Upload
eileen0692
View
671
Download
0
Tags:
Embed Size (px)
DESCRIPTION
Citation preview
SCHOOL OF ARCHITECTURE, BUILDING & DESIGN
ARCHITECTURE CULTURE & HISTORY 2 [ARC 1323]
Project: Architecture Heritage Building Analysis
Site: Pre-war shop lots at Jalan Raya Timur
Tutor : Ms. Ida
Group Member Student ID
Choo Ai Lin 0317253
Chin Pui Man 0310331
Cheang Eileen 1006A77249
Lim Zhi Hong 0304547
Introduction
The origin name of Klang is from the language Mon-Khymer that is “Klong”. Klong can
be identified as a warehouse because Klang became an important port that has lots of
warehouses. Meanwhile another evidence, “Klang” means “canal” or waterway (Official
Portal Klang Municipal Council [OPKMC],2013). Klang’s history came before Malacca.
Klang is claimed to be one of the oldest city in Malaysia. According to history, Klang was
occupied since 2000 years ago. The first entry on Klang was written starting from the
moments of Klang resurrection that was once was not tied to any area.
Klang from the time it functioned as the principle port of the state of Selangor to the
period when greater Klang and its surrounding territories become a major agricultural
centre. Finally, mention is made of an important development hitherto little known
namely the beginnings of the industrialization in Malaya. The major industries were
located in Klang because of the proximity to Port Swettenham (known as Port Klang).
Figure 1: Jalan Raya Timur shop lots top view. (Google Maps, 2013)
Introduction of Site
The site of study a historical building is pre-war shop lot along Jalan Raya Timur,
situated within close proximity of Klang railway station. Jalan Raya Timur contains 40
shop lots which with different phase and size.(Figure 2) These lots, which were
constructed between year 1930 and 1940, made the area one of the busiest spots in
southern Klang then. The pre-war shop lots are just rows of dilapidated buildings. Due to
the decline of the town’s economy, these lots are now functioning as commercial offices
but many of the lots have been abandoned.
Figure 2 shows the shop lots along Jalan Raya Timur
Architect
This building was completed by WCT Land Development Company. This company
become the fastest growing township in the Klang Corridor and also involved in many
big projects in all over the place. For example, the opening of AEON Bukit Tinggi
Shopping Center and hypermarkets like Tesco and Giant. This has transformed Klang
into a lively royal town with complete facilities and total convenience. BBT has received
a thumping endorsement from Klang residents, going by the strong occupancy rate of
more than 90% for its houses and shops. In addition, the group has since ventured out
of the country with a key project in Ho Chi Minh, Vietnam. Platinum Plaza- an
architectural and innovative design mixed commercial developments of office towers,
SOHO, Business class Hotel and the largest shopping mall in Vietnam.
Introduction of Chosen Building- Teck Heng Enterprise
This building built by Labur Bina Sdn. Bhd was
a 3m x 7m x 7m height office building. At the
early 1940s, it was a residential building after
the completion of this building. Most of the
Chinese people stayed here having their daily
routines and activities.
After the Chinese family moved away this shop
has become a commercial area. Onion
business was operated. An Indian businessman
took over it and ran his business for 5 years.
Year 1940
Year 1945-1950At year 1951, the onion business had stopped
and failed to operate. The Yap family took over
this building and it became Teck Heng Office
Equipment Sales & Service.
At year 1951-1965, the Company only provided
service and repair works of office equipments
only. Later, the Company started its business and
slowly expanded to provide a full range of repair
services.
After 1965, Teck Heng Enterprise has grown from
strength to strength and is now a well-established
and dynamic organization, specializing in
repairing type writer, office furniture &
workstation, office renovation, blinds, carpet,
safety box, steel cabinet, CCTV, door access
system, office automation, whiteboards, etc.
Concept - Art Deco Style with Early Straits Eclectic Features
Art Deco Style Building
They are usually 2 to 3 storeys high, main entrance in the front, center with symmetric
windows, and optionally, wings on both sides. The front, especially the entrance, may
have columns and decorations. Mostly influenced by European, they geometrically
design their building highlighting vertical and horizontal lines. They also have Shanghai
plaster wall finishing and flagpole and relief writings on the wall.
Teck Heng Enterprise is an Art deco building has the concept of a simple rectilinear line
and its geometry forms. This building is masonry ornamented with rectilinear façade and
geometrically pilasters which are the main characteristic of an art deco building. Besides,
it also maintain some early straits eclectic building features, for example the jack roof
and the five-foot way.
At year 1951, the onion business had stopped
and failed to operate. The Yap family took over
this building and it became Teck Heng Office
Equipment Sales & Service.
At year 1951-1965, the Company only provided
service and repair works of office equipments
only. Later, the Company started its business and
slowly expanded to provide a full range of repair
services.
After 1965, Teck Heng Enterprise has grown from
strength to strength and is now a well-established
and dynamic organization, specializing in
repairing type writer, office furniture &
workstation, office renovation, blinds, carpet,
safety box, steel cabinet, CCTV, door access
system, office automation, whiteboards, etc.
Year 1951 – 2013 (today)
In fact, it has already expanded to include
import and export activities as one of its core
business.
At 1995, the owner retired and passed his
business his elder daughter. Hence, the
business was well-known and continued until
today.
Early Straits Eclectics Style Building
They are also 2 to 3 storeys high, the facades are usually decorative mixture of Malay,
Chinese and European ornaments with light indigo blue, ocre or white colour. The
building material used are timber, clay bricks and lime.
Building Inventory (Art Deco Architecture Features - Teck Heng Enterprise)
Flagpoles
Banding Devices
Main Features of Art Deco Building
Main Features of Early Straits Eclectics Building
Full length louvered windows
Plaster arches and central keystone
Air Vent
Geometric pattern clay floor tiles and granite edge block and step
Sea green glass with metal frame
Shanghai plaster wall finish
Strong horizontal/ vertical lines
Sketch Diagram
Sketch Diagram
Symmetry
- Radial Symmetrical design can be shown from the building
Façade when it is reflected across a plane vertically to create
another instance of itself.
- The whole building was divided into 2 similar parts, showing
the reflection of the vertical symmetry.
Sketch Diagram
Repetitive Form
- The facades are strong metal works with geometrically
rectilinear forms.
- Above the doors and windows are metal bar which is
repetitive linear form.
Extruded Concrete canopy
- The individual concrete canopy that
used as sunshades above the 1st floor
of the building offsets the wide
banding below.
Extruded concrete canopy
Bright Painted Facade
Art Deco is a style of colours. This office building
was highly coloured. The colour of art deco were
always bright and glossy or pastels and decorated
both interiors and exteriors. Teck Heng Office
Equipment façade was painted with bright orange
colour.
Vertical Banding Device
Art Deco architects sought to emphasize
verticality as a symbol of modernity and
progress. Strong vertical lines dominate the
Teck Heng Building's facade and extend all
the way up to the roof.
Vertical Banded Front Elevation
Plaster Moulding
Unlike in Europe and America where the monumentality of Art Deco was expressed in
sculptured stone, in Malaysia, stone was not readily available and was therefore too
expensive. Local builders looked for a finish that was mode easily available but possessed
the same properties to stone which is Shanghai Plaster, a good, cheap external grade
Early Straits Eclectic Architecture Features - Teck Heng Enterprise
Party wall
- Party walls are typically made of non-
combustible material. Where required by
code, the party wall could be a fire wall.
Party wall can be seen in every
adjoining building.
Plaster Moulding
Plaster Moulding
Unlike in Europe and America where the monumentality of Art Deco was expressed in
sculptured stone, in Malaysia, stone was not readily available and was therefore too
expensive. Local builders looked for a finish that was mode easily available but possessed
the same properties to stone which is Shanghai Plaster, a good, cheap external grade
- Horizontal bands below window and rendered
wall were finished by Shanghai plaster and the
finish was left in beige colour.
Jack Roof
- Usually in Straits Eclectic building,
they always built with a jack roof which
elevated above the main roof.
- This is to ensure hot air to escape and
as well lights to penetrate the upper
floors.
The Five-Foot Way
- First imposed by Sir Stamford Raffles in Singapore in 1822.
- Pedestrian walkways indented into the ground
floor of a building from the road, so that the
overhanging upper floors can provide a cover to
shield pedestrians from the sun and rain.
- This feature can be found in many shop
houses all over the world, and also in some
office buildings.
- As the ground floor of most buildings are shops
or eating places, the five foot ways can also
function as a corridor for people to window-
shop or stop by for some refreshments.
- As implied by name, five foot ways were
intended to assume a consistent width of
five feet from the absolute front to the wall and
entrance defining the frontal of the inner space,
but the guideline is not necessarily applied
universally, as certain five foot ways are wider
or narrower depending on the age, size and
function of the building.
Section Diagram Of Teck Heng Enterprise
Sketches
Business Area
Five-Foot Way
Building Material Used
Shanghai plaster was used
as the wall finishes
Concrete for the ceiling and
bricks for the wall
Glass panel door with metal
frame for the main entry
Classical wooden stairs
that link to the upper floor
Sea-green glass window with metal
frame which is art deco style
Marseille tiles was used
as the roofing material
Ceiling made from plywoodWall partitions from rigid acoustic wood
Zinc roofing for the kitchen Decorative wood panel door Grill doors for security
Contextual Condition
Before Renovation After Renovation
Before that, door grills was used as a
safety door to provide security hence bring
in natural ventilation and natural lighting
that may save electricity cost.
Nowadays, people prefer to use glass for
their office/ business area. This is to
upgrade the building façade to a modern
and elegant extent while glass may provide
transparency as well as security for the
owner to alert when people pass by.
Timber roof truss was exposed at the
upper floor. Dust and spider webs are
easily trapped onto the joints of the truss.
Plywood is used to cover the truss not only
improve the aesthetic of office, it also helps
to cover up the air condition piping and
fixing hence make the cleaning job easier.
Door made of plywood
that not easy to
maintain because the
wood layer is thin and
not durable.
Door made of hard
wood replaced plywood
door is more durable
and can be easily
maintain.
Before Renovation After Renovation
Terra cotta roof tiles are subject to unequal
shrinkage in burning, which sometimes
causes the pieces to be twisted.
When this is the case great care must be
taken in fixing the blocks, otherwise the
long lines of a building, such as those of
the string-courses or cornices, which are
intended to be straight, are apt to be
uneven, and the faces of blocks are often
"in winding."
Straight and plain column which is not
attractive compare to decorative column
with plaster moulding. Rectilinear façade is
dull compare to an arch entrance that is
more eye catching.
Monier Marseille roof tiles are known as
the interlocking French roof tile that has
an existence of about 100 years in
history. Monier is the first in Asia to
combine two state-of-the-art technologies
(H-Cassette & Gypsum mould) to ensure
the roof tiles are of the highest precision
with the smoothest surface finishing. This
roof tiles are used for most art deco
building.
Curve arch (which
contain impost and
keystone) is used in
Art Deco design to
replace column of
Art Deco which is
straight and does
not support not support much weight as compare to
curve arch. Flat and smooth wall is applied
because it will absorb light and make them
noticeable then they can focus on the
element of the building.
Before Renovation After Renovation
Open space at the back area of upper
floor.
Roofing was added to cover up as the owner
wanted to use this area as a store room
The original building provides concrete
canopy which is art deco style.
The owner removed the canopy because he
wanted to put up his company logo.
Besides, there’s different between two
windows on the building where left side
window have the element of Early Straits
while on the right side, it contains the element
of Art-Deco where it introduces the use of
glass. This changes it made by the owner
because they want to keep it to old style
concept yet do not want lights to emit into
the interior.
Conclusion
In the 1960 and 1970s, shophouses again became the common building idiom,
especially in the central areas of new towns and housing estates. In 1980s, however, the
new found of influence of urban Malaysians sparked a booming car population and a
consequent demand for car parks. Shophouses were replaced by high-rise buildings,
complete with parking bays ad surrounded by roads, which often became ‘islands”,
isolated from adjacent buildings.
In 1980s also marked the appearance of powerful corporation seeking expressions
through their buildings, and these were provided by the construction of high-rises. In the
late 1980s and 1990s, the merits of these isolated building as urban forms, unsupported
by a structured urban framework, began to questioned.
These doubts were paralleled by a surge of interest in conservation and the
environment. The shophouses were seen by conservationists as representing the typical
Malaysian urban form, one that particularly suited the climatic conditions of the country.
Conversely, high-rise was viewed as an anonymous international form common to
every city in the world. There was concern that Malaysian towns were losing their unique
character. Shophouses, which have provided Malaysian streets with a continuous
framework and, occasionally, the frames around town squares were preferred to isolated
high-rises. Hence, the shophouse is seen again in modern guise, housing estates and
new towns built after the 1980s. ( Chen Voon Fee, 1998 )
References
1. Latest Issue. (n.d.). Gaya Travel Klang Heritage Walk Comments. Retrieved October 10, 2013, from http://www.gayatravel.com.my/articles/gaya-traveller/klang-heritage-walk
2. ROYAL KLANG TOWN. (n.d.). Official Portal Klang Municipal Council. Retrieved October 13, 2013, from http://www.mpklang.gov.my/en/sejarah
3. Background Overview. Retrieved October 17, 2013, from http://www.luas.gov.my/icm/knowledge_center/bckground_general.htm
4. The soul of Klang. (n.d.). - RED. Retrieved October 17, 2013, from http://www.nst.com.my/red/the-soul-of-klang-1.140649#ixzz2kWTL3ktS
5. Early Modern Style | PENANG SHOPHOUSE. (n.d.). PENANG SHOPHOUSE. Retrieved October 6, 2013, from http://penangshophouse.com.my/?page_id=186
6. DEVELOPMENT / PROJECT ARCHITECT - Labur Bina Sdn Bhd. Retrieved November 3, 2013, from http://www.jobstreet.com.my/jobs/2013/5/default/10/1936413.htm?fr=21
7. Art Deco Ornamentation. (n.d.). Art Deco Ornamentation. Retrieved November 3, 2013, from http://www.brynmawr.edu/cities/archx/05-600/proj/p2/npk/artdecoexamples.htm
8. Heritage of Malaysia – Cultural Heritage Buildings. (n.d.). manamy RSS2. Retrieved November 3, 2013, from http://www.mana.my/heritage-of-malaysia-cultural-heritage-buildings/
9. Straits Eclectic Shophouses in George Town. (n.d.). Straits Eclectic Shophouses in George Town. Retrieved November 4, 2013, from http://www.penang-traveltips.com/straits-eclectic-architecture-style.htm
10. Penang Shophouse Styles. (n.d.). Penang Shophouse Styles. Retrieved November 6, 2013, from http://www.slideshare.net/chatpenang/2-penang-shophouse-styles
11. L.A. Places. (n.d.). : From the Archives: Downtown Art Deco. Retrieved November 6, 2013, from http://laplaces.blogspot.com/2009/07/downtown-art-deco.html
12. Voon Vee, Chen, The Encyclopedia of Malaysia: Architecture, Volume 5, Archipelago Press, 1998