View
327
Download
1
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
ICCA10, Mannheim 1
Inhabiting the Family Car:Children-Passengers and Parents-Drivers
Chaim Noy
Sapir College
Israel
ICCA10, Mannheim 2
Automobility: The social car
A move away from reductionist, functionalist and binary approaches to transportation From “vehicles” or “riding animals” (a-la Verilio) to socio-
semiotic systemic view From a/the car to the “system of automobility”
Merits being… Integrating “car cultures” into sociology: objects and
practices in everyday life: semiotic approaches critical approaches
Technology and sociality… Agency: hybrids/cyborgs, ANT, cognition (route-selection, etc.) emotion (Katz, Noy)
ICCA10, Mannheim 3
Families-in-interaction/Families in cars “The socially inhabited car … permits multiple
socialities, of family life, community, leisure” (Urry) Families are “our first institution” (Aronsson) Interactions and conversations in families
in (semi-)domestic settings argumentative interactions in families
Families and automobility: Families’ (family members’) everyday mobilities “The car rivals the house as an alternative zone of
everyday life … a closed realm of intimacy” (Baudrillard) “The domestic car,” where we find “a duplication of
accessories” (Verilio) … the role of the car in sustaining families’ routines
ICCA10, Mannheim 4
Inside the car: Communicative affordances All face the same direction (and not each
other, i.e. no face-to-face interaction). “Architecture of visibility” (Laurier et al.)
Division of inner (sub)spaces: 1. Front seat / back seat
entrances/exits sitting apparatuses/arrangement access to the car’s driving equipment views of the outside
Limited mobility
ICCA10, Mannheim 5
Research questions
We ask how familial interactions proceed inside the (moving) car?
How members employ cars’ communicative (in)affordnacs? How they accomplish their aims via contextual
affordances? How members establish and engage or disengage
from familial interaction in the car? How family memebrs maintain/disrupt the family’s “o-
space” (Kendon)? What is the interactional formation that sustains the “o-space”?
ICCA10, Mannheim 6
Paradigmatic shifts/mobile methods
Challenges: Ethnography of mobilities: actors, places, etc.
ethnography of familial (intimate) places & interactions
The “hectic camcorder”: Supplying a camcorder to the car’s passengers –
children in the backseat Everything recorded is viewed from the perspective of
the passenger who is using the camcorder gestures and orientations
ICCA10, Mannheim 7
Interacting in the car
Interacting in the car: (dis)engaging in familial “o-space” widthwise interaction: side-by-side interactions
within cars’ subspaces crossover interaction: interactions that run
across the front-back division bodily gestures, orientations, etc. volume of talk address terms (“mommy”)
ICCA10, Mannheim 8
Data
Video recordings of five urban, middle class families residing in (West) Jerusalem.
Heterosexual, secular Jewish families with 2-4 children (9m.-12y)
Camcorder: 2-3 weeks = ~four hours recordings
The “school run”
The Normans: Five family members seated in the car: 1.
DRV/mother (Bella, 40), FP/grandmother (Xaya), BPs: Tom (7.5), Tamir (5.1), Ronit (3.1).
ICCA10, Mannheim 9
i. Entering the car
ICCA10, Mannheim 10
i. Extract 1
View from rear
Tom narrating
Complaint: mother/driver
-- loud
Topic & orientational shift
to personal transactional
space (Kendon)
ICCA10, Mannheim 11
ii. Dispute develops
ICCA10, Mannheim 12
ii. Extract 2
Grandmother's soothing interventions Quiet, widthwise
Tom in personal transactional space until Ronit replies
Ronit’s reply: accusing
ICCA10, Mannheim 13
iii. Dispute’s conclusion
ICCA10, Mannheim 14
iii. Extract 3
Further attempts by Xaya to sooth Bella (quitely)
Tamir enters the dispute,picking up on the resistive thread -
gestures with wrists laterally
Xaya playfully endorses Tamir’s war-against-mom and swiftly (re)turns to Bella:- shift from crosswise to
widthwise interaction- change of volume - change of topic- discourse marker (ma)
ICCA10, Mannheim 15
Conclusions
The system of automobility as part of everyday life in cultures effected by modernity.
Not autonomous but intertwined with other social systems, presently families
If interactionists “enter the car” its interior spaces emerge as socially animated interactionally inhabited collaboratively accomplished scenes
ICCA10, Mannheim 16
This is accomplished via movements within and between… Members’ personal transactional spaces Car’s subspaces (front seat/backseat) “o-spaces” Car’s shared, overall orientational space (“o-space”)
In the “school run” - less issues of route selection, attractions, etc. as the activities inside the car are most relevant routine
Driving and co-driving family members FPs - mother and grandmother perform two
roles/responsibilities: automobile and familial simultaneously.
Emotions in families/cars