46
mediaprofile.com Michael O’Connor Clarke Vice President, Digital & Social Media SOCIAL MEDIA: WTF? 1

Mesh12 Session - Social Media WTF

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Mesh12 Session - Social Media WTF

mediaprofile.comMichael O’Connor ClarkeVice President, Digital & Social Media

SOCIAL MEDIA: WTF?

1

Page 2: Mesh12 Session - Social Media WTF

ABOUT ME

Michael 1.0 = Tech hardware & software sales

Michael 2.0 = Corporate Marketing & PR exec

Michael 3.0 = Agency bloke & social media “pioneer”

http://michaelocc.com

@michaelocc

linkedin.com/michaelocc

2

Page 3: Mesh12 Session - Social Media WTF

ALMOST FAMOUS3

Page 4: Mesh12 Session - Social Media WTF

ALMOST FAMOUS4

Page 5: Mesh12 Session - Social Media WTF

5

OVERTURE

Page 6: Mesh12 Session - Social Media WTF

source: @tomheg at http://tpdsaa.tumblr.com

Page 7: Mesh12 Session - Social Media WTF

HYPOTHESIS1. Marketing is broken2. The Web offers the promise to fix it3. Social Media enables Web’s real potential (Yay!)4. Marketers freak out (OMG! People are talking back!)5. Marketing shoehorns the same old crud into the shiny

new channels6. Social Media is broken

7

Page 8: Mesh12 Session - Social Media WTF

http://www.flickr.com/photos/catherinebennett/

Page 9: Mesh12 Session - Social Media WTF

THREE FALLACIESWhat we bullshit about when we bullshit about bullshit…

9

Page 10: Mesh12 Session - Social Media WTF

SIZE MATTERSFollower & Fan counts are inflated and largely meaningless

10

1

Page 11: Mesh12 Session - Social Media WTF

CANADA’S TWITTER CHAMP11

Suspect A

Page 12: Mesh12 Session - Social Media WTF

12

Suspect A

Suspect A

Suspect A

Page 13: Mesh12 Session - Social Media WTF

13

Suspect A

Suspect A

Suspect A

Suspect A

Suspect A

Page 14: Mesh12 Session - Social Media WTF

14

Page 15: Mesh12 Session - Social Media WTF

15

Page 16: Mesh12 Session - Social Media WTF

16

Page 17: Mesh12 Session - Social Media WTF

17

But why not…?

Page 18: Mesh12 Session - Social Media WTF

18

IT’S A LIE You get dummy, shell accounts Most <100 days old, very low follower/friend

counts, average of 9 tweets per account Most accounts are filled with bot-generated

spam content You’re not buying an audience, you’re buying

crap

Page 19: Mesh12 Session - Social Media WTF

19

IT DOESN’T WORK Metcalfe’s Law: “The value of a telecommunications

network is proportional to the square of the number of connected users of the system”

Michael’s Law: “The value of a social network is proportional to the square of the number of engaged contributors to the system”

Followers and fans are only of any real “value” if they:1. Have a pulse;2. Have consciously chosen to follow or Like you, and;3. Are actually engaged in spreading the word about you

among their own circles of influence

Page 20: Mesh12 Session - Social Media WTF

BIG FAN COUNT != BIG ENGAGEMENT20

Source: Pagelever - reported on AllFacebook.com

Nearly 70 per cent of people who Like a brand page rarely or never return to the page

(Source: Penn State U Study)

Page 21: Mesh12 Session - Social Media WTF

21

BIG FAN COUNT != BIG ENGAGEMENT

Page 22: Mesh12 Session - Social Media WTF

22

BIG FAN COUNT != BIG ENGAGEMENT

Page 23: Mesh12 Session - Social Media WTF

MORE CONNECTIONS DOES NOT MEANMORE CONNECTEDNESS

23

Page 24: Mesh12 Session - Social Media WTF

FAKE IT…till you make it

24

2

Page 25: Mesh12 Session - Social Media WTF
Page 26: Mesh12 Session - Social Media WTF

@TechnoBlortTechnoBlort Industries

FRIENDS DON’T LET FRIENDS TWEET LIKE THIS

26

Page 27: Mesh12 Session - Social Media WTF

27

7 DEADLY SOCIAL MEDIA MARKETING SINS1. Sock puppets!2. “Conversation Calendars” written by copywriters3. Automated tweeting + zero-response monitoring4. Transmedia promotion (same batcrap, different

batchannel)5. Pushing news releases as status updates or blog

posts6. Ignoring feedback, deleting comments or, even

worse, not allowing them7. Thinking you can control the message

Page 28: Mesh12 Session - Social Media WTF

BRAND SPAM28

Page 29: Mesh12 Session - Social Media WTF

29

STUCK IN A MESSAGE TRACK

From this…

To this:

Page 30: Mesh12 Session - Social Media WTF

FISH WHERE THE FISH ARE

30

3

Page 31: Mesh12 Session - Social Media WTF

31

Page 32: Mesh12 Session - Social Media WTF

32

“At the heart of the Internet business is one of the great business fallacies of our time: that the Web, with all its targeting abilities, can be a more efficient, and hence more profitable, advertising medium than traditional media.”

“The nature of people’s behavior on the Web and of how they interact with advertising… has meant a marked decline in advertising’s impact.”

Page 33: Mesh12 Session - Social Media WTF

QUASI-PERSONALIZED CLUEHOLES33

LeakyAlgorithmicMarketingEfforts

More at: http://ow.ly/b9YRC

Page 34: Mesh12 Session - Social Media WTF

34

WTF

Page 35: Mesh12 Session - Social Media WTF

THE #1 SOCIAL MEDIA MISTAKE35

Page 36: Mesh12 Session - Social Media WTF

Social Media is like Soylent Green…

It’s PEOPLE!source: http://newsevents.arts.ac.uk

Page 37: Mesh12 Session - Social Media WTF

Culture Check

Page 38: Mesh12 Session - Social Media WTF

PREREQUISITES A desire to be closer to your customer A belief that conversation can build a

bond of understanding A willingness to act on what you hear and

learn A tolerance for dissent – not everyone will

agree with you And one other thing…

Page 39: Mesh12 Session - Social Media WTF

39

Facebook

Twitter

Website

Page 40: Mesh12 Session - Social Media WTF

BUILD YOUR OWN HUB Why are you investing so much in building

a community someone else controls? Where’s the “Tweet this” button on

Facebook; the “Like” button for Twitter? When people find you out there, where do

you want them to end up? Create and curate! But… what do I write about?

40

Page 41: Mesh12 Session - Social Media WTF

http://www.flickr.com/photos/niclindh

Step One: Grow Big Ears

Page 42: Mesh12 Session - Social Media WTF

This is a BFDsource: http://bigeffingdeal.info/

Page 43: Mesh12 Session - Social Media WTF

43

WHAT I’VE LEARNED If you’re genuinely interested in what your

customers want, they’ll tell you Talk to people; try not to be a dick Don’t self promote. Remember “The Because

Effect.” Tell great stories If someone starts telling you how to do it right,

chances are they’re doing it wrong Er…

Page 44: Mesh12 Session - Social Media WTF

JUST DO IT If you’re a small company

Change now. You’ll win. If you’re an agency

Push back. Tell clients they’re wrong. Refuse to execute crap ideas.

If you’re a consumer Talk loud. Be heard. Out the bad and the good.

If you’re a big company drone Get porous with customers. Be human. If you can’t

fix it: leave.

Page 45: Mesh12 Session - Social Media WTF

When you think of the Internet, don't think of Mack trucks full of widgets

destined for distributorships, whizzing by countless billboards.

Think of a table for two.@Man, 1997

Page 46: Mesh12 Session - Social Media WTF

mediaprofile.comMichael O’Connor ClarkeVice President, Digital & Social Media

THANK YOU

46

[email protected]@michaelocc