7

Click here to load reader

Managing Deaccession debates in Portugal

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

NEMO Conference Dublin, November 2012 Short, 10-minute address on how the issue of deaccession is discussed in Portugal - and on its application in some public museums under the guise of inter-museum collaborations.

Citation preview

Page 1: Managing Deaccession debates in Portugal

MANAGING DEACCESSIONING DEBATES IN PORTUGAL

Inês Fialho Brandão

NEMO conference, Dublin, 2-4 November

Page 2: Managing Deaccession debates in Portugal

1909First recorded attempt of deacessioning through sale to finance PUBLIC museum refurbishments.

Page 3: Managing Deaccession debates in Portugal

2011First debate on deaccessioning – including sale -open to museum profiessionals (and media!)

Page 4: Managing Deaccession debates in Portugal

2012Copying the example from Greece

by selling architectural heritage, including palaces (and, presumably, their collections)

In Flash magazine

Page 5: Managing Deaccession debates in Portugal

RESTRICTIVE & BUREAUCRATICLEGAL FRAMEWORK

Public museums

• Minister of Culture & Museums Council

• Allowed only upon:• Disappearance

(documented);

• Degradation beyond salvaging.

• Specific mention– “not a source of income”

Private museums

• Allowed to do as they see fit;

• State has right of preference upon deaccessioning;

• If exercised, item to integrate PMN collections.

Page 6: Managing Deaccession debates in Portugal

Hat collection on permanent loan from the costume museum (Museu do Traje), Lisbon.

MOTIVE: Extension collection of duplicates

Hatmaking museum, S. Joao da Madeira

Page 7: Managing Deaccession debates in Portugal

ROGUES & MAVERICKS

… LACK OF DEBATE, LACK OF TRANSPARENCY

… PRESSURES OF THE CRISIS