16
0 IL' m 0 D Z 0 0 IL' X I- IU 0 IU IU 8 IG C u IL' C 08 V lU Gl IL 5 C ID 8 E 0 8 N 0 Za 0 0 0 Gl OD C C Gl I IL K IU 0 UI 0 L Ol IO CA IA Ct o Cr IP Gl Gl CV CO IA COI 0 Z CJ 8 N IA IA IPI IP E 6) 0 Gl 0 O Z 0 I- O CI CO K Z' 0 O Z Z o O 3 Gt m lU Z Z 3 I- J I CI CG CII 0 6 IL' Z 5 0 0 O E 0 Gl Q X 'Z O 4 0 8 C 0 O C Gl E 0 O G X Z O CO I- Z O IL IL '0 CD 8 C 8 0 N E g C 0 ~2 o 0 0 0 Ol 8 0=- CDD IP Gl Gt 0 N Se .C o Ol C 0 8 C- IA 8 t 5 CG ~ 0 CO 1 SC c E -I Cl C 8 0 c Z 0 I O 0 0 Z ~ ( ~ t 0 0 'Z 0 Gl '0 0 O IG IP N IG 0 IA Gl ,So 0 Ctl C ID V Ol 8 '0 D C 8 8 o. Z 0 0 C 8 ID g IU CV 8 Ctl C CV L ID Ee 8 IA J3 . C N 'O Gl CA Gl N Gl Gl 'G E cn %) O IL E G X Z O 0 C 0 CO O Z CI IU IU O 0 IL'. 0 C 8 E IG 0 CO '0 IP ID 0 CG Ol CB CO CI C 0 '0 Gl 2 8 PL'V Ol CD CO CI D PC 8 lU 0 Dl C 0 0 0. Gl C CD 'C 0 0 Z C 8 E 2 N 8 Gl 0 CD OI CO CI o C 0 'D 8 'O CD Ol I CI o '0 8 Gl jNX 8 Gl E Ol Gl IL O. GC CA GC C Gf E 2 N C 0 m 'D 8 Gl 0 CO Cl Cl I CI CG CI C 0 0 Gl '0 CO CI CI Ol o '0 8 0 Gl IU 8 'p 0 C Gl E IP ~ L CO Gl 0 Z C 8 E N 0 m '0 8 IP 0 CO CI 0 '0 8 'o 0 CII CI Ctt IA CI Ctt 8 0o IA C CG IP ~ Eo 8 Cl NO Gl GP N 0 OZ

0 C- · 2017-04-14 · CG IPEo ~ 8 Cl NO Gl GP ... T1 Id 0 I-C 0 QlI 0 Gd 5 N c c ld «D " QY 0.0. 4 '0ld 0 C N m III cc LC I-0e Ql 0 00 e ~C ol0 CD ~ C 0 0 JYn I II! 0 QI QD n 0e

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: 0 C- · 2017-04-14 · CG IPEo ~ 8 Cl NO Gl GP ... T1 Id 0 I-C 0 QlI 0 Gd 5 N c c ld «D " QY 0.0. 4 '0ld 0 C N m III cc LC I-0e Ql 0 00 e ~C ol0 CD ~ C 0 0 JYn I II! 0 QI QD n 0e

0IL'

m

0DZ

0

0IL'

XI-IU

0IUIU

8IG

Cu IL'

C0 8V

lU GlIL5

C ID8E 08N 0

Za0

00Gl

ODC C

Gl

IIL KIU 0UI 0L Ol

IOCA

IACt

o

CrIPGl

Gl

CV

CO

IA

COI

0Z

CJ8N

IA

IA

IPIIPE6)

0Gl

0O

Z0I-OCICO

K

Z'

0OZ

Zo O

3 Gt m

lU

ZZ

3 I- J

ICI

CG

CII

06

IL'

Z

500

O

E0

Gl

QX'ZO408

C0O

CGl

E0O

GXZO

COI-ZO

ILIL

'0

CD 8C 80 NE gC 0~2o 0

0 0

Ol 80=-

CDD

IPGl

Gt0 NSe.C oOl C08C-

IA 8t 5CG ~0CO 1

SCc E-I ClC 80 c

Z0I

O00Z~(

~t00'Z

0Gl'00OIGIP

NIG

0 IAGl,So0 CtlCID

V

Ol 8'0 DC8 8o. Z0 0C 8

IDg IU

CV

8 CtlC CV

LID

Ee8 IA

J3 .CN 'O

Gl—CAGlN GlGl

'GE cn

%)

O

ILE

GXZO0

C0

CO

OZ

CIIUIUO0IL'.

0

C8E

IG

0CO'0IPID0

CGOlCB

COCIC0'0Gl

28

PL'V

OlCD

COCID

PC8lU

0DlC000.GlCCD'C0

0ZC8E2N

8Gl0

CDOI

CO

CIo

C0'D8'O

CDOlI

CIo'08

Gl

jNX8 Gl

E OlGl ILO. GC

CA GC

CGf

E2NC

0m'D8Gl0

COClCl

ICICGCIC00Gl'0

COCICI

Olo'080Gl

IU

8'p0CGl

EIP ~L CO

Gl

0 Z

C8E

N

0m'08IP0

COCI

0'08'o0

CII

CICtt

IACI

Ctt

8

0oIAC CG

IP ~Eo8 ClNO

GlGPN 0OZ

Page 2: 0 C- · 2017-04-14 · CG IPEo ~ 8 Cl NO Gl GP ... T1 Id 0 I-C 0 QlI 0 Gd 5 N c c ld «D " QY 0.0. 4 '0ld 0 C N m III cc LC I-0e Ql 0 00 e ~C ol0 CD ~ C 0 0 JYn I II! 0 QI QD n 0e

C8E

C

0CI088CI

Cl

lpC3C0'0Ql'00O8

CL

0N

N

Cr'0tn5OGlI«

UJ'ftCI

Gl'E00

PtC»Ea8 OE oVI p02

Ql

E

MC

0063'a880(0

63C0'0Ql'00V8

!L'A

CIN(0N

'Cl8D

ilpCI

GlU0CeoEo8 0M CI

J3Vl

0Z

C

MC

00IZI

UGlID0tv

0N

0Cl

C08'0O0tlt

iL

(0CI

alCr'08aOSI(

IU(0CI

8O

0oC al

Ea8 Cl8 O

N pCt 2

IUOI02

300fh

UJ8

C

Vt0CLID'0C0Vl'OC C00 03

OlC QQt UE QlID CN O

t0

6I8

8C0 8Ol

L-0 C5 8

O

0Ih

8 JJr

0 E0 t-Ol 0C

Ol0—al0-

8C JCD

E a«C 8

O

8

0Ol?88

bCl

08J38

U8N8808I

C0ID0 (LfnQ 0

Vnl al

F„m

C 0DU8

m CC U8

C rh

Q.0 0.Ol «L'D

acC0Vl8

8 Vl

CJ E8N

N

N

raNl

Ilt

Ihr

CIz

E NN

C(063 p8 t0

0 ipec

Vl Ifhal'C Ue

'0 P 8«QlC

E 0O 88ID 8

Orh

01 .. IO

SJ0 CC 2 (00 DO CJ2 Q

CL

LL «C

Ql

N0 c

h E~a (0

0O (0

0~«C Ch

Ql N,.-NF-C

'

8(0 0Vl

(0Otfi 0

+'J

ah<C N

(0 CNQ.«C N

QU(0E 8

Cl

ZI»OCi J3CDSKIOJD a

al0'L

Vl Vl8 8

VI- al '-C 8 0

CC C 8IO IDEJDC» Ol

(0VE jnt(0 frt vlChm 6!8 0c CO

al ~8OE»0 8N 8

c C (38 3O0 N

p c t0

O MON IQ XID

(00 8).OX E al

CtI-

ai O J3

'0Cm

Cj CQ.CL 8Ot ~ CC 8

E 13Gl0 NIE

U CQECCJDIO .0\ 0 M

8 irlln Ol'

NCL N0 ch

C (0Ql '0 03880 E«t

CL IVIc 8m 0 Nmec0

80 (0 0

th N 8) Jt'03

OagcU a8 0,

IO0 0VI

0 vO ID&8C3c 88 Olv

CtQ'E UC (0 r-8 0CDO V'Ql V

J3

(D

0CLrh(0C8)CV

OtVI8 8O

CD'0

'E ctO Ol

Ql «-aO8 m

0 lp

CIO

C Z0l .E 3Ql

Q 0a US

Vl»ECalU 8)Cal c

(D8V0 0

CD CIII

0 (0aE8 U

D 8C (3lmID c mcc

alVlID

C8E (D

CGl Col 0n! 0C 5m m

8 U

8«80 'O8 (00C mec0 I—)Qt U

8 0O N

J30mcU8«0 808 (UC CU CgIDIc rn 8eci- o.U O (0

0Ql

8OalO8J30M

Vl

J38U8

VtQl

V8CLN

'OCItl

0Cl

'UOl88CC8Vl

8JD(0

Vlnl

0QlICC(D0

J3C JtUJ C

I«8 IUal'0 (08

IO

c IOlU 8

8IO8Ol

alEIht0Ih880

0fh

Ct.

(0

N

0EQ.0ID

(0

N8:00CLI8

08I«ID

alIJIUJ

3(LU

ID8C(3

ID

E

ONOl

0'U

O

08CL

E0O(00X2O

E(0V(ht0CO

Ol

0

VQl

'O8

JQ(0

(ialcL 8ID Ol

JD C

NN

63

C80 IQal «t

3 f(II

O C8rh «C

80CU

)OJ3 ai:0 >OlCL (0U Cc I-8 «3

Page 3: 0 C- · 2017-04-14 · CG IPEo ~ 8 Cl NO Gl GP ... T1 Id 0 I-C 0 QlI 0 Gd 5 N c c ld «D " QY 0.0. 4 '0ld 0 C N m III cc LC I-0e Ql 0 00 e ~C ol0 CD ~ C 0 0 JYn I II! 0 QI QD n 0e

CNE 0N E

0'E

IhQ

Ih

tt

'0hl

0

@O

mO

'0htN

Ol

0

ClOOINO

CV

8IA

»0OOOOCII

Qt aIP

tll ZL0

N 0C

OO

ht

th g0I-C

ClCl

CSENL

06 C)

OCI

CttCl

t

00N

Cl

I-

8TlNI-ChlE

Zirh

Cl

Ehl

Cl

ChOt

CQ

IQ

Q.

F

gQ.CIOtCO

Cott0

CQ

0Q.D

tholGl

»NN0N E8 o0 N

N(9

b xN

O

Ih

C

EEO

Page 4: 0 C- · 2017-04-14 · CG IPEo ~ 8 Cl NO Gl GP ... T1 Id 0 I-C 0 QlI 0 Gd 5 N c c ld «D " QY 0.0. 4 '0ld 0 C N m III cc LC I-0e Ql 0 00 e ~C ol0 CD ~ C 0 0 JYn I II! 0 QI QD n 0e

In'0C

tl

QVIL,

cN'0IQl'00'0Ql

0QII(edl

n0CL

e0dl

0Vl»IO0(0

CeC v

eT1Id

0 I-C

0QlI

0 Gd5 N

c cld

«D "QY 0.0.

ld4 '00 CN mIII

LCccI- 0

e

Ql

000 Ce ~

ol0

CD ~C 0

0JY n

I

II! 0QI QD

n 0eC !.dl0

) Z00~ III(n(0 0

a(d

N0 QI00 IO

Ql

o ~~r0e ce g'0 ~0 Qm

Vl Zl

Ce IUCO~

VI

0 D'Q

Vl0 0(

III GGerc(tl GI

0GG

Oz

GI(I!

0G!'oQl

C(d

cnQ!

(d

cedl

'0CG!ID

Q

0cG!

0eNVl00N»0CL

(D

Gl'0C(tl

Ql

Ql

'0eV!ID

Ql«f

Q!

- C!Gl IIIou:

UJCI

Ql ICc 0

(0

III0.0.4

Cm.oO In0

(dC E«CEc 00N cQl m Cl8'0 G!

t OLQc>o0 Ql CIC e

(D

m e(ocrc cm GD

(Vl 0 e(d

) om g0 lo0

e Ic 0GI ~(0 )

L eQl CLO(D

Vl (G"Nee Io cLNC OICLC G!0 0 m

'Cn 0 0Q

e cLQ! eCL CLCId» ecc or

dl

EEVER0 m (LQolo ogQ(0 N

tdtt! e

0

N.O 0c.m rn In0 G!

In op«Ldll a mCL Q!

GC o o."

Page 5: 0 C- · 2017-04-14 · CG IPEo ~ 8 Cl NO Gl GP ... T1 Id 0 I-C 0 QlI 0 Gd 5 N c c ld «D " QY 0.0. 4 '0ld 0 C N m III cc LC I-0e Ql 0 00 e ~C ol0 CD ~ C 0 0 JYn I II! 0 QI QD n 0e

DONE AND EXECUTED this 22 day of March, 2017 by a majority of the Virginia Gas and OilBoard.

Chairman, Bradley C. Lambert

DONE AND PERFORMED this 22 day of March, 2017 by Order of the Virginia Gas and OilBoard.

Rick CooperPrincipal Executive to thestaff, Virginia Gas and Oil Board

COMNIONiWEALTH OF VIRGINIACOUNTY OF RUSSELL

Acknowledged on this ~day ofw au rr X.,~, personally before me a notary publicnd

in and for the Commonwealth of Virginia, appeared Bradley C. Lambert, being duly sworn diddepose and say that he is the Chairman of the Virginia Gas and Oil Board and appeared RickCooper, being duly sworn did depose and say that he is Principal Executive to the staff of theVirginia Gas and Oil Board, that they executed the same and was authorized to do so.

My Commission expires: July 31, 2017

Sarah JesseIF4ilmer, Notary Public262946 Unnnn

'~W. 'OTARY '4y'UBLIC

REG,4i262946:= *:MYCOIViIAISSILIN:

*=

il i.ni

Page Number 5.

Page 6: 0 C- · 2017-04-14 · CG IPEo ~ 8 Cl NO Gl GP ... T1 Id 0 I-C 0 QlI 0 Gd 5 N c c ld «D " QY 0.0. 4 '0ld 0 C N m III cc LC I-0e Ql 0 00 e ~C ol0 CD ~ C 0 0 JYn I II! 0 QI QD n 0e

BEFORE THE VIRGINIA GAS AND OIL BOARD

PETITIONER. CNX Gas Company LLC DIVISION OF GAS AND OIL

DOCKET NO: VGOB 92-0721-0240-07

RELIEF SOUGHT: (1) DISBURSEMENT FROM ESCROW REGARDING TRACT(S) 3 (2) ANDAUTHORIZATION FOR DIRECT PAYMENT OF ROYALTIES {3)AND DISMISSAL OF COAL OWNERSPURSUANT TO CODE OF VIRGINIA SECTION 45.1-361.22:2.

HEARING DATE: On June 16, 2015, the Virginia Gas and Oil Board, on its own motion, granted the Director ofthe Division of Gas and Oil the authoriiy to process coal owner dismissal disbursements thathave no pending deficiencies or issues. Code of Virginia Section 45.1-361.22:2. Effectivedate: July 1, 2015.

DRILLING UNIT: W20

BUCHANAN COUNTY, VIRGINIA

PETITION FOR ORDER OF DISBURSEMENT OF ESCROW FUNDS

1.Petitioner and its counsel

Petitioner is CNX Gas Company LLC, PO Box 570, Pounding Mill, VA 24637, (276)596-5075.Petitioner's counsel is Mark A. Swartz, Hillard & Swartz, LLP, 122 Capital Street, Suite 201,Charleston, WV 25301.

2. Relist Sought

(1) the disbursement of escrowed funds heretofore deposited with the Board's Escrow Agent(s)attributable to of Tract(s) Tr. 3 as depicted upon the annexed Table; and (2) Dismissal of coalowner{s): Theodore Blaine Mullins, Cornelia Maurice Mullins, Marilyn Mullins, George W. Mullins,Sr., Elizabeth Barker, Thomas Joseph Barker, Timothy John Barker, Jennifer Wheeler, StephanieMullins-Williams, John David Mullins, Brandon Mullins, Heather L. Dawson, Sandra Gsrende,Karla Jones Mullins, Thomas L. Mullins, Jr., and Madeline Hunt.(Royalties currently being paid under VPSSGU1, Docket ¹YGOB95-1024-0526)

3.Legal Authority

Va. Code Ann. IJ 45.1-361.1st seq., 4 VAC 25-160-140.,and relevant Virginia Gas and OilBoard Orders ("Board") heretofore promulgated pursuant to law.

4. Type of Well(s)

Coalbed Methane

5. Factual basis for relief requested

Page Number 6.

Page 7: 0 C- · 2017-04-14 · CG IPEo ~ 8 Cl NO Gl GP ... T1 Id 0 I-C 0 QlI 0 Gd 5 N c c ld «D " QY 0.0. 4 '0ld 0 C N m III cc LC I-0e Ql 0 00 e ~C ol0 CD ~ C 0 0 JYn I II! 0 QI QD n 0e

i "f () IL) 00709a. CNX Gas Company LLC is the gas claimant in Tr. 3. As such CNX Gas Company LLC isentitled to 100% of ths CBM royalties now in escrow and as may be hereafter payable. See Va.Code Ann. () 45.1-361.22:2.A.b. That CNX Gas Company LLC has given the notice(s) required by () 45.1-361.22:2.Ato all

conflicting claimants Identifled in the above referenced pooling Order and any supplementalOrders pertaining thereto.c. That none of the conflicting claimants noticed have provided, within 45 days of the notice(s)given as provided in b. above, the Board, its designated agent the Director of the Division of Gasand Oil, the Operator and/or the Applicant evidence of either an agreement regarding theescrowed funds/royalties or a proceeding regarding same.d. That a detailed accounting in accordance with the applicable provisions of si 45.1-361.22issubmitted herewith and identified as Exhibit J.e. That an Exhibit identified as Table 1 is annexed hereto, and it specmes how the disbursement(s) is to be calculated and paid by the escrow agent.f. That Va. Code Ann, 5 45.1-361.22:2.A,further provides thai the Operator shall pay suchroyalties as may hereafler be payable directly to the gas claimant CNX Gas Company LLC andnot escrow same. Sse Exhibit EE annexed hereto.

6. Attestation

The foregoing Petition to the best of my knowledge, Information, and belief is true and correct.

Page Number 7.

Page 8: 0 C- · 2017-04-14 · CG IPEo ~ 8 Cl NO Gl GP ... T1 Id 0 I-C 0 QlI 0 Gd 5 N c c ld «D " QY 0.0. 4 '0ld 0 C N m III cc LC I-0e Ql 0 00 e ~C ol0 CD ~ C 0 0 JYn I II! 0 QI QD n 0e

~doO00700

LATITUDE

1

SKARINO OASISISLAND RIC

STATS FLAN@'COORPINATE SYSTKAls

h

II

rrr

Qz —SOO'-

o/

78Is dILOd8YCC8IIPOSSDCP'SO yA

rr

I

/(-BOO''

/

7 CIII / I

'I

IVO NKc. '.ress urer'I

VIKLL LOCATION I*LAT

COMPANY taiga'liad NK IVELL NAME end Ho. MIY w enTRACT Ne. ELKVATKSI k50AaSLarsdarr ~unvCOUNTY +IICIddIVaI+ — DISTWCT earrrrgrr~eakg ALK. P SOO D srs~ar

aonaao vnsreaTHIS PLAT IS A NKW PLAT~; AN ISSATKD PLAT I OR A g+ftrte ~%

DENOmS THK LOCATION OF A %%LL ON UIETKD STATES 7 RCPSSSOALKEWrOOOr LATITISIK AIe LOHSITUDK LINKS SKS80 RSPRE Y BOfK@P4ESA+

sk'Y~W~eORII DSO-GO-7 UCEHSED PROFESSIONAL ENSINKER OR LICENSED LAND SURV4EV. S/'SI

Page Number 8.

Page 9: 0 C- · 2017-04-14 · CG IPEo ~ 8 Cl NO Gl GP ... T1 Id 0 I-C 0 QlI 0 Gd 5 N c c ld «D " QY 0.0. 4 '0ld 0 C N m III cc LC I-0e Ql 0 00 e ~C ol0 CD ~ C 0 0 JYn I II! 0 QI QD n 0e

Well Plat. LegendProperty nnd Lease M'crmatien

Weti Unit - W40

l. Coa!Oil dt GasOil sk Gas LesseeCoal Lessee

1 c 31.68% - 2$.34 Acres

Hugh Macrae Land Trust Tract 11. Gaston Cook, Heirs............,.None of Record. Consolidation Coal Company, Island Creek Coal Company. Perrnac, Inc,

Coalded Methane Lessee,.........Pocahontas Gss Partnership

lA. Coa! .Oil dr Gss .Oil tk Gas LesseeCoal Lessee .

Coalbed Methane Lessee

Hugh Macrse Land Trust Tract 11Permac, Inc.....None of RecordConsolidation Coai CompanyIslind Creek Ccsl Company

, Permac, Inc.....Pocahontas Gas Partnership

1A ~ 0.64% - 0.51 Acres

2. Coal, Oil, tk Gas

Oil k Gas LesseeCoal Lease

Coalbed Methane Lessee .

,, Yukon Pocahontas Coal Company, Bt Al,.BVP Tract 9..Cahot Oil Ec Gas Corporation, ~ Island Creek Coal Company

, Permac, Inc...Buchanan Producdon Company

2 ~ 0.07% - 0.06 Acres

3. Coal .Oil de Gas,Oil & Gas LesseeCoal Lessee .

Cosihed Methane Lessee

Mullins Tract 1Consohdatton Coal Company

, . None of RecordConsolidadon Coal CompanyIsland Creek Coal CompanyPennac Inc...No lease of Record

3 = 15.68% - 12.54Acres

Page Number 9.

Page 10: 0 C- · 2017-04-14 · CG IPEo ~ 8 Cl NO Gl GP ... T1 Id 0 I-C 0 QlI 0 Gd 5 N c c ld «D " QY 0.0. 4 '0ld 0 C N m III cc LC I-0e Ql 0 00 e ~C ol0 CD ~ C 0 0 JYn I II! 0 QI QD n 0e

ifuu00700

Well Plat LegendWell Unit W-20

/Page 2

4, Coal

Oil & Gas .Oil & Gas LesseeCoal Lessee .

Coalbed Methane Lessee

Landon R, Wyatt and Wayies R. Harrison,Trustees, Slg Axe Tract 32

. Dianna L. Graham.......,...Hone of RecordIsland Creek Coal CompanyPeimac, Inc.......,...Ituchanan Production Company

4 = 3.12% - 2.50 Acres

5, CoalOil & GssOil & Gas LameCoal Lessee

Coalbed Methane Lessee

. Hugh Macrae Land Trust Tract 11.W,S. Bills, Heirs......Hone of RecordConsolfdadion Coal CompanyIstarrd Creek Coal CompanyPermac, Inc.....,Pocahontas Gas Partnership

5 = 15.61%- 12,49 Acres

6. CoalOil &Gas .Oil & Gas LesseeCoal Lessee,....,..Coalbed Methane Lessee

Hugh Macrae Land Trust Tract 11Permac, I'nc....None of Record...Consolidation Coal CompanyIsland Creek Coal CompanyPermac, Inc....Pocahontas Gas Partnership

6 ~ 33.20% - 26.56 Acres

Page Number 10.

Page 11: 0 C- · 2017-04-14 · CG IPEo ~ 8 Cl NO Gl GP ... T1 Id 0 I-C 0 QlI 0 Gd 5 N c c ld «D " QY 0.0. 4 '0ld 0 C N m III cc LC I-0e Ql 0 00 e ~C ol0 CD ~ C 0 0 JYn I II! 0 QI QD n 0e

Exhibit EUnit W.20

Docket ¹YGOB92.0721-024047List of Respondents remalnfng In Essrow

~r0000700

Net AcresIn Unit

Division of Division of Division ofInterest In 3 - Panel 4 - Panel 5 - Panel

Unit 8.945% 38.891% 33.254%

Treat 88- 12.49 acme

COAL OWNERSHIP

(I) Hugh MacRse Land Tmsl Tr 11c/o Gamp, Skeuss, Akin LLPI Bryant Park, Floor 41New York, NY 10036.6715

12.49 acres 15 6125% 1 0843% 8 0719ok 5 1918%

By Arsignmenl and Brli o/Sale (Gar lease roynay2 HMLT devised aff ol ffsright, liffe end inleretl foiher Ihan Ercluderf Assets I loTorch Enrvgy Advirom inc effective Seplsmhr r 4, I ggl and r«corrlr din Buchanan Counly under OB474/ PGi!Is

Torch Og & Gas Companyr/o Sue Ann Craddock670 Done Ans Road SWDarning, New Mexico 88030

Effective 2/I/It, Torch Od 4 Gas Cnmpnny ossrgned a 2% VRRI io SAC Inveslmer tv, L.p.

Effsctive 3/31/I4, Torclr Oil & Gas Company. el al. assigned and ronvay ed I0% of rls nght hllc and inierr el ln Rorkpori Oil &

Gas L L C. In add lion, Torch Orle Gav Company alai sssryned and ronveyed fha remaining 00% ofrt" nghi lrffe arrienrl rnlerert fo Chrsos, Lld.

Rookport Oil & Gas L.L.C.PO Sox 847Houston, TX 77001

1.25 acresI f10 of 12.49acres

15.612S% 1.0843% 8.0710yo 5.1918%

Chlsos, LTD670 Done Ana Road SWGaming, New Mexko 88030

OIL 8 GAS OWNERSHIP

Unresolved Heirship

11.24 screegll0 of 12.49acres

15.6126% 1.0843'k 8.0719% 5.1018%

(I) W.S. Ellis Heirs, Devlsaes,Successors or Asstgltsc/o James W. Herman, Agent296 TlmberleafBeaveroreek, OH 45430

12.49 acres 15.8125% 1.0843% 6.0719% 5.1018%

Preva¹lng pfentlff under Cess No. 12-294Awarded 100% of the CBN royally.

Total Acreage ln EscrowTalal Percentage In Escrow

12.400016.6126%

Page I of II Ill 0/2016

Page Number 11.

Page 12: 0 C- · 2017-04-14 · CG IPEo ~ 8 Cl NO Gl GP ... T1 Id 0 I-C 0 QlI 0 Gd 5 N c c ld «D " QY 0.0. 4 '0ld 0 C N m III cc LC I-0e Ql 0 00 e ~C ol0 CD ~ C 0 0 JYn I II! 0 QI QD n 0e

Exhibit EEUnit W-20

Docket 0VGOB 924I721AI2404ITList of Respondents wah Royally Spul Agreements/Court Orders/HB2058

i"r'0000700

Net AcresIn Unit

Division ofInterest In 3 - Panel

Unit &945%

Division of Division of4-Panel 6-Panel Percent38.091% 33264% of Escrow

Tract 81 - 25.34 acres

COAL OWNERSHIP

(1) Hugh MacRae Land Trust Tr 11r/o Gump, Strauss, Akin LLP1 Bryant Park, Floor 41New York, NY 10036-0715

25.34 acres 31.6760% 2.1998% 12.3107%%uo 10.5332'/o n(a

By Assign manf and Bill of S tie (Gax leave rnycliy), RML 7 devi sert ail of i/ x right, frr/e nnrf inferrmt (niner Ihnn 'Err/crier/ A xssm'/ roTorrh Energy Advrsors Inc epecirve September 4, fog r and rernrderi ~ r Buchsnsrr Cnunry under OBI/4/ pG381.

Torch 06 & Gss Companyc/o Sue Ann Craddoek870 Dona Ana Road SW

Darning, Nsw Mexico 88030

E//scrive 2/1/11, Torclr Oil 6 Gas Company ass/gned a 2% ORR/ to SAC Invexirnenis, L P.

Eriscr ve 3/31/14, Torh ori 6 Gos cnmpsny, et ai sssignod und conveyed 10% ni its nghl aria ond rnleresl iu Rnckporr or/ 6Gax, L L C. In kdrhriun, Torch Ori 6 Gas Comivrny, et ai. sssrgner/and conveyed Ihs remaining gn% of ris right, hde cndend inlerexi tc Chrsox, Lrd.

Rockporl Og & Ges L.L.C.PO Box 847Houston, TX 77001

2.53 acres1/10 of 26.34 acres

3.1875% 0.2200'4 t.2319% 1.0633% n/s

Chlsos, LTD 22.81 sores670 Done Ans Read SW 9/10 of 25 34 acresDarning, New Mexico 88030

OIL & GAS DWNERSHIP

28.5075% 1.9798% tb08e9% 0.4709%

(1) Boston Cook Heirs, Devlsees,Successors or Assigns

(a) MaryAnn Berlram1639 Nlcolay WayBsBlmore, MD 21201

(b) Thelma Jean Kgrre

3707 Overview DriveFrsderlcksburg, VA 22405

(c) Harold V. CookeP.O. Box 306Oakwood, VA 24831

(d) Leslie K. Cook57'l4 W. Noble ClrdeHomossssa, FL 32840

(e) Mamle K Caok140S06 Watson Lane 61Woodbrklge, VA 22193

25.34 acres

2.53 acres1/ig of 26.34 acres

2.63 acresI/tg of 25.34 acnm

2.53 earns1/10 of 26.34 acres

2.63 sores1/10 of25.34acms

2.63 sofas1/10 of 25.34 acres

31 8750vA

3.1675%

3.1676%

3.1875%

3.1676%

3.1675%

2.200%

0.220%x

0.220%

12.319%

1.232%

1.232%

1.232%

1.232%

1.232%

10.533%

1.053%

1.063%

1.053'ye

1.053%%uk

1.053%

n/a

n/s

n/s

n/s

(f) Robert B.Cook Heirs, Devlsees, Successors, or Assigns

(f.l ) Barbers Cack132Autumn Chase RoadLebanon, VA 24266-4!H5

(9) Nancy C. DulyP.O. Box810Grundy, VA 24614

(h) Betty Lswonne Gibson2117 Old York RoadYork, 6C 20746

2.53 acres1/10 af26.34 acres

2.63 acresI/10 of25.S4 acres

2.53 acres1/10 of 25.34 nares

3.1875%

3.1675%

3.1675%

0.220%

0.220%

0.220%

1.232%

1.232%

1.232%

1.053%

1.053%

n/a

n/e

(I) Kathy Diane Murray

147 Holly Ave.ML Airy, NC 27030

2.53 acres1/10 of 25.S4 acme

3.1876% 0.220% 1.232'yx 1.053% n/a

Page 1 of 5 11/11/2010

Page Number 12.

Page 13: 0 C- · 2017-04-14 · CG IPEo ~ 8 Cl NO Gl GP ... T1 Id 0 I-C 0 QlI 0 Gd 5 N c c ld «D " QY 0.0. 4 '0ld 0 C N m III cc LC I-0e Ql 0 00 e ~C ol0 CD ~ C 0 0 JYn I II! 0 QI QD n 0e

Exhibit EEUnit W-20

Dna ket ¹VGOB 92-07214I2404ITList of Respondents wgh Royalty Spgt Agreements/Court Orders/HB2058

iiU000700

Net AcresIn Unit

Division ofInterest In 3- Panel

Unit 6.945/r

Division of Division of4 - Panel 5 - Panel Perse nl

38.891% 33.284% of Escrow

0) Francis C. Hinohee Slssms14411 North Falnriew LenaWoodbrldge, VA 22191

Tatal tract acresTotal tract percent

Tinct 814 - 0.51acres

2.53 acresI/10 of 25.34 acres

25.340031.8750%

3.1676'4 0.220'4 1.232% 1.063% n/s

COAL OWNERSHIP

(1) Hugh MecRee Lend Trust Tr11do Bump, Strauss, Akin LLP1 Bryant Park. Floor 41New York, NY 10036-8715

0.51 acres 0.63/S% 0.0443% 0.24T9% 0.2120% n/a

By Iirslgnmcrrl nnd Bill of Sale /Gns leave roysny/, HML 7 dsvLred s¹olils rlghl, fitlc nnd inicrcrl /nlhsr lhsn "Excluded As rais') lnTon h Energy Arlvisors Inc efferlrve Snplembsr 4, Igal nnu n'corded in Srichsnnn County under 08474 / PG354

Torch083 GasCompanyc/o Sue Ann Craddock870 Done Ana Rond SWDarning, New Mexico 88030

E¹eohve 2/ill f, Tnrch Oil 4 Gns Coinpcny osugnrd s 2% CRRI lo SAC invcrlnrerds. L.P

Eh'nchve 3/31/Id Torch Crl 3 Gsr Company vl al assigned nnd conveyed 10% clilr nght Irge nrrd intereri io Rcckpcrl 04 3Gss L LC. In sdditron, Torch Cil 3 Gss Ccmpony el el assigned onu convoyed Ihe remaining 00% of its righl Irtlo sndarrrl rnlersrl lo Chi roc, Lid

Rackporl Og 3 Gas L.L.C.PO Box 847Houston, TX 77001

0.05 acresI/10 of 0.61 acres

0.0638% 0.0044% 0.0248'/r 0.0212% nys

Chlsos, LTD6/0 Dona Ana Road SWDarning. New Mexico 88030

OIL B. GAS OWNERSHIP

0.46 acres9/10 of0.51 amus

0.5738% 0.0398% 0.2231% 0 1908r/v n/s

(1) Gsston Cook Heirs, Devlsees,Successors or Assigns

0.51 acres 0.8375% 0.044% 0.248% 0.212%

(s) Mary Ann Barlram1539 Nlcolay WayBagimore, MD 21201

(b) Thelma Jean Kgne3707 Cvswiew DriveFrededcksburg, VA 22408

0.05 naresI/10 of 0.51 acres

0.05 acresI/10 of 0.51 sores

0.0638% 0.004%

0 004%

0.026% 0.021% nys

0.025% 0.021% n/a

(c) Harold V. CookeP.O. Box 305Oakwood, VA 24631

0.05 acresI/10 of 0.51 acres

0.004% 0.025% 0.021% nia

(d) Leslis K. Coak5714 W. Noble CircleHomosassa. FL 32646

(e) Msmle K. Caok140505 Watson Lane ¹IWaodbrldge, VA 22193

D.05 acresI/10 of 0.51 acres

0.05 acres1/10 of 0.61 acres

0.0038% 0.004% 0.025% 0.021% nrs

0.0838% 0.004% 0.025'7 0.021% n/s

(I) Robert B.Cook Heirs, Dsvisees, Successors, or Assigns

(1.1) Barbara Cook132 Autumn Chase RoadLebanon, VA 2428BA545

(g) Nancy C. DulyP.O. Box 816Grundy, VA 24614

O.D5 acres1/10 of 0.51 acres

0.05 acres1/10 of 0.61 ames

0.0838%

O.DB38%

0.004%

0.004%

0.026% 0.021% n/s

0.025% 0.021% nya

Page 2 of 5 11/I I /2016

Page Number (3.

Page 14: 0 C- · 2017-04-14 · CG IPEo ~ 8 Cl NO Gl GP ... T1 Id 0 I-C 0 QlI 0 Gd 5 N c c ld «D " QY 0.0. 4 '0ld 0 C N m III cc LC I-0e Ql 0 00 e ~C ol0 CD ~ C 0 0 JYn I II! 0 QI QD n 0e

Exhibit EEUnit W.20

Doeket6VGOB 924I721-02404ITList of Respondents with Royalty Spgt Agreements/Court Orders/HB2058

>ivu00700

Nst AcresIn Unit

Division ofInternet In 3 - Panel

Unit 6.945%

Division of4-Panel38.891%

Division of5-Panel33254%

Percentof Escrow

(h) Ectly Lswonne Gibson2117 Old Yerk RuedYork, SC 29746

0.05 acresI/10 of 0.51 acres

0.0838% 0.004% 0.02mo 0.021% nle

(I) Kathy Diane Murray

147 Holly Ave.Ml. Airy, NC 27030

5) Francis C. Hlnchee Slesrns14411 North Falrvlsw LaneWcodbridgs, VA 22191

Total tract astraTotal tract ps resort

True/ 63 ~ 12.64scree

0.05 acresI/10 of 0.51 acres

0.05 acresI/10 of 0.51 acres

0.61800.8376%

0.0638%

0.0638%

0.004%

0.004%

0.026%

0.025%

0.021%

0.021%

n/a

nle

COAL OWNERSHIP

T.R. MuUlns, et al., Tr.1 12.64 asres 15.6760% 1.088S% 6.0962% 5.2126'/o

(I) Theodore A. Mugins Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

(e) Theodore Blslne Mu9ins1650 Summa Drive

Charleston, WV 26302-2921

(b) ComeKa Maurice MuKins

P.O. Sox 61Clendenln, WV 25045

(c) MsrKyn MuKlns

10107Park Place Blvd.Eustls, FL 3273a

0.94 acresI/27 of 12.54 acres

0.94 acresI/27 of 12.64 acres

O.S4 acresI/27 of 12.54 acres

1.1731%

1.1731%

1.1731%

0.081%

0.081%

0.081%

OA562% 0.3901% n/a

OA562% 0.3901% nle

OA562% 0.3901% nla

(2) Sandra Gerende303 Barbour Rd, Unlt 901Morehead Cay, NC 28557

(3) John L. 4 LucEle M. MuKins Sr. Heirs, Oevlsees,Successors or Assigns

5.63 acres2/9 of 12.64 acres

7.0389% 0.489% 2.7376% 2.3407% nle

(a) George W. MuKins, Sr.315 Evergreen Hills RdCoKsgevKle, WV 25239-7835

(b) Jc Ann Barker Heirs, Devisees,Successors or Assigns

2.11 acres 2.6396% 0.183% 1.0266'/ O.ST/8% nle1/12 of 12.54 sums

(b.1) Robert Barker Heirs, Dsvisees,Successsors or Assigns

(b.1.1) Thomas Joseph Barker13658 NW 172 AvsAlucha,FL 32616-4463

(b.1.2) Timothy Jahn Barker3854 Hampton Crest Ln

Kennesew, GA 30162-6990

(b.1.3) Elizabeth Baker7745 Lupine DrBlsoklick, OH 430044I062

0.63 acresI/48 of 12.54 sass

0.63 acresI/48 of 12.54 sass

0.53 acresI/48 of 12.54 acres

0.6699'lo 0.046% 0.2566% 0.2194'/o nle

0.55994 0.046% 0.2565% 0.2194o/o n/a

0.6599% 0.046'4 0.2566% 0.2194oA nle

(b.1.4) Jennl/sr Marie Wheeler2151 Easlover Ln

Mlamlsburg, OH 45342-5299

0.63 rrcresI/48 of 12.64 acres

0.6591P/ 0.045% 0.2566% 0.2194% nls

(c) John L Mullns, Jr Heirs. Oevlsees,Successors ar Assigns

Page 3 of 5 11/I I/2016

Page Number 14.

Page 15: 0 C- · 2017-04-14 · CG IPEo ~ 8 Cl NO Gl GP ... T1 Id 0 I-C 0 QlI 0 Gd 5 N c c ld «D " QY 0.0. 4 '0ld 0 C N m III cc LC I-0e Ql 0 00 e ~C ol0 CD ~ C 0 0 JYn I II! 0 QI QD n 0e

Exhlhlt EEUnit W-20

Docket ¹VGOB92-0721 42404ITList of Respondents with Royalty Split Agreements/Court Orders/HB2056

i(0000700

Net AcresIn Unit

Division nf Division of Division olInterest in 3- Panel 4- Panel 6- Panel Percent

Unit %945% 38.591% 33.2644 of Escrow

(c.1) Stephanle Muggns-Wgliems

9409 8th AvenueOrlando, FL 32824

0.63 aurasI/48 of 12.54 acnm

0.8599% 0.046'/o 0.2666% 0.2194% nfo

(c.2) John David Mugins

2209 Falls CirdeVere Beech, FL 32967

0.63 acresI/48 of 12.54acres

0.8599% 0.048% 0.2566% 0.2104% n/a

(c.3) Bamdon Ovsrlon Muglns2736 Tegmen Avs SEPalm Bsy, FL 32909

0.53 acresI/48 of 12.54acres

0.6599% 0.048% 0.2566% 0.2194% nfo

(c.4) Heather L. Dawson317 8royles Dr. SEPalm Bsy, FL 32909

0.53 acresI/45 of 12.64acres

0.6599'/ 0.046'4 0.2556% 0.2194'4 n/o

(d) Thomas L Muglns Heirs, Deviance, Successorsor Assigns

(d.1) Ksds Jones Muglns315Spruce StreetSummersvige, WV 28651

(d.2) Thomas L. Muglns, Jr.PO Box 545Danvgle, VA 25053

(3) Augulus C. Muglns Heirs. Deviance,Successors or Assigns

1.06 acresI/24 of 12.54 sores

1.05 acres1/24 of 12.54scree

1.3198'/o 0.092% 0.5133% 0.4389% nfe

1.3190% 0.092% 0.5133% 0.4389% nls

(s) Madegne Muglns Heirs, Dsvisees,Successors or Assigns

(s.l) Msdsline Hunt

28809 Bennlngton DrWesley Chapel, FL 33544

8.45 acres 10.5553% 0.733% 4.1062% 3.5111'/o nleI/O of1254acres

OIL 5 GAS OWNERSHIP

(I) CNX Gas Campany LLCPO Box 843830Plllshurgh, PA I52644830pmvlouo/y Concolidalfon Cool Company

lyse t ¹4- 2.60 acres

12.54 acres 15.6750% 1.0886% 6.0962% 6.2126% 50.0999%HB2058

COAL OWNERSHIP

(I) H-W Rnsndal, LLC Tr.32P.O. Box I I O0O

Danvgle, VA 24543

OIL E GAS OWNER6HIP

2.50 acres 3.1250% 0.217% 1.215% 1.039yo n/a

(I) Dienna GrahamP. O. Box 395Aylell, VA 23009

Enr¹led ro t¹0%of Ihe Roya/lies

Tract ¹5~ 28.65acres

2.50 acres 3.1260% 0.217% 1.215% 1.039% nfs

COAL OWNER6HIP

(I) Hugh MacRae Lend Trust Tr I Ic/o Gamp, Strauss, Akin LLPI Brirnrlt Perk, Root 41Nsw Yerk, NY tooadertd

26.56 sores 33.2000% 2.3067% 12.9118% 11.0403% nla

Sy Assignment snd Gill of Sole (Gcs Ieccc royc¹y), HIVLT devised clf ofirc right, rifle anrf fnrercrl forhrrr than 'Excluded Aocerc ) foTorch Energy Advroorc lcc effcr rrve Sech mbr r 4, ros r anrf mccrr lcd re Suchonoc Coucry under D8474 / PGJdd

Page 4 of 5 iintnOIS

Page Number (5.

Page 16: 0 C- · 2017-04-14 · CG IPEo ~ 8 Cl NO Gl GP ... T1 Id 0 I-C 0 QlI 0 Gd 5 N c c ld «D " QY 0.0. 4 '0ld 0 C N m III cc LC I-0e Ql 0 00 e ~C ol0 CD ~ C 0 0 JYn I II! 0 QI QD n 0e

Exhlblt EEUnit W-20

Docket SVGOS 824I721-024tngyLiat of Respondents with Royalty Spgt Agrssmsnts/Caurt Orders/HS2058

~/0000700

Net AcresIn Unit

Dlvlslon ofInterest ln 3-Panel

Unit 6.945%

Dlvlslon of4- Panel38.891%a

Division of6-Panel Peraent33S54% of Escrow

Torch Oil 6 Gas Companya/o Sue Ann Craddock670 Dona Ana Road SWDarning, New Mexbo 88030

Effecfrve 2/lf f I, Tnrclr Oil 8 Gns Cnmparry assigned a 2% ORRI to SAC Invr slmr nls, L P.

Effrcli vs 3'3 lite, Torch Oil 8 Gas Company, el nl. assigned ond convoyed f0% ol rls nghl, litle nnrl interest lo Rnckpon Otl 8Gas, L I C. In adr//lrorr, Tnrch Oil 8 Gas Cnmpony, ef al assigned onrl conveyed the rernalrrlng 90% of rts right, Irde anrferrd iitferesl Irf Clti sos. Ltd

Rrmkport OI & Gas L.L.C.PO Sox 847Houston, TX 77001

2.68 soresI/10 of2658awas

3.3200% 0.2306'4 I 2912% 1 1040% nfa

Chlsos, LTD670 Done Ans Road SWDarning, New Mmdso 88030

OIL It GA6 OWNERSHIP

23.90 acres9/10 of 26.68 acres

29.8800% 2.0752% 11.6206% 9.9363% nfa

(1) CNX Gss Company LLC

PO Sox 843830Pittsburgh, PA 15264-3S30Prevlousfy Consalidalion Coal Company

20.56 acres 33.2000% 2.306yt 12.912% 11.040%%ua nia

Total Acreage Resolved 67ABOO

Total Percentage Resolved 84.3125%

!I<K I I'I JhcNT I!1'[00[ID'/'i)[Ii-'F["I![/[YF[l ! Il IH['.',LFi l

".: '.iV[:.ILCL. III

I I h A I I I I C [II I

Hr! I L.,I,/II! i EI I Ocf:~'"*rA[r[

ILfl Y IT[I t[ !, I [ [I:r f,l!~P,L/[.I'-I(:

[/[334'age

5 of 5 11/11I2016

Page Number 16.