FEBRUARY...ESTIMATED N)DITIONAL MONIES TO BE GENERAT'ED tsY PROPOSED FEES WITH SOME SUPPORTING DATA Line Item 2.8 2.9 3.2 Subtotal Line Item 4.7 4.8 Subtotal Total of Renewal Fees

FEBRUARY 6

Sunday, February 6, 2005

2zOO p.m. to 4:00 p.n.

Earl- Ray Tomblinex officio nonvoting member

Senate

Min:rrl f-hri rr-,,*-.,nanUngerBoIeyMinear Absenc

Leqisl-ative Rul-e-MakingReview Commi-ttee(Code S29A-3-10)

Robert \\Bob" Kissex officio nonvoting member

Eouse

Mahan, ChairmanPalumbo, Vice Chaj-rmanUA]III

.H.INO

ArmsteadA*r^ r.i - ^{- ^*v v s! lrrv uvrr

The meet.ing was call-ed to order by Ms. Mahan, Chairman.

The minutes of the January 6, 2005, meeting were approved.

Connie Bowling, Associate Counsel, reviewed her abstract onthe rule proposed by the Board of Risk and Insurance Managenent,Patient rnjury conpensation E'und, 115csR?, stated that the Boardhas agreed to technical- modifications and responded to guestionfrom the Committee.

Chuck Jones, Execut.ive Director with the Board of Risk andInsurance Management responded to question from the Committee.

Mr. Armstead moved that Subsections 6.2 and 6.3 of theproposed rul-e be modified. The motion was adopted.

Mr. Mj-nard moved that the proposed rul_e be approved asmodified. The moLion was adopted.

Ms. Bowling explained her abstract on the rul-e proposed by theWest Virginia State PoJ.ice, I{VSP Career Progression Systern, 81CSR3.

Mr. Minard moved that the proposed rule be approved. Themotion was adopted.

Joe AItizer, Assocj-ate Counsel-, reviewed his abstract of therul-e proposed by t.he Division of Air Quality, per:nits forConstruction and Major Modification or Major Stationary Sources ofAir Pollution for the Prevention of Sigmificant Deterioration(PDS) ' 45CSR14 and responded to suestions from the Committee.

Laura Crowder, with the Department of Environmental-Prof ar-l- i nn niVision Of Air Or:a I i tv- re! !vLs\-L--L\rrrr uJ-VJ-sJ-oD ol Ar- yes!+ er, --sponded to questions f romthe Committ.ee.

Mr. Mi-nard moved that the proposed rule be approved. Themotion was adopted.

Mary Wifdfire, with CALP, addressed the Committee.

Mr. Altizer explained his abst.ract of the rule proposed by theDivision of Air Quality, Permits for Construction and t'f"io=Modification or Major Stationarl, Sources of Alr pollution WtrichCause or Contribute to Nonattainment, 45CSR19.

Mr. Minard moved that tho nrnnnco6l rule be approved.motion was adopted.

The

Rita Pauley, Associate Counsel, reviewed her abstract of therule proposed by the West Virginia Board of Dental- Examiners, Rulefor West Virginia Board of Dental Exrrniners, 5CSR1, stated that theBoard has agreed to technicat modifications and responded toquestions from the Committee.

John Parkulo, Executive Secretary, with the Board of Dental-Examiners responded to question from the committee.

Mr. Minard moved that the proposed rure be approved asmodified. The motion was adopted.

Ms. Pauley explained her abstract of the rul-e proposed by theWest Virginia Board of Dental- Exarniners, Formation and ApprovaL ofProfessiona]- Linited Liabi1ity Companiss, 5CSR2, sLated that theBoard has agreed to technical modifications and responded toquestions from the Committee.

Mr. Minard moved that the proposed rule be approved asmodified. The motj_on was adopted.

Ms. Pauley reviewed her abstract of the rul-e proposed by theWest Virginia Board of Denta1 Exarniners, For:rnation and Approva]. ofProfessional I,irnited Lialrility Conpanies, 5CSR3 and responded toquesti-ons f rom the Committee.

Mr. Parkul-o distributed handouts relating to the Board'sfinances and responded to questions from the committee.

Ms. Boley moved that the proposed rule be laid over untiLTuesday, February B, 2005. The motion was adopted.

Ms. Pauley explained herTlest Virginia Board of Dental.Dental Corl>orations, 5CSR6,technical modifications andCommittee.

abstract of the rule proposed by theExartriners r For:mation and Approval ofstated t.hat the Board has agreed to

responded to guestions from the

Mr. Minard moved that the proposed rule be approved asmodi-fied. The motion was adopted.

Ms. Pauley reviewed her abstract of the rul-e proposed by theFanily Protection Service Board, Perpetrator Intervention PrograrnsLicensure for Correctional. Institutions, 191CSR5, stated that theBoard has agreed to technical modificatj-ons and responded toquestions from the Committee.

Mr. Minard moved that the proposed rul-e be approved asmodified. The motion was adopted.

The meeting was adjourned.

FEBRUARY TnTBnTiu ATTENDANCELegislative Interim MeetingsFebruary 6, 7, and 8, 2005

,/

-

Debra Graham

Please return to Brenda in Room r3z-Eor Fax to 3474g1g.

Sunday. February 6.2005

2:00 - 4:00 p.m.

Earl Ray Tomblin, exofficio nonvoting member

SenateMinard, ChairUnderBoleyMinear

Robert S. Kiss, exofficio nonvoting member

HouseMahan, ChairPalumbo, Richard, Vice ChairCannPinoArmsteadOverington

Legislative Rule-lVlaking Review Committee

_tr/.

€-7-,,_.-

--.- --j.;-n--1:-- -_F-- -r-

. I -:_ l

l4'w!L

,'"'i//n

ni' .

TEIiTEATTW AGENDALEGISI,ATTVE RI'LE-INKING REVIETV COMMITTEE

Sunday, February 6, 2OOs2:OO p.m. to 4:00 p.m.

House Judiciary Conmittee Room

1. Approval of Minut'es - Meetino of ,Tanuary 10, 2005

2. Review of LegisJ-ative RuJ-es:

fl1op,o od fr ;:il:":' #;:,?:#;::il= H::n"""A.g yt?odt nicd' 115CSR7

: H;:::: as Morriried

A n-{ Tlest Virginia State poticeHpnf+eF wvsP Career Progression system

B7CSR3

. Layover

. Atrrprove

A I L{ Division of Air euatiryrlPPaoc(/v ?r#:::,":;' r::::::" :;';i, ";:, {:J::, 2f ':;:' ;::,"",:r r::j ZiSignificant Deterioration (PSD)4 5CSR14

. Approve

n t{ Division of Air eraal-ityf*qorAF'AU Permits for Construction and lulajor Modification of Major

Stationary Sources of Air PoJ-l-ution Whieh Cause or Contributeto Nonattainment4 5CSR1 9

. Approve

ft@rtu rL{,ffi: ::",":;:',::?";r*rH:=:"*TFili.", Examiners,4 rnod4Vd . scsR1

t-a

U . Approve as Modified

l-*mAarl *t"f

West Virginia Board of Dental_ ExaminersFormation and Approvaf of professional_Companies5CSR2

Approve as

Linited LiabiJ_itv

West Virginia BoardFees EstabJ-ished by5CSR3

Modified

of Denta]. Exaninersthe Board

Approve as Mor{i fied

lt lb t-rF - â West *=nrrra Board, of Dentaf f,sami ag3s

' Formation and Approvar- of Dentaf corporationsl-b.fY.Pv- lla-l Ar tFo t ,taw" -f v ^)tu'- 5CSR6

^FW

sP- . Approve as Morti fied

rrrr.kJ ;H::,::::T"T::,ffil#'" ::;:*, Licensure ror Correctionardl|* Institutions

tl/ |0,8 191-CSR5

Approve as Morli fied

3. Other Business

t- FTBRUARY INTERIM ATTENDAI{CELegislative Interim Meetings

Sunday 617rand8, 2005

Sgnday. February 6o 2005

2:00 p.m- - 4:00 p.m.

Earl RayTomblin, exoffi cio nonvoting me,mber

Minard" ChairVice Chair

Legislative Rule-Making Review Commit.tee

Robert'Tfob" Kiss, exoffi cio nonvoting me,mber

House

MaharU ChairPalumbo, Vice ChairCannPinoArmsteadOverington

'L*4y'*-tz-

UngerBoleyMinear

-----t--{z----v_v

l5-essa=ifu";a_

:Jsa-45 (snN

d- b-gtt-estE+s --- --1

?rntrlin*)_

r.-.. tj

f

/o

o

o

TENTATTW AGENDALEGISI,ATI\IE RIIIJE-INKTNG REVIE;}I COM}4ITTEE

Sunday, February 6, 20052:00 p.m. to 4:00 p.m.

Eouse ilurliciary Connrittee Room - 418M

1. Approval- of Minutes - Meef incr nf ,Tanuary 10, 2005

2. Review of LegisJ-ative Ru1es:

a. Board of Risk and Insurance I'tanagernentPatient Injury Compensa tion Fund1 15CSR7

b. IVest Virginia Sta.te poJ-iceWVSP Career Proqression SvstemB7CSR3

c. Division of Air QualityPermits f or Construction and Ma jor lulodif ication of Maj orStationary Sources of Air PoJ-l-ution for the Prevention ofSignificant Deterioration (PSD)45CSR14

d. Division of Air QsatityPermits for Construction and Major Modification of MajorStationary Sources of Air Pol-Lution Which Cause or Contributeto Nonattainment4 5CSR1 9

e. West Virginia Board of Dental. ExarninersRufe for the V{est Virginia Board of Dental_ Examiners5CSR1

f. West Virginia Board of Dental ExarninersFormation and Approvaf of Prof essionaL Linited Liabil-itvCompanies5CSR2

g. West Virginia Board of Dental. Exa'ninersFees Establ_ished bv the Board5CSR3

h. West Virginia Board of Dental- ExaminersFormation and. ApprovaJ_ of Dental_ Corporations5CSR6

J-/-

o

o

i. Fa'niJ.y Protection Service BoardPerpetrator Intervention Programs Licensure for Correctional_Institutions191CSR5

3. Other Business

TEIiW;ATTW AGENDALEGTSLATNZE RI'LE-IAKING REVIEW COMMIITEE

Sunday, February 6, 20052:OO p.m. to 4:00 p.m.

House Jurli ciary Comittee Room

1. Approval of Minutes - Meetino of ,Tanuary 10, 2005

2. Review of LegisJ-ative Rules:

a - Board of Risk and Insurance ManagenentPatient Injury Compensation Fund1 1 5csR7

. Layover' Approve as Morli fied

b. West Virginia State poJ.iceWSP Career progression SystemBlCSR3

. tayover

. Approve

c. Division of Air eual-ityPermits for Construction and Major Modification of MajorStationary Sources of Air Pol-lution for the Prevention ofSignificant Deterioration (pSD)4 5CSRl4

. Approve

d. Division of Air eual.ityPetmits for Construction and Major Modification of MajorStationary Sources of Air Pofl-ution Which Cause or Contributeto Nonattainment4 5CSR1 9

. Approve

e. West Virginia Board of Dental ExarninersRuIe for the West Virginia Board of Dental- Examiners5CSRl

. Approve as Morrified

f. West Virginia Board of Dentat f,3ami1s3sFormation and ApprovaJ- of Professionaf Linited LiabiLitvCompanies5CSR2

Approve as Modified

g. West Virginia Board of Dental Ex:rninersFees Establ_ished by the Board5CSR3

Approve as Modified

h. West Virginia Board of Dentat f,samingjsFormation and Approval_ of Dentaf Corporations5CSR6

Approwe as Modified

i. FaniJ-y Protection Service BoardPerpetrator Intervention Programs Licensure for CorrectionalInstitutions1 91CSR5

' Approve as Morti fied

3. Other Business

Proposed modification to 115 CSR 7:

6.2. Subject to the provisions of section 6.3 of this rule, the amount payable by the fundto a qualified claimant is the amount of uncollectible economic damages. Indetermining the amount of uncollectible economic damages, payments of availableinsurance in the underlying professional medical liability action are considered tohave been applied first to satisfy any economic damages award.

6.3. The maximum amount payable out of the fund in respect to any one occurrence,inclusive of attorney fees, shall be the lesser of one million dollars or the maximumamount of money that could have been collected for all applicable insurance priorto the creation of the Fund. For purposes of this rule, amounts payablb by anyinsurance guarang funds due to the insolvency of an insurance company aredeemed applicable insurance.

JUNE 30,2OOO

JtrNE 30, 2001

JLNE 3O,2OO2

JLINE 30,2OO3

JUNE 30,2004

SEPTEMBER 30,2OOO

SEPTEMBER 30,2OO1

SEPTEMBER 30,2OO2

SEPTEMBER 30, 2OO3

SEPTEMBER 30,2OO4

CASH BALANCE COMPARISON

700,620.16

87,890.1 1

70,291.59

78,890.43

72,909.08

<o 5?5 ??Jt)J-J.J-

40,635.97

27,270.28

26,049.44

18,624.97

ESTIMATE OF REVENUE BY REVENUE SOURCE

Fiscal Year 2005

Page No.

Amendment Date

Amendment No.

WVFIMS Account No

I I npprooriated Federal Funds Accounls (Listed in Budget Act)

I llpptopriated Special Revenua Accounts (Listed In Budget Act)

lr _I Jederal Block Grants (Listed in Budget Act)

l--l o,nu, Federal Funds

I ry | otner Special Revenue Accounts

enonrtinn tlnit W Board of Dental Exaninqs

Mis. Boards ard CormissitrrsDepartment/Bureau of:

Revenue Name

licsse lgg,.afs of Dsrtisrs

Ftthd x\/t

2m50909

FY

org

Name of Account: Dsrtisl,Dstal t[€isri.+s OFFrating Erri

Total Revenue --%? tW'n=---

Form ES-2A

ESTIMATED N)DITIONAL MONIES TO BE GENERAT'ED tsY PROPOSED FEESWITH SOME SUPPORTING DATA

Line Item

2.8

2.9

3.2

Subtotal

Line Item

4.7

4.8

Subtotal

Total of Renewal Fees

Line Item

2.7

2.3

4.1

4.3

Total of Application Fees

Line Item

7.1

7.2

Total of Licensure Verification fees

GRANT TOTAL

Additional Monies Estimated

17,525

26,175

14,700

59,400


10,530

14,940

25,370

93,770


2,500.00

3,750.00

1,500.00

1,r25.00

500.00

9,375.00

Additional Monies Es t=mated

1,200.00

2,500.00 - 5,000.00

3,700.00 - 6,200.00

96,845.00 - 990345.00

1. Renting/relocation costs

2. Additional legal expenses

3. Increased costs associated with trvo additional board members

4. Anticipated Costs of Hiring aHearing Examiners

5. Increase Costs of Insurance Premiums

6. Future consideration to salary increases to employees

Rental 7,200 - 74,400 estimated

Relocation 5.000 estimated

Two additional board members 10, 000 estimated

Legil,Expenses 4,000 - 10,000 estimated

Hearing Exarniners 20,000 - 50,000 estimated

lnsurance Premiums (PEIA & BRIM) 4,000 estimated

2 Additional Meetings 14,000 estimated

Computer Equipment 2,000 - 5,000 estimated

Meeting Costs - divided by number traveled

57t6.14 l9 : 635.13

643L76 18 : 803.97

4440.84 19 : 493.43

3280.17 l5 : 656.03

3932.37 l5 : 786.45

estimated meeting costs per year with 4 meetings 77,763 - 28,942

Number of Active Licensees

Total Dentists in State

SpecialistsGeneral

Total Dentists out of State

SpecialistsGeneral

Total HYgienists in State

Totat Hygienists living in State not practicing

Total HYgienists out of State

Expanded Duties Certiflcates lssued

Assistants Restorative & Orthodontic Duties

Hygiene Local Anesthesia

Hygiene Monitoring Nitrous Oxide

Hygiene Bleaching

thesehygienistshaveactive|icensesbutdidnot|istanemployerordonotpractice

851

145706

38948

341

717174236

8

1

FEBRUARY 8

Sunday, February 8, 2005

2:OO p.m. Lo 4:00 p.n.

Earl- Ray Tomblinex officio nonvoting member

Senate

Minard, ChairmanH-ann 1 nd

PreziosoUngerBoIeyMinear Absent

Legislative Rul-e-MakinqReview Committee(Code 529A-3-10)

Robert "Bob" Kissex officio nonvoting member

House

Nr-r.-- atL-; --wtdIIdIl, uItd.IrttlanPa I rrmhn - \/i r-e Chairman, v 4vL

CannPinoArmsteadf)rrari naf nn

The meetj-ng was called to order by Mr. Minard, Chairman.

The minutes of the January II, 2005, meeting were approved.

Patrick Campbell, with the West Virginia Department ofEnvironmental- Protection, gave a presentation and distributedhandouts on the cause and status of state fish consumption warningbecause of excess mercury in fish. Mr. campberr responded toquestions from the Committee.

Edward M. Snyder, Ph. D., Envi-ronmental Quality Board Chair,discussed and distribut.ed handouts on the Board proposal regardingthe mercury water quality standard and new manganese standard. Mr.Snyder answered questions from the Committee.

Joe Aftizer, Associate Counsel, explained his abstracts on therule proposed by the Environmental- Qual.ity Board, RequirenentsGoverning rfater Qgality Standards, 46csR1 (August 2Q, 2004 andSeptember 29, 2004) and responded to questions from the Committee.

Ms. Mahan moved that the August 20, 2004, version of the rul-ebe withdrawn. The rnoti_on was adooted.

Ms. Mahan moved that the September 29, 2004, version of therule be modified to include the provisions of the version of therul-e that had been filed on August 20, 2004. The motion wasadopted.

Ms. Mahan moved that the proposed rul-e be approved as modified

Joe Altizer, Associate Counsel, explained his abstract on therul-e proposed by the Office of lVater Resources, National PoJ.J.utantDischarge Elirnination System (NPDES), 47CSR10, stated that theOffice has agreed to technical modifications and responded toguestions from the Committee.

Bill Brannon with the Office of Waste Management, RobertwiIliams, Executj-ve secretary-Treasurer, with the west VirginiaFarm Bureau, Mark Harman with the west virginia poultryAssocj-ation, and Joe Do11ie, General counser, with the Departmentof Environmental- Protection addressed the Committee and respondedto guestions.

Mr. Unger moved that the rule be modified to remove theprovisions regarding the permitting of farmers throughout theproposed rule. The motion was adopted.

Ms. Mahan moved that the proposed rule be approved asmodi-fied. The motion was adopted.

Debra Graham, Chief Counsel, reviewed her abstract on the ru1eproposed by the West Virginia Heal-th Care Authority, Benchrnakingand Discount contract RuJ.e, 65csR26, stated that the Agency hasagreed to technical- modifications and responded to questions fromthe Committee.

Ms. Mahan moved that the proposed rul_e be approved asmodified. The motion was adocted.

Rita Pauley, Associate Counsel, explained her abstract on theru1e proposed by the Board of Dent,al. Exarniners, Fees Established bythe Board, 5CSR3 and responded to guest.ions f rom the Cornmittee.

John Parkulo, Executive Secretary, with the Board of DentalExaminers distributed handouts regarding the Board's budget.

Mf . l'3np i nn mnrrad f hrt- t- ha nrnnnggd fUle be appfOVed aSmodi fied.

Mr. Fanning requested unanimous consent that he be allowed towithdraw his mot.ion. There being no objections the motion waswithdrawn.

Mr. Parkulo explained the handouts and responded to questionsfrom the Committee.

Ms. Mahan moved that the Board be requested to withdraw theproposed rul-e based on the Committees determinat.ion that the 30 t.o40 percent overall fee j-ncreases were not warranted by the agenciesexpenses. The motion was adopted.

Mr. Minard moved that staff be directed to prepare the reportand bills of authorization for introduction. The motion wasadopted.

The meeting was adjourned.

TEMTATIW AGENDALEGISI,ATI\IE RIIf,E-IAKING REVIEIT COMI4TTTEE

Tuesday, February 8, 2OOs2:00 p.m. to 4:00 p.m.

Eouse ilurri ciarT Committee Room 418M

1. IVater Q,ua1ity Standards Study

A. Mercury

1 - Presentations on cause and status of state fishconsumption warning because of excess mercury in fish:Bret Preston- Department of Natural Resources, Barbara Taylor,Department of Heal-th and Pat Campbell Department of EnvironmlntalProtection.

2- Presentation by Dr. Ed Snyder chairman and Dr. ScottSimonton, vice-chairman of Environmental Quality Board on Boardproposals regarding mercury water quarity standard.

O b. Dranganese

1 - Presentations by Dr. Snyder, Dr. Taylor and arepresentative from the Department of Environmental protectionregarding the DEP proposar for new manganese standard.

2. Review of LegisJ.ative RuLes:

a. West Virginia Environnenta3- eual.ity BoardRequirements Governing Water euality Standards4 6CSR1

b. West Virginia Environmental eual.ity Board.Requirements Governing Water eual_ity Standards4 6CSR1

c. Office of Water Resources - DEpNational- Pol-Tutant Discharge Erinination system (NZDES)4 7CSR1 O

d. West Virginia Health Care AuthorityBenchmaking and Discount Contract RuJe55CSR2 6

e. West Virginia Board of Dental ExarninersFees EstabLished bV the Board5CSR3

3. Other Business

Direct staff to prepare report and bil1s of authorization fori-ntroduction.

TENTATTW AEENDALEGISI,ATWE RI'LE-I4AKING REVIETY COMMITTEE

Tuesday, February 8, 20052:OO p.m. to 4:00 p.m.

Eouse Judiciary Committee Roon

1. IVater Qsa].ity Standards Study

A. Mercury

1. Presentations on cause and status of state fishconsumption warning because of excess mercury in fish:

Bret Preston- Department of Natural Resources, Barbara Taylor,Department of Health and Pat Campbel-l Department of EnvironmentalProtection.

2. Presentation by Dr. Ed Snyder chairman and Dr. ScottQimnnr^- -'+:e-chairman of Environmental Quality Board on Boardv4rltvrruvrrt v r\

proposals regarding mercury water quality standard.

b. I'langanese

1. Presentations by Dr. Snyder, Dr. Taylor and arepresentative from the Department of Environmental Protectionregarding the DEP proposal_ for new manganese standard.

Review of Legis1ative Ru1es:

a. Flest Virginia Envirorunental- Qual-ity BoardRequirements Governing Water QuaJ-ity Standards4 6CSR1

2.

h

. Approve

West Virginia Environ:nentaL Qual.ity BoardRequirements Governinq Water QuaLity Standards4 6CSRI

. Approve

Office of Vlater Resources - DEP/Vational- PoJ-l-utant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES)47CSRlO

. Layover

. Approve as Modified

d. West Virginia Health Care AuthorityBenchmaking and Discount Contract RuLe65CSR2 6

. Layover' Approve as Morli fied

e. West Virginia Board of Dental Exa'ninersFees EstabLished bV the Board5CSR3

. Layover' Approve as Morlified

3. Other Business

Direct st-aff rn nr^nare report and bills of authorization forintroduction.

FEBRUARY INTERIM ATTEI\DANCELegislative Interim MeetingsFebruary 6, 7, and. 8, 2005

Tuesday. February 8. 2005

2:0O - 4:00 p.m.

Earl Ray Tomblin, exofficio nonvoting member

SenateMinard, Chairun&rBo/"vMinear

Robert S. Kiss, exofficio nonvoting member

HouseMahan, ChairPalumbo, Richard, Vice ChairCannPinoArmsteadOverington

Legislative Rule-Makine Review Committee

7-v+-vG.r,-*.1

^Jt'r'<,2-logr.

Debra Graham

Please return to Brenda in Room I3Z-Eor Fax to 3474g19.

b/

'/t/

-,,4.

*oh

".. ,i.. .; lf-;.1 t1.:1i:-,1-' :,

: - ii.it,1..lt ,

:::: -:i::rrr!: :

i :-iP..'::::'i'l r]}.;:::. i

,,",. lr.'n_i t,. l.,'l "-

t: : =t,, ,

ii.,,l.;i".,ll1l'

';i,l:.,r.,[

"+ ,t :. '." ,::"

'':, I I", ,,:::[.I r.:1.,:r: . _i:

'a.:i ,t.| ,: .r .,

,';,;;-i:r::.;I

::i.,1 .j :t .;r. lu

:,;:':t-',: l:..+:]r-.'a+, *]

'- , ':::t-1.. -:.1:'l€:ti';r !..

';'j ':'' ,-,i.r".,',; r

lLi 1 -' tl)

":' ;":,';jl: '.': "t l

., ::. {::" ::::;,;:-r1: ',',,:.. '. - 'o: ,r'-' :1

' :r-. :.1

:;:t.:i"

',ti'i:'::,;:"" : ''-' ,,rî'l tt.'.l ! io,

.'* I',-,1

- :.i:'il:.: :

"jn,,,:+:,.i,: *''.t F.-.: ;-;'| : ''-t,;' ,' i s,'., , :.ii:i'.:-. ]:#l

+.,:,;:r,.'.,, n

i':!:,ri:::. +...: l, l"::'i :ilt-1

"rl tj:.-

,l.i-i.tt- ' ,'i, -+.-.-i',i

, i: "f-:-:..1-

,1'1,i1. 1.!.,

..... tt* i*: :f,*,+,i;:-f'::-'.1:r,-'-.i,:t

iitt, -,:.. I

:... rt#i+,i:i ;:. ,..

. i',r-+:;'r :. ''-..'t*: i ,'W""..,11?' ,=llS

.t?-:: J ',,4 I ':v:'1!(W

t^

.;-i,i::,,1i; :;,,:i;.,

I ll r::: .;,.. :.1.i. r:! . ol- 'i 1..' :;.r l-. l il* ,rl"r1 t,,,;1.,

ti. 1 r! .' -l -i. 1 ;:-i,,, -i' T: :'::lt t :r ;,.,*,

r-iil;; f ' "'.1 ::';,:"iF,1 fi';

t t.., ,'=.'.u

:r ?';-,{',.,:.:.

E.:r..:

{ ffi'*!.tt:: r'i, ":, i,1' ''tir, 't ,- ,.," I

".',: :';ir- P -l; ;t:.'

F r;-;.jt: ,ir '", ^l

i,-r,,,1'r,,i.",F t ttuJ F\r.'t ' ,---(!- q

.,t.-:-:,.*

_., ir.-, o' ,],,-i'i":.

1,'n,n:.'

il

iirt{:rr,,.,-.j,,r:1i!,1 r.; . :::, : a:r -:i -, i.- li- .'t

,...:t:a't;,:$. i':l-'.,,1,;':'.-*;F,o lA,v-YS5!,irl

ll:!'

' l ,, ri; - ,..,, "' ;:l:- i;:ila: ..:j,giiJ

i.l, r- 'i 4."

. .-..1,, .: '. ''v:i ,. L.i,,.!:. i:ri

i-. 'ali

' ;-.i-.o- -'

,:* ".'., :' . -'tt, .,

-i, ''-:F.ir,;i'i. I ':',:i l, '::;':io,;:',:;'i:l't;i llf

!F.'i,r '. - !{

*' ,,itjj:-;-: - '*r

rt tt ..:.;t-..,:I"

i.tf,.=,-0.t, '1.;",

l1'l 'l -"- ,l:-, riir.. ,;"1,'

-,:i'.?f':;j.,:f-"1:,irr' i :,i

Jt'jltt

.. :-,.:

"'.,'

,;;* :.

t ,i'; I .l:, i'l1,iS:

;F,l',,ii,].l:i::-:!'r:r'

i;i*i,;,:.! ,,.ri'Ii :'' : '. r,i: "..

it ', . -.., 1.

*,,-. ., ,l : . !;: llla,i - r 1.a: I"'Y..a; : :, : . i_'. :i '::i

: i : .,,:al'

',:-':;'-;':li;,.:'"$'". _:: ,s:i .. r+'.' ,i I l:i:r i'r ii

.i.: ,1.

tli,,.!: . ::: ,; .+. '::t+t:ii, ,5'''ii 'i':'',..,i....'i:.:;,tnj- t:," ;,.ii '. .i::r.

,,;.,.ta.,...','tt.: .., ''t -:' "]*'t. 'u 1.- :. :i

i .: l

...:: ,' l'o-l

::: :.,:'.. - :iri+r:+'l :'

l':- : ljl.i -a:.: t l.at!:i i ;{:,:+. "'llI

,:.,.,]'i:.l:tr' : j;.''4i;.":; '..," ,, ],t ,Y

Pclglp.,,.5f2 'eqry{lft},'i t ,

"tt. ,' t^

i,i:,i;.-i:l.-:t..ri:i .

r ,,jir,:;

.]::-:t;lr;' :l, f::+.i. .,*.,: : ..r ,

ij:,.,,Ii:llii-:.1,:+i::lil

:::': :' a,;

ri

''a\a{. .;'-,-Fi :,r ,

'":::l:.a

;":,,:,-

-t r:l . .' ,-:; t'

.'.,: lr,:'l, a'j,T'it',ri

":4:;r=

i:: lr:; :

,;t, , .*,'i r, i;..:, t .,,' .'r' " ''l:., il]},. ir l'.:'::r i

:a -'! :1 ; .:-,:il' ti ,'' l':'

_'.-t: i I _ i:- 't -. !.,:l

{ri::1,;'..1:'..1.1.l.:,,; t:,,1i-1,,': ;i'.. : j: l:.:,.

:11.1":,*,,,,,_.'i :F

II ,"ff,Y: ::.

,}

,, t-',f,=fl 5F ,Jrawtt $=..

r"'Tt}tc.d* ":,1!,Fiit:

ta

;;j;.L i:' 'r.,;J}. ,:-

:.:,*j.t:r:itr: r:

ti#:'i :' l. t . t'. , ' ,,.'

., r- i t-t;, * z.\{r:;iY

'flT,w,.+,',11i:....'r'','' :;"

'l l!,:ilri": ;'-::

. "-i F.t'lli:-: "-r.

ryr.

' ,.t{,' -r ,l

. ,.,1 , .11 :'r i

",;1.;r; '.': jT r-'': :i"i -:: j:

:r'. i'lt-. .".j

,, )i"7 Yit--..'.r4.*+- ", -r:1

-i .'.1: +..- : ,i- -" _.,,, . =rj* ;];;. -' ;, 111 ..-ti

,re'{'. ry-'fl,:,. ',,." , :i tt* '-,, t. .* '- 1." 11:

-t ,,

* t, , -":a-., ,, ,'

,"..

T., ,'_t ,r, . l , ttr .t;: ,.rl

"v,r| 1 r

'.: '.-.r5i i' -, tlt;

.

',.-,t..,1t':=.!''"I: : :r .: .-al,'1,,!.1-.. j'

:r-..;',1+'...,1i,,', -i;:!.::.:\':+tr::-:]4 1. j ,::j:

^ 1t/?',f/,n( 7 YW,'

, ,*",1 .,,,;j .l -:.,t.i,i

oir]--'. -' ' ' :i

,,,"1'1'

i*|."t" : .t'u ",i ,

c.',i:..,

n6t-J.I fli..1'r,, ,irt. : t,l-j '

i.i' ..

'*l1r.i;:

:.:::1:..t.,.

.':JiU,;,,:l l'l-- , ., I:, ':{

1,=,fl:,,,.:ti''

"tjLi:,.';':4i;iil:- il" ' 'iii -:;

'*1,:-F; '., ,Ir.i-

/

I{ater Qual-ity Standards Study

A. Mercuzy

1. Presentations on cause and status of state fishconsumption warning because of excess mercury in fish:

Bret Preston- Department of Natural Resources, Barbara Taylor,n^h^-**ent of Health and Pat Campbell Department of EnvironmentalusI/a! Lrrt\

Protection.

2. Presentation by Dr. Ed Snyder chairman and Dr. ScottSimonton, vice-chairman of Environmental- Quality Board on Boardproposals regarding mercury water quality standard.

It b. Manganese

1. Presentations by Dr. Snyder, Dr. Taylor and arepresent.ative from the Department of Environmental Protectionregarding the DEP proposal for new manganese standard.

2. Review of LegisJ-ative Rules:lt

,.,J^ J/ IVest virginia Environmental Qua:.ity Board Sep| eqA..nntV' o ),,4 Requirements Governinq Water QuaLity Standards Ucralq/.tulllv' tlwHfl ngt' 46csR1

.t I n rhb ,. ' Approve a \ pcld;{l @6L-

l-/l-/

A .cv ^t)\-8. West Virginia Environmental Qual.ity Board \\A'-. l(0 Requirements Governing Water Qual-ity Standards ..bYo r\d' 46csR1 ^ I drr'c;6lq1

lJ\ +ourr(r rtuqult I n -L<f4f au--t. Approve

I . Office of Water Resourc,es - DEPNational- Pol-l-utant Discharqe ETimination System (NPDES)4 7CSR1 O

t f{1'

tl | . Layover0P ' APProve as Modified

d?'5

TEIiTEATTW AGENDALEGISI,ATWE RI'LE-!4AKING REITIEE{ COM!fiTTEE

Tuesday, February 8, 20052:OO p.m. to 4:00 p.m.

Eouse iludiciary Cornm.ittee Roon

,/

. I{ater Oua]-itv Stanr{ards Strrdrr

n0,ff^'r*'r

MWest Virginia Health Care AuthorityBenchmaking and Discount Contract Rufe6sCSR2 6

. Layover

. Approve as Modlfied

West Virginia Board of Denta1 ExarninersFees EstabJ-ished bv the Board5CSR3

a

a

LayoverApprove as Mor{i fied

3. Other Business

Direct staff to prepare report and bills of authorization forintroduction.

TIEBRUARY INTERIM ATT.'ENDAI{CELegistative Interim Meetings

Sunday 617rand8, 2005

Tuesday. tr'ebruary 8n 2005

2:00 p.m. - 4:00 p.m. Legislative Rule-Making Review Committee

Earl RayTomblin, exoffi cio nonvoting me,mber

Robert ooBob" Kiss, exoffi cio nonvoting me,mber

Senate

#t*4, Ur-r,flnnr#urB<roeA_UngerBoleyMinear

5y'.+

House

Mahan" Chair ,/Palumbo, Vice ChairCannPinoArmsteadOverington

- Jo<.

14\'

ylYt"

_'l.L.,,1

Dg,P: \rJcr&e{'caAA

r Bi-tt

[o,snrrar-S- ^f'106&-lo - -

\D\rl- *Xr.ir.B .|rcon'.-$"* sr4-

. ^ | furp.fr nJo* Do\li. .,qno*rrryl: , -"1 Laf - 1.^.sg*}^J1-,

It

-ff\ove.{ -cS tc\st

l.

I

o

o

16 rg 1S 1S5 1S7 1S lgmmr @@fw

s%

:ffi

=d 25%

?ieit; r0%t

FfuME]

I

oIA

...includes ORSAI\ICO

ations in WV

Fish Tissuepling

o

tulercury M6t Stringent Scenario

o

o

PCBS: Most Stringent Scenario

o*""@*"*"o-""*o*"-*@*-*,o-*-

I

o

o

l.

West Virginia Fish Consumption Advisorres Page I of6

WV - DHHR - BPH - OEHS - FISH DHHR Site Search - DHHR Site MaP

WV Fish Consumption Advisories

(back to Advisory Page)

\ryesl Virginia Current Fish Advisories

Sections:Suggested Meal SizesGeneral AdvisoriesRestrictave Advisories

Fish Consumption Advisories Available for 2OO5

The West Virginia Department of Health and Human Resources (DHHR) has updated the West Virginia sport fishconsumption advisory for 2005. West Virginia DHHR, through an interagency agreement, partners with the WestVirginia Department of Environmental Protection and the Division of Natural Resources to develop consumptionadvisories for fish caught in West Virginia. Fish consumption advisories are updated annually and help WestVirginia anglers make educated choices about eating the fish they catch.

While most West Virginia sport fish are of high quality, low levels of chemicals like polychlorinated biphenyls (PCBs),

mercury and dioxin have been found in some fish from certain waters. To ensure the continued good health of WestVirginians, the West Virginia DHHR offers an advisory for how often these fish can be safely eaten' An advisory isadvice, and should not be viewed as law or regulation. It is intended to help anglers and their families makeeducated choices about: where to fish, what types of fish to eat, how to limit the amount and frequency of fisheaten, and how to prepare and cook fish to reduce contaminants.

This advisory covers only sport fish caught in West Virginia waters. Safety regulations and aclvisories for fish in themarket place are the responsibility of the Federal Food and Drug Administration (FDA). For more information you

can contact the FDA at www.fda.gov/oclopacom/hottopics/mercury/backgrounder.html.

The following updated advisory recommendation is the result of a recently completed study of spoft fish samplesfrom 56 collection sites across West Virginia and historical data, Data collected from lakes and rivers in WestVirginia show that a general statewide aclvisory of sport-caught fish is appropriate. A review of this informationindicates that mercury, PCBS and dioxin are the most prevalent pollutants of concern. If you would like moredetailed information about these contaminants and the levels measured consult the DHHR Web Site atwww.wvdhhr.orglfish

http ://www.wvdhhr. orglfi sh/print. asp U1U2005

West Virginia Fish Consumption Advisories Page2 of 6

Body weight and meal size are important factors in Fish advisories. Use this chart to find the size of meal thatcorresponds to your body weight. This advisory is designed to keep the amount of chemicals you eat at a safe level.

Find the meal advice for the fish you've caught. "Do Not Eat" means you should not eat those fish because of highercontamination. The other groups ("One Meal a Week", "Two meals a Month", "One Meal a Month", and "Six Meals a

Year") are advice for how often to eat fish.

Women of childbearing age, chilctren and people who regularly eat fish are particularly susceptible to contaminantsthat build up over time. If you fall into one of these categories, you should be especially careful to follow the mealsizes and space fish meals out according to the advisory tables.

Your body can get rid of some contaminants overtime. Spacing the meals out helps prevent the contaminants frombuilding up to harmful levels in the body. For example, if the Fish you eat is in the "One Meal a Month Group", wait a

month before eating another meal of fish from any restricted category. Occasionally eating fish in quantities slightlygreater than the advisories recommend, such as during an annual fishing vacation, should not present a healthhazard.

Follow the advice presented in this advisory, noting the differences between the General Advisories for all WestVirginia waters and the more restrictive Specific Advisories.

Meal SizesA person weighing between Should eat no more than this amount per meal

nounds ounces of orecooked fish20 or less l0

2t-35 l536-50 205l-70 .tu7t-90 40

91 -1 10 50t11 t30 60l3r-150 l0

l5l and over 80Remember that 3.0 ounces of precooked fish is about the size of the palm of your hand or a deck of cards

Remember that 1.5 ounces of precooked fish is about one-half the size of the palm of your hand or one-half of adeck of cards

http ://www. wvdhhr. org/fi sh/print. asp Urv200s

GENERAL ADVISORIES FOR ALL WESTVIRGINIA WATERS

Water Bodv SpeciesLimit your fish

meals to: Contaminants*

ALL WESTVIRGINIA WATERS

(except where listedin the specific

advisories below):

Black Bass (largemouth,smallmouth, spotted) less than12"Channel Catfish greater than17"

Sauger

AllSuckers

2 meals a month

*MercuryPCBs

Black Bass (largemouth,smallmouth, spotted) greaterthan 12"

Walleye

Saugeye

White Bass

Hvbrid Strioed Bass

1 meala month

Rainbow Trout No Limit

Channel Catfish less than 17"

AllOther Species1 meala week

West Virginia Fish Consumption Advisories Page 3 of6

xcontaminant: Meal Limits are determined by the chemical with the asterisk. other listed chemicals would have an

advisory at a less restrictive level.

http ://www.wvdhhr. org/fi sh/print. asp Urv200s

West Virginia Fish Consumption Advisortes

More restrictive actvlsories issued in 2005 affect the following water bodies:

KANAWHA RIVERdownstream of 144 bridgein Dunbar including: allbackwaters, Armour Creek,Heizer Creek, Manila Creek,Pocatalico River (lower twomiles)

rage 4 0r o

West Virginia Sport Fish Gonsumptionwaterbodies of specific concern in west virginia's 2005 Fish consumption Advisory

(All other waterbodies fall under the general advlsory

NORTH BRANCH OF POTOMAC RIVER

SLEEPY CREEK LAKE POTOMAC RIVER - MAiN STTEAM

MIDDLE ISLAND

HUGHES RIVER

LITTLE KANAWHA

KANAWHA RIVER - Pmatali@ Rivel

KANAWHA RIVER - HEZET CTEKSHENANDOAH RIVER

KANAWHA RIVER ' AMOUT CT*KSOUTH FORIOSOUTH BRANCH

NORTH FORI(SOUTH BRANCH

MEADOW RIVER

Ss chart bdw lq epecbB aff@iodand consmpt'Pn adYlco tor grch

mterbody mapped.

0 15 30 60 90 12O

#uites

SPECIFIC ADVISORIES . SPECIES NOT LISTED BELOW CAN BE

EATEN AS INDIGATED IN THE GENERAL ADVISORYLimit your fish

meals to:

Do not eatCarp

Channel Catfish, all sizes

Suckers

FLAT FORK CREEK

HUGHES RIVER

Do not eat

Flathead Gatfish, all sizes

Channel Catfish, all sizes

Carp

Hybrid Striped Bass

Suckers

http ://www.wvdhhr.org/fi sh/print. aspUrrl2005

Allother 1 meala month

KANAWHA RIVERupstream of 164 bridge inDunbar

Channel Caffish less than 17" 2 meals a month*PCBs

Mercury

2 meals a month*Mercury

PCBsLITTLE KANAWHA RIVER Flathead Catfish less than 17"

*MercuryMEADOW RIVER Rock Bass 2 meals a month

*Mercury

PCBsMIDDLE ISLAND CREEK Spotted Bass less than 12" 1 meala month

*PCBsMONONGAHEI.A RIVER Channel Catfish, all sizes 6 meals a Year

*DioxinPOTOMAC RIVER mainstem

Allnongame fish Do not eat

*DioxinNORTH BRANCH ofPOTOMAC RIVER

All non-game fish Do not eat

NORTH FORK of SOUTHBRANCH of POTOMACRIVER

Rock Bass 2 meals a month*Mercury

'MercurySOUTH FORK of SOUTHBRANCH of POTOMAGRIVER

Smallmouth Bass less than12" 1 meala month

Qrrnfich 2 meals a month

Do not eat*PCBs

MercuryDioxin

OHIO RIVER, entire lengthin lAlV

CarpChannel Catfish greater than17"

Channel Catfish less than 17"

Flathead Catfish, all s!299-6 meals a Year

Drum 1 meal a month

'PGBsR. D. BAILEY LAKE

Channel Catfish greater than17"

6 meals a Year

*PCBs

MercurySHENANDOAH RIVER

Carp

Channel Catfish greater than17"

Do not eat

2 meals a month*Mercury

SLEEPY CREEK I.AKE Yellow Bullhead

1 meala month *MercuryWHEELING CREEK

Smallmouth Bass less than12"

W.est Virginia Fish Consumption Advisorres ragg J ur u

xcontaminant: Meal Limits are determined by the chemical with the asterisk. other listed chemicals would have an

advisory at a less restrlctive level.

PCBs: Polychlorinated BiPhenYls

http ://www.wvdhhr.org/fi sh/print. asprlrrl200s

West Virginia Fish Consumption Advisories rage o or o

For further information or the most current advice consult the DHHR Web site at www'wvdhhr'org/fish

or call 304-558-2981.

Other contacts:

Consult the WV Division of Natural Resources Web Site at www'wvdnr'gov/fishing/fishing'shtm

or cafl (304) 55A'277t.

Consult the WV DePartment of Environmental Protection Web Site at www'wvdep'orq

or call (304) 926-0495'

Consult the US EPA Web Sate at www.epa.gov/ost/fish'

http : //www. wvdhhr. org/fi sh/pri nt. aspU1r12005

PCB and Mercury DabAssociated with 2005 Fish Consumotion Advisories

Note: Some Ohio lf iver frsh were skinon f llets

Sorted by Waterbody

WaterbodyRhrarmb LOCATpI{ Gouac$on Specie6

lrnefir FruetPreoarltlon

F clrl FCBsDqnrrir. rh. Sc DE. nn. Aec. ht hch.r -En

]EAR ROCK LAKE )HIO COUNTY. VVV 4l 4 8( 3 17-Jun4: :HANNEL CATFISH t6 ;KIN OFF

]EAR ROCK LAKE )HIO COUNTY. WV 4( 4 8( 5 17-Jun{: ]HANNEL CATFISH 20 ;KIN OFF

FORK LAKE A/AYNE COUNTY VVV 38t 1{ I 4t 15-Auo4i ]HANNEL CATFISH 3l ;KIN OFF

]EECH FORK LAKE A/AYNE COUNry. WV 3l 'il 8 2/ 4t 15-Auo-0i SPOTTED BASS ;KIN OFF]EECH FORK LAKE /VAYNE COUNry. WV 38t il 8 4t 15-Auo-oi ARGEMOUTH BASS 4 ;KIN OFF

]EECH FORK LAKE ruAYNE COUNTY. WV 3t 8 4t 15-Auo-Oi )HANNEL CATFISH 7 ;KIN OFFlEECH FORK LAKE iVAYNE COUNTY. WV 3l 1l I 4t 15-Auo{l ARGEMOUTH BASS 0( ;KIN OFF

]EECH FORK LAKE A/AYNE COUNTY. WV A2l 2t 4t 15-Auo{: ;KIN OFFCH FORK LAKE A/AYNE COUNTY. WV 3l 1l I 4t l5-Auo{2SPOTTED BASS ;KIN OFF 0.532i

]IG COAL RIVER t9 RAC NE 38 3 I 391 3( 04-Ju {i ;POTTED BASS I JKIN OFF

]IG COAL RIVER tq TACINE 381 8 39 3( O2-Jul4: ;ILVER REDHORSE SUCKER 18: JKIN OFF]IG COAL RIVER t9 lAC NE 3 I J 3{ 02-Jul{ )MALLMOUTH BASS 9 JKIN OFF

]IG COAL RIVER 19 lACINE 3 361 02-Jul{3IBLACKREDHORSESUCKER 15 JKIN OFF

]IG COAL RIVER l9 TACINE 3 3 A 3 3( 05-Jul{: ;POTTED BASS 9 ]KIN OFF]IG COAL RIVER 19 TACINE 3 3 8 3( 0s-JUI4SSMALLMOUTH BASS 10 ;KIN OFF

Page 1 of '13

PCB and Mercury DataAssociated with 2005 Fish Consumption Advisories

Sorted by Waterbody

Waterbody RiverMile

LOGATIONl-ffid. Collectlon

DateSp€cies

rttret ruEShmDm. lMin-lSc Dm-lMin-l Sm- nnm

]LIJESTONE LAKE 3UMMERS COUNry VVV 3 351 361 8r 5 4l O9-Oct-{)i :HANNEL CATFISH l< JKIN OFF]LUESTONE LAKE SUMMERS COUNTY. WV 3 35t 36t 8( 5 4l 09-Oct4, ]HANNEt CATFISH 18 JKIN OFF]LUESTONE LAKE }UMMERS COUNTY. WV 3 351 361 8( 5 4( O9-Oct{i SPOTTED BASS l0

'KIN OFF

]LUESTONE LAKE JUMMERS COUNTY. WV 31 351 361 8( 4l 09-Oct4i SPOTTED BASS 11 JKIN OFF]LUESTONE LAKE ;UMMERS COUNTY. WV 3i 3sl 361 8( 4( O9-Oct4: BASS 11 JKIN OFF

]LUESTONE RIVER 22 {EAR EADS MILL 371 2Al 4 8 2! 25-Jun43lROCK BASS iKIN OFF

'LUESTONE RIVER 22" 'IEAR EAOS MILL 371 281 4l 81 2a 25-Jun43lROCK BASS 7. ;KIN OFF

]LUESTONE RIVER {EAR EADS MILL 371 281 4( 8 2a 25-Jun{3ISMALLMOUTH BASS 8( SKIN OFF

7 IALL 39 1 ao 4 20-Auo{ -ATHEAD CATFISH 't7 i SKIN OFFIALL 3! 11 8( t 4t 20-Auo{: 15( SKIN OFF{ALL 3! ,l a( t 4t 20-Auo4: ]MALLMOUTH BASS 11 SKIN OFF

25|- 38t 5{ 4 8( 1 1t 06-Jun4: ;MALLMOUTH BASS 14 3KIN OFF

'URNSVILLE LAKE ]RAXTON COUNry. WV 3{ 4! 801 3a 5 1o-Jun{21 REDHORSE SUCKER 't0 SKIN OFF

]URNSVILLE LAKE IRAXTON COUNry. WV 3l 4! 801 31 5l lo-Jun{2 REDHORSE SUCKER t6 SKIN OFF]URNSVILLE LAKE )MXTON COUNTY. WV 3t 4! 2i 801 3i 5 10-Jun4: -ARGEMOUTH BASS t0 SKIN OFF]URNSVILLE LAKE ]RAXTON COUNTY. WV 3t 491 2Al 801 351 3r 1 7-ADr. l2 ]KIN OFF]URNSVILLE LAKE ]RAXTON COUNTY. WV 3{ 4! 2 80t 3r 5 l0-Jun4: JPOTTED BASS ;KIN OFF]URNSVILLE LAKE ]RAXTON COUNW. WV 3l 491 2, 80t 3r 5 lo-Jun{2ISPOTTED BASS t0 IN OFF3URNSVILLE LAKE ]RAXTON COUNry. WV 1l 4! 2At 80t 3r 3 17-ADr{i ARGEMOUTH BASS 16 ]KIN OFF 0.6'

)HEAT LAKE 4 59t 7l 5 20 2' 29-Oct-0i ]HANNEL CATFISH t9 IIN OFF]HEAT LAKE 4 5( 5 20 2' 29.QCI42IREDHORSE SUCKER t3 JKIN OFF)HEAT LAKE 3l 4 5( 5 m2, 29-Oct-02IREDHORSE SUCKE I FF)HEAT LAKE 3l 4 7S 20.24 29-Oc1{: ]HANNEL CATFISH t6 SKIN OFF)HEAT LAKE 3! 4 7l 5 20 2' l5-Mav-02LARGEMOUTH BASS 'tl SKIN OFF)HEAT LAKE 4 7l 51 20 2t 29-Oct-o, /VHITE BASS 't0 SKIN OFF]HEAT LAKE 4 I5.MAy.OZLARGEMOUTH BASS 14 SKIN OFF)HEAT LAKE 4 5( 7( AI 20 2t '15-Mav-0: ARGEMOUTH BASS SKIN OFF]HEAT LAKE

'/IONONGALIA COUNTY. WV 3 4 5! 7l <i 20 2t 29-Oct{: AiHITE BASS 13 SKIN OFF 0.4i

)HEAT LAKE i,IONONGALIA COUNTY. WV 3 4 5! 7l 20 2t 26-Seo{: ;MALLMOUTH BASS 11 SKIN OFFT LAKE T(JNUN(jALIA UUUN I Y. WV 4 4! 4 05-Auq{i A/HITE BASS 13 1 SKIN OFF o.5721

Page 2 of 13

PCB and Mercury DataAssociated with 2005 Fish Consumotion Advisories

Sorted by Waterbody

LLY GROWN CATFISH \IOT APPLICABLE 23-Jun{: SHANNEL CATFISH 20 ;KIN OFFNOT APPLICABLE 23-Jun{: HANNEL CATFISH 221 SKIN OFF

]OMMERCIALLY GROWN CATFISH !OT APPLICABLE 2}Jun4: ]HANNEL CATFISH 181 SKIN OFF

]RANBERRY RIVER 22 N CATCH AND RELEASE SEGMENT 3t fsl 331 801 2'tl 231 24-Jun4: A/HITE SUCKER 8t JKIN OFF]KIN OFFSKIN OFF

}RANBERRY RIVER 22 IN CATCH ANO RELEASE SEGMENT 3t 1l 331 801 2'll 231 24-Jun4i ]ROWN TROUT 9I}RANBERRY RIVER 22 TCH AND RELEASE SEGMENT 3{ la 331 801 211 231 24-JUn{3IBROWN TROUT 13 (

)RY FORK 6 !EAR GLADWIN 3( 7l 331 491 29-Auo{: 3OLOEN REDHORSE SUCKER 14 ;KIN OFF)RY FORK 6 !EAR GLADWIN 7l 3 4 29-Auq{2GOLDEN REDHORSE SUCKER t6 N OFF)RY FORK !EAR GLADWIN 7( 4 2g-Auo4i ;MALLMOUTH BASS 11. JKIN OFF)RY FORK 6 \.IEAR GLADWIN 4 29-AUo42ISMALLMOUTH BASS t3 N OFF n.6121

)RY FORK/TUG FORK 31 ? 1t t I 2l 25-JUn43INORTHERN HOGSUCKER 7 :IN OFFY FORI(TUG FORK 31 !EAR CANEBRAKE 3 1t ' d s 25-Jun4: 8 JKIN OFF

)RY FORKTTUG FORK 31 1t a 25-Jun{3lROCK BASS JKIN OFF

:AST LYNN IAKE'I/AYNE

COUN' 3t a2t 2'. 271 24-Jtrl4l 3OLDEN REDHORSE SUCKER t6 ;KIN OFFiAST LYNN LAKE ,VAYNE COUN- 3{ 2 a2 2 3 21-Auo{: :LATHEAO CATFISH 14 iKIN OFFEAST LYNN LAKE /YAYNE COUNTY. WV 3t 62 271 24-Jul4: }OLDEN REDHORSE SUCKER l7 JKIN OFF:AST LYNN LAKE fiAYNE COUN' 3t 8 2 3 21-Auo{: .ARGEMOUTH BASS 6 JKIN OFFEAST LYNN LAKE ,VAYNE COUNTY. WV 38t 6t

"a 3 l2 iKIN OFF

=AST LYNN LAKE A/AYNE COUN' 3l I 2 3 21-Auo4i JPOTTED BASS 9 iKIN OFF

EAST LYNN LAKE WAYNE UUUN I Y. WV 3{ 2l t0 JKIN OFFr LYNN LAKE WAYNE COUN 3t I 3( 21-Auo-0: .ARGEMOUTH BASS '14

'KIN OFF

:AST LYNN LAKE r'\iAYNE COUNTY. WV 381 61 2( 8 361 21-Auo4i iPOTTED BASS 11 ]KIN OFF

:LK FORK LAKE IACKSON COUNry. v\^/ 3l 4 21 I 3 1 09-Mav{ -ARGEMOUTH BASS lo SKIN OFF:LK FORK LAKE IACKSON COUNTY. WV 3l 21 8 3 I 09-Mav4i -ARGEMOUTH BASS 124 SKIN OFF:LK FORK LAKE IACKSON COUNW. WV 3 4 21 I 1 09-Mav-02LARGEMOUTH BASS 15 sISKIN OFF 0.:LK FORK LAKE IACKSON COUNTY. VVV 3 4 8 3 I 09-Oct4i 3HANNEL CATFISH 18 slSKtN OFF:LK FORK LAKE IACKSON COUNry. VVV 3 4 21 I 3 1 09-Oct-oi lLACK BULLHEAD 12i iKIN OFF:LK FORK LAKE IACKSON COUNTY. v\^/ 3 4 2 8 3 I 09-tu4i ]HANNEL CATFISH 21 iKIN OFF

Page 3 of 13

PCB and Mercury DataAssociated with 2005 Fish ConsumDtion Advisories

Sorted by Waterbody

Wltertody Rlverfllle LOCATION

CdlectbnSpoclee L€neth Flll€t

PremratlonMercwy

oomPCBsomDeo. llln. S.c, D.o, llln. 8.c" D.t hchc

:LK RIVER 10( ;ASSAWAY 381 401 241 8( 4( 24-.\tl4: JMALLMOUTH BASS 10 SKIN OFF:LK RIVER 10( JASSAWAY 4 8( 41 24-Jul4: JMALLMOUTH BASS 9l SKIN OFF

JREENBRIER RIVER MILLOWWOOD 1l 8( 4{ I 30-Oct4: 14 I SKIN OFF;REENBRIER RIVER ryILLOWWOOD 381 261 801 481 'l 30-Oct4: 16 1 SKIN OFF

|,\/TLLOWWOOD 8( 4t 30-Oct4: SMALLMOUTH BASS 11t SKIN OFFovvwooo 37f 381 261 8( 481 1 30-Oct{:

'MALLMOUTH BASS 't0 SKIN OFF

10( } MI ABOVE SEEBERT al 8( 21 -Auo{21 NORTHERN HOGSUCKER t3 SKIN OFFIEENBRIER RIVER 10( 3 MI ABOVE SEEBERI 8( ( 21-Auq{2ISMALLMOUTH BASS t0 SKIN OFF

l0( I MI ABOVE SEEBERT 5a 8( 21-Auo{: ]MALLMOUTH BASS t5 ]KIN OFF o.442!

3UYANDOTTE RIVER 61 : qT GODBY HEIGHTS 5( 1 8 4 24-Jul{3ISPOTTED BASS 7 ;KIN OFF3UYANDOTTE RIVER 61 a {T GODBY HEIGHTS 3 131 A2l 0l 461 24-Jul41 ]HANNEL CATFISH 15 JKIN OFF]UYANDOTTE RIVER 6't : \T GODBY HEIGHTS 5( I 4 24-Jul{i )HANNEL CATFISH 19 ]KIN OFF

iUYANDOTTE RIVER 6't : \T GODBY HEIGHTS 8 461 24-Jul-0: iMALLMOUTH BASS 9 ;KIN OFF3UYANDOTTE RIVER 61 : \T GODBY HEIGHTS J 5( I 4l 24-Jul{i ;AUGER 11 ]KIN OFF}UYANDOTTE RIVER 61 : \T GOOBY HEIGHTS 37t 5( a 4l 24-Jtr141 iPOTTED BASS 9( JKIN OFF

IUGHES RIVER 7 {EAR FREEPORT 8 2 1t 30-Jun{: )HANNEL CATFISH 5 ]KIN OFFIUGHES RIVER {EAR FREEPORT 8 1l 30-Jun{i )HANNEL CATFISH 7 JKIN OFFIUGHES RIVER {EAR FREEPORT 3 8 2 1{ 3O-Jun{: ]HANNEL CATFISH 't9 r OFFIUGHES RIVER 7 IEAR FREEPORT a 8 1l 30-Jun{ :RESHWATER ORUM 4 ;KIN OFFIUGHES RIVER {EAR FREEPORT 3 8 t{ 3O-Jun-O: }AUGER

'KIN OFF

IUGHES RIVER 7 VEAR FREEPORT 8 .il 30-Jun{l MHITE BASS 2l ;KIN OFFIUGHES RIVER VEAR FREEPORT 3 3 I 1t 30-Jun{: ;AUGER 4 iKIN OFF 0.5:

JENNINGS RANDOLPH LAKE \,INERAL COUNTY. WV 3 2. 56t 7l '18-Mav-0i ;MALLMOUTH BASS '12 N OFF,ENNINGS RANDOLPH LAKE \,||NERAL COUNTY. WV 3 f t 16-Mav-02SMALLMOUTH BASS 141 ;KIN OFFJENNINGS RANDOLPH LAKE \,INERAL COUNTY. WV 3 2t 5 g '17-Mav-0: iMALLMOUTH BASS 10 JKIN OFFJENNINGS RANDOLPH LAKE \,INERAL COUNTY. WV 2/ 5 7 , 14-Mav-02RAINBOW TROUT 10, ;KIN OFFIENNINGS RANDOLPH LAKE \,INERAL COUNry- WV 3! 2t 15-May-02RAINBOW TROUT 121 JKIN OFF

Page 4 of 13


Sorted by Waterbody

<ANAWHA RIVER 3 A/INFIELD 3t 3 q I 4 21-Aua4i ]MALLMOUTH BASS 15 llSK|N OFFAWHA RIVER A/INFIELD 3i 8 * 4 21-Aus{zFLATHEAD CATFISH 141 ;KIN OFF

<ANAWHA RIVER 5 r'VINFIELD s ? 8't ? 4 21-Auo4: JMALLMOUTH BASS 12( ;KIN OFFGNAWHA RIVER 31 WINFIELD J' I * 4 21-Auo4', JMALLMOUTH BASS 9t ;KIN OFF(ANAWHA RIVER 32i A/INFIELD TAILWATFRS al a 3 8 * 5 27-Mat4i ;AUGER 13t iKIN OFF aGNAWHA RIVER ?a WINFIELO TAILWATERS 3t 3 3 8 5t 5 21-Aor4'. TE BASS )KIN OFF 0.51<ANAWHA RIVER 33 /VINFIELD TAILWATERS 3 I 5( 21-ADr4i )HANNEL CATFISH 17t ;KIN OFF 0.4:GNAWHA RIVER 1a' /VINFIELD TAILWATERS 3t 3 8 5( 2'l-ADr4i CHANNEL CATFISH SKIN OFFGNAWHA RIVER 33 /VINFIELD TAILWATERS 31 3 8 * 5( 27-Mat4i ;AUGER 15i SKIN OFF !.GNAWHA RIVER 33 &INFIELD TAILWATERS 3T 8 5( 2'l-ADr{:

'HANNEL CATFISH 19t SKIN OFF o

(ANAWHA RIVER r'VINFIELD TAILWATERS 3t ? 8 5 5( 21-Ao14: WHITE BASS ! OFFGNAWHA RIVER 70 \4ARMET TAILWATERS 3t 1 1l 8 3 t( 25 ]HANNEL CATFISH 14( JKIN OFF aGNAWHA RIVER 70 IiIET TAILWATERS 3t 1a 1l 8 1( 25-Mat4i. }HANNEL CATFISH t6 iKIN OFF aGNAWHA RIVER 70 I,IARMET TAILWATERS 1t 1t 8 1( 25-MeG SMALLMOUTH BASS 10 ]KIN OFF aGNAWHA RIVER 70 i4ET TAILWATERS 3t 't! 1l 8 3 't( 25-Ma14i SMALLMOUTH BASS 13 JKIN OFF o-522!GNAWHA RIVER 70 1 I,IARMET TAILWATERS 1! t{ 8 3/ t( 25-Mar4l SMALLMOUTH BASS '12' JKIN OFF o.707!

(EE RESERVOIR ilERCER COUNry. WV 8 1( 2t.hn{: ]HANNEL CATFISH 21 ;KIN OFF(EE RESERVOIR R COUNTY. WV 1 8 1( 25-Jun4l -ARGEMOUTH BASS 14 ;KIN OFF(EE RESERVOIR VIERCER COUNTY. WV 3 'l 8 1( 2'Jun{3ILARGEMOUTH BASS 10( JKIN OFF

ITTLE COAL RIVER 8 ,.IEAR MCCORKLE 'l 8 4l O3-Jul4l SPOTTED BASS o iKIN OFF-ITTLE COAL RIVER 8 {EAR MCCORKLE ? I I 4l 03-Jul4l SPOTTED BASS 10 JKIN OFF.ITTLE COAL RIVER I {EAR MCCORKLE e 1 8 4! O3-.lul{l SOLDEN REDHORSE SUCKER 17 }KIN OFF.ITTLE COAL RIVER 8 {EAR MCCORKLE 1 8 4l 03-Jul4l ]HANNEL CATFISH 't9 | iKIN OFF.ITTLE COAL RIVER I {EAR MCCORKLE 381 la 8 4l O3-Jul- SAUGER 't5 iKIN OFF-ITTLE COAL RIVER 8 {EAR MCCORKLE 3 1 8 4l 03-Jul4l 3OLDEN REDHORSE SUCKER 14/ iKIN OFF

-ITTLE KANAWHA RIVER ABETH t( I '1'l-Seo4: ]HANNEL CATFISH 17 JKIN OFFITTLE KANAWHA RIVER 3( :LIZABETH 3( 1! 8 2 11-Seo4l ]HANNEL CATFISH 15 ]KIN OFFITTLE KANAWHA RIVER a :LIZABETH 1{ R 2 11-SeD{, :LATHEAD CATFISH 14 iKIN OFF

.ITTLE KANAWHA RIVER 3OIELIZABETH 3! 't! I I l-S( ]HANNEL CATFISH 19 ]KIN OFFITTLE KANAWHA RIVER :LIZABETH 3( l( I 2 I l-Seo{i SPOTTED BASS t0 IN OFF

.ITTLE KANAWHA RIVER 3 :LIZABETH 391 i 1! I 1t-s( SPOTTED BASS t0 ]KIN OFFITTLE KANAWHA RIVER 3 :LIZABETH 1( 8 1 1-Seo-Oi 3LUEGILL ot SKIN OFF

Page 5 of 13


Sorted by Waterbody

ADOW RIVER 5 iUSSELVILLE 3( 8( 25-Jun4i ROCK BASS SKIN OFF

!4EADOW RIVER IUSSELVILLE 3I 39t 8( 531 301 26-Jun4: JMALLMOUTH BASS 9 SKIN OFFADOW RIVER 5 lIRUSSELVILLE 3t 8( 5 26-Jun4i )UTH BASS SKIN OFF

!4EADOW RIVER TUSSELVILLE 3t 8( 5 301 25-Jun{3lROCK BASS 7 SKIN OFF

TIIDDLE FORK 1( ..IEAR ELLAMORE 38t 5l 4 8( 501 o8-Auo{i SUNF SH JKIN OFF

vllDOLE FORK t( .IEAR ELLAMORE 38t 5{ 4 8( 5OI O8.AUO{2IBROWN BULLHEAD a iKIN OFF

dIDDLE FORK 1( .IEAR ELLAMORE 4 8( 5ol o8-Auo{: A/HITE SUCKER t5 ;KIN OFF

IIIDDLE FORK 1( .IEAR ELLAMORE 38t 5{ 4 8( 501 o8-AUq42SMALLMOUTHBASS 9 JKIN OFF

,llDDLE FORK 't( {EAR ELLAMORE 381 551 4 a( 501 o8-Auo-O: JMALLMOUTH BASS t1 SKIN OFF

ilIDDLE ISLAND CREEK llIMOUTH OF SUGAR CREEK 3! 2! d 251 16-Auo{i ]HANNEL CATFISH l7 ]KIN OFF

LAND CREEK 1 UOUTH OF SUGAR CREEK 2l l6-Auo{: ]HANNEL CATFISH l4 JKIN OFF

,4IDOLE ISLAND CREEK 25IMOUTH OF BUFFALO RUN 39t 2t 8 13-Auo4: ]HANNEL CATFISH 19 ]KIN OFFLAND CREEK {EAR WEST UNION 2( I 4l 24-Mat4i iPOTTED BASS 12 JKIN OFF o-!

,,IIDDLE ISLAND CREEK {EAR WEST UNION 39t 2( d 48t 31 24-Matqi JPOTTED BASS 10 ]KIN OFF 0.5{r7!

,llDDLE ISLAND CREEK !EAR WEST UNION 2( 8 4 24-Mat4i ]POTTED BASS t1 IKIN OFF O-5121

-A RIVER 101 sIMORGANTOWN I 1 5 1o-od{: t3 SKIN OFF

to't ! 39t 3i I 5 1o-Ocl{: ]HANNEL CATFISH 16 JKIN OFF

lOl,5IMORGANTOWN 3 1 1o-Oct{: ]HANNEL CATFISH t9 JKIN OFF o.6l

10t LOCKS AND DAM 39t 3; 1 7l 5{ l8-Seo{: /VHITE BASS t0 JKIN OFF

t0i ]ELOW MORGANTOWN LOCKS AND OAM a( a 24 aa JMALLMOUTH BASS t0 SKIN OFF

10t ]ELOW MORGANTOWN LOCKS ANO OAM 391 3t 2t 7( 5t 04-Jun4i ;AUGER 't1 JKIN OFF10t ]ELOW MORGANTOWN LOCKS AND DAM 2. 7( qt 04-Jun{: iMALLMOUTH BASS 12 3KIN OFF

10 ]ELOW MORGANTOWN LOCKS AND DAM 391 3i 2t 7l 5t 04-Jun4: JMALLMOUTH BASS 14 SKIN OFF

10t ]ELOW MORGANTOWN LOCKS AND DAM 2t 7l 5t iAUGER 12 SKIN OFF

10 ]ELOW MORGANTOWN LOCKS AND DAM 3( 2t 7l 5l 04-Jun{l ]AUGER 14 SKIN OFF

VIOUNT STORM LAKE ]RANT COUNTY. WV 3! 7l 4 06-Mav-0 .ARGEMOUTH BASS t2: SKIN OFF

INT STORM LAKE ]RANTCOUNTY WV 1 2( 7! 1 4 0GMav-0 ARGEMOI.ITH BASS 'lO r SKIN OFF

IIOUNT STORM LAKE iRANT COUNTY. WV 21 7l 1 4 O6-Mav-0 ]HANNEL CATFISH 11. SKIN OFF 03ttOUNT STORM LAKE 3RANT COUNTY. WV 3( 1 1 4 06-Mav-0: ]HANNEL CATFISH lO.r ]KIN OFF

\,IOUNT STORM LAKE JRANT COUNTY. WV 1 26t 7l 4 06-Mav-0: ]HANNEL CATFISH 11{ ;KIN OFF

\4OUNT STORM LAKE 3RANT COUNTY. V\A/ ?( 1 2l 1 4 0&Mav-0: -ARGEMOUTH BASS 11 ;KIN OFF

Page 6 of 13


Sorted by Waterbody

.IEW RIVER / THURMOND a 57t 4t 8t 1l l7-Oct{: JMALLMOUTH BASS 11 'l SKIN OFFi 56 3 461 131 801 531 361 27-Auo{3INORTHERN HOGSUCKER 141 SKIN OFF

.IEW RIVER 5b-r ;ANDSTONE 3 461 1l 8( 5 361 27-Auo{3lROCK BASS o SKIN OFF,lEW RIVER 56 E 3 ,t6l 13f 8ol 531 361 27-Auo4: ]MALLMOI.JTH BASS 9 SKIN OFF,lEW RIVER 56 iANDSTONE a 461 131 801 5: 361 27-Auo4i ;MALLMOUTH BASS 10 JKIN OFF\|EW RIVER 56 TONE 461 131 801 5: 36f 27-Auo4l ;MALLMOI.'TH BASS l2 SKIN OFF.IEW RIVER 561 ;ANDSTONE I 46t li 8( 361 27-Auo{SROCKBASS 8 ;KIN OFF!EW RIVER 56.i ;ANDSTONE 3 461 r3l 801 5i 361 27-Ato4i TLATHEAD CATFISH 10 SKIN OFF{EW RIVER SANDSTONE a 46t la 8( F 3 o JKIN OFF!EW RIVER col SANDSTONE 461 1: 3 27-Aua4i iUNFISH SKIN OFF

TH FORICSOUTH BRANCH ; MILES ABOVE MOUTH 381 5r 7l 1 '17-Seo-0: tocK BAss N OFFIORTH FORK/SOUTH BRANCH

' MILES ABOVE MOUTH 3{ 5t l7-Seo{2IREDHORSE SUCKER 16; JKIN OFF

RTH FORICSOUTH BRANCH MILES ABOVE MOUTH 3t 5t 7l '17-Seo-o2lWHlTE SUCKER 14 ;KIN OFFIORTH FOR}CSOUTH BRANCH

' MILES ABOVE MOUTH 3( 5t €eD{2lROCK BASS 8/ ;KIN OFF

TH FORI(SOUTH BRANCH'

MILES ABOVE MOUTH 3At 5t -Seo{i 12/ iKIN OFFIORTH FORI(SOUTH BRANCH i MILES ABOVE MOUTH 3t 5{ 7 -SeD{ZSMALLMOUTH BASS 11 / iKIN OFF{ORTH FORI(SOUTH BRANCH

' MILES ABOVE MOUTH 38t 5t 7l -SeD{): IAINBOW TROI.JT 12 I OFF

O RIVER 4( a 8 a 3! 0 t -Jan4( )HANNEL CATFISH 221 iKIN OFF]HIO RIVER t 4( 31 a 8r 3! 01-Jan{( )HANNEL CATFISH 14 1 iKIN OFF]HIO RIVER 4( a 55t 8l 3 01Jul{: ]ARP 191 ;KIN OFF)HIO RIVER g 4( 31 5 8r 3 01-JUI42ISMALLMOUTH BASS 13( iKIN ON]HIO RIVER 4( 3 8 3 0 -Jan40lCARP iKIN ON)HIO RIVER 5r 4( 31 3 d 3 I 0 -Jan4( )ARP 211 }KIN ONfHIO RIVER 4( 3 3 8 3 0 .Jan{OIFRESHWATER DRUM 16 SKIN ON o-5!

)HIO RIVER I 4( 31 3 I 3 a 0 .Jan{OIFLATHEAD CATFISH 201'KIN

OFF)HIO RIVER * 4( i a I 3 e 0 -Jan4( :LATHEAD CATFISH 25 SKIN OFF

fHIO RIVER a 4( 11 a 8( a 0 -Jan{OIWHITE BASS 11 JKIN ON)HIO RIVER At 'IKE ISLAND LOCKS AND DAM 4l I 53t 8( 4 01-Seo{ )HANNEL CATFISH t5 ]KIN OFF

)|-|IO RIVER S4IPIKE ISLAND LOCKS AND OAM 4l 5 8( 4 01€{ )HANNEL CATFISH 15 JKIN OFF

o-7

RIVER iLAND LOCKS AND DAM 4l 531 a( 4 O1-Seo{) ]HANNEL CATFISH 20 iKIN OFF)HIO RIVER g

'IKE ISLAND LOCKS AND DAM 4( 5 8( 4 O,I -Seo-gg| FLATHEAD CATFISH 20 JKIN OFF)HIO RIVER g

'IKE ISLAND LOCKS AND DAM 4 53t A( 4 OI-SEO-ggIHYBRID STRIPED BASS 17 iKIN ON)HIO RIVER 84IPIKE ISLAND LOCKS AND DAM 4 53t 8( 4 01-Seo-9! ]HANNEL CATFISH 22.1 SKIN OFF)HIO RIVER & )IKE ISLAND POOL 4 1 6( 4 1 0.1-Jul{i JMALLMOUTH BASS 13 SKIN ON)HIO RIVER s4IPIKE ISLANO LOCKS AND DAM 4 531 6( 4 01-Seo{ :RESHWATER DRUM 16t SKIN ON)HIO RIVER & )IKE ISLAND LOCKS AND OAM 4 5 8( 4 0l -Sl A/ALLEYE 17< SKIN ON)HIO RIVER w rIKE ISLAND LOCKS AND DAM 4 53t 8( 4 01-Seo-g! A/HITE BASS 'tl SKIN ON)HIO RIVER 4 )IKE ISLAND LOCKS AND DAM 4 8( 4 0l-SeD{ ]ARP 22( SKIN OFF

Page 7 of 13

PCB and Mercury DataAssociated with 2O05 Fish Consumption Advisories

Sorted by Waterbody

WaterbodyRivsrMile

LOCATpT{l-.fltMd.

SpociesFiltet Msrcw! P(;Es

omD.c. nn. SG Dm kl 3e Itft lmtaa)HIO RIVER g ,IKE ISLANO LOCKS AND DAM 4( 5 8( 4 0l-Seo4 :LATHEAD CATFISH 221 SKIN OFF)HIO RIVER * ,IKE ISLAND POOL 4( 1 8( 4 1 0lJul{: ]ARP 20 SKIN OFF)HIO RIVER S4IPIKE ISLAND POOL 4( 1 I 4 I 0'lJul{: -ARGEMOUTH BASS 15( SKIN ON)HIO RIVER & )IKE ISLAND LOCKS AND DAM 4( 5 8 4 0 l-Seo-91 ;AUGEYE 16 SKIN ON

)HIO RIVER 'l2t {ANNIBAL LOCKS AND DAM 3 q( 5 I 01-Jan4( ]HANNEL CATFISH 18 SKIN OFF)HIO RIVER l26IHANNIBAL POOL 4( 2 al 5 ol-Jul{2|CHANNEL CATFISH 1 SKIN OFF

)HIO RIVER l26IHANNIBAL t 4( 8 5 t 14-S( )HANNEL CATFISH 16 JKIN OFF]HIO RIVER l2e {ANNIBAL LOCKS AND DAM 3 3( 5l P 5 5! O1-Jan{( {YBRID STRIPED BASS I JKIN ON o-5r]HIO RIVER 12e. {ANNIBAL LOCKS AND DAM 3 5t 8 5 5{ 01-Jan{( ]ARP 23 iKIN ONfHIO RIVER l2t .{ANNIBAL LOCKS AND DAM 3 3 8 5l O1-Jan{( :RESHWATER DRTJM t5 SKIN ONfHIO RIVER 1X. IANNIBAL a 4 2l 8 t '14-Seo-9( JYBRIO STRIPED BASS lA JKIN ON 0.5i)HIO RIVER 12 IANNIBAL POOL 3 4 2l I 5 O1-Jul-0: ]ARP)HIO RIVER 1X IANNIBAL LOCKS ANO DAM 5t I 01-Jan{( )HANNEL CATFISH 21 JKIN OFF)HIO RIVER l26IHANNIBAL POOL 4 2l 8 t 01 JUI42SMALLMOUTH BASS 12/ SKIN ON)HIO RIVER 121 {ANNIBAL LOCKS AND DAM 2 3 5{ 8( 5 5! 0'l-Jan4( {YBRID STRIPED BASS 17 JKIN ON 0.0i)HIO RIVER l2SIHANNIBAL LOCKS AND DAM a 3 5t 8( 5 5( o'l-Jan{( RESHWATER DRUM t9 ;KIN ON

)HIO RIVER 121 {ANNIBAL LOCKS AND DAM a 3 6t 8( 5 5( O,I.Jan4OI FLATHEAD CATFISH 241 JKIN OFF)HIO RIVER 15: TVILLOW ISLAND POOL a 4 8 't( 01-Jul4i ;AUGER 't3 ( JKIN ON)HIO RIVER 16 /VILLOW ISLAND LOCKS AND DAM 4( 8 1l 1( 01-SeD-99IFRESHWATER ORUM 15! JKIN ON)HIO RIVER 16 A/ILLOW ISLAND LOCKS AND DAM 4( 8 1! 1( 01-Seo-g! SHANNEL CATFISH 17" ;KIN OFF)HIO RIVER 't6 A'ILLOW ISLAND LOCKS AND DAM 2 4( 1! 1( O1€eD-99ICHANNEL CATFISH 201 ]KIN OFF)HIO RIVER 16 TVILLOW ISLAND LOCKS AND DAM 2 4( A 1( 01-Seo-g( ]ARP 19: ]KIN ON)HIO RIVER 16 /VILLOW ISLAND LOCKS AND DAM 2 1( I 't! 1( 01-Seo-gglWHlTE BASS 12.1 ]KIN ON 0.E()HIO RIVER t6 A/ILLOW ISLAND LOCKS AND DAM t 2 4( I 1! 't( 01-Seo-g( ]YBRID STRIPED BASS 't7 ]KIN ON o-61

)HIO RIVER 't6 A/ILLOW ISLAND LOCKS AND DAM 4( I l( 1( O1 -Seo-99ISAUGEYE '15 ( JKIN ON)HIO RIVER 168 i vIARIETTA. ABOVE DUCK CREEK 3 t1 e 3 1o-Oct{ }HANNEL CATFISH 19_! JKIN OFF)HIO RIVER 168 VTARIETTA. ABOVE DUCK CREEK 2. 8 2l 5( 'l0oct4 ;MALLMOUTH BUFFALO 20

'KIN ON 06

)HIO RIVER 168 i VIARIETTA. ABOVE DUCK CREEK 3 I I 2 3 'to-Oct{ TRESHWATER DRUM t6! SKIN ON

)HIO RIVER I69 4IMARIETTA. BELOW DUCK CREEK 3{ I 2l 5( 1o-Oct{ )ARP 17 JKIN ON)HIO RIVER 169 4IMARIETTA. BELOW DUCK CREEK 3 3t 8 A 10-&{)

'LACK CRAPPIE 10( ;KIN ON

)HIO RIVER 169 4IMARIETTA. BELOW DUCK CREEK I 2, 3l I 2 5( 1o-Oct{^/ARMOUTH

SUNFISH I'KIN

ONfHIO RIVER 169 r \,IARIETTA. BELOW DUCK CREEK t R 2 5( lO-Ocl{ )HANNEL CATFISH 18 SKIN OFFfHIO RIVER 169 4IMARIETTA. BELOW DUCK CREEK 3 2t 3| A 2 5{ l0-Oct4' :LATHEAD CATFISH 16 JKIN OFF]HIO RIVER 169 r lilARlETTA. BELOW DUCK CREEK 3 e 2 5{ lo-Oct-O' -ARGEMOUTH BASS I SKIN ON)HIO RIVER 't69 r TARIETTA. BELOW DUCK CREEK 1( 2t 3 I 10-Oc{4 JMALLMOUTH BASS 12 ]KIN ON)HIO RIVER 169-r ,IARIETTA- BELOW DUCK CREEK 3! 2/ 3 I z 5l tO-Oct{' JMALLMOI.'TH BUFFALO 27 iKIN ON)HIO RIVER 169, dARIETTA. BELOW DUCK CREEK 2t 3t A 5r 10-Oct4 )ARP 24 ;KIN ON o.7(

RIVER 169 r rTA- BELOW DUCK CREEK 3! 8 \TER DRI.IM

)HIO RIVER 169 r ,IARIETTA. BELOW DUCK CREEK e( 2t AJ 81 21 5 10-Oct-0 :RESHWATER DRUM 21 JKIN ON)HIO RIVER 2O3IBELLEVILLE LOCKS AND DAM 8 44 ? 01-SeD4 ]HANNEL CATFISH SKIN OFF 0.4t)HIO RIVER 20'l ]ELLEVILLE LOCKS AND DAM 3! 81 4t 3 01-Seo{ IYBRID STRIPED BASS 15 SKIN ON 0.6i

Page I of 13


Sorted by Waterbody

WaterbodyKUetMilo LOCATPN

l.omltud. Co|LcfbnSpecios l,ngrn FItet

P.eDrrtlonPCBSnmD6, kr Aac D.6. liln Se Drb lEls

RIVER 2O3IBELLEVILLE LOCKS ANO DAM a I 4/ ? 01€eo{) ]ARP 24.( ;KIN OFF)HIO RIVER 2O3IBELLEVILLE LOCKS AND DAM 3 8 4/ v O'l -Seo-o iRESHWATER DRUM 17

'KIN ON 0.7:

2O4IBELLEVILLE POOL 2! 8 4t 3( 01.Ju14, ]HANNEL CATFISH 21 ;KIN OFF)HIO RIVER 2O4IBELLEVILLE POOL a 2l d 4/ 3( Ol Jul{i ]ARP 23 ;KIN OFF 0.5()HIO RIVER 23i MCINE POOL 3l I 3( I c: 01Jul{i JPOTTEO BASS 13 4ISKIN ON)HIO RIVER 23i RACINE POOL 3l 3! 5l OlJul4i :ARP 23t SKIN OFF)HIO RIVER 23i RACINE POOL 3l u 3 I 0l-Jul{: ]HANNEL CATFISH 19S SKIN OFF o5)HIO RIVER 2U IACINE LOCKS AND DAM 3t 5 8 4 O1-.lan4l ]HANNEL CATFISH 14 SKIN OFF 0.3i)HIO RIVER 23t RACINE LOCKS AND DAM 3{ 81 u 4 01-SeD-91 ]HANNEL CATFISH 22 SKIN OFFCHIO RIVER 23 1ACINE LOCKS AND DAM 3l 5 8 4 o1 EL CATFISH '18 SKIN OFF

0.51

CHIO RIVER 23 iACINE LOCKS AND OAM 3{ d g 4 0'l-Jan4( A/HITE CRAPPIE t0 iKIN ONCHIO RIVER 23SIRACINE LOCKS AND DAM 3t 8 1-Jan 11

'KIN ON

CHIO RIVER 2g iACINE LOCKS ANO DAM 3t 5l I * 4 0l -Jan{( :RESHWATER DRUM t6 JKIN ONSHIO RIVER 23AIRACINE LOCKS AND DAM 3{ 5! 8 * 4 o'l-Seo-991 FRESHWATER DRUM

'KIN ON

CHIO RIVER 23SIRACINE LOCKS AND DAM at 5! I 4 0l -Jan{( ]HANNEL CATFISH 23', JKIN OFFf,HIO RIVER 231 1ACINE LOCKS AND DAM 3t 5! 8 t 4l O1-Jan4( ]ARP

'KIN ON llt

)HIO RIVER 23SIRACINE LOCKS AND DAM 3t 8 I 4( 0 -Seo-gglWHlTE BASS 121 ;KIN ON NR)HIO RIVER 238IRACINE LOCKS AND DAM 3t 5i 8 4l o -Seo-g1 :LATHEAO CATFISH 19: iKIN OFF OA)HIO RIVER 23SIRACINE LOCKS AND DAM 3t I , 4l 0 €eo-9( iAUGER 13 ;KIN ON)HIO RIVER 231 ?ACINE LOCKS AND DAM 3t 5a 8 4l o -Jan-O( ;TRIPED BASS 17 0.&

RIVER rRD LOCKS AND DAM 3t 4 8 'l 01-Jan{( ]HANNEL CATFISH 15 ]KIN OFF)HIO RIVER 27 SYRD POOL 3t 41 I 01-Jul4: iAUGER 12 ]KIN ON)HIO RIVER 3YRD LOCKS AND DAM 3t 41 8 1 01-Jan{( )HANNEL CATFISH 20 ]KIN OFF 0.8r

0.01

0.51

)HIO RIVER 279IBYRD POOL 3{ 4 8 01Jul-Oi ARGEMOUTH BASS 12 JKIN ON)HIO RIVER 279IBYRD LOCKS AND DAM 3{ 4 I 01-S( :RESHWATER DRUM ]KIN ON)HIO RIVER 279IBYRD POOL 3{ 4 8 01-Jul4: ]HANNEL CATFISH t9 I ]KIN OFF o-3

RIVER rRD POOL 3t 4 I 01Jul{: ]ARP 23 JKIN OFF 0.6:fHIO RIVER 279IBYRD LOCKS AND DAM 3t 4 R 01-Jan{0lWHlTE BASS t3( ;KIN ONf,HIO RIVER 27 ]YRD LOCKS AND DAM 3{ 4 A 01-Jan4( )ARP JKIN ON 0.6{f,HIO RIVER 279IBYRD LOCKS AND DAM 3{ 4 8 01-Seo{ ]ARP ;KIN OFFCHIO RIVER 27 3YRD LOCKS AND DAM 3( 4 I 01-Jan4( :RESHWATER DRUM 17' JKIN ON o.8lCHIO RIVER ]YRD POOL 3{ 4 8 01-Jul{: ;POTTED BASS 13 ;KIN ONCHIO RIVER 271 SYRD LOCKS AND DAM 3{ 4 8 01-Seo{ ]HANNEL CATFISH JKIN OFFCHIO RIVER 27( 3YRD POOL 3t 4 I o1-JUI42FRESHWATER DRUM N 1.61

0.6')HIO RIVER 274 BYRD LOCKS AND DAM 3{ 4 8 01-Jan{l lYBRIO STRIPED BASS | 1.1 JKIN ON)HIO RIVER 271 3YRD LOCKS AND DAM 3l 8 01-Jan4l :LATHEAD CATFISH 23

'KIN OFF

Page 9 of 13

PCB and Mercury DataAssociated with 2005 Fish Consumolion Advisories

Sorted by Waterbody

Wd.rbody Rhr(I|le LOCATPN

Irtltude Lmllud. Gdlectbn 3ped.3 L.noO FilletPremratlon

ll.rqry PCBSomD.o.lUlrLl8.c D.o,l l|ln.l S€c" Drt hcts m

t O BAILEY LAKE \,IINGOMYOMING COUNTIES. VVV 361 3( 8 4 501 10-Oct{ )HANNEL CATFISH 19 SKIN OFFt D BAILEY LAKE 3? 361 3r I 4 501 1o-Oct4i ;POTTED BASS 10 JKIN OFF{ U. tsAILEY UKE \,IINGO/IVYOMING COUNTIES. WV 361 3 501 10-Oct4

'POTTED BASS 16 JKIN OFF

R D BAILEY LAKE 36t 3( I 4 501 10-Oct4i ]HANNEL CATFISH 't5 JKIN OFF

SHAVERS FORK 8 ] 7 MILES ABOVE MOUTH 4 29-Auo{i 10( ;KIN OFF

o.52!

'HAVERS FORK 8

' 7 MILES ABOVE MOUTH 7 4 29-Auo{i SMALLMOUTH BASS 6t )KIN OFF

SHAVERS FORK 8 ] 7 MILES ABOVE MOUTH 4 ;KIN OFFFORK I } 7 MIt FS ABOVF MOI.'TH 24t 7l 4 29-Auo4, SUCKER lA ( }KIN OFF

;HAVERS FORK I I 7 MILES ABOVE MOUTH 7< 4 29-Auo4i ;MALLMOUTH BASS '12 | ;KIN OFF

9tROU' E 9 BRIDGE 3 1 7 4( 25-Seo42 REDBREAST SUNFISH 7 3ISKIN OFF)OAH RIVER IOUTE 9 BRIDGE 1 7 4! 2s-Sep42 BLUEGILL 6! ;KIN OFF

9tROU' E 9 BRIDGE 3 'l 7 4{ 25-Seo{2REDHORSE SUCKER 19( ]KIN OFFTOUTE 9 BRIOGE 3 1 7 4! 25-Seo{2ISMALLMOUTH BASS 111 JKIN OFF o.7171

JLEEPY CREEK LAKE ]ERKELEY COUNTY. VVV 39t 3( 4 7t 1s-Mav-01 TELLOW BULLHEAO 10( ;KIN OFF]LEEPY CREEK LAKE ]ERKELEY COTINTY. WV 39t 3l 4 7l 291 1s-Mav-Oi ARGEMOUTH BASS l0 illSKlN OFF]LEEPY CREEK LAKE ]ERKELEY COUNTY. VVV 39t 3( 4 at '15-Mav{: -ARGEMOUTH BASS 11( ;KIN OFFJLEEPY CREEK LAKE ELEY COUNTY- WV 39t 3l 4 7l 291 15-Mav-0: ARGEMOUTH BASS 15t iKIN OFF

Page 10 of l3

PCB and Mercury Datja

Associated with 2005 Fish Consumption AdvisoriesSorted by Waterbody

4 IEAR MOUTH 39 7t ? 15 JKIN OFFIEAR MOUTH 391 18-Jun42lCHANNEL CATFISH I

4 IEAR MOUTH 39 2 7l 5 18-Jun4i ]HANNEL CATFISH 20 ;KIN OFF4 IEAR MOUTH 391 301 3l 7l 3 5 18-Jun{i lEDHORSE SUCKER 1A :IN OFF4 {EAR MOUTH 391 301 3l 7l 3 5 18-Jun{Z REDHORSE SUCKER l8 ;KIN OFF

)OUTH BRANCH/POTOMAC RIVER 4 {EAR MOUTH ao 71 3l 5 '18-Jun-0i TH BASS 11

4 {EAR MOUTH 1( 30t 3l 18-Jun4i JMALLMOUTH BASS '12! JKIN OFF57', )LD FIELDS 3! 1 7t 3 l8-ADr{: TEDBREAST SUNFISH

'KIN OFF

57 )LD FIELDS 3! 1 7t 3 1 7-Jun{2lREDHORSE SUCKER 11 ;KIN OFF57.i )LD FIELDS 3! 1 7t 3 17-Jun{: iEDHORSE SUCKER 141 JKIN OFF57 )LD FIELDS 3! 1 7l 3 18-ADr43lROCK BASS 7! ;KIN OFFaa )LD FIELDS 3! 1 7l 3 '17-.hrn{)21 REDHORSE STJ(lKER 121

57 )LD FIELDS 3( 1 7l 5 17-Jun{: ;MALLMOUTH BASS 10: ;KIN OFF)OUTH BRANCH/POTOMAC RIVER 57 )LD FIELDS 1 3 l7-Jun-0 LMOUTH BASS 12i FF

57 )LD FIELDS 1 7l 5 3 17-Jun{i ;MALLMOUTH BASS 15 i ;KIN OFF

15.{ {EAR MOUTH OF BRAKE RUN 3{ 5 7a 7.3ISKIN OFF161 {EAR MOUTH OF BRAKE RUN 3l 5 7l 1 SUCKER 15 TtSKtN OFF161 {EAR MOUTH OF BRAKE RUN 3{ 7a l8-SeD{: ]UNFISH 6 ;KIN OFF

'OUTH FORI(SOUTH BRANCH 16 sINEAR MOUTH OF BRAKE RUN 3I 1 | 8-Seo-O: JMALLMOUTH BASS 10t ;KIN OFF o

;PRUCE KNOB LAKE { COUNTY, WV 3{ 4 7l 3! 1O-Jun{ ]ROWN BULLHEAD 12.! ;KIN OFF;PRUCE KNOB LAKE TANDOLPH COUNTY. WV 3l 4 7l 3l 10-Jun{ IAINBOW TROUT 13( iKIN OFF;PRUCE KNOB LAKE TANDOLPH COUNTY. WV 3l 7l 3! lO-Jun{: TAINAOW TROUT t4! ;KIN OFF

;TONECOAL LAKE COIJNTY. WV 3At 5t 4t 8( 5 1lJun{: ]HANNEL CATFISH t6_( }KIN OFFJTONECOAL LAKE _EW|S COUNW. WV 38t 5l 4t 8( 5 }Jun4: .ARGEMOUTH BASS 11 / ;KIN OFF

'TONECOAL LAKE -EWIS COUNTY. VW 38t 5l 4t 8( 5 13-Jun-O: ]HANNEL CATFISH 23 slSKtN OFF

JTONECOAL LAKE -EWIS COUNTY. WV 3at 5l 4/ 8( 3Jun4: A/HITE CRAPPIE 9'KIN

OFFJTONECOAL LAKE -EWIS COUNTY. WV 3at 5l 4t 80t 2 5 l 3-Jun{2ILARGEMOUTH BASS 14 ISKIN OFF

iTONEWALL JACKSON LAKE -EWIS COUNTY. WV 3 591 5l 801 2l o$Jun{2ICHANNEL CATFISH t3 iKIN OFFJTONEWALL JACKSON LAKE -EWIS COUNTY. VW 80t 2l 6( 02-Jul{: ]LACK CRAPPIE 7l JKIN OFFJTONEWALL JACKSON LAKE -EWIS COUNTY. VVV a 80t 2l 6( 02-Jul-0: /VALLEYE 12 OFFJTONEWALL.IACKSON LAKE EWIS COUNTY. V\l^/ 381 591 551 801 2Al 321 09-Mav-0: -ARGEMOUTH BASS 11 SKIN OFF

o-8871

JTONEWALL JACKSON LAKE -EWIS COUNry. WV 3t 6( 5 801 2l tlJun{i )HANNEL CATFISH 18 SKIN OFFIONEWALL JACKSON LAKE EWIS COUNry. WV 3( ( 80f 281 6( 02-Jul{: iAUGEYE t5 ]KIN OFF

]TONEWALL JACKSON LAKE .EWIS COUNTY. WV 3t 5( 5 801 2l o9-MaV{ZLARGEMOUTH BASS t5 SKIN OFF

STONEWALL JACKSON LAKE EW|S COItNTY. WV 3At 5! 55f 8ol 2al 321 og-Mav-o: t3 JKIN OFF

Page11of13

PCB and Mercury OataAssociated with 2005 Fish Consumotion Advisories

Sorted by Waterbody

{ICHOLAS COUNTY. WV 38 22t 8( 24-Jul4a. ;MALLMOUTH BASS 12( ;KIN OFFIMMERSVILLE LAKE LAS COI.JNry. WV 38 22t 8( t9-Jun{ IH 1t { OFF

,ICHOLAS COUN' 3l 1/ 22t 8( 5 '19-Jun{: TEDHORSE SUCKER 17.2ISKIN OFFJUMMERSVILLE LAKE NICHOLAS COUNTY. VVV 3l 1 221 8( 24-.\tloi ]HANNEL CATFISH SKIN OFF

\IICHOLAS COUN' 3t 221 8( 5 24-Jul4i JMALLMOUTH BASS 10 ! SKIN OFFSUMMERSVILLE LAKE {IUHULAJ UUUN IY. WV 3{ 1 221 8( 5 l9-.lun-0: .ARGEMOUTH BASS 15! 3KIN OFF

!ICHOLAS COUNTY. WV at 221 8( 5 31-oct4: A/ALLEYE t7e SKIN OFF 0.5110.5681SUMMERSVILLE LAKE \.IICHOLAS COUNTY. WV 3{ I 22t 8( 6 3l -Oc1-0i A/ALLEYE 12i SKIN OFF

SUMMIT LAKE 3{ 1 8( 2t 24JuI{3IBLUEGILL 5 ;KIN OFFSUMMIT LAKE 3t tl 8( 2t 24-Jul-0: -ARGEMOUTH BASS 8 JKIN OFFSUMMIT LAKE JKtENbKItsK UUUN I Y. WV 38t lst 6t 80t 2t 151 24-Jul43lBLUEG|LL N OFFSUMMIT LAKE 3REENBRIER COUN 3t 1 8( 24Jul{: .ARGEMOUTH BASS 'l2l SKIN OFFSUMMIT LAKE JKEENbKIEK UgUN I Y. WV 151 61 8l 2( 151 24-JUI{3IBLUEGILL 6 N OFFSUMMIT LAKE 3REENBRIER COUN 3t 1 8( 2( 24-Jul4: .ARGEMOUTH BASS 9 JKIN OFF

SUTTON LAKE ]RAXTON COUNry. WV 3t 80t 3l 29-AD[{3IREDHORSE SUCKER 16i ]KIN OFF

0.508r

SUTTON LAKE ]RAXTON COUNTY. VVV 3{ 3t 561 801 361 331 10-Jun. .ARGEMOUTH BASS 10i iIN OFFSUTTON LAKE ]RAXTON COUNry. WV 5r 80t 3( 10-Jun{: iPOTTED BASS 11 . JKIN OFF

UTTON LAKE AXTON COUNTY WV s5l 8ol 351 331 1o-Jun{2SPOTTED BASS 9l :IN OFFSUTTON LAKE SRAXTON COUNry. WV J 3{ 5 80t 3( 3 10-Jun{i ARGEMOUTH BASS t3 ]KIN OFFSUTTON LAKE ]RAXTON COUNry. WV 3t 801 351 2', 29-ADr{: t5 ;KIN OFF

; FORK 36 ,|T 3 sol 3ol a2l 241 391 o2-Jul-o: :LATHEAD CATFISH iKIN OFFrUG FORK 36 <ERM T 3 50f 301 821 241 391 02-Jul4i ]OLDEN REDHORSE SUCKER 14 ]KIN OFFrUG FORK 36 3 50f 301 a2l 241 391 O2-Jut-O: ONGNOSE GAR 211 iKIN OFF

ryGART LAKE TAYLOR COUNTY, WV a( 8( 3O-Oct4: :HANNEL CATFISH 't7 ]KIN OFFTYGART LAKE TAYLOR COUNTY. WV t( 8( 16-Mav-0: .ARGEMOUTH BASS '12 iKIN OFFryGART LAKE TAYLOR COUNTY- WV 3! 8( 16-Mav-Oi iMALLMOUTH BASS l'l ]KIN OFFryGART LAKE IAYLOR COUNry. WV 3! 8( lGMav-0: ]MALLMOUTH BASS t0 JKIN OFF

TYGART LAKE TAYLOR COUNTY. WV 1( 30-Oct-o: A/HITE BASS t0 SKIN OFFryGART LAKE IAYLOR COUNTY. VVV 8( 1s-ADr{: /VALLEYE 12 SKIN OFFryGART LAKE AYLUK UUUN I Y. WV 8( 16-Mav-0: SMALLMOUTH BASS '12( SKIN OFFryGART LAKE TAYLOR COUNry. WV 8( 15-ADr4: /VALLEYE 14 SKIN OFFTYGART LAKE TAYLOR COUNTY. WV 3 8( 30-Oct4: A/ALLEYE 19 ;KIN OFF 0./|82lryGART LAKE I-AYLOR COUNTY WV 3 8( l5-Aor{i A/ALLEYE 17t ;KIN OFF o5ryGART LAKE I'AYLOR COUNTY. VVV 3 8( 30-Oct4i iVHITE BASS 14! JKIN OFF 0.761

ryGART LAKE IAYLOR COUNTY. WV 3 a( l6-Mav-0: /ELLOW PERCH 7t ;KIN OFFTYGART LAKE IAYLOR COUNTY. WV 3 8( 16-Mav-0: TELLOW PERCH )KIN OFF

Page 12 of '13


Sorted by Waterbody

$rrtertody Rlverlllla LOCATION

t tltude Lonoltude Collecllon 8pccL. LEf|eM Fill{rtPhdrtlan

Uafclry PC83oDmIt d- l Hln- lS* Dm-lllln-l Sm- Dale lmls

ryGART VALLEY RIVER 8 :LKINS 381 551 261 7l 5 451 25-Jtl4t ARGFMOIITH BASS 101 JKIN OFF 0.t7tTYGART VALLEY RIVER I :LK NS 38t 55t 21 5 4! 25-Jul4l LARGEMOUTH BASS 14t ;KIN OFFryGART VALLEY RIVER 8 :LK NS 381 551 21 7 5 4 25-Jul{2IBULLHEAD 12i ;KIN OFF

ilEST FORK RIVER 23! ,IEAR SPELTER 391 201 571 8( 1! 1 I 7-Sep-oaCHANNEL CATFISH 14i SKIN OFF (ilEST FORK RIVER 23! 'IEAR SPELTER 391 201 571 8( 1{ 1l 1 7-SeD42ICHANNEL CATFISH 16( SKIN OFF o

ryHEELING CREEK 1t 'IEAR SHERRARD 8( 10 SKIN OFF0.0A/HEELING CREEK l4INEAR SHERRARO 391 591 341 8ol 3i 14 SKIN OFF

^/HEELING CREEK 1t .IEAR SHERRARD g 8( 3 21 SKIN OFF

UHEELING CREEK 18( !EAR BURCHES RUN 58t 3t 8( e 5 1s-Mav{: ;MALLMOUTH BASS 9 SKIN OFFA/HEELING CREEK 18t {EAR BURCHES RUN 391 s8l 321 a( '15-Mav-0: ;MALLMOUTH BASS 1'l

'KIN OFF o.471

VHEELING CREEK JNKNOWN 15-Mav{: JMALLMOUTH BASS t5 iKIN OFF

/VILLIAMS RIVER 22IBELOW TEA CREEK 2( 45t 8( 1' 27-Auo4i TAINBOW TROUT 9 ]KIN OFFA/ILLIAMS RIVER 22IBELOW TEA CREEK 38f 201 451 8( 1. O2INORTHERN HOGSUCKER '10

'KIN OFF 0.0

/VILLIAMS RIVER 22IBELOW TEA CREEK ?t 2( 45t 8( 27-Auo4i ]ROWN TROUT tl ]KIN OFF o.

Page 13 of 13

To: Legislative Rule Making and Review CommitteeRe: Mercury RuleDate: January 10,2005

The following outline follows the process that led to the proposed changes for mercurystandards sent to the Legislature by the Environrnental Quality Board during the lastTriennial Review. Environmental Quality Board meetings along with EQB action takenare indicated along with public comments.

Novenber 412002 Board MeetingIssues regarding mercury during Triennial Review discussion.Section 8.18. Mercury. The DEP has suggested that the Board clariff the application ofbody burden value for mercury. Ms. Charles informed the Board that she had researchedthe issue and would recommend that the Board change the language in that section toprovide "The total organissl body burden of appropriate aquatic species shall notexceed..." and adopt footnote O from USEPA's National Recommended Water QualityCriteria 2002 which provides " the fish tiszue residue for methylmercury is based on atotal fish consumption rate of 0.0175 kglday."The Board directed staffto incorporate this proposed change into the criteriacomparison table they are creating for the Board's review.

April 16,2003 Board MeetingThe Board members expressed concern regarding removal of the methylmercury valuefrom the Human Health - Category A (Water Supply Public) and determined that it wouldrequire additional information and input from the USEPA and the WYDEP prior tomaking a final determination on the values for this criteria.

April L7, z}O3Board MeetingSection 8.18. Mercury.The Board retained section 8.18 in Appendix E which contains the human health totalbody burden value for mercury of 0.5. Also in section 8.18.1 the Board retained the in-strdam total mercury value of 0.15 for human health Category 6C" and a humanhealth Category o'At' mercury value of 0.14, but deleted the acute aquatic life valueof 2.4 from that section, the motion canied sianimsusly 5 to 0.

The Board adopted dissolved mercury values for Aquatic Life of Acute 1.4 ugll andAquatic Life Chronic of 0.77 ugllwith the appropriate conversion factor, but deletedthe methylmercury parameter in section 8.8.2 from Appendix E of the rule.

July 11 2003; Libby Chaffield's MemoSummery of Comments on proposed revisions to 46 CSR I

Summary of proposed revisions and associated Board action.

$95.a-95.c Mercury. Revised WV mercury values

. USEPA encourages Board to consider adoption of the 2002 NationalRecommended Water Quatity Criteria for nercury.

June 23, 2003 correspondence from EPA.Evelyn MacKnight, ChiefPA/DE/WV Branch

Mercury and Methylmercury"EPA has updated its national recommended mercury and methylmercury criteria

for human health and they are available in the repor! National Recommended WaterQualitv Criteria: 2002 (EPA-822-R-02-047). EPA encourages WV to review EPA'shuman health methylmercury criterion and consider adoption of the EPAzD0zNationaIRecommended Water Quality Criteria for this parameter.

.IOGA (Independent Oil and Gas Association) suggests adoption of current MCLof 2.0 ug/I for inorganic mercury for category A protection.

June 23, 2003 correspondence from lndependent Oil and Gas Association of WestVirginia

M. Axn Bradley, attorney

" Mercury - The Board has proposed to eliminate the acute criterion for'totalMercury in any unfiltered water sample" for aquatic life. The Board has not proposed anychange however in this criteria as it would apply to Category of Category C. SEE Section8.1,46 CSR.

1. Consistent with action the Board has taken with regard to other parameters, theBoard should have proposed to change the Mercury criterion to2ugl,the current MCLfor "inorganic mercury" as established under the federal SWDA. See 40 CFR 141.62(b).Because there is not crurently a human health criteria established by EPA under theCWA, to adopt MCL as established under the SWDA would be consistent with EPAguidance, and other guidance that has been heretofore provided to the Boatd."

August 11200346 CSR 1

Requirements Governing Water Quality StandardsResponses to Comments and Explanation of Proposed Amendments

$95.a - 95.c. Mercury Proposed replacing current aquatic life criteria with USEPA'srecommended values for dissolved mercury for protection of Categories Bl, 82, and B4.Current human health mercury criteria retained.

. USEPA encourages Board to consider adoption of the 2002 NationalRecommended Water Quality Criteria for mercury - which include new bodyburden values.. Another commenter suggests adoption of current 2u91for inorganic mercwyfor Category A protection.

Board Response. [n our review of this parameter, the Board considered of USEPA'srecently developed body burden value for mercury. We were concerned, however,because the agency's implementation guidance for the new body burden value has notbeen completed. Moving to a body burden value, without in sheam values, norimplementation guidance would provide little assistance to the WVDEP ia imFlementingthe new criteria- We determined that retaining our current human health values untilUSEPA's implementation guidance is finalized is the appropriate route to take forthisparameter. We note that a revision to this section is needed to provide reference to theConversion Factor (CF) for the dissolved aquatic life criteria for mercury.Board Action. Proposed revisions adopted; also adopted reference to conversion factorsfor aquatic life criteria.

The WV Environmental Quality Board Agency Proposed Legislative Rulesubmitted to the Legislature on May 19,2003 contained the following criteria formercury.

Aquatic Life Human HealthParameter CAS Bl, 84 B2

Acute Chronic Acute Chronic A C95aMercury-dissolved (ug/l) 7439976 1.4 0.77 1.4 0.779sb.Total mercury in any 0.14 0.15unfiltered water sampleshall not exceed (ugn)95.cMercury - total organism 0.5 0.5

body burden of appropriateaquatic species shall notexceed 0.05 ug/g as

methyl mercury

l.The WV Environmental Quality Board Agency Approved Legislative Rulesubmitted to the Legislature on August 1,2003 contained the following criteria formercury.

Aquatic Life HumanHealthParameter CAS 81, B4 Bz

Acute Chronic Acute Chronic A C95a.Mercnry-dissolved (ugA) 7439976 l.4CFs 0.77CFs l.4CFs 0.77CFs9sb.Total mercury in any 0.14 0.15

unfiltered water sampleshall not exceed (ugA):95.cMercury - total organi56 0.5 0.5

body burden of appropriateaquatic species shall notexceed 0.05 ug/g as

methyl mercury.

The Legislative Rule passed by the Legislature and Final Filed by theEnvironmental Quality Board on May 7r20O4 contained the following criteria formercurT.

Aquatic Life HumanHealthParameter 81, B4 B2

Acute Chronic Acute Chronic A C

8.18 MercuryThe total organism body burden 0.5 0-5

of any aquatic species shall notexceed 0.5 uglg as

methybnercury.8.18.1Total mercwy in any 2.4 2.4 0.14 0.15

unfiltered water sampleshall not exceed (udl):8.18.2Methybnercury (water column) 0.12 0.12

Not to exceed (ug/l):

I have placed the Legislative Rule focused on Mercury from August l, 2003 (the finalrule that went to the Legislature from the EQB) and the Legislative Rule focused onMercury from May 7 ,2004 (the final rule passed by the Legislature) together on theprevious page for comparison.

The standards in the Legislative Rule have not been revised, and remain those in placeprior to the triennial revision proposed to the Legislature. I hope this provides someinsight on the EQB's position as it relates to the ongoing debate on this maffer. Thankyou for the opportunity to address the committee, and I sincerely thank you for yourinterest in addressing the important policy matters related to water protection for the Stateof West Virginia

Thank you for your interest in addressing the important policy matters related to waterprotection for the State of West Virginia

Chair, West Virginia Environmental Quality Board

/t

o

o

To: Legislative Rule Making and Review ComnitteeRe: Manganese RuleDate: January 10,2005

As a background to the issue of manganese, and as you are aware, the Environmental

Quality Board conducted a review of the Water Quahty Standards rule and submittedamendments to it that were considered by the Legislature in the 2004 session. On July 23,

2002,the Board solicited public comments regarding issues that the Board should address

during its upcoming triennial review. The EQB did not receive comments on themanganese 5-mile rule language, and did not therefore propose revisions to it. t\rring the

legislative session, the manganese 5-mile rule revision was advanced by the regulatedcommunity and adopted as an amendment to the rule in House Bill 4193. After passage

of the bill, the Coal Association contacted our staff, and followed up with a lettersuggesting that the EQB provide appropriate justification of the manganese revision-

The EQB reviewed that letter at its May 2004 meetrng and agreed to write the House and

Senate Judiciary Committee chairmen to request any supporting documentation that itconsidered when revising the rule. (The letter was carbon copied to the Legislative RuleMaking and Review Committss). The EQB atso agreed at the May meeting that if noinformation was forthcoming from the committees, thatthe rule would be forwarded tothe EPA with an explanation of the situation and of the EQB's ef[ort to get supportingdocumentation.

The EQB received responses from Senator Kessler, and from Senator Ross and Delegate\dahan, indicating that no supporting data was available. ln early June those letters wereforwarded to USEPA along with the rule package, in accordance with the Clean WaterAct requirements for submission of WQS revisions to the agency for review and

approval.

OnJune 8th the EQB received documents from the Coal Association which included a

rationale in support of the revised manganese S-mile rule language. The EQB addressed

the Coal Associations submission at its June l lth meeting and agreed to forward thatinforrration, without recommendation, to the USEPA. Furttrer, we agreed to provide an

opportunity for the public to submit infonnation in response to the manganese revision byJuly Zod, which mJeqn would also forward to the USEPA. A number of additionalcomments were received and forwarded to the agency on July 6th" also withoutrecommendation from the EQB. All these comments were forwarded to the Committeein a letter dated July l5th, 2004.

There was a statement made before this committee in June of 2004 by Chris Hamilton ofthe West Virginia Coal Association that the EQB was unwilling to cooperate inaddressing the revision to the "manganese 5-mile rule", that the EQB had not been

willing to forward information from the coal association to the USEPA, and further thatthe EQB had "lost the information or sornething". No document was lost or retainedinappropriately by theEQB during the process. Further, the EQB has historically been

receptive to comments by the Coal Association and prioritized mining issues includingremining permits.

The Coal Association has also expressed concern that they have sent a great deal ofinfonnation to the EQB over the years regarding impacts of manganese pollution, and has

criticized the EQB for not forwarding the historic information in support on themanganese 5-mile rule. I agree that we have received manganese information over theyeaxs, but all that information addressed the toxicity of manganese to aquatic life. TheEQB removed aquatic life limits for manganese a number of years ago.

The manganese 5-mile rule being discussed today addresses the human health protectionvalue. It is my opinion that sending the "historic data" addressing aquatic life matters forwhich the standards have been removed from the rule would have been irrelevant inevaluating the change of the human health criterion.

To put it simply, the data needed to support the human health criteria is different from thedata needed to make the prior change in the aquatic life criteria The EQB does not havestudies or scienffic information to address the human health criterion change.

By letter received on December27,2004,EPA informed the EQB that it is defeningaction on the "Manganese Five Mile Rule" change while it evaluates and collectsadditional information sufficient to finalize a decision. As EPA moves to collect theinformation and to evaluate it, we are willing to assist EPA in its efforl

I hope this provides some insight on the EQB's position as it relates to the ongoingdebate on this matter. Thank you for the opportunity to address the committee, and Isincerely thank you for your interest in addressing the important policy matters related towater protection for the State of West Virginia

Chair, West Virginia Environmental Quality Board

Print Versioti Page I of'|

*.*", '{ r''

qualibl ot streams cannot be comprornised for any reason

lohn Denver toud'led on only a sllce d l'lr6t Virginia when he sang about the Shenandoah River'

But we're sure his view of "Atr,-.ogt Heaven' included all of the state's streams, arery mile of thcrn'

L;sr week, a chsnicat industrg ofiicial told state legislatoi's that west virginia should stop requiriftg that all

of its rivers and streams be clean enough to ciinr. irom. John Hili of Dow chemical was speaklng on b€haif of

the west virginia Flanufa€turers Association, llhich vlants the Legistature to chanqe a 1950s-era state rule

goveming water quality standards.

He said Huntington Afloys has paid thousands of dollars to trcat what it tlischarges into a nearbY creek that

"is not nor ever uuill be a public water supplY."

"Having alt the waterways in west Virginia m€et dri;Hng water standards is lii(e havtng all the highways in

the state meet schoot zone speed standards," he sakl-

we fail to see the togic in his anatogy. Highways don't flow and carry toxins that enter our botlis' Rivers and

str€n€ dc- Highwa)5 drcn"! attracf s'*immers, fisherrnen and boaters- Rivers and strearns do- Highulays are

not home to aquatic life. RiYers and streams are.

Thafs not being environrnenblly extreme. Thafs being honest'

Hitl also termed the protecuon "an unnecssary burden that pro',rid€ no publlc benefltg"

He is ofrthe mark- lgatcr is our rnost important regource. Be€ause of water t#c have agricutture' r4rcational

tDurism, green halds, tre€s, fish. wildiife, water for our hontg and businesses- When'ft colrt6 right down to

lL we have a water-based trono{nY.

The damage that can be done ts certainty to the publlcs detrtment. A lltfle stream Rows lnto a larger one

that flolrs in a creek that flo!{s into a river - rerfiaps the very crek or rtver fmm whidt our drinkhg ttjater

@mes.

Industrial eonbminants are not easily diluted and surely have-more far-reaching effects than Hill - or the

compenles he represents -- ls wllltng to clalm.

wesi vlrginia and the nation have come a long way slnce the dap when there were gugtlons whether some

rivers and stFeafixs ectually contalned water

We don,t want to retum to those days. we owe it tD ourselves and to comtng generauons to continue theprogress toward better and better water qualiEy.

For tfie sake of $lose who live here and those who vislt, water quality can't b€ comPromlse{l- If West Virginla

ls tndeed'Almost Fleaven,' lefs kep ittf'3t way-

http://rrmrur.register-heraldcom/articlesl2m4/l l/t7lditorisvl leditlT-p* ultTlzarM

-

/t

o

o

Katherine Bonenberger

Dana Sill

Pamela Graham

Lois Logan

Melissa Cochran-Gust

Michelle Spagnuolo

Shawn Fox

Amanda Hatfield

Billie Taylor

Laura Santos

Michele Schmidt

Julie Likar

AmandaDight

Donie Bintz

Darcy Henry

Terica Springer

Maria Weatherspoon

Dawn Bames

Donna Tweel

lefi a message

will renew it

left a message

Less likely

lefi a message

will renew it

will renew it

will renew it

left a message

Will renew it

will renew it

Less likely

will renew it

Lert a message

Less likely

left a message

less likely

will renew it

will renew it

PA

FL

VA

NC

OH

NC

TN

MD wouldn't like it

MD

MN

VA

PA

VA

OH

OH

KS

NC

PA would like biennial renewals

TN

Based on the duta guthered I oat of every 3 oat of state licensed hygienists are less

tikely to renew, resalting in u potential net loss of 137 licensees under line item 4.8.

H. Richard Marshall, Jr.. DDSPresident120 Maplewood AvenueRonceverte. \I\t\t 2497 0

Mrs- Dina Agnone Vaughan, BSDH, MS

^-hcretaryIE-"-îe \UarJ..,:^r.,-^ rrl\t 1/onl

George D. Conard, Jr., DDS6353 Easr Pea Ridge Road

Hunrington, \l7V 2570-5

John C. Dixon, DDS1961 Parkwood Road

Charleston, qIV 25314

Richard D. Smith, DDSi50l Seventh Avenue

Charleston, \ 11' 253I1

John F. ParkuloExecutive Secretarl'207 S. Heber SLreet

BeckleY, l\/\/ 15801

V,EST \/IRGI}-IIA B OA}T[) OtrDET.TTAL E)iAI{IhIERS2OTS.HEBERSTREETBECM-EY.\\/\I]5801

(3{A.t252-8266Toll Free ( E 77 )

L.) 1 1-826('Fax: ili(a)253'9-l-54

w\4'\'.\,vdentalboard.orgwvbde@charterintemet conl

Bernard J- Grubler, DDS154 Leewood Farnrs Road

Wheeling, W\' 26003

James SI. Vargo, DDS92 Brookshire LaneBecklev, I \1 :5801

Mrs. Debra D. Dent, CDA56 Siiver Maple Lane

Union, W\,' 24983

Mrs. Dolores L Gtibble1l Davis Place

Clarksburg, W\/ 25301

Susan M. Combs

Office Manager207 S. Heber Srreet

BeciJey, W\/ 15801

June 10,2004

RE: 5CSR1, 5CSR2, 5CSR3 & 5CSR6

Dear Licensee:

Please find enclosed a copy of proposed rule changes to Title 5, Series 3 of the Code ofSate Regulations concerning the Board's fee schedule. This proposed rule is scheduled for a

comment period to end on July 12,2004 at 4:00 pm. Comments are to be mailed to the Board'saddress, 207 South Heber Street, Beckley, West Virginia 25801 . Any comments received after4:00 pm July 12, 2004 will not be considered.

Also, please be advised the Board has also set a comment period for proposed rulechanges to Series 'l , the Rule for the West Virginia Board of Dental Examiners mainly for changesto continuing education requiremenis, Series 2, Formation and Approval of Professional LimitedLiability Companies for language changes concerning names of PLLC and Series 3, Formation andApproval of Dental Corporations for language changes concerning names of Corporations.

These rules may be viewed on the Board's website at www.wvdentalboard.orq or you maycallthe Board's office or the Secretary of State's office for a copy of these proposed rules. Thecomment period for these proposed rules ends on July 12,2004 at 4:00 pm. Comments are to bemailed to the Board's address, 207 South Heber Streeet, Beckley, West Virginia 25801. Anycomments received after 4:00 pm July 12, 2004 will not be considered.

As always, if you have any questions please do not hesitate to contact'this office.

JFP/smcEnclosures

JOHN F. PARKULOExecutive Secretarv

f wEST vLRGtF{iA/ SECR.ETARY CF STATE

*!CE [dAhTCF{II-J, III

EN MINISTR"ATIVE LAVf D IVi SIOruFonn #- =

NCTICE OF A CCIV]MENT PERICD CN A' PRCPOSED RULE

aGENCY: \nl::;i \lirgjnia Branl of ir=nial F>::rninar-r TITLE]'JLI1vIEIEI'L:

E-ULE T\?E,; 1p:i qlativ: CITE ALTTHCRITY:

A-lvGl'{Dh'IEl{T TO A]'i E}JSTING RULE: f"gS )' l{C) --

nr \TS. SEFIES NUh4BEI'- OF F.lJl-E BEn'lG -L]VIE\DED: '3

TITLE OF RLLE BENG '{'{ENDED:Fees Esi-ablisi-hj b\'TfE Bo?xl

Dc, No-- Mari: In This Bo>

F NO, SERES NI,]lvtsE'R OF RI-IT-E BEING PROPOSED:

TITLE OF F-tiLE BEtr'lG PROPOSED:

N.{ LIEU OF APT]BLIC TIEARN{G, A COMN'ff'NT PENOD IL{S BEEN ESTABLISIIED DLII'b]G \\TilCH

AN1'NTERESTEDPERSONMAY SEND COT4MENTS CONCERNI'IGT}tr'SEPROPOSEDB.LILES' TIilS

coN4MENTpERloD \{[-L END ON # AT +:eO pn ONLY WR]TTEbI

COM}4ENTS 'v\rILL BE ACCE'PTED A}rD r's.E To BE MAtr-ED To TIfi FOLLO'*|D{G ADDR'ESS:

14.51 thginia@

207 Sci-ILh lleler Streel TTIE,ISSIJES TO BE IIEARD S}TAIL BE

LN4ITED TO TTTIS PROPOSED RULE'

Becklelz, W ?5801

OF YOUF, PF.OPOSALATTACIf A ERTEF SUI'{I\'IARY

\

o

SUMMARY OF PROPOSED RULE

To increase various application and renewal fees as well as charging for services

currently supplied by the board that are noi recouped at this time but are services

charged by other State boards.

/

o

STATEMENT OF CI RCUMSTAN CES

To enable the Board to continue to carry out effectively their responsibilities of

licensure registration and discipline of individuals subjectto their authority by increasing

the various application and renewal fees as well as charging for services. currently supplied

ty the board that are not recouped at this time, in order to prepare for increased costs of

office expenses anticipaied in the shorl term, including but not limited to' rent

increase/relocation costs, additional legal expenses, increased costs associated with two

additional Board Members, anticipated costs of hiring a hearing exanriner; increased costs

oftnsurancepremiums,andfutureconsiderationstosalaryincreasestocurrentemployees.

FI

APPENDL\ B

FISCAL NOTE FOR. PROPOSED R.IILES

Ruie Title:

v a .11:-.^ ProceduralTvpe of Rul.' x Legisiative lnterpretve

AsencY:

?ffi enutfi flebeT Slre^tLVI W{OOIESS:

Becktey, W 5801

1. Effect of Proposedruie: These ann-nts are only o!T."ttd anJ wlild be approprlated to ttle

proper bdget LjIe itms to n'ebt the bGrds n"eds ir jrcreases are passd'

ANNUAI' FISCAI YEAR

INCREASE I DECREASE .rrppFN.r I f.inXf ITHEREAFTER

273,0C0.00 273,000.0 373,0C0.00ESTIMATED TOTAICOST

lm,c00.00 0

0 u9,55o.Co a9,420.0 rcO,0m.mPERSONAL SER\'ICES 30,450.m

90.150.m BB. q80.0 143.(^m.mCURRENT EX?ENSE 52,850.00 0

REPAIRS &ALTERATIONS

2,0c0.00 0 t_,000.00 5C0.0 3'C0o.c0

1? rm rn7.5cn.m sm0EQI.IIPMENT 4.5m.001 0

OTHER F'n-BmefiJs---.: ln

2, F,xpianation of Above Estimates:

Estjnntes are based, on pnojctiors of lrcrease jn application, rel-nnal ad pemiL fees

only, misc. fees not itituO"a d-b to lack of st4portive data'

3. Objectives of These Ruies:

To jrnrease Lt]e AIruaf &-dget of f?re Boad as set for[h jn the StateTPl.lt of Ci:crmstarces'

\

o

/

o

l'rr l+ r ITIP'

E::pianatr on oi C)r'erall Economrc Imp zrcl oi Prop o s eo fiule :

-^,. Economrc Impaci ol Stare Govemtl:nt:

Tb allo^, ttE Boad of IF*ntaL h;annno:s to effe:tirr.-I1' drsC'rar:ze ttnir r-eq:rrsLbilitresa'-s set for-th ir-i the Statarert'- of Cinlnsian:es.

B. Economtc Impact on Pohtrcal Subdilisionsl specific lndusrnes' specific Groups of

Ciuzens:

l{cnrinal ircrouse rn app}icatjorL, r-an:iual anf p'rnrif fe'q asso:iated \"Jith the prrtice of

dentig'ry jn tbe Stale of West \/jrgxna.

C. Economic Impact ori CitizensPubiic at l-arse'

possibLe nmirnl imrease il cosis of D.na"l- Senaces in *te StaLe of lbsr \li:=irria'

Date:JLnre 10 20ch

o

Sisnaure of Agency Head or Authorized Representatlve:

5CSR3

TITLE,5I-EGISLATI\'E RUI,E

WEST \ryRGINIA ROARD OF DENTAL EXA-MINERS

SERIES 3

FEES ESTABI,ISI{ED E\'Ttr{E BOATTD

$5-3-1. General.

1.1. Scope, * Trris legisiative ruie establisires fees for the Board of Dental Examiners'

1.2. Authodty. -- W. Va. Code $$30-1-6 and 30-4-4/^'

1.3. FilingDate. --

1.4. Effective Date. --

\

o

$5-3-2. Schedule of Fces ftrr Dcntists'

2..l. Dental Licensure Application

2.2. Re-examination fee for Dentists Gaw Exam)

ZZ 2.3. Out of State Dentist - Dental Licenswe Application

* 2.4. TemPorary Pennit

* Z.t Dental Lrtern/Dentai Residencl' Permit

* Z.6.Teaching Permit

7# 2.7 .Investigation of Qualification for Temporary' Dental

hrtelrVDental Residency or Teaching Permits

--2+ 2.8. Annual Ilformation & Renewal fee for a General Dentist Practicing In State

+r2ffi0 $1s0.00

$5e.00 $1-s0.00

$20.00

sl€+€o $250.00

$+90;00 $150.00

$5ess $100.00

$+€€s0 $1s0.00

ss0.00

$200.002.9.

$s-3-s1.

s!.1.

3.2.

Scheclule of fees for Specialty Licensure for Dentists'

D ental Specialty Licensure Application $3€O3s $4s0.00

$200.00

/

o

:L: N:'

55-3-4!. Schedu}e of Fees for Dental Corporations'

4!.1. Application to Form a Dental Corporation

45.2. Amrual R€.gl-stffifion reneu,al fee for a Dental Colpotation

5-3-5. Sched fees f,or' sional ited Liatrilifv C anles.

i.1 Application to Fonn a Dental Professional Linrited

Liabilin' Conipany

55-3-31 Scireduie o{'Fees 1'or livgictiists'

3f,1. Denral ll\rglene Liceusut'e -tpphcarion $'H+e $ir0'0t)

]dl. Iie-e>ramilatiou fee foi Delral flygienisrs {'Lau E>lani) $ft;se Sl20 0t)

l:1.3. Clr-rr of Srate Dental ll,r,gienisr - Dental lil'gi.t tt, Licensure -A.pplicatiorr $':€-$0 S; I 00'00

34.4. Tempolary Pennit

i4.5. I eac)ring Pemrit

sr100.00

$ 1 t)0.t)0

}1=6.lnr,estigationofQua1ificationforTenrporar1'.ffi-*:csrtcnef-or Teachhc I'ertlits $50'00

i4.7. Anlr,ral ilfonnation &Reneu,al fee for a Dental Fl1'gienist Practicing ln State

ffise $65.00

l lliomr &R for O State tal Hvcienisr S85.00

$200.00

s150.00

$5-3-6. Scheclule of fees for Anesthesia.

6.1. Class Tu'o Cerlification Application Fee

6.2. Class Ts'o Certification Renerval Fee

8.3. Class Thlee or Foul Penlit Applicarion Fee

8.4. Class Tlu'ee or Four Petmit Reneu'al Fee

$5-3-62. Schedule for n{isceilaneous Fees'

$200.00

$150.00

$50.00

$25.00

$600.00

$200.00

'ofessio

Liabiiiw Company

5CSR3

62.1. \lelification of Licensur:e to another State

(Ciralge for licensee)

7.2. \/elification of Licensr-rle (otlrer entities)

7.3. Ccl,n'se approval application fee

7.4. Durplicate renewal license

7.5. Duplicate wall cerlificate

7.6. Roster of Active Dentai/Flygiene Licensees

(paper. enrail or cd)

7.7. Roster of Aotive Dental'&I]'eiene Licensees (labels')

7.8. Rostel of Actirre Dental/l-Ivgiene Licensees (one countr')

(paper. email or labels)

7.9. Miscellaneoirs Copies ([Lrst page)

additional Pages

'1 1 A T) o+.i o. ro I Fac/ t\r. t\ultlvvGr r vv

r\l

tirewa

bv staturte ot'rule.

8.2. Any Linte or rule bt

fee ofsaid iicensee'

$5-3-9. Returned Checks.

9.1. RetLrrned Cireck Cirarse

$5-3-L0. Non Refundable.

1 0. 1 . All fees ar e non-refundable'

$tSiOO 525.00

$25.00 per nante

$100 00

$s.00

$10.00

$50.00 per list

$100.00 per list

$ I0.00 per list

$3.00$0.2s

$25.00

il toual

forlh

WEST VTRGINIA BOARD OF DENTAL EXAMINERS PROPOSED LIII-E ITEMEXPENDITTJRES FOR ESTIMATED ADDITIONAL MONIES

TO BE GENERATED BY PROPOSED F'EES

5. Computer/Office EquiPment 5,000

1. Rent

2. PElA/Retirement

3. lnsurance

4. Phone

6. 2 additional members

7. 2 additional meetings

8. Legal/Professional

9. Hearing Examiner

Total Lines 1- 9

7,200

10,000

2,000

2,000

20,000

14,000

2,000

25,000

87,200

10. Remainder to replenish reserve account to ll5 budget at end of September.

1 1. Any savings or excess to be used for consideration of larger office accomodations and/or

employee salary increases.

ESTIMATED ADDITIONAL MOI\'IES TO BE GENERATED BY PROPOSED FEESWITH SOME SUPPORTING DATA

Line Item

2.8

2.9

3.2

Subtotal

Line Item

4.7

4.8

Subtotal

Total of Renewal Fees

Line Item

2.1

2.3

3.1

4.1

4.3

Total of Application tr'ees

Line Item

7.1

7.2

Total of Verification fees

GRAND TOTAL

17,525

26,1,75

14,700

58,400


10,530

14,840

25,370

93,770


2,500.00

3,750.00

1,500.00

7,125.00

500.00

9,375.00

Additional Monies Es t"nated

1,200.00

2,500.00 - 5,000.00

3,700.00 - 6,200.00

96,845.00 - 99,345.00

43 * $200: $8,600 (note loss calculated atcurrent fee plus proposed increase.)

137 * $85 : $11,645 (note loss calculatedat curent fee plus proposed increase.)

Additional Monies Estimated Esfimated Fees Lost - Non Renewals

Dr. Abou-Rizk

Dr. Sa:n D'Arco

Dr. Sanford Fenton

Dr. David Funderburk

Dr. Gregory Hill

Dr. Randall Patterson

Dr. Mark Mitchell

Dr. George Shepley

Dr. William H. Mason

Dr. Judith Porter

Dr. Robert Hamilton

Dr. John Ambrose

Dr. Teresa Conley

Dr. Suzanne McCorrnick

Dr. Catherine Tebay

Dr. John Canter

Dr. Jean Carlson

Dr. Michael Hedmond

Dr. Michele Jasper

Dr. Steve Kirk

Dr. Harry Legan

Dr. Ricky Massullo

would renew at $200

would renew at $200

would renew at $200

would renew at $200

would renew at $200

left a message

less likely to renew TX

would renew at $200 TN

left a message

he may be willing to let it go after a few years

less likely to renew

would renew at $200

would renew at $200

would renew at $200

would renew at $200

would renew at $200

would renew at $200

would renew at $200

would renew at $200

would renew at $200

left a message

left a message

VA

NV

GA

NC

GA

TN

CO

FL

PA

FL

NC

CA

WY wouldn't like it, but wouldkeep it

VA

MD would like to see inactivefee

OH

SC

FL

MD

MD

Based on the datu collected I oat of every 9 oat of state licensed dentis* are less likelyto renew, resalting in u potential net loss of 43 licensees ander line item 2.9.

/ ISTATEMENT OF MONIES RECEIVED FOR THE

FlscAL YEARS 2003 & 2004

Renewals -DentistsRenewals-HygienistRenewals-Dental CorPorationsRenewal--Gen. AnesthesiaRenewal--PLLC'sApplication f ees-SPecialistsApplication fees-Dentistslntern PermitsApplication f ees-HYgienistsApplication fees-Gen' AnesthesiaApplication f ees-CorPorationApplication fees-P. L. L. C'sReinstatement feesLicense VerificationsAnderson & AssociatesCosts & Fines

TOTAL MONIES RECEIVED:

2003

149,875.0051,435.0024,250.OO

5,700.006,000.002,100,003,050.00

50.002,510.001,500.002,000.002,800.002,050.00

730.001,650.001,500.00

$257,200.00

2004

148,1 00.0052,975.OO20,400.00

5,200.006,600.002,700.oo3,550.00

0.001,990.00

600.002,400.oo3,600.00

100.00770.OO300.00

3,500.00

$252,785.00

/

oSTATEMENT OF MONIES RECEIVED FOR THE

FISCAL YEARS 2OO1 & 2OO2

Renewals -DentistsRenewals-HygienistRenewals-Dental CorPorationsRenewal--Gen. AnesthesiaRenewal--PLLC'sApplication f ees-SPecialistsApplication f ees-Dentistslntern PermitsApplication f ees-HYgienistsApplication fees-Gen. AnesthesiaApplication f ees-CorPorationApplication fees-P. L. L. C'sCertif icate f ees-DentistsCertif i cate f ees-HYgi enistsReinstatement feesLicense VerificationsCopiesAnderson & AssociatesCosts & Fines


2001

92,325.OO49,875.OO20,850.004,800.003,450.002,700.oo2,050,00

50.001,975.001,800.001,200.00

600.00135.00150.00300.00830.00204.45

1,200.007,500.00

$ 191 ,994.45

2002

149,375.O050,400.0020,850.004,900.002,700.oo2,100.003,1 50.00

50.002,550.001,200.002,400.oo2,200.oo

0.00o.o0

100.00780.00

o.o02,550.00

14,002.00

$259,307.O0

/

ISTATEMENT OF MONIES RECEIVED FOR THE

FISCAL YEARS 1999 & 2OOO

Renewals -DentistsRenewals-HygienistRenewals-Dental CorPorationsRenewal--Gen. AnesthesiaRenewal--PLLC'sApplication f ees-SpecialistsApplication fees-DentistsApplication f ees-HygienistsApplication fees-Gen. AnesthesiaApplication f ees-CorporationApplication fees-P. L. L. C'sCertificate f ees-DentistsCertificate fees-HygienistsReinstatement feesLicense VerificationsCopiesAnderson & AssociatesCosts & Fines


1 999

95,025.0049,400.0019,350.004,800.001,350.004,200.oo1,950.002,748.OO

600.002,400.00

600.00130.00260.00

1,660.00950.00209.95

1,984.489,389.00

$ 1 97,006.43

2000

93,750.0049,200.0022,200.Oo

5,300.002,250.OO2,100.001,650.002,255.OO

300.002,200.oo1,800.00

190.00190.00575.00850.00338.19

1,950.002,881.45

$189,979.64

/

oStatement of Disbursemenb

For the Fiscal Years 2003 & 2004

001 Personal Services004 Annual lncrement010 Dept. of Administration011 Social Security012 Public Employees Insurance Agency014 Worker'sCompensation016 Consolidated Public Retirement Board020 Office Expenses021 Printing & Binding022 Rentals024 Telephone025 Professional026 Travel027 lS&C WVNet030 Rentals (machine & misc.)031 Association Dues032 Fire, Auto, Bond & other insurance035 Advertising037 Medical/Research038 MaintenanceContracts042 Hospitality052 Training & Development053 Postal & Freight054 Computer Expenses058 Miscellaneous Equipment061 CommunicationEquipmentRepairs070 CommunicationEquipment110 PEIA Reserve170 Computer Equipment171 Computer Software

Total Expenditures

2003

127,200.242,250.00

656.249,507.65

20,569.84652.98

9,319.83700.11679.92

7,787.754,101.506,488.54

37,256.55697.78

10,026.963,685.002,189.00

0.0063.00

515.70930.27340.00

3,971.0182.29

0.000.000.00

959.000.000.00

$250,631.16

2004

122,486.142,700.00

962.519,000.06

28,806.68698.83

10,191.671,868.291,583.907,650.006,387.181,908.25

28,850.591,014.277,844.824,230.003,116.00

70.540.00

1,031.50572.19595.00

5,768.23729.04

1,028.7130.00

1,240.00947.00

1 ,185.0019.95

$252,516.35

/

oStatement of Disbu nsernents

For the Flscal Years 2001 & 2002

001 Personal Services002 Personal Services without deductions

004 Annual lncrement010 Dept. of Administration011 Social SecuritY012 Public Employees lnsurance Agency014 Worker's ComPensation016 Consolidated Public Retirement Board

020 Office ExPenses021 Printing & Binding022 Rentals024 Telephone025 Professional026 Travel027 lS&C \tt/VNet030 Rentals (machine & misc.)031 Association Dues032 Fire, Auto, Bond & other insurance035 Advertising037 Medical/Research038 Maintenance Contracts042 HospitalitY052 Training & DeveloPment053 Postal & Freight054 Computer ExPenses058 MiscellaneousEquiPment079 MiscellaneousEquiPment110 PEIA Reserve171 Computer EquiPment

Total Expenditures

2001

102,793.411,150.003,900.00

755.007,770.51

17,988.00423.13

8,140.58895.72506.16

7,789.144,540.472,022.05

21,554.64546.58

9,165.063,265.001,262.00

33.470.00

464.99922.67170.00

4,695.680.000.00

90.58858.00

0.00

$199,898.65

2002

123,626.40450.00

1,650.00656.24

9,271.3018,510.88

588.5836,996.29

615.75470.16

8,497.353,792.134,495.40

29,240.92572.45

9,187.683,265.001,820.00

95.41252.00

1,254.20542.51

0.002,751.501,398.101,542.39

0.00928.00

3,249.88

$265,720.52

/

oStatement of Disbursements

For the Fiscal Years 2000

001 Personal Services002 Personal Services without deductions010 Dept. of Administration011 Social Security012 Public Employees Insurance Agency014 Worker'sCompensation016 Consolidated Public Retirement Board020 Office Expenses021 Printing & Binding022 Rentals024 Telephone025 Professional026 Travel027 lS&C WVNet030 Rentals (machine & misc.)031 Association Dues032 Fire, Auto, Bond & other insurance035 Advertising037 Medical/Research038 Maintenance Contracts042 Hospitality052 Training & Development053 Postal & Freight054 Computer Expenses055 Supplies (purchasing card)061 Equipment Repairs078 Equipment079 Equipment (purchasing card)110 PEIA Reserve171 Computer Software

Total Expenditures

2000

82,218.001,500.00

595.006,100.62

17,498.00522.34

6,395.27546.75496.59

7,851.753,853.64

60.0027,290.15

547.049,494.163,015.001 ,180.00

30.560.00

375.25652.70

0.005,513.64

0.00632.45

1,090.202,586.521,805.55

0.000.00

$176,030.14

/

oESTIMATED LEASE INFORMATION

BECKLEY

Current

$600 per month hardship exemption1639 sq ft4.39 per sq ft

$7 - $9 per sq ft expected this July

$11,473 - $14,751

increase of $4,273 - $7,551

CHARLESTON

1639 sq ft

$13 - $15 per sq ft

$2r,307 - $24,595

increase of $14,107 - $17,385

$5,000 relocation monies

George D. Conard, Jr.

Debra D. Dent

John C. Dixon

David G. Edwards

Dolores L. Gribble

Bernard J. Grubler

H. Richard Marshall, Jr.

Richard D. Smith

Ja:nes W. Vargo

Dina A. Vaughan

Totals

Susan M. Combs

John F. Parkulo

April D. Stone

Bradford A. Vaughan

Total

7270.24

2494.37

2783.45

2007.03

3799.43

1944.68

4739.68

1291,.23

236s.03

28695.t4

EMPLOYEE SALARIES

Gross Per W2

21,260.00

50,350.16

13,416.82

12,060.00

97,086.98

JANUARY - DECEMBER 2OO4

Expenses Per 1099 Per Diem Per W2

3150.00

1950.00

1650.00

600.00

1350.00

2250.00

1500.00

2850.00

1350.00

1650.00

18300.00

OTHER PERSONS PAID A PER DIEM JAN . DEC 2OO4

Tilden D. Bobbitt

Robert W. Graves

Nathan E. Kirk

Hubert E. Kiser

William R. Marshall

Craig L. Meadows

Gerald E. Nieusma

Babak D. Noorbakhsh

Ashley J. Patnoe

Harold H. Reed

Paul T. Rose

Charles L. Seita

Michael H. Shahan

Nicolas Shalhoup

Don E. Skaff

James F. Szarko

Kimberly S. Thompson

Bryan D. Weaver

Joel R. Whitaker

David E. Yates

Total

Gross Per W2

150.00

600.00

150.00

150.00

900.00

150.00

150.00

150.00

r50.00

150.00

150.00

150.00

150.00

37s.00

600.00

300.00

150.00

600.00

300.00

450.00

5925.00

Oral Surgery Exarriner

Oral Surgery Examiner & Anes. Committee

Pediatric Exarniner

Orthodontic Examiner

Anesthesia Commiffee

Periodontic Exa:niner

Oral Surgery Examiner

Oral Surgery Examiner

Pediatric Examiner

Periodontic Examiner

Pediatric Examinsr

fthodontic Examiner

Periodontic Exarriner

Peer Review Commillss

Pediatric Examiner & Anes. Committee

Peer Review Committee

Pediatric Examiner

Anesthesia Committee

Peer Review Committee

Anesthesia Committee

II Meeting Costs - divided by number toaveled

5716.14 l9 = 635.r3

803.97

493.43

6s6.03

786.45

6431.76 /8

4440.84 19

3280.t7 I 5

3932.37 l5

estimated meeting costs per year with 4 meetings 17,763 - 28,942

Documents

FEBRUARY...ESTIMATED N)DITIONAL MONIES TO BE GENERAT'ED tsY PROPOSED FEES WITH SOME SUPPORTING DATA Line Item 2.8 2.9 3.2 Subtotal Line Item 4.7 4.8 Subtotal Total of Renewal Fees