*��!���EEG���2 ,�������/!'

+0 %����$��$��-� #��)& ����. � 1�&" (

2019/06/07 12019©Taiki Kinoshita AHC-Lab, IS, NAIST

[4F2-OS-11a-03]

[Aiva, A., et al. (2017)]

– ���������������� �

– .–

2019/06/07 22019©Taiki Kinoshita AHC-Lab, IS, NAIST

������

��

Aiva, A., Leite, I., Boukricha, H., & Wachsmuth, I. (2017). Empathy in Virtual Agents and Robots.ACM Transactions on Interactive Intelligent Systems, 7(3), 1–40.

+%�0;Q< [Decety, J., et al. (2004)]�K-*�MA

���%�#�����– >4�G5�%8���'���������&"– 9'C3��������� �71�2L� �����+%��>�0;Q<�2.�#?�– >4�T7�T�D@6S– %8+N��� OF��%8�R:

$��� �����%EEG� !����– IJ�2L�EEG������E$B�C(�,=– !P�9/���� ��OF�%8+N�)&H"

2019/06/07 32019©Taiki Kinoshita AHC-Lab, IS, NAIST

Decety, J., & Jackson, P. L. (2004). The functional architecture of human empathy.Behavioral and cognitive neuroscience reviews, 3(2), 71-100

�;(!

fMRI#"�����!��� [Anders, S., et al. (2011)]– functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging (fMRI)� 6'9�&1���/"8,�6�3�4 �&1

EEG��� ������������[Matsuda, G., et al. (2016)]– -)#:.������3*��+– 6��37�������������3�EEG&1 ������– -�$%�02&1�5��EEG#"– EEG�2������ ��/"8�&1

2019/06/07 42019©Taiki Kinoshita AHC-Lab, IS, NAIST

Anders, S., Heinzle, J., Weiskopf, N., Ethofer, T., & Haynes, J. D. (2011). Flow of affective information between communicating brains. NeuroImage, 54(1), 439–446.Matsuda, G., Hiraki, & H., Ishiguro (2016). EEG-Based Mu Rhythm Suppression to Measure the Effects of Appearance and Motion on Perceived Human Likeness of a Robot. Journal of Human-Robot Interaction, 5(1), 68–81.

F>R< (1/2)

F>�)S– 1N9m���d0^�_5�EEG���<W*cT@=8 [Anders, S., et al. (2011)]�4�,\– VOG�!� "#��fE��gD�3��e���

i1N�� ����Y(��Mk�U6– IOG�VOG�fN�2CF>:pG– VOG1j�IOG1j�l/�b�Z��i��– 2j���LQ�LQ�h�91����;?�XB�����– aoT]+.7J[.'[.�qn$&-���PA�F>:pG��_%KH`

2019/06/07 52019©Taiki Kinoshita AHC-Lab, IS, NAIST

(#3" (2/2)

Self Assessment Mannequin (SAM) [Bradley, M., et al. (1994)]

– �/���������28� ?8����/����DC– 40*�&>�<.�/��/��96�=�– ,0*�9'�/�B:���/�2+E�96�=�����– EEG�Cognionics)1Quick-30

– EMG�%G;!�%5@$! �</!!7�-F

2019/06/07 62019©Taiki Kinoshita AHC-Lab, IS, NAIST

%G;!

%5@$!

A�/����� �����

Bradley, Margaret M. & Lang, Peter J. (1994). Measuring emotion: The self-assessment manikin and the semantic differential. Behavioral and cognitive neuroscience reviews, 3(2), 71-100

7

2019/06/07 72019©Taiki Kinoshita AHC-Lab, IS, NAIST

G G

M

EEEEEE

S

A 54 4+

10

G 26 3 G 26 3

×2

EEG����N��KA^

1. YINC�����J�?�– MF<�0E�=a�8:�9R���-20~20X�J�?�

2. "��B31. U_HYYI2. EMG��� �L5L2�0.1,D�HY�7B3. ADJUST [Mognon, A.,et al. (2011)] ���"��HY�;S7B

3. TQ`�P?1. &()����%)� \12. #*���'+!(]�W@.�Z40�W@[61�3. />VGO-��($�V��������#*��Z4

2019/06/07 82019©Taiki Kinoshita AHC-Lab, IS, NAIST

Mognon, A., Jovicich, J., Bruzzone, L., & Buiatti, M. (2011). ADJUST: An automatic EEG artifact detector based on the joint use of spatial and temporal features. Psychophysiology, 48(2), 229–240.

e h (1/2)

1. c b a

2019/06/07 92019©Taiki Kinoshita AHC-Lab, IS, NAIST

– B– &) (h p g– i p < 0.05 B

��� �����t�

(n = 16)���

�+�������(20s) ���� (20s)

HH

Target Observer

Target Observer

0' 3 (2/2)

2. ���)��Global efficiency�#– ���$2+*�5 /��.– Global efficiency ( ) �

– 1�����24-�,������

2019/06/07 102019©Taiki Kinoshita AHC-Lab, IS, NAIST

Eglob(G)<latexit sha1_base64="Fj5mY6EfwxYExe+mksXNfAzEnk4=">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</latexit>

d(i, j) =

(1 (i, j) 2 E

1 otherwise<latexit sha1_base64="o4EIiZTXC780sKBEDRiFD0bqqbU=">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</latexit>

�(%������"��(%������&�!%������"��!%������&

Vt<latexit sha1_base64="iQD6uIVJHRAPF/tODiiUkoI/SK8=">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</latexit>

|Vt|<latexit sha1_base64="paCsMF5ZCi/fMmNCf0+ZRh+fo6o=">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</latexit>

|Vo|<latexit sha1_base64="BHyrdvMXTHA3K9n8U2CV6lVByZY=">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</latexit>

Vo<latexit sha1_base64="qIxJ17ZuEn9PD3ZoYPdSVghZTqY=">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</latexit>

�1"�E<latexit sha1_base64="fGUvFDQ2+unxN4xm5M+MHhfMW0o=">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</latexit>

Eglob(G) =1

|Vt||Vo|X

i2Vt,j2Vo

1

d(i, j)<latexit sha1_base64="k2kkqegJIHL8zf85zdHT9jrYFqM=">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</latexit>

SAM4 =

2019/06/07 112019©Taiki Kinoshita AHC-Lab, IS, NAIST

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9

4

��� �����4

5.6

5.6

4 . 904 904 9

EEG (

送信者 受信者

2019/06/07 122019©Taiki Kinoshita AHC-Lab, IS, NAIST

送信者 受信者

���� ) 1

����� ) 1

0< ) 01) 1

5.1

EEG����5.'!�(*

2019/06/07 132019©Taiki Kinoshita AHC-Lab, IS, NAIST

���� ����$� 0.572 0.385

3�� 0.152 0.000

6#, 0.000 0.000

Global Efficiency

���2����2����$��3�����Global Efficiency�0��6#,���0�4"��)� �Global Efficiency�� �#,%7�&/��� 1-�+���(����

����40�#D

���– &;*N�2MH6-C��EEG�� �-C– &;*N�?���6�2M�EEG'�A/A(�Global efficiency�2��,1

– A/A(�Global efficiency�� �J%G�H)�&;*N�-C���"I>

40�#D– 7.+Q8�=�B��– :<8�0F����A/A(�2��PO�K@��– A/A(!$�9L�EEG<3�R5E�-C������� ����

2019/06/07 142019©Taiki Kinoshita AHC-Lab, IS, NAIST