Upload
others
View
0
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
公益社団法人日本都市計画学会 都市計画論文集 Vol.53 No.3 2018年 10月Journal of the City Planning Institute of Japan, Vol.53 No.3, October, 2018
*� ����� ������ ��� �� ���� �The Open University of Japan� ** ���� � ����� ���������� �The University of Tokyo� *** ��� ������ �� !"����� �The University of Tokyo�
�������
��� ������ � 2015#$% 2045#&$'()*+,-.+,��!,/01+234567289:;<=>?@ABC?DE
FG(CH(1)�IJK�LM,67NO��P 20181)�Q
345;R94&SHTUVWXYZ[\U2]^?C_
`NOabcdHQe&R��fg2hi=;jk=&l
mFG`n2nBoRp2qr;sC?tc%GHQp
2`uR34567289;Rvwxyz2{�|a}~
S�n3uH�\���HQ � <�R34�?��&���(s`���&S�y�,
y��2���2vwxy��5;���Re&��xy
��5�;���`����O?�_(CHQ�� {¡
¢��2£¤��345�2¥X¦§2¨La�_(CH
W©Tn�H�RK�LMª28�«¬2®���¯
�$R°%G`«±��� {¡¢��²a³´FµH¶
?&n°·��HQ � ¶2Sd�¸¹^�Iºxy»;=>vwxy2¼��
½¾¿�2À�&ÁÂHÃÄ�Å(2)&ÆC(R=>vwx
y²ÇÈÉÊ2ËÈ&ÁÂHÃÄÌ��Í2dÎRÃÄÌ
��Å�Ïh�2{�|ą&ÐÑFµHÒ'��oR
h��ÓT?�_(vwxyatcRF%&;Z�&nÁ
ÔH?C_`ÕÖÌ,×ØÌÁÙa�d¶?�ÚÛÜ?�
(CHQh��ÓTÌ&Ý9ÂH¶?�R9Þ%�2009�2)�ßàÂHSd�Ï�_`��CC�Wá;����C
�e&Áân�CÜ?C_`Ïãä2åæç,èé�êÜ
2¸ë�ìí�sRp2��îï2Z�×Ø2`u2ðY
�ñ2òóaÂHôõ�3öHÒ÷dQ¶2Sd�h�2
ÁÙaÀÂ`u&;R�¬�Ý92øùúVòóûüaý
þÂHÚÛ��HQÄ���;R��2Sd�ð���H
h�2ÓTÌ�Ý9&S_(��îï�2vwxya�
�,���(CH��îï�(3)a�� {¡¢xy?¾R
v���V�� {¡¢��?��(�CH��1�Q ���� ���������
� Ä���;R345:2 8�DEFGR�� {¡¢
xy2�Û�3öH�\�2�H��!â?p2fg�Ä
���;R���a�o��!,)*+,-.+,/01
+?ÂHQö`R¶G%2=>aö?u(Ïã!�+Ü?
�o�a����=?ÂHQ����=2W©T&��R �������a�d¶?��� {¡¢xyÁ�¬�?
�� {¡¢xy��a²�Ì& !�Rp2e"?B# �Çë2$~a%%$&ÂH¶?���2&Ì��HQ ������ ��� � !"#�
� �� {¡¢xy&ÁÂH��V��,'(;)&Bo
�ÔG(CHQ � *ã&R+���&,C(-.�`��2/Õ��HQ
�c0R/1"2Ïh23oHoH��Ü2JÎ�4$%
Z�l5RF%&p26&,C(ö?u`782�� 3)�
��Rª�;9µ�Cn22Á:;Á?2�ý<?�(=
UÂH�¬2>�?$G(CHQ
$%&'�(#)*+,-./01�23�45�67 -$%&'89:;<=>�?@ABCDEFG�HI<1�J- Actual Situation of Policy and Case about Community-led Transportation in the Suburbs of Tokyo -Analysis of Questionnaire Survey for Municipalities in the Suburbs of Tokyo -
@ABC*,fÞDÑ**,6ÞEF�***,GHIJ***
Yuuki Terada*, Sae Kondo**, Chikako Goto***, Hideki Koizumi*** The purpose of this study is to comprehensively grasp policy and case of community-led transportation and to clarify the characteristics and existence of various forms of that in the suburbs of Tokyo where the number of elderly people will be increase rapidly. A questionnaire survey was conducted for all municipalities in the suburbs of Tokyo. The followings are major conclusions: 1) There are only 19 municipalities (11.5%) have community-led transportation support system. 2) Deficit covering rate of operation cost for operator driving community-led transportation 4 municipalities do not cover deficit. 3) Resident driving community-led transportation has various operating modes according to local circumstances. The authors have been able to provide useful knowledge that can give municipalities criterion to decide to introduce community-led transportation in the future. Keywords: community-led transportation, public transportationRsuper-aged society, suburban residential areas, public involvement
�� {¡¢xy, vwxyRK34K�, gLhi=, h�Ý9
��
������� ��������������������� !�"��#$%&'($%)*+,-./0123�456
������� ����78$%9:�;��"��< =>�!�"��#$%&'($%)*+,?./0123�45@
��<�ABCDEFGH23
IJKL�MNO!PQ�� �RST���UV WX!IJKL�� YZ[5\M]^_`! ��a?bcCDEFGH23PQaSd �� YZ[5efg�hi_`�jCDEFGH23a��UVaSd k]Nlm�SZa$�noNpqr_`! �j@a#s�KL�AtMTNuN �a
KL�ABCDEFGH23
IJKL�MNO!PQ�� �RST���UV WX!IJKL�� YZ[5\M]^_`! ��aa#s�IJKL�v��;��� �IJKL�w�AtMNO!�"��#�a
�x
yz&'
CDEFGH&'
CDEFGH23
- 1399 -
公益社団法人日本都市計画学会 都市計画論文集 Vol.53 No.3 2018年 10月Journal of the City Planning Institute of Japan, Vol.53 No.3, October, 2018
� *M&RN:2��a@O�`��nCo,$�ÔG(
CHQPQ%�2010�4)2���;Rh�ÓTR��2È
JST��&,C(h�ùUV�¬Rxy��5�ñ2V
ÓT2<WáX&,C(YZ",[î",\]"",^]
_"a��&@Oa�_(CHQF%&R`Ä,9Þ
�2012�5)�;h�ÝÊ&SHvwxyZ���aÏh�
ma,h�Z�ÜÏ"bcda,h�Z�ÜÏxy��5
da,h�ÝÊÜ&eR��`��"2òónfu(áe
�(CHQö`RÏg�ùú2ûü�Ü2ÚÛ�VÏ��
h¢i��ÂH"bc2<W�jÛ��HÜ?�(CHQ
F%&Rc�,kl�2016�6)�;RIºxy»2��m
$%��an9�RÏ=>h�ÓT2�� {¡¢��Ü
a��&RCo xy2ÈJ�\�&,C(����a�CV���2h�V�¬2ÁÔ��&,C(ýo�(CHQ ��R)p��aqr�`�s22,2�O�tFG(CHQ*ã&R����=��HQ�&ßà�`Sd&u
634567�89��� {¡¢xy2�Û�3ö�d
Hã!�+a��?�`��;v?wñ�CQ*M&R�
�x�2�y��HQ)p���;��5Wz�Z�&{
%$2Ç�|Ô_`��2'(VRe"Ì���&°_(
@O��ÔG(C`Qp2`uRpG}G2��&Æ'H
W©T2<WVòó�ñ2~üã���sH$;Ú��n
%¨��CQe&R��&SH�TÌ�òó2~ü��c
0R�� {¡¢xyÄ�Z��2����2øùú�2
���@O;�FG(C�CQ¶2Sd&e��!"�&
°_`?�(nR�� {¡¢xy¬�V��2��;% ��� ABCDEK�8L�M�
��
����{�{�� {�����
��|����}~��
� �������� !"#$
% &z���|'(#$
) �z��*+|#$
, -./#0*1|#$
2 ����34�#0*1|#$
� ��������*+|#$
� ��������5678|#$
��������|9�:;
��������}<������=>|#$
��������}<������=>|?@AB
��������}<������=>|�C{���:{DE}������
F=>}���G&�HI�|JK
��������|L�M�NO|PQ
F=>}��������|RST�}~��
UV*+W}XY'Z���[\��\�]�
UV*+}^�����NO|#$
��������}<������=>|9�_`
G&*ab��������|#$
G&*ab��������}<������=>|#${9�:;�9�_`
������cdefg|�hij
Ffg}���G&DkAB}~��|lm��\�]�
�no
�np
�nq
�nr
�ns
tu
�s
�v
�w
�x
�ny
�nn
�n
�o
�p
�q
�r
%$&�_(C�CQÄ��;ã!�+?Cde�2!"
��(2W©Ta��?�(CH��)p���;�%G
�$_`��ad��sH?tc%GHQ�
N�� �OP�QR�ST�
� ��2�O&�cHAoÄ���;ã!�+2�"b
c�203 W©T�a��&�`�������&S�RVW©T2�� {¡¢xy¬�2´ëa%%$&ÂHQF
%&R�� {¡¢xy¬�2$~ÂHW©T&Æ'H�
TÌ�îï2��&,C(�������R������R
}=��2��$%ö?uRp2e"a%%$&ÂHQ � �����;R2016 # 11 � 20 ]&VW©T&���a���R��ö`;��ç�ì�aì �`QãüR¡
¢a£¤�R2017#1�6]ö�&165W©T$%ì� a�`�ì ¥¦81.3%�Q��Í&a�2&§ÂQ � s&RĨ�2©ÈaªAHQ,«o*2¬�;ã!�+2���2vwxy¬�,ûü2��aqr�`��R
�� {¡¢��£¤2¥a§ÂQ*3¬�;R�� {¡¢xyÁ���&,C(R��5Z[R?h�Z[R
&á'RpG}G&,C(W©T�2��2®¯a%%$
&ÂHQ*4¬�;R�TÌ��� {¡¢xy2îï&,C(²�Ì&§Â??n&Rp2e"aö?uHQ°6
2*5¬�;R*4¬ö�2±¨a²'(�� {¡¢xyÁ�¬�?��2´ë&,C(Rt³a�dQ U��VWX�YZ0123[\]�^_�
��`abc�23[\]�de�
� ��=>2���2vwxy¬�2}¸a�3&§ÂQ �N�=>fg�VWX�YZ0123�^_
�h �
������ijk� � ���
��lmn�o p� ���
��lmq� �� ���
r���sqtq� �� ���
��������sqtq� p ���
u���vwlmq� ��� ���
� !qxyu���vw��z{|"#$
�% ���
&�qxyu���vw��z{|"#$
���
'()* '(} �
������+,~-�'( �� � ��� � �3$%R��=>�2°n£¤¥23C¬�;�� {¡¢��2Z����R�T2´ 2/3 2W©T�£¤�(CHQö`R=>vwxy�±�a�µ�(CHW©T
nBC¶?�Ô$HQ����z2�¶·&SHòóa�
_(CHW©Tn�T24W¸��HQã��Rv���2Z�R"bc¹ºZ�2Z�Rvwxy»¼=¹ºZ�
2Z�a�_(CHW©T;1W½¾?��CQ�#&RÄ��2Ó`H��Áâ��H�� {¡¢xy2¿À�
�ûüVRh�Z[R�� {¡¢xy�Z�FG(CH
W©T;��C¶?�Ô$HQF%&R*1¬�ÁG`=>vwxy²ÇÈÉÊ2���ÂÃ�(CH½¾��Ä�
�HW©Tn�T215%&?ñöHQ
- 1400 -
公益社団法人日本都市計画学会 都市計画論文集 Vol.53 No.3 2018年 10月Journal of the City Planning Institute of Japan, Vol.53 No.3, October, 2018
���*+,-./VW����� � Ä��;Rs¬��ªÂH�� {¡¢xy?2@Oa
ÂH`u&R�� {¡¢��2£¤Å:2¥a§Â
�Æ 1�Q����ö��� {¡¢��2Z��Ç2�HW©T; 117��H (6)Quì2��2��R°È&ã!
�+��� {¡¢��a£¤�`2;"Q&ÉÊË2�
CÌÍcÎ"�R1980 #2¶?���Rp2 4 #6&;ÏÐÑ�Ò�&�HÒÏÐ"�n£¤FG`QF%&R
1986#&]Ó"R1989#&ÔÎbR1990#&ÕÖ"?C_`{ ��×�?�(lmFG`>a�,W©T�n
£¤FG`QF%&R1991#&;�� 232ØÙ�£¤FG`Q1993 #�Ú;Û# 1 W©T����� {¡¢��a£¤�(CHQe&R�IÌ&¹Ü�����H
ÌÍÓ"2�����Z�al5�` 1995 # 7)$%£¤
:�8c(CHQ
��
��
��
��
��
���
���
���
��
���
���
���
���
����
����
����
��������������������������������������������������������������������������������
�������� � ������
����������������
��=>fg��
*+,-./VW����abc���� � 2003 #? 2005 #&ÆC(Ý#2£¤W©T:� 13 ?Þ�ßaàcHQ¶G; 2002 #2ÊîZ�y2á�&S�îï����z2ݤ,â9��ã&��R)$2��
5?@AR]ä��Z���\��å��5(7)�R ¤æ
�2ç�ß�]C�è�2²é�a¼�ÂH¶?�Rݤ
�`����H?tc%GHQp26R2009 #�Ú;£¤:�V#4W©T�^?��Rêë;ìíî_`?CcHQs&R!+ï?&£¤2¸¹a§Â��4�Q ���9��;.��*+,-./VW����abc�
��� ��� �����
� � �� �����
��� �� �� �����
��� �� �� �����
���� �� �� ����� � �4a�H?R/01+�VV£¤¥�]C¶?��(gGHQ2005 #&�I2W©Ta��&�������a�_`ðÓ,ÄÎ(2006)8)&SG0Rñ�2!Êò+ï
?2�� {¡¢��2£¤Wó�R)*,-.,��,
/012ô&Ï45.5%,53.8%,40.3%,8.1%Ü��_`QpG?@AH?Rñ2!+�n£¤¥;3o�_(CHQ1 W½¾Ò_`/01+�n£¤�Ç¥;3ö_(CHn22R
V;�<+S�n£¤�Ç¥�]C}¸&�H¶?�Ô$
HQ
��*+,-./01��/)23�67�
N��4�����*+,-./0101DE\]����
� Ä��;��5Z[R�� {¡¢xy¿À��ûü
��^RÏ�5R��xûüÜ�2¹õ&,C(ö?uHQ � �5R��xûü��H?�`W©T:;R�1�§�`?Æ� 18 ��HQp2dÎRh�Ý9aöÆ�`ûü&÷�a�(R=>ùUaËH¶?a¿À��ûüQ&%
§�(CH�Q7-1�?ì��` 15 2W©Taáø2��?ÂHQ�ª2�� {¡¢��£¤�Ç?;�ùÌ&R
/01+�6W©T?°nBCQ � �5R��xûü2£¤¸¹a�^2�5&§ÂQ
�M����*+0\]�2)abc
����
��� �� ��
�� ������
����
���� ��� ���� !"#$%�&
'( )* +
,-.�,-.���/0 !���& 12�34�567
89� )*:;<=
>?� !��@¡¢£�&
A��¤BC�¤DE�FGH¤IJ�K�
'( +
DE�
DE�L¥¦§MN��O��<PQRS�34�5TUVW67
>?� '( +
XY��L¥¦§MN �O�<Z[\
]¨E�¤^_�¤`a��¤bc�¤,-.�¤dDb
)* +
���e �D��D�L¥¦§MN � �fg
'( )* +
hijk�L¥¦§MN ��O�lm©ªm«
XY�� )* +
no�no�L¥¦§MN��O�<PQTUVW67
'( )* ¢
XY��pqrst¢O�<Z[\
>?�¤u.�¤v��¤wxyz{�¤?c�
)* +
|}� !~�L¥¦§MN �� �PQ��
'( )* ¢
��������� !������¬ �O��
'( )* +
���� ��� !��������
'( )* ¢
�8C�� � �lm©ªm«
hijk�¤`a��
)* ¢
�^_��^_�L¥¦§MN �� �lm©ªm«
��� )* ¢
>���>��� !��PQ�&
>?�¤DE� '( ¢
�c�� !�<)�j'����O�<®¢®
XY�� '( ¢
����
����
����
����
����
� ã!�+�°È&�5R��xûüa£¤�`2;
2005 #&£¤�`"l"��HQ"l";Äûü&S_( 2015 #&Ï=>vwxyúûüTIºxyý�þÜa²'(CHQIºxy»������ 9)&SH?R "l"2h�ÓT2Z�=±�a"�¿À��ÂHûü��
- 1401 -
公益社団法人日本都市計画学会 都市計画論文集 Vol.53 No.3 2018年 10月Journal of the City Planning Institute of Japan, Vol.53 No.3, October, 2018
þ2����_`Q � pG�;R¶2Sd�ûü;<2W©T&��_(C`
2Ò÷d$Q�5a�H?R"l"aÝù�`?ì��`W©T;$~��CQÝt!"?�(2���4%G`2;R��",��Ü",�l"23,��HQ��"aÝù�`W©T2dÎR1"?���";��"?�#
&ÏÄ�Z�6&����a�Ô�CÜ?Cdûü?�_
(CHQö`R��Ü";�5R��xûüa£¤�(C
�C�RZ�×Ø Å&,C(R�l"?^]�"�Ý
ù�`?tc%GHQ � Ä�Z��(CH��2¹õ&,C(�N�`?¶÷R
7W©T��l"; 1,2"� 2,ûü��H�p2����Ä�Z�a�_(CH¶?�Ô$_`Qq�Rûü
��o$%�HW©TvñÄ�Z�����%GR°fR
ûü��s`W©T�;öÒÄ�Z�����CQ � ö`Ru6�5R��xûü2£¤a���(CHW©
T;�5R��xûü�Ï�CÜ?ì��`147W©T2dÎ16W©T�10.9%�Ò_`Q N��4�����*+,-./0101DE\]����
� Ä��;R�5R��xûüa£¤�(CH 15 W©T&,C(ûüÌe"a@OÂHQ ������h�z2���y�
� h�Ý9aÀÂ&;RW©T$%ÕÖÌ&��a��Â
HÚÛ��HQ15 W©T2dÎR���������a�_(CH?�`2; 13 �R��T���a�_(CH?�`W©T; 10 Ò_`Q�ÆRÂA(2W©T�C�G$&SH��;�ÔG(C`Qã��R�5R��xû
üa �?�(û��(CHW©T;�$_`Q ������h�2<W�
� VW©T&ÆC(�5R�
�xûü&ÆC(W©T�h
�&�u(CH<W&,C(
ö?u`2��6��HQ � h�2<W;Bo2W©T
�®¯��H?CdS�nR
wy�(CH���BCQe
&R���2�µ�µ&�Â
HóôÇÈ2x ¥; 100%���R����µ&!df
"2hi?2óôÇÈ&ÆC
(h�2<W�ë#FG(C
H?$cSdQF%&R��5VW©T��d¶?nBC
?tc%GH��´ë��´�&,C(nR10 W©T�;h�2<W?FG(CH�ne"Ì��HQ ������W©T2ª�%X�
� W©T2ª�%X&,C(R&'ÇZ�2ª�R(Ä�
Z��2Y�2ª�R)Ä�Z��2����µª�R*
Ä�Z��2�ªz2�¶&,C(+�`Q&;�(2W
©T��¶�(CHQ(&,C(;8W©T��u(C�C 1 W©Tf¯�R)&,C(; 11 W©T��u(C�
C2W©Tf¯��%X�(CH¶?�%%$?�_`Q � *&,C(;R�ªz2�¶R,ö�Ä�Z��2��
a����C?�`W©T�4W©T��R����aÂHW©T��np2ûü;so¯�H��7�Q
�3� ������4�5�
� � ¶G%a@OÂH?������?ÂH��",1
",���",GAl"�C�Gn/01+��°n,�
C Åa��(CH¶?�Ô$HQp2s&,�Cûü�
�H ò¥ 50-���Z�×Ø2 ÅR�HC;��è2Ñèö�a��ÂH?Cd2�./�",�l",-
.",01"��HQ � ã��RD2234Q��¶ÂH�5"R���;�
o�ª2Ñèö��¶ÂH"l"R��::400�^�,ö� ò¥� 25-�?ÂH^]�"�ñ��Ì&�����FGVÂCW©Tn�HQ � s&R������?�`4"2o6a§Â��8�Q
�5� ����?67��
������ �
�� �� �
����������
���������
��� !" ��
#$%&'( �)*+,-./012
3��� �
456�7( �)
89#$:; �<
=>?@A;!" �)
=>?@A;!" �)
=>!B� !" �C
(D� E
89
#$F
GH
#$F
89
#$
IJ
KL
MNOPQ�RSTUV�WXYZ[\2��]^_`a�b
cd ¯ ! !e "f¯ gh°i#±jklm²³$n%o
´µµ¶ ���·¸�¹�� ����
º» °���±�¼½¾
����
�����¹����¹��°����À����
!���ÁÂÃ"ÄÅÆ#$Ç%Ȼɼ±´&±Ê'(±¼
+,���¹ÌÍÎÏ��
-¯�Ð.Ñ�Ð/0�Ð12�345Ò
��º»
12�
12�ÓÔÕÖ×Ø�¹6$±789Ù��À��ÁÚÛÆ��
+,� ��º»
:;��ÓÔÕÖ×Ø·¸6$±<=Ü
>Ý2�Ð?@�ÐABC�ÐDE�Ð����ÐF1D
ÞÊGßÉñàáHIâʵH'J¾ßÆãäåæçÞ°è#$âéKLM�ÇÈêÉ�N�O±¶µë'J¾ßÆãäå
´µµì �1��1�ÓÔÕÖ×Ø·¸°�Pí
º»°�QRÁS�ºTUVîïµë'JдðWñòR¾TUVÇXYóÉÄ°�Z[
ôêɽ�ÓÔÕÖ×Ø·¸6$õö÷øöù
:;��#7Vïµë'Jú´Wñ±ûüÊWñîýþÆS�âßÆ�
\]�\]�ÓÔÕÖ×Ø�¹6$±78ÁÚÛÆ��
º»°���æÄ°èÐ��ÀÐ^_#$�±`±#$Ça»=êÉ��Ç78
:;��bc���Î6$±<=Ü
+,�Ð���Ðd��Ð^efgh�Ð,E�
Þi�»ÉG±ÊGßÉñàáHIâʶH'J¾ßÆãäåæçÞj°�klÁ�ÛÆ)°�kl±i�Vⶵë'J¾ßÆãäå
mn��opqÓÔÕÖ×Ø·¸°�78rs
º»°�tu¼±Ê´Ç�âvwúJ�¶µµxy�°�#$âz�ËÇXYÆ{cî°�±|[º ±P6
}~����¹�G�������ú·¸6$��
º»
��Wï�æÄì�½¾±��â°���±¶µ�Ç#$ÁÂÃ��¾ÜÉ{c�#$Á���æıvwÀÇ��Æãäâ¾ÜÆ���Wï�æÄì�½¾±��â°���±¶µ�Ç#$ÁÂÃ��¾ÜºæóÉ{c����Ç��»�°���±¶µ�Ç#$ÁÂÃ��ÛÆÂûÁÛÆ�´WòR¾�ï�æÄì�½¾±��â°���±¶µ�Ç#$ÁÂÃ��¾ÜºæóÉ{cî�°�h[�
´µÊï �������¹��rs
º» #7Vïµë'J¾)*°���
� Ñ��·¸°�õö÷øöù
ôêɽ�ÐABC�
���lﵵ'X
�?@��?@�ÓÔÕÖ×Ø·¸°�õö÷øöù
���
�±��¼úWñ¶µµxy�sÇJ��±��(¾°�ÛÆ�ãÅÁ�ɺê{cî��ÁÂÆ�O �9Ù�¡ÁÂÆ�Î�Î�º Ç�êÐ�±J¾�¢£Á�ɺê{cî�Z[Ç��É��Ç�û�
+�¤�+�¤���¹78��
+,�Ð12� ��º»
�E����±ßÄɺ���¹6$±�Î�
:;�� ��º»
´µµ�
´µµ�
´µÊÊ
´µÊ
´µÊ!
8��� ������� �����
��
��������������� !"#$�%�&� �'()*+,'-./01�234���'�567�8'�$3 !�����1¡5�¢9��:�;< !&<=��1>* !?@£1�ABC�DE�F6�G&4HI�56�����;J¤K��¥L4��5MN7
O�PQRSTU !�$3V¦1W�&��XY�Z)��ABC�)B¥45[�\G&4]�&�'��^_7
`�a§�b[>&c8'�2'4� 6�&¨d1©e�'�5\^_���4fgªh&6�^_�¨d¥Li>��XY1j«&�k,[>7
l�m0mn��d¥L�op��¬qr�s&�'()*����t�'����u��¨dJ�vw[>xZy5�DWJ�����®z4HI�'��^_7
- 1402 -
公益社団法人日本都市計画学会 都市計画論文集 Vol.53 No.3 2018年 10月Journal of the City Planning Institute of Japan, Vol.53 No.3, October, 2018
4"2dÎA";xy»¼=;�C?7õ�(CH¶?ao6&�4(CHQ,ö�R�� {¡¢xy;°]°
2s2§8�ÚÛ�xy¦§?�(tc(CH?9ÔGHQ
B";h��ÓT��H¶?�o6Ò?�(CHQC"?D"�;«¬¸¹2,�Fao6&�4(CHQ¶2Sd&Ô�$4"��_(no6;#:&¯�HQ NN�9{���*+,-./0101DE\] � s&Rh�Z[R�� {¡¢xy&�ÂH¿À��û
ü��^RÏh�R��xûüÜ�2£¤¸¹,£¤ô;
?��2¹õa�^2�9&§ÂQ �:9{�*+0\]�|}�\]��~�
&' (�
=)&'
*+�,=)
���
���-�6�� �-�6�
����-��6����-��6�
���-��6
����-��6�����-��6
� ��
!"#$%&��'(�
�)*+�,-��./��
01���23��4�56�78�
� ��
!"9:
.;<�� =3��
�>?@���A��B�+CDE
FGHIJKLMNOPQRDST
�
��
UV
� ��2Sd&Rh�Z[R�� {¡¢xy&,C(;R
��nûün�HW©T�5W©T�2&��R��;�H�ûü��CW©T�7W©T��RûüS�n´�����(CH?CcHQ¶G;Rð�$%Z<a" ��
C=ó;ÊîZ�y2��?�%�C`uR��>��?
Û��H`u?tc%GHQ}¸�;R!â�$% 40km�6@G`W©T�ûü��HA;��Hn22Rûü2
£¤a���(CHW©T&;��",BAP,�C"
?C_`!â$%@OÌfD@2W©Tn�HQ N��*+,-./0123�;�23���� � �Íö�2�� {¡¢xy¿À��ûüa£¤�(C
HW©TaƧ�`2�Æ2��HQĬ2EF�nªA`�R/01+�2£¤��BCQ¶2¶?$%R��
{¡¢��2£¤�Ç��CW©T2vd�R�� {¡
¢xyÁ�¬�a£¤�(CH?tc%GHQßT�mÉ
a�CRGH2ð��a�_`��a�10&§ÂQ � GH2ð��2��$%�I2JK;ò�FG`Qö`R�L2Á:�»MÂH�R�� {¡¢xy&ÁÂHûü
a£¤�(CHW©T;R"bc¹ºZ�Vvwxy»¼
=¹ºZ�a�_(C�$_`Q<��R=>vwxy�
���*+,-./0101DE\]�2)abc�:��
�<=>W¯°�
あり なしあり 42.1% 57.9% 19なし 70.6% 29.4% 143
コミュニティ交通サポート制度
コミュニティバス導入経験
p<0.05
合計
N=162
±2�HW©T;�� {¡¢xy¿À��ûüa�_(
CHA;n¨7�s`Q ±�*+,-./0145�67 � �¬�;�� {¡¢xy&ÁÂH¬�2e"a�(s
`QĬ�;}~Z�Ä2�� {¡¢xy2}¸aqr
ÂHQ ��4�����*+,-./01�67 � �^2�11;2017#3����Ä�Z��FG(CHRö`;Ä�Z�&¥�ÂH¶?�N��(CHîïãO�
�H(10)Q�ÆR��"2��&,C(;)$2îï��2
8mVZ��2PQ��H��(11);�C`Q�^RV
Í&&,C(e"a�(CoQ � ö�RZ���5; 2äe&á'%GHQ1,u;RRS$%p2=>���Z�a�w�C`��5?p2Tç
�Sö���H�� ��,/01ÄUxy,�� ��
�,��� ����Q2 ,u;RpG�L2WXYxyÁ���5��^R�åݤ��5?V���HQ�T
Ì&;��"2ð3rW,Mjxy,w�R1"231
X�R�l"2Î7WXYRFC`ö"2*�xy��
HQ � Á:b�,W©�&,C(;RBo2îï�b�,W©
�aYCÒ=�Á:�(CH¶?�Ô$HQ � Z<&,C(Z&ÂHQRS2�� {¡¢���;
100[\ãV 200[\ã?$_`Sd&R\ãZ<��42îï��S�Z<��Cîï�BCQ��5Z[R��
{¡¢xy�;R"1"2�� {¡¢xy;Z<�Ä
����150[���Rã�2îï��?@AH?Z<��CQö`R��"2 E ��2Z<n\ãZ< 210 [���R��"Qa]Hã�îï��2\ãZ<��H 220[�IC G�êa���`=ó; 216 [�S�nVV�CZ<���FG(CHQã��Rã�2îï��?@A(
Z<�3C�� {¡¢xynBo�HQ�&I�`Sd
&RZ�2×Ø ÅVW©T$%2����2�°��H
ÄRZ�ª�aZ< ¤�^d`u&p2Sd&Z<��
a�(CH?tc%GHQ �åݤ��52�� {¡¢xy�L2��&Z&Â
H�� 12�?R_¢��a�¯��5?�ß`���a�¯��5&soá'%GHQ�5;Ïã�_¢a�W
XYZ���ÜR65;Ïã�ð�a�WXYZ���Ü
2>�&S�Z��sHn2��HQã��R� 12 &�H�� {¡¢xy;C�Gn?e�B:2a�að�ó
Ôµ(�da�WXYZ���R,ö�R��&�`Hn
0 25 50km
- 1403 -
公益社団法人日本都市計画学会 都市計画論文集 Vol.53 No.3 2018年 10月Journal of the City Planning Institute of Japan, Vol.53 No.3, October, 2018
WX�� ��� �� ��� ���"��� �� ��� ��
�������#� !"#$
%&'($ )*+,�%�� -./0 122345561257452689:��&';<=>
(')'?@AB+�#CDE#*+,-
%&'($ ?@,�.�� -./0 1227456
/0+1FG2/0+1HI3
FG,�J %&,45-$ FG,�67��K9��2322L3
125M476
8N9NO2/0+1HI3
PQ,�J %&,45-$ PQ,�6:��K9��2312L3
125M4R6
)STUV,���&'
)*+�WXY�TZ [\&']^_)STUV,�]`�)S�aTUV�_
K9��2112L3
125b436
cde,���&'fg&'h
ijkXl�Wcdemn,�
o+pA^q�r
cdemn���K9��2152L3
125b4b6
sXl,�(;<=>?&'ftuvw@Oh
xyz�#{|�#tu}+#~z�#'-A-0B
x�HI^q�r
sXl,�2~z�atu}+3
K9��2M22L3
125M4b6
�?���C���&'f�M5��h
��C�,�#�!��
��zXlHI]^_
��C��J�K9��2112L3
12514b6
��,���&'f�5"�1"�Mh
���#��+�,,�
�\&'^q�r
D'>5>?���"��EF,G+�J�"�?�����"��+�,���
K9��]572L_
122R4R6
%���&'f��jvOh
%�,�#!�� ^q�r��� %��J�K9��2M22L3
122R4�6
�3 ��+�#��,��� \&']^_
��,����K9��]572L_
125�4526
Y�@O%G\���H��# ¡¢£�,
^3¢¤¥¢£��I¦§��I¢£�,���¨©
K9��2M22L3
12554R6
�ª«iO¬®#¯°±F�²¯°³,�
^3¢¤¥ ´µ��
K9��²±F�21�2L3³,�2112L
125b4516
!¶,�(;<=>?&'f··J¸Oh
KLM¤{"¤{�?Z#T¹�*+,-#º»z�¼¹|
2^3º»��H&'
X¹½���a�¾¶���a¾¶���a�¾¶Xl���a¤{,�NFO,G+���a�!¿���
-./0 122�456
!�T,�(;<=>?&'
ÀÁ�#Â�Ã�TZ#ÄÅÆÇ�#ÀÁ�
2^3º»��H&'
�ÀÁ���aYÈ���aº»É'PFEFQ���a�É����aORKS-T<Â�Ã���a�ÄÅ���acÄÅ���
-./0125b416
2ÊË�X3
125�4M68@{Ì�I125�4b68@Í�{Ì�IÎÏ�ÐÑÒX
J½,���,45-f�Ó©@Oh
(?,�#Ô)Y,Õ*+,-
YZ�Ö×2^3
(T���a(?���aØÉ���a Z���aYZ���
K9��2M22L3
122R4526
Ù%Ú,���,45-
ÛÜ,�#X�,�YZ�Ö×2^3
ÝÞ���aÝc���a´ß���a£H¶���aàµÙ���aáâ���aX����aã�É���aÍä���aÛÜ���aÙ{���aåF���a®¶���aζ���aæç���aæÉ���
K9��2M22L3
125b6b6
è�"éê,���,45-fëU�iOh
ì��íÃ#º»î�íÃ
YZ�Ö×2^3
�¤���a�ï���aXï���acï���aðF���añ����aXÉ���a�ò{���
K9��2M22L3
125b4526
z (;<=>?&'T[ÁV-W
óô+�#õö÷�ø"ùX/?KA-4²úûIüýþ�*+,-#üýþ�*+,-²��@²��@
�&'^q�r
!�,�������Iݳü"c������I z[,�������
%"â522LIX"â��532L
12234526
z (;<=>?&'?ÁV-W
[ YFþ�*+,-#õö÷�ø"ùX/?KA-4
�WN+TZW&'^q�r
z[,�������I� "xy,�������I�,�������I?�,�������
%"â522LIX"â��532L
12234526
«i�� ���dÎ,���,45-
���#��� ��HI2^3 dÎmn���K9��2M22L3
12514516
G��ä��G��#G��ä,�
�&'^q�r
6���@[6:L
12554�6
çY� çY%��#Ä�¶��¤� �&'^q�r
6���@!�67:La%�.:L
12554�6
U� å�U� åT#xd!+�
�¤� �&'^q�r
6���@!�67:La%�.:L
12554�6
É
��
z�
º»É
z
�¤
�� �<3�N���?���²@AJ7)89:;�4�����*+,-./018L
- 1404 -
公益社団法人日本都市計画学会 都市計画論文集 Vol.53 No.3 2018年 10月Journal of the City Planning Institute of Japan, Vol.53 No.3, October, 2018
2�RÏã�ðóa�WXYZ���Ü2>��ÚÛ��
�R�åݤ��52RS��?2>�?;¯�Hn2�
�HQ � ö`RÄKP~=;ÂA(Z�W©TQ&��R�¬
2bcç�n�d�HC;"eÂH&ÄK��HQ¶
G%2¶?aö?uH?RÏ=f2�ß`��Kö`;_
¢���K�gã�ðóa�WXYZ���h2>�ag
��`��Rp2=>2�� {¡¢xyaZ��(C
HÜ?$cHQ � ��� �³��4���B��²´µ����
� ���9{���*+,-./01�67�
� ûü&ëC`h�Z[R�� {¡¢xy�Z�FG
(CH2;R]3",i�j",kl",5",m1c
��_`Q�ÆRC�GnWn�Y��Z�FG(CH`
uRZ<;õo��HQ �N� 9{���*+,-./01�5�
� � 13 &§�`Sd&R5 W©T2dÎ 3 W©T2îï;��&D´�ÚÛ�hp�ê�HS2Z�Çë��HQ
ã�R5"2���2��C�;Û]Z�FGR$,h
p�ê�HS�;�CQö`Rqc��£¤FG(CHi
�j",m1c2��&��Rkl"V]3"2���;
�Hã�2�ë&æÌ&lmFG`hiü=Q�Z�FG
(CHQ5"2=ó; 5 W©TÄRrãÉÊË?hi=,X�=a�Vîï?�_(CHQh�Z[R�� {
¡¢xy&,C(;��C����%=>2´s&�d`
B#�Çë��H¶?�Ô$_`Q ¶�·��C�� M�*+,-./0123��/)·� � ¬�æ&,C(;Rpnpn�� {¡¢xy¬�a£
¤�(CHW©T� 19��5R2ú 12Rh�R2ú 4R
���3W©T�?R�T21W~ü��H¶?�%%$?�_`Q¶G;��&���`�� {¡¢��2tÕ
£¤:?@OÂH?R1995 #2§8�10 W©T�&fCQp2Ä�R2005 #&ã!�+�°È&�5R��xûü�£¤FG`"l";R<2W©T$%Ýt?�`!"&
�4%G(Æ%�RW©T�2s'�|��w�C�C¶
?n§uFG`Q�� {¡¢��2W©T�v½2Ûw
&;Ïf"�Ü2$~�ßàFG(Æ���Î,xy
200310��Rf"W©T�2�zÝù��w�C�C¶?
�£¤W©T:289��ö�Co621,Ò?tc%GHQ{$ÂH?Rf"W©T�2�zÝù��u0R��
{¡¢xy2£¤���u689�(Co�\���HQ � ¬�2Äz?�(so¯�_(oH2�ÏÄ�Z�6
����Ü2¹õ&,C(��HQRS2�� {¡¢�
�;ã�Ì&Z<a]|&�R���á&,C(;W©T
����(C`Q�$�R�8&�H4W©T;��5Z[R�� {¡¢xy&ÆC(RÄ�Z�62����a
��C?�(CHQ,ö�RZ<?�(V}~�Z��ª
2�(a^dÚÛ���R�� {¡¢xyaÈJFµH
è�êç�S�3CQ¶2¶?$%RW©T&SH���
�è2B�&S�R�HW©T�;ÈJÂH��5Z[R
�� {¡¢xy�S� Å�,�CW©T�;ÈJ��
C¶?�d$�c`Q<�R�ª2Ñè�¶2Sd&Z�
×Ø2 Å���Ì&,�o�CW©Tn�HQã!�+
?Cd�H~ü2�Fa�_`�>&ÆC(����VZ
�×Ø Å2®¯��H¶?�%%$?�_`Q � W©T�2®¯��ö��$_`2�R��5Z[R�
� {¡¢xy£¤&;'`h�2<W��HQe&Rh
���2�ý�jÛ��H����µ&;'`óôÇÈ;
�(2���h�2<W?FG(C`Q � h�Z[R�� {¡¢xy2Ä&;RÊîZ�y* 2 *3Í�å�ÂHÏ<62�Û&�dR¹º�RWXYa���(a�aZ�ÂH��Ü&ñ`%�R>�,��
�?Û��Hn2n��(13)RW©T2¿À��ûü��o
?nZ��(CH����H¶?�%%$?�_`Q � 2 ,2�HS2�� {¡¢xy2£¤W©T;R�� {¡¢��aZ��(C�CW©T&BC¶?n%%$
&�_`QW©T2���z2ÁÙ&,C(R�� {¡
¢��R?Cd§8a�0�(�� {¡¢xyR?Cd
§8&¥��(CH¶?�§FG`Q M��*+,-./0145��/)·� � s&R´ë&,C(Ò�R��5Z[R�� {¡¢x
y�;R)$2��îï?�d$pGS�nZ<�3Cî
ï�BCQ¶G;�ª2y�R����VZ�×Ø Å�
,�C`uRZ<a3oµ�Ha��C?Cd¶?Ò÷dQ
ö`RÁ�ÂHW©T�N:&ö`�_(CH¶?n%%
$&�_`Q,ö�RÝã2b�,W©�?C_`��
{¡¢S�n�C34�ùUaÇÈ�(�� {¡¢xy
2£¤a��ÂHÚÛ���RÝã2b�,W©��2�
� {¡¢¼X?;¯�H�O��H�\���HQ
��� ���� �� � �� �� ����� �����������
!"#$%&� '()*+,�����-.��/
0123456*+,78��
9:�;<��=>?@AB
'()CD�
EF����
GHIJ$%&� '()
K34��LMNOPQ��-RSTUVW/
GXY5Z�[\ZRS]!Z^Y\Z�_`_ab
?9�;<��=9@@AB
'()K�
cde_��
$%&�fgh '()ij����-kl1TW/
ij��Zmn5
?9�;<��=9@@AB
'()op�
<qrstuvwxydez_etuvEF����
Y{) |}VWi~������5Z)�����
?9�;<��=9@@AB
Y{) ���0W���Z���o5�����5
>��
;<���o5=>:@AB��5=>>@A
���)������cde_-���VW/
����Z��|�� ¡c_
¢�;<��=9@@AB
���)£i¤����cde_
¥¦��Z3§��
¢�;<��=9@@AB
���)
¨§v©C����cde_-ª«�0W/
¬§5®Z��¯5®
¢�;<��=9@@AB
°±IJ=$B �0²³)´µ�+¶����cde_
´µ5Zµ·¸
¹�;<��=9@@AB
�0²³)´µ�
<qcde_fvº»v¼½cde_fv¾¿º»��
|À�ÁÂ=$B
$B�ÃÄ�ÅÆ_eÇ¡�ÂÈÉÊË_Ì��ÍÎ<qrstuÎEF����
Y{)ÏÐ�
���)34�
�ÁÂÑÒvÂÓ�vEF��ÔÕ�vÖ¡c×_�vrs�u�vØÙÚÛvÜÂv3ÝÂvÞß_dàÞwáâ
-.�� ���� ���o ��� o
��� �t���g��� ����� �������
!"�#$%�&'($%�
)*+*��� ����
,-� ./0%���%��1234567�*+*����89:)��7
;
<=� >?@%�ABCD%�/EFG�HI*JKLMNOP #� ;
Q'RQ'RSTUG,-�VWQ'RXTYGZ[\�] ^Q'RXTYG_'`a\
#� ����
- 1405 -
公益社団法人日本都市計画学会 都市計画論文集 Vol.53 No.3 2018年 10月Journal of the City Planning Institute of Japan, Vol.53 No.3, October, 2018
� ö`R��5Z[R�� {¡¢xy2Z�&�`_(R
��5�ݤ�(CH���_`QpG%2��5;
Z�=>Qö`;"e�`=>&ÄK��Hö���HQ
=>Q2ÓT2ã,?�(pdC_`��5�ÁÔ_(C
H¶?�d$�c`Q � h�Z[R�� {¡¢xy;Rh�Wz�è�êça
!_(Z�ÂHn2���Rqc�,hiü=,Ë?hi
=a�Vîï�ñ=>2´s&�d`B#�îï����
H¶?�%%$?�_`Q MN�C���D��¸¹ � Ä��2&Ì;Ru6R34567� �&89ÂH�
��ã!�+a��&R345�2xy¸52¥X¦§?
�Hvwxy2��Sd&,C(R�� {¡¢xy&Z
&�(p2¬�?´ë2��æ$%%%$&ÂH¶?��
_`Qp�(RÄ��2e¤;e"Ì���aÞ�ß��
Sµ�R����a�_`���_`Q � ��ö�2t³&S�Rp2¬�V´ë2B#�a§�
`Q¶G&S�RW©T2òó2�TÌ�~üVZ�2Ç
ë�ñ&,C(�H~üã���\���a�%G`?$
cSdQ¶G%2��;u6R�`&�� {¡¢xya
£¤ÂHW©T&?_(R����2¸¹?Wz2W©T
2¸¹aù%�óÔH¶?�°��ûü�Éa�d`u&
¹��Ã�&�HÒ÷dQ�$�RÄ��;�oö�¬�
2B#�?´ë2B#�a§�`&ìí�CQu6R+:
2´ë&��(¶G%2¬�2®¯�½��`qr&,C
(%%$&ÂHÚÛ��HQ´�&;RÙc%G`W©T
2¬�2 Å^�#:�¦y�V=2´s&�d`��
{¡¢xy�£¤FG(CH?tc%GHQpGa%%$
&ÂH¶?�R=>&?_(°���� {¡¢xy2£
¤atcH��a�H¶?��sHÒ÷dQ Eº»F�
� Æ��CÄR�����&ï=UoÒFCö�`VW©T2Xñ52�#&�����4öÂQ���?dï�Cö�`Q E��F�
(1) 3456789:��5�;ã!�+?��+(4�)��HQ (2) 2014 #&��FGR2015 #2=>vwxy2¼��½¾¿�&ÁÂHy�2á�&S�á�FG`Q (3) ð�óC�ß`��nf¯Q (4) Ä���;R�J,BAP,���ñ2Sd&ã�Ì&�� {¡¢���£¤FG(CH?tc%G(CHW©T��_(nR��52�J�2û���a�_(CHîï;�� {¡¢��?;w�C�
CQö`R��������;RÏ��5Z[R�� {¡¢xyÜ2¶
?aÏ�� {¡¢xyÜ?�(Nd(CHQ (5) ��������;RÏ��5Z[R�� {¡¢xyÜ2¶?aÏ�� {¡¢xyÜ?�(Nd(CHQ (6) � 3 S�������� {¡¢��aZ��(CHW©T; 109 ��H¶?$%R8 W©T�;)&�� {¡¢��2�îï���FG(CHQ (7) �c0R�!ò2W©Ta��&�� {¡¢��2Z�ª�&,C(áø�`Ä1%�2012�11)
&SG0R�å��5;Ï)$2îï���
�5?@A(]����Z��sH?Cde"��úgGHÜ
�p.I_1361�Q
(8) �ÆRÄ�Z�62×Ø Å,�����&,C(;)&Ä�Z���2�HW©T&,C(;�����S�Rp2<2W©T;VW©T2
ûü2qÛaVW©T2��������O�`Q (9) Ä��;=Æ2ËÈ2`u&QGISa�C`Q (10) �����2 Q8 2ì�af&ËÈ�`Q�ÆR��"&,C(;�������&s'� _(CH`uR¡5�ýo�`Q (11) �TÌ&;Ï*1�¢3=îï��ÜÏ£�3ü==îï��ÜÏ�¤�=îï��Ü23îï��HQ (12) Vö�2������aÝù�(ËÈ�`��O]¦2017 # 1 � 21]�Q ð3rW¥¦�Khttp://www.tendaikanko.co.jp/ ¥¦�K w�http://www.kyoudou-group.jp/index.html ¥�31X�http://www.tls.ne.jp/index.html Î7WXY�¥�http://www.yamaguchi-motor.com/index *�xy�¥�http://www.daisan-taxi.co.jp/ E��2Y�&,C( http://www.city.yokohama.lg.jp/doro/plan/chiiki/kaigi/h25/download/1shimoizumi.pdf ¶Â�u§2Y�&,C( http://www.city.yokohama.lg.jp/doro/plan/chiiki/kosuzume-bus/unkou.html Mjxy¥¦�K&,C(;H��¨ �2����HQ 1"2�� {¡¢xy&,C(;������aÝù�`Q http://www.city.kawasaki.jp/kurashi/category/26-1-2-2-1-0-0-0-0-0.html �l"2ðó�ß`�&,C(;H��¨ �2��?R=>vwxyòó����2©oaÝù�`Qhttp://koutsu-shien-center.jp/jirei/ FC`ö"2ðó�ß`�&,C(;FC`ö"©oaÝù� ̀http://www.city.saitama.jp/006/008/002/012/004/013/p047706_d/ fil/siryo3.pdf (13) ã��Rh�Z[R�� {¡¢xy;Rvwxy»¼=¹ºZ�?�(Z�FGH��nª�FGR¶2=ó;���ÚÛ��H�ÊîZ�
y* 78 ½¾* 79 �Q`Ò�R������vwxy»¼=¹ºZ���H?ì��` 6 W©T��«¬c,®",ÒÏÐ",¯b,¤�b,¤Òb�&;C�Gnh�Z[R�� {¡¢xy;£¤FG(C�
$_`Q E�·R�F�
1)IJK�LM,67NO��P(2018)RÏ]Ä2=>�°SÉ67�±È30�2018�#É�-±È27�2015�#²57�2045�#-ÜR http://www.ipss.go.jp/pp-shicyoson/j/shicyoson18/1kouhyo/gaiyo_s.pdfR2018 # 4�20]�O³ 2)9Þ´5,3��µ,`Ķ·(2009)RÏ=>ÝÊRvwxy¿�¨��¸2ÈJ�\�?�Ø�\�&ÁÂH´¹áø:Ï�¼��S_$CÎÜa��?�(ܺl��¨�m DR65(4)Rpp.568-582³ 3)78ºã(2013)Ï*1¬� h23oHoH��ÜR78ºã»g�� {¡¢xy2,o�$ -̀}=�¼cHȽ2�oúhRpp.25-48R�¾9¿K³ 4)PQÀÁ�,Â_´�,�ALs(2010)RÏh�ÓTR��¿�¨�2Ã��ST��&ÁÂH��@OáøÜxy �R41(1)Rpp.3-13³ 5)̀ Ķ·,9Þ´5(2012)RÏ=>vwxyz2︎h�ÝÊÀ���&ÁÂH��ܺlÉÊ���,ÄÅmR45RCD-ROM(195) ³ 6)c�DÆ�,klÇÈ(2016)RÏ=>å¨ç¡¢&Æ'H�Ø�\�=É&SHÏCoxyÜ2�\�-ÏCoxyÜ?�(2�� {¡¢��2�O-Ü!"Éʨ�mR51(2)Rpp.153-158³ 7)Iºxy»(2013)Ï�I2��¿���mÜR http://www.mlit.go.jp/jidosha/topics/bus_saisei/comibus14.pdf, ,2018# 4� 20]�O³ 8)ðÓÊ�,ÄÎË(2006)RÏ�� {¡¢��Z�gù¸¹&ÁÂH��-�IW©T2´�¸¹ !?áø-Ü]ÄÌÍ����'(mR23Rpp.415-420³ 9)Iºxy»g±È 27#²Î52gù´ÏhÏ=>vwxyúûüTIºxyý�þ&,C(ÜRhttp://www.mlit.go.jp/common/001094560.pdf 2018#4�20]�O³ 10)�ÎÐ,xy�Ñ(2003)RÏ�� {¡¢��2£¤ST��?W©T�v½&ÁÂHt³ Ò��fg2��S�ÒÜ!"Éʨ�mR38(3)Rpp.481-486³ 11)Ä1,ÓÄÔ©,ÕÖ©,ÄÎ×6(2012)RÏZ���52ØC?W©T2ª�%X&Z&�`�� {¡¢��2Z�ª�&ÁÂH��Ü
ºl��¨�mD3�ºlÉÊ��R68(5)RI_1357-I_1362³
- 1406 -