Upload
mailshahani
View
448
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
DESCRIPTION
Citation preview
The Right Game: Use The Right Game: Use Game Theory to Shape Game Theory to Shape
StrategyStrategy
The Right Game: Use Game The Right Game: Use Game Theory to Shape StrategyTheory to Shape Strategy
Adam M. Brandenburger, Barry J. NalebuffAdam M. Brandenburger, Barry J. NalebuffHarvard Business Review, July-August, 1995Harvard Business Review, July-August, 1995
“Successful business strategy is about actively shaping the game
you play, not just playing the game you find.”
Game Theory:
• Using game theory allows us to consider “changing the game” WHY is that helpful?
• You can make the game you want…to your advantage. HOW?
• Change the player, added value, rules or tactics.
• PARTS are the levers for moving the world of business ala Archimedes.
Lessons from Game Lessons from Game TheoryTheoryLook at the situation from the perspective
of all others’ involved
Look for win-win, not just win-lose opportunities
Look for opportunities to “change the game” for the better
Game theory gives more complete picture of business relationships
Avoids exclusive focus on competition(win-lose)
““Co-opetition”Co-opetition”
Businesses must both cooperate to create value, even while competing to divide this value among
themselves
•Recognizes that business relationships have more than one aspect
•By identifying all the players and all the interdependencies, game theory expands the repertoire of strategies
Brandenburg and Nalebuff use “Value Net” as their core concept. They identified four types of players that every company faces: 1. CUSTOMERSParties to which the company directs its products and services. In return, money goes from the customers to the company. 2. SUPPLIERSParties who flow resources to the company. In return, money goes from the company to the suppliers.
3. COMPETITORS
The definition depends on perspective:
Customer perspective: “A player is your competitor if customers value your product less when they have the other player’s product than when they have your product by itself.” Your product behaves as a substitute for a competitor’s product – your increase in market share will directly decrease your competitor’s share. Substitutes can be both direct, e.g. two bakeries competing as well as indirect, e.g. bread versus rice.
Supplier perspective: “A player is your competitor if it is less attractive for a supplier to provide resources to you when it is also supplying the other player than when it is supplying you alone.” Any firm competes for resources in quantity, quality and price with other organizations.
4. COMPLEMENTORS
The definition also depends on perspective.
Customer perspective: “A player is your complementor if customers value your product more when they have the other player’s product than when they have your product by itself.” Complementors are the inverse of a competitor because more demand for their products will lead to more demand for your product.
Supplier perspective: “A player is your complementor if it is more attractive for a supplier to provide resources to you when it is also supplying the other player than when it is supplying you alone.” When a market is small, it is difficult to get resources delivered exactly on spec. When the market increases, suppliers begin to tailor their offering and make the purchasing efforts easier on all acquiring firms.
Competition and Competition and CooperationCooperation
Elements of the GameElements of the GamePlayers
Added Values◦What each player adds to the value
inherent in the total game
Rules
Tactics (Perceptions)
Scope
Changing the PlayersChanging the PlayersPlayers are participants in the Value
Net◦ The Company itself, and its Customers,
Suppliers, Substitutors, Complementors◦ How does the game change as players
come in or out? Canadian Airlines no longer exists in the
Canadian airline industry. • Even if you can’t make money in a game, figure out who stands to gain from your entry and make them pay (Holland Sweetener)
• once you’re in the game try to change who else is in the game; try to bring in customers, suppliers, complementors, competitors (e.g.credit union/auto sales)
Changing Added ValueChanging Added Value What added value does each player bring to the
game?
◦ If a player were not participating at all, how would the value of the overall game be affected?
Bobby Hull joining the Jets gave the WHA instant credibility. With a monopoly its ok to limit the added values of
other players (Nintendo)
In competitive situation, you need to build your own added value, e.g. improve quality at low incremental cost or vice versa
but only way to protect added value is to create relationships with your customers and suppliers…have a loyalty program (Advantage), because it doesn’t disappear even when imitated!
Your added value=
the size of the pie when you are in
the gameminus
the size of the pie when you are out
of the game
Changing the RulesChanging the RulesRules determine how the game is
played
◦Can the rules be changed to make the game more favorable for one, or for all?
Guarantees to match lowest price Funding rules for universities in Manitoba
Usually we think we should charge more to our customers and less to competitors
Changing this rule is possible, e.g., introduction GM card (cash award)and Advantage (in kind award): latter is better because it increase the size of the pie by delivering more value for same price)
Changing PerceptionsChanging PerceptionsPlayers’ perceptions of the game
influences the way they play it.
◦Commitment strategies, (as ploys) Publicly committing to something to make
others perceive you’re serious
Changing the ScopeChanging the ScopeScope is the boundaries of the
game
◦Tying issues together in negotiations Softwood lumber and energy?
◦Opening a “second front” in competition Hezbullah attacking Israel from Lebanon
• Look at the game as part of an even bigger game…change the links between
• added values--price superior product high so you don’t eat away at incumbent’s existing product
• rules--if you have power get long-term contracts with suppliers, or offer package discounts
• tactics--get another player to believe that what you will do in one situation depends on what happens in another.
• To think you have to accept the game you find yourself in.
• To think that changing the game must come at the expense of others.
•To believe that you have to find something to do that others can’t.
• Failing to see the whole game.
• Failing to think methodically about changing the game
•Finally there is no silver bullet for changing the game of business. It is an ongoing process.
The Traps Of Strategy :