Communty Playbook Created wth love by the Yammer communty team for communty managers and busnesses they support. A comprehensve gude to communty strategy, desgn and executon.
Online communities have taken hold among businesses, to connect employees, customers and partners. However, community management as a profession is largely misunderstood and inadequately resourced. We created this book to raise the literacy level among businesses on what community managers actually do, and for community managers to have a trusted guide in their daily jobs. This guide addresses at a high level the strategy, design and everyday execution of a successful and healthy community.
Text of Community Management Playbook
Community Playbook A comprehensive guide to community strategy,
design and execution.Created with love by the Yammer community team
forcommunity managers and businesses they support.
What is community?Community is a group of people with unique
shared values, behaviors and artifacts. - The Community
Roundtable
External community ecosystem has business benefits Customer and
partner advocacy Richer customer Top line experience growth Greater
visibility, Customer Bottom line richer stories growth partnerships
Better Market decisions relevance Best practices evolution
Internal (employee) communities make companies more adaptable
Engaged employees Stronger Business innovation transformation High
Business Better performing agility communication teams Employee
Market advocacy relevance Better customer experience
But.. communities arent yet strategic Value hard to quantify
Lack of resources Unhealthy communities Poor ROI
When done right, they have tangible benefits membership in
employee community customer community makes better burgers
increases spending by 19% Source: University of Michigan
collaboration with stores in shopping largely untapped centers
opportunity in social $1.3 Trillion! Source: McKinsey
These benefits are achievable but without proper planning
andresources, your community may not reach its potential; even
worse, it may backfire.
Potential risks without active and strategic community
management 1. Lack of supporting resources: people, technology,
finances 2. Low engagement; vocal minority drowns out the community
3. Negativity: can be cultural or ongoing, driven by culture or bad
fit, habitual trolling. May be situational or temporary negativity.
4. Content sprawl: Too many resources across too many spaces can
feel confusing and daunting to members 5. Lack of direction: People
dont know what to do when they get into the community or why its
relevant to them For more pitfalls, check out the Community
Roundtable
What do we do now?
Communitymanagers: you mustelevate communitybuilding as
astrategic discipline
Strategic CM Cultural foundation Community design Day to day
What a community is What a community Engine that mobilizes and isnt
empowers, gives people what they A marketing, broadcast or one-way
need, speeds up your business and communications channel helps you
make better decisions
Strategic CM Cultural foundation Community design Day to day A
community strategist is an individual who has tacit or explicit
authority to define enterprise-wide standards for social media and
community engagement. This includes approaches to strategy,
leadership, culture, community management, content and programming,
measurement, policies / governance and tools. - The Community
Roundtable
Strategic CM Cultural foundation Community design Day to day
Community managers strategic goal: Facilitate an environment where
members work together to build shared outcomes, driven by a common
vision
Strategic CM Cultural foundation Community design Day to day
Role of a community managerA CM facilitates this kind of
environment by: Building an environment of trust to convert tacit
knowledge into shared artifacts Being a cheerleader,
anthropologist, connector, leader, detective, conductor Giving
people a voice, inspiring and mobilizing to act Curating stories
and celebrating members success Handling negative situations
Upholding the communitys mission and vision; builds community WITH
community Educating, paying it forward, nurturing community
Ambassadors Collaborating internally, getting support for
initiatives and removing roadblocks
Strategic CM Cultural foundation Community design Day to day
Internal Communities External Communities Internal hierarchies and
politics come Bridge gap between company and into focus external
stakeholders Need to help teams and business Help stakeholders meet
each other & units think through use cases form a working
relationship Internal and external communities possess some
differences, but behavioral foundations are very similar
Strategic CM Cultural foundation Community design Day to day
The community manager mindset HEART BRAIN COURAGE Empathetic
Well-connected Tactful and diplomatic Passionate Has credibility
Confident and shrewd Inspired by people Understands existing
politician Inspires others to act business process Creates
structure without Patient Industry and market stifling Approachable
expertise Can make difficult decisions Honest, transparent
Examine cultureas the foundationto community
Strategic CM Cultural foundation Community design Day to day
Culture Community Communitys health (internally and externally) is
a manifestation of companysculture. Being open magnifies the good
and the bad; culture can enable or hurt community efforts.
Community orientation can help shape culture.
Strategic CM Cultural foundation Community design Day to dayTo
be effective externally, get your house in order! Engaged employees
Engaged customers 37% Engaged employees drive customer 3x more
likely to stay with more likely to engagement their employer
recommend product Source: Constellation Research Source: Gallup
Source: Constellation Research Engaged companies However, Engaged
and informed employees are a source of knowledge 5x 71% higher
shareholder of employees are return unengaged Source: Dachis Group
Source: Kenexa Source: Gallup
Strategic CM Cultural foundation Community design Day to day
Strive for community-centric cultureComfortable Honesty fromwith
working leaders out loudCollaborative Mutual trust & & open
accountability Hierarchy Aligns to higherdoesnt define purpose, the
flow of why informationTransparency Ability to communicate without
fear ofAuthenticity retribution
Strategic CM Cultural foundation Community design Day to day Be
realistic about culture change Culture is highly ingrained in the
ways people work; any company culture has assets. Honor your
cultures strengths, focusing on changing just a few critical
behaviors rather than attempting a wholesale transformation.
Harvard Business Review, Cultural Change that SticksInstead: Focus
on a few behavior changes Take actions every day as individuals and
teams: work out loud Discover pockets of people practicing the
desired behaviors Focus on changing behaviors you can change To
change your behavior, change your mind Focus on helping each other
to turn narrating your work into a habit Harold Jarche
Strategic CM Cultural foundation Community design Day to day
Catalyze change through observable actions Working out loud =
Narrating Your Work + Observable Work Bryce Williams Narration is
making ones tacit knowledge (what one feels) more explicit (what
one is doing with that knowledge). Narrating work is a powerful
behaviour changer Harold Jarche Working out loud requires courage
and comfort with making mistakes publicly. Trust is necessary to
work out loud, and transparency, in turn builds trust. " DO IT Post
a draft, update or what youre working on and ask the community for
feedback and insight. Do this often and encourage others to do the
same.
Strategic CM Cultural foundation Community design Day to day
Set expectations for your community Community is not a one-way
communication or broadcast channel It takes time to build a healthy
community; ROI wont be immediate Communities are messy You have to
learn to let go Feedback is a gift You cant control what members
do, nor should you try. But you can increase purposefulness by
helping people be their best Expectation setting is an ongoing
process internally and externally. Have a vision and stick to it DO
IT Determine your communitys mission and vision before you set up
and build the community.
Strategic CM Cultural foundation Community design Day to dayTo
create the conditions thatcan support a self-sustainingcommunity,
you must bedeliberate about communitydesign. Community designguides
members to outcomesand helps them iterate andmake the community
their own.
Be deliberate incommunitydesign
Strategic CM Cultural foundation Community design Day to
day
Strategic CM Cultural foundation Community design Day to day
Understand your community Design with the purpose of creating value
for each member. Start by profiling your members. You need to know:
Needs, jobs that need to get done (official and unofficial)
Expertise that exists, expertise thats needed Intrinsic motivators;
is there a higher purpose that binds? Where they are in employee /
customer life cycle What other informational sources compete for
their attention / time DO IT Get to know your community, their
goals and motivators
Strategic CM Cultural foundation Community design Day to day
Discover the sweet spot Your community needs to be healthy and
deliver business value Striking the sweet spot between the
interests and needs of the community and the interests and needs of
the organization is critical to the long Organizations Target
member needs and needs and term success of business wants wants
communities. - Rachel Happe, The Community Roundtable What is your
sweet spot? Map needs of company to needs of membersDO IT
Strategic CM Cultural foundation Community design Day to day
Build community WITH community Charter & Enlist Make it Result:
vision: co- Evolve best founding about the Healthy create with
practices members members foundation community Founding members are
the early members of your community. These early Ambassadors are
stewards of communitys vision and culture. Their behavior informs
& shapes behaviors of those who come after. Come up with a list
of 20-50 early members. Work with them to define the vision andDO
IT purpose of community. Grow the community as culture
congeals
Strategic CM Cultural foundation Community design Day to day
Create light structure without stifling Work with your early
Ambassadors to design spaces By function to bring like-minded
people together By Design wider spaces for geography purposeful
mingling across interest and work groups By expertise levels May
need separate communities if value sought is too different What do
your members have in common and how are they different? Map out
groupsDO IT inside of communities & work with Ambassadors to
seed them
Strategic CM Cultural foundation Community design Day to day
Help members make it their own Provide guidance in group creation;
help members become leaders Ask Does the group have a specific
purpose? Is someone responsible for making sure the group thrives?
How will you measure the success of your group? Encourage To choose
the group leader / administrator To determine group settings To set
the tone To keep engagement levels up DO IT Encourage community
members to create their own groups; create a group creation guide
and list of responsibilities
Strategic CM Cultural foundation Community design Day to day
Set people free by providing guardrails Focus on what TO DO, not on
what not to do - People want to do the right thing, they just dont
know how - Clarify roles, expectations and etiquette - Help evolve
best practices and community culture Think through governance and
policy internally and externally - Involve IT, Legal, HR and Comms
early on - Understand and address fears and plan scenarios - Work
together, but be careful of voting by committee - Understand how
policy fits in with existing policies, but dont be afraid to tread
new ground. Hold people accountable - take action when necessary DO
IT Work with stakeholders to create a policy that creates a safe
and productive environment for all members
Strategic CM Cultural foundation Community design Day to day Be
thoughtful about membership In external communities, think through
vetting Vetting process impacts engagement: the higher the hurdle,
the higher a sense of purpose, participation and engagement Dont
invite all customers at once; allow culture to evolve first Think
through an exit process, if necessary Figure out flow between
communities; what are the triggers? Think through community
sunsetting at the beginning what happens to content & members?
Beyond a certain level of activity, it becomes difficult for all
members to believe they can influence the community. Members no
longer feel a genuine sense of connection with another member.
Richard Millington, FeverBee
Strategic CM Cultural foundation Community design Day to day
Onboard new members Outline a 30-60-90 day plan Example: NAB has 10
day plan overseen by a Yammer mentor. Helps people go through daily
milestones Public and private welcomes set the tone, orients, gives
information Socialize new members with existing members DO IT
Create an onboarding plan to welcome members, integrates them into
the community and provides insight into how to get the most out of
the community
Strategic CM Cultural foundation Community design Day to day
Educate and guide Onboarding, Employees expectation Educate
employees setting, & open through onboarding communication
Bring together stakeholders and are an ongoing champions process
Educate and reiterate purpose with and group leads Externally
Executives Educate the community Address fears and around vision
concerns Educate members about Get the right resources community
through Encourage execs to onboarding participate Align to existing
training Reiterate purpose, programs and provide updates
certifications
Strategic CM Cultural foundation Community design Day to day
Collaborate internally to power external communities Establish an
active work channel to support activity in external communities
Example: we work closely with internal teams (product, marketing,
customer support, PR, legal, IT) to be proactive with issues,
inform, and operationalize feedback. Each teams ambassador posts as
subject matter expert Encourage execs to engage with customers DO
IT Establish an enablement board internally. Set up collaboration
groups with all the jobs that touch your customers and
partners.
Strategic CM Cultural foundation Community design Day to day
Expand your global reach Global communications are complex:
Languages Time zones Customs and cultures Subtle peculiarities
Solutions: Work with ambassadors in local areas Create local groups
digitally and physically Localize content Can someone translate? DO
IT Get to know your international community. Surface Ambassadors in
each local area and nurture them. Conversation more meaningful
coming from a local.
Strategic CM Cultural foundation Community design Day to day
Design to self-sustain Help members get to know each other. It
builds trust. Uphold your vision and policy to ensure its a trusted
space. Make meeting people and exchanging stories and experiences
easy, connect & facilitate Engage silent majority, avoid vocal
minority from taking over Create and curate engaging content Start
dialogue that moves the conversation forward (nascent community)
Curate members stories, Ambassadors start dialogue (mature
community) Model healthy behaviors, encourage others to do the same
Avoid unilateral moves; ask Ambassadors to think through and
implement change with you DO IT Think of ways that you can connect
members online and offline. Ask good questions to uncover stories.
Make it easy to share.
Commit to dailyaction
Strategic CM Cultural foundation Community design Day to day
Aim, fire, adjust! Befriend change & be comfortable with
ambiguity. You wont have all the answers, and you will be wrong
sometimes. Design with purpose and take cues from community.
Listen, learn and iterate quickly.
Strategic CM Cultural foundation Community design Day to day
Strive for balance Diversity of members in external Diversity of
content communities - Questions, answers, statements - Balance of
company & customer - Discussion of big picture representatives
- Tactical problem solving - Across industries and job types -
Dialogue, narration of work - Community manager should be invisible
as much as possible Facilitate a mix of conversations and problem
solving. Resist the urge to answer DO IT everything yourself; ask
other members to contribute. In external communities, select
members with same purpose, but different experiences.
Strategic CM Cultural foundation Community design Day to day
Give up control to Ambassadors Let champions emerge & become
Ambassadors. Ensure diversity from across members. Pay it forward;
invest in Ambassadors Understand and meet needs Understand
motivators: recognition, ability to help, drive, influence Be clear
around expectations Relegate control to Ambassadors; its more
meaningful & authentic Help ambassadors model behaviors by
doing For more on working with Ambassadors, check out this post!
Look for people who are most helpful to others; dontambassadors
check out this post. For more on look at level of activity only.
Create an ongoing channel where you can work closely with
them.
Strategic CM Cultural foundation Community design Day to day
Build engagement Engagement activities Celebrate members by
building activities around them Be purposeful; dont do it for
engagements sake Help members share their stories; make sharing
easy Dont do it for them, but ask good questions. Design daily /
weekly activities Let Ambassadors lead Build trust first; make
small asks first, ask bigger questions later Measure success and
iterate DO IT Think about activities that can boost your communitys
engagement. Look to your Ambassadors for suggestions and ideas.
Pull quieter members in.
Strategic CM Cultural foundation Community design Day to day
Connect community members Via community-wide and small-group
activities On a conversation basis; draw people in to contribute by
tagging them publicly or privately If people trust you, and you
take the time to bring them relevant questions, people are more
likely to participate As community matures, the environment itself
will allow people to connect, without CM brokering introductions DO
IT Get to know your members first. Understand their needs and
expertise. If an opportunity arises, ask a member to display their
expertise to help others.
Strategic CM Cultural foundation Community design Day to day
Help create artifacts and history Create Curate Stories are the
kernel of the Tagging, categorizing and curating community makes
things easy to find Make sharing easy Help people make sense of Ask
good questions information and adapt it for their context Connect
people with issues to people with solutions Encourage remixing. It
increases shelf-life of information and makes it Celebrate
successes and learn from more useful failure Tyco publishes a
success booklet to inspire through personal stories DO IT Ask
Ambassadors to post and encourage others to do the same. Develop a
tagging scheme to organize. Let people know the content is
there.
Strategic CM Cultural foundation Community design Day to day
Partner with customersLook for ways to partner with external
community: Innovation / product ideas Marketing campaigns, social
sharing Running & designing the community itselfHeres what weve
done with our customers: Customer named annual conference Source
& co-create content Celebrate customers, facilitate sharing
Work with champions to evolve dialogue Advisory boards for
innovation & high-level strategy Become outside-in vs.
inside-out. Ditch campaign mindset; communities dont want to
consume campaigns, they want to create with you.
Strategic CM Cultural foundation Community design Day to day
Engage employees in internal communityEmployees want to know how
they can contribute;they want to be respected, listened to and
nothandcuffed in process. Help them translate high-levelstrategy to
their daily actions.Design around these sources of
motivationAutonomy: Are employees free to get their job done theway
they need to? Do they feel trusted and empowered?Mastery: Do
employees have opportunities to get betterat their craft? Formal
training is not enough; allow them tolearn from each other
daily.Purpose: Do employees feel like they are part ofsomething
bigger? Do they feel like they can directlyinfluence the direction
of the company? From Daniel Pinks book Drive
Strategic CM Cultural foundation Community design Day to day
Turn those frowns upside down Create a balanced culture by working
with Ambassadors early. Have a clear set of guidelines,
expectations and etiquette To find source of negativity, ask
yourself Why? If unfounded or troll behavior have a private
conversation, then take action as necessary. Ambassadors should
come to the rescue If compelling reason, fix issue & create the
feedback loop back Never make it personal Take it to a private
channel DO IT Have a plan for how you will deal with negativity as
it arises. On a daily basis, remind offenders about your common
goals and expectations of members.
Strategic CM Cultural foundation Community design Day to day
Blend online and offline " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " " Catalyze
online relationships in Enhance physical events with online person.
Physical space should match community elements. online interactions
& community Examples: personality All-hands meetings, exec
breakfasts Examples: (internal) User groups, meetups (external)
Customer and partner events, Innovation jams (internal)
conferences, roadshows (external)
Strategic CM Cultural foundation Community design Day to day
Measure success 1. What does it look like? What does it mean to the
community? What does it mean to the organization? 2. How will you
measure it? Tell the whole story with: Quantitative metrics
Qualitative benefits and impacts 3. Understand and quantify value
to your business Check out this FeverBee article on community
health metrics DO IT Go back to the business goals that your
community supports. Measure quantitative indicators, as well as
ability to meet business goals.
Wrapping up
What will you get in the end? Agility Awesome culture Customers
are partners Engaged employees produce
Remember 1. Be realistic about your culture 2. Take baby steps
and be patient; behavior change takes a long time. Prepare for a
marathon, not a sprint 3. Thoughtful community design should free
and enable; not handcuff 4. Be the change you want to see; model
behaviors 5. Pay it forward
Resources Six Risks of Not Having Community Management from
Community Roundtable Community Managers, Dont Try To Do It All On
Your Own on The Yammer blog Measuring an Online Community from
Feverbee The social economy: Unlocking value and productivity
through social technologies, McKinsey Global Institute Firms own
social networks better for business than Facebook, University of
Michigan Narration of Work, Harold Jarche Three Principles of Net
Work, Harold Jarche How to Engage Your Customers and Employees, Ray
Wang for Harvard Business Review Majority of American Workers Not
Engaged In Their Jobs, Gallup How Employee Engagement Leads to
Higher Stock Prices, Kevin Kruse for Open Forum Change That Sticks
by Harvard Business Review When Will We Work Out Loud? Soon by
Bryce Williams
Contact usFor more Community Management tips, connect with us
on: Twitter: @Yammer @TheMaria @MollyBugler @MJensen Read our blog:
http://blog.yammer.com Email: [email protected]