B + 5%"#$+)%.-^061.))(&6+(.5.1+"%(")&%*)7+6+4"-"3U+6.6+6+-0)U-)U+)"#)%,0(("4"+-./,&%&7A + M"/(&6.0% + )U#d06%(.7 + 2"/&C&7 + 2" + "%("^0(&L + 6+)"#)%,0(("DU + "#-./",.(&LB + ,$#"-U + ,U/.B + )E0-$ + 307%01*(")%& + ,+#U3U_0DA+

E;=.>27.8,?<32,$62;481,$X,32G,32?2A1B,6/25$768=,B1$6$6201RG2G9$

2@48$-,?2725$1A=4$ZLR=3.?168[

C=I=B)38#"701$4&

Y,32G,32?2A1B,6/.C $ A,=G,3,781/. $ 1 $ 2;=.>27.31,D $h17+2-.6%&6& + 1&5(")%(" + /(.5&D"4" + "#-./",.(&7 + 2-&(C&2&.1*("+U30-a&,.%* + #.1.() + D0a3U + f(.%U-.1&/D"Dg + & + %-.()C0(30(%.1&/D"DB+2"/&%&,&)%)6&D +& + x6/&)%0(C&.1*($DB + "#d06%&,($D+& + )U#d06%&,($D+2"3O"3.D&A + !"41.)(" + FA`&6�-UB + %.6&D + -04U1&-",.(&0D + & + 3"1a(.+/.(&D.%*)7 + E0("D0("1"4&50)6.7 + 40-D0(0,%&6.B + 2$%.L_.7)7+&(%0-2-0%&-",.%* + 2"/&%&,&)%)6&0 + (.U6& + ) + 2"/&C&& + fE&1")"E&&+)D$)1.gA+\"+0)%*+U50(&6+&+203.4"4+6.6+E0("D0("1"4&+D"4U%+)""%(")&%*+"#d06%&,($0 + 3.(($0 + (.U6 + ) + ,"/D"a($D + )U#d06%&,($D + "2$%"DB+f&)2"1*/",.%* +&O +6.6 + )&D2%"D$B +&1& +f&(306)$gB +317 + %.6"4" +"2$%.A+fG(306)$g+3"1a($+2"D"5*+E0("D0("1"4&50)6"DU+"2$%U+"20-&-",.%*+, + )DU%("' + "#1.)%& +20-0O"3. + "% + 3UO",("J%010)("4" + 6 + %010)("DU +6.6+%.6","DUg:=A+|%"+3,&a0(&0+"%+-.3")%&+U/(.,.(&7+"50,&3($O+)D$)1",+6+-.3")%&+-.)^&E-",6&+)D$)1",B+)%"7_&O+/.+(&D&A+m+-.3")%*+U/(.,.(&7+c+x%"+&+0)%*+-.3")%*+"%+2"3-.a.(&7+&300B+5%"+),"')%,0(("B+(.2-&D0-B+%0.%-.1*("' + &4-0A + fG)6U))%,"B + c + )"41.^.0%)7 + �AJ�A�.3.D0- + )+m-&)%"%010DB+c+6.6"4"+#$+-"3.+"("+(&+#$1"e0)%*+-"3+U/(.,.(&7B+6"43.+,D0)%0 + ) + U/(.,.(&0D + U41U#170%)7 + (.^0 + ).D"2"/(.(&0 + &+3",0-&%01*(")%* + (.^&O + "%("^0(&' + ) + D&-"Dg:;A + N"1*^UL + -"1* + ,+&(%0-2-0%.C&&+&4-.0%+xD2.%&50)6"0+2-03J2"(&D.(&0+f20-,"'+,)%-05&g+9MAQ.'/0-B+|A+�%.'40-<::+)+D&-"DA+|%"+20-,"0+D"15.1&,"0+,205.%10(&0B+:=+ !DA +R./$1U+mAhA +�0-D0(0,%&50)6.7 +f"3&))07g +F"17 +`&6�-.A + �� +�0-D0(0,%&6.k+&)%"-&7+&+)",-0D0((")%*A+RAB+8?K@B+)A==:w:;+�.3.D0-+�AJ�A+G)6U))%,"+&+2"3-.a.(&0A���.3.D0-+�AJ�A+m6%U.1*(")%*+2-06-.)("4"A+RAB+8??8B+)A=;Iw::+ QU-6&(. + �AiA + �0-D0(0,%&6. + & + f%0"-&7 + &(%0-2-0%.C&&g + OU3"a0)%,0(("4"+2-"&/,030(&7A+���0-D0(0,%&6.k+&)%"-&7+&+)",-0D0((")%*A+RAB+8?K@B+)A=@IJ=@KB=YYJ=Y?w

8>?

Page 110: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

430 + 2-&"%6-$,.0%)7 + %.7_.7)7 + &)%&(.B + + (0"#O"3&D" + /.%0D+/.E&6)&-",.%*+,+)1",.O+&+)&D,"1.O+&+,)%U2&%*+,+2"1&1"4+-./1&5($O+7/$6",$O + "2&).(&' + & + )%&10'B + 430 + .6%U.1*("' + )%.(",&%)7 + 6U1*%U-.+20-0,"3.A + M + 20-0,"30 + "27%* + a0 + ,.a($ + (0 + %"1*6" + /(.(&0,$0+6"()U1*%.C&&B + (" + 1&5(")%($0 + "#D0($ + -"17D& + (")&%010' + 7/$6", + &+)%&10'A +G(%0-2-0%.C&7 +6.6 +f-05*JD0a3Ug + 9srtz�J��zvv< +2"3-./UD0,.0%+20-0,"35&6.J%"1D.5.B + )%.-.L_04")7 + , + ),"0' + ,(U%-0((0' + 2"/&C&&+U30-a.%* + "2%&D.1*(UL+-"10,UL +3&)%.(C&L +fi + 6.6 + #U3%" + 7/$6","'+(")&%01*+fmg+c+i+).D+c+i+6.6+#U3%"+7/$6","'+(")&%01*+fMgg:@A+

LR=3.?1681/.$Z>-,6<$1$6,5B.6[D F-.6%&50)6&D + 2-&D0-"D+203.4"4&50)6"'+E0("D0("1"4&&+"#-./",.%01*("'+)-03$B+(02-03,/7%"4"+,")2-&7%&7+3.((")%&+D0)%.B +6U1*%U-("4"+&1&+2-&-"3("4"+1.(3^.E%.+D"a0% + )1Ua&%* + -./-.#"%.((.7 + .,%"-"D + )",D0)%(" + ) + RA|2^%0'("D+/"?+7(%&$T#(+fTU-(.1&)%gA

�1.,($D+2-&(C&2"D+,+&4-0+7,170%)7+2-&(C&2+f/30)*+&+)0'5.)gA+Z(+,+),"0"#-./("D+-0.1&)%&50)6"D+.)206%0+),7/.(+)+E0("D0("1"4&50)6&D+2"3O"3"DB + -./-.#"%.(($D + ,-0D7 + |3DU(3"D + �U))0-10D + & + 04"+2")103",.%017D& + 317 + "2&).(&7 + )%-U6%U- + )"/(.(&7 + & + 2-"C0))",+fa&/(0(("4" + D&-.g:YA + !"41.)(" + x%"DU + 2"3O"3UB + f2"%"6 + )"/(.(&7g+501",06.+-.))D.%-&,.0%)7+6.6+%.6","'B+,+5&)%"D+,&30B+"%,1050(("+"%+(.4-Ua0(("4" + 2)&O"1"4&50)6&D& + ")"#0((")%7D& + & + 6U1*%U-("'+%-.3&C&0' + ,")2-&7%&7 + D&-.A + F")6"1*6U + f2"%"6 + )"/(.(&7g + ,)043.+&(%0(C&"(.10(+&+2-03D0%0(B+%"+2-&+E0("D0("1"4&50)6"D+2"3O"30+"(+"6./$,.0%)7 + "#-._0( + f6 + ).D&D + ,0_.DgB + (.2-&D0-B + 6 + fD0)%.Dg + &+f)&%U.C&7Dg+"#$30(("'+)"C&.1*("'+a&/(&+6.6+"(&+7,17L%)7+,+(06"0D+(.&,("D + ,")2-&7%&&B + (0/.^"-0(("D + )%0-0"%&2.D& + & + &30"1"40D.D&+f/30)*+&+)0'5.)gA+

\.6"0+,")2-&7%&0+D&-.+,+,&30+fD"D0(%.1*("4"+)(&D6.g+9f)0'J*(0&(.+(","D+D0)%0g<+)%.(",&%)7+2"10/($D+&+x,-&)%&50)6&D+,+)"C&.1*("'+.(.1&%&60 + ,""#_0 + & + ," + ,3UD5&,"' + aU-(.1&)%&60 + , + 5.)%(")%&A+Z#-0%.0%)7 + 1&5(")%($'B + (" + 2-& + x%"D + & + , + ")(",("D + #0/"C0("5($'+,/4173+(.+,0_&+&+)"#$%&7A+S($D+aU-(.1&)%.DB+0_0+(0+/.4-Ua0(($D+2-"E0))&"(.1*($D&+^.#1"(.D&+&+,/-")1"'+6U1*%U-"'B +2-&)U_+x%"%+)2"(%.(($'+&+2.-.3"6).1*("+)U#6U1*%U-($'+,/4173B+")%.,17L_&'+,(0+E"6U).+)"C&.1*($'+f417(0CgA

!"+),"&D+(.&,($DB+f/./0D10(($Dg+,/4173"D+(.+)"C&.1*($'+D&-+U5.)%(&6& + &3U% + (0 + 2-",0-7%* + /.3.((UL + , + ^6"10 + %0"-&LB + .+:@+!DA+�.3.D0-+yAJ�A+\06)%+&+&(%0-2-0%.C&7A���0-D0(0,%&6.+&+306"()%-U6C&7A+!F#AB+8???B+)A==IJ==Kw:Y + !DA + �U))0-1* + |A + Q-&/&) + 0,-"20')6&O + (.U6 + & + %-.()C0(30(%.1*(.7+E0("D0("1"4&7A+!F#AB+=>>:w+�L%C+mA+!D$)1",.7+)%-U6%U-.+2",)03(0,("4"+D&-.k+"50-6& + 2" + E0("D0("1"4&50)6"' + )"C&"1"4&&A +RAB + =>>;w + y0--D.(( +jAJMA + E"(A+F"(7%&0+E0("D0("1"4&&+U+y.'30440-.+&+�U))0-17A+\"D)6B+8??Iw+!D&-(",.+PARA+Z% + )"C&.1*("' +D0%.E&/&6& + 6 +E0("D0("1"4&& + f0)%0)%,0(("' + U)%.(",6&gA +RAB+8??Iw+j&1&22",+mAjA+!"C&"1"4&7+2-")%-.()%,.A+!F#AB+=>>Kw

88>

Page 111: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

,$-.#.%$,.%*+)"#)%,0((ULA+Z(&+"),.&,.L%+%.6"'+D0%"3+)"C&.1*($O+(.U6 + 6.6 + fU5.)%,UL_00 + (.#1L30(&0gB + 3.L_00 + f5U,)%," + )&%U.C&&gB+2"D"4.L_00+,+,$-.#"%60+4&2"%0/B+6"%"-$0+D"4U%+#$%*+20-0)D"%-0($+2" + D0-0 + -")%. + /(.(&'A + |%"% + D0%"3 + &D00% + &4-",UL + )%-U6%U-U + &+2"/,"170% + U,&30%* + , + "E&C&.1*($O + &()%&%UC&7O + & + 2-.,&1.O+(0"E&C&.1*("0B +, +2-&,$5($OB +(0&(%0-0)($O+D0)%.O +(02-&,$5("0 +&+&(%0-0)("0A + P05%" + 2"3"#("0 + 2-"&)O"3&% + & + , + )"C&.1*("JE0("D0("1"4&50)6&O + &))103",.(&7O + x%("D0%"3"1"4", + 9�A�.-E&(601*B+mA!&6U-01B +yA�.6)B +FAR.6Jy*L+&+3-A<A +h17+(&O+x6)%-."-3&(.-($0+&+"-3&(.-($0++)"#$%&7B+30')%,&7+&+,0_&+"3&(.6","+,.a($A

M + 2-"C0))0 + )"C&.1*("JE0("D0("1"4&50)6"4" + aU-(.1&)%)6"4"+&))103",.(&7 + )",0-^.0%)7 + 3,"'(.7 + 2-"#10D.%&/.C&7B +#(0%&2&/.C&7k+50-0/+&4-U+306"()%-U&-U0%)7+2-"E0))&"(.1*($'+aU-(.1&)%)6&'+D&-+6.6 + f%&2&/.C&7 + ,%"-"4" + 2"-736.gB + . + 50-0/ + -"10,UL + f6.6 + #$+aU-(.1&)%)6UL+U)%.(",6Ug+,"+,)%-050 +f/30)* +& +)0'5.)g +) +"#d06%"D+2",)03(0,("4" + fD&-.g + 306"()%-U&-U0%)7 + f%&2&/.C&7 + 20-,"4"+2"-736.gA + \0D + ).D$D + 2-&"%6-$,.0%)7 + 2"31&((" + #$%&'(.7 + 2-&-"3.+)"C&.1*("4"+2"-736. +& +, +(0DB +6.6 +, + /0-6.10B +U5.)%(&6&+) +-.3")%*L+U/(.L%+&+(.5&(.L%+")"/(.,.%*+1&5(")%("J/(.5&D$0+2-.,&1.A

M + %.6"' + )"C&.1*("' + .(.1&%&60 + fD0)%gB + fD&-",g + L($0+aU-(.1&)%$+,)%-05.L%+&+&)2"1*/UL%+6.6+f&(306)&5($0+,$-.a0(&7gB+%.6 + & + f"#d06%&,($0 + ,$-.a0(&7gA + fG(306)&5($0 + ,$-.a0(&7+"2&)$,.L%+"#d06%$+)+%"56&+/-0(&7+&O+")"#0(($OB+U(&6.1*($O+6.50)%,B+& +2"x%"DU +"(&+),7/.($+) +6"(%06)%"DB + , +6"%"-"D+"(& +&)2"1*/UL%)7A+Z#d06%&,($0+,$-.a0(&7B+(.2-"%&,B+"2&)$,.L%+"#_&0+),"')%,.+),"&O+"#d06%",B +%"+0)%*+%0B +#1.4"3.-7+6"%"-$D+"#d06%+,")2-&(&D.0%)7+6.6+%&2&50)6&'B+6.6+2-03)%.,&%01*+%&2.+&B+)103",.%01*("B+6.6+),"#"3($'+"%+6"(%06)%.+c+2"+6-.'(0'+D0-0+2-&D0(&%01*("+6+(.1&5("'+C01&+%"4"B+6%"+%.6+04"+"2&)$,.0%g:IA+M+2"1UJ&4-","'+9E0("D0(+&D0(("+f301","'+&4-$g< + 2"/&C&& + f(.&,("4" + aU-(.1&)%.JE0("D0("1"4.g + (.O"37%+)"50%.(&0 + & + %0B + & + 3-U4&0B + )",D0_.L%)7 + f#$%",.7g + aU-(.1&)%&6.+9f%&2&/.C&7 + 20-,"4" + 2"-736.g< + & + fE"-D.1*("0g + aU-(.1&)%)6"0+D$^10(&0+9f%&2&/.C&7+,%"-"4"+2"-736.g<A+M+1"4&60+&4-$+2-"&)O"3&%+50-03",.(&0B +6.6+#$+,-0D0((.7+2-&")%.(",6.+%"+"3("4"B +%"+3-U4"4"A+P.5&(.0% + a0 + E0("D0("1"4&50)6&' + aU-(.1&)% + ),"L + -.#"%U + + 2-&+,)%-050+)+fD&-"Dg+f)6"-00+)+%"4"B+5%"+,&3&%B+50D+)+%"4"B+5%"+3UD.0%g+9haA+!x/0)<A

M + x6)2-0))J.(.1&%&60 + 2",)03(0,("' + a&/(&B + O.-.6%0-("' + 317+301","' + &4-$ + fTU-(.1&)%gB + ,.a(" + ,205.%10(&0 + f/30)* + & + )0'5.)gA+�","-7%+f20-,"0+,205.%10(&0+"#D.(5&,"gB+("+x%"+"%(")&%)7+6+(.^0'+f0)%0)%,0(("'+U)%.(",60g+,")2-&7%&7+)"C&.1*("4"+D&-.B+,")2-&7%&7B+"#U)1",10(("4" + %&2&5($D& + "#$30(($D& + 2-.,&1.D& + %.6"4"J%"+C0((")%("4" +"%("^0(&7 +6 + fD0)%Ug +&1& +f)&%U.C&&gA +fmB + x%" +2-")%"+

:I+ j&1D0-+FA+Z#+x%("D0%"3"1"4&&+�.-"1*3.+�.-E&(6017A+ ��P",$0+(.2-.,10(&7+,+)"C&"1"4&50)6"'+%0"-&&A+RAB+8?IKB+)A;;Yw

888

Page 112: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

-./,.1&($egB+fZ#$5($'+/.,"3+c+(&504"+")"#0(("4"egB+fF"(.0O.1&+%U%eg+c+x%"+,/4173+(.+2",)03(0,($0+)C0($+a&/(&A+

h01" + , + %"DB + 5%" + , + &4-0J%" + U + U5.)%(&6", + f(00)%0)%,0((.7+U)%.(",6.g+,")2-&7%&7B+U)1",("J-"10,.7+U)%.(",6.+&_U_04"+)D$)1$+aU-(.1&)%.A + Z(& + (0 + %"1*6" + ,&37% + D0)%.J)C0($ + , + ")(",("D+(02-0/0(%.#01*("' + &1& + a0 + 2-&,$5(" + 2-0/0(%.#01*("' + )"C&.1*("'+a&/(&+6.6+"(&+0)%*+).D&+2"+)0#0B+("+&+2$%.L%)7B+&)O"37+&/+x%"'+5&)%"'+3.((")%&B+-.)^&E-",.%*+x%&+D0)%.B+"%6-$%*+&O+2"%.0(($0+)%-U6%U-$+&+EU(6C&&w+301.L%+x%"+L($0+aU-(.1&)%$+0_0+#0/+4-U/.+&30"1"40D+&1&+f/(.(&0,$Og +^.#1"(",B + #U3U5& +3.106. +"% + )"C&.1*("' +2",)03(0,("'+2-.6%&6&B + ^6"1. + 2-03)%.,170% + 00 + , + U6-U2(0(("D + & + 2"1&%&50)6&+20-0-.#"%.(("D + ,&30A + h01",.7 +a0 + &4-. + fTU-(.1&)%g + 2-"O"3&% + ,(0+"#U50(&7B+U5&%01*)6"'+C0(/U-$+&+&a3&,0(50)6"'+2"/&C&&+U50(&6.A+M+(0'+0)%*+1&5(")%(.7+"%,0%)%,0((")%* +U5.)%(&6",+/. +O.-.6%0-+),"04"+2-0#$,.(&7+,+aU-(.1&)%)6"'+-"1&B+0)%*+-&)6+&+,")%"-4+a&,"'+,)%-05&+) + (0&/,03.(($D + , + #1&a.'^0D + D&-0B + 0)%* + ).D".6%U.1&/.C&7 + ,+20-)"(.1*("D+&+6"1106%&,("D+%,"-50)%,0A

j0("D0("1"4&50)6&'+2"3O"3+,+&4-0+fTU-(.1&)%g+,$2"1(70%)7+(0+)%-"4"k+)"C&"6U1*%U-($'+6"(%06)%+,D0^&,.0%)7+,+)&%U.C&L+f/30)*+&+)0'5.)g + ,")2-&7%&7 +D0)% + 2")0_0(&7 +L($D& +aU-(.1&)%.D&B + ,1&70%+%.6a0 + & + /.3.,.0D.7 + "-4.(&/.%"-.D& + %. + &1& + &(.7 + %0D. + &4-$A+\0D.%&50)6&0 + -.6U-)$ +&))103",.(&7 + x%&O +D0)% + %.6a0 +2-031.4.L%)7+U5.)%(&6.D + (. + ")(",0 + E0("D0("1"4&50)6"4" + 2"3O"3.B + (" + 2-&+&)2"1*/",.(&& + 2-&(C&2. + (02"1("'B + %0D.%&50)6"' + -03U6C&&A+F"3-"#(00+"+%0D.O+)6.a0D+3.100B+2"6.+"#-.%&D)7+6+"-4.(&/.C&"(("J203.4"4&50)6&DB + 2-03J2-"E0))&"(.1*($DB + + 2-"E"-&0(%.C&"(("J&4-",$D+2-&(C&2.DB+(.+6"%"-$O+)%-"&%)7+1"4&6.+&+.14"-&%D+&4-$A

h=1301@ $ .88=./0123.+ 9"% + .(41A +i��li��nfp+ c + 2-&%7a0(&0B+2-&,106.%01*(")%*<A + F-&%74.%01*(")%* + 317 + 2"3-")%6", + x%"' + &4-$+/.61L5.0%)7+,+2-035U,)%,&&+&D&+,"/D"a(")%&+-.)6-$%*+(06&0+%.'($+,/-")1"4"+)"C&UD.B+2-&6")(U%*)7+6+"#$5("+f/.2-0%("DU+21"3Ug+2"6.+(03")74.0D"' + /. + &()%&%UC&"(.1*($D& + #.-*0-.D& + 2-"E0))&&B+7,17L_0')7B + 2"a.1U'B + "3("' + &/ + ).D$O + 2U#1&5($O + & + ,1&7%01*("'+9f50%,0-%.7+,1.)%*g<+,+)",-0D0(("D+D&-0A+|%"%+2-&(C&2+)""%(")&%)7+)" + )%-0D10(&0D + 2"3-")%6. + )%.%* + (0/.,&)&D$D + "% + -"3&%01*)6"' + &+U5&%01*)6"'+"206&B+)+a01.(&0D+2"1U5&%*+U3","1*)%,&0B+"%,105*)7+"%+U($1"'+U50#$+,+)"C&.1*("J/(.5&D"DA

h=1301@$@=1/?HB,31CD+ !"41.)("+x%"DU+2-&(C&2U+)"/3.L%)7+(0"a&3.(($0+)&%U.C&&+,$2"1(0(&7+aU-(.1&)%)6&O+/.3.(&'B+U)1",&7+2")0_0(&7+2"-"'+)",0-^0(("+(0/(.6"D$O+D0)%B+2-&(7%&7+-0^0(&'+&+&))103",.(&7 + f/30)* + & + )0'5.)gA + |%" + %"% + 1046&' + )"C&.1*($' + -&)6B+x6)%-&D + )#"-. + & + "#-.#"%6& + aU-(.1&)%)6"4" + D.%0-&.1. + f) + 6"10)gB+6"%"-$'+%.6+2-&)U_+2)&O"E&/&"1"4&50)6"'+2-&-"30+2"3-")%6",A+|%"+%"% + )1U5.'B + 6"43. + 317 + -0#7% + )"/3.L%)7 + #0/"2.)($0 + U)1",&7 + 317+2-&61L50(&'+f(.+),"'+a&/(0(($'+&+2"/(.,.%01*($'+"2$%gA

88=

Page 113: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

h=1301@ $ 768=,B1D+ l5.)%(&6& + 2"1U5.L% + ,"/D"a(")%*+2"2-"#",.%* + )0#7 + , + -0.1*(" + ,")%-0#",.(("D + 3010 + ,D0)%0 + )"+),0-)%(&6.D& +& +,/-")1$D&J2-"E0))&"(.1.D&A +M)%-05. +(. +&4-0 +c +(0+%"1*6" + 2-"3U6%&,("0 + "#_0(&0 + , + -./(""#-./($O + 4-U22.OB + (" + &+).D",")2-&7%&0B + ).D"2"/(.(&0B + ,)%-05. + ) + )"#)%,0(($D&+,"/D"a(")%7D&A + F"7,170%)7 + U(&6.1*($' + ^.() + "%6-$%* + (",$0+)D$)1",$0 + E&4U-$ + , + 2-&,$5("D + )"C&.1*("D + E"(0B + ,)%-0%&%*)7 + )+"#$5(" + (0 + /.D05.0D$D& + ,0_0)%,0(($D& + & + a&,$D&+f&(3&,&3U.1*(")%7D&g+D&-.+&+2""#_.%*)7+)+(&D&A

h=1301@ $ >,=/.?.D+ M$)%-.&,.0%)7 + &4-",.7 + 307%01*(")%*B+U5.)%(&6& + )"#)%,0(($D& + aU-(.1&)%)6&D& + )-03)%,.D& + "%-.a.L%+U,&30(("0 +& +U)1$^.(("0 +, +D0)%.O +2")0_0(&7B +20-03.,.7 + x%" +50-0/+2U#1&6.C&&B + .3-0)",.(($0 + 5&%.%017DB + a&%017D + &1& + -.#"%(&6.D+2-032-&7%&'A

h=1301@ $ -,?.D+ l + U5.)%(&6", + 0)%* + ,"/D"a(")%* + )"/3.%*+-0.1*(UL+4./0%U+9,+205.%("D+&+x106%-"(("D+,&30<B+2"%-0(&-",.%*)7+,+-./,&%&&+6"DDU(&6.%&,($OB+aU-(.1&)%)6&O+&+&/3.%01*)6&O+(.,$6",B+-.)^&-&%*+),"'+a&/(0(($'+&+"#-./",.%01*($'+6-U4"/"-A

h=1301@ $ 8=.36X2=G,=.D+ F-& + )"O-.(0(&& + "#_04"+.14"-&%D&50)6"4" + )%0-a(7 + 6"()%-U6C&7 + &4-$ + 3"2U)6.0% + (06"%"-$0+)%-U6%U-($0B+EU(6C&"(.1*($0+&+)"30-a.%01*($0+,.-&.C&&+(.+6.a3"D+x%.20+&1&+%0D0A +h.(($'+2-&(C&2+30')%,U0% +%"1*6"+2-&+)"#1L30(&&+,)0O + ,$^020-05&)10(($OA +j"-D. +2-& + )"O-.(0(&& + )U%& +&4-$+D"a0%+D0(7%*)7 +%"1*6" +, +"4-.(&50(($O+2-0301.OA +M+2-"%&,("D+)1U5.0+x%"+Ua0+(0+301",.7+&4-.+fTU-(.1&)%gB+.+5%"J%"+3-U4"0A+ h=1301@ $ X.61?18.011+ 9(0(.,7/5&,"' + 2"330-a6&<A + F-&(C&2+

6.).0%)7+2)&O"1"4"J203.4"4&50)6"'+2"/&C&&+,/-")1$O+9"-4.(&/.%"-",B+6"()U1*%.(%",<A + F-0a30 + ,)04"B + &D00%)7 + , + ,&3U + 3"#-"a01.%01*("J301","0 + "%("^0(&0 + 6 + U5.)%(&6.D + 6.6 + (.-.,(0 + ) + 2-"E0))&"(.1.D&+,$2"1(7L_&D + )"C&.1*("J/(.5&DUL + -.#"%UA + M/-")1$0 + )"/3.L%+"2%&D.1*(UL+)-03UB+,"/30-a&,.7)*+"%+(.)%.,10(&'+&+-0/6&O+"C0("6B+,+/.%-U3(&%01*($O+)&%U.C&7O+&)2"1*/UL%+%.6%&5($0+(.D06&J2"3)6./6&B+U30-a&,.7 + (0"#O"3&D" + & + 3")%.%"5(" + ^&-"6&0 + -.D6& + 30')%,&7+U5.)%(&6",+,+)""%,0%)%,&&+)+/.D$)1"D+&+1"4&6"'+&4-$A+

E632734,$@=1301@4$=.;284$7$Z/2=@R3/8.W[$TG,68.WU9J+&/+D&(&DUD.+&(E"-D.C&&+3"#$%*+D.6)&DUDwJ+")"#"0+,(&D.(&0+6+/".(?%-+D0)%.wJ+2"2-"#",.%*+"_U%&%*+D0)%"+(0+%"1*6"+)+4-U22"'B+("+&+,+"3&("56UwJ+2"2$%.%*)7+(.2&).%*+(0)6"1*6"+)%-"6+2-7D"+(.+D0)%0wJ + #$%* + )D0100 + , + ,$-.a0(&& +D$)10' + & + 5U,)%, + 2")10 + ,")2-&7%&7+

)"#$%&7wJ + (0 + "%1U5.%*)7 + &/ + 6"-2U(6%. + #0/ + U,03"D10(&7 + ,/-")1"4"+

6"()U1*%.(%.wJ+&)2"1*/",.%*+&4-","0+,-0D7+)+D.6)&D.1*("'+2"1*/"'+317+-./,&%&7+

)0#7+6.6+aU-(.1&)%.A+

88;

Page 114: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

f,G.81B,6/1,$262;,332681$7$@2-A2827/,$1$@=27,-,311$1A=4\0D. + )"30-a.%01*(" + (.)$_.0% + &B + , + (06"%"-"' + )%020(&B+

"-4.(&/.C&"(("+%-.()E"-D&-U0%+1"4&6U+301","'+&4-$+fTU-(.1&)%gA+M + (.^0D + "2$%0 + 2-"-.#"%.($ + 50%$-0 + %&2. + %0D.%&50)6&O + &4- + 9,+-061.D($O+2-&41.^0(&7O+&+(.+2-"4-.DD.O+D$+x%&+%&2$+%-.3&C&"(("+"#"/(.5.0D+-&D)6&D&+C&E-.D&<k+VA fTU-(.1&)%k + �0-6.1" + 317 + -.'"(.g+ 9,"/D"a($ + ,.-&.(%$k+f�0-6.1"+317+-04&"(.gB+f�0-6.1"+317+4"-"3.g+&+%A3A<

VVA fTU-(.1&)% +VVk +{0D2&"(.%g+ 96"D.(3("0+20-,0()%,"+2"+301","'+&4-0+)+-.)6-$%&0D+1L#"'B+("+(0+)1&^6"D+%-U3("'+2"3%0D$<

VVVA fTU-(.1&)% +VVVA + Q"D.(3&-",6.g+ 9(.2-&D0-B + , + &1& + (.+Q&-",)6&'+/.,"3g<

V­AfTU-(.1&)%+V­A+m6%U.1*(.7+2-"#10D.g+9(.2-&D0-B+fF&%0-JVrtz�Jrutsoru«gB + f�.#$%$0 + 2.D7%(&6& + F0%0-#U-4.gB + fR.1$0 + DU/0&+F0%-"4-.3)6"'+)%"-"($g<

`./,&%&0 + %0D + ," + D("4"D + "2-030170%)7 + &D0L_&D&)7+)"C&.1*($D&B + 6U1*%U-($D& + & + x6"("D&50)6&D& + -0)U-).D& + %"4"+-04&"(.B+430+#U30%+2-","3&%*)7+&4-.A+F-03)%.,10(&0+"#+")"#0((")%7O+-0)U-)", + c + %,"-50)6&OB + 6.3-",$OB + &()%&%UC&"(.1*($O + c + 2"/,"170%+")%.(",&%* + ,$#"- + (. + %"' + &1& + &("' + %0D0A + N"1*^UL + -"1* + &4-.0%+a01.(&0 + U,&30%* + , + "#$5("D + (0"#$5("0 + & + , + (0"#$5("D + /(.6"D"0B+,)D"%-0%*)7+,+6.6"'J1&#"+)"C&"6U1*%U-($'+"#d06%B +"#-.%&%*)7+6+04"+2",)03(0,("DU + #$%&LA + |%" + "3(",-0D0((" + & + aU-(.1&)%)6.7B + &+2)&O"1"4"J203.4"4&50)6.7B + & + )"C&.1*("JE&1")"E)6.7+&))103",.%01*)6.7+2"/&C&7A+

!.D"0+U,106.%01*("0+2")10+,$#"-.+%0D$+/.61L5.0%)7+,+2"3#"-0+D0)% + 2")0_0(&7B + &1& + 6"-2U(6%", + 317 + U5.)%(&6", + &4-$A + �30)* + 0)%*+(0)6"1*6" + 6-&%0-&0,A+ C+,H"#782R+ "(& + 3"1a($ + #$%* + 3")%.%"5("+"-&4&(.1*($D&B+x6/"%&5($D&+,+6"(%06)%0+#U3(&5("'+a&/(&B+,+6.6"DJ%"+)D$)10+D.1"/(.6"D$D&A+C+,7.+#82R+"(&+D"4U%+(.D06.%*+(.+6.6"0J%"+f/.6U1&)*0gB+(.+/.4.36&+&O+)"C&.1*("'+f6UO(&g+9(.2-&D0-B+(0+D("4&0+2")0_.L%+)%.3&"($+)+103","'+.-0("'B+("+0_0+D0(*^0+,""5&L+/(.6"D$+)+2-"C0))"D+00+"#)1Ua&,.(&7<A+C,.#".F$2R+"(&+3"1a($+#$%*+-0.1*("+3")74.0D$D&A +C,*".7"#.82R+ (0"#O"3&D" + &O + )%-U6%U-("0 + &+EU(6C&"(.1*("0+-./(""#-./&0+,+-.D6.O+,$#-.(("'+%0D$+96+2-&D0-UB+(0+)%"&%+"4-.(&5&,.%*)7+%"1*6"+4")U3.-)%,0(($D&+U5-0a30(&7D&+&1&+%"1*6"+2-032-&7%&7D&+"3("'+"%-.)1&<A+C,H%.82R+a01.%01*("B+5%"#$+(.+D0)%.O + L($0 + aU-(.1&)%$ + D"41& + ,)%-0%&%*)7 + (0 + %"1*6" + )+2-03)%.,&%017D& + .3D&(&)%-.C&&B + (" + & + -73",$D& + )"%-U3(&6.D& + &+61&0(%.D&+9(.2-&D0-B+2")0_0(&0+"%301.+E030-.1*("'+D&4-.C&"(("'+)1Ua#$+O"-"^"+#$+3"2"1(&%*+,&/&%"D+(.+D0)%($'+,0_0,"'+-$("6B+430+D"4U% + "#&%.%* + 61&0(%$ + x%"4" + "%301.<A +C,X"0.82R+ &D07 + , + ,&3U+,-0D0(("'+-041.D0(%+&+.14"-&%D+&4-$B+)103U0%+%.6+2"3#&-.%*+D0)%.+

88:

Page 115: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

2")0_0(&7B+5%"#$+"(&+"#-./",$,.1&+3")%.%"5("+21"%($'+D.-^-U%($'+6U)%+)+")(",.(&0D+,+^%.#0+&4-$A

P.+2"34"%",&%01*("D+x%.20B +2-&D0-("+/.+D0)7C+3"+(.5.1.B +D$+2-&)%U2.0D+6+D"(&%"-&(4U+D0)%+2")0_0(&7+9)#"-+&(E"-D.C&&+50-0/+G(%0-(0%B + /,"(6&B + )2-.,"5(&6&B + U)%.(",10(&0 + 3"4","-0((")%& + "+,)%-05.O<A + M + )1U5.0 + ,$#"-. + %0D$ + fQ"D.(3&-",6.g + "-4.(&/.%"-.D+,.a(" + 2"#$,.%* + (. + D0)%0B + 5%"#$ + /.%0D + 2" + ),"&D + ,205.%10(&7D+9(0"%74"_0(($D + /.6./"D + 6.6"4"J%" + -U6","3)%,.< + 2-&)%U2&%* + 6+)")%.,10(&L + -.6U-)", + &))103",.(&7B + "2-03010(&L + ,"/D"a($O+,"2-")",B + 6"%"-$0 +#U3U% +"-&0(%&-",.%* + U5.)%(&6", +&4-$ +, + )#"-0 +&+"#-.#"%60 +&(E"-D.C&&+(. +D0)%.OA +Z% +(02")-03)%,0(("4" +"_U_0(&7+D0)%. + /.,&)&% + O.-.6%0- + E0("D0("1"4&50)6"' + E"6U)&-",6&B+)"/3.,.0D"' + "-4.(&/.%"-.D& + , + ,&30 + )"30-a.(&7 +B(-%.1$ & /?%&W)#'(?$0.(&`0-=&B#$?+W"'$"aA$

#238R=4$2;=.>27.8,?<34W$@,=6@,/817$1A=4D+Z#-./",.%01*($'+2"%0(C&.1 + 2"3O"3", + & + D0%"3", + 301","' + &4-$ + fTU-(.1&)%g+-./(""#-./0( + & + 41U#"6A + y"%7B + 6"(05("B + 20-0O"3 + &/ + ,"/D"a(")%& + ,+30')%,&%01*(")%*+"#U)1",10(+(0+%"1*6"+xEE06%&,(")%*L+).D"'+&30&B+(" + & + 3.1*(0'^&D + "),"0(&0D + )"C&"6U1*%U-("4"B + x6"("D&50)6"4" + &+"#-./",.%01*("4"+6"(%06)%",B+6"%"-$0+2-03")%.,170%+)"C&UD+)0'5.)+&+2-03")%.,&% + , + #U3U_0DA +M + 3.(("0 + ,-0D7 + x%" + "),"0(&0 + "6./$,.0%)7+2-"#10D.%&5($D + &/J/. + %"4"B + 5%" + )",-0D0((.7 + -"))&')6.7+30')%,&%01*(")%* + 5U-.0%)7 + 30D"6-.%&50)6&O + & + 4UD.(&)%&50)6&O+&(&C&.%&, + & + ),7/.(($O + ) + (&D& + D0%"3"1"4&' + .1*%0-(.%&,($O+%-.3&C&"(($D + .,%"-&%.-("J&()%-UD0(%.1*($D + & + D.(&2U17%&,("J307%01*(")%($D+2"3O"3.DA+

P.-73U+)"+)30-a&,.L_&D&+%0(30(C&7D&+2-"3"1a.L%+-./,&,.%*)7+%.6&0 + #1&/6&0 + (.^0' + &4-0 + )E0-$ + 6.6 ++#T('$3(9$+''+"&1+'0)?F.$#+7('$"+ & +T#)HH+7(% &H0$2+."#(H$%A +Z(&+3.L%+(.30a3U+(.+U)20^("0+"),"0(&0+U6./.(($O+)"C&.1*("Jx6"("D&50)6&O+6"(%06)%",+&+2"/&%&,("0 + ,&30(&0 + "#-./",.%01*($O + 20-)206%&, + 301","' + &4-$+fTU-(.1&)%gA +~)%* +50%6&0 + 6"(%U-$ +00 +"#-./",.%01*($O +20-)206%&,B+&30&B + "2&-.L_&0)7 + (. + 6"(6-0%($' + .,%"-)6&' + "2$% + 2-&D0(0(&7+&4-",$O+D0%"3&6+&+%0O("1"4&'+,+)E0-0+^6"1*("4"+&+3"2"1(&%01*("4"+"#-./",.(&7 + 94&D(./&7 +H@YB +^6"1. +H@> + & +Z#-./",.%01*($' +C0(%-+fl5.)%&0g + , + !.(6%JF0%0-#U-40B + Mh� + fZ-10("6g + , + Q-.)("3.-)6"D+6-.0<A+

F-.6%&6"J"-&0(%&-",.((.7 + 2-"4-.DD.B + , + 6"%"-"' + hG+fTU-(.1&)%g + &4-.0% + 61L50,UL + -"1*B + )D"a0% + (.301&%* + -0.1*($D+2-.4D.%&50)6&D + )D$)1"D + & + .(.1&%&50)6&D + )"30-a.(&0D + (0 + %"1*6"+2-"E"-&0(%.C&"((UL + 307%01*(")%*B + (" + & + ^6"1*($0 + #./",$0 + &+x106%&,($0 + 6U-)$ + 2" + x6"("D&60 + & + )"C&"1"4&&B + D0(03aD0(%U + &+D.-60%&(4UB+aU-(.1&)%&60+&+),7/7D+)+"#_0)%,0((")%*LA

88@

Page 116: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

~_0 + "3(&D +^%-&O"D + 6 + 6"(%U-.D + "#-./",.%01*($O + 20-)206%&,+&4-$+D"a0% +)1Ua&%* +&307 +00 +&)2"1*/",.(&7 +, +2-"4-.DD0+.6%&,("4"+"%3$O. +2"3-")%6", + , + )&)%0D0 + /.4"-"3($O +"/3"-",&%01*($O +1.40-0'B+%U-&)%&50)6&O + & + 61U#("J-"10,$O + )10%", + (. + 2-&-"30B + . + %.6a0+-./1&5($O + U50#($O + x6)203&C&'A + M + 5.)%(")%&B + E0("D0("1"4&50)6&'+2"3O"3B + 2-&(C&2$ + & + )%-U6%U-. + &4-$ + D"4U% + #$%* + U)20^("+.3.2%&-",.($+6+&D0L_&D)7+2)&O"1"4"J203.4"4&50)6&D+-./-.#"%6.D+,+3&3.6%&60 + )",-0D0(("4" + x%&50)6&J"-&0(%&-",.(("4" + x6"1"4&50)6"4"+"#-./",.(&7 + & + &)%"-&6"Jx%("4-.E&50)6"4" + 6-.0,030(&7A + l + .,%"-",+&4-$ + &D00%)7 + 3"2"1(&%01*($' + (.#"- + D0%"3&6B + 2"/,"17L_&' + x%"+)301.%*A

h2>181734,$=,>R?<8.84I$@26?,-,56871,! M)%-05. + D"1"30a& + ) + -0.1*($D& + 2-"#10D.D& + , + -0.1*("'+

)"C&.1*("'+)&%U.C&&B+-0E106)&7A+! !",D0)%(.7 + 2-"3U6%&,(.7 + 307%01*(")%* + ) + ,$O"3"D + (.+

-0.1*($0+)"C&.1*($0 +"#d06%$A +l5.)%&0 +, +-0^0(&&+"#_0'+ /.3.5& +c+)"/3.(&7+"#_04"+2-"3U6%.

! M61L50(&0 + D"1"30a& + , + .(.1&/ + -0.1*($O + )"C&.1*($O+2-"#10D + & + ,"/D"a(")%* + 2-"7,10(&0 + )"#)%,0(("' + 4-.a3.()6"'+2"/&C&&A+

! Q-.%6")-"5(")%* + & + &(%0()&,(")%* + )",D0)%("' + -.#"%$B+-0.1*("4"+a&,"4"+"#_0(&7+&+,/.&D"30')%,&7B+,+%"D+5&)10+2"1U50(&7+-0/U1*%.%.B+2-"3U6%.+,+-0.1*("D+,-0D0(&+92-&(C&2+f/30)*+&+)0'5.)<A+

! !"/3.(&0 + .%D")E0-$ + &4-$ + & + 2-&61L50(&7 + )%"1*+),"')%,0(("'+2"3-")%6","DU+,"/-.)%UA+

! !",D0_0(&0 + %-0(&(4",$O + ,"/D"a(")%0' + & + 2-.6%&50)6"4"+,/.&D"30')%,&7 + , + -0.1*("' + )"C&.1*("' + )&%U.C&&w + 4-.a3.()6"4"+U5.)%&7+&+"#-./",.(&7+,+"3("'+9&1&+(0)6"1*6&O<+&/+)"C&.1*($O+)E0-+9aU-(.1&)%&6.B+)"C&"1"4&7B+2"1&%"1"4&7B+6"(E1&6%"1"4&7+&+3-A<A

DEFGHIJ!FKZ-4.(&/.C&7D+F0%-"4-.3)6"4"+-.'"(.

!7.c.,G4,$/2??,A1uP.^.+"-4.(&/.C&7+,$)%U2&1.+)+&(&C&.%&,"'+2-",030(&7+(.+%0--&%"-&&+

F0%-"4-.3)6"4"+-.'"(. +-,?2725$1A=4$ZLR=3.?168[+ 317+^6"1*(&6",+?J88+61.))",A +G4-. +#U30% +2-","3&%*)7 +, +-.D6.O+"#_0)%,0(("'+.6C&&+f�0-6.1"+317 + -.'"(.gA + P.^U + &(&C&.%&,U + 2"330-a.1& + m))"C&.C&7 + 30%)6"' + &+203.4"4&50)6"'+2-0))$+!.(6%JF0%0-#U-4.+&+Z%6-$%$'+m,%"-)6&'+G()%&%U%+m1*%0-(.%&,("4" + Z#-./",.(&7 + &DA + iAQ"-5.6.A + F0-,$0 + &4-$ + U)20^("+

88Y

Page 117: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

2-"^1&+8Y+.2-017+&+8+"6%7#-7+=>>@+4"3.A+`0/U1*%.%$+#$1&+"2U#1&6",.($+,+4"-"3)6"'+4./0%0+f�./0%.+317+-"3&%010'g+ +`/(.(&H#+7"/"'$%&+*"#"/'+4&$T#8&��a=

M + O"30 + &4-$ + 4-U22$ + 6"--0)2"(30(%",J-0#7% + 2")0%7% + -./1&5($0+"#_0)%,0((" + /(.5&D$0 + D0)%. + -.'"(.B + (.2-&D0-B + 30%)6&0 + #&#1&"%06&B+30%)6&0+&4-",$0+&+)2"-%&,($0+21"_.36&B+)6,0-$B+6&("%0.%-$B+D.4./&($+&+%A3A+h17+(.)+#$1"+#$+,.a("B+5%"#$+,+O"30+%.6"4"+2")0_0(&7+-0#7%.+)D"41&+2"3-"#(" + "/(.6"D&%*)7 + ) + D0)%"D + 9"-4.(&/.C&0'<B + 2"#0)03",.%* + )+)"%-U3(&6.D&+&+2")0%&%017D&B+D"a0%+#$%*+)E"%"4-.E&-",.%*+5%"J%"A+

F"+&%"4.D+%.6"'+-.#"%$+-0#7%.+2"34"%",7%+aU-(.1&)%)6&0+D.%0-&.1$B+1U5^&0 + &/ + 6"%"-$O + #U3U% + "2U#1&6",.($ + , + 4./0%0B + ,$2U)6.0D"' + 2"+-0/U1*%.%.D + &4-$J.6C&&A + \.6.7 + 4./0%. + D"41. + #$ + #$%* + ),"0"#-./($D+f�0-6.1"D+317+-.'"(.gB+)"/3.(($D+)%.-.(&7D&+-0#7%A+R$+#U30D+M.D+"50(*+#1.4"3.-($B+0)1&+M$+-./-0^&%0+(.D+"-4.(&/",.%*+%.6"'+f2U(6%+2")0_0(&7g+(.+#./0 +,.^0' +"-4.(&/.C&&A +R$+-.))5&%$,.0DB +5%" +-0#7% +#U30%+, +4-U220+2-&D0-("+YJK+501",06A+P.+%0--&%"-&&+,.^0'+"-4.(&/.C&&+-0#7%.+2-",03U%+2-&D0-(" + "3&( + 5.)A + NU30D + #1.4"3.-($ +M.D + /. + 2"330-a6U + x%"4" + (.^04"+(.5&(.(&7+&+-.3$+2-&+(0"#O"3&D")%&+,)%-0%&%*)7+&+"#)U3&%*+,"/D"a($0+,"2-")$A+

+./R=64$166?,-27.31C$@2$8,G,$Z#2G.3-1=27/.$3.$.782>.72-[$¶+!.D"0+2-&,106.%01*("0+9)1"a("0B+2-")%"0<+,+"),"0(&&+3.(("'+2-"E0))&&¶+P.&#"100+,")%-0#",.(($0+,+2-"E0))&&+&(%01106%U.1*($0B+xD"C&"(.1*($0+&+,"10,$0+6.50)%,.¶ +!.D$0 +D0310(($0 +& +).D$0 +#$)%-$0 +%-U3",$0 +"20-.C&&B +,$2"1(70D$0+501",06"D+,+3.(("'+2-"E0))&&¶+!%020(*+(0"#O"3&D")%&+.,%"-&%.-("4"B++a0)%6"4"+)%&17+U2-.,10(&7+¶ +l-",0(* + E&/&50)6"' + & + 2)&O"1"4&50)6"' + U)%.1")%& + 501",06. + , + 3.(("'+2-"E0))&&+2"+)-.,(0(&L+)+3-U4&D&¶+l-",0(*+6"DE"-%(")%&+&+x6"1"4&5(")%&+U)1",&'+%-U3.+¶+Q.6&0+,$)^&0+&+)-03(&0+U50#($0+/.,030(&7+4"%",7%+x%&O+)20C&.1&)%",¶+!.D$0+D.10(*6&0+&+).D$0+,$)"6&0+/.-21.%$+¶ + y.-.6%0- + "%#"-. + 20-)"(.1. + (. + -./1&5($0 + 3"1a(")%& + 9"% + -.#"5&O + 3"+D0(03a0-",+,$)^04"+/,0(.<¶+`U%&(("0+&+%,"-50)6"0+,+3.(("'+2-"E0))&&¶+!%-.^("0+&+)D0^("0+,+2-"E0))&&¶+l-",0(*+/._&%$+&(%0-0)",+)"%-U3(&6",+¶+Q.6&0+0)%*+"4-.(&50(&7+2"+,"/-.)%U+&+2"+/3"-",*L+317+-.#"%$+¶+Q.6&0+)20C&.1&)%$+5._0+,)04"+#$,.L%+,+6"D.(3&-",6.O

`2>G2c345$/=RA$72@=2627$@2$8,G,$Zf2?,=.38345$h,8,=;R=A[¶+F-03)%.,&%01&+6.6"'+(.C&"(.1*(")%&+2-0"#1.3.L%+,+3.(("D+D0)%0+&+

2"50DU�¶+P.)6"1*6"+U3.0%)7+)"O-.(&%*+(.C&"(.1*("J6U1*%U-(UL+")"#0((")%*+,+

3.(("D+D0)%0�¶ + Q.6 + 5.)%" + & + 317 + 504" + )"#&-.L%)7 + 2-03)%.,&%01& + %"' + &1& + &("'+

(.C&"(.1*(")%&+,+3.(("D+D0)%0�

88I

Page 118: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

¶ +{0D +D0^.0% + & + 50D + 2"D"4.0% +F0%0-#U-4 + , + U30-a.(&& + (.C&"(.1*("J6U1*%U-("'+")"#0((")%&+3.(("4"+D0)%.�¶+Q.6"'+2-03D0%+3.(("4"+D0)%.+D"a("+)5&%.%*+)&D,"1"DB+,$-.a.L_&D+

(.C&"(.1*($'+)%&1*�¶ + {04" + )103U0% + "2.).%*)7 + 2-03)%.,&%01L + &("' + (.C&"(.1*(")%& + ,+

F0%0-#U-40�¶+Q.6"0+)"#$%&0+D"a("+)5&%.%*+&)%"-&50)6&D+317+3.(("4"+D0)%.�¶ +Q.6&0 +(.C&"(.1*($0 +2-./3(&6& +1U5^0+,)04" +U3.L%)7 + , +F0%0-#U-40�+

F"50DU+%.6�+Q.6&0+(.C&"(.1*($0+2-./3(&6&+"%D05.1&)*+,+3.(("D+D0)%0�¶ + Q.6.7 + DU/$6.B + ,$-.a.L_.7 + (.C&"(.1*("J6U1*%U-(UL + ")"#0((")%*B+

5._0+,)04"+/,U5&%+,+x%&O+)%0(.O�¶ +Q.6"' +C,0% + 5._0 +&)2"1*/U0%)7 + , + 3.(("D +D0)%0B + 5%"#$ +"%-./&%* + 04"+

(.C&"(.1*("J6U1*%U-($'+O.-.6%0-�¶+Q.6&0+0)%*+D05%$+2"+2","3U+D("4"(.C&"(.1*("4"+F0%0-#U-4.�

`2>G2c345$/=RA$72@=2627$@2$8,G,Zb,=/.?2$-?C$=.523.D$:201.?<34,$R6?RA1[

J+M+50D+)U%*+2-"#10D$+%0OB+6"DU+2"D"4.0%+"-4.(&/.C&7�J+Q.6&0+(.&#"100+%&2&5($0+&+")%-$0+)1U5.&+,"/(&6.L%+,+-.#"%0+)+%0D&B+6"DU+2"D"4.0%+"-4.(&/.C&7�J + h0')%,&%01*(" + 1& + "-4.(&/.C&& + U3.0%)7 + "6./$,.%* + )U_0)%,0((UL+)"C&.1*(UL+2"D"_*+1L37D�+{%"+,)0J%.6&+(0+2"1U5.0%)7�J+Q.6",.+3"17+4")U3.-)%,0(("'+2"D"_&+,+307%01*(")%&+"-4.(&/.C&&�J+{0D+a&%01&+!.(6%JF0%0-#U-4.+D"4U%+2"D"5*+3.(("'+"-4.(&/.C&&�J+�.+5%"+5._0+,)04"+#1.4"3.-7%+"-4.(&/.C&L+&+(.+5%"+a.1UL%)7+%0B+6"DU+"(.+"6./$,.0%+2"D"_*�J + {%"B + 2" + D(0(&L + "-4.(&/.C&&B + D0^.0%B + . + 5%" + 2"D"4.0% + 1L37D + #$%*+D&1")0-3($D&�J+Q.6"'+-06"-3+)U_0)%,U0%+,+&)%"-&&+307%01*(")%&+"-4.(&/.C&&�J+Q.6"'+2-03D0%+,+"-4.(&/.C&&+)5&%.0%)7+).D$D+,.a($D�

+./R=64$166?,-27.31C$@2$8,G,$Zb,=/.?2$-?C$=.523.[G)%"-&50)6.7+)2-.,6.+D0)%.!.D$'+,.a($'+2-03D0%+D0)%.G)%"-&50)6&'+)%&1*+D0)%.\.'(.+D0)%.�0(&'+940-"'<+D0)%.F-&61L50(&7+D0)%.|D"C&&+D0)%.F"1*/.+D0)%.

`06"-3+D0)%.`01&6,&7+D0)%.F0-)"(.a&+9/.,)043.%.&<+D0)%.j"%",&/&%6.+D0)%.`U&($+9-./,.1&($<+D0)%.F-032"1.4.0D"0 + 9,"/D"a("0<+#U3U_00+D0)%.

+,/2G,3-.01CD+ P0 +(.3"+%-0#",.%*B +5%"#$+U5.)%(&6&+&4-$+)103",.1&+x%&D+-.6U-).D+&+,"2-").DA+P.+x%.20+#1&CJ)",0_.(&'+aU-(.1&)%)6&O+#-&4.3+)"2-","a3.L_&D+,.a("+"#-.%&%*+,(&D.(&0+-0#7%+(.+-.6U-)$+&+,"2-")$+%.6"4" + -"3.B + /.,&)7_&0 + "% + %0D$ + &4-$A + \-0(&(4 + 2" + %.6"' + D0%"3&60+)"C&.1*("4"+&))103",.(&7+&+ +&(%0-,*L&-",.(&7+O"-"^"+#$+20-&"3&50)6&+2-","3&%* + & + ,(0 + &4-$ + fTU-(.1&)%gB + 2")6"1*6U + (. + (0' + x%" + ,)04"+f61.))&50)6&0g+Y>JK>+D&(A+2-0#$,.(&7+(.+"#d06%0A+M+6.50)%,0+2"3)6./6&+2"+

88K

Page 119: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

1&%0-.%U-("DU+"E"-D10(&L+2"1U50(("'+(.+D0)%0+&(E"-D.C&&+, +F.D7%60+D$+U6./$,.0D+&+D.1$0+a.(-$+aU-(.1&)%&6&A+P.+&4-U+2-&O"37%+U5.)%(&6&+)+-./($D&+U-",(7D&+/(.6"D)%,.+)+")(",.D&+-.#"%$+aU-(.1&)%.A+T01.%01*("B+5%"#$ + &4-. + )2")"#)%,",.1. + )"/3.(&L + )""#_0)%,. + L($O + aU-(.1&)%",B+.6%&,(" + )",0-^0()%,UL_&O + (.5.1*("0 + D.)%0-)%," + & + D0a3U + &4-",$D&+f2"4-Ua0(&7D&gA+

p.?4,$c.3=4b.G,8/. $ Q+ ,)0 + E.6%$ + "#d03&(7L%)7 + "3("' + %0D"' + & + E&6)&-UL%)7+

"3("D"D0(%("A +M+(.5.10+%06)%.+,+3,UOJ%-0O+E-./.O+)6"(C0(%-&-",.(.+,)7+)U%*A+,@2=8.c$Q+#$)%-.7+"#-.#"%6.+&(E"-D.C&&+&+.(.1&/+)"#$%&7A+Z2&).(&0+

)"#$%&7+2")103",.%01*("B+("+D"a0%+-./-$,.%*+-0.1*("0+,-0D7A+h")%&4.0%)7+xEE06% + 2-&)U%)%,&7 + -02"-%0-. + (. +D0)%0 + )"#$%&7A + `02"-%0- + &D00% + 2-.,"+2-&,0)%&+),&30%01*)%,.+3-U4&O+U5.)%(&6",+&+"50,&3C0,+)"#$%&'AN38,=7<H$Q+ ,+#"1*^0'+&1&+D0(*^0'+D0-0+2-03)%.,170%)7+%"56.+/-0(&7+

)"#0)03(&6.A + F-7D" + &1& + 6"),0((" + 2"/&C&7 + 6"--0)2"(30(%. + %"a0+2-&)U%)%,U0%A + j"-D$ + &(%0-,*L + 9#0)03$B + 3&.1"4&B + D"("1"4&B + 2"1&1"4&B+.(60%$<+-./1&5($+2"+31&%01*(")%&k+-./,0-(U%$0+#0)03$J3&.1"4&B+x6)2-0))J&(%0-,*LB+D&6-"&(%0-,*L+&+%A2AE8B,8 $ Q $2"1($' + -.))6./ + " + 6"(6-0%("D + "%301*("D + )"#$%&&B + 1&5("+

(.#1L3.0D"D+.,%"-"Dw+"#$5("+2",0)%,",.(&0+"4-.(&50("+2-")%-.()%,0(("J,-0D0(($D&+-.D6.D&+)"#$%&7w+04"+30%.1&/.C&7+&/1"a0(&0+2"3-"#(")%0'+)"+)1",+30')%,UL_&O+1&Cw+.6%&,(.7+30D"()%-.C&7+)"#)%,0(("'+2"/&C&&A#2==,6@23-,301C $Q+ &))103",.(&0 +& +"2&).(&0 + 6"(6-0%("' + )"C&.1*("'+

)&%U.C&&B + )&)%0D$ + E.6%",B + "#d03&(0(($O + O"-"^" + 2-")10a&,.0D$D&+2-&5&(("J)103)%,0(($D& + ),7/7D&B + &1& + c + 4-U22$ + E.6%",B + ),7/.(($O+03&()%,"D+,-0D0(&B+D0)%.B+40-"7B+2-"#10D$A+j.6%+6.6+")(",.+%06)%.+&+2","3+317 + 04" + &(%0-2-0%.C&&A + ~)%* + .,%"-)6"0 + -.))Ua30(&0B + ,$%06.L_00 + &/+"#"#_0(&7+"2&)$,.0D$O+E.6%",A+#2GG,38.=15$F$+x%"+"20-.%&,($'+"%61&6+(.+)"#$%&0B+x%"+,205.%10(&0B+(0+

2-0%0(3UL_00+(.+&)50-2$,.L_UL+2"1("%U+.(.1&/.A+M+C0(%-0+c+(",")%*+&1&+E.6%B+Ua0+"#(.-"3",.(($'+-.(00A+M.a(.+(0+#$)%-"%.+20-03.5&+)""#_0(&7B+.+%"56. + /-0(&7 + (. + )"#$%&0B + ,.-&.%&,(")%* + "#)Ua30(&7 + 2-"#10D$ + &+"-&0(%.C&7+(.+xD"C&"(.1*($'+"%61&6A:8.8<C $ Q $)%-U6%U-. + %06)%. + c + 6"D2106) + 2"1"a0(&'B + -.))Ua30(&'B+

)Ua30(&'B + 3"6./.%01*)%,B + "2&-.L_&O)7 + (. + ,$7,10(&0 + 2-&5&(("J)103)%,0(($O + ),7/0' + D0a3U + "%301*($D& + E.6%.D&A + `./,&% + 2"(7%&'($'+.22.-.%AhR;?101681B,6/2, $ 2;2>=,31, $ Q+ )D0)* + 6"--0)2"(30(C&&B + )%.%*& + &+

6"DD0(%.-&7A +G)2"1*/UL%)7+3.(($0B +2"/,"17L_&0+)301.%*+2",0)%,",.(&0+-./(""#-./($D+2"+%0D.DAh16<G2 $ Q $1&5(")%("J"6-.^0((.7 + %"56. + /-0(&7 + (. + 2-"#10DU + 9.,%"- + c+

")%-.7+2-"#10D.+c+.3-0).%<A+h",0-&%01*($'+-./4","-($'+)%&1*AG%.6B+ +U6./.(+(.&#"100+),"#"3($'+&+(0)6"1*6"+2"2U17-&/&-",.(($'+

,.-&.(% +&4-$A +Z3(.6" +D"a(" + )D0)%&%* + .6C0(%$ +, + "-4.(&/.C&& +(. +#"100+U/6&0 +E0("D0("1"4&50)6&0 + U)1",&7A +G + %"43. + (0 + (Ua($ +2-03,.-&%01*($0+D.%0-&.1$+"+D0)%.O+2")0_0(&7+9�<A+P0+)103U0%+(.+D0)%.O+2"7)(7%*+5%"J%"+

88?

Page 120: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

/.-.(00k+%"1*6"+"%,05.L%+(.+,"2-")$A+P0%+,"2-")",+c+(0%+&+&(E"-D.C&&A+|%"+2-&(C&2&.1*("�

F")10 + ,"/,-._0(&7 + ) + D0)% + 6.a3$' + 2&^0% +.782=6/15 $ 8,/68A + �.%0D+U)%-.&,.0%)7+-03.6C&"(("0+)",0_.(&0B+430+2-"&)O"37%+2-0/0(%.C&&+%06)%",B+!"#&-.L%)7+1U5^&0+-.6U-)$+"%+6.a3"4"+aU-(.1&)%.A+j"-D&-U0%)7+"#_&'+%06)% + 2"1")$A +!U20-J,0-)%6. + (0,.a(.A +FU)%* + U5.)%(&6& + 301.L% + 2-")%"'+,.-&.(%+"-&4&(.1JD.60%.+4./0%$B+1&^*+#$+#$1+O"-"^&'+%06)%B+5%"+,.a("+2"+)D$)1U+&4-$A

`.=1.38$1A=4I$8,G.$Zf2?,=.3832,$7>.1G2-,56871,$7$/R?<8R=,[t&C&2+/"&$T#8R&7&."*"'$"&+/'+T+&#(:+*"T+&/'%k+-0#7%.+-./#&,.L%)7+(.+

,-0D0(($0+)D0^.(($0+4-U22$+9-03.6C&&<w+U5.)%,UL%+,+%-0(&(4.OB+&4-",$O+U2-.a(0(&7OB + 2"),7_0(($O + 6.6 + -0^0(&L + 2)&O"1"4&50)6&O + /.3.5B + %.6 + &+/.3.5 + f2-"E0))&"(.1*($Og + J + aU-(.1&)%)6&Ow + ,$O"37% + 9,$0/a.L%< + (.+f"#d06%$g + (. + %0--&%"-&&B + 430 + , + )""%,0%)%,&0 + ) + /.3.(&0D + /(.6"D7%)7 + )+f"#d06%"Dg+& +1L3*D&B + #0-U% +&(%0-,*LB +2-","37% +"2-")$w + ,"/,-._.7)* +,+f^%.#J6,.-%&-UgB+-.#"%.L%+(.3+%06)%"DB+4"%",7%+aU-(.1&)%)6&0+D.%0-&.1$B+U5.)%,UL%+,+2-0))J6"(E0-0(C&&+)+&(%0-0)($D&+1L3*D&+&1&+3&)6U))&&A

t&C&#"3)?F.(."&$T#8Z+ U5.)%(&6&+&4-$+2"1U5.L%+"2$%+2-"3U6%&,("4"+2"1"a&%01*("4" + 9%"10-.(%("4"< + ,/.&D"30')%,&7 + ) + h-U4&D& + 1L3*D&w+2"7,170%)7 + &/4"%",10(($' + /. + "3&( + 30(* + 2-03,.-&%01*($' + D.60% + 4./0%+9C01&6"D+2"+D.%0-&.1.DB +2"34"%",10(($D+U5.)%(&6.D&<w +D.%0-&.1$+&4-$+-./D0_.L%)7 + (. + ).'%0w + -0#7%. + /(.6"D7%)7 + 3-U4 + ) + 3-U4"DB + 5.)%" + 3-Ua#.+2-"3"1a.0%)7+&+2")10+&4-$wU5.)%(&6&+2"1U5.L%+"2$%+)"C&.1*("+2"10/("'+307%01*(")%&B + ,"/D"a(")%* + 2-"7,10(&7 + .6%&,("' + 4-.a3.()6"' + 2"/&C&&B+2-&"#-0%.L% + (.,$6& + D0a1&5(")%("' + 6"DDU(&6.C&& + & + aU-(.1&)%)6"'+307%01*(")%&A+

F" + "6"(5.(&& + &4-$ + D.%0-&.1$B + 2"34"%",10(($0 + U5.)%(&6.D&B+2U#1&6UL%)7+1&#"+,+,&30+"%301*("'+4./0%$B+1&#"+,+,&30+,61.36&+,+6.6"0J%"+&/3.(&0+&+-.)2-")%-.(7L%)7+2"+a&%017D+-.'"(.+9&1&B+5%"+%"a0+,"/D"a("B+4"%",&%)7+%01020-03.5.<A+

f,G$6.G4GI$;R-R8$-2681A3R84$);)0+3"01)7#?<*"*"9J + a&%01& + -.'"(. + U/(.L% +D(0(&0 +D"1"30a& + " + 2-"&)O"37_0D + , + (0DB+

U,&37%B + 5%" + "#$5(" + -U4.0D.7 + D"1"30a* + %.6a0 + D"a0% + #$%* + "50(* + 3.a0+6"()%-U6%&,(.w+

J+2"3-")%6&+9D"1"30a*<B+(0+U5.)%,UL_&0+,+&4-0B+)D"4U%+2"/(.6"D&%*)7+) + %.6"' + ,"/D"a(")%*L + &B + %0D + ).D$DB + U,&30%*B + 5%" + %"10-.(%("0B+2-"3U6%&,("0+,/.&D"30')%,&0+1L30'+-./($O+6U1*%U-+,"/D"a("A

+

E;=.>27.8,?<32,$62;481,$Z:26,-6872[9768=,B.$6$62;25I$6$/R?<8R=25I$6$G1=2G

8=>

Page 121: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

Q=>=K+0."'1+

�"4&6. + )",-0D0(("4" + D&-. + %.6",.B + 5%" + U + 501",06. + 2"7,170%)7+(0"#O"3&D")%*+UD0%*+a&%*+,+-./($O+f6U1*%U-($O+)-03.Ogk+,+)0D*0+c+"3&(+U61.3B +U +#.#U^6&+c+3-U4"'B +(. +-.#"%0+&+,+^6"10+c+%-0%&'B +,"+3,"-0+c+50%,0-%$'A+!-03.B+,+6"%"-"'+"6./$,.0%)7+501",06B+3&(.D&5(.B+&/D0(5&,.B + D("4"21.(",. + & + ,61L5.0% + (0 + %"1*6" + a&,U_&O + -73"D+-./($O+1L30'+&+2-03D0%$+"6-Ua.L_04"+D&-.B+("+("-D$+&+2-.,&1.B+2-&(7%$0 + /30)* + & + )0'5.)A +�0((")%*L + 7,170%)7 + 4"%",(")%* + 501",06.+,/.&D"30')%,",.%* + ) + (&D& + & + ,$)%-.&,.%* + &(3&,&3U.1*(UL+"#-./",.%01*(UL+%-.06%"-&L+,(U%-&+(&OA

\.6"'+,$/", +&+2-&(71&+203.4"4&+%"D)6"'+^6"1$+R"(%0))"-&+,+=>>Y4AB+6"43.++-"3&1.)*+&307+"#-./",.%01*("'+2-"4-.DD$+f!")03)%,"gA+M+%"D+)0(%7#-0+8=+)D01$O+%"D)6&O+)0D0'+-0^&1&)*+"%2-.,&%*+),"&O+30%0'B + D1.3^&O + ^6"1*(&6",B + &))103",.%* + 6-.)("7-)6&0 + !%"1#$B+2"(&D.%* + 2-" + f(","0 + (""40(",)6"0 + D$^10(&0gB + /(.6"D&%*)7 + )+.-O&%06%U-"'+&+2.D7%(&6.D&+4"-"3.+Q-.)("7-)6.A++

! +%0O +2"- +)")%"71")* +Ua0+Y +)0))&'+& +&(%0-0) +6 +2-"4-.DD0+(0+")1.#0,.0%k + " + (0' + ) + x(%U/&./D"D + -.))6./$,.L% + 30%&B + )6-"D("+&(%0-0)UL%)7+5&(",(&6&B+-.))2-.^&,.L%+-"3&%01&B+)2"-7%+203.4"4&A+{%"+/.+"#-./",.(&0+%.6"0�+!-03&+U50#("4"+4"3.+4-U22.+^6"1*(&6",+(.+3,0 + (0301& + U0/a.0% + U5&%*)7 + , + 3-U4"' + 4"-"3B + 3"D.^(&0 + /.3.(&7+"%D0(7L%)7B+30%&B+,0-(U,^&)*+3"D"'B+2-"3"1a.L%+"#)Ua3.%*+6.6&0J%"+(""40(",)6&0 + /.3.5&B +U +(&O +2"7,170%)7 +D("a0)%," +3-U/0' +, +-./($O+4"-"3.OB + "(& + 20-02&)$,.L%)7 + & + 2-&0/a.L% + 3-U4 + 6 + 3-U4U + , + 4")%&A+!04"3(7 + , + x%"D + "#-./",.%01*("D + )"#$%&& + U5.)%,UL% + 50%$-0+-"))&')6&O+f4"-"3.J)")03.gk+\"D)6B+Q-.)("7-)6B+Q0D0-","B+`0,3.A+|%"+c + Y> + 30%0' + )" + ,%"-"4" + 2" + 27%$' + 61.))$A + `73"D + ) + (&D& + )0-*0/($0+,/-")1$0k + 3&-06%"-.B + 6.(3&3.%$ + (.U6B + D0(03a0-$B + 6&(""20-.%"-$B+U50($0B+,"0(($0+)%-.%04&50)6&+,.a($O+"#d06%",B+-"3&%01&B+(.+,-0D7+)%.,^&0+D("4"30%($D&A

+ P. + 10(%0 + ,-0D0(& + (.^& + ,)%-05& + "%D050($ + + 6.6k +5\1+?+T$%&0+0"/0.7(;+ 9)0(%7#-*B +=>>Y+4AB +Q-.)("7-)6<B +5@0.+#$%&-$#(&$&0":%;&9E0,-.1*B+=>>I4A+\"D)6<B +5�'(1$&-$#(;+ +9)0(%7#-*B+=>>I4A+Q-.)("7-)6<B+56()1(&$&$01)00.7+;+ +9E0,-.1*+=>>K4AB+\"D)6<B+5b&7&-$#"R&-$#&7+&-'";&9)0(%7#-*+=>>K4AB+Q-.)("7-)6<B+5�(&0"-FU&H"*(.%-$;&+9E0,-.1*+=>>?4AB+\"D)6<

Z#-./",.%01*(.7+2-"4-.DD.++f!")03)%,"g+,$)%-"0(.+2"+2-&(C&2U+"#-./",.%01*("4"+)"#$%&7A+!"#$%&'(")%*+/.3.0%)7+%0DB+5%"+2-&,$5("0+U50#("0+2-")%-.()%,"+f-./D$6.0%)7g+2"+-./($D+2.-.D0%-.Dk+¶+ 768=,B. $ 62 $ 67,=6831/.G1+ &/ + 3-U4&O + 4"-"3", + & + ^6"1B+

,"/D"a(")%*+,/417(U%*+(.+)0#7+6.6+(.+2-03)%.,&%017+),"04"+2"6"10(&7w+

8=8

Page 122: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

¶+ 768=,B.+ =.>34W $ /R?<8R=34W $ 2;=.>27.8,?<34W $ @=./81/k+R"(%0))"-&B + -./,&,.L_04" + "#U50(&7B + ,.1*3"-E)6"' + 203.4"4&6&B+),"#"3("' + 203.4"4&6& + \"1)%"4"B + 4&D(./&50)6"4" + & + 1&C0')6"4"+"#-./",.(&7w¶+ 768=,B.+ ) +=.>34G1 $ 7>=26?4G1B + D.)%0-.D& + ),"04" + 301.B+

U)20^($D& + , +a&/(&B + 3&/.'(0-.D&B + &)6U))%,",03.D&B + )6U1*2%"-.D&B+-0a&))0-.D&B + U50($D&B + + DU/$6.(%.D&B + OU3"a(&6.D&B+6&(""20-.%"-.D&wm$768=,B.$6$62;25B+/.+)50%+"-4.(&/.C&&+%*L%"-)6"4"+)"2-","a30(&7+

2-"&)O"37_04" + )"#$%&7k + 5%" + 7 + U/(.1 + 2-" + )0#7B + 2-" + 4"-"3B + ),"0+2"6"10(&0B+D&-+,/-")1$OB+(.U6UB+U50#($'+2-03D0%A+

R1.3^&D+^6"1*(&6.D+,.a("+2-&)"03&(&%*)7+6+),0-)%(&6.D+317+%"4"B+5%"#$+2"5U,)%,",.%*+2-&5.)%(")%*+6+)""#_0)%,U+^6"1$B+61.)).B+U50(&50)%,.B+"#(.-Ua&%*+"#_&0+20-0a&,.(&7+2"+2","3U+"3("4"+&+%"4"+a0 + )"#$%&7k +)22g,3276/25 $ >.-.B1I $ $ @2?,725 $ j/6@,-1011I$872=B,6/25$?.;2=.82=11I $3.RB32A2$166?,-27.31CI $68=.8,A1B,6/25$1A=4A+

M+ 8./1W $ 28/=484W $ X2=G.8.W+ 9x%" + 0_0 + "3&( + 2.-.D0%-< + &+-./,"-.5&,.0%)7+2-"4-.DD.+f!")03)%,"gA+|%&+E"-D.%$+2-032"1.4.L%+-./(UL+"-4.(&/.C&Lk+"3(&+U)%-"0($+%.6B+5%"+(0"#O"3&D"+,$2"1(7%*+/.3.(($0�"#4","-0(($0 + ("-D$ + & + 2-.,&1.w + , + 3-U4&O + 2-.,&1. + 5U%*+f(.D050($B + /.3.($g + ,03U_&Dw + , + %-0%*&O + "#-./",.%01*("0+2-")%-.()%," + "2-03010(" + "%5.)%&k + (0% + U6./.(&'B + 6.6 + 30')%,",.%*A+l5.)%(&6&+,$(Ua30($+).D&+3")%-.&,.%*+4-.(&C$+)"J#$%&7+-73"D+)+3-U4&D&+&+"2-03017%*+2-.,&1.B+2"+6"%"-$D+fUD0)%("+#$%*g+,+3.(("D+2-")%-.()%,0A++

\.6.7 + "%6-$%")%* + E"-D.%", + 2-032"1.4.0% + (02")-03)%,0((UL+2-"#U + )2")"#", + 30')%,&' + 30%0' + , + U50#("D + D.%0-&.10B + . + %.6a0+2"/,"170% + &(.50 + ,/417(U%* + (. + ),0-)%(&6", + & + ,/-")1$OB + (.+,/.&D""%("^0(&7 +D0a3U + 2"6"10(&7D&B + (. + ),"0 + D0)%" + , + D&-0A + \.6B+&/U50(&0 + .-O&%06%U-$ + 4"-"3", + /.3.0%)7 + , + E"-D.%0 + 2"10,"4"+&))103",.(&7k++6.a3"'+4-U220B+)")%"7_0'+&/+30%0'+&+,/-")1$O+-./($O+4"-"3",B + ,$3.L%)7 + E"%"4-.E&& + /3.(&' + & + 2-&D05.%01*($O + D0)%B+(.2-&D0-B + Q-.)("7-)6.A + �01* + x6)203&C&&k + + 2-"'%& + 2" + D.-^-U%UB+"-&0(%&-U7)*+2"+6.-%0B+(.'%&+,+\"D)60+)O"a&0+2"+.-O&%06%U-0+/3.(&7B+)E"%"4-.E&-",.%* + &OB + "#d7)(&%*B + 2"50DU + 3,. + )&#&-)6&O + 4"-"3.B+#1&/6&O +2" +,"/-.)%U + 9\"D)6U +c +:>@ +10%B + . +Q-.)("7-)6U +c +;K=+4"3.<B+D"4U%+&D0%*+2"O"a&0+)%-"0(&7�+G1&+0)1&+&O+(0%B+%"43.+2"50DUB+D$+a0+)")03&�

F-&41.^0(&0 + , + 2-"4-.DDU + )20C&.1&)%",B + (0 + "%(")7_&O)7 + 6+^6"10 + & + ^6"1*("DU + "#U50(&LB + 2"/,"170% + 30%7D + & + 203.4"4.D+2-&"#-0)%& +C0(($' +"2$% + /(.6"D)%,. + & + "%6-$%&7 + 317 + )0#7 +3-U4"4"B+-0.1*("4" +D&-. +,/-")1$OA +\.6B +6.(3&3.% +E&1")"E)6&O +(.U6B +3"C0(%+!&#&-)6"4" + j030-.1*("4" + l(&,0-)&%0%.B + 3&-06%"- + ^6"1$+.(%-"2"(&6& + & + 2-"4-.DD&-",.(&7 + + R.-&7 + R&-60) + 9Q-.)("7-)6<B+

8==

Page 123: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

2-031.4.0%+/.3.(&7B+,$)%-"0(($0+,+1"4&60+P""�0(",)6"'+%0O("1"4&&B+(.2-&D0-k +fF")%-"&%*+D&-+21")6&O+)U_0)%,B +f21")6"%&6",gB +D&-B +,+6"%"-"D+(.1"a0(&7+(0,"/D"a($A +Z2&).%* +"3&(+30(*+a&/(&+, +%.6"D+D&-0A+Q.6+D"a0%+,$41730%*+a&1&_0+x%"4"+)U_0)%,.�+Q.6+"("+D"a0%+2&%.%*)7B+20-03,&4.%*)7�gA+

~)1&+x%"+c+RG B+%"+,+(0D+3"1a("+#$%*+,)0+,/.&D"),7/.("B+x%"+c+,.a(.7 + C02"56.B + 6.a3"0 + /,0(" + 6"%"-"'B + ,$2.3.7B + ,1050% + /. + )"#"'+&/D0(0(&7+,"+,)0'+)&)%0D0A+�.3.5&+(.+2")%-"0(&0+D&-",+&(&C&&-UL%+%,"-50)6"0 + D$^10(&0B + )#&,.L% + -./1&5($0 + D$)1&%01*($0 + )O0D$ + &+^.#1"($B+/.3.L%+(",$0+-.D6&+,&30(&7+&+C01")%(")%&+"6-Ua.L_04"A+M/-")1$0 +(.-73U +) +30%*D&+%"a0+2"J50)%("DU+-0^.L%+P""40(",)6&0+/.3.5&B+,03*+2-.,&1*("4"+"%,0%.+(0+/(.0%+(&6%"e+P.+2")103(0'+)0))&&+U5.)%(&6& + ,)%-05& + ) + 2"D"_*L + D"(0%"6B + x10D0(%.-($O + ^.-&6", + &+6U#&6", + "%6-$1& + %0"-&L + ,0-"7%(")%& + 92"5%& + 2" + |'(^%0'(U<A + Z(&+2"5U,)%,",.1& + .%D")E0-U + %,"-50)%,. + , + D.)%0-)6"' + (.)%"7_04"+a&,"2&)C.B + 2"2-"#",.1& + a.(- + 3"61.3", + (. + (.U5("' + 6"(E0-0(C&&B+)%.1& + .6%0-.D& + , + %0.%-0 + 3-.D$ + & + DU/$6.(%.D&J&)2"1(&%017D& + ,+"-60)%-0A+l5.)%&0++,++(.)%"7_0D+E"%"6-"))0++/(.5&%01*("+-.)^&-&1"+-.D6& + 2-03)%.,10(&7 + " + OU3"a0)%,0(("' + & + 3"6UD0(%.1*("'+E"%"4-.E&&A

h=2A=.GG.$@=,-@2?.A.,8$2;=.>27.8,?<34,$$=,>R?<8.84h17+30%0'&0+:8.$"+)*(0.$%+,+2-"4-.DD0+c+2","3+2"5U,)%,",.%*+

)0#7+4")%02-&&D($D&+O"/70,.D&B+6"%"-$0+2"J(","DU+"%6-$,.L%+)0#7+94")%&+a&,U%+,+)0D*7O+),"&O+),0-)%(&6",<B+),"L+)0D*LB+^6"1UB+4"-"3A+|%" + c + U(&6.1*(.7 + ,"/D"a(")%* + U,&30%* + )0#7 + (. +E"(0 + ),0-)%(&6",B+2"1("C0((" + 2-"a&%* + -./($0 + )"C&.1*($0 + -"1&B + (.U5&%*)7+2-&30-a&,.%*)7 + "#_&O + 3"4","-0((")%0'A + |%" + c + 2-&"#-0%0(&0+#0)C0(("4" + "2$%. + 2-03)%.,10(&7 + %-.3&C&' + ),"0' + )0D*& + & + 2"2$%6.+2"(7%*+"#$5.&+)0D*&B+2-&(&D.L_0'+%0#7+6.6+4")%7A+l5&%017+"%D05.L%+2",$^0(&0+U50#("'+D"%&,.C&&+-0#7%+&+20-0(0)0(&0+(",$O+317+(&O+E"-D + /.(7%&' + & + )2")"#", + 307%01*(")%& + , + 2",)03(0,(UL +^6"1*(UL+a&/(*A

"?C $@,-.A2A27 $c + ,$O"3 +(. + 4-.(&CU + ),"0' +2-.6%&6&A +l5&%017+-./,&,.L_04" + "#U50(&7 + & + U5&%017 + 61.))&50)6"' + (.5.1*("' +^6"1$B+&D0L_&0 + #"4.%$' + "2$% + & + 2-03)%.,10(&0 + " + %"DB + 6.6 + 3"1a0( + #$%*+U)%-"0(+U50#($'+2-"C0))B+)%.16&,.L%)7+)+%0DB+5%"+,+3-U4&O+2-.6%&6.O+D"a0%+#$%*+&(.50k+/".$&#(:+.(U.&'"&3(&H(#.(-$R&)*":'84&-(."#$(?&78:$#(U.&0(-+0.+%."?F'+R & 0(-$ &H?('$#)U.&07+" & )*":'+" & 7#"-% &$&

+9"'$7(U.&0/"?(''+"=&

l5&%017 +6=,-2725$@,-.A2A1/1B+UD0L_&0+-.#"%.%*+)+&(%0-0)"D+-0#0(6. + & + 2"330-a&,.%* + 04" + &(&C&.%&,UB + )%.-.L%)7 + &)6.%* + 2-&0D$+&(3&,&3U.1&/.C&&+&+)2")"#$+-0E106)&&+,(U%-&+/.3.(("4"+E"-D.%.A+M$)%-"0((.7 + , + -.D6.O + 2-"4-.DD$ + 203.4"4&50)6.7 + -0E106)&7+2"/,"170% + 203.4"4.D + (.O"3&%* + 2-"#10D($0 + %"56& + ),"&O + 2-.6%&6B+

8=;

Page 124: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

2"#Ua3.0%+20-0")D$)1&,.%*+203.4"4&50)6UL+307%01*(")%*+&+)2")"#$+,/.&D"30')%,&7 + ,(U%-& + 2-"E0))&"(.1*("4" + )""#_0)%,.A + \.6.7+2"/&C&7 + ,/-")1"4"B + (. + ,/4173 + .,%"-", + 2-"4-.DD$B + )2")"#)%,U0%+)%.(",10(&L+)U#d06%("'+2"/&C&&+D1.3^&O+^6"1*(&6",A+

A?%&#+/$."?"4+ U5.)%&0 +, +2-"4-.DD0+c +,"/D"a(")%* +"#"4.%&%*+-"3&%01*)6&'+"2$%B+,/417(U%*+(.+),"04"+-0#0(6.+)"+)%"-"($B+U,&30%*+04" + (. + E"(0 + + -",0)(&6",A + l5.)%&0 + , + 2-"4-.DD0 + f!")03)%,"g + c+"%,0%)%,0(($' +^.4k +(. +(0301L+)%.%* +D("4"30%("' +)0D*0'B +3",0-&%*+),"& + "#$5.& + & + %-.3&C&&B + (.'%& + + ,-0D7 + + 317 + -.,("4" + "#_0(&7 + + )+30%*D&e+

F" + &%"4.D + 6.a3"' + )0))&& + )"/3.0%)7 + .1*D.(.OB + 6(&4.B+,&30"E&1*DB+0a03(0,("+,$2U)6.0%)7+(.)%0((.7+O-"(&6.+)"#$%&'A +�.+)50% + -./(""#-./&7 + E"-D.%",B + )1"a(" + U)%-"0(("4" + D("4"U-",(0,"4"+2-")%-.()%,. + ,"/(&6.0% + &(%0()&,($' + -0a&DB + , + 6"%"-"D +^.()$ + (.+1&5($0 + )"#$%&7 + + U5.)%(&6", + U,01&5&,.L%)7A + !04"3(7 + D"a("+"2-03010((" + )6./.%*B + 5%" + a&/(* + , + 2-"06%0 + c + /.D05.%01*(.7+,"/D"a(")%*+"%50%1&,"+U,&30%*+&+2"(7%*B+5%"+)")03&+#$,.L%++-./($0B+f("+,)0+"(&+2"O"a&0+%0DB+5%"+"(&+c+O"-"^&0g+9)1",.+&/+20)(&B+6"%"-UL+30%&+)"5&(&1&+).D&<+&B+5%"+)",D0)%("0+#$%&0+c+,01&6"0+ +,-.#--*3&^$9&1&+%"#."vU$DDD

p,82-4$28/=482A2$2;=.>27.31C$/./$=,6R=6$,A2$62;481532681+

6=>=J(?$-+7(

!+D"D0(%.+D"04"+20-,"4"+^6"1*("4"+,$2U)6.+2-"^1"+3,0(.3C.%*+10%A+G+,"+,-0D7+,)%-05&+)+Ua0++2",/-")10,^&D&+-0#7%.D&+&/+1L#&D"4"+&+(0/.#$,.0D"4"+88J#+&/+U)%+"3("4"+&/+,$2U)6(&6",B+%020-*+"E&C0-.+,""-Ua�(($O + )&1B + "%C. + 27%&10%(04" + -0#�(6.B + 2-"/,U5.1. + E-./.B+2"-./&,^00 + D0(7A + Z( + 2-031"a&1 + , + )103UL_&' + -./ + ,)%-0%&%*)7+"#7/.%01*(" + , +^6"10B + , + 61.))0 + & + 2-",0)%& + U-"6B + 6.6 + -.(*^0e+Q.6+-.(*^0A+|%.+E-./.+/.C02&1.B+&+)%-.(("'+2"6./.1.)*+2-")*#.B+.+(.+D"'+,"2-")B +5%" +/(.5&%B +f6.6+-.(*^0g+&+2"50DU+,"/(&61"+a01.(&0+)(",.+)0)%*+/.+2.-%UB+7+U)1$^.1.+"%,0%k+e+U-"6&+#$1&+317+(.)+(.)%"7_&D+)"#$%&0Dw+O"50%)7+0_�+-./+20-0a&%*+-.3")%*+"#_0(&7+&+2")%&a0(&7+(","4"A

l-"6B + )%.,^&' +0+:8.$"-e + F"50DUB + )2U)%7 + 4"3$B + 04" + (0+/.)1"(7L% + 3-U4&0 + )"#$%&7B + (.,0-("0B + (0 + D0(00 + ,.a($0A +G)O"37 + &/+)0D.(%&6& + 2"(7%&7B + D$ + "2-030170D + 41.,("0 + + U)1",&0k + ,)�B + 5%"+2-"&)O"3&%++(.+U-"60B++3"1a("+/.%-.4&,.%*++1&5($0+&(%0-0)$+-0#�(6.B+#$%*+/(.5&D"+ +317+(04"A+i+O"-"^"+2"D(L+D"D0(%B+6"43.+"50(*+")%-"+

8=:

Page 125: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

,)%.1. + 2-"#10D. + + "#(",10(&7 + )"30-a.(&7 + 2-02"3.,.(&7B + ,(03-0(&7+(",$O+%0O("1"4&'B+6"%"-$0+2"/,"1&1&+#$+6.a3"4"+U50(&6.+,61L5&%*+,+U50#($' + 2-"C0))B + )2")"#)%,",.1& + #$ + E"-D&-",.(&L + %,"-50)6"4"B+6-&%&50)6"4"+ +D$^10(&7+(.+")(",0+")"/(.(("4"+",1.30(&7+(.U5($D&+/(.(&7D&B+)2")"#(")%&+6+).D"-./,&%&LA+

�(.6"D)%," + ) + %0O("1"4&7D& + + "%6-$%"4" + "#-./",.(&7 + )%.1" + 317+D0(7+"%6-$%&0DA+!(.5.1.++c+)+D0%"3.D&+@,-.A2A1B,6/25$G.68,=6/25D$Z50(*+2-&,1061&+")(",($0+2"1"a0(&7+j-.(CU/)6"'+�-U22$+P","4"+Z#-./",.(&7B + 6"43. + U5&%01* +-.#"%.0% +(0 +(.3 + 2-&5&(.D& +(0U3.5 + 04"+U50(&6",B+.+(.3 +@=1B13.G1$R6@,W.B +5%"+3.0%+,"/D"a(")%*+,+2"1("'+D0-0+-.)6-$%*+%,"-50)6&'+2"%0(C&.1+%0OB +6%"+U5.)%,U0% +, +2-"C0))0+"#U50(&7A+\0D+).D$D+D$+-./-U^.0D+&()%-UD0(%$+&(%01106%U.1*("'+2.))&,(")%&B++&)O"37+&/+%"4"B+5%"+)2")"#($+,)0k+&+U50(&6&B+&+U5&%017A+

�1.,("0+c+(.U5&%*)7+%,"-&%*+,D0)%0+,+2-"C0))0+2"/(.(&7A+M+x%"D+)1U5.0+U50(&6&+(0+%"1*6"+307%01&B+("+&+.,%"-$+),"04"+"#-./",.(&7B+2"x%"DU + (.^. + C01*k + ,61L50(&0 + 6.a3"4" + -0#0(6. + , + 2-"C0))+)"#)%,0(("4"+1&5(")%("4"+-./,&%&7B+)%.(",10(&0+)U#d06%("'+2"/&C&&B+)"/3.(&0+%.6"'+.%D")E0-$B+430+&+U+203.4"4.B+&+U+U50(&6.+2-"&)O"3&%+"#-0%0(&0+)0#7A+

m2-"#&-",., + %0O("1"4&L + (. + 2-.6%&60B + 7 + U#03&1.)* + , + 0�+xEE06%&,(")%&A + F-.,&1*(")%* + ,$#-.(("4" + (.D& + 2U%& + 2"3%,0-3&1&+U)20^($0+-0/U1*%.%$+&%"4","'+.%%0)%.C&&+,$2U)6(&6",A +\,"-50)6&0+)"5&(0(&7 + -0#7% + "%1&5.L%)7 + "-&4&(.1*(")%*LB + ).D"#$%(")%*LB+(02",%"-&D$D+2"3O"3"DA+M+6.a3"'+5U,)%,U0%)7+/.&(%0-0)",.((")%*+&+a01.(&0+)",0-^&%*+),"0+)"#)%,0(("0+"%6-$%&0A+F-",0-6.+)"5&(0(&'+20-0)%.1. + ,")2-&(&D.%*)7 +6.6 +(.3"0,^.7 +"#7/.((")%*k + ) + &(%0-0)"D+5&%.0^* + 6.a3UL + -.#"%UB + &("43. + 2"-.a.7)* + %"DUB + (.)6"1*6"+"-&4&(.1*($+&+(0"#$5($B+2"-"'+2.-.3"6).1*($+,$,"3$+-0#7%A

`.)^&-&1" + D"� + 2-03)%.,10(&0 + "# + &((",.C&"(($O+"#-./",.%01*($O + %0O("1"4&7O + /(.6"D)%," + ) + D0%"3.D& + & + 2-&�D.D&+-./,&%&7 + 6-&%&50)6"4" + D$^10(&7B + 60')J)%.3&B + 30#.%$A + h17 + D0(7+,.a("B +5%"+"%6-$%"0+"#-./",.(&0+-0^.L%+2-"#10DU+D"%&,.C&&A +|%U+EU(6C&L+,$2"1(70%+f&(3U6%"-gB+6"%"-$'+2"D"4.0%+U50(&6.D+")"/(.%*+&O + D"%&,.C&"(($' + /.2-")A + |%" + D"a0% + #$%* + /.3.(&0 + ,"6-U4 + )1",.B+2-03D0%.B + -&)U(6.B + DU/$6.1*("4" + "%-$,6. + c + (0"a&3.(("0 + &+"#7/.%01*("+1&5(")%("0A+

Q.6 + 2"D"5* + xD"C&"(.1*(" + ,")2-&(7%* + -.))6./ + GANU(&(.+fm(%"(",)6&0 + 7#1"6&gAAA + M + (.5.10 + U-"6. + D"a(" + 2-031"a&%*+"3&((.3C.%&61.))(&6.D + 2"2-"#",.%* + )"5($0 + 3.-$ + ")0(&B + D$+-./-0/.0D+)201$0+21"3$B+&+61.))+(.2"1(&%)7+(02",%"-&D$D+.-"D.%"D+7#1"6B +&+D$B+6.6+&+40-"&+x%"4"+-.))6./.B +(0+%"1*6"+5U,)%,U0DB +("+&+fU)1$^&Dg + /.2.O + .(%"(",)6&O + 7#1"6A +Z( +6.6 +#U3%" + /.2"1(70% + +(.)+&/(U%-&A + G + (.5(�%)7 + (.^0 + 2U%0^0)%,&0 + , + )%-.(UB + f6"%"-UL + D$+2"%0-71&gA+f{U3(.7+,1.)%*+2-"^1"4"g+/.O,.%$,.0%+(.)+&+-./,"-.5&,.0%+

8=@

Page 126: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

3&)6U))&LA + `"a3.0%)7 + C02* + .))"C&.C&' + & + "#-./",B + D$ + #0-0a("+,5&%$,.0D)7+,+%06)%B+2"(&D.7B+6.6+,.a(.+6.a3.7+30%.1*A+

�. + )%-.(&C.D& + -.))6./. + c + -./D$^10(&7 + 30%0' + " + `"))&&+)",-0D0(("'B+(0-./-$,("'+),7/&+,-0D�(B+),"&O+(.30a3.O+&+5.7(&7OA+Q./.1")*+#$B+(0#"1*^"'+(L.()k+#U3%"+)"^03^&'+)"+)%-.(&C+-.))6./.+.-"D.%+7#1"6e+P"+&D0(("+"(+2"/,"170%+U5._&D)7+U30-a&,.%*+),"&+"#-./",.%01*($0 + )D$)1$ + & + C01&A + ! + 2"D"_*L + &(3U6%"-. + D$+f,61L5.0Dg + 2"3)"/(.(&0B + )E0-U + xD"C&'B + �.&(%0-0)",.((")%*+2-"7,170%)7 + %"43.B + 6"43. + 2-&O"3&% + 5U,)%,"B + -"a3.0%)7 + D"/.&6.+,"2-")",A +P.+20-,$'+21.(+,$O"37%+2"/(.,.%01*($0+D"%&,$B+D"%&,$+).D""2-03010(&7A + h0%&B + 2"/(.,.7 + )0#7B + 2"/(.L% + D&-B + U5.%)7 + ,0)%&+3&.1"4B + 3"6./$,.%* + & + )1U^.%* + 3-U4 + 3-U4.B + (0 + 3.,.7 + "C0("5($O+)Ua30(&'B + 6"%"-$0 +D"41& +2"D0^.%* + %,"-50)%,UA +\.6 +2-0"3"10,.0%)7+"%5Ua3�((")%*+U50(&6.+"%+2-03D0%.A++

|EE06%+"50,&30(k+6.6+41.)&%+&/,0)%($'+2)&O"1"4&50)6&'+%0/&)k+fh07%01*(")%*+,1&70%+(.+1&5(")%*+,+D0-U+,61L5�((")%&+501",06.+,+0�+),0-^0(&0g+98<A+|%"+/(.5&%B+5%"+)"#$%&'(")%*+)%.(",&%)7+,.a(0'^&D+E.6%"-"D+-0/U1*%.%&,(")%&+"#-./",.(&7A+!U%*+)"#$%&'(")%&+(.+U-"60+c + , + (","D + "%("^0(&& + 6 + /(.(&LB + 2"31&(("0 + )"03&(0(&0 + ) + D&-"DB+6"%"-$'+2-03)%"&%+2"/(.%*A +G+,+x%"D+2"/(.(&&+,)76"0+(","0+/(.(&0+)%.(",&%)7 + (",$D + 1&^* + 2"%"DUB + 5%" + -0#�("6 + 2"-$,.0% + ) + %0DB + 5%"+)5&%.1+2-.,&1*($D++3"+)&O+2"-k+"%6./+"%+)%.-"4"+&+)"%,"-0(&0+(","4"A+Z%6./+&+ +%,"-50)%,"+")U_0)%,17L%)7+U50(&6"DB+6"%"-$'+2-"06%&-U0%+2-"4-.DDU + ),"0' + 307%01*(")%& + 9U50#("'B + "#-./",.%01*("'<B + %A0A+f"-4.(&/U0% + + 30')%,&7 + , + -0)U-)("JC010,"D + 2"10B + 430 + 501",06U+(0"#O"3&D"+"2-0301&%*+"#1.)%*+&+4-.(&C$+),"&O+,"/D"a(")%0'g+9=<A+

+ Z#0)2050(&0 + )U#d06%("4" + 2",030(&7 + U5._&O)7 + 7,170%)7+2-03D0%"D+-.#"%$+U5&%017+(.+U-"60B+6"%"-$'+D"a0%+#$%*+2-03)%.,10(+6.6 + )"#$%&0A + Z#7/.%01*($' + x10D0(% + (. + %.6"D + U-"60 + c + ")"/(.(&0+6"(E1&6%. + , + ).D"D + )0#0B + (02"1("%$ + ),"04" + 2-0a(04" + /(.(&7 + &+-./-U^0(&0 + x%"4" + 6"(E1&6%. + ,"10,$D + U)&1&0D + 2-"3,&a0(&7 + &+2-0"3"10(&7A+�30)*+6.6+#$+)(&D.0%)7+,"2-")+6"(6-0%("4"+2-03D0%("4"+/(.(&7B +%.6 +6.6+/.6"("D+7,170%)7 +)&(%0/ +,)0O+,&3",+307%01*(")%&+&+"#-._0(&0+6+,"/D"a(")%7D+&(%01106%.+501",06.+,+C01"DA+`0#�("6+).D+)%-"&%+),"'+2U%*+2"/(.(&7B+.+41.,("0+c+20-0a&,.0%+3"#$%$0+/(.(&7A+

|%" + 1&5(")%("0 + "%("^0(&0 + 6 + ),"0DU + "#-./",.(&L + 7,170%)7+).D$D + ,.a($DA + G)2"1*/U7 + %0O("1"4&& + "%6-$%"4" + "#-./",.(&7B + D$+"-4.(&/U0D+ +' U50#($'+ +2-"C0))B + 2")%-"0(($'+(. +")(",0 +.6%&,("4"+,/.&D"30')%,&7 + U5.)%(&6", + , + O"30 + ,$2"1(0(&7 + )0-&& + /.3.(&'B+2-&,"37_&O+6+")D$)10(&L+&+f,$)%-.&,.(&Lg+(","4"+/(.(&7A

M + 2")103(00 + ,-0D7 + 6.a3$' + -./ + 20-03 + &/U50(&0D + %0D$B+2"),7_�(("'+%,"-50)%,U+mARA�"-*6"4"B+7+3UD.1.B+6.6+"%,105*+30%0'+"%+&30"1"4&50)6&O + )%0-0"%&2",B + 6"%"-$0 + /.6-02&1&)* + /. + &D0(0D+2&).%017B+&+2"D"5*+U,&30%*+U50(&6.D+)%-.3.L_UL+3U^U+.,%"-.B+04"+&)%&(("0 + 1&C"A + i + (.5.1. + ) + 5%0(&7 + fP0),"0,-0D0(($O + D$)10'gA+

8=Y

Page 127: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

l5._&0)7B + -.#"%.7 + ) + %06)%"D + 3(0,(&6",B + 6-&%&50)6& + .(.1&/&-U7+%06)%$B + )")%.,&1& + 2"-%-0% + (0&/,0)%("4" + &D + .,%"-.w + 7 + 2"2-")&1.+(./,.%*+.))"C&.C&&B+),7/.(($0+)+&D0(0D+�"-*6"4"A+!.D$0+"a&3.0D$0B+0)%0)%,0(("k +)"-.%(&6 +�0(&(.B +2-"10%.-)6&'+2&).%01*B +,")20,.,^&'+&30.1$ + -0,"1LC&&A +G + 6"43. + %.'(. + &D0(& + .,%"-. + 3(0,(&6", + + #$1.+-.)6-$%.B+7++U,&301.+(03"UD0(&0++(.+1&C.O+D"&O+U50(&6",A+M+&O+UD.O+/.-"3&1)7 + 6"(E1&6%B + 6"%"-$' + %-0#",.1 + (0D0310(("4" + -./-0^0(&7A+!103UL_&0 + U-"6& + 2-"^1& + (. + "3("D + 3$O.(&&A + \.6 + ,01&6" + #$1"+a01.(&0+30%0'+(.'%&+&)%&(U+&+"%,0%&%*+(.+,"1(UL_&0+&O+,"2-")$A+F"+)U_0)%,UB+D$+Ua0+-.#"%.1&+,+2-")%-.()%,0+)"#$%&'(")%&A+h17+D0(7+5-0/,$5.'(" + ,.a(" + 2-&,&%* + U5._&D)7 + f,6U)g + 6 + ).D")%"7%01*("DU+D$^10(&LB + -./,&,.%* + 6"DDU(&6.%&,($0 + (.,$6&B + )2")"#)%,",.%*+-.)6-$%&L + &O + %,"-50)6"4" + 2"%0(C&.1.B + ",1.30(&L + %0O(&6"'+-0E106)&,("4"+D$^10(&7A+

Q.6 + )"#$%&'(.7 + ,")2-&(&D.L%)7 + U5._&D&)7 + 2-"06%(.7+307%01*(")%*A +M03*+2-"06%B +) +%"56& +/-0(&7+U50(&6.B +c +307%01*(")%*B+2"/,"17L_.7 + 2-"7,&%* + )0#7B + 2"2-"#",.%* + ),"& + )&1$B + 2-&1"a&%*+/(.(&7B+2-&(0)%&+2"1*/U+&+2"6./.%*+2U#1&5("+3")%&4(U%$'+-0/U1*%.%w+fx%" +307%01*(")%*B +(.2-.,10((.7 +(. +-0^0(&0 +&(%0-0)("'+2-"#10D$B+)E"-DU1&-",.(("'+).D&D&+ +U5._&D&)7+,+,&30+C01&+&+/.3.5&B+6"43.+-0/U1*%.% + c + (.'30(($' + )2")"# + -0^0(&7 + 2-"#10D$ + c + (")&%+2-.6%&50)6&' +O.-.6%0- +& +&D00% +,.a("0 +2-&61.3("0 +/(.50(&0 +&B +5%"+,0)*D.+)U_0)%,0(("B+&(%0-0)0(+&+/(.5&D+317+).D&O+"%6-$,.%010'g+9;<A+F-"06%(.7+307%01*(")%*+-./,&,.0%+(.,$6&+).D")%"7%01*("4"+2-&(7%&7+-0^0(&'B + D$)1&%01*("' + 307%01*(")%&B + ).D".(.1&/.B + -0E106)&&B+).D")%"7%01*("' + -.#"%$ + ) + &)%"5(&6.D&B + &()%-UD0(%.D&B + 5%"B+#0/U)1",("B+),7/.("+)+/.3.50'+ +)"/3.(&7+U5._&D)7+6"(C02C&&+"#-./.+).D"4"+)0#7A+

j.6%"-+)"#$%&'(")%&+,+-.D6.O+-0.1&/.C&&+2-"06%.+)2")"#)%,U0%+f2-"3,&a0(&L + U5._04")7 + , + 2"10 + 3")%&a0(&'B + 430 + )U_0)%,U0%+&30.1*("0+ 96U1*%U-($0+"#-./C$< +& +-0.1*("0+ 9501",050)6&0+a01.(&7B+&(%0-0)$<A + |%" + ),"0"#-./("0 + f2-")%-.()%," + "2-"#",.(&7g + 9:<A + F"+D$)1& + NA|1*6"(&(.B + f)U_0)%,0(("' + O.-.6%0-&)%&6"' + 2-"#("4"+2-")%-.()%,. + & + 04" + f(0)U_&Dg +!"#$%&0D + 7,170%)7 + )&)%0D.%&50)6&+,"))"/3.,.0D$' + 20-0O"3 + D0a3U + 2-"#("J2"&)6",$D + & + -0.1&/UL_0J-0/U1*%.%&,($D+/(.50(&0D+30')%,&7gw+6.6+-0/U1*%.%B+f307%01*(")%($0+2-&-")%$+&+(",""#-./",.(&7+,+"#1.)%&+)U#d06%(")%&B+-0E106)&,($O+UD0(&'+&+-0E106)&,("4"+"2$%.B+"2$%.+).D""2-03010(&7+&+U2-.,10(&7+-0)U-).D&g + 9@<A + l50(&6B + -.#"%.7 + , + 2-")%-.()%,0 + )"#$%&'(")%&B+",1.30,.0% + )2")"#.D& + ).D""#-./",.(&7B + ).D"-0.1&/.C&&B+,")2-&(&D.0%+2-"&)O"37_00+(.+U-"60+6.6+-0)U-)+317+).D")%"7%01*("4"+"#-./",.%01*("4"+3,&a0(&7B+ +%A0A+"%,05.0%+(.+,"2-")B+50DU+&+/.50D+"(+U5&%)7A + \.6 + "( + 2"1U5.0% + ,"/D"a(")%* + -0.1&/",.%* + ),"'+&(3&,&3U.1*($'+/.6./+(.+"#-./",.(&0A

8=I

Page 128: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

e18,=.8R=.8A +B+?%1+7&!=A=+ `0.1&)%&50)6"0+,")2&%.(&0AJ +RAk +�0(%-+fF03.4"4&50)6&'+2"&)6gB+=>>:AJ+!A+8:>A=A +\?F1+'$' & N=A=+ F-"#. + 6.6 + 6"()%-U6% + "#-./",.%01*("' + )&)%0D$ + ��+F03.4"4&6. + -./,&%&7k + 61L50,$0 + 6"D20%0(%(")%& + & + &O + )%.(",10(&0k+R.%0-&.1$ + ?J"' + (.U5("J2-.6%&50)6"' + 6"(E0-0(C&& + � + Q-.)("7-)6&'+�")U3.-)%,0(($'++l(&,0-)&%0%AJ+Q-.)("7-)6B+=>>;AJ+!A@+J+==A;A+B(2+-+7(&6=I=+R0%"3+U50#("4"+2-"06%.+,+"#-./",.%01*("D+U5-0a30(&&k+F")"#&0AJ+RAk+m`Q\GB+=>>KAJ+!A+8IA:A+A+?T+7(&P=D=+\*L%"-)%,"+,+.)206%0+-0/U1*%.%&,(")%&+"#-./",.(&7A+J�tt�k��¥¥¥At�ztqto�A�q���o�u�tsn«zv>=A�tp«

@A +\?F1+'$' & N=A=+ F-"#. + 6.6 + 6"()%-U6% + "#-./",.%01*("' + )&)%0D$ + ��+F03.4"4&6. + -./,&%&7k + 61L50,$0 + 6"D20%0(%(")%& + & + &O + )%.(",10(&0k+R.%0-&.1$ + ?J"' + (.U5("J2-.6%&50)6"' + 6"(E0-0(C&& + � + Q-.)("7-)6&'+�")U3.-)%,0(($'+l(&,0-)&%0%AJ+Q-.)("7-)6B+=>>;AJ+!A@+J+==A

E;=.>27.8,?<32,$62;481,$/./$=,6R=6$@=2X,66123.?<32A2$68.327?,31C$

68R-,3827$@,-.A2A1B,6/2A2$7R>.

6=C=B$?$H*"701(%R&6=C=B".#+H(7?+701(%&

F-"E0))&"(.1*("0 + )%.(",10(&0 + 1&5(")%& + #U3U_04" + U5&%017 + ,+2-"C0))0 + 04" + 2"34"%",6& + , + ,$)^0' + ^6"10 + ,61L5.0% + (0 + %"1*6"+",1.30(&0 + )%U30(%.D& + 61L50,$D& + 6"D20%0(%(")%7D&B + (" + & + 04"+2-"E0))&"(.1*("J1&5(")%("0 + ).D")",0-^0()%,",.(&0B + )%.(",10(&0+.6%&,("' +a&/(0(("' + 2"/&C&&A +Z3(" + &/ + 2-&"-&%0%($O + (.2-.,10(&'+,$)^04" +203.4"4&50)6"4" + "#-./",.(&7 + c + ,$-.#"%6. + &(3&,&3U.1*("'+%-.06%"-&& + )"C&.1*("' + a&/(&B + 2-"06%&-",.(&0 + & + -0.1&/.C&7+)"#)%,0(("4" + "#-./",.%01*("4" + D.-^-U%.B + 2-"E0))&"(.1*("'+"#-./",.%01*("'+2-"4-.DD$A+P0+)1U5.'("+,+2")103(00+30)7%&10%&0+,+)&)%0D0 + "#-./",.(&7 + 2"7,&1.)* +327.C $ @2>101C $ Q $ 8<H82=.A + ~�+/.(&D.L% + )%U30(%$ + )%.-^&O + 6U-)",B + )"/3.L_&0 + "-4.(&/.C&"(("J203.4"4&50)6&0 + U)1",&7 + 317 + -0.1&/.C&& + &(3&,&3U.1*($O + 2-"4-.DD+-./,&%&7 + )%U30(%",J20-,"6U-)(&6",B + ")U_0)%,17L_&0 + 2)&O"1"4"J203.4"4&50)6UL + 2"330-a6U + & + )"2-","a30(&0 + 2" + E"-D&-",.(&L+)U#d06%("'+2"/&C&&A+

M + &))103",.(&7O + RASAT&1&("'B + PASA�-.50,"' + ,$3017L%)7+)103UL_&0+,&3$+2-"E0))&"(.1*("'+307%01*(")%&+%*L%"-.+,+,$)^0'+^6"10k + )"2-","a30(&0 + -./-.#"%6& + & + -0.1&/.C&& + )%U30(%.D&+2-"E0))&"(.1*($O + "#-./",.%01*($O + 2-"4-.DDB + 6"()U1*%&-",.(&0+")%.1*($O+U5.)%(&6",+"#-./",.%01*("4"+2-"C0)).B+U5.)%&0+,+U50#("JD0%"3&50)6"D + & + 3"6UD0(%.1*("D + "#0)2050(&0 + "#-./",.%01*("4"+2-"C0)).B + "-4.(&/.C&7 + 2"34"%",6& + & + 2-",030(&7 + "#-./",.%01*("4"+)"#$%&7+9;<A+

8=K

Page 129: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

G/ + 2-03)%.,10(($O + ,&3", + 2-"E0))&"(.1*("' + 307%01*(")%&+%*L%"-.+2"3-"#(00+")%.(",&D)7+(.+O.-.6%0-&)%&60+2;=.>27.8,?<32A2$62;481CA +RASAT&1&(. +-.))D.%-&,.0% +"#-./",.%01*("0 +)"#$%&0 + 6.6+0$.)(9$UR & 1+.+#(%+ H"#"W$7(".0% & $ & +0+3'(�.0% & *"?+7"1+- & 1(1&3'(*$-(%&`H+7+#+.'(%a&7&"T+&0+:0.7"''+-&+:#(3+7('$$R&1+T/(&*"?+7"1&

+:#".(".&'+78"&3'('$%R&'(#(V$7(".&1+-H"."'.'+0.$R&0+:0.7"'')U&

0):]"1.'+0.FR&78')W/"'&-"'%.F&0."#"+.$H8&/"40.7$4+9:<A+mAmA�U60-B + PAMARUO.B + RARAR&-60) + "#-./",.%01*("0 + )"#$%&0+

"%(")7%+6 +-+/"?%-&.FU.+#01+4&/"%."?F'+0.$+$&#(00-(.#$7(U.&"T+&1(1 & 0+7-"0.'+" & H#+W$7('$" & 0$.)(9$4R+ 2-","C&-UL_&O + "50-03($0+^.4&+2"3"205("4"A+M(U%-&+)"#$%&7+"-4.(&/UL%)7+&(%0()&,($0+2-"#$B+)"/3.L%)7 + )&%U.C&& + (0"2-0301�((")%&B + 6"%"-$0 + ) + "3("' + )%"-"($+2"3%.16&,.L% + U5.)%(&6", + "#-.%&%*)7 + 6 + )"#)%,0(($D + -0)U-).DB+3"2"1(&%01*($D + ,)2"D"4.%01*($D + )-03)%,.DB + ) + 3-U4"' + )%"-"($+O.-.6%0-&/UL%)7 + "%(")&%01*("' + ),"#"3"' + 30')%,&'B + ,"/D"a(")%0'A+!"2-","a3.7+"#-./",.%01*("0+)"#$%&0B+%*L%"-+"-4.(&/U0%+-0E106)&L+3,&a0(&7 + U5.)%(&6. + , + 2"10 + -./(""#-./($O + ,"/D"a(")%0'B+)2")"#)%,U0%+,$)%-.&,.(&L+&(3&,&3U.1*("'+%-.06%"-&&A+

F-03)%.,&D+"2$%+"-4.(&/.C&&+&+2-",030(&7+"3("4"+&/+/(.5&D$O+)"#$%&'+317+)%U30(%",+&+%*L%"-",+c+�0%(0'+\*L%"-)6"'+�6"1$A+|%"+,$0/3(.7B + &(%0()&,(" + "-4.(&/",.((.7B + %-0OJ50%$-0O3(0,(.7 + ^6"1.J2"4-Ua0(&0B + 6"%"-.7 + 6.a3$' + 4"3 + "%1&5.0%)7 + -./(""#-./&0D + E"-D+2-",030(&7 + , + /.,&)&D")%& + "% + ")(",("' + &30& + 2-"06%.A + {0%,0-%.7+�0%(77+\*L%"-)6.7+�6"1. +2-","3&1.)*+,+-.D6.O+-0.1&/.C&&+D.1"4"+)"C&.1*("J203.4"4&50)6"4" + 2-"06%. + f\*L%"-)6"0 + )""#_0)%,"+)%U30(%",+&+,$2U)6(&6",+Q�Fl+&DA+MAFA+m)%.E*0,.gA+

Z)(",(.7 + C01* + ^6"1$k + "#0)205&%* + U)1",&7 + )%.(",10(&7+%*L%"-)6"4"+)""#_0)%,.+)%U30(%",+&+,$2U)6(&6",+,U/.B+&(%0()&,("4"+"#D0(. + "2$%"DB + (.1.a&,.(&7 + 2-"E0))&"(.1*($O + & + 1&5($O + ),7/0'+D0a3U + )%U30(%.D&B + 2-02"3.,.%017D& + & + 3-U4&D& + )20C&.1&)%.D&B+/.(&D.L_&D&)7 + 2-"#10D.D& + %*L%"-)6"4" + )"2-","a30(&7 + , + -./($O+)&)%0D.O + "#-./",.(&7A + �\�J=>>? + 31&1.)* + 50%$-0 + 3(7B + "#_00+6"1&50)%,"+00+U5.)%(&6",+)")%.,&1"+I>+501",06A+

G/+(&O+c+f(",&56&g+9%0B+6%"+(0+2-03)%.,170%B+5%"+/(.5&%+-.#"%.%*+=@+5.)",+, +)U%6&<B +f#$,.1$0g+9%0B +6%"+ /(.0%B +6.6 +-.)2-0301&%* +),"&+)&1$+(.+,)0+3(&<+&+f6"-&E0&g+9%0B+6%"+50%$-0+4"3.+(./.3+"-4.(&/",.1+20-,UL + %*L%"-)6UL + ^6"1U<A +F"D&D" + 2-02"3.,.%010'B + )%U30(%", + &+,$2U)6(&6", + , + 5&)1" + U5.)%(&6", +�6"1$ + ,"^1& + )%.-^061.))(&6&B+6"%"-$0+,$)%U2&1&+,+-"1&+"-4.(&/.%"-",+"3("4"+&/+D0-"2-&7%&'+2"+%0O("1"4&&+2-",030(&7+)"C&.1*("J2"10/($O+.6C&'A+

l)%.(","5($' + 3"61.3k + f\*L%"-)%," + 6.6 + -0)U-)+2-"E0))&"(.1*("4" + & + 1&5(")%("4" + )%.(",10(&7 + )20C&.1&)%.gB + )+6"%"-"4" + (.5.1.)* + -.#"%. + �6"1$B + 2"/,"1&1 + U5.)%(&6.D + ")"/(.%*+6"(C02C&L + 2-03)%"7_0' + 307%01*(")%&B + ,$)%-"&%* + )"#)%,0((UL+"#-./",.%01*(UL+)%-.%04&LB+D.-^-U%+3,&a0(&7+(.+�6"10B+"2-0301&%*+

8=?

Page 130: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

,(U%-0((&0 + & + ,(0^(&0 + -0)U-)$ + 317 + &O + -0.1&/.C&&B + . + %.6a0+(.)%-"&%*)7+(.+&(%0()&,(UL+-.#"%UA+

F0-03+U5.)%(&6.D&+#$1.+2")%.,10(.+/.3.5.+c+1>2;=.>18<$@?.3F/.=8R $ 62;687,332A2 $ 2;=.>27.8,?<32A2 $ -71c,31C $(. +�6"10 + 2U%�D+)"2")%.,10(&7+),"&O+C010'B +&(%0-0)",B +"a&3.(&'+)+%"'+2-"4-.DD"'+�6"1$B+6"%"-.7+#$1.+2-031"a0(.+"-4.(&/.%"-.D&A+

M%"-"0+&(%0-0)("0+&+,.a("0+30')%,&0+c+2.(01*(.7+3&)6U))&7+)+x10D0(%.D& + D"301&-",.(&7$ fF-"E0))&"(.1*("0 + )%.(",10(&0+)20C&.1&)%. +, +,U/0A +Q.6&0 +U)1",&7 +,.a($�gB +6"%"-.7 +)")%"71.)* +,"+,%"-"'+30(*+�6"1$+&+#$1.+1"4&50)6&D+2-"3"1a0(&0D+20-,"4"+3(7A+M+O"30+.6%&,("4"+"#)Ua30(&7+)%U30(%$+,$7,&1&+%0+-0)U-)$B+6"%"-$D&+-.)2"1.4.0% + ,U/ + & + 6"%"-$0 + "(& + D"4U% + &)2"1*/",.%* + , + O"30+2-"E0))&"(.1*("4"+)%.(",10(&7A+

F.(01*(.7 + 3&)6U))&7 + ) + x10D0(%.D& + D"301&-",.(&7+2-03U)D.%-&,.0%+)103UL_UL+)%-U6%U-Uk

V+x%.2+c+2")%.(",6.+2-"#10D$wVV+ x%.2 + c + D"301&-",.(&0 + 92-",030(&0 + 4-U22","4" + .(.1&/.+

"#-./",.%01*($O + -0)U-)",B + 2-"06%&-",.(&0 + & + 2-03)%.,10(&0+D"3010'+2-"E0))&"(.1*("4"+)%.(",10(&7+)%U30(%",<wVVV+ x%.2 + c + .(.1&%&50)6&' + 9-.#"%. + , + 4-U220 + )#"-6& + 2"+

"#"#_0(&L+D"3010'B+2-03)%.,10(&0+&+/._&%.+"#_0'+D"301&<wV­+x%.2+c+%0O("1"4&50)6&'+9"),"0(&0+%0O("1"4&'<w+­+x%.2+c+-0E106)&7A

h.(("0 + D0-"2-&7%&0 + 2"/,"1&1" + U5.)%(&6.D + "2-0301&%*+f2-"#01$g + , + &(E"-D.C&"(("D + 2-")%-.()%,0 + U(&,0-)&%0%. + &+,$)%-"&%* + 2U%& + 2" + &O + U)%-.(0(&LB + . + %.6a0 + ",1.30%* + (",$D&+%0O("1"4&7D&B + (.U5&%*)7 + .-4UD0(%&-",.%* + ),"L + %"56U + /-0(&7B+,$)%-.&,.%*+6"()%-U6%&,($'+3&.1"4+,+2-"C0))0+3&)6U))&&A+

M+%-0%&'+30(*+%*L%"-.(%$+"-4.(&/",.1&+6-U41$'+)%"1+(.+%0DUk+fQ"(6U-0(%")2")"#(")%* + ,$2U)6(&6", + 203.4"4&50)6"4" + ,U/. + ,+)",-0D0(("D + "#_0)%,0gA + M + O"30 + "#)Ua30(&7 + U5.)%(&6& + 2-&^1& + 6+"#_0DU+D(0(&L+"+%"DB +5%"+,+O"30+"#U50(&7+(0"#O"3&D"+",1.30,.%*+-./("4" + -"3. + 6"D20%0(C&7D&B + %.6&D& + 6.6k + .6D0"1"4&50)6&0B+2-"4(")%&50)6&0B+2-"06%&,($0B+6"()%-U6%&,($0B+.(.1&%&50)6&0+&+3-A

E8?1B18,?<34, $ W.=./8,=1681/1 $ 8<H82=6/2A2$62@=272c-,31C+U5.)%(&6",+(.+�6"10k+

• 0a03(0,("0 + )"2-","a30(&0 + U5.)%(&6", + (. + x%.2.O+2-"06%&-",.(&7+&+-0.1&/.C&&+21.(J6.-%$+f�.4+6+U)20OUgw• "-4.(&/.C&7 + &(3&,&3U.1*($O + %*L%"-)6&O+

6"()U1*%.C&'B + (.2-.,10(($O +(. + + ")"/(.(&0 + ),"04" +D0)%. + ,+2-")%-.()%,0+�6"1$A• 2-",030(&0 + 4-U22","' + -0E106)&& + ) + C01*L + .(.1&/.+

)"#$%&'+3(7B +"#)Ua30(&7+3.1*(0'^&O+20-)206%&,+&+)(7%&7+xD"C&"(.1*("4"+(.2-7a0(&7A+++

8;>

Page 131: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

�1.,(.7 + %-U3(")%*B + ) + 6"%"-"' +D"4U% + )%"16(U%*)7 + "-4.(&/.%"-$B+")U_0)%,17L_&0+3.(("0 +"#-./",.%01*("0 +)"#$%&0B +c+ (0"#O"3&D")%*+U30-a.%* + 2"/&C&L + %*L%"-. + & + (0 + )D0^&,.%* + 00 + ) + ")(",($D&+2-"E0))&"(.1*($D& + -"17D& + c + 2-02"3.,.%01*B + 2)&O"1"4B + D0(03a0-B+U2-.,10(0CA+

Z-4.(&/.C&7+&+2-",030(&0+2"3"#($O+"#-./",.%01*($O+)"#$%&'B+.+%.6a0 + &O + )"2-","a30(&0 + )2")"#)%,UL% + (.-._&,.(&L+6"D20%0(%(")%0'B + )2")"#(")%0'B + )U#d06%(")%& +)%U30(%",B +-.)6-$%&L+&O +1&5(")%("4" +2"%0(C&.1.B +5%"+2",$^.0% +6.50)%," +203.4"4&50)6&O+6.3-",+(","4"+2"6"10(&7A+

e18,=.8R=.8A K)/#%79"7 &Q=CA +F)&O"1"4"J203.4"4&50)6&0 +2-"#10D$ +,$)^0' +^6"1$ + ��+M"2-")$+2)&O"1"4&&A+8?K8A+H+=A+!AYI+J+Y?A

=A P"7$.(' &K=DA + �&5(")%* + 203.4"4.k + )%.(",10(&0 +& + -./,&%&0Ac +!.-.%",B+8??8Ac8;@)A

;A S$?$'( & D=I=R & M#(*"7( & 6=I=R+ F"3O"3$ + 6 + )%.(3.-%&/.C&&+2-"E0))&"(.1*("' + 307%01*(")%& + %*L%"-. + , + ,$)^0' + ^6"10 + ��+Z-4.(&/.C&7 + %*L%"-)6"4" + )"2-","a30(&7 + , + "#-./",.%01*($O+U5-0a30(&7Ok+)"30-a.(&0B+("-D&-",.(&0+&+)%.(3.-%&/.C&7+307%01*(")%&+%*L%"-.k + R.%0-&.1$ + M)0-"))&')6"4" + (.U5("JD0%"3&50)6"4" + )0D&(.-.+f!%.(3.-%$+%*L%"-)6"'+307%01*(")%&k+%0"-&7+&+2-.6%&6.gB+R")6,.B+8KJ8? + D.7 + =>>? + �P.U5A + -03A + \ARAQ",.10,.w + Z%,A + -03A + mAmA\0-",B + RASA+T&1&(.A+c+RAk+mFQ&FF`ZB+=>>?AJ+!A+@@A

:A S$?$'( & D=I=+ Z#-./",.%01*("0 + )"#$%&0k + ,.-&.(%$ + 2-"5%0(&7 + ��+Z-4.(&/.C&7 + %*L%"-)6"4" + )"2-","a30(&7 + , + "#-./",.%01*($O+U5-0a30(&7Ok+)"30-a.(&0B+("-D&-",.(&0+&+)%.(3.-%&/.C&7+307%01*(")%&+%*L%"-.k + R.%0-&.1$ + M)0-"))&')6"4" + (.U5("JD0%"3&50)6"4" + )0D&(.-.+f!%.(3.-%$+%*L%"-)6"'+307%01*(")%&k+%0"-&7+&+2-.6%&6.gB+R")6,.B+8KJ8? +D.7 +=>>? + � +P.U5A + -03A +\ARA +Q",.10,.w +Z%,A + -03A +mAmA +\0-",B +RASA+T&1&(.A+c+RAk+mFQ&FF`ZB+=>>?AJ+!A8@=J8@KA

@A !."H('+7(&@=I=R&>/+?F^&C=>=+F-"E0))&"(.1*(.7+2"34"%",6.+U5&%017+,+U)1",&7O+2")%&(3U)%-&.1*("4"+"#_0)%,.k +D"("4-.E&7+ � +Q-.)("7-A +4")A+203A+U(J%+&DA+MAFA+m)%.E*0,.A+c+Q-.)("7-)6B+=>>?A+c+@=>+)A++

f1@2?2A1C$@=,-68.7?,315$2$6,;,

<=!=M+:+7(R&G=6=@T'(.+7(

8;8

Page 132: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

{%"#$+2"(7%*+(.)%-"0(&0+&+"%("^0(&0+6+a&/(&+2"3-.)%.L_04"+2"6"10(&7B + (0"#O"3&D" + &/U5&%* + (.&#"100 + %&2&5($0 + 2-03)%.,10(&7+30%0'+&+2"3-")%6",+"+)0#0+&+),"�D+#U3U_0DA++M+2-"C0))0+&))103",.(&'+D$ + U)%.(",&1& + %-& + 61L50,$0 + )")%.,17L_&0B + (. + (.^ + ,/4173B+,.a(0'^&0+317+2-"06%&-",.(&7+&+")D$)10(&7+a&/(&k+f5)?<8L02+)?&8L02()$*"8A + \"B + 6.6 + "2-030170% + 317 + )0#7 + -0#�("6 + &1& + 2"3-")%"6 + x%&+)")%.,17L_&0+2"+D0-0+,/-")10(&7B +6.6&0+C01&+)%.,&%+&+3")%&4.0%+,+a&/(&B + 6.6"0 + 301" + 0DU + 2" + 3U^0 + & + 6.6.7 + D05%. + 3,&a0% + 04"+U)%-0D10(&7D&+c+&+2-&3.0%+(.2-.,10(&0+)%.(",10(&L+04"+1&5(")%&A+{0D+7)(00+"2-03010($+&+")"/(.($+2"3-")%6"D+04"+C01&B+301.+&+D05%$B+%0D+")D$)10((00+04"+-./,&%&0+&+%0D+&(%0-0)(00+04"+#U3U_00A

+!"C&.1*("J2)&O"1"4&50)6&'+2-"06%+fB0$2+?+T$*"01$4&H+#.#".&H+1+?"'$%g + "#d03&(&1 + ;@ + #"1*^&O + & + D.1$O + 4"-"3", + `"))&&A + R$+2"1U5&1& +#"100 +@>>> +"%,0%", +U50(&6", +) +20-,"4" +2" +"3&((.3C.%$'+61.))$B +, +6"%"-$O+)"30-a.1&)*+"2&).(&7+&O+2-03)%.,10(&'+"+),"&O+C017O+(. +#1&a.'^00+#U3U_00A +F-&+.(.1&/0 +2"1U50(($O+"%,0%",+D$+2-",01& +%&2"1"4&/.C&L+2-03)%.,10(&'A +Z)(",.(&0D +317 +-./3010(&7+%&2",+,$)%U2&1" +-&&*%&M)%,)05)?):L 0+)?"0, 0()$*4A +M +-0/U1*%.%0+"%,0%$+#$1&+-.)2-03010($+(. +88 +4-U22A +Q.a3.7 +4-U22. +"#d03&(70%+"%,0%$B + )O"3($0 + 2" + ")(",("' + (.2-.,10((")%&B + D&-",")2-&7%&LB+a&/(0(($D+C017D +& +&0-.-O&& +C0((")%0'B +& +D"a0% +#$%*+"%(0)0(. +6+"3("' + &/ + 3,UO + 6.%04"-&'B + "%-.a.L_&O + 1&#" + + 6"()%-U6%&,($0+92"/&%&,($0< + 2-03)%.,10(&7 + " + )0#0 + & + #U3U_0' + a&/(& + 1&#"+(06"()%-U6%&,($0+9(04.%&,($0<+2-03)%.,10(&7A

Q+ .&%-*1#.*,3%4( 0 N=&7,*,3%4(< + 2-03)%.,10(&7D + "%(")7%)7+)103UL_&0+4-U22$k

f�~�»P[~ + �G{PZ!\GgB + f|jj~Q\GMP[~+jlPQ�GZP~`[gB + fhZRZyZ�i]QGgB + f!M~\!QG~ + hmR[gB+fZN´~!\M~PP[~+h~i\~�GgB+fh~�ZM[~+�ShGgA

Q+%).&%-*1#.*,3%4(0N%)O"*,3%4(<+2-03)%.,10(&7D+"%(")7%)7+%.6&0+4-U22$k

f m�PZNZ]gB+fP~ZF`~h~�GM�G~!igB+f�mQ`[\[]+\GFgB+fP~�m\GMgA+

h.,.'%0 +2"/(.6"D&D)7 +) +6.a3"'+4-U22"'+, +"%301*(")%&B +5%"#$+2)&O"1"4&B + 203.4"4&B + & + ).D& + U50(&6&B + . + %.6a0 + &O + -"3&%01& + D"41&+).D")%"7%01*(" +"%1&5&%* +"3(U +4-U22U +"% +3-U4"'B +2"(7%* +)&1*($0 +&+)1.#$0 + )%"-"($ + 6.a3"' + 4-U22$B + . + %.6a0 + ")"/(.%* + ,"/D"a(")%*+20-0O"3", + &/ + "3("' + 4-U22$ + , + 3-U4ULB + ")(",.((UL + (. + 3&(.D&60+&/D0(0(&7+2-03)%.,10(&'+"+)0#0+&+"6-Ua.L_&OA+

#2368=R/81734,$@=,-68.7?,31C$2$6,;,$1$672,G$;R-RJ,Gf�~�»P[~+�G{PZ!\Gg

~)1&+-0#0("6+&1&+2"3-")%"6++2&^0%+"+),"0'+C01&B+#U3U_0D+3010+&+),"0' + D05%0B + 6.6 + " + 03&("D + C01"DB + %" + %.6&0 + 2-03)%.,10(&7 + D$+O.-.6%0-&/",.1&+6.6+2-03)%.,10(&7+C01*($O+1&5(")%0'A+R$+(./,.1&+

8;=

Page 133: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

30%0' + & + 2"3-")%6", + C01*($D& + 1&5(")%7D& + 0_� + & + 2"%"DUB + 5%" + "(&+2-03)%.,17L% + #U3U_00 + 6.6 + 03&(UL + a&/(0((UL + )%-.%04&LB + 6+")U_0)%,10(&L+6"%"-"' +"(& + 4"%",$A +M.a("B +5%" +,$)%-.&,.L%+),"L+)%-.%04&L+%.6&0+30%&+&+2"3-")%6&+(0+&/+C01&+9C01&+(0"#O"3&D$+317+"20-.%&,("4" + U2-.,10(&7<B + (0 + &/ + 301. + 9"(" + , + 20-,UL + "50-03* + c+)-03)%," + 3")%&a0(&7<B + . + &/ +G,B84B + "(.B + 6.6 + /(.5&D.7 + &+2-&,106.%01*(.7 + C01*B + 3.0% + )&1$ + & + U,0-0((")%* + , + U)20O0 + + 2-&+")U_0)%,10(&&+/.3UD.(("4"A+

P0+6.a3"DU+501",06U+U3.�%)7+,$-.)%&%*+),"L+D05%UB+(.'%&+)&1$+317+0�+")"/(.(&7+&+)301.%*+)%0-a(0D+a&/(0(("'+)%-.%04&&A+R("4&0+,/-")1$0 + D"4U% + 2"3UD.%*B + 5%" + %.6&O + C01*($O + 1&5(")%0' + )-03&+)",-0D0(($O + 2"3-")%6", + (0%A + Z3(.6"B + 2" + 3.(($D + (.^04"+&))103",.(&7B + fC01*($0 + 1&5(")%&g + )")%.,17L% + %-0%*L + 2"+(.2"1(70D")%&+ +4-U22UB +,+)-03(0D+8>J8@¼A+ +M"%+%&2&5($0+2-&D0-$+%.6&O+"%,0%",k+++++++++

h]8=I$?+61.))9E"?$Z+ Z6"(5&%* + ? + 61.))B + 2")%U2&%* + , + F\l +H + =; + (. + 6U1&(.-("0+"%3010(&0A"?+Z+ i+O"5U+)%.%*+2",.-"DB+2"%"DU+5%"+7+1L#1L+4"%",&%*+&+301.%*+-./($0+,6U)($0+#1L3.B+205*+%"-%$+&+2&-"a($0D"*.(Z+ !%.%* +^0EJ2",.-"D +& +-.#"%.%* +2-& + 4")%&(&5("D+-0)%"-.(0+µovno¥+�oqrt��+�«qºA+

p.=13.I088+61.))kE"?$Z+ Z6"(5&%* + ^6"1UB + 2")%U2&%* + , + &()%&%U% + E&/6U1*%U-$ + (.+

%-0(0-)6&' + E.6U1*%0% + 9E&4U-("0 + 6.%.(&0<B + /.6"(5&, + 04"B + )%.%*+O"-"^&D+&+&/,0)%($D+%-0(0-"DA"?+Z+ i +O"5U +#$%* +%-0(0-"D +2" +E&4U-("DU+6.%.(&LB + %.6 +6.6 + x%.+

2-"E0))&7+D(0+3")%.,170%+"4-"D("0+U3","1*)%,&0+&+6-"D0+%"4"+U+D0(7+O"-"^&0+-0/U1*%.%$D"*.(Z+M)L+),"L+,/-")1UL+a&/(*+7+4"%",.+-.#"%.%*+317+%"4"B+5%"+

)%.%*+(.)%"7_&DB+U)20^($D+2-"E0))&"(.1*($D+%-0(0-"DA�01*(.7 +1&5(")%* + )2")"#(. +.6%&,(" +)"/3.,.%* +& +-0.1&/",$,.%*+

),"&+)%-.%04&&+3.a0+2-&+&/D0(0(&&+U)1",&'A+N1.4"3.-7+,(U%-0((0DU+)%0-a(LB+#0-U_0DU+(.5.1"+,+D05%0B +C01*(.7+1&5(")%*+#"100+3-U4&O+U)%"'5&,. + 6 + (04.%&,($D + ,1&7(&7DA + Q.6 + 2"6./.1& + -0/U1*%.%$+&))103",.(&'B + 2-"E0))&"(.1*($0 + ,$#"-$ + fC01*($O + 1&5(")%0'g+"6./.1&)*+(0&/D0(($D&A+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++f|jj~Q\GMP[~+jlPQ�GZP~`[g

|EE06%&,($0 + EU(6C&"(0-$ + )%-0D7%)7 + (.2-.,17%* + U)&1&7 + (.+"),"0(&0 + 6"(6-0%($O + /(.(&'B + (0"#O"3&D$O + 317 + %"4"B + 5%"#$ + )%.%*+2-"E0))&"(.1.D&+),"04"+301.B+2"1U5.%*+/.+-.#"%U+2-&1&5($0+30(*4&B+(.+6"%"-$0+D"a("+)"30-a.%*+)0D*LA+GD+),"')%,0(("+2"35&(7%*+),"&+C01&+%"DU+301UB+6"%"-"0+"(&+,$#-.1&A+M+3.((UL+4-U22U+,"^1&+30%&+&+

8;;

Page 134: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

2"3-")%6&B+317+6"4"+-.#"%.+)%"&%+(.+20-,"D+D0)%0+,+a&/(&B+)0D*7+&+30%&+c+(.+,%"-"DA+~_0+,+^6"10+"(&+).D""2-0301&1&)*+,+"%("^0(&&+2-"E0))&&A + R05%$ + xEE06%&,($O + EU(6C&"(0-", + -036" + ),7/.($ + )+)"30-a.(&0D + &O + 301.B + . + 0)1& + & + ),7/.($B + %" + ) + 2-"3,&a0(&0D + 2"+)1Ua0#("'+10)%(&C0+95.)%"+"(&+D05%.L%+"+2U%0^0)%,&7OB+"#+"%3$O0+,+)%.-&(("D+/.D60B+(.+")%-",.O+,+%021"D+D"-0A<+!103U0%+/.D0%&%*B+5%"+4-U22. + xEE06%&,($O + EU(6C&"(0-", + c + ).D.7 + D("4"5&)10((.7 + &+)%.#&1*(.7 + ," + ,)0O + 2.-.11017O + & + ," + ,)0O +^6"1.O + c +=>J;> +¼A$ M"%+%&2&5($0+2-&D0-$+"%,0%",k+++++++++

N33.I0?+61.))kE"?$Z+Z6"(5&%*+88+61.))",B+2")%U2&%*+(.+2"34"%",&%01*($0+6U-)$+,+

)%.(6")%-"&%01*($' + &()%&%U%B + 2")%U2&%* + , + x%"% + &()%&%U% + (.+x6"("D&50)6&'+E.6U1*%0%A"?+k + M)L + ),"L + a&/(* + 7 + O"%01. + #$ + #$%* + 2-"4-.DD&)%"DJ

x6"("D&)%"DA+~)1&+7+#U3U+&D0%*+x%U+2-"E0))&LB+%"+,)043.+)D"4U+(.'%&+)0#0+O"-"^UL+&+,$)"6""21.5&,.0DUL++-.#"%UD"*.(k+F"#$,.%*+,+F.-&a0B+�-0C&&B+`&D0+&+�"(3"(0

fZN´~!\M~PP[~+h~i\~�Ggh0%& + & + 2"3-")%6& + , + "%,0%.O + ,$-.a.L% + )%-0D10(&0 + 2-&(")&%*+

2"1*/U + "#_0)%,UB + )"5U,)%,&0 + 6 + D.1"&DU_&DB + 2-0)%.-01$D + 1L37DB+#"1*($D+&+(Ua3.L_&D)7A+\.6&0+2-03)%.,10(&7+D$+"%(")&1&+6+%&2U+f"#_0)%,0(($O+307%010'gA+M.a("B+5%"+&O+"%,0%$+(.2"1(0($+(0+%"1*6"+501",050)6&D+)"5U,)%,&0D+&+2"(&D.(&0DB+("+&+a01.(&0D+,+#U3U_0D+2"D"4.%* +1L37D+2-"E0))&"(.1*(" +92)&O"1"4&B +L-&)%$<B +#"-"%*)7+ /.+2-0)%&a+)%-.($A+Z(&+(.D0-0($+a&%*+#0/+,"'(B+(.)&1&7B+/.4-7/(0(&7+2-&-"3$A+Z%D0%&DB+0)1&+,+8???J=>>>+U50#("D+4"3UB+6"43.+2-","3&1")*+20-,"0+&))103",.(&0+fF)&O"1"4&50)6&'+2"-%-0%+2"6"10(&7gB+2-"C0(%+f"#_0)%,0(($O +307%010'g +3")%&4.1 +8;¼B+ %" +, +&))103",.(&&+ +=>>=4A+(.#1L3.0%)7+-0/6"0+)(&a0(&0+5&)10((")%&+-0#7%B+"%(")7_&O)7+6+x%"DU+%&2UA+M+=>>K4A+x%"+6"1&50)%,"+2-"3"1a.1"+)(&a.%*)7+&+3")%&4.1" +=¼+2"+(06"%"-$D+^6"1.DA+M"%+2-&D0-$+"%,0%",k

M3-=,5I&K+61.))kE"?$k+F"1U5&%*+2"1("0+)-03(00+"#-./",.(&0A+F")%U2&%*+,+&()%&%U%+

(.+7/$6","0+"%3010(&0AA"?+k+i+O"5U+2"D"4.%*+1L37D+&+2"2$%.%*)7+&/D0(&%*+2-.,&%01*)%,"+

&1&+%0+-0^0(&7B+6"%"-$0+"("+2-&(&D.0%AD"*.(Z+~/3&%*+2"+D&-U+&+,)%-05.%*)7+)+%0D&+1L3*D&B+6%"+7,170%)7+

1&30-"D + , + ),"0' + )%-.(0B + & + &/U5.%* + "2$% + , + U2-.,10(&& + , + 3-U4&O+)%-.(.OA

M=8]G+K+61.))kE"?$Z+F")%U2&%*+,+&()%&%U%B+#U3U++6"()%-U6%"-"D++&1&+,"0(($DA+T0(&%*)7+,+=@J;>+10%B+&D0%*+8J=+30%0'B+#$%*+2"-73"5($D+501",06"DA

8;:

Page 135: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

A"?+Z+P.)%"7_00+301"+c+2-&(")&%*+2"1*/U+1L37D+&+2-&-"30A+P0)D"%-7+(. + ,$#-.((UL + 2-"E0))&LB + O"%01 + #$ + #$%* + 510("D + �`GPFG! + &1&+Q-.)("4"+Q-0)%.B+5%"#$+(.&#"100+xEE06%&,("+2"D"4.%*+1L37DAD"*.(Z+h"#&%*)7+U)20O",+,+,$#-.(("'+2-"E0))&&B+("+,+1L#"D+)1U5.0+7+O"5U+/.(&D.%*)7+301"DB+2"10/($D+317+1L30'A

fhZRZyZ�i]QGg~)1&++41.,($D+301"D+,+2-03)%.,10(&&+,$)%U2.0%+)"/3.(&0+)0D*&+&+

,")2&%.(&0 +30%0'B +%" +%.6&0+2-03)%.,10(&7+D$+"O.-.6%0-&/",.1&+6.6+2-03)%.,10(&7 + f3"D"O"/706gA + |%U + 4-U22U + , + ")(",("D + )")%.,&1&+30,U^6&+9("+0)%*+&+"%,0%$+D.1*5&6",<A+M+)-.,(0(&&+)+&))103",.(&7D&+=>>>4A + x%. + 4-U22. + /(.5&%01*(" + UD0(*^&1.)*k + )+ @J8=¼+ "2-"^0(($O+30,U^06B+3"+@+¼+,+=>>=4A+M+=>>K4A+6"1&50)%,"+"%,0%",+6"10#10%)7+"%+K¼+3"+:¼+,+/.,&)&D")%&+"%+^6"1$+&+61.)).A

N=.I+?+61.))kE"?$k+F"1U5&%*+,$)^00+"#-./",.(&0A+Q+=:+4"3.D+,$'%&+/.DUaA+GD0%*+3,UO+30%0'+9D.1*5&6.+&+30,"56U<B+/.(&D.%*)7+30%*D&AA"?+k+F"D"4.%*+),"0'+)0D*0+&+1L37D+,"6-U4+D0(7AD"*.(Z&y"5UB+5%"#$+U+D0(7+#$1.+1L#7_.7+)0D*7A

f!M~\!QG~+hmR[g~)1& + + , + "%,0%.O + U6./$,.1")*B + 5%" + ).D"0 + ,.a("0 + c+

).D")%"7%01*(")%*B+&(%0-0)($'+"#-./+a&/(&B+(.2"1(0(($'+"#_0(&0DB+2U%0^0)%,&7D&B + 2-&61L50(&7D& + & + 3-U/*7D&B + )%-0D10(&0D + #$%* + ,+C0(%-0+,(&D.(&7+1L#"'+6"D2.(&&B+%"+%.6&0+2-03)%.,10(&7+"+#U3U_0D+O.-.6%0-&/",.1&+6.6+2-03)%.,10(&7+f),0%)6"'+3.D$gA+|%.+4-U22.+c+(.+8>>¼+a0()6.7A +h0,U^6&B +6"%"-$0 +"%(0)0($+6 +x%"' +4-U220B + )5&%.L%+(0"#O"3&D$D +317 + )0#7 + 2"1U50(&0 + ,$)^04" + "#-./",.(&7B + , + 6.50)%,0+/"?(+ U6./$,.L%+).D")",0-^0()%,",.(&0B+6.6+,+1&5("D+21.(0B+%.6+&+,+2-"E0))&"(.1*("DB +&/U50(&0 +&(")%-.(($O+7/$6",B + /.(7%&7 +)2"-%"DA+R05%.L%+"(&+"+%"DB+5%"#$+2-&,106.%01*("+,$41730%*B+)%.%*+&/,0)%("'+1&5(")%*LB + ,0)%& + 2-./3($' + "#-./ + a&/(&B + 6.6 + D"a(" + #"1*^0+2U%0^0)%,",.%*+&+"#_.%*)7+)"+/(.D0(&%")%7D&A+|%"+c+"3(.+&/+).D$O+D.1"5&)10(($O + 4-U22 + 92-03)%.,10(&' + " + ),0%)6"D + "#-./0 + a&/(& + ,+(.5.1*("' + ^6"10 + (0 + )U_0)%,U0%B + f),0%)6&0 + 3.D$g + 2"7,17L%)7 + )"+)-03(0'+^6"1$<A+

K?1>.7,8.I+K+61.))k+E"?$Z+M+)",0-^0()%,0+&/U5&%*+&(")%-.(($0+7/$6&B+0/3&%*+2"+D&-U+&+1046"+"#_.%*)7B+,0)%&+"#7/.%01*("+/3"-",$'+"#-./+a&/(&B+/.(&D.%*)7+.x-"#&6"'B+)"O-.(&%*+E&4U-UB+&D0%*+D("4"+3-U/0'+&+2"61"((&6",A"?+Z+ F-"E0))&7 + 3"1a(. + 2-&(")&%* +D(0 +D("4" + U3","1*)%,&7B + 7 + (0+D"4U + -.#"%.%* + (. + 3-U4&OB + %"1*6" + (. + )0#7A + iB + )6"-00 + ,)04"B + #U3U+(0/.,&)&D$D+4&3"D+&1&+"%6-"L+),"L+E&-DU

8;@

Page 136: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

D"*.(k + R"7 + a&/(* + #U30% + ,0)�1"' + & + 2"3,&a("'B + 7 + D05%.L + )%.%*+&/,0)%("' +, +D&-0 + & + 2"2U17-("' + )-03& +DUa5&(B + , + 1L#"' +6"D2.(&&+,0)%&+),0%)6&0+#0)03$+&+#$%*+0�+C0(%-"D00

+++++++++++++++fh~�ZM[~+�ShGg

Q"43. + 2"3-")%"6 +2&^0% + " +a01.(&& + )"/3.%* + )"#)%,0(("0 + 301"B+E&-DU+,+,$#-.(("'+&D+)E0-0+307%01*(")%&B +%"+%.6&0+2-03)%.,10(&7+D$+O.-.6%0-&/",.1&+6.6+2-03)%.,10(&7+301",$O+1L30'A +M+x%U+4-U22U+,"^1& + %0 + 2"3-")%6&B + 6"%"-$0 + )5&%.L% + 317 + )0#7 + (.)%"7_&D + 301"D+"%6-$%&0 +)"#)%,0(("' +E&-D$B +2-032-&7%&7B +"-4.(&/.C&&A +F-& +x%"D+"(& + 1&#" + 6"(6-0%(" + U6./$,.L% + )E0-U + 307%01*(")%&B + , + 6"%"-"'+21.(&-UL% + "%6-$%* + ),"� + 301"B + (.2-&D0-B +0+.+7(% & 07%3F & $?$&H#+T#(--$#+7('$"R &1&#" + 2&^U% + " + )%-0D10(&& + /.(&D.%*)7+2-032-&(&D.%01*)%,"DB +-.#"%.%*+(. +6-U2($O+2-032-&7%&7OB +5%"#$+,+6"(05("D+&%"40B+)%.%*+-U6","3&%010D+)"#)%,0(("'+"-4.(&/.C&&A+R05%$+301",$O + 1L30'B + 6.6 + 2-.,&1"B + ),7/.($ + ) + -0.1&/.C&0' + )"#)%,0(($O+%,"-50)6&O + & + 2-032-&(&D.%01*)6&O + 21.(",A + F" + -0/U1*%.%.D+)"C&.1*("J2)&O"1"4&50)6"4"+&))103",.(&7+fF)&O"1"4&50)6&'+2"-%-0%+2"6"10(&7g+,+=>>>4A+f301",$0+1L3&g+)")%.,171&+"% +(w+ +3" +OOw+ A+M+)-03(0DB + 2" + ,)0D + ^6"1.D + 301",$O + 1L30' + #$1" + (0 + #"100 +&wD+ M+&))103",.(&&+=>>K4A+2-"C0(%+301",$O+1L30'+)-03&+"2-"^0(($O+30%0'+&+2"3-")%6",+)(&/&1)7+2"5%&+,+3,.+-./.+&+)")%.,&1+(0+#"100+(wD

N7.3B++?+61.))k0E"?$k+F")%U2&%*+,+&()%&%U%+(.+x6"("D&50)6&'+E.6U1*%0%A"?+k + y"5U + )%.%* + 3&-06%"-"D + ),"04" + )"#)%,0(("4" + #.(6.A + |%"+2-&#$1*("+&+(0)6U5("A+i+#U3U+/.61L5.%*+)3016&+)+&(")%-.(C.D&D"*.(k+!%.%*+,1&7%01*($D+&+#"4.%$D

)K#E):f+!#fN`)oK$h+K":fM`eK)Ni$hE"+E:f#E`$E$:`Exp$'!"!yKp

�(.5&%01*($'+2-"C0(%+"%,0%",+#$1+"%(0)0(+6+(06"()%-U6%&,($DA+M +(&O +1&#" +(0 + )"30-a.1.)* +&(E"-D.C&7 +" + 21.(.O +& + (.D0-0(&7O +c+f/.6-$%$' + %&2gB + 1&#" + (.D0-0(&7 + "2&)$,.1&)* + (050%6"B + . + + ).D+"%,05.L_&'+2-&/(.,.1)7B+5%"+(0+D"a0%+)+"2-03010((")%*L+(./,.%*+(&+),"L + #U3U_UL + 2-"E0))&LB + (& + 301"B + (& + ,U/B + , + 6"%"-"D + O"%01 + #$+U5&%*)7A + \.6&0 + "%,0%$ + D$ + 2-&5&)1&1& + 6 + 4-U220 + f(0+).D""2-0301&,^&O)7gA+

h]8=I&K+61.))kE"?$k+�.6"(5&%*+88+61.))",+&+2")%U2&%*+,+&()%&%U%A+!"/3.%*+)0D*L+&+,$-.)%&%*+=+30%0'AA"?+Z&`.#"%.AD"*.(Z+!%.%*+&/,0)%($D+EU%#"1&)%"D+&+,$)%U2.%*+/.+`"))&LgA

8;Y

Page 137: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

M+2-&,030(($O+4-U22.O+f/.6-$%$0g+&+f(0+).D""2-0301&,^&0)7g+L("^& + &1& + 30,U^6& + (0 + /(.L%B + 504" + &D + O"%0%* + "% + #U3U_04"B + .+2-03)%.,10(&7 + " + #U3U_0D + + 4-U22$B + (./,.(("' + (.D& + f-./("#"'gB+20-02"1(0($+&307D&+&+)%-0D10(&7D&B+"(&+O"%7%+f,)04"+&+)-./UgA+GO+C01&+(0+)""%,0%)%,UL%+%"DU+301UB+6"%"-"DU+"(&+O"%01&+#$+2"),7%&%*+),"L + ,/-")1UL + a&/(*A + GO + D05%$ + %.6a0 + (0 + ),7/.($ + (& + )+2")%.,10(($D&+C017D&B+(&+)+,$#"-"D+301.A

M3-=,5I+K+61.))kE"?$k+i+O"5U+&D0%*+-.#"%UB+),7/.((UL+)+O&D&0'+&+#&"1"4&0'A+�(.%*+,+)",0-^0()%,0+.(41&')6&'+7/$6B+%A6A+"(+(Ua0(+,0/30A +FU%0^0)%,",.%*+2"+),0%U+6.6+hD&%-&'+Q-$1",B+&D0%*+)0D*L+&+30%0'AA"?+Z+i+O"%01+#$+/.#"%&%*)7+"+)0D*0+&+30%7O+&+(.2&).%*+6(&4UB+6"%"-.7+,")2&%$,.1.+#$+,+1L37O+1L#",*+3-U4+6++3-U4U+&+2-&-"30A

+,5813A$@=2X,6615$Pzz{$A2-.F-".(.1&/&-",., + "%,0%$B + 2-&)1.(($0 + (.D + &/ + -./($O + 4"-"3",+

`"))&&+2"+(.^0'+D0%"3&60+f�01*A+h01"A+R05%.gB+D$+2"1U5&1&+-0'%&(4+2-032"5&%.0D$O+2-"E0))&'A+`06"-3$+2"#&,.0%+2-"C0(%+U5._&O)7B+(0+,$#-.,^&O+317+)0#7+6.6ULJ1&#"+"2-03010((UL+2-"E0))&L+9=K¼<A+

P. + 20-,"D + D0)%0 + 9{F|w $ 74;2=.U+ (.O"37%)7k + x6"("D&)%B+#UO4.1%0-B+-.#"%(&6+#.(6.w+L-&)%B+.3,"6.%B+)U3*7w+,-.5B+D03&C&()6&'+-.#"%(&6w+,"0(($'B+D&1&C&"(0-B+R{!A+M%"-"0+D0)%"+T*F(w$74;2=.U$U+2-"E0))&'k + -.#"%(&6 + ^"UJ#&/(0).B + .6%0-B + 20,0CB + DU/$6.(%w+2-"4-.DD&)%w + 2)&O"1"4B + )"C&.1*($' + + -.#"%(&6A + �. + (&D& + )103UL%k+D0(03a0-w + 3&/.'(0-B + .-O&%06%"-w + 6")D0%"1"4B + )%&1&)%B + ,&/.a&)%B+2.-&6D.O0-w + )2"-%)D0(A + |%& + 2-"E0))&& + ,$#&-.L% +28 $ P $ -2 $ % $ w$U5._&O)7A +P0D("4&D + #"1*^0 + "3("4" + 2-"C0(%. + )%.-^061.))(&6",+,$#-.1&+2-"E0))&&k +.,%"D0O.(&6B +,"3&%01*B +.,%")10).-*B +aU-(.1&)%B+&(a0(0-B+%0O(&6B+&/"#-0%.%01*B+U5&%01*B+2",.-A+

M +O"30 +&))103",.(&7 +2" +D0%"3&60 +f�01*A +h01"A +R05%.g +U +(.)+#$1. + ,"/D"a(")%* + )""%(0)%& + ,$#&-.0D$0 + 2-"E0))&& + ) + (.^0'+%&2"1"4&0' + 2-03)%.,10(&7 + " + #U3U_0DA + Q.a3$' + %&2 + ,$#&-.0%+"2-03010(($' + 6-U4 + 2-"E0))&'A + h01" + , + %"DB + 5%" + U + 6.a3"4" + %&2.+)"#)%,0(("0 + "%("^0(&0 + 6 + -"1& + 2-"E0))&& + , + &O +a&/(&A + P.2-&D0-B+fxEE06%&,($0 + EU(6C&"(0-$g + ,$#&-.L% + 2-"E0))&& + %"1*6"+2-0)%&a($0B +317+(&O+,.a("+(0+)%"1*6"+)"30-a.(&0+-.#"%$B +)6"1*6"+D0)%"+-.#"%$A+

h17 + fxEE06%&,($O + EU(6C&"(0-",g + ,.a(. + ).D. + ,"/D"a(")%*+#$%* + f, + )&)%0D0gB + 6"%"-.7 + #U30% + %0#7 + 2-"3,&4.%* + & + 2"330-a&,.%*B+6"%"-.7+"#0)205&%+&O+3")%"'("'+/.-21.%"'+&1&+2"/,"1&%+&D+)301.%*+6.-*0-UA+h17++f3"D"O"/706g+x%&+2.-.D0%-$+)",0-^0(("+(0+,.a($+2-&+,$#"-0 + 2-"E0))&& + & + D0)%. + -.#"%$A + h17 + (&O + ,.a("B + 5%"#$+2-"E0))&"(.1*($0 + /(.(&7 + D"41& + 2-&4"3&%*)7 + , + )0D0'("' + a&/(&+93"D"O"/7'6& + ,$#&-.L% + 2-"E0))&& + ,")2&%.%017B + D03&C&()6"4"+-.#"%(&6.B + 2",.-.B + 3&/.'(0-.B + 2)&O"1"4.<A + ~_0 + 317 + f3"D"O"/706g+

8;I

Page 138: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

,.a("B + 5%"#$ + -.#"%. + #$1. + (03.106" + "% + 3"D. + & + 2-031.4.1.+(0(.2-7a0(($'+-.#"5&'+30(*B+&1&+,""#_0+),"#"3($'+4-.E&6A+

f!,0%)6&0 + 3.D$g + 2-032"5&%.L% + 2-"E0))&& + 2U#1&5($0B+%-0#UL_&0 + UD0(&7 + ,$)%U2.%*B + 2-0/0(%",.%* + )0#7B + "#_.%*)7 + )+#"1*^&D&+4-U22.D&+1L30'A+h17+(&O+,.a(.+,"/D"a(")%*+)"%-U3(&5.%*+)+DUa5&(.D&B+a0()6&O+6"1106%&,",+"(&+(0+%0-27%A+

fZ#_0)%,0(($D+307%017Dg+2" +3U^0+%.6.7 +2-"E0))&7B +6"%"-.7+2"/,"1&% + &D + &)2$%$,.%* + 5U,)%," + 2"10/(")%& + "#_0)%,UA + ~)1& + "(&+)D"4U% + 2-"E0))&"(.1*(" + 2"D"4.%*B + 2"330-a&,.%*B + 2"(&D.%*B+/.#"%&%*)7B + %" + "(& + #U3U% + )5&%.%* + ),"L + a&/(* + (0 + /-7 + 2-"a&%"'�+N1.4"-"3($' + D"%&, + ,$#"-. + 2-"E0))&& + f"#_0)%,0(($O + 307%010'g+(0-036" + 2-&,"3&% + &O + & + , + 2)&O"1"4&LB + & + , + L-&)2-U30(C&LB + & + ,+x6"1"4&LB + & + , +aU-(.1&)%&6U + &1& + , + )"C&.1*($0 + & + 4")U3.-)%,0(($0+U5-0a30(&7A + h17 + f301",$O + 1L30'g + (0% + 2"(7%&7 + 1L#&D"4" + 301.B+2")6"1*6U+&D+(0,.a("B+5%"+2"6U2.%*+&1&+2-"3.,.%*B+2-"&/,"3&%*+&1&+20-0-.#.%$,.%*A + Z(& + U)%-0D10($ + , + )"/3.(&& + ),"04" + #&/(0). + 6.6+"-4.(&/.C&"(("J307%01*(")%("4" + D0O.(&/D. + ) + (06"%"-$D + 5&)1"D+1L30'B + -0.1&/UL_&O + &O + 21.($B + /.-.#.%$,.L_&O + &D + 30(*4&B+-.#"%.L_&O+(.+&O+U)1",&7OA+h17+f301",$O+1L30'g+,.a(.+3&(.D&6.+&+2-&#$1*(")%*A + h17 + (&O + &D00% + /(.50(&0 + &D0%* + 3&21"D + " + ,$)^0D+"#-./",.(&&B+1&#"+2"1U5&%*+&D0(("+%U+2-"E0))&LB+(.+")(",0+6"%"-"'+"(& + )"#&-.L%)7 + "%6-$%* + ),"' + #&/(0)k + (0-036" + x%" + c + f)%"D.%"1"4gB+f2-"%0/&)%gB + f2-"4-.DD&)%gB + fL-&)%gB + f%",.-",03gB + f2-"3.,0CgB+f-&x1%"-gB+fD0(03a0-+2"+%U-&/DUgA+++

f�01*($0 + 1&5(")%&g + c + 03&()%,0(($0B + 6%" + (.C010( + (.+)"30-a.(&0 + %-U3.A + M + 2-"%&,"2"1"a(")%* + fxEE06%&,($D+EU(6C&"(0-.DgB+&D+(0+,.a($+(./,.(&0+&+2-0)%&a+E&-D$A+�1.,("0+c+,"/D"a(")%* + /.(&D.%*)7 + 1L#&D$D + 301"DB + 6"%"-"DU + "(& + 2-03.($+&D0((" + ,)0' + 3U^"'A + M$#"- + 2-"E0))&& + 317 + fC01*($O + 1&5(")%0'g+2-"&)O"3&%B +6.6 +2-.,&1"B +, +30%)%,0 +& +(. +3"14&0 +4"3$A +M$#"-+%.6&O+1L#&D$O + )E0- + 307%01*(")%& + (.)%"1*6"B + x%" + & + (.U5("J&))103",.%01*)6&' + D&-B + & + x6)%-0D.1*($' + D&-B + & + D&- + &)6U))%,.A+�.D0%&DB + 5%" + fC01*($O + 1&5(")%0'g + "50(* + 2-&,106.L% + ) + -.((04"+,"/-.)%. + &D0((" + 2-"E0))&& + f,01&6&O + 1L30'gk + 2&).%010'B+aU-(.1&)%",B + -0a&))0-",B + 2U%0^0)%,0((&6",B + U50($OB + )2"-%)D0(",B+O&-U-4",B+2"x%",B+,"0(($OA+

E; $ 166?,-27.8,?<6/2G $ 6201.?<32F@61W2?2A1B,6/2G $ @=2,/8,$Zh61W2?2A1B,6/15$@2=8=,8$@2/2?,31C[D $G))103",.%01*)6&'+2-"06%+fF)&O"1"4&50)6&' + 2"-%-0% + 2"6"10(&7g + )%.-%",.1 + , + =>>?J=>8>UA4A+`U6","3&%01& + 2-"06%. + 2-&41.^.L% + ^6"1*($O + 2)&O"1"4", + 2-&(7%*+U5.)%&0+,+2-"06%0A+MD0)%0+)+(.D&+2")%-"'%0+2)&O"1"4&50)6&'+2"-%-0%+,.^0' +^6"1$B + 4"-"3.B + -04&"(.B + )"/3.'%0 + -./,&,.L_&0 + 2-"4-.DD$B+FU)%* + x%" + )%.(0% + EU(3.D0(%"D + 317 + "#-./",.(&7 + & + ,")2&%.(&7+^6"1*(&6",+&+)%U30(%",A+`U6","3&%01&+2-"06%.+,03U%+3&)%.(C&"(("0+

8;K

Page 139: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

"#U50(&0 + -.#"%0 + ) + D0%"3&6"' + f�01*A + h01"A + R05%.g + & + 2-","37%+,$0/3($0+)0D&(.-$A+M)7+&(E"-D.C&7+c+(.+).'%0 +¥¥¥+ +A++pzn�tu+ +J+ +�zts+ +A++�q+ +A+�.2&).%*)7+(.+6U-)$+M$+D"a0%0+2"+.3-0)Uk+��p+ +>?½+ +pus«+ +A++�q+ +A+

:2;481C$/./$26327.$7>.1G2-,56871C$6$-,8<G1

>=!=B(#('U1

C8&%7?%"."0F&*"-,.+&0+7"#X"''+&'+78-&7&Y.+-&-$#"=&

L(/)4."0F&Y.+-)=&@0H+?F3)4."&'($?)*X$-&+:#(3+-&.+R&

*.+&C(-&/(?(&B#$#+/(=&C8&-+W"."&H".F&.+?F1+&07+$-&

T+?+0+-=&C8&-+W"."&#$0+7(.F&.+?F1+&07+"4&#)1+4=&C8&

/+?W'8&:8.F&.(1$-R&1(1$-&7(0&0/"?(?$&7(X&+H8.R&7(X(&

0#"/(&$&7(X(&'(0?"/0.7"''+0.Fd&&&&&&&&&&&&A=&K(#'"T$=&

+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++:2012/R?<8R=3.C $ 6=,-.D+ �6"1.B + 430 + 7 + -.#"%.LB + (.O"3&%)7 + ,+

C0(%-.1*("' + 5.)%& + 4"-"3.B + , + (02")-03)%,0(("' + #1&/")%& + (.O"37%)7+-./1&5($0 + U5-0a30(&7 + 6U1*%U-$ + & + 3"2"1(&%01*("4" + "#-./",.(&7k+"#1.)%("'+h,"-0C+%,"-50)%,.+L($O+&+D"1"3�a&B +)2"-%&,(.7+^6"1.B+DU/$6.1*("0 + U5&1&_0 + & + DU/$6.1*(.7 + ^6"1. + H8B + h"D + (.-"3("4"+%,"-50)%,.B + C0(%- + fG)%"6&gB + QM� + f�U#0-()6&'gB + %0.%- + + &DA+Z)%-",)6"4"B+6U6"1*($'+%0.%-B+DU/0&+&+#&#1&"%06&A+l+U5._&O)7+0)%*+,"/D"a(")%* + /.(&D.%*)7 + + 1L#&D$D + ,&3"D + 307%01*(")%&A + !0'5.) + ,+(.^0D + IJ. + 61.))0 + U5.%)7 + =I + 501",06k + 8= + 30,"506 + & + 8@ + D.1*5&6",A+M"/-.)% + 30%0'k + 88J8= + 10%A +F"5%& + K@ +¼ + U5._&O)7 + 61.)). + 2")0_.L%+-./1&5($0 +6-Ua6&+, +^6"10 +& +,(0 +^6"1$B +#1.4" +D0)%"-.)2"1"a0(&0+^6"1$ + 3.0% + 317 + x%"4" + "%1&5(UL + ,"/D"a(")%*A +Z)(",(.7 + 4-U22.+/3"-",*7+c+=;+501",06.A+`"3&%01&+30%0'+,+")(",("D+&/+-.#"50'+)E0-$+307%01*(")%&B + )-03(&' + ,"/-.)% + -"3&%010' + c + ;@ + 10%A + I@¼ + -"3&%010'+&D0L%+)-03(00+)20C&.1*("0+"#-./",.(&0A++M+61.))0+&/+=IJ%&+c+8;+)0D0'+%-0#UL%+")"#"4"+,(&D.(&7k+"3("4"+&1&+3,UO+30%0'+,")2&%$,.0%+%"1*6"+D.D.w +^0)%* + )0D0' +c + )"C&.1*(" +(0#1.4"2"1U5($0A +h,"0 +30%0' +c +(.+&(3&,&3U.1*("D + "#U50(&&A + R("4&0 + -"3&%01& + /.(7%$B + (0 + D"4U%+)&)%0D.%&50)6&+2")0_.%*+-"3&%01*)6&0+)"#-.(&7B+("+,)043.+(.O"37%)7+(.+),7/&+&+2"-"'+2"D"4.L%+"-4.(&/",.%*+5%"J1&#"A

Q1.)) + , + ")(",("D + )E"-D&-",.( + ) + (.5.1*("' + ^6"1$B + -0#7%.+)3-Ua&1&)*w+,+x%"D+U50#("D+4"3U+,+61.))+2-&^1.+(",.7+30,"56.B+("B+"%D05UB +#$)%-"+(.^1.+)0#0+3-U/0'A +l-",0(*+.3.2%.C&&+&+D"%&,.C&&+30%0'B+(.5&(.7+)+27%"4"+61.)).B+-.)%0%A+Q.6+61.))($'+-U6","3&%01*+7+%0)(" + "#_.L)* + )" + ^6"1*($D + )"C&.1*($D + 203.4"4"D + & + ^6"1*($D+2)&O"1"4"DA+P0+-./+"(&+,$-U5.1&+D0(7+)",0%"D+2"+2","3U+-./-0^0(&7+6.6"'J1&#"+)&%U.C&&B+.+2-",030(($0+2)&O"1"4"D+3&.4(")%&6&+3.,.1&+

8;?

Page 140: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

D(0 + #"100 + 2"1(UL + 6.-%&(U + "#)%.(",6& + , + 61.))0B + ,03* + )"41.)("+&/,0)%("'+E-./0 +f2-03U2-0a30(+c+/(.5&%B +,""-Ua0(gB +#$1&+,",-0D7+2-032-&(7%$+D0-$+2"+-./-0^0(&L+(./-0,.L_&O+2-"#10DA

h17 + )"/3.(&7 + ,")2&%.%01*("' + 2-"4-.DD$ + #$1& + ,$3010($+")(",($0 + 1&(&& + 3&.4(")%&6& + 9) + @J4" + 2" + ?J$' + 61.))<k + U-",(0'+E&/&50)6"4" + /3"-",*7 + 30%0'B + U-",(7 + .3.2%.C&& + 27%&61.))(&6", + ,+)-03(0D + /,0(0B + U-",(7 + U3",10%,"-0((")%& + 30%0' +^6"1*("' +a&/(*LB+U-",(7 + &O + D"%&,.C&& + 6 + "#U50(&LB + U-",(7 + 2)&O"1"4&50)6"4"+D&6-"61&D.%. + , + 61.))0A + M$)"6&' + U-",0(* + .3.2%.C&& + , + @JD + 61.))0+)")%.,171+:I¼B+,+YJD+c+@K¼B+,+IJD+c+:K¼A+F-&+x%"DB+(01*/7+)6./.%*B+5%"+,)0 + ) +U50#"' + 41.36"A +M +),7/& +) +U)1"a(0(&0D +2-03D0%", +& +#"1*^0'+(.4-U/6"' +U-",0(* +D"%&,.C&& +6 + "#U50(&L+)(&a.0%)7A +|%. + )&%U.C&7+U)1"a(70%)7+%0DB+5%"+30%&+U5.%)7+,"+,%"-UL+)D0(UB+.+,+20-,UL+)D0(U+2")0_.L% + -./1&5($0 + 3"2"1(&%01*($0 + 6-Ua6& + , + ^6"10 + & + 3-U4&O+"#-./",.%01*($O+U5-0a30(&7OA+!U_0)%,UL%+&+3-U4&0+"%-&C.%01*($0+D"D0(%$k+U+(06"%"-$O+-0#7%+"%)U%)%,U0%+&(%0-0)+6+U50#0A+Z(&+#$,.L%+(03&)C&21&(&-",.(($B + (0.66U-.%($B + (0 + D"4U% + "-4.(&/",.%* + )0#7 + ,+-.#"%0B + (.)%-"&%)7 + (. + U-"6A + ~)%* + U5._&0)7B + U + 6"%"-$O + (0%+)&)%0D.%&50)6&O + /(.(&' + 2" + (06"%"-$D + 2-03D0%.DB + "(& + (0 + UD0L%+"-4.(&/",.%*+),"0++,-0D7+2-.,&1*("B+(06"%"-$0+E.6%&50)6&+"6./.1&)*+#0/+6"(%-"17+-"3&%010'A++

M+61.))0+0)%*+),"&+1&30-$B+6+D(0(&L+6"%"-$O+2-&)1U^&,.L%)7+")%.1*($0B + x%" + c + (.^0 + f.,%"-&%0%("0 + 73-"gB + "50(* + .6%&,($0 + &+&(&C&.%&,($0 + -0#7%.B + 6"%"-$0 + O"-"^" + U5.%)7 + & + "%,0%)%,0(($A +M)0+-0#7%. + /.30')%,",.($ + , + -./($O + %,"-50)6&O + 4-U22.OA + !")%., + 4-U22+2"3,&a0(B+6.a3$'+&D00%+,"/D"a(")%*+2"2-"#",.%*+)0#7+,+-./1&5($O+)E0-.O + 307%01*(")%&A + F"5%& + ,0)* + 61.)) + /.30')%,",.( + , + -./1&5($O+^6"1*($O + & + ,(0^6"1*($O + 6-Ua6.O + & + )06C&7OA +�0)%0-" + 2")0_.L%+)-./U+(0)6"1*6"+)06C&'A+R("4&0+-0#7%.+U,106.L%)7+)2"-%"D+&+&D0L%+3")%&a0(&7 + , + x%"' + "#1.)%& +(. + "#1.)%("D +& + ,)0-"))&')6"D +U-",(0A+�0)%0-" + U5._&O)7 + 2")0_.L% + DU/$6.1*(UL + ^6"1UA + P. + ^6"1*("D+E0)%&,.10+f�,0/3"2.3g+&+(.+-"3&%01*)6"D+)"#-.(&&+D$+,$)%U2.1&+2"3+)"#)%,0(("0+DU/$6.1*("0+)"2-","a30(&0A+

+ h0%)6"0 + )""#_0)%," + "#-./U0%)7 + &/ + (0)6"1*6&O + D&6-"4-U22A+Z)(",.(&7D& + 317 + "#d03&(0(&7 + , + 4-U22$ + )1Ua.% + "#_&0 + &(%0-0)$B+3-Ua#. + ) + (.5.1*("' + ^6"1$B + "#_&0 + "#7/.((")%&A + R"%&,$ + U5.)%&7+^6"1*(&6", + , + 307%01*(")%& + 61.)). + -./1&5($k + 2"%-0#(")%* + ,+).D"U%,0-a30(&&B + ).D"-0.1&/.C&&B + )%-0D10(&0 + ,$301&%*)7B + 317+(06"%"-$O+0_0+&+2"%-0#(")%*+,+xD"C&"(.1*("+#1&/6&O+6"(%.6%.OA+M)0+)%-0D10(&7 + -0#7% + 2"330-a&,.L%)7B + 5%" + )6./$,.0%)7 + (. + )")%"7(&&+D&6-"61&D.%.+,+61.))0A

h61W2?2A1B,6/15 $ /?1G.8 $ 7 $ /?.66,D+ R$ + 2-","3&1&+&))103",.(&7B+6"%"-$0+2"6./.1&B+5%"B+2"+D(0(&L+30%0'B+61&D.%+4"3+"%+4"3.+)%.(",&%)7+#"100+6"DE"-%($Dk

8:>

Page 141: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++@+61A+++++++++++++++Y+61A+++++++++++++I+61M$)"6&'+U-",0(* @8 Y> YI!-03(&'+U-",0(* ;: =? ;>P&/6&'+U-",0(* 8@ 88 ;

G/(.5.1*("+6+4-U220+-&)6.+"%(")&1&)*+%-&+U5._&O)7B+)5&%.L_&0+61&D.% + , + 61.))0 + (06"DE"-%($D + 317 + )0#7A + M + -0/U1*%.%0 + #"1*^"4"+6"1&50)%,. + )",D0)%($O + 301 + , + 61.))0 + & + ^6"10B + -./,&%&7 + )&)%0D$+).D"U2-.,10(&7+,/.&D"30')%,&0+30%0'+)%.1"+#"100+%0)($DA+F")103(77+3&.4(")%&6.+#$1.+)301.(.+,+306.#-0+=>>K4AB+&+7+)5&%.LB+5%"+2",%"-(.7+3&.4(")%&6. + , + 6"(C0 + U50#("4" + 4"3. + 2"6.a0% + 2"1(UL+U3",10%,"-0((")%*+30%0'+D&6-"61&D.%"D+,+61.))0A

h0%&+,+61.))0+-./($0B+("+6.a3$'+&D00%+%"B+#0/+504"+(0+3")%&4(0%+U)20O. + ,0)* + 6"1106%&,k + 6%"J%" + 2-0,")O"3($' + "-4.(&/.%"-B + 6%"J%"+2-06-.)(" + -&)U0%B + U + 3-U4&O + %.1.(% + 6 + 20(&LB + %.(C.DA + M + ^6"10+)U_0)%,U0%+-0'%&(4+61.))",B+D$+)%.-.0D)7+(.O"3&%*)7B+2"+D0-0+),"&O+,"/D"a(")%0'B + #1&a0 +6 + 04" + ,0-^&(0B + U5.)%,U0D + ," + ,)0O + 6"(6U-).OA+N1.4"3.-7 + )1.a0(("' + -.#"%0 + %,"-50)6&O + 4-U22B + 3")%&4.0D + O"-"^&O+-0/U1*%.%",A+l-",0(*+U3",10%,"-0((")%&+^6"1*("'+a&/(*L+-.)%0%k+,+@J"D+61.))0+:@¼+-0#7%+"%D0%&1&+04"+6.6+,$)"6&'B+,+YJD+61.))0+c+@K¼+6.6+,$)"6&'B+,+IJD+61.))0+c+I>¼+6.6+,$)"6&'A

).V1 $ 2;J1, $ -,?.A + N1.4"3.-7 + 2-.,&1*(" + ,$#-.(($D+(.2-.,10(&7D + 307%01*(")%& + 30%0'B + ,",1050((")%& + &O + , + ^6"1*(UL+a&/(* + & + 61.))("4" + )""#_0)%,. + & + #$1& + 2"1U50($ + 2"/&%&,($0+-0/U1*%.%$A

M + (.^0D + ,030(&& + (.O"3&%)7 + 2"3^0E($' + 61.))B + 6"%"-$' + D$+f,030Dg + ) + @J4" + 61.)).B + )0'5.) + D$ + c + IJ' + 61.))B + "(& + c + 50%,0-%$'k+,/-")100D+,D0)%0A+M+x%"D+61.))0+(.)+,)043.+)+(0%0-20(&0D+a3U%A+Q-"D0+2"3^0E("4"+61.)).+U+(.)+0)%*+&+3-U4"'+"#d06%+/.#"%$A+|%"+c+,0%0-.(+\.&)&7+G,.(",(.+Q"-(00,.A+Z(.+20-0(0)1.+(0)6"1*6"+"20-.C&'B+2"5%&+(0+O"3&%B+&+D$+0'++2")%"7(("+,+5�DJ(&#U3*+2"D"4.0DA+F"+)"C&.1*("DU+2-"06%U + fR$ + c + %&DU-",C$g + 61.))($' + 6"D&%0% + fP.^& + ^0E$g+"-4.(&/",.1+2")&1*(UL+2"D"_*+2"+3"DUB+,+#$%UA+M"+,-0D7+2")0_0(&'+\.&)&7 +G,.(",(. +-.))6./$,.1. +-0#7%.D +" +)0#0B +" + ),"0' +a&/(&B +"(&+U/(.1& + D("4" + (","4" + & + &(%0-0)("4"B + ,)� + /.2&).1&A + P. + 61.))("D+)"#-.(&& + -.))6./.1& + "# + x%"D + ")%.1*($D +& + "E"-D&1& + )""#_0(&0 + ,+Q1.))("D + U4"160A + M + -0/U1*%.%0 + (.^0' + %&DU-",)6"' + -.#"%$ + D$+2"1U5&1&+2&)*D0((UL+#1.4"3.-(")%*+"%+\.&)&&+G,.(",($+&+3&21"D+/.+1U5^UL+-.#"%U+2"+^6"10+,+x%"D+(.2-.,10(&&+/.+=>>K4A+

P.^.+^6"1.+/(.D0(&%.+),"&D+DU/00DB+/30)*+)"#-.(.+,)7+&)%"-&7+^6"1$+,+3"6UD0(%.O+&+E"%"4-.E&7OB+6"%"-$0+2"D"4.1&+)"#&-.%*+).D&+30%&A + !0-40' + M"16",B + G1*7 + !0,")%*7(",B + ~4"- + ~4"-", + & + !0-40'+y,")%0(6",+/.(&D.L%)7+,+�6"10+|6)6U-)","3",B+6"%"-.7+"-4.(&/",.(.+

8:8

Page 142: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

, + (.^0D + DU/00A + M)0 + 30%& + .6%&,(" + U5.)%,UL% + , + "#_0^6"1*($O + &+61.))($O+301.OB+")"#0(("+,+)2"-%&,($O+&+%,"-50)6&O+D0-"2-&7%&7OA

|%"% +61.)) +c +D"0 +20-,"0 +61.))("0 +-U6","3)%,"A +R(0 +2-&^1")*+)%"16(U%*)7+)+D("a0)%,"D+%-U3(")%0'B+2-"3UD$,.%*+D("4"0+(.20-03B+)%.%*+"%,0%)%,0(("'+/.+,")2&%.(&0+30%0'A+M+%.6"D+f,"3","-"%0+301+&+/.3.5g+D(0+,+20-,UL+"50-03*+2"D"41&+-"3&%01&+30%0'A+P.+20-,"D+a0+-"3&%01*)6"D+)"#-.(&&+97,6.+#$1.+8>>¼�<+,)0+-"3&%01&+#$1&+.6%&,($B+).D&+2-031"a&1&+2"D"_*+,+-.#"%0+)+61.))"DB+,+"-4.(&/.C&&+2"0/3"6+&+,$0/3($O+D0-"2-&7%&7OB+^6"1*($O+&+61.))($O+301.OA+|%"+#$1"+6.6+#$+2-"3"1a0(&7+"#$5($O+)0D0'($O+301B+("+,+#"100+^&-"6"D+30%)6"J,/-")1"D + )""#_0)%,0A + ~)1& + U + 30%0' + ,"/(&6.1& + U50#($0 + 2-"#10D$B+-"3&%01& + 2-&O"3&1& + 317 + -./4","-.B + .6%&,(" + &(%0-0)",.1&)*+2",030(&0D+&+21.(.D&A+Za&,10(("+2-"O"37%+)",D0)%($0+)+-"3&%017D&+61.))($0+5.)$+&+-"3&%01*)6&0+)"#-.(&7B+430+U5.)%&0+2-&(&D.L%+30%&A

F"+-0/U1*%.%.D+2-",030(($O+&))103",.(&'+D"a("+)301.%*+,$,"3k• 2-.6%&50)6&+,)0+30%&+U)20^("+2-"^1&+2-"C0))+.3.2%.C&&B• 2"+U-",(L+/3"-",*7+61.))+f2-.6%&50)6&+/3"-",gB• 30%& + &D0L% + 3")%.%"5(" + ,$)"6&' + U-",0(*+

U3",10%,"-0((")%&+^6"1*("'+a&/(*LB• U-",0(*+2)&O"1"4&50)6"4"+D&6-"61&D.%.+"C0(&,.0%)7+6.6+

,$)"6&'A"1.A32681/1$76]$c,$74C71?1$3,/282=4,$@=2;?,G49• ")%.0%)7+(06"%"-.7+-./"#_0((")%*+6"1106%&,.B• 0)%*+%0(30(C&7+6+)(&a0(&L+D"%&,.C&&+6+"#U50(&LB• (06"%"-$0 + -0#7%. + 0_0 + (0 + ).D""2-0301&1&)* + & + (0 + )%.1&+.6%&,($D&+U5.)%(&6.D&+(.^&O+301B+")%.1&)*+f,+%0(&gB

• (Ua(.+")"#.7+)&)%0D.+-.#"%$+)+f2-"#10D.D&g+30%0'AG)O"37+&/+3.(($O+U)1",&'B+D$+)+-0#7%.D&+%.6+"2-030170D +6725$

G.=V=R8$7@?28<$-2${FA2$/?.66.9• F-&"-&%0%($0 + (.2-.,10(&7 + 307%01*(")%&k + C0((")%("J"-&0(%&-",.((.7B + OU3"a0)%,0(("Jx)%0%&50)6.7B + )2"-%&,("J"/3"-",&%01*(.7B + 2"/(.,.%01*(.7B + 6"DDU(&6.%&,(.7B + . + %.6a0+-.#"%.+)+2-"#10D.D&+30%0'+&+,/.&D"30')%,&0+)+-"3&%017D&A

• Z)(",("'++&()%-UD0(%+")U_0)%,10(&7+307%01*(")%&+c+)&)%0D.+61.))("4"+).D"U2-.,10(&7A+

E6327. $ -,C8,?<32681 $ Q $ 138,=,64 $ 6.G1W $ -,8,5A +l50(&50)6&'+6"1106%&,+7,170%)7+U50#("J,")2&%.%01*($'+)""#_0)%,"DA+~4"+C01*+c+",1.30(&0+"2-0301�(($D+"2$%"DB+)UDD"'+/(.(&'B+UD0(&'+&+(.,$6",B+-./,&%&0 + )2")"#(")%0' + & + )"C&.1*("J2"10/($O + 6.50)%, + 1&5(")%&A + M+"#_&O+301.O+)""#_0)%,.+-./,&,.0%)7+1&5(")%*B+)2")"#(.7+%,"-50)6&+&+).D")%"7%01*(" + -0^.%* + ,"/(&6.L_&0 + 2-"#10D$w + ,")2&%$,.L%)7+&(%01106%U.1$B + %,"-C$B + "-4.(&/.%"-$B + 2-032-&&D5&,$0 + 1L3&B+1&30-$B+)2")"#($0+,0)%&+/.+)"#"'+3-U4&OA +\.6&0+6.50)%,.+1&5(")%&+E"-D&-UL%)7 + %"1*6" + , + 6"1106%&,0 + & + 50-0/ + 6"1106%&,A + F-"#10D.+E"-D&-",.(&7 + 30%)6"4" + 6"1106%&,. + & + 04" + ).D"U2-.,10(&7 + )04"3(7+

8:=

Page 143: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

.6%U.1*(.B + ")"#0((" + , + U)1",&7O +-./,&%&7 + 4-.a3.()6"4" + "#_0)%,. +&+D"30-(&/.C&&+)&)%0D$+"#-./",.(&7A+

`./,&%&0 + 30%)6"4" + 6"1106%&,. + c + x%" + 2-"#10D. + -")%. + 6U1*%U-$+"-4.(&/.C&&B+)"/3.(&7+&+)",0-^0()%,",.(&7+)""#_0)%,.B+,1&7(&7+04"+(. + ,)0O + ,D0)%0 + & + (. + 6.a3"4" + , + "%301*(")%&A + F-"C0))$ + x%&+,/.&D""#U)1",10($+&+(0-./-$,($B+"(&+),7/.($+)+,61L50(&0D+-0#7%+,+21.(&-",.(&0+& +)",D0)%(UL+307%01*(")%*A +!",D0)%(")%* +E"-D&-U0%+"#_0)%,0(("0+D(0(&0B +U%,0-a3.L_00+"#_0501",050)6&0 +C0((")%&+&+)"/3.0% + )&%U.C&&B + 6"--06%&-UL_&0 + "%("^0(&7 + 30%0' + , + 6"1106%&,0B+(.C01&,.0%+&O+(.+"6./.(&0+2"D"_&+-0#7%.DA

l50(&50)6"0 + ).D"U2-.,10(&0 + c + E"-D. + "-4.(&/.C&&+a&/(0307%01*(")%& + U5._&O)7B + "#0)205&,.L_.7 + -./,&%&0 + &O+).D")%"7%01*(")%&+&+,$#"-.+,+2-&(7%&&+&+-0.1&/.C&&+-0^0(&7+317+3")%&a0(&7 + "#_0)%,0((" + /(.5&D$O + C010'A + Z(" + )2")"#)%,U0%+.6%&,("DU + U),"0(&L + /(.(&'B + "-4.(&/.C&& + "#_0)%,0(("J2"10/("4"+%-U3.B + 2"-736. + , + ^6"10B + /3"-","4" + 3")U4.w + E"-D&-U0%+4-.a3.()%,0((")%*B + "%,0%)%,0((")%*B + 2-&U5.0% + 30%0' + 6 + 2"-736U + &+)"C&.1*("'+)2-.,031&,")%&A+

M"2-")$ + ).D"U2-.,10(&7 + & + 04" + -"1& + , + -./,&%&& + 6"1106%&,.+"%-.a0($+,+-./($O+&))103",.(&7OA+F-"%&,"-05&7+-./,&%&7+6"1106%&,.+& + 1&5(")%&B + "#_&0 + /.6"("D0-(")%& + E"-D&-",.(&7 + 6"1106%&,.+-.))D.%-&,.1& + E&1")"E$ + �ANANU0,.B + MA�AG,.(",B + PAGA�.2&(A+F)&O"1"4& + mA�Am)D"1",B + mAmAN"3.1�,B + mAPA�U%"^6&( + & + 3-U4&0+"),0_.1&+,"2-")$+"#_0(&7+30%0'+&+&O+D0a1&5(")%($O+"%("^0(&'A+F03.4"4& + FAjAQ.2%0-0,B + PAGAF&-"4",B + �APA\"1)%"'B + QAhAl^&()6&'+&))103",.1& + U)1",&7 + 2"330-a6& + .%D")E0-$ + %",.-&_0)%,. + &+,/.&D"2"D"_&+)-03&+30%0'A+

G30& + mA!AR.6.-0(6" + & + MAmA!UO"D1&()6"4" + /.(&D.L% + ")"#"0+D0)%" + , + %0"-&& + 30%)6"4" + 6"1106%&,.A + mA!AR.6.-0(6" + -./-.#"%.1+")(",$ + D0%"3&6& + )21"50(&7 + & + ,")2&%.(&7 + 30%)6"4" + 6"1106%&,.B + 6+6"%"-$D+"(+"%(�)k+%0"-&L+20-)206%&,B+,61L50(&0+30%0'+,+)",D0)%(UL+307%01*(")%*B + -./,&%&0 + ).D"U2-.,10(&7 + & + %-.3&C&'B + /.6-0217L_&O+6"1106%&,($0+3")%&a0(&7+&+D("4"0+3-U4"0A

!",-0D0((.7 + 6"(C02C&7 + ,")2&%.%01*("4" + 6"1106%&,.+9\AmAQU-.6&(B + �AGAP",&6",.B + mAMARU3-&6< + -.))D.%-&,.0% + 04" + 6.6+),"0"#-./(UL+D"301*+"#_0)%,.B +"%-.a.L_UL+(0+)%"1*6"+E"-DU+04"+"-4.(&/.C&&B+)6"1*6"+%0+"%("^0(&7B+6"%"-$0+0DU+2-&)U_&B+.%D")E0-UB+6"%"-.7 + 0DU + ),"')%,0((.B + )&)%0DU + 501",050)6&O +C0((")%0'B + 6"%"-.7+2-&(7%.A +h0%)6&' +6"1106%&, +-.))D.%-&,.0%)7 +6.6 +D"301*B + , +6"%"-"'+"%-.a.L%)7+"%("^0(&7+"#_0)%,.+&+%0(30(C&&+04"+-./,&%&7A+

F"1"a0(&7+("-D.%&,($O+3"6UD0(%",+fQ"(C02C&&+D"30-(&/.C&&+"#-./",.(&7gB + fF-"4-.DD$ + -./,&%&7 + ^6"1$ + =>>Kc=>8= + U5A + 4"3.gB+^6"1*("0 + 2"1"a0(&0 + " + )&)%0D0 + 30%)6"4" + ).D"U2-.,10(&7 + 2"D"4.L%+"2-0301&%* + /.3.5& + E"-D&-",.(&7 + 1&5(")%&B + "#1.3.L_0'+6"D20%0(%(")%7D& + 9&(E"-D.C&"(($D&B + 6"DDU(&6.%&,($D&B+

8:;

Page 144: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

).D""-4.(&/.C&&B + ).D""#-./",.(&7<A + !04"3(7 + ,")2&%.(&0+"-&0(%&-",.(" + (. + 2-.6%&50)6&0 + (.,$6&B + -./,&%&0 + )2")"#(")%&+2-&D0(7%* + /(.(&7B + -0.1&/",$,.%* + )"#)%,0(($0 + 2-"06%$A + �01*+,")2&%.%01*("' + )&)%0D$ + ^6"1$ + & + D"0' + ,")2&%.%01*("' + -.#"%$ + c+E"-D&-",.%*+(-.,)%,0((ULB+).D")%"7%01*(UL+1&5(")%*B+)"/3.%*+)-03UB+"#0)205&,.L_UL + -.)^&-0(&0 + )E0- + & + )2")"#", + ,/.&D"30')%,&7+^6"1*(&6",+)+"6-Ua.L_&D+D&-"DA++

#2??,/817 $ 1 $ 622;J,6872I $ ?1B3268< $ 1 $ 13-171-R.?<32)%*A+F-03)%.,10(&0B + 5%" + 30%)%," + c + 1&^* + ,-0D7 + 2"34"%",6& + + 6 + a&/(&+)0-*0/("+&)6.a.0%+-0.1*(")%*+&+U_0D170%+2-.,.+30%0'A+`0#0("6B+6.6+&+1L#"'+,/-")1$'B+a&,0%+,+-0.1*("'+a&/(&+&+2"x%"DU+"(+3"1a0(+&D0%*+2-.,.+U5.)%,",.%*+,+00++2-0"#-./",.(&&A+`0#0("6+3"1a0(+U5&%*)7+a&%*+,+"6-Ua.L_0D+04"+D&-0B+,)%U2.7+,"+,/.&D"30')%,&0+)+"6-Ua.L_&D&+04" + 1L3*D&B + "( + 3"1a0( + UD0%* + "#_.%*)7B + (.1.a&,.%* + "%("^0(&7B+"-&0(%&-",.%*)7 + , + 1L#"' + )&%U.C&&B + .306,.%(" + "C0(&,.7 + )0#7 + &+-0/U1*%.%$ + ),"0' + 307%01*(")%&A + \.6"' +D"301& + 2",030(&7 + "( +D"a0%+(.U5&%*)7B+@=2c17.C$=.>?1B34,$>3.B1G4,$618R.011$7$;?1>/2G$,GR$622;J,687,D+ P" + ,(.5.10 + (Ua(" + 2-"'%& + 2-"C0)) + "#-./",.(&7+6"1106%&,.+&+)"/3.(&7+%.6&O+U)1",&'B+6"%"-$0+2"D"41&+(.+04"+")(",0+)"/3.%*+4.-D"(&5("0+)""#_0)%,"+30%0'B+430+(0+#$1"+#$+f.'%).'30-",gB+.+,)0+D"41&+(.'%&+2"10+30')%,&7B+).D""2-03017%*)7+&+-0.1&/",.%*+)0#7A

h17 + x%"4" + (0"#O"3&D. + )",D0)%(.7 + )"C&.1*("JC0((")%(.7+307%01*(")%*A + !.D"U2-.,10(&0 + , + 30%)6"D + 6"1106%&,0 + 2-03)%.,170%+)"#"' +%.6UL+3&(.D&5(UL+)&)%0DUB +. + )&)%0D""#-./UL_&D+E.6%"-"D+7,170%)7 + "#_.7 + C01* + 307%01*(")%&A + G)%"5(&6"D + -./,&%&7+).D"U2-.,10(&7+,$)%U2.0%+2-"%&,"-05&0+D0a3U+ +C017D&B+2-"C03U-"'+&O+3")%&a0(&7+&+"%("^0(&0D+6+ +x%"DU+U5._&O)7A+j"-D.+-./-0^0(&7+x%"4"+2-"%&,"-05&7+c +,",1050(&0 +U5._&O)7 +, +-0.1*($0+2-"#10D($0+)&%U.C&&B+&(%0()&,(UL+"-4.(&/.%"-)6UL+307%01*(")%*+&+00+.(.1&/A+

�01*++61.))("4"+).D"U2-.,10(&7+c+)2")"#)%,",.%*+E"-D&-",.(&L+).D"-./,&,.L_0')7 + 1&5(")%&B + ,")2&%$,.%* + U + 6.a3"4" + 510(.+^6"1*("4"+6"1106%&,.+30D"6-.%&50)6UL+6U1*%U-UB+4-.a3.()%,0((")%*B+)%&DU1&-",.%*+30%0'+6+)"C&.1*("'+&(&C&.%&,0B+UD0(&L+30')%,",.%*+,+&(%0-0).O +)",0-^0()%,",.(&7+),"0'+1&5(")%&B +"#_0)%,.B +Z%050)%,.A+!.D"U2-.,10(&0 + & + )"U2-.,10(&0 + c + E"-D$ + )2")"#)%,UL% + -./,&%&L+6"DDU(&6.%&,($OB + %,"-50)6&OB + 1&30-)6&O + 6.50)%,A + N1.4"3.-7 + x%"DU+U2-.,10(&0 + ,")2&%.%01*($D + 2-"C0))"D + )%.(",&%)7 + #"100+2-"3U6%&,($DA + P.5.1"D + & + ,$)^&D + -0/U1*%.%"D + ).D"U2-.,10(&7+7,170%)7+U2-.,10(&0+6.a3$D+,")2&%.((&6"D+).D&D+)"#"'A+!U_(")%*+%.6"4" +U2-.,10(&7 + /.61L5.0%)7 +, + ).D"2"(&D.(&&B + ).D""-4.(&/.C&&B+).D""2-03010(&&B +).D"-0.1&/.C&&B +).D"-.)6-$%&&+c+&+x%"+-0/U1*%.%+,")2&%.(&7A$

E632734G1$@[email protected][email protected]$$-?C$G,3C$C7?CH86C9

8::

Page 145: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

!2-&(C&2 + &(3&,&3U.1*(")%& + 9-./,&%&0 + 1&5(")%& + 2-"&)O"3&% + ,+U50#("J2"/(.,.%01*("' + & + ,")2&%.%01*("' + 307%01*(")%&B + , + -.#"%0+%,"-50)6&O+D&6-"4-U22B+50-0/+"#_0(&0<

!2-&(C&2 + 307%01*(")%("4" + 2"3O"3. + 950-0/ + )&)%0DU + 301B+D0-"2-&7%&' + 2-"&)O"3&% + ",1.30(&0 + )"C&.1*($D + "2$%"DB + )"/3.0%)7+)&%U.C&7+U)20O.<

!2-&(C&2+%,"-50)%,.+96.a3"0+301"+c+,"/D"a(")%*+317+-.)6-$%&7+)0#7B+2-"7,10(&7+),"0'+E.(%./&&B+%,"-50)%,.<

! 2-&(C&2+"%6-$%")%&+)&)%0D$+9)",D0)%(.7+-.#"%.+^6"1$B+-"3&%010'B+3-U4&O+"-4.(&/.C&'<

!.D"U2-.,10(&0 + (0,"/D"a(" + #0/ + 21.(&-",.(&7 + 6"1106%&,("4"+9)"#$%&'("4"< + %,"-50)6"4" + 301. +T#f"UI+ &(.50B + /.50D + "(" + (Ua("�+F")-03)%,"D + C02"56& + )"#$%&'($O + Q\h + -./,&,.0%)7 + )&)%0D.+).D"U2-.,10(&7B+2-0,-._.7)*+,+"#_0)%,0(("+c+/(.5&DUL+)%-U6%U-UA+

+G)%"-&L+Q\h+D"a("+"%)5&%$,.%*+)+20-,"'+2"1",&($+2-"^1"4"+)%"10%&7B + ) + D"D0(%. + 203.4"4&50)6"' + 307%01*(")%& + mA!AR.6.-0(6"B+6"%"-$'+-./-.#.%$,.1+D0%"3$+)"/(.(&7+30%)6"4"+6"1106%&,.+&+-./,&1+U(&6.1*($0 + )-03)%,. + ,")2&%.(&7 + 1&5(")%& + 50-0/ + 6"1106%&,(UL+307%01*(")%*A + GAFAG,.(",$D + Q\h + -.))D.%-&,.0%)7 + 6.6+EU(3.D0(%.1*(.7+E"-D.+307%01*(")%&+)+50%6"'+)%-U6%U-"'A

:2-,=c.31, $ [email protected] $ 7 $ /?.66,A + F-.,&1*(.7 + "-4.(&/.C&7+)",D0)%("'+307%01*(")%&+U5._&O)7B+2")%.(",6.+20-03+(&D&+/(.5&D$O+317 + (&O + C010'B + )",D0)%("0 + 2-"3UD$,.(&0 + 2U%0' + & + )-03)%, + 0�+3")%&a0(&7B + )&)%0D.%&5(")%* + %.6"' + 307%01*(")%& + "#0)205.%+3")%&a0(&0 + C01& + 30%0' + & + C010' + ,")2&%.%01*("' + -.#"%$ + 61.))("4"+-U6","3&%017A + j"-D&-U7 + 6"1106%&,B + (0"#O"3&D" + 301.%* + .6C0(% + (.+E"-D&-",.(&0 + &O + 4"%",(")%& + 6 + ).D"U2-.,10(&LB + ,$-.#"%60+x10D0(%.-($O + UD0(&' + ).D"U2-.,10(&7 + & + 50-% + 6"1106%&,&/D.B+)2")"#)%,",.%* + -./,&%&L + "-4.(", + ).D"U2-.,10(&7B + . + %.6a0+(.)$_0(&L+&(%01106%U.1*("'+a&/(&+30%0'A

Q1.))("0 + ).D"U2-.,10(&0 + c + %.6"' + &()%-UD0(%B + ) + 2"D"_*L+6"%"-"4" + ,"/D"a(" + ,")2&%.(&0 + & + ).D",")2&%.(&0 + U5._&O)7 + 2"+2632734G$3.@=.7?,[email protected],?<325$-,C8,?<326819$

h2>3.7.8,?<3.C $ -,C8,?<3268<+ c + &(%01106%U.1*($0 + &4-$B+,&6%"-&($B + "1&D2&.3$B + ,$)%U210(&7 + (. + h(0 + P.U6&A +E"?$Z&U3",10%,"-0(&0 + 2"/(.,.%01*($O + &(%0-0)", + U5._&O)7w + )"/3.(&0+U)1",&' + 317 + E"-D&-",.(&7 + D"%&,.C&& + U50(&7w + -./,&%&0 + U50#($O+&(%0-0)", +& + UD0(&'B + %,"-50)6&O +& +&))103",.%01*)6&O + )2")"#(")%0'+2")-03)%,.D&+61.))("'+&+,(061.))("'+-.#"%$A

#2GGR31/.8173.C $ -,C8,?<3268<+ c + )",D0)%($0 + D0-"2-&7%&7k+2"0/36&B + ,050-.B + ^0E)6.7 + -.#"%.B + "-4.(&/.C&7 + "#_&O + 301A +E"?$Z&U3",10%,"-0(&0+2"%-0#(")%&+U5._&O)7+,+6"DDU(&6.C&&w+,")2&%.(&0+U+U5._&O)7 + 2"%-0#(")%& + )""%(")&%* + ),"& + &(%0-0)$ + & + a01.(&7 + )+&(%0-0).D&+3-U4&O+1L30'w+,")2&%.(&0+%"10-.(%(")%&+6+"6-Ua.L_0DU+)"C&UDU+&+04"+%-.3&C&7DA

8:@

Page 146: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

a,3326832F2=1,381=27.33.C $ -,C8,?<3268<+ c + U5.)%&0 + ,+)"C&.1*($O + 2-"06%.OB + 61.))($0 + 5.)$ + 2" + 2.%-&"%&50)6"DUB+(-.,)%,0(("DU + ,")2&%.(&LB + )D"%- + )%-"7 + & + 20)(&B + ,)%-05& + )+,0%0-.(.D&A +E"?$Z &,")2&%.(&0 + (-.,)%,0(($O + 6.50)%, + 1&5(")%&+U50(&6.w +2-&,1050(&0 +U5._&O)7 +6 +2"&)6","' +-.#"%0B + ,"1"(%0-)6"DU+3,&a0(&LB + 6 + "#_0)%,0((" + c + 2"10/("' + -.#"%0w + E"-D&-",.(&0+2-03)%.,10(&' + U + U5._&O)7 + "# + "#_0501",050)6&O + ("-D.O + D"-.1&w+,")2&%.(&0+)%-0D10(&7+6+3")%&a0(&L+a&/(0(("4"+U)20O.w+,")2&%.(&0+4-.a3.()6"'+2"/&C&&A

\R-2c,687,332$Q$j68,81B,6/.C$-,C8,?<3268<+c+E0)%&,.1&+20)(&+& + %.(C.B + F"3&UD + m-%B + 6"(6U-)$ + 2" + &/"#-./&%01*("DU + &)6U))%,UB+"E"-D10(&0 + 4./0% + & + "%6-$%"6B + 61.))("4" + U4"16.B + &(E"-D.C&"(("4"+61.))("4"+)%0(3.+=&E"?$k+,")2&%.(&0+x)%0%&50)6"4"+,6U).B+2"%-0#(")%&+, +3")%"'("D+2",030(&&+, +2",)03(0,("'+a&/(&w +E"-D&-",.(&0 +("-D+2",030(&7B + (0"#O"3&D$O + U5._&D)7 + , + #$%UB + , + "#_0(&& + )"+),0-)%(&6.D&B+,+)0D*0B+,+"#_0)%,0(($O+D0)%.OB+(.+2-&-"30w+)"/3.(&0+U)1",&'+317+OU3"a0)%,0(("J%,"-50)6"4"+).D",$-.a0(&7A

:@2=81732 $Q $2>-2=2718,?<3.C$-,C8,?<3268<+ c +h(& +�3"-",*7B+)"-0,(",.(&7 +(. + 1&5("0 +20-,0()%," +& +6"D.(3($0 + /.50%$B + fM0)01$0+)%.-%$gB + ).D")%"7%01*(" + "-4.(&/",.(($0 + )"-0,(",.(&7 + D0a3U+61.)).D&A +E"?$Z &)"/3.(&0 + (0"#O"3&D$O + U)1",&' + 317 + 2"1("C0(("4"+E&/&50)6"4"+-./,&%&7+U5._&O)7+(.+U-"6.O+&+,(0U-"5("'+307%01*(")%&w+,")2&%.(&0 + )"/(.%01*("4" + "%("^0(&7 + 6 + )"O-.(0(&L + )"#)%,0(("4"+/3"-",*7B + )%-0D10(&7 + 6 + ,$2"1(0(&L + -0a&D. + 3(7B + 2-.,&1*("DU+2&%.(&Lw+2"330-a6.+)2"-%&,($O+&(&C&.%&,+U5._&O)7+&+-"3&%010'A

+.;28.$6$@=2;?,G.G1$-,8<G1+c+6"(%-"1*B+U5.)%&0+,+6"()&1&UD.OB+2")%"7((.7 + ),7/* + ) + )0D*0'A +E"?$Z &6"--06C&7 + 2",030(50)6&O + ("-D+f%-U3("4" + -0#0(6.gw + )"%-U3(&50)%," + ) + )0D*0'B + 2-&,1050(&0+"-4.(&/.C&'+92-03)%.,&%01&+30%)6"'+6"D(.%$+D&1&C&&B+&()206%"-.+2"+301.D + (0)",0-^0(("10%(&OB + )"C&.1*("4" + 203.4"4.<w + 2"D"_* + ,+2"/&%&,("D+).D""2-03010(&&+9E"-D&-",.(&0+(.,$6",+"#_02-&(7%$O+("-D + 2",030(&7B + )2")"#(")%& + "2-03017%* + & + -0^.%* + )"#)%,0(($0+2-"#10D$<A

+.;28. $ 6 $ 2-.=,334G1 $ -,8<G1+ c + "1&D2&.3$B + ^6"1*($0B+4"-"3)6&0+6"(6U-)$A+E"?$Z&2-&,1050(&0+U5-0a30(&'+3"2"1(&%01*("4"+"#-./",.(&7+9�0(%-+"3.-0(($O+30%0'B+6-Ua6&B+)06C&&B+E.6U1*%.%&,$B+x106%&,($0 + 6U-)$<w + -./,&%&0 + %.1.(%1&,$O + U5._&O)7B + 2")&1*(.7+2"D"_*+,+).D"-0.1&/.C&&A

Y2=G4$1$G,82-4$=.;284$3.$26327,$62;4815326819 $fQ-U41$'+)%"1gB+301",$0+&4-$B+D.-.E"($w+f\,"-50)6&0+)#"-$gB+)#"-+)",0%.+301.+2-&+2-",030(&&+Q\hB+D"/4","'+^%U-DB+6"2&16.+&30'B+)U(3U5"6+UD($O+D$)10'B + .U6C&"( +&30'B + #.(6 +3.(($Ow + %,"-50)6&0 +"%50%$ +6"D&%0%",B+2-0/0(%.C&& + ),"0' + -.#"%$w + 2-0))cC0(%-w + &(3&,&3U.1*("0+6"()U1*%&-",.(&0w + "-4.(&/.C&"(("J307%01*(")%(.7B + -"10,.7 + &4-.w+

8:Y

Page 147: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

%0.%-.1&/.C&7w+D.)%0-)6&0w+&(E"-D.C&"(($0B+%0D.%&50)6&0++61.))($0+5.)$B+&(%01106%U.1*($0+&4-$w+%0.%-.1&/.C&7A

p,82-1B,6/.C$26327.$2=A.31>.011$-,C8,?<32681$3.$26327,$62;481532681

• f!6,"/(.7 + %0O("1"4&7 + Q\hgB + , + ")(",0 + 6"%"-"' + 10a&%+"-4.(&/.C&7 + 6"1106%&,("4" + %,"-50)6"4" + 301. + 2" + )&)%0D0+MAmAQ.-.6",)6"4"B +mAPA\U#01*)6"4"+&+3-U4&O+203.4"4",J(",.%"-",A+Z)"#0((")%*+c+"O,.%+#"1*^"4"+5&)1.+U5.)%(&6",A• \0O("1"4&7 +2-"06%&-",.(&7B +&D0L_.7+),"&+x%.2$+-0.1&/.C&&k+&307+c+4&2"%0/.+c+2"&)6+c+2U%0'+-0^0(&7+c+"2-03010(&0+)-03)%,+&+D0%"3",+3")%&a0(&7+C01&+c+2"4-Ua0(&0+,+307%01*(")%*+c+-0/U1*%.%A• \0O("1"4&7 + 203.4"4&50)6"' + D.)%0-)6"'B + 430 + 2-032"1.4.0%)7+2"4-Ua0(&0+&+2-"a&,.(&0+6.6"'J1&#"+)&%U.C&&+&+2-"#10D$+9FR+2")%-"0(&7 + /(.(&'B +FR+ + C0((")%("J)D$)1","' + "-&0(%.C&&B +FR+-./,&%&7+D$^10(&7+&+-05&B+FR+21.)%&6&<A).VR$G2-,?<$6.G2R@=.7?,31C+ D"a("+"#-./("+2-03)%.,&%*+6.6+

30-0,"k• @2B7.+c+)-03.�U61.3B+,+6"%"-$O+30')%,UL%+&+-.)%U%+30%&w• /2=31+c+(.2-.,10(&7+)",D0)%("'+)"#$%&'("'+307%01*(")%&w+• 6872?$c+)&)%0D.+61.))("4"+).D"U2-.,10(&7w• 7,871I$?1681/1$c+6"D&%0%$B+%,"-50)6&0+4-U22$B+&D0L_&0+),"&+6"(6-0%($0+/.3.5&w• /=23.$c+(.^&+6"1106%&,($0+%,"-50)6&0+301.AP.^.+D"301*+).D"U2-.,10(&7+-./,&,.0%)7kJ+,+@JD+61.))0+D"301*+/.-"a3.0%)7k+50%$-0+6"D&%0%.+2"+6U1*%U-0+&+

Q\hB+&(E"-D.C&&B+)2"-%UB+fP.^+DU/0'gA+h0-a.%)7+,)0+x%&+f1&)%&6&g+(.+)",0%0+61.)).+&+(.+%"(0(*6"D+)%0#01*60+-.)%U_04"+).D"U2-.,10(&7w

J +, +IJD+61.))0+D"301*+c+Ua0+)%-"'("0+30-0,"B+0_0+D"1"3"0B +("+3")%.%"5(" +6-026"0B + 5%"#$+,$)%"7%* +2-"%&, + ,"/(&6.L_&O+2-"#10DA+P.^&D + f,0%,7Dg + 96"D&%0%.D< + )1"a(" + )2-.,17%*)7 + )" + ,)0'+307%01*(")%*LB+&O+)%.1"+#"1*^0+c+Ua0+,")0D*+6"D&%0%",k+2"+(.U60+&+"#-./",.(&LB + 6U1*%U-0 + & + Q\hB + &(E"-D.C&& + & + 205.%&B + E&/&50)6"'+6U1*%U-0 +& +)2"-%UB + %-U3UB +3&)C&21&(0 +& +2"-736UB +)",0% +61.)). +hMZ+f!$($ + Z%050)%,.gB + fP.^ + DU/0'gB + fP.^& + ^0E$gA + G + 6"1&50)%,"+,0%"506 + 9(.2-.,10(&'< + & + 1&)%*0, + 9)",D0)%($O + 301< + 2")%"7(("+U,01&5&,.0%)7A+

!6?271C$@=2C7?,31C$62;481532681$2;=.>27.31C

6=N=K#8?+7(

b3.B,31, $ 62;481532681A + h.,(" + Ua0 + 2-&/(.("B + 5%" + 203.4"4&6.+317 + "#d7)(0(&7 + ),"04" + )"30-a.(&7 + & + E"-D + ^&-"6" + &)2"1*/U0%+"#_0(.U5($0 + 2"(7%&7B + & + ")"#0((" + c + E&1")"E&L + & + 2)&O"1"4&LB+

8:I

Page 148: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

2"x%"DU+(0+)1U5.'("+,1&7(&0+x%&O+(.2-.,10(&'+4UD.(&%.-("'+D$)1&+(. +2"(&D.(&0 + %"4"B + 6.6 + U)%-"0(. +203.4"4&50)6.7 +& + "#-./",.%01*(.7+307%01*(")%*+&+6.6+"(.+D"a0%+-./,&,.%*)7+&+,1&7%*+(.+"#_0)%,"A+\.6"0+2"(&D.(&0+6U1*%U-")""#-./("B+"("+2"D"4.0%+)E0-0+"#-./",.(&7+&+00+E&1")"E)6&DB + 203.4"4&50)6&D + & + 3&3.6%&50)6&D + &307D + -./,&,.%*)7+0)%0)%,0(($DB + 6U1*%U-($D + 2U%�DB + "#0)205&,.7 + )1"a("0+,")2-"&/,"3)%," + -./(""#-./&7 + & + 2-"&/,"3)%," + (",$O + 6U1*%U-($O+&30'A

Z3(.+&/ +/(.5&D$O+6U1*%U-""#-./UL_&O+&30'+"#-./",.(&7+c+04"+62;48153268<B + "#0)205&,.L_.7 + U(&6.1*(")%* + 1&5(")%("4" + -")%.+6.a3"4" + -0#0(6.A + M + x%"D + 2"(7%&& + "%-.a0(. + ).D"#$%(.7 + 2-&-"3.+"#-./",.(&7B + 04" + &(%0(C&7B + ,(U%-0((00 + 3,&a0(&0B + )"C&"6U1*%U-(.7+3&(.D&6. + , + -./1&5($O + )&%U.C&7OB + . + %.6a0 + , + "2-03010(("' + D0-0+2-"%&,"2"1"a0(&0 + %0O("1"4&/DU + U)%"7,^&O)7 + 3&3.6%&50)6&O+2-&0D",A+

|%" + 2"(&D.(&0 + )"#$%&'(")%& + ,"/(&61" + (. + ")(",0 + &/,0)%($O+E&1")"E)6&O+&30'B+6"%"-$0+&D0L%+)"#)%,0((UL+31&%01*(UL+&)%"-&LA+GO + 21"3"%,"-("0 + ,1&7(&0 + (. + E&1")"E&L + "#-./",.(&7 + 904" + "#_UL+%0"-&LB+203.4"4&6U+&+6U1*%U-"1"4&L+"#-./",.(&7<+)301.1"+,"/D"a($D+.(.1&/ + x%"' + 2-"#10D$B + (.5&(.7 + ) + K>JO + 44A + 2-"^1"4" + ,06.B + 6"43. + ,+"%050)%,0(("' + %0"-&& + "#-./",.(&7 + )%.1& + (0 + %"1*6" + .6%&,("+.(.1&/&-",.%* + 2-"#10DUB + (" + & + 2$%.1&)* + "#0)205&%* + -0.1*(UL+)"#$%&'(")%* + , + "#-./",.(&&A + P",$' + 2&6 + &(%0-0). + 6 + 2-"#10D0+)"#$%&'(")%& + )04"3(7 + )%.1 + -0/U1*%.%"D + ")"/(.(&7 + 2-"%&,"-05&'+D0a3U + 2-0"#1.3.L_&D& + E"-D.1*($D& + D0O.(&/D.D& + U2-.,10(&7B+%0(30(C&7D& + -./,&%&7 + )1"a("' + )U#d06%(")%& + 1&5(")%& + &+(.C010((")%*L+)E0-$+"#-./",.(&7+(.+"%6-$%")%*B +&((",.C&"((")%*B+,.-&.%&,(")%*+-./,&%&7+^6"1$A++++++

!E0-. + "#-./",.(&7 + )04"3(7 + 30')%,&%01*(" + )&1*(" + /.,&)&% + "%+"-4.(&/.C&"(("JU2-.,10(50)6&O+.D#&C&'+4")U3.-)%,.B+)30-a&,.0D$OB+2-.,3.B+04"+x6"("D&50)6&D&+,"/D"a(")%7D&A+l2-.,10(50)6.7+)&)%0D.+30')%,U0%+(.+")(",0+)"#)%,0(($O+)&)%0D+C0((")%0'+&+/(.5&D$O+317+(0�+("-DB +6"%"-$0B+6.6+2"6./.1+2-.6%&6.B +2"-"'+,0)*D.+/(.5&%01*("+-.)O"37%)7 + ) + "(%"1"4&50)6&D& + )D$)1.D& + "#-./",.(&7B + %A0A+2"-"a30(($D& + 04" + )"#)%,0(($D + 6U1*%U-($D + #$%&0D + & + -0.1*($D+2"%-0#(")%7D&+^6"1A+P.2-&D0-B+)&)%0D.+U2-.,10(&7B+2$%.7)*+/.3.%*+6"--06%&-UL_&0 + )"C&.1*($0 + -.D6& + -./,&%&7 + ^6"1*("4" + "#U50(&7B+301.0% + x%" + #L-"6-.%&50)6&D& + & + %0O("1"4&50)6&D& + )-03)%,.D&A + M+-0/U1*%.%0 + (. + 20-,$' + 21.( + ,$O"3&% + (0 + "#0)2050(&0+6U1*%U-")""#-./("4" + O"3. + -./,&%&7 + ^6"1*("4" + "#U50(&7 + ) + U5�%"D+)"C&"6U1*%U-($O+U)1",&'B+.+(.2-&D0-B+%0O(&50)6&'+6"(%-"1*+^6"1+2"+E"-D.1*($D + 2-&/(.6.D + fU)20,.0D")%&gA + G1& + ,D0)%" + %"4"B + 5%"#$+-.)^&-&%* + )0%* + ^6"1 + & + UD0(*^&%* + (.2"1(70D")%* + 61.))", + 95%"+7,170%)7 + "3(&D + &O + a&/(0((" + ,.a($O + E.6%"-", + 6"DE"-%(")%&+"#U50(&7<B + )"/3.,.%* + U)1",&7 + 317 + 2)&O"1"4&50)6& + ,$,0-0(("4"+

8:K

Page 149: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

-./,&%&7 + 30%0'B + )&)%0D. + U2-.,10(&7 + /.6-$,.0% + D.1"6"D2106%($0+^6"1$ + 976"#$ + x6"("D&50)6& + (0,$4"3($0< + & + %0D + ).D$D + (.-U^.0%+6U1*%U-(UL+)-03U+)"C&UD.B+")"#0(("+x%"+6.).0%)7+D.1$O+2")010(&'A+F-&D0-",+D("4"A+

F-"#10D$ + "#0)2050(&7 + )"#$%&'(")%& + , + "#-./",.%01*("' + &+203.4"4&50)6"'+307%01*(")%&+)%.(",7%)7+,)�+#"100+.6%U.1*($D&B+"(&+(.2-7DUL+),7/.($+)+)"/3.(&0D+(0"#O"3&D$O+6U1*%U-($O+U)1",&'+317+-.)6-02"_0(&7+501",06.+,+"#-./",.(&&A+l2-.,10(&0+9,+%"D+04"+,&30B+,+6"%"-"D + "(" + )U_0)%,U0% + , + (.^0' + )%-.(0< + 5._0 + "#0)205&,.0% + ),"&+)"#)%,0(($0 +"-4.(&/.C&"(($0 +& +6"(%-"1*($0 +EU(6C&&B +(0 +2"(&D.7+41U#&(("4"B + "(%"1"4&50)6"4" + )"30-a.(&7 + "#-./",.(&7 + & + -"1& + 04"+)"#$%&'(")%&+317+-.)6-$%&7+2"%0(C&.1.+501",06.A

{%"#$+3,0+)E0-$+9)"#)%,0(("+"#-./",.(&7+&+U2-.,10(&7<+D"41&+#$ + )"J)U_0)%,",.%* + & + ,/.&D"30')%,",.%* + 2-"3U6%&,("B + (Ua("+,$)%-"&%*+"2-03010(($0+("-D$+,/.&D""%("^0(&'B+6"%"-$0+2"6.+U+(.)+(0 + ,$-.#"%.($ + )",D0)%("B + . + 30')%,UL% + %"1*6" + U)%.(",10(&7+4")U3.-)%,. +& +04" +%-0#",.(&7 +, +"%("^0(&&+%"4"B +5%" +& +6.6 +3"1a($+301.%*+^6"1$+,(U%-&+),"04"+2-")%-.()%,.A+

QU1*%U-")""#-./(UL + 2-&-"3U + "#-./",.(&7 + &/D0(&%*+%0O("1"4&50)6&D& + )-03)%,.D& + (0 + U3.)%)7 + c + "#-./",.(&0 + ,)� + -.,("+#U30%+&)6.%*+)"#)%,0(($0+)-03)%,.+317+U30-a.(&7+),"0'+"#_0)%,0(("'+-"1&+E.)&1&%.%"-.+D"1"3"4" +2"6"10(&7k +,03*+^6"1*("0 +"#-./",.(&0+2-&/,.("+(0+4.)&%*B+.+/.a&4.%*+D"%&,.C&L+30%0'B+)"/3.,+,)0+U)1",&7+317+)%.(",10(&7+&O+)U#d06%(")%&+&+.,%"-)%,.+,+"#-./",.(&&A+|%"+2"6.+(0 + U3.�%)7 + )&)%0D0B + (" + ,"/D"a(" + , + U)1",&7O + "-&0(%&-",.(("4" + (.+501",06. +U61.3. +^6"1*("'+a&/(&B +5%" +2"D"4.0% +")U_0)%,&%* +("-DU+9&1&+2-&(C&2<+)"#$%&'(")%&+,+"#-./",.(&&A+

F-&+6.6&O+U)1",&7O+,"/(&6.0%+)"#$%&'(")%*+,+"#-./",.(&&�+c+M+)&%U.C&7OB+6"43.+%"B+5%"+2-"&)O"3&%+)+30%*D&+,+^6"10B+-./,0-%$,.0%)7+(.+")(",0+)"#)%,0(("4"+fO"3.+,0_0'gB +. +(0+2"+)20C&.1*("DU+21.(UB+/.6./U + & + UD$)1U + )" + )%"-"($w + 6"43. + ^6"1*(.7 + a&/(* + (0 + f3.,&%g+-0#0(6.B + . + "#0)205&,.0% + 0DU + %U + a&/(0307%01*(")%*B + 6 + 6.6"' + "(+)%-0D&%)7 + & + 6"%"-UL +&_0%A +GD0((" + %.6.7 + )"#$%&'(.7 + "-4.(&/.C&7+"#-./",.(&7+%,"-50)6&+/.-7a.0%+501",06.A+

F"50DU+%.6+,.a(.+f)"#$%&'(")%*g+,+x2"OUB+6"43.+,)�+2"35&(70%)7+21.(","J2-"4-.DD("DU + -./,&%&L� +M03* + , + &)%"-&& + "#-./",.(&7 + "(.+2-"7,171.)* + (0 + ," + ,)0O + "#-./",.%01*($O + )&)%0D.O + & + (0 + U + 6.a3"4"+203.4"4.B + 3.a0 + U + 203.4"4.JD.)%0-. + "(. + )1U5.0%)7 + (0 + 6.a3"3(0,("B+2")6"1*6U + %-0#U0% + "2-03010(($O + U)1",&'B + 6"%"-$0 + , + )U0%0 + &1& + ,+"#$30((")%&+(0+,"/(&6.L%A+

M)2"D(&%0 + %0 + D"D0(%$ + &/ + ,.^0' + ^6"1*("' + a&/(&B + 6"%"-$0+/.2"D(&1&)* + ,.D + ),"0' + f")"#")%*LgB + 7-6&D + 2-"a&,.(&0DB+x6/&)%0(C&0'B+c+%0+D"D0(%$B+6"%"-$0+,$+2"/a0+")"/(.0%0+6.6+f,$)^&0+2-"7,10(&7g+),"04"+30%)%,.+c+-./,0+&O+#$1"+D("4"B+&+-./,0+"(&+#$1&+),7/.($+, +")(",("D+) +"#U50(&0D+, +61.))0� +Q"(05("B + 41.,("0 +c + x%&+

8:?

Page 150: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

x6/&)%0(C&.1*($0+2-"-$,$+&/+30%)%,.+,+(",$'+)"#$%&'($'+4"-&/"(%+,)�+a0+#$1&+,.D&+2-"a&%$+&+,"^1&+,+,.^+6U1*%U-($'+"2$%A

M"/(&6.0% + &1& + (0 + ,"/(&6.0% + )"#$%&'(")%* + , + "#-./",.%01*($O+2-"C0)).OB+/.,&)&%+"%+%"4"B+2-&,(0)0($+1&+,+)&%U.C&L+,.^04"+1&5("4"+U50(&7 + 9,.D& + & + 3-U4&D&< + (",$0 + 6"4(&%&,($0 + & + xD"C&"(.1*($0+)D$)1$ + & + 6U1*%U-($0 + C0((")%&A + |%" + )1U5.0%)7B + 0)1& + %,"-50)6"0B+6"DDU(&6.%&,("0B + "#-./",.%01*("0 + 30')%,&0 + &((",.C&"(("B+)2"(%.(("B+,.-&.%&,("+&+%,"-&%)7+)",D0)%("+/30)*+&+)0'5.)B+2"%"DU+&+-.)6-02"_.0% + ,.)B + 2-"7,170% + , + ,.) + f.,%"-)%,"gA + \.6&0 + )"#$%&7 + (0+2",)03(0,($A + \0D + (0 + D0(00B + "(& + "2-03017L% + -./,&%&0B + 2"D"4.L%+-"a30(&L + , + "#-./",.(&& + & + , + 1&5(")%("D + "2$%0 + (",$O + &30' + &+)D$)1",A+

p32A2G,=3268< $ 1 $ ,-13687,33268< $ Z62;481C[D+ P0D0C6&'+E&1")"E+y.'30440-+9.+2"(7%&0+f)"#$%&0g�f)"J#$%&0g+#$1"+"3(&D+&/+)%0-a(0,$O+,+04"+E&1")"E&&<+"2-030171+04"+6.6+#$%&0B+)",D0)%("0+)+3-U4&DA + !"#$%&0 + 2-032"1.4.0% + ,61L5�(("0 + 2-&)U%)%,&0A + h17+y.'30440-.+)"#$%&0+"/(.5.1"+"J),"0(&0B+-./J-0^0(&0B+,"/J-.a0(&0B+"%J)%-.(0(&0B+"%)%U210(&0B+"2-"_0(&0B+"03&(0(&0e+!"J#$%&0+#$1"+317+E&1")"E. + & + UJ),"0(&0DB + & + 04" + UJ)%-"0(&0 + , + #0/3"((")%* + ,-0D0(&J2-")%-.()%,.ew + )"#$%&0 + 0)%* + %"B + 5%" + 2")1.(" + #$%&0D + 9fM-0D7 + &+#$%&0g+&+3-U4&0+-.#"%$<A+

!"#$%&0 + c + x%" + "%6-$%&0 + )D$)1. + 2-"&)O"37_04" + 317 + 6.a3"4"+)U#d06%. +& +"#_04" +"#(",10(("4" +)D$)1. +317 +,/.&D"30')%,UL_&O+,+3.(("D+30')%,&&+)U#d06%",A+�(.6+-.,0()%,.+&1&+30E&).B+6"%"-$'+5.)%"+)%.,&%)7+,+)1",0B+&D00%+(0)6"1*6"+)D$)1",A+Z(+"%-.a.0%+)",D0)%(")%*+2-"%06.L_0' + /30)* + & + )0'5.) +a&/(0307%01*(")%&B + 4","-&% + " + -.,("D+/(.50(&& + )",D0)%(")%& + 317 + 6.a3"4"B + U6./$,.0% + (. + E.6%"-B+"#d03&(7L_&' + -./($O + 1L30' + & + -./($0 + 7,10(&7 + , + (",$0 + ),7/&A+!"#$%&0 + c + ,)043. + 3-U4"0B + 04" + (01*/7 + 2",%"-&%*A + ~)1& + 5%"J%"+2",%"-70D"B++"("+20-0)%.0%+#$%*+)"#$%&0DA++

M + E&1")"E&& + 2")%D"30-(&)%", + )D$)1""#-./UL_&0 + 2"(7%&7 + c+3-U4&0k+(.2-&D0-B+f306"()%-U6C&7gB+6"%"-.7+9U+h0--&3$<+"#d7)(70%)7+6.6 + -./#1"6&-",.(&0 + 2"(&D.(&7B + ,$7)(0(&0 + ,(U%-0((0'+2-"%&,"-05&,")%& + %06)%. + 9,)7 + 6U1*%U-. + ,$)%U2.0% + 6.6 + 4&20-%06)%<B+)%"16(",0(&0 + ")%.%"5($O + )D$)1", + 2-"^1"4" + & + )",-0D0(($O+)D$)1",$O+)%0-0"%&2",A+P"+&+/30)*+(0+"#O"3&%)7+#0/+f)"#$%&7gA+F"+D$)1& +h0--&3$B + 306"()%-U6C&7 + 0)%* + 3,&a0(&0 + "2$%.B + "%6-$%"4" + 6+#U3U_0DUB+"2$%.+2"+(0"#O"3&D")%&+(0"2-03010(("4"B+6"%"-$'+7,10(+,+"a&3.(&& + h-U4"4" + & + !"#$%&7A + G + 2")6"1*6U + (0% + 03&("' + 317 + ,)0O+)U_(")%&B + %" + ) + )"#$%&0D + ,)� + D0(70%)7A + F-0a30 + ,)04"B + %"%B + ) + 60D+2-"&/"^1"+)"#$%&0B+D0(70%)7+5.)%&5("+&1&+2"1(")%*LA+

M.a(.+/(.5&D")%*+)"#$%&7+c+xD"C&"(.1*(.7B+x6/&)%0(C&"(.1*(.7B+(-.,)%,0((.7+c+#1.4"3.-7+x%"DU+-"a3.0%)7+")D$)10(&0+)"#)%,0(("4"+"2$%.A + !"#$%&0 + E&6)&-U0%)7 + & + -06"()%-U&-U0%)7 + U5.)%(&6"DB + 04"+

8@>

Page 151: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

&(3&,&3U.1*(.7 + -0E106)&7 + & + 4-U22",.7 + -0E106)&7 + 2"-"a3.L%+(0)",2.30(&0+"2&).(&'A+\.6+-"a3.0%)7+,.-&.%&,(")%*+2"/&C&'+&+&O+&(3&,&3U.1*("0 + 2"(&D.(&0A + P" + U5.)%(&6 + (0 + %"1*6" + (.#1L3.0%B + "(+D"a0% + .6%&,(" + ,D0^&,.%*)7 + , + O"3 + )"#$%&7A + Z( + 2-&"#-0%.0% + "2$%+,1&7(&7+(.+)"#$%&7+&+"2$%+)"41.)",.(&7+),"0'+2"/&C&&+)+2"/&C&7D&+3-U4&O+9"2$%+3")%&a0(&7+6"()0()U).<A+\.6+D("4"D0-(")%*+,")2-&7%&7+)"#$%&7 + , + 2-")%-.()%,0�,-0D0(& + )D$)1", + -"a3.0% + )0D.(%&6U+2"1&6U1*%U-($O+D&-",A

F"50DUB + 6./.1")* + #$B + "%3.10(($0 + "% + -0.1*(")%& + &30.1*($0+6"()%-U6C&& + 2-&/$,.L%)7 + &))103",.%017D& + , + .(.1&/ + .6%U.1*($O+2-"#10D+"#-./",.(&7A+M&3&D"B+2"%"DUB+5%"+)"#$%&'(")%*+c+),"')%,"+"%6-$%"4" + & + ),"#"3("4" + "#-./",.(&7B + 6"%"-"0 + U)%-"0(" + &(.50B + 50D+%-.3&C&"((.7 +^6"1.B +& +a&,�% +2" +3-U4&D+("-D.DA +h")%&a0(&0 +x%&O+("-D+,+"#-./",.(&&+)%.(",&%)7+,)�+#"100+.6%U.1*($DA+

Q + 2"(&D.(&L + .6%U.1*(")%& + f)"#$%&'(")%&g + ^1& + , + (.^0D+"#-./",.(&&B + 6.6 + "% + D0%"3"1"4&& + & + %0"-&&B + %.6 + & + "% + 2-.6%&6&+.,%"-)6&O +^6"1B + 5%" + ,/.&D(" + "#"4._.1" + x%& + (.2-.,10(&7A + F0-,$0+2"2$%6& + ,$'%& + (. + "#"#_0(&0B + f/.)%"1#&%*g + &((",.C&"(($0+2-")%-.()%,.+)"#$%&'(")%&+#$1&+2-032-&(7%$+(.+-U#0a0+K>J?>JOA+

�30)* + ,.a(" + "%D0%&%* + ")(",("0 + ),"')%," + )"#$%&'(")%& + c + 04"+U(&6.1*(")%*A + M)0 + .,%"-)6&0 + ^6"1$ + c + )"#$%&'($ + & + 2"x%"DU+U(&6.1*($B+(02",%"-&D$A+GO+(01*/7+f2",%"-&%*g+,+3-U4&O+)&%U.C&7OA+F"x%"DU+6.aU%)7+(.&,($D&+2"2$%6&+(06"%"-$O+203.4"4",+2",%"-&%*+6.6ULJ1&#" + .,%"-)6UL + )"#$%&'(UL + D"301* + 9,D0)%" + %"4"B + 5%"#$+)"/3.%*+),"L+)"#)%,0((UL�<k+30)6.%*B+3.'%0+(.D+%0O("1"4&LB+&+D$+00+,")2-"&/,030D�AA + F03.4"4U + %-U3(" + 2-03)%.,&%*B + 5%" + 3&3.6%&50)6&'+2-&�D+0_0+D"a("+20-03.%*B+("+%"1*6"+(0+.,%"-)6UL+D"301*A+Q.6+(&+)%.-.%*)7B +.,%"-)6.7+D"301*+,+3-U4&O+-U6.O+#U30%+3-U4"'B +,"/(&6(0%+&(.7+)"#$%&'(")%*+c+6.6+2-"7,10(&0+&("4"+#$%&7A+

Q"43.+(.5&(.0^*+)""%(")&%*+"2-03010(&7+-"3)%,0(($O+2"(7%&'B+,&3&^*B + 5%" + "(& + ),7/.($ + ) + -./1&5($D + 6"()%-U&-",.(&0D+a&/(0307%01*(")%& + & + (.O"37% + ,$-.a0(&0 + , + -./($O + 6"()%-U6%.O+E&1")"E&&+&+%0"-&&+"#-./",.(&7B+,+-./($O+D"3017O+"#-./",.(&7B+5%"+,+/.,&)&D")%&+"%+,/7%$O+/.+")(",U+)D$)1",+2"-"a3.0%+-./($0+)&)%0D$+/(.50(&'A+

P.2-&D0-B+)"03&(0(&0+)&%U.C&'+&+2"(7%&'�C0((")%0'+-&64*,)0P0-&3()-*%&-*<0P0-&&6;)-*3&0P0-&+):-*3,)0P0-&#=1"3?)%,)+2"-"a3.0%+,2"1(0 + "2-03010(($0 + "#-./",.%01*($0 + D"301&�2-")%-.()%,.B + ,+6"%"-$O+-0#0("6+&+U5&%01*+5U,)%,UL%+)0#7+&+,/.&D"30')%,UL%+)",)0D+&(.50B + 50D + , + )&)%0D0 +()1&=1,/*,) 0 P 0 1&?)34) 0 7"3,-,(&-*, 0 P0.&%*,%O)%* 0P 03&7+):-*3,) 0P 0 .&%*1&?<A + +!"J#$%&0 +& + 0)%* + %"B +5%"+-./,&,.0%)7 + "3(",-0D0((" + ) + %"' + &1& + &("' +E"-D"' + )U#d06%&,(")%&+501",06.A+

�&-"6"& 2"(&D.0D$0 + f!U#d06%(")%*g + & + f!U#d06%&,(")%*g + ,+"#-./",.(&& + 2"/,"17L% + ,$)%-.&,.%* + 3-U4"0 + 501",050)6"0+

8@8

Page 152: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

2-")%-.()%," + , +^6"10A +!"#$%&0 +2-032"1.4.0% + /(.5&D"0B + %,"-50)6"0+30')%,&0+1L30'B+)"/3.L_&O+/30)*+&+%020-*+(",.C&"((UL+6U1*%U-(UL+)&%U.C&L+&+"#"4._.L_UL+1&5(")%("0+/(.(&0+9F"1.(&<+&+1&5(")%($'+"2$%+U5.)%(&6",A+|%"+30')%,"+(01*/7+)-020%&-",.%*+&+)J"-4.(&/",.%*+9O"%7 + D"a(" + , + (06"%"-"D + 21.(0 + 2-03JUJ4"%",&%*B + -.)6-02")%&,+U5.)%(&6", + 6.6 + , +D"/4","D +^%U-D0<A +F"x%"DU + )"#$%&'(")%* + ,)043.+x6,&,.10(%(.+(.2"1(0(&L+a&/(0307%01*(")%&+)"#$%&'("'++"#_(")%&A

MAGA!1"#"35&6",+9,+fP�Zk+%0/.U-U)gB+)AKY<+(./,.1+)"J#$%&'(UL+"#_(")%* + "3("' + &/ + EU(3.D0(%.1*($O + 6.%04"-&' + 2)&O"1"4&& + &+203.4"4&6& + -./,&%&7 + )U#d06%&,(")%& + , + "(%"40(0/0k + "(. + E&6)&-U0%+"(%"1"4&50)6&0 + ")(",.(&7 + a&/(& + & + 307%01*(")%& + 501",050)6&O+"#d03&(0(&'A + F"x%"DUJ%" + )"#$%&'(")%* + %.6 + ,.a(. + , + )%.(",10(&&+2"1("C0(("4" + 6U1*%U-("4" + "2$%. + -0#0(6.B + 6"%"-$' + 50-0/ + ),"'+)"#$%&'($'+-73+,61L5.0%)7+,+,+#"100+"#_&0+6U1*%U-($0+2-"C0))$A+

�30)* +D"a("+,)2"D(&%* +&30L+mAj1&0-.k +6U1*%U-($0 +)"#$%&7+c+x%"+.-%0E.6%$+6U1*%U-($O+E"-D+9fQU1*%U-"1"4&7+yy+,06.A+!1",.-*gB+)A+;Y><A+Q.a3$'+U5.)%(&6+"2-03017L%+/(.50(&0+)"#$%&7+)U#d06%&,("w+1L3& + &D0L% + "#$6(",0(&0 + .6%&,(" + & + -0%-"n206%&,(" + )-.,(&,.%* + &+.(.1&/&-",.%*+)"#)%,0(($0+a&/(&B+.+%.6a0+&)%"-&L+,+%0-D&(.O+x2"O&B+-./D05.7+&O+)"#$%&7D&+%"4"+&1&+&("4"+/(.50(&7A

f!"#$%&Lg+,+"#-./",.(&&+2-"%&,")%"&%+fE"-D.1*("0+30')%,&0gB+%A0A+2-"O"3("0B+)301.(("0+f317+4.1"56&gB+%-.3&C&"(("0B+(0+"%D050(("0+)D$)1.D& + 2-&)U%)%,UL_&OA + P.^. + 2-&,$56. + 6 + "-4.(&/.C&&+D0-"2-&7%&' + , + ^6"10 + 3"1a(. + (.D& + a0 + & + &/a&,.%*)7B + 2")6"1*6U+D0-"2-&7%&0 + 2" + 60DJ%" + (.2&).(("DU + )C0(.-&L + 9%0O("1"4&&<+2-&,(")&%+,+,")2&%.(&0+/.U-73(")%*B+("+30')%,&0B+2-"a&%"0+30%*D&+&+,/-")1$D& + 6.6 + ")"#$' + a&/(0(($' + .-%0E.6%B + ,)043. + )%.(",&%)7+)"#$%&0DA+

!"#$%&'(")%* + /.3.�% + %,"-50)6UL + ,61L50((")%* + )U#d06%. + ,+307%01*(")%*B + &)61L5.7 + )%"-"((00 + (.#1L30(&0 + & + 2.))&,("0+,")2-&7%&0A + !"#$%&'(")%* + )",D0)%(" + )"/3.0%)7B + (" + &(3&,&3U.1*("+2"(&D.0%)7A

!"#$%&0+c + 30')%,&0B + 2-&,"37_00 + 6 + 6"-0(("DU + &/D0(0(&L+-./,&%&7B + /(.5&D"0 + &/D0(0(&0 + )")%"7(&7B + )6.5"6A + G/D0(0(&7+2-"&)O"37%+&+U5.)%(&6.D&+)"#$%&7B+("+/.,&)7%+"(&+"%+"2$%.+6.a3"4"+501",06.B + 04" +)U#d06%&,("4" +,")2-&7%&7 +& +%0O +)D$)1",B +6"%"-$0+"(+&/,106.0% + &/ + 2-"&)^03^04" + ) + (&DA + !U_0)%,UL% + )1"a(.7+D("4"D0-(")%* + ,")2-&7%&7 + )"#$%&7 + , + 2-")%-.()%,0 + & + ,-0D0(&B+(0)",2.30(&0 + &O + )D$)1",B + "%)L3. + & + )0D.(%&6. + ,)0,"/D"a($O+)"#$%&'($O+4"-&/"(%",A

Q.a3$' + 501",06 + 9& + )""#_0)%,"< + )"/3.0% + ),"' + )"#$%&'($'+4"-&/"(%+307%01*(")%&�a&/(0307%01*(")%&+&+04"+D"a("+&/"#-./&%*+,+,&30+f2&6",g+9)"#$%&'<B+&/D0(7L_&O+)U_0)%,",.(&0+&+04"+2"(&D.(&0+)U#d06%.D& + 30')%,&7A + {0D + 2&6", + #"1*^0B + %0D + /(.5&D00 + ,)7+2-"&)^03^.7 + ) + U5.)%(&6.D& + 307%01*(")%*A + \.6"' + f#"4.%$'g+

8@=

Page 153: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

)"#$%&'($' + 4"-&/"(% + 2-"%&,")%"&% + ,71"%06U_0DUB + "3(""#-./("DU+2-"C0))U+&+2"%"DU+(&J(.J5%"J(0J,1&7L_0DUA+

!6?271C $ 62>-.31C $ 62;481532681A + G%.6B + "#-./",.(&0+-./,&,.0%)7B + 0)1& + , + (0D + ,"/(&6.0% + )"#$%&'(")%* + & + )",D0)%(")%*A+Q"43. +(.^. +)&)%0D. +"#-./",.(&7 +2$%.1.)* +(. +-U#0a0 +K>J?>JO +,/7%*+6U-) + (. + 4UD.(&/.C&L + & + 1&#0-.1&/.C&LB + D("4&0 + (.3071&)*B + 5%"+,$),"#"a30(&0 + 1&5(")%& + U5&%017 + & + 1&5(")%& + -0#0(6. + 2"D"a0%+)301.%*+&+^6"1U+#"100+),"#"3("'+"%+-U%&(("'+&+E"-D.1*("'+-.#"%$B+5%"+^6"1.+)%.(0%+2-")%-.()%,"D+%,"-50)%,.A +G+30')%,&%01*("B+%"43.+2"7,&1&)*+&(%0-0)($0+.,%"-)6&0+^6"1$B+2-"&/"^1"+D("4"+/(.5&D$O+)"#$%&'B+,+5.)%(")%&B+!d0/3+-.#"%(&6",+"#-./",.(&7B+D("4&0+203.4"4&+)"#&-.1&)* + , + &((",.C&"(($0 + )""#_0)%,. + , + C017O + -0"-4.(&/.C&&+"#-./",.(&7A +P"+,)� +,0-(U1")*+f(. +6-U4&+),"7gB +6.6 +%"1*6" +)%.1.+,+"#-./",.(&& + ,$)%-.&,.%*)7 + (. + ")(",0 + 2"1&%&50)6&O + %0O("1"4&'+f,0-%&6.1*+,1.)%&gA

P.^.+D.))",.7+^6"1.+3.,("+2"%0-71.+2"31&((UL+)"#$%&'(")%*+,+),"0' + a&/(0307%01*(")%& + 9/. + &)61L50(&0D + (06"%"-$O + .,%"-)6&O+D"3010'B + 6"%"-$0 + ) + %-U3"D + 2-"-$,.1&)* + )6,"/* + )%-"' + 2.1"5("'+DU^%-$<A +R.))",.7 +^6"1. + 2")%020((" + U6-02&1.)* + 1&^* + , + (.,$6.O+.3.2%.C&&B+D&D&6-&&+&+&D&%.C&&A+Z(.+"#U5.0%+2U%�D+(.%.)6&,.(&7+&+2")1U^("+,2&)$,.0%)7+,+D0O.(&/D$+6"(%-"17A+Z(.+)"-&0(%&-",.(.+(.+a0)%6&0 + 21.(",$0 + -0^0(&7 + & + %0O("1"4&&B + 2-"3,&4.0D$0 + ),0-OUB+2"x%"DU + )"/3.(&0 + -./(""#-./($O + "#-./",.%01*($O + )&%U.C&' + &+)"#$%&'B +(0 + 1"a._&O)7 + , + U%,0-a30(($0 +2-"4-.DD$B + -.))D.%-&,.0%+5.)%" + 6.6 + &/1&^(LL + x6/"%&6UB + 6 + %"DU + a0 + (06"%"-$0 + D0%"3&)%$+)5&%.L%B+5%"+%-.3&C&"((.7+3&3.6%&6.+&+61.))("JU-"5(.7+)&)%0D.+)0#7+0_0+(0+,$-.#"%.1.B+("+x%"+c+6.6+2")D"%-0%*A

l+(.)+0)%*+&+^6"1$B+&+203.4"4&B+6"%"-$0+,$O"37%+/.+%-.E.-0%$+)%-"4&O+%0O("1"4&50)6&O+2-&�D",+&+.3D&(&)%-.%&,($O+U)%.(","6A+Q+)"a.10(&LB+,"+D("4&O+^6"1.O+30')%,UL%+&+U5&%017B+&+D0%"3&)%$B+&+.3D&(&)%-.%"-$B+6"%"-$0+#"7%*)7+,$O"3&%*+&/+(.0/a0(("'+6"10&B+(0+O"%7% + &)6.%* + #"100 + 2-"3U6%&,($0B + a&/(0J + & + 6U1*%U-")""#-./($0+"#-./",.%01*($0 + -0^0(&7B + (0 + 2-&,$61& + ).D")%"7%01*("+6"()%-U&-",.%*+(0)%.(3.-%($0+"#-./",.%01*($0+)&%U.C&&B+2")6"1*6UB+,)� + x%"B + ) + &O + %"56& + /-0(&7B + %-U3"�D6"B + (0 + .2-"#&-",.(" + ),$^0 + &+,""#_0+(0&/,0)%("B+6+50DU+,03�%A+Z(&+#"7%)7+(0"2-03010((")%&+&+,(0J21.(",")%& + , + "#U50(&& + & + "-4.(&/.C&& +^6"1*("' +a&/(&B + )6.56", + &+)D0($+4.1)", +, +1&5(")%("D+-./,&%&&B +O"%7 +3.,(" +Ua0+2"(7%("B +5%"+-./,&%&L+),"')%,0((.+(01&(0'(")%*+&/D0(0(&'B+.+a&/(0307%01*(")%*+)61.3$,.0%)7+&/+(021.(",$O+)"#$%&'+&+)&%U.C&'A+

F-.6%&6.+&((",.C&"(($O+^6"1+&+&((",.C&"(($O+x6)20-&D0(%",+, + "#-./",.(&& + 2"6./.1.B + 5%" + ,"/D"a0( + ,$O"3 + &/ + a0)%6"4"+&(E"-D.C&"((" + "-&0(%&-",.(("4" + & + )%.(3.-%("J2-"4-.DD("4" + 2"17+"#U50(&7+,+"3("D+&+%"D+a0+61.))0B+2"+"3("'+&+%"'+a0+)O0D0A+

8@;

Page 154: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

P.^. + "%050)%,0((.7 + &((",.C&"((.7 + 2-.6%&6.B + (.5&(.7 + ) + K>JO+4"3",B +U)20^("+3"6./$,.1.+(. +2-&D0-.O+)"#$%&'($O+D"3010'+^6"1+\U#01*)6"4"B+´0%&(&(.B+Q.-.6",)6"4"B+QU-4.(",.B+�"#6.B+�0"(%*0,"'B+�"1*3&(. + & + 3-U4&OB + 5%" + (0 + %"1*6" + ,"/D"a(.B + (" + & + (0"#O"3&D.+20-0"-&0(%.C&7 + "#-./",.%01*($O + 2-"C0))", + ) + 61.))("JU-"5($O+%-.3&C&"(($O + E"-D + (. + 6U1*%U-")""#-./($0 + ,0-"7%(")%($0 + &+,.-&.%&,($0+ 9, +6"(C0 +)%.%*& +U6./.($ +(06"%"-$0+-.#"%$B +, +6"%"-$O+"%-.a0($+x%&+2"&)6&<A+

~)%*+&+&((",.C&"(($0+3&3.6%&50)6&0+2"3O"3$B+")(","'+6"%"-$O+)%.(",&%)7+.,%"-)6"0+30')%,&0+-0#0(6.B +)%.,7_04"+)"#)%,0(($0+,0O&+"#U50(&7++)"/3.(&0D+),"04"+)"#$%&'("4"+4"-&/"(%.+9(.2-&D0-B+D"301&+mARA�"#6.B+SA�A\-"&C6"4"+&+3-A<A+

|%& + D"301& + 2"6./$,.L%B + 5%" + 3.,(" + (0"#O"3&D + 20-0O"3 + (.+-./1&5($0 + 2-.6%&6"J2-"3U6%&,($0 + E"-D$B + , + 6"%"-$O + 2-"&)O"37%+"#U5.L_&0 + 2"4-Ua0(&7B + D("4""#-./($0 + 2-.6%&6&B + 301",$0 + &4-$B+%0D.%&50)6&0+E0)%&,.1&B+"#-./",.%01*($0+2U%0^0)%,&7B+6"D2106)($0+&))103",.%01*)6&0 + 2-"06%$ + & + D("4"0 + 3-U4"0A + Z(&J%" + & + 0)%*+"#-./",.%01*($0 + )"#$%&7B + D0(7L_&0 + ,)L + D"%&,.C&LB + "#-./+D$^10(&7B+2",030(&7+&+307%01*(")%&+30%0'A+

Q.6 + 2"350-6&,.0% + mARA�"#"6 + , + 6(&40 + fM0-"7%(")%($' + D&-gk+C0(%-"D+"#-./",.%01*("4"+2-")%-.()%,.+3"1a0(+#$%*+(0+U-"6J)O0D.B+430 + %-.()1&-U0%)7 + &(E"-D.C&7B + "%504" + "(. + )%.(",&%)7+-02-"3U6%&,("'B + . + )"#$%&0B + , + 6"%"-"D + f(05%" + 2-"&)O"3&% + &1& + (0+2-"&)O"3&% + ) + &/,0)%("' + 3"10' + ,0-"7%(")%&gA + h17 + %.6"'+"#-./",.%01*("' + )&%U.C&& + %-0#U0%)7 + U5&%01*B + )2")"#($' + 6+)",D0)%("DU+)+-0#0(6"D+f#$%&L+,+6U1*%U-0gA+P"+c+f#$%&0+,+6U1*%U-0B+)2")"#(")%*+6+%,"-50)6"DU+.6%U+,+6U1*%U-0+"6./.1&)*+(0)",D0)%&D$+)+&307D&+U-"6.B+21.(.+&+6"(%-"17eg+9)A8=Y<A+

!6?271C $ 2;,6@,B,31C $ 62;481532681+ D"a(" + -./301&%* + (. + 3,.+,&3.k+,(0^(&0B +2"+"%("^0(&L+6+^6"10B +&+,(U%-0((&0B+)"/3.L_&0)7+U61.3"D+).D"'+^6"1*("'+a&/(&+&+)"#$%&'($D+4"-&/"(%"D+"#U50(&7A

`3,V31, $ R6?271C+ 2;R6?27?,34 $ /R?<8R=25 $ 6201.?<32A2$R@=.7?,31CI $)1"a&,^&D&)7 + %-.3&C&7D& + "%("^0(&' + )%-U6%U-+U2-.,10(&7 + ) + "#d06%.D& + U2-.,10(&7 + , + "#-./",.(&&B + )%&10D+U2-.,10(50)6"4" + "#_0(&7B + . + %.6a0 + )"C&.1*("Jx6"("D&50)6&D&+U)1",&7D& + + )U_0)%,",.(&7 + ^6"1 + , + 6"(6-0%("D + )"C&"6U1*%U-("D+2-")%-.()%,0A

Q+)"a.10(&LB+(.+,(0^(&0+U)1",&7+^6"1.+2"6.+D"a0%+,1&7%*+D.1"A+P" + ,)� + /.,&)&% + "% + %"4"B + (.)6"1*6" +^6"1. + D"a0% + )%.%* + .6%&,("' + ,+)"C&UD0B+,+307%01*(")%&+4-.a3.()6"4"+"#_0)%,.A+|%"+2"/,"1&%+0'+(0+%"1*6"+#$%*+#"100+"%6-$%"'B+&((",.C&"(("'+&+).D")%"7%01*("'B+("+&+#"100 + (0/.,&)&D"' + , + D0%"3&50)6"D + 21.(0B + )2")"#("' + ,$)%-.&,.%*+)"#)%,0((UL+"#-./",.%01*(UL+2"1&%&6U+,+D0)%("D+)""#_0)%,0A+

8@:

Page 155: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

`3R8=,331, $ R6?271C $ 2;R6?27?,34 $ /R?<8R=25 $ 2;=.>27.31C$T2;RB,31CI $ [email protected] $ 6.G22;=.>27.31CI $ -2@2?318,?<32A2$2;=.>27.31CU$1$/R?<8R=25$V/2?<325$c1>3,-,C8,?<32681I+ 6.6+"(&+)1"a&1&)*+,+6.a3"'+^6"10A+

�30)* + ^6"1. + D"a0% + , + 2"1("' + D0-0 + ,1&7%* + (. + ,$)%-.&,.(&0+)"#)%,0(($O+4UD.(&)%&50)6&O+("-D+,/.&D"30')%,&7+30%0'+&+,/-")1$OB+"#0)205&%* + &((",.C&"(($0B + 2-"3U6%&,($0B + %,"-50)6&0B + "%6-$%$0+E"-D$ +^6"1*("4" + U61.3. +a&/(& + c + )"/3.L_&0 + 0)%0)%,0((UL + )-03U+)"#$%&'(")%&+,+"#-./",.(&&A

e18,=.8R=.N(?(:('&D=>=+Q.6+2")%-"&%*+^6"1U+#0/+61.))",+&+U-"6",A+RAk+F0-,"0+

)0(%7#-7B + =>>8B + J + =>:w + %.D +a0k + ZA�A�0"(%*0,.A +�6"1.J2.-6 + )04"3(7 + & + ,+#U3U_0DA+!A8?8J=>:

!=I=K)#T('+7A + |6)20-&D0(%.1*(.7 + 2-"4-.DD. + �6"1$ + h&.1"4.+QU1*%U-B+8J:+61.))$A+Q0D0-","k+fm10EgB+8??;A+c+Y=)A

C=D=C$/T+^=+ �6"1. + 6.6 + )"}#$%&0 + 9E&1")"E)6"J6U1*%U-"1"4&50)6.7+6"(C02C&7+-./,&%&7<A+��+P",$0+C0((")%&+"#-./",.(&7k+30)7%*+6"(C02C&'+&+x))0B+RAB+H;+c+8??@B+)A+8@:A

�6"1.+).D""2-03010(&7A+�.4+,%"-"'A+`03A+&+)")%A +>=6=Q):"?F01$4A+RAB+fF"1&%06)%gB+8??:A++c+:K>)A

>=M+?F/$' & >=+ Z#-./",.%01*(.7 + )&)%0D. + f�6"1.J2.-6gA + \0"-&7 + &+2-.6%&6.A+~6.%0-&(#U-4k+fF"1&4-.E&)%gA+=>>=A+)A+c+=?;)A

P+:+1&>=D=+M0-"7%(")%($'+D&-A+~6.%0-&(#U-4B+=>>8A+J++==;)A!?+:+/*$1+7 & C=@=+ !"}#$%&'(.7 + "#_(")%*A + �� + P",$0 + C0((")%&+

"#-./",.(&7k+\0/.U-U)+317+U5&%010'+&+^6"1*($O+203.4"4",B+RAB+H8A+c+8??@A+B#+3)-"'.+7( & M=6=+ iJ2-")%-.()%," + 6.6 + O.-.6%0-&)%&6.+

"#-./",.%01*("4" +2-")%-.()%,. +^6"1$+ �� +�6"1. +& +"%6-$%"0 +"#-./",.(&0A+!#A+(.U5($O+%-U3",+2"+D.%0-&.1.D +VVV+M)0-"))&')6"'+(.U5("'+%*L%"-)6"'+6"(E0-0(C&&A+R")6,.J\"D)6B+8???A+c+8@=)A

�6"1. + ,")2&%.(&7k + K=@J' + D.-^-U% + � + F"3 + -03 +C=>=K(#(1+701+T+R&A=C=M#$T+#F"7(R&<=@=!+1+?+7+4A+RAB+=>>:A

+

8@@

Page 156: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

M`fE+o

'2=276/.C$K?,3.$`1/82=273.B+)%A(A)A+1.#"-.%"-&&+)-03$+&+)-03",$O+&))103",.(&' + , + "#-./",.(&&B + P&a04"-"3)6&' + &()%&%U% + -./,&%&7+"#-./",.(&7A`.?,,7 $ +R6?.3 $ g,?<G.3271BB + �U4.()6&' + 4")U3.-)%,0(($'+U(&,0-)&%0%+,(U%-0((&O+301+&DA+|AmAh&3"-0(6"B+�U4.()6B+l6-.&(.Ag2;27.$K?,3.$:,=A,,73.B+Q-.)("4"-)6B+R")6",)6.7+"#1.)%*AL1?13. $p.=1C $}=<,73.B + 6.(3A +203A +(.U6B + /.DA +3&-06%"-. +�0(%-.+%*L%"-)6"4" + )"2-","a30(&7 + R")6",)6"4" + &()%&%U%. + "%6-$%"4"+"#-./",.(&7B + 30')%,A + 510(Jx6)20-% + R0a-04&"(.1*("' + %*L%"-)6"'+.))"C&.C&&B + )%A(A) + j030-.1*("4" + &()%&%U%. + -./,&%&7 + "#-./",.(&7B+R")6,.A+NA3.827.$E?<A.$)1/2?.,73.B++Q-.)("4"-)6B+R")6",)6.7+"#1.)%*#27.?,7.$f.8<C3.$p1W.5?273.+c+3"6%A+203A+(.U6B+2-"EA+R")6",)6"4"+203.4"4&50)6"4"+U(&,0-)&%0%.B+,A(A)A+1.#A+3&3.6%&6&+G()%&%U%.+%0"-&&+&+&)%"-&&+203.4"4&6&+ mZB+F-0/&30(%+R0a-04&"(.1*("'+%*L%"-)6"'+.))"C&.C&&B+R")6,.A#2=B.?27. $ ).8.?1C $ "G18=1,73.B + (.5.1*(&6 + "%301. + -./,&%&7+U(&,0-)&%0%)6"4"+"#-./",.(&7+�0(%-.+2-"#10D+-./,&%&7+"#-./",.(&7+N01"-U))6"4"+U(&,0-)&%0%.B+)%A+2-02A+6.E03-$+2)&O"1"4&&+E.6U1*%0%.+E&1")"E&&+&+)"C&.1*($O+(.U6+N01"-U))6"4"+U(&,0-)&%0%.B+R&()6A#268,3/2$f.8<C3.$M?,/6.3-=273.B +/.,A+RhZl+fR"(%0))"-&gB+510(+x6)20-%A+)",0%.+R0a-04&"(.1*("'+R"(%0))"-&+m))"C&.C&&B+\"D)6A#=4?27.$).8.$'2=16273.B+6.(3A+E&1")A+(.U6B+,A(A)A+GlZ+ mZAp.3R5?27 $ }=15 $ :8,@.3271BI $3"6%A + 203A + (.U6B + 2-"EAB + /.,A+1.#"-.%"-&& + )-03$ + & + )-03",$O + &))103",.(&' + , + "#-./",.(&&B+P&a04"-"3)6&'+&()%&%U%+-./,&%&7+"#-./",.(&7Ap1=/,6 $ p.=1C $ p216,,73.I $3&-06%"- + f�6"1$ + .(%-"2"(&6& + &+2-"4-.DD&-",.(&7gB +3"C0(% +!&#&-)6"4" +E030-.1*("4" +U(&,0-)&%0%.B+6.(3A+E&1")A+(.U6B+x6)20-%+R0a-04&"(.1*("'+%*L%"-)6"'+.))"C&.C&&B+Q-.)("7-)6A+pRW.$).-,c-.$`?.-1G1=273.I$203.4"4J&))103",.%01*B+/.DA+3&-06%"-.+2" + &(((",.C&"(("' + 307%01*(")%& + RZl + !Z� + f|,-&6.J-./,&%&0gB+\"D)6AE68.@,3/2$M3-=,5$M?,/6.3-=271BB+3"6%A+203A+(.U6B+2-"EA+QU#.()6"4"+U(&,0-)&%0%.B+41.,A+-03.6%"-+aU-(.1.+fF03.4"4&50)6.7+%0O(&6.gAh.=.3H/$M33.$:,=A,,73.B+U5&%01*+(0D0C6"4"+&+.(41&')6"4"+7/$6",B+^6"1.+H=?B+Q")%-"D.A+h1?1@B,76/.C$)D$`DI0Q-.)("7-)6&'+4")U3.-)%,0(($'+203.4"4&50)6&'U(&,0-)&%0%+&DA+MAFAm)%.E*0,.A

8@Y

Page 157: 01*(’+&+203.44&50)6’ 307%01*()%& - values-edu.ru · PDF file!"#$%&’()*&+,$)-."/0-)1,/02!&34)05)%%&-*,0&61"7&3"%,/8 ")(",.(.+,+8??@+4ab+&/3.0%)7+6.6+20-&"3&50)6"0+&/3.(&0+)+=>>=+4a+!,&30%01*)%,"+"+-04&)%-.c&&+)-03

h,[email protected]?276/.C $ )D $ `AB + Q�NlB + hFZ + Q-.)("7-)6&' + C0(%-+2-"E0))&"(.1*("' + "-&0(%.C&& + & + 2)&O"1"4&50)6"' + 2"330-a6&+(.)010(&7Ah2@27 $ M?,/6.3-= $ M3.82?<,71BI $3"6%A + E&1")A + (.U6B + 3&-06%"-+Z%6-$%"4" + 6"-2"-.%&,("4" + U(&,0-)&%0%.B + /.,A + 6.E03-"'+"#-./",.%01*($O + 2-"4-.DD + Z%6-$%"4" + &()%&%U%. + f`./,&,.L_00+"#-./",.(&0gB+R")6,.A+hR>4=,76/15 $`.?,=15 $}=<,71BB + 6.(3A + E&1")A + (.U6B + 6""-3&(.%"-+2-"4-.DD + Z%6-$%"4" + m,%"-)6"4" + G()%&%U%. + m1*%0-(.%&,("4"+Z#-./",.(&7+&DA+iAQ"-5.6.B+3"C0(%+6.E03-$+203.4"4&6&+&+.(3-"4"4&6&+!F#+mFFZB+!.(6%JF0%0-#U-4A:?2;2-B1/27$`1/82=$N7.3271BB +3"6%A +2)&OA+(.U6B +/.,A+1.#"-.%"-&&+2)&O"1"4&50)6"' +.(%-"2"1"4&& +G()%&%U%. +2)&O"1"4"J203.4"4&50)6&O+2-"#10D+30%)%,.+ mZB+510(J6"--0)2"(30(%+ mZB+R")6,.f=210/15 $}=15 $e<7271BB+ 6.(3A + &)%A + (.U6B + 2-"EA + 6.EA + %0"-&& + &+&)%"-&& + 4UD.(&%.-("4" + /(.(&7 + `��lB + -U6","3&%01* + 6"1106%&,. + &+-./-.#"%5&6 + "#-./",.%01*("' + )&)%0D$ + f�6"1. + 2"(&D.(&7g+96"DDU(&6.%&,(.7+3&3.6%&6.<B+R")6,.An.?1G27.$)DMAB+U5&%01*+1&%0-.%U-$+RZl+4&D(./&&+H8@B+Q")%-"D.AnR6827.$N33.$}=<,73.B +6.(3A+203A+(.U6B+3"CA+6.E03-$+203.4"4&6&+l1*7(",)6"4"+4")U3.-)%,0(("4"+U(&,0-)&%0%.+9l1�l<nR7.?27+ M?,/6.3-= $ `?.-1G1=271BB + 6.(3A + 2)&OA + (.U6B + -U6A+2)&O"1"4"J1"4"203&50)6"4"+"%301.+�0(%-+-./,&%&7+%,"-50)%,.+30%0'+&+L("^0)%,.+f�0E"-%","gB+R")6,.A

8@I